<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Tal Minear on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Tal Minear on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@talminear?source=rss-31b66a653b20------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 18:15:24 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@talminear/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Audio Drama Casting Call Template]]></title>
            <link>https://talminear.medium.com/audio-drama-casting-call-template-377186440804?source=rss-31b66a653b20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/377186440804</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[audiodrama]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[casting-call]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tal Minear]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Jul 2025 01:57:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-09T02:00:23.101Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is meant as a companion to my article on <a href="https://medium.com/@talminear/writing-audio-drama-casting-calls-d8ebaf29a244">how to write audio drama casting calls</a>. Please read it first! It explains my thought process. But if you know what you’re doing and want a simple template, you’re in the right place.</p><h4>Basic Info</h4><p><strong>Title: <br>Project Type: <br>Union/Non-Union: <br>Length: <br>Recording Period: <br>Recording Location: <br>Compensation: <br>Audition Deadline:</strong></p><h4>Audition Instructions</h4><ul><li>We’re looking for broadcast quality audio, with no background noise or reverb.</li><li>No previous voice acting experience required. We encourage new VAs to audition!</li><li>Slate your name at the top of your audition.</li><li>No more than 2 takes, in ABC ABC format (read all the lines, then go back again).</li><li>Submit files as a mp3, named Character_YourName.mp3</li><li>Separate files for each character, please, if you’re auditioning for multiple.</li><li>Submit files via this google form.</li></ul><p><strong>[Optional Additions]</strong></p><p>Voice actors of all genders are welcome to audition for any character. For audition lines that are exchanged with another character, you do not need to read the lines for that other character.</p><p>Questions about auditioning? Email [your email here], but don’t submit your auditions here, as they will be discarded.</p><h4>Characters</h4><ul><li>[Quick bullet point list of characters for reference, potentially with brief info like age, pronouns, VA compensation]</li></ul><h4>Then, Begin the Sides</h4><p>[Character Name]<br>[Age, Pronouns, Sentence or two description of their personality.]<br>[Audition Sides.]</p><p><strong>Modify this template to your heart’s content.</strong> Here are some example casting calls that are each slightly different:</p><p><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Dg0jvPIlDEeGwDCPIq4FGJa6odkim2-1bVZreB9L1SI/edit?usp=sharing">Dracula’s Guest</a></p><p><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1zqpuOHQLdXRNvtkIzLHE1ad4bPbn0hOOIaWxZTYWZSE/edit?usp=sharing">SDITE</a></p><p><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tLQ3JwhhItIekoGxVU0X5kYgyzO9hP6zuGJXlEnDgy0/edit?usp=sharing">Re: Frankenstein</a></p><p><a href="https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ZEchSwB1thMYWX7L0pIS3zJQSMn3wtk_8XC-GkCCIBU/edit?usp=sharing">Sidequesting</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=377186440804" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Finding Asexual Representation in Indie Audio Drama]]></title>
            <link>https://talminear.medium.com/finding-asexual-representation-in-indie-audio-drama-07269cd3b749?source=rss-31b66a653b20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/07269cd3b749</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tal Minear]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 May 2025 23:04:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-20T13:59:19.438Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wD0kBywPKfVP0r0DgN6wCw.png" /></figure><p><strong>This piece was originally published in </strong><a href="https://discoverpods.com/asexual-rep-indie-audio-drama/"><strong>Discover Pods</strong></a><strong> in 2021. It’s one of my favorite things I’ve written, and I want to share it here as well :)</strong></p><p>In the fall of 2016, I listened to episode 28 of <em>The Bright Sessions</em>.</p><p>The next year, I came out to all my friends as asexual (often shortened to “ace”).</p><p>This is probably not a coincidence.</p><p>In the same way it hides in the back of the LGTBTQIA+ acronym, asexuality is not an obvious orientation. It’s frequently disregarded by those who aren’t queer, often overlooked by the community it’s a part of, and even purposefully excluded on occasion. Aces joke about needing a PowerPoint to come out because so many people don’t know about Asexuality, even the well meaning.</p><p>Mainstream media is not well known for its queer representation in general, but the count of <a href="https://www.vox.com/culture/2018/3/26/16291562/asexuality-tv-history-bojack-shadowhunters-game-of-thrones">canonically ace characters across TV shows</a> is low. Across movies it is, as far as I can tell, <em>zero</em>. Even when the source material has an asexual-identifying character, the adaptation is likely to ignore that (I’m looking at you, <em>Riverdale</em>). While novels are almost certainly the best form of mainstream media if you’re looking for ace rep, the count is also not high. In 2016, it was small enough that despite being an avid reader, I had yet to come across asexuality in fiction.</p><p>In fact, I was 21 when I first came across a canonically ace character. Not in a book, movie, or tv show, though. In a podcast.</p><p>I nearly dropped my phone listening to “Patient #13 (Chloe) + Friend”<em> </em>when Dr. Bright said, “Some people find asexuality a difficult concept to grasp.” It was the first time I’d heard the term said outside of certain corners of the internet or my school’s Safe Space training, and it meant <em>so much</em> to me.</p><p>This was the first time I considered that possibly, my ace-ness was a part of me I wouldn’t have to hide. I’m not exaggerating when I say I was prepared to have everyone except my closest friends assume I was straight until the end of time. But it was at this moment — sitting at my desk, listening to an audio drama — where I started to see that maybe, just maybe, I could be proud of who I was.</p><p>This is what representation does for us. It reminds us that we’re not alone in the world. It reassures us that we’re allowed to exist. Out of a whole world of media, it was this tiny corner of indie audio drama that looked me in the eyes and told me <em>I was allowed to exist</em>. Because while I found representation in <em>The Bright Sessions</em> first, I’ve been finding it again and again across independent audio drama.</p><p>I maintain <a href="https://www.podchaser.com/lists/ace-rep-107ZzsCTjw">a list</a> of audio fiction shows with ace characters, and at the time of writing, it’s at 43 different shows, 25 of which have in-episode confirmation by characters in the show. There is quite possibly more ace representation in indie audio drama than every other form of media combined.</p><p>There is <em>The Beacon</em>, a fantasy audio drama about magic powers, giant monsters, and the importance of making friends. In the first episode of season two, main character Bee mentions not understanding why her friend is interested in someone, attributing it by saying, “Maybe it’s just me being asexual.” As someone who’s been in that exact situation, I found the scene incredibly relatable.</p><p>There is <em>Love &amp; Luck</em>, a slice of life queer romance story with a touch of magic, told via voicemails. In episode 55, CJ mentions “bonding over asexuality stuff” with Ricardo. I love that their ace identity is not a disruption to possible romance, but actually helps it form. This episode was really inspirational for me, and in a way that is entirely too difficult to explain, it also gave me hope.</p><p>There is <em>Inkwyrm</em>, a sci-fi podcast about fashion, aliens, and the indeterminately fabulous future. Robert so boldly states in episode 7, “I’m aromantic asexual. You know that.” He says this like it’s no big deal, channeling the precise confidence I wanted to have myself some day.</p><p>And more recently:</p><p>There’s season 2, episode 7 of <em>Arden</em>, “Rosalind and Pamela are Dead,” where Rosalind gives an extraordinarily relatable rant about her friendship being viewed as a compromise. This is something I’ve personally encountered, and her monologue about the situation hit close to home. Never has this particular sensation been so thoroughly captured in a piece of media for me.</p><p>There is <em>Less is Morgue</em>, where Riley brings up being Asexual a number of times, often to fairly unpleasant guests on the show. I love that even the most evil of guests don’t give them a hard time about it, and if any of them come close, Riley shuts them down swiftly. I need to start taking notes.</p><p>There is episode 5 of <em>The Godshed Incidental</em>, “In the Dark,” in which protagonist Em questions, “You know I’m ace, right? Ace and aro and undateable?” and is met with a simple “Yes, it’s in your file.” This right here is the <em>ideal </em>response I want to receive when coming out to someone. It’s the dream, and it was so refreshing to hear.</p><p>Again and again and again, these shows tell me that it’s okay to be me. They tell <em>others </em>that it’s okay for me to be me. Bee can be at college and trying to fight a monster and also be asexual. CJ and Ricardo can be falling in love and be Asexual. Robert can have an adorable kid and be a doctor and also be asexual.</p><p>Maybe I can be a podcaster and engineer and whatever else it is that I am — and also be asexual? Maybe that’s okay?</p><p>When society as a whole says the opposite, the message these shows give is incredibly meaningful. Through the simple inclusion of asexual characters, they make me feel that I don’t need to prove I have a right to exist as ace.</p><p>Here in 2021, I’m both confident in and proud of my identity. I don’t need this message — but, that wasn’t the case in 2016. Would I have gotten here without these shows? Yes. Am I extremely grateful for the push they gave me to accept who I am? Also yes.</p><p>Perhaps it would be slightly more accurate to say this in broader terms:</p><p>In 2016, I started listening to indie audio dramas.</p><p>The next year, I came out to the world as asexual.</p><p>This is, definitely, not a coincidence.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=07269cd3b749" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[For Everyone and No One]]></title>
            <link>https://talminear.medium.com/for-everyone-and-no-one-224d25814253?source=rss-31b66a653b20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/224d25814253</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[audio-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[audio-verse-awards]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[audiodrama]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tal Minear]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Jan 2024 19:45:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-19T20:49:49.327Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The Mixed Bag of the AVAs</h4><p>The <a href="https://audioverseawards.net/about/">Audio Verse Awards</a> are “an annual celebration, dedicated to the greatest people and productions in immersive audio fiction around the world, whether it’s an audio play, improvised, or spoken word production.” Many have called it a popularity contest, though the chair insists it’s a “preference contest.” They’re in their 10th year of running, and consist of a 12 member team.</p><p>This piece looks at the good and bad of the Audio Verse Awards — there’s a lot of both! In addition to my own opinions, I’ve asked a few other audio drama creators to chime in.</p><h4>Audio Verse Awards</h4><p>The AVAs bring the audio fiction community together each year to promote their favorite shows, new and old. Because fans can vote for multiple shows, it’s a competitive <em>and</em> collaborative awards experience. It’s common to see productions supporting other podcasts alongside their own. The AVAs are frequently an audio drama’s first award, in no small part due to their “new production” categories. I think this is fantastic. It brings credibility to indie audio fiction as a whole, which is why I hold their operations to such a high standard.</p><p>The AVAs strive for perfection — an admirable goal, but one that comes at the cost of consistency. The awards change nearly every year, so submitting can feel like a roll of a dice for creators. The modified borda count has been in place for a dependable amount of years, but the categories themselves or the ways in which nominees will advance to the finals have yet to be standardized this decade. It’s confusing, which hinders the credibility and reliability of the whole awards system. Creators cannot plan for the categories they apply for, fans cannot understand how their favorite shows make the finals, and those outside the indie sphere cannot respect an awards system that does this.</p><p>To their credit, the AVAs publish a lengthy change log every year detailing what’s different and why they’re changing it. This is a stunning level of transparency I wish more organizations would hold themselves to. But the AVAs is also the only awards system I know of that requires an annual “here’s what’s different this year” post. To my knowledge, no other awards experiment with their system quite this much. Popular vote awards have existed for a while with a process that works. Do the AVAs <em>need</em> to reinvent the wheel?</p><p>Some of these changes are more drastic than others. For example, a few years ago they added a Hall of Fame portion to the awards. Voters induct a handful of shows each year. It’s the last question on the ballot, and it cannot be skipped. Sarah Rosina Winkler says, “Whilst I certainly appreciate the sentiment, it’s fairly useless. The voters don’t know these shows and they’re being asked to vote anyway. It needs to be completely separated from the AVAs.” In contrast, Evo Terra wrote “Having been involved with fiction podcasting quite literally since fiction podcasting started, I know there are some fantastic fiction podcasts from the early days of podcasting that were and still are great. To me, having a new Hall of Fame category in the Audio Verse Awards will be a great way to pay homage to some of the great audio fiction shows that left their mark on today’s landscape.” Terra is overseeing the 2023 Hall of Fame, and curates <a href="https://www.theend.fyi/">The End</a>.</p><p>New this year is a juried system of awards. Little has been said about it beyond the few paragraphs on their <a href="https://audioverseawards.net/juries/">website</a>. They say that “If we get enough volunteers, every nominee will receive a judged rating,” but as of publication, it’s unclear if they’ve made this number. It’s also unclear how many people make up the jury, but I spoke to two people on it. They shared that the AVA Team’s goal is to have 3 jurors to review each show and average the scores, but didn’t know if this goal had been met. I assume we’ll learn more once the winners are announced.</p><p>When I asked what the AVAs could do to improve, Jeff Van Dreason says they should simplify. “I think they need to find an identity that’s far less complex and doesn’t try to serve so many functions at once. I respect what they’re trying to do in that regard, but at this point much of the AVAs feels contradictory and it continues to get more confusing every year, both as a creator and as a voter.” I agree with Jeff — it seems that the team is trying to do too many things and managing it mediocrely. As it stands, the AVA ballot take me comparably long to fill out as voting in the US general election. It’s long, confusing, and unintuitive, especially to casual fans of just a few podcasts.</p><h4>Audio Verse Accessibility</h4><p>This confusion also leads to accessibility issues. Voters must vote in every category, and the voting form is often cluttered and busy. The AVA team has tried to improve their ballot layout each year, but it has been to mixed results. Caroline Mincks’ first experience voting was in 2020. They write, “I haven’t participated in the AVAs [since then], in large part because of how frustrating the experience was the first time around. Sifting through what felt like an endless list of oops-wait-they’re-still-loading thumbnail images, which were not organized in any way I could make sense of, would have been more than enough to make many people call it quits on the spot.” They noted that “at the time at least, you were not allowed to skip categories in the voting process.”</p><p>For Mincks, who had “only heard a fraction of the shows nominated for certain categories,” this led to an obligation to listen “through quite a lot of audio in a short amount of time.” They said, “I happen to be deaf, and part of what I deal with on a regular basis is what I call “hearing fatigue”. Listening takes a lot more energy for me than it does for hearing people — it’s harder for me to understand sound, it takes a lot more focus, I often have to rewind or refer to transcripts to keep up, the list goes on… It took me a really, really long time to get through all those episodes, and it was a truly exhausting ordeal.”</p><p>In the past, the AVA team has responded to requests to allow skipping categories by encouraging use of the Nominee Showcase to listen to more podcasts instead. In 2020, Evan Tess Murray said on Twitter “I actively dislike listening to AP shows and should not be judging them…. it feels strange to rate shows in a format I personally dislike.” The response from the AVA account was to say “We’re confident with the nominee showcase you’ll find one to your taste.” Mincks told them that “requiring this [amount of] research for these categories in order to vote and not giving the option to skip any presents an accessibility issue.” A user agreed, saying “I’m disabled. your voting system is inaccessible for those of us who can’t spend hours researching &amp; listening to things that don’t interest us anyway, when some of these things don’t have transcripts or easily accessible info. Not letting up skip is a major accessibility issue.”</p><p>The official response by the AVA team, posted October 16 2020, stated “during our first few years, we learned that skipping categories can be abused by voters for one particular show to influence the results. However, we do take accessibility very seriously.” Wil Williams observed of their response, “you seem to be saying your method is fine and good, regardless of people saying actually it is not… I’m not seeing evidence of accountability being taken.” The march of time seems to agree — despite their claim that “if we can adjust things to make things more accessible, we will,” categories remain unskippable three years later, and the Nominee Showcase’s transcripts are hit or miss. But unlike in 2020, voters do not have to put 10 shows in each category to submit a ballot. Small progress is still progress!</p><p>Newton Schottelkotte observes, “The voting in the AVAs only takes forever and is so complicated and annoying because you can’t just go in, vote for your favorite shows in the categories they’re actually in, skip anything you don’t want to/don’t feel informed enough to vote in, and leave. They are so dedicated to arbitrarily denying it’s a popularity contest that they have made it actively more cumbersome to vote, thus ensuring that only the shows with the most rabidly dedicated fans actually go in and vote. By trying to not be a popularity contest they have become the APEX of one to a torture nexus degree.”</p><p>Sarah Rosina Winkler consistently tries to “listen to every single show before getting to rate it,” without success. “In [2023], I listened to 94 episodes on the Nominee Showcase… for a total of 58 hours, [with] 28 episodes to go. It’s too much to listen to within a month, and it’s tiring to boot. I appreciate the new changes to the voting system — especially as it doesn’t force my laptop into overdrive — that you can choose which shows you want to rate, but it’s still a lot of work for the people voting. Especially if you consider that some episodes on the Nominee Showcase can go for two hours. How can you be expected to make a reasonable decision like that?”</p><h4>Audio Verse Aspersions</h4><p>In the past, the team has struggled with criticism. Before this year, I’ve kept any negative opinions of the AVAs to myself, so I asked Wil Williams if they’d be willing to share their experience speaking to the AVA team in previous years. They said:</p><blockquote>For at least two years of the AVAs, I have been asked directly to provide feedback on proposed categories and submission processes for the upcoming year. My feedback was clear, consistent, and hopefully, kind: I expressed that I felt the categories were too complicated and confusing, especially for fans who might not be versed in industry terminology — let alone the idiosyncratic and opaque vocabulary used by the AVAs. I also stressed that making massive changes to the categories, voting system, etc. every year does not help the nominees or the fans, and continues to make for a confusing and inaccessible system.</blockquote><blockquote>These conversations were always presented to me via Discord. I did not start any of these conversations myself. My thoughts and feedback were directly sought out. And each year, my feedback was ignored. I was bafflingly treated like I had done nothing but praise the proposed changes. It was very surreal. I tried to emphasize that I was not agreeing, and in fact, did not think the changes would be good — and still, I was treated like I was in agreement. I stopped trying to get on the same page, because frankly, I did not think it was possible.</blockquote><blockquote>The one time I did initiate conversation directly with the AVAs, it was in a reply to a thread on their Twitter, and I was asking a clarification question for a detail that confused me — and confused others, who had come to me asking for clarification in case I understood something they didn’t. I was responded to by the same person who had asked me for feedback before coming into my Discord DMs and calling me hostile. I was guilted for having the conversation in public (again, it was in a reply to a thread that they had posted on Twitter, in public), and blamed for not having memory of past conversations that loosely related to the topic at hand. I explained my motivation for asking, and I asked why I was being called hostile, given my question was very simple. I was then told I was never called hostile. When I showed a screenshot of where this person had called me hostile, the blame continued to come back onto me.</blockquote><blockquote>This was the last time I spoke with any representative of the AVAs, and is very indicative to me of how their upper management responds to criticism in public spaces where they cannot hide. In private, meanwhile, the responses to criticism are even more confusing. I am glad that the AVAs have afforded so many creators the accolades they deserve and, often, greater professional opportunities. I, however, am not going to put any energy into hoping or expecting that the way the AVAs are run will change for the better.</blockquote><p>Williams provided screenshots of these interactions to me, and I can personally confirm their claims.</p><p>While I feel that the team’s communication has never been great, in the past I excused it. It was a free awards run by unpaid volunteers — and if it took them three months to count the ballots, so be it. Disappearing behind a wall of silence has been as standard between rounds four years ago as it is today. Finalist voting closed Jan 2, and nothing has been said when we can expect the winners to be announced. Last year, tabulations were finished on January 30, and winners were announced on March 19. No updates were posted between these two dates.</p><p>I’m willing to cut a lot of slack for a small group making something for free. But two years ago, they started charging for entry, and not much has changed. Initially, I was strongly in favor of adding a small fee to submit your show to the AVAs. The team was clearly overworked, and I’m generally a fan of people getting paid for what they do. Plus, the scholarships for shows that can’t afford the fee are working great. In the past two years, I’ve seen that nearly every show applying for sponsorship will receive one in the end. Additionally, compared to the hundreds of dollars the Ambies and Signal Awards charge, $25 pales in comparison. I’ll be the first in line to proclaim how reasonable this fee is. It’s on par with the early submission fees for web festivals, and it doesn’t even increase as the deadline approaches.</p><p>In 2022, each team member received about $550. Yet, they’re still referred to as volunteers, which is a bit misleading. Their FAQ says “in 2021, each volunteer received $434, and in 2022, it was approximately $554 per volunteer.” While I may dislike their wording, but I truly appreciate the transparency in reporting these figures. Last year, I counted 191 shows in the list of nominees — an revenue of $4,775 if each show paid $25. The website in 2022 showed 6 team members, and if they each got $554 that’s $3,324 profit. Their <a href="https://audioverseawards.net/about/#Frequently_Asked_Questions">FAQ</a> says, “Our operational expenses are our website and hosting, our mailing list for the number of participants we email for the awards, our voting systems to ensure fair and accurate, and tools for accessibility sadly kept behind paywalls. We use the fees submitted to cover any shows which can’t afford the entry fee, and the rest goes to our volunteers who share it equally.” Since the team has doubled between this year and last, I’d guess each member will receive about half of what they got last year.</p><p>I do think each member of the AVA team deserves more than this for their work. In past years, I’ve seen firsthand how much time goes into running the AVAs. This year, the community manager said “I have dedicated multiple hours every single day since September (with months more to go) to try and provide outreach and answer questions.” Running an awards is hard work. No matter the faults of the awards, the team is passionate and well intentioned. Brad Williams (<em>no relation to Wil Williams</em>) says, “I have absolutely no doubt that the people running [the AVAs] are doing so earnestly and with the best interests of the community as well as fiction podcasting in general at the core of their efforts… building a truly fair and equitable program to recognize creative works for their quality is incredibly difficult.”</p><h4>Audio Verse Accidents</h4><p>That being said, I did expect to see <em>some</em> difference in how the AVAs would be run with a few thousand dollars at their disposal. Perhaps there is a difference internally, but externally… well, they’re still goofing. That’s their wording, not mine.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/585/0*s_F__jicNwybssvy.png" /><figcaption>They goofed.</figcaption></figure><p>Due to display issues, votes were not properly counted for the Recurring Voices and Director categories in the first 24 hours of finalist voting this year. In response, the AVAs closed the ballot, “decided the best remedy [was] to clean out the existing votes cast and start again,” and did exactly that. I asked “why is it fair to all categories [to] remove all the votes?” and got the response, “In our assessment, it is more expedient if we start over in voting with a clean ballot than trying to find ways to collect data after people have already voted. We have not tossed any ballots.”</p><p>I attempted to clarify, “If you have the data from my ballot on the first day of voting, why aren’t you using it?” but the team did not reply. I genuinely do not know what to call the removal of my ballot because I voted in the first day, if not the tossing of. The ignoring of early ballots? I’m not sure why they didn’t keep the votes for correctly displayed categories, run additional votes for the two messed up categories, or test their form before finals voting opened. This is the sort of thing I’m happy to excuse for a group of unpaid volunteers, but less so for a team accepting $25 from most of the 100+ shows nominated.</p><p>Updates to the issues with voting were first shared to the now-defunct AD Lab Discord server. Anyone could join this server, but posts to it were only visible to members. The AD Lab was not directly connected to the AVAs, so people wanting more information on the awards may not have known to join it. Thankfully, an update was later sent to their mailing list and posted on social media.</p><p>When server members asked questions about the AVAs’ fees, the community manger responded:</p><blockquote>Sadly, this experience has begun to sour me on this community. If the volunteers are given a little gas money after working hours every day, why are we the bad guys? Why is the awards show suddenly villainized? Is it because it’s easy to attack a faceless entity and easy to forget that we’re just a small group of human beings who want a place to celebrate audio dramas? This is my first year. I can’t speak to the past. And no one on our team believes there isn’t room for improvement. But stop for a minute and recognize we are people before spreading all of this slander.</blockquote><p>The two most negative statements I saw while were these questions: “what has the new $25 entry fee contributed to?” and “Wait so not really all volunteers? I’m confused.” When asked, the community manger elaborated:</p><blockquote>The slander comes from it being spread around that the awards are not ‘transparent’ in discussing where our fees are distributed. That is a willful false statement meant to defame the awards because not only has the information been readily available under our ‘FAQ’ on our website for years, but numerous links have been provided to that information, yet people are actively choosing to continue the false statements in order to damage the awards reputation.</blockquote><p>The question “Where does the entry fee go?” is the 9th question on the FAQ, which is itself in the middle of the two thousand word “about” page on the website. I’ll admit to looking for and not finding it initially, which makes me curious about how many of the “willful false statements” came from others in my position. I also wonder how useful numerous links are if they’re buried in the replies of ever-breaking Twitter threads or sitting in hidden Discord channels. But the question at the top of my mind is: Why does the community manager assume bad faith?</p><h4>Audio Verse Afflictions</h4><p>I think this illustrates the issue at the core of the AVAs — a desire to please the <em>entire</em> community. This manifests not only in the constant changes to the awards, but the level of frustration in the team’s response to criticism. Everything about the awards seems to be taken personally by them. Queries are deemed hostile. Questions are attacks. Confusion is slander. It comes across like they’re angry about not receiving the thanks they think they deserve. Or maybe the team is stressed out by the pressure of perfection, and merely lashing out. Neither is a great scenario.</p><p>The problem is that the “audio drama community,” whatever that may be, is unlikely to come together and thank <em>anyone</em>. Indie audio drama consists of diverse and overlapping circles of fans and creators that can’t even agree on what audio drama is. Doing anything for this community is, by nature, a thankless task. Expecting accolades for your work is a path towards anger and frustration when those accolades don’t come. It is truly impossible to please everyone, and I wish the AVAs would stop trying. It’s negatively impacting both their team members and the awards itself.</p><p>I want the team to know that fans and creators hold the AVAs to a high standard because they want to participate in something successful and good. The team receives criticism because people have faith in their improvement, not because the awards are their favorite punching bag. People only take the time to share their thoughts when there’s a chance they’ll be listened to. Some people, like Brad Williams, have found their feedback welcome. Others, like Wil Williams, have found their feedback ignored. It’s truly a mixed bag.</p><p>But do the AVAs even need to listen? Jeff Van Dreason says:</p><blockquote>This is their vision and while others can and should offer advice, we should also respect their autonomy to do it their way and find the best way for them to do it. I think sometimes people think ‘I gave them advice and they didn’t listen to me.’ They don’t…have to? Should they improve? Absolutely, but if the advice they’re receiving runs contrary to <em>how</em> they want to run the thing, who is that for us to say? We can opt out of participating if we find it to be too big of a problem or not in line with what we want out of an audio fiction award.</blockquote><p>Matters of accessibility aside, I give the AVAs full permission to stop listening to us and make the thing they want to make — <em>one</em> thing, instead of numerous different things in one AVA shaped cloak. I hope the team’s takeaway from the criticisms of this piece is to understand that perfection is pointless and applause will never come. The nebulous entity of “the audio drama community” is not who the AVAs should be making happy. The AVAs should be making the AVA <em>team</em> happy. From an outsider perspective, that doesn’t seem to be happening right now.</p><p>The AVA’s quest for perfection is a quest to please everyone. To be the best popular vote awards, but not be a popularity contest. To be a way to discover new shows, but also to award old shows. To be sustainable, but accessible. It’s for indie audio fiction, but also not quite, because the AVAs welcome all. It’s for scripted shows and improv shows (but not if you’re behind a paywall), storytelling podcasts (but not this year because there were too few last time), fan works (but not if you’re infringing on IP), ever-growing groups with complicated exceptions to cast the widest possible net.</p><p>Every year they change how it works, spaghetti thrown at the wall to see what sticks. Add a entry fee. Hall of Fame. Juried portion. Expand the scope, and expand it again. The AVAs want to be everything. Are they doing the opposite instead?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=224d25814253" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Podcast Movement’s Performative Allyship]]></title>
            <link>https://talminear.medium.com/podcast-movements-performative-allyship-254af111751d?source=rss-31b66a653b20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/254af111751d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[podcast]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[podcasting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[podcast-movement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tal Minear]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Aug 2023 22:09:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-24T01:40:52.915Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Wjhp5UVbyIIh0K-aNCO6Kg.png" /></figure><p><em>This story was updated on 8/23/23 to add that Cumulus Podcast Network is an exhibitor at Podcast Movement Denver.</em></p><p>It’s been about year since Podcast Movement Dallas, and the perfect time to look back on what exactly went wrong.</p><p>Maybe you attended, or a friend did, and hearing that something went wrong comes as a surprise. Here’s <a href="https://talminear.medium.com/inaction-is-an-action-moving-forward-with-podcast-movement-342f0bc908a7">an article I wrote</a> about it last year, and <a href="https://wilwilliams.reviews/2022/08/28/too-little-too-late-podcast-movement/">another by Wil Williams</a>. But I’ll break it down into facts, more briefly:</p><ul><li>The Daily Wire has a booth on the first floor of the conference (ironically, right next to the pronoun buttons).</li><li>Ben Shapiro shows up at this booth on the 24th. He does not have a badge.</li><li>I tweet about it.</li><li>Jared Easley, head of Community and Content at Podcast Movement, confirms to me personally that Shapiro was not invited or expected. Later, he’s seen on twitter supporting Shapiro fans.</li><li>Dan Franks, President of Podcast Movement, confirms to me via DM that “there was no badge registered for [Shapiro] or any talent associated with him.”</li><li>The morning of the 25th, Podcast Movement apologizes on twitter for the unexpected appearance of Shapiro.</li><li>A bunch of Shapiro fans harass the PodMov twitter account, my personal twitter account, and the accounts of my friends who had tweeted supporting me. This includes Libs of TikTok (an account connected to multiple bomb threats against children’s hospitals that provide gender-affirming care).</li><li>The Daily Wire posts a video that included screenshots of my tweets. More fans harass me online as a result. My podcasts start getting review-bombed.</li><li>Still on August 25, a fan of Shapiro enters the conference area without a badge, and films videos heckling attendees and workers. I’ll find out later he’s not the only one.</li><li>On the last day of Podcast Movement, friends escort me to my final panel in case anyone else is let in without a badge.</li><li>I receive no communication from Podcast Movement after the event ends.</li><li>On September 2, Podcast Movement unfollows me on twitter. This is their last “direct” message to me.</li><li>On September 8, Podcast Movement tweets an apology to Shapiro.</li></ul><p>And now you’re caught up. Podcast Movement is currently gearing up for their next big event in Denver on August 21. <strong>They’ve failed to address why people were let into the Dallas conference without badges or provide a plan to prevent it from happening in the future. </strong>Their actions have shown that they don’t care if speakers at their events are put in danger.</p><p>The organization joined the likes of Bud Light and Target before events put those two companies on the map. There’s a pattern here, and I’d like to dive into it.</p><p>Bud Light worked with trans influencer Dylan Mulvaney, then received violent emails in response. They <a href="https://www.cnn.com/2023/06/29/tech/dylan-mulvaney-bud-light-statement/index.html">abandoned Mulvaney</a> to a torrent of harassment.</p><p>Target worked with a number of queer and trans creators to create Pride merchandise, then received <a href="https://www.thecut.com/2023/06/target-employees-harassment-transphobia.html">harassment and threats</a>. They removed the Pride merch from display across their stores.</p><p>Podcast Movement has worked with several trans speakers at their events. When they get online vitriol after an attempt to make their conference safe for trans guests and speakers, they backpedal. Trans attendees being harassed online are left out to dry, no attempt is made to help them during the conference, and after the event, Podcast Movement ignores them.</p><p>Their support of trans individuals is performative. They’ll put pronoun pins out at their events, but also have a booth for The Daily Wire (an organization well known for their attacks on trans rights). They’re happy to have trans people speak at Podcast Movement, but as soon as that person receives targeted harassment during the event, they’re on their own.</p><p>What if I had been attending the conference alone? What if the people let in without badges had run into me? I was put in an <em>incredibly </em>unsafe position by this organization last year. It’s only thanks to good luck and the support of my friends that nothing went wrong.</p><p>Speakers at Podcast Movement should not have to “hire” friends to escort them. We should not have to explicitly tell people not to speak about our whereabouts online, and hide when we’re flying home. Nobody should spend their nights at the event blocking hundreds of people online, and their days looking over their shoulder.</p><p><strong>Podcast Movement should not have apologized to the individual who directly sent his fans to harass me online.</strong></p><p>They should not have supported a company like The Daily Wire in the first place, but <em>especially </em>should not have doubled down in the aftermath of Shapiro’s appearance. Their apology on September 8 emboldened the people who had spent their weeks sending me slurs and threats. Intentional or not, it welcomed those individuals to future events. Intentional or not, it told transgender podcasters that they are <em>not</em> welcome at future events.</p><p>I <a href="https://talminear.medium.com/and-id-do-it-again-f7669a38b4a6">said</a> on August 30, 2022<strong>,</strong> “Build an event I can safely be at, and you’ll have me there.” The actions Podcast Movement have taken in the past year have shown that they simply don’t care. They’re unwilling to put in the work to build an event that’s safe for trans people. They simply distance themselves from any criticism, ignore those of us asking what they’re going to do about it, and continue on.</p><p>I will not be at Podcast Movement this year, as a speaker or attendee. I don’t want to support an organization that won’t support me — an organization that <em>didn’t </em>support me. It’s fine if you’re going; I know how fun the event is. But if you were able to purchase tickets without a second thought to your personal safety, take a minute to recognize that privilege.</p><p>If we keep holding podcast industry events that are not safe for trans people, what does that say about our industry?</p><p><em>Addendum:</em></p><p>Cumulus Podcast Network, which hosts The Daily Wire’s Ben Shapiro Show and Matt Walsh Show, is an exhibitor at Podcast Movement Denver. I am very glad I didn’t attend. It was obvious from the moment they apologized to Shapiro and unfollowed me on twitter that this was their game plan — continued partnership with Cumulus and The Daily Wire.</p><p>This sends a message to speakers and attendees at Podcast Movement. If an exhibitor or sponsor behaves like this (has collaborates attend without a badge, directs fans to harass you during the event, or puts your safety in danger), they will ignore you and invite them back. Money trumps ethics. Fascists welcome.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nLFw2C_RsclNf2Zd3QOYlQ.png" /></figure><p>No thanks.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=254af111751d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Editors’ Response to Rusty Quill’s Statement]]></title>
            <link>https://talminear.medium.com/the-editors-response-to-rusty-quill-s-statement-57c9485f9ac2?source=rss-31b66a653b20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/57c9485f9ac2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rusty-quill]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[workers-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[audiodrama]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[audio-fiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tal Minear]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Jan 2023 04:23:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-27T16:00:24.025Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A Research, Opinion, and Advocacy Piece by Wil Williams and Tal Minear</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Bt-HCK5kiUo6jg1oslv1Ig.png" /></figure><p>On December 11th, 2022, podcaster and journalist Newton “Newt” Schottelkotte published “Who’s Afraid of Alex J. Newall?: The Layoffs, Lapses, and Lessons of Rusty Quill” on their <a href="https://medium.com/@newtschott/whos-afraid-of-alex-j-newall-ae3a67f3a5e1">Medium blog</a>. The piece was edited by Tal Minear and Wil Williams, the two authors of this follow-up piece — more on us shortly. The piece discussed alleged mismanagement at podcast network Rusty Quill, ranging from intense non-disclosure agreements (NDAs), to missed payments, to a culture of neglect towards employees, freelancers, and volunteers.</p><p>Newt’s research involved interviews with several individuals affiliated with Rusty Quill. The draft was reviewed by attorneys before publication. Copies of documents were procured from multiple sources for analysis and fact-checking. The draft was also reviewed by labor organizers and others familiar with contracts in podcasting and similar industries. And, of course, it was reviewed by us, Tal Minear and Wil Williams, known veterans of audio reporting, both of whom are also involved in labor organizing in the independent fiction audio industry.</p><p>Our goal in publishing this piece was simple: we wanted to give those affected by the alleged culture of Rusty Quill a voice they did not previously have due to restraints like the aforementioned NDAs and fear of retribution or industry blacklisting. Our audience was fellow audio industry professionals, given the piece was focused on labor rights. It was not focused on individuals, and Rusty Quill was consistently given an assumption of good faith, with the blame put on unexpectedly rapid growth instead of malice. However, after the publication of the piece, all three contributors to the piece faced harassment from fans — especially Newt, who was consistently misgendered. On December 13, 2022, Rusty Quill issued <a href="https://rustyquill.com/2022/12/13/public-response-to-an-opinion-piece/">a response</a>, which began by calling the piece “what appears to be a case of carefully timed, deliberate defamation from people seeking to exploit recent hardships for our staff possibly to sabotage our fundraising and reputation.”</p><p>What follows is our response to that statement and the events following the initial piece. This update is written by Tal Minear and Wil Williams only. Responses may be directed to us, via the email addresses we have supplied in the initial piece. We will not tolerate harassment on any platform. We owe no platforming to attacks. We owe none of our time on our personal social media platforms to anyone with whom we do not wish to interact.</p><h3>Who we are</h3><h4>Tal</h4><p>Let me introduce myself. I’m Tal Minear, a fiction podcast producer. I’ve been a creator in this space for over 5 years now, and I do a lot of things across audio fiction. Recently, I designed the cover art for <a href="https://afflictedaudio.com/"><em>Afflicted</em></a><em> </em>(distributed by Rusty Quill). I’m not going to name everything I’ve made here, because it’d take a while, but you can find most of what I do with a simple search. Most relevantly, I edited the article by Newt. I was part of interviews with 10 people and heard story after story of alleged mistreatment by Rusty Quill. If you read the piece, you know a few of them — but it’s different getting the first-hand story. I didn’t have to take Newt’s word for it.</p><p>As with the initial piece, we’ll only be sharing what we’ve been told in the hopes that readers can form their own conclusions. While most quotes are anonymous, they are not fabricated. My motive is, and always has been, to give a voice to those who have been silenced and to call out what I feel are poor labor practices in the field I work in. I don’t own a company; my podcasts are produced independently and distributed by a third party. I have nothing to gain from Rusty Quill’s demise, nor do I wish for it. I simply want creators to have the information they need to not be taken advantage of.</p><h4>Wil</h4><p>I’m Wil Williams, a professional podcaster and writer. Like Tal, I’ve been in the podcasting industry for some time, formally entering the space in 2016 — and like Tal, I wear many hats. I have written on podcasts for publications like <em>Vulture</em> and <em>Polygon</em>. I’ve discussed podcasts on NPR programs several times. I was the managing editor for Discover Pods, a blog dedicated to podcasts, before being laid off during a buyout. I’m the CEO of Hug House Productions, a podcast collective, and the showrunner for a fiction podcast. I do not see my work in any competition with Rusty Quill — more on this later — but it certainly has informed my concept of what a healthy workplace can look like in audio.</p><p>For my entire career, I have championed fiction podcasts in a journalistic landscape that continually writes them off. Each time I am given an opportunity to speak on podcasting, I try to put the focus on fiction podcasts, especially those created and produced independently of major production houses. This includes the several times I have written glowingly on Rusty Quill original <em>The Magnus Archives</em>, as well as recently discussing <em>Afflicted</em> on KQED’s <em>Forum</em>. I have continually uplifted and supported Rusty Quill. I am even quoted on Rusty Quill’s own <a href="https://rustyquill.com/reviews/">“Reviews and Press” page</a>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*s_eTb_ZX0KLa0JPV" /></figure><p>However, I have also continually advocated for better labor conditions in audio as a matter of ethics, philosophy, and principle. My support of Rusty Quill does not mean I can turn a blind eye to reports from multiple sources. I will make it no mystery that I am greatly disappointed by what is alleged in these reports. I will not soften my stance in the face of Rusty Quill’s response, let alone the response of the company’s fans, who were never the intended audience of the initial piece (and are not the intended audience of this piece). This project has nothing to do with what is and is not a good podcast. This project is about trying to understand and illuminate the working conditions for real people in an industry I have worked in for just about as long as Rusty Quill itself.</p><h3>Journalistic standards and ethics</h3><p>A few quick notes on what “makes” a journalist: there is no such thing as journalistic “accreditation.” Journalism is an industry, a field of work, that can be entered through various methods. Journalism is facilitated, but not preceded necessarily, by a journalism degree; the two are not synonymous. Journalism is, ultimately, a job, and a journalist is a person who does the act of journalism. Every person who worked on this piece does journalism and is a journalist, and we are all known within the podcasting industry — again, our specific demographic — for our work.</p><p>There also seems to be some confusion about Medium as a platform. Medium is a blogging platform akin to WordPress: anyone can start and host a blog on Medium, and Medium will host whatever is posted within the lines of their terms and services. There seems to be some confusion about whether the piece was shopped to other publications, so to clarify: it was not. This article was never intended for publication at a mainstream media network, primarily because it became quickly apparent that its length would be well over a standard article length. Newt chose, instead, to simply publish on their Medium account, and we have also done so with this response.</p><p>And, now, on the discussion of journalistic objectivity versus accuracy. Journalists are people, and every person has a specific lens, perspective, and set of biases that inform their reporting. You can read more on this philosophy in a <a href="https://discoverpods.com/anti-racist-open-letter-public-media/">2021 piece</a> edited by Wil Williams for <em>Discover Pods</em>, “Over 200 Audio Professionals Sign Anti-Racist Open Letter to Public Media”:</p><p>The letter ends with sections on the transformation of coverage and accountability, particularly “<a href="https://www.npr.org/2020/06/09/873172499/the-debate-over-objectivity-in-journalism">ending the pursuit of objectivity</a>,” a journalistic standard that upholds white supremacist and oppressive structures in the newsroom and in the media. It is why the coverage on the insurrection at the Capitol looks so different from coverage of the Black Lives Matter protests in the summer of 2020. Journalistic objectivity is a standard that actively prevents people from telling the truth, as happened to Lewis Wallace with<a href="https://medium.com/@lewispants/objectivity-is-dead-and-im-okay-with-it-7fd2b4b5c58f"> this article</a> that led to his firing from <em>Marketplace</em> in 2017.</p><p>We agree with this philosophy. You can also read more about it at the following sources:</p><ul><li><a href="https://thecorrespondent.com/6138/why-objective-journalism-is-a-misleading-and-dangerous-illusion/157316940-eb6c348e">“Why objective journalism is a misleading and dangerous illusion</a>,” Rob Wijnberg, <em>The Correspondent</em>, 2017</li><li><a href="https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/V/bo29172094.html"><em>The View from Somewhere: Undoing the Myth of Journalistic Objectivity</em></a>, Lewis Raven Wallace, The University of Chicago Press, 2019</li><li><a href="https://niemanreports.org/articles/herschel-walker-nina-totenberg-objectivity/">“Journalistic Objectivity Is Overrated. What Really Matters Is Transparency, Accuracy, and Fairness</a>,” Isaac J. Bailey, <em>Neiman Reports</em>, 2022</li><li><a href="https://current.org/2021/09/seeking-objectivity-in-journalism-is-getting-in-the-way-of-speaking-truth/?wallit_nosession=1">“Seeking objectivity in journalism is getting in the way of speaking truth</a>,” Celeste Headlee, <em>Current</em>, 2021</li><li><a href="https://nationalpress.org/topic/objectivity-journalism-new-norms-debate/">“Objectivity in Journalism: New Norms Under Debate</a>,” Kathleen McElroy, National Press Foundation, 2022</li></ul><p>In regards to criticism of our unnamed sources, the fear that most sources expressed in their unwillingness to be named was one of our main points in the article. Regardless, it is a very common practice to release a piece with preliminary findings of an investigation to find additional sources. This was one of our goals with the initial piece. Because our investigation led us to allegations of a workplace with rigorous NDAs (with the expectation that they would be enforced), publishing a piece with such initial findings was an obvious and common method to garner trust and empower additional sources to reach out to us. This is what happened. Our sources were unnamed to protect them from the legal and workplace ramifications of discussing alleged workplace practices prohibited by the NDA agreements. Our goal is to advocate for workers, and naming them would implicate them, which has legal ramifications due to the NDA agreements we addressed in the piece.</p><p>In their response, Rusty Quill wrote, “We cannot however, accept this level of unprofessional misinformation made at the expense of our colleagues and clients, regardless of whether it was well-intentioned or not. Such actions are wildly irresponsible and damaging, not just to Rusty Quill but our whole industry, as it discredits legitimate journalism in the space.” We disagree. To claim that Rusty Quill is bettering the industry, the company needs to agree to be the subject of criticism in public. We will address Rusty Quill’s claims of misinformation in a later section. We believe that Rusty Quill and all others are entitled to their opinion regarding what makes journalism “legitimate”; however, we hope this section has elucidated the very common journalistic practices and ethics applied to the initial piece.</p><h3>Labor and competition in audio drama</h3><h4>Labor</h4><p>Let’s discuss what we mean by the terms “labor” and, in a moment, “competition.” In regards to labor, we can use this simple definition from Kimberly Amadeo via <a href="https://www.thebalancemoney.com/labor-definition-types-and-how-it-affects-the-economy-3305859"><em>The Balance</em></a>: “Labor is the amount of physical, mental, and social effort used to produce goods and services in an economy.”</p><p>Every person who contributes any amount of physical, mental, and/or social effort toward a podcast is providing labor for that podcast. The authors of this piece believe that every person who contributes labor — whether an employee or a contractor, more below — is entitled to a fair, healthy, and equitable workplace; communication and transparency from their coworkers and colleagues, including their superiors; and compensation for that labor commensurate to the scope of their labor and experience, as well as the scope and budget of the podcast and any organization producing that podcast.</p><p>This does not mean we demand every actor get paid SAG wages, or that volunteer projects should not be allowed in the podcasting space. This means, instead, that if anyone is being paid, everyone doing that same role should be paid, and that pay should make logical sense for the amount of labor expected, the quality of labor delivered, and the amount of funds within the project’s budget. If a project’s budget, therefore, is $0, it would make sense that everyone is being paid $0.</p><p>Everyone involved in this piece and the original piece are members of the WGAE Audio Alliance and are demonstrably pro-union and pro-laborer. This piece is not affiliated with the WGAE Audio Alliance; however, for clarity and transparency, Tal and Wil are both members of the group’s Organizing Committee. We have signed the <a href="https://www.equalityinaudiopact.co.uk/">Equality in Audio Pact</a>, which has also been signed by Rusty Quill Ltd. While the contributors to this piece and the original piece are all residents of the United States, we have also researched labor rights in the UK, where Rusty Quill is based — both for this piece and for our labor advocacy work overall.</p><h4>Employees vs. Contractors</h4><p>Another important clarification when discussing labor rights is the difference between an “employee” and a “contractor.” A thorough breakdown of the distinctions between these two types of laborers can be found <a href="https://www.acf.hhs.gov/css/training-technical-assistance/whats-difference-between-independent-contractor-and-employee">here</a>, but there are two sections especially pertinent for labor in the podcasting space:</p><ol><li>In regards to employment laws, employees are “covered by a number of federal and state employment and labor laws,” whereas, in many cases, contractors are “not covered by employment and labor laws.”</li><li>In regards to compensation, employees “[earn] either an hourly rate or a salary,” whereas contractors have “[contracts which] may be for a total amount. It could be for an hourly, daily, or weekly amount that ends on a specific date or a total amount to be paid when the job is completed.”</li></ol><p>Most laborers in the audio space are contractors. There’s nothing wrong with this; for most podcasts, contract work makes sense. Contract work allows businesses to offer a set, flat rate of compensation for a specific project to be completed, and that project is typically temporary.</p><p>However, the lack of protections under employment and labor laws mean that contractors (sometimes called 1099 employees) are typically more susceptible to labor exploitation. This has been reported on largely in terms of the “gig economy” across the world, including in <a href="https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20220308-why-gig-work-is-so-hard-to-regulate"><em>BBC</em>’s <em>Worklife</em></a>. Stateside, there have even been monumental court cases, legislation, and initiatives regarding the gig economy, such as <a href="https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2022-12-13/california-prop-22-appeals-court-hearing-weighs-gig-workers-fate">California’s Prop 22</a>, which regarded how delivery and rideshare services classify their laborers.</p><p>We believe that all laborers are equally entitled to fair and equitable workplaces and wages, as stated above. We believe that all laborers are “real” laborers, even though contract workers often do not receive the same legal protections as employees.</p><h4>Competition</h4><p>“Competition” is an interesting concept in the audio space. In regards to physical products sold, competition is usually clear: Pepsi is a competitor to Coke, as both are similar products with slight variations that lead to a preference for one over the other in most consumers. Typically, those consumers will choose one option over the other regularly, making competition an important factor in the business plans of both Pepsi and Coke. You can read more about it <a href="https://www.investopedia.com/articles/markets/081415/comparing-cocacola-and-pepsis-business-models.asp">here</a>.</p><p>This is not true for audio fiction. Audio dramas are not in direct competition with each other. While listeners do have limited time to devote to podcasts, it is understood that audio drama fans are often fans of the medium as a whole versus fans of single specific podcasts. Wil and Tal have discussed this — see this <a href="https://discoverpods.com/how-to-audio-drama-getting-lost-noise/">advice column</a> by Wil Williams, for example, in which they write:</p><p>“Remember that people are still being brought into the world of podcasts to begin with. Your friends’ success means that they’re bringing more people to the medium, which means more potential listeners for you! Your friends’ success will help your medium’s success overall, which will, by proxy, help you succeed.”</p><p>None of the podcasts by the original piece’s contributors view themselves in competition with any Rusty Quill property. We feel that we are in <em>community</em> with them. We are <em>colleagues</em> with them. The reason our disclosure, now at the top of the initial article, wasn’t immediately given is that none of us considered ourselves in competition with Rusty Quill. Once we noted that the missing disclosure was a potential issue, we added it promptly.</p><h3>Thanks, Corrections, and Clarifications</h3><p>There were statements in Rusty Quill’s response that we feel were inaccurate. But before we touch on those, a few things we’re happy about. Quotes from Rusty Quill’s response will be bolded and put in quotes for clarity.</p><p><strong>“We use a basic Microsoft Teams package for coordination, which is a standard professional package, and monitor shifts and timekeeping using a basic Sling package. Both of these are considered the most cost-effective options at our scale given their functionality.”</strong></p><p>This makes sense, and we agree that these packages seem to make sense for Rusty Quill. We appreciate the clarification.</p><p><strong>“It is worth noting at this point that to our understanding, the duplicated Spotify feed alluded to in the article was believed to pre-date anyone joining the RQ Network, and the claims of lost listenership seem to be conflated with a transition from a non-IAB certified host to Acast’s IAB 2.1 certification. This transition would result in large numbers of historic false downloads being discounted from metrics as unreliable.”</strong></p><p>We are thrilled to hear that this seeming lapse in listenership was due to switching to an IAB-certified host. This is a terrific change, and we’re glad to hear Rusty Quill was proactive in making sure their host was in compliance. Considering the former data unreliable makes sense and is prudent.</p><p><strong>“It is standard procedure for producers to factor in pickups for recordings and for producers to be provided with our Standard Operating Procedures so they can help with equipment setup if needed. Having heard that these procedures may not have been observed, we have begun a complete check of our production processes to ensure no such issues occur with future productions.”</strong></p><p>We are glad to hear Rusty Quill is taking measures to ensure this protocol moving forward.</p><p><strong>“It is true that our website was out of date following these consultations as we have been required to hold making alterations until our redundancy process was complete in accordance with UK HR best practice. It is since updated.”</strong></p><p>We are glad to hear the website has been updated accordingly.</p><p><strong>“We at Rusty Quill are committed to working for the betterment of everyone we associate with and have worked tirelessly towards this goal.”</strong></p><p>We thank Rusty Quill for this commitment.</p><p><strong>“Since we began business operations in 2015, there have been a couple of instances where Rusty Quill has been unable to fulfil an advertisement due to reasonable business complications. In every instance the advertiser was offered (and accepted) a replacement or refund of equivalent or better monetary value.”</strong></p><p>We are glad to hear this.</p><p><strong>“Producers were informed that they should not contact show staff as a company representative once they had been served their notice as this is considered HR best practice and ensures GDPR requirements are met.”</strong></p><p>We are glad that Rusty Quill is complying with GDPR requirements. We wrote, “Producers were no longer allowed to contact show staff, leading to actors emailing them asking for updates and receiving no response” to question why someone still employed with Rusty Quill had not messaged these actors to provide updated contact information. This would have prevented producers who had been served their notice and actors left out of the loop from being in this position. We apologize for unintentionally implying that these producers should have been allowed to email their actors; we feel that a <em>current </em>company representative should have promptly emailed show staff.</p><p>A correction we would also like to make involves this quote from one producer, which said: “An observation has been made to me that there’s a very good chance that the list on Kickstarter of stretch goal guest writers may be the totality of the people in the audio fiction indie world that have still not had an experience with Rusty Quill.” It should have read: “An observation has been made to me that there’s a very good chance that the list on Kickstarter of stretch goal guest writers may be the totality of the people in the audio fiction indie world that have still not had <strong>[a negative]</strong> experience with Rusty Quill.” The context of this conversion was about bad experiences, not experiences in general. This was on us as editors for not catching that, for which we apologize. It is public information that writers on Kickstarter have worked with the company before, and the quoted producer was aware of this.</p><p>And finally, we’d like to apologize to those network members who expressed that they felt spoken for, as the intent of the piece was to highlight and share the reality of those who had bad experiences. We celebrate each story from a network member about their positive experiences with Rusty Quill. We did not intend to speak for or over these positive experiences, and we love to hear about all positive workplace experiences in the audio industry.</p><h3>Responses and rebuttals</h3><h4>Our “fundraising projects”</h4><p>In its response, Rusty Quill said, “Two out of the three of the contributors appear to be involved in fundraising projects running at the point of publication, and the article actively encourages people to pull support from <em>The Magnus Protocol</em> in favour of other creators.” This is incorrect. Only Tal was remotely involved in a fundraising project (they are a voice actor in the second season of <em>Transmission Folklore</em>). While they were involved with the podcast, they were not involved in <em>fundraising </em>for it. The <em>Transmission Folklore</em> campaign ended 2 days after the article’s publication and did not hit its full goal. Tal would have been paid $146 at the end of the campaign. We do not feel the article increased that rate by any amount, but in a show of good faith, Tal has requested that the showrunners keep their pay.</p><p>Other shows funding at this time that we knew about were <em>The Sheridan Tapes</em>, <em>Apollyon</em>, <em>Shadows at the Door</em>, and <em>Before the Tone</em>. None of us are currently involved with these podcasts. Furthermore, the article does not request that people pull their pledges from the Kickstarter to support other shows’ crowdfunding. Tal has run a <a href="https://twitter.com/podfunds">Twitter</a> that amplifies audio drama crowdfunding campaigns since July 2021. They are consistently promoting audio drama crowdfunding, never implying that one should be supported over another. This instance is no different.</p><p>Lastly, the implication that crowdfunding is a zero-sum game between Rusty Quill and the contributors to the original piece, or that there could be a reasonable expectation that a pledge withdrawn from <em>The Magnus Protocol</em> would end up being given to any particular project is speculative fiction unworthy of any of the relevant parties.</p><h4>Financial and reputational “sabotage”</h4><p>Rusty Quill alleged, “we are being forced to defend ourselves from what appears to be a case of carefully timed, deliberate defamation from people seeking to exploit recent hardships for our staff possibly to sabotage our fundraising and reputation,” a claim we would like to address in this section.</p><p>In this <a href="https://passerkirbius.tumblr.com/post/703586760054145024/what-do-you-think-about-the-timing-of-the-article">Tumblr post</a>, podcaster Lee Davis-Thalbourne writes:</p><blockquote>Releasing [the article] in the last week is probably the point where it was gonna do the least damage — If someone wanted to really hurt Rusty Quill’s chances of success, you’d release something like this in the first week, when people are already looking up Rusty Quill, when the buzz about the project is at it’s [sp] height.</blockquote><p>We agree with his observation. To our knowledge, this Kickstarter had more money pledged to it than the <em>combined </em>total of every other audio fiction crowdfunding campaign in the last five years. This is not merely a guess; we have been keeping track of over 100 campaigns since 2018, and the total is approximately <a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1cvVyM9fOcJxSvTAvySl5fEXdPh_-vfAW99z36t7zIWE/edit?usp=sharing">$528,000</a>. The Kickstarter had raised over this amount well before the article’s publication, and we did not anticipate that to change — we’ve both crowdfunded before, and we’re familiar with the buzz of a campaign’s initial launch. Accusations of an intent to financially sabotage Rusty Quill are false, and regardless, any money lost by the Kickstarter was rapidly regained.</p><p>During the month of the article’s publication, Rusty Quill gained followers on <a href="https://socialblade.com/twitter/user/therustyquill">Twitter</a> and subscribers on <a href="https://socialblade.com/youtube/channel/UCAfn5ahWLpQmCIN7D0E1YQg">Youtube</a>. 11,215 fans gave money to <em>The Magnus Protocol </em>before the Kickstarter closed. To our knowledge, nobody has stopped working with the company because of the article. Accusations of an intent to reputationally sabotage Rusty Quill are false, and regardless, no sabotage was done. We have friends and collaborators that work with Rusty Quill, and we want the best for them and their work.</p><h4>Industry standards</h4><p>Rusty Quill said, “Our company wide flat pro-rata rate is £13.25 per hour for all staff including leadership, but this excludes creators who are paid separate rates as industry standard. It is true that freelance editors would expect a higher rate, but this pay is competitive in the UK for people holding permanent positions that also offer additional support.” We’d like to elaborate on industry standard payments for sound designers to clarify why we (and others) believe that industry standard sound work should, in almost all cases, be paid more than £13.25.</p><p>The post-production branch of the UK Union BECTU published this <a href="https://members.bectu.org.uk/advice-resources/library/2966">rate card</a> for 2022–2023. These rate cards are updated annually, and the union encourages workers to stick to these minimums whether they are union members or not. The day rate for a sound designer on a microbudget (below £850K) episodic production is £340, which comes out to a £37.78 minimum hourly rate. BECTU is the UK’s media and entertainment trade union. Sectors they cover include “broadcasting, film, independent production, theatre and the arts, IT and telecoms, live events, leisure and digital media,” which include audio drama. It should be noted that these figures are recommended minimum rates “which you should get the first time you work at that particular grade.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/932/0*HIl33qVnhvkFPEem" /></figure><p><a href="https://airmedia.org/">AIR</a>’s 2021 <a href="https://airmedia.org/tools/2021-rate-guide">rate guide</a> said “Our sample size for sound design wasn’t sufficient to estimate separate rates for sound designers. Some of the sound designers we interviewed do both sound design and engineering, and their rates are described in the engineering section above.” This engineering section concluded “Independent engineers who are early in their career or still building a portfolio cited hourly rates in the $75–125 range [£60-£100 as of Jan 2023], while experienced engineers reported rates of $150–200 [£120-£160] per hour or day rates commensurate with that range.” AIR also provides a <a href="https://airmedia.org/tools/sample-budget-audio-fiction">sample budget for audio fiction</a> based on a 45-minute drama for the BBC by an independent production company. £20,000 is a typical budget for a BBC fiction production, so this sample budget works with that constraint. £500 per day is allotted for a “post production engineer” (assumed to be doing both sound design and the audio mix). This gives an hourly rate of approximately £55.</p><p>Trace Callahan, sound designer for <em>This Planet Needs a Name</em>, said:</p><blockquote>£13.25 (currently $15.79 [at the time of this interview]) for skilled, delicate work that requires insight, practice, precision, artistry, and a high degree of care makes absolutely no sense to me. Whether you look at it as an art, or a skilled profession it’s still so far below what the level of work you’re expecting merits that it’s insulting. In creative media with picture (games, film, etc) junior and entry level positions out there pay more than twice this amount, and in Audio Fiction the sound designer is asked to provide more, to replace what picture would provide and make it feel, not like a lack, but like a bonus that you’re experiencing things through audio alone.</blockquote><h4>Network partners</h4><p>Rusty Quill wrote, “In terms of network partners, the allegations seem to be made by a single former creator on the network who left some time ago and another who is not, nor ever has been, a network partner.” This is inaccurate; we spoke with several sources. However, we will not be revealing with whom we spoke, as everyone has requested anonymity.</p><p>Rusty Quill also wrote, “We do not forbid network shows from promo swaps, crossovers with other podcasts, or live shows as the article claims, though we do request consultation regarding such so that we can ensure no accidental competition and similar concerns.” We can confirm that in one case, in the instance of a promo swap, this is reportedly inaccurate based on screenshotted emails from a source. It was the basis for the following statement in the initial piece: “At one point, a creator wanted to run a promotion for a podcast which contained language that some might read as explicit, but was told Acast wouldn’t allow it: ‘I called Acast, and they said they would allow the ad. Then Callum said I couldn’t air it anyway.” It is worth reiterating that the article only ever claimed one instance of this occurring (quoted above), and does not say that Rusty Quill forbids promo swaps, crossovers, or live shows in general. We are happy to hear they do not.</p><p>It is also worth noting that “cherry-picked” sections of the distribution contract were shared out of a desire to not publish an entire confidential document. However, we provided the contract to a lawyer who read it in full and confirmed that our readings of the individual sections were a fair interpretation of the wording within the context of the full document. It would be inaccurate to say that commentary on the contract sections was made based solely on the clauses included in the article. If Rusty Quill feels that the contract has been taken out of context, we invite them to share the full clauses they feel were misrepresented or the document in full. Our analysis would not change.</p><h4>The numbers</h4><p>Rusty Quill wrote, “The claim that a show would require 125,000 downloads on the network in order to make $1000 is completely false.” While our reporting was accurate as far as what our source reported, we have been able to gather additional information that paints a more nuanced picture since the article’s publication.</p><p>We were able to obtain monthly statements from multiple creators on the Rusty Quill network. These statements do not account for all creators on the Rusty Quill network, and no reader should assume they are to be. They covered 14 separate shows and were taken from the fall of 2022. The average GBP per ad impression across these shows was .00315, after Rusty Quill’s 50% cut. This means that one would make £315 per 100,000 ad impressions (or the more common industry standard term, a £3.15 CPM). As this was calculated from the <em>average </em>rate, it is possible that creators would need slightly more or slightly fewer ad impressions to make this amount. It is also worth noting that ad impressions do not correlate one-to-one with downloads.</p><p>Using the above CPM averaged from 14 shows on the Rusty Quill Network, it appears that with 125,000 ad impressions the shows we got data from would make £393.75 (or $485.58 using January’s conversion rate). If a show had multiple ad impressions per download, this revenue could increase. Three ads per show, at those rates, would indeed cross that threshold. However, for shows with only one ad per download, our reporting and our source would be correct. It’s also possible that other shows have higher ad revenue, and that there are additional revenue opportunities beyond these ads. In those cases, Rusty Quill could be correct.</p><p>A data point from Tal: my average USD per ad impression, taken from one month in fall 2022, was .0114 after my distributor’s cut. I would have made $1,140 on 100,000 ad impressions (or £924 using January’s conversion rate, giving a £9.24 CPM ). This was averaged from three shows and also varies slightly from month to month. I hesitate to include data from what has been accused of being a rival network, but I feel that including my own experience here is important. A creator making a third of what I make from ads with the same impressions is alarming to me. Fluctuations from network to network are to be expected, but the magnitude of difference is why I have included my own data here. There could very well be good reasons for this discrepancy, but without that context, I find it to be a red flag. The showrunners I spoke to did not know any reason why these numbers should be so different, and I hope Rusty Quill may be able to provide more information.</p><h4>The transcripts</h4><p>In response to the statement, “Rusty Quill’s [transcripts] are riddled with errors, inconsistent, incomplete, and generally a poor representation of the show’s audio,” Rusty Quill wrote “In terms of our transcripts, these are historic allegations that are now factually untrue. All our official, original transcripts have been generated by paid professionals.” We have never disputed that paid professionals generated the transcripts, only that they are not fully accurate.</p><p>Franzi, a professional in the language service industry, alleged in a <a href="https://franzis-frantic-thoughts.tumblr.com/post/703469864933900288/professional-linguists-should-only-ever-work-in">public Tumblr post</a> in December 2022 that several transcripts still included typos and errors. In February 2022, she and another person contacted the company about transcript issues. Their email, which includes screenshots of transcript errors, can be read <a href="https://www.tumblr.com/franzis-frantic-thoughts/703459344094724096/whos-afraid-of-alex-j-newall-by-newt?source=share&amp;_branch_match_id=1088170494533879604&amp;_branch_referrer=H4sIAAAAAAAAAxXIQQ6AIAwF0RPVhp3xNkWBYkAMfIJ6enU1L6PA2RZmwYSebarTWjL7KscTG%2F1FXAlaelA0HloaybfjRsWTJHfRTocbkhLZ%2Bxf4NO5xPgjMrC85TT1mYAAAAA%3D%3D">here</a>. Such errors included “Many spelling and grammar errors… Misspelling of player and character names and misattribution of lines…. [and] Listing of content warnings is inconsistent, if present at all.” According to Franzi, the bulk of issues were present in <em>Rusty Quill Gaming</em> transcripts, but not limited to the one show. And if she emailed Rusty Quill about these issues in February of last year, Rusty Quill has known about them for almost a year and has not corrected them in this time.</p><p>One example of inaccurate transcripts can be found in the screenshot below, taken from page 14 of <em>Rusty Quill Gaming</em>’s episode 187 <a href="https://rustyquillcom.sharepoint.com/Shared%20Documents/Forms/AllItems.aspx?ga=1&amp;id=%2FShared%20Documents%2FRusty%20Quill%20Public%20Access%2FTranscripts%2FRusty%20Quill%20Gaming%2FRQG%20PDF%2FSeason%204%2F1734480%20%28CD%29%20RQG%20187%20It%20Tolls%20for%20Tree%2Dconverted%2Epdf&amp;viewid=585e2cf0%2Dc969%2D4847%2Dad54%2D2302c335d0a1&amp;parent=%2FShared%20Documents%2FRusty%20Quill%20Public%20Access%2FTranscripts%2FRusty%20Quill%20Gaming%2FRQG%20PDF%2FSeason%204">transcript</a> in January 2023. Dialogue was not included due to it being unclear, which hinders readability. It should also be noted that there is no <em>Rusty Quill Gaming</em> cast member named “Adam,” and no characters named “Summit and Neil”. These should read “ALEX” and “Sumutnyerl” respectively instead.</p><p>The blue highlights in these screenshots were not added by us; they are present in the published, official documents. This may indicate that these transcripts were works in progress from the supplier, who completed as much as possible but needed clarification from Rusty Quill on a few details. Whatever the situation was, it should be clear to Rusty Quill that the published transcripts are, in some cases, incomplete.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/615/0*a3uNx6hhQorgl8Az" /></figure><p>One example of missing content warnings can be found in the screenshot below, taken from page 1 of Rusty Quill Gaming’s episode 217 <a href="https://rustyquillcom.sharepoint.com/Shared%20Documents/Forms/AllItems.aspx?ga=1&amp;id=%2FShared%20Documents%2FRusty%20Quill%20Public%20Access%2FTranscripts%2FRusty%20Quill%20Gaming%2FRQG%20PDF%2FSeason%204%2F1772983%20%28CD%29%20RQG%20217%20Last%20Stand%2Dconverted%2Epdf&amp;viewid=585e2cf0%2Dc969%2D4847%2Dad54%2D2302c335d0a1&amp;parent=%2FShared%20Documents%2FRusty%20Quill%20Public%20Access%2FTranscripts%2FRusty%20Quill%20Gaming%2FRQG%20PDF%2FSeason%204">transcript</a> in January 2023. The content warnings are listed in the <a href="https://open.spotify.com/episode/43RLFouELj0wK3ZG1eeBjR">show notes</a> (and youtube <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WYTPExaAQjs">episode description</a>), though do still seem to be missing from the <a href="https://rqg.fandom.com/wiki/RQG_217_-_Last_Stand">RQG Wiki</a>. However, according to Franzi, the Wiki is fanmade and not affiliated with the company. The fans behind the RQG Wiki do not have a responsibility to update the content warnings on the site. This raises the question: why are the official transcripts referring to this fanmade wiki? Had they referenced the official show notes, the content warnings would be available.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/0*MGKNIiZQpInGbW-o" /></figure><p>Given that the examples pointed out by Franzi are still present, we agree with the statement that the transcripts are “generally a poor representation of the show’s audio.” Franzi also brings up that Rusty Quill’s feedback form is not easily accessible “as it isn’t linked anywhere <em>near </em>the transcripts, but only in the<a href="https://href.li/?https://rustyquill.com/2022/01/26/rusty-quill-launches-a-brand-new-website/"> 26 January 2022 “news” update</a>.” As of January 2023, <em>Trice Forgotten</em> is also not listed as an option to provide <a href="https://forms.office.com/pages/responsepage.aspx?id=BdOYuKEs7EenjH_Z34zhjyKBQok_3bJCiXDJKFHczWxUMzREUkJNRjk2TUQ3WjhLWVFBM1gxTlUwQy4u">transcript feedback</a> on.</p><h4>Workplace culture</h4><p>Rusty Quill said, “Our most recent formal Employee Satisfaction Survey, which was conducted by an independent third party, found our scores to be ‘exceptional’ and these were shared internally. Furthermore, we have already internally released a 2023 Operations Update which included factual information on related topics including recent redundancies and our plans for the future. This update is due for public release in the new year.”</p><p>While we look forward to the public release of the 2023 Operations Update, we have several questions about the Employee Satisfaction Survey. When, how, and by whom was this survey conducted? How many responses were received? A former contractor of Rusty Quill, hired during Fall 2021 as a producer for a new production and let go a year later, said:</p><blockquote>I was never sent an RQ employment satisfaction survey during my time there and don’t personally know anyone who was, so it must have been before or after my time there. The only time they checked in on how I was doing overall with my satisfaction toward the company was verbally, during my probation meeting around the 3 month mark.</blockquote><p>If the survey was allegedly not sent to a producer on a Rusty Quill original, someone on company payroll who was listed on the website, then to whom was it sent? If the survey was sent a year before the September layoffs or in the months after, how accurate are the responses? Did the survey also go to network members and/or freelance contractors? The lack of information about this survey prevents it from being a reliable source, in our opinion. We are truly happy to hear that the experiences of the individuals we spoke to are not shared across the company. However, it is possible that one person can have a difficult time at their job while someone else has a great time. 20 people could have negative experiences with Rusty Quill while 20 other people have a wonderful time working with the company. The existence of positive testimonies does not nullify alleged mistreatment of others (or vice versa).</p><p>Rusty Quill wrote, “We have donated more than one hundred thousand pounds to charitable causes, pushed for increased diversity in front and behind the microphone, and constantly work to support and upskill new people joining our industry.” This response is irrelevant to the claims we relay in our article. We have never questioned Rusty Quill’s charitable donations, nor their push for diversity and support in the industry — in fact, we commend it. However, this does not make any statements from sources who claim to have been mistreated untrue.</p><p>Rusty Quill also wrote, “The only employees who have ever not been paid for work in our history are leadership members who, unprompted, kindly volunteered to postpone a month’s wages in order to further delay redundancies for other staff.” We spoke to three contractors, anonymous per their requests, who reported not being paid for various work.</p><p>And finally, Rusty Quill also wrote, “the company has no history of ‘financial failings’ nor ‘worker exploitation’ as is alluded to in” the article. For the former, we were referencing the <a href="https://graphtreon.com/creator/rustyquill">steady decline of Patreon earnings</a> since April 2021, which is public data. Between April 26, 2021, and August 22, 2022 (this date was chosen as the last data point before Rusty Quill’s stats were set to private), Rusty Quill lost 3,119 patrons. Rusty Quill’s own admission that leadership members “volunteered to postpone a month’s wages in order to further delay redundancies for other staff” could be said to indicate a financial failure, as well. What constitutes a “financial failing” is an opinion. We have shared ours.</p><p>The history of worker exploitation can arguably be found in the story of the unpaid Discord mods. The Equality in Audio pact, signed by Rusty Quill as of at least <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20201204110507/https://www.equalityinaudiopact.co.uk/signed-by">December 4, 2020</a>, says “Using unpaid labour to help run your business not only restricts who is able to work within audio but it also can be viewed as exploitative.” At its peak, this Rusty Quill Official Discord had about 15,000 members according to the mods, and reportedly was a central part of community engagement. Because there were channels exclusively for patrons, this Discord may have contributed to Rusty Quill’s income, and it could be said that those running the Discord were helping Rusty Quill with their business. Outside of Patreon emails, the moderators we spoke to said, from their own experiences, that the Discord acted like Rusty Quill’s primary method of getting information out to the community.</p><h4>The Discord</h4><p>After the publication of Newt’s official piece, we were advised by previous members of the Rusty Quill Official Discord server (a hybrid between a large group chat and a forum) to investigate the goings-on in the server before it was closed. As such, we reached out to some of the server’s former moderators to discuss their experiences with Rusty Quill and the server. We were not members of the server, and our discussion in this section is informed by interviews with those moderators. Allegations of racism have been made towards the entire team of moderators — not just the sources we communicated with — and the server itself. Many of the rules that garnered complaint seem to have come not from the moderators themselves, but from Rusty Quill; however, we understand the gray lines between the different levels of power at play in regards to this situation. We wish to give these moderators space to share their experiences. We do not condone racism of any kind, and we are actively committed to anti-racist efforts in our work.</p><p>We spoke to three former moderators (mods); two requested anonymity, but the third, Brinn Anza, was willing to go on the record. These mods said that they knew the position would be unpaid before joining, and initially had no problems with it. However, as one of them summarized, “We were told on various occasions that they wanted to pay us in some non-monetary way, varying from merch to paying for professional training, but none of that ever came through in the two years I was modding.” Many of the moderators received “an endless parade of suggestions and ‘we’re working on this’ and ‘we’d like to do this’ [from Rusty Quill] and nothing ever materialized.” Allegedly, Rusty Quill may have compensated some of their UK-based mods with a gift of beer, but US-based mods received nothing. The moderators we spoke to all emphasized that the issue was not that they weren’t compensated, but that they were reportedly <em>lied to</em> about being compensated, repeatedly.</p><p>Rusty Quill also wouldn’t provide mods with patron-exclusive content, even though “there was an assumption that [moderators] knew the content being discussed.” Brinn said:</p><blockquote>The early access channels were the busy channels that needed a lot of moderation. You had to know what was going on in order to effectively moderate the conversation. Not having access to the content hogtied you for that. Allowing access to the paywalled stuff to the mod team without having to pay for it would have been an easy thing [for Rusty Quill] to do.</blockquote><p>The content behind the paywall of Rusty Quill’s Patreon was vital for several aspects of the moderators’ job, and they weren’t provided access to it without paying out of their own pocket. One mod said, “If you needed to moderate a discussion about Patreon-only content you’d need to have paid for the Patreon to be able to do your job.” These former moderators alleged that Rusty Quill “really did not like giving us information. Not even just ahead of time, but complete information [at all]. How are you supposed to moderate conversations about things when you don’t know what is going on?”</p><p>When Rusty Quill announced their network, they reportedly gave Discord moderators very little notice, despite the direct impact it would have on the server. “We got zero info and zero answers,” a mod said, adding that the mod team gave Rusty Quill a list of questions they anticipated people in the server would have, only to be told that people in the server with questions could just email Rusty Quill.</p><p>This was unsatisfactory because, in the words of one mod:</p><blockquote>Emailing RQ was largely seen as about as valuable as writing a letter and handing it to a passing carrier pigeon in terms of getting any kind of timely response, or indeed any response at all. ‘Email RQ’ meant ‘you’re not getting an answer’ and everyone knew it.</blockquote><p>The mods reported feeling frustrated about the whole situation. “We had people from the network shows joining the Discord and we had absolutely no idea what to do with them,” one added. This alleged lack of information or communication from higher-ups was said to be a trend throughout these moderators’ time.</p><p>One moderator said:</p><blockquote>The mods volunteered when the Discord was far smaller, maybe 2,000 people. After the massive rise in TMA’s popularity, we really struggled to get new mods approved, so we were massively understaffed. By the end, the Discord was at 15,000 people and we still had very little support.</blockquote><p>Despite being understaffed, the moderators said it was difficult to add new mods to the team because the volunteers “did not have the control or ability to hire them.” The mods expressed that they were always talking about adding new members to their team and even had specific people in mind. However, getting Rusty Quill to approve additional moderators was said to be nearly impossible. “It grew so fast, and we needed help and we could not get it,” said one mod. “There was a year and a half where we were going ‘what about more mods?’” added another. “We wanted more diversity and better representation [in the moderator team] and it never materialized.”</p><p>The moderators said, “We had no power to deal with the people who were actually stirring shit up… no authority to do literally anything except tell people off and ban [spam bots].” One added, “We were caught between the astonishingly sharp vitriol of Discord members and the endless apathy of anybody with actual authority to do anything.” Rusty Quill’s higher-ups were allegedly not in the Discord server to see what was happening, “but also they did not listen to us when we told them what was going on.” As a whole, the moderators reported that they were left on their own to act on behalf of a company that, according to at least one mod, seemed to refuse to give them the time of day.</p><p>One mod said of their experience:</p><blockquote>The rules [of the server] weren’t completely vague, but what was less clear cut was how genuinely empowered we were to enforce them and what was an appropriate escalation of consequence. We were told we had the authority to enforce server rules but had ultimately minimal support from [the company] when there was pushback. It was very much working in a vacuum.</blockquote><p>Another recalled:</p><blockquote>We had pretty much no way of dealing with repeat offenders until they did something really egregious, by which point the damage would be already done. It also meant that when we were being harassed by server members we pretty much just had to take it.</blockquote><p>One instance that brought ire towards the mods was when the initialism “<a href="https://www.gq.com/story/history-of-acab">ACAB</a>” was banned from the server. The moderators we spoke to said “that decision came from above us” and that they had to enforce it regardless of their personal opinions. Brinn added:</p><blockquote>We did not write the server rules. We did not have any say in the server rules. Anyone who’s spoken to me for more than thirty seconds knows I am a noted cop and landlord hater and enforcing rules that I did not write does not mean I agreed with the sentiment.</blockquote><p>The moderators described multiple instances of not being able to remove problematic server members, even as those people’s actions caused others to become uncomfortable and leave. Brinn said, “We were hamstrung on several levels. People could get away with saying racist shit and we wouldn’t be able to ban them.” Some moderators left allegedly because of how they were treated by server members.</p><p>At this point it is important for us to highlight that enforcing racist rules and regulations is something we are taught to do, through our upbringing and existence in society. It is not anti-racist to implement and enforce those rules, even if one feels they have no other choice and especially if one benefits from white supremacy. After communicating with these mods and reviewing public information posted by former members of this server, we believe that the moderators should have made different decisions when faced with the directions they were allegedly given. As such, we also believe that their unpaid work in this server resulted in harm both for themselves and the community they were trying to serve.</p><p>The mods we spoke to also wanted to make it clear that “the majority of the server was lovely.” One mod said:</p><blockquote>Up until the last few months it was essentially self-moderation. The community did an amazing job of encouraging the culture of being polite and respectful. It was a really good community and for a really long time, the mods were there not so much to enforce as to encourage. Towards the end is where it got bad.</blockquote><p>When the community manager was let go, the moderators alleged that other employees were told by Rusty Quill not to talk to her. Some of them reportedly reacted by unfriending her on every platform. While the moderators of the Discord were initially not told she had been fired, one of them alleged that Rusty Quill had gone to the moderator of the fan-run Facebook page and told them to remove the former community manager from the page. Many of the moderators said they considered the community manager to be a friend, and seeing this treatment of her made them deeply unhappy.</p><p>“People have the impression we quit because [the community manager] was fired and that is not the case… It’s not just that they fired her, it’s that they were not going to tell us,” said one mod, adding, “That event is what made it clear that we were not valued.” Allegedly, Rusty Quill was “taken aback” when the moderators asked about the situation. After the moderators stepped down, they said “We got ghosting, we got so much passive aggression” from the Rusty Quill team. “I had thought better of them.” Brinn said that when they quit, they received an email from Rusty Quill’s head of HR that deadnamed them. “They don’t value people. They really don’t… They treated some of my very good friends — and me — like garbage.”</p><p>Another said:</p><blockquote>We had faith in RQ and we were happy to do [the moderation job] for free. But over time the utter disregard for us became more and more obvious … they took us for granted and were happy to leave us scrambling in the dark.</blockquote><h3>Final thoughts</h3><p>Two or three people having the experiences we’ve shared is an outlier. Ten to twenty people is, in our opinion, a trend. We’re glad for the positive stories people have shared in the aftermath of our first article, but plenty of unhappy tales came our way as well. Here’s a quote from someone who reached out after the article’s publication:</p><blockquote>Rusty Quill promised a lot more than they could deliver when they took on a small, successful podcast and suggested they’d bring greater success… RQ see no value in the work of audio editors and producers. I count myself very lucky that by seeing my work and contribution to a podcast as completely worthless, simply for not using the same software or methods that they demanded I use, that they never got me on a contract.</blockquote><p>This person requested anonymity, so we are unable to share the full story of their situation, which we verified as true. We also spoke with <a href="https://matt15016.wixsite.com/smidgehurstthornhill">Matthew Hurst</a>, a writer who has done work for the BBC and others. He was willing to go on record about his experience with Rusty Quill:</p><blockquote>I saw linking up with Rusty Quill as a way to get my work in front of more people because they have a huge listener base, and any drama writer just wants to be produced, in the end.</blockquote><blockquote>I’m sure that most of the people at RQ have the best of intentions and are working in what they see as good faith, but they seemed to be expanding so fast their infrastructure couldn’t keep up with the hares they set running. That meant a bunch of delays and falling back on being very controlling about the IP they were dealing with, at the same time as telling the podcast community what a great home they were for creatives. I’ve worked with big broadcasters and production companies and had work commissioned, produced and paid for. I love the development process and I’ve never been precious about it.</blockquote><blockquote>The reality for me with Rusty Quill seemed that as soon as I even asked a few basic, polite questions about their offer they took their ball home. RQ seemed to have the best intentions but were out of their depth. They talked a lot of idealistic aspirations but maybe couldn’t match them with the realities of how successful they wanted to be as a business.</blockquote><p>While Matthew was never an employee, his experience is similar to many of the stories we’ve heard, both before and after the initial article’s publication. We’ve provided these stories to you so that you can form your own conclusions. Ultimately, this entire project was an endeavor to bring to light how individuals have been treated by Rusty Quill. We hope this follow-up article has provided additional clarification, and we’re always happy to hear from more sources. However, we’d like to reiterate that we will not tolerate harassment of ourselves, Rusty Quill and their collaborators, or anyone readers think may have spoken to us.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=57c9485f9ac2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Podcast Feed Drops: A Short Guide]]></title>
            <link>https://talminear.medium.com/podcast-feed-drops-a-short-guide-5773bb6496f2?source=rss-31b66a653b20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5773bb6496f2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[podcasting-tips]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[podcast]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[podcasting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tal Minear]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 08 Nov 2022 20:24:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-08T20:24:59.577Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M22BrHS8_NqOgGW2jQJoZA.jpeg" /><figcaption>A chicken eating feed that has been dropped on the ground. Get it? There was a feed drop.</figcaption></figure><h4>What is a podcast feed drop?</h4><p>A podcast feed drop is when you drop an episode of another show onto your own RSS feed! Usually this is followed by that podcast dropping an episode of your show on their feed.</p><h4>Why would you do a feed drop?</h4><p>The main reason is cross promo! Audiences from you show discover the show you’ve shared on your feed, and vice versa. Done right, it will bring more people to your podcast!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/680/0*Inz0jAewSGUKkVGj" /><figcaption>A screenshot of the SDITE feed on Spotify, showing a feed drop above a normal episode of the show.</figcaption></figure><h4>How often should you do feed drops?</h4><p>Personally, I stick with one per feed per month (or less). It just feels right for me! But if you’re uploading more frequently than bi-weekly or monthly, a different answer might work for you.</p><p>Some people use feed drops as a “replacement” for a normal episode. Ex: If you’re traveling/sick/busy and can’t meet your normal upload schedule, stick a feed drop in on your standard release date to give your audience something to listen to. But because my shows are fiction, this scenario doesn’t really work for me (<em>in my opinion! it might work for you and your audio drama!</em>). I’ll do feed drops more or less when my heart desires it.</p><h4>How long do you keep a feed drop up?</h4><p>This varies, and might be something you discuss with the person whose podcast you’re sharing! I usually keep mine up for about a month, because I do monthly feed drops and I like having one on the feed at a time. Some people might do a shorter or longer time. For example, sometimes you’ll have a smaller show swapping with a bigger show, and the smaller show will leave the drop on longer to acquire more downloads! As long as you communicate your plan, you can basically do what you want.</p><p>It took me a while to think of an RSS feed as a malleable thing! You’re allowed to delete things. You can rearrange the order of bonus episodes. It doesn’t have to stay static, as you initially uploaded it, forever. So don’t be scared to take a feed drop down after it’s had its time to shine.</p><p>It can also be helpful, at the end of your scheduled feed drop, to let the show know how many downloads they got on your feed.</p><h4>How do you know what shows to do a feed drop with?</h4><p>Pick ones that have something in common with your show! For example, <a href="https://sidequestingpod.com/">Sidequesting</a> is a light hearted fantasy audio drama, so I like to swap with shows that are light hearted, fantasy, kid-friendly, OR have actor overlap!</p><p>But even within audio drama, audiences listen to all sorts of genres, so I wouldn’t discount “fiction” as being a thing in common! I also keep all this in mind for trailer swaps too, not just feed drops.</p><p>But if you’re a non-fiction podcast, don’t be afraid to swap with audio dramas (and vice versa)!</p><h4>How do you find shows to do a feed drop with?</h4><p>Listen to them! Engage with fellow creators! Ask around!</p><h4>How do you approach a show for a feed drop?</h4><p>Ask them nicely! It’s okay to cold-email shows as long as you do it kindly. You might get a no — maybe their show isn’t in a place for feed drops, maybe the creator is too busy to coordinate one, maybe they don’t think you’re a good fit. But it doesn’t hurt to ask! Rejection is just part of the game.</p><h4>When do you know a show isn’t a fit for you?</h4><p>There’s not a good answer for this. It could be a simple as vibes. Personally I make sure not to have “adult” shows on my kid-friendly feed and that’s about as strict as I get.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5773bb6496f2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Inaction is an Action: Moving Forward with Podcast Movement]]></title>
            <link>https://talminear.medium.com/inaction-is-an-action-moving-forward-with-podcast-movement-342f0bc908a7?source=rss-31b66a653b20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/342f0bc908a7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[podcasting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tal Minear]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Sep 2022 04:46:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-27T00:28:09.234Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zNOY4eiXg18ezI81NTMAGQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4>The Background</h4><p>At the most recent Podcast Movement, Ben Shapiro showed up. He didn’t have a badge, but was nonetheless present at the booth for his podcast network, The Daily Wire. This was the first year Podcast Movement had agreed to give the network a booth (at the reported cost of $30k).</p><p>If you’re unfamiliar with the company, The Daily Wire is a conservative American media company founded by Ben Shapiro and Jeremy Boreing that has branched out into the podcast sphere. They are also known for their consistent efforts to dehumanize and degrade queer and transgender people. Shapiro, <a href="https://www.glaad.org/gap/ben-shapiro">among other things</a>, has argued homosexuality should remain in the DSM as a mental illness. Recently, a member of their team, Matt Walsh, attempted to trick trans people into joining his <a href="https://twitter.com/EliErlick/status/1490799028401020932">anti-trans documentary</a>. The Daily Wire is known for creating and spreading misinformation about transgender people (for more information on this disinformation pipeline and how it vilifies trans people, check out <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cya2IyZmZOQ">Jessie Gender’s breakdown on Youtube</a>. For more information on the general Alt-Right Playbook, check out <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wCl33v5969M">this video by Innuendo Studios</a>).</p><p>Here it needs to be said: I am a queer and nonbinary podcaster who uses they/them pronouns. I was attending Podcast Movement both as a speaker and exhibitor; I was on stage each day of the conference and part of a team running a booth in the expo hall. You are getting my personal experience in this piece, and I hope you can respect it.</p><h4>The Event</h4><p>I saw the Daily Wire’s booth on Tuesday evening, August 24, after I had finished setting up my own. I felt that its presence said something — that Podcast Movement had decided their actions were acceptable, or at minimum acceptable enough to give them a booth on the first floor, next to the likes of Paramount, Audible, and Stitcher. I’ll be honest, it sucked to see Podcast Movement endorsing a company that has been actively threatening the livelihood of transgender activists and individuals. I hope it is clear why I wasn’t (<em>and still am not</em>) happy about this booth. I tweeted a picture of it captioned “oh come on” that evening, mostly so that people not attending the conference would know about the booth, and moved on. What else was there to do?</p><h4>The Inciting Incident</h4><p>I even moved on when Shapiro bypassed conference security to take pictures and shake hands at his booth on the 24th. I say “bypassed security” because I want to be clear that he was in an area of the conference where only people with badges were supposed to be, and he did not have one. This was not a public space. This was a Sheraton. When I saw he was there, I took a picture, tweeted directly to Podcast Movement, and shared in a reply that his presence made me feel unsafe and unwelcome. I went back to manning my booth on the lower floor. Shapiro left the conference.</p><p>At the time, I had no idea if he was an invited guest. The presence of The Daily Wire booth implied so, but the lack of any sort of badge implied the opposite. But soon after, I ran into Jared Easley walking around the expo hall, and asked him. Easley is the head of Community and Content, and one of the organizers of the conference. I got confirmation that Shapiro was not invited, but I also got to see firsthand that Easley wasn’t very concerned about it.</p><p>Dan Franks, President of Podcast Movement, messaged me on twitter not long after, confirming what Easley has said. Unlike Easley, Franks did seem concerned. He wrote:</p><blockquote>“We did not know he was attending. There was no badge registered for him or any talent associated with him, and we did not put any of their people on any sessions. Him showing up was the first we knew about it. I know that does not make it right, but I was caught off guard completely by this.”</blockquote><h4>The Aftermath During The Event</h4><p>The next day (August 25), Podcast Movement posted their first apology for Shapiro’s presence. I thanked them, publicly, in the replies of their tweet thread, and went on with my busy day. I took the stage in the afternoon to talk about sound design, then had two pre-scheduled meetings back to back. I did not look at my phone for a long time — not until, after my final meeting, a friend ran (literally ran) up to me, and told me “Libs of TikTok is sharing your tweets. You need to lock your account down.”</p><p>For those unaware, Libs of TikTok is a multi-platform hate account. They’ve had their TikTok, Twitter, and Instagram accounts each temporarily suspended at least once for breaking community guidelines. On Twitter, one such suspension was for “violence, threats or harassment against others based on their sexual orientation or other factors such as race or gender.” Most recently, the account is connected to multiple bomb threats against children’s hospitals that provide gender-affirming care.</p><p>Do you understand why my friend did not simply walk? With them standing next to me, I put my twitter account on private, deleted my bio, and closed DMs. But those hours in which I was offline were significant. I had already accrued hundreds of hateful replies to my tweets about Shapiro. Naturally, these people did not know the situation and did not care to. It didn’t matter that I was an invited guest to this conference, nor did it matter that Shapiro was not. It’s ironic how many times I was told “facts don’t care about your feelings” from a group of people who did not care about the facts, only <em>their </em>feelings.</p><p>I noticed I had been added to lists, some simply titled “idiots”, others which say “accounts to be removed.” You stay on lists even as a private account. I had to ask my friends how to get myself removed. The answer turned out to be blocking the creator, so I did that, 20 different times for 20 different people.</p><p>Later that day, a friend gave me the heads up that the Daily Wire had posted a video that included screenshots of my tweets. This directed more people to my account — those who missed the initial virality of my tweet before I went on private. Not content with merely bothering me, they found anyone replying kindly to my tweets and harassed them too. By the end of the day, many of my friends put their accounts on private. Later, when someone mentions that many queer podcasters have locked their account, they will be met with replies calling them a liar and asking for proof — proof that would necessarily link the accounts of people avoiding harassment. It’s a clear catch 22, and that is what they want.</p><p>I spent that night blocking people on my phone, hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of them. Many had found other tweets I had made from the conference before I went on private. One of them, in which I shared a photo of the pride flag we had hung up at our booth in the expo hall, was a favorite for homophobic replies. On that one, I got called a groomer, pedophile, and spreader of monkeypox. Most of my other tweets faced transphobic and generally hateful comments. I was called a crossdresser, a “gender pretender”, told I would never be a man, and separately, that I would never be a woman. Many favored calling me antisemitic, some picked racist, others went for fascist. Most people used whatever pronoun they thought matched my gender assigned at birth, some used they (<em>the right one!</em>), and many went for “it” in a form of blatant and basic dehumanization. I don’t even remember what Libs of TikTok said, their comment lost among the mob.</p><p>I asked friends online to help me report people. There were too many terrible tweets to link directly, so I told my friends to just search my username. They found plenty of people to report. Twitter will end up taking maybe 5% of the hateful comments down.</p><p>The online harassment continued on August 26. Unable to reply directly to my tweets, people took to simply tagging my username in their tweets. I know they hoped their hateful words would show up in my notifications, but I had changed my twitter settings long ago. I took to periodically searching my username and blocking those people.</p><p>A small part of me was worried that someone would try to harass me in person. Of the thousands of Shapiro fans gleefully posting about me online, were any of them here? A friend walked with me to and from my final time on stage, just in case. This was the only time strangers would know my location. Nothing happened, and I breathed a little easier. I’m sure some would call that cowardly. I call it basic safety.</p><p>Later that day I found out Alex Stein had visited the conference, camera in tow. He doesn’t have a badge either, but he’s been allowed inside. On the <a href="https://twitter.com/alexstein99/status/1562955984456536064?s=20&amp;t=yWygjdL4Elwfptjhkt3PYg">two</a> <a href="https://twitter.com/alexstein99/status/1562950922082275330?s=20&amp;t=yWygjdL4Elwfptjhkt3PYg">videos</a> he tweeted August 25, he shares screenshots of my tweets and heckles attendees and workers at the conference. To me, this is confirmation my fears were warranted. I’m grateful our paths did not cross.</p><p>On Twitter, many were claiming I had single-handedly forced Podcast Movement’s hand. Of course this was not the case — several others talked to Dan Franks, those who had worked with him in ways beyond speaking at his conference. The Daily Wire’s website still says that Podcast Movement’s apology was due to “one person being triggered,” but we’ve already covered how they’re not known for accurate reporting.</p><p>I think here we should review my crime. I, a speaker and attendee at Podcast Movement, shared that someone without a badge at the conference made me feel unwelcome and unsafe. To Ben Shapiro and The Daily Wire, this statement was worth the effort of directing their fans to harass me online (and in at least one case, threaten my life). I said I felt unsafe, and they ran to prove me right.</p><h4>The Aftermath Post-Event</h4><p>The next day, as I traveled home, I got emails with negative Apple Podcast reviews. They called my shows trash, intolerant, and generally terrible. Of course, these weren’t people who had listened to my shows. It was the people discontent with harassing me on a single platform. Before I deleted my bio, it linked to three of my podcasts: Sidequesting, What Will Be Here, and Someone Dies in This Elevator. Guess which three podcasts got review-bombed. Yep. Not Hubris, not Falling Forward, not Light Hearts. I wasn’t entirely surprised. I had already gotten multiple hateful/spammy emails to my business account (one of them was just BEN SHAPIRO written out 50 times), and one “review request” to my newsletter (titled “You Need Help”). I had sort of figured it was a matter of time.</p><p>I got an email from James Cridland of Podnews with a request for comment. I started writing something on the last plane. I finished it the next day, published it on twitter, and sent it to him, along with the <a href="https://wilwilliams.reviews/2022/08/28/too-little-too-late-podcast-movement/">piece</a> Wil Williams had just published.</p><p>Williams had been hit with similar harassment as myself. Reading their article, I found out that Easley had been interacting with the very people harassing me on twitter and validating them. I had no idea of this until I got home. “You are right,” he said, to the same group of people harassing me. I found out some other things about the history of Podcast Movement, but Easley’s words were what stuck with me.</p><h4>But Wait, There’s More</h4><p>On Sunday I am greeted with unexpected and devastating news. You don’t get to know the news, only that it was fully unrelated to podcasting and it leaves me miserable and heartbroken. The next week passes in a haze where I do not care about anything.</p><p>Here’s what was notable:</p><p>On August 30, I change my twitter handle. None of the Shapiro fans notice. They’re still tagging starplanes. I unlock my account.</p><p>On September 2, Podcast Movement unfollows me on twitter. They post:</p><blockquote>“We’re listening to our Podcast Movement community — many who’ve been with us since the start. We’re putting in place policies to guide our social media &amp; events with inclusivity, diversity &amp; respect for all. It’s a journey. We’ll keep listening, keep growing together.”</blockquote><p>It feels like they are not listening.</p><p>On September 3, Joe Rogan chimes in, calling Podcast Movement a cult. This naturally adds fuel to the fire. Cumulus (Daily Wire’s ad rep) pulls their sponsorship of Podcast Movement a few days later, on the 6th.</p><p>September 6 is also the first day nobody tags me in a hateful message on twitter.</p><p>It took two weeks.</p><h4>Give it up for Week Three</h4><p>September 7 is when Podnews joins the fray, over a week after Wil and I had published our pieces, and in time for me to start caring about this situation again. They write:</p><blockquote>“Since the Shapiro thing has resurfaced: Dave Jackson, a member of the Podcast Hall of Fame and podcast consultant, has written his thoughts. After reflection, Podnews has consciously avoided publishing “hot takes” from both sides, but unlike many, <a href="https://schoolofpodcasting.com/who-is-ben-shapiro-and-why-are-people-attacking-podcast-movement/">Dave’s piece</a> is balanced, respectful, and written with humility and curiosity.”</blockquote><p>Personally, I don’t feel that Wil or I’s pieces were hot takes, and I was disappointed to see them called such. They were write ups of our experiences being harassed by Shaprio fans, and our calls for Podcast Movement to improve. Wil’s piece included history of their work with the company. Perhaps we weren’t respectful enough of the organization that platformed a transphobic network, or didn’t have the necessary humility after being called slurs online for half a week. Maybe, by virtue of being queer and nonbinary podcasters, we are assumed to be too invested for a balanced take. Whatever Podnews’ thoughts were, the article they chose to platform was, in my own opinion, simply bad. This article references Wil and I’s writing, but misses the point entirely.</p><p>Dave did not know who Ben Shapiro was until the latter showed up at Podcast Movement. It follows that he’s therefore unaware of The Daily Wire’s consistent attacks on transgender rights or anything I detailed in the second paragraph of this article. I don’t fault him for not knowing, but I do fault his entire piece for being poorly researched. He uses she/her pronouns for me (<em>my twitter bio, website, and medium bio all state I use exclusively they/them pronouns</em>), and misspells Wil’s name. Dave does link <a href="https://www.glaad.org/gap/ben-shapiro">the GLAAD site</a> on Shapiro, and states “When I saw that he has argued homosexuality should remain in the DSM as a mental illness, I could see why people find him offensive.”</p><p>This is as close as he comes to understanding what I was getting at, but fails to make the leap that a conference platforming a man with these views would make queer podcasters feel unwelcome in that space. Dave writes, “It sure sounds like everyone is welcome <em>except Ben Shapiro.</em> If you are inclusive you include everyone.” The fact of the matter is that welcoming hateful people like Shapiro will exclude the marginalized people he attacks. It’s disappointing that Dave read what Shapiro fans said to me online, and still fail to understand that I would not be safe in a room of Shapiro fans.</p><p>Even after reading “my very existence as a marginalized person is inherently political. The only thing a ‘politics free’ space does is form a breeding ground for hate” (in my <a href="https://talminear.medium.com/and-id-do-it-again-f7669a38b4a6">article</a>), Dave asks in his, “So, can we have a ‘Check your politics at the door sign?’”. For many people who are not white, able-bodied, straight, or cisgender, they cannot check their politics at the door because their politics involve demanding basic human dignity and rights. For example, my simple request for Dave to use my correct pronouns was deemed “absurd theater” by a commenter on his article. It’s clear that Dave doesn’t understand the experience of marginalized groups. His statement of “I’ve attended MANY podcast conferences and I’ve never heard anyone ask someone to “turn down your queerness.” further reflects this.</p><p>I say this not specifically to tear down Dave’s writing, but to underline that <em>this </em>was the article Podnews chose to send to their 20k subscribers. Not Wil’s article calmly explaining what happened at Podcast Movement, and the steps they should do to improve. Not my piece explaining why I tweeted about Shapiro’s appearance and breaking down the fallout of it. Nothing written by a queer, or trans individual. Nothing written by someone actually impacted by Shapiro’s performance.</p><p>I think it highlights an issue within the podcast industry — taking the stance of “both sides” and maintaining a “neutral image” more often than not silences marginalized voices. There’s a level of tone policing also at play here, where those impacted by the platforming of racist/homophobic/transphobic creators are criticized for being over-emotional or disrespectful in their responses. And thus, it’s the “balanced” responses by people without a stake in the situation that get shared. A cishet white man’s poorly researched article gets sent to thousands of people, and the pieces by nonbinary people don’t. We see this again and again in the podcast industry, and it is a <em>problem</em>.</p><p>Additionally, maintaining a neutral image while platforming The Daily Wire is impossible. When you do this, you’re platforming an organization with a host (Matt Walsh) that has declared “an all out assault on gender ideology” and a founder (Ben Shapiro) that has said being transgender “ is a psychological disorder.” This is not neutral. By platforming them, you are complicit in their active harm of trans people.</p><p>And so you can imagine my disappointment when, on September 8, Podcast Movement deleted the apology they posted during the conference. They tweeted:</p><blockquote>“As we stated, we’re continuing to evaluate our policies guiding social media &amp; events with inclusivity, diversity &amp; respect for all. We have to start by sincerely apologizing to Mr. Shapiro for our reaction when he visited a booth we sold his company. That wasn’t right.”</blockquote><p>In my perspective, they are apologizing to a man who put my tweets in a video for his company, twitter handle and all, and directed his followers to harass me. They have said the experience I’ve laid out for you in this article is acceptable. Exhibitors at Podcast Movement can encourage the harassment of Podcast Movement speakers online, and it’s fine.</p><p>Wil and I have been left out to dry by Podcast Movement. Since the direct messages we received from Dan Franks at Dallas, neither of us have been spoken to. The closest thing to direct correspondence we’ve received was Podcast Movement unfollowing us on twitter. Unlike The Daily Wire, I don’t need an apology. I simply need to know what they plan to do moving forward. But it seems like they’re hoping we’ll forget about it.</p><p>Us and everyone else.</p><h4>Where do we go from here?</h4><p>On September 23, Podcast Movement sent out a standard marketing email about Evolutions. It was reported they were going to meet with The Daily Wire on the 14th, but if they did, nothing has been said about it. There was no mention of this debacle, no statement on how they’re moving forward. I waited nearly a month to publish this article in the hopes it would have a satisfying conclusion, but alas, we don’t know what their game plan is.</p><p>People aren’t going to forget, though.</p><p>At minimum, without knowing if Podcast Movement will be actually checking badges at their next event, I don’t feel safe attending. Some of you will say this is overblown, but you don’t get to have an opinion unless you’ve gotten death threats too. Regardless, if Podcast Movement is platforming the Daily Wire again, I won’t be there. You can’t support transgender speakers at your event and give floor space to a company attacking them. In turn, I will not be supporting you.</p><p>The actions Podcast Movement takes before their next event in March will make it clear if their support is and has been performative, or if they genuinely value diversity and inclusion. They still have a chance to do the right thing. I hope they take it.</p><p><em>ps. If you are unkind in the replies of this article I will remove your comments.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=342f0bc908a7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[And I’d Do It Again]]></title>
            <link>https://talminear.medium.com/and-id-do-it-again-f7669a38b4a6?source=rss-31b66a653b20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f7669a38b4a6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tal Minear]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 31 Aug 2022 04:00:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-10T04:27:02.568Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*ItoxY_kGS-27uhX7" /><figcaption>ALT: A sign that reads “GET USED TO IT” in white letters on a board with the progress flag painted in the background. It’s held by two people who appear to be at marching at a protest.</figcaption></figure><p>I think it’s probably accurate to say I’m one of the people most impacted by Shapiro’s appearance at Podcast Movement because I tweeted that he was there and I shared how I felt about it. This thread was, of course, widely spread around out of context by Shapiro’s fans, who took to gleeful name calling, attempted doxing, and efforts to harm my podcasting career. <br> <br> That being said,<strong> I’d do it again in a heartbeat.</strong> And let’s talk about why.</p><p>When I saw him in the expo space, I wanted to know immediately if he was an invited guest of Podcast Movement. Why is that different than Daily Wire being an invited guest? A fine line, absolutely, but the former provides a much stronger rallying point for Shapiro’s fan base. I know this because I tweeted about the Daily Wire Booth (captioned “oh come on”), and got no traction. I tweeted about Shapiro (captioned “hey Podcast Movement what the fuck”) and had to lock my Twitter for safety. The line is formed by Shapiro’s fans. On one side I am ignored. On the other side, I am threatened.<br> <br> Let me say — it was a relief to know that Shapiro wasn’t invited by Podcast Movement, that a team I respected hadn’t gone out of their way to platform a man who believes I have a mental illness for being nonbinary. It was bad that the Daily Wire had a booth, but it was good that they were not on stage.<br> <br> I was on stage every day of the conference. I am working hard to carve out a place in this industry for people like myself — people who are not cisgender, straight, white, men. I’ve chosen to use whatever ounce of power I have in this space to fight tooth and nail to make it inclusive. Because here’s the thing — my very existence as a marginalized person is inherently political. The only thing a “politics free” space does is form a breeding ground for hate. I refuse to let this industry become that. Not just for me, but for everyone one else.<br> <br> There’s <a href="https://twitter.com/IamRageSparkle/status/1280891537451343873?s=20&amp;t=avHhkYQYVMaFp_6OJP0qAg">this story</a> about a Nazi bar. The first people who come are friendly and kind. They don’t raise a ruckus. They’re paying customers. You let them in because they seem polite. They bring their friends. Who being their friends. You look around, and suddenly, this is a Nazi bar. <br> <br> This exact scenario is what a no politics, anti-safe space rhetoric brings. <strong>And the people advocating for it know that and want that</strong>.<br> <br> It’s just the Daily Wire booth. Ben Shapiro came for 15 minutes and he was polite. He didn’t have a badge or anything, but his network has a booth so I guess it makes sense. Walking by, I see people shaking his hand. Some of his fans are here this year, and I wonder who’s going to come next? How many of them will there be?<br> <br> Do you follow the allegory? A podcast movement full of Shapiro fans is not a convention I’d feel safe at. Emphasis on <em>FANS</em>. Many people on Twitter have shared that they think I could win a physical altercation with Shapiro, and I don’t doubt it. I didn’t feel unsafe because of his measly frame. I felt unsafe because I knew who would follow him here.<br> <br> It’s the same people on Twitter I spent the second half of the convention blocking. The folks who don’t hesitate to tweet at my collaborators like Realm and Apollo in an attempt to get me fired, the people speculating about what’s in my pants in very graphic detail, and those telling me I shouldn’t leave my house in a way that makes me glad I own literally 7 swords. I cannot safely be in a room with these people. And if Podcast Movement is that room, I cannot safely speak. I am not welcome in that room — this isn’t about feelings, it’s a basic fact. I will not be respected, I will not be granted bodily autonomy, I will not leave unharrased.</p><p>See this <a href="https://twitter.com/macwrites/status/1563201631336148995?s=20&amp;t=gsdlCXpn-FzJ2D9cOouPQw">thread</a> by Mac Rogers that breaks this down in even better words.</p><p>I said Shapiro’s presence made me feel unsafe, and mere hours later, his supporters proved me right with threats. This is the reality of being a marginalized creator in podcasting. I refuse to sit by and let this space insult, harm, and threaten other creators. At the end of the day, I’m a target for them, but it’s not about me. I lock my Twitter and move on with my life. (It needs to be said — I can get away with a lot because I am a white person, and I wholly believe the deluge of harassment I got this week would be 10 times worse otherwise.) <br> <br> But <a href="https://wilwilliams.reviews/2022/08/28/too-little-too-late-podcast-movement/">read the article by Wil Williams</a>. Jared Easley, Head of Community and Content at Podcast Movement, was interacting with the very people harassing me on twitter and validating them. I had no idea of this until I got home. “You are right,” he said, to the very people calling me racist, fascist, an anti-Semite, and “it”. <br> <br><strong> Yikes.</strong><br> <br> I love speaking at Podcast Movement. Taking the stage to talk about sound design on Thursday was the highlight of the conference for me. But will it be physically safe for me to speak next year? To broadcast to all attendees the room I will be in and when? I wish I knew.</p><p>I deeply appreciate that Dan Franks reached out to me before PM posted their apology. I noticed their efforts to shield other creators from harassment by restricting replies and removing tweets. I respect that they’ve stood their ground. I hope all the employees of Podcast Movement (yes even Easley) are doing okay despite the harassment I know they’ve gotten too. I thank the organization for the actions they took, and I believe in their ability to do even better. <br> <br><strong> But I join Wil Williams in their list of demands:</strong><br>- I would love to see Jared Easley removed entirely from Podcast Movement.<br>- I want Podcast Movement to develop statements and policies regarding diversity, equity, and inclusion.<br>- I want them to hire full-time DEI employees.<br>- I want them to develop standards for whose money they take and whose they reject.<br>- I want them to donate the money received from The Daily Wire.<br> <br> Sometimes I’m too much of an optimist — but I think yall can do it. <strong>Build an event I can safely be at, and you’ll have me there.</strong></p><p>And if you don’t? I’ll find another conference to speak at. Or I’ll make my own. I’m not going to stop being queer and nonbinary, I’m not going to stop being a podcaster, and I’m not going to stop pushing this industry in a better direction. Get used to it.</p><p>ps. If you clown in the replies it’s a block. Freedom of speech protects you from the government not from the Tal.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f7669a38b4a6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sound Designs: Interview with C. S. W. of Incarnation Read]]></title>
            <link>https://talminear.medium.com/sound-designs-interview-with-c-s-w-of-incarnation-read-e19b06bcbf3a?source=rss-31b66a653b20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e19b06bcbf3a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[audio-dram]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[horror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sound-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[podcast]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tal Minear]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Aug 2022 16:23:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-22T16:23:19.693Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-nWjYBHQocQkjJbIDFGR8Q.png" /></figure><p>Welcome to the fourth interview of <a href="https://sounddesigns.crd.co/">Sound Designs</a>, monthly blog about audio fiction sound design by Brad Colbroock and Tal Minear. Today we sat down with C. S. W. of <a href="https://www.cswhorror.com/">Incarnation Read</a> to talk horror podcasts, foley creation, and more. We met him earlier this year at Podcast Movement and more or less immediately started interrogating him about his sound design, so it was nice to get a chance to do so a bit more formally. C. S. W. has mastered the art of sound design for horror, and uses amazing distortion of sound in his work. <em>(Note: This interview has been lightly edited for clarity.)</em></p><p><strong>I think something that makes you really unique as a sound designer is that you do all your own foley. So I’m starting with a deceptively simple question: why?</strong></p><blockquote>In the beginning, it came from a few different reasons: For one thing, I didn’t want to have to pay for sound effect royalties etc., and at the time I had no idea what free sound effect databases were (true amateur status). I suppose I knew of the concept, but then there was the other reason: I didn’t want <em>anything</em> in Incarnation Read to sound recognizable, or familiar, or similar to the sound effects you’d find in other shows. I wanted it to be a purely organic, from-the-ground-up production, which was partially indebted to my preference of non-literal sound design. Almost all the sound effects in Incarnation Read I create to be more synesthetic than exact; to create what the event in question <em>feels </em>like, rather than sounds like. Not that I’m knocking the alternative; don’t get me wrong, there are shows that are best treated with literal sound design, but that’s not just how I like to do it.</blockquote><p><strong>I’m curious what your foley room looks like. Do you have a designated box of props, or do you just find stuff around the house that could make the right sound?</strong></p><blockquote>Hate to pull back the curtain, but no such room exists, actually. Mostly it is the latter: finding random objects that have the right weight, size, and timbre for whatever I’m doing. If it’s not exact, I’ll use a plugin or other effects to perfect the sound, which may seem like a cop-out, but to be honest I prefer my sounds to be strange, departed from the original sound, to create that synesthetic effect I mentioned. That’s how I made firework crackles out of a cat toy, and a roulette wheel out of scissors and a grill grate. The only props I keep in my home studio are an electric toothbrush (to create buzzy, fuzzy, distorted sound that are in a lot of episodes, most prominently in the pilot) and a Waterphone, which is an inharmonic stringed instrument that is designed to be dissonant. I used this more in Season 1 than later seasons, but it is used in the opening theme quite a bit.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/794/0*EBsHKAXdRm8bpRFo.jpg" /><figcaption>Picture of a Waterphone, because Tal had to google it. Source: <a href="https://www.etsy.com/shop/TurtleDrums?ref=simple-shop-header-name&amp;listing_id=510392441">TurtleDrums</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>A lot of the sound design in Incarnation Read depends on loud noises distorting as they clip — is there a particular reason you’ve chosen that as your signature style?</strong></p><blockquote>I just can’t resist it. I don’t have it in me to resist it. I like sound design that attacks, overwhelms, creates a sensation as chaotic and disorienting as real life is — and real <em>fear</em> is. In a way, clipping and distortion can be used to create this effect where, just as the speaker or headphones can’t handle the signal properly, nor can the narrator handle the emotional agony of a horror they are experiencing. I was very inspired early on by an experimental rap group called Clipping, who use noise and distortion to create a distinctly dark, violent, and visceral experience. Can I recommend this to a sound designer? Honestly, no; it can turn off listeners very easily and it’s damn hard to balance volume levels. Will I ever be able to kick the habit? Probably not. Don’t be like me, kids.</blockquote><p><strong>Another thing you really like to do which I think works great for horror is to use distorted transients at the beginning of lines. Sometimes it’s a delay, a pitch change, or reverb that only sticks around for a single word or two; how do you decide which lines get this? Do you decide during scripting or sound design?</strong></p><blockquote>I suppose I do that during the scripting process. To be honest, I wasn’t really conscious of doing this until you mentioned it. Any effect on my voice is meant to indicate an inhuman presence, whether it’s the narrator slowly giving into inhuman urges / inner darkness, or something horrific that was never human to begin with. So I suppose that’s where that tendency comes from.</blockquote><p><strong>Incarnation Read goes into a lot of weird places; what sort of plugins and sound design techniques do you like to use to achieve that otherworldly anxiety?</strong></p><blockquote>Strangely enough, I only had 2 plugins to my name up until Episode 25, and one of those plug-ins was TAL Reverb. The other was the Polyverse Manipulator, a very curious plug-in created by an Israeli rave music group called Infected Mushroom. While its interface and most of its presets make it clear that it is designed for hype dance music, its effects on the voice and on diegetic sound can go absolutely monstrous in a way that I just fell in love with. There has yet to be an episode of Incarnation Read that I haven’t used it in. Post-Episode 25, I am a big fan of the Unfiltered Sandman Pro, the Sound Particles Energy Panner, and Neutron Elements by iZotope. Anything that helps me create sounds that externalize the internal terror that I envision, and feel.</blockquote><p>Note from Tal: No sponsorship here, but I feel obligated to link the <a href="https://tal-software.com/">TAL Software</a> that C. S. W. mentioned. TAL Software please sponsor this Tal Sound Designer.</p><p><strong>You work primarily in Ableton, a DAW that is geared more towards music than podcasts (but obviously can be used for both!). What do you find are the advantages working in this program? What keeps you coming back to it?</strong></p><blockquote>I get asked this quite a bit, and to be honest, the answer is pretty simple. All I really knew when starting Incarnation Read was that I wanted to create <em>nuanced</em> sound design, to create a podcast with the same level of sonic density as an album. So, in this mindset, I felt the most appropriate DAW was Ableton, since it was used so much for music, but you must remember: I am ABSOLUTELY untrained in sound design, and so any DAW would have been starting from square one anyway. And that’s my answer to the latter question as well: if I started using a new DAW, I’d have to re-learn quite a bit, and since I started being a sound designer at the same time as I started using Ableton, I have a very intimate relationship with it. It’s very detailed, very nuanced, and very, very versatile. It’s just not very intuitive, at all.</blockquote><p><strong>What advice do you have for sound designers who haven’t worked in the horror genre, but want to? Are there any tips or tricks for creating suspense and terror?</strong></p><blockquote>Horror sound design follows the same principle as good horror storytelling: It’s all about the unknown. If a listener knows what presence is haunting a character, they will cease to fear it, and the horror becomes redundant. Same with sound design: If a listener understands what they are hearing, they will not be afraid of it. On the same token, though, if they have absolutely <em>no </em>idea what they’re hearing, they might just check out and let their ears glaze over. So it’s all about balancing what they recognize about a sound against what they <em>don’t </em>know about it, a little thing we in the horror field call <em>suggestion. </em>As far as tips and tricks, there are a million other ways I could delve into horror philosophy, but the one that matters most is this: Create sounds that scare you. What would scare you if you heard it in your room at night? What would make your blood run like cold sludge in your arteries if you heard it right behind you? Whatever that is, emulate it in your sound design. It will scare people. As with all art, the best way to tell if something will speak to someone else, is to determine if it speaks to you.</blockquote><p>I (Tal) will be seeing C. S. W. this week at yet another Podcast Movement, and I can’t wait to continue the tradition of interrogating him about sound design. He’s just got really good thoughts, okay!</p><p>If you enjoyed this interview, share it! If you’re an audio fiction sound designer who would like to be interviewed, let us know <a href="https://sounddesigns.crd.co/#contact">here</a>! (This blog is on Tal’s Medium page, but it’s a dual effort between <a href="https://twitter.com/starplanes">Tal</a> and <a href="https://twitter.com/HolographicVA">Brad</a>).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e19b06bcbf3a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Let’s Talk About Podcast Press Kits]]></title>
            <link>https://talminear.medium.com/lets-talk-about-podcast-press-kits-22dda8038d07?source=rss-31b66a653b20------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/22dda8038d07</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[press-kit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[podcast]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[podcasting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[audiodrama]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tal Minear]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Aug 2022 19:20:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-19T19:20:36.112Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OhDZjofiJA44nwuTueSj5Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>ALT: A black and white image of a person reading a newspaper</figcaption></figure><h4>Q: What is a press kit?</h4><p>A: It’s a document (and/or page on your website) that contains all the important info about your show.</p><h4>Q: Why?</h4><p>A: It makes it easy for people not familiar with your podcast to learn about it without having to do a lot of searching.</p><p>You’d be surprised at how hard it can be, when researching a podcast, to find such facts as: what genre the show is, is it scripted, who does the sound design, how long are episodes, what is the target audience, what episode to start at, where transcripts can be found… I’ve had to scour a show’s website, show notes, and social media before to collect all the information I needed to write about it.</p><p>As the curator of a newsletter, I spend a lot of time looking at podcast press kits while deciding if I want to feature the show. As a casting director, I spend a lot of time looking at press kits for cast information. As a showrunner, I spend a lot of time looking at press kits to see who is behind a show and where I can follow them. Usually, I don’t know much about a podcast when I’m pulling up their press kit. And as such:</p><p><strong>Assume the reader of your press kit is coming in with no prior knowledge of the show. </strong>Maybe they’re a newsletter curator deciding if they should rec your show. Perhaps they’re a critic wondering if your show should go on a list. Maybe they’re a potential listener! Don’t be scared to include seemingly obvious facts about your show. <strong>The easier you make it for people to find info about your podcast, the more likely they are to share and recommend it.</strong> You should have one, no matter how small your are! Don’t make people email you for it. Having a link that says “press” or “press kit” on the menu of your website would be ideal.</p><p>“But I have an about page!” you say. (It is good to have an about page as well, don’t get me wrong). But does that page have literally everything about your show, such as a short and long description, cover art, selected reviews, links to awards and press coverage, stats and download info, contact info, and so on and so forth?</p><p>It’s okay if you answered no. Most people aren’t coming to your about page for all that info. BUT — people who want to write about your podcast sure are. They need to get their facts right. Hence: press kit.</p><p>If your press kit can be copied and pasted from it will make some people (me) very happy. I’ll occasionally pull info directly from the press kit when recommending a show.</p><h4>Q: What do I include?</h4><p>A: All the facts about your podcast. I’ll list a bunch below.</p><p>Show name &amp; tagline.</p><p>Short description, long description.</p><p>Episode count, episode length. Do you have seasons?</p><p>Where should a first-time listener start?</p><p>Genre &amp; target audience.</p><p>The show rating.</p><p>Important content warnings.</p><p>Is it scripted? Is it fiction?</p><p>Links to social media accounts.</p><p>Link to website.</p><p>Contact email.</p><p>Downloadable cover art.</p><p>Promotional images.</p><p>Where it can be listened to.</p><p>Is it independent? Who is producing it?</p><p>List the cast &amp; crew — ideally, link their websites.</p><p>Don’t forget to list yourself and your roles too!</p><p>When did it launch?</p><p>Include significant audience info &amp; stats, like download milestones.</p><p>Link any press coverage. Mention any awards.</p><p>Include a review or two!</p><p>Do you have transcripts?</p><p>If there is anything significant about your show, mention it! Does it focus on a specific type of representation? Perhaps it was made in 24 hours?<strong> If something sets you apart from other podcasts, mention it.</strong></p><p>And there you have it! Organize the info in whatever way makes the most sense to you. Want a more in-depth explanation of the reasons you need a press kit and what you should include? Check out <a href="https://bellocollective.com/press-play-on-a-podcast-press-kit-c729befb15fd">this article</a> by Elena Fernández Collins and Wil Williams. Want an example of a press kit? Here’s one I made for <a href="https://sidequestingpod.com/#press-kit">Sidequesting</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=22dda8038d07" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>