<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Simone Lilavois on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Simone Lilavois on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@swimone21?source=rss-acf525f6767a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 22:24:39 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@swimone21/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rethinking Kuhn’s Paradigm Shifts in Modern Physics]]></title>
            <link>https://swimone21.medium.com/rethinking-kuhns-paradigm-shifts-in-modern-physics-f6580a396a5e?source=rss-acf525f6767a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f6580a396a5e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history-of-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simone Lilavois]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Jun 2026 16:24:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-11T16:25:35.408Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/0*cyMLQfHw7Wzej3Ce.jpg" /><figcaption>Thomas Kuhn. Source: © Bill Pierce/The LIFE Images Collection/Getty Images</figcaption></figure><p>In contrast to popular portrayal, science is not a machine that extracts absolute fact from observation. The acquisition of knowledge is not a linear process, and through scientific discovery, our understanding of the world not only improves, but more importantly, it evolves. Thomas Samuel Kuhn, born in 1922, was an American philosopher and historian of science who studied the trajectory of scientific knowledge. While Kuhn’s description of how science has historically advanced is accurate, he did not account for the hyper-specialization and increasing complexity of modern research, which have allowed scientists to more readily identify gaps in existing theories. Over time, this has reduced the probability that entirely incompatible paradigms can emerge. The modern scientific landscape, therefore, cannot be described simply by Kuhn’s “normal science” or “crisis” periods, since many scientists are operating in a more nuanced combination of both. Thus, although Kuhn’s model of paradigm shifts accurately describes the development of early scientific fields, the accumulation of empirical constraints within physics today decreases the likelihood of fully incommensurable revolutions, instead producing smaller paradigm shifts across interconnected subfields.</p><p>Originally a scientist himself, Kuhn received a doctorate in physics from Harvard in 1949, with his dissertation on theoretical solid-state physics. Grounding his philosophy in his research experience, Kuhn rejected the traditional history of science at the time, which described the evolution of science as a slow accumulation of facts that are added to the sum total of human knowledge. Instead, Kuhn promoted a history of science that was non-linear, in which the advancement of ideas could be largely attributed to rare, revolutionary theories and data that contradicted the established beliefs of the time. Kuhn referred to these revolutions as “paradigm shifts.” A paradigm describes the theories, methods, relevant questions, and standards for conducting research accepted by the scientific community at a given time, and when a shift occurs, there is a drastic change in how a scientific field is approached. In between revolutions, Kuhn coined the term “normal science,” which he defined as a period of time in his cycle of scientific advancement when scientists operate within the assumptions of the existing paradigm, accepting current ideas as largely correct. Kuhn writes that a paradigm shift only occurs after there is an anomaly, whereby an experiment yields results that cannot be explained within the current paradigm, and as anomalies accumulate, they produce a time of crisis, which eventually triggers a shift in paradigm. By contextualizing scientific advancement in historical foundations, Kuhn reshaped how we understand the course of science, describing long periods of gradual advancement, interspersed with short periods of major discovery that radically change scientific understanding. Importantly, when one paradigm replaced another, Kuhn saw the two as being incommensurable. For Kuhn, two paradigms must differ so radically that their assumptions, language, concepts, and methods cannot be compared. Kuhn published these ideas formally in “The Structure of Scientific Revolutions” in 1962.</p><p>Overall, Kuhn’s perspective on how science advances is more historically accurate than previous descriptions. For centuries, advancements in science have largely been shaped by individual major discoveries that defined new epochs of research. Part of what inspired Kuhn to reconstruct the history of science was what he identified as an oversimplification in how the public understands the trajectory of science. Contrary to how most textbooks portray the evolution of science, the sole accumulation of knowledge is not the primary avenue by which science advances. Because all scientific models are incomplete in some key way, only a shift in foundational understanding can produce a significant shift in science. In ““Paradigm” as a Central Concept in Thomas Kuhn’s Thought,” Turkan Firinci Orman describes the history of science prior to Kuhn: “…we had what amounted to the Whig interpretation of scientific history, in which past researchers, theorists, and experimenters had engaged in a long march, if not towards truth, then at least towards greater and greater understanding of the natural world” (Orman, 48). Orman discusses Kuhn’s historical accuracy, but also acknowledges that “Kuhn based his model on the classic paradigm shifts in physics” (Orman, 48), and this physics-centrism limits the applicability of his philosophy to other fields. Specifically, Kuhn’s ideas are mostly rooted in the evolution of early 20th-century physics. Thus, I will base my arguments in this essay on the evolution of physics as well.</p><p>Another key tenet of Kuhn’s philosophy is that scientific discoveries must be situated in the sociological, cultural, and technological context of the given time. Current beliefs, or the prevailing paradigm, determine which discoveries are possible by establishing which questions are reasonable to ask. Kuhn mainly draws from Copernican, Newtonian, and Einsteinian revolutions to demonstrate that more knowledge is not enough to advance science. To go from geocentrism to heliocentrism, there needed to be a fundamental shift in how people understood the world, moving away from the Church’s role in the proliferation of scientific ideas and rejecting the longstanding cultural belief that Earth was the center of the universe. To go from Newtonian mechanics to relativity, the perspective of space and time as separate, absolute entities was overthrown, replaced by a unified spacetime framework, and fundamental concepts such as simultaneity, motion, and mass had to be reconsidered. It was not simply that we learned something new about the world and added it to existing ideas; it was that we completely redefined what was accepted as the “right” way of understanding something. This key difference was not captured in previous histories of science.</p><p>In his introduction to “The Structure of Scientific Revolutions,” Kuhn points out that if the history of science is to be just an accumulation, then historians of science run into the issue of explaining where early science, often rooted in cultural and religious beliefs, fits into this accumulation. Knowing that previous theories have been wholly discarded makes it difficult to describe scientific development through the process of pure accumulation of knowledge. Kuhn writes, “The more carefully [historians] study, say, Aristotelian dynamics, phlogistic chemistry, or caloric thermodynamics, the more certain they feel that those once current views of nature were, as a whole, neither less scientific nor more the product of human idiosyncrasy than those current today. If these out-of-date beliefs are to be called myths, then myths can be produced by the same sorts of methods and held for the same sorts of reasons that now lead to scientific knowledge. If, on the other hand, they are to be called science, then science has included bodies of belief quite incompatible with the ones we hold today” (Kuhn, 2). Consequently, an account of the progression of science must include sharp changes in understanding as a field advances. Within this framework, it becomes clear how paradigms determine the possible science of the time, and how only enough data in direct contradiction with the given paradigm can produce a truly new idea that revolutionizes science. Kuhn also argues that “normal science” occurs in between paradigm shifts, stating “Normal science, the activity in which most scientists inevitably spend almost all their time, is predicated on the assumption that the scientific community knows what the world is like” (Kuhn, 5). This is where I believe Kuhn’s philosophy is inaccurate today.</p><p>Based on this definition, the large majority, if not all, of modern-day physicists could not be considered conducting normal science. Particle physics is an illustrative example of this: it is entirely accepted that the Standard Model of Particle Physics is incomplete, and Kuhn’s anomalies are pervasive. However, if there is a complete paradigm shift that replaces the Standard Model, it cannot be absolutely incommensurable with particle physics today. This is because many parts of the Standard Model have gone through rigorous precision tests that have constrained values and validated theories in ways that can’t entirely be abandoned should a paradigm shift occur. Additionally, although the Standard Model is the current paradigm in particle physics, there has never been a period of normal science in its development because it has always been known to be incomplete, and it has always been known that it cannot answer all “puzzles” in the paradigm. In this case, the majority of particle physicists are not doing “normal science” but are working at the forefront of revolutionizing the current paradigm. Thus, normal science has evolved to become anomaly-searching.</p><p>When describing normal science in more detail, Kuhn writes, “…the most striking feature of the normal research problems we have just encountered is how little they aim to produce major novelties, conceptual or phenomenal” (Kuhn, 35). Yet much of modern particle physics research has some aspect of pushing the boundaries of the Standard Model and is motivated by the recognition that the current paradigm is incomplete. Physicists search for particles that do not yet fit in our description of the universe, investigate the nature of dark matter, seek a quantum theory of gravity, and attempt to explain parameters that currently appear arbitrary within existing theory. Even precision tests of the Standard Model are often designed to uncover deviations that could suggest new physics. Thus, the majority of particle physics research <em>does</em> aim “to produce major novelties, conceptual or phenomenal.” This is very different from the state of physics when Kuhn was developing his philosophy, which seemed to have epochs of normal science between the Newtonian and Einsteinian revolutions, where theories were largely accepted as nearly complete. In “Thomas S. Kuhn as Sociologist of Knowledge,” John Urry also challenges Kuhn’s definition of normal science: “Rather normal science should be regarded as consisting of a major paradigm with various paradigm competitors, and with a continual struggle for hegemony between the adherents…. To explain science as such is to allow for…the insecurity of established paradigms,” (Urry, 469). Urry’s definition agrees more with how particle physics is conducted today, with insecurity in the established paradigm.</p><p>From this, I argue that Kuhn’s philosophy is more accurate in describing the advancement of pre-modern science. Paradigms in the early stages of a field may seem more sound, whereas the more a field is developed, the clearer it is what is not yet understood. For example, for more than two centuries, Newtonian Mechanics seemed to describe the motion of objects with remarkable accuracy, and most physicists did not believe that its fundamental framework would need to be replaced by something as radically different as General Relativity. Only toward the late nineteenth century did subtle anomalies, including the unexplained precession of Mercury’s orbit and the failure to detect the luminiferous ether, begin to suggest limitations in the Newtonian classical physics framework that warranted a paradigm shift. In fact, Newton himself acknowledged that his laws of motion did not account for the mechanism behind the force of gravity, though it was not anticipated that a complete revolution overthrowing Newtonian Mechanics was needed to explain this mechanism. In a letter to Richard Bentley in 1693, Newton expressed his concern about gravity acting across a vacuum without an intervening medium: “That one body may act upon another at a distance through a vacuum without the mediation of anything else, by and through which their action and force may be conveyed from one another, is to me so great an absurdity that, I believe, no man who has in philosophic matters a competent faculty of thinking could ever fall into it” (American Association for the Advancement of Science, 2012). In essence, Newton’s laws described how objects move but did not address why gravity exists. Although Newton was disturbed by the lack of a mechanism behind gravity, his laws led scientists to believe that they could describe the motion and forces of objects accurately. This is a stark contrast to much of physics today, where we are very aware of how much we don’t know. Thus, at least in physics, previous paradigms were more well-established and agreed upon as accurate, whereas today, it is acknowledged by the entire community that the current paradigm is incomplete.</p><p>Further, in the early foundations of any scientific field, there is a wider range of ideas that seem plausible during the “crisis” period, since there is less evidence to narrow down the scope of what is possible. However, inevitably, as a field matures and the wealth of experimental and theoretical data increases, the number of realistic theories that account for every observation made will drastically decrease, and there will be significantly less speculation. This suggests that Kuhn’s paradigm shifts are more adept at describing the early evolution of a scientific field. Indeed, much of Kuhn’s argument is based on major breakthroughs in physics that were occurring early in the development of the field, when documentation and experimental techniques were poor, or in the earlier stages of formalization, when there was significantly less exchange of ideas throughout the scientific community. For example, in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, there were many competing atomic models, and a wide range of different structures were theoretically possible given limited experimental constraints. These included the plum-pudding model by J. J. Thomson, the planetary model by Ernest Rutherford, and the quantized orbit model by Niels Bohr, each of which could explain an aspect of atomic theory but lacked others. With incomplete spectroscopy data and unknown nuclear structure, multiple atomic models seemed plausible, even though each was incompatible with the others. However, with the advent of quantum mechanics, there was a fundamental shift in the mathematical tools used to describe elementary particles, which could no longer be explained by classical physics. The introduction of probabilistic outcomes and wavefunctions significantly narrowed the range of possible theories for explaining atomic structure and invalidated all previous classical models. Thus, in the early development of a field (such as pre-modern physics), there will be a smaller range of data and theory to account for, and thus a higher likelihood of producing a new paradigm highly incommensurable with what it replaced. This is not the case today in particle physics, since any new theory must reproduce and explain an enormous body of precise data, drastically limiting how “radical” a new paradigm can be. That being said, I want to recognize that, of course, it remains possible that future discoveries will force a profound rethinking of our understanding of nature.</p><p>With all of this in mind, I would update Kuhn’s philosophy to incorporate a spectrum of paradigm shifts that depends on both the stage of development of a scientific field and how deeply rooted a given anomaly is. Younger fields may have more frequent, fully incommensurable paradigm shifts, with wider implications for all active researchers. In between paradigm shifts in younger fields, true normal science can be conducted because the earliest iterations of paradigms in a field have had less time to be scrutinized to identify anomalies. These shifts correspond to Kuhn’s traditional definition of paradigm shifts. Building on this, I would define micro-paradigm shifts as smaller, relevant breakthroughs in the ever-growing subfields within the umbrella of a larger field. These micro shifts would not affect everyone in the larger field, but, for example, could radically alter how research is conducted within the given discipline. For example, the discovery of the first brown dwarf prompted a significant re-thinking of what types of astronomical bodies are possible in the universe, and how we can best study them, yet it did not radically change all of physics. I would consider this to be a micro-paradigm shift. Lastly, I would define the macro-paradigm shift, representing major and increasingly rare breakthroughs in a developed scientific field that truly affect every researcher. For example, reconciling quantum mechanics and General Relativity, or discovering the particle or phenomenon responsible for dark matter, would create a shift in how every physicist describes the universe. Scientists who are conducting work that could produce a macro-paradigm shift are never truly doing normal science, since the research they conduct is operating at the very boundary of the current paradigm, and their work more closely represents the work Kuhn refers to as occurring during a crisis period. Together, today’s micro- and macro-paradigms form a massive branching network throughout physics, shifting at different times, with researchers hunting for the next anomaly. We are aware of the limits of our knowledge with a greater scope than ever before, yielding less rigidly defined paradigms overall. Still, even if radical shifts decrease in frequency as science advances, paradigm shifts will always occur, producing new ideas at all scales and continuously refining our understanding of the universe.</p><p><strong>References</strong><br>1) “Paradigm” as a Central Concept in Thomas Kuhn’s Thought. (2016). International Journal of Humanities and Social Science. Retrieved February 23, 2026, from<br><a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/316550322_Paradigm_as_a_Central_Concept_in_Thomas_Kuh">https://www.researchgate.net/publication/316550322_Paradigm_as_a_Central_Concept_in_Thomas_Kuhn&#39;s_Thought</a>2</p><p>2) Anand, G., Larson, E. C., &amp; Mahoney, J. T. (2020). Thomas Kuhn on Paradigms. Production and<br>Operations Management, 29(7), 1650–1657.<a href="https://doi.org/10.1111/poms.13188"> https://doi.org/10.1111/poms.13188</a></p><p>3) Kuhn, T. S. (2009). The structure of scientific revolutions (3. ed., [Nachdr.]). Univ. of Chicago Press. The story of gravity | American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS). (n.d.). Retrieved February 23, 2026, from<a href="https://www.aaas.org/taxonomy/term/10/story-gravity"> https://www.aaas.org/taxonomy/term/10/story-gravity</a></p><p>4) Urry, J. (1973). Thomas S. Kuhn as Sociologist of Knowledge. The British Journal of Sociology, 24(4), 462–473.<a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/589735"> https://doi.org/10.2307/589735</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f6580a396a5e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Modern Narratives of al-Andalus: The Power of History and Memory]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-still-point/modern-narratives-of-al-andalus-the-power-of-history-and-memory-59cd3fc95d46?source=rss-acf525f6767a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/59cd3fc95d46</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[al-andalus]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simone Lilavois]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Jul 2025 19:45:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-12T19:45:42.698Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*8XeX5dfsl3k_9UsZ" /><figcaption>The painting “La civilització del califat de Còrdova en temps d’Abd al-Rahman III” is a depiction of the civilization of the Caliphate of Cordoba during the rule of Abd al-Rahman III. Source: <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:La_civilitzaci%C3%B3_del_califat_de_C%C3%B2rdova_en_temps_d%27Abd-al-Rahman_III.jpg">Wikipedia</a></figcaption></figure><p>History cannot be written, studied, or portrayed objectively. There is always a selection bias in which stories get preserved through time and an interpretation bias in how we perceive the events of the past in the context of the present. In a world wrought with religious, racial, and cultural conflicts, the concept of genuine coexistence is captivating. This captivation has led to a variety of contradictory interpretations and presentations of the history of al-Andalus — some nostalgic, some disdainful, and some that champion complete erasure of portions of the past. When considering the eight centuries of interfaith cohabitation in medieval Spain, it is vital that we are aware of how the Andalusian narrative has been distorted over time in academia, politics, and the tourism industry, and continues to change with the state of the modern world.</p><p>The concept of “convivencia” stemmed from the controversial thesis of Spanish cultural historian Américo Castro in 1948, whose work popularized a version of al-Andalus that was a utopian society of harmonious and eager coexistence. Because of this, many considered, and still consider today, al-Andalus to be an example of a multi-religious society that, in its prime, surpassed the modern world in its functionality and cohesiveness. In opposition to Castro was Claudio Sánchez-Albornoz, who rejected the idea that Islam had influenced Spanish identity. Instead, Sánchez-Albornoz argued that Spanish identity had been established before an Islamic presence in Spain, and the presence of Muslims and Jews for eight centuries has no relevance when defining what it means to be Spanish today. Yet as argued by Kenneth Baxter Wolf in “Convivencia in Medieval Spain: A Brief History of an Idea,” “Castro and Sánchez-Albornoz were both guilty of ‘reconstructing a Spanish past through the perspective of their own contemporary culture, a culture that is at least in part a product of the events and conditions which form the subject of their investigations’” (Wolf, 83). As most scholars agree, both men were heavily influenced by the political climate of the time. It is generally agreed that Castro’s thesis was a reflection of his opposition to nationalist ideologies, Spanish Catholic purity, and the authoritarian rule of Francisco Franco. On the other hand, Sánchez-Albornoz’s thesis was inevitably shaped by his traditional, conservative, and proud Catholic views; he was in favor of a unified, homogeneous Spanish identity founded in Catholicism. Although Sánchez-Albornoz was strictly against authoritarianism and Franco’s regime, his ideas were appealing to nationalist frameworks of thought that promoted a Catholic narrative of Spanish history and thus were adopted by those in favor of Franco’s vision of Spain as a unified Catholic nation. Sánchez-Albornoz further argued that the resources and time expended during the reconquest of Spain could explain why the country’s development compared to the rest of Europe was lagging so far behind. This allowed individuals to blame the presence of Islam in Spain for the modern state of the country.</p><p>However, as Wolf argues, once Spain was integrated into Europe in the 1980s and 1990s, becoming a part of the modern, multicultural, and religiously pluralistic global society we have today, Castro’s thesis dominated scholarly debates. It would be ignorant to deny the impact that the eight centuries of cultural exchange had on the national identity of Spain today. Wolf writes, “Instead of treating the Islamic presence as an obstacle to Spanish participation in the modern world, historians began to see it as the sine qua non of peninsular ‘multiculturalism’, Spain’s most distinctive contribution to medieval European history” (Wolf, 74–75). Nevertheless, despite the general consensus in academia that Islam cannot be ignored in discussions on Spanish history, many individuals, fueled by the Catholic Church’s anti-Muslim rhetoric, still saw the idea of historic Islamic influence in Spain as a threat to Spain’s identity as a modern European nation.</p><p>The rise of modern Christian nationalism can be seen in Spain’s ultra-right conservative political party, Vox. Founded in 2013, the party is notorious for Islamophobic campaigns built on disinformation and Christian nationalism. This technique is not new; during Franco’s regime, specific narratives of the Reconquista were often used as a political tool to justify his authoritarian rule. By tying Spain’s identity directly to Christian exclusivity and the rejection of Islam, politicians are able to fuel their supporters through hatred and discrimination. Vox is the most recent example of this. The party’s leaders continuously romanticize the Reconquista and vilify the role of Islam in Spanish history, attempting to unite their supporters by embracing a purely Catholic Spanish identity. In “Vox: A New Far Right in Spain?,” Vicente Rubio-Pueyo discusses Vox’s political agenda, which is laid out in a document titled, “100 medidas para la España Viva,” meaning “100 measures for the living Spain.” In the first section, “Spain: Unity and Sovereignty,” Vox calls for the suppression of the Law for Historical Memory, which recognizes descendants of victims of the Civil War and condemns the tyranny of Franco’s dictatorship. The first section also suggests a new education plan for Spanish history, focusing on “the deeds of [Spain’s] national heroes” (Rubio-Pueyo, 10). This is direct evidence of how historiography may be exploited for political agendas. In the “Defense” section of the document, Vox proposes the closing of “fundamentalist mosques” and removing Islam from public education programs (Rubio-Pueyo, 10). The document even advises building a wall in Spanish cities that border Morocco.</p><p>Rubio-Pueyo further writes, “One of [Vox’s] slogans for the Andalusian elections said no less than ‘The Reconquista begins in Andalusia’. A historically inaccurate, and out-of-date reference, was nonetheless effective in terms of connecting that tale of the past with the present day’s Islamophobia” (Rubio-Pueyo, 13). Today, anti-Muslim rhetoric in Spain goes beyond just historical references. According to Robert Gould in “Vox España and Alternative für Deutschland: Propagating the Crisis of National Identity,” “a report by the Institute for Strategic Dialogue in London [stated] that a network of nearly 3000 fake Twitter accounts was sending Islamophobic messages and/or messages in support of Vox, particularly during the election campaign in the spring of 2019” (Gould, 16). In essence, Islamophobia in Spain is given a unique and dangerous justification because the rejection of Islam has been linked to the very nature of what it means to be Spanish. The history of al-Andalus is thus an ongoing narrative that continues to be redefined as political goals evolve and demand different beliefs among the general public.</p><p>The perception of medieval Spain is controversial, varying, and relevant not only in scholarly debates. Beyond politicians, the tourism industry, perhaps at times unwittingly, has been able to leverage the uncertainty in Spain’s Islamic past. With no clear consensus on how large an influence Muslim culture has had on Spain’s culture today, the tourism industry can capitalize on the complicated Andalusian history, distorting it even further. The industry, in some instances by the hand of the Catholic Church, has taken advantage of both narratives: a “pure” Christian history of Spain as well as an intertwined Arabic-Spanish past that panders to Muslim tourists.</p><p>The Mosque-Cathedral of Cordoba stands at the center of this dichotomy. The building is believed to have a Visigothic foundation from 590 A.D. when it was the church of San Vicente, indicated by tiles discovered during excavations. However, the building is not famous for its indeterminate Visigothic origins. In 785, with the rise of the Umayyad Caliphate, Abd al-Rahman I commissioned the Mosque’s construction. What was once a Visigothic church was transformed into an elegant architectural masterpiece, combining Byzantine, Roman, and Islamic architecture and becoming a symbol of power, faith, and wisdom that would be expanded over generations of the Umayyad Dynasty. The Mosque was revered by Muslims, Christians, and Jews alike, and used not only as a space for prayer but also for education and translation efforts and served as an elite university. It was large enough to hold 40,000 people. After the fall of the Caliphate and the rise of the Christian Monarchs, Ferdinand III converted the Mosque into a Cathedral. However, despite this change, nearly all of the original Mosque still stood, a clear sign of the universal respect for the remarkable building.</p><p>Some have claimed that the Visigothic foundation is evidence of the space’s true origins as being rightfully Christian. Some further argue that this shows how the Islamic Empire in Spain was an interruption in Spanish history, a fluke in the past during which the rightful Christian nature of Spain was suppressed and dormant, but eventually re-emerged victorious. Today, the Mosque-Cathedral is controlled by the Catholic Church, and this is partially justified by the Visigothic foundation discovered during the mid-20th century. Muslim tourists are prohibited from praying within its walls, as the building is “rightfully” Christian, leading some to argue that the name should be reduced to the “Cathedral of Cordoba.” Yet this argument, as one may be able to see quite plainly, is inherently flawed. A building can always be claimed as having a more “rightful” origin. If the Visigothic foundation is enough to overlook centuries of Islamic development in the space, perhaps we should then also consider what came before the Visigoths. Perhaps the building is more accurately described as belonging to the Romans. Or perhaps we should go even farther back and credit the group of people who constructed the very first building at that location. Clearly, this logic is absurd and unproductive. So, who does the space “belong” to? Who deserves the right to decide what the space means today?</p><p>The Catholic Church wants to make it clear that the Mosque-Cathedral of Cordoba is under Christian jurisdiction, rightfully and irrefutably. The Visigothic foundation is uncovered and on display for visitors to see at the entrance of the building, through a glass-covered hole in the floor. A plaque close by attributes the excavated mosaics to the Basilica of Saint Vincent, making visitors’ first impression of the space relate to the original Christian nature of the building. The brochure for the Mosque-Cathedral even states, “It is a historical fact that the Basilica of Saint Vincent was expropriated and destroyed in order to build on top of it the subsequent Mosque in the Islamic period” (Tourist Pamphlet for the Mosque-Cathedral of Cordoba (2015)). The brochure’s section on Muslim history in Spain is titled “The Islamic Intervention,” perpetuating a negative narrative of Muslims as an unwanted, villainous, foreign presence. The Catholic Church has intentionally weaponized history to further its agenda and shape the narrative of Spanish identity as being fundamentally Catholic.</p><p>Today, the act of interpreting the history of Islam in Spain has inescapable political implications. With religious conflict so prevalent in our modern world, the way Andalusian history is portrayed will significantly impact an audience. However, this portrayal does not always have to be negative. The history of al-Andalus may conversely be used to encourage religious tolerance and multicultural collaboration. For example, President Barack Obama leveraged a positive view of coexistence during a speech in Cairo in 2009. His speech, titled, “On a New Beginning,” addressed the tension between Islam and the West. When encouraging religious cooperation, Obama stated, “Islam has a proud tradition of tolerance. We see it in the history of Andalusia and Cordoba during the Inquisition” (Remarks by the President at Cairo University, 2009). By using al-Andalus to perpetuate principles of inclusivity, collaboration, and acceptance, we may use the narrative of the past to change the present. The history of medieval Spain is provocative, captivating, and dynamic, and is unique in its ability to inspire a certain line of thought in its learners. Whether al-Andalus and the relations of its inhabitants are painted in a positive or negative light is directly related to the objective of the historian, or the one painting the narrative. We all have the shared responsibility to not only educate ourselves and remain critical of the historical narratives portrayed to us, but to further leverage such knowledge to incentivize mutual respect and care for people of all backgrounds across the world.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Gould, Robert. “Vox España and Alternative Für Deutschland: Propagating the Crisis of National Identity.” <em>Genealogy</em> 3, no. 4 (December 2019): 64.<a href="https://doi.org/10.3390/genealogy3040064"> https://doi.org/10.3390/genealogy3040064</a>.</p><p>ResearchGate. “VOX: A NEW FAR RIGHT IN SPAIN? Study Published by Rosa Luxemburg Stiftung — NYC Office.” Accessed December 11, 2024.<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334304634_VOX_A_NEW_FAR_RIGHT_IN_SPAIN_Study_published_by_Rosa_Luxemburg_Stiftung_-_NYC_Office"> https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334304634_VOX_A_NEW_FAR_RIGHT_IN_SPAIN_Study_published_by_Rosa_Luxemburg_Stiftung_-_NYC_Office</a>.</p><p>whitehouse.gov. “Remarks by the President at Cairo University, 6–04–09,” June 4, 2009.<a href="https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/remarks-president-Cairo-university-6-04-09"> https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/remarks-president-Cairo-university-6-04-09</a>.</p><p>Wolf, Kenneth Baxter. “Convivencia in Medieval Spain: A Brief History of an Idea.” Accessed December 11, 2024.<a href="https://compass.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1749-8171.2008.00119.x"> https://compass.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1749-8171.2008.00119.x</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=59cd3fc95d46" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point/modern-narratives-of-al-andalus-the-power-of-history-and-memory-59cd3fc95d46">Modern Narratives of al-Andalus: The Power of History and Memory</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point">The Still Point</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Diamond Within: Virtue, Religion, and Identity in 15th-Century Spain]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-still-point/the-diamond-within-virtue-religion-and-identity-in-15th-century-spain-954f521fb270?source=rss-acf525f6767a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/954f521fb270</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[al-andalus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simone Lilavois]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Jul 2025 19:33:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-12T19:33:46.699Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/244/0*7TnfS0DuQdxmly87.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*2XyS7tYP0rwQ5eLj.jpg" /><figcaption>Left: Book Cover for El Abencerraje. Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Abencerraje">Wikipedia</a>. Right: Page from 1565 version of El Abencerraje. Source: <a href="https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/94/Inventario_1565_p233_El_Abencerraje.jpg">Wikipedia</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>Does the nature of a diamond depend on whether it is set in gold, silver, or lead? Or, in other words, does the outside appearance of an object, or individual, contribute to its inherent essence? <em>El Abencerraje</em>, an influential anonymously published novella written in 16th-century Spain, indirectly poses this question in its prologue, alluding to the cultural reckoning during the Spanish Golden Age that redefined where Muslims stood in society. Set in the 15th century, one hundred years earlier than its release, the story takes place along the border between Christian and Muslim Spain and explores religious relations during a time when the expectations for such relationships were transforming rapidly. Because the novella was anonymously published, and due to the volatility of the 1560s, there are various contradictory ways to interpret the piece. Does the overt presentation of Muslims as honorable and valorous mean that the novella is attempting to challenge the increasing anti-Muslim rhetoric of the time? Or does the fact that the Christian knight, Rodrigo de Narváez, defeated his Muslim counterpart, Abindarráez the Younger, represent an underlying theme of Christian superiority? While it would be foolish to ignore the apparent themes of Christian dominance, power, and control throughout the story, the novella still demonstrates, remarkably, that honor can be found in all individuals, no matter their religious identity. Ultimately, <em>El Abencerraje </em>idealizes human connection that can transcend religious boundaries.</p><p>To understand and reliably interpret this seminal piece of literature, it is critical to consider the historical context in which it was produced. The 16th century was defined by uncertainty and drastically changing power dynamics, and the revered Islamic Empire that garnered so much respect from Christians for hundreds of years had been overthrown. Although the novella’s publication only marked the centennial of Granada’s fall, Islamic power had been dwindling for hundreds of years as the Monarchy gained more territory. Further, what it meant to be “Spanish” was changing, and its new definition alienated Muslims and Jews who had considered the Iberian Peninsula their home for generations. Within the decade of <em>El Abencerraje’s </em>first appearance, royal decrees issued by Phillip II prohibited Moorish dress, celebrations, dances, music, and the use of Arabic. Less than half a century later, in 1609, the Monarchy expelled all Moriscos from the Peninsula, despite the fact that many families had been Christian for over a century. It is important to note that while the story of <em>El Abencerraje </em>was constructed in a period of upheaval and religious persecution, it was set a century prior, when interfaith relationships, though still strained, were more acceptable and stable. <em>El Abencerraje </em>is an ode to an earlier time — a time when Spain wasn’t so rigidly defined as a Christian nation, a time when frontier life still offered the rich cultural exchange of interfaith connection.</p><p>I find the most compelling evidence for how we should interpret the novella in the prologue: “…just as a precious diamond, whether set in gold or silver or lead, retains its fair value according to its carats and its lister, so too virtue shines and shows its qualities in any flawed subject, just like the seed that grows when it falls on fertile soil and in the barren soil is lost” (27). This language suggests that a diamond set in gold is superior to a diamond set in silver or lead and that the latter two are inherently flawed. It is plausible that the “gold or silver or lead” is a reference to the three monotheistic religions that occupied the Iberian peninsula. One could argue that the language used in the prologue is evidence of a continuous theme of Christian superiority throughout the text; however, nearly all people of faith would declare that their belief is the “right” one and that others are flawed. In these opening lines, the narrator metaphorically asserts that they believe Christianity is the superior religion, being the diamond that is “set in gold.” And yet remarkably, the narrator also posits that the diamond remains a diamond no matter how it is set, just as every individual is no less human if they are Christian, Muslim, or Jewish. This may seem contradictory — how can both claims be true at the same time? Indeed, the text is promoting a radical idea for the time. For example, as the story comes to a close, Jarifa’s father comments on the kindness of Rodrigo de Narváez. He encouraged his daughter and Abindarráez to “…keep [Narváez] henceforth as a friend, even though we are of different faiths,” (45). The explicit mention of “difference” is a powerful indicator of the novella’s true intentions. As argued by Richard F. Glenn in “The Moral Implications of <em>El Abencerraje</em>,” the novella emphasizes “mutual recognition of human dignity by enemies at a time when Christians did not normally recognize unconverted Moors as equals. It is extraordinary that a work such as this should argue that members of the two races can retain their inherent nobility without abandoning their basic religious principles” (Glenn, 203). It is unsurprising that the novella was published anonymously, given that such a progressive claim would assuredly draw unwanted attention to an author in the 1560s. The Christian Monarchy would certainly not allow an individual to promote the notion that a devout and honorable Christian could be true to their faith and simultaneously recognize virtue in members of other religions.</p><p>Further, although <em>El Abencerraje </em>is not truly representative of Christian-Muslim relations, by romanticizing reality and portraying Muslims as honorable, the text encourages respect and honor across religious lines. As written in the introduction to “<em>The Abencerraje” and “Ozmín and Daraja,” Two Sixteenth-Century Novellas From Spain</em>, the Moors in the story “are literary constructs who cite Greek myths and communicate easily with Christians, but their very depiction makes a point about their familiarity” (13). These “literary constructs” are intentional, reflecting a subtle yearning for a more unified civilization throughout the peninsula, albeit still under Christian rule. Muslims are represented throughout the story as overtly, sometimes even excessively, righteous. <em>El Abencerraje </em>portrays Abindarráez as an honorable man whom the Christians seem to admire in many ways. The text describes the Moor as having a “powerful build” and a “beautiful face,” as well as being “brave” and “valorous.” These words indicate that Moors garnered respect and may have been idolized by Christians. In the story, when the squires first catch sight of the Moor, they are struck by his image and freeze: “The squires, transported by the sight of him, almost let him through before they set upon him” (29). Some Moors were likely viewed with great esteem by Christian citizens, even up to the late 15th century. Despite the official policies of anti-Muslim rhetoric being pushed by the monarchs, this suggests that the average citizen still thought highly of Islamic culture.</p><p><em>El Abencerraje </em>is considered the first “Moorish” novel and triggered the beginning of a Maurophilic preoccupation in popular culture, inspiring a new epoch of literature that idealized Muslim culture. Despite increasing laws enacted by the Monarchy that oppressed Muslims in the 15th century and their Morisco descendants in the 16th century, the average citizen’s perspective on Islamic culture changed gradually. A deep-seated respect had developed throughout generations of religious coexistence — the admiration for elegant Islamic architecture, eloquent Arabic poetry, and the sophisticated Muslim lifestyle was not going to dissipate overnight, even in the face of a rapidly changing social order. Golden Age Christians were the product of Ferdinand and Isabella’s Spain, defined by a contagious sense of nationalism and an imperialistic pride generated by the unification of the peninsula, the Reconquista, and the exploration of the Americas. These shaping events undoubtedly fueled narratives of Christian superiority. However, despite all of this, the public had an unshakable fascination with and reverence for Islamic culture and was having difficulty letting go of an interconnected, multi-cultural national identity. <em>El Abencerraje </em>is representative of this national identity crisis and the contradicting social views that accompanied the drastically shifting social hierarchy. The overly valorous characters in the novella remind us that human connection and friendship can be cultivated beyond religious identity. Even in the face of religious oppression and inescapable narratives of Christian superiority, one can find a diamond within the religious “setting” of any individual.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Fuchs, Barbara, Larissa Brewer-Garcia, and Aaron J. Ilika. <em>“The Abencerraje” and “Ozmín and Daraja”: Two Sixteenth-Century Novellas from Spain</em>. University of Pennsylvania Press, 2014.</p><p>Glenn, Richard F. “The Moral Implications of El Abencerraje.” <em>MLN </em>80, no. 2 (1965): 202–9. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/3042610.">https://doi.org/10.2307/3042610.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=954f521fb270" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point/the-diamond-within-virtue-religion-and-identity-in-15th-century-spain-954f521fb270">The Diamond Within: Virtue, Religion, and Identity in 15th-Century Spain</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point">The Still Point</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Andalusian Coexistence: Christians, Muslims, and Jews in Medieval Spain]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-still-point/andalusian-coexistence-christians-muslims-and-jews-in-medieval-spain-f36d70338423?source=rss-acf525f6767a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f36d70338423</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[al-andalus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spain]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simone Lilavois]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 12 Jul 2025 19:02:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-12T19:02:04.111Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A <strong>Fluid Dynamic of Cultural Exchange</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*orxj7m-FjY54jg7P.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/463/0*cwCxd5A87ToQl7gd.jpg" /><figcaption>Left: Al-Andalus c. 732. Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Andalus">Wikipedia</a>. Right: Map of modern day Spain. Source: <a href="https://stock.adobe.com/search?k=spain+portugal+map&amp;asset_id=40021594">Adobe Stock</a></figcaption></figure><p>Cambridge Dictionary defines “coexistence” as “the fact of living or existing together at the same time or in the same place.” And if one were to deem the interreligious communities of medieval Spain as “coexisting” under this definition, I would be tempted to argue that coexistence was pervasive and obviously present. Individuals practicing the three monotheistic religions did coexist; they resided in the same place at the same time. Yet the traditional views of coexistence, or rather, those that have stemmed from the controversial thesis of “<em>convivencia</em>,” as first outlined by Spanish cultural historian Américo Castro in 1948, often paint an overly simplistic, romanticized picture of what such religious relations may have looked like. The cultural and religious exchange that occurred in al-Andalus — from 711, when the first Muslims crossed the Strait of Gibraltar from North Africa to the Iberian Peninsula, to 1492, when the Catholic Monarchs finally took Grenada, achieving the Christian unification of the Peninsula and expelling all Jews and Muslims who did not convert to Christianity — cannot be defined as one static dynamic between clearly defined groups. “Tolerance” in al-Andalus from the 7th through 15th centuries was an ever-changing, fluid dynamic between not just three religions, but also a multitude of subsets within each religion itself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*6LXwW6P6zbi9YMst.jpg" /><figcaption>The Mosque–Cathedral of Córdoba was built during the reign of Abd ar-Rahman I in 785 and later expanded by his successors. Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Andalus">Wikipedia</a></figcaption></figure><p>Over the course of those eight centuries, the dominant culture molded the definition of coexistence, continuously redefining what an interreligious society looked like. Because of this, coexistence looked like different things to different groups at any one time due to their status and allotted privileges determined by the governing body. For example, under Umayyad Islamic rule, the two other religions were respected far more than they were under Christian rule. Ingrained in the foundation of Islam is the respect for “Peoples of the Book,” or the acknowledgment that the Bible and Torah are legitimate scriptures and deserve the respect of those who follow the Quran.</p><p>Under Islamic rule, in the early 8th century, Christians and Jews were given the status of “dhimmi,” or “protected people.” Indeed, the 713 Treaty of Tudmir is demonstrative of this relatively liberal religious polity. Under the conditions of the treaty, Muslim leader Abd al-Aziz granted Visigothic ruler Theodoric — Tudmir in Arabic — a degree of autonomy and religious freedom: “His followers will not be killed or taken prisoner, nor will they be separated from their women and children. They will not be coerced in matters of religion, their churches will not be burned, nor will sacred objects be taken from the realm…” (Ruggles, 64). This status was similarly applied to Jews at the time, which was a significant improvement from their lives under Visigothic rule the century prior, when laws restricted their actions. As explained by María Rosa Menocal in <em>The Ornament of the World</em>, “…[Umayyad rule] spectacularly improved the Jews’ everyday lives and social status: a community not long before reduced to squalor and slavery was upwardly mobile now…” (Menocal, 68). As Jews moved up in social status, Christians moved down, becoming the minority in a society in which they had previously been dominant. The changing rule of al-Andalus is indicative of how coexistence cannot be truly defined.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Gw5tJxvapt-xtX3c.jpg" /><figcaption>The Alhambra was a palace and fortress built between 1238 and 1358 in Granada during the Nasrid Dynasty. The Nasrid Dynasty was the last Muslim dynasty to rule in the Iberian Peninsula and fell in 1492 during the Reconquista led by the Catholic Monarchs Isabella and Ferdinand. Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alhambra">Wikipedia</a></figcaption></figure><p>Considering Muslim tolerance alone, one may argue that the aforementioned treaty is evidence of genuine coexistence. However, the status of “dhimmi” did not come without cost. Christians and Jews were forced to pay a tax in exchange for their religious freedoms and civil protection. Thus, was this sincere coexistence, or a ploy for economic benefit and political security? Islamic art expert and historian D. Fairchild Ruggles argues the latter, writing “These treaties were the strategy of conquerors who sought to impose minority rule over a majority of a different faith, knowing that peaceful submission was far preferable to a state of continual war…[those in power were] careful not to destabilize [their] minority government’s rule by threatening its base, a Christian majority,” (Ruggles, 64). Tolerance was often justified on a large scale by those in power in exchange for personal benefit. This can be seen under Christian rule as well. Bishops at the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215 condemned the “damnable mixing” of Christians with Muslims and Jews, ordering that “…[Jews and Muslims] of either sex, in every Christian province and at all times…be distinguished in public from other people by the character of their dress…” (Lowney, 200). King Ferdinando III did not comply with the Lateran decrees, expressing his concern to Pope Honorius III that should he enforce such laws upon Jews, “[they would] choose rather to flee to the Moors [i.e., to Spain’s Muslim-ruled south] than to be burdened with such a sign…” (Lowney, 200–201). The King’s decision was not one of altruism, but one motivated by power and profit. Losing the Jewish population would mean losing the tax revenues they provided. When looking at these facts, coexistence seems more realistically defined as a reluctant tolerance of religious differences for personal gain.</p><p>It may be more accurate and interesting to define coexistence not only as how the three Andalusian religious groups treated one another, but also how the cultures themselves changed due to interactions with the other cultures present. For example, the Almoravids and Almohads were North African Muslims who wanted a purely Muslim state in al-Andalus. These absolutist sects of Islam had not lived alongside Christians and Jews for centuries prior, and were appalled at how Andalusian Muslims lived. Islam in al-Andalus had evolved from being in such proximity to the other religions, each altering one another’s values, beliefs, and practices. Andalusi Muslims drank alcohol, Christians largely abandoned Latin, and Jewish scholars were fluent in Arabic. We cannot claim that Christians, Muslims, and Jews coexisted in al-Andalus because at the height of cultural exchange, each religious culture had become thoroughly transformed into something new. This is evident in Abd al-Rahman III’s proclamation of absolute primacy within the House of Islam in 929, declaring himself the Commander of the Faithful, the rightful caliph to the entire Islamic world. Not long after, Hasdai ibn Shaprut, the vizier and right-hand man to the caliph, declared that the Jews of al-Andalus would follow their own calendar, marking their own new moons and holy days. These two acts of independence cannot state more clearly that the religions of al-Andalus had evolved into their own entities. This is where we may find the most compelling evidence for what coexistence looked like.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/0*48tK3pDaQL0c9gkY.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/460/0*0kLpWFks0081_4PE.jpg" /><figcaption>Left: Portrayal of King Ferdinand III of Castile. Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ferdinand_III_of_Castile">Wikipedia</a>. Right: The tomb of King Ferdinand III, who died c. 1252. On his tomb, there is writing in Hebrew, Latin, Arabic, and an early form of Castilian. Source: <a href="https://www.lovegranada.com/monuments/royal-chapel/">Love Granada</a></figcaption></figure><p>In the end, our minds are inevitably warped by how we understand modern religious relations. The concept of tolerance seems to arise when we examine the cultural stratigraphy of architectural artifacts, the religiously collaborative creative, scientific, and philosophical literature, and the evolution of Andalusian philology. Yet what were the day-to-day experiences that were not captured by elite scholars or those in power? We saturate the stand-alone, isolated pieces of evidence that we have with a continuous, ubiquitous, and perhaps false, sense of accepting coexistence — the kind we see in the modern day in multicultural cities around the world. Ruggles captures this idea poignantly:</p><blockquote>“It is only in the modern era that we look back and identify [these pieces of evidence] as <em>convivencia</em>, imbuing it with the values of mutual respect and tolerance for difference, and the fact that we do so says much more about the twentieth and twenty-first centuries’ conflicts and yearnings than about the contestations and ethnic polyvalence of the eighth century,”</blockquote><blockquote>(Ruggles, 64).</blockquote><p>We mistakenly define tolerance in the context of what it looks like today when our medieval forebears operated under different cultural and societal norms, expectations, and practices. Further, our definition of coexistence cannot be static. It must change with time, region, and religious group. There are stories of love and hate, of war and peace, of intellectual exchange and cultural erasure. Al-Andalus was certainly no utopia, but it also was not a dystopia. When defining coexistence in medieval Spain, we must be careful not to romanticize the past, and we must take into account how Andalusian history is particularly susceptible to historical distortion because of how relevant religious conflict is today.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>Lowney, Chris. 2006. <em>A Vanished World: Muslims, Christians, and Jews in Medieval Spain</em>. Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press.</p><p>Menocal, Maria Rosa. 2009. <em>The Ornament of the World: How Muslims, Jews, and Christians Created a Culture of Tolerance in Medieval Spain</em>. Little, Brown.</p><p>Ruggles, D. Fairchild. 2011. “The Stratigraphy of Forgetting: The Great Mosque of Cordoba and Its Contested Legacy.” In <em>Contested Cultural Heritage</em>, edited by Helaine Silverman, 51–67. Springer. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4419-7305-4_2.">https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4419-7305-4_2.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f36d70338423" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point/andalusian-coexistence-christians-muslims-and-jews-in-medieval-spain-f36d70338423">Andalusian Coexistence: Christians, Muslims, and Jews in Medieval Spain</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point">The Still Point</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Objective Truth: Dune by Frank Herbert]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-still-point/the-objective-truth-dune-by-frank-herbert-4a262d58f89b?source=rss-acf525f6767a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4a262d58f89b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[humanity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dune]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simone Lilavois]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Apr 2024 17:28:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-15T17:28:24.163Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/663/0*KOh-dsMYGR2HuR_c.jpg" /><figcaption>Dune by Frank Herbert.</figcaption></figure><p>The <em>Dune</em> series by Frank Herbert is a brilliant exposé of human nature. Herbert intricately interweaves politics and organized religion in his plot, revealing their delicate balance and how a disequilibration between the two can lead to social chaos, and ultimately a hedonistic bureaucracy. With philosophical and existential wonderings layered within Herbert’s writing, the saga reflects humanity’s most fundamental, innate quest: our pursuit of meaning in an indifferent universe. Throughout the fourth book in the series, <em>God Emperor of Dune</em>, Herbert warns the reader of the genesis of absolutes, positing that absolutes are fabricated by the human mind to derive meaning from existence.</p><p>The God Emperor, more intimately known by readers as <em>Leto Atreides II</em>, is a prescient, near-immortal merge of human and sandworm; an ostensible tyrant who leads humanity’s intergalactic network of civilization. While the average civilian thinks of the God Emperor with either deep hatred or undying worship, Herbert reveals Leto’s true nature as an enigmatic, covert hero, whose singular objective is to secure humanity upon the “Golden Path,” by whatever means necessary. In Leto’s words, “[The Golden Path] is the survival of humankind, nothing more or less.” (13, Herbert). Through this, the reader is forced to consider: do intentions justify means? During his nearly 4,000-year reign, the God Emperor observes humanity and remarks on his reflections in the <em>Stolen Journals, </em>a collection of ridulian crystal sheets (only several molecules thick) — an advanced method of documentation that operates with a device to record Leto’s thoughts at will. Leto deliberately hid the journals containing his valuable insights to be uncovered and scrutinized by future generations. Leto often examined the concept of the Absolute in the <em>Stolen Journals</em>, reflecting:</p><blockquote>“In all of my universe I have seen no <em>law of nature, </em>unchanging and inexorable. This universe presents only changing relationships which are sometimes seen as laws by short-lived awareness. These fleshly sensoria which we call <em>self</em> are ephemera withering in the blaze of infinity, fleetingly aware of temporary conditions which confine our activities and change as our activities change. If you must label the <em>absolute</em>, use its proper name: <em>Temporary</em>. — The Stolen Journals.”</blockquote><blockquote><em>(Herbert, 456).</em></blockquote><p>Leto contends that absolutes are fallacies fabricated by the human mind. Humanity’s futile attempts to use internal subjective perceptions to define the objective nature of reality results in the creation of absolutes. We assign fragmented, biased laws to the limited iota of the Cosmos we observe, in hopes of bringing order to chaos. In our naive, anthropocentric framework of thought, we ordain our existence a false centrality. In <em>Heretics of Dune, </em>the fifth book in the series, Herbert alludes to this, writing,</p><blockquote>“There was a man who sat each day looking out through a narrow vertical opening where a single board had been removed from a tall wooden fence. Each day a wild ass of the desert passed outside the fence and across the narrow opening — first the nose, then the head, the forelegs, the long brown back, the hindlegs, and lastly the tail. One day, the man leaped to his feet with the light of discovery in his eyes and he shouted for all who could hear him: “It is obvious! The nose causes the tail!””</blockquote><blockquote><em>(Herbert, 414).</em></blockquote><p>This passage demonstrates humanity’s ignorance in attempting to detect an absolute truth, to discover and label meaning. Reaching this understanding — the objective truth is an unattainable construct — is profoundly humbling, yet one may take it as an opportunity for growth. By recognizing how humanity often reverts to the safety of absolutist belief structures to prescribe meaning, one may begin to overcome such limited, parochial thinking. Once liberated from the necessity to feel <em>special</em> we may embrace the absurdity of our being. This realization enables one to appreciate the miracle in our existence.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4a262d58f89b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point/the-objective-truth-dune-by-frank-herbert-4a262d58f89b">The Objective Truth: Dune by Frank Herbert</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point">The Still Point</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Heart as a Beacon of Freedom: Beloved by Toni Morrison]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-still-point/the-heart-as-a-beacon-of-freedom-beloved-by-toni-morrison-e9dd868cb055?source=rss-acf525f6767a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e9dd868cb055</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reading]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simone Lilavois]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Apr 2024 17:23:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-15T17:23:57.074Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/929/0*O4VzpJex4JiZnGVv.jpg" /><figcaption>Beloved by Toni Morrison. Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beloved_%28novel%29#/media/File:Beloved_(1987_1st_ed_dust_jacket_cover).jpg">Wikipedia</a></figcaption></figure><p>What do you call the essence of your being? Some say it’s their soul, some say their personality, or the frontal lobes of their brain, their consciousness, their spirit, their heart. We all know what it is, though we have many names for it: it’s the deepest part of the self that is terrifyingly and miraculously aware. “How and why? What is the meaning? Does this awareness remain after death? How can one reach the purest awareness of the self?” Throughout history, those who have had the privilege to ponder and debate such questions, have. However, the year is 1873 in America, and nearly 4 million enslaved people do not have the philosophical luxuries of the transcendentalists. Generations of persecution, oppression, and subjugation have maimed the self-identity and self-worth of the African-American populace. In <em>Beloved,</em> Toni Morrison uses the heart as a symbol of individuality and free will to illustrate how deeply the essence of the self was scarred under the dehumanizing conditions of slavery in America.</p><p><em>Beloved</em> follows the story of Sethe, a formerly enslaved woman, and her 18-year-old daughter Denver, who live in a house numbered 124 in Cincinnati Ohio. Sethe is haunted by her past at Sweet Home, a plantation in Kentucky she was sold to at age 13. After a remarkable and agonizing escape from Sweet Home in 1855, Sethe arrived in Cincinnati to live with her mother-in-law Baby Suggs, and was reunited with her children. Baby Suggs was freed by her son Halle after 60 years of enslavement on various plantations. Halle, the husband of Sethe and father to their children, never escaped Sweet Home, yet his extra labor bought his mother’s freedom. When thinking of her son and her freedom, Baby Suggs reflects on Sweet Home compared to other places where she was enslaved:</p><blockquote>“Sweet Home was a marked improvement. No question. And no matter, for the sadness was at her center, the desolated center where the self that was no self made its home. Sad as it was that she did not know where her children were buried or what they looked like if alive, fact was she knew more about them than she know about herself, having never had the map to discover what she was like”</blockquote><blockquote><em>(165).</em></blockquote><p>A lifetime of enslavement steals the self and one’s identity — or prevents self-identity from forming. As Morrison wrote, Baby Suggs’ sadness was “the self that was no self” at her center. Under such repressive conditions, there is no room or time to get to know oneself.</p><p>Baby Suggs proceeds to ask a series of questions about herself, wondering if she could sing, if she was pretty, if she was a good friend, or if her mother would like her if she knew her. These pieces of information are how we define ourselves; we consider what we are and what we are not, what we like and dislike, and who we surround ourselves with. From that, we construct an identity, something to call our own. Freedom and self-identity are deeply connected. Having free will and feeling your independence as a being is crucial to finding the self. Yet for someone who has never had such an opportunity, someone whose mind and body have been imprisoned for decades, the self is buried beneath a lifetime of suppressing individuality for survival. As such, the fruits of freedom remained unsung for many who were enslaved. Baby Suggs even asked herself, “What for? What does a sixty-odd-year-old slavewoman who walks like a three-legged dog need freedom for?” (166). Yet then, she acknowledges that freedom — no longer an abstruse concept existing only in futile daydreams — held all the difference in the world. Baby Suggs had a revelation after her first breath of free air:</p><blockquote>“Suddenly she saw her hands and thought with a clarity as simple as it was dazzling, “These hands belong to me. These <em>my</em> hands.” Next she felt a knocking in her chest and discovered something else new: her own heartbeat. Had it been there all along? This pounding thing? She felt like a fool and began to laugh out loud…“My heart’s beating,” she said”</blockquote><blockquote><em>(166).</em></blockquote><p>Baby Suggs’ freedom allowed her to realize her own being, her own person, and find the desire to learn about herself. Morrison uses the heart to symbolize the relationship between the sense of self and freedom. In <em>Beloved</em>, the heart is the deepest part of one’s being and it remains locked behind the bars of enslavement.</p><p>Often, those who were enslaved entombed their hearts, a form of autonomy in an effort to survive — it is only rational to release a part of the body that has been jeopardized by a predator, especially that which is most vulnerable and empathic. Paul D, a man who was enslaved with Sethe at Sweet Home, was among those who were forced to sacrifice their hearts to survive. After arriving at 124 18 years after Sethe’s escape, the two delve into their pasts. Paul D discloses that he had “the bit” — a form of punishment for enslaved people. Yet it wasn’t the bit itself that caused him the most agony, instead, it was “the roosters.” Paul D reflects on walking past the roosters (specifically one called Mister) when he had the bit in his mouth. Morrison writes, “Mister, he looked so…free. Better than me. Stronger, tougher. Son a bitch couldn’t even get out the shell by hisself but he was still king and I was…” After a moment of silence, Paul D continues:</p><blockquote>“Mister was allowed to be and stay what he was. But I wasn’t allowed to be and stay what I was. Even if you cooked him you’d be cooking a rooster named Mister. But wasn’t no way I’d ever be Paul D again, living or dead. Schoolteacher changed me. I was something else and that something was less than a chicken sitting in the sun on a tub”</blockquote><blockquote><em>(86).</em></blockquote><p>Through one memory, this dialogue illustrates the utter dehumanizing nature of slavery. Yet Paul D had only just begun to reveal the trauma of his past. He worried that saying more would “push them both to a place they couldn’t get back from. He would keep the rest where it belonged: in that tobacco tin buried in his chest where a red heart used to be…there was no red heart bright as Mister’s comb beating in him” (86). Paul D felt less free than a rooster — his suffering and punishment stole all hope and dreaming, all dignity and self-worth, his liberty and pride, and reduced him to less than an animal. He had to surrender his heart to endure his enslavement. He had to forsake his nature and relinquish the core of his identity. Using the rooster, Mister, as a symbol of taunting freedom, and the heart, as a symbol of individuality and free will, Morrison highlights the stark difference between living free and living under bondage and tyranny. Morrison also uses irony in this scene to exemplify the tragedy in Paul D’s oppressive experience. Mister, the rooster, would have died if it weren’t for Paul D. The rooster’s egg was left behind, unhatched, until Paul D tapped it to encourage the chick out. And who would have thought that later on, Paul D would feel inferior to that same rooster whose life was owed to him? Though only a bird, Mister had more free will and individuality than Paul D contained in his red heart.</p><p>It is human nature to wonder, to question, to search for meaning. Under the right conditions, the free individual flourishes, finding and shaping their identity, and developing the principles of their hearts. Yet enslavement of a person and repression of their heart restricts the potential of one’s being — preventing the realization of their individuality. This further ensures the individual will remain confined by their enslavement, perpetuating the cycle of oppression and impeded self-actualization. In <em>Beloved</em>, Toni Morrison uses the heart to symbolize the destructive nature of this calculated cycle and its terrifying power to subdue and suppress the will of the individual.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e9dd868cb055" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point/the-heart-as-a-beacon-of-freedom-beloved-by-toni-morrison-e9dd868cb055">The Heart as a Beacon of Freedom: Beloved by Toni Morrison</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point">The Still Point</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why is there something rather than nothing?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-still-point/why-is-there-something-rather-than-nothing-95de4036fcf5?source=rss-acf525f6767a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/95de4036fcf5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[existence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simone Lilavois]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 Mar 2024 16:21:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-20T16:21:14.424Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Why does the universe exist?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*aslEubwPGnBRuX9u.jpg" /><figcaption>Timeline of the universe. Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Bang#/media/File:CMB_Timeline300_no_WMAP.jpg">Wikipedia</a></figcaption></figure><p>Why is there something rather than nothing? This question emerged in my mind two years ago and I haven’t been able to shake it since. Musing on the beginning of space and time as we know them, I rewound the clock as far as it would take me: the Big Bang. Yet what came before this? Void? Darkness? What triggered the creation of something at all? Wouldn’t it have been far simpler for nothing to ever exist? If energy cannot be created or destroyed, how could something suddenly pop into existence? Questions swarmed my mind, relentless in their cyclical nature, each one taking me back to where I started: <em>why is there something rather than nothing?</em></p><p>This question is paradoxical. First, we must ask, what is “something” and what is “nothing?” The paradox lies in the fact that each phenomenon is defined in contrast to the other. Something is not nothing and nothing is the absence of something. And the concept of nothing is inherently something. This question also assumes that “nothingness” is even possible. “Nothingness” is not darkness or empty space; instead, it is the absence of anything at all. But “the absence of anything at all” is still something! Language is not capable of expressing what “nothing” is and our brains are not capable of grasping the concept. Perhaps the concept of “nothing” is itself flawed: perhaps there was no absolute beginning, no before, no discernable moment of total creation, only transformation. All that ever was is infinite, and “nothing” means…nothing.</p><p>Further, to ask “why” presupposes there is any reason at all for the existence of the universe. There may not be a reason, just like there may not be a reason for the gravitational constant to have the value it has. It simply exists the way it is. Or perhaps there is a reason, unintelligible to us, far beyond what we are capable of comprehending. Or perhaps it just comes down to mere probabilities, with no “why” involved. To ask “why” is entirely anthropocentric: this question can only be asked because we exist to ask it.</p><p>We are familiar with beginnings and endings, cause and effect, with the comfort of neat storylines where we can say when and where things happened and identify a “why.” The human mind tends to resort to absolutes: here or there, this or that, good or evil, something or nothing. Yet the truth may be far more complex than our primitive sensory organs can decipher. Humanity’s futile attempts to use subjective perceptions to define the objective nature of reality results in the creation of absolutes.</p><p>In one of my favorite series, <em>Dune</em>, Frank Herbert alludes to this in the fourth book, <em>God Emperor of Dune. </em>The God Emperor, more intimately known to readers as Leto Atreides II, is a prescient, near-immortal merge of human and sandworm — yes, if you didn’t make it that far, by the fourth book he does become a worm. The God Emperor is an ostensible tyrant who presides over humanity’s intergalactic network of civilization for nearly 4,000 years. He reflects:</p><blockquote>“In all of my universe I have seen no law of nature, unchanging and inexorable. This universe presents only changing relationships which are sometimes seen as laws by short-lived awareness. These fleshly sensoria which we call self are ephemera withering in the blaze of infinity, fleetingly aware of temporary conditions which confine our activities and change as our activities change. If you must label the absolute, use its proper name: Temporary”</blockquote><blockquote><em>(Herbert, 456).</em></blockquote><p>Though we have expanded (and will continue to expand) our understanding of the Cosmos through generations of observations, theories, experiments, and simulations, we will only ever perceive a fragment of the “something.” Because of this, I doubt we will ever be able to answer why “something” exists at all.</p><p>Reaching the understanding that the objective truth is an unattainable construct is profoundly humbling, yet it can be an opportunity for growth. By recognizing how humanity often reverts to the safety of absolutism to prescribe meaning, one may begin to overcome such limited, binary thinking. Once liberated from the necessity to find reason in the “something,” we may embrace the absurdity of our existence. Perhaps there is no why. Perhaps there was never “nothing.” We just simply <em>are</em>. But that doesn’t mean we should stop asking.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=95de4036fcf5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point/why-is-there-something-rather-than-nothing-95de4036fcf5">Why is there something rather than nothing?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point">The Still Point</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Robert Owen’s New Moral World: Education in a Utopian Socialist Society]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-still-point/robert-owens-new-moral-world-education-in-a-utopian-socialist-society-56183d835d97?source=rss-acf525f6767a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/56183d835d97</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[robert-owen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simone Lilavois]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 02 Mar 2024 17:38:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-02T17:38:26.304Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/680/0*7KwL7FK83tfFpDjq.jpg" /><figcaption>Source: <a href="https://www.newlanark.org/introducing-robert-owen">New Lanark World Heritage Site</a></figcaption></figure><p>Robert Owen, born May 14, 1771, in Newtown, Wales, was a philanthropist and utopian socialist. Recognizing how the trajectory of the industrial world threatened the social, political, and economic rights, along with the physical and mental well-being of the working class, Owen dedicated his life to creating what he called a “New Moral World.” This utopian socialist reimagination of society was based on cooperative living, fair employment, and full-time schooling for children. Owen pursued his vision as the manager of the New Lanark cotton mills, creating a work environment that prioritized the well-being of the employees, while also remaining efficient and profitable. Owen wrote a series of essays between 1812 and 1814, titled <em>A New View of Society</em>, which laid out the principles of his New Moral World. The essays also described how his philosophy was implemented at New Lanark. Above all else, Owen believed education had the power to shape human nature and consequently, educational reform was fundamental to his vision for a New Moral World.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*0FGLM41tzsGGxShI.jpg" /><figcaption>A portrait of Robert Owen by William Henry Brooke in 1834. Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Owen">Wikipedia</a></figcaption></figure><p>Owen’s success at New Lanark was not unfounded — he had experience as a businessman and knew how to be in charge of large operations. Earlier, at age 19, after a series of increasingly successful business ventures — from a wholesale drapery to a yarn spinning business — Robert Owen was put in charge of 500 workers as the manager at Drinkwater’s Bank Top Mill in Manchester. It was during a business trip to Glasgow, that Owen met Caroline Dale, his future wife, and was offered the chance to visit New Lanark, which was her father’s enterprise (<em>Introducing Robert Owen — New Lanark Visitor Centre</em>).</p><p>The New Lanark cotton mills were founded by David Dale and opened in 1786. Four large mills were constructed by waterfalls on River Clyde, to provide for the water-powered cotton spinning machinery. Housing, a school, and a church were also constructed for the workers. In the early 1790s, the population at New Lanark had grown substantially to about 2,000. Half of the population is suspected to have been under 18, most of whom were workers at the mills. New Lanark was not unique in the problems it faced as the population grew — such problems were being faced everywhere with the rise of industrialization. Problems commonly faced included “population growth, urbanisation, health and disease, crime and policing, children’s employment, adult unemployment, poverty and popular education” (“Robert Owen and New Lanark”). Children as young as six years old were often employed in dangerous working conditions, not receiving an education. Robert Owen became the mill manager in 1800 and followed in the path of Dale’s philanthropy work, who had already established a school to educate the children living at New Lanark. Owen spent the next 25 years, until 1825, in charge of New Lanark.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*o3PtEApxk92ewUza" /><figcaption>Lithographic print of a New Lanark advertisement. Source: <a href="https://universityofglasgowlibrary.wordpress.com/2011/03/11/new-lanark-collection-at-archive-services/">University of Glasgow Library Blog</a></figcaption></figure><p>Owen’s theories for a New Moral World were put into action at New Lanark. It was there that his work as a social reformer truly began. In “William Maclure’s Boatload of Knowledge: Science and Education into the Midwest,” Donald E. Pitzer describes the New Moral World as “a world of enlightenment and prosperity leading to human happiness, which Owen defined as mental, physical, and moral health enjoyed in a rational way of life. It would displace the Old Immoral World of ignorance, superstition, selfishness, and suffering intensified by the first wave of the Industrial Revolution” (Pitzer). At New Lanark, Owen instituted a range of new rules and practices. Much stricter than previous managers, he would dismiss an employee for “theft, fraud, absenteeism [or] persistent drunkenness” (<em>Introducing Robert Owen — New Lanark Visitor Centre</em>). Owen decreased the working day from 11 hours to 10.5 hours, began a village store, and hired a doctor to care for those who were ill. Owen also didn’t allow anyone under 10 years old to work at the mill. Rather, he established a free, full-time schooling program that began at age three (“View of New Lanark by John Winning”; <em>Introducing Robert Owen — New Lanark Visitor Centre</em>). In 1816, the “Institute for the Formation of Character” was opened at New Lanark. This was the basis for his philosophy. Owen wrote in the second of his <em>A New View of Society</em> essays: “Children are, without exception, passive and wonderfully contrived compounds; which, by an accurate previous and subsequent attention, founded on a correct knowledge of the subject, may be formed collectively to have any human character” (<em>A New View of Society by Robert Owen</em>). Owen also went on to write, “That any character, from the worst to the best, may, with the certainty of a law of nature, be given by society to all of the human race, — and that through this knowledge every one may be made to become at maturity, good, wise, and happy” (Owen, 10). Owen believed that the “making of a character” began at a young age, and that education was crucial to setting a child on the right path. He also believed that the formation of human character could be exacted to a science: “[Owen] came to feel that it was possible to discover the laws governing human nature and to have a practical science of society” (Pitzer). Owen described his work at New Lanark as “the most important experiment for the happiness of the human race that has yet been instituted in any part of the world” (<em>Introducing Robert Owen — New Lanark Visitor Centre</em>). Owen sought to establish this “practical science of society” to create a morally-just, enlightened, and prosperous world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*vQvQNVENgJYcjA8X.png" /><figcaption>Watercolor of New Lanark by John Winning, c. 1818. Source: <a href="https://www.newlanark.org/introducing-robert-owen">New Lanark World Heritage Site</a></figcaption></figure><p>In <em>The New Harmony Movement,</em> George Lockwood analyzes Robert Owen’s efforts for social reform: “Education, indeed, was at the very basis of Owen’s philosophy: man’s character, he insisted, was formed by his environment, and the only way of making good citizens was by providing conditions in which man’s better nature would be encouraged to grow, and in which body and mind would be well cared for and trained in right habits and ways of living. The whole benevolent system at New Lanark was based on this proposition” (Lockwood, vii). Schools at New Lanark were extremely progressive compared to what was available at the time. Lacking a rigid structure, an emphasis on memorization, and a reward-punishment system, Owen’s education system was a stark difference from traditional schools. Dancing, physical exercise, and play were held in high regard. The following image, made by artist George Hunt in 1825, is a depiction of a dancing class at The Institute for the Formation of Character in New Lanark (“Mr. Owen’s Institution, New Lanark”).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/0*_B19Jz4bZ24-rst0" /><figcaption>Source: <a href="https://digitalcollections.nypl.org/items/04b21590-06de-0132-b099-58d385a7bbd0">NYPL</a></figcaption></figure><p>The image shows children at New Lanark wearing the uniform Owen designed for them, which was “a toga like garment made of white cotton that was light and comfortable for the children to wear and well suited to dancing and physical activity” (<em>Introducing Robert Owen — New Lanark Visitor Centre</em>). One of Owen’s sons, Robert Dale Owen, gave a detailed account of the room depicted above in his 1824 book about the Institute: “The [room] has the walls hung round with representations of the most striking zoological and mineralogical specimens…At one end there is a gallery, adapted for the purpose of an orchestra, and at the other end are hung very large representations of the two hemispheres…This room is used as a lecture- and ball-room, and it is here that the dancing and singing lessons are daily given” (<em>Education in Robert Owen’s New Society: The New Lanark Institute and Schools</em>).</p><p>The schooling system at New Lanark was designed so that children would be spared from their parents’ prejudices as early as possible. This was because Owen believed parents who had not received a proper education and lacked a good character would be a poor influence on their children. Thus, as soon as a child could walk, they were put under the supervision of older children at the nursery (<em>Introducing Robert Owen — New Lanark Visitor Centre</em>). Because of this, mothers, who would normally spend their time looking after a child, could instead spend that time working at the mills. From age 3–6, children at New Lanark went to the “infant school.” The infant school was held outside, weather permitting, and “no child [was] forced in any way, not even to mid-morning rest, although ‘when an infant felt inclined to sleep it should be quietly allowed to do so’” (<em>Education in Robert Owen’s New Society: The New Lanark Institute and Schools</em>). Then, from 7–10, children attended the “junior school.” Here, lessons included “nature study, history, geography and art, as well as reading, writing and arithmetic” (<em>Introducing Robert Owen — New Lanark Visitor Centre</em>). Field studies were also incorporated into the curriculum. Owen had cleared paths through the surrounding fields and forest for students to take walks through and collect specimens (<em>Education in Robert Owen’s New Society: The New Lanark Institute and Schools</em>). The school was progressive, with no corporal punishment. Music and dancing were incorporated into the curriculum. It was emphasized that children always understood what they were learning, why they were learning it, and that they enjoyed school. Even as children began to work in the mills, they were encouraged to continue their education through evening classes provided at the Institute.</p><p>Owen was convinced that he could use his model of cooperative living at New Lanark to develop a utopian society that would transform the world. Pitzer writes, “To accomplish his secular utopia, Owen proposed that democratic, socialistic “communities of equality” averaging 1,200 persons each should be created worldwide” (Pitzer). In 1825, Owen purchased a plot of land in Indiana, investing half of his savings into his social experiment. Owen recruited teachers, scientists, and philanthropists who aligned with his mission, and invited “any and all to come.” In April 1825, after arriving in New Harmony, Indiana, Owen proclaimed: “I am come to this country…to introduce an entire new system of society; to change it from an ignorant, selfish system to an enlightened social system which shall gradually unite all interests into one, and remove all causes for contest between individuals” (Lockwood, x). While New Lanark was only able to actualize part of Owen’s vision, New Harmony gave him total freedom to build the world he envisioned. Though New Harmony only lasted a few years, from ~1825–1828, Owen never gave up promoting his educational philosophy. As Owen declared in his Address to the Inhabitants of New Lanark on the day the Institute for the Formation of Character opened, January 1, 1816:</p><blockquote>“The causes which fashioned me in the womb, — the circumstances by which I was surrounded from my birth, and over which I had no influence whatever…gave me a mind that could not rest satisfied without trying every possible expedient to relieve my fellow-men from their wretched situation, and formed it of such a texture that obstacles of the most formidable nature served but to increase my ardour, and to fix within me a settled determination, either to overcome them, or to die in the attempt”</blockquote><blockquote>(<em>Robert Owen: An Address to the Inhabitants of New Lanark</em>).</blockquote><p>A social reformer ahead of his time, Owen committed his life to his vision for a New Moral World, truly believing a re-arrangement of society was on the horizon. In the words of Frank Podmore, “Robert Owen was essentially a dreamer, and it is ultimately the dreamers that move the world” (Podmore).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*ihEjtLVriOX6bPPO.jpg" /><figcaption>Source: <a href="https://www.newlanark.org/introducing-robert-owen">New Lanark World Heritage Site</a></figcaption></figure><blockquote><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ib_Fa0-n87EEKfV14r8lodQ3DNfUkmHeKV6VYvWo8sI/edit?usp=sharing">References</a></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=56183d835d97" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point/robert-owens-new-moral-world-education-in-a-utopian-socialist-society-56183d835d97">Robert Owen’s New Moral World: Education in a Utopian Socialist Society</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point">The Still Point</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Scholars Divided: Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois on Black Progress]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-still-point/scholars-divided-booker-t-washington-and-w-e-b-du-bois-on-black-progress-2ff478d15bdf?source=rss-acf525f6767a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2ff478d15bdf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[civil-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[united-states]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simone Lilavois]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 02 Mar 2024 00:35:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-02T00:35:53.225Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*WmkUNR72x--KvQPw.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*t2s1Hw1-s3qfb6bC.jpg" /><figcaption>Left: Booker T. Washington (Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Booker_T._Washington">Wikipedia</a>). Right: W.E.B. Du Bois (Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._E._B._Du_Bois">Wikipedia</a>).</figcaption></figure><p>Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois are considered two of the most influential figures during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Both intellectuals lived through Reconstruction and pioneered the movement for Black equality in America, though they employed different strategies. The origin of their distinct approaches to gaining Black rights can be traced back to their early lives and the environments in which they grew up. Washington, born in 1856, spent the first nine years of his life enslaved on a plantation in Virginia. Conversely, Du Bois, who was born in 1868 in Massachusetts, grew up in a family that had been free for generations — it is believed Du Bois’ maternal great-great-grandfather, Tom Burghardt, gained his freedom from serving in the Continental Army during the American Revolutionary War. As such, two disparate figures emerged: Washington grew up having experienced the barbarity of slavery firsthand, lived through the Civil War, and received a vocational education at the Hampton Institute, whereas Du Bois knew freedom from birth, and grew up in an America where slavery was abolished and citizenship and voting rights for Blacks were promised. Du Bois pursued academic education, eventually becoming the first Black man to receive a Ph.D. from Harvard University. Thus, the two matured in starkly contrasting realities. This led to their contrasting approaches to fighting for Black equality. Yet although the two are notoriously portrayed as polar opposites, Washington and Du Bois were two sides of the same coin; both wanted the same thing, and both agreed that education for Blacks was a critical precursor to achieving their goals, yet they disagreed on the most effective type of education and method to reach their objectives.</p><p>Every social movement throughout history has had leaders who disagreed. Variety in leadership and constructive criticism of varying opinions are necessary for growth and change. The question then becomes: between the two scholars, who was right? The distinct strategies of Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois to reach Black equality were similarly biased and inversely valuable, yet not equally effective, and their dispute further nurtured their respective ideologies.</p><p>On September 18, 1895, Washington delivered the most notable speech of his life: The Atlanta Exposition at the Cotton States and International Exposition held in Atlanta, Georgia (a recording of the speech was made in 1908, which you can listen to <a href="https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/civil-rights-act/multimedia/booker-t-washington.html">here</a>). The audience was nearly all white and responded favorably to Washington’s message: Blacks should not prioritize advocating for social or civil rights at the moment; instead, they should pursue vocational education to become an integral part of the workforce. Washington argued that civil rights would naturally follow once Blacks were recognized as essential to the American economy. While Washington’s gradualist ideology has been criticized by many for being too conciliatory, his position was born from his intimate knowledge of the practicality of vocational education in the South. Near the end of his speech, Washington declared,</p><blockquote>“In all things that are purely social, we can be as separate as the fingers, yet as one hand in all things essential to mutual progress<em>…</em>The wisest among my race understand that the agitation of questions of social equality is the extremist folly, and that progress in the enjoyment of all the privileges that will come to us must be the result of severe and constant struggle rather than of artificial forcing. No race that has anything to contribute to the markets of the world is long in any degree ostracized. <strong>It is important and right that all privileges of the law be ours, but it is vastly more important that we be prepared for the exercise of these privileges.</strong> The opportunity to earn a dollar in a factory just now is worth infinitely more than the opportunity to spend a dollar in an opera-house…”</blockquote><blockquote>(<em>Booker T. Washington’s “Atlanta Compromise” Speech — Library of Congress</em>).</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*_FgeST5lW4-UTis3Aru5gg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Washington delivering his speech at the Atlanta Exposition in 1895. Source: <a href="https://blogs.loc.gov/now-see-hear/2021/09/from-the-recording-registry-booker-t-washingtons-atlanta-exposition-speech-of-1895/">Library of Congress</a></figcaption></figure><p>Though the conclusion of his speech was met with roaring applause, handshakes, and bouquets of flowers, there became a growing controversy over Washington’s words. White supremacists saw in his ideas an opportunity to further disenfranchise Blacks and perpetuate Jim Crow laws without resistance. And over time, many Blacks, including Du Bois, came to view the ideas communicated in his speech as an obstacle to Black progress. Du Bois would go on to argue that Washington’s “Atlanta Compromise” (a name Du Bois coined to expose what he considered a compromise of Blacks’ rights) encouraged complacency among Black Americans and acceptance as an inferior class. In the Atlanta Compromise, Washington promoted socially regressive conditions for Blacks, yet his ideas were “born out of present [southern] reality” (<em>W.E.B. Du Bois — The Atlantic</em>). The placative nature of Washington’s ideas lead many to wrongly believe that he didn’t think political and social rights were important for Blacks; however, it is quite the opposite, as pointed out by Rose D. Greco in “The Educational Views of Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois: A Critical Comparison.” Greco writes, “Washington proposed industrial education not because he wanted to limit the Blacks but because he wanted them to build a strong economic base to enter the world of business and commerce” (Greco, 63). Du Bois’ contentions, though justified in hindsight, came from a place of privilege and idealistic ignorance, having grown up in the North sheltered from the harsh circumstances Washington faced his entire life. C. Spencer Poxpey explores this in “The Washington-Du Bois Controversy and Its Effect on the Negro Problem:”</p><blockquote>“[Washington knew the South] as well as anyone…He knew, as Du Bois could not know, the antipathies of the leading class and the lower whites who were to take over and make worse the Negro problem. He knew by experience the problems faced by the Negroes, the vast majority of whom were living in a section where the stresses and strains were at the breaking point. He knew where the points of conciliation were; indeed, he was an integral part of that society. He had first-hand knowledge of the high illiteracy of both the whites and the Negroes…”</blockquote><blockquote><em>(Poxpey, 129–130).</em></blockquote><p>With this in mind, Washington’s “conservative” approach, though accommodative and narrow-lensed, is understandable, perhaps even practical for many southern Blacks, for a brief time. His stance was molded by his experience and the same can be said for Du Bois.</p><p>Though the two are often portrayed as always having opposing beliefs, Du Bois initially supported Washington’s stance. In fact, in a letter sent to Washington after the Atlanta Compromise speech, Du Bois congratulated Washington on “a word fitly spoken” (<em>Letter from W.E.B. Du Bois to Booker T. Washington, September 24, 1895 — Columbia University</em>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/589/0*cj73Pa__jUIXV2YZ.jpg" /><figcaption>Du Bois’ letter to Washington congratulating him on “a word fitly spoken.” Source: <a href="https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/african-american-odyssey/booker-t-washington-era.html">Library of Congress</a></figcaption></figure><p>However, Du Bois’ position diverged at the turn of the 20th century. In “Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. Du Bois: The Problem of Negro Leadership,”<strong> </strong>Robert A. Gibson analyzes “Of Mr. Booker T. Washington and Others,” an essay Du Bois included in his 1903 book, <em>The Souls of Black Folk</em>. Gibson writes,</p><blockquote>“[In the essay] Du Bois charged that Washington’s program tacitly accepted the alleged inferiority of the Negro. Expressing the sentiment of the radical civil rights advocates, Du Bois demanded for all Black citizens 1) the right to vote, 2) civic equality, and 3) the education of Negro youth according to ability. Generally, Du Bois opposed Washington’s program because it was narrow in its scope and objectives, devalued the study of the liberal arts, and ignored civil, political, and social injustices and the economic exploitation of the Black masses”</blockquote><blockquote>(<em>Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. DuBois: The Problem of Negro Leadership — Yale New Haven Teachers Institute</em>).</blockquote><p>Du Bois approached the fight for Black equality with fierce promptitude, in a manner that did not try to accommodate the wishes of whites. With progressive awareness, he argued that vocational education was not sufficient to overcome racial inequality. In “The W. E. B. DuBois and Booker T. Washington Debate: Effects upon African American Roles in Engineering and Engineering Technology,” Keith V. Johnson and Elwood Watson discuss the ultimate abandonment of vocational education with the growing industrialization of the South and country as a whole. In the following excerpt, Johnson and Watson use quotes from Michael R. Wintson in his 1971 paper “Through the Back Door: Academic Racism and the Negro Scholar in Historical Perspective:”</p><blockquote>“Educationally, vocational training was a failure: It not only failed to prepare Blacks to move up in society, but it also guaranteed that they would move down. The emphasis on manual training and the trades served to destroy the educational aspirations that had been aroused during Reconstruction and wiped out the hope that education could provide a way out of poverty. By 1930 industrial education was seen as a “cynical political strategy, not a sound educational policy” and proved to be the “great detour” for Blacks from which they are just beginning to return”</blockquote><blockquote><em>(Johnston and Watson, 66; Winston, 683).</em></blockquote><p>And so, while Washington’s approach may have been temporarily valuable, it was not an effective long-term strategy to gain Black equality and eventually became obsolete.</p><p>Du Bois also advocated for the establishment of what he called the “Talented Tenth.” In <em>The Autobiography of W. E. B. Du Bois, </em>Du Bois explained the ideology: “I believed in the higher education of a Talented Tenth who through their knowledge of modern culture could guide the American Negro into a higher civilization…” (Du Bois, 70). This idea has been categorized by some as an “elitist approach,” relying on a highly-educated top 10% of the Black population to cultivate change for the masses. Yet it was this idea that guided Du Bois and others in the creation of the Niagra Movement in 1905 and ultimately the NAACP in 1910. Both Washington and Du Bois fought for the same fundamental goal: Black equality. Their dispute “polarized African American leaders into two wings–the ‘conservative’ supporters of Washington and his ‘radical’ critics” (Booker T &amp; W.E.B | The Two Nations Of Black America — PBS). Neither was completely “right” — they addressed the problem with their unique perspectives, yet Du Bois’ approach was more progressive and effective. In an interview with Du Bois in 1963, at age 95, only months before he died, Du Bois reflected on his philosophical feud with Washington. Du Bois said, “I never thought Washington was a bad man…I believed him to be sincere, though wrong…I admired much about him. Washington died in 1915. A lot of people think I died at the same time ” (<em>W.E.B. Du Bois — The Atlantic</em>). The rivalry between the two was tangible, as though it had a life of its own, and it catalyzed the development of their respective ideologies.</p><p>Washington knew that many southern Blacks needed to work their way up; they could not immediately advocate for political rights if they did not even know what those rights entailed and did not know how to read or write. Du Bois knew that becoming an integral part of the American economy would not guarantee social and political rights for Blacks. An elitist class did not need to lead the Black population. And a working class did not need to dominate the Black population. For change to occur, there needed to be a balance of both. The two distinct approaches represented the bifurcating needs of Black Americans. Washington understood and personalized with many southern Blacks, and his approach catered to the needs of formerly enslaved Blacks and their children. Yet that population was shrinking and a newer, more progressive strategy was needed to fight for Blacks’ rights. Du Bois, unlike Washington, was able to envision a future where southern Blacks did not need to wait to obtain social and political rights. While the rivalry between Washington and Du Bois may have temporarily weakened the movement for Black equality in the early 20th century, their feud also fueled a generation of revolutionary thinkers. The publicity of the Washington-Du Bois controversy fostered a renewed national focus on the educational, social, and political rights of Black Americans, paving the way for the Civil Rights movement only a few decades later.</p><blockquote><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1jGXUxAok8oJs4RUZPWgNOYMdhVOYpatJaTh_9BLMfIk/edit?usp=sharing">References</a></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2ff478d15bdf" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point/scholars-divided-booker-t-washington-and-w-e-b-du-bois-on-black-progress-2ff478d15bdf">Scholars Divided: Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois on Black Progress</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point">The Still Point</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How British Colonialism Contributed to Violence During the Partition of India in 1947]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-still-point/how-british-colonialism-contributed-to-violence-during-the-partition-of-india-in-1947-eee3d77ef77d?source=rss-acf525f6767a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eee3d77ef77d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pakistan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Simone Lilavois]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 Feb 2024 00:33:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-29T00:34:09.212Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*6f5bGkpzLA2DXOkm.jpg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*m6Oc-qMjqsrSPwGj.jpg" /><figcaption><em>Refugees crowded emergency trains leaving to India or Pakistan c. 1947–1953 (</em><a href="http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File%3AEmergency_trains_crowded_with_desperate_refugees.jpg"><em>left</em></a><em>). These trains continued for years after 1947, such as the train leaving India for Pakistan in 1954 (</em><a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:A_refugee_special_train_at_Ambala_Station_during_partition_of_India.jpg"><em>right</em></a><em>).</em></figcaption></figure><p>The partition of India was an impetuous attempt to force peace among a religiously divided nation. The British Indian Empire rushed through the process to grant India its independence, and in doing so, induced the largest mass migration in human history, characterized by its brutal outbreaks of violence and irreparable political damage. Religious conflict, inflamed by British imperialism, was the central instigator of violence during the mass migration following the partition of India in 1947.</p><h4><strong>Background</strong></h4><p>The existence of both Hindu and Muslim cultures in India can be traced back to the Islamic conquest of Lahore (today the capital of the Punjab province in Pakistan) in 1021 by Persianized Turks led by <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahmud_of_Ghazni">Sultan Mahmud of Ghazni</a> of the Ghaznavid Empire. Over the next few centuries, a unique merging of the two cultures occurred, creating a blended Indo-Islamic civilization. British rule began at the turn of the 16th century with the creation of the East India Company (EIC) — a corporation flagrantly akin to a power-hungry nation. The EIC transformed over time, originally only meant for trading goods such as cotton, silk, tea, and spices. However, as wealth grew, so did the imperialistic desire for more territory regardless of the effects. By 1803, the EIC had an army of nearly 260,000 soldiers, ready to defend the company and carry out their aggressive colonial objectives. In the 1850s, the EIC’s misguided involvement in local politics began to incite frequent violence and revolts.</p><p>In 1857 there was a series of uprisings by Indian soldiers employed with EIC. As the uprisings got increasingly more violent and the lives of British soldiers were lost, the British government decided a more direct rule of India was needed and took control of the EIC’s assets, effectively abolishing the corporation. In 1858, the British Raj assumed control of India without the consent of the people, disrupting decades of peaceful social, cultural, and political development. This was made official on August 2, 1858, with the passing of the Government of India Act, where autocracy was transferred from the company to the royal crown.</p><p>Succeeding the Second World War, mass decolonization efforts were instated. With the end of WWII and the formation of the United Nations, the world was in a fragile state. Britain saw their rule over India, as well as all of its major colonies, as outdated and wanted to withdraw as hastily as possible, even at the expense of India’s political stability. On August 15th, 1947, British rule in India officially ended and partition was instated, followed by one of the largest and most violent migrations in human history. The partition was officially declared in the Indian Independence Act 1947 and resulted in the creation of two self-governing independent dominions which legally came into existence at midnight on August 15, 1947, marking the disunion of the British Raj. That night, British India was divided into two independent dominions: The Dominion of India (which is the Republic of India today) and the Dominion of Pakistan (which is the Islamic Republic of Pakistan and the People’s Republic of Bangladesh today). Bengal and Punjab, two major provinces, were also divided during partition based on district-wide non-Muslim or Muslim majorities. The Partition was partially instated out of necessity by the British Empire (they were in economic crisis after the war), however, the social movement led by Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi provoked a profound change in the attitude towards colonial powers — something which heavily contributed to the fall of the British Colonial Empire.</p><p>Following the partition, millions of Muslims migrated to West and East Pakistan (East Pakistan is now known as Bangladesh), while millions of Hindus and Sikhs migrated to the slightly shrunken India. Partition abruptly ended over two centuries of British rule, simultaneously disrupting decades of coexistence between the two religions. The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees estimates nearly 15 million Hindus, Sikhs, and Muslims were displaced during the partition of India, with a death toll of up to two million. There was an unprecedented amount of sexually motivated and gender-based violence, with terrifying statistics reporting over 75,000 women raped, with many, many more subject to sexual abuse. Beyond this, there were innumerable, senseless violent acts throughout the migration, including massacres, arson, forced conversions, mass abductions, and child violence.</p><p>Indian nationalism first gained attention with the formation of The Indian National Congress (INC) in 1885, which acted as the central opposition party to the British Empire. Partition itself can be traced back to the creation of the INC. The ideology behind partition grew in popularity with the INC and truly began with India’s first direct resistance towards British rule, around WWI. An important turning point in the movement was the explosion in Gandhi’s popularity — The Salt March in April 1930.</p><p>Gandhi returned to India in 1915 after two decades of Indian activism in South Africa and began his movement for Indian independence. His first act under the satyagraha campaign of the INC was to protest the British Salt Act of 1882 which prevented Indians from collecting or selling salt. Gandhi organized a 240-mile march of civil disobedience. The original crowd of just under 100 quickly grew as thousands of people joined along the way, united by their oppression. The destination of the march was Dandi, a town on the Arabian Sea. By the time Gandhi and his followers reached the coastal town on April 5th, there were nearly 50,000 people with him. To protest British policy, the plan was to make salt from seawater. It was a clever and effective act of opposition, a challenge to autocratic rule. With his position in the INC and his natural diplomacy, Gandhi quickly grew to fame. He was idolized and in some cases even worshiped and deified for his non-violent methods of protest. He was regarded as “Mahatma” by many of his followers, which translates to “the great-souled one.” As a member of the INC, Gandhi worked constantly to promote Indian Nationalism, for both Hindus and Muslims, peacefully.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uCPQLaYXFI9WoXmo.jpg" /><figcaption>Gandhi leading a group of people during the Salt March in March 1930. Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salt_March">Wikipedia</a></figcaption></figure><p>On the other side of the spectrum lies Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the founding father of Pakistan. Originally, Jinnah was an advocate of a hybrid Hindu-Muslim civilization. He was a member of the Indian National Congress as well and worked to strengthen bonds between the INC and the All-India Muslim League. In 1916 he was elected president of the Muslim League. However, in 1920, when the INC embraced satyagraha — Gandhi’s ideology of “holding firmly to truth” through nonviolent protest — Jinnah was firmly against the approach and resigned from the INC. At this point, the Muslim League and the INC had significant differences in the objectives and methods by which they carried out their work.</p><p>Though the INC was supposed to represent all of India, many Muslims felt overshadowed by the Hindu majority and began to pull back. Most of the issues on which the INC was divided were related to religious disagreement. Then, in the 1937 Indian Provincial elections, the Indian National Congress won by an overwhelming majority and spectacularly failed to represent Muslims. Of the 482 Muslim seats available, the INC contested only 58 of them and won a mere 26. When Jinnah requested to form coalitions between the INC and the Muslim League, he was denied. This marked a major bifurcation in Indian politics, eventually leading to the partition of India. While partition can largely be attributed to imperialistic British rule, the extreme religious division during the mid-20th century was heavily intertwined with the extreme political divide. Specifically, a lot of it came down to the discord between the personalities of Jinnah and Gandhi. The incompatibility of the politicians at the time furthered the tension between the two religious groups, as each was seen as a representative figure of the entire religious body.</p><p>Gandhi was imprisoned multiple times in his life, most notably when he demanded British succession from India at the start of WWII. He offered that India would cooperate with the war effort and provide soldiers in return for their absolute independence. In response, British forces imprisoned Gandhi along with the entire INC leadership. During this period, the Muslim League was able to gain strength and popularity, no longer overshadowed by the regular Hindu-majority leaders. As the Muslim nationalist movement grew, it seemed less and less likely for any type of peaceful coexistence. In Lahore in 1940, at a Muslim League session, the first official demand was made for the partition of India. Here it was first suggested to create the Muslim state of Pakistan.</p><p>As outbreaks of religiously motivated violence became frequent, congress members who had originally opposed partition began to consider it as the only remaining viable option. According to the New Yorker, “the British realized that they had lost any remaining vestiges of control and began to speed up their exit strategy. On the afternoon of February 20, 1947, the British Prime Minister, Clement Atlee, announced before Parliament that British rule would end on “a date not later than June, 1948.” If Nehru and Jinnah could be reconciled by then, power would be transferred to “some form of central Government for British India.” If not, they would hand over authority “in such other way as may seem most reasonable and in the best interests of the Indian people.”” (The New Yorker, 2015). Then, four months later, in early June, a minor royal named Lord Louis Mountbatten announced August 15, 1947, as the official date for the partition and exit of the British Empire. This transfer of power was now to occur ten months earlier than initially planned. A British judge named Cyril Radcliffe was given only five weeks to redraw the borders of South Asia and halt an impending outbreak of sectarian violence. It was a monumental task that was clumsily rushed through and given to a man who had never before been to India. According to the New Yorker, following the partition, Jinnah regarded the territory given to the Muslims as “a maimed, mutilated and moth-eaten travesty” of the land he had fought for. He warned that the partition of Punjab and Bengal “will be sowing the seeds of future serious trouble.””” (The New Yorker, 2015). This was a major foreshadow for the events to follow.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wTc4Jbc4CGIVYosO.png" /><figcaption>Map showing the “Radcliffe Line” dividing the newly independent dominions. Source: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radcliffe_Line">Wikipedia</a></figcaption></figure><p>Once partition was made official, the British Army was mandated to exit India. According to Stanford University, “In Punjab, confidential instructions insisted that British army units had no operational functions except in emergency to save British lives.” (Stanford, 2019). This was a selfish attempt, an act of self-interest to stay out of “internal conflicts,” especially when India’s own army was unstable, unable to prevent violence, and secretarially divided. It is grossly analogous to the actions of the Belgian army and UN Peacekeepers during the Rwandan genocide. Conditions that had been imposed by the oppressive party were now left to be dealt with by the innocent masses.</p><p>Despite all his devoted followers, and despite his own identity as a Hindu, Gandhi was assassinated by a Hindu radical on January 30th, 1948. His death brought a public reaction unlike any other: over one million people attended his procession. Gandhi’s embrace of a hybrid Hindu-Muslim civilization eventually brought his downfall — an ironic portrayal of the extent of the religious conflict. The toxic environment that had been created spewed such hatred that a young radical would kill the leader of his own party. Gandhi died a victim of his own principles.</p><p>When analyzing the causes and eventual effects of the partition of India, it is imperative to consider the role played by the British Empire. The 1947 partition of India and the violent migration that ensued were direct results of British imperialism and its efforts to exacerbate religious divisions. As written by British historian Alex von Tunzelmann, in <em>Indian Summer: The Secret History of the End of an Empire</em>, “[when] the British started to define ‘communities’ based on religious identity and attach political representation to them, many Indians stopped accepting the diversity of their own thoughts and began to ask themselves in which of the boxes they belonged.” (von Tunzelmann, 2007). This piece of evidence provides further background context regarding the role that Britain played in exacerbating the conflict. The greed of state formation overtook the independent, stable cultural, religious, and political development of a society. Once politics and religion were intertwined, the line that separated faith and political belief was blurred. This significantly contributed to the religious divide in British India.</p><p>Further, as British scholar Yasmin Khan brilliantly writes in <em>The Great Partition</em>, “[Partition] stands testament to the follies of empire, which ruptures community evolution, distorts historical trajectories and forces violent state formation from societies that would otherwise have taken different — and unknowable — paths.” (Khan, 2007). This quote provides insight into the overarching effects of partition as an imperialistic mechanism and how it connects to a much bigger idea about the nature of imperialism. Imperialism inhibits cultural development and in the case of partition, the intertwining of faith and politics led to a failed democracy.</p><p>Ayesha Jalal, a Pakistani-American historian, is a descendant of partition survivors. In one of her books, <em>In ​​The Pity of Partition: Manto’s Life, Times, and Work across the India-Pakistan Divide,</em> Jalal quotes her uncle, Saadat Hasan Manto, a Bombay-based writer. She writes, “the pity of partition was not that instead of one country there were now two — independent India and independent Pakistan — but the fact that “human beings in both countries were slaves, slaves of bigotry . . . slaves of religious passions, slaves of animal instincts and barbarity.”” (Jalal, 2013). This quote speaks to the role human nature played in the mass outbreaks of violence and how the hatred spread. The people themselves are not fully at fault — yes, atrocities were committed, but it was the diabolical situation that caused the outbreaks of mass violence. Jalal further says, “His [Manto’s] main point really is that you can’t blame people; that it’s the circumstances that lead people to this kind of human bestiality.” The circumstances were imposed by the British.</p><p>The intertwining of faith and politics was the underlying reason for all push factors for the migration during the partition of India in 1947. Gruesomely described in <em>Midnight Furies</em> by Hajari, “Gangs of killers set whole villages aflame, hacking to death men and children and the aged while carrying off young women to be raped. Some British soldiers and journalists who had witnessed the Nazi death camps claimed Partition’s brutalities were worse: pregnant women had their breasts cut off and babies hacked out of their bellies; infants were found literally roasted on spits.” (Hajari, 2015). There was unspeakable violence committed during the migration after the partition of India. This quote reveals the unfiltered reality of the violence that occurred during the partition. It provides information for understanding the horrors that tore communities and families apart. The transition following the partition was not a smooth one. The process of one nation separating into two severed decade-long relations and disrupted the economic stability of both. Agricultural systems were broken apart, some were left without sellers, and some without buyers. Supply and demand chains were dismantled, businesses were forced to close down, and railroads were put out of service. Entire villages were burnt to the ground — their inhabitants massacred. The region was left in a state of seemingly irreparable devastation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/976/0*YNlgDz9sbQFDGy9f.jpg" /><figcaption>Buildings were destroyed during riots. Source: <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-south-asia-62467438">BBC</a></figcaption></figure><p>Throughout the 1940s, violence between the two religious parties only escalated. Increasingly polarized ghettos were formed and the once abundant blend of cultures was rarely found. According to the <em>New Yorker</em>, “Tensions were often heightened by local and regional political leaders. H. S. Suhrawardy, the ruthless Muslim League Chief Minister of Bengal, made incendiary speeches in Calcutta, provoking rioters against his own Hindu populace and writing in a newspaper that “bloodshed and disorder are not necessarily evil in themselves, if resorted to for a noble cause.”” The mass religious violence that ensued after the partition of India in 1947 was an inevitable manifestation of imperialistic division.</p><p>Beyond southern Asia, the reality of the barbaric violence that followed partition was not widely known. This could be attributed to the fact that it was not accurately reported by Britain. Biased media and historical reports distorted the severity of the violence during the mass migration and covered up the role Britain played in exacerbating the conflict by rushing through partition. As said by Nisid Hajari, the author of <em>Midnight’s Furies: The Deadly Legacy of India’s Partition</em>, “At the time [following partition], there was an impetus to portray the moment of independence as a triumph — that after 200 years of colonial rule, the British could part as friends. If you emphasize the death and violence, that tarnishes the achievement.” This was done to cover up that much of the blame could be placed on Britain. Partition was avoidable up until the last months. Gandhi was adamantly against it, and so was Jinnah, though less vocally. Though tensions had been building up throughout the messy British rule, the British could have put in more effort to exit the country peacefully and sagaciously. Religious violence was only triggered later.</p><p>Stanford University put together a virtual partition museum with over 50 interviews with partition survivors. It is an incredible collection of forgotten stories, family traumas, and childhood memories. For far too long the focus of partition has been on the stories of politicians, the leaders of the movement, and well-known historical events. Never has there been enough focus on those who actually suffered from partition, those who were subject to the abhorrent violence: the civilians. As written in The Guardian, “Partition history used to be all about the high politics and the relative responsibilities of Mountbatten, Jinnah, Gandhi and Nehru — these four men have always towered over the story, and ultimately their animosities and the reasons they failed to agree on a constitutional settlement make them the leading actors of an enduring and gripping drama — but today many historians are far more interested in the fate of refugees in the camps, the ways in which villagers experienced the uprooting of 1947, or how they rebuilt their lives in the aftermath.” (The Guardian, 2017). The exhibit available through the Stanford Library is an attempt to tell the world the story of partition before the last generation of survivors can no longer tell it themselves.</p><p>One oral history report given by Sardar Tarlochan Singh, a Sikh, who was only 14 when partition took place, is especially moving. Tarlochan said, “Many other nations had situations like ours, but no blood shed like the one we saw, half a million lost lives. It’s hard to imagine how neighbors living next to each other became enemies, we became like animals, I saw people being killed, houses being burned, bodies of the people flowing in the canals and people being shot in trains…one can’t imagine how a human can be so wild.” (Stanford Library, 2012).</p><p>Today, India and Pakistan remain in religious conflict. For South Asia, partition was a defining historical event of the 20th century and its effects are still prevalent today, especially as the media continues to spread false information. Since August 1947, there have been three Indo-Pakistani wars over territory. India tested its first nuclear weapon in 1974, followed by Pakistan in 1988. Tensions are only rising. As said in Midnight Furies by Nisid Hajari, “[The conflict between India and Pakistan] is getting more, rather than less, dangerous: the two countries’ nuclear arsenals are growing, militant groups are becoming more capable, and rabid media outlets on both sides are shrinking the scope for moderate voices.” (Hajari, 2015). The conflict is only worsening — if things aren’t eased soon, the spark of tension threatens to once more transform into a raging fire. The effects of partition have no discernable end. It was an unprecedented example of the inhibitions of imperialism and the detestable capabilities of humanity when pushed to hatred. Seeds of division planted by the British Empire flourished into an unavoidable outbreak of violent human nature under a diabolical situation. Partition could have been avoided had the peaceful coexistence of Hindus and Muslims not been besieged by unhinged, manic religious nationalism. Partition was an example of how the bridging of politics and religion is always dangerous: to associate one political party with the voice of God is to condemn the freedom of democracy. This vicious cycle of hatred and violence will only continue unless we can find ways to transcend social labels and the historical baggage they hold.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*-RGVYGTQrtgRBYIl.jpg" /><figcaption>Jinnah with Gandhi in 1944. Source: <a href="https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Photograph_of_Jinnah_with_Gandhi_in_1944_%28Photo_429-17%29.jpg">Wikipedia</a></figcaption></figure><blockquote><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kt-2m8QEgNwdXdyvK1c0jeEfpKvWGMRp-Y2Itoa5xdg/edit?usp=sharing">References</a></blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eee3d77ef77d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point/how-british-colonialism-contributed-to-violence-during-the-partition-of-india-in-1947-eee3d77ef77d">How British Colonialism Contributed to Violence During the Partition of India in 1947</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-still-point">The Still Point</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>