<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Tom Coyne on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Tom Coyne on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@tcoyne?source=rss-d4fb1d4bda4c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 22:56:04 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@tcoyne/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Critique of the Colorado Education Association’s 2023 “State of Education” Report]]></title>
            <link>https://tcoyne.medium.com/critique-of-the-colorado-education-associations-2023-state-of-education-report-b3346622eb9d?source=rss-d4fb1d4bda4c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b3346622eb9d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jefferson-county]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colorado]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[k12]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Coyne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Dec 2023 02:08:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-14T02:08:00.413Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>For most people, the end of another year brings joyous thoughts of holiday cheer. But for K-12 in Colorado, it brings the Colorado Education Assocation’s <a href="https://coloradoea.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/CEA_SOE_2023.pdf">annual screed bemoaning how terrible things are here</a>. And by some measures, they really are. But those aren’t the ones CEA uses.</p><p>So here’s a short response you can use when your local teachers union, advocate group, or progressive education “journalist” rolls out CEAs tired talking points in 2024.</p><p><strong>The Report is Based on a Non-Random Response from Just 3.1% of the State’s Teachers</strong></p><p>Replies from 1,700 of the state’s 55,197 teachers (data from Colorado Department of Education) — that’s a response rate of 3.1%. And you have to believe that isn’t a random sample, when a survey is sent out by the teachers union.</p><p><strong>The Claim That Teachers are Badly Underpaid is Based on Economic Policy Institute Analysis that Has Been Discredited for Years</strong></p><p>To arrive at its teacher pay gap, EPI merely compares teacher salaries with the salaries of people who have roughly the same number of years of education and the same demographic characteristics. By EPI’s logic, a newly graduated chemical engineer from Colorado School of Mines should make the same salary as a newly teaching graduate from Adams State College. For example, in Colorado the average starting salary for a newly minted graduate with a BS in nursing is $61,499 (salary.com). For a newly minted accountant, it is $63,500. Jeffco pays a new graduate with an elementary education degree $52,625 (2023/2024 salary schedule). And that’s not counting the value of the defined pension plan benefits that are much better than the 401K that the nurse and accounting get from their employer if they’re lucky.</p><p>And that’s a key point, because the EPI methodology does not consider the far superior defined benefit pension benefits that teachers receive, in comparison to workers in the private sector, where hardly any employers offer them anymore.</p><p>Here are three more critical analyses of the EPI methodology:</p><p><a href="https://www.aei.org/articles/the-truth-about-teacher-pay/">https://www.aei.org/articles/the-truth-about-teacher-pay/</a></p><ul><li><a href="https://fordhaminstitute.org/ohio/commentary/teacher-compensation-compared-other-professions">Teacher compensation compared to other professions</a></li><li><a href="https://www.eduwonk.com/2019/10/we-should-probably-stop-citing-epis-teacher-wage-gap-data.html">We Should Probably Stop Citing EPI&#39;s &quot;Teacher Wage Gap&quot; Data</a></li></ul><p><strong>New Teachers Don’t Make Enough to Buy a House in the City or Town Where They Teach</strong></p><p>Oh please. When I got out of college at the end of the 1970s, every one of my friends moved into an apartment with roommates when they started work. So did my children when they got out of college and started work in Washington, DC. And my godchildren when they started work in Boston, Seattle, and New York. Forty years later, nothing had changed — none of these new graduates expected to make enough money in their first job to afford to buy a house.</p><p>Except, it seems, if you are a teacher, who thinks that for some reason you deserve that.</p><p>Also, the CEA report makes no mention of just why housing is so expensive in Denver (hint: in the Denver Metro, there are a lot of constraints that constrain increases in the supply of housing, unlike metros like Houston or Salt Lake City that do not, and where housing is much less expensive). Could that be because many of those constraints were legislated by their fellow Progressives? Awkward that.</p><p><strong>The “Teacher Shortage” Means We Must Pay Teachers MUCH More, or the Sky Will Fall</strong></p><p>Public schools require teachers to obtain “teaching certificates”. Private and charter schools do not. So guess who has a “teacher shortage”?</p><p>Let me put it more bluntly: Would you want your child (or future employee) to have a math teacher whose primary undergraduate degree is in math, or elementary education? In recent years, the Canadian province of Quebec has posted dramatic gains in math scores. Why? Because they started to require every math teacher to have a primary degree in math.</p><p>Here’s the brutal truth: Read these stories about the consequences of US students being very weak at math (there are plenty more):</p><ul><li><a href="https://apnews.com/article/math-scores-china-security-b60b740c480270d552d750c15ed287b6">Americans have poor math skills. It&#39;s a threat to US standing in the global economy, employers say</a></li><li><a href="https://hechingerreport.org/why-it-matters-that-americans-are-comparatively-bad-at-math/">Experts: Americans&#39; poor math skills threaten productivity, security</a></li></ul><p>And here’s one of the key root causes that CEA won’t mention: Many teachers, especially in elementary and middle school, are weak at math — even though they’re teaching it. See these stories:</p><ul><li><a href="https://source.cognia.org/issue-article/how-do-we-improve-elementary-math-education-it-starts-high-school/">How Do We Improve Elementary Math Education? It Starts in High School. - Cognia - The Source</a></li><li><a href="https://www.chicagotribune.com/opinion/commentary/ct-opinion-teachers-scared-math-education-20191125-faoy22apazgxxkc2ib65rpvnge-story.html">Commentary: Math scares your child&#39;s elementary school teacher - and that should frighten you</a></li><li><a href="https://www.nctq.org/review/Elementary-Mathematics-2022">NCTQ Teacher Prep Review: Elementary Mathematics</a></li><li><a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/news/education-schools-flunking-math/">Education Schools Flunking Math</a></li><li><a href="https://www.nsf.gov/news/news_summ.jsp?cntn_id=110845">U.S. Middle School Math Teachers Are Ill-prepared Among International Counterparts</a></li></ul><p>One story from our children’s experience in Jeffco epitomized the problem and the frustration that many parents feel at public schools (and rigid limitations that CEA and its affiliated unions like JCEA contractually impose on them).</p><p>Our childen’s high school lacked a teacher for another section of BC Calculus. A full professor of Mathematics at Colorado School of Mines offered to teach it. Jeffco rejected his offer because he didn’t have a Colorado secondary teaching certificate, which would take two years to get. The district could have given him emergency certification to teach the class. But they refused to do so.</p><p>Here’s another example, this time in physics. A an officer in the US Navy had taught physics for years at the <a href="https://www.navsea.navy.mil/Home/NNPTC/powerschool.aspx">Navy’s elite Nuclear Power School</a>. After leaving the Navy, she applied to teach physics in Jeffco. Frankly, I would have killed to have my daughter take her class. But I wasn’t give the chance. Jeffco told her she first had to spend two years getting a Colorado secondary teacher certification (again, Jeffco refused to go the emergency certification route). She was shocked, and took a job in the private sector instead. Today, she is a very successful executive.</p><p>This always reminds me of a third story. When I was in high school, some of my best teachers were people for whom teaching was a second career. One had been an Executive Vice President at a New York City Bank. Another had been a Senate committee staff director on Capitol Hill in DC. A third had been a practicing clinical psychologist for years. I doubt that any of them would be willing to put up with the bureaucratic BS that people like them face today if they want to teach in our public schools.</p><p>Bottom line: The only reason the “teacher shortage” exists is because the districts and unions and legislature and CDE have created it.</p><p><strong>All These Problems Would Disappear If Only the Legislature and Local Taxpayers Would Substantially Increase School Funding</strong></p><p>BS. The ugly truth (that few in K12 will ever acknowledge) is that school districts don’t modern financial management methods like Activity Based Costing that links goals to the activities that are required to achieve them to the cost of performing those activities (as well as other issues, like automation vs outsourcing vs in-house performance of those activities, and, in the latter case, the knowledge, skills, and experience required to perform them proficiently).</p><p>This is why you will NEVER get CEA or any other Progressive advocacy organization to give you a straight answer to the question, “How much do our schools need to ensure that 75% of our children graduate proficient in reading, writing, math, and science, and equipped to compete with talented people in other nations, and rapidly improving artificial intelligence automation technologies?”</p><p>Nobody in K12 management — whether Superintendents, Board Members, or Union Leaders (much less Progressive advocacy groups) has the slightest idea. Instead, they revert to the famous answer given by New York City public sector union leader Victor Gotbaum, who, when asked what the union wanted, honestly answered, “More”.</p><p>If you don’t believe me, ask your district Superintendent, CFO, or favorite School Board Member these questions:</p><ol><li>Including the value of teacher time, the cost of substitute teachers, and direct cash costs, what is the total amount your district spends on teacher professional development, and the district and school level?</li><li>How do you measure the impact of that spending on student achievement, and what do those measurements show?</li></ol><p>I guarantee that if you ask these questions, you will be met with a blank stare — or worse. And remember, teacher PD is just one area of spending in a district.</p><p>You can read more about this in <a href="https://tntp.org/publications/view/the-mirage-confronting-the-truth-about-our-quest-for-teacher-development">The New Teacher Project’s “Mirage” report</a>, which found that large districts spend an average of $18,000 per year, per teacher on professional development (including the costs noted above), with little or no positive impact on student achievment results.</p><p><strong>Here’s the Crisis in Colorado K12 Education that CEA Doesn’t Want to Face: Our Results Stink. Especially in One of the Nation’s Most Highly Educated States</strong></p><p>Consider the results in these Metro districts:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/272/1*H-ETrwD1hartApocDsI02Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/272/1*mMUpHlo9JGb_O1V0l4HXWQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/263/1*NjldJ3pyzwpQncozix6aSQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/270/1*GSEd-_aTDquDOa4TKPnUmQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/270/1*evYljkDwI_RfcDSYPaO-QA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/264/1*Lxm3CScfWu3LNFVtr2LT2Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/271/1*34LjB-kqsBSCy9Km4G_I6w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/268/1*S18dJYDxDAph-LsvEEkpOg.png" /></figure><p>Do you think these kids are going to reach proficiency by the time they graduate? Think again if you do. <a href="https://www.act.org/content/act/en/research/pdfs/catching-up-to-collegeandcareerreadiness.html">Research by the ACT Organization shows that most of them won’t</a>.</p><p>And if they don’t, will they be able to survive and thrive when competing with talented students from around the world (I love the saying, “if you can do your job from anywhere, someone from anywhere can do your job”), much less rapidly improving cognitive automation technologies (e.g., GPT-4, DALLE, and other generative AI models)?</p><p>And what will our economy, society, and politics look like in a world where so many of today’s children cannot compete? Is that the world you want to bequeath to them?</p><p>Apparently that’s precisely what CEA and its fellow travelers want. Why else would they be turning the other way, <a href="https://www.the74million.org/article/a-rose-colored-recovery-study-says-parents-dont-grasp-extent-of-covids-academic-damage/">as grade inflation accelerates, to fool parents into believing that their kids are doing just fine in K12?</a></p><p>Parents will only realize they were played for fools when their children <a href="https://www.jamesgmartin.center/2023/12/the-coming-wave-of-freshman-failure/">start failing in freshman year in college</a>, or flunking employer assessment tests, or the military’s ASVAB assessment.</p><p><strong>Last But Not Least, CEA Avoids Any Discussion of the Larger System Crisis in Colorado</strong></p><p>Consider these seemingly disparate bits of evidence:</p><ul><li>Colorado’s funding of higher education is among the lowest in the nation;</li><li>Colorado’s infrastructure is in poor shape, and not keeping up with population growth (tried to drive to the mountains on a weekend lately?);</li><li>Colorado’s defined benefit pension plan for state employees is one of the most underfunded in the country, <a href="https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/z1/dataviz/pension/">per the Federal Reserve</a>;</li><li>Despite having one of the most educated populations in the nation (#2 behind Massachusetts), Colorado’s K12 results are shockingly poor;</li><li>Colorado’s social safety net costs are exploding;</li><li>Colorado citizens have repeatedly rejected tax increases, quite possibly because they don’t believe they are getting value for the money they send to state and local governments;</li><li>IRS state-to-state migration data shows that Colorado is now losing (on a net basis) middle class taxpayers.</li></ul><p>The increased stress on all these fault lines are indications of a system careening towards a crisis. And the poor performance of our K12 system is part of that, however much CEA would have you believe that if we just gave public schools (and especially public school union teachers) much more money, everything would magically improve.</p><p>But that’s fantasy.</p><p>In sum, CEA’s “State of Education” in Colorado report is intended to deflect the public’s attention from the nature of the crisis facing our state, the profound failure of our public schools, and the massive negative consequences of that failure that are rushing towards us.</p><p>After moving here 13 years ago from Alberta (which has a high performing K12 system), I’ve come to expect this type of cynicism from CEA and its affiliated unions like JCEA. What they don’t realize, it seems, is that they can’t play this game forever, and, unless things drastically change in Colorado K12, someday they and their members who mindlessly puppet the union party line are going to pay a terrible price for years of deceiving the public and condemning a generation of children to a lifetime of struggle.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b3346622eb9d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Jeffco Schools: The Bad, Good, and (Still) Ugly]]></title>
            <link>https://tcoyne.medium.com/jeffco-schools-the-bad-good-and-still-ugly-68357bb76c0b?source=rss-d4fb1d4bda4c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/68357bb76c0b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[schools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colorado]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education-reform]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Coyne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 02 Nov 2023 21:47:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-05T17:05:26.670Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*dPOCO4DPkdiG_Uq9YzYbbg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Jefferson County Public Schools is a complex, $1.4 billion organization facing multiple crises. Here’s my assessment of its condition today, based on 13 years of observations since we moved here from Calgary, and years of experience leading organizational turnarounds.</p><p><strong>The Bad</strong></p><p>Long gone are the 1980s, when Jeffco Schools had a sterling national reputation. While county residents are still affluent and educated (48% have a bachelor’s degree or higher), the district’s academic results have been declining for more than 20 years. In reading, math, and science they are dismal, across all student groups:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/291/1*CdHO6dj6OyjkMagwZTGnZA.png" /><figcaption>Pct Jeffco Students Who are NOT Proficient</figcaption></figure><p>Jeffco claims that it’s mission is to provide “a world class education.” Clearly, it is failing, and not providing an education that will enable our children to successfully compete in the 21st century economy — not only with talented people from around the world, but also with <a href="https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4573321">rapidly improving artificial intelligence technologies</a>.</p><p>Declining academic performance contributed to the loss of 11,058 students from Jeffco’s district-run schools between 2012 and 2021. Over the same period, Jeffco’s Option Schools gained 2,050 students, charter schools gained 1,952, and students choicing out of Jeffco to schools in other districts increased by 1,351 to 5,088 students. Due to falling enrollment, Jeffco closed 16 district-run schools last year, with more closures coming as enrollment continues to fall.</p><p>Jeffco also faces a rapidly worsening budget crisis, with sharply rising deficits due to (1) falling enrollment; (2) the end of federal ESSER aid next year; and (3) the impact of the board’s decision to increase teacher compensation by more than 18% over the past two years, even as student achievement results continued to worsen.</p><p>Jeffco’s Capital Program is also <a href="https://tcoyne.medium.com/jeffco-schools-out-of-control-705-million-capital-program-the-scandal-has-widened-and-worsened-36a06bf2e6e6">mired in scandal</a>. Its cost has ballooned from $705 million to $856 million, due to cost overruns on projects at district-run schools (charter schools had none) and spending on projects never disclosed to Prop 5B voters in 2018 (like $50 million on athletic facilities and $17 million to GIFT a pool to the City of Arvada).</p><p>Consequently, Jeffco now lacks the funds to replace Fletcher Miller, the district’s decrepit school for our most disabled children.</p><p><strong>The Good</strong></p><p>Jeffco has an entirely new top leadership team, many of whom came from outside Jeffco. Members have been hired based on their potential to improve the district’s performance, in stark contrast to Jeffco’s traditional “it’s your turn” approach to promotions. Weak leaders are slowly being replaced, and the new team is more focused on improving academic results than at any time since the late 1990s when Jane Hammond was Superintendent (she was the last to deliver substantial academic gains).</p><p>Starting this year, all schools in each articulation area finally report to a single Community Superintendent, which should dramatically improve accountability for their results.</p><p>Student performance data and related analytics are no longer tightly guarded secrets, and are now available to teachers in real time to help improve student performance.</p><p>Jeffco has finally standardized reading and math curricula across the district (which should further boost results), and invested in MAP Accelerator (a joint venture of NWEA and Kahn Academy) which, in other districts, has delivered <a href="https://educationaldatamining.org/edm2022/proceedings/2022.EDM-industry-track.112/2022.EDM-industry-track.112.pdf">stunning results</a> in helping students to recover their math learning losses.</p><p>The new CFO has ended the old (and shocking) practice of running a $1.4 billion organization using a set of linked, error-filled spreadsheets, and replaced it with a modern financial management system.</p><p>Superintendent Dorland has also brought in Moss Adams (a firm which specializes in auditing school district capital programs) to provide an <a href="http://www.millerforjeffcostudents.com/resources/Moss-Adams-Report-on-Jeffco-Capital-Program.pdf">independent analysis of Jeffco’s capital program</a> and recommend corrective actions in response to its many management and governance failings.</p><p><strong>The Ugly</strong></p><p>Among turnaround specialists, there is an old saying: “The most dangerous problems facing a failing organization are the ones nobody talks about.”</p><p>Take a look at <a href="https://tcoyne.medium.com/12-years-of-reported-root-causes-of-poor-achievement-in-jeffco-schools-80d2078b9f7e">this list </a>of the “Major Root Causes” of Jeffco’s declining academic results that have appeared in a decade’s worth of the district’s Unified Improvement Plans. What don’t you see?</p><p>None of these UIPs acknowledged that dramatic changes to Jeffco’s culture are needed for the district to become a high-performance organization.</p><p>While there are always hopeful school-level exceptions, today the district as a whole remains too insular, too tolerant of mediocrity, too focused on spin, and too lacking in a collective feeling of urgency to dramatically improve outcomes for our children.</p><p>Why?</p><p>From what I’ve seen over the past 13 years, the most important (unmentionable) cause is the powerful influence the teachers union exerts on district decisions through its very strong collective bargaining contract and control of a majority of board directors. Both are powerful obstacles to the critical changes that are needed if the district is ever to achieve its mission of providing our children with a “world class education” (e.g., like getting weak teachers out of Jeffco classrooms and linking higher pay to improved district academic performance).</p><p>And after the 2023 election, the teachers union now controls all five seats on the Jeffco Board of Education.</p><p>Will Team Dorland succeed in turning around the district? The past thirty years of Jeffco history says the odds are against them. But for the sake of our children, our employers, and our property values, we should all hope they do.</p><p><em>Tom Coyne is a business executive, former member of the Jeffco District Accountability Committee, and former Chair of the Wheat Ridge High School Accountability Committee. His wife, Susan Miller, was elected to the Jeffco Board of Education in November 2019 and is not running for reelection this year. Their four children all attended district-run Jeffco schools. These are solely Coyne’s views.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=68357bb76c0b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Crisis in Jefferson County (Colorado) Schools: A Case Study of the Failure of Multiple District…]]></title>
            <link>https://tcoyne.medium.com/the-crisis-in-jefferson-county-colorado-schools-a-case-study-of-the-failure-of-multiple-district-1a44f69c88a7?source=rss-d4fb1d4bda4c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1a44f69c88a7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colorado]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education-reform]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Coyne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Dec 2022 00:27:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-02T17:55:08.710Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>The Crisis in Jefferson County (Colorado) Schools: A Case Study of the Failure of Multiple District Governance Processes</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*dPOCO4DPkdiG_Uq9YzYbbg.jpeg" /></figure><p>A growing number of US school districts face a worsening wicked problem. Before the pandemic arrived, its interacting elements included declining academic results, falling enrollment and revenue, increasing overcapacity, and rising costs. COVID accelerated all these negative trends.</p><p>If districts don’t find a way to solve the wicked problem they face, it won’t just be their students who will suffer the consequences. So will employers, the economy, and national security. Our society and politics will also pay the price, via worsening income inequality and intensifying conflicts between different groups.</p><p>To solve a problem, understanding its root causes is critical. I’ve written this case study to explore one of them in depth: The failure of multiple governance processes in the nation’s 39th largest school district.</p><p>Jefferson County is an affluent, educated suburb located to the west of Denver, Colorado, with annual total revenues of $1.4 billion.</p><p>Faced with General Fund deficits forecast to total more than $130 million over three years, on November 10, 2022, the Jefferson County (Colorado) Board of Education voted to close sixteen underutilized elementary schools.</p><p>None of the media reports about the closures mentioned a critical point: The situation facing Jeffco represents a colossal, decade-long governance failure.</p><p><strong><em>Background</em></strong></p><p>Jeffco’s financial crisis has resulted from the confluence of a number of negative trends that have been building for at least a decade.</p><p>Jeffco is an affluent, educated suburb. Yet its academic results have been declining.</p><p>In 2019 (before COVID arrived), 54% of Jeffco 3rd graders didn’t meet state ELA standards on CMAS — an improvement of only 2% from 2015. In 6th grade math, performance got worse. While 58% failed to meet state standards in 2015, 65% didn’t in 2019.</p><p>The 2022 state assessment results showed that COVID learning losses have made Jeffco’s situation even worse. For example, even though over three thousand students who had low scores in 2019 didn’t take the 2022 CMAS, this year a shocking 70% of 6th graders failed to meet the state math standard!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/899/1*Ownkrllsj0OIPBAE6OxpAQ.png" /></figure><p>In Colorado, all 11th grade students take the SAT. This is the last measure we have of the effectiveness of our school districts in meeting their primary goal of educating our children. In 2022, Jeffco’s 11th grade SAT scores continued their five-year slide.</p><p>A July 2022 EdChoice/Morning Consult poll found that parents’ top three school choice criteria are that it is close, safe, and has strong academic results. With 48% of Jeffco students choicing away from their neighborhood school, many parents are willing to sacrifice proximity for the other two benefits.</p><p>Given this, it is reasonable to assume that Jeffco’s worsening academic results has caused an increasing number of parents to “choice away” from their local neighborhood school.</p><p>As you can see in the table below, over the last decade Jeffco’s district-run neighborhood schools lost 11,058 students (2,050 went to district run Option Schools, 1,952 to district Charter Schools, and 7,056 left the district across all grades, including moves to other states, districts, and private, religious, and home schools).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/899/1*3RVnAiymLrcpOJHArzu4Lg.png" /></figure><p>As a result of these losses, before the announced closure of 16 elementary schools, sixty-eight Jeffco schools were operating at less than 80% of capacity, the industry threshold for low utilization. While forty-eight operated at below 65% of capacity; Jeffco is closing only sixteen of them. And since 2018, almost all these underutilized schools have received millions in new facility investments under the district’s capital improvement program.</p><p>The district’s costs have been rising, even as student enrollment in district-run neighborhood schools declines.</p><p>In 2012, Jeffco spent $446 million on salary and benefits to serve 77,143 students in its district-run schools). Ten years later, it spent $702 million (57% more) to serve 69,526 students (10% fewer). On a per student basis, Jeffco spent $5,782 on total compensation in 2012, and, in constant 2012 dollars, $10,097 per student in 2022. That’s a real increase of 41% in compensation cost per student — even as academic results were steadily declining.</p><p>In September, by a 4–1 vote, Jeffco’s Board of Education (whose majority is backed by the teachers union) made matters much worse by approving a $73 million increase in total compensation for district staff. Due to the steps and levels structure of its union contract, this amount will significantly increase in the years ahead.</p><p>In sum, Jeffco’s current crisis has resulted from the interaction of an academic performance crisis, a capital program and facilities management crisis, and a budget crisis.</p><p>A root cause of all of these has been the utter failure of multiple Jeffco governance processes.</p><p><strong><em>Governance Processes in the District</em></strong></p><p>In addition to the Board of Education, there are three other governance bodies in Jeffco.</p><p><strong>Financial Oversight Committee (FOC)</strong></p><p>Jeffco’s Financial Oversight Committee was established by the Board of Education in December 1999 to assist the board in fulfilling its fiduciary oversight responsibilities by reviewing:</p><ul><li>“Financial reports and other financial information used internally and provided by the district to any governmental body or the public;</li><li>“The district’s system of internal controls regarding finance, accounting, legal compliance and ethics that management and the Board have established (note that this is in line with Government Accounting Standards, which state that <a href="https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-01-1008g.pdf">maintenance of sound internal controls</a> is a governance responsibility);</li><li>“The business risk of the district; and</li><li>“The district’s accounting and financial reporting processes generally.</li></ul><p>The committee has a citizen chair. Members serve without term limits.</p><p><strong>District Accountability Committee (DAC)</strong></p><p>In Colorado, District and School Accountability Committees (DACs and SACs) are independent bodies created by the state legislature in 2009 to improve the performance of public schools.</p><p>Their legal existence exists separate and apart from school districts and boards of education. However, DAC members are appointed by the local school board, subject to distribution requirements for their membership (e.g., a certain number of business community members, parents of Special Education and Gifted Students, etc.). Parents of current students must represent a plurality of DAC members.</p><p>The DAC has citizen co-chairs, and members are term limited.</p><p>DACs are charged with reviewing student achievement results versus goals, the root causes of any underperformance, and the plans and budgets that are proposed to drive improvement, and advising the Board of Education on these issues.</p><p>Each year, every school and district in Colorado prepares a Unified Improvement Plan. These “UIPs” are intended to drive a continuous student achievement improvement process. Each UIP has three main sections: (1) a discussion of the previous year’s results and identification of key achievement problems; (2) discussion of the root causes of these problems; and (3) a detailed description of the major improvement initiatives that will be undertaken over the next 12 months to address the identified root causes, as well as clear metrics and goals that will be used to evaluate these initiatives.</p><p>Colorado’s <a href="https://www.cde.state.co.us/uip">Unified Improvement Planning process</a> is just a variant of the process that is frequently attributed to W. Edwards Deming and Toyota Motor Company. Its four steps are summarized as “Plan”, “Do”, “Study”, and “Act”. Since the 1950s, organizations around the world systematically applied it to continuously and substantially improve their performance.</p><p>District UIPs must be approved by the local Board of Education before being submitted to the Colorado Department of Education (CDE).</p><p>CDE does not systematically track or publicly report on whether the Major Improvement Initiatives in district’s UIPs are actually implemented, or whether they achieve their achievement improvement objectives.</p><p><strong>Capital Asset Advisory Committee (CAAC)</strong></p><p>In 2010, the Jeffco Board of Education authorized the establishment of the Capital Asset Advisory Committee advise the board on the planning of capital needs and the implementation of capital programs, and “ensure that sound, long-term decisions are consistent with the needs of the district and in support of the district’s strategic plan.”</p><p>Per Jeffco’s website, “members have a working familiarity with facility design and/or construction practices; business management expertise with organization(s) of comparable size to the district, and are independent and free from any relationship that would interfere with independent judgment.”</p><p>As is the case with the Financial Oversight Committee, members serve without term limits. Unlike the FOC, the CAAC has no citizen chair, and instead is led by the District’s Chief Operating Officer and its Director of Facilities.</p><p><strong><em>The Systematic Failure of Governance in Jeffco</em></strong></p><p><strong>The District Accountability Committee</strong></p><p>While DACs were intended by the legislature to provide independent advice on improving student achievement results, such independence was quickly undermined by the provision that allowed Boards of Education to determine DAC membership.</p><p>More specifically, the Jeffco DAC has consistently undermined the effectiveness of the Uniform Improvement Process — which, as noted above, has driven performance improvement in private sector and other government organzations (e.g., the United States Marine Corps) for seventy years.</p><p>What are the root causes of this surprising failure? At the highest level, three come to mind:</p><ul><li>The root causes that were identified were not the most important root causes;</li><li>The major improvement strategies identified to address the root causes were incorrect (e.g., not based on strong research evidence);</li><li>The major improvement strategies were poorly implemented.</li></ul><p>Consider this list of all the root causes that were contained in the Unified Improvement Plans that Jeffco Public Schools has submitted to the Colorado Department of Education since the 2010/2011 school year:</p><p><strong>2010/11 UIP</strong></p><ul><li><em>District Superintendent: Dr. Cindy Stevenson</em></li><li><em>Board of Education: Dave Thomas, Jane Barnes, Laura Boggs, Paula Noonan and Robin Johnson</em></li></ul><p>“Schools lack district-wide formative and benchmark progress monitoring tools in writing to calibrate the fidelity of implementation of the district writing curriculum.”</p><p>“Students needing to catch-up do not receive quality and/or adequate time for universal/core instruction in addition to effective, aligned targeted/intensive interventions.”</p><p>“Many secondary schools do not have a systematic, tiered system of support to respond to the needs of catch-up students.”</p><p>“The district has not strategically resource mapped and allocated resources differently among schools to better meet the needs of catch-up students.”</p><p><strong>2011/12 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Dr. Cindy Stevenson</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Dave Thomas, Jane Barnes, Laura Boggs, Paula Noonan and Robin Johnson</em></p><p>“Schools lack district-wide formative and benchmark progress monitoring tools in writing to calibrate the fidelity of implementation of the district writing curriculum.”</p><p>“Teaching and learning have not consistently demanded high expectations in every classroom due to superficial coverage of a large number of standards, lack of understanding of grade level mastery, lack of relevance for students, and lack of systemic progress monitoring.”</p><p>“Educators lack consistently rigorous, growth-producing feedback through the evaluation process.”</p><p>“The district is not meeting the state expectation of 100% highly qualified teachers…because an effective monitoring system is not in place for existing staff especially for secondary schools.”</p><p><strong>2012/13 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Dr. Cindy Stevenson</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Lesley Dahlkemper, Paula Noonan, Laura Boggs, Robin Johnson, Jill Feldman</em></p><p>“The district lacks systemic practices in writing instruction and effective feedback in every classroom.”</p><p>“The district lacks structures to ensure consistent quality of professional development is provided to all instructional staff.”</p><p>“District and school leadership lack systemic understanding around multiple pathways for students to stay on track to graduate.”</p><p><strong>2013/14 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Dr. Cindy Stevenson</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Lesley Dahlkemper, Paula Noonan, Laura Boggs, Robin Johnson, Jill Feldman</em></p><p>“Systemic implementation of intentional lesson design to engage students’ conceptual understanding of their learning and increase student cognitive load is not evident in all classrooms.”</p><p>“Educators have received inconsistent training on effective literacy instruction and the use of research-based resources”</p><p>“Math instruction tends not to be differentiated, lacking a variety of structures to meet students’ needs”</p><p><strong>2014/15 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Dan McMinimee</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Ken Witt, Julie Williams, John Newkirk, Lesley Dahlkemper, Jill Feldman</em></p><p>— Note: the following is not a typo. The 2014/15 UIP repeats the same root causes as 13/14 because this was the year the state assessment transitioned from TCAP to CMAS.</p><p>“Systemic implementation of intentional lesson design to engage students’ conceptual understanding of their learning and increase student cognitive load is not evident in all classrooms.”</p><p>“Educators have received inconsistent training on effective literacy instruction and the use of research-based resources”</p><p>“Math instruction tends not to be differentiated, lacking a variety of structures to meet students’ needs”</p><p><strong>2015/16 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Dan McMinimee</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Ken Witt, Julie Williams, John Newkirk, Lesley Dahlkemper, Jill Feldman</em></p><p>“There is a need for implementation across the district of systemic evidence-based instructional practices that promote learning of rigorous literacy skills and competencies to ensure every student can “read to learn” by the end of third grade.”</p><p>“There is a need for implementation across the district of vertical alignment (PK through 12th) and interdependence of math concept development that leads to successful learning in algebraic thinking…There is a need across the district for systemic classroom-based instruction, assessment and grading practices throughout the elementary and middle years that focus on higher level math concepts and procedures.”</p><p>“Core instruction in academics, and social and emotional skill development must meet the needs of all students in achieving the performance expectations that will prepare them each step in their chosen learning pathway to successful completion of a Jeffco education.”</p><p><strong>2016/17 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Dan McMinimee</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Ron Mitchell, Ali Lasell, Susan Harmon, Amanda Stevens, Brad Rupert</em></p><p>“In many schools, there is a lack of systemic evidence-based instructional practices that promote learning of rigorous literacy skills and competencies to ensure every student can “read to learn” by the end of third grade…For many students, the various literacy interventions are not specifically matched to student learning needs and may create additional barriers to learning rather than supporting literacy growth…Evidence indicates that current professional development in standards/competency-based core instructional strategies and learning supports has had limited impact on the effectiveness of high level literacy practices and matching interventions to student needs…Evidence indicates that current professional development and resource allocation for literacy instruction has had limited impact on desired increases in student performance.”</p><p>“In many schools, there is a lack of systemic classroom-based instruction, assessment, and grading practices throughout the elementary and middle years that focus on higher level math concepts and procedures leading to algebraic thinking…In many schools, there is a lack of systemic classroom-based practices that require application and transfer of higher order algebraic thinking to meaningful/relevant real world problems and contexts…There is a lack of understanding across the system of vertical alignment (PK through 12th) and interdependence of math concept development that leads to successful learning and algebraic thinking…There is a lack of commitment across the system to ensure consistent differentiated teaching and learning practices matched to student needs.”</p><p>“There is a need across the district for a system-wide commitment to ensure classroom practices and programming choices that provide every student with the opportunity to successfully complete a Jeffco educational pathway…There is a need across the district for a clear understanding among students and staff of the most critical performance expectations to achieve in order to be prepared for each student’s learning pathway…The allocation (or reallocation) of resources and supports to meet students’ social, emotional, engagement, and advancement needs are not addressing barriers to learning for all students (including students with educational plans).”</p><p><strong>2017/18 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Dr. Jason Glass</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Ron Mitchell, Ali Lasell, Susan Harmon, Amanda Stevens, Brad Rupert</em></p><p>“The district and schools have not provided equitable resources and support for math students to have a well-established foundation in: mathematical reasoning to explain, justify, and evaluate their thinking used to solve problems and applications of reasoning across content areas.”</p><p>“Due to inequitable resources and support, schools have limited capacity to differentiate instruction and engage students in relevant, authentic tasks, specifically in the core areas of mathematical reasoning and conceptual understanding in addition to memorization of facts.”</p><p>“All schools currently do not have the full capacity to meet all students’ early literacy learning needs due to inequitable resources and support, for a variety of reasons, including inconsistent structures and routines across schools for foundational classroom (core) reading instruction, variable evidenced-based instructional practices to differentiate teaching for all learners’ needs, and lack of literacy transfer and application to other content areas.”</p><p><strong>2018/19 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Dr. Jason Glass</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Ron Mitchell, Ali Lasell, Susan Harmon, Amanda Stevens, Brad Rupert</em></p><p>“Early Literacy: All schools currently do not have the full capacity to meet all students’ early literacy needs due to inequitable resources and support, for a variety of reasons including: (1) Inconsistent structures and routines across schools for foundational classroom (core) reading instruction; (2) Variable evidence-based instructional practices to differentiate teaching for all learners’ needs; and (3) Lack of literacy transfer and application to other content areas.”</p><p>“Middle School Math: The district and schools have not provided equitable resources and support (for example, differentiated professional learning, and interventions) for math students to have a well-established foundation in: (1) Mathematical reasoning to explain, justify, and evaluate their thinking used to solve problems; and (2) Application of reasoning across content areas.”</p><p>“Post-Secondary and Workforce Readiness (PWR): Due to inequitable resources and support, schools have limited capacity to differentiate instruction and engage students in relevant, authentic tasks, specifically in the core areas of: (1) Mathematical reasoning and conceptual understanding in addition to memorization of facts; and (2) Literacy transfer and application to other content areas.”</p><p><strong>2019/20 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Dr. Jason Glass</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Ron Mitchell, Ali Lasell, Susan Harmon, Amanda Stevens, Brad Rupert</em></p><p>“Inequitable early academic access, resources, and support that transform the student experience”</p><p>“There is a lack of engaging student learning experiences for middle level students. Many Jeffco students have not fully engaged in their learning due to a lack of student agency (voice and choice in their learning) and relevance (real world application) with high expectations for all learners.”</p><p>“There is a lack of student learning experiences for both career and college connections during the high school years that will ensure students are ready and able to connect to career, college, and life as productive citizens.”</p><p><strong>2020/21 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Kristopher Schuh</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Susan Harmon, Brad Rupert, Ron Mitchell, Stephanie Schooley, Susan Miller</em></p><p>“In Jeffco, we continue to focus on providing deeper learning, namely rich and authentic learning experiences for all students built on the foundation of “student task” — or what teachers create for students to do in the classroom. We want our students to have the opportunity to develop skills and abilities such as collaboration, adaptation to changing conditions, communications, creative problem solving, and civic and global engagement (a.k.a. Jeffco Generations Skills). Over the past century, historical approaches to teaching have not focused on this real-world application and it takes time for systems to adapt instructional approaches and change traditional practices.”</p><p>“A major root cause for many of the district’s priority challenges this year concerns the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. Disruptions to learning, increased social-emotional needs, and exacerbated opportunity gaps for students experiencing poverty, homelessness and other risk factors have all contributed to this year’s challenges for the district and schools.”</p><p><strong>2021/2022 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Tracy Dorland</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Susan Harmon, Brad Rupert, Ron Mitchell, Stephanie Schooley, Susan Miller</em></p><p>“Inconsistent district/school/classroom leadership, data-based decision making, family partnerships, tiered supports and evidence-based practices to meet all students’ needs.”</p><p>“Depending on the school and/or classroom, all students may not receive or benefit from effective continuous improvement processes to meet their varied academic, behavioral, and social-emotional needs.”</p><p>“District supports have not been integrated across all departments to develop and support systemic leadership, data-based decision making, family partnerships, tiered supports and evidence-based practices to meet all students’ needs.”</p><p><strong>2022/2023 UIP</strong></p><p>· <em>District Superintendent: Tracy Dorland</em></p><p>· <em>Board of Education: Stephanie Schooley, Mary Parker, Paula Reed, Danielle Varda, Susan Miller</em></p><p>“Prior improvement efforts through strategic planning and district unified improvement plans have not yielded anticipated results due to inconsistent: District Focus, Clarity of expectations, Adequate training/support for staff, and, Effective tools to check progress and adjust implementation strategies.”</p><p>This list of root causes from more than a decade of UIPs raises two critical questions:</p><p>First, why did the root causes change? If the ones listed were successfully addressed but achievement results didn’t improve, it implies that the real root causes either weren’t identified or for some reason were identified but not listed in the UIP.</p><p>Second, if the listed root causes were not successfully addressed, why were they then changed in the subsequent UIP?</p><p>My observations over the past decade (including the time I spent as a member of the DAC), have led me to conclude that there were very clearly root causes which, for political reasons, could never be acknowledged. Here are two examples.</p><p>Unlike most other districts, Jeffco’s organizational structure diffuses responsibility and accountability. For example, in other districts principals of elementary, middle, and high schools in a given geographic area all report to the same “Area” or “Community” Superintendent (ensuring what the military calls “unity of command”). But in Jeffco elementary and middle/high school principals report to different Community Superintendents.</p><p>The weakness of middle management in Jeffco has resulted in 150 plus school principals in Jeffco all having a de facto relationship with the Superintendent. Jane Hammond was the last Jeffco Superintendent who actually improved academic performance. When she arrived in Jeffco in the mid-1990s (after successful stints in Maryland and Washington State), she observed that Jeffco wasn’t a “school system” at all, but rather a collection of 150 independent fiefdoms, presided over by princes and princesses of the realm. When she challenged this system, she was forced out, despite having improved academic results.</p><p>One critical consequence of this radically decentralized system been that building principals have historically chosen or allowed teachers to develop their own curriculum, instructional materials, and often professional development, with no consistency within Articulation Areas, much less across the district.</p><p>Even with a given “articulation area” (i.e., elementary and middle schools that feed to a specific high school) a student could encounter different curricula in elementary, middle, and high school. Given the demonstrated power of consistent curricula and instructional materials (e.g., EngageNY, or Alberta’s Provincial Curriculum), is it any surprise that Jeffco’s approach has produced poor and declining academic result?</p><p>Second, in such a radically decentralized and highly politicized system, there is essentially no accountability. As such, in Jeffco poor principals and other leaders have hung around for years — another cause of persistently poor academic results, and a key element of its extremely insular and frequently toxic culture.</p><p>Moreover, even when the DAC UIP accurately identified an important root cause of poor academic performance, the Unified Improvement Process was often undermined by selection of initiatives that were either aspirational and ambiguous, or driven by politics and unsupported by evidence.</p><p>Even in the rare case where an improvement initiative made sense (eg., switching to Math Expressions as the district’s consistent math curriculum) implementation was almost always poor, and was too often undermined by independently minded principals. And the results of these initiatives were never rigorously and systematically evaluated, much less widely shared either internally or externally.</p><p>Finally, two damning independent outside evaluations of the Root Causes of Jeffco’s student achievement decline were conducted in <a href="http://www.millerforjeffcostudents.com/resources/Deliver-Ed-final-report.pdf">2017</a> (by DeliverEd consulting) and <a href="http://www.millerforjeffcostudents.com/resources/Aquino-Report.pdf">2021</a> (by Dr. Jaime Aquino, who is now Superintendent of San Antonio Schools). The DAC never mentioned them in its reports to the Board of Education.</p><p>In sum, despite the best intentions of the state legislature, in Jeffco, the District Accountability Committee has been an utter failure as a governance mechanism and continuous improvement process, as evidenced by the steady decline in the district’s academic results.</p><p><strong>Capital Asset Advisory Committee</strong></p><p>The Jeffco CAAC has seen number of very expensive governance failures.</p><p>In 2017, 14 Jeffco schools (3 high school, 6 middle schools, and 5 elementary) were operating at less than 65% of capacity. Unlike Jeffco, many school districts use less than 80% of capacity as their criteria for low utilization.</p><p>That year the district tried to close five elementary schools. After public protest, only one was closed. It was a Title 1 school, and its students were sent to two other schools that were not Title 1 schools, and thus lacked the per student funding the closed schools had.</p><p>After this, Superintendent Jason Glass instituted a two-year moratorium on further school closures. The Board directed Glass to prepare a long-term Facilities Master Plan to guide future closure and new school building decisions.</p><p>Glass never provided it to the Board or the public, despite paying $167,000 to an outside facilities consulting firm to prepare it. And the Board never held him accountable for this.</p><p>Moreover, despite multiple Freedom of Information Act requests, the district has consistently claimed that no Facilities Master Plan exists. And the Capital Asset Advisory Committee never said anything about this to the Board.</p><p>This isn’t surprising, because despite its status as a creation of the board, the CAAC had no civilian chair. Instead, it was co-chaired by the district’s Chief Operating Officer and Director of Facilities.</p><p>You read that right. A governance committee was chaired by management.</p><p>In 2018, 19 Jeffco schools were operating at less than 65% of capacity (3 high schools, 7 middle schools, and 9 elementary schools).</p><p>Two things happened that year that propelled Jeffco towards the crisis it now faces in 2022.</p><p>First, to avoid closing middle schools, the district decided to move 6th grade from elementary schools to middle schools.</p><p>They claimed that there would be no adverse impact on 6th graders’ academic achievement, and that expanded pre-school programs would fill the now unused elementary school seats.</p><p>Both claims subsequently proved to be wrong.</p><p>The second major event in 2018 was the CAAC’s recommendation that the district undertake a $705 million dollar Capital Improvement Program. As described in the “<a href="http://www.millerforjeffcostudents.com/resources/JeffcoFlipbook-OriginalPresentedtoVoters.pdf">Flipbook</a>” given to voters, every school in the district — even those with very low capacity utilization — would receive millions in facility investments.</p><p>When it recommended the proposed Capital Improvement Program to the Jeffco Board of Education, not only was the CAAC aware of the 19 schools with less than 65% capacity utilization, but also of adverse enrollment trends.</p><p>Jeffco’s 2018 Enrollment Report showed that over the previous 5 years, enrollment in district-run schools had decreased by (2,837) students.</p><p>By 2023, district-run schools were forecast to lose another (1,208) students. Moreover, the data showed that Jeffco’s projections had continuously underestimated the loss of students at district-run schools.</p><p>Moreover, <a href="https://yourhub.denverpost.com/blog/2018/10/no-5a-5b-jeffco-empty-school-seats/228415/">members of the public also provided detailed analysis of Jeffco’s overcapacity problem</a>.</p><p>But the CAAC still recommended the Capital Program and its associated bond issue to the Board of Education.</p><p><a href="https://tcoyne.medium.com/should-jeffco-leaders-be-blamed-for-spending-more-than-20-million-of-bond-funds-on-the-16-schools-813ba00c73eb">An extensive analysis of the information that was available to the CAAC raises very serious questions about the logic behind this decision.</a></p><p>In November 2018, the $567 million bond issue was barely approved by 1,286 votes (1/4 of 1% of the votes cast).</p><p>With two more years to go, today the Capital Improvement Program has <a href="http://www.millerforjeffcostudents.com/page-2/page-9/">$174 million in cost overruns and spending on projects that were never disclosed to voters in 2018</a>.</p><p>Management of the Capital Program has been sharply criticized by Moss Adams, which conducted <a href="http://www.millerforjeffcostudents.com/resources/Moss-Adams-Report-on-Jeffco-Capital-Program.pdf">an independent review</a> (Moss Adams is the market leader in conducting such reviews of school bond programs in California, where they are required by law).</p><p>The Capital Improvement Program’s many scandals and failings have also been extensively documented on <a href="https://improvejeffcoschools.org/">Improve Jeffco Schools</a>, and by me in <a href="https://tcoyne.medium.com/jeffco-schools-out-of-control-705-million-capital-program-a-case-study-in-poor-management-weak-dd8e93fc63f2">this</a>, <a href="https://tcoyne.medium.com/jeffco-schools-out-of-control-705-million-capital-program-the-scandal-has-widened-and-worsened-36a06bf2e6e6">this</a>, and <a href="https://tcoyne.medium.com/using-17m-in-jefferson-county-school-funds-to-build-an-olympic-natatorium-for-the-city-of-arvada-586a50b77da">this</a> column here on Medium.</p><p>Yet since 2018, apart from one CAAC member’s resignation in protest over the committee’s failure to perform its role, the CAAC’s reports to the Board of Education (always delivered by a member of management) have never been critical of the Capital Program — even when it was revealed that the family company of a CAAC member had received over a million dollars in contracts from the Capital Improvement Program. The member in question was also a long-serving member of the Financial Oversight Committee, to which we now turn.</p><p><strong>Financial Oversight Committee</strong></p><p>The first thing to note about Jeffco’s FOC committee is the requirement that its “members have a strong background in finance and accounting practices as well as substantial large organization business management expertise.”</p><p>For the past decade, very few of its members have met this test. For example, after recent appointments, this is the first time in years that the FOC has had two members who are CPAs, but only one of whom has significant large company experience (remember, Jeffco is an organization with $1.4 billion in annual revenue).</p><p>The FOC’s most glaring shortcoming has been its failure to effectively oversee, much less warn the Board of Education about, Jeffco’s dangerously weak system of internal controls and deteriorating financial condition.</p><p>The Capital Program is one painful example.</p><p>During the 2018 bond campaign, Superintendent Jason Glass repeatedly promised voters that Capital Improvement Program spending would be independently audited.</p><p>Along with the Flipbook, this assurance formed the basis for Colorado Community Media’s Jeffco newspapers’ endorsement:</p><p><em>“We applaud the district’s commitment to transparency: A citizens financial oversight committee and independent audit of expenditures will make sure money from the measures is spent as intended. We also commend the district for listening to criticism from its failed bond attempt in 2016, which cited a lack of clarity in how the money would be used. This time, the district has prepared a detailed booklet and website of exactly where the money will go at each school.”</em></p><p>Yet the promised annual independent audits of expenditures were never performed. Instead, the district claimed that its annual financial audit met this requirement — despite denials by Clifton Larson (the district’s independent auditor) that it only audited the accuracy of the district’s accounting, not whether Capital Program spending aligned with what had been promised to voters in 2018.</p><p>Nor in its reports to the Board did the FOC ever comment on Moss Adams’ criticisms of the Capital Program’s numerous internal control weaknesses, or criticize the district for failing to implement any of Moss Adams’ recommendations for strengthening Jeffco’s internal control processes.</p><p>Instead, in its reports to the Board the FOC seemed much more focused on defending Jeffco from its critics. When the Capital Program was more than $174 million over budget because of cost overruns and spending on projects never disclosed to the voters, and well-after the Moss Adams report had been released, the FOC’s former chairwoman told the Board of Education that it was “just like when you’re doing a project to remodel your bathroom, sometimes projects experience cost overruns.” Really. She actually said that. It’s on video.</p><p>A second example of the FOC’s oversight failure came to light after the arrival Tracy Dorland, Jeffco’s new Superintendent, and Brenna Copeland, its new CFO. Both expressed astonishment to the Board that, instead of basing its budget on forecast revenues (as was the practice in every other district they’d seen), Jeffco uniquely created its initial budget based on the previous year’s revenue.</p><p>Equally shocking was Jeffco’s practice of thereafter focusing its budgeting discussions only on the allocation of incremental changes in revenue — and not whether the entire $1.4 billion in revenue was being spent efficiently and effectively.</p><p>Copeland soon discovered (and promptly informed the FOC and the Board) of one of the reasons for this: Shockingly, a complex $1.4 billion organization was being run using a set of linked spreadsheets, rather than a modern financial planning and management system.</p><p>Even worse, these spreadsheets were riddled with errors — some leading to millions of dollars inaccurate budget information — that Copeland had to disclose and reverse.</p><p>Moreover, decision authority over spending decisions was so confused and diffuse that budget overruns were rampant and inevitable. And nobody ever seemed to be held accountable for them.</p><p>Despite all these disclosures, the FOC said nothing to the Board. Nor did the district’s outside auditor ever publicly comment on them.</p><p>The FOC never opened its own investigation of these internal control failures, nor did it recommend an independent audit of the magnitude and severity of Jeffco’s internal control failures. And it never provided the Board with any recommendations about how to improve Jeffco’s internal control environment.</p><p>It was almost as though the FOC did not understand its responsibility for the soundness of Jeffco’s internal control environment, either under its Board mandate or Government Accounting Principles. Nor has the Board ever asked for this; perhaps they also don’t understand the critical importance of internal controls in a $1.4 billion organization, and their responsibility for it.</p><p>A final governance failure by the Financial Oversight Committee has been its silence for years on the increasingly negative budget and financial implications of Jeffco’s declining enrollment, rising costs, and growing number of severely underutilized schools, much less the wisdom of investing millions of dollars of Capital Program funds in schools that were likely to be closed.</p><p><strong>The Jeffco Board of Education</strong></p><p>If the DAC, CAAC, and FOC were all guilty of not warning the Board about Jeffco’s worsening problems, with few exceptions the Board itself was guilty of never asking about them, even in the face of highly credible evidence of their existence.</p><p>It wasn’t the case that Board members lacked the required expertise. Over the years, they have included people with MBAs and Law Degrees; one was the CFO of a large healthcare organization.</p><p>Rather than a lack of ability, the Board’s failure appears to have been due to a lack of willingness to delve into the district’s problems, much less hold the Superintendent accountable for failures to achieve goals (“Board Ends”) or violations of Executive Limitations (both of which are critical to the successful implementation of the Policy Governance model the Board claims to use).</p><p>To cite one example: Before Tracy Dorland arrived, one Board member proposed a resolution detailing the many failings of the Capital Improvement Program and demanding an independent Performance Audit. None of the other four Board members seconded the resolution.</p><p>Note that when Dorland arrived she too avoided a full independent Performance Audit, and only requested that Moss Adams perform a much more limited review (which still uncovered may failings).</p><p>Why was the Board so unwilling to ask questions about Jeffco’s obvious shortcomings, in academic performance, Capital Program management, or budgeting and internal controls?</p><p>In my experience, three possible explanations stand out. First, for the past seven years, the majority of board members have been elected with the backing of the teachers’ union. The union’s top priority has always been improving conditions for their members, not uncovering district problems that might interfere with the achievement of their primary goal.</p><p>There is no better example of this than this year’s 4–1 board vote to increase employee compensation by $73 million (which, due to annual changes in steps, levels, and inflation will annually increase). That this would trigger the financial crisis that has led to the closing of 16 schools this year, more next year, and almost certainly hundreds of layoffs was apparently not a major concern of the four board members who approved it (though it was the major concern of the one board member not backed by the teachers union who voted against it).</p><p>Perhaps this was the reason the Board never asked the Financial Oversight Committee for its assessment of the potential impact of the proposed pay increase.</p><p>The second explanation is the deeply insular culture of Jeffco Public Schools, which has, since we moved here from Alberta 12 years ago, repeatedly shown that it harshly reacts to criticism, whether from internal or external parties. Put differently, Jeffco represents the antithesis of a high-performance culture.</p><p>Over the years the Board of Education has almost always chosen people who appeared to share this culture to be members of the DAC, CAAC, and FOC. In fact, district management first screens people who apply to serve on these governance committees before they recommended appointees to the Board.</p><p>This is a system perfectly designed to perpetuate the Jeffco’s toxic, low-performance culture.</p><p>The third explanation is one found in many suburbs — strong opposition on the part of some parties (e.g., realtors and economic development officials) to any criticism of their local school district. Better to hide its problems rather than trying to fix them.</p><p>Unfortunately, kicking the can down the road works only as long as there’s some road left. When it runs out, you end up like Jeffco.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>If the many governance and management failings detailed herein had occurred at a $1.4 billion public company instead of a $1.4 billion school district, it would have been front page news in the global business media, and triggered reactions ranging from an avalanche of litigation (e.g., shareholder derivative suits against board directors) to attacks by activist investors or an outright takeover by a better performing company.</p><p>But that didn’t happen.</p><p>The K-12 media has been silent, and the business media uninterested in the deepening crisis, management, and governance failures at the nation’s 39th largest school district.</p><p>As a result, and despite Jefferson County’s educated, affluent population, the district’s academic performance has deteriorated for years, enrollment has continuously declined (and with it district revenues), and school underutilization has worsened. Yet the number of district employees and total compensation cost have continued to rise.</p><p>As Herbert Stein famously warned, “If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.” In Jeffco, it finally has.</p><p>The district now faces a severe financial crisis, with forecast budget deficits totaling more than $130 million over the next three years.</p><p>Meanwhile, Capital Program cost overruns and spending on projects never disclosed to voters have ballooned to $174 million — and still rising. Millions now must be spent on the schools receiving students from the 16 elementary schools being closed.</p><p>Many people would like to blame the multiple crises now facing Jeffco on failures of district management. But this misses a deeper root cause.</p><p>The district’s crises refledt the complete failure of Jeffco’s governance processes.</p><p>Worse, this governance failure is deeply rooted in the district’s insular and toxic culture, which over the years has been extremely resistant to criticism, much less substantial change.</p><p>A $1.4 billion public company in the same situation would almost certainly see its stock price collapse, and then either be acquired or enter Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings.</p><p>But neither will happen in Jeffco, where Colorado’s regulations for state takeover of school districts are extremely weak (e.g., compared to Massachusetts), and, to avoid bankruptcy, state law provides for the imposition of emergency taxes on county residents when a school district exhausts its financial reserves.</p><p>Given the district’s multiple governance failures, and the deeply rooted culture that underlies them, it is difficult to be optimistic, either about Jeffco or the prospects for substantially improving the performance of other school districts that share many of the same pathologies.</p><p>And that is very bad news for our nation.</p><p><em>Tom Coyne is an executive at Britten Coyne Partners, a turnaround expert, and a former member of the Jeffco District Accountability Committee. He is married to Jeffco Public Schools Board Director Susan Miller. The opinions in this column are Coyne’s alone.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1a44f69c88a7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Should Jeffco Leaders Be Blamed for Spending More than $20 Million of Bond Funds on the 16 Schools…]]></title>
            <link>https://tcoyne.medium.com/should-jeffco-leaders-be-blamed-for-spending-more-than-20-million-of-bond-funds-on-the-16-schools-813ba00c73eb?source=rss-d4fb1d4bda4c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/813ba00c73eb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[colorado]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[k12]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Coyne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Nov 2022 17:15:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-02T17:57:02.577Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Should Jeffco Leaders Be Blamed for Spending More than $20 Million of Bond Funds on the 16 Schools They’re Closing?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*dPOCO4DPkdiG_Uq9YzYbbg.jpeg" /></figure><p>During the meetings the Jefferson County Board of Education held with sixteen elementary schools that had been identified for closure, one angry question came up again and again: “If the district knew it was going to close our schools, why did you spend millions of bond funds upgrading it?”</p><p>The district has studiously avoided directly answering this question. Did this represent a gross management and governance failure, or was the fall in enrollment at these schools a “black swan” that could not have been foreseen?</p><p>A fair analysis begins with a look at the evidence that was available to Jeffco management and the Board of Education at various points in time.</p><p>Jeffco’s 2014/2015 “Facilities Condition Assessment” Report found that:</p><p>12 of 17 district-run high schools were operating at less than 80% capacity (the threshold many districts used to signify “low utilization), and 5 were operating at less than 65%</p><p>· 14 of 19 middle schools were operating at less than 80% capacity, and 7 were at less than 65%.</p><p>· 12 of 92 elementary schools (which housed students in kindergarten through sixth grade) were operating at less than 80%, and 2 at less than 65%.</p><p>In response to this, members of the Republican majority that then controlled the Jeffco Board of Education suggested that charter schools be encouraged to co-locate in underutilized middle schools, as had been done in Denver.</p><p>This was opposed the Democratic minority, which regained control of the Board in November 2015.</p><p>In 2016, the Jeffco Board of Education rejected the district’s proposal to consolidate 10 underutilized or old elementary schools into five new schools. Instead, it proposed a $568 million bond issue for school improvements and to build new schools. It was soundly defeated by a 54% to 46% margin.</p><p>The 2017/2018 Facility Condition Assessment Report found that:</p><ul><li>6 of 17 district-run high schools were operating at less than 80% capacity, and 2 were operating at less than 65%</li><li>2 newly created 7/12 schools (Alameda and Jefferson) were operating at less than 80% of capacity</li><li>12 middle schools were operating at less than 80% capacity, and 5 were at less than 65%</li><li>26 elementary schools were operating at less than 80%, and 8 at less than 65%.</li></ul><p>In 2017, the district proposed closing five elementary schools.</p><p>After public outcry, only one, Pleasant View, was closed, and its students sent to Shelton and Welchester elementary schools. Unfortunately, while Pleasant View was a Title 1 school with a high percentage of at-risk students, that was not true of either Shelton or Welchester. But the district did not make up the Title 1 funding loss by increasing either Shelton or Welchester’s budget.</p><p>After this painful experience, Superintendent Jason Glass unilaterally imposed a two-year moratorium on further school closings. At the same time, the Board of Education requested that Glass prepare a new District-Wide Facilities Master Plan, and deliver it to the Board.</p><p>This was never done — and the Board never complained.</p><p>Instead, to reduce middle school underutilization, the district proposed, and the Board approved, moving sixth graders out of elementary schools and into middle schools, <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0047272710000824">despite research that this could have negative impacts on their student achievement results</a>.</p><p>The district’s 2017/2018 Enrollment Projections Report found that over the previous five years, Jeffco’s district-operated neighborhood schools had lost 2,174 students. Over the next five years, the report forecast a further decline of 1,773 students.</p><p>As you can see below, by 2018 it was very clear that enrollment losses in Jeffco’s neighborhood schools had been ongoing since 2012, and were accelerating.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/855/1*5XL8g9oJeF7oKFmlsMflQw.png" /></figure><p>The 2018/2019 Facility Condition Assessment Report found that:</p><ul><li>9 of 17 district-run high schools were operating at less than 80% capacity, and 2 were operating at less than 65%</li><li>Both 7/12 schools (Alameda and Jefferson) were operating at less than 80% of capacity</li><li>8 middle schools were operating at less than 80% capacity</li><li>Following the move of 6th grade to middle school, 45 elementary schools were operating at less than 80%, and 20 at less than 65%.</li></ul><p>The 2018/2019 Enrollment Projections Report showed that over the previous five years, Jeffco’s neighborhood schools had lost 3,615 students. Yet over the next five years, they were projected to lose only 1,171.</p><p>Despite evidence of continued enrollment declines and worsening overcapacity, and even without a Facilities Master Plan to guide the proposed Capital Improvement Program, in 2018 Jeffco district management recommended, and on a 5–0 vote the Board of Education approved, putting a $567 million bond issue on the November 2018 ballot that included new investments in all district-run schools, along with a 10% allocation to charter schools.</p><p>In October 2018, all of Colorado Community Media’s Jeffco newspapers (e.g., the Arvada Press, Golden Transcript, Jeffco Transcript) ran this editorial endorsement:</p><p>“<em>We commend the district for listening to criticism from its failed bond attempt in 2016, which cited a lack of clarity in how the money would be used. This time, the district has prepared a detailed booklet and website of exactly where the money will go at each school… We also applaud the district’s commitment to transparency: A citizens financial oversight committee and independent audit of expenditures will make sure money from the measures is spent as intended.”</em></p><p>The district’s commitment to spend bond funds in every school was part of its strategy to pass the bond issue in the face of <a href="https://yourhub.denverpost.com/blog/2018/10/no-5a-5b-jeffco-empty-school-seats/228415/">opposition that noted extent of low capacity utilization and declining enrollment in many district-run schools.</a></p><p>The proposed bond issue only passed by a scant 1,286 votes — less than 1/2 of 1% of the total votes cast.</p><p>The 2019/2020 Facility Condition Assessment Report should have rung alarm bells for district management, the Capital Asset Advisory Committee, and the Board of Education about the wisdom of continuing to invest bond funds in schools with declining enrollment and worsening overcapacity.</p><ul><li>9 of 17 district-run high schools were operating at less than 80% capacity, and 2 were operating at less than 65%</li><li>Both 7/12 schools (Alameda and Jefferson) were operating at less than 80% of capacity</li><li>8 middle schools were operating at less than 80% capacity</li><li>Despite the move of 6th grade to middle school, 49 elementary schools were now operating at less than 80%, and 28 at less than 65% — a sharp increase over the previous year’s report.</li></ul><p>The Projected Enrollment Report also should have rung alarm bells:</p><ul><li>Over the next five years, district staff projected a further decline of 1,171 students in Jeffco’s neighborhood schools.</li><li>Much more worrisome was evidence of large and worsening errors in Jeffco’s five year enrollment projections.</li><li>Jeffco’s 2014 five-year enrollment projection had overestimated enrollment in district run schools by 4,170 students.</li><li>Jeffco’s 2015 five-year enrollment projection had overestimated enrollment in district run schools by 9,020 students.</li></ul><p>But no alarm bells were sounded, and Jeffco continued to invest millions in district-run neighborhood schools.</p><p>Even worse, there is <a href="https://improvejeffcoschools.org/index.php/2022/11/19/jeffco-staff-lied-to-boe-and-public-regarding-bond-money-put-into-closing-schools/">evidence that the district has not disclosed to the public an accurate total of the amount of bond funds that have been spent to improve the condition of the 16 elementary schools that will now be closed</a>.</p><p>And <a href="http://www.millerforjeffcostudents.com/page-2/page-9/">the Capital Improvement Program is now $173 million (and still counting) over budget, due to cost overruns and spending on projects that were never disclosed to the public (e.g., more than $50 million on athletic fields and facilities at affluent schools</a>).</p><p>Moreover, <a href="http://www.millerforjeffcostudents.com/resources/Moss-Adams-Report-on-Jeffco-Capital-Program.pdf">management and governance of the Capital Improvement Program was heavily criticized after an independent review by Moss Adams, the leading provider of school capital program audits in California, where they are required by law</a>.</p><p>To conclude, let’s go back to our original question:</p><p><em>Does the district’s decision to spend millions on 16 elementary schools that will be closed (and more schools that will almost certainly be closed next year) represent a gross failure of Jeffco’s management and governance, or was the fall in enrollment at these schools a “black swan” that could not have been foreseen?</em></p><p>The evidence leaves no room for argument.</p><p>But despite this, nothing has been done in Jeffco.</p><p>Millions of dollars continue to be spent on schools that will almost certainly be closed in next year’s round of consolidations, and none of the Moss Adams report’s recommendations for management and governance improvements have been implemented.</p><p>In Jeffco Schools, business as usual continues, and gross management and governance failures in the nation’s 39th largest school district, a $1.9 billion organization, remain unaddressed.</p><p><em>Tom Coyne is an executive at Britten Coyne Partners, and a former member of Jefferson County School District Accountability Committee. For more than 20 years, he has invested all his volunteer time in K-12 performance improvement, in New England, Alberta, and Colorado. He is married to Jeffco Public Schools Board Director Susan Miller. The opinions in this column Coyne’s alone.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=813ba00c73eb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It’s Time Again for State Assessment Turkey Bingo!]]></title>
            <link>https://tcoyne.medium.com/its-time-again-for-state-assessment-turkey-bingo-572f27e9caa2?source=rss-d4fb1d4bda4c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/572f27e9caa2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colorado]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Coyne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Aug 2022 19:30:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-15T19:30:05.470Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>With Colorado’s annual CMAS state assessment results being released this week, it’s time again for Turkey Bingo! How many of these spins will your district leaders use?</p><p>1) “Our district performed better than the state.” If your district has a lower percentage of at-risk students than the state, you bloody well should have better achievement proficiency results. But if you have a higher percentage, this really is something to celebrate — and for other districts to learn from.</p><p>2) “Our Median Growth Percentile is above 50, so our students got more than a year’s worth of learning.” This is a perennial favorite for district leaders, because so few parents understand the Colorado Growth Model (and so few district staff too).</p><p>MGP is a RELATIVE not an absolute measure. A student’s growth percentile reflects their achievement performance relative to other student who had the same starting score. A growth percentile &gt; 50 does not mean that a student met the state proficiency standard. If a student is in a group of other students who ended 2021 with the same low CMAS score (say in Math), scoring in the 60th percentile does not mean they got more than a year of growth. It only means that their CMAS results improved by more than half the students in their starting group. It does not mean they received “more than a year’s worth of learning.”</p><p>The Median Growth Percentile (MGP) is the Growth Percentile for the student in the middle of a given group (e.g., a grade or a school or the district). As <a href="http://millerforjeffcostudents.com/resources/Jeffco-Artic-Area-Achievement-Results3.pdf">this document </a>shows, there are lots of examples of schools with MGP &gt;50 where the percent of proficient students actually declines.</p><p>3) “You should trust your student’s grades, not their standardized test scores.” No, exactly the opposite. Why? Because grade inflation has increased over the past decade, and got much worse during COVID. For example, <a href="https://www.act.org/content/act/en/research/pdfs/R2134-Grade-Inflation-Continues-to-Grow-in-the-Past-Decade-Final-Accessible.html">see this analysis of grade inflation by ACT Inc.</a></p><p>4) “Our CMAS results show our learning losses were small.” Pure spin. In many districts, students who had low scores in 2019 did not take the 2022 CMAS. This imparted an upward bias to 2022 scores, and hid the true size of learning losses relative to 2019.</p><p>5) “We’re spending enough to recover our learning losses.” Your district almost certainly is not. <a href="https://edunomicslab.org/calculator/">Georgetown’s @EdunomicsLab has estimated how much your district needs to spend to get achievement results back to their 2019 level </a>(when many students weren’t proficient). Most districts are spending much less than this on initiatives to recover students’ learning losses. In fact, most district leaders cannot quantitatively explain why their mix of initiatives will recover students’ COVID learning losses, much less catch up to proficiency, <a href="https://www.act.org/content/dam/act/unsecured/documents/Catching-Up-To-College-and-Career-Readiness.pdf">which, as ACT research has shown, is extremely difficult</a>.</p><p>From what I’ve seen so far this year, I’m afraid that a depressing number of districts will score a five out of five on this assessment of their transparency.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=572f27e9caa2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Has Jeffco’s $705 Million Capital Program Really Spent $173 Million on Cost Overruns and…]]></title>
            <link>https://tcoyne.medium.com/has-jeffcos-705-million-capital-program-really-spent-173-million-on-cost-overruns-and-d6774647e95?source=rss-d4fb1d4bda4c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d6774647e95</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[k12]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colorado]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scandal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[project-management]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Coyne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Apr 2022 18:53:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-09T15:45:19.733Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Has Jeffco’s $705 Million Capital Program Really Spent $173 Million on Cost Overruns and Undisclosed Projects?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1004/1*1Kk8PjcvYyn4Q9vBYixzBA.png" /></figure><p>At last night’s Jeffco Schools Board meeting, Director Mary Parker tried to argue that Jeffco’s Capital Program was doing just fine, and that claims it had overspent by more than $170 million were false.</p><p>Let’s look more deeply at this claim.</p><p>In 2018, Jeffco voters were asked to approve the issuance of $567 million in bonds to fund a $705 million Capital Improvement Program (CIP). The remaining $138 million was to be provided by the annual transfer of $23 million to the district’s Capital Fund from its General Fund for six years.</p><p>Voters were issued a “Flipbook” which detailed how much of the $705 million would be spent at every school in the district. The total added up to $563 million. Of the remaining $142 million, $56 million was transferred to Charter Schools and $86 million was for “Program Contingency”.</p><p>The budget every project at a district run school contained a 10% “Project Contingency” for possible cost overruns. This is a normal contingency percentage for capital program projects (note, in the past I was the CEO of an engineering firm that constructed large units as part of new LNG projects around the world).</p><p>Jeffco’s “Program Contingency” was in theory an extra level of protection against cost overuns on individual projects over the six year life of the Capital Improvement Program. If a project had cost overruns in excess of its 10% Project Contingency, the excess would be charged to the CIP’s Program Contingency.</p><p>When they passed Prop 5B (by a scant 0.24% of the total votes cast), Jeffco voters approved a total amount of money that could be spent to repay bond principle and interest. Because interest rates dropped between when Prop 5B was approved in November 2018, and when Jeffco later issued bonds, it received more bond proceeds than $567 million. Specifically, it received an additional $118 million. This is known as “Bond Premium”.</p><p>As an aside, state laws treat bond premium differently. Some states don’t allow it, and require that, even if interest rates have declined, only the amount of bonds approved by the voters (i.e., $567 million) can be issued. Other states require that any bond premium be contributed to the debt service fund, which reduces the amount of taxes that must be imposed to repay bond principle and interest. Colorado has no such provisions, nor any laws that specify who must decide how the bond premium will be used (e.g., a school board).</p><p>Back to our story.</p><p>Following questioning by Jeffco Board Director Susan Miller, the district transferred about $12 million of bond premium to Charter Schools (technically, 11.8, given Charters’ 10% share).</p><p>Finally, Jeffco has earned $12 million in interest on bond proceeds.</p><p>So what was the total amount of money that Jeffco had available to spend on district-run schools?</p><ul><li>Start with the total $705 million Capital Program that was described to Jeffco voters when they approved Prop 5B ($567 million in bond funding, and $138 million in funding from transfers from the General Fund to the Capital Fund for six years).</li><li>Add to that $118 million in Bond Premium and $12 million in interest earnings.</li><li>That gives you $835 million to spend.</li><li>Of that, $56 million went to Charters from the Bond Proceeds, and a further $12 million from the Bond Premium (charters didn’t get any of the interest earnings.</li><li>That left $767 million for Jeffco to spend on district-run schools.</li></ul><p>Based on the latest district data, how much of that $767 million has not yet been spent or committed (including the $30 million plus that was recently set aside to cover anticipated cost increases driven by rapidly increasing inflation)?</p><ul><li><strong>An estimated $31 million.</strong></li><li>You read that right.</li><li>With three years still left on its six year Capital Improvement Program, Jeffco has already blown through through not only the 10% contingency on the projects it has completed, but also the $86 million in Program Contingency that was supposed to cover the full six year program, as well as nearly all the $130 million in Bond Premium and interest earnings it received.</li></ul><p>The original Capital Improvement Program budget presented to Jeffco voters in 2018 showed original project budgets totaling $563 million.</p><p><strong>Contrary to what Director Parker believes, Jeffco’s Capital Improvement Program really has spent or committed $173 million more that its original $563 million budget </strong>(767 minus 563 minus 31).</p><p>That is both shocking and depressing.</p><p>To be sure, some of the scheduled projects to which funds have been committed but not spent could be cancelled in the future, which would increase the amount of unspent funds. But given the information available today Parker’s claim is clearly wrong.</p><p>So where has $173 million gone? It appears to have disappeared down three holes:</p><ul><li><strong>The first hole was cost overruns</strong>. For example, the Alameda High School project had overruns of more than $10 million, or at least 70% of the original budget (it is hard to calculate the actual overrun, because Jeffco has started to spread Alameda costs across multiple projects — e.g., multischool constracts for asbestors removal and paving).</li><li>District management would like the public to believe that all these cost overruns were due to inflation. But CIP spending started in 2019, and inflation didn’t take off until this year (2022). Many times since 2018, Jeffco management has bragged to the Board and the Capital Asset Advisory Committee about the great pricing they were getting from suppliers in a market where construction labor and materials demand had been severely reduced by COVID (it’s all on the videos of Jeffco Board meetings). In point of fact, inflation is not the reason for all the cost overrns.</li><li>What then is? When she took over, new Superintendent Tracy Dorland ordered an independent review of the CIP by <a href="https://go.boarddocs.com/co/jeffco/Board.nsf/files/C8H2TP03C10D/$file/REPORT%20Moss%20Adams%20JPS%20Capital%20Improvement%20Program%20Evaluation.pdf">by Moss Adams</a>, which is a leading provider of Independent Performance Audits of school bond programs in California, where they are required by law.</li><li>Moss Adams findings (and note that they only did a review, not a more thorough performance audit, as they do in California) hint at some possible explanations for the CIP’s cost overruns.</li><li>For example, bids received by Jeffco for different CIP projects were not retained by the district (which is a legal requirement in other states), nor were the criteria used for the award of the bids specified. Moss Adams also found that on many projects the low bidder later submitted change orders (which raise the project cost if the district agrees to them) in amounts that were unusually high percentages of the original bid. All these change orders were approved by district management. In other cases, contractor bids came in well above Jeffco’s budgeted cost for projects.</li><li><strong>The second hole was spending on projects that had not been disclosed to the voters in the Flipbooks they received ahead of the November 2018 election</strong>. Perhaps the most egregious example was an estimated $50 million in spending on expensive new athletic fields and facilities for the districts’ affluent high schools.</li><li>Jeffco’s own polling ahead of the 2018 election showed that one of the reasons the 2016 bond election failed was because of the large amount of proposed spending on athletic fields. The poll found that these were voters’ top priorities for the proposed capital improvement program (source: “<a href="https://p12cdn4static.sharpschool.com/UserFiles/Servers/Server_627881/File/Jeffco%20PS/About%20Jeffco/Superintendent/FutureFunding/NSPRA%202019%20Gold%20Medallion%20Award%20Application%20-%20Jeffco%20Public%20Schools%20-%20Final.pdf"><em>2019 NSPRA Gold Medallion Entry Bond/Finance Campaign</em></a>” produced by Tammy Schiff, Communications Director for Jeffco Public Schools):</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/802/1*Dypdd1dTkq81cI9pwsbfng.png" /><figcaption>Findings from 2018 Jeffco Poll on Voters’ Capital Program Priorities</figcaption></figure><p>Defenders of Jeffco’s Capital Improvement Program (including some current and former Board members, who had a fiduciary duty of care to effectively oversee its activities) have lately taken to claiming that the original Flipbook distributed to voters in 2018 (and the displays in each district school showing how much Capital Program money would be spent on it) were “just marketing documents” that didn’t provide the full picture of all the projects on which money would be spent.</p><p>There are two responses to this:</p><p>If that was the case, then why did the budgets for the projects in the original flip book add up to $563 million?</p><p>Second, the claim is contradicted by Jeffco’s “<a href="https://p12cdn4static.sharpschool.com/UserFiles/Servers/Server_627881/File/Jeffco%20PS/About%20Jeffco/Superintendent/FutureFunding/NSPRA%202019%20Gold%20Medallion%20Award%20Application%20-%20Jeffco%20Public%20Schools%20-%20Final.pdf">Gold Medallion” entry </a>to the National School Public Relations Association’s contest for best 2018 Bond/Financing Capaign, which includes these statements:</p><ul><li><em>“The flipbook…summarized what every school was going to receive in terms of renovations or new construction from the bond program”.</em></li><li><em>“In all, we estimate over 150 “Mill Levy and Bond Factual Information” presentations where made morning, noon and night over the eleven weeks between the board vote to approve the questions and election night. These presentations were fact-based.”</em></li><li><em>“The efforts to build a collection of targeted, transparent, and comprehensive materials positioned the district as a trustworthy resource of election information — the published and online materials became the “truth” all supporters referenced, the schools’ and district’s community outreach efforts spoke those truths, and the community responded positively.”</em></li></ul><p><strong>The third hole was overstatement of the actual size of the transfers from the General Account to the Capital Account.</strong></p><ul><li>The $23 million/year for six years failed to deduct $2 million per year from the Capital Account that was already committed to repay Certificates of Participation (COPS) that were issued in the past to pay for the construction of new schools.</li><li>The annual capital transfer was further reduced by an additional $2.5 million, which is the amount that will be deducted from the Capital Account over the next three years of the Capital Improvement Program for payments related to Jeffco’s decision to pay for half the construction cost of a new “Olympic Natatorium” for the City of Arvada. The district will not end up with any ownership interest in this facility, which is a scandal in itself (for more on this, <a href="https://tcoyne.medium.com/using-17m-in-jefferson-county-school-funds-to-build-an-olympic-natatorium-for-the-city-of-arvada-586a50b77da">see my article here</a>).</li><li>Thus, $4.5 million of the planned $6 million annual transfer from the General Fund to the Capital Fund will not be available to pay for the Capital Program, as Prop 5B voters were originally told in 2018. The missing money must come out of bond premium.</li></ul><p>There is one final outrage related to Jeffco’s Capital Improvement Program that should not be overlooked. In other Colorado school districts, the Board of Education decides how bond premium should be spent. But not in Jeffco, where the Chief Operating Officer and district facilities management team made these decisions.</p><p>There were plenty of worthwhile district projects that could have been built with Bond Premium funds.</p><p>For example, Fletcher Miller School is Jeffco’s facility for severely disabled children. Today, it is in decrepit condition, and badly in need of replacement. That would have been a great use for bond premium funds.</p><p>Another possible use of bond premium funds (and another scandal in itself) would have been to construct new elementary schools to facilitiate the closure and consolidation of Jeffco’s large number of schools that are operating far below their capacity (which drives up district costs). Jeffco’s enrollment has been declining for years:</p><ul><li>In 2011/12, Jeffco enrolled 78,997 non-charter students. Overall capacity utilization of district-run schools was 83%. District projections forecast declining student enrollment in future years.</li><li>At the 10 January 2011 board meeting, district staff recommended closing 10 elementary schools: Campbell, Glennon Heights, Kullerstrand, Parr, Pleasant View, Red Rocks, Martensen, Stober, Thompson, and Zerger. Since then, only two of these have been closed (Martensen and Zerger). Pleasant View was briefly closed (and its students sent to Welchester and Shelton), then quickly reopened to accomodate a charter that had agreed to convert to Innovation status and become a district-run school.</li><li>In 2014/15, Jeffco had three schools operating at less than or equal to 50% Capacity Utilization, a cumulative six schools at 60% or less, and twelve at 65% or less. Moreover, the district forecasted continuing enrollment declines in district-run schools.</li><li>At the time of the Prop 5B Bond Election in November 2018, 16 schools were operating at less than or equal to 65% capacity utilization, which is the district’s standard for “Low Utilization” schools. Yet the Capital Program included no provision for constructing larger and more efficient new elementary schools to facilitate the closure and consolidation of the districts’ small, underutilized, and inefficent schools.</li><li>Since Prop 5B was passed, capacity utilization has continued to worsen. by 2020/21, Jeffco had 12 schools operating at less than or equal to 50% capacity utilization, 32 at or below 60%, 50 at or below 65%, and a whopping 87 below the industry standard for low utilization, which is 80% or less of capacity.</li><li>Since January 2011, only four elementary schools have closed, even as enrollment in district-run schools fell by 8,376 students between 2011/12 and 2020/21 (to 70,621students). Overall capacity utilization of district run schools fell over this period from 83% to 72%, in part because, despite falling enrollment, Jeffco kept building new schools!</li><li>Millions of dollars in Capital Program funds have been spent on schools that district management knew, or should have known, were destined to close (note that since 2011 Jeffco’s annual enrollment projections, which are publicly available, have continued to forecast a falling number of students in district-run schools).</li></ul><p>A fair and painful question to ask — which must be answered — is how could this excess spending happen, in spite of all the checks and balances and controls that the district claimed were in place. These include:</p><ul><li>Jeffco’s Facilities Management Group, which managed the CIP;</li><li>Jeffco’s Chief Operating Officer, to whom Facilities reports;</li><li>Jeffco’s Internal Audit group;</li><li>Jeffco’s Chief Financial Officer;</li><li>Jeffco’s Superintendent (i.e., Chief Executive Officer);</li><li>Jeffco’s Citizen Capital Asset Advisory Committee (the ‘independent citizens committee” that former Superintendent Jason Glass assured voters would review all CIP spending);</li><li>Jeffco’s Financial Oversight Committee (which provides, among other things, independent oversight over the district’s internal controls);</li><li>Jeffco’s external auditor, Clifton Larson Allen;</li><li>Jeffco’s Board and Directors;</li><li>And last but not least, the Jeffco, Colorado, and national K-12 media, some of whom have been aware of this story for a long time (to its credit, the Jeffco Transcript did attempt an investigative series, but it was inexplicably cut short). As investigative reporting into the failure of Colorado’s READ Act by Chalkbeat Colorado’s Ann Schimke has shown, the K-12 media can play a critical role in improving district performance when it chooses to do so.</li></ul><p>To be sure, Jeffco isn’t the only district where massive cost overuns have occured on school bond programs. For example, that is why California changed its state constitution to requite annual independent performance audits (not just financial audits) of all bond-funded school capital programs.</p><p>But that doesn’t excuse all the apparent failures that have allowed it to happen here too.</p><p>At this point, the most important questions are whether anyone will be held accountable for this debacle, and whether anything will change.</p><p>The fact that the key players are still employed by Jeffco, and that neither district management nor a majority of the school board has yet to take any action to implement the recommendations in the Moss Adams report provides — for now at least — the depressing answer.</p><p><em>Tom Coyne is a business executive, former member of the Jeffco District Accountability Committee, and former Chair of the Wheat Ridge High School Accountability Committee. His wife, Susan Miller, was elected to the Jeffco Board of Education in November 2019. These are solely Coyne’s views.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d6774647e95" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Another Devastating Independent Report on the Causes of Poor Achievement Results in Jeffco Schools]]></title>
            <link>https://tcoyne.medium.com/another-devastating-independent-report-on-the-causes-of-poor-achievement-results-in-jeffco-schools-da826bb46290?source=rss-d4fb1d4bda4c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/da826bb46290</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[schools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colorado]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[k12-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education-reform]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Coyne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 10 Nov 2021 16:20:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-10T16:20:30.253Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/508/1*TEiaGRWRRCO8SopP0BSEdQ.png" /></figure><p>Educated, affluent Jefferson County, Colorado is a suburb located West of Denver. Jeffco Schools is the nation’s 37th largest school district, serving 80,000 students with an annual budget of $1.4 billion.</p><p>New Superintendent Tracy Dorland commissioned an independent investigation into Jeffco’s poor and declining student achievement results.</p><p>It’s finding are devastating:</p><p>“Declining student achievement rates from 2017 on, in both math and reading. Additional impacts…from the pandemic.”</p><p>“There is a lack of shared understanding of the district’s strategic direction, thus creating a system that lacks coherence.”</p><p>“There is a lack of a clear and coherent communications protocol to ensure that strategies and decisions related to curriculum and instruction are relayed to, and understood by schools.”</p><p>“There is lack of system coherence between and among schools due to a culture that values autonomy without accountability.”</p><p>“There appears to be an insufficient sense of urgency regarding improving achievement for ALL students, and special attention needs to be paid to students who have historically under-performed.”</p><p>“The EdCenter [central district office] is not set up to support schools and teaching and learning.”</p><p>“There is no systematic approach to identify, execute, and monitor strategies aimed at driving academic improvement.”</p><p>“Improvement strategies and their expected outcomes are often undefined or poorly defined. The review found no evidence that the District routinely uses data to evaluate the effectiveness of the strategies it has implemented.”</p><p>“There is an absence of shared understanding of [state] standards throughout the system. Lessons do not appear to be aligned to state standards.”</p><p>“The review found a prevalent lack of rigor throughout the District…The item on the student survey that receives the lowest rating is students feeling academically challenged.”</p><p>“The review found that the District seems to pay more attention to operational issues over improving student learning.”</p><p>“The deficiencies of instructional coherence have led to a weak and disjointed instructional program that does not appear to give all students access to a guaranteed and viable standards-based curriculum.”</p><p>There is a lack of trust throughout the district.”</p><p>“A recurring theme that surfaced during [our] interviews was that the district, as a system, appears to make decisions that are not always… in the best interest of students.”</p><p>“There is a lack of collective responsibility for students with IEPs and those learning English as a second language.”</p><p>“There is a lack of cohesion and alignment among the departments at the Ed Center [the district’s central office].”</p><p>“The District has granted schools the autonomy to select their own instructional programs. Consequently,</p><p>curriculum programs vary greatly across content areas and grade levels.”</p><p>“The deficiencies of instructional coherence have led to a weak and disjointed instructional program that does not appear to give all students access to a guaranteed and viable standards-based curriculum.”</p><p>“The District lacks systems to hold its staff accountable for their accomplishment of identified goals, including any clear systems for monitoring and reporting progress.”</p><p>“Goals are set, but there is no clear mechanism to provide the community, or the schools, with the data necessary for evaluating the progress of initiatives or the system as a whole.”</p><p>“There is a lack of a coherent approach to professional learning that is provided consistently across the system.”</p><p>“There is apparent variability in the processes used for hiring for central and school leader positions.”</p><p>You can read the Board presentation here:</p><p><a href="https://go.boarddocs.com/co/jeffco/Board.nsf/files/C8M5LW10D398/$file/PRESENTATION%20Review%20of%20Academic%20Functions%2011.10.21rev.pdf">https://go.boarddocs.com/co/jeffco/Board.nsf/files/C8M5LW10D398/$file/PRESENTATION%20Review%20of%20Academic%20Functions%2011.10.21rev.pdf</a></p><p>What is particularly depressing is that the findings in this report are very similar to those in another independent investigation into Jeffco’s poor academic performance that was delivered to the Jeffco Board of Education in November 2017.</p><p>Jeffco’s culture is very insular and extremely resistant to change. If Superintendent Dorland is to substantially improve the district’s academic performance, a few tweaks here and there won’t do. Jeffco is in desperate need of a fundamental turnaround, that involves many difficult changes in its processes, systems, organizational structure — and some of its people.</p><p>Successful turnarounds require tough minded leadership, and a supportive board. Whether Jeffco can muster that remains to be seen.</p><p>But one thing is certain: If Dorland fails to turnaround the district, 80,000 children will lack the knowledge and skill they will need to survive and thrive in the 21st century economy.</p><p>You can read the DeliverEd report here:</p><p><a href="http://k12accountability.org/resources/Jeffco-School-Reports/Deliver-Ed-final-report.pdf">http://k12accountability.org/resources/Jeffco-School-Reports/Deliver-Ed-final-report.pdf</a></p><p><em>Tom Coyne is a Democrat and business executive. He is a former member of the Jeffco District Accountability Committee and former chair of the Wheat Ridge High School Accountability Committee. His wife, Susan Miller, was elected to the Jeffco Board of Education in November 2019. These are solely his views.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=da826bb46290" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why “We Need Teachers on the School Board” is a Dangerous Fallacy]]></title>
            <link>https://tcoyne.medium.com/why-we-need-teachers-on-the-school-board-is-a-fallacy-c51d38724291?source=rss-d4fb1d4bda4c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c51d38724291</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-of-directors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colorado]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Coyne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Oct 2021 15:05:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-18T15:05:37.105Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/747/1*LI2yBL62b5JOiZ2NaD3I-Q.png" /></figure><p>At every school board election, teachers unions and their allies tell voters that, “we need teachers on the school board.” Just as predictably, the candidates unions endorse are often former teachers, parents or spouses of teachers, or members of advocacy groups that are teachers union allies.</p><p>But is this claim valid? Do we really need teachers on the school board? Let’s take a deeper look at it.</p><p>I’ll begin with a critical point that is often either overlooked or misunderstood: Governance is not management.</p><p>Governance has been defined as “the set of responsibilities and practices exercised by the board with the goal of providing strategic direction, ensuring that objectives are achieved, ascertaining that risks are managed appropriately, and verifying that the organization’s resources are used responsibly.”</p><p>The fundamental governance duties of board directors are summed up in their duty of care and their duty of loyalty.</p><p>One definition of the duty of care is that it is “a requirement that a person act toward others and the public with the watchfulness, attention, caution and prudence that a reasonable person in the circumstances would use”. The duyt of care can be further unpacked into a director’s five core responsibilities:</p><ul><li>To set the critical goals an organization must achieve to survive and thrive, and examine and approve management’s strategy to meet them;</li><li>To ensure that the allocation and organization of human, financial, technical, and other resources is consistent with the strategy;</li><li>To ensure that management is mitigating and managing critical risks to the achievement of the organization’s goals;</li><li>To hire, coach, and evaluate the performance of the organization’s leader (whether a Superintendent or CEO);</li><li>To ensure that the organization’s results are fully and accurately reported to multiple stakeholders (e.g., parents, the broader public, regulators, bond investors, etc.).</li></ul><p>It is very hard to see how the knowledge, skills, and experience required to become an effective classroom teacher equips a person to be an effective board director of a school district, especially a large, complex school district.</p><p>Let’s look at a specific example.</p><p>Located in Denver’s western suburbs, Jefferson County, Colorado is the nation’s 37th largest school district, serving more than 80,000 students through more than 150 schools over a district covering 774 square miles. Jeffco employs more than 12,000 people and has an annual operating budget of $1.4 billion dollars.</p><p>Consider just a few of the complex issues that the Jeffco Board of Education has recently faced:</p><ul><li>The district’s $705 million, six year Capital Improvement Program is <a href="https://tcoyne.medium.com/jeffco-schools-out-of-control-705-million-capital-program-the-scandal-has-widened-and-worsened-36a06bf2e6e6">more than $100 million over budget</a> after just three years, due to a combination of cost overruns and spending on projects that were not disclosed to voters during the 2018 bond campaign.</li><li>The board must decide on <a href="https://tcoyne.medium.com/using-17m-in-jefferson-county-school-funds-to-build-an-olympic-natatorium-for-the-city-of-arvada-586a50b77da">a proposal</a> to spend more than $30 million of district funds on a new Olympic quality natatorium (i.e., a large fancy swimming facility) for one city in the district. Funding would come from Certificates of Participation, repayment of which would take money out of classrooms from across the district. While some, but not all district swim teams could practice at the new pool, it would mostly be used by residents of the city in which it is built. This would also set a precedent why which other Jeffco cities and Recreation Districts (and perhaps libraries) would logically demand that the school district fund their future capital projects.</li><li>Jeffco’s Career and Technical Education programs are weak, and its relationships with employers poor, particularly in comparison to nearby Denver Public Schools award-winning “Career Connect” CTE program. The school board must evaluate a range of proposals for improving Jeffco’s CTE programs and employer relationships.</li><li>Like other districts across the country, the pandemic has confronted Jeffco with a very different clinical mix and scale of student mental health needs. Management has yet to deliver to the board options for efficiently obtaining and effectively providing the mix of clinical mental health skills needed to address these needs.</li><li>The pandemic has also confronted Jeffco with the need to substantially revamp its technology strategy. Once again, the board will have to evaluate and decide from a range of options for achieving a complex mix of new technology goals.</li><li>COVID also made the shortcomings of Jeffco’s management of strategic risks painfully clear. Like other districts, it wasn’t prepared, despite years of warning from multiple sources about the possibility of a pandemic caused by a severe respiratory virus. The board must evaluate the root causes of this failure, and choose between a range of options for substantially improving the district’s risk management performance.</li><li>Even before the pandemic arrived, Jeffco was already losing students because of an accelerating decline in its student achievement results. Those losses are now increasing, which will soon confront board directors with an urgent need to take an in-depth look at how effectively and efficiently the district is spending its $1.4 billion budget.</li></ul><p>The presence of teachers on a school board also raises questions regarding directors’ duty of loyalty. This requires a director to act at all times in the best interests of their organization, and not their own or any other organization’s best interest. Here are some examples of potential conflicts facing teachers on school boards:</p><ul><li>According to the latest data from the US Department of Education’s Civil Rights Division, 1,219 out of Jeffco’s 4,987 teachers (24%) use more than 10 personal and sick days during their 187-day contract year. Ten days of absence is the point at which research has found significant negative impacts on student achievement appear. It beggars belief that teachers or union allies on a school board are going to raise, much less try to address this issue. The same goes for taking steps to get poor teachers out of district classrooms.</li><li>The underlying principle at work is the same one we have seen on other school boards during the pandemic — Teachers’ interests have taken precedence. COVID is a wicked problem that has confronted school boards with difficult decisions that involve tradeoffs between conflicting goals, like minimizing the risk of infection, minimizing students’ learning losses, and minimizing the loss of mothers’ jobs due to their need to stay at home with children learning remotely. Too many school boards dominated by teachers’ interests have focused only on the first goal, and neglected the enormous costs associated with failing to meet the other two.</li><li>Another painful issue is declining student achievement results. For example, in 2019 54% of Jeffco’s third graders did not meet state ELA standards, 65% of sixth graders failed to meet state math standards, 62% of eighth graders didn’t meet state science standards, and SAT scores were falling. COVID has made these problems much worse. And as you can see in the table below, there were also serious equity issues:</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/585/1*DqNP6rTR-Uinp-hopuWOrQ.png" /></figure><ul><li>Regardless of these results, teachers union backed board directors in Jeffco have continued to support substantial pay increases for teachers.</li><li>In the face of accelerating student achievement declines, in reading, writing, math, and science, both in Jeffco and across the country, school board directors beholden to the teachers union have repeatedly proved themselves unwilling to seriously seek out the root causes of these declines, much less consider what must be done to remedy them (e.g., reducing teacher absences, getting weak teachers out of the classroom, improving the quality and consistency of curriculum, instructional materials, and professional development, etc.).</li><li>Instead, too many union-backed school board directors have attacked any assessment that highlights poor district achievement results, prefering instead to focus on teacher assigned grades, regardless of widespread evidence of grade inflation in recent years. Union allies have also sought to to shift the very purpose of K-12 education away from academics to an equal focus on students’ “social and emotional health” (see Robert Pondiscio’s recent analysis of this issue, “<a href="https://www.aei.org/research-products/report/the-unexamined-rise-of-therapeutic-education-how-social-emotional-learning-extends-k-12-educations-reach-into-students-lives-and-expands-teachers-roles/">The Unexamined Rise of Therapeutic Education: How social-emotional learning extends K–12 education’s reach into students’ lives and expands teachers’ roles</a>”).</li></ul><p>In sum, teachers on school boards, especially in large, complex districts, usually lack the knowledge, skills, and experience needed to effectively carry out their fiduciary duty of care.</p><p>Just as important, teachers and other union-backed school board directors face significant conflicts of interest in the exercise of their fiduciary duty of loyalty.</p><p>For both reasons, the claim that “we need teachers on school boards” is a dangerous fallacy.</p><p><em>Tom Coyne is a Democrat and business executive. He is a former member of the Jeffco District Accountability Committee and former chair of the Wheat Ridge High School Accountability Committee, and has </em><a href="https://fordhaminstitute.org/national/commentary/weak-board-governance-weakens-k-12-performance"><em>previously written about weak school board governance</em></a><em>. His wife, Susan Miller, was elected to the Jeffco Board of Education in November 2019. These are solely his views.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c51d38724291" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Por qué voy a votar por Jeff Wilhite, Theresa Shelton y Kathy Miks para la Junta Escolar de Jeffco]]></title>
            <link>https://tcoyne.medium.com/wpor-qu%C3%A9-voy-a-votar-por-jeff-wilhite-theresa-shelton-y-kathy-miks-para-la-junta-escolar-de-jeffco-cda1a386b8b1?source=rss-d4fb1d4bda4c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cda1a386b8b1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[k12]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colorado]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[school-board]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Coyne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Oct 2021 01:37:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-18T01:37:24.413Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FvW5R6OQ__aQFQbnK8mnuQ.png" /></figure><p>Nuestra nueva superintendente Tracy Dorland ha anunciado la ambiciosa meta de convertir una vez más las escuelas de Jeffco en uno de los distritos de mayor rendimiento en la nación. Pero fracasará sin una Junta de Educación profesional y competente que apoye sus esfuerzos.</p><p>Yo apoyo fuertemente la elección de Jeff Wilhite, Theresa Shelton y Kathy Miks, tres candidatos pragmáticos y centristas con experiencia sustancial en administración y gobierno, para la Junta de Educación de Jeffco.</p><p>Estoy de acuerdo con ellos en tres cuestiones fundamentales.</p><p><strong>Mejorando el rendimiento de los estudiantes</strong></p><p>En Jeffco, rico y educado, los resultados de rendimiento de los estudiantes han sido sorprendentemente pobres durante demasiado tiempo.</p><p>En 2019, antes de la llegada de COVID, el 54% de los estudiantes de tercer grado de Jeffco no cumplió con los estándares de lectura del estado, el 65% de los estudiantes de sexto grado no cumplió con los estándares de matemáticas del estado, el 62% de los estudiantes de octavo grado no cumplió con los estándares de ciencias del estado y los puntajes del SAT fueron cayendo tanto en leyendo y escribiendo como en matemáticas.</p><p>Las pérdidas de aprendizaje de COVID han empeorado mucho esta situación.</p><p>Aún más deprimente, como puede ver en la tabla a continuación, existe una fuerte evidencia de que una vez que los estudiantes se retrasan en Jeffco, pocos de ellos alcanzan el nivel de competencia. ¡En matemáticas, los resultados de muchos estudiantes empeoran con el tiempo!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/541/1*NewkroOpjVuVclaORlUMoQ.png" /></figure><p>Wilhite, Shelton y Miks están firmemente comprometidos a mejorar sustancialmente los resultados de rendimiento de los estudiantes de Jeffco.</p><p>En contraste, los candidatos respaldados por el sindicato de maestros (Parker, Reed y Varda) han minimizado los problemas de rendimiento de los estudiantes de Jeffco, y Reed llegó a decir (en el reciente foro de candidatos celebrado en Pomona High School) que, “Resultados de las pruebas no son un indicador de éxito o fracaso “.</p><p><strong>Mejora de la gestión financiera</strong></p><p>Es dolorosamente claro que la gestión financiera de Jeffco necesita una mejora sustancial.</p><p>Después de solo tres de los seis años previstos, el Programa de Mejora de Capital de $ 705 millones de Jeffco está más de $ 100 millones por encima del presupuesto debido a costos excesivos sustanciales y gastos en proyectos (como campos deportivos para escuelas pudientes) que nunca fueron revelados a los votantes durante el bono de la Prop 5B elección que fue aprobada por muy poco en 2018.</p><p>Wilhite renunció al Comité Asesor de Activos de Capital del distrito en protesta por la mala gestión y gobernanza del Programa de Capital.</p><p>El presupuesto operativo de Jeffco también está fuera de control.</p><p>Si bien tanto los resultados de rendimiento como la cantidad de estudiantes en las escuelas administradas por el distrito han disminuido, desde 2017 Jeffco ha agregado 338 empleados en la oficina central y aumentó los costos de la oficina central en $ 48 millones, a $ 267 millones en el presupuesto 2020/21.</p><p>A diferencia de las mejores prácticas en otras organizaciones de miles de millones de dólares, el proceso de presupuestación anual de Jeffco se enfoca solo en cómo asignar cambios incrementales en los ingresos, en lugar de cuán efectiva y eficientemente se gasta todo el presupuesto de $ 1.4 mil millones de dólares.</p><p>Wilhite, Shelton y Miks tienen una sólida experiencia en gestión financiera (por ejemplo, Wilhite en préstamos para la construcción, Shelton como CPA y Miks liderando programas importantes en grandes empresas). Se han comprometido a proporcionar una supervisión mucho más sólida sobre el Programa de Mejoras de Capital de Jeffco y a llevar las mejores prácticas al proceso presupuestario anual del distrito.</p><p>En contraste, los comentarios de los candidatos respaldados por el sindicato Parker, Reed y Varda sobre el presupuesto de Jeffco se enfocan en obtener más dinero del estado para pagar más a los maestros. Como era de esperar, cada uno de ellos también tiene uno o más miembros de la familia que son maestros de Jeffco.</p><p><strong>Apoyo para la elección de los padres bien informados</strong></p><p>Más del 40% de los padres de Jeffco ejercen su elección de escuela enviando a sus hijos a otro lugar que no sea la escuela de su vecindario asignada por el distrito. Lo hacen por muchas razones, incluida la búsqueda de programas que se adapten mejor a las necesidades de sus hijos o la búsqueda de escuelas con mejores resultados académicos.</p><p>Wilhite, Shelton y Miks apoyan el suministro de más datos a los padres para permitirles tomar decisiones mejor informadas para la educación de sus hijos.</p><p>Por el contrario, en el reciente foro de candidatos del Consorcio de Escuelas Autónomas de Jefferson, Parker, Reed y Varda dijeron que no aprobarían ninguna escuela autónoma nueva (incluso aquellas con programas especializados, por ejemplo para estudiantes con espectro autista) si esto reduciría la inscripción en cualquier escuela administrada por el distrito, independientemente del desempeño de los últimos.</p><p>Dado que la inscripción de estudiantes en las escuelas administradas por el distrito de Jeffco ya está disminuyendo (a un ritmo acelerado), esto equivale a una prohibición de la expansión de las escuelas autónomas (y tal vez otras formas de elección) si son elegidos para la junta.</p><p>Por primera vez desde que nos mudamos a Colorado en 2010, los votantes de Jeff Wilhite, Theresa Shelton y Kathy Mix finalmente tienen una seria oportunidad de votar por candidatos que puedan revertir el largo declive de las escuelas públicas de Jeffco.</p><p>Además, Kathy Mix sería la primera latina elegida para la Junta Escolar de Jeffco.</p><p>Cuando reciba su boleta, vote por estos candidatos a la Junta de Educación como si el futuro de sus hijos o nietos dependiera del resultado de esta elección.</p><p>Porque esta vez realmente lo hace.</p><p><em>Tom Coyne es un Demócrata y ejecutivo de negocios. Él es un ex miembro del Comité de Responsabilidad del Distrito de Jeffco y ex presidente del Comité de Responsabilidad de Wheat Ridge High School. Su esposa, Susan Miller, fue elegida miembro de la Junta Escolar de Jeffco en Noviembre de 2019. Estos son únicamente sus puntos de vista.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cda1a386b8b1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[14 Years of Reported Root Causes of Poor Achievement in Jeffco Schools — Updated inOctober 2023]]></title>
            <link>https://tcoyne.medium.com/12-years-of-reported-root-causes-of-poor-achievement-in-jeffco-schools-80d2078b9f7e?source=rss-d4fb1d4bda4c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/80d2078b9f7e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[performance-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[k12]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colorado]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tom Coyne]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 Oct 2021 14:06:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-03T21:24:41.105Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/389/1*hQCeFc1SJ__U_ZLZJA4gTw.png" /><figcaption>Colorado Unified Improvement Planning Process</figcaption></figure><p>Since the 1950s, organizations around the world have used a systematic performance improvement process that is frequently attributed to W. Edwards Deming and Toyota Motor Company. Its four steps are summarized as “Plan”, “Do”, “Study”, and “Act”.</p><p>In the study step, the root causes of shortfalls between intended and actual results are identified, using <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Root_cause_analysis">a variety of techniques</a>. Plans are then designed and implemented to address these root causes.</p><p>Since the 2010, Colorado school districts have been required to annually prepare “<a href="https://www.cde.state.co.us/uip">unified improvement plans</a>” that include the identification of the root causes of their achievement shortfalls, along with “major improvement strategies” to address them.</p><p>The UIP process is a version of the familiar Deming process that has driven performance improvement in thousands of organizations for the past seventy years. Yet in Jefferson County Public Schools (and arguably across multiple Colorado school districts) it has singularly failed to produce substantial improvement in student achievement results, which have in fact declined.</p><p>For example, in 2015, 58% of Jeffco 6th graders failed to meet state math standards; in 2019 this rose to 65%. By 2023, this had further worsened, to 68%.</p><p>Similarly, in 2015 56%of Jeffco 8th graders failed to meet state science standards; in 2019, this rose to 62%. In 2023, it was 63%.</p><p>What are the root causes of these shockingly poor results in affluent, educated Jefferson County, where 48% of adults 25 or older have a bachelors degree or higher?</p><p>In the context of the UIP process, there are three possible answers:</p><ul><li>The root causes that were identified were not the most important root causes;</li><li>The major improvement strategies identified to address the root causes were incorrect (e.g., not based on strong research evidence);</li><li>The major improvement strategies were poorly implemented.</li></ul><p>This column kicks off a new series that will address these questions.</p><p>I’ll begin with a list of all the root causes that were contained in the Unified Improvement Plans that Jeffco Public Schools has submitted to the Colorado Department of Education since the 2010/2011 school year.</p><p><strong>2010/11 UIP (Cindy Stevenson, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>· “Schools lack district-wide formative and benchmark progress monitoring tools in writing to calibrate the fidelity of implementation of the district writing curriculum.”</p><p>· “Students needing to catch-up do not receive quality and/or adequate time for universal/core instruction in addition to effective, aligned targeted/intensive interventions.”</p><p>· “Many secondary schools do not have a systematic, tiered system of support to respond to the needs of catch-up students.”</p><p>· “The district has not strategically resource mapped and allocated resources differently among schools to better meet the needs of catch-up students.”</p><p><strong>2011/12 UIP (Cindy Stevenson, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>· “Schools lack district-wide formative and benchmark progress monitoring tools in writing to calibrate the fidelity of implementation of the district writing curriculum.”</p><p>· “Teaching and learning have not consistently demanded high expectations in every classroom due to superficial coverage of a large number of standards, lack of understanding of grade level mastery, lack of relevance for students, and lack of systemic progress monitoring.”</p><p>· “Educators lack consistently rigorous, growth-producing feedback through the evaluation process.”</p><p>· “The district is not meeting the state expectation of 100% highly qualified teachers…because an effective monitoring system is not in place for existing staff especially for secondary schools.”</p><p><strong>2012/13 UIP (Cindy Stevenson, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>· “The district lacks systemic practices in writing instruction and effective feedback in every classroom.”</p><p>· “The district lacks structures to ensure consistent quality of professional development is provided to all instructional staff.”</p><p>· “District and school leadership lack systemic understanding around multiple pathways for students to stay on track to graduate.”</p><p><strong>2013/14 UIP (Cindy Stevenson, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>· “Systemic implementation of intentional lesson design to engage students’ conceptual understanding of their learning and increase student cognitive load is not evident in all classrooms.”</p><p>· “Educators have received inconsistent training on effective literacy instruction and the use of research-based resources”</p><p>· “Math instruction tends not to be differentiated, lacking a variety of structures to meet students’ needs”</p><p><strong>2014/15 UIP — Note: this is not a typo. The 2014/15 UIP repeats the same root causes as 13/14 because this was the year the state transitioned from TCAP to CMAS.</strong></p><p>· “Systemic implementation of intentional lesson design to engage students’ conceptual understanding of their learning and increase student cognitive load is not evident in all classrooms.”</p><p>· “Educators have received inconsistent training on effective literacy instruction and the use of research-based resources”</p><p>· “Math instruction tends not to be differentiated, lacking a variety of structures to meet students’ needs”</p><p><strong>2015/16 UIP (Dan McMinimee, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>· “There is a need for implementation across the district of systemic evidence-based instructional practices that promote learning of rigorous literacy skills and competencies to ensure every student can “read to learn” by the end of third grade.”</p><p>· “There is a need for implementation across the district of vertical alignment (PK through 12th) and interdependence of math concept development that leads to successful learning in algebraic thinking…There is a need across the district for systemic classroom-based instruction, assessment and grading practices throughout the elementary and middle years that focuson higher level math concepts and procedures.”</p><p>· “Core instruction in academics, and social and emotional skill development must meet the needs of all students in achieving the performance expectations that will prepare them each step in their chosen learning pathway to successful completion of a Jeffco education.”</p><p><strong>2016/17 UIP (Dan McMinimee, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>· “In many schools, there is a lack of systemic evidence-based instructional practices that promote learning of rigorous literacy skills and competencies to ensure every student can “read to learn” by the end of third grade…For many students, the various literacy interventions are not specifically matched to student learning needs and may create additional barriers to learning rather than supporting literacy growth…Evidence indicates that current professional development in standards/competency-based core instructional strategies and learning supports has had limited impact on the effectiveness of high level literacy practices and matching interventions to student needs…Evidence indicates that current professional development and resource allocation for literacy instruction has had limited impact on desired increases in student performance.”</p><p>· “In many schools, there is a lack of systemic classroom-based instruction, assessment, and grading practices throughout the elementary and middle years that focus on higher level math concepts and procedures leading to algebraic thinking…In many schools, there is a lack of systemic classroom-based practices that require application and transfer of higher order algebraic thinking to meaningful/relevant real world problems and contexts…There is a lack of understanding across the system of vertical alignment (PK through 12th) and interdependence of math concept development that leads to successful learning and algebraic thinking…There is a lack of commitment across the system to ensure consistent differentiated teaching and learning practices matched to student needs.”</p><p>· “There is a need across the district for a system-wide commitment to ensure classroom practices and programming choices that provide every student with the opportunity to successfully complete a Jeffco educational pathway…There is a need across the district for a clear understanding among students and staff of the most critical performance expectations to achieve in order to be prepared for each student’s learning pathway…The allocation (or reallocation) of resources and supports to meet students’ social, emotional, engagement, and advancement needs are not addressing barriers to learning for all students (including students with educational plans).”</p><p><strong>2017/18 UIP (Jason Glass, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>· “The district and schools have not provided equitable resources and support for math students to have a well-established foundation in: mathematical reasoning to explain, justify, and evaluate their thinking used to solve problems and applications of reasoning across content areas.”</p><p>· “Due to inequitable resources and support, schools have limited capacity to differentiate instruction and engage students in relevant, authentic tasks, specifically in the core areas of mathematical reasoning and conceptual understanding in addition to memorization of facts.”</p><p>· “All schools currently do not have the full capacity to meet all students’ early literacy learning needs due to inequitable resources and support, for a variety of reasons, including inconsistent structures and routines across schools for foundational classroom (core) reading instruction, variable evidenced-based instructional practices to differentiate teaching for all learners’ needs, and lack of literacy transfer and application to other content areas.”</p><p><strong>2018/19 UIP (Jason Glass, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>· “Early Literacy: All schools currently do not have the full capacity to meet all students’ early literacy needs due to inequitable resources and support, for a variety of reasons including: (1) Inconsistent structures and routines across schools for foundational classroom (core) reading instruction; (2) Variable evidence-based instructional practices to differentiate teaching for all learners’ needs; and (3) Lack of literacy transfer and application to other content areas.”</p><p>· “Middle School Math: The district and schools have not provided equitable resources and support (for example, differentiated professional learning, and interventions) for math students to have a well-established foundation in: (1) Mathematical reasoning to explain, justify, and evaluate their thinking used to solve problems; and (2) Application of reasoning across content areas.”</p><p>· “Post-Secondary and Workforce Readiness (PWR): Due to inequitable resources and support, schools have limited capacity to differentiate instruction and engage students in relevant, authentic tasks, specifically in the core areas of: (1) Mathematical reasoning and conceptual understanding in addition to memorization of facts; and (2) Literacy transfer and application to other content areas.”</p><p><strong>2019/20 UIP (Jason Glass, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>• “In Jeffco, we are intent on providing rich and authentic learning experiences for all students built on the foundation of “student task” — or what teachers create for students to do in the classroom. We want our students to have the opportunity to develop skills and abilities such as collaboration, adaptation to changing conditions, communications, creative problem solving, and civic and global engagement. The district has provided tools and supports for our teachers and staff to develop student tasks with these objectives as a priority across all levels and all schools…Supporting students to connect their learning from authentic experiences in a variety of settings, including state tests, has been inconsistent. This shift to a new way of teaching and learning takes time and one hypothesis for the dip in district test scores may be attributable to the learning curve associated with this new pedagogical approach.”</p><p>• “While the district has focused on authentic learning experiences for our students, factual information and deep content knowledge remain important. For the state accountability assessments, about 60% of the CMAS test measures factual information, with the remainder focuses on problem-solving and critical thinking. An analysis of the district CMAS performance by standards shows the lowest performing areas are the critical thinking sections, specifically integration of knowledge &amp; ideas as well as prose constructed response for English language arts and reasoning and modeling for mathematics…Jeffco students generally are performing lower on the CMAS items that require more critical thinking and problem-solving (writing, modeling and reasoning) and [because they] may be experiencing fewer opportunities to demonstrate these higher-level thinking skills on district, school, and classroom tasks and tests.”</p><p><strong>2020/21 UIP (Kristopher Schuh, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>· “In Jeffco, we continue to focus on providing deeper learning, namely rich and authentic learning experiences for all students built on the foundation of “student task” — or what teachers create for students to do in the classroom. We want our students to have the opportunity to develop skills and abilities such as collaboration, adaptation to changing conditions, communications, creative problem solving, and civic and global engagement (a.k.a. Jeffco Generations Skills). Over the past century, historical approaches to teaching have not focused on this real-world application and it takes time for systems to adapt instructional approaches and change traditional practices.”</p><p>· “A major root cause for many of the district’s priority challenges this year concerns the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. Disruptions to learning, increased social-emotional needs, and exacerbated opportunity gaps for students experiencing poverty, homelessness and other risk factors have all contributed to this year’s challenges for the district and schools.”</p><p><strong>2021/2022 UIP (Tracy Dorland, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>· “Inconsistent district/school/classroom leadership, data-based decision making, family partnerships, tiered supports and evidence-based practices to meet all students’ needs.”</p><p>· “Depending on the school and/or classroom, all students may not receive or benefit from effective continuous improvement processes to meet their varied academic, behavioral, and social-emotional needs.”</p><p>· “District supports have not been integrated across all departments to develop and support systemic leadership, data-based decision making, family partnerships, tiered supports and evidence-based practices to meet all students’ needs.”</p><p><strong>2022/2023 UIP (Tracy Dorland, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>•“Prior improvement efforts through strategic planning and district unified improvement plans have not yielded anticipated results due to inconsistent district focus, clarity of expectations, adequate training/support for staff, and effective tools to check progress and adjust implementation strategies.”</p><p><strong>2023/2024 UIP (Tracy Dorland, Superintendent)</strong></p><p>• “Core instruction in every classroom has not consistently met high expectations due to lack of understanding and planning instruction at grade level expectations from the Colorado Academic Standards.”</p><p>• “The district has not provided a consistent expectation and framework to support schools in their data analyses and continuous improvement process.”</p><p>• “There has been insufficient focus on developing authentic relationships that enable all students and families to have a sense of belonging at school.”</p><p>— — — — — — — —</p><p>Reading this list of root causes from different years’ UIPs raises two critical questions:</p><p>First, why did the root causes change? If the ones listed were successfully addressed but achievement results didn’t improve, it implies that the real root causes either weren’t identified or for some reason were identified but not listed in the UIP.</p><p>Second, if the listed root causes were not successfully addressed, why were they then changed in the subsequent UIP?</p><p>The painful truth is this: Jeffco’s academic results have been declining since we moved here from Calgary in 2010. In the context of the Uniform Improvement Process, there are three possible explanations:</p><p>Either (1) the district has not accurately diagnosed the true root causes of the problem; (2) it has accurately diagnosed the root causes, but used ineffective major improvement strategies to address them; or (3) it has pursued major improvement strategies that have been effective in other districts, but has poorly implemented them.</p><p>Unfortunately, for more than a decade, nobody on the Jeffco Board of Education or the District Management Team has had any idea which of these has been the main driver of declining results (or if they do, they have kept silent about it).</p><p>And tens of thousands of Jeffco’s children have and continue to pay a lifetime price.</p><p><em>Tom Coyne is a business executive, former member of the Jeffco District Accountability Committee, and former chair of the Wheat Ridge High School Accountability Committee. His wife, Susan Miller, was elected to the Jeffco Board of Education in November 2019. These are solely his views.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=80d2078b9f7e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>