<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Sky Nelson-Isaacs on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Sky Nelson-Isaacs on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@skynelson?source=rss-73dcc8fa0e9e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 10:44:51 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@skynelson/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Interview with Sky Nelson-Isaacs, “Spacetime Paths as a Whole”, on Clubhouse]]></title>
            <link>https://skynelson.medium.com/interview-with-sky-nelson-isaacs-spacetime-paths-as-a-whole-on-clubhouse-44bb3b7d1bfc?source=rss-73dcc8fa0e9e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/44bb3b7d1bfc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spacetime]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quantum-mechanics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fourier-transform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hologram]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sky Nelson-Isaacs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 08 Jun 2021 21:43:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-09T00:12:22.538Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>June 5, 2021</h3><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 0:00</h4><p>My work has been for many years trying to understand some basic questions in space and time, and the foundations of quantum mechanics, and I went into education for a while, I’ve spent many years as a high school teacher. I’ve also worked in industry and software. And currently, the paper “<a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2624-960X/3/1/2">Spacetime Paths as a Whole</a>” that I was speaking about was published in quantum reports in December, and as a result of funded research that was done for the previous two years. So happy to talk about it today. Thank you for having me.</p><h4>Paul Borrill 0:33</h4><p><em>Thank you for being here, Sky, it’s a pleasure to have you. So let’s get started on the paper Spacetime Paths as a Whole. So my first question here is can you lay out the basic model, what motivates it, and what is it intended to accomplish?</em></p><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 0:50</h4><p>I was inspired really early in my education in college by learning about holograms, learning about Fourier transforms. I was really interested in fractals and all these things held sort of a similar mystique to me. I got to build a hologram in college, so I really got a first hand experience of what that is and what’s amazing about a hologram is that it encodes the information in a distributed fashion, so you’re taking a photograph of like, say, I took a photograph of a rubber duck, you know, we had this big table, and add a rubber duck in the middle of the table, turned off all the lights and shone a laser on it, and captured the light bouncing off of the rubber duck with a piece of film.</p><p>And in that film, the duck looks realistic and looks three dimensional. What’s amazing about it i s if you cut the hologram in half, you still see the whole duck, because the duck is not actually fixed to one part of the film it’s actually distributed across the film. So depending on your perspective on the film, you see the duck in different places and different angles. So there’s a disconnection between the space of the film itself and the image you see in it. And there’s a holism that happens, a one to all relationship that was evident in the Fourier transform that describes the hologram, and in the physical hologram itself.</p><p>And to me that was a fundamental thing that wasn’t fully explored. You can see this in this example, too and anybody’s familiar with the ability to break down an image into pixels, so your screen is made of pixels that are all different colors, and they’re side by side so they create an image together. But you can also decompose any image in terms of frequencies, in terms of patterns that look kind of like zebra stripes going in all sorts of different directions. And this is the Fourier transform. And what’s amazing about that is that you can, with the same amount of data but using these really different fundamental building blocks, you can create the same imagery, and what’s different about a point particle or like a pixel and a waveform is that a waveform is distributed across all of the space and infinity. So the question of how do you decompose things into these non local patterns, I think is really foundational.</p><p>And, turning to quantum mechanics, there’s some basic questions in quantum mechanics that I’ve had for a long time, specifically around time. When you go from the Schrodinger equation in its simplest form called the time independent equation, Time is sort of very simple, there’s a simple way of looking at that and it’s very classical. And when you go to the time dependent Schrodinger equation suddenly gets very complicated, you have to add these recursive cycles of computation.</p><p>So it seemed to me early on that there’s more than just trying to make special relativity compatible with quantum mechanics, there’s actually some, some other aspects of time that we don’t fully understand. And with my interest in optics and images and decomposing images, I thought that there might be some way to connect that field with the field of quantum wavefunction propagations. So my paper is not really a reformulation of quantum mechanics. It’s a reformulation of just wave function propagation, how wave functions, move from place to place, and hopefully gives us an insight into time and to quantum mechanics in the mean time.</p><h4>Paul Borrill 4:09</h4><p><em>Thank you, Sky. So, what’s wrong with time in your opinion?</em></p><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 4:16</h4><p>Well, the Fourier Transforms is a really interesting thing. In physics, we, we know that Fourier transforms are a fundamental part of quantum mechanics, because you know everyone is familiar some extent with the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. This is a trade off in accuracy between position and momentum. But what every physicist knows is that position is represented by sort of a distribution in space or a wave function and momentum is also a distribution in momentum, Fourier transforms of each other. So there’s this fundamental relationship, that is the Fourier transform between these two spaces. You can consider these two real spaces you have the regular space that you’re familiar with this alternate momentum space that you’re maybe not so familiar with. And these are related by the Fourier transform.</p><p>But what happens is, we very often use the Fourier transform, like in crystallography, we convert the crystal structure to its frequency space, and we do calculations there all the time. But we very rarely convert the time behavior into the frequency space. And, you know, mathematically, there’s no reason why we shouldn’t, there is a relationship, as an uncertainty relationship between time and energy. If you try to measure something very, very, very brief interval you get a very large spread and energy so there is this trade off. But, like, let’s look at a specific example. In optics, if you want to move an image, like how an image moves from your TV screen to your eyes, because it gets emitted from the TV screen.</p><p>And then what we usually do in what’s called Fresnel diffraction is we convert the image on the screen into its frequency representation. In other words, we take the Fourier transform of a two dimensional surface spatially. And then we propagate it, and we propagate it in what’s called the angular spectrum, because the frequency domain you’re now dealing with frequencies, and you’re propagating those. But what’s really important here is this kind of shortcut taken. You don’t convert the time domain, you leave that as it is. So, there’s sort of this crutch where we like to think of time as this spatial thing that moves forward all the moves forward in time, we’re always moving forward in time, and propagate image by evolving in time.</p><p>And my question is, you know, from a pure mathematical point of view, if you’re converting the spatial dimensions to the Fourier domain, why wouldn’t you convert the time dimension to the Fourier domain as well. And in doing so, how would you then interpret evolution because evolution usually means evolution over time, so suddenly you’re dealing with representation that has no time in it, because this time is embedded or encoded into the waveforms. So how do you interpret that and most of my work here is actually restating some formalisms that already exist, but interpreting them I think in a way that it makes more of a coherent picture.</p><h4>Paul Borrill 7:12</h4><p><em>Thank you Sky. So tell me, what is a hologram and why is it relevant, in your view?</em></p><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 7:20</h4><p>Well let me describe something about digital audio files first, because it’s really a useful technology to help us understand the purpose of what I’m trying to do. In a digital audio file you have music that plays like a five minute song, you know, it’s a WAV file and uncompressed audio file. And you would convert that file into its frequency representation in order to modify, like the equalization, if you want to change the high end or the low end as everyone’s familiar with. You can convert it to its frequencies and modify those things. But when you do that, you lose any kind of time ordering. So if you tried to play that file on your computer couldn’t do it. It’s the same size data, no data has been lost, but it’s not ordered according to time anymore, it’s ordered according to frequency. And so in order to play it back you have to invert the form back to time.</p><p>So what this illustrates is that there is a coherent way of talking about a system that is originally time ordered, but you can encode that time ordering, or hide the time ordering into an alternate representation. So that’s a very useful practical example of what we’re really doing here with the wavefunction that evolves in time. So a hologram, to get to the question. A hologram is essentially capturing the frequency domain. A lot of people think about the important thing about a hologram is, is it captures a three dimensional image, on a two dimensional piece of film. And the way it does that is by, let’s say you have a speck of dust, just to represent like a point particle, and a speck of dust, you shine light on the speck of dust, it bounces off the dust and shines onto a film. And you capture that light on a film you’re going to be trying to capture an image of the speck of dust. And again a speck of dust I’m using just as sort of a point particle to see what’s the simplest possible image you can create. So to create a hologram you shine light on this object, you capture the light that bounces off of it onto the film, and you interfere that light with just a plain beam of laser light coming in. So now you have laser light coming in that’s plain, and laser lights coming in from the object and you interfere them so that you basically take the, you subtract the phases of those two sources of light. And so your film captures a really mathematically accurate representation of what’s, what is in the visual scene around you. And if you, if you take like a rubber ducky and you look at the beak versus the wing, those are just different points that all all emanate light in the same way, and create this much more complicated image of a holographic image of a duck versus just a point of dust.</p><p>But nonetheless, the process is pretty straightforward, and it’s capturing the difference in phase on the film. And then when you shine a laser light on that film, without the duck present, do you actually see that the light that passes through the film takes on all the characteristics that it would have had if the duck was there, because the film is actually imparting the right phases, exactly to mimic what you originally had there. So then when you shine the laser on it, and nothing else is there and you actually see the duck floating in space where it originally appeared to have been.</p><p>So that’s a hologram, and it’s a very cool technology, but it’s more than just capturing a three dimensional image in the two dimensional piece of film. That’s kind of the hack of it, sort of a technological hack that we can do, but what it really is doing is it’s capturing the frequency domain, as it is. And usually, you know, when we take a photograph, if you just switch gears and think about photographs on your phone, for instance, you’ve got a lens in there, and what the lens is doing is performing a Fourier transform. So it’s taking the light out of the frequency domain, putting it back into spatial resolution, and then, capturing that. So that’s what our eyes do as well. But what we’re doing with the hologram is not converting it to the spatial resolution, we’re leaving it in the frequency domain and that’s what we’re capturing on the film. So it’s a great starting point for thinking about fields and how they can be represented in the frequency domain.</p><h4>Paul Borrill 11:24</h4><p><em>Thank you, so what’s the key insight in your work that leads to something new here?</em></p><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 11:33</h4><p>So all of what I talked about is, is understood, I think generally. One thing I mentioned is that we don’t usually do this kind of treatment for time, we usually leave time as this independent variable. If you look at like a quantum field, the simple version of a quantum field that is an oscillator. You know you you write the frequency portion, you read the spatial portion in terms of the integral over the frequencies which is essentially a Fourier transform in space. So you do a Fourier transform in space but you don’t do a Fourier transform in time. So your field is oscillating in time.</p><p>What I’m doing is, I want to get rid of this sense that time is actually happening in an explicit way. And when you encode, also the time domain into its frequencies, you get what is really a map. It’s not a “one to one” map, as I described earlier, it’s a “one to all” map. So every point of the map corresponds to a distributed information throughout throughout the dual space. Every point in the frequency domain, corresponds to something that shows up everywhere in physical space. But this map, although it totally encodes — there’s no information has been lost — it’s not one to one. And in particular, this kind of map can’t change. So now you have a map of reality that cannot change, because how would it change in time? It’s a map in time, and it’s encoding time. So what we’re doing here is by applying this Fourier transform to time as well, just as we would in an audio file, we get rid of the ability to have this thing — this map — change at all. And then we have to think about, okay if my map of reality can’t change, but the particles in reality are moving around, how is it that my map of reality which doesn’t change, because there’s no…I don’t want to add an extra time parameter like a “meta time” so that the map can change…so this map doesn’t change but somehow it encodes particles that are moving around and have equations of motion, that’s the real challenge here. And that leads to a concept of a path as a whole, which maybe we’ll get to shortly, but directly as a corollary that falls out of the principles of treating space and time — the wave function — as essentially signals in space and time, that are Fourier transformed into the frequency domain.</p><h4>Paul Borrill 14:02</h4><p><em>So, let’s get to that right now so what is meant by “paths as a whole”?</em></p><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 14:08</h4><p>Well a simple example is to think about light. And let’s take light traveling from the Sun to the Earth. It takes about eight minutes to do that. And if you think about that journey, it’s a certain distance. And that frequency domain representation if you’re converting both the time and the space domain into the frequency domain, then the representation you get describes the entire path. So, one…the frequency domain representation…So, the folks who might be familiar with engineering are familiar with this principle called the shift property of the Fourier transform, where if you want to move something in space, you multiply it by a phase factor in the frequency domain. And that’s it that’s all we’re doing here. If you’re moving a particle from the Sun to the Earth that corresponds to a phase factor that is being introduced in the, in the frequency domain.</p><p>But that phase factor applies to the whole path, the whole journey. And this really important question that John Wheeler brought up comes into play, this delayed choice experiment. I’m not even approaching it from a quantum mechanics point of view, I’m approaching it from a Fourier transform point of view. If the journey from the side of the Earth is represented by a Fourier transform, then that whole journey is encoded into the frequencies. But now let’s say I take satellite in between space in between the Sun and the Earth and I interject it and I capture the light. And I do this sort of at the last minute. Well that’s with a different endpoint, has a completely different Fourier transform.</p><p>And so the key here is two paths of different lengths, are going to have completely different Fourier transforms, because even though part of the journey is the same, just like in the hologram, the whole journey is what determines the frequency domain, the patterns in the frequency domain. So if you change any portion of the journey you’ve completely changed the frequency representation. And this is really the key element, so that the journey from the Sun to the satellite is fundamentally different, there’s no portion of that frequency domain that is equal to the journey from the Sun of the Earth.</p><p>And so that brings up this really important question of “if the light was already traveling on its way to the earth, and you change its path, well, you’ve just modified the frequency domain that it was already traveling, according to…you’ve modified the map that it was already traveling by.” And so that’s a really difficult interpretational question, how do you modify a journey this already started, but it’s already been described as a whole. And, in short, the conclusion is that there must be a superposition of multiple of these maps, of these frequency domain maps each of which corresponds to the light traveling from the Sun to a different endpoint. And so you recover this notion of superposition, which is very much a part of the Fourier transform, but it’s also a fundamental part of quantum mechanics.</p><h4>Paul Borrill 17:19</h4><p><em>Thank you. Well, this sounds somewhat like the block universe model in special relativity Minkowski spacetime, can you clarify, please?</em></p><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 17:29</h4><p>Yeah, and I’ll say about the last point that it does become hard to justify separating the macro from the micro in this view of paths as a whole and that’s one of the key challenges to face, is how do we understand this, how do we handle…usually we think about quantum mechanics as a microscopic theory, and that’s something that comes into conflict with this theory.</p><p>So, let me say about the block universe. The block universe is this idea from relativity theory that space and time are on equal footing as dimensions. And if you want to lay these out visually you can think of it like a block of ice. And one of those dimensions of the ice is time. And so, if you’re traveling through spacetime, it’s like a crack in the block of ice that moves from one point to another, along both space and time. And it’s like a frozen picture of a trajectory. It’s looking at time, essentially from the outside.</p><p>Now, what’s what’s interesting about this block universe is that it really explicitly looks like the world we live in, right? You can you can map positions in space and positions in time from the real world, to this block of ice. The difference here, and what we’re talking about in this model is that we’re talking about a “frequency domain block universe”. So things that, as I mentioned, the frequency domain map of something, even if it’s moving, the frequency domain map is fixed, it doesn’t change, because there’s no time in which to mark that change. So, the path, any notion of a path through the frequency domain block universe is not aligned…it doesn’t resemble the physical path that we’re used to in spacetime. And yet, the physical path of a particle is encoded fully into the phase map of the frequencies, and the frequency map — the phase map — is static. So you’ve got this static dataset that gives rise to equations of motion so that particles can move within the physical space. Which I think is really the really fundamental interesting piece here.</p><h4>Paul Borrill 19:43</h4><p><em>So how then can a dynamical description of nature emerge from such a static data set?</em></p><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 19:54</h4><p>Well, first of all think about, they make the basic calculation here — and for the next question I’d like to let Tony asked this question after in the questions about signal processing and I’m going to touch on signal processing a little bit — but for this question around the dynamical description of nature…when someone does a computation of the wave function, moving forward in this particular model, they’re doing a convolution, just like in image processing you’re doing convolutions. So when are they doing that convolution? The data scientist is doing a convolution, sort of in an abstract moment in time, in the physicists moment in time. But the time itself is a dimension that is part of the convolution. So we can’t say, when the physicist does this calculation, it would imply some kind of extra time parameter.</p><p>So because of this again I’ll just restate that the field can’t change during a four dimensional convolution. In other words, a four dimensional image transform that includes time — three dimensions of space one dimension of time — can’t happen at a specific time. So, the mathematician’s work is to find out what needs to happen so that the four dimensional field doesn’t change. And here’s really the key. We want the four dimensional field, space and time field, to not change during an interaction. So you convolve it with, you convolve like the incoming wave function with some kind of filter or other particle, and you get a resulting field, a resulting distribution.</p><p>But, you need that resulting distribution to be identical to the original distribution because if it wasn’t identical then something would have changed. In other words, it’s like time would have passed, and you can’t have time pass in this abstract way of calculation. So by holding this notion that the field is…that the thing is static, and requiring that it remains so, you then get a bunch of phases that change. What’s happening in the calculation of convolution, is a bunch of phases that are changing for every frequency, and phases changing…and you require those phases to cancel or to vanish — those phase changes. And those phases are specifically described by variables in space and time.</p><p>So by making sure that those phase changes disappear, or they cancel, you essentially get things that look like, you know if you’re familiar with high school algebra you have a equation of motion like x equals V T — position equals velocity times time. And let’s say let’s say you’re going 100 miles an hour. Well if you mark the position at 100 miles, and you mark the time at one hour, then x minus VT is going to be zero, because that is the equation of motion of the particle. You travel 100 miles in one hour and your speed is 100 miles per hour, those are going to cancel. And so what we get is that equation of motion that is allowed is precisely the values for which the particles are moving and their motion in space and time is cancelling out.</p><p>So the result is that in the block universe, nothing changes. The frequency domain block universe can’t…doesn’t even notice that any changes happen for the particles, because they’ve changed the position, exactly equivalent to how they’ve changed their time based on the speed they’re going. And so all motion cancels out, which is to say that the beautiful thing about this is the following. If you’ve thought about freezing time before, you might have thought about freezing time that’s like taking a snapshot of time, like a frozen image of the world. And that’s not what happens here. When you freeze time here, you allow things to continue moving along what are called “inertial trajectories”, as long as they don’t…a measurement isn’t made. So, the timeless view is actually one in which there’s this actual evolution of time happening where things are moving along their normal paths, kind of like Newton’s first law of motion where an object in motion tends to stay in motion.</p><p>So this is really a key conclusion or way of interpreting the data. That what we think of is the simplest possible view is actually one in which things are moving, they’re just not interacting in the usual way, there’s no measurements being made. And so what we call unitary motion is actually associated with a frozen picture of the frequency domain, and it takes us away from this very much more simple notion of freezing time being like everything, everything stops. I’ll leave it there hopefully maybe we can talk more about this in the Q&amp;A.</p><h4>Paul Borrill 24:36</h4><p><em>Sounds good. Okay so what I’ll do is ask Tony to ask this question later on. I’ve got three or four more questions and then we’ll switch to the panel onstage and then I would like to see some people from the audience ask some questions. So my next question then is, relates to interpretations and how does this relate to the many worlds interpretation that’s preferred by Sean Carroll and David Deutsch?</em></p><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 24:36</h4><p>I love this question. I love Sean Carroll, I listen to his podcast Mindscape. It’s a great podcast. What is really important to understand is that this paper is not an interpretation of quantum mechanics. An interpretation of quantum mechanics starts from the same postulates of quantum mechanics, the six postulates or so, that make up quantum mechanics, and then says, given those, those facts as physical facts, how do we interpret what they mean. And I don’t touch on those postulates at all. I don’t bring them up in any way. So I’m not doing quantum mechanics here in the traditional sense.</p><p>My postulates are about optics and image processing. So I basically say, the physical wavefunction is a four dimensional wavefunction, a spacetime wavefunction, and it’s got a counterpart, which is a momentum space wavefunction. It’s both the momentum and energy domains. And that these are related by the Fourier transform as one would expect. And I’ve made that statement and say that you really have to be very strict about your treatment and then see what happens. And the second postulate is simply from optics again, that when you interact these two signals or two systems you convolve them together. And from this, you get an equation of essentially evolution that can be reduced to Schrodinger’s equation, and hopefully some other more complicated, like the Dirac and Klein-Gordon, but I haven’t shown those to be the case. I suspect that they are but it would take significant work to do so. So I don’t want to go beyond what I’ve already shown.</p><p>But what what I’m doing is not an interpretation of quantum mechanics, it’s a reformulation of wavefunction propagation, and it does reproduce some of the basic ideas in…specifically superposition of states. And in that in that regard it really mirrors the many worlds hypothesis very well. The most relevant area of agreement is the description of this branching waveform, and the relative nature of measurement in that in that wave form. You know, when you measure a system in Many Worlds theory you’re not actually collapsing to that world, but from the observer’s point of view, you’re getting a particular outcome. And a process I call retroactive event determination, which is very similar to the delayed choice that I mentioned earlier by Wheeler, so it’s this notion that histories are flexible, or that the branching wavefunction is essentially flexible to, I would say, influencing branches of the past that haven’t been determined yet. I think that’s supported by Many Worlds and it’s supported by what I’m doing here so there is some some real crossover but again it’s not an interpretation of quantum mechanics in the usual sense.</p><h4>Paul Borrill 27:47</h4><p><em>Thank you. Well it all raises questions in my mind here about how people think about things and not, not necessarily interpretation but this does seem to me like it relates somewhat to the Cramer transactional interpretation. Can you say something about that?</em></p><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 28:03</h4><p>Yeah, so the Cramer interpretation has some interesting aspects, I can point to a couple. In Cramer’s view, the wave function is a function of space and time. It represents real physical waves. And this is contrary to the Copenhagen interpretation where the wavefunction represents something more abstract. In Copenhagen, you can use a wave function to calculate real probabilities, but it’s like a probability wave, it’s not a physical wave like electromagnetism is. So Cramer makes that sort of bold distinction in his view of the transactional interpretation that the wavefunction is physical. But he specifically says there’s a problem when you convert the wavefunction into its frequency domain — which is something you’re allowed to do in physics — the frequency domain wavefunction does not correspond to real physical waves, because he doesn’t really have a way to interpret what that would mean. What is a physical wave in the frequency domain? And that’s exactly what I’m doing, is sort of making sense of waves in spacetime and in the frequency domain, and how they relate to each other.</p><p>But I would not agree that the waves are physical waves. I think that what we’re talking about as waves are informational waves that are giving rise to all of space and time and physics. So they’re not made of physical particles or anything like that. So there’s a limitation to his view that is pretty distinct from what comes out of my view.</p><p>He does say that, you know, his transactional wave functions are solutions of the Dirac or the Klein-Gordon equation, they don’t actually come out of the Schrodinger equation, because the Schrodinger equation is first order in time which for anyone who’s not a scientist, means that it just has one solution, the forward in time solution. Whereas, the other equations, the more complicated and more accurate ones have both forward in time and reverse time solutions, what are called advanced waves and retarded waves. And so his wave function doesn’t actually come from the Schrodinger equation, it has to come from these more advanced equations, or two different Schrodinger equations, one which is forward in time and one which is explicitly backwards in time. So there is this crossover in the views. But again, he views wavefunctions as real things, and that doesn’t really line up with my view or with, I think the majority of views in quantum mechanics.</p><h4>Paul Borrill 30:33</h4><p><em>Thank you. Beautiful. So, finally, how does this relate to QBism and models such as Rob Spekkens toy models?</em></p><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 30:45</h4><p>QBism, is really interesting to me. Not because I agree with it, let’s just say that, but I really admire the people that were doing work in it. I like David Mermin is someone I followed for a long time. He’s got some really lucid explanations of what the measurement problem really is and what quantum mechanics is trying to tell us. With literally a paper that’s titled “What is quantum mechanics trying to tell us”, so great work there. And the QBism approach is to, I think if I understand it correctly, is to say that wave functions are really a state of knowledge of the observer or the agent. They don’t represent something physical about the world, which sort of takes away the mystique of what quantum mechanics is really trying to tell us. That there isn’t actually…what would you say…there isn’t actually something that the observer is doing to change the physical system, by making an observation, but that the physical…all the observer is doing is updating the knowledge of the physical system. And it explains…some of the results can be explained that way but when you get to Bell’s theorem, which is essentially measuring entanglement, what I understand is the QBism approach has trouble reconciling with entanglement, because entanglement requires this notion of the observer’s choice of measurement operator having an effect on what are the possible outcomes, both for their particle and for any entangled particles. And the details of that really QBism doesn’t have an answer for, as far as I understand, currently.</p><h4>Paul Borrill 32:18</h4><p><em>Thank you. Excellent. Really beautiful description, Sky, thank you so much. What I’d like to do now is move to questions for people that are on the stage. I know that Tony, you’ve got a question you’d like to ask.</em></p><p><em>So the rules are very simple. This is a very interesting topic, and these issues concerning the nature of time and causality are perhaps among the most challenging and subtle in science and mathematics. And the distinctions between the various models and paradoxes and so on are exceedingly difficult to pinpoint. So our job today is to try to get these issues on the table. And one way to do this is through open mindedness, come from a place of curiosity, rather than defending or refuting a particular argument.</em></p><h4>Tony Schultz 33:45</h4><p><em>Thanks, I just first want to say thanks to Paul, for starting this club, and making a space for this, this conversation to happen. And, yeah, I wanted to thank Sky. You know first just for this paper. This is a big accomplishment, and it’s very elegant scholarship, so we’ve had some conversations over the past couple of days and I’ve spent some time with this paper, and it’s been a pleasure to engage. You know, for my development, for my time evolution, I’ve spent a lot of time doing signal processing. So I have this breeding as a physicist and then, you know, I became a little bit more technical in working on the computer. And so you know I spend more time doing signal processing now than pure physics. And that language is just really engaging, and I think might be a familiar framework for many of the people listening. I was hoping that you would speak on these fairly technical terms: convolution, impulse response, and transfer function, and how those are used in your concept development, and then just do the hand holding, kind of guide me through how these relate to holography.</em></p><h4>Sky Nelson-Isaacs 35:25</h4><p>I love that question and I think it is a really useful, tangible point of development of the theory, because that is what guided me to making tangible progress in writing these things down. So, the field we’re talking about here is called scalar diffraction theory, developed by Helmholtz, Kirchoff, and some others. And you can find a great introduction to this, a complicated one, but a pretty thorough one in Goodman’s book on Introduction to Fourier Optics, as I’m sure you’ve done this research, Tony, but other folks haven’t had that background. So, what we’re talking about here…the basic equation in my paper is a convolution equation, where you take a four dimensional signal that represents space and time, and you convolve that with some other four dimensional signal, and that’s really just the mathematics that you would use to apply a filter in Adobe Photoshop. If I have an original two dimensional image, and I want to filter it, I apply a low pass filter, or a high pass filter, or a bandpass filter to convolve the two together and I get a resulting image.</p><p>And what’s important about a convolution is the convolution theorem, that applies to it, which says that what you’re really doing is converting to the frequency domain, and multiplying. So when you convert a filter to the frequency domain, and then multiply it by your original signal, you’re essentially…one example would be a low pass filter, you’re…you’re masking out all the high frequencies. In other words you’re blanking out or zeroing out all the high frequencies by multiplying by zeros everywhere there’s a high frequency. And that’s in the frequency domain. When you convert it back to the spatial domain, via an inverse Fourier transform, you get a picture that has all the high frequency data removed.</p><p>What that looks like physically is all the details are gone, your picture has been blurred, because high frequency data in a picture corresponds to that all the quick variation. So, filters…that’s the way filters work, through convolution. And what you what you typically do is, to understand how your filter is going to work, you break it down into the most basic form, which is called the impulse response. So any kind of camera or digital or analog imaging system will have an impulse response. And that’s the way it responds to the most basic signal. And you convolve your incoming signal with your impulse response, you find out what that looks like, and then you integrate that over the actual filter itself, and it’s like adding up all those point particles to create the overall hologram that I was talking about earlier.</p><p>So, what you’re doing here is…in the physics…I’m suggesting the impulse response shows up as well, and the impulse response…when you convert it, you’re convolving it with your signal. So you did the convolution theorem, you’re actually doing that in the frequency domain, that turns into what’s called the transfer function which is how your…the transfer function just describes how your frequencies evolve in the frequency domain. And, in short, the way that this gets written in the paper is this very elegant way of looking at it. Which is part of the appeal is how straightforward this is.</p><p>You start with — and this is the basic evolution of a system in this model — you start with your original four dimensional wave function, like space and time. You multiply it by some phase distribution, which is some complicated distribution, that corresponds to what’s called a transmittance function in optics, which is like, just your image, your original acetate or overhead projector. You know like your piece of film that you shine light through, that’s called the transmittance function. That’s the thing you’re trying to change. And that actually correlates to the potential in physics. You multiply your original wave function by this thing that has to do with the potential in the spatial domain, and then you convert the whole thing into the frequency domain. And in the frequency domain, you do the same thing. You multiply by another phase factor, which has to do with the kinetic portion of the Hamiltonian…in my example is momentum squared over 2m, which is just…the Hamiltonian has to do with the energy, the kinetic energy of the system.</p><p>So that shows up in the frequency domain, as a phase factor, and then you convert that whole thing back to regular space. And that’s all you do to understand the evolution of the system. And then you make sure that you set the beginning equal to the end, because time can’t actually evolve, and then what you get is some constraints on how the phases must change.</p><p>But the point is that how the phase has changed determines the equation of motion. Okay. The point is that all of this is that the original signal, multiplied by a transmittance function, convolved with an impulse response — which has to do with the kinetic energy — and then obtaining the final result in spacetime. So it really is drawn directly from Fourier optics, and the first appendix really just makes that available for folks in the paper. Thanks for that question too, I think it’s great.</p><p>And I guess there’s one more point about holograms; that holograms are really described by scalar diffraction theory and Fresnel diffraction, which is a special case that I’m talking about here. And what a hologram is is just capturing the phase differences between the frequencies of a signal and reproducing those for the viewer. So they’re described by exactly the type of physics we’re talking about here.</p><p>I will also point out something I didn’t get to mention about a hologram. There is this disconnect between the film itself — when you look at a hologram, the film is kind of invisible, it’s meant to stay in the background and you’re not supposed to see it — and then the image appears in the film as something you can actually see. There’s this direct, exact correlation in the theory between that description of holograms and the physics of the fields. The field or the wavefunction is something that is not visible, you can’t measure it in the background. And the space time event, like a detector capturing a particle, is exactly equivalent mathematically to the holographic image that you see in the film. So there’s this real direct correlation between the spacetime physics and the optics, and holograms.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=44bb3b7d1bfc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Publication of “Spacetime Paths as a Whole”]]></title>
            <link>https://skynelson.medium.com/publication-of-spacetime-paths-as-a-whole-351fe432c04e?source=rss-73dcc8fa0e9e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/351fe432c04e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[leap-to-wholeness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[timeless]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[living-in-flow]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[synchronicity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spacetime]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sky Nelson-Isaacs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 31 Dec 2020 18:31:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-31T18:37:02.332Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The aim of The Synchronicity Institute is to establish the phenomenon of synchronicity — or meaningful coincidence — as a scientific phenomenon. The path to doing this is a bit circuitous and strategic, and the publication of “<a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2624-960X/3/1/2">Spacetime Paths as a Whole</a>” in Quantum Reports on December 31, 2020, is a milestone on this path.</p><p>“Spacetime Paths as a Whole” deals with our understanding of time. There is a long history of confusion in science around the mathematics of time, because as human beings we are very familiar and intimate with time. We are immersed in it, we are constrained by it, we can’t go backward, only forward at the pace of the clock. This limitation shows up as inconsistencies in many areas of science. The famous Schrodinger equation in quantum mechanics is known to be a compromise which doesn’t treat time properly, yet it is extremely successful from an engineering and technical perspective.</p><h3>Time as a filmstrip</h3><p>What does the new paper say about time? It’s the difference between a clock and a filmstrip. A clock is a way of tracking seconds, dividing the day into pieces, reducing the whole to its parts. A filmstrip is a means of telling a story, it is connected from beginning to end, it sees the whole from the parts.</p><p>When light leaves the Sun, it starts an eight minute journey to Earth. When you see the Sun, you are seeing light that is eight minutes old. But Gilbert Lewis pointed out in 1926 that the mathematics of light propagation indicates that light actually does not register any distinction between the Sun and Earth. It doesn’t travel. The beginning and ending are a single event. It appears to us that light travels 92 million miles over eight minutes, but to light this is a single, timeless, spaceless event. It is a whole story, a whole journey rather than a series of individual steps.</p><p>The aim with “Spacetime Paths as a Whole” is to use well-established theories such as the Feynman path integral to show that space and time are holistic, they cannot be broken into pieces, and that there is a description of the world which is non-reductionist. The mathematics of “frequency space” and the Fourier transform are central to this view. One can learn about the holistic nature of the Fourier transform through simple everyday examples, such as your music mp3 files or streaming videos and photographs. These technologies use the same techniques for data compression, and you can see the results sometimes when the quality of the media isn’t quite good enough.</p><p>This approach doubles down on the notion of the world as information, or even as a “simulation.” It also may resolve some of the technical problems we have with the mathematics of time.</p><h3>A Vast, Intimate Cosmos</h3><p>On another hand, it points to a cosmos which, though vast, is intimate. From this starting point, rooted in non-controversial mainstream science, my book “Leap to Wholeness: How the World is Programmed to Help Us Grow, Heal and Adapt,” makes a case for a more profound possibility. You are not isolated in the present moment, separated from the history of the cosmos to drown in obscurity. Rather, you are part of a filmstrip, a story which has an arc from the past to the future. The choices you make matter towards the unfolding of this journey, and we are all part of something really big.</p><p>With this vast, yet intimate picture of history, let’s raise our vision beyond the immediate horizon and decide where we want the story to lead.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=351fe432c04e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[With every choice you make, you are anticipating experiences.]]></title>
            <link>https://skynelson.medium.com/with-every-choice-you-make-you-are-anticipating-experiences-10ba485ee5ca?source=rss-73dcc8fa0e9e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/10ba485ee5ca</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sky Nelson-Isaacs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Mar 2020 05:19:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-16T05:19:07.685Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/875/1*apJfttimsI91z1w7YxlkNg.jpeg" /></figure><p>With every choice you make, you are anticipating experiences. You invest time setting up your kid’s birthday party because you anticipate them having a great birthday experience. Or you drive fast because you are anticipating receiving a rebuke from your manager for being late. You are actually anticipating your experience of each situation, what it will be like to feel (fill in the blank).</p><p>Now think about the tree of possibilities. On some of those branches you have the experience you are anticipating. On some you do not. Any of the future situations that align with the experience you are seeking to have grow apples and become a little more probable. If an area of the tree is heavily weighed down by apples, all the possible events on that part of the tree become more likely.</p><p>A synchronicity is one of these events which has its probability boosted because it leads toward the apples you are actively striving for. At the last minute the birthday party gets rained out, so you are very disappointed, but that same week a friend needs help moving and asks you to store some of their things, including a bunch of indoor party games for kids. As a result, your kid’s party is a success. That is a synchronicity, because it is a seemingly random event which leads you to where you were already trying to go.</p><p>But synchronicity is not a “positive” thing. The process is neutral. If we dwell on worry about our manager’s reaction to us being late, we might disregard the instructions of our GPS and follow a “short cut” to work, only to find unexpected roadwork that makes us decisively late. The road work is a synchronistic event because, just as before, it leads to the experience we are anticipating.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=10ba485ee5ca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Living Inside a Hologram]]></title>
            <link>https://skynelson.medium.com/living-inside-a-hologram-5697ea8c153c?source=rss-73dcc8fa0e9e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5697ea8c153c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[holographic-reality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[flow]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healing-emotions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[simulation-hypothesis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[synchronicity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sky Nelson-Isaacs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Jan 2020 21:53:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-07T07:49:47.189Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>1. Holograms, quantum mechanics, and choices</h3><p>Making good choices is difficult. Whether the choices are in our business, our social lives, our finances, or our family, the choices we make determine the direction of our lives and our society.</p><p>It may be surprising that a field as abstract as physics may help us better understand our choices. I will make the case here that your worldview–and your ability to understand how your choices influence your lifepath–can benefit from cutting edge research on space and time itself.</p><p>In recent years, the advent of the digital frontier has birthed the notion of the world as a giant “simulation.” In work currently under academic review, I establish a connection between the physics of quantum mechanics and that of <em>holograms </em>to demonstrate how our “world as simulation” might really be operating. The study of holograms is the study of patterns, and the language of patterns is “waves,” because a pattern is about repetition and the quintessential repeating structure is a wave. Not coincidentally, this is the same language that describes everyday matter through the science of quantum field theory.</p><p>The result may be a world in which our choices not only influence the “present moment” but entire timelines of history. In this sort of world, history is flexible to fall into place many different ways based upon our choices.</p><blockquote>“Instead of simply entertaining ourselves on a playground of pleasure and pain, we might consider ourselves in a school of choices.”</blockquote><p>Such a world is more like a subjective gaming environment than the usual objectivity most of us take for granted. A video game world can be alive in a way that an inert world is not. A virtual world can respond to its inhabitants. It can be programmed with algorithms that are purposeful. A training program, for instance, can wait to see what the trainee chooses before deciding what curricular experience to provide next. Could it be that we exist in a training environment, here to learn something purposeful? Instead of simply entertaining ourselves on a playground of pleasure and pain, we might consider ourselves in a school of choices.</p><p>By understanding the world we live in better at this fundamental level, we might come to better understand the consequences of our choices, and in doing so, make more conscious ones.</p><h3>2. Holograms: The math of The Matrix</h3><p>(For a glossary of terms used here, appendix <em>A </em>is provided.)</p><p>To think more systematically about choice in your life, recall the movie “The Matrix”, in which our world is discovered to be an artificial simulation. What makes this simulated world different from the world we inhabit? <em>It responds to choices. </em>When a character in the movie makes a specific choice about how to proceed with their mission, the histories of objects in the virtual world <em>adjust</em>. Suddenly, instead of being in hallway A, the enemy will be found in hallway B. After this adjustment, the plot plays out in a new, more interesting fashion. For this to happen, objects in the virtual world must not be as solid as we like to think. Rather, objects get arranged into specific situations <em>with respect to </em>the perspective of the person making the choices.</p><p>To build a scientific theory of a world like The Matrix, I propose we need to show that the world is holographic. You can find examples of holograms used as counterfeit protection on many credit cards (see fig. 1). They are images which appear 3-dimensional–for instance a face or a flying eagle–because they seem to float above the film and move as we tilt our perspective, giving the illusion of depth. A hologram appears realistic but it is really a trick played by light passing through an interference pattern on a piece of film (see fig. 2).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*wNVc3BlN5njj-RDlB_05nQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 1: </strong><em>A hologram on a credit card</em></figcaption></figure><p>Similarly, a holographic world would appear realistic, yet the underlying “film” would guide the objects in it. We shall see that objects which seem so solid may in fact be momentary reconstructions of the underlying holographic information, presented to us when we look, but not persisting in our absence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/452/1*hrZHOTRQ_oZD6e38fx7Yng.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2: </strong><em>A simple holographic interference pattern</em></figcaption></figure><p>The possibility that the world is a giant hologram has sparked interest for generations of philosophers, scientists, and laypeople, beginning with physicist David Bohm’s idea of an “implicate order”[1] and the publishing of Michael Talbot’s “The Holographic Universe”.[2] More recently, cosmologists such as Gerard ’t Hooft [3] and Leonard Susskind [4] have drawn a similar conclusion through the study of black holes.</p><p>Holograms are different from photographs because they capture their images in terms of <em>patterns </em>rather than pixels. The patterns form something we can call “frequency-space,” a landscape of all the possible patterns that could exist. In fact, this mathematics is central to some pattern recognition technology[5] [6] and in some theories of brain function,[7] possibly accounting for our own brains’ keen ability to recognize patterns. Instead of storing visual information in specific regions of the film (the pixels), the image is stored in <em>patterns of interference </em>across the entire film. Frequency-space is actually quite familiar, the colors of the rainbow–ROYGBIV–being a prime example. Each color describes a particular pattern of electromagnetic vibration.</p><blockquote>“Holograms are different from photographs because they capture their images in terms of <em>patterns </em>rather than pixels.”</blockquote><p>It is this focus on patterns that makes a holographic world adjustable based on choices. We think of matter as the most fundamental thing there could be. After all, you can’t walk through a closed door. But if patterns of information are more fundamental than material objects, this changes how we should think of material objects.</p><p>To envision the way that patterns in frequency-space modify the possibilities for actual events in the physical world, consider the power of a few bits in your online calendar. Those few bits could mean the difference between showing up at a meeting at 8am or 8pm. Let’s say it’s noon when you check your calendar. Did you miss the meeting or not? In a hologram-like world, both possibilities exist, up until you check the calendar to find out. In one possibility, your colleagues are mad at you, and in the other possibility they are expecting to see you in 8 hours. These are two causal chains, both of which are consistent with what you know about the situation since you haven’t talked to them yet. Here, the patterns of bits in the computer’s memory are loosely analogous to the patterns in frequency-space.</p><p>In a hologram-like world, a change in the bits which encode “pm” versus “am” can shift a whole downstream collection of experiences. In such a world, it is only when we check our calendar that one or the other situation is reconstructed from the patterns in the hologram to bring our reality to life. Which was it, 8am or 8pm? The resulting life-paths may be radically different.</p><p>To understand patterns in frequency-space, let’s think about how music is recorded in the digital age.</p><h3>Frequency-space is hard to imagine</h3><p>The invention of the mp3, while awesome, is a hack. An mp3 is a small, portable type of digital music file that has become very popular in the internet age. What makes an mp3 so awesome is its small size.</p><p>This is accomplished by converting air vibration data into frequency data. Thus we can tell if a middle-C is being played, or if there is a stray low frequency buzz in the recording. A graphic equalizer can process the data in this “frequency-space” and either remove or amplify the desired sounds.</p><p>A process called the Fourier transform changes the data from regular space to frequency-space by completely intermixing the sound data into a soup of frequencies, its spectrum. (What I call regular space is also known as the “time domain”.) But this is done in a very precise way which can later be unmixed. All the information is preserved in this transformation. Importantly, it is possible to do any kind of signal modification one desires using this mathematical process, so long as one converts back to regular space afterwards.</p><p>Yet it is here that the hack comes in. A pure application of the Fourier transform process would intermix data from <em>across the entire song</em>. “Beginning” and “end” would be lost in frequency-space because the technique gets rid of time ordering. This is not problematic, because when you invert the process you would get the time ordering back. Yet we don’t do it this way. We humans are very attached to time. We don’t easily make sense of a data file that doesn’t have a beginning and an end. We want to think in terms of a linear progression of time, a string of time-ordered moments.</p><p>What we do, then, is chop up the original sound file into short sound bytes. Then we Fourier transform each sound byte to get the frequency data at that moment, <em>keeping the sound bytes in the original time order</em>. In other words, we <em>force </em>time ordering onto the file. This allows us to manipulate the file in ways more familiar to us, due to our familiarity with living sequentially from past to future. But remember, it is just as possible to manipulate the frequencies in the desired way without using this hack, it just isn’t how things are done. It feels less confusing to keep the data time ordered.</p><p>Now consider the wavefunction, a mathematical tool used in quantum mechanics to describe the world. The wavefunction in quantum mechanics is a hack similar to an mp3. It is spread over space, like the surface of an ocean, undulating in time. Yet the wavefunction should extend not only over space, but also over time. (I hope it seems reasonable to treat time the same way as we do space, and indeed this is the essence of the theory of special relativity.) But it is very difficult for us to picture this. We insist on having a “Now”. So we break time up into little ordered time-bytes and we say that “at each individual ‘Now’ moment there is a wave function.” Just like with the mp3, we force time ordering onto our description because we default to seeing everything through the lens of “Now”.</p><blockquote>“The roadmap captures the entire journey of your car across the countryside, and 4D frequency-space captures a car’s entire journey through space and time.”</blockquote><p>There is a better way. My research treats every physical object as if it were an audio file, converting it into frequency-space to obtain its spectra.</p><p>Some spectacular results emerge when we work in frequency-space. In the usual approach, we have a 3-dimensional wavefunction sitting in 3-dimensional space, and free to change steadily in the 4th dimension, time. In the new approach we have a 4-dimensional wavefunction spread over space <em>and </em>time. Notice that because it is a map <em>over </em>time, it can’t change <em>in </em>time, in the same way that a roadmap doesn’t change as you drive along the road. The roadmap captures the entire journey of your car across the countryside, and 4D frequency-space captures a car’s entire journey through space and time.</p><p>What is frequency-space, then? It doesn’t describe a simple path through space and time. It does not contain any single point identified as “now”, which makes it very hard for us to grasp. In frequency-space, there is no way to illustrate the passage of time.</p><blockquote>“We are not simply in the present moment. We are part of a timeline with a beginning and an end.”</blockquote><p>Just as with the music file, the Fourier transform is again used to take us into frequency-space. Here, what we see are interference patterns. Imagine a still pond of water when a gentle rain first begins. A web of intermixing ripples extends over the entire pond, as in fig. 3. Note that the pattern you see on the pond’s surface corresponds precisely to the locations at which the raindrops fell. If you saw a pattern of concentric circles, you would know that the raindrop hit right at their center.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/453/1*KCTk8DC3cFPZpswIGqMf8w.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3: </strong><em>Ripples in a pond capture the patterns of frequency-space. You can infer where in the picture two water drops fell in order to create the pattern of the ripples</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/583/1*NLzCiTl1iqWzrztOyp2VDA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 4: </strong><em>An illustration of frequency-space for a particle travelling from point A to point B. The pattern here doesn’t resemble a moving particle, yet the start and end points of its travel, as well as its speed, are encoded into the pattern you see</em></figcaption></figure><p>In the same way, the frequency-space description of reality is an interference pattern which corresponds precisely to our physical world, recording the way everything is arranged right now and over all time (see fig. 4). We are not simply in the present moment. We are part of a timeline with a beginning and an end.</p><p>But if the world is like a holographic image, where is the holographic film located? Is it like a movie screen at the edge of the universe, so that the universe within is like a vast theater? No, the “film” is the interference pattern in frequency-space. It exists right here. It cannot be observed, but it is ubiquitous, existing everywhere and always.</p><p>To imagine this, think of how the meaning of this sentence is generated. If we were to ask “Where, in this sentence, does the meaning reside?”, the question makes no sense. The meaning of the sentence arises from the collective interaction of all of the words in the sentence. The meaning doesn’t exist “somewhere”, but it is encoded in the linguistic patterns of the sentence. Similarly, frequency-space exists ubiquitously within all of space and time, a realm not of individual points but of patterns.</p><p>The complete ontology of the holographic model is not yet clear. Is what we call the “universe” a cosmic hologram which includes us? Or are we separate observers viewing the hologram from the outside? My research has not produced a definitive answer to these questions. The simplest way to imagine the effect of living in a holographic world is to picture yourself as a witness to the hologram, viewing one possible timeline from the outside. Your place in the hologram is based on your choices, but in principle there are other possible timelines and other possible locations in space and time that you could view the hologram from.</p><blockquote>“Frequency-space exists ubiquitously within all of space and time, a realm not of individual points but of patterns.”</blockquote><p>However, I suspect that this is ultimately the wrong view, for it adds complications rather than removing them. In that case, what is the hologram and what are we? I fear that answering these questions would be like trying to explain the apparent retrograde motion of the planets by inventing complicated epicycles, rather than seeing the underlying wholeness of planetary orbits. My preferred model is that the holographic interference pattern <em>is </em>us. In this ontology, we are living inside a virtual world of our own creation, and the other objects in that creation are projections of ourselves, with similarities to the view on dream states proposed in depth psychology. In this view,</p><blockquote>“The dream is the larger Self that is talking to the narrower ego…The various characters in the dream become representatives of the individual’s particular characteristics.”[8]</blockquote><p>The implications of such a view are substantial, and I view it as a tentative proposal beyond the scope of this article.</p><p>So how does a hologram create the illusion of 3D? Next, we’ll uncover the key insight about space and time that leads to the world as a hologram.</p><h3>Is physical reality an illusion?</h3><p>A hologram is different from a regular photograph because the image in it appears 3 dimensional. What does this mean? Consider the holographic rendering of a city in figures 5–8. The first clue of 3-dimensionality is that the image of the city does not look like it is actually on the film, but above or below it in 3D space (although it is difficult to make this out in a still image reproduction). The second clue of 3-dimensionality is that when the film is tilted through the sequence of figures, the pixels representing different parts of the city <em>move at different rates </em>across the field of view. The buildings in front shift position relative to the buildings in back, making it seem like the buildings in back are farther away. This “parallax” illusion can be created through the simple relative motion of pixels, as any 3D game developer knows.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/862/1*w6ZbI-YFHZ1YefCzV99fLw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xoliKiM5d0Ijq8qmpU_oMA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 5: </strong><em>City hologram, perspective A; </em><strong>Figure 6: </strong><em>City hologram, perspective B, viewer moving from right to left</em></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5MFiw75e5dFqR3ESZKcCkA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rjq6Yd1DURFCabbNjLD8Dg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 7: </strong><em>City hologram, perspective C; </em><strong>Figure 8: </strong><em>City hologram, perspective D</em></figcaption></figure><p><strong>“Space” has two distinct meanings in a hologram</strong></p><p>There is an important point in this: “space” has two distinct meanings. To illustrate this, let’s simplify the geometry of a hologram. In the series of figures 9–12 we start with a side view of four real objects at different heights above the floor. Then, when we look from the top view at a hologram of these objects, the positions of the objects move across the background as we tilt our perspective. This is parallax. The images of the objects in figures 10–12 <em>appear </em>3-dimensional, even though the film encoding the image is a flat piece of film. Note that you can also see the interference pattern on the film in the background, but your brain essentially ignores this information.</p><blockquote>“As we tilt the film with our hand, although the interference pattern on the film tilts with our hand, the objects move relative to the interference pattern on the film.”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/745/1*NNeaiGOppPmKo5ghr57Sxw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9VGvLclkC9oahwrBqpT2kw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 9: Four point objects at varying heights above a holographic film, to be imaged in a hologram, viewed here from the side.<br>Figure 10: Reconstructing the hologram from fig. 9. Viewing the holographic film from above, the geometric objects appear in front of the film</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QKjQFE43lAnN7V3jJ2vLmw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xfPKnJjcSxXDmypCfDmXOQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 11:</strong> Viewing from a vantage point partway to the right, we see that the interference pattern stays with the film, yet the geometric objects appear to move, giving the illusion of parallax. <strong>Figure 12:</strong> View from further right. The geometric objects continue to move as if they are totally independent of the film</figcaption></figure><p>The first “space” describes the coordinates where the different geometric objects appear. But as we tilt the film with our hand, although the interference pattern on the film tilts with our hand, the objects move relative to the interference pattern on the film! The interference pattern on the film is described by a <em>separate </em>set of numbers. They do not correspond to the image of the city, but to the physical piece of film. We’ll call them “parameters.” In the ripples on the lake in fig. 2, the parameters describe the interference pattern of ripples, while the coordinates describe where the water droplets have hit the surface, which is encoded into the ripples.</p><h4><em>Space and time in a holographic world</em></h4><p>Just as there are distinct parameters and coordinates representing space in a hologram, in a holographic universe, there are two unique descriptions of both space <em>and </em>time.</p><p>The first kind of space and time has to do with actual things that take place, the locations and times at which interactions happen. This is the space and time you are familiar with, for instance the location of a particular building in the city. When you say “I bumped into my colleague in the hallway at lunch,” you are describing the place and time of a specific or <em>discrete </em>event, at coordinates (<em>x, y, z,t</em>).</p><p>The second form of space and time, analogous to the patterns on the holographic film, is less familiar. Just as our brain ignores the interference pattern behind a hologram, the interference patterns in spacetime are not measurable. These “parameters” help us convert into frequency-space and back, but they can never be directly measured. Hence, the 4D waveform I introduced earlier doesn’t actually look like the things it describes, just as the interference pattern on the holographic film doesn’t look anything like the city it encodes.</p><blockquote>“Your physical reality is not continuously ‘delivered’ to your inbox. Rather, it only downloads when you log in.”</blockquote><p>So let’s return to the coordinates, which you normally think of as space and time. A subtle point jumps out at us here, the most important point in our quest to understand how <em>choice </em>works in a holographic world. Coordinates only have actual values for actual events you experience. Like rungs of a ladder or fenceposts in a wire fence, the coordinates don’t vary smoothly. Each experience is a discrete interaction or perception, capturing the world in a certain state. For instance, you check your email to discover that you got the contract you were hoping for, but this entire situation takes shape at the moment you read the email. Only the interaction between you and your inbox is real. The history leading up to you checking your email–the time period during which the mail was delivered–is not captured anywhere within the holographic data.</p><p>In this sense, reality works more like a “get” email system, in which your email inbox only loads emails when you login, rather than downloading them behind the scenes. Your physical reality is not continuously “delivered” to your inbox. Rather, it only downloads when you log in. At that time, however, you get all your emails <em>as if </em>they were delivered smoothly over time. Each email has a datestamp corresponding to when it was (supposedly) sent.</p><p>The real world moves in jumps and starts, becoming actualized only when you check on it. But when you do, life appears to have been happening continuously all along.</p><p><strong>The illusion of continuity</strong></p><p>The coordinates at which an actual thing happens–the time at which you check your email and the specific email you find waiting for you–is an event <em>encoded </em>into the interference pattern of 4D frequency-space. Even the time-stamp when it was supposedly sent is part of the data you download, but this is all for show. It <em>becomes </em>that only when you check. The time-stamp on that email means you <em>infer </em>that it was sent some time earlier. You have the illusion that things were happening all along even though you are only really sure of what happens when you check.</p><blockquote>“Much like the infant who has not yet developed “object permanence,” the physical objects we observe everyday are an illusion in the sense that they do not persist. They only take on a definite form when we interact with them.”</blockquote><p>Note, too, that <em>in a typical hologram there is nothing actually present at the location where the image appears to be. </em>The image is an illusion which appears to float above or below the film, even though the data exists on the film’s surface. In an analogous sense, a holographic world would be driven by the underlying holographic interference patterns in frequency-space. The facts of daily life–whether or not a certain email comes to your inbox, whether or not your flight gets cancelled, whether or not the roulette wheel lands on black or red–are not the <em>fundamental </em>reality. Rather, the complicated interference patterns which encode these facts are fundamental. Much like the infant who has not yet developed “object permanence,” the physical objects we observe everyday are an illusion in the sense that they do not persist. They only take on a definite form when we interact with them.</p><p>To clarify why this point would matter to your process of choosing, imagine you were expecting to receive an email around 12pm with an important decision affecting your life, say a job offer at a technology company. Yet you don’t check your email until 6pm. Could it be that the holographic world waits to see whether you are <em>ready </em>for the job? Could the outcome depend on the level of commitment and preparation you have demonstrated?</p><blockquote>“The causal chain only becomes determined when you check your email at 6pm, at which time any one of a number of possible causal chains can fall into place.”</blockquote><p>Let’s say, then, that at 3pm you choose to educate yourself more about the company and train yourself further in the relevant technology. Could your choice influence the decision communicated in that 12pm email? Even though you will only <em>later </em>find out that the decision was made at noon, it is not until 6pm that their decision becomes real for you, at the moment when you check your email. We conclude that selecting one outcome over another <em>after the fact </em>is perfectly consistent with causality. In a hologram-like virtual world there could exist what Carl Jung would call “an acausal connecting principle”, in which the action at 3pm influences the outcome of a decision made at noon, without violating causality. The causal chain only becomes determined when you check your email at 6pm, at which time any one of a number of possible causal chains can fall into place.</p><p>The choices you make can impact even those events you may assume have already happened.</p><h3>Choice and Timelessness</h3><p>I have described a very specific sense in which the world is timeless, and this begs a question about choice and destiny. Like the navigation system on your GPS describes your whole journey at once, the interference patterns in frequency-space encode all of history at once. And like a fully Fourier transformed music file (not the “hack” used on the mp3 file), the interference patterns in frequency-space have a spectrum which is not described by time <em>yet still encodes how something changes in time</em>.</p><p>Consider what this means for light travelling from Sun to Earth. The trip takes 8 minutes. Yet that entire path of travel is encoded all at once. 4D frequency-space is like a map which shows the whole route. The end point, e.g. landing on Earth, is part of the whole map, and the light can’t even leave the Sun without a map which describes its journey to Earth. But then, does it have a choice? Is it destined to reach the Earth rather than the Moon or Mars? What if a satellite intercepts it before hitting Earth?</p><p>It seems evident that there must be a plenitude of maps describing the path light could travel, each one describing a unique end point and allowing for all the available choices. Frequency-space describes the object’s potential journey over a whole range of times, without any preference for “Now”. Thus the word “timelessness” is an apt description.</p><p>Instead of travelling light waves, now consider the motion of a car along the road. Can it be represented in frequency-space? Since frequency-space doesn’t change in time, it cannot tell us “exactly where the car is at any given moment.” If it did, then the interference pattern would have to update itself moment by moment as the car drove down the road, like the frames of a movie. But we already established that frequency-space cannot change in time. (If you haven’t convinced yourself of that point yet, it’s worth taking a few moments to do so.) Rather, <em>the car’s path of travel through space and time is defined not moment-by-moment, but as-a-whole, over its entire path. </em>As with light from the Sun, frequency-space describes the car over a whole range of times without any preference for “Now”.</p><blockquote><em>“When you make choices in the holographic world, all of the possible consequences of your choice exist as possibilities encoded into the hologram.”</em></blockquote><p>To better understand what this implies about the nature of choice, consider the following analogy. You take a new job for an autonomous vehicles company, and must commute to work in a self-driving company car. You look up the directions before you leave the house and program them into the GPS. Up pops a map of your route, and as the vehicle pulls out of the driveway you kick back to enjoy your ride to work.</p><p>When the next morning comes, you hop in, load the same map, and hit “go”. But on the way you notice your favorite coffee shop on a side street! You attempt to turn the wheel or reprogram the GPS, but the system requires a preset route and won’t let you change course. The autonomous vehicle is heading to work because the path is defined as-a-whole from the moment you left the house.</p><p>You solve this dilemma the next morning by including the coffee shop in your route plan, and programming this route into your autonomous vehicle’s GPS before you leave the house. Now you have a second map loaded in the system, and both maps are available to you when it comes time to choose between them.</p><p>In this same way, the entire journey of something in space is defined as-a-whole in the holographic world. You might think you are making a spontaneous decision to get coffee in that moment, but you are actually choosing between all the various timelines that have “stopping for coffee” as part of them. The subtle difference is this: <em>when you make choices in the holographic world, all of the possible consequences of your choice exist as possibilities encoded into the hologram.</em></p><p>We have come back to “choice.” The photon is not destined to hit Earth–and you are not destined to get to work–because there are so many maps to choose between. Whether you get there or somewhere else depends on <em>choice</em>.</p><p><strong>The fence-post reality</strong></p><p>Let’s return to an earlier question, “When is <em>Now</em>?” Remember, unlike the usual 3D wavefunction, 4D frequency-space can’t change in time. It is timeless. In a holographic reality, the sense of “Now” is only related to you and your interactions with the world.</p><p>In between interactions, when you are absent, everyday objects don’t take definite form. The paths of objects are determined by holographic information in frequency-space, but travel itself is an illusion. An object does not have an “actual history,” only the history that falls into place at the moment you interact with it. Let’s call this “retroactive event determination,” a phrase that captures the idea that you are not changing the past from what it already was, but rather selecting from various possibilities which <em>might have been</em>.</p><p>Therefore, when you make choices and interact with the world, you are not interacting with a fixed, set-in-stone environment. The world is flexible. What “has already happened” is not yet decided, because the time period in between the last interaction and this one is unknowable. The certainty of life events is delayed until you make a choice. You would not be surprised to find this behavior as part of a flight simulator or virtual-reality training program.</p><blockquote>“The paths of objects are determined by holographic information in frequency-space, but travel itself is an illusion. An object does not have an ‘actual history,’ only the history that falls into place at the moment you interact with it.”</blockquote><p>In a holographic world, reality is like a fence. Your interactions with things are like the fence-posts that we can call real. In between the fence-posts are just wires of imagination, linked chains of possibility, in which options are developing but nothing is certain. The hologram contains embedded in it all the posts of the fence, and in fact all the available fences. It is your particular view of the hologram that provides you the specific experiences that you call real life. You have navigated to this view via the choices you made to get here, a “choose your own adventure” novel. (As touched upon earlier, it is not yet clear what is meant by “taking a view,” since we haven’t defined what a “viewer” is, or what the holographic interference pattern is “made of” in relation to the viewer.)</p><p>Note that timelessness doesn’t exactly mean that one can <em>change </em>the past. Rather, so long as the past circumstance you want to change lies along the gaps in the fence, then it doesn’t actually have a form yet. What would it mean to “change” it? Rather, it becomes “retroactively determined”, or falls into place after the fact.</p><blockquote>“A holographic world allows the paths of objects to fall into place based upon the choice of action you make at the end of the journey.”</blockquote><p>Consider again the analogy of language. Associate the phrase “The old train…” with the wire in between the fence posts. This is the undetermined past. Why is it undetermined? It is not yet clear what the meaning of “train” is. The “fence post” at the end of the sentence should make this clear. Let’s say the end of the sentence is “…left the station”, which makes it clear what the meaning of the whole sentence is. However, a different end of the sentence could be “..the young”, changing the meaning of the sentence to a statement about education rather than railroads. Did you <em>change </em>the past? No. It existed in a superposition of possibilities until the final words were uttered.</p><p>This example of retroactive determination of meaning is called local ambiguity. It is an apt analogy for the way in which a holographic world allows the paths of objects to fall into place based upon the choice of action you make at the end of the journey.</p><h3>3. Testability</h3><p>The conjecture that the world is like a hologram is testable. If the only things we can call “real” are the fence-posts or rungs of the ladder, then our world cannot be both objective and certain. For instance, I claim that the hiring decision conveyed in an email, time-stamped at 12pm, only became part of <em>my </em>fencepost reality at 6pm. At this time the decision became a <em>fact </em>for me, and before that the email message lived in uncertainty, along with the author of the email! There must be some sense in which the author of the email is either not objective or not certain, because the contents of the email they already wrote is, from my point of view, still flexible. Since we experience certainty in our reality everyday–you either did or did not drink coffee today–the certainty we experience must be subjective. Yet so long as there is consistency between my view of the world and yours, it will appear objective enough for us not to notice.</p><blockquote>“The mathematics of quantum mechanics in its most pure form points to an ever-expanding tree of possible realities, rather than one actual reality.”</blockquote><p>(Note that although we are using applying the “superposition principle” from quantum mechanics on systems that are not generally understood as quantum mechanical (like emails and people), it is crucial to understand that this principle was derived here from the properties of space, time, light and signal processing, not via the usual Hilbert space postulates. Hence there is no reason to limit the application to the usual microscopic systems. This is something addressed in detail in the research.)</p><p>In quantum mechanics, there is a testable difference between subjective and objective events. We’ll call the subjective description “relative reality”. That the world is described in this relative manner is a proposal put forward originally by Everett with the Many Worlds hypothesis, then by Wigner with the Wigner’s Friend thought experiment, and more recently by Rovelli and others with Relational Quantum Mechanics.</p><p>Far from being far-fetched, this approach is the Occam’s Razor–or simplest–way to think about quantum mechanics. As humans, we want to think that the world we experience is concrete. Yet the mathematics of quantum mechanics in its most pure form points to an ever-expanding tree of possible realities, rather than one actual reality. In the “relative reality” model, what we call an “actual” reality is only <em>relatively </em>true. Although it’s taken many decades for this view to gain traction given the challenges it poses to our concrete sense of reality, over time it is one of only a handful of basic approaches that has survived.</p><p>This approach has become more popular as more experimental results have been obtained. Specifically, experiments with entanglement and the violation of Bell’s inequalities have made this “relative reality” model more appealing to mainstream physicists. Three important cutting edge papers grounded in experiment are:</p><ul><li>“Quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself” [9]</li><li>“Experimental rejection of observer-independence in the quantum world” [10]</li><li>“Testing the reality of Wigner’s friend’s experience” [11]</li></ul><p>Due to the subtlety of the issues involved, it would be premature to suggest that the evidence proves the relative-reality view. Yet these experimental results, and to my knowledge all others that have been produced, are consistent with this view.</p><p>A formidable challenge in achieving consensus on the issue of interpreting quantum mechanics has been our own human bias toward the existence of an objective reality which has a definite form even when we are absent. With the emergence of more nuanced experimental techniques, I suspect we will gradually gain further confidence in our quest to verify these results in a non-ambiguous way.</p><p>However, given that the relative-reality model is not dependent on the holographic universe model, even non-ambiguous proof of the subjective nature of experience wouldn’t prove the veracity of the holographic model. Still, the holographic model explicitly requires these results, so the existing experiments provide a boost to the credibility of what is otherwise quite a difficult proposal to believe.</p><h3>4. What to do with this information?</h3><p>Though modeling the world as a hologram may seem like an abstract undertaking, it may have great relevance for our everyday experience. Too common today is the worldview that we must simply react to a world which is already unfolding. Life becomes about coping with change after it occurs, believing that “things are as they are.”</p><blockquote>“In a holographic world, there are latent possibilities hidden in every choice.”</blockquote><p>Business leader Joseph Jaworski writes,</p><blockquote>“If individuals and organizations operate from the generative orientation, from possibility rather than resignation, we can create the future into which we are living, as opposed to merely reacting to it when we get there… Leadership is about creating, day by day, a domain in which we and those around us continually deepen our understanding of reality and are able to participate in shaping the future.”[12, p.182–184]</blockquote><p>If we live in a holographic world, what we think of as the “real world out there” may actually not yet be certain. The circumstances yet to unfold can do so in a wide variety of ways, and they may depend on our choices. The past is less constrained than we might think, waiting for us to make choices before the responses are determined. In a holographic world, there are latent possibilities hidden in every choice.</p><blockquote>“A world which responds to our choices by bringing the appropriate next learning experience is a world that is sympathetic to each of our specific challenges as evolving human beings.”</blockquote><p>In this model, the metaphor of a school comes to mind, in which each lesson is appropriate to the level of development of the student. This provides a sense as to why the flow state of Csikszentmihalyi is so effective: we experience flow when we are treating life like a challenge designed just for us, at the perfect balance of challenge and skill.[13]</p><p>Living inside a hologram is a shift from resignation to flow. It involves increased focus on what we need to do to get to the next level of challenge, and decreased focus on losing or winning. A world which responds to our choices by bringing the appropriate next learning experience is a world that is sympathetic to each of our specific challenges as evolving human beings. Yet even more amazing, it is a world which is waiting for us to be ready before moving to the next level. What do we, humanity, need to learn in order to get to our next level?</p><h3>5. Acknowledgements</h3><p>This research was undertaken through Theiss Research, 7411 Eads Ave., La Jolla, CA 92037–5037, USA, and supported by the Foundational Questions Institute (fqxi.org; grant no. FQXi-1801) via funding from the Federico and Elvia Faggin Foundation.</p><h3>Appendix</h3><h3>Glossary of terms</h3><ul><li>Fourier transform: A mathematical procedure used to convert between frequency-space and regular spacetime. Forms the basis of holography.</li><li>Hologram: A 3-dimensional looking image produced with a special photographic procedure.</li><li>Spectrum: The vibrational frequencies present in a signal.</li><li>Wavefunction: A mathematical object that encodes everything we can know about a system; an object is no more and no less than the properties predicted by its wavefunction.</li><li>Wave distribution: The natural extension presented here of the wavefunction into 4 dimensions of space and time.</li><li>Implicate order: David Bohm’s idea that there is a hidden world enfolded into our visible spacetime.</li><li>Coordinates: Numbers describing the location of interactions.</li><li>Parameters: Numbers describing the locations of pixels on an interference pattern on a holographic film.</li><li>Spacetime: The world we are familiar with of length, breadth, width, and duration.</li><li>Frequency-Space or Frequency Domain: A complimentary and equivalent version of our normal spacetime reality.</li><li>Collapse of the wavefunction: A poorly understood process by which an object apparently changes from many possibilities into one remaining possibility.</li></ul><h3>References</h3><p>[] S. Nelson-Isaacs, A holographic framework for quantum wavefunction propagation (2020)<br>[1] D. Bohm, Wholeness and the Implicate Order (Routledge, 1980)<br>[2] M. Talbot, The Holographic Universe (Harper-Collins Publishers)<br>[3] G. ’t Hooft, (1993). URL https://arxiv:org/abs/gr-qc/9310026<br>[4] L. Susskind, Journal of Mathematical Physics36(11), 6377 (1995). DOI 10:1063/1:531249. URL <a href="https://doi:org/10:1063/1:531249">https://doi:org/10:1063/1:531249</a></p><p>[5] N.G. Bourbakis, A.T. Gumahad, in Proceedings of the 2nd International IEEE Conference on Tools for Artificial Intelligence (1990), pp. 571–576<br>[6] L. Gelman, S. Braun, Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing<br>[7] K. Pribram, Knowledge based text character recognition using Fourier transform (1991)<br>[8] J. Leon. Carl jung’s psychology of dreams and his view on freud. URL http:<br>//psychopathology:imedpub:com/carl-jungs-psychology-of-dreams-and-his-<br>view-on-freud:php?aid=9795<br>[9] D. Frauchiger, R. Renner, Nat Commun 9, 3711(2018)<br>[10] M. Proietti, A. Pickston, F. Graffitti, P. Barrow, D. Kundys, C. Branciard, M. Ringbauer, A. Fedrizzi, (2019)<br>[11] K.W. Bong, A. Utreras-Alarc´on, F. Ghafari, Y.C. Liang, N. Tischler, E.G. Cavalcanti, G.J. Pryde, H.M. Wiseman, (2019). URL https://arxiv:org/abs/1907:05607<br>[12] J. Jaworski, Synchronicity: The Inner Path of Leadership (Berrett-Koehler, 2011)<br>[13] M. Csikszentmihalyi, Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience (Harper Row, 1990)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5697ea8c153c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Staying in flow by pedaling the bicycle]]></title>
            <link>https://skynelson.medium.com/staying-in-flow-by-pedaling-the-bicycle-d4f71c22223?source=rss-73dcc8fa0e9e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d4f71c22223</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[living-in-the-present]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[free-will]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[synchronicity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[flow]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sky Nelson-Isaacs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Dec 2019 18:56:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-03T18:56:01.613Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Sky Nelson-Isaacs, 4 min read</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OyGl3EqNMmgo5mBlEaulRQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://www.pexels.com/@leonardo-vazquez-1427877?utm_content=attributionCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=pexels">LEONARDO VAZQUEZ </a>from <a href="https://www.pexels.com/photo/photo-of-person-riding-road-bike-2807963/?utm_content=attributionCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=pexels">Pexels</a></figcaption></figure><p>Do you find yourself waiting around for that one email?</p><p>Do you place your goals on hold because someone else hasn’t gotten back to you?</p><p>This can be a clue that you are not in flow, and there are easy ways to get back in the zone.</p><h3>A complete focusing of attention</h3><p>Flow is a state of <a href="http://www.dailygood.org/story/2287/searching-for-meaning-purpose-and-patterns-sky-nelson-isaacs/">optimal easefulness with the tasks of life</a>. According to <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Flow-Psychology-Experience-Perennial-Classics/dp/0061339202">Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi</a>, flow requires “a complete focusing of attention on the task at hand.” He says that one reason flow facilitates happiness is that “the clearly structured demands of the activity impose order, and exclude the interference of disorder in consciousness.”</p><p>I think of it as “pedaling the bicycle”. Rather than worrying about how close I am to my goal, or how far I have come from my start, my job is to keep pushing the pedals forward. In this mode, I lose track of whether I am happy or not. I forget about the markers of “success”, like “Did my manager like my report?” or “Did I get the promotion?” There is only commitment to my next steps along the path.</p><p>One way I know I am <em>out of flow </em>is when I am worried about outcomes. If I find myself needing to check my email or social media to check whether I’ve received positive news, I know that I am not in flow.</p><h3>Don’t look back</h3><p>If you are in a bike race, it’s pretty hard to pedal when you are turned around looking at who is behind you. Glancing behind to see how big your lead is can cost you critical concentration. Likewise, in pursuit of your goals, the circumstances of life respond to your input. The more effort you invest of yourself, the more opportunities will emerge.</p><p>Being out of flow can indicate that you are doubting yourself. If you are pursuing a positive response from someone, then you may not be confident in your own position. Have you elevated your own need for validation over being of service to the situation? Victor Frankl wrote “Success, like happiness, cannot be pursued; it must ensue…as the unintended side-effect of one’s personal dedication to a course greater than oneself.”</p><p>To maintain positive synchronicities in your life, don’t take your feet off the pedals to look back and see how far you’ve come, or see how far you have to go. In flow, the positive response comes unbidden when you least expect it as a result of your commitment to the result.</p><h3>Practice riding the bike</h3><p>To see what this feels like in your own life, try these steps.</p><ol><li><strong>Write down an opportunity that excites you. </strong>This could be an experience with a friend, a chance to improve your standing at work, or anything else that you would like to see happen.</li><li><strong>List the things you’ve done already to take advantage of the opportunity, either directly or indirectly. </strong>If the goal is to make better friends with a particular individual at work, the next time you need help with something, ask someone that you don’t know. Reaching out to new people (in general) is meaningfully aligned with the goal of making a friend (with this specific person).</li><li><strong>Now write down the next milestone for this opportunity. </strong>Is there a company picnic coming up at which you will spend social time with your colleagues? Is there a team meeting when you are going to need this individual to support your work?</li><li><strong>Identify anything else you can do which is meaningfully aligned with your desired outcome. Keep pedaling the bicycle.</strong></li></ol><p>Keep tracking the milestone, but don’t let it distract you. Stay focused on creative ways to commit to your goal without constantly checking whether you’ve been successful. See how long you can endure in the state of unknown!</p><p>Here’s the key: By continuing to pedal the bike, you <a href="https://youtu.be/J2mPmv0mhXk">build momentum on a tree of possibilities</a>, and the probability increases for an opportunity to drop in your lap. It may not look as you expected. In speaking to new people in the office, maybe <em>you develop a different friendship instead of the one you expected. </em>Then, a month later, the person you originally wanted to be friends with leaves the company anyway. Turns out, this is the friendship that you were “destined” for.</p><h3>Befriending the unknown</h3><p>Living in flow is about befriending the unknown.</p><p>By tolerating the feeling of uncertainty and staying committed to the inner experience you want to have, you stay in flow and increase your momentum towards your desired experiences, leading to a steady stream of synchronicities which support your effort. Just keep riding the bike.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.uthrivehere.com/livinginflow">Living in Flow Course</a> provides further practices for integrating these insights into your daily grind.</p><p>Keep tracking the milestone, but don’t let it distract you. Stay focused on creative ways to commit to your goal without constantly checking whether you’ve been successful. See how long you can endure in the state of unknown!</p><p>Here’s the key: By continuing to pedal the bike, you <a href="https://youtu.be/J2mPmv0mhXk">build momentum on a tree of possibilities</a>, and the probability increases for an opportunity to drop in your lap. It may not look as you expected. In speaking to new people in the office, maybe <em>you discover an unexpected positive connection that turns into the very friendship you were seeking in the first place.</em></p><h3>Befriending the unknown</h3><p>Living in flow is about befriending the unknown.</p><p>By tolerating the feeling of uncertainty and staying committed to the inner experience you want to have, you stay in flow and increase your momentum towards your desired experiences, leading to a steady stream of synchronicities which support your effort. Just keep riding the bike.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.uthrivehere.com/livinginflow">Living in Flow Course</a> provides further practices for integrating these insights into your daily grind.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d4f71c22223" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>