<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Frank J. Wyatt on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Frank J. Wyatt on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@tallyfy?source=rss-6e478a9a46e8------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 21:09:45 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@tallyfy/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is MavenLink?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tallyfy/what-is-mavenlink-71a373f4f68b?source=rss-6e478a9a46e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/71a373f4f68b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Frank J. Wyatt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 May 2019 18:01:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-06T18:01:23.390Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>This post has moved to this URL: <a href="https://tallyfy.com/what-is-mavenlink/">https://tallyfy.com/what-is-mavenlink/</a></h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=71a373f4f68b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We are moving :)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/we-are-moving-58e63f278638?source=rss-6e478a9a46e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/58e63f278638</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Frank J. Wyatt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Apr 2019 17:40:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-07T17:40:05.417Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Hi everyone — all future posts will be on the blog at <a href="https://tallyfy.com/">https://tallyfy.com/</a></p><p>To subscribe to updates with Tallyfy and more articles — please visit this link:</p><p><a href="https://tallyfy.com/newsletter/">https://tallyfy.com/newsletter/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=58e63f278638" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/we-are-moving-58e63f278638">We are moving :)</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons">On Business Process Management and Workflow Automation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Pros and Cons of Asana — With 5 Asana Alternatives]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/project-management-tools/pros-and-cons-of-asana-with-asana-alternatives-5fa894a107a5?source=rss-6e478a9a46e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5fa894a107a5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trello]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[asana]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[process-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wrike]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[project-management]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Frank J. Wyatt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Mar 2019 16:22:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-06T18:02:36.046Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Pros and Cons of Asana — With 5 Asana Alternatives</h3><p>This post has moved to this URL: <a href="https://tallyfy.com/pros-and-cons-of-asana-with-asana-alternatives/">https://tallyfy.com/pros-and-cons-of-asana-with-asana-alternatives/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5fa894a107a5" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/project-management-tools/pros-and-cons-of-asana-with-asana-alternatives-5fa894a107a5">Pros and Cons of Asana — With 5 Asana Alternatives</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/project-management-tools">Project Management Tools</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The 5 Best Smartsheet Alternatives — With an Unconventional Solution]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/project-management-tools/pros-and-cons-of-smartsheet-smartsheet-alternatives-ad4cde72678?source=rss-6e478a9a46e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ad4cde72678</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trello]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[process-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wrike]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[project-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[smartsheet]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Frank J. Wyatt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 Mar 2019 20:39:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-06T18:41:13.820Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Pros and Cons of Smartsheet — With 5 Smartsheet Alternatives</h3><p>This post has moved to this URL: <a href="https://tallyfy.com/pros-and-cons-of-smartsheet-with-5-smartsheet-alternatives">https://tallyfy.com/pros-and-cons-of-smartsheet-with-5-smartsheet-alternatives</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ad4cde72678" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/project-management-tools/pros-and-cons-of-smartsheet-smartsheet-alternatives-ad4cde72678">The 5 Best Smartsheet Alternatives — With an Unconventional Solution</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/project-management-tools">Project Management Tools</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How social collaboration and cloud computing are changing process improvement]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/how-social-collaboration-and-cloud-computing-are-changing-process-improvement-862710c5ffc8?source=rss-6e478a9a46e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/862710c5ffc8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cloud-computing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-process-analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Frank J. Wyatt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Mar 2019 05:33:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-11T16:09:25.735Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Business Process Analysis (BPA) is a fundamental technique for analyzing and improving business performance, whether or not it results in the automation of the business processes. In the past, BPA was performed mainly by specialized process analysts and architects, with very little involvement from other stakeholders and process participants. The quality and speed of the analysis can be greatly improved by including stakeholders in collaborative analysis and design, which requires easy-to-use, cloud-based BPA tools to remove any barriers to participation.</p><p>This paper provides an introduction to the value of BPA and social collaboration, explores why BPA, social and cloud form the perfect partnership for business process improvement and wraps up with some practical use cases for social BPA in the cloud.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/939/1*szX4aEwY_i4mrEJdUU1GJA.png" /></a></figure><h4>The value of BPA</h4><p>BPA, the practice of identifying business process-related problems and determining solutions and improvements, has been in existence far longer than process automation: As long as people have looked for better ways to do things, there have been techniques for documenting, analyzing and improving how tasks are accomplished. Unlike IT-focused solutions, however, BPA is business-led: Business analysts and users work together using BPA tools to document and analyze the existing processes, then streamline and redesign complex processes to make them more efficient and improve quality. This type of process innovation through analysis, led by the business rather than IT, may be a precursor to automating processes, or may result in adjustments to existing systems and manual procedures.</p><p>Although most Business Process Management Systems (BPMS) used for process automation provide some BPA functionality, they do not provide full analytical capabilities, nor do they serve the needs of the majority of BPA projects that are never be automated using a BPMS. Instead, we have seen the rise of dedicated BPA and Enterprise Architecture (EA) modeling tools used by business analysts to create and optimize business models. BPA may include complex analysis techniques and representations, such as simulation, value stream analysis, SIPOC, risk analysis, SWOT and process mining; it can also include related model types, including organizational, network and data models, in addition to process models. Typically, only the process model — and in fact, often only a subset of the process model — is transferred to a BPMS if required for automation.</p><p>In short, BPA may be part of a process discovery, design and BPMS automation continuum, but is often used independently of a BPMS for more complex and comprehensive business-led analysis.</p><p>BPA can provide significant benefits:</p><ul><li>Analysis of business processes provides a visualization of processes for a common understanding, highlights process bottlenecks and weaknesses, and identifies potential savings. In many situations, process improvements can be performed purely by changing manual procedures, with no systems enhancements required, so can be done quickly and at very little cost.</li><li>In advance of a BPMS or other system implementation, BPA provides powerful tools for designing optimal future-state processes that improve efficiency and reduce costs, with the process expenses well-understood in advance. Without BPA, many BPMS implementations simply automate the existing manual processes, reducing the potential for improvement.</li><li>For organizations with multiple locations, a BPA tool that allows models to be easily shared across the organization provides a framework for creating standard business models and procedures, reducing the time and effort required to establish those procedures in each location.</li></ul><h4>Social collaboration</h4><p>For the past decade, collaboration within — and beyond — enterprises has been an increasing trend. By tapping into talent wherever it exists, whether in far-flung corporate offices or key customers, co-creation can be distributed across the value chain. This has the benefit of incorporating ideas from all stakeholders directly, not as interpreted by an analyst, thereby dividing the labor between multiple parties while improving the quality. More innovative ideas are likely to occur, and “tribal knowledge” is captured and shared.</p><p>Social collaboration within business typically takes one of two forms: either it is focused on social interaction that strengthens weak ties within a large or geographically dispersed organization, or it is focused on goal-oriented social production. Collaborative BPA falls into the latter category, by permitting multiple people, both technical and non-technical, to participate in the discovery, modeling, analysis and optimization of a business process. In this type of social business software, the social aspect is integrated directly into the work that people are performing, so that the collaboration has a direct business purpose. This trend towards social as a feature of core business applications (rather than a separate tool), or “purposeful collaboration”, is predicted to increase within many enterprise applications, and accelerate the acceptance of collaboration within enterprises.</p><p>A collaborative BPA environment can provide a rich set of social features beyond the standard business analysis functions:</p><ul><li>Using a shared repository ensures that everyone is looking at the same version of the business representation, creating a shared understanding and documentation of the business: the “institutional memory” of the business processes.</li><li>Different participant roles may have different permissions — full editing versus comments only, for example — and any changes made by any participant can immediately be seen by others.</li><li>Different roles may have a completely different view on a set of models, due to skill levels or permission to access information, so that a user that is less process-savvy may see a simpler view of a process than an expert process analyst. For example, a user unfamiliar with the Business Process Modeling Notation standard may see a simplified view of a process model, and provide feedback through typed notes rather than graphical manipulation of the model.</li><li>Users may elect to “follow” certain processes in which they have an interest, even if they are not involved directly in the collaboration, providing the opportunity for anyone to add their comments on how to improve the process at any time. This would typically be viewed via an activity stream interface, similar to that seen in consumer social software.</li></ul><p>Collaborative BPA allows a wide variety of participants to be involved in documenting and improving business processes. A recent report by Deloitte2 discusses how social software can be transformational to business performance, highlighting capabilities that most contribute to enterprise-wide adoption and transformation:</p><ul><li>Collaborative creation and preservation of enterprise processes and practices, allowing for discovery and re-use in other areas</li><li>Cross-silo collaboration across enterprise hierarchies and boundaries</li><li>Bringing together skills from different areas to drive innovation</li></ul><p>As more people participate in collaborative BPA, new ways of analyzing and solving problems will emerge as people from different areas of the enterprise bring a fresh perspective. This network effect — when a tool becomes more valuable as more people use it — has the ability to improve the quality of the business analysis, as well as improve awareness of changed business processes and ease change management.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*pTNdl-A8GpypNBzkxGOIFA.png" /></a></figure><h4>Moving to the cloud</h4><p>Why are software applications moving to the cloud? Cloud infrastructure is optimized for elasticity, making it easy to start small, then grow and shrink dynamically, typically with a much smaller cost and time scale than on-premises software installations. Often, cloud infrastructure can be more reliable than on-premises, since it is based on a highly available pool of computing resources rather than a single server, and can provide equal or better performance. With collaborative applications, once the collaboration extends beyond one organization, or even becomes widespread within a large organization, cloud infrastructure is essential to provide a shared collaborative platform.</p><p>Moving BPA to the cloud leverages all of these advantages. Elasticity is important for cost control and to enable rapid growth, since BPA projects typically start small with a few analysts, then scale up to a larger team and potentially many reviewers and commenters; as the improved processes are put into practice, the project scales back to a smaller team of analysts, then eventually the number of viewers decreases. Rather than buy on-premises software licenses, servers and ongoing maintenance for the peak number of users, cloud-based BPA allows organizations to increase and decrease the user base on demand. Cloud BPA can be set up within minutes without IT involvement, allowing a BPA project to start without delay and achieve a fast time-to-value. Costs are typically per user per month, matching expenditures to the actual number of people involved at any time rather than the maximum number over the life of the project. And since it’s all browser-based, there’s no software to install (or upgrade) on users devices. This low-cost entry point makes it suitable for any size of organization: These capabilities are no longer restricted to large organizations that can afford more expensive on-premises BPA and EA packages.</p><p>Once on the cloud, people can participate in BPA from distant corporate offices, home offices, partner and customer locations, and even mobile devices. This democratizes process improvement by allowing anyone to collaborate, from anywhere, on any platform. A common shared repository ensures that everyone is looking at the same information, and that any change made by anyone is immediately seen by everyone involved.</p><p>Cloud adoption for all types of software is increasing, and most organizations no longer consider cloud infrastructure as riskier than on-premises solutions; rather, they see it as the only possible alternative when elasticity, cost and time to value are important factors. Recent breaches of security by government agencies have made cloud users understandably nervous, but cloud providers are offering more alternatives for the location of the cloud servers, and improving security through the use of private encryption keys that are held by the user rather than the provider. It’s also important to consider the relative risk for the type of information being stored in the cloud environment: With cloud BPA, the models and analysis stored in the public cloud may represent some valuable intellectual property, but rarely include any personally identifiable information about the user organization’s customers.</p><h4>Use cases for social BPA in the cloud</h4><p>Although cloud-based, collaborative BPA could be used in almost any BPA scenario, there are some use cases where it is especially appealing.</p><p>First, the ability to collaborate across multiple locations and organizations enables the following uses:</p><ul><li>Multi-national organizations that have similar processes in different locations and want to involve process designers and reviewers in multiple countries. Although this could be done using an on-premises BPA solution, a cloud solution provides easy access regardless of the internal connectivity between the corporate locations.</li><li>Organizations that need to involve business partners or customers in process analysis. Cloud based BPA allows both internal and external participants without costly VPN configurations, and the collaborative features allows partners and customers to be restricted to comment-only or allowed full process editing, depending on their skills and required input.</li><li>Business process consultancies that need to share projects with their clients. Cloud BPA allows for easy sharing, plus easy scalability as projects are started, ramped up and completed. It also allows ownership and control of the project artifacts to pass from the consultancy to their client, depending on their agreement. Furthermore, since the consultancies can’t control the end-user environment of their customers, a browser-independent cloud solution typically enables a wide variety of desktop operating systems and mobile devices for different types of users.</li></ul><p>The last scenario above, of consultancies and clients, also benefits from the elasticity of cloud solutions, that allow many users to be added quickly, then just as quickly decommissioned at the end of a project. This scalability and the related cost benefits is the key driver behind several other use cases:</p><ul><li>Organizations starting on their process improvement journey often need to see results before they can justify a large-scale roll out of BPA capabilities, but then need to be able to scale quickly to meet their needs. This is particularly attractive for small- to medium-sized companies that can’t justify the initial cost of an on-premises solution, and may not have the administrative IT staff to support it.</li><li>Higher education institutions, such as universities teaching process analysis and design, need to expand and contract the number of users based on student enrolment. As with consultancies, they can’t control the computing environments used by the students, so need to support a wide variety of operating systems and devices using a browser-based cloud tool.</li><li>BPM Centers of Excellence (COE) are often the initial point of standardization for BPA software in the organization, as well as process improvement ideas and methodologies. A scalable, cloud-based solution can be used internally by a COE, then exposed and scaled up for fast enablement of subsidiaries, departments and projects.</li></ul><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*mYg-kLIbyQnqTbTpHKi3FQ.png" /></a></figure><h4>Summary</h4><p>BPA, social and cloud are truly the perfect partnership. By combining the analytic capabilities of BPA, social features for purposeful collaboration, and cloud/mobile infrastructure for democratization of process improvement, cloud-based social BPA can transform process improvement efforts:</p><ul><li>Start fast with no capital investment or on-premises installation</li><li>Start small, then grow and shrink the participants dynamically</li><li>Extend reach to collaborators in different locations</li><li>Include stakeholders of all technical and analytical skill levels</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=862710c5ffc8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/how-social-collaboration-and-cloud-computing-are-changing-process-improvement-862710c5ffc8">How social collaboration and cloud computing are changing process improvement</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons">On Business Process Management and Workflow Automation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Secret to Unleashing an Unstoppable Improvement Culture]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/the-secret-to-unleashing-an-unstoppable-improvement-culture-75843cbcab15?source=rss-6e478a9a46e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/75843cbcab15</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[process-improvement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Frank J. Wyatt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Mar 2019 05:20:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-11T16:11:15.311Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Read on to learn how to create a successful culture of process improvement.</p><h4>Improvement and change culture</h4><p>Why is it that some organizations successfully do more with less — continually increasing their efficiency, improving productivity and outstripping the competition, while similar organizations in the same industry struggle? A focus on continuous improvement is often the reason. So how do you make sure your organization has that focus, and advantage?</p><p>It all comes down to your culture. The dominant culture of an organization has a huge impact on the success rate of any change initiative.</p><p>Generally human beings want to improve and make things better. The key is to normalize this behavior — in other words, to make improvement your organization’s natural state.</p><p><em>“If teams are excited, empowered and motivated with a real desire to achieve, then the sky is the limit.”</em></p><p>If teams are excited, empowered and motivated with a real desire to achieve, then the sky is the limit. But if they are not engaged, if they feel powerless and lack the motivation to drive change, it’s what we call a weak process culture.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*pTNdl-A8GpypNBzkxGOIFA.png" /></a></figure><h4>Signs of a weak process culture</h4><p>While every business is different, the signs of a weak process culture are the same. There will be little or no collaboration and engagement among employees, overall morale will be low, and you’ll see high rates of failure in process and change initiatives.</p><p>This can become an ingrained problem. In companies with a weak process culture, teams will push back on change. You’ll hear statements like “Trust me, I’ve been doing this job for twenty years, I don’t need to write it down.” No-one will be looking at or talking about process, and the general attitude towards process improvement and ownership will be one of inconvenience.</p><h4>Causes of a weak process culture</h4><ol><li><strong>Invisible leadership</strong></li></ol><p>The exec and the leadership team believe there is benefit to be gained from investment in ongoing improvement, but are not visible in their support (or worse — they verbalize support but deep down are dismissive of process, and consider it to be merely a compliance requirement).</p><p><strong>2. Initiatives that disempower teams</strong></p><p>When outside experts are brought in to change things, the true process owners, the people on the ground, are side lined. This can diminish confidence to collaborate and hinder innovation.</p><p><strong>3. Loss of momentum</strong></p><p>Projects start off with a big bang but things quickly revert to the old way of doing things and often any gains are lost.</p><p><strong>4. Unhelpful process documentation</strong></p><p>Pages and pages of process documents and charts that are complicated and indecipherable. If staff need help and can’t immediately find it, it can kill engagement and weaken the brand of process.</p><p><strong>5. Improvement in silent mode</strong></p><p>Basically there is no acknowledgement of improvement efforts — no announcements, no KPI’S, no measures, no success celebration, no brand. If there is no inspiration to succeed, no kudos for success, teams cease to care.</p><p>If we visit a company website that isn’t helpful, isn’t easy to navigate and is pages and pages long, we just don’t come back to it. We shouldn’t expect attitudes to process guidance to be any different — if teams can’t use it easily, then they won’t use it at all.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*mYg-kLIbyQnqTbTpHKi3FQ.png" /></a></figure><h4>How to make positive change go viral</h4><p>You may recognize some of the above causes in your organization, but the good news is that with the right foundations in place, weak process culture can be fixed.</p><p>Here are 5 key ingredients to unleash an unstoppable improvement culture:</p><p><strong>1. Demonstrate active leadership</strong></p><p>Get your leaders on board right from the beginning by demonstrating that there is an issue that needs addressing. Do whatever it takes to find that sore spot that makes the executive team sit up and take notice.</p><ul><li>Speak to them in their language, not just using numbers, but with evidence. Win their hearts. Show them a Facebook post written by a customer, give them evidence of a customer survey or share feedback from teams.</li><li>Then get them out among the people, showing their support and celebrating successes. They need to be visibly committed. If they’re not, everyone out there in the business can tell and will respond accordingly.</li><li>Appoint a CPO (Chief Process Officer) and process champions. These are the leadership roles responsible for communicating the vision to the organization. The champions set the standards and expectations and make sure the improvement opportunities are followed up on.</li></ul><p><strong>2. Empower the real process owners</strong></p><p>Process ownership can be divided into two tiers — owners and experts. Process owners are the people who are ultimately responsible for the process operating effectively. Process experts are the people working on the ground with the processes. If they can work in tandem, processes will be kept up to date and any suggestions for improvements might actually be made, adding real value to the business.</p><p><em>“Do whatever it takes to find that sore spot that makes the executive team sit up and take notice.”</em></p><p>Updating a process needs to be easy. Name your owners and experts, then give them tools to make managing their processes easy. Set the expectation that change and improvement should be ongoing, continuing after projects have finished.</p><p><strong>3. Sustain momentum — deploy ongoing structures</strong></p><p>To ensure process improvement remains a day to day priority, set up a structure and a schedule for improving processes. Have a process forum and give it a name that resonates with people within your organization. Once the system is in place it becomes easier for people to engage in these forums.</p><p>Hold improvement opportunity workshops regularly, and get your CPO to come along. Instead of making it feel like an audit or process review session, focus on problems, opportunities and customer satisfaction. Share ideas and get cross fertilization happening across teams.</p><p>Often the idea that process owners in the business can change their own processes is met with fear. Quality or Improvement Managers worry that things may get out of control, ignoring the fact that those process owners are already doing things their own way to work around a process that no longer applies. Giving process owners more control merely formalizes what is already happening — and, in fact, gives more transparency and control.</p><p>Everyone needs to participate in the discussion, everyone needs to be involved in the drive for incremental change, especially the process owners and experts.</p><p><strong>4. Introduce helpful process guidance</strong></p><p>If your process documentation isn’t easy to use, change it. It should help teams get things right, learn new processes and give consistency across the organization. Aim to provide information that explains the process so well, it’s comprehensible (at a high level at least) in ten seconds. If it’s easy to understand and easy to use, teams will go back to it again and again.</p><p>Make the information easy to access by embedding links into the places and tools that teams already use every day, so the information is available where and when they need it.</p><p><strong>5. Sustain communication</strong></p><p>Good communication is what it takes to get people involved and driving change. So how do you do it well?</p><p>The first, most important thing is to choose the right people to be your process champions. They can’t be so senior that they’re inaccessible, but they must know the people and processes inside out. Just be aware that if your champion leaves or is promoted, your process culture may be at risk.</p><p>Here are some other ways to make sure your communication supports an improvement culture:</p><ul><li>Celebrate successes — people love to be praised and are often more productive when their successes are recognized.</li><li>Share information — send out automatic notifications of changes to processes to all stakeholders. A personal dashboard is a great way to share what’s going on, what’s coming up and what’s out of date.</li><li>Be interesting and interested. Make it personal and have fun by fostering the spirit of competition and holding team building exercises.</li><li>Use discussion threads and ‘like’ buttons to make it easy for users to give feedback.</li></ul><p><em>“The first, most important thing is to choose the right people to be your process champions.”</em></p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/939/1*szX4aEwY_i4mrEJdUU1GJA.png" /></a></figure><h4>The building blocks of improvement</h4><p>For years the focus of process improvement efforts has been on tools and methodologies, at the expense of harnessing the real engine of change — engaged teams that are driven to improve and succeed.</p><p>With the building blocks for a strong improvement culture in place, your teams will feel more empowered to collaborate on improvement efforts. Engaged teams armed with the right attitude can take any tools and turn their efforts into real improvement for your customers and for your bottom line.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=75843cbcab15" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/the-secret-to-unleashing-an-unstoppable-improvement-culture-75843cbcab15">The Secret to Unleashing an Unstoppable Improvement Culture</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons">On Business Process Management and Workflow Automation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Drucker On Training & Management Development]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/drucker-on-training-management-development-21879bcb7716?source=rss-6e478a9a46e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/21879bcb7716</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[peter-drucker]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Frank J. Wyatt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Mar 2019 05:18:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-11T16:13:10.340Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>“The world knows he was the greatest management thinker of the last century,” Jack Welch, former chairman of General Electric Co., said after Peter F. Drucker’s death in 2005.</blockquote><p>Management guru Tom Peters, among many others, said “he was the creator and inventor of modern management.”</p><p>In short, Drucker’s name is synonymous with management. His writings consistently offer rich insights served up in a soufflé of good style. Slightly paraphrasing Harvard’s Ted Levitt: “Drucker always discovered, understood, and clarified more about any subject he studied than most people who spent a lifetime on that subject…”</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*mYg-kLIbyQnqTbTpHKi3FQ.png" /></a></figure><p><strong>Drucker’s Focus on the Challenge of Developing People</strong></p><p>Education and training were arguably the most pervasive of Peter F. Drucker’s multiple intellectual interests.</p><p>Drucker had an intense interest in management development, developing people, and building continuous learning into the job of the knowledge worker. Therefore, it is surprising he never wrote a major treatise on these highly intertwined subjects.</p><p><strong>We Value Your Feedback</strong></p><p>Hopefully, you will provide us with your tips, compliments, and complaints on Part I, so we will know how we can improve parts II, III and IV prior to release.</p><p>The articles selected have a common theme, despite their diversity. They all deal with the question: What do training executives need to know to better design, develop, integrate, and implement more effective learning programs?</p><p>Drucker’s profound insights can guide all of us in developing people with an emphasis on their contribution to performance and results.</p><p>To ever so slightly paraphrase Joseph A. Maciariello (one of the world’s foremost expert on Drucker’s teachings): “… Drucker brought into focus…beyond getting the right things done through others… the need for understanding the responsibility for what is happening to the people in the process — who they are becoming and how the work environment is contributing to their growth and development…”</p><p>A significant percentage of the subject matter contained in part I is discussed in a variety of forms in our forthcoming Corporate Learning Week 2014. (Link to online brochure)</p><p>Leading practitioners examine and illustrate many of the learning &amp; development practices originally formulated by Drucker to meet the new demands on the individual employee in the knowledge society.</p><p><strong>Get Ready. Get Set. Grow</strong></p><p>We believe you are going to love this e- book. It is not a “fad” book; it is a “fact” book — full of truths, concepts, and thought processes that are timeless and actionable.</p><p>We believe it can/will change the way you view the role and mission of your internal training organization.</p><p>Today’s knowledge-based workforce are becoming the largest single group… and have already become the major creator of corporate wealth. Increasingly the success, indeed the survival of every business will depend on the performance of its knowledge workforce.</p><p>What does this mean? Workforce training, constant retraining and continuous learning activities must climb to the top of the agenda of the individual firm and the nation.</p><p>More than ever before, internal training organizations must prepare its workforce for a rapidly arriving and disruptive future. Drucker’s teachings form a blueprint for every thinking leader.</p><p>The true objective of many of Drucker’s principles and practices is to take chaos and uncertainties as givens and convert them from problems into opportunities.</p><p><strong>Meet with Representatives From the Drucker School of Management</strong></p><p>We hope to see you at our Corporate Learning Week 2014 conference. The program is chock-full of employee development strategies &amp; tactics offered that will help your internal training organization become more strategy supportive… and develop learning programs that produce performance and results on the corporate battlefield.</p><p>You’ll discover from a host of solution providers new approaches for delivering productivity boosting learning programs that have great impact on attracting and holding a knowledge-based workforce.</p><p>Plus, you’ll have an opportunity to talk with representatives from the Drucker Graduate School of Management. You’ll learn first-hand how to potentially integrate Drucker’s astonishing methodologies into your management/leadership development programs.</p><p>Peter F. Drucker’s effective leadership model provides a set of leadership practices that can be taught, learned, and practiced. It’s a great opportunity to discover ways to augment existing learning programs… and update your agenda for developing talent management strategies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/590/1*W6d68vlSmKOMwYfMUcVBEg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Chapter 1</strong></p><p>The Difference Between Training and Education: Rediscovering Training Fundamentals From Pocket Billiards</p><p><strong>Chapter 1 Part I: Drucker on Learning for Performance &amp; Results</strong></p><p>Editor’s Note: In today’s fast-paced business environment, it’s easy to overlook the importance of three learning essentials: 1) there is a difference between training and education; 2.) training requires mentorship expertise and; 3.) continuous learning and knowledge sharing are an integral part of the training process.</p><p>We illustrate the learning essentials through the anecdote of a colleague who became an avid billiards player, first as a self taught novice and then instructed from one of the sport’s top players.</p><p><strong>If you’re a pocket billiards enthusiast, you’ll relate to this story.</strong></p><p>Several years ago, a co-worker purchased a top-of-the-line Gold Crown III pool table, a dozen or more instructional videotapes, how-to books and dvd’s that enabled him to simulate playing a world-class professional.</p><p>He viewed, studied and carefully practiced what he learned. Pocket billiards (i.e., pool) is a game that can be played equally well alone or competitively. He learned the fundamentals and his level of play improved, but most of his playing was confined to nightly practice sessions in his basement.</p><p>Then, one day, he ventured into a New York City billiard establishment populated by the world’s top-ranked professionals. Men and women of all ages were competing in tournaments.</p><p>Some were actively engaged in professionally taught clinics designed to improve playing ability. Others — mostly prosperous Wall Street types — were busily engaged in one-on-one instructional sessions with worldchampions-turned instructors.</p><p>In one defining moment, he realized he was an inferior player compared to those he viewed as worthy opponents. He was amazed at the playing ability of those fortunate enough to afford weekly private lessons.</p><p>Prior to witnessing all of this, he thought he had progressed and was satisfied with the skills he possessed. Now he knew he had wasted a great deal of time and was not equipped to play competitively against those he would have thought (in his basement, practicing alone) he would unmercifully defeat.</p><p>But that’s not all. He also discovered that many of the players were students of the game. They shared “secrets” and newly acquired knowledge, such as making recurrent kinds of rail shots, determining the exact path of the cue ball after contacting the object ball, and using the overhead billiard lighting fixture to determine the exact aiming point. None of these “finer points” could to be found in any of the printed or visual materials purchased by our friend.</p><p>So he secured an expensive two-hour lesson from the then-12thranked player in the world, who was an accomplished instructor and a marvelous diagnostician. His verdict? Our friend’s skills were deficient — he stunk — and in the process of self-instruction, our friend developed many bad habits.</p><p>He jumped up too quickly and thereby deflected his aim, which meant he missed a lot. He had not acquired the habit of a full backstroke accompanied by a complete follow-through, which meant his stroke was choppy.</p><p>The champion player and expert instructor also said: “You understand very little about the basic skill sets that must be mastered before anything else. Self-development is great, and all learning relies on self-development. But, you need the watchful eye of an instructor to make sure there’s no slippage.”</p><p>Our friend, an Ivy-leaguer, decided to engage his instructor for a series of expensive lessons. The instructor corrected, mentored, coached, demonstrated and provided take-home lessons. As predicted, slippage always occurred and more coaching was required to make the lessons taught become firmly ingrained habits.</p><p><strong>A Rude Awakening</strong></p><p>Initially, our friend was near-certain he could master the game. Why? Because he thought he had the natural attributes reflected by past academic achievements. Granted, he had promise, that is, potential. But the key to success in pocket billiards as in any skill-based sport is practice.</p><p>He noted that a lot of the Wall Street types, obviously quite brilliant, never learned the fundamental lesson that brilliance was usually irrelevant in terms of behavioral learning development. In other words, they didn’t practice. He also observed that “the less brilliant” achieved uncommon performance through practice.</p><p>Finally, he understood — in very practical terms — what learning experts have been claiming for decades. That is, the achievement of sophisticated skills involves relentless taskmasters. They demand from the individual a high level of commitment, immense concentration, and continual practice with each ascending plateau.</p><p>Seasoned performers in any sophisticated skill realize they grow according to the levels of achievement attained once they reach a certain stage. They understand that learning really begins anew with each addition to the repertoire.</p><p>This sense of incessant achievement and reinforcement through the self-discipline of practice is perhaps the real secret of motivation.</p><p><strong>Lessons learned</strong></p><p>This story is given in such detail because it illustrates three easily forgotten learning essentials: 1) there is a difference between training and education; 2.) training requires instructor expertise and; 3.) continuous learning and knowledge sharing are an integral part of the training process.</p><p><strong>1 There is a difference between training and education</strong>. Training, unlike education, requires coaching, mentoring, performance consulting and “learn-by-doing” activities.</p><p>Simply put, the difference between education and training is like the difference between taking a music appreciation course and spending years learning how to play a musical instrument.</p><p>Many of today’s “training courses” — whether in e-learning form, instructor-led or a mixture of instructional methodologies — are not really training courses. They are lecture and reading programs. The development process will always have disastrous results if the role of behavioral learning is neglected.</p><p>Training requires drill, repetition, and constant feedback. Most good teachers/lecturers are brilliant synthesizers who are capable of organizing a complex subject into a meaningful pattern. They’re also capable of engrossing their audience with dramatic wit and sparkling examples.</p><p>The lecture method is a valid technique in the hands of skilled practitioners. But the lecture method is at best only a preparation for learning and is not learning itself. In too many instances the information goes from the instructor’s mouth into the employee’s notebook without going into his/her head. Similarly, reading is not the same thing as doing.</p><p>Action learning, today’s newest term for training, rests on the old Chinese proverb: “I hear and I forget; I see and I remember; I do and I understand.” Training requires doing. Yet there is “watch out” associated with learning from practical experience or just doing.</p><p>If practicing a craft with 30 years of professional experience essentially involves doing the same thing over and over, it probably means that the person has never gone beyond the behavioral dimension of learning. There is a difference between 30 years experience and one year’s experience 30 times.</p><p>Learning theorists have a fancy term for the component of learning that spurs learning to a higher level. It’s called “cognitive learning.” Cognitive learning supplies the role of vision in the development process. In effect, it incorporates insights into behavioral practice, thereby distinguishing the master professional from the pedestrian performer. The key point: many so-called training programs are really education programs.</p><p>2 <strong>Training requires mentorship expertise</strong>. Applying the principles of pocket billiards requires the services of a live instructor.</p><p>For example, knowing where to strike the cue ball does not mean students actually strike the cue ball at the designated point. The mechanics of aiming — striking the cue ball at its exact center and dozens of other critical-to-success factors — must be mastered to successfully apply theoretical knowledge.</p><p>Our point? Getting an “A” in a web-based training program is next to meaningless if the program is not related to specific internal business processes and if the correct way to apply what was learned or taught is not firmly established.</p><p>Slippage in learned skills almost always occurs when first learning a new subject. If the subject is important — whether it be in safety management, quality management, project management, or collecting and analyzing Web data — the learning program must constantly diagnose “fast forgetting” and reinforce what was previously taught.</p><p>Real skill acquisition, after all is said and done, requires showing, doing, correcting, practicing and customizing. This is best done by real on-site experts.</p><p><strong>3 Continuous learning and knowledge sharing are an integral part of the training process</strong>. The need for continuous learning and knowledge sharing, designed for specialists and/ or individuals trained to do a given job, is rapidly becoming understood by training groups.</p><p>Continuous learning does not replace formal training. It has different aims and satisfies different needs.The billiard parlor utilized the teaching services of many top-notch instructors. To be sure, individual instructors did not share their teaching methods with other instructors. But students, eager to win tournaments, asked other instructors and their students specific questions related to improving their own performance.</p><p>Students of the game happily shared “best kept secrets” with others about solving specific playing problems. Continuous exposure to the experiences, problems and solutions of others produced remarkable gains in the performance capacity of most players/students affiliated with the billiard parlor.</p><p>In all likelihood, the management of this billiard establishment did little to create a “learning group.” But, at least, they did not discourage its emergence.</p><p>Internal training organizations would be well advised to create formal and informal online learning groups in subjects such as project planning, scheduling and control, maintenance management, integrated supply chain management, quality control and other formal methodologies requiring continuing improvement in employee skills and knowledge.</p><p><strong>Summary and Conclusions</strong></p><p>Training groups must take a high view of their function, set high standards for their objectives and accept the notion that there is a difference among training programs, education courses, and continuous learning.</p><p>Whatever deterioration there has been in the quality of employee training has resulted from the acts of senior management and internal training groups.</p><p>If senior management puts an emphasis on minimizing training cost per employee and refuses to take the purpose of the training seriously, in the final analysis, their actions ultimately will bring about a conscious downgrading of expectations.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/526/1*eNVu-pZsKHFsoCxIy_cCZg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Chapter 2</strong></p><p><strong>Will the MBA Degree Become Less Valuable in the Near-Future?</strong></p><p><strong>Chapter 2 Part I: Drucker on Learning for Performance &amp; Results</strong></p><p>Every major business publication, in the recent past, has featured articles on the importance of an MBA degree. Business schools have become a thriving growth industry. Of late, many have contended that the university has become a credential cartel controlling the rights of entrance into the job market. Further, many are beginning to question the value of an MBA.</p><p>Typical criticisms claim that the traditional MBA curriculum ill-serves and ill-prepares the student because of its transparent neglect of the requirements of the business practitioner. According to critics, doing well in an MBA program at best shows the student’s promise for performance.</p><p>Peter F. Drucker once commented, “In the academic disciplines a student cannot perform…he or she can only show promise…”He extended this observation by asserting there was no correlation between academic tests and actual performance on the corporate battlefield.</p><p>Doing well on tests only proves you can take tests. It often happens that the promising “A” student turns out to be a mediocrity. On the other hand, the “C” student sometimes turns out to be a star performer because of his/her ability to concentrate on the task and get things done.</p><p>The popular methodologies of case studies, business games, simulations and the like are often so remote from the world of decision making that Drucker equated them with going to war with toys.</p><p>Quite frankly, we believe undergraduate and graduate business schools are poor surrogates for the substantial challenges found in the real world of decision making.</p><p>It should be mentioned — indeed, emphasized — the hard-core business specialties (accounting, finance, statistics, taxation, computer science, etc.) in the curriculum, at least, provide the benefit of a solid foundation of knowledge competency, assuming the individual is willing to take responsibility for learning after graduation.</p><p><strong>Misdirected Faculty Contribution</strong></p><p>John Flaherty, a true Drucker scholar and synthesizer, revealed in an unpublished manuscript Drucker’s criticism of the role of business school faculty. Interestingly, Flaherty shows Drucker’s intense interest in the field of medicine, and why and how throughout its history it has been intertwined with the feature of professional practice. According to Flaherty:</p><p>“One of the lessons Drucker learned from his study of medical diagnosis was the principle that one never argues with results.</p><p>Drucker ascribed a good deal of the university’s failure to deliver the goods, in the way of meaningful results, to the misdirected focus and the composition of the faculty. He specifically faulted academic preparation for business on two counts — the excessive concern with theoretical concepts and undue emphasis on tools and techniques. Particularly incomprehensible to Drucker was how academics addressed theoretical concepts devoid of any concrete organizational experience.</p><p>Drucker further argued that academics imagine that a business career was a purely pristine activity apparently isolated from the pressure cooker travails of business life.</p><p>In order to dissuade them from this idyllic ‘Eden’ divorced from crises, tensions, turbulence and the uncertainties, “Drucker recommended and urged” that they take a lesson from the medical profession which through its internship and other training programs demanded that the practitioner gain experience by confronting operating realities… “</p><p><strong>Wow!</strong></p><p>These timely Drucker observations ring true. For years, for-profit and non-profit organizations have been disappointed with the bulk of academic research and disappointed with the products of many MBA programs.</p><p>To be sure, there are a lot of good things being done. But the bulk of faculty member research and articles are adorned with a mixture of confusing graphs, lengthy footnotes and frightening mathematical equations that obscure relatively simple findings.</p><p>Someone once paraphrased the words of Winston Churchill when relating academic research in the field of business to the world of management practice, “Never have so many influenced so few.”</p><p>Again, many believe business schools do a reasonably good job with specialized subjects — perhaps the problem is they do too good a job. Instead of training more and better technicians, business school faculty should concern themselves with the education students are not getting.</p><p><strong>Technicians But Not Managers</strong></p><p>Instead of creating more building blocks of specialization, Drucker suggested that more attention be paid to conceptual thinking, multidisciplinary understanding and the challenge of managing change.</p><p>Instead of mindlessly adding more and more courses, it would be wiser to practice some systematic abandonment of obsolete subjects and then to derive a more purposeful and better designed curriculum.</p><p>Many business school graduates reflect their professors’ teachings. Drucker believed the typical MBA student — after being inundated with their school’s excessive emphasis on rationality — graduates with the false expectation that top management actually knows what it is doing.</p><p>It takes years of front-line experience to discover the realities of business differ from those presented in the classroom. For some, it is quite startling to learn that the quantification of the observable and measurable has its limits, particularly when confronted with complex phenomena.</p><p>Hopefully, the cliché “learning how to learn” is the most important skill derived from an MBA program.</p><p>Indeed, the single-most factor in making organizations unbeatable on the corporate battlefield will be the ability of their people to constantly learn new and different things and successfully integrate them into daily practice.</p><p><strong>The Real Benefits of an MBA Degree</strong></p><p>Perhaps it is best to view a business degree as a preparation for learning. But not for learning itself.</p><p>Then again, the right curriculum targeted to the right people (experienced executives/managers) can be a marvelous experience. Mature individuals are more responsive to theoretical concepts that enable them to organize their past experiences and have the savvy to evaluate the usefulness of what is being taught.</p><p><strong>Continuing Education Combined with Battlefield Experience</strong></p><p>Designing the right curriculum is not so easy. An executive who needs to read and interpret a balance sheet, an income statement, and a cash flow analysis can acquire these all important skills in a short course or seminar.</p><p>Similarly, they can learn project management, statistical analysis, purchasing management and dozens of other subjects by attending systematic, well-organized learning programs offered by universities and for-profit organizations.</p><p>As continuing education advances, we can expect it to collide with advanced degree granting programs. The integration of school and work in many ways negates the need for an advanced business degree.</p><p>Of course, this is not a particularly new insight. Approximately 50 years ago Drucker used the theme of balancing continuity with change to write one of the great books of the 20th century, Landmarks of Tomorrow.</p><p>And his point that in an age when continuing education of practicing professionals becomes the norm, the question, “What’s school for?” will have to be addressed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/532/1*jLGnEf8Bh6iZgHa1mBXkyg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Chapter 3</strong></p><p><strong>Things to Learn About Revitalizing Yourself: Seven Personal Stories from Peter Drucker</strong></p><p><strong>Chapter 3 Part I: Drucker on Learning for Performance &amp; Results</strong></p><p>Editor’s Note: In times like these we tend to turn to the great leadership sages for inspiration, and to revitalize our spirit and belief in the power of true authentic leadership.</p><p>Peter F. Drucker has no equal for providing us with enduring wisdom, principles and practices on how to grow, to change, and to age without losing our effectiveness.</p><p>Drucker attempted to answer the question: How can people remain effective over long periods of years, over periods of change, over years of work, and over years of living?</p><p>The following Drucker essay details seven experiences that provided him with direction, method and purpose with respect to remaining capable of achieving continuous growth, purposeful change — and graceful aging without becoming a prisoner of the past.</p><p>The seven experiences for revitalizing oneself was originally published in Drucker On Asia (first published in Japan in 1995 and then in the UK in 1997).</p><p><strong>Revitalizing Oneself — Seven Personal Experiences by Peter F. Drucker</strong></p><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>I was not yet 18 when, having finished high school, I left my native Vienna and went to Hamburg as a trainee in a cotton-export firm. My father was not very happy.</p><p>Ours had been a family of civil servants, professors, lawyers, and physicians for a very long time. He therefore wanted me to be a full-time university student, but I was tired of being a schoolboy and wanted to go to work.</p><p>To appease my father, but without any serious intention, I enrolled at Hamburg University in the law faculty. In those remote days — the year was 1927 — one did not have to attend classes to be a perfectly proper university student.</p><p>All one had to do to obtain a university degree was to pay a small annual fee and show up for an exam at the end of four years.</p><p><strong>THE FIRST EXPERIENCE: Goal And Vision Taught By Verdi</strong></p><p>The work at the export firm was terribly boring, and I learned very little. Work began at 7:30 in the morning and was over at 4 in the afternoon on weekdays and at noon on Saturdays. So I had lots of free time. Once a week I went to the opera.</p><p>On one of those evenings I went to hear an opera by the great 19thcentury Italian composer, Giuseppe Verdi — the last opera he wrote, Falstaff. It has now become one of Verdi’s most popular operas, but it was rarely performed then.</p><p>Both singers and audiences thought it too difficult. I was totally overwhelmed by it. Although I had heard a great many operas, I had never heard anything like that. I have never forgotten the impression that evening made on me.</p><p>When I made a study, I found that this opera, with its gaiety, its zest for life, and its incredible vitality, was written by a man of 80! To me 80 was an incredible age.</p><p>Then I read what Verdi himself had written when he was asked why, at that age, when he was already a famous man and considered one of the foremost opera composers of his century, he had taken on the hard work of writing one more opera, and an exceedingly demanding one.</p><p>“All my life as a musician,” he wrote, “I have striven for perfection. It has always eluded me. I surely had an obligation to make one more try.”</p><p>I have never forgotten those words — they made an indelible impression on me. When he was 18, Verdi was already a seasoned musician.</p><p>I had no idea what I would become, except that I knew by that time that I was unlikely to be a success exporting cotton textiles. But I resolved that whatever my life’s work would be, Verdi’s words would be my lodestar.</p><p>I resolved that if I ever reached an advanced age, I would not give up but would keep on. In the meantime I would strive for perfection, even though, as I well knew, it would surely always elude me.</p><p><strong>THE SECOND EXPERIENCE: “The Gods can see them” — Taught by Phidias</strong></p><p>It was at about this same time, and also in Hamburg during my stay as a trainee, that I read a story that conveyed to me what perfection means. It is a story of the greatest sculptor of ancient Greece, Phidias.</p><p>He was commissioned around 440 BC to make the statues that to this day stand on the roof of the Parthenon in Athens.</p><p>They are considered among the greatest sculptures of the Western tradition, but when Phidias submitted his bill, the city accountant of Athens refused to pay it.</p><p>“These statues,” the accountant said, “stand on the roof of the temple, and on the highest hill in Athens. Nobody can see anything but their fronts. Yet you have charged us for sculpting them in the round — that is, for doing their back sides, which nobody can see.”</p><p>“You are wrong,” Phidias retorted. “The gods can see them.”</p><p>I read this, as I remember, shortly after I had listened to Falstaff, and it hit me hard. I have not always lived up to it. I have done many things that I hope the gods will not notice, but I have always known that one has to strive for perfection even if only the gods notice.</p><p><strong>THE THIRD EXPERIENCE: Continuous Learning- Decision as a Journalist</strong></p><p>A few years later I moved to Frankfurt. I worked first as a trainee in a brokerage firm. Then, after the New York stock-market crash, in October 1929, when the brokerage firm went bankrupt, I was hired on my 20th birthday by Frankfurt’s largest newspaper as a financial and foreign-affairs writer.</p><p>I continued to be enrolled as a law student at the university because in those days one could easily transfer from one European university to any other. I still was not interested in the law, but I remembered the lessons of Verdi and of Phidias.</p><p>A journalist has to write about many subjects, so I decided I had to know something about many subjects to be at least a competent journalist.</p><p>The newspaper I worked for came out in the afternoon. We began work at 6 in the morning and finished by a quarter past 2 in the afternoon, when the last edition went to press. So I began to force myself to study afternoons and evenings: international relations and international law; the history of social and legal institutions; finance; and so on.</p><p>Gradually, I developed a system. I still adhere to it. Every three or four years I pick a new subject. It may be Japanese art; it may be economics. Three years of study are by no means enough to master a subject, but they are enough to understand it.</p><p>So for more than 60 years I have kept on studying one subject at a time. That not only has given me a substantial fund of knowledge. It has also forced me to be open to new disciplines and new approaches and new methods — for every one of the subjects I have studied makes different assumptions and employs a different methodology.</p><p><strong>THE FOURTH EXPERIENCE: Reviewing –Taught by an Editor-in-Chief</strong></p><p>The next experience to report in this story of keeping myself intellectually alive and growing is something that was taught by an editor-in-chief, one of Europe’s leading newspapermen.</p><p>The editorial staff at the newspaper consisted of very young people. At age 22, I became one of the three assistant managing editors. The reason was not that I was particularly good. In fact, I never became a first-rate daily journalist.</p><p>But in those years, around 1930, the people who should have held the kind of position I had — people age 35 or so — were not available in Europe. They had been killed in World War I. Even highly responsible positions had to be filled by young people like me.</p><p>The editor-in-chief, then around 50, took infinite pains to train and discipline his young crew. He discussed with each of us every week the work we had done. Twice a year, right after New Year’s and then again before summer vacations began in June, we would spend a Saturday afternoon and all of Sunday discussing our work over the preceding six months.</p><p>The editor would always start out with the things we had done well. Then he would proceed to the things we had tried to do well. Next he reviewed the things where we had not tried hard enough. And finally, he would subject us to a scathing critique of the things we had done badly or had failed to do.</p><p>The last two hours of that session would then serve as a projection of our work for the next six months: What were the things on which we should concentrate? What were the things we should improve? What were the things each of us needed to learn?</p><p>And a week later each of us was expected to submit to the editor-inchief our new program of work and learning for the next six months. I tremendously enjoyed the sessions, but I forgot them as soon as I left the paper.</p><p>Almost 10 years later, after I had come to the United States, I remembered them. It was in the early 1940s, after I had become a senior professor, started my own consulting practice, and begun to publish major books.</p><p>Since then I have set aside two weeks every summer in which to review my work during the preceding year, beginning with the things I did well but could or should have done better, down to the things I did poorly and the things I should have done but did not do. I decide what my priorities should be in my consulting work, in my writing, and in my teaching.</p><p>I have never once truly lived up to the plan I make each August, but it has forced me to live up to Verdi’s injunction to strive for perfection, even though “it has always eluded me” and still does.</p><p><strong>THE FIFTH EXPERIENCE: What is necessary in a new position — Taught by a senior partner.</strong></p><p>My next learning experience came a few years after my experience on the newspaper. From Frankfurt I moved to London in 1933, first working as a securities analyst in a large insurance company and then, a year later, moving to a small but fast-growing private bank as an economist and the executive secretary to the three senior partners.</p><p>One, the founder, was a man in his seventies; the two others were in their mid-thirties. At first I worked exclusively with the two younger men, but after I had been with the firm some three months or so, the founder called me into his office and said, “I didn’t think much of you when you came here and still don’t think much of you, but you are even more stupid than I thought you would be, and much more stupid than you have any right to be.”</p><p>Since the two younger partners had been praising me to the skies each day, I was dumbfounded. And then the old gentlemen said, “I understand you did very good securities analysis at the insurance company. But if we had wanted you to do securities-analysis work, we would have left you where you were.</p><p>You are now the executive secretary to the partners, yet you continue to do securities analysis. What should you be doing now, to be effective in your new job?” I was furious, but still I realized that the old man was right.</p><p>I totally changed my behavior and my work. Since then, when I have a new assignment, I ask myself the question, “What do I need to do, now that I have a new assignment, to be effective?” Every time, it is something different. Discovering what it is requires concentration on the things that are crucial to the new challenge, the new job, the new task.</p><p><strong>THE SIXTH EXPERIENCE: Writing Down –Taught by the Jesuits and the Calvinists</strong></p><p>Quite a few years later, around 1945, after I had moved from England to the United States in 1937, I picked for my three-year study subject early modern European history, especially the 15th and 16th centuries.</p><p>I found that two European institutions had become dominant forces in Europe: the Jesuit Order in the Catholic South and the Calvinist Church in the Protestant North. Both were founded independently in 1536. Both adopted the same learning discipline.</p><p>Whenever a Jesuit priest or a Calvinist pastor does anything of significance — making a key decision, for instance — he is expected to write down what results he anticipates. Nine months later, he traces back from the actual results to those anticipations.</p><p>That very soon shows him what he did well and what his strengths are. It also shows him what he has to learn and what habits he has to change. Finally, it shows him what he has no gift for and cannot do well.</p><p>I have followed that method for myself now for 50 years. It brings out what one’s strengths are — and that is the most important thing an individual can know about himself or herself. It brings out areas where improvement is needed and suggests what kind of improvement is needed.</p><p>Finally, it brings out things an individual cannot do and therefore should not even try to do. To know one’s strengths, to know how to improve them, and to know what one cannot do — they are the keys to continuous learning.</p><p><strong>THE SEVENTH EXPERIENCE: What to be remembered for — Taught by Schumpeter</strong></p><p>One more experience, and then I am through with the story of my personal development. At Christmas 1949, when I had just begun to teach management at New York University, my father, then 73 years old, came to visit us from California.</p><p>Right after New Year’s, on January 3, 1950, he and I went to visit an old friend of his, the famous economist Joseph Schumpeter.</p><p>My father had already retired, but Schumpeter, then 66 and world famous, was still teaching at Harvard and was very active as the president of the American Economic Association.</p><p>In 1902 my father was a very young civil servant in the Austrian Ministry of Finance, but he also did some teaching in economics at the university. Thus he had come to know Schumpeter, who was then, at age 19, the most brilliant of the young students.</p><p>Two more-different people are hard to imagine: Schumpeter was flamboyant, arrogant, abrasive, and vain; my father was quiet, the soul of courtesy, and modest to the point of being self-effacing. Still, the two became fast friends and remained fast friends.</p><p>By 1949 Schumpeter had become a very different person. In his last year of teaching at Harvard, he was at the peak of his fame. The two old men had a wonderful time together, reminiscing about the old days.</p><p>Suddenly, my father asked with a chuckle, “Joseph, do you still talk about what you want to be remembered for?” Schumpeter broke out in loud laughter.</p><p>For Schumpeter was notorious for having said, when he was 30 or so and had published the first two of his great economics books, that what he really wanted to be remembered for was having been “Europe’s greatest lover of beautiful women and Europe’s greatest horseman — and perhaps also the world’s greatest economist.”</p><p>Schumpeter said, “Yes, this question is still important to me, but I now answer it differently. I want to be remembered as having been the teacher who converted half a dozen brilliant students into first-rate economists.”</p><p>He must have seen an amazed look on my father’s face, because he continued, “You know, Adolph, I have now reached the age where I know that being remembered for books and theories is not enough. One does not make a difference unless it is a difference in the lives of people.”</p><p>One reason my father had gone to see Schumpeter was that it was known that the economist was very sick and would not live long. Schumpeter died five days after we visited him.</p><p>I have never forgotten that conversation. I learned from it three things: First, one has to ask oneself what one wants to be remembered for. Second, that should change. It should change both with one’s own maturity and with changes in the world.</p><p>Finally, one thing worth being remembered for is the difference one makes in the lives of people.</p><p>I am telling this long story for a simple reason. All the people I know who have managed to remain effective during a long life have learned pretty much the same things I learned.</p><p>That applies to effective business executives and to scholars, to top ranking military people and to first-rate physicians, to teachers and to artists.</p><p>Whenever I work with a person, I try to find out to what the individual attributes his or her success. I am invariably told stories that are remarkably like mine.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/529/1*t6ZSPZhxB9K8YuLULneouA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Chapter 4</strong></p><p><strong>L&amp;D’s Role in Creating Corporate Wealth: Overcoming Training Myopia</strong></p><p><strong>Chapter 4 Part I: Drucker on Learning for Performance &amp; Results</strong></p><p>In 1954, Peter F. Drucker retold the parable of the three stonecutters.</p><p>It goes something like this:</p><p>Asked what they were doing:</p><ul><li>the first replied, “I am making a living.”</li><li>the second replied, “I am doing the best job of stone cutting in the country.”</li><li>the third replied, “I am building a cathedral.”</li></ul><p>After reading this article, we hope many in the training/learning profession view their role as “building a cathedral.” This is the first in a series of articles that attempts to set the stage for strategically repositioning the internal training organization.</p><p>Though practical rather than theoretical, this article has a core thesis: Corporate economic performance rests on knowledge and its applications. Done correctly, knowledge increases corporate wealth, which, in turn, increases societal wealth.</p><p>Human beings apply knowledge. For them to do so requires systematic, well-organized training/learning programs in a variety of forms. The results of learning and knowledge applications must increase productivity and innovation.</p><p>Stated differently: New wealth creation is a function of two explanatory variables — productivity improvement and innovation. The beacons of productivity and innovation must become the guideposts for judging, or at least appraising, the effectiveness of training/learning activities.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/939/1*szX4aEwY_i4mrEJdUU1GJA.png" /></a></figure><p><strong>Training Myopia: What Business Are We Really In?</strong></p><p>Back in the ’60s, the article “Marketing Myopia” published in the Harvard Business Review by Theodore Levitt, then-distinguished professor of marketing at the Harvard Graduate School of Business, made a tremendous impact on senior level executives.</p><p>Levitt said most company management teams were looking at their businesses with tunnel vision, what he termed myopia.</p><p>He implored people in the airline business or railroad business to broaden their perspectives to realize that they were actually in the transportation business. Their customers wanted to be moved from one location to another by some affordable, efficient means of transportation, and they didn’t really care whether the vehicle was a plane, train, bus, or car.</p><p>Levitt implicitly stated that before an organization broadens its vision, it must be sure it has the core competencies or specific knowledges required for success.</p><p><strong>Product-Oriented Versus Market-Oriented Definitions</strong></p><p>Management should avoid a market definition that is too narrow or broad. Marketing guru Philip Kotler provided the following illustration in an early edition of his classic textbook Marketing Management:</p><p>“Consider a lead-pencil manufacturer…If it sees itself as a writing instruments company, it might expand into the production of pens…</p><p>…If it sees itself as a writing-equipment company, it might consider making word processors…The broadest concept of its business is that of a communications company, but this would be stretching things too far…”</p><p>Because of Levitt’s article, many organizations looked beyond their specific products and/or services and attempted to define the specific value they were providing to their customers.</p><p>As a result, organizations selling, say, maintenance services decided they were in the corrosion control business; oil companies redefined themselves as natural energy companies; watch/clock manufacturers redefined themselves as being in the time business (this opened up their horizons to oven clocks, vault timers and the like).</p><p>Encyclopedia Britannica redefined itself as being in the information distribution business; Carrier changed from defining its business as making air conditioners and furnaces to providing climate control in the home; Missouri-Pacific Railroad reinvented itself by defining the company as “a people-and-goods mover.”</p><p><strong>How Does This Apply to Internal Training Organizations (ITOs)?</strong></p><p>For starters, those of us involved with the internal training function would be better served if we stopped thinking we are in the training/ learning business and started realizing we are in the business of creating corporate wealth, instead. Properly viewed, the internal training organization is charged with the awesome responsibility of preparing/enabling employees to achieve greater productivity and innovation, that is, greater corporate wealth.</p><p>This kind of thinking will elevate your expectations, get you to ask the right questions about the current and future role of training/learning in your organization, and, above all, liberate you to create and grow opportunities for your training/learning activities.</p><p>Admittedly, this may be a foreign thought process to many readers. But it will soon click. Keep reading. Your “aha” moment will arrive. So, let’s get started.</p><p><strong>How Training (an American Invention) Created the Foundation of Societal Wealth</strong></p><p>In the book Wealth of Nations (1776), Adam Smith discussed how it took centuries for a country to build a core competency. Germany, for example, “because of grueling winters coupled with lots of snow, learned to be woodworkers and make clocks and violins. It took almost 200 years for them to do so.” Smith called this “the tradition of labor.”</p><p>“America, in its early beginnings,” noted Drucker, “bribed English craftsmen and supplied them with false papers to come to America and teach us how to build textile machinery and dye cotton….New England became an industrial power around 1810.”</p><p>Translated, America founders put NIH (Not Invented Here) behind them — and learned to copy with unique adaptation/enhancement from the best. Americans aggressively sought out the knowledge of experts in foreign countries and practiced what might be called today creative swiping or innovative imitation.</p><p>In short, swiping from the best with pride telescoped the 200 years involved in Adam Smith’s tradition of labor to a decade or so. America, because of its initial practice of creative swiping quickly built a thriving economy and was enabled to turn out high-quality products by importing needed expertise.</p><p><strong>Apprenticeship</strong></p><p>The next big workforce productivity breakthrough was apprenticeship. First introduced in Germany, apprenticeship led to the formation of specialty skill craft guilds. These guilds were credited with speeding up the skill acquisition learning process.</p><p>According to Drucker, “Prior to World War I, unions were craft monopolies; membership in them was restricted to sons or relatives of members. They required apprenticeship of five to seven years, but had no systematic training or work study. Nothing was ever allowed to be written down; there were not even blueprints or other drawings of the work to be done…The members were sworn to secrecy and were not permitted to discuss their work with non-members.”</p><p>The 200 years required to build a nation’s skills, observed by Adam Smith, was reduced or compressed into five to seven years because of the exposure to the experience of master craftsmen, that is, apprenticeship learning. That was considered real progress. And it was.</p><p><strong>Moving from Apprenticeship Learning to Training</strong></p><p>Next, came the invention of TRAINING. It was the greatest workforce productivity revolution of all time.</p><p>Training was, in reality, the invention of Frederick Winslow Taylor (1856 –1915). Taylor was the first to study, and reengineer (i.e. redesign) work so that the worker could become more productive — enabling workers to work smarter not harder.</p><p>Taylor studied, analyzed, and divided work into a series of systematic, well-organized steps each of which had to be done in one specific way and with a specific set of tools. This led directly to the invention of training. Why? Because Taylor’s approach converted the work to be done into a methodology that could be quickly and easily learned.</p><p>Take, for example, Taylor’s first project: analyzing a laborer shoveling sand. He figured out which steps to eliminate and how to do the job with the least physical strain on the operator. Further, he found the traditional shovel was the wrong size, wrong shape, and it had the wrong handle. He then redesigned the shovel for maximum output with minimum effort.</p><p>As a consequence, the laborer’s productivity (output/hours worked) nearly tripled. The job became easier and enabled the laborer to be paid a much higher wage.</p><p>Taylor was probably America’s, if not the world’s, first industrial engineer and first instructional course designer. Taylor made manual work capable of being taught, learned and practiced. In short, he enabled a “craft skill” (i.e. ad hoc experience, anecdote and the like) to be converted into a step-by-step methodology or systematic learning program.</p><p>The result of Taylor’s work? Five or seven years of apprenticeship was reduced to weeks or months of systematic, well-organized learning, that is, training. Now, people could acquire both elementary and advanced skills fast and successfully via training rather than apprenticeship.</p><p>Training made many kinds of apprenticeship obsolete. Training substituted systematic learning for exposure to experience. Training enabled people to put knowledge, skills, and tools to work in a very short period of time. Training enabled us to acquire in less time and with the less effort what took years of apprenticeship to learn.</p><p>Bottom Line: Training telescoped five or more years of apprenticeship learning into six months or even 90 days.</p><p><strong>Historians Believe Taylor’s Contribution to Training Helped Win World War II</strong></p><p>Taylor’s greatest impact all told was probably in training. Many believe Taylor’s approach to training explains, more than any other factor, why the United States was able to defeat both Germany and Japan in World War II.</p><p>The United States’ Armed Forces during World War II applied Taylor’s methodology to train thousands of recruits and draftees to serve as navigators, electricians, pilots, cooks, welders, riveters, quality inspectors, paramedics, masons and hundreds of other skilled positions.</p><p>To get these young men and women up to speed, trainers compressed years of experience into months (sometimes weeks) of organized and systematic learning. Formal course work replaced apprenticeship. The Armed Forces used systems and programs as the foundation for a great variety of skills, such as clerical, supervisory, engineering, and medical.</p><p>It was commonly believed before World War II that years of mentoring, coaching, and practicing were necessary to attain first-class skills in the manual crafts. During the war however, everyday Americans with average native intelligence became highly skilled craftsman after 60 to 90 days of training.</p><p><strong>Taylor’s Training: Foundation of Post-World War II Economic Growth</strong></p><p>Taylor-based training, observed Drucker, endowed a relatively lowwage workforce with world-class productivity in practically no time:</p><p>“All the earlier economic powers in modern history — Great Britain, the United States, Germany — emerged through leadership in new technology…The post-World War II economic powers — first Japan, then South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore — all owe their rise to Taylor’s training.”</p><p>In The New Convergence, Nobel Peace Prize winner Michael Spence shows how workforce productivity exponentially increased (because of training and retraining) in all advanced countries (and now in developing nations), and why those productivity increases correlate with a huge expansion in both the standard of living and quality of life.</p><p>Drucker said: “Consider that years ago, there wasn’t a person in South Korea who had any tradition of skill or craft if only because Japan didn’t allow its neighbors to acquire any…Today, Korea can do almost anything any advanced industrial nation does, thanks to training.”</p><p><strong>Knowledge is the Source of New Corporate Wealth</strong></p><p>Karl Marx was thought by many to be brilliant. He was. For starters, he had an uncanny knack for asking the right questions. Unfortunately, he was not so good at getting the right answers.</p><p>What creates wealth? Marx’s answer was the worker. He called his answer the labor theory of value. He was close but no cigar. He missed the underlying contributor to enabling human beings (i.e. the worker) to create wealth.</p><p>What is that enabler? It’s KNOWLEDGE. The real source of wealth is KNOWLEDGE.</p><p><strong>Drucker’s Insights About Knowledge</strong></p><p>“Knowledge is a specifically human resource. It is not found in books (and cannot be obtained through spell-binding lectures). Books (and lectures) contain information; whereas knowledge is the ability to apply information to specific work and performance. And that only comes with a human being, his brain or the skill of his hands.”</p><p>“We now know that the source of wealth is something specifically human: knowledge…If we apply knowledge to tasks we already know how to do, we call it ‘productivity’… If we apply knowledge to tasks that are new and different, we call it ‘innovation.’”</p><p>The beacons of productivity and innovation must be our guides in judging whether or not wealth creation is occurring.</p><p>If an organization, by whatever means, continues to improve productivity of all key resources and innovative standing, it’s going to be profitable. This, we assert, should be the primary focus of all training/learning activities.</p><p>Labor, most notably the knowledge worker, has to be equipped with the right knowledge(s) to achieve productivity improvement and innovation. That’s what creates wealth for the organization which, in turn, creates societal wealth.</p><p><strong>Productivity Improvement: Applying Knowledge to Tasks We are Already Doing</strong></p><p>The American economy is expected to grow at the abysmally low rate of 2 percent per year over the next decade or so. Translated, this means we can expect a slow/low growth economy that will force organizations to re-strategize and cut costs.</p><p>ITOs will have to formulate new programs and activities to equip professional, managerial, technical, and administrative workers with the skills required to effectively carry out tasks required by new corporate agendas.</p><p><strong>Structured Learning Programs Boosts Workforce Productivity</strong></p><p>What’s the purpose of providing employees with a structured learning program on, say, new concepts in production planning scheduling and control? Or structured learning programs on maintenance management, sales management, facilities management, call center management, warehousing management, manufacturing management, shop floor control, digital marketing and the like?</p><p>Think about it for a moment. The purpose is greater productivity — getting more output (or better outcomes) with the same amount of resources or the same output with less resources. It’s really not much different from Taylor’s redesign of the task of shoveling.</p><p>By enabling employees to learn how to put into practice new techniques, technologies and methodologies should result in increased productivity. That’s what most learning and knowledge applications are all about.</p><p>This means information presented in all forms has to be put into actual practice to be useful. It has to result in increased productivity. So, applying knowledge to tasks we already know how to do, increases productivity. Remember that! It will serve you well when talking to your CEO and/or CFO.</p><p>People have to be trained, and re-trained in many instances, to correctly apply the information to obtain the desired results. Ultimately, if successful, corporate wealth increases because resource productivity increases.</p><p><strong>Productivity in Knowledge Work and Service Work Demands We Build Continuous Learning into the Job and Into the Organization</strong></p><p>Many global ITOs are spreading best internal practices through the use of organized continuous learning activities. They bring together various groups — market researchers, chemical engineers, digital marketers, maintenance managers, warehouse supervisors for social media get-togethers.</p><p>Many companies have star plants, which are held up as examples to other plants located around the world. Knowledge gained in one part of the world can be used to gain advantage in another. By comparing the performance of different divisions via the use of measurement, the worst performers learn what the best are doing to get superior results.</p><p>There is a need for workers, whether unskilled, skilled, or knowledge workers, to share with others what they have learned to improve their performance.</p><p>Continuous learning, as opposed to structured learning, must ask knowledge workers the following question on a continuous basis: “What have you learned that can make your job and the job of all of us (doing a similar thing) more productive, better performing, and better achieving?”</p><p>We believe ITOs must organize these social media get-togethers. Sharing best internal practices increases both individual and organizational productivity. And this leads directly to wealth creation via productivity improvement.</p><p><strong>The Discipline of Innovation — It’s Capable of Being Taught, Learned, and Practiced</strong></p><p>An established company in an age demanding innovation — but not capable of innovation — is doomed to decline and extinction. And management in today’s low/slow growth economy that does not know how to stimulate, direct, and make effective innovation is incompetent to its task.</p><p>Innovation is not improvement. Improvement aims at making the already successful better still. It is a never-ending activity that requires specific quantitative goals, such as annual improvements of 3 percent to 5 percent in cost, quality, and customer satisfaction. Improvement starts with feedback from the frontline: people who actually make the product and will deliver the service, salespeople, and, of course, the end-users.</p><p>After feedback information is collected and analyzed, the company’s scientists, engineers, or product designers must convert the front line’s suggestions and queries into changes in product, process, or service. But, again, improvement is not innovation.</p><p>Innovation is sometimes confused with managed evolution. Managed evolution, observed Drucker, is the use of a new product, process, or service to spawn an even newer product, process or service.</p><p><strong>A Quick Example of Managed Evolution</strong></p><p>Interestingly, many years ago Drucker was a consultant for ServiceMaster (a multi-billion-dollar corporation) and helped them define “What is our business?”</p><p>He (and members of the management group) determined they had great strength in applying Taylor-based training methods and, as a consequence, could quickly and easily prepare low-skilled people to do a very specific type work.</p><p>Essentially ServiceMaster is a low-tech organization that specializes in providing supporting functions–such as termite and pest control, landscape maintenance, office maintenance, and home care for the elderly.</p><p>Elizabeth Edersheim in the Definitive Drucker said: “The core of the company’s business is to offer professional management of the jobs that most of its clients consider menial and a nuisance to oversee… The real secret to the company’s success, however, is its unique ability to develop sometimes illiterate hires into highly productive, motivated and quality-conscious service workers.”</p><p>Drucker believed that ServiceMaster was the perfect example of an organization that grew–and continues to grow– through managed evolution. Specifically he said:</p><p>“ServiceMaster started with the systematic application of industrial engineering to hospital maintenance and the training of low-skill people…It then evolved this, step-by-step, into office maintenance and the care of elderly shut-ins…Managed evolution is always market driven; it often requires, however, new, or at least newly developed, technology and tools.”</p><p><strong>What is Innovation?</strong></p><p>Innovation is the specific function of entrepreneurship, whether in an existing business, a public-service institution or a new venture started by two friends in a garage.</p><p>Innovation is doing truly and different things. Innovation is much more than spinoffs from science and engineering. It is creating new value.</p><p>The measure of innovation is the impact on the environment. The iPod, iPhone and iPad are examples of real innovation with tremendous societal impact.</p><p><strong>Can Innovation be Taught?</strong></p><p>Drucker and others provided the equivalent of a structured learning program that enables managers to easily and quickly acquire what had, since the beginning of time, been accessible only to the neargenius. What formally required trial-and-error learning now requires formalized study, hard work, and, in some cases, imagination.</p><p>In short, internal entrepreneurship can be learned. It’s an acquired skill. (We will discuss this in future articles). For example, fast-track managers can be taught what kind of innovation is likely to become a major product or process, a major new business, a major market; managers can be taught how to identify areas where innovation is needed; managers can be taught how to develop the right organizational structures to nurture innovation.</p><p>Managers can be taught how to budget for innovation as opposed to budgeting for the ongoing organization; managers can be taught how to formulate and implement the appropriate entrepreneurial strategies and venture management systems, and much more.</p><p><strong>Implications for ITOs</strong></p><p>Innovation is not a “Eureka moment.” Thanks to the work of Drucker and many others, fast-track managers can be “trained” to produce and manage innovation. Once again, training can be used to create new wealth via structured learning programs and organized continuous learning activities dedicated to the subject of innovation.</p><p>In this period of extreme slow economic growth, innovation will be required to thrive and survive. Producing and managing innovation is an essential and acquirable skill for management.</p><p>Yes, managing innovation is in acquirable management skill. Repeat that to yourself five times. Innovation can be taught, learned, and practiced. In the final analysis, ITOs that convert this truism into operating reality will help create new corporate wealth for their organization.</p><p><strong>Summary and Conclusions</strong></p><p>There are two components to creating corporate wealth — productivity improvement and innovation. The right kind of training can significantly increase workforce productivity and create wealth producing innovation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/546/1*wJALyNuVvXPRJYryZLdxRA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Chapter 5</strong></p><p><strong>Learning to Learn: Preparing People for Lifelong Performance &amp; Results</strong></p><p><strong>Chapter 5 Part I: Drucker on Learning for Performance &amp; Results</strong></p><p>This article synthesizes many of Drucker’s astonishing observations about why the most important thing to learn in school is how to learn — the habit of continuous learning. More specifically, Drucker pinpointed specific practices for enabling young people to discover learning and the joy of learning.</p><p>Another thing: Most educated people who go to work in their early 20s will keep on working until they are 70 or 75. And perhaps even older if current longevity trends continue. Second and third careers will become the norm.</p><p>Translated, this means people must be prepared to want to learn — to see continuous learning as something they enjoy doing not something they need to do.</p><p>Thankfully, Drucker provided us with clear, practical advice on what needs to be done to enable people to acquire the habit of learning and be prepared to combat inevitable knowledge obsolescence and boredom.</p><p>Many believe the answer to improving our school system resides in finding and hiring the best teachers. Others believe the focus of our school system must be on learning rather than teaching.</p><p>Unfortunately, it’s a false hope to get “better teachers” in quantity. Superior teachers will always be in short supply.</p><p>What we need is the proper usage of learning technologies to elevate the performance of all teachers.</p><p><strong>Needed: A Systematic Learning Methodology</strong></p><p>Peter F. Drucker observed that teaching is the only major occupation for which we have not yet developed tools that make an average person capable of competence and performance in the classroom.</p><p>Said Drucker: “In teaching we rely on the ‘naturals,’ the ones who somehow know how to teach. Nobody seems to know, however, what is it the ‘naturals’ do the rest of us do not do…</p><p>…The only way we can get better results is by giving qualified teachers the right tools and by organizing their work properly.”</p><p>Drucker contended that teaching involves artistry. Therefore he concluded that it is impossible for artistry to confine itself to the boundaries of routine and convention.</p><p>Because there are so few truly gifted teachers, it is impractical to rely on the naturals. This reality of statistical probability dictates an inevitable gap between master and pedestrian teachers.</p><p>Without going into detail about “the role of the teacher in motivating students to learn.” It can be said that a mediocre teacher tells; a good teacher explains; a superior teacher demonstrates; a great teacher does all three.</p><p>Today’s learning technologies gives to today’s competent teacher a capacity to perform well beyond that of the ablest teacher of 50 or 100 years ago, and enables the outstanding teacher of today to produce learning miracles.</p><p><strong>Learning Smarter</strong></p><p>The world is changing. Developing countries are hungry for knowledge. They want to put new and old knowledge to work. To become more productive. To become effective competitors.</p><p>We all know this. This requires us to prepare students for tomorrow’s realities.</p><p>Today’s reality (and tomorrow’s) calls for continuous learning and training.</p><p>Students must be equipped with something that yesterday’s schools paid little attention to: They need to learn how to learn.</p><p>They will need this skill to economically survive. Schools must prepare students to learn again and again — just to keep up in their respective fields and for second and possibly third careers.</p><p>Said Drucker: “They must be prepared to want to learn — to see it not as something they need to do, but as something they enjoy doing… they will have to learn how to learn… they will have to have acquired the habit of learning.”</p><p>Drucker pointed out, again and again, in schools of today many students lose self-confidence. And that’s the greatest barrier to learning. Much of Drucker’s writing on the subject deals with overcoming this deficiency in our educational system.</p><p>In essence, Drucker proposed three principles upon which our school system must be based. These are:</p><ul><li>Schools must focus on the student’s strengths (as opposed to their weaknesses)</li><li>Schools must recognize that one of the best ways to learn is to teach others</li><li>Schools must employ learning technologies to enable young people to work individually at their own speed, rhythm and attention span</li></ul><p><strong>Focusing on the Learner’s Strengths</strong></p><p>For starters, we know how people learn how to learn. All it requires is to focus on the strengths and talents of learners so that they will excel in whatever it is they do well.</p><p>Said Drucker: “Any teacher of young artists — musicians, actors, painters — knows this. So does any teacher of young athletes.”</p><p>But most schools are forced — understandably — to focus instead on a learner’s weaknesses. That’s the way the system works.</p><p>“When teachers call in the parents of a 10-year-old, they usually say: ‘Your Jimmy has to work on the multiplication tables. He is way behind.’</p><p>They rarely say: Your Jimmy should do a good deal more writing to do even better at what he already does well’…”</p><p>Teachers tend to focus on the weaknesses of students, and for good reasons: The school has to endow students with the basic skills they will need whichever way you choose to go.</p><p>But — and this is a very big but — “one cannot build performance on weaknesses, even on corrected ones; one can build performance only on strengths.”</p><p>Schools are problem-focused. But that must change. In today’s society, teachers will have to learn to say: “ I will focus on your child’s strengths and that will give him/her self confidence and self-esteem.”</p><p>Children must be given a sense of achievement and that means building on their strengths.</p><p>When a student focuses on what they’re good at, whether they play computer games or writing, they tend improve upon what they’re not good at.</p><p><strong>In short</strong>: By focusing on what they are good at, they become motivated to overcome their weaknesses in other subjects.</p><p><strong>Learning by Teaching Others</strong></p><p>“Just as no one learns as much about a subject as the person who was forced to teach it, no one develops as much as the person who is trying to help others to develop themselves.”</p><p>This is a simple, but amazing insight into the learning process. Anyone who has taught/trained others immediately recognizes this Drucker truism.</p><p>Simply put, the best way to learn is to teach .</p><p>Indeed, observed Drucker, “one of the reasons why the one-room schoolhouse “of a century ago was such a good learning environment is that the teacher with 70 kids from ages 6 to 16 had to use the older children to tutor and mentor the younger ones… And the older children learned…”</p><p>In a series of time-spaced articles Drucker repeatedly noted that teaching others had to be part of the specs for the school of tomorrow.</p><p>The key question: How do we put more advanced youngsters to work teaching so that they not only learn but also discover learning and the joy of learning? Much research is being done with respect to going from principle to practice with respect to learning through teaching.</p><p><strong>Technology-Assisted Learning</strong></p><p>The technology exists to produce and manage real learning. Electronic messaging, when professionally done, in form and style art expert, masterly, teaching, communicating.</p><p>Take, for instance, the 30-second television commercial. Every splitsecond counts; every word means something.</p><p>“Few teachers spend in their entire teaching careers as much time with thought on preparing that classes as is invested in the many months of writing, drawing, acting, filming, and editing one 30 second commercial…”</p><p>More than 50 years ago Drucker observed that “electronic messaging conveys accessible information ,clear image, and perfect comprehension…</p><p>…It is just the right length for the attention span of the small child… It is perfect learning in its methodology, is indeed the prototype of the “ideal program” with its three key elements: effective sequence of the material, validation through repetition, and self-motivation of the learner through pleasure.”</p><p>We have reviewed some astonishing DVD/streaming programs in fundamentals of mathematics, algebra 1, algebra 2 and others. Great teachers coupled with animations, simulation exercises, and all the rest make difficult concepts exciting and easy to understand. Need we say more?</p><p>Indeed, we have also reviewed programs that have built-in tutors. For example, if the student has difficulty with, say, subtraction, he/she is led into a tutorial that teaches subtraction in a way very few teachers could replicate.</p><p>Stated differently, technology makes it possible for the individual student to work individually, and work at his or her own speed and rhythm and attention span. Technology can also extend a teacher’s span, the time teacher has to spend with individuals.</p><p>With the type of technology available today, the student can manage himself or herself quite effectively. Yes, “you still have to supervise them, but to a large extent, but to a large extent the oldest children do that, if you use them as teachers…”</p><p>Asking the Right Questions About our Educational System</p><p>Drucker emphasized the need to ask the right questions. He believed that the most serious mistakes are not the result of wrong answers. The truly dangerous thing is asking the wrong questions — and getting the right answers.</p><p>Executives in business or administrators in a government agency, parents or their children, policy-makers or citizens, teachers or students must make every effort to address the right questions.</p><p>For decades, politicians among others, observed Drucker, have been asking the wrong questions about how to improve our educational system. At best, they been getting the right answers to the wrong questions.</p><p>Once the right questions are formulated, the school of tomorrow will not just be a restored version of yesterday’s (or today’s) school.</p><p>It will have different objectives and different priorities. It will prepare students for a world that requires continuous learning and re-training.</p><p>We have to facilitate “learning smarter” as opposed to better teaching. Today, many of these tools are now available. Learning technologies, in the last few years, have made remarkable gains. However, the majority on these tools have not yet made their way into the classroom.</p><p><strong>Unfortunately, the focus of many schools is still on teaching not learning.</strong></p><p>Billions of dollars have been spent in an attempt to get better teachers. But it won’t happen. It’s money down the drain if the cost to results ratio is examined.</p><p>Our politicians and educators must begin to ask the right questions about education. If they don’t, America’s economic prosperity, standard of living, income equality and world standing ill greatly diminish.</p><p>The next five years will make unprecedented demands on political courage, political imagination, political innovation, and political leadership. After all is said and done, we need government competence.</p><p>Summarizing: Income Equality and Education</p><p>For America to remain competitive, its students need to learn vastly more, much more quickly. The Gates foundation, among others, have demonstrated a link between a country’s GDP and the academic test scores of its children.</p><p>Stanford economist Eric Hanushek’s statistical analyses have found “that if a country scores were only a half a standard deviation higher than another’s in 1960, its GDP grew a full percentage point faster in every subsequent year through 2000.”</p><p>Translated, long-term growth in the United States is dependent upon dramatically increasing the quality of our educational system.</p><p>Discussions relating to income equality rarely mention equality of effort. It seems that the effort is not only related to the individual student but to the entire system.</p><p>If we wait until these challenges have indeed become insurmountable, perhaps we will never recover.</p><p><strong>A Glimpse of What You Can Expect from Reading the Total E- book (parts I — IV)</strong></p><p>We believe you are going to love this e- book. It is not a “fad” book; it is a “fact” book — full of truths, concepts, and thought processes that are timeless and actionable.</p><p>We believe it can/will change the way you view the role and mission of your internal training organization.</p><p>Today’s knowledge-based workforce are becoming the largest single group… and have already become the major creator of corporate wealth. Increasingly the success, indeed the survival of every business will depend on the performance of its knowledge workforce.</p><p>What does this mean? Workforce training, constant retraining and continuous learning activities must climb to the top of the agenda of the individual firm and the nation.</p><p>More than ever before, internal training organizations must prepare its workforce for a rapidly arriving and disruptive future. Drucker’s teachings form a blueprint for every thinking leader.</p><p>The true objective of many of Drucker’s principles and practices is to take chaos and uncertainties as givens and convert them from problems into opportunities.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*pTNdl-A8GpypNBzkxGOIFA.png" /></a></figure><p><strong>Here follows some of the general topics you’ll learn about in this four-part series:</strong></p><ul><li>Training measurements related to business results and/or process management</li><li>Aligning training with corporate goals via usage of strategy maps</li><li>Technology-assisted behavioral learning (i.e. drill, repetition, incessant practice)</li><li>Social media and organized continuous learning (i.e. sharing best practices between and among employees to increase productivity)</li><li>Management development and manager development in rapidly changing technological and business environments</li><li>Understanding how people learn… and how to design instructional programs to capitalize on easily forgotten but enduring truths about learning principles &amp; practices</li><li>How training can nurture internal entrepreneurship in an era of management</li><li>Training measurements related to business results and/o</li><li>Using the Beacons of Productivity &amp; Innovation as Guideposts in Designing &amp; Appraising Training Outcomes</li><li>How talent management through training and continuous learning can restore the will to work at all levels in the organization</li><li>Strategic leadership development in a turbulent economic and world environment — how to develop the thinking skills to adapt quickly, navigate messy environments, and grow talent assets to survive and thrive</li><li>The critical linkage between talent management &amp; Internal training organizations: Working together to create &amp; deliver career products that attract &amp; retaining employees</li><li>And much more!</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=21879bcb7716" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/drucker-on-training-management-development-21879bcb7716">Drucker On Training &amp; Management Development</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons">On Business Process Management and Workflow Automation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Five Catalysts of Implementation Success]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/the-five-catalysts-of-implementation-success-63c09ddb2dec?source=rss-6e478a9a46e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/63c09ddb2dec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Frank J. Wyatt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Mar 2019 05:13:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-11T16:15:48.558Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Dale Carnegie was once quoted as saying: “Develop success from failures. Discouragement and failure are two of the surest stepping stones to success.” So let’s first understand what contributes most to failure, as a means of making the right choices when striving for operational improvement.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*pTNdl-A8GpypNBzkxGOIFA.png" /></a></figure><h4>Failures in Implementation</h4><p>Why do we hear so many conflicting stories about how good or bad a particular improvement philosophy actually is? Whether it is Six Sigma, Lean Sigma, Lean or Manufacturing Excellence? Simple. Success is driven not only by the philosophy and tools you choose, but also by how you implement them. It is important to embrace the right approach for the pressing issues of the business — and even more important to implement the changes well. Here we will focus on the implementation phase.</p><p>There are many tough choices during implementation that have to be taken, and the twin factors of engagement and involvement are critical. Overplay it and decision making is slow and cumbersome; underplay it and you don’t have the necessary buy-in to ensure implementation success. The buy-in that we all know is essential across a wide array of functions and disciplines required to make the lasting organizational improvements everybody is looking for.</p><p>So where do implementation failures occur most frequently and what can we do to ensure they don’t occur next time around? There is of course no one simple answer, and no silver bullet to resolve this. There have been various research reports on the topic, one of the most recent published by The Wall Street Journal online that explains that without the ‘twin fires’ of senior-level involvement and sustained engagement, results decline over timei . No great surprises there then!</p><p>From the various experiences and projects that the Kepner-Tregoe (KT) team have had over the years, we can clearly identify the failures that businesses have had at three levels of interaction and communication. It is through these interactions that things get missed, forgotten, overlooked, ignored, are not aligned correctly — or are just completely misunderstood. Any of these will mean implementation falters.</p><p>These opportunities for interaction and communication failure occur at three levels and can manifest themselves in many different ways. Here are a few examples:</p><p><strong><em>– Organisation:</em></strong></p><p><em>What does each of us understand about the strategy and the different people in the different functions? What roles do they play? Who are the power players and influencers? Which processes and systems are our strength and priority? What is the best way to work within the culture that exists? How do we get things done around here? What are the rules by which the company is governed? What are the approval protocols?</em></p><p><strong><em>– Team:</em></strong></p><p><em>How do you best interact with the team? Which teams is the company made up of and how do they work? More importantly, how do they make decisions? How do they tackle complex problems? How do they mitigate risk for the teams and business? Who has to be involved and committed to the decisions of the team for success? And for how long?</em></p><p><strong><em>– People: (One-to-One: Manager/Leader to Associate/Individual or Peer to Peer)</em></strong></p><p><em>How clear are the expectations? Have they been agreed as achievable? What is our overall performance environment? What influences it and how do we influence others? How do people deliver, receive and react to critical feedback?</em></p><p>There are many questions here with the potential for confusing, inconsistent or contradictory answers, depending upon who you talk to within the organization. However if we know and understand that these are the issues, why do we not do something about them? Here are some of the most cited reasons we’ve been exposed to from our project interactions over the years:</p><p><em>– Not enough internal time to devote to the right activities</em></p><p><em>– Not enough engagement with appropriate stakeholders</em></p><p><em>– Not enough budget (irrespective of ROI) to bring in the necessary skills or capacity to get the job done</em></p><p><em>– Other short-term priorities take precedence</em></p><p><em>– The job procedures, workflows and priorities are not aligned with the new goals</em></p><p>Irrespective of responsibilities, budget, money and time, our experience leads to the following simple implementation model which needs to be adhered to in order that the success of any transformational improvement campaign can be maximized. In our book, this effectively acts as a checklist of activities to ensure they are all understood and acted upon.</p><h4>A Simple Implementation Model</h4><p>Our consultancy and training experience in Europe and worldwide has shaped our belief that there are five rules to follow. We have synthesized these to define the critical implementation success factors for an improvement program. This model is represented below and captures the key elements of work that underpin the success of a human capital-led improvement program. We’ve taken an example with a focus on troubleshooting improvement, yet we use the principles across all human capital-led improvement program.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/738/1*cQHxfOO1gpJ2qZQ9sActpQ.png" /></figure><p>There is, however, an assumption which sits behind this: that we have already got the right people who are going to both lead this transformation and support the implementation. That is not to say they have everything they need just yet. Just that they have the behaviors, attitudes, skills and knowledge that are required for the task at hand.</p><p>To understand how prepared an organization and its leaders are, our business has established a series of questions to conduct an initial assessment of Organisational Readiness for Implementation in each of these five areas.</p><h4>Rule 1: Acknowledge the Journey — Set Your Target</h4><p><em>“In an ideal world I’m not sure we would be starting here!”</em></p><p>We all get it, I’m quite sure. We have to know where we are heading in order to get on the right road. So where do you start? We have to first define some elements of the end game. You have to start with a timeframe. If we don’t set the targets, we could be going on for ever just attempting to get started. Identifying the right Key Performance Indicators and having people understand and agree them is essential.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/746/1*bVjkjGdIhurC0ox5iQQ6Jg.png" /></figure><h4>Rule 2: Understand the Capability Gaps — Prioritize Your Needs</h4><p><em>“If you always do what you’ve always done, you’ll always get what you’ve always got.”</em></p><p>To do things differently, to make new things happen, quite often requires the application of different or new skills. People may already have these skills but have just not yet tapped into them. Understanding what skills are required, what skills you’ve got and deducing from this the skills gap you have is essential to deploying people effectively to instigate improvements.</p><p>It is quite often so very easy at a human level to misunderstand the required change in people. There are different levels of seniority, capabilities and emotions which require the development of different capability development needs — one size does not fit all. Having common ways of working involves everyone understanding the roles each of us plays. We have to develop technical knowledge and expertise as well as ensuring how we work together is effective and efficient. Quite often the training carried out can be standard, but the coaching support provided is unique.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/744/1*qMv0L22NH1nSlYXZn7rqCg.png" /></figure><h4>Rule 3: Integrate the Solutions — Make Your Processes Deliver Value</h4><p><em>Colin Boughton, Operations Director from FujiFilm Speciality Ink Systems, understands what before and after looked like. “Our previous formulations were on a page of A4 and said things like ‘add ingredient slowly by stirring’,” reflects Boughton. “The description is more like a novel now. It lists the amount of material to use, the RPM for stirring and the number of seconds after which you should turn the stirrer off.”</em></p><p>To do things differently, to make new things happen, quite often requires focus on those processes that add the most value and integrate the thinking around the solution — removing both variation and waste. It is quite clear that processes should add value. There is however heavy reliance on so many other inputs to ensure success. Processes need to be well-defined, with clear steps, have defined responsibilities and be executed to the agreed standards. Then managed for accountability and continued improvement within that supporting performance environment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/742/1*Mlxu-rOBhL3SwrWi8AIhwg.png" /></figure><h4>Rule 4: Align the Expectations — Lead by Example</h4><p><em>William Egenton, Managing Director of Dromone Engineering, comments, “Ensuring there is value built in from an integrated end-to-end process view is essential for any transformational improvement program. There are always many things to do but integrating our approach and prioritizing the work gives us much more clarity on where to get the best return.”</em></p><p>Getting the expectations and the measures aligned from the board room to the shop floor ensures people share in the pain and the reward. With this achieved, role modeling behavior becomes so much more meaningful. The aim of making every day our very best day can then mean everyone gets involved, supporting one another to get things done.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/744/1*rlUn6VnO2nKnELfmc-ME0w.png" /></figure><h4>Rule 5: Never Rest — Coach for Exceptionally High Performance</h4><p><em>“Courage is what it takes to stand up and speak. Courage is also what it takes to sit down and listen.”</em></p><p>The external environment is unforgiving. There are new players entering the market. New regulations to comply with and constant technological advances that exceed most people’s imaginations. The mantra of continuous improvement has been with us for years, however getting the final ounces of improvement requires dedication and focus. Ensuring that there is an independent eye, a critical challenging observer, is essential to ongoing development.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/747/1*BNaiMnEU4tr2CNQuaOpx5g.png" /></figure><p>The five rules of the implementation model that have been outlined above have to be at the heart of any human capital transformational improvement plan. The transformational journey that is the successful achievement of your improvement goals doesn’t succeed or fail in the lecture room, the project room or the operations room, but in the board room. The executive leadership sets the tone and the priorities — and creates the heartbeat of the business. For transformational change where people are at the heart, we all look to our role models; role models who we respect, trust and can relate to.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/939/1*szX4aEwY_i4mrEJdUU1GJA.png" /></a></figure><h4>The Transformational People Plan</h4><p>So in addressing the failures outlined previously — and to maximize our probability of implementation success, we need to address the engagement and involvement failures of people, teams and the organization in the context of the implementation model. We also need to look for the role models who make those things happen.</p><h4>A Good Individual Job</h4><p>Everyone comes to work to do a good job.</p><p>There are, of course, those who need more time and energy spent on them than others to get the most out of them. Yet few come to work thinking, “I am deliberately going to underperform today.” When it comes to interaction and communication, the failure to execute well at an individual level will be down to the performance environment that surrounds an individual. In particular:</p><p><em>– Expectations not matched or aligned in their situation,</em></p><p><em>– Inability to be clear and precise,</em></p><p><em>– No feedback,</em></p><p><em>– Out-of-balance consequences.</em></p><p>Exceptional people excel because they create their own performance environment. They don’t wait for others. If the expectations are unclear they clarify them, if they have not received any feedback they go and source it, if they don’t have all the resources they need they go and find them. Excellent performers not only deliver on their promises, they know how to remove the barriers that might get in the way. Knowing the performance system and its strengths and weaknesses in relation to your own and others’ behaviors will give you the edge.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/614/1*v7D1WpqkTMOTAK_kR7dYFw.png" /></figure><p><em>William Egenton continues: “It has added tremendous value to the Dromone team to get external support, but it is also important that there is the mutual respect at all levels so that the role modeling, coaching and feedback can all be acted upon without any negative connotations.”</em></p><p>For every individual contributor we have to ensure they are set up to make the five rules of the implementation model meaningful, relevant and above all tangible.</p><h4>An Effective Team Result</h4><p>When transformation is required, it means involvement from across all functions and departments and at the right pace. Too much engagement and things move too slowly, too little consideration and stakeholders won’t have fully ‘bought in’ and won’t be ready for implementation.</p><p>So many of the decisions have to be team-based. Not necessarily formal teams, but ad hoc teams quite often playing to different rules with different characters and different styles. In truth not everyone needs to be involved in every situation. There are, however, two key variables which determine the level of involvement and engagement:</p><p><em>– Does it make a big difference which course of action is adopted?</em></p><p><em>– Is commitment of others critical to effective implementation?</em></p><p>These two questions heavily influence the involvement style that should be adopted. If the answer to both is no, don’t waste time: make the decision and move quickly. If the answer to both is yes, then it is not so straightforward. It is critical to understand the difference between a consensual and a consultative style.</p><p>The simple involvement model illustrated below identifies five different involvement styles. Only the last style is truly consensual. The underlying influence that ‘involvement style’ plays on the implementation model’s five rules is difficult to quantify, however the alignment of expectations and prioritization of capability development are key.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/444/1*iHvwu8X4FTMKLBYj_zBjiw.png" /></figure><h4>An Organisation Transformed</h4><p>Alan Brache describes an organization in an holistic illustration he calls ‘The Enterprise Model’. He likens an enterprise to mechanical systems, in that all the moving parts have to interact in a predefined harmonious fashion. They are dependent upon one another for success. And so it is to implement human capital-focused transformational change. A new organization structure or a redefined role, a new system or the definition of a business process alone, won’t bring about the transformation some organizations need.</p><p>The principle is simple. It is the business process that adds value to the organization. Therefore to address our reasons for failure of transformational change, the understanding of what supports our business processes is essential.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/767/1*pAGnbsyEYIITAh1AA37AsA.png" /></figure><p>The decisions we make in our teams and the things we do as individuals all have to be aligned and work in synchronization. Ignore one element at your peril, as it is this element that allows the doubt and uncertainty to creep in.</p><p>The focus on business process and aligned metrics both in running a business and through the implementation model only goes to further illustrate the difficulties so many managers and leaders have in both running their business and changing their business simultaneously.</p><h4>Conclusion: Critical Implementation Success Factors</h4><p>It is of course all about people. Jim Collins wrote: “Get the right people on the bus, sit them in the right seats and then figure out where to take it.” Without the right people with the right skills in the right place, implementation becomes virtually impossible. So returning to our original question: is it simply that improvement initiatives fail because we don’t have the right people?</p><p>Individuals can’t do it on their own. There needs to be flawless interaction with peers, within teams and across an aligned and purposeful organization. Of course we need to develop our people to transform the organization, but in developing those people we must ensure we know:</p><p><em>– What the skills are targeted to achieve</em></p><p><em>– That the business processes are aligned</em></p><p><em>– The business culture, leadership and performance environment are aligned, and…</em></p><p><em>– That there is coaching support, facilitation and guidance every step of the way</em></p><p>After all, the very best in the business of sport need their coaches, why not the very best in the business of business? In one pharmaceutical company with which we work, the stigma has been lifted. The coach whose existence was once denied is now introduced by their executive to colleagues in a lift; a badge of honor, a sign that investment and support for the very best can only make them better.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*mYg-kLIbyQnqTbTpHKi3FQ.png" /></a></figure><p>We will finish with a two line tale and don’t get us wrong — some of our best business colleagues are CFOs:</p><p><em>– CFO to CEO: “What if we develop our people and they leave?”</em></p><p><em>– CEO responds: “What if we don’t develop our people and they stay?”</em></p><p>We need therefore to recruit, acquire or create our heroes of change. If they don’t already exist, the team needs supplementing. But at the end of the program we need those talented people to have delivered their all and be ready for the next challenge for which they are now much better equipped.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=63c09ddb2dec" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/the-five-catalysts-of-implementation-success-63c09ddb2dec">The Five Catalysts of Implementation Success</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons">On Business Process Management and Workflow Automation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Top 5 Objections to Adopting Process Excellence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/top-5-objections-to-adopting-process-excellence-91540423f4f3?source=rss-6e478a9a46e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/91540423f4f3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[process-excellence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Frank J. Wyatt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Mar 2019 05:11:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-11T16:17:04.828Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The number one challenge cited by the heads of change and business transformation is the issue of getting management buy-in. In answer to this crucial challenge, we examine the most common objections you will encounter when implementing your Process Excellence initiative and approaches you can take to not only get that initial management buy-in, but also see the project through to completion and success.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*mYg-kLIbyQnqTbTpHKi3FQ.png" /></a></figure><h4><strong>1. Process Excellence is Not a Priority</strong></h4><p><strong>– SENIOR MANAGEMENT DOES NOT SEE THE BENEFIT</strong></p><p>You cannot even begin Process Excellence unless you convince your senior management of the benefits. The problem is your organization has been functioning adequately for years without Process Excellence so why should your company adopt it now?</p><p><strong>Common Causes for Objection:</strong></p><ul><li>Lack of awareness of Process Excellence benefits</li><li>Uncertainty regarding how projects will be selected</li><li>Lack of Process Excellence experts at leadership level</li><li>There may be a legacy of unsuccessful quality programs</li><li>Can the top leadership sell this to customers as differentiator</li></ul><p><strong>Ways to Overcome Objections:</strong></p><p>Top leadership needs to be made aware of Process Excellence benefits, but how? One way of doing this is to emphasise the risk of falling behind by demonstrating which competitors are already implementing Process Excellence. When forming your team, ensure that you carefully choose the right people to lead the Process Excellence program. Then make sure you select a just few critical projects first and prioritize achieving results as early as possible. Once you’ve gotten these results, be sure to share your success stories to develop organisational confidence.</p><p>2 What financial benefits will your process excellence initiative really yield? Whilst Process Excellence requires time and investment, the prospect will be significantly easier for your senior colleagues to understand if you can clearly and reliably demonstrate the ROI. Underestimate the benefits and you may encounter challenges getting the buy-in, but overestimate and you’ll find yourself falling short and damaging your chances of continuing. Common Causes for Objection: l Have your estimated savings been validated? l Have accounting principles been followed? l Estimations have been based on virtual assumptions l Lack of approval of “actuals” from financial teams l Lack of financial knowledge amongst Process Excellence leads Ways to Overcome Objections: It’s critical that Process Excellence leaders understand financial accounting methods. One way to help with this is to ensure that stakeholders from finance teams must be a part of your Process Excellence teams. Then be sure that all your financial estimations are validated properly otherwise you will risk being discredited. Once all this is in place, ensure that all savings are linked with actual profit and loss (P&amp;L) statements so to clearly demonstrate the effect of Process Excellence on the wider business.</p><h4>2. Process Excellence Costs Too Much</h4><p><strong>– DIFFICULTY ESTIMATING ROI</strong></p><p>What financial benefits will your process excellence initiative really yield? Whilst Process Excellence requires time and investment, the prospect will be significantly easier for your senior colleagues to understand if you can clearly and reliably demonstrate the ROI. Underestimate the benefits and you may encounter challenges getting the buy-in, but overestimate and you’ll find yourself falling short and damaging your chances of continuing.</p><p><strong>Common Causes for Objection:</strong></p><ul><li>Have your estimated savings been validated?</li><li>Have accounting principles been followed?</li><li>Estimations have been based on virtual assumptions</li><li>Lack of approval of “actuals” from financial teams</li><li>Lack of financial knowledge amongst Process Excellence leads</li></ul><p><strong>Ways to Overcome Objections:</strong></p><p>It’s critical that Process Excellence leaders understand financial accounting methods. One way to help with this is to ensure that stakeholders from finance teams must be a part of your Process Excellence teams. Then be sure that all your financial estimations are validated properly otherwise you will risk being discredited. Once all this is in place, ensure that all savings are linked with actual profit and loss (P&amp;L) statements so to clearly demonstrate the effect of Process Excellence on the wider business.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/939/1*szX4aEwY_i4mrEJdUU1GJA.png" /></a></figure><h4><strong>3. </strong>Resistance to Change</h4><p><strong>-DIFFICULTY GENERATING MOMENTUM</strong></p><p>You cannot even begin Process Excellence unless you convince your senior management of the benefits. The problem is your organisation has been functioning adequately for years without Process Excellence so why should your company adopt it now?</p><p><strong>Common Causes for Objection:</strong></p><ul><li>Too complex projects</li><li>BHAG : Big Heavy Audacious Goals?</li><li>Top talent not part of Process Excellence program</li><li>Effort wasted on non-critical projects</li><li>Perceived lack of support to complete improvements</li></ul><p><strong>Ways to Overcome Objections:</strong></p><p>Start by selecting the top critical projects that impact business and then begin addressing the low hanging fruits. One way to help achieve this is to ensure that you set SMART goals, make sure that your top talent leads these critical projects and ensure that your top leaders act as “sponsors” for Process Excellence.</p><h4><strong>4. </strong>Frustration over</h4><p><strong>THE LACK OF SUPPORT INFRASTRUCTURE NEEDED FOR PROCESS EXCELLENCE SUCCESS</strong></p><p>Even with best laid plans, implementing change within an organization can cause stresses and strain. Unless you have an adequate support structure already in place, its inability to help will impede progress and demotivate for colleagues.</p><p><strong>Common Causes for Objection:</strong></p><ul><li>Are the right people leading Process Excellence initiatives?</li><li>Lack of skills (black belts, master black belts)</li><li>Lack of program management for Process Excellence projects</li><li>Lack of training capabilities</li><li>Lack of data analysis</li></ul><p><strong>Ways to Overcome Objections:</strong></p><p>Your success depends on your people so pay careful attention to select the RIGHT people and team for Process Excellence initiatives. As for the people your initiative affects, incentivise them by ensuring that rewards and recognition is in place. To alleviate confusion, be sure to formalise everyone’s roles and responsibilities and then improve your Process Excellence training capabilities.</p><h4>5. This is Taking Too Long</h4><p><strong>WE WANT RESULTS NOW!</strong></p><p>Unless your Process Excellence initiative starts delivering results, there is an increasing chance that it will be viewed as a cost rather than a competitive advantage. Worst of all, if this sentiment is allowed to flourish, it threatens to undermine the entire project.</p><p><strong>Common Causes for Objection:</strong></p><ul><li>You have chosen the wrong projects</li><li>The business wants to see immediate results</li><li>There are no control measures</li><li>There is a lack of rewards and recognition</li><li>Are best practices being leveraged?</li></ul><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*pTNdl-A8GpypNBzkxGOIFA.png" /></a></figure><p><strong>Ways to Overcome Objections:</strong></p><p>To overcome this issue, the business must be made aware of the cost benefit of quick wins versus deep-dive Process Excellence projects. One way that will help you is to focus on choosing the right methodology to fit the task, such as using Lean tools versus traditional Six Sigma tools. At the end of the day, the tools you use should help solve problems, and not vice-versa and if you know the solution to an issue, don’t wait — JUST DO IT!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=91540423f4f3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/top-5-objections-to-adopting-process-excellence-91540423f4f3">Top 5 Objections to Adopting Process Excellence</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons">On Business Process Management and Workflow Automation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Making Knowledge Workers More Productive: Insights from the Works of Peter F. Drucker]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/making-knowledge-workers-more-productive-insights-from-the-works-of-peter-f-drucker-e3fe6ef91df9?source=rss-6e478a9a46e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e3fe6ef91df9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[drucker]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peter-drucker]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Frank J. Wyatt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Mar 2019 05:07:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-11T16:18:46.142Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>“Making knowledge workers productive requires changes in attitude, not only on the part of the individual knowledge worker, but on the part of the whole organization.” — Peter F. Drucker</blockquote><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*pTNdl-A8GpypNBzkxGOIFA.png" /></a></figure><p>Companies have a vested interest in increasing the productivity of their workforce. Increased productivity means the ability to do more without increasing headcounts.</p><p>But it means something more — much more. Knowledge workers put knowledge to work.</p><p>Knowledge workers can be doctors, robotic repair people, sales managers, maintenance managers, quality specialists, market researchers, graphic artists and the like. The list is virtually endless given the composition of today’s knowledge-based workforce.</p><p>Let’s be clear here. Information is not knowledge. Only if information is put to work can it become KNOWLEDGE. Perhaps Oscar Hammerstein said it best: “A Bell is not a bell ‘till you ring it, a song is not a song,’ till you sing it.”</p><p>Information must be applied to specific work and performance for it to be classified as knowledge. It must be mentioned — indeed, emphasized — that only human beings with their brains and/or the skill of their hands can convert information into knowledge.</p><p>Wealth creation results if knowledge workers do the right things and do them right. In other words, the right knowledge properly applied by human beings creates wealth.</p><p>Translated, this means that knowledge workers (which are completely different than manual workers) must be made more productive. Only by making knowledge workers more productive — as you’ll learn from the selected articles — can inflation be controlled and wealth created for organizations and society.</p><p>Peter F. Drucker taught us much about managing knowledge work. He provided us with a framework for being able to think through thoughtfully and thoroughly what must be done and how to do it.</p><p>In this article compilation, colleagues, and students of Peter F. Drucker, share their thoughts on what the “master of management” thought about the keys to making knowledge workers more productive.</p><p>A special thank you to Dr. Robert W. Swaim and Dr. William F. Cohen for their contributions to this report.</p><blockquote>“The most valuable assets of the 20th-century company were its production equipment. The most valuable asset of a 21st-century institution, whether business or non-business, will be its knowledge workers and their productivity.” — Peter F. Drucker</blockquote><p><strong>A NEW EMPHASIS ON PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT</strong></p><p>Productivity improvement will be a major challenge and concern in the years just ahead.</p><p>Productivity, as we’ve all heard a good many times by now, is the key to managing the inflation many believe will occur because of the government’s well-intended (but questionable) economic policies.</p><p>To have price stability, wages must not rise faster than productivity. A simple equation, formulated by C. Jackson Grayson Jr, former pricing commissioner/czar during the Nixon administration, explains this quite well:</p><p>[Wages — Productivity Increases = Price Increases]</p><p>For example, if wages increase by 10 percent and productivity increases by 3 percent, then the price increase would be 7 percent.</p><p>If wage increases gallop at a significantly faster rate than productivity, price inflation will occur.</p><p>We expect we will soon be hearing about gearing wages to productivity improvement guidelines. Unfortunately, many economists believe this never works.</p><p>One scenario predicted by several leading economists claims that using government spending to stimulate consumption is a sure-fire recipe for inflation. It will lead to too much money chasing too few goods and services.</p><p>Once the inflation starts — if, indeed it does — people will demand higher wages to keep up with the increasing cost of living. If wages increase faster than productivity increases, hyper-inflation is a possibility.</p><p>The only way our society will be able to maintain or enjoy a comfortable, let alone rising, standard of living is if managers in all enterprises solve the productivity puzzle. This is not an easy task.</p><p><strong>MANAGING PRODUCTIVITY</strong></p><p>Making resources productive is the specific job of management, as distinct from the other jobs of the “manager”: administration and entrepreneurship.</p><p>The world knows that Peter Drucker was the greatest management thinker of the last century. His story is a story of management itself.</p><p>According to Drucker, it is only managers — not nature or laws of economics or governments — that make resources productive.</p><p>Resources can be made productive in the individual plant or enterprise, the individual store, the individual hospital, the individual office, the individual research and development lab and the individual port.</p><p>They are made productive — or deprived of productivity — by individual managers within their own individual spheres of responsibility.</p><p><strong>PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT THROUGH INNOVATION</strong></p><p>Thanks to Drucker we now know quite a bit about productivity improvement. We know that it is, in part, achieved by innovation — the shifting of resources from old and declining employments to new and more productive ones.</p><p>Organizations must be able to systematically identify emerging opportunities and develop the structures required to make the new and different happen.</p><p>In his book Innovation and Entrepreneurship (Harper &amp; Row,1985), Drucker definitively described what must be done and how to do it with respect to making innovation an acquired organizational skill.</p><p>But — and this is a big but — organizations must be able to get rid of yesterday’s tasks and free their energies and resources for new and more productive tasks. Abandonment is a prerequisite for innovation and change.</p><p>“If an organization wants to be able to work on opportunities, it must be able to abandon the unproductive and slough off the obsolete,” Peter Drucker said.</p><p>No organization that purposely and systematically abandons the unproductive and obsolete ever wants for more productivity improvement opportunities. Ideas are always around in profusion.</p><p>The key, said Drucker, is to convert them into doing. Lack of creativity is, therefore, not the problem of today’s organization. Rather it is organizational inertia which always pushes for continuing what we are already doing.</p><p>Drucker left no doubt that existing organizations must know how to organize for innovation. Otherwise the ongoing business will squash newness of more than a trivial dimension.</p><p>Internal entrepreneurship will be a major trend in most organizations. It is missioncritical if organizations want to leverage productivity improvement opportunities. But internal entrepreneurship requires systematic, organized, purposeful management.</p><p>Innovation within an existing organization is a device for moving scarce and expensive resources from areas of low productivity and non-results to opportunities for achievement and contribution.</p><p><strong>MAXIMIZING PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT THROUGH CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT</strong></p><p>In addition to innovation, productivity is increased through the continuous improvement of the productivity of resources in existing deployments. Six Sigma advocates speak prescriptively of kaizen, or continuous improvement.</p><p>Trying routinely to get better one step at a time is a far better way to improve than shooting constantly for the big payoff. Major leaps into sudden business success are very rare.</p><p>Sustained success is largely a matter of focusing on streamlining and re-engineering existing processes. Getting better and better one process at a time leads to greater productivity improvement over time.</p><p><strong>PRODUCTIVITY IMPROVEMENT VIA TECHNOLOGY</strong></p><p>Technology can increase productivity if appropriately applied. Technology does not necessarily mean spin-offs from “science and engineering.”</p><p>Techne, Peter Drucker reminded us, is the Greek word from which “technology” derives and means “useful knowledge,” or “organized skill,” rather than engineering.</p><p>The substitution of capital-intensive technology for labor-intense activities in many instances can help productivity improvement. But in certain areas such as health care, more capital-intensive equipment usually requires more skilled technologists to operate the equipment.</p><p>Translated, this means the substitution of capital for labor does not necessarily increase output or productivity and simultaneously lower costs.</p><p>In many instances, it just increases the quality of the output with a corresponding increase in costs.</p><p>Using a broader definition of technology, that is, “useful skill,” points to the direction of more job-focused training. New and better skills must be continually acquired by today’s labor force.</p><p>Organizations will have to upgrade the skills of their employees and/or find more talented employees to accommodate changing strategies. Organizations need people who can work smarter.</p><p>People will have to spend more time at their jobs away from their offices and labs attending conferences, seminars and short courses at universities and colleges. Further, they will have to spend more time when in the office taking webinars, virtual conferences and exchanging information with peers on social networks.</p><p>Indeed, acquiring and successfully applying useful knowledge to productive work is probably one of the best solutions for productivity improvement.</p><p><strong>MANAGING THE KNOWLEDGE WORKER FOR INCREASED PRODUCTIVITY</strong></p><p>Making the knowledge worker productive requires more than training and information acquisition. It requires knowing the factors that determine knowledge worker productivity.</p><p>What follows provides a more comprehensive viewpoint of how to manage and maximize knowledge worker productivity.</p><p>Peter Drucker listed six key factors that determine knowledge worker productivity. These are:</p><ol><li>Knowledge worker productivity demands that we ask the question: “What is the task?”</li></ol><p>2. It demands that we impose responsibility for their productivity on the individual knowledge worker themselves. Knowledge workers have to manage themselves. They have to have autonomy.</p><p>3. Continuing innovation has to be part of the work, the task and the responsibility of knowledge workers.</p><p>4. Knowledge work requires continuous learning on the part of the knowledge worker, but equally continuous teaching on the part of the knowledge worker (to facilitate the sharing of best practices).</p><p>5. Productivity of the knowledge worker is not — at least not primarily — a matter of quantity of output. Quality is at least as important.</p><p>6. Finally, knowledge worker productivity requires that knowledge workers are both seen and treated as an “asset” rather than a “cost.” It requires that knowledge workers want to work for the organization in preference to all other opportunities.</p><p>Each of these are requirements that were noted by Drucker, except perhaps the last one — is almost the exact opposite of what is needed to increase the productivity of the manual worker.</p><p>In knowledge work quality is the essence of the output. For example, in appraising the performance of, say, surgeons in a given hospital, the question of how many patients has he/she operated on is quite secondary to the question of how many truly successful outcomes has she achieved?</p><p>Knowledge worker productivity, Drucker repeated again and again, has to aim first at obtaining quality — and not minimum quality. Maximum quality.</p><p>Only then, can one ask: “What is the volume, the quantity of work?”</p><p>In essence, when managing the knowledge worker, a rigorous operational definition of quality must be established. What results are expected?</p><p>Finally, Drucker thought the most crucial question in knowledge worker productivity is the first one: “What is the task?”</p><p>In manual work, the key question is always: “How should the work be done?” In manual work the task is always given.</p><p>The first requirement in tackling knowledge worker productivity is to find out what the task is so to make it possible to concentrate the knowledge worker on the task and to eliminate everything else.</p><p><strong>CONCLUSION</strong></p><p>Productivity is the key to managing inflation. To have price stability, wages must not rise faster than productivity.</p><p>Whether it is recognized or not, many practices for productivity improvement are derived largely from the thinking of Peter Drucker. His teachings form a blueprint for every thinking manager.</p><p>“When a cynic asks, ‘What if we train them and they leave?’ winning organizations respond: ‘what if we don’t train them and they stay?’” — Peter F. Drucker</p><p><strong>GETTING DOWN TO BUSY-NESS: KNOWLEDGE WORKERS ARE LESS PRODUCTIVE THAN EVER</strong></p><p>Knowledge is now the main product of advanced economies and the livelihood of the largest group of the population in developed countries. But how do you measure and improve the productivity of knowledge workers, asks columnist Dr. Robert Swaim, when you cannot readily observe what they are doing?</p><p>Peter Drucker coined the term “knowledge workers” over forty years ago and wrote the following in his book, Management Challenges for the 21st Century:</p><p>“The most valuable assets of the 20th-century company were its production equipment. The most valuable asset of a 21st-century institution, whether business or non-business, will be its knowledge workers and their productivity.” Peter F. Drucker</p><p>This article addresses the following questions and Drucker’s views with respect to knowledge and manual workers:</p><ul><li>What is the difference between “Manual Workers” and “Knowledge Workers”?</li><li>Why has the productivity of manual workers dramatically increased during the 20th century, while productivity of knowledge workers has decreased?</li><li>What are the characteristics of knowledge workers, their job needs, what motivates them, and how to lead, not manage them?</li><li>How do you increase the productivity of knowledge workers and why this is important?</li></ul><p>“Manual Workers” are those who essentially work with their hands, operate machines, assemble parts, etc. and are generally involved in the manufacture of a tangible product. The task of what they are to do is given, including the tools and equipment to use, with the focus on how to do it and to do things right, or efficiency. If manual workers leave the organization, the tools they used to perform their work generally remain behind with the organization. This may differ where certain trades require the craftsman to furnish their own tools such as in home building, but rare in most other cases such as an automobile manufacturing plant.</p><p>In knowledge work the task of what to do is controlled by knowledge workers, they own the means of production (knowledge not machines), they decide what methods and steps to use, and they focus on what to do and to the right things or effectiveness. When they leave an organization, they take the tools with them — knowledge.</p><p>Drucker identified another group that is in between both the manual worker and the knowledge worker, the “Technologist.” This is someone who may work with their hands but requires special knowledge, training, and skills to perform their work. As an example, an X-Ray technician in the hospital, the dental assistant who cleans your teeth, the Xerox service representative who repairs the copier and so forth.</p><p>Drucker felt this group was becoming the largest of the three but did not really focus on them in his discussions of the knowledge worker. He did acknowledge that technologist have to be treated as knowledge workers and that although the manual work of their job may comprise the majority of their time, the focus has to be on making the technologist knowledgeable, responsible, and productive as a knowledge worker. In that regard, much of what is contained in this article would also apply to the technologist, and I suggest, might also apply to most of today’s workforce other than perhaps the pure laborer digging a trench.</p><p><strong>THE PRODUCTIVITY ACHIEVEMENTS OF MANUAL WORKERS</strong></p><p>In the 20th century, organizations and management experts focused on increasing the productivity of “Manual Workers.” As a result, according to Drucker, there was a fifty-fold increase in the productivity of the manual worker due to the contribution of the early Classical School management theorist, Fredrick Taylor (Scientific Management) in the early 1900’s, and later in the century, by other contributors, such as Edward Deming (statistical quality control and quality management). As recently as the 1960s, almost fifty percent of all workers in industrialized countries were involved in making things or helping to make things.</p><p>Today however, less than twelve to seventeen percent of the employees in developed countries are involved in manual work — making things with their hands. In 1950, seventy three percent of employees in the United States worked in production or manufacturing while now less than fifteen percent do. This decrease was not created by globalization and the exporting of jobs by multinational companies to China and other low labor-cost countries as many in the U.S. Congress argue for the benefit of their labor union constituencies who are few in number but vocal.</p><p>It has largely been the direct result of the productivity gains in manual work as mentioned here.</p><p>Also, farmers were the backbone of most economies a century ago — not only in the numbers of people employed, but also in the value of what they produced. Now, in developed countries, few people are involved in farming work. As an example, in the 1900’s, eighty five percent of the United States workforce was employed in agriculture. Now only three percent of the U.S. workforce is employed in agriculture and most likely are illegal Mexicans, while in the world’s second largest economy, approximately thirty one percent of the Chinese population is still involved in farming today.</p><p><strong>KNOWLEDGE WORK, KNOWLEDGE WORKERS AND PRODUCTIVITY</strong></p><p>Knowledge work and the knowledge worker produce a different type of product, such as a new computer software program, a design for a new product, market research studies as to what opportunities the organization should pursue, etc. Typically, the output of a knowledge worker is someone else’s input and information for management decision-making. Knowledge workers are “specialists” in their own fields, and typically know more about their field than the managers they work for, which is why they are knowledge workers. This presents another challenge for the manager, how to manage someone who knows more about the job than you do?</p><p>In the 21st century organization and economy, there are now more knowledge workers than manual workers. Knowledge is now the main product of the advanced economy and the livelihood of the largest group of the population in developed countries. Increasingly, knowledge is the key factor in a country’s international economic strength and managers need to understand how to lead and increase the productivity of knowledge work.</p><p>Alvin Toffler in his book Revolutionary Wealth (2006) discusses three waves or movements. The first being the early transition from hunters to agriculture, the second from agriculture to industrialization, and now the third wave from industrialization to knowledge. Some developing nations such as China face the challenge of transitioning in two waves at the same time, from agriculture to industrial to absorb the over one hundred and fifty to two hundred million floating unemployed migrant workers from the rural areas of China, and from industrial to knowledge as China attempts to keep pace with the developed world in technological achievements.</p><p><strong>HOW CAN YOU MEASURE AND INCREASE THE PRODUCTIVITY OF KNOWLEDGE WORK?</strong></p><p>According to Drucker, “Where manual worker productivity has dramatically increased, the productivity of knowledge workers has been decreasing and the problem has not been addressed.” The question is how to measure and improve the productivity of knowledge workers when you really cannot observe what they are doing, as in the case of manual workers? Are they looking out the window at the birds, or are they creating a new product design? Drucker commented, “In terms of actual work on knowledge worker productivity we are, in the year 2000, roughly where we were in the year 1900, and a century ago, in terms of the productivity of the manual worker.”</p><p><strong>REASONS FOR LOW KNOWLEDGE WORKER PRODUCTIVITY</strong></p><p>As mentioned, Peter F. Drucker recognized this issue over 40 years ago. Some of the reasons he identified which contribute to decreasing knowledge worker productivity are as follows:</p><ul><li>The tendency to confuse busyness (filling out paper, passing paper back and forth and attending meetings) with productivity</li><li>Knowledge work cannot be replaced by capital investment as in the case of manual work</li><li>Capital investment creates the need for more knowledge work and creates a demand for new and more highly paid employees</li><li>Few know how to deal with managing the knowledge worker and increasing their productivity. In fact, Drucker suggests that, “Knowledge workers need to be led, not managed.”</li></ul><p>A recent survey of 10,000 knowledge workers in the United States revealed they feel they are less productive today compared to a decade ago and that they waste over two hours a day excluding lunch. Interesting, many attributed this to technology, namely the Internet and time consumed reading and responding to emails each day although some also played games. Another major reason cited by the respondents was not having enough work to do or they felt they were underpaid for the work they did do.</p><p><strong>UNDERSTANDING THE KNOWLEDGE WORKER</strong></p><p>To improve knowledge worker productivity, according to Drucker, it is necessary to understand the characteristics of knowledge workers, their job needs, and what motivates them. These are presented as follows:</p><p><strong>CHARACTERISTICS OF THE KNOWLEDGE WORKER</strong></p><p><strong>HOW DO THEY LIKE TO WORK?</strong></p><ul><li>Knowledge workers have their own routines and patterns of work and therefore, they may not necessarily conform to 9 AM to 5 PM office hours.</li><li>They consider the productivity of their work to be the quality, not quantity, of their output of their work.</li><li>They are highly mobile and can move to a new company if learning and personal growth opportunities do not exist, or if they are underutilized in their present positions. As such, they are more committed to their professions rather than to the organization where they are employed.</li><li>They will work with associates in a team depending on the assignment but often prefer to work alone.</li><li>They must respect who they work for.</li><li>They need feedback but do not accept criticism of their work well.</li><li>The physical space where they work does not need to be too large but it should also not be a “black hole.”</li><li>They have a “mental space” and do not appreciate people intruding on it.</li><li>Their performance and energy levels operate in cycles — they are not machines that can be turned on and off easily.</li></ul><p><strong>WHAT KIND OF WORK DO THEY WANT AND HOW TO PERFORM IT?</strong></p><ul><li>Knowledge workers need challenging work — opportunities to pursue and problems to solve. Continuous innovation must be built into the job.</li><li>Their authorities and responsibilities need to be clear — what decisions can they make?</li><li>Knowledge workers need to take responsibility for the job and need productive work.</li><li>They are self-directed, but need leadership and support from their manager.</li><li>Continuous learning in their field of specialty and profession is extremely important.</li><li>Knowledge workers need feedback information in order to measure their own performance against standards and objectives.</li></ul><p><strong>WHAT MOTIVATES THEM TO PERFORM?</strong></p><ul><li>Knowledge workers are not motivated by fear, but are motivated by achievement — they want to see the results of their work.</li><li>They are self-motivated — given a positive organizational environment.</li><li>The value support — they want others to think that what they’re working on is important.</li><li>Money and promotional opportunities are low on their list of motivation factors — typically they are well paid and enjoy what they do. Their chief reward is in their job and the work itself — if it is meaningful and makes a contribution to the organization.</li></ul><p>As can be seen, the characteristics, job needs and what motivates knowledge workers are considerably different than that of manual workers. In relation to popular motivational and leadership theories, knowledge workers can be considered to be at the highest level of motivational needs.</p><p>As an example, they are at the highest level of Abraham Maslow’s “Hierarchy of Needs Theory” in that they are motivated by “Self Actualization and Learning and Understanding Needs” rather than the lower level “Security and Safety Needs.” With respect to Frederick Hertzberg’s “Hygiene and Motivation Theory,” they are motivated by the need for “Achievement and the Quality of Their Work” rather than other “Hygiene Factors,” such as compensation and benefits and working conditions.</p><p>And in terms of David McClelland’s “Needs Theory” they are motivated by the “Need for Achievement,” rather than the needs for “Power” or “Affiliation.”</p><p>It is not practical to expand on all of the motivational theories sited here. For those not familiar with these and other motivational theories, I suggest a reference text written by Steven P. Robbins, Organizational Behavior. As previously noted in an earlier article, Drucker took a relatively dim view of the various leadership and motivational theories that emanated from the Behavioral School although he did have is own views on these topics that were covered in that article such as it is easier to de-motivate than motivate people including knowledge workers.</p><p><strong>GUIDELINES FOR IMPROVING THE PRODUCTIVITY AND EFFECTIVENESS OF KNOWLEDGE WORKERS</strong></p><p>According to Drucker, increasing the productivity of the knowledge worker requires addressing a number of key factors and asking some important questions. These have been incorporated into a checklist for easier reference compared to searching for the key points on knowledge workers in Drucker’s books that are mainly narratives. It should also be interesting to ask yourself as you review the checklist, do these factors apply only to knowledge workers or everyone who works for me (manual workers, technologists, managers who report to me, etc.)?</p><p>There are Eight Major Factors and key questions associated with each factor to consider that are outlined below. Also building on the checklist, each factor will be addressed in detail.</p><p><strong>DEFINING THE “TASK” OR THE “RESULTS”</strong></p><p>According to Drucker, “The first requirement in tackling knowledge work is to find out what is the task is so to make it possible to concentrate knowledge workers on the task and eliminate everything else — at least as far as it can possibly be determined.”</p><p>This initially can create some confusion in terms of attempting to differentiate between the knowledge worker’s “job” (Market Research Analyst), the “tasks” that the knowledge worker performs (conducts market research surveys, designs survey questionnaires, conducts focused interviews, etc. and the desired “results” (delivers a market research report on a particular market segment in China).</p><p>It was also felt that Drucker deviated here from his holding people accountable and responsible for “results” by now focusing on how these results are to be achieved — the “task.” To maintain consistency, we should focus on the “desired results” the knowledge worker is expected to produce — not the tasks.</p><p><strong>THE EIGHT KEY FACTORS IN KNOWLEDGE WORKER PERFORMANCE</strong></p><ol><li>Define Results: What results is the knowledge worker to produce?</li><li>The Job Assignment: What is the job the knowledge worker is to be assigned to or in now?</li><li>Task and Time Assessment: What are the tasks the knowledge worker is to perform and over what period of time? When do we expect the results?</li><li>Agreement on Objectives and Their Measurement: What objectives will be mutually agreed to and how will they be measured?</li><li>Providing Support: What support does the knowledge worker require to produce the results (budget, information, your coordination to involve others, etc.)?</li><li>Feedback and Self-Feedback Systems: How will the knowledge worker be able to measure his or her progress (self-control)?</li><li>Recognition: How do you plan to recognize the knowledge worker for producing the desired results (financial and non-financial rewards)?</li><li>Continuous Learning: What continuous learning and self-development experience will be made available to the knowledge worker (courses, seminars, professional conferences, and associations, etc.)?</li></ol><p>The following is a more detailed discussion of each of these eight factors and key questions to ask relative to the factor.</p><p><strong>FACTOR #1: DEFINING RESULTS</strong></p><p>Drucker stressed that the starting point in managing knowledge workers and their productivity is a definition of “results.” What is the final product the knowledge worker is to produce? Drucker also outlined “Four Dimensions” with respect to defining results that include; The Quality and Quantity Dimension, The Time Dimension, The Resource Dimension, and The Restrictions and Limitations Dimension. These Dimensions are summarized in the following checklists for easy reference.</p><p><strong>THE QUALITY AND QUANTITY DIMENSION</strong></p><ul><li>What should the quality and quantity of the results be?</li><li>How will quality and quantity be measured (agreed upon standards)?</li></ul><p><strong>THE TIME DIMENSION</strong></p><p>When should these results be delivered?</p><p>Is when the results are expected to be delivered flexible enough to allow the knowledge worker time to perform?</p><p><strong>THE RESOURCE DIMENSION</strong></p><ul><li>What financial resources are needed to produce the results (budget)?</li><li>What special knowledge and skills will be needed by the knowledge worker to produce the desired results?</li><li>What additional resources may be required (clerical support, research assistants, other knowledge workers, etc.)</li></ul><p><strong>THE RESTRICTIONS AND LIMITATIONS DIMENSION</strong></p><ul><li>What restrictions and limitations exist that must be considered (limited budget, hiring freeze, other restrictions, etc.)?</li></ul><p><strong>FACTOR #2: THE JOB ASSIGNMENT</strong></p><p>According to Drucker, “Assignment control is the key to knowledge worker productivity.” Here again, Drucker suggests there are “Three Dimensions” to the Job Assignment; The Selection Dimension, The Autonomy and Responsibility Dimension, and The Knowledge Worker Reflection and Work Plan. A checklist is provided again for easy reference.</p><p><strong>THE SELECTION DECISION DIMENSION</strong></p><ul><li>Who has the best strengths for this assignment (knowledge, skills, qualifications, and experience) to produce the desired results?</li><li>Can an individual complete the assignment or will it require a team of knowledge workers? If a team, who should be included and who should be the team leader?</li><li>Is this assignment the best one for this knowledge worker(s) that will produce the desired results?</li><li>Is this the best use of the knowledge worker?</li><li>Is this the best assignment for this person? Does it utilize his or her strengths?</li><li>Will this assignment present a challenge for the knowledge worker?</li><li>Is this assignment an opportunity to pursue or a problem to solve? If a problem, how long will the knowledge worker be dedicated to solving it?</li></ul><p><strong>THE AUTONOMY AND RESPONSIBILITY DIMENSION</strong></p><ul><li>Will the knowledge worker be provided the autonomy to complete the assignment or is there a tendency of the manager to want to over or micromanage the project?</li><li>Will the knowledge worker be able to make decisions relative to his or her work? What decisions will require additional approval?</li><li>What will the knowledge worker be responsible for — and not responsible for?</li><li>What responsibilities will the manager of the knowledge worker retain?</li></ul><p><strong>KNOWLEDGE WORKER REFLECTION &amp; WORK PLAN DIMENSION</strong></p><ul><li>How will the assignment be performed to produce the desired results?</li><li>Has the knowledge worker been provided time for reflection on what work needs to be done and how to produce the desired results?</li><li>What are the tasks that need to be completed? Who should perform these tasks and in what order? Will some tasks of other knowledge workers or support people be input for other tasks? (See Knowledge Worker’s Preliminary Work Plan for an example.)</li><li>How will progress be measured (objectives, milestones, and feedback and self-feedback systems)?</li></ul><p><strong>FACTOR #3: TASK ANALYSIS AND TIME ASSESSMENT</strong></p><p>In assessing the Tasks to be completed and the Time to complete them in, several key questions needed to be asked by both the manager and the knowledge worker who has been assigned to produce the results. This could also be considered part of the knowledge worker’s reflection prior to starting the project. The key questions to answer are also included in the checklists.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*mYg-kLIbyQnqTbTpHKi3FQ.png" /></a></figure><p><strong>TASK ANALYSIS CHECKLISTS</strong></p><p><strong>THE “WHAT?”</strong></p><p>Check the need and use of the job considered.</p><ul><li>What is being done?</li><li>What is the purpose?</li><li>Is it essential? Would the sky fall down on us if we stopped doing it?</li><li>What keeps you from doing your tasks and should be eliminated?</li></ul><p><strong>THE “WHERE?”</strong></p><p>In order to check if the place where we are doing something is the most appropriate one.</p><ul><li>Where is the job performed? Why?</li><li>Could it be performed somewhere else, in a more economical and satisfactory manner? Outsourced?</li></ul><p><strong>THE “WHEN?”</strong></p><p>In order to make sure that the job is being carried out at the most appropriate time.</p><ul><li>When is the job being carried out? Why?</li><li>Is this the best time to do it?</li><li>Could it be done in another sequence?</li><li>What is the current status toward achieving the knowledge worker’s present objectives?</li></ul><p><strong>THE “WHO?”</strong></p><p>In order to make sure that the person who performs the job is the most appropriate one.</p><ul><li>Who does this job? Why? Who could or must do it? Why?</li><li>Could a more qualified person do it more economically?</li><li>Could a less qualified person do it after being trained?</li><li>Could the tasks be outsourced?</li></ul><p><strong>THE “HOW?”</strong></p><p>In order to find out whether the job can be simplified or better performed, with less complication, higher quality, and lower cost.</p><ul><li>How is the job done? Why?</li><li>Could it be done in an easier and simper way?</li><li>Can it be done with higher quality, without introducing complications?</li><li>Are the means used the most appropriate?</li><li>Are there alternative means or other ways of doing the job that are better than the present ones?</li><li>Which things make the job complicated or difficult for the people who perform it? Could some things be eliminated?</li></ul><p>As can be seen, there are number of important questions that need to be addressed in this area alone if the productivity of knowledge workers is to be improved.</p><p><strong>FACTOR #4: OBJECTIVES AND THEIR MEASUREMENT DIMENSION</strong></p><p>This Dimension is classic Drucker and directly from his book Managing for Results (1964) and later adopted in the Classical School as Management by Objectives (MBO). Since the practice of MBO is now over forty years old this checklist is relatively brief:</p><p>MBO as Applied to the Knowledge Worker</p><ul><li>Knowledge and Objectives — Knowledge workers require that demands be made on them by knowledge — rather than bosses and by objectives — not people.</li><li>Mutually Established — The knowledge worker’s objectives should be mutually established between the management and the knowledge worker and directly relate to the results to be produced and the tasks to be completed to produce the desired results.</li><li>Milestones — Establish milestones for each task and objective. The manager should not over manage, but needs information as to progress in achieving the desired results.</li><li>Reporting — The times the knowledge worker will report results or progress need to be determined.</li></ul><p><strong>FACTOR #5: PROVIDING SUPPORT</strong></p><p>This factor includes a number of “Key Questions to Ask” in terms of providing support to the knowledge worker.</p><p><strong>PROVIDING SUPPORT — KEY QUESTIONS</strong></p><ul><li>Support Required — What can management do to help the knowledge worker do his or her job? Ask when discussing the “Knowledge Worker’s Preliminary Work Plan” and provide the support that is required.</li><li>Obstacles — What hinders the knowledge worker from doing the job? Ask and remove it.</li><li>Others — Who else needs to know about this assignment? Do they have to provide input to the knowledge worker to complete a task? Are they cooperative or acting in their own self interests and not as a team?</li></ul><p><strong>FACTOR #6: FEEDBACK &amp; SELF FEEDBACK</strong></p><p>Once again, the literature on providing feedback to people for their performance to sustain or improve performance is extensive. Thousands of books have been written on performance appraisal and so another tree will be spared here. Drucker did stress, although not entirely unique, that the best feedback for knowledge workers is self feedback.</p><p>In essence then, the knowledge worker should be able to refer to his or her Work Plan and the tasks and milestones and be able to gauge where he or she is in the path to producing the desired results. This also relates to one of the characteristics of the knowledge worker in that they do not accept criticism well.</p><p>This is not to say that the manager avoids contact with the knowledge worker, or worse yet, adopts a Management by Exception (MBE) approach, one of the worst concepts ever developed in management theory. This is the old, “You have complete freedom to do what is necessary to get the job done — just don’t screw up and then you will hear from me.” In the MBE approach, the only time the knowledge worker sees his or her manager is when he or she makes a mistake and as such dreads seeing the manager. It does not take long for the relationship between the manager and knowledge worker to deteriorate. During the progress review, the manager should provide both positive and constructive feedback to the knowledge worker but care must be taken in how the constructive feedback is presented.</p><p><strong>FACTOR #7: RECOGNITION</strong></p><p>Another factor in Drucker’s approach to improving knowledge worker productivity is to provide recognition for producing the desired results, once again a concept not unique to Drucker. Recognition could be in the form of both financial and non-financial rewards. Since the knowledge worker wants to stay abreast of developments in his or her own field, allowing them to attend industry conferences and professional organizations on company time versus their own time is an inexpensive form of recognition. If the manager is unsure as to what non-financial rewards would be appealing to the knowledge worker, simply ask them. Recognition can also be provided by providing the knowledge worker with opportunities for self-development as covered in Drucker’s last factor.</p><p><strong>FACTOR #8: CONTINUOUS LEARNING</strong></p><p>The following are several of Drucker’s guidelines in dealing with the knowledge worker’s self development and the need for continuous learning, one of the job needs of knowledge workers previously discussed.</p><ul><li>The knowledge worker should ask — what do I need to learn to keep up with the knowledge and know the things I am paid to know?</li><li>Knowledge workers should request their own training and development needs.</li><li>Training and development should be focused on people’s strengths, rather than on their weaknesses and limitations.</li><li>The objective is to do better the things that one already does well.</li><li>Everyone (knowledge workers) should be encouraged to teach and share their knowledge with others in the organization.</li><li>The knowledge worker should also ask, what do others need to know and understand about my area and what it can contribute to their own work?</li><li>Finally, the knowledge worker should ask what does my manager need to know about my knowledge in order to understand the opportunities, issues, and problems we need to deal with?</li></ul><p><strong>SUMMARY</strong></p><p>The productivity of knowledge workers has not kept pace with the productivity of manual workers and in fact, has been decreasing. Management must know how to address this problem, since the number of knowledge workers as compared to manual workers in organizations, is increasing and will continue to do so.</p><p>A number of application tools that can be used in dealing with knowledge workers in your organization that should prove useful in applying a number of the concepts that were presented here can be obtained from the author, Dr. Robert Swaim, directly by contacting him on docswaim@gmail.com.</p><p>“There is nothing quite so useless, as doing with great efficiency, something that should not be done at all.” ― Peter F. Drucker</p><p><strong>ABANDONING THE OBSOLETE AND UNPRODUCTIVE: A DIFFICULT BUT NECESSARY TASK</strong></p><p>A fruit tree grows stronger and fuller when it is pruned periodically. In a long-out-of-print book entitled The Folklore of Management, Clarence B. Randall, a retired president of Inland Steel, expressed this thought most elegantly:</p><p>“The world around, hearty men who make a living by harvesting the fruits of the soil know when and how to use the pruning knife. They have no more useful working tool…whether it be a French peasant who gives daily, almost hourly, care to his precious two hectares of sun drenched hillside soil in Burgundy, or the cherry grower of Michigan or the owner of an apple orchard in the Virginia, he preserves the quality of his product by his skill in removing deadwood…</p><p>… the significant thing about his operation, however, is that he works at it all the time…Never does he rush out in terror to lay about him with an ax, slashing indiscriminately right and left…he is steady and consistent about the whole process and keeps constantly at it…in the spring following a bumper crop, when he is sure he has a vintage product, he does the same amount of trimming as after one of those sad years when the hail damage has all but ruined him…”</p><p><strong>THE MESSAGE IS CLEAR</strong></p><p>Every enterprise, business or non-business, must constantly abandon the obsolete and the unproductive. Every organization is likely to be loaded down with yesterday’s promises. These include activities and programs that no longer contribute; the ventures that looked so enticing when started, but now, five years later, are still unproductive.</p><p>The best therapy for any organization from the point of view of performance is to purge itself of mediocrities. Systematic sloughing off of yesterday frees energies and resources. It makes available the people and funds required for new things.</p><p><strong>WHY PETER DRUCKER’S IDEAS STILL MATTER</strong></p><p>The late Peter Drucker identified the key management challenge of the 21st century as leading change and believed that the first question to ask is: “What should we abandon?” He realized abandoning yesterday is excruciatingly difficult.</p><p>Modern organizations must be capable of change. Indeed, they must be able to initiate change, that is, innovation. It is essential to move scarce and expensive resources from areas of low productivity and non-results to areas where there are opportunities for achievement and contribution.</p><p>Drucker observed:</p><p>“Maintaining yesterday is difficult and time-consuming and therefore always commits the institution’s scarcest and most valuable resources — and above all, its ablest people — to non-results…organizational inertia always push for continuing what we are already doing…</p><p>…organizations are always in danger of being overwhelmed by yesterday’s tasks and being rendered sterile by them… An organization — whatever its objectives — must therefore be able to get rid of yesterday’s tasks and thus free its energies and resources for new and more productive tasks.”</p><p><strong>CONTINUITY VS. CHANGE</strong></p><p>Drucker’s central theme involved the never-ending battle of continuity vs. change. He repeated over and over again that an organization’s most able people tend to be committed to yesterday’s tasks, which means they are not available to create tomorrow. Every strategic plan stresses what should be done. But Drucker reasoned that the initial emphasis of a strategic plan must focus on what to stop doing.</p><p>Weeding out the nonproductive activity garden is as important in “running HR like a business” as is in the example given by Randall. One sobering method of avoiding putting too much effort into the soil bed of yesterday’s activities and programs is to raise the Drucker question, “If we were not presently doing this or that activity would we risk going into it today?”</p><p>Shortly after Jack Welch became CEO of General Electric in 1981, Business Week magazine reported, “He sat down with Drucker at the company’s New York headquarters… Drucker posed two questions that arguably changed the course of Welch’s tenure: ‘If you weren’t already in a business, would you enter it today?’ he asked. ‘And if the answer is no, what are you going to do about it?’”</p><p>Those questions led Welch to a slew of abandonment decisions and to realize that “maintaining what no longer works draws your most valuable resources away from your number one job, creating tomorrow.” Welch reinvented General Electric and is credited with allocating resources on the right results. And in the process, Welch made General Electric into one of America’s most successful organizations.</p><p><strong>WHY IS ABANDONMENT SO DIFFICULT?</strong></p><p>Without doubt, abandoning yesterday is painfully difficult but necessary. Yesterday is comfortable. By contrast, the new and different always produce new problems. Custodial managers nurture yesterday far too long.</p><p>In short, it boils down to familiarity with and sentimentality for what already exists.</p><p>Organizations that are incapable of abandoning old and tired programs and activities are unlikely to make the new happen. Just asking the question, “What should we abandon or de-emphasize?” will force thinking and actions that can significantly improve operations and productivity.</p><p>“Successful enterprises create the conditions to allow their employees to do their best work.” -Peter F. Drucker</p><p><strong>THE SECRET TO ACHIEVING MORE WITH LESS — THE PARETO PRINCIPLE IN ACTION</strong></p><p>Improving productivity requires abandoning things that do not work, never worked, or have outlived their usefulness and capacity to contribute. As both governments and businesses look out at a tough new operating environment that doesn’t look set to change anytime soon, here’s how Pareto analysis can help.</p><p><strong>INTRODUCTION</strong></p><p>Peter F. Drucker rendered explicit the interrelationship between and among three distinct concepts — namely, abandonment, concentration and Pareto’s Law (a.k.a. the 80/20 Principle).</p><p>Abandonment and concentration, Drucker reminded us, are opposite sides of the same coin. Simply put, abandoning unproductive and obsolete activities frees up resources to concentrate on result areas.</p><p>However, deciding what to abandon is never easy. We all need a framework or methodology to help us decide what to stop doing… and to pinpoint areas we should concentrate efforts and resources.</p><p>Pareto analysis is one of many tools used to identify activities, programs, products and services that should be considered candidates for abandonment/de-emphasis.</p><p><strong>PARETO’S PRINCIPLE</strong></p><p>One of the best books ever written about the Pareto Principle is Richard Koch’s The 80/20 Principle. It details how systematic and predictable lack of balance appears in data relating to a wide range of activities in both life and management activities.</p><p>Here’s an excerpt from Koch’s book:</p><p>“The pattern underlying the 80/20 Principle was discovered in 1897 by the Italian economist Vilfredo Pareto (1848- 1923). His discovery has since been called many names, including the Pareto Principle… the Pareto Law… the 80/20 Rule… the Principle of Least Effort… and the Principle of Imbalance.</p><p>“So what did Pareto discover? He happened to be looking at patterns of wealth and income in 19th-century England. He found that most income and wealth went to a minority of the people in his samples.”</p><p>Koch explains that, in essence, Pareto found that 20 percent of the population enjoyed 80 percent of the wealth in all the countries studied. Indeed, that’s what really excited Pareto.</p><p>This pattern of imbalance was repeated consistently whenever he looked at data referring to different time periods or different countries.</p><p>It took many years for others to discover that Pareto’s finding could be extended all kinds of resources. In most situations, a pattern of imbalance with respect to efforts and results is a near-certainty.</p><p>“In 1949, George K. Zipk, a professor at Harvard, discovered the ‘Principle of Least Effort,’ which was actually a rediscovery and elaboration of Pareto’s principle…”</p><p>Ever so slightly paraphrasing Koch’s summary of Zipk’s principle:</p><p>Resources (people, products, time, knowledge, physical assets or anything else that can be made more productive) tends to arrange themselves so that approximately 20- 30 percent of any resource accounts for 70–80 percent of the activity related to that resource.</p><p>What does this really mean? More results can be squeezed out of existing resources. It’s a good bet that an organization’s resources are not as productive as they could be.</p><p><strong>AN EXAMPLE</strong></p><p>Drucker provided an excellent example of how nurses in a major hospital were asked a few questions in an employee survey:</p><ul><li>What is your task?</li><li>What should it be?</li><li>What should you be expected to contribute?</li><li>What hampers you in doing your task, and should these obstacles be eliminated?</li></ul><p>According to Drucker:</p><p>“The nurses were sharply divided as to what their task was, with one group saying ‘patient care’ and another saying ‘satisfying physicians.’ However, they were in complete agreement on the things that made them unproductive.</p><p>“They called them ‘chores:’ paperwork, arranging flowers, answering the phone calls of patients’ relatives, answering the patient bells and so on.</p><p>“All — nearly all — of these could be turned over to a non-nurse floor clerk, [who are] paid a fraction of a nurse’s pay.</p><p>“When the nurses were freed of chores, their productivity nearly doubled, as measured by the time at the patients’ bedsides.</p><p>“Further, patient satisfaction more than doubled and turnover of nurses (which had been catastrophically high) almost disappeared, all within four months.”</p><p>The point? Resources have a tendency to decline in productivity. But, as Drucker so clearly illustrates, the way to get more output from existing resources is to make the resource “work smarter.”</p><p>Making resources productive is the specific job of management. In this case, a workplace survey revealed that a large percentage of the nurses’ time was spent in non- nursing activities.</p><p>That percentage had to be favorably altered — a greater percentage of nursing time had to be directed towards the results desired.</p><p>Zipk’s principle is valid. This means we have to constantly improve the productivity of resources in existing employments. “We know that we need to work on the productivity of each of the factors of production: capital, natural resources, time and knowledge.”</p><p>Why? Because it’s near-certain that the efforts-to-results ratio with respect to most resources is predictably unbalanced.</p><p><strong>JURAN’S CONTRIBUTION</strong></p><p>The other pioneer of the 80/20 Principle was the quality guru Joseph M. Juran. Indeed, he coined the phrases “Pareto Principle” and the “Rule of the Vital Few.”</p><p>According to Juran, in any relevant data set a small number of elements will be responsible for the preponderant portion of results. In terms of results the vital few within the configuration or data set will always take precedence over the trivial many.</p><p>For example, if we assume there are five frequently cited reasons for customer complaints, one reason (20 percent of the reasons) probably accounts for 80 percent of the complaints. Efforts should be concentrated on the one reason causing the majority of complaints.</p><p>Still another example: While a manufacturer makes 20 different products, five of those products account for 75 percent of its customers complaints.</p><p>And still another example: While there may be 12 distinct steps in the process of transferring a patient out of an intensive care unit into a standard bed, two of those steps account for 82 percent of the total time in the total process.</p><p><strong>LESSON LEARNED SO FAR?</strong></p><p>Always look</p><p>for the predictable imbalance. Breakdown the numbers. Disaggregate the data.</p><p>Expect the unexpected. Expect 20 percent to lead 80 percent… and 80 percent to lead to 20 percent. Always look for the powerful vital few. It’s bound to be there.</p><p>This will enable you to spot the important things. Accept the reality that with respect to causes, inputs and efforts the majority have little impact. But, rather, a small minority of causes, inputs and efforts will have the major, dominant impact.</p><p><strong>DRUCKER’S SUMMARY OF THE PARETO PRINCIPLE</strong></p><p>Drucker repeatedly demonstrated how the application of Pareto’s Law could be used in diagnosing patterns of potential misallocation of resources.</p><p>“Business enterprise is not a phenomenon of nature but one of society. In a social situation, however, events are not distributed according to a ‘normal distribution’ of a natural universe…</p><p>“In a social situation a very small number of events at one extreme — the first 10 percent to 20 percent at most — account for 90 percent of all results; whereas the great majority of the events accounts for 10 percent or so of the results.</p><p>“This is true in the marketplace: A handful of large customers out of many thousands produce the bulk of orders; a handful of products out of hundreds of items in the line produce the bulk of the volume; and so on.</p><p>“It is true of sales efforts: A few sales people out of several hundred always produce two-thirds of all new business. It is true in the plant: A handful of production runs account for most of the tonnage.</p><p>“It is true in research: The same few people in the laboratory are apt to produce nearly all the important innovations.</p><p>“It holds true for practically all personnel problems: The bulk of grievances always comes from one group of employees (for example, from the older, married women or from the clean-up people on the night shift), as does the great bulk of absenteeism, of turnover, of suggestions under a suggestion system and accidents…”</p><p><strong>PREDICTABLE IMBALANCES HAVE IMPORTANT IMPLICATIONS</strong></p><p>In short, Drucker, Zipk, Juran observed that aggregate data misinform, misdirect, mislead. It’s a near-certainty that there’s an imbalance present between efforts and results.</p><p>Every manager, to be effective, must assume an imbalance exists with respect to resource allocation. And must work hard to incrementally change the ratio.</p><p>The relationship between efforts and results are generally in a state of imbalance. The imbalance may be 65/35, 70/30, 75/25, 80/20 or 99/1, or any set of numbers in between.</p><p>The key is to alter the ratio between effort and results. For example, if a manager could change the percentage proportion from 90–10 to 60–40, 70–30 or even 80–20, misallocation could be reduced and results improved.</p><p>To be specific, if 10 percent of the sales force is contributing 90 percent of the results and the other 90 percent of the sales force is producing most of the cost, then the elimination of marginal performers and improvement of the mediocre performers should be a priority commitment.</p><p>Eliminating non-productive efforts, that is, abandonment will enhance performance and make resources more productive.</p><p><strong>TO SUMMARIZE</strong></p><p>Improving productivity requires abandoning things that do not work, never worked, or have outlived their usefulness and capacity to contribute.</p><p>It also requires concentrating on the things that do work — the things that produce results — or the things that improve the organization’s ability to perform.</p><p>Economic results, Drucker reminded us, require efforts be concentrated on the few activities that are capable of producing significant business results.</p><p>In making a distinction between the vital few and the trivial many, management can improve its asset management by making its capital work more effectively. The more the Pareto Principle is explored, the greater the relevance to improving the productivity of all resources.</p><p>Drucker frequently mentioned — indeed, emphasized — that:</p><p>“In every industry there are institutions that operate at an essentially higher productivity level than the average… What makes one company stand out and lead in any one industry is that it operates at about twice the average productivity of its industry…”</p><p>Most of today’s managers have grown up in a period of rapid economic growth. Productivities have become endangered because they have been neglected.</p><p>In many organizations, to reverse the trend in productivities is a major managerial task. It requires abandonment of obsolete and unproductive activities. It requires focusing resources on what works.</p><p>It requires, among other tools and techniques, systematic application of the Pareto Principle.</p><p>“The first sign of decline of a company is loss of appeal to qualified, able, and ambitious people.” — Peter F. Drucker</p><p><strong>THE DEMOTIVATION TRAP AND WHAT YOU CAN DO ABOUT IT</strong></p><p>Understand Drucker’s approach to motivation, and you can forget the countless other books on employee motivation. In this month’s Drucker Files, Dr. Robert Swaim — student, colleague and friend of Peter Drucker for thirty years — summarizes Drucker’s Seven Keys to inspiring performance in your people.</p><p>There are many textbook definitions of what managers are supposed to do; the job of the manager, but perhaps one of the more pragmatic definitions is one by Peter Drucker:</p><p>“A manager is paid to enable those people who are able and capable of work to earn their wage and not hinder them in the process.” Peter Drucker at the Claremont Graduate School (1976).</p><p>Along this line, Dr. Drucker pointed out that, “People know they are on the payroll to get work out. They respect this and also want to respect the company and manager they work for. When people are not allowed to do the work they are paid for, they lose respect.”</p><p><strong>THE SEVEN KEYS TO MOTIVATION</strong></p><p>There are Seven Key Areas in which Drucker suggested the manager needs to ask questions relative to motivating performance and include:</p><ol><li>The performance of your people.</li><li>Time — the scare resource</li><li>Taking responsibility for the relationship with others.</li><li>Establishing and maintaining the relationships with others.</li><li>Accountability for results.</li><li>Relationship with your manager.</li><li>Assignment control and staffing.</li></ol><p><strong>AREA 1: PERFORMANCE</strong></p><p>In terms of motivating the performance of your people, Drucker suggested the first thing you as a manager can do today is to ask the following questions:</p><ul><li>What does this organization do that allows your people to do the job they are paid for?</li><li>When you have identified what “helps,” — provide them with more. When you have identified what “hinders,” — remove it. In terms of what hinders your employees the most, don’t speculate and assume you know — ask your employees.</li></ul><p><strong>AREA 2: TIME</strong></p><ul><li>Am I wasting my people’s time?</li></ul><p>Another area worthy of exploration is the resource of time. No matter what the demand for time, there is no more supply — it is a perishable resource. Investigate to see if you are taking time away from your people by making them do things they really aren’t paid for.</p><p>In other words, make sure your people can do the work they are paid for and have the necessary tools to do it.</p><p><strong>AREA 3: UNDERSTANDING RELATIONSHIPS</strong></p><ul><li>Who depends on me for information, ideas, products, etc.?</li><li>Whose input is my output?</li><li>Who do I depend on for my input?</li></ul><p>As a manager you must take responsibility for your relationship. When you have answered these questions, take the responsibility for establishing and maintaining the relationship. It will probably be no surprise to find many of these relationships are with your counterparts in other functional areas. Drucker pointed out that, “Work and information flow sideways thorough the organization, not through the organization chart.”</p><p>Therefore, it would also be helpful to keep in mind you are responsible for the work of other people, not just subordinates. This includes yourself, your manager, your peers, and finally, your subordinates, in the order of easiest to control, to most difficult to control.</p><p><strong>AREA 4: MAINTAINING RELATIONSHIPS</strong></p><p>This logically leads to the fourth area of how to establish and maintain these relationships, and can be summarized by a very simple Drucker Rule:</p><p>“Don’t ever assume there are mind readers at work.” Peter Drucker</p><p>Drucker, in support of this rule stated, “There is no such thing as a communications problem — you have not told them and furthermore, assumed they understood.”</p><p>Therefore, concentrate on relationships, not communications. You can’t assume that people you deal with don’t need to know — take responsibility by keeping them informed and let them make the decision whether they need to know or not. People do not trust things they do not understand, so make sure they understand. They may not approve of what you are doing, but they should at least know what you are trying to do. Also, it is important they understand what you are not trying to do otherwise people will be working on it.</p><p><strong>AREA 5: ACCOUNTABILITY</strong></p><p>The fifth area you should investigate is accountability by asking the next series of questions:</p><ul><li>What do you do that explains your being on the payroll?</li><li>Why do you do this work?</li><li>If you don’t do this, what happens?</li></ul><p>When you have answered these questions, take the responsibility for the results and contribution, and demand the same of everyone who reports to you.</p><p>After you have accomplished this, appraise the results of your people, don’t judge. Your job is not to judge people, but to get them to perform. With respect to this analysis or appraisal, don’t let effort absorb you, remind yourself of why it is done, and what is the result supposed to be.</p><p><strong>AREA 6: RELATIONSHIP WITH YOUR MANAGER</strong></p><p>The sixth area to explore closely corresponds to relationships and specifically, the relationship you have with your manager. In this regard, it would be helpful to ask him the following questions:</p><ul><li>What do I need to know about what you are trying to do?</li><li>What is it that he considers to be our organization’s greatest contribution?</li><li>What is it you think I should be doing to support you?</li><li>What is it I should be concentrating on and held accountable for?</li></ul><p>When you have answers to these questions, establish a priority list of what must be done, and begin by concentrating on the first thing on your list. When you have completed the first thing, don’t go on to number two on the list, but rather make another priority list. You may find number two is still number two, replaced by something more critical.</p><p><strong>AREA 7: ASSIGNMENT CONTROL</strong></p><p>The seventh and final area is Assignment Control, or as traditional management texts describe as staffing. Every six months, make a list of the people who report to you, and deliver and produce.</p><p>Then ask the question:</p><ul><li>Are they assigned where the results are?</li></ul><p>If they are not assigned where the demands are for results, they are being misallocated. Look at these assignments every six months in terms of planning. Drucker stated, “Plans fail because you don’t allocate an individual who can perform.” If you identify an opportunity in your plan that can be exploited, it should be staffed with people who can deliver.</p><p>In terms of making this list, don’t get confused between performance and potential. If you have someone on the list that has potential, ask what he or she has done? Don’t be misled by those with high potential, but don’t deliver, look for low potential people who perform. Drucker expanded on this idea by indicating that, “Low potential people have learned to perform, to do honest work and not to fail because they are not bright enough to improvise.”</p><p>Finally, don’t leave high performing people assigned to the problem areas too long for it is a poor use of them. Assigning the best salesmen to move the dead products in Drucker’s view, “May be an honest and respectable goal, but it is hard work, useless, and the quickest way to create a market for competition.”</p><p><strong>DRUCKER ON MOTIVATION</strong></p><p>“There are only two books that a publisher does not lose money on — cook books and books on motivation. The reason is they are purchased by people who can do neither.” Peter Drucker</p><p><strong>DRUCKER’S CRITICISM OF THE BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES AND MOTIVATIONAL THEORIES</strong></p><p>“There have been no major substantive intellectual breakthroughs in our understanding of employee motivation since the Hawthorne Study of seventy years ago (Elton Mayo).” — Peter Drucker.</p><p>Drucker’s quote above is in reference to a major event that led to the evolution of the Human Relations School in the 1930s. This was the conclusions that were generally reached as a result of the infamous “Hawthorne Studies” by Elton Mayo and his colleagues at Harvard, F.J. Roethlisberger and T. N. Whitehead. Although the studies were originally designed to attempt to measure changes in the employees’ working environment and their effect on productivity (the “Illumination Experiments”), it was finally discovered that the changes that were observed were the result of other factors, such as how the employees were treated.</p><p>This lead to the “human relations-be kind to people” approach to motivation that was really more manipulative than sincere in attempts to improve productivity. Drucker therefore felt that nothing meaningful in the way of research on motivation has occurred since then.</p><p>Of the 39 books Drucker wrote, not one was solely dedicated to discussing leadership and motivation. In fact, Drucker had little use for the behavioral sciences. Drucker’s major criticism of the behavioral science was that many of their theories focused on job satisfaction and ignored productivity. The problem he cited here was that there was no measurement as to what employee satisfaction really is. If the mean score on the results of employee attitude surveys registered 85, are the employees more satisfied than if the score was 75?</p><p>Drucker also argued that there was no evidence from the behavioral sciences to substantiate that employee satisfaction results in any better organizational performance — in other words a “happy worker” is not necessarily a productive worker. Actually, Drucker did feel Frederick Herzberg’s “Two-Factor” theory of motivation was useful as a diagnostic tool in terms of assessing an organization’s environment from the perspective of “dissatisfiers” that tended to support his own views on motivation. Drucker therefore made a limited contribution to this school based on a somewhat simplistic approach to leadership and motivation as shared in this article.</p><p><strong>THE RESEARCH SUPPORTS DRUCKER’S VIEWS</strong></p><p>Many studies have been conducted in an attempt to show a relationship between job satisfaction and productivity and the results of those studies actually support Drucker’s views in terms of their inability to prove a positive relationship. Some other studies have actually suggested a causal relationship exists in the opposite direction in that productivity leads to job satisfaction. These studies concluded that, “If you do a good job, you intrinsically feel good about it. Additionally, assuming that the organization rewards productivity, your higher productivity should increase verbal recognition, your pay level, and probabilities for promotion. These rewards, in turn, increase your level of satisfaction with the job.” Once again, this different relationship may actually support Drucker’s views on motivation.</p><p>“It is easier to de-motivate people than to motivate them.” Peter Drucker</p><p>Drucker took a completely different and unique approach to the subject of motivation by expressing the following views:</p><ul><li>It is easier to de-motivate people.</li><li>The best way to motivate people is through example.</li><li>To set an example by having standards, both of performance and of basics, by realizing that being a manager is not a rank and a privilege, but a responsibility.</li><li>To motivate professionals, knowledge people, and managers is by making demands on them for performance and responsibility. (Note: the next article will deal with the growing number of knowledge workers compared to manual workers and their unique job and personal needs and how to measure their performance.)</li></ul><p><strong>WHAT DE-MOTIVATES YOUR PEOPLE?</strong></p><p>In keeping with Drucker’s view, refer to the following statements and ask if you and your organization are contributing to some of these de-motivators?</p><p><strong>MY ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT:</strong></p><ul><li>Creates a company environment of internal politics as the way to get promoted.</li><li>Promotes destructive internal competition between workers.</li><li>Changes the rules in the middle of a project.</li><li>Creates unclear expectations regarding employee’s performance and results.</li><li>Creates a bureaucracy of forms and reports and unnecessary rules for individuals to follow.</li><li>Over manages (tells what to do, how to do, and controls) vs. leading and does not allow autonomy.</li><li>Withholds information that individuals need to perform their jobs, lying, and claiming it’s a misunderstanding.</li><li>Takes time from people by having them attend unproductive meetings.</li><li>Emphasizes criticism and negative feedback vs. recognition and positive feedback.</li><li>Tolerates poor performance of others so that high performing people feel taken advantage of.</li><li>Treats people unfairly and show favoritism to a select few.</li><li>Underutilizes the capabilities of people and inhibits their personal growth.</li></ul><p><strong>WHAT SHOULD YOU DO AS MANAGER?</strong></p><p>Refer to the above statements. These were management actions that Drucker felt contributed to employee de-motivation. Which actions do you and your organization need to change to create a more positive and motivating environment? Also review the seven key areas Drucker suggested contribute to organizational performance and answer the key questions relative to each area. Ideally, you will find Drucker’s approach to be more useful as compared to reviewing the countless number of books and theories on employee motivation.</p><p>“Efficiency is doing the thing right. Effectiveness is doing the right thing.” ― Peter F. Drucker</p><p><strong>5 GLOBAL “CERTAINTIES” YOU CAN’T AFFORD TO IGNORE</strong></p><p>Drucker wrote that the purpose of strategy is to enable an organization to achieve its desired results in an unpredictable environment. So contrary to what many believe, strategy is not about achieving results in a known and foreseeable environment, but an environment that is unknown and unforeseeable. In Drucker’s own words, it allows an organization to be “purposefully opportunistic.”</p><p><strong>THE FIVE CERTAINTIES</strong></p><p>Drucker was never afraid to propose ideas which others may never have even considered, and this was certainly the case with the five environmental variables which he felt were phenomena so unique that they could safely be considered certainties and not just possibilities as we normally assume for fixed variables that we sometimes call “environmental.”</p><p>Moreover, he believed that they were different from anything current strategies considered as they were not essentially economic, but were primarily social and political.</p><p><strong>CERTAINTY #1: COLLAPSING BIRTHRATE IN THE DEVELOPED WORLD</strong></p><p>Drucker found the falling birthrate in the developed world to be a phenomenon unique in history, with dramatic collateral effects and important secondary effects. Perhaps the most obvious change was in the very old assumption that markets would continue to increase as the population increased.</p><p>How many times have we heard that markets are bound to enlarge due to simply to the automatic increase in birthrate? But Drucker looked at the facts and found that birthrates were no longer steadily increasing for populations in the developed world.</p><p>Of course the decline in birthrate could be somewhat offset, delayed, or somewhat concealed by immigration. But even this would result in dramatic changes and would also cause turmoil as border populations with different, customs, religions, and even languages were attracted into countries of diminished numbers of younger workers.</p><p>Drucker saw several important secondary effects resulting from the collapsing birthrate. He said that for the immediate future demographics would dominate the politics in developed countries, shunted aside only temporarily by wars and economic conditions.</p><p>Eventually government instability in developed countries would likely soon become the norm. The definition of the concept of retirement was certain to change. While early “retirement” would continue, it would no longer mean a return to childhood in some kind of golden year’s playground. Rather it might mean extended employment with the former employer, but under a different name and conditions.</p><p>We have seen this come to pass even before the onset of the current recession.</p><p>Drucker noted that older workers, especially the knowledge worker who worked primarily with his mind and not his hands would become increasingly productive. He speculated that firms that first discovered how best to utilize this experienced talent in a new type of relationship would acquire a significant competitive advantage.</p><p>Perhaps of even more direct importance would be the effect on potential markets. The size of the youth and younger market would inevitably decline and the senior market increase. But the increase in potential would not only be due to numbers of potential customers, but to the individual purchasing power of those who retired from a first career and continued to find employment while in a “retired” state.</p><p><strong>CERTAINTY #2: SHIFTS IN DISTRIBUTION OF DISPOSABLE INCOME</strong></p><p>Drucker found that the truly important statistic that most companies overlook completely is the share of disposable income that is being spent on the products or services that they provide.</p><p>Drucker believed that this figure was the most reliable in formulating strategy as it changed very little over long periods while any change in trends of disposable income are crucial to a firm’s strategy. He concluded that utilizing this certainty required both quantitative information and qualitative analysis.</p><p>Thus another example of looking at data but deciding what the data meant rather than primarily crunching numbers.</p><p><strong>CERTAINTY #3: CHANGING DEFINITION OF PERFORMANCE</strong></p><p>According to Drucker, the traditional view of performance has been that the corporation was run for the interest of the manual worker, at least in Japan, Germany, Scandinavian countries and some others. Of course, in the U.S. and Britain, the interests have been somewhat different, at least since the late 1920s.</p><p>Though not clearly defined, business is supposed to be run for an ill defined conglomeration of interests including customers, employees, shareholders, and society. The only big question is whether this should be short term for gain in stock price, or longer term for future growth.</p><p>Drucker noted that even “long term” isn’t necessarily all that long since the average span of a “successful” enterprise in the U.S. is usually less than thirty years. The resulting fixed certainty was many traditional views would need to be revised including the definition of performance.</p><p>These new definitions of performance would have a clear impact on strategy, would be based on longer term estimates, and less and less on “social harmony,” and that performance would need to be defined non-financially with a nonfinancial “value” return. Only in this way would this be meaningful to knowledge workers and generate the commitment which today is frequently termed “engagement.”</p><p><strong>CERTAINTY #4: INCREASING GLOBAL COMPETITION</strong></p><p>According to most definitions of global competitiveness, this has to do with competitiveness of nations. Each year the World Economic Forum compiles a weighted average of many different components measured by publically available data and surveys of a country’s relative competitiveness globally. That’s not what Drucker was talking about with this certainty.</p><p>As he looked into the future, no small business, giant corporation, hospital, university, you name it could ignore institutions outside of its own national boundaries. It could neither succeed, nor even survive, without measuring up to standards set by the leaders in its industry anywhere on the planet.</p><p>Of considerable benefit if our political, corporate, and labor leaders would simply integrate the knowledge into their strategies it was Drucker’s contention that traditional means of protection of home industries no longer protects, “no matter how high the customs duties nor how low the import quotas.”</p><p>Drucker predicted the struggles now occurring for increased protectionism. He said that the net result of protectionism would not solve a nation’s problems, or a particular institutions, only make individual companies even more vulnerable.</p><p>The only solution was for the organization to find a way to compete considering the standards set by the best organizations in every area of management no matter where located, and essentially to consider such issues as government subsidies of global competitors as environmental variables which must be overcome by superior strategies, not by similar protection strategies of its own government.</p><figure><a href="https://tallyfy.com/solutions/business-process-management-software-bpms/"><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/939/1*szX4aEwY_i4mrEJdUU1GJA.png" /></a></figure><p><strong>CERTAINTY #5: GROWING INCONGRUENCE BETWEEN ECONOMIC GLOBALIZATION AND POLITICAL SPLINTERING</strong></p><p>Drucker’s first successful book, The End of Economic Man took on the historic notion that man behaved rationally in response to economics. According to Drucker, the rise of Nazism disproved that theory.</p><p>Sixty years later Drucker revisited his earlier work in a management context and strategy development. His conclusion: even within transnational economic units, national politics will invariably overrule economic rationality.</p><p>Managers in all industries and disciplines are well advised to consider these certainties as equally important to traditional environmental variables usually considered the sole factors in developing strategy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e3fe6ef91df9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons/making-knowledge-workers-more-productive-insights-from-the-works-of-peter-f-drucker-e3fe6ef91df9">Making Knowledge Workers More Productive: Insights from the Works of Peter F. Drucker</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/business-process-management-software-comparisons">On Business Process Management and Workflow Automation</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>