<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Talya Wintman on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Talya Wintman on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@talyawintman?source=rss-57d296b5b1e8------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 07:58:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@talyawintman/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Evicted in Sheikh Jarrah: When the Courts Fail]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@talyawintman/evicted-in-sheikh-jarrah-when-the-courts-fail-cea258648fba?source=rss-57d296b5b1e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cea258648fba</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Talya Wintman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 26 Aug 2020 04:23:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-03T22:26:00.391Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/310/1*UDNSIHtWq6Sg-yc7d2N9hw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>The following piece was written for <a href="https://vianewsglobal.com/story/evicted-in-jerusalem-when-the-courts-fail">Via News</a>. It was first published January 21, 2020.</p><p>About a mile from where I studied at the Hebrew University, 32 members of the Palestinian Sabbagh family will be forcibly evicted from their home in the neighborhood of Sheikh Jarrah.</p><p>Media buzz is absent, at best because it has been a slow burn with the eviction of four other families proceeding over years, and at worst because formal property proceedings provide cover for deep injustice. While Israel’s High Court, the country’s supreme judicial body, closed the door to their appeal last year, ambiguity about what part of the property needed to be vacated has granted the family a temporary freeze. Until then, the Sabbagh family, who have lived in this home over six decades, await a final deadline to move out so that a Jewish family can move in.</p><p>This is happening throughout Palestinian East Jerusalem. In some neighborhoods, Jewish families employ private security guards to protect them from their Palestinian neighbors. They drive in bulletproof cars between their East Jerusalem homes and central West Jerusalem locations. When their families expand, they build additions with municipal permits that are rarely granted if at all to Palestinian families. And when the communities expand, they start the process all over again. This is the Judaization of East Jerusalem.</p><p>Nahalat Shimon, a corporation registered out of Delaware, bought the Sheikh Jarrah property from two Jewish trusts in 2003 with the intent to push Palestinians out of Jerusalem.</p><p>According to the High Court, the Sabbagh’s eviction is a foregone conclusion. There is no equivalent right of return of property for Palestinians who owned homes and land in West Jerusalem or elsewhere inside Israel.</p><p>After 1948, the Sabbagh family uprooted from their original two-family home in Yaffo, were resettled by UNRWA and the Jordanian Government in Sheikh Jarrah. Hence the eviction from their Sheikh Jarrah home would be the second eviction the family has faced to make room for Jewish families.</p><p>Most American Jews I have talked to are dismayed to hear this. They try to litigate the evictions, looking for justification, and when that fails, feign ignorance. It could not possibly just be a land grab on behalf of the settler lobby, they say. The Israeli High Court would strike down the law if it were so egregious.</p><p>This is perhaps true for many Israelis as well. They trust decisions made by the High Court. It is not as though the Court has never made a ruling in favor of Palestinians. Israelis feel reassured that in moments of political short-sightedness, there are rational minds on the High Court to supersede anti-democratic laws. However, this neglects the original function of the High Court, which was to uphold the laws of the Knesset rather than check them.</p><p>While judicial review takes place, it does not have the formal backing of a constitution, and the Human Dignity Basic Law does not contain the word equality in its text. Ostensibly, the court system is designed to uphold the legislative status quo — with a few notable historic exceptions of activist supreme court justices — which by proxy means indefinite military occupation. If political will is to ever change, direct action is necessary.</p><p>Despite the High Court’s ruling on Sheikh Jarrah, continued action is justified. The High Court cannot and is not designed to override property law, however, elected representatives in the legislative body can. Laws are changed through political will, which is created through constituency building and direct action.</p><p>Opposing evictions in Sheikh Jarrah is not a blanket condemnation of the Court, it’s an acknowledgment of where the power lies, and it is essential to the democratic process. Especially when judicial checks are insufficient.</p><p>The government can block these land grabs and limit the funding supporting them on the grounds of public safety and the use of land for public purposes.</p><p>Former Attorney General Michael Ben-Yair, whose own family was forced to leave Sheikh Jarrah and relocate to Katamon, when speaking publicly at the home of the Shamasneh family during their eviction proceedings in 2017 said, “If the Israeli government would have acted decently toward all its residents, including you [the Arab residents], it would have appropriated the properties in the neighborhood [from their Jewish owners who lived there before the War of Independence] and given these properties to the Palestinians who live there today….The current Israeli law that enables double compensation only for Jews for [lost] properties in east Jerusalem from the times before 1948 is unjust.”</p><p>Since 2009, when Nahalat Shimon removed three Palestinian families from their homes in Sheikh Jarrah, Israelis and internationals have banded together, holding demonstrations in the neighborhood every Friday, which continue to this day.</p><p>These efforts have successfully held off evictions until most recently in 2017 with the Shamasneh family, and with the Sabbagh family next.</p><p>Exposing the truth and changing public opinion, both in Israel and in the American Jewish community where much of the funding originates, is imperative. Perhaps more useful and productive than fighting Israel’s delegitimization is fighting for justice with the end of evictions and demolitions once and for all.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cea258648fba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The COVID19 Pandemic Exposes the Shortcomings of Jewish Philanthropy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@talyawintman/the-covid19-pandemic-exposes-the-shortcomings-of-jewish-philanthropy-8df7640ffb33?source=rss-57d296b5b1e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8df7640ffb33</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[judaism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philanthropy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Talya Wintman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 May 2020 01:40:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-15T13:39:34.137Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/460/1*1OC-G8i-IUnM4uA0mfmXmg@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>In May of 1958, Martin Luther King, Jr. addressed the American Jewish Congress (AJC) at the National Biennial Convention in Miami Beach. In the two years preceding the speech, white supremacists had bombed more than 40 Black homes and institutions. The Jewish community – except for a minority of McCarthy-tainted leftists – remained utterly silent. Until the late 1950s they embodied a middle way politik that sought to appease anti-communists fighting desegregation while nominally supporting anti-racists fighting white supremacy. Then in March 1958, white supremacists bombed the school-wing of Miami’s temple Beth El, enraging the community and exposing the hollowness of their middle-way. In King’s speech a few months later, he rebuked the “quasi-liberalism” which had “developed a high blood pressure of words and an anemia of deeds.” King chose not to out the quasi-liberals that evening. Instead he appealed to a common victimhood narrative, linking the fight against fascism abroad with the domestic struggle against racism. Maybe this was a mistake. More than a half century of liberalism and survivalist politics later, one wonders if our communal institutions are any less white, or any less anemic in deeds.</p><p>Today, many are just beginning to reckon with the explicit and implicit state violence against Black and brown bodies. If there is anything the COVID-19 pandemic has reinforced, it is that the health and economic toll of a global pandemic are not shared equally between white communities and communities of color, that America’s racial capitalism has produced a racialized class order, and that any sort of structural change to this system requires material reparations. For white Jews, it means taking responsibility for the white supremacy that has festered within Jewish communal life for far too long, obscured by our blue voting streak, elegant waxing on racial justice, and a handful of cherry-picked Jewish civil rights leaders that defied elders to commit acts of civil disobedience. The community transformation required of us will be challenging. However, reassessing how we aggregate and allocate community funds would be a meaningful place to start. Simply put, our local federations should support the broader local communities in which they are situated.</p><p>In April, seven Jewish foundations, in coordination with the Jewish Federations of North America, launched an $80-million relief fund for Jewish nonprofits in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, reinvigorating conversation on charitable giving in the Jewish world and its distribution priorities. Many young progressives have long rejected Jewish communal institutions, a casualty of our culture war over Israel. This fall, when the New Israel Fund launched their own donor advised fund (DAF) (a private philanthropic savings account managed by a public charity and privy to a host of tax deductions) it was seen as a welcome addition to the Jewish philanthropic landscape. It is an open secret that most federations maintain stringent red lines on DAF recommendations to Palestinian solidarity organizations. However, the biggest problem facing the Jewish philanthropic world today is not merely transparency or the steady trickle of tax-exempt dollars over the Green Line. Our communal institutions’ race and class problem strikes deeper than tacit support for Israeli occupation; it directly impacts the communities in which we’re embedded. The current pandemic impresses upon us the value of immediate relief, and reminds us that local needs are often paramount in a global crisis.</p><p>As historian Lila Corwin Berman has scrupulously documented, the idea of the charitable endowment in perpetuity has not always been a fixture of the American financial landscape. Following the 1969 Tax Reform Act, private foundations faced increased scrutiny and financial penalties. To help community foundations avoid increased taxes and payout minimums, the IRS allowed foundations to reclassify themselves as public charities. Jewish federations were among the first community foundations to apply for the public charity loophole. Private donors could then move their charitable funds under the auspices of federations to gain tax deductions and avoid payout minimums. By 2015, DAFs around the nation totaled $80 billion.</p><p>For every dollar in tax deduction, there is no guarantee that the dollar sitting in a DAF will be circulated quickly into the economy. According to the Congressional Research Service, more than 70 percent of DAF-sponsoring organizations (organizations that offer DAFs) paid out less than 5 percent of DAF funds per year, and more than half paid nothing. Still, by subsidizing these charitable gifts, the federal government has changed the way Americans think about generosity and what types of giving deserve our praise. Stocks and property put into a DAF circumvent capital gains taxes completely. In 2016, the nation’s top 0.5 percent of earners, meaning individuals making $1 million or more, represented half of all tax dollars deducted due to charitable gifts in New York State.</p><p>Our local federations should support the broader local communities in which they are situated. The receding social safety net and the resurgence of white nationalism has not only affected those in our own direct Jewish world, but also those in the broader communities in which we’re embedded as diaspora Jews. But more critically, and perhaps more difficult to acknowledge, is that the private wealth that built our community foundations is impossible to disentangle from the racial dynamics of capitalist class formation in America.</p><p>The first Jewish federated charities were created to respond to the influx of Jewish immigration at the turn of the century. Given their fundraising structure, they were destined for a more elitist bent than the eastern European landsmanshaftn (hometown societies) for mutual aid, recreation, and socialist politics. By the turn of the century the federation movement had established itself in Boston, Cincinnati, Baltimore, San Francisco, and Pittsburgh, among other cities. In New York, landsmanshaftn were eventually overtaken by wealthier German Jews uptown as part of the Kehillah, an institutional precursor to the Joint Distribution Committee and federations. But often federations’ community mandates were used to enforce a racially and economically myopic vision of Jewish identity. In 1913, at a National Conference of Jewish Charities meeting, the future vice president of the Federation of Jewish Philanthropies in New York, Maurice Hexter, lamented “the psychic and psychological difference” between the European and Levantine Jew. Similarly, the Kehillah, under the leadership of Judah Magnes, refused to assist Levantine Jews in creating their own communal organisation and Ladino newspaper.</p><p>These internal conflicts are part of our communal history, but are less coherent, and certainly less comfortable than the story of American Jewish political identity that white Ashkenazi Jews tell ourselves. As the Miami Jewish community’s response to white-supremacist violence illustrated in the 1950s, white Jews’ adoption of American liberalism and their upward mobility often came at a cost to Black-Jewish solidarity. But additionally, as anthropologist Karen Brodkin has argued, accepting a myth that “Jews pulled themselves up by their own bootstraps” without federal assistance through programs like the GI Bill damns us to a present where a generational racial wealth gap “seems to maintain itself ‘naturally,’ even after legal segregation ended.”</p><p>Eventually, many Jews left American cities for suburbs, often divesting community funds from public welfare projects like hospitals that were no longer serving the immediate Jewish community. As white Jews accumulated greater wealth, Hebrew schools and summer camps won out over organizations addressing urban poverty, and we employed new financial instruments to avoid taxes. The lost tax revenue came at a cost to the larger cities we lived in.</p><p>We are loathe to air these communal politics publicly; and rightly so, for fear of inciting antisemitic tropes or disparaging the real generosity of American Jews. We struggle to reconcile the Jew as both the oppressed and the oppressor: this prized and conflicted identity of the upper-middle-class Ashkenazi Jew, mired in contradictions and blind to its whiteness and privilege. But for the sake of our survival, both existentially and spiritually, we must.</p><p>There is no immediate fix for tax subsidies supporting wealth held in perpetuity inside DAFs, but in the short term we can focus on the mission and goals of the funds we hold as a community. Funds subsidized by the American taxpayer through charitable deductions should be democratized and reach individuals most hurt by our receding social safety net. Local community foundations can take up the mantle on their own if they choose to ratify new bylaws around transparency and in support of racial and economic justice.</p><p>To expand Jewish communal funds’ benefits beyond our own children and grandchildren and the 501(c)(3)s that serve them, we could start by reconciling the particularism and universalism of our tradition and covenant. Survival is sustained through community organizing and the coalitions we build within the broader community, not philanthropic silos. Instead of burying political differences under federations’ “apolitical” mandates and BDS litmus tests, we need to air these tensions in the open. If we are serious about racial and economic justice, we must center the voices of small local nonprofits, people of color, and the broader communities in which we are situated, and we must do so inside of our endowment meetings.</p><p>It is through these coalitions that we build localized support networks to protect each other when our government does not. Through these networks – practicing outside the shadow of mega-donors’ economic largesse – Americans learn to practice democracy. While we will not be able to solve the wealth inequality inherent to our philanthropic institutions overnight, we can start by thinking more intentionally about power and who gets to make decisions.</p><p>By painting our internal racism and classism as external issues for the national consciousness rather than our own, white Jews own up to neither. Reforming Jewish philanthropy begins with the acknowledgement that white Jews profit from systemic racism. Systemic racism undergirds the financial instruments that have allowed us to amass wealth at the cost of the communities in which we’re embedded. But it cannot end with this acknowledgement alone. To act requires more than over-wrought prosing on Jewish values and the political panaceas of tikkun olam. As the late Reform Rabbi Arnold Jacob Wolf said, the world is not the only thing that needs repair. So do we. And so do our institutions.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8df7640ffb33" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Life at the Hebrew University: French Hill and the Ghettoization of Issawiya]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@talyawintman/life-at-the-hebrew-university-french-hill-and-the-ghettoization-of-issawiya-3759efa9b787?source=rss-57d296b5b1e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3759efa9b787</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[apartheid]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[israel-palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jerusalem]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[exchange]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Talya Wintman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Mar 2020 17:26:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-15T17:26:52.226Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This piece was originally published on Facebook on July 20, 2019, and subsequently featured on Free Jerusalem.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/285/1*0zIH_YqgByMzf062N55-VQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’ve been here for nearly twelve months, mostly in the Student Village. Twelve months that is on לוחמי הגטאות (Lohamei HaGetaot) the Ghetto Warriors street, on a stretch of land between the neighborhoods of French Hill and Mount Scopus, the ring neighborhoods. It’s nothing more than a street name, but it’s disconcerting- what I’ve come to understand as “affirmative justice.” An attempt to remedy the historic wrongs done to our people.</p><p>Most Israelis don’t come to these parts unless passing through the University. Otherwise, there’s not much else around, and it feels eerie. That’s what I usually hear from Israelis I’m bumming a ride from back to the village. “What do you do here, anyway?”</p><p>The closest neighborhoods outside French Hill are Wadi Joz, Shuafat, Issawiya (east Jerusalem). Living in the student village, you are virtually surrounded by these neighborhoods. You are living in east Jerusalem. But the University teaches day one at the security orientation that these are all no-gos.</p><p>It is possible to go about your day and never interact with these places. We play coy. We smile at the janitors in the hallway, the folks collecting trash in the University. We erect roadblocks, employ separate bus systems; we take the long way home.</p><p>But take a left past the Student Village and follow the road to the gas station until Lohamei Hagetaot intersects with Ha Khayil Street. It shouldn’t take more that four minutes by foot to reach the unmarked road entering Issawiya.</p><p>The village is without the tidiness one comes to expect in “other” parts of the city, without the municipal resources, infrastructure, or masterplans afforded these “other” parts. This fall, there was a teachers’ strike when there were not enough classrooms for students to begin school. Despite this, to live in Issawiya is not to go unnoticed. It’s a life of constant surveillance. The lack of resources is not an oversight.</p><p>Most cars are stopped on the way down to the village from the gas station road. It’s been like this for the past month, but it is not new either. Border police wait by the gas station, ID-ing folks. Each car is inspected and ticketed for minor violations. This is one of two entrances to the village — the others are only accessible by foot.</p><p>In the past few weeks, I’ve been doing monitoring shifts in Issawiya with several Israeli activist groups from across the city, in an attempt to mitigate potential police violence. I wonder what the drafted migavnikim, border police, think. If they want to be there, and if they are scared. I have a choice to be at the gas station; they don’t. We hear someone shout צבע אדום, (RED)! A group of Palestinian teens makes eye contact with an Ethiopian Border Police officer, and the teens start laughing. They had poured red paint on him the other day during a regular incursion into the village, and the video had gone viral on Palestinian media outlets.</p><p>On the Palestinian bus, I see older men discussing the Ethiopian protests against Police brutality happening across the country — so we don’t live in a vacuum after all. Why am I surprised? Why would I think these protests don’t have implications for Issawiya? And still, it feels so distant.</p><p>On the ground, we see a rubber knob the size of a small fist. This is a גומי (gummy). They sound innocuous enough until someone clarifies for me, it is missing the metal interior. This is a rubber bullet. Harmless gummies for crowd dispersion, that have left people paralyzed.</p><p>During the monitoring shift, we visit the family of Mohammed Samir Obaid, the twenty-year-old boy killed in clashes last month. A group of mostly Israelis, an American. Jews. We speak in Hebrew and offer condolences. A mother in tears. Inconsolable. There is nothing to say that does not feel uncomfortable, not insincere, just superfluous. Every mother that loses a child is a disquieting horror no matter where they live, on which side of the green line. And we let that sink in. Samir is gone. What to say? We want to help however we can. Our presence is appreciated they say, so are our words. But “Where have you been?” All this time, while small children barely old enough for school experience nightly military incursions. What type of childhood is this? What future is in store for these kids?</p><p>Today, the day we visit the family, coincidentally, is the memorial of Mohamed Abu Khdeir’s kidnapping and gruesome murder from Shuafat. We don’t need another Samir the parents say, exhausted under a banner of their dead son, the shahid, the martyr. This banner will be forcibly removed by the authorities a few days later.</p><p>On the way back to the gas station, a Jerusalem police officer stops us, recognizing our Palestinian liaison. He senses who we are and begins making small talk. We don’t mince words when we elucidate the night we had, what we’ve seen. It’s just routine policing, he tells us. We have another patrol going in French Hill, all over the city. It’s no different.</p><p>We shuffle back to our cars and drive back up Lohamei Hagetaot.</p><p>‎#מחוז_ירושלים_הסיפור_האמיתי</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3759efa9b787" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Prelude to Trump’s Peace Plan: Politicizing College Campuses]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@talyawintman/the-prelude-to-trumps-peace-plan-politicizing-college-campuses-60ec5c21f628?source=rss-57d296b5b1e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/60ec5c21f628</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-semitism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Talya Wintman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Feb 2020 00:36:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-18T05:19:10.642Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Through the Looking Glass: Peace as Apartheid and Title VI as its Stooge</h3><h4>The Title VI Complaint Against My University is Part of Trump’s Annexationist Agenda</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*W4h02jxX8kRDJsEk07qv3Q.png" /></figure><p>With the release of the Trump peace plan, if it wasn’t clear already, the two state solution is no more than a platitude — and international activism for Palestinian human and civil rights is more important than ever. However, as a prelude to this politically expedient deal, President Trump announced an executive order which risks conflating Palestinian solidarity activism on college campuses with antisemitism, making it even harder to proceed. I would know, because my own university has been embroiled in a Title VI allegation since December.</p><p>About a month ago, I discovered a Title VI <a href="http://www.thelawfareproject.org/releases/2019/12/19/breaking-lawfare-project-files-ocr-complaint-against-columbia-university-on-behalf-of-jewish-israeli-student-first-since-issuance-of-presidents-executive-order-on-combating-anti-semitism">complaint</a> had been filed against my university with the Department of Education (DOE) by the Lawfare Project, alleging systematic antisemitic discrimination through Palestinian solidarity advocacy at Columbia University. This is the first complaint of its kind since Trump’s December executive order adopting the International Holocaust Remembrance Agency’s (IHRA’s) antisemitism definition — created as a <a href="http://www.timesofisrael.com/the-scholar-who-wrote-the-definition-of-anti-semitism-says-its-been-subverted/">research tool</a> to help measure the prevalence of antisemitic acts in Europe — to Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act.</p><p>I am a Jewish student in a Middle Eastern Studies department. Difficult conversations about Israel-Palestine were a formative part of my college education. The fact that the same conversations would for another student amount to hate speech should speak to the danger of politicizing the IHRA’s broad definition of antisemitism to potentially cut back federal funding from universities.</p><p>With all the news coverage on Trump’s executive order, we’ve paid less attention to the organization that is filing these Title VI complaints, the Lawfare Project. While the Lawfare Project has been intent on fashioning itself as a bipartisan civil rights group, Brooke Goldstein, the organization’s executive director, has a track record far more sinister than her organization’s public image lets on. Goldstein has <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wEIP9giL5pI&amp;feature=emb_title">compared</a> Ilhan Omar to the KKK’s David Duke. She has <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XDYjb_8CVgI&amp;feature=emb_title">linked</a> Huma Abedin to Al Qaeda and the Muslim Brotherhood. She willfully neglects to call out white supremacist antisemitism disseminated from the highest office. Make no mistake, as Goldstein’s regular Fox News appearances with Tucker Carlson make clear, this is not about antisemitism. It’s a culture war.</p><p>Before establishing the Lawfare Project, Brooke Goldstein was director of the legal project at Daniel Pipe’s Middle East Forum (MEF). Pipes, for those unfamiliar, is an American neoconservative pundit. He may split his most notable accolade between Campus Watch, a McCarthyesque listserv on college anti-Israel activism, and his tenure as Rudi Guliani’s advisor for a 2008 presidential bid. At MEF, Goldstein litigated against what she <a href="https://www.thelawfareproject.org/articles/2008/5/19/ithe-next-phase-of-islamist-lawfareibronfaith">described</a> as “Islamist ‘lawfare,’ or the use of Western legal systems to achieve the goals of radical Islam.” Lawfare Project, started in 2010, was the logical next step to advance her work with MEF.</p><p>In my four years at Columbia University following the Trump administration’s <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/11/us/politics/rutgers-jewish-education-civil-rights.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share">crusade</a> <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/19/us/politics/anti-israel-bias-higher-education.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share">against</a> Middle Eastern Studies departments across the country, I’ve come to understand that Department of Education “law-fare” targeting pro-Palestinian activism is not about antisemitism or existential threats to young American Jews. On the contrary, it risks curtailing our most basic civil liberties and diminishing the quality and rigor of our education. These cases seek to exploit Jewish generational trauma as a wedge for the GOP, and in so doing they also present the Israeli electorate with a sense of threat and isolation to justify a brutal military occupation and boost Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s poll numbers.</p><p>American Jews are fearful of persecution and assimilation — not unlike other minority communities — and we often project these fears, as well as our hopes, onto Israel, as an extension of ourselves and our own community. This abstraction of a universalized Israel and Jewish peoplehood under siege pulls at the heartstrings of my grandparents and many in our community. The perceived precariousness of our continuity, our inherited trauma, and our relative success, however, have conscripted us into a culture war that pits right-wing populism against institutions of democracy and learning and has no bearing on the rising tide of antisemitism in our country.</p><p>Despite the outrage, the fuss, and the millions spent by Evangelicals, American Jews, and Israel’s Ministry of Strategic Affairs to fight the Boycott Divest Sanctions movement (BDS) at universities like Columbia, Gilad Erdan, the Member of Knesset charged with running the Israeli ministry fighting Israel’s delegitimization, has <a href="http://www.jpost.com/Israel-News/Politics-And-Diplomacy/Erdan-We-have-a-broad-government-program-to-fight-boycotts-453276">stated</a>, “[BDS] has had no real influence on the State of Israel or its economy.”</p><p>Since the 1970’s, economic boycott of Israel has been <a href="http://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2019/12/11/21010986/trump-executive-order-anti-semitism-college-campus">restricted</a> across the US by the Office of Antiboycott Compliance, augmented by many individual state laws including New York’s 2016 executive order. Even nominal settlement boycotts in Europe have been <a href="http://www.thejc.com/news/world/lawyers-vow-to-fight-ireland-s-illegal-west-bank-boycott-law-1.467051">threatened</a> with legal action. Meanwhile, foreign direct investment in Israel is at an all-time <a href="http://tradingeconomics.com/israel/foreign-direct-investment">high</a>. Israel is engaged in trade with China, Gulf economic rapprochement, and natural gas deals with <a href="http://www.aljazeera.com/ajimpact/israel-begins-exporting-natural-gas-egypt-200115143113330.html">Egypt</a>. All this, while Israel continues to operate with impunity in the occupied territories, regulating whatever exists of a Palestinian civil economy.</p><p>There is something deeper than fighting “delegitimization” that attracts Israeli Public News broadcasters, Lawfare lawyers, and pundits to my college campus. This is about Jewish fear and its exploitation by the right. In the Israel delegitimization debate, we make mountains out of molehills and cynically conflate criticism of Israel as a threat to Jewish peoplehood.</p><p>When Civil Rights cases are brought against campus protests, discussions, and lectures, they serve to increase the perceived threat level. Jews in my community look with alarm, seeing a threat to their children, continuity and whatever tenuous status we’ve achieved in the United States. It’s what keeps my grandfather up at night when he forwards me Algemeimer’s Worst Colleges for Jewish Students ranking, where Columbia, nearly a quarter Jewish and with a joint degree program with the Jewish Theological Seminary, routinely hovers in the top five, or Campus Watch newsletters disparaging my very own professors.</p><p>I would like my community to trust me enough to confront new uncomfortable ideas with me. I would also like the Department of Education to allow me to learn without imposing a paternalistic and overly broad IHRA guideline on my university studies. And finally, I would like to be able to discuss generational trauma with my grandparents, apart from the culture war playing out in Congress, the Department of Education, and on my very own college campus.</p><p>Using restrictions on Palestinian solidarity activism as a stand-in for confronting antisemitism inherent in the white supremacy the United States was built on exposes the hollowness of this administration’s actions. In my eyes, both of these events, curtailing civil liberties on my college campus and disenfranchising Palestinians in <a href="https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/middle-east-peace-plan-will-push-israel-into-apartheid-palestinian-envoy-says-1.8465027">bantustans</a> through Trump’s peace plan, are connected.</p><p>These Title VI complaints reinforce Trump’s cynical plan. They are meant to restrict international solidarity activism in a time when Palestinian and Israeli peace activists need it most. As Trump continues to sow division in our community, we must remember: the nativism and white-supremacy he continues to espouse are part and parcel of the antisemitism targeting us.</p><p>We should all be concerned about cases such as the one at Columbia being brought to the DOE under the guise of a Title VI complaint: for freedom of speech, with the risk of curtailing the intellectual rigor being applied to questions of justice. More than that, we should be concerned about the intractability of an economically and politically unipolar conflict and the restriction on the use of non-violent economic levers and protest. Title VI was designed to fight for an aspirational America of participatory democracy and equal opportunity. This is our collective struggle and responsibility no matter where we are, whether that’s the US or Israel Palestine.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=60ec5c21f628" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Epilogue to Niceness]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@talyawintman/an-epilogue-to-niceness-d41a4f863f28?source=rss-57d296b5b1e8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d41a4f863f28</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consent]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sexual-assault]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Talya Wintman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 24 May 2019 13:14:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-24T13:14:57.202Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gry3845XbZxY0oX2uOcZlw.png" /><figcaption>(Image by author)</figcaption></figure><h4>From the generation that grew up after it was ok for women to want sex, and before the facade of gender equality and sexual agency fell apart.</h4><p>There are two dresses. Sundresses. Short. Loose. Fun and flirty. The kind men ogle at. The first is pink, with small flowers. This was the dress I went home in. The one I washed three times before I could remove his stench. The second, red and black, I wore a week later. This was the dress I slept in overnight at the ER alone on a stretcher, with a high fever, when I feared I had contracted acute HIV.</p><p>After my name, the second most interesting thing about me was his, according to every doctor, nurse, and social worker I interacted with that night. I didn’t reveal that, though they kept asking. But with my fever, a lucid dream emerged where he was not anonymous, where I had exposed him. Then I was discharged, and all I could think about was keeping down 1,000 milligrams of azithromycin.</p><p>I told myself that real rape survivors didn’t initiate casual sex, let alone send their assailant emoji peppered text messages the following week. And so I did not file any charges. I couldn’t imagine a lawyer litigating this in court. It would only be me on trial.</p><p>I am part of the generation that grew up after it was ok for women to want sex, and before the facade of gender equality and sexual agency fell apart.</p><blockquote>We learned consent as a linguistic device reserved for the bedroom, separate from the language of power experienced everywhere else.</blockquote><p>We were convinced we could love our bodies, men could love our bodies, and we could enjoy sex. And when we didn’t, a simple no thank you would do. We didn’t pay attention to power.</p><p>I left for boarding school at age 14 in 2012, the first year of Fourth Wave Feminism. Peers wrote expository pieces on “Free the Nipple” and spent afternoons perched by the living room coffee table painting each other naked. Eventually, I too posed for my body to be developed on black and white film. I walked with a male friend to the woods in the dead of winter, stripped, and lay in the snow. Apparently, people were worried about us. They worried that our wardrobes were becoming self-objectifying and that older boys were exploiting us. We rolled our eyes.</p><p>When I got to university, I joined an extracurricular club teaching health classes in area public schools. I figured if I was qualified enough to teach sex to 15-year-olds, then I had figured it out myself.</p><p>That changed the first day of class, when I had to teach the sexual health unit in front of the math teacher standing in the back of the room, who coincidentally I had met earlier on Tinder. Maybe that’s why nothing ended up happening between us. After nearly an hour of graphic reproductive science, he’d never look at me the same way again.</p><p>In that high school health class, we also talked about informed decision making and consequences. Yes, pregnancy, STIs, and HIV. We also discussed how to talk about sex. How to have a conversation about what you want and what you need. The dialogues we used though were formulaic. John wants to have sex, but Jill is scared. She doesn’t think she’s ready. What does Jill say?</p><p>I’d walk between the desks reviewing the students’ responses. Most were light, humorous even.</p><p>“No thanks”, “I’m gonna take a pass”, and “There’s no way in hell I’m having sex with you, John.”</p><p>Ok, I saw some good answers. I particularly liked, “I’m not feeling this, John.”</p><p>If Jill does not want to have sex, she can tell John, “No thanks John! I really like you, but I’m not ready to have sex.”</p><p>I continue with the dialogue. John responds, “Thanks for telling me Jill, I understand.”</p><p>“But what if John doesn’t say that?” A student interjects.</p><p>“Than she should leave him,” I propose. “Sounds like John is probably not the right person for her.”</p><p>Any millennial that’s been on a college campus in the past ten years could tell you, “Consent is sexy, simple, and legally binding”. We see it on Student Life posters. We review it in online modules from our insurance providers. We read about it every other day in school papers.</p><blockquote>But what if John tells you you’re worthless and no one else will ever love you? What if John tries to persuade you to have unprotected sex, because why else would you be on birth control and it just feels better that way, even though he’s already the one statistically more likely to cum in this encounter?</blockquote><p>What if John removes his condom when you’re not paying attention? What if John strangles you to the point of asphyxiation and anally rapes you because you just seemed like the kind of girl that liked it rough? What if John tells you it was an accident afterward? What if John tells you you’re naive? What if John tells you after that he wasn’t really listening to you when you were talking together in the bar, when all you really wanted was a conversation and someone to listen? What if Jill said yes, at the beginning, just the beginning? What if Jill cares about John’s feelings? And what if John doesn’t care at all?</p><p>What I wasn’t explicitly teaching my high school health class is sometimes it doesn’t matter if a woman “knows how to say no” at all, it doesn’t make a difference.</p><p><strong>Sexual violence happens when we’re intoxicated, but also when we’re completely sober. When we say no. And when we say nothing at all</strong> — because we’re scared, because we’re frantically searching for the safest way out alive, which in those quick calculations may not necessarily be out of his bed, because he might be angry, or because we worry about his feelings and response after this is over, or because we said yes initially, so feel we must continue as it was our choice, even though this is not what we want now, because we don’t want to cause trouble or bring attention to ourselves, because we feel people will just say we wanted it and knew what we were getting into anyway, or because we freeze.</p><p>This sexual violence has fatal consequences.</p><blockquote><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5657947/">CDC data</a> from the National Violent Death Reporting System (NVDRS) shows that over half of all homicides of women are related to intimate partner violence, and 11.2% of the time there was a warning in the month before their deaths with the victim experiencing violence by the very same perpetrator — and this is just those who called the police.</blockquote><p>The number experiencing intimate partner violence leading up to their deaths is likely far higher. Intimate partner violence and homicide also starts early. In a study of <a href="https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/2730578">NVDRS data on adolescent homicide</a> published last month, intimate partners perpetrated almost 7% of the homicides, and 90% of the victims were female.</p><p>I was the last in my class to go through puberty, fifteen and a half. I was tall, thin, and pretty, people would comment. You’d be surprised how much that can get you, they’d say. But I didn’t want to get anything. I just wanted everyone to leave me alone. I walked with my shoulders forward and my head down.</p><p>Men began to notice me and some even solicited me for sex on the street. Once I was almost abducted by a taxi driver. I pleaded with him until he let me go — but at least I got a free ride out of it. I’ve only ever told this story as a joke followed by nervous laughter. Another time an older man whispered to me in a crowded cafe to masturbate about him that evening. I was mortified. And at night cars would swerve near me, honking and yelling. Eventually, I started staying out less and walking home with other people.</p><p>Despite this, I was nice, eager to please, and rarely said no. I could talk abstractly about female pleasure, but I couldn’t articulate what I wanted or needed. Anywhere, not just in the bedroom.</p><p>And still, I could have casual sex, quick penetrative sex, as much of it as I wanted. <strong>It is this understanding of sexual agency that creates an illusion of free will and gender equality while only rewarding men’s pleasure and assertiveness.</strong> It is this eager to please, self-sacrificing expectation of womanhood that gas lights women into taking responsibility for their assailants’ actions.</p><p>We talk about the struggle for gender parity, and often it seems immovable and lacking direction. Women receive less pay at work, married women still do most housework even when they also hold down jobs, sex workers are the ones criminalized, trans and gender non-conforming identities are erased, and female bodies are legislated and policed.</p><p>The list is long and ever growing. We have not even passed the Equal Rights Amendment — and there are women as vehemently opposed as men, who embrace arcane gender roles of the past.</p><p>But I have a suggestion. Maybe some of our efforts start in the dark with our clothes off when no one’s watching. <strong>The average time it takes to pleasure a woman to orgasm, 20 minutes, requires care, patience, and respect — nothing short of the respect it takes to allow women to legally preside over their own bodies.</strong></p><p>But I didn’t grow up in Alabama, where abortion is now criminalized.The men I was surrounded by called themselves liberals, some even feminists, and still my niceness was considered an asset — until 21 years later when I realized it was my greatest liability. I’m sure Harvey Weinstein was pro-choice. I’m sure Anthony Weiner regularly donated to Planned Parenthood.</p><blockquote>Men like their feminism like their women, nice and obliging — something glossy that can fit in a 280 character tweet or a body positivity post wearing pink pasties that they can jack off to when no one’s looking.</blockquote><p>I want sexual predators to get their hands off my reproductive rights. But I also want sexual predators to stop hiding behind them.</p><p>I have tolerated latent sexism everywhere else in my life, so I was tolerating it from physically intimate partners as well. I want men to stop cajoling me to have protection-less sex, rating me with their friends, bragging about me as a sexual conquest, critiquing my body, treating me as their personal call girl, dismissing my comments in class, talking over me in meetings, and telling me that I just don’t understand.</p><p>I do understand, and I am not naive. I know more about them, than they’ll ever know about me. While men played with me, I’ve been intently studying them for years. This week I just negotiated my first raise, and I stopped responding to unwanted solicitations. I no longer owe anyone an explanation, because I am not nice. Girls who are not nice get rape kits in pink dresses with small flowers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d41a4f863f28" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>