<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Colorado Steve Harvey on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Colorado Steve Harvey on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@steveharvey_72374?source=rss-78c6b46b7dd1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 11:07:32 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@steveharvey_72374/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Tyranny of the Minority: The Real Rationale in Favor of the Electoral College]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@steveharvey_72374/the-tyranny-of-the-minority-the-real-rationale-in-favor-of-the-electoral-college-afab848e1a42?source=rss-78c6b46b7dd1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/afab848e1a42</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[electoral-college]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tyranny]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[national-popular-vote]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colorado Steve Harvey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 15 Jan 2019 16:24:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-15T18:05:59.188Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Despite the historical genesis and relevance of the electoral college, current insistence of its virtue is based on rationalizations applied unevenly and for the ideological convenience of those doing so, in order to impose their will on others in a non-democratic way. But before diving into why and how that is so, here are a couple of disclaimers:</p><p>First, I’ve never been a fan of the narrative that Trump’s victory isn’t legitimate because he didn’t win a majority of the popular vote. That’s a bogus argument; you can’t decide that the same electoral system we’ve had since the ratification of the Constitution 230 years ago is suddenly devoid of legitimacy because it doesn’t give you the results you want, and you shouldn’t conflate the issue of the electoral college with other issues that actually do call the legitimacy of his victory into question.</p><p>Second, I don’t think that getting rid of the electoral college is something we should be investing a lot of time, energy, and passion on, in part because the only reasonably possible way of doing so in the foreseeable future (the interstate national popular vote compact, which does an end-run around the Constitution and is by no means an easy lift) would cause a lot of additional rage among the already excessively raging populist authoritarian right, and that is a truly dangerous situation, and in part because it is neither at the heart of our dysfunction nor an artifact that is likely to continue to do harm as demographic trends continue down their current path.</p><p>Having said that, let’s address the merits of the notion that the electoral college is a necessary counterbalance to the concentration of the population in a few urban areas mostly on the two coasts:</p><p>The electoral college was a compromise between federal and state sovereignty, with the national popular vote representing federal sovereignty and states having votes as states representing state sovereignty. When the Constitution was drafted to replace the toothless Articles of Confederation, each state still saw itself as a sovereign country, and no national system that ran roughshod over that was going to be acceptable</p><p>History has a way of changing things. While we still value and benefit from the principle of the devolution of power (e.g., that things that affect only the state population should be decided at the state level), few people in this country sincerely continue to see states as having co-equal sovereignty to the federal government. Culturally and institutionally, states are subordinate to the federal government, in ways that are now deeply woven into our institutional landscape. And that’s not something to lament; it is what led to the abolition of slavery, the civil rights movement and the legislation and Court holdings that movement produced, and, in short, the progress of our nation into modernity and expanding democracy and equal protection of rights and justice for all.</p><p>We evolved to see tyranny not only as something inflicted by more remote centers of power that more local centers of power must be vigilant against, but also as something inflicted by more local centers of power that more remote centers of power must be vigilant against. The federal government had to protect the rights of African Americans against state governments and individual property owners who were intent on denying them their rights. We came to realize that states should protect children from the brutality of parents when such brutality exists. We decided that governments should protect minorities from private sector discrimination. Tyranny takes many forms, and protection comes from many places.</p><p>The “States’ Rights” Doctrine and its penumbra, originally perceived as advocacy of liberty against incursions of tyranny, became exactly the opposite. It began its descent into infamy when it became synonymous with defense of slavery, and continued as it became synonymous with defense of Jim Crow, and has reached the nadir of its reputation today, when, despite plenty of experience with which to enlighten us, it continues to be a part of the north star of the faction that eventually came to worship the unfortunate creature currently occupying the oval office.</p><p>What the “states’ rights” mantra — which is implicit in the skewing of the national vote provided by the electoral college — quickly came to represent in the course of our national history, and has only increasingly come to represent, is a desire to cling to an unjust past and oppose the arrival of a more just future. So let’s examine how that plays out through the electoral college.</p><p>A North Dakota resident has a vote in presidential elections that is three and a half times greater than a California resident. The original justification for this was that North Dakota is a state with co-equal sovereignty; it was NOT that rural minorities need to be protected from urban majorities. This distinction is critical, because the prevailing arguments aren’t that North Dakota has co-equal sovereignty, but rather that the rural minority needs to be protected from the urban majority, and that latter argument, when examined closely is clearly one of convenience, applied unevenly to serve the specific interests of those doing so in a brazen expression of their own tyrannical inclinations.</p><p>Should a North Dakota farmer have just as much say in who should be president as a Los Angeles movie producer? Hell yeah! Should the North Dakota farmer have three and a half times more say than the Los Angeles movie producer (as is currently the case)? Hell no! Because North Dakota isn’t really a sovereign country, and that rationale, which is the only legitimate rationale, is an anachronistic pretext for a predominantly rural, incidentally regressive faction to hold the country hostage to their oppressive mentality, a regressive political force that would fade thankfully away, as it has to a far greater extent in the rest of the developed world, were we a national democracy when it comes to presidential elections instead of a faux-federalism of ideological convenience when it comes to presidential elections.</p><p>I have been told that seeking to abolish the electoral college is discrimination against rural voters. But ensuring that each rural voter has the same vote as each urban voter is, by definition, an absence of discrimination against rural voters; seeking for each rural voter to have a vote more heavily weighted than each urban voter is rather, by definition, discrimination against urban voters. Those insisting that the electoral college is fair are the ones favoring discrimination, by definition.</p><p>And the discrimination amounts to the argument that land should get votes. The entire argument is that because rural areas are more sparsely populated, rural individuals should have more heavily weighted votes. By that logic, a single individual living alone in a large wilderness should have a vote many times larger than anyone else in the country. It’s a bit absurd.</p><p>Despite how horrible for this nation and world reasonable people consider authoritarian populism to be, we don’t seek to reduce the vote of those who advocate it to less than one third the value of those who don’t; that would be tyrannical, and I loathe authoritarian populism precisely because it’s tyrannical. We all should have the same vote, none with three and a half times the vote of others, something that becomes especially destructive when the minority thus holding the majority hostage happens to be intent on repeating the most horrifying errors of modern history.</p><p>But we don’t have to debate the merits of authoritarian populism; we just have to choose whether we are committed to the democratic principle that those who disagree with us should have the same vote that we do or to the tyrannical principle that those who disagree with us should have less of a vote than we do.</p><p>Finally, we need to clear up a misconception that really lays bare how wrong-headed the current prevailing defenses of the electoral college are: It was not established to protect a shrinking population of rural voters from a growing population of urban voters; it was established in recognition of state co-sovereignty, period. The only valid argument in favor of the electoral college that can be made is that an archaic commitment to giving states rather than exclusively people votes is better than democracy.</p><p>But that’s not the argument most people benefiting from it are making. The argument they’re making is that since rural people are a minority they need a vote weighted in their favor to protect them against the urban majority.</p><p>Let’s accept, for the sake of argument, that that makes sense, that minorities should get more heavily weighted votes to protect them against the tyranny of the majority. In that case, blacks and Latinos should get votes weighted two and a half times that of whites (since they each comprise about a fifth of the population and whites comprise about half). If you’re going to apply this principle that minorities need more heavily weighted votes to protect them against the tyranny of the majority, it shouldn’t just be at one’s own ideological convenience, but rather evenly and universally.</p><p>But that notion is undoubtedly horrifying to those who are adamant that it be applied to their own benefit, because it’s not electoral fairness to minorities that they’re championing; it’s tyranny for themselves.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=afab848e1a42" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Trump and His Supporters are Factually, Logically, and Morally Wrong.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@steveharvey_72374/why-trump-and-his-supporters-are-factually-logically-and-morally-wrong-a1c9a82bdd21?source=rss-78c6b46b7dd1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a1c9a82bdd21</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[illegal-immigration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[xenophobia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[border-wall]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[immigration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colorado Steve Harvey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Jan 2019 16:48:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-12T19:04:53.581Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>All decent human beings, all people who care about both the economic health of this country and the values it stands for, should reject, resoundingly, the nativist xenophobia hawked, cynically, by the current president to a tragically receptive segment of our population. Illegal border crossings, as measured by apprehensions, are less than one fifth of what they were 20 years ago, are at a 46 year low, and reached a comparably low mark prior to Trump’s election. Our border security is quite sufficient, in reality, with crime rates by illegal immigrants being lower than crime rates by natural born citizens and crime rates by geographic locale being inversely correlated to the proportion of the population that are immigrants in that locale (i.e., more immigrants = less crime). Those are statistical facts.</p><p>There is absolutely no evidence that even a single terrorist has ever come across our southern border, according to Trump’s own justice department. The 4000 number that Sarah Huckabee Sanders used refers to people arriving at airports from countries that we consider to be countries that terrorists frequently hail from; they are not even suspected of terrorism, and they do not come across the southern border. In fact, the justice department and anti-terrorism experts in general consider the Canadian border to pose a greater danger of providing a conduit for terrorists, because there is much more radical Islamic influence in Canada than in the Latino countries south of us.</p><p>It’s also a fact that at a certain point further investment in border security costs more per person successfully prevented from crossing the border illegally than that person costs us if they do cross the border illegally. In fact, it’s extremely likely that we have already passed that point. Non-partisan analyses of the costs and benefits that illegal immigrants provide to our coffers and our economy range from net benefits on both scores at both the state and federal levels to fairly marginal net costs on both scores. No peer-review study has come to the conclusion that costs are any significant portion of GDP, or that they are anywhere near posing an economic crisis to the country.</p><p>Conversely, that which is currently illegal immigration DOES redress a critical and rapidly growing demographic imbalance between retirees drawing out of pension funds and working people paying into them. Developed countries really have little choice, if they want their pension funds to remain solvent, but to legalize and normalize fairly massive immigration of working age people.</p><p>Furthermore, the argument that the nativism and xenophobia on very prominent and obvious display by this president and his followers is just a commitment to the rule of law, not an anti-immigrant stance, is belied by both the nature of the issue and the facts. We determine what the laws are, and virtually everyone agrees that we need immigration reform, which means changes in the laws. So the real debate is over what the laws should be and how we should implement them. The divide in the debate is between those who favor a kinder and more open society and those who favor a crueler and more closed society.</p><p>That it isn’t just, or even primarily, about enforcing current laws is highlighted by the fact that when Trump proposed changes in the law to make immigration more restrictive and favor “Norwegians” over people of color, and when crueler and more restrictive choices of policy not dictated by currents law were implemented, his supporters passionately supported and defended his choices, demonstrating that the debate isn’t over enforcing the law but rather shutting out precisely the people we used to welcome.</p><p>Those who echo Trump’s narrative on immigration often compare the nation to a house, insisting that just as we use walls and locks to exclude people at will from our homes we should do so to exclude them from our country. It is redundant at this point to address the ineffectiveness of a wall (something a review of expert analyses of border security makes perfectly clear), so instead let’s focus on the errors in that analogy.</p><p>A country isn’t a house. It wasn’t legally purchased from its previous owners; it was stolen. Its property lines aren’t​ determined by developers selling lots; they’re determined by military conquest. Its walls don’t separate inhabitants from the elements, but rather secure those who managed to divert more of the Earth’s resources to themselves against those who have been violently relegated to diverting less to themselves. And it is not a refuge from the world financed by inhabitants’ labors external to it, but rather a complex economic, social, and cultural entity that thrives by means of its robust interactions with the world around it.</p><p>Let’s address the last point first, because it is the one that cuts across values and appeals directly to systemic realities. Our nation functions through an internal and external market economy, engaging in market exchanges within our borders and across borders. Classical (and conservative) economic theory maintains that the fewer barriers there are to such market exchanges, the more wealth is generated by them, the ideal being a “free market,” characterized by unhindered market activity. Advocacy for strengthening national borders and obstructing the flow of people across them is a contradiction of this ideal. Less ideologically pure understandings of market dynamics also recognize the value of allowing labor to travel to where there is demand for it. Whatever limits we feel we must place on that free flow of goods and people in service to a free market, the fact that it is a consideration is one of the principal ways in which a country differs from a house, not just on scale, but also in systemic attributes.</p><p>But a country differs from a house in other ways as well, on moral and historical dimensions. We can’t return land to all those with historical claims on it, but we can stop pretending that we have some absolute, inherent moral authority to deprive entry to those who are the descendants of the ones we stole it from seeking to work hard and provide opportunity for their children under our rule of law. Those who *have* always pass laws to protect what they have from those who don’t; one can defend that through a cynical insistence that might makes right but not through a claim to having the morally virtuous position. The morally virtuous position would be to recognize our moral debt to humanity as a result of the historical moral infractions through which we secured our privileged place in the global political economy.</p><p>And it’s a pretty easy form of “generosity” to let hard working people come here and do our dirtiest, most difficult jobs for the lowest wages, contributing to our economy, to our coffers, and to our culture. The fact is that most analyses show net gains to our economy, many show net gains to our state and federal coffers, and all show a net gain in our demographic distribution of workers to retirees, a critical imbalance at present that massive immigration redresses.</p><p>You people who think we should wall out the less fortunate because you feel threatened by them are the least fortunate of all, coveting material wealth that isn’t being threatened by inflicting passive and active brutalities on those most in need. You’re not Christians; you’re what Christians exhort us not to be.</p><p>This entire nativist, xenophobic narrative is a fabrication, refuted by fact, by reason, by our own national interests, and by basic human decency. And it is one that an opportunistic con-artist has leveraged, as he’s leveraged other similarly dishonest scams before, to stoke up the bigotries of a certain segment of our national population in order to serve his own personal self-aggrandizement.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a1c9a82bdd21" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“The Reason for the Season”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@steveharvey_72374/the-reason-for-the-season-5e8e479702c2?source=rss-78c6b46b7dd1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e8e479702c2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[paganism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christmas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[charles-dickens]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humanity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colorado Steve Harvey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 09 Dec 2018 23:54:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-09T23:54:42.726Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>While walking my dog Buttercup just now, I saw a yard sign that said, “JESUS is the reason for the season.” Well, he may be YOUR reason for the season, but he’s not mine. And I DO love the season; I love Christmas. As a Taoist Pantho-Atheistic Nominal Jew, Christmas resonates with me.</p><p>“A Christmas Carol” is my favorite story of all time. A recent movie ostensibly about its writing, “The Man Who Invented Christmas,” while taking lots of poetic license, emphasized the probably accurate observation that the way we celebrate Christmas today owes a great deal to that story.</p><p>I have an intimate history with that story. From my earliest childhood memories, I was familiar with and adored the “Mr. Magoo” animated version for children. In elementary school, a reader we had was half a children’s version of the book and half Greek mythology, Greek mythology also ending up playing a robust role in my life.</p><p>As a grad student in Connecticut, I used to read “A Christmas Carol” out loud to my brother and sister-in-law in Boston on Christmas Eve, a ritual that began with my jokingly reading the first couple of paragraphs. It turned into the whole book every year, by the fire with hot cider, at my sister-in-law’s insistence. I later occasionally read it for other audiences as well.</p><p>And “A Christmas Carol” became the archetype for what I call “metamessaging,” referring to political-cultural messaging that isn’t tied to a single issue, but rather simply to the notion of being reasonable people of goodwill.</p><p>But Christmas is more than that story to me, and more than a time when the ideal of goodwill, the ideal of humanity, is celebrated and really does light a bit of a glow here and there; it’s also a pagan snowball rolling down the long hill of history, picking up just a bit of Christian debris at one brief moment along the way.</p><p>It began, more or less, as the pagan Roman Saturnalia (“more or less” because winter solstice festivals have existed in some form or another since prehistory and all around the world). Early Christians, while still persecuted by the Romans (rather than, as later was the case, persecuting others AS the Romans), decided it would be prudent to celebrate Christ’s birth at a time when the rest of the Roman Empire was celebrating as well, to be inconspicuous about it. And so the Saturnalia survived with a new name long after Rome had fallen.</p><p>It not only has pagan roots, but also pagan leaves (or pine needles, as the case may be). The Christmas Tree, elves in their shops making toys headed up by the jolliest old elf of all, a Christmas wreath on the door, lights and decorations strung over everything, are, of course, all pagan in origin. And then, most recently, there’s that which is neither pagan nor Christian but just humanistic.</p><p>Dickens, who liked to get to the heart of the matter, wrote his book as a critique of the recently dominant Neo-Malthusian callousness he described and decried, and as an exhortation to make joy and kindness our guiding stars instead; not, particularly, as an ode to the birth of a Jewish rabbi two millennia earlier. Frank Capra’s “It’s a Wonderful Life” wasn’t about Jesus either, nor was “Miracle on 34th Street.” All of those beloved tales and many more since are celebrations of our humanity, regardless of our religion.</p><p>So Jesus really isn’t the reason for the season, but if he’s YOUR reason, hey, that’s just fine with me. Just don’t forget to be kind to all the Pequeño Timoteos out there while you’re at it. And know that this wonderful life of ours is all about doing acts of kindness small and large that ripple out through the fabric of our shared existence, creating a world that was enriched by our presence in it. Let THAT be the reason for the season.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e8e479702c2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Cure to Trumposis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@steveharvey_72374/the-cure-to-trumposis-ef671ae91305?source=rss-78c6b46b7dd1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ef671ae91305</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anger]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kindness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reason]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hate]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colorado Steve Harvey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 10 Aug 2018 02:35:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-08-10T02:36:33.503Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Trump is an aberration. His base is demographically doomed. While we’re ensuring that we defeat them politically, let’s also ensure that we’re not carrying the infection of anger and hatred forward into a future that doesn’t need to be defined by them.</p><p>The left and the right both think the other needs to look in the mirror, and on that point, they are both right. What’s more, to an extent greater than either want to admit, they are looking into that mirror when they are looking at each other and just don’t know it.</p><p>I know how eager we all are to claim “false equivalency!” And, yes, there is much that is not equivalent. But I’ve noticed for quite some time that, as a general rule, those who are quickest and loudest in shouting that refrain are the ones who have the least justification for doing so; it is the ideologues who fancy themselves most different from their counterparts while being in some very essential ways most alike.</p><p>There is less moral hazard in being eager to confront our own fallibility than in being eager to deny it. There is less moral hazard in being willing to acknowledge our opposition’s humanity than in doggedly denying it. We risk less by trying to ratchet down the vitriol than we do by refusing to. A future committed to human decency can’t be achieved through anger and hatred.</p><p>The Roman writer Livy said of the Greeks that they had “conquered their rude conquerors,” because though the Roman military captured Greek territory, it was Greek culture that captured Roman minds. We face a reverse problem, threatened by the contagion of vitriol rather than the contagion of more edifying sentiments, and I look at a future in which the left prevails with more trepidation than relief, because the left is growing angrier and meaner and more Intransigent, and that is not the spirit I want to prevail.</p><p>So let’s start now trying to be kinder. Let’s oppose the hate without hating. Let’s oppose irrationality with reason rather than another brand of irrationality. Let’s look inward as well as outward. It’s up to us to create and follow a better path. And it’s well within our reach to do so.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ef671ae91305" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Actual Conversation with the Most Rational and Civil Trump Supporter I’ve Yet Encountered]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@steveharvey_72374/an-actual-conversation-with-the-most-rational-and-civil-trump-supporter-ive-yet-encountered-ac3c679e78ba?source=rss-78c6b46b7dd1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ac3c679e78ba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trumpism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colorado Steve Harvey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 23 Jun 2018 16:23:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-23T17:34:38.828Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/0*CaeQHGzN2IEnOeAM.jpg" /><figcaption>Trump Supporters Walling Out Reason and Human Decency</figcaption></figure><p>After posting a well-worded invitation to Trump supporters to engage in civil discourse with me, a woman, LR, who first responded with dismissive scorn began commenting on my Facebook page. After some trust building between us, and editing out the participation of another individual, this is the meat of the discussion we had. (I edited her comments for spelling and punctuation and to reduce “noise”. My first comment follows her declaration, in response to the other participant — who carried most of the first part of the conversation — that she has absolutely no second thoughts about her support for Trump.)</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: LR, I’m going to jump in here with an observation. Intellectually, as a student of society and of the human mind, I know that many of the things I believe are wrong. I know that many of the things I am absolutely certain are true are not true. I know that the narratives of reality that form my identity and my relationship to the world around me is laden with defense mechanisms that protect it from critical challenges. And I know that all of that is true despite the higher-than-average degree to which I work to mitigate them.</p><p>It’s very hard to act on the knowledge I just outlined above, particularly when engaged with people with whom I disagree. I don’t want to give them that admission as a lever or weapon to use against me. But even in the privacy of my own mind, or in the company of like-minded people, it is hard to own and harder to act on.</p><p>That’s why, in the process of creating Transcendental Politics, I increasingly came to emphasize “intellectual humility.” I’m not talking about the appealing personality trait in which one presents as knowing that they’re not special, but rather simply the knowledge that we don’t know, that much that we think we know is wrong, and that some things we are absolutely certain are true are in reality false.</p><p>I just finished reading Steven Pinker’s new book, “Enlightenment Now: The Case for Reason, Science, Humanism, and Progress.” Pinker and I think in similar ways, share a tendency to be critical of ideologues across the spectrum, believe in the value of reliance on empirical evidence, rational analysis, and a commitment to our shared humanity, wherever it leads. I’m a pretty diligent consumer of information, trained in research methodologies, aware of psychological pitfalls (such as confirmation bias and attribution bias), and yet was surprised that Pinker managed to bring into question some things that I thought were beyond dispute. It was a humbling reminder of how much crap we all have in our minds.</p><p>(I’m not suggesting that Pinker is infallible either. There were some emphases, some ways of framing information and conceptualization that I remain at odds with him on, though mostly it is really just more a matter of emphasis than anything else. But I recognize that rejecting data that doesn’t confirm my bias is inexcusable, and some of the data he presented absolutely challenged some of my biases.)</p><p>So, I encourage us all, to the greatest extent possible, to come to the table knowing that we don’t know, that we may be wrong about some things we are certain of, that the more we allow reason and humanity to guide us the better, and that our inevitable boat load of false certainties is a major obstruction to doing so.</p><p>I didn’t really want to interrupt the flow of yours and EB’s discussion, or attempt to impose my will while trust is still being built, but I just wanted to plant the seed of this suggestion early, just to tuck away in the back of your mind.</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: Colorado Steve Harvey Sounds like an interesting book . I struggled with whether to use the word “absolutely,” and in the end decided that that was the most truthful answer for me to give at this time . Nothing of course is absolute, except “Universal Truth” which only the creator of the universe is privy to. I understand where you are coming from. Point well taken : )</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: LR, first, I want to reiterate that we appreciate your having the courage and integrity to be here, where you knew that you were going to be bombarded with challenges to what you hold to be true. Most people are unwilling to put themselves in that situation. I don’t like putting myself in that situation! (But, we would all benefit, individually and collectively, if we all put ourselves in that situation more routinely.)</p><p>Second, I have to continue that bombardment just a little, because not only conservative Republican Jeff Flake, but many others, both publicly and privately, echo his sentiments. The more thoughtful conservative columnists and pundits –George Will, Bill Kristol, Charles Krauthammer, most Republican congressmen and senators at some point or another, every living former president from both parties (implicitly or explicitly), virtually every reputable, established news publication in the world, virtually the entire corpus of professional historians, economists, foreign policy experts, anti-terrorism experts, diplomats, and statesmen, the former heads of the CIA and NSA, the former head of the FBI, all echo the sentiment that Trump is a disaster for this nation and world. Historians posted video-testimonials, with reference to historical analysis, to implore people not to make this mistake. Economists and foreign policy experts wrote mass letters signed by the luminaries in their fields with the same message. Venerable old publications that have either never endorsed anyone or have done so only once or twice in the course of centuries came out to endorse Clinton, not because they loved Clinton, but because they recognized how unthinkable it was to elect Trump to the presidency. Conservative papers that had always endorsed the Republican nominee prior to 2016 received death threats for doing the same.</p><p>That humility we agreed we all require should give us pause in the light of so enormous, so well-informed a chorus of both the expected and unexpected voices urging the same warning upon us. Can we entertain the possibility that we have ventured into some horrifyingly dangerous territory here? Not an agreement that it is so, necessarily, but a recognition that it might be so?</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: EB, If you are asking my opinion of (a speech by Flake that EB had posted), which I was already familiar with, and others …. well here goes …. all I can think of is that Flake went on an unhinged tirade of sanctimonious grandstanding . He hates Trump , he was a never Trumper from day 1 , and he wants someone like himself to challenge Trump in 2020 . As my Father used to say ” He has a better chance of being struck by lightning ” Good luck with that : )</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: If being a “never Trumper” disqualifies all of the conservative voices echoing liberal, academic, and expert concerns over Trump, then all of the most intelligent and informed and venerable of conservative voices, including previous conservative Republican nominees for the presidency and Republican presidents themselves, are disqualified, and the only definition of credibility becomes the refusal to listen to those voices and consider what they’re saying, which is a very dysfunctional definition of credibility.</p><p>Isn’t it just possible that the virtual unanimous voices of the world’s historians, economists, foreign policy experts, former presidents, former candidates for the presidency, editorial columnists for major publications, might, just might, have a point that is being systematically ignored by those who prefer not to hear it.</p><p>There are really two possibilities here: Virtually the entire universe of people with relevant knowledge, experience and expertise are all engaged in a conspiracy against what is good and true, or that which they are against isn’t actually good and true. Which seems more reasonable on the face of it?</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: Colorado Steve Harvey, all I will say is this: I am very familiar with all of these views. I have been listening for 3 years now. If this Presidency turns out to be the unmitigated disaster that they ( experts ) are predicting, our Constitutional Republic will be strong enough to survive.</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: I agree that our republic will *probably* survive a Trump presidency, but some of the harm done may be irreparable, and some of it may take generations to repair, and some of it may cause multitudes real harm in the meantime. So, if he is an unmitigated disaster, that is not a trivial concern.</p><p>I’m going to risk all of the goodwill we’ve built on a frank, admission, LR.</p><p>I personally am convinced that it is impossible for any rational person of goodwill to look at the evidence comprehensively and arrive at or retain the conclusion that Trump is anything other than a travesty that we have to do everything in our power to rectify.</p><p>I also believe, from all I’ve seen of you here, that you ARE a reasonable person of goodwill.</p><p>By syllogistic logic, if those two premises are correct, you would have to come to the conclusion that Trump is a travesty that we have to do everything in our power to rectify.</p><p>Now, given all that, there are three possibilities: 1) Premise number one is wrong because I’m wrong, the world’s historians are all wrong, the world’s economists are all wrong, the world’s foreign policy experts are all wrong, this nation’s living former presidents from both parties are all wrong, the most intellectual of conservative pundits are all wrong, and Trump isn’t a travesty that we have to rectify; or 2) I’m wrong in my assessment of you; or 3) you will, in time, come to the rational and humane conclusion.</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: Colorado Steve Harvey, well , apparently the grass roots voters in the swing states and the thousands who went to the rallies didn’t get the “Memo.” Trump was approachable, he worked like a dog going everywhere, he spoke plain english, he was smart enough to know that there was an untapped silent majority out there who was furious over 8 years of Obama’s policies . We are not racists, we are not anti LBGT. I know transgender Trump supporters, educated conservative women. Check out the FB page of Rocky Mountain Black Conservatives , they are in your state. I don’t know what else to say. That’s how he won 306 electoral votes . I went to bed on election night thinking “no way” we are never going to win Pennsylvania which I had determined was crucial. I was just as surprised as you guys . Peace : )</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: LR, but none of that really gets at the crucial question. Multitudes of ordinary, intelligent, kind people can opt to support and create horrors. We’ve seen that, repeatedly. Among Nazi supporters were kindly old grandmothers who baked cookies for their neighbors…, sometimes even for their Jewish neighbors! That multitudes of ordinary, intelligent, kind people supported and support Trump doesn’t tell us that the analysis of those who are specifically informed on each dimension of policy are wrong, and that the mind-bogglingly abundant evidence of Trump’s racism, misogyny, xenophobia, crudeness, incompetence, anti-constitutional authoritarianism, and general malignant buffoonery are all wrong. You said that his many supporters “didn’t get the memo;” that might be exactly right. And those many supporters might just be demonstrably wrong.</p><p>That there are some from categories of people the majority of which didn’t support him who do support him is both unsurprising and uninformative. There were slaves who defended slavery; there were women who opposed women’s suffrage; there were even Jews who sided with the Nazis. It is always the case that when horrifying injustice and brutality occurs, some members of those groups that are specifically targeted by the injustice and brutality actually support it. That is not proof that what they were supporting was not in fact injustice and brutality.</p><p>Appeals to the proof of the support of large pluralities or even outright majorities are not appeals to truth, or to justice, or to human decency, because we have many, many, many instances throughout history in which such pluralities or outright majorities were clearly on the side opposing truth, justice, and human decency. I would argue that the evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates that this is just such a circumstance.</p><p>That’s a lot to digest. Hang around a while and let’s find out together which of the three possibilities I listed is the correct one.</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: Colorado Steve Harvey, you are telling me which possibility is correct for me to pick ? I will tell you this: The minute you start to use the Natzi comparison, you lost me. Forget the other stuff like his foreign policy, which I agree with. I was willing to play fair, but don’t try to railroad me. You are not interested in my views. You want to change my views.</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: I want only one thing: For reason in service to our shared humanity to prevail. If I am failing, in my understandings and actions, to contribute to that, then I want my understandings and actions to be corrected. If others are, then I want the same for them. That is the only thing I want.</p><p>As for the Nazi analogy, it was to make a specific point, and that is that the argument that the support of many “good people” is proof that Trump is good is fallacious. My analogy was to point out that that is wrong. That’s all. And, it is.</p><p>Now, you are welcome to stay; I hope you do. I will continue to be courteous, and will continue to champion reason in service to humanity. No argument I have made has been irrational, nor has any been in service to inhumanity. If you want to find a pretext to bow out, I understand. If you want to put your own views to the test of whether they satisfy that objective, that would be more admirable, but it is entirely up to you.</p><p>Let’s see how good your faith really is; will you find pretexts to reject arguments that have been nothing but factual, rational, and made with a will to serve humanity? Or will you continue to find the courage to allow your own beliefs to be challenged?</p><p>As I said, I always welcome having mine challenged, and if you have arguments that can do that, I invite you to snare me in the same trap; I would be most grateful for the favor.</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: Colorado Steve Harvey What if everything that happens, no matter how bad we think is is serves Humanity. Lessons learned. I wonder who you wanted as president?</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: LR, that we are fallible and that the unexpected can occur is a given, but that that should not stop us from, with humility and diligence, making choices based on the best analysis of the best evidence available is a necessity.</p><p>I wanted the person of the two in the binary choice available who had the most competence, who was the most emotionally stable, who was the most professional, and who had given the greatest reason to believe that her choices would better serve our general welfare. I didn’t have to love her, or believe that she was without serious flaws; I only had to believe that she was the best of the two viable choices presented. And as I’ve already indicated, I think almost any other human being alive would have been the best of the two choices available, if they went up against the one who prevailed.</p><p>As for the fatalism, the suggestion that reason and responsibility may be irrelevant, because whatever we do serves humanity. In that case, we are free to commit acts of violence and predation, to harm others for our own benefit, to be cruel and selfish and reckless and devoid of compassion or mercy. But neither you nor I believe that; we both believe in our responsibilities as human beings, and that is really what we are discussing now; what is our responsibility as human beings, in the context of our role as citizens and sovereigns, and considering what is being done in our name?</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: Remember these words …. ” we’ll stop it ” that came from the email of the lead FBI agent on the Mueller investigation . That came out in the hearings today . Meaning we will stop the Trump presidency . Some heads are going to roll over there , and that is not Trump interfering with an investigation . That is the top tier of the FBi . They mishandled the Clinton email investigation also . Comey ruined his reputation . McCabe lied to Congress , and Struzk was escorted out of the FBI building today by security . There are also 3 other unnamed agents under investigation. That is what should have all Americans scared, not some crazy allegations that Trump is like Hitler.</p><p>My role as citizen was to vote for the person I felt was the best choice to lead this country. I did that, and I have no regrets . My issues were border security , the economy , and foreign policy. 60 million others made that choice also, they have a right to have their choice respected and not demeaned</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: Yes, two FBI agents who were in an intimate relationship opined via email about how horrifying the prospect was that Trump would be elected, a perspective I believe any rational human being would hold. “We’ll stop it” could easily have referred to us all, as Americans, at the ballot box, not in their capacity as FBI agents. As soon as he became aware of those emails, Mueller removed the two agents from the investigation AND released the information himself about the existence of the emails (which were not known to the public or to anyone else who might have released them prior to that). That’s not evidence of a corrupt investigation; that’s evidence of an investigation that is assiduously non-corrupt and incorruptible. Furthermore, it was the head of the FBI himself who sealed the deal FOR Trump, by announcing days before the election that he was reopening the case against Clinton, so if their purpose was to block Trump, and their actions were predictably more causative in the opposite direction, they are either the most incompetent conspirators in the history of the world, or you’re entire narrative is wrong.</p><p>Our responsibility is to do as much due diligence as we can, to refrain from ignoring massive quantities of relevant information, and to make choices that are not just appealing to us but that are rationally and empirically defensible. If you think you did that, fine. The election is over, but our responsibility to one another and to humanity is not.</p><p>We are interdependent. If someone commits acts of terrorism, for example, and says that that was their choice for how best to serve humanity, that choice can indeed be criticized. Voting for Trump was not an act of terrorism, but it was a choice that has consequences and, like any other choice that has consequences, can be critiqued.</p><p>Why don’t we take a break from this, and find more pleasant and agreeable things to discuss in the near future. We can always return to this another time.</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: Colorado Steve Harvey, that is only part of the story . The part the left wing media don’t you to hear . More is going to come out, but I am sure you aren’t interested because it doesn’t fit your narrative. That’s okay. It doesn’t really matter.</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: There are, as always, multiple possibilities, each of which we should consider methodically before either rejecting or accepting it as truth. There is a range of possibilities about the balance of how right and wrong we each are. There is a range of possibilities about the relative reliability and credibility of competing sources of information. And there is a range of possibilities about what will or will not come out, and how accurate and salient it will be.</p><p>To determine which among those many possibilities are in fact realities, we would need to refer to arguments made using reason applied to evidence, and not mere assertions. I strive, imperfectly but in earnest, to ensure that what fits my narrative (or rather what my narrative is fit to) is that which reason and evidence recommend as best serving our shared humanity.</p><p>If you have an argument to make, I am eager to hear it. If you are just going to make empty assertions, that’s fine, but it doesn’t mean anything until it has reason and evidence to support it. That is after all the trap we set, the one I invited you into from the very beginning.</p><p>I want to ask an isolated question, without letting it sprawl out into every other issue. (It helps to be able to focus on one issue at a time rather than shift to another one as soon as the first one becomes uncomfortable, never really dealing with it.) You said that the 60 million people “have a right to have their choice respected and not demeaned.” You also were unhappy with my earlier analogy of the tens of millions of Germans who supported Hitler and the question of whether they had “a right to have their choice respected and not demeaned.” But it’s a relevant question, because if there are extremes at which people don’t have a right to have their choice respected and not demeaned, then the question becomes whether those who made this choice crossed that threshold or not, and where the threshold is.</p><p>I think we can agree that there are choices that DON’T merit respect. Choices to commit acts of predatory violence don’t merit respect, for instance. Choices to support leaders who commit acts of predatory violence don’t merit respect. Choices to vilify whole categories of people don’t merit respect. Choices to support leaders who vilify whole categories of people don’t merit respect. The choice to foment fear and hatred in service to callous and brutal policies doesn’t merit respect. The choice to support a leader who foments fear and hatred in service to callous and brutal policies doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to forcibly take children from their mothers who arrived at your door in terror, fleeing from violence, in order to discourage such mothers from seeking such assistance, doesn’t merit respect. The choice to support leaders who forcibly take children from their mothers who arrive at our borders in terror, fleeing violence, in order to discourage them from doing so, doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader who calls white supremacists who rioted in and terrorized a southern town, including murdering one counter-protester with a car, “some very good people” doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader who bragged about routinely committing sexual assault, and is accused by 19 women of having done so, doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader who mocked a disabled reporter doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader who tries to undermine the free press and convince the American people that the free press is their enemy doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader who lies twice as often as he tells the truth, and always to serve his own interests rather than the public interest, doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader who praises despots and alienates allies, igniting a mutually destructive trade war with tariffs no economist thinks are a good idea doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader who, as a candidate, asked three times in a military briefing why, if we have nuclear weapons, don’t we use them, doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader who has said that he is in favor of nuclear proliferation and wouldn’t care if there were a nuclear war in Asia (which wouldn’t just be a humanitarian crisis on an almost unimaginable scale, but would also destroy the global economy and create a global catastrophe which would be completely disastrous for us as well) doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader who said that an American born judge of Mexican descent was unfit to hear a lawsuit against Trump because of his Mexican heritage doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader whose anti-constitutional authoritarian policies have been blocked by the courts repeatedly for violating the protections of fundamental rights guaranteed in our Constitution doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader whose own racism is evident from his violation of the Fair Housing Act for discriminating against blacks, his taking out of full-page ads calling for the execution of a group of black teens arrested for a crime they didn’t commit, his repeated vilification of Mexicans, his constant fear and hate mongering, his courting of and support by white supremacists (including appoint one as a senior advisor after winning the election), his support of the preservation and continued display of symbols of white supremacy, his exploitation of racist outrage toward peaceful and respectful protests by blacks of excessive use of deadly force by police toward frequently innocent black suspects, doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The choice to support a leader who is economically and diplomatically illiterate, uninformed, incurious, indifferent to the consequences of governing with self-glorifying and dysfunctional bluster rather than with skill or knowledge doesn’t merit respect.</p><p>The tragic thing is that this list can go on ten times longer than it already has, this president is such a dramatically unqualified and disqualified individual for the presidency. He has quoted Mussolini, the inventor of Fascism, favorably; he had (according to Ivana in a 1990s interview in Vanity Fair) a copy of “Mein Kampf” on his bed stand; he has bragged about his superior “German blood;” he made his entry into politics by becoming the figurehead of the arbitrary racist insistence that the first black president wasn’t born in America but rather Kenya…. How is it even possible for anyone to insist that it is unfair to them for others to be appalled that they supported this horrid, incompetent, hateful individual for the presidency?</p><p>But I don’t want us to be stuck in our being appalled and you feeling wronged by it. I want us to join together to try to be the nation and the people we once were and could and should be again, a compassionate people, a nation that values our alliances and understands the need to mobilize expertise in navigating the complexities of the modern world, a nation that seeks to join people together rather than divide them into warring tribes, a nation that believes in justice and in human decency, a nation that strives to be wise and fair and admirable. I don’t care about your past decisions; I care about your present and future decisions, about whether you continue to double down on choosing to destroy this nation, or whether you will join with all reasonable people of goodwill to correct our course and be a decent and honorable people once again.</p><p>This is self-destructive craziness we are in now. Yes, it’s true, I want to shake people like you and shout, “What the hell is the matter with you?! Why are you doing this to us?!” Obviously, you are free to dismiss me and all of the world’s historians and all of the world’s economists and all of the world’s foreign policy experts and all of our nation’s living past presidents from both parties and all of the evidence and all reason and all human decency, and insist that up is down and in is out and even if it isn’t it doesn’t really matter because fate is in charge anyway, all incredibly irresponsible things to insist upon and impose upon this nation and world. You are free to do it, but you are wrong to do it, morally wrong. And I really don’t believe you’re that kind of person, who knowingly inflicts harm on multitudes and knowingly destroys this country we all love. I don’t believe that that is who and what you really are.</p><p>So my question is: Are you more concerned with not being criticized for this choice, or with doing what’s right if the criticism is, after all, warranted? Which is more important, your feelings, or America’s and humanity’s welfare?</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: Colorado Steve Harvey, I don’t care about the critics. Call me immoral, call me whatever you want. If you want to change politics why don’t you run for office, or find a candidate of your choice to back? It’s not about my feelings. To me and many others, I guess you can boil it down to one core issue, and this issue was central to us way before Trump arrived on the scene. It’s our issue, no matter who is in office or who is running. The issue is Globalism. I believe in Sovereign Nations, free and independent of any kind of “One World Governing Body.” If America First is appalling to you, and I think it is, you have the right to your opinion. I am sure you won’t like our Governor here in Texas either : ) The Democrats, in my opinion are ruining this Country.</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: What we’re doing now doesn’t put “America first,” anymore than the Hatfields and McCoys were putting their respective families first when they spent generations killing each other. You subscribe to a zero sum fallacy in a non-zero sum world, to everyone’s detriment, including our own. That’s where the phrase “enlightened self interest” comes from, the realization that to serve ourselves well we must enter into messy cooperative relationships with both friends and foes. People who actually spend their lives in economics and diplomacy get this; people who refuse to recognize the limits of their own expertise not only don’t get it but obstruct the beneficial mobilization of knowledge and experience they lack, believing that their current understanding is the understanding that should govern us, and that the expertise of others is irrelevant. And, if you’ll pardon my saying so, that combination of ignorance and arrogance is the most destructive force in the human world, the author of all our woes.</p><p>Here’s the point: I don’t, in general, just believe in random ideological narratives of reality. None of us should. But when you “argue” your position, you don’t argue it at all. Rather, you appeal to some random article of ideological faith. We can do better than that. We can analyze data. We can formulate an evolving, precise, highly sophisticated understanding of reality, and we can use that understanding to govern ourselves intelligently rather than arbitrarily. And that’s the real political divide in the world, between those who believe in our responsibility as citizens and human beings and do due diligence in service to it, and those who don’t. Guess which group is comprised of creative problem solvers and which group, in one form or another, flies planes into buildings and calls it a noble cause.</p><p>I’m done. Feel free to stay and chat about the weather. You clearly don’t want to be reached, and I clearly don’t appreciate the plane you’re​ choosing to fly into our building.</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: I am not choosing to fly a plane into anything. I voted. You don’t like my choice. 2020 is 2 years from now, a lot can happen between now and then, so we will see : )</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: This isn’t a plane that hits the building just once and the damage is done. It occurs in slow motion, more of the damage mitigated the sooner those who’ve hijacked us either have a change of heart or are simply overpowered. The fact that we have a legal opportunity to overpower you in two years does not mean that it would not be to everyone’s benefit for you to have a change of heart long before then.</p><p>I think it’s important to note that this is a familiar historical scenario for the collapse of a republic, going back to the collapse of the Roman republic under Julius Caesar, and through the collapse of the Weimar Republic under Adolf Hitler. The scenario is as follows: An authoritarian populist attracts a large following by promising a return to supposedly lapsed “greatness,” and in the modern scenario by targeting foreigners, minorities, intellectuals, and the press, and countervailing governmental branches acquiesce out of either fear or self-interest in light of the populist pressure put upon them. The republic then becomes a dictatorship.</p><p>You wrote in an earlier comment that if all of this is a mistake, the republic will survive it. I answered, with emphasis on “probably,” that we would *probably* survive it, but I have no desire to continue to gamble our freedom and well-being on that very uncertain assessment of where the probability lies. We are in great danger as a republic right now. We really are. This is scary. This is horrifying. And, yes, people can vote their own freedom away without knowing it; they can vote their own prosperity, their own safety, their own welfare away without knowing it. It’s happened many times in the past, in republics that had existed longer than ours has and among people who didn’t believe it possible that that could ever change.</p><p>It can. We are gambling everything that we are, everything that our Founding Fathers and every soldier and public servant after them fought and often died for. And for what? To make enemies of friends and to strengthen the hand against us of the enemies we already had? To pretend that a trade war that no one wins and everyone loses makes us greater? To rail against history and the reality of interdependence? This is self-destructive insanity, pure and simple. The urgent challenge facing us as a nation and world –that, as I said, virtually everyone, from both parties and across the ideological spectrum, with relevant experience and expertise not only knows but is shouting as loudly as they can from the rooftops– is whether we can convince enough of those who are deceived or self-deceived to help pull us back from the brink in time</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: Colorado Steve Harvey, contrary to what you may believe about my capacity to understand, I totally understand where you are coming from in the above statement. I have thought deeply about it. My main question to others who I ask about this is “Why are they drawing a correlation between Trump and Hitler?” Now I see from your perspective, but I still think you are making a far stretch here, as far as what is happening or going to happen. I don’t know what else to say : )</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: LR, as far as I know, I am not saying or implying anything about your capacity to understand. And my analogies to Hitler, as well as to Julius Caesar, are for specific purposes, identifying specific similarities. Since I make those similarities explicit, there is no question of it being “a stretch,” unless you can explain why those similarities aren’t in fact real or relevant.</p><p>Again, every position has to be argued rationally and with reference to empirical data to be anything other than an empty ideological assertion. One can believe whatever they want, but, in discourse, the standard should be how well they made their case, not just whether they announced what they believe. My whole point is that reason applied to evidence DOES lead to the conclusions I am drawing (and, frankly, the conclusions shared by virtually everyone else on Earth with relevant expertise or highly developed critical thinking skills), and I make my case why that is so. Simply saying “I have thought deeply about it” is not an actual argument.</p><p>I, and a whole lot of other people, continuously lay out in detail exactly why Trump and the movement surrounding him is not just bad for America, but an existential threat to America as we know it, and dangerous to the world. It may sound like hyperbole to you, simply because any such claim is assumed to be hyperbole, but a lot of very non-hyperbolic people are shouting it very loudly, and there are clearly times in history when it has not been hyperbole; lots of times in history, in fact. So, we have to consider the possibility that it isn’t hyperbole now. And if a cogent argument is being presented as to why it isn’t, simply assuming it is out of habit or convenience isn’t really very convincing.</p><p>A guy named Dan Kanan (if I’m remembering his name correctly) came up with a notion he called “the tragedy of the belief commons.” The tragedy of the commons is one variation of a set of scenarios in which when each individual acts in their own self-interest, the collective outcome is more harmful to everyone involved than had they been able to act cooperatively in their collective interests instead. (Something very relevant here as well.) But the tragedy of the belief commons is that we form our beliefs more as an expression of allegiance to some social identity we hold, while those beliefs may not actually be (and more often than not aren’t) what actually serves our general welfare.</p><p>So, it’s important for each person not just to state what they believe, but to explain why it actually does serve our general welfare. And in a conversation in which one side is doing that and the other is not, the side that is doing it is presumptively the one that has the better claim to be in service to our general welfare, until someone makes a more cogent argument to the contrary.</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: Colorado Steve Harvey My answer comes from my husband who has a Masters in Sociology. Revisionism. Germany the 1930’s was nothing like the USA today. The economy, unemployment, Plus, Germany had never been a democracy, also the Treaty of Versailles, where they were blamed for WWI and had to make reparations and give up land as part of the surrender agreement.</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: Again, I made specific comparisons, explicitly enumerated. You have not addressed any of them. I can help you out with listing differences, if you like: the <em>de facto</em> national languages are different, the populations are different, the size and shape of the territory is different, the longitude and latitude of the capital is different, the currency is different. There is an endless list of differences, all of which are irrelevant to disproving the validity of the specific similarities I named.</p><p>By the way, the Weimar Republic was democratic, and Hitler rose to power through mostly democratic processes.</p><p>Though I know it’s not intentional, I’m going to point out that focusing the debate on the tangential question of whether the comparisons I drew to Nazi Germany are warranted, especially without addressing the actual comparisons I made, is a tactic called “pettifogging,” which involves avoiding the central issue by focusing on tenuously relevant tangential issues, like whether the imposition of German reparations in the Versailles Treaty render comparisons of different instances of authoritarian populism moot (it doesn’t), when the real issue is whether our current crisis of authoritarian populism is dangerous to our republic and to humanity (it is).</p><p><strong>LR</strong>: Colorado Steve Harvey Its because the comparisons you made on the surface seem valid , and I can understand them , if you dig deeper into history , ” that dog won’t hunt ” Why are some people losing their minds over this ? Because a non Politician with no political experience was elected President over all the experts .career politicians , and Washington elites. In short , some peoples world was turned upside down and they just can’t get over it.</p><p><strong>Colorado Steve Harvey</strong>: Okay, I do officially give up at this point. The dog that doesn’t hunt is your willingness to absorb information that utterly destroys any notion of logical, empirical or moral defensibility of the position you hold. You will continue to insist that up is down, in is out, and wrong is right forever, and there’s nothing I can do about that.</p><p>You have the entire world population of people with relevant knowledge, experience and expertise trying desperately to get you to open your eyes (and heart) to a reality you have closed them to. You have argument after argument compellingly showing you that you are, frankly, just plain wrong, in every conceivable way. You have most of the party that supports Trump and all of the party that opposes him, publicly or privately, beside themselves in disbelief and horror at what is happening. And it’s all irrelevant to you.</p><p>What we have is an enormous quantity of evidence that Trump is an authoritarian populist eroding our democratic and constitutional institutions, our norms and conventions that maintain and preserve them, our international alliances, and our basic human decency, stoking fear and hatred, inciting racist and xenophobic rage and violence (there HAS been a rise in hate crimes). And it’s clear that no amount of fact, reason, or appeal to human decency is ever going to have any impact on you at all.</p><p>If you and EB would like to continue this conversation, please feel free to do so, preferably, at this point, elsewhere. It was a noble experiment, asking the question of whether a person dogmatically holding an empirically, rationally, and morally indefensible position but willing to listen to arguments against them could be persuaded to give up that position. The answer, in this case, was no. That’s too bad. But I don’t have an eternity to devote to this experiment. I wish you all the best.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ac3c679e78ba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Draft of a TED-like Talk on Transcendental Politics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@steveharvey_72374/draft-of-a-ted-like-talk-on-transcendental-politics-1a617e25b080?source=rss-78c6b46b7dd1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1a617e25b080</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[humanism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-movements]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reason]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colorado Steve Harvey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Jun 2018 14:35:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-14T17:21:07.862Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I want you all to close your eyes for a few moments and just listen to my voice, using your imaginations to take a quick, accelerating tour of human history. Imagine a tribe of primates on the African savanna that developed speech and fingers with enough dexterity to make more intricate tools out of bones and stones than their predecessors, reproducing faster than they died, diverse cultures emerging as they spread across the face of the Earth, hunting and gathering for hundreds of thousands of years, passing on wisdom and lore throughout the tasks of the day and around a campfire at night. Not so very long ago on the time scale of human existence, agriculture emerged in the Middle East and elsewhere, spreading, an idea, a technology that caught on. Towns emerged, civilizations, monumental architecture, writing, Egypt, Greece, Rome, China, India, Mesoamerica, the Middle Ages, and, just a blink of the eye ago, the onset of the modern era, the Renaissance, the development of science, exploration and the spread of Western Civilization, the Enlightenment, the Industrial Revolution, the political revolutions that turned citizens into sovereigns, emancipation, civil rights, human rights, the information revolution, history accelerating, all coming at us so quickly, the world of my childhood noticeably different from the world of the present, Jim Crow a thing of the past, Apartheid a thing of the past, the Iron Curtain a thing of the past, global poverty dramatically reduced, mass, decentralized, constantly accessible global audiovisual communication and information at our fingertips.</p><p>Now open your eyes and think of where we are now, the technologies we have, the social institutions we have, the lives we live. Progress is real. It’s not without its bumps and brutalities and dangers, but it most certainly is real. And we are not passive recipients of this progress; we are its authors. We are writing this story together, and it is incumbent on us to write it well. It is our sacred duty to do our best to realize as great a breadth and depth of our human potential to do good as we are capable of, because the welfare of billions of people in the present and future is dependent on it.</p><p>The story is not all good, with devastating world wars, nuclear weapons, global warming, violence, brutality, oppression, discrimination, gross inequality, it would be a lie to say that our history is defined only by our progress; it is also defined by the fact that we are talking apes whose awesome technologies pose as many problems as they solve. But we are capable of addressing them; when we’re at our best, we do a pretty impressive job of it. We create institutions that rein in our own worst excesses, and we do so in very sophisticated ways.</p><p>You know, we really do create our future<strong><em> together</em></strong>. It’s not some external force; it’s not even just those in power; it’s all of us. It doesn’t always seem like it, because it is an aggregation of lots of actions by lots of people, and most of us aren’t in leadership positions, or engaged in entrepreneurialism, or in engineering and innovation, or cutting edge science, and so the most visible things, the crests of the waves atop the sea of our existence, are produced by relatively few. But we all have skin in the game, and we all are participants, affecting the whole in ways large and small. We comprise the sea without which those cresting waves can’t occur.</p><p>So what if more of us became excited about what that means? What if more of us took the responsibility of our citizenship in this country and world more seriously, and did so more robustly, more joyfully? What if the willing, the visionaries or aspiring visionaries, the activists or aspiring activists, the youth with their passions waiting to be tapped for good or for ill, the people who want to do their part to create a kinder, gentler, wiser world, what if we all organized a perpetual social movement that wasn’t designed to tackle just one issue in one time and place, like independence from an imperial power, or the abolition of slavery, or women’s suffrage, or the Civil Rights Movements, but rather to tackle the larger issue of which they all are a part, from which they all emanate, and that is, cultivating more reason, more imagination, more empathy, more humility, and more humanity in the world. What if we created a citizen academy, a perpetual, comprehensive social movement, that rallied people to a shared commitment to strive to be more rational, more imaginative, more empathetic, more humble, and more humane?</p><p>Well, it sure wouldn’t be the first time people tried to do such a thing. World religions have some element of this to them, started by people with a vision. We might laud or lament what they became, but, for the most part, they have been vital forces in human history, often for good, sometimes for bad, but robust experiments from which we can learn. And intellectual movements have had some element of this to them as well. The growth of ancient and modern philosophical schools, the development of science, the establishment of universities, all of which have been powerful enzymes of modern human history, didn’t just happen on their own; they involved motivated people, organizing in service to a vision, sometimes facing brutal repression, striving to bring new approaches and institutions and technologies for understanding the world, ourselves, the universe, the microscopic and macroscopic, the tangible and intangible, into our lives, and they certainly have had quite a bit of success, and have had quite an impact on the world. All of these human innovations, social movements, vehicles for the growth of human consciousness and improvement of the human condition, all are slices of this same pie.</p><p>All of these are past iterations, past experiments, and even living organizational realities, from which we can draw, from which we can learn, on which we can build. If we wanted to aspire, if we wanted to really strive to realize humanity’s potential, if we wanted to do our best to cultivate human consciousness and human welfare, why wouldn’t we choose to be more conscientious and intentional about continuing this progression, about learning from past iterations and instances of this process of which we are a part, drawing on them, articulating with them, creating something new out of them that filters out some of what hasn’t worked so well and intentionally develops some of what has worked out very well?</p><p>And that’s what Transcendental Politics really is. Transcendental Politics is the shared endeavor of transcending our tribal identities, our ideological dogmas, our pettiness and egomania, not perfectly or completely — we are mere talking apes, after all — but to the best of our ability, in earnest, and with goodwill. It is an invitation to all people so inclined, to all people who would like to participate in doing better, to all people who want to try to be responsible citizens of their countries and of this Earth, to rally to this common ground of focusing not on what our various tribal identities are and on what our various positions on various issues are, but on an agreement, an underlying commitment to our shared humanity and to utilizing and further developing the most effective and useful procedures for arriving at positions that best serve it.</p><p>Transcendental Politics accepts us each as we are, pro-life or pro-choice, Christian or Muslim or Buddhist or Atheist, conservative or liberal, welcomes us into the fold, and asks only that we all agree to strive, in earnest, to mobilize disciplined reason, imagination, empathy, and humility in service to our shared humanity. We allow all ideas to be placed on the table, because if there’s not agreement on what ideas a commitment to reason and humanity does and does not support, then we need a process that as many people as possible participate in, that is in a context in which we diminish as much as humanly possible feelings of being attacked or disparaged — even for the benefit of those who some might feel are attacking and disparaging others — because if we don’t create a context in which hate is met with kindness, and in which misguided ideas are met with patient reason, and in which we all admit to our own fallibility — we can’t most effectively increase kindness in the world and in ourselves, increase wisdom, increase our humanity. As long as something isn’t stated with overt hostility or in a threatening way, it has to be allowed on the table, because if we don’t bring as many people as possible into this process, in which they feel included rather than excluded, heard rather than silenced, acknowledged rather than disregarded, we can’t bring them along with us on this journey.</p><p>The real political divide isn’t between the left and the right. It’s between the choice to strive to be rational and the choice not to, between the choice to strive to be kind in both form and substance and the choice not. Most of us find ourselves on the wrong side of that divide at some point in our lives, and sometimes even at certain points in any given day. And when we do, are we more effectively drawn back into the fold of reason and kindness by those who attack us and disparage us, or by those who are kind to us and patient with us? I listen to a person who says, “Steve, I love you, but you’re screwing up right now.” I don’t listen to the person who showers me with vitriol. And while it may be true that there are multitudes of people beyond the reach of kindness and reason, there are also multitudes of people within their reach, and we can’t really know which is which until we try. Neo-Nazi white supremacists with swastikas tattooed on their foreheads have been utterly transformed by black guys who were kind to them. Can you imagine that? How powerful i<em>s</em> that?</p><p>Kindness is powerful. Reason is powerful. Humility is wise. Reason depends on humility, on knowing that there is much we don’t know, on knowing that much we think we know, are certain we know, is wrong; reason depends on encountering the world with as much wise uncertainty as possible, leaving our dogmas at the door. Humility, in very short supply in our society and perhaps throughout the world, is thus a cornerstone of Transcendental Politics.</p><p>Obviously, there are lots of potential questions and objections. The objection I probably hear most frequently is that we’re not going to convince fanatical ideologues, of which there are many, to join us in this effort. Right. We won’t. No social movement in history has ever depended on universal membership. None ever started out with more than a handful of people with a vision, rallying others to it, with the majority always shaking their heads dismissively on the sidelines. And yet, human history is full of highly successful social movements that have, cumulatively, carved out our rather amazing existence from the material around us and within us.</p><p>Another is that people aren’t rational, and so social change can’t be driven by trying to be rational. Well, it’s true, as we know from cognitive science, that people are, in many ways, not very rational, and that we are not really driven by evaluating the best arguments but rather by social and psychological forces that pretty much do end runs around reason. But social change very much IS driven by reasonable people appealing to the better angels of our nature, sometimes with soaring oratory, sometimes with courageous confrontations with the evils they are opposing, sometimes just with quiet grace.</p><p>Transcendental Politics is not just a debating club. It is also a social gathering, a barn raising, outings in the wilderness, a way for people of different backgrounds and views to bond first, and discuss later. A lot of our rancor in public discourse is a function of the remoteness and anonymity of social media, whereas people in person, when they first share a task or a game or a hike, tend to be far more cordial with one another. So, Transcendental Politics is very much about promoting reason, but we do so by navigating the realities of what human beings are and what we respond to.</p><p>But, yes, Transcendental Politics is also very much about cultivating reason and empathy, about creating a citizen academy in which critical thinking skills are taught and exercised, in which people are asked and taught how to examine an issue from all sides, to argue against their own passionately held positions, to put themselves in the place of the other, cognitively, emotionally, socially, in order to be better citizens of the world. And, on top of the social bonding components and the critical thinking components, we also will utilize and disseminate state of the art practices for bringing people together to work cooperatively to mutual benefit in resolving differences and arriving at shared understandings and agreements.</p><p>In other words, we’ll create a framework for reasonable people of goodwill to <strong><em>be</em></strong> reasonable people of goodwill. We’ll take the best of what humans have created for working together in service to our shared humanity, and weave it into a new iteration of an ongoing process, one more intentionally focused and refined than most previous iterations of comparable scope. And when I say “we,” I mean all of us. This is not something that can or should be hierarchically controlled. Though we’re forming a nonprofit to help catalyze the movement, its real success depends on it taking off in a decentralized way, with various local experiments in implementing it, with the aid of resources provided to facilitate doing so.</p><p>It’s such a simple idea. It’s such an obvious idea. It’s a little like reinventing the wheel, but with inflated rubber tires instead of just metal or wood on stone. So, come give this new wheel a test drive with me; let’s see how it rolls.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1a617e25b080" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[To Appease or Oppose?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@steveharvey_72374/to-appease-or-oppose-a62c90f4b82f?source=rss-78c6b46b7dd1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a62c90f4b82f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[appeasement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colorado Steve Harvey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Mar 2017 14:45:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-17T15:42:12.955Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This will not be one of my well-crafted posts, incisively nailing some aspect of the reality that envelopes and permeates us. This is more a case of thinking out loud, of trying to make sense of something I can’t quite make sense of, in part because there are competing imperatives at work.</p><p>First, there is the tendency among some, whose inclination I respect and admire, to try to give the benefit of the doubt to those they disagree with, and to treat them with civility and respect and a determination to interpret ambiguities generously rather than unfavorably. And, certainly, what the world needs perhaps more than anything else is more kindness, including more kindness toward the unkind, because kindness has the greatest potential of making them kinder.</p><p>But, in much the same way that (British Prime Minister) Neville Chamberlain’s then-popular commitment to appeasement was exactly the wrong thing to do in the face of Hitler’s rise to power, legitimating the narrative of the current American right (it’s no longer even necessary to qualify that as “far-right,” since their current major party standard bearer — and dangerously unstable and belligerent president of the United States — is as odious as they get) may not be the right approach.</p><p>Just to be clear, I am not conflating interpersonal civility with political appeasement; they are two distinct things. But while formal civility is almost always the right choice, excessive generosity in reading and representing the current narrative of the right may not be.</p><p>On the one hand, there is the question of what, if anything, might persuade those who have supported or currently support Trump and his agenda to cease to support it, to oppose it, to join the ranks of reason and humanity and help us to back away from the brink of brutal infamy on which we have positioned ourselves as a nation. On the other, there is the question of what might consolidate the existing and latent opposition, those who always found Trump at least distasteful (if not horrifying). And underlying those two questions is the one of whether the two agendas might not be at loggerheads, a strategy suitable to one being counterproductive to the other, and, if so, which of the two should gain primacy in the resolution of that inconsistency.</p><p>My personal inclination, often repeated here, is that there is little ground to be gained in the arena of converting those who have supported or currently support Trump un less the former are also among those who find him disgusting and dangerous, and much more ground to be gained by mobilizing everyone else against them, and him.</p><p>Therefore, I do not favor excessive generosity toward Trump supporters, an excessive attempt to shield them from accusations of being ignorant and bigoted or otherwise morally or intellectually defective, because, while the opposite message has to be carefully tailored so as to attract rather than offend the silent majority who are somewhere on the spectrum of aghast, the message should be that we as a society should be ashamed of what we’ve done, and we, as a society, have a moral and social responsibility to ourselves and to the world to undo it as quickly and completely as possible.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a62c90f4b82f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Bonfire of the Vanities]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/series/the-bonfire-of-the-vanities-d9aa28344493?source=rss-78c6b46b7dd1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d9aa28344493</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colorado Steve Harvey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 11 Mar 2017 17:46:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-11T17:53:08.223Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This series is titled for the name of a particular event in the 15th century and the generic kind of event that it was — a public bonfire in which “vanities” such as unsanctioned books, make-up, perfume, and other things frowned upon by the Church, were burned — and a novel by Tom Wolfe, in which the various overreactions of various people led to foolish outcomes.</p><p>I just saw a Salon article on the “antifa” movement, the inevitable left-wing “we need to violently oppose the alt-right, fascist, white supremacist movement of which Trump is now the figurehead,” citing the historical example of Germany, in which, while urbane and civil liberals tried to reason with the Nazis, the Communists and Anarchists were out fighting them on the streets, as if the outcome vindicates either strategy. (It is at least as probable that the Communists and Anarchists going out into the streets to fight the Nazis escalated rather than mitigated the rise of Naziism in Germany.) I won’t post a link to the article, because I don’t want to endorse this movement or spread ITS legitimacy in any way.</p><p>In one perfect illustration of the underlying problem, an antifa member stated that we have to deny free speech to those we disagree with to protect it from them, exactly the kind of rationalization radicals accelerating or causing the destruction of a liberal society typically resort to.</p><p>I’ve long said that one of the biggest dangers Trump poses is the reaction to him on the left. This danger of the reaction is something people need to be more aware of. Immediately after 9/11, my greatest fear was not of Islamic terrorism but rather of the American reaction to it, and we can all now see how well founded that concern was. Trump himself is a product of reaction, the personification of the reactionary right, and now we are discussing whether a reactionary left is the right response to it. It isn’t.</p><p>Trump waltzed into the presidency in the first place because a lot of untempered ideological zealotry, across the spectrum, imposing centrifugal forces on our body politic, ripped open a gaping hole through which he could do so. If everyone who had opposed Trump and what he stands for had kept their cool and held the center, had eschewed their purisms and settled for moderation and sanity, we wouldn’t have a Trump presidency now. America has avoided that fate until now by being a moderate, centrist nation. Preaching the virtues of zealotry and violent reaction is a part of the escalating problem, not a part of the solution to it.</p><p>The article is right about one and only one thing: We can’t normalize and legitimate the odious ideology Trump is currently the figurehead of by pretending that it can be reasoned with, by being “civil” and “polite” and implicitly acknowledging that their point-of-view is a reasonable one that we simply reasonably disagree with, and go forward as if that’s enough. We have to make it emotionally and psychologically and socially costly to be an ignorant racist bigot in America today. Absolutely. I am a staunch believer in that, because while it won’t affect those who are currently adamant Trump supporters, it will affect everyone who isn’t but could be persuaded to be, preventing that from happening, and everyone who is an ambivalent Trump supporter, drawing them away from the brink.</p><p>But we don’t accomplish that by rejecting that which we are supposedly defending; we don’t do it by feeding into the escalating passions and physical, violent expressions of those passions. We do it by being tactically and strategically smart, and staying cool. Because while that provides no guarantee of prevailing, everything else provides a guarantee of failing to, in one way or another. Don’t let your subtle similarities to Trump’s supporters seduce you into becoming a part of the problem; we don’t need any more of it. We need less of it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d9aa28344493" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Bonfire of the Vanities]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@steveharvey_72374/the-bonfire-of-the-vanities-429be88c403a?source=rss-78c6b46b7dd1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/429be88c403a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[reason]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[radicalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reaction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colorado Steve Harvey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 11 Mar 2017 15:56:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-11T15:56:32.871Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I just saw a Salon article on the “antifa” movement, the inevitable left-wing “we need to violently oppose the alt-right, fascist, white supremacist movement of which Trump is now the figurehead,” citing the historical example of Germany, in which, while urbane and civil liberals tried to reason with the Nazis, the Communists and Anarchists were out fighting them on the streets, as if the outcome vindicates either strategy. (It is at least as probable that the Communists and Anarchists going out into the streets to fight the Nazis escalated rather than mitigated the rise of Naziism in Germany.) I won’t post a link to the article, because I don’t want to endorse this movement or spread ITS legitimacy in any way.</p><p>In one perfect illustration of the underlying problem, an antifa member stated that we have to deny free speech to those we disagree with to protect it from them, exactly the kind of rationalization radicals accelerating or causing the destruction of a liberal society typically resort to.</p><p>I’ve long said that one of the biggest dangers Trump poses is the reaction to him on the left. This danger of the reaction is something people need to be more aware of. Immediately after 9/11, my greatest fear was not of Islamic terrorism but rather of the American reaction to it, and we can all now see how well founded that concern was. Trump himself is a product of reaction, the personification of the reactionary right, and now we are discussing whether a reactionary left is the right response to it. It isn’t.</p><p>Trump waltzed into the presidency in the first place because a lot of untempered ideological zealotry, across the spectrum, imposing centrifugal forces on our body politic, ripped open a gaping hole through which he could do so. If everyone who had opposed Trump and what he stands for had kept their cool and held the center, had eschewed their purisms and settled for moderation and sanity, we wouldn’t have a Trump presidency now. America has avoided that fate until now by being a moderate, centrist nation. Preaching the virtues of zealotry and violent reaction is a part of the escalating problem, not a part of the solution to it.</p><p>The article is right about one and only one thing: We can’t normalize and legitimate the odious ideology Trump is currently the figurehead of by pretending that it can be reasoned with, by being “civil” and “polite” and implicitly acknowledging that their point-of-view is a reasonable one that we simply reasonably disagree with, and go forward as if that’s enough. We have to make it emotionally and psychologically and socially costly to be an ignorant racist bigot in America today. Absolutely. I am a staunch believer in that, because while it won’t affect those who are currently adamant Trump supporters, it will affect everyone who isn’t but could be persuaded to be, preventing that from happening, and everyone who is an ambivalent Trump supporter, drawing them away from the brink.</p><p>But we don’t accomplish that by rejecting that which we are supposedly defending; we don’t do it by feeding into the escalating passions and physical, violent expressions of those passions. We do it by being tactically and strategically smart, and staying cool. Because while that provides no guarantee of prevailing, everything else provides a guarantee of failing to, in one way or another. Don’t let your subtle similarities to Trump’s supporters seduce you into becoming a part of the problem; we don’t need any more of it. We need less of it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=429be88c403a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[2017 is 1984]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@steveharvey_72374/2017-is-1984-af86368b3d59?source=rss-78c6b46b7dd1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/af86368b3d59</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fake-news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[orwell]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tweetstorm]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Colorado Steve Harvey]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 05 Mar 2017 23:06:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-05T23:06:09.004Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Trump phenomenon goes beyond the mere propagation of unreliable, generally false information, something that would be serious enough in itself coming from the oval office on such a constant basis. Trump is attempting, consciously or unconsciously, to turn reality on its head. He is the most Orwellian development in this country, ever. He takes a truth that is supported by evidence and stands in opposition to him and buries it by coopting it and inverting it, turning the same words into a lie that serves his agenda. And he does it constantly and relentlessly.</p><p>The term “fake news” is perhaps the best example. Obama and others publicly identified the role that actual fake news — pure fabrications propagated on social media under the guise of news reports — played in Trump’s victory in the presidential election. Trump then coopted the term to refer to the mainstream press — ABC, NBC, CBS, PBS, CNN, BBC, AP, UPI, Reuters, The New York Times, The Washington Post, any news outlet that ever says anything critical of him or inconvenient to him — not only using the bastardization of a legitimate concern to discredit the institution that serves as a bulwark against governmental abuses of power, but also burying that legitimate concern — an increased intensity of published intentional misinformation — that is a vehicle of those very same abuses of power.</p><p>Now Trump is taking legitimate and growing concerns about his administration’s possible collusion with a despotic foreign power to attain his electoral victory and turning it into a false allegation against the last president, by making an arbitrary and unsubstantiated criminal allegation against that last president. And his followers, even his relatively intelligent followers eat it up: Yesterday morning on the Craig Silverman radio show, Craig ambushed me with a question that began, “now that it’s known that Obama wiretapped Trump tower…,” accepting and repeating that allegation as a fact while using it to ignore the more credible and evident facts that it was generated to bury.</p><p>It is hard to overstate how dangerous and troubling this development is.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=af86368b3d59" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>