<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Southern Hands on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Southern Hands on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@southern_hands?source=rss-a61b18615ec2------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 14:15:09 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@southern_hands/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The El Salvador Reality, According to Two Expats]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@southern_hands/the-el-salvador-reality-according-to-two-expats-da4eaa0060b8?source=rss-a61b18615ec2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/da4eaa0060b8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[el-salvador]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[expat-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[latin-america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Southern Hands]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Aug 2024 15:11:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-05T15:20:38.277Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This article is my brief summary of a three and a half hour conversation between two expats on life in El Salvador — unless I explicitly state otherwise, none of this is my opinion, but simply my attempt to paraphrase what was said in the conversation. The full conversation can be found below. My unabridged notes, with some rough time-stamps, are linked at the bottom of this article, if you wish to reference certain parts of the audio recording.</p><h3>Cubby 🗝️🧀🇸🇻🇺🇸 on X (formerly Twitter): &quot;In my opinion, the first 2.5 hours of this space is THE best &quot;reality check&quot; if you want to move to El Salvador. It&#39;s a big time investment but if you want the audio version of one of my massive articles, this one is great!!! https://t.co/3mXCNhBQsr / X&quot;</h3><p>In my opinion, the first 2.5 hours of this space is THE best &quot;reality check&quot; if you want to move to El Salvador. It&#39;s a big time investment but if you want the audio version of one of my massive articles, this one is great!!! https://t.co/3mXCNhBQsr</p><p>Cubby is an American expat now living in ES for ~9 months. Dan, after 15 months in ES, decided to leave, never to return. Dan’s biggest letdown with El Salvador was that the “Bitcoin Country/Freedom Country” narrative is greatly oversold &amp; misleading. He says you can get around using only BTC, but at great effort, with some big exceptions.</p><p><strong>The Bitcoin Narrative</strong></p><p>The disenchantment began upon the night of his arrival in ES, when his family took him to the corner-store and told him, this is “the guy” who accepts BTC. Notably, upon purchasing a home, Dan was unable to pay his property tax to the government in BTC. They would only accept USD. Bitcoin country indeed. Aside from Bitcoin Beach (El Zonte) and a few neighborhoods around San Salvador, BTC is not generally accepted or desired. When Dan decided to leave the country and sold his house, no buyers wanted anything to do with BTC. After 15 months in the country without interacting with the banks, he had to finally set up a bank account to wire his money from the house sale out of the country.</p><p>His sense is that the locals largely view BTC as a vehicle to entice spending (at a hefty mark-up) by wealthy visitors, then convert back into dollars ASAP. Now living in the Philippines, Dan says that because of the ease of conversion between BTC and local fiat, both paper &amp; digital, it is actually easier to live off his BTC in the Philippines, compared to trying to find someone to spend BTC natively in ES.</p><p>According to both expats, part of the difficulty of using BTC in ES is that Chivo Wallet is still very hit or miss. Your lightning payment may or may not go through. If a store accepts BTC, you’ll have to show the cashier how to use it. And then there are the KYC checks because…</p><p><strong>The Freedom Narrative</strong></p><p>The “Freedom Country” narrative is greatly oversold. I was shocked to hear how heavy-handed some of the KYC practices are — whether you use dollars or BTC. Both Cubby &amp; Dan recount in person KYC-checks (passport required) when attempting purchases of $200 at the grocery store or hardware store. Dan’s step-mother tried to use Chivo to buy $1,000 of BTC, and got a call from the authorities asking where she got the money. Dan worries that people in El Salvador will come to associate Chivo &amp; the government’s heavy-handed practices with Bitcoin itself.</p><p>Cubby explains that in the 80s &amp; 90s the US government basically strong-armed El Salvador into compliance with the Bank Secrecy Act to “stop communism,” which is why you see these policies.</p><p>Dan recommends using Blink wallet for a much better experience, but Chivo doesn’t play nice with Blink. He was not able to send BTC between the two wallets.</p><p>Other freedom-related shortcomings include the difficulty of owning a gun or recreational drugs, if you’re into that. Weed and other drugs are illegal bigtime, though this may be selectively enforced. For a gun, forget owning an AR or AK — they’re “weapons of war.” For a handgun it’s going to be a psych eval, clean criminal record, take a class, and fill out an application explaining why you feel you need one, and then you may or may not be approved, followed by an expensive renewal every year. Dan says, forget owning multiple guns. Cubby recommends getting a lawyer who already has a gun to help you with the process because…</p><p><strong>3rd World Woes</strong></p><p>You need a guy (especially a lawyer) for everything (“Oh yeah I have a guy for that…”). You must trust no one, verify everyone, because El Salvador is still your typical 3rd world country, with all the challenges that entails. As a gringo or other foreigner, you will be a mark for potential scams or simple pricing rip-offs. Dan recounts being scammed by a lawyer (referred by his own dad, no less) who charged him $$$, then just didn’t do the work. Seeking a landscaper to cut down some trees he was told to his face, well you’re a gringo so it’s more expensive. He never did find someone to do it.</p><p>No murder does not mean no crime. Bukele may have locked away the violent criminals, but bureaucratic corruption and petty crime are another matter. Dan recounts a story of a coffee farmer whose crops were being stolen. Despite repeated complaints to the police, he was basically told there’s nothing they could do about it. Yes, this is par for the course in poor countries, &amp; he deals with similar issues in the Philippines, but what disappointed him is that El Salvador is portrayed as different.</p><p>The real estate market is not very efficient, and documentation is sparse. Cubby says to expect months of surveys to establish property boundaries. Dan did not discover until after he purchased his home that back taxes were owed by the previous owner — something that would have been uncovered in a typical North American home transaction. The cultural expectations around a home transaction are quite different. Whereas in the U.S., the process is often very impersonal, mediated by the buyer’s &amp; seller’s agents, to avoid inadvertently giving away negotiating leverage, in ES Cubby describes a much more personal, even intimate process. It’s apparently common to spend the day with the seller, meet their family, have dinner with them, get to know them, etc.</p><p><strong>Dating</strong></p><p>It can be hard for single expats. Dan describes very traditional expectations around dating. In the villages, you seem to be expected to get in good with the family if you want to date a girl. Casual dating is frowned upon and hook-up culture seems to be virtually non-existent. This may sound very based, but another problem is that it can be hard to find good looking girls outside the city, sadly due to widespread obesity. Dan explains the local diet is heavy on corn &amp; seed-oils and recalls getting funny looks upon checking out at the grocery store with large quantities of beef and butter. One girl he did date for a time insisted that all the beef would kill him.</p><p>Cubby suggests if you, as a western expat, want to meet a good-looking girl who shares your values &amp; worldview, your best bet is going to be the nicer neighborhoods around San Salvador, and maybe El Zonte.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Not everything is bad about El Salvador — Dan had good experiences there too, and Cubby, after living there for ~8 months does not have plans to leave. But they say the Twitter hype is simply unreliable, and useless for determining if you should make the move to ES with the trade-offs it requires. Dan, it seems, would have been willing to make some of those trade-offs in return for a bustling Bitcoin economy, but felt that promise was not delivered.</p><p>Asked, are you glad you moved, and would you do it again, Cubby says, “it’s complicated, but yes.” He feels it’s a blue ocean opportunity to build something and make a difference in an unspoiled culture.</p><p>I asked him about the upsides of living in ES day-to-day, and he had this to say:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?type=text%2Fhtml&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;schema=twitter&amp;url=https%3A//x.com/rorshockbtc/status/1813983913230127215&amp;image=" width="500" height="281" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/2c3aa76a93420a238bc3c82f146a39ce/href">https://medium.com/media/2c3aa76a93420a238bc3c82f146a39ce/href</a></iframe><p>This conversation may have focused on more of the negative aspects of moving to ES, but I don’t think anyone should take it as the final word on the subject. Personally I take it as a useful data point to balance out some of the more euphoric narratives around El Salvador. I’m very grateful to both @rorshockbtc &amp; @tabarnakdan for taking the time to have this conversation and give us a look behind the curtain, so to speak. I recommend following both of them, and I recommend listening to the whole conversation, as it has a lot of good tidbits that I had to skip over. Cubby has a lot of great “reality-check” content on expat life.</p><p><strong>Unabridged Notes</strong></p><ul><li><a href="https://medium.com/@southern_hands/unabridged-notes-to-cubby-tabarnakdan-on-el-salvador-791813a996a8">https://medium.com/@southern_hands/unabridged-notes-to-cubby-tabarnakdan-on-el-salvador-791813a996a8</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=da4eaa0060b8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unabridged Notes to Cubby & TabarnakDan on El Salvador]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@southern_hands/unabridged-notes-to-cubby-tabarnakdan-on-el-salvador-791813a996a8?source=rss-a61b18615ec2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/791813a996a8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[el-salvador]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[expat-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[latin-america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Southern Hands]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Aug 2024 15:11:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-05T15:12:12.208Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>NOTES ON CUBBY (C ) &amp; TABARNAK DAN (TD) DISCUSSING EXPAT LIFE IN EL SALVADOR</p><p>Read my concise summary here: <a href="https://medium.com/@southern_hands/da4eaa0060b8">https://medium.com/@southern_hands/da4eaa0060b8</a></p><p>Full audio conversation here:</p><h3>Cubby 🗝️🧀🇸🇻🇺🇸 on X (formerly Twitter): &quot;In my opinion, the first 2.5 hours of this space is THE best &quot;reality check&quot; if you want to move to El Salvador. It&#39;s a big time investment but if you want the audio version of one of my massive articles, this one is great!!! https://t.co/3mXCNhBQsr / X&quot;</h3><p>In my opinion, the first 2.5 hours of this space is THE best &quot;reality check&quot; if you want to move to El Salvador. It&#39;s a big time investment but if you want the audio version of one of my massive articles, this one is great!!! https://t.co/3mXCNhBQsr</p><p>• Cubby: expat bitcoiner living in ES<br> • TD now lives in the Philippines<br> • Discussion of weather differences — both get rainy seasons. Mid July-rains everyday in ES<br> • TD left ES mid-May. Doesn’t miss it. <br> • Only (maybe) regret — has to use 100% fiat in Phil., managed to use BTC in ES, with great effort<br> ◦ BTC adoption is oversold<br> • exchg. $ ~3 times in 15 months in ES<br> ◦ bus<br> ◦ $ for btc convention (2023) bcs hotel &amp; food wanted fiat</p><p>7:50</p><p>• Chivo won’t let you LN exchange for $ unless Salvadoran, but then $1000 limit with KYC checks<br> • C hates chivo — has not successfully paid via Chivo invoice for the amount desired, nor paid a merchant with chivo wallet (other than selectos — big merchant)<br> ◦ d4n says he has had success once: $150 LN, phoenix →chivo<br> • C: onchain is correct price + $40 instant transfer fee (e.g. for rent)<br> • C thinks Bukele makes a mistake championing chivo wallet bcs it sucks<br> • TD suggests Blink is better, anecdotes of people getting locked out of their chivo accts</p><p>11:00<br> • C: least fav things about ES? Greatest “marketing bullshit” things?<br> • TD: biggest pet peeve — “legal tender” is totally oversold/not true. <br> ◦ TD’s father lived in ES before, said its night and day (in terms of crime)<br> ◦ Lands on the ground, brother takes him to the corner store: “this is the place that accepts it”<br> ▪ merchants broadly don’t care for BTC<br> • C: Max and Stacey talk it up, so he plays the role of the “evil angel” on the expat’s shoulder<br> • C: “my town doesn’t even have an atm, much less btc adoption”<br> ◦ hard to find merchants (handful) accepting CC, much less btc<br> ◦ you try to use btc, they have to dl a wallet, it’s gonna be chivo, it’s gonna be 3 day KYC, ok will you just take a 20?<br>14:30<br> • TD: double pricing rip-offs<br> ◦ charging 1$ for the bus when the sign says $0.5<br> ◦ garderner explicitly tells him “you’re a gringo, so it’s more” — same for other work<br> ▪ not unique to ES, “poor country” issue<br> • TD: not in “BTC country” but nevertheless its easier in some ways to get around with BTC<br> ◦ “Pouch” send LN BTC to pouch → $ bank account or “g-cash” (digital cash pesos) accepted by any vendor<br> • TD: “It’s Bitcoin Country” letdown was “my biggest issue”<br>16:30<br> • TD: can’t own gun in ES<br> ◦ ar15: “weapon of war”, can’t get one<br> ◦ handgun: psych eval, no criminal record, do a class, fill out app listing reasons why you need one, then maybe approved maybe not<br> ◦ expensive license renewal every year<br> ◦ C: confirmed TD’s complaints about guns (around 19:30)<br> • TD: weed illegal bigtime. Years in prison.<br> ◦ Anecdotally they may not care/enforce in the tourist areas<br> ◦ C: confirmed, saw ppl smoking around hotels and such, thinks there’s more strict enforcement on hardcore drugs<br>20:00<br> • TD: forget having multiple guns<br> • TD: in a sense these aren’t huge deals, (not personally into them in a big way) but they portray themselves as “Freedom country”<br> • C: top recco — get a lawyer who has a gun and you can probably speed up the process<br> ◦ you need “a guy” for everything, and then you can hire that guy’s guys<br>23:30<br> • C: there is a tendency to get ripped off as a gringo, esp in tourist areas. Less so in the pueblo where he lives<br> • TD: no murder vs no crime. There’s still corruption.<br>25:00<br> • TD: knew a coffee grower whos crops were being stolen. Cops told him nothing they could do.<br> • TD: got ripped off a few hundred $ by a local lawyer (who was recco’d by his own dad, 28:00), complained to the gov office 4x, nothing done<br> ◦ doesn’t seem like a reformed country, it’s like eveyr other poor country<br> ◦ At the DMV, scammer tried to ask for $1000 to get his license for him<br> • TD: it’s like that in a lot of poor countries, but ES is portrayed as different — that’s the issue<br> • TD: in Philippines, foreigners not allowed to have guns, weed, straight to jail, his license at the DMV in Philippines was slowed because they were cracking down on unofficial “expediting”<br>28:00<br> • Detailed story of getting scammed by the lawyer<br>33:00<br> • TD: paying property taxes<br> ◦ Bought a house, had title, but City hall still had it under the prev owner with back taxes.<br> ◦ Had to pay back taxes to have it transferred over, to then pay his own property taxes<br> ◦ The govt. office wouldn’t accept BTC payment, just USD<br> • C: when buying a house, no one knows how much land is with it. 3–6 mo to do surveys and get the paperwork in order<br>35:00<br> • C: buying a car — needs a card with the VIN and a serial no. for the engine<br> ◦ heavy bureaucracy in general, as per typical LatAm<br>36:45<br> • On Lawyers<br> • C: used Aso Bitcoin — $2700 for 4 years legal retainer, help with legal docs, buying cars, lawyer helped straighten out issues with furniture delivery<br> ◦ need to have a good lawyer to make things happen for you<br> • TD: found lawyer through the embassy’s list. (Miguel Avaralo?). Needed documents translated &amp; notarized<br> ◦ Miguel good connection for translations — knows the translator<br> ◦ Miguel reviewed previous paperwork (for the house purchase) from the scam lawyer<br> ▪ the scam lawyer is a genuine lawyer, but subs out all the work<br> • TD: not everyone’s a scammer, but you have to get valid references, esp for lawyers<br>42:00<br> • Aso Bitcoin: not perfect but honest &amp; generally reliable ($1.5k-2k for residency)<br> • Escape to ES: white glove, more expensive ($5k for residency)<br> • Independent Lawyer- $300-$500<br> • But you have to renew your res every year<br>45:00<br> • C: not many english speakers<br> • TD: confirmed, only knows some ES-Americans who speak english, even the ES-Americans get ripped off like a gringo (“brown gringos”)<br>47:00<br> • TD: more getting ripped off on price. Given a different price than quoted before. Then attempted to steal the merchandise back after he paid<br> • TD: got a little ripped off on sunglasses in Philippines, but it’s to be expected. But then in ES everyone acts like it’s different, but it’s not. It’s the same poor country stuff. <br> • Unmet grand, lofty promises.<br>49:00<br> • TD: reluctant to talk about this stuff while in ES because it’s against the narrative<br> ◦ concerned about device surveillance<br> ◦ concerned about being openly critical of the govt.<br> ◦ rumors of political prisoners, not just gangsters<br> ◦ “it’s a police state”<br>51:00<br> • TD: you meet a girl there and you’re expected to meet the whole fam before you kiss her<br>52:00<br> • getting ID/passport checked for hardware store purchases or $200 worth of groceries<br> • C: confirmed the KYC stuff is ridiculous<br>53:00<br> • Cubby on getting good prices<br> ◦ going around to street vendors until someone gives him an honest price, then promises to business exclusively with them in the future<br> ◦ brick &amp; mortar stores rip you off the most — compare the receipt price to the sticker price<br> ◦ It’s a low trust society<br>56:00<br> • Unusual expectations around dating &amp; sex<br> ◦ Assumption that you marry who you sleep with<br> ◦ yet a lot of apparent cheating culture<br>58:00<br> • ES supposed to be bitcoin country, but it’s perfectly easy to just send BTC to Pouch, and convert that into local paper in Philippines<br> • as opposed to being limited to going to one corner store to spend your BTC<br> • TD: if you’re going to ES, bring dollars<br>1:00<br> • TD: your point about finding honest people and dealing with them — same as in Philippines<br> ◦ never could find someone honest to deal with to cut down his trees<br> ◦ Lots of people in ES are nice, reliable, honest, but it’s typical 3rd world country<br> ◦ “When I hear people defend ES, Bukele, on Twitter and they haven’t been there, or they just vacationed in Zonte, get out a little bit, go see the countryside”<br>1:03<br> • TD: you can work around it and use BTC, but it’s a lot of work<br> ◦ Super Selectos accepts BTC, but every time he has to help the cashiers to it<br> ◦ D4n: confirmed “click on that, now it’s that option, ok now do that”<br> ◦ Now the people in line think you’re slowing down the line — makes BTC look bad<br> ◦ TD &amp; D4N — had times where Chivo took 10 minutes to work (because cashier accidentally selected on chain option??)<br>1:05<br> • C: haven’t had those experiences *this year*, but he spends a lot of time in and around tourist areas, where they’re used to gringos coming through, so Wal Mart &amp; Selectos have been able to accept his BTC<br> • C: people who come and spend a week in Zonte, Escalon, etc, have no idea what it’s actually like in the country. Adoption is not the same elsewhere<br>1:07<br> • TD: getting KYC’d to buy stuff at the hardware store.<br> • TD: in his village, richest guy in town was actually very anti BTC<br> • TD: tried to sell house for BTC, buyers wanted nothing to do with it<br> ◦ So he had to set up a bank account, they messed up his wire transfer out of the country<br> ◦ The bank will buy your btc, but won’t sell it back to you<br> ◦ Used Blink — props to Blink — had to do extra KYC to buy BTC<br> ▪ the only way to buy BTC in ES as a non-Salvadoran<br> ◦ Step-bro’s mom got account locked up for attempting to buy $1k BTC on Chivo — called for a KYC/AML check<br> ◦ “Freedom Country”<br>1:11<br> • TD: it seems they think BTC is a fad that brings in rich tourists<br> ◦ lots of restrictions on BTC<br> • C: one of the reasons that banking sucks, and consequently chivo, and hence BTC<br> ◦ 1980s during the civil war, Reagan admin concerned about USSR coming to stage commie coup<br> ◦ Communism in LatAm isn’t really communism, it’s just opposition to American interventionism, adopting the anti-American symbol of the time (USSR)<br> ◦ Chivo is built on BSA Compliance framework that ES banks were compelled to adopt during the 80s and 90s<br> ◦ To make Chivo work, you’d have to tear up all the BSA KYC stuff up from the roots and rearchitect the local financial system<br>1:15<br> • C: concerned about restrictions on “political speech” for foreigners<br> ◦ needs to build up follower count/notoriety so authorities are discouraged from putting pressure on him for expressing his opinions about the country<br> ▪ “tier 2 level free speech”<br> • Agrees that much of the marketing “what you have been sold”, about ES is bullshit — (nevertheless there is a lot to appreciate about ES)<br>1:16<br> • Q &amp; A<br> • TD on “love life”<br> ◦ step-dad, brother, &amp; his [bro’s?] wife tried introducing people, brother warned: whoever you hook up with, you’re stuck with her<br> ◦ a couple false starts with different girls<br> ◦ no luck on Tindr — a lot of obesity — lots of corn &amp; chips consumption<br> ◦ Good looking girls in the city, but lived far away from the city<br> ◦ In the village, have to figure out how to get in good with the family<br> ◦ Only white guy in the village after his dad moved back to Europe<br> ▪ “he must be rich!”<br> ▪ try explaining to a girl you’re waiting until bitcoin pumps before spending — low time preference<br> ▪ his dad spent large sums of money in ES, nothing to show for it<br> ◦ how will you deal with the cultural differences?<br>1:27<br> • C: “What’s the average woman like?” — short fat &amp; ugly<br>1:28<br> • On groceries<br> • Lots of seed oil junk food<br> • TD: in line with 15 lbs of beef, 2 lbs of butter, getting weird looks<br> • TD: if you go to a family dinner (e.g. with a girl) you’re gonna be eating junk, or being rude<br> • Butter very expensive $7/lb<br> • Beef largely imported<br> • <a href="http://twitter.com/beefbackbetter">@beefbackbetter</a> — bitcoiner beef guy sourcing local grassfed beef<br> • One of the girls he was talking to insisted all the beef would kill him<br> ◦ they’re indoctrinated to the meat = bad myth<br> ◦ mainly eat chicken &amp; pork<br> • Lots of local beef in Philippines<br>1:33<br> • On the Philippines<br> • 5 min walk from the beach, 3–4 hours from Manila<br> • TD: not a fan of “Bitcoin Island”, very touristy &amp; expensive<br> • have to renew visa every 60 days<br> ◦ takes the bus to the immigration office<br> ◦ does any needed shopping during the visa renewal trip<br> • Disappointed to be using fiat, but it’s easier to convert back and forth<br>1:35<br> • C on China UX<br> • UX of using WeChat in China is seamless in every service industry, etc., if you don’t think about how you’re being tracked on everything<br> • ES lacks a similar UX experience for using bitcoin over LN or NOSTR<br> • C doesn’t see it really happening yet<br>1:37<br> • TD: Philippines used to using e-cash (Maya &amp; G-cash), so they will be ready to transition to BTC when fiat collapses — people used to paying with their phones<br>1:39<br> • C: the biggest msitake people make when moving to ES is picking a place that doesn’t align with their lifestyle goals<br> • C: If you want to meet a girl — neighborhoods western San Salvador, that’s it. Maybe Zonte<br> ◦ you have to find someone with common values/life experiences<br> ◦ if you move to a village, you’re the only white guy, english speaker, hard to find someone<br> ◦ if you move with a spouse/partner, they have to know what they want too.<br> ◦ The idea that everything’s going to be perfect, easy, a dream, is very misleading<br> • There’s lots of good things about coming to ES, but there are trade-offs, so it depends on how those trade-offs align with what you value/priorities<br>1:42<br> • TD: willing to make some of those trade-offs to spend time with his dad, until he moved back to Europe<br> • TD: took months to sell his house, 20% under value, and still had to take $<br> ◦ no one could wrap their heads around a contract for a fixed amount of sats, without regard for the $ price volatility<br> • C: the people are so used to dollars, $1=$1, they haven’t encountered volatility before, they simply don’t understand the devaluation over time<br>1:45<br> • Adoption is greatly overstated — most people who get “orange-pilled” ultimately just want to go back to $<br>1:47<br> • there’s a difference between being familiar with the Gospel of Christ, and committing your life to it<br> • Salvadorans have heard the story, but they largely want to get the money from the tourists and then go back to $ — “real money”<br>1:48<br> • TD: it took me 11 months of buying with BTC at the corner store and showing the guy the numbers before he started to save a little BTC<br> ◦ hard for the store owner to save very much because of his expenses<br> ◦ most people won’t read btc books you give them — in the rural areas there’s low education, illiteracy<br>1:53<br> • C: ES doesn’t use their own currency anymore since 2003 — since they use $, they are dependent on the US central banking policy, but USD is better than most emerging market currencies<br> • C: as opposed to in Argentina or somewhere, people intuitively grasp inflation, debasement, etc<br> • C: ES is on the $ standard. They don’t have the holy sh*t moment where they realize life is getting more expensive by the day<br> • C: orange-pilling in ES is actually harder than in other countries<br>1:56<br> • Amazon<br> • TD: in ES getting stuff from amazon is impossible, but he can get stuff from Amazon in Philippines<br> ◦ even free shipping on $50+<br> • TD: want to buy something in ES that’s not readily available? Wait for a fam member to come visit and have them buy it in Canada first<br> • TD: hard to get physical books (e.g. from Amazon) is hard<br> • C: to get books on Amazon, typically have it shipped to a correspondent in Miami, and they charge you $20+/lb to bring it in<br> ◦ now afraid to bring down older/more valuable books because of moisture/mold<br>1:59<br> • C: mold/mildew — have to clean mold out of the clothes etc.<br> • C: moisture in the house. It’s normal there so the people haven’t even searched out solutions — don’t know life without it<br> ◦ TD: confirmed, got mold on paperwork<br>2:03<br> • TD: had both good and bad experiences in ES, but don’t believe what you hear on Twitter. If people have just been spending time in the tourist areas, they don’t know what the country is like, because it’s not the same outside those areas<br> • C: was trying to arrange a tour for some people, and their idea of experiencing the country was staying in one of the resorts<br> ◦ if you have tons of money ($10-$100M) ES probably isn’t that attractive, because you can have a better life eleswhere<br> • C: drives me crazy when people spend a week in El Zonte then say “let’s move to ES, there’s bitcoin everywhere!”<br> • TD: trying to correct people about BTC adoption in ES on Twitter, and reply-guys trying to tell him how it is<br>2:08<br> • TD: realizing the adoption hype isn’t real happened the first night he arrived — dad took him to the corner store: “this is the guy that accepts BTC”<br> • Next day when he went to get a phone — the phone company doesn’t accept BTC, $ only<br> • The bus wouldn’t take BTC<br>2:10<br> • TD: went to Berlin (ES), supposedly “Bitcoin city”, maybe 4 places took BTC<br> • D4n: at Don Pollo, ordered food, they said, no we don’t take BTC. Then they checked the price and came back and said, ok we’ll take it, after they paid<br> ◦ Berlin struck him as a sad place, wouldn’t like to live there<br>2:12<br> • C: Bitcoin Jungle, Costa Rica, maybe the best ‘circular economy.’ But it doesn’t really work long term, because the clientele is mostly ex-pats, so when the ex-pats leave, the economy doesn’t sustain. The merchants just saw an opportunity to make cash <br> • C: doesn’t think the circular economy model is scalable. You only ever see marketing hype, you never see honest discussion of failures &amp; setbacks<br> • C: feel like you can’t talk about any of the negatives or lessons, like you’re speaking against BTC adoption itself<br>2:15<br> • C: The ES hype on Twitter is like popular Bitcoin memes on twitter — lacking substance, just appealing to potential tourists<br> ◦ but poor quality information if you’re wanting to actually move there<br> • TD: maybe the govt. figured out that BTC is a good reserve currency, but they have not successfully helped the people figure it out<br> ◦ sees some shitcoinery coming in, likely to burn the locals, since they don’t adequately understand<br> • TD: even at the BTC conference, no one wanted to talk about Chivo<br> ◦ you can’t send from Chivo to Blink and back<br> ◦ got the corner store guy to use Blink, and was able to pay him remotely — would not have worked with Chivo<br>2:18<br> • TD: couldn’t pay the gas station’s Chivo with his Blink wallet<br> • People are wary of govt. They associate Chivo with govt, and hence associate BTC with govt.<br> • People expect as soon as they hit the $ threshold, they’re gonna get a KYC check from the govt, and associate that with BTC<br>2:19<br> • C: don’t disagree with anything TD says<br> • C: if you want to move here, have realistic expectations<br> • C: chatting with a well-known Bitcoiner considering moving and warning against getting scammed, renting a place sight unseen<br>2:20<br> • C: if you use the methods youre familiar with to find housing, cars, etc online, you’re getting screwed<br> • The online economy (e.g. for rentals) is like a separate market because it’s exclusively shopped by wealthy foreigners, so it’s not the realistic market price<br> • C: you have to spend several months to find a good deal<br>2:23<br> • C: the market there has very inefficient price discovery. You have to physically check out everything<br> • TD: yeah it’s similar in the Philippines<br> • TD: pretty common in poor countries. The people saavy enough to list online realize they can take advantage of wealthy foreigners. The price you get in person is different<br>2:26<br> • C: Town of Apaneca — one of the colder places in ES. Offered locals payment to shop around for him. Asked the barista in a coffee shop what’s a typical fair price to rent, she insisted she had no idea. Her family had never really moved, so she didn’t have any concept of prices other people paid. Quasi-caste system — unaware of prices outside her ‘caste’<br>2:29<br> • C: people come here and think they can find a place in a few days, and it’s just not true<br> • C: if you read Max &amp; Stacy’s tweets they make it seem easy and great, but it’s not that simple<br> • TD: wages are so low there, that if they can rip you off for $5 it’s a big impact to their income<br>2:31<br> • C: in the US people think of BTC as a SoV, just DCA and you’llb e better off in the long run etc.<br> • But in ES almost all their money just goes to survival, they’re unable to plan that far in the future<br>2:33<br> • TD: even the corner store guy he orange pilled had to spend all his ‘savings’ on an emergency<br> • C: need for a time-locked savings product in order for people to see the long term pay-off<br> • C: most of the BTC builders build for the US perspective of BTC as a high-beta, tech, speculative thing, without udnerstanding the reality on the ground in ES<br>2:35<br> • TD: it’s still early. It’s going to take more time for BTC to distribute to the lower income strata…50 years?<br>2:37<br> • C on distorting the local labor market<br> • Considering huge house in Apaneca — owner suggests hiring help to cook &amp; clean the large house, $14/day<br> • C: oh, well I’ll pay them more. “No, because then everyone has to pay more, and the community will hate you” — youre creating wage inflation, the local dollar is now worth less<br> • TD: if you overpay for your taxi ride, the taxi driver is going to be lazy and wait for the rich foreigner instead of serving the locals.<br>2:41<br> • TD: if you go on the Salvadoran FB groups, people complain about the increasing cost of labor<br> • Discussion on trouble getting workers because of inflated wage expectations, and “easy money” from remittances<br>2:43<br> • TD: If US economy struggles, and remittances decline, people in the villages will struggle because they’ve living off of remittances. A lot of the hard workers leave to go work in the US<br> • More discussion on remittances — the expectations on remittances throw off the local economy<br> • If you have a relative sending money back home, you’re not gonna go do the manual labor<br>2:47<br> • Buying a Coffee Farm Anecdote<br> • Expected to visit the house/land for an hour — instead took 6 hours, meeting the family, having lunch, etc<br> • Where’s the property line? Well, former neighbors were in the gangs, and controlled the local gov, and moved the property line a couple hundred meters<br> • Waterfall on the land shares water rights with the town, and you have to maintain it for the town with no payment. <br> • 2–5 acre section of the property had settlers/squatters — cheap labor since they’re squatting<br> • Big piece of land, but all these strings attached. Squatters depending on you, etc. Sellers didn’t even think it was a big deal<br> • different expectations between sellers and western buyers</p><p>2:51<br> • TD: bad experience with real estate. Nothing’s organized, documentation is sparse<br>2:52<br> • TD: concern about potential reversal on the criminal/prison situation<br> • C: no doubt ES had great success with the gangs, but solving the problems around bureaucracy, real estate, documentation, is perhaps a more complicated problems<br> ◦ you have to change the whole culture — and the leadership are perhaps underestimating the task<br>2:54<br> • TD: not convinced they’re going to win the race on BTC adoption — it’s a cash culture, used to bureaucratic corruption</p><p>2:57 Lisa Hough joins convo<br> • Working on BTC adoption in Santa Monica<br> ◦ “Proof of Workforce” <a href="http://twitter.com/btcworkforce">@btcworkforce</a> — works with unions/pensions to educate on bitcoin<br> ◦ Santa Monica will work with Proof of Workforce to educate the local community on bitcoin<br>3:03<br> • Discussion of orange-pilling local government, rather than top down from the federal government as in ES<br>3:07<br> • LH: are you glad you moved, would you do it again?<br> ◦ C: it’s complicated, but yes I would <br> ◦ C: moved to the mountains — always wanted to live in the mountains<br> ◦ C: blue ocean: unspoiled culture, not taking it over and changing the culture or turning it into a resort. <br> ◦ Find a core group of aligned people who also want to move to the mountains and help the locals build businesses not dependent on tourism<br> ◦ opportunity to make a difference <br>3:11<br> • LH: would you raise kids in ES? How are the schools? Homeschool?<br> ◦ C: plan to attempt to birth kids in Chile/Argentina for passport access given difficulties of Victoria traveling as a Russian<br> ◦ C: Probably not public school (not that EU or US are any better)<br> ◦ Pretty robust homeschool community in ES — and is LEGAL<br> ◦ Expats can send kids to American schools in San Salv. — 600–2k/mo<br> ◦ A lot of opportunity to build homeschool communities<br>3:16<br> • LH: are your families willing to visit you?<br> • C: parents are coming down, actually somewhat easier to visit than where he lived in the US<br> • For V’s fam, has been hard as Russians<br> ◦ Hard for Russia to get repair parts for commercial aircraft<br> ◦ Airport near them is not operational — have to take a long train ride to a different airport, then connect flights to jurisdictions that aren’t black-balled<br> ◦ 2–4 days travel minimum<br> •</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=791813a996a8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Brief Response To Rodarmor’s “Inscriptions: A Guide for the Ideological Maxi”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@southern_hands/a-brief-response-to-rodarmors-inscriptions-a-guide-for-the-ideological-maxi-2d8d657548b0?source=rss-a61b18615ec2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d8d657548b0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Southern Hands]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 30 Dec 2023 09:39:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-30T09:39:29.404Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Before reading, find Rodarmor’s piece <a href="https://rodarmor.com/blog/inscriptions-a-guide-for-the-ideological-maxi/">here</a>.</p><p>For the sake of goodwill, let us not dispute Rodarmor’s profession of anarcho-capitalist values and commitment to Bitcoin’s flourishing. We may thus treat this as an “in-house” debate.</p><p>Rodarmor proffers “advice” to us “ideologues,” mainly to learn about inscriptions and to drop what he takes to be our “worst and least compelling arguments.” Unfortunately, the advice given doesn’t really cut to the heart of the matter, and in my view Rodarmor marshals some uncompelling arguments of his own.</p><p>First, that “whining about inscriptions makes [us], and Bitcoin, look weak,” and that we contradict ourselves if we insist that Bitcoin is unstoppable, and yet could be felled by “a bunch of retards publishing JPEGs on-chain.” Yes, we are all familiar with the platitudes: Bitcoin is unstoppable, everything is good for Bitcoin, yada yada. But there is no contradiction here, for Rodarmor picks out the least sophisticated formulation to knock down. Merely uttering “Bitcoin is unstoppable,” is not the thing that makes it so. It is because of what the <em>human participants</em> in Bitcoin do, or don’t do, that makes it so…but of course this leaves open the possibility that things go awry. And indeed, perhaps in the present controversy the best thing to do is exactly nothing! I am open to this possibility, though I’m sad to say I have not seen it convincingly argued. In any case, to say that there is no possible world in which Bitcoin does not get co-opted or corrupted seems a bit premature. Now add to this the apparently subtle and nuanced take that something could be net negative for Bitcoin yet fail to utterly destroy it. For my part, I believe inscriptions, stamps, and the like are indeed spam, and are indeed net negative, though I doubt they will lead to Bitcoin’s utter ruin. And I think if there is something to be done to mitigate them, then let us get on with it. I also believe that, due to the self-interested actions of free agents seeking to store their wealth in the hardest money ever conceived, Bitcoin very likely will prevail in the end. It so happens that some of those self-interested actions may involve mitigating non-monetary on-chain data (as has been done <a href="https://blog.bitmex.com/dapps-or-only-bitcoin-transactions-the-2014-debate/">in the past</a>). That is precisely what is under debate. Where is the contradiction?</p><p>As an aside, it’s worth pointing out that Rodarmor chastises inscription critics as ideologues struggling to cope with an unpleasant reality, yet he himself invokes simple platitudes like “Bitcoin is unstoppable” as a sort of mantra to ward against the possibility that anything might do it harm. Pardon me if that appears a bit…idealogical. To be sure, many a Bitcoin O.G. has been seen to post on Xitter the liturgies of Bitcoin’s inevitability in recent days. One wonders if they are struggling to cope with the unpleasant reality that Bitcoin has a problem?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*WAhr8xSMe8Z553Ijz1c7Vg.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>For all the whining on Twitter, nobody has been able to make so much as a dent in ordinals and inscriptions.</blockquote><p>Yes, because the Core devs declined to patch a mempool filter in response to an obvious exploit, and this despite a long tradition of discouraging non-monetary data storage on the blockchain. Given that most node-runners appear to <em>trust</em> the Core devs to ship them a working product, it takes time to raise awareness of the issues and options, if the devs do nothing. The block size controversy was not decided in a week, so I see no reason why we should be gaslit into throwing in the towel.</p><blockquote>This will no doubt not be the last time that people start doing unpleasant things on Bitcoin, so it would be a good exercise to start accepting it now.</blockquote><p>This simply hand-waves away the multiple times in the past that undesirable behaviors were successfully discouraged, filtered, or blocked, whether by changing the OP_Return limit, or the dust limit, or whatever else, whether reactively or in anticipation of abuses. Many such cases. Conversely, a great way to <em>encourage </em>abuse in the future is to do nothing in response to present abuse.</p><blockquote>Also, strategically, all press is good press, and complaining about inscriptions just makes more people learn about them…</blockquote><p>Indeed, all press is good press, and complaining about spam filtration and idealogical maxis just makes more people learn about the difference between mempool policy and consensus validity, and indeed whether Bitcoin should have a purpose at all. We are locked in a battle of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect">Streissand effects</a>. One does begin to wonder, if there really is nothing we can do, why your camp bothers engaging with us at all.</p><blockquote>If you still insist on complaining about inscriptions, at least take a moment to learn about them…</blockquote><p>I wholeheartedly agree, and anyone wishing to do so may consult my <a href="https://medium.com/@southern_hands/ordinals-are-fiat-and-inscriptions-arent-rare-f1681b60facc">previous piece</a> — based upon a thorough reading of the Ordinals Handbook — wherein the reader will learn why this sometime artist finds Bitcoin “NFTs” to be just as much a let-down as the ethereum NFTs Rodarmor so rightly criticizes.</p><p>Now for Rodarmor’s treatment of the apparently “least compelling arguments.”</p><blockquote>Anyone can right-click save the JPEGs…Nobody is buying inscriptions based on the delusion that they are buying access.</blockquote><p>Ok so what are they buying? Control? Nope, inscriptions live inside a transaction, which is an indelible monument over which no private keys exercise control, as Rodarmor well knows. It’s as though you and I record a business deal with the county clerk. I draw a pic on the paperwork I give to the clerk. You pay me. Anyone can come into the county and make copies of the paperwork — it’s public record. The clerk will never let you destroy the record or take it out of the building. We say you own the pic on the paperwork. Then profit I guess? Seriously, if access or control are not the value props here, then <em>what is?</em></p><blockquote>Inscriptions aren’t real, they’re just a collective hallucination. I’ve been saying basically exactly this since day one, that ordinals and inscriptions are an opt-in lens with which to view Bitcoin. Behaving as if this is some kind of damning revelation makes you look like a moron.</blockquote><p>Rodarmor is being too hard on himself. Inscriptions are obviously real. It’s just the ownership of them that is a complete fabrication.</p><blockquote>Everything important is just social conventions. Bitcoin is, in fact, just a social convention. Or, put another way, it’s not the software or data that matter, it’s the social conventions around it. Inscriptions are no different.</blockquote><p>Yet I think there is a difference here. A convention emerges around Bitcoin because people find value in controlling private keys that give the user actual power over the ledger. The convention around inscriptions relies upon a pernicious falsehood: that you have any ownership, control, possession, or power over the inscription at all. The only powers you have with respect to the inscription reside in an off-chain protocol.</p><blockquote>You can just store the data off-chain. People value on-chain data. It makes inscriptions scarce,</blockquote><p>Scarce? Seven months ago there were already half as many inscriptions as bitcoins:</p><h3>Lauren Sieckmann on Twitter: &quot;Ordinals just hit 10 million inscriptions 🤯Who said Bitcoin wasn&#39;t for building?! / Twitter&quot;</h3><p>Ordinals just hit 10 million inscriptions 🤯Who said Bitcoin wasn&#39;t for building?!</p><p>The supply of inscriptions trends ever toward infinity. Did you know, anon, there are currently something like 60,000 BRC-20 inscription shitcoins queued up to be minted? (I will edit to include the chart as soon as I find it again).</p><blockquote>Every other NFT ecosystem uses off-chain data, and uninformed users delegate trust to whoever happens to be pinning the files on IPFS, and they might stop at any time.</blockquote><p>So does the inscriptions ecosystem. In fact the off-chain data pointing to the inscription is the only thing you actually own. Of course, you do in fact own the on-chain UTXOs numbered by your ordinal wallet; it’s just that those UTXOs are not associated with the inscription, since it does not reside in a UTXO, but rather in a transaction witness. So with respect to the inscription, what you own is access to an off-chain protocol that automates looking up the TXID for you. Cool, but I could already do that for free, so again I ask, what is the value prop? Stamps are far superior to inscriptions in this regard, since, as I understand it, the data actually is attached to a UTXO, which actually is controlled by your on-chain private key. But you still shouldn’t use stamps because…</p><blockquote>Inscriptions [and stamps] are illegitimate.</blockquote><p>Rodarmor seems to think that when we argue about the legitimacy of inscriptions, it’s because we think they’re stupid. On the contrary, it’s because we believe Bitcoin does in fact have a purpose, which is, at the very least, not to be Filecoin, and indeed that Bitcoin has had a long tradition of honoring that purpose. Curiously, Rodarmor seems to think Bitcoin does not have a purpose:</p><h3>Casey on Twitter: &quot;I understand the argument that NFTs are lame and stupid, but I don&#39;t understand the argument that NFTs are somehow *illegitimate*. Bitcoin has transcended its original creator and purpose. Bitcoin is not *for* some things and *not for* other things. It just is. / Twitter&quot;</h3><p>I understand the argument that NFTs are lame and stupid, but I don&#39;t understand the argument that NFTs are somehow *illegitimate*. Bitcoin has transcended its original creator and purpose. Bitcoin is not *for* some things and *not for* other things. It just is.</p><p>It is an older tweet, so perhaps he has updated his views since, but it is odd given what he has said about social conventions, and especially given his professed belief “that Bitcoin is the path away from the debauched debasement of our lives and civilization that fiat currency has wrought.” If it has no purpose then how can it achieve that which we all hope for?</p><blockquote>Inscriptions are a state attack. Somehow, you see NFTs and shitcoins on other chains, understand that they exist because of enthusiasm, demand, grift, and degeneracy, don’t think that these things are a state attack on Ethereum, and somehow turn around and think that they’re a state attack on Bitcoin?</blockquote><p>I’ll grant this is a fair point. We should seek to be consistent in our reasoning, and it’s worth pondering one’s motives here. Yet it doesn’t warrant dismissing the concern altogether. The question to ask is, “what would it look like if the state wanted to attack Bitcoin?” It seems strange that we all assume Bitcoin threatens the state’s power, and that the state will at some point react, and yet we apparently don’t expect the state to employ subterfuge to do it. Bribing miners to mine empty blocks, or spamming the chain with dust transactions, or spamming the chain with dust transactions with JPEGs attached all have the same end result: greater friction and cost for end users. But the first two are painfully obvious while the latter receives plausible deniability. It may indeed all be pure grift, but the outcome is the same.</p><blockquote>Attempting to censor inscriptions is exactly identical to attempting censoring other kinds of transactions. Any machinery you build or public support you muster will immediately lend support to censorship on Bitcoin in general.</blockquote><p>At last we come to it: the naughty C-word. The use of the C-word by inscription enjoyers is deliberate, since they know it switches Bitcoiners’ amygdalae into overdrive. They want you angry, anon, so you aren’t thinking clearly. Fair’s fair; I’m not above evoking a little adrenaline, here and there, to help my point. But let’s be aware of what’s happening here. The simple fact is, your node already “censors” certain types of valid — yes, valid — bitcoin transactions. I have to suspect Rodarmor and Co. know this, so in my view the argument is a bit disingenuous.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/888/1*wHQwu8iTXGZcIcyD63PGiw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Bitcoin’s mempool filters, sometimes called “spam filters” have been around since pretty much forever, and have evolved over time. It’s perfectly legitimate to discuss continuing that evolution, especially with regard to an obvious and controversial exploit.</p><blockquote>…you will ultimately fail…</blockquote><p>That is the million dollar question, is it not? If there truly is nothing that can be done, one wonders why inscriboors continually feel compelled to remind us of it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d8d657548b0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ordinals are Fiat. And Inscriptions aren’t Rare.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@southern_hands/ordinals-are-fiat-and-inscriptions-arent-rare-f1681b60facc?source=rss-a61b18615ec2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f1681b60facc</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Southern Hands]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Jun 2023 15:21:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-05T14:35:56.345Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Part I. Introduction</h4><p>Back in the good ol’ days, when you earned 8% safe yields on Celsius and Solana was the next big thing because good ol’ boy SBF said so, you had to mint your NFTs on Ethereum or a similar smart contract chain. As a burnt-out sometime artist myself, I was initially intrigued by the prospect. Digital scarcity, but for art? Maybe I should get back into it, and the hype would ease the task of bringing attention to my work. Yet, some skepticism seemed warranted, because I took more than one minute to think about how such a thing could be possible. On Ethereum, your cost of gas is directly proportional to the amount of data you ask the network to compute. Aren’t images data-rich, and therefore won’t it be prohibitively costly to execute transactions involving them? Oh, yes, that’s why the first NFT’s were exceedingly low-res little thumbnails — as a high-res digital photographer, that’s not exactly my style, but I’ll grant the idea was at least interesting. So, naturally I wondered how it was possible that so many relatively high-res NFTs seemed to be proliferating on NFT marketplaces. In the beginning it was difficult to find an answer to this question (it’s almost like no one wanted to talk about it, I wonder why), but it eventually became clear that most NFTs were just pointers to some off-chain, centralized data-storage provider which hosted the actual image. No art on-chain. Everyone was minting hyperlinks, and no one seemed to care. How fiat. Insert your favorite quote about the destruction of the money driving speculation and gambling to maddening heights in Weimar Germany.</p><p>But now, in 2023, things are different! We can now inscribe images directly into the Bitcoin blockchain, and if “Ordinals theorists” are to be believed, trade ownership of these images in some meaningful sense. Yet, once again, skepticism is warranted, if you take more than one minute to ask how such a thing could be possible.</p><h4>Part II. Ordinals are Fiat</h4><p>Before we look at Ordinals, let’s just consider what a Bitcoin transaction is, from the perspective of the blockchain itself. Very roughly, in a Bitcoin transaction Bob uses his private key to sign over some of his bitcoins from an address he controls, to an address Alice controls. A transaction is simply a record of this process, which is broadcast to the node network, and after sufficient confirmations, becomes immutable. Neither Bob nor Alice can do anything to make that transaction record disappear from the ledger. They cannot change its position in the total sequence of transactions. They cannot duplicate it, because those coins have already been spent. Other than the fact it references their public addresses and the amounts of coin that were transacted, the transaction viewed as an on-chain object has nothing to do with anything that either Bob or Alice can actually control. A transaction can include supplemental data in a section of the transaction record called the “witness.” The witness data stays with the transaction. It does not exist in Bob’s wallet prior to the transaction — it comes into being when the transaction is constructed — and it does not travel to Alice’s wallet after the transaction. When we inscribe jpegs onto the Bitcoin blockchain, we are inscribing them into the witness portion of a transaction, which does not move. If you take nothing else from this, please just absorb this: there is no concept of on-chain “ownership” of a transaction, and hence there is no on-chain concept of ownership of a jpeg inscribed within a transaction. Why then do “Ordinal theorists” act as though they do in fact own inscriptions?</p><p>The name itself, “Ordinal Theory,” the practitioners of which style themselves “ordinal theorists,” attempts to shroud the enterprise with a veil of erudition and gravitas, which, upon closer inspection, simply disintegrates. Let us consult the <a href="https://docs.ordinals.com/overview.html">ordinal handbook</a> itself (And for a more technical description of the method, <a href="https://docs.ordinals.com/faq.html">here</a>).</p><blockquote>“Satoshis are numbered in the order in which they’re mined, and transferred from transaction inputs to transaction outputs first-in-first-out. Both the numbering scheme and the transfer scheme rely on order, the numbering scheme on the order in which satoshis are mined, and the transfer scheme on the order of transaction inputs and outputs. Thus the name, ordinals.”</blockquote><p>The handbook also points out that all the way back in 2012 Bitcoin users, including Charlie Lee, were already proposing similar schemes for numbering satoshis. The <a href="https://docs.ordinals.com/overview.html">handbook</a> takes this as evidence that Ordinal theory is more akin to a discovery, rather than an arbitrary invention:</p><blockquote>“These independent inventions of ordinals indicate in some way that ordinals were discovered, or rediscovered, and not invented. The ordinals are an inevitability of the mathematics of Bitcoin, stemming not from their modern documentation, but from their ancient genesis. They are the culmination of a sequence of events set in motion with the mining of the first block, so many years ago.”</blockquote><p>The flowery language here creates the impression of a significant development — a weighty epiphany — ah, the Ordinals were there all along. Allow me to restate the discovery in plainer language, so we may evaluate its significance: Numbers exist, and we can perform logical operations on them. Bitcoin has had numbers in it all along; therefore, we can perform logical operations on those numbers. Profound.</p><p>In fact, we can perform any arbitrarily complex set of logical operations we wish. We may yet “discover” infinitely many internally consistent algorithms for stipulating labels for slices of bitcoins and tracking those labels across arbitrarily complex sequences of transactions. Starting at the genesis block, counting up from 0.00000001, and positing a first-in-first-out rule for matching inputs to outputs may be the most intuitive one, but we need not stop here!</p><p>So, Ordinals are a method of, first, pretending that it makes sense for satoshis to have serial numbers, and second, stipulating a set of rules to put them in order so that we can count and assign those serial numbers. In other words, we number the satoshis <em>by fiat</em>.</p><p><a href="https://maxmoney.substack.com/p/ordinals-and-inscriptions-improvement">Maxmoney’s</a> summary is helpful (the full article is recommended):</p><blockquote>“Of course, this is nonsense. It makes no sense to say that “Output 8 came from the 3rd satoshi of Input 2”. Because inputs (less mining fees) always equals outputs, it is possible to do this “lining up” process for every transaction, but it does not contain any actual information regarding which satoshis went from where or to whom. To figure out the “ordinal number” of any “virtual satoshi”, start with any UTXO. Work backwards through all of the transaction history to line it up with previous outputs until you get to the coinbase in which it was mined. Add up all of the satoshis that had been mined until that point in time, and that’s the ordinal number. It’s a totally meaningless metric.”</blockquote><p>The crucial point is that at the base layer, the Bitcoin protocol does not recognize this ordering. This counting method is imposed upon it by the third-party software that is your ordinal wallet running the algorithm. As Maxmoney (and many others) have observed, in reality a bitcoin transaction is a little bit like melting down some number of gold bars, and recasting them into new bars of differing sizes. The ordinal scheme is as if you imposed an imaginary three dimensional grid on your gold bars to subdivide them into arbitrarily numbered cubes before melting them down, and a similar grid on your new bars. Then you say “Grid cube (x,y,z) of bar X, pre-melt, corresponds to grid cube (x,y,z) of bar Y, post-melt. You can say such things, if you wish, but saying them and expecting to be taken seriously is foolish, to put it gently. To their credit, competent Ordinal theorists, including the original developer, are quick to admit this (well, they don’t admit that it’s foolish, but they admit the basic facts of the matter), but apparently, it bears repeating, because it fatally undermines the value proposition of “owning” a so-called digital artifact on Bitcoin. More exactly, it undermines that value proposition by undermining the notion that Ordinals and especially inscriptions are things that even <em>can be</em> owned.</p><p>This finally brings us to inscriptions. How is it that content is said to be inscribed “on” a particular satoshi? Again, from the <a href="https://docs.ordinals.com/overview.html">Handbook</a>:</p><blockquote>“Satoshis can be inscribed with arbitrary content, creating Bitcoin-native digital artifacts. Inscribing is done by sending the satoshi to be inscribed in a transaction that reveals the inscription content on-chain. This content is then inextricably linked to that satoshi, turning it into an immutable digital artifact that can be tracked, transferred, hoarded, bought, sold, lost, and rediscovered.”</blockquote><p>Or <a href="https://docs.ordinals.com/inscriptions.html">here</a>:</p><blockquote>“Inscriptions inscribe sats with arbitrary content, creating bitcoin-native digital artifacts, more commonly known as NFTs… These inscribed sats can then be transferred using bitcoin transactions, sent to bitcoin addresses, and held in bitcoin UTXOs.”</blockquote><p><a href="https://docs.ordinals.com/guides/inscriptions.html">Again</a>:</p><blockquote>“Individual sats can be inscribed with arbitrary content, creating Bitcoin-native digital artifacts…”</blockquote><p>Again and again the Handbook makes the bald assertion that sats themselves can be inscribed. Yet, as you delve into the technical details, the language starts to get a bit cagey. It appears to simultaneously acknowledge the reality that inscription content lives inside an indelible transaction, while maintaining the unsupported assertion that it is actually inscribed “upon” a particular sat.</p><blockquote>“<a href="https://docs.ordinals.com/guides/inscriptions.html">Additionally, inscriptions are included in transactions</a>, so the larger the content, the higher the fee that the inscription transaction must pay.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Inscription content is entirely on-chain, stored in taproot script-path spend scripts. Taproot scripts have very few restrictions on their content, and additionally receive the witness discount [because this is where the content actually lives], making inscription content storage relatively economical.”</blockquote><blockquote>“The commit transaction commits to a tapscript containing the contents of the inscription, and the reveal transaction spends from that tapscript, revealing the contents on chain and inscribing them on the first sat of the first output of the reveal transaction.”</blockquote><blockquote>“<a href="https://docs.ordinals.com/inscriptions.html">The inscription content is contained</a> within the input of a reveal transaction, and the inscription is made on the first sat of its first output.”</blockquote><p>Again we see the bald assertion that the content is inscribed on the first sat of the first output. The only problem is that this statement is literally false in every way. We already saw that where the <em>content</em> (a jpeg, poem, other file, whatever) resides is in the witness data of a transaction — the Ordinal Handbook is quite up front about this. And we know that satoshis do not carry content from wallet to wallet. And as we already saw, it is literally impossible to “own” a Bitcoin transaction — it is just a record of what happened. Why then does the Handbook continuously aver that satoshis <em>do </em>get inscribed, and that you <em>can own</em> them? The only sense in which the satoshi — more exactly, the UTXO which, by fiat, is said to contain the sat — is linked to the inscription is that they have some shared history, on account of appearing in the same transaction at some point in the past. Nothing in the ordinal logic requires inscriptions to be linked to the “first” sat. So why is it the first sat of the first output? Why not the second sat of the first output? Why not the last, or one of the other hundreds, thousands, or millions of other satoshis which were also present in that same transaction? The answer is, well, because we are<em> pretending</em> that it is<em> </em>so. In other words, we say a sat is inscribed <em>by fiat</em>.</p><p>I’ve scoured the Handbook for a clear explanation of precisely <em>why </em>an inscription is bound to a particular sat, and I’ve found nothing but the bald assertions presented above. I suppose the reason for this is that if you say it like it is, it’s harder to trick non-technical users into attributing value to your project.</p><p>Consider Tuur Demeester’s inquiry and incisive counterpoints <a href="https://twitter.com/TuurDemeester/status/1662193207227084801">here</a>.</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/TuurDemeester/status/1662193207227084801">https://twitter.com/TuurDemeester/status/1662193207227084801</a></p><p>He likens ordinal &amp; inscription ownership to being offered the opportunity to purchase title to the planet Mars. I would refine the analogy further. It’s like being presented with a star chart of the actual night sky, with a novel “constellation” arbitrarily drawn on top, and being offered the privilege to pay money to “own” this constellation and all the stars within. The blockchain is the night sky, and every bit as immutable. The historical transactions recorded therein are the stars, every bit as untouchable. The jpeg is the constellation, every bit as arbitrary. And the chart depicting where to locate the constellation is the ordinal in your wallet, and every bit as meaningless. If you ascribe meaningful value to this charade, you either don’t understand what you’re buying (a problem this essay seeks to correct), or are at best acting imprudently. “But free agents value it on muh free market!” Yes, and we may simultaneously acknowledge that all valuation is subjective while also recognizing that wisdom is not.</p><p>Now, to further drive a wedge through the already-tenuous conceptual link between an ordinal-labelled sat and its associated inscription, here is some top kek for you. The default search method for an inscription in the Ordinal wallet or on the Ordinal block explorer does not even reference the Ordinal number. Once more from the <a href="https://docs.ordinals.com/guides/inscriptions.html">docs</a>:</p><blockquote>“To create an inscription with the contents of FILE, run:</blockquote><blockquote>&lt;ord wallet inscribe — fee-rate FEE_RATE FILE&gt;</blockquote><blockquote>Ord will output two transactions IDs, one for the commit transaction, and one for the reveal transaction, and the inscription ID. Inscription IDs are of the form TXIDiN, where TXID is the transaction ID of the reveal transaction, and N is the index of the inscription in the reveal transaction.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Once the reveal transaction has been mined, the inscription ID should be printed when you run:</blockquote><blockquote>&lt;ord wallet inscriptions&gt;</blockquote><blockquote>And when you visit the ordinals explorer at ordinals.com/inscription/INSCRIPTION_ID.”</blockquote><p>Screenshot for posterity:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EfIkyZODL05NE3Vcb9cwlQ.png" /></figure><p>The unique identifier for the inscription is just the TXID with an integer (not the ordinal number) appended to it. It is laughable that the simplest way to identify an inscription does not even reference the so-called digital artifact that is said to bear the inscription. You certainly <em>can</em> input the ordinal number into the block explorer and find the relevant inscription, but you need not. Obviously, it is a simple design change to incorporate the ordinal number into the inscription ID, but to do so would be an acknowledgement that there is no real link, it’s all fake, and they’re trying to obfuscate this fact. You could also imbed the ordinal number within the inscription content, but this carries no more weight than the U.S. government inscribing on the blockchain the statement “The USD is hard money.” Fiat written on the blockchain is still fiat.</p><p>In view of the foregoing, what “inscribe on a satoshi” really means is, if you count numbers a certain way up to a particular UTXO, then work backwards through that UTXO’s transaction history, you will eventually find a transaction with this particular inscription in it. Ultimately, therefore, what you have in your Ordinal wallet is a kind of off-chain “pointer” to a location on chain which is not controlled (owned) by any private key. Whereas Ethereum NFT’s are largely on-chain pointers to off-chain content, Bitcoin NFT’s are essentially off-chain pointers to on-chain content. In neither case is the thing to which you have any meaningful claim of ownership an immutable digital asset. According to the <a href="https://docs.ordinals.com/digital-artifacts.html">Ordinals Handbook</a> itself, “Digital artifacts can have owners.” Therefore, inscriptions are not digital artifacts, because they cannot have owners. The only digital artifacts on Bitcoin are bitcoins.</p><h4>Part III. Inscriptions are not Rare</h4><p>Bitcoin is not designed to make digital art scarce.</p><p>The notion that blockchain-enforced digital scarcity is a property that art can have stems from a misunderstanding of how digital scarcity emerges from a blockchain. Digital scarcity is a property that emerges from carefully considered protocol design. A blockchain, when sufficiently decentralized across enough independent nodes, enforces consensus rules. If those consensus rules are engineered in such a way as to yield digital scarcity, then that blockchain enforces digital scarcity. E.g., the Bitcoin consensus rules contain an algorithm which logically ensures that there will never be more than 21 million bitcoins:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/528/1*GBlZ00Trl0Jkic1I8vhifA.png" /></figure><p>Hence, given sufficient decentralization, the supply is credibly capped, and bitcoins are credibly scarce. The Bitcoin consensus rules do not permit the appending of certain ledger entries without the requisite private keys (namely, ledger entries involving someone else’s coins). Hence, the ownership or control of those ledger entries is provably inviolable — we might say permission to append to the ledger is scarce. In your word processor of choice, you may create new ledger entries to transfer my sats to you as much as you want, but if you try to commit those ledger edits to the chain without my private key, the nodes will laugh you out of the mempool, because you are not abiding by consensus rules. Scarcity as a property inheres in bitcoins, which are themselves abstractions from the state of the ledger. Scarcity is not a property of any bit of information within the ledger. Indeed, strictly speaking, every bit of information in the ledger is replicated across the entire network.</p><p>The consensus rules do in fact permit the inscription of arbitrary sequences of bytes (e.g. jpegs) of data — information — into the witness data of a transaction. What the Bitcoin consensus rules <em>do not</em> contain, is anything whatsoever to restrict the long-term supply of jpegs on chain, nor any restriction on the ability to reproduce them. In fact, you can inscribe the same arbitrary sequence of bytes of data into as many transactions as you wish. So can I. After you pay your egregious fee to mint your “rare” piece of “art,” I can copy-pasta the exact sequence of bytes, and duplicate your “rare” piece of “art” (I won’t, because I’m not a rube who enjoys wasting what is scarce to obtain what is abundant, but I could). But I might make it my Twitter profile pic. Much scarce. Very digital. Wow.</p><p>In what is becoming a pattern of making spurious claims, once again the Ordinals handbook contends that inscriptions on Bitcoin are scarcer than NFT’s on, e.g., Ethereum:</p><blockquote>Inscriptions are scarcer.</blockquote><blockquote>Inscriptions require bitcoin to mint, transfer, and store. This seems like a downside on the surface, but the raison d’etre of digital artifacts is to be scarce and thus valuable.</blockquote><blockquote>Ethereum NFTs, on the other hand, can be minted in virtually unlimited qualities with a single transaction, making them inherently less scarce, and thus, potentially less valuable.</blockquote><p>And yet, we already saw there is no supply cap to on-chain jpegs. The supply of on-chain jpegs may approach infinity at a slower pace than Ethereum NFT’s, but it is still conceptually infinite. It’s only been six months, and there are already half as many inscriptions as there are bitcoin that will ever be mined.</p><h3>Lauren Sieckmann 🧙🏻‍♀️ on Twitter: &quot;Ordinals just hit 10 million inscriptions 🤯Who said Bitcoin wasn&#39;t for building?! / Twitter&quot;</h3><p>Ordinals just hit 10 million inscriptions 🤯Who said Bitcoin wasn&#39;t for building?!</p><p>In ~120 years, when the final bitcoin has been mined, how many inscriptions will there be? So. Heckin. Scarce.</p><p>We’ve seen how you can mint as many copies of a jpeg on-chain as you want. What you cannot do, is broadcast duplicate sequences of bytes that constitute a valid bitcoin transaction. This constitutes a double-spend, and violates consensus rules. The information contained in a valid bitcoin transaction cannot be duplicated at any later time. The information contained in a jpeg can be. Bitcoin the protocol is designed to enforce the scarcity of one thing and one thing only: the supply of bitcoins.</p><p>If you wanted to make a given jpeg provably, digitally scarce, you would need to engineer something like a protocol with consensus rules that check the entire history of the chain to see if that particular sequence of bytes had ever been inscribed before — but, leaving aside the feasibility of such a project, this isn’t much use because I can still mint the same image, less one pixel, ushering in an impossible process of filter refinement to reject those images that are “too close” to an extant one. This is, of course, leaving aside the fact that I can copy-pasta anything that appears on my screen, and an off-chain copy exists on the artist’s personal hard drive. If we have to trust the artist to destroy off-chain copies, what is the point of a “trustless” blockchain? Even if the consensus rules did somehow limit duplicate images, this by itself confers no value to a work of art. The starving artist is a meme for a reason. Uniqueness is not a sufficient condition for value accretion. How many unique pieces of analog art have little or no value? (Spoiler: nearly all of them). Converting to a digital medium and paying a bunch of money for a data center operator to distribute the image to a network of independent storage hosting providers adds value….how, exactly?</p><p>Alternatively, suppose you devise a way to inscribe an encrypted sequence of bytes, such that the jpeg is not viewable without your particular private key. But then you don’t get to display your degen trollery to the public and chase clout. I suspect many of the current participants would be less keen to blow sats on memes they can’t publicly display to “own the maxis.” Perhaps, bona fide art collectooor that you are, you could integrate your private key into a physical display screen in your posh moon-manor, to show off your avant-garde collection to your pump’n’dump profiteering social circle…but then, why not just own analog art? Once again, if you<em> ever</em> display your encrypted “rare” NFT in a publicly accessible digital format, you’ve compromised the only quality that made it rare. Moreover, the private key is information that lives off chain. You’re retaining off-chain the only thing that makes the art visible, so you’re not enjoying the benefits of “digital scarcity” that putting art on the blockchain was meant to provide. The scarcity is being enforced by your control of the private key, not the encrypted data replicated across the nodes.</p><p>“But but but, there are digital images of famous artworks, and the originals are still considered valuable!” Yes, because obviously a digital image of a Picasso is not a Picasso. The Picasso is a physical artifact existing in meatspace with a particular history and provenance. A byte-for-byte copy of a digital image is… literally the same digital image. There are no meaningful properties by which to distinguish them. “But if, <em>by fiat</em>, we count sats from the genesis block via an entirely gerrymandered method, we can point to the location on a distributed network of hard drives where the “original” jpeg resides…something something provenance!” Uh…congratulations…I guess? You came up with a convoluted way of doing something we could already do by just, ya know, looking up the TXID…oh yeah, that’s basically what the Ordinals explorer already does. Also, it’s not the original because you have to trust the creator to delete the original.</p><p>If you want to support an artist, why not just send him some sats in exchange for a beautiful piece in meatspace? Heck, you can even ask him for a digital piece, and ask him to destroy the original. You now have more control and exclusivity than you would if you inscribed it in a public ledger, in which case you would still have to trust him to destroy the original. The only reason the enterprise of putting art on the blockchain appears to add value, when in reality it adds none whatsoever, is because we are in the middle of a high time preference, fiat-brained gold-rush — a fake gold-rush of affinity scams, in which the application of the bitcoin/blockchain/crypto monikers to an endeavor creates a veneer of bleeding-edge innovation, to extract maximum value from speculators desperate to escape the manipulations of central bankers and kleptocratic, power-mad bureaucracies. But the tool for that escape already exists. It’s just Bitcoin. Don’t overthink it.</p><h4>Part IV. Objections</h4><ol><li>“Uhm…ACKSHUALLY, the term <em>fiat</em> implies the power to coerce or enforce! No one is enforcing the Ordinal scheme or the accepted conventions of inscriptions on anyone!” OK reply guy, don’t be pedantic. Obviously I am being rhetorical for effect. The relevant aspect of <em>fiaticity </em>for this discussion is the sheer fakeitude of it all (gosh heck now he’s making up words). Fakeitude, if you need clarification, is the lack of correspondence to an underlying reality. The problem is that less technical users are easily misled by the confident assertions of a reality that does not exist to buy something they otherwise might not. While I believe individuals are solely responsible for their own financial destinies, that does not absolve you of taking advantage of their inadequate due diligence.</li><li>“We’re creating an indelible monument to last for eternity!” No, what you’re doing is defacing an indelible monument with your grotesque monkeys, inane pixel art, and pumponomics scam tokens. And once more, to make sure I thoroughly beat the dead horse, your defacements are infinitely replicable by anyone of a mind to do so.</li><li>“Money is a collective hallucination, and so is Bitcoin, so why can’t ordinals and inscriptions be so?” <a href="https://nakamotoinstitute.org/mempool/bitcoin-is-not-backed-by-nothing/">Money is not a hallucination.</a> The emergence of some good as money is a shared <em>realization</em> that that good has the best monetary properties. It is a shared realization that it is the most salable good, as Saifedean (and the fathers of Austrian economics before him) likes to say. Monetary properties are grounded in reality. A money emerges as more and more people recognize this reality. A hallucination is a mistake. In that sense, Ordinals and inscriptions <em>are</em> a collective hallucination — a hallucination that something is there when it is not: a claim to ownership of any meaningful asset.</li><li>“Heckin’ darn it! I paid good money for this here inscription! Who are you to tell me I don’t own it?” This is not really an objection, but I’m trying to tell you that you got taken. Don’t be easier to fool than to be convinced you have been fooled. Take the L and get on with your life.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f1681b60facc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>