<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by SorareScosmo on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by SorareScosmo on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@sorarescosmo?source=rss-80f3cdcb8738------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 00:26:23 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@sorarescosmo/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[2024: Sorare 2.0 — Divisions (Concept)]]></title>
            <link>https://sorarescosmo.medium.com/2024-sorare-2-0-divisions-concept-4cf657c415bb?source=rss-80f3cdcb8738------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4cf657c415bb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sorare]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[SorareScosmo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 Jan 2024 16:08:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-09T17:27:47.115Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>2024: Sorare 2.0 — Divisions (Concept)</h3><h3>Opening Rant</h3><p>As Sorare teeters on the verge of collapse (it’s not) it’s great to see the economists (they’re not) of the community come together to save us (they won’t), by constantly regurgitating the same posts about price movement, lack of users and the glue that holds us all together — thresholds!</p><p>Constructive criticism of Sorare is great and, naively, I hope the team are able to filter through the noise (there’s a lot) on social media to build quality feedback and build a sustainable product that suits consumer demands.</p><p>Sure the market is low, very low, but you (the 319th person) tweeting about it isn’t going to change anything. We know that the team are slow to activate on roadmap projects, but there is a clear path to user adoption (if it’s going to happen):</p><p>Full mobile experience (Go Android!) &gt; Instant payment methods (Cash wallet for America) &gt; Full marketing campaign activation (what’s an ambassador?) &gt; Moon. Or something like that.</p><p>Anyway, I got bored over the weekend and decided to have a go at restructuring gameplay to build a new version of Sorare. The figures used in this are extremely rough (I am not Mpenn) so there will be rounding errors, general mistakes and some of the figures may not be enitrely accurate — but they certainly give an order of magnitude accurate enough for this to be a framework, so don’t take it too literal. If anyone reads this, I’m looking forward to discussing the general ideas, not one or two specific numbers that are out by 5%. I don’t work for Sorare so there’s a limit to how much work I’m putting into this.</p><p>I realise no one asked for this and I’m now just one more person trying to save Sorare and that it will make 0 impact on Sorare, but oh well, some of you might enjoy the idea!</p><h3>Introduction</h3><p>As the new roadmap looms, the community sits in fear with concerns of the platform:</p><ul><li><strong>Sustainability of Threshold payments</strong> (We don’t <strong>know </strong>anything about Sorare’s financial health, this is purely speculation)</li><li><strong>Supply</strong> (There is a fixed rate of supply every year. “Stop minting cards” is stupid — Sorare needs revenue)</li><li><strong>Demand</strong> (User growth is low, we can only wait and see the success of activation methods over the next 6 months. It’s not instant)</li><li><strong>Reward Pools</strong> (Pools are incredibly poor, just employ someone to do this)</li><li><strong>Reward Quality</strong> (Super Rare rewards are terrible, largely down to the current structure not accommodating for scarcity and just assuming that the card model will suffice. It doesn’t)</li></ul><p>With the market and rewards in the position they are in, we find ourselves with little incentive to break beyond the Capped 240 tournaments to grind the Thresholds. What used to be an activity for small accounts in All-Star Rare using a common goalkeeper trying to break into the game, has now turned into a platform wide epidemic, and it needs to change.</p><p>There is no incentive to buy <em>expensive*</em> players. There is no incentive to <strong>WIN. </strong>There is a misguided idea from Sorare that progression means winning a useless T5 of the above scarcity will incentivise a user to play in the worst tournament on the platform to win another useless T5. This needs to change.</p><ul><li><em>Expensive players ≠ Good players. Most, but not all good players are expensive. But with the lack of premium label to the product right now, there is little incentive to win top prizes of elite / expensive cards as the cost to win is so high in comparison.</em></li></ul><p>So I have a new idea. Divisions! In this gameplay suggestion I have restructured the current tournaments on offer and the cash payments* with the principles of:</p><ul><li>Long term gameplay with a side order of instant gratification. Play 2x a week and earn weekly rewards, with monthly promotion / relegation to strive for bigger rewards from consistent overperformance. Bigger jackpot prizes to incentivise being the best manager you can be!</li><li>Scalable and controllable rewards of which Sorare need to assume more accountability. (“We don’t control anything within the market” is not a good enough response, take control!)</li><li>Simple tournament structure with complex gameplay for a challenging, immersive, rewarding and fun user experience.</li><li>Logical hierarchy of tournaments, players and rewards reflecting real life status and popularity, without compromising the core scouting / breadth of Sorare’s partners.</li><li>I have not worked out card allocation because I don’t work for Sorare and there was only so much time I put into this. Maybe later. For now, assume the card rewards will follow a similar path to cash reallocation to satisfy the above principles — long term strategy, jackpot wins, weekly rewards.</li></ul><h3>Tournament Structure</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/483/1*tS3zjxbBDD_e_BOmIfAVlw.png" /></figure><p>Currently, we have 11 tournaments across each scarcity covering the regions of the world, GAS / U23 and Capped modes. We also have the onboarding leagues in Champ EU / MLS (Amateur / Kickoff / Specialist) &amp; we have Legends (eurgh).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/659/1*WhK802rkTSZp5RbYs42scQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Proposed changes:</strong></p><ul><li>Remove all capped mode tournaments (the essence of the gameplay will be implemented in the new system)</li><li>Global All-Star, Under 23, Champion Europe and Legends (eurgh) will remain as tournaments</li><li>Challenger Europe will retain it’s name, but it will absorb Second Division Europe. It is widely argued that leagues / clubs from both of these tournaments are interchangeable in terms of real life ability / stature and one is not above the other. Secondary to this — the rewards in Second Division Europe are poor in comparison to other regions due the amount of unlicensed clubs v players who move to Opta covered clubs and are scored. Knock on effect is the overuse of Second Division cards in Global All-Star as the region is not seen as valuable. Merging the leagues and rewards would more evenly distribute reward value across the tournaments. Thirdly, having just the two European leagues gives a clearer hierarchy and premium effect to Champion Europe — the flagship product of the platform.</li><li>Champion America and Champion Asia are merged into a Rest of the World tournament. We have seen issues with coverage in both regions (South Korea / Peru), merging these tournaments gives more utility to cards from either region when they may otherwise have low volume of fixtures in a Gameweek. Further streamlines the regional split of Sorare.</li><li>Free-To-Play amateur / onboarding limited leagues to be scrapped with the introduction of Rivals. Rivals should be the primary onboarding tool with the ability to convert users into “Sorare Pro” card buyers. There is no need to weaken the Pro product with more F2P tournaments. Focus on value.</li><li>Individual cash leagues for Champion Europe fully licensed partners — a copy of the existing EPL special tournament currently open.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/488/1*MSWdQGFPDfV3U3CoOIy87g.png" /></figure><h3>Division Structure &amp; Rewards</h3><h4>Ideology</h4><p>Progression will be encouraged three-fold:</p><ul><li>UP through promotion / relegation to better rewards within scarcity.</li><li>OUT to different tournaments and compete on multiple fronts for all rewards with a wider gallery.</li><li>EVOLVE to compete at higher scarcities and bigger prizes.</li></ul><p>Tournaments would be split into a number of divisions, enabling promotion and relegation, with better prizes in higher divisions, allowing the best managers to climb to the top of the competition and win big.</p><p>Tournaments would be open to multi-entry lineups. Users would be eligible for multiple weekly prizes based on GW finishing positions, however only the highest score in a division will count towards it’s Season Leaderboard.</p><ul><li>Do you pool all your resources into one tournament and focus on multiple lineups increasing your odds? Do you diversify across multiple tournaments? Choose your best strategy for progression within your scarcity!</li></ul><p>Season leaderboards will be calculated as the best 4 scores cumulative out of the 8 Gameweeks (similar to current long format approach).</p><p>There will be different criteria (capped lineup entry) in each division, forcing managers to use a variety of strategies and levelling the playing field somewhat.</p><p>The introduction of divisions would, over time, group players by competitiveness — a combination of skill and investment. The competitions become subset groups of users and make the chances of success in your division higher, allowing users to find their level and compete for relevant rewards.</p><ul><li>Rising through the divisions and performing above your investment level? You’ll be rewarded highly allowing you the opportunity to re-invest, acquire better players and be able to compete at the next level!</li><li>Found your level and not able to break through to the higher division? Then retain your place and beat the game (capped) for your monthly threshold to help maintain your gallery.</li><li>Struggling and finding yourself relegated? Well that means you’re in the bottom 20% of users at that level and it was too difficult for you. GG and GF. See you next month, maybe!</li></ul><p>Theoretically the capped modes encourage wider galleries in order to build optimal lineups. Extrapolated over long format (8xGW) henceforth referred to as “Seasons”, with changing capped criteria, this is definitely the case.</p><h4>Divisions</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oLwq-bebLgwJ6NyT9adC5g.png" /></figure><p>I took some very rough data from Capped 240 in GW411 when all regions were active as guidance to user numbers and available reward funds. I’ve not done any quantitative analysis to work out how many unique users and how many eligible users there would be across all the divisions, so I’ve just stuck with this number across all divisions as indicitive numbers to show what could be. This makes the figures involved conservative for Sorare and therefore should be sustainable.</p><p><strong>Division 5 — Amateur Division (Limited &amp; Rare) <br>Rewards: Weekly / Seasonal Auction Credits + Weekly / Seasonal Cards</strong></p><ul><li>Entry level division for users at this scarcity. There are no restrictions on lineup cap cost, so users starting out are incentivised to buy the best players possible to get out the division as quickly as possible.</li><li>Rare scarcity allows the use of 1 limited, to aid progression from the lower scarcity.</li><li>48.5% of the users will be in this division fighting for promotion (approx. top 10% get promoted)</li><li>No Threshold payment in this division. No more participation trophies — earn your threshies.</li><li>Weekly and Seasonal Cash rewards are available in this tournament, in the form of auction credits. If you’re at the bottom of the user base, get better! It’s not a platform to farm cash, use the credits to buy players from auction, improve your gallery and move up!</li></ul><p><strong>Division 4 — Semi-Pro Division (Limited, Rare &amp; Super Rare)<br>Rewards: Weekly / Seasonal Auction Credits + Weekly / Seasonal Cards</strong></p><ul><li>Qualification level division for users at this scarcity. First capped mode at 270, users are able to use the majority of the gallery brought up from previous division, but will need to be agile and operate under the 270 cap. Perhaps buy a few cards throughout the Season to plug gaps in optimal lineups.</li><li>Super Rare scarcity allows the use of 1 Rare, to aid progression from the lower scarcity.</li><li>Rare scarcity allows the use of 1 Limited again, to allow users to establish themselves in the higher of the non-threshold-paying divisions. (Maybe this is overkill? I’m trying to give rare users something as they’re going to riot when it comes to payouts…)</li><li>25% (Limited / Rare) &amp; 50% (Super Rare) of the users will be in this division fighting for promotion (approx. top 10% get promoted) and avoiding relegation (approx. bottom 20%).</li><li>No Threshold payment in this division. No more participation trophies — earn your threshies.</li><li>Weekly and Seasonal Cash rewards are available in this tournament, in the form of auction credits. If you’re at the bottom of the user base, get better! It’s not a platform to farm cash, use the credits to buy players from auction, improve your gallery and move up!</li></ul><p><strong>Division 3 — Pro Division (All Scarcities)<br>Rewards: “Lower” Seasonal Threshold, Weekly / Seasonal Prize Money + Weekly / Seasonal Cards</strong></p><ul><li>Congratulations, you’ve earned the right to farm cash from Sorare by being in the top 26% of users at limited / rare scarcity. Seasonal Thresholds, Weekly &amp; Seasonal cash instead of auction credits — just don’t get relegated!</li><li>Capped criteria drops from 270 to 240 making it a more difficult division to navigate and a wider variety of cards needed to build optimal lineups.</li><li>Single scarcity divisions<strong>*</strong></li><li>15% (Limited / Rare), 30% (Super Rare) &amp; 50% (Unique) of the users will be in this division fighting for promotion (approx. top 12–15% get promoted) and avoiding relegation<strong>*</strong> (approx. bottom 20%).</li></ul><blockquote><strong>*</strong>Division 3 in Unique does not have relegation and will allow 1 card from the below scarcity as it is the first division of the scarcity (Similar to Div 5 Limited/Rare &amp; Div 4 Super Rare).</blockquote><p><strong>Division 2 — Experienced Division (All Scarcities)<br>Rewards: “Upper” Seasonal Threshold, Weekly / Seasonal Prize Money + Weekly / Seasonal Cards</strong></p><ul><li>Capped criteria reverts from 240 to 270 encouraging users to pick up more high scoring players to compete at a higher level with more skilled and resourceful managers.</li><li>Single scarcity divisions</li><li>Increased Seasonal threshold value. Increased weekly and monthly cash rewards. Higher quality cards rewards.</li><li>10% (Limited / Rare), 15% (Super Rare) &amp; 30% (Unique) of the users will be in this division fighting for promotion (ranging from top 3–16% get promoted) and avoiding relegation<strong>*</strong> (approx. bottom 20%).</li></ul><p><strong>Division 1 — Champions Division (All Scarcities)<br>Rewards: “Jackpot” Seasonal Threshold, Weekly / Seasonal Prize Money + Weekly / Seasonal Cards</strong></p><ul><li>Capped criteria set at 300, effectively but not quite uncapped. Compete against the best users, with the best cards, for the best prizes. Everyone should aspire to get here and stay here.</li><li>NEW SEASON CARD CRITERIA — Limited / Rare will require 2 new season cards in lineups, Super Rare / Unique will require 1. Keep those whales splashing or risk relegation.</li><li>Big Seasonal threshold rewards. Big weekly and monthly cash rewards. Best quality cards rewards.</li><li>1.5% (Limited / Rare), 5% (Super Rare) &amp; 20% (Unique)<strong>*</strong> of the users will be in this division fighting for promotion (ranging from top 3–16% get promoted) and avoiding relegation<strong>*</strong> (approx. bottom 20%).</li></ul><blockquote><strong>*</strong>Unique user percentage is high because of the low number of entries. A division size of 40 minimum applied — percentage will decrease as Unique participation increases.</blockquote><h4>Reward Funds — Projected, split and distribution:</h4><p><strong>Projected Costs</strong></p><p>Estimated cash cost for a Season is approx. $3m, being $500k for a full GW + $250k for a half GW (just halved the weekend number) x 4. Projected costs for the new structure is ~$3.45m, so Sorare will need to find another $0.45m a month from various sources:</p><ul><li>Rivals rake?</li><li>Revenue Growth</li><li>Increased facility from Sorare reserves (Stop the insolvency FUD people)</li><li>Increased Secondary Fees</li><li>Sell SPFL to Ultimate Champions (kidding)</li></ul><p><strong>Cash Reward Split</strong></p><p>$3.45m reward pot to be split between:</p><ul><li>Seasonal Threshold — $1.95m</li><li>Seasonal Prize Money (Podiums only)— $300k</li><li>Weekly Prize Money (Podiums + Placements) — $1.2m</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/592/1*2kIYqrQZrsbSro89z_wEMA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Cash Reward Distibrution</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/786/1*-8QnB3U7mBP8EElKOF3fKA.png" /></figure><h4>Seasonal Threshold Rewards</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/553/1*azyI3_PbAIdCdPqrNhswqA.png" /></figure><p>Currently, you can hit the threshold score in one GW, in one tournament and farm cash. This is boring. So in line with the divisional payout structure — the threshold money has been spread and allocated to ALL tournaments in line with the above tournament distribution percentages (e.g. Global All-Star 30%).</p><p><strong>Total Threshold values by division:</strong></p><p>In order to earn the full threshold of a division, you would need to do so in all 5 tournaments. You can of course earn varying levels in different tournaments — these are not dependent or linked to each other in any way. This is representative of the cumultaive potential threshold yield in one Season.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/858/1*Ro6K4ymtydGwYOXQvNe_0g.png" /></figure><p><strong>Global All-Star example:</strong></p><p>If we take an example of a user playing ONLY Global All-star, this would be their potential Seasonal Threshold rewards.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/856/1*_zFfgbGsPYCkEBNqv1i1DA.png" /></figure><p>In short:</p><ul><li>Play more tournaments, succeed and play higher divisions, push into higher scarcities = Big threshold payments!</li><li>Sit on cheap cards and try to shithouse your way to 4 man threshies every now and then = bottom division and GF.</li></ul><h4>Tournament Cash Reward Breakdown</h4><p><strong>Seasonal — </strong><em>Threshold — All Tournaments</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/779/1*kLXPmSP53GpaqG3pV1J7hA.png" /></figure><p>Breakdown of the total payouts by division on an expected 50% strikerate by the isolated top x% of each scarcity — increased from the current rate of 25–35%. This is likely not going to be hit due to laziness of me applying the Capped 240 user numbers to all divisions, the difficulty for users hitting all thresholds simultaneously and the dynamic capped modes.</p><h4>Threshold Rates v the old threshold:</h4><p>The old rates of $40 | $400 | $1,600 | $4,000 is the assumption of the absolute maximum and users hitting 8/8 GW’s, so take that with a huge pinch of salt when comparing the different scenarios. You are committing 8 GW to the Seasonal threshold, however you only require 4 scores. For the majority of users, this is like to result in a 1:1 with eligible lineups on weekends, however the additional opportunities of midweek scores are added. Consistency and gallery depth are rewarded.</p><p>Current threshold rewards are disproportionately paid out to the Rare scarcity. This is the biggest area impacted by the changes and is necessary to suffer for the rest of the platform to function. Remember — Thresholds are NOT the main priority. And to counter this, whilst the lower levels of Rare thresholds have been reduced significantly, the jackpot threshold in Division 1 is equivalent to 20 weeks!</p><p>The number of users hitting threshold would significantly decrease from 25–35% to around 13% in the lower scarcities, before taking into account the issues of spread across the 5 tournaments. The users who do hit the threshold, are incetivised to do so at the highest level and progress, not to sit and farm the current level. Those that succeed are rewarded a higher level of threshold payout than before.</p><p><strong>Seasonal — </strong><em>Podium Prize Money — All Tournaments</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/786/1*dx9x75mV_jaFYLVHtSBW3A.png" /></figure><p>Seasonal Podium Cash Rewards to split across the tournament allocations previously referenced (e.g. Global All-Star 30% below)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/787/1*boUgNhtikINbdZAvMIFDSg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Weekly — </strong><em>Podium Prize Money — All Tournaments</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/786/1*WK_-QG14Zc0I5wVV2BMKXg.png" /></figure><p>Weekly Podium Cash Rewards to split across the tournament allocations previously referenced (e.g. Global All-Star 30% below)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/788/1*XBZsvOR3AGEwH0G5c5aRYA.png" /></figure><h3>Summary</h3><p>That was longer than I’d hoped. I’ll summarise bits but I’ll let you draw your conclusions. Most probably only made sense in my head and no doubt was just a huge waste of time but feel free to chat to me on Twitter/X whatever it’s called @SorareScosmo — discussion and/or abuse is welcome.</p><ul><li>Restructure current tournaments — Merge Challenger and 2nd Div Europe. Merge Asia and America. Remove Capped modes.</li><li>Divisional structure, with promotion and relegation in long format — Reward ambition and longevity. Smaller grouped leaderboards to compete against more similar managers without capping utility for any user.</li><li>Varying gameplay throughout progression to keep challenging.</li><li>Progression encouraged within scarcity, up scarcities and out to other tournaments.</li><li>Threshold farming restricted to top x% of users — Earn your “free money”. Incentives to not get complacent but to push for more “free money”.</li><li>Bigger jackpot prizes.</li><li>Minimal additional cash required to achieve this from the existing payouts — sustainable!</li><li>Should scale with new user growth — adjust division sizes based on expected lineups. Adjust cash rewards based on expected lineups / revenue etc.</li><li>Add in Rivals, Sorare Career / Challenges / Achievements (stolen idea, thanks Maxime), the single league cash tournaments, Legends I guess.</li><li>Throw the card prizes in there, lootboxes, coins, experiences, merch, whatever you want there’s plenty more to win.</li><li>Moon!</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4cf657c415bb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>