<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@socratic-scribbler?source=rss-ce1b1e71bf4e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 11:32:55 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@socratic-scribbler/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[HOW ADAM SMITH CAN HELP US BECOME MORE PRODUCTIVE WRITERS… some Socratic Scribbling on how to…]]></title>
            <link>https://socratic-scribbler.medium.com/how-adam-smith-can-help-us-become-more-productive-writers-some-socratic-scribbling-on-how-to-3ef7bb65680?source=rss-ce1b1e71bf4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3ef7bb65680</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[index-card]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing-habit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing-tips]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[adam-smith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing-productivity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Nov 2021 20:39:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-04T15:44:18.359Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>HOW ADAM SMITH CAN HELP US BECOME MORE PRODUCTIVE WRITERS… some Socratic Scribbling on how to divide the labors of writing</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*yBhXtYvTCWktzCE-" /></figure><p>Adam Smith has always offered us a stellar model of clear and vivid writing, especially when he is explaining complicated matters… like the components of money. Indeed, before he begins his discussion, he apologizes for the necessity of proceeding with his analysis in step by miserable step fashion. Still, if you bear with him, you would be ready to debate the Bitcon phenomena with the best of them, perhaps even with Smith’s understated wit and charm.</p><p>Smith’s lessons in writing go beyond his almost magical ability to combine ruthless logic with vivid illustration and precise choice of words. In his discussion of the division of labor, Smith gives us hints about how we can organize our time more productively when we write. Adam Smith opens his <em>Wealth of Nations</em> by telling us that civilized wealth (Wealth not exclusively gotten via rape and pillage) is made possible primarily by two activities: division of labor and commerce with money.</p><p>Smith brings this idea to life with his famous pin factory illustration. If you were to try to make pins on your own, by the time you bought the materials and tools you needed and then started to make your pins, you would be lucky to make a few in a day. And once you finally had crafted your pins, you would have to find someone to buy the pins you do not want to keep for yourself. You would expend much money and labor for not much, if any, profit.</p><p>Smith then observes that in a factory, you have the benefit of the division of labor, with some people responsible for getting the materials; other people focusing on different stages in the manufacturing process; and, still others in distributing the pins to potential buyers. The power of this division of labor is exponential in terms of the output and potential profits…your pin factory could make and sell thousands if not millions of pins..as long as there were people to buy them.</p><p>Smith explains that the benefits of labor division derive from three factors: 1. The spearation all the work into simple, easy to learn, and focused tasks 2. The improvement of the skill and dexterity at doing those tasks through repetition and the probability that workers will invent ways to improve the time and effort spent. 3. The reduction of any time wasted in the intervals from one task to the next, by reducing any time or space between them. Through specialization people discover what they are good at doing, so the best people gravitate to the best jobs in the process.</p><p>As you proceed from production to distribution and sales, Smith notes that this commerce involves not only the ability to connect with lots of potential buyers but also to have the capacity to deliver the goods. Hence, commerce is driven by ready transportation and broad communication networks. This simple but elegant analysis allowed Smith to account for the dominance of Western Civilization in the world, not based on some triumphal theory of tribal or racial superiority but rather on the plain presence of rivers, lakes, and seas…the water ways that provided easy transportation in many parts of Europe, North Africa, West Asia via the Mediterranean and key rivers. He notes that it is no accident that Egypt represents the first major civilization because of the Nile and the Mediterranean, permitting easy commerce of goods, services, and ideas from town to country and town to town.</p><p>These insights by Smith have accounted for the differences among developed and undeveloped countries throughout history. Lower Africa, for instance, was less lucky in its river networks or presence of well placed lakes or seas. When transportation is difficult, people are tribal and isolated. Little commerce happens and commerce tends towards barter.</p><p>Smith also predicted that machines would free even more labor to create kinds of work yet uninvented, which digital technology surely amplifies.</p><p>How does all this relate to writing? While it is easy to imagine how Smith’s division of labor and commerce principles explain much about the publishing business and many of the media businesses from television to streaming, what does it have to do with the productivity of the writer?</p><p>Well, it seems like we writers haven’t advanced much beyond the original pin maker. Yes, we have digital ways of recording our words and sending them out to others easily enough. But the process of finding the words and putting them together still falls on the Writer, the one or small group of people, who actually come up with the ideas and words that make the show or the novel. At some point, each writer has to go to his office or cubby hole and make his own pins.</p><p>No wonder Google is full of quotes like “Writing is easy. I just sit down at the type writer and bleed!” (Attribution uncertain; some say Hemmingway). And you can find lots of books and articles detailing the eccentric and peculiar habits and rituals of writers, which are not only entertaining but actually provide some exemplars of best practice. You begin to understand how difficult it can be for writers just to organize their day, much less their thoughts.</p><p>So let’s go back to our pin maker for guidance. Despite the victory of pin factories, a few gifted people figured out a way to keep making pins all by themselves and selling them for lots of money. This is now called hand crafted jewelry. We no longer have just a pin. We now have art. And here lies the connection to writing.</p><p>Now, how does a hand crafting jeweler work effectively and efficiently? Actually, they apply Smith’s principles of labor and commerce — but focused on their own work habits. First, they specialize — in a look or design, in a kind of metal, in a kind of stone, in a kind of bodily ornament — -in all of Aristotle’s four causes — -form, materials, tools, and intended use or benefit. They may even employ laborers, but keep control over each item in the causal chain. They find their niche.</p><p>In terms of commerce, they need to network into the groups of people most likely attracted to their kind of jewelry. They must also become experts at the occasions on which jewelry is purchased and worn in order to schedule their communications directly. For instance, my wife and I, married almost 40 years, are lucky enough to have hand crafted wedding rings by the late Bill Fredericks, who taught gold smithing at the Art Institute of Chicago. Bill argued that hand crafted jewelry has little to do with pricey prestige like “designer” rings and everything to do with signifying the importance and meaning of relationships.</p><p>In effect, specialty jewelers apply Smith’s principles of the division of labor to their own work habits. Dividing and conquering doesn’t always have to involve more people but it does have to involve dividing and leveraging similarities and differences. Bill Fredericks focused his jewel and metal work on the rituals of special occasions, from wedding rings to mass chalices to anniversary mementos…items expected to delight and signify for generations.</p><p>What lessons can writers learn from Adam Smith? Like Bill Fredericks, we must make some decisions. We must determine the kind of writing business we want to do. What kind of writing or genre do you want to create and for whom? What innovations will your writing bring to the writing that already is being provided in your chosen genre and audience. Do you work better alone or in a team? Do you need to work with art directors and musicians? Aristotle’s four causes again provide a handy way to begin to think this through.</p><p>Once you get past the big questions, you must now find ways to use Smith’s principle of division to your own writing process. Now, the steps in the writing process were pretty well outlined in by Plato in the<em> Phaedrus</em>, noted in Aristotle’s<em> Rhetoric</em>, and formalized by Cicero and Quintillian. The Five Steps of Classical Rhetoric: Invention, Arrangement, Style, Memory, and Delivery.</p><p>The more efficient writers tend to follow the guide of Nabakov and Hollywood storyboard writers by using sortable index cards (or some digital equivalent) to generate focused thoughts and ideas that will go into their writing project. Most of their time is spent generating lots of bits of the puzzle…the Invention Stage on their cards or slips of paper. The writer or team will then shuffle all these bits and cards in an order that they believe will be both comprehensible and entertaining to their audience. The advantage of this method is that it combines the loose and random capacity of creative connection with focus on one bit at a time, gradually letting the structure emerge.</p><p>Here we see the genius of Smith’s insight about the powerful impact the division and arrangement of our labor can make on the productivity of a factory or an individual. Lots of people report about how the simple Pomodoro method of scheduling their day has dramatically increased the volume and quality of their writing. The Pomodoro method merely asks you to divide your day into manageable bits of work and planned breaks, all with the help of a kitchen tick tock timer shaped like a tomato.</p><p>Like all great principles, the principle of labor division has a kind of irony to it. We divide a task into parts in order to simplify it. Yet, when we have turned our one task into many, we have somehow complicated it. Fortunately this is a complication of creative opportunity rather than a multiplication of obstacles.</p><p>In his <em>Sophist, </em>Plato tells us that the Philosopher’s power rests in his ability to divide and sort ideas. Then by engaging in the intellectual commerce of dialogue, we increase our understanding of the world and ourselves. No wonder, as children, we loved pulling things apart to see what makes them work. Now, as adults all we have to figure out is how to put all the parts together again to live the life we desire.</p><p>And so the Socratic Scribbler will continue to search for advice on writing and life from the Great Books…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3ef7bb65680" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[TRIANGULATION…Three Powers of Persuasion]]></title>
            <link>https://socratic-scribbler.medium.com/triangulation-three-powers-of-persuasion-85f595fcba77?source=rss-ce1b1e71bf4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/85f595fcba77</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[plato]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[advertising]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[persuasion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[happiness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 Oct 2021 17:01:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-17T17:01:47.520Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>TRIANGULATION…Three Powers of Persuasion…Three ways to insure your message motivates your audience</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*NB5SA0hnDGdFLcBN" /></figure><p>Working in advertising for thirty years gave me plenty of opportunities to think about and read about the art of persuasion. Now that I’m a retired old man I’ve come to believe that just about everything you need is in Plato and Aristotle.</p><p>I’m not sure Plato would approve of my unsolicited endorsement. Plato was always wary of persuasion. He believed that the Sophists, the personal persuasion coaches of his day, claimed to show young people how to win in political and legal debate, no matter what the truth of the matter. Plato’s Socrates compares persuasion to cookery, serving up delicious but often unhealthy food. He believed Sophists were teaching people how to use flattery and high sounding phrases to distract people from the right things to think, feel, or do. For Plato, Sophists are scoundrels who pretend to know what they are talking about. They are like actors or magicians, expert in the arts of illusion. I suspect many people think the same of advertising folks like me.</p><p>POWER ONE: A GOOD REASON</p><p>Anytime there is an issue of choice, Plato believed that we should tell people the truth and recommend the best choice we can. We should not be tempting people to act against their own best interest. Indeed, Plato went so far as to ban not just the sophists but even the poets from his Republic. People who speak or write too well can mislead us. You can’t even trust Homer to tell you the truth about the gods. I guess Plato would ban most of us from Facebook.</p><p>However, even Plato was forced to recognize that it’s not always enough to present the logic, science or rationale. Even if we are experts in the choice or issue at hand, that expertise alone is sometimes insufficient to the task. The rhetorician Gorgias offered Socrates a compelling example. Georgias had a good friend who was very ill. A medical doctor knew exactly what was wrong with the friend and prescribed a medicine. The friend, however, was afraid of the medicine and refused to take it, putting his life at risk. The doctor asked Gorgias to talk to the friend. Gorgias succeeded, and the friend took the medicine and thrived. Gorgias asks Socrates, “Who cured my friend, the doctor or me?”</p><p>POWER TWO: TRUST</p><p>Well the answer is clearly both. The philosopher and the scientists may well be the closest things we have to rational or scientific experts in ethics and medicine. The doctor asked Gorgias to talk to the friend because he knew that Gorgias would know better how the friend thinks and makes decisions and how to help steer him in the right direction. The doctor understood the power of friendship.</p><p>Aristotle argues that beyond the rationale or logos of our arguments, our audience needs to trust us…as they would a friend. We need to have an ethos or character that the audience finds credible. They need a reason beyond our words to believe us.</p><p>Aristotle would agree that a con man can thrive by manipulating the truth, by the magic tricks of the illusion of language. We’ve all encountered a fast talker. While such con men may well succeed in putting one over on us once, we are unlikely to trust them ever again. They have to keep moving on.</p><p>If you do not keep your promise to pay me back a loan, I’m unlikely to offer you money again. Indeed, I’m more likely to warn others about you.</p><p>So, you have to work at developing an ethos or reputation for trust and expertise if you expect people to believe you. That’s why ad guys like me understand why KFC finds it easier to sell chicken than hamburgers. We call it “branding.” You may object that McDonald’s sells chicken…but only as long as it is in a hamburger bun. Forget the wings, ’til you get to Wingstop.</p><p>Now, if you have a good argument, or logos, and have projected a good character, or ethos, you are well on your way to persuasion. However, you’re still not done. But wait…there’s more.</p><p>You not only have to be an expert in what you are talking about and an expert projecting a trustworthy character, you also have to be an expert in understanding your audience…the people you want to persuade.</p><p>It’s not just a matter of choosing truth over lying. We need yet another truth: a truth about our audience that will connect directly with the truth we are selling. Finding the intersection between the two will be what Lisa Fortini Campbell famously called The Sweet Spot.</p><p>Assuming we know the truth of the choice we are advocating, we still have to find a way to make a motivating connection between that truth and the people we are trying to persuade.</p><p>Here’s where a little humility comes into play. Not everybody is persuasible. Once someone has already made a choice, they are less open to change because they have already invested time and effort into that choice. If they have not only made the choice but also experienced a positive result of some kind, they will be even less likely to change. In addition, if they have received such a positive result that they have become advocates for that choice, you’ll have even less of a chance of changing their mind. The chances get even lower when the stakes of the choice are high…life, death, love, success. When Aristotle talks about courage, he centers it between cowardice on one side and recklessness on the other. Wise commanders do not throw their armies against overwhelming forces. So too, if we want to change people’s minds, we have to start with the “easy to gets” the people looking to satisfy some desire. We do not waste time or money on the people with other or prilr commitments.</p><p>No doubt big data about behavior and attitudes can help us do that. Still, even that only takes us half way there. When we finally figure out how to identify and to connect with the people most likely to find our offers desirable, what are we going to do or say that will get them to do the right thing?</p><p>Aristotle tells us that we think, feel, and do things which we believe will make us happy by helping us lead a good life…a life not only of material pleasures, comforts and good fortune. For Aristotle, a flourishing and full life would also include intellectual, social, and spiritual satisfactions, further complemented by great friends and divine contemplation. Aristotle also reminds us that when we do anything in excess or extreme, we tend to get ourselves in trouble…personally and socially. If this sounds a bit like Maslow’s hierarchy, now you know where he filched it.</p><p>Aristotle provides insight into how to interpret all that big data. He observes that as we go through the different stages of life, our priorities change as well. We move from toys and games to school and peer competition, then to sex, drugs, and rock and roll, then to making a living, then to finding a partner, then to raising families, then to negotiating mid life crises driven by our success or failure, and then to the relief of retirement, and finally to aging and health issues…all the while trying to manage relationships..family, romance, work, and politics and even God. Life for everybody is complicated and hard.</p><p>POWER THREE: EMOTIONAL LEVERAGE</p><p>This takes us to Aristotle’s third factor Pathos: the emotional leverage that derives from the wishes and fears of our audience. We experience positive emotions and feelings like joy, confidence,and pride when our desires are satisfied. We endure negative emotions like sadness, anxiety, and anger when our desires are frustrated.</p><p>Hence, when we connect with people we must somehow show them how the thought, feeling or action that we are recommending will help satisfy their desires, fulfill their wishes, and allay their fears.</p><p>Many people believe that one of the greatest tv commercials ever made was <em>I’d Like to Teach the World to Sing… </em>which showed a group of young people in a beautiful natural setting, all singing together about how Coca Cola could bring harmony to the world. Absurd? A Lie! Plato was right. Arrest the copyriter. Well wait a minute. The key line in the song is: <em>I’d like to buy the world a Coke and keep it company. </em>Offering to buy someone a Coke is an act of sharing, an act of enjoying a little time together, the beginning of a conversation… If everybody could have this ideal attitude, well who knows… a challenge to the tribalism that continues to divide our worlds. And who wrote the book on Idealism if it wasn’t Plato? Coke is the essence of wishful thinking. What could be more real than that!?</p><p>Aristotle loved threes…I suspect because it takes at least three legs for just about anything to stand up firmly. The three persuasive powers of triangulation: the truth about the speaker, the truth about the choice, and the truth about the audience. When they all three truths triangulate …you’ve got a three-fer.</p><p>Why didn’t we learn this in school? Hey, can I buy you a Coke?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=85f595fcba77" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[WHY DO SO MANY PEOPLE LOVE TED LASSO? The Socratic Scribbler meditates…]]></title>
            <link>https://socratic-scribbler.medium.com/why-do-many-people-love-ted-lasso-the-socratic-scribbler-meditates-38a42cdde081?source=rss-ce1b1e71bf4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/38a42cdde081</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ted-lasso]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comedy-show]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[popular-appeal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anger-management]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Sep 2021 16:00:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-21T18:40:33.133Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*TOqCh-SCDsGTaDt4rQYkyw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Ted Lasso</em> is not just popular. It’s good, getting rave reviews and recommendations from just about everyone…except the chronically grouchy.</p><p><em>Ted Lasso </em>is based on a classic “fish out of water” premise. A Witchita State football coach is surprisingly hired as a coach for a professional British soccer team, AFC Richmond, by a Rebecca Welton. She is seeking vengeance on her ex husband. Her scheme is to make the team a miserable failure to the embarrassment of her cheating, ex-husband. Of course, just as in <em>The Producers</em>, the opposite happens.</p><p>“Fish out of water” stories, are winning big audiences these days. Consider the last year’s Emmy craze over <em>Schitt’’s Creek</em>, where a wealthy New York family loses its money and ends up living in a sleazy motel in the middle of a hick town. It was immensely popular, tapping into our inclinations to wish ill on the idle rich, who do not even know how to trim their own nails. Yet, the eccentric family somehow wins us over with their ingenious adaptations and rebirth.</p><p>Given the Covid plague, perhaps the whole world is feeling a bit like fish out of water these days. We all move around while wearing unbreathable masks and swimming our arms to keep social distance. This said, I suspect tha<em>t Ted Lasso </em>is more than just collective unconscious reaction to our weird plague world. After all, “fish out of water” stories have been popular since Aristophanes’ T<em>he Clouds</em>, in which a regular guy tries to escape his debts by joining Socrates’ oddball Thinkery. The “fish out of water” story taps into a basic fear…the terror that began on our first in that place full of strangers our parents called kindergarten.</p><p>Yet, I think there is much more at work in <em>Ted Lasso</em> than a classic comic premise that taps into a contemporary fear. The “fish out of water” works as framework for a much more powerful comic plot. Ted Lasso is todays Don Quixote, accopanied by his Sancho Pansa, the taciturn, chess playing Coach Beard. The errant knight values that Ted Lasso proclaims are the positive American Sports Coach values consistently celebrated from Knute Rockne to Casey Stengel to Vince Lombardi to John Wooden to every great coach or manager of a sports team.</p><p>These are the heroic values we all learned in Little League or high school football: Teams win; egotistical individuals lose. People who know the game have left us great aphorisms, many comically paraphrased in Ted Lasso, often ensconced a Yogi Berra koan. And, just as Don Quixote is considered crazy for following the noble values of a knight errant, Ted Lasso is considered crazy for taking a coaching job in a sport he does not even understand. Ted tries to explain that the purpose of being a coach is not so much to win (pace Lombardi) as to build a winning team by helping all the players become their best selves. Ted appears so laughably naive in his mission that everyone tries to take advantage of him…the owner of the team, the players, the media, and the fans.</p><p>But like Don Quixote, Ted gradually wins people over to his noble mission and humble Will Rogers persona. Here is where the script writing of Ted Lasso is exceptional. The writers, like Cervantes, create one moment after another where Ted is set up for failure. And,like Don Quixote, he often does fail and takes a genuine beating. Also like Quixote, Ted nonetheless surprises people with his uncanny insight and intelligence, making his enterprise all the more difficult for people to understand. Why would he leave a wife and child home in America to come to the UK and submit to the arrogant wanker insults of Brits?</p><p>What’s even more peculiar is that Ted’s values are not only out of fashion, but also considered dangerous these days…the cracker white values of Trump’s Big Lie heartland. Is Lasso’s sly way of winning over of the Brits a dangerous reassertion of American exceptionalism? Or is it possibly something more profound? During all their wars, the Greeks had their Olympics. Somehow sports values were thought to transcend city state rivalries and battles. Politics today has lost its sense of sportsmanship and Fair Play; indeed, politics has even infiltrated the playing field before and after the game. One episode addresses this issue directly, only to resolve it by making it less a political cunundrum and more a matter of team members supporting their own. Aristophanes loaded his comedy with politics but never embraced an ideology. Instead he finds the human truth that idealogues seem to want to ignore.</p><p>Like Aristophanes, the comedy of <em>Ted Lasso</em> goes deeper than political palaver. It explores “responsibility” in friendship and love. The world of Ted Lasso’s Quixote is a a mean spirited world where everybody places themselves first and acts out of spite and vengence. A player rationalizes the bullying of Nate, the kit manager, by saying that Nate is weak and cannot do anything about it so he deserves to be bullied and it is fun. Right out of Thrasymachus in in Plato’s<em> Republic</em>. The women are the prizes of victory, to be discarded and replaced as they grow older. Ted encourages Rebecca, the team owner, to give up her Medea-like passion for revenge on her despicable ex-husband. The result: she paradoxically becomes stronger by allowing herself to be vulnerable as she attempts to date again. Inside that Medea is a teenage girl.</p><p>Again the artistry and wit of the writers impresses us from one moment to the next. The role of food in the story is worth its own exploration, from secret recipe shortbread baked by Lasso for a ritual meet with Rebecca to spicyhot Indian food to a happy birthday cake…Lasso reaffirms food its ceremonial role in life. When life loses its ceremonies…it’s like sports losing its rituals. Lasso has a bold Twainish honesty when he readily admits that he thinks tea taste disgusting….the truth at last. Innocents abroad.</p><p>Homer looked at the Trojan War through the lens of the anger of Achilles. The writers of <em>Ted Lasso</em> turn all their comedy on the exploration of Anger…of being rejected by a spouse, of being bullyied by team mate, of losing important games, of growing too old to play, of being snubbed in a restaurant (called A Taste of Greece..a punitentiary worthy detail).</p><p>After being forced to retire because of physical limitations, a Roy Kent, player famous for his anger, becomes passive and depressed. When given the forced opportunity to be a sports commentator, his anger breaks forth, insulting every aspect of the game in progress ….leading to cheers for his “telling it like it is.” He has diffused his anger by turning it into a mode of entertainment, like political commentators talk radio.</p><p>I notice that some people are put off by the sweet and happy resolutions in the storylines, complaining that <em>Lasso</em> is more of a crunchy comfort food indulgence than a biting comedy. Perhaps, but so many people are so angry these day. This is the real reason we are fish out of water…whether its politics, work, or romance…everybody is so angry that we don’t know how to cope without hiding or being mean. Despite enlightened advice to the contrary, it’s hard to be angry when you are eating an eclair or watching <em>Ted</em> <em>Lasso</em>.</p><p>Ted and his assistant coach consistently play with words and phrases for fun and delight, from awful puns to amazing bits of Second City verbal improv. These sword flashes of language remind us that playing with words is as important as playing on the field. When we lose our sense of play, we again lose our sense of ritual. The irony of play is that it uses repetition and ritual to discover a new way of seeing the familiar. Better to tilt at windmills, than to see everything as irredeemable. After all, windmills are the comic cross we use to crucify our prophets. It’s good to see Ted lasso a few Emmys along the way.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=38a42cdde081" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[HOW SOCRATIC SCRIBBLING CAN MAKE YOU A BETTER BUSINESS THINKER]]></title>
            <link>https://socratic-scribbler.medium.com/how-socratic-scribbling-can-make-you-a-better-business-thinker-1dbc9d61cfbe?source=rss-ce1b1e71bf4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1dbc9d61cfbe</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Sep 2021 17:14:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-06T17:14:21.335Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*Ipst4Uyut-27LKry" /></figure><p>When we think of preparation for a life of working in business, few people put Philosophy at the top of their list. In today’s obsessive, STEM driven world, many people are calling into question the value of the liberal arts all together. The very thought of sitting around and talking about the nature of truth or justice or beauty seems at best an occupation for people with little else to do. Also, these issues invite constant disagreements which often lead nowhere except for self-righteous speeches and unfriending. And, Philosophy is not even fun. Why spend your leisure time arguing about Natural Law when you could be having cocktails or sex? And, if we dare focus on the key sources of the liberal arts, we are admonished that we are propagating the ideas of privilege developed by dead white guys. So, by this line of thinking, philosophy is definitely impractical, possibly immoral and surely uncomfortable. We tell our children today to major in logistics or robotics or digital do-dah if they want a job.</p><p>I am not here to dispute these opinions. I spent most of my life as a businessman working many years at a big advertising agency called J. Walter Thompson . I worked there from the end of the Mad Men Decade through the beginning of the Digital Divide. This is just before the Era of Fun died.</p><p>I actually was a Philosophy major at a jesuit school called Georgetown and then studied great books at the University of Chicago before venturing into the real world in the 1970s. I was lucky enough never to have a business course in my life, though I did have Calculus, Physics, Chemistry, and Biology as part of my liberal arts degree. Because I had a reputation as somewhat entertaining writer, people recommended that I go into the ad biz. In the seventies, job were scarce but I learned from Herodotus to look for back doors when you want to join the battle. Instead of sending a resume, I stalked Creatives from Leo Burnett after work to their evening watering hole. I bought a few rounds and got an opportunity to talk myself in. This first job ultimately led me to my long term home at J. Walter Thompson.</p><p>Now, ad agencies did employ people with business degrees — the suits — who had MBAs from Northwestern and Harvard — who “coordinated the business” meaning that had martini with olive lunches with the clients. I was what was called a Planner… responsible for figuring out what the hell we were going to say about our clients’ products and services. I worked closely with the Creatives, writers and art directors, who made commercials and ads based upon my Creative Brief.</p><p>It was in this activity that I recognized the true importance and practical relevance of my study of Philosophy. No, we did not sit around and talk about Truth and Goodness. But we did have to dig deep into breakfast cereal, cheese, beer, beef, shaving cream, life insurance, vacations, banking, cars…. and all the other things and activities that make the world go round.</p><p>You think there’s disagreement about the nature of justice? Well try to get agreement on the ideal qualities of beer or toothpaste. Worried about choices or war and peace in the Middle East? Nothing compared to war between chicken and burgers. The metaphysics of End-Dust would befuddle Hume; the invisible hand of Adam Smith could not compete with the shrewd scissors of Thursday coupon clippers. While Kellogg seemed to sell cereal on the basis of social-darwinism, Gerber portrayed baby food as a cute Kantian responsibility.</p><p>The business of advertising made us think hard about what people want and need and how they make their choices. We had to understand the difference between people’s perceptions of things and the realities. The ethics of Aristotle that explore Happiness and Character become transformed into the ethos or reputation of a Brand. We may not have been able to define The Good, but we sure had to define the good of a Midas Muffler. One of the first universal truths I learned from focus groups is that nobody can tell you why they do things. They are like Meno stumbling to expain the nature of virtue to Socrates. Quick, what brand of shampoo do you use and why that brand? If you actually can explain why, you are probably a weirdo. Just sayin’.</p><p>And, it was Plato’s Socrates and boring Aristotle that gave us the tools we needed to create advertising programs that actually worked…the ability to ask and answer questions from a variety of points of view: from the user of a product or service, from the purchaser (often not the user), from the corporation that provided it, to the workers who made it, to the distributors who shelved it, to the transport workers who got it going. The event of getting something to eat involves as many or more systems as does for your body to purchase, prepare, serve, and eat it. The questions are always simple but hard. The first question on our Creative Brief was always: “Who do want to do what?”</p><p>The trick is finding the right questions. That’s what Plato teaches us in those dialogues. Start your answers with examples. Look at both sides. Engage in the dialectics of opposites and exceptions. Work out definitions. (Ries and Trout created a rage with their book on Positioning, which was basically a restatement of how to write an Aristotelian definition!). In the Organanon, Aristotle tells us how we can connect ideas together. He also tells us about the power of examples, images, stories, the shorthand logic of enthymemes (Yes the original memes), fallacies, types of evidence…you name it, he covers it. And Maslow’s famous hierarchy is embarassingly similar to Aristotle’s discussion of happiness.</p><p>As you ask and answer questions, you need to do some sorting as well. Questions and answers come in types and levels. Some questions require no proof or evidence. When you ask somebody directions to the closest grocery store, you do not expect a proof — just a clear sequence of straights, lefts, and rights. Answers to questions must address people’s expectations. A scientific question invites different kind of evidence and proof than a business question. Some questions require not only explanations but also appeals to a hierarchy of goods and preferences. For many, a “healthy” chocolate bar is an oxymoron; for others, it would be ambrosia from the gods, and for old folks like me, it’s EXLAX.</p><p>How we pose and answer questions can raise or lower stakes in making decisions. Think of the surveys that asked “Is it time to leave Afghanistan?” versus, “Should we leave Afghanistan if it means the Taliban will not let girls go to school.” Surveys are only as good as their questions.</p><p>There are lots of books you can buy which claim to help you improve your thinking. You can read the “It’s all brain chemistry” neuro scientists, you have the statisticians talk about “risk management,” you can take advanced logic classes or investigate “artificial intelligence” models. You can “follow the science” of the moment, which will probably change momentarily. You can buy a life coach or guru. I’m not sure any of these methods approach, much less improve on, the ideas of Plato and Aristotle.</p><p>I do not mean to be dismissive to more quantitative approaches to thinking things through. “Let no one ignorant of mathematics enter” says the mythical sign on the Plato’s Academy. Yet, even if you aspire to investment banking, you need more than just the numbers. You need case histories, metaphors, and imagination. One of the most successful investors I know said that he never hired finance majors. “No, I hire people who studied art history. I can teach an art historian how to evaluate a company. (Not as different as evaluating a work of art as you might think. Even DaVinci had liabilities as well as assets.) What I cannot do is help people see the big picture. Maybe I’m being literal, but I like people who know how to understand the big picture. And that’s your art historian” I was sure he was kidding; he was not. And, his firm achieved stellar results.</p><p>I do not entirely blame the “business” or “tech” people for the decline in the appeal of the liberal arts and intelligent literacy. The problem is that many liberal arts schools stopped teaching “original sources”, those so called great books that actually shaped the way we think and talk about things. Who actually reads Einstein or Euclid? No, we are told to read textbooks, written by people with left or right political agendas. “We trade the “so-called hard books” for the babyfood textbooks that Gerber would be ashamed to sell. Do we read the histories of Thucydides and Herodotus and Caesar and Livi? No, we read text book histories, devoid of great questions beyond multiple choice. Why would anyone read less than the original source of a great idea. Let me read Smith and Marx, Freud and James, Jefferson and Martin Luther King, Hegel and Confucious, Keynes and Friedman. I want to know how they think. You may reply that my line of thinking is OK for the humanities, but the math and science need to be as “up to date” as Kansas City. Yes and No. Reading Hippocrates on Medicine, Faraday on electricity, Newton on motion will surprise and shock you with their clarity of thought and their ability to focus on the key issues. They teach us how to think about stuff. ..how to recognize problems and address them. The people who have improved on their theories learned how to think “on the shoulders of giants.” It’s as if schools are afraid of what would happen if we actually read the best people with the best questions and answers.</p><p>You can get a real education to help you think better for the cost of gym membership or less. All you need to do is join a Great Books discussion group, in person or online or both. Start with the Illiad and work your way up through the Greeks, the Romans, the Medievals, and the Moderns through James and Freud. Then, start over. They get more interesting every time you read them. I guess that’s why they call them Great Books. And, you do not have to limit your reading to the Western Classics. People all over the world have been thinking or writing for a long time, and you do not have to search far to find the great ones. And, if you join a discussion group, you’ll find that great books not only enlighten, but also they relight the fun lamp. Oh yeah…And, increasing your knowledge capital doesn’t hurt your personal bottom line. Next time you are trying to sell something to women, use the Austen test…Would Emma Woodhouse buy this?…If not, shelf it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1dbc9d61cfbe" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to use the socratic method to take better notes]]></title>
            <link>https://socratic-scribbler.medium.com/how-to-scribble-reading-notes-in-the-socratic-way-f76163f12f05?source=rss-ce1b1e71bf4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f76163f12f05</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[notes-to-self]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indeed-cards]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[better-notes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[notes-on-reading]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[note-taking-systems]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Aug 2021 17:00:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-23T20:25:33.590Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>HOW TO SCRIBBLE READING NOTES…IN THE SOCRATIC WAY</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*3VdUlaIaDWDqUi0i" /></figure><p>At OnlineGreatBooks many people from around the world are reading the Great Books and meeting in small groups for monthly discussions on Zoom. They are generally following the chronological scheme outlined by Hutchins and Adler. I have the good fortune to host a few of those monthly Great Conversations. The mix of people is startlingly diverse, from young people to retired folks like me, from physicians to nurses, from nuclear scientists to oil rig workers, from airline pilots to active military, from building contractors to plumbers, from atheists to priests, from bankers to high school dropouts, from home schoolers to prep schoolers, from body builders to whiskey connoisseurs.</p><p>When you start to work your way through the Great Books, you unhappily discover that your ability to take good notes gets severely challenged. Great Books are never easy books. You start with the<em> Iliad </em>and have to figure out a way to remember the names of all those warriors and all those gods. And lots of stuff happens on every page. How are you supposed to remember everything? Sometimes questions or ideas occur to you. Why is Agamemnon such a jerk? Is Tom Brady more like Achilles or Hector? Words and phrases like “rosy fingered dawn” keep showing up. What should you write down?</p><p>When you get to Herodotus <em>History, </em>things can seem totally out of control. Hundred of pages full of hundreds of unfamiliar names and dates and places peppered with highly entertaining digressions on rivers and giant ants. How could you ever pass a multiple choice test after one or even ten readings? Well, maybe you shouldn’t.</p><p>In Adler’s <em>How to Read A Book, </em>he recommends, somewhat scandalously, writing notes in the margins of the books and underlining important words and phrases. He also suggests writing a brief summary of the key points and definitions of key terms. Some of the Great Books people use the Cornell method that they learned in school, dividing a sheet in two columns, one for a paginated index of anything you want to remember, the other column for your own comments and key division markers. Others use Ryan Holliday’s and Robert Greene’s variation on the old Commonplace Books where you note anything of interest on index cards, a system likely borrowed from high school research paper courses. A few people take the index card system even further, trying to follow Nicholas Luhrman’s <em>Zettelkasten, </em>a sophisticated filing system. Indeed, note taking systems can be a little dangerous to people who border on Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (that would be me). We suffer too much from fear of forgetting. We probably collected baseball cards as kids.</p><p>The temptation of the Cornell methods is to take too many notes. You suddenly have reams of notebook pages full of names, snatches of dialogue, epithets, little summaries, questions…in two columns! By the time we’ve put the “meaning of the book” in our own words, our notes are almost as long as the book itself! How do you find that compelling scene with Andromache? The same can hold true with index cards. It’s easy to create a stack big enough for Triple Solitaire. Here’s one card for a vocabulary word, here’s another card with a great description of a battle death, and here’s the number of Achaean ships, by origin, and….</p><p>I haven’t even touched on all the new digital alternatives for taking and organizing reading notes. Just shoot a picture of anything you want to remember. Or try Evernote and then combine it with….</p><p>I fear that as long as we search for an ideal system for notetaking, we are doomed to failure. Why? Because the best way to take notes for any endeavor will depend on what you want to do with those notes.</p><p>This can even get more befuddling if you are trying to integrate your reading notes with all the other kinds of writing and learning and performing you may do. Do you keep a journal? Write stories? Prepare meetings at work? Give speeches? Collect butterflies? (Nabakov did and also wrote his novels on index cards. Hmmm.)</p><p><em>What is a note, anyway? Notes help us remember stuff. And we want to remember stuff so we can answer questions. We want those answers to help us accomplish things in life. The quality and relevance of our notes will depend on the quality and relevance of our questions!</em></p><p>So, let’s suppose that we are reading a novel, say, Cervantes’ <em>Don Quixote. </em>What notes, if any, should I take? Imagine you are reading it for a bookclub, and you are going to have a discussion of the book over port and brie next month. Do you need to take any notes? Well, what will you need to be an active participant in the discussion? You will probably need to remember the basic story, what we might call the plot. The problem is that this book is over a thousand pages long. Lots of stuff happens. That’s why they call it “picaresque.” You’ll probably want to remember the names of the characters in the story…except there are several hundred!</p><p>What you need to recall may also depend on the nature of the book group. If everyone at the gathering is an academic who speaks Spanish, well good luck playing “Smartest Guy in the Room.”</p><p>In our Great Book conversations we try to stay focused on the book under discussion, because that is the book we all share. We try to avoid bringing in outside expertise. Yet a chat about Cervantes certainly invites comparisons to Shakespeare and Montaigne and Sterne and Joyce. Where do we draw the lines.Or do we need to?</p><p>This is where Socrates can help us. When we are reading, we must address two sets of questions. First, there are the questions that the book addresses, whatever the genre. Second, there are the questions that are important to us. Third, there are the questions that other readers of the book have asked. The overlap of those questions is where the magic lies for the pleasure and enlightenment of reading and conversation.</p><p>This simple socratic insight has led me to organize my reading and my notes for just about everything by questions. I like to think of questions and answers as if they were shots in a movie. Some shots give us a panoramic picture of the whole scene, some shots have the camera move with the action, some shots focus our attention on some kind of physical or verbal interaction, some shots go in for the close up of a detail, and some shots get tricky, peeking over a shoulder. The point is that questions, like movie shots, always have a scope and a depth and an angle…drawing and following the viewer’s interest. A reading note is really a way to triangulate on a passage or idea.</p><p>So, for <em>Don Quixote, </em>I write down brief answers and copy passages that address panoramic questions like: What is the overall event or change that holds the story together? <em>Don Quixote </em>comes in two volumes, which also include reference to an original source and also a rip-off story by someone other than Cervantes. And the story itself includes several tales, one the length of a novella, told by one of the characters in the book. (Now we know where Faulkner stole those infuriating narratives.) How do you summarize this complex tome?</p><p>Well, underlying all those pages and all that complexity is a relatively simple story, beginning with a man in his fifties deciding to become a knight errant and then proceeding to find a squire called Sancho. They embark on several quests, inspired somehow by Quixote’s fantasy woman named Dulcinea. Family and friends in his hometown worry that he has gone crazy. The people he meets on his quests respond to his wild claims with anything from hostility to exploitation to games of <em>let’s pretend </em>to actual attempts to help.Finally Quixote’s friends and family get him home where he dies in bed, surrounded by people who love him but questioning the value of his adventures. The various ways different characters in the story respond to Don Quixote’s actions provides a panoply of issues and ideas from from the metaphysical (how do any of us know what’s real) to the political (the power of the king and aristocracy to Spain’s expulsion of Moors) to the power of love (amorous and practical) to the nature of friendship and loyalty to…just about anything you want to talk about over a glass of wine.</p><p>Your panoramic summary would surely be different than mine, but both of us would have a version of the big story and the elements in that story of particular relevance to ourselves. The point is that despite the novel’s length and complexity, each of us can summarize our idea of what the novel is about in a few sentences that would fit on a couple of index cards. And our panoramic summary says as much about us as it does the book we are reading.</p><p>We would probably also want to write down a description of passages in the book that somehow impressed us the most…the things you want to discuss close-up. Why would we need more than a dozen, unless we were working on our own book? Good idea to jot down the page numbers of our citations or quotes.</p><p>If we aremaking a systematic study of the book, we might also want to write index card length summaries of each chapter…over 150 of those mid shots for DonQuixote. Some books, like some events, require only a few snapshots. Others, like weddings or a new baby, require an album. Let the purpose of your reading drive the questions you need to address in your notes.</p><p>Who and what are the people, places, conflicts, actions, ideas and language that drive the central event in the story? What questions does it provoke and explore in the story? How is it similar to other great stories that came before or after? Different?</p><p><em>Don Quixote</em>, like th<em>e Decammeron</em> or <em>Canterbury Tales</em> contains many stories within the the key overall frame of Don Quixote’s adventures. For a simple discussion of the book I did not think I needed to account for each of those stories so much as ask a question concerning the overall role of all these stories that lie within the DonQuixote story. Both books and people tend to be the sum of their stories.</p><p>As a rule, whether our question is panoramic or close up, we can answer each of these questions briefly on its own index card or half sheet of paper. We can also list about ten key passages and their page numbers on one or two cards or slips. And I can write additional answers to additional questions I think might be interesting to me or to the reading group, including some of my own thoughts or comparisons.</p><p>You might well ask different questions than I do. Great. Won’t we have a wonderful conversation sharing our views on the questions we share and enlightening each other on questions that did not occur to us.</p><p>So, the procedure works like this: When I read a book, I read through quickly so I can enjoy the story or follow the argument without much worry about notes. When I encounter something I might want to recall later(a person, place, thing, passage, vocabulary word, etc) I just put a check mark in the margin. For <em>Don Quixote</em> I had hundreds of check marks. When I “finish” the book, I decide on the key questions I think I will need for my purposes. I make a list on an index card. I’ll want to remember the names of the key characters, so I’ll take an index card, label it KEY CHARACTERS?, look through all my check marks and list them on a card or two, with the page number where they were first introduced. I’ll do the same for new vocabulary words, the overall plot outline, short list of back stories with their key characters, etc. Since<em> DonQuixote </em>is such a long and rich book, I think I ended up with about twenty or thirty cards, each with its own question and answer. Since each card is limited to one specific question, I can flip through the cards easily to find something quickly or to review before a conversation. If I were “studying” the book or wanting to write an essay about it, I would use the appropriate questions for those purposes. Again, organizing by questions allows me great flexibility while giving me strength of focus. Also, I must page through the book reviewing my check marks for each question and answer card. This repetition provides a thorough review and memory enhancement. I usually save my list of key passages for last, because by then I have a pretty good idea of what I want to share with others.</p><p>When I am done with the book and my notes, I put the cards or slips in an envelope with the name of the author and book title. If I go back to the book for another read, I’ll review my previous notes and perhaps write a few additional thoughts.</p><p>Please observe that the Socratic way of note taking is not wedded to cards, slips, or any particular medium. I have come to believe those choices are highly driven by personal experience, technical expertise, and taste. If each note focuses on one question, then whatever the medium, your notes will be easy to sort and arrange in the order you want. What is key: organizing by questions and answers. How do you determine the questions? That depends on what you intend to do with your experience of the book.</p><p>Of course, not all books are novels. Different kinds of books invite us to ask different kinds of questions as we read them.</p><p>The good thing about this method is that it encourages us to organize our ideas by the questions we think the book evokes or provokes. Each book becomes our own Socrates, challenging us about the way we see our world and what we think is important. Great books have a way of opening our minds to the great questions and the important answers given by whe world’s best thinkers and writers. The significant questions are never in some teacher’s multiple choice test. The big questions are deep in your psyche, yearning to be set free with the help of great writers and thinkers…and that second glass of wine.</p><p>The Socratic question/answer way of organizing notes and information has many applications beyond taking notes, from journaling to planning, from writing to problem solving. Indeed, writing down questions and answers is a great way to pick your own brain. How do you even know what you think until you write it down. We can discuss these questions and answers in other Socratic Scribblings. And then we have to find a way to organize all these notes we might write…journals, projects, dream diaries, ideas for books and articles, math problems….When it comes to note taking systems, I suspect we are all tilting at windmills.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f76163f12f05" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[SOCRATIC SCRIBBLER ON HOW TO THINK AHEAD]]></title>
            <link>https://socratic-scribbler.medium.com/socratic-scribbler-on-how-to-think-ahead-d92d1de3972b?source=rss-ce1b1e71bf4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d92d1de3972b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[happiness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[planning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 25 Jul 2021 19:39:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-25T19:39:01.043Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*mhCGKyJ_kjtEUUTxeHRh5Q.png" /></figure><p>When was the last time you said, “Hmmm, I’ll think about it.” When we say that, just what do we intend to do? All kinds of books on Amazon promise to show us how to think better. Many of them tell us how the brain works, you know, the ones written by those neurosomethings. But wait…after they tell us how our mental engine works, they forget to show us how to drive. In college, you may have taken a course in logic where you learned that thinking is, well, just another math course with elaborate proofs and twisted problems. Or if you were a business major, maybe you took a course in “decision making” only to find out that it was a statistics course in disguise. And, now that the liberal arts are a long lost cause, schools today seems to be where we learn <em>what </em>to think rather than<em> how</em> to think. Even if we just want practical training to make a living, something like digital programming, we end up making digital maps for machines. Who is making our maps? Who is doing the thinking for us?</p><p>Are you woke? Are you a fox fed conservative? What do you think about China? Is there too much government or too little? Too much spending or too many taxes? Lots of people are not only willing but are also poshly paid to tell you what to think. Is childcare considered infrastructure? Is there a vaccine to protect us against viral thinking? Maybe it is the selection of words. Maybe instead of saying “I will think on it”, we are better off muttering “I will chew on it” or “I will mull it over” or “Let me play with it” or “Let’s run it up the flag pole and see if anybody salutes.”</p><p>What do we actually end up doing when we say ‘I’ll think on it”? Well, if we are trying to make a choice of some kind, say which apartment to rent while you are in Denver on some assignment, we might make a chart comparing and contrasting each apartment with a list of criteria. And you will generate these criteria based on the things that you might think are important.</p><p>Indeed, when we look at specific cases of thinking, we realize that we are engaging in the activities of list making, mind mapping, side by side comparing. These help us lay out the “facts” in a vivid way that can show the relationship of one fact to another. Making a list is very useful when we just want to understand what’s going on. We work like TV detectives discussing a big white board.</p><p>What our list or map does <em>not</em> tell us is the importance of each factoid. And importance is a tricky kind of triangle, for it involves not only how one fact is connected to another (the logic of situation) but also the role each fact plays in our lives (the drama of our situation). I just need the apartment for three months while I do business in Denver, but the apartment needs to be someplace where “I can jog every morning to keep sane and located in a place that my girlfriend will want to come visit me and….”</p><p>How do we figure out the importance of each of our criteria? Is the size of the apartment more or less important than the location? Parking? Distance from the airport? Commute time to the office? In order to determine the importance of each of our criteria, we need to recognize the “event” that drives our desire for the apartment in the first place. Thinking is the way we navigate through the events of our lives trying to fulfill our desires…from getting married to introducting a new product, to buying a fish, to correcting a child, to starting a new job. When you think about it, everything is not really even a thing.</p><p>Everything is an <em>event </em>because all things come and go in time. And time is always a three act play: a before, a now, and an after. Even the mountains and the stars emerged and evolved and will ultimately be transformed into some other event.</p><p>Living in three acts demands that we answer those awful Why questions. If I do not know why I am moving to Denver for three months, then how could I possibly have any criteria for shopping and choosing an apartment there. Every list needs a Why.</p><p>The event of our moving to Denver for three months is driven by previous events with the intention of generating some kind of future event. We’re moving the Denver to do something, to make things happen…for our job and for ourselves, for the skiing.</p><p>Thinking always seems to be a part of doing or making something. What we are doing will define the scope and direction of our thinking, the scope of our lists and the weight or value we place on each item of our list. If we are doing math, we should think like a mathematician. If we are sailing a boat, we should think like a sailor. If we are in love, we should think like a lover. If we are techies, we should think like techies, if we are writers, we should have a cocktail.</p><p>That sounds like a lot work, because all of us play a lot of roles in life. And you will have to balance one role with another, one kind of thinking and doing with another — the job that takes you to Denver and the girlfriend you leave behind in Cincinnati. How do we figure out this balance?</p><p>Sounds like we might need role models. How do we balance our different desires and intentions? Can thinking be taught?</p><p>It is easy to imagine thinking and logic as unemotional and cold. “Euclid alone looked on beauty bare,” sings Saint Edna. Yet, if you’ve ever watched a math professor solve an impossible problem on a blackboard and then watch how she steps back to gaze at her work, as if she had just made love to Cary Grant and was still savoring the moment…well, it’s impossible to think of math as unemotional.</p><p>In his Ethics, Aristotle tells us that each of our actions is the result of some desire…something we want to do or to make …something we want to change into something somehow better. We may discover that we made a mistake, that what we thought would be better is actually worse, but it was that desire that got us thinking and moving in the first place.</p><p>When we are reading books in school, we are taught to figure out what the author is saying or thinking. “What does Shakespeare say about ambition in Macbeth?” “What does Herodotus think about freedom?” The older I get, the more frustrated I am with these kind of quiz kid questions.</p><p>Was Shakespeare just trying to <em>say </em>something or was he actually trying to accomplish something, to make a script to do a play that would delight and instruct? Is it a matter of what the three witches are saying in Act One, scene one? Or is it even a matter of what Shakespeare is trying to “say” in that scene? Isn’t the important question more abot what Shakespeare is trying to do with those witches in dramatizing his story. What is their role in the story? When Fr. Vernon used to ask our high school English class, “What does Shakespeare mean when he says…..blah by blah….?” I raised my hand and replied, “I guess he meant just the words he wrote for Lady Macbeth to say…otherwise he would have used different words.” Fr. Vernon never really liked me. Apparently I was supposed to learn that in order to understand great writing we had to translate the great writing into not so great writing. If poetry is the best expression of a thought or a feeling, why do we need other words to explain it? Now, if you tell me that Lady Macbeth changes the way you think about love between a husband and wife, a love bonded in the eros murder and power…that might make you more cautious in your romantic life or it might excite and incite you to do a Bonnie and Clyde adventure. Is poetry a set of words waiting to be translated into other words or is it designed to change the way we see the world and our roles in it?</p><p>Is the question, “What do I think about this apartment?” or is it better to ask, “What role could this apartment play in my life.” What can I do here? What can I make? That would give us the criteria to make our lists.</p><p>Years ago, Jerome Bruner made the observation that we think in two ways: in logic and in stories. Science wants us to be objective, to put logic first and set the story and the emotion aside. Good luck with that. If logic is the way we human folks are supposed to think, then we must always remember that it is part of our story.</p><p>Kenneth Burke, borrowing from Aristotle, tells us that we should look at our life and our world as an unravelling drama. This drama consists of a simple set of key elements:</p><ul><li>The settings and scenery we inhabit</li><li>The people or characters we encounter</li><li>The agendas triggered and planned by our desires</li><li>The language and ideas we use to express those desires</li><li>The actions we initiate to fulfill those desires</li><li>The obstacles generated by our conflicting agendas</li><li>The resulting consequences that round out the story…all of these in a sequence of events or scenes creating befores, nows, and futures.</li></ul><p>With a dramatic model as insightful and comprehensive as Burke’s, you could write a play as good as <em>Macbeth</em> or pick an apartment in Denver. You could plan a day or a life. You could start a business. Or, like me, you could have spent a working life develop successful, and some not so successful, communication programs for Fortune 500 companies</p><p>In this world of drama, thinking is neither absolute nor relative. Desire drives the action, action drives the dialogue, and dialoge drives the thinking that leads to agendas of action. And conflicting desires make us think and choose.</p><p>Until you figure out what you really desire, until then, no list, no thinking, no action will help. In life, we get to play our roles, but we don’t have much control over the script. Could the universe just be a giant improv theater with all of us tilting at our own windmills?</p><p>Aristotle tells us that we are driven by our natural desire to do good and to be happy. How do we find out what we desire? Look at what you have done and made. What do those actions and creations tell you about your desires? When have your plans worked out? When not? Aristotle would ask you to reflect on what makes you happy. I remember my father giving me the good advice that… “In order to think ahead, you sometimes have to think back.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d92d1de3972b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE SOCRATIC SCRIBBLER ON BLANK PAGES and GRAND COLLISIONS]]></title>
            <link>https://socratic-scribbler.medium.com/the-socratic-scribbler-on-blank-pages-and-grand-collisions-571ec1755d1f?source=rss-ce1b1e71bf4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/571ec1755d1f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Jul 2021 03:29:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-05T03:29:18.140Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*QPNtcJFY7B6aidRW" /></figure><p><strong>THE SOCRATIC SCRIBBLER ON BLANK PAGES and GRAND COLLISIONS</strong></p><p>Trapped home during the plague, my wife Karen and I joined a faith group of several people who meet on Zoom early Saturday mornings to discuss the scripture readings for Sunday’s mass. We begin by reading the passages aloud, then we take a solitary “meditation” break for twenty mintues, and then return to discuss.</p><p>During my twenty minute meditation period, my mind seems to go blank. My thoughts just seem to echo memories of things I had heard or read about the scripture passages. Although I am supposed to use my meditation time to have an “authentic encounter” with a spiritual text, I still tend to react like I am in school…looking for an idea to impress the teacher and other students. In <em>Loss of the Creature, </em>Walker Percy talks about a similar experience. Percy tells us that it is impossible to see the Grand Canyon “for real” because of all those beautiful postcards. If we get to the canyon, we approve with the praise “Looks just like the postcard.” I had an identical experience the first time I saw the Eiffel Tower. This is why I try to avoid landmarks; they seem like cultural cliches. I did not know how to begin looking at the Taj Mahal or the Great Wall when I saw them from the tour buses, other than to kind of verify that they are, yup, there. I’ve seen images of the Mona Lisa a million times in books, and I did a walk by once in the gallery. I’m not sure I’ve ever really looked at it.</p><p>When somebody asks me what I think or feel about something important like God or love or evil or the Statue of Liberty, the truth is that I usually have no idea what I’m thinking or feeling. I do not think I am alone in this. I wrote <em>Socratic Scribbling</em> trying to help people find something to say when they sit down to write. Anyone who has ever tried to keep a journal knows what I mean. You sit down ready to enter your great insights and observations for the day, and you end up just writing your shopping list.</p><p>Fortunately, on occasion, there are times when I do know what I think. What’s the best way to get to Miami, who will I vote for as Mayor, how should we market the Great Books to a world that now thinks that they are politically incorrect?</p><p>So, what empowers us to have an authentic opinion about something? I think we have real opinions when we are actually trying to do or accomplish something. These are times when we have to make choices, when we put ourselves a bit at risk. You have to think and plan when you give a birthday party, look for a job, or correct a child. We have to think ahead and make choices. When we think and plan, things don’t always turn out the way we expect or want, but they still somehow make sense…as a success to enjoy or a failure to negotiate.. The folks who fix the elevator in the Eiffel Tower may not know its history, but they know all about the quirks of the elevator. When we do not think and plan, things just sort of happen. The Marine drill sergeant orders us to “Move with a purpose!” We also must think with a purpose, with an interest.</p><p>Many years ago, about a dozen of us were taking a class about Chaucer from William Ringler, a wiley professor. On our desks, we all had our new “critical edition” of Chaucer’s works. Ringler assigned us a simple bit of homework for the next week. He gave each of us a different “minor” poem included in the text and told us to come back next week and tell the class why we thought Chaucer did in fact write the poems he gave us. The next week we all appeared after spending hours looking at microfilm and researching every factoid about our poems. We all reported that, unfortunately, we could not find much evidence that Chaucer had, in fact, written our poems…included as Chaucer’s in the critical edition…indeed, there was a very good chance the poems were written by someone else. Beyond a lack of any solid manuscript evidence, the words and style of the poems did not fit very well with Chaucer’s “other”works. Ringler also pointed out something to us about each of our poems: the sources of each of the poems were on the last pages of manuscripts that held a longer work by Chaucer. Our hypothesis: once the scribe had finished copying the Chaucer work, he could not waste very expensive writing materials, so he filled up the space with poetry by others. These could then easily be mistaken as Chaucer’s, with the error compounded in edition after edition of Chaucer’s works. Suddenly, Chaucer was no longer the Grand Canyon. We were not sure where Chaucer started or ended, and we could not count on even very smart scholars to always be guides. We had to do our own Chaucer hike.</p><p>When the Eiffel Tower just becomes a way of proving to yourself that you are in Paris, well then a glimpse and a smile is all you need. I am more likely to go back to Paris for the food than for the Tower. Sometimes places will shock you. I went to Berlin a few years ago on business, and I was amazed how hip everyone looked walking down Ku’damn avenue. People my age, fellow septuagenarians, sported fashionable purple jackets and orange hair. Everybody looked as if they were en route to a club that played amazing jazz. People in Chicago, where I live, walk more invisibly and more vigilantly, especially when cars drive by slowly. Unfortunately it is not music that is making us a little jumpy.</p><p>Aristotle in his <em>Organon</em> is occasionally given credit for collecting and sorting the first organized grammar and logic of thinking. Beyond the formal procedures of subject and predicate, Aristotle begins with an amazing insight: We can only understand or explain one thing in terms of something else. If you let that idea sink in for a minute, you become a befuddling Bavarian philosopher pronouncing that you can only know what is by <strong>what it is not</strong>. (This is when you wisely decide<strong> not </strong>to become a philosophy major). Still the idea gets particularly useful when we encounter something new to us. We can only understand the unfamiliar in terms of something familiar. Aristotle also reminds us of an obvious but important fact: when we put things in language, that language must be thought or spoken or written. And then those words must be read or heard, by ourselves or someone else. We are always writing to someone else or to ourselves, perhaps even trying to persuade ourselves of something. It’s hard, if not impossible, to separate our ideas from our relationships with the world, with other people, and even with ourselves. Ideas and words seem to be about how we make connections.</p><p>Scribbling questions and answers teaches me that I can only make authentic encounters with Grand People, Places, Events, and Passages by trying to connect them to something familiar — to my own life experiences — not an expert’s guide. I can only see through my eyes, not somebody else’s. When I do this, I remember the first time I saw the Eiffel tower — in a 1950s documentary on tv showing Hitler dancing in the streets after his conquest of Paris. That memory shows the pride of Paris, even in defeat, standing tall and still elegant while a killer clown dances. It is the role things and people play in events that connect them to us, that give us opinions to write. When I do this, I am not just seeing…I am looking. If knowledge is just knowing what something it is, it can go on being what it is without any help from us. But when we connect what we are looking at with our own memories and experiences, new connections are made. The Mona Lisa is no longer just an old image on a wall; by connecting with us, it has a future.</p><p>The page is never blank when we connect a new experience with the old and let them collide and connect. It is collisions of our new experiences with ingrained memories that are the cure for the blank page. You let your mind wander in the desert. Eventually it will take you home with something new to say.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=571ec1755d1f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[WHY THE SOCRATIC SCRIBBLER MISSES THE DAILY NEWSPAPER — THE ONE MADE OUT OF PAPER —]]></title>
            <link>https://socratic-scribbler.medium.com/why-the-socratic-scribbler-misses-the-daily-newspaper-the-one-made-out-of-paper-6da592a73ca7?source=rss-ce1b1e71bf4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6da592a73ca7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Jun 2021 20:57:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-17T20:57:15.457Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xhJ-eloDrPbo-ME2" /></figure><p>WHY THE SOCRATIC SCRIBBLER MISSES THE DAILY NEWSPAPER — THE ONE MADE OUT OF PAPER —</p><p>Have you been finding your life a bit chaotic, adrift, almost random…bouncing from one thing to another? This seems to be more and more true of everyone I know, but especially young people who seem to be triggered primarily by the last tweet.</p><p>At first, I attributed this to the pandemic. Wearing masks and not being next to people you care about can surely make all of us a little crazy and some of us a big crazy. That said, I suspect there is more to it than a mere plague.</p><p>I’m an old man. I grew up with the daily newspaper stretched in front of my face, not a mask.. Indeed, as a kid it was my job to go out on the porch and find it buried somewhere in the bushes where the paperboy had tossed it at 4 AM. And, fetching that paper was no pleasure on cold, wet days in Chicago. Worse, I later ended up being that 4 AM guy pitching the papers.</p><p>So, you might think I welcome the digitalization of that cold soggy rag. Not so.</p><p>Let’s take the old Sunday newspaper for example. For us, it was the<em> Chicago Tribune</em> and the<em> New York Times</em>. They were big thick things, full of sections: Global and national news, followed by local or metro news, then followed by just about every category of life: Home, Real Estate, Business, Travel, Auto, Classified Sales, Sports, Comics, Health, Education, Books, Movies, Theatre, Entertainment, Gossip, Restaurants, Home Decoration, Food and Cooking, Holiday Planning, Gifts and Gadgets, Household Tips, Romance Advice. Political Opinions, Local Loud Mouth Columnist (Mike Royko, Jimmy Bresslin) Religion… in effect those categories of our lives and our world that are always changing. And throughout were sprinkled wonderful display and classified ads, letting us know how to increase and decrease our store of goods and fashion. The newspaper would tell us what is New, that is… different…than yesterday, including the obituaries, reminding us there would be a last call for us all. And every personal ad could be decoded into a mystery thriller.</p><p>The newspaper also taught us how to put ideas and images together. I have yet to see a meme as good as the old front page political cartoons. The business section and the sports page taught us how to read tables and graphs. Just by being there, headlines taught us how to find the actual news in the story. Why we could even learn how to play chess or improve our vocabulary with crosswords.</p><p>You may reply: Yes, but all these things still exist in their own way online..these and more. Yes, but they are all scattered, bits of body with no souls… incoherent, random, scattered atoms in ether, like a Lucretian death.</p><p>When you picked up the newspaper and literally thumbed through the sections and finger licked through the pages, your brain was tangibly reminded that the world consists of all these things and events. It also implied that you need to think about all these things in relation to yourself and your world. Some things you could ignore; others would become passions; some more relevant when you were young, others when you became a parent. But you were invited to think about them. Indeed, the people who actually read the newspaper every day seemed, well, a little smarter and more informed than the rest of us. We would know to go to them for advice.</p><p>Is it me or have digital social media absorbed all other news into one giant Gossip Column? So and so says. Isn’t that terrible? Did you hear what so and so did? What else would you expect?</p><p>Newspapers don’t work well online. You start to read a headline story that sparks your interest , and then you are shuffled to other links based on some clandestine math formula…until you are through a rabbit hole of propoganda and micro-targeted ads just for you. Your so called “browser” is anything but…you are being tracked and steered and taken for a ride and a pick-pocketing.</p><p>Do you ever sit down with your shrink or go on a retreat for a few days…pause… and rethink your life? Do you try to decide what you should change and what you should continue? Do you forget what you should be thinking about? Do you forget to plan? Do you wait until your boss fires you or your wife divorces you before you think back or think ahead? Do you let life happen or do you actively engage? Do you need to become more entrepreneurial to make a living, do you want to travel, what books should you read, how do you find a mate? To think about this stuff means we have to thumb through the sections in our mind and think about how we are doing and where we want to go with it. I fear, unless this list is etched in our minds, we will just wander in the gossip column and nobody will ever plan anything, cooperate and play well with others, and get anything done.</p><p>When you sit down to plan your life, you have to run through the same checklists that organized that daily and weekly newspaper. You have to think about Romance, Family, Health, Wealth, Home, Car…..keep on thumbing. The problem is that we now have a whole generation that does not know the checklist. We are forgetting the questions we ought to be asking ourselves. Does anybody even use their thumbs anymore…except to text while driving? How do you think anything trough plan anything out of the gossip news online and on cable…except perhaps something wicked? People without a plan rarely win the game or even play good improvisational jazz. Everyday followers of St. Ignatius ask themselves a few questions before they go to bed, including “Where did I see God today?” Followers of late night social media are lucky to remember to ask themselves if they brushed their teeth.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6da592a73ca7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[HOW ARISTOTLE AND ADVERTISING CAN HELP YOU PLAN YOUR LIFE…]]></title>
            <link>https://socratic-scribbler.medium.com/the-socratic-scribbler-on-life-planning-from-aristotle-to-pantyhose-e368c2abe59f?source=rss-ce1b1e71bf4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e368c2abe59f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Jun 2021 17:32:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-16T16:48:16.722Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/494/0*2C6fecueluRhBcrU" /></figure><p>Just about any self-help guide to life planning will recommend that we start by asking ourselves some tough Socratic Questions. The problem is that they are are not so easy to answer. .</p><ul><li>Where’s your life right now? How has it changed in the past year? For the better? Worse? What caused these changes?</li><li>Where do you want to take your life? What would make you happy now? Five years from now?</li><li>What changes need to happen for you to achieve that happiness?</li><li>Which of these changes are actually in your control or within your power. What are the realistic choices and actions that you can actually take?</li><li>What actions do you need to take to make those changes? In what order?</li><li>What resources or help do you need to take those actions?</li><li>How will you know that your actions will be effective? What will be different?</li><li>What is your Plan B, if your actions fail?</li></ul><p>These questions can seem overwhelming. The problem is that asking how well your life is working for you now and how you want to change it covers way too much territory.</p><p>Nonetheless, these questions are the same questions I had to ask all the time during my thirty some years in advertising. To develop our business and creative plans for the wares we were peddling, we put the prospective customers on the couch and asked…. may be happy with your job but hate your romantic life. You may be happy with your health but unhappy with your appearance. If I break up with my girlfriend, does that mean I’m going to chew more gum?</p><p>Here, again, is where we want to follow Aristotle’s advice in his <em>Ethic</em>s and recognize that our happiness depends upon the fulfillment of our desires. And, Aristotle noted that our desires actually can be organized into a manageable list.</p><p>According to Aristotle, we all desire good things for</p><ul><li>Our mind…pleasure and utility of learning and knowing new things that can enrich our lives</li><li>Our physical and mental health</li><li>Our physical appearance and attractiveness</li><li>Our personality..self confidence, likability, ambition</li><li>Our virtues: courage, prudence, wisdom, justice, magnanimity…our vices…gluttony, lust, envy….</li><li>Our family — parents, children, spouse, extended family</li><li>Our friends — past and present</li><li>Romance — love and sex</li><li>Our work, job, business, vocation…how we spend our time to support ourselves and others</li><li>Our network of colleagues and resources</li><li>Our finances and wealth</li><li>Our home</li><li>Our rest and relaxation</li><li>Time and information management</li><li>Access to technology</li><li>Our community — neighborhood, city, state, nation, the world</li><li>Transportation — so we can go the places we need or want</li><li>Our knowledge and skills</li><li>Our affiliations, clubs, charities, political commitments</li><li>Our social status</li><li>Our spiritual life</li></ul><p>Depending on your stage in life, your philosophy, and your own dreams, you may add some things to the list by enlarging one of the topics… like romance or work as you look for a new mate or job. Also, at different stages in life, different items are more or less important. Romance can be a big deal from high school into your twenties, where health and wealth get very important when you retire.</p><p>This checklist is also reasonably manageable… around twenty items. When you go for your annual physical, the doctors have a longer checklist list which they manage get through in an hour or so. An airplane pilot has an even longer checklist before he takes off. (Or, so we hope) Note also, that the importance of various items on a doctor’s checklist will be also driven by your stage in life. Now, imagine going through Aristotle’s list of goods and asking our Socratic questions about how you are doing in each of these areas of human desire. Are you satisfied with your social status? Do you have the knowledge and skills you need to achieve the wealth you want to secure? Are you likable? The list demands that you make some choices and rankings. It forces you to confront your strengths and your weaknesses.</p><p>The amazing result of doing this exercise is that you really can get a feel for how happy you are and where you think you need to make some changes. Your list also needs to include what is going on in the world. Which trends or events in the world are working to your benefit and which are not? If you are in Texas you may see your property value increase; if you are in Illinois, maybe you should move to Florida for lower taxes.</p><p>Imagine that you follow the the sage advice of Ryan Holiday, Nicholas Luhrman, and your high school English teacher and use a stack of index cards, slips of paper, or a sortable computer program to make some twenty master lists for yourself. Let’s pretend we are using old fashioned index cards.</p><p>On the first index card, you would write Health and then answer the question of how you are doing and what needs to change. On the next card, you might write Romance and then write down how you are doing and why. “Women avoid me because I’m fat.” Being fat may also appear on your Health card. Looks like an area you want to address for some kind of change. You may decide you like being fat. Well, then, you need to become a happy fat fellow, attractive in many other ways. Perk up your wardrobe and personality. Get rich. While you may never win romance with someone seriously adverse to your hefty size, others will find that your weighty wallet more than compensates. Yet, your doctor may come into play, saying…’I don’t care if you did get a pretty girlfriend, if you keep packing on the pounds I promise you’ll be dead at forty.” Well now, you will need to re-evaluate. As you do this exercise, you will have many interesting conversations with yourself…in the Socratic Way.</p><p>Once you do this master exercise, then you can turn your insights into a real plan of action with a specific list of projects to accomplish. Now you will make your master list…the projects that you set for yourself in each area, from painting your kitchen to sending a birthday present to an old friend.</p><p>I confess that I developed this way of evaluating situations for my work as a strategic planner in advertising at J. Walter Thompson. I did this in my twenties, with ideas I stole from Aristotle. (By the way, my study of Aristotle proved much more useful to my work progress than any business book I ever read) For each client, I filled out my index cards for each important area in a checklist I developed for my work. These checklists would, in turn, lead to my specific projects for each brand. I would review my project list every day, and ta da, a proper to do list for the day would magically emerge. On my desk, I had an index card for every project, usually about thirty going on, with a scheduled checklist of actions. I would thumb through them quickly each evening, and make a list for the next day.</p><p>This part was not as easy as it sounds. With all those projects we have in life, which should we do first? Which should we spend most of our time on? This is the dilemma the efficiency experts call Urgency versus Importance. Some things just get important because they are urgent, like hustling to the bathroom. But if we keep running after urgencies, when do we get those big, important things done. How do we turn a million things into Jack Palance’s ONE THING?</p><p>Arisototle has a trick that we advertising people call “laddering.” That means trying to figure out which desires make the most difference overall.</p><p>The advertising campaign for Hanes Panty Hose is a classic case.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*AZ4G2Dz5xsfCgR1U" /></figure><p>Hanes had successfully introduced L’eggs in a clever, fun egg shaped package back 1969 to fit the happy, sexy mood of the the 70s as baby boom women entered the labor market. L’eggs were priced lower than ladies hosiery and distributed in drug stores rather than department stores. Women loved them. At the same time, Hanes management knew that music and fashion change and that there was an opening in the market for a more premium pantyhose. Some women were advancing in their careers. They were putting aside their mini skirts and wanted to look more stylish with padded shoulders and big hair. That means they were ready to spend more money. Hanes now had to figure out how their new Hanes pantyhose could be worth more. They had sold L’eggs on the notion of fit…”Our L’eggs fit your legs”…a real issue and problem at the time, and the egg shaped package reinforced that idea in a suggestive feminine way. Now, how to sell the Hanes flagship brand?</p><p>I’m now telling the story as it was presented to me at a luncheon many years ago by someone who worked on the campaign. Apparently, their team worked with Maslow’s version of Aristotle’s goods…his pyramid of needs and wants, starting at the bottom with the physical security of food and shelter, moving up to sensual pleasure, moving still higher practical function, moving up to cost, convenience, and performance, still higher to romance, to social position, to self power and actualization. Working your way up the pyramid was called “laddering” a product and service’s benefits. Aristotle called it inclusiveness or necessary conditions, meaning you can’t get one thing until you have the other. It’s difficult to worry about the taste of your food if you don’t have shelter; and, if you are a gourmet, odds are you have a few bucks or a lot of cooking skill or both.</p><p>So, Hanes knew that L’eggs already owned fit and even fun in pantyhose. They also knew that women who bought more premium fashion tended to be more stylish. But what did that mean? Why do people wear pantyhose…to show off their legs…why…for sexual appeal…why…to beckon a temporary or permanent partner. Now, if you go too high up the ladder, you lose credibility. Telling women that if they wear Hanes pantyhose that they will soon be hearing wedding bells strains everyone’s credibility. However, telling people that their legs will be noticed people they want to notice …well…that simple idea lead to the highly successful campaign “Gentlemen prefer Hanes” which showed women being noticed by men by showing a shapely leg.” The campaign boomed with success. However, even in the eighties, this began to be seen as sexist by feminists…women’s worth dependent on a gentleman’s preferences…and was dumped. A costly dump…the brand never recovered. Fortunately, the pantyhose craze was almost over anyway and business dress was becoming more casual. Welcome yoga pants.</p><p>The point of this story is the value of laddering in helping us focus a long list to key ideas and actions. When you have a big list of changes you want to make in your life, you have decide which change you need to make first…your big idea…which will have the most positive impact on your life and even move your other desires forward. This is really just a re-statement of the old Pareto 80/20 rule, that twenty percent of actions create 80% of the results.</p><p>So, as you go through those thirty lists, that pile of index cards…you want to put them in order of importance. That’s why you use cards…so you can shuffle them around. Which things have the most impact on your other card lists? For instance, if you win a new client, that brings in more money to hire more people, so you can service your current clients better. Also, seeking new clients will make you hyperaware of what clients really want. So, paradoxically, the best way to serve your current clients may well be to seek new ones! That would not occur to you without a method something like this.</p><p>After lots of success with this question and answer method, I saw that this Aristotelian way of working was bigger than just another nifty Getting Things Done clerical tool. It proved to be a practical way to plan every aspect of my life, not just business. It doesn’t just tell me to make lists. It tells me what to think about and what choices I need to make. Once a quarter, I would review all the areas in my life and set the key changes and actions I wanted to make in the next three months. That generated another twenty or so cards for my personal life projects, from planning a family vacation or writing a wedding toast for my daughter. This doesn’t just make your life more efficient and effective; it makes it happier because you are actually doing what you want.</p><p>I also used a version of this system to plan and make notes for all my reading and knowledge projects. Indeed, when I interview highly successful people, I find that most people ladder up to their spiritual life to inform just about everything else, something a lot of people might find surprising. Well perhaps not Plato or Arisotle or Marcus Aurelius. But that’s a topic for another Scribbler. Better jot that down on my Scribbler project index card. Now, where did I put it?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e368c2abe59f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[THE TO-DO LIST: The Socratic Scribbler on the Art of Planning Your Life #2]]></title>
            <link>https://socratic-scribbler.medium.com/the-to-do-list-the-socratic-scribbler-on-the-art-of-planning-your-life-2-92ee3adefb5f?source=rss-ce1b1e71bf4e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/92ee3adefb5f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[self-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socratic-scribbler]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[getting-things-done]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[planning-ahead]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[to-do-list]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Malachy Walsh, Socratic Scribbler]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Jun 2021 04:21:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-22T05:01:45.734Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uFLCoWs8QasDBb7d" /></figure><p>THE TO-DO LIST: The Socratic Scribbler on the Art of Planning Your Life #2</p><p>Every day, we all make a to-do list. And many of us actually do get through our lists. Yet, we also find that we still don’t make as much progress in our lives as we hoped, whether it be romance, business, fitness, or even fun. Why is that?</p><p>Remember that Writing 101 class you took in high school, the one that told you to begin any writing project with an Outline, you know, that list of the things you want to say. The problem those books forgot to address was how to figure out what you want to say in the first place. There’s a conundrum here. How do you know what you want to say, well, until you say it, at least in your own head.</p><p>I think that to-do lists work sort of like those outlines. We make a list of things to do that pop into our head as we drink our morning coffee. However, are those the things we really ought to be doing? And how much time and effort should we spend on each item. The problem with to-do lists is that they are lists. What we need first is a<strong> plan</strong>.</p><p>There’s a big difference between a plan and a list. <strong>A plan is based on a purpose, and the plan consists of the actions required to fulfill that purpose, along with a schedule for each of those actions.</strong></p><p>Before you can make a plan, you must have a purpose. A purpose may be as broad as “the purpose of your life” or as narrow as to be “financially independent” or as specific as to “buy a new car.” Notice, that having a purpose means identifying something you want or desire. Unless we acknowledge and name our desires when we encounter them, we are likely to misinterpret what we really want. Do we really want a Porsche or do we want to recapture our youth and virility?</p><p>So, perhaps before making a to-do list, we should begin by making a list of all our desires. Well, that sounds kind of onerous. I want eggs for breakfast, to win the lottery, to get a promotion…. Here’s where people like Mr. Aristotle can help. He says that when your lists of desires get too long you should ladder them up in a hierarchy. Say, what? Let’s say, I want to lose fifty pounds. Well to ladder that up, we ask why. To be healthy? To attract a mate? To be more popular at work? To have more energy? Might be all of these, though some might be more important at one time or another. In your twenties, losing weight might be more driven by a desire to attract a life partner. In your thirties, you might want to lose weight to convince your boss you have the energy and discipline for a promotion. Or, you might want to be a role model to one of your children. Or maybe even something more fundamental. Maybe you feel like being fat has side-lined you in life, kept you out of the game, kept you from participating. As you “ladder up” the reasons, the more compelling they stat to sound. You are raising the stakes. That creates motivation.</p><p>Desires, while they may seem infinite and confusing in number, tend to cluster in a reasonably stable hierarchy of needs ranging from physical to sensual, to functional, to economic, to family life , to romantic relationships, to social position, to intellectual knowledge and skills, to creative activities, to spiritual connections. Mr. Aristotle made a version of this list in his Ethics, and you may have seen another version based on Maslow’s so-called pyramid of needs and wants.</p><p>For practical purposes, it does not make much difference which list you use, as long as you customize and adapt it to your own life. The issue is that if you want to have your desires fulfilled and be happy, you have to figure out exactly what your desires are in each of these areas at this stage in life.</p><p>In effect, a life plan should probably start with a list of the desires which are most important to you at this particular stage in your life under a set headings more or less like this: Health, Wealth, Family, Romance, Friends, Work Network, Education, Entertainment, Home, Transport. Right now, education may be your number one priority. Once you have a job rich with opportunity, maybe you will be looking for long-term romance and settling down. Once you have children, you might trade just about anything for a little peace and quiet.</p><p>You know what I liked about the newspapers that you used to hold in your hand, the ones that came in sections….News, Business, Entertainment, Real Estate, Fashion, Education, Home Advice, Sports…Each topic had its own section. Well, when you think about, those our the topics that not only organize the daily news, the daily “What’s up? What’s Changing?” but also to plan and organize our own life. If you follow baseball, you probably have some strong opinions about what the Cubs need to do to have a winning season. Well, you might find that it pays to consider what needs to happen for you to have a winning season of life.</p><p>For each of these topics of desire, we should think like Socrates and ask ourselves some annoying questions:</p><ul><li>Are you satisfied with where you are now? Why or Why not?</li><li>What is helping you progress? What is standing in your way?</li><li>What is in your control? What is not? What can you, what should you change?</li><li>How can you move forward, realistically?</li><li>What resources do you need to do to move forward? What do you need to learn? What do you need to do? Whose help do you need?</li></ul><p>As you answer these questions and make hard choices, some things will jump out at you. If you choose a career where you do a lot of good but don’t make a lot of money, then you cannot make choices in the other categories that conflict with that choice. You may have to pass on the luxury mansion and the trophy wife. Or, you better get into Harvard Business School and make some good connections. Or learn a lot about Bitcoin.</p><p>Notice that if you want your life to improve, you have to start by changing yourself. As the Stoics tell us, over and over, you really only have control over yourself, and probably not as much as you would like. You have to be honest about your strengths and weaknesses in each area. You will find it much easier to change yourself than change the world.</p><p>Notice that Life Planning is not a Philosophy. It does not tell you what choices to make. It does, however, tell you which choices you need to think about and make some decisions. Life planning is based on the principles of Ethics and Classical Rhetoric. Ethics can help you decide what must be done. And, just as Rhetoric can help you persuade other people, so Life planning can help you to persuade yourself to move in the direction that your chosen Philosophy takes you.</p><p>Step one: Get a philosophy! Read a Great Book. Read a Sacred Text. Get inspired. Become a Marine. Move with a purpose!</p><p>Step two: Make a life plan based on the priorities of your life right now. What are the desires that you need to work on?</p><p>Step three: Determine a course of action to fulfill each of your desires. These will become your life projects right now. The Socratic Scribbler will talk more about projects next time, because successful lives consist of creating and completing a set of projects that can fulfill our desires.</p><p>And, yes, from that checklist of projects, you can now begin to make daily to-do lists that will actually move your life forward. Trust me.</p><p>Remember that journal The Scribbler wrote about last time. It is a great place to ask yourself important questions and then try to answer them. You do not know what you really think until you try to write it down and then see if it still makes sense to you. Remember, you can trust the Socratic Scribbler. He spent a lifetime in advertising.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=92ee3adefb5f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>