<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Stethornton on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Stethornton on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@stethornton6?source=rss-1d66cdb4449------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 23:20:41 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@stethornton6/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mechanics Monday II]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stethornton6/mechanics-monday-ii-6604652b566b?source=rss-1d66cdb4449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6604652b566b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[titanfall-2]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-games-industry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-mechanics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stethornton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Mar 2021 21:24:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-01T21:24:21.507Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Celebrating Game Mechanics Big and Small</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d0SGOFgERtFgn7N2Ii60Ag.png" /></figure><p>The first part of this series and a proper introduction can be found <a href="https://medium.com/@stethornton6/mechanics-monday-1769f60ae891">here</a> but in short: every Monday I tweet about a game mechanic I like and remember from games I’ve played over the years. These Medium articles will collect and expand upon those tweets, released every time the <a href="https://twitter.com/i/events/1262428574172229632">original moment</a> reaches a new milestone. Welcome to part II, commemorating <strong>50 </strong>Mechanics Monday’s!</p><h4>Mass Effect — “Biotic Charge”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*bcVGOFrJ-7HZt7MJiZm4MA.gif" /></figure><p>Mass Effect’s high risk/reward Vanguard class is niche, but extremely my jam. The centerpiece is Biotic Charge: firing Shepherd into enemies like a human battering ram. I <strong>love </strong>how the camera lags behind as the trail stretches out… then slams in, bringing the impact with it. A successful Biotic Charge (one that connects with an enemy) refills your shields and has a separate cooldown to the melee powers, giving you a window to destroy all your enemies while they’re still on the backfoot from your explosive entrance. It’s also great for moving around the battlefield: the charge can act as a teleport, using enemies as an anchor to pull you to the higher ground or to skip behind their cover. No doubt this was fully accounted for in the encounter design but it <em>feels </em>like you’re doing something the game (and enemies) didn’t plan for. Finally, it has great synergy with an ally in your party de-buffing your victims before you charge them.</p><p>It’s possible to stack your class build to the point the charge and follow-up powers can be used to exploitatively spam through fights; but there is a point mid-game where my charges were far enough apart to ensure I was gambling on smashing everyone in one burst or being left behind enemy lines with no shields and empty power banks. Exactly the Hail Mary gambit it should be.</p><h4>LEGO Ninjago: Shadow of Ronin — “Spinswitchu”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*Hdt7470dCr3UuZaHRDkQjg.gif" /></figure><p>This entry is unique in that it’s the only Mechanics Monday pick (so far) that’s from a video game I actually worked on — but I’m not a total egomaniac! I don’t take any credit for the “Spinswitchu” mechanic family, it came from the brain of my good friend and TT Games veteran Chris Wyatt. In the world of LEGO Ninjago, the art of Spinjitzu allows the titular Ninjas to “go” and become an elemental tornado. Spinswitchu uses this iconic ability from the IP to power and control various LEGO mechanisms via a spinner platform. Though to the player it appears like one mechanic, behind the scenes there are actually 4 types:</p><h4>Spinswitchu</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*Cdkq3V3plBZidEwY0f3m4g.gif" /></figure><p>The vanilla version controls an object, allowing it to be moved between two states by rotating the spinner platform left or right.</p><h4>Springswitchu</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*_NlwpgbpbxN7YUle5iSQTw.gif" /></figure><p>With this variant, the tornado’s rotation compresses the platform, coiling the spring… and then on release it shoots the player upwards. Sonic the Hedgehog vibes intentional.</p><h4>Screwswitchu</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*7kdqSScVROg0SBeIdXsT7A.gif" /></figure><p>The spinner is attached to the object it controls, allowing the player to ride the object between its two states like an elevator. Again, Sonic vibes welcome! My favorite example is the drill, stylizing the elevator motion as burrowing underground into a cavern.</p><h4>Slotswitchu</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*BTpdVQPnWR9bjfnpgF68sA.gif" /></figure><p>This final type of Spinswitchu was not part of the original spec— it was added later in development when the level designers requested a variant where the controlled object did not have any end states but rather moved in a loop; allowing puzzles where the player had to release the object in the correct location — or “slot”.</p><p>Last factoid! LEGO fans will notice that the Spinswitchu devices themselves are topped with the spinner toys from the LEGO sets. I believe that we successfully used every type of spinner somewhere in the game. Driven by the IP’s most iconic power, high mechanical versatility <em>and </em>full product placement? Big box ticker.</p><h4>Smash Brothers — “Sweet and Sour Spots”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/749/1*V0-LoCw0J0zNFzGCpOo-3A.gif" /></figure><p>Smash Bros has a lot of mechanics it doesn’t teach, but really change your playstyle once you know about them. For example: Sweet &amp; Sour Spots. Some attacks have specific frames or hitboxes that hit stronger or weaker than normal, rewarding strategic timing &amp; positioning. Marth players know his sword hits are stronger at the tip, aka <em>Tippers</em>, so they dance to put enemies at the edge of their swords reach — whereas Roy’s sword is stronger at the hilt, rewarding striking enemies deeper within the attacks swing. Successful spot-hits often come with extra juicy feedback like frame stops (and lightning, if you’re Captain Falcon) to let you know you landed them.</p><h4>Smash Brothers — “Stale Move Negation”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/350/1*9sYKTtmGkGZTeneFf03AEg.gif" /></figure><p>Another subtle Smash mechanic I always keep in mind when playing is “Stale Move Negation”; essentially using a move repeatedly will weaken it. This leads players to keep some attacks “fresh” until later in the fight. Having a fresh attack in the bank feels great: a plan in your pocket.</p><h4>Thief — “Intel Maps”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/788/0*ABeb5nRP2sS74SJ4" /></figure><p>Thief’s paper maps are a polarizing extreme of waypoint-less design, and <em>fascinating </em>as a concept. Like any good thief, Garrett does his research — before every mission he gathers as much information as he can about the place he’s sneaking into, represented as a hand-drawn map annotated with useful details like guard routes and alarms. These aren’t omniscient, fourth wall breaking UI systems, these are in-universe scribbles pulled together from rumors and street whispers. They vary in reliability and don’t mark the players current location within them, requiring that players contrast shapes/names/clues against the level itself in order to identify locations and orientate themselves in the maps context; true navigation gameplay.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/788/0*BYd57NGZxj_ogjaY" /></figure><p>I think it’s really interesting how the detail of the maps can be varied from area to area, providing tips in one place and leaving others to improvisation. Having players identify a rooms nature by the objects in it was also a great way to ingrain connection to the locations, one reason Thief’s levels are so memorable. I do have a general soft spot for “Journal” based puzzle solving like in <em>Uncharted</em>, when it’s used to provide extra context about the nature of puzzles, rather than beat the player over the head with hints or answers. Which is, a super delicate balance.</p><h4>Gears Tactics — “Overwatch”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*fCbgtLRyKz58wg3uiMi9tA.gif" /></figure><p>Overwatch: Bringing real-time reactions into turn-based combat since… 1990 sometime I think?. Predict enemy movements, deny areas, set traps. I know this is a genre staple but <em>Gears Tactics’ </em>grid-less “cover &amp; cone” synergy turns overwatch into it’s own tasty hook by a) triggering shooting on any exposure from cover, even a peek over the top, and b) stacking all remaining action points as extra overwatch shots— without the harsh accuracy penalties the mechanic usually has. Navigating and shutting down enemy overwatch zones while plotting your own coverage turns every battle into a fluid puzzle, while still feeling like a gunfight.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*OKaXD4Q3jncJHVYMvcIKOw.gif" /></figure><h4>Skyrim &amp; Fallout — “Discovering Locations”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*_CU7j6nLecozOQTk" /></figure><p>In Big Bethesda RPG’s unvisited locations can be marked on your world map in several ways. Reading about them in logs and loose books, overhearing NPC’s gossiping in the settlements, sneaking a peek at the maps displays in faction bases, or the classic: being quested to go there for questing purposes. When you’re out in the world the HUD also hints at the locations you haven’t been yet; bobbing their icons on your compass. These unknown locations have faded icons. Once you visit a location for real it is “discovered” — the icon on your map becomes solid, and is unlocked as a fast travel point. It’s so simple maybe you think it’s stupid to celebrate it, but there are few things more admirable in design than elegance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*_QNwWujHpZkIGWuE" /></figure><p>With so many ways to inject new markers to it, players maps are gradually being filled in a way that feels organic and personal, even earned: when locations are discovered via self-motivated exploration and lore diving. The marked but unvisited locations provide a reason to strike out into an unknown area of the map, where inevitably the compass will tempt you towards even more. Every location is worth discovering as it expands your network of fast travel anchors, and using a previously banked location as a starting point reinforces the feeling of setting off into uncharted territory. It’s a self perpetuating incentive and reward scheme. Every location is both a goal <em>and </em>a foothold for later goals. <em>It’s just neat!</em></p><h4>Monkey Island — “Insult Sword Fighting”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kdA-4gVgmoPslJm9" /></figure><p>You need to be very clever when bringing combat and confrontation into comedy/puzzle games, and there are few solutions as ingenious as Monkey Island’s Insult Sword Fighting. A dialogue puzzle themed around the anatomy of a joke, and perfectly piratey. Collecting all the insults and comebacks is admittedly just trial and error, but the process is full of laughs — first perusing all Guybrush’s (wrong) improv responses, and then pairing them up correctly in oral battle. It’s a mix of memory and logic that initially favors repetition, but the culmination is a sword master showdown where memory no longer works and you must correctly pair your existing punchline collection with all new insults. All the previous fights serve as set up for a real battle of wits, that actually has players trying to be funny in order to win.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*nBoECLsu-hzcb8Np" /></figure><p>I also LOVED <em>Curse of Monkey Island</em>’s twist, where at sea they have their own rules: all the insults must rhyme, sea shanty style. Refreshes the formula and resets Guybrush’s “expertise” in a very funny way.</p><h4>Red Dead Revolver — “Duel”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*CJC_9rBTHY8uEQFtzif7LA.gif" /></figure><p>I actually loved <em>Red Dead Revolver </em>when it first came out. The wacky western was a central inspiration of my 2nd year GDD project, which directly led to my first industry placement and thus, indirectly to getting my first job — a special place in my heart and gaming memoirs. In particular I really admired the dueling system as both a set-piece and for its kinetic control scheme. You pull the analog stick down to move Red’s hand to his hip and then up, to pull his pistol out of its holster. It was very interesting to me as a “kinetic imitation” of the real action.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*lrx1KTQ2KpAN90Elw8HsXg.gif" /></figure><p>These first two movements (grab/draw) get a boost if you time them to the on-screen animation, but can’t be rushed or they skew the shot. The next two duel phases (lock/fire) are under time pressure, but the crosshairs cycle between weak and strong tempting you to wait that extra second for the better shot. Together, these two halves recreate both the tension and reflex action you want from your very own “High Noon” moment. The later (less wacky) Red Dead’s kept the duel mechanic, but the first <em>Redemption </em>makes the analog stick grab and draw optional while <em>RDR2 </em>removes it completely.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*hFUZzMGkMkMpnn-GBBMddQ.gif" /></figure><p>I wrote a bit in my player/character relationship article <a href="https://medium.com/@stethornton6/i-mario-97f4701f273b">“I, Mario”</a> about the idea of Kinesthetic Projection (borrowed from Extra Credits) and I think this sort of imitative movement is a compelling middle ground between total abstraction and the potential uncanny valley of motion controls. Games are of course full of “kinetic imitations”, like rotating the analog stick to turn valves or activate spin attacks — holding buttons to “grip”, or charge and release energy as special moves— back and forward motions for triggering stabs and thrusts — lighter analog pressure for balancing and sneaking… Its cool to think about!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IT3gyxO8dXNvDh8VmS6NbQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>For the month of October, Mechanics Monday shifted into <strong>Spooky Season </strong>— focusing exclusively on mechanics from games gothic, dark and spooky.</p><h4>The Darkness 2 — “Demon Arms”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*7bRQ_dwuAmCP40MvuSaokA.gif" /></figure><p>Remembering <em>The Darkness 2 </em>and its Demon Arms. They live in the upper screen corners and on the shoulder bumpers, paired nicely with the guns on the triggers. They layer onto the FPS core very naturally, and really make you feel like an unstoppable monster. Left arm is grab/throw; allowing you to weaponize the environment, scoop up enemies or snatch guns from the floor. The right arm is a melee slash that instantly shreds most enemies. Nice kinetic imitation too, you hold the button and slash directionally with the right stick for different results.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*YRDQijSTJ1CQhlxq8ErFEg.gif" /></figure><p><em>The Darkness 2</em> is actually full of cool mechanics; the need to avoid and disable light sources to enable your demon arms — distinctive darkness powers like “gun channeling” and “swarm” — the darkling assistant — the essence incentive on doing executions and eating hearts — plus: I’m always up for some dual wielding.</p><p>I had forgotten until I grabbed the footage for these gifs, but it’s also extremely cool how Jackie’s gun hands are animated during dual wielding — the way he reaches them out when firing and has one in front of the other. Stylin’.</p><h4>Hades — “Nectar” &amp; Sekiro — “Sake”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/444/1*KBOfHGudq9BQCi-txVj9wQ.gif" /></figure><p>I wrote a bunch about <em>Hades </em>and its motivation design <a href="https://medium.com/@stethornton6/the-seven-deadly-feels-of-hades-6381bac61cc0">here</a>, including the Nectar mechanic but in short: it’s a “do a nice thing” button in a game full of likable characters. Deciding who you’ll give it to, feeling excited for their reaction, it feels like gift giving!</p><p>I was reminded on Twitter that <em>Sekiro </em>has an extremely similar mechanic in Sake. While exploring Ashina the Wolf finds only a precious few Sake drams, which he can choose to share with any of his NPC allies. Much like the Nectar of the underworld, and real life booze, the Sake loosens lips and earns some unique dialogue — providing some more insight into the lore and relationship of the characters. In <em>Sekiro </em>especially, those are some otherwise pretty cryptic, stoic lips, and sharing a Sake is a rare moment of levity in an otherwise bleak game world. What a treat.</p><h4>Eternal Darkness — “Low Sanity Effects”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*5safHdn_3vFpOzgYHcVtkA.gif" /></figure><p>Exposure to the mind-melting horrors of <em>Eternal Darkness</em> drains the player character’s sanity. A low sanity bar begins to trigger hallucinations; starting with environmental changes (bleeding walls and such) eventually escalating into fourth wall breaks like simulated technical issues like blue screens, faking TV volume changes, all your save games being deleted… There are dozens of clever tricks in the collection: pretending the controller is disconnected — pretending the game has ended and advertising a sequel — making your whole inventory look empty… a horror game with real world scares, I love the idea. I think any way you can extend emotion beyond the screen and make it resonate with the player human is super interesting. Plus, <a href="https://youtu.be/8aUGmABfeR8?t=28">what a gag</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/705/0*O3RcZyFGqen0LOfI" /></figure><p>I was surprised there aren’t more experiments like this on record (think of how well they’d play in today’s streamer culture!) but after a little research, it turns out Nintendo has held <a href="https://patents.google.com/patent/US6935954B2/en">the patent</a> for this mechanic for over a decade, though it is due to expire towards the end of 2021.</p><p>Despite this, there is a slightly similar concept in <em>Bloodborne </em>called “Insight”; a statistic which — in the lore — represents the gathering of arcane knowledge, that gradually allows the player character to see beyond the veil… bringing the doll to life in the Hunter’s dream, triggering new audio stimulus, expanding enemy move-sets, among other things. In action, it is gradually filled by doing standard progression things like killing enemies and acts mostly as a currency of the bell that summons other players into your game — but the potential is there!</p><h4>Hollow Knight — “Soul Focus”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*5yi9TROXQsthDpc4DR4Q-A.gif" /></figure><p>Soul juice is collected from hitting baddies, a guaranteed byproduct of fighting. Supply is ample, but finding time to convert it into HP mid-battle is (intentionally) tricky. While many games have a healing animation that includes some risk to perform, Soul Focus plants you to the spot and is tuned too long to fit in the usual breakaways we’re accustomed to gulping down flasks and gourds. Common gamer instinct is to heal asap and often, but <em>Hollow Knight </em>demands you wait for your moment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*rkK-AlykccLjcB9z1-Rdsg.gif" /></figure><p><em>Hollow Knight </em>emphasizes patterns, position and timing, requiring you to find the windows for evading, attacking and healing; often requiring a choice between healing and damage-dealing. Focus is actually a “spell” that only casts after enough Soul is spent, so if you get caught by further damage before the spells completion the supply is wasted without awarding any health — further punishing trying to squeeze in a heal at the wrong time. Later bosses seem deliberately tuned to provide less viable healing windows, while later spells can convert Soul into special attacks instead of spending them on healing, further encouraging “no heal” strats.</p><h4>Alan Wake — “Light and Darkness”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*kxwhUMSVXcsSzMQ8vkPAEQ.gif" /></figure><p>To hurt “The Taken” you first have to burn away their darkness, usually with your torch; this creates a fragile power balance with high stakes and tense moments. Your thin beam of power can only hold back one enemy at a time, requiring you to swap and prioritize threats, and even with the torch on them the enemies can push onward, creating a tense race between the burning of their shield and their impending attack. Alan <em>can </em>try a last minute dodge, but they’re tough to time, adding more risk/reward.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*hRpYNY255ZZ-8J80zjLTMQ.gif" /></figure><p>The dark burn mechanic creates an initial phase of vulnerability before you can deal damage, followed by the explosive payoff of burning away those defenses and turning the tables. Exploiting the weaknesses of an other-wise invulnerable foe is always satisfying, and the other light sources and light-emitting tools in the game (like the flare and flash) create more opportunities to turn the tables against impossible odds, creating new safe zones, shields or AOE attacks that hurt them — but not you. Also, I really like the contracting lens flare indicator on the burn, tasty presentation.</p><h4>Titanfall 2 — “Time Machine”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/1*XghjlsqlxKuDRha70eLc7Q.gif" /></figure><p>Generally I try to use Mechanics Monday to highlight less obvious, less appreciated ideas but this is one super obvious, already famous mechanic that I felt needed to be in the list for posterity: <em>Titanfall 2</em>’s “Effect and Cause” Time Machine. The one-shot hook of the best(?) level in a stellar campaign, in short: instantly switch between two versions of the map. The level plays creatively with the potential of this mechanic in both combat and platforming.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/1*fOGTwdxzYrTnd6QVp264gA.gif" /></figure><p>There’s always something so clean and smart about games taking an ability — like swapping between two versions of the map — and brainstorming out the potential interactions &amp; challenges it enables. I personally love when you can see arcade bones under blockbuster presentation.</p><h4>Metal Gear Rising — “Blade Mode”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*7XglCQdEvWz0NgjrnVGgkg.gif" /></figure><p>Slow down time and free-aim precision slashes that actually cut targets into pieces. It’s an inherently empowering, satisfying action and a cool technical feat to boot. *knife commercial voice* <em>Mechs, soldiers, melons: it cuts through anything!</em></p><p>The Zandatsu (cut and take) mechanic adds a strategic reason to slice baddies open, while boss battles find loads of creative ways to play with the mechanic — for example; Mistral’s tentacles, Monsoon’s magnetic body, Sundowner’s shields, or simply slicing through incoming debris anime style.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*d1GAd3nMJFrr30YwOD2IAw.gif" /></figure><p>Blade Mode is also cool because it has a few control systems to choose from. You can manually aim for max precision, pretend the analogue stick is a sword and flick out your cuts, or simply mash vertical/horizontal slash: for when you just NEED to turn your target into mulch.</p><h4>Vanquish — “Boost Slide”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/628/1*ej399ykrWUjhlQcF5Co6xg.gif" /></figure><p>Like many of the best mechanics this move is the glue that connects the other systems together; taking the player in and out of cover, acting as a launch pad into melee and slow-motion: letting them cut safely across big chaotic battlefields in style.</p><p>Special mention to the smoking mechanic where you can light up in cover and flick your cigarette out to distract enemies. I like the small ideas too!</p><h4>Final Fantasy VII — “Materia”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*e6ZHO23wIlX2vYFR" /></figure><p>Every weapon and accessory in the original <em>FFVII </em>comes with a number of sockets where the player can plug in “Materia” — colorful orbs that provide special abilities such as magical spells to whoever has them equipped. The orbs themselves are portable items that can fill any empty socket, meaning that unlike most RPG’s all the powers are totally character agnostic and aside from some subtle weighting in the default statistics and sockets available in their gear, the characters party roles are totally flexible. The burly tank with the Gatling gun arm can be the healer, the airy mage with the flower business can be the range powerhouse.</p><p>The Materia slots provide yet another key consideration when contrasting equipment; instead of weapons competing purely on key stats like damage output, players may consider sacrificing attack power if it makes room for an extra spell. Some slot networks even include linked pairs that allow Materia to boost each other, adding further strategy in how the player arranges and assigns their available skills. After a battle, it’s usually easy to see where the team is lacking support and quick and easy to re-tool your builds.</p><p>I have always loved and celebrated this system, so it’s no surprise that it returned almost unchanged in the remake. The remake does exacerbate some of the downsides though: mostly through an increased emphasis on specific enemy weaknesses that can quickly lead to regretting your Materia assignments mid-battle. I would be surprised if Remake Part 2 doesn’t introduce some sort of on-the-fly swapping or multi-profile system per character to address this.</p><h4>Final Fantasy VII Remake — “Proficiency”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/680/0*aRH8bbbh05dFQaYB" /></figure><p>Every weapon in the <em>FFVII Remake</em> has a unique ability that the character can absorb into their permanent repertoire by using the ability enough times or completing a sub-objective. I really like systems that incentivize players using all the games abilities and varying their play style, and I like how this mechanic, much like Materia, also works as a partial solution to a classic RPG problem: items competing on stats, leading to the majority of loot being instantly discarded after a quick contrast against your current gear. With this mechanic, I’m always excited to find a new weapon, and always wear it long enough to grab the new ability.</p><p>Proficiency has the same goal as a durability system but is also the antithesis of it: rewarding using new weapons rather than punishing overuse of the same ones.</p><h4>Final Fantasy VII Remake — “Core Nodes”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xcib3q_XrGSByhT4" /></figure><p>Rather than having static stats or powering up in a linear fashion, inside each weapon are a network of “cores” — clusters of potential upgrades in the form of unlockable nodes. Leveling up a character earns skill points aka SP that can be spent to unlock the benefits of these core nodes but (clever!) the SP gathers on <em>all </em>the weapons in inventory regardless of if they’re being used and (clever!) all new cores are unlocked inside the weapons at higher levels. These later cores contain extremely potent nodes like new Materia sockets and links, or big statistical jumps that can make old weapons viable again.</p><p>Having ability points gather on unused weapons while unlocking powerful new upgrade branches for them at later levels is a SUPER clever way to give old weapons a second wind— though it does make it hard to compare their value before going through the process of manually updating all the available cores, which can be a bit of a chore.</p><h4>Resident Evil 4 — “Attaché Case”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*vavAb1JzBePTbeZWBq0ywA.gif" /></figure><p>The inventory system that doubles as a puzzle — a natural evolution from limited slots and stacking that makes the choice of what to pickup and carry feel extra strategic and personal. Plus, acts as a meditative retreat from the games action and can be immensely satisfying in a very mundane way… like arranging your sock drawer. In general I prefer limited space over weight when it comes to inventory limits, as your capacity is constantly visible and most strategic decisions are made upfront when finding new items/picking up, rather than looting blind and creating a backlog of organization to do later.</p><h4>The Witcher III — “Quen”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*WUWBmAb7mATbz32aIH5EIA.gif" /></figure><p>Cast a layer of super armor on yourself that absorbs incoming damage without triggering a flinch — it allows mistakes in high-stakes combat but more importantly prevents your own attacks from being interrupted, so that you can push them through incoming assaults: essential strategy against Witcher’s aggressive, slippery enemies, who seem tuned specifically to exploit any gaps in your reach or swings.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*tNWW8CHvVoIC7FRUn1MdxQ.gif" /></figure><p>The Quen spell upgrades add revenge effects that hurt or stun the enemies who strike or break your shield, and the “alt-cast” lets you project a protective bubble useful for hiding during recovery animations, or closing the distance against a range threat. Later upgrades even let you convert incoming damage into health, which is wildly potent.</p><h4>Devil May Cry — “Twosome Time”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/390/1*Vd531-l6ZO7kg_Y2jhIiHA.gif" /></figure><p>One of the purest gun kata mechanics ever: I thought this was the <strong>coolest </strong>shit when I was a teen. Anchor to one enemy with lock on, then aim at another. Credit where credits due, it was the infamous <em>Devil May Cry 2</em> that actually introduced Twosome Time — with the offhand pistol having an extra kick that could push away approaching enemies — an idea <em>Devil May Cry 5 </em>touches on again by making Ivory fast, and Ebony heavy, as per their original lore.</p><p>Hope you found that enjoyable! If you want to sample these posts fresh out of the oven you can follow me on Twitter — <a href="https://twitter.com/_SteveThornton">@_SteveThornton</a> — as we work our way towards Part III. Ciao.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6604652b566b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mechanics Monday]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stethornton6/mechanics-monday-1769f60ae891?source=rss-1d66cdb4449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1769f60ae891</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gears-of-war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[devil-may-cry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-mechanics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stethornton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Jan 2021 19:29:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-27T20:51:16.873Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Celebrating Game Mechanics Big and Small</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zTb9JyFdODbLws_ux4zyIQ.png" /></figure><p>Six months ago I started a weekly feature on my Twitter account called “Mechanics Monday”. Every Monday, I tweet about one of my favorite game mechanics from the hundreds (thousands?) of games that I’ve played over the years. Both the feature and this article are headlined by the Portal Gun, an obvious example of mechanics royalty and the titular centerpiece of the games it stars in (<a href="https://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2018-05-22-thinking-outside-the-cube">if you want to hear me gush about Valve’s genius puzzler you can take the blue portal over to GamesIndustry.biz</a>) — but for Mechanics Monday I wanted to avoid spending tweets on the flagship features and biggest, best-known mechanics. Instead I wanted to try and spotlight the less obvious, the “support actors” of the mechanics world, the little masterstrokes and forgotten ideas that really stuck with me and still tickle at my feelings or inform my own design philosophy now that I work in the industry myself. The most interesting, the most memorable, the most full of potential, ideally: the most underrated. …Mostly. There’s nobody to hold me to that rule so I indulged a dip into the mainstream a fair few times — but only for the real crème de la crème!</p><p>The term “game mechanics” comes up a lot in video game discourse both professional and amateur, despite lacking an agreed universal definition. At its core, a game mechanic is simply a rule about how the game works, but over time it’s become popular shorthand for gameplay actions and interactions, such as the player characters abilities or the environmental elements that those abilities can interact with — similar to the less widely-used game design term “verbs”. For Mechanics Monday I am using this colloquial definition — I’m a systems guy and I think all the best hooks revolve around some exciting new action or ability for the player to wield with their beautiful, terrible agency — but whatever semantics you favor, discussions about game mechanics are usually my favorite type of video game discussion because they cut closest to the nuts and bolts of how games work, just as the word “mechanism” promises.</p><p>I decided to gather and expand the posts thus far in article form, because each week when I went searching for inspiration I found precious few other collections of this type, outside of forum posts and the occasional “best mechanics of the year” list; many of which stretched the definition of mechanic even further. Thus far I have spotlighted 46 mechanics in the original <a href="https://twitter.com/i/events/1262428574172229632">Twitter Moment</a> — this first article will cover only the first 25, with a second part to follow when I hit the big 5–0.</p><h4>Devil May Cry — “Exceed”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*mScFexQUEAzBbGPPD1lRRg.gif" /></figure><p>The <em>Devil May Cry</em> series is packed with cool and clever weapon mechanics, but one that really caught my imagination was the Exceed system — especially the instant rev or “Ex-Act” (<em>exact</em> — get it?). Press a button during specific frames of attacks to bank an energy slot that will automatically power up your next move. Basic attacks get faster and stronger, specials are upgraded into new forms with juiced up FX and new animations. There are 3 Exceed “lamps” to fill, with your next attack spending them all at once — the more lamp levels burned on a move, the more the special evolves.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*oV_4JtpAXxQonxVezwul6Q.gif" /></figure><p>Like a lot of Nero’s mechanics it’s a clever way to spice up the basics and expand his move-list without any weapon swapping. You can also unlock the ability to “Max-Act” which lets you skip to three lamps with a single, extra precise rev. Rev windows are even hidden in Nero’s taunts, for the truly smug. I like this mechanic because it gives players something to think about <em>during </em>their attacks: a time they are normally just watching. The downside of Exceed is that it’s really a mechanic for frame counting fighting game nerds, with casual players reporting it confusing or simply ignoring it. Still, there’s always the manual rev; lamps don’t drain so anyone can prep some sauce for the opening salvo of their next battle. Plus, manual rev is when the Red Queen’s motorcycle motif sings the loudest.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*JtDJvQJis4HudcDA5ZkFGw.gif" /></figure><h4>Splinter Cell Conviction — “Last Known Position”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*ndrwYW-S0dVq5xLhPl_sfw.gif" /></figure><p>When you slip out of the enemies view, you leave behind a ghostly copy of yourself that marks where the AI think you are — and while they magnetize to your shed skin like flies to a lightbulb you can flank and hatch your traps. Lots of games have a behind the scenes system for this, but as a stealth noob, making it so overt was essential to giving me the confidence to embrace manipulation tactics. While most stealth games reward staying invisible, this mechanic turns giving enemies a glimpse of you into one of your most viable strategies.</p><h4>Splinter Cell Conviction — “Mark and Execute”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*ITD4sGfhtNUjsZCc1WiyLg.gif" /></figure><p>This mechanic involves tagging enemies so you can later trigger a string of instant auto-headshots. The catch is that you must earn those tags with proper stealth kills and you can only execute multiple targets in one swoop if you sneak into a vantage point with line of sight on all of them at the same time. Mark and Execute brings a whole new meta to stealth play, turning it into a prep phase where eye-line is currency: It creates interesting resource and LOS puzzles, and gives the genre a big payoff it usually lacks. A violent payoff earned via stealth.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*Tkz00KCehr1QE014RXhu7Q.gif" /></figure><h4>Bayonetta — “Witch Time”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*EqQ8seIHHMChQenDr5nBEg.gif" /></figure><p>This mechanic was submitted by <a href="https://twitter.com/FrauGakidou">@FrauGakidou</a></p><p>As Miss Gakidou wisely said, any time you reap the rewards of a well-timed dodge feels great, especially when it doesn’t steal your controls away for the counter attack. <em>Bayonetta’s </em>perfect dodges envelop the world in purple, slowing enemy movement to a crawl and bending the laws of physics in her favor; making even the biggest creatures vulnerable to launchers and new stun states, while delaying knockbacks from reaching fruition so you can hit enemies with your hardest attacks without them slipping out of your range as easily as normal.</p><h4>Bayonetta — “Dodge Offset”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*rkZNaW5UBPrOMvEh6zuwPw.gif" /></figure><p>A very subtle mechanic, but a game-changer. If you hold down the last-used attack button before dodging it puts your current combo on pause, allowing you to safely evade without resetting your string … and then pick it up again where you left off. Perfect for a sequence based combat system like <em>Bayonetta </em>where triggering new moves is dependent on completing previous ones.</p><h4>Gears of War — “Active Reload”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*oq5gsyR7o63VIK_h-NHKeQ.gif" /></figure><p>This fun (optional) risk/reward mini-game turns a usually passive beat into another chance to feel skillful. Just like Exceed, it gives players something to think about at a time they’re normally an observer. Nail a quick timing challenge in the HUD to complete your reload early, or <em>really </em>nail it, and all the bullets added to your gun during that reload get a power boost. From a gameplay perspective, the potential of this “Perfect Active Reload” provides incentive to delay reloads until later in the clip, so that you get even more juiced rounds to play with — but there is a risk/reward aspect also, because if you slip the timing the character will instead bungle their animation and leave you waiting longer than usual. Best of all, it’s totally optional! Those who prefer to live without the distraction can let the reload animation play out as normal. Since the industry spent like ten years copying the <em>Gears of War</em> stop n’ pop cover system, I don’t know why it’s been too proud to lift the active reload system while it was at it … it just makes things better.</p><h4>Onimusha — “Absorb”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*_XYAH9XIKmvUGrn_yGs_hQ.gif" /></figure><p>In <em>Onimusha </em>slain enemies release souls that float around in the air like ethereal tadpoles — the only way to claim these treats is to stop and absorb them into your Oni Gauntlet. Since the loose souls will fade over time, this often requires finding combat beats to squeeze in your absorbs, creating an interesting juggle of fighting and collecting. Loot magnetizing mechanics appear in other games of course, such as <em>Sekiro </em>— I even added one to a LEGO game I assistant-directed: in <em>LEGO Chima Laval’s Journey </em>players can absorb loose Chi energy into their breastplate by holding a shoulder button. I have a soft spot for mechanics like these because it adds a nice little flex to the end of combat loops; the same feeling as manually reloading or holstering after an encounter. Underrated flair.</p><h4>Streets of Rage 4— “Special Regain”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*MUus1w9Ry_HItvjSpbjesw.gif" /></figure><p>In the OG <em>Streets of Rage</em>, special moves cost HP… so I barely used them. Spending some HP to escape a situation where it looks like you’re about to lose it all does make logical sense, but it’s bitter math to swallow in the heat of combat. In the series’ recent revival though, specials don’t consume your HP immediately; instead they highlight a potential deficit that will be confirmed by any real damage or recouped with successful hits on enemies. It lets players gamble on themselves.</p><h4>Bloodborne — “Rally”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*RFJocGmw7Sf74aroWil-Xw.gif" /></figure><p>Crunchy goth-em-up <em>Bloodborne </em>also monetizes aggression with their game-changing Rally mechanic. After taking a hit players can see the potential injury highlighted on their health bar, but before it drains away for real they can attempt to refill it with the blood of their enemies — helpfully sprayed with each blow they land. Essentially in order to avoid feeling a hit you need to strike back immediately, blood for blood. Retreating means accepting the full damage, which shakes up the risk reward dynamic significantly. If you want to read more about how health mechanics can craft play style, crouch roll over to <a href="https://medium.com/@stethornton6/hp-and-other-drugs-cb8476b19054">HP and other Drugs</a> — the article I borrowed this paragraph from.</p><h4>Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild — “Climb”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/1*zP5COoe2A25utHvb1YSi2w.gif" /></figure><p>Most games with climbing mechanics designate specific surfaces for it, but in <em>Breath of the Wild</em>’s open world players can climb anywhere, limited only by their stamina bar. Without official paths and boundaries to follow, traversal feels personal. Soft gates like this are incredibly brave design choices because they blow the possibility space wide open, and as a result players feel like they’re finding solutions the game didn’t plan for (and it’s probably true). The only limit is a stat they know they can boost and overclock with items.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/444/1*mwWUW7X0RxFShQH1UAYxog.gif" /></figure><p><em>Breath of the Wild</em> is built on soft gates and invisible boundaries, it’s why it takes so long to find its edges, and it’s why the whole world feels free and interactive. Plus, with the telescope and glider in your pocket, there’s always a reward for gaining height and always a safe way down. There are a lot of details that make this mechanic work so well; the camera pull, the refilling of stamina on tangible footholds that turn mountains into puzzles, the increased stamina cost of steepness, the desperate last jump mechanic. Also, barely any clipping or floating, no matter the incline.</p><h4>Titanfall — “Vortex Shield”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*BYOcs_6EGAjzMRofLn4XIw.gif" /></figure><p>Flips the script on gunfights so that taking fire is a good thing, and there’s few things in combat more satisfying than “return to sender” mechanics. The limited charge adds tension and makes for interesting mindgames with opponents, plus the shield only working from the front means that users need to find and face threats while they move around. Bonus: The potential “projectile tennis” interactions between two vortex shields are more interesting than normal shootouts: Eat your heart out Ganondorf.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*4N6uc9U0gky1pcXxOZjkLA.gif" /></figure><h4>Prince of Persia: Sands of Time — “Rewind”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/1*p2ZBGeS0Hry_sVAb5L0B2A.gif" /></figure><p>I remember playing <em>Sands of Time</em> and thinking the rewind mechanic was REVOLUTIONARY and must surely now be a staple for all games with fast fail states (platforming/racing/stealth); an elegant sidestep around game overs and save scumming. Rewinds being a limited resource maintains tension and adds a splash of agency, unlike quick restarts/checkpoints that feel like the game is replacing you like an errant ornament. One game genre that apparently did pick it up is racing, as highlighted in the “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uF6c8KJuuEk">School of Stealth</a>” series from Game Makers Toolkit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*Q5tzUx3bO381WVFCK7LwmA.gif" /></figure><h4>Metal Gear Solid V — “Reflex Mode”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*dW4oETd_X-tT4ZzWyASf-w.gif" /></figure><p>This mechanic was submitted by <a href="https://twitter.com/luca_ucc">@luca_ucc</a></p><p>The GMTK video linked above discusses solutions to the stealth genres own failure problem — once the player is discovered, the stealth is over but the game’s still going. As a band-aid, <em>Phantom Pain</em> gives the player one last chance to avoid falling off the sneaky wagon. When Snake is spotted, the game automatically kicks into slow motion — providing a short window of time for the player to neutralize any whistle blowers before the alarm is raised for real. The mechanic is optional and the player is lauded for not using it, but for those without the patience to muddle their way back into the shadows it’s nearly as good as a do-over.</p><h4>Resistance: Fall of Man — “Bullseye”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*MQ5XEq0LSvMDJrTG9GJWAw.gif" /></figure><p><em>Resistance </em>brought the exotic weapon mechanics of <em>Ratchet &amp; Clank</em> to FPS, and it was awesome. Bullseye is the series’ poster gun: tag an enemy and all later bullets bend towards the tag, ala The Fifth Element. Plant that all important first bullet in your target, and you can freely spray the air between you, confident the rest will find their mark. A satisfying trick that subverts traditional FPS strategy — and not the only one in the game...</p><h4>Resistance: Fall of Man — “Auger”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*NuU70fVmYQwcXhwR64IGyg.gif" /></figure><p><em>Resistance</em> is full of great gameplay ideas. Another that stuck with me is the Auger: a gun whose energy bullets can phase through walls and cover — but the best part: those energy bullets actually <em>gain </em>power the more surfaces that they phase through, rewarding players who engage with the mechanic. Grabbing a mental map and sneaking back into cover to shoot at it feels very clever, and the slight delay it takes for your projectiles to drill through each surface adds an extra layer of skill. PS: It is SHOCKING how few playthroughs on Youtube use the Auger in this alleyway, which is clearly purpose built for it; appearing shortly after the guns initial unlocking, with layers of light cover and emplaced/leashed enemies waiting to be exploited. I remember having a ball with the Auger in this section. Those pesky gamers never do the obvious thing.</p><h4>Gears of War — “Digger Launcher”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*q0vsyvynCYJawIeqByPF0Q.gif" /></figure><p>Another gun whose projectile can pass through (or in this case <em>under</em>) cover is the <em>Gears of War</em> Digger Launcher. Given the series’ entrenched cover combat, a cover penetrating weapon feels like sanctioned rule breaking — a potent trick balanced out with its travel time and clear visual trail.</p><p>Inspired by <em>Resistance </em>and <em>Gears</em>, the next set of mechanics continue the firearms theme!</p><h4>Gears of War — “Torque Bow”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*PvNTPLmCNWoxMbS0cQxbjw.gif" /></figure><p><em>Gears </em>is generally brilliant at creating satisfying, contained interactions. Another example is the Torque Bow: the flaccid trajectory tightening alongside the clockwork SFX until it clicks into place, followed by the pressure to aim your fully charged shot before the tension becomes too much and it automatically releases— worth leaving cover for!</p><h4>Halo — “Needler”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*YtBxmVUevsv3Tu9Ls25ekA.gif" /></figure><p><em>Halo Combat Evolved</em> was a trailblazer, often credited with revolutionizing the console FPS. Gamers are famously reluctant to part with the tight precision of a keyboard and mouse, so <em>CE </em>worked very hard to adapt the genre to the looser reins of a controller; the staple twin sticks and binary weapon slots were introduced, health regenerated and physics were exaggerated — meanwhile combat pulled players into medium and close range where the iconic Assault Rifle’s wide reticule and hitscan barrage could batter foes easily; Elite enemy shields negated long-distance chip play and demanded players commit to their targets. The Needler is a perfect extension of these ideals; with homing darts that compensate for loose aim at assault range and build to crescendo if landed consistently.</p><h4>Halo — ”Plasma Pistol”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*xrmnfZ-G8YysLNtdxqFxKg.gif" /></figure><p>In my opinion, an underrated weapon is the common Plasma Pistol, whose charged blast homes and instantly strips shields (and in some of the games EMPs vehicles) making it the perfect comeback tool — converting any enemy into a weapon locker. Not to mention, it pairs great with guns that capitalize on low shields: Few classic <em>Halo </em>players will forget the infamous “Noob Combo” : wandering the map with a fully charged Plasma Pistol, ready to strip and swap to Battle Rifle for a hitscan headshot — solved in <em>Halo 3</em> by having the Plasma Pistol burn through its ammo while held at full charge.</p><h4>DOOM Eternal — “Meathook”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*VKFnhIhbyyXwZap2eyP_8w.gif" /></figure><p>This mechanic is multi-tier genius. Firstly, it’s a shotgun that pulls the player into shotgun range (already perfect) — secondly, it fits into the mobility and traversal system, pairing with the double jump and dash, turning aerial demons into anchors to propel you or redirect your momentum —then with the flame chain upgrade it acts as a new way to immolate enemies and get them shedding armor shards (let’s face it, the resource we all forget to keep full) at which point it’s an escape strategy that also basically <em>heals</em>. Add the synergy it has with the slow time rune (with which it helpfully shares a button!) or the air control rune: insanely good. <em>“A good idea is something that does not solve just one single problem, but rather can solve multiple problems at once.”</em> — Shigeru Miyamoto</p><h4>Bulletstorm — “Thumper”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*9WtIomJQ7fGpSrIa_GdaaQ.gif" /></figure><p>I forgot how much I loved <em>Bulletstorm</em>, it was absolutely packed with wild, OTT ideas. Similar to <em>DOOM’s </em>Meathook, the Energy Leash is a linchpin between systems — by which I mean it acts as a bridge between other verbs. The leash can pull enemies out of cover, into one of the various environmental hazards or into the range of the players powerful kick, which is just as likely to redirect them into a nasty spike or electric fence— alternatively, the leash can hang them in the air with the immensely satisfying Thumper ability, creating an aerial shooting range.</p><h4>Bulletstorm — “Head Hunter”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*HeReKQgk2O-LUs8_L37DEQ.gif" /></figure><p>I love projectile steering mechanics, and <em>Bulletstorm’s </em>Head Hunter sniper is a savage example. Its bullets are also manually detonated explosives, allowing you to grab enemies and steer them to hazards or other enemies before detonation. Another gun that contains a mini-game.</p><h4>Wolverine’s Revenge — “Strike System”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/389/1*tP9N-W2E2rsxyPzkCVaZlg.gif" /></figure><p>The Wolverine license games are scrappy gems full of cool ideas. In <em>Wolverine’s Revenge </em>you can trigger finishers on multiple enemies based on their positioning around Wolvy; through the “Strike” system. There are a handful of arrangements to learn but multiple moves to trigger per formation. I loved this game as a teen and referenced it in a meeting during my early years at TT Games, only for a colleague, Mr Dave Reynolds (no social media) to say he worked on <em>Revenge </em>and the Strike system was actually his feature!! The first time I’d ever been starstruck in my career.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xC2V3wAYDW3F4-bw" /></figure><p>Above is a grab of the <em>Wolverine’s Revenge</em> Strike system menu page, showing some of the positions you can use to trigger finishers. Fitting Wolverine into the right spot to pull these off during combat -and choosing which move to use- helped make canned finishers feel an extension of player choices, instead of a Quick Time Event. Similar to Mark and Execute, it’s a payoff players can plan towards.</p><h4>Wolverine Origins — “Lunge”</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*mOVFEF44aYTN07JPRkoLOQ.gif" /></figure><p>Runner up in the family is the <em>Wolverine Origins</em> game adaptation and its “Lunge” mechanic. Super satisfying to use, useful in both traversal and combat, and also a linchpin mechanic that could be chained into standard combos or other moves like flips, throws and ground stabs.</p><p>I’ve had a lot of fun doing Mechanics Monday week to week, and although I thought I’d eventually run out of favorites, I’ve got a whole list of picks in mind for 2021 already. Part II of this article is just over a month away, or you can stop by my Twitter — <a href="https://twitter.com/_SteveThornton">@_SteveThornton</a> — if you want to see the posts hot off the presses…. or share your own favorite mechanics! I’d love to hear them.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1769f60ae891" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Seven Deadly Feels of Hades]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stethornton6/the-seven-deadly-feels-of-hades-6381bac61cc0?source=rss-1d66cdb4449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6381bac61cc0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[games-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roguelike]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hades]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stethornton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 06 Oct 2020 15:21:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-06T15:21:42.766Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Emotion with Agency</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vNEoww1BbndKJWp9_ruK5w.jpeg" /></figure><p>One of my favorite game development quotes is from Todd Howard’s 2012 DICE keynote “<a href="https://youtu.be/7awkYKbKHik">Why we play, Why we create</a>”, where he says the emotion games can create that non-interactive entertainment cannot, is pride. I reference this sound bite a lot (too much probably) in my work and writing because pride is usually the feeling I’m striving for as a designer and player: Success and satisfaction, those most intoxicating of vices. I like to be good at stuff and feel good about myself, which is great because one usually follows the other. The reason that other mediums cannot create pride is that (much like video game cutscenes) they don’t offer audiences any agency — the ability to influence events with your actions and thus take ownership of the outcome. Pride is the high we’re most used to chasing in games but agency, and the resulting responsibility and ownership it can create, actually opens the door to a whole cocktail of possible emotions.</p><p>At the time of writing, Twitter is aflame with righteous praise for <em>Hades -</em> the 4th title from darling indie’s <em>Supergiant Games</em>. All the <em>Supergiant </em>staples are there in force; art direction is impeccably sharp and stylish, the combat is their trademark juicy staccato, overall presentation is Luxurious with a capital L. There’s a lot to love about this elegantly paced Roguelike, but perhaps the most vital element to its success is the studios recurring raison d’être; making narrative a constant companion. In most games narrative and gameplay feel like parallel rails, only meeting at specific crossroads and bringing the story in fits and starts. Harking back to <em>Bastion</em>’s omnipresent narrator <em>Supergiant </em>has long been experimenting with ways to interweave gameplay action with narrative response. Thus far, their major answer to this problem has been sheer volume: <em>Hades </em>supposedly has over 20,000 lines of (voiced!) dialogue, allowing interactions near endless permutations — conversations reference everything from the players current weapon and health status, to their most recent death or most recent interactions with other characters. Sometimes it’s a little on-the-nose, a little <em>Psycho-Mantis-knows-you-played-Castlevania</em>, but when it lands organically it’s cutting-edge narrative design and is very effective at recognizing gameplay as part of the player’s personal story.</p><p>So it was during my <em>Hades </em>playthrough that I started to really savor some of the other emotions games can make us feel, that other fictional mediums can’t. With <em>Hades </em>as a prism, lets take a quick tour through a spectrum of emotions exclusive to agency.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*viwBiil3FsfokltVojkMjw.gif" /></figure><h4>Pride</h4><p><em>See also: Confidence, Power</em></p><p>Pride first, just to get it out of the way. <em>Hades </em>still offers plenty of that old drug, albeit short-lived and hard fought. Success in <em>Hades </em>can take many forms; every battle a buffet, every chamber a banquet — the taste of victory is most recognizable in every boss you pass and new area you touch, but even the salad of defeat brings you a step closer to your dream body. Stretched metaphors aside, <em>Hades </em>does have great gamefeel that rewards every strike and slash — as well as a wide range of upgrades and modifiers that chamber after chamber compose into a formidable collage of powers, raising Zagreus into a colorful whirlwind of destruction. While most of these enhancements are washed away by defeat, the spoils earned with them come back to the HUB, where a multitude of upgrade systems are working in parallel to ensure a steady flow of permanent gains. At first these changes are much more subtle than the flash and bang of boons and hammers, but they quickly start to build into tangible growth.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S0egATh6zdaH-C382r3p0A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Like all Roguelikes <em>Hades </em>benefits from players constant revisiting of the games first areas, always contrasting their new strength with their struggles of the past. Gradually the biggest challenges become small, surprises become expectations, improvisation becomes strategy — there are few satisfactions in life as potent as growth, and no better way to feel your growth than to return strong to somewhere you were once weak. Yet while your constantly escalating strength allows you to pierce ever faster and deeper into the labyrinth, the ending awaiting you is near always to be struck down at the height of your power and slide right back to the start again. For the majority of the game your ultimate goal of escape is dauntingly out of reach; every victory turns bittersweet in the end. Which is perhaps why it allows so many other flavors to come to the fore. (Boom, full circle taste metaphor)</p><h4>Loyalty</h4><p><em>See also: Gratitude</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qbItSAVV253B3WlJuk4keQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Another thing I say a lot: If you want players to like an NPC, make them useful in gameplay. Even the most ludo-brained player will learn to love the sight of NPC’s they associate with items, healing, combat help or checkpoints and safe zones. That sort of assistance resonates through the 4th wall, it allows in-game characters to help the person holding the controller. Most of the characters in <em>Hades </em>act as a literal support system; in their dialogue they root for you and want you to succeed, and in gameplay they offer the tools most vital to your success. The Olympian’s with their boons, Nyx and Achilles who gift Zagreus his mirror and codex, Charon and The Shade’s; whose chambers offer respite and resource, Skelly who gets credit for the weapons for some reason — you’re always happy to see them. Over time, this association starts to build into loyalty and gratitude towards those characters. This process can happen in games with extremely simple characters (“<em>What are ya buyin?”</em>) so it helps that the ones in <em>Hades </em>are a particularly vibrant, endearing (and I’ve heard it said — fanciable) bunch.</p><p>You can find the same feeling in a lot of RPG’s where you’re accompanied by a party or a companion, whose support and skills open new doors for you, save your bacon in battle, or — being honest — just draw fire so you spend less healing items. The real test of whether this emotion has settled in isn’t necessarily the relief of their presence (more on that later) but whether or not you would reciprocate their support given the chance. If they were in trouble, would you jump at the chance to help? (<em>*whispers* I would die for you, Nick Valentine *end whisper*)</em> If someone asked you to betray them in exchange for a windfall of rewards, would you do it? (<em>Kill Paarthurnax? Are you crazy? He has the voice of Mario!</em>) Does the idea of hurting them or their feelings make you cringe? (<em>honestly if you have it in you to shoot Mordin even once, even in a one-off Renegade playthrough, I don’t trust you)</em></p><p>Your ability to experience this kind of emotion will likely be somewhat dependent on how much immersion you allow yourself in the games fictional stakes — <a href="https://medium.com/@stethornton6/i-mario-97f4701f273b">which I wrote about in this article</a> — but if you’re an empathetic player like me who likes to really jump into a role, this can be a potent one.</p><h4>Guilt</h4><p><em>See also: Shame, Embarrassment</em></p><p>Guilt and shame, the opposites of pride and satisfaction. This is probably the second most popular feeling for games to try and invoke, though almost all fail because they forget the golden rule: guilt can only be born of agency. Many games interested in exploring the Power Of The Medium try to position the player adjacent to bad decisions by having their avatar make them on their behalf, or by placing an amoral action on the golden path between the player and progression. Alas for a player to take ownership over an outcome, it has to be avoidable. <em>Spec Ops: The Line </em>tries to argue that the avoidable action was playing the game at all, which is novel, but *<em>hand wavy motion*</em></p><p>Admittedly, nearly all my sharpest pangs of guilt in <em>Hades </em>were accidental. There are some mechanics that you won’t understand until you interact with them, including “Trial of the Gods”, a chamber in which you must choose between the gifts of two God’s, leaving one spurned and vengeful. Apparently there aren’t any long-term repercussions to these choices (which is either pretty shallow in the context of a game that strives to make gameplay into narrative… or totally fitting for the capricious Olympians of lore) but to see one of your ardent cheerleaders turn sour and renounce your relationship, even briefly: big regrets. I tried it twice more after burning Ares on accident; hurting Artemis’ feelings and breaking the bro code with Dionysus… now I just avoid those chambers so I don’t have to face the shame. I’ve noticed they’re always optional, which may be a recognition of either how socially uncomfortable they are or that <em>Supergiant </em>know guilt only works with choice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tRwjFgZKo5kvyr9CEtKFzA.jpeg" /></figure><p>A similar moment occurred when a mysterious bag appeared in Charon’s store, with “Borrow” prompted. I <strong><em>stole</em></strong>! Stole from Charon, whose riverboat wares are an oasis in the endless withering grind of chambers and challenges. My best friend Charon; that witty affable guy who I had all those fun chats with… Charon! <em>My brother from the land of suffer!</em> Anyway, he challenged me to single combat and spanked me with his paddle. Transported back to the HUB, Father Hades chastised me for Death By Shoplifting. “An ignoble end, even for you”. Yep, I felt that shame.</p><p>Stepping outside the world of <em>Hades </em>for a moment, the greatest guilt I carry from my video gaming memoirs is from <em>Mass Effect 3</em>, when my delayed acceptance of a seemingly forgettable side mission came back to haunt me in the games final hours as the horrible death of a crew-mate. A real Spider-Man Uncle Ben moment. …Also, one time in <em>Red Dead</em> I shot a dog.</p><p>They should not have that button so close to the others!</p><h4>Duty</h4><p><em>See also: Responsibility, Morality</em></p><p>Morality is another of the video game industry’s obsessions. As we just learned from my great <em>Mass Effect 3</em> shame, with great power comes great responsibility. As the only being in the game world with agency, it’s your choices alone which can shape the fate of its inhabitants. Will you wield that power for good and evil? Well, that largely depends on whether you want the Angel Wing jetpack of the Devil Horns armor, 1000 karma points each.</p><p>Loyalty almost always creates a sense of duty to protect what you are loyal to. Equally, responsibility should result in a sense of duty, assuming you aren’t a politician. Most interesting is when two lines of duty; loyalty and responsibility for example, conflict — something that few games attempt and fewer games pull off (though <em>Sekiro’s</em> Iron Code question got pretty close) but at least video games offer players the chance to experiment with the perks and demands of importance and leadership. It’s wish fulfillment, but if you really embrace the fictional stakes, it also pulls on you just a little. Failure in the line of duty comes with a little extra sting, and fulfilling it comes with just a little more pride. In the world of <em>Hades </em>part of what kept me going back out that door was the enthusiasm of the God Squad, constantly reminding Zagreus that they have a seat ready for him on Olympus. To give up would feel like a waste of their time and generosity. Don’t we owe it to the people who support us to succeed?</p><h4>Spite</h4><blockquote>“I had a boyfriend who told me I’d never succeed, never be nominated for a Grammy, never have a hit song, and that he hoped I’d fail. I said to him, ‘Someday, when we’re not together, you won’t be able to order a cup of coffee at the fucking deli without hearing or seeing me.” — Lady Gaga</blockquote><p>Never forget: Spite is a very underrated motivational tool. Sure, traditional media can make you <em>hate </em>a character. But can they turn that hatred into fuel, and then convert that fuel into a smugness chaser for your pride high? While most characters in <em>Hades </em>cheer you on and build you up, there are others who constantly tell you your task is impossible; who scoff and mock your every struggle and defeat. A reason not to quit is so that they never have the satisfaction, a reason to win is so that you can prove them wrong and see the look on their faces.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0fNDt1uA15l9pW68y35TSA.png" /></figure><p>Most of these characters are just stubborn and small-minded, they can never imagine anything beyond what they’ve already seen. They don’t believe you can achieve more, because they don’t aspire to any more themselves — Zagreus is a frustrating reminder that they’ve already given up, and a rebuke of the life they’ve accepted. Father Hades himself is all those things and more, the authoritarian whose self-righteous conservatism makes rebellion taste so sweet — the parent who told their child they would never amount to anything unless they exchanged their dreams for reality, and is now so invested in that being true they belittle their achievements and try to ruin their plans. Yet with Hades himself, there trembles the worry that you may actually succeed — with every roadblock he adds and chamber he shakes with his voice, he shows his hand. Screw you, dad! (Not my dad, I actually have very supportive parents)</p><h4>Desperation</h4><p><em>See also: Relief</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Olx3ZPRmNgMkssKOraYsPw.png" /></figure><p>The highs and lows of a story can take us to the edge of our seats or have us hiding behind our pillows, but it’s unlikely we will ever feel <em>desperate </em>while watching a movie (except perhaps while trying to sit through <em>The Revenant</em> in a cinema) — but video games take the stakes much closer to home, where we own our own successes and failures. I wrote in <a href="https://medium.com/@stethornton6/hp-and-other-drugs-cb8476b19054">my article about health systems</a> that when a player is running low on health, red vignette pulsing and HUD ringing, it’s the closest thing to hunger you can make a player feel. Desperation is the longing for relief, the invisible hand reaching out for <em>something</em>.</p><p>The unpredictable maze of chambers and challenges in <em>Hades </em>wither away at your resources; death can come quickly or by a thousand cuts. Opportunities to replenish your health are initially very sparse, oft leaving players longing for the endless threats to give way to a store or heart or friendly shade — the relief of a reward crashing down after a cleared chamber or the image of those icons floating over the next door is palpable. Negative emotions like tension, frustration and desperation may sound unappealing but as we know, they will eventually convert into extra pride through the alchemy of success, assuming we get that far.</p><h4>Kindness</h4><p><em>See also: Compassion, Helpitude</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1szXQiApF8KmrbNmvVFd6g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Non-interactive mediums can still provoke sympathy and compassion, but what they don’t allow is for you to do something about it. I couldn’t find a word that meant “the warm feeling of doing something nice for someone else” (which we shall call helpitude) but you definitely can’t get it from watching a TV show. Agency allows you to be kind. As covered in the <em>Loyalty </em>segment, the House of Hades is populated with characters who usually land somewhere between endearing and adorable, possibly even crushable, and on top of that they ingratiate themselves with unconditional generosity that touches the soul and the stats. They help you without asking anything in return, but it’s quickly apparent that despite all the generosity they freely offer <em>you</em>, many are carrying the weight of their own burdens.</p><p>The problems of NPC’s often serve as the backdrop for video game quests but much like guilt, real helpitude only really works when it’s based on self-motivated actions, and quests are part of the authored path, not the players own. <em>Hades </em>develops loyalty to its characters, gradually exposes their own needs, and doesn’t immediately offer a path to assist them. There’s an item called Nectar which is a contraband delicacy treasured in both the under world and Olympus; it acts as a gift you can give to any character — in practice, a “do a nice thing” button. Nectar is initially a rare commodity and gifting it is essentially optional, which means that each time you find some it feels like your decision what to do with it. Choosing who to give it to, looking forward to their reaction, it replicates the excitement of gift giving. I‘m not as big a fan of the affinity system it serves, I think “buying” relationships with bulk gifting reduces something organic and potentially beautiful into something mechanical… it turns the gifting back into a task (also, giving 6 of the same thing is lame gift etiquette) but I do think it’s clever how the first time you give Nectar to a character you receive a useful item in return, making it viable in the games first phase when players are still making ludo-brained choices — then for a long-time thereafter the only reward is the dialogue and relationships themselves, just in time for the next phase.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3Kx0Qe4Vx_o2nLoM6rbf0g.jpeg" /></figure><p>When you start playing <em>Hades </em>you’re fixated on your gameplay goals and are “using” the characters to progress your escape, but over time that mentality starts to invert, and you’re using the escape to progress the characters and relationships. You find yourself spending your gems fixing up the lounge to ease Dusa’s workload, or venturing into the labyrinth not with escape on the horizon, but to bring word of Orpheus to Eurydice, or to gather Nectar as an apology to Meg for tarnishing her reputation. You can make kindness your own mission, and that means you get to own the results.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6381bac61cc0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Knowledge as Power]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stethornton6/knowledge-as-power-d8f4b3fb6dc3?source=rss-1d66cdb4449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d8f4b3fb6dc3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dark-souls]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sonic-the-hedgehog]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[level-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stethornton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Oct 2020 18:36:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-02T18:38:38.193Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Finding the Why in the What</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_2uzIWtbJmewi2Zqry9kLg.png" /></figure><p>In the world of 2006’s vulgar satire <em>Idiocracy, </em>human society continues to rely on their technology long after everyone smart enough to understand how it all works is dead. They are able to do this simply by following the routines they associate with the technology working as intended. As consumers, we don’t need to know why our products work in order to enjoy the results. We can even hold extremely simplified or flat-out incorrect beliefs about why they work and still get the results we expect, assuming we don’t deviate too far from the routine we recognize. Similarly if you’re a creative, copying the “routines” from existing products that deliver your desired results will work as long as you copy closely enough that you accidentally pull across all the functional interactions attached to the underside of the superficial parts. Of course, every addition or subtraction to a feature or its environment risks breaking it, possibly in a subtle way you can’t readily articulate. Without understanding why these features work as intended, you won’t be able to predict or analyze the impact of new variables. In the world of <em>Idiocracy</em>, they swap their crop irrigation systems water supply for branded Gatorade and don’t understand why their crops stop growing. See also: <em>The Rise of Skywalker</em> and <em>Game of Thrones </em>Season 8.</p><p>Similarly it’s common for game developers to push forward attempting to lift popular features from –sometimes multiple- successful games; mix, tweak or replace prominent elements and place them in new ecosystems, and then desperately try to solve the resulting problems with rudderless iteration and guess-work. The only way to escape the cycle is for people holding the creative reins to understand and articulate WHY things work the way they do, not simply have a vast mental library of things that worked before. Games can be complicated holistic beasts that defy a single thesis, but even if analysis finds more discussion than answers, at least you’re asking the right questions. As an artist and as a leader, you owe it to yourself and your team to design with intent. Great games don’t happen by accident: never confuse a goal with a plan.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OCDV4iJVAbvM8nBj" /></figure><h4>Why does Sonic work?</h4><p>Sonic is a classic example of a series that was remembered wrong and misunderstood by its audience. Even many die-hard fans would tell you that Sonic is about “going fast”, when the original games actually make going fast the hardest thing to do. True, Sonic levels were <em>about </em>speed — about interacting with lots of different environmental mechanics that allowed you to gather speed, translated your speed, required a certain amount of speed, stole your speed, or required you to curb your speed in order to navigate them. However those levels are filled with just as many speed bumps and spike strips as loop-de-loops.</p><p>It’s well-known that when Sonic has a boo-boo on those speed bumps he immediately ejects his gold ring collection in all directions. Most of the rings will fire so fast and far they’re lost completely, but a portion will land close enough to Sonic that he has a chance to recollect them before they fade away. Even a single ring in the pocket ensures Sonic won’t be instantly killed, and the more rings he has the more likely he’ll be able to reclaim some from the ringplosion. It’s an iconic feature of the 2D Sonic games that you don’t really see anywhere outside them. So Sonic, why the rings?</p><p>The original Sonic games understand that at high speed, with Sonic’s momentum to wrestle, it would be somewhere between difficult and impossible to parse upcoming hazards and react in real-time. Running face first into spikes, badniks, lava and such is basically inevitable in your first playthrough. In fact, loads of levels in the first Sonic game DELIBERATELY funnel and trick the player into hazards. Sonic is a trial and error game, and the rings are an attrition-based health system that expects Sonic to get hurt, only landing you with an actual game-over if you make several mistakes in a short period of time. The farther you go without a mistake, the more margin you earn for later errors, a classic positive feedback loop. In that regard, rings are also a <em>distance </em>based health system. If you manage to put some distance between Sonic and the last time you dinged his bumper, you will inevitably rebuild your safety net of rings ready for the next surprise. Players who can “go fast” through a Sonic level don’t learn how to parse faster, they just learn what’s ahead through repetition. When that happens the rings start to double as a scoring system; the more you have when you spin that flag, the less mistakes made along the way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*zsPQjwJbdSJEAHX1.jpg" /></figure><p>Granted, the player’s ultimate goal is to gather and keep their speed (and rings) for as long as possible, but the most potent commodity in achieving that goal is knowledge, not reflexes. Essentially, the game is training its own speed runners, ideal for an old fashioned series like Sonic where running out of lives means a one-way-ticket back to the Green Hill Zone. When players get kicked back to the start of the game, they can use their knowledge to return to that game-over spot faster, and faster. That arcade loop is what enables Sonic players to start treating platforming levels like race tracks. “Going fast” in perpetuity is the Sonic equivalent of a 10+ hit combo in a fighting game, it’s a sign of mastery. If you make “going fast” the baseline experience, you’re going to lose all the nuance that made the originals enjoyable. A mistake plenty of 3D Sonic games readily made.</p><p>There are things that rings can’t save you from, such as being crushed between blocks, drowning In the games underwater areas, and death drops. The two former fates are probably the most memorably scary hazards for fans, but while death drops or “pitfalls” are abundant in many other platforming games they are notably scarce in early Sonic games and levels. The designers anticipated the potential for frustration when the games unique pace and rebellious controls are paired with the standard instant death condition. Many of the handheld and 3D Sonic games didn’t parse this threat before they hit it, and shed their rings as a result.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c_yREF0hGC8289YaUJKy0w.png" /></figure><h4>Why does Dark Souls work?</h4><p>The Dark Souls craze and subsequent “Soulslike” wave is an incredibly vivid example of consumer experience confused with actual understanding. The most common encapsulation of Dark Souls is that: it’s hard. So, for almost a decade, every hard game was “like Dark Souls” or “The Dark Souls of” its subject matter. Everyone could see that FromSoftware were doing something different, but what was the secret sauce? The grimdark aesthetic? The stamina bar? The sprawling interconnected map? Bonfire checkpoints? The lack of overzealous tutorializing and narrative exposition? Really slow weapons? Being fair, none of these answers are wrong given that Dark Souls is like all truly great works, a masterclass in thematic cohesion: the holistic beast (which actually sounds like a Dark Souls boss). All of its parts are working together towards a greater whole, and thus there’s almost nowhere you could point the finger that wouldn’t reveal some part of the puzzle. As usual, it was so easy to identify and shower praise on WHAT was working, that there was no need to dig any deeper for the WHY it worked. At first, anyway.</p><p>With Dark Souls the mountain of op-eds and think pieces piled so high that they eventually gave way to genuine insight, and many critics and fans are now able to discuss and dissect the series with real depth. Nonetheless, for a long time even some of Dark Souls’ most evangelistic fans could be found struggling to get past the first layer of compliments. It definitely had great “games design” and “level design”. It was “deep”, “clever”, “dark”, “pure”, it didn’t “hold your hand” like those other games, it was “old school” — which is usually Gamer™ code for “inaccessible”. In fact much of the infamous wind beneath Dark Souls’ leathery gothic bat wings was the idea that whatever enjoyment could be gleaned from its miserable world had to be EARNED with patience, grit and commitment. It was trapeze without the net, bowling without the rails up. A game for the Real Gamer only, in a world rife with noob tubes and kill streaks served on silver platters. A certain cut of the fanbase got an almost sensual glee out of how Dark Souls would “brutally punish” any players who aren’t sufficiently committed. Finally, a wing of the clubhouse with a gate they could keep. Big sign over the door: Git Gud or Get Out.</p><p>My 60+ year old father played and finished Dark Souls. I was surprised to discover this at the time, as I only knew the series by its reputation as the Crown Prince of Hardcore Town. Bewildered, I asked him how he did it and in an endless sea of hot takes, my dad -who exists completely outside of gamer culture- nailed it in one. “Well you die a lot, but it doesn’t really matter.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-G-AQ33gF5YUlcZe" /></figure><p>Dark Souls is a trial and error game too, it expects players to die on their first few tries at almost any of the games challenges, and so the punishments associated with death are strategically softened. The primary punishment for dying is dropping all the currency on your person; the titular souls. However, you can reclaim those lost souls simply by getting back to where you died without dying for a second time. Dark Souls only ever demands that you do as well as your most recent try. If you can do this, you will technically never lose anything tangible no matter how many times you die. Even if you do lose a crop of souls for good, souls are not a rare or finite resource, they can be squeezed out of almost any enemy in the game. The other obvious punishment is a classic; being casted back to your last checkpoint. This is still a time sink, providing that essential drip feed of frustration that can be converted into satisfaction later, but loss of physical progress through a space is not actually that big a deal here either. The interconnected map allows players to unlock literal shortcuts that quicken the route back to the spot of their last demise, but more importantly, figurative shortcuts are being constantly unlocked in the players very own brains — without any need for actual changes to the game world itself. In fact, that the world itself never changes is why it works.</p><p>Soulsborne games have tightly leashed enemies that take a hot second to clock the player’s presence and become an active threat. Thus, a totally viable and common strategy in these games is to simply run right past them. The level design again does the heavy lifting here, as environments are intentionally complicated, cluttered or outright dark and around every corner could be a drop, hazard or scary new enemy to run headlong into. Yet if you stop to take even a single beat it is usually enough time for something to get their claws into you. You can only reliably rush through an area if you’ve been through it before and have a mental map of its paths and dangers. Choosing to skim an area without defeating its inhabitants at least once will also mean you aren’t getting a chance to root through its useful items or get the developer recommended dose of experience points, which will eventually catch up to players when they end up locked in with the games next non-optional boss armed with only a rusty starter knife and default underpants.</p><p>FromSoftware games have an unusually large rogue’s gallery, because Dark Souls enemies are at their most dangerous the first time you meet them. Their attacks may be intimidatingly fast, flashy and far-reaching, but their wind-ups are slow and obvious. The only problem is that players need to tango with each enemy long enough to learn what’s going to come out of each wind-up — and experiment to discover the best response. (This is where most of the dying happens.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*3RVY9Sr2uVIilxi8.jpg" /></figure><p>By arming the player with slow, heavy weapons and hamstringing them with a limited stamina bar, Dark Souls reduces video game combat to its bare bones: frame data. All video game attacks can be broken down into how long they take to start (the wind-up), the part that hurts things, and how long before you are free to do something else. Winning a fight is essentially about fitting your wind-up into the time between your opponents last action and next. Dark Souls also has very little “cancelling” aka the ability to change your mind after you start an action, which combined with the stamina limit, explicitly highlights that every action is a strategic choice. Dark Souls is a combat system in slow motion. This increases clarity of where everyone’s attacks start, end and meet, a big reason behind why Souls is so famous for feeling “fair”.</p><p>Most enemies also have at least one built-in success strategy to discover — often a route behind or above them that allows a stealth kill — forming more figurative shortcuts, as well as crafting classic lock and key relationships and combat puzzles. The point is that once players learn how to run through an area or how to defeat an enemy once, they can now do it a million times. What was once an impassable wall is now barely a speed bump. Dark Souls turns every player into a speed runner. Sound familiar? That’s right, <em>Dark Souls is the Sonic the Hedgehog of games</em></p><p>What is more, despite the hype around Dark Souls being inaccessible to all but the most serious gamers, almost nothing in the game demands a copious amount of traditional “skill”, aka hand-eye-coordination, reflexes or controller-fu. As my dad proved, you can beat Dark Souls simply through repetition and patience. Aside from the slow escalation of stats intended to encourage players to at least put some armor on during their playthrough, there is almost no expectation that the player actually becomes more “skillful” or powerful in the traditional sense. The power the player gains that allows them to breeze through the areas that once stumped them is knowledge, just like Sonic. Miyazaki himself says that the intended satisfaction in Dark Souls is overcoming challenges by learning something. Unlike skill, knowledge is also something that can be easily shared or exchanged with other people, which along with the opaque lore to decrypt and empathy of the struggle is a big reason that the nicer parts of the Soulsbornekiro community thrive and bond so easily. “Death as education” might be the clean cut vision statement, but there are a lot of systems in place to ensure that it works.</p><h4>Knowledge as Power</h4><p>My main takeaway from both these games is how you can make the player more powerful without changing a single stat. The trick is ensuring that the discovery phase is structured to soften failure and that information is always powerful enough to replace traditional skill checks. Notably Sonic and Souls levels are played very differently by people in the discovery phase versus those in the mastery phase, there are features and challenges in them that are only valid for one type of player and would be missed by the other, as if there was a second game living inside the first. The pleasure of progression is well reported in game design, there are few things as affirming as returning somewhere you once felt weak as a newer stronger version of you, seeing your growth through the eyes of your previous self.</p><p>If we’re going to grow as game designers and creators, we need to rely on more than imitation and instinct, we need to understand and appreciate the craftmanship underneath our favorite worlds and moments, we need to lead with our “why”. (How was THAT for a segue? Pretty good I thought. Oh shush, it’ll do)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d8f4b3fb6dc3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I, Mario]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stethornton6/i-mario-97f4701f273b?source=rss-1d66cdb4449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/97f4701f273b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-last-of-us-2]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stethornton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 02 Aug 2020 18:21:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-02T19:01:20.375Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The symbiotic relationship between player and character</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5_LtOl4LryR3PRcjpVokYg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Wish fulfillment is one of video gaming’s earliest goals. When we visit exciting fantasy worlds through linear mediums like books and movies, a common indulgence is fantasizing about <em>literally </em>visiting them. Of being plucked from our routines into adventure and danger (within reason) and on a deeper level, of being confirmed special and worthwhile. When we see characters thrust into grand challenges, we like to imagine how we would fare. When we see a hero of grand skill with a sword, gun or guitar, we covet their mastery and wish we could feel what it’s like to be them. Games are the closest we can get to being inside the fantasy; living those worlds, passing those challenges, wielding those skills.</p><p>Self-aware to these desires, I have always approached games looking to immerse myself as much as possible in the protagonist role. Todd Howard said in his 2012 DICE Keynote that the emotion games can provide that other mediums cannot, is pride. That’s the prize I’m looking for in most genres; the pride of skill and success, the faux validation of defeating a challenge authored specifically to be defeatable. The temporary sensation of being the heroes that elsewhere I can only read about and watch. Enabling this cocktail of feelings is a popular game design philosophy at many studios, often literally called “The Fantasy”. It’s also the inspiration for Star Trek’s holodeck, and hey — if it’s good enough for Jean-Luc Picard to get his kicks pretending he’s an old timey detective sometimes, I think we should all embrace our dreams.</p><p>Despite the draw of the immersive fantasy, the majority of games are actually set in complete worlds with already written stories to tell. The protagonist seat isn’t empty and waiting for you, it’s actually taken, and you’re going to have to share it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WqPALSZ3cBqEy4pwJmYcpA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Degrees of Separation</h4><p>The relationship between player and playable character is complicated. They begin separate to you, no doubt about that. They are a marionette dancing on invisible strings attached to your controller buttons. They have haircuts and abs that are logistically impossible for most of us. However, as humans we have a psychological trick up our sleeve that allows us to ignore those degrees of separation. Years ago I watched an episode of the seminal game design essayist channel <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ijcezUy3ZzY">Extra Credits</a> that talked about a concept called <em>Kinesthetic Projection</em>; the idea that humans have evolved to wield tools as an extension of ourselves. I wrote the majority of this article without realizing that the concept of the player erasing the divide between themselves and the character on-screen is covered in this very episode. The divide ends when your mental process evolves from “I am going to move this stick with my finger and thus turn the character to the right” into “I am going to turn the character to the right” and finally, “I am going to turn right”.</p><p>Self-aware of my desire to enter the fictional world as myself, I make this jump willingly, and near immediately. However, it turns out that among the billions of people who play video games, this is not the only school of thought. It may not even be the most common. I read this <a href="https://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/AdrianChmielarz/20131112/204587/Empathy_in_Game_Design_or_Why_Some_People_Like_Beyond_Two_Souls.php">Gamasutra article</a> from Adrian Chmielarz, in which he theorizes that most players approach a game with either cognitive empathy or emotional empathy, resulting in either role-playing or care-taking. Among other things, he goes on to identify new player categories defined not by their desire to collect and explore or their love of the frag, but by their blend of these two empathies.</p><p>Before writing this article I ran a <a href="https://twitter.com/_SteveThornton/status/1287019312239333376">poll</a> on Twitter asking people which category they might place themselves. Although there was a clear winner, every option had its loyal defenders.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/594/1*Q71iYlKTL6Um4jvZljhHvg.png" /></figure><h4>The Empty Vessel</h4><p>Many people who answered my poll replied to point out that it varied depending on the genre and perhaps most vitally, how fleshed out the character was before they arrived. The “blank slate” or “empty vessel” is a well-established narrative strategy; providing players a character with no backstory, traits or goals of their own beyond what the player brings to them. The purest example of this are RPG’s that allow full customization of cosmetics and talents, such as in <em>Skyrim </em>where the characters appearance, gender, race and bag of skills, are (almost) completely irrelevant to how the world reacts to them. In these worlds the player character is essentially just a digital skin for the players will, the literal avatar.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S7TtIDkl5Hcxx81l7S0LxA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Between the empty vessel and the fully fledged character is the “archetype”. These are characters that come packaged with their own style, personality and goals, but still make room for the player to inhabit them by not expressing themselves beyond that premise for the majority of the game; this is true for many of gaming’s most famous and tight-lipped heroes: Sonic, Link, Master Chief, Samus, GTAIII guy (Claude for nerds) and the original DOOM Guy. This <a href="https://vocal.media/gamers/link-the-difference-between-silent-protagonists-and-blank-slates">short and sweet piece</a> by Mimo Le Singe coins the term “Flexible Slate” for this type of character. The player is aware of the type of character they are meant to be, but the precise expression of that premise is left to the players imagination. In both cases the more space a character leaves for the player to fill, either with themselves or with their own interpretations, the more ownership players take over the character.</p><p>The players imagination is a pure extension of themselves, which means they either fill the blank space with their perfect interpretation or allow it to remain as untainted potential — something that no tangible choice can ever compete with. A great example of this is the horror genre, where very few monsters will ever be as scary as the tension of the unseen thing scratching in the ventilation shafts. You might argue that one of the biggest struggles of bringing back a beloved protagonist from the mascot age is that players have already forged a unique image of these characters in the blank space left around them in their original appearances. Back when characters only really expressed themselves in their box-art poses and the flair of their jump animations, leaving the player to do the rest. Just think how disturbing it is when they let a previously silent cartoon character talk: it’s never the voice we imagined they would have.</p><p>An interesting extension of the Flexible Slate approach is when the character’s real self is shrouded in armor, essentially faceless. This both renders them a suit that anyone can wear, and helps elevate them from mortals into symbols. When it comes to the Master Chief or DOOM Slayer, the reflective visor is more their face than any face we care to see. Every look under the helmet teased by fan artists and extended universe material is a guaranteed disappointment, just like the cartoon mouse’s voice.</p><h4>Response Time</h4><p>So while some players may arrive to your game with a certain predisposition, there are clearly ways we can coax them towards different types of immersion. My going theory is that the type of empathy and amount of kinestheic projection the player feels is actually fluid and their relationship with the protagonist (and by extension, the world itself) is constantly fluctuating from scene to scene, and even second to second.</p><p>For example: Any time the game reduces or takes away player control over the character, their projection is interrupted and the division between them is increased. This can range from cutscenes where the player is temporarily put into a traditional audience role, to the times when we find our health bars at risk waiting for our character to complete an animation; such as gulping down a health potion, or waking up from a long stun state. Even in times the character is slowed down by digital injury, the loss of responsiveness prevents us from completing our kinestheic projection. Instinctively in these moments, we find ourselves yelling at our character, demanding they do THEIR part.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*SFlQQWpn5B9Kgwzccx8Daw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The time a player is most likely to inhabit the character is during a high engagement flow state, where the character nearly disappears behind the urgency of our choices and the immediacy of their responses. A high-octane action scene in a Good Game will dance between these states, giving and taking back control like a pressure release valve. In fact, waiting for character animations like finishing moves can provide vital pacing and payoff to intense action sequences, assuming that they are risk free. For example in the Arkham Quadrilogy (Origins counts!) we fluctuate between the choices of being Batman; aiming every punch and choosing every target, versus watching Batman execute choreographed takedowns.</p><h4>Zero to Hero</h4><p>Video game and media scholar <a href="https://medium.com/@DocSeuss">Doc Burford</a> pointed me towards the concept of <a href="https://people.uwec.edu/ranowlan/suture.html">Suture Theory</a>. In film this refers to the extent to which audiences will immerse themselves in the imaginary reality of a fiction and allow the apparatus that enables them to experience the world e.g. the camera, screen, controller, to become temporarily invisible. This is a mutual contract between the audience and the fiction, which can be broken by either side. Projecting ourselves through the controller is part of this, but in all media there must also be a willingness to accept the conceit of its stakes if we are to empathize with its inhabitants.</p><p>At this point, I have started to imagine the players empathetic relationship with the playable character as a gradient of immersion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*B2S_197g5cHsYdnoazy_FA.png" /></figure><p>On one side the player refuses to interface with the game world as anything but a game, their relationship with the characters remains one of an observer puppeteering their avatar as a vehicle through the games events. On the other side the player accepts suturing into the world and accepts a role within it, attempting as best they can to treat the fictional stakes as “real” and react to them accordingly. Somewhere between are those who build relationships with the world and characters, embracing the fictional reality enough to invest emotionally in the journey, but maintaining the objectivity of the observer.</p><p>At a certain depth of immersion, the characters will become real enough for the player to care for their well-being within the fantasy, and then eventually real enough for the player to recognize as an entity of their own that they are working alongside against the games challenges. When we are yelling at a character to complete an animation, we might be a user blaming a faulty tool, or a team-mate demanding his companion to pull his weight. I think the teamwork stage is often felt acutely during that dance between states, as you lead the character from moment to moment, passing the baton to them for the scripted feats beyond your controller mapping.</p><h4>The Superman Problem</h4><p>Those who embrace high immersion role-playing either as a central satisfaction of gaming, or as their responsibility as an interactive audience member, find themselves with another choice. One option is to act as themselves placed in this fictional situation; applying their real judgement and morals to the stories challenges. This is the ultimate wish fulfillment: getting to test if thrust into this role (and a suitably skilled/athletic body) you would be able to make the right choices and be the hero. The other type of role-playing is attempting to be consistent with a fictional construct, taking the role of an improv actor in a grand virtual play.</p><p>Playing a game like Mass Effect, the first type of role-player aka The Insert, would likely find themselves with a mix of karma points and some frustration about Shepherd’s oft-questionable interpretation of their dialogue choices, whereas the second type, The Actor, would do pure Paragon/Renegade play-through’s, embracing an “existing” version of Shepherd. Which I would argue is farther down the chart from full immersion, as it is inherently acknowledging the authorship of the writing. A really powerful example of this dichotomy is the hypothetical Superman game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mnuf3WXbRWCbEb1VaSrpVg.jpeg" /></figure><p>If you are role-playing as Superman, does that mean you are “you” with Superman’s powers and responsibilities, or is it your role to behave consistently with Superman’s existing traits and embrace his beliefs as your own for the duration of the game? “What Would I do if I was Superman” V “What would Superman do?” Basically what I’m asking is: should you be allowed to laser eye people in half? Another genius Twitter contemporary, Mr <a href="https://twitter.com/WritNelson">Xalavier Nelson Jr.</a> wrote an <a href="https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/3bk43j/why-hasnt-anyone-made-a-great-superman-game?">article </a>about the Superman problem which prods at this same topic, the potential clash of role-playing and agency.</p><h4>Shared Experiences</h4><p>Going back to the concept of characters as vessels for the player, one way to reduce any potential friction between the player’s desire and the character’s nature, is to align their motivations. I think the purest form of this are protagonists who already embody the players own reason for playing. They want what the player wants, and they enjoy what the player enjoys.</p><p><em>Devil May Cry</em>’s Dante loves killing demons, and doing it in the most over the top, stylistic and show-offy way possible. In a game about racking up points with unnecessary flair and variety, we play the ultimate showman. One of my favorite things in both the <em>Tomb Raider</em> Reboot and Remedy’s <em>Control</em>, is how during those games Lara and Jesse both discover their passions — exploring ancient tombs and being up to her eyeballs in trippy weird stuff, respectively. Their motivation is the same as the one that led us to pick up their stories in the first place, so their enthusiasm resonates deeply with us. Although they are actively expressing personalities and are thus separate to us, it helps us slip into that care-taking and teamwork mindset — itself quite far down the immersion graph. Arguably exactly as far as most linear third person narratives hope to take the player.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uuDc7WHcEbuOszPeoCdPbw.jpeg" /></figure><p>A near perfect example of aligning the player and their vessel is <em>DOOM 2016’s </em>DOOM Slayer. Critics celebrated <em>DOOM 2016</em> for its all killer no filler philosophy, actualized in the Slayer’s literal rejection of any narrative depth or information dumps that the game (or Samuel) attempted to push his way. When someone picks up <em>DOOM</em>, they don’t want to be lectured on space station schematics or asked to handle stuff with care: they want to shoot some demons in the face. And that’s exactly what the Slayer wants to do. This allows the Slayer to be the perfect vessel for the player, a total alignment of motivation and character. Further, in-universe the Slayer represents the gold standard of demon killing, and as such acts as both wish fulfillment and a goal. We are simultaneously being him and striving to be him. The same might be said for many of our most totemic video game heroes and superhero simulators: when we slip out of their shoes and see them on-screen, we are reminded of what we want to feel and it only spurs us back into the role again.</p><p>If your protagonist is going to have motivations beyond those that reflect the player’s own, the best strategy is to ensure that they are introduced to both the character and player at the same time. The aforementioned <em>Skyrim </em>Dragonborn has seemingly no memory or history, all their motivations are introduced to the player at the same time as the character. In <em>Fallout 4</em> the protagonist is almost an empty vessel, except that they enter the wasteland with the central motivation to avenge their murdered spouse and find their missing child. To help ensure players share this motivation, the opening has the player spend a short time with the Sole Survivor’s family; having them experience first-hand a slice of their idyllic pre-apocalypse life, and the helplessness of watching their spouse be murdered and their child stolen from behind frozen glass.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M2vqPoiBlDmIztRkT5bZHg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The opening is exceptionally brief, so it’s fairly unlikely to grow a bond meaningful enough for this twist to really hurt, but however shallow that connection to the Sole Survivor’s family might be, it’s relatable because it happened not just to the character, but to the player too. When I did get my opportunity to confront my digital wife’s killer, I definitely detected some extra satisfaction in the overkill of firing a miniature nuke into his face.</p><p>In DOOM Eternal, the Slayer’s backstory becomes more prominent; pushing deeply unrelatable lore about being indoctrinated into a warrior clan on an alien planet and old grudges from events that the player wasn’t even present for. Further, they introduce a motivation that I personally didn’t share: saving humanity. There are versions of humanity I would strive to save, but not DOOM’s deeply cynical pastiche of it. This leads to a much greater division between the player and Slayer where we might share motivations on a gameplay level, but would separate for any story beats. This is literally realized in the transition to third person during cutscenes, kicking the player out of the character into the audience for any major narrative moments.</p><p>When as players we are forced to deal with the consequences of a backstory we don’t share, or of decisions we would not have made, it pushes us farther apart. When we experience things together, we understand the character more and are more likely to root for them to succeed, there is even a chance we will echo the characters feelings and want the same things — not just for them, but for ourselves. If we find ourselves immersed enough to feel like we are protecting or allied with the character, working towards the same goal or helping them towards theirs, we start to feel a bond close to loyalty. When we accompany a character throughout the entire journey of a 8–30 hour game, through narrative beats both scripted and emergent, that bond is likely to become very strong.</p><h4>The Last of Us and Loyalty</h4><p>Upon release, <em>The Last of Us: Part 2 </em>was hit with a wave of toxicity, leaving any meaningful discourse awash in a sea of hate and anger. The vast majority of this mess came from the disingenuous agendas of console warriors and the Hitler youth, but among the angry were also genuine fans of the original left frustrated and bewildered by Part 2’s narrative choices, specifically its treatment of the original games protagonists; Joel and Ellie. The original game resonated powerfully with players because it managed to make them relate to the games characters and align with their motivations; it spends a lot of time trying to get players to understand Joel and fostering a mutual protectiveness over Ellie. As the player, we experience Joel’s defining loss alongside him, much like the opening of <em>Fallout 4. We </em>are then present for the building of his relationship with Ellie, and thus we ourselves build one with her. What’s so impressive about the end of <em>TLOU </em>is that it had a HUGE number of players rooting for Joel, despite the objective immorality of his actions. I would argue that is a triumph of immersion and alignment. Yet if <em>TLOU </em>is about alignment of player and playable character, <em>TLOU2 </em>is about the opposite.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K_tCpwjzjWC8hWJtSzqCEw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>TLOU2 </em>subverts these existing relationships by introducing a new perspective, a character that is antagonistic towards Joel and Ellie, and yet treating their perspective as valid. The game then asks players to actually take the role of this new character, and actively work against the goals of the original protagonists. Given the deep resonant loyalty that the first game strives to create, demanding players turn on these characters in order to progress creates a strong conflict of interest that strikes to split the very core of a returning players relationship with the franchise. As the game continues, it becomes apparent that <em>TLOU2 </em>is weaponizing these difficult feelings, and many analyses of <em>TLOU2</em>’s themes have identified that misaligning the player and playable character is clearly intentional. The story offsets the players growth and perception of the world with that of the characters they must play, who are always one tragic step short of making a better choice.</p><p>However, this tactic only works if players are willing to step away from the symbiotic relationship the first game created and assume a more traditional audience perspective. Any returning fan who clings to their old loyalties or refuses to take that step away from their trench-level view of the fantasy, will never be able to forgive the game (or its new characters) for the betrayal of their meta allegiances. <em>TLOU2 </em>perhaps underestimates that success of its first game in building those allegiances, and the 7 years thereafter that fans had to distill and ferment them.</p><h4>Out of Sight, Out of Mind</h4><p>A common belief within the 3C community is that the cameras literal closeness to a character directly correlates to how close players feel to that character. Ranging from viewing them with the detachment of the God’s eye (meta) to peering directly out of their skull, literally submerged inside their perspective. In between these extremes, the over-the-shoulder revolution has consistently experimented with new ways to hug the player characters movements as closely as possible, clearly hungry for the total immersion of first person but unwilling to give up the last vestige of connection to the on-screen protagonist. After all, it is highly possible in FPS games for players to actually forget what their character looks like, or never find out… especially given the general unavailability of reflective surfaces in most digital worlds.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F99QRurWEk1eqwuPykrMJw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Fascinating that the camera coming so close that it absorbs the playable character into the player risks the character itself being forgotten, while pulling the camera so far out that the playable characters become chess pieces limits our ability to connect with them. Following the idea of my gradient; maximum immersion actually leads players to replace the character. This is basically just another way for the player to usurp the vessel, regardless of how empty it is.</p><p>Going back to my Twitter poll, there was a place everyone agreed that they were acting as themselves: Multiplayer. Without any narrative context to the player goals, pretty much everyone discarded all pretense of role-play and rather than inhabiting a role in the fantasy - they are again themselves, playing a video game. It’s an easy assumption to make that once there are real people present (even hidden inside virtual avatars) we become much more reluctant to lose ourselves in the fantasy. There’s probably some psychological principle at play that I don’t know the name of, but in short: we ensure we treat the world as real so as not to embarrass ourselves. This circles back to the idea of the “avatar” as the in-game characters simply become cosmetic shells for our real selves to walk the game world in.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fNuHtvpcBphnPZ4yLYvShw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Strangely, the avatar was a concept not from the low immersion end of my original graph, but near the empathetic height, where without the baggage of an established character to clutter their role-play, players might enter the fantasy as themselves. Yet one step further, and they have walked right out of the fiction. Whereas the fully fleshed out and even “Flexible Slate” characters have their own weight and attachment to the fiction, a fully customized or absorbed character has no value, and therefore becomes too thin a skin to hold us in our role, or suture ourselves into the narrative. After all, how many of us have used those anatomical sliders to create a laughable freak of nature just as silly as a <em>Fortnite </em>Banana Spy. Thus we arrive at the unsurprising conclusion that it actually helps our immersion for the game to provide us an existing character perspective deeply anchored to the narrative, to ensure we don’t drift too far back to the real world. Although a perspective too different from our own can push us away from empathy, no perspective at all gives us nothing to hold on to.</p><p>“I am me in the game” and “I am me playing the game” are only one degree of separation apart. So, perhaps my immersion graph is now an immersion ring?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9TQHdtL7LFaXm1XcKDKPHw.png" /></figure><p>Increasingly contrived graphs aside, I think the proximity of these states is largely further testament to the speed at which players can change their empathetic state. This was ultimately a somewhat clumsy journey of discovery, but the topic is fascinatingly fluid, just like the relationship itself. When starting a game project, or making any choices thereafter, consider what role you want the player to take — and whether you are doing enough to help them accept that role.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=97f4701f273b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[HP and Other Drugs]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stethornton6/hp-and-other-drugs-cb8476b19054?source=rss-1d66cdb4449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cb8476b19054</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[games-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[doom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-games-industry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stethornton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 May 2020 19:51:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-21T19:51:02.208Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Crafting Gameplay with Incentives</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gs0i5acZVstZy3Uqgc3uLw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Last month a Twitter thread asked what it would look like if all the wisdom of contemporary games design had to be contained in a single tweet. My first answer was that it would be a bit like the found footage from Event Horizon, but then I decided to actually try a real answer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/606/1*3nHUQEhvO7jleBgPY75qOg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Games Design: Thinking of things for players to do and then making them do those things. Numbers four and five are key. Games designers have to put a lot of work in to encouraging the “right” play styles — the ones where players use all the toys they’ve been given and engage in activities that feel good — and discouraging them from the “wrong” play styles — such as not doing any of that, and winning through dull repetitive tactics. Players buy a game expecting to enjoy themselves, but faced with any of a games challenges: they play to win. The most common dissonance between these two goals is when the safest or most effective way to win isn’t enjoyable. It’s a contradiction, but players will often sacrifice fun for victory.</p><p>Games designers have many ways to lure players away from this self sabotage, sometimes by <a href="https://medium.com/@stethornton6/your-own-best-enemy-6509e5e06879">tuning the challenges themselves to demand the correct behavior</a>— the proverbial stick — and other times with strategic use of positive incentives — the proverbial carrot.</p><h4>Safety First</h4><p>Regenerating health all but replaced traditional static health systems for nearly a decade. There are many design advantages to regenerating health — primarily it is good for compartmentalizing encounters and enabling short bursts of risk taking — but it also incentivized a lot of very boring behaviors. Retreating, hiding, waiting, all suddenly extremely effective combat tactics. In combination with the popularization of stop-and-pop cover systems, players were able to indulge in that most tempting of vices: caution.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*FrQ1oIlwTUCuUPKZZmEUQw.gif" /></figure><p>Winning means defeating the games challenges and losing only happens when all potential to win is erased, aka: death. Which is why players keep being alive as the very foundation of their play style, even more important than the actions that would take them closer to the winning. This aversion to death and damage creates a “safety first” approach where players seek the minimum amount of risk.</p><p>Since players are so obsessed with survival, the most powerful incentive in the game designers toolbox, is Health™. A games health system almost always defines the way it is played and players are never more single-minded than when they’re running low on the stuff; it’s the closest thing to hunger you can make a player feel. HP, Hit points, hearts, medi-packs, potions, trash turkey — whatever form it takes, players will do what it takes to get it. In regenerating health systems, that thing is usually running away and waiting in cover.</p><h4>The Best Defense</h4><p><em>DOOM (2016) </em>broke the mold with their philosophy of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2KQNpQD8Ayo">Push Forward Combat</a>. In the heat of battle the only place to get more health is from a kill. And not just any kill, the most up close and personal kill of all — a <em>Glory Kill — </em>DOOM’s melee range finishing moves that literally pull the player towards the demons. When low on HP the player is actually incentivized to participate in the battle <em>more </em>rather than retreat from it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*DWNaLzlghdzLzK24hlG49Q.gif" /></figure><p>Design discussions about energetic shooters like <em>Halo </em>and <em>DOOM </em>often refer to the “dance” and a big job of the incentives is dragging people to the dance floor; close enough to the enemies for players to be strafing around attacks, pushing enemy positions, controlling and shifting territory: the fun stuff.</p><p>Remedy’s weird and wonderful <em>Control </em>knows that its infinite guns and throwables might tempt players to hover on the arena edge relying on chip damage, never committing to a space. To lure players onto its dance floor, <em>Control </em>sprinkles it with lil’ health shards. When enemies are damaged they shed health items like loose change, but for players to collect they need to advance to the enemies position. They need to enter the dance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*kxc2vh5hn9w3VsWgVDXYqA.gif" /></figure><p>Gorgeous pixel-art boss rusher <em>Eldest Souls</em> (<a href="https://store.steampowered.com/app/1108590/Eldest_Souls/">releasing later this year</a>) has a clever mechanic called Bloodthirst that converts impacts from your fully charged slashes into health. The players strongest attack is also how they heal, providing a potent comeback machine.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*mXSnlSf2BnijN7sEsJiYTQ.gif" /></figure><p>Crunchy goth-em-up <em>Bloodborne </em>also monetizes aggression with their game-changing Rally mechanic. After taking a hit players can see the potential injury highlighted on their health bar, but before it drains away for real they can attempt to refill it with the blood of their enemies. In order to avoid feeling the hit they needed to strike back immediately, blood for blood. Retreating means accepting the full damage, which shakes up the risk reward dynamic significantly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*RFJocGmw7Sf74aroWil-Xw.gif" /></figure><p><em>Streets of Rage 4</em> has a similar regain mechanic. Special attacks in the original Rage-filled streets cost health — so I basically never used them. Health was too precious to waste on winning. In this years long-belated sequel, specials don’t cost health immediately; instead they highlight a deficit that can be recouped with hits on enemies or confirmed real by any actual damage, making every special a gamble on yourself going at least one combo without a scratch.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*MUus1w9Ry_HItvjSpbjesw.gif" /></figure><h4>In Case of Emergency, Break Vase</h4><p>Players learn that in old school games like Streets and <em>Legend of Zelda </em>that during boss battles there will be extra health hidden in the arena dressing. The resulting action from this system is players breaking away from battle to slip their finger over to the item button or scrounge extra hearts from the ring-side pottery.</p><p>Item based healing inspires strategy; the risk reward gamble of choosing when to use one of your items and finding a safe window to gobble it down. Although this can also be a retreat from the intended activities of the fight, these are at least interesting, assertive choices with player input from launch to completion, and the finite supply limits repetition.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*1xr_GlKPd5H4a41wOzVkfQ.gif" /></figure><p>The availability of these items has a big impact on the players choices. FromSoftware has experimented a lot with the details of their genre-spawning Souls series, with seemingly small tweaks to their incentives having a butterfly effect on the player behavior. <em>Dark Souls</em> refills the players Estus Flask at every checkpoint allowing them to swig confidently, whereas <em>Demon Souls’</em> healing grass is a fickle resource that players are anxious to spend.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*JYMLGkwZG0X6vflPjp8AyA.gif" /></figure><p>Players holding onto their best items in preparation for some unseen future challenge that may never come is a well-known trope, so providing guaranteed refill locations can help encourage players to actually use their items without completely eradicating all tension and strategy from that choice.</p><h4>Always Be Prepared</h4><p>The other supply that players are most acutely aware of after Life Itself, are the resources that enable taking action and actually defeating the games challenges; ammo for their guns, magic for their spells, buffs for their stats. A shortage of these can also put players in a more cautious mindset or inspire a detour.</p><p><em>DOOM Eternal</em> expanded on 2016’s idea of tying health to kills by tying all the key resources to different abilities — when the paired resource runs low, it triggers players to use that ability. This is one of the ways Eternal is tuned to demand players vary their play style. Even though the chainsaw and flamethrower are very effective (and very cool) they are easily forgotten in the whirlwind of demon-slaying without the reminder of low ammo and armor bars.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*dbqnKccwUouCh3yW0F1CFw.gif" /></figure><p>Conversely, to ensure players neither hoard nor spam these useful abilities and their related resources, they are tied to cool-down meters — so players can use them confident there is always more where that came from, but after every usage they have a window of time where they need to look elsewhere in their toolbox. This clever push and pull away from individual abilities makes variety an essential part of any successful <em>DOOM Eternal</em> play style.</p><p><em>Control </em>does something similar by placing its two primary offensive abilities on separate cool-downs and goes a step further by having them overheat if used too much without a break. This not only encourages swapping back and forth, but punishes not swapping often enough. Those who wait until high heat to swap will find themselves stuck in one ability set at a time, while players who dance between the two resources constantly will likely never find themselves cut off from either — a versatility that becomes necessity as the games encounters get tougher.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*wS_AuFhdPcG8NFNdeMMvdw.gif" /></figure><h4>Faster Better Stronger</h4><p>Once players are comfortable with their health and resources they are more willing to risk them on less vital rewards. There is the classic risk reward scenario of a desirable item visible on the other side of some intimidating hazard. The very first risk a comfortable player takes is engaging with the game as intended — the very first reward is defeating them faster. High-caution play styles like hit-and-run or long-range chipping take a lot longer than playing properly so the first reward felt by the player once they get their dancing shoes on — is time. Fights that would be a slog from cover burn bright and fast in the arena.</p><p>Rocksteady’s <em>Arkham Quadrilogy</em> (we respect <em>Origins </em>in this house) has a really great combat system that can be played in an embarrassingly dull way. Most of us will be compelled to strive for flawless combos, which the game highly encourages by increasing the speed and damage of your attacks, awarding special moves and upgrading your counters into take-downs. Longer combo strings actually increase Batman’s effectiveness and make it easier to defeat enemies. Take-downs are definitely faster than punching.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*KKYtBEoJqsXsP1PrgQXBIQ.gif" /></figure><p>Yet I have seen friends mash through Arkham ignoring the counter prompts, I have seen flatmates pause to wait for each counter, never reaching the momentum necessary to evolve the animations from schoolyard pushing and shoving into bone-breaking. Extra power and faster kills wasn’t enough to lure them away from repetition and waiting. Nor apparently was some innate sense of dignity. Using Batman’s gadgets in combat has an even weaker incentive — scoring. Including gadgets in a combo adds little modifiers that juice up the players combat score. However, most aren’t directly paired with any particular enemy types and feel very much like optional flair.</p><p>Games with very high skill ceilings often want to lure players into engaging with their more advanced mechanics while still leaving them optional. The most common technique here is with a rating system. Players with weaker play styles can still pass the games challenges, but are slapped with F grades, dunce caps and coal for Christmas — while high ratings usually pay out dividends in the form of praise, currency and experience.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*KT3lyQGlHoiyo8hkaGxO6w.gif" /></figure><p>Currency and experience are the most common incentive in the game world, with small amounts of each littered behind every corner and ornament, sprinkled on every surface and traversal route. In the environment where the question is reward or no reward at all, players are loathe to leave any behind — but the value is far more obscured in a scoring system dolling out less or more based on granular performance.</p><p>The only players who will change their play style to get a little extra sauce are those who are already secure in their ability to win. Most other people are going to continue doing whatever gets them past the challenges, and accepting whatever amount the game provides afterwards.</p><p>Weekly challenges, sub-objectives and achievements that ask players to get X kills with every gun and such, are similar last ditch attempts to encourage players toward features the designer fears they might be neglecting. These also link to the final incentive — pride. After survival, security, efficiency and a full skill-tree, the only thing left is mastery, and all the badges and back-pats that it warrants. The intrinsic reward of being damn good at this game and knowing it. The highest rating, the max grade, the big trophy. And yes, the extrinsic bling that immortalizes those accomplishments is part of it. When there are no more lands to conquer, what players seek is a big hat that only the people who conquered every land get to wear.</p><h4>Hierarchy of Wants</h4><p>For a gag, I arranged these games design incentives in the pyramid format of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Human Needs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YJSQo5GdIt20hTbFMSu0oQ.png" /></figure><p>This was intended to just be a tongue-in-cheek cover picture for this article but after I built it I noticed that some of the tiers in my gamer pyramid actually lined up with some of the tiers from the real thing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZIs23m4NEIyA5HTJZ81CkQ.png" /></figure><p>In both pyramids the foundational layer is physiological well-being: staying alive. The second layer up is security, which is very similar to the resources players need to feel secure in their ability to face the games challenges.</p><p>Hilariously my combat design focused pyramid offers more efficient murder methods as layer 3 while humanity’s pyramid looks for love and belonging. <em>What a fitting treatise on the medium.</em> Not that games can’t offer love and belonging; it’s just rarely a primary motivator at the gameplay level. It’s pretty rare for success within a games challenges to correlate directly to the games digital relationships (outside of when progressing them is a by-product of progressing through the games challenges) and though socializing and connection in the real world is extremely possible through games, it doesn’t usually come up in a boss fight.</p><p>Just like in the real chart though, the pyramid shifts to intrinsic desires towards the tip. Currency and experience are self-actualization in the digital; the sense of growth, power and progress — literally your character becoming the best “you”, while the tip of my pyramid represents Mastery aka the player’s self-actualization. Which funnily enough converts to esteem and recognition in the form of bragging rights and bling.</p><h4>Flattening the Pyramid</h4><p>The point of Maslow’s Hierarchy is that people only seek the needs on the higher tiers once they have satisfied the base-line requirement of the lower ones. When HP gets low, all other concerns go on the back-burner until that need is satisfied. Players won’t indulge in full-throated combat or optional flair until they feel secure in their ability to survive, regardless of what shineys you offer in return. Unless of course, you make full-throated combat and flair the only route to fulfilling those needs.</p><p>As a games designer, your smartest move will be making sure that the fun way to play, the safest way to play, and the most effective way to play, are all the same thing. Where did you hide the HP?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cb8476b19054" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Remake of the King]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stethornton6/remake-of-the-king-6227c96eff93?source=rss-1d66cdb4449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6227c96eff93</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[video-games-industry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[doom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[final-fantasy-vii]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[remakes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stethornton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Apr 2020 14:30:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-21T15:36:09.491Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Gameplay as good as you remember it to be</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/967/1*FI92S1I4VwqhK0t9ksgkeg.png" /></figure><p>In the last decade, our pop culture has become increasingly fueled by nostalgia for the blurry gems of a collective youth; a cross-generational soup of nerve endings located loosely between the mid-70s and late-90’s; oft referred to as “the 80’s”. A surge of reboots, remakes and decades-late sequels has left hundreds of creative teams tasked with recapturing the “magic” of intellectual properties that have long-since been elevated to near mythical status.</p><p>As audience members we only have to experience our entertainment in a very superficial way. Ask most people what they liked about their favorite video games, they’ll usually point to favorite characters, “art style”, “the story”, or generic praise like “it was cool/funny/scary”. Audiences remember the impact of big moments, the reveals and twists, what they felt from that impact. As consumers we are not required to dissect or articulate why something is cool or funny or impactful and we certainly don’t need to know how it was achieved in order to enjoy it.</p><p>Take that already shallow extract, ferment it for two decades, and details melt into sensations. The soup of feelings; media intermingled with the ambiance of a lost time — rich with a purer form of stability, calm and happiness than is achievable in any present tainted with the anxieties of an unknown future… which is pretty much all of them. Though farther than ever from articulating what made us fall in love with these worlds and characters, they are empowered as totems that can briefly transport us to that well of contentment. This is one advantage that remakes and reboots have in their favor. The act of remembering itself becomes pleasurable, every familiar hum and click from the soundbank enough to evoke a lick of sentiment.</p><p>Unfortunately, winks and nods are not enough to keep your audience transported to that other place. Call backs are how the present self looks back on how they felt in the past — the goal of a remake, reboot or long-belated sequel is to recreate that feeling in the present. To do that, they must genuinely recreate what made us like the thing in the first place. This presents a problem, because while the returning audiences esteem for the original is immortalized, their expectations for the medium have evolved. The most beloved properties inevitably become the building blocks on which contemporary releases stand. Their innovations become industry standard, and are soon displaced by further innovation. So, you can’t just do the same thing again. Industry leaders cannot return to us as followers. The only way to bring back a pioneering, genre-defining classic, is to do something new.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nnUSGrL1rLsA3CCjOd7bww.jpeg" /></figure><p>The original <em>Final Fantasy VII (1997)</em> featured a system called Active Time Battle or ATB which is a variation of turn-based combat where action gauges for both the player and enemy fill in realtime, and then its a race to push your actions into the queue. This simultaneously created a sense of time pressure and provided regular downtime for planning. It also put the player and enemies on even footing. Although some encounters changed the formation as a novelty, your characters were all rooted to the spot and only perked up to execute your commands: battles were primarily about rationing your actions between outputting damage and keeping your party healthy (a constantly fluid evaluation) as well as arranging your actions so that the most urgent arrived first. Outside of battle you shared out spells and abilities in the form of “materia”, character agnostic items that could be assigned to weapon and equipment slots — allowing you to hand-craft the roles each party member would play in battle. The game had a rhythm of downtime and action, preparation meeting adaptation.</p><p>Over the years the Final Fantasy franchise has experimented with many hybrids of menu-based and realtime combat, with the ratio skewing farther into the latter with nearly every entry. The <em>Final Fantasy VII Remake (2020) </em>technically has a fully realtime combat system, with all standard attacks, movement and blocking occurring in a full third person action environment. At first I was sure this would leave the game incapable of recreating the rhythm of the original, but while the battle rages in realtime, the most powerful attacks and healing abilities are still only available with an ATB charge, which means that the player still finds themselves building their strategy around their next available character action, still rationing and prioritizing between offense and defense. Evades are tricky and blocks only reduce incoming damage, so it is near guaranteed that your party health will be worn down in encounters, ensuring the importance of heals and buffs, recreating the patterns of attrition and maintenance present in turn-based combat. When choosing your action you are in “tactical mode” which slows time to a crawl but crucially does not stop it completely, imitating the passive-yet-pressured menu-fu of the original.</p><p>Characters now have unique abilities that along with their weapon imply a natural role in combat, but the materia system remains universal, maintaining the players ability to craft the specialties of their own party— either leaning into their natural aptitude or providing them with the versatility of a secondary role. It wasn’t the familiar riffs on the jukebox or the meta gags about victory songs that took me back to 1997. It was waiting for my next ATB bar, tense that the enemies next attack would force me to spend it on a heal. It was tweaking my party build and materia grids after a close call or slim defeat. What is fascinating about FFVIIR is how it is able to recreate the gameplay patterns of the original game within a brand new one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9uLreoldfCIwJZSKV9Af-w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Resident Evil is another franchise that has juggled conflicting gameplay styles. Although <em>Resident Evil (1996) </em>established the survival horror genre for the mainstream, many of the franchises most iconic features — like fixed camera angles, door transitions and “tank” controls —were intrinsic to the technical limitations of the era, and the series has since struggled to balance the impact of contemporary controls and increased action elements on that formula.</p><p>The original<em> Resident Evil 2 (1998) </em>requires the player to stop dead in order to shoot, and to pivot on the spot before they can change position. Combined with the tight spaces and ambiguous health of the zombies, this turns shooting into a tense risk / reward stand-off, where players must stand their ground as the zombies shuffle ever closer, judging when to risk another shot and when to break away to start the possibly greater risk of a 3-point-turn retreat. The <em>Resident Evil 2 remake (2020)</em> has a contemporary over-the-shoulder camera and allows the player to move while aiming and even strafe, but now the player is responsible for lining up their own head shots, a task made deviously tricky by the zombies clumsy, unpredictable gait that keeps their skull bobbing and weaving through the reticule — and in order to tighten their shaky aim to make the best use of their limited bullets, players must again stand still. This cocktail of challenges helps recreate that same risk / reward stand-off, even amidst all the expected contemporary freedoms.</p><p>The claustrophobia of the fixed cameras is provided instead by darkness, with many of the police stations infested areas now lit only by torchlight — though even without that the close shoulder camera does already have its own blind spots for zombies to live in. The remake development team discuss in their <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p84HJt3fMSQ">round table videos</a> that they originally intended to offer a “classic” camera mode with the static angles from the original game. Upon playing the new over the shoulder camera, they quickly decided it wasn’t necessary, the gameplay was no longer dependent on a restricted camera.</p><p>The remake does bring back many aspects verbatim, including the scarcity of resources and inventory management that makes players question every bullet and encourages that vital restraint when gambling on another shot. The pressures, motivations and resultant decision making is the same. What zombies to leave shuffling and which to put down (and how hard) — what route to take back to the safe room and whether to wait for another bite before downing a herb. Despite all the modernizations, it creates the same gameplay patterns as the original and thus, the same mindset in players.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SE4Z16YFiwjdmL6VK2_pwA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>DOOM (2016)</em> is not a direct remake but it had the same task: to bring back one of the mediums most iconic and influential properties into a world it created and yet had no longer had a place in. There is arguably no stronger example of a game whose innovations became standards that <em>DOOM (1993) </em>— so how do you bring back a series whose most exciting features are now the norm? In DOOM’s case, you go back and find the lessons that the medium forgot.</p><p>Game Makers Toolkit (one of my favorite games design channels, for which I am a proud patron) did an episode called “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuOObGjCA7Q">What We can Learn From DOOM</a>”. This video actually came out 3 months before the reboot, but gosh damn if it doesn’t identify exactly the same central gameplay pillars and patterns that the 2016 development team preach openly in their interviews for both 2016’s DOOM and <em>DOOM Eternal (2020)</em>. I won’t discuss Eternal too much here, as it is more a case study in the challenge of sequels, but despite their differences, both modern DOOM games are built on the same central principles: Distinctive enemy types who exert unique pressures to encourage prioritization, and have unique weaknesses to encourage fluid strategy, projectiles over hitscan to emphasize movement — they found the gameplay patterns that create the DOOM mindset.</p><p>DOOM (2016) is also smart enough to understand the feeling in the soup. The average player would not be able to identify the patterns behind it, but they remember the <em>feeling</em>. Shotguns, big guts and heavy metal, hell yeah. You couldn’t use these superficial trappings alone to recreate DOOM, but its a reputation that has only been magnified by the hyperbole of time, and it can be extrapolated into another guiding principle: attitude. DOOM is remembered for gore and aggression, and partially due to technical limitations (and partially due to the memorable, carnal pleasure of shotguns and chainsaws) it is associated with largely close quarters or assault range combat, so the Glory Kill mechanic and “push-forward combat” philosophy ensure that players get the kicks they expect and encourage a play style befitting the series’ attitude— even if it was never actually in the original.</p><p>Following the feeling can backfire when it is confused for the primary driver behind a series, for example how the Sonic the Hedgehog franchise was led astray by the idea that the series was about “going fast”, confusing their own slogan for design principles, but once you identify the actual reasons the series worked and became so beloved, you can also indulge their now exaggerated larger-than-life concept of it.</p><p>Audiences and critics constantly talk about recapturing the “magic” of a series, and of new gameplay with the “feel” and “spirit” of the originals. When you’re tasked with making a remake, or resurrecting a long dormant franchise, you don’t have the luxury of dismissing their defining qualities as long-forgotten magic. <em>Final Fantasy VII</em>, <em>Resident Evil 2</em> and <em>DOOM (2016) </em>are all great examples of identifying the patterns — the pressures, motivations and resultant decision making that happens within the player — and recreating them within systems that match or exceed the expectations of a contemporary audience, while indulging the expectations they have as fans and using that to extend the patterns even farther. That’s not how you get gameplay that’s as good as it used to be “back in the day” — that’s how you get gameplay that’s as good as you remember it to be.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6227c96eff93" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Disco Elysium Forever]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stethornton6/disco-elysium-forever-62ce7d510f46?source=rss-1d66cdb4449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/62ce7d510f46</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[detective]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disco]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rpg]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stethornton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Apr 2020 16:09:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-03T16:10:53.740Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Dice, Drugs and Disco Detectives</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UElGIVxGn-jzO8cMuBJRjQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Me: Man, Disco Elysium rules. I should tell everyone!</p><p>ℙ𝕣𝕒𝕘𝕞𝕒𝕥𝕚𝕤𝕞: “Everyone” already knows, it’s swimming in critical acclaim, might as well spit in the ocean</p><p>ℭ𝔬𝔫𝔫𝔬𝔦𝔰𝔰𝔢𝔲𝔯: But they haven’t heard it the way YOU would say it. Your takes are beautiful and unique</p><p>н𝓔đＯ𝓝𝕀𝓢𝕄: Yeah and it’ll feel good too. Especially if we get some likes</p><p>ℙ𝕣𝕒𝕘𝕞𝕒𝕥𝕚𝕤𝕞: Fine, but if we’re doing this we make it count. Gonna have to reshare this tomorrow to maximize our audience. You’re going to feel like an idiot if you spend an hour on this for nothing</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*a6gZA80qpcgE-198cJKT8w.gif" /></figure><p>Start flexing your inner encyclopedia because I love words nearly as much as Disco Elysium does and there’s a lot of praise to dole out. I wasn’t surprised to find this surreal RPG was as special as the smart people on my social media feeds promised, but playing is believing: Disco Elysium RULES. The writing is swaggeringly potent stuff, swinging from sharp wit and emotional sincerity to delighted surrealism and slapstick with rare, fearless ease. It’s a huge compliment to drop, but dare I say there’s a dash of the Discworld in the Disco.</p><h4>Trick or Trait</h4><p>Disco Elysium’s hook is that the protagonists personality traits haunt his brain like backseat passengers, reaching for the wheel as often as offering aid. Empathy, ego, fashion sense, all subjective lenses that breathe life into the defective detective and his acid-washed world. The personification of traits as competing voices is a brilliant and surprisingly relatable method of replicating the unpredictable domino fall of opinions, feelings and information that can occur in the split second before we make a choice. Having traits act as willful actors with their own agendas is a great replication of how our minds squirm to escape their duty for tangents, and the dangers of letting any one aspect of yourself run wild without the counsel of the others. Some part of us is always running for a cliff edge.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*s5GT10L0F1YNU5FcY-_yXg.png" /></figure><p>Not just a tight summary of the human condition, also a perfect tool for a detective game; the perfect contraption to deliver both slick deductive observations and the beginnings of floating instinctual epiphanies; ranging private dick “gut” solves to dream-walking Lynchian ones. In a traditional game this stream of hints would feel unearned, but because the info provided is determined by the traits the player chose and honed themselves, it feels like an expression of their own style, and often they only expose a thread that still must be carefully pulled — and always at the whim of the dice. Perhaps it’s a symptom of being a developer, but I can almost sense the invisible web of tripwires being pulled and checked as my detective explores the city, and it’s a beautiful machine that I assume must be dizzyingly complicated behind the curtain.</p><h4>Thorny Branches</h4><p>Disco Elysium has done a huge favor to those of us who have long hungered for verbal sparring as gameplay. Intimidation and embarrassment hurts, literally, which makes enemies with sharp tongues as dangerous as those with knives. The pang of pain as your morale drops is visceral. This is the first time in a game that I felt a character had me helpless and outmaneuvered with words alone; my stats slashed, my traits panicking and jostling in my ears, ringing warnings from my health and morale bars — it established the games largest threat without him leaving his chair.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*8RQdDH88M8MS7GWCyDQpkw.gif" /></figure><p>Meanwhile there are times that all it takes is a compliment from the right person to heal your wounds. Again, it’s a great abstraction of how it feels to be alive. The damage people can do to your emotional well-being, the soothing salve and reassurance that can come from the support and kindness of a friend.</p><p>I also really liked how you can modify the challenge of some conversational routes by exploring others first, and how the detectives sometimes seek out privacy before discussing sensitive information. I want more games that take into account strategic role-play choices like that. When I play a branching dialogue game I always choose the order of questions strategically, usually trying to build rapport with softer questions and avoid alienating rudeness that might cut the conversation short, but its rarely rewarded. Disco Elysium recognizes this effort in refreshing ways, but still has a lot of video game in its veins.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KGMZzhHWaUyy3AxX0DASnA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The structure of most conversations is elegant enough that they feel and flow natural on first run, but the game overtly encourages emptying all dialogue options — even the contradictory ones — by hiding xp in unexpected branches. There’s something lost in the ability to retread conversations and try new responses as if you didn’t say the old ones, it unmasks colorful, compelling characters as mechanical excel sheets. On the bright side it does mean that you never know what conversation starter might bear the juiciest fruit, and spotting any new conversational partner is enough to squeeze out a little dopamine — which certainly isn’t true in most RPG’s. Even the least likely tangents have a way of proving useful or pulling you back to the case, which both reveals the impressive narrative network underpinning all the characters and their world, and translates even the most stubbornly irrational player into a surprisingly effective Dirk Gently style holistic detective.</p><h4>Long Live Disco</h4><p>Disco Elysium also has its own approach to time, with the clock only moving with each new interaction and dialogue option. At the start of the game, in concert with the occasional time-specific task, this provides an excellent sense of structure and every in-game day is packed with progress, never worn away on the pavement between choices. At first Revachol seems impossibly packed with content, but by the endgame I found myself struggling with ways to advance the in-game day without returning to previous characters to embarrass myself in the Disaster Cop branches I’d avoided (Kim was watching!). In the end, I read “Secrets of the Pale” many times and drank countless imaginary cure-all’s — this was enough to get me to the last act, where I savored every bubble and branch once again. Though preventing players from wasting their days is vital early on, I wish there was a better way to push the clock when the task list gets sparse on Day 8 or 9.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*oLVO8sj5wgioMDp2TJrEEg.gif" /></figure><p>The endgame also brings higher stakes and a higher bar for the stat checks, with more riding on the dice than ever. As they often do in games, steeper challenges push players to mechanics they might have been neglecting or avoiding, and I’m ashamed to say I hit the drink (ok, and the speed) a few times. Something I’m <em>not </em>ashamed of is turning my handlebar junkie into a classic noir-style Smoking Detective. ZA/UM made the ingenious choice to have nicotine temporarily boost intelligence, and before long I was taking a drag on the crime scenes edge before every big solve. Unfortunately, I did also have to start dressing for the occasion, which was fine when it was just swapping to my slightly larger glasses in preparation for a rigorous debate — slightly less agreeable when I have to put on my string vest and kimono in order to take the karaoke stage. The video game logic is on display there even more than my avatar’s nipples.</p><p>Yet even with chemical enhancements and the power of fashion under your (leopard-skin) belt, you can’t hide from the occasional snake eyes. Did I ever save scum away from a failed 90+% roll? Well, you — the — did you ever consider shutting up?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*lfAO3sXK8NZKfwzQT8peIw.gif" /></figure><p>My largest complaint is probably the frustration of dragging my avatar click-by-click across Revachol when I’m chasing a tasty lead, which I guess is also a backhanded compliment; the character moments are so damn good that I begrudge even the few dozen seconds between them. The inevitable console releases and controller support will of course negate this in the long-term.</p><p>Actually my biggest complaint is that Kim clearly says that he smokes a single cigarette and reflects on the case <em>every </em>night, but seemingly you can only join him for a de-brief there on Day 1? I wanted (needed?) those nightly buddy-cop bonding sessions, ZA/UM. And you know, I think Kim does too.</p><p>….</p><p>𝐒𝐡𝐨𝐰𝐦𝐚𝐧𝐬𝐡𝐢𝐩: Pretty good article, but should have spiced up the tableau with more gifs. People need a little sugar</p><p>Me: There are precious few non-spoilery Disco Elysium gifs</p><p>ℙ𝕣𝕒𝕘𝕞𝕒𝕥𝕚𝕤𝕞: Nevermind that, you’ve been ignoring your work messages for hours, we’re probably fired</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=62ce7d510f46" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Your Own Best Enemy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stethornton6/your-own-best-enemy-6509e5e06879?source=rss-1d66cdb4449------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6509e5e06879</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sekiro]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[boss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[doom]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Stethornton]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Mar 2020 22:21:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-03T11:35:12.137Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Ask not what you can do for your enemies, but what your enemies can do for your player. You might think that enemies exist to challenge the player, but their actual job is to make the player do things. All the obstacles in your game are there to make your player actually use those cool abilities that you gave them, and enemies are just a particularly fancy obstacle. You can tell, because sometimes obstacles are dressed up as an enemy, but are basically just environmental hazards with a face. Particularly complex enemies or bosses are a collection of different obstacles, which makes a boss battle not unlike a level design.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NkQzlXWkW8OlCpL_BjYrpQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The majority of this article will apply to designing either enemies or bosses -because as we know, the difference between the two is often just a matter of timing, fanfare and whether or not a HUD element appears alongside them — but fear not boss battle purists, we’ll have some big bad exclusives later.</p><h4>Codependent Relationships</h4><p>Let’s start with some common sense: anything an enemy can do, the player has to be able to somehow anticipate, and subsequently defend against or avoid. This means two things. Firstly that any attack the enemy can perform must come with a warning (we’ll get back to that later) and secondly — the enemy move list is ultimately determined by the move list of the player.</p><p>If the player can jump, the enemy can perform a shockwave which the player has to jump over. If the player can aim and shoot easily, the enemy can fire projectiles that must be shot out of the air before they reach their target. If the player can already perform a block or dodge, well, this makes creating the enemy move list considerably easier.. but at the very least the player can usually move around, which means the enemy can perform attacks which affect a particular area of the environment and require the player to run around/away.</p><p>By the same token, when an enemy does one of these things, the player must respond with the relevant counter, or they die. Flipping the script, an enemy must have a way to be defeated, and if the player doesn’t do THAT thing — they can’t win and still probably die. Let out your best evil laugh, because you’ve got ’em right where you want ‘em.</p><h4>Safety First</h4><p>So, what do you want the player to do? As a game or level designer, you always have an idea in your head of how you want the player to play. There’s a motto that my friend and I often repeat:</p><p>Given the chance, players will optimize the fun out of their own experience.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*OUzzZkamgNS8b9F2PBOA1A.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Dark Souls</strong> had a “shield” problem. Many Souls players were so reluctant to venture out from behind their shields that they didn’t engage with the dodge mechanics that the designers wanted them to use and ignored most of the games weapon library because they couldn’t be paired with shields. When they made <strong>Bloodborne</strong>, Miyazaki and his team were so acutely aware of this problem that they did away with shields completely and inserted a self-deprecating gag about it — “Shields are nice, but not if they engender passivity”.</figcaption></figure><p>If you want the player to lower their shield, if you want the player to come out of cover, if you want them to dip deeper into their inventory than the highest DPS weapon, you need to make them.</p><p>A lot of this work can be done on the systems side but beyond that enemies are maybe the most powerful method of encouraging the player to do the things you want, or discouraging them from doing things that you <em>don’t </em>want them to be doing.</p><p><em>THINGS </em>you say? Weapons, abilities, mechanics — strategies.</p><h4>Highway to the Fun Zone</h4><p>Huge swathes of this article will be borrowing examples and terminology from Hugo Martin’s <em>DOOM Eternal </em>interviews because they demonstrate an incredibly firm and articulate grasp of what their <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uzX09_4hcPc">enemies</a> and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J5IdHqg2rT8">weapons</a> are for. They talk about pushing the player into the “Fun Zone”. Fun can be a toxic metric without definition, but at id Software they’ve bottled it as a list of key activities (things) they want the player to be doing in their game e.g. moving, swapping weapons, glory kills and prioritizing targets.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ImNhdYvyx4ra5qGJ221B_g.jpeg" /><figcaption>The <strong>Arachnotron </strong>is a mobile turret, the <strong>Archvile </strong>is a summoner, so both demand prioritization. <strong>Whiplash</strong> is low, quick and flanks constantly, so pushes the player around and encourages them to swap to faster weapons. Pushing the player to move is as simple as punishing standing still. The enemies create the play style.</figcaption></figure><p>Every enemy you add to your game should have a role they are intended to play, a pressure they exert onto the player to change how they behave. Simple examples are that an aggressive melee charging enemy will cause the player to retreat, a sniper emplacement will cause them to take cover, a shield will cause them to flank. Low-threat “fodder” enemies are often multi-purpose; both walking resource crates that tempt the player forward, and distractions that lure the players attacks away from other enemy types long enough for them to get their own attacks out.</p><p>In his brilliant <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qBHIalb01ew&amp;feature=youtu.be&amp;t=1">NoClip interviews</a> Mr Martin talks about each enemy type as part of a chess set.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Xx0XzShCouhdhth4n9dpvQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The <strong>Halo </strong>franchise’s Covenant army is one of gaming’s most distinguished rogues galleries. <strong>Grunts </strong>serve as the fodder — <strong>Jackal’s</strong> slow the player push and encourage weaving through cover — <strong>Elites </strong>have regenerating shields, forcing players to commit, chase and pressure them all the way to their last health point, lest they slip away and come back with a full shield again. The intended play style is created by the enemy design.</figcaption></figure><h4>The Right Tool for the Job</h4><p>Martin also mentions a flaw he felt in <em>DOOM (2016) </em>was that the player was not pushed to vary their weapons and strategies outside of the highest modes. Powerful weapons like the Super Shotgun and Rocket Launcher worked in pretty much any scenario, so they saw the lions share of screen-time while other weapons languished in the inventory unless ammo got especially desperate. In <em>DOOM Eternal</em> they want players to see each weapon as a tool that fits specific jobs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CU9IAeNhik4LqClTzpbxQg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The <strong>Plasma Rifle </strong>can overheat and detonate the soldiers enemy shields, while its <strong>microwave beam</strong> can temporarily slow enemies, an ideal strategy against Whiplash. The Combat Shotguns <strong>sticky bomb</strong> mod and the <strong>Horoscope </strong>rifle are especially good at stripping enemy weak points, such as the Arachnotron’s turret.</figcaption></figure><p>“Toolbox” design philosophy is a strong backbone for any combat system and you don’t need to make it complicated for it to land with players.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ENGCEieoPTh68pUzgOQhaw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice </strong>has very clean Toolbox design. Look at the prosthetic library: The <strong>Axe </strong>smashes shields, <strong>Firecrackers </strong>spook animals, <strong>Shurikens </strong>knock jumpers out of the air,<strong> Flame Vent</strong> can set straw (or oil) on fire. Outside the prosthetics — <strong>Swipe </strong>attacks are best jumped over, <strong>Thrust </strong>attacks can be exploited with a special counter, and you can only hurt evil spirits by blessing your sword with <strong>Divine Confetti.</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uuA-HbsTZeRzPnpdAZeQaw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ninja Theory’s <strong>DmC (2013) </strong>had a pretty draconian approach — literally coloring some enemies blue or red and having them only take damage from the matching weapons. This wasn’t a great fit for a game that simultaneously encouraged weapon swapping through its style bar, but <strong>Destiny </strong>does something similar with color coded shields without any complaints.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qDdJzLDFdwdvyAMcEM0kNg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The <strong>Arkham Quadrilogy</strong> (we respect Origins in this house) has a color coded warning system, where Batman can counter any standard punches and kicks, but <strong>blade </strong>carrying enemies require you to pull back at the same time to dodge, electric weapons like <strong>stun batons</strong> require you to jump over their heads first, <strong>shield </strong>guys you need to use your cape stun, <strong>gunmen </strong>you need to prioritize them and possibly stun with a projectile</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*C2i47UbUcISIeg7iMb2lxg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Halo </strong>premises that plasma weapons are more effective at stripping energy shields while kinetic is better at flesh and armor. The <strong>Pokemon </strong>battle system is entirely based on a literal chart of corresponding weaknesses. At its simplest, the toolbox can be as simple as a light and heavy attack where only the heavy can break through blocks and shields, such as in <strong>Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers</strong> and one million other games</figcaption></figure><p>The premise is simple: Establish a relationship between an obstacle and a tool (player ability). Give the obstacle an extremely clear and consistent identifier, and let the player read that information and choose the right tool. Pick almost any game and you can probably identify these relationships clearly. Some studios refer to this set-up as “combat puzzles” and it’s a huge part of encounter design, which is when your enemy types start to mix. If it sounds familiar, it’s probably because -as promised- it’s a lot like level design. See for example: the <em>Tomb Raider</em> reboot trilogy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XUtdW6X0IRyoPF0ZpUtDEw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Shotguns smash<strong> light wood</strong>, Fire burns <strong>white cloth</strong>, Rope arrows can create paths from specific <strong>roped posts</strong>, you can attach to<strong> craggy walls</strong> with your climbing axe if you hold a certain button when you throw Lara against them. In the games blockbuster set pieces, the player is asked to apply their knowledge of these toolbox relationships at high speed.</figcaption></figure><p>It works because of the obstacles come with a strong and consistent visual language. This doesn’t need to be as overt as color coding or repeating a single specific prop — Lara’s shotgun can smash any light wood structure, flames can burn anything swathed in white cloth. Sekiro’s axe can smash shields of various shapes and sizes, but also the large bamboo rice-hats that those pesky “Rats” wear — the fireworks can scare any animal from boar to horse to crow. Batman needs to use his blade counter whether it’s a broken bottle or a samurai sword. The trick is that once you establish the rule, it must be consistent enough that players can internalize the rule and apply it with total confidence.</p><p><strong>Sound the Alarm</strong></p><p>Just like how every category in your rule-set needs a consistent language, so must every enemies attack list. We’re back onto cues and telegraphing now. We won’t linger here long, because it’s basic combat design: you need to give the player a way to predict when an attack is about to happen so that they can pick the right reaction.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*39n4K9CA1k8rC31JUt6QVw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Pictured: <strong>Arkham Asylum</strong>’s counter warning, the Peter Tingle from <strong>Marvel’s Spider-Man </strong>and a charging tail laser from the <strong>Final Fantasy 7 Remake </strong>demo</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Visual: </strong>This can be as simple as an enemy glowing a particular color, raising a poised claw, or adopting a pounce stance. It is a few moments (or frames) that precede the part of the attack which actually hurts. Sometimes designers cheat and have a universal cue for all enemies, such as a tingly spider sense around the protagonists head, or a button prompt that pops up somewhere on screen.</p><p><strong>Audio: </strong>Cast your mind back over any boss AI pattern you have ever memorized and you’ll find that those annoying things they kept saying or noises they kept making were actually paired with a specific attack. Essentially the enemy sounds off with a particular noise or phrase immediately before the attack, and the player can learn that this audio cue is attached to a particular action the enemy is about to perform and prepare accordingly. This is essential for any enemies who might come at the player from off-screen, where most visual cues don’t do anyone any good.</p><p><strong>Pattern: </strong>Some attacks have very little warning of their own, because they always follow one of the bosses other attacks, or always occur in response to a specific player action or position; such as an attack they will always do if the player gets up close, or when the player has been knocked onto their back by another move. The player learns where these attacks will occur from trial and error, so it’s important there’s no randomness involved in a low-cue attack.</p><p>In all cases, the key is that the cues of different attacks are consistent enough to learn and distinct enough to avoid any conflation.</p><p><strong>The Art of War</strong></p><p>Crucially, different attacks require different responses from the player, ensuring they are constantly engaged with the game; assessing the danger and reacting with the correct input, rather than finding comfort (and thus eventually boredom) in routine. All the best enemies and bosses forge a relationship with us as a player because we have to watch them closely and become attuned to their specific body language and needs. You ever date a Cacodemon? Then how come you know the face they make before they spit a fireball?</p><p>Back to the <em>DOOM Eternal </em>coverage again for one last nugget of wisdom: Game Director Hugo Martin puts forth the importance of keeping the player thinking. The games designers goal should be keeping the player engaged. The player is engaged when they have to pay attention and think about their next move. Again, the Q+A can be extremely simple because the player is going to jumping from stimulus to stimulus, applying their knowledge bank of rules at speed and under pressure.</p><p>Behold the bedrock of my games design philosophy: The Bop-It Theory.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/425/1*8SP_3U9VZ-hphTQUAkNrug.jpeg" /><figcaption>ALL VIDEO GAMES ARE JUST FANCY BOP-IT’S</figcaption></figure><p>Thus, we’re back to the start! After all, what is a boss battle if not a collection of obstacles, each requiring different responses? If enemies are intended to teach the player how to play the game, bosses are there to test what they’ve learned.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zWkCSvZkSlwbVkPWIKdqfw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sekiro’s battle with <strong>Lord Genichiro </strong>above the rooftops of Ashina Castle is lauded as one of the games best fights and most outright enjoyable moments. His move-list collects nearly all the games core combat rules in one place — stabs, grabs, leaps, swipes, rhythm parries and projectiles. More like the “Lightning Round” of Tomoe, eh? eh?</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4USuFZCGQZ52LXpeQhmIzA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Devil May Cry</strong> has many great bosses, but dueling with Dante’s brother <strong>Vergil </strong>is always a highlight. In both DMC1 and 3 he clashes with Dante multiple times throughout the game, gradually expanding his move-list each time so that by the finale, the player is ready for an epic showdown. His iconic cues and patterns are so ingrained in long-term fans that they get callbacks in both DmC and DMC5</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*trb3y7oVMtzyoqCn7ds-Gw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>God of War (2018)</strong> optional extra hard boss, <strong>Queen Sigrun</strong> of the Valkyries, has a dizzyingly long list of attacks, but by this point the player will have seen most of them before — the games trains you to fight her with the preceding Valkyrie battles, each of her sisters teaching a different part of Sigrun’s own repertoire.</figcaption></figure><p>The best boss battles put in the work to teach players their rules before they start testing them. This allows the player to confront their enemy with confidence, and only have themselves to blame for every missed window and slipped prompt.</p><h4>Mechanics Spotlight</h4><p>While a bosses various attacks might call on the players full range of defensive tactics to maximize their engagement — boss battles can also be an opportunity to spotlight a specific player tool or ability as the key to defeating them, a natural extension of toolbox design. Many of the most memorable boss battles are themed around a particular game mechanic. This gives the designer another opportunity to ensure they’re squeezing every good idea out of their systems, adds variety, and forces players to deep-dive into abilities they might be neglecting.</p><p>The <em>Legend of Zelda </em>series strictly follows this approach in the majority of their games. If their dungeons are the classroom where players get to grips with new mechanics and concepts, then Zelda boss battles are essentially the “pop quiz” at the end.</p><p>Let’s say you just got the boomerang. This will almost surely be shortly followed by a dungeon themed around the boomerang. Soon after, it’s boss fight time, and how do you beat the boss? Well, you just spent the last few hours using the boomerang and learning it’s various advantages and applications in puzzles and level design, so your guess is as good as mine. ..assuming that you guessed boomerang. But just like how math papers always phrase their “problems” as obscure metaphors about train arrival times and dynamic apple exchange, it’s not as simple as just doing what you have done before in an exam environment. The core rules of how the mechanic has worked before remain the same, but a boss battle should force it to be applied to a more complex and abstract situation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SFI_TcTz3FMtUk1OTBQWJA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In <em>Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time </em>the boomerang themed dungeon is Jabu-Jabu’s belly, and the pop-quiz is hosted by “Bio-electric Anemone” and “Electric Rotating Intestinal Worm”, Barinade. Let’s call him Barry for short. The boomerang is thus far known for it’s ability to hit things that are out of reach, and stun enemies. The battle firstly calls on the boomerang to sever tentacles which are holding Barry to the roof of the room, a static out-of-reach target as previously experienced, albeit minus the usual visual cues and in a new topical environment for added satisfaction. <strong>That was just to get you in the boomerang-ing mood.</strong> The player must then carefully time their boomerang throws between spinning electrical jellyfish things rather than simply throwing it willy-nilly-y. <strong>Timed throws, check. </strong>Barry then takes off around the room and must be stunned with the boomerang to reveal a weak-spot. <strong>-Moving target, check- </strong>which the boomerang can hit.. assuming the player can strafe Link around the fuzzy electricity texture planes Barry is throwing at you. <strong>Timed throws AND a moving target, at the same time!</strong></p><p>This battle is both the culmination of a classic Nintendo <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBmIkEvEBtA">4-step-level design</a> and the final test of the boomerang dungeon, and once it’s completed the player has proven themselves as a fully certified and card-carrying boomerang expert. Well, boomerang-carrying.</p><p>Although Nintendo have the most overt examples of this boss battle style, it can be identified in many other games.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AYZlINTnomtgzw2UMKWlWg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The deeply magnificent <strong>Portal 2 </strong>introduces and (literally) tests its suite of mechanics in passive puzzle rooms, and then calls on the player to weaponize them during energetic set pieces. Fittingly, the final boss fight has cameos from each of the games gel mechanics and culminates with an ingenious extension of its most important rule: you can make Portal’s on any pure white surface. 10/10 payoff</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3e6y3ZGJazle-Ad97HgC0A.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Metal Gear Solid</strong> often uses bosses to spotlight different types of gameplay, with many of the franchise showdowns themed on Snake beating a specialist and/or freak at their own game. <strong>Revolver Ocelot </strong>(MGS/MGS3) and <strong>Olga</strong> (MGS2) test mid-range gunplay, <strong>Liquid</strong>, <strong>Gray Fox </strong>(MGS1)<strong> </strong>and <strong>The Boss </strong>(MGS3) are CQC matches, <strong>The Fear</strong> (MGS3) must be tracked with the thermal goggles and his poison crossbow bolts require multi-step surgeries to fix. <strong>Sniper Wolf </strong>(MGS) and <strong>The End</strong> (MGS3) are sniper duels, the latter calling on the player to use their camo, directional mic, and even wildlife capture mechanics. There’s also a boss battle in MGS1 with a <strong>Tank </strong>that puts the spotlight on chaff grenades and claymores.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EIh41hAf0vA8RB8VWAsLPw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Despite their reputation for making super hard games, FromSoftware actually does a lot of work teaching, testing and re-iterating its rules — while main bosses showcase the toolbox, sub-bosses are often used to ingrain specific mechanics. <strong>Jinsuke Saze</strong>’s nasty double cut demands precision timing and multi-parries, a gatekeeper that ensures you can’t face Genichiro until you’re ready for a good time. <strong>Long Arm Centipede’s</strong> intimidating barrage of slashes is when many players realize parrying is about rhythm not reaction speed. Unlike other enemies <strong>Armored Warrior </strong>doesn’t take damage, so can only be defeated using the posture system.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*85Bc4ZgiEBrc_mdaCr1DEg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Another example from the <strong>Arkham </strong>series is the <strong>Mr Freeze</strong> battle in Gotham PD; which unlike most of the series’ boss encounters is a test of the players stealth abilities. The room is rigged with a variety of opportunities to surprise Freeze with Batman’s various stealth take-down moves, but the good doctor won’t get fooled twice the same way — so unlike the rest of the game, the player will have to open some dusty pockets in the utility belt and dig deeper than their usual go-to gadgets.</figcaption></figure><p>In many of these case studies, the game forces the player to do what it wants by subtracting the other options. This is acceptable assuming the subtraction doesn’t feel contrived and the remaining options are enjoyable. Granting immunity to some or all of the players attacks is also a popular answer to a question all boss designers must ask: What if the player does EVERYTHING?</p><h4>Defense Mechanisms</h4><p>When the player strikes an enemy, it is tradition for the enemy to recoil in pain. This is called a “hit stun” and usually prevents the enemy from doing their own attacks. Without a way to escape hit stun, enemies can be “stun locked” by a player simply bombarding them with maximum aggression. This is acceptable for fodder and lower-level bads who can find time to do their thing while the player is focusing elsewhere in the scrum, but it’s too embarrassing for elites and big kahuna’s who face the player without distractions.</p><p>If you are chasing engagement as a goal then thoughtless mashing is top of the list of things you don’t want the player to be doing and closing that door is the first step to pushing the player back towards your intended Fun Zone. These enemies either need a way to escape the players onslaught or to control the players opportunities to deal damage.</p><p>The easiest (and thus rarely the best) solutions are to keep the boss out of reach or in possession of a standard immunity to the players attacks, either for certain preset sections of the battle, or until the player succeeds in completing a predetermined task or puzzle to lower that immunity/get in reach.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ztd_lI7yX0jh8UP0ud2kuw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Pictured: <strong>DMC3</strong>’s Vergil is immune to Dante’s pistols in the majority of his states. A boss from frenetic power-slide-emup <strong>Vanquish </strong>that’s only vulnerable in its titular Argus Core. Many <strong>God of War</strong> bosses are so big they exist beyond the arena and can only be hurt when they reach into it to smush you</figcaption></figure><p>Another classic defense mechanism for bosses is the “weakspot”. If this spot is only available at controlled intervals or after puzzles, it is basically the same as the out of reach/immunity approach, but some bosses wear their weakspots loud and proud the whole battle. The fact it is slightly trickier to hit the bulls eye than the dartboard is sometimes just enough increased challenge to stop the player spamming out damage and draining the boss bar too quickly, particularly if that spot is hidden on the bosses back or lesser spotted areas. This system often links well with another design tactic in boss battles, that of the boss opening itself up to damage through some of its own attacks. Just as each boss attack must be designed so it can be avoided, certain moves may leave the bosses defenses down or “unintentionally” reveal that tell-tale weakspot. Ideally if this is the method you choose, more than one of the bosses moves should be open to reprisals, or the player will simply find themselves waiting for that move to come up, and “waiting” is rarely one of the things you want the player to be doing.</p><p>The most sophisticated bosses are open to damage throughout the whole battle but have techniques to escape stun lock and punish the player for being thoughtlessly aggressive, usually a “get away” move such as a teleport or jump, or a “keep away” move like a short-range AOE. These are triggered when the player overstays their welcome in the bosses personal space, with the latter normally prefaced by either an auto-block or temporary “super armor” state. Super Armor is when an enemy is still taking damage but will no longer react, which means their attacks cannot be interrupted. Some bosses walk around wearing it all the time.</p><p>If you ever wondered why so many bosses play by the same rules, it’s because they’re trying to solve the same problems. The designers most challenging boss battle is balancing convenience with contrivance.</p><h4>Too Big Too Bad</h4><p>Enemy and Boss design is a big juicy topic that shares so much real-estate with other big juicy topics like combat systems and level design that it’s impossible to wrangle into a single thesis. This article runs the gamut from macro to micro in an attempt to show enemy design shouldn’t happen in a vacuum, enemies and bosses should be conceived and designed to serve a purpose. Their attacks, their weaknesses and their defenses are all ways to control and define the way your game is played.</p><p>What do you want the player to do?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6509e5e06879" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>