<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Taylor Clogston on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Taylor Clogston on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@taylorclogston?source=rss-bc0003e9fbbe------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 01:11:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@taylorclogston/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[After NaNoWriMo: Rewriting Through Iteration]]></title>
            <link>https://taylorclogston.medium.com/after-nanowrimo-rewriting-through-iteration-48cd7cf3b973?source=rss-bc0003e9fbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/48cd7cf3b973</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nanowrimo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books-and-authors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[publishing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[editing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing-tips]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Taylor Clogston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 31 Dec 2021 16:00:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-02T09:29:55.584Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="Scrabble tiles spelling the words “REFINE”, “PAUSE”, “OBSERVE”, “CONSIDER”, and “REPEAT”." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G5vuEXeRFhCAVGe_i-ErtA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@brett_jordan?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Brett Jordan</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/s/photos/iteration?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>National Novel Writing Month has ended, and writers — many of whom have just, for the first time, <a href="https://taylorclogston.medium.com/win-where-i-failed-nanowrimo-survival-lessons-d3548bef70af">finished drafting a book</a> — are flocking to forums and social media groups to ask “Now that I have finished a whole draft, do I need to rewrite my story?”</p><p>“Rewriting is the path to great fiction” is one of the most evergreen concepts in the literature sphere. Everyone from Stephen King to Francine Prose to Kurt Vonnegut seems to share this idea.</p><p>To grow quickly, beginning and intermediate artists should <a href="https://herbertlui.medium.com/why-quantity-should-be-your-priority-3bc2b16fe3f5">finish projects rapidly</a> rather than strive for perfection.</p><p>However, manuscripts should not be considered “finished” after one draft. Rather, rewriting is a powerful tool to finish projects for maximum output and growth.</p><h3>What Is Rewriting?</h3><p>For today’s purpose, rewriting means, “An editing framework which examines a whole draft and then improves it.” Rewriting does <em>not</em> refer to throwing out a first draft and starting again from scratch.</p><p>A common response: “How does rewriting apply to rejecting perfectionism and instead completing many projects?”</p><p>The goal is “good enough,” rather than perfection.</p><h3>Finding the Right Standard</h3><p>Many writers idealize a story experience in their head, but cannot replicate this on the page. They hold a useless standard in their head, one they can never meet.</p><p>Rather, writers should create a standard of quality based on several traits.</p><ul><li><strong>Audience</strong> — Stories are written for readers. Writers must serve their audience before themselves.</li><li><strong>Genre </strong>— From romance’s Happily Ever After to thriller’s final showdown with the villain, a text belonging to a genre has a responsibility to fulfill the expectations of that genre.</li><li><strong>Mechanics </strong>— A writer must apply proper paragraphing, punctuation, spelling, and dynamic voice both in narration and dialogue.</li><li><strong>Shared Human Experience</strong> — People read stories to learn <a href="https://taylorclogston.medium.com/conflict-and-the-end-of-fiction-ab65995e8e6d">what it is like to be another human being.</a> Universal experiences and emotions drive every story. Writers must be careful to give them the narrative spotlight.</li><li><strong>Structure</strong> — A story’s pacing and particular story beats are as integral to keeping a reader’s attention and interest as well-maintained roads are to a city’s functioning.</li></ul><h3>Iterative Revision</h3><p>Once a writer has created a standard, they can rewrite.</p><p>Iteration is key to rewriting. One should apply several editing passes to a manuscript, correcting large-scale problems (e.g., story structure) before making finer-scale changes (e.g., character voice).</p><p>Under this model, a writer examines the entire story at once before any other step.</p><p>The perfectionist alternative to this model often involves a writer moving through one chapter at a time, making structural, character, and copyediting changes based on their intuition from scene to scene.</p><p>Under this model, writers might edit a paragraph to have beautiful language, only to realize later that they must cut the paragraph. Not only have they wasted time editing, but the effort and the paragraph’s beauty may convince the writer to keep it despite its harm to the story.</p><p>A writer’s revision standard not only gives them a target to reach but also a point at which they know to stop working. This is crucial to the goal of finishing one project and beginning another.</p><h3>Efficiency in Quantity</h3><p>Consider a writer who creates unlikably arrogant protagonists. If they write ten stories in a row, editing none of them, they may add the same problematic character into many stories. If they instead fix the issue in revision, the writer will err less often in future projects.</p><p>Such issues are hard to detect during drafting, but become clearer with distance from the project. Craft books recommend putting a manuscript away for a while after drafting, so the writer can separate themselves from it and see it more objectively during revision.</p><p>There are other (and sometimes more efficient) ways to achieve this goal. If possible, writers should join or create a community with others of at least similar skill and exchange writing criticism.</p><h3>When Perfectionism Works</h3><p>Perfectionism <em>can</em> serve advanced artists, those whose audience will eagerly wait for near-perfection that may be years in the making. These authors have often already proved themselves with phenomenal books. Independent writers will unlikely achieve this, nor keep an audience via a perfectionist’s languid writing pace.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Iteration is an elegant, effective path to improving the writing craft. It allows a writer to fix craft problems while completing projects from beginning to end. It allows them space to experiment and grow while adhering to standards of professional quality.</p><p>Creators who revise and iterate surpass those who agonize over one paragraph at a time, and surpass them rapidly. If you have recently finished a story’s first draft, use this advice as the next step in your writing journey. Iterate, fix your flaws, and then write another book that is even better.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=48cd7cf3b973" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Intertextuality and Disney: Response to a Two-Year-Old Video]]></title>
            <link>https://taylorclogston.medium.com/intertextuality-and-disney-response-to-a-two-year-old-video-2e06dbe0671d?source=rss-bc0003e9fbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2e06dbe0671d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[self-publishing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[star-wars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disney]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marvel]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Taylor Clogston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 06 Nov 2021 16:43:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-06T16:44:12.091Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*H1x8CYkp7EV-jFAs" /><figcaption>Picture by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@dariox">dariox</a></figcaption></figure><p>On January 9, 2020, the YouTube channel Nerdstalgic released a video called <a href="https://youtu.be/2RIcKhYpZPc">The Problem With Disney’s Movies In One Word.</a></p><blockquote>“You might have noticed something different about Disney … over the past six or seven years. Something has changed. … (W)hat I think <em>is </em>wrong with Disney is a solvable creative issue. All modern Disney movies are not bad; they aren’t all <em>terrible </em>pieces of entertainment, but I do think that there’s an inherent flaw in the way they’re being made. See, I recently sat down at a surprisingly empty theater and watched <em>The Rise of Skywalker, </em>and something quickly occurred to me. It’s a movie almost entirely built upon a single word, and that word is <em>intertextuality — </em>and in this case, the <em>façade </em>of intertextuality.” -Nerdstalgic, transcription by me</blockquote><p>I encourage you to watch this video. The production value is very nice and I appreciate the conclusion. Sort of.</p><p>Nerdstalgic essentially says Disney, through their “live action remakes” (whose scare quotes are necessary for instances like <em>The Lion King, </em>which contains very little live action) and the recent <em>Star Wars</em> movies, has shifted from a prior strategy of creating new experiences to one of exploiting nostalgia and old experiences.</p><p>In a literary sense, intertextuality isn’t quite what that video describes it as.</p><p>Intertextuality is a critical term to describe something present in literally every work of art that isn’t outsider art, to ask which other texts interact with the examined text, whether consciously and unconsciously.</p><p>Since Nerdstalgic referenced <a href="https://youtu.be/QeAKX_0wZWY">a certain video by Nerdwriter1 on intertextuality,</a> I suggest you watch that as well.</p><p>Both videos fail to understand intertextuality by narrowing their critique to a nearly useless context. Their arguments are akin to a person arguing baked goods are unhealthy when they actually mean <em>chocolate cake</em> is unhealthy.</p><p>This matters because literary criticism is a powerful toolbox creators and consumers of fiction, whether film or novel or other narrative work, can use to meaningfully engage with art. Other powerful tools such as deconstruction are frequently attacked by <a href="https://youtu.be/njTBdCrlmLY">people who don’t understand them,</a> and I believe it’s imperative readers and writers alike know what they mean when they use critical terms.</p><p>Proper examples of intertextuality appear all throughout Tolkien’s <em>The Lord of the Rings.</em></p><p>LotR — the books, I mean — don’t bank on nostalgia, nor, with a few exceptions, is the story harmed by the reader having <em>not</em> read other supporting texts such as <em>The Silmarillion.</em></p><p>However, LotR <em>does </em>draw heavily upon Catholic and Norse mythology, among other real-world sources, perhaps most notably in Gandalf, a figure Odinic in name and aspect while angelic in role and provenance.</p><p>Understanding this intertextuality gives one a fuller appreciation of LotR, but isn’t required to understand the text.</p><p>Simply put, when a writer takes inspiration from other sources, they employ intertextuality.</p><p>A subset of intertextuality is <em>allusion,</em> something much closer to what both nerds talk about in the above videos.</p><p>Allusion is a direct reference to another text the reader is <em>intended</em> to recognize and to carry meaning from that other text into the examined text.</p><p>The question “What’s the problem with Disney movies?” which Nerdstalgic’s video aims to answer needs further qualification. The question implies a “badness” which isn’t defined, but which assumes an audience which agrees with that badness. It points to an empty theater for <em>The Rise of Skywalker, </em>implicit evidence that Disney is on the wrong path, that Nerdstalgic knows why, that he knows how to fix it.</p><p>Yet, there’s a problem with this perspective, one that becomes clear as Nerdstalgic spends most of his video examining the remakes of <em>The Lion King </em>and <em>Aladdin.</em></p><p>Disney <em>has served its primary audience well</em> during the time Nerdstalgic references, and in the years since.</p><p>Essayists can write all day about how Disney used to create much more meaningful art — a perspective with which I whole-heartedly agree — but at the end of the day, Disney tends to cater well to its audiences.</p><p>Yes, plural. That’s my point.</p><p>Look at the Rotten Tomato audience scores for most of the recent “live action remakes,” along with their domestic lifetime grosses:</p><h3>The ones people seemed to like*</h3><ul><li>Aladdin — 94% — $355,559,216</li><li>Beauty and the Beast — 80% — $504,481,165</li><li>Cinderella — 78% — $201,151,353</li><li>Cruella — 97% — $86,103,234</li><li>The Jungle Book — 86% — $364,001,123</li><li>The Lion King — 88% — $543,638,043</li><li>Maleficent: Mistress of Evil — 95% — $113,929,605</li><li>Pete’s Dragon — 72% — $76,233,151</li></ul><h3>The ones people didn’t seem to like so much*</h3><ul><li>Dumbo — 48% — $114,766,307</li><li>Lady and the Tramp — 50% — n/a</li><li>Mulan — 48% —n/a</li></ul><p>Generally speaking, Disney’s “live action remake” strategy has found an audience. In my experience, there is a huge audience which loves these remakes, an audience of blue-collar, ordinary people and their kids and grandkids, people who may not remember much or have any experience with the originals.</p><p>Their Marvel movie audience is comprised of often different people, an audience Disney seems to continuously serve well. The audience they serve the most poorly is their Star Wars audience, and that, by all accounts, from a lack of unified vision throughout the main theatrical releases.</p><p>Artistically, I strongly believe there is a problem with Disney movies. I would love the company which once created some of the most foundational films of my childhood to create more works filled with original artistic vision.</p><p>Yet, from a drawn back perspective, Disney seems to have clearly identified several audiences and to serve them well.</p><p>In one word, my problem with Disney is <em>audience.</em></p><p>We need our culture to <em>want</em> better movies before we can expect Disney to <em>make</em> better movies. Rejecting intertextuality — especially when we don’t know what the word actually means — is not the way to create that culture.</p><p><em>*(all data retrieved from rottentomatoes.com and boxofficemojo.com on 11/6/21)</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2e06dbe0671d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Win Where I Failed: NaNoWriMo Survival Lessons]]></title>
            <link>https://taylorclogston.medium.com/win-where-i-failed-nanowrimo-survival-lessons-d3548bef70af?source=rss-bc0003e9fbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d3548bef70af</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[novel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing-tips]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nanowrimo]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Taylor Clogston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Oct 2021 21:50:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-26T00:03:54.245Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w6OdA6zpxujAdGllRgcZvw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Picture by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@johnschno">John Schnobrich</a></figcaption></figure><h3>November, National Novel Writing Month, is right around the corner!</h3><p>I’m as pumped as I usually am, which means my enthusiasm fluctuates heavily depending on how many things outside writing I remember I need to do in November.</p><p>In case you’re not aware, here’s the lowdown:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/NaNoWriMo.org">NaNoWriMo.org</a> organizes writers all over the world, providing encouragement to write a 50,000 word novel — or whatever other arbitrary goal you set, though 50K is the minimum—during the month of November. Participants are encouraged to use the forums to build accountability and camaraderie with participants living close to their geographical location, and to meet up for in-person write-a-thons.</p><p>I don’t use the official forums much, and neither do most writers I know. Usually, we NaNo in Facebook groups, in Discord servers, on niche writing forums, or in real life.</p><p>These are the lessons I’ve learned to maximize my chances of NaNo success.</p><h3>Don’t partner with likely dropouts.</h3><p>One of the primary benefits of the official NaNo forum is you’ll maintain contact with people who will, you know, keep writing throughout the month. I’ve found that when I write with a pod of three or four friends — adults with jobs and families, the villains — real life overtakes NaNoWriMo.</p><p>The higher the percentage of dropouts, the more pointless my continuation feels. This July, I accepted the invitation of a few friends to do “Camp NaNoWriMo,” which is like a less fancy NaNo throughout the month of July.</p><p>I happily joined, then promptly found myself the only member in the group actually writing. I pretty quickly went back to my regular schedule.</p><p>To avoid this outcome, ask “Am I doing NaNo because I want to write a book in a month, or because I want to write with my friends?”</p><p>If the former, and you’re considering writing with friends without existing writing routines, perhaps you should join the forums. If your writing cohorts already write each day, this might be a fantastic opportunity to inject some fun and competition into the daily grind.</p><h3>Cheat if you can.</h3><p>To be clear: I don’t mean you should lie about your word count.</p><p>I mean that, assuming your goal is to meet your self-imposed word requirement, it’s okay to do everything in your power to make sure you meet that goal.</p><p>You’re allowed to outline and research before November 1st. You’re allowed to rework an old project. It’s okay to write a series of short stories instead of one long book.</p><p>I did that one. That’s how I won my first NaNo after years of failing to write novels. I’ve been told I cheated, but I wrote 50,000 words in a month, and that was my goal.</p><h3>Educate your family and friends.</h3><p>When I was a teenager, I told my dad I would write a book in a month. He thought that sounded cool. Then he came home from work on the evening of November 1st and found me elbow-deep in Microsoft Word 2003.</p><p>“What are you doing?” he asked.</p><p>“Writing my book,” I said.</p><p>“Oh,” he said, “on the computer. I thought you meant like on paper. You’re in for a rude awakening if you think you’re gonna be on the computer every day.”</p><p>To my everlasting shame, I was not — and never will be — the starry-eyed, passionate child who, faced with a minor setback, pulls himself up by his bookstraps and writes the next great American novel on napkins because he has a story to tell, gol dangit.</p><p>When he offered his initial words of encouragement to my NaNo attempt, my dad didn’t know what he was getting into. With proper context, he would have realized he wasn’t willing to bend our family’s low computer usage rules for the sake of my ambition, and both our frustrations would have been lower than they were in the reality where he felt I tricked him and I felt my precious dreams were torn from my grasp.</p><p>My father no longer controls whether I can write on the computer. I have the advantage, at the moment, of being responsible for no one but myself and my decreasingly obese cat, Mr. MacLeod.</p><p>Other people… well, I won’t call them more or less fortunate, but it cannot be denied that bearing responsibility for a family or a significant other can hamper one’s ability to commit to sitting down and writing every single day for a month. Before you commit to NaNo, consider carefully whether “I’m going to write a book in a month” will elicit a response, perhaps on Monday the 1st or, more likely, Saturday the 7th, of “Oh. I didn’t realize you meant <em>that. </em>I didn’t realize you planned on writing <em>every day…”</em></p><p>Be explicit. Be doubly explicit. Be rated something very adult, because it’s a very adult matter to ask someone else to let you be and to understand your availability will diminish until Santa’s first mocking laugh echoes over the horizon.</p><p>Thirty days is a long time, friend. Your support network will realize that, eventually. Make sure they know what they’re getting into.</p><h3>In conclusion…</h3><p>Each of these lessons boils down to smart preparation. Don’t go into NaNo alongside people likely to quit, ensure your friends and family know your intentions for the month, and don’t impose more restrictions on yourself than are necessary.</p><p>Here’s one more NaNo survival tip: Self-hype covers a multitude of sins. Go tell someone, right now, what you’re writing for NaNo. Tell them how it’s going to be fun and dumb, something you can be excited about regardless of how good it is, because no sane person expects you to write a good book in thirty days.</p><p><em>A </em>book. That’s all.</p><p>You got this.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d3548bef70af" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conflict and the End of Fiction]]></title>
            <link>https://taylorclogston.medium.com/conflict-and-the-end-of-fiction-ab65995e8e6d?source=rss-bc0003e9fbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ab65995e8e6d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[conflict]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aesthetics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[drama]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Taylor Clogston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Sep 2021 17:49:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-15T19:38:26.988Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="One mannequin is posed to appear to strangle another mannequin." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*prVvhf4lWR4_rOJFZtyiJw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Charl Folscher on Unsplash</figcaption></figure><blockquote>“…[I]f you don’t have a strong element of conflict inherent in your novel, you don’t have a novel worth reading…” (Lakin, 54)</blockquote><p>Strong words! The typical view of conflict in fiction is that it’s the core of all storytelling, the thing that makes us care about a story to begin with.</p><p>This is a view shared by such people as Larry Brooks:</p><blockquote>“…[T]he hero begins a quest … and then must square off with and ultimately conquer (or not) obstacles — this being the most critical element of storytelling: conflict.” (Brooks, 39)</blockquote><p>And likewise by Damon Knight:</p><blockquote>“Here are all sorts of incidents, but what has become of the story? There is none, because there is no conflict, no difficulty, no tension.” (Knight, 86)</blockquote><p>Even Robert McKee of <em>Story</em> agrees:</p><blockquote>“…[T]he protagonist … enters a world governed by the Law of Conflict. … Nothing moves forward in a story except through conflict.” (McKee, loc 3271)</blockquote><p>Finally, K.M. Weiland insists conflict must exist from the very beginning:</p><blockquote>“No conflict, no story. Conflict doesn’t always mean nuclear warheads going off, but it does demand your characters be at odds with someone or something right from the get-go. Conflict keeps the pages turning, and turning pages are nowhere more important than in the beginning.” (Weiland, 11)</blockquote><p>Most writing craft books I’ve read agree with this general principle, that conflict <em>is</em> story. This agrees with the general form of Western storytelling described in the Monomyth, the Hero’s Journey, the Story Circle, the three-act-structure, and all other slight variations of “Reluctant hero is drawn into an unfamiliar world in which he engages in cyclical striving and failing until he either finds wisdom or fails once and for all.”</p><p>Contrary to this popular wisdom, Ursula K. Le Guin says:</p><blockquote>“Modernist manuals of writing often conflate story with conflict. This reductionism reflects a culture that inflates aggression and competition while cultivating ignorance of other behavioral options. No narrative of any complexity can be built on or reduced to a single element. Conflict is one kind of behavior. There are others, equally important in any human life, such as relating, finding, losing, bearing, discovering, parting, changing. Change is the universal aspect of all these sources of story. Story is something moving, something happening, something or somebody changing.” (Le Guin, 146)</blockquote><p>Le Guin refers to external conflict between persons here, to zero-sum games in which all players are either winners or losers. She elaborates on this perspective in an interview:</p><blockquote>“[T]o preach that story is conflict, always to ask ‘where’s the conflict in your story?’ — this needs some thinking about. If you say that story is about conflict, that plot must be based on conflict, you’re limiting your view of the world severely. And in a sense making a political statement: that life is conflict, so in stories conflict is all that really matters. This is simply untrue. … Conflict, of course, is part of life, I’m not saying you should try to keep it out of your stories, just that it’s not their only lifeblood.” (Le Guin)</blockquote><p>Though she disagrees that “conflict” is the core of storytelling, she holds that “movement” and “change” fill that role.</p><p>Some writers scratch their heads at this. “Sounds like conflict to me,” they mutter. Here lies one of the evergreen problems of writing: We agree on a handful of aphorisms, such as “conflict is necessary,” but we mean different things by the word “conflict.”</p><p>My goal is to reframe the concept of conflict as a fundamental aspect of story, to show that conflict is one of the most useful elements of story, rather than the most important, and that when conflict is absent or only barely present, other elements such as wonder and beauty can create stories worth consuming.</p><h3>The Axiom of Story</h3><p>I hold the following to be self-evident: <strong><em>The two fundamental elements of story are contrast and shared experience. From these proceed all other aspects of story.</em></strong></p><p>I further define conflict for the our purpose today: <strong><em>The difference, friction, stress, or tension between two disparate elements.</em></strong></p><p>Writers who hold the affirmative position “conflict drives story” likely agree with this definition. I believe <em>most</em> writers agree with it in a casual sense, whatever their strict definition.</p><p>Yet that strict definition <em>is </em>frequently different. Often, these authors hold a more particular definition of conflict: <strong><em>The contrast between desire and its obstacle.</em></strong></p><p>This is a view held (indirectly) by Matt Bird:</p><blockquote>“Drama refers to interaction between characters, not conflict within a character, and drama is at the heart of great writing. Conflicted characters are great because they’re volatile, but that volatility only erupts when that conflicted character meets her match and is thereby challenged.” (Bird, loc 1177)</blockquote><p>James Scott Bell and Christopher Downing agree with Bird. They both specify (the latter referencing the former) that a story must create the threat of total destruction — physical, professional, or psychological — of the main character, and Downing specifically urges writers to always answer the narrative question “What is the lead character’s passionate/ethical center that would provoke aggressive action if violated?” (Downing, 19)</p><p>Bird, Bell, and Downing all argue <em>for</em> what Le Guin argues <em>against, </em>that zero-sum, externalized, interpersonal conflict is the heart of story. In contrast, our active definition allows for valid internal conflict that is not necessarily dramatized/externalized.</p><p>I go to these lengths to clarify what I mean by conflict and to establish a survey of what a few of the most prestigious writers of books on story craft mean when they refer to conflict. I was inspired to do so by one resounding theme from <em>Story Trumps Structure</em> by Steven James:</p><blockquote>“When in doubt, add conflict.” (James, 114)</blockquote><p>After years of reading similar proclamations in craft books and hearing the same from the mouths of writers far more accomplished than I’ll ever be, this was the point of exasperation at which I said “There’s more to story than <em>that!”</em></p><p>Again, my axiom of story: The two fundamental elements of story are contrast and shared experience. Conflict plays into this, to be sure. Since systems tend toward equilibrium, we must introduce change into the system of a story world before we have reason to follow any particular event — we need to find the day everything changed. This results, yes, in friction, stress, or tension before the synthesis of the original system with its new element.</p><p>Yet, as we’ll soon see, we should focus on creating contrast and shared human experience, not conflict itself. To fixate on conflict is to look at a patient and see only their symptoms, not the human who hosts the disease or their underlying medical history.</p><h3>Conflict</h3><p>Contrast and shared experience are the building blocks of story, and it’s easy to see how conflict relates to these and why so many intelligent, thoughtful storytellers believe conflict to be the heart of story.</p><p>Conflict almost wholly implies contrast — between what a character wants (that is, what they think they need) and what they truly need, between comfort and calling, between fear and courage, between passivity and activity.</p><p>And conflict <em>does</em> change characters. <em>Internal</em> conflict forces a character to change who they are — there is tension between two aspects of themselves, and they must either discard one, synthesize the two, or roil in a perpetual fugue. If this internal conflict resolves, it creates contrast between the pre-and-post-conflict selves.</p><p>Likewise, <em>external</em> conflict often creates visible and dramatic contrast, whether between an old, comfortable state to which there is no returning and the new world of that character’s reality, or between two characters with clashing desires for whom one must become a winner and the other a loser. These transformations illuminate the involved characters over time, giving the reader a sense they are coming to know the characters as they wade through diverse conflicts.</p><p>Because of this truth, that conflict is valuable, two claims often appear when authors write about conflict’s place in fiction. First, the repeated application of conflict is a powerful story engine. Second, the repeated application of conflict is <em>necessary</em> for any story to function, perhaps to the extent that story is <em>defined</em> by the repeated application of conflict.</p><p>The first point, that conflict is a powerful tool, cannot be denied. Both internal and external conflict clearly contribute toward contrast and, as we’ll see, toward shared experience. We will later examine how the second point, that conflict defines story, lacks universality.</p><h3>Shared Experience</h3><p>Shared experience is a difficult aspect of storytelling to define. We can define contrast with a single example — A bright desert and a dark tomb, a cheerful birthday party and a boy sitting alone on an orphanage bed.</p><p>Shared experience is trickier.</p><p>Modern storytelling descended from ancient oral traditions. Stories were once a way of sharing the wisdom of the family, the community, the tribe. A story said “These people came before us. Learn from them, from their mistakes and their triumphs. See how they were just like you and me, how they still live on through us.”</p><p>Robert McKee says,</p><blockquote>“As our faith in traditional ideologies diminishes, we turn to the source we still believe in … the story arts have become humanity’s prime source of inspiration, as it seeks to order chaos and gain insight into life. Our appetite for story is a reflection of the profound human need to grasp the patterns of living, not merely as an intellectual exercise, but within a very personal, emotional experience.” (McKee, loc 212)</blockquote><p>Damon Knight agrees.</p><blockquote>“There is an implied contract between the author and the reader that goes something like this: Give me your time and pay your money, and I’ll let you experience what it’s like to be • a trapper in the North Woods • an explorer in the Martian desert • a young woman in love with an older man • a dying cancer patient…” (Knight, 51)</blockquote><p>When a reader shares the experience of a character’s life, they empathize with, identify with, grow fond of that character. As the reader shares a character’s experience, the reader grows more tolerant of exposition related to that character — sometimes even eager to experience more.</p><p>Granted, not every reader will cherish the experience of every character. In my experience, this arises — when it doesn’t come from the general failure of suspension of disbelief in the story’s internal consistency — from the reader disapproving of a character’s actions or reactions, whether that be dissonance with a character’s moral choice or that character’s incompetence or petulance.</p><p>Shared experience is present in all stories, for it exists whenever a single character is present for any length of time. The closer we are to a character, the easier it is to share their experience. This is a particular strength of stories told in the first person and/or from a single viewpoint, for they put us as close as possible to our principle character throughout the story. Conversely, stories told from a drawn-back, omniscient point of view, disassociated from any single character, may find difficulty in connecting readers to their characters.</p><p>It’s important to note that shared experience demands authenticity. A reader consumes the story of a shipwright because they want to share the experience of a shipwright — if the author has no idea what it’s like to be one, they’ll disappoint their reader and fail to create the sought experience.</p><p>We’ll now examine how, when contrast and shared experience come together, they have the power to create meaningful stories with redeeming value which don’t rely on conflict. In particular, we can find this value by moving away from the quasi-Western framework of linear “road map” structure which requires “roadblocks” of conflict to create engagement.</p><h3>East vs West</h3><p>Imagine you and your alternate universe self each visit an ancient, lovely European city — perhaps somewhere in France or Italy.</p><p>The first “you” follows your tour guide through a curated tour of the city. First, you pass a selection of historical landmarks which describe how a certain king once owned an estate here or how a famous musician was born in a hut at this very spot.</p><p>This tour culminates in a visit to the city’s capitol building, a stunning piece of architecture you’ve been bursting with anticipation for hours to see. Here and there your guide forces the group to stop while he explains something no one cares that much about — they’re all staring at the more desirable land mark only a few yards away. This careful pacing makes arrival at the anticipated location much sweeter than if you had rushed from place to place.</p><p>As the sun sets, you retire to a fancy restaurant, the reservations made for you ahead of time. You have not only delightful musical entertainment and rich food, but also a framing view of the capitol for you to admire as you dine.</p><p>The second “you” steps into the city without a guide. Having a fair grasp of the local dialect, you make your way through streets not curated for tourists’ eyes, seeing some beautiful and some pitiful sights.</p><p>You give coins to snot-nosed children and pat walleyed dogs and see the birthplace of the aforementioned musician. Having no guide to explain things, you chat with the locals. An elderly couple, proud to show their culture to an interested visitor, make you a few recommendations. You listen to them and climb an old, disused church tower. At the very top, you look out upon the city in its rings of old and new, clean and dirty, happy and sad.</p><p>You gain a new perspective of all that came before, and as the sun sets, you join your impromptu guides for a simple, hearty meal which seems to reflect the city in every way.</p><p>These exaggerated examples describe typical differences between Western and Eastern storytelling. Western storytelling demands a thesis and then an inexorable march toward it. Eastern storytelling often meanders through varying situations and ideas which culminate in a way often synthetic and unexpected. Western storytelling grips its reader by the throat and does not let go until the promised journey is complete, while Eastern storytelling is often an invitation along a journey for which the destination is not the most important aspect.</p><p>Of course, both traditions allow for our axiom of story. Both are about contrast and shared experience. In the Western tradition, the contrast often comes through the conflict between want and need, between a character’s desire to be at rest and external forces which demand that character move or be crushed, between deep-seated longing and three or more obstacles standing in the way.</p><p>Contrast in Eastern storytelling often comes from the difference between two disparate elements which might not seem connected until the story’s conclusion, between one state of being and another, between different ideological answers to the same question.</p><p>Both traditions say “This is what it means to be human!” In the Western tradition, to be human is primarily to overcome. Whether one overcomes a corporeal foe, inner fear, physical weakness, or one’s sin and vice, one strives and is opposed and seeks to overcome.</p><p>In the Eastern tradition, to be human is primarily to experience. It may sound flippant or tautological, but the Eastern tradition is one that often describes the facts of life and says “So it goes.” This does not preclude a message or narrative destination, however. Dostoevsky’s narrative philosophy, for example, tends more toward this Eastern mindset than the typical Western one, yet his novels are thematically rich and promote strong moral viewpoints. The Eastern tradition is not necessarily one of postmodern or nihilistic fixation on the meaninglessness of objective reality.</p><p>I should note that we can’t define every non-Western storytelling style at once, for they vary considerably more than the storytelling traditions of the West. South African, Japanese, Polish, and Saudi traditions may be in ways more similar to each other than to the Western canon, but that does not by any means unify them. This detail passes outside the scope of our discussion.</p><p>As we’ll see in describing one example of Eastern storytelling, while both Western and Eastern traditions rely on shared experience as a primary narrative component, the Eastern tradition leans on it at a more fundamental level.</p><h3>Kishōtenketsu</h3><p>The single most famous Eastern story structure is Kishōtenketsu, the Japanese story structure which likely originated in China’s Qiyan Jueju poetic structure and which can also be seen in Korean storytelling. It is closely related to the Japanese aesthetic concept of Johakyū, which describes events that build slowly, break or tear or scatter, and then conclude urgently or rapidly. (Boylan)</p><p>The Kishōtenketsu structure is named for elements which don’t look much different to an act-based Western structure:</p><blockquote>Ki — Introduction</blockquote><blockquote>Shō — Continuation/Development</blockquote><blockquote>Ten — Twist</blockquote><blockquote>Ketsu — Conclusion</blockquote><p>Meanwhile, an expression of the Western story structure could be described thusly:</p><blockquote>Act One — Exposition/Introduction/“Once Upon a Time”</blockquote><blockquote>Act Two — Rising Action/“Then One Day…”</blockquote><blockquote>Act Three — Climax/“Until, finally…”</blockquote><blockquote>Act Four — Falling Action + (Denouement/Resolution/“And so, they lived…”)</blockquote><p>There are a few key differences. The Western structure relies on conflict, while Kishōtenketsu doesn’t. In Kishōtenketsu, Ki can be any situation, including a woman setting off on a mountain hike. The Western structure would demand the woman have some twist, reversal of fortune, or moment of danger (to borrow from Jane Cleland) as early as possible, though no later than the end of the act, while in Kishōtenketsu we may simply follow the woman’s journey. This is taboo to the Western structure, and is the most important difference between the two.</p><p>A second important contrast appears between Shō and Act Two. In Kishōtenketsu, Shō simply continues Ki. It progresses Ki in that it moves forward, but this does not imply it moves to a different location. If our Ki was that a woman sets off on a hike, Shō encompasses all the locales and wildlife she encounters on that hike.</p><p>In the Western Act Two, we almost necessarily see twists and changes as plot points force characters to act and react to unfamiliar or unexpected circumstances. We likely see at least two shifts in perspective in the first and second plot points which bound Act Two. These are not necessary or even expected in Shō.</p><p>The twist of Ten, however, is imperative — Not specifically a plot twist in the ordinary sense (though we’re not excluded from one) but a twist in perspective, sensibility, character, or setting. The important thing is something <em>shifts.</em> In our hiker’s story, Ten might involve a scene break that shifts its perspective to a desolate graveyard, very different to the prior scene. It’s not immediately connected. Contrast draws between the pre-Ten and post-Ten perspective.</p><p>And of course, the Western Climax (which you may consider its own act, or perhaps the scene immediately between Acts Two and Three in Three Act Structure. We consider it an act here to compare and contrast with the similarly placed Ten) often involves the protagonist making the choice whether to sacrifice their want to attain their need and overcome the final obstacle or to cower/retreat/die tragically, unable to relinquish their deepest flaw. Contrast is drawn by recontextualizing the failures in the Rising Action in light of the protagonist’s epiphany.</p><p>Ketsu synthesizes all the prior elements of Kishōtenketsu. Our hiker appears at our graveyard and sits on a bench beside a tombstone, talking to her grandmother’s gravestone about how the tree they planted atop the mountain is bearing fruit for the very first time. There is often little to no equivalent to falling action or epilogue in Kishōtenketsu, a practice derived from the kyū or “rapid conclusion” of Johakyū. The final moment of Ketsu most often exists as a prompt to the reader to contemplate the journey and ask themselves if seeing the whole changes their perspective of its constituent parts.</p><p>Act Four, the falling action and resolution of the Western structure, show the transformed protagonist more able to deal with the unchanged world of Act One. Contrast is drawn once more between each of the story’s extremes, in character, emotion, setting, and situation. The triumph of the protagonist validates their worldview.</p><p>I hope this example of Eastern story structure illuminates how millions of people for thousands of years have used an entirely different story structure to those typically found in the West to describe the meaning in their lives. Now that we’ve shown how stories can be created which aren’t centered on conflict, we’ll examine some elements found in both Eastern and Western storytelling which provide redeeming value outside of conflict.</p><h3>Beauty and Wonder</h3><p>More elements than simply “Story with a capital S” (as Steven James puts it) contribute to making a work of fiction worth reading. Two of the most powerful elements are beauty and wonder.</p><p>But these are subjective and difficult to define! They rely on the reader’s artistic sensibilities and are, likely, less universal than other story elements. Yet, they can be some of the most powerful elements in fiction. Wonder invokes the reader’s awe of things greater than themselves, of the divine or of the unimaginable vastness of space or of looming mountains and impenetrable jungles.</p><p>Beauty is simply aesthetically pleasing prose, words which are delightful to speak and to hear and to see upon the page.</p><p>Many Japanese books in the Kishōtenketsu tradition hang upon beauty and wonder for their artistic merit, as did many of the revolutionary fantasy writers such as Lord Dunsany, George MacDonald, and J.R.R. Tolkien. Books which rely on these elements, when they find an audience capable of appreciating them, can often get away with little conflict — not to say Tolkien, at the very least, ignored conflict in his writing!</p><p>Take, for example, this passage from <em>The King of Elfland’s Daughter</em> by Lord Dunsany:</p><blockquote>“Nobody can tell you about that sword all that there is to be told of it; for those that know of those paths of Space on which its metals once floated, till Earth caught them one by one as she sailed past on her orbit, have little time to waste on such things as magic, and so cannot tell you how the sword was made, and those who know whence poetry is, and the need that man has for song, or know any one of the fifty branches of magic, have little time to waste on such things as science, and so cannot tell you whence its ingredients came. Enough that it was once beyond our Earth and was now here amongst our mundane stones; that it was once but as those stones, and now had something in it such as soft music has; let those that can define it.” (Dunsany, 4)</blockquote><p>The book has little conflict. A king of men ventures to Elfland and takes its princess back to marry him, and then her father spends a while trying to take her back, and a man wanders futilely in search of Elfland, and the people of the land can’t make up their minds if they want a magic lord or not. None of that is, frankly, very interesting — yet, the words pull a certain kind of reader in with their sheer beauty, with their constant evocation of an unseen Eden mankind may no longer touch (though Dunsany might not have appreciated that comparison).</p><p>Perhaps the book would be better with a stronger plot. I still hold that its beauty and wonder alone make it worth reading.</p><p>Similarly, <em>The Name of the Wind</em> by Patrick Rothfuss has little conflict or plot progression relative to its length. However, its prose is so beautiful, its sense of wonder so carefully cultivated, and we spend so much time sharing the experience of its narrator Kvothe that it’s one of the most beloved works of modern fantasy. Its opening line, for example, has become a modern classic:</p><blockquote>“It was night again. The Waystone Inn lay in silence, and it was a silence of three parts.” (Rothfuss, 1)</blockquote><p>A certain objection arises: “Is a bunch of pretty language without much conflict really a story? Even if it is, is it an <em>interesting</em> story? Isn’t it closer to a poem?”</p><p>Perhaps. Every art form has its particular strengths over the others — film combines the audible and the visual in a way impossible for fiction to replicate, while fiction allows a more personal connection to a character’s inner world than film can provide. The single frame of a painting invites detailed study of every brush-stroke in a way the standard film experience — that is, not pausing every frame — allows. The physical dimensionality of sculpture, its presence in the real world, cannot be approached by any other visual form.</p><p>Some writers, such as John Gardner, argue that one of the prime strengths of fiction is its ability to deliver character-and-event-driven narrative (that is, adhering to the Western tradition) which fails when “…interrupted … by some … conscious ploy on the part of the artist.” (Gardner, 98) When only wonder and beauty remain, Gardner argues, the art form does not play to its strength.</p><p>This is an argument especially suited to genre fiction, where readers demand more than simply beauty and wonder. The more a story is a product, rather than a work of art, the more it must rely on conflict and the Western, conflict-driven try-fail cycle to reach its audience. The James Bond books are beloved, but for neither their beauty nor their wonder. Beloved for their contrast and shared experiences, yes, but Fleming never skimped on the conflict, and the conflict created his audience.</p><p>This raises an important question: Can popular (that is, “ones which serve the people”) fiction exist without relying on conflict above and before all else? I argue they can, and will examine four examples which show this.</p><h3>Case Studies</h3><h4>Case Study 1: The opening of Up by Pixar</h4><p>The opening portion of <em>Up</em> is one of the most powerful introductory sequences in recent filmmaking. As of this writing, if one types “opening of” in the YouTube search bar, “opening of <em>Up”</em> is the sixth result, and the only result referring to a movie.</p><p>The sequence opens on two children with contrasting personalities, Ellie and Carl, agreeing to go adventuring when they’re older. They marry, buy a house, fix it up, decorate it. They discuss their dreams for the future. Ellie dreams of exploring, which Carl passively shares, while Carl dreams of starting a family, which Ellie actively shares. Their till-now idyllic life strikes a discordant note as they learn Ellie can’t carry a child.</p><p>Seeing Ellie depressed, Carl reassures her of his love, and the two grow old and happy in each other’s company. Eventually, Carl remembers Ellie’s old dream of adventure, and, saddened by the realization that Ellie left her dream behind, determines to surprise her with plane tickets so he can fulfill the promise they made as children. Unfortunately, Ellie is struck down by illness before this can happen, and she soon passes away, leading to the situation of the beginning of the movie — Carl is a disillusioned and bitter man who wants to be left alone after the love and light of his life has vanished.</p><p><em>Up</em> conveyed that in less than ten minutes and with only a few lines of dialogue at the very beginning. Its power comes from the contrast in personalities and desires of its characters, of the emotions of joy and sorrow, of color and light, of physical framing in the scene — elements of beauty which are the strength of the film medium. Its power comes from following two people throughout nearly their whole lives and seeing them bloom and fade, shining in the prime of youth and the glory of old age.</p><p>Aside from the twist that the pair can’t have children which breaks the continuation of their happy lives, and from Ellie’s eventual death which is the turning point in the “once upon a time” which allows the story to take place, there is little to no conflict in this sequence.</p><p>Yet few people would look at this and say “What a terrible story. There’s nothing here of interest!” By contrast, the portion of the movie which follows a more traditional Western structure afterward is cute, but is generally less memorable.</p><h4>Case Study 2: Calvin and Hobbes — Jan 14, 1990 comic strip by Bill Waterson</h4><p>This work relies on the reader’s prior shared experience with the <em>Calvin and Hobbes</em> comic strip by Bill Waterson. Heavy contrast defines the dynamic between Calvin and his dad, as Calvin is a hyperactive troublemaker and his dad is a straight-laced businessman frustrated by Calvin’s antics.</p><p>A typical interaction between them involves either Calvin asking about some scientific fact, only for his dad to give him a deliberately wrong but amusing answer which Calvin tries to logically unravel, or Calvin performing some annoying or destructive act which prompts his dad to scream at Calvin to stop, sometimes punishing him with chores, a spanking, or the dire threat of cold anger. However, his dad has some tolerance for Calvin’s troublemaking — he doesn’t react immediately with fury unless Calvin destroys property.</p><p>Though the reader will likely come to this particular strip with the intellectual understanding that Calvin and his father share a loving relationship, the reader will likewise have seen mostly negative interactions between the two of them. We rarely see the ordinary day-to-day interactions between the two, but only those during which Calvin causes trouble. Our case study is a unique exception.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/562/0*E1dAWZZmghRgveAG.jpg" /></figure><p>In the first few panels, Calvin dresses for snowy weather and asks his dad to join him outside. His dad points to his heavy workload and implies he can’t spare the time, which prompts Calvin to walk away with a look of disappointment. Over the next few panels, his dad continues working, though his expression is one of dreariness. He looks out the window, then back to his work, then grabs his coat.</p><p>We see a panel in which Calvin faces his dad, both expressing joy. The two build a snowman. In the final panel, Calvin’s mom lifts him up to plant a good-night kiss on his dad’s forehead — who is back at his desk, showing that he didn’t simply choose play over work, but gave up time he wouldn’t get back to spend it with his son.</p><p>This would be a cute vignette on its own if it involved arbitrary characters. In its proper context, in contrast to the ordinary scenes between Calvin and his dad, it expands and illuminates their relationship beautifully.</p><p>Though there is some conflict to the story, in that Calvin wants his dad to play and his dad must choose between work and play (and it’s true that without this element, the story wouldn’t be as strong), the reliance on contrast and shared experience is stronger and more thoroughly present. (I didn’t point out much wonder or beauty here, but any reader of the comic will know these are a mainstay of it)</p><h4>Case Study 3: The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle by Haruki Murakami</h4><p>This novel by Japanese author Haruki Murakami is a peculiar, polarizing book. It has very little conflict and an enormously passive main character. In fact, the opening scene finds unemployed protagonist Toru interrupted by an obscene phone call while making spaghetti. He politely hangs up, refusing to engage with the caller. When Toru’s wife comes home that night, they converse about horses going mad during the full moon, and Toru promises to talk to a psychic about finding their missing cat.</p><p>The next day, Toru discovers his wife has vanished without a trace. This does not prompt a wild investigation, as it likely would in a Western story structure, but a chain of increasingly surreal events involving the history of Toru’s marriage, his friends and acquaintances, and a dry well with which Toru thematically identifies.</p><p>The novel is filled with (beautiful and wondrous) literary flourishes, Dostoevsky-esque anecdotes punctuating each sub-book, and a battery of comparisons and contrasts between what Toru is and what he should or could be. It is, in a word, magical, and yet adheres hardly at all to requirements for proactive protagonists driven by yearning and opposed at every angle by an ever-mightier array of obstacles. Though a commercially successful book, it is, to be sure, not genre fiction, and does not serve as broad an audience as a family-focused Pixar movie or a syndicated comic strip.</p><h4>Case Study 4: The Book of Ruth</h4><p>This classic book of the Hebrew and Christian Bibles opens with tragedy: Ruth, a native woman of the nation of Moab, loses her Hebrew husband to illness, along with her brother-in-law. Soon after, her father-in-law also dies, leaving her Hebrew mother-in-law, Naomi, alone in a foreign land.</p><p>Naomi commands her two daughters-in-law to choose happiness and live among their own people, but Ruth refuses and proclaims she will go with Naomi to live in Naomi’s homeland of Judah. In this new land, Ruth collects alms from the field of a distant relative of her husband. This man, Boaz, hearing of Ruth’s identity, creates a situation favorable and secure for Ruth, allowing her to collect grain unmolested and even giving her an extra portion of grain.</p><p>Upon learning of Boaz’s desire to support Ruth, Naomi prompts Ruth to invoke the Hebrew tradition of kinsman redemption, through which Ruth can call upon Boaz to marry her. This would allow Ruth to retain the right of inheritance she would have otherwise lost through her husband’s death.</p><p>Boaz agrees to this, though there is another relative who has a more direct responsibility to redeem Ruth. The relative agrees to relinquish his right of redemption, and Boaz marries Ruth. The two have a son, who is the grandfather of King David — in the Christian tradition, the ancestor of Christ.</p><p>This narrative contains little conflict, but is nonetheless a beautiful story of devotion and mercy. There are only two real points of conflict. First, Ruth and her sister-in-law desire both to remain in their homeland and to remain devoted to the downstruck mother of their late beloved. Later, there is a brief complication before Boaz marries Ruth, for the more eligible redeemer must choose whether to take the sacrificial act of giving up his own inheritance to give Ruth hers. He keeps his, of course, and this immediately upon understanding the stakes.</p><p>On the other hand, the narrative is filled with not only the touching, human story of a woman giving up everything to support a loved one, but also with beautiful prose:</p><blockquote>“But Ruth replied:</blockquote><blockquote>Don’t plead with me to abandon you</blockquote><blockquote>or to return and not follow you.</blockquote><blockquote>For wherever you go, I will go,</blockquote><blockquote>and wherever you live, I will live;</blockquote><blockquote>your people will be my people,</blockquote><blockquote>and your God will be my God.” (Ruth 1:16, CSB)</blockquote><p>Despite its lack of conflict, the Book of Ruth is one of my favorite books of the Christian Bible, for its shared human experience and for its beauty, not to mention its thematic weight when considered as one part of a small whole: In my own Christian tradition, the redemption of Ruth the outsider into a Hebrew family is a picture of the later redemption of the Gentile church into a covenant with God by Jesus Christ.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>We must address one final, vital truth: for many people, writing and storytelling are their trades, not simply forms of art. Story, to these people, puts meat on the table. You might ask “What does it matter if it’s possible to write a story without conflict at its core when that seems to be what everyone wants to read?” For certain, the authors and editors referenced throughout this discussion have written about how to create stories that will reach, hook, and capture audiences more often than they have set out to teach how to create good art.</p><p>For this point, I read through thirty writing craft books, as well as Alfred Hitchcock’s definition of story within his interviews with Truffaut, and a transcript of Kurt Vonnegut’s lecture on story structure. Within them, sixteen storytellers describe what they believe story to be, or, at least, what they believe a great story to be, or one worth reading. The remainder seem to take it for granted that a person reading a book about story-writing knows what a story is to begin with.</p><p>Five of these sixteen — Robert Olen Butler, Robert McKee, Julio Ortega, Deb Olin Unfearth, and Kurt Vonnegut — achieved scholarly or literary success, but no popular success that I could find — at least, none made a living by selling screenplays to Hollywood or by writing thrillers.</p><p>The remaining eleven — Hirohiko Araki, Larry Brooks, Deborah Chester, Jane K. Cleland, John R. Erickson, John Gardner, Alfred Hitchcock, Damon Knight, Ursula K. Le Guin, Brian McDonald, and Dennis O’Neil — are popularly successful storytellers who give an interesting array of aspects they considered to define story.</p><p>Hirohiko Araki and Larry Brooks lean on Western story structure in their definitions (and in fact the purpose of Brooks’ whole book is that Western story structure is to story as architecture is to buildings).</p><p>Deborah Chester describes story as providing poetic justice and the answers to dramatic questions.</p><p>Alfred Hitchcock and Jane K. Cleland hang everything upon suspense, though they likewise claim that sharing characters’ longing is vital.</p><p>Dennis O’Neal gives a practical and workmanlike definition — story is a structured narrative that serves purposes like revealing character or proposing a point of view.</p><p>Erickson, Gardner, Knight, Le Guin, McDonald, and McKee agree that shared experience, telling your human reader “this is what it is to be human,” is the core of story (and certainly Araki, Hitchcock, and Cleland put strong emphasis on this also).</p><p>The definitions from which I draw, and my brief interpretation of each, <a href="https://taylorclogston.medium.com/conflict-and-the-end-of-fiction-appendix-and-bibliography-6a6505edebc">can be found in the appendix, along with the bibliography.</a> Feel free to examine my judgments at your leisure.</p><p>At least six of these twelve popular creators, people who made quite a lot of money writing stories which ordinary people enjoyed consuming, put greater emphasis on shared experience than upon anything else. They, of course, add more nuance to their definitions through their works. We mentioned earlier how McKee believes story can’t move forward except by conflict, and outside of his particular definition above, Knight claims incidence without difficulty or obstacle is not story. As it turns out, complex human storytellers have complex views on storytelling.</p><p>What I hope I’ve showed is that there is more to storytelling than conflict. Moreover, a story can be worth consuming without being driven at every turn <em>by</em> conflict.</p><p>I do <em>not</em> believe that conflict is completely unnecessary to story. I can’t think of a single great story without some level of friction, stress, or tension. Yet I have never enjoyed a story purely for its conflict, never been gripped by thwarted desire. I, and many others, consume stories to make sense of a world that seems often senseless, to empathize with other humans and to see the beauty of the universe represented in the delightful way only the human mind can interpret.</p><p>I believe we can look at life transcribed, see loss and pain and joy and redemption, and call that story regardless of how many times and exactly when our guy lost before winning.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ab65995e8e6d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conflict and the End of Fiction: Appendix and Bibliography]]></title>
            <link>https://taylorclogston.medium.com/conflict-and-the-end-of-fiction-appendix-and-bibliography-6a6505edebc?source=rss-bc0003e9fbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6a6505edebc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literary-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[appendix]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bibliography]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Taylor Clogston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Sep 2021 17:37:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-22T17:49:59.375Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Appendix — What Is a Story?</h3><p>Here I’ve transcribed the various definitions of story I referenced in the conclusion of <a href="https://taylorclogston.medium.com/conflict-and-the-end-of-fiction-ab65995e8e6d">Conflict and the End of Fiction.</a> I put them here, alongside my interpretations, for the purpose of transparency. It’s entirely possible for another person to read the same text as myself and come to a different conclusion about the author’s intentions, but I made my analysis in good faith and I hope my notes make that clear.</p><blockquote>“The artist is comfortable only with going back to the way in which the chaos is first encountered — that is, moment to moment through the senses. Then, selecting from that sensual moment-to-moment experience, picking out bits and pieces of it, reshaping it, she recombines it into an object that a reader in turn encounters as if it were experience itself: a record of moment-to-moment sensual experience, an encounter as direct as those we have with life itself.” (Butler, l0c 143)</blockquote><p>Butler believes story is shared experience via sensation to make sense of the world.</p><blockquote>“So in this short piece, we have seen: the development of a complex psychology, a set of startlingly original sentences, a sharp emotional shift from calm observation to rage, an unparalleled style, a knock-out title, a social critique, and a very moving story about one woman’s private crisis while running a common errand. (Unfearth, 137)</blockquote><p>Deb Olin Unfearth in Rose Metal Press Guide does not set out to define story, but in response to the question “Can you write a full story in flash fiction, and what even is a story?” she uses this as an example of flash fiction which is a story — Note the presence of contrast and shared experience, as well as the elements of beauty and intellectual engagement.</p><blockquote>“The first story ever, I read somewhere, appears on an ancient Egyptian tablet and declares that “John went out on a trip.” How do we know that this is a flash fiction and not a document? Because no one during that time period could have left his town on his own will. Moreover, it encapsulates the high rhetoric of sudden fiction: it has a character (I call him “John,” but he has 1,000 names); there is a dominant action (the storytelling is fully present); and what is shown or said happens in time. Not less important, it announces the very rule of any story — the breaking of a code. John is an adventurer who stands against authority and decides to leave, to explore, to know.” (Ortega, 167)</blockquote><p>Ortega lays out his definition of story clearly here: Has a character, a line of action, a frame of time, and, most importantly, conflict between the system of the world and a character.</p><blockquote>“CONCEPT — The idea or seed that evolves into a platform for a story. Best and most empowering when expressed as a “what if?” question. The answer leads to further “what if?” questions in a branching and descending hierarchy, and <strong>the collective whole of those choices and answers becomes your story.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>CHARACTER — Don’t leave home without one. … we do need to root for him.</blockquote><blockquote>THEME — … Not to be confused with concept, theme is what your story is illuminating about real life.</blockquote><blockquote>STRUCTURE — What comes first, what comes next, and so forth … and why. And no, you can’t just make it up for yourself. There are expectations and standards here. …</blockquote><blockquote>SCENE EXECUTION — You can know the game, but if you can’t play it well you can’t win. …</blockquote><blockquote>WRITING VOICE — The coat of paint, or if you prefer, the suit of clothes, that delivers the story to the reader. The biggest risk here is letting your writing voice get in the way. Less is more. Sparingly clever or sparsely eloquent is even better. … That’s it. There’s nothing else under the writing sun, because anything you can think of that pertains to developing and writing a story aligns under one of these categories.” (Brooks, 23, emphasis mine)</blockquote><p>Brooks considers story to be a conglomerate of six aspects — a story needs to have a dramatic question, a character, a theme, adherence to the Western structure which he describes as Setup, Response, Attack, and Resolution (and he describes these elements as fulfilling a universal storytelling law the same way architecture has rules defined by the laws of physics), and moreover be aesthetically pleasing. Though I don’t know that he intended to give a full definition of story with the line, he seems to describe a story as a series of what-if questions and their answers and consequences.</p><blockquote>“A story is built with a beginning, middle, and an ending. … Whatever lingo you use, each of these three components contains specialized elements necessary to the delivery of a good story. These elements include: grabbing reader interest; sustaining reader interest; steadily increasing tension and suspense regarding the outcome; guiding readers through an emotional catharsis; providing a satisfying resolution of events; answering the story question; and delivering poetic justice. They are designed to capture readers, and move them from start to finish while keeping them enthralled. (Chester, loc 156)</blockquote><p>Chester gives mechanical definitions for a story, and describes an ideal story as one which grabs and holds reader interest throughout while answering dramatic questions and delivering poetic justice.</p><blockquote>“A good story ought to perform a service by making us better, stronger, wiser, or happier than we were before. It makes us laugh or cry. It imparts wisdom. It teaches lessons about human nature and our place in God’s creation. It addresses our need to find coherence in our lives. It gives us a sense of continuity within the overall stream of human experience. That occurs when writers frame off a piece of experience and describe it well, following the intuitive blueprint inside the human soul that has responded to the craft of storytelling since the dawn of time.” (Erickson, 71)</blockquote><p>Erickson argues a good story encompasses truth about what it means to be human via shared experience.</p><blockquote>“The most important single notion in the theory of fiction I have outlined — essentially the traditional theory of our civilization’s literature — is that of the vivid and continuous fictional dream. … the writer sets up a dramatized action in which we are given the signals that make us “see” the setting, characters, and events; that is, he does not tell us about them in abstract terms, like an essayist, but gives us images that appeal to our senses … so that we seem to move among the characters, lean with them against the fictional walls, taste the fictional gazpacho, smell the fictional hyacinths.” (Gardner, 98)</blockquote><p>Gardner calls for story to simulate reality via shared experience.</p><blockquote>“A successful story is or seems to be all of a piece — all in harmony, all saying the same thing in different ways, having its own steady rhythm, with nothing out of key, nothing inappropriate or irrelevant. In a story we expect a quality of completion, of roundedness, which sets it apart from a sketch, an incident, or an anecdote. … the incident or the anecdote could be turned into a story by adding complications and characters. … we have established an emotional relationship involving at least two people … and an impediment to a satisfactory conclusion…” (Knight, 48)</blockquote><p>Knight describes a story as opposed to an anecdote in that a story is complete — we could interpret this as a variation of beginning, middle, end, but with the added condition of thematic wholeness involving characters in a relationship for whom conflict stands between them and a “satisfactory” conclusion.</p><blockquote><strong>“…truth is all that any story worth telling is getting at.</strong> … This simple sentence, <strong>we are all the same,</strong> is the Golden Theme that all stories express. And it is my firm belief that the closer a story comes to illuminating this truth, the more powerful and universal it becomes, and the more people are touched by it.” (McDonald, loc 131, emphasis original)</blockquote><p>McDonald doesn’t set out to define what things could be seen as a story, but to say all stories are really about shared experience.</p><blockquote>“The writers of portraiture and spectacle, indeed all writers, must come to understand the relationship of story to life: Story is metaphor for life. … A two-hour metaphor that says: Life is like <strong>this!</strong> … A story must be like life, but not so verbatim that it has no depth or meaning beyond what’s obvious to everyone on the street. … What happens is fact, not truth. Truth is what we think about what happens.” (McKee, loc 426, emphasis original)</blockquote><p>McKee says anecdotes and not-stories simply relate the literal incidence of reality, but a proper story interprets events to evoke universal truth. This implies shared experience but, deliberately, the simple shared experience of a person with no subtextual commentary would not be a proper story.</p><blockquote>“A story is structured narrative designed to achieve an emotional effect, demonstrate a proposition, or reveal character.” (O’Neil, 14)</blockquote><p>O’Neil’s definition, used for the writing of superhero comics, simply demands structure and some kind of narrative goal.</p><blockquote>“Story is something moving, something happening, something or somebody changing.” (Le Guin, 146)</blockquote><p>Le Guin argues for motion and change as it relates to human experience — she therefore argues for shared experience. Despite her literal claim against conflict, many of her examples can be described as both conflict and contrast.</p><blockquote>“…there are two features that most published books share. First, they’re simultaneously fresh and familiar. … The second feature … is something in the writing that touches readers’ hearts and makes them feel the characters’ yearnings. (Cleland, 10)</blockquote><p>Cleland doesn’t specifically give a definition of “What is a story?” Story as described in her book may be self-evident — if you’re telling it, it’s a story. But she claims the key to a good story is a particular kind of contrast, similar to the “Surprising, yet inevitable” hallmark of the Writing Excuses podcast hosts, as well as connection to its characters so that the receiver shares their experience.</p><blockquote>“I don’t want to film a “slice of life” because people can get that at home, in the street, or even in front of the movie theater. They don’t have to pay money to see a slice of life. And I avoid out-and-out fantasy because people should be able to identify with the characters. Making a film means, first of all, to tell a story. That story can be an improbable one, but it should never be banal. It must be dramatic and human. What is drama, after all, but life with the dull bits cut out. The next factor is the technique of film-making, and in this connection I am against virtuosity for its own sake. Technique should enrich the action. One doesn’t set the camera at a certain angle just because the cameraman happens to be enthusiastic about that spot. The only thing that matters is whether the installation of the camera at a given angle is going to give the scene its maximum impact. The beauty of image and movement, the rhythm and the effects — everything must be subordinated to the purpose.” (Hitchcock via Truffaut, loc 1570)</blockquote><p>Hitchcock explains that suspense is key to storytelling, that the ideal story is a believable, realistic narrative with no dull bits. He believes beauty (through filmmaking technique, analogous to literary style) should never exist on its own but always serve the suspenseful narrative. There is an element of shared experience which is assumed, not emphasized.</p><blockquote>“Any manga that can be considered famous, as well as any novel or movie, will share certain story beats that will never stop captivating audiences. The basic version of this structure can be summed up as <strong>ki-shō-ten-ketsu</strong> … • Introduction: Introduce the protagonist to the reader … • Development: The protagonist encounters the antagonist or some hardship, etc. • Twist: The protagonist rises to face the challenge, but an additional problem creates a dilemma. In this part of the story, the protagonist attempts to strike back at the antagonist/hardship but the difficulties keep building … • Resolution: A victory or other happy end. Creators who willfully eschew the entire ki-shō-ten-ketsu pattern … can still produce masterworks, but only when done with purpose and knowledge of the pattern in the first place. Without exception, you must have ki-shō-ten-ketsu in your mind when creating your stories. This is the immutable law of story writing.” (Araki, 87, emphasis original)</blockquote><p>Araki argues for kishōtenketsu, though clearly in a different manner to how we described it earlier. In fact, Araki seems to describe the Western storytelling tradition of a try-fail cycle, though couched in the terms of kishōtenketsu. My best explanation for this, though by no means airtight, is Araki is strongly inspired by Western storytelling. The book from which this excerpt is taken describes almost entirely popular Western films such as Pulp Fiction and Jurassic Park. I argue that Araki’s example of kishōtenketsu does not undermine our previous definition but is simply the result of his essentially Western creative education which he tries to define in terms of the kishōtenketsu structure which is so ingrained into his everyday life. In essence, his definition of story is one which uses traditional Western structure as its reference point.</p><blockquote>“I want to share with you something I’ve learned. I’ll draw it on the blackboard behind me so you can follow more easily [draws a vertical line on the blackboard]. This is the G-I axis: good fortune — ill fortune. Death and terrible poverty, sickness down here — great prosperity, wonderful health up there. Your average state of affairs here in the middle [points to bottom, top, and middle of line respectively]. This is the B-E axis. B for beginning, E for entropy. Okay. Not every story has that very simple, very pretty shape that even a computer can understand [draws horizontal line extending from middle of G-I axis]. … after the war I went to the University of Chicago and studied anthropology, and eventually I took a masters degree in that field. … I started going to the library in search of reports about ethnographers, preachers, and explorers … I read these stories, one after another, collected from primitive people all over the world, and they were dead level, like the B-E axis here. So all right. Primitive people deserve to lose with their lousy stories. They really are backward. Look at the wonderful rise and fall of our stories. … [gives an example of Hamlet’s structure according to the aforementioned graph, showing that it is level] I have just demonstrated to you that Shakespeare was as poor a storyteller as any Arapaho. But there’s a reason we recognize Hamlet as a masterpiece: it’s that Shakespeare told us the truth, and people so rarely tell us the truth in this rise and fall here [indicates blackboard]. The truth is, we know so little about life, we don’t really know what the good news is and what the bad news is.” (Vonnegut, 24)</blockquote><p>Vonnegut provides a method of tracking contrast along two axes, but he claims, in his typically opaque style, that the contrast itself is not the most important aspect of storytelling. Rather, truth-telling about human experience creates great story, the act of saying “So it goes.”</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>[1] Lakin, C. S.. The 12 Key Pillars of Novel Construction: Your Blueprint for Building a Strong Story (The Writer’s Toolbox Series Book 3). Ubiquitous Press. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[2] Brooks, Larry. Story Engineering. F+W Media. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[3] Knight, Damon. Creating Short Fiction. ReAnimus Press. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[4] Robert McKee. Story: Substance, Structure, Style and the Principles of Screenwriting. It Books. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[5] Ursula K. Le Guin. Steering the Craft. The Eighth Mountain Press.</p><p>[6] <a href="https://www.awpwriter.org/magazine_media/writers_chronicle_view/4249/a_conversation_on_craft_with_ursula_k._le_guin">https://www.awpwriter.org/magazine_media/writers_chronicle_view/4249/a_conversation_on_craft_with_ursula_k._le_guin</a> (Retrieved 1:30 PM, 09/22/21)</p><p>[7] Bird, Matt. The Secrets of Story: Innovative Tools for Perfecting Your Fiction and Captivating Readers . F+W Media. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[8] James, Steven. Story Trumps Structure. Writer’s Digest Books.</p><p>[9] Calvin and Hobbes strip Jan 14, 1990 <a href="https://i.imgur.com/5yaLa.jpg">https://i.imgur.com/5yaLa.jpg</a> (Retrieved 1:30 PM, 09/22/21)</p><p>[10] Dunsany, Lord. The King of Elfland’s Daughter. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[11] (Deb Olin Unfearth, Julio Ortega) The Rose Metal Press Field Guide to Writing Flash Fiction: Tips from Editors, Teachers, and Writers in the Field. Rose Metal Press. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[12] <a href="https://ejmas.com/tin/2007tin/tinart_boylan_0703.html">https://ejmas.com/tin/2007tin/tinart_boylan_0703.html</a> (Peter Boylan) (Retrieved 1:30 PM, 09/22/21)</p><p>[12] Chester, Deborah. The Fantasy Fiction Formula . Manchester University Press. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[13] Downing, Christopher. Fool Proof Outline: A No-Nonsense System for Productive Brainstorming, Outlining, &amp; Drafting Novels (Fool Proof Writer Book 1). Mad Devil Media. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[14] Erickson, John R.. Story Craft: Reflections on Faith, Culture and Writing From the Author of Hank the Cowdog (p. 71). Maverick Books, Inc.. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[15] Gardner, John. The Art of Fiction. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[16] McDonald, Brian. The Golden Theme: How to Make Your Writing Appeal to the Highest Common Denominator . Talking Drum, LLC. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[17] O’Neil, Dennis. The DC Comics Guide to Writing Comics. Potter/Ten Speed/Harmony/Rodale. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[18] Weiland, K.M.. Structuring Your Novel: Essential Keys for Writing an Outstanding Story (Helping Writers Become Authors Book 3). PenForASword Publishing. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[19] Butler, Robert Olen. From Where You Dream: The Process of Writing Fiction. Grove/Atlantic, Inc.. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[20] Cleland, Jane K.. Mastering Suspense, Structure, &amp; Plot: How to Write Gripping Stories That Keep Readers on the Edge of Their Seats. Writer’s Digest Books.</p><p>[21] Truffaut, Francois. Hitchcock: A Definitive Study of Alfred Hitchcock. Simon &amp; Schuster. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[22] Araki, Hirohiko. Translated by Nathan A. Collins. Manga in Theory and Practice: The Craft of Creating Manga. Viz Media.</p><p>[23] Vonnegut, Kurt. A Man Without a Country. Random House Publishing Group. Kindle Edition.</p><p>[24] The Christian Standard Bible. Copyright © 2017 by Holman Bible Publishers.</p><p>[25] Rothfuss, Patrick. The Name of the Wind. DAW Books, Inc.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6a6505edebc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Just Keep an Eye On Things]]></title>
            <link>https://taylorclogston.medium.com/just-keep-an-eye-on-things-ef04733a3ed5?source=rss-bc0003e9fbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ef04733a3ed5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[flash-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[short-story]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scifi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Taylor Clogston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 May 2021 12:19:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-24T16:48:07.422Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Just Keep an Eye On Things — Flash Fiction</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*gfjdD1IPSHf9XR3B" /><figcaption>Photo by NASA on Unsplash</figcaption></figure><p>He sat in the booth, alone. Two seats beside him lay empty. Soft, translucent rubber cushions belied the cold metal beneath.</p><p>He had sat long enough that the rubber no longer provided comfort. It felt as hard and lifeless beneath him as the panels of lights he did not understand, as the halted gauges that had not marked progress for many hours now.</p><p>The viewport above the console stretched the whole eight feet of the breadth of the booth, showing nothing but a blue and unspotted dune outside.</p><p>By now, the others should have passed across that viewport. Their steps should still be present as reminders of their passing.</p><p>Nothingness. Not even the stars seemed to have moved since the others had exited the shuttle.</p><p>“Computer.”</p><p>The water heater blinked on, a waveform indicative across its crystal display that it had indeed heard him. It was the only thing which would respond to him. He was only the intern. He lacked the authority to command anything else.</p><p>“Computer,” he repeated, “how long has it been now?”</p><p>The generic circuits of the heater’s processor spun for a few million cycles before chirping a reply. “Eight hours and thirty-two minutes.”</p><p>The ship would have responded to the demands of the missing others. Any of them could have pulled up the remote sensors, could have switched to one of the seven other viewports on the ship, could have purged the communication buffers, could have referenced the vitals of everyone else outside.</p><p>“Computer,” he asked. “Any new messages for me?”</p><p>“No new messages,” it replied.</p><p>He rose, moved to the door, and tried to open it again. Its micro-display politely asked him to swipe his card.</p><p>He didn’t have it. He had left it in his bunk.</p><p>He returned to his seat and keyed for the administrative controls.</p><p>The viewport flickered and then shifted to reveal the operating system’s administrative software console. A set of debug messages informed him that the I/O system had been locked due to too many failed passcode attempts. It had initially informed him he could try again in twenty-four hours.</p><p>Fewer than sixteen to go now.</p><p>He looked down at the scrap of paper upon which he had written every passcode he could think of. All but three were scratched out.</p><p>“Computer,” he asked, “are the onboard life-support systems still fully functional?”</p><p>The water heater cycled for a few seconds. “I’m sorry,” it said at last. “I don’t have that information.”</p><p>“Computer, how long can a person survive without food?”</p><p>“An average human in good health can survive up to two months without food, so long as it has access to adequate water.”</p><p>He keyed out of the administrative console and returned to the frozen view outside the ship.</p><p>“Computer, how long can a person survive without food or water?”</p><p>“An average human in good health can survive up to three weeks without food or water.”</p><p>He was silent for a minute.</p><p>“Computer,” he asked, “how much oxygen did their tanks have?”</p><p>“I’m sorry. I don’t have that information.”</p><p>He drew a cup of scalding water, sipped it slowly, and stared at the frozen screen.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ef04733a3ed5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bowling With the President of the United States of America]]></title>
            <link>https://taylorclogston.medium.com/bowling-with-the-president-of-the-united-states-of-america-463a91511c23?source=rss-bc0003e9fbbe------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/463a91511c23</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-satire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[short-story]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Taylor Clogston]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Jan 2021 17:02:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-24T16:47:50.391Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Bowling With the President of the United States of America — A Short Story</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*GNRTc_zw_ZYErDxDNhq5gA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Markus Spiske on Pexels</figcaption></figure><p>It was well past eleven at night — twenty-three, actually, since the Party had declared twelve-hour time illegal three years prior. Something about railways. Every citizen of the great nation of Shcarstan had, ostensibly, received a letter demanding they give up each piece which reported in twelve-hour time and receive, in its stead, a Party-approved replacement.</p><p>In the lamplight of the guest house’s dining room, both Arshakon and Grigoryan’s own tin-and-glass wristwatches gleamed on their arms, neighbors to cheap and worn linen suits, to heirloom silverware, and to cups of the bitterest espresso Grigoryan had ever tasted.</p><p>Like the over-extracted nonsense in his cup, like the flimsy timepiece on his wrist, Grigoryan was an ugly, unpleasant fellow who nevertheless got the job done. This was his own perception of himself. He reckoned that was the best you could expect from an agent of the Party.</p><p>Arshakon, by contrast, stood out from Grigoryan with a freshness describing a man too young to have achieved Fourth Clerk under the current regime. Grigoryan was old enough. He had fought in the civil war when he was twenty. Arshakon did not have the look in his eyes of a man who had seen those days.</p><p>The two men had met for the first time on the day they began their assignment, two Fourth Clerks standing in the unheated office of the Minister of Demographical Accounting. The Minister tasked them with designing a ballot for the upcoming election. “It must communicate to the common people the import of their decision,” the Minister said. “They must look at this slip of paper and think ‘Ah! I, alongside my neighbors, will decide who the prime minister will be! Through my action, we move from dictatorship to glorious freedom!’”</p><p>Arshakon and Grigoryan had traveled through fourteen provinces of Shcarstan before arriving at this, the fifteenth and final province, which had a name none of the locals knew. In each province, the clerks interviewed mayors, dairy maids, tax collectors, and goatherds, asking the things they would like to see on a ballot.</p><p>The clerks had returned three drafts of their project to the winter-frozen office of the Minister of Demographical Accounting. They had, in fact, only sent the most recent draft four days prior.</p><p>The work was disheartening. After a six-hour wagon trek up a mountainside, Arshakon and Grigoryan had arrived at this forsaken township only a half hour previously. A room had been prepared ahead for them through the erratic network of telegraphs and foot runners which the province used, having not yet obeyed the Party’s four-year-old command to install a telephone system stretching across Shcarstan from village to town. It was a ridiculous concept, one that would never be completed, one that might never be given a thought after its initial conception in the capital.</p><p><em>Much like this worthless project,</em> Grigoryan thought. He and Arshakon now sat on the same bench at the rough, almost-square dining table in the village’s guest house. The housekeeper, a young woman none too happy that her guests had arrived three hours past due, bustled about them, gathering things from the room that served likewise as a kitchen. The table had been set for hours, but the clerks had pushed aside the housekeeper’s preparation to make room for their papers, and so with a thin grimace of irritation the housekeeper did her best to find places for pickles, cold chicken, and black bread.</p><p>“Damn woman,” Arshakon muttered as a splash of brine ran close to one of the dim papers. He scrubbed at the wet spot on the table with a threadbare shirtsleeve before replacing the sheet, a sample of eight distinct styles of calligraphy, none of which had proved popular with as many as half of the provincial clerks they had queried. “I jump every time she comes up from behind. Can’t she walk around like a normal person?”</p><p>Grigoryan liked the close bustle of the guest house. It was a two-room affair comprising the kitchen-cum-dining room they now occupied — a room plastered with cupboards and rafters and smoke-stained wallpaper — and a sleeping room connected to the kitchen with a door ajar. The place reminded Grigoryan of the house his father had built, which had seemed so large when Grigoryan had been young.</p><p>Arshakon picked up a piece of chicken and gnawed at it. “Damn it all,” he cursed. The man seemed to Grigoryan to lack focus. Every few days, Arshakon’s attention veered from one component of the ballot to another. Each time, he abandoned the fascination he had held with whatever line of instruction or design flair and gave himself wholly to the new.</p><p>Grigoryan found these fascinations pointless. He was of a mind that little mattered to the function of the thing. All the Shcarstani peasants and oligarchs could write their candidates on a bit of foolscap and send it in, and the result would be no different.</p><p>He left aside the probability that nothing would come of the ballot, that it would be another of the Party’s plans proclaimed in the capital for the benefit of the curated central broadsheets, and then never touched again.</p><p>On a shelf over the kitchen’s little stove, the clock struck twelve.</p><p>Arshakon threw his chicken bone at the clock. The housekeeper, who was on the other side of the room and rummaging through a cupboard for something, didn’t seem to notice. “So close to the end,” said Arshakon, “but still no closer to resolving the central issue.” He jabbed a finger at their current draft. “A ranked list gives us nuance, Grigori. I don’t know why that’s so hard for you to see.”</p><p>Grigoryan sighed. In the middle of the paper, bordered by elegant lines, the stallion crest of the Party, and several paragraphs of the legal text whose exact language had inspired much debate between Arshakon and Grigoryan, was a void. Within that void, they would need to set down lines for the names of candidates and boxes for their faces.</p><p>That latter element had been a hopeless concession on Grigoryan’s part. Arshakon was adamant that the peasants craved a personal connection to their candidates, that they would feel wonder and joy at seeing the faces of the men who were candidates for leader of their nation.</p><p>As few peasants could read, and local clerks would facilitate the ballot, Grigoryan thought this was a tacky waste of ink, but cared too little of it to argue.</p><p>This was different. “Nuance isn’t what we want,” he said tiredly. He had said the same in, well, a few more nuanced ways on the journey up the mountain, but was too fatigued for anything but directness now. Arshakon did not take kindly to direct disagreements, but with every passing moment Grigoryan cared less about that. “Imagine all the men in a village lined up in front of some poor clerk’s desk, asking to hear that list for the sixteenth time because he can’t decide whether Davros Martinosya or Mikaiel Demirdjyan belongs in slot twelve.</p><p>“Now imagine him asking again because he doesn’t know if maybe the winner of that contest may in fact deserve slot eleven instead. Now imagine he is only the third man to vote today, and it is almost time for lunch.”</p><p>Arshakon snorted. “This is an obscene enough undertaking, Grigori! All the men of the country voting on a new leader, from the poorest to the richest! A social triumph! What are a few more hours when the victor will serve his people for the rest of his life? This is…”</p><p>Despite the espresso, Grigoryan’s mind wandered. He was exhausted with the constant argument, fatigued in body and mind alike. Arshakon did not understand, and nothing Grigoryan could say would change that. Arshakon had not seen, as Grigoryan had, the way the ideals of brilliant men disintegrated when met by the wall of ordinary banality.</p><p>All the philosophers and the poets together will find themselves hard-pressed to keep a man from his work for a day. The earth needs tending; the animals need watering. The less a prime minister asks a man away from these things, the better his chances of success.</p><p>Unless there comes, across the telegraphs and highways where no wire crosses, the call to war. Men make a special exception for that.</p><p>Arshakon had not noticed Grigoryan’s absent mind. His soliloquy swept across the table like tobacco smoke, and Grigoryan ignored man and papers as he began assembling a plate of food.</p><p>The door to the sleeping room opened.</p><p>Grigoryan sat up with a start, hand moving into his coat to the Nagant revolver which every Party agent carried.</p><p>Seeing this, Arshakon cut off in mid-sentence, drawing his own weapon and staring at the emergent figure. “I thought the room was ours,” he muttered to Grigoryan.</p><p>As the figure resolved in lamplight, neither clerk lowered their weapons, for the man was a bizarre sight. A little shorter than two meters, he wore a suit of the Italian style that had been in fashion in the capitol perhaps five years ago. The material was worn in places, patched in others, a shape even worse than that of the Party suits which the clerks wore.</p><p>The man’s shoes were likewise of Italian leather, but well-kept, gleaming with oil and free of scuffs. A narrow blue necktie dragged down from the man’s collar to below his belt, and tufts of hair — not a full beard — sprouted from his face and above his crooked ears. His feet and shoulders and hands were gangly and enormous, and from his left hand dangled a red, white, and blue-striped canvas bag holding something that looked about the size of a man’s head.</p><p>The housekeeper started at the man’s appearance and rushed to the door of the sleeping room. “Oh, Mr. Kruny! I’m sorry, I forgot to tell you we would be serving other guests tonight… Please don’t bother them, they’re very important people from the Party…”</p><p>The man, Kruny, looked past the housekeeper’s shoulder and stared at Arshakon. “I heard you talking about voting,” he said. “That’s what folks use for elections, right?”</p><p>They use voting? What an odd turn of phrase. Grigoryan glanced toward the housekeeper. “Mistress, we thought we had the room to ourselves.”</p><p>She turned to face the clerks, and her mouth dropped open. “To yourselves? I’m terribly sorry, sir. The message said nothing about that. I saved two beds as you reserved, but, no disrespect, sir, you didn’t pay for the other eight. If you’d like, you can reserve the others and I’ll turn away anyone else tomorrow, but you’ll need to sort it out with Mr. Kruny if you want his. He’s been here for the last four years, and…” her voice trailed off as neither clerk changed expression. She turned back to the suited man. “Mr. Kruny, I’d be more than happy to let you stay with my husband and I as long as these gentlemen are here, no charge — ”</p><p>Arshakon set his revolver on the table with a clatter. “Don’t worry about it, miss. We have nothing to hide.” His eyes gleamed. “Come on, friend. Sit down and join us for dinner. You seem like a man with strong opinions about elections.”</p><p>Grigoryan pivoted toward his companion, who, Grigoryan noted, had not put the Nagant away. Grigoryan lowered his own below the lip of the table, resting it upon his knee, out of sight.</p><p>“I ate,” said Kruny, “but I would like some ex-presso.” He sat opposite the clerks, setting his bag onto the seat beside him. “So you said you were doing voting. Is the Party fixing to have a president, like in America?”</p><p>“Like in America” was a very dangerous phrase. Though they had encountered no trouble from pro-Western rabble-rousers during the bulk of their trip, Grigoryan wondered if their luck had finally run out, if a dozen swarthy revolutionaries were squatting in the sleeping room.</p><p>“No,” said Arshakon. “Not like in America. They are a corrupt and hedonistic people. You know, they kill — ”</p><p>“Yeah yeah, they kill the negroes,” Kruny interjected. “Folks say that all the time but it isn’t really true you know.”</p><p>Arshakon’s cheekbones reddened. He was not used to being interrupted, let alone contradicted.</p><p>“I visited there once,” Kruny said in an eager voice. “I saw New York City, and no one was killing the negroes. It was a beautiful place. I met the President of the United States, and he gave me this.”</p><p>With a jerk, Kruny grabbed the bag and slammed it onto the countertop, rattling plates and cutlery. Arshakon and Grigoryan leaped to their feet, revolvers pointed at Kruny’s chest, but he seemed to ignore them.</p><p>Grigoryan’s nerves sung. His hands trembled.</p><p>His thoughts trailed off as he saw the object, which was large even in Kruny’s spade-like hands.</p><p>It was a glossy, blue-black orb like a polished gem. Three thumb-wide holes dug into it about six centimeters apart from each other. Kruny stroked it like a favorite dog. “It’s a ten-pin bowling ball,” he said, smiling down upon it. “I played all day at the American Bowling Congress building in New York City. It was the best day I’ve ever had.”</p><p>For three heart-pounding seconds, silence reigned. No thugs burst from the sleeping room, no shots rang through the kitchen, no poison gas emanated from the largest bowling ball Grigoryan had ever seen.</p><p>Behind Kruny, at the back of the room, the housekeeper’s eyes gleamed wide and dark. She had dropped a dish with butter upon it, but despite the waste stared only at the oiled revolvers pointing toward her.</p><p>Grigoryan felt a twinge of guilt.</p><p>Though his companion remained standing, Grigoryan sighed, holstered his revolver, and took his seat again. “It’s a beautiful ball,” he said. “I played bowling when I was a little boy, though I seem to remember the ball being quite a bit smaller. And… I’m sorry, sir, did you say the President of the United States gave it to you?”</p><p>“On account of I beat him best two out of three,” said Kruny, eyes still fixed on his treasure.</p><p>“I see,” said Grigoryan. “Well. Please forgive my friend. What he meant was we are electing a prime minister, not a president. He will serve the people for life, giving him the time to effectively act, unlike the American presidents who are limited by their laws to only a few years in office, which prevents anything of importance from being accomplished. My friend and I have a job to design the ballot for this election.”</p><p>“A ballot?”</p><p>“It’s the paper people will write the names of their chosen candidate on. We were talking about whether a person should write just one name, or rank every candidate from their favorite to least favorite.” He shot a glance to the still-alert Arshakon. “For more nuance.”</p><p>“I see,” said Kruny. He looked back up, though he kept his hands on the bowling ball. “A candidate is one of the people we’re voting for?”</p><p>“Yes.”</p><p>“Who are all of them?”</p><p>“I don’t know,” said Grigoryan. “You’ll find out when the ballots are sent around.” He hesitated. “Sir, I’m afraid my friend won’t sit down until you explain why you were standing around at midnight wearing a suit, and why you seem to live in a guest house. Do you have no home in this village, no people anywhere else? Where do you get the money to afford this?”</p><p>Kruny’s eyebrows knitted. “I always wear this,” he said. “I have three suits from a tailor in New York City when I visited it. I put on a new suit in the morning and wash my old one. When I was in New York City, I heard a man speak about wearing the clothes for the job you want every day and every night, and he was the richest man in the world, so it worked for him.”</p><p>“I… see. Well, what is your job now, and what is the one you want?”</p><p>Kruny ducked his chin. “Well, I haven’t really worked for a while now, I guess.”</p><p>By this time, the housekeeper had made her way to the other side of the room, and she was humming a frantic tune as though trying to avoid hearing the conversation.</p><p>Arshakon twisted his head and shot her a glare before sitting back down, though he kept his revolver up. “You don’t work? That takes some real guts to admit to a couple of Party boys, friend. You know we don’t look fondly upon those who live on charity.”</p><p>“No, no, no!” Kruny lifted both hands in a placating gesture, but clapped them back upon the ball as it rolled toward his lap. “I, uh, it’s inheritance. My father was a business man in America, that’s why I went to visit his lawyer after he died and get the money he left me. It was all in gold and I’ve been using it to pay for everything here, I’m not living on anyone’s charity!”</p><p>Grigoryan put his face in his hands, sighing. How had someone like this survived so long, someone so eager to approach Party agents with fond recollections of America and open admission of not only connection to but inheritance from a wealthy capitalist?</p><p>“You are aware,” Grigoryan said, unable to keep the fatigue from his voice, “that the Party made the reservation of inherited money beyond one hundred rubles a serious crime with prison time attached?”</p><p>“Well…” Kruny shrunk in his seat. “I spent most of it in New York City. Things don’t cost very much here. I didn’t think it would be a problem.”</p><p>Blood thumped in Grigoryan’s head. Beside him, Arshakon was fairly licking his chops. He seemed to be drinking in every word of Kruny’s admission, as though drawing up arrest documents in his head. “Well,” Grigoryan said at last, “Kruny, if you have no job, what do you do all day?”</p><p>“Oh,” he said, “I have the job I have always wanted since I was in New York City when I visited America. There was an old building which no one was using, and so I bought it with some of my inheritance. I am the manager and commissioner of the Shcarstan Bowling Council!” He sat back proudly.</p><p>No one spoke for a long time. The housekeeper, her face bloodless and her lips a thin line, began clearing the table of the largely untouched food.</p><p>With a condescending snort, Arshakon began shuffling papers together. “I am happy,” he said lightly, “that you seem to have found more joy and purpose in your life than most men I have met. Recently, I have been asking those men their opinions of what they would like to see on this electoral ballot. It is a tool to empower the people, and so the people’s opinion is paramount.”</p><p>Kruny nodded. “The mountain is a beautiful place to live,” he said.</p><p>Arshakon ignored him. “It is clear that your experience with America, though clouded by the glamor of capitalism’s facades, has nonetheless instilled within you a fondness for the ideas of freedom and liberty. Would you agree?”</p><p>Grigoryan did not know whether Arshakon was trying to trap the man or to give him another chance. He wished for a cigarette.</p><p>Kruny opened his mouth and then closed it before answering. “I just want to say I’m very grateful you all are working hard at this. Can you tell the other people at the Party that I said thank you?”</p><p>Arshakon pushed forward. “Kruny, friend, do you know other people as interested as you in liberty? We’d be grateful if you would help us talk with the people of your village. As we are with the Party, some people have difficulty trusting us, difficulty opening up and sharing with us what they really feel. And what they feel is what we are here to find out. Friend, will you help us with this tomorrow?”</p><p>Kruny bobbed his head. “I would be honored. I’ll introduce you all to the people in the Shcarstan Bowling Council. They’re good folks, smart guys who love freedom and bowling as much as I do. Maybe you could even play a couple games with us.”</p><p>Grigoryan forced a smile.</p><p>Within a quarter hour, the three men lay in the dark of the sleeping room. Their beds were straw mattresses upon wooden frames. They were some of the nicest accommodations Grigoryan had known over the course of their trip.</p><p>He and Arshakon took turns lying awake, pistols across their chests, as Kruny snored on the other side of the room.</p><p>The next day, the men woke at about six and went about the work of washing, shaving, and breakfast. As he had described, Kruny scrubbed the suit he had slept in as well as his own body in the metal tub which the housekeeper prepared for her guests in the kitchen’s corner, and then dressed himself in another, similarly weathered Italian suit of a greener cloth which he had kept folded underneath his bed.</p><p>After morning preparations, Kruny led the clerks outside. Most of the households in the village kept goats, and a bead-eyed boy in a blue cap led a herd of these sinewy creatures down the village road as the men exited, their snake eyes rolling and nostrils spewing steam in the cold mountain air.</p><p>“Your friends are ready to meet right now?” Grigoryan asked, looking around at the stonewall dwellings they passed on their walk. “They are not at work?”</p><p>“Perhaps,” said Arshakon, “they also all went to America and inherited money from their rich fathers and now do nothing all day. One wonders what good money is in a village where no man produces value by his labor.”</p><p>“Oh, no!” said Kruny. “All of them are good, hard workers. Just all members of the Shcarstan Bowling Council meet in the morning before we go to work to have a good game and get our spirits up for the day.”</p><p>“Hmm,” said Grigoryan. “Kruny, that may be the strangest thing I’ve ever heard. My friend and I’ve been going all around the country over the past few weeks, and I can’t say I’ve ever heard of a bunch of people sitting around in the morning playing games instead of getting to work.”</p><p>“Folks do things different here,” said Kruny. “At least the SBC does. Maybe it’s why we’re so happy. I’m just trying to make people happy. There were a lot of happy people in New York City when I visited America, sir. Folks in this country don’t seem like it so much, and I just want to change that.”</p><p>They passed from the road down a forest path that had perhaps once been a goat trail but was now trampled by heavy work boots. Arshakon and Grigoryan wore the standard-issue Party boots of rubber and cheap stuffing, and while they kept the rain out on wet days, the things were terrible at trail walking. Grigoryan would have given much for the stocky boots he had once worn in the army, which at Party command had been replaced with the current pair.</p><p>For his part, Kruny fairly danced over bramble and stone in his loafers, heavy ball swinging in its bag like a book in a schoolboy’s hand. The boot prints certainly belonged to the friends they were to meet, the goatherds and farmers of the village.</p><p>They came upon a wide clearing in the forest. The somber pines rose darkly above the promised barn like judgmental sentinels. In every way, the building was out of place: Wooden while the village was stone, isolated from the people who ostensibly used it in times past, and not big enough — maybe ten by twenty meters — to house all the goats of a village.</p><p>Light diffused from behind oilclothed windows. The sun had risen before the men had set out, but tree shade darkened the clearing. Without the sunlight, the mountain air bit into Grigoryan’s bones. He drew his army-issue coat more closely around himself as they approached the barn’s entrance. At least the Party had not yet gotten it into their heads to take his coat.</p><p>Arshakon and Grigoryan stood behind Kruny as the man fiddled with the crooked door’s latch. Grigoryan held their bundle of draft papers under one arm, the other shoved deep into a fleece-lined pocket. Arshakon’s hand was instead thrust into the opening of his own wool coat, no doubt clutching the revolver there.</p><p>“What are you expecting?” Grigoryan muttered. “Surely you don’t still think this is some elaborate plan to assassinate us.”</p><p>“I don’t know,” said Arshakon. “But I don’t care to be surprised.”</p><p>The door opened, and Kruny stepped inside. “Morning, morning!” he bellowed, swaying under the influence of his bowling ball as he stepped up onto the raised floor of the barn. “Everyone, please welcome these folks. They’ve traveled a long way to come here and talk with us about freedom and liberty…”</p><p>Grigoryan stepped behind Kruny, heard Arshakon enter behind him, and was met by the overwhelming bite of raw pine.</p><p>Most of the floor, at least eighty percent of it, had been transformed into a smooth set of parallel lanes separated by small metal rails. At the end of each lane was a neat triangle of what looked more like white-painted belaying pins than the candlestick-shaped things he had seen otherwise used for bowling.</p><p>Before each lane in what appeared to be a dimple in the floor rested a polished wooden ball of about the same size as the thing Kruny lovingly carried. Every three meters along each wall was a window, and before it, a lit candle in an iron fixture.</p><p>Occupying the remaining bit of the barn, just beyond the door, seven men sat around a warped, peeling table which seemed to be the only thing which belonged in the outwardly neglected building.</p><p>These men turned to look at Kruny and the clerks, mouths agape, eyes narrowed, breath puffing in a communal cloud between them. They were rough men, and there was desperation in their eyes. Papers littered the table in their midst. Most of these men were young, perhaps in their twenties, but in one man’s eyes Grigoryan recognized a familiar haunting, that of a man who had known the war.</p><p>This was no moment of community, no joyful gathering of comrades before a day of work. These men were restless, dangerous. Revolutionary.</p><p>They bolted upright, the veteran shouting “Damn you, Kruny!” His voice warbled, covering the sounds of a few others drawing firearms.</p><p>Grigoryan moved without thinking. He turned and slapped the revolver from Arshakon’s hand, prompting a “You damn traitor!” before dropping the parcel of papers, falling to his knees, and putting his hands behind his head.</p><p>Arshakon scrambled for his weapon but the men were already upon them, two striking the clerk savagely about the face while another tied Grigoryan’s hands behind his back and then hauled him up.</p><p>All the while Kruny was weeping, mewling out “No, stop, these are good folks, they’re my guests, they’re just here to talk with us…”</p><p>In a minute the two clerks had been frisked and tied to rickety chairs shoved up against the table. The village men argued in one of the bowling lanes, leaving only the veteran to guard the clerks and Kruny mumbling to himself all alone, clutching his bag and staring down at the toes of his Italian leather shoes.</p><p>Grigoryan looked into the old man’s eyes. His coat was of the Protectorate style, putting him on the same side as Grigoryan during the war. Grigoryan ignored Arshakon’s dazed moaning, and looked down at the papers which the villagers had been reading.</p><p>They were plans to escape, to go to America. There was murder involved, and much treason, but these were no revolutionaries. Grigoryan looked back up to his guard. “Kruny was not lying,” he said in as even a tone as he could muster. “We came here to talk with the people of your village, not to seek dissidents and punish them. We are no police, adjustors, or tax collectors.”</p><p>“Of course he wasn’t lying,” said the man in a reedy voice. “Kruny is too stupid to be anything but earnest.”</p><p>“Then why do you keep him around sensitive things such as this?”</p><p>The man gave Grigoryan a tired look. “We’re a few people on top of a mountain. No one cares about us up here. That is our security.” He ran his gaze from the battered Arshakon back to Grigoryan. “But… I believe you, that you didn’t come here looking for us. Even the Party wouldn’t send two men atop a mountain to prevent a few men from seeking their freedom.”</p><p>“You’re wrong,” said Grigoryan. “A thousand times over. Yet, that is not why we are here. My companion and I are truly on a mission of freedom and liberty. Kruny can tell you about it.”</p><p>“Or you could.”</p><p>“I think he is more excited about it than I am,” said Grigoryan.</p><p>The man grunted. He had in his hands the bundle of papers which Grigoryan had taken along, but it remained unopened. “And in here, what will I find? No warrant for my arrest, I presume?”</p><p>“The Party doesn’t bother with such things,” said Grigoryan. “A waste of paper when they could be asking men to turn in their watches and boots instead.”</p><p>His captor grimaced at this. He drew an antler-handled knife from his belt and cut the string securing the bundle. The man laid out all Arshakon’s careful work, and those bits which Grigoryan had at times been permitted to help with, directly on top of the shipping charts, diagrams, and translations of English phrases into their own tongue.</p><p>“Kruny,” said the veteran. “Come here and explain these things to me.”</p><p>At the mention of his name, Kruny stopped his blubbering. He ran a hand through the greasy tufts above his ears, looking with swollen eyes toward the table. “We won’t hurt them anymore,” he muttered as he waddled up to Arshakon, looking at the man’s broken nose. “These folks are my guests, and we won’t hurt them anymore.”</p><p>“That man had a gun. He’ll be fine. No one will hurt him again.”</p><p>Three half-lies. Grigoryan’s heart beat more heavily.</p><p>Kruny looked down at the papers. “They just wanted to ask us about election,” he said. “The people at the Party are fixing to elect a president.”</p><p>“Prime minister,” said Grigoryan automatically. “We’ve gone through every province, giving overview and receiving feedback. This province was our last stop.”</p><p>Their guard exhaled a long breath. The hairs of his mustache trembled. “The Party is letting us choose our ruler? What does that even mean for goatherds living on a mountain who never see a Party officer once in five years?”</p><p>Grigoryan grasped for an answer. He thought there must be one, somewhere, that would reach this man. They shared an understanding of the sort of world that asked brothers and neighbors to put a gun to each other’s heads and squeeze the trigger until no one was left.</p><p>But that same understanding was the reason this affair could have no happy ending. “I doubt anything will change,” said Grigoryan. “Not in any different way than it does now.” He paused. “Maybe it’ll be a first step. My companion has been talking without cease these past few weeks about dignity and social triumph. People like you and me making the decisions. He’s an overblown child, and full to the brim with propaganda, but when he talks, I almost believe it.”</p><p>The old man did not speak throughout all of this. When Grigoryan’s ambling words were finished, the veteran reached over and pulled one of Arshakon’s eyelids wide, staring at the dilated pupil underneath. Arshakon did not react.</p><p>“Those boys went too hard on him,” the man grunted. “Did you notice his skull cracked on a barn spike back there? I don’t think he’ll last a day without a proper hospital.”</p><p>Grigoryan felt nothing. “Then you’ll have killed an officer of the Party.”</p><p>Kruny did not react to any of this. He was, at the moment, looking at the bowling lanes which he must have, after one fashion or another, recreated from his cherished memories of New York City in America. There was pure love in his eyes.</p><p>Across the room, the huddle of men had stopped talking. They were all staring at the veteran, clearly waiting for a signal.</p><p>Grigoryan sighed. “Well, what are we waiting for? If you aim to put a bullet in my head, will you please not do it where Kruny can see?” Alien words. He felt as though he were talking about fetching a loaf from the baker, not his own execution at the hands of political dissidents.</p><p>The veteran picked up one of the ballot forms and stared at it. “In two weeks,” he said, “we will be gone to America. Us and all our families.” He looked up. “I was a surgeon.”</p><p>Grigoryan nodded dully. “Infantryman. Were you there at Ingala?”</p><p>Kruny left them. He waddled to the nearest lane, set his bag on the ground, and retrieved his gleaming American ball which he swore the President of the United States had given him, the only one of its kind among the wooden balls of Shcarstan. He took a peculiar stance, swept back his arm, and hurled the ball down the lane.</p><p>In a blue-black streak, the ball swooped toward the far wall, striking the triangle of pins nearly dead center, blowing all of them away except the furthest most on the right. “Split! That’s a split, a split,” Kruny chanted as he ran down the lane where his ball rested against bales of hay set behind the pins. He squatted down and began resetting the lane.</p><p>“Ingala,” said the veteran. “Hmph. The identifications of two Party officers will make our journey much easier. We will pray that, when your work is completed, it will likewise ease the journey of all who remain in this Godforsaken place.”</p><p>He picked up his knife, limped around the table, and severed Grigoryan’s bonds.</p><p>Grigoryan buried Arshakon’s naked corpse before he left. True to the veteran’s prediction, the man never awoke, but passed from life altogether around eighteen in the evening.</p><p>The lone clerk descended the mountain with his papers in a neat bundle. By the time he reached the mountain’s foot, he had determined to use Arshakon’s strategy of ranking candidates on the ballot. Such a ridiculous undertaking would not be made much more absurd with the addition of nuance.</p><p>Wearing a peasant’s clothes and a twelve-hour watch underneath his army jacket, Grigoryan stepped into the telegraph office of the town at the base of the mountain, from which he and Arshakon had sent their previous draft using a special code designed by the Party for transmitting visual information over telegraph. Grigoryan did not use this now, but determined to return their final draft in person. He did, however, plan to send a curt message informing the Party of Arshakon’s tragic fall from a cliff face during their journey.</p><p>There was a message waiting for Grigoryan at the station. In plain language it appeared to be a meandering letter about the best places to eat and sleep in the province. Once the true meaning was coaxed out through application of the Party’s cipher, it congratulated the clerks on their hard and steadfast work. It said they should not bother with an additional draft, that the one which they had sent was already being printed by every press in the capital. The war hero Petrosyan would be prime minister, said the message, and the ballot of Arshakon and Grigoryan would facilitate this historic event.</p><p>Then Grigoryan read the message again with his own private cipher.</p><p><em>“A man called Kruny lives in such-and-such a village. He has been brainwashed by the American CIA and is building an army to overthrow the Party. Arshakon is a member of this plot. Destroy these men, before the blight of America taints even the simplest citizens of great Shcarstan.”</em></p><p>Grigoryan stared at it for a long time.</p><p>“What the hell,” he muttered, crumpling the letter and putting it into his pocket. He wondered what other meaning lay in the message, hidden in the cipher of a dead man atop a mountain. He wondered if either clerk were ever intended to descend alive, and what might have been different had the message arrived only a day earlier.</p><p>Grigoryan turned his back on the great nation of Scharstan and began the long trek up the mountainside. His back had been to the wind as he descended, but now it bit him directly on the face.</p><p>He wished for espresso, for a cigarette, and for a world he could understand. All he had was his old army coat, and that was a poor substitute for any of them. Grigoryan reckoned that was the best you could expect from anything.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=463a91511c23" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>