<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by SurelyKnott on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by SurelyKnott on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@surelyknott?source=rss-7746e8fb75de------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 13:32:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@surelyknott/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Souvenirs du portrait de la jeune fille en feu]]></title>
            <link>https://surelyknott.medium.com/souvenirs-du-portrait-de-la-jeune-fille-en-feu-e007fb047600?source=rss-7746e8fb75de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e007fb047600</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[SurelyKnott]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Aug 2021 13:01:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-03T13:05:28.577Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Malheureusement, cet article n’est pas tout en français</p><p>I watched <em>Portrait of a Lady on Fire</em>. It is incredible. My heart has grown heavy with the sadness. To process my grief, I’ve written my unstructured thoughts.</p><p>—</p><p>In Orpheus &amp; Eurydice, Charon ferries Orpheus across the Styx to enter the Underworld, just as Marianne is ferried to the island.</p><p>—</p><p>When Marianne first sees Heloise’ face, they are physically aroused by Heloise running. Research suggests that people misattribute physical arousal as romantic attraction. Heloise’ running may have planted the seed of attraction between them.</p><p>—</p><p>The pivotal scene is when Heloise reveals to Marianne that they have been studying each other as equals. Marianne’s gaze is matched by Heloise’. Originally this was meant to be Marianne and Heloise’ first kiss, but it was moved until after the midpoint. Just as well, a first kiss would have distracted from the scene’s important transformation of Marianne’s asymmetric gaze to a gaze between equals. Equality is a pleasant feeling.</p><p>—</p><p>The women at the bonfire are singing in Latin fugere non possum, “which means ‘they cannot fly,’ said Sciamma. “It’s an adaptation of a sentence by Nietzsche, who says, ‘The higher we soar, the smaller we appear to those who cannot fly.’”</p><p>—</p><p><em>Portrait of a Lady on Fire</em> is fixated on faces and the passion they express. The film feels like a spiritual successor to The Passion of Joan of Arc.</p><p>—</p><p>The male gaze in cinema objectifies women by framing their body in isolation. The person is never entirely in frame. Early in <em>Portrait of a Lady on Fire</em>, Marianne objectifies Heloise’ by noting how her ear should be painted — broken down into its visual components, reconstituted and commodified for Milanese suitors. Marianne is a conduit for the male gaze.</p><p>But, later <em>Portrait of a Lady on Fire</em> isolates Heloise’ and Marianne’s bodies together — after the bonfire, we see their hands touching, coaxing each other to the beach. When they take an apothecary drug, we see their arms and hands, together, their lips, together. The camera focuses not on their bodies but on the relationship between their bodies.</p><p>Marianne’s lasting memory of Heloise captures here entirely within frame. Heloise is remembered standing in her wedding dress, as her whole person.</p><p>—</p><p>The editing is almost always conventional and excellent. The only unconventional cut I counted is when Marianne and Heloise say goodbye. The scene of their final embrace cuts prematurely, and when Marianne looks back, the image cuts uncomfortably quickly. We glimpse Heloise too briefly.</p><p>—</p><p>When Heloise calls Marianne to turn and see her one last time before she leaves, it is the only time that they address each other as <em>tu</em>, not <em>vous</em>. “<em>Retourne-toi</em>,” Heloise calls. By convention, <em>vous</em> is used between different classes, <em>tu</em> between equals.</p><p>—</p><p>Heloise’ final portrait could have only shown page number twenty-eight if Heloise had insisted that this detail be added.</p><p>—</p><p>Marianne tells us in the final scene that Heloise did not see her. This frees Marianne, and ourselves, to gaze on Heloise without fear of being seen. As Heloise expresses her joy and sadness she expresses those same emotions that <em>Portrait of a Lady on Fire</em> has grown within us. We feel this longing more fully because we gaze on Heloise’ without reservation.</p><p>In gazing, we are party to the reversal of Heloise’ and Marianne’s relationship. They’re no longer equals who see each other. Marianne is gazing asymmetrically as she did before Heloise disabused her of this inequality. Only now, Marianne gazes with memory and understanding.</p><p>—</p><p>The film is set in the 1770s. Heloise and Marianne are in their early-twenties. The French Revolution and the Reign of Terror will begin in their forties.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e007fb047600" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Cultural Progress]]></title>
            <link>https://surelyknott.medium.com/on-cultural-progress-e8a0c7eaff8a?source=rss-7746e8fb75de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e8a0c7eaff8a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[SurelyKnott]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Jul 2021 02:45:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-23T04:41:50.057Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*tw1Nu6yuYtFO7eMH" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@jeremyyappy?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Jeremy Yap</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Ryan Murphy has <a href="https://worksinprogress.co/issue/this-is-what-peak-culture-looks-like/">written</a> a provocative and <a href="https://www.theverge.com/2016/8/16/12508398/this-is-the-ideal-make-body-meme">meme</a>-<a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/paradoxplaza/comments/9rly2e/you_may_not_like_it_but_this_is_what_peak/">savvy</a> piece for Works in Progress. In the article, Murphy argues that progress applies not just in scientific but also artistic endeavours. However, artistic progress is held back by a set of cultural assumptions, at which Murphy takes aim.</p><p>The article has prompted Reddit <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/badphilosophy/comments/nztjuc/this_is_what_peak_culture_looks_like/">dissections</a>, and verbal <a href="https://www.affix.live/1518706/8766148-episode-26-we-are-peak-culture">reflections</a> by two of my favorite <a href="https://www.affix.live/">podcasters</a>. I’ve written this essay because I agree with Murphy’s conclusion, disagree with his argument why, and propose a different argument in support of the fact that cultural progress is not only possible, but happening right now.</p><h4>Steelmanning Murphy</h4><p>Murphy opens with the attention grabbing rhetorical questions</p><blockquote>If someone refused to use Google Maps and preferred to rely on a vellum chart from the 1400s, we would think they were very strange. If a bank communicated with its branches via telegraph, who would deposit money with them? If an army used guns from 1650 in a modern battle, they would meet certain death. (<a href="https://worksinprogress.co/issue/this-is-what-peak-culture-looks-like/">Murphy, 2021</a>)</blockquote><p>And yet, Murphy asserts, we do exactly this in the realm of arts and culture.</p><blockquote>“It is commonplace to allege that not only is the art and media we produce no better than that of the near or far past, but that it is actually worse. These arguments are false.” (<a href="https://worksinprogress.co/issue/this-is-what-peak-culture-looks-like/">Murphy, 2021</a>)</blockquote><p>How do we know that cultural products are better now than in the past?</p><blockquote>“Our<strong> revealed preferences</strong> mean something… if we can replicate a near approximation of a historical masterwork at a cost no higher than it was in the past, and we’re doing something else, that something else is probably better than the supposed historical masterwork.”(<a href="https://worksinprogress.co/issue/this-is-what-peak-culture-looks-like/">Murphy, 2021</a>, emphasis mine)</blockquote><p>The appeal to revealed preference may be stronger than Murphy lets on. For example, Murphy recommends that people watch <em>Ford v Ferrari </em>instead of <em>Citizen Kane </em>because <em>Ford v Ferrari</em> is more popular. I would add to this that for <em>Ford v. Ferrari</em> to be so popular, it must appeal to a wide variety of movie goers. Thrill seekers must enjoy it. People going on a date must enjoy it. Parents with their kids must enjoy it. The wider the revealed preference for a movie, the greater the range of preferences that it must have, successfully, appealed to. This tells us something about its quality.</p><p>Murphy deploys revealed preference to take exception with critics like Douthat, Hickel, Hirsch and Biskind. These critics argue the the pinnacle of cultural accomplishment was sometime well before the current day. Douthat for one has <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/14/opinion/sunday/1970s-weinstein-sexual-predation.html">argued</a> that the 1970s were “our civilization’s last great burst of creative energy”, to which I, and I’m sure Murphy would too, disagree.</p><p>To Murphy, lauding the past and poo-pooing the present is progress denialism. People today much prefer watching <em>Ford v. Ferrari </em>to <em>Citizen Kane. </em>People much prefer scrolling Instagram than going to the Louvre. People’s revealed preference shows us that the golden age is now, not 1970, not 1570, not any other period.</p><p>Murphy argues that this misplaced sense of a past golden age rests on nostalgia rather than cultural merit. He cites <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/2059204320965058">research</a> into the nostalgia-age nexus, where our perception of the quality of cultural products coincides with their salience during our formative years.</p><p>To Murphy, it’s somewhat dangerous to laud antiquated works because of nostalgia and deference. If we cannot conceive of removing these revered cultural artifacts from our top ten lists, then we may be, at least tacitly, opposed to the idea of cultural progress.</p><blockquote>“If one can’t imagine the removal of items from the Western cultural canon taking place, then one’s paradigm may be inconsistent with even the <strong>possibility</strong> of cultural progress.” (<a href="https://worksinprogress.co/issue/this-is-what-peak-culture-looks-like/">Murphy, 2021</a>, original emphasis)</blockquote><p>Murphy argues that in order to for culture to progress, we must be able to conceive of the possibility that masterpieces like Beatles music, Shakespearean drama, and Orson Welles’ filmography can and will be surpassed. To consider de-canonising any of the classics to be inconceivable is to be against progress — quoting Joel Mokyr</p><blockquote>Progress is “an implied disrespect of previous generations… The same age that fostered a belief in progress shed its excessive respect for earlier thinkers, exuding a confidence that ‘we can do better.’ (<a href="https://worksinprogress.co/issue/this-is-what-peak-culture-looks-like/">Murphy, 2021</a>)</blockquote><p>Murphy adds a final, stronger claim to his thesis. Works such as Beatles music, Shakespearean drama and <em>Citizen Kane</em> have, in many way, already been surpassed. Contemporary music, stories and films employ more clearly written prose, more complex plots, and more sophisticated literary devices, as well as more photo-realistic images, higher-quality sound and more advanced special effects. The fact that today, as we speak, these classical works continue to be lauded despite their technological inferiority suggests that we as a culture are <em>already</em> incapable of conceiving of the idea of cultural progress.</p><p>As Murphy asserts, quote:</p><blockquote>“Those studying Shakespeare today are metaphorically using the same scholarly methodology as medieval monks copying ancient texts line-by-line while thinking it’s teaching them science.” (<a href="https://worksinprogress.co/issue/this-is-what-peak-culture-looks-like/">Murphy, 2021</a>)</blockquote><h3>An outline</h3><p>I find a lot that’s interesting in this thesis. However, the argument is conceptually muddled and much is asserted that ought to have been demonstrated with reference to actual behaviour. My argument in short is:</p><ol><li>Murphy doesn’t explain the purpose of art.</li><li>Revealed preference indicates popularity, not quality or progress.</li><li>Revealed preference is incoherent with what we think of as artistic quality.</li><li>Audiences’ revealed preferences lean toward the classics.</li><li>Praise for the classics doesn’t prevent cultural progress.</li><li>Artistic progress continues to be made to this day.</li><li>We underrate contemporary art because of biases.</li><li>Progress is positive sum.</li></ol><h4>1. What is the purpose of art?</h4><p>Works in progress is a great publication. I adored Sue Marquez’ article in May 2021 calling for more work to eliminate lead pipes in the United States. Lead pipes are a huge problem, and if we invested more in locating and replacing lead pipes, then we would solve a serious problem that causes a lot of human suffering.</p><p>I also love Steven Pinker’s The Better Angels of our Nature. Violence has been a huge problem throughout human history, but if we doubled town on the trends of better governance, free markets, literacy, feminisation and rationality, then we could reduce a lot of violence that causes a lot of suffering.</p><p>In both cases we can measure progress by pointing to an outcome — developmental disorders, violent deaths. But what’s the better outcome that Murphy’s trying to progress? What is the outcome of art?</p><p>Murphy’s argument frames consumption as the outcome of art. Good art is what is our revealed preference, and what is popular is our revealed preference. I think this is fine as far as it’s necessary to debate cultural progress without getting bogged down in “what is art, anyway?”. However, it opens up the argument to other definitions of artistic progress.</p><p>Notwithstanding the ongoing debate within aesthetics, I propose an alternative measure of artistic progress that:</p><blockquote>Cultural progress is the expanding capacity of our cultural repertoire to evoke our thoughts and feelings. Cultural stagnation or regression is the stagnant or shrinking capacity to evoke thoughts and feelings.</blockquote><p>This definition puts thoughts and feelings at the center of artistic purpose, rather than popularity and revealed preference. Consuming a piece of art is necessary for art to evoke thoughts and feelings, but it is not sufficient. People often consume art that fails to evoke their thoughts or their feelings!</p><p>My definition doesn’t privilege either high culture or mass culture. It’s legitimate for a painting to evoke ‘refined’ thoughts and feelings. It’s also legitimate for a blockbuster film to evoke feelings of enjoyment, excitement and “gee-whizz”. Both are legitimate. What matters is how well the art evokes those thoughts and feelings.</p><p>Philosophers may <a href="https://www.quora.com/According-to-J-S-Mill-Its-better-to-be-Socrates-dissatisfied-than-a-fool-satisfied-better-to-be-a-human-being-dissatisfied-than-a-pig-satisfied-How-is-a-fool-and-pig-satisfied?share=1">argue</a> whether some thoughts and feelings are better than others. Philosophers may <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Death_of_the_Author">argue</a> whether the author’s intended thoughts and feelings are more important than those unintended. I’m sidestepping those debates for now. All thoughts and feelings are equal, what matters is the work’s capacity to evoke them.</p><p>This is a more satisfying metric of cultural progress, which we’ll return to later. I will argue that it’s more coherent than Murphy’s revealed preference.</p><h4>2. Revealed preference indicates popularity, not quality or progress.</h4><p>Murphy’s invocation of revealed preference as a measure of quality is an interesting one. If the classics are so good, and accessing them is so cheap, why don’t people access them all the time?</p><p>To address this, I ask you, the reader, what is your favourite movie? For me, the it’s 1996 movie <em>Gattaca.</em> I probably watch <em>Gattaca</em> once a year at most, but to be honest I think the last time was in 2014. You probably watch your favourite movie about as often as I watch mine.</p><p>You and I both say that we like our favourite film, and yet 99.9% of our spare time is spent not watching this movie. This raises the question: If we can recreate the experience of watching our favourite movie at a cost no higher than it was in the past, and we’re doing something else, we probably like that something else better than our supposedly favourite film.</p><p>If revealed preference is our measure of artistic success, then it’s paradoxical that we spend the vast majority of our spare time not watching our favourite film. It’s paradoxical that masterworks aren’t replayed night after night. But this isn’t a a paradox if evoking thoughts and feelings is the purpose of art.</p><ul><li>Many cultural works are excellent, but you only need to experience them once to appreciate them. Some works lose their edge through repeated viewings. It’s OK to want to move on and experience new things.</li><li>Many works elicit difficult emotions like fear and sorrow. Just because you don’t enjoy experiencing those emotions doesn’t make the work bad. Many great works evoke very difficult emotions, but many people just want to come home and experience comfort and security.</li><li>Many works can only evoke our thoughts and feelings after close engagement. Engaging with a work this way can be very rewarding, but it’s OK if you just don’t have the time or willpower to do so. It’s OK to come home and unwind with something easy.</li></ul><p>Many great works are difficult, so it’s understandable that many people’s revealed preference is to not engage with them. That’s fine! But in Murphy’s article, engagement can be scorned.</p><blockquote>“Those studying Shakespeare today are metaphorically using the same scholarly methodology as medieval monks copying ancient texts line-by-line while thinking it’s teaching them science.” (<a href="https://worksinprogress.co/issue/this-is-what-peak-culture-looks-like/">Murphy, 2021</a>)</blockquote><p>This trikes me as the artistic version of Chesterton’s Fence. I think you should only remove classics from the canon once you fully understand why they were put there. Murphy’s article does not even attempt to understand why Shakespeare is canonical.</p><p>It’s true that many people don’t read Shakespeare. Shakespeare is difficult for modern readers to understand. But difficulty is a weak reason to de-canonise a classic. I think Tyler Cowen is right about Shakespeare’s works</p><blockquote>“Shakespeare is very likely the deepest thinker the human race has produced, so these are worth careful study!” (<a href="https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/06/now-need-post-ranking-shakespeares-plays.html">Cowen, 2017</a>)</blockquote><p>Accessible works are not intrinsically better, nor are inaccessible works worse. Murphy quotes from Adam Smith and Malcolm Gladwell to demonstrate how Gladwell’s 2005 <em>Blink</em> is more readable than Smith’s 1776 <em>Wealth of Nations</em>. But the reason that Gladwell is easier for us to read than Smith is not because the prose of one is objectively better, as Murphy claims, but the fact that English was a different language in 1776. The fact that a 21st century English speaker finds something easier to read does not make that work superior.</p><p>Between 2011–2014, Elena Ferrante published the Neapolitan Novels. They have sold over 10 million copies, and have been heralded as <a href="https://www.vulture.com/article/best-books-21st-century-so-far.html">classics</a>. But, they’re written in Italian. Murphy could have placed an excerpt from Ferrante’s novels next to Blink by Malcolm Gladwell and asked which was easier to read. To an English speaking audience, it’s clearly Gladwell. But this seems unfair, Ferrante’s prose is accessible to Italian speakers. If we took the time to learn Italian, then we could enjoy these novels too. It’s no different for Smith. The <em>Wealth of Nations</em> is written in 16th century Scots-English, a language different from our own. The fact that the reader must learn the language does not take away from the value of the <em>Wealth of Nations </em>or from Shakespeare. They are brilliant thinkers who reward close study.</p><p>Just because most people don’t engage with a difficult work doesn’t make the work bad. People may prioritise other things in their life than the time and effort of studying a difficult work. These are legitimate reasons to not engage with the classics. But if revealed preference is synonymous with artistic quality, they become a misplaced condemnation of the work itself.</p><h4>3. Revealed preference is incoherent with what we think of as artistic quality.</h4><p>Revealed preference doesn’t necessarily work even on its own terms. Reading Murphy’s piece I asked myself: over what time frame is revealed preference meant to indicate quality?</p><p>Murphy suggests that viewers will get more out of watching <em>The Aviator</em> than many supposed masterworks. This is an odd recommendation. <em>The Aviator</em> made <a href="https://www.the-numbers.com/movie/Aviator-The-(2004)#tab=summary">$103 million</a> domestically in 2004, reaching around 16.9 million tickets sold. By contrast, in 2004 there were a mere <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/383020/number-of-visits-to-smithsonian-national-museum-of-natural-history/">4.4 million</a> visitors to the Smithsonian in Washington D.C. The audience’ revealed preference suggests that <em>The Aviator</em> was better than all the works in the Smithsonian.</p><p>But if we look a few years later to 2007 it’s less clear. Theaters no longer screen <em>The Aviator</em>. Streaming services and DVD sales are hard to come by, but it’s hard to imagine the number of people who watch <em>The Aviator</em> each year would surpass half a million. In that same year, <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/383020/number-of-visits-to-smithsonian-national-museum-of-natural-history/">7.1 million</a> visitors attended the Smithsonian. The audience’ revealed preference suggests that the works of the Smithsonian Museum are better than <em>The Aviator</em>.</p><p>How can this be? <em>The Aviator</em> was a popular and therefore artistically superior film in 2004, but then a less popular, artistically worse film in 2007, despite the fact that <em>The Aviator</em> has not changed. The Smithsonian was artistically inferior in 2004, but superior in 2007 despite having not changed. This rapid change in quality, despite neither work changing at all, is incoherent.</p><p>—</p><p>The effect is even more extreme in laboratory settings. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2006/02/14/health/in-music-others-tastes-may-help-shape-your-own.html">Researchers</a> at Columbia University created an online music marketplace for over 14,000 teenage participants. The marketplace consisted only of obscure indie songs none of the participants had heard before. Participants were asked to listen to songs, rate them, and could reveal their preference for certain songs by downloading them to keep.</p><p>The popularity of each song within a given cohort was random. Downloads created a cascade effect where high downloads induced participants to try the song, leading to more downloads. For one group of participants, one song reached number one out of 48 songs, while in another group the same song ranked 40th. As the <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16469928/">paper</a> noted, “The best songs rarely did poorly, and the worst rarely did well, but any other result was possible.”</p><p>How can this be? Each cohort’s revealed preference for each song varied wildly. This would imply that each song’s quality varied wildly, despite the song remaining identical across cohorts. This wild variation in revealed preference despite the song not changing at all seems incoherent.</p><p>—</p><p>On 10 December 2020, CD Projekt Red released <em>Cyberpunk 2077</em>, a highly anticipated video game. Within twelve hours of release it had over <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20201212020012/https://www.businessinsider.com/cyberpunk-2077-tops-steam-and-twitch-charts-at-launch-2020-12">one million players</a> on Steam, but initial reviews were scathing. There game was full of <a href="https://gamerant.com/cyberpunk-2077-most-common-bugs/">bugs</a>, <a href="https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ffab&amp;q=cyberpunk+2077+combat+review&amp;ia=web">clunky combat</a>, and was <a href="https://www.gamespot.com/reviews/cyberpunk-2077-review/1900-6417622/">unplayable on last-gen consoles</a> (CD Projekt Red offered these players a refund).</p><p><em>Cyberpunk 2077</em> has gotten better since launch. CD Projekt Red have released 11 patches, with a 12th in development. And yet, in June 2021 the number of concurrent Steam users peaked at <a href="https://steamcharts.com/app/1091500#All">15,703 players</a>, it’s lowest month on record. These patches are meant to have made <em>Cyberpunk 2077 </em>better, but each new patch has seen the player base shrink. Players’ revealed preference is that buggy, unplayable <em>Cyberpunk 2077 </em>was better than patched and working <em>Cyberpunk 2077. </em>This seems incoherent with what we think of as artistic quality.</p><p>—</p><p>These counter-examples underscore that revealed preference is an incoherent measure of a work’s quality. To embrace this approach is to reach strange conclusions where that quality of a work varies considerably even when the work remains unchanged, that quality is random, and that unambiguous improvements to a work make it worse.</p><h4>4. Audiences’ revealed preferences is for classics.</h4><p>Even if revealed preference were a coherent measure of artistic quality, it would not necessarily support Murphy’s conclusion that new art is better art.</p><p>Last year my housemate bought a Disney + subscription. First we watched <em>The Little Mermaid</em> (1989), <em>Sleeping Beauty</em> (1959), then <em>Snow White &amp; the Seven Dwarfs</em> (1939). At various points I found them watching <em>Pinocchio</em> (1940) and <em>Cinderella</em> (1965). Despite having a Netflix account, and its award winning original films such as <em>Roma</em> (2018) and <em>The Irishman</em> (2019), they preferred watching old movies on Disney +.</p><p>Which is not to say that Disney + has no new content, but the new content embodies the reverence for old classics that Murphy lambasts. <em>Beauty &amp; The Beast</em> (2017) at its most ambitious added a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it nod to same-sex attraction, and fixed a ‘plot hole’ that no one knew about the Beasts’ castle that was only a day’s ride from the village. <em>The Lion King</em> (2019) updated the graphics of <em>The Lion King</em> (1994) and added <a href="https://youtu.be/5CqaBDQDYOY?t=19">one line</a> to show that Nala could be a boss too, but otherwise no change.</p><p>The latest Star Wars films fare little better. <em>The Force Awakens</em> remade <em>A New Hope</em>. <em>Rogue One</em> used CGI to recreate Carrie Fisher and Peter Cushing exactly as they appeared in 1977. Disney tried to move the franchise forward in <em>The Last Jedi</em>, but fans revolted against these changes<em>.</em> Fans would rather that Star Wars repeat 1977 again and not progress at all.</p><p>Murphy appeals to revealed preference to argue that we are progressing as a culture, but our revealed preference is very often for classics and reverent recreations of the classics.</p><h4>5. Praise for the classics doesn’t prevent cultural progress.</h4><p>Murphy raises another interesting point in the essay that our view of the classics conflates quality with what was ground breaking technology at the time. At one point Murphy argues that <em>Citizen Kane</em> is overrated because people often praise <em>Citizen Kane </em>for its ground breaking technology.</p><p>In fairness, many people do say this and it’s very annoying. Ask <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/9vjoge/is_citizen_kane_overrated/">Reddit</a> and responders cite <em>Kane</em>’s innovation. Crash Course <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qk0-m_LARCY">says</a> <em>Kane</em> was groundbreaking. Roger Ebert too</p><blockquote>“Citizen Kane” is more than a great movie; it is a gathering of all the lessons of the emerging era of sound, just as “Birth of a Nation” assembled everything learned at the summit of the silent era.” (<a href="https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/great-movie-citizen-kane-1941">Ebert, 1998</a>)</blockquote><p>Murphy leans on the over-praise of Kane to show how critics conflate past accomplishment with contemporary enjoyment. But this doesn’t prove anything about cultural progress more broadly. Groundbreaking movies can and are declassified as greats, <em>Kane</em> is the outlier in how long it has survived.</p><p>In 1998 the American Film Institute (AFI) released <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AFI%27s_100_Years...100_Movies">100 Years, 100 Movies</a>, a poll of the 100 best American films according to 1,500 of its members. In 2007 they released an updated list in which twenty three movies were removed, including:</p><ul><li><em>The Jazz Singer </em>was the first feature film with synchronised sound. For this accomplishment, The Jazz Singer was added to the 1998 list, then removed in 2007.</li><li><em>Birth of a Nation</em> was once <a href="https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/great-movie-citizen-kane-1941">praised</a> as “the summit of the silent era”. It was added to the 1998 list, then removed in 2007.</li><li><em>Close Encounters of the Third Kind </em>pioneered <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_control_photography">motion control photography</a>, was added in 1998, and removed in 2007.</li><li><em>Stagecoach</em> pioneered cinematic stunt work in 1939, was listed in 1998, and removed in 2007. That said, <em>The Lord of the Rings</em>, which was added in 2007, does have pretty good stunt work.</li></ul><p>Nor is willingness to de-list cultural classics confined to film. In 2005, Universal Publishing released <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1001_Albums_You_Must_Hear_Before_You_Die">1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die</a>. There have been three more editions, the latest published in 2018. Seventy seven albums have been <a href="http://1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie.wikidot.com/ex-albums-year">de-listed</a> over the thirteen years, all of them in order to make room for new albums that came out during that period.</p><p>Had Murphy’s article explored further, it would have been able to demonstrate that technological innovation does not guarantee even temporary status as a great film.</p><ul><li><em>Tron</em> was praised on release for its groundbreaking CGI but has never broken into consideration as a great film <em>qua</em> film.</li><li>The first film to use all digital colour grading was <em>O Brother Where Art Thou</em>, which by consensus is in <a href="https://editorial.rottentomatoes.com/guide/all-coen-brothers-movies-ranked-by-tomatometer/">the</a> <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/film/2018/sep/07/the-coen-brothers-film-ranked">bottom</a> <a href="https://screenrant.com/coen-brothers-movies-ranked-worst-best/">half</a> of all Coen Brothers’ films.</li><li><em>Vertigo</em>, <em>The Godfather</em>, <em>Casablanca </em>and <em>City Lights </em>are <a href="https://www2.bfi.org.uk/films-tv-people/sightandsoundpoll2012/films">argued</a> to be great films. They made, at best, minor advances in the technology of movies.</li><li><em>City Lights</em> is considered one of Charlie Chaplin’s great films, yet it was a silent film that <a href="https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/great-movie-city-lights-1931">poked fun</a> at ‘talkie’ pictures after the technology had been mainstream for over three years.</li></ul><p>Technological innovation is neither necessary nor sufficient for a movie to be perceived as great. Murphy’s criticism that technological praiseworthiness clouds our assessment of film quality is not born out in practice.</p><h4>6. Artistic progress continues to be made to this day.</h4><p>But here’s the thing, I think Murphy is right that culture is getting better. Murphy is wrong about why, but the fact is that we are living through the best time in all history to enjoy culture.</p><p>Earlier I proposed that the purpose of culture is to evoke thoughts and feelings. Cultural progress is the expanding capacity of our cultural repertoire to evoke our thoughts and feelings. And there has never been a more exciting time for the arts to evoke our thoughts and feelings.</p><ul><li>If you enjoy horror, you can watch <em>It Follows</em> and <em>The Babadook</em>, <em>The Thing</em> and <em>The Shining. </em>Old or<em> </em>new, each of these films evoke fear and dread.</li><li>If you enjoy suspense, you can read <em>And Then There Were None</em>, <em>Misery</em> and <em>Red Dragon</em>, you can watch <em>Vertigo</em> and <em>Wages </em>of Fear. Old or new, each of these works continues to evoke tension.</li><li>If you enjoy animation and gorgeous visuals, you can watch <em>Into the Spiderverse, Spirited Away </em>or <em>Snow White. </em>Old or new, each is beautiful.</li><li>If you enjoy spooky vampires you can watch <em>Nosferatu</em> if you enjoy spooky Swedish vampires you can watch <em>Let the Right One In</em>, if you enjoy Mormon vampires you can watch <em>Twilight</em>. Where the range of vampire films was once narrow, it is now wide and caters to many tastes.</li><li>If you enjoy American epics, you can watch <em>Citizen Kane </em>and <em>The Godfather</em>, you can read <em>Last of the Mohicans</em> and <em>Freedom. </em>It’s a sign of cultural progress that authors continue to evoke new, complex thoughts and feelings towards the world’s last super-power.</li><li>If you enjoy action, you can watch <em>Mad Max Fury Road</em>, <em>Terminator 2</em> and <em>Die Hard</em>. They’re all awesome.</li></ul><p>Thirty years ago, if you enjoyed a certain genre of art, there may have been one great work to enjoy. Today, there are dozens. That is progress.</p><h4>7. We underrate contemporary art because of biases</h4><p>Despite the fact that masterpieces continue to be released, many doubt that today’s cultural output is as good as that of the past. These doubters are wrong. They are wrong because they’ve fallen prey to a suite of psychological biases.</p><p>We are prone to <a href="https://www.schwabassetmanagement.com/content/recency-bias">recency bias</a>, where we put too much emphasis on recent memories. A lot of cultural products in any era just aren’t that good, but we consume them because they’re novel and because other people are consuming them. This recency bias means that contemporary mediocrities are fresh in our memories while we forget about past mediocrities altogether.</p><p>Recency bias is compounded by <a href="https://www.oxfordreference.com/view/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803095436724">availability heuristic</a>, where we judge the frequency of something by how readily it comes to mind. We overestimate the frequency of exciting but rare events like shark attacks because they are vivid and memorable. Great pieces of culture are memorable. Mediocre ones forgettable. So when we’re asked to name a song, film or painting from the past, we tend to remember only the good ones. The availability heuristic then leads us to think that because good culture from the past is easier to remember, there must have been more of it.</p><p>The past had just as many dud songs, films and other works as we have now. The only difference is that we forget about past duds, we only remember past masters, and we are all too aware of recent mediocrities. This creates a false impression that the past produced more classics than today.</p><p>The truth is that we are producing as many great cultural works today as we ever had. Our culture’s capacity to evoke thoughts and feelings continues to grow. Each new masterpiece is a contribution to the cultural repertoire.</p><h4>8. Progress is positive sum</h4><p>My final objection relates to the nature of progress as Murphy describes it. I may be reading more into Murphy’s words than I think is fair, so consider my epistemic status of this section far less certain.</p><p>Murphy opens the piece with a set of rhetorical questions</p><blockquote>“If someone refused to use Google Maps and preferred to rely on a vellum chart from the 1400s, we would think they were very strange. If a bank communicated with its branches via telegraph, who would deposit money with them? If an army used guns from 1650 in a modern battle, they would meet certain death”</blockquote><p>This is an impoverished way to think of progress. Progress is not about the tools we use, like vellum charts, telegraphs and muskets. Progress is about better outcomes — like reducing inter-state violence, or reducing developmental disorders associated with lead-contaminated drinking water.</p><p>Consider how Murphy’s rhetorical question would come across if posed differently.</p><ul><li>If a construction worker built your house using a hammer invented in the 1500s, you’d think they were very strange — but this is exactly what a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claw_hammer">claw hammer</a> is and construction workers use them all the time because they achieve the outcome of building sturdy buildings.</li><li>If your doctor recommended you prevent the spread of fomites using a technique developed during the Islamic Golden Age, they would become a super-spreader — but the invention of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soap#History">soap</a> goes back to medieval Syria (if not earlier!) and we still use soap because it achieves the outcome of killing viruses.</li><li>If someone refused to use Google Maps… — which is what hikers do on multi-day hikes. You won’t have mobile reception and even if you did Google Maps provides an inferior description of terrain contours, hazards and search-and-rescue coordinates. Google Maps is awesome for achieving the outcome of driving across town. But if you go hiking, you <em>must</em> take a <a href="https://www.topomap.co.nz/">topographic map</a> or else the outcome may involve getting lost and dying.</li></ul><p>My concern with Murphy’s focus on means rather than outcomes is that it paints a picture of progress that is zero-sum. For map navigation to progress, vellum charts must be removed. For war fighting to progress, old machinery must be abandoned. For culture to progress we must remove old classics from the cultural canon.</p><p>Alyssa Rosenberg has expressed why this is a tragic view of progress better than I could. She was writing in 2017 when <em>La La Land</em> was accidentally awarded the Oscar meant for <em>Moonlight</em>:</p><blockquote>“I hate that the contest between “Moonlight” and “La La Land” … emphasized the sense that they were locked in a zero-sum contest, and that for “Moonlight” to win, “La La Land” not merely had to lose, but to be <strong>defeated</strong>.</blockquote><blockquote>The truth is that both “Moonlight” and “La La Land” are highly moving, original works… &lt;by&gt; directors of tremendous vision who are going to compete for Academy Awards again, maybe even against each other.</blockquote><blockquote>Let’s hope the next time they do, they aren’t pitted against each other in a way that mirrors an ugly idea about… progress that is ascendant in our politics: that the only way for members of one community to advance is at the expense of another.” (<a href="https://medium.com/r?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.washingtonpost.com%2Fnews%2Fact-four%2Fwp%2F2017%2F02%2F27%2Fthe-insane-end-of-the-oscars-sent-a-false-message-about-racial-progress%2F">Rosenberg, 2017</a>, emphasis original)</blockquote><p>Replace <em>La La Land</em> with <em>Citizen Kane</em> and <em>Ford v Ferrari </em>with <em>Moonlight</em> and I feel like Rosenberg is describing Murphy’s article. This zero-sum approach is not supportive of cultural progress. What cultural progress needs is for us to think about culture as a positive sum endeavour. I think Tyler Cowen is right about this too, so I’ll give him the last word:</p><blockquote>“Seeing Roger McGuinn perform has not detracted from my memories of seeing Paul McCartney or for that matter seeing Vladimir Horowitz… In many cases good experiences can even complement each other, rather than detract. (<a href="https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2005/12/most_status_gam.html">Cowen, 2005</a>)</blockquote><p>Great piece of culture do not complete — they complement each other. Both old and new works are a legitimate way to evoke our thoughts and feelings. We are making cultural progress right now because new works are expanding our cultural repertoire’s capacity to evoke our thoughts and feelings. Praising the great works that have come before us doesn’t detract from that progress.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e8a0c7eaff8a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dry humoured travel advice]]></title>
            <link>https://surelyknott.medium.com/dry-humoured-travel-advice-949ba3b02887?source=rss-7746e8fb75de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/949ba3b02887</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[advice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lists]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[SurelyKnott]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Feb 2020 06:35:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-24T06:35:54.179Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Like the liberal technocrat that I am, I have some actionable lessons after traveling Australia to India and back for 33 days.</p><ul><li>7–10 days is a good duration. More than 14 days, you might as well go for 3 weeks or 3 years.</li><li>Hotel gyms are a lie. They are, at best, three dumbells with a treadmill. Learn calisthenics, practice every morning.</li><li>Australia has the finest sunscreen in the world, take some with you.</li><li>Don’t buy these international SIM malarkies, go with your ho(s)tel driver to a local phone retailer and point to the local SIM you want on the local brochure. Bring your passport, license and selfie stick.</li><li>Even if you’re not going to take photos, you will. Complete a short course and you will take less bad photos. I recommend these Melbourne courses: <a href="https://mel365.com/stefano-ferro-photography-workshops/">https://mel365.com/stefano-ferro-photography-workshops/</a> You will thank yourself.</li><li>Buying travel essentials as you go is cognitively and time inefficient. Unless it’s heavy, bring it from home.</li><li>If you know nothing of you destination, read the simple wikipedia entry. If you’re knowledge hungry, read the regular wikipedia. If you have too much time, read a book.</li><li>Do not bring a book. Books are heavy. Podcasts weight nothing. Podcasts are books with mattress ads.</li><li>Travel with old friends or make new friends? Do both, they’re the actual best.</li></ul><p>Advice from the comments:</p><ul><li>Get a Kindle!</li><li>Get an eSim!</li><li>Get a shawl!</li><li>Get a daybag! Small/light enough to take anywhere. Stuff it with layers, snacks, toiletpaper and a waterbottle.</li><li>Get a toilet paper! From hotels/etc, keep in your day bag and regularly replenish. You will probably get a runny nose, you may get the runs, you will not always have a bathroom with toilet paper.</li><li>It’s hard to find universal adaptors in Australia, but they’re often duty free from airports. Amazon also has an amazing range.</li><li>Pack less than you think you need. At the end of a trip review what you used and resolve to never pack such things again.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=949ba3b02887" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Links 2019–01]]></title>
            <link>https://surelyknott.medium.com/links-2019-01-dc7a3aafde21?source=rss-7746e8fb75de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dc7a3aafde21</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[video-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[working-class]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[enlightenment-now]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[revolutionary]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[SurelyKnott]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 28 Jan 2019 01:23:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-28T01:33:51.473Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A link is not an endorsement, but it sure is interesting.</p><h3>Read</h3><h4>Enlightenment Wars: Some Reflections on ‘Enlightenment Now,’ One Year Later</h4><p>I like Pinker’s response but I’m always sad how much of this response has unpick the critics’ double standard.</p><blockquote>The recurring fallacy in lamentations of modernity is “to compare an idealized past, its vices overlooked, with a demonized present, its virtues overlooked.”</blockquote><p>If you’ve not read<em> Enlightenment Now! </em>then you get the greatest hits here</p><p><a href="https://quillette.com/2019/01/14/enlightenment-wars-some-reflections-on-enlightenment-now-one-year-later/">Enlightenment Wars: Some Reflections on &#39;Enlightenment Now,&#39; One Year Later - Quillette</a></p><h4>Steven Pinker on slavery and the Enlightenment</h4><p>Apologies for double dipping Marginal Revolution this month.</p><blockquote>This strikes me as a classic case of mood affiliation: “we must have a positive mood toward the Enlightenment!” And perhaps we must. But what is wrong with this alternative formulation?:</blockquote><blockquote>“Early modern Europe, including its later manifestation of the Enlightenment, brought great benefits to the world. Part of those benefits involved enhanced capacities. Some of those enhanced capacities were used to do great evil”</blockquote><p>Now <em>this </em>is a more thought out criticism of <em>Enlightenment Now!</em></p><blockquote>I would note also that so many of the most radical abolitionists, including in Britain, were <em>Christians</em>. It is fine to consider them part of the Enlightenment as well, but still to describe the Enlightenment as “the inventor of the notion that no one should be held as a slave” seems off-base to me. The 16th century Spanish Salamancans — theologians I might add — strongly opposed slavery well before the Enlightenment.</blockquote><p>Although this raises the question, are you suggesting that we must have a more positive mood toward Christians, Tyler? Perhaps we must. But what is wrong with an alternative formulation?</p><p><a href="https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2019/01/steven-pinker-slavery-enlightenment.html">Steven Pinker on slavery and the Enlightenment - Marginal REVOLUTION</a></p><h4>A short history of the creation of regions in Ghana</h4><p>I used to get really incensed that post-colonial nations maintained their colonial borders. Their national identity was a European fiction! But the more I read about European history, there really shouldn’t be Alsatians in France, Catalans in Spain, Cornish in England, or Switzerland.</p><blockquote>As part of the First World War, the British and the French took over German Togoland and divided it between themselves. The League of Nations, formed after the war, recognised British occupancy of its part which they called Trans-Volta Togoland and mandated them to administer it on behalf of the League.</blockquote><p><a href="http://www.myjoyonline.com/opinion/2019/January-22nd/a-short-history-of-the-creation-of-regions-in-ghana.php">A short history of the creation of regions in Ghana</a></p><h4>The Keys to a Great Rebrand</h4><blockquote>Before Spotify rebranded, it saw itself as a tech company… the company had tapped out most of its early adopters, who were into the music technology, and needed to make inroads with people who didn’t care for “engineered-driven language around music,” as Collins puts it.</blockquote><blockquote>“When you want to scale, you can’t just speak to early adopters; you have to have a broader, more popular language,” he says. “The aesthetic and the symbols Spotify was using all said ‘engineering’ when they really should’ve been saying, ‘Wouldn’t you like to listen to this great piece of music?’</blockquote><p><a href="https://99u.adobe.com/articles/61031/the-keys-to-a-great-rebrand-advice-from-the-duo-who-rebranded-chobani-and-spotify">The Keys to a Great Rebrand: Advice From the Duo Who Revamped Chobani and Spotify</a></p><h4>The Media Botched the Covington Catholic Story</h4><p>An under-argued approach to many controversies is to point out that leaders and institutions fail to live up to their own standards. Not that their critics’ standards are valid and everyone should make their critics happy. But by their own stated commitment to integrity, the NYT and many others failed.</p><blockquote>How could the elite media — <em>The New York Times</em>, let’s say — have protected itself from this event, which has served to reinforce millions of Americans’ belief that traditional journalistic outlets are purveyors of “fake news?” It might have hewed to a concept that once went by the quaint term “journalistic ethics.” Among other things, journalistic ethics held that if you didn’t have the reporting to support a story, and if that story had the potential to hurt its subjects, and if those subjects were private citizens, and if they were moreover minors? You didn’t run the story.</blockquote><p><a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/01/media-must-learn-covington-catholic-story/581035/">The Media Botched the Covington Catholic Story</a></p><h4>What would actually put more working-class people in office?</h4><p>Very few revolutionary leaders were working class. Successful firebrands are almost always disgruntled elites. Robespierre was a lawyer. George Danton was a dyslexic lawyer. Lenin’s father was a regional primary school director. Mao’s was one of the wealthiest farmers in Shaoshan. Stalin was unusually raised in poverty by was the first in his family to go to school.</p><blockquote>When party leaders look for new talent, they often look to their own friends and acquaintances. And since most party officials are well off, they usually don’t have many working-class people in their social networks…</blockquote><blockquote>If we don’t pay politicians enough, the story goes, only rich people will be able to afford to hold office. And if elections were publicly financed, more working-class people could afford to run.</blockquote><blockquote>But working-class people don’t run because they can’t afford to take time off to campaign, not because the salary for winners is too low.</blockquote><p>File under: the crisis of liberalism is the cultural, geographic and economic segregation of the upper-middle class from everyone else.</p><p><a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2019/01/22/what-would-actually-put-more-working-class-people-in-office/">Analysis | What would actually put more working-class people in office?</a></p><h4>So you think you know diet?</h4><p>If you read Marginal Revolution, you know how hard it is for Tyler Cowen to outright <em>say</em> something. But this time he does, and he’s not the only one.</p><blockquote>People, I am not trying to claim this is true! As is so often the case, I am trying to confuse you and persuade you that maybe you know less than you think.</blockquote><p><a href="https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2019/01/think-know-diet.html">So you think you know diet? - Marginal REVOLUTION</a></p><h4>The Right Needs To Grow Up On Environmentalism</h4><p>Don’t forget the Burkean impulse to not just explode complex systems!</p><blockquote>Conservatives believe — or ought to believe — in low time preferences, prudence and restraint, the fragility of order, and the love of home. The Left’s apparent use of environmental matters as Trojan horses for egalitarian and internationalist ambitions has no doubt raised hackles on the Right but it is the all-but-unqualified embrace of free market capitalism, has led to an almost absolute abandonment of the field to the Left. Yes, free market capitalism has enabled growth and innovation, but it is also a force for presentism, insecurity and greed.</blockquote><p><a href="https://quillette.com/2019/01/25/the-right-needs-to-grow-up-on-environmentalism/">The Right Needs To Grow Up On Environmentalism - Quillette</a></p><h3>Watch</h3><p>The British Film Institute has kindly compiled the best of video essays of 2018</p><blockquote>When a new movie is released, the odds are stacked against audiovisual critics. Before they can engage with the material they have to wait for the movie to find its way onto a streaming service or for it to be released on DVD or Blu-ray. This inescapable delay is frustrating… but it is also a blessing. It is an incubation period that allows opinions to ferment and that makes the video essay a form of slow, sustainable criticism.</blockquote><p>I’m not even only half way through but here are some highlights:</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EVQflnGcx4k"><strong>Disney, The Magic of Animation</strong></a> <em>Kaptainkristain</em></p><p><a href="https://vimeo.com/234536729"><strong>PlayTime, Controlled Chaos</strong></a> <em>Andrew Saladino (The Royal Ocean Film Society)</em></p><p><a href="https://youtu.be/akaPSGMi03k"><strong>Comparing Every Version of A Star Is Born</strong></a> <em>Be Kind Rewind</em></p><p><a href="https://vimeo.com/251237497"><strong>Based on a True Story</strong></a> <em>Zackery Ramos-Taylor</em></p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cL31rRUMRUY"><strong>Why James Bond sounds like James Bond</strong></a> <em>Dan Golding</em></p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyx7YRU4trs"><strong>Michael Bay: Understanding A True American Auteur</strong></a> <em>Patrick H Willems</em></p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vv9mL0YjUiE"><strong>Kiki’s Delivery Service: The Millennial Starving Artist</strong></a> <em>Debra Minoff &amp; Susannah McCullough (ScreenPrism)</em></p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kavxsXhzD48"><strong>See With Your Ears: Spielberg and Sound Design</strong></a> <em>Evan Puschak (The Nerdwriter)</em></p><p>Watch them all here</p><p><a href="https://www.bfi.org.uk/news-opinion/sight-sound-magazine/polls-surveys/best-video-essays-2018">The best video essays of 2018 | Sight &amp; Sound</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dc7a3aafde21" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Best of 2018 Online]]></title>
            <link>https://surelyknott.medium.com/best-of-2018-online-41f0024a8f59?source=rss-7746e8fb75de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/41f0024a8f59</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[best-of-2018]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meaning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[productivity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[star-wars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[SurelyKnott]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 31 Dec 2018 04:59:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-31T04:59:54.268Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There’s no shortage of good things to read, the trick is finding them. Here are the most interesting, enjoyable or teachable articles I read this year, and why they matter.</p><p>In a rare break from precedent, I endorse all of these links.</p><h3>We Live in the Tail End</h3><p>This year has been more real than most that we have strictly finite time to do what we can with our lives. Wait But Why gives one of the best accounts of that feeling I’ve read:</p><blockquote>I’m 34, so let’s be super optimistic and say I’ll be hanging around drawing stick figures till I’m 90. If so, I have a little under 60 winters left… as weird as it seems, I might only go in the ocean 60 more times…</blockquote><blockquote>I read about five books a year, so even though it feels like I’ll read an endless number of books in the future, I actually have to choose only 300 of all the books out there to read and accept that I’ll sign off for eternity without knowing what goes on in all the rest.</blockquote><p>What does this mean?</p><blockquote><strong>1) Living in the same place as the people you love matters. </strong>I probably have 10X the time left with the people who live in my city as I do with the people who live somewhere else.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>2) Priorities matter. </strong>Your remaining face time with any person depends largely on where that person falls on your list of life priorities. Make sure this list is set by you — not by unconscious inertia.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>3) Quality time matters. </strong>If you’re in your last 10% of time with someone you love, keep that fact in the front of your mind when you’re with them and treat that time as what it actually is: precious.</blockquote><p><a href="https://waitbutwhy.com/2015/12/the-tail-end.html">https://waitbutwhy.com/2015/12/the-tail-end.html</a></p><h3>Amazon Knows the Value of Time</h3><p>I can’t stop thinking about this off-hand remark from Amazon’s first strategic analyst. The whole article is excellent and timely, but this quote is a dense thicket of behavioural insights and life advice:</p><blockquote>Our first attempt to address this was to show, in the shopping cart and checkout process, that even after paying shipping, customers were saving money over driving to their local bookstore to buy a book…</blockquote><blockquote>People didn’t care about this rational math. People, in general, are terrible at valuing their time… Wealthy people tend to receive a much more direct and immediate payoff for their time which is why… the first thing that most ultra-wealthy people I know do upon becoming ultra-wealthy is to hire a driver and start to fly private.</blockquote><p><a href="http://www.eugenewei.com/blog/2018/5/21/invisible-asymptotes">http://www.eugenewei.com/blog/2018/5/21/invisible-asymptotes</a></p><h3>Postmortem of a Youtube Channel</h3><p>Every Frame A Painting was a goddam, 65 million views phenomenon. <br>Go <a href="https://www.youtube.com/user/everyframeapainting/videos">watch all</a> 28 video essays right now, it’s an education in film making. Start with <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8q4X2vDRfRk">The Spielbeg Oner</a>, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1PCtIaM_GQ">How to do Action Comedy</a>, and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UWEjxkkB8Xs">The Art of the Gag</a>.</p><p>The channel wrapped up over a year ago but the hosts shared their reflections in 2018. Read the whole thing if you are a writer, learner, movie lover or you’re going to deliver that big creative project in 2019.</p><blockquote>Here are some habits we picked up while making essays. Take whichever you like, ignore the rest.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Keep a notebook</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Whenever you have an idea, jot it down (along with the date), then forget about it. The most important part of the process is to forget. Every idea seems amazing at the moment of inception, but once you sleep on it and check the notebook weeks later, you’ll find that your brain has already forgotten the weak ideas, but still thinks about the promising ones…</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Research offline</strong></blockquote><blockquote>A huge percentage of the Internet is the same information, repeated over and over again. This is especially apparent on film websites; they call it aggregation but it’s really just a nicer way to say regurgitation.</blockquote><blockquote>So go to the library. Read books. We cannot emphasize this enough: read books, read books, read books. Your work is only as good as your research, and the best research tool we have is the public library…</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Test ideas out loud</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Then we take that simple question and we test it out on real people — usually our friends (who are also filmmakers), usually over drinks or dinner. The key is to ask the question casually, as if we aren’t planning to make an essay.</blockquote><blockquote>The goal is to see if people react to an idea <strong>without us trying to sell it</strong>. Because if the basic idea is already interesting to people, it’ll only get better once we sharpen and hone it into a proper argument.</blockquote><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tonyszhou/postmortem-1b338537fabc">https://medium.com/@tonyszhou/postmortem-1b338537fabc</a></p><h3>Gattaca Part III: Edu-Gattaca</h3><p>I studied Gattaca in Year 12 and it’s still in my top three personal films of all time. I was absolutely delighted when Slate Star Codex discovered its two <em>plausibly non-fake</em> sequels. Such as how Vincent overcame prejudicial credentialism at edu-Gattaca:</p><blockquote>This time, we know how to identify truly superior human beings who deserve to be astronauts, no creepy biology involved. We’re going to base our decision on…what institution you spent four years in during your teens and early twenties!”</blockquote><blockquote>“Oh, <em>come on</em>,” said Vincent. “Can’t you just give up already and judge people on their merit?”</blockquote><blockquote>The supervisor pounded the desk. “Never!</blockquote><p>I think about this <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/08/opinion/sunday/wasps-meritocracy-ross-douthat.html?pgtype=Homepage">every</a> <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2018/12/22/ross-douthat-attacked-meritocracy-what-would-rousseau-say/">time</a> <a href="https://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/politics/the-problem-with-meritocracy-twilight-elites-review-hayes">the</a> <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment">internet</a> <a href="https://feministphilosophers.wordpress.com/2012/10/19/against-meritocracy/">blows</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/matthewschmitz/status/887010890020737024">up</a> about meritocracy. Education is not meritocracy. Meritocracy is the allocation of jobs, status and power in proportion to demonstrated ability to deliver better outcomes. Education is not demonstrated ability to deliver better outcomes.</p><p><a href="http://slatestarcodex.com/2018/06/19/the-gattaca-trilogy/">http://slatestarcodex.com/2018/06/19/the-gattaca-trilogy/</a></p><h3>Hugh Trevor Roper on the Crisis of the 17th Century</h3><p>This essay about the 1600s was written in 1959 but might has well been for the here and now. Please stop me if this all sounds too much like Brexit, Trump and democracy in a divided Australia.</p><blockquote>These problems, are not constitutional, they are not concerned with monarchy or republic, Crown or Parliament. Nor are they economic: they are not concerned with methods of production. Essentially they are demands for emancipation from the burden of centralization; for reduction of fees; reduction of useless, expensive offices, including — even in Spain — clerical offices; abolition of the sale of offices… abolition of heredity of offices; abolition of those wasteful, indirect taxes which yield so little to the Crown but on whose superabundant “waste” the ever-expanding fringe of the Court is fed.</blockquote><blockquote>Thus the tension between Court and country grew.</blockquote><p>The solution at the time, Roper argues, was assertive state intervention in the economy. What we might now call protectionism. You heard him, neoliberals!</p><blockquote>&lt;The city&gt; controlled the price of food and labour, limited imports in the interest of its own manufactures, encouraged the essential methods of trade — fishing and shipbuilding, freedom from internal tolls — invested its profits not in conspicuous waste or pursuit of glory, or wars merely of plunder, but in the rational conquest of markets and the needs of national economy: in technical education, municipal betterment, poor relief. In short, the city had recognized that its life must be related to its means of livelihood.</blockquote><p><a href="https://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/roper-the-crisis-of-the-seventeenth-century">https://oll.libertyfund.org/titles/roper-the-crisis-of-the-seventeenth-century</a></p><h3>Renewing Liberalism</h3><blockquote>Liberalism thus began as a restless, agitating world view. Yet over the past few decades liberals have become too comfortable with power. As a result, they have lost their hunger for reform. The ruling liberal elite tell themselves that they preside over a healthy meritocracy and that they have earned their privileges. The reality is not so clear-cut.</blockquote><p><a href="https://www.economist.com/leaders/2018/09/13/a-manifesto-for-renewing-liberalism">https://www.economist.com/leaders/2018/09/13/a-manifesto-for-renewing-liberalism</a></p><h3>The Origins of Western, Educated, Industrial, Rich, Democratic Culture</h3><p>Liberal individualism, which I’m a big fan of, may have its roots in the early church securing revenue from deceased estates.</p><blockquote>Part of the variation in these institutions arose historically from the Catholic Church’s marriage and family policies, which contributed to the dissolution of Europe’s traditional kin-based institutions, leading eventually to the predominance of nuclear families and impersonal institutions.</blockquote><p><a href="https://psyarxiv.com/d6qhu/">https://psyarxiv.com/d6qhu/</a></p><h3>Jacob Zuma is (still) no longer President of South Africa</h3><p>I was in South Africa when Jacob Zuma was elected leader of the ANC. In February he was removed from office after nine years as President. Even while liberal democracy backslides in Turkey, Hungary, Poland and elsewhere, South Africa continues its long walk to freedom.</p><blockquote>Now Mr Zuma’s days are numbered. He is expected to respond to the “recall” by February 14th… The ultimate option to remove him would be through parliament. A vote of no confidence is scheduled for February 22nd.</blockquote><p><a href="https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2018/02/13/jacob-zumas-last-stand">https://www.economist.com/middle-east-and-africa/2018/02/13/jacob-zumas-last-stand</a></p><h3>The Top List of the Top Lists of Books You Must Read</h3><p>When stuck for books to read (a rare circumstance), look no further than the amalgamated list of greatest books of all time. Culled from eight esteemed literary lists into one concise article.</p><blockquote>Surprisingly enough, there were 520 books from the 8 lists, which meant there was less overlap than I expected. 65 of the books were pretty straightforward as they were mentioned at least 3 times (with <em>The Great Gatsby</em> and <em>Catch-22</em> being the only 2 making it on all 8 lists).</blockquote><p>This year I’ve re-read Catch 22, which is hilarious, dark and rich. I first read it in 2007, and two things jump out at me now: First, the repetitive prose and circular logic underscore Yoassarian’s horror that every escape leads back to danger. Second, the text is laced with problematic, period-specific sexism. I look forward to how the upcoming <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catch-22_(miniseries)">Hulu series</a> will address it.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/world-literature/creating-the-ultimate-list-100-books-to-read-before-you-die-45f1b722b2e5">https://medium.com/world-literature/creating-the-ultimate-list-100-books-to-read-before-you-die-45f1b722b2e5</a></p><h3>Star Wars: Verraten</h3><p>Every so often I re-watch Empire Strikes Back with commentary by director Irvin Kerschner. His philosophy was simple: show real human emotion, fill the frame with the human face, and don’t undercut the drama.</p><p>The best new Star Wars material I’ve seen that embodies that philosophy is Verraten, a six minute trailer for the Old Republic video game. It tells a simple story about a mother and daughter, righting your mistakes, and it earns its badass fight scene.</p><p>What makes it super great? The pivotal choice is a matter of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X05TDsoSg2Y">left or right</a>.</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ENJ5rTkwYlA">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ENJ5rTkwYlA</a></p><h3>Rules for Life</h3><p>Living by our ideals is a constant struggle. Tamara Winter’s crowd-sourced recommendations are plain, buy I’m glad for any resource that gives aid and comfort in our endeavour. Reproduced in their entirety:</p><h4>Interpersonal and Mindfulness</h4><ul><li>Wake up early.</li><li>Spend time in prayer and/or meditation first thing in the morning. Or, if you can’t fit it in then, find time later in the day. I love using <a href="https://www.headspace.com/headspace-meditation-app">Headspace</a>. If you’re Catholic, pray the Rosary daily.<em> (Cam here: use </em><a href="https://www.smilingmind.com.au/smiling-mind-app"><em>Smiling Mind</em></a><em> !)</em></li><li>Practice gratitude, and be specific when thanking someone.</li><li>Keep a personal calendar.</li><li>Write something, anything, everyday.</li><li>Study a foreign language for 5, 15, or 25 minutes a day. Here’s a <a href="https://www.lingualift.com/blog/best-language-learning-apps/">list</a> of 10 great options.</li><li>Eat meals with people you love.</li><li>Keep in touch with close friends.</li><li>Read to your children, and take pictures of them frequently.</li><li>Read for at least 15 minutes daily.</li><li>Read or watch something new daily. Ideally something you’re curious about.</li><li>Ask questions often.</li><li>Don’t slouch.</li><li>Learn to dance.</li><li>Call your parents and grandparents.</li><li>Go on lots of first dates. Law of large numbers.</li><li>Introduce yourself to new people.</li><li>Before dinner, write down tomorrow’s priority list.</li><li>Restrict your tv time. Or substitute tv time for your most potent distraction. For me that’s Twitter. <a href="https://interestingengineering.com/11-easy-ways-to-reduce-your-screen-time">Here</a> are some practical ways to reduce screen time.</li><li>For young people, ask people you admire in your area for coffee once, twice, or a few times a month. Email is another option. The likelihood of a positive response in both scenarios is probably higher than you expect.</li></ul><h4>Finances</h4><ul><li>Negotiate your salary.</li><li>Practice making money online. For a fun place to start, try <a href="https://www.predictit.org/">PredictIt</a>.</li><li>Contribute early and often to your IRA/401(k).</li><li>Invest as you’re able to.</li><li>Save a predetermined percentage from each paycheck.</li><li>Pay off your credit cards monthly.</li></ul><h4>Health</h4><ul><li>Sleep 8 hours or more each night. Limiting your blue light exposure after sunset can also <a href="https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/blue-light-has-a-dark-side">improve your sleep quality.</a></li><li>Try not to use your cell phone in bed. You can also go even further, and put away your phone 30 minutes, an hour, or even two hours before bedtime.</li><li>Increase your water consumption, and whenever possible, drink it to the exclusion of everything else.</li><li>Reduce your sugar, carb, and processed food intake.</li><li>One way you can do this is by bringing your lunch from home to work rather than ordering take out. Added bonus: saving money.</li><li>When you do eat out, choose the healthier options.</li><li>When grocery shopping, check the ingredients of what you’re buying. Try to avoid processed foods with numerous and complicated ingredients.</li><li>Take the stairs if and when you can. If you live in a fairly walkable area, walk everywhere within a mile.</li><li>Don’t overeat — stop just before you’re full.</li><li>If you can, try <a href="https://blog.bulletproof.com/intermittent-fasting-guide/">intermittent fasting</a> at least once a week.</li><li>Exercise daily. Try exercises that you enjoy, otherwise it’s unlikely that you’ll stick with them.</li><li>Incorporate resistance weight-training into your routine.</li><li>Floss!</li></ul><p><a href="https://medium.com/@TamaraWinter/one-of-my-favorite-uses-for-twitter-aside-from-being-able-to-interact-with-brilliant-people-id-c2b8bd2c2bcd">https://medium.com/@TamaraWinter/one-of-my-favorite-uses-for-twitter-aside-from-being-able-to-interact-with-brilliant-people-id-c2b8bd2c2bcd</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=41f0024a8f59" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reading Roundup 2018–12]]></title>
            <link>https://surelyknott.medium.com/reading-roundup-2018-12-b36e73464b8a?source=rss-7746e8fb75de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b36e73464b8a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[links]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nudge]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[SurelyKnott]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 22 Dec 2018 01:39:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-22T01:39:42.679Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>As always, a link is not an endorsement.</p><h3>Read</h3><h4>Tyler Cowen &amp; Paul Romer chat Immigration, Orthgraphy, Kanban</h4><p>“I think we should talk about a trilemma for migration, which is three things, and we can only have two out of the three… One of the things we want is local democratic accountability for the officials in the government. The second would be equal treatment under the law. And the third is, in this jurisdiction, the ability to absorb large numbers of migrants, potentially numbers that are bigger than the existing population.”</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/conversations-with-tyler/paul-romer-tyler-cowen-economics-education-growth-979315047773">Paul Romer on the Unrivaled Joy of Scholarship (Ep. 55)</a></p><h4>Your Intuition Is Wrong, Unless These 3 Conditions Are Met</h4><p>How to develop good intuition:</p><ol><li>Train on something with rules and patterns that can be learnt. Chess has rules, the stock market does not.</li><li>Get immediate feedback.</li><li>Practice, practice, practice.</li></ol><p>Notwithstanding my previous recommendation to listen to <a href="https://medium.com/conversations-with-tyler">Conversations with Tyler</a>, Tyler’s conversation with Daniel Kahhneman is probably not worth listening to. Read this article instead, then listen to <a href="https://medium.com/conversations-with-tyler/paul-romer-tyler-cowen-economics-education-growth-979315047773">Paul Romer and Tyler</a>.</p><p><a href="https://www.thinkadvisor.com/2018/11/16/daniel-kahneman-do-not-trust-your-intuition-even-f/?slreturn=20181024205234">Daniel Kahneman: Your Intuition Is Wrong, Unless These 3 Conditions Are Met | ThinkAdvisor</a></p><h4>What the Sydney Opera House teaches us about Brexit</h4><p>Planning fallacy and optimism bias are my favourite biases. Among the best antidotes is to run a pre-mortem, Red Teaming, selecting an appropriate reference class, and opening a betting market.</p><p>“Alas, most British politicians are wary of seeming negative or timid about Brexit, for fear of implying the electorate was unwise. Instead, both government and opposition have embraced the goal of leaving while enjoying all the benefits of staying — hardly a clear-eyed exercise in spotting obstacles.”</p><p><a href="http://timharford.com/2018/11/what-the-sydney-opera-house-teaches-us-about-brexit/">What the Sydney Opera House teaches us about Brexit</a></p><h4>The Secret to Ant Efficiency Is Idleness</h4><p>Ask your self each week, how many people depend on me? How can I reduce my dependency tasks to, say, five.</p><p>“The reason, it seems, is that the ants were working in narrow tunnels where traffic jams could easily clog up the entire effort to build nests. So it helped if some of them took a pileup in the tunnel as a signal to suggest that they take a break.”</p><p><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/16/science/ants-worker-idleness.html">The Secret to Ant Efficiency Is Idleness</a></p><h4>Fallout 76 player begs Bethesda for the sweet relief of death</h4><p>There’s a broader point here about the ethics of human longevity.</p><p>“I’ve had to limit myself to more boring activities because I do not want my exploration, or the PvP aspect ruined by my godmode… what the heck am I supposed to do besides actually starting to make all content in the game trivial? I’m really frustrated and I have no idea what I’m supposed to do.”</p><p><a href="https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2018/11/23/fallout-76-player-begs-bethesda-for-the-sweet-relief-of-death/amp/">Fallout 76 player begs Bethesda for the sweet relief of death</a></p><h4><strong>Suicide is declining globally</strong></h4><p>The evidence all points to a general, global reduction in suicide. Do we feel that the opposite it true because it’s the leading cause of death in Australian 15–44 years olds, when it is most preventable and tragic?</p><p>“As people move to cities and the grip of tradition loosens, women have more choice about whom they marry or live with, making life more bearable. Leaving the village helps in another way, too. Because farming involves killing things, rural folk are likelier to have the means to kill themselves — guns, pesticides — to hand. …</p><p>Policy plays a role, too. When Mikhail Gorbachev restricted the production and distribution of booze in the mid-1980s, both drinking and suicide fell sharply. The collapse of the Soviet Union swept those regulations aside, and both drinking and suicide shot up again. Restrictions introduced by Vladimir Putin in 2005 are reckoned to have contributed to the recent decline. …</p><p>Suicide is surprisingly impulsive. A study of young Chinese women who had tried to kill themselves showed that three-fifths had been contemplating suicide for less than two hours, and one in ten for less than a minute. Of 515 people who had survived the leap from San Francisco’s Golden Gate bridge between 1937 and 1971, 94% were still alive in 1978 — which suggests that a suicide postponed is likely to be a suicide prevented.”</p><p><a href="https://www.economist.com/leaders/2018/11/24/why-suicide-is-falling-around-the-world-and-how-to-bring-it-down-more">Why suicide is falling around the world, and how to bring it down more</a></p><h4>Headspace vs. Calm: The Meditation Battle That’s Anything but Zen</h4><p>“Calm has topped the category in both downloads and mobile revenue since last December, with revenue through October at $50.7 million, according to estimates from mobile-data firm Sensor Tower. Headspace, now in second place, saw revenue of $34.3 million.”</p><p><a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/headspace-vs-calm-the-meditation-battle-thats-anything-but-zen-11544889606">Headspace vs. Calm: The Meditation Battle That&#39;s Anything but Zen</a></p><h3>Listen</h3><h4>Smiling Mind</h4><p>If you’re trying to relax more, I recommend Smiling Mind. It’s a not-for-profit mindfulness app with a pleasing Australian accent. I’ve used it for better sleep and very much enjoy it. I hope you do too.</p><p><a href="https://www.smilingmind.com.au/">Smiling Mind</a></p><h4>Political Research Digest</h4><p>Political research digest is a fortnightly version of exactly what it says on the tin. Matt Grossman at the Niskanen Centre interviews political scientists on their new research for the gentle summarisation of all.</p><p>For example, “<a href="https://niskanencenter.org/blog/how-americans-politics-drives-their-religious-views/">How Americans’ Politics Drives Their Religious Views</a>”</p><ul><li>All Americans become less religious in their youth but White Republicans and Black Democrats are likely to become religious when they start a family.</li><li>Politics drives religion as much as religion drives politics. After the election of famous Catholic Democrat John F Kennedy, Protestant Democracts and Catholic Republicans were less likely to attend church.</li><li>There is no neat distinction between atheistic Democrats and religious Republicans. Black Democrats are very religious. Only actively secular whites are strong Democratic. Passively secular and evangelical whites are strongly Republican.</li><li>Politicians lose support if they identify as an atheist. But they lose very little support if they instead say “I don’t currently practice a religion.”</li></ul><p><a href="https://niskanencenter.org/blog/niskanen-centers-podcast/">https://niskanencenter.org/blog/niskanen-centers-podcast/</a></p><h3>Watch</h3><h4>Thaler &amp; Sunstein Discuss Nudge</h4><ul><li>People approach an identical risk-likelihood very differently if it’s the status quo or not.</li><li>Partisans are divided more by facts than values. (Though I wonder how often facts stand in for values and inter-group status competition.)</li><li>Cass Sunstein isn’t that into food, is very into John Stuart Mill. Book on Hayek</li><li>Nudges include GPS, auto-enrolment in voting and food programs, calorie labels, default number of prescribed drugs (e.g. opiods).</li><li>Choice architecture is unavoidable. If you do anything you must design it. To not choose is just another choice.</li></ul><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FOwufv9667yw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DOwufv9667yw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FOwufv9667yw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/5b9c363543bd222df5e1abac3c19d035/href">https://medium.com/media/5b9c363543bd222df5e1abac3c19d035/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b36e73464b8a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reading Roundup: 2018–11–18]]></title>
            <link>https://surelyknott.medium.com/reading-roundup-2018-11-18-2740c99b2b9b?source=rss-7746e8fb75de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2740c99b2b9b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[recommendations]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[SurelyKnott]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 18 Nov 2018 03:26:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-18T03:26:25.424Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This year my link posting sustained a double blow. Facebook blocked apps like Buffer from posting to user profiles, and Instapaper locked the ability to highlight text behind a paywall. So I’m experimenting with a new way to share links.</p><p>This is a semi-regular series of my commentary on interesting articles, in the vein of <a href="http://slatestarcodex.com/2018/07/30/links-7-18-url-mountains/">Slate Star Codex</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@michaela_ep/september-2018-whats-news-in-education-c965c119cb23?fbclid=IwAR2VLuoshw5l56MfdJTgVM9dyIeJXg1q0UL-tFgk3xlgqPL7YBOUd_o5zN0">What’s News in Education</a>. As always, a link is not an endorsement. Like Marginal Revolution, many links are a comment on another.</p><h3>Read</h3><p><strong>What It’s Like Knowing You’ll Die of Cancer at 35</strong></p><p>Reader, I want you to take a moment to savor what you have and let go of what anger you may hold.</p><p>“What makes us change is when something is taken away from us that we feel entitled to. Our bodies are rented. This day is rented. Nothing will stay. And if we live from a mindset of “I am entitled to this,” “I deserve this,” at some point we get stuck trying to hold onto something that is not ours, that is no longer there, and have to change.”</p><p><a href="https://www.vice.com/en_au/article/pa9j5n/what-its-like-knowing-youll-die-of-cancer-at-35">What It&#39;s Like Knowing You&#39;ll Die of Cancer at 35</a></p><p><strong>Your Real Biological Clock Is You’re Going to Die</strong></p><p>Take a hard look at the end of your life and work backwards. How long do you have to do what you want to do? Maybe it’s to have kids, maybe it’s something else entirely.</p><p>“I hope someday my children can do the same things for their own children. Maybe I’ll see them do it, but maybe I won’t: If my firstborn waits till he’s 35, going on 36, to have a child, the way I did, my grandchild will arrive the year I would turn 71. When that grandchild finishes fifth grade, I’ll be due to turn 81. And that would be the first of my grandchildren.”</p><p><a href="https://hmmdaily.com/2018/10/18/your-real-biological-clock-is-youre-going-to-die/">Your Real Biological Clock Is You&#39;re Going to Die</a></p><p><strong>Jessica Hische: Tomorrow I’ll Be Brave</strong></p><p>There are no earth shattering facts here, only aid and comfort in the struggle to achieve work life balance.</p><p>“I’ve found that I’ve had to navigate away from projects with unpredictable schedules and clients who require late-night and weekend work because of their own mismanagement of timelines. I feel excluded from working on last-minute campaigns, which can be very lucrative, because I’m unbending in my boundaries about family time. I have to be more proactive about projects and pursue different kinds of work that can fill the gap left from high-pressure, crazy-timeline agency work.</p><p>I couldn’t imagine doing it any other way, though. I know that years from now I won’t have regrets over passing on a client project that could have been cool but would have insane regrets.”</p><p><a href="https://99u.adobe.com/articles/59945/jessica-hische-tomorrow-ill-be-brave">Jessica Hische: Tomorrow I&#39;ll Be Brave</a></p><p><strong>Preschool: I Was Wrong</strong></p><p>It’s hard to draw a broader lesson for researchers here. If you cram all the outcome measures you can into a study, the odds of finding a spurious improvement goes up. But if you only record narrowly defined measures, then you can miss important benefits such as these.</p><p>“Despite the earlier studies of achievement being accurate, preschools (including the much-maligned Head Start) do seem to help children in subtler ways that only show up years later. Children who have been to preschool seem to stay in school longer, get better jobs, commit less crime, and require less welfare. The thing most of the early studies were looking for — academic ability — is one of the only things it doesn’t affect…</p><p>Head Start seems to work for reasons unrelated to the ones that made people want to do it. Those people were still wrong, and this is still a good example of policy effects being difficult to predict. It seems to have succeeded by coincidence, not because “early childhood education” is a good idea.”</p><p><a href="http://slatestarcodex.com/2018/11/06/preschool-i-was-wrong/">Preschool: I Was Wrong</a></p><p><strong>Why Is the Fight for Free Speech Led by the Psychologists?</strong></p><p>Psychology isn’t scientific enough to have an exclusively empirical debate but, it is scientific enough that facts are very important.</p><p>“Behavioral science self corrects. Uncomfortable data and uncomfortable arguments have the power to force change. Given enough time researchers will converge upon the truth.</p><p>But all of this is true if and only if scientists are allowed to debate and investigate freely. Haidt et. al. are confident they can win the debate if they are allowed to debate.”</p><p><a href="http://scholars-stage.blogspot.com/2018/11/why-is-fight-free-speech-led-by.html">Why Is the Fight for Free Speech Led by the Psychologists?</a></p><p><strong>The Independence of Judges Reduced Legal Development in England, 1600–1800</strong></p><p>At face value, it looks like judges with tenure are cited less often because they issue poor rulings. But the authors argue that judges look out for each other by citing un-tenured judges more often, shoring up that judge’s standing.</p><p>“Tenure has a strong, significant, and deleterious effect on the quality of associate-judge decisions. Tenure has no effect for chief judges. The Act of Settlement reduces citations by 20% in the 18th century. The results are interpretable in terms of the incentives provided by a powerful legal profession that could protect vulnerable judges in a politically volatile era.”</p><p><a href="https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3260739">The Independence of Judges Reduced Legal Development in England, 1600-1800 by Peter Murrell :: SSRN</a></p><p><strong>The Winnowing of American Democracy: A Few Readings</strong></p><p>A short, well curated reading list about self-government. The quote is the part where I say: Yes and, capitalism trains the Il Duces to be bloodless financiers.</p><p>“Quadrennial contests over the imperial crown have very little to do with day-to-day democracy. Do not misunderstand: those contests are important, praiseworthy, and worth preserving. The reason <em>why</em> they are worth preserving, however, is little understood. The genius of representative elections is not that they encourage leaders to enact the popular will (the people’s representatives rarely enact such things), but because they are the centerpiece of a system that keeps political competition between the elites from escalating into terrible violence.”</p><p><a href="https://scholars-stage.blogspot.com/2018/11/the-winnowing-of-american-democracy-few.html">Pining for Democracy: A Few Readings</a></p><p><strong>Tribalism Isn’t Our Democracy’s Problem. The Conservative Movement is</strong></p><p>Goldwater and Nixon’s Southern Strategy continues to be the defining realignment of American politics. Debate rages inside me whether they were the cause or the effect.</p><p>“Back when the major party coalitions were more socially heterodox, there were far more “cross-pressured” voters in the electorate; which is to say, voters who identified with one social group that was typically associated with Republicans (say, Protestants), and one that was linked to Democrats (say, union members). These “cross-cutting” social identities made it far less psychologically difficult for such Americans to respond to their party’s failures of governance — or candidate selection — by swinging to the other side: At least one important aspect of their self-conception was already pulling in that direction.”</p><p><a href="http://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/10/polarization-tribalism-the-conservative-movement-gop-threat-to-democracy.html">Tribalism Isn&#39;t Our Democracy&#39;s Problem. The Conservative Movement Is.</a></p><p><strong>The Grapes of Path Dependence: The Long-Run Political Impact of the Dust Bowl Migration</strong></p><p>The title of this paper is so good I had to have a lie down.</p><p>“Hispanics living in areas with large Okie migrations in the 1930s are much more likely to have conservative social values and, importantly, to vote and identify as Republicans. Put together, these results suggest that the historical legacies of migration can have a strong and sustained impact even after nearly a century after the fact.”</p><p><a href="https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3258402">The Grapes of Path Dependence: The Long-Run Political Impact of the Dust Bowl Migration by Adam Ramey :: SSRN</a></p><p><strong>A Determined Man: World War I, Hitler, and the unlikely march to World War II</strong></p><p>So the piece argues, the post World War I fundamentals pointed to a negotiated, peaceful resumption of German influence. It was Adolf Hitler that caused World War II, not Versailles.</p><p>Hitler’s “own political tactics suggest the expansionary theme was <em>not</em> significantly popular. In fact, he found it politically wise to mellow and downplay this element of his thinking as he neared and then attained office. Indeed, for political expedience, he stressed his desire for peace in every foreign policy <a href="https://politicalscience.osu.edu/faculty/jmueller/HITPEACE.pdf">speech</a> in the 1930s. As Hitler <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Hitler-Joachim-C-Fest/dp/B007EQJJQE/ref=sr_1_2?s=books&amp;ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1541760717&amp;sr=1-2&amp;keywords=hitler+joachim+fest">put it</a> late in 1938, “Circumstances have forced me to talk almost exclusively of peace for decades.”</p><p><a href="https://warontherocks.com/2018/11/a-determined-man-world-war-i-hitler-and-the-unlikely-march-to-world-war-ii/">A Determined Man: World War I, Hitler, and the Unlikely March to World War II - War on the Rocks</a></p><h3>Watch</h3><p>YouTube is my Netflix. I don’t recommend it. But if you must, there are some gems you should enjoy while you’re logged out of Gmail.</p><p>Watch <a href="https://www.youtube.com/user/thugnotes">Wisecrack</a>. They unpack the themes and references in popular culture, it’s just fantastic. I highly recommend their episodes on the international relations of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cV_BTUGPg7U">Spiderman</a>, the Confucianism of <a href="http://www.wisecrack.co/shows/wisecrackedition/nier-automata/">NieR: Automata</a>, the loneliness of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rORIDYHOFTQ">Bojack Horseman</a>, the ethics of <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=stHk4_VePds">The Good Place</a>, and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZgQlwscDyus">Deadpool</a> being <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oK4c3Yw0JJw">Deadpool</a>. Their sub-channel <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCu6DDGoV21YhwSb5iWbriAw">Alien’s Guide</a> is just as hilarious and clever.</p><h3>Listen</h3><p>It’s a podcast. It will always be a podcast. I recommend that you listen to <a href="http://feeds.soundcloud.com/users/soundcloud:users:146429914/sounds.rss">Conversations with Tyler</a> this month and every month. Tyler finds interesting people, reads everything they have ever written and discusses the Straussian interpretation of their work with them.</p><p>Listen to Cass Sunstein defend the metaphysics of nudge and the quintessential American governing principle. Atul Gawande lay down the value of good check lists and human fallibility in the operating theatre. Dani Rodrik argue the qualitative benefits of industrialisation and why Lebanon developed liberalism before democracy but lost it in the 1970s. If it’s not clear by now, Tyler often considers his guests to be underrated.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2740c99b2b9b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Game of Thrones 6x06/07 — Breakers and the Broken]]></title>
            <link>https://surelyknott.medium.com/game-of-thrones-6x06-07-breakers-and-the-broken-1a326a9e2087?source=rss-7746e8fb75de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1a326a9e2087</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[television]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-of-thrones]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[SurelyKnott]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Jun 2016 07:56:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-14T07:56:57.814Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>.</p><blockquote>Spoilers for Game of Thrones up to Season 6, Episode 7 and all books.</blockquote><p>.</p><p>.</p><p>.</p><p>Episode Seven, The Broken Man, is a misnomer. The episode features not one but many broken men: The Hound, Septon Ray, Jaime Lannister, Jon Snow, Theon, Cersei, the list goes one. And there are countless more broken characters not featured this episode, including Ramsay Bolton, Samwell Tarly and Jorah Mormont. The show’s title could refer to any one of many broken people in any one of Game of Thrones many episodes. It calls to mind Tyrion’s empathy for “<em>cripples, bastards and broken things</em>,” and George R R Martin shares the sentiment.</p><p>The episode’s narrative through-line, however, is the Hound’s aborted attempt to rebuild himself. We first see him carrying wood for the citizens of a pious commune: a place so unlike the normally violent depiction of Westeros that the opening credits serve as a metaphorical wall separating the pre-credits Sept on the Hill (an allusion to Matthew 5:14) as compared to the post-credits world of Game of Thrones proper.</p><p>In this community the Hound discovers he is useful for more than just killing. Here, far from the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norman_yoke">Westerosi Yoke</a>, the people are wholesome, innocent. He reflects on his moral failings as a first step to consider becoming a better man. His redemption is cut short, however, when the Brotherhood Without Banners kill the settlers over some chickens. Their efforts to build a community without violence thwarted by the reality that life is nasty, brutish and short in Westeros. The Hound un-buries the hatchet and sets out to kill those who killed his friends —His chance to rebuild himself scuppered.</p><p>The failed redemption of the Hound contrasts with that of Septon Ray, the leader of the slain community. Ray was proof-of-concept that a murderer like the Hound could change. His saving grace was a non-denominational belief in the existence of “<em>something greater than us. And whatever it is, it’s got plans.” </em>For Septon Ray, the existence of suffering was evidence of a divine plan — if there were no divine plan, then that would mean suffering was for nothing. The logic is broken, however. It suggests that Ray himself may still a broken man. While the Hound rejects Ray’s beliefs, he is uncomfortable with the implications. Given time, prayer and some warm ale the Hound may have come around to Ray’s perspective, had the Brotherhood not hung the Septon in his church.</p><p>Utopian communes seeking to escape violence are common throughout history, and usually end the same way. In the aftermath of the English Civil War a sect of proto-agrarian socialists called the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diggers">Diggers</a> isolated themselves in closed communes, farming the soil and lived off of the harvest (hence the name <em>Diggers</em>). In practice, the Diggers were arrested by local militias, evicted for squatting on common land and, in some cases, their villages were burned down by arsonists.</p><p>Less radical were the Quakers, who founded the North American colony of Pennsylvania. Like Septon Ray, the Quakers were pacifists. In 1690, Quaker colonists were deeply torn whether to use violence against a gang of pirates attacking colonies along the Delaware River. Unlike the Diggers, Quakers were not driven from their land, as the Native Americans of eastern Pennsylvania were unusually peaceful. None the less, Quakers were out-maneuvered in the aftermath of the Revolution by more ‘militant’ sects like the Puritans. Unable to attract and retain followers, the Quakers tolerated themselves out of existence.</p><p>Septon Ray is a cautionary tale of a seemingly healthy, unconflicted man who was in fact broken inside. Although cheerful and charismatic, Ray was overwhelmed by a revulsion of violence, so much so that he rejected even justifiable self-defence. Pacifism is morally laudable but pragmatically dubious. Ray’s retort that “<em>Violence is a disease. You don’t cure a disease by spreading it to more people</em>” is a false syllogism — Historically violence has been cured by the threat of violence by an independent third-party (i.e. Government). The Hound may not have read <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leviathan_(book)">Leviathan</a>, but he recognises how unrealistic Ray is being. It underscores that an unwillingness to preserve your own life and that of others can be its own form of brokenness. Ray appeared strong but was in fact broken by the powerful.</p><p>In King’s Landing, the High Sparrow praises men like Septon Ray, while in practice they are nothing alike. The High Sparrow tells Margaery the honest piety of the common folk can be more insightful than that of those who memorise every word of the Seven Pointed Star. This is on the one hand a subtle dig at Islamic <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hafiz_%28Quran%29">Hafiz</a>, who memorise the entire Quran, but also a smokescreen. For all his talk of serving the people, it’s the thugs with swords and scars on their foreheads that maintain the High Sparrow’s power.</p><p>The High Sparrow is a Machiavellian schemer consolidating their power. His pious intonations that Margaery take to Tommen’s bed is pragmatic. For Margaery to birth a royal heir would consolidate the rule of King Tommen and the Sparrows’ architecture of oppression. So far, Queen Cersei has been imprisoned and humiliated in front of the city. Ser Loras is in prison on charges of sodomy, whose only release will be to join a monastery of penetants (because <em>that</em> could never a hot-bed of sodomy). And Lady Oleanna is under threat of physical harm. On all fronts the Sparrows are breaking down the will of their opponents — Septon Ray would be aghast.</p><p>The Sparrows’ success depends on breaking Margaery, but underneath the facade of a broken woman she remains strong. Margaery has always been strong. Margaery endured the humiliation of marrying the Renly Baratheon, whose homosexuality was an open-secret. She wed the sadistic Joffrey. She has navigated the challenges of being a noble woman better than most. Her survival always depended on playing innocent whilst thinking ten steps ahead.</p><p>There is reason to fear the Sparrows can break Margaery where others have failed. The Sparrows are, after all, strikingly similar to the proto-totalitarian Puritans. The Puritans who founded Massachusetts believed that in America they could “give up all freedom and individuality and art, and you can have a perfect society without crime or violence or inequality.”(<a href="http://slatestarcodex.com/2016/04/27/book-review-albions-seed/">1</a>) Indeed, when Margaery parrots that were Loras to accept the life of a penetant he would “begin again… as a free man,” it is this notion of freedom she has in mind. Historically, the Puritan colonies had near zero teenage pregnancy, the lowest murder rate in America, and, lest anyone think Puritans were anti-women, Massachusetts communities punished domestic violence <em>severely</em>.(<a href="http://slatestarcodex.com/2016/04/27/book-review-albions-seed/">2</a>) If anyone can bring Margaery from her perch among the nobles and down into the ranks of broken things, it would be the crypto-Puritan Sparrows.</p><p>The arc of Game of Thrones is for the broken become the breakers. The Hound once exuded violent power, until Arya broke him. Septon Ray was a soldier in a powerful army until the army broke his humanity. The Sparrows were downtrodden until they rose up. If they break Margaery it will be another phase in the cycle.</p><p>The story is driven by cripples, bastards and broken things. They have an interest in overthrowing the status quo; they are made strong through hardship; and, they can win because they are under-estimated. As the series’ end game approaches it looks increasingly like the wheel will turn once more. Unless Danaerys makes good on her promise to“break the wheel,” it shall always turn.</p><h3>Stray Observations</h3><ul><li>During shore leave in Essos, Theon’s sword is rested in a particularly phallic angle against the bar table. A sick joke, given that he’s gelded. However, Yara is setting him on his path to getting the Old Theon back, so perhaps it’s prophetic.</li><li>When Lady Oleanna confronts Cersei about how useless she has been this whole time, notice that the Lady of Highgarden is writing while she lambasts Cersei’s idiocy. Cersei pulled the exact same trick of writing a letter during her meeting with Lady Oleanna back in Season Four (Five?). Back then, Lady Oleanna called Cersei out on her amateur theatrics, whereas Cersei, who has learnt nothing, fails to call Lady Oleanna out on the same trick.</li><li>When Davos convinces Lady Mormont to back Jon Stark, notice that the blocking in the room is almost identical the the blocking when Davos persuaded the Iron Bank to lend Stannis money and troops.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1a326a9e2087" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Game of Thrones 6x04/05 — Love and Suffering]]></title>
            <link>https://surelyknott.medium.com/game-of-thrones-6x04-05-love-and-suffering-deb4409708ab?source=rss-7746e8fb75de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/deb4409708ab</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-of-thrones]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[romanticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[SurelyKnott]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 31 May 2016 01:52:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-05-31T01:52:22.289Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>.</p><blockquote>Spoilers for Game of Thrones up to Season 6, Episode 5 and all books.</blockquote><p>.</p><p>.</p><p>.</p><p>Undoubtedly the greatest twist in Game of Thrones season six thus far is the revelation that the Stark’s aphasic servant Hodor was mentally crippled at a young age by a time-travelling Bran Stark. In a flight of panic, Bran Stark uses a psychic projection of himself to forcibly penetrate the mind of a teenage Hodor and in doing so command the adult Hodor, many years in the future, to sacrifice himself to “Hold the Door” against undead wights.</p><p>Hodor has become a tragic figure. The name “Hodor” has become a sad reminder that a teenage servant was mentally abused so that they, years later, would lay down their adult body to physically block a horde of undead wights.</p><p>This revelation has prompted considered debates about the<a href="http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2016/05/the-ethics-of-hodor/484643/"> ethics of disability</a>, whether Hodor is an <a href="http://asoiaf.westeros.org/index.php?/topic/140477-hodor-saint-christopher/">allegory for St Cristopher</a>, and whether we still find all those ‘Hodor-fication’ <a href="http://www.avclub.com/article/now-chrome-users-can-hodor-their-browser-208680">jokes funny</a>. A friend of mine argued that Hodor’s unwilling sacrifice underscored how unjust feudal society is. I think this is too narrow a point. Hodor’s death reveals to me the long standing question of Game of Thrones in general and this episode in particular: Why is there suffering at all?</p><p>Rewind Game of Thrones to Season One. Jaime Lannister has been captured by Robb Stark. Ned Stark has just been executed. Caitlyn Stark visits the imprisoned Jaime, who asks her “If the gods are real, and they are so just, why is the world so full of injustice?” Caitlyn has no answer. She can only blame Jaime “Because of men like you.” Jaime balks at the accusation, telling her “There are no men like me. Only me.” His answer to why there is suffering in the world is unsatisfactory, and it remains unanswered six seasons later.</p><p>This episode, season six episode five, reminds us that not only is there injustice and suffering, but that there are many ways to rationalise it. Arya Stark belongs to a cult of faceless men who kill low and high-born alike. Murder gives Arya a reason to live, so she can learn and one day exact revenge on those who made her suffer. But to do so she must create new suffering, murdering oyster sellers and theatre performers. They seem decent people, why must they die, she asks. Why should we create more suffering?</p><p>The Faceless Men asks Arya “Does death only come for the wicked, and leave the decent behind?” There is no reason for injustice because there is no justice or injustice. There is only life or death, and neither mean anything. These nihilists would see no reason to mourn Hodor’s abuse, disability and eventual death.</p><p>Not so far away in Meereen the followers of the Lord of Light take a completely opposite view. There is suffering and injustice, yes, but it all has meaning. Every wound and wrong doing is part of a divine plan. Tyrion Lannister is attempting to bring order to Meereen through the preaching of evangelical followers of the Lord of Light. Only Varys seems to appreciate the contradiction. Tyrion is trying to create ‘justice’ of a sort where people don’t murder each other. Yet the Lord of Light cares not for murder, all death is just because all is part of the grand plan.</p><p>The Lord of Light’s rationalisation of the existence of evil is as life-denying as the Faceless Men’s nihilism. Is it not so different to accept a young stable boy’s abuse, disability and death as part of a grand plan as it is to accept that same event as meaningless. In both cases the innocent have suffered unjustly. Neither the Faceless Men nor Lord of Light can condemn Hodor’s death.</p><p>There is a third way, between nihilism and all-is-the-Lord’s-will. The alternative is suggested to us by Jorah the Andal, whose character is motivated first and foremost by Love. Jorah’s every move is to serve the woman he loves. Love is the be-all-and-end-all of his existence. For Jorah, suffering in the service of love is meaningful.</p><p>Culture inundates us with motifs such as Jorah’s. The Beatles tell us that “all you need is love”. It is sung by Nat King Cole (by way of Moulin Rogue!) that “the greatest thing you’ll ever learn is just to love and be loved in return.” And, hard rock band KISS emphasis that he was <em>made </em>for loving you, baby, and you were <em>made </em>for loving him.</p><p>In films too, love is portrayed as our <em>raison d’etre </em>in The Matrix, Titanic, Forrest Gump, The Notebook, and Last of the Mohicans. Even Interstellar goes so far as to suggest “<a href="https://youtu.be/Rt2LHkSwdPQ?t=1m48s">Love is the one thing that transcends time and space</a>.” The subtext is clear, love is the new God.</p><p>Love’s primacy in culture is a recent development, only two-hundred years old. In his book <a href="https://www.timeshighereducation.com/books/love-a-history/416707.article"><em>Love: A History</em></a> author Simon May states that this conception of love as “itself the supreme Good; the creative source of all things; absolute Being; immortal; true; nameless” is the work of Romanticism (namely, late German Romanticism such as Wagner). Traditionally, an all-powerful feeling of love was reserved for God alone. In the 19th century, however, German Romantics replaced God’s love and love for God with human love and love for others as the heart of reverential, life subsuming emotion. This placing of love at the center of human existence is still with us. The next time you hear “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kR5YqaKLYWU">Love conquers all</a>,” you’re hearing line of thinking that <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Love_Conquers_All">runs from </a>Virgil and Caravaggio through to Terry Gilliam and Jorah the Andal.</p><p>Before Jorah met Daenerys he was the heir to House Mormont. He married a beautiful but fickle noblewoman who demanded an extravagent lifestyle. Jorah could not honestly provide such lavishness, so he turned to slavery to support his wife’s extravagant tastes. This ultimately led to his exile and meeting the then slave Daenerys, with whom he fell madly, predictably in love.</p><p>Jorah’s tale is full of suffering. Jorah himself suffered scorn and separation living with the woman he idolised but who would never love him whilst living in poverty. When Jorah turned to slavery he brought shame on his family and immense suffering on those he trapped and sold. Living in exile Jorah has suffered great physical and emotional hardship, not least of all Daenerys’ rejection. Now he carries a fatal disease.</p><p>Given his history of suffering, consider how Jorah might answer: “If the gods are real, and they are so just, why is the world so full of injustice?” His actions suggest that the answer is love. It was love that justified his turning to slavery; love justified his betraying Vary’s to become a devout Targaryen follower; and, love justifies his self-sacrificing behaviour in Daenerys’ service. “All I’ve ever wanted was to serve you” he tells her. Of course he does; service and sacrifice is the logical conclusion of his philosophy that places love at the center of human existence. There is suffering in the world, he might say, but suffering in the name of love is just.</p><p>This week “Book of the Stranger” offers three responses to the problem of evil. The Faceless Men propose Nihilism, the Lord of Light suggests everything is divine will, and Jorah lives his life believing love is the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_QZjJU-mtFU">answer</a>. I, personally, find all three of these answers unsatisfactory, and I suspect that is the point. As the young Sansa Stark was told many times “Life is not a song, sweetling. Someday you may learn that to your sorrow.” Game of Thrones is a work of fiction aimed at exploding our assumptions about fiction. Honourable men can be executed by ignoble kings, legendary swordsmen lose their hands, and those without power are abused, disabled and die for no good reason.</p><h3>Stray Observations</h3><ul><li>Episode Five was especially heavy with biblical imagery: Euron Greyjoy was baptised in the ocean, died and lives again like a metaphorical Jesus; The White Walkers were arrayed in Bran’s vision like the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse (as indeed they were arrayed at Hardhome last season); Hodor holds the door with his arms outstretched in a position of Christ-like crucifixion, and he’ll probably be resurrected as a wight as well; and, Jorah’s creeping Greyscale emanates from the part of the wrists that Christ was likely nailed to the Cross.</li><li>I speculate that Jorah’s quest to find a cure for Greyscale will some how cause a greyscale epidemic across Westeros. A plague would soften up the Seven Kingdoms before Dany’s invasion; a neat historical parallel with the Black Death that devastated Europe in the lead up to the Mongol Invasion. Also, a plague of Greyscale would mean Westeros is beset by raving, undead stone men in the South AND raving, undead ice men in the North.</li><li>It’s sad but sweet to watch Arya take the Bravosi Production of King Robert’s Death rather hard, yet she still has the humanity to recognise her target, the actress playing Cersei, is a decent woman. Compare that to the real Cersei whose response to a commoner flashing his genitals during her walk of shame was for Zombie-Gregor to murder the man.</li><li>Speaking of the Bravosi Theatre Troupe, it was a delight to watch the characters backstage. Australians may recognise the actor-playing-the-actor-playing Cersei is <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Essie_Davis">Essie Davis</a> (a.k.a. Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries), and the actor-playing-the-actor-playing King Robert Baratheon was <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_E._Grant">Richard E Grant</a>, certified best guest ever on <a href="http://www.abc.net.au/tv/enoughrope/transcripts/s1666103.htm">Enough Rope</a>. His most memorable line in this small part? “There are no small parts.”</li><li>In the books, Victarion Greyjoy is bringing Daenerys a fleet of ships to carry her to Westeros, and he has a Red Priest, Moqorro, in tow. In the show, I predict that Yara and Theon will perform a similar role by bringing Daenerys their ships ahead of Euron. Although Yara and Theon do not have a Red Priest in tow, the show has made it clear a Red Priest will still arrive at Meereen. The fact that the narrative changes between the book and the show have ensured a Red Priest still arrives in Meereen suggests that they will be important going forward.</li><li>It’s revealed that the Children of the Forest created the first White Walker under the branches of a Weirwood tree, surrounded by rings of Stonehenge-esque pillars. Although I’m clearly reading too much into it, I like that the stone pillars make a vortex pattern with the Weirwood at the ‘eye’ of the vortex. The man chained up in the ‘eye’ of the vortex becomes a White Walker when their ‘eyes’ turn deep blue. An eye for and eye.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=deb4409708ab" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Game of Thrones 6x03 — Oath keeping]]></title>
            <link>https://surelyknott.medium.com/game-of-thrones-6x03-oath-keeping-7a3d5fa622ca?source=rss-7746e8fb75de------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7a3d5fa622ca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[got]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feudalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[game-of-thrones]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[SurelyKnott]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 May 2016 12:51:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-05-16T12:51:21.183Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>“I’ve always agreed with William Faulkner — he said that the human heart in conflict with itself is the only thing worth writing about.” — George RR Martin</blockquote><p>Oaths are the lynch-pin of feudal Westerosi society. Compared to the anarchic Free Folk, slave masters of Essos, and canonical thugs of the Faith Militant, a society based on oaths looks positively safe and orderly. However, the episode “Oathbreaker” demonstrates how untenable feudalism is when oaths are made in opposition to the desires of the human heart. Oath breaking damages the feudal apparatus for generations. Our heroes are still working through the consequences of their fore-father’s disloyalty, whilst committing treason of their own.</p><p>This week’s eponymous oath breaker is Jon Snow, who handed in his Lord Commander’s cape to declare “my watch has ended.” In doing so, he directly repudiated his sworn oath that “<em>Night gathers, and now my watch begins. It shall not end until my death</em>.” Some may argue that Jon is technically not an oath breaker because he swore to serve until death. Jon has died, so now his watch ended.</p><p>The status of Jon Snow’s oath breaking is not clear cut. Firstly, in the books Jon repudiated his vows <em>before</em> he was murdered. Book Jon was marshaling Wildlings to march on Winterfell minutes before he was stabbed to death.</p><p>Secondly, TV Jon Snow’s resurrection is a loophole. Westerosi nobles rely on Watchmen serving until death as a mechanism to manage inheritance without resorting to murder. If Samwell Tarly had not sworn to “ <em>take no wife, hold no lands, father no children” </em>his father, Randyll Tarly, would have killed him long ago. Jon’s disavowal of the oath, not to mention Sam’s oath-violating partnership with Gilly, may cause Randyll Tarly to wonder if perhaps he should murder Samwell.</p><p>Thirdly, the Watch cannot function unless Watchmen uphold their oaths. The oath denies men any power base with which to challenge the Watch leadership. The oath neutralises interests of family, lordship and status that may be contrary to those of the Watch. And, the oath creates a legal basis to execute mutineers. It’s therefore ironic that Jon executed Ser Alister Thorne for violating an oath that Jon himself is undermining.</p><p>This makes a powerful case that, technicalities aside, Jon is the episode’s oath breaker. His refusal to re-swear the oath could well be the killing blow that destroys the watch. Granted, the Watch appears so broken it would benefit from a good euthanising. However, an oath broken for good reasons is still a broken oath.</p><p>Jon’s willingness to exit the Nights Watch on a technicality speaks to a more fundamental character shift. Last week I predicted that his resurrection would change him into someone more cynical, less compassionate. That may have over-stated things — One doesn’t need a supernatural personality change to feel betrayed by an institution that let twelve angry men stab him to death. None the less, Jon clearly no longer believes in the Watch. His heart is no longer in it, and an oath contrary to the heart’s desires is quickly abandoned. Even if Jon weren’t technically absolved of his oath, it’s likely he’d have quit the Watch anyway.</p><p>Jon Snow’s disloyalty creates a surprising contrast with Varys the Spider. This week Varys arranges a surprisingly honourable deal with Vala, an agent for the Sons of the Harpy: Reveal the financial backers of the Meereenese insurgency in exchange for passage to Pentos. There is absolutely no evidence whether Varys makes good on this deal or throws Vala overboard once the ship is halfway to Pentos. What’s more interesting is that whatever vow Vala made to help the Meereenese insurgency, in helping Varys she is breaking that vow because she cares more about her own son than the Sons of the Harpy. Once again the heart’s desires overrule an oath of fealty.</p><p>In Vaes Dothrak, Daenerys is entering a similar situation as Vala. We have just learned that when Khal Drogo died Daenerys was obligated to join the Dosh Khaleen, the council of widow Dothraki elders. Although I’m glad Dany did no such thing, it does mean that that the breaker of chains is, technically, the breaker of oaths. Daenerys may not have <em>known</em> she was expected to join the Dosh Khaleen, but it’s beside the point. The Dothraki enforce the Dosh Khaleen based on what <em>they</em> think, Dany has no say in the matter. Oaths don’t just exist on pieces of paper; oaths exist where people believe they exist.</p><p>A council of imprisoned widows seems barbaric, yet it’s uncomfortably similar to the Westerosi custom that babies are born into non-negotiable lordships. It’s an obligation with real consequences. The late baby Bolton never made an oath to succeed Roose as Lord of Winterfell. Yet the tacit obligation was held so strongly that it was easier for Ramsay to murder the baby than challenge the laws of inheritance. We see at Vaes Dothrak, in the North and at the Wall, it’s easier to kill a person than an institution.</p><p>Everywhere we look the rule-of-oaths looks positively lethal, yet the subtext of Game of Thrones suggests that the alternatives are even worse. This week Lord Umber requested Ramsay fulfill a basic obligation of lordship — to provide for mutual self-defence against Wildling invaders. The new Lord Umber doesn’t put much stock in the oath of the patricidal Ramsay. Therefore, their self-defence could only be assured through costly hostage taking and bluff calling. Poor Rickon has become collateral damage in a lawless tit-for-tat.</p><p>Not so long ago Robb Stark’s mere suggestion that Greatjon Umber would break an oath was a serious affront. Under Stark rule, an oath was a credible commitment — No hostages were necessary, disloyalty was punished severely. This suggests that although oaths may create perverse incentives, and although oaths may be broken, the oaths of yesteryear were superior to the lawless war of all-against-all under Bolton rule.</p><p>In the current setting it seems unlikely peace and feudalism will even be restored. However, Bran’s visions of the past are a glimmer of hope that stability and honour may be restored. Years before the narrative of Game of Thrones, Robert Baratheon and Ned Stark raised their banners in defiance of the rightful, but mad, King Aerys. The Seven Kingdoms were as ravaged by war then as they are now. Bran Stark has begun to appreciate that devastation through his visions of the Rebellion’s final days — when young Ned Stark rescued his captive sister, Lyanna, from Rhaegar Targaryen’s bodyguards. Although Ned was victorious in combat, he was too late to save Lyanna.</p><p>Casual fans may not know it, but when Ned rescued Lyanna he ended the Rebellion.</p><p>We know from the books that Lyanna died soon after in Ned’s arms. Her cause of death is unknown, but there is strong evidence Lyanna died giving birth to her child by Rhaegar Targaryen. According to fan theories, Ned promised the dying Lyanna he would protect her half-Targaryen child, who he named Jon Snow. Knowledge of Jon’s heritage would have sparked a second civil war to install the boy king. It would be chaos once again. Instead, Ned promised to keep Jon Snow’s identity a secret. He kept that promise because he loved his sister. And so, the Rebellion ended when someone, finally, kept a promise in concordance with their heart.</p><p>It is almost certainly going too far to suggest a series like Game of Thrones, which deliberately subverts fantasy tropes, could end with the realm reverting to peace and harmony. All Ned has shown us is that it is possible for peace to be restored when oaths are made in accordance with the heart’s desires. Whether such a state of affairs will ever come to pass, however, is too soon to say.</p><h4>Stray observations</h4><p>It’s interesting that this episode didn’t include Sansa, her sworn-sword Brienne of Tarth, Brienne’s loyal squire Podrick, or Brienne’s sword “Oathkeeper”. It’s possible that featuring them in the episode “Oathbreaker” would be like mixing matter with anti-matter.</p><p>Ser Alister Thorne condemns Jon for letting Wildling “murderers” through the Wall, yet the ranks of the Nights Watch are full of murderers, rapists and thieves from across the Seven Kingdoms. Ser Alister: a hypocrite ‘til the end.</p><p>Ramsay holding Rickon captive is risky. On the one hand, Ramsay can use Rickon to blackmail Sansa to return to Winterfell and legitimise Bolton rule. On the other hand, Rickon is a legitimate claimant to Winterfell whom disaffected Northern Lords can rally around. Every day that Sansa holds out while Rickon is alive weakens Bolton rule.</p><p>For fun, here are some oath takers and whether they were oath breakers:</p><ul><li>Jon Snow vowed to serve the Nights Watch until his death. Abandoning the Watch despite being very much alive: Oath breaker (in spirit);</li><li>Ser Alister Thorne, Othell Yarwyck, Bowen Marsh and Olly vowed to serve their Lord Commander faithfully. Stabbing the Lord Commander until dead: Oath breaker;</li><li>Samwell Tarly promised Gilly he would take her and Little Sam to Oldtown. Going to live with Sam’s parent’s at Horn Hill instead: Oath breaker;</li><li>Daenerys Targaryen, <em>First of Her Name, Queen of Meereen, Queen of the Andals, the Rhoynar and the First Men, Breaker of Chains, Mother of Dragons</em>, agreed to be Khal Drogo’s Khaleesi,* swore to uphold the customs of the Dothraki* and vowed to join the Dosh Khaleen when Drogo died.* Overthrowing the regimes of Slaver’s Bay instead: Oath breaker;</li><li>Varys promised Dom’s Mother she and Dom can sail out of Meereen with a bag of silver if she names the Sons of the Harpy’s financial backers. Letting them sail out of Meereen with a bag of silver: Oath keeper;</li><li>Dom’s Mother (probably) promised to not betray the Sons of the Harpy. Ratting out the Sons of the Harpy to Varys: Oath breaker;</li><li>Lord Umber told Ramsay to Fuck Oaths: Oath breaker;</li><li>Osha the Wildling promised to keep Rickon Stark safe. Allowing Lord Umber to capture Rickon, butcher Shaggydog and hand them to Ramsay Bolton: Must try harder;</li><li>Ned Stark promised Lyanna Stark that he would keep Jon Snow’s identity secret. Keeping Jon Snow’s identity a secret: Oath keeper;</li><li>Lyanna Stark promised to marry Robert Baratheon. Eloping with Rhaegar Targaryan: Oath breaker;</li><li>Rhaegar Targaryen promised Elia Martell to be her lawfully wedded husband. Eloping with Lyanna Stark: Oath breaker;</li><li>The Three-Eyed-Raven promised Bran he will leave the tree one day. Still waiting to leave the tree: Too soon to say; and,</li><li>David Benioff and D.B. Weiss promised a mature and exciting Game of Thrones TV Series. Giving us Ramsay Snow: Oath breakers.</li></ul><p>* No she didn’t</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7a3d5fa622ca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>