<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Stuart Gill on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Stuart Gill on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@spdgill?source=rss-e2b3961518e1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 07:05:02 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@spdgill/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Love?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@spdgill/why-love-53cd9a80e235?source=rss-e2b3961518e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/53cd9a80e235</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[power]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stuart Gill]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 May 2024 05:44:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-09T11:27:48.461Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IEp0bfFeRES5IGRrZd5oyQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Generated with DALL-E</figcaption></figure><p><em>A relational imperative</em></p><p><strong>By Stuart Gill</strong></p><p><strong><em>St. Nikolai Velimirovich </em></strong><em>once said that — while a scholar attracts by knowledge, the wealthy by riches, the handsome by beauty, and the artist by skill: “Only love attracts all human beings. The attraction of love is unlimited. And educated and uneducated, rich or poor, skilled or unskilled, beautiful or ugly, healthy or sick, and young or old — all want to be loved.”</em></p><p>After my father died, I sat down to write his eulogy. I looked at the blank page, and a question surfaced, quiet at first, then insistent. Did my father love me? The funeral was days away. I still could not find a way to begin. Every memory felt tangled. I waited for something to come loose.</p><p>Eventually, I reached for a book I had nearly forgotten. Twenty years earlier, I had picked up a copy of Paul Tillich’s Love, Power, and Justice in a secondhand bookstore. That little book had followed me across continents, survived a bushfire, narrowly escaped being resold, and endured years of neglect, until the month my father died, I finally read it.</p><p>As I sat with my grief, Tillich’s words met me with unexpected force. They did not console me, but they did something more useful. He set love, power and justice in relation to one another. His understanding of love as “the drive toward the unity of the separated” still felt cold and abstract, yet the way he bound these forces in a kind of moral entanglement, where each moved in response to the others, changed how I saw my father and the nature of relationship itself. Something in me began to shift.</p><p>That shift has led me here, to the quiet but persistent ambition of this essay: to explore the nature of love, not only as a feeling but as something deeply personal and endlessly complex. Love resists easy definition. It spans time and culture, shaped by memory, longing and hope. We all long to be loved, as St Velimirovich observed, yet when we reach for it, love slips through our fingers. Still, the reach matters. For in reaching, we may find that love is not something to be grasped, but something to be met, a living presence, full of wonder, waiting to be embraced.</p><p><strong>One of the greatest problems of history</strong></p><p>I could conclude this essay just as quickly as I began it, with the following quote from a speech Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. delivered in 1967.</p><p><em>“One of the great problems of history is that the concepts of love and power have usually been contrasted as opposites — polar opposites — so that love is identified with a resignation of power, and power with a denial of love….We’ve got to get this thing right. What is needed is a realization that power without love is reckless and abusive, and love without power is sentimental and anaemic. Power at its best is love implementing the demands of justice, and justice at its best is power correcting everything that stands against love.”</em></p><p>There is a beauty in these words that makes their truth hard to ignore. Yet they also uncover a troubling reality. As Dr. King observed, “One of the great problems of history” is that we lack an understanding of love, power, and justice that truly serves us. Take justice, for example: it is unsettling to realise that even a terrorist believes their actions are just. And in a way, many of us are not so different, though on a much smaller scale. We often justify our own harmful actions by pointing to circumstance.</p><blockquote>As Dr. King observed, “One of the great problems of history” is that we lack an understanding of love, power, and justice that truly serves us.</blockquote><p>Why, then, do our understandings of justice diverge so widely? And what does this mean for how we understand love? With such differing views on what is just, how can we ever hope, as Dr. King challenged, to “get this thing right”?</p><p><strong>The different faces of justice</strong></p><p>In Western society today, the political landscape rests on two dominant understandings of justice: equality of outcome and equality of opportunity. These principles anchor the contrasting worldviews of the political Left and Right, respectively. Yet in practice, the pursuit of justice often places these ideals in tension, creating a paradox that divides the very society it seeks to serve.</p><p>In my work in economic development and impact investing, I occasionally encounter this tension as it plays out within real-world economies. Each ideal, equality of outcome and equality of opportunity, seeks to shape economic realities in its own way. To better grasp this tension, consider the cartoon below, which offers a simple but vivid illustration of these competing visions in action.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*AHTZtNAxEIsdfKWQ" /><figcaption><em>Figure 1. 2019 Design In Tech Report | “Addressing Imbalance” Illustrations by @lunchbreath</em></figcaption></figure><p>In the first panel, the cartoon sets up the core problem: inequality, depicted through the uneven distribution of apples. It raises a central question: how can we correct this unfairness? The cartoon then offers three potential solutions, each illustrating a distinct way to approach the challenge of achieving justice.</p><p>The first solution, shown in the second panel and labelled simply as <em>equality</em>, focuses on providing equal opportunity. Everyone receives the same tools and resources to achieve their goals: in this case, identical ladders to reach the apples. Yet while this seems fair on the surface, it can unintentionally deepen inequality, because identical resources do not guarantee equal outcomes. Ironically, if equal outcomes are the goal, treating everyone the same might actually push us further from that goal.</p><p>The next solution, labelled <em>equity</em>, takes things a step further by accounting for each person’s unique circumstances. Instead of distributing the same resources to everyone, it provides each character with a ladder specifically suited to their needs. This brings the system closer to ensuring both individuals receive a fair share, a meaningful improvement, though it stops short of fully closing the gap.</p><p>Finally, the cartoon presents <em>justice</em>, suggesting it is achieved by addressing systemic inequalities directly, fixing the underlying conditions within the system itself. Once these deeper issues are corrected, equal opportunity becomes genuinely fair, as everyone can now make effective use of identical resources on a truly level playing field.</p><p>However, the cartoon begins by framing unequal apple distribution as the core problem. But even after addressing systemic issues, what prevents one character from simply taking more than their share? Wouldn’t this risk recreating the original inequality? To achieve true justice, would we then need an arbiter, perhaps a central authority, to ensure fair distribution? Or has inequality suddenly become acceptable simply because the playing field is now level?</p><p>Of course, society’s understanding of justice isn’t neatly divided into two opposing views. Many theories offer more nuanced perspectives. For example, John Rawls’s <em>Justice as Fairness</em> emphasises impartiality and prioritises equality of opportunity, allowing inequalities of outcome only when they benefit society’s least advantaged. By contrast, Robert Nozick’s <em>Libertarian Justice</em> advocates minimal intervention, endorsing formal equality of opportunity while firmly rejecting any attempt to enforce equality of outcome.</p><p>Yet perhaps the cartoon’s premise is flawed. Maybe justice isn’t only about how resources are distributed. While fairness in sharing matters, is it truly the foundation on which we should build our understanding of justice? Consider, for example, a Utilitarian perspective, where both equality of outcome and equality of opportunity are viewed as means to a larger end: maximising overall happiness.</p><p>But is happiness really the right goal? It may seem fine for us as humans, but what does happiness mean for the environment? As our little characters pluck apples from the tree, who is caring for the tree itself?</p><p>Perhaps the true lesson of the cartoon lies elsewhere. Maybe it teaches us that justice is far more complex and interconnected than it first appears. That justice for one is rarely justice for all. As John Muir so beautifully observed, “When we try to pick out anything by itself, we find it hitched to everything else in the Universe.” Could it be that beneath these competing ideals lies a deeper framework, one that draws us toward a more expansive understanding of the nature of love?</p><blockquote>Maybe it teaches us that justice is far more complex and interconnected than it first appears, that justice for one is rarely justice for all.</blockquote><p><strong>Looking through the lens of the Relational Imperative</strong></p><p>In an earlier piece, <em>“</em><a href="https://medium.com/@spdgill/what-lies-between-us-my-journey-in-pursuit-of-a-good-society-4655fd2f85be"><em>What Lies Between Us</em></a><em>,”</em> I argued that building a good society requires shifting the center of our moral universe, moving away from a singular focus on either the individual or the collective, and turning toward <em>what-lies-between-us</em>: relationship. This shift is captured in the Relational Imperative, which now serves as our guide as we continue exploring justice and love. If you’re unfamiliar with the Relational Imperative, I encourage you to explore a fuller introduction <a href="https://medium.com/@spdgill/introducing-the-relational-imperative-0169fcdc19fd">here</a>. For now, I’ll offer a brief overview.</p><p>The Relational Imperative is a heuristic, illustrated as an x-y graph, that deepens our understanding of the belief that “in nature nothing exists alone.” This principle suggests not only that we need one another, but also that we become who we are through our relationships with each other. Though the graph may seem simple at first glance, it holds within it the same depth and complexity as the principle it represents.</p><p>At its core, the graph captures the state of a relationship at a given moment. For example, when applying the Relational Imperative to my relationship with my wife, I don’t position myself on one axis and her on the other. Instead, the Relational Imperative places me (or her, depending on the focus of the dialogue) on the y-axis and our marriage itself, the relationship we share, on the x-axis.</p><p>The first thing to note about the Relational Imperative is this: assigning the axes in this way places me on both. I exist on the y-axis as an individual and on the x-axis as part of the collective we create through our marriage. This dual placement reflects our inherent interdependence, capturing the heart of the idea that nothing exists alone.</p><blockquote>The first thing to note about the Relational Imperative is this: assigning the axis in this way places me on both axes.</blockquote><p>Secondly, it’s important to recognise that the Relational Imperative is not merely a simple 2x2 matrix. Rather, it is a living graph with directional axes that symbolise growth. In our example, this represents both my personal growth as an individual and the growth of our marriage as its own collective unfolding. But growth toward what, exactly? That is perhaps the most challenging and most vital aspect of the Relational Imperative because it is something that must be discovered and defined both individually and together.</p><p>Our final point here is that mapping the state of a relationship ultimately means mapping the expression of power between the individual and the collective from moment to moment. Whether we are looking at a person within a marriage, a player within a team, a team within a company, or a citizen within a state, power is always present, shaping the interaction between the “I” (on the y-axis: person, player, team, citizen) and the “We” (on the x-axis: marriage, team, company, state).</p><p>Because this power is realised in relationship, it is always in motion. Each choice shifts the balance between the I and the We, enabling either the individual or the collective to empower, uplift, disempower or overpower the other. That motion does not stop at the boundary of a single relationship, since no relationship stands alone. Each is nested within larger systems that are dynamic and linked to the rest. Influence flows both ways. Small shifts move out as ripples and return as waves. What happens in one moves through them all.</p><p>In our distilled picture, however, the dynamic process reveals four basic relational states:</p><ul><li>I + We are realised</li><li>I am realised at the expense of Us</li><li>We are realised at the expense of I</li><li>Neither I nor We are realised</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jqAWfhkgl4bcIBi8" /><figcaption>Figure 2. The Relational Imperative</figcaption></figure><p>With the Relational Imperative (re)introduced, we can now use it as a lens to deepen our exploration of justice. I have come to see the four quadrants not simply as relational states, but as expressions of deeper assumptions, the underlying beliefs that shape how we understand the world and justice. The quadrants reveal different foundations for justice because each one illuminates a distinct way we can value, privilege and attend to relationship. Seen through this lens, concepts like equality of outcome and equality of opportunity emerge from different ways of attending, each privileging a different aspect of the “I–We” dynamic.</p><blockquote>The quadrants reveal different foundations for justice because each one illuminates a distinct way we can value, privilege and attend to relationship.</blockquote><p>Take, for example, the concept of equality of outcome. In this worldview, justice seeks to ensure that everyone ends up with the same, defining fairness through uniform distribution. It prioritises equality within the collective, often emphasising sameness over individuality. While it aims to eliminate disparities, it can diminish the uniqueness that defines us as individuals. Here, morality is rooted in the collective, where justice is achieved when resources or outcomes are evenly shared, regardless of personal circumstances. This emphasis on the collective, sometimes at the expense of individual distinctiveness, aligns with the bottom-right quadrant.</p><p>Now consider the concept of equal opportunity. In this worldview, justice aims to give everyone the same starting point by removing barriers so that differences in outcome arise from differences in choice or effort. Here, individuality is valued over uniformity, and the focus shifts to recognising personal differences, needs and abilities. From this perspective, unequal outcomes are not a failure but the expected result of a fair process. Morality centres on the individual. Justice is served when the same formal opportunities are available to all and outcomes follow from merit and choice. This emphasis on the individual over the collective aligns with the top-left quadrant.</p><p>What this tells us is that our understanding of justice is not fixed. It shifts depending on what we choose to value, privilege and give our attention to. The Relational Imperative makes this visible by showing how each way of attending to relationship generates a different moral starting point. This is illustrated in Figure 3.</p><p>What we give our attention to does more than shape what we notice; it shapes how we see. This is not a straightforward, linear process but a reinforcing loop that draws us deeper into a particular perspective, gradually shaping our entire worldview. When our attention is fixed on the bottom right, we prioritise the collective, elevating the whole above the individual. When our gaze is fixed on the top left, we centre the individual. Each focus pulls us further into a distinct vision of justice and reality, shaping not only our perceptions but also our values and choices.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UDtw-zJw2yRFUOXoKrIGXw.png" /><figcaption>Figure3. Where attention is given within the Relational Imperative</figcaption></figure><p>In his book “<em>The Geography of Thought: How Asians and Westerners Think Differently…and Why,”</em> Richard Nisbett observed that Western societies tend to prioritise the individual, while Eastern societies emphasise collective social structures. Yet, as Nisbett points out, reality is rarely that simple. Societies do not simply choose between the individual and the collective nation-state. Some place the highest value on immediate family, while others elevate extended familial structures such as clans and tribes. Across cultures, there exists a rich spectrum of relational scales that societies may choose to prioritise.</p><p>My point here is not just to highlight the diversity of these choices, but to emphasise that as societies have evolved, each has made deliberate decisions about which relational scale to prioritise. Decisions that have shaped their entire worldview. These choices, in turn, determine where attention is directed and what is held most sacred in their pursuit of justice.</p><p>By privileging one relational scale over another, we inevitably sow the seeds of discontent. But is this the only path before us? Must we always choose a single, or even multiple, scales upon which to build a society? Is it necessary to elevate one way of relating above all others, or might there be a way to create dialogue between these scales without placing one above the rest?</p><p><strong>A third way</strong></p><p>This brings us to the top-right quadrant, where the focus turns from privileging either the individual or the collective toward what lies between us: relationship. Here, relationship itself takes precedence. By placing the relationship at the centre, we open a space that honours both the individual and the collective, allowing neither to diminish the other. It is a movement toward the coexistence of unity and multiplicity, where the many remain distinct yet move together as one. This approach is not a compromise but a fundamentally different path, a third way in which the dialogue between scales becomes the foundation rather than the battleground for building a good society.</p><p>Adopting the perspective of the top-right quadrant means recognising that relationship is the ground of justice. Viewed through this lens, our cartoon invites us to consider not only the interaction between the two characters but also the role of the tree and its connection to the broader ecosystem. A relational perspective reminds us that justice for one rarely translates into justice for all.</p><p>This worldview calls for dialogue, a deep listening that seeks to understand how our actions ripple through the lives of others. It invites us to care for our neighbours as we care for ourselves, recognising that our well-being is inseparably tied to theirs. It is a commitment to nurturing the potential of both the individual and the collective, one that asks for a radical reorientation of our attention and a courageous re-examination of what we truly value.</p><p>This commitment to relationship is not just an abstract ideal; it’s something I’ve had to learn to practice in my own life. When my wife and I argue, and cooler heads prevail, our guiding question becomes: <em>Are we drawing closer to each other or moving apart?</em> This shift in perspective steers us away from the urge to win or persuade and toward engaging in meaningful dialogue that addresses the heart of the issue. Over time, we’ve come to believe that healthy relationships aren’t simply byproducts of happiness; they are the foundation that makes lasting happiness possible.</p><p>This is an example of top right behaviour, where a third path to justice emerges beyond familiar symbols. It looks past the figure of Lady Justice, the blindfold signalling impartiality, the scales keeping account in an eye-for-eye measure, and the sword enforcing retribution. Here, justice is not primarily about balancing a ledger or delivering penalties, but about something more foundational.</p><p>That foundation is the restoration and strengthening of relationship. This vision of restorative justice extends an invitation, one that calls for grace and mutual commitment. It creates the space where ruptures can be acknowledged, healing can take root, and connection can be rebuilt. A space where both the “I” and the “We” stand strong together, each upheld and made more whole by the other.</p><blockquote>The true purpose of justice is this: to restore and strengthen relationship.</blockquote><p>It’s important to clarify that I am not advocating for grace from a victim toward an abuser. Such situations lack the genuine commitment required for a mutual relationship. At its heart, grace is an invitation into relationship, and true relationship can never be imposed; it requires a willing, mutual response. Just as in my relationship with my wife, this form of justice demands that both parties actively move toward one another.</p><p>This mutual response calls for vulnerability, humility, and above all, honesty. It asks us to take responsibility for our actions, to extend forgiveness when it is needed, and to seek it when it is ours to ask. The path is often demanding and difficult, yet if we believe that a steadfast commitment to relationship is the foundation of true happiness, then the real question is not whether we will choose it, but how could we possibly choose otherwise.</p><p><strong>Love as a commitment</strong></p><p>This brings us to our first definition of love: at its core, love is a mutual commitment to a just relationship where both the individual (“I”) and the collective (“We”) are upheld and strengthened by each other. It is the living expression of right-relationship, a dynamic space where the needs of both are not just balanced but tended with care, where each gives shape and strength to the other. Love, in this sense, is neither passive nor fleeting; it demands intention, effort, and a willingness to sustain this delicate dance. The truest measure of love is therefore not found in words or emotions, but in the depth of our commitment to live this way of being into reality.</p><blockquote>The truest measure of love is therefore not found in words or emotions, but in the depth of our commitment to live this way of being into reality.</blockquote><p>To love, then, is to commit not only to joy and peace but also to hardship, pain, and the weight of real consequences. Love is not merely about basking in the light; it is about standing together in the shadows. And within those shadows, we encounter our own brokenness and the brokenness of others, along with our differing capacities to care for both the “I” and the “We.”</p><p>Yet when there is a shared commitment to right-relationship, we lay a foundation of hope, not a passive hope, but one born of trust. This kind of commitment signals that neither party is walking away, even when things are difficult. It creates the safety needed for honesty, the space where brokenness can be named and healing can begin. In that space, we grow in our relational capacities. Love, like the journey toward wholeness, meets us not in ease, but on the far side of the trials we’ve walked through together.</p><p>It was here that I found the answer to my question: Did my father love me? He never gave up on me, and I never gave up on him. Though we were both limited by our brokenness, we each tried our best, and we never gave up on each other.</p><p>Love isn’t always about grand gestures or flawless affection. It’s about the steadfast presence in each other’s lives and the unwavering commitment despite our flaws and limitations. My father, though imperfect, showed his love by never surrendering to the weight of his brokenness, and for that, I love him dearly.</p><p><strong>Love as the affirmation of life</strong></p><p>Love, as a mutual commitment to right-relationship, has one final thing to teach us. Since “in nature, nothing exists alone,” this commitment cannot be confined to ourselves or our immediate relationships. It calls us to reach beyond the familiar, embracing all “I’s” and “We’s.” In its fullest expression, love recognises that every relationship, no matter how distant, is “hitched to everything else in the Universe.” By affirming these connections, we affirm all living things, and in doing so, love becomes known to us as the affirmation of life itself.</p><p>To love is not merely to care for those closest to us, but to recognise that our thriving is bound up with the thriving of others, of communities, ecosystems, and even the unseen forces that sustain life. It is an acknowledgement that the same breath moves through us all, that the pulse of life within one echoes through the whole. In this way, love becomes more than just an emotion or a choice. It transforms into a sacred affirmation of existence. An unwavering yes to life in all its forms.</p><blockquote>In this way, love becomes more than just an emotion or a choice. It transforms into a sacred affirmation of existence. An unwavering yes to life in all its forms.</blockquote><p><strong>The other faces of Love</strong></p><p>The story of love does not end here. Just as we examined justice through the lenses of the Relational Imperative, we can now turn to love and consider how it unfolds within the different worldviews of each quadrant. When we do, two familiar narratives come into focus, first in the bottom right, then in the top left.</p><p>The bottom-right quadrant tells a story of self‑sacrificial love, the kind that calls us to set aside our own needs and desires to serve others. This was the story I was taught to believe and value growing up, the story that was modelled for me. It is a love often celebrated, even idolised. Perhaps you have experienced this kind of love or felt the weight of its expectations. There is undeniable beauty in such devotion, yet there is also a danger. When it is left unchecked, this love can drain one side of the relationship, leaving the giver empty, and it can plant seeds of unworthiness in the other, closing the door to reciprocity. Without being balanced by a right love of self, this love risks becoming a pathology.</p><p>The true beauty of self‑denial in love lies not in sacrificing the self for the sake of the We, but in letting go of what hinders wholeness, gathering and integrating the parts of yourself that keep you from bringing your full self to the relationship. Only a whole self can fully receive love in return. Only then can mutual realisation deepen. Love, after all, is not a zero‑sum game.</p><p>The narrative of the top‑left quadrant centres on self‑love. It has become one of the ailments of our time. Our social and economic structures reward independence and often embed this story within us without our noticing. Yet the beauty of self‑love lies in its mutuality. Loving myself means knowing my limits and voicing my needs so that together we can care for both us and me. Without the counterweight of love for the We, the love of I folds in on itself. We are left isolated, and in the end, on our knees, in need of a new story.</p><p><strong>Seeing the story of love anew in the age of broken relationship</strong></p><p>We are living in an age of broken relationship, from our fractured connection with the planet, driving the sixth mass extinction and climate change, to the epidemic of loneliness and polarisation flowing from our broken relationship with each other and ourselves. Everywhere we turn, we see dysfunctional narratives of love playing out. As Dr. King reminded us, “We have to get this thing right.”</p><p>I believe the Relational Imperative invites us to see the story of love with fresh eyes. But let me be clear: I’m not suggesting love can be neatly captured in our 2x2 graph. Love defies such simplification.</p><p>In fact, this irreducibility illuminates something central to love’s nature, as captured in Martin Buber’s description of the I-Thou relationship: “If I face a human being as my Thou, [they are] no thing among things … not a condition to be experienced and described, a loose bundle of named qualities. But whole in themselves, they are Thou and fill the heavens.” When we meet another as Thou, not It, we step into something alive and sacred. A space where we see the other not as a means to an end, but as an end in themselves, worthy of reverence and response. It is within this space, beyond measure or control, that love reveals its fullest depth: real, alive, and irreducible.</p><p>And yet, despite this, we are shaped by a world Buber calls the I-It. A world shaped by propositions and material outcomes, by the objective (top-left quadrant) and the subjective (bottom-right quadrant). But the top right-hand quadrant points us beyond these categories, toward Buber’s I-Thou world: a what-lies-between-us world, a relational ontology in which the very ground of being is not substance or object, but relationship itself. A reality that, by its nature, resists reduction.</p><p>Even so, in this age of broken relationship, the I-Thou, the space of what-lies-between-us, remains within reach. We encounter it in nature, where the living world meets us not just as a resource to use, but as a presence to behold and tend with care. We hear it in our Scriptures, where love, justice, and awe call us into right relationship. And we discover it within ourselves and others, presence to presence, through capacities like empathy. That remarkable crossing beyond our own experience, where we glimpse the world through another’s eyes and, even if only for a moment, share in their life.</p><p>Yet here lies the challenge: our capacity to live in I-Thou relationship (in right-relationship, in loving relationship) has evolved to thrive at the human-to-human scale. But this capacity begins to thin as we approach the edge of what we can meaningfully hold, what social scientists call Dunbar’s number, placing it at around 150 relationships. Beyond that, we begin to sort people into categories, and it becomes far easier to dismiss or harm a group labelled as other than it is to dismiss or harm a person we know by name, face, and story.</p><p>How, then, do we carry this capacity further? How do we extend this way of relating, this intuitive, immeasurable capacity, so it can function across broader relational scales, beyond the small circles we can personally hold?</p><p>I believe this question stands as the defining challenge of our time, the central fault line beneath this age of broken relationship.</p><p>Dr. King understood this well, reminding us that meeting such a challenge is not merely structural or political, but a moral and imaginative task. One that asks us to reimagine how love moves through power and shapes justice.</p><p>The story of love we have traced here does not resolve into a definition. It opens into an invitation, a call to shared responsibility for one another and for all living things. When relationship becomes our ground, the place from which we think and act, we learn to move with care between the needs of the one and the many and to find wisdom in the tension that holds them together.</p><p>Practised in this way, love is not something to be grasped or controlled, but encountered. And when it meets us, it comes clothed in wonder. As Buber reminds us, “The world is not comprehensible, but it is embraceable: through the embrace of one of its beings.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=53cd9a80e235" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Introducing the Relational Imperative]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@spdgill/introducing-the-relational-imperative-0169fcdc19fd?source=rss-e2b3961518e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0169fcdc19fd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stuart Gill]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 May 2024 09:11:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-07T11:38:53.770Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U52nxkREKIHieWb8mLzlBw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Generated with DALL-E</figcaption></figure><p><em>A simple heuristic for a more relational world</em></p><p><strong>By Stuart Gill</strong></p><blockquote>“In nature nothing exists alone.” — Rachel Carson</blockquote><p>The world has never been more connected, or more fragile. A single action, whether a subtle shift or a seismic shock, can ripple across continents, upending lives, ecosystems, and economies in ways we can barely grasp. Human achievement has expanded our reach, but in doing so, it has worn thin the buffers that once kept our influence in check. The intricate layers of society, especially the environment, that once fostered equilibrium and stability are unravelling. We stand exposed, unmoored, struggling to find our footing in a world growing ever more volatile.</p><p>This fragility is not new, but it has deepened. It first became existential with the creation of the atom bomb, the moment we gained the power to unmake ourselves. Today, that sense of threat lingers on too many fronts to name. At the root of it all is a forgetting, a failure to remember, as Rachel Carson once wrote, that in nature, nothing exists alone. That forgetting has been the recurring story, and tragedy, of history.</p><p>Those few words carry immense weight, reminding us that our very existence is bound to the other. Yet we alone, among all creatures, have the freedom to deny this reality<em>.</em> Ensnared by our small self, we fail to recognise the greater Self to which we all belong. Overwhelmed or oblivious to our interdependence, we struggle to act in alignment with it. We need help to make that choice, to see beyond ourselves to the other, to what lies between us. We need simple tools that sharpen our awareness and expand our sphere of concern. This is the purpose of the Relational Imperative.</p><p>When one of my kids provokes the other, or when I catch myself doing the same, I remind them (or myself) that they are not only <em>Fred</em>, <em>Lulu</em>, or <em>Amie</em>, but also a <em>Gill</em>. And in a family, hurting someone always hurts you too. They might not feel it right away, but they eventually will.</p><p>Moments like these don’t just arise. They’re shaped by what’s already stirring within us. The quiet tug of frustration, the pull of pride, the need to be right or seen, these often surface before a word is even spoken. There’s a widely shared story, often attributed to Cherokee tradition, that speaks to this inner dynamic.</p><p>One evening, an elder tells his grandson about a battle that takes place inside every person. “My son,” he says, “the battle is between two wolves. One is evil — it is anger, envy, jealousy, sorrow, regret, greed, arrogance, self-pity, guilt, resentment, inferiority, lies, false pride, superiority, and ego. The other is good — it is joy, peace, love, hope, serenity, humility, kindness, compassion, empathy, generosity, truth, and faith.” The grandson thinks for a moment, then asks, “Which wolf wins?” The elder replies, “The one you feed.”</p><p>Yet it is not only your own wolf you feed. Every choice you make, every word you speak, every small act of kindness or cruelty also feeds the wolves that roam in the hearts of those around you, whether you mean to or not.</p><p>Each choice made by one member of our family shapes the others as well. It’s a ripple sent out, an upset sibling or parent carrying the storm to another corner of the house. We are a ‘relationally bound unit’, a tapestry of lives woven inseparably together. To disregard one another is to fray the threads that hold us fast, a fate none of us wishes for. And so, we remain bound, constantly shaping each other in ways both seen and unseen.</p><p>The same truth holds across every sphere of our lives: the family we care for, the workplace we serve, the nation we call home, the wider world, and the environment that sustains us. We shape it, it shapes us, and it shapes others. This relational dynamic is foundational, inescapable. If there is one truth that underpins the universe, for me, it is this.</p><p><strong>The form of the Relational Imperative</strong></p><p>The Relational Imperative gives shape to this foundational dynamic through a simple x–y graph. Though the graph may appear straightforward at first glance, it carries the same depth and complexity as Carson’s reminder that “nothing exists alone.” At its core, the graph captures the state of a relationship at a given moment. For example, when I apply the Relational Imperative to reflect on my relationship with my wife, I don’t place myself on one axis and her on the other. Instead, the Relational Imperative positions me (or her, depending on the focus of our dialogue) on the y-axis, and our marriage itself on the x-axis.</p><p>Our marriage is placed on the x-axis of the Relational Imperative because it serves as our <em>relationally bounded unit, </em>the shared space of our collective becoming. It is the context, the container, the ground of our relationship. In a real and tangible way, our marriage takes on a life of its own. We tell stories about it, make choices in light of it, and carry it with us in memory and intention. It has been woven together through countless small interactions and decisions. We cannot simply disregard each other without risking the very life we’ve built, a life neither of us wishes to lose. And so, once again, we find ourselves bound, shaping and being shaped by each other in ways both seen and unseen.</p><p>The first thing to notice about the Relational Imperative is how it places me on both axes. I appear on the y-axis as an individual, and on the x-axis, through my marriage, as part of a collective. This dual placement reflects our inherent interdependence, capturing the idea that “nothing exists alone.”</p><p>Secondly, it’s important to recognise that the Relational Imperative is not just a simple 2x2 matrix. Instead, it’s a graph with directional axes that symbolise growth. In our example, this reflects both my personal growth as an individual and the growth of our marriage. But growth toward what, exactly? This is perhaps the most challenging aspect of the Relational Imperative. Something that must be discovered and defined both individually and together.</p><p>Let’s consider individual development. Numerous influential thinkers, from Erikson to Piaget to Jung, have deepened our understanding of this area. I’m especially drawn to Jung’s concept of individuation; the ongoing integration of all aspects of the self, both conscious and unconscious. However, our understanding of individual development isn’t limited to science. Across traditions, religions have long offered frameworks for inner growth; from the Buddhist path toward enlightenment to the Christian journey of Theosis, each pointing toward a deeper union of self and spirit.</p><p>When I think about growth, I think about moving towards greater peace and wholeness. To me, this is where true freedom lies. Not just as a feeling, but as a way of being. To make sense of this, I find it helpful to frame things in ontological terms. Ontology, simply put, is the branch of philosophy concerned with the nature of being. Viewed this way, the axis represents the “power to be.” As I traverse this axis, my power of being increases or decreases. We’ll leave the deeper ontological exploration for another time, but one insight is worth carrying forward: as something is realised, as it matures and grows, it also gains in power. Not the power to dominate, but the power to be itself, fully, freely, and faithfully.</p><p>One of the most important things you can do for yourself is to hold a clear picture of what growth looks like in your own life. Too many of us lack clarity about who we are or who we hope to become. Sometimes we cling to an identity that no longer fits, or perhaps never truly did. The truth is, if you don’t choose for yourself, you leave space for others, whether individuals or the broader culture, to choose it for you.</p><p>While we get to choose what growth looks like in our own lives, we don’t, and shouldn’t, make those decisions alone when it comes to our collective realisations. Returning to our example, I don’t get to choose for my marriage. That is a decision my wife and I make together. Something we learn about and discover along the way, as we do life together.</p><p><strong>The Core Assumption of the Relational Imperative</strong></p><p>With this understanding of the two axes, that they represent growth, and that I exist on both, we arrive at what I believe may be the most important implication of the Relational Imperative: that my realisation is intimately bound to our realisation. It sounds simple, even obvious, but living as if it were true is something else entirely.</p><p>Of all my personal flaws, the belief I’ve worked hardest to unlearn is the idea that my realisation is something I can achieve on my own. I’ve wrestled with this for decades, and I still have a long way to go. Whatever progress I’ve made has not come from within me alone, but from the conversations I’ve had with a community I trust to speak honestly into my life. They help me see myself more clearly, challenge me, support me, and remind me to give myself a break now and then. I’m deeply grateful to have them in my life.</p><p><strong>The Relational Imperative as a heuristic</strong></p><p>This, then, is the purpose of the Relational Imperative: it offers a simple heuristic for examining the shape of our relationships through the lens that nothing exists alone. It helps us recognise not only that we need each other, but that we become who we are <em>through</em> each other.</p><p>The Relational Imperative can be visualised as a graph (see image) that captures how this core belief is expressed at any given moment. In doing so, it reveals four basic relational states, each of which can vary in intensity.</p><ul><li>I + We are realised</li><li>I am realised at the expense of Us</li><li>We are realised at the expense of I</li><li>Neither I nor We are realised</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hiFqKBrjrGZh0l8AhFTlSQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>The Relational Imperative in Practice.</strong></p><p>I use the Relational Imperative most directly in my role as a people manager. The process begins with a staff member identifying two or three key relationships that most shape their experience within the company. From there, we map the current state of each relationship from both perspectives. When exploring their relationship with the company, we place the individual on the y-axis and the company on the x-axis. As part of the initial conversation, we discuss what realisation looks like, for both the individual and the organisation, framed by professional development and existing organisational goals. Each of us then places a point on the Relational Imperative to reflect our sense of how fully both the individual and the collective are being realised. More often than not, our points are close, but not quite the same.</p><p>The goal of the exercise isn’t to convince one another whose assessment is more accurate, but to spark meaningful dialogue about what is actually happening in the relationship. Sometimes the conversation is brief; other times, it calls for a deeper dive into one of the axes to clarify what ‘realisation’ means for each party.</p><p>The ultimate aim of these conversations is always to explore how we might move both points higher towards the top-right quadrant of the graph, where both the individual and the company are safe and growing. We call this shared goal <em>right-relationship</em>.</p><p>We also use the Relational Imperative as a lens to critically examine interactions and experiences within the workplace. Take, for example, a range of workplace moments that might fall into each quadrant of the graph, with each reflecting a distinct state of relationship:</p><ul><li><strong>Bottom-right quadrant </strong>(the collective is realised at the expense of the individual): Workplace demands are so high that they begin to erode an employee’s personal or family life, leaving them overextended and unseen.</li><li><strong>Top-left quadrant </strong>(the individual is realised at the expense of the collective): An employee uses their position to dominate discussions or silence others, prioritising personal expression at the cost of team cohesion.</li><li><strong>Top-right quadrant (</strong>where both the individual and the collective are realised): An individual creates a collaborative space where ideas are shared, contributions are acknowledged, and both personal growth and team success are nurtured.</li><li><strong>Bottom-left quadrant </strong>(neither the individual nor the collective is realised): Misalignment on values, unclear expectations, or persistent communication breakdowns leave both the individual and the organisation underperforming.</li></ul><p>And because relationships are never fixed, always in motion, always becoming, every word, gesture, or silence is an opportunity to exercise the power of the ‘I’ or the collective ‘We’ to realise, empower, disempower, or overpower. Over time, these small choices accumulate, shaping not only our individual experiences but the broader relational culture in which we live and work.</p><p>This is why the top-right quadrant, what we call <em>right-relationship, </em>matters so much. It reflects a deliberate commitment to valuing both the individual and the collective. It speaks directly to the kind of culture we aim to build within the organisation: one that not only respects its people and performance but understands that the two are inseparable. Cultivating right-relationship isn’t just a cultural aspiration; it is a strategic priority that strengthens engagement and drives meaningful performance.</p><p><strong>Not all relationships are created equal</strong></p><p>One of the strengths of the Relational Imperative is that it can be used to explore the relationship between two people just as readily as the dynamic between a person and their team, organisation, or even the state. While a single graph is not designed to capture the full complexity of a relationship, it offers a meaningful snapshot of how one person or group perceives the current balance, or imbalance, within it. And because it applies across relational scales, a series of these snapshots can begin to reveal the deeper patterns that shape how we relate, both up close and across the broader structures we are part of.</p><p>Yet even across these varied scales, not all relationships carry equal weight. Some exert more influence on our lives than others, shaped by the strength, depth, or context of the bond. These may include the emotional connection with a loved one, the shared commitment of a team, the legal relationship with the state, or the social license that allows a company to operate within a community. Some ties live close to the heart; others remain at arm’s length.</p><p>Still, whether intimate or distant, certain relationships stand out for their impact. This reflects the 80/20 principle, first observed by economist Vilfredo Pareto, which suggests that in many contexts, a small number of causes produce most of the effects. In relational terms, a handful of connections often shape the majority of our joy, emotional energy, growth, and stress. These relationships carry disproportionate weight and deserve our fullest attention, not just because they profoundly shape us, but because we inevitably shape them as well. They call for care and intention, precisely because our stories are inseparably woven together.</p><p><strong>The Unseen Weight of Relationship</strong></p><p>Beyond the core relationships that most influence our lives, the 80/20 principle also reminds us of the long tail of everyday choices and interactions that may seem small on their own, yet when repeated across populations, have a profound impact. Think of the emissions from a single car ride, the energy behind each flick of a light switch, or the hidden cost of fast fashion. These acts may feel distant or insignificant, but together, they quietly reshape the climate and ecosystems we all depend on.</p><p>Leonard E. Read’s classic essay <em>I, Pencil</em> offers a vivid illustration. He describes the extraordinary number of skills, professions, and processes required to make something as simple as a pencil. From the lumberjack felling cedar trees, to the miner extracting graphite, to the chemist mixing lacquer, each person brings a specialised craft. No one person knows how to make a pencil on their own; it emerges through a vast web of cooperation, coordination, and trust.</p><p>Read’s point is that the market enables this intricate collaboration not through central control, but through decentralised effort. Yet here’s what we often overlook: while the value of the pencil is immediately clear, we rarely consider what we lose in that decentralisation. Beyond the thirty cents we pay, something else quietly slips away: our proximity to the relationships behind it. The pencil in my hand feels distant because we do not walk in the forest where the cedar was felled, nor do we share a meal with the miner who brought the graphite to light.</p><p>These relationships are real but remote, leaving us with a pressing question: who carries the weight of responsibility for them? How do we account for the unseen, the far-off, the lives and ecosystems touched by even the smallest actions we take and the everyday objects we hold? Where does our responsibility begin, and where does it end? These are questions for another time. For now, it is enough to say that the Relational Imperative turns our attention outward, reminding us that we are connected, and that these ties are not abstract, but made of families, communities, forests, and rivers.</p><p>I’ll end with this thought. If the crisis of our time rests on two conflicting truths, first, a forgetting that nothing exists alone, and second, a rising global hyper-connectivity that overwhelms the social and environmental layers that once held us, then perhaps what we need is a counterbalance: a hyper-awareness of our interdependence. The Relational Imperative invites us into this awareness, to see differently, to act with greater care, and to value right-relationship for all, not just a few. It may not offer easy answers, but it might help us find our way forward. One thing is certain: we will need every tool at our disposal, from the simple and practical to the sacred and sublime.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0169fcdc19fd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Lies Between Us]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@spdgill/what-lies-between-us-my-journey-in-pursuit-of-a-good-society-4655fd2f85be?source=rss-e2b3961518e1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4655fd2f85be</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[systems-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-economy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stuart Gill]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Apr 2022 02:34:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-07-24T08:15:04.121Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>What Lies Between Us: My Journey in Pursuit of a “Good Society”</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5iO_9wuqSY17iVKXPOG_cA.png" /></figure><p><em>My struggle with early parenthood led me on a journey that redefined my understanding of a good society, from the family unit on up to our economy, political system and beyond.</em></p><p><strong>By Stuart Gill</strong></p><p>Despite an unprecedented number of people experiencing unprecedented prosperity, many of us still struggle with the pressures of modern life, which often manifest in malaise, mental illness or deep existential dread. So, what are we doing wrong? Well, lots of things, obviously. But what would need to change to start getting things right? What would need to be put in place for society to move from its current state of dysfunction to one of health? What conditions actually give rise to a good society?</p><p>Years before a personal crisis shed light on answers to these questions, I thought I had them figured out. While researching and teaching astrophysics at Columbia University, I had the opportunity to engage with academics across disciplines, which solidified my understanding of the established definition of a “good” society: one that strives to strike the right balance between the market and the state — the pillars of Western societies — thereby equipping individuals with the freedoms and protections to pursue happiness.</p><p>I initially agreed with the broadest strokes of this established view: Over the last 400 years, the market has proven itself an unrivalled engine of production, lifting hundreds of millions of people out of poverty and providing a quality of life early kings and queens would have envied. This enormous redistribution of wealth resulted in a redistribution of political power, shifting the centre of sovereignty from monarchs and emperors to the people through the birth of the modern republics. But, despite all this apparent good at scale, the flaws of the Western system are clear. In our market-based society, wealth production is heavily biased towards the wealthy, creating an imbalance in power that ties our politics, media and futures to the will of the wealthiest 1%. Meanwhile, the modern democratic state, driven by electoral cycles and the contest for public opinion, focuses on too few issues that often become polarising and thus work to divide us.</p><p>With all these costs and benefits in mind, I subscribed to the belief, common within many institutions seeking to address societal challenges, that in an open society, any problems with the market or state could simply be innovated away. When I joined the World Bank in 2009, designing solutions to reduce climate and disaster risk, you could say that I joined the establishment. Yet, as I flew around the world as an optimistic ambassador of this worldview and beneficiary of this system, my mental health and personal life began to crumble.</p><blockquote>During my “dark night”, I discovered I no longer believed that society will solve the challenges we face by simply innovating them away.</blockquote><p>I didn’t know it at the time but I had entered a period the renowned psychiatrist and spiritual writer Gerald May described as a “dark night of the soul”, a process of loss, doubt and discovery that in the end leads to liberation and transformation. During my “dark night”, I discovered I no longer believed that society will solve the challenges we face by simply innovating them away. The realness of life forced me to interrogate the base assumption I held about market and state that underpinned my life and our society. This ultimately led to a simple shift in thinking that has fundamentally shaped me and my family, and helped me see a future where we could move toward embodying the good society we so long for.</p><p><strong>A Personal Crisis Awakens Me to Society’s Brokenness</strong></p><p>My dark night of the soul was largely a result of my “success”, as defined by Western society. I had earned multiple degrees and landed a job at a respected, mission-driven institution that paid well and offered me the comforts of modern life. The price I paid for these trappings included long hours, high stress and continuous travel. In one year alone, I travelled twice to every continent except Antarctica. I became disconnected from my wife, family and friends, battled infertility and illness, and ultimately found myself withdrawing from everything other than the demands of the job.</p><p>When my wife finally became pregnant through in vitro fertilisation, I quit the World Bank, fearful of becoming the kind of dad I did not want for my kid. Unsurprisingly, leaving my job did not magically restore balance to my life, and my wife and I were seriously challenged by the demands of early parenthood. Our daughter, born prematurely at 33 weeks, spent the first weeks of her life in the hospital. She developed colic soon after coming home, screaming for hours on end, and slept extremely poorly into her third year of life. There were nights I felt like my arms were falling off as I tried to pat her to sleep. I had to ask myself, if billions of people had done this before, how could it be so hard? In her infinite wisdom, my wife pointed out that we were trying to do something alone that was never meant to be done that way.</p><p>As an introvert, I had never seen being alone as a problem, until suddenly it was, which prompted me to look inward and consider what role I had played in our isolation. Why had I chosen to live abroad for years, away from my family? Why didn’t my wife and I have strong connections to our neighbours? Why did we lack sufficient emotional support and practical help when we needed it most, despite the proximity of loving family?</p><blockquote>At what point in the human journey did the integral importance of prioritising our relationships with each other shift to the periphery, and why don’t we all see the urgency in restoring its value?</blockquote><p>Over those long nights and bleary-eyed days, I came to believe that our lack of practical and emotional support was not so much the consequence of a personal flaw as a flaw in the very society in which we exist. Why don’t we grow up striving for healthy community, like we learn to strive for high grades, good jobs and other markers of personal “excellence”? At what point in the human journey did the integral importance of prioritising our relationships with each other shift to the periphery, and why don’t we all see the urgency in restoring its value? I began to notice similar forms of lonely struggle all around me, manifesting in the anxiety, depression and general melancholy that has become something of a backdrop to Western society. My personal problem, I realised, was rooted in something much more foundational: I began to see that our society is starving for community. And that all of us who struggle with isolation and its consequences have simply arrived in our dark places by absorbing and adhering to the rules of our broken society.</p><p><strong>Uncovering the Roots of the Problem: How Did Relationship Lose Its Value?</strong></p><p>How did our Western society come to value community so little, I wondered? I turned to psychology, political economy, social science research and long conversations with friends and colleagues for answers. What I found reorientated my understanding of what makes a good society and how we got to where we are now. Not to oversimplify, a complex story, but in short, we can trace it back to the ancient Greeks and their fierce commitment to logic in pursuit of objective truth. They believed the world could be categorised (“objectified”) and broken down into independent parts governed by rules. According to this way of thinking, an individual could obtain a predictable outcome by adhering to the system’s rules. In other words, to the ancient Greeks, the world was deterministic and, thus, by extension, individuals had the power to shape the course of their own lives.</p><p>While this way of thinking is common today, it was profoundly different for its time, which tended toward more circular ways of thinking shaped by the seasons or belief that the world was too complex to determine. The Greeks’ deterministic worldview birthed the sciences, my foundational area of study. It also birthed the idea of the individual, imbued with rights, freedoms and agency to exert control over their own destiny, and it elevated logic as a superior form of reason.</p><p>The Enlightenment resurrected, refined and disseminated the Greeks’ way of thinking across Europe, in reaction to a world in which the Catholic Church and landowning minorities wielded absolute power, suppressing individual freedoms. This intellectual movement, centred on the rights and needs of the individual, gave rise to the market and state systems we know today, with all their benefits and flaws.</p><p>Over time — for better and for worse — responsibilities and power shifted away from the community. Safety, justice, education, health care and just about everything else were no longer the sole responsibilities of families and interdependent neighbours. The state and market began to fulfil these needs, and as these twin pillars of society grew more powerful, communities weakened and became less relevant. Through colonisation, this pattern replicated itself across much of the world, cumulating to a crippling overreaction.</p><p>Individuals, once valued for their contributions to their communities, became valued primarily for their contributions to the market and the state. And today, as the state increasingly concedes to the primacy of the market, we find the “good” in society is now measured by what the market values. From the market, we expect qualities such as efficiency, full employment and profit. Profit got us hooked on debt, and debt demands growth, leading to an obsession with growth — rising GDP and personal income — at the expense of everything else. This effect cannot be overstated: it has transformed our economy, our values even, most importantly, our way of thinking.</p><p><strong>Why We Cannot Simply Innovate Our Way Back to Community</strong></p><p>In his book <em>The Geography of Thought: How Asians and Westerners Think Differently…and Why</em>, social psychologist Richard Nisbett highlights the striking cognitive differences between people in East Asian and Western societies. His research has found that East Asians tend to think more holistically, accept contradictions and focus on harmony, while Westerners tend to be more analytical, prioritising logic and focusing on objective truth.</p><p>He concluded that the relationships between people and their distinct environments lead to unique economic structures that influence social practices, which in turn influence how our brains process information. This leads to distinct attitudes, values and behaviours that loop back and reinforce a society’s culture and economy. Nisbett writes, “The social practices promote the worldviews; the worldviews dictate the appropriate thought processes; and the thought processes both justify the worldviews and support the social practices.”</p><p>Following Nisbett’s reasoning, why wouldn’t Westerners, including myself, see community as an afterthought, oblivious to the harm done by its absence, like the proverbial frog being slowly boiled alive? While we and our leaders pay lip service to the notion of community, we are primed from birth with independence cues. The market incents us to spend our lives focused primarily on ourselves — our studies, our career and our ideas — rather than our communities and relationships. Even creating a family is often approached as another collection of assets — house, caravans, extracurricular activities for and accomplishments by children — with less focus on family relationships and little unstructured time left for family cohesion and just being together. While we may not be explicitly told that capital is more valuable than labour, ideas more valuable than feelings and individuals more valuable than communities, we learn these lessons by simply existing in the world and noticing which attributes tend to be recognised and rewarded.</p><p>If Nisbett is correct, just “innovating away” the flaws at the level of the market and the state is impossible. While my dark night of the soul had convinced me that community needs to play a larger role in our market-state system, I hadn’t considered the futility of any reform failing to address the very way we <em>think</em> — the filter through which we interpret the world and give it our attention.</p><blockquote>What we truly need, I now believe, is to shift the locus of our moral universe and reorient ourselves from the individual to “what lies between us” — that is, relationship.</blockquote><p>What we truly need, I now believe, is to shift the locus of our moral universe and reorient ourselves from the individual to “what lies between us” — that is, relationship.<em> </em>I am convinced that such a shift in perspective could transform our attitudes, values and behaviours and equally transform how we structure our society, economy and relationship with the planet. Why do I believe this so strongly?</p><p>May called the “dark night of the soul” dark, not because it is harrowing (though it often is) but because “liberation takes place in hidden ways, beneath our knowledge and understanding.” It was by withdrawing from relationship that I entered my dark night. Equally, by embracing relationship, I found my way out.</p><p>While this shift in perspective has personally wrought profoundly positive effects on my life and family, I would argue that we are benefitting from a legacy that can be traced all the way back to the origin of our species (in fact, the origin of all species), where our key evolutionary advantage was our ability to collaborate, to be in relationship, which our large brains evolved in service to. Not “I think, therefore, I am”. Rather, “We think, therefore we are”.</p><p><a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7777651/">R. Baumeister and M. Leary’s 1995 review of the scientific literature</a> establishes the need to belong as a fundamental human motivation, similar to other basic motivations like food and sex. In other words, relationship is not merely a means to an end; it is an end in itself, imperative to our health and survival. Surely, if our relational capacity is at the very core of who we are, it is reasonable to suggest it should be the paradigm we organise around.</p><p><strong>A New Framework to Help Reorganise Society Around Relationships</strong></p><p>If we accept the basic premise that relationships belong at the centre of our moral universe, we must carefully consider what form of relationship is worthy of organising ourselves around, and whether it will scale from, say, your relationship with your partner to your relationship with the state?</p><p>I began exploring answers to these questions in early 2019, when, after a 14-year battle with cancer, my father died. The pain of his passing and personal challenges at the time led to confusion about our relationship. I began to question whether my father had loved me. As I tried to write his eulogy, I was painfully stuck on this question.</p><p>At the same time, I had just finished reading the book <em>Love, Power, and Justice</em> by Christian existentialist philosopher Paul Tillich. Tillich defines love as “the drive towards the unity of the separated.” In my pain, as I sat with his understanding, I came to see that love is not equivalent to affection; it is rather a commitment to being in a relationship. While it is true that not all my encounters with my father were affectionate — he was a man of his time — I had always felt his commitment to our relationship.</p><p>In Tillich, I found answers to my personal questions — and even more. His analysis of love, power and justice enabled me to consider these ideas in relation to each other, which helped me articulate the type of relationship worthy of commitment.</p><p>Over the next few months, I adapted Tillich’s analysis into a graph (see below) that maps the power dynamics between an individual and the collective (for example, a marriage, family, business, government, etc.) at a given point in time. The Relational Imperative, or Love Framework, as my colleagues have come to call it, became the tool I used to assess the health of every relationship in my life. The concepts that underlie it, I believe, are the key to understanding breakdowns in relationships and society and, crucially, how to repair those fissures.</p><p>Central to the framework below is its acknowledgement that power is active in every encounter a person has with another person or collective. That power can empower and realise; it can also disempower or even overpower.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bunxI7G1JP9UH93S-xV6pA.png" /></figure><p><em>The Y-axis represents the realisation of the self, and the X-axis is the realisation of the collective, revealing four basic categories.</em></p><p><em>In the top-right quadrant, both I and We are realised.</em></p><p><em>Each person can read the Y-axis for themselves or an individuated organisation.</em></p><p><em>The X-axis always relates to a collective realisation (not another individual’s realisation). For example, the X-axis could represent your marriage as a collective of both partners (but not your partner as an individual, as you are on both axis), your workplace, your country, or the local ecosystem where you live (so it’s not limited to any one scale).</em></p><p>Let’s imagine a range of workplace scenarios that map to each quadrant in the graph.</p><ul><li><strong>In the bottom-right quadrant, in which the collective is realised at the expense of the individual,</strong> unrealistic workplace demands may be so high that they adversely impact an employee’s relationship with their family.</li><li><strong>In the top-left quadrant, in which the individual is realised at the expense of the collective, </strong>an employee may use their privilege to always be the first to speak or silence others in the group.</li><li><strong>In the top-right “I + We” quadrant, an individual may use their power to create a safe space to build on the team’s ideas creatively, </strong>and in supporting others also share the benefits of their ideas. Top-right-quadrant relationships are a decision to value the individual and the collective. In fact, they fundamentally recognise that individual realisation is interdependent with the realisation of the collective.</li><li><strong>In the bottom-left quadrant, neither I nor We is realised.</strong></li></ul><p>While this explanation just scratches the surface (a more in-depth exploration of this is coming soon) the Relational Imperative laid bare that <em>just </em>relationships exist in the top-right I + We quadrant, where each party benefits, grows and thrives from the relationship with the other.</p><p>Though, life being life, we don’t always manage this successfully, the <em>commitment </em>to doing so creates the space for hope to restore relationships when we inevitably find ourselves living outside this quadrant. When such a rupture happens, retributive or distributive justice may succeed in building that pathway back to relationship. But when retributive and distributive justice are insufficient, we then need a restorative justice that values relationship above all else. The commitment to live in the “I + We” quadrant then requires an undeserved gift of grace to heal the rupture and restore relationship. We are not saying commit to an abusive relationship (in which there is no commitment to the I + We, as it takes at least two) because in a loving relationship all parties commit to living in the graph’s top-right quadrant. Hence the name!</p><blockquote>Our current system, of course, doesn’t recognise relational wealth; it treats the bonds between us as personal endeavours, not fundamental needs.</blockquote><p>Commitment to this type of relationship — between spouses, employer and employee, government and citizen, corporation and clients, people and the land — for me is the foundation of a “good society”. For me, this means reorientating our moral universe around “what lies between us”. This balance does not place the individual before the collective nor does it place the collective before the individual. This view places ideas in service to relationship, not above it. It does not value harmony for its own sake but values a commitment to dialogue and hard conversations. These collections of I+We–quadrant relationships are what my colleagues and I have started calling “relational wealth”. We have come to view relational wealth as the building blocks of healthy relationships, which are the building blocks of a healthier society and an economy that works for all.</p><p>Our current system, of course, doesn’t recognise relational wealth; it treats the bonds between us as personal endeavours, not fundamental needs. It does not incent or empower citizens to exist in that I + We quadrant where justice thrives and the economy empowers its people. Instead, it recasts citizens as individual consumers whose purpose is to serve the economy, resulting in everything from poverty and inequality to climate change and the decimation of the world’s resources — and even the lonely struggle of isolated new parents lacking loving community because every invisible power in their lives had attuned them to prioritise the individual over “what lies between us”.</p><p><strong>How to</strong> <strong>Build Relational Wealth for a Better Society</strong></p><p>But what does it take to live relationally? What actually needs to happen in order to reorient our individual and collective lives around I+We–quadrant relationships, with the aim of nurturing a good society?</p><p>Over time, and with the arrival of two more children, my wife and I slowly learned to live a more relational life. This took identifying and shifting some shared narratives and behaviours. It also meant working on ourselves. For me, it was understanding how my childhood had shaped the way I relate to others and healing old wounds. Our guiding question as a couple became, “‘Will this action draw us closer in relationship or not?” This transformed arguments that were once about persuading or winning into a richer dialogue where we could talk about the hard stuff. We came to regard healthy relationship as the foundation for our happiness, not a by-product, and likewise to believe that the purpose of seeking justice was to restore loving (that is I + We) relationship.</p><blockquote>The purpose of justice is to restore right relationship.</blockquote><p>Beyond the family unit, we sought out a community of people who listened to our struggles, saw our blind spots, offered wisdom and helped practically with life’s challenges, be it a meal, moving a couch or a ride home from the hospital. And we committed ourselves to providing similar support to others. We took steps to cultivate the oft-mentioned “village” so needed to raise our children and found others likewise hungry for the same kind of mutual support. Eventually, we found we weren’t alone anymore. While the relief was enormous, it’s worth mentioning this shift wasn’t (and still isn’t) always easy. I’m still learning to ask for help, and also learning that receiving support is not just about me but is a shared experience that likewise permits others to ask for support.</p><p>As I look back over my life, this way of living was not wholly absent. For example, growing up, I had been taught that being gay was a sin. When one of my closest friends came out when we were in our teens, I faced internal dissonance between my belief and my relationship. To build relational wealth, requires we value the relationship first. This “relational ethic” requires us first to meet the person and then explore ideas. Where there is dissonance between a belief and the experience of a relationship, a change of belief may follow, or at least a valuing of difference. In my case, the friendship led me to grapple with and ultimately abandon my pre-held idea. In view of our friendship, my beliefs changed.</p><p>Like my old belief that being gay was sinful, many of our beliefs are inherited from the culture we live in, including family and broader society, and they play a powerful force in our lives and drive much of our behaviour. While some are innocuous, like believing that one style of jeans is preferable to another, toxic beliefs that prioritise the value of one group over another can cause untold hardship at a personal and societal level. This is living in the top left “I am realised at the expense of Us” quadrant of the Relational Imperative.</p><p>These beliefs, propagated and maintained by our relationships, can likewise be changed by our relationships, as happened for me. At the individual level, this change often requires a commitment to dialogue. In other words, it requires conversations grounded in the I + We quadrant, that respect the dignity of both parties and of the relationship, reflecting a critical relational capacity between individuals. A good society, however, requires this relational capacity at scale, and I have to believe these capacities are scalable across every level of society.</p><p>Critical relational capacities (some of which my colleagues and I have identified and will be exploring in another work) are prerequisites for just relationships. Without self-knowledge or the ability to change one’s mind (examples of individual relational capacities) a person will not have the capacity needed to engage in those just and healthy relationships that sit in the I + We quadrant of the Relational Imperative. Similarly, an organisation, institution or group that lacks the collective relational capacity to engage in dialogue or create unifying social narratives cannot be expected to engage in just relationships either. Like a muscle, these capacities can be developed over time to become strong but they require consistent attention to maintain that strength. Also like a muscle, they can be injured, sometimes severely, requiring healing, treatment and time for recovery.</p><p>Currently, I don’t think it is a stretch to suggest our relational capacities within society require therapy. We need only look at the advent of social media with its anonymity leading to objectification and its echo chambers confirming our in-group biases. At the same time, there is little relational capacity to have a collective dialogue at scale to make sense of our world together. While collective dialogue would not demand everyone participate in the same conversation, nor would it be the stratified screaming matches that play out on social media, feeding tribal bigotries. It would rather require a critical mass of people intentionally connected in relationships that transcend economic, ethnic, gender and other bounds.</p><blockquote>It is not the sort of wealth that can be spent by any one individual but is rather a “commonwealth” that benefits us all.</blockquote><p>The relational wealth required for a good society is built upon such capacities. It is not the sort of wealth that can be spent by any one individual but is rather a “commonwealth” that benefits us all. The great poet Rumi wrote, “Out beyond ideas of wrongdoing and rightdoing, there is a field. I’ll meet you there.” From this foundational place, that relational wealth, that ”what lies between us,” may be present between individuals, within families, firms — even economic sectors, or our oceans. It may be present wherever relationship exists. And that is everywhere.</p><p>While “relationship” may sound soft and difficult to quantify, the science of human “relationship” is a rich and active research field across disciplines and these relational capacities can be measured. For example, Harvard University’s long-running <a href="https://www.adultdevelopmentstudy.org/grantandglueckstudy">Grant and Glueck</a> studies have been tracking the physical and emotional well-being of two different groups of men since the 1940s. According to Robert Waldinger, director of the Harvard Study of Adult Development, “The clearest message that we get from this 75-year study is this: Good relationships keep us happier and healthier. Period.” Furthermore, “It’s not just the number of friends you have,” says Waldinger, it’s the quality of your close relationships that matters.”</p><p><strong>Envisioning a More Loving, Just and Healthy World with Relationships at the Centre</strong></p><p>We have always been given political choices that embrace systems focused on either the individual or on the collective. Capitalist or communist economy? Democracy or socialism? Those questions force us to make extreme choices. As we choose, we certainly don’t want to overcorrect in the opposite direction and wind up, once again, in a world where individuals have no power or personal freedom. Nor do we want to abandon all the good that markets and modern states have brought to the world. Instead, we should aspire to a relational system that respects the benefits of our current system but corrects its systemic flaws by prioritising relationships.</p><p>So, what does a market-state system look like in a world where we are actively building relational wealth?</p><p>First, consider the market as it exists today. Economists call the indirect (social and/or environmental) cost to other parties resulting from an economic transaction a “negative externality”, and it is widely accepted as a cost of doing business. However, seen through the relational wealth lens, a negative externality is really a relationship that has not been respected in the design of a product or service. When externalities are not costed into the price of a product, the price is ultimately paid by someone else — think pollution from a mine or the human costs of cheap sweatshop labour.</p><p>Directing capital towards companies that best capture — or avoid — their negative externalities promotes a relationally focused market. It also provides a purpose for the financial industry from one just fixated on propagating itself through endless growth and extraction to one that builds relational wealth through thoughtful investment.</p><p>Taking a closer look, as the market has continued its slow march to commodify our world, it has inevitably begun to commodify our relationships. Think Big Tech. The people in your social network are now avenues for corporations to sell stuff, and to capture the “resource” of your attention — which is fundamental to relationship. Our relationships and attention are quite literally the products sold to advertisers. Business models like this cross a line of what is healthy for society; that does not mean we have to turn off these platforms, however, we must rethink the business models that fuel them. Perhaps then they could live up to their hype and build relational wealth rather than erode it.</p><p>At the political level, the legislative floor would no longer resemble a schoolyard playground. It would be a place to struggle with competing needs, to produce legislation that builds relational wealth. For example, policies that deliver services such as retraining, or that provide food or shelter, would not be merely transactional, contributing to further stigmatisation and exclusion that follows from objectification. Rather, they would be required to consider the relational environment shaping those programs, aiming to promote social inclusion and enhance recipients’ dignity.</p><p>Our educational system wouldn’t teach only facts and figures or give students the mistaken impression that things are always right or wrong or ignore the nuance of historic events. Rather than overvaluing classification and logic as ways of knowing, it would develop individual relational capacities within students and collective relational capacities within schools. Education’s primary goal would not be to prepare us for the job market but — while still acknowledging that we need jobs — prepare us to be citizens.</p><p>In homes, the quality of care provided to new parents would be a central measure of a good society, with both parents receiving (and taking) time off to care for their infant. As a community, we would strive to ensure that the next generation is securely attached, with a strong foundation on which to trust others and the world they will grow into and serve.</p><blockquote>Profits and votes would still shape the world but they would be constrained and balanced with an understanding of the foundational importance of relational wealth to the health and well-being of our planet, our communities and ourselves.</blockquote><p>Finally, in this world, the market and state would remain intact but continue evolving to serve humanity. Profits and votes would still shape the world but they would be constrained and balanced with an understanding of the foundational importance of relational wealth to the health and well-being of our planet, our communities and ourselves.</p><p>While on the surface it may seem too difficult to achieve such a fundamental shift in the way we think about and approach the world, history is full of examples of significant, world-changing shifts in thinking that have led to vast improvements. Consider the shift in base assumptions that had to occur to enable women to vote and enjoy more freedom to work outside the home, even after marriage. Consider the shift in base assumptions that was needed to abolish legal slavery.</p><p>We sit at the precipice. How we respond to the unprecedented global threats facing humanity will have existential consequences. “Business as usual” is not going to cut it. Nothing short of a paradigm shift will do. As more people journey through the dark night of the soul and find themselves coming to similar conclusions, I am convinced that fundamentally reorientating the centre of our moral universe from the individual to “what lies between us” will be vital in building the relational wealth required for the good society we long for. Addressing the most pressing social and environmental challenges of our times at their deepest roots is a monumental task. The stakes could not be higher. Nor could the possibility of what we might achieve together.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4655fd2f85be" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>