<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Shawn West on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Shawn West on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@swesty?source=rss-b1e29371e347------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 21:02:02 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@swesty/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Fixing West Point]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@swesty/fixing-west-point-54c2241022b0?source=rss-b1e29371e347------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/54c2241022b0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn West]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Oct 2017 16:41:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-19T17:37:49.981Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*38hBaqBKjWOa6wsUFPI_SA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Image: Stephen Chernin/Getty Images</em></figcaption></figure><h4>Improving the Academy is a community effort</h4><p>In 1861, at the height of the Civil War, liberal Republicans in the United States Congress took to the Senate floor to force a vote on an issue of imminent national security. The United States Military Academy at West Point, they argued, was a breeding ground for conservatives and turncoats. With 259 graduates, including Robert E. Lee, defecting to the Confederacy, and with the poor performance of conservative Democratic officers like McClellan, it appeared as though West Point was a prime contributor to the Southern war effort. Senator Zachariah Chandler of Michigan testified that West Point had “<a href="https://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=llcg&amp;fileName=058/llcg058.db&amp;recNum=228">produced more traitors within the last 50 years than all the institutions of learning and education that have existed since Judas Iscariot’s time.</a>” The Secretary of War, suspicious of what was being taught at the Academy, asked if the grooming of so many traitorous Officers was “<a href="http://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Journals/MVHR/25/4/Attack_upon_West_Point*.html#note8">a radical defect in the system of education itself</a>” and questioned whether or not the institution should be closed.</p><p>In 2017, following the public revelation of communist beliefs held by Second Lieutenant Spenser Rapone, a recent graduate, many of the questions asked in 1861 have resurfaced. In <a href="https://americanmilitarynews.com/2017/10/exclusive-former-west-point-professors-letter-exposes-corruption-cheating-and-failing-standards-full-letter/">an open letter</a>, Lieutenant Colonel (Ret.) Robert Heffington, Class of 1997, lamented, “a series of fundamental changes at West Point that have eroded it to the point where I question whether the institution should even remain open.” Col. Heffington and others describe a failure at the highest levels of Academy leadership to enforce basic academic, physical, behavioral, and Honor standards, a failure that has led to apathy and a sense of entitlement amongst the 4,000 Cadets at West Point in any given year. More so, it has demoralized Academy staff to the point where they now see their purpose not as gatekeepers or mentors, but as rubber-stampers in an institution that mechanically produces Army officers.</p><p>There is always room for debate on the West Point developmental model, and Col. Heffington raises some valid criticisms that need to be addressed. <a href="https://medium.com/@Doctrine_Man/a-cadets-perspective-1e22bc551989">Many</a>, including the current superintendent, <a href="http://www.usma.edu/news/Shared%20Documents/USMA%20Superintendent%20Addresses%20Open%20Letter%20from%20Academy%20Graduate.pdf">Lieutenant General Robert Caslen</a>, have responded thoughtfully to Col. Heffington’s critiques, but the air of resignation and lack of hope in his letter, from someone who very clearly cares about the Academy, demands more than a simple refutation of points. Unfortunately, the institutional changes that Col. Heffington would like to see, short of establishing a political litmus test for graduates, will not prevent another Lt. Rapone from graduating any more than the efforts of Republican Senators in the 1860s would prevent Southern sympathizers from graduating. The solution for those dissatisfied with stagnant Academy policy and the quality of recent graduates, then, is increased involvement in the admissions process.</p><p>Each year, roughly 13,000 candidates open an application to West Point. Of these, about 4,000 receive Congressional nominations (a separate application process itself). Of those nominated, only 2,300 candidates are deemed fully academically and physically qualified. Before accounting for those fully qualified applicants who choose to go to another university or service academy, the 1,200 New Cadets admitted at the start of the year represent about a 52% true acceptance rate. This acceptance rate, well above the 10% published rate, reveals a true lack of competition. Regardless of any directed vetting process to ensure applicant quality, anyone who meets the physical and academic baseline standard has a coin-toss chance of being accepted.</p><p>In theory, the Congressional nomination process is designed to ensure that service academy applicants, beyond surpassing academic and physical standards, possess the intangibles necessary for a successful military career after graduation. In reality, candidates end up filling out another online application which culminates in a 30 minute interview, often without the representative present. Additionally, Congressmen and women are generally keen to fill their nomination slots, as sending a high number of candidates to service academies is a point of pride for a district. This eagerness to nominate candidates results in 43% of Congressional nominees being unqualified for admittance, meaning that nearly half of all Congressional nominations are effectively nullified, further reducing competition.</p><p>Alumni, and especially retired alumni with a permanent residence, can have a direct and profound influence on the quality of future West Point graduates by making a concerted effort to identify and recruit potential candidates from their local area. Through involvement in sports teams, Scouting associations, school activities, and even business, Academy alumni should seek out those young men and women who display a natural tendency towards leadership, personal responsibility, and who show a desire for self-improvement. Beyond simply identifying and mentoring potential West Point candidates, graduates should also strive to serve as a bridge between elected officials and the service academy candidate pool. By volunteering to serve on an Academy interview board, liaising with an area admissions field force, or by ensuring that representatives know the baseline standards that candidates must meet, West Point alumni can directly contribute to the creation of a more competitive selection of applicants. Doing so ultimately results in a greater chance that deserving candidates fill the limited admissions slots.</p><p>The United States Military Academy also offers <a href="https://www.armytimes.com/news/your-army/2016/01/25/under-pilot-program-enlisted-soldiers-can-apply-to-west-point-in-one-day/">a direct admissions program</a> for active duty and reserve soldiers below the age of 22. The Academy reserves around 170 slots in each class for enlisted applicants who have the option to be nominated by their commander, rather than by a Congressman. It is a great disservice to the young soldiers in the Army that each year only about 100 of these slots are filled. The young men and women who are most deserving of a West Point nomination are most often the ones who do not believe they deserve it, do not know they qualify for it, or for any number of reasons do not want it. They may be hesitant to put in the extra time writing application essays, taking the Candidate Fitness Assessment, and studying for SATs and ACTs because doing so takes time away from their duties. Many leaders, whether noncommissioned officers, ROTC graduates, or Academy alumni, may be hesitant to nominate young soldiers to go to West Point because those soldiers do not seem mature or experienced enough to lead a platoon. Very few people, however, show up to the Academy immediately ready for such responsibility. The peer group against which active duty and reserve soldiers are competing is that of 17 and 18-year-old high school students. All these applicants will have four years in which to mature and grow before pinning on their second lieutenant bars. By identifying soldiers based on their strength of character and their potential for growth, rather than on their immediate readiness to commission, and by ensuring that those soldiers have the time and the resources to complete the applications process, leaders across the Army can extend their influence into the Corps of Cadets.</p><p>It is possible to argue that supplying good men and women into a broken system can only lead to apathy and disenfranchisement. What good, a critic may ask, is West Point going to do for a motivated young Cadet when the institution can barely enforce its own Honor code for football players? All people, Cadets included, are affected by their experiences. But the idea that a botched honor case can entirely demoralize the Corps of Cadets fails to account for the numerous graduates who, in the face of these scenarios, went on to attain Rhodes Scholarships, climb Mt. Everest, or get accepted to Harvard Medical School, as members of the class of 2014, 2015, and 2016 did — during the same period of time that Col. Heffington claimed to see corrosive changes degrade the institution beyond recognition.</p><p>There will always be institutional failures, not only at West Point, but in the Army and in the United States at large — it is unrealistic to expect that the Academy is capable of taking in any input and producing a phenomenal Officer. The strength of West Point, however, has always been its ability to provide motivated young men and women with the opportunities to challenge themselves while learning the difficulties of peer leadership and coming to grips with what it means to be a professional and an officer. These challenges are only ever effective when they are undertaken voluntarily, as they are every single day by the vast majority of Cadets. While there will always be room to debate the manner in which certain Honor cases were prosecuted, or what standards need better enforcement, and while some individuals will always fall through the cracks, the self-reflection and drive for improvement that turn Cadets into successful officers arise from a much deeper place than can be significantly affected by any institutional policy. Those who care deeply about West Point and its product, rather than lament what it has become, should seek to provide it with motivated young men and women who will make the most of the challenges it provides and make good on the Nation’s investment.</p><p><em>The points in this article are unofficial expressions of opinion; views are those of the author and not necessarily those of the Department of the Army, the Department of Defense, or any agency of the US (or any other) government.</em></p><p>Special thanks to JY, GH, TM, SV, CW, NM, AB, RP, and MS for assistance in editing and revising.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=54c2241022b0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conventional Leadership]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@swesty/conventional-leadership-5093cc02dcd5?source=rss-b1e29371e347------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5093cc02dcd5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[military]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn West]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Aug 2016 21:34:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-15T17:30:33.988Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6uzhxa7SsSfIf9cYAuzcSA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Terror overcomes the former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff as he gazes upon the daily news. (Win McNamee/Getty Images)</figcaption></figure><h4><em>Despite the outrage, we could learn a thing or two from generals at conventions.</em></h4><p>I found out that I had a bad attitude following a summer training exercise. My parents were right the whole time.</p><p>That summer, I had been acting Platoon Sergeant and was sitting down with my company First Sergeant to receive my close out counseling. Our final platoon level raid had been a small disaster by my measure and naturally the reason why became a point of discussion. I had my excuses ready. First, my Platoon Leader had <a href="http://www.newsmax.com/Politics/GenFlynn-Obama-Trump-Intelligence/2016/07/13/id/738417/">never consulted me during planning</a>, and second, it was a <a href="http://www.politico.com/story/2015/07/michael-flynn-drone-strategy-obama-white-house-120227">failed plan</a> from the start — our assault element would have to advance fifty meters over open terrain with no support by fire. When the execution time came, things fell apart in the way that they always do when cadets lead their first mission. If anyone had asked me for my help in planning, I thought, the operation wouldn’t have failed as miserably. My First Sergeant nodded in agreement.</p><p>“And what did you do to make it work?” he asked.</p><p>Kept accountability, made sure we got resupplied, managed the patrol base, MEDEVAC plan — basic Platoon Sergeant things, of course.</p><p>“Yes, those things are your job, but what did you do to <em>make the plan</em> work?”</p><p>I paused. Truth be told, I had done very little beyond what was required of my position. In fact, I had even vented my frustrations to some of my subordinates, actively undermining my Platoon Leader’s authority (an act taboo in military culture). I didn’t have a good answer for my First Sergeant, but despite my frustrations with the mission and my leadership, I understood the point he was making: my disagreements with the Platoon Leader’s plan never excused me from fully applying myself to the success of the mission.</p><p>This instance came to mind when I saw Generals (Ret.) Michael Flynn and John Allen take the stage at the Republican and Democratic National Conventions. As they took stabs at each other, their favored candidates, and the current administration, it was easier for me to side with the former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Martin Dempsey, <a href="http://www.npr.org/2016/08/03/488442470/gen-dempsey-to-fellow-officers-stay-off-the-political-battlefield">saying in a radio interview</a>, “The image of the American professional officer is one who is on guard for the nation, who is representative of all the people, who is subordinate to elected official, not the image of someone giving an angry speech at a political convention.” The gut instinct of many senior military leaders, dating back to George Washington, is an aversion to partisan political involvement.</p><p>At the same time, however, twelve American presidents have been retired generals and 59% have had military experience. As the the number of Americans with a history of military service dwindles, it becomes even more important for veterans to become involved in national politics. Many of America’s prominent politicians today such as Senator John McCain (R-AZ) or Representative Tulsi Gabbard (D-HI) have not only distinguished military records, but a decidedly partisan streak to their politics. Regardless of their political orientation, though, no one doubts that these veteran politicians have America’s best interests at heart.</p><p>True, Flynn and Allen have skirted the edge of what could be considered divisively partisan rhetoric — <a href="http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2016/07/18/lt-gen-michael-flynn-leads-convention-crowd-in-anti-clinton-chant-lock-her-up/">Flynn joining in a “lock her up” chant </a>and Allen implying that Trump <a href="http://www.politico.com/story/2016/07/john-allen-donald-trump-226479">has no credibility</a> because he never, “spent a minute in the deserts of Afghanistan or in the deserts of Iraq.” The generals should seek to minimize the negative effects of these comments by focusing further statements on particular policy recommendations to strengthen the United States as many other former generals such as Abizaid, Hagenbeck, and Shinseki have done and are currently doing. Diversity of thought in pursuit of a common goal is a strength, not a weakness.</p><p>The tragedy of Generals Flynn and Allen is not that they disagree about the direction that the country should take over the next four years, it is that these disagreements are cast as fundamentally irreconcilable rather than as different paths to the same end state. While serving on active duty, these officers undoubtedly faced tactical and strategic situations in which multiple courses of action were possible, each with their own benefits and drawbacks, much as America faces its own decision point in this election. As competent leaders these generals elicited feedback and criticism from their subordinates, some of whom surely opposed one option or another. Once the final plan was selected, however, Flynn and Allen would have expected the men under their command to execute it with audacity, regardless of any misgivings or disagreements they had during planning.</p><p>What America stands to learn from veteran involvement in politics is exactly what I learned from my time as a cadet Platoon Sergeant: that once debate has ceased, the success of the team becomes a matter of each individual’s willingness to give their fullest effort. Service is not about always getting one’s way, but about always finding a way to contribute (John F. Kennedy, paraphrased). Whether one disagrees with the emplacement of a support by fire unit or a Supreme Court ruling, there are always ways to give back to the community and the country. This is especially true for our general grade officers who have a wealth of both experience and information to share.</p><p>Despite the appeal of a united America, it is important to remember that the American public is not a military organization. Americans are not duty-bound to fall in line and cease discussion once the results of an election are tallied. Enthusiastic civil debate, the constant push-pull of progressive and conservative thought that divides the nation, is what allows America to take great leaps forward but also to remain grounded, and none of that is possible without all the passion and anger that is inherently present in our system of government and the obstructionism that comes with it. But these factors are already present without retired service members contributing to them. Our veteran politicians should seek to set a positive example in a vitriolic environment and demonstrate the professionalism and respect that characterizes the United States military.</p><p>Come November, either Flynn or Allen will have thrown their support behind a losing candidate and will be faced with three options: side with the obstructionists and try to undermine the elected president, try to contribute to the nation in some other way, or slip into a quiet retirement and disengage from the American political process. The example these generals set for America’s men and women in uniform and the message that they send to the American public will be a direct result of their choice. Hopefully, that message will be that participating in politics is encouraged, but not at the expense of the ethics and values that have earned the United States military the trust of its citizens. This is a message sorely needed today.</p><p>Oh, and that Platoon Leader I resented so much? I wound up writing her a letter of recommendation a few months later.</p><p><em>The points in this article are unofficial expressions of opinion; views are those of the author and not necessarily those of the Department of the Army, the Department of Defense, or any agency of the US (or any other) government.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5093cc02dcd5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Killing People]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@swesty/killing-people-ff04fcf4f5f0?source=rss-b1e29371e347------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ff04fcf4f5f0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[purpose]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[futureofwar-series]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn West]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2015 00:32:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-11-11T21:10:15.592Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The American military must not succumb to intellectual shortcuts concerning its purpose.</p><p>About a month ago I sent my mother an unsolicited late-night phone call. I consider it the mark of adulthood that one can provide for oneself at the bare minimum, so I had to swallow a little bit of my pride in asking my parents for a favor. Of the many worst-case scenarios that could have passed through my mother’s mind as she answered her cell phone, I’m sure that the last thing she expected me to ask was, “Mom, what’s your cable account information? I’m stuck in a hotel and need to stream the Fox News GOP debate.” As a conscientious objector to cable television, I had never needed an account before.</p><p>From my admittedly unprofessional analysis of the debate, peak applause was achieved in response to Governor Mike Huckabee’s comment, regarding the handling of transgender troops that, “The purpose of the military is to kill people and break things.” Although he would later add “protect[ing] every American,” to that job description, it was clear which statement resonated with the audience.</p><p>I can forgive Governor Huckabee for such an oversimplification. Having earned his living as a pastor and a politician (who, I assume, has never killed anyone and most likely avoids breaking things on a regular basis), this grossly reductionist view of the <a href="http://www.gallup.com/poll/1597/confidence-institutions.aspx">most trusted institution in the United States </a>served as a politically expedient and effective means of minimizing sticky internal issues and appealing to the hawkish nature of those in attendance. If I were in his shoes, it would be too easy for me to say the same and earn a little political capital. However, I am not in his shoes. I am an officer in the United States Army and the people of my country deserve and should expect better from my colleagues and myself.</p><p>Major Matt Cavanaugh, a former artillery officer and Army strategist, excellently laid out the semantic and logical failings of the “oft-repeated and inaccurate maxim,” in a <a href="http://warontherocks.com/2015/08/the-militarys-purpose-is-not-to-kill-people-and-break-things">recent article</a>. Based on the responses the article generated, many people (including currently serving and retired service members) agree that yes, Governor Huckabee oversimplified the many functions and stated purpose of the military, but, they say, the spirit of his words rings true. This is a dangerous misconception that threatens to undermine our profession and our effectiveness.</p><p>An institution’s purpose, both stated and implicit, should ideally shape the behavior of its members. In the absence of any guidance, the lowest “ground level” employee of an institution should be able to reference his or her institution’s purpose in order to answer the question, “What should I be doing right now?” The significance of this understanding is easily revealed in comparison to another government agency:</p><p>The American Police Force at home serves in a comparable but by no means entirely analogous role to our Armed Forces overseas. Both institutions are granted a nearly full legal protection for the use of force in the advancement of their respective missions. The trust emplaced in these two institutions to coerce, restrain, and kill if necessary, is undoubtedly a unique feature which separates them from other government agencies, but a single-minded focus on these capabilities would inevitably produce undesirable results. Consider the consequences if a police officer considered his or her primary duty to be, “arresting criminals and shooting bad guys,” rather than <a href="http://www.nyc.gov/html/nypd/html/administration/mission.shtml">promoting the rule of law and securing the safety of the populace</a>. While at times these actions may be necessary, the officer who conducts himself in a manner reflective of the former understanding creates a functional gap between policy and practice, damaging the effectiveness of his institution.</p><p>A common excuse for this mindset manifests itself in any one of many, “That’s above my pay-grade”-style quips. “If our job isn’t to kill people, then why is every Marine a rifleman first?” These objections to a more holistic view of the military’s purpose stem from a conception of the military as an <em>instrument</em> of national power. Instruments, which have a limited number of capabilities, are meant to be used, usually with other instruments as well, by intelligent individuals to achieve a greater purpose. As such, it is not a significant mental leap to assume that, as an instrument of national power, the military should be proficient in its primary capability (the killing of others and the breaking of things) and simply guided by America’s policy makers, as a carpenter would guide a hammer. This conception breaks apart once one realizes that the American military is composed of human beings, not hammers. Perhaps in an era where battalions and regiments were wheeled across open battlefields like massive, rigid firing platforms, or perhaps in some unforeseen conventional battle of the future, we could conceive of the soldier as an instrument. But this is no longer the case. The modern battlefield demands that each serviceman is more than just a cog in some massive machine, that he or she is also a set of eyes, a decision maker, a second-guesser, an expert, an active listener, a historian, a scientist, an investigator, a killer, and a negotiator as the situation demands. Rather than acting as a hammer, it is perhaps more accurate to view our military as the carpenter himself, capable of using multiple tools and techniques to address multiple problems, and to view our military policy as the job he is given.</p><p>This is the new challenge our military and our politicians must grapple with. Former Deputy Director of the CIA Michael Morell writes in his book, <em>The Great War of Our Time</em>, that the enemies America faced in the past were, “easy to find and hard to kill.” Now, that paradigm has completely switched. The enemy wears civilian garb. Ideas spread across the internet faster than at any time in history. Despite our best technologies and efforts, Usama bin Laden was able to hide for over a decade while actively micromanaging al Qa’ida operations. By mentally fixating on killing people and breaking things, we are focusing on the easiest part of our job. We are the tennis player who only practices forehands. We are the doctor who can stop the bleeding but cannot reconnect the nerves. We are the musician who can read notes but is incapable of improvisation. The rifle in your hand, the notebook in your pocket, the muscles in your legs, and the radio on your back — these are the instruments of national policy. As a member of the most powerful military in the history of the world, you are more than that. You bridge the gap between instruments and policy and must act accordingly.</p><p>This is a lot to ask of the young men and women who form the ranks of our front lines. Perhaps it would be better to let our military focus on kinetic operations and to leave the ancillary tasks to the State Department or Joint Special Operations Command. This is a strategy. Or, better yet, we can deploy our military, let them wreak havoc, and then let the local government pick up the pieces with a strongly worded warning that the next time they decide to act up, things will be worse. This is also a strategy. Both of these approaches, unfortunately, present their own problems. In the first case, the State Department and JSOC lack the manpower to effectively deliver policy and intent to the sheer number of competing individuals, tribes, and factions that comprise the modern area of operations. As it stands, the Department of Defense is the only agency with the treasure, the population, and the physical connection between America and other countries or non-state actors to effectively do so. In the second case, the “fix yourself before we do it for you” attitude is precisely the process of deciding what <em>not </em>to break. Could we have left Saddam’s institutions in place and forced him, or his deputies, to host supervised and fair elections for the next decade? Maybe. Could we have invaded Afghanistan and told the Taliban, as morally reprehensible as they are, “We’re just here for al Qa’ida. If you harbor them, we will destroy you, if you hand them over, we will leave you be.”? <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/world/2001/oct/14/afghanistan.terrorism5">We did.</a> Our enemies have seen our weak side in the unconventional wars of the last decade and a half and will undoubtedly try to draw us into similar conflicts. We can either pull the wool over our eyes and fool ourselves into wishing for another easy victory like Desert Storm, or we can accept that this is the new reality we face and make ourselves better. The relics of nations choosing the former path can be found in museums across the world.</p><p>There will still be critics. There are those who will say, “Everything we do ultimately serves the purpose of making it easier to kill our enemies.” This is a mental shortcut that can be applied to nearly all outcomes of military action. Everything we do serves the purpose of occupying territory or denying it to our enemies. Everything we do serves the purpose of ending combat operations. Everything we do serves the purpose of getting back for a hot meal and away from Meals-Ready-to-Eat. The real damage of this critique, though, is not its logical shortcomings, but rather the implication it makes that if we are good at killing people, we will be successful. If this were true, a young female West Point graduate deployed to Afghanistan in 2007 would have never thought to ask <a href="http://www.newsweek.com/2013/08/16/human-terrain-system-sought-transform-army-within-237818.html">why the Haqqani network primarily recruited the sons of widows</a>, an insight that would significantly cut recruitment in her area of operations. In order to win complex wars, we need to avoid any train of thought that unnecessarily narrows our focus. We understand now that even if we are fully capable of killing a lot of people and breaking a lot of things, this does not guarantee us a quick and easy victory and in fact may generate more threats to our national security. This truism is almost as old as war itself, still taught to this day in the ancient Greek myth of the Hydra.</p><p>There will always be a place for the critics, for the ones who cannot accept that the gap between policy and practice has shrunken from the distance between Washington D.C. and the general’s command post to the distance between a soldier’s mind and his trigger finger. Perhaps that place will be on some future battlefield, as I said earlier, where futuristic tanks clash in the Fulda Gap, or where mariners unleash swarms of drones to dive-bomb ships in the Pacific. But for now, the critics’ place is under the supervision of intelligent noncommissioned and commissioned officers capable of using them for what they wish to be — instruments — Officers and NCOs who understand that wars are battles of will before they are tallies of the dead.</p><p><em>The points in this article are unofficial expressions of opinion; views are those of the author and not necessarily those of the Department of the Army, the Department of Defense, or any agency of the US (or any other) government.</em></p><p><em>Special thanks to IDM, JJ, RW, SA, and MC for assistance in editing and revising.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ff04fcf4f5f0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Everyone is Missing the Point About American Sniper]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@swesty/everyone-is-missing-the-point-about-american-sniper-f5c0f8834106?source=rss-b1e29371e347------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f5c0f8834106</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[american-sniper]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[west-point]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Shawn West]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Jan 2015 04:51:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-02-08T15:19:45.329Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Everyone Is Missing the Point About American Sniper</h3><p><em>The debate about Chris Kyle is damaging the film’s message</em></p><p>As with most points of contention in modern American discourse, <em>American Sniper</em> finds itself sandwiched between two vocal factions, both of which manage to completely miss the point. On one side, critics arm themselves with snippets about the <a href="http://www.salon.com/2015/01/23/7_enormous_lies_american_sniper_is_telling_america_partner/">aftermath of hurricane Katrina</a> and bar fights from a book that they have never read. They condemn the careless dehumanization of Iraqis in the film while simultaneously lending the same flattening treatment to Chris Kyle, labeling him a psychotic, pathological liar. On the other hand, patriots flock, in typical American fashion, to the defense of a hero who not only had the guts and the determination to do what he needed to, but also the intestinal fortitude to tell anyone who would disagree with his methods to go screw themselves. The viewer’s response, predictably, tends to fall neatly along political lines. I think that this division reflects something more than politics, though. It begins to highlight what the viewers are afraid of — because believe me, you don’t get this kind of response unless someone is scared.</p><p>I think that we have one sect of America that is scared to admit the existence of true evil. They don’t believe that it is out there, and as such they <a href="http://www.sott.net/article/291749-American-Sniper-or-American-psycho">criticize Kyle for referring to Iraqis as savages</a>. Or maybe they are worried about what the process of dehumanizing our enemies does to our fighting men and women. You will see them use words like, “complexity,” “<a href="http://www.salon.com/2015/02/01/i_was_an_american_sniper_and_chris_kyle%E2%80%99s_war_was_not_my_war/">nuance</a>,” and “fully realized human beings,” in their arguments. They do their best to paint Kyle’s black-and-white characterization of the conflict as overly simplistic, as if being simplistic is grounds for being wrong.</p><p>When I hear these criticisms, they remind me of a late night (or early morning) out on the training grounds at West Point. I sat next to a staff sergeant who had been tasked to train the cadets in infantry tactics — he had been a Cavalry Scout since before 9/11 and the disparity between his time in service and his rank reflected a history of alcohol abuses, insubordination, hazing, and marital problems. I remember the way he casually mentioned seeing Al-Qaeda campfires across a river where fighters had kidnapped underage girls, raped them, and then skinned them alive, leaving them in the dirt. I remember how the rain dripping off my helmet and down my back didn’t bother me so much anymore. The sergeant took pleasure in killing those guys. Hell, I would too. Later, we talked about how his ex-wife, while he was deployed, had been telling his daughter that her father is a liar, a sociopath, and an alcoholic, and now she doesn’t even consider visiting him anymore. A man fights to rid the earth of the horror he sees and when he returns, society must shelter his children from him. There is evil out there, and no one that goes to fight it comes back unaffected. In the very truest sense of the term, those that we send to fight evil sacrifice their innocence.</p><p>The other faction seems to fear complexity. Perhaps they are discomforted by the notion that for over a decade we have been sending good men and women to die in an unjust war, or that they ardently supported a war resulting in hundreds of thousands of civilian deaths (we may never know the true number). More accurately, though, I think that this sect is afraid of what they believe acknowledging complexity will do to our fighting men and women. From their articles, arguments, and less vitriolic comments we hear them shout, “You don’t know what it’s like!” or we see them invoke Colonel Nathan Jessup from <em>A Few Good Men</em>, who has neither the time nor the inclination to explain himself to those that sleep under the blanket of the freedom he provides, then question the manner in which he provides it. The problem with this take is that, by definition, it fails to accommodate the fact that the people we fight don’t necessarily hate America, or freedom, or democracy. We have learned the hard way over the last decade that the human dimension of our enemies is often the most important. Understanding that they may be fighting to help support their widowed mother, or that they may be launching mortars in protest of a contract that fell through has typically led to longer-lasting and more effective conflict resolutions than night raids and drone strikes. The positive effects of understanding the cultural terrain in which our military operates are heavily documented and widely supported. (While a topic in and of its own right, I would highly recommend Vanessa Gezari’s <em>The Tender Soldier</em> or David Kilcullen’s <em>Out of the Mountains</em> to the incredulous reader.)</p><p>So why would it ever be okay for a movie to over-simplify the lives of Iraqis? Simply put: It’s not. It’s not okay to ignore their situation — whether they are being victimized by extremists or killed in American airstrikes or by American snipers or being evicted from their homes. But our fighting men and women do “not okay” things all the time. They have to, because that’s how wars are fought. Is it “okay” for a lieutenant fresh out of college to order kids fresh out of high school to kill, or to die? No. Not for the domesticated, suburban mind. But by forcing the viewers to sit through something that is “not okay,” by forcing the viewer to see Iraq through that lens and then subsequently justify it, Eastwood grabs the viewer by the neck, throws them in the hot seat, and says, “This is what it’s like.” At least for some of us. This is what it’s like to rationalize. This is what it’s like to do it because you have to. The fact that going through that makes you uncomfortable, or disgusted, or angry, or swell with patriotic pride, or “hate muslims 1000x more,” as one Twitter user wrote, is exactly what needs to be done in a country where no more than <a href="http://www.mcclatchydc.com/2013/03/14/185880/millions-went-to-war-in-iraq-afghanistan.html">1%</a> of the population has served in the military over the last 14 years, not because those feelings are right or wrong, but because those are the same feelings that our veterans are coping with.</p><p>The viewer must remember that the American military is a cross section of the population as a whole, so the feelings of the viewer are undoubtedly reflected in a portion of the military as well. That also means that the feelings of your neighbor, or your Facebook friend, or that idiot who sits in class next to you are reflected in the veteran population, too. The emotions you feel when you watch a montage of five or six Iraqis gunned down on screen, without so much as a second thought, are a microcosm the same ones that many returning Soldiers and Marines are feeling. Knowing this, however, the viewers must be aware that at the end of the day, they are ultimately able to dissociate themselves from those feelings. After two and a half hours, we have the luxury of tearing <em>American Sniper</em> down, of rationalizing, of ignoring or enjoying it. This is a luxury that is not afforded to America’s trigger-pullers who have to live with their actions, inactions, and thoughts for the rest of their lives. This is a fact that escapes political definition.</p><p>Perhaps this is why America’s military has been uncharacteristically quiet about the film. While there seems to be healthy debate over whether or not Chris Kyle is a hero, there is an obvious dearth of dialogue on what this film means for the rehabilitation of veterans — you know, the purpose to which Kyle dedicated the last years of his life? I have not seen a single review mention the look on Jeff Kyle’s face as he redeploys from Iraq and says to his brother, “Fuck this place.” No one talks about the scene in the auto shop and the difficulty Chris had in accepting an invitation to go to the VA hospital. No one is talking about how he died. I think that a significant portion of the veteran population realizes that we need “psychos” (as some have characterized him) like Chris Kyle, but that we also need to bring them home, because by God if Kyle was a psychopath, then so am I, and so is my company commander, and my roommate, and any number of mentors and friends I’ve had.</p><p>This is not a new concept, and the difficulty America is having with digesting it highlights the growing divide between the American population and its military. Cyrus Trask, a Civil War veteran in John Steinbeck’s <em>East of Eden</em>, despite being a pathological liar (as some have characterized Kyle), hints at this idea of what it means to go to war as his son prepares to join the Army,</p><blockquote>Look now — in all of history men have been taught that killing of men is an evil thing not to be countenanced. Any man who kills must be destroyed because this is a great sin, maybe the worst sin we know. And then we take a soldier and put murder in his hands and we say to him, “Use it well, use it wisely.” We put no checks on him. Go out and kill as many of a certain kind or classification of your brothers as you can. And we will reward you for it because it is a violation of your early training.</blockquote><p>That was written 60 years ago. Maybe now, in 2015, this film will help those Americans who have been detached from the conduct of our wars better understand what our nation’s sheepdogs have to go through, psychologically, in order to perform their job well. That warfare, at the end of the day, takes humans and damages or destroys them — on both sides. Or that we need to find a better way of incorporating people who have done “not okay” things back into the folds of society. Maybe the critiques of this film will help those who cannot accept criticism of US military action to confront the stark reality of what blind support for warfare or killing does to those who would carry out our nation’s will. But then again, maybe Americans don’t actually want to discuss these topics because there are no easy answers, so the question inevitably becomes, “who is responsible for helping our veterans?” And if there is anything that people hate more than their political rivals, it’s the thought of responsibility.</p><p>You don’t have to like Chris Kyle to appreciate <em>American Sniper</em>. You do not have to agree with the justifications for the Iraq War or think that Iraq is populated with savages in need of killing. At the end of the day, that is not what <em>American Sniper</em> is about. The film, even with all its factual inaccuracies or imposed political ideology, is about sitting the viewer down and forcing him to see warfare through the eyes of a warrior. To see that sometimes we have to do things or see things that are “not okay,” and that we have to find ways to live with ourselves afterwards. If that upsets you, then you are well on the way to empathizing with our fighting forces as we draw down from 15 years of conflict. If nothing else, Clint Eastwood’s film is important because it sparks discussion at a time when there is such a disconnect between civilians and the military that the president of the United States felt obligated to chastise “every CEO in America” during the State of the Union for the dismal hiring rate among former service members.</p><p>Edit: Since I began writing this article, a <a href="http://mic.com/articles/109040/what-everyone-gets-wrong-about-american-sniper-according-to-a-former-soldier">few</a> <a href="http://slicingthebread.blogspot.com/2015/02/everyone-is-completely-missing-point-of.html">other</a> authors have begun to discuss similar points about empathy for and reintegration of veterans. Notably, Erik Gains of Forbes has a <a href="http://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2015/01/29/american-sniper-isnt-pro-war-propaganda/">very thoughtful piece</a> on the subject.</p><p><em>The points in this article are unofficial expressions of opinion; views are those of the author and not necessarily those of the US Military Academy, Department of the Army, the Department of Defense, or any agency of the US (or any other) government.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f5c0f8834106" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>