<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Theodore Taptiklis on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Theodore Taptiklis on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@taptiklis?source=rss-d692d077701a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 19:20:49 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@taptiklis/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Enlarging humanity: how we might start to remake our world with acoustic synergy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@taptiklis/enlarging-humanity-how-we-might-start-to-remake-our-world-with-acoustic-synergy-38d9fb294a6e?source=rss-d692d077701a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/38d9fb294a6e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sensory-processing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[humanity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[listening]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collaboration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Theodore Taptiklis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 01 Nov 2024 00:00:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-01T00:00:06.541Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Humanity seems stuck. Our politics seem stuck. Our behaviors seem stuck. Our ways of being in the world seem stuck. It’s time to attempt an evolutionary shift.</em></p><h4>An <strong>introduction</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/347/1*LI5pjXrJWAbljKSKl318rg.png" /></figure><p>Our present era has atomized our sense of self, encouraging us to see ourselves as separate from the world and from each other. To position ourselves in this maelstrom of individualized collision, we easily become consumed by efforts of self-definition and identity.</p><p>Such efforts tend to turn us inward, away from spontaneity, curiosity, connection and possibility. Our ways of speaking can become declarative, rehearsed and defensive. Instead of following the natural instincts of all living creatures to reach outward into the world — enlarging the boundaries of selfhood and concern (our “cognitive light cone”) to connect with otherness and others — we can allow the stress of self-actualization to overwhelm our capacities of care and concern. The result can be a kind of ‘shrunken self’ that stops listening, and blocks out the unknown and unfamiliar to retreat into stereotyped attitudes, representations and fantasies. The recent rise of social media seems to have exaggerated these tendencies. Instead of enlarging our worldly experience, we shrink into more determined identity formation and us-versus-them-ism.</p><p>But this has not always been the way of things — nor need it be for the future. I believe that we can break the shackles of individualism and discover a richer, more joyful, more generative and more satisfying way of being together. There’s so much to be learned by being more open and generous in listening to the creativity of our differences. An enlarged way of being employs our nature-given faculties: capacities of awareness that we have used differently in the more distant past, and that we now have the opportunity to revive, strengthen and deepen for a more promising humanity. I believe what’s possible is a kind of sensory evolution.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/287/1*nQzzTmRflEgAMncowEDZFQ.png" /></figure><p>The proposition starts with bodies: our physical selves and the complexity of their design for engagement with the world of which we are a part. Discussion of human senses tends to focus on their capabilities as receptors, as conveyors of signals from our surroundings to the brain as hegemon. Sight, hearing, touch, smell, taste and the rest are prized for their sensitivity as openings to our experience of worldly events. But the reality is more complicated: our senses also act upon the world and change it at the same time. Our awareness of our body in space provokes our muscle movements and their impacts on things around us; what we look at activates our gaze, focusing our thoughts and our actions in response; what we hear draws our attention and invites an expressive act of our own. Our brain is one bodily node among others. And our sensory systems are not separate but interdependent with each other and the world, passing control between themselves and worldly reactions without pause at every moment. In effect it is these exchanges, not our physical entities, that are the real substance of the living world: that give rise to our continual relational existence. The physicist Carlo Rovelli describes physical reality as a matter of “kisses, not stones”, where it’s not things but the encounters between them that have significance.</p><p>The most relationally complex of all our sensory apparatus is our auditory-vocal system, that in dyadic human encounters systematically joins the perception of sound to the production of a response in the same currency. Our hearing is involuntary: sound ‘pours into us’ whether or not we point ourselves towards it. Each moment of sound vanishes as soon as it appears, so we have to hold its arrival in our memory to make sense of the following moments. We have to interpret the character of the sound signal to judge the opportunity and the moment for a response. And then we have to form a responding signal that begins in our diaphragm, controlling our breath and gauging the tenor of our own sound production through our larynx in relation to the shape of the incoming signal by using the quite different internal hearing pathway that we have for our own voice.</p><p>We ‘tune’ our vocal response to what we hear — by varying its pitch, its loudness, its duration and timing, as well as its intensity and emotive affect — in such a way that the interplay of listening and responding can be highly detailed and relationally sensitive. If our intention is to ‘go on’ with the other, we look to catch and sustain the spirit of the encounter in the minutest details of our vocal expression, amplified by our facial and bodily movements. Much of this sensitivity is subliminal and habitual. All of our faculties work together in our exchanges — but it is the complex back-and-forth of our hearing and voicing and the bioelectrical impulses that ripple through our viscera that carry the biggest expressive-relational load.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/236/1*sOEFFOE0m1phRLTuHKMaWA.png" /></figure><p>The sonic affordances of human communication are very ancient — and predate the evolution of music and language. Their inherent rhythms are designed to promote synchrony between individuals by allowing us to predict what comes next, and as a result to be able to align our movements with others. The synchrony of sound production reverberates through the body, activating movement and neurological and physiological responses in a very short space of time. It is said that the social bonds that can quickly form between people in synchrony — for example in group singing — seem to dissolve the sense of a boundary between self and other. Nina Kraus and Jessica Slater suggest that “Words may scratch the surface, but sound can move us beyond words”.</p><p>Interest in the sonic character of vocal expression has accelerated in recent years. And it is the non-verbal attributes of speech — called ‘prosody’ — that has increasingly attracted attention in a range of disciplines (for example in specialized medical diagnostics). Prosody captures the expressive melodic and rhythmic features of an utterance — of breath, sound and movement — that convey information about emotion, intention, attitudinal focus and communicative stance. All of this is information that may or may not be present in its verbal content. Prosody may emphasize or underline a verbal message: but it may also reveal things about a speaker and their sense of the world in that moment that go well beyond the words that are spoken. And now, the recent advances of AI are enabling the detailed analysis of prosodic features at levels of acuity and at speed and scales not previously attainable — so it becomes possible to detect depths of meta-verbal information from small fragments of recorded or real-time utterance. Evidence so far also suggests that many, perhaps most prosodic features may be largely language and culture-independent — something that testifies to the likelihood of their pre-linguistic origins, hundreds of thousands of years ago. Long before there was language, we communicated in something more like song — as other creatures still do.</p><p>Paying more attention to the sounds of our utterances is also emphasizing a shift that is beginning in how we understand and teach communication: from focusing mostly on the skills of performance, expression and assertiveness to include a greater recognition of the importance of listening. We know that capability in conversation matters in a challenging world: for example, the UK’s Oracy Commission is proposing to raise speaking and listening skills to the same level of importance as literacy and numeracy in school curricula. However the proposal here is that it’s listening that demands the most attention. Speaking skills can be taught as though always addressing an audience, concentrating on fluency and needing only cursory recognition of the other. Teaching listening, on the other hand, requires a much greater emphasis on presence, behavioral awareness and social sensitivities. Projecting oneself outward is one thing: allowing others to project themselves inward to oneself is quite another thing.</p><p>Listening occupies the center ground of human awareness because the way we listen determines the nature of our relationships. How much we can hear in another’s vocal expression sets the boundaries of possibility between us. If we hear only what we are already looking for, our relationship is confined to our pre-existing expectations. Many domains of discourse constrain our noticing and encourage these expectations, so that we operate with each other only in predefined roles. Layers of understanding and potential connection never get to make an appearance. In this way, <strong>listening is<em> </em>relationship</strong>.</p><p>But even as the generator of relational awareness, listening itself remains in the shadows, mostly taken for granted in our struggles for verbal authority. Our exchanges are often like a game of shadow tennis where we try to hit the ball even before it has reached us. With verbal accomplishment always in the foreground, bringing listening out of the shadows is a significant challenge. For instance, a performative approach to listening — to simply aim to be a better listener — is not nearly enough. Listening is not just a skill to be learned, like literacy, or an attitude to adopt, like empathy. It’s an entirely immersive capacity — a way of being in the world so that we are also present to the worlds of other beings.</p><p>So if we are to take listening seriously enough to realize its full potential, we have to begin by exploring and experiencing the entire realm of listening — to recognize what listening does, what it shapes, what it unfolds, what it reveals, and what it allows and enables. This means that it’s not enough just to do more listening ourselves. We have to listen to and experience other people’s and other kinds of listenings in all of their variety. We have to listen closely and carefully enough to discover what different listenings do — and what happens as a result. We have to plunge ourselves into the rushing river of multi-directional sensory exchange with sound at the center, and start to learn with greater sensitivity about how to navigate its swirling currents.</p><p>This means two things. We have to work at <strong>listening with others</strong> present at the same time so that we can recognize and compare different ways of experiencing the same event. And we have to <strong>listen to listening</strong> — to hear and discuss the listening of others and ourselves by ‘listening again’. With available technology, we can now move beyond the limitations of face-to- face synchronous exchange, where the details vanish in the anxious rush of ordinary conduct. We can weave accessible capacities of voice recording into our working approaches. And brief recordings invite a lot of learning.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/332/1*8N9r0oVmopOxx8-nWLWkuQ.png" /></figure><p>If we expose a group of people to a carefully chosen short piece of recorded conversation, and ask them without any prompting to record themselves privately saying in a few words about what strikes them most immediately in what they hear, a lot begins to happen. First, each person notices something different. Second, there’s surprise that the same phenomenon is experienced in quite different ways. And third, as people tune in to each separate noticing by hearing them one at a time, and then discussing them together, something like a mixture of curiosity and appreciation of difference appears. It turns out that shared sensing — even with its uncertainties and contradictions — is much richer than any individual view. What seemed straightforward on first listening unfolds itself on detailed noticing to new observations and interpretations, revealing unexpected depth and complexity in the recording and in exchanges within the group.</p><p>With this approach, the listening opportunities pile on one another in ways that increase understanding. First, in a recorded provocation we notice each speaker listening (or not) to the other’s utterance. Next, we notice each group member’s listening orientation in their recorded responses to the provocation, one after the other. Then in the workshop exchanges, we notice what each group member listens and attends to as they hear one another’s recordings again, and how they build a shared sense of each of their orientations. And finally, as researchers in a post-workshop review, we listen to the movement of the whole workshop sequence, to each other’s views of what we have learned, and to what we think the group members have learned from the conduct of the workshop. There’s a lot of listening there.</p><p>Group listening and noticing begins to change the character of a group. It can feel unsettling at first to have others discuss one’s own way of speaking so directly and in such detail: but people come to respond with increasing interest and even a sense of delighted curiosity. Eventually the experience feels like a kind of affirmation. “I thought that my noticing was ordinary — that everyone does it — but that’s not the case. Others here are telling me that for them, it’s special.” People discover that differences and details matter, and that what they’ve always taken for granted about themselves may be worth valuing and cultivating. It seems that there’s always more going on: that even in everyday conversations, we might ask, “What’s really going on here? What is it at this moment that someone else is attending to and that I’m not noticing?”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/273/1*gOVrrMXzoXSFSNlzq5nUmQ.png" /></figure><p>Careful examination of this practice reveals a pattern that is repeated through a series of experiments. Listening closely with others to recordings of our own brief but concentrated utterances is something new to almost everyone. But gradually and quite naturally, the steady focus on the sound and sense of another person’s voice reveals details in a pattern that normally goes un-noticed. Typically, it’s the verbal content that first draws most attention: but as a group settles into discussion, awareness eventually turns towards the prosodic features of each voice — the rises and falls, the pauses and hesitations, and the moments of emphasis or salience.</p><p>Underlying this shift is a characteristic movement towards deeper levels of awareness, from reasoning towards sensing. Examples of this development have been traced in many domains: for example in nursing, from the rule-following novice to the ‘transparent self’ of the expert practitioner; or in observations of tracker-hunters who — once they abandon the interpretation of animal signs — enter a trance-like state in which they become the chased animal and assume its behavior.</p><p>In these listening experiments, we observe a spectrum of responses, from a position of detachment from the phenomenon (speaking ‘about’ rather than ‘with’ it) — seeing it as a ‘thing’ with ‘content’; through several levels of deeper engagement, where people think about the speakers they are listening to by comparing the exchanges of the conversation with their own experiences; and eventually a position of something more like embodiment, where it’s the physical sensation of the phenomenon that stands out and has the most interest and significance.</p><p>Here’s a summary of this movement from a series of experiments:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/627/1*GWaouCEz0Gabm9jIINLo2w.png" /></figure><p>This kind of listening work reveals that in many ways, ordinary conversation is quite partial and ineffective. We can’t or won’t express everything we have to say: and we can’t or won’t hear everything that’s going on between us. There’s often an element of competition in our conversational behavior, so that we hasten to make our own contribution in ways that reduce our listening capacity. Speech analysis suggests that in preparing our responses — and anxious to leave no gap between speakers that another might fill — we can miss long stretches of the other’s utterance. But by working here with brief recorded utterances and extracts, we are slowing down our exchanges sufficiently for more sensitive noticings to appear. The more thoughtful and respectful are the observations, the more comfortable the group becomes with reflective silences and more thoughtful consideration of each other’s perspectives. This deliberately slower pace is characteristic, for example, of Quaker gatherings.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/268/1*5Rb3TicnpRNRkK3SfPrbOA.png" /></figure><p>From these efforts to slow down our listening, there are two important lessons. First, there’s a lot more to be understood about what’s going on between us — and what else might be available to us — in our exchanges. And second, since we are each moved differently by what’s happening, our differences might be powerful in combination — if we could figure out how to put them together. In other words, our habitual stance of individuality and separation — and our competition for air time —is leaving a lot of joint human capability unrealized. So there’s a challenge now to craft a response that addresses both of these lessons.</p><p>I am drawn to the notion in evolutionary biology of <strong>bowtie architecture.<em> </em></strong>The argument, set out in a recent Michael Levin paper <em>(</em>“<em>Self-Improvising Memory”) </em>is that all living creatures, bombarded by realms of sensory data at every moment, have to deal with the problem of salience: determining what matters and needs to be stored to deal with future situations, or to pass genetically to succeeding generations. The capacity for this storage is memory, taking various forms (biochemical, bioelectrical, biomechanical) along the evolutionary sequence. But if memory is finite, experience must be compressed or distilled an to a dense knot or kernel — sometimes known as ‘engram’— for storage, to be later unpacked and regenerated at the moment of need. And if context must be lost in compression, regeneration is a creative process, in that the memory kernel gets reinterpreted and reprocessed for the new external world situation in which it now appears. The suggestion is that memory gets ‘remapped’ to maintain its salience in a new environment — perhaps with fragments of orginal context attached.</p><p>But given the unreliability of biological matter (compared, say, with computational data) how does this remapping occur so that salience is preserved? Levin asks, “What if memories, which are not static details but active deep patterns, can resonate with a cognizer or even a group of cognizers (in the case of federated inference and belief-sharing) in a kind of circular causality, in which they exert some minimal agency as they shape the mind of the thinker and thus help construct the niche within which they will be utilized in subsequent time steps?”</p><p>In other words, is there a kind of iterative organic process of mutual influence going on where our thoughts are collectively relating and self-transforming even as they arise? Perhaps our memories are acting as a kind of temporal ‘juice’ (bioelectrical current?) that enables our bodies to maintain flow through the shifting demands of each living moment without resorting to conscious thought? And in doing so, might they address the inherent unreliability of biological matter by federating sense-impressions with others to reduce the error rate? If so, are we like trees in a human forest, entangled by unconscious bioelectrical roots? (And by the way, does all this mean that consciousness is simply — or complexly(!) — the experience of being alive, from each moment to the next? On this view, consciousness is a shared property, and every form of life exists within it.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/358/1*FPXzRQ62LxEXesDPdmgpVw.png" /></figure><p>I want to build on these speculations to suggest a trajectory of sensory evolution for ourselves.</p><p>Two hypotheses underlie the proposal. The first is that fragments of characteristic prosody may be strong candidates for engram formation — the kernel of the bowtie memory storage architecture. And the second is that there are deep patterns of human synergy that can be identified as dynamic scaffolds for assembling sonic memory traces in collaborative intra-action. The aim of both together is to try to reach below the level of logical inference and reason to activate acoustic instincts that can operate more immediately and directly alongside, and in support of, the back-and-forth of conventional verbal exchange. By hearing the sounds of our voices with more acuity, both separately and together, we can be guided towards deeper understanding and productive shared action. If we find a way to learn to recognize what each other is reaching for — the yearning behind our words — we might more directly tune our responses towards our common purposes.</p><p>The proposal is for an unfolding sequence of developmental experiments.</p><p><strong>1. Conduct a carefully-designed organization-wide listening project.</strong></p><p>The first stage is to extend the body of small group listening workshops trialled so far towards a larger population with specific outcomes. A large organization oriented towards process and culture development (such as a university) is an ideal candidate for a large-scale multi-group experiment. The aim might be to engage a thousand or more participants in a parallel workshop experience of (say) two 90-minute sessions.</p><p>Members of each group in the workshop initiative will listen to a conversational provocation together and will separately record a brief audio response, followed by a structured discussion and reflection sequence for each response in turn. The experience will be valuable both for the organization and for each participant independent of the research context, who gain:</p><ul><li>a new understanding of a group’s differences of orientation</li><li>an appreciative sense of their own distinctiveness in relation to others</li><li>a set of collaborative verbal accounts of what is special about each person’s way of being from the noticings that they offer</li><li>some clues about how to elicit and make use of people’s underlying differences in their everyday encounters</li></ul><p>Each participant will carry different lessons away from the experience. And with sufficient scale, the appreciation and value of listening can become self-reinforcing and viral across the organization.</p><p><strong>2. Attempt to distill an organized body of sonic gestures from the results.</strong></p><p>The next stage is much more experimental and speculative. It begins by assembling audio recordings and transcriptions of all the group conversations. Then, with the help of AI, audio fragments for each separately recorded orientation can be isolated, compared and clustered together to look for matches with the verbal descriptions in the transcriptions. The hypothesis, supported by findings from earlier prosody research, is that similar descriptions might be able to be attached to similar sound patterns. A possible result is a sequence or spectrum of identifiable voicings or ‘gestures’. Each gesture is the sonic expression of an orientation — an attitude, an intention, a particular way of responding to the phenomenon. Orientations can be additive — in effect, different forms of work conducted by different people. Together, they might create a synergy of multiple perspectives or interpretations of the same event.</p><p>Many questions need to be explored here. What exactly is a recognizable sonic gesture? Is it like a chord or passage in music? How long is it? What is its frequency range? Is it a pattern of sound, or is it a noise like a grunt? How rich could a gesture repertoire be? Can they be identified without constraining categorization? Could they be prompts or reminders with fixed meanings?</p><p><strong>3. Explore the application of sonic gestures to ordinary conduct.</strong></p><p>A third stage of the research is to consider the use of prosody as a practical relational instrument using the body of sonic gestures generated by the workshops. Questions to be explored include:</p><ul><li>Can sonic gestures be identified free of context? (Prior research suggests that they can.)</li><li>Can gestures be stored and recalled as distilled memory traces, as in bowtie architecture? (Evolutionary biology suggest that this is possible.)</li><li>Can they be understood and experienced like musical gestures, where sequences and patterns form recognizable movements and combinations of sound, as a kind of musilanguage? (Study of language evolution suggests that this was prelinguistic human practice.)</li></ul><p>There are lots more questions to be considered here. Could sensitizing people to sonic gestures be enough to stimulate them into unprompted awareness? Do we need to learn and recognize specific gestures in what we’re hearing? Or can they be replayed to us in some way as prompts?</p><p><strong>4. Study conversational streams to look for sonic markers of generative moments, sequences and patterns.</strong></p><p>Alongside these tests of prosody, another related and highly speculative research stream can be undertaken to explore and identify generative relationships and patterns in a wide variety of recorded conversations, using AI for rapid forensic processing of prosody and verbal content. The hypothesis here is that we’re seeking to link ‘generosity’ in listening to generative conduct, and that the main purpose of such conduct in any domain is to maintain and develop collaborative relationships. While in the course of these relationships, solutions are pursued and actions result, these are never closed-ended, and the ultimate purpose is always to sustain the capacity for fruitful continuation. For this research there are two kinds of questions:</p><ul><li>Are there strong markers of collaborative intention in the tone and content of group conversational exchanges? For example, how important is curiosity? What does curiosity sound like? What are the precursors to the appearance of curiosity, and what follows as a result? (The recorded group discussions should be productive ground for this enquiry.)</li><li>Beyond a micro-study of particular conversational exchanges and sequences lie some larger questions: what overall orientations should be present to enable a productive and successful group encounter, and can each of these different orientations or forms of work be detected from the conversational conduct of those present? In other words, who (or what intentions) should be in the room to generate the best shared outcomes? If their presence can be detected, can their absence also be recognized? (I propose a potential pattern of orientations inspired by the experience of collaborative encounter in the oral traditions of Te Ao Māori, attached below as Annex 1).</li></ul><p><strong>5. Devise tools and practices that encourage more understanding between people, and that invite more spontaneous synchronization of joint efforts.</strong></p><p>The final stage of developmental research, gathering all the evidence of the foregoing stages, is to devise and test initiatives for improving and deepening the quality of purposeful conversation that might operate within the flow of ordinary conduct. Many possibilities can be examined and tested here:</p><ul><li>First, can acoustic signals compress intentional, orientational meaning with greater intensity and acuity than verbal expression?</li><li>Second, can an acoustic channel usefully accompany ordinary conversation through appropriate devices available to participants?</li><li>Third, can acoustic prompts helpfully influence conversational conduct?</li><li>Fourth, can social protocols can be adopted and accepted to support this kind of intervention?</li><li>Fifth, can sound-based games can be developed to invite and encourage acoustic sensitivity and engagement from rising generations (think: <em>Soundcraft</em> — an acoustic version of <em>Minecraft</em>)?</li><li>Sixth, might there be interest and appetite for developing a sophisticated musilanguage to support all kinds of endeavours?</li><li>Seventh, is it possible that with experience, listening skills may evolve so far that instruments, devices, channels and prompts become unnecessary, or embodied, or both?</li></ul><p>We might frame all of this as reaching towards an extended process of biological evolution. Over millennia, with language and artistry we have progressively outsourced spoken knowledge and imagery from memory to carved, written, printed and recorded materials — and now to digital storage. So the systematic retention of recorded sonic gestures as memory traces for human synergy might perhaps be thought of as a further step on the same pathway.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/281/1*oiLcmeL9GhHcR9p1kBdorA.png" /></figure><p>We already communicate non-verbally, recognizing facial expression, body posture and other cues as well as vocal expression in our encounters. Our pre-linguistic ancestors managed perfectly well for likely millions of years. But language — spoken and written — is now the dominant and legitimizing currency of exchange, tending to crowd out what we might reconsider as our most fast-acting, intuitive and universal capacities. Memorizing shared meanings and understandings for prosody open up a range of possibilities:</p><ul><li>We are familiar with the synchronous effects of singing and dancing together: how group vocal performance based on learned and remembered sound sequences creates a unity of sensation and purpose. In singing — arranged or spontaneous — we tune our differences together to make a multi-part harmony of merged musical intention. Even in unison, the experience flows through our bodies with an intensity of shared presence and common feeling;</li><li>Imagine how synchronies of vocal expression might feel. By recognizing another’s orientation in a moment, we might quickly choose how to fit our purpose to theirs, and vice-versa. Because sounds combine with one another in ways that words do not, we could look for combinations that harmonize or contrast with one another in galvanizing ways to form creative and productive relationships. If we can identify what a person is really wishing for from the sound of their voice — and can also relate these to the needs of a situation — we can pursue complex tasks and goals by forging relationships of human capacity that make the most of one another’s differences;</li><li>By listening more closely to each other in this way we can advance civic practice. We can bypass layers of debate and argument to discover the roots of each other’s concerns with greater acuity and deeper compassion. If only they can be expressed and properly listened to, our voices can reveal things about ourselves that we can never explain. By learning to reach and value what is present but unspoken in our utterances, we may ultimately look to develop a better, more sensitive humanity. By entangling our sensory roots, we might cultivate a forest of shared understanding.</li></ul><h4>Some references</h4><p><a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02688/full">Michael Levin, <em>The Computational Boundary of a Self: Developmental Biolectricity Drives Multicellularity and Scale-Free Cognition,</em> Frontiers in Psychology, 2019</a></p><p>Carlo Rovelli, <em>The Order of Time, </em>Penguin Books 2018</p><p><a href="https://www.annualreviews.org/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-psych-122414-033318">Nina Kraus &amp; Jessica Slater: <em>Beyond words: how humans communicate through sound</em>, Annual Review of Psychology, Volume 67, 2016</a></p><p><a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0749596X16000024">Nelle Hellbernd &amp; Daniela Sammler: <em>Prosody conveys speaker’s intentions: acoustic cues for speech act perception, </em>Journal of Memory and Language, Volume 88, 2016</a></p><p><a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2017.01894/full">Steven Brown, <em>A Joint Prosodic Origin of Language and Music</em>, Frontiers in Psychology 2017</a></p><p><a href="https://www.mdpi.com/1099-4300/26/6/481">Michael Levin, <em>Self-Improvising Memory: A Perspective on Memories as Agential, Dynamically Reinterpreting Cognitive Glue</em>, Entropy, 2024</a>, and also, <a href="https://thoughtforms.life/self-improvising-memories-a-few-thoughts-around-a-recent-paper/"><em>Self-improvising memories: a few thoughts around a recent paper</em></a></p><h4>Annex 1</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/798/1*Ote8iPBNU1aQrCwcJus6Cg.png" /></figure><h4>Annex 2</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/794/1*wYGc4oKIcRx3nRFiSsUVhQ.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=38d9fb294a6e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why we’re No-thing: and how that brings our relationality into focus]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@taptiklis/why-were-no-thing-and-how-that-brings-our-relationality-into-focus-c72ffc75ac71?source=rss-d692d077701a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c72ffc75ac71</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[relationality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[listening]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[groups]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conversational-ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Theodore Taptiklis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 07 Sep 2023 22:43:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-07T22:43:27.066Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OG-SOOHOTKeHpDBNHYCNrw.png" /></figure><p>With colleagues, I’ve just completed a series of experimental group practices that enable people who don’t know each other — without any special preparation or instruction — to quickly develop a new and deeper sense of themselves in relation to others, and at the same time come to understand and appreciate the different ways that those around them experience the world. The change is so immediate that it demonstrates that in the future, strangers and familiars might easily come to use their differences as resources for one another, whatever they are doing. It’s such a valuable discovery that we’re now looking to build on and extend it as far as possible across realms of human endeavour.</p><p>Beyond this promising behavioural change, our discovery is part of a movement in human understanding that is bringing many branches of investigation in the both the humanities and the sciences into a new synthesis. Our collisions and encounters with each other and the world are evidently so rich with complexity and under-used potential, that attuning ourselves to their details — with the support of all of the capacities of our human and physical sciences — is a project that offers enormous rewards for the conduct of human affairs.</p><p>This paper tumbles through some of the ideas and influences around this discovery, and sets up some ambitious proposals for how we might respond to the opportunity that is now beckoning.</p><p>I’d like to start by referencing my recent enchantment by the cosmology of Carlo Rovelli — a glimpse of a new interpretation of ourselves and our natures in relation to the world we inhabit. In Rovelli’s luminous accounts of quantum science there’s a language and a structure of insights that gesture towards what we’ve been noticing.</p><p>We don’t have a quantum theory of personhood — as though this were even possible — but Rovelli’s writings <em>(*1a-1d below)</em> set aside the assumptions of the doctrine of atomised individualism that still remains the foundation of social, political and economic organisation almost everywhere today. And as a result, it feels as though they underpin our efforts in strengthening our relational muscles to face a larger sense of the urgent task of our present planetary circumstances.</p><h4>Being human, revisited</h4><p>Carlo Rovelli is a poet, a lyrical author of understanding, and at the same time a determined and plain-speaking scientist. The practice of scientific enquiry that arises in Rovelli’s work is a constant movement of <em>successive approximations</em> — a reaching forward, a stumbling towards, interspersed with moments of genius and revelation that may not be appreciated until they can be correlated with other insights, quite often at a later time.</p><p>The world of quantum physics that Rovelli inhabits depends upon abstruse and complex mathematics—something well beyond my capacities. But in discussing the pantheon of illustrious forbears in the science of reality, he characterises some of the great leaps of insight as <em>visions — </em>powerful images, rather than formulae. And he traces the beginning of the whole story back to Anaximander, who was my hero when I was eighteen years old and studying philosophy. Gripped by the story of this Greek forbear who, grappling with the nature of the universe, saw the sky above as continuing unseen below the globe of the earth, I wrote a poem — a tribute to “young Anaximander” that I now recognise as shameless self-identification.</p><p>All of this warms me towards Rovelli — and gives me the confidence to try to express my emerging understandings in ways that may reference some of his.</p><p>From his <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/books/2022/sep/05/the-big-idea-why-relationships-are-the-key-to-existence">recent Guardian article</a>:</p><blockquote>A good scientific theory…should not be about how things “are”, or what they “do”: it should be about how they affect one another…So quantum physics may just be the realisation that this ubiquitous relational structure of reality continues all the way down to the elementary physical level. Reality is not a collection of things, it’s a network of processes. We understand reality better if we think of it in terms of interactions, not individuals. We, as individuals, exist thanks to the interactions we are involved in.</blockquote><p>My world for the past three decades has been the study of human interactions — or, as my colleague and mentor John Shotter preferred to call them, <em>intra-actions. </em>Shotter used this term to capture the notion of interpenetration: that our exchanges are not simply actions and reactions, like those in a game of tennis, but can change ourselves and the others in the room even in their formation or utterance.</p><p>My colleagues and I have been diving ever more deeply into the phenomenology of human intra-action — and what emerges as central in this experience is our <strong>relationality</strong>. So strong is our relational experience now that we have started to sense ourselves no longer as ‘things’ — as discrete entities — but as something that needs a new descriptive language. For the moment, I’ll try <em>“fuzzy bundles of intra-acting relationships floating in an atmosphere of many other fuzzy bundles of intra-acting relationships”.</em> On this view a new image of humanity is appearing, where the apparent solidity of the Self dissolves into a sense of each of us as a vibrating set of processes in a vast network of intra-actions with other vibrating sets of processes, including the whole of the non-human world that surrounds us. A declaration of this altered perspective is the expression <strong>No-thing </strong>of the title above.</p><p>It’s not a mystical perspective. It’s an attempt to capture an understanding based on specific observations that have entirely practical consequences. And the language of quantum physics seems helpful here— not necessarily as a direct parallel, but as a useful point of reference. Rovelli distills the foundational discoveries of quantum science into three features of the world: <em>granularity</em>, <em>indeterminacy</em> and <em>relationality</em>.</p><p>He explains: <em>granularity</em> means that the structure of reality is not continuous or infinite. Instead “there is a limit to the number of states in which a system can exist.” Smallness does not ultimately reduce to emptiness. <em>Indeterminacy </em>means that at the atomic level, nothing in quantum physics is predictable. The results of collisions between fundamental particles are always uncertain: “things are constantly subject to random change”. And <em>relationality</em> means that things cannot be described as they are, but only how they occur and how they interact with each other. Quantum physics doesn’t describe where a particle <em>is</em> but only how the particle <em>shows itself to others. </em>This sounds to me very like Heideggerian phenomenology: the idea that things “show up” for us, where we are understood as “world disclosers”.</p><p>I’ll consider here the echoes of Rovelli’s three features in our own work.</p><p>I’ll make the case for <strong>No-thing</strong> in two sections. In the first section, I‘ll set out a perspective that has arrived for us using a language that describes each element of this new view and summarises them at the end. And in the second section, I’ll lay out the description — and then suggest the consequences — of a practice that manifests this view, using as the exemplar our experimental learning sequence, <strong><em>Entangled Bodies</em></strong>.</p><h4>Some notes towards a language of relationality</h4><p>Our practical experiments suggest that our sense of self arises at the confluence of a number of different forms of relational phenomena. Each of these may strike and move us towards a particular relational orientation, either separately or severally. But none of these is definitive: our relational sensitivity is always open to movement and alteration. This why we are not determinate selves, but beings that are fuzzy at the boundaries. Not things, but states of being, in flux with the motion of the world.</p><p>A number of relational phenomena have bubbled up from our explorations. Because there are overlaps this is not a definitive, separated list, but a first account of movements and turnings that have made themselves felt in our work:</p><h4><strong>Encounters</strong></h4><p>Encounters are the stuff of the world. Each ‘I’ or ‘me’ lives in an atmosphere constantly buffeted by encounters. We can think of encounters as experiences of adjacency, or collisions, with ‘not-me’ or otherness. These <em>not-me’s</em> may be other people, other living creatures, aspects of the surrounding landscape or locality, or forces like the weather, the seasons, the movement from day to night, or the phases of the moon.</p><p>Encounters are complex events and can overwhelm our senses so that their layers are hard to untangle, and some may easily be missed. Wittgenstein observed that “it all goes by too fast”. They strike us in a variety of ways depending on our orientation, emphasising the challenge they pose to our attentiveness as they ‘come at us all at once’. In response, each of us may tune our natures to recognise some of their aspects and not others. We can experience the same phenomena differently from others by deliberate or acquired attunement.</p><h4><strong>Noticings</strong></h4><p>Noticings are ‘turnings towards’ aspects of our phenomenological experience that distinguish the characteristics that seem salient to us. Noticing is a quality or a tool of attentiveness, allowing an aspect of our surrounding circumstances to ‘make an impression’ on us. Noticing may not be deliberate, or necessarily arise during the event or encounter: we may claim afterwards that we noticed something through memory recall, or when prompted by another’s noticings.</p><p>In everyday encounters, noticings are seldom remarked. Social conventions — and a habit of diffidence about our internal lives — keep most of our noticings from view. Because they often follow one another in rapid succession, they are quickly forgotten. But if they are allowed to find expressive articulation to others, they can be remarkable sources of shared insight and discovery. Noticings are the basis for the leaps of genius described by Rovelli. Artistic expression, great and small, is created from noticings. In meetings and exchanges, noticings can be prompts for new levels of attentiveness and acuity. Noticings may be fleeting and partial, not quite graspable, even <em>slippery</em> <em>(*2)</em>.</p><p>In conversation, noticings work differently from other forms of expression. They have an invitational quality — a sense of putting something forward that is unfinalised and incomplete — that leaves space for the contributions of others. They create a different atmosphere than, for example, conclusions or assertions.</p><h4>Differences</h4><p>Our backgrounds, our histories and our life experiences — as well as the natural variations that we express as members of our species — all combine to form selves that operate distinctively in the world. Our differences emerge in what we pay attention to and how we respond. They are the raw material for collaborating and for combining our talents.</p><p>The value of our differences is evident from the density of human experience. Since there is so much to be attended to at every living moment, no one of us can possibly address it all. Only when we attune ourselves to one another as well as to the event can we hope to deal with the immensity of worldly circumstances.</p><p>A clear sense of another’s orientation and perception can become a point of navigation for understanding our own. Comparison brings insight. But to locate ourselves and others around differences of orientation, we need a shared language. And to be able to articulate and make use of individual difference, a certain quality of open-ness and acceptance of vulnerability is required — something unusual in conventional public discourse.</p><h4>Influences</h4><p>The continuing movement of the world subjects the relational self to influence and change. Some influences — such as shifts in the atmosphere — may be subtle but nonetheless profound. Our own bodily changes may be drawn-out events that alter our capacities and our selfhood in ways that pass un-noticed.</p><p>Our relational selves may be heavily influenced by our sense of the perceptions of others. And how we feel ourselves perceived can be quite different from how others might feel and how they might describe their perception of us. Such cross-currents of influence can be ephemeral and difficult to resolve.</p><p>Recognising how we are influenced may only come from comparison with the situations of others. And understanding how we are influencing others can be equally mysterious. However, having a sense of how our gestures and utterances ‘land’ with other people has considerable practical value. What we intend and project, and what is caught and felt, may be not at all the same thing.</p><h4>Tendencies</h4><p>If we understand ourselves as existing in relation to the movements of the world around us, it no longer makes sense to consider our behaviours and capacities as settled characteristics. Instead, we might think of them as tendencies, reaching towards certain kinds of responsiveness in typical but not yet fixed patterns.</p><p>From this comes an idea of selfhood as a bundle of tendencies — behaviours usual for us, but still open to influence and change. Observing one another in terms of tendencies rather than certainties feels more relationally generative. To find synergy with the efforts of others, we might think of our tendencies as ‘leanings towards’, as though our instincts and habits have a kind of gravitational attraction. With enough ‘escape velocity’ we can overcome or modify their force.</p><h4>Aliveness</h4><p>Relational being can generate a vibrant sense of ‘in-touchness’ with the energies of the world — a feeling of heightened awareness that seems to stretch out from the self towards the distant horizon, embracing every aspect of our surroundings. It’s a bodily sensation — a deep breath of life — that’s a sharp reminder of our physical presence as an inhabitant of a turbulent planet.</p><p>Aliveness is also a sense of possibility — that our sensations of profound connection may generate movement and change. That acting on the world can come from within our own experience, and recognising how, even with its hesitations and uncertainties, it reaches and touches others. That this can be more useful than trying to operate on the world from the distant certainty of an external perspective.</p><p>John Shotter distinguishes <em>aboutness</em> and <em>withness </em>ways of speaking <em>(*3)</em>. When we speak about something, that something is ‘over there’, separate from ourselves and immune to our feelings. But including, even centering, how we feel in our expression of something is to acknowledge our bodily existence in what is going. And this can be an invitation for others to acknowledge their feelings as well.</p><h4>Entanglement</h4><p>The experience of deep relationality reveals a state of being that may be best described as entanglement. It’s a circumstance that entails the re-positioning and even the dissolution of selfhood.</p><p>To be entangled is to move in step with others — to be <em>going on together, </em>as Wittgenstein proposes <em>(*4)</em>. What seems to happen is that the boundaries of individual expression fade away. Instead of turn-taking, utterances and gestures tumble in on and with each other in a kind of social music, so that when there’s a pause for breath and to consider the result, it’s no longer clear who did what in its formation. Mutual respect and understanding have reached a stage where each new movement and gesture contributes to an emerging shared sensibility. It’s an exciting experience.</p><p>In Rovelli’s terms, entanglement is a process — a kind of enfoldment where separation and identity are no longer important. Where No-thing is present.</p><h4>Unfinalisation</h4><p>To be attuned and in step with the constant flux of the world is to recognise the impossibility of completion — that matters are never fixed and final. Unlooked-for happenings and encounters will continue to arrive and will threaten to unmake what has just been made. I like the way Rovelli puts it: “The events of the world do not form an orderly queue, like the English. They crowd around chaotically, like Italians.” (He makes this wry observation as an Italian himself, not as a social critic.)</p><p>But unfinalisation is not a reason for despair. Instead it’s a reminder of the power of possibility and relationality — that instead of being preoccupied with results and outcomes, it’s the creation of a continuity of shared capacities to deal with whatever arrives that is the real achievement. Using differences as resources to be able to address surprises and uncertainties is part of this process. Shotter calls this a state of “poised resourcefulness”.</p><h4>Acceptance and resistance</h4><p>In this view of ourselves as beings with fuzzy boundaries, bombarded by and sensitive to the unordered happenings and influences of our surrounding circumstances, there is a question about the depth of this fuzziness. How open are we to all of this chaos, and is there some kind of a core that is impervious to influence?</p><p>I am thinking of a response to this question as the ‘art of entanglement’ — a capability to be learned and honed through experimentation and experience.</p><p>On the one hand, we want to be open to positive and useful influence. We want to be open to the wonders of the world and the unfoldings of the details and glories of our natural surroundings. We want to delight in the joy of communal happenings whether these are organised or spontaneous. We want to be able to accept noticings about ourselves when they increase our sensitivity to our relational footfall and improve our ability to operate in the midst of others.</p><p>But the world is also full of negative influences: attempts at coercion and manipulation by distracting us, confusing us and overwhelming our emotional defences. Here we want to practice scepticism and resistance.</p><p>Learning the balance between acceptance and resistance is a relational challenge that can be addressed with the help of others. I am imagining our ‘fuzziness’ as a capacity that we continually work on through trial and error and engagement with others. Within it, a denser core of selfhood is formed around our values and our moral determinations. Yet even these may one day be disturbed by the events of a living world.</p><h4>Appreciation</h4><p>An unexpected attribute of a more deeply relational being is a sense of appreciation for the emergent capacities of other beings. Close and considered encounters, even with strangers, can reveal details of another’s responses to the world that are different to our own and feel new and astonishing.</p><p>Such discoveries — when they are not about opinions, beliefs or finalised assertions, but are simply about the experience of the present moment — reveal the richness of human sensitivities in ways that evoke curiosity and admiration. And appreciation is an invitation to open ourselves up to the myriad possibilities of a truly relational world.</p><h4>Relational sovereignty</h4><p>From deeper and considered connection with others, and careful explorations of their entanglements and invitations, comes a sense of oneself that entails a more confident navigation of arriving circumstances and a happier and more easeful entry into new and existing human relationships.</p><p>This capacity can be thought of as relational sovereignty — strong and capable selfhood in the midst of a volatile world. It’s a capacity different from leadership, that is about prominence and separation from followers. Relational sovereignty is a fluid attribute, where the orientation and the role shifts and changes according to events and the capacities of others. It’s about the best fit to the the needs of each moment, something that might entail a carefully timed offer to others — or equally, might entail deference to the capability of another self. And unsurprisingly, relational sovereignty is a capacity best practised amongst the relational sovereignties of other people.</p><h4>A summary of a relational view of human experience</h4><ul><li><strong><em>In a relational world none of us is fixed and final, whether mouse or mountain</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>We are more like tendencies, always susceptible to influence</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>Influences bear on us from other tendencies and our own physicality</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>Our tendencies are like centripetal forces that form a bundle or cluster</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>Our relationality constitutes our aliveness and our entanglement</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>Our relationality is also a product of our encounters and our experiences</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>The influences that arise in and around us can be accidental and unconscious</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>They can be generative and affirming, and also disturbing and unsettling</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>The balance between acceptance and resistance is the art of entanglement</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>To invite others to recognise unfamiliar and un-noticed influences is to practise this art</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>Group swarming with differentiated influences makes for productive entanglement</em></strong></li><li><strong><em>Now we can move together through the world as constellations of appreciative, unfinalised essences</em></strong></li></ul><p>And so to return to Rovelli and quantum science: our view of <em>relationality </em>seems congruent with his; our sense of <em>unfinalisation</em> seems like a cousin of <em>indeterminacy</em>; but so far, <em>granularity </em>remains to be discovered here. However, there’s more to say about being human and particle physics…</p><h3>An arc of discovery</h3><p>The film <strong><em>Particle Fever (</em></strong><em>*5</em><strong><em>)</em></strong>appeared in 2013. I saw it at the New Zealand International Film Festival, and was immediately inspired. Not only was it a great story, but I was awed by the efforts and the dedication of those documented in the movie in exploring the effects of collisions between the fundamental elements of the cosmos — and also by the scale of the resources available to their enterprise. I immediately dreamt of constructing something like the Large Hadron Collider to examine the results of deliberately engineered human intra-actions.</p><p>Several years later, I have with colleagues been building and testing a facility that we might describe as a <strong>Small Human Collider</strong>. It operates as a series of workshop sessions for groups of five invited people with ourselves as the organising scientists, with the working title <strong><em>Entangled Bodies</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p>Using an internet Zoom facility as the container, we orchestrate a sequence of intra-actions or collisions over several sessions with the members of each group. All that I have written above about aspects of relational being are findings from these experiments.</p><p>The size of the group is deliberately small because of the richness and variety of responses that we seek to observe. And to cope with this complexity, we ‘slow down’ all of the intra-actions so that the details of the group experience and the exchanges that result become more easily visible.</p><p>We rely on the technology of recording to capture short utterances in an iterative pattern of exchanges. This allows us to conduct a series of conversations about our conversation. This way we are able to explore successive layers of mutual affect together.</p><p>It’s a ‘human collider’ because the experiment seeks to engage, or ‘collide’ people as far as possible without directing the nature of the collision. All of the intra-actions form a spontaneous chain of consequences from a shared encounter.</p><h4>Inside the human collider</h4><p>Our practice design makes a container that is designed to settle people and ensure they are comfortable. We explain that there are no rules for how they are to respond to what happens in the session — that whatever comes up for them is valuable.</p><p><strong><em>Step 1</em></strong>: We begin the experiment by inviting everyone to listen carefully to a short recorded conversation between two people who are entirely unfamiliar to them — the ‘provocation’. We explain that afterwards, we will ask everyone to withdraw from the Zoom chat and to each make a brief recording of their own, using WhatsApp, where they respond to the question, “What did you notice in what you heard?”\</p><p><strong><em>Step 2</em></strong>: We gather up people’s recorded responses on WhatsApp and play them back to the group straight through, from first to last. Then we invite an open discussion with the question, “What did you notice in each others’ noticings?”</p><p>We find that immediately, significant differences of orientation and forms of awareness have appeared in the recorded responses. These differences evoke surprise and curiosity. An appetite for further exploration grows.</p><p><strong><em>Step 3</em></strong>: We return to all of the group’s responses, and address each one separately in turn. First, we select the response and play it back to everyone again. Then we ask each other person to discuss what they have heard this time with the question, “What did you notice in this particular response?” When they have all spoken, we invite the responder themselves to speak, with the question, “What did you notice in the experience of being spoken about in this way?”</p><p>In this way we open up the discussion, slowing it down further to begin to focus on details, differences and unprompted observations as we make our way around the members of the group. Gradually, we are able to explore further questions, including</p><ul><li>What do you notice in each others’ noticings?</li><li>What do you notice in each others’ noticings of you?</li><li>What do a notice is being invited in your sense of yourself?</li><li>What do you notice is being invited in others’ sense of themselves?</li></ul><p>If this seems directive, in practice it is not so at all. The experience becomes one of a series of spontaneous, free-flowing exchanges, as people’s confidence in this level of attentiveness grows. Normally we are diffident about speaking directly about another person to their face. But in the safety of our container, a deeper sense of curiosity about one another’s natures is able to develop, often evoking delight, and eventually prompting appreciation for the honesty in the quirks of outlook and behaviour that are naturally revealed.</p><p>Here’s some of what happened for a recent group:</p><ul><li>Person C interpreted the recorded provocation in the light of their own experience with marked generosity and open-ness. The details of their experience invited disclosures of similar honesty from others</li><li>Person R recognised the frame and meta-context of the experience, noticing how new aspects of the ‘inside world’ of the group’s experience was brought out in their conversation. This orientation provided reassurance to the group</li><li>Person P paid close attention to the acoustics of the encounter, and how the movement of the group’s discussion was reflected in shifts in the sound of their voices — inviting others to do the same</li><li>Person T was tuned to the emotional resonance of the exchange, saw different group roles being invited, and explored a social context for the group’s experience. This gave people a sense of how their encounter in the container might play out beyond it</li><li>Person L was interested in the lessons for family life from the recording and the group’s response, noticing who asked questions and what they themselves were learning. Here there was an invitation beyond the details of the experience towards its potential for learning</li></ul><h4>Products of collision</h4><p>From our perspective as the scientists conducting the experiment, so far we’ve seen the following:</p><ul><li>Relational discoveries and understandings emerge strongly <strong>in small groups </strong>in a contained setting</li><li>The richness of human intra-action becomes clearer by <strong>slowing down</strong> the pace of exchanges</li><li>Recording conversations and then selecting particular utterances for <strong>listening again together </strong>is a practical means of slowing things down</li><li>The <strong>affordances of online gathering</strong> can help to focus attention and presence for this kind of multi-layered exchange</li><li>Listening again together immediately reveals <strong>unseen differences of orientation and purpose</strong></li><li>Discoveries are richer and more diverse for being <strong>unguided and unprompted</strong>, arising in effect as spontaneous collisions</li><li>A prospect of collaborative energy between the members of a group arises <strong>very quickly</strong></li><li>What begins is a new kind of conversational exchange in which people’s differences are spoken about with <strong>warmth and appreciation</strong></li><li>So group members learn <strong>how their capacities appear to others</strong>, and can start to see <strong>how to fit their strengths into a shared endeavour.</strong></li></ul><p>What we’ve come to understand is that a shared experience of <em>microattunement— </em>paying attention to carefully circumscribed intra-actions — makes room for unexpected otherness to enter into our own experience. And this effect occurs with remarkable speed.</p><h4>Possibilities from here</h4><p>From the outset, our enquiry has made constant use of technology. We began by recording and analysing conversations. Twenty years ago — in order to isolate and organise individual utterances, matching audio files to expert transcriptions — we had to develop our own software. Then, as we continued the work of slowing down people’s intra-actions through a practice of ‘listening again’, we found we could offset the intractability of audio files by encouraging people to record their noticings as brief (1–2-minute) responses. We learned that “less is more” — that brevity increases concentration and focus, allowing the richness of detail and the differences of orientations to be more easily seen.</p><p>In the same way, we learned that with sensitive convening, the nature of the online Zoom environment invites concentrated attention and presence. For one thing, the sound environment can be more closely controlled: we can hear each other clearly, and even better than in some face-to-face settings. Recording, listening again and conversational turn-taking all flow easily. Inside the ‘container’ there are few distractions, and the technology becomes largely invisible.</p><p>But since this work began two decades ago, technical capabilities around voice and facial recognition, transcription, translation, and pattern recognition have advanced considerably. Healthcare applications that detect bodily responsiveness from smartphones and wearable devices are now being developed, leading towards capabilities like gaze tracking, heart rate monitoring and observations of cognitive function, eg: <a href="https://www.cambridgecognition.com/images/uploads/Covid_Caregivers_poster_reduced_size.jpg">https://www.cambridgecognition.com/images/uploads/Covid_Caregivers_poster_reduced_size.jpg.</a></p><p>Our enquiry so far has been about skilled embodiment: that by locating selfhood more deeply in the midst of others and the moment-to moment maelstrom of the world, we can ‘make our collisions count for more’. So our efforts have emphasised increasing sensitivity and bodily awareness in learning practices within small groups and teams.</p><p>But now there is a question: Can we enhance this enablement with the careful use of newly-developed technologies? Given what we now recognise about the complexity of human encounters, should we try to further increase our sensitivity to what is going on between us with the help of AI tools? Could technology help us to catch and use more of what is going on between us in each moment?</p><p>There are lots of reason for extreme caution here. Recent history shows that the introduction of new tools and technologies can easily outstrip our ability to understand and moderate their effects. For example, the widespread use of simplistic algorithms to direct attention based on a history of search tracking produces effects that range from annoying to dangerous.</p><p>Digital analysis is always binary — switches and markers are either on or off. But human connections and relationships are non-binary — there’s always room for uncertainty and evanescence. In our work so far we’ve been learning to avoid mechanistic approaches that might lead us to make assumptions or to direct the experience into specific pathways, rather than letting encounters unfold with all their serendipity and creativity.</p><p>Suddenly, though, there’s a <em>frisson</em> of a counter-view. Despite the multiplicity of our sense-organs, and the enormous complexity of the intra-actions these invite — so that relationality is the confluence of many different sense-impressions — what if our “fractal improvisational mutual communing” (as Nora Bateson puts it) is not infinite in its variety, but just the combination of a very large number of possible network collisions? Could relationality actually exhibit Rovelli’s <strong>granularity</strong>? Might there be some kind of fundamental particles of affect and intra-action? And could we discover these as patterns for learning and teaching?</p><p>We might put the question in this way: is there an ethical middle ground for synergy between <em>inviting </em>and <em>predicting </em>human behaviours?<em> </em>It’s a difficult question — one that<em> </em>belongs to many other enterprises and is already being considered elsewhere, for example as <em>bioethics</em>. But for our part, we might perhaps lean on <strong>difference</strong> as our animating principle. Instead of allowing the practice to develop from the predictive insight of a single orientation— like the products of Silicon Valley — continuous exposure to differences of orientation, intention and belief in our explorations might keep our initiative in balance. We shouldn’t be afraid to consider things — but at the same time to keep questioning, being critical, and advancing with caution — in the spirit of Rovelli’s science of successive approximations.</p><h4>Ontologies of encounter practice</h4><p>Perhaps we can proceed as follows. To use technology to enhance our collective awareness and noticing capabilities, we have to begin by guessing what is worth noticing in the first place. But these are only guesses. If we are always open to the possibility that our guesses are entirely wrong — and other things matter instead — we can learn as we go and adapt or abandon the approaches we have tried.</p><p>So we might start with our aim to improve the relational quality of encounters. And then it makes sense to consider, What kind of qualities do we want to improve?</p><p>There might be a spectrum of these qualities. And their importance may differ according to the nature of the encounter. Whatever the purpose, a crucial influencing factor is the <em>number of people</em> ‘in the room’ and who take part in the exchange. A taxonomy of scales is set out here by my colleague Richard Bartlett: <a href="https://www.microsolidarity.cc/">https://www.microsolidarity.cc/essays/five-scales-of-microsolidarity</a></p><p>The focus of the present initiative has been at the middle of these scales: the <strong>crew</strong><em> </em>or small group, including people in contained gatherings or meetings who are looking to do something together.</p><p>Here, from our efforts so far, are some first thoughts about how a verbal ontology of relational practice might be constructed:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/868/1*sSdW16ekNP0kAo6UzSJ0zQ.png" /></figure><p>On the left-hand side of the table are relatively straightforward practices of productive conversational behaviour — the kinds of behaviours encouraged by a good facilitator or group convener. Moving from left to right across the table are progressively deeper experiences of relationality — understandings of both selfhood and otherness — that increasingly promote opportunities for synergy between the distinctive capabilities of those present. On the right-hand side, the members of a group are so invested in the shared pursuit of their enterprise that their collaborative entanglement becomes entirely spontaneous and unremarked.</p><p>It’s worth restating that these are just guesses. For example, there might be good relational flow in a conversation where one person does most of the talking, or where others don’t speak at all. Study of real conversations will discover if these are outliers or regular examples. And generative practice will differ according to the domain of the encounter — for example at a specialised workplace, a public event, or a family meeting.</p><p>But this first guess at a generalised ontology builds on many sources — for example the Dreyfus model of skill acquisition from the 1980’s— as well as our own experiments. And a particular memory comes to mind: a Danish pre-school adviser explaining that she could judge the quality of the teaching and learning experience in a particular classroom just by the sound of the room. This points towards the likelihood that a developed ontology of relationality might eventually incorporate a wide range of non-verbal markers of human response, including the tonal features of the exchanges — that, like a piece of music, might help to understand what’s going on.</p><p>In this connection, there are some interesting lessons in the world of music from the art of sound design:</p><blockquote>In the past, acousticians relied primarily on what was easiest to measure — things like frequencies and reverberation times…(but in) concert-hall design… this started to change in the 1990’s when acousticians began o rely more on their ears, informed by historical precedence, than their measurement devices…psychoacoustics is the study of how mood, colour, sense of place and other emotional factors affect the way people perceive and understand music (from the <em>New Yorker,</em> October 10th 2022)</blockquote><h4>Understandings from pre-literacy</h4><p>Explorations in the deployment of human difference have led to an experience of the protocols of encounter on the Māori marae, or meeting ground. The marae is a collection of buildings and spaces designed for events and occasions where people gather for communal purposes, including visits, ceremonies and celebrations, involving a deep connection with the land and ancestry of that place.</p><p>A clue to the function of the marae came from a remark to me by Teina Moetara of the Rongowhakaata iwi at Manutuke near Gisborne. “Growing up on the marae,” he explained, “we learn to use our differences as resources for one another.”</p><p>An invitation to learn about the encounter practices on the marae came through a series of visits hosted by Teina and Ngapaki Moetara. As a group of learners, we began to understand gatherings there as a carefully sequenced set of movements between manuhiri (visitors) and tangata whenua (the people of that place, or hosts). Each move had a distinct mood and character. Together, they were designed to draw the visitors and hosts together into deeper relationship in readiness for the event’s purpose — and then (perhaps over several days) to lead onwards towards a satisfactory conclusion.</p><p>It became clear that the quality of the encounter practice is reinforced by its physical structure and its profoundly metaphorical character. Each part of the marae is configured around a specific set of activities against a background of custom and historical narratives, often illustrated by carvings, weavings or building structures.</p><p>What this means is that the sequence of activities on the marae is performed from specific localities. Over time, members of the community learn which place best suits their particular talents and orientations. Yet these places are never fixed and final: there is sufficient mutual understanding that people may substitute for one another if the need arises.</p><p>The whole is a physical and social architecture of human intra-action that has evolved in a close-knit, oral society. Respecting this pattern, we would like to explore approaches that might support a movement in today’s individualised world towards something more relational.</p><h4>The metaphor of a vessel</h4><p>The Māori marae exemplifies a practice of differential capability that has <strong><em>dimensionality</em></strong>: established orientations that are expressed from specific localities across a network or a landscape of joined-up activities. In our world, there are echoes of historical dimensionality in places of ritual such as parliaments, churches and courts.</p><p>But in our present everyday activities, there are no structures and few routines to guide us. Moreover, a strong physical connection to an ancestral locality is largely lost in a world of commuting, travel, migration, global reach and other kinds of displacement.</p><p>Our human collider workshops have fostered the recognition that there is a <strong><em>container</em></strong> for the activity: a sense of enclosure, within which encounters are recorded and interpreted as a preparation for dealing with events outside the container. From this has evolved the metaphor of a <strong>vessel </strong>to represent a group activity or enterprise.</p><p>Unlike the marae, the vessel is constantly in movement. We imagine it floating gracefully above a metaphorical landscape of onrushing events. It has portholes and places of observation directed both outside and inside the vessel. A different form of work is enabled from each viewpoint. Through a series of iterations, and inspired in part by Te Ao Māori, we have devised a pattern of entangled orientations that are intended as a complete whole, that makes up an example of the ‘discriminative synergy’ described in the right-hand column in the spectrum of relationality above.</p><p>To the front, the orientation is towards what’s coming up. The work is to separate out and distill the events and occurrences that are most important for the enterprise amidst the writhing tendrils of the many external calls for attention. We might call this orientation <strong><em>mattering</em></strong>.</p><p>To the rear, the orientation is to the ground beneath, as though there were a kind of sea-anchor that reaches into and trawls the soil and rocks passed over by the vessel. Here the work is to recognise the character of the historical understructure: the understandings and values that can keep the enterprise on an even keel. This orientation is called <strong><em>grounding</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p>Within the vessel, there is an orientation that reaches all around the interior and embraces everyone inside. The work here is to arrange and manage the circumstances within the vessel to nourish and sustain the physical and mental well-being of the whole crew. This is an orientation of <strong><em>caring</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p>Also within the vessel is an individually focused orientation with a high degree of acuity. The task here is to pay detailed attention to each utterance and gesture so as to detect what is present but unsaid — to pay attention to what lies beneath the surface of exchanges and bring out any important missings. A name for this orientation is <strong><em>diving</em></strong>.</p><p>Finally there is an orientation that attends to the passage and the movements of the vessel both within and in relation to external circumstances. As it moves across the vibrant landscape of the world, we imagine that the vessel leaves a kind of wake or disturbance in the atmosphere behind it. The work here is to capture this disturbance as a narrative account or story of the enterprise. Because this account stitches disparate moments of the crew’s experiences together, we might call this orientation <strong><em>weaving</em></strong>.</p><p>Our thinking is that a set of orientations may be normative: that is, they combine to make a whole that best sustains the enterprise. Within this combination, the importance of each orientation may be differently weighted according to circumstances.</p><p>Here’s a candidate image for the vessel:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/814/1*aSZg9oYYJy8RGB7FqOxVQA.png" /><figcaption>Studio Ghibli: Howl’s Moving Castle</figcaption></figure><p>And here it is as a diagram:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9qFeXBvFO0fWuldPLs0g4g.jpeg" /></figure><h4>The potential contributions of AI</h4><p>Given recent advances in voice recognition and translation, it is worth imagining some first steps towards the use of AI in furthering the verbal relationality of everyday encounters, in the workplace or otherwise.</p><p>One approach might start at the ‘flow’ end of the relational spectrum above. This would involve making judgements about which conversational behaviours are inviting and productive, either within a specific encounter domain or alternatively, without specific reference to context. For example, we could first look to encourage exchanges that feel safe and considerate.</p><p>As I understand it, we have to train an AI engine by taking a large sample of recorded material in order to encode the things that we want the engine to look for. To invite good practice, we first have to find examples of good practice and then encode for that.</p><p>So we might begin with a small set of variables (say, utterance length, turn-taking, utterance completion, tolerance of pauses), encode some conversational samples for these, and produce some test analyses.</p><p>We will then have some intriguing considerations about how to try connecting the AI engine to actual conversational practice.</p><p>In the first instance, we might work asynchronously. With a test group, a conversation is chosen, recorded and analysed. The results are passed back to the group for consideration and potential incorporation into later practice.</p><p>A next stage might be to explore real-time analysis and response. Here a running or a periodic analysis might be available to members of the group who can make decisions about whether or not to intervene to try to influence the flow of exchanges.</p><p>The possibility of real-time intervention against a running transcript of the discussion is also an affordance for a valuable aspect of our experimental practice so far — the practice of ‘listening again’ to a particular utterance to divine further layers of meaning and understanding.</p><p>All of this supposes a very different experience of conversational working than one without intervention. Real-time feedback and learning may turn out to be be disturbing, distracting, confusing and annoying for participants. Carefully staged experiments will be needed to discover what people might accept and find useful.</p><h4>Directions for a research and development trajectory</h4><p>Some thoughts about our next steps, either as sequential, parallel or alternative tasks, and questions these entail:</p><p><strong>1.Discuss and consider the validity and practicality of ontologies of relational practice. </strong>Are there ‘good conversational practices’ with general application? Or does ‘good’ alter with context, and in different domains of activity? Could they form a spectrum of deepening relationality, and how could we tell if this is happening? How does this idea fit with existing research orientations around the affordances of human encounter within the social and physical sciences, and can we build on these?</p><p>We might look for contributions to these questions from a range of fields, including psychology; family and personal therapies; interpersonal skill development in hospital and medical practice; group organisation and management practices; and neuroscience and cognitive studies, as well as others like ethnology and media studies.</p><p>2.E<strong>xtend our Entangled Bodies initiative towards a domain of urgent present need. </strong>Can we find a situation where the recognition and deployment of difference can build demonstrably stronger — even mission-critical — capability? One where there is scope for demonstrating the value of the intervention by comparing parallel or ‘before-and-after’ effects?</p><p>We might look for circumstances where agencies or operations with distinctive traditions and orientations are to be brought together to build better shared understanding and joined-up responsiveness. This way we could add real value through the deployment of difference. We can also build a large body of recorded conversational practice to draw on in further learning.</p><p><strong>3.Set up an initial experiment in enhancing conversational productivity that uses AI. </strong>Can we identify a suitable body of recorded conversational material for analysis and AI training? And can we find and organise a conversational domain with willing participants for some early experiments?</p><p>There is a tempting array of sensory observations that we might explore here, including text, sound, image, gesture and other kinds of biomarkers.</p><p>Our enterprise has been directed towards the possibility of recognising and improving human relationality. But beyond this prospect lurk some more open-ended questions: What do our doings do? In our dealings with one another and the world, what happens? What matters? What makes a difference? Our efforts might contribute to their answers.</p><p>Ideally we need a professional research partner for this activity. Could we find a partner that could eventually follow this development across a spectrum of relational practices and through a variety of sensory faculties, technologies and apparatuses?</p><p>There’s a large agenda in all of this, and it might best be initiated by association with existing research and development efforts rather than as a stand-alone enterprise.</p><h4>Postscript</h4><p>I’ve been reading Rovelli’s writings as I’ve been drafting this piece. And I’ve just come across some passages that seem to connect us even more closely. In <em>The Order of Time</em>, he discusses the nature of human identity, proposing that there are three ingredients: first, that each of us “identifies with <em>a point of view</em> in the world. The world is reflected in each one of us in a rich spectrum of correlations essential for our survival.” This precisely is our notion of <em>orientation.</em></p><p>Second, he suggests that “in the process of reflecting on the world, we organise it into entities…In particular, we group into a unified image the processes…that are other human beings, because our life is social…they are <em>knots of cause and effect</em> that are deeply relevant to us.” I am astonished by how closely the language here mirrors out own.</p><p>But then he introduces a third ingredient that lurks behind our typology, but one that we have not specifically named: <strong><em>memory</em></strong>. “Our present swarms with traces of our past,” he says.</p><blockquote>“I am my thoughts full of the traces of the phrases I am writing; I am my mother’s caresses, and the serene kindness with which my father calmly guided me; I am my adolescent travels; I am what my reading has deposited in layers in my mind; I am my loves, my moments of despair, my friendships, what I’ve written, what I’ve heard; the faces engraved on my memory. I am, above all, the one who a minute ago made a cup of tea for himself.”</blockquote><p>How could I not be moved by this reminder? Not that our memories exist in ourselves, but the opposite: that ourselves <em>exist as memories</em>? And that these are what we bring to others in all of our dealings — No-thing but our accumulated and recalled <em>ways of being human in the world</em>?</p><p><em>Wellington, 25th October 2022</em></p><h4><strong><em>References:</em></strong></h4><p>(1a) Carlo Rovelli (2016) <strong><em>Reality Is Not What It Seems</em></strong>, Allen Lane, London</p><p>(1b) Carlo Rovelli (2018) <strong><em>The Order of Time</em></strong>, Riverhead Books, New York</p><p>(1c) Carlo Rovelli (2020) <strong><em>Helgoland</em></strong>, Allen Lane, London</p><p>(1d) Carlo Rovelli (2020) <strong><em>There Are Places in the World Where Rules Are Less Important Than Kindness</em></strong>, Allen Lane, London</p><p>(2) Eva Pallesen (2022) <strong><em>Slippery Inquiry: Engaging with the Vague and Half-Glimpsed</em></strong>, Qualitative Inquiry 1–7, Sage Publications</p><p>(3) John Shotter (2005) <strong><em>Understanding Process from Within: An Argument for ‘Withness’ Thinking</em></strong>, Organization Studies 27(4): 585–604</p><p>(4) Ludwig Wittgenstein (1953), <strong><em>Philosophical Investigations</em></strong><em>,</em> Blackwell</p><p>(5) Mark Levinson (2013), director, <strong><em>Particle Fever</em></strong><em>, a documentary film by Anthos Media</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c72ffc75ac71" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How AI can help us to transform our listening]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@taptiklis/how-ai-can-help-us-to-transform-our-listening-975e9c506e46?source=rss-d692d077701a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/975e9c506e46</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[conversational-ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[team-collaboration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[listening]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Theodore Taptiklis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 May 2023 05:30:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-05T05:34:00.155Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/692/1*27qSDfdyzWXKK1iMkXKPhw.png" /><figcaption>With thanks to Ethan Kobayashi-Hseih</figcaption></figure><h4><strong><em>Here we are</em></strong></h4><p>As if unbidden war, pestilence, autocracy, poverty and human displacement, planetary heating and degradation weren’t enough, we’ve now been visited by an apparently apocalyptic, era-defining technology. Having wintered and withered more than once in fifty years, AI has suddenly blossomed into a rampant and apparently uncontrollable force of nature.</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xoVJKj8lcNQ">Tristan Harris and Aza Raskin</a>, dubbing generative large learning multi-modal models (GLLMM) as ‘Gollems”, show that developments in what were distinct and specialised research silos (speech recognition, robotics, image generation, music generation, speech synthesis and computer vision — and perhaps also sensory biomarkers in healthcare) — have coalesced since 2017 into an integrated predictive language capability that is embracing and mimicking every aspect of human behaviour. Now the hyper-exponential speed of these developments — AI teaching AI, say Harris and Raskin — can multiply the unintended effects of social media by leading to the collapse of reality (fake everything, the evisceration of trust and the edifice of law, automated fake religions and cyberweapons, and much more besides). All of this is in the hands of technology enterprises who — regardless of the consequences — are focused on the race for for the commercial high ground of the greatest possible intimacy with users — the position of maximum control of everyone’s attention.</p><h4><strong><em>And yet</em></strong></h4><p>The challenge is both deeper and more historical than this. It goes to our affordances as human creatures in a world of other human and non-human creatures. Our ability to withstand and temper this new technology onslaught has been undermined over centuries of socialisation that have channelled and occluded our sensory capacities. But our capacities have not disappeared. They remain within us, just waiting to be opened up again.</p><p>I’ve been playing with a notion I’ve called <strong>the shrunken self</strong>. This is a way, first, to recognise the richness of the means we have for engaging with the world. These come from the intra-operation of all of our bodily capacities, traced and carefully described in great detail by <a href="https://monoskop.org/images/d/df/Gibson_James_J_The_Sense_Considered_as_Perceptual_Systems_1966.pdf">James J Gibson</a> around fifty years ago. Second, it’s an attempt to show how, in our increasingly individualised and isolationist world, these capacities are reduced to their most-internalised versions. And third, it indicates a prospect of a movement towards its opposite: <strong>the resonant self</strong>, open, curious, engaging, connecting and entangling with otherness in as many ways as possible. My effort to picture this notion is drawn here:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DIUZ3k88nKis2Q91DQnMNA.jpeg" /></figure><h4><strong><em>The shrunken and the resonant self</em></strong></h4><p>There’s a long trajectory behind the shrunken self. Our atomisation comes especially from the reinforcing hegemony of words and writing that privilege certain kinds of articulation, conformity and elitism in daily conduct and from the domination of our highly text-dependent institutions. Our literacy bias activates our faculties of abstraction, deconstruction and individuation. And the corresponding absence of emotional acceptance and compassion in public and private discourse leaves many of us feeling clenched and defensive, separated from otherness, brittle and vulnerable, easily triggered, and even abandoned. As <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UZABhHWGhSE">Vanessa Andreotti (<em>Hospicing Modernity</em>)</a> puts it, even our unconscious has been colonised by our history of expropriation and exploitation, restricting what we can see, feel and imagine, and channelling us into patterns of consumption that maintain our subservience. Harris and Raskin now show that this narrowing of our sensibilities has been rapidly accelerating, fuelled first by the rise of social media and now by unbounded AI. A generation ago, the response to increasing interiorisation and separation was <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Unmanaging-Opening-Organization-Unspoken-Knowledge/dp/0230573525">a kind of grumpy acceptance</a> (Ch 3); now the social mood is evidently turning to <a href="https://thespinoff.co.nz/society/08-05-2023/across-new-zealand-tempers-seem-shorter-than-ever-is-it-always-going-to-be-like-this">fear and anger</a>.</p><p>There’s also clinical evidence for the idea of the shrunken self as a diagnosis. Mental health researchers have been tracking the movement of individuals towards psychosis in their internet behaviour, such as their search activity and social media posts. <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41537-019-0085-9">They note a decline in word frequencies that relate to work, friends, and health, and an increase in self-referential focus.</a> “Suddenly things that are typically neutral in the environment (for healthy individuals) take on the kind of significance that arise as delusions in schizophrenia.” The researchers (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6T3vUgS8TtY">teams from Northwell Health, Cornell Tech and IBM Research</a>) note that indicators of withdrawal from worldly engagement, such as the loss of open-ended curiosity, have predictive value for remedial interventions.</p><p>The resonant self, on the other hand, entails the convergence and entanglement of human difference: what comes when the distinctive orientations of people working together combine to make a capability ‘greater than the sum of the parts’. It’s visible, for example, in the pre-modern, pre-literate encounter practices of Te Ao Māori in New Zealand, that orchestrate a careful sequence of moves through a physical and vocal landscape of human connection in which each person has learned to operate from their own ‘best place’. If we recognise the world as events, rather than as structures or as objects (“kisses, not stones” — <a href="https://www.penguin.co.nz/books/the-order-of-time-9780141984964">Carlo Rovelli</a>), resonance can be understood as arising from the complex <em>intra-action</em> (<a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0959354314541984">John Shotter</a>) of bodily movements and emanations, and the patterns of <em>diffractio</em>n (<a href="https://www.dukeupress.edu/meeting-the-universe-halfway">Karen Barad</a>) that they generate. And it’s taken up by <a href="https://medium.com/@hanzifreinacht/what-can-stop-the-ai-apocalypse-grammar-yes-only-grammar-fe6ab26cc30d">Hanzi Freinacht</a> in his response to the onrush of AI, characterising our task as “structuring reality into resonant wholes” in order to create “a social justice AI”. But this yearning, and the resonance that is envisaged — for example, in <a href="https://www.gameb.wiki/index.php?title=Game_B">Jim Rutt’s Game B proposal for a new society</a> — still feels there like a distant dream.</p><h4><strong><em>The asymmetry of our senses</em></strong></h4><p>We relate to the world and to each other through our senses. And we have a rich array of senses that are carefully arranged to undertake different kinds of perception in synchrony with each other. As many as eight human senses are now recognised, grouped by how far from the body they detect signals:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/637/1*8RIOxe88_s1Rl4w_j4vPLg.png" /></figure><p>The resonant self deploys all of these sensory capacities. But our responsive communication with the world is principally enabled through our faculties of sight and hearing — though we are sensing and feeling the atmosphere, our physical environment, and our bodily states at the same time.</p><p>Our distance-oriented faculties of sight and hearing operate in entirely different ways. We see the world by concentrating our visual attention, with our gaze. At the same time, our gaze flickers across the scene, so that we can take in ‘the whole picture’. But at any moment, we can return our gaze to an earlier point to reassure ourselves that what we glimpsed is really still there. Sight therefore paints and repaints a picture, affirming a continuity of the existence of the visible world — a sense that things are themselves, objects beyond our own body. This means that we experience a kind of ‘over-there-ness’: an arena in front of us that is filled with light, shade, and the depth and movement of ‘things that are not-us’.</p><p>In contrast, hearing is a quite different kind of experience. What we hear ‘pours into us’ as an entirety: as an undifferentiated whole. We have a name for this whole — sound — for which the visual equivalent — view — is seldom used instead of the names for the individual objects of our gaze. And sound has no continuity. As soon as we have heard a moment of it, it has gone forever. To understand and distinguish its meaning, we have to do the cognitive work of focusing on its particular source and character (the ‘cocktail party’ phenomenon). Sight is a straight-line capacity: but we can hear around corners. And unlike most of the objects of vision, sound is continually altering from moment to moment. So to make sense of it — for example, something that is said to us — we have to deploy our memory, retaining our grip on earlier sense-impressions to connect them with the present (and at the same time, anticipating what might come next). Hearing confers a heavier cognitive load on us than does sight. From these differences, hearing brings us a different kind of world from that of sight. Instead of a world of objects, hearing delivers a world of events, that have duration and locality in time and a corresponding sense of occasion.</p><p>In human exchanges, the faculty of hearing delivers speech to the hearer with a great variety of pitch, tone and rhythm that goes to characterise each speaker and each utterance. There are layers of affect in a spoken sound event that invite and guide the response of the hearer. In making their own voice response, the hearer begins a relational practice through the qualities of the sound that they generate. The subtleties of the qualities in human vocal exchanges interpenetrate the bodies of each party to arouse their background sensibilities and influence their responses. When a hearer speaks in reply, they hear their own voice differently than the voice of the other, through bone conduction. Managing the relationship between these two separate sound channels is a further cognitive effort. We never quite match the two — so hearing our own recorded voice can be disconcerting, in the way that it differs from our aural experience at the time of our speaking.</p><p>So hearing speech, and responding with our own, is a rich sound-and-voice duality with a great deal of relational complexity (so much, in fact, that our own experiments — see below — demonstrate that aspects of its unfolding richness are easily missed). The equivalent duality with sight is initiating or returning another’s gaze — something with such intensity that we are uncomfortable maintaining it directly for more than a few seconds. So we conclude that the affordances of hearing and speaking with others are more extended, more layered, more nuanced and more relationally influential than the affordances of seeing and exchanging gazes with others. Though sight, gaze and facial expression might invite an encounter, it takes hearing and voice to deepen and develop it. For the quality of relationality and resonance that we yearn for, listening and speaking are what matters most.</p><h4><strong><em>A world out of balance</em></strong></h4><p>In a pre-literate world, most communication was oral. Knowledge was created and remembered orally in poems, songs, stories and rituals. To communicate with others, you had to be within hearing distance, so the scale of gatherings and shared activities was determined by the ‘thrown-ness’ of the human voice. Styles of speaking were tuned to the protocols of different occasions. Oratory was valued and taught. In gatherings, the different timbres of the male and female voice, projection techniques like ululation; rhetorical gesture and harmonisation; the incorporation of coordinated movement; and the amplification possibilities of reflection and echo, all worked together to multiply the varieties and purposes of communal oral expression as a relational medium. The flourishing of oral cultures through the long millennia of human history was born from the entanglement and resonance of distinctively oriented sensing bodies, building and developing capacities and patterns of sounds, language, movements, moods and memory traces together.</p><p>But the advent of alphabetisation and writing changed everything. Written expression enlarged human societies through the replication of ideologies, the ‘fixing’ of social orders and the projection of power at a distance, while forging self-consciousness, identity and individualism by separating people in the isolation of the acts of writing and reading. Gradually, text came to supplant oral expression. Now the written word is the hegemon, deeply enshrined in our institutions and our practices of governance and regulation. By elevating literacy — teaching writing and reading at an early age — we emphasise the importance of sight, and in doing so, we pay less attention to the value of hearing and speaking and their relational affordances. At the same time, vision (and the conceptual abstraction associated with it) <a href="https://www.fordhampress.com/9780823227730/listening/">has become a dominant paradigm in Western thought</a>:</p><p><em>“Philosophical thinking about perception has focused predominantly on vision. The philosophical puzzle of perception and its proposed solutions has been shaped by a concern for visual experience and visual illusions…detailed accounts of what we perceive frequently address just the visual case…</em><a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/perception-auditory/"><em>much of the philosophy of perception translates roughly as philosophy of visual perception</em></a><em>”.</em></p><p>So we’ve made a world where in public life, the persistence and permanence of silent, vision-mediated text has largely pushed aside the relational sensitivities of the evanescent spoken word.</p><h4><strong><em>Towards a new orality</em></strong></h4><p>For several years we’ve been exploring a way of working that seeks to tilt the balance in our everyday dealings away from sight and the written word towards the meanings that are present in the human voice. Its starting point is a practice of listening again, or <strong><em>recursive listening</em></strong>: using the technology of recording to capture and re-hear moments of spoken exchange to uncover their details for reflective consideration and appreciation of the importance of human difference. We’ve been finding that as people sink into a deeper listening experience, a relational alteration begins. By hearing their own voices in the midst of others, and by speaking about and recognising the significance of their different noticings of one another, an emotional tone and mood develops that invites a mutuality of curiosity, respect, understanding and even awe.</p><p>These practices, that we call <strong>Entangled Bodies</strong>, demonstrate that in each of our voices ‘<a href="https://poets.org/poem/song-myself-51">there are multitudes</a>’. At the same time, it is only with care and repetition that their layers of resonance reveal themselves.</p><p>And because our utterances are so aurally dense, it is impossible to grasp all this richness at one hearing, especially without experience or training. For example, one of the great students of the human utterance — Mikhail Bakhtin — points out that when we speak, <a href="https://www.sup.org/books/title/?id=2937">we are never simply addressing those in front of us</a>, but at the same time appealing to a ‘superaddressee’ (perhaps our parents, or posterity). There’s always an unvoiced yearning or aspiration in our speaking — and with careful and studied attention, especially by ‘listening again’ — we’ve found it possible to catch a sense of this ‘other’.</p><p>The richness of our meanings and the complexity of their resonances also point toward the value of the small group as the unit of practical achievement. Though there’s too much going on for any one of us to grasp, the different natural orientations of the members of a group mean that we can make better sense of our utterances together. Richard Bartlett, author of <a href="https://www.microsolidarity.cc/"><em>Microsolidarity</em></a>, argues for a small group or crew of four to six people as ideal for serious development work. In Entangled Bodies (built out of a sister practice to Microsolidarity called <a href="https://medium.com/between-us/a-unity-of-unmerged-voices-a-proposal-to-synchronise-our-efforts-through-microattunement-870922e7082f"><em>Microattunment</em></a>) we’ve found that five is a great number, with intentional asymmetry. Hanzi Freinacht (referenced earlier) argues for the ‘meta-team’: “a small number of closely allied friends who collaborate professionally in order to achieve idealistic and political goals”. The number matters: large enough for real difference and variety of outlook, but small enough for safety, intimacy and trust.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/339/1*3fp4lLS8s8iB7jNFpi9Yjg.png" /></figure><p>As a result, the complexity of the pathways from the shrunken to the resonant self (the earlier illustration) can be navigated by team members who move in different ways, but are oriented towards the same awakening. Recordings of striking moments from group encounters can act as reminders and reinforcers of changes in mood and tone.</p><p>The context for this work is a burgeoning interest in the affordances of all of our bodily senses and in deepening our collaborative capacities. The growth of ‘inner work’, the rise of mindfulness and meditative practices, and the translation of therapeutic interventions into organisational setting are examples of this movement. Reflective group “recursive listening” is a touchstone here, distinctive because it requires no theorising or preparatory explanation, its focus on difference is naturally inclusive, and because the learning experience is entirely emergent and unique to each group and each occasion. It sits with the increasing recognition that the real challenges we face in the world are not about <strong><em>what things to do</em></strong>, but about <strong><em>how to do things</em></strong>. The importance of the ‘how’ is well exemplified by the deliberately gentle gathering practices (feeling-shape) of Peter Limberg of the Stoa, underscored in his recent essay <a href="https://lessfoolish.substack.com/p/meme-to-vibe-a-philosophical-report"><em>Meme to Vibe</em></a>. Whatever the concerns and questions that trouble us, the key to the resonance that we seek lies in changing the ways that we speak with each other.</p><h4><strong><em>The contributions of AI</em></strong></h4><p>To return to the AI apocalypse: some of the most striking recent responses are not about withdrawing from the phenomenon, but are about engaging much further and deepening and extending it. Here are some examples:</p><p>(1) From Douglas Rushkoff — <a href="https://rushkoff.medium.com/teach-your-children-even-if-theyre-ais-fe4a059fbd33"><em>“Treat it as a child that needs to be embraced, nurtured and taught”</em></a>.</p><p>(2) From John Vervaeke: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-_RdKiDbz4">“<em>Respond relationally and spiritually: recognise sample bias from the finitude of the data, and increase the sensitivity of the machines so they can love wisely”</em>.</a></p><p>(3) From Hanzi Freinacht: <em>“</em><a href="https://medium.com/@hanzifreinacht/what-can-stop-the-ai-apocalypse-grammar-yes-only-grammar-fe6ab26cc30d"><em>Accept Donna Harraway’s notion of the cyborg and optimise for resonance — expanding our sense of self to include the technological environment”</em></a>.</p><p>Our discussion of sight versus sound, text versus voice, is directly relevant here. The vast reaches of the internet that AI draws from are mostly denatured text, cleaned, organised and carefully arranged (like this document) with none of the infelicities, hesitations, repetitions, quirks and non-verbal sounds and incipient biomarkers of ordinary conversational speech*.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/801/1*d5GpmkwOTMs1rhkym5CCRw.png" /></figure><p>So why don’t we simply <strong>flood the digital realm with our everyday conversation</strong>? Bring the whole of ourselves to the data? If the processing power of AI is now unlimited, let’s throw the whole of our world at it!</p><p>And in taking the meanings of our utterances and our phenomenological differences more seriously, we’ve already seen many ways that AI can be helpful:</p><ul><li>AI can parse conversational speech by marking and indexing the start and end of each utterance;</li><li>AI can distill speech corpora into themes and patterns. These can reveal the distinctive orientations of each speaker — and from appropriate samples, how these change over time;</li><li>AI can identify ‘striking moments’ in speech (samples of altered vocal quality) and make them available for re-hearing;</li><li>As a background capability, AI can make any utterance available for ‘listening again’. So in a gathering, we might pause and invite people to listen again to something just said, slowing down and deepening our appreciation of our exchanges.</li></ul><p>In short, AI can make both synchronous and recorded speech as tractable as text, helping to redress our present sensory imbalance.</p><h4><strong><em>‘Inner work’ for everyone</em></strong></h4><p>So far, we’ve been working with groups of professionals who are curious about their own capacities in the midst of others, and are already drawn towards self-improvement. This population tends to see a deliberate orientation towards ‘inner work’ as the starting point for learning better relational skills and collaborative abilities.</p><p>But we’ve been discovering that if people in groups simply listen closely enough to one another — slowing down their exchanges by ‘listening again’ and giving space for noticing and appreciating the differences between them — the inner work ‘just happens’ without any deliberation.</p><p>The change comes through <em>iteratively recursive practice</em>: listening together to a provocation and recording noticings separately — then listening to each person’s noticing in turn, and recognising how their different orientations to the world are being revealed in their speaking. We follow a careful sequence of noticings, and then noticings of noticings, distilling what we learn as we go. And we find that being present to the layers of meaning in the everyday speech of others, and to how our own responses land with them, is enough to invite a change in attitudes and behaviour in ourselves.</p><p>In other words, everything we need for ‘inner work’ is already there — if we can enlarge ourselves beyond the habits of our shrunken existence, and allow what naturally arises between us into our bodies and our minds. The resulting ‘resonant self’ is not only more skilled and attentive, but is more settled and at ease with themselves in the world at large.</p><p>Of course, overcoming habits — perhaps the habits of a lifetime — is not easy. That’s why group practice is so helpful, because it can settle our inner critic and normalise our doubts, uncertainties and hesitations. In this way, we can start to do together what is difficult to do by ourselves. For these reasons, we propose that this kind of recursive listening practice is not just for ‘self-improvers’, but can work for anyone who is prepared to engage their relational curiosity.</p><h4><strong><em>Use cases for recursive listening</em></strong></h4><p>Four qualities are unique to this practice:</p><ol><li><em>The changes begin quickly.</em> An alteration in the mood and tone of a group’s conversational exchanges starts immediately. A great deal is achieved in three 90-minute learning sessions.</li><li><em>It’s directly tuned to needs. </em>The work begins with a provocation: a listening exercise using a fragment of recorded conversation. There is an art to a selection that’s calibrated to the needs of a particular group.</li><li><em>It requires no special preparation. </em>There are no abstract ideas, models or vocabularies to be absorbed beforehand. Everything flows from the individuals in the room and what they bring.</li><li><em>It is non-brutally honest</em>. It enables people to speak directly to and about one another in great detail, in ordinary language, even as strangers, without giving offence. This is a very rare experience.</li></ol><p>So where should the unique value of this practice be deployed?</p><p>Here are some possibilities:</p><p><strong><em>Where there is an impulse to reconcile and build on existing differences</em></strong><em>.</em> This approach works by getting beneath differences of belief or opinion, reaching towards underlying motivations and aspirations by surfacing manifestations of spontaneous whole-body responsiveness in place of entrenched attitudes.</p><p>Prospective domains around difference include</p><ul><li>Intra-generationality: Enterprises where there are major age gaps to be bridged — such as local councils</li><li>Intra-ethnicity: Where there are efforts to strengthen, combine and integrate the capacities of different ethnic groups</li><li>Interfaith: Movements that treat faiths as opportunities for shared discovery and appreciation rather than separation</li><li>Intra-partisanship: Where political differences must be bridged to make progress on policy or legislation</li></ul><p><strong><em>Where there is value in eliciting and combining distinctive professional interpretative talents</em></strong><em>. </em>The practice can be structured around provocations drawn from case conversations in particular domains as learning and development opportunities for groups such as</p><ul><li>Psychologists and psychiatrists</li><li>Nurses and doctors</li><li>Social workers and care workers</li><li>Lawyers and judges</li><li>Scientists and researchers</li></ul><p><strong><em>Where there are mission-critical tasks that require spontaneous integrated group performance</em></strong><em>.</em> Here the provocation might be a verbal expression of a multi-layered front-line circumstance that elicits a range of responses, for example in</p><ul><li>Emergency response</li><li>Any kind of battlefield coordination</li><li>Large-scale event management</li></ul><p><strong><em>Where understanding and appreciation of the capacities of others in an existing relationship can make a real difference.</em></strong><em> </em>The starting point here can be an extract from a recorded conversation around an upcoming task or decision, with the aim of forming ‘an unmerged unity’ of all the talents. Domain examples include</p><p>- Multi-generational family deliberations</p><p>- Small business or family business decision-making</p><p>- Boards and governance entities</p><p>- Political entities</p><p>- Activist groups</p><p><strong><em>Where learning about self and others, and the development of relational skills, are seen as important preparation for the adult world</em></strong><em>. </em>In these instances, the practice can be structured as a game where the conversational provocation is a kind of puzzle to be solved, tuned to people’s capacities in particular settings, such as</p><ul><li>Pre-school and primary school encounters</li><li>Secondary school classroom exercises</li><li>Tertiary/university teaching focused on particular subject areas</li><li>Civic participation, for example in community gatherings</li></ul><h4><strong><em>AI and recursive listening</em></strong></h4><p>A lot has already been learned in our experiments without AI. But by enfolding AI speech analysis into the practice (with sufficient care and discernment) it becomes possible to</p><ul><li>Work much more easily with large speech files</li><li>Distill and explore layers of meaning and affect in the course of learning encounters</li><li>Help people to recognise their distinctive capacities</li><li>Show how a group can form and deploy a unique pattern of entangled sensibility</li><li>Identify varieties of variation and markers of learning and advancement</li><li>Draw comparisons and insights from large bodies of recorded material</li><li>Systematise the learning process to advance the scaleability of the initiative</li></ul><p>There’s no doubting the ambition here: ultimately to enrich the nature and quality of ordinary, everyday human discourse. It might seem fanciful that something as simple as better listening can change the world. But it can.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/597/1*Q8iN53qpk1txak2_Uml7NA.png" /></figure><p><em>For some of this discussion as spoken, not written words, there’s a three-part podcast with Angie Luo from April 17th, 2023 here:</em></p><blockquote><a href="https://www.interfaithbusinessnetwork.com/podcast/season-3-episode-4-part-1">Part 1</a>: The promise of listening</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://www.interfaithbusinessnetwork.com/podcast/season-3-episode-4-part-2">Part 2</a>: Using AI</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://www.interfaithbusinessnetwork.com/podcast/season-3-episode-4-part-3">Part 3</a>: Designing gatherings</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=975e9c506e46" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It’s time for a new kind of relational leadership]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@taptiklis/its-time-for-a-new-kind-of-relational-leadership-170780f379cf?source=rss-d692d077701a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/170780f379cf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[collaboration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relational-organizing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[listening]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership-skills]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[noticing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Theodore Taptiklis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Mar 2022 00:05:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-07T03:03:00.732Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/842/1*5vjmBr_il-Z5p9493i9mOw.png" /></figure><h4>What we’re facing</h4><blockquote>In their ground-breaking book <strong>The Dawn of Everything</strong>, Davids Graeber and Wengrow show that — against the run of 30,000 years of human history — our era has now become entrenched in an extraordinary level of stuckness.</blockquote><blockquote>Painstakingly, they demonstrate that societies and civilisations of earlier times have existed in many varieties of connectedness and organisation — and have even shape-shifted to entirely new norms and forms in the face of discomfort and oppression. On the carefully assembled evidence of this book, there is nothing God-given about the particular way our human world operates at present. Our way of living represents no inevitable pinnacle of evolution, but is just one among many possible kinds of social order. However, an important part of our stuckness is our belief that our present architectures of power, of money, of nationhood and of individual selfhood are irrevocable and irreplaceable.</blockquote><blockquote>Clearly these structures are not serving us well. The historical freedoms Graeber and Wengrow have distilled from the multiplicity of human ways of being — the freedom to relocate and be welcomed elsewhere; the freedom to disobey the commands of others; and the freedom to change and improve our social realities — these are nowhere to be found at present. Instead, our structures are working furiously to preserve the privileges of a few within the maelstrom of unprecedented planetary degradation. Our politics, our economics, our pedagogy, our relational practices—even our public language — all seem tired and helpless in the confusion of our present circumstances.</blockquote><h4>Preparing a response to what’s happening now</h4><p>A movement has been under way for many years to explore forms of conduct that invite a deeper, more generative humanity in the world. This movement has come from many different directions, and weaves many different strands together: studies in consciousness, psychology and neuroscience; explorations in pre-history and the understandings of indigenous peoples; experiments in group practice and organisational development; new manifestations in the arts, media and technology; and gleanings from the evocations of spirituality and bodily presence.</p><p>The authors of this enterprise (see below) are members of a gathering coalition within this movement, guided by some giants of the past and near-present (notably, John Shotter in the world of psychotherapy). And we are certain that a very different response to our present circumstances is becoming available to us.</p><p>We propose a response with a new starting-place. This new beginning doesn’t focus on looking <em>outward</em> towards new dreams and visions of social reality — there are plenty of these already — nor does it demand that we look <em>inward</em> in order to evaluate and rearrange ourselves (as if we all possessed a penetrating self-organising instrumental capacity). Neither reaching for utopias, nor for personal salvation, we’re starting <strong><em>in between </em></strong>— in the spaces between our selves and others (at first, other people, and ultimately all of the othernesses and forms of life around us).</p><p>What we want to pay attention to is <strong>the nature of human encounter</strong>. We ask: What happens when we meet? What are the qualities and characters of our comings together? What is going on at each moment — what can we sense in our bodies, as well as in our minds? How do these moments of encounter change us, as at the same time that others are being changed? What do others teach us about ourselves, and how are they learning from us? How do we recognise, embrace and appreciate our differences together? And with these new understandings, what new possibilities will arise between us? How do we cultivate a new level of everyday <strong><em>aliveness</em></strong> together, in our ordinary dealings with the world and with each other?</p><p>The underlying question here is one proposed some time ago by my former colleague Patricia Shaw: <strong>What are our doings doing? </strong>Beneath the surface of our exchanges and our activities together, what shapes the seething mass of disturbances, interpretations and reactions that constitute our mental and visceral responses? And what is the most useful and practical way to plunge into this turbulence to develop and enhance our substructure of being?</p><p>Surprisingly, these questions only appear in the margins of worldly concerns at present. Our exchanges with each other — given our taken-for-granted transactional orientation — are often quite superficial. In our public lives, we meet to get something — information, acceptance, consent — for which we use ritual exchanges and forms of address. We are easily ignorant or uncaring about how our doings land with the other, and unconscious of how we are influenced by their doings. The beliefs that we are encouraged to have, through education and through societal influence — to see ourselves as self-contained, self-determining individuals — hide all but a fraction of our relational capacities from us. The evidence of our myriad sensitivities is easily set aside by the instrumentality and immediacy of our given purposes and goals. As a result we mostly march from moment to moment without pausing to experience deep engagement, reflection, or the joy of spontaneous discovery.</p><p>These narrowband habits of encounter constrain and cramp our lives in countless unseen ways. Most importantly, they act to reduce our public behaviours to predictable stereotypes, reinforcing our dull acceptance of the way things are — the stuckness of Graeber and Wengrove’s analysis.</p><p>In a world so carefully curated towards the interests of a few, many people struggle to find a place. Only certain predictable human capacities — of expression, of presentation, of orientation and of imitation — are rewarded. Vast swathes of natural undirected human energy and impulse are set aside. And as we’re discovering, such energies easily fester and turn inwards in the darkness of solitary social confinement.</p><p>Our efforts are showing that these overlooked and suppressed energies and capacities within all of us can instead be acknowledged, embraced and celebrated in our dealings together. This then points us towards unnoticed human possibilities that can be animated and recovered. And this all helps us to shake off our stuckness, and to forge a new settlement with each other and with the planet we inhabit. Our ordinary activity — <em>our relational conduct with each other at each living moment </em>— is what now matters.</p><h4>A prospect of deliberate relationality</h4><p>Our public worlds of shared activity — our workplaces, our meetings, our institutions of learning, of politics, of laws and administration, of healthcare — are run according to established rules of social conduct. People gather around events and topics; arguments are prepared and ideas are presented; and conversational exchanges (mostly polite) take place. Consequences and actions are decided or assumed. In today’s language, ‘outcomes’ are determined — at least until the next moment in the event or activity.</p><p>All of this behaviour is oriented towards the ‘what’ of human endeavour. What matters most is the ‘thing’ we’re doing or producing. This focus has tended to privilege ‘action orientation’ — people and practices that are goal-directed and deterministic, even single-minded and aggressive or manipulative. What has attracted much less public attention and accountability is the underlying ‘how’ of everyday human affairs.</p><p>In recent years, cracks in this behavioural edifice have begun to appear. Workplace bullying and sexual predation are now spoken about, and the victims — usually women — are starting to be supported and taken seriously. A fight over public language and the opinions and beliefs it embodies — the ‘wokeness’ argument — has broken out. Efforts are being made to redress injustices towards the powerless and oppressed by acknowledging ‘outsider’ voices in public discourse.</p><p>New forms of public conduct are also being attempted. A striking example is the rise of <strong>mindfulness</strong> in the workplace and in education. The practice of mindfulness entails ‘time out’ from from routine activity for reflection, mindful contemplation and bodily awareness. Beginning as an off-duty activity, mindfulness is now emerging as a catalyst — a kind of ‘reset’ — during working or learning hours, inviting people to pause their mental activity and to refresh their connection with their physical selves and their surroundings.</p><p>We see these developments as positive ones, as the beginnings of a rebalancing of our behaviours between the ‘what’ and the ‘how’ of our public lives. Now we are proposing a further step: a move towards deeper and more conscious relational awareness. By recognising ourselves in the midst of others — by coming to know how others see and appreciate our distinctiveness — we can each learn how best we can place ourselves within our ongoing shared endeavours, and find the confidence to offer this ‘best self’ to whatever is happening around us. When this takes the form of our speaking up, bringing a truly generative relational understanding to a meeting or discussion, the quality of the encounter can be transformed.</p><p>What we are proposing is the introduction of spontaneous skilled responsiveness in public conduct: something that represents <em>a new form of leadership</em>. We’re suggesting a kind of ‘time out’ that can recalibrate and re-energise the working relationships of those in the room. Like mindfulness, it’s a ‘pause’ that opens up a greater sense of awareness — but this time, awareness of others, and their pulsating and vibrant entanglement with ourselves.</p><h4><strong>Getting from habituated separation to easeful entanglement</strong></h4><p>We are a small group of activist-developers (see below) that has been working to create a new relational group practice called <strong>Entangled Bodies</strong>. We are widely spread across the globe, so in Covid times we have come to rely on the affordances of the internet to marshall and host our efforts.</p><p>It turns out that by sitting down in front of screens when we meet, we have found a facility that is a little more awkward to replicate face-to-face: an ability to routinely record and recover our group exchanges. Previous years of studying conversational exchanges have always relied on being able to “listen again” — to slow down what normally passes by too quickly to grasp it more completely. Now we can introduce this capacity directly into our workshop and learning initiatives. By these means, we’re looking to set fire to our entrained conversational habits, and awaken a more deeply relational world of conscious human connection and mutual enterprise.</p><p>We’ve designed a learning practice with three interconnected steps. These iterate and cycle through the course of a workshop or learning engagement.</p><p>First, we invite a new kind of <strong>listening</strong>.</p><p>Second, we encourage new qualities of <strong>sensing and noticing </strong>one another.</p><p>Third, we use the qualities to develop new capacities of <strong>sharing and relating </strong>together.</p><p>The whole amounts to <strong>a re-invention of the practice of leadership</strong>. Instead of leadership as belonging to a person, this is leadership seen as a distributed, emergent capacity. It’s the ability for any person in a gathering to step forward just at the moment of need — armed with their own unique relational understanding — to offer an invitation that can galvanise and awaken what is now ready to arise in the room.</p><h4><strong>How the practice works</strong></h4><p>First, we ask people to experience <em>a new kind of listening</em>: not so much a listening to respond, but a listening to sink into, to dwell in, a few minutes of recorded human encounter. This recording — a ‘provocation’ with layers of content and natural drama— is a new experience for everyone: a level playing field where no-one has prior experience or privileged knowledge.</p><p>Second, we ask people, having reflected on what they heard, to make a short voice recording in private that expresses <em>what they notice most clearly</em>: what comes up for them strongly and immediately. Everyone retires from the room to record themselves speaking.</p><p>Third, we replay these voice recordings to the group. Now <em>we explore these noticings together</em>, looking to recognise and enjoy the different perspectives that emerge, by describing what these perspectives may reveal or indicate about their author. Here an interesting quality appears in the exchanges. People who may still be strangers, or perhaps acquaintances, find that they are able to speak directly about one another in quite detailed — and even intimate — ways. Conventional social constraints may be set aside in the effort to articulate what is most distinctive about each person’s way of relating to the listening experience.</p><p>Fourth, these exchanges become <em>layered further through repetition</em>. There are opportunities for people to listen again to the recordings, and to deepen their noticings in doing so. And people whose recordings are spoken about by the others in the room can respond by reflecting on the unfamilar experience of being witnessed in this way, and can share the fresh relational insights that arise from this experience. By now, there is a vibrational energy among the members of the group. People are sharing their feelings and operating largely from their increased bodily awareness of one another. We move to heighten this sense of physical connection by inviting exchanges without words, using gestures, images or sounds to convey meaning and identity. People discover that others can offer them powerful truths in quite simple and moving ways, and that they can do the same in return.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fplayer.vimeo.com%2Fvideo%2F692682129%3Fh%3D11e6b45627%26app_id%3D122963&amp;dntp=1&amp;display_name=Vimeo&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fvimeo.com%2F692682129&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.vimeocdn.com%2Fvideo%2F1401940643-61db5fa9d2b9909c6eeaa84470f649197feeb6d02d914aecf04d60f9442fec80-d_1280&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=vimeo" width="1920" height="1080" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b857fb5c0b7d38fef06cef3085b9a8f5/href">https://medium.com/media/b857fb5c0b7d38fef06cef3085b9a8f5/href</a></iframe><p>Fifth, the group turns towards the world outside the room, considering <em>how to bring this practice into public life</em>. We discuss the possibility of ‘time out’ reflections that can reset relationships and energies at appropriate moments in a workplace or other gathering. Such reflections form a kind of ‘meta-conversation’ — a conversation about the conversation we’re having, in order to deepen relationships that will make things work better. We imagine and rehearse what this move might entail: what pausing to reconsider ‘what our doing is doing’ might feel like, and how it might be conducted. Here we are working to build people’s courage and competence for <em>the art of interruption</em>. We discuss gestures and ways of speaking that feel warm and invitational, and are appropriate to different conversational settings.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fplayer.vimeo.com%2Fvideo%2F692684798%3Fh%3D3a3bcae380%26app_id%3D122963&amp;dntp=1&amp;display_name=Vimeo&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fvimeo.com%2F692684798&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.vimeocdn.com%2Fvideo%2F1401947654-9dbf731ade64d9ad46b52af61d940b34420ef4997113b1b5bd9c76e59ea3bc55-d_1280&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=vimeo" width="1920" height="1080" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/4dc9fc9c515d9cb111cb108bd1aaab66/href">https://medium.com/media/4dc9fc9c515d9cb111cb108bd1aaab66/href</a></iframe><p>People leave with undertakings to experiment with a practice of responsive reflection, and an agreement to reconvene at a later time to share the success of these experiments. In this way the learning practice is seen as the beginning of a shared journey, where building the capacity for ‘going on together’ is recognised as the key purpose of the enterprise.</p><h4>The behavioural shifts that are fostered</h4><p>An important element of this practice design — its pace and its sequence — is the aim of drawing people away from their habitual ‘head’ orientation towards a deeper sense of what’s happening in the room among those present.</p><p>However, we don’t attempt this task with models or theories — indeed with any ‘big ideas’ at all — since these would defeat the intention. Instead, we offer an experience that has the least possible guidance, that allows people to discover the shifts in awareness and conduct for themselves. At the risk of ‘giving away the secret’, here are the kinds of changes that people in our workshops have been describing to us:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/764/1*4rboZXZISAthSEuOOyWkoA.png" /></figure><h4>The characteristics of this practice</h4><p>The work creates an environment that embodies a certain set of values and principles:</p><ul><li>It starts by gathering people online in <strong>groups of five</strong>. Five is a kind of magic number for learning: with five people, there’s room for everyone to be heard, for sufficient variety of outlook to emerge, and for trust and fellowship to naturally develop.</li><li><strong>A safe space</strong> is crafted for the work — a place where people feel comfortable and can find and express their common humanity. The <strong>shared experience of</strong> <strong>careful listening</strong> at the beginning is dramatic enough that anyone can relate to it in a deep way.</li><li><strong>A tone is set </strong>for the work that invites full-hearted participation. We accept and acknowledge the presence of trauma that may have relational influence. We check people’s readiness for concentrated engagement before we begin working together. We introduce a metaphorical pattern of weaving that binds everyone’s contributions together.</li><li><strong>Space for unhurried and thoughtful considering</strong> by each person is provided. We invite observations that lead to the recognition and appreciation of difference. People’s life experiences and cultural backgrounds are bound up with these differences.</li><li>Each person’s recorded responses reveals <strong>a different way of being situated in the world</strong>. As these distinctions emerge and are noticed, an atmosphere of curiosity, surprise and delight develops in the room. A sense of relational groundedness and entanglement appears.</li><li>In conventional discourse, mis-steps, mistakes and awkwardness can easily turn the mood towards impatience, criticism or disdain in ways that stifle generosity and creativity. But here, instead of criticism, <strong>the space for enjoyment and mutual regard is opened up</strong> through greater awareness and attention to detail. There’s much more to say and do that’s both genuine and constructive. This atmosphere sustains the quality of people’s engagement.</li></ul><h4>How people respond to the experience</h4><p>Here’s what we’ve learned about what people feel:</p><ul><li>Being asked with others present in the room to tune in to the details of an entirely unfamiliar recorded conversation, and then to privately record your impressions — without knowing what you are supposed to look for, or what the rules are — is an unsettling, and even daunting experience. You are ‘speaking into the air’ and it can feel quite strange.</li><li>Then, as you listen to these recordings, you notice that everyone is struggling with the same uncertainty. This is a group of equals where no-one has privileged knowledge or rank. You observe that everyone tackles their uncertainty in different ways. The differences are intriguing, and at the same time reassuring.</li><li>When you speak about someone else’s recording, without any sense that there’s a ‘right’ answer, you find that you can respond directly with your version, your sense of what you hear. Such openness — this unmediated purity of social expression — feels liberating.</li><li>Then, as you hear several people discussing what you have recorded, there are more discoveries. Others have found aspects of your responding that you hadn’t seen in yourself, or paid particular attention to. The variety of others’ noticings opens up new feelings of being recognised and appreciated. There’s more to you than you have given yourself credit for.</li><li>As the discussion continues, you begin to experience what we are starting to call <strong>relational sovereignty</strong>. You are recognising what is distinctive about yourself in the midst, and in the company, of others. You are starting to settle into who and what you can be without having to strain, or to make a particular effort with others around you. You are helped in this move by sensing that others are relaxing into themselves as well.</li><li>Perhaps most importantly, you discover how the relational sovereignties of others — the acute sense of how they are tuned and oriented — can magnify and deepen your own. As you rehearse a reflective practice that can manifest elsewhere what you have been learning here, you emerge from the workshop with a heightened sense of your aliveness in the world, and with a readiness, even a hunger, for what you now glimpse as new possibilities for yourself and with others together.</li></ul><h4><strong>Entanglement’s the coming thing</strong></h4><p>What’s most extraordinary is the immediacy of the moves and alterations that take place here. It feels as though people may be ready for, may be yearning for, the quality of relationships that spontaneously arise in this experience. The steps are simple, but their effects are profound.</p><p>What arrives, strongly and steadily, is a powerful experience of <strong>trust</strong>. By listening carefully and responding instinctively in this work of shared curiosity, we find our way into a new kind of world: one where we come to know that whatever we say and do is valued, appreciated and enjoyed. This sense of trust becomes enfolded in our way of expressing ourselves — a part of our relational sovereignty.</p><p>So a prospect that our encounters — with acquaintances and with strangers — might, through a practice of relational leadership, become charged with trust is an exciting one. Imagine the time that is saved, the awkwardness and misunderstandings that are bypassed, and the energy that is redirected!</p><h4><strong>Why this matters now</strong></h4><p>The rise of the internet has enlarged and fractured public discourse in unimagined ways. Institutions and hierarchies of information-sharing have suffered an erosion of their hegemony and authority — and legions of self-generated impressions and opinions have sprung up in their place. On the one hand, this feels liberating. On the other hand, without accepted methods for credentialising what appears, extremes of sensation and vulgarity become dominant hooks for attention.</p><p>Amidst the swirl of competing platforms and claims, a growing meme is an ideology of personhood — the Cartesian self on steroids — called the <strong>sovereign individual</strong>. This is someone free to outcompete everyone else for money and influence, to live free from the rules of society or nation-states, and to exploit technology for first-mover and other advantages. This Howard Roarkian vision has been embraced by Silicon Valley entrepreneurs and authoritarian kleptocrats, and is also deeply embedded in the cult of QAnon. Its anti-democratic underpinnings and their hyper-partisan consequences are also influential in right-wing politics, notably in the US.</p><p>Our notion of relational sovereignty is a deliberate and hopeful counter to this development. We seek to enable people to reach, touch and feel the energies of engagement and entanglement with difference. Using our differences to combine our talents and extend our shared understanding of the world — instead of dividing us — is our dearest wish.</p><h4>Our call to action</h4><p>We are looking forward to the further evolution and application of this practice in different settings and at different scales in collaboration with many others who are reaching in congruent directions. There are possibilities here for exciting work, for example with:</p><ul><li>other communities of practice</li><li>organisational changemakers</li><li>community groups and activists of many kinds</li><li>families, schools and universities</li><li>remedial practitioners in social work and other domains</li><li>facilitators of cultural and artistic understanding and exchange</li></ul><p>We’re actively seeking collaboration opportunities at present, so if you’re ready to entangle your practice or your enterprise with ours, please talk to us here:</p><h4><strong><em>In New Zealand and Australia</em></strong></h4><p>In Wellington, <strong>Theodore Taptiklis: </strong><em>taptiklis@gmail.com</em></p><p>In Sydney, <strong>Bernhard Resch:</strong> <em>bernhard.j.resch@gmail.com</em></p><h4><strong><em>In the US and Canada</em></strong></h4><p>In Massachusetts, <strong>Jenny Katz Brandoli: </strong><em>jennykatzdesign@gmail.com</em></p><p>In Ontario, <strong>Christine Samuel:</strong> <em>christine@innerworkmatters.com</em></p><h4><strong><em>In Europe</em></strong></h4><p>In Poland, <strong>Patrick Kozakiewicz:</strong> <em>kozakiewiczp@vcu.edu</em></p><blockquote><strong>Richard Bartlett, </strong>in Italy, is also a brother-in-arms to our endeavour. His work at <a href="http://microsolidarity.cc/">microsolidarity.cc</a> and <a href="http://thehum.org/">The Hum</a> intersects with and inspires our efforts. <em>Microsolidarity</em> and <em>Microattunement</em> (another name for our practice) have shared roots, and are alternative entrypoints to a common vision of social transformation.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=170780f379cf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[These strange times]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@taptiklis/these-strange-times-13fe20126f9a?source=rss-d692d077701a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/13fe20126f9a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[entanglement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[protest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collaboration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Theodore Taptiklis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Feb 2022 00:10:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-21T00:10:36.303Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/777/1*rK97C8GbyUl8ajhpYETB1Q.png" /><figcaption>Source: Stuff</figcaption></figure><p>As the world turns, we’re coming into a new moment.</p><p>The Enlightenment project — the dream of the self-determining, self-affirming individual — is vanishing in the face of earthly reality. The failures of trickle-down and neoliberalism are some of the most recent and egregious instances of this reality.</p><p>Now the pandemic has finally swept away the fantasy of personal, individual control. And hard on its heels, the climate and environmental crises are the enforcers of this lesson.</p><p>The real legacies of Enlightenment thinking — its elitism, its hubris and and its instrumentalism — have been colonisation and dispossession. And now some of the colonised and the dispossessed across the globe, with the help of the internet, are finding each other, triggered by anger and frustration about the manifestations of the pandemic.</p><p>There’s a curious paradox here. In their rejection of the status quo — their anger at the established forces of social order — the protest-occupiers of recent weeks are claiming, among other things, the ‘rights’ of the ‘sovereign citizen’ — seemingly a response to the siren call of the Enlightenment dream. But if we look beyond the violent and rejectionist rhetoric of the internet memes and the placards, these gatherings — including those here in New Zealand — are creating something else: <strong>community</strong>. It’s almost as though the arguments, complaints and anger aren’t really the main thing at all: what counts is <strong>being together</strong>, holding the line and holding the space, eating and sleeping and caring for each other. Even the ugly intimidation of ‘outsiders’ is just a crude expression of group solidarity, typical of cults and gangs everywhere.</p><p>But what if we were able to distinguish words from actions? What if we could see this yearning for gathering as the primal force here? All the efforts to distil from these events a single cause-and-solution response (a typical Enlightenment approach) don’t work. (Vaccine mandates! Clearing the streets!) Everything from dark and weird imaginings to thoughtful scepticism and unbelief is entangled in the relationships that are developing here.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/775/1*tSBDJYnrSfSH7GJjudKveQ.png" /><figcaption>Source: Stuff</figcaption></figure><p>Is this a moment where we could imagine something truly radical? In place of sovereign citizenship — or tribal sovereignty — could we find something new (that is also something old): a prospect of <strong>relational sovereignty</strong>? Could we work to replace the fever of contested opinion with the grounded certainty of bodily knowing?</p><p>In the practices that underlie this way of operating, I come to know myself — and become understood and valued — <strong>in relation to others</strong>. My self-understanding and my capacity grow from the recognition by others of what is distinctive about me — as I recognise what is distinctive about each of them — and I learn what we can do together, by paying attention to and making practical use of our differences. We find solidarity — not in argument, but in a deep knowing of ourselves in the midst of others, and in the quietness of shared actions rather than polarising words.</p><p>Is there, then, a way to cultivate the positives — the appetite for participation and belonging among strangers that has suddenly appeared here — as the beginning of a serious possibility of remaking our societies as coalitions of mutual regard, recognition, and appreciation?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=13fe20126f9a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Empowering human behaviour]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@taptiklis/empowering-human-behaviour-8e13151f6ebd?source=rss-d692d077701a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8e13151f6ebd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[neurodiversity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entanglement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relational-agility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[attentiveness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Theodore Taptiklis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 21 Aug 2021 03:46:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-22T21:31:15.984Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8nsm6dW0xNLYFfqQROXd6g.png" /><figcaption>Acknowledgements and thanks to enallaktikidrasi.com</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>The Entangled Bodies enterprise</em></strong></p><p>Throughout recorded time, humans have enquired into their own natures and into the nature of the worldly phenomena they experience. But what remains curiously absent from these explorations is the detailed character of human intra-actions: the entangled complexity of our encounters; the myriad possibilities that are always available there; and the realm of influences that shape those possibilities.</p><p>By foregrounding the study of human experience as though we were atomised, separated beings, we miss what matters most as a purposeful species:</p><ul><li>The importance and value of our differences</li><li>The patterns of synergy available to us in combination</li><li>The capacities we have for appreciating these synergies</li><li>The beneficial effect of these synergies on our everyday conduct</li></ul><p>Without these understandings, humanity is suffering a crippled mode of existence.</p><h3>Undoing bad conduct</h3><p>What amounts to a kind of relational ‘locked-in syndrome’ for many of us has disastrous consequences.</p><p>Without habitually sensing the world as each other of us senses it, our exchanges are simplistic and easily misdirected. Misunderstandings feed on one another to generate anxiety, dread and hostility. Productive patterns of cohabitation are disrupted and turn to disdain and enmity. Organisations and institutions around the world are infected with unfeeling and arrogant behaviours enabled by asymmetries of power and influence. People’s usual behaviours easily become defensive, aggressive or both.</p><p>We have now reached a turning-point where our relational inadequacies threaten our survival. Halting the anthropogenic destruction of our habitation demands widespread levels of understanding and cooperation never achieved in modernity. Without a transformation in our everyday connectedness and sense of mutuality, all the reports and warnings of climate scientists and others amount to “somebody should” straws in the wind. The grand designs for mitigation will ultimately depend on the small repeated intra-acting shifts in all of our lives together if they are to make a real difference.</p><h3><strong>Discovering relational agility</strong></h3><p>The missings of modernity have fed on one another. Our Western history of individuated orientation has exaggerated our inward focus, in ways that limit our appreciation of our own distinctiveness in relation to those of others in each present moment. Being unfamiliar with the patterns of these natural differences, we can’t spontaneously bring our most particular capabilities to the strengths of others at these moments. Nor can we immediately recognise what’s missing and needed in the room, and look for ways to fill the gaps ourselves — or even invite others, better-placed than ourselves, to do so. Instead we tend to reach for coherence through simplification and hierarchy — and through ego and brute strength — rather than through the sensitive and carefully layered complexity that the world demands of us. And it’s not our mental capacities that hold us back: it’s our lack of relational depth and agility — something that’s been drained from us by the one-dimensional expectations set for us in our public existences.</p><p>Relational agility means knowing just how and when to fit our best talents to those of others in the unfoldings of our surrounding circumstances. It also means acting with confidence that our particular gifts are valued and appreciated by those around us, as we appreciate theirs. And it means being able to carry these understandings from one situation to another, easily adjusting and adapting how we express ourselves to the different needs of each room that we enter.</p><h3><strong>Experiencing what’s possible</strong></h3><p>With Entangled Bodies, we’re pursuing practices that are revealing a new behavioural landscape in the midst of our everyday entanglements.</p><p>Our work starts by creating opportunities to express and enjoy our most characteristic ways of being in contrast to and in sympathy with the ways of being of other people in the same room — and especially, by discovering a sense of delight in one another’s differences. Next, we look for patterns of these different ways of being that reveal their complexity and their potential generosity and synchronicity in combination. In this way we’re learning to reveal and celebrate all the perspectives of neurodiversity. And finally, we’re drawing these patterns together into a tapestry (a kind of memory) of the ‘forms of work’ — all the capacities within a group of different people. This then becomes a visual reference for keeping everything in balance, maintaining high levels of group synergy, energy, and shared orientation. It’s something that invites people to see the best in each other, to share all the necessary tasks, and maximises their ability to ‘go on together’ in the continuously unpredictable reality of our everyday lifeworld.</p><p>We hypothesise that everyone is capable of the relational agility to go on together well in any circumstance. We can see this agility in traditional encounter practices that pre-date literacy. We have been guided in such practices in Aotearoa/New Zealand by Māori colleagues, joining complex, extended sequences of exchange that combine roles, tasks, movements, chants and ritual settings that together enable strangers to gather and meet productively. In this world, members of the community grow into the roles that suit them best: but they also learn to step easily into other roles when gaps appear. From the recorded observations of ethnologists, other examples are apparent among the indigenous peoples of Australia; in the practices of the Hopi Indians of North America; in the frozen tundra peoples of Siberia; and in a range of other oral cultures. Indeed it may be the rise of literacy that has helped to reduce our capacity for spontaneous synchronous entanglement to today’s patterns of organised, separated individuation.</p><p>We don’t have to abandon our organised forms of human behaviour. But we can rebuild them around our underappreciated and underutilised natural talents, so that we can realise the richness of the shared potential in our differences.</p><h3><strong>The challenge of the ‘meta’</strong></h3><p>All of this work requires us to pay attention, not only to what we are doing, but to the effect of what we are doing on those around us as we do it. We can sum this up in the question, What is our doing doing?</p><p>Responding to this question demands a particular kind of noticing: first, a sense of how our words and actions are landing, and second, how that landing is acting back and influencing what we are up to at each moment. In other words, we are asked to attend both to the flow of our own efforts and to the layer of effect beyond or above these — something we can think of as the ‘meta-level’ of human encounter.</p><p>However, attending to the complexity of all of this requires concentration, and can be hard work. We have a glimpse of how to reach an increased quality of attentiveness in practices like mindfulness. Here we are invited to slow ourselves down to a kind of stillness where we can lose the urgency and mental turmoil of performance and response, and concentrate on just being in our bodies and in our immediate physical surroundings. So mindfulness seeks to replace the onrush of everyday sensation with a different kind of steady and focused inward attention.</p><p>But to reach relational agility, we are looking to ‘tune ourselves in’ — both mentally and physically — to our own relational qualities and to those of others at the same time. We see three pathways to achieving these more productive levels of attentiveness in our everyday world:</p><ul><li>First, this is work for people acting together in groups. If we are all reaching for increased relational agility, and we see this as shared learning and practice, then each one of us doesn’t have to be ‘on’ at every moment. There’s room to switch off, to withdraw or to reflect even in the flow of shared presence and action, confident that the others in the room remain ‘in tune’ until it is their turn to for a break or a rest;</li><li>Second, our enterprise arrives at a time when we have a growing array of technologies to help us to deal with the increasing complexities of our efforts together. We can record our exchanges so that we can notice their details and nuances by experiencing them again, even several times. We can auto-transcribe our utterances to make them earlier to scan, index and highlight. We can use AI for translation and analysis, and to identify and explore productive patterns of language, gesture, tone and mood. What normally rushes past too quickly to be noticed and savoured, can now be caught and reconsidered in the midst of our deliberations. This is an exciting prospect for deepening our in-touchness and for increasing the quality of our gatherings;</li><li>Third, we can borrow from the ritualised practices of oral cultures to distill our gathering and working practices into memorable and familiarised patterns to achieve the relational synergies we are looking for. So we can habituate and share natural sequences of encounter that bring people into the room in the right state of readiness, that sustain their energy and their motivation through the work, and enable them not only to address complexity in the moment, but to be able to go on together for as long as the work demands. These are the qualities we’ve been building into our Entangled Bodies workshops.</li></ul><h3><strong>Attracting participants and partnerships</strong></h3><p>Our enterprise has both qualitative and quantitative dimensions, and involves artistry as well as analysis. Because we are addressing and seeking to awaken the fullest possible range of human capacities, we need to explore interventions that revive and engage all aspects of our being — from speech to listening, from sound to silence, from movement to stillness, and from action to contemplation, in all their varieties. So we will value help from people with experience in many different kinds of mind and body practices, and in a wide range of cultural, remedial, educational, generational and intergenerational contexts. Such participation can also invite practice application and behavioural in these wider contexts.</p><p>Our developing practice is centred on recording, retrieving and re-experiencing our oral and physical expressions. These come from workshop participants as memorable vignettes and ‘striking moments’ in response to a deliberate succession of relational invitations. As a result, we generate a large body of archival data.</p><p>This corpus will repay detailed analysis extended over successive series of workshop cohorts. There’s scope for careful examination of the nature and flow of the exchanges throughout a developmental sequence. What patterns of relational responsiveness are emerging? Which moves generate which responses? How do speech patterns, language and atmospheres change through these encounters? Can the invitations and provocations be refined for greater effect? Can relational agility be identified, recognised, evaluated and stimulated? As people more easily ‘find their place’ in the midst of others, and settle into more graceful patterns of intra-action, what new shared capacities emerge, and what new collaborative possibilities become evident?</p><p>Here we’re looking for large-scale quantitative and processing support since AI, quantum data analytics and graphic design and visualisation can become valuable tools in deepening our understanding of our worldly entanglement and its possibilities for betterment. So there’s scope for a constellation of expert practitioners to join and support this enterprise. We’re now looking forward to adding these capacities to our enterprise team...</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8e13151f6ebd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[5 Graces — Part 3: Jumping together into a new river]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@taptiklis/5-graces-part-3-jumping-together-into-a-new-river-6e8c9a30d6e5?source=rss-d692d077701a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6e8c9a30d6e5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[post-corona-world]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kindness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[activism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Theodore Taptiklis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 20 Jun 2020 05:03:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-24T11:21:39.455Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>5 Graces — Part 3: Jumping together into a new river</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OOJmSUUf0_vZYalth5NqIQ.png" /><figcaption>Image from Text Publishing: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6PZMGYPqs0Q">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6PZMGYPqs0Q</a>: Tyson Yunkaporta discusses Sand Talk</figcaption></figure><h4>Sand Talk and the Five Graces</h4><p>In his book <em>Sand Talk</em>, Tyson Yunkaporta traces a linked series of images and yarns, forming a cosmology of stories, practices and understandings that have sustained the lives of Australia’s original peoples for something like sixty thousand years. Their focus is on relationships — between men and women, within family and kinship linking, with ancestors, and with all living and non-living creatures and phenomena including the earth, the rocks, the weather, the microbes and the stars.</p><p>I can’t really do justice to the resonance of his way of seeing and his way of being in just a few words. When I’m <a href="https://teamhuman.fm/episodes/ep157-tyson-yunkaporta/">listening to Tyson’s sand talk</a>— even for the first time — it somehow feels as though I’ve heard what he’s saying, and know what he’s saying, already. He speaks to the distant past and to the arriving future on a millennial time scale, recalling the common origin stories that link cultures everywhere. He proposes aggregation as a relational quality different from consensus: shared stories of experience become yarns (like the separation of earth camp from sky camp) and then rituals, that live in the worlds of spirit where everything is related to something and someone else — “forming an aggregate truth that reflects all of our relational obligations”. He talks of the need to to tap into a state beyond the conscious mind to reach an ancestor mind of collective wisdom: a deeply meditative place that extends beyond your brain, to your body, to your hands, to the tools you’re using, to the objects around you, to the place you’re in, to places you’re connected to, and then to your ancestors — as well as inwards to your cellular knowledge — in order to see bigger, holistic patterns. And he sets out a decision-making practice where happenings and indications aggregate with someone who then decides, “We’ll go this way,” until the work of aggregation and decision-making naturally passes to another person, in a recognized rhythm of handoffs and acceptances.</p><p>Yunkaporta’s extraordinary work inspires me to attempt, not quite a cosmology, but a distillation, a pattern of human orientations and relationships that we might aim to recognize in order to make the most of our differences in our everyday doings. And the same patterns might form the background of an educational practice for the challenges of the new world we are facing now.</p><p>One of the results of our own explorations in human responsiveness is that it suggests a complex relationship between the responses that are called for in any situation and the different roles people play in offering these responses. We see this for example on the Māori marae, where there are names for forms of work <em>(mahi)</em> and also names for the roles these entail and the people who perform them within the protocols <em>(kawa) </em>of marae conduct. In a gathering on the marae, where visitors (<em>manuhuri</em>) are meeting the hosts — the people of that place (<em>tangata whenua</em>) — there are tasks associated with each moment of encounter and each location on the landscape of the marae. These situational needs then ‘choose’ the individuals to perform these tasks according to each person’s natural orientations.</p><p>I had the opportunity to experience this calling when I was invited by Teina Moetara to take part in a group <em>wananga </em>(learning) experience of encounter on the marae at Manutuke. Amongst the other members of the group, I felt myself drawn to stand by the beautifully woven tukutuku panels inside the <em>wharenui </em>(meeting house) where my work was to weave — to tell the stories — of the gathering. And I could see how each other group member was similarly called to a different place and role, one that best fitted their particular way of being, and how we came to form a harmonious whole that made the best use of everyone’s talents.</p><p>What was this calling — this sense of being chosen by the circumstances of that place and that moment? Was it something spiritual? Perhaps it was — it was certainly metaphysical. But I also think it was a product of communal presence and purpose, no doubt enhanced by the sense of joining a pattern of shared obligation in exchanges that reached back through the history of encounters in that place.</p><p>I believe that we need to embrace this multi-dimensional complexity in our own consideration of phenomenological differences and ways of being. The proposition goes something like this: people’s underlying tendencies and orientations show up as different kinds of response. Their responses coalesce into patterns of activity that can be understood as distinctive combinations of physicality and relationality, and each combination finds its active expression at specific moments in particular situations and circumstances. So what we tend to think of as the roles of individuals, such as <em>leadership, </em>are really aspects of behaviour that can be called out in different ways <em>in anyone</em> at particular moments of human interaction (as Yunkaporta indicates).</p><p>I therefore want to propose a way of understanding productive human activity as a set of distilled patterns that form a complete whole, in homage to Yunkaporta’s cosmology. These distillations are both tasks and roles — and might also be thought of as <em>aspirational archetypes</em>. There is no simple one-to-one correspondence between individuals and either tasks or roles: one person can inhabit more than one role and task and one role and task can be undertaken by more than one person. Any one group will be able to find a combination of these patterns of inter-relationship that works best for them.</p><p>I’m calling these archetypes the Five Graces. I’m not sure why they’re called graces: that’s just the name that came to the surface as I thought about them.</p><p>The first is <strong>knot wrangling.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/472/1*h6SWJVQfZMYSvkzZ3AgZJA.png" /><figcaption>the Project Gutenberg ebook of Knots</figcaption></figure><p>A knot wrangler is someone who is drawn to solving puzzles — to grappling with and unravelling knots. This work involves teasing apart the threads of complex causality and relationship in a situation to try to reveal their ends — and if not, at least to produce a smaller knot. Knot wrangling is a task of deconstruction and analysis that suits someone at the thinking end of the physicality spectrum. Knot wranglers can sometimes be drawn to deterministic solutions, when laying out the threads of connections for others to consider may be a better course. Of the five graces, knot wrangling is the one closest to current practices of training and education.</p><p>The second is <strong>soul diving</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/420/1*06zPazzkF3uS_WB732tXSw.png" /><figcaption>aishwarya on steemit.com</figcaption></figure><p>Soul divers are skilled readers of human behaviour. They follow micro-indications of facial expression, voice tone, bodily posture, and movements and gestures to infer another person’s concerns, needs and aspirations. Soul diving is work for all the senses, coming from a position of habitual curiosity about other people and what they’re about. Experienced soul divers can learn a lot from a glimpse or a glance: but they also use their own bodily responses to check or confirm their sense of another person. In groups, soul diving can involve sending silent messages to others to communicate what they’re learning. Its fleeting, unwritten character makes soul diving an evanescent, sometimes magical, activity.</p><p>The third is <strong>space crafting</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/606/1*qtP2gIOWk4q4RGIJudDSSQ.png" /><figcaption>emma macleod at wordpress</figcaption></figure><p>A space crafter is someone who shapes the physical conditions and circumstances for the activities and experiences of a group. It’s a tactile skill that recognizes textures and surfaces as well as the affordances of place and space. Space crafting is also sensitive to energies, flows and pulses, so that time and timing are its concerns as well. A space crafter is a designer and curator of events and occasions, alive to the spontaneous and unexpected as well as to planned sequences and protocols of engagement. Despite its importance, it’s a background skill, operating most strongly when it’s unnoticed. It operates through the mediums of feelings, mood and atmosphere rather than visible structures.</p><p>The fourth is <strong>load bearing.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*Tg9cM7Jk7B1gblewYxf7ZQ.png" /><figcaption>Hesperian health guides</figcaption></figure><p>Load bearing is a bodily capacity: it means taking on a posture and a stance that manifests and demonstrates responsibility for responses and outcomes that meet the needs of the situation. A load bearer ‘inhabits’ the circumstance and acts as an exemplar to others. Like Benner’s expert nurse, load-bearing is an ego-free pattern of activity, where the identity of the person seems to ‘melt’ into the demands of the moment. Load bearing is all action: speaking is reduced to a minimum of simple pointing, guidance and emphasis. Load bearers inspire others with their sure-footedness, their certainty of purpose, their sense of calm under pressure and their focus. At the same time, load bearing is a highly sensitive pattern of response, able to alter its character at the moment that the situation changes and a different orientation is required. Load bearers can operate with others as extensions of themselves, not mechanically but organically, by invitation rather than compulsion. And as soon as the load eases, the load bearer becomes just another member of the group again</p><p>The fifth is <strong>yarn threading.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/432/1*QxLv2eSA0isS0A2SzyKbLQ.png" /><figcaption>knitnowmag.co.uk</figcaption></figure><p>A yarn threader is an organizer and arranger, weaving people into patterns of relationship and behaviour like living fabrics, conscious of how they fit best together. But yarns are also stories and conversations inhabited by people in patterns of sequence and history. Yarn threading is work with an eye to arrangement and harmony that involves introduction, connection and maintenance of relationships with a gentle touch. A yarn threader can carry a big pattern of organization and contact like a garment in their minds, and be constantly working to mend tears and holes, renew buttons and clips, and check for overall fit, coverage and warmth. In a community, yarn threading can operate across the generations, putting people into relationships that encourage the transfer of knowledge and experience. Yarn threading also operates at different scales. It can be about the organization of a small piece of people fabric woven for a particular task: or about forming a large quilt from many fabric pieces. It’s a skill of touch, detail, narrativization and deft people placement.</p><p>The five graces embrace all of the dimensions of physical and relational response that we uncovered in Part 2. They spread across the entire landscape, becoming interdependent and entangled with each other to look something like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0oYv3FROItRLxg3BmsFQzw.jpeg" /></figure><p>They constitute a touchstone for a new kind of learning and education, oriented not towards what to know and what to do, but <strong>how to know </strong>and <strong>how to do</strong>. This will be a significant alteration.</p><p>The argument is that all our endeavours can proceed more happily if all of our human capacities are invoked in their pursuit. So we should look to collective relationships that reach as far as possible across the dimensions of responsiveness, reaching beyond the confines of the upper-left corner that tends to promote ego-centricity, domination and exploitation when it is separated from the larger landscape of human capacity. We are therefore looking for combinations of people who are dominant in one or other of these aspirational patterns, as well as people whose capacities span several of them. The aim here is a simply a richer mix and a better balance than our current structures and systems afford.</p><p>Going further, our purpose is to pay attention to how our interactions are in fact intra-actions — how, as we work together, certain ways of noticing are privileged. Listening into ourselves and to each other — for what I am noticing <em>and at the same time</em> for how my actions influence your capacity for expression — becomes an exercise in collective mindfulness that invites co-development, empowerment and wellbeing</p><h4>Plunging at once into the river of a new humanity</h4><p>So the leading edge of our initiative is an invitation to take other people really seriously — not just what they do, or what they say, but who they are, in the deepest recesses of their being — how they vibrate to the rhythm of the surrounding atmosphere, and what resonances their souls are tuned to. When we absorb the vibrations of others, we start to feel our own. Their discovery reveals a force-field of relational awareness — patterns of selfhood in the midst of others — that can multiply the capability of people in joint action.</p><p>Because such essences can be unremarked and unfamiliar, there’s a special kind of work that must be done in order to draw them out. So here’s a pattern that we’ve been working on — something we’ve called <strong><em>Entangled Bodies</em></strong><em> — </em>for people who are curious and ready to learn to get this new river flowing:</p><p><strong>1.An initiator convenes a learning group.</strong> From lots of experiments, we’ve settled on five as the ideal group size for sensitive transformative learning. Five people gives scope for real difference, without sacrificing the necessary safety and intimacy in the process of group development. Six people can work too. But more won’t.</p><p>The work is about learning from others, so the more dissimilarity the better. However, it’s the initiator who has the relational responsibility in convening the gathering. Any group of people who know and trust the initiator can form a productive learning relationship.</p><p><strong>2.The group signs on to a learning platform.</strong> The programme runs online (or post-pandemic, face-to-face.) There’s technology that curates the experience and records the group’s exchanges and their outcomes. The platform is explained in detail and asks people to give permission for its use.</p><p>The key to <em>Entangled Bodies</em> learning is <strong>the emphasis on the human voice</strong>. We begin by recording and sharing our responses on a private audio channel. Recording our utterances means that we can <strong>listen again. </strong>Because all of our exchanges are recorded, and any striking moments can be immediately identified and replayed, we can do something that never happens in ordinary discourse — we can ‘go more deeply’ into these moments and explore their layers of affect and effect. Listening again always uncovers understandings that usually “go by too fast”.</p><p><strong>3. The group begins a gathering practice.</strong> The first session requires a commitment of ninety minutes together. After the first session, the group is invited to continue with a succession of four further ninety-minute sessions over one or two following weeks. (Post-pandemic, a two-day residential weekend of five sessions is a good alternative.)</p><p><strong>4. A rhythm of working is established.</strong> Each session is a ‘dive’ into deeper levels of productive exchange. People’s energies are ‘gathered up’ at the beginning of each session and released again at the end. In each case there’s settling work so that people feel comfortable together and ready to work. There’s lots of bodywork as well as talking, listening and reflecting. Nothing is forced or coerced: there’s lots of space for dissonance and uncertainty along the way.</p><p><strong>5. The learning pattern is recorded graphically and aurally.</strong> Each person chooses an icon to represent their own responses as the exchanges unfold. Responses are mapped after group discussion by location as post-it notes on the landscape (‘heartland’). The pattern traces their own journey as well as the movement of the whole group over the life of the gathering. Post-it notes link to the underlying audio clips.</p><p><strong>6. The work begins with a shared experience of noticing</strong> once the group is initially settled. Everyone witnesses an enacted event (a ‘provocation’) and is invited to record individually what comes up for them most powerfully as a result. There are no bad responses — any reaction or noticing is going to be valuable. To begin with, each person’s response is held separately, to be revealed and discussed in turn.</p><p><strong>7. The group considers each response as it is revealed. </strong>The purpose of the discussion is not to judge the quality of the response, but to try to discover what kind of noticing is involved — how to position and place it on a landscape of responsiveness. The aim is to to look for a point of intersection between the two dimensions of physicality and relationality. What muscles of physical and relational awareness are being exercised in the way the response emerges? Can the group uncover and describe what each response is doing — how it lands, and what it invokes or invites?</p><p>Particular responses may land differently with different people. So in effect, they may be doing different kinds of work at the same time. In these cases, the response is not a simple point, but a multiplicity, to be so recorded. <strong>The discussion should continue until everyone feels that their sense of each response has been included.</strong> Notes on the results of the discussion will aid later reflection.</p><p>Responses are mapped using the iconography chosen by each person. A pattern of differences begins to emerge.</p><p><strong>8. After the first noticing round, the experience is repeated.</strong> The provocation is played again, and people are asked to record what comes up for them most strongly this time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yvOndnvKdWrRQQufu_vu_w.png" /></figure><p>But now they will do so in the knowledge of the different ways of seeing they have just been discussing. Will their awareness and their focus of attention shift as a result? Will they experience the provocation differently? This second round of noticing forms an overlay to the first.</p><p><strong>9. The second round of discussion is more complicated and entangled.</strong> What can arise in this round are two levels of response: a new kind of noticing of the provocation, and at the same time, an account of how that new kind of noticing has been influenced by the experience of the first round of discussion. Here we are layering successive levels of response on one another. With care, these can be considered and mapped by the group. Shifts in position indicate movement and development.</p><p><strong>10. Gradually the kick-starter effect of the provocation is left behind.</strong> The group discussion takes on its own life, following the needs and concerns of those present in relation to worldly circumstances. With heightened group awareness and sensitivity, and with deeper understanding and respect for one another, striking or troubling moments in the exchanges can be ‘called out’, explored in discussion and mapped on the landscape as learning opportunities. This shared permission to pause, record and reflect constitutes a new maturity of group practice and relational consideration that has the potential to flow into many aspects of everyday life.</p><p>11. <strong>Traceable, visible shifts will echo invisible movement. </strong>The 5 Graces are paradigm cases, or archetypes, suggesting how distinctive capabilities can cluster into interdependent and complementary roles for people working together.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GQmP-typ2VOTTIjsC5Yzww.png" /></figure><p>Understanding and recognizing these roles opens up lots of possibilities for natural and spontaneous collaboration. And each group that follows an <em>Entangled Bodies</em> programme will be able to reconfigure these clusters for themselves, creating their own patterns of graces, as in the example here.</p><p>However, the most important outcome from this work is something invisible — something that’s felt rather than seen. It amounts to a great shift in the way that people address and deal with each other in ordinary interaction. It becomes apparent in movement and in action rather than in words, like the ‘transparent self’ of Benner’s nursing expertise. It’s an awakening — a new level of human flourishing — that intensifies the engagement and entanglement of heart, body and mind. The conscious, individualized self melts away, to be replaced by a new kind of group embodiment, where each person, with their quirks, their obsessions and their proclivities, is acknowledged and respected in something like instinctive shared becoming.</p><p><strong>12. The practice invites new stages of learning. </strong>As people go deeper into the recognition of otherness — as they pay closer attention to the nuances of other’s responses — they may identify aspects and characteristics outside the scope of our landscape of physicality and relationality. In this way the language of noticing can extend in further directions, modifying what is here, adding new or borrowed levels of understanding to the practice.</p><h4>Going on together from here</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/473/1*vHgZwd98ovbuvGPH4H8D7w.png" /></figure><p>The <a href="https://www.between-us.net/"><em>Between Us </em>website</a> introduces some of the colleagues engaged in this project. Together we are pursuing any and all opportunities to take this work further. With this publication we are inviting you to:</p><ul><li><strong>Dive into the practice with <em>Entangled Bodies</em> workshops.</strong> We’re looking for individuals and groups who are intrigued by the possibilities afforded here and are ready to learn with us. We’re ready to help you to set up and run your own workshop programme — either as a stand-alone event, or integrated with other self- and group-development activities.</li><li><strong>Join our research efforts at </strong><a href="https://www.between-us.net/"><strong><em>Between Us</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong>around testing, extending and configuring the approach for different learning contexts. Is your curiosity flickering? There’s lots to do here. Building the responsive practices of adults, against the background and in the face of established educational systems and organizational practices is one thing. But what about other learners? Infants, schoolchildren, students in higher education, families, professional and practical workplaces, communities and other social groups, for instance? We’re keen to link in with and support research initiatives both here and in other countries, especially where — as Yunkaporta says — we can rediscover and recognize the ‘indigenous’ as simply human, not as something exotic, apart, or separate.</li><li><strong>Help us to build a library of learning phenomena</strong>. To awaken our silent or sleeping capabilities, we’ve been developing and exploring constructed experiences that ‘call out’ different forms and habits of response. We’ve been discovering that the work of creating provocations that open the fullest possible forms of physicality and relationality is a challenging and demanding combination of artistry and science. So we’d welcome an opportunity to work with artists and creatives from the worlds of theatre, improv, film and elsewhere to build these entirely new kinds of recorded phenomena. Can we design and produce an archive of provocations that matches many different kinds of group needs and learning settings?</li></ul><p>Waking up our sleeping humanity means many things, including the recognition of crucial human attributes and behaviours that are overlooked by an instrumentalized industrial and consumer society — and that enable us to engage with and respect the Other. There’s a hint of this recognition already in the coronavirus epidemic, in the acknowledgement and celebration of ‘front line’ workers, from cleaners to clinical staff. There’s another even greater hint in the upswelling of support for Black Lives Matter.</p><p>So our invitation here is to extend this recognition to all the capacities and all the affordances of everyday human response wherever they appear —especially those that are presently un-noticed, unsung and unheard. And by becoming truly awake to what our doings do with one another, then we’re also going to become conscious of and properly accountable for their consequences…</p><p>Back to: <a href="https://medium.com/p/a9eab5e054c1/edit"><strong>Five Graces Part 1 — <em>Recovering our humanity for a post-coronavirus world</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong>(the story of what’s been lost, why it disappeared, and what we’ve been left with in its place).</p><p>Or to: <a href="https://medium.com/p/76d7ae489c8c/edit"><strong>Five Graces Part 2 — <em>A new beginning for education and learning</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong>(the detailed affordances of human responsiveness, as a landscape of physical and relational capacities that can position each person’s natural orientations as part of an interconnected and productive whole).</p><p><strong><em>Reference (additional references </em></strong><a href="https://medium.com/p/76d7ae489c8c/edit"><strong><em>at Part 2</em></strong></a><strong><em>)</em></strong></p><p>Tyson Yunkaporta (2019), <em>Sand Talk:</em> How Indigenous Thinking Can Save the World, Text Publishing</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/185/1*kgGM2eX9W-QHi7fbN72S6g.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6e8c9a30d6e5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[5 Graces — Part 2: A new beginning for education and learning]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@taptiklis/5-graces-part-2-a-new-beginning-for-education-and-learning-76d7ae489c8c?source=rss-d692d077701a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/76d7ae489c8c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[new-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[post-corona-world]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[activism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kindness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Theodore Taptiklis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 20 Jun 2020 05:02:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-24T11:19:07.529Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>5 Graces — Part 2: A new beginning for education and learning</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/912/1*xFg844YidelYmxKw1TPlLg.png" /><figcaption>the Māori wharenui, the home of wānanga (learning)</figcaption></figure><h4>Education and learning as improving human responsiveness</h4><p>The history of this enquiry has been to discover what it is to be a human person in a world of other human persons (and non-humans as well). <a href="http://between-us.net/">What are the possibilities that arise between us all</a>, and how can we seize and make the most of these possibilities for everyday thriving and wellbeing? Exploring this question over many years has taken me (and friends and colleagues) deep into a range of lifeworlds and domains of study and practice, including nursing, social work and family therapy; into all kinds of organizations; into phenomenology, ethnology, prehistory and the philosophy of language; into psychology and neuroscience; and the study of storytelling and conversation.</p><p>The focus has been <strong>the detailed nature and conduct of human encounter</strong>: in face-to-face and in technology-mediated settings, both synchronous and asynchronous, including learning and teaching practices in pre-schools, corporations, social enterprises, universities and a drama school; and most especially on a Māori marae at the settlement of Manutuke near Gisborne, in New Zealand‘s North Island. This work has included many hours of recorded and re-studied conversations and stories. The approach has come to recognize human encounter not only as exchanges with other people, but with all living and non-living beings on our planet, as well as with all the events, happenings and circumstances that enter our lives.</p><p>Studying encounter evokes continual curiosity about the qualities and character of human responsiveness. As the world turns, what does it produce in human beings? In all of the happenings of the world, what happens to us? Are there patterns of responsiveness that we can learn more about so that we might enhance and develop our shared capabilities? In particular — and this is a lesson from Te Ao Māori — do the natural variations and individual life courses of each member of our species mean that there are <em>differences between us</em> in the ways that we experience things that can become shared, productive group resources?</p><p>It seems that the worldly understanding of human responsiveness — in our practices, our policies and our ordinary discourses — is partial and disconnected. This disconnection reflects the separation of our many domains of human activity, each focused on its own view of the person. For example, clinical and remedial domains tend to view people as manifestations of symptoms for treatment or behaviours to be corrected; industrial, administrative and military institutions as replaceable entities to be trained, directed and coordinated; educational establishments as vessels to be filled with knowledge in preparation for the worlds of work and adulthood; artistic and entertainment enterprises as audiences for delight, surprise and challenge; and selling and political domains as objects of attraction, persuasion and manipulation (think here about the politics of ‘nudge’).</p><p>Each domain, steeped in the doctrines of individualism, distills and simplifies its view of human behaviour in line with its own practice. This simplification is a feedback loop, and leads to an emphasis on doing things to, rather than with, people. Other people are ‘out there’, objects of aboutness thinking. Domain separation means that a fuller view of human needs and capabilities is never assembled. As a result, the richness and complexity of our faculties of responsiveness operating in combination — as teachers and learners at the same time, acting with the full power of each of our distinctive orientations to the world — is seldom appreciated or realised. So we have come to inhabit a society that admires and privileges a significantly diminished set of human talents, particularly those that are verbal, instrumental and coercive.</p><p>Our project seeks to redress this imbalance. It focuses directly on what is seemingly invisible in our ordinary discourse, that is: <em>What do our doings do?</em> It proposes an enlarged and expanded basis for learning — one that re-opens our diminished humanity and invites new relational practices that increase our sensitivity and acuity in our everyday dealings with one another. It makes room for a much more extensive repertoire of talents in our exchanges and enterprises. And at the same time, it’s intended to promote a greater sense of ease, comfort and sense of place for everyone in our communal endeavours.</p><h4>Discovering the dimensions of responsiveness: (i) physicality</h4><p>Reflecting on the detailed observations of <em>Microattunement — </em>where the affordances of behaviour appropriate and useful to people at different scales (individuals, dyads, crews, congregations and beyond) were set out<em> —</em> then prompted a question: What did all these micro-noticings add up to? Is there an overall shape and pattern across these scales that could guide our learning efforts? After years of research and experimentation, could their understandings be brought together to make a systematic development practice — something that could help in the recovery of our lost humanity? I started to look back over the accretion of insights that had been gathered.</p><p>The first clue came from one of my earliest influences: the work of Patricia Benner in her 1984 treatise on nursing development, <em>From Novice to Expert</em>. Benner, who studied with leading phenomenologist and Heidegger scholar Hubert Dreyfus, had gathered a body of stories of moments in nursing practice. She reinterpreted the Dreyfus brothers’ five-stage model of airline pilot skill advancement, applying it to nurses in hospital settings. Benner’s book — drawing on a repertoire of documented instances of actual practice rather than on abstract formulations — traces a five-stage spectrum of ‘ways of being’ in nursing practice (<em>novice; advanced beginner; competent; proficient; and expert</em>).</p><p>As she explains it, at the novice end, nursing practice is a matter of learning and following the rules: internalizing and remembering a script and applying it to the current situation. Thinking carefully and memorizing sequences of steps are crucial. The novice nurse is highly self-conscious, tuning behaviour to written or previously taught practice, hoping they have chosen the right set of rules for the circumstance they find themselves in. But at the expert end of the spectrum, things are quite different. Thinking plays very little part. The expert nurse, familiar with a very wide range of situations, recognizes each one and simply ‘melts into’ and inhabits the moment. Advanced capabilities, rehearsed many times, have become embodied. Benner uses the term ‘transparent self’ to describe this way of being. There is no self-consciousness — and therefore no conscious thought — present here. The body ‘knows’ what to do. We might call this simply <em>being</em>.</p><p>Benner’s work suggests a spectrum of responsiveness that goes from detached thinking and reasoning at one end to fully engaged and embodied presence at the other end. And this spectrum seems to follow the contours of the upright human body, with thinking at the head or top end, and embodiment lower down. Could we extend the metaphor?</p><p>Some new directions in neuroscience suggest that we can.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*7Rg7QalBAwp4bsXW-kB1mA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Wellcome Library</figcaption></figure><p>We are steadily increasing our understanding of the vagus nerve — the long ‘wanderer’ nerve that connects the brainstem through the neck and the thorax down to the abdomen, and sends information about the gut, liver, heart and lungs to the brain. Among many other functions, this nerve bundle influences mood and anxiety through the action of gut bacteria. Its condition is correlated with the body’s capacity to regulate stress responses and can be influenced by breathing. The vagus nerve is therefore involved in managing our psychological wellbeing in breathing-related practices like meditation and yoga. In ordinary talk we have tended to characterize our ‘gut instinct’ as somehow at odds with, and lesser than, our powers of intelligence and reason. But increasingly it seems that our ‘feelings’ — especially through awareness of our internal, chemical, visceral responses — are some of our most important ways that we connect to the world.</p><p>So what is emerging is a spectrum of responsiveness that extends from <em>thinking</em> to <em>being</em> with <em>feeling</em> somewhere in between, not separate but infusing the entire spectrum. And following the lead of Dreyfus and Dreyfus and Benner’s sequences of ‘stages of proficiency’, I’d like to extend this into a five-stage natural sequence of bodily capacities:</p><ul><li><strong><em>thinking</em></strong><em> </em>is considered to be the gold standard of human response, unique to humans and the source of our dominance as a species. The association of thought with logic and reason positions intellectual activity as the most elevated of our faculties, understood (almost) exclusively as the property of our brains. At the same time, it’s the most internalized and detached of our capacities. To think of something, we need nothing but our own imaginations. In this way, thought is not necessarily a direct response to the world but a kind of considered reflection of it — something that can float freely outside and beyond the present moment.</li><li><strong><em>sensing</em></strong> is about the responsive capacities of our traditional sense organs: our eyes, our ears, our noses, our tongues, and our skin. These are the principal organs of conscious awareness that enable us to notice the qualities of the world around us, and their relationship to our bodies. They register large and small movements in our immediate surroundings, the sound and tone of external events, the nature of the atmosphere and air-borne odours, the character of substances that may enter our bodies, and the external texture and temperature of anything that we come into contact with. They allow us to make judgements about all of our surrounding circumstances and their potential to help or harm us, and as a result to make a physically or socially appropriate response. Unlike thinking, sensing is all about the here and now.</li><li><strong><em>feeling</em></strong><em> </em>is a deeper capability. We sense with organs that are directly connected to the external world. But following the perspective of neuroscience, feeling is a kind of portmanteau capability that registers and generates a multi-stranded whole-of-body response. The noticings of our senses are mostly easy to describe: our feelings, on the other hand, can be complex and difficult to put into words. They involve a multiplicity of elements and stimuli; chemical, electrical, muscular and vascular — infused with our cultural and social experience and inheritance. To feel something is to be affected and changed oneself. Because the significance of a feeling can be mysterious and uncertain, revealing it and and sharing it with others can be a way to better discover its extent and its meaning. A feeling can be an important kind of bodily knowing that deserves attention and repays further exploration.</li><li><strong><em>doing</em></strong><em> </em>(or simply <em>moving</em>)is a responsive capability removed from words and explanations that finds its expression in physical movement, action and tasks. A doing response ‘goes straight to jail without passing Go’. In everyday gatherings, doing might simply mean opening a door or window to get some fresh air, or a gesture of support or affirmation to another person. In an occasion or event, a doing response might be offstage, unseen: for example, on a Māori marae, all the food preparation work that takes place at the <em>wharekai</em> (dining hall). Doing responses perform functions that address the body rather than the mind. They are <em>responses to needs that continually arise in the moment</em>. They may be unremarked in traditional oratory or discourse, and unrecorded in conventional decision-making, but are vital to group cohesion and shared effort.</li><li><strong><em>being</em></strong><em> </em>is a level of responsiveness where there is no separation between the person and their circumstances: where the ego and the self float away and the person is entirely immersed in and responsive to the needs and the moment of the situation. Benner describes an expert nurse in the midst of a complex clinical event, moving and directing the activities of an entire clinical team without conscious thought but with highly refined physical awareness. It is as though the skilled body is in charge of the action, and all self-consciousness has vanished. In some circumstances events are too large or move too quickly for conscious deliberation and decision-making: instead, a less clumsy and more adroit form of bodily knowing takes over and drives the response. [Driving a car is an everyday example of this for most people; Strati describes a group of roofers who operate without thought of their danger by navigating the rafters with their feet.] Being includes doing, but as a continual state of dwelling rather than an immediate response.</li></ul><p>This spectrum of physicality forms an arc of differential capability in several parallel dimensions. We can see it as movement through the body that gathers up more capacities as it proceeds: from the inside of the head, or the brain <em>(thinking) </em>to the face and skin <em>(sensing)</em> to the centre of the body <em>(feeling)</em> to the limbs <em>(doing)</em> to all of these capacities operating together <em>(being)</em>. We can see it as movement from <em>thinking</em> as the most interiorized or detached capacity towards <em>being</em> as the most exteriorized or worldly capacity<em>. </em>We can also see it as movement from the most formal, deconstructive capacity to the most informal, holistic of our capacities<em>. </em>The aim is to see these as aggregative capacities rather than as separable or distinct forms of response. The argument here is that in our present era, we are mostly trapped at the narrowest, least responsive, least creative and least generative end of the spectrum: we need to rediscover, embrace and develop the entire spectrum of physical responsiveness to reassert our humanity as a species.</p><h4>Discovering the dimensions of responsiveness: (ii) relationality</h4><p>At the same time, our explorations have opened up another, equally important dimension of responsiveness: that of <em>relationality</em>, or the extent to which our doings recognise the others (and ‘othernesses’) in our surroundings. This dimension forms a spectrum whose extent, like that of physicality, has emerged from the insights of other people through acts of discussion, study and shared practice.</p><p>Central to recognizing the significance of relationality has been the work of my close friend and colleague <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/profile/John_Shotter2">John Shotter</a>. John also introduced me to two of the most important of his many ‘textual friends’: Mikhail Bakhtin and Ludwig Wittgenstein. These three giants brought the relationality spectrum to life for me. And finally, the practices of Toi Whakaari, the New Zealand drama school, of its former director Christian Penny and of Teina Moetara of Rongowhakaata, and more recently the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nBc-p2H2T2Q&amp;feature=youtu.be"><em>sand talk</em> of Tyson Yunkaporta</a>, have infused this understanding of relationality with insights from teaching the dramatic arts and from antique and time-honoured ways of being from the <em>longue durée</em> of pre-modern human history.</p><p>An important starting point for me was Shotter’s proposition that self-understanding begins, not with Cartesian self-examination, but with noticing and understanding the orientation of another person. Being able to see the world from the perspective of someone else, Shotter argues, provides a point of navigation for oneself. In other words, we come to recognize ourselves <em>in relation to</em> other people, not by taking the self as a fixed point and gazing inward from there. This struck me as a revolutionary insight because it did away with theories and models of the self as the taken-for-granted framework of self-study. Instead, it gave emphasis to the faculties of observation, empathy and taking the other seriously as the foundations of responsive learning and practical activity in the world.</p><p>This perspective was deepened and strengthened by the discovery of Bakhtin, a Russian philosopher of language during and after the Stalin era. I first came to Bakhtin when I was working with another colleague, Charles Hett, in gathering, recording, and exploring stories of professional practice in organizational life. We were looking for a way to deconstruct lengthy recording sessions into themes and topics, and were drawn to the Bakhtinian notion of the <em>utterance — </em>the unit of speech from the beginning of a thought to the moment when a response was possible. We found that careful and repeated listening to individual recorded utterances revealed lots of details of sound, texture and movements of the voice — discoverable meanings and implications beyond the verbal content of what was said. So when it came to condensing the meaning of an utterance into a summary title, we were learning not simply to parse the words, but to identify what the speaker was <em>reaching for — </em>where they were heading with their utterance, even if all the words weren’t quite there yet. We were aiming to catch the relational quality — the present but unvoiced surrounding context — of a speaker’s utterance.</p><p>All of this was unfolded in the writings of Bakhtin, as introduced to me by Shotter and also by David Boje. For example there is his notion of <em>the answering word — </em>the argument that every utterance is made in the expectation of a response:</p><blockquote>“the word in living conversation is directly, blatantly, oriented toward a future answer-word; it provokes an answer, anticipates it and structures itself in the answer’s direction. Forming itself in the atmosphere of the already spoken, the word is at the same time determined by that which has not yet been said but which is needed and in fact anticipated by the answering word.”</blockquote><p>Bakhtin also argues that our words are not necessarily addressed only to someone in front of us, but also to what he called the <em>superaddressee — </em>to a virtual audience in our own minds — to our parents, or perhaps to posterity. This larger sense of relationality is important because it’s a clue not just to our intention but to our <em>aspiration — </em>what in our speaking we are reaching for, even beyond the words we have been able to find. Bakhtin asserted — and I discovered for myself in listening again and again to recorded utterances — that careful attention to the utterance can begin to reveal this underlying aspiration. Hearing what is unsaid but nonetheless present, and able to be discerned, is a way of tuning in to aspiration — a relational intentionality that once grasped, can open up a prospect of shared orientation and purpose with the listener. Instead of focusing only on the ‘content’ of another’s utterance — the information, opinion or assertion it expresses — we can read the hopefulness and wishfulness that is also present, and join it to our own.</p><p>Shotter‘s understanding of relationality also leads to the insights of late Wittgenstein. Two seemed most apposite. First, the claim that in our doings with each other, “nothing is hidden”: and that “it’s all laid out to view”. In the living of our lives, says Wittgenstein, all of the phenomena and all of our responses are present and visible — if only we can pay close enough attention. But at the same time he acknowledges the difficulty of detailed attention to the richness of our interactions: “it all goes by too fast”, he says elsewhere. So our work of recording and listening again to utterances was a way of slowing things down so that more of this richness could be recognized.</p><p>Second, Wittgenstein’s account of the purpose of our (and his) investigations: to <strong><em>go on together</em></strong><em> “</em>with each other in a sensibly followable way”. As Shotter says, this is foundational for Wittgenstein “because it is in doing so, that we can achieve all the other things we think of as being important to us”. For me this was a blinding insight. Instead of the orientation drilled into me in my professional education and practices — to solve problems, to find solutions, to discover answers — our everyday strivings have a much simpler relational purpose. That is, to be able to continue together in the face of the onrush of worldly events — to have relationships, understandings, languages, methods, practices and ways of being that allow us to make sense together, not just in specific tasks or in response to particular events but on and on as far as we can imagine. At once it struck me that this — something that Shotter calls <em>joint action</em> — is the real work, from which everything else would flow.</p><p>The final piece in the jigsaw puzzle of a spectrum of relationality came from my time at Toi Whakaari, the drama school. Teachers there had cultivated a whole-of-school teaching practice where in a class of 150 people, students were invited to communicate by making “offers” to one another about their upcoming projects or their interests or their concerns. In this setting, direct, simple personal talk was encouraged and modelled by the teachers. How these “offers” were being received was noticed and studied, and live feedback given to students to help them to orient and ‘land’ their speaking as well as possible in the context of the needs in the room. Having spoken once, students were invited to reset themselves and try to do better a second time. Such a radically open form of teaching was new to me.</p><p>A particular piece of language in this teaching practice was a powerful insight for me. Someone whose speaking failed to connect with the room, who seemed to be following an internal script and was in effect talking to themselves, was held to be ‘expressing’. This might be a bubble of passion and enthusiasm for something that somehow stayed inside the student’s head, or a statement or assertion that bolstered the self-esteem of the speaker rather than those being spoken to: such expressive talk was strongly discouraged. I was suddenly reminded about how much of the talk in my professional and organizational life amounted to the same thing: ‘expressing’ in ways that reinforced the identity and ego of the speaker but failed to invite any real connection with the needs and wishes of its audience. I thought of occasions when statements were made or conclusions delivered that were ostensibly informative but were really forms of self-presentation. I particularly remembered the performances of colleagues at consultants McKinsey and Boston Consulting Group that looked to demonstrate “thought leadership” with analyses of dazzling intellectual brilliance, but were often mostly elaborate expressions of self promotion and identity.</p><p>From all of this a three-stage spectrum of relational responsiveness emerges:</p><ul><li>At one end is <strong><em>articulating the self </em></strong><em>— </em>responses that express the attitudes of the person and reflect and reveal their own thoughts and feelings about the event or circumstance under discussion. They can be statements of heightened emotion or can be cool and dispassionate statements of opinion and interpretation. In self-articulation the person addresses the world from within themselves, and their ideas and offerings come from their own perspective. This interiorised self tends towards a position in which the object of the speech or gestural act is ‘over there’, separate from the person speaking (Shotter’s ‘aboutness’ talk).</li><li>Towards the middle of the spectrum is <strong><em>tuning in to others </em></strong><em>— </em>where what is said pays attention to and respects the perspective or the position of another person or persons. It’s a mode of conduct and discourse with an outward orientation, characterised by noticing, reflecting and building on the responses of other people. It’s not about speaking for others — where adopting another’s viewpoint can be a kind of appropriation or even self-articulation — but more about noticing another’s gestures or bearing and finding ways to drawing that voice into the discussion. Speaking with the consciousness of others, and of their different points of view, is less assertive and deterministic than speaking only for oneself. Tuning in to others may also be a physical, bodily response rather than a verbal one. At its simplest it is an act of noticing that acts as an invitation to other people present to reorient their attention in a fresh direction.</li><li>At the far end of the spectrum is <strong><em>going on together</em></strong><em> — </em>a response that is oriented not simply to the present moment but to the unfolding possibilities of the occasion. It’s a kind of pathfinding manner that ‘gathers up’ what has been going on and points forward or embodies an emerging sense of direction. Like tuning in to others, this kind of response conveys its meaning through tone, mood and physical stance as much as through the spoken or written word. As Shotter paraphrases Wittgenstein, it’s not about ‘understanding’ each other, nor about sharing ‘agreements’, nor about ‘communicating messages’ to one another — the conventional aims of purposeful gatherings — but only with being able to ‘go on’ with each other: to make ‘followable’ or ‘responsible’ sense to each other in ways that makes it possible to continue our relationships.</li></ul><p>Now we can make an image (a ‘heartland’) that brings these two dimensions of responsiveness — <strong>physical</strong> and <strong>relational </strong>— together:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CTnoUk1X62RgFCyNmi9zqA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Recognizing these dimensions in group interaction</h4><p>For several years we’ve been developing practices that strengthen working relationships for groups of people with a shared purpose. These practices involve exercising people’s muscles of response by inviting and drawing out deeper attention and more detailed noticing in relation to the experience of a specific event or circumstance (a curated or constructed ‘phenomenon’).</p><p>We’ve experimented with a range of phenomena, both ‘live’ and recorded audio and video, with groups that gather face-to-face and also online. In each case, we’re presenting a rich and tangled situation — something that involves a mix of people and relationships. Here are examples of the variety of responses we’ve elicited, mapped across the dimensions that we’ve been discussing. First, the <em>physicality</em> spectrum:</p><ul><li><strong>thinking: </strong>the classic thinking response is to explain aspects of the situation presented. Explanations might involve <em>interpretation</em> (“this happened because of that”); <em>comparison </em>(“this reminds me of that”); <em>analysis</em> (“this then this, so now this other thing”) or <em>solution</em> (“the answer is this”).</li><li><strong>sensing: </strong>these responses typically involve pointing towards a particular moment or detail: “ — listen to this bit”; “ — did you see what happened there?”; “ — there’s a noticeable atmosphere between these two”; “ — what this person was saying didn’t ring true”; “ — that was an odd move”. This kind of noticing tends to gather momentum with further practice.</li><li><strong>feeling:<em> </em></strong>it’s harder to get these voiced, but with encouragement, they can be responses like, “I felt the hairs on my neck go up”; “my stomach feels really uncomfortable about this”; “that made my heart race”; “I felt like shouting out there”; “it made a funny taste in my mouth”; “I’m really jazzed by all this”; I’m feeling quite disturbed now”. Because locating and identifying feelings can be difficult, these responses can be hesitant or incomplete (sometimes the less said, the more that is communicated).</li><li><strong>doing: </strong>these are often silent, like hugging someone, or holding the gaze of other people. They might also be responses like calling for a silent moment, asking for time out, or starting a shared body movement (like applause). They can be as simple as opening a door or window, holding someone’s hand, or leaving the room.</li><li><strong>being</strong>: here the response is physical and spontaneous — a move that ‘inhabits’ the situation, where the person ‘loses themselves’ in the experience of the phenomenon. It might involve enacting a moment or a character in the event; adopting something of its voice or tone; mirroring a gesture or a movement; or demonstrating and embodying the consequences or appropriate next steps in the unfolding experience. The response is no longer outside, or even a reaction to, the situation — but is entirely identified with it.</li></ul><p>Next, the <em>relationality</em> spectrum:</p><ul><li><strong>articulating the self:</strong> responses here can be strongly assertive. They reflect the relationship between self and situation, and can therefore involve the ego in a sense of mastery or threat. Examples include “ — I know about this”; “ — this happened to me”; “ — this could never happen to me”; “ — I get this because”; “ — here’s how to think about this”; “ — to understand this you need to know”; “here’s where this situation belongs“ — this whole thing is ridiculous”; “ — I don’t know what they’re trying to prove here”; “ — discussing this is a waste of time”.</li><li><strong>tuning in to others:</strong> these responses are about noticing relational details in the situation, for example, “ — this moment was awkward”; “ — that signal got missed”; “ — this person wasn’t listening”; “ — that person’s hesitation got covered up”; “ — this move was misinterpreted”; “ — that offer landed badly”.</li><li><strong>going on together:</strong> what arises here are responses that ‘gather up’ what’s been going on, and invite forward movement, or a pivot from discussion to action: “ — there’s space now for this to happen;” “ — here’s a way that we could start the change”; “ — let’s make the story from here”; “ — we could ask these people to join us”; “ — are we ready for this now?”. This kind of orientation can be conveyed as much in a bodily stance as in words. But in the same way that Quakers find the ‘sense of the meeting’, <em>going on together</em> is only possible as the sensing of a whole group by one person.</li></ul><p>Of course these are not exclusive categories — responses can extend across them and combine more than one capacity — but they indicate a useful sense of the physical and relational directions and flow that arise in human interaction.</p><h4>Discovering phenomenological differences between people</h4><p>These dimensions represent different ways of seeing the world and reading its happenings. And these differences can be found in the characteristic behaviours of individuals. Some differences between people occur naturally as a result of species variation: others are influenced by their life trajectories, their upbringing and often by significant ‘marker’ experiences.</p><p>Though we are arguing here for a greater spread of physical and relational capacities in people’s efforts together, we are not in any way promoting an ideal of behaviour that applies to everyone. Just the opposite: it’s the differences between us — that show up differently in differing groups, emerging in relation to moment-by-moment circumstances — that make for shared creativity and human synergy. And recognizing and making productive use of these differences is crucial for our surviving and thriving together.</p><p>Teina Moetara of Rongowhakaata explains his experience of growing up on the marae at Manutuke as one of learning to use these differences as <em>shared resources</em>. Among its other qualities, the marae is a landscape of collaborative work, each with a specific location. There’s the work of scanning the horizon to see who and what is arriving, so that the community is properly prepared. There is work to do with encounter and arrival, that begins with ceremonies of greeting, and leads towards a careful pathway of connection and engagement. There’s the work of gathering and preparing food, and of cooking and serving it to everyone. There’s the work of planting, growing and harvesting crops. There’s work to do with discussion and learning, and with remembering the genealogy and activities of ancestors. There’s work to do with recording the stories of the community and weaving and carving these into sacred objects and treasures. Each of these activities has a particular place in the landscape. If you grow towards adulthood here you come to find the place and the form of work that best fits your particular capacities through observation, association and apprenticeship. In this way the community develops and constantly redevelops itself as an organic whole, in which each person uses their talents in relation to and in support of the talents of those around them.</p><p>The phenomenological differences between us — the way each of us relates and responds to our surrounding circumstances — can be subtle and hard to distinguish, either in ourselves or in other people. In te ao Māori they are understood to emerge only over time. In our modern world they are glimpsed only partially and occasionally, if at all. Our individualized ways of differentiating people tend to focus on what we look and sound like, what we produce (our achievements) and what is in us (our natures and personalities). But here we are concerned instead with <em>how we are in relation to one another</em>, with an emphasis on how we might find complementarity in our differences.</p><p>The landscape of responsiveness acts as a map for a conversation that deepens people’s understanding of each other and their differences. Each person’s noticings can be plotted in a back-and-forth exchange between those present that eventually lands in a shared conclusion. As people discover how their own responses are understood by others, they also learn how others can respond quite differently to the same event. For each person, the result is a new sense of how to ‘fit in’ to others in a group. Once these differences are named and acknowledged, the members of the group can function more naturally and powerfully together.</p><p>The transformation we are seeking here is a shift from a sense of people who come together and offer their talents to a joint activity, towards something more like an organic capacity to form an unmerged unity of hearts and minds that meets the needs of any situation.</p><p>Forward to: <a href="https://medium.com/p/6e8c9a30d6e5/edit"><strong>5 Graces — Part 3:<em> Jumping together into a new river</em></strong></a><strong><em>:</em></strong> a set of five responsive archetypes (the Graces) as a basis for an invitation to a learning practice for people in groups. In a workshop pattern, people recognize their own distinctive orientations so that they can weave them together and combine their talents in the most productive way.</p><p>Or back to: <a href="https://medium.com/p/a9eab5e054c1/edit"><strong>5 Graces — Part 1: <em>Recovering our humanity for a post-coronavirus world</em></strong></a><strong><em>: </em></strong>uncovering what has been lost, what needs to be recovered, and why.</p><p><strong><em>Some references</em></strong></p><p>Patricia Benner (1984), <em>From Novice to Expert:</em> Excellence and Power in Clinical Nursing Practice, Addison Wesley</p><p>Hubert Dreyfus (1990), <em>Being-in-the-World: </em>A Commentary on Heidegger’s Being and Time, Division 1, MIT Press</p><p>Hauke Heekeren &amp; Srikantan Nagarajan, Health Eds (2018), <em>Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, </em>online journal at <em>frontiersin.org</em></p><p>Sigrid Breit, Aleksandra Kupferberg, Gerhard Rogler &amp; Gregor Hasler, <em>Vagus Nerve as Modulator of the Brain-Gut Axis in Psychiatric and Inflammatory Disorders</em>, online journal article in <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5859128/"><em>frontiers in Psychiatry</em></a></p><p>Mikhail Bakhtin (1986), <em>Speech Genres and Other Late Essays,</em> translated by Vern McGee, University of Texas Press</p><p>Antonio Strati (2007), <em>Sensible knowledge and practice-based learning</em>, in Management Learning 38</p><p>Ludwig Wittgenstein (1953), <em>Philosophical Investigations,</em> Blackwell</p><p>John Shotter (2008),<em> Conversational Realities Revisited:</em> Life, Language, Body and World, Taos</p><p>Eden Grace (2004), <em>An Introduction to Quaker Business Practice,</em> at <em>edengrace.org</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=76d7ae489c8c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[5 Graces — Part 1: Recovering our humanity for a post-coronavirus world]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@taptiklis/5-graces-part-1-recovering-our-humanity-for-a-post-coronavirus-world-a9eab5e054c1?source=rss-d692d077701a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a9eab5e054c1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[new-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[activism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[post-corona-world]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kindness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Theodore Taptiklis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 20 Jun 2020 05:01:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-07T22:05:49.301Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>5 Graces — Part 1: Recovering our humanity for a post-coronavirus world</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*59lyxfcLdaS-GJhkMgX4tQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04xrv9n">Peter Bruegel the Elder: The Fight Between Carnival and Lent</a></figcaption></figure><p>The ground has shifted. The world looks and feels quite different than it did only six months ago. In this moment of great confusion, something new and momentous is arriving.</p><p>The voices of the old mainstream are still yearning for a return to ‘normal’. A political party leaflet that arrived in my letterbox a week ago says “we must save jobs and get the economy growing again.” But a new mainstream is forming — one that knows that many jobs won’t be saved, and that economic growth is less important than survival and wellbeing. Seldom have the tired habits of oppositional politics, or the sorcery of demagogues, seemed less useful or relevant than they do just now.</p><p>What’s come up instead— first with the pandemic, and now with Black Lives Matter and its excoriation of history — is a growing recognition that what matters most is <strong><em>how we are with each other</em></strong>. (And as well as with each other human, with each other entity on the planet we inhabit). So now we must turn from our seething beliefs and imaginings to face the most basic aspect of our lives: the <strong><em>practicalities of noticing and relating</em></strong> — of recognising the rich complexities of ordinary life, and then dealing with the entanglements of ourselves and other people in the onrush of our everyday encounters.</p><p>But our difficulty here is a challenge, like water for fish, that is invisible to us — because we swim in it all the time and because it pervades every aspect of our conduct. As living, breathing creatures we possess a rich repertoire of bodily capabilities for making sense of and relating with sensitivity and acuity to the world around us: yet our educational and social practices suppress most of these capabilities, confining us instead to a narrow, crippled version of our humanity.</p><p>Our sense of ourselves as the world’s dominant species blinds us from seeing how stunted our abilities have become. For example, a viral pandemic bursts upon us as an unprecedented and unimaginable calamity rather than as a repeated pattern of global history with discoverable traces in our ancestral memories. But now — as a check to our grand narrative of human accomplishment — it’s triggering a yearning for a profound reorientation in the way we do things in the world.</p><p>What follows is my contribution to this yearning, in three parts. In <strong>Part 1: <em>Recovering Our Humanity for a Post-Coronavirus World </em></strong>(below), I start with an account of our self-prescribed diminishment and its devastating consequences. I try to tease apart what is so hard to grasp: our shrunken human behaviours and their exclusionary effects. In <a href="https://medium.com/p/76d7ae489c8c/edit"><strong>Part 2:<em> A New Beginning for Education and Learning</em></strong></a>, I lay out the story of a twenty-year journey of discovery that lays the foundations for a new set of educational and re-educational practices that can start to re-awaken what has been put to sleep. Finally, in <a href="https://medium.com/p/6e8c9a30d6e5/edit"><strong>Part 3: <em>Jumping Together into a New River</em></strong></a>, I offer a work programme for groups that changes the way we deal with one another in our everyday lives as a basis for a new approach to learning, together with some proposals for collaborative research and development. So to bypass the story of getting there and go straight to the invitation, click <a href="https://medium.com/p/6e8c9a30d6e5/edit"><em>here</em></a>.</p><p>Towards the end of 2019, I published some of the background to this story in a six-part essay, <a href="https://medium.com/between-us/a-unity-of-unmerged-voices-a-proposal-to-synchronise-our-efforts-through-microattunement-870922e7082f"><em>Microattunement: a Pattern Language to Wake Up Our Humanity</em></a><em>. </em>That essay was provoked by my colleague Richard Bartlett’s ground-breaking proposal for a fractal view of human organizing that he called <a href="https://www.microsolidarity.cc/articles/proposal"><em>Microsolidarity</em></a>.</p><p>Then as I recognised a number of things missing from that story, I began this document as a sequel to <em>Microattunement</em>. But in the telling it’s become a bigger statement for these new times, as a proposal for a new approach to human relating, self-understanding, belonging and collaboration, and for lifelong education and training. It owes debts to many forebears and fellow-explorers — wherever possible mentioned here — and so in various ways its radical character is not really original.</p><p>My hope is that it might be able to be recognised less as something new, than as something that has always been understood, deep down — perhaps even before there were words with which to say it.</p><h4>Recognising our shrunken mode of human existence</h4><p>We’ve seen modern man — individualized, rational, reflective and critical — as the epitome of human development. Modernity can be understood as a long trajectory, starting with scripture and Greek philosophy. Yet the longer history of life on earth reveals that in several ways, humans have become reduced versions of their former selves.</p><p>This conclusion will be hard to understand and to accept. It’s not an argument to be found in mainstream discourse, in academia, or even in the scuttlebutt of social media. But looking long and hard at the evidence, it seems inescapable.</p><p>Here’s the backdrop for this conclusion, in a nutshell:</p><ul><li>Over the last two millennia almost all peoples have established written languages and have moved towards literacy and numeracy;</li><li>There has been an explosion of written recorded materials that have steadily become accessible to all;</li><li>Written accounts of human experience have sought to supplant oral traditions with the certainties of science;</li><li>Verbal, written and analytical fluency have become the most prized accomplishments of education and the principal basis for success in mainstream public life.</li></ul><p>The rise of literacy and science has laid bare the private lives of fundamental particles and the transgressions of the cosmos, <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/independentpremium/world/all-species-in-world-list-catalogue-animals-plants-microbes-biodiversity-extinction-a9605886.html">un-wilded the world’s wildlife</a>, produced boots on the moon, weapons that can lay waste to the planet, nations of a billion people, factories and supply chains that entangle the world, a maelstrom of interventions that promote health and survival, and has enabled instant communication and increasing surveillance everywhere. Today’s world is unrecognizable from its pre-literate origins.</p><p>But along the way, many human capabilities and behaviours have also been transformed. They include:</p><ul><li><strong>memory. </strong>Pre-literate societies<strong> </strong>had powerful memories. Without writing, human experience was transmitmentatited orally, in songs and stories. Rhythm, assonance and repetition, in sounds, gestures and movements, helped people to remember things and to pass them down the generations.</li><li><strong>attention spans.</strong> In oral societies, epic stories might take days to unfold. People were accustomed to long periods of attentive listening and participation as clans and gatherings.</li><li><strong>ancestry. </strong>The present and future were rooted in a deep sense of the past. The lessons of history in the stories of ancestors were continually present and remembered.</li><li><strong>connection to place.</strong> Aspects of landscape and location were endowed with meanings that invited awareness, recognition, appreciation and understanding of the natural world, and a settled sense of belonging to locality.</li><li><strong>physical awareness. </strong>Survival in a pre-industrial world meant living in and on the land in tune with local inhabitants and circumstances. The best teacher was the body with its multiple capacities of sight, sound, voice, touch, mood and sensitivity to circumstance.</li><li><strong>recognition and acceptance of difference. </strong>Co-dependent and interdependent communal life, with time-honoured divisions and patterns of labour, encouraged a natural association of distinctive talents and bodily capabilities with particular tasks and activities.</li><li><strong>group synergy. </strong>Many activities were collaborative rather than solitary. In shared activities people could bring their recognised differences together to make an unmerged unity that was greater than the sum of its parts</li></ul><p>All these characteristics have been traced by anthropologists and ethnologists and are still visible among indigenous societies and their descendants today. They are listed here not to idealize early humans, but to be able to recognise how our faculties and our relational sensitivities have been influenced and altered, emphasising some capabilities and de-emphasizing others, over thousands of years of human existence.</p><p>So how has literacy and modernization changed us?</p><ol><li><strong><em>Disconnection. </em></strong>Literacy began a long process of encouraging separation from the real world and from lived experience. This effect was famously foreseen by Socrates from his time much closer to the world of orality, nearly 2500 years ago. Text — increasingly available in variety and quantity unimaginable even a century before our own — is now the go-to medium for recorded experience, knowledge, storytelling, news, opinion and communication. Text is a disembodied medium that demands absorption. It’s hard to read (or write) with divided attention. When you’re with text you’re not with anything or anyone else. Instead you’re in the world of the author. As you are with this piece.</li><li><strong><em>Individualism.</em></strong> The notion of the atomised, self-enquiring and self-determining individual is a relatively recent invention, showing up powerfully in the philosophical explorations of René Descartes around 400 years ago. In the wake of Descartes’ assertion of individual choice and decision-making capacity, philosophy, education and public policy all have become focused on the individual as the unit of analysis and concern. What individualism does is to invite a preoccupation with self that draws a person’s attention away from others and the world. In a society of competing individuals, the cultivation, articulation and maintenance of selfhood and identity becomes an important task — something that consumes significant mental and emotional energy. Institutions in most domains now claim individualized values like personal freedom and autonomy as inalienable human rights — however unattainable or inappropriate they are in practice.</li><li><strong><em>Aboutness. </em></strong>Literacy has encouraged mentalization and conceptualization. With the help of the written word, we can form and exchange elaborate models and theories of the world. Moreover, the perspective of science and discovery positions the individual as separate from the object of study. We talk ‘about’ the world and its events and circumstances as something ‘over there’ that we are distant from and can consider objectively. Such a posture of detachment reinforces our mentalization and at the same time suppresses the importance of our own physical engagement with the world and the effect it has on ourselves. ‘Aboutness’ talk is depersonalized, analytical and unemotional. It favours a lofty tone, and often uses the passive voice to give the author or speaker an air of elevated authority and certainty.</li><li><strong><em>Opinionizing. </em></strong>Alone among his contemporaries, Kierkegaard saw the rise of printed newspapers in the early 1800’s as a misfortune because, he explained, it would give people the opportunity to form opinions about happenings far distant from themselves to which they would have no personal commitment. Empty opinions would preoccupy people and distract them from their immediate surroundings and responsibilities. Today we imagine that “everyone is entitled to their own opinion” on any matter. Entire industries have been built to promote the formation and opposition of opinions about any subject or anyone who does or says anything. Like selfhood, this activity absorbs precious mental and emotional energy at the cost of physical presence and attention to the living world of our everyday being. When people meet, a reflex action can be to exchange opinions — often dead, overbaked statements — rather than glimpses of their own, local, live experiences, from which the possibility of fresh insights can arise. The suppression of authentic personal experience in favour of hearsay and rumour is a striking feature of modern times. And with the rise of social media, opinionizing rapidly condenses into fantasies of socially toxic and and divisive conspiracies.</li><li><strong><em>Education as mental fluency. </em></strong>The three ‘r’s — reading, riting and rithmetic — have been the foundation of schooling since Victorian times. The core of our educational practices remains the cultivation of our mental capacities: our logic and reason, our verbal and written expression, and our analytical abilities. We admire quick, confident and persuasive talk. We evaluate, stream and reward learners according to their intellectual prowess. Our physical and artistic capacities are channelled into subordinate domains. In our individualized, competitive institutions of learning, our relational abilities are largely irrelevant and overlooked. We notice and reward learners as team members on the sports field, but seldom in the classroom. In this way, intellectual dominance and verbal capability become instruments of power and authority.</li><li><strong><em>Detachment from the body.</em></strong> Our physicality — all of the manifest dimensionality of our physical, relational selves — is studied as an object of curiosity, but without any practical engagement with its capacities. By seeing it as an object, we mentalize our body and dismiss it from our conscious awareness. In contrast to their view of our orderly, rational mental selves, the Victorians saw our bodies as disturbing and uncontrollable — the potential sites of unfathomable weakness and breakdown. And even for the Greeks, the body was ‘base’ and the head was above and precedent (air over earth). We retain echoes of this mistrust and even disgust in our sense of our bodies as objects beneath the gaze of our higher mental selves. More recently we have channelled objectification into instrumentalization. Now we are seeing our bodies as manifestations of social acceptance, and we push, prod and sculpt them at the gym and the cosmetic surgery to attempt to make them conform to some idealized fantasy. In everyday discourse, our bodies are simply containers for our minds.</li></ol><p>What I’m describing here is a long-term, systematic retreat from presence and engagement with the complexities and spontaneous possibilities of the physical world, in favour of living in our heads and reliance on our entrained and compartmentalized imaginations. By this means we have reduced ourselves to a shrunken version of our original humanity, dwelling in a shadow world of surging thoughts and assumptions that afford us only a heavily filtered and shrouded experience of the real world.</p><p>Our diminishment in this way has serious consequences for our survival. For example, we no longer trust the rich and multilayered evidence of our senses in our everyday encounters. As human animals, we have the capacity to read one another in finely nuanced judgements of voice, gesture and mood to divine the other’s intentions, and respond accordingly. We don’t even need to hear another person’s words to know what they are about and how best to proceed. But living in our heads as we do, we no longer heed what our bodies are telling us. Instead we often resort to stereotypes and fantasies of identity such as differences of skin colour, clothing, religion or accent — to determine our responses. Because we no longer trust our own judgement, we have lost our capacity to trust others.</p><p>Such crippled habits of behaviour help to explain why right-wing hate groups are on the rise around the world, and the shocking and tragic deaths of innocent US African-Americans at the hands of white law-enforcement agencies that has propelled Black Lives Matter into a worldwide movement. They also explain our indifference to global warming and our resort to antagonism and argument in place of action. A society whose responsive capacities have been stifled becomes a petri dish for fear and hatred. Without the capacity for careful and caring acts of relationship, we become trapped in bubbles of uncomprehending isolation and anxiety.</p><blockquote>Barack Obama, May 10 2020: ‘What we’re fighting against is these long-term trends in which being selfish, being tribal, being divided, and seeing others as an enemy — that has become a stronger impulse in American life. And by the way, we’re seeing that internationally as well.’</blockquote><p>This is the global challenge that we now face. Yet there’s no single entity or moment in history to blame for our predicament. All of the institutions and structures of our present human world are combining to reinforce our habits of human diminishment. So it’ll be a big job to shake them off and devise a new path forward.</p><p>Forward to: <a href="https://medium.com/p/76d7ae489c8c/edit"><strong>5 Graces — Part 2: <em>A new beginning for education and learning</em></strong></a></p><ul><li>In this next part I set out an approach to education and learning considered as a practice of <em>improving human responsiveness</em>. Responsiveness is explained as a spectrum of interconnected capabilities in two dimensions — first <em>physical</em>, and then <em>relational</em>. I give examples from group interaction — the focus of the proposed learning approach — for each element of both dimensions. Finally I suggest that our individually distinctive ways of being in the world — our phenomenological differences — can become the touchstone for human synergy and collaboration.</li></ul><p>And lastly to:<strong> </strong><a href="https://medium.com/p/6e8c9a30d6e5/edit"><strong>5 Graces — Part 3: <em>Jumping together into a new river</em></strong></a></p><ul><li>Tyson Yunkaporta and the yarns he tells in his book <em>Sand Talk </em>are the inspiration for a proposed set of patterns — I’m calling them Five Grace<em>s </em>— that weave distinctive physical and relational orientations into linked capabilities that give strength and power to any group endeavour. I set out a work programme called <em>Entangled Bodies</em> that reveals and liberates these under-developed capabilities, and then I invite collaboration and experimentation with groups of people who feel ready to work with us in building a new learning practice aimed at developing what my friend John Shotter described as ‘<em>poised resourcefulness’</em>.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a9eab5e054c1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Towards a harmony of interlocking differences]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@taptiklis/towards-a-harmony-of-interlocking-differences-9cf22817579a?source=rss-d692d077701a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9cf22817579a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[taiwan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-zealand]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collaboration]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[activism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Theodore Taptiklis]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Dec 2019 01:08:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-02T21:03:23.464Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qzHNCcUeGOpTt9TbPcAP9A.png" /><figcaption>Design Theodore Taptiklis/Sam Muirhead</figcaption></figure><p>Reading the articles in <a href="https://taiwaninsight.org/">“Taiwan Insight”</a> emphasises the orientation that we have in New Zealand — that of a modest-sized island nation looking to steer an independent course between global superpowers with whose trajectories we are unavoidably entangled. There are common themes around democratic participation and economic development based on distinctive comparative advantage. The connections don’t end there…it seems that Taiwan’s indigenous peoples may have formed part of the great chain of Pacific migrants that led to New Zealand’s pre-colonial settlement. And now I think Taiwan’s ‘southward’ outlook and its emphasis on youth development may perhaps open up the connections between us even further.</p><p>My first real awareness of Taiwanese identity and difference came in the wake of the 2014 Sunrise student movement and the visit of the inspirational Audrey Tang to a technology conference that in Wellington that was hosted by <a href="https://enspiral.com/">Enspiral</a>, the tech activist community to which I belong. We shared our experiences and also our hopes for purposeful and civilised civic discourse that would be supported and enabled by internet-based tools and technology.</p><p>Since that time, our sense of network technology as an unconstrained force for good has darkened somewhat. But two things have not changed: the urge and the determination for youthful activist participation and the yearning for new methods, platforms and institutions that can manifest this participation.</p><p>In these times of mutual great power aggression, bullying and a retreat to polarised identities of ideology and manufactured conspiracy, we see an opportunity for unthreatening nations like Taiwan and New Zealand to take an opposite tack. Our proposal is that rather than fearing human difference, we should be going out of our way to recognise and celebrate it. Instead of striving for and even enforcing homogeneity of thought and action, we should look for the practical value and sustainable energy of the balance of opposites for the flourishing of life on earth.</p><p>Making practical use of human difference is as old as humanity itself. Bands of hunter-gatherers combined the distinctive faculties and capacities of each member of the band in every search for food. In surviving hunter-gatherer communities we can still see this effortless synergy at work — each person carefully attuned to the skills of each other person at every unfolding moment of the hunt. Today the best sports teams, improv theatre groups and teams of professionals in hospital operating theatres display the same moment-to-moment sensitivity to one another’s distinctive talents. But most of our efforts in public life — in government, in organisations, and in commerce — show little of this essentially physical awareness of one another. Instead, we conduct our affairs and our exchanges largely in our heads, through beliefs, ideas, arguments, systems and frameworks. These abstractions lead us naturally to ignore the details and possibilities of each passing moment that can join our efforts together, and instead to habituate symbolic attitudes and behaviours that keep us apart.</p><p>We have launched a project — Between Us — so far touching New Zealand, Australia and Denmark, that is designed to cultivate the awareness of human difference and to develop it into an everyday practice of mutual understanding and collaboration. The details of this project are set out at <a href="http://www.between-us.net/">between-us.net</a>. The landscape image shown above is a device for locating differences of individual orientation in two dimensions: <em>physical</em> and <em>relational</em>. Such differences are discovered as responses to a purpose-designed, multi-layered experience that is witnessed by groups of people who are ready to recognise and learn to use their particular capabilities in the midst of — and in relation to — others.</p><p>The design of this learning programme draws from ancient wisdoms like those of Confucianism, of <em>yin</em> and <em>yang</em>, and of indigenous practices of encounter and habitus. The aim is to equip people with the skills and understanding that enable them to form a <strong>harmony of interlocking differences</strong> in their everyday dealings — something quite unlike the bruising individuality of much of today’s world.</p><p>We see many hopeful possibilities in this approach, including new forms of schooling and basic education, as well as a new politics that embraces and makes practical use of opposition and difference. And we would love to incorporate a Taiwanese activity stream in our research and development programme, if there is energy and capacity for such a move. Please contact us at <a href="http://hello@between-us.net/">hello@between-us.net</a> if you would like to know more!</p><p><em>No rights reserved for this story.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9cf22817579a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>