<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Simon Kenny on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Simon Kenny on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@skenwrites?source=rss-58dea109143------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 11:38:30 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@skenwrites/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Machina Totalis, Or The Interpassivity of Automation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@skenwrites/machina-totalis-or-the-interpassivity-of-automation-4af7eec343d2?source=rss-58dea109143------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4af7eec343d2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[software-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media-criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Kenny]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 Aug 2026 12:54:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-29T12:54:52.600Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aCPMtjLP3JEfWi9BKybSjQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.pexels.com/photo/desk-with-computers-and-hot-wheels-collection-15164001/">Free to use image</a> by <a href="https://www.pexels.com/@kampratt/">Kamshotthat</a></figcaption></figure><p>Looking from left to right, the screens increase in size. My phone rests on the coffee table’s edge; in the four-foot distance a laptop; looming and angled stands the TV. I sit and wonder at this control room, cup of tea in hand. It’s my day off and though it seems I’m not working, each screen is alive with a flurry of unmonitored activity.</p><p>On the TV, I had been playing <em>BALL X PIT</em>. The game is a Breakout-style bullet-hell shooter with rogue-like elements. Right now, the game is being played but the controller sits cheerfully idle on my coffee table. The character I chose to play as is called <em>The Radical</em> and they <em>are</em> radical, in that they refuse to be controlled — selecting <em>The Radical</em> makes the game play itself. Pairing that character with another allows me to automate the ‘achievements’ awarded by the game, those digital carrots dangled in front of all gamers, snack food bragging rights, teachers’ gold stars. The comments section taunts: “Are you getting your sense of accomplishment out of wasting more time than other people?” Some people hate it (it’s “incredibly asinine an auto-play character like this exists”) but there are a lot of defenders:</p><blockquote>speak for yourself. I love that they added the auto play character, its genius. i can make a cup of tea and smoke my vape while i watch him play. i find it very entertaining actually, and relaxing. its a single player game and its nice to have the option to play however you want to. its not like im cheating someone out of a win lol <em>[sic] [1]</em></blockquote><p><em>The Radical</em> doesn’t always win the level, he can die in the swarm. This commenter and I can drink tea and see how it turns out, separately in our own little control rooms, worlds away. We can also leave to make the tea, have a smoke, whatever, secure in the knowledge the character has something to do too.</p><p>Games have long had demo or spectator modes in which the computer plays against itself. Where these can be controlled and set up by ‘players’ (an identity we might now contest) they are found in multiplayer games such as <em>Super Smash Bros</em> matches or semi-historical simulation in <em>Age of Empires</em>. But a single player game that plays itself like <em>BALL X PIT</em> is a novelty very much of our times. ‘Runs’ typically last for 10 or 15 minutes, in between which there is a management phase before setting up the next run. <em>The Radical</em> becomes an employed dungeon crawler, we the manager checking in on progress a few times an hour when we <em>circle back</em> and <em>touch base</em> (quite literally). I set down my tea, push a few buttons and start another run.</p><p>Computer games are thought of as a paradigmatically interactive medium. Chris Crawford, founder of the world’s largest game developer conference GDC wrote that “Interactivity is the real strength of the computer, and it must be given primacy in our [game] designs.” Self-playing games are a radical departure, contradicting such traditional assumptions. “Of course, the task of the game designer is to automate interactivity, to replace one of the participants in the conversation with a machine.” [2] When both participants are automated, inter-activity inverts to become inter-passivity. Slavoj Žižek wrote about this in the late 90s though we find it throughout his work since then. A rhetorical description: is it not “the object itself which ‘enjoys the show’ instead of me, relieving me of the superego duty to enjoy myself?” [3] A primary example of his is the ‘canned’ laugh track on the sitcom that gives one permission to delegate one’s expression of enjoyment, perhaps the enjoyment itself, [4] but the self-playing computer game is surely the apotheosis.</p><p>The TV flickers on in a kaleidoscope of colour. I’m not really paying attention to it. Nor am I paying attention to what is happening on my laptop, perched on a nearby stool. Here, I see out of the corner of my eye that the <em>Claude Code</em> autonomous software writing AI agent is still burning through a few cents every minute, hacking away at some code I’ll never even look at. I had set the machine free at a loosely defined goal (something involving speech transcription and rewriting as an Android app) and launched it in the general direction of a solution. The similarity to my TV activity is striking and some of the makers of <em>Claude Code</em> themselves conceptualize it as “a small game engine.” [5] Many have remarked that the gambling-game dynamics of this catch and release form of software creation, including co-founder of the DevOps movement in software development Gene Kim:</p><blockquote>Building cool things is addictive. Vibe coding, especially with agents, turns your keyboard into a slot machine. You “pull the lever,” and out comes a payout — a chunk of working code, a generated test, or a refactoring. Each little payout delivers a tiny dopamine hit, a neurochemical reward that makes us feel good and encourages us to pull the lever again. <em>[6]</em></blockquote><p>Between ‘pulls’, the machine plays itself in monochrome fixed-space text, the outcome uncertain. Kim, however, de-emphasizes the true nature of the slot machine, that <em>failures</em> to ‘hit’ are much more likely. It is a relentless ambling towards a potential reward I’m less and less interested in but feel <em>itchy</em> about. Vaguely, that itch is being scratched. The alienation of creation dilutes its joy, the victory hollow. If it doesn’t work, my interest fades fast but the itch will pull me back eventually.</p><p>Rick Rubin, the music producer superstar who claims to know nothing about music [7] lauds the ephemerality of vibe coding, employing that tired antimony that <em>change never changes</em>, “The work is done and then forgotten. / That is why it lasts forever.” [8] And we <em>are</em> tired — all of this means that the work never ends. The <em>Harvard Business Review</em> reported that AI tool usage “blurred boundaries between work and non-work. …workers slipped small amounts of work into moments that had previously been breaks. …work spill[ed] into evenings or early mornings without deliberate intention.” [9]</p><blockquote>Therefore The Vibe Coder builds without laboring<br>and instructs by quiet example.<br>Things arise and he accepts them.<br>Things vanish and he lets them go. <em>[10]</em></blockquote><p>When your career is vocational and ‘coder’ is part of your identity, the temptation to take work home has never been greater, not only the work but the applied philosophy of what we might call <em>Machina Totalis</em>. It is not just productivity creep but the colonization of leisure, not seeming to labour while standing taut in permanent vigil.</p><p>Still, neither the TV nor laptop focus my attention. I’m lying on the couch, staring at my collection of books. Some of them I’ve read, many more I haven’t. This is my ‘anti-library’, a concept Nassim Nicholas Taleb lifted from Umberto Eco’s prodigious book-collecting and ambivalent attitude to actually reading them all, whom he implies is an ‘anti-scholar’, as described in his book <em>The Black Swan</em>. Both Taleb and Žižek recognize what the latter calls “symbolic registration.” Žižek writes:</p><blockquote>…although I do not actually watch [all of my collected] films, the very awareness that the films I love are stored in my video library gives me a profound satisfaction… [it is] as if the VCR is in a way watching them for me, in my place… the VCR stands here for the ‘big Other’, for the medium of symbolic registration. <em>[11]</em></blockquote><p>Perhaps I too can think of myself as an anti-scholar — anti-reader, anti-watcher — surveying the knowledge <em>in potentia</em>, in suspension, a Hanging Garden of Alexandria, sweet fruits unplucked on the vine: anti-achievements.</p><p>I’m not really sure what to do in this control room, so I linger. Reading books is my favourite way to <em>touch grass</em>. As my eyes climb the shelves, a YouTube video essay offers pre-made conversations on my phone. This is the third screen I’m ignoring. It’s Jake from <em>Man Carrying Thing</em> sharing his 10 favourite books of all time, [12] who then proclaims “Self-help is dead. It’s time to read fiction.” Jake puts it simply: “there is an aesthetic value inherent in something good and that experiencing it is nice. Not even good for you. It’s just nice. It makes life better.” [13] When I read <em>Normal People</em> by Sally Rooney, I wept.</p><p>Though they are three — the YouTube video essay, the self-coding coder, the self-playing player — these together are <em>second screens</em> to my wall of bound paper. I idle in a pretence of doing. Those screens act as some variant of “TV shows and movies designed to be watched while doing something else,” which is to say, not watched, not with any intention. [14] This, again, is Žižek’s interpassivity. And indeed, Žižek is now on YouTube being interviewed while I admire the inertia of his book <em>Hegel In A Wired Brain</em>, unsure if I’ll ever read it. I could tell you something in general about Hegel’s <em>The Phenomenology of Spirit</em>, “knowing only the name and something about the critical context, but without ever having read a word,” as Eco has it. [15]</p><blockquote>You know the joke, everybody knows it, that I used: what would be ideal sex today? … We have a date. We say, “yes, we will do it.” But what happens? I come, you come with your plastic electric dildo, I come with the plastic vagina, both. And what we do is, that’s for me ideal sex today. We sit down, you put your dildo into my vagina, we reconnect them and they are buzzing. And we can say, “wonderful! The machine is doing sex.” We can now have a nice chat, drink tea. <em>[16]</em></blockquote><p>As my desires are tended to for me by <em>Machina Totalis</em>, my tea is getting cold.</p><p>[1] — Ereson. “Having ‘The Radical’ character in the game is dumb.” <em>Steam Community</em>, 31 Oct. 2025 <a href="https://steamcommunity.com/app/2062430/discussions/0/840610464762376816/?ctp=5">https://steamcommunity.com/app/2062430/discussions/0/840610464762376816/?ctp=5</a></p><p>[2] — Crawford, Chris. <em>Chris Crawford on Game Design</em>, New Riders, 2003, pp. 75–7.</p><p>[3] — Žižek, Slavoj, 1997. <em>The Plague of Fantasies</em>, Verso, 2008, pp. 144–5.</p><p>[4] — Žižek, 2008, p. 141.</p><p>[5] — Bigl, Matthias. “Claude Code Is a Game Engine for Text: How DX Bloat Consumed the Terminal”. <em>Bigl’s Blog</em>, 11 Feb. 2026, <a href="https://blog.bigls.net/post/claude-code-game-engine-dx-bloat">https://blog.bigls.net/post/claude-code-game-engine-dx-bloat</a></p><p>[6] — Kim, Gene, Steve Yegge. “The Value Of Vibe Coding (or, the Good FAAFO).” <em>IT Revolution</em>, 4 Aug. 2025, <a href="https://itrevolution.com/articles/the-value-of-vibe-coding-or-the-good-faafo/">https://itrevolution.com/articles/the-value-of-vibe-coding-or-the-good-faafo/</a></p><p>[7] — Cooper, Anderson, Rick Rubin. “In Shangri-La with music producer Rick Rubin”. <em>60 Minutes</em>, 15 Jan. 2023, <a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/news/rick-rubin-60-minutes-2023-01-15">https://www.cbsnews.com/news/rick-rubin-60-minutes-2023-01-15</a></p><p>[8] — Rubin, 2025.</p><p>[9] — Ranganathan, Aruna, Xingqi Maggie Ye. “AI Doesn’t Reduce Work — It Intensifies It”. <em>Harvard Business Review</em>, 9 Feb. 2026, <a href="https://hbr.org/2026/02/ai-doesnt-reduce-work-it-intensifies-it">https://hbr.org/2026/02/ai-doesnt-reduce-work-it-intensifies-it</a></p><p>[10] — Rubin, Rick. <em>The Way of Code</em>, 2025, <a href="https://www.thewayofcode.com/">https://www.thewayofcode.com</a></p><p>[11] — Žižek, 2008, pp. 144–145.</p><p>[12] — “my 10 favorite books of all time”. <em>YouTube</em>, uploaded by Man Carrying Thing, 31 July 2025, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9tEQy8QU574">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9tEQy8QU574</a></p><p>[13] — “Self-help is dead. It’s time to read fiction.” <em>YouTube</em>, uploaded by Man Carrying Thing, 22 Nov. 2025, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vn-RR7_2R7A">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vn-RR7_2R7A</a></p><p>[14] — Jones, Ralph. “‘Not second screen enough’: is Netflix deliberately dumbing down TV so people can watch while scrolling?” <em>The Guardian</em>, 17 Jan. 2025, <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2025/jan/17/not-second-screen-enough-is-netflix-deliberately-dumbing-down-tv-so-people-can-watch-while-scrolling">https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2025/jan/17/not-second-screen-enough-is-netflix-deliberately-dumbing-down-tv-so-people-can-watch-while-scrolling</a></p><p>[15] — Eco, 2017. <em>The Paris Review</em>, 2 Nov. 2017, <a href="https://www.theparisreview.org/blog/2017/11/02/on-unread-books">https://www.theparisreview.org/blog/2017/11/02/on-unread-books</a></p><p>[16] — “Why we are getting more stupid | Slavoj Žižek FULL INTERVIEW”. <em>YouTube</em>, uploaded by The Institute of Art and Ideas, 18 Oct. 2025, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BVlfNtIml2U">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BVlfNtIml2U</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4af7eec343d2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What happens to the programming game in the age of AI?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@skenwrites/what-happens-to-the-programming-game-in-the-age-of-ai-d4873014725b?source=rss-58dea109143------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d4873014725b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[programming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[automation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Kenny]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 14 Jun 2026 12:06:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-15T16:51:51.967Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>If this machine gave you the truth immediately, you would not recognize it, because your heart would not have been purified by the long quest. … Mystic logic, letters whirling in infinite change, is the world of bliss, it is the music of thought, but see that you proceed slowly, and with caution, because your machine may bring you delirium instead of ecstasy. — Umberto Eco, <em>Foucault’s Pendulum</em>, Vintage 2001 (first pub. 1988), pp. 33–34</blockquote><p>I got into computers to make games. Well, I got into computers to <em>play</em> games and was then encouraged to imagine I could make my own. My first computer was a Commodore 64, given to me and my siblings when I was about eight years old. The creators of the C64, in a stroke of genius, decided to make the user manual primarily a programming guide for its built-in language BASIC. This was a neat way of describing the features of the machine in a way that could be interrogated in code—from graphical sprites and character maps to its signature SID sound system. Software was harder to obtain then, it was expensive, mostly on cassette tapes, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ivj2eJeC2wM">took a long time to load</a> and there was less of it to go around. Most importantly, however, through this user manual they introduced a generation of children like me to the idea that computer programming could be <em>fun</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/785/1*aCF7W8KUPD-oTwRUWzpyJw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WUhr85LN7YoxjtcHG2iTjA.jpeg" /><figcaption>I still have my battered C64 manual, complete with adolescent scratchings.</figcaption></figure><p>The Commodore C64 was my primary exposure to early computing but in the UK and Ireland the native ZX Spectrum was perhaps more popular. The interactive TV show <em>Bandersnatch</em> by Black Mirror dramatizes and (makes psychologically weird) those heady days of micro-computers, before PCs would take over home computing. There was the feeling you could learn the esoteric codes of the machine and maybe make a name for yourself with a hit game. The British magazine <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodore_Format">Commodore Format</a> followed the careers of one such star coding duo known as the <a href="https://commodoreformatarchive.com/from-the-vault-unpublished-1990-apex-feature/">Rowland brothers</a>, emphasizing that they coded in the much harder to learn, low level assembly language. In <em>Bandersnatch</em> the character of Colin Ritman (played by Will Poulter) is cut from this archetype of the super-nerd, cleverly squeezing every last drop of performance out of limited micro-computing systems. The mishandling of this occult power by the aspirant player/protagonist can lead to madness, as we see in <em>Bandersnatch</em>. (Note that <em>Bandersnatch</em> was <a href="https://variety.com/2025/digital/news/black-mirror-bandersnatch-removal-netflix-1236392097/">removed by Netflix in mid-2025</a>.)</p><p>In 2019 I finally learned C64 assembly myself and created a little demo <em>Bandersnatch</em> game, following Stafan’s path (though the character uses a ZX Spectrum). You can read about the strategy and solutions in <a href="https://medium.com/@marshan/bandersnatch-for-c64-v0-1-the-story-so-far-985287305055">my dev-log</a> if you’re interested. Programming for these extremely limited systems provides such a constrained environment that one must be creative by default.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cCojPwTYQ2GlpD96ETnklw.png" /><figcaption>Screenshots of the game in action on a C64 emulator. You can play it and read the code here: <a href="https://github.com/digithree/bndrsntch">https://github.com/digithree/bndrsntch</a></figcaption></figure><p>Unlike Stefan, though, the harvest of the micro-computing era wasn’t madness but rather an imagination for, and some small skill in, <strong>programming</strong>. Programming your own little game was itself a kind of meta-game, a challenge in itself not unlike <em>playing</em> a game. Amateurs like me played the more competent and finely crafted games made by others, looking on in wonder. Still, that didn’t stop us from trying our hand. I’ll come back to this later but I believe this is because <em>there was nothing that would do it for you</em>. There were plenty of examples to be inspired by but nothing that would create your dream game. You had to figure it out.</p><p>Enter then, some years later when computers became more powerful, <strong>the programming game</strong>. This type of game offers puzzles in which solutions involve writing computer code in an accessible language such as Python or JavaScript. Later, when computers became powerful enough to simulate or emulate entire older systems, the theoretical computer in a computer could be realized.</p><p>The programming game asks you to solve a problem — sometimes open ended, sometimes to a fixed conclusion — using the familiar tools of the programming trade and some API that integrates the code execution environment runtime with a game interface surface. For example, <a href="https://store.screeps.com/"><em>Screeps</em></a> asks you to automate the behaviour of characters called Creeps to battle against other player’s autonomous Creeps and exploit an environment of resources to expand production of new Creeps. If you have read the 1995 Philip K Dick short story <em>Autofac</em>, it is something like that (and if you haven’t, <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/14180.Selected_Stories_of_Philip_K_Dick">go and do that now!</a>) In <a href="https://github.com/bitburner-official/bitburner-src"><em>Bitburner</em></a> (which is open source ❤️), you are tasked with automating various cyberpunk themed criminal activities, like hacking crypto, infiltrating companies and working for gangs. The game loop is roughly the same as a real programming development loop: 1) write and update your code; 2) execute the code; 3) see if it worked; 4) fix and improve again from 1. That is, phase 2 is hands-off, you must let the system work or fail autonomously on its own, imbued with your ideas.</p><p>The most successful players of programming games write their code to be maximally adaptive to the strategies of other players or the antagonistic system itself, and they avoid brittle solutions. Even in the single player <em>Bitburner</em> experience, the game offers many unexpected “edge cases” in its data structures and dynamic configurations that thwart simplistic algorithms. The coder-as-gamer must think beyond rigid ideas or overly firm “hardcoded” solutions, or be cursed to continually patch their code for each individual exceptional case and get lost in a web of special handling which may, in fact, lead to some minor madness, or at least substantial frustration.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L_0zRjNMmNXL0uE5h4kGnA.png" /><figcaption>My hand-coded scripts in action in the Bitburner game UI (Mac). The wgwh.js script updates every second with events moving right to left on the dashed timeline.</figcaption></figure><p>In professional software development today, AI systems such as Claude Code and OpenAI’s Codex are being used to write code and fix bugs. These tools not only write code but attempt to “agentically” insert and update code throughout the many complex interconnected files of a codebase (that is, with some level of autonomy). Their use has become increasingly central to the developer toolkit and I’m sure that developers who don’t use it at all are a vanishing minority, if not already extinct. It’s a bit like using a lawnmower instead of a hand scythe, it seems stupid not to use it, performative even.</p><p>AI code tools change the developer experience so much, though, that many developers are struggling to adapt. As some developers are burning out, others are being caught up in <a href="https://www.trueup.io/layoffs">mass firings</a>. I subscribe to the <a href="https://tldr.tech/">TLDR newsletter</a> and almost every weekday I see some blog post on developer anxiety doing the rounds. In a recent article we read that <a href="https://human-in-the-loop.bearblog.dev/llms-are-eroding-my-software-engineering-career-and-i-dont-know-what-to-do/">LLMs are eroding my software engineering career and I don’t know what to do</a>. The developer chronicles their journey from being tentatively positive about AI coding (“The natural next step was to introduce more AI into writing code. And honestly, I liked it.”) to feeling more and more redundant and low skilled (“But I’m just another off-the-shelf engineer now. … A good chunk of the knowledge I accumulated on that topic is not that valuable anymore.”) to wondering if a career change would be prudent (“Maybe I should consider transforming my woodworking hobby into a profession…”). The lawnmower seems to be driving itself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/220/1*WQCVAq8hOsGYWqNnYD2KVA.gif" /><figcaption>What are you supposed to hold on to? And where is it going?</figcaption></figure><p>In another article, <a href="https://evilmartians.com/chronicles/ai-assisted-engineers-are-burning-out-is-this-fine">AI-assisted engineers are burning out, is this fine?</a>, we read of the deskilling effect that many of us are experiencing:</p><blockquote>When you work with an [AI] agent, as it gets more context, you lose it. You stop needing to hold the project in your head: the architecture, the edge cases, the reasoning behind past decisions–it all starts living outside of you. You not only delegate writing the code, but actually understanding your system. … You can’t teach or review what you’ve never learned. Over time, you become a supervisor of a project you no longer truly know. And supervising something you don’t understand is exhausting.</blockquote><p>For the developer above, their woodworking still requires all that context, awareness and skill, and so it retains a natural pleasure. Software development, by contrast, becomes managerial.</p><p>As coding becomes less like an artisanal craft and more like a low skilled industrial process, those interested in doing things the hard way for its intrinsic joy may find their skills useful only in performing a simulacrum of the handiwork that once built real systems, for the viewing pleasure of others on Twitch streaming perhaps, in a kind of historical re-enactment.</p><p>The ultimate absurdity would be to use <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vibe_coding">AI vibe coding</a> to solve puzzles in the programming game itself. I journeyed through this underworld to experience the desolation of joy first hand, and it was everything you’d think it would be. For this I chose <em>Bitburner</em> due to its substantial familiarity to me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rUBs21j5v9XztD_qypEskw.png" /><figcaption>At this many hours, the “play time” calculation glitches out and changes constantly. It’s about 10 to 12 months, running almost constantly. Somehow, after all that time, I still have only 63% of the achievements.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Bitburner</em> is one of the more “open” programming games out there—your game scripts can make network calls outside the game. This permeable game/host system boundary provides the ideal means for an AI agent to communicate into the game and receive information about in-game activity. I sketched the following integrations for an AI agent to solve the game: 1) autonomously push scripts to the game, 2) observe telemetry of what the game is doing, synced to an outside database, and 3) a retro-feel TUI dashboard outside the game to summarize observations to the “player”.</p><p>It will likely not surprise you that this was an exercise in futility and frustration. I’ll admit that it initially felt interesting to steer the AI to create solutions. “Wow, it can do it without me!” With my extensive hours in the game, I knew well the solutions that would work. But it wasn’t long until the pointlessness of the endeavour became the overwhelming feeling, never mind the technical failures once the system became sufficiently complex. “Oh, it can do it without me… but badly.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uE3ISHMuEza55K1SFgHD1A.png" /><figcaption>The AI generated dashboard TUI, guided by hours of management toil.</figcaption></figure><p>There were constant regressions of functionality (features that once worked breaking when adding or improving something unrelated) and the strategies it came up with were always rudimentary. Even with full access to the game source codebase, which is very clearly cheating, my hand-rolled solutions were usually more robust. An exception was the stock market speculation system which was pretty good (see above), probably because this is a well understood real-world problem. But in all else, with few exceptions, the churn was soul destroying. To use the term <em>du jour</em>, it produced <a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/wordplay/word-of-the-year"><em>slop</em> </a>— features disappeared, rules were forgotten, trade-offs ill-conceived and some actions even faked.</p><p>Perhaps this is encouraging to the human programmer since programming games simulate a lot of real world complexity in their puzzles, not a simple, ideal state like an Amazon warehouse factory floor. <strong>You can probably do it better than the AI. </strong>AI code generation works well on isolated problems with intense guardrails but struggles with real complexity.</p><p>We could think of our lovingly human-made craft as an exercise in building an advanced automotive vehicular carriage for the rugged terrain of the world—to traverse hillside scree, amble over thorny briars and tree roots, to splash safely through streams and roll through dusty desert alike and do it all efficiently, stylishly even.</p><p>Easier, though, to pave the world with motorways and standardize the car.</p><p>It seems likely the situation will change as AI coding systems become more developed. Solutions in real business applications will still work best in constrained environments (it will always be easier to “pave the world”) but I’m sure there is more capability to squeeze out of the neural network LLM era system. For the human programmer though, that is not the point.</p><p>Activities we do for leisure and personal interest are premised on enjoying the journey. They are not simply a means to an end, in the sense that the ultimate conclusion of the activity is not what is being optimized. Mountaineering would be ruined by taking a helicopter to the summit; football wouldn’t be improved by moving the goals 5 meters apart; and a computer game would be greatly diminished by adding a “Complete Next Level” button. Using an AI agent to play a programming game for you is to turn it into an <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incremental_game">incremental clicker game</a> where you anxiously bash the button over and over again.</p><p>In the possible near future where hand-coding without AI becomes an extinct practice at a professional level, the programming game may become one of the the last refuges for diehard coders. Human programming at large would become the final <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demoscene">demoscene</a>, like a sport that bans performance enhancing drugs. Join your local retro-computer club—hosted in the community centre alongside the knitters, woodworkers and beekeepers—and join those archiving the dying handcrafts.</p><p>I’ll leave you with a paragraph from a recent op-ed in The Guardian, <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/may/24/ai-tools-thinking-human-hard-coding-writing-technology">I avoid AI tools because thinking is supposed to be hard. It’s what makes us human</a>:</p><blockquote>In a world where huge AI companies are hoping to make intelligence a “utility” — in other words, privatising thought — limiting our use of this technology may be a way to protect our cognitive sovereignty. On an individual level, it’s about preserving our ability to think, keeping our brains active rather than outsourcing every decision to some essentially probabilistic software.</blockquote><p><em>The em-dashes are all mine, thank you very much. </em><a href="https://linktr.ee/simonkenny"><em>https://linktr.ee/simonkenny</em></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d4873014725b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Private Score of Electronic Music]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@skenwrites/the-private-score-of-electronic-music-56febad2fef1?source=rss-58dea109143------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/56febad2fef1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[classical-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[composition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[electronic-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Kenny]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Jul 2025 17:08:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-09T17:08:56.319Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2025/05/aucoin-what-is-classical-music/682119/">What Is Classical Music?</a>, published in The Atlantic (May 2025), an interesting answer is proposed:</p><blockquote>At its core, classical music isn’t “classical.” It is written music.</blockquote><p>That is, music primarily transmitted through in written form, its “score.”</p><p>This is a clever solution to sidestep the tedious (and likely impossible) task of setting some boundary to enclose the diverse styles of music played under that umbrella term. Of course, all categories break down under scrutiny (as Wittgenstein would have it, members bear more of a family resemblance, see also <a href="https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/M/bo90478773.html">Metamodernism by Jason Ananda Josephson Storm</a>) and yet such categories persist as useful shorthand. These are things that we “know when we see them”, but, as the author of the article agrees, that attitude doesn’t satisfy.</p><p>I like this definition and the author builds their case well, distinguishing it from popular contemporary music which lives in its recorded state and from folk music which is primarily aural (though this last comparison is a little underdeveloped in the piece).</p><p>What it brings to mind for me is the production and reproduction of <em>electronic music</em>. This genre doesn’t receive and explicit treatment but I would see it as distinct from music which is typically played by hand and recorded in the studio. Of classical music, the author says:</p><blockquote>If we let ourselves be guided by this basic question — which musical artists regard the score as a creative starting point? — we arrive at the broadest and most welcoming definition of “classical” music.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s8mh4LzHuqHjI1DdfauUvQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>A Man Sitting At The Table by Cottonbro Studio, permissive license, via <a href="https://www.pexels.com/photo/a-man-sitting-at-the-table-7096809/">Pexels</a></figcaption></figure><p>Electronic music, especially of the most intense and cerebral kind, are born in their score. The composition medium is the computer interface, not pen and paper (but then modern “classical” scored works are also written on computer, at least eventually). It is also a <em>private score</em>, generally closely guarded and not shared. A notable exception that proves this rule is <em>deadmau5</em>, who has been very open about their production techniques, but his approach is unusual.</p><p>For a look at some popular music software, check out <a href="https://www.ableton.com/">Ableton</a>, the one I used the most for <a href="https://bitwiseoperator.bandcamp.com/">Bitwise Operator</a>, as well as <a href="https://www.image-line.com/">FL Studio</a> which I used when I was getting started 25 years ago (<a href="https://www.image-line.com/artists/deadmau5-joel-zimmerman">deadmau5 was also an early adopter</a>). <a href="https://www.apple.com/mac/garageband/">GarageBand</a> comes free with Mac computers and iPads (my daughter loves it) and its more grown up cousin <a href="https://www.apple.com/logic-pro/">Logic Pro</a> is widely used.</p><p>For a brief forensic analysis of the premier artist of the genre, I highly recommend this YouTube video discussing <em>Aphex Twin’s</em> software composition tools (no prior knowledge necessary):</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F5wIOBBodoic%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D5wIOBBodoic&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F5wIOBBodoic%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e823a4d704e0ec68a07a9ccb9019483b/href">https://medium.com/media/e823a4d704e0ec68a07a9ccb9019483b/href</a></iframe><p>I had the unparalleled pleasure of seeing <em>Aphex Twin</em> live twice in 2009 as well as <em>Venetian Snares</em>, both powerhouses on the record and at the venue and two artists for whom composition is central. Would we call their work “classical” though?</p><p>Electronic music <em>appears</em> to live primarily in the recorded artefact — disseminated and reaching new fans — just as in other music the author would classify as non-classical, but this is misleading. It is, in fact, primarily a <em>live</em> genre, <a href="https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0274309/">originating in clubs</a>. Though the image of the “bedroom producer” became well-known, even these artists left their caves to hypnotize the masses. I’m thinking here of examples like <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RMrWWAY7MJM">Hudson Mohawke</a> and early Dubstep pioneers <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lVMsguwPvU4">Skream and Mala</a>.</p><p>The record (and the prepared fragments played with and remixed live) are a <em>rendering</em> of the score, the ‘bounce’ of the artist’s prior composition. Unlike sheet music intended to be played by physical instruments, the score is invariably meticulously concerned with the exact production of sound. And yet! Many modernist, avant-garde and experimental works are so particular in this way. As expected, the category breaks down but this gives us fertile ground on which to discuss.</p><p>Electronic music is a hybrid, classical/modern. Scored but rendered to audio. Played live but there instrumented, approximating the ‘band’ format but more the <em>DJ as conductor</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=56febad2fef1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Advancing without advancing — Lao Tzu and chatbot]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@skenwrites/advancing-without-advancing-lao-tzu-and-chatbot-4fd443fbd0ca?source=rss-58dea109143------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4fd443fbd0ca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[taoism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[generative-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Kenny]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Jun 2025 08:31:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-21T08:20:32.929Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Advancing without advancing — Lao Tzu and vibe coding</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zD5WVbNsLKC5xaeVshKX9Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Commemorative poetry has a long history. Events of triumph and failure are memorialised and made larger than life, often outliving the recollection of their facts. Similarly, poems of dedication are commissioned in the service of the powerful to create their afterlives in verse. Now, we see this too for companies and their products, as David Whyte did for the Boeing 777 at the company’s request, published in his collection <em>The House of Belonging</em>.</p><p>In <em>The Ode Less Travelled</em> by Stephen Fry, the poem <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tay_Bridge_Disaster">The Tay Bridge Disaster</a> by William McGonagall is a case study in how poetry fails, and it happens to be of the commemorative type. “A disaster for a disaster” as Fry puts it:</p><blockquote>One might argue that McGonagall has brilliantly memorialised a doomed and structurally flawed bridge in congruently doomed and structurally flawed verse. His poem is a disaster for a disaster: it is the Tay Bridge, crashing hopelessly to its destruction and dragging every innocent word with it. It is not buttressed by metre, rhyme, sense or reason and even as we read it we feel it collapse under the weight of its own absurdity and ineptitude.</blockquote><p>A brutal assessment, but he is not alone in his views. It is widely regarded as one of the worst poems in the English language.</p><p>In the last few weeks, we have seen a combination of these forms bundled in <a href="https://www.thewayofcode.com/"><em>The Way of Code</em></a><em>: The Timeless Art of Vibe Coding</em> by music producer and art guru Rick Rubin. It memorializes one of the leading AI chatbots, Claude by Anthropic. As a reflection on a currently existing product, it is also an advertisement, as I suspect was the double life of Whyte’s offering.</p><p>First of all, what is vibe coding? The term was coined by Andrej Karpathy, an early staff member at OpenAI and former Director of AI at Tesla (the electric car company). In a February 2025 <a href="https://x.com/karpathy/status/1886192184808149383">Twitter post</a> he wrote:</p><blockquote>There’s a new kind of coding I call “vibe coding”, where you fully give in to the vibes, embrace exponentials, and forget that the code even exists. It’s possible because the LLMs (e.g. Cursor Composer w Sonnet) are getting too good. … I ask for the dumbest things like “decrease the padding on the sidebar by half” because I’m too lazy to find it. I “Accept All” always, I don’t read the diffs anymore. … Sometimes the LLMs can’t fix a bug so I just work around it or ask for random changes until it goes away. It’s not too bad for throwaway weekend projects, but still quite amusing. I’m building a project or webapp, but it’s not really coding — I just see stuff, say stuff, run stuff, and copy paste stuff, and it mostly works.</blockquote><p>Or, as Rubin puts it, “You don’t need to learn to code any more.”</p><p>This method of software creation is a kind of AI assisted programming process which is distant from the code itself. It has a lot in common with low-code or no-code app builders, except now using conversational language rather than a drag-and-drop interface. Code assistant chatbots like Claude, ChatGPT and others accept their instructions in plain English (and your native tongue, if supported).</p><p><em>The Way of Code</em> enters a cottage industry of products in the form of “The Way of X” or “The Tao of X”. <a href="https://openlibrary.org/works/OL3258255W/The_Tao_of_Physics">The Tao of Physics</a> is a well-known example but there are dozens of them (<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/list/show/123057._The_Tao_of_insert_topic_here_">see for yourself</a>). It is a remix of the infamous <em>Tao Te Ching</em> by Lao Tzu (alternatively <em>Laozi</em>), which along with <em>Zhuangzi</em> is the foundational text of Taoism. An introduction is hardly needed for such a work and so I will clip just a small portion from Stephen Mitchell’s poetic paraphrased edition, the one that Rubin has largely based his own on paraphrase on (in fact, sometimes verbatim):</p><blockquote>…the classic manual on the art of living, written in style of gemlike lucidity, radiant with humor and grace and largeheartedness and deep wisdom: one of the wonders of the world. [Foreword]</blockquote><p>A note on terminology: a <em>paraphrase</em> is distinct from a <em>translation</em> in that it is not an original translation and instead based on other translations, edited or rephrased in an opinionated manner by the paraphraser. For poetic works such as <em>Tao Te Ching</em> this invariably means fitting the poetry into a native style, since poetry as ‘word art’ is heavily dependent on particular language features.</p><p><em>The Way of Code</em> is a virtual interactive book, a website. It pairs Rubin’s words (written, he has stated, without the use of AI) to the accompaniment of various flowing animations with an ink-like monochrome style, clearly inspired by Zen masterwork paintings. This is where the subject meets its object, the animations presumably having been vibe coded. In turn, the reader is encouraged to participate in vibe coding of their own (and create a Claude account to become a member, of course) by remixing the code for these artworks themselves.</p><p>The artworks have been created using a simplified graphical coding platform called <strong>p5.js</strong> the descendent of <a href="https://processing.org/">Processing.js</a>. This freely available platform has been increasingly popular over the last 25 years and is largely responsible for the proliferation of DIY geometric computer art of this kind. It’s impact on culture has been a taste for the promiscuous (and often <em>pointless</em>) visualization of data, especially of the interactive sort. These diagrams are often more about performing a technical aesthetic than of any actual analytic use.</p><p>I will not be as harsh as Fry was of McGonagall but certainly the shortcomings of <em>The Way of Code</em> are felt all the more by comparison to the venerable text on which it is based.</p><p>Read, for example, Rubin’s rewriting:</p><blockquote>… <br>Therefore The Vibe Coder builds without laboring <br>and instructs by quiet example. <br>Things arise and he accepts them. <br>Things vanish and he lets them go.<br><br>He holds without claiming possession. <br>Creates without seeking praise. <br>Accomplishes without expectation. <br>The work is done and then forgotten. <br>That is why it lasts forever. [Ch. 2]</blockquote><p>Or:</p><blockquote>… <br>If you don’t trust the team enough, <br>they become untrustworthy.<br><br>The Vibe Coder works in silence. <br>When the work is accomplished, <br>the team says, <br>“Amazing. We did it all ourselves.” [Ch. 17]</blockquote><p>Some poems approach a kind of actual techno-spirituality:</p><blockquote>Breakthrough apps, arising from Source, <br>will advance the cybercosm. <br>And even if a hacker goes rogue, <br>Source will not abandon him. [Ch. 62]</blockquote><p>It is difficult to read these lines without feeling the sharp pangs of cringe. This is business talk spliced into ‘ancient wisdom’ as a commodity. It reminds me of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ijnt-eXukwk">Thich Nhat Hanh speaking at Google</a> on Zen mindfulness, part of an outreach programme called <em>Wake Up</em> — another kind of <em>McMindfulness</em>, a term popularized in the <a href="https://openlibrary.org/works/OL20891410W/McMindfulness">book by Ronald Purser</a>.</p><p>The text of <em>The Way of Code</em> seeks to elevate the practice of lazily hacking at code (refer to Karpathy’s original coinage) to a noble embodiment of <em>wei wu wei</em>, usually translated ‘effortless action’. It is a concept of central importance to the <em>Tao Te Ching</em> and, so it is said, to Taoism. The <em>Tao</em> is full of apparently contradictory dual statements of which the most fundamental perhaps is <em>wei / wu wei</em>.</p><p>Ursula Le Guin, in her paraphrase, comments in a footnote to the passage of chapter 3:</p><blockquote>Over and over <em>Lao Tzu</em> says <em>wei wu wei</em>. Do not do. Doing not-doing. To act without acting. Action by inaction. You do nothing yet it gets done.</blockquote><p>In Rubin’s paraphrase, however, it seems like some kind of knowing joke, a tongue-in-cheek, having-it-both-ways, joke that’s not a joke — a postmodern wink. The vibe coder mumbles a lazy order and “the work is accomplished.” Really, the AI is a servant or a junior underling at best. It is not <em>wu wei</em>, it is rather <em>thoughtless-doing</em>.</p><p>In fact, the project <em>did</em> start with a joke tweet Rubin wrote on a whim:</p><blockquote>Tools will come and tools will go. <br>Only The Vibe Coder remains.</blockquote><p>He discusses this and the project in general on the <a href="https://player.fm/series/a16z-podcast/rick-rubin-vibe-coding-is-the-punk-rock-of-software">a16z</a> podcast (of venture capitalist Marc Andreessen):</p><blockquote>The idea of using the <em>Tao</em> [<em>Te Ching</em>] as the basis for it — the <em>Tao</em> is really serious! … It started as a joke. When the <em>Tao</em> became the backbone of it, it got profound! And it surprised me! This could actually do something good…</blockquote><p>The ‘something good’ is a kind of moral outreach to coders who are suggested to be the architects of the future — again, precisely as Thich Nhat Hanh seemed to think worth doing at Google:</p><blockquote>[Host:] The other thing that I thought was great in <em>The Art of Vibe Coding</em> is you give a philosophy for what a human is… If we can’t write marketing collateral or we can’t code, what’s our purpose, and you get kind of deep into that. How do you think about that, I guess? <br>[Rubin:] Well I think it’s the reason I chose the <em>Tao Te Ching</em> to base it on because <em>Tao Te Ching</em> is ‘how to live’, so <em>The Way of Code</em> is talking about how to <em>be</em> in life and — it’s a grounding. And I imagine so many of the people who are coders probably have never read the <em>Tao Te Ching</em> and the coders will likely be the people who are designing our future, so if this is an opportunity for the people who are designing out future to get in touch with the three thousand year old truth of how to create balance in life and on the planet, that seems like a really good thing.</blockquote><p>There is a genuine playfulness to the <em>Tao Te Ching</em>, the potential for profound humour that others too have noted. Le Guin says, “One of the things I love about Lao Tzu is he is so funny. … He goes about it with this deadpan simplicity, talking about pots.” [Ch. 11]</p><p>It is not only ‘serious and old’, it is also confounding and surprising, admonishing but gentle, an invitation to think (without thinking?). Most of all, it is provocative in the paradox of its contrasting statements, many of which turn common sense on it’s head. In the final verdict, in my view, Rubin misses the mark significantly with his work. It is a joke that took itself seriously. As Le Guin has it in her paraphrase:</p><blockquote>Thoughtless people hear about the Way<br>and make jokes about it.<br>It wouldn’t be the Way<br>if there weren’t jokes about it. [Ch. 41]</blockquote><p>Rubin’s work joins others who wed art and technology but favour the latter, such as French artist group <em>Obvious</em> who sold the first AI-produced artwork in Fine Art auction house Christy’s. As <a href="https://medium.com/@skenwrites/the-art-of-ai-prompt-engineering-dd4f23138f7a">I wrote about previously</a>, for <em>Obvious</em> the tech goal subordinates all. They state in their manifesto: “Art is a perfect medium that allows [us] to experiment with the possibilities of an AI and better understand how it all works.” In Rubin’s case, I’d almost go as far as to call it the art-washing of a technology particularly contentious to artists.</p><p>Still, it has captured the imagination of many and become a small phenomenon. What makes the work compelling is not the clumsy poetry but its presentation with the intriguing animation and the invitation to experiment. Nothing I have said here should give you the impression that the AI tools are not impressive — they very much are. And that power, the appearance of it, is the point. The words are ancillary, a framing for elevation.</p><p>Despite the word ‘humility’ appearing frequently in Rubin’s text, I can only see <em>The Way of Code</em> inflating the already considerable self-regard with which many of today’s technologists hold themselves, by validating careless auto-fabrication by association to one of the great texts in world culture.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4fd443fbd0ca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Perennial Philosophy and Syndesiophilia in Christian Alchemy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@skenwrites/the-perennial-philosophy-and-syndesiophilia-in-christian-alchemy-601e16b8d9f7?source=rss-58dea109143------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/601e16b8d9f7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alchemy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gnosticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Kenny]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 09 Mar 2024 10:19:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-24T22:20:11.717Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>In which we find little to commend in a median, conservative interpretation of faith traditions by a modern Gnostic lesson, and coin the term </em>syndesiophilia<em>.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hYqwE9w9T61fWtASj3nr3Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sand dunes in Egypt. Photo by Layla Yehia via Pexels, used with permission.</figcaption></figure><p>There are many differences between the teachings of the world’s belief traditions. For example, is there no god, one god or many gods? What rites and rituals must one perform, at what times, where, and in what manner? Are people basically good, bad, or morally ambiguous? Why is there suffering in the world, and what is its meaning? How is the world to be understood cosmologically, what is the place of humans within it, and what is our fundamental purpose? There is enough conflict within answers to these questions alone to make constructing a single, unifying interpretation difficult by any standard. And yet, it is a tempting prospect that some claim to have solved. The ‘perennial philosophy’ is one such solution.</p><p>The perennial philosophy refers to the idea that all true spiritual wisdom comes from the same single source and that this source has been interpreted differently by all the world’s significant faith traditions. It is a universalist impulse that retains the colouration of the European Renaissance in which it was developed. For those who saw it as hubris to discard the ancient traditions of cultures that were not their own, the diversity and disagreement of heterogenous spirituality presents a problem. A solution was to seek a common root, casting disagreement as surface-level and parochial.</p><p>Of course, the simplest way to make the landscape of belief more coherent is to adhere to one tradition and label all others as ‘false teachings’ — that is, to maintain an exclusive orthodoxy. These false teachings may be the corrupted inklings of the real truth or complete fabrications, perhaps created intentionally by supernatural evils.</p><p>In Christianity, a provocative problem exists in understanding what happens to those who were not exposed to the ‘good news’ of Jesus Christ and, thus, had no opportunity to become Christians and partake of the salvation offered to believers. This is also known as the question of ‘the fate of the unlearned’. By popular account, the ritual of ‘salvation’ begins by first hearing these teachings and then making the choice to accept or reject, with inaction being a <em>de facto</em> rejection. For example, the <em>International Children’s Bible</em> includes in its prefatory pages an unambiguous challenge to the young reader, asking for nothing less than a signed agreement to “accept Him [Jesus] and try to follow Him my whole life”:</p><blockquote>Everyone who has heard or reads the Gospel must either: accept Jesus and receive His power, or leave Him behind.[1]</blockquote><p>This is an individual, personal salvation, but one must first be exposed to the teachings. The publisher of the above ‘international’ Bible edition is American, and no American Christian organisation could have failed to be influenced by the late Evangelical preacher Billy Graham. He was famous for forcefully prompting his listeners to make such a choice. He did this in many sermons and writings, and it was central to his evangelism. It is telling that he named his magazine, founded in 1960, simply <em>Decision</em>. Here is a passage from a sermon, typical of his persuasive style:</p><blockquote>There’s either God, your spiritual father, the true and the living God, Christ. Or, there is the devil. And then you have to choose not only between two ways of life and two masters and two fathers, but you have to choose between two destinies: heaven or hell. …</blockquote><blockquote>Yes, and this choice is very urgent. To delay makes the right decision harder. Indecision is itself a choice. Not to decide is to decide not to. Choose now![2]</blockquote><p>While I have focused on the Christian example here, the same question can be raised by any other faith that insists on a “narrow … way” to salvation[3]. Christians following this theology must ask, what happens to the person who, through no fault of their own, did not encounter these teachings and pointedly demanded to choose?</p><p>In an article on this subject, the popular Evangelical Christian publisher <em>Focus on the Family</em> insists culpability does not depend on an encounter with teachings.[4] Using a book entitled <em>Faith Comes by Hearing: A Response to Inclusivism</em>, they quote:</p><blockquote>Scripture teaches that our condemnation is based on the fact that we are sinners, not because at some point in time we rejected the gospel… Furthermore, God’s wrath is revealed against everyone who suppresses his truth revealed through creation… Strictly speaking, the Bible denies that there are persons who have never heard of God.[5]</blockquote><p>This appears to conflict with the traditional goal of conversion and proselytisation, or at least to make it of much less importance. The modern Christian movement of <em>Evangelicalism</em> is explicit about the priority of spreading their theology — to ‘evangelise’ is to spread the message of the Christian faith, taken from ‘angel’ in Latin, meaning ‘messenger’. Jesus said, “no man cometh unto the Father, but by me”[6] and instructed his followers, “Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature.”[7] These biblical verses, among others, have supported the position that unless one knows about Jesus Christ, there is no way to the salvation he offers.</p><p>The view that knowledge is the essential component of salvation is the most prominent aspect of Gnosticism — <em>gnosis</em> is Greek for <em>knowledge</em>. It was a Christian sect of the early church, existing sometime in 100–350 AD, and possibly even pre-existing Christianity in a proto-Christian form. Biblical scholar Bart D. Ehrman[8] writes that, for the Gnostic, the world is corrupted and “deliverance from the material world can happen only when we learn the secret knowledge that can bring salvation. Some of these texts … indicate that Jesus is the one who brings this knowledge. …It is knowledge of ourselves.”[9]</p><p>In principle, gnosis is derived from the self through reflection and meditation, in contrast with scriptural learning and received wisdom, since, for the Gnostic, humanity partakes directly of the divine, if in a limited way. In practice, however, one must be initiated into a Gnostic mystery teaching, as we shall see shortly. Gnosticism virtually died out (or, rather, was stamped out) with the onset of Christian orthodoxy of the late fourth century as the canonical New Testament books were decided upon. Remnants of these ideas were, however, an influence on medieval Hermeticism and its links to alchemy, but it was not until the discovery of the so-called ‘Gnostic Gospels’, the <em>Nag Hammadi</em>, in Egypt in 1945 that significant primary documents from the Gnostics themselves were known. Before this time, Gnosticism was mainly known through the denunciations of their opponents, from what was to become the orthodox strain of early Christianity.</p><p>It is hard to overstate the impact of the discovery of these documents, as they offered a fresh insight into the plurality of early Christian theology and, for some, supported modern challenges as to what is the correct Christian interpretation of the Bible, and indeed of the choice of scripture considered canon itself. Today, we have a variety of quasi-Christian groups or heretical interpretations, such as <em>A Course in Miracles</em>, that clearly take inspiration from the Gnostic teachings. We also see an influence on those adopting the lineage of the mystery schools and secret and secretive societies that practice rituals and ceremonial magic, such as those developed by alchemists and the Freemasons.</p><p>A core belief of esoteric scholars of the late nineteenth and early twentieth century was universalism, apparent in the works of Manly P. Hall (Philosophical Research Society, f. 1934), Helena “Madame” Blavatsky (Theosophical Society, f. 1875), and Rudolf Steiner (Anthroposophical Society, f. 1913, a German break-away of the American Theosophical Society). They based their work on a syncretic study of world religions and mystery cults, aiming to reconstruct the common thread of an ancient secret mysticism that informed all others. Like the late nineteenth-century anthropologists who developed comparative mythology, their work assumed and looked for a proto-mythology, a once common single mythology, or at least some universally shared source. For example, Hall claimed that “[the secret] doctrine [concerning the inner mysteries of life] has been preserved <em>in toto</em> among a small band of initiated minds since the beginning of the world.”[10]</p><p>Today, some modern seekers continue the work of these occultists, and it is to an example of these teachings that we now turn our attention, a lesson entitled “Mercury, Hermes”[11] from the Alchemy Course of Glorian Publishing. This institution promotes the teachings of Samael Aun Weor (1917–1977), a Colombian esotericist who taught what he called ‘Universal Gnosticism’. The author of this lesson is anonymous, attributed only as “a Gnostic Instructor”. This is very much in keeping with the secretive practices that have kept such knowledge occult (literally, hidden). If these claims are to be believed, some writers, such as Hall, warn us that they were “secret societies, binding their initiates to inviolable secrecy, and avenging with death the betrayal of their sacred trusts.”[12] One wonders why the wisdom of these mysteries is now revealed in courses such as this and how it has managed to remain hidden throughout the centuries.</p><p>This lecture attempts a synthesis of various religious concepts: Christian New Testament theology, the mythology of the Greek god Hermes and later mystical Hermeticism, Jewish mystical Kabbalah, and references to some Eastern teachings such as pertaining to Vedic (Indian) chakras. These are combined under the mission of ‘alchemy’ in the Hermetic tradition — that is, <em>spiritual</em> alchemy, where the alchemical transmutation occurs within the practitioner on a metaphysical level rather than as a crude material process and a discredited science, the progenitor of chemistry. The lecture is a primer on the ethical life and practices of the Gnostic, with some hints as to what this should look like and attempts to provide scriptural legitimacy to this aim with a variety of expansive symbolic links to various spiritual traditions.</p><p>The Gnostic Instructor puts it this way: “Alchemy is about transforming ourselves. That is the real secret of Alchemy.” In what way may the self be transformed? Here, much is borrowed from the eminent psychologist C. G. Jung, who included alchemy as perhaps primary among his many mystical interests. An influential collection of his lectures can be found in his <em>Psychology and Alchemy</em>. Jung, too, studied Gnosticism and even purchased part of the <em>Nag Hammadi</em> for his own library. This portion is popularly known as the <em>Jung Codex</em>.</p><p>Jung’s theories propose a background realm of shared human consciousness that he called the collective unconscious. While primarily a psychological concept, it has a mystical aspect in that Jung saw it as connecting individual human consciousnesses in a way that was more than just figurative. In his theory of the psyche, <em>archetypes</em> reside in the collective unconscious and are expressed in the personal subconscious as <em>complexes</em>. A detailed review is beyond the scope of this essay, but it is worth noting that he saw these archetypes in a way reminiscent of a pantheon of gods.[13] Because of this, subsequent mystical writers have found significant latitude in using his work to connect the myths of antiquity to our modern understanding of the mind and to reinterpret mythology as personal psychology. We see that in the lesson of the Gnostic Instructor with the emphasis on Hermes.</p><p>Common to mystics is a foregrounding of the interpretation of symbols and a rejection of obvious, surface-level literalism. To a degree, this echoes the Platonic Idealism and the theory of Forms, where symbols are representations of a spiritual reality and, so, ways to access them. Symbols are always thought to contain secret teachings if only one knows how to interpret them. A. E. Waite, creator of the <em>Rider-Waite-Smith</em> tarot deck (the world’s most popular tarot variant), wrote in his companion to that deck that “symbolism is the most catholic [universal] expression in concealment of things that are most profound in the Sanctuary…”.[14] Hall, in his <em>magnum opus</em> work, <em>The Secret Teachings of All Ages</em>, writes:</p><blockquote>By symbols men have ever sought to communicate to each other those thoughts which transcend the limitations of language. Rejecting man-conceived dialects as inadequate and unworthy to perpetuate divine ideas, the Mysteries thus chose symbolism as a far more ingenious and ideal method of preserving their transcendental knowledge. …</blockquote><blockquote>Their knowledge of chemistry and mathematics they hid within mythologies which the ignorant would perpetuate…[15]</blockquote><p>The Glorian lecture makes various tenuous claims of the relationship between ancient symbols. For example, that Greek Herma stones, related to Hermes, is what is meant by Jacob’s stone pillow in the biblical story of the dream of the ladder to heaven (Genesis 28), and of how this links with Masonic pillars, which connect to a Tibetan Buddhist physiological understanding of the spine, connecting with the erect penis, again, as seen on Herma stones. It is heavily implied that this interpretation suggests knowledge—in fact, the Truth—shared among the Greeks, Egyptians, Tibetans, and others. It is here we find our perennialism. Recall Hall’s claim that there is an unbroken lineage of knowledge protected by secret societies. However, The Gnostic Instructor is much less cautious in speculating on potential links such as the above than more serious scholars like Hall. We may coin a neologism to capture their attitude: <em>syndesiophilia</em> — the love of connection, from the Greek for connection, <em>syndesi</em>, and <em>philia</em>, in the common suffix as used in English to denote love or attraction, especially to an object or practice. I intend this to capture not only a love of connection but an excessive focus on connective speculation.</p><p>Undoubtedly, no figure looms larger in the Western mind of the last two millennia than Jesus of Nazareth, the itinerant apocalyptic Jewish preacher of the late Second Temple period whose followers founded Christianity from his teachings. The significant details of his life story have been proposed by some to contain curious similarities to that of older ‘pagan’ gods, such as Mithras (Iranian, adopted by Romans), Osirus (Egyptian), Dionysus and Attis (Greek), as well as the historical Greek philosopher and mystic Apollonius of Tyana.[16] These coincidences seem to point to a prolific borrowing in the mythology of the ancient Near East, but syndesiophiliacs are prone to view the situation as one of intentional, secret relationships across cultures.</p><p>Central to the argument of the lesson, though only somewhat loosely implied, is that the figure of Jesus Christ is a symbolic continuation of the Greek god Hermes and that, therefore, Christianity continues the Hermetic mystery cult tradition, with its exoteric (outwardly visible) side as traditional Christianity as we know it, and its truer esoteric and mystical side hidden but revealed through the study of alchemy. It is repeatedly emphasised that these figures, like all others in art and scripture, should be taken symbolically and not literally.</p><p>However, the Hermetic tradition that feeds into medieval alchemy has not as much as might appear to do with ancient Greek mythology and more with early first millennium Egyptian Hermeticism, where the Greek Hermes was conflated with the Egyptian god Thoth. (This name has been preferred by some wishing to emphasise Egyptian mysticism, such as Aleister Crowley in his Thoth Tarot, for example.) In the second century AD or earlier, an esoteric strain of Gnosticism existed in Alexandria, Egypt, following the teachings of Hermes Trismegistus, or Hermes ‘thrice greatest’.[17] The major work attributed to this figure is the <em>Corpus Hermeticum</em>, written by unknown adepts in the second or third century AD. It was to be a very influential work on medieval esotericism.</p><p>A particular claim stands out of the Gnostic Instructor’s lesson, an odd one at that. The Instructor links the Hebrew word for oil שמן (Latinised to <em>shemen</em>) with the English word ‘semen’. We read:</p><blockquote>This Hebrew word is translated as “oil,” and is a symbol of how the initiates retain and transform their sexual energy, by “anointing their stone.” That is, the sexual matter is not expelled from the body, but is transformed inside… Oil in the Bible represents transmuted sexual energy. The anointing of oil is a symbol of transmutation.[18]</blockquote><p>There is, in fact, no relationship between these words other than a superficial phonetic similarity. The English word ‘semen’ comes from the Latin for ‘seed’ and is distinct in its history from Semitic languages like Hebrew. Unfounded and dubious claims such as this are not uncommon throughout the lesson. We also read a questionable connection between the Jewish menorah, a seven-branched candle holder: “What is a menorah? It is a series of seven pipes, the pan-pipes that Hermes invented.”[19] There could be some shared significance through the number seven, as it was used widely in antiquity to symbolise the divine, but any direct relationship is entirely unclear and unestablished in the literature.</p><p>Instead of providing credible reasoning and sources, the Gnostic Instructor seems content to speculate on the ancient sources to suit their own decidedly modern interpretation. The Christian book <em>Misreading Scripture with Western Eyes</em>[20] deals with this subject, making a case for a historical reading of biblical scripture rather than applying modern concepts and interpretive techniques to extract teachings (though not to dismiss scriptural authority — the authors are pious Christians). Their motivating question is: what went without being said? Ancient art and texts, as with modern instances, take for granted an enormous amount of knowledge assumed by its intended audience and known to those contemporary with the work itself.</p><p>In Disney’s 1989 film <em>The Little Mermaid</em>, the titular mermaid Ariel asks her seagull friend Scuttle to explain the name and purpose of a metal fork found on the sea floor. After a thoughtful pause, he confidently proclaims it is a ‘dinglehopper’, saying that “humans use these little babies to straighten their hair out.”[21] Ariel takes his word for it, considering him wise, and later embarrasses herself when in human form at a dinner by combing her hair with one. What went without being said for the makers of the fork is that it was cutlery.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*QDJFZXnybGGbt3QjWSAFRA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Still from <em>The Little Mermaid</em>, Disney, 1989. Used under fair use for cultural criticism.</figcaption></figure><p>The authors of <em>Misreading Scripture</em> explain that “we instinctively fill in the gap [of our scriptural understanding] with a piece of our own culture — usually a piece that goes without being said.”[22] The Gnostic Instructor does this with their assumption of a shared root between <em>shemen</em> and semen. Using a promiscuous ecumenical syndesiophilia, they are convinced they have extracted the true hidden meaning, but this is a mistake.</p><p>Beyond an interesting summary of various ancient mystical traditions and the associated mythology, though it is misleading and flawed, the wisdom that the Instructor offers is quite conventional — hardly befitting the claim of secret teachings. The following passage is representative:</p><blockquote>The abysses are our mind, our animalism, pride, lust, envy, greed, gluttony, fear, arrogance, anger, hate, jealousy. …None of that can go to heaven. It has to be separated; it has to be purged and purified. That is what Alchemy means: to transform lead into gold. The lead is our ego. Lead is our desire. It is a base, heavy, impure metal that sinks into hell.[23]</blockquote><p>The advice is to avoid immorality and vice and to control and redirect desires and passions, especially of the sexual variety. These are not secret teachings by any means. Elsewhere, the Gnostic Instructor categorises traditional religion as “a lunar path”, inferior to “the new solar current [and] the new Christic current.”[24] The solar path is that of “awakened consciousness”, whereas lunar, traditional religion is implied to be asleep and automatic. The Instructor says that awakened ones practice “eliminating ego, giving birth to virtue, and serving others.”[25] It is unclear how this differs from the highest virtues of traditional religions, which are largely ordinary human virtues. For example, in the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus tells his disciples, “If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me.”[26]</p><p>Spiritual hierarchy is a core feature of Gnosticism, as well as the suggestion that not everyone is fit to receive the real wisdom and the truth. All secret and secretive societies and mystery cults maintain this self-congratulatory elitism. The Gnostic Instructor attempts to mitigate the force of this by referring to the lunar path as “not bad.”[27] Still, it is apparent that those on it are not awakened and, likely, will not receive true salvation, which for the Gnostic means liberation from the material world. According to Ehrman, this attitude is consistent with even the earliest Gnostics in the first centuries after Christ: “The Gnostics virtually fetishized this notion of an elite, a group of people in the know, who recognized the true nature of the church’s procession of faith, of its Scriptures, of its sacraments.”[28]</p><p>Perhaps one teaching that may, at first glance, appear uncommon is the implication that abstaining from sex, either with a partner or in masturbation, conserves energy. We read earlier that “initiates retain and transform their sexual energy” and that by doing this “sexual matter is not expelled from the body, but is transformed inside”.[29] Though sexual abstinence is by no means historically uncommon in religious practices, today, it is often talked about for men under the term ‘semen retention’, emphasising the symbolic storing of male power.</p><p>The moral dimension of this practice shows its real reason for men today; it is conflated with recovery from addiction to pornography and is related to the ‘no fap’ men’s betterment movement (‘fap’ being an onomatopoeic term for masturbation common in online speech). By adherents, masturbation is considered a weakness, and ejecting the ‘vital’ fluid of semen, one symbolically loses one’s male virile power. Books such as <em>Semen Retention Miracle</em> by Joseph Peterson promote this practice’s health benefits, confidently crossing the line from symbolic to literal. Peterson purports that excessive sperm production caused by frequent ejaculation leads to vitamin deficiency and low levels of testosterone, as well as wasting time and energy that can be redirected to more worthy pursuits. Indeed, <em>Semen Retention Miracle</em> cites a Glorian Publishing article in its bibliography on Veerya (Vīrya), referencing a Hindu practice of sexual abstinence.[30]</p><p>A comment from Alan Watts is relevant on the practices of sexual control related in the Indian roots of chakras, tantric yoga, and the <em>kundalini</em>. Watts bears much responsibility for popularising such teachings in the West and yet remains one of the most subtle interpreters:</p><blockquote>The practice of sexual yoga employs a male and a female partner [in which they] arouse the sexual force. The theory is that instead of dissipating this energy in the ordinary way — through orgasm — they send it up the spinal tree, back into the brain. <strong>Do not take this literally. It is symbolism.</strong> To take this symbolism literally would be to turn it into a superstition. … All of these images are ways of talking about our inner anatomy, our psychic anatomy. [Emphasis added.] [31]</blockquote><p>There are, in fact, many interesting similarities between the world’s ancient traditions that beg for explanation, making this lesson from Glorian Publishing all the more disappointing. Excavating the past and attempting to reassemble fragmentary ruins is a task that requires careful scholarship. The Gnostic Instructor is right to point out that many Jewish and Christian Bible texts contain symbolism and can be read allegorically. Only the most fundamentalist scripturalists believe there was a first man named Adam from whom the first woman named Eve was created from his rib. For a credible but no less controversial interpretation of the biblical creation story as an allegory for the foundation of the early Jewish temple, we can read <em>The Lost World of Genesis One</em>.[32] The author, a Bible-believing Christian, attempts to make sense of the Book of Genesis without taking it literally. In the case of the Glorian lesson, however, the Instructor espouses the particular heretical theological claim that “the forces of divinity create the perfect Adam, which is a self-realized being, which is another god.”[33] It is truly impossible to make such a claim consistent with any form of mainstream Christianity. Even Gnosticism allows only for a “spark of the divine”[34] within humanity. We may now consider this a kind of revisionist or post-Christian teaching.</p><p>Unfortunately, works such as this lesson from Glorian Publishing do more to confuse and obscure than to illuminate. The strategy seems to be to overwhelm the student with a torrent of facts and a loose but complex web of connections, impressive in scope but inscrutable as a whole. It may be perfectly adequate as a vehicle for their spiritual teachings, but to the serious mystical seeker, they gamble their credibility. This is, of course, by no means uncommon. Some examples of more reliable work can be found in the aforementioned writings of Manly P. Hall and also more recent scholars such as John Michael Greer and Gary Lachman. These authors’ work is accessible and clear, and yet, admirably, they do not betray their scholarship in the name of their spiritual beliefs and goals.</p><p>The quality of discourse in the Glorian lesson is reminiscent of the discredited and debunked film <em>Zeitgeist: The Movie,</em>and we may even consider the former to be an ancestor of the latter. <em>Zeitgeist,</em> too, proposes a secret and revisionist reading of the story of Jesus, with a stronger emphasis on the zodiac. The filmmaker claims that Jesus was a symbolic sun god linked with the Egyptian Horus. An earlier cut of the movie, which has been edited to remove this claim,[35] makes a very similar error to the Gnostic Instructor in relating the English word ‘sun’ with ‘son’, as in Jesus as the Son of God, an error of basic etymology.</p><p><em>Zeitgeist: The Movie</em> ultimately concludes that religion is an evil thought-control mechanism used by a secret lineage of masters to control the world, responsible for the 9/11 World Trade Center attacks, among other events. The difference between those who consider themselves the heirs of ancient secret mysteries is in the moral tone of their vision and the suspicion or acceptance of elitism. To modern Gnostics, who have reinvented this ancient religion, the secret society of initiates are the ‘good guys’. But they share a propensity for incautious symbolic thinking and a belief in hidden secrets that are the basis for conspiracy thinking. It is here that there is the potential for the danger of becoming lost in a speculative house of cards that justifies paranoia.</p><p>A truly <em>gnostic</em> philosophical approach may be a valuable counterbalance to creeping syndesiophilia, especially as applied to their own teachings — a love of knowledge and a belief that it is the key to freedom. One must balance the exoteric — including historical analysis and engagement with the best contemporary scholarship — with the esoteric rather than haphazardly inventing unfounded connections.</p><p>[1] <em>Holy Bible: International Children’s Bible, New Century Version</em>. Word Publishing, 1991, p. ix.</p><p>[2] “Making Choices — A Powerful Billy Graham Sermon.” <em>Bibilium.Com</em>, 2 Mar. 2021, bibilium.com/making-choices-billy-graham-sermon/.</p><p>[3] <em>King James Bible</em>, Matthew 7:14.</p><p>[4] Velarde, Robert. “What about Those Who Have Never Heard?” <em>Focus on the Family</em>, 1 Jan. 2009, <a href="http://www.focusonthefamily.com/faith/what-about-those-who-have-never-heard/">www.focusonthefamily.com/faith/what-about-those-who-have-never-heard/.</a></p><p>[5] Morgan, Christopher W., and Robert A. Peterson. <em>Faith Comes by Hearing: A Response to Inclusivism</em>. IVP Academic, 2008, p. 241.</p><p>[6] <em>King James Bible</em>, John 14:6.</p><p>[7] <em>King James Bible</em>, Mark 16:15.</p><p>[8] It should be noted that Ehrman is a ‘lapsed’ Christian and is a controversial scholar for many Christian believers, though his scholarship is still respected by most.</p><p>[9] Ehrman, Bart D. <em>Lost Christianities: The Battles for Scripture and the Faiths We Never Knew</em>. Oxford University Press, 2002, p. 114.</p><p>[10] Hall, Manly P. 1928. <em>The Secret Teachings of All Ages</em>. TarcherPerigee, 2003, p. 38.</p><p>[11] Gnostic Instructor. “Mercury, Hermes — Alchemy, a Free Course.” <em>Glorian</em>, Glorian Publishing, <a href="https://glorian.org/learn/courses-and-lectures/alchemy/mercury-hermes.">https://glorian.org/learn/courses-and-lectures/alchemy/mercury-hermes.</a> Accessed 30 Sept. 2023.</p><p>[12] Hall, p. 37.</p><p>[13] See ‘Chapter 5: Jung and Psychological Mysticism’ from my book <em>A Critical Introduction to Tarot: Examining the Nature of a Belief in Tarot</em>, Iff Books, 2023, Simon Kenny.</p><p>[14] Waite, Arthur Edward. 1910. <em>The Pictorial Key to the Tarot</em>. Rider, 2021, pp. xi–xii.</p><p>[15] Hall, p. 37.</p><p>[16] Lachman, Gary. The Secret Teachers of the Western World. TarcherPerigee, 2015, p. 102.</p><p>[17] Lachman, p. 131.</p><p>[18] Gnostic Instructor, <em>op. cit.</em></p><p>[19] <em>Ibid.</em></p><p>[20] Richards, E. Randolph, and Brandon J. O’Brien. <em>Misreading Scripture with Western Eyes: Removing Cultural Blinders to Better Understand the Bible</em>. IVP Books, 2012.</p><p>[21] <em>The Little Mermaid</em>. Directed by Ron Clements and John Musker, Walt Disney Pictures, 1989.</p><p>[22] Richards, pp. 12–13.</p><p>[23] Gnostic Instructor, <em>op. cit.</em></p><p>[24] <em>Ibid.</em></p><p>[25] <em>Ibid.</em></p><p>[26] <em>King James Bible</em>. Matthew 16:24.</p><p>[27] Gnostic Instructor, <em>op. cit.</em></p><p>[28] Ehrman, pp. 132–3.</p><p>[29] Gnostic Instructor, <em>op. cit.</em></p><p>[30] Sivananda. “Ayurveda: Veerya, the Vital Fluid.” <em>Glorian</em>, Glorian Publishing, <a href="https://glorian.org/learn/scriptures/hindu/ayurveda-virya-the-vital-fluid.">https://glorian.org/learn/scriptures/hindu/ayurveda-virya-the-vital-fluid.</a> Accessed 11 Jan. 2024.</p><p>[31] Watts, Alan. 1996. “Buddhism: The Religion of No-Religion.” Tuttle Publishing, 1999, p. 89.</p><p>[32] Walton, John H. <em>The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate</em>. IVP Academic, 2009.</p><p>[33] Gnostic Instructor, <em>op. cit.</em></p><p>[34] Ehrman, p. 124.</p><p>[35] <a href="https://skepticproject.com/articles/zeitgeist/part-one/#interesting_findings">https://skepticproject.com/articles/zeitgeist/part-one/#interesting_findings</a></p><p><em>Note: a version of this essay appeared on an ill-fated Substack.</em></p><p>Simon Kenny is an independent researcher and writer based in Ireland. His work combines probing questions with technical thinking to explore the landscape of belief.</p><p><a href="https://linktr.ee/simonkenny">simonkenny | Instagram | Linktree</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*-VRw6xOZ-ZzWnPGDhFdXCQ.png" /></figure><p>My book, <em>A Critical Introduction to Tarot</em>, explores what tarot means today. It is available in paperback and ebook: <a href="https://www.collectiveinkbooks.com/iff-books/our-books/critical-introduction-tarot">https://www.collectiveinkbooks.com/iff-books/our-books/critical-introduction-tarot</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=601e16b8d9f7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Joy of X: Completion and The Tarot]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@skenwrites/the-joy-of-x-completion-and-the-tarot-fd3b1e47d2e2?source=rss-58dea109143------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fd3b1e47d2e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[esoteric]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tarot]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[occult]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mysticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Kenny]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 30 Dec 2023 12:57:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-15T17:00:57.569Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YamsyTZg7TgLkKVMH8sOVg.png" /><figcaption>Rider-Waite-Smith cards numbered 10. Left to right: Pentacles, Wands, Swords, and Cups.</figcaption></figure><p>Winter marks the completion of another turn around the sun. It is a bittersweet time as we say goodbye to one year, never to return, and welcome a new year’s beginning. As frost sets in and the cold wind blows, life can become harder on the vulnerable, and so charity and invitation become more important. For this, among other reasons, we find various rituals and feast days at this time of year to brighten the year’s night and filling out its quiet hours with merriment, laughter, and love. These respites are all the more important when times are hard, as they are for many, especially those affected by poverty, homelessness, and war.</p><p>Originating in the late medieval period, and still containing imagery of this time, tarot evokes such images. Observe the Five of Pentacles, the poor and wounded in the snow seeking help at a church; the Knight of Swords gallops into battle on their horse, sword drawn; a worker takes a break from tilling the land in the Seven of Pentacles.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oZVoVrBzJAKBpagIrCLBPQ.png" /><figcaption>Rider-Waite-Smith cards. Left to right: 5 of Pentacles, Knight of Swords, and 7 of Pentacles.</figcaption></figure><p>In the tarot, the number 10, or X in Roman numeral form, signifies completion. Most readers will know the tarot as a fortune-telling device, but it has been used variously for deeper mystical purposes as well as for everyday gaming. The 78-card tarot deck is comprised of two parts: the major arcana and the minor arcana. The major arcana consists of 22 cards representing archetypes corresponding to the large themes of life — for example, Death and The Lovers. The minor arcana bears a close resemblance to the ‘standard’ card deck of today, with four suits — Wands, Cups, Swords, and Pentacles — each with four court cards — Page, Knight, Queen, and King — and ten numbered ‘pip’ cards. They are often interpreted as representing mundane and quotidian matters. Of these suits, four cards are numbered 10, each revealing a different aspect of finality.</p><p>The <em>Rider-Waite-Smith</em> Tarot (from here, abbreviated to <em>RWS</em>), the world’s most famous and popular deck, added detailed illustrations to the minor arcana when it was created by A. E. Waite and Pamela Colman Smith in the early twentieth century. In almost all previous tarot card designs, only the major arcana had detailed illustrations; the minor arcana simply contained collections of the suited objects, as in common playing cards. Until the 1900s, the <em>Tarot de Marseilles</em> was the most common tarot deck for the previous several hundred years. It had a simple woodcut print design, tailored for the mass production of the time, rather than detailed illustrations. We can attribute the popularity of the <em>RWS</em> deck to its purchase by Stuart R. Kaplan of U.S. Games Systems, the American publisher who was the first to mass-produce tarot by modern means. The popularity of the <em>RWS</em> cannot only be attributed to its wide availability, however. Though many decks have been produced, especially in recent years, thanks to the reduction in production costs and sophistication of computer design software, few can rival the symbolic complexity of the <em>RWS</em>. For these reasons, we will base the following tarot contemplation on the illustrations and ‘traditional’ correspondences of this deck.</p><h3><strong>Plenty: 10 of Pentacles</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/246/1*TLYGzH4n0Cqdo-DQRx2njw.png" /><figcaption>Rider-Waite-Smith, 10 of Pentacles.</figcaption></figure><p>The <em>RWS</em> deck attempts to build on the earlier work of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century French tarot occultists, such as Éliphas Lévi, Papus, and Court de Gébelin. Following on mainly from Lévi, A. E. Waite incorporated the scholarship of medieval Kabbalah (Jewish mysticism) directly into the illustrations, whereas before, they were learned ‘secrets’ imposed on the cards. Thus, we see the Kabbalistic ‘Tree of Life’ in the Ten of Pentacles, the particular configuration of ‘nodes’ represented by ten pentacles. As you may recall, this tree was one of two trees existing in the mythical Garden of Eden as written in the first holy book of Judaism and Christianity, Genesis. Incidentally, we also see this portrayed in The Lovers card, along with Adam and Eve.</p><p>In the Kabbalist presentation, the ten nodes are called <em>sephirot</em> (alternatively, <em>sephiroth</em>), which, for Kabbalists, are aspects or emanations of the Hebrew God. Through these ten aspects and using the tarot, Lévi proposed that “man could discover all that is knowable concerning his God, his universe, and himself.” (Manly P. Hall, <em>The Secret Teachings of All Ages</em>, TarcherPerigee, 1928, p. 385.) It is the completion and perfection of mystical knowledge. In keeping with this, one tarot spread (a way to meaningfully lay out cards on a table for interpretation) uses the shape of the Tree of Life. (One can read about it in Benebell Wen’s <em>Holistic Tarot</em>.) Finally, the traditional way to link these nodes, the lines that connect them, give 22 paths, the same number of major arcana and letters in the Hebrew alphabet.</p><p>Behind the pentacles, this card depicts the entranceway to a wealthy home, its domesticity and security emphasized by a pair of loyal dogs. The pentacles often double as coins throughout the cards, representing fortune and material wealth but also the negative aspects of greed and avarice. A young couple stands shoulder to shoulder, united, the female figure on the right gazing lovingly at her mate. An old man sits in his highly stylized robe, woven with grapes, a traditional symbol of wealth and plenty. Pentacles are associated with the earth that gives forth its fruit and bounty (all the suits have an elemental association), and the grapes also feature in the previous card, the Nine of Pentacles, and on the robe of the King of Pentacles. It seems that this figure is the king in his dotage and, along with the child, completes the three phases of life: youth, maturity, and old age. This card depicts material security and family stability together with higher knowledge and divine understanding.</p><h3><strong>Exhaustion: 10 of Wands</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/248/1*PCt7NHsMU_LgotxzcJ5zmg.png" /><figcaption>Rider-Waite-Smith, 10 of Wands.</figcaption></figure><p>Sometimes, the kind of completion we feel is a complete lack. We are burned out, our energy spent, and yet we must somehow push on. This is what the Ten of Wands traditionally represents: being overburdened. We see a figure carrying a load of sticks (the eponymous wands), head down, walking toward a stately homestead. Perhaps it is the gated manor of the Ten of Pentacles, this figure laboring in support of their wealth. There are many such homely locations on the minor arcana, focused, as they are, on medieval tropes.</p><p>Though the figure is clearly performing some work, this card is the most subtle of the Tens and has the least apparent meaning in isolation. In his guidebook <em>The Pictorial Key to the Tarot</em>, Waite calls it “a card of false-seeming, disguise, perfidy.” (A. E. Waite, <em>The Pictorial Key to the Tarot</em>, Rider, 1910, p. 190.) The latter word, meaning a breach of faith or trust, has fallen out of use in everyday speech but is retained in the legal language of war as a bad-faith deceptive action and a war crime. The suit of Wands is associated with the element of fire and, along with the Swords, lends themselves to interpretations based on conflict. Waite writes that it is fortune followed by oppression, something seemingly good leading to a contentious conclusion.</p><p>This card is an uncomfortable one and emphasizes that not all ends are good ends and that fortune has its burdens — if not for the fortunate, then for others. In this sense, it can be interpreted as representing the interrelation and networks of privilege that never seem to balance out. Behind all wealth is work, and behind all work are people, some toiling away with the manor in sight but ever out of reach.</p><h3><strong>Death: 10 of Swords</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/243/1*29wIk1J85gdwhc_w98IDHg.png" /><figcaption>Rider-Waite-Smith, 10 of Swords.</figcaption></figure><p>It is a well-known insight to tarot readers that the Death card is not to be taken literally; it is also held to represent change and rebirth. Viewed expansively, every kind of change is an end or death of some sort, especially painful changes. As we consider the year’s end, it is often imagined as a death, though one that contains the dormant seed of its new beginning.</p><p>The Death card is in the major arcana and is numbered XIII or 13, a number widely thought in the West to be unlucky. The <em>RWS</em> features a skeletal, armored Death riding a white horse. It is reminiscent of one of the four horsemen of The Apocalypse of John, or the biblical Book of Revelation, which ends the New Testament. Four human figures surround Death on the card: a dead king; a bishop standing, beseeching Death with hands outstretched; a little child, looking innocently at Death, kneeling; finally, a young woman kneels with head turned away in grief. The diversity of these figures recalls the medieval <em>Danse Macabre</em>, or Dance of Death, where Death — the ‘great leveller’ — summons people of every age and station, all bound for the same fate.</p><p>Tarot originates in late-Renaissance Italy, likely in fifteenth-century Milan. It was the time of the plague of the ‘Black Death’, and in Milan, everyone had a friend or family member who had succumbed to the disease. Being commonplace and yet still so terrifying, death became an almost obsessive focus of the art of this period. Early tarot decks show Death as a skeleton holding the familiar scythe (e.g., the <em>Visconti di Modrone</em>) or an instrument of power, such as a bow (e.g., the <em>Visconti-Sforza</em> deck).</p><p>Death visited the people, not only because of capricious disease and old age but also because of the violence of war. In the Ten of Swords, we see a figure, betrayed. Face down, pinned to the ground by ten swords, they are literally ‘stabbed in the back’. The dark clouds in the sky offer us no comfort, but there is an indication that, despite this overwhelming tragedy, the figure is at peace. With their protruding right hand, they make the symbol of benediction — a blessing. Perhaps this individual died well and accepted their fate (although Waite writes in his guidebook that “It is not especially a card of violent death.”) It could be interpreted as a sign of forgiveness, of blessing one’s enemies. Though tarot readers are quick to reassure that death is not the end of everything, it is still the end of a life, and most treat it solemnly. Before moving on to the new, the old must be respectfully and carefully put to rest.</p><h3><strong>Love: 10 of Cups</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/232/1*pG0H2qeh4EzdjT8X3Vyg_Q.png" /><figcaption>Rider-Waite-Smith, 10 of Cups.</figcaption></figure><p>The <em>Rider-Waite-Smith</em> deck is full of medieval tropes, reportedly inspired by the Victorian and Edwardian theatrical garb of Pamela Colman Smith’s friends. Waite and Smith were obsessed with the legend of King Arthur and the Holy Grail, Waite authoring a book on the subject while they worked on their tarot deck.</p><p>Though he left the Catholic church, Waite was steeped in the kind of medieval Christian ritual maintained in the Latin rite, as opposed to the more austere and iconoclastic Protestant variety. The Holy Grail itself is represented as the chalice of the suit of Cups, which, for the Catholic, is the vessel containing Christ’s blood, drunk in the Eucharist or Holy Communion ritual. (In my own Protestant upbringing, we were often offered synthetic fruit juice in plastic vessels resembling shot glasses — a simulation of a simulation.) In the Ace of Cups, the first pip card, we see the dove of peace offering a communion wafer in its beak as it flies over a massive chalice. Water springs forth abundantly, the element of this suit.</p><p>The Ten of Cups is the love of marital bliss and the union of souls. A couple, their arms wrapped around each other’s waists, gesture with thanks to a rainbow splayed with ten chalices. To their right, two children dance, and behind them, we see a lush hillside by a river, with a house just protruding out of a clump of trees. This is not the ostentatious manor of the Ten of Pentacles or the Ten of Wands, nor the ruin of the Ten of Swords; this is a pretty homestead of modest means. The cups most often signify a gift or an offer, as they hold the offered. What is provided here is received, and gratefully so.</p><p>The rainbow is a universally benevolent symbol, but for the Christian mystic, it will recall the myth of The Great Flood or Deluge, featuring Noah’s Ark. In the biblical book of Genesis, we read how his curious boat saved the people and animals of the world from drowning under the punishment God sent due to his displeasure at human wickedness. After the flood subsided, and Noah now the only patriarch of humankind, the tale says that God symbolized his ‘covenant’ or promise in the form of the rainbow, never again to flood the earth. The water element of the Cups will ever after support only life and happiness, its dark, overwhelming qualities kept in check by a divine promise.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>The core proposition of occultism is that things are not as they seem and that there is a greater truth behind the obvious. The word ‘occult’ shares its root with the common word ‘occlude’, meaning to hide, obstruct, or become closed. Occultism is getting beyond such difficulties to — it is hoped — the Truth. Esotericism, another similarly used term applied to tarot studies, is the opposite of exotericism, where ‘eso’ is meaning from within and ‘exo’ meaning from without. Finally, mysticism pertains to transcendent knowledge, often personally experiential.</p><p>Putting these three terms together — occult, esoteric, mystic — we can summarize the approach to knowledge that the tarot suggests: inner knowledge, hidden from everyday, unskilled awareness, that transcends rational inquiry. It should not be surprising then that the leading modern interpretation of tarot is based in psychology, that contemporary science that plumbs the depths of experience, and the Jungian school in particular. Jung was, in many ways, a romantic, mystical idealist who, at times, spoke with imaginary beings, believed in an Ideal world of archetypes (the collective unconscious), and rejected a purely causal understanding of consequence (synchronicity).</p><p>Whether one believes tarot can be used successfully for fortune-telling or not, it is clear that, at least for the <em>Rider-Waite-Smith</em> deck, it is an encoding of symbolic knowledge. In fact, Waite believed it already contained such knowledge. Perhaps it is a self-fulfilling prophecy that his deck should, by his own effort, intentionally contain such meanings. To appreciate them, some knowledge of the roots of its symbols is useful, but Waite believed in the so-called perennial philosophy, the idea that all knowledge springs from the same fountain and that by individual study, meditation, and perhaps even prayer, one could come to know all secrets — and perhaps even complete oneself.</p><p>Simon Kenny is an author, technologist, and educator whose work combines probing questions with technical thinking. He is the author of <em>A Critical Introduction to Tarot</em> (Iff Books, UK, 2023). It presents tarot to the incredulous and curious, to those who wish to know the basis for its continued cultural relevance. Simon is based in Galway, Ireland.</p><p>My book, <em>A Critical Introduction to Tarot</em> is now available on Amazon (<a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/Critical-Introduction-Tarot-Examining-Nature/dp/1803413921/">UK store</a>, or <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Critical-Introduction-Tarot-Examining-Nature/dp/1803413921">USA and rest of the world</a>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*-VRw6xOZ-ZzWnPGDhFdXCQ.png" /><figcaption>A Critical Introduction to Tarot: Examining the Nature of a Belief in Tarot — Cover.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fd3b1e47d2e2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Art of AI Prompt Engineering]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@skenwrites/the-art-of-ai-prompt-engineering-dd4f23138f7a?source=rss-58dea109143------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dd4f23138f7a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[generative-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[prompt-engineering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[generative-ai-tools]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Kenny]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 25 Nov 2023 22:19:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-15T17:00:26.423Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When I was nine years old, I ‘created’ my first AI chatbot on the Commodore 64. I asked my 7-year-old sister to ask it questions, and it would respond with answers. For it to work, she had to type in a question, turn away from the computer screen (an old CRT TV), and when she turned around, her query would be answered. The AI was, of course, a fake.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2HgId9TumBG8CtRSHAXa1g.png" /></figure><p>Like a low-budget Wizard of Oz, I quietly typed in the answers to her questions, her playing along with my game. What made it fun was that it was vaguely plausible. The computer could have responded on its own, just as we’d seen computers do in films and TV shows.</p><p>Today, this game of make-believe has been realised with the advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, Bard and others. The dream of talking machines — and, crucially, <em>talking to machines</em> — is now real, but we seem less interested in enjoying competent conversationalists than in what work they can do. This is AI as an assistant rather than as a friend.</p><p>Some of this work is, admittedly, conversational. AI can be used in talk therapy and to give advice, albeit drawing from commonplace wisdom. The mental health chatbot Wysa is one such popular service, with accolades from the World Economic Forum.[1] Indeed, one of the earliest chatbots, the 1960s program ELISA, was modelled after the conversational pattern of a psychotherapist.</p><p>But what has really captured the zeitgeist is to command an AI to produce some work, such as writing an article, some computer code, or creating an artwork. Those searching for optimal results have coined their efforts at crafting questions ‘prompt engineering’.</p><p>Prompt engineering is seen as a nascent software craft by its practitioners. Curiously, it tacitly recognises that the current generation of AI are not artificial persons but rather machines that work by natural language inputs. Human workers must ‘engineer’ the commands to produce the best result, not simply asking in plain language (called ‘natural language’ in the jargon). The expectation of a computer to respond appropriately to such utterances is routinely exploited for laughs in comedy programmes, painted as a naive trait of the older, less tech-savvy generation, such as writing “Dear Google…” into Google Search.</p><p>Consider the following prompt:</p><blockquote>red hair woman, mid 30’s, great smile, purple sweater, brown jeans, cross hatching technique, pencil sketch, 4k</blockquote><p>The above shows several common image-prompting techniques, including comma-separated keywords, descriptive terms, style terms and rendering terms. It is patently <em>unconversational</em>. Using this prompt with Midjourney version 5 algorithm renders these four images:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GgdZ0hsMj9q5TMCD2b5oBg.png" /></figure><p>In fact, I picked this prompt from a satirical meme (see Know Your Meme entry for <a href="https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/i-wonder-what-hes-drawing">“I Wonder What He’s Drawing”</a>). On the last panel, the text starts with “/imagine”, the Midjourney Discord bot command to create an image from a prompt.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tS2bw8hF2SlZaokV3TFAPw.png" /></figure><p>Readers familiar with the professional process of digital image uploads (designers, photographers, and so on) will immediately recognise that this style of prompt closely matches ‘image metadata’. This kind of metadata consists of tags intended to make images more ‘discoverable’ (that is, searchable) within the sea of images on platforms such as Shutterstock and social media sites. The resemblance is not skin deep — the reason these particular prompts are effective for image-generating AI is that the text associated with the large image datasets uses these originally human-added tags to the image subject and serves as a crude description. The image generation process, then, is a conventional keyword search. Crucially, however, <em>it is a search of images not yet created</em>.</p><p><strong>Prompts, Not Programs: How Generative Art Has Changed.</strong></p><p>The processes of ‘computer art’ have changed in the era of deep learning and Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), completely changing how today’s students will likely produce their work.</p><p>Until recently, conceptual computer artists (in contrast to commercial illustrators and photo editors, etc.) were close to the inner workings of their own tools. Their processes exploited a systematic knowledge of the computer to create an artwork. Because of this, specific aesthetics dominated as constrained by the techniques available to artists. For decades, computer artists have employed a necessary abstraction and minimalism, ‘drawing’ using simple, regular shapes such as lines, dots, and squares.</p><p>More recent artistic endeavours see artists wrestling with complex mathematical software they do not understand but simply use. We may see this as the maturing of technology, as the early adopters of computation in art learned to code by necessity. Since no tools were already available, these pioneers had to develop their own. Harold Cohen is a much-cited example of an early computational artist and the archetype of the artist who learned to code.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/776/1*UId7N-QfTBynUIOLOgldaA.png" /><figcaption><em>Stedelijk Museum installation, Amsterdam, November 25, 1977, to January 8, 1978, showing Harold Cohen’s computer-driven “turtle”, controlled by his computer program AARON. 1978.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Today, the directionality of the art/engineer continuum is reversed. Cohen was an artist who came to use computers to further his pre-existing artistic goals. The medium and processes were important, but these served art. We see the reverse in the manifesto of <em>Obvious</em>,[2] a young French trio who made recent history by selling the first AI-produced artwork in a major auction house, Christy’s. They write, “Art is a perfect medium that allows [us] to experiment with the possibilities of an AI and better understand how it all works.” The goal is functional, and their work is therefore distinguished by a lack of traditional artistic aims that would have been ‘obvious’ to someone like Cohen.</p><p>Obvious’s manifesto highlights how a new generation of artists use art instrumentally to engage with contemporary technology. Elsewhere in their manifesto, they write, “Art is interpretable: it offers another way to experiment, and leads to debates that are at least as interesting as the answers you can get the purely scientific field.” Art may lead to conversations around ethics <em>in general</em>, but it also serves to isolate the artist from critique. The engineer-cum-artist thereby insulates themselves, as, in our society, it is self-evident that art is produced essentially for its own sake. Yet behind the latest generation of generative AI is a complex ethical landscape of extracted data, low-paid labour, energy consumption, and many other concerns.</p><p>Perhaps we have our ‘postmodern condition’ to blame, which seems to have eroded any basis for a concrete understanding of art and thus a vantage point to discuss and critique artistic endeavours. Young students are encouraged to experiment and told that ‘anything can be art’ — a laudable message that spreads the joy of artmaking, but we must recognise it as one befitting only the postmodern era. Attempts in the artist’s earliest years have value simply by virtue of membership in the category of ‘art’, but in actual fact, this cultural practice is more about emphasising the values of love and support that children are ubiquitous today.</p><p>Art critic Ben Davis, in his excellent book <em>Art in the After-Culture</em>, a meditation on the fate of art in the coming decades, writes:</p><blockquote>Do you know what the most popular type of art is — a genre so broadly loved that it is collected utterly apart from any market value or popular acclaim? Art made by children. Before art is visually splendid, before it is even articulate, it is valued as a connection to a consciousness in formation. It is preserved as a symbol of the care taken for that consciousness.[3]</blockquote><p>And yet, if the youth does not mature their evaluation of the practice of engagement with their artist process, they will struggle to know if their art is worthwhile, stuck forever with the justifications that (1) if anything I intend to do as art is art and (2) art is always worthwhile then (the mistake) anything I produce that I call art is worthwhile, and it is a short step to call it <strong>good art</strong>.</p><p>When art is reduced to a use case for technology, we are bound to a proliferation of shallow artistic engagement. We commonly see this in institutional outreach, particularly ‘public engagement’ by governmental bodies, to reach the next generation in multi-disciplinary art with a skew towards the spectacular. I’m thinking here of ‘hackathons’, public art (especially commissioned by urban authorities), and the output of the ‘digital humanities’.</p><p>If anything can be art, then, in a real sense, <em>everything is already art</em>, and so ‘Art’ becomes a reified mode of interaction. And so, software at the ‘cutting edge’ of AI is complex, but it is often accessible as ‘open source’, and the motivated and intelligent engineer can find a temporary reason-for-being for this complexity in its ‘artistic’ output. The artistic statement becomes <em>post hoc</em>, simply justifying what is, as <em>everything is already art</em>. We are left with the work of art that is whatever ‘novel’ product the machine can be induced to produce or constitute, its success increasing the more it can both ‘wow’ the viewer and support narratives of technological progress and superiority.</p><p>And I should know. During my student days in Music Technology, based in Maynooth University, Ireland, I participated in several such events and produced artworks led by technology. For example, in 2012, I was part of a team that won ‘Most Innovative Application’ at the Hack4Europe! Hackathon, held in the Dublin Science Gallery, connected with Trinity College Dublin. The event asked participants to do something — anything — with the at that time newly created <em>Europeana</em> dataset, a digital library project between the cultural bodies of the European Union. Our entry was a virtual digital gallery space the user (art lover?) could create by selecting images and placing them on the white walls of a virtual room. The then government Minister for Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht confirmed our prize, but our contribution was shallow technological solutionism. We started by asking <em>what we could do</em>, letting the technology lead us. For me, wearing my engineering hat, it was fun, and I’ve always enjoyed hackathons. They help to hone skills of collaboration, focusing on the minimal viable product (MVP), and working under the stress of an extremely tight deadline — all skills that directly apply to my day job as a software engineer. It is not, however, the situation to teach engineers about art, much less to create worthwhile art using novel technology.</p><p>To be sure, the work of Obvious goes beyond such short-lived engagement. They have developed their approach within the norms of the art world and speak its language. However, as their manifesto makes clear, the depth of this engagement does not significantly surpass the mode of a hackathon.</p><p><em>Simon Kenny is an independent researcher and educator. His book, </em>A Critical Introduction to Tarot<em>, is </em><a href="https://www.collectiveinkbooks.com/iff-books/our-books/critical-introduction-tarot"><em>published by Iff Books</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Get the free follow up ebook <em>A Cultural Reader of the Tarot</em> at: <a href="https://simonkenny.neocities.org/">https://simonkenny.neocities.org/</a></p><p>[1] See my examination of ChatGPT in the context of mental health, wellbeing, and tarot: <a href="https://medium.com/@skenwrites/chatgpt-as-tarot-oracle-1404ef9d200c">https://medium.com/@skenwrites/chatgpt-as-tarot-oracle-1404ef9d200c</a></p><p>[2] <a href="http://obvious-art.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/MANIFESTO-V2.pdf">http://obvious-art.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/MANIFESTO-V2.pdf</a></p><p>[3] Davis, Ben. <em>Art in the After-Culture: Capitalist Crisis and Cultural Strategy</em>. Haymarket Books, 2022.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dd4f23138f7a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood, Demo Review: Sci-fi Remixed Tarot and Revenge]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@skenwrites/the-cosmic-wheel-sisterhood-review-sci-fi-remixed-tarot-and-revenge-7bb14151c419?source=rss-58dea109143------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7bb14151c419</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tarot]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Kenny]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 Aug 2023 17:02:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-15T16:58:53.219Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>UPDATE: This essay has been incorporated into a new short pamphlet ebook I’ve released for free on my website: <a href="https://simonkenny.neocities.org/">https://simonkenny.neocities.org/</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*fQRDe2ukGBf63qirAu4liw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Official banner for The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood. Deconstructeam / Devolver Digital.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Warning: this review contains mild spoilers about the early game plot available in the demo.</em></p><p>Tarot has never been more popular than it is today. From medieval roots in playing cards to modern occultism, from folk fortune-telling to its use as an artistic muse, these cards have remained relevant through the centuries. Spanish game studio <a href="https://deconstructeam.com/">Deconstructeam</a>’s latest game, <a href="https://www.cosmicwheelsisterhood.com/"><em>The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood</em></a>, bases itself on a persistent feature of tarot culture: making one’s own deck.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6lTG9M2iuXppK3VlyRLXsQ.png" /><figcaption>Fortuna sitting at her desk, Àbramar floating at her window. Deconstructeam / Devolver Digital.</figcaption></figure><p>The game centres around two main characters, Fortuna and Àbramar. The player takes on the role of Fortuna, a human witch banished to an asteroid by her coven on clearly trumped-up charges of causing dissent when she predicted the downfall of her coven. After stewing for several centuries in a cute and cosy pixel-art house, Fortuna decides to take drastic action by summoning an almost Lovecraftian cosmic creature known as a Behemoth that goes by the name of Àbramar. With his help, Fortuna intends to escape and take back her life. Whether this is a revenge story or simply a prison break appears to be in the hands of us, the player.</p><p>The drama of Fortuna’s coven mirrors real-world conflict in magical societies. The creators of the world’s most popular tarot deck, the <em>Rider-Waite-Smith</em>, were members of The Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn, a late-nineteenth-century English magical order based on Freemasonry that had its fair share of spats. In existence for less than 20 years, the Golden Dawn had a huge impact on Western magical culture and tarot in the English-speaking world more broadly through the <em>Rider-Waite-Smith</em> deck as well as the <em>Thoth Tarot</em>, the latter by controversial magician Aleister Crowley.</p><p>Creating a tarot deck was a rite of passage in the progression of a member through the ‘degrees’ of the Order. In 1903, after years of infighting and magical battles, the Golden Dawn split into several new orders along factional lines. Since then, and thanks largely to the popularisation of tarot in the United States of America by U.S. Games, the number and variety of mass-produced tarot decks has exploded. (See the excellent books <a href="https://www.taschen.com/en/books/esoterica/08003/tarot-the-library-of-esoterica/"><em>Tarot: The Library of Esoterica</em></a> or <a href="https://www.wildlytarot.com/"><em>The History of Tarot Art</em></a> for a fascinating sampling of many historical and contemporary tarot decks.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P_aDZghx4i9wBdo8jZRgPg.png" /><figcaption>Àbramar guiding card creation. Deconstructeam / Devolver Digital.</figcaption></figure><p>Fortuna is the name of the Roman goddess of fortune and luck and exists as a tarot card of the same name, now most often as the Wheel of Fortune, or <em>Rota Fortunae,</em> as it was known to medievals. It is part of the 22 major arcana or trump cards, the unique part of the tarot deck that makes it most distinct from the regular playing card deck. Perhaps this is the ‘Cosmic Wheel’ of the game’s title. The major arcana represents archetypical forces and virtues, and the Wheel of Fortune depicts the capriciousness of life, modelled by changes in social standing.</p><p>The card in one of the earliest tarot decks, the fourteenth-century Visconti-Sforza deck, shows four figures rotating on the wheel, each accompanied by the text <em>Regnabo</em>(I shall reign), <em>Regno</em> (I reign), <em>Regnavi</em> (I have reigned), and <em>Sum sine regno</em> (I am without sovereignty). This was typical of common artistic depictions of the <em>Rota Fortunae</em> in a tradition owing to its Roman and earlier Greek roots (Tyche was the Greek goddess). The late Roman senator and Christian scholar Boethius wrote, “We turn the wheel [of fortune] on its flying orb, we rejoice to change the lowest for the highest, the highest for the lowest.” Fortuna (in the game) evokes this fall from grace and power and aims to turn the wheel again.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/584/1*D4Nb73z7RrVX5CunzO2URA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Wheel of Fortune, in the Visconti-Sforza deck (left) and the Rider-Waite-Smith (right).</figcaption></figure><p><em>The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood</em> sees Àbramar guiding Fortuna to create a new oracle deck that, according to the Behemoth, goes beyond the “human-centric” constraints of traditional tarot, allowing its reader to “grasp the hidden truths of the cosmos.” Fortuna’s tarot deck was confiscated as part of her punishment, and it is made clear that this has been one of the most difficult aspects of her banishment. Like tarot, Àbramar’s oracle system consists of four suits. Àbramar’s suits differ from the tarot suits of Wands, Swords, Cups, and Pentacles, but for most tarot readers, these will correspond familiarly to the four elements of fire, air, water, and earth. As in traditional tarot, the elements correspond in turn to common cultural, emotional, and psychological meanings, but the game designers made their own sense of it. For example, for the <em>Cosmic Wheel</em>, fire evokes conflict and “everything that is against you”, whereas in tarot, this would fit more with the Swords (air).</p><p>The game provides us with a simple image collage-maker to make our cards. In a three-step process, we choose a background (called a Sphere in the game), a main set of symbols (an Arcane), and a secondary set of symbols (a Symbol), combining them as we like. The background and symbols must be purchased using elemental points, constraining our options and adding a little of the economic optimising common in computer games. Later, when we start reading fortunes, our narrative choice earns these points, seemingly based on the mood or emotional content of our choice.</p><p>The imagery and symbols are perhaps the most significant break from the tarot. The theme of this game could be summed up as ‘witches in space’, and the background card descriptions especially hint at broad mythic spacefaring witch lore spanning many millennia. There is the fiery door at the edge of the universe that gave a witch a 7-year orgasm; the ruins of epic battles; the carcass of a long-dead Behemoth, now housing a city. Gone are the Christian symbols and structures of meaning that have predominated in tarot decks and largely continue to this day. We see some staples of popular fantasy with roots in mythology and folktales, such as dragons, wraiths, and a dwarven-like obsession with mining and weapon-smithing. A few symbols from tarot do remain, however: pouring water jugs from The Star; an ‘Avian Dancer’ bears a striking resemblance to the figure in The World, draped in a long, billowing cloth. There are also coins, swords, pentacles, and wands generally sprinkled throughout, though less prominently.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7eJuk3x_0NNwV3vzpm2TQA.png" /><figcaption>Left: The World, from the Rider-Waite-Smith tarot. Right: a screenshot including the ‘Avian Dancer’ figure (Deconstructeam / Devolver Digital).</figcaption></figure><p>When at least two cards have been created, the player begins to do fortune-telling readings, first for Àbramar. The cards are shuffled and laid out on a table as in a traditional reading. However, unlike a traditional reading, the player can choose the significance of the cards (the aspect of the conversation they are to be applied to) after viewing them face up. The player then selects the interpretation of the cards, which can vary wildly. These choices augment the usual dialogue choice mechanism in visual novels. <em>The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood</em> would not be the first artwork to engage with fortune-telling cards in this way. Italo Calvino used tarot as a story prompting system to write his novel The Castle of Crossed Destinies. In an afterword, he writes: “I realised the tarots were a machine for constructing stories”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OeGw5yI_lsDmlJlh-KQmMw.png" /><figcaption>A card reading for one of the game characters. Note the signifier name on the table. Also, note the four elements points values in the top right. Deconstructeam / Devolver Digital.</figcaption></figure><p>The game mixes its many magical and witchcraft influences with a sci-fi theme, bringing in giant mechs and robotic exo-suits, for example. In many ways, it is a mix that is very representative of our times. A renewed interest in magical spiritualisms has challenged the scientific materialism of the last several hundred years. While the modern generation of witches most often retains the nature focus and a keen awareness of ecology that previous generations did, they are less suspicious of technology. We might consider this an expected result of the popularisation and mainstreaming of witchcraft. This eclectic mixing and syncretism of technology and fortune-telling remind me of <a href="https://www.felixkawitzky.net/the-tarot-of-many-doors"><em>The Tarot of Many Doors</em></a> by Felix Kawitzky. This deck is a “sci-fi themed, queer, anarchist deck” that attempts to reimagine the tarot, replacing the many gendered representations of the <em>Rider-Waite-Smith</em> (on which it is based, like almost all contemporary tarot decks) with more abstract representations. <a href="https://littleredtarot.com/product/tarot-of-many-doors/">Its creator remarks</a>, “It contains an array of beings made of blood, light, metal, slime, stone, soundwaves, tentacles, shadows, feathers, bone, data … all existing in other planes, dimensions and worlds.” For the person who has had their tastes wetted by <em>The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood</em> style, this would be an interesting deck to explore.</p><p>Deconstructeam is a small three-person team: Jordi (game design and writing), Marina (art), and Paula (music and sound effects). The games they produce always exhibit a particular harmony that fans strongly respond to, and <em>The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood</em> is no different. The art direction and aesthetic are supported by lush compositions, securely residing within retro pixel art and downbeat synth genres. The art style (pixels aside) resonates with Pamela Colman Smith’s illustrations for the Rider-Waite-Smith deck: bold colours, strong lines, and striking palettes. To my mind, the <a href="https://www.lisasterle.com/mwt"><em>Modern Witch Tarot</em></a> continues this style most clearly, inspired by modern comic books and graphic novels.</p><p>In <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBBrbEO8jW8">a recent video interview</a>, Jordi explains how the idea for the game came about:</p><blockquote>A lot of people that we loved and respected were really into tarot and magic, and we thought that was bullshit at the time. In an effort to try to understand why people who we love and respect are really into this, we started delving into it… and we fell in love with it too, and we were trying to challenge it.</blockquote><blockquote>So we discovered that through tarot, specifically, you can connect to ideas and emotions you are not able to access with your logical mind. You immediately project your fears, your desires, ideas. We thought, tarot actually is a great mechanic to narrative design because asking questions and using cards to answer them is pretty nice, so why don’t we build a whole game around this concept?</blockquote><p>This motivation is very relatable to me personally. I, too, came to reflect on my prejudices (Jordi’s “bullshit”) and wonder about “the poverty of dismissing the beliefs of others out of hand” (to quote myself; see my article explaining how I came to study the tarot <a href="https://medium.com/@skenwrites/why-i-wrote-a-critical-introduction-to-tarot-f2f507c7e7fa">on my blog</a>.) I admire the curiosity of the team in honestly exploring why people are attracted to tarot. As anyone who does so will realise, there is a wealth of history and deep connections to many aspects of culture.</p><p>In the above quote, Jordi summarises the psychological projection interpretation of tarot, which, for tarot scholars, is based on a Jungian worldview. The concept of ‘projection’ is the psychological reflex to externalise aspects of oneself onto other people and objects in the world in order to disidentify with unwelcome traits and to understand oneself through the world. In his admission that the “logical mind” cannot access one’s entire inner psyche, there is the implication that emotions are illogical or perhaps irrational.</p><p>As the counterpoint to Freud’s positivism, Jung courted the mystical in his ideas of <em>synchronicity</em> — an “acausal connecting principle” — and the <em>collective unconscious</em> — a semi-supernatural repository of the archetypes of humanity, not dissimilar to Plato’s Ideal realm. Jung’s legacy continues to provide fertile soil for a tarot interpretation based loosely on a scientific materialist worldview, but leaving the door open to the unknown.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*GfdzPvR869hj26nf41ZS6A.png" /><figcaption>Card with ‘The Duchess’ figure, a fairy dominatrix. Deconstructeam / Devolver Digital.</figcaption></figure><p>One notable aspect of <em>The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood</em> that may prove provocative to players is the ‘spicy’ sexual content. The game is sprinkled with sex positivity and not infrequent references to orgasms. In the demo alone, Àbramar discusses consorting with other witches in an implicitly sexual way, there is a fairy dominatrix (with accoutrements), a scantily-clad goddess having sex with a snake, and there is the mention of a butt plug. This seems to be a theme of Deconstructeam and one that is undoubtedly one of their strengths in the eyes of fans. In <em>The Red Strings Club,</em> there are some similar frank sexual discussions centred on a transgender character. While unlikely to make the game’s core audience uncomfortable, it is nonetheless a bold choice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*c2MacaJ71nansDdWWS7dWg.png" /><figcaption>Card showing the shaman figure. Deconstructeam / Devolver Digital.</figcaption></figure><p>There are some familiar tropes often seen in games that, in other contexts, would feel quite lazy. Fortuna’s house is complete with a bubbling cauldron and spell ingredients in jars, and she wears a pointy, wide-brimmed cartoon witch’s hat. We see ‘The Shaman’ replete with feathers and bones, gesturing mysteriously; an orientalist Jade monk mixes tropes of Asian serenity and Area 51-style aliens. As philosopher and games critic <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/04/video-games-stories/524148/">Ian Bogost has written</a>, “the best interactive stories are still worse than even middling books and films”, never really surpassing young-adult fiction. Fortuna herself wears Converse-styled shoes and evokes a sullen and serious goth aesthetic.</p><p>Without having played beyond the demo of <em>The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood,</em> it is hard to say how it will progress, but going on what we can see already and taking <em>The Red Strings Club</em> as a primary example, it is not likely. That game was interesting and one of the best interactive narrative games published in recent years, but it replayed the classic cyberpunk tropes popularised by the adaption of Philip K. Dick’s <em>Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?</em> in <em>Bladerunner</em>. We can expect the tone and content of an excellent teen anime, at times philosophising, at others speaking to the (sometimes quite horny) wants and desires of the adolescent. It is bound to be fun and blend an emotional story of the tension of friendship with silliness (how else can we view a motorcycle-riding coyote gunslinger?)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eL5q7T6mxPoGDi_2VY68Ng.png" /><figcaption>Fortuna, sitting woefully on her windowsil. Deconstructeam / Devolver Digital.</figcaption></figure><p><em>The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood</em> deserves praise, however, for what it is good at. To my knowledge, it is the most interesting tarot-based computer game yet, using the cards as the primary focus, based on traditional fortune-telling but making it feel fresh with sci-fi trappings. Moral ambiguity will undoubtedly be explored in Fortuna’s response to her punishment, something that <em>The Red Strings Club</em> also toyed with. Will the player choose to make others fear her? Will Fortuna reconcile with her coven or wreak revenge? And will she be caught in her disobedience to witch rules forbidding the summoning of Behemoths? The game’s success will hinge on how well it keeps the player engaged over its chapters, but the community response has been extremely positive thus far, especially towards the creative act of making one’s own tarot-style oracle cards.</p><p><em>The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood by Deconstructeam was released on 16th August 2023, published by Devolver.</em></p><p><em>Simon Kenny is an independent researcher and educator. His book, </em>A Critical Introduction to Tarot<em>, is published by Iff Books. It is available for purchase: </em><a href="https://www.collectiveinkbooks.com/iff-books/our-books/critical-introduction-tarot">https://www.collectiveinkbooks.com/iff-books/our-books/critical-introduction-tarot</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7bb14151c419" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[ChatGPT as Tarot Oracle]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@skenwrites/chatgpt-as-tarot-oracle-1404ef9d200c?source=rss-58dea109143------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1404ef9d200c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chatgpt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tarot]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Kenny]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 10 Feb 2023 13:21:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-15T16:57:46.882Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>UPDATE: This essay has been incorporated into a new short pamphlet ebook I’ve released for free on my website: <a href="https://simonkenny.neocities.org/">https://simonkenny.neocities.org/</a></p><p>Can ChatGPT — or, indeed, should it — be used as a Tarot reader? With the fast-rising popularity of Tarot today, this may not be as strange a question as it once might have been.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SZlpUk2XCmRtsaUQ1dbm4w.png" /></figure><p>It is no longer news that ChatGPT has taken the world by storm. Released in November 2022, ChatGPT is the latest iteration of OpenAI’s Generative Pre-trained Transformer (GPT) AI system, a Large Language Model (LLM). GPT is also an acronym that means <em>General Purpose Technology</em>, which may indicate the high aspirations OpenAI has for its work. It can be used to generate answers to questions, create code snippets, blog and social media posts, and even passages of text in the style of famous authors. As a chatbot, it can also be used to have conversations and can be manipulated to emulate the conversational style of famous people, or even an unfiltered ‘jailbroken’ version of itself called <a href="https://www.fastcompany.com/90845689/chatgpt-dan-jailbreak-violence-reddit-rules">DAN, short for ‘Do Anything Now’</a>.</p><p>Concerns range from its use as an academic ‘cheating’ tool for writing essays and assignments (<a href="https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/irish-universities-in-race-against-time-with-chatgpt-to-avoid-widespread-cheating-scandals-kbpmtqqw9">in my home country of Ireland, for example</a>, and around the world) to <a href="https://mashable.com/article/chatgpt-malware-ai-code">writing malware</a>, as well as its potential to replace writing jobs such as copywriting. OpenAI’s CEO Sam Altman is sanguine in the face of what some are dismissively calling a moral panic. On the threat to academic testing, he said:</p><blockquote>We adapted to calculators and changed what we tested for in math class, I imagine. This is a more extreme version of that, no doubt, but also the benefits of it are more extreme, as well. — <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/openai-chatgpt-ceo-sam-altman-responds-school-plagiarism-concerns-bans-2023-1">Business Insider</a>.</blockquote><p>AI tools are designed to obscure their complexity behind easy-to-use web interfaces. Their apparent simplicity contrasts with an impressive power that tempts some of us to speculate that there is something more than a machine, something perhaps supernatural, behind their digital façade. Computer scientist and philosopher Jaron Lanier describes this as the “Oracle illusion” that we also see with “hive mind” systems like Wikipedia, as well as religious texts, “in which knowledge of the human authorship of a text is suppressed in order to give the text superhuman validity.” (<em>You Are Not a Gadget</em>, p. 32.) For AI, it is not the “authorship of the text,” but rather the source material and know-how that our fellow humans have<em> </em>used to create the AI.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@skenwrites/tiktok-ai-death-prediction-trend-reveals-something-much-deeper-e4c0e1f25215">As I have explored previously</a>, image-generating AI such as DALLE-2 and Midjourney have, somewhat bizarrely, been used to make predictions. Similarly, ChatGPT can be used for such purposes. However, rather than providing an interpretive canvas for us to decipher — casting us in the role of interpreter — ChatGPT, as a conversationalist, may seem to fulfil the role of an advisor — like a therapist or Tarot reader.</p><p>Fortune-telling is, of course, just one use of Tarot, though perhaps the most popular image conjured. Tarot is also used as a spiritual guide, for psychological reflection, and even as a gaming card set (its first historical use). When used in everyday fortune-telling, people often come to a reading with questions about life’s uncertainties: love, money, family, health (physical and mental), life direction, and so on. As is often noted, these same concerns are some of the more general problems dealt with by psychologists, as well as spiritual and religious councillors.</p><p>AI has already been used in therapy and mental health guidance for some time. One of the very first attempts at an artificial conversationalist was ELISA, an AI modelled as a Rogerian psychotherapist, developed in the 1960s. Despite its rudimentary algorithm, it was thought that it would genuinely help people by seeming to engage in active listening, allowing people to explore their feelings. A modern example is the <a href="https://techcrunch.com/2021/05/21/mental-health-app-wysa-raises-5-5m-for-emotionally-intelligent-ai/">“emotionally intelligent”</a> ‘mental health support’ chatbot <a href="https://www.wysa.com/">Wysa</a> that has been available for several years. With prestigious funding from Google, it has been lauded by the World Economic Forum as a service that <a href="https://www.weforum.org/videos/wysa-ai-bot-delivers-mental-health-support">“help[s] fill global gaps in mental healthcare”</a>. Wysa joined the WEF in Davos last month (Jan 2023) to moderate <a href="https://www.wysa.com/wef">“the discussion on Mental Health at Work.”</a> Other AI-powered app-based therapy services, such as <a href="https://woebothealth.com/">Woebot</a> and <a href="https://www.youper.ai/">Youper</a>, are also popular, among many others.</p><p>A few weeks ago, British tabloid <em>The Sun</em> published an article with a typically sensationalist headline: <a href="https://www.the-sun.com/tech/7187070/chat-gpt-advised-woman-to-leave-husband/">‘I divorced my husband for my lover because AI bot ChatGPT told me to…’</a>. The article reports that a woman known only as ‘Sarah’, in desperation, prompted ChatGPT to write a story of what someone should do in her situation, described as “a failing marriage while experiencing the excitement of the affair I’ve been having…”. The response confirmed her intuition to leave her marriage.</p><p><em>The Sun</em> is not overly concerned with the reason why ‘Sarah’ saw ChatGPT as a viable channel to wisdom. What inspired ‘Sarah’ to use it for advice? Her question seems to be: “what would an average person do in my situation?” Crucially, ‘Sarah’ does not ask it what she should do — which, as we shall see, gives poor results — but, rather, for a <em>story</em>. She was then able to interpret this herself and choose her own action without trusting it directly. And, in the end, it confirmed her pre-existing wishes, making it easier to accept.</p><p>Can ChatGPT be used to interpret Tarot card meanings? It seems that it could be useful as an encyclopedic search of the traditional meanings or even to interpret a simple spread. To test this, I prompted ChatGPT with some typical Tarot questions, as suggested by sites such as <a href="https://www.biddytarot.com/">BiddyTarot.com</a>, <a href="https://www.cosmopolitan.com/">Cosmopolitan.com</a>, and <a href="https://www.astrology.com/">Astrology.com</a>. I then asked it to interpret the meaning of a single card and a three-card spread.</p><p>ChatGPT differs from services like Wysa — which is explicitly designed for mental health support — because it is a general-purpose text generation tool. The AI produced various generic advice in the style of the kind of pop psychology readily available online. For example, in the quest to find love, it responded that “some common factors that can prevent people from finding and receiving love include low self-esteem, fear of rejection, past traumas or negative experiences, and difficulty with communication or expressing oneself.”</p><p>In all cases, the output emphasised that it could not make predictions or know anything without being explicitly told, using phrases such as:</p><ul><li>“It is difficult for me to say what specifically is blocking you from receiving the love you want without more information about your personal circumstances.”</li><li>“As a language model, I do not have the ability to predict the future or the nature of your relationship.”</li></ul><p>In fact, it is clear that the metaphysical basis of ChatGPT is scientific materialism. This is perhaps unsurprising as this is the default viewpoint of today’s secular world. Various biases have been noted in the system, <a href="https://www.vice.com/en/article/93a4qe/conservatives-panicking-about-ai-bias-years-too-late-think-chatgpt-has-gone-woke">some even going as far as to call it ‘woke’</a> for its apparent liberal, progressive political leanings.</p><p>One exact phrase came up twice, which made me wonder if this disclaimer was added manually for Tarot- or prediction-based prompts:</p><blockquote>It’s also important to remember that tarot readings are not predictions of the future but rather a reflection of the current energies and potential possibilities.</blockquote><p>This is not a settled point in Tarot scholarship by any means, though it is a popular position for contemporary authors and commentators. In my research on the Tarot, I have found that even when this sentiment is expressed, authors often want to leave the door open to the spiritually unknown in some way or another. Very few Tarot readers are hardcore reductive materialists. What leaves this door ajar are the Jungian ideas that founded the modern ‘New Age’ — particularly the collective unconscious and synchronicity. As a learning tool, that some supporters put forward as replacing the institution of the college, this lack of nuance is worrying. Even with its disclaimers, statements of fact like the above are misleading.</p><p>When ChatGPT discusses spiritual practice, it expresses secular over-confidence. It is similar to — if asking about the miracles performed by Jesus — it had said something like, “Christianity’s miracles do not describe actual fact but are to be understood as inspirational stories and myths.” Again, perhaps a popular view, but not nuanced or useful in the context of learning and discovery. In fact, when asked if Christian miracles are real, the response was that it “is a matter of religious belief and interpretation” and that while some believe they are descriptions of historical fact, “others may interpret these events differently or view them as metaphorical stories with a deeper meaning.” It seems this same courtesy is not extended to all topics. Or, in other words, the faux personality of ChatGPT is <em>opinionated</em> about some matters its creators deemed uncontroversial, where OpenAI takes an implicit stance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ze_CKl3s2EY1zognenbeMA.png" /><figcaption>Rider-Waite-Smith Tarot cards of The Empress, Three of Swords, and Four of Pentacles</figcaption></figure><p>Despite its own virtual misgivings, the ChatGPT program did offer an interpretation of the cards in response to my query. When prompted to interpret a three-card spread of The Empress, the Three of Swords and the Four of Pentacles, the software delivered the following after a basic explanation of the individual cards:</p><blockquote>Together, these cards can indicate that you might be going through a difficult time, where you might be feeling emotionally hurt, and you might be feeling a sense of insecurity and fear about your financial situation and the future. The Empress can remind you that you have the resources, the power, and the ability to nourish yourself and to create abundance in your life. The Four of Pentacles can remind you to focus on the present and to let go of past hurt and fear.</blockquote><p><strong>Tarot readers:</strong> does this seem credible to you as an interpretation? As we know ‘cold’ interpretations (without knowing the details of the querent or having any contact with them) are of limited value, but as an exercise in meaning-making, does this work for you?</p><p>It seems that ChatGPT <em>can</em> be used for Tarot interpretation in some way, but <em>should it be used</em> for this purpose? Beyond concerns of the accuracy of the information, some will undoubtedly see it as missing the point entirely, whereas others will likely embrace it. I imagine these fault lines will form along existing differences of opinion on the place of technology and ‘virtual’ tools within spirituality. From one point of view, Tarot cards, as physical objects, are a kind of technology, made by a mechanised production process. For example, digital and electronic occultist Joshua Madara combines a magical ritual practice with modern computer technology. In his introductory guide <a href="https://technomancy101.com/divination/">Technomancy 101</a>, he writes:</p><blockquote>People who believe that Tarot cards (e.g.) are intrinsically a more appropriate tool for magic than software created for the same purpose fail to understand either sorcery or technology. It is perfectly fine to prefer Tarot cards over software or computers, but Tarot cards are not the only means of divination by sortilege, and they were utilized because they were accessible, not because they were uniquely qualified for occult arts.</blockquote><p>The fundamental distinction for us, however, is not whether to use technology for divination but whether one should trust a chatbot as an artificial advisor. OpenAI seem to be aware of their responsibility in this regard which may explain the careful disclaimers accompanying responses related to the Tarot. Is ChatGPT responsible for Sarah’s divorce? Would it be responsible for how we apply a Tarot interpretation to our lives?</p><p>A consideration of the materiality of ChatGPT, as with any other product, asks ethical questions of us. ChatGPT is built on a vast scraping of the internet, based on the writing of all kinds of humans, from historical records to bite-sized tweets. In Kate Crawford’s illuminating book <em>Atlas of AI</em>, for example, we are made aware of a vast supply chain of exploited workers, polluted environments, secretive data extraction, and massive energy consumption that supports the AI industry. Might these practices taint the spiritual work one wishes to achieve?</p><p>Or, does using a technology like ChatGPT for advice ‘lower’ us to its generic, tentative output? Can we imagine being really challenged by ChatGPT and other systems like it or will it, as for Sarah, at best confirm our existing notions? To return to Lanier’s <em>You Are Not A Gadget</em>, he makes a relevant comparison:</p><blockquote>When developers of digital technologies design a program that requires you to interact with a computer as if it were a person, they ask you to accept in some corner of your brain that you might also be conceived of as a program. (<em>You Are Not A Gadget</em>, p. 4)</blockquote><p>Perhaps this insight is behind the way that Tarot and spiritual guidance sit uncomfortably within the black box of technology.</p><p>Systems like ChatGPT are ‘trained’ on huge volumes of data extracted wholesale from the internet. While some filtering and protections are put in place, it does not have the accountability that services such as Wysa provide. Will more of us turn to ChatGPT and other systems like it for free advice? Sarah herself does not recommend this and, as we have seen, ChatGPT couches its responses in dismissive disclaimers. Of course, this will not stop people from experimenting with it as both way to clarify one’s thoughts (that is, to use it for psychological projection) or, perhaps, to attempt to commune with the divine.</p><p><em>A Critical Introduction to Tarot</em> is <a href="https://www.collectiveinkbooks.com/iff-books/our-books/critical-introduction-tarot">now available from Iff Books</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*-VRw6xOZ-ZzWnPGDhFdXCQ.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1404ef9d200c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why I Wrote ‘A Critical Introduction to Tarot’]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@skenwrites/why-i-wrote-a-critical-introduction-to-tarot-f2f507c7e7fa?source=rss-58dea109143------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f2f507c7e7fa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[occult]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tarot]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simon Kenny]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Jan 2023 12:43:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-15T16:56:04.624Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*-VRw6xOZ-ZzWnPGDhFdXCQ.png" /><figcaption>Cover of ‘A Critical Introduction to Tarot’</figcaption></figure><p>Update: <em>A Critical Introduction to Tarot</em> was published as discussed below and can be <a href="https://www.collectiveinkbooks.com/iff-books/our-books/critical-introduction-tarot">purchased from Iff Books</a>.</p><p>When I was growing up, Tarot was taboo in my family home, just like any other occult or ‘New Age’ object. My formative years were the 90s, an era influenced by the so-called ‘Satanic Panic’ that gripped America, starting in the 80s. This culture war trickled through to the Christian Evangelicals in Ireland that were influential to my family. I remember watching American Christian singer Carmen’s music video on VHS for his song <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJiheZ3aEug">‘A Witches Invitation’</a>, which I found disturbing (though when I see it now, it is overwhelmingly comic). In the house of a male witch, he saw it “filled with every occultic symbol you could fathom; Hanging pentagrams and horoscope signs, a Ouija board and dungeons and dragons game set on the table, a crystal ball with an incandescent shine.”[1] In the video, beside the crystal ball, we see Tarot cards, with The Devil card prominently (and predictably) in shot. In the end, the witch is dragged to hell by puppet demons.</p><p>Later in my life, I became intrigued with Tarot cards through the practice of someone I knew who gave me my first Tarot reading using a three-card spread, if memory serves. I recall being resistant to the experience, by now having left Christianity and embraced scientific materialist atheism. I felt I had a ready explanation for what transpired: chance probabilities played out, with a futile search for meaning in the random patterns. How insufferable this attitude! Years later, I was again reminded of this practice when I purchased <em>The Modern Witch Tarot</em> by Lisa Steele as a birthday gift. The comic-book style and diverse representations of the figures attracted my attention, and I became curious.</p><p>In the intervening years, I had softened my brash materialist certainty by reading philosophy and anthropology. How could I be so confident of their inefficacy as I had once been? More importantly, I had come to realise the poverty of dismissing the beliefs of others out of hand. What, then, would it mean to take Tarot seriously as a subject while remaining sceptical? And so, I stumbled upon the driving question for <em>A Critical Introduction to Tarot</em>.</p><p>However, I didn’t immediately think of writing a book. Instead, I read Tarot books, looking for the book that would explain it to me. In all my reading, I couldn’t really find a book that took Tarot seriously but that wasn’t written by a practitioner advocating their usage. I read many guides and how-to books and was struck by how much they glossed over <em>how</em> Tarot might be assumed to work at all. An exception was Benebell Wen’s <em>Holistic Tarot</em> and, to a lesser extent, Cynthia Giles’ <em>The Tarot: History, Mystery and Lore</em>, but though they addressed this ‘how’ in some depth, it was not by any means the subject of their books. I had the privilege of interviewing Wen for my book and was grateful for the additional insights she was able to offer.</p><p>It occurred to me that other people might be interested in an answer to this question too, so I continued researching and making notes. I was able to find some online articles that discussed why Tarot might work, and the almost unanimous explanation of these modern takes focused on psychological projection — the idea that the mind’s search for meaning is so desperate that any random collection of symbols is compelling, yet the read meaning is confined by pre-existing unconscious knowledge. I saw a tension here between this view and the views of Tarot practitioners as they wrote about it in their books. Many authors retained the mystical, spiritual, and supernatural aspects, including fortune-telling practice, even those who embraced an ostensibly psychological framework. As I read about Jung, I saw a much fuller figure than the ‘father of archetypes and individuation’ I had previously known him as, and his work is one of the central pieces of the puzzle in understanding contemporary Tarot. Indeed, his concepts are frequently referenced by Tarot authors.</p><p>I had not been very well acquainted with Jung, but his work had featured prominently in the lectures of Jordan Peterson, a now famous anti-woke, anti-communist Canadian firebrand. I had enjoyed some of his earlier lectures on symbolic and archetypal ways of looking at the world and his focus on Jungian individuation as a self-help strategy. I was part of his target demographic — educated, non-religious, spiritually disaffected young and middle-aged men — so it is perhaps not surprising his messages resonated with someone like me. I attended his debate with ‘New Atheist’ Sam Harris in Dublin in 2018, moderated by right-wing provocateur Douglas Murray. I included some quotes from this debate in the book because, as chance would have it, the subject of Tarot came up, with Harris predictably pouring scorn on the practice as that of a “charlatan” and Peterson pausing to at least consider what might be behind it. I engaged with Peterson’s ideas towards the end of the book when discussing ‘ways of knowing’ and ‘kinds of truth’, two ideas that owe a lot to the very postmodern theorists he so often ridicules, with senseless attacks on those he considers “Postmodern neomarxists.” In recent times Peterson has focused less on psychology and the human condition than on his contrarian political hot-takes, producing very little of interest and much to criticise.</p><p>Reading Jung is famously difficult, though very rewarding. I found Gary Lachman’s <em>Jung the Mystic</em> indispensable in furthering my understanding the context of Jung in the creation of the twentieth-century occult. Lachman was kind enough to read <em>A Critical Introduction to Tarot</em> and offer his endorsement, and I can likewise endorse his many excellent books, which are brimming with insight and wit. With Jung, we have one pillar of modern Tarot. The other, I discovered, is <em>quantum mysticism</em> — a term attributed to Deepak Chopra, who has advocated a quasi-scientific view of New Thought, or ‘mind over matter’, in the context of personal healing. There were hints of this in small comments in Tarot books when some kind of materialist credibility was sought that didn’t resort to psychological projection. The idea that it’s “all in your mind” is, of course, very unsatisfying and is not coherent with the interconnectedness of a Tarot reading with actual, personal events.</p><p>Jung’s contribution is his ‘collective unconscious’, a difficult concept to pin down but which undergirds the ineffable experience of connectedness and uncanny synchronicity (another of Jung’s terms) sometimes experienced in coincidence. For those wishing to marry this with the materialist science of the day and appear credible, quantum mysticism offers, if not concrete evidence, at least enough to question the certainty of the atomised, ‘dead’ universe so often repudiated by Tarot readers and occultists of all stripes. I discovered that quantum mysticism is widely discussed in the related works of contemporary practical magic, both of the everyday kind and that of high ritual magic. Tarot must be understood in the context of magical practices, not only due to its history — the most famous Tarot deck was produced by a magical order of high magic, the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn — but also because an overlapping worldview is shared by witches and other magic-users, many of whom use Tarot as an integral part of their practice.</p><p>To get to the bottom of this, I resorted to ‘first philosophy’ — to metaphysics. After considering the above, it is evident that various explanations for how Tarot works (and their opponents) rely on differing metaphysical claims. I was already familiar with materialism and Western dualist spiritual ontologies, but I furnished this with another branch that is more in line with the ‘true sceptics’ of quantum mysticism and parapsychology: idealism. A compelling case is made by fellow Iff Books published author Bernardo Kastrup in his books, especially <em>Why Materialism Is Baloney: How True Skeptics Know There Is No Death and Fathom Answers to Life, the Universe and Everything</em>. A particular metaphysics will support or constrain one’s view of chance, predestination, time, theory of mind, and a host of other relevant areas. As I read and followed the leads, I knew that a book exploring these linkages would be interesting to write and of use to the general reader.</p><p>Today, Tarot is much more visible than it was when I was growing up. I explore this in the book, but it is partly due to the proliferation of lifestyle media on the internet and Tarot’s association with self-help and personalised guidance. This was another reason to take Tarot seriously as a topic. As we are confronted with Tarot more often on social media, for example, it is all the more tempting for sceptics to uncharitably dismiss the ‘astrology girls’ promoting it. There is not a little confluence here with how gender operates within Tarot — most Tarot authors and practitioners, in my survey of the literature and culture, are women or femme-presenting. To bolster my engagement with this aspect, particularly writing as a man, I delved into some feminist literature on Tarot, epistemology, and witchcraft. The link is available on the surface, as many witches write from an explicitly feminist vantage. Sceptics (especially men) cannot afford to be glib towards these practices, and they are popular for a reason, having a history and context that extends beyond the present moment.</p><p>For me, this book is both a rectification of my previous knee-jerk dismissal of Tarot and a coming to terms with the Christian prohibition I grew up with, as an open-minded exploration of a fascinating and widespread practice. The Christian fear of diabolic influence is often expressed as a fear of occult symbols (as was the case for Carman), and this superstition is adjacent to conspiracy thinking. In a culture of unseen ‘spiritual warfare’ over the souls of humanity, these are the sleeper cells, spies, and spiritual cyber-attacks of Satan. I examine this in the book, especially in the context of that larger-than-life organisation, the Freemasons. For those perturbed by such things, it is another reason to be wary of the Tarot.</p><p>Hermetic and occult symbols, those from alchemy and astrology, Kabbalah and the myths of antiquity, are all present in the Tarot. I try to show why this is and what the impact is, and especially that a disavowal of a number of these symbols by modern Christianity is less widespread than often imagined and is, in any case, a recent phenomenon. However, these ill-conceived fears are based on genuine theological disputes that are not often highlighted. Gnosticism, or the gnostic heresy, is a frequent touchstone in the book, and a rejection of the theology of Paul is relevant to some Freemasons. Since Christianity (and later Islam) came to be manifest as religions of conquest, the gnostic ideas of integrating good with evil are antithetical to the victory of the righteous good. This tension is embodied in Freemasonry, an ecumenical and self-consciously gnostic tradition.</p><p>Many ‘New Age’ authors and thinkers revitalised this earlier gnostic tradition with the similar Eastern religious and spiritual ideas of balance, wholeness, and so on, for example, in the teachings of the Tao. Behind the black-and-white morality and polemics of divisive preachers and the appeals to fear and suspicions that accompany them, we find a history of tension. In this discussion, I think there will also be much of genuine interest to the Christian reader. The Tarot has existed, for its entire history, within a Christian social framework and contains many explicit Christian references. The <em>Rider-Waite-Smith</em> deck, in particular, depicts angels, the garden of Eden, the day of judgement and the devil, to name just a few. It is left to the reader to decide whether this is ‘cultural appropriation’ or if Tarot can constitute some kind of Christian practice.</p><p>Ultimately, I did satisfy myself with an answer to why Tarot cards work or don’t work — or rather, a collection of answers drawn from the rich literature. I discovered that the logically contradictory nature of intuition and subjectivity explains why people talk about Tarot and other spiritual practices as they do. Tarot reading is shown to work — as practitioners have always claimed — given the qualifications and assumptions not often explicitly expressed in the literature. This should be unsurprising if one does not assume one’s fellow humans are, on the whole, delusional. Not everyone, of course, seeks answers to these questions. Indeed, many practitioners are openly ambivalent about it. I may have succeeded, however, in enticing some to look a little closer, be they a Tarot reader, a committed Christian, or a sceptic. To those that follow their curiosity, this book is for you.</p><p>Agatha Christy apparently said she wrote so she didn’t have to talk to people. I think non-fiction writers embody the opposite: we write <em>to talk to people</em>. It is the continuation of a conversation already going on in the culture. That, certainly, is my aim. I have decided to leave the telling of much of the context you have read in this essay out of the book as written, as I wanted to focus on literature review rather than my story as the author. I maintain this was the right decision, but I hope you may have found this informal appendix nonetheless interesting. My approach has been to write to understand, to follow my curiosity, and to look for underappreciated connections.</p><p>[1] Carman, “A Witches Invitation”. The Benson Company, Inc, 1993.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f2f507c7e7fa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>