<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Sundararaman T on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Sundararaman T on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@sundar2016?source=rss-cfe3781b0191------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 14:33:16 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@sundar2016/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[KN Rao Memorial Lecture 2021- Awarded by Indian Public Health Association]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy/kn-rao-memorial-lecture-2021-awarded-by-indian-public-health-association-140802b3a9bf?source=rss-cfe3781b0191------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/140802b3a9bf</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sundararaman T]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 03 Jan 2022 12:12:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-03T12:12:48.335Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>KN Rao Memorial Lecture 2021- Awarded by Indian Public Health Association</p><p>Presented 26th September 2021, Published December 2021</p><h3><strong>Health Sector Reform at the COVID‐19 Cross‐roads: Public Goods or Health Markets — An Agenda for Health Systems Research</strong></h3><p><strong>Sundararaman Thiagarajan</strong></p><p>Adjunct Faculty, JIPMER International School of Public Health, Jawaharlal Institute of Post‐Graduate Medical Education and Research, Puducherry, India- Also former Global Coordinator, Peoples Health Movement..</p><h4>Abstract:</h4><p>The debate around approaches to health sector reform is one of the foundational questions around which the discipline of health policy and systems research has grown. In the immediate postwar period, health and health care were recognised as areas of market failure, requiring state action in the provision of free or subsidised services. In the eighties and nineties, due to both geopolitical and ideological reasons, this understanding changed, leading to a wave of market-based health sector reforms. An academic discourse built around neoliberal economics initiated, shaped, and legitimised these reforms. Faced with worsening health outcomes and costs of care after a decade of such reforms, there was a partial reversal of policy toward improving health sector performance that relied on nonmarket solutions built around notions of solidarity, trust, and rights. In India, this took the form of the National Rural Health Mission. Examples of health systems research that supported this direction of change are discussed. In the last decade, a second wave of health sector reforms sought to make markets work by repositioning government as purchaser of health care from private providers through insurance and contracts. There is little evidence that this worked. The need to rely on public services to cope with the COVID-19 pandemic, further questioned this direction of reform. We emphasise the need to expand and develop a framework of health systems and policy studies that are more appropriate to the achievement of universal health care, health equity, and health rights in the Indian context.</p><p><strong>Key words: </strong>Health systems research, health systems strengthening, National Rural Health Mission</p><p>Indian Journal of Public Health, Volume 65 / Issue 4 / October-December 2021</p><p><strong>How to cite this article:</strong><br>Thiagarajan S. Health sector reform at the COVID cross-roads: Public goods or health markets — An agenda for health systems research. Indian J Public Health 2021;65:332–9</p><p>Access this article at. <a href="https://www.ijph.in/text.asp?2021/65/4/332/333975">https://www.ijph.in/text.asp?2021/65/4/332/333975</a>.</p><p><strong>How to cite this URL: </strong>Thiagarajan S. Health sector reform at the COVID cross-roads: Public goods or health markets — An agenda for health systems research. Indian J Public Health [serial online] 2021 [cited 2022 Jan 3];65:332–9. Available from: <a href="https://www.ijph.in/text.asp?2021/65/4/332/333975">https://www.ijph.in/text.asp?2021/65/4/332/333975https://www.ijph.in/text.asp?2021/65/4/332/333975</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=140802b3a9bf" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy/kn-rao-memorial-lecture-2021-awarded-by-indian-public-health-association-140802b3a9bf">KN Rao Memorial Lecture 2021- Awarded by Indian Public Health Association</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy">Conversations on Health Policy</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ayushman Bharat: Health and Wellness Centers:]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy/ayushman-bharat-health-and-wellness-centers-7ecbaff020?source=rss-cfe3781b0191------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7ecbaff020</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[public-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ayushman-bharat]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comprehensive]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[primary-health-care]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sundararaman T]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Oct 2019 10:03:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-01T10:03:54.682Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The design, the many variants and the key barriers, and what peoples’ movements should do about it.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/648/0*IiPnkY9TS88953Oo.jpeg" /></figure><ol><li><strong>What are Health and Wellness Centers?</strong></li></ol><p>This component of Ayushman Bharat promises to upgrade health sub-centers and primary health centers into what is called health and wellness centers. The target is 1.5 lakh HWCs, which is roughly equivalent to the total number of sub-centers in existence (1.46 lakhs). Each sub-center caters to about 5000 population. In tribal and hilly and desert areas it could cater to 3000 population or even less. This target of 1.5 lakh HWCs would, according to the government, be achieved by 2022.</p><p>Health and Wellness Centers differs from both the existing sub-centers and urban dispensary services and even the primary health centers in four important ways:</p><p>a. The primary healthcare services available to households in that area are comprehensive- NOT selective.</p><p>b. All the services are organized in a manner that ensures continuity of care. There are two types of continuity- if a patient with chronic illness comes in periodically, the center is equipped to provide follow up and medication so that the treatment can be continued without a break 365 days of the year. And secondly –vertical continuity between the primary healthcare provider and the consultant/specialist/doctor at the higher levels. For most illnesses, the doctor or specialist will see the patient and confirm the diagnosis and make a treatment plan- and then the treatment is continued by the service providers in the HWC.</p><p>c. The services at a HWC are delivered by a team- ideally of at least one Mid Level Healthcare provider or doctor plus two female multi-purpose workers and one male multipurpose worker plus about 5 ASHAs (community health workers).</p><p>d. The services are population based- not limited to individuals. The doctor in a urban dispensary, like a Mohalla clinic, or the usual general practitioner in private practice feels responsible for those who sought their care. But a HWC is responsible for the health of the entire list of households/individuals assigned to them, those who are usually resident in their area. Thus, children or adults who are at risk, and the population who need preventive services like screening for common cancers even if they appear well.</p><p><strong>2. Why is this such a big thing. Was this not what primary health centres were always mandated to do?</strong></p><p>A. If we are referring to the Alma Ata declaration, the answer is yes. This was exactly what primary healthcare was meant to be. However if we are referring to currently existing primary healthcare facilities and even the healthcare policy since 1993- the answer is a big NO. Sub-centers and PHCs fulfil the criteria of continuity of care and being population based for only a very selective package of services- typically immunization, and care in pregnancy, contraceptive services and care in tuberculosis, HIV, malaria and leprosy. To some extent for cataract blindness also. This accounts for only about 10 to 15 % of all primary healthcare needs. For the remaining 85% of health care needs there are NO services at the primary level- or at best very sporadic, one-time consultations with no arrangements to ensure continuity or compliance or control. Under the re-branding of this concept as HWCs, there is a potential to bring back the full notion of primary healthcare. Even within the understanding of achieving universal health coverage, the HWCs would be the main strategy.</p><p>B. Even the current list of services under the HWC is not comprehensive enough. But it makes for a big start. The 12 services listed for delivery by HWCs are as follows:</p><p>i. Care in pregnancy and child-birth<br>ii. Neonatal and infant health care services<br>iii. Childhood and adolescent health care services<br>iv. Family planning, Contraceptive services and other Reproductive Health Care services<br>v. Management of Communicable diseases including National Health Programmes<br>vi. Management of Common Communicable Diseases and Outpatient care for acute simple illnesses and minor ailments.<br>vii. Screening, Prevention, Control and Management of Non-Communicable diseases<br>viii. Care for Common Ophthalmic and ENT problems<br>ix. Screening and Basic management of Mental health ailments<br>x. Basic Oral health care<br>xi. Elderly and Palliative health care services<br>xii. Emergency Medical Services</p><p>The first five of these are already on the existing health sub-centers and Primary Health Centre mandate. The Health and Wellness Centre adds the other 7 services also.</p><p>Since most Primary Health Centres (PHCs) are also not providing these services, by including these in the list the government is making the point that these too should be capable of providing this list of services. The PHC would not need additional human resources if it has the level mandated by Indian Public Health Standards (IPHS), but it would need to organize its service delivery better.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/25/0*r-BshR0aeRexbf-W" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/284/0*TsQjVzEtUzREKfWJ.png" /></figure><p><strong>3. Primary Health Care is about preventive and promotive services. But this above list of HWC services seems dominated by curative care.</strong></p><p>a. The emphasis must remain on prevention and promotion. Inter-sectoral action on environmental and social determinants will be limited to what can be done at the level of the village through village health, sanitation and nutrition committees (VHSNCs) and with respective departments taking a lead role in their areas of accountability. Public health tasks such as vector control continue without losing emphasis. This has never been questioned nor have they been in doubt.</p><p>b. But what is added on now is “secondary prevention”. The early detection of diseases like hypertension and diabetes through screening programmes and appropriate treatment is what saves lives in a large number of non-communicable diseases. Even in chronic communicable diseases like TB, HIV, leprosy, etc, early detection and appropriate treatment has a major preventive role. So, it is quite misleading to think of preventive and curative as being in two separate silos in a public health care system.</p><p>c. Establishing such secondary prevention as part of primary health care would also give urgency to primary prevention in terms of reduction in exposure to risk factors. This would include change in diet, increased exercise, better life styles, reduced use of tobacco and alcohol and such factors. Currently very little happens in many elements of such promotive care.</p><p>d. This is not to diminish the importance of how economic policies and development policies act as determinants of ill health. But building awareness for policy changes in development policies at the state and national levels must be accompanied by and would be reinforced by local action to ensure the above elements of care as individual entitlements.</p><p><strong>4. The government claims that they now have about 25,000 HWCs that are functional. Are the HWCs on the ground similar to what is promised? Or like the way the Alma Ata declaration of primary healthcare was reduced to selective healthcare, are there major deviations from the conceptual framework when it comes to implementation? The World Bank and other international aid agencies and global health institutions played a key role in reducing the Alma Ata declaration to selective primary health care. What are they up to now?</strong></p><p><strong>Response:</strong> This number of 25,000 is probably an over-estimate where many PHCs and Sub-centers which have been taken up for upgradation are presented as if they have already achieved it. The focus of peoples health movements should therefore not be on the numbers but whether those declared as HWCs conform to what is envisaged and promised.</p><p>It is important to note that the conceptual framework on which HWCs is based is part of a progressive framework on comprehensive primary health care that has evolved over many decades and which peoples’ movements have contributed greatly to shaping. Therefore, there is great urgency for peoples’ movements to be alert to deviations that trivialize or divert from the main objectives and call out/expose such deviations. Otherwise a government that is reluctant to implement the HWC concept in full will make use of the discontent with HWCs as implemented to scuttle the whole concept itself.</p><p>Some of the main deviations and distortions in the implementation of HWCs are listed below:</p><p><strong>A)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to what services are provided in the HWC:</strong></p><p>i. Instead of comprehensive primary healthcare, just one or two NCDs- usually hypertension and diabetes are added into the selective package. There is no effort to move to other services at all. In some states, even for hypertension and diabetes only screening and an unstructured referral up is done. There is no feedback from the referred doctor/specialist and no effort to ensure access to medication and follow up tests throughout the year at the HWC. In some states, it is even more cynical and HWCs have become only a branding exercise. A new coat of paint is given, the name of the center is changed- but no expansion of services occurs.</p><p>ii. In some states the focus is yoga. The scheme does see yoga as an important element of promotive health- and as one element among many there is case for it. But it certainly should not be the central or main agenda, displacing the other core services that HWCs are meant for. Any efforts to expand infrastructure in terms of yoga halls etc would be a distortion of priorities. There are many local administrators or officers who may take this path- since there is much less work involved, and it can distract from the main purpose, and since there is money that can be made in infrastructure.</p><p>iii. Improving infrastructure is one important element- but it is not and should not become the central component. There are examples where the entire emphasis is on beautification- painting the walls, putting ceramic tile flooring, re-building rooms and toilets etc. Part of this happens because this is what local administrators have understood the program to be. A more negative view would be that this happens because there is more opportunity to spend and to make money in infrastructure activity. The real danger is that equating upgradation to HWCs with improved infrastructure, would lead to a betrayal of expectations. Worse, when after all this expenditure, utilization does not go up, it would become another argument to favor privatization. The reasons for poor utilization lie in the lack of appropriate services — not in the lack of ceramic flooring.</p><p>iv. In some states the attention is given to starting up a general out-patient clinic and providing medicines and even some diagnostics in it. This helps, and like in the Mohalla clinic, can even be welcomed. But without the continuity of care for chronic illness, without the population-based coverage, without the referral platforms, it will not make much of a difference. The initial welcome will soon go away because people will have to go in search of better care for their healthcare needs than what such a clinic can prepare.</p><p>v. In most states, the feeling is that we should proceed gradually to add services to the package. But gradually based on what? Now the entire healthcare system waits for central directives before any service is added on. However, there is no reason to deny any service from these 12 service areas if there is a suitable specialist who is available to confirm diagnosis, make a treatment plan and communicate it to the the staff at the HWC, and then also be available if there is any complication</p><p><strong>B)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to Human Resources:</strong></p><p>i. The most common distortion is to equate the HWC with appointing a mid level health care provider. The rest of the team is not even thought about or planned for. There is neither a clear work distribution, nor the requisite training. The mid level healthcare provider alone cannot make a difference.</p><p>ii. The other common distortion is to understand the mid level healthcare provider as a substitute doctor- because doctors do not go to rural areas. In most or all chronic illnesses the doctor or specialist is not substituted by the MLHP. Once the diagnosis is confirmed and treatment plan made by the doctor, the MLHP would, with the help of the team, ensure follow up Related to this distortion, is the failure to design training programmes that enable MLHPs and the rest of the team to play this role.</p><p>iii. Another problem is the debate about whether the MLHP should be a B.Sc nurse or a GNM nurse, or an ANM or an AYUSH provider, or a three year new graduate. Can dentists and physiotherapists be allowed to become MLHPs? This debate diverts us from the main features of a MLHP- which should be a) he/she should be of that locality/block/district and happy to be working there b) he/she should be trained close to their place of work and preferably in state language using standard treatment protocols — and this training should be a periodic life long process c) that he/she should be conditionally licensed only to work in primary health care within government institutions- and not to become private providers- which means that even at the time of recruitment into the training, their employment position should be assured and d) one would need them as part of a permanent workforce- and not on an ad hoc contractual basis. E) they should always be working under the supervision of doctor/doctors in the public health system. It does not really matter which allied health professional or nursing qualification they have to begin with. If these five conditions are fulfilled, they would play their role- and if these are not, whatever their qualification they would not be able to work.</p><p><strong>C)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to continuity of care:</strong></p><p>i. The most common distortion is a complete failure to plan for the link with the doctor/specialist who shall receive the referral confirm diagnosis, make the treatment plan and rule out or manage complications, and communicate to the providers in the HWC- all according to a standard treatment protocol.</p><p>ii. The other common distortion is to assume that the providers empanelled with PMJAY will take care of this referral function. Not only does the PM-JAY not provide for such consultation, the incentive environment for the PM_JAY hospital is not to promote preventive care and avoid or delay the need for procedures. Rather, their interest is in increasing the number of secondary and tertiary care opportunities they have.</p><p>iii. A third distortion is to grossly underestimate the quantity of medicines required to provide continuity of medication and diagnostic support to patients with chronic illness. Thus, even if all persons with hypertension in a community were taking only one tablet per day, a population of 5000 with about 10% of those about 30 years having hypertension would need close to a lakh anti-hypertensive tablet. There is little effort in understanding and organizing the logistics for such increase in access to medication. The same goes for diagnostics. If the government is serious about HWCs as the route to UHC and of the promise to free drugs and diagnostics, it can certainly manage this.</p><p><strong>D)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to Population Based Care</strong></p><p>i. Most HWCs still limit population-based care to immunization, pregnancy, tuberculosis. There is no commitment to seek out those who have not been screened, or those defaulting on taking medicines, or those not taking care for complications etc. But ASHAs should make household visits that ensure this. And there has to be a system of documenting the health needs of different families and individuals and being able to follow it up. For example, a HWC team would know what proportion of population at risk have been screened for hypertension or diabetes, what proportion were confirmed to have that disease and how many of these are registered with the HWC for regular care, and finally in what proportion of them was hypertension controlled.</p><p>ii. There is no allocation of households to each HWC. This problem is most ….in urban areas. In rural areas there is at least an implict understanding. That would further mean that every household and individual would have a health card that indicates which is the HWC that is closest to their residence and to which they are attached. That card would also help support access for their health needs if they have any health risk or chronic illness.</p><p>iii. All of this would be greatly helped if the right ICT tools are available- but ICT tools and smart cards are not a substitute for the team building and coordination that is required. One distortion of HWCs is to equate it with introduction of ICT and smart cards. Often ICT tools add an additional layer of work for the overburdened providers without enabling local planning or decision making. Good ICT design should decrease the burden of data collections and reporting of the HWC providers. It will take quite a while to use UHC app (ICT tool) appropriately- and HWCs need not wait till then to expand the services they provide.</p><p>iv. The defnition of population should include all households and individuals usually resident in that area. Even three months residence in a year should be counted. No exclusions based on ID documentation should be permissible- since healthcare is an inalienable human right. Special care must be taken to ensure that migrants and seasonal workers are included. And if they are from another place in Indiathe continuity of care should be assured. If a person not usually resident in that area seeks care, that care should be provided. The only difference is that there is no assurance of follow up at household level to ensure compliance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/26/0*Q78jcLPS0fUy-tcK" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/977/0*dasBQ7T6xA0vN_kC.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>5. What should be the popular demands that peoples’ health movements should make at the level of the village/urban poor?</strong></p><p>There is a need for popular campaigns to demand the following as an entitlement:</p><p>a. Any person with a chronic illness who needs to take medicines every day, or very often for the rest of their lives would be able to get their medicines in the sub-centre (HWC), free of costs. This is a long list. It includes medicines for hypertension, diabetes, angina, mental illnesses, epilepsy, asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, arthritis- just to name some of the most important ones.</p><p>b. If any person is detected with any of these illnesses when he or she comes for a visit for any other illness or a health check- up, they would be entitled to a reference for confirmation at the higher level (facilitated by the HWC) and they would have a treatment plan made by the specialist- with some elements of routine follow up being provided at the HWC.</p><p>c. Every person over 30 years would be actively screened at the HWC once a year for diabetes, hypertension and once in three to five years for chronic illnesses like cancer cervix, breast and oral cancers. If they are suspected of having the disease, they would be referred to a higher center and have the diagnosis confirmed and a treatment plan made. Similarly, all newborns have to be screened at the place of their birth. All pregnant women are already being screened.</p><p>d. There should be an out patient service on all 5 days of the week in the HWC- so that a much wider range of acute simple illness can be treated. This would include fever, acute respiratory infections, common infectious diseases etc.</p><p><strong>6. What should be the demand of peoples’ movements at the level of policy, advocacy and agitation? What should peoples’ movements be alert about with respect to pressures from international donors and corporate India?</strong></p><p>a. There is a great danger that the HWC can turn out to be another jhumla. The real push is on PM-JAY, while the HWC is only for show- to give the appearance of a evidence based progress towards UHC for public consumption and for international agencies like the UN. There are two key indicators of whether it is jhumla or a real action on the ground. The first indicator is the financial resources allocated to it. The second is the human resources policy.</p><p>i. Financing: By the governments own estimates it requires about 9 lakhs recurrent and 8 lakhs non recurrent expenditure- additional to what is currently spent on sub-centers and PHCs. This is a serious under-estimate — but even if we use this figure the allocation would be 13,500 crores per year or 65,700 crores recurrent plus 12,000 crores non-recurrent or about 77,000 crores over 5 years. The actual amount needed, if full HR and medicines and referral costs are included is likely to be at least twice that. But that would be about 1 % of GDP- a reasonable estimate. In the current year the allocation was only 1600 crores. In the previous year, the allocation was notional.</p><p>ii. Matching Human Resources Policies: The HR policy needs to provide resources for hiring the entire team, plus the ASHAs on a regular basis. And also we need to create HR policies which enable us to overcome the very skewed availability of human resources. Very often the government starts by stating that other than increasing HR, one can consider all options. Which means negating the whole program.</p><p>b. There is a need to identify distortions of the concept and build public and even provider understanding of what comprehensive primary health care means. Equating these distortions with HWCs would lead to loss of credibility regarding the whole idea of primary health care — and HWCs would be quietly shelved or reduced to some token level- while all the media attention etc. is focussed on the insurance scheme. An alert peoples movements and a democratic polity has a choice in how it goes about its protest ; It can demand that HWCs ought to be developed without these distortions, as the route to comprehensive primary health care and expose efforts that deviate, distort or trivialize the scheme. OR it could be dismissive of HWCs and thus add to the energies that for a variety of often varied reasons, call for ignoring if not scrapping the scheme. The PM-JAY is in no danger of being ignored- and there would be an active lobby of healthcare industry very ready to support and shape it. Every single media channel, newspaper and periodical, especially those specializing in health care, would be watching it roll out. (PMJAY covers journalists also). Comprehensive primary health care, on the other hand, does not attract such attention or support. It has no support except sections of the health policy community and peoples’ health movements. What peoples’ health movements do would therefore be critical.</p><p>c. The other big danger is the push to outsource clusters of HWCs to the private sector- and within that to the corporate sector. The BMGF (Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation) has a number of pilots and initiatives to do just this. BMGF currently leads this effort. USAID too actively supports these initiatives. Swasthya Piramal, Tata Trusts, Apollo Hospitals/enterprises are major corporate players who are interested in developing such models. The World Bank is more focussed on PMJAY. Niti Aayog has been pushing for private sector participation in HWCs — and has included a commitment to outsource at least a proportion of HWCs as part of the mandate of Aysuhman Bharat. There are also efforts to push part or all of HWCs into the National Health Authority and/or fuse it with the PMJAY platform in the name of integration. In all of these models the aim is to create a network of private providers linked to a corporate entity, which the government would contract in. The corporate agency will then engage the private providers either as a sub-contract or as employees. Till date, this approach has not succeeded. This lack of success is partly due to good sense prevailing in the ministry about their own ability to ensure that private sector abides by the contract, and partly because private players are not very keen. Part of the lack of progress in outsourcing despite political pressures to do so is because of the technical complexities of contracting a corporate consortium to provide primary healthcare. But a number of international agencies and Indian pro-industry academicians and consultancy organizations are trying to address the technicalities of contracting and promoting innovations in organizing services. This has given time and space for the public sector/healh ministry to come up with viable and visible government run HWCs.Would corporate India run better primary healthcare than what government would? Given the prevailing culture and perceptions fostered by neo-liberalism and the rise of right wing populism, many would support such a perception. But if experience and evidence is any guide, then what is far more likely is that it would, like in PMJAY, only lead to profits for private health sector, a weakening of public services and no major contribution to health.</p><p><strong>7. Is this idea of HWCs a new idea? Has it been tried anywhere?</strong></p><p>The name is new. But this is the basic concept of primary health care, before selective health care came along. Many nations in the world have organized care along these lines and are doing it for very long and very successfully. In the developed world, UK’s National Health Services is a model of such care- and it has been there for over 70 years. Most other developed nations also have similar arrangements for primary health care. In the developing world Cuba, Thailand and Brazil have very similar programmes. Thailand in particular is very similar to what is proposed in India. Over 95% of primary health care providers in all these nations are within the public sector- just like in India.</p><p>In fact, this is what was always meant by primary health care. Such organization of services is what peoples’ health movements have been demanding since its inception.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7ecbaff020" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy/ayushman-bharat-health-and-wellness-centers-7ecbaff020">Ayushman Bharat: Health and Wellness Centers:</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy">Conversations on Health Policy</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part 3: The Making of the Health Professional — Changing Policies in Health Professional Education…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy/part-3-the-making-of-the-health-professional-changing-policies-in-health-professional-education-6e2a368ae2c1?source=rss-cfe3781b0191------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6e2a368ae2c1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[professional-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare-regulation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medical-council]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health-professionals]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sundararaman T]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Sep 2019 04:43:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-27T04:43:45.742Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Part 3: The Making of the Health Professional — Changing Policies in Health Professional Education and Professional Regulation, And the task before Peoples’ Health Movements</h3><h3>The National Medical Council Bill- 2019</h3><p>A Jan Swasthya Abhiyan Policy Brief (<strong>up-dated 10th August, 2019)</strong></p><p>The need for a new act replacing the Medical Council Act is no doubt of utmost importance. Unfortunately, the National Medical Council Bill of 2019, now an Act, has failed to identify and address the main problems of the earlier council, and by rushing through this current bill using its brute majority, it has created considerable new dangers. Many state governments have also opposed this Act.</p><p>In this note we share with the public some of our major concerns with regard to this bill:</p><p><strong>Loss of Federal Structure</strong></p><p>Firstly, there is an almost complete abandonment of the federal structure and an obsession with centralizing every detail of both medical education policy and professional regulation, and all the means of implementation.</p><p><strong>Governed by the bureaucracy:</strong></p><p>Further, even at the centre the powers are immensely concentrated in the bureaucracy- with only a very token role for a limited number of 5 elected members. The representatives of the state medical councils elect these 5 members. The Commission has totally 25 members. All the other commission members are nominated. Search committees for key posts are also largely nominated by the government of the day. Not satisfied with this, the government arms itself with even more powers to give instructions to the commission on policies or overrule any policy made by the commission.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/30/0*2InvaOv6HD_ufEdA" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OMSxj8pMON11Oz1P" /></figure><p><strong>States- Not decision makers, but advisors:</strong></p><p>There is a Medical Advisory Council, whose only role is to allow members to voice their views. States are represented in this by a government nominated representative specified as the Vice-Chancellor of the state’s Medical university (or equivalent) and a member nominated by the state medical council. This downgrades the state role from decision-making to consultative. Even on providing this limited space for consultation there seems to be high degree of risk-avoidance since peculiarly all members of the commission are also made members of the advisory council!!!</p><p><strong>Centralization and Institutional Capacity:</strong></p><p>Centralization and micro-management are also inherent in the scope of the commission since it has powers to make rules and regulations for almost every operational detail. It would need an incredibly high level of institutional capacity in this central institution to administer such a mandate- and nothing that one has seen of central ministries and institutions would give us the confidence that they can do so. A humbler and more honest estimate of their own capacity by the central government, would have allowed for a greater role to states within a broad framework set by the national commission.</p><p><strong>Open doors to private sector</strong></p><p>Despite its omnibus mandate, on one aspect the Commission is curtailed. It can at best “frame guidelines for determination of fees and all other charges in respect of fifty per cent. of seats in private medical institutions and deemed to be universities.” Implying that for 50% of seats there would be no regulation whatsoever. Even for this 50% there are no indications of what would be principles of fee decision. One of the more retrogressive steps in this bill is that it opens the door to ‘for-profit entities” for the first time, and in the current context this largely implies opening the gates for the corporate sector. The obligation of providing access and affordability to under-serviced populations and aspirants gets no mention. These are just off the agenda. The aim of this policy is only within a highly privatized sector, how government can be seen to be concerned with the problems of quality of education.</p><p><strong>Quality Assurance as Common National Examinations</strong></p><p>For assuring quality, there is only one idea, another great centralizing one, the common national examination, one for entry into the MBBS course (National Eligibility cum Entrance Examination- NEET) and the other for exit. (National Exit Examination- NEXT) The exit examination is the examination for the license to practice as well as the examination for entry into Post-graduation courses.</p><p><strong>The NEET Problems</strong></p><p>There are problems with both. As an entry test into the MBBS course (NEET) it does not help prioritize suitable candidates for under-served areas — which is a great necessity considering the highly skewed availability of human resources. It does not recognize the limitation of the MCQ format and why performance in this within a timeframe requires skills and practice different from what it takes to understand a subject or write the usual examination. It thereby boosts the coaching industry and shifts the measure of merit towards the wealthier students who can afford such coaching… There are powerful arguments why states prefer to hold such common entrance examinations at the state level. Some 15% of seats can be surrendered to a central pool for which a national examination would be relevant. There is an even stronger case for going only by school leaving marks with standardization of marks across different boards.</p><p><strong>The NEXT Problem:</strong></p><p>As an exit examination, the MCQ format is even more limited since it does not test skills and patient interaction. Also, a final year student passes through different subjects in phases- and combining all into a single examination does not help. It will also act as a barrier against innovation and improvement. As an entrance examination into post-graduation, both sets of problems as described for NEET and for exit examination apply. Along with some newer ones.</p><p><strong>Four Boards- but autonomous?</strong></p><p>The NMC mandates four autonomous boards- (a) the UG medical education board, (b) the PG medical education Board, © the Medical Assessment and Rating Board and (d) the Ethics and Medical registration Board. The separation of these functions is welcome and potentially a step in the right direction. But there is nothing to indicate how these are autonomous and how each of these Boards would have the capacity to do what is required of them, and how these would retain even a minimum of internal democratic functioning. The notion, that these four functions can be carried out across the country, by four five-member teams situated in Delhi. To solve this problem for the Medical Assessment and Rating Board the bill state that the Board may<em> “hire and authorize any other third-party agency or persons for carrying out inspections.”</em> The main problem with these boards is the way they completely undermine the state’s role.</p><p><strong>Corruption Neutral:</strong></p><p>One big reason for the new act, and for repealing the earlier act is corruption. But there is nothing in this bill that gives anyone the confidence that corruption would reduce. The shifting from board members and medical experts to third party agency is more likely to change the form of corruption than eliminate it.</p><p><strong>Ethics or Registry: Where is the capacity?</strong></p><p>The Ethics Board function combines with medical registry- though these are very different skill sets and different institutional requirements. The only overlap is that it could be easier to remove the name of a person debarred on ethical grounds from the medical register. Nowhere is there a recognition of what it takes to maintain a live register or identify those without a registration who are in practice- and what would be the mechanism by which this is done. The requirements of the ethics function of this board is not only understated, there is not enough on what it covers, and how these functions will be managed.</p><p><strong>Surprise Inclusion: Community Health Providers:</strong></p><p>The other major new inclusion in the bills is the clauses related to community health providers. To quote:</p><blockquote><em>“The Commission may grant limited licence to practice medicine at mid-level as Community Health Provider to such person connected with modern scientific medical profession who qualify such criteria as may be specified by the regulations;</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Provided that the number of limited licences to be granted under this sub-section shall not exceed one-third of the total number of licenced medical practitioners registered under sub-section (1) of section 31.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>The Community Health Provider who are granted limited licences under sub-section (1), may practice medicine to such extent, in such circumstances and for such period, as may be specified by the regulations.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>The Community Health Provider may prescribe specified medicine independently, only in primary and preventive healthcare, but in cases other than primary and preventive healthcare, he may prescribe medicine only under the supervision of medical practitioners registered under sub-section (1) of section 32.”</em></blockquote><p>To the Indian Medical Association this is one of the main areas of opposition. They label this a backdoor entry to quackery. The truth is that after poor progress in nearly ten years of efforts to put in place a mid-level care provider for the sub-centre level, there is a quick move to use the rapid movement of this bill to include that need. While one could argue that there is a need for such a provider at the primary healthcare level, most nations and some of the Indian states which have such a cadre in place, have a separate legislation to cover that cadre. Like there is for nursing, pharmacists, allied healthcare providers etc. To hurriedly pack that new agenda into this bill, without so much as a definition of what this term means, and no understanding of qualifications, conditional licensing measures, entry or exit, scope of work etc is to ask for big trouble. Even if that is not the intent of the government, the IMAs worst fears on this would come to pass- and a poorly qualified healthcare provider could get generated who would then proceed to enter to the highly competitive, almost predatory urban markets for healthcare.</p><p><strong>Silences in the bill:</strong></p><p>There are also important silences of the bill on a few critical issues. For example, though the effective grievance redressal mechanisms is one of the stated objectives, there is no further mention of it in the bill. The bill is also completely silent on kick-backs, commissions and other conflict of interests. The Bill has little mention of what happens to the state medical councils and how its mandate would get modified.</p><p><strong>The Sub-Text: Professionals Role in Governance</strong></p><p>Part of the reasons why this bill has so many flaws is that the entire history of the poor functioning of the medical council has been reduced to the inability of the medical profession to govern itself and this in turn is attributed (in the sub-text) to be inherent problem of the profession. Therefore, it is assumed that the moment such professional control is removed or diluted, the problems would go away. To some extent the medical professionals in the past medical councils brought this on itself- by not only failing to check corruption and poor ethics, but often becoming seen as the source of such corruption and failing to even eject the leadership that was tainted by courts for such corruption. But that was not the only problem- nor even the main problem- and the solutions that this bill offers may act to worsen the situation. The failure to analyse or understand the other policy and systemic roots for problems like poor quality of education, corruption, ethical deficits, lack of live registers, failure to generate human resources that are appropriate to our needs all come together with an anti-professional bias to bring about a bill that satisfies no one, and solves very little.</p><p><strong>The Political Context</strong>:</p><p>The overall political context of this bill is also important to note. The main thrust of government policy is to shift the government from the role of provider of healthcare services to purchasing it from private providers through insurance or partnerships. This is a form of privatization where public expenditure to pay for the healthcare of the majority is routed through private providers at terms where they can make a profit and monopoly control can be encouraged. However, the lack of regulation — both in private medical education and private medical care is making this very difficult. Studies are showing that private providers do not abide by contractual terms and that private educational institutions are overwhelming corrupt and of poor quality. Instead of seeing the roots of the problem in privatization, the government would locate the problem entirely in the profession and professional regulation. This brings out stiff resistance from medical professionals.</p><p><strong>In conclusion:</strong></p><p>Clearly it is important to educate and shape public opinion on the provisions of the Act, our concerns regarding this- where we agree with the professional opinion as articulated by IMA and where we differ, and what would be the alternative formulations on some of the key issues.</p><p>Through this Act the central government has captured and concentrated all powers for improvement of medical education, and of closing gaps in availability of medical professionals and of quality of medical education in itself, and they would need to be held accountable for these tasks.</p><p>In the coming years as implementation of this Act begins, the problems are going to show up more glaringly. Already the ministry has begun with asking for a three-year time to begin implementation of NEXT as a licensing examination. Sections of civil society which have fought for health rights, professional associations and all democratic forces would need to exercise the utmost vigilance, ensure timely public exposure of the limitations and introduce into public discourse, better options/alternatives that could address these problems.</p><h3>Health Professional Education and the Draft National Education Policy:</h3><p>There are three important challenges that any policy on healthcare education would have to address:</p><p>First and most important of these is the serious mal-distributions of healthcare professionals across the nation. The national commitments to achieving universal access to healthcare can be achieved only if there is a minimum density of doctors, nurses, and allied healthcare professionals in every block and district of the nation. Such a distribution of healthcare professionals is closely linked to policies concerning entry into educational institutions, the context and content of the curriculum, and the subsequent policies of public financing and organization of public health services.</p><p>The second important challenge is ensuring the quality of education, so that the young men and women who are churned out of these institutions have the knowledge and skills to make the right decisions and provide the right care. Healthcare in a service sector where due to information asymmetry and uncertainties in outcome, the service user’s ability to make the choice of provider, or even to judge whether the care received was appropriate and adequate is limited. Further in most contexts of private practice the providers own monetary incentives may not be aligned with the best interest of the patient. All this calls for a high degree of trust and the state must ensure that healthcare professional have the skills to deserve such trust.</p><p>The third challenge is also a dimension of quality of education- it is not just technical competence in terms of knowledge and skills that is required, but an attitude of caring. These are caring positions where the majority of practitioners would have to feel fulfilled and creative though acts of preventing illness, of taking care of the sick and even in supporting the dying. No doubt at all levels of care, some technical skills are essential, but what is equally important is the empathy that care providers have for those they care for, and the close bonding that is required between providers and the communities that are served, and the ethical values they have imbibed during professional education and practice.</p><p>The Draft National Education Policy, not only fails to address these challenges, it could actively worsen it. (Healthcare education finds place in the draft National Education Policy as one of the sub-topics of the chapter on Professional Education). -</p><p>In table 1 below, we show the highly skewed distribution of undergraduate and post-graduate seats per lakh population across the states. Those states which have the largest shortfall of doctors are also the states where the number of seats per one lakh population are less than the national average. The distribution within states is also similarly skewed. A similar skew in availability of seats and professionals can also be demonstrated for nurses and for many of the allied health professionals.</p><p>Given the fact that upwardly mobile urban youth from more privileged sections are the most successful in gaining entry into healthcare educational institutions, the increases in seats in states with relative surplus is only going to lead to unhealthy competition and lowered remuneration for doctors within a few of the larger urban areas. It does not lead to surplus doctors and nurses shifting to under-serviced areas. Bonds and other forms of compulsion for working in rural areas seldom work, and even to the extent they do, such professionals would not have the same level of empathy and bonding with communities as a doctor who would actively choose to work in such an area. In many nations across the world, preferential admissions for students from under-serviced communities and regions along with commitments and incentives to go back to these areas after graduation is what has helped most in closing such service gaps.</p><p>The National Education Policy is silent on how these huge human resource gaps by region, by state, by gender, or by more marginalized castes and communities would be addressed. The silence is not surprising since equity in access to healthcare education and access to healthcare can be achieved only though public educational institutions based on public financing and affirmative actions such as free or highly subsidized education to bring in suitable candidates from these regions and communities. The silence would however be consistent with an approach that prioritizes opportunities for private profit in healthcare education and the demand of more privileged sections to send their children to medical schools over the public needs for health care. Over the last two decades commercialization of healthcare education has been rapidly increasing, and now the majority of the institutions are in the private sector. Further the majority of medical and nursing seats need such high payments that much of the population is actively excluded from such education. This NEP exacerbates this problem. It gives permission to educational institutions to charge any level of fees- and commits them only to providing scholarships for a proportion of the students- a commitment that in practice would be almost impossible to enforce.</p><p>The terms of such market driven expansion of healthcare education have led to great loss of quality in the output- a fact that is almost universally noted and lamented. The policy quite correctly states that regulatory regimes under the professional councils were inadequate to the task, and had serious conflicts of interests but the solutions proposed are worse than the problem. The NEP calls of dispensing with the role of councils as regulator, but in its stead what it proposes is one huge centralized structure that will command all of higher education, all across the nation. The NMC bill has already done this for medical education. The proposal is now to extend this approach to all of healthcare education. It is unclear whether; any single central institution can ever command such a capacity, or needs to. Constitutional provisions today put educational standard setting in the union list but explicitly leave regulation of higher education to the states.</p><p>But the bigger problem is an almost exclusive reliance on common national eligibility cum entrance examinations (NEETs) at every stage, as the single most important strategy of all educational governance. The proposal assumes that common examinations for entry at the under-graduate level and the post-graduate levels are effective and seeks to transform the latter to also serve as a common exit examination, for licensing purposes. Presumably the two NEETs would be the most fair and transparent purely merit based measurements of quality which would cut across the divides of public and private, communities and regions. If the proposal to allow all professional students to do a common first year foundational course followed by a merit-based sorting into medicine, nursing and dentistry streams is taken seriously, that would probably add a third NEET to the pool. But the challenges of implementing such a streaming are so ridiculously high, that we need not get distracted into discussing it.</p><p>The NEET itself has been a basis of considerable criticism and it is now clear that it is a tool that exacerbates inequities and undermines the federal nature of educational governance. Protest is maximal in precisely those states, like Tamilnadu, where after a long process of discussion with different sections a working balance had been struck between the needs of different regions to access healthcare and the needs of different sections of the population to access the opportunities of healthcare education. Then and now 15% of the under-graduate seats and 50% of the post-graduate seats were given to all India quota. But for filling up the 85% of seats, another merit based, fair and transparent systems was devised by states, which was perceived as giving students from government schools, and more marginalized communities studying with state language as a medium, and unable to afford costly coaching session, a reasonable chance of getting selected. Even this had problems. But post NEET, students who are from schools following central, all India examination boards, and those going to costly coaching schools which have cracked the sub-text of these examinations have a much stronger advantage.</p><p>Similarly, at the post-graduation level, the state of Tamilnadu had a system in place, where graduates could to work in rural areas, confident of the extent of advantage it would give them for accessing post-graduation and governments had worked out how to fill specialists’ posts in all its district hospitals. The state also had chosen to invest in expanding postgraduate and super-specialization courses using their own budgets and made public service after qualification mandatory for those getting government education. But with a nation-level centralization of the examination process, and surrender of 50% of postgraduate seats and 100% of super-specialization seats to the central pool, the ability of the state government to find the necessary candidates has been seriously compromised.</p><p>Further private educational institutions are allowed to keep fairly high levels of seats in the management quota. And thus, any student seeking admission in a private medical institution and able to pay the high fees and with enough influence to get selected would qualify with much lower NEET cut-off score. This system not only continues but also is encouraged within the language of the policy.</p><p>All of this emphasis on nation-wide common examinations is presumably in pursuit of measuring merit in a manner that is blind to social and educational backgrounds- a sort of huge educational level playing field that encourages a competition among students where the only currency is objectively measured merit. But then in a bizarre Freudian slip, the text of the draft policy has this gem: “this exit examination will be administered at the end of the fourth year of the MBBS so that students are relieved of the burden of studying for a separate, competitive entrance examinations at the end of their residency period. <em>With the entrance examination out of the way, they can spend their residency period acquiring valuable skills and competence</em>.” (para 16.8.3, pg. 305) The true import of this is that the proposed measure of testing would not measure valuable skills or competence, even those which are learnt in the most crucial part of the medical curriculum- the final year of clinical training. De jure, NEETs are the only basis for measuring learning. But de facto, the national common examination is accepted as a barrier to learning. The only use that NEET then has is as a device for ranking and sorting students into an apparent hierarchy of merit with all its attendant privileges and to exclude the rest and justify the exclusion. Close to 1.47 lakh medical graduates appeared for the PG-NEET examination last year, of which only about half are considered to have passed and only about 27000 would get seats anywhere and of which a much smaller proportion would be affordable seats. The majority of those who ‘fail’ NEET would face frustration and guilt- all the more so because to get so far, they have had excellent academic careers and though by temperament, attitude, experiences and skills — and even knowledge they may be much better than those who made it. There are other unfortunate collaterals of this NEET defined hierarchy of merit. One, for example is that students who qualify with lower thresholds due to reservation quotas face discrimination which could get justified on this basis, though their work performance may be no less than the others. The recent tragic suicide of Dr Payal Thadvi was an example of this. The rich student in the management quota is however unlikely to face such a disadvantage.</p><p>This hierarchy of merit takes other forms. There is for example the proposal to phase out all diploma education in nursing, and make B.Sc the only nursing entry. Persons working in field situations would testify that not only is it impossible to close gaps in nursing cadre with only B.Sc nurses, there are many field situations where diploma nursing students are better suited. Similarly, a community health worker or a mid-level care provider is not an apology for not having a doctor. Rather they are the most appropriate care providers in that given context.</p><p>One curious inconsistency in the draft is a proposal for periodic renewal of licenses for nurses through some testing procedures- while there is no such clause for any other category of service providers- specialists, doctors, or other allied healthcare professionals who may need such on the periodic skill upgradation and re-certification even more.</p><p>On the challenge of creating healthcare professionals with empathy- scientifically competent, but also ethical, humane, caring, communicative, sensitive to concerns of equity, and social accountability, the section on healthcare policy is a non-starter. Which is surprising considering the almost poetic eloquence with which the importance of liberal education is set out in the introductory chapters of the higher education section. The introductory chapters posit liberal broad-based multidisciplinary education as essential for developing “critical 21st century capacities” and defines this as including not only exposure to humanities and social sciences but also an ethic of social engagement… (11.3.1. pg. 234–5). It calls for professional education to be “cognizant of larger social concerns, and develop a mindset of public service and cultural awareness” and promises that professional and technical education will not remain narrowly-focussed on technical expertise alone (see chapter 9, pg. 202). On specific strategy to achieve this that is proposed is that “the practice of setting up stand-alone universities for professional education will be discontinued,” as “the practice of setting up separate technical universities, health sciences universities, legal and agriculture universities in each State to affiliate colleges offering professional education in their respective disciplines, has resulted in deepening the isolation further”. “All institutions offering either professional or general education must organically evolve into institutions offering both seamlessly by 2030. (pg. 301)”. It particularly condemns how in healthcare; education is offered largely in silos of individual subjects and separate from general higher education. Although the effort in professional education has been focused mainly on making students ready for ‘jobs’, the outcomes, in terms of employability, leave a lot to be desired. (pg. 293. Chapter 16).</p><p>None of these laudable values seem to inform or animate the authors of the healthcare education section. There is nowhere in the text of this section, any attention given to how we produce healthcare professionals who care, who feel for the individual and society. And whatever space emerges for such character building locally or spontaneously, would be swallowed up by the waves of MCQ based national examinations that the student would have to face. The proposals in this section are all examples of what is declared as wrong with professional education in the earlier section. NEP paragraph on allied healthcare providers states that a “syllabus will be standardised pan-India, drawn up in conjunction with Health Universities and State Allied Health Sciences Boards, … These training programmes will be hospital-based, at those hospitals that have adequate facilities, including state-of-the-art simulation facilities, and adequate student-patient ratio.” In this policy statement, the health university is retained, and the vision of the educational institution has given way to a description of a corporate hospital. Further some of the jobs mentioned as priorities are very narrowly based on current corporate healthcare industry requirements (e.g. general duty assistant), and more broad-based skills like pharmacists and counsellors find no mention. Almost none of the essential public health skill merits mention.</p><p>As a concession to the imperative of regional equity in the creation of new health education institutions, the policy puts forth a proposal “to upgrade the nation’s 600 district hospitals to become teaching hospitals, “to train doctors, nurses and allied healthcare professionals.” But are district hospitals so easy to transform into educational institutions? Whatever happened to all those brave words about liberal education and the multi-disciplinary university? It is one thing to ask for district hospitals to be upgraded to tertiary care hospitals and linked to university based medical colleges. Quite another to talk of upgrading district hospitals into teaching hospitals “by investing in infrastructure” and “stationing adequately qualified teaching faculty”. A proposal to identify districts with major HR shortages and link these with medical colleges and healthcare institutions which are part of public universities providing subsidized or free education with affirmative policies to bring in more candidates who relate to local communities would have been welcome. What is stated now (<em>all</em> district hospitals are to be so upgraded), read in conjunction with repeated announcements and efforts to outsource district hospitals to corporate agencies, gives rise to fears that even this proposal, may be a justification for providing private medical colleges an access to the clinical exposure that the public hospitals provide.</p><p>The answers to any of the three challenges that a healthcare education policy faces, are not easy- but they are available, and across the world many nations have learnt to address them. Even for the most difficult challenge of the three- providing healthcare professionals with empathy and ethics, there are many innovative efforts to learn from. Even within the nation there are many good examples that the authors could have learnt from. Institutions like CMC Vellore have for over a century been identifying and training students from very remote and under-privileged communities and returning them successfully as sensitized caring individuals to serve these communities for a number of years, while maintaining standards of excellence far above the average. Far from learning from them, NEET has so comprehensively undermined these policies that CMC Vellore has had to petition the Supreme Court to try and safeguard their mission- as yet unsuccessfully. If select universities and regions did have the powers and flexibility and there was a suitable policy framework, which ensured that such flexibility was only exercised in favour of healthcare needs of the population and not for private profits, much could be improved.</p><p>But as it stands the policy has not seriously engaged with these questions. It is contradictory to its own stated objectives of a liberal education, fails to address concerns of equity in access to healthcare or access to healthcare education and paves the way for an unhealthy commercialization of education in this domain. There is a need for a re-think with more broad-based consultations, taking care to exclude conflicts of interests in the process of decision-making.</p><p>(Note: Both of the above articles have been published elsewhere. The latter on medical education policy is published in Frontline. This is with few edits to make it more relevant for this audience).</p><p><strong>Tasks before Peoples Movements (these need to be deliberated upon and evolved in a national meet):</strong></p><p>1. That there is a substantial increase in public financing of healthcare education, and complete abolition of capitation fees and management quotas.</p><p>2. That 100 % of seats are under price control- and in the event that this is unviable for private sector to manage these institutions, these should be taken over by the government.</p><p>3. That at least 50% of seats are free or nominally charged- so that all sections of society can access such education, and no student is denied access to education because of inability to pay for it.</p><p>4. That further seats in healthcare education be prioritized for districts with inadequate human resources- with matching policies to ensure local candidates and candidates willing to serve in these areas get preferential access to this education.</p><p>5. To demand that functions of regulation of quality in healthcare education be a state subject. The national accreditation and rating process would be voluntary and independent of permission and licensing. The National board can review the functioning of the state boards for quality in healthcare education, and where there are defects give directions to improve their functioning- but the actual assessment and action would be the responsibility of the state board. (if state board remains deficient, there has to legal remedies that the national board can resort to ??)</p><p>6. That quality of care in healthcare education be the function of state boards which have representation from healthcare professionals, educationists, health rights groups and administrators- and that these boards function in a transparent manner. The quality indicators of each institution need to be publicly displayed and based on processes established.</p><p>7. The selection processes should be fair and transparent- and may therefore opt for a common examination. The entrance examinations are best state specific with a central examination for only 15 to 30% of the seats. States could consider selections based on school board results converting school leaving scores into percentiles. Different forms of affirmative action to ensure under-serviced areas get the human resources they need should be encouraged.</p><p>8. The exit from healthcare educational institution should be by an examination conducted by the state university, and licensing should also depend on it. These examinations should be reviewed for quality, and these details be known publicly</p><p>9. Recruitment for government jobs- central and state- could use a common examination, and other employers could also use the scores on this examination for recruitment also.</p><p>10. The content of the healthcare education should include a strong foundation on ethics, gender sensitivity, constitutional obligations and equity- and should aim to build graduates who have compassion. This is not just a stated intention but should have clear processes and measures.</p><p>11. The content of healthcare education should also be appropriate to what is required of that category of professional in a given context. Setting of educational standards should reflect this. This may require the creation of new professional entities and courses.</p><p>12. There is a need for much better and much more extensive faculty development programs at all levels and for all healthcare education.</p><p>13. There has to be a rapid increase in the number of human resources employed by public health services, across the districts and states. This is essential to absorb the graduates from the healthcare education and to address problems of inequity in access to healthcare. Expecting graduates to find their own way in private markets for healthcare will merely lead to overcrowding and unhealthy competition in areas already having excess- while leaving large parts of India without essential healthcare services.</p><p>14. For regulation in professional ethics, state boards must be constituted for each profession, in each state. These boards should have leadership from within the profession, but there must be significant and empowered representation of other sections of society, so that it is not limited by professional solidarity, and can reflect larger societal objectives and concerns, while remaining fair and transparent. The national board can review the adequacy of the state boards and make directions to improve its functioning, but the actual implementation would be by the state board.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6e2a368ae2c1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy/part-3-the-making-of-the-health-professional-changing-policies-in-health-professional-education-6e2a368ae2c1">Part 3: The Making of the Health Professional — Changing Policies in Health Professional Education…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy">Conversations on Health Policy</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unpacking Ayushman Bharat and other Recent Health Policy initiatives: Part II]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy/unpacking-ayushman-bharat-and-other-recent-health-policy-initiatives-part-ii-ab30ae1d16a?source=rss-cfe3781b0191------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ab30ae1d16a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[primary-healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universal-health-coverage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health-policy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sundararaman T]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Sep 2019 04:37:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-27T04:37:55.651Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Ayushman Bharat: Health and Wellness Centers</strong></p><p>The design, the many variants and the key barriers, and what peoples’ movements should do about it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/30/0*oRc2X1Pr4pzVyNhP" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/648/0*FeWnssXY5JEfEgnx.jpeg" /></figure><ol><li><strong>What are Health and Wellness Centers?</strong></li></ol><p>This component of Ayushman Bharat promises to upgrade health sub-centers and primary health centers into what is called health and wellness centers. The target is 1.5 lakh HWCs, which is roughly equivalent to the total number of sub-centers in existence (1.46 lakhs). Each sub-center caters to about 5000 population. In tribal and hilly and desert areas it could cater to 3000 population or even less. This target of 1.5 lakh HWCs would, according to the government, be achieved by 2022.</p><p>Health and Wellness Centers differs from both the existing sub-centers and urban dispensary services and even the primary health centers in four important ways:</p><p>a. The primary healthcare services available to households in that area are comprehensive- NOT selective.</p><p>b. All the services are organized in a manner that ensures continuity of care. There are two types of continuity- if a patient with chronic illness comes in periodically, the center is equipped to provide follow up and medication so that the treatment can be continued without a break 365 days of the year. And secondly –vertical continuity between the primary healthcare provider and the consultant/specialist/doctor at the higher levels. For most illnesses, the doctor or specialist will see the patient and confirm the diagnosis and make a treatment plan- and then the treatment is continued by the service providers in the HWC.</p><p>c. The services at a HWC are delivered by a team- ideally of at least one Mid Level Healthcare provider or doctor plus two female multi-purpose workers and one male multipurpose worker plus about 5 ASHAs (community health workers).</p><p>d. The services are population based- not limited to individuals. The doctor in a urban dispensary, like a Mohalla clinic, or the usual general practitioner in private practice feels responsible for those who sought their care. But a HWC is responsible for the health of the entire list of households/individuals assigned to them, those who are usually resident in their area. Thus, children or adults who are at risk, and the population who need preventive services like screening for common cancers even if they appear well.</p><p><strong>2. Why is this such a big thing. Was this not what primary health centres were always mandated to do?</strong></p><p>A. If we are referring to the Alma Ata declaration, the answer is yes. This was exactly what primary healthcare was meant to be. However if we are referring to currently existing primary healthcare facilities and even the healthcare policy since 1993- the answer is a big NO. Sub-centers and PHCs fulfil the criteria of continuity of care and being population based for only a very selective package of services- typically immunization, and care in pregnancy, contraceptive services and care in tuberculosis, HIV, malaria and leprosy. To some extent for cataract blindness also. This accounts for only about 10 to 15 % of all primary healthcare needs. For the remaining 85% of health care needs there are NO services at the primary level- or at best very sporadic, one-time consultations with no arrangements to ensure continuity or compliance or control. Under the re-branding of this concept as HWCs, there is a potential to bring back the full notion of primary healthcare. Even within the understanding of achieving universal health coverage, the HWCs would be the main strategy.</p><p>B. Even the current list of services under the HWC is not comprehensive enough. But it makes for a big start. The 12 services listed for delivery by HWCs are as follows:</p><p>i. Care in pregnancy and child-birth<br>ii. Neonatal and infant health care services<br>iii. Childhood and adolescent health care services<br>iv. Family planning, Contraceptive services and other Reproductive Health Care services<br>v. Management of Communicable diseases including National Health Programmes<br>vi. Management of Common Communicable Diseases and Outpatient care for acute simple illnesses and minor ailments.<br>vii. Screening, Prevention, Control and Management of Non-Communicable diseases<br>viii. Care for Common Ophthalmic and ENT problems<br>ix. Screening and Basic management of Mental health ailments<br>x. Basic Oral health care<br>xi. Elderly and Palliative health care services<br>xii. Emergency Medical Services</p><p>The first five of these are already on the existing health sub-centers and Primary Health Centre mandate. The Health and Wellness Centre adds the other 7 services also.</p><p>Since most Primary Health Centres (PHCs) are also not providing these services, by including these in the list the government is making the point that these too should be capable of providing this list of services. The PHC would not need additional human resources if it has the level mandated by Indian Public Health Standards (IPHS), but it would need to organize its service delivery better.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/25/0*vOQkQWBFUl30pTz1" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/284/0*lt7_Ap1JZgUETlq2.png" /></figure><p><strong>3. Primary Health Care is about preventive and promotive services. But this above list of HWC services seems dominated by curative care.</strong></p><p>a. The emphasis must remain on prevention and promotion. Inter-sectoral action on environmental and social determinants will be limited to what can be done at the level of the village through village health, sanitation and nutrition committees (VHSNCs) and with respective departments taking a lead role in their areas of accountability. Public health tasks such as vector control continue without losing emphasis. This has never been questioned nor have they been in doubt.</p><p>b. But what is added on now is “secondary prevention”. The early detection of diseases like hypertension and diabetes through screening programmes and appropriate treatment is what saves lives in a large number of non-communicable diseases. Even in chronic communicable diseases like TB, HIV, leprosy, etc, early detection and appropriate treatment has a major preventive role. So, it is quite misleading to think of preventive and curative as being in two separate silos in a public health care system.</p><p>c. Establishing such secondary prevention as part of primary health care would also give urgency to primary prevention in terms of reduction in exposure to risk factors. This would include change in diet, increased exercise, better life styles, reduced use of tobacco and alcohol and such factors. Currently very little happens in many elements of such promotive care.</p><p>d. This is not to diminish the importance of how economic policies and development policies act as determinants of ill health. But building awareness for policy changes in development policies at the state and national levels must be accompanied by and would be reinforced by local action to ensure the above elements of care as individual entitlements.</p><p><strong>4. The government claims that they now have about 7500 to 10,000 HWCs that are functional. Are the HWCs on the ground similar to what is promised? Or like the way the Alma Ata declaration of primary healthcare was reduced to selective healthcare, are there major deviations from the conceptual framework when it comes to implementation? The World Bank and other international aid agencies and global health institutions played a key role in reducing the Alma Ata declaration to selective primary health care. What are they up to now?</strong></p><p><strong>Response:</strong> It is important to note that the conceptual framework on which HWCs is based is part of a progressive framework on comprehensive primary health care that has evolved over many decades and which peoples’ movements have contributed greatly to shaping. Therefore, there is great urgency for peoples’ movements to be alert to deviations that trivialize or divert from the main objectives and call out/expose such deviations. Otherwise a government that is reluctant to implement the HWC concept in full will make use of the discontent with HWCs as implemented to scuttle the whole concept itself.</p><p>Some of the main deviations and distortions in the implementation of HWCs are listed below:</p><p><strong>A)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to what services are provided in the HWC:</strong></p><p>i. Instead of comprehensive primary healthcare, just one or two NCDs- usually hypertension and diabetes are added into the selective package. There is no effort to move to other services at all. In some states, even for hypertension and diabetes only screening and an unstructured referral up is done. There is no feedback from the referred doctor/specialist and no effort to ensure access to medication and follow up tests throughout the year at the HWC. In some states, it is even more cynical and HWCs have become only a branding exercise. A new coat of paint is given, the name of the center is changed- but no expansion of services occurs.</p><p>ii. In some states the focus is yoga. The scheme does see yoga as an important element of promotive health- and as one element among many there is case for it. But it certainly should not be the central or main agenda, displacing the other core services that HWCs are meant for. Any efforts to expand infrastructure in terms of yoga halls etc would be a distortion of priorities. There are many local administrators or officers who may take this path- since there is much less work involved, and it can distract from the main purpose, and since there is money that can be made in infrastructure.</p><p>iii. Improving infrastructure is one important element- but it is not and should not become the central component. There are examples where the entire emphasis is on beautification- painting the walls, putting ceramic tile flooring, re-building rooms and toilets etc. Part of this happens because this is what local administrators have understood the program to be. A more negative view would be that this happens because there is more opportunity to spend and to make money in infrastructure activity. The real danger is that equating upgradation to HWCs with improved infrastructure, would lead to a betrayal of expectations. Worse, when after all this expenditure, utilization does not go up, it would become another argument to favor privatization. The reasons for poor utilization lie in the lack of appropriate services — not in the lack of ceramic flooring.</p><p>iv. In some states the attention is given to starting up a general out-patient clinic and providing medicines and even some diagnostics in it. This helps, and like in the Mohalla clinic, can even be welcomed. But without the continuity of care for chronic illness, without the population-based coverage, without the referral platforms, it will not make much of a difference. The initial welcome will soon go away because people will have to go in search of better care for their healthcare needs than what such a clinic can prepare.</p><p>v. In most states, the feeling is that we should proceed gradually to add services to the package. But gradually based on what? Now the entire healthcare system waits for central directives before any service is added on. However, there is no reason to deny any service from these 12 service areas if there is a suitable specialist who is available to confirm diagnosis, make a treatment plan and communicate it to the the staff at the HWC, and then also be available if there is any complication</p><p><strong>B)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to Human Resources:</strong></p><p>i. The most common distortion is to equate the HWC with appointing a mid level health care provider. The rest of the team is not even thought about or planned for. There is neither a clear work distribution, nor the requisite training. The mid level healthcare provider alone cannot make a difference.</p><p>ii. The other common distortion is to understand the mid level healthcare provider as a substitute doctor- because doctors do not go to rural areas. In most or all chronic illnesses the doctor or specialist is not substituted by the MLHP. Once the diagnosis is confirmed and treatment plan made by the doctor, the MLHP would, with the help of the team, ensure follow up Related to this distortion, is the failure to design training programmes that enable MLHPs and the rest of the team to play this role.</p><p>iii. Another problem is the debate about whether the MLHP should be a B.Sc nurse or a GNM nurse, or an ANM or an AYUSH provider, or a three year new graduate. Can dentists and physiotherapists be allowed to become MLHPs? This debate diverts us from the main features of a MLHP- which should be a) he/she should be of that locality/block/district and happy to be working there b) he/she should be trained close to their place of work and preferably in state language using standard treatment protocols — and this training should be a periodic life long process c) that he/she should be conditionally licensed only to work in primary health care within government institutions- and not to become private providers- which means that even at the time of recruitment into the training, their employment position should be assured and d) one would need them as part of a permanent workforce- and not on an ad hoc contractual basis. E) they should always be working under the supervision of doctor/doctors in the public health system. It does not really matter which allied health professional or nursing qualification they have to begin with. If these five conditions are fulfilled, they would play their role- and if these are not, whatever their qualification they would not be able to work.</p><p><strong>C)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to continuity of care:</strong></p><p>i. The most common distortion is a complete failure to plan for the link with the doctor/specialist who shall receive the referral confirm diagnosis, make the treatment plan and rule out or manage complications, and communicate to the providers in the HWC- all according to a standard treatment protocol.</p><p>ii. The other common distortion is to assume that the providers empanelled with PMJAY will take care of this referral function. Not only does the PM-JAY not provide for such consultation, the incentive environment for the PM_JAY hospital is not to promote preventive care and avoid or delay the need for procedures. Rather, their interest is in increasing the number of secondary and tertiary care opportunities they have.</p><p>iii. A third distortion is to grossly underestimate the quantity of medicines required to provide continuity of medication and diagnostic support to patients with chronic illness. Thus, even if all persons with hypertension in a community were taking only one tablet per day, a population of 5000 with about 10% of those about 30 years having hypertension would need close to a lakh anti-hypertensive tablet. There is little effort in understanding and organizing the logistics for such increase in access to medication. The same goes for diagnostics. If the government is serious about HWCs as the route to UHC and of the promise to free drugs and diagnostics, it can certainly manage this.</p><p><strong>D)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to Population Based Care</strong></p><p>i. Most HWCs still limit population-based care to immunization, pregnancy, tuberculosis. There is no commitment to seek out those who have not been screened, or those defaulting on taking medicines, or those not taking care for complications etc. But ASHAs should make household visits that ensure this. And there has to be a system of documenting the health needs of different families and individuals and being able to follow it up. For example, a HWC team would know what proportion of population at risk have been screened for hypertension or diabetes, what proportion were confirmed to have that disease and how many of these are registered with the HWC for regular care, and finally in what proportion of them was hypertension controlled.</p><p>ii. There is no allocation of households to each HWC. This problem is most ….in urban areas. In rural areas there is at least an implict understanding. That would further mean that every household and individual would have a health card that indicates which is the HWC that is closest to their residence and to which they are attached. That card would also help support access for their health needs if they have any health risk or chronic illness.</p><p>iii. All of this would be greatly helped if the right ICT tools are available- but ICT tools and smart cards are not a substitute for the team building and coordination that is required. One distortion of HWCs is to equate it with introduction of ICT and smart cards. Often ICT tools add an additional layer of work for the overburdened providers without enabling local planning or decision making. Good ICT design should decrease the burden of data collections and reporting of the HWC providers. It will take quite a while to use UHC app (ICT tool) appropriately- and HWCs need not wait till then to expand the services they provide.</p><p>iv. The defnition of population should include all households and individuals usually resident in that area. Even three months residence in a year should be counted. No exclusions based on ID documentation should be permissible- since healthcare is an inalienable human right. Special care must be taken to ensure that migrants and seasonal workers are included. And if they are from another place in Indiathe continuity of care should be assured. If a person not usually resident in that area seeks care, that care should be provided. The only difference is that there is no assurance of follow up at household level to ensure compliance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/26/0*EUJDgupopLl0YMR3" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/977/0*Winf2mJUS1sAOFsc.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>5. What should be the popular demands that peoples’ health movements should make at the level of the village/urban poor?</strong></p><p>There is a need for popular campaigns to demand the following as an entitlement:</p><p>a. Any person with a chronic illness who needs to take medicines every day, or very often for the rest of their lives would be able to get their medicines in the sub-centre (HWC), free of costs. This is a long list. It includes medicines for hypertension, diabetes, angina, mental illnesses, epilepsy, asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, arthritis- just to name some of the most important ones.</p><p>b. If any person is detected with any of these illnesses when he or she comes for a visit for any other illness or a health check- up, they would be entitled to a reference for confirmation at the higher level (facilitated by the HWC) and they would have a treatment plan made by the specialist- with some elements of routine follow up being provided at the HWC.</p><p>c. Every person over 30 years would be actively screened at the HWC once a year for diabetes, hypertension and once in three to five years for chronic illnesses like cancer cervix, breast and oral cancers. If they are suspected of having the disease, they would be referred to a higher center and have the diagnosis confirmed and a treatment plan made. Similarly, all newborns have to be screened at the place of their birth. All pregnant women are already being screened.</p><p>d. There should be an out patient service on all 5 days of the week in the HWC- so that a much wider range of acute simple illness can be treated. This would include fever, acute respiratory infections, common infectious diseases etc.</p><p><strong>6. What should be the demand of peoples’ movements at the level of policy, advocacy and agitation? What should peoples’ movements be alert about with respect to pressures from international donors and corporate India?</strong></p><p>a. There is a great danger that the HWC can turn out to be another jhumla. The real push is on PM-JAY, while the HWC is only for show- to give the appearance of a evidence based progress towards UHC for public consumption and for international agencies like the UN. There are two key indicators of whether it is jhumla or a real action on the ground. The first indicator is the financial resources allocated to it. The second is the human resources policy.</p><p>i. Financing: By the governments own estimates it requires about 9 lakhs recurrent and 8 lakhs non recurrent expenditure- additional to what is currently spent on sub-centers and PHCs. This is a serious under-estimate — but even if we use this figure the allocation would be 13,500 crores per year or 65,700 crores recurrent plus 12,000 crores non-recurrent or about 77,000 crores over 5 years. The actual amount needed, if full HR and medicines and referral costs are included is likely to be at least twice that. But that would be about 1 % of GDP- a reasonable estimate. In the current year the allocation was only 1600 crores. In the previous year, the allocation was notional.</p><p>ii. Matching Human Resources Policies: The HR policy needs to provide resources for hiring the entire team, plus the ASHAs on a regular basis. And also we need to create HR policies which enable us to overcome the very skewed availability of human resources. Very often the government starts by stating that other than increasing HR, one can consider all options. Which means negating the whole program.</p><p>b. There is a need to identify distortions of the concept and build public and even provider understanding of what comprehensive primary health care means. Equating these distortions with HWCs would lead to loss of credibility regarding the whole idea of primary health care — and HWCs would be quietly shelved or reduced to some token level- while all the media attention etc. is focussed on the insurance scheme. An alert peoples movements and a democratic polity has a choice in how it goes about its protest ; It can demand that HWCs ought to be developed without these distortions, as the route to comprehensive primary health care and expose efforts that deviate, distort or trivialize the scheme. OR it could be dismissive of HWCs and thus add to the energies that for a variety of often varied reasons, call for ignoring if not scrapping the scheme. The PM-JAY is in no danger of being ignored- and there would be an active lobby of healthcare industry very ready to support and shape it. Every single media channel, newspaper and periodical, especially those specializing in health care, would be watching it roll out. (PMJAY covers journalists also). Comprehensive primary health care, on the other hand, does not attract such attention or support. It has no support except sections of the health policy community and peoples’ health movements. What peoples’ health movements do would therefore be critical.</p><p>c. The other big danger is the push to outsource clusters of HWCs to the private sector- and within that to the corporate sector. The BMGF (Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation) has a number of pilots and initiatives to do just this. BMGF currently leads this effort. USAID too actively supports these initiatives. Swasthya Piramal, Tata Trusts, Apollo Hospitals/enterprises are major corporate players who are interested in developing such models. The World Bank is more focussed on PMJAY. Niti Aayog has been pushing for private sector participation in HWCs — and has included a commitment to outsource at least a proportion of HWCs as part of the mandate of Aysuhman Bharat. There are also efforts to push part or all of HWCs into the National Health Authority and/or fuse it with the PMJAY platform in the name of integration. In all of these models the aim is to create a network of private providers linked to a corporate entity, which the government would contract in. The corporate agency will then engage the private providers either as a sub-contract or as employees. Till date, this approach has not succeeded. This lack of success is partly due to good sense prevailing in the ministry about their own ability to ensure that private sector abides by the contract, and partly because private players are not very keen. Part of the lack of progress in outsourcing despite political pressures to do so is because of the technical complexities of contracting a corporate consortium to provide primary healthcare. But a number of international agencies and Indian pro-industry academicians and consultancy organizations are trying to address the technicalities of contracting and promoting innovations in organizing services. This has given time and space for the public sector/healh ministry to come up with viable and visible government run HWCs.Would corporate India run better primary healthcare than what government would? Given the prevailing culture and perceptions fostered by neo-liberalism and the rise of right wing populism, many would support such a perception. But if experience and evidence is any guide, then what is far more likely is that it would, like in PMJAY, only lead to profits for private health sector, a weakening of public services and no major contribution to health.</p><p><strong>7. Is this idea of HWCs a new idea? Has it been tried anywhere?</strong></p><p>The name is new. But this is the basic concept of primary health care, before selective health care came along. Many nations in the world have organized care along these lines and are doing it for very long and very successfully. In the developed world, UK’s National Health Services is a model of such care- and it has been there for over 70 years. Most other developed nations also have similar arrangements for primary health care. In the developing world Cuba, Thailand and Brazil have very similar programmes. Thailand in particular is very similar to what is proposed in India. Over 95% of primary health care providers in all these nations are within the public sector- just like in India.</p><p>In fact, this is what was always meant by primary health care. Such organization of services is what peoples’ health movements have been demanding since its inception.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ab30ae1d16a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy/unpacking-ayushman-bharat-and-other-recent-health-policy-initiatives-part-ii-ab30ae1d16a">Unpacking Ayushman Bharat and other Recent Health Policy initiatives: Part II</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy">Conversations on Health Policy</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unpacking Ayushman Bharat and other Health Policy initiatives of the last one year (2018 -19)…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy/unpacking-ayushman-bharat-and-other-health-policy-initiatives-of-the-last-one-year-2018-19-2b3a9080c34e?source=rss-cfe3781b0191------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2b3a9080c34e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health-insurance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sundararaman T]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Sep 2019 04:29:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-28T04:57:08.679Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Unpacking Ayushman Bharat and other Health Policy initiatives of the last one year (2018 -19): Part 1</h3><h3>The task before peoples’ health movements</h3><p>I. Ayushman Bharat: PMJAY (Modicare)<br>II. Ayushman Bharat: Health and Wellness Centres<br>III. The Making of the Health Professional: Changing Policies in Healthcare Education and Professional Regulation <br>IV. Privatization, Public Private Partnerships and Growth of Healthcare Industry: The Niti Aayog at work. <br>V. Developments in Access to medicines, patents and innovation<br>VI. Gender Issues in Health and Healthcare. <br>VII. The Social Determinants of Health.</p><p><strong>I. AYUSHMAN BHARAT:</strong></p><p>This is the main health program initiated under the NDA Government. It was launched in 2018. This program has two components; the Health and Wellness Centres &amp; the Prime Ministers Jan Arogya Yojana. The former is an approach to comprehensive primary health care and the latter is a publicly funded health insurance scheme to provide access and financial protection to BPL families requiring secondary and tertiary health care. We describe each of these schemes below, and the problems we have with the way these are designed and implemented, as also the way Peoples Health Movements, Peoples Science Movements and all democratic forces should respond to these policies and their implementation.</p><h3>Prime Ministers Jan Arogya Yojana: (Modicare)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wrnkCgnk7qZ8mmAk.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>1. </em><strong>What is this scheme? A description</strong></p><p>This is a Government Funded Health Insurance Program. Those who are poor by the socio-economic caste census or identified as belonging to certain occupational categories are eligible for this scheme. An estimated 10.74 crore families (about 50 crore individuals) are estimated to be eligible.</p><p>Under this scheme, if any eligible individual needs what is called a secondary care or tertiary care treatment/procedure, they can go to any empanelled hospital. The hospital will admit them and provide them free care- no charges at all. All medicines, diagnostics and even some element of the transport are to be paid by the hospital without charging the patient. The government would then reimburse the hospital on the agreed upon rate. A family can utilize up to Rs 5 lakh rupees of such treatment in a year (called a family floater basis- since anyone defined and enrolled as part of the family can be paid for within this Rs 5 lakhs. All pre-existing illnesses are also covered, and some part of pre-hospitalization and post hospitalization expenses are also covered.</p><p>PM-JAY has defined 1,350 medical packages covering surgery, medical and day care treatments.</p><p>Both government hospitals and private hospitals are empanelled under this scheme. About 60 % of the number of claims and about 75% of the total value of claims is made by and paid to the private sector hospitals.</p><p>It will offer a benefit cover of Rs. 500,000 per family per year (on a family floater basis).</p><p><strong>2. There is a wide welcome for this scheme in media, among providers and even in public? Why has this been so welcomed?</strong></p><p><strong>i. </strong>Free or subsidized care in the public hospitals was the main approach to ensuring that everyone received affordable and good quality healthcare. However, the capacity of the public health services to deliver services is very limited, and a majority of people are either forced to , or are choosing to seek care in the private sector. The high costs of such private healthcare leads to high levels of financial hardship and to impoverishment that affects the whole family. Insurance schemes are meant to protect against this. Hence there is a considerable welcome from the public</p><p><strong>ii.</strong> Private Hospitals have considerable un-used capacity. There is no shortage of number of sick patients, but there is a shortage of those who can pay. Also, typically, much of the profits of the modern hospital comes from deployment of high-end technologies used in diagnostics, procedures and surgeries. The number of paying patients who need or can be persuaded to consume these procedures are limited. Publicly funded insurance is thus a boost to what is nowadays referred to as India’s private healthcare industry.</p><p><strong>iii.</strong> Much of the media welcome and the welcome in civil society and academic circles is because shifting to private providers is seen as a desirable reform, in tune with the times. Private providers are perceived as better in quality and public providers as inherently of poor quality. This is not so much a perception of the poorer and weaker population, but it is very much the perception of the middle class. The differing perceptions are in part due to the considerable heterogeneity in the type of private sector encountered, and the influence of the pro-private, anti-public sector discourse in these sections.</p><p><strong>3. Government has claimed considerable success in this scheme and it is considered as one of the big achievements of the Modi government. What is the truth and what is just hype?</strong></p><p><strong>i.</strong> Government claims “Modicare” is the largest health scheme in the world. This is far from true. In terms of budgetary outlay, it is one of the smaller schemes- less than even the National Health Mission- and certainly less than what most states are spending on health. In terms of insurance coverage also, it provides cover to much less diseases than most other comparable scheme in other nations. In terms of the population covered by an insurance scheme, it would be less than what China covers.</p><p><strong>ii.</strong> The number of those actually enrolled is only 3 crores- though 12 crores are eligible for a smart card.</p><p><strong>iii.</strong> In almost all the states where PMJAY is seen to be effective, the central government has merely added its name to a pre-existing state government run health insurance program. The central government in return is also committed to paying 60% of the costs- though for a number of reasons this has not fully happened. The state governments are also being persuaded to change some of the rules they have evolved, and many states which had reasonably effective schemes in place- like Kerala, are suffering as a consequence.</p><p><strong>iv.</strong> The government’s claim to success is largely based on the number of claims they have received and paid, across the states. There is no evidence at all on whether health outcomes have improved or even whether the poor have been protected from financial hardships due to healthcare costs. A considerable number of studies have been conducted on the earlier government funded health insurance programs and they all have shown the following patterns:</p><p><strong>a. Lack of Information:</strong> Most of those eligible do not know about the scheme, and therefore are unable to claim its benefits.</p><p><strong>b. Denial of Care:</strong> Of those who are eligible and who know about the scheme, a large proportion are denied benefits on one or other technical grounds. The most common being to state that the scheme does not cover the illness or procedure that the patient has, or that the hospital does not offer that particular service.</p><p><strong>c. Double Billing</strong>- Of those who successfully manage to seek care under the scheme, almost all are billed for some or all of the services, for which they have to pay out of pocket. Free, cashless services are almost a myth. At best they may have to pay about 20% less than those who do not have a card. Having charged the patient, the hospital goes on to get reimbursed from the government also.</p><p><strong>d. Supply driven care</strong>: Quite often the private hospital tends to provide much more of those procedures, for which they have greater profits, and deny those where the profit margins are less. Sometimes they actively recruit those patients who qualify for the procedures that they wish to supply. Thus, if we examine the pattern of claims across districts, there is little correlation with epidemiology- but a lot with which private providers are enrolled and pushy.</p><p><strong>e. Substituting, not supplementing, public services:</strong> The aim of bringing in private sector was to provide access to many procedures which are not currently available within the government hospital. However, if we examine the claims of each state, they tend to provide services in those same few areas where government already provides care. For example, in UP, Bihar, and Chhattisgarh, it would cater to normal deliveries and cataract surgeries, which are the few procedures that government provides. But when it comes to renal stones, or glaucoma, or acute abdomen or burns, there would be little contribution from the insurance scheme.</p><p><strong>f. Inappropriate care and dumping:</strong> Earlier if a private hospital could not provide the care to a poor patient, it would refer the patient away. Now, the same hospital is likely to admit the patient, exhaust all the money that the patient has in the smart card, and then refer the patient away. The treatment gets delayed and is exhausted of all resources when he or she reaches the government public hospital. Dumping patients who have exhausted their insurance coverage into public hospitals is a common practice even in the USA.</p><p>4. <strong>Is not government aware of these problems? What is being done to address these? And why is it not doing more? If government seriously addresses these issues, can we then expect the insurance program to provide relief?</strong></p><p><strong>·</strong> Government is aware of these problems. The government has both a grievance redressal system and monitoring mechanisms. The grievance redressal system is under-used by beneficiaries who are not aware of their entitlements as also how to seek redress for it. Even those who seek redressal have a poor experience. The big problem is that it takes great effort to bring a grievance to notice, and then what the private hospital gets is a very token penalty. Similarly, monitoring mechanisms are weakly functional, but even to the extent they are functional, authorities are unable or unwilling to take action against errant hospitals. Underneath there is a tacit understanding that such cheating is alright, since otherwise the private sector hospitals will refuse to participate. The current rates for each procedure that government is paying to hospitals are said to be low- but that is not the case. That is merely a convenient excuse for double billing- an excuse that those monitoring the scheme accept too readily even if it is in violation of the contract and the law. Delays in payment also push out ethical small providers who cannot manage the delays and uncertainties in reimbursement.</p><p>· Were the government to be serious about preventing all of the above distortions, and plan for adequate monitoring and grievance redressal, the immediate result would be that the private hospital participation would drop. Even now private hospitals are unwilling to come in at these rates. This in itself is not a bad thing, because public hospitals would continue, and so would not- for- profit hospitals and ethical small providers who are able to manage within these rates quite well.</p><p><strong>·</strong> However, in such a scenario, insurance and purchase from the private sector would be a supplement to a robust public sector- which because of ideological reasons the current policy makers are unwilling to accept.</p><p><strong>·</strong> While better monitoring would address issues like double-billing and denial, none of these solutions, and not even tighter regulation would affect the problem of supply driven care- when decisions on what care is to be provided is influenced by the monetary/business model driven interests of the provider more than that of the beneficiaries.</p><p><strong>5. There are many nations where insurance schemes are working well. How are these nations doing better? What prevents our government from adopting those strategies?</strong></p><p><strong>·</strong> Germany and Japan are examples of such nations, where providers are mainly private and payment is by insurance mechanisms. This is so in Canada and Australia also, though the proportion of public providers is much higher.</p><p><strong>·</strong> The single most important feature of these is that these are built around the principle of solidarity. Great care is taken to ensure that the decision making by providers is ring-fenced from immediate monetary incentives. The Japanese, for example, have a law against making profits from health care and for that reason little foreign direct investment/corporate funding comes in- since dividends cannot be paid. Germany rules out profits for insurance companies, and the government steps in to pay part of the premium to prevent losses and ensure equity.</p><p><strong>·</strong> All these nations which are insurance based have high degrees of regulation, where the prices of all healthcare services, even for those who are not insured, are regulated at the same prices as what the government allows. In Australia and Canada all payments are from the government. Along with taxes they collect different premiums from rich and poor, but the treatment for rich and poor, whether insured or not is the same. Families may purchase a second private insurance for higher quality of hospital care- but that is as much choice as is allowed.</p><p><strong>·</strong> Health systems which are insurance based a sentence is incomplete.</p><p><strong>·</strong> Thailand and UK are not insurance schemes in the conventional sense. They are much better and more flexible forms of public financing and public managing/ management by the public. Here again, clinical decisions are ring-fenced from monetary considerations. The market is kept out of the transaction.</p><p><strong>·</strong> All national health systems that are largely based on purchasing healthcare from private providers spend much more than other systems which are dominated by public providers. Thus, Sri Lanka spends only 3% of the GDP, Thailand 4% of GDP, Cuba and Brazil 8% of GDP. In contrast, USA, which is free market plus insurance based, spends 19% of GDP on healthcare.</p><p><strong>·</strong> In nations like India and the USA, the principle is of “making markets work for healthcare.” Which really means figuring out how to channel public expenditure on health through private sector, so that they are able to benefit from it. That leads to a huge over-consumption of care, much of which is unnecessary, while large proportions of population are excluded from the care that is needed.</p><p><strong>·</strong> The classic example is USA, which spends 19% of the US GDP on healthcare, and yet close to 25% of the population are uninsured and another 25 % or more are under-insured- meaning that the insurance cover which they have fails to pay for their healthcare need. India’s PMJAY is rapidly trying to take us down the US type of health insurance model.</p><p><strong>·</strong> If India was to achieve Universal Health Coverage based on purchasing care from a dominant private sector, it has to be ready to spend many times more than what it would need to spend in comparison to a public provisioning-based system.</p><p><strong>6. How should peoples’ movements respond to this initiative? What should their approach be to mobilizing people for change, and in shaping the public discourse on these subjects?</strong></p><p>The response has to be at many levels.</p><p>At the level of public discourse, Peoples Movements must disseminate a select few key messages- and this would have to be backed up by evidence:</p><p>a. The PM-JAY scheme is unable to deliver on its key promises, which are: providing financial protection for the costs of health care and increasing access to healthcare and improving health outcomes.</p><p>b. The PM-JAY is being projected as a great gain for the poor- but in reality, the main purpose it serves is as an economic boost to the private sector in healthcare. The poor would have been better served by increasing the quantity, range and quality of public services.</p><p>c. There is a need for much better monitoring of the PM-JAY and civil society organizations’ and people’s movements must be involved in such monitoring. If monitoring improves, many private providers would exit or have to be pushed out. But this is good, for it would leave only the ethical not- for- profit providers- and these could supplement the healthcare system. Furthermore, private providers may be encouraged only where public sector is unable to provide care.</p><p>d. Paying public providers using the current insurance mechanism brings the problems of private sector behaviour into the public sector. The insurance scheme can however be approached to top up the usual facility budget based on variety and quantity of cases managed in the previous months or year.</p><p>e. Payments to private providers must be made in a timely manner and without corruption, so that ethical players are encouraged to stay on. For both public and private providers, it is only the marginal capacity that should be paid for- (that is the running costs. It should not include the capital costs).</p><p>f. There has to be a substantial improvement in number of beds and range of services provided by public hospitals, along with improvement in quality of care. Quality of care should include all elements of patient dignity, comfort and satisfaction, and also access to timely care, polite behaviour, better patient communications and facilitation, fixing appointments for consultation etc. Public investment is best spent on achieving these objectives.</p><p>At the level of popular mobilization of those who are directly affected, peoples’ movements can undertake the following activities:</p><ol><li>Ensure that patients know their entitlements under the scheme, and where it is denied, they bring it to notice of authorities. These should include at least the following:</li><li>The patients are consulted and informed of price of services before they are charged the same.</li><li>The patients can readily see how much money is on the card, and how much is being charged and they receive a bill for it- even though they are not paying in cash. It should be clear that the same bill that the patient has signed is the basis for reimbursement.</li><li>That a patient is not denied any service for which the hospital is empanelled. The services they are providing and those they are not providing should be clearly listed in the contract itself and be available to the public.</li><li>After gathering testimonies or other forms of data on breach of the contractual terms, forms of collective protest can be organized. These could take the form of a petition, or news statement, or meetings etc.</li><li>Gather evidence of double-billing and help both individuals and organizations to challenge it.</li><li>Demand right to anonymized data base of the PM-JAY claims for district level analysis to identify distortions and patterns of supply driven care</li></ol><p><strong>7.</strong> <strong>PM_JAY is limited to inpatient care and procedures. It does not cover out-patient care and primary healthcare. But greater proportion of health expenditure is on out-patient care. Also, by keeping outpatient care outside the PM-JAY package, does not healthcare get fragmented? Should we therefore demand inclusion of out-patient care in the PM-JAY package?</strong></p><p>a. Out-patient care is far more difficult to monitor and regulate than in-patient care. When the PM_JAY platform is so prone to problems like double billing and inappropriate care, adding out-patient care will only exacerbate the problem. Also, much of primary health care and out-patient care at all levels is preventive and promotive- like screening for early detection, counselling and medication to prevent complications and the need for in-patient care and procedures. The business model of private hospitals and clinics is focused on curative care, preferably complex, secondary, and tertiary level care. The private sector is not the best carrier for preventive care, that too at the primary level.</p><p>b. A large game being played today is to somehow persuade government to route its one lakh crore expenditure in primary healthcare through the private sector. The proposal from international aid agencies promoting privatization in the primary healthcare sector is to go for a model where primary healthcare in a geographical area is outsourced to a corporate entity. The demand for inclusion of primary health care and outpatient care into PM_JAY can play into their hands, as the main providers within PM_JAY are private providers. Peoples’ movements need to insist on universal comprehensive primary healthcare being through public provisioning.</p><p>c. The other demand that we must guard against is asking for more funds for PM-JAY or reimbursement at higher rates for procedures. These will only drive more money into private hands without improving health outcomes, or access to health care, or financial protection.</p><p><strong>8.</strong> <strong>Should our main demand be roll back of all government funded insurance schemes?</strong></p><p>The JSA has already called for a complete rollback of insurance schemes with the alternative being strengthening public health services. There is merit in such a position. But many civil society and academic groups (and the HLEG report) also call for “complete rollback of insurance schemes” with the alternative being the outsourcing of all primary, secondary and tertiary care services in a geographical area to a corporate entity or integrated care network as they prefer to call it. Sometimes the alternative is articulated as contracting in all individual private doctors in that area- which in practical terms could amount to the same. Thus, a call for “completely roll back of insurance schemes” is a slogan that we should voice cautiously if at all. Given also the popularity of the insurance schemes within trade unions as well as many other sections of the people, it may be a wiser strategy in the current context to push for limiting the presence of insurance, with larger proportion of public providers, and call for ensuring that private providers adhere to contractual terms. Moreover, primary healthcare must remain separate and should be based on public provisioning. One would also need to call for making effective and expanding the ESI network and ensuring that the ESI as well as healthcare units of public sector undertakings are not privatized using insurance or any other route.</p><h3>REFERENCES:</h3><p>i. Prinja, S., Chauhan, A.S., Karan, A., Kaur, G., Kumar, R. 2017. Impact of Publicly Financed Health Insurance Schemes on Healthcare Utilization and Financial Risk Protection in India: A Systematic Review. <em>PLoS One.</em> 2017;12(2):e0170996. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0170996.</p><p>ii. Ranjan, A., Dixit, P., Mukhopadhyay, I., Thiagarajan, S. 2018. Effectiveness of government strategies for financial protection against costs of hospitalization Care in India. <em>BMC Public Health.</em> 2018;18(1):501. doi:10.1186/s12889–018–5431–8.</p><p>iii. Ravi, S., Ahluwalia, R., Bergkvist, S. 2016. Health and Morbidity in India (2004–2014); 2016. <a href="http://www.brookings.in./">www.brookings.in.</a> Accessed September 6, 2018.</p><p>iv. Rent, P., Ghosh, S. 1997. Understanding the “Cash-Less” Nature of Government-Sponsored Health Insurance Schemes. <em>SAGE Open.</em> 2015;5(4) doi:10.1177/2158244015614607.</p><p>v. Prinja, S., Bahuguna, P., Gupta, I. et al. 2019. Role of insurance in determining utilization of healthcare and financial risk protection in India. <em>PLOS One.</em> Published: February 5, 2019. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0211793">https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0211793</a></p><p>vi. Devadasan, N. Seshadri, T. Trivedi, M. Criel, B. Promoting universal financial protection: evidence from the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) in Gujarat, India. <em>Heal Res Policy Syst.</em> 2013;11(1):29. doi:10.1186/1478–4505–11–29.</p><p>vii. Fan, V.Y., Karan, A., Mahal, A. 2012. State health insurance and out-of-pocket health expenditures in Andhra Pradesh, India. <em>Int J Health Care Finance Econ.</em> 2012;12(3):189–215. doi:10.1007/s10754–012–9110–5.</p><p>viii. Ghosh, S. and Gupta, N. 2017. Targeting and Effects of Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana on Access to Care and Financial Protection. <em>Econ Polit Wkly</em>. january 28, 2017 vol LII No 4. 61–70</p><p>ix. Karan, A., Yip, W., Mahal, A. 2017. Extending health insurance to the poor in India: An impact evaluation of Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana on out of pocket spending for healthcare. <em>Soc Sci Med.</em> 2017;181:83–92. doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2017.03.053.</p><p>x. Nandi, S., Schneider, H., Garg, S. 2018. Assessing geographical inequity in availability of hospital services under the state-funded universal health insurance scheme in Chhattisgarh state, India, using a composite vulnerability index, <em>Global Health Action</em>, 11:1, 1541220, DOI: 10.1080/16549716.2018.1541220</p><p>xi. Nandi, S., Schneider, H., Dixit, P. 2017. Hospital utilization and out of pocket expenditure in public and private sectors under the universal government health insurance scheme in Chhattisgarh State, India: Lessons for universal health coverage. PLoS One. 2017;12(11):e0187904. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0187904.</p><p>xii. Acharya A. et al. 2012. <em>Impact of national health insurance for the poor and the informal sector in low and middle-income countries: a systematic review.</em> London: EPPI-Centre, Social Science Research Unit, Institute of Education, University of London.</p><p>xiii. Gertler, P. and Solon, O. 2000. <em>Who Benefits From Social Health Insurance in Developing Countries?</em> University of California at Berkeley. 2000.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2b3a9080c34e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy/unpacking-ayushman-bharat-and-other-health-policy-initiatives-of-the-last-one-year-2018-19-2b3a9080c34e">Unpacking Ayushman Bharat and other Health Policy initiatives of the last one year (2018 -19)…</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/conversations-on-health-policy">Conversations on Health Policy</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Part –III.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/from-prof-sundararamans-desk/part-iii-a85ed6962a4f?source=rss-cfe3781b0191------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a85ed6962a4f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sundararaman T]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Sep 2019 17:41:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-15T17:50:31.492Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Part 3: The Making of the Health Professional — Changing Policies in Health Professional Education and Professional Regulation, And the task before Peoples’ Health Movements</strong></h3><h3><strong>The National Medical Council Bill- 2019</strong></h3><p>A Jan Swasthya Abhiyan Policy Brief (<strong>up-dated 10th August, 2019)</strong></p><p>The need for a new act replacing the Medical Council Act is no doubt of utmost importance. Unfortunately, the National Medical Council Bill of 2019, now an Act, has failed to identify and address the main problems of the earlier council, and by rushing through this current bill using its brute majority, it has created considerable new dangers. Many state governments have also opposed this Act.</p><p>In this note we share with the public some of our major concerns with regard to this bill:</p><p><strong>Loss of Federal Structure</strong></p><p>Firstly, there is an almost complete abandonment of the federal structure and an obsession with centralizing every detail of both medical education policy and professional regulation, and all the means of implementation.</p><p><strong>Governed by the bureaucracy:</strong></p><p>Further, even at the centre the powers are immensely concentrated in the bureaucracy- with only a very token role for a limited number of 5 elected members. The representatives of the state medical councils elect these 5 members. The Commission has totally 25 members. All the other commission members are nominated. Search committees for key posts are also largely nominated by the government of the day. Not satisfied with this, the government arms itself with even more powers to give instructions to the commission on policies or overrule any policy made by the commission.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Apa6FqenhAxu33SM" /></figure><p><strong>States- Not decision makers, but advisors:</strong></p><p>There is a Medical Advisory Council, whose only role is to allow members to voice their views. States are represented in this by a government nominated representative specified as the Vice-Chancellor of the state’s Medical university (or equivalent) and a member nominated by the state medical council. This downgrades the state role from decision-making to consultative. Even on providing this limited space for consultation there seems to be high degree of risk-avoidance since peculiarly all members of the commission are also made members of the advisory council!!!</p><p><strong>Centralization and Institutional Capacity:</strong></p><p>Centralization and micro-management are also inherent in the scope of the commission since it has powers to make rules and regulations for almost every operational detail. It would need an incredibly high level of institutional capacity in this central institution to administer such a mandate- and nothing that one has seen of central ministries and institutions would give us the confidence that they can do so. A humbler and more honest estimate of their own capacity by the central government, would have allowed for a greater role to states within a broad framework set by the national commission.</p><p><strong>Open doors to private sector</strong></p><p>Despite its omnibus mandate, on one aspect the Commission is curtailed. It can at best “frame guidelines for determination of fees and all other charges in respect of fifty per cent. of seats in private medical institutions and deemed to be universities.” Implying that for 50% of seats there would be no regulation whatsoever. Even for this 50% there are no indications of what would be principles of fee decision. One of the more retrogressive steps in this bill is that it opens the door to ‘for-profit entities” for the first time, and in the current context this largely implies opening the gates for the corporate sector. The obligation of providing access and affordability to under-serviced populations and aspirants gets no mention. These are just off the agenda. The aim of this policy is only within a highly privatized sector, how government can be seen to be concerned with the problems of quality of education.</p><p><strong>Quality Assurance as Common National Examinations</strong></p><p>For assuring quality, there is only one idea, another great centralizing one, the common national examination, one for entry into the MBBS course (National Eligibility cum Entrance Examination- NEET) and the other for exit. (National Exit Examination- NEXT) The exit examination is the examination for the license to practice as well as the examination for entry into Post-graduation courses.</p><p><strong>The NEET Problems</strong></p><p>There are problems with both. As an entry test into the MBBS course (NEET) it does not help prioritize suitable candidates for under-served areas — which is a great necessity considering the highly skewed availability of human resources. It does not recognize the limitation of the MCQ format and why performance in this within a timeframe requires skills and practice different from what it takes to understand a subject or write the usual examination. It thereby boosts the coaching industry and shifts the measure of merit towards the wealthier students who can afford such coaching… There are powerful arguments why states prefer to hold such common entrance examinations at the state level. Some 15% of seats can be surrendered to a central pool for which a national examination would be relevant. There is an even stronger case for going only by school leaving marks with standardization of marks across different boards.</p><p><strong>The NEXT Problem:</strong></p><p>As an exit examination, the MCQ format is even more limited since it does not test skills and patient interaction. Also, a final year student passes through different subjects in phases- and combining all into a single examination does not help. It will also act as a barrier against innovation and improvement. As an entrance examination into post-graduation, both sets of problems as described for NEET and for exit examination apply. Along with some newer ones.</p><p><strong>Four Boards- but autonomous?</strong></p><p>The NMC mandates four autonomous boards- (a) the UG medical education board, (b) the PG medical education Board, © the Medical Assessment and Rating Board and (d) the Ethics and Medical registration Board. The separation of these functions is welcome and potentially a step in the right direction. But there is nothing to indicate how these are autonomous and how each of these Boards would have the capacity to do what is required of them, and how these would retain even a minimum of internal democratic functioning. The notion, that these four functions can be carried out across the country, by four five-member teams situated in Delhi. To solve this problem for the Medical Assessment and Rating Board the bill state that the Board may<em> “hire and authorize any other third-party agency or persons for carrying out inspections.”</em> The main problem with these boards is the way they completely undermine the state’s role.</p><p><strong>Corruption Neutral:</strong></p><p>One big reason for the new act, and for repealing the earlier act is corruption. But there is nothing in this bill that gives anyone the confidence that corruption would reduce. The shifting from board members and medical experts to third party agency is more likely to change the form of corruption than eliminate it.</p><p><strong>Ethics or Registry: Where is the capacity?</strong></p><p>The Ethics Board function combines with medical registry- though these are very different skill sets and different institutional requirements. The only overlap is that it could be easier to remove the name of a person debarred on ethical grounds from the medical register. Nowhere is there a recognition of what it takes to maintain a live register or identify those without a registration who are in practice- and what would be the mechanism by which this is done. The requirements of the ethics function of this board is not only understated, there is not enough on what it covers, and how these functions will be managed.</p><p><strong>Surprise Inclusion: Community Health Providers:</strong></p><p>The other major new inclusion in the bills is the clauses related to community health providers. To quote:</p><blockquote>“The Commission may grant limited licence to practice medicine at mid-level as Community Health Provider to such person connected with modern scientific medical profession who qualify such criteria as may be specified by the regulations;</blockquote><blockquote>Provided that the number of limited licences to be granted under this sub-section shall not exceed one-third of the total number of licenced medical practitioners registered under sub-section (1) of section 31.</blockquote><blockquote>The Community Health Provider who are granted limited licences under sub-section (1), may practice medicine to such extent, in such circumstances and for such period, as may be specified by the regulations.</blockquote><blockquote>The Community Health Provider may prescribe specified medicine independently, only in primary and preventive healthcare, but in cases other than primary and preventive healthcare, he may prescribe medicine only under the supervision of medical practitioners registered under sub-section (1) of section 32.”</blockquote><p>To the Indian Medical Association this is one of the main areas of opposition. They label this a backdoor entry to quackery. The truth is that after poor progress in nearly ten years of efforts to put in place a mid-level care provider for the sub-centre level, there is a quick move to use the rapid movement of this bill to include that need. While one could argue that there is a need for such a provider at the primary healthcare level, most nations and some of the Indian states which have such a cadre in place, have a separate legislation to cover that cadre. Like there is for nursing, pharmacists, allied healthcare providers etc. To hurriedly pack that new agenda into this bill, without so much as a definition of what this term means, and no understanding of qualifications, conditional licensing measures, entry or exit, scope of work etc is to ask for big trouble. Even if that is not the intent of the government, the IMAs worst fears on this would come to pass- and a poorly qualified healthcare provider could get generated who would then proceed to enter to the highly competitive, almost predatory urban markets for healthcare.</p><p><strong>Silences in the bill:</strong></p><p>There are also important silences of the bill on a few critical issues. For example, though the effective grievance redressal mechanisms is one of the stated objectives, there is no further mention of it in the bill. The bill is also completely silent on kick-backs, commissions and other conflict of interests. The Bill has little mention of what happens to the state medical councils and how its mandate would get modified.</p><p><strong>The Sub-Text: Professionals Role in Governance</strong></p><p>Part of the reasons why this bill has so many flaws is that the entire history of the poor functioning of the medical council has been reduced to the inability of the medical profession to govern itself and this in turn is attributed (in the sub-text) to be inherent problem of the profession. Therefore, it is assumed that the moment such professional control is removed or diluted, the problems would go away. To some extent the medical professionals in the past medical councils brought this on itself- by not only failing to check corruption and poor ethics, but often becoming seen as the source of such corruption and failing to even eject the leadership that was tainted by courts for such corruption. But that was not the only problem- nor even the main problem- and the solutions that this bill offers may act to worsen the situation. The failure to analyse or understand the other policy and systemic roots for problems like poor quality of education, corruption, ethical deficits, lack of live registers, failure to generate human resources that are appropriate to our needs all come together with an anti-professional bias to bring about a bill that satisfies no one, and solves very little.</p><p><strong>The Political Context</strong>:</p><p>The overall political context of this bill is also important to note. The main thrust of government policy is to shift the government from the role of provider of healthcare services to purchasing it from private providers through insurance or partnerships. This is a form of privatization where public expenditure to pay for the healthcare of the majority is routed through private providers at terms where they can make a profit and monopoly control can be encouraged. However, the lack of regulation — both in private medical education and private medical care is making this very difficult. Studies are showing that private providers do not abide by contractual terms and that private educational institutions are overwhelming corrupt and of poor quality. Instead of seeing the roots of the problem in privatization, the government would locate the problem entirely in the profession and professional regulation. This brings out stiff resistance from medical professionals.</p><p><strong>In conclusion:</strong></p><p>Clearly it is important to educate and shape public opinion on the provisions of the Act, our concerns regarding this- where we agree with the professional opinion as articulated by IMA and where we differ, and what would be the alternative formulations on some of the key issues.</p><p>Through this Act the central government has captured and concentrated all powers for improvement of medical education, and of closing gaps in availability of medical professionals and of quality of medical education in itself, and they would need to be held accountable for these tasks.</p><p>In the coming years as implementation of this Act begins, the problems are going to show up more glaringly. Already the ministry has begun with asking for a three-year time to begin implementation of NEXT as a licensing examination. Sections of civil society which have fought for health rights, professional associations and all democratic forces would need to exercise the utmost vigilance, ensure timely public exposure of the limitations and introduce into public discourse, better options/alternatives that could address these problems.</p><h3><strong>Health Professional Education and the Draft National Education Policy:</strong></h3><p>There are three important challenges that any policy on healthcare education would have to address:</p><p>First and most important of these is the serious mal-distributions of healthcare professionals across the nation. The national commitments to achieving universal access to healthcare can be achieved only if there is a minimum density of doctors, nurses, and allied healthcare professionals in every block and district of the nation. Such a distribution of healthcare professionals is closely linked to policies concerning entry into educational institutions, the context and content of the curriculum, and the subsequent policies of public financing and organization of public health services.</p><p>The second important challenge is ensuring the quality of education, so that the young men and women who are churned out of these institutions have the knowledge and skills to make the right decisions and provide the right care. Healthcare in a service sector where due to information asymmetry and uncertainties in outcome, the service user’s ability to make the choice of provider, or even to judge whether the care received was appropriate and adequate is limited. Further in most contexts of private practice the providers own monetary incentives may not be aligned with the best interest of the patient. All this calls for a high degree of trust and the state must ensure that healthcare professional have the skills to deserve such trust.</p><p>The third challenge is also a dimension of quality of education- it is not just technical competence in terms of knowledge and skills that is required, but an attitude of caring. These are caring positions where the majority of practitioners would have to feel fulfilled and creative though acts of preventing illness, of taking care of the sick and even in supporting the dying. No doubt at all levels of care, some technical skills are essential, but what is equally important is the empathy that care providers have for those they care for, and the close bonding that is required between providers and the communities that are served, and the ethical values they have imbibed during professional education and practice.</p><p>The Draft National Education Policy, not only fails to address these challenges, it could actively worsen it. (Healthcare education finds place in the draft National Education Policy as one of the sub-topics of the chapter on Professional Education). -</p><p>In table 1 below, we show the highly skewed distribution of undergraduate and post-graduate seats per lakh population across the states. Those states which have the largest shortfall of doctors are also the states where the number of seats per one lakh population are less than the national average. The distribution within states is also similarly skewed. A similar skew in availability of seats and professionals can also be demonstrated for nurses and for many of the allied health professionals.</p><p>Given the fact that upwardly mobile urban youth from more privileged sections are the most successful in gaining entry into healthcare educational institutions, the increases in seats in states with relative surplus is only going to lead to unhealthy competition and lowered remuneration for doctors within a few of the larger urban areas. It does not lead to surplus doctors and nurses shifting to under-serviced areas. Bonds and other forms of compulsion for working in rural areas seldom work, and even to the extent they do, such professionals would not have the same level of empathy and bonding with communities as a doctor who would actively choose to work in such an area. In many nations across the world, preferential admissions for students from under-serviced communities and regions along with commitments and incentives to go back to these areas after graduation is what has helped most in closing such service gaps.</p><p>The National Education Policy is silent on how these huge human resource gaps by region, by state, by gender, or by more marginalized castes and communities would be addressed. The silence is not surprising since equity in access to healthcare education and access to healthcare can be achieved only though public educational institutions based on public financing and affirmative actions such as free or highly subsidized education to bring in suitable candidates from these regions and communities. The silence would however be consistent with an approach that prioritizes opportunities for private profit in healthcare education and the demand of more privileged sections to send their children to medical schools over the public needs for health care. Over the last two decades commercialization of healthcare education has been rapidly increasing, and now the majority of the institutions are in the private sector. Further the majority of medical and nursing seats need such high payments that much of the population is actively excluded from such education. This NEP exacerbates this problem. It gives permission to educational institutions to charge any level of fees- and commits them only to providing scholarships for a proportion of the students- a commitment that in practice would be almost impossible to enforce.</p><p>The terms of such market driven expansion of healthcare education have led to great loss of quality in the output- a fact that is almost universally noted and lamented. The policy quite correctly states that regulatory regimes under the professional councils were inadequate to the task, and had serious conflicts of interests but the solutions proposed are worse than the problem. The NEP calls of dispensing with the role of councils as regulator, but in its stead what it proposes is one huge centralized structure that will command all of higher education, all across the nation. The NMC bill has already done this for medical education. The proposal is now to extend this approach to all of healthcare education. It is unclear whether; any single central institution can ever command such a capacity, or needs to. Constitutional provisions today put educational standard setting in the union list but explicitly leave regulation of higher education to the states.</p><p>But the bigger problem is an almost exclusive reliance on common national eligibility cum entrance examinations (NEETs) at every stage, as the single most important strategy of all educational governance. The proposal assumes that common examinations for entry at the under-graduate level and the post-graduate levels are effective and seeks to transform the latter to also serve as a common exit examination, for licensing purposes. Presumably the two NEETs would be the most fair and transparent purely merit based measurements of quality which would cut across the divides of public and private, communities and regions. If the proposal to allow all professional students to do a common first year foundational course followed by a merit-based sorting into medicine, nursing and dentistry streams is taken seriously, that would probably add a third NEET to the pool. But the challenges of implementing such a streaming are so ridiculously high, that we need not get distracted into discussing it.</p><p>The NEET itself has been a basis of considerable criticism and it is now clear that it is a tool that exacerbates inequities and undermines the federal nature of educational governance. Protest is maximal in precisely those states, like Tamilnadu, where after a long process of discussion with different sections a working balance had been struck between the needs of different regions to access healthcare and the needs of different sections of the population to access the opportunities of healthcare education. Then and now 15% of the under-graduate seats and 50% of the post-graduate seats were given to all India quota. But for filling up the 85% of seats, another merit based, fair and transparent systems was devised by states, which was perceived as giving students from government schools, and more marginalized communities studying with state language as a medium, and unable to afford costly coaching session, a reasonable chance of getting selected. Even this had problems. But post NEET, students who are from schools following central, all India examination boards, and those going to costly coaching schools which have cracked the sub-text of these examinations have a much stronger advantage.</p><p>Similarly, at the post-graduation level, the state of Tamilnadu had a system in place, where graduates could to work in rural areas, confident of the extent of advantage it would give them for accessing post-graduation and governments had worked out how to fill specialists’ posts in all its district hospitals. The state also had chosen to invest in expanding postgraduate and super-specialization courses using their own budgets and made public service after qualification mandatory for those getting government education. But with a nation-level centralization of the examination process, and surrender of 50% of postgraduate seats and 100% of super-specialization seats to the central pool, the ability of the state government to find the necessary candidates has been seriously compromised.</p><p>Further private educational institutions are allowed to keep fairly high levels of seats in the management quota. And thus, any student seeking admission in a private medical institution and able to pay the high fees and with enough influence to get selected would qualify with much lower NEET cut-off score. This system not only continues but also is encouraged within the language of the policy.</p><p>All of this emphasis on nation-wide common examinations is presumably in pursuit of measuring merit in a manner that is blind to social and educational backgrounds- a sort of huge educational level playing field that encourages a competition among students where the only currency is objectively measured merit. But then in a bizarre Freudian slip, the text of the draft policy has this gem: “this exit examination will be administered at the end of the fourth year of the MBBS so that students are relieved of the burden of studying for a separate, competitive entrance examinations at the end of their residency period. <em>With the entrance examination out of the way, they can spend their residency period acquiring valuable skills and competence</em>.” (para 16.8.3, pg. 305) The true import of this is that the proposed measure of testing would not measure valuable skills or competence, even those which are learnt in the most crucial part of the medical curriculum- the final year of clinical training. De jure, NEETs are the only basis for measuring learning. But de facto, the national common examination is accepted as a barrier to learning. The only use that NEET then has is as a device for ranking and sorting students into an apparent hierarchy of merit with all its attendant privileges and to exclude the rest and justify the exclusion. Close to 1.47 lakh medical graduates appeared for the PG-NEET examination last year, of which only about half are considered to have passed and only about 27000 would get seats anywhere and of which a much smaller proportion would be affordable seats. The majority of those who ‘fail’ NEET would face frustration and guilt- all the more so because to get so far, they have had excellent academic careers and though by temperament, attitude, experiences and skills — and even knowledge they may be much better than those who made it. There are other unfortunate collaterals of this NEET defined hierarchy of merit. One, for example is that students who qualify with lower thresholds due to reservation quotas face discrimination which could get justified on this basis, though their work performance may be no less than the others. The recent tragic suicide of Dr Payal Thadvi was an example of this. The rich student in the management quota is however unlikely to face such a disadvantage.</p><p>This hierarchy of merit takes other forms. There is for example the proposal to phase out all diploma education in nursing, and make B.Sc the only nursing entry. Persons working in field situations would testify that not only is it impossible to close gaps in nursing cadre with only B.Sc nurses, there are many field situations where diploma nursing students are better suited. Similarly, a community health worker or a mid-level care provider is not an apology for not having a doctor. Rather they are the most appropriate care providers in that given context.</p><p>One curious inconsistency in the draft is a proposal for periodic renewal of licenses for nurses through some testing procedures- while there is no such clause for any other category of service providers- specialists, doctors, or other allied healthcare professionals who may need such on the periodic skill upgradation and re-certification even more.</p><p>On the challenge of creating healthcare professionals with empathy- scientifically competent, but also ethical, humane, caring, communicative, sensitive to concerns of equity, and social accountability, the section on healthcare policy is a non-starter. Which is surprising considering the almost poetic eloquence with which the importance of liberal education is set out in the introductory chapters of the higher education section. The introductory chapters posit liberal broad-based multidisciplinary education as essential for developing “critical 21st century capacities” and defines this as including not only exposure to humanities and social sciences but also an ethic of social engagement… (11.3.1. pg. 234–5). It calls for professional education to be “cognizant of larger social concerns, and develop a mindset of public service and cultural awareness” and promises that professional and technical education will not remain narrowly-focussed on technical expertise alone (see chapter 9, pg. 202). On specific strategy to achieve this that is proposed is that “the practice of setting up stand-alone universities for professional education will be discontinued,” as “the practice of setting up separate technical universities, health sciences universities, legal and agriculture universities in each State to affiliate colleges offering professional education in their respective disciplines, has resulted in deepening the isolation further”. “All institutions offering either professional or general education must organically evolve into institutions offering both seamlessly by 2030. (pg. 301)”. It particularly condemns how in healthcare; education is offered largely in silos of individual subjects and separate from general higher education. Although the effort in professional education has been focused mainly on making students ready for ‘jobs’, the outcomes, in terms of employability, leave a lot to be desired. (pg. 293. Chapter 16).</p><p>None of these laudable values seem to inform or animate the authors of the healthcare education section. There is nowhere in the text of this section, any attention given to how we produce healthcare professionals who care, who feel for the individual and society. And whatever space emerges for such character building locally or spontaneously, would be swallowed up by the waves of MCQ based national examinations that the student would have to face. The proposals in this section are all examples of what is declared as wrong with professional education in the earlier section. NEP paragraph on allied healthcare providers states that a “syllabus will be standardised pan-India, drawn up in conjunction with Health Universities and State Allied Health Sciences Boards, … These training programmes will be hospital-based, at those hospitals that have adequate facilities, including state-of-the-art simulation facilities, and adequate student-patient ratio.” In this policy statement, the health university is retained, and the vision of the educational institution has given way to a description of a corporate hospital. Further some of the jobs mentioned as priorities are very narrowly based on current corporate healthcare industry requirements (e.g. general duty assistant), and more broad-based skills like pharmacists and counsellors find no mention. Almost none of the essential public health skill merits mention.</p><p>As a concession to the imperative of regional equity in the creation of new health education institutions, the policy puts forth a proposal “to upgrade the nation’s 600 district hospitals to become teaching hospitals, “to train doctors, nurses and allied healthcare professionals.” But are district hospitals so easy to transform into educational institutions? Whatever happened to all those brave words about liberal education and the multi-disciplinary university? It is one thing to ask for district hospitals to be upgraded to tertiary care hospitals and linked to university based medical colleges. Quite another to talk of upgrading district hospitals into teaching hospitals “by investing in infrastructure” and “stationing adequately qualified teaching faculty”. A proposal to identify districts with major HR shortages and link these with medical colleges and healthcare institutions which are part of public universities providing subsidized or free education with affirmative policies to bring in more candidates who relate to local communities would have been welcome. What is stated now (<em>all</em> district hospitals are to be so upgraded), read in conjunction with repeated announcements and efforts to outsource district hospitals to corporate agencies, gives rise to fears that even this proposal, may be a justification for providing private medical colleges an access to the clinical exposure that the public hospitals provide.</p><p>The answers to any of the three challenges that a healthcare education policy faces, are not easy- but they are available, and across the world many nations have learnt to address them. Even for the most difficult challenge of the three- providing healthcare professionals with empathy and ethics, there are many innovative efforts to learn from. Even within the nation there are many good examples that the authors could have learnt from. Institutions like CMC Vellore have for over a century been identifying and training students from very remote and under-privileged communities and returning them successfully as sensitized caring individuals to serve these communities for a number of years, while maintaining standards of excellence far above the average. Far from learning from them, NEET has so comprehensively undermined these policies that CMC Vellore has had to petition the Supreme Court to try and safeguard their mission- as yet unsuccessfully. If select universities and regions did have the powers and flexibility and there was a suitable policy framework, which ensured that such flexibility was only exercised in favour of healthcare needs of the population and not for private profits, much could be improved.</p><p>But as it stands the policy has not seriously engaged with these questions. It is contradictory to its own stated objectives of a liberal education, fails to address concerns of equity in access to healthcare or access to healthcare education and paves the way for an unhealthy commercialization of education in this domain. There is a need for a re-think with more broad-based consultations, taking care to exclude conflicts of interests in the process of decision-making.</p><p>(Note: Both of the above articles have been published elsewhere. The latter on medical education policy is published in Frontline. This is with few edits to make it more relevant for this audience).</p><p><strong>Tasks before Peoples Movements (these need to be deliberated upon and evolved in a national meet):</strong></p><p>1. That there is a substantial increase in public financing of healthcare education, and complete abolition of capitation fees and management quotas.</p><p>2. That 100 % of seats are under price control- and in the event that this is unviable for private sector to manage these institutions, these should be taken over by the government.</p><p>3. That at least 50% of seats are free or nominally charged- so that all sections of society can access such education, and no student is denied access to education because of inability to pay for it.</p><p>4. That further seats in healthcare education be prioritized for districts with inadequate human resources- with matching policies to ensure local candidates and candidates willing to serve in these areas get preferential access to this education.</p><p>5. To demand that functions of regulation of quality in healthcare education be a state subject. The national accreditation and rating process would be voluntary and independent of permission and licensing. The National board can review the functioning of the state boards for quality in healthcare education, and where there are defects give directions to improve their functioning- but the actual assessment and action would be the responsibility of the state board. (if state board remains deficient, there has to legal remedies that the national board can resort to ??)</p><p>6. That quality of care in healthcare education be the function of state boards which have representation from healthcare professionals, educationists, health rights groups and administrators- and that these boards function in a transparent manner. The quality indicators of each institution need to be publicly displayed and based on processes established.</p><p>7. The selection processes should be fair and transparent- and may therefore opt for a common examination. The entrance examinations are best state specific with a central examination for only 15 to 30% of the seats. States could consider selections based on school board results converting school leaving scores into percentiles. Different forms of affirmative action to ensure under-serviced areas get the human resources they need should be encouraged.</p><p>8. The exit from healthcare educational institution should be by an examination conducted by the state university, and licensing should also depend on it. These examinations should be reviewed for quality, and these details be known publicly</p><p>9. Recruitment for government jobs- central and state- could use a common examination, and other employers could also use the scores on this examination for recruitment also.</p><p>10. The content of the healthcare education should include a strong foundation on ethics, gender sensitivity, constitutional obligations and equity- and should aim to build graduates who have compassion. This is not just a stated intention but should have clear processes and measures.</p><p>11. The content of healthcare education should also be appropriate to what is required of that category of professional in a given context. Setting of educational standards should reflect this. This may require the creation of new professional entities and courses.</p><p>12. There is a need for much better and much more extensive faculty development programs at all levels and for all healthcare education.</p><p>13. There has to be a rapid increase in the number of human resources employed by public health services, across the districts and states. This is essential to absorb the graduates from the healthcare education and to address problems of inequity in access to healthcare. Expecting graduates to find their own way in private markets for healthcare will merely lead to overcrowding and unhealthy competition in areas already having excess- while leaving large parts of India without essential healthcare services.</p><p>14. For regulation in professional ethics, state boards must be constituted for each profession, in each state. These boards should have leadership from within the profession, but there must be significant and empowered representation of other sections of society, so that it is not limited by professional solidarity, and can reflect larger societal objectives and concerns, while remaining fair and transparent. The national board can review the adequacy of the state boards and make directions to improve its functioning, but the actual implementation would be by the state board.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a85ed6962a4f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/from-prof-sundararamans-desk/part-iii-a85ed6962a4f">Part –III.</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/from-prof-sundararamans-desk">From Dr. Sundararaman’s Desk</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unpacking Ayushman Bharat and other Recent Health Policy initiatives: Part II]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/from-prof-sundararamans-desk/unpacking-ayushman-bharat-and-other-recent-health-policy-initiatives-part-ii-545b93f17f32?source=rss-cfe3781b0191------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/545b93f17f32</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indian-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sundararaman T]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Sep 2019 16:19:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-15T17:22:25.875Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Ayushman Bharat: Health and Wellness Centers</strong></p><p>The design, the many variants and the key barriers, and what peoples’ movements should do about it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/648/1*InXwBmoej3Ysd06cj-80vQ.jpeg" /></figure><ol><li><strong>What are Health and Wellness Centers?</strong></li></ol><p>This component of Ayushman Bharat promises to upgrade health sub-centers and primary health centers into what is called health and wellness centers. The target is 1.5 lakh HWCs, which is roughly equivalent to the total number of sub-centers in existence (1.46 lakhs). Each sub-center caters to about 5000 population. In tribal and hilly and desert areas it could cater to 3000 population or even less. This target of 1.5 lakh HWCs would, according to the government, be achieved by 2022.</p><p>Health and Wellness Centers differs from both the existing sub-centers and urban dispensary services and even the primary health centers in four important ways:</p><p>a. The primary healthcare services available to households in that area are comprehensive- NOT selective.</p><p>b. All the services are organized in a manner that ensures continuity of care. There are two types of continuity- if a patient with chronic illness comes in periodically, the center is equipped to provide follow up and medication so that the treatment can be continued without a break 365 days of the year. And secondly –vertical continuity between the primary healthcare provider and the consultant/specialist/doctor at the higher levels. For most illnesses, the doctor or specialist will see the patient and confirm the diagnosis and make a treatment plan- and then the treatment is continued by the service providers in the HWC.</p><p>c. The services at a HWC are delivered by a team- ideally of at least one Mid Level Healthcare provider or doctor plus two female multi-purpose workers and one male multipurpose worker plus about 5 ASHAs (community health workers).</p><p>d. The services are population based- not limited to individuals. The doctor in a urban dispensary, like a Mohalla clinic, or the usual general practitioner in private practice feels responsible for those who sought their care. But a HWC is responsible for the health of the entire list of households/individuals assigned to them, those who are usually resident in their area. Thus, children or adults who are at risk, and the population who need preventive services like screening for common cancers even if they appear well.</p><p><strong>2. Why is this such a big thing. Was this not what primary health centres were always mandated to do?</strong></p><p>A. If we are referring to the Alma Ata declaration, the answer is yes. This was exactly what primary healthcare was meant to be. However if we are referring to currently existing primary healthcare facilities and even the healthcare policy since 1993- the answer is a big NO. Sub-centers and PHCs fulfil the criteria of continuity of care and being population based for only a very selective package of services- typically immunization, and care in pregnancy, contraceptive services and care in tuberculosis, HIV, malaria and leprosy. To some extent for cataract blindness also. This accounts for only about 10 to 15 % of all primary healthcare needs. For the remaining 85% of health care needs there are NO services at the primary level- or at best very sporadic, one-time consultations with no arrangements to ensure continuity or compliance or control. Under the re-branding of this concept as HWCs, there is a potential to bring back the full notion of primary healthcare. Even within the understanding of achieving universal health coverage, the HWCs would be the main strategy.</p><p>B. Even the current list of services under the HWC is not comprehensive enough. But it makes for a big start. The 12 services listed for delivery by HWCs are as follows:</p><p>i. Care in pregnancy and child-birth<br>ii. Neonatal and infant health care services<br>iii. Childhood and adolescent health care services<br>iv. Family planning, Contraceptive services and other Reproductive Health Care services<br>v. Management of Communicable diseases including National Health Programmes<br>vi. Management of Common Communicable Diseases and Outpatient care for acute simple illnesses and minor ailments.<br>vii. Screening, Prevention, Control and Management of Non-Communicable diseases<br>viii. Care for Common Ophthalmic and ENT problems<br>ix. Screening and Basic management of Mental health ailments<br>x. Basic Oral health care<br>xi. Elderly and Palliative health care services<br>xii. Emergency Medical Services</p><p>The first five of these are already on the existing health sub-centers and Primary Health Centre mandate. The Health and Wellness Centre adds the other 7 services also.</p><p>Since most Primary Health Centres (PHCs) are also not providing these services, by including these in the list the government is making the point that these too should be capable of providing this list of services. The PHC would not need additional human resources if it has the level mandated by Indian Public Health Standards (IPHS), but it would need to organize its service delivery better.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/284/1*DLZY2izcNyV5Rual0jeWgA.png" /></figure><p><strong>3. Primary Health Care is about preventive and promotive services. But this above list of HWC services seems dominated by curative care.</strong></p><p>a. The emphasis must remain on prevention and promotion. Inter-sectoral action on environmental and social determinants will be limited to what can be done at the level of the village through village health, sanitation and nutrition committees (VHSNCs) and with respective departments taking a lead role in their areas of accountability. Public health tasks such as vector control continue without losing emphasis. This has never been questioned nor have they been in doubt.</p><p>b. But what is added on now is “secondary prevention”. The early detection of diseases like hypertension and diabetes through screening programmes and appropriate treatment is what saves lives in a large number of non-communicable diseases. Even in chronic communicable diseases like TB, HIV, leprosy, etc, early detection and appropriate treatment has a major preventive role. So, it is quite misleading to think of preventive and curative as being in two separate silos in a public health care system.</p><p>c. Establishing such secondary prevention as part of primary health care would also give urgency to primary prevention in terms of reduction in exposure to risk factors. This would include change in diet, increased exercise, better life styles, reduced use of tobacco and alcohol and such factors. Currently very little happens in many elements of such promotive care.</p><p>d. This is not to diminish the importance of how economic policies and development policies act as determinants of ill health. But building awareness for policy changes in development policies at the state and national levels must be accompanied by and would be reinforced by local action to ensure the above elements of care as individual entitlements.</p><p><strong>4. The government claims that they now have about 7500 to 10,000 HWCs that are functional. Are the HWCs on the ground similar to what is promised? Or like the way the Alma Ata declaration of primary healthcare was reduced to selective healthcare, are there major deviations from the conceptual framework when it comes to implementation? The World Bank and other international aid agencies and global health institutions played a key role in reducing the Alma Ata declaration to selective primary health care. What are they up to now?</strong></p><p><strong>Response:</strong> It is important to note that the conceptual framework on which HWCs is based is part of a progressive framework on comprehensive primary health care that has evolved over many decades and which peoples’ movements have contributed greatly to shaping. Therefore, there is great urgency for peoples’ movements to be alert to deviations that trivialize or divert from the main objectives and call out/expose such deviations. Otherwise a government that is reluctant to implement the HWC concept in full will make use of the discontent with HWCs as implemented to scuttle the whole concept itself.</p><p>Some of the main deviations and distortions in the implementation of HWCs are listed below:</p><p><strong>A)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to what services are provided in the HWC:</strong></p><p>i. Instead of comprehensive primary healthcare, just one or two NCDs- usually hypertension and diabetes are added into the selective package. There is no effort to move to other services at all. In some states, even for hypertension and diabetes only screening and an unstructured referral up is done. There is no feedback from the referred doctor/specialist and no effort to ensure access to medication and follow up tests throughout the year at the HWC. In some states, it is even more cynical and HWCs have become only a branding exercise. A new coat of paint is given, the name of the center is changed- but no expansion of services occurs.</p><p>ii. In some states the focus is yoga. The scheme does see yoga as an important element of promotive health- and as one element among many there is case for it. But it certainly should not be the central or main agenda, displacing the other core services that HWCs are meant for. Any efforts to expand infrastructure in terms of yoga halls etc would be a distortion of priorities. There are many local administrators or officers who may take this path- since there is much less work involved, and it can distract from the main purpose, and since there is money that can be made in infrastructure.</p><p>iii. Improving infrastructure is one important element- but it is not and should not become the central component. There are examples where the entire emphasis is on beautification- painting the walls, putting ceramic tile flooring, re-building rooms and toilets etc. Part of this happens because this is what local administrators have understood the program to be. A more negative view would be that this happens because there is more opportunity to spend and to make money in infrastructure activity. The real danger is that equating upgradation to HWCs with improved infrastructure, would lead to a betrayal of expectations. Worse, when after all this expenditure, utilization does not go up, it would become another argument to favor privatization. The reasons for poor utilization lie in the lack of appropriate services — not in the lack of ceramic flooring.</p><p>iv. In some states the attention is given to starting up a general out-patient clinic and providing medicines and even some diagnostics in it. This helps, and like in the Mohalla clinic, can even be welcomed. But without the continuity of care for chronic illness, without the population-based coverage, without the referral platforms, it will not make much of a difference. The initial welcome will soon go away because people will have to go in search of better care for their healthcare needs than what such a clinic can prepare.</p><p>v. In most states, the feeling is that we should proceed gradually to add services to the package. But gradually based on what? Now the entire healthcare system waits for central directives before any service is added on. However, there is no reason to deny any service from these 12 service areas if there is a suitable specialist who is available to confirm diagnosis, make a treatment plan and communicate it to the the staff at the HWC, and then also be available if there is any complication</p><p><strong>B)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to Human Resources:</strong></p><p>i. The most common distortion is to equate the HWC with appointing a mid level health care provider. The rest of the team is not even thought about or planned for. There is neither a clear work distribution, nor the requisite training. The mid level healthcare provider alone cannot make a difference.</p><p>ii. The other common distortion is to understand the mid level healthcare provider as a substitute doctor- because doctors do not go to rural areas. In most or all chronic illnesses the doctor or specialist is not substituted by the MLHP. Once the diagnosis is confirmed and treatment plan made by the doctor, the MLHP would, with the help of the team, ensure follow up Related to this distortion, is the failure to design training programmes that enable MLHPs and the rest of the team to play this role.</p><p>iii. Another problem is the debate about whether the MLHP should be a B.Sc nurse or a GNM nurse, or an ANM or an AYUSH provider, or a three year new graduate. Can dentists and physiotherapists be allowed to become MLHPs? This debate diverts us from the main features of a MLHP- which should be a) he/she should be of that locality/block/district and happy to be working there b) he/she should be trained close to their place of work and preferably in state language using standard treatment protocols — and this training should be a periodic life long process c) that he/she should be conditionally licensed only to work in primary health care within government institutions- and not to become private providers- which means that even at the time of recruitment into the training, their employment position should be assured and d) one would need them as part of a permanent workforce- and not on an ad hoc contractual basis. E) they should always be working under the supervision of doctor/doctors in the public health system. It does not really matter which allied health professional or nursing qualification they have to begin with. If these five conditions are fulfilled, they would play their role- and if these are not, whatever their qualification they would not be able to work.</p><p><strong>C)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to continuity of care:</strong></p><p>i. The most common distortion is a complete failure to plan for the link with the doctor/specialist who shall receive the referral confirm diagnosis, make the treatment plan and rule out or manage complications, and communicate to the providers in the HWC- all according to a standard treatment protocol.</p><p>ii. The other common distortion is to assume that the providers empanelled with PMJAY will take care of this referral function. Not only does the PM-JAY not provide for such consultation, the incentive environment for the PM_JAY hospital is not to promote preventive care and avoid or delay the need for procedures. Rather, their interest is in increasing the number of secondary and tertiary care opportunities they have.</p><p>iii. A third distortion is to grossly underestimate the quantity of medicines required to provide continuity of medication and diagnostic support to patients with chronic illness. Thus, even if all persons with hypertension in a community were taking only one tablet per day, a population of 5000 with about 10% of those about 30 years having hypertension would need close to a lakh anti-hypertensive tablet. There is little effort in understanding and organizing the logistics for such increase in access to medication. The same goes for diagnostics. If the government is serious about HWCs as the route to UHC and of the promise to free drugs and diagnostics, it can certainly manage this.</p><p><strong>D)</strong> <strong>Distortions related to Population Based Care</strong></p><p>i. Most HWCs still limit population-based care to immunization, pregnancy, tuberculosis. There is no commitment to seek out those who have not been screened, or those defaulting on taking medicines, or those not taking care for complications etc. But ASHAs should make household visits that ensure this. And there has to be a system of documenting the health needs of different families and individuals and being able to follow it up. For example, a HWC team would know what proportion of population at risk have been screened for hypertension or diabetes, what proportion were confirmed to have that disease and how many of these are registered with the HWC for regular care, and finally in what proportion of them was hypertension controlled.</p><p>ii. There is no allocation of households to each HWC. This problem is most ….in urban areas. In rural areas there is at least an implict understanding. That would further mean that every household and individual would have a health card that indicates which is the HWC that is closest to their residence and to which they are attached. That card would also help support access for their health needs if they have any health risk or chronic illness.</p><p>iii. All of this would be greatly helped if the right ICT tools are available- but ICT tools and smart cards are not a substitute for the team building and coordination that is required. One distortion of HWCs is to equate it with introduction of ICT and smart cards. Often ICT tools add an additional layer of work for the overburdened providers without enabling local planning or decision making. Good ICT design should decrease the burden of data collections and reporting of the HWC providers. It will take quite a while to use UHC app (ICT tool) appropriately- and HWCs need not wait till then to expand the services they provide.</p><p>iv. The defnition of population should include all households and individuals usually resident in that area. Even three months residence in a year should be counted. No exclusions based on ID documentation should be permissible- since healthcare is an inalienable human right. Special care must be taken to ensure that migrants and seasonal workers are included. And if they are from another place in Indiathe continuity of care should be assured. If a person not usually resident in that area seeks care, that care should be provided. The only difference is that there is no assurance of follow up at household level to ensure compliance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/977/1*HN2Cfc5sp4LLB9-YdGypQA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>5. What should be the popular demands that peoples’ health movements should make at the level of the village/urban poor?</strong></p><p>There is a need for popular campaigns to demand the following as an entitlement:</p><p>a. Any person with a chronic illness who needs to take medicines every day, or very often for the rest of their lives would be able to get their medicines in the sub-centre (HWC), free of costs. This is a long list. It includes medicines for hypertension, diabetes, angina, mental illnesses, epilepsy, asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, arthritis- just to name some of the most important ones.</p><p>b. If any person is detected with any of these illnesses when he or she comes for a visit for any other illness or a health check- up, they would be entitled to a reference for confirmation at the higher level (facilitated by the HWC) and they would have a treatment plan made by the specialist- with some elements of routine follow up being provided at the HWC.</p><p>c. Every person over 30 years would be actively screened at the HWC once a year for diabetes, hypertension and once in three to five years for chronic illnesses like cancer cervix, breast and oral cancers. If they are suspected of having the disease, they would be referred to a higher center and have the diagnosis confirmed and a treatment plan made. Similarly, all newborns have to be screened at the place of their birth. All pregnant women are already being screened.</p><p>d. There should be an out patient service on all 5 days of the week in the HWC- so that a much wider range of acute simple illness can be treated. This would include fever, acute respiratory infections, common infectious diseases etc.</p><p><strong>6. What should be the demand of peoples’ movements at the level of policy, advocacy and agitation? What should peoples’ movements be alert about with respect to pressures from international donors and corporate India?</strong></p><p>a. There is a great danger that the HWC can turn out to be another jhumla. The real push is on PM-JAY, while the HWC is only for show- to give the appearance of a evidence based progress towards UHC for public consumption and for international agencies like the UN. There are two key indicators of whether it is jhumla or a real action on the ground. The first indicator is the financial resources allocated to it. The second is the human resources policy.</p><p>i. Financing: By the governments own estimates it requires about 9 lakhs recurrent and 8 lakhs non recurrent expenditure- additional to what is currently spent on sub-centers and PHCs. This is a serious under-estimate — but even if we use this figure the allocation would be 13,500 crores per year or 65,700 crores recurrent plus 12,000 crores non-recurrent or about 77,000 crores over 5 years. The actual amount needed, if full HR and medicines and referral costs are included is likely to be at least twice that. But that would be about 1 % of GDP- a reasonable estimate. In the current year the allocation was only 1600 crores. In the previous year, the allocation was notional.</p><p>ii. Matching Human Resources Policies: The HR policy needs to provide resources for hiring the entire team, plus the ASHAs on a regular basis. And also we need to create HR policies which enable us to overcome the very skewed availability of human resources. Very often the government starts by stating that other than increasing HR, one can consider all options. Which means negating the whole program.</p><p>b. There is a need to identify distortions of the concept and build public and even provider understanding of what comprehensive primary health care means. Equating these distortions with HWCs would lead to loss of credibility regarding the whole idea of primary health care — and HWCs would be quietly shelved or reduced to some token level- while all the media attention etc. is focussed on the insurance scheme. An alert peoples movements and a democratic polity has a choice in how it goes about its protest ; It can demand that HWCs ought to be developed without these distortions, as the route to comprehensive primary health care and expose efforts that deviate, distort or trivialize the scheme. OR it could be dismissive of HWCs and thus add to the energies that for a variety of often varied reasons, call for ignoring if not scrapping the scheme. The PM-JAY is in no danger of being ignored- and there would be an active lobby of healthcare industry very ready to support and shape it. Every single media channel, newspaper and periodical, especially those specializing in health care, would be watching it roll out. (PMJAY covers journalists also). Comprehensive primary health care, on the other hand, does not attract such attention or support. It has no support except sections of the health policy community and peoples’ health movements. What peoples’ health movements do would therefore be critical.</p><p>c. The other big danger is the push to outsource clusters of HWCs to the private sector- and within that to the corporate sector. The BMGF (Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation) has a number of pilots and initiatives to do just this. BMGF currently leads this effort. USAID too actively supports these initiatives. Swasthya Piramal, Tata Trusts, Apollo Hospitals/enterprises are major corporate players who are interested in developing such models. The World Bank is more focussed on PMJAY. Niti Aayog has been pushing for private sector participation in HWCs — and has included a commitment to outsource at least a proportion of HWCs as part of the mandate of Aysuhman Bharat. There are also efforts to push part or all of HWCs into the National Health Authority and/or fuse it with the PMJAY platform in the name of integration. In all of these models the aim is to create a network of private providers linked to a corporate entity, which the government would contract in. The corporate agency will then engage the private providers either as a sub-contract or as employees. Till date, this approach has not succeeded. This lack of success is partly due to good sense prevailing in the ministry about their own ability to ensure that private sector abides by the contract, and partly because private players are not very keen. Part of the lack of progress in outsourcing despite political pressures to do so is because of the technical complexities of contracting a corporate consortium to provide primary healthcare. But a number of international agencies and Indian pro-industry academicians and consultancy organizations are trying to address the technicalities of contracting and promoting innovations in organizing services. This has given time and space for the public sector/healh ministry to come up with viable and visible government run HWCs.Would corporate India run better primary healthcare than what government would? Given the prevailing culture and perceptions fostered by neo-liberalism and the rise of right wing populism, many would support such a perception. But if experience and evidence is any guide, then what is far more likely is that it would, like in PMJAY, only lead to profits for private health sector, a weakening of public services and no major contribution to health.</p><p><strong>7. Is this idea of HWCs a new idea? Has it been tried anywhere?</strong></p><p>The name is new. But this is the basic concept of primary health care, before selective health care came along. Many nations in the world have organized care along these lines and are doing it for very long and very successfully. In the developed world, UK’s National Health Services is a model of such care- and it has been there for over 70 years. Most other developed nations also have similar arrangements for primary health care. In the developing world Cuba, Thailand and Brazil have very similar programmes. Thailand in particular is very similar to what is proposed in India. Over 95% of primary health care providers in all these nations are within the public sector- just like in India.</p><p>In fact, this is what was always meant by primary health care. Such organization of services is what peoples’ health movements have been demanding since its inception.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=545b93f17f32" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/from-prof-sundararamans-desk/unpacking-ayushman-bharat-and-other-recent-health-policy-initiatives-part-ii-545b93f17f32">Unpacking Ayushman Bharat and other Recent Health Policy initiatives: Part II</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/from-prof-sundararamans-desk">From Dr. Sundararaman’s Desk</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unpacking Ayushman Bharat and other Recent Health Policy initiatives Part I]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/from-prof-sundararamans-desk/unpacking-ayushman-bharat-and-other-recent-health-policy-initiatives-part-i-309f9a9bec09?source=rss-cfe3781b0191------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/309f9a9bec09</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[health-insurance-india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[modicare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health-policy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Sundararaman T]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Sep 2019 15:24:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-15T17:21:45.859Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Unpacking Ayushman Bharat and other Health Policy initiatives of the last one year </strong>(2018 -19): Part 1</h4><h4>The task before peoples’ health movements</h4><p>I. Ayushman Bharat: PMJAY (Modicare)<br>II. Ayushman Bharat: Health and Wellness Centres<br>III. The Making of the Health Professional: Changing Policies in Healthcare Education and Professional Regulation <br>IV. Privatization, Public Private Partnerships and Growth of Healthcare Industry: The Niti Aayog at work. <br>V. Developments in Access to medicines, patents and innovation<br>VI. Gender Issues in Health and Healthcare. <br>VII. The Social Determinants of Health.</p><p><strong>I. AYUSHMAN BHARAT:</strong></p><p>This is the main health program initiated under the NDA Government. It was launched in 2018. This program has two components; the Health and Wellness Centres &amp; the Prime Ministers Jan Arogya Yojana. The former is an approach to comprehensive primary health care and the latter is a publicly funded health insurance scheme to provide access and financial protection to BPL families requiring secondary and tertiary health care. We describe each of these schemes below, and the problems we have with the way these are designed and implemented, as also the way Peoples Health Movements, Peoples Science Movements and all democratic forces should respond to these policies and their implementation.</p><h3><strong>Prime Ministers Jan Arogya Yojana: (Modicare)</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WB3HnJPndxTS_lJiUgBskQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>1. </em><strong>What is this scheme? A description</strong></p><p>This is a Government Funded Health Insurance Program. Those who are poor by the socio-economic caste census or identified as belonging to certain occupational categories are eligible for this scheme. An estimated 10.74 crore families (about 50 crore individuals) are estimated to be eligible.</p><p>Under this scheme, if any eligible individual needs what is called a secondary care or tertiary care treatment/procedure, they can go to any empanelled hospital. The hospital will admit them and provide them free care- no charges at all. All medicines, diagnostics and even some element of the transport are to be paid by the hospital without charging the patient. The government would then reimburse the hospital on the agreed upon rate. A family can utilize up to Rs 5 lakh rupees of such treatment in a year (called a family floater basis- since anyone defined and enrolled as part of the family can be paid for within this Rs 5 lakhs. All pre-existing illnesses are also covered, and some part of pre-hospitalization and post hospitalization expenses are also covered.</p><p>PM-JAY has defined 1,350 medical packages covering surgery, medical and day care treatments.</p><p>Both government hospitals and private hospitals are empanelled under this scheme. About 60 % of the number of claims and about 75% of the total value of claims is made by and paid to the private sector hospitals.</p><p>It will offer a benefit cover of Rs. 500,000 per family per year (on a family floater basis).</p><p><strong>2. There is a wide welcome for this scheme in media, among providers and even in public? Why has this been so welcomed?</strong></p><p><strong>i. </strong>Free or subsidized care in the public hospitals was the main approach to ensuring that everyone received affordable and good quality healthcare. However, the capacity of the public health services to deliver services is very limited, and a majority of people are either forced to , or are choosing to seek care in the private sector. The high costs of such private healthcare leads to high levels of financial hardship and to impoverishment that affects the whole family. Insurance schemes are meant to protect against this. Hence there is a considerable welcome from the public</p><p><strong>ii.</strong> Private Hospitals have considerable un-used capacity. There is no shortage of number of sick patients, but there is a shortage of those who can pay. Also, typically, much of the profits of the modern hospital comes from deployment of high-end technologies used in diagnostics, procedures and surgeries. The number of paying patients who need or can be persuaded to consume these procedures are limited. Publicly funded insurance is thus a boost to what is nowadays referred to as India’s private healthcare industry.</p><p><strong>iii.</strong> Much of the media welcome and the welcome in civil society and academic circles is because shifting to private providers is seen as a desirable reform, in tune with the times. Private providers are perceived as better in quality and public providers as inherently of poor quality. This is not so much a perception of the poorer and weaker population, but it is very much the perception of the middle class. The differing perceptions are in part due to the considerable heterogeneity in the type of private sector encountered, and the influence of the pro-private, anti-public sector discourse in these sections.</p><p><strong>3. Government has claimed considerable success in this scheme and it is considered as one of the big achievements of the Modi government. What is the truth and what is just hype?</strong></p><p><strong>i.</strong> Government claims “Modicare” is the largest health scheme in the world. This is far from true. In terms of budgetary outlay, it is one of the smaller schemes- less than even the National Health Mission- and certainly less than what most states are spending on health. In terms of insurance coverage also, it provides cover to much less diseases than most other comparable scheme in other nations. In terms of the population covered by an insurance scheme, it would be less than what China covers.</p><p><strong>ii.</strong> The number of those actually enrolled is only 3 crores- though 12 crores are eligible for a smart card.</p><p><strong>iii.</strong> In almost all the states where PMJAY is seen to be effective, the central government has merely added its name to a pre-existing state government run health insurance program. The central government in return is also committed to paying 60% of the costs- though for a number of reasons this has not fully happened. The state governments are also being persuaded to change some of the rules they have evolved, and many states which had reasonably effective schemes in place- like Kerala, are suffering as a consequence.</p><p><strong>iv.</strong> The government’s claim to success is largely based on the number of claims they have received and paid, across the states. There is no evidence at all on whether health outcomes have improved or even whether the poor have been protected from financial hardships due to healthcare costs. A considerable number of studies have been conducted on the earlier government funded health insurance programs and they all have shown the following patterns:</p><p><strong>a. Lack of Information:</strong> Most of those eligible do not know about the scheme, and therefore are unable to claim its benefits.</p><p><strong>b. Denial of Care:</strong> Of those who are eligible and who know about the scheme, a large proportion are denied benefits on one or other technical grounds. The most common being to state that the scheme does not cover the illness or procedure that the patient has, or that the hospital does not offer that particular service.</p><p><strong>c. Double Billing</strong>- Of those who successfully manage to seek care under the scheme, almost all are billed for some or all of the services, for which they have to pay out of pocket. Free, cashless services are almost a myth. At best they may have to pay about 20% less than those who do not have a card. Having charged the patient, the hospital goes on to get reimbursed from the government also.</p><p><strong>d. Supply driven care</strong>: Quite often the private hospital tends to provide much more of those procedures, for which they have greater profits, and deny those where the profit margins are less. Sometimes they actively recruit those patients who qualify for the procedures that they wish to supply. Thus, if we examine the pattern of claims across districts, there is little correlation with epidemiology- but a lot with which private providers are enrolled and pushy.</p><p><strong>e. Substituting, not supplementing, public services:</strong> The aim of bringing in private sector was to provide access to many procedures which are not currently available within the government hospital. However, if we examine the claims of each state, they tend to provide services in those same few areas where government already provides care. For example, in UP, Bihar, and Chhattisgarh, it would cater to normal deliveries and cataract surgeries, which are the few procedures that government provides. But when it comes to renal stones, or glaucoma, or acute abdomen or burns, there would be little contribution from the insurance scheme.</p><p><strong>f. Inappropriate care and dumping:</strong> Earlier if a private hospital could not provide the care to a poor patient, it would refer the patient away. Now, the same hospital is likely to admit the patient, exhaust all the money that the patient has in the smart card, and then refer the patient away. The treatment gets delayed and is exhausted of all resources when he or she reaches the government public hospital. Dumping patients who have exhausted their insurance coverage into public hospitals is a common practice even in the USA.</p><p>4. <strong>Is not government aware of these problems? What is being done to address these? And why is it not doing more? If government seriously addresses these issues, can we then expect the insurance program to provide relief?</strong></p><p><strong>·</strong> Government is aware of these problems. The government has both a grievance redressal system and monitoring mechanisms. The grievance redressal system is under-used by beneficiaries who are not aware of their entitlements as also how to seek redress for it. Even those who seek redressal have a poor experience. The big problem is that it takes great effort to bring a grievance to notice, and then what the private hospital gets is a very token penalty. Similarly, monitoring mechanisms are weakly functional, but even to the extent they are functional, authorities are unable or unwilling to take action against errant hospitals. Underneath there is a tacit understanding that such cheating is alright, since otherwise the private sector hospitals will refuse to participate. The current rates for each procedure that government is paying to hospitals are said to be low- but that is not the case. That is merely a convenient excuse for double billing- an excuse that those monitoring the scheme accept too readily even if it is in violation of the contract and the law. Delays in payment also push out ethical small providers who cannot manage the delays and uncertainties in reimbursement.</p><p>· Were the government to be serious about preventing all of the above distortions, and plan for adequate monitoring and grievance redressal, the immediate result would be that the private hospital participation would drop. Even now private hospitals are unwilling to come in at these rates. This in itself is not a bad thing, because public hospitals would continue, and so would not- for- profit hospitals and ethical small providers who are able to manage within these rates quite well.</p><p><strong>·</strong> However, in such a scenario, insurance and purchase from the private sector would be a supplement to a robust public sector- which because of ideological reasons the current policy makers are unwilling to accept.</p><p><strong>·</strong> While better monitoring would address issues like double-billing and denial, none of these solutions, and not even tighter regulation would affect the problem of supply driven care- when decisions on what care is to be provided is influenced by the monetary/business model driven interests of the provider more than that of the beneficiaries.</p><p><strong>5. There are many nations where insurance schemes are working well. How are these nations doing better? What prevents our government from adopting those strategies?</strong></p><p><strong>·</strong> Germany and Japan are examples of such nations, where providers are mainly private and payment is by insurance mechanisms. This is so in Canada and Australia also, though the proportion of public providers is much higher.</p><p><strong>·</strong> The single most important feature of these is that these are built around the principle of solidarity. Great care is taken to ensure that the decision making by providers is ring-fenced from immediate monetary incentives. The Japanese, for example, have a law against making profits from health care and for that reason little foreign direct investment/corporate funding comes in- since dividends cannot be paid. Germany rules out profits for insurance companies, and the government steps in to pay part of the premium to prevent losses and ensure equity.</p><p><strong>·</strong> All these nations which are insurance based have high degrees of regulation, where the prices of all healthcare services, even for those who are not insured, are regulated at the same prices as what the government allows. In Australia and Canada all payments are from the government. Along with taxes they collect different premiums from rich and poor, but the treatment for rich and poor, whether insured or not is the same. Families may purchase a second private insurance for higher quality of hospital care- but that is as much choice as is allowed.</p><p><strong>·</strong> Health systems which are insurance based a sentence is incomplete.</p><p><strong>·</strong> Thailand and UK are not insurance schemes in the conventional sense. They are much better and more flexible forms of public financing and public managing/ management by the public. Here again, clinical decisions are ring-fenced from monetary considerations. The market is kept out of the transaction.</p><p><strong>·</strong> All national health systems that are largely based on purchasing healthcare from private providers spend much more than other systems which are dominated by public providers. Thus, Sri Lanka spends only 3% of the GDP, Thailand 4% of GDP, Cuba and Brazil 8% of GDP. In contrast, USA, which is free market plus insurance based, spends 19% of GDP on healthcare.</p><p><strong>·</strong> In nations like India and the USA, the principle is of “making markets work for healthcare.” Which really means figuring out how to channel public expenditure on health through private sector, so that they are able to benefit from it. That leads to a huge over-consumption of care, much of which is unnecessary, while large proportions of population are excluded from the care that is needed.</p><p><strong>·</strong> The classic example is USA, which spends 19% of the US GDP on healthcare, and yet close to 25% of the population are uninsured and another 25 % or more are under-insured- meaning that the insurance cover which they have fails to pay for their healthcare need. India’s PMJAY is rapidly trying to take us down the US type of health insurance model.</p><p><strong>·</strong> If India was to achieve Universal Health Coverage based on purchasing care from a dominant private sector, it has to be ready to spend many times more than what it would need to spend in comparison to a public provisioning-based system.</p><p><strong>6. How should peoples’ movements respond to this initiative? What should their approach be to mobilizing people for change, and in shaping the public discourse on these subjects?</strong></p><p>The response has to be at many levels.</p><p>At the level of public discourse, Peoples Movements must disseminate a select few key messages- and this would have to be backed up by evidence:</p><p>a. The PM-JAY scheme is unable to deliver on its key promises, which are: providing financial protection for the costs of health care and increasing access to healthcare and improving health outcomes.</p><p>b. The PM-JAY is being projected as a great gain for the poor- but in reality, the main purpose it serves is as an economic boost to the private sector in healthcare. The poor would have been better served by increasing the quantity, range and quality of public services.</p><p>c. There is a need for much better monitoring of the PM-JAY and civil society organizations’ and people’s movements must be involved in such monitoring. If monitoring improves, many private providers would exit or have to be pushed out. But this is good, for it would leave only the ethical not- for- profit providers- and these could supplement the healthcare system. Furthermore, private providers may be encouraged only where public sector is unable to provide care.</p><p>d. Paying public providers using the current insurance mechanism brings the problems of private sector behaviour into the public sector. The insurance scheme can however be approached to top up the usual facility budget based on variety and quantity of cases managed in the previous months or year.</p><p>e. Payments to private providers must be made in a timely manner and without corruption, so that ethical players are encouraged to stay on. For both public and private providers, it is only the marginal capacity that should be paid for- (that is the running costs. It should not include the capital costs).</p><p>f. There has to be a substantial improvement in number of beds and range of services provided by public hospitals, along with improvement in quality of care. Quality of care should include all elements of patient dignity, comfort and satisfaction, and also access to timely care, polite behaviour, better patient communications and facilitation, fixing appointments for consultation etc. Public investment is best spent on achieving these objectives.</p><p>At the level of popular mobilization of those who are directly affected, peoples’ movements can undertake the following activities:</p><ol><li>Ensure that patients know their entitlements under the scheme, and where it is denied, they bring it to notice of authorities. These should include at least the following:</li><li>The patients are consulted and informed of price of services before they are charged the same.</li><li>The patients can readily see how much money is on the card, and how much is being charged and they receive a bill for it- even though they are not paying in cash. It should be clear that the same bill that the patient has signed is the basis for reimbursement.</li><li>That a patient is not denied any service for which the hospital is empanelled. The services they are providing and those they are not providing should be clearly listed in the contract itself and be available to the public.</li><li>After gathering testimonies or other forms of data on breach of the contractual terms, forms of collective protest can be organized. These could take the form of a petition, or news statement, or meetings etc.</li><li>Gather evidence of double-billing and help both individuals and organizations to challenge it.</li><li>Demand right to anonymized data base of the PM-JAY claims for district level analysis to identify distortions and patterns of supply driven care</li></ol><p><strong>7.</strong> <strong>PM_JAY is limited to inpatient care and procedures. It does not cover out-patient care and primary healthcare. But greater proportion of health expenditure is on out-patient care. Also, by keeping outpatient care outside the PM-JAY package, does not healthcare get fragmented? Should we therefore demand inclusion of out-patient care in the PM-JAY package?</strong></p><p>a. Out-patient care is far more difficult to monitor and regulate than in-patient care. When the PM_JAY platform is so prone to problems like double billing and inappropriate care, adding out-patient care will only exacerbate the problem. Also, much of primary health care and out-patient care at all levels is preventive and promotive- like screening for early detection, counselling and medication to prevent complications and the need for in-patient care and procedures. The business model of private hospitals and clinics is focused on curative care, preferably complex, secondary, and tertiary level care. The private sector is not the best carrier for preventive care, that too at the primary level.</p><p>b. A large game being played today is to somehow persuade government to route its one lakh crore expenditure in primary healthcare through the private sector. The proposal from international aid agencies promoting privatization in the primary healthcare sector is to go for a model where primary healthcare in a geographical area is outsourced to a corporate entity. The demand for inclusion of primary health care and outpatient care into PM_JAY can play into their hands, as the main providers within PM_JAY are private providers. Peoples’ movements need to insist on universal comprehensive primary healthcare being through public provisioning.</p><p>c. The other demand that we must guard against is asking for more funds for PM-JAY or reimbursement at higher rates for procedures. These will only drive more money into private hands without improving health outcomes, or access to health care, or financial protection.</p><p><strong>8.</strong> <strong>Should our main demand be roll back of all government funded insurance schemes?</strong></p><p>The JSA has already called for a complete rollback of insurance schemes with the alternative being strengthening public health services. There is merit in such a position. But many civil society and academic groups (and the HLEG report) also call for “complete rollback of insurance schemes” with the alternative being the outsourcing of all primary, secondary and tertiary care services in a geographical area to a corporate entity or integrated care network as they prefer to call it. Sometimes the alternative is articulated as contracting in all individual private doctors in that area- which in practical terms could amount to the same. Thus, a call for “completely roll back of insurance schemes” is a slogan that we should voice cautiously if at all. Given also the popularity of the insurance schemes within trade unions as well as many other sections of the people, it may be a wiser strategy in the current context to push for limiting the presence of insurance, with larger proportion of public providers, and call for ensuring that private providers adhere to contractual terms. Moreover, primary healthcare must remain separate and should be based on public provisioning. One would also need to call for making effective and expanding the ESI network and ensuring that the ESI as well as healthcare units of public sector undertakings are not privatized using insurance or any other route.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=309f9a9bec09" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/from-prof-sundararamans-desk/unpacking-ayushman-bharat-and-other-recent-health-policy-initiatives-part-i-309f9a9bec09">Unpacking Ayushman Bharat and other Recent Health Policy initiatives Part I</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/from-prof-sundararamans-desk">From Dr. Sundararaman’s Desk</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>