<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Alex M H Smith on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Alex M H Smith on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@smithesq?source=rss-191b6f15263e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 18:56:08 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@smithesq/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Remapping the world: the rise of horizontal loyalty]]></title>
            <link>https://smithesq.medium.com/remapping-the-world-the-rise-of-horizontal-loyalty-f8be61fb6698?source=rss-191b6f15263e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f8be61fb6698</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[geography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trends]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[class]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex M H Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Jun 2022 13:36:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-22T13:36:19.311Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*w2dTHFnTW26V7ZQCkCUPwA.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s time for another macro-trend piece.</p><p>As long time readers will know by now, these are my crude attempts to sketch some of the more subtle forces shaping the world around us. As strategy is all about adaptation to context, it follows that we must understand our context to think strategically — and that’s what these pieces are all about.</p><p><em>(Mostly however it’s a bit of fun and a chance for me to talk about something other than brands for a change)</em></p><p>The last two topics were <a href="https://mailchi.mp/dd9af7538fb4/the-problem-with-strategic-models-6462286">concentration</a> and <a href="https://us16.campaign-archive.com/?u=dbfcfcd097fd0818275a2b8b8&amp;id=da1736ac52">hyper normal stimulus</a>. If you’ve not read them then check them out. But otherwise let’s move onto today’s matter:</p><p><strong>The rise of horizontal loyalty.</strong></p><p>What is this?</p><p>Well first let’s think about loyalty. Mutual loyalty between a group of people is probably the central force that determines the shape of a society. Indeed we could probably define society just like that: <em>a group of people loyal to each other</em>. For the most part this is what defines national boundaries. Within X boundary there’s a group of people loyal to each other, and within Y boundary there’s another group of people loyal to each other. Naturally when the boundaries don’t neatly match the loyalties within them, that’s when conflict arises.</p><p>Where do these loyalties come from? Well, that of course varies. They may be religious, cultural, ethnic, or simply the reflection of a shared history and a shared land. Forest people do things the forest way; plains people do things the plains way. It doesn’t really matter: what matters is simply that such loyalties exist, and that they are <em>particular</em>.</p><p>Nobody — <em>nobody</em> — is loyal to everyone. Nobody takes a genuinely “one word” perspective, despite the plentiful rhetoric to the contrary. We all have “our people”, and therefore by definition we also have “not our people”. This is only human, only natural, and there’s nothing wrong with it per se; it doesn’t necessarily imply animosity. Our loyalties simply give us a shortcut with which to smoothly engage with others, without having to establish trust from a base of zero with every new person we meet.</p><p>And on top of this, they also give us a sense of home and belonging.</p><p>Now, as suggested above, human loyalties have traditionally been <em>place-based</em>. They exist primarily between people who are from / live in a certain location. Often they are multi-scale; strongest at the immediate local level, and then getting weaker the wider you draw the circle around it. For our purposes here however, we’ll talk about them in terms of nations, simply because that’s a simple unit of “place” to discuss.</p><p><strong>This “place-based kinship” is vertical loyalty.</strong></p><p>The reason it’s “vertical” is because while it’s pinpointed in one spot, it also moves “up and down” the social spectrum. In other words it binds people of different classes together, provided they have that place in common. A Lord and his butler, although miles apart in “rank” may still feel a sense of brotherhood due to being from England, say.</p><p>This diagram illustrates what I mean:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2k2Cu8VUx3zbxNc0.jpeg" /></figure><p>Vertical loyalty is the oldest and most common form of loyalty in the world. It’s the loyalty which, like I said, created the nation state, and with it pretty much all legal, economic, and social systems we live by.</p><p><strong>So what’s horizontal loyalty?</strong></p><p>Well, at various points throughout history vertical loyalty has faced a challenge. A typical example of this challenge can be found in the various communist revolutions of the 20th century. These revolutions drew their lines of loyalty not from <em>place</em>, but from <em>class</em>. “Workers of the world unite” is clearly a statement untethered from geography. It says it doesn’t matter where you’re from, it just matters what class you are; that a worker from Peru should feel more loyalty to a worker from China than they do to their middle class neighbour down the street.</p><p>That’s horizontal loyalty, and on our diagram it looks something like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*LpH_AK5d9bMD54me.jpeg" /></figure><p>Now as both this image and history have shown us, the dilemma with horizontal loyalty is that it can be quite bloody. That’s because it results in people living side by side with others who have <em>conflicting loyalties</em>. Under conditions of vertical loyalty, this doesn’t really happen; you’re basically pals with everyone you’re likely to come into contact with. But when horizontal loyalty is at play, that’s no longer true. Your neighbour could be operating to a completely different set of values from you.</p><p>As a result horizontal loyalty is pretty unstable — and this instability probably contributed to the eventual collapse of the USSR’s horizontal model towards the end of the century.</p><p>Vertical loyalty went toe to toe with its challenger, and triumphed.</p><p>But that wasn’t the end of the story. There was another revolution just around the corner. One ultimately far more powerful than anything Marx envisaged: the internet.</p><p>As we discussed in the concentration piece, the internet’s central feature is the <em>removal of boundaries</em>, and the <em>dissolution of place</em>. Naturally then we might expect this to have a corrosive effect on vertical loyalty, and so it has proved, but in a way that the revolutionaries of the 20th century perhaps wouldn’t have expected.</p><p>Instead of their vision of “workers of the world unite”, what we are now seeing could be better described as “elites of the world unite”; a pretty ironic reversal of fate.</p><p>In essence what we see today is a high degree of horizontal loyalty not at the bottom of society, but at the top: where the values, opinions, and concerns of the global upper classes (which I think would include everyone I’m talking to here) have begun to converge, often in ways that decouple them from their vertical place.</p><p>Here’s the diagram:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OMZ6PA25Fu1JZLPg.jpeg" /></figure><p>How this happened isn’t exactly rocket science. Those at the top of the socio-economic ladder have the most access to the boundary-dissolving technologies of the the connected world. This means they have greater means of finding each other than the rest of the world. Couple this with the homogenising power of big tech algorithms and you have a recipe for unification and consensus across geographic lines.</p><p>There are naturally thousands of examples of this. A pretty obvious and benign one can be found with TV. Whilst the global lower classes (speaking broadly) continue to consume locally specific programming, the globally connected class are now coalescing around “horizontal TV stations” such as Netflix. You and I probably consume pretty much the same cultural diet even if I live in England and you live in Brazil. However this may not be the same diet as our neighbours down the street.</p><p>Less benignly of course none of us can fail to notice the political fallout of this division. “Populism” we might say is basically a word used by the horizontally integrated to describe the priorities of vertically integrated; whilst “conspiracy theories” are how the vertically integrated interpret the priorities of the horizontal.</p><p>We might even say that “political polarisation” isn’t really a policy conflict at all; it’s instead a conflict between the models of vertical and horizontal integration, just like the Cold War (with which of course it shares many dynamic characteristics).</p><p>Anyway, plenty has been written about all that stuff, and it’s not my remit to get into it here. What’s more interesting I think is following the thread of horizontal integration a little bit further, to see where it may lead.</p><p>If we accept the idea that the internet encourages horizontal loyalties rather than vertical, then it stands to reason that as it continues its march across the globe more of these kinds of loyalties will emerge.</p><p>This isn’t a game that only the so-called “metropolitan elite” can play — everyone can. Provided they have the technology of course, which increasingly they do.</p><p>This may lead to a future looking something like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*TUFmcwsaP5LTXe9e.jpeg" /></figure><p>Understand of course that the reality would be far more complex than simply the binding of the upper / middle / lower class. I use these terms only to illustrate the principle. Horizontal loyalties <em>could</em> organise like this, sure. But they could also organise along the lines of religion, political persuasion, cultural preferences, ethnic background, who knows.</p><p>However it happens, the key thing is people will no longer get their sense of belonging in <em>place</em> but in something untethered from place.</p><p>What would this mean? Well, who bloody knows, but clearly a hell of a lot.</p><p>For a trivial business thought, we may need to start thinking differently about what constitutes a “market”. At the moment we draw these via geographical boundaries. But will that be the right way of thinking in the future? When you launch a business, will you be launching it to a “vertical loyalty bubble” like the UK, or France, or India? Or will you be launching it to a “horizontal loyalty bubble” of like minded people spread around the world?</p><p>Even today I think it’s worth considering whether your company operates within horizontal or vertical loyalties — but in the future this question may well be standard.</p><p>Less trivially we will of course have to contend with the same dilemma as the past revolution: the local intermingling of conflicting loyalties.</p><p>Indeed many people may even come to question the very legitimacy of structures which are organised vertically in the first place. If you see your identity as being unrelated to the land under your feet, then where does the authority of that land’s legal, economic, and social system come from?</p><p>In the past it came from the consensus of a mutually loyal local populous. But if such a thing ceases to exist, then what then?</p><p>But anyway, this is all just sci-fi speculation. The result, as always, will be something far less crisp than such theorising suggests; but it’s intriguing to think about nonetheless.</p><p>My purpose with this piece was simply to introduce you to the vertical / horizontal lens of looking at the world, and hopefully I’ve done that.</p><p>I hope you find it somewhat useful — and not too scary.</p><p>__</p><p>This comes from my email newsletter The Way, teaching strategic thinking to founders. To sign up, and get access to the free course, click here: <a href="https://basicarts.org/newsletter/">https://basicarts.org/newsletter/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f8be61fb6698" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Armani, aspiration, and the decline of luxury]]></title>
            <link>https://smithesq.medium.com/armani-aspiration-and-the-decline-of-luxury-9e01aa6d3668?source=rss-191b6f15263e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9e01aa6d3668</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[luxury]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[branding]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex M H Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 20 Jan 2022 15:15:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-20T15:15:28.277Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*DLtTtMiAA41f_0g4om0LiQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>If we’re reductive about it, we might say there are really only two strategic levers a business can pull from a consumer perspective:</p><ul><li>Utilitarian</li><li>Brand led</li></ul><p>When it comes to delivering value, these are basically the paths to do it. Utilitarian companies offer a genuinely useful and unique “function” — for instance the supermarket Lidl, and its low prices. Meanwhile brand led companies make up for their lack of differentiated function with a brand image people want to be associated with, or buy into — e.g. Nike, and their powerful cultural innovation we explored <a href="https://basicarts.org/nike-and-the-concept-of-cultural-innovation/">here</a>.</p><p>This isn’t to say that founders should pick one or the other. The greatest brands do both simultaneously; using utilitarian difference to support a branded proposition (Steve Jobs era Apple is a perfect example of a 50/50 split between these two directions, hence why it is so revered). Typically however the balance will be skewed in one direction or another. Whilst I would never suggest that Lidl has no brand power, I think it’s fairly safe to assume that if its brand was totally different, but its prices were the same, it wouldn’t suffer much damage.</p><p>Now whilst utilitarian offerings are easy to understand — the company does a job which solves a particular issue — branded ones are a bit more subtle. To the cynic, they are exercises in selling people essentially “nothing”. Just a chimera, wrapped around a generic overpriced item or service. However, as I think we all know here, there is “real value” in brand. It does indeed have the capacity to give people something they are looking for — just as much as more tangible offerings like “low prices” or “fast delivery”. And, if we were to pick a word which summarises that value, we would probably alight here:</p><p><strong>Aspiration</strong>.</p><p>Yes, that old chestnut. What brand on the planet doesn’t want to be seen as “aspirational”? Paradoxically even the low priced ones are at it (other than perhaps Ryan Air, whose anti-aspiration stance is what makes them so damn cool).</p><p>So universal is this desire in fact that it has become cliche. I’ve always said that a good test of whether a goal is worth stating is if the <em>opposite</em> would be equally plausible — a test which “aspirational” clearly doesn’t pass.</p><p>However, as with many cliches, just because everyone agrees on it does’t mean that everyone understands it. To create something with an “aspirational” quality is actually quite tricky. It is tempting to view the characteristic as being analogous with “premium” — whereby each category might have its “aspirational option”, that being the more more expensive and high quality one. However in reality the dynamics of aspiration are far more subtle than that — as evidenced by a recent phenomenon we might call “luxury erosion”.</p><p>Luxury erosion — a term I just made up, but it will do — is the process by which various premium and luxury brands have gradually drifted from aspirational to “anti-aspirational” over the course of the past decade or two. For a basic example, think of the brand Armani. Undoubtedly this is a luxury “aspirational” brand, and yet it some respects it has come to represent something of the opposite, at least in the hyper-developed West. If you see a person walking down the street wearing a t-shirt with a big Armani logo emblazoned on the front, you will, I suggest, not be liable to look up to them so much as to look down on them. Such a display has come to be seen as a bit gauche, a bit declassé. In a different manner the same fate has befallen the iconic luxury car trio: Mercedes, BMW, and Audi. Again these brands were once seen as archetypal symbols of aspiration and success, and yet now that sense has faded. For many they are now gently derided as “rep mobiles” — or in the case of Mercedes in particular, “taxis” (given how regularly that brand is now used for that purpose). This isn’t to say that these brands aren’t still desired in various ways; just that they have lost a lot of the caché they enjoyed in the 90s.</p><p>Wherever you look, you can see various iconic luxury brands suffering the same fate — losing their allure and becoming if not anti-aspirational then at the very least ordinary.</p><p>How can we explain this drift? And moreover, how can we decipher aspiration in a manner which allows us to harness its effects for our own brand?</p><p>To do this there is one very simple principle I think we should cleave to:</p><p><strong>As material comfort increases, and societies become more “developed”, aspirational status markers become increasingly ethereal.</strong></p><p>Here’s a scientific graph to make the point:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*KBqfOxyMNuhl2q32.jpeg" /></figure><p>What does this mean?</p><p>Well when we say something is aspirational, we mean that it raises our social status. It is something we perceive as being above our current status, and therefore by associating with it we might pull ourselves up to a higher level on the ladder. Clearly we are all constantly, unavoidably, and largely subconsciously jostling for status, and this jostle is what all brand led businesses basically rely on.</p><p>What the above graph is about is that the things which have power to confer status are highly variable depending on cultural context. A high status thing in an Amazonian village is not going to be the same as a high status thing in New York City, that goes without saying. This variability is not random however. It’s highly predictable. <em>And it’s predictable in the way that it always follows the path of becoming less obvious, more subtle, more ethereal as development progresses.</em></p><p>To illustrate this, think about the concept of “bling”. Bling, I think it’s fair to say, is very unfashionable in the hyper-developed West. However in cultures who have a more recent history of hardship and depravation, bling is highly fashionable. The tastes of wealthy Russians, Chinese, and Africans is not the same as wealthy Northern Europeans and Americans. It tends to be more ostentatious and glitzy — and this makes sense given the historical backdrop. If you are emerging from 50 years of Communist rule, say, it will be impressive to display material excess, since few of your peers have access to it. If however you live in a society where material excess is the available to pretty much anyone, you have to look elsewhere to prove your position at the top of the social pile.</p><p>This explains the erosion that has befallen Armani and Mercedes. In the 1990s they were flawless status symbols and powerfully aspirational, since they were undeniably brands few people could access. As time has rolled on however, and they’ve become more accessible, they’ve gradually lost that power — taking us to the point we’re at today where they are pretty easy for ordinary people to buy into if they so choose. At such a point to flaunt these things ceases to be impressive, and actually becomes self-damaging, as it suggests that you are coming from a position that reveres such symbols; a position the culture around you has moved on from.</p><p>Clearly this division doesn’t only occur across national boundaries, but within them too. Different social classes have different ideas of what’s aspirational for precisely the same reasons. Luxury brand names used to be common in hip-hop lyrics because the art arose from a deprived backdrop. By the same token we can see why Tony Soprano wears a gold chain, watch, and rings, but the chairman of the World Bank does not.</p><p><strong>Wherever you look the pattern repeats: as wealth and status goes up, a taste for glitz goes down.</strong></p><p>Understanding this then, we might well wonder what aspirational looks like in a social milieu which looks down on such obvious “premium” markers. We all understand the idea that Magnum, say, is a premium ice cream because it’s a bit more expensive, uses fancy gold typography, and yammers on about indulgence all the time. But if this is no longer seen as aspirational — and in fact is seen as a little gauche — then what is?</p><p>One clue we can find is in the relentless ascension of “Scandic-style”: the fashion for the clean, minimalist, and “tasteful” (note that it is only considered tasteful due to the social position of the taste makers). It’s a look that says “I’ve got nothing to prove”, and perhaps at a deeper level “I have the means to curate and standardise my aesthetic life”. The blanding phenomenon is, in a way, a Scandification of consumer goods. A removal of all traces of showiness or idiosyncrasy, to produce something which blends seamlessly with the carefully managed environments of the taste maker classes. Looking like you’re not trying to flaunt your power has become the standard power-play: an extension of the hoodie and sneakers uniform we’ve come to expect of tech billionaires, now writ large.</p><p>Connected to this is the trend for infantilisation of products — or what we in the UK might call “Innocentification”, in honour of the pioneer, Innocent drinks. This generally isn’t found in fashion, but is common in consumer goods and technology, whereby the most premium option is often that which looks the most “childlike”. I’ve had various food and beverage clients who wished to be seen as premium, and thought that “luxury” would be the path by which they could best achieve this; however I’ve always had to point out that perhaps the two most premium brands in the supermarket at the moment are Innocent and Ben &amp; Jerry’s: the two most self-consciously <em>unluxurious</em> ones.</p><p>Part of the reason infantilised brands are seen as aspirational is their connection with virtuous behaviour, which leads me to a more profound status marker which has emerged recently: “luxury beliefs”.</p><p>A term coined by sociologist Rob Henderson, luxury beliefs are social and political opinions which are typically only held by those of a very high status, and as such have come to be wielded in the same ostentatious way that gold jewellery would have been in the past. What enables them to be “luxury” is:</p><ol><li>Being highly non-intuitive, meaning they can’t be “sensed” but rather must be learned through extensive education (e.g. “stealing is wrong” is not a luxury belief because it’s intuitive; whereas “stealing is actually right” would be a luxury belief if you could support it with some convoluted academic scaffolding)</li><li>Being fast moving, meaning they change all the time so you have to keep on top of them, thus displaying that you’ve got your finder on the pulse (a hard working Joe Schmo won’t be able to keep pace with academic fashions, and thus will quickly out themselves as a rube when they display outmoded opinions and vocabulary)</li><li>Being financially costly to hold; thereby showing that costs are something you are able to bear (those in relative poverty are forced to place their own material concerns higher in their priorities than those at the top, who are able to be more idealistic)</li></ol><p>A typical example might be a commitment to the total dissolution of national borders: a view which effectively no ordinary people hold, but which is quite common in the highest echelons of society, and certainly acts as a strong status indicator.</p><p>Away from such hyper-elite views like this, the luxury beliefs phenomenon can be seen in strategy through the continued ascendancy of ethical offerings. Although the things most ethical brands stand for don’t fully meet the definition of luxury beliefs, they do nevertheless tap into one of the main aspirational currents in post-luxury societies such as the UK and USA. While the 90s millionaire would have bragged about his sweater being made from cashmere, the 20s millionaire would do so about hemp. The motivations are the same, the content changes.</p><p><em>(I appreciate it sounds quite cynical to put the explosion of ethical brands down to petty status games rather than some great moral awakening, but hey, people are people. Just because the trend is powered by vanity that doesn’t make it necessarily unwelcome.)</em></p><p>There are other interesting and perhaps more abstract status indicators for the hyper-developed too. Irony is a big one, artfully harnessed by brands such as Supreme, who subvert old luxury codes in a “knowing” way. Still I could never begin to list all of them here. They are by their nature quite complex and subtle. The only point we really need to land here is that what passes for aspirational in the most developed corners of the globe is no longer basic material wealth, but rather various forms of “meta-commentary” which are perceived as out of reach for regular people. Things which fundamentally may not be literally expensive, but which show you are “in the club” — a far more valuable signifier.</p><p>Ultimately we must always come back to this simple principle:</p><p><strong>That which is aspirational must always be a little out of reach.</strong></p><p>To simply make something premium does not work, because premium has become democratised. To stretch people out of their social strata today, you have to find new paths.</p><p>This job is much harder than in the days when you simply used swirly gold font and charged 20% more than your competitors. It requires far more insight and cultural nous. But for those who achieve it, the rewards are exponentially higher.</p><p>__</p><p>This piece is from my newsletter on strategic thinking. To sign up for free, just click here: <a href="https://basicarts.org/newsletter/">https://basicarts.org/newsletter/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9e01aa6d3668" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sex, sugar, and the supernormal]]></title>
            <link>https://smithesq.medium.com/sex-sugar-and-the-supernormal-ad6dc4623ce0?source=rss-191b6f15263e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ad6dc4623ce0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[distopia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metaverse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex M H Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Nov 2021 12:00:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-16T12:00:20.073Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*JW-e9iKXsKuwlEBODmMn6g.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>The following piece was written before everyone started talking about the metaverse, however as you’ll see the two concepts are deeply connected; hence I thought I’d repost it here.</em></p><p>__</p><p>Following my piece a few months back on the phenomenon of <a href="https://mailchi.mp/dd9af7538fb4/the-problem-with-strategic-models-6462286">concentration</a> — the great invisible force shaping pretty much everything right now — I wanted to do another similar piece on a different macro-trend.</p><p>The purpose of such pieces, which of course aren’t strategy “how tos” like some others, is to give you a grasp of the soup we are swimming in (at least as I see it). This is crucial, since all ideas and plans we might have need to be acutely sensitive to context. For example when I talk about business, I often use the terms “the value you offer the market” and “the value you offer the world” interchangeably. This is because they <em>are</em>interchangeable. Focusing on the market or category can be helpful because it gives you a digestible starting point, but ultimately the <em>true</em>category anything exists in is life at large. And therefore, it helps to know what’s going on in it — and this one’s a biggie.</p><p><strong>The idea is that of <em>supernormal stimuli</em>.</strong></p><p>Supernormal stimuli are essentially artificially intensified versions of natural stimuli, which we consume and in doing so make ourselves “immune” to the effects of the natural. For a simple example consider the following: if you eat a Mars bar every day then strawberries will cease to taste sweet to you. The Mars bar represents a <em>supernormal</em> dose of sugar — far more than would be accessible in a natural context — and thus it sets your expectations of sweetness artificially high. So much so that old norms sweetness cease to be sweet at all. On the flip side if you <em>never</em> ate any refined sugar the opposite would be true: strawberries would taste very sweet indeed.</p><p>One high profile example of supernormal stimulus which most people these days have cottoned onto is pornography. Porn is of course a supernormal version of sex, and is engineered to elicit highly concentrated doses of titillation. As a result porn addicts — just like sugar addicts or any other form of addict I suppose — are constantly chasing ever more specific and rarified hits of stimulation in order to remain satisfied. This has resulted in an epidemic which parallels that of obesity, only this time in sexual dysfunction. Reportedly real sex is no longer hitting the spot for a great number of young men who have been raised with on tap access to pornography — resulting in negative side effects ranging from performance issues to alarming stories of violence and degradation towards women being carried from the internet into real life sexual encounters.</p><p>In the case of both sugar and sex, supernormality is broadly understood and well documented. The point I want to make in this piece is that today <em>everything</em> is becoming supernormalised; and that it’s a pattern which has become both a blueprint for business success, and a roadmap to where we are going. For better and (let’s face it) worse.</p><p>Taken in the abstract, the pattern looks something like this:</p><p>Each year new businesses are finding ways to supernormalise different parts of every day life. Because human beings find the supernormal irresistible — it’s something they like, but now offered in boundless form — these businesses become phenomenally successful. I would venture that the majority of “unicorns” are in the supernormalisation game either directly or indirectly. Almost invariably supernormal products are tech based, since the defining feature of the internet is the removal of boundaries and constraints. This means that people need to “plug in” to access these rewards, and in doing so gradually retreat from the “real life” which houses the old fashioned “non-super” stimuli.</p><p>In summary:</p><ol><li>Normal stimuli exists in the real world</li><li>Supernormal stimuli is accessible online</li><li>People are drawn into the online world by the supernormal</li><li>And in doing so withdraw from the real world, as well as finding it increasingly boring and unsatisfying</li></ol><p>Now I expect you might be a little bit sceptical of how pervasive I suggest this trend to be. Sure, we can all picture in our mind the stereotypical young male dropout, existing purely in a world of gaming, internet forums, and porn. In the US they’re sometimes called “incels”; in Japan sometimes “grass eating boys”. But most of us aren’t like that. Most of us resist such supernormal traps, right?</p><p>At the acute end of the spectrum perhaps this is true. But the issue here is that we don’t recognise how many of the innovations we believe are “good” and “normal” are themselves in fact supernormal.</p><p>To take a single example, think about podcasts. At first glance they seem to be uncontroversial, and all upside. Quality information, available anywhere, often educational and mind expanding. All this is true. However the thing about the supernormal is that it is its <em>very quality and goodness</em> which presents a danger. Podcasts are to conversation what Mars bars are to strawberries: their very richness and ubiquity recalibrate our expectations of the real world, in a manner it often can’t live up to. Let’s face it, when chatting with the average person 80% of what they say is totally banal — small talk, how’s the kids, awkward silences etc. Podcasts (not to mention audiobooks, Twitter, etc.) have none of that. It’s all killer no filler. Better still, you don’t have to lift a finger. You don’t have to participate, just consume — any time, anywhere, totally on your terms.</p><p>No wonder the image of the couple having dinner both glued to their phones has become a cliché. The phones are <em>genuinely</em> more interesting than the other person. Not purely because of nefarious manipulation on behalf of the social media companies, but because they truly give you more of what you want. They’re not powerful because they’re “bad”. It’s not a trick. They’re powerful because they’re <em>good</em>. Too good.</p><p>Rich content which is more interesting than another person has been around for a long time of course — in the form of books, theatre, and latterly TV. However, like all non-super stimuli these were highly bounded in terms of logistics and accessibility. The options at any given moment were limited, and typically only available in a particular place. They were mildly super-normal, no question, but not enough to throw shade on the real world. You could’t <em>live</em> in them — hence perhaps why TV is now seen as a relatively wholesome pastime for kids. Eventually they’ll get bored and do something else.</p><p>Supernormal stimuli on the other hand removes friction. It combines intensity with ubiquity and ease: a potent combination.</p><p>Let’s look elsewhere: the world of dating. App based dating has become so ubiquitous that some now consider it faux pas to ask someone out in person. Little wonder since — in true supernormal style — it simultaneously increases the volume of what you want (options) whilst removing the limiting factors (logistics and, more importantly, fear of rejection). One of the more widely understood consequences of this is of course the erosion of long term commitment. A more recent and more peculiar development that some users have reported is an increased volume of people who are happy to chat but never meet up. The chase is apparently more stimulating than the payoff — particularly, perhaps, when you have pornography to deal with that side of the equation.</p><p><strong>This analysis wouldn’t be complete if we didn’t fold the timely advent of Covid into the equation.</strong></p><p>People like to debate the effectiveness of lockdown restrictions, but the one achievement we can all agree on is the way they’ve accelerated our adoption of digital services. Items which we’d previously never have thought of buying on Amazon we now order habitually. Prime has fulfilled its destiny as the supernormal model of delivery. “Ordinary” delivery times and fees — or indeed the inconvenience of fetching items for ourselves — have now been rendered not only irritating but unacceptable. Services like Deliveroo have supernormalised the restaurant industry. Who needs to trek 45 minutes to a bistro to have stilted conversation with a friend when the very same food can come to you in 20 minutes, to be enjoyed with your favourite Netflix show / podcast / YouTube channel / social feed?</p><p>I wasn’t remotely surprised the other day to see the emergence of the new grocery delivery app wars — promising to get your items to you <em>faster than you can go out and get them yourselves</em>. Slowly but surely the few remaining reasons we have to engage with the non-super world are being chiselled away; even if it’s simply popping to the corner shop for a Cornetto and a scratch card.</p><p><em>(I won’t even bore you with the whole Zoom / working from home revolution — it’s too obvious an example to warrant even a mention).</em></p><p>How do you know if you’re becoming supernormalised? You feel it, quite distinctly. When someone invites you to dinner — or worse still, a birthday party — do you ever feel a slight pang of duty? Sure, you’ll do it, old social mores are still clinging on — but secretly you’d just rather stay in.</p><p>You personally may not feel this, but certainly many do. In 2019 an unbelievable 22% of millennials reported having no friends. Zero. Not something deliberate of course, but something which is becoming increasingly “easy” to achieve, or slip into, without realising it’s happening. Doubtless too you’ve read the various reports of the significant minority of people who don’t want lockdown restrictions to end, <em>ever</em>, or who are enjoying being released from their social obligations. Naturally there are various causes for this — but it’s pretty clear that a major contributing factor is the irresistibility of the supernormal life. Everything you want, better, faster, and in higher volume than ever before, all accessible without exertion or risk. Old life can back off thanks very much.</p><p>The picture being painted here is one which makes the 1999 movie The Matrix seem highly prescient. In its dystopian future, machines grow humans for batteries to power their tech superstructure. In “exchange” the humans are plugged into the matrix: a simulation of the real world prior to the machine revolution. Where it went wrong of course was in painting the ordinary world of non-super stimuli as the fantasy to which we’d be connected. They didn’t anticipate that soon we’d have access to something much more intoxicating. However where it was right was in its portrayal of a future where the real might be somehow inferior to the fake: making it increasingly difficult to tell which you’d rather live in.</p><p>Still, even if supernormalisation continues marching on, hopefully the result will be a little more soft and subtle than such sci-fi nightmares. After all most of us don’t even realise it’s going on even though (as I’ve hopefully demonstrated) it is.</p><p>The strategic utility of understanding this pattern is threefold:</p><ol><li>Most plainly, if you understand supernormal stimuli, then you have a pretty strong model for making money. Sure, much of the low hanging fruit has been picked — but as can be seen with the instant groceries model, there is always a benign real world situation vulnerable to super stimulating. A few short years ago we were happy with the status quo of all these things; it is only once we’ve tasted alternative that we struggle to go back. Of course there are ethical dilemmas with all supernormal ideas — I’m not convinced that any of them are net positives in a socio-historical sense. But nonetheless that’s the way the current is flowing, so if you swim with it, and design things to connect with our increasingly insular “plugged in” futures, you can’t go too far wrong. (Knowingly or not this is what the avalanche of DTC brands are currently doing).</li><li>Secondly, you always have the reverse option: to stand in opposition. Gradually the penny will drop on the negative consequences of many of these things — as it has more or less already with sugar and sex. This means that there are a huge number of underreported social issues to push against. Any movement, any media, and any brand profits massively from the presence of an enemy. The things people particularly remember almost always take an antagonistic stance. And in the rise of the super normal, there are enemies everywhere — so take aim, and take your shot.</li><li>Finally, as I said at the outset, to effectively strategise you don’t need to know the “facts” of the world, so much as the <em>dynamics</em>. The system of feedback loops and incentives which are driving things, mostly unwittingly, in certain directions. Nobody is masterminding this process; this is nobody’s idea of an optimal future. It’s simply a wheel that’s been put in motion by particular technological capabilities coupled with natural human impulses. Spot such wheels, and you can spot strategies.</li></ol><p>As with the concentration trend, I would anticipate an eventual re-balancing, as nothing can go on intensifying forever. But I feel we’re some way from that at the moment. So until then this is playing field; let’s get out there and play ball.</p><p>_</p><p><strong>This piece comes from The Way, my newsletter teaching strategic thinking to founders. To sign up, just go </strong><a href="https://basicarts.org/newsletter/"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ad6dc4623ce0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The cautionary tale of Only Fans, and why it matters to your business]]></title>
            <link>https://smithesq.medium.com/the-cautionary-tale-of-only-fans-and-why-it-matters-to-your-business-713c8a2c8450?source=rss-191b6f15263e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/713c8a2c8450</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trends]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[onlyfans]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex M H Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Sep 2021 14:45:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-27T14:45:48.774Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k3szNfHR-F8dKTbvsjL-RQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>A couple of months back I wrote a piece about the trend of <a href="https://us16.campaign-archive.com/?u=dbfcfcd097fd0818275a2b8b8&amp;id=32293af9e4">concentration</a> — whereby technology is enabling attention and money to be pooled into fewer and and fewer people and organisations.</p><p>That piece was extremely broad in scope, and considered the issue at a societal level, so here I want to take it down a knot and consider the implications for businesses specifically — starting, inevitably, with the sex trade.</p><p>A few weeks ago I picked up on a minor Twitter stir prompted by a successful Only Fans performer, Aella.</p><p><em>(For the unaware Only Fans is a platform where individuals can create “exclusive content” for paying subscribers / fans, and for the most part this content tends to be porn).</em></p><p>Surprisingly the controversy wasn’t a result of anything particularly salacious she tweeted, but rather a simple graph. It mapped earnings on the platform to the percentage of creators in each earning bracket, as you can see here:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/916/0*O1Q2Po8iKP-1lXcs.png" /></figure><p>Clearly the results are pretty stark. Almost all money on the platform is being earned by a tiny fraction of creators, whilst the vast majority are grinding away for nothing at all. We’ve probably all heard of the Pareto Principle of course, whereby in this case you would expect 80% of the earnings to accrue with 20% of the performers, but in actuality the results turn out to be far more extreme; more like 99% of the earnings with 0.1% of the performers.</p><p>So what is going on here?</p><p>Well, quite simply, as technology removes geographical and supply barriers to services, consumers are no longer forced to buy from the most <em>accessible</em> seller, but can instead buy from any one they choose. As a result they unsurprisingly congregate around the “best” option (or, perhaps more accurately, the most algorithmically successful one), and thus trade is pooled there.</p><p>While this is clearly good news for the winner, it’s clearly bad news for everyone else, as the ability to make a decent living as a “mid market” supplier vanishes. Before recorded music there used to be a professional violinist in every town, servicing that town’s musical needs. But when people were able to listen on demand to recordings of the world’s greatest, the market for such performers crumbled. Who wants to listen to that mediocre nobody when we can listen to Yehudi Menuhin whenever we want?</p><p>This of course is why parents tend to be a bit sceptical when their child announces a desire to be a professional musician. 150 years ago this was a pretty viable career choice, but now, as they would no doubt say, it’s like winning the lottery.</p><p>These days the same thing is happening with Only Fans, and as a result one would have to be similarly cautious about choosing that “career choice” too.</p><p><strong>This then, is the true commercial danger of technology.</strong></p><p>It is not, as we were always warned, “automation” (although there is a bit of that of course). It is instead severe concentration, the hollowing out of the mid-market, and the contraction of industries and the opportunities within them.</p><p>The narrative we’ve all been sold is that the internet has increased business opportunities, and naturally in some cases that is true. However I would suggest that if we were to look on a more statistical level — in terms of jobs and money — then in aggregate the opposite is the case. The number of opportunities to become successful as a mediocre service provider, business, or employee (i.e. what most people do) are contracting every day.</p><p>The relevance of this to our purposes here, I think, is in understanding the dynamics of your own industry, and to what extent this effects you.</p><p><strong>Simply put, some industries are pretty immune to these effects, and some are highly vulnerable.</strong></p><p>The immune are those industries which either a) cannot be delivered at mass scale by technology, or b) in which the consumer demands high diversity. A classic example of this would be restaurants. Not only can you not make a restaurant into a digital product; you also can’t expect people to only eat at one restaurant for the rest of their lives. People like to mix it up, and as a result such pooling can’t occur.</p><p>The vulnerable are naturally those industries which can be delivered at scale by technology, and in which the consumer simply wants to find one or two good options which work for them, and stick with them.</p><p>I myself feel a little guilty for recently contributing to this phenomenon in the area of exercise classes — a vulnerable industry category. In looking for online strength, HIIT, and yoga classes I came across the platform Alo Moves — the classes offering of American yoga apparel brand Alo. I’ve got to say it’s great: thousands of classes from world class instructors, beautifully presented, and for only $20 per month. However I have chosen this over all the online pandemic offerings of studios local to me; studios with whom I have an offline relationship. Their offerings are clearly less good, so aren’t I just a “consumer exercising free choice”? Perhaps. But technological dynamics underpinning that choice are, I would say, somewhat complex — making it slightly more dubious than it would normally be.</p><p>I would encourage you to think carefully about whether your business is now — or may be in the future — part of such a vulnerable industry. If this is the case, then it’s important you acknowledge it, and get on top of it. For example:</p><ul><li>If the industry you’re in is already in this state, then it’s absolutely imperative that you command a clear and compelling niche, and avoid a generic offering. One of the benefits of technology is that it makes highly obscure niches commercially viable, as it allows you to collect rare and highly dispersed types of consumers in one place. So whist the prospects of making a good living as a yoga teacher are diminishing, the prospects of making a good living as (say) a dog yoga teacher increasing. The degree to which an industry is vulnerable to concentration, and to which it is able to support niche concepts is directly correlated — which I appreciate sounds like a bit of a paradox, but few people will have the strategic precision to pull off the niche game effectively.</li><li>On the other hand if you feel the industry is transitioning into this state, or may enter it in the future, then it might be worth trying to get ahead of it, and to position yourself as one of the 0.1% who will prosper in a big way. To achieve this starting from scratch in an already concentrated industry is indeed like winning the lottery. But if you see this coming in a pre-concentrated industry, then your odds are much better. A lot of people are going to be caught flat footed — if you understand this concept, you won’t be one of them.</li></ul><p>In sum, it increasingly feels like we are heading to a world where there is “one of everything”. One shop, one radio station, one TV channel, one yoga teacher, etc. It reminds me of something I once heard which suggested that the Communist Revolution is occurring, it’s just being driven by capitalism rather than socialism — regardless the end result is pretty much the same.</p><p>I don’t know if that’s true at all, but it’s a clever observation nonetheless. It’s a revolution of some flavour alright, and one in which we are all unwitting revolutionaries.</p><p>As consumers we can embrace it or resist it; but as founders we have no choice but to adapt to it.</p><p>__</p><p>This piece is from The Way, my free weekly newsletter teaching strategic thinking to founders. To sign up, go here: <a href="https://basicarts.org/newsletter/">https://basicarts.org/newsletter/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=713c8a2c8450" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Innocent, 21 Jump Street, and why consistency requires constant change]]></title>
            <link>https://smithesq.medium.com/innocent-21-jump-street-and-why-consistency-requires-constant-change-5f0c827358a4?source=rss-191b6f15263e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5f0c827358a4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[brand-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brand-positioning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[branding]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing-strategies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex M H Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Aug 2021 16:01:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-02T16:01:00.083Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*10E1iHjzFiew6GwL099K_g.jpeg" /></figure><p>In 2012 they made a new movie adaptation of the TV show <em>21 Jump Street</em>, where two cops (Channing Tatum and Jonah Hill) go undercover as students in a high school to bust open a drugs case.</p><p>Near the beginning it has this great scene which I think is, weirdly, very strategically instructive.</p><p>Basically, although they’re both adults in their early 20s, they are still nervous about their first day back at school. Aside from wanting to do their job, they also understandably want to fit in, and be part of the “cool crowd”. Luckily for them Tatum’s character was supercool when he was in high school, and so assures Hill that if he simply follows his lead they’ll have no problem. As a result they rock up at school:</p><ul><li>In a sweet 80s muscle car</li><li>“One strapping” their backpacks</li><li>Putting on an air of not giving a damn, teasing kids who take studying seriously, etc.</li></ul><p>Much to their surprise however, this behaviour immediately leads them into a confrontation with the current generation of cool kids, who are actually <em>into</em> studying, the environment, being sensitive — and worst of all, “two strapping” their backpacks.</p><p>One exchange I love:</p><p><strong>Cool kid:</strong> “Hey yo — is that your car?”<br><strong>Tatum:</strong> “Yeah”<br><strong>Cool kid:</strong> “What’s that thing get, like 10 miles to the gallon?”<br><strong>Tatum:</strong> “Nah, try like, 7”<br><strong>Cool kid:</strong> “We try to ride bikes whenever we can, global crisis and what not”<br><strong>Tatum:</strong> “Whatever man, I don’t care about anything”<br><strong>Cool kid:</strong> “You don’t care about the environment? That’s fucked up man”</p><p>Anyway, sorry, I realise this is a long rambling intro to make a pretty simple point (I just love that movie), but the moral that’s hopefully obvious is this:</p><p><em>In order to retain your strategic positioning, your behaviour needs to constantly change in line with the contextual changes happening around you.</em></p><p>If we were to imagine that Tatum’s character was a brand, and that his market position was “the cool one”, and he wanted to <em>maintain</em> that position, then he couldn’t do that by keeping on doing the same thing. He would instead need to keep on updating his “execution” in line with the expectations of the market, which naturally is constantly evolving.</p><p><strong>Put simply: you have to keep moving in order to stand still.</strong></p><p>I find that a lot of actual brands really don’t get this. Most of them realise — quite rightly — that consistency is absolutely key to claiming a strong market position. Endless repetition, without ever getting bored of your own schtick, is a crucial virtue for any business. However the way they interpret consistency is “staying the same”, which is in fact the <em>opposite</em> of the truth. <em>Genuine strategic consistency is only achieved by constant change</em>, for the reasons outlined above.</p><p>An example of a brand who have fallen foul of this trap are Innocent.</p><p>Innocent, when they emerged, were a true breath of fresh air; one of the great brand launches in UK history. Their positioning was of course all around healthiness, purity, naturalness, simplicity, and, well, overall <em>innocence</em>. The way they delivered this was, initially, through smoothies. At the time there wasn’t really a mainstream smoothie offering in supermarkets, so this was quite innovative. Even more important however was that it entered a <em>context</em> where traditional soft drinks were still dominant, and largely unruffled by questions of health and the like.</p><p>This context enabled Innocent — both on a product and brand level — to truly challenge what it meant to drink “innocently”; shifting people from unhealthy sodas, to relatively angelic smoothies.</p><p>All in all a great job — and a masterful grab of key strategic space in the market.</p><p>Having established such a position, their next job was to retain it; indefinitely if possible. However this is where Innocent came unstuck. For the next 20 years they basically behaved pretty much identically to how they did at the point of their breakthrough. Sure, they launched some new products, but most were variations on the juice theme — and in addition they had to suffer the unhelpful flattery of seeing pretty much every other brand in the supermarket copying their twee tone of voice and “wackaging” style. Meanwhile, the cultural definition of “innocence” (health, purity, ethics, naturalness) gradually changed beneath their feet. Attitudes towards sugar, for instance, evolved dramatically — flipping juice from a virtue to a vice — and, combined with other cultural factors, this saw the brand’s grip on its position gradually slip.</p><p>Just like Tatum, they weren’t sensitive to the demands of their position in a changing context.</p><p>Now all in all this hasn’t been particularly devastating for Innocent in a commercial sense. Yes, they’ve lost their cultural position, and have settled into the mid-market pack — however given that they’re now following the corporate playbook of their owner, Coca-Cola, this is perfectly fine. They’re playing a different game, living off former glories, and it works well. Nevertheless, you can still appreciate from their example how a brand can <em>change by not changing.</em></p><p><em>The more you change the more you stay the same; the less you change the more you deviate.</em></p><p>As a side note I would argue that you could also say the same thing for Apple, who became locked in stasis pretty much the day Steve Jobs died — another brand who are cashing in the hard work done by former generations. Not bad business by any means, but not the same.</p><p>On the flip side, if you want an example of a brand who have managed to maintain their position through constant change — who have kept moving so they can stand still — look no further than Nike.</p><p>I wrote about them a couple of months back, so apologies for the repetition, but they really are masters of this particular art. Since the 70s they have been the brand who represent the <em>struggle</em> to overcome obstacles. This is the meaning of “Just Do It”; the application of will and determination in the face of a daunting challenge. Over the years they have always been careful to manifest this “constant” in ever changing ways, in order to maintain position. Most recently this has taken the form of aligning themselves with various social justice movements which their athletes are engaged with — a topical example of a struggle to be overcome, and thus a continuation of their strategy.</p><p>Ultimately, I’ve found that many brands don’t truly believe that they can follow one basic strategy for 5, 10, 30 years. They don’t believe me when I say this is a job you have to do only once. They think that they need to constantly “refresh” and “update”, in order to avoid going stale. As Nike shows, this is a misconception — a misconception which arises out of believing that a single strategy has a single way to be executed. Great strategies aren’t like that. They are the gift that keeps on giving; sources of an endless flow of contemporary executional ideas.</p><p>You need to make sure as a business that you offer a value which works this way; a value which is <em>timeless</em>. Something which never needs to change.</p><p>This way you can constantly execute underneath it, and gradually strengthen your grip on your position more and more until it is <em>completely indivisible</em> from you.</p><p>Consistency is king, no question about it. But so is change. And these two things are not contradictory.</p><p>_</p><p>This piece is from my newsletter The Way, teaching strategic thinking to founders. To sign up for free, just go here: <a href="https://basicarts.org/newsletter/">https://basicarts.org/newsletter/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5f0c827358a4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The creative canvas — the key to building a charismatic business]]></title>
            <link>https://smithesq.medium.com/the-creative-canvas-the-key-to-building-a-charismatic-business-98fa5c7e64e2?source=rss-191b6f15263e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/98fa5c7e64e2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing-strategies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex M H Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jul 2021 09:51:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-23T09:51:38.821Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The creative canvas — the key to building a charismatic business</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d5kPW-DcP9-7Eo2P8WBOcw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Sometimes people ask me the meaning of my company name, Basic Arts.</p><p>It came from the original idea I had for the business, which in essence was to embed advertising-esque creativity and artistry into the very fabric of the company itself, rather than limiting it to external “media”.</p><p><strong>Basic</strong> = foundational, structural, the bones of the business<br><strong>Arts</strong> = creative flair</p><p>As an example consider the way that Hiut Denim have their seamstresses sign their name on the inside of the jeans they put together; or the jokes told by Southwest cabin crew; or the flagship Vans store which is an underground skate park; or the way that Alo yoga clothes come with a subscription to their online class platform. These are juicy, “talkable” enhancements to these brands which do the same job as a great ad campaign — only they are <em>permanently woven into the operations of the companies themselves</em>.</p><p>“Make interesting companies, not interesting advertising” was my way of summing this up.</p><p>In recent years I have shifted to focusing more on the strategy that <em>generates these ideas</em>, rather than the ideas themselves — but this doesn’t mean that I’m any less committed to this original idea of embedded creativity than I was before.</p><p>Therefore in this piece I want to expand on it by introducing the idea of the “creative canvas” — an essential tool in building a business like this.</p><p><strong>To understand this idea, we first have to be clear on what the role for creativity in a business actually is.</strong></p><p><em>(Sorry to teach you to suck eggs here, but just to get everyone on the same page)</em></p><p>Starting at the top, we must root everything in the realisation that the job of a business — any business — is to <em>deliver value</em>. There is categorically nothing more to business than this; indeed it is the very definition of the term. <em>A business is a system which has been designed to deliver value in one form, and to collect value in another form in return</em>. Any founder who always has this simple concept front of mind is destined to go far.</p><p>That settled, we can move down a level to <em>brand</em>. What is its role?</p><p>Obviously a lot of bullshit is written about this topic (more so than anything else in human affairs perhaps!), however again, like business, it has a very simple purpose: to <em>communicate</em> the value the business is delivering. That’s it. Communication of value. Anything else is a bonus.</p><p>This leaves us with a simple model:</p><p><strong>The role of a business</strong> -&gt; to deliver value<br><strong>The role of its brand </strong>-&gt; to communicate that value</p><p>Now naturally, even if your business delivers tremendous value, that second job is hard. To do it effectively you need to be:</p><ul><li>Clear, so people can “get it” in an instant</li><li>Noisy, because if nobody notices you everything else is academic</li><li>Viscerally appealing, because, well, people like nice stuff obviously</li><li>And of course memorable</li></ul><p>This is where creativity comes in. Great brands are those who have used artistic creativity to communicate their value proposition in a manner which fulfils these requirements.</p><p>So far this is all pretty standard stuff. Just good tidy branding. Where things get different is the next level down — where you <em>execute</em> that creativity.</p><p><strong>Your <em>canvas</em>.</strong></p><p>In the world of traditional branding, the canvas is pretty limited. It essentially boils down to any “media” which the brand has at its disposal, which typically means:</p><ul><li>Logo</li><li>Website</li><li>Packaging</li><li>Sales materials</li><li>Social media channels</li><li>Bought media (i.e. ads)</li></ul><p>These represent the “space” on which you can tell your story, and do groovy creative things.</p><p>Now clearly these are important, and should be exploited as much as possible — but the true potential for creative expression in a business is far broader than that. You can add idiosyncrasies to every single touchpoint of your consumer journey. You don’t need to be restricted to the “2D” world of images, but can also manifest in the “3D” world of operations.</p><p>The process of building your creative canvas is to “map” these opportunities for your own business, so you are left with broad range of spaces where you might come up with and execute interesting ideas.</p><p>Imagine for instance if you ran a chain of gyms. To build your canvas you would need to break down your entire structural operation, assets, and customer journey — anything with creative potential. E.g.:</p><ul><li>Where should a gym chain with this proposition be located? What are we communicating with our geographical footprint?</li><li>What kind of classes should we offer? What is in and out of our scope? Is there a new form of class which we should invent which you can’t get anywhere else?</li><li>What sort of membership packages should we offer? How can we get creative in our pricing, our tiers, our cancellation policies?</li><li>What sort of equipment should we stock? How should we organise it on the floor? What should the “flow” around the space be?</li><li>What about our staff? What sort of people should work at this gym? How should they be employed? How should they interact with our customers?</li><li>What about our changing rooms? Should we even have changing rooms? Lockers, soap, hair dryers, mirrors; do we have a slant on any of this stuff?</li><li>What secondary amenities should we have? Things like saunas, cafes, vending machines, lounges? Is there something most people have which we choose not to have? Is there something that only we have?</li></ul><p>I could go on and on, but I think you get the point.</p><p>All of these things are just as relevant for creative expression as a 30 second ad is — in fact more so, because once executed they continue <em>communicating</em> indefinitely, and more than communicating they actually help <em>deliver</em> on your proposition too.</p><p>Every business should go through an exercise of mapping its own creative canvas like this. What are all the things which you might potentially twist in a branded way? These then should be “briefed” creatively just like any piece of media, using your strategy as the point of focus — and the resulting ideas should be evaluated in the same way:</p><p><strong>Will this get noticed? </strong><br><strong>Is it exciting? </strong><br><strong>Does it say precisely what we want to say?</strong></p><p>Compounded together, the sum of such creatively aligned parts will be a business which glows with such charisma and clarity that traditional forms of branding will become increasingly unimportant</p><p><em>(This is why various brands who do this well, such as Lush, have been able to adopt “no-advertising” policies).</em></p><p>I have used gyms here as an example because they have an unusually rich creative canvas to play with. Unfortunately not all kinds of businesses are so lucky. FMCG brands in particular have a few levers to pull in this regard — little more than the product on shelf — hence why they lean so heavily on traditional branding.</p><p>The one FMCG brand to have overcome this limitation is Red Bull, who effectively built a whole new business onto the side of their core company with which to express themselves creatively. This is their genius, and certainly represents one option for brands with a limited canvas.</p><p>However, being realistic, such extraordinary lengths are beyond the limits of most of us — so we have to think laterally instead. No matter how limited your canvas appears, there will be more opportunities for creativity than you think.</p><p>For example an FMCG brand might want to think about:</p><p><strong>Product</strong> — It should be an obvious one, but you need to consider how you can adapt your product to fulfil / communicate your proposition more explicitly. On the subject of Red Bull they did this beautifully by making their product taste horrible and come in smaller volumes than other soft drinks. Why did this work? Because these “negatives” <em>signalled</em> the product’s potency, which amplified their core “energy” proposition.</p><p><strong>Format</strong> — Most brands come in the same rough format as all their competitors. But they don’t have to. Tony’s Chocolonely, despite focusing their messaging on their anti-slavery proposition, actually owe far more of their rapid growth to the usual <em>thickness</em> of their bars. It seems like a tiny change, but it bought a whole new level of joy and decadence to the category: one which is fast being followed by other brands.</p><p><strong>Distribution</strong> — Where you are seen has the potential to say just as much about you as any ad campaign. Look at Oatly; a brand built <em>almost entirely</em>on performative distribution. They rose to prominence by pushing their “barista edition” oat milk into speciality coffee shops around the world. Commercially this wasn’t the heart of the business, but raw sales wasn’t the point — <em>communication</em> was, and they realised this was the most powerful piece of brand building they could do.</p><p>These three companies are solid examples of just how much creative brand building you can do outside of traditional media work, even when it seems like you have very little to play with.</p><p>We should never make the mistake of siloing creativity into the superficial, secondary parts of our business. We should never draw a line between the “serious stuff” of the core company, and the “fun stuff” on the periphery. Great brands are <em>inherently</em> interesting, and need no borrowed credibility from a jazzy ad, celebrity tie in, or viral post to prove that.</p><p>Your company should be its own ad.</p><p>And, after strategy, understanding your creative canvas is the most important step to making that happen.</p><p>__</p><p>This piece comes from The Way, my newsletter to teach strategic thinking to founders. To subscribe and access the free course, click here: <a href="https://basicarts.org/newsletter/">https://basicarts.org/newsletter/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=98fa5c7e64e2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Appreciating scale — what to do about the things you can’t control]]></title>
            <link>https://smithesq.medium.com/appreciating-scale-what-to-do-about-the-things-you-cant-control-500259eb42b7?source=rss-191b6f15263e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/500259eb42b7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[complexity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scale]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex M H Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jul 2021 09:40:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-23T09:40:33.176Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Appreciating scale — what to do about the things you can’t control</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Q5nLMVu5QEc7CEo2CsWC8A.jpeg" /></figure><p>There is a quote you may have heard which goes something like:</p><p>“I am a libertarian at the federal level, Republican at the state level, Democrat at the local level, a socialist with my friends and family, and a communist with my dog”.</p><p>The idea is designed to reveal the fatuousness of political labels, but when taken more broadly it beautifully illustrates the importance of an almost completely neglected concept in modern life:</p><p><strong>Scale</strong>.</p><p>To think about things (ideas, systems, organisations, strategies) in terms of scale is to recognise that they behave differently when implemented at different “sizes”, and across different expanses of space. In the case of the above quote, you can see that it suggests that various policies work when activated at the appropriate scale — and equally that they don’t work when activated at a different, inappropriate scale.</p><p>This way of thinking differs wildly from the more standard belief that certain ideas are simply “good” or “bad” in a general sense. Scale matters hugely, and your behaviours and philosophies must vary a great deal when you are operating at different levels.</p><p>If I were to offer a very rough rule of thumb for this variation, it would be something like:</p><p><em>The bigger the scale the less you should seek to control things; the smaller the scale the more you may control things.</em></p><p>At the root of this idea is the unassailable (but routinely ignored) fact of human limitation. We creatures, it goes without saying, are not omnipotent. We are smart, but we are only <em>so</em> smart. We can see, but we can only see <em>so</em> far. We can run, but we can run only <em>so</em> fast. We can remember, but we can only remember <em>so</em> much.</p><p>What this means is that we have a highly limited “sphere of competence”. In other words, we have a scale at which we are highly competent (generally referred to as “human scale”), and then larger scales at which we are incompetent (what we might call “inhuman scale”).</p><p><strong>When we seek to master conditions at a human scale we are highly effective. But when we seek to control things at an inhuman scale we are less so — sometimes disastrously.</strong></p><p>An example I’ve used before of this idea is the comparison between a car engine and the global economy. The car engine is a human scaled machine which we can effectively manipulate and master — thus producing predictable results in line with our intentions. The global economy on the other hand is an “inhuman scaled machine”, which we cannot reliably manipulate and master — thus producing unpredictable results not in line with our intentions.</p><p>Historically I believe this idea was well understood, but as technology has gradually increased our sphere of influence (but not, I stress, our sphere of <em>competence</em>) we have forgotten it. It is now commonplace for us to talk the language of “global solutions”; to buy from global corporations; to consume global news media; to judge our own lives via global comparison. All of these things represent action at an inhuman scale and thus provoke inhuman consequences — which are by definition unpredictable, because we do not have the processing power to understand the complexity of what we are doing at that level.</p><p>Recent conversations about how we might “rein in” the tech giants are a case in point. They miss the fact that the dubious consequences of these companies aren’t peculiar them as organisations; they are embedded in the <em>very concept of the internet itself</em>. Information completely unbounded by geography betrays all laws of scale, and therefore must produce outcomes completely beyond our control.</p><p>Inhuman system, inhuman outcome.</p><p>Not to get <em>too</em> philosophical here, but personally I find it interesting to consider that there is not only a competence question here, but also one of psychological health. If you think about it, you will notice that nature never gives any creature knowledge that is beyond its physical capabilities. An eagle can see for miles and has mastery over all it surveys, meanwhile a mole can barely see at all and yet <em>also</em> has mastery over all it surveys. Their knowledge and capabilities “match”. What is going on beyond their sphere of influence is of no concern to them, so their lives are inherently <em>satisfying</em>. We of course have no such privilege; our vision and knowledge far surpass our abilities, and as such we are forever aware of that which lies out of reach. We are not only <em>acting</em> at a scale that is beyond our competence; we are also <em>thinking</em> at such a scale too.</p><p><strong>So what’s the upshot of all this?</strong></p><p>In short, we must recognise that strategic behaviour should always be bound up intimately with consideration of scale. We must always consider the scale we are acting at, and adjust our plans accordingly — even if that means contradicting our prior positions as scale changes.</p><p>This is why I always propose a “leading from behind” approach to business strategy. All businesses, other than perhaps the most tiny, are beyond human scale. The founder is not a puppet master; the business is out there doing things they cannot see and cannot control. It is not bounded, it is free, and interwoven with the outside world; a living thing more like an organism than an object.</p><p>This means the founder cannot hope to bend it precisely to their will, because it is beyond their capacities to do so. It is too complex. Therefore they must adopt the leadership style which is necessary for <em>all</em> systems beyond human scale, and that is to <em>facilitate</em> it rather than control it. You must allow it to be what it “wants” to be, rather than dictating what you think it “ought” to be.</p><p>If helpful, you can imagine your leadership as something similar to being a politician.</p><p>A sensible political leader, when elected to office in a particular country, will recognise that that country has an organically evolved personality and culture, which was “designed” by nobody. Their job is to simply <em>facilitate</em>this culture, by removing barriers to its flourishing and cohesiveness. This submissive form of leadership is of course why we call such politicians “civil servants”. If on the other hand they wished to <em>transform</em> the culture from above we would call that totalitarianism, and it would look something like the handiwork of Pol Pot. Imperialism is another example of this, where X culture takes control of Y culture and seeks to remake it in its own image.</p><p><em>(As an interesting aside I have read that many ancient empires didn’t seek to do this, and were quite happy for the people they invaded to continue in their own traditions. Whether this is because of wisdom or simply lacking the technological means I’m not sure!)</em></p><p>In any event, such humble facilitation is the best you can ever do when operating at an inhuman scale. Seek first to <em>understand</em> what you are nurturing, and then help it flourish in its own image.</p><p>A beautiful word for this process, which you may find useful, is “husbandry”. This is normally used to describe human care for natural resources, which makes it a perfect analogy since we cannot remake nature as we please; we can only support it on its own terms. As a founder or chief exec you too should practice husbandry of your business, out of respect for its scale, and your own limitations.</p><p>The one other way to tackle leadership at scale is <em>decentralisation</em>. When you decentralise something you break it down from a large unwieldy unit, into multiple human scaled ones. Each of these then becomes manageable, provided they remain oriented to the priorities of the larger “whole” of which they are a part.</p><p>In politics this is exemplified by local governance; and in business it is exemplified simply by the “department” — logistics, sales, marketing, etc. — all of which of course need to harmonise under the will of the overall business.</p><p>So there you have it — two scales, and two corresponding behaviours:</p><p><strong>Human scale (within our competence) — you may control and guide it</strong></p><p><strong>Inhuman scale (beyond our competence) — you follow it and nurture it</strong></p><p>Flow back and forth between these states, with constant sensitivity to which is right at any given moment, and whatever you lead will become beautiful, vibrant, and healthy.</p><p>__</p><p>This piece comes from my newsletter The Way, which teaches strategic thinking to founders. To subscribe and access the free course, click here: <a href="https://basicarts.org/newsletter/">https://basicarts.org/newsletter/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=500259eb42b7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nickelback, Starbucks, and the power of in-authenticity]]></title>
            <link>https://smithesq.medium.com/nickelback-starbucks-and-the-power-of-in-authenticity-efe226e3ef28?source=rss-191b6f15263e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/efe226e3ef28</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[brand-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[branding]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[starbucks]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nickelback]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex M H Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 23 Apr 2021 11:54:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-23T11:54:57.956Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vKXumoIlNhm0gGnZcq4Ygw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Everyone agrees, apparently, that it’s good for a brand to be “authentic”.</p><p>So much so that it’s become one of those overused words which people are increasingly embarrassed to use: like “engagement” or “purpose” or “millennials”. We all know authenticity is good, there’s no need to go on about it.</p><p>But then again… is it? Is it really desirable for a business to be highly authentic?</p><p>This lionisation of authenticity is, I think, quite a modern invention. A good example can be found in world of travel — where tourists have become obsessed with <em>not</em> behaving like tourists; going where the locals go, eating where the locals eat, staying where the locals live. We recognise that in every city there is the “authentic” part, and then there are the “tourist traps”, which generally take the form of a kind of pastiche of local culture — like Madam Tussauds in London, or Times Square in New York, or an industrial pizzeria on the tourist drag in Rome. Former generations of tourists would have unironically embraced these tacky pleasures — but now we’re too jaded, too cynical, and too self aware. Only the “authentic” will do.</p><p>Needless to say such authenticity-seeking has trickled through to brands. Great brands, we are assured, are those who are authentic: in other words “real”, and “pure”, and “uncompromised”. This means different things in different categories, but examples of this might include:</p><ul><li>Homespun back stories</li><li>Ingredients provenance</li><li>Elite level performance standards</li><li>Impeccable health credentials</li><li>Cutting edge design and branding</li><li>Credibility within a purist cultural niche</li></ul><p>My contention is that, generally speaking, this kind of authenticity is not useful for brands. In fact, it is often harmful. The simple reason for this is obvious: being truly authentic generally means being small. Appealing only to the “true believers”, and not being accessible to the masses.</p><p>Now at first glance this might seem like I’m advocating for broad, generic, uninteresting, lowest common denominator commodity brands — the apparent opposite of authenticity. But I’m not. There is a third way:</p><p><strong>Not authentic (too niche), not broad (too boring), but instead <em>deliberately in-authentic</em>.</strong></p><p>In-authentic brands act as mass market pastiches of authentic ones. Simply put, they fake it. They take the good bits from some sort of cultural or category niche, and they package them in a way which has the broadest mass market appeal whilst still maintaining a level of interest.</p><p>If you want a model to aspire to, think of Nickelback. Nickelback represent an artistic expression of sublime business strategy. They took something powerful, real, and pure, and created a sanitised version of it for the widest possible audience. This made them objects of ridicule for the cognoscenti — true metal fans — but massively popular with a much larger audience elsewhere.</p><p><em>(For the record I have nothing against Nickelback — in fact they came on the radio the other day, and I rather enjoyed it — but then again I’m not a metal purist, so what do I know?)</em></p><p><strong>This is precisely what the greatest brands do in their own cultural and commercial territories.</strong></p><p>The reason this works so well, is because most consumers fall for the trick. Most consumers believe that in-authentic brands are in fact authentic (hence why we’re always told how important authenticity is). This is because very few people belong to the elite sub culture that those brands are ripping off. To you and I, the casual observer, brands like The Body Shop, Lululemon, Green &amp; Black’s, Innocent, etc. might look like “authentic brands”, but in reality they are <em>pastiches</em>, and have far more authentic competitors that we’ve never heard of.</p><p>Just like your mum might think that Nickelback is “hard rock”, so too do you think that Brewdog is “craft beer”; and just like Nickelback such brands will have a small and dedicated group of haters who curse them for their in-authenticity.</p><p>One of the greatest examples growth through in-authenticity is Starbucks.</p><p>Today most of us recognise Starbucks for the pastiche of true coffee culture that it is, but in its years of ascendancy that wasn’t the case. Starbucks was, for a very long time, “the coinesseur’s choice”; a mark of status and taste, not mid-market conformity. The way they did this was by taking various characteristics of authentic coffee (espresso based drinks, Italian words, nods to bean provenance, etc.) and sanitising them; packaging them in a manner acceptable for mainstream tastes. Bear in mind that proper Italian cafes had been around for a long time in the USA at that point. If the authentic experience was what mattered, one of them would have blown up long before Starbucks. But authenticity isn’t what matters. Being interesting-but-also-easy-to-buy is. And the quickest way to achieve that is to borrow the juicy bits of something pure, and ignore the bits that are hard to swallow.</p><p>Starbucks was neither a broad commodity coffee chain, and nor was it a proper artisanal cafe. It was the perfect blend of both. I cannot express my admiration highly enough for calling what is basically a milkshake a “frappuccino”. The cynicism is breathtaking, and thus so is the strategy. Because like it or not strategy is always a cynical act. It is always an act of manipulation; of behind-the-curtain computation designed to elicit your desired outcome.</p><p>So, my appeal to all of you “authentic” brands out there, is get off your high horse. Walk into any groovy independent health foods shop, and you’ll find the shelves packed with genuinely authentic brands that neither you, nor anyone else, has heard of. If that’s your ambition, then fine — but don’t kid yourself into believing that you are doing the noble thing. Because the truly noble thing is to create something people love and value; and to extend exciting ideas to the widest possible audience.</p><p>Nickelback knew this. And in-authentic brands do too.</p><p>__</p><p>This piece is from <em>The Way</em>, my newsletter teaching strategic thinking to founders.</p><p>To sign up, and get access to the free 7 day email course, just click here: <a href="https://basicarts.org/newsletter/">https://basicarts.org/newsletter/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=efe226e3ef28" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Know your enemy]]></title>
            <link>https://smithesq.medium.com/know-your-enemy-e88637159b?source=rss-191b6f15263e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e88637159b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[startup-lessons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategic-planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brand-strategy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex M H Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 09 Apr 2021 12:49:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-09T12:49:30.212Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YPrAnSCqAgMHgb5qcOMN4A.jpeg" /></figure><p>A couple of days ago I came across a great anecdote. It concerned the skirmish that broke out in the early 1750s between an Englishman called Jonas Hanway, and the hansom cab drivers of London.</p><p>Hanway’s crime was being the first umbrella user in the city. Prior to that point umbrellas had only existed in the form of sun parasols, originating in the far east and gradually spreading across Europe. It was only in the early 18th century that the French had cottoned on to their potential as a rain deterrent, and it was following a trip to Paris than Hanway brought the new innovation to English shores.</p><p>There were a number of reasons that umbrellas were initially an object of scorn — not least their association with the dastardly French — but their main crime turned out to be the threat they posed to the business of cab drivers.</p><p>It doesn’t take much thought to figure out why. Rainy days were the cornerstone of the cabbie’s trade (especially in London), and so naturally they were concerned when a new method of rain protection hit the market.</p><p>Thus, as Hanway strutted around town with his new contraption, he was not only subjected to jibes about being a “mincing Frenchman”; he was also pelted with rubbish from cab drivers. One even tried to run him down, resulting in Hanway using his umbrella to “give the man a good thrashing”.</p><p>Aside from finding this quite amusing, the reason I want to share it here is because I think it serves as a good illustration of true competitive dynamics.</p><p>Most businesses routinely fail to see their competitors as anything other than “things that look like them”, which results in them completely missing all sorts of threats, as well as growth potential. The true definition of your competitor is <em>anything that results in you losing a sale</em>.</p><ul><li>Chocolate bars and fruit are competitors</li><li>Boats and home extensions are competitors</li><li>Bars and TV are competitors</li><li>Porn and sex are competitors</li><li>Religion and politics are competitors</li></ul><p><strong>If it has the potential to scratch the same itch, then it’s a competitor.</strong></p><p>What this means of course, is that most businesses have far more competitors than they realise. At first this sounds a little alarming, because more competition means more threat. But then at the same time it also means more opportunities, since the places your business goes are also the places it can come from.</p><p>Now my sense is that most people understand this point, at least intellectually. I expect you will have heard variations of it before, maybe even from me! However although everyone “gets it”, almost nobody bothers to engage with it — which is a problem as its value lies entirely in the <em>specifics</em>, not the abstract theory.</p><p>For this reason, it’s a great idea for every business to map out its true competitive landscape: consisting not only of its obvious competitors, but its less obvious ones too.</p><p>To do this, I suggest looking at it in three dimensions:</p><ol><li><strong>Direct competitors</strong> — the obvious ones, the businesses that look like you (e.g. boat brand A versus boat brand B)</li><li><strong>Indirect competitors</strong> — businesses outside your category which have the potential to scratch the same itch (e.g. boats and home extensions, or boats and cars)</li><li><strong>Non business competitors</strong> — activities, behaviours, and motivations which may prevent a sale (e.g. boats and not living near the sea)</li></ol><p>I have found that strategically strong businesses tend to orient themselves against “competitors” which come from category 2 or category 3, and largely ignore those in category 1.</p><p>This is often what I mean when I talk about “companies without competitors”. It’s not that such companies don’t have “rivals for their customers’ attention”. Everything has that. It’s more that they choose to attack rivals which are outside of their superficial category.</p><p>Ultimately this is about realising that brands don’t operate in this neat and bounded thing we call a “category”. That’s a fake concept we invented to make things seem more simple than they really are.</p><p><strong>In reality brands operate in this messy and unbounded thing we call the real world.</strong></p><p>You’ll never be able to map it or master it. But if you try, you can get a rough idea. And that’s a hell of a lot better than nothing.</p><p>__</p><p>This piece is from my newsletter <em>The Way</em>, which teaches strategic thinking to founders. To sign up, and access my free 7 day course in strategic thinking, just go here: <a href="https://mailchi.mp/53e8061f1686/basicarts">https://mailchi.mp/53e8061f1686/basicarts</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e88637159b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Something’s wrong with marketing — here’s how to fix it]]></title>
            <link>https://smithesq.medium.com/somethings-wrong-with-marketing-here-s-how-to-fix-it-db5765a09130?source=rss-191b6f15263e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/db5765a09130</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[brand-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[advertising]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing-strategies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[branding]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alex M H Smith]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Mar 2021 10:36:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-25T10:36:44.939Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Something’s wrong with marketing — here’s how to fix it</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zKFOpgtrSw2PoghziYA8Jw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Something is wrong with marketing.</p><p>Looking back across my clients, I struggle to think of any that have a wholly positive relationship with it. For example:</p><ul><li>For those who invest heavily in it, it often becomes a confusing and expensive burden; all convoluted brand pyramids, wheels, houses, and onions; built via excruciatingly protracted conversations about the merits of “this word” versus “that word”, culminating in large agency costs that they aren’t even sure were worth it.</li><li>For others, it’s seen as being “the thing you can give to the intern”. Something that everyone else in the business secretly (or not so secretly) thinks is a bit of fluff. Superficial, and unimportant compared to the “real business” which happens elsewhere.</li><li>And then there have even been clients with no marketing department at all — who perversely are often better marketed than the ones who throw money at it.</li></ul><p>Whether you’re a founder or even a marketer yourself, I expect at least one of these scenarios provokes a flicker of recognition — and this is a big problem.</p><p>It’s a problem because, as Peter Drucker once said, “marketing and innovation produce results; all the rest are costs”. This means that if your business has a dysfunctional relationship with the discipline, you are essentially flying with one wing. You’re choosing to forgo perhaps the most potent weapon in your arsenal, and worst of all you probably don’t even realise it.</p><p>Now I am not exactly a marketer per se, but I do consider marketing to be the most important subset of strategy. And so here I want to lay out the key misunderstandings which surround marketing, and suggest some practical changes which founders might want to consider if they wish to turn marketing from a liability into a serious asset.</p><p>The first thing to say, is that the marketing Drucker spoke of is <em>radically </em>different from what people understand “marketing” to mean today. The main cause of dysfunctional marketing is simply that people and organisations don’t understand what it is — and this sadly this includes many marketing professionals. (<em>I want to stress however that this is hardly their fault; they obviously need to adapt their behaviours to modern expectations if they wish to progress in their careers</em>).</p><p>Drucker saw the business of marketing the same way as Martin Glen, former chief exec of the FA, who summed it up by saying:</p><p><strong>“The fundamental role of marketing is to decide what a company is”.</strong></p><p>Stop and consider that for a second. <em>What a company is</em>. Clearly there is nothing more crucial and fundamental than that. The clue in fact is in the name: “marketing” — as in navigation of the market. As in determining how the business clicks into the market and interfaces with it. In other words, determining <em>its very nature</em> from an external point of view.</p><p>This is why Drucker said “all the rest are costs”. He means that “all the rest are simply necessary expenses in order to execute the determination of marketing”. An efficient business would naturally minimise those costs as much as it could; doing as little as it could get away with whist still fulfilling the market purpose.</p><p>This existential understanding of marketing is what gave birth to the famous 4 Ps:</p><ul><li>Product</li><li>Price</li><li>Place</li><li>Promotion</li></ul><p>If you think about it, the combination of these essentially covers the entire business from an external (i.e. market) point of view. There is nothing more which contributes to what a business <em>is</em> for its customers.</p><p>However today, as many have noted before me, how often do you see marketing designing the product? Or setting the price? Or really doing anything other than the final P: promotion?</p><p>Yes, that pretty much summarises the unfortunate evolution of marketing. Moving from deciding what a company <em>is</em>, to simply how a company <em>presents itself</em>. Decorators rather than architects. It would be far more accurate, strictly speaking, to call most modern marketing departments the promotion department — because that’s basically all they do. This isn’t to denigrate their importance in any way (promotion is obviously crucial); it’s just that this is not how strong marketing works.</p><p>So why does this matter?</p><p>Well, there are two key drawbacks for businesses to this evolution:</p><ol><li>Most importantly, as marketing has receded from its true role, <em>nothing has taken its place</em>. It’s not like the old job of marketing has now been taken by finance, say. There is instead simply a vacuum. There’s a vacancy at the tiller, so nobody is navigating the market whatsoever (other than occasionally the founder, in an informal manner). This means that the business doesn’t make decisions in an integrated manner. It has no central blueprint with which to coordinate product, price, place, and promotion. These decisions are instead made independently — thus creating an end result with weak market fit.</li><li>Secondly, and consequently, the new responsibility of marketing, promotion, becomes much much harder. As there is no central blueprint, it becomes extremely difficult to articulate what exactly the business is; what exactly you are selling. Marketers have to somehow make sense of this weird thing that has been created. This is what has given rise to the modern cult of marketing jargon, and inflated agency power: these are attempts to fill the vacuum left by the disappearance of grown up organisational marketing.</li></ol><p><em>(As a side note, keen eyed amongst you may have noticed that my description of true marketing is similar to my description of strategy. This is because the central strategy for the vast majority of businesses is market oriented — and thus yes, is essentially marketing. It is possible to have non-market-oriented strategies — like exploiting mining rights in Peru or whatever — but for most businesses leverage is going to come from their market role).</em></p><p>So, as you can see, this is a problem — and one which I would encourage any founder to address. The question is how?</p><p>My first suggestion pertains to naming. I acknowledge that it will now be more or less impossible rewind the meaning of the word “marketing” in most people’s minds, so the obvious solution could be to rename the department in order to break that spell. The downside of this however, is that it could be a bit confusing, so a more simple hack which I personally would employ would be to break marketing and promotion into two separate departments. Although I appreciate that strictly speaking promotion is part of marketing, such a separation would force a business to seriously engage with all the other parts of marketing which are currently neglected.</p><p>My other suggestion is to reconsider the way marketing is integrated into the organisational structure. The typical mistake which modern companies make is to have all their departments (marketing, HR, sales, finance, logistics) running in <em>parallel</em>, underneath management. If we recall that true marketing plays an orchestrational role, determining how other departments <em>knit together</em>, then in reality it should operate <em>over</em> or <em>though</em> them, rather than alongside. This either means that it is an umbrella department — under management, but above operations — or even if you wanted to be really radical, a <em>decentralised</em> department: where all divisions have a marketing representative within them, who coordinates with the other marketing representatives to align operations.</p><p>Anyway, these are just ideas. However you do it what really matters is that you do do it. That somebody takes responsibility for market navigation, and ties together policy and practice accordingly. In a small organisation that can (and probably should be) the founder. But in a larger one the task will eventually need a degree of specialisation.</p><p>So if you’re a founder ask yourself who is doing this job. And if you’re a marketer, ask yourself if <em>you</em> are doing it. Because if you’re not, there’s a big opportunity there. And nobody else is going to grab it.</p><p>__</p><p><strong>This piece is from The Way, my newsletter designed to teach strategic thinking to founders. To subscribe, and access the free 7 day email course, just go here: </strong><a href="https://mailchi.mp/53e8061f1686/basicarts"><strong>https://mailchi.mp/53e8061f1686/basicarts</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=db5765a09130" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>