<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Steven Mayers on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Steven Mayers on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@stevenmayers?source=rss-7d1c53d6469a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 04:39:54 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@stevenmayers/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Opinion | Steven Mayers: Why I’m Not Giving Up on Public Schools]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stevenmayers/opinion-steven-mayers-why-im-not-giving-up-on-public-schools-88a247726547?source=rss-7d1c53d6469a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/88a247726547</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[charter-schools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-schools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Mayers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 Dec 2021 17:36:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-09T17:36:00.468Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In response to <a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/michael-bloomberg-why-im-backing-charter-schools-covid-19-learning-loss-teachers-union-11638371324?fbclid=IwAR3-4s2FR5JOZgMma9KJFmdAEh8TfHMH5joJwkbwn5eMwzKu7fY9UotCEqM">Opinion | Michael Bloomberg: Why I’m Backing Charter Schools</a></p><p>I’m not sure what’s more troubling here, Bloomberg’s hyperbolic assertion that all public schools “are failing,” or that this self-serving advertisement for the charter school industry is given space in the Op-Ed section. The public school system is failing: this has been the battle cry of those set to destroy public schools and them blame them for failing while corporations they own stock in are handed the contacts that public schools should have. And because we deeply care about the education of our children, this battle cry has been rhetorically effective. The assertion that “other nations are rising to this challenge and racing ahead” adds to the rhetoric and leads us onto the slippery slope of looking for silver-bullet answers to student success. It was Bloomberg in New York and Alan Bersin in San Diego that ushered in this new approach to public education, which became nationalized with Bush’s No Child Left Behind and given a shot of steroids with Obama’s Race to the Top, which just expanded Bush’s system.</p><p>As mayor, Bloomberg recalled the public school board and made virtually all the decisions himself while silencing teachers and parents! He didn’t live up to his promises to diversify schools, to lower classroom size. He punished schools for low test scores while allowing charter schools to swoop in with public money and without the accreditation standards that public schools must adhere to and whisk the top test score earners and then label the public schools for “failing,” firing boatloads of teachers and shutting down schools.</p><p>We have measured student success so simplistically using metrics that even the companies that make the tests say are not accurate. There is more than the three r’s. What about community, civic engagement, argumentation? Before this new wave of thinking, schools with low test scores could apply for extra money to run programs to help students; now these schools are punished for low test scores by having their funding reduced and then being shut down and replaced.</p><p>I worked with newcomer students at my son’s public elementary school yesterday, who were “having trouble in math.” I discovered that their biggest challenge was reading and writing in English. In Spanish, they explained the math quite strongly. We need better support for these students at the school. There is no Spanish program for the English speaker and no ESL program for the Spanish speakers in this fairly segregated school where around half are Latinx students.</p><p>Blaming them for low test scores, for bringing down the school’s test scores, and for making the schools “fail” would be shortsighted and unfair, just as the hyperbole of blaming “low test scores” on Covid.</p><p>Has Bloomberg taught in the classroom? Did Bloomberg study education? Have his policies worked to better our public schools? Why is Blomberg telling us how schools should be run? Isn’t it at all suspicious that he wants to destroy a public institution and replace with a business that he benefits from while allowing them public funding without public accountability?</p><p>Bloomberg’s piece is dishonest argumentation. He takes people’s statements out of context. He brings in only the data he wants to. Consider education historian <a href="https://dianeravitch.net/2021/12/02/billionaire-bloomberg-will-give-750-million-to-expand-charter-schools/">Diane Ravitch’s short piece</a> in response.<a href="https://smayers.wordpress.com/#_edn1">[1]</a> She points out, “Although the press release claims that Bloomberg’s decision is based on ‘evidence,’ it completely ignores the large number of charter schools that close every year, the high attrition rates of charter students and teachers, and the multiple studies showing that charter schools are outperformed by public schools, except when the charters curate their enrollment to exclude students who are unlikely to succeed or conform.” She asks, “How does it help the 85–90% of students in public schools to invest in a privately run sector that, contrary to his claims, has not demonstrated success in closing the achievement gap and that poaches students and resources from public schools? How will it ‘close the achievement gap’ to spend $750 million to add 150,000 seats to the charter sector?”</p><p>Like Ravitch, I support the <a href="https://democracyjournal.org/arguments/the-untold-history-of-charter-schools/">original idea behind charter schools</a> but the way they are pitted against our public schools has been disastrous. That we shouldn’t give up on public schools — or social contract — and always try to think deeply about how to best educate our children is true on principle.</p><p><a href="https://smayers.wordpress.com/#_ednref1">[1]</a> To learn more about the effects of Bloomberg’s educational reforms as mayor, I highly recommend her book <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6954133-the-death-and-life-of-the-great-american-school-system"><em>The Death and Life of the Great American School System</em></a>. I also highly recommend her next book, <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/17262199-reign-of-error"><em>Reign of Error: The Hoax of the Privatization Movement</em></a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=88a247726547" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Representing the Other]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stevenmayers/on-representing-the-other-9c357a2b5f00?source=rss-7d1c53d6469a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9c357a2b5f00</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[oral-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[representation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[testimony]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anthropology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Mayers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 13 Aug 2019 21:39:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-12T03:19:24.374Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DuODmYcebosoQDEUC5WAxg.jpeg" /><figcaption>©Library of Congress via pingnews</figcaption></figure><p><em>From the edges of every border, they look back — mud and cardboard kingdoms, from a busted makeshift hotel they pace; huddled, caught by surprise, by their own hunger and history; a broken hotel, made of smoke, revolution, and the strange intersections of global invasions…Outside, the future lurks and stalks.</em></p><p><em>— Juan Felipe Herrera, 1993</em></p><p><strong>Representing the Self</strong></p><p>“How can I write about Mexico?” asks Juan Felipe Herrera, the child of migrant farm workers from Mexico and the Poet Laureate of the United States, upon returning to California from a trip to Chiapas a year before the Zapatista Rebellion of 1994 (2007: 175). In “One Year After the Zapatista Rebellion,” Herrera writes about Juan, a fictionalized version of himself, trying to write from within the borders of the U.S. about indigenous Mexico, trying to see, through the “smoke,” the land of his ancestors. “It was starting over, he could taste it; this uncanny inclination to say something true; to cast out his soul and let it fly in all of its multicolored vapors — with language” (2007: 176). Even as a Latino writer, Juan cannot seem to represent his homeland, his roots, to bring the asymmetrical gazes together, face-to-face, to use the master’s tongue to embody the subjugated people of his homeland. “What writing? What language? Even the term ‘native’ irritated him. He had nothing to say” (2007: 177). “Fixed on tearing the new language out of the old structure,” Juan was determined to create meaning for himself, to understand himself while “swallowing the master’s conquest language in order to liberate oneself…‘I have to become a trickster, a language saboteur” (2007: 181).</p><p>Which theoretical approaches inspire our work as anthropologists, oral historians, writers, speakers, people? Is our writing inspired by science, by art, by both? Whether we are writing an essay about a person, transcribing his or her recorded story, or representing it through some other medium, how can we truly represent the other, even the self? Recollecting the last century, we have seen the field of anthropology move from functionalism to structuralism, and then into the trifurcating schools of postmodern thought on interpretation — those of critical theory, deconstructionism, and hermeneutics — all stabs at representing the other. Representation is the perennial struggle of the anthropologist and the oral historian, as our very presence in the field changes the way those we are attempting to understand act and speak. While we will never be able to fully and accurately embody ourselves let alone others, we must keep in front of us the ideal of truthful representation, a representation to come, remembering our infinite limitations while intending our work towards collective ethical action and the pure, unfiltered truth of the spoken word.</p><p><strong>The Bird’s-Eye View: From Functionalism to Structuralism</strong></p><p>In the early 1930’s, functionalist anthropologists such as German anthropologist Franz Boas undertook the task of “turn[ing] anthropology into a real science” (Lewis 2004: 247). In a 2004 edition of Boas’ 1932 work, <em>Anthropology and Modern Life</em>, Herbert Lewis condenses the general trends in European anthropology throughout Boas’ life, largely focused on racial determinism, its practitioners measuring bodies and skulls in order to group the people of the world into nebulous categories called “races,” and to argue that these so-called biological categories explain the behaviors and characters of people. Dissenting against this trend, “[Boas’] suspicion of universal categories, his rejection of grand narratives, and his stress on diversity and historical contingency were not appreciated then” (Lewis 2004: 248).</p><p>Moving to America in the end of the nineteenth century, Boas developed a new movement in anthropology called functionalism, which endeavored to understand people according to their social functions, and argued that “environment and learning,” that is, nurture, played a role in making up a person’s identity along with one’s biological and genetic nature (2004: 13). “The individual is important only as a member of the group, for we are interested in the factors that determine the distribution of forms or functions in the group” (Boas 2004: 13). Boas was central in developing the notion of culture as central in determining a person’s actions and beliefs. “We must recognize that specific forms of our actions are culturally determined” (Boas 2004: 138). In <em>Anthropology and Modern Life</em>, Boas dedicated two chapters to the idea of race, arguing against the impression of racial purity. In the chapter “Stability of Culture,” he reflects on individual conformity and nonconformity and, comparing cultures, argues that, while “the repetition of the same act without change, generation after generation, gives the impression of a biologically determined instinct,” in reality it reflects a more closed culture with little individual freedom (2004: 133). This belief that behavior was culturally rather than racially determined led to anthropology’s break with racial determinism and turn towards culture.</p><p>Playing a major role in the growth of structural anthropology, French anthropologist Claude Lévy-Strauss is considered by many the father of the intellectual movement of structuralism (Bloch 2009). Driven especially by his early trips in South America and his studies of Amerindians in Brazil, Lévy-Strauss attempted to bring into anthropology an appreciation of the grandeur and complexity of cultures that had been written off as primitive by his contemporaries such as Auguste Comte (Bloch 2009). Witnessing a growing contrast between the real profundity of the people he was attempting to study and the superficiality of Europe’s grand claim to superiority over the less “civilized” cultures, he developed his brand of structuralism, which grew out of his naturalist approach and was nourished by the ideas arising in American cultural anthropology and structural linguistics, particularly the work of Russian linguist Roman Jacobson. While living in New York, Lévy-Strauss began to voice his rejection of the claim of cultural reductionists that “denied the intellectual achievement that indigenous mythology and social thought represented” (Bloch 2009).</p><p><strong>Becoming the Other</strong></p><p>Inspired by French linguist Ferdinand de Saussure and American linguist Leonard Bloomfield, Lévy-Strauss’ nascent notions of structural anthropology lead him to assert that the brain “systematically processed organized, that is to say structured, units of information that combine and recombine to create models that sometimes explain the world we live in, sometimes suggest imaginary alternatives, and sometimes give tools with which to operate in it” (Bloch 2009). This scientific and naturalistic approach involved studying the specific traits of particular languages in order to speculate on their origins and implications. Recognizing that “cognitive could explain structure…but not content,” he dedicated a large portion of his career to studying Amerindian myths, which he considered the real philosophical venture of mankind (Bloch 2009). He wanted to not only record the history of the mythology but to participate in its growth, to enter its subjects of discussion, especially that of ecological reflection.</p><p>Towards the end of his life, Lévy-Strauss expressed a mounting aversion to the narrow scope and sense of entitlement in modern thought, which was focused primarily on studying other things as precisely other to the self, the consecrated subject looking down upon his object from privileged altitudes. In <em>Tristes Tropiques</em>, originally published in 1955, Lévy-Strauss reflects on the traditional concept of the traveler, who only traveled temporarily to witness cultures from the outside, only skimming the surface of the culture’s underlying profundity: “I have only two possibilities: either I can be like some traveler of the olden days, who was faced with a stupendous spectacle, all, or almost all, of which eluded him, or worse still, filled him with scorn and disgust; or I can be a modern traveler, chasing after the vestiges of a vanquished reality” (Lévy-Strauss 1992: 43). In the following chapter, “The Making of an Anthropologist,” Lévy-Strauss recounts his years of studying philosophy at the Sorbonne, and his frustrations with what he called the “mental gymnastics” performed by his colleagues, which incessantly repeated the binary process of comparing and contrasting two views of a problem, building justification and destroying it in an exercise that is “purely verbal, depending, as it does, on a certain skill in punning, which replaces thought” (1992: 51). Offering a “way of escape” from what he saw as the futile, self-indulged circles of thought in philosophy, he took refuge in the field of anthropology, though within the field he became evermore disenchanted by the “chronic rootlessness” of the anthropologist: “While remaining human himself, the anthropologist tries to study and judge mankind from a point of view sufficiently lofty and remote to allow him to disregard the particular circumstances of a given society or civilization” (Lévy-Strauss 1992: 55). Critiquing Marx, Kant and Hegel, he says, “Understanding consists in reducing one type of reality to another; that the true reality is never the most obvious; and that the nature of truth is already indicated by the care it takes to remain elusive” (1992: 57–58).</p><p><strong>Emplotment: Anthropology’s Turn to Language</strong></p><p>From race and culture, anthropology turns to language. Clifford Geertz, an American anthropologist born in San Francisco in 1926, was inspired by “the literary turn of postmodernism” (Lewis 2004: 256). <em>Ritual and Social Change</em>, one of Geertz’s first articles (originally published in 1959), argues against the functionalist approach and calls for a new approach that takes into account the symbolic cultural forms as well social structure (1973: 142–149). In <em>Clifford Geertz: Culture, Custom and Ethics</em>, Fred Inglis outlines Geertz’s attempt to develop semiotics into a science that recognized signs not only as tools with which to communicate, but as ways of thinking. Geertz strove for a hermeneutics of representation that drew upon the enlightenment’s faith in human reason, as well as in modernism, literary criticism and anthropology, imagining a place “where the big old world simply refers to the effort all of us make to catch hold of and shake into an intelligible version of itself the strange estrangements of other people” (Inglis 2000: 3). While many anthropologists in the last few decades have been immersed in deconstructionism, which is centered in a distrust of language as a means of creating meaning and understanding, Geertz’s anthropology saw language as a medium through which both the universal and particular qualities of the human condition could be understood.</p><p>Geertz’s anthropology of interpretation grew out of his studies of literature, from Falkner and Melville to James and T.S. Elliot, and his fascination with New Criticism, whose proponents convicted that “[literary interpretation] was a serious and highminded undertaking and to write about it well was to write, in the real language of men and women, about matters of life and death” (Inglis 2000: 7–8). Geertz brought the works of linguist J.L. Austin and literary critic and philosopher Kenneth Burke into anthropology, which he saw as less “abstract and unempirical” (Inglis 2000: 9). Austin’s theory of performative language, “or words like promising, cursing or marrying,” which “are active <em>in themselves</em>, and constitute doing in the very speaking of them,” inspired Geertz to ground his work in the ontological and ethical nature of language. Burke’s idea of dramatism as a mode of interpretation, which distinguished between practical and symbolic acts, led Geertz to formulate that the “‘real is as imagined as the imaginary,’ that public action, symbolic of ourselves, is all there is to go on” (Inglis 2000: 10). In anthropology, Geertz saw the ethical responsibility of the interpreter to imagine a reading of the world that sees world peace and justice as possible futures.</p><p>In <em>Local Knowledge</em>, originally published in 1983, Geertz places all of the humanities and social sciences into the realm of anthropology in a movement of “intellectual deprovincialization” (2000: 3): “To produce a description of modern thought that can account for the fact that such assorted enterprises as herpetology, kinship theory, fiction writing, psychoanalysis, differential topology, fluid dynamics, iconology, and econometrics can form for us any category at all, it is necessary to see them as social activities in a social world” (2000: 14). Striving to put to an end all of the “mental gymnastics” that Levi-Strauss (1999: 51) had seen in the field of philosophy, Geertz tried to steer the field of anthropology away from the empirical sciences and towards a poetic and linguistic search for understanding that placed language at the center of one’s ontology. Inspired by the “penetration of the social sciences by the views of such philosophers as Heidegger, Wittgenstein, Gadamer [and] Ricoeur,” Geertz finally called for a hermeneutics of interpretation in which the anthropologist understood himself in relation to the de-capitalized other. “To see ourselves as others see us can be eye-opening” (Geertz 2000: 16).</p><p><strong>Narrative Form and Meaning</strong></p><p>Paul Ricoeur’s climactic work, <em>Oneself as Another </em>(1983)<em>,</em> sets out to serve as “a reflexive meditation on the self or subject; a dialectic on the meaning of the word <em>meme</em> or ‘same’ in the sense of identical <em>(idem)</em> or in the sense of ‘one in the same’ <em>(ipse)</em>, or selfhood; a dialectic between the self and the ‘other’” (Reagan 2002: 4). Placing himself between Descartes and Nietzsche, “from its apology of the cogito and from its overthrow” (Reagan 2002:4), Ricoeur sets out to demonstrate how <em>ipse</em>, or selfhood, the part of a person’s identity that changes throughout life, shares dialectical relationships with both <em>idem</em>, or sameness, the character of a person that stays the same, and with the other, both in the sense of another person, and in the sense of the inherent dialectical tension between these two poles of personal identity. It is through the story that personal identity is formed, from reflection upon and recreation of the past. Ricoeur’s theory of narrative identity is based on, first, the dialectic of sameness and selfhood, and, second, narrative’s relationship with actions and morals. Through the configuring of the plot through his three-part cycle of Mimesis, he point us down a circular path on which the past is brought together with an imagined future in order to establish a configured present, and thereby facilitate the acts of forgiving, healing, and moving into the world of ethical action. In his words: “We are following therefore the destiny of a prefigured time that becomes a refigured time through the mediation of a configured time” (Ricoeur 1983: 54). Through the <em>emplotmet</em> of narratives, configuration comes in to serve as a mediator between concordance and discordance. Ricoeur’s seminal work, <em>Time and Narrative, </em>sets out to exemplify the synthesizing ability of a plot to “grasp together” the “plot, goals, causes and chance” into a “temporal unity” through the “productive imagination” (1983: ix, x). Basing his vision on Aristotle’s theory of mimesis in <em>Poetics</em>, Ricoeur expands this idea to make up a mimetic spiral that brings together Mimesis1, the pre-figured past, with Mimesis3, the re-configured past, in order to create a Mimesis2, the configured present.</p><p>In light of Geertz’s ideas of interpretive anthropology, Ricoeur’s critical hermeneutics, and Habermas’ critical theory, anthropologist Ellen A. Herda began to develop a malleable framework for interpretation in the field of anthropology. In <em>Research Conversations and Narrative: A Critical Hermeneutic Orientation in Participatory Inquiry</em>, Herda “presents practical examples of participatory research based in a critical hermeneutic tradition where researchers and research participants worked collaboratively on the problem, and a determination of meaning and significance of the problem at hand” (1999: 3).</p><p>Herda uses Gadamer’s notion of horizons to express the goal of the anthropological researcher: “Gadamer (1988: 269) uses the image of horizons to express the limitations and potentials of our understandings” (1999: 5). The anthropologist recognizes that his presence in the field affects the research process itself; therefore, the goal of the researcher is to work with the research participants to create a “fusion of horizons,” whereby researcher and research participants strive to first recognize their limitations of understanding and second to fuse these horizons in mutual understanding (Herda 1999: 5). Central to participatory research is Ricoeur’s conception of <em>mimesis</em>, this spiral of text and interpretation that places researcher and research participant in time together, endeavoring to reconfigure the present through imagining a shared future, and the understanding of the pre-figured past.</p><p>Instead of conducting interviews in which the qualitative researcher approaches the interviewee’s responses from an objective distance, the participatory researcher takes place in research conversations that are grounded in an ontological expedition for understanding and ethical action. “The transcripts of the conversations between researcher and research participant are shared with the participant so that the participant can see the course of discussion, change parts of their conversation that, upon reflection, they disagree with, and/or provide additional insights” (Herda 1999: 120). In the spirit of Austin and Geertz, a common language is developed in which researcher and research participants steer conversations towards understanding. “For every conversation there is a common language or there is a creation of a common language among interlocutors” (Herda 1999: 121). The researcher and participant collaborate in the creation of understanding: “This process can help build a community of memory among various participants setting he ground for continuation of work after the research project is completed” (Herda 1999: 120). The participatory researcher is guided towards <em>praxis</em>, meaningful action. “Participatory Research in a critical hermeneutic tradition invokes language, understanding and action” (Herda 1999: 1). It is the idealistic quest for reconstruction in face of deconstruction, its dialectical partner. “We need to acknowledge and understand that humans have the capacity to live in community and to address and solve problems together in organizations and social settings” (Herda 1999: 1).</p><p><strong>Intentionality, Orality and the Subjective Truth</strong></p><p>The practice of <em>testimonio</em>, or what Mary Louise Pratt calls auto-ethnography, removes the interpretive field between the writer, the interviewer, and the speaker, in order to expose a pure and unadulterated personal narrative from an intentional witness and speaker. The word <em>testimonio</em> in Spanish carries the connotation of an act of truth telling in a religious or legal sense — <em>dar testimonio </em>means to testify, to bear truthful witness. Testimonio’s ethical and epistemological authority derives from the fact that we are meant to presume that’s its narrator is someone who has lived in his or her person, or indirectly through the experiences of friends, family, neighbors, or <em>significant others</em>, the events or experiences that he or she narrates (Beverly 2004: 3).</p><p>Professor of Hispanic Languages and Literatures John Beverly argues that the speaker in <em>testimonio</em> is called to speak by having bore witness to events caused by hegemony, that of the U.S. in particular. “Today the context in which <em>testimonio </em>is read and debated is not the Cold War but globalization, not a bipolar world but one dominated by U.S. military and geopolitical hegemony” (Beverly 2004: x). Having both witnessed and suffered the consequences of repression, the testifier’s need to communicate is what gives the account its authority. “In <em>testimonio,</em> by contrast [to oral history, in which “it is the intentionality of the recorder”], it is the intentionality of the narrator that is paramount. The situation of narration in <em>testimonio</em> has to involve an urgency to communicate, a problem of repression, poverty, subalternity, imprisonment, struggle for survival, implicated in the act of narration itself” (Beverly 2004: 32).</p><p>In “What Makes Oral History Different,” published in 1979 by Italian oral historian Alessandro Portelli, he argues that orality, narrative form, subjectivity, the “different credibility” (2006: 37) of memory, and the relationship between the interviewer and interviewee are what “make oral history interesting” (2006: 41). Speaking on the process of turning an audio recording into a visual transcript, Portelli notes: “The tone and volume range and the rhythm of popular speech carry implicit meaning and social connotations which are not reproducible in writing” (2006: 34). In a section of the essay subtitled “Should we believe oral sources,” he argues, “The importance of oral testimony may not lie in its adherence to fact, but rather in its departure from it, and imagination, symbolism, and desire emerge. Therefore, there are no ‘false’ oral sources” (Portelli 2006: 37). From Portelli, we learn that the audio recording of a testimony is a truer representation of the person than the written transcript, that oral histories beak down the illusion of objectivity, and that the narrative form of oral history created symbolic and poetic meaning. Finally, Portelli celebrates oral history’s counter to the historian’s “ventriloquizing” of his “discourse” “through the narrator’s testimony,” with a counter-hegemonic voice of the people: “the recounting of a strike through the words and memories of workers rather than those of the police and the (often unfriendly) press obviously helps (though not automatically) to balance a distortion implicit in these sources” (2006: 40). Portelli recognizes the primacy of the recorded spoken word, spoken by the one that experiences hegemony.</p><p>Praxis grows out of the space where personal memory and collective memory meet. In “Anzac Memories: Putting popular memory theory into practice on Australia,” Australian oral historian and Professor of History at the School of Philosophical, Historical and International Studies at Monash University in Melbourne Alistair Thompson reflects on his conversations with Fred Ferrel a Melbourne working-class veteran of the Great War. “Fred Ferrel’s case highlights the dynamic relationship between individual memory and national myth…These understandings can enable us to practice more effectively as historians and in collective struggle for more democratic and radical versions of our past and of what we can become” (Thompson 2006: 253). Here, Thomson seems to speak to Ricoeur’s reconfigured present, which class for meaningful action.</p><p>In a 1997 interview with British oral historian Tony Parker, Studs Turkel, considered by many to be the father of American oral history, speaks of the uncharted role of the oral historian: “You’re Columbus, you’re setting out onto the unknown sea. There are no maps, because no one’s been there before” (Turkel 2006: 123). The witness and the oral historian together trump the conquistador’s quest for eternal youth, gold, and fame with personal truth that is intended towards praxis. Like testimonio, oral history is a counter-historic, counter-hegemonic act, and like the critical hermeneutic representation of the self as the other, oral history merges with personal with the collective through its narrative form. In 2015, Ukrainian oral historian Sletvana Alexievich won the Nobel Prize in Literature. Recognizing oral history as art as well as history, the committee celebrated her “polyphonic writings, a monument to suffering and courage in our time.” In her acceptance speech, she states: “Right after the war, Theodor Adorno wrote, in shock: ‘Writing poetry after Auschwitz is barbaric.’ My teacher, Ales Adamovich, whose name I mention today with gratitude, felt that writing prose about the nightmares of the 20th century was sacrilege. Nothing may be invented. You must give the truth as it is. A ‘super-literature’ is required. The witness must speak. Nietzsche’s words come to mind — no artist can live up to reality. He can’t lift it.”</p><p>While I don’t share Adorno’s sentiment that writing poetry is barbaric, I do strongly agree that the need to share stories, to listen to the story of he other, is colossal. The orality of the spoken word in its pure form, with its variations in pitch, tone, tempo, melody, and harmony, might our closet embodiment of ourselves, and of each other.</p><p><strong>Bibliography</strong></p><p>Alexievich, Sletvana. 2015. “Nobel Lecture.” Stockholm, Sweeden.</p><p>Beverly, John. 2004. Testimonio: On the Politics of Truth. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.</p><p>Bloch, Maurice. 2009. “Claude Lévy-Strauss Obituary.” London: The Guardian.</p><p>Boas, Franz. 2004e. Anthropology and Modern Life. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers.</p><p>Geertz, Clifford. 2000e. Local Knowledge: Further Essays in Interpretive Anthropology. 3rd ed. Basic Books.</p><p>Geertz, Clifford. 1973e. Ritual and Social Change: A Javanese Example In The Interpretation of Cultures. New York: Basic Books.</p><p>Herda, Ellen A. 1999. Research Conversations and Narrative: A Critical Hermeneutic Orientation in Participatory Inquiry. Westport: Praeger Publishers.</p><p>Herrera, Juan Felipe. 2007. “One Year After the Zapatista Rebellion.” 187 Reasons Why Mexicanos Can’t Cross the Border. San Francisco: City Lights Books.</p><p>Inglis, Fred. 2000. Clifford Geertz: Culture, Custom and Ethics. Cambridge: Polity Press.</p><p>Lévy-Strauss, Claude. 1992e. Tristes Tropiques. New York: Penguin.</p><p>Lewis, Rebert. 2009. “The Passion of Franz Boas.” Anthropology and Modern Life. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers.</p><p>Portelli, Alessandro. 2006e. “What Makes Oral History Different.” The Oral History Reader. 2nd ed. Eds. Robert Perks and Alistair Thompson. London: Routeledge.</p><p>Ricoeur, Paul. 1983. Time and Narrative: Volume 1. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.</p><p>Thompson, Alistair. 2006e. “Anzac Memories: Putting popular memory into practice in Australia.” The Oral History Reader. 2nd ed. Eds. Robert Perks and Alistair Thompson. London: Routeledge.</p><p>Turkel, Studs. 2006e. “Interviewing an Interviewer.” The Oral History Reader. 2nd ed. Eds. Robert Perks and Alistair Thompson. London: Routeledge.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9c357a2b5f00" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Grizél Betanco: I Need to Break the Cycle]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stevenmayers/griz%C3%A9l-betanco-i-need-to-break-the-cycle-108793d1d997?source=rss-7d1c53d6469a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/108793d1d997</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[migrants]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[central-america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[refugees]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[child-migrant-stories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[migrantes]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Mayers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 13 Aug 2019 20:30:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-13T22:56:09.628Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LLkkLD7rasBqEMmtrY9Ulw.jpeg" /><figcaption>La 72 Hogar-Regugio Para Personas Migrants, © Steven Mayers</figcaption></figure><p><em>We meet Grizél at the La 72 migrant shelter in Tenosique de Pino Suárez, Tabasco, Mexico, a town of thirty thousand that was founded in the preclassic Maya period around 1,000 BC. It’s July of 2014 and although the relative lack of tropical rain this week has cleared many of the mosquitos away, the jungle humidity and staggering temperatures make everyone at the shelter congregate in the shady spots next to buildings and umbrellas. Named after the 72 mostly Central American migrants who were massacred by Los Zetas in the state of Tamaulipas in northeastern Mexico, La 72 is run by a Franciscan priest named Fray Tomás Gonzáles, known for his large-brimmed hat and blue jeans and for his unswerving dedication to human rights. As Tenosique sits on one of the two main migrant routes along Mexico’s southern border, many organizations and journalists visit the shelter and data that the shelter collects serves as kind of a barometer on the migrant crisis. At twenty-seven, Grizél is a mother of three: a six-year-old daughter, an eight-year-old son, and a nine-year-old daughter. She has survived the trauma of domestic violence as well as the violence of feuding landowners, who murdered her brother. In the state of Olancho, multigenerational feuds between landowning families take many lives including those of people who accidentally walk across the corner of a plot of land. Grizél left her daughters in Juticalpa, Olancho, Honduras with their grandmother and is traveling with her son. She hopes to make it to the United States and send for her daughters. Grizél is fiercely determined for her children to have a better life and won’t give up.</em></p><p>THEY DON’T LIKE PEOPLE WALKING ON THEIR LAND</p><p>I know that someday we’ll leave all of this behind. I feel that my children have never been happy even though they play and have fun. When I was little, I played. I watched TV. But I saw how my parents fought, how they grabbed each other. My mom would hit us a lot, would mistreat us. We played, but we played as if we were our parents. I said to my brother, “You’re dad and I’m mom.” And we started to do the same things as our parents, fighting with each other, grabbing each other. It’s like that. That stayed with us. Psychologists and doctors here at the shelter have seen me. They were really rude to me, and to my son especially. In Roatán they wanted to take my children away from me. They started to tell me a lot about how to treat them better. And so I said to myself, <em>enough with repeating the same story that my mother started</em>. <em>I need to break the cycle of fighting in the house.</em></p><p>I completed fourth grade in the schools in Honduras. I liked math the best. My family had some bad luck and my mom and dad died when I was little, seven years old perhaps. A teacher took care of me. She only taught me up until third grade, and when I was older, about twelve or thirteen, an uncle came to get me and took me to a village outside of the city. It is called Santa Elena, toward Palestina.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> He lived with his wife and daughters. He only gave them limited food. He said if I wanted to continue to study, I had to work on his coffee farm. I would pick coffee in order to finish the next grade in school. I got up to fourth grade picking coffee but then I got sick. It could have been from the coffee plants, but I don’t know. From there things got bad. My uncle started to say bad things to me. I was thirteen then.</p><p>I suffered. They yelled at me. They hit me now and then. So I didn’t keep studying. My uncle said that if I wanted to study more, I had to work. Having grown up in the city without anything, without parents, nobody taught me anything, I didn’t know how to do anything. Parents sometimes teach their kids how to work, how to make a living. I had to work to earn money to buy myself clothing.</p><p>When I was about fifteen years old, this guy proposed to me. I had been saying to my uncle that I didn’t want to get married, but my brother said, “If you don’t want to suffer anymore with our uncle, do it.” And I asked him, “But what am I going to do after getting married?” At fifteen I felt I had to marry someone. After that, another type of suffering started. My siblings came to live with me. My brother taught me to make food, to make tortillas. I’m grateful to him. I would leave the house for work. I also had a sister living with me at the time. She was sick. She needed a lot of care. I took her in. And so what happened when I left for work? My daughter found my husband having sex with my sister. I left him and now they are together.</p><p>Then my brother was killed. I don’t know if they were related to my parents, those people. They shot my brother three different times. At first, they couldn’t kill him because someone saved his life. The third time they killed him. The first time, I was with him. He had a bullet stuck in his side that the friends that helped him couldn’t take out. He took it out himself. The second time they shot him again, he escaped from the hospital. The third time they shot him, I didn’t find out about it until later. I had gone to Tegucigalpa. He went to another village called Dulce Nombre de Culmí. They finished him off there last year.</p><p>I believe the people who killed him are cattle owners. You had to go past their paddock to get to the street. My brother would walk past their land even though they prohibited us from going there. That’s when it started, fighting over their land. They don’t like people walking on their land over there. That was the first time they shot him, when they saw him walking by. The second time, I don’t know why they shot him. The last time, on December 31, he was going to buy food for his family. I was away, and then I went to spend New Year’s Day with my family. When I arrived, I found to my surprise at about two in the morning, last year on January 1, that they had killed him. So the pain started. The crying started. When his friends brought him over, he was missing an ear. They had cut it off. They had tortured him. They cut him with a machete. I suppose the landowners had ordered them to kill him, because they took his ear as proof.</p><p>He was twenty-eight. He left behind a wife and three young children. Now his wife has remarried and the kids are with her. She doesn’t let our family see them or help her. She doesn’t let us do anything. Maybe it’s pride. It could be that it was her fault, too, because she stayed with one of men that had killed my brother. For us it was really difficult when they killed him. Before that they had killed an uncle, too, sliced him up. They threw him in a black bag and brought him to another uncle. That uncle was traumatized and stayed that way. I don’t know who killed him.</p><p>And someone also killed my mom’s brother, my mom, and my father. They killed them with a root called <em>camotillo</em>. They say that depending on how long the plant has been cut, that’s how long the person lasts. They cut that plant and dry it. They give it to the person they hate. If it is dried for fifteen days, the person lasts for fifteen days. If you dry it for a week and give it to the person, they last a week. They first killed my dad. He lasted three months. I heard the story about how they killed him from my older siblings. It gives you bloody diarrhea and grows in the stomach. My mom spent more than a year like that, vomiting with bloody diarrhea. That’s how it killed them. According to my siblings, it was our very own aunt who killed them, and over a land dispute as well. There are people who butt heads and hurt each other in the same family.</p><p>Not so long ago, about six months ago, my own cousin was doing things like that to me, with witchcraft. It’s common there. I would have been killed in the same way as my parents if I hadn’t left. I visited a family and they told me I wasn’t well. I started to see ugly things. I didn’t sleep well and everything hurt. I didn’t sleep all night. Then my family noticed that things were happening to me and they cured me.</p><p>About two months ago, I was renting a little room. I’m a single mother. A neighbor woman appeared and started to treat me badly. She said that I was a single bitch and that one can kill a dog that is alone. I don’t understand why from one moment to the next she became my enemy. She threatened me with a pistol. She said she wanted to fight with me, but she didn’t have the guts to fight me with her hands, so she grabbed a pistol and said she was going to kill me. A guy defended me. He told her not to do it because if she did, she would have problems with him. From then on I don’t count on anybody. So I said to myself, <em>If I don’t do what’s good for me, no one else will. I’m not going to depend on anyone.</em> I decided to follow this path. I said, “I’m going to fight for myself.” That’s why I’m here. This same courage helps me. But thank God I’m on this path and I didn’t lack the courage to leave.</p><p>There are people who don’t like to help others. I have another sister I asked to stay with. I’ve lived with her two, three times and she’s thrown me out. She said she was tired of having me there. One time she threw me into a pile of mud. I got my things. My kids saw all of that, the humiliation. Another time when I stayed with her, she got tired of having me there, and she came over and threw my clothes outside. Maybe the problem is that when my mom got sick, we didn’t grow up together. I grew up with the teacher. One of my sisters, the one who took my husband away from me, lived with an aunt. And another grew up with an uncle and lived in a lot of different places. Another sold gum in the streets. My older brothers joined gangs. When people grow up that way, they never get to know their brothers and sisters. I got curious about getting to know them, living with them, but brothers and sister who grow up together don’t love each other that much. I chose this path and nobody knows that I’m here. It doesn’t matter to them, so why would I tell them? I sometimes talk with one of them, and she supports me a little bit. But she doesn’t believe me. She says that my stories are lies, that she doesn’t believe me one bit.</p><p>THE DEPARTURE WAS SUDDEN</p><p>I left on Monday the fourth, two weeks ago. Two young women were leaving. They had children as well. They said they were going to help me with food and things like that, and that it would cost me 2,000 Honduran lempiras.<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a> They were leaving for here and told me that if I wanted to come along, I could. They said, “We’re going tomorrow.” That was Sunday. “So come at nine on Monday.” The departure was sudden.</p><p>My boy was doing badly too. Kids humiliated him in school and in public because he has problems speaking. They hit him, and it hurts me because I’m a mom. It’s not my fault and it’s not his fault. I said to him that one day we were going to leave that place. That was my motive for bringing him. One time they were bullying him and he came up running and sweating. I asked him what had happened and he said they almost raped him. I took the fastest road out of there. Imagine sending your kid to school and then he returns traumatized, worried. Sometimes he doesn’t talk and I ask him, “What happened to you?” He doesn’t tell me how they humiliated him, how they did something to him so that he wouldn’t talk. That hurt me.</p><p>We left at nine in the morning and traveled from Olancho to Tegucigalpa. We left from Tegucigalpa at nine that night in an express bus to the capital. In Guatemala one of the women started to fight with me. She liked to smoke marijuana. She said a bunch of things, and I told her not to talk like that because we were all going to pay for it. She expressed herself really badly. She was touching everything and everyone. She wanted to have sex and smoke marijuana, and she started to get crazy. I told her to calm down because if people heard her, they were going to think that we were the same. When we got here to Tenosique, they went off to look for a hotel and we started to fight again, saying that I was a hindrance. I said, “Do you know what? From now on, I’m going to part ways with you guys.”</p><p>They stayed at the Hotel Fuente, right around the corner from the shelter. They started to fight with me again, saying I was an ungrateful burden, asking me why I was there. I said, “Well, I paid money.” One of them said, “In Guatemala, you should have left and taken your own trip. You shouldn’t have come with us.” I said, “Okay, starting now, I’ll travel separately from you guys.” I flagged down a taxi and it brought me here to the shelter. When I got to the central plaza, a man arrived, and said, “I’ll give you twenty pesos. Go in a taxi.” It was nine at night. I was crying, and I said to the taxi driver, “Take me to the migrant shelter.”</p><p>On Sunday morning I was feeling bad because they had said bad things about me. They left me behind and kept going. I was doing badly because of all this sadness, and I went to look for them. I was told that they had left.</p><p>A MOTHER ALWAYS THINKS OF HER KIDS</p><p>What dream do I have in life? Well, my biggest dream is to work, to fight hard for my kids, to go to the United States, to own my house. I want to have a place to live, not to have to go around asking for a place to stay, having to walk from place to place. They throw us out of places. To wander around this way is not fair. If I can, I want to fly my daughters to the United States so that they have the opportunity to study, to work. I don’t want my kids to suffer like I’ve suffered. People have hit me, done a lot of things to me, so I don’t want them to go through that.</p><p>I have one son and two daughters. My daughters stayed in Honduras, with their grandma on my father’s side. I couldn’t bring all of my children with me. Without money to give them food, I don’t think it’s easy. I brought my son because he’s quieter. I see that my daughters chat more. He doesn’t chat.</p><p>My kids know about my brother’s death. They were there. They saw him when they brought him over, without an ear, all cut up and everything. They’ve seen all of that. My older daughter says that when they grow up they’ll get even, but I say, “Kids, leave these problems behind. Leave them to God.” I say, “One day we’ll have a place to live so we don’t have to suffer anymore.” Sometimes people humiliate people without houses who go around like this. Those who have houses enjoy seeing others suffer. There are people who enjoy that.</p><p>My son is very happy. Sometimes I say to him, “Let’s go back to Honduras,” and he says, “No, let’s go to the States.” Now he talks. He plays here. Nobody looks at him badly here. Here he’s happy. In Honduras, he wasn’t. You can see the happiness in him. He’s not the boy that looked so shut off, the boy that was bullied, that was called many things: a mute, a stutterer, even gay. And he’s a child. He is really shy. That bothers me. After someone that you know has been killed, any personal problem you encounter makes you afraid that someone will be killed again, maybe you. People are even killed for defending their own kids. So I said, “It’s better to leave there.” I have hope in God that my kids will leave there.</p><p>It’s really difficult to leave my daughters behind. My youngest girl told me, “Mom, never leave us. Moms who do that don’t love their kids.” I told her, “My daughter, someday you’ll understand why.” And I only ask of God that I can achieve my dreams: to arrive, to get a house, and make sure that they have a place to live and that they don’t have to go through what I went through, suffering and humiliation. The dream starts now. I spoke with one of my daughters. I said to her, “I’m in Mexico.” She says it doesn’t matter where I am, but it matters that I call and take care of her. She told me, “I love you to the stars.” My boy says, “Mom, don’t get married again because then you’ll go to another man and another woman will take him away.” He’s so young, but they understand, they see, they hear. The girl too, she’s the same. She says, “If you get married, don’t think that we’ll call him <em>Dad</em>. No, we’re not going to want to.” But I will have to think about getting married. “Someday we’re going to grow up; we’re going to work, and we’re going to help you.” That’s what they say.</p><p>Moving is like being born again, because you put things behind you and start another life, do new things. And you say, <em>Here I am. And I want my son who is here to be happy. </em>But it’s always in my mind that I want my kids who aren’t here to be here too. They’re going to stop suffering and they’re going to study. They’re going to have a better life. That’s what they’ve asked from me. My boy is the one who’s asked me for the most. I tell him that if he wants to get ahead he has to dedicate himself to his studies. He’s good at studying. He’s such an understanding kid that he even eats what he should. He never says, “No, this isn’t good.” He’s conscious. When prices rose at the school, I said, “I don’t have money. I can’t buy you more things.” So he started gathering money, peso by peso. And when he gets enough together he buys his colored pencils, his eraser, his pencils, whatever’s missing. Once he said to me, “Mom, this is the teacher that you have to pay the restroom fee to. I started to cry. I said, “My God, I don’t have anything.” He said, “Don’t worry. I paid ahead.” He’s very young, but he’s incredible. He makes me cry.</p><p>When he’s eating something and sees that another person isn’t eating or doesn’t have food, he shares it. My youngest daughter, when she sees a girl who is naked, she bathes her, puts clothes on her. She goes up to her and starts to give her a bath and to change her clothes. She says, “Poor thing, mom.” She says, “Someday, we’re going to be rich.”</p><p>My daughters understand too. My younger daughter is very smart. She asks God for everything to go well and to help us get out of poverty and away from so much suffering. She says that if I get scared, she does too, because she is watching. She watches and she listens. She wants to get out of poverty. She wants to do so many things. She sees how her little brother was mistreated. She says, “I want to go with my brother to save him from everything they do to him.” And she’s the youngest. They are the ones who give me the strength to keep going. Kids are the ones who give you strength to move forward because you don’t do it for yourself; you do it for your kids.</p><p>A father has it easier finding work. Mothers go above and beyond and offer their children the moon and the stars, and they fall into the trap. The man works, and it’s easier to raise a kid. For a single mother, it’s not easy, with the little that she earns, having to take care of the children and pay for school. There are men who have offered me money. They even ask for my body in exchange for things. There are women who foolishly fall into the trap easily. Things shouldn’t be like that. But a mother always thinks about her kids, always. Sometimes they have food, but they’re missing love. They need love, too. And sometimes you have to abandon them out of necessity, because of so much poverty and so many other things that happen.</p><p>I feel like I only want positive things, positivity. Leaving my country, I know I’m going to do something. I know I come with a purpose, to keep fighting, to fight for my kids. I’m never going to say, “They’re going to get me and they’re going to send me back.” No. I only think of positive things. If we left there, it’s because God has something in store for us. And I’m worried about my kids, too. A mom worries if her kids don’t have enough underwear, if they’re missing other things, if they’re eating well or not. And it’s sad. It’s hard. Sometimes my son asks me how long it will be until we get to the States, until we finish with this. I tell him I don’t know and it pains me.</p><p>The people who run the shelter say that I should apply for asylum to work and live freely in Mexico. It’s like a lottery. You go, and the people with luck get it.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Santa Elena is a village in the municipality of Campamento, known for its coffee production, in southern Olancho state, about 60km from Juticalpa. Palestina is a village on the banks of the Cuchillo River in southern Olancho state, about 88km south of Juticalpa.,</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> 2,000 is about 85 USD.</p><p>To support the L 72 migrant shelter, please visit: <a href="https://la72.org/donar/">https://la72.org/donar/</a></p><figure><img alt="La 72 Hogar-Regugio Para Personas Migrants, © Steven Mayers" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*brfPKhqWwYo5jG4T1xgTHg.jpeg" /><figcaption>La 72 Hogar-Regugio Para Personas Migrants, © Steven Mayers</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=108793d1d997" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Madre de los Migrantes: An interview with Guadalupe Serrano of Casa de la Caridad in San Luis…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stevenmayers/madre-de-los-migrantes-an-interview-with-guadalupe-serrano-of-casa-de-la-caridad-in-san-luis-9dcd98341bd2?source=rss-7d1c53d6469a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9dcd98341bd2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[youth-migrants]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[immigration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[refugees]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[casa-de-migrantes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[central-american-migrants]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Mayers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Jul 2019 18:43:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-13T22:57:56.764Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Madre de los Migrantes: An interview with Guadalupe Serrano of Casa de la Caridad in San Luis Potosí</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/203/1*G0wI_aK3kBd0xkPPlxe-CA.jpeg" /><figcaption>© Steven Mayers</figcaption></figure><p>Bienvenidos<em>. Welcome. </em>Toca<em>. Knock. </em>Abierto las 24 Horas. <em>Open twenty-four hours a day. The single door pierces the block-long windowless wall that flanks the tracks of </em>la<em> </em>bestia<em>, the beast, as the refugees fleeing Central America refer to the cargo train. Tight clutches of travelers crouch in the shade of scarce trees along the track eye us as we ring the bell. Until recently, there was a sign along the tracks advertising an imposter </em>casa migrantes<em> on the other side of the tracks, where people were kidnapping refugees.</em></p><p><em>As a beast roars by and its whistle lets out a long, jarring scream, a young man opens the door and leads us into a small conference room, where we are introduced to Guadalupe Serrano Medina, the casa’s operating manager. Inside the singe door is one of the largest migrant shelters that we have seen on our travels through Mexico. It makes up half a city block and has a full size outdoor basketball court and a large mural of multi-colored quadrants, which migrants have been painting in. Together, the quadrants of the mural spell out, “I was here.” “We decided to use English,” Guadalupe, tells me, “because that’s the language they’ll be speaking when they get to the U.S.” We’ve come to the shelter talk to youth migrants for </em>Solito, Solita: Crossing Borders With Young Refugees from Central America<em>, an book for Voice of Witness to be released in the spring of 2019.</em></p><p><em>As Guadalupe takes us around the facilities — through the kitchen, where a former refugee from Honduras cooks, a large the cafeteria, and long rows of dormitories with bunk beds — teenage guests spring to attention, rising from naps, putting down poker cards, and stubbing out cigarettes. “Buenas tardes, Señora! How can we help?” “Someone sweep over here,” she replies. There are cloths all over the floor. This place is a mess!” “Si, Señora, si Señora!”</em></p><p>Casa de la Caridad<em>, in San Luis Potosí, is funded by Cáritas and is part of a network Jesuit migrant shelters throughout Mexico, as well as the largest network of shelters and organizations working to protect the rights of migrants n Mexico, </em>Red de Documentación de las Organizaciones Defensoras de Migrantes <em>(REDODEM, Network of Documentation of Migrant Defense Organizations). These casas make up a veritable underground railroad helping thousands of refugees seek safety.</em></p><p><strong>Our <em>Casa</em> is Full of These Stories</strong></p><p>There is no money. There is no one to help. Nothing. Our <em>casa</em> is full of these stories. In 2014 we had a boom. Someone in the United States said that parents would be able to enter with small children. We had a huge number of minors passing through, most with parents and some alone. We experienced the birth of six newborns here that year. This casa<em> </em>wasn’t constructed with children in mind, because only every once in a while a minor would pass through. Now it’s a daily occurrence. We are getting used to working with minors. There are times when groups of up to ten children arrive together. As a <em>casa migrantes</em>, we have had to open up to this change in the migrant population.</p><p>Right now we have around a hundred and fifty migrants staying here. About thirty people leave during the day to work. Our regulations say that this is a house in which people can pass though, rest, eat, recuperate, and then continue on their travels. In reality, it is not like that. There is an official limit of twenty four to seventy two hours. I’ve been here for five years and I’ve never seen them follow this rule, especially now that they have to battle so much to make it here. Increasingly, they arrive here injured, beat up, with of their human rights abused. They arrive in worse shape. Therefore, our casa is open to the possibility of a longer stay. Sometimes, after a migrant’s family has promised them that they will be helping them along the way, when they arrive here, and they are closer to the border, their families don’t answer their phone calls. One parent might have had an accident, might not be able to work, and then no more help. So because we have young people here that don’t know what to do, we have to open ourselves up to longer stays. And by longer stays I mean, for example, that we have people who stay for one month, two months with us.</p><p><strong>It’s Better Than Sleeping Outside</strong></p><p>Our casa is big. We have enough space for around two hundred and forty people to stay here comfortably. When we have more people than that, we don’t have beds for everyone, but they can sleep on mats on the floor. I always say that even if they are sleeping on a mat, or even a blanket on the floor, at least it’s better than sleeping outside, where they might be confronted with a gun. I always tell them, “My children, try to rest and at least while you are sleeping not think that someone is going to try to harm you.”</p><p>We are part of a network of Jesuit <em>casas migrantes</em> that go from the south of Mexico to the north. So we have an Excel spreadsheet that we record our data, and we can easily analyze how many men are coming through, how many women, how many from Honduras, how many minors. I just check in with reception to see how many are here so I know how much food the kitchen should prepare. Those who work in the reception office have all of the data.</p><p>This is a safe house, because our priest has been very intelligent. Padre Rubén Pérez reaches out to the various levels of government so that we are protected. The immigration patrol doesn’t come here. They have to stay a certain number of meters away from the shelter. They never cause any trouble outside of the shelter here. Even when they need me to sign something, they contact me from an appropriate distance from the shelter and I speak with them outside. We have a good working relationship with them because when someone tells us that they want to return, we give them a ring and tell them that they want to return but don’t have the means.</p><p><strong>It’s What They Carry With Them</strong></p><p>There were rumors a few months ago that certain members of our team had been threatened, but nothing has happened. In 2011, we worked in a small space in a few rooms of a church. We had to modify them. It wasn’t a house, so we had to build bathrooms, dormitories. This was our birth. Before this time, we had been getting six to seven hundred people at a time. I arrived in 2010, and I’ve never seen more than three hundred people at one time, but before that, they were seeing six, seven hundred at a time. In the beginning, we were a shelter for people who had family members in the hospital perhaps, and didn’t have anywhere to stay. In the beginning, we’d get one migrant, two, and then five, ten, one hundred. The neighbors were very vocal. Here too, our neighbors see us as a burden. They ask us to not have too many people standing by the entrance. When we get a donation, we try to share it a bit with the neighborhood. It’s always been the same with our neighbors. Some say, “I need help. Why do you help them but not me?” We always try to carry on in peace, but there have always been those that complain that there is too much noise, our microphone is too loud. We have one neighbor who comes over and yells at us because of the noise, so we just have to stay calm and try not to respond with the same stress. Our priest has always been very concerned with this. At 9:30 in the evening, we shut the lights out. So we have a complicated relationship with our neighbors.</p><p>They play soccer here, but they play like they are going to kill the ball! I don’t know if you saw a soccer game in Tenosique when you were there. They don’t play like normal people. I tell them, “You guys play like you want to kill the ball or something!” We try to have rules — no kicking the ball against the wall, no making too much noise — but the rules aren’t worth a peanut! It is a place where they can take out some of their stress. They let out everything on that ball, the abandonment, the abuse. They bring a lot of trauma with them and it comes out, even in their dreams. Some people say the house is haunted, and I say, “No, kids, it’s your stress.” They wake up in the middle of the night from dreams. They are startled, scared. What ghosts? It’s what they carry with them.</p><p>In the past the migrants came for the famous American Dream, and now it’s not the American Dream. It’s to escape the violence. I think Honduras is the most violent country now. Or at least it held this small honor. And it’s a tiny country, but the world capital of violence! We’ve received whole families that are fleeing from the violence.</p><p><strong>If Someone Knocks on the Door, We Open It</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/288/1*5kUF3qUNOXB4d2fN6P7rUg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Guadalupe and I, © Steven Mayers</figcaption></figure><p>We have some people staying here that go out and work, and when payday comes around on Saturday, they go out and drink. And here we have strict rules about drinking. If someone has been drinking, the help ends. “We helped you, and you didn’t respect the rules of the house, so <em>adiós</em>!” If a person is under the influence of any alcohol, or a drug, they are not permitted to enter the house. And they know that they are going out to work, but if they return in an inconvenient state, the help ends. They are not allowed inside. It’s a house, so there are rules, like any of our houses. But this house is very big. We have hundreds of children, so we have to be very conscious of each other. If we let one little mistake go, then others notice that nothing happened to one person, and next week we have five, ten more doing it.</p><p>If someone knocks on our door, we open it. So we don’t know how good the person’s intentions are, how good of a person he or she is. If you knock on our door, we open it. All types of people enter. We interview people when they arrive and ask them to be as sincere as possible. We trust them to tell us as much as they can. If they feel that sharing certain details will put themselves or their families in danger, then we don’t push them.</p><p>We allow our guests to go out and work with people that we know, people that have been connected with us for years. They paint houses, recycle plastic bottles. We have about thirty people that go out and work, and the employers come to our door for them. And at six in the evening, they return them to me. This is the understanding we have with their employers. They come and get them, and they drop them off. We haven’t had any problems, with the immigration patrol, or anything.</p><p>Our casa<em> </em>is located in a neighborhood that is not that safe. It’s been that way all of my life, though. It’s a red zone in terms of safety here in San Luis. There are drug dealers, a lot of drugs, infinite dangers, so it doesn’t make sense to let the migrants come and go as they please. We’ve been analyzing this for a long time and we can’t expose them to these dangers. If they want protection, we can protect them, but there are some rules.</p><p><strong>I Feel Like a Mother to All of These Kids</strong></p><p>I feel like a mother to all of these young kids passing through. I would like them to not be considered migrants. They are people just like you and me. We shouldn’t label them as undocumented, as immigrants. They have the right to migrate. They are in a very complicated situation. Each individual has his own story, his own case. We have to help them. This house is an oasis for them. Here they are able to take a moment to breathe, to feel safe for a moment.</p><p>I’ve been here in the casa for five years, and I’m here almost twenty-four hours a day. As a mother, I have a very difficult time understanding women who come here and leave two or three little ones behind. I have two children myself. One is twenty-four and the other is twenty-nine. I am very conflicted about this. I can’t understand it. I wouldn’t do it. But I also try to put myself into their shoes. If I don’t have anything to feed them, then I have to go out and search for what I need for their wellbeing. And if I don’t have an education, I need to prepare things so that my little ones get an education. So I a very conflicted abut the status of the woman, very conflicted. You have no idea. And sometimes I am not able to reach an understanding. I see men making the trip as more normal. Only by putting yourself in their shoes of the other can you begin to even understand a little. But it affects you emotionally. At first it caused me a lot of pain. I’ve tried to distance myself from the emotions at times, so that it doesn’t affect me as much, because I am here all of the time and it is really heavy.</p><p>I receive their money transfers for them. I think this is a service that most casas provide. I collect the money transfers that their family sends them. I enjoy these moments a lot, when I connect with them face-to-face, in my office, with the door closed, and we can talk for at least ten or fifteen minutes. They can stay as long as they want. I don’t just say, “Here is your money. Sign here and <em>adiós</em>.” No. They can come talk to me about whatever they want. I don’t mind if someone else has to wait in the hallway for twenty or thirty minutes because there are the moments that I can me in contact with them. They can talk to me about anything, about something they need, anything. It is difficult trying to balance the office work with managing the kitchen.</p><p>These people have a lot of faith. I don’t know if they bring this faith from their countries of if it grows along the way, but when they kneel down to pray, they pray with a passion that you can’t imagine. If we don’t take the hand of God, I don’t know how we’d make it.</p><p>To support Casa de la Caridad:</p><p>Casa de la Caridad Cristiana</p><p>Calle Escandón #203, Barrio de San Juan de Guadalupe, San Luis Potosí, Mexico</p><p>Contact: Renata Calderón</p><p>(011) 52.444.815.6225</p><p><a href="/service/mailto:renata.calderonf@gmail.com">renata.calderonf@gmail.com</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/315/1*MF4QCIGO80tIk-IB_fGgDw.jpeg" /><figcaption>© Steven Mayers</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/263/1*MN0U7lGUjujPLbzTypAWNQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>© Steven Mayers</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9dcd98341bd2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Practice Contradicts the Discourse: Heriberto Vega Villaseñor on Mexican immigration policy…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@stevenmayers/the-practice-contradicts-the-discourse-heriberto-vega-villase%C3%B1or-on-mexican-immigration-policy-6775259ca1a1?source=rss-7d1c53d6469a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6775259ca1a1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[southern-border-plan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[immigration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[central-america]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[casa-migrantes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[refugees]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Steven Mayers]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Jul 2019 18:27:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-13T22:59:02.839Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>The Practice Contradicts the Discourse: Heriberto Vega Villaseñor on Mexican immigration policy, casas migrants, and Central American migrants in Mexico</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/333/1*0E62jHgQlZAXwRvNQwz5qg.jpeg" /><figcaption>© Steven Mayers</figcaption></figure><p><em>Heriberto Vega Villaseñor, a professor of social science and philosophy at ITESO, the Jesuit University of Guadalajara, and the University of Guadalajara, is also the lead researcher at FM4 Paso Libre, a </em>casa migrantes<em> in Guadalajara. We meet Heriberto while visiting </em>casas migrantes<em> throughout Mexico to speak with refugees fleeting Central America’s Northern Triangle. He speaks on Mexico’s immigration law, the Southern Border Plan, casas migrantes in Mexico, and the conditions in Mexico for Central American migrants. Since the implementation of Mexico’s Southern Border Plan in 2014, and despite its purported focus on human rights, Mexican authorities have focused on increasing the deportation of Central American migrants from Mexico. The casas are considered a protected space where migrants can rest knowing that they are safe from deportation while inside. Yet outside the shelters refugees are vulnerable to both the authorities and criminal organizations.</em></p><p><em>While many Central Americans flee unlivable conditions in their homelands, their infinitesimal chances of being granted asylum in Mexico and the assaults they face create a second human rights crisis in Mexico. With fewer refugees being able to enter the U.S. more refugees are stuck in Mexico, in a legal and financial purgatory, these casas are often the only recourses these people can turn to for survival.</em></p><p><strong>The Mexico-Guatemala Border Was Open</strong></p><p>Before, with Bush, there was the Merida Initiative. The Merida Initiative gave arms and money to supposedly control the violence and increase security. There were many flows [of refugees]. Then there was the Southern Border Plan [Plan Integral Frontera Sur], which began in July 2014. Before the Southern Border Plan, the Mexico-Guatemala border was open. Here was Mexico and here was Guatemala. They overlapped. In the last century, there was still a model based on solidarity in which Mexico would receive refugees, from the Spanish Civil War, Argentinians, Chileans, Venezuelans. We accepted people from Guatemala, all of the people that needed to seek refuge in Chetumal, in Chiapas. Many became Mexican citizens. Mexico used to be opposite in many ways from how it is now. It believed in solidarity, care, hospitality. And they have abandoned all of this in the 90’s with the free trade act (NAFTA). This was right as the wars in Central American were coming to an end. The last one to end was the Salvadoran war, which ended in 1992. And Mexico mediated the end of this war through the Chapultepec Agreement. Mexico played an important role and this has been lost. Mexico is not liked now. If you ask Central Americans, many will say that they don’t like Mexico, for all of the abuse they have faced.</p><p><strong>The Practice Contradicts the Discourse</strong></p><p>Between the 1990’s and 2011, there is a period in which Central American transit through Mexico became regularized, and it was somewhat accepted to be traveling through without papers. This was the period in which casas migrantes started to appear. The first casa migrantes was started in 1985 in Tijuana. They saw the need for a shelter and built the first house. And from there it grew. In the last register that I did last year, there were more than sixty casas across Mexico. There are others that are not registered in the network.</p><p>More money was directed towards humanitarian aid under the General Population Law [Ley General de la Población]. There was a man who ran a small casa in Queretaro, and the police came. He was put in jail for two years. The Miguel Agustín Pro Juárez Center for Human Rights [Centro de Derechos Humanos Miguel Agustín Pro Juárez] took up his case around 2008. It was then that the political pressure mounted, particularly from the church, as well as other organizations, began to mount which lead to the new immigration laws of 2011. The new immigration law, taking up the discourse on human rights promoted by the International Organization for Migration, considered traveling without papers to be considered an administrative misdemeanor, so people would get a fine, but not a crime. But this isn’t really the case. They are brought in to a governmental migration station, which starts as a preventative jail, and ends in deportation. So the practice contradicts the discourse. They don’t say they <em>detain</em> migrants. They say that they <em>protect </em>them. Instead of saying <em>detention</em>, they say <em>protection</em>. Instead of saying <em>deportation</em>, they say <em>assisted return</em>. This is the language, but in practice it’s not the same. But the new law did bring about some positive changes. The migrant is no longer criminalized, there is more money dedicated to humanitarian aid. So this law brought along a lot of contradictions within the Mexican government. It was focused on transitory migration, what they call the foreigners, and didn’t affect other types od migration. And they keep detaining, deporting.</p><p><strong>The Goal of the Plan Is to Contain</strong></p><p>The idea of the Southern Border Plan was to protect human rights because the new immigration law is written to be part of the human rights discourse. So the discourse says, <em>We’re not going to let you ride on the train, because the it is not a passenger train. It’s a cargo train, so human rights conditions are bad. And we’re going to control the border crossing point.</em> There are three objectives, including controlling the migration flows, facilitating the movement of commercial enterprises, and opening legal pathways to seek refuge. But in reality the goal of the plan is to contain: contain the migration by taking people off of the trains, many times in violent manners, with grenades, with powerful arms, with assaults. So human rights really don’t exist. What this did then is to put roadblocks into all of the traditional migrant routes on the train, so people started to look for other routes. Because they didn’t address the causes of migration, the flows continue. If we can’t go that way, then will go this way. And these new ways are more dangerous, more secretive, less visible. And organized crime increased the costs of passing. If it cost $1,500 before, now it costs $3,000. More need, higher prices.</p><p>With the implementation of the Southern Border Plan, the numbers of migrants staying at the casas migrantes have lowered, but this doesn’t mean that the flows have diminished. They just come on different routes. And if migrants feel that staying at a casa migrantes will make them more visible, then they will go another way. We collect data on all of the migrants that pass through FM4. If it were biometric data, it would be better, because part of protecting migrants is collecting data.</p><p><strong>A Certain Pragmatism</strong></p><p>I’ve been wondering if the Mexican government profits from the Southern Border Plan, and I think that they don’t really make anything. Really, what they are gaining is arms from the U.S. Maybe a little money as well, but not anything significant. Peña Nieto and the Mexican political class have fallen into a certain pragmatism, and I think that their only true concern is to be the new wealthy class of tomorrow. Cash. Steal the money quickly and the country doesn’t matter. It is a very large and strong cynicism. This is my point. There is no vision for the future, nothing. This is my story. There are no politics for the working class, no protection of the people. It’s all about cutting costs everywhere, so people cannot advance, move forward.</p><p>Last year, there were more deportations by the Mexican Immigration Institute [Instituto Nacional de Migración] than the US border patrol. So we’re pleasing the U.S. while angering the rest of the world. And the rate of turning down asylum claims in Mexico is over 90%. We did a study last year on criminalization and discrimination against migrants here in Guadalajara. We interviewed people in various sectors of society, trying to be as strategic as possible, and we were surprised by their answers. We were expecting to uncover a much more discriminatory attitude than we did. There is still a sensibility of solidarity with the migrants within the civil population, at least in the discourse. This is a good thing. We were aligned with the National Survey on Discrimination Based on Sexual Orientation and Gender[Encuesta Nacional sobre Discriminación por Motivos de Orientación Sexual e Identidad de Género]. Our question was, “Do you think that those that migrants from outside of our city create division in society?” Seven out of ten said no. This is high. There are people like our neighbors here, who didn’t want us to be here when we arrived. They put up banners that said we are not welcome. But even they say that it’s not our migrant brothers that they don’t want. It’s that close to the migrants, around them, are opportunities for delinquency and crime. In our old location, we received death threats and that’s why we moved.</p><p>To support FM4 Paso Libre, please visit:</p><p><a href="http://www.fm4pasolibre.org/english_help_money_donations.html"><em>http://www.fm4pasolibre.org/english_help_money_donations.html</em></a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/1*_Uk8QRAaFZ7gXTlJ_Xly2A.jpeg" /><figcaption>© Steven Mayers</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/304/1*UAihOufYrbLGu1Ml77gnPQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>© Steven Mayers</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6775259ca1a1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>