<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@terrydieheiden?source=rss-c3352d52dbb3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 13:31:45 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@terrydieheiden/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mashallah, You Played Yourself: Laugh-Reacting Your Way to Irrelevance — On Berlin Pride, Selective…]]></title>
            <link>https://terrydieheiden.medium.com/mashallah-you-played-yourself-laugh-reacting-your-way-to-irrelevance-on-berlin-pride-selective-1cb6fc4a93bc?source=rss-c3352d52dbb3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1cb6fc4a93bc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine-and-israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-criticism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Jul 2026 06:42:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-28T06:42:00.491Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Mashallah, You Played Yourself: Laugh-Reacting Your Way to Irrelevance — On Berlin Pride, Selective Humanity, and the Ummah’s Gift to Zionism</h3><h4>On Baudrillard, Butler, Puar, and the moral suicide of a community that demands mercy it refuses to give.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M_bWw0PNpd2G32B0LpRe3Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>On July 25th, 2026, a 21-year-old man named Abdul Ballout drove a van into a crowd at Berlin’s Christopher Street Day — the city’s annual Pride celebration. He then got out and attacked people with a machete. One woman was killed. Twenty-nine were injured, several critically. He fled. The next day, police found him hiding in an allotment garden in Spandau. He charged at them with a knife. They shot him dead.</p><p>He was born in Berlin. German citizen. Lebanese roots. Known to police as part of the city’s Islamist scene. Previously convicted of planning an attack and trying to join ISIS. He received a suspended sentence from a juvenile court. Two months later, he rented a van and drove it into queer people celebrating their right to exist.</p><p>These are the facts. They are not complicated.</p><p>What happened next is where it gets ugly.</p><h3>I. The Sign</h3><p>Jean Baudrillard wrote about the moment when reality collapses into its own image; it is when the thing ceases to matter and only the sign remains. He called it the precession of simulacra: the copy without an original and the map that precedes and replaces the territory.</p><p>Abdul Ballout stopped being a person the moment the van stopped moving.</p><p>He became a sign; a floating signifier consumed simultaneously by three competing semiotic economies, each extracting a different meaning from the same body, none of them interested in the body itself.</p><p>To a segment of the Muslim world, he became a <strong>martyr</strong>. A lion. A soldier of God who struck at degeneracy. The Al Jazeera Facebook post about the attack accumulated thousands of laugh reactions. Hundreds of comments celebrating. Not grief. Not horror. Not even silence. <em>Laughter</em>. The specific emoji reserved for jokes and comeuppances, deployed on an article about a woman being killed and twenty-nine people maimed at a festival of joy. This is not just simply an isolated event since I am from Malaysia, same kind of reactions are visible across all malay and indonesian speaking news pages on Facebook, X (formerly known as Twitter), Threads.</p><p>To the German far right—the AfD, Alice Weidel, the whole machinery gearing up for Berlin state elections in September—he became a campaign poster. The <strong>perfect specimen</strong>: <em>born in Germany</em>, still couldn’t be civilized, a known wolf that the system released back into the streets. <em>Every talking point about Islam’s incompatibility with Western values was validated in one evening.</em> Weidel, whose party would roll back queer rights in a heartbeat, now wraps herself in rainbow grief. Interior Minister Dobrindt, who last year refused to fly the rainbow flag over the Bundestag and called equal rights supporters a “shrill minority,” now speaks solemnly about protecting queer lives.</p><p>To the Israeli right and Zionist media apparatus, he became <strong>Exhibit A</strong> in the permanent case file. <em>See? This is who they are. This is what Islam produces. And you want us to have sympathy for Gaza?</em></p><p>Three economies. One corpse. Zero interest in the dead woman, the 65 years old mother from Poland that died, or the twenty-nine bleeding bodies. Baudrillard would recognize the structure immediately: the event has been fully replaced by its representations. The territory is gone. Only maps remain.</p><h3>II. Who Gets Mourned</h3><p>Judith Butler asked the question that nobody wants to answer honestly: whose lives count as grievable?</p><p>In <em>Frames of War</em>, Butler argues that grief is not a natural response to death—it is a politically distributed resource. Certain lives are framed as livable, and their loss registers as tragedy. Other lives are never framed as livable in the first place, so their destruction barely registers as loss. The frame precedes the feeling. You don’t mourn what you were never taught to see as alive.</p><p>The laughs reactions on the Berlin Pride post are not an aberration. They are a <em>public demonstration of the frame</em>. They are thousands of people performing, in real time,<strong> the refusal to admit queer lives into the category of grievable</strong>. Not because they don’t understand what happened. Because they understand perfectly, and they have decided it doesn’t count.</p><p>This is not ignorance. This is a moral position. It is the position that certain human beings are so far outside the boundary of legitimate life that their murder is either justice or comedy. And it is held openly, proudly, as an expression of faith.</p><p>I want to be precise here, because precision matters when the stakes are bodies.<strong> The people laughing are not all of Islam. They are not all Muslims.</strong> They are <strong>not even a majority.</strong> But they are <strong><em>loud</em></strong>, they are <strong><em>visible</em></strong>, and they are doing the work of confirming every accusation that the enemies of Islam have ever made—voluntarily, enthusiastically, without being asked.</p><h3>III. Orlando’s Ghost</h3><p>I’ve been here before.</p><p>June 12th, 2016. Omar Mateen walked into Pulse nightclub in Orlando, Florida, and murdered forty-nine people. It was, at the time, the deadliest mass shooting in American history. The victims were overwhelmingly queer, overwhelmingly Latino, overwhelmingly young. They were dancing.</p><p>And in certain corners of the Muslim world—corners I share a faith with—there was celebration.</p><p>I was younger then. It broke something in me. Not the shooting itself, horrific as it was, but the <em>reaction</em>. Watching people who pray in the same direction I do, who fast the same month I fast, and who invoke the same God I invoke—cheering the massacre of people whose only crime was existing in a nightclub on a Saturday night. I left the faith, completely after that, eventhough I’ve struggled with faith since I was 12, on-off relationship with faith, even through my darkest hours prior to 2016. I wasn’t militant “Atheist” then, I would still try to bridge the gap where I can. I believed in dialogues, in dialectical processes — Orlando Shooting and the subsequent witnessing of the cheerings from muslim world shifted me into something I’ve been trying to not be.</p><p>Orlando gave me my first real encounter with what I would later come to understand as the ummah’s asymmetrical humanity problem:<strong> the demand for universal compassion paired with the categorical refusal to extend it.</strong></p><p>I’ve matured since Orlando. I will not generalize all Muslims. I know better. I know the diversity, the internal dissent, and the millions of Muslims who were as horrified as anyone else but stayed silent because the takfir machine—the mechanism that declares dissenters apostates, traitors, and enemies of God—would eat them alive for saying so publicly.</p><p>But I will not be kind about it either.</p><p>Ten years later, the pattern hasn’t changed. The celebration has simply moved from Facebook comments to laugh reactions. The technology evolved. The moral failure didn’t.</p><h3>IV. The Pinkwash Machine</h3><p>Here is where the other side of the ugliness lives.</p><p>Jasbir Puar coined the term <em>homonationalism</em> in 2007. Her argument, developed in <em>Terrorist Assemblages</em>, is elegant and brutal: certain queer subjects get conditionally admitted into the national body in exchange for supporting the nation’s violence against racialised others. Gay rights become a civilizational metric—not because the state genuinely cares about queer lives, but because queer-friendliness can be weaponized as proof of superiority over the Muslim, the Arab, the Brown Other.</p><p>Israel is the paradigm case. <em>Pinkwashing is the</em> state branding strategy where gay rights at home become the PR shield for apartheid and genocide abroad. Tel Aviv Pride gets marketed globally while Palestinian queers get bombed with the same missiles that hit everyone else. The IDF Instagram posts rainbow flags. The bombs don’t discriminate, but the propaganda does.</p><p>Now watch the same machinery activate in Berlin.</p><p>The AfD—a party whose state-level branches have been classified as extremist organizations by Germany’s own intelligence agencies—is exploiting a queer death to fuel anti-Muslim racism. Alice Weidel, the AfD’s co-leader, posted about “migrant violence” within hours. Her party’s platform would restrict queer rights, dismantle anti-discrimination protections, and roll back marriage equality if given power. She does not mourn queer people. She <em>deploys</em> queer corpses.</p><p>Dobrindt refused the rainbow flag. Merz called CSD “not a circus tent.” These men spent years signaling that queer visibility was excessive, performative, and irritating. Now a Muslim man has killed a queer woman, and suddenly they are champions of LGBTQ+ dignity.</p><p>This is homonationalism in real time. Queer grief laundered through nationalist machinery, emerging on the other side as anti-Muslim ammunition. The dead woman becomes a prop. Her name is barely mentioned. Her life irrelevant except as evidence that <em>they</em> — the Muslims, the migrants, the civilisational Other — are barbaric.</p><p>The queer community in Berlin understands this. At the vigil at Brandenburg Gate, mourners carried signs that read “FCK AFD” alongside rainbow flags. They know. They know the threat comes from both directions—the Islamist who drives the van <em>and</em> the fascist who uses the van to justify the next deportation, the next restriction, the next erosion. They are grieving while being instrumentalized by the very people who would, in any other week, legislate against their existence.</p><p>Butler would call this the double bind of grievability: queer lives become visible precisely at the moment they can be used, and invisible again the moment their utility expires.</p><h3>V. Asymmetrical Humanity</h3><p>I have written before about what I call <em>asymmetrical humanity; </em>the structural condition in which a group demands universal moral recognition while systematically denying it to others.</p><p>The Zionist version is well-documented and increasingly exposed. Israel’s moral architecture has been leaking for years. The “most moral army in the world” line is dead. The hasbara playbook — <em>we are a democracy, we investigate ourselves, they started it</em> — has collapsed under the weight of documented atrocities, ICJ rulings, and the sheer mathematical obscenity of the body count in Gaza. The world watched Israeli society defend rapists when the victims were Palestinian, protest not the rape but the <em>exposure</em> of the rape, and then turn around and demand the world grieve on their terms.</p><p>They are, however, <em>adapting</em>. Very fast. This is the cynical part. Zionist PR is recalibrating — not morally, but tactically. They understand the old playbook is leaking. They modulate the optics. They deploy new messengers. They are responsive to pressure, even while committing to the project. It’s sinister, but it’s <em>strategic</em>.</p><p>Islam? The ummah broadly?</p><p>There is no comparable self-corrective mechanism.</p><p>No institutional infrastructure for public moral accounting. No theological confrontation with its own selective humanity. No reckoning with the fact that the moral architecture that makes Palestinian solidarity coherent—all<em> human life is sacred; suffering is suffering regardless of identity—is</em> the <em>same</em> architecture that should make Berlin Pride an atrocity to mourn, not celebrate.</p><p>You cannot hold Palestine in one hand and laugh react in the other without gutting your own argument. But they do. And they see no contradiction. Because queerness was never admitted into the category of “human” in the first place.</p><p>The Zionists strip humanity from the Palestinians. The Islamists strip humanity from the queer. The structure is identical. The targets differ. The mechanism doesn’t.</p><h3>VI. The Pipeline</h3><p>This is not a European problem.</p><p>Two days after Berlin, Singapore’s Internal Security Department announced the detention of three self-radicalized youths under the ISA. All Singaporean citizens. All planning attacks. One of them—a 19-year-old Muslim convert named <em>Tan Jun Jie</em>—had specifically planned to attack LGBTQ students at his school because their behavior was “un-Islamic.” He researched knife techniques online. He wanted to die a martyr. He also attempted cyberattacks against Muslim organizations he considered “deviant.”</p><p>But it’s the second case that crystallizes the pipeline. A 15-year-old was radicalized by online content depicting Palestinian suffering after October 7th. He started by supporting Hamas. Then he encountered ISIS content. Then he planned a mass stabbing at his school during the June holidays. He wrote a 21-page manifesto.</p><p>Read that again. A teenager’s legitimate grief about Palestinian children — grief that is <em>morally correct</em>, that <em>should</em> exist, that any decent human being should feel — was captured, processed, and converted into a targeting system. The pipeline runs from solidarity to extremism to violence, and LGBTQ people sit on the kill list right next to military personnel and “deviant” Muslims.</p><p>This is happening in Southeast Asia. Not in the banlieues of Paris. Not in the immigration debate of Germany. In my neighborhood. Berlin, Orlando, Singapore — different continents, same filter, same exclusion, same self-defeating spiral.</p><p>The third Singaporean youth—a 14-year-old—was radicalized through Roblox. Through a children’s game. He planned a mass stabbing of non-Muslim schoolmates.</p><p>Whatever institutional reckoning the ummah thinks it can defer indefinitely is already overdue. The pipeline is eating children.</p><h3>VII. The Petty Squabbles of the Ummah</h3><p>For most Muslims, <strong>the only war that matters is Palestine</strong>. And it <strong>ends there</strong>.</p><p>This is simultaneously noble and catastrophically myopic. Noble because the solidarity is real—the grief for Palestinian children is genuine, the rage at the hypocrisy of Western governments is justified, and the demand for recognition of Palestinian humanity is morally unimpeachable. I share it. I have made art for it. I have written for it. I have lost friendships over it.</p><p>But myopic because the moral architecture that makes Palestinian solidarity coherent is universal, or it is nothing. <strong>You don’t get to select which humans count as human.</strong> <strong>You don’t get to demand that the world mourn Palestinian children while laughing at queer people being run over at a parade. You don’t get to invoke the sacredness of life on Monday and celebrate its desecration on Saturday.</strong></p><p>And yet the ummah’s discourse remains consumed by what I can only call petty squabbles—sectarian one-upmanship, Sunni-Shia hatred, the takfir machine churning through anyone who deviates, and the obsessive policing of who is Muslim <em>enough</em>. The 19-year-old in Singapore attacked Muslim organizations he considered “deviant.” He was prepared to kill fellow Muslims who disagreed with his theology. The enemy is always inside the house as much as outside it.</p><p>Meanwhile, the real enemies—the ones who would strip Muslims of rights, dignity, and presence in the societies they inhabit—sit back and watch the community tear itself apart and hand them ammunition with every laugh, reaction, celebration, and refusal to extend to others the humanity they demand for themselves.</p><h3>VIII. If You’re Stupid, You’re Stupid</h3><p>I want to end where I started: with the <strong>laugh </strong>reacts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EQY8MDX7gSAucAR7" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@manas_rb?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">manas rb</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Every single one of those reactions is a data point. Every celebration screenshot is a .jpeg that will circulate through AfD Telegram channels, Zionist media accounts, right-wing campaign materials, and Islamophobic propaganda networks for years. Every “mashallah” typed under a news article about a woman being murdered at a Pride parade is a gift—wrapped, ribboned, and hand-delivered—to the people who want Muslims expelled, surveilled, dehumanized, and bombed.</p><p>The people celebrating Berlin are not defending Islam. They are not defending Palestine. They are not defending anything. They are performing their hatred of queer people in a public square and calling it piety.</p><p>If you are celebrating the murder of civilians at a Pride event and in the same breath demanding the world care about Palestinian children—you are not a freedom fighter. You are not righteous. You are not defending the faith.</p><p>You are stupid. Dangerously, morally, and strategically stupid.</p><p>You just handed every Islamophobe, every right-wing demagogue, and every Zionist propagandist exactly what they needed. And you are too drunk on your own righteousness to see it.</p><p>I will not generalize all Muslims. I know better than that. I know the diversity, the dissent, the quiet horror of millions who cannot speak because the machinery of their own community would devour them for it.</p><p>But I will name stupidity when I see it. I will not dress it up. I will not contextualize it into softness. I will not offer the caveat that redeems the unredeemable.</p><p>The people who actually deserve solidarity—Palestinians under bombardment, Muslims facing genuine persecution, queer Muslims trying to survive in communities that would rather they didn’t exist—they pay the price for this stupidity. Every single time.</p><p>The laugh reaction is not resistance. It is a confession. And the whole world is reading it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*UxZcEmTP-JLyfgiW" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@resourcedatabase?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Resource Database</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><em>Somewhere, a strategist in Berlin is updating a campaign deck.</em></p><p><em>Somewhere, a Zionist media officer is archiving screenshots.</em></p><p><em>Somewhere, a policymaker is recalculating how much political capital it costs to defend Muslim civil liberties.</em></p><p><em>They are always calculating.</em></p><p>And with every laugh react, the number gets worse. Not for them. For you. For the Palestinian mother who needs the world’s empathy to survive. For the Muslim kid in Hamburg who just wants to go to school unbothered.</p><p>The people making the calculations don’t celebrate and don’t mourn. They just count. And <em>you’ve </em>been making their math <em>easier </em>for years.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1cb6fc4a93bc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Chrome and Compliance: Why Women Join the Machine That Eats Them]]></title>
            <link>https://terrydieheiden.medium.com/chrome-and-compliance-why-women-join-the-machine-that-eats-them-ef3aa3179354?source=rss-c3352d52dbb3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ef3aa3179354</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cyberpunk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Jul 2026 15:03:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-16T15:03:30.784Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>On Cyberpunk 2077, Andrea Dworkin, and the dirty engine of gendered violence in supremacist structures</em></p><p>I was mid-mission in Cyberpunk 2077 when the question dropped into my lap like a grenade with the pin already pulled:<em> why do women join Maelstrom? (Or any of the gangs in Cyberpunk universe).</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*mFAHcmxPGo9CB5PV" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@liamd197?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Liam Nguyen</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>For those unfamiliar with the game — Maelstrom is a gang in Night City, a hypercapitalist hellscape set in 2077 California. They are violent, nihilistic, and fanatically devoted to cybernetic modification. Members routinely tear out their own eyes and replace them with military-grade optics. They cook synthetic drugs in abandoned factories. Their initiation rites involve pain thresholds that would make a Cenobite pause. And their gender politics are, to put it diplomatically, unreconstructed.</p><p>And yet there are women in Maelstrom. Not captives but active <em>members</em>. Women who chose to walk through that door, sit in that chair, and let someone bolt chrome into their skulls.</p><p>The easy answer is false consciousness: they don’t know any better. This is also the lazy answer, the answer that flatters the analyst and infantilises the subject. I want the hard answer. But before we get to the hard answer, we need to understand what these women are choosing <em>between</em>.</p><h3>The Market of Night City</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K2yAg2u-ZXa1XGBrzfHSaw.jpeg" /><figcaption>From r/LowSodiumCyberpunk captured by iAmStylised © CD Projeckt RED</figcaption></figure><p>Night City is, before anything else, a market. And in that market, women are a commodity class.</p><p>This is not subtext. It is on every billboard, every holographic advertisement, every scrolling marquee on every building in every district. Night City’s advertising is not merely sexualised or violent — it is <em>sensorially totalising</em>. I’ll share <em>SOME </em>of the ads available in-game that showcase how it is fully uncensored and hyper-violent, hyper-sexual the city has become. If you like to explore more, consider purchasing the game, or/and get into the Cyberpunk genre, books, games.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-zrFlmufBFMdh-iPMuC33Q.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*i-EMBg0or-kDMYjo9j1giA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sO_e5UaI5noL583PpXUdBQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-mV6UMWWDbHH-ZTtLj_xgA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/562/1*UcuqNhtM5QdfQVFDbSD3Tg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/1*6QfXyr7JTHJnB2yGLTgRcA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/1*-654lBYMDA30lYZrBfD1Ag.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/1*YgOAX4eD_Qf15Mbr6WGkTw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/564/1*75UJXoG9FpmRDEN2WkdSCw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zAsQNFSLlKS1LYSr-gqDzQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U_lYkrMhXcs5kfVLGBysNQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/697/1*kIH489-qx3C9ZHFCUJpanw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MG5ydK5-85abnWBquaKFYw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tNXpe19A996XG5vJARskrA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UWJTwUoUb-uNyNaGyKgSDg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3tQ72lmfrnft3y4vmSFFXA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/783/1*PjTtWczTNxEf-hJFoBAq2w.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/823/1*rtHSird6RkIAiQTdXxInzQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VEVPIyQ84lcfZc9tBJ8sBg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/661/1*mKmsV2dJgufAcl8wI6PnoQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Full-sensory braindance ads that bypass cognition entirely and write desire directly into the nervous system. Billboards for Mr. Stud and Midnight Lady implants that treat the human body as a platform to be optimised for someone else’s consumption. The city does not suggest that bodies are products. It <strong>screams </strong>it from every surface, in every frequency, until the distinction between person and commodity becomes architecturally invisible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wV3EFsR9XUKParmbutJ3Kw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QOBsmNtH7EKn_GB1IgU8Lg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OYvCYFg3BfExs0dMfsTOdg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/996/1*GZKl3Adym4A7H9KeeAD5EQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>For women navigating this landscape, the available options are brutally narrow. Consider the menu:</p><p>The <strong><em>corpo route; </em></strong>climb the Arasaka or Militech ladder, trade your body for a different kind of consumption. Corporate life in Night City is not gendered liberation; it is the replacement of sexual commodification with professional commodification. You are no longer a body to be consumed — you are a resource to be deployed, backstabbed over, and discarded when your utility expires. The corpo woman is not free. She has simply moved from one shelf to another.</p><p><strong><em>Braindance celebrity</em></strong><em>; </em>become the content. Braindance is Night City’s entertainment backbone: full-sensory recordings of lived experience that audiences consume like drugs. The BD star is the logical endpoint of our own influencer economy, the direction TikTok and OnlyFans are already trending toward — a future where the commodity is not just your image but your <em>entire sensorium</em>. Your joy, your pain, your orgasm, your terror, recorded and sold. The braindance celebrity does not own her experience. She <em>is</em> the experience, packaged for mass consumption. The more extreme the sensation, the higher the price. There is a reason the Tyger Claws produce snuff BDs. The market always wants more.</p><p><strong><em>Dolls</em></strong><em>; </em>and here the metaphor collapses into literalism. Night City’s Doll system is the purest expression of commodification ever committed to fiction. A Doll is a sex worker fitted with a personality construct chip that takes over during client sessions. The Doll’s own consciousness <em>leaves</em>. Her body is rented out while she is, for all functional purposes, absent. She does not experience her own exploitation. She returns to herself afterward, in a body that has been used in ways she may never know. This is not sex work. This is the industrialised separation of a person from her own body; the final severing of subject from object, where the object continues to function without the subject present. Clouds, the Doll house in Westbrook, is run by the Tyger Claws. The same gang that has female enforcers with katanas. The same building, different floors.</p><p><strong><em>Blue-collar survival</em></strong><em>; </em>mechanics, food vendors, ripperdoc assistants, fixers’ errand runners. Grinding, precarious, and offering no protection from the street-level violence that saturates every district. You eat. You pay rent. You are one bad night away from the next category.</p><p><strong><em>Homeless</em></strong><em>; </em>which in Night City means prey. Scavengers harvest the unprotected for cyberware. Gangs use the desperate for testing, for sport, for parts. To be homeless in Night City is to be raw material.</p><p>Or.</p><p>You dissolve. You walk into <strong>Maelstrom</strong>, or the <strong>Tyger Claws</strong>, or the <strong>Wraiths</strong>, or the <strong>Scavs</strong>, and you let the gang eat your identity in exchange for something none of the other options offer: <strong><em>the capacity for violence AND to survive (for most part)</em></strong>.</p><p>These four are the most notorious gangs in Night City; for many players these fours are shoot-to-kill because of how inhumane and violent they are. There are others (<em>I will share their gang names and details below</em>).</p><p>Not beauty, not compliance, not endurance, not absence; but the ability to <em>do harm</em>. To be the threat instead of the threatened. To hold the katana instead of kneeling in Clouds.</p><p>This is the landscape Andrea Dworkin was mapping forty years before CD Projekt Red rendered it in Unreal Engine.</p><p>Before we venture into Andrea Dworkin realm, let’s get familiarized with Night City Gangs:</p><p><strong>6th Street</strong> — Watson/Vista del Rey. Founded by 4th Corporate War veterans. American patriot aesthetic turned protection racket turned gang. They fetishise military brotherhood, the flag, the uniform. Think “<em>We Support The Troops</em>” bumper stickers with actual artillery. Gender politics are traditional military masculinity; women can earn a place through combat service, but the framework is fundamentally <em>earned admission into a male space</em>. The woman in the lineup isn’t dressed differently from the men. She’s been absorbed into the uniform. Gender dissolution through <em>military assimilation</em> rather than chrome.</p><p><strong>Aldecaldos</strong> — Badlands nomad clan. Extended family structure, communal living, automotive culture. This is the closest thing to a functional community in the entire Cyberpunk universe. Panam Palmer — one of the game’s major characters — is an Aldecaldo, and she holds genuine authority. Gender here isn’t dissolved, it’s <em>integrated</em>. The family model allows women to be warriors, mechanics, leaders without requiring them to abandon womanhood. The Aldecaldos are the essay’s implicit counter-example — the road not taken.</p><p><strong>Wraiths</strong> — Badlands raiders. If the Aldecaldos are nomad community, the Wraiths are nomad <em>predation</em>. They raid caravans, strip vehicles, kidnap people. Heavy chrome, road warrior aesthetic. Their women aren’t performing community; they’re performing <em>hunt</em>. Function has eaten identity here too, but the function is specifically predatory. You don’t read the female Wraith as a woman. You read her as an ambush.</p><p><strong>Moxes</strong> — Kabuki/Lizzie’s Bar. The Moxes are the splinter in the argument. Founded in memory of Elizabeth “Lizzie” Borden, a strip club owner who actually <em>protected</em> her workers. The Moxes exist specifically to defend sex workers, queer people, and the vulnerable from exploitation by gangs like the Tyger Claws. They are a gang formed by the commodified <em>against</em> commodification.</p><p>HOWEVER, The Mox themselves are contradiction; They are the most overtly sexualized gang in the lineup. The lingerie, the heels, the exposed skin. But it’s <em>weaponised</em> — every one of them is armed. The aesthetic isn’t submission, it’s <em>reclamation</em>. They took the Doll’s outfit and put a baseball bat in its hand.</p><p>One has to ponder; does the Moxes’ existence <em>disprove</em> the Dworkin circuit or <em>prove</em> it? Because the Moxes still use violence. They still operate as a gang. They are still inside the machine. They’ve simply seized a different lever within it — protection rather than predation, but protection <em>enforced through the same violence</em>. Is that liberation or is it the most sophisticated form of the lateral promotion? We’ll explore this futher on.</p><p><strong>Voodoo Boys</strong> — Pacifica. Haitian diaspora community. Expert netrunners. Their power isn’t physical — it’s <em>informational</em>. They live in the Net the way Maelstrom lives in chrome. Their dissolution isn’t of the body but of <em>location; </em>they exist as much in cyberspace as in the abandoned resort district they occupy. Gender dissolves differently here: in the Net, your body is an avatar. Your flesh is a terminal. The Voodoo Boys don’t need chrome to escape the body. They just <em>leave</em> it. Deeply insular, xenophobic toward outsiders, willing to sacrifice anyone; including you, for access to the Old Net beyond the Blackwall.</p><p><strong>Tyger Claws</strong> — Japantown, Kabuki, Westbrook. Already in the essay and they should be, because they’re the <em>infrastructure</em> of sexual commodification in Night City. They run Clouds. They run the Doll houses. They produce braindances; legal or otherwise. They traffic women. And the female Tyger Claw enforcer stands guard <em>in the same building</em>. Same organisation, different floors. She protects the system that commodifies her sisters. The katana in her hand and the doll chip in the room down the hall are products of the same machine. They are pimps with full Arasaka corporate backing, and the weapons to boot.</p><p><strong>Maelstrom</strong> — Watson/All Foods/Totentanz. The essay’s primary subject. Chrome-worshipping, flesh-hating, industrial body horror. I’ll talk about them further in. They are the <em>endpoint</em> of the spectrum; gender engineered out of existence at the hardware level.</p><p><strong>Valentinos</strong> — Heywood. Latino gang. Catholic iconography, gold aesthetic, honour culture, lowriders, roses, saints. The most <em>traditionally gendered</em> gang in Night City and that’s what makes them analytically interesting. The Valentinos operate on machismo, on the madonna/whore framework. Women exist within a clearly gendered role structure: respected as mothers and lovers, dangerous as fighters, but always <em>legibly female</em>. The Valentinos don’t dissolve gender. They <em>hyper-perform</em> it. Every gold chain, every rose tattoo, every candlelit altar is a performance of gendered meaning. They’re the only gang where womanhood is preserved as a <em>category; </em>but preserved within the cage of honour culture. Is that a good thing or bad thing in a carnivorous city like Night City? One has to wonder.</p><p><strong>Animals</strong> — Pacifica/Grand Imperial Mall. All about raw physical power through a drug called Juice and bioware — not cyberware. They don’t replace the body with chrome. They <em>inflate</em> the body with biochemistry. Underground fighting rings. Pure physical dominance ideology. And here’s the thing: one of their leaders, Sasquatch, is a woman; a massive, terrifyingly strong, will kill you with a sledgehammer. The Animals don’t care about gender. They care about whether you can bench-press a car. Gender dissolves here through <em>hyperphysicality and </em>when everyone is a wall of muscle, the distinction becomes irrelevant. Not erased by chrome. Erased by sheer mass.</p><h3>The Dworkin Circuit</h3><p>In <em>Right-Wing Women</em> (1983), Dworkin makes an argument so uncomfortably lucid that both the left and the right have spent four decades trying to pretend she didn’t make it. Her thesis, stripped to its load-bearing walls: women who align with patriarchal, authoritarian, and violent structures are not suffering from stupidity, brainwashing, or internalised misogyny in any simple sense. They have surveyed the available options; which are, in the world as it actually exists, severely constrained and chosen the arrangement that maximises their survival. Not their freedom. Not their flourishing. Their <strong><em>survival</em></strong>.</p><p>This is not a defense of their choice. It is a refusal to dismiss it as irrational.</p><p>Apply this lens to Night City. A woman unaffiliated in Watson district or Maelstrom’s territory is not liberated, she’s a victim in waiting; this is an inescapable truth. She is unprotected prey in a place where corporate security doesn’t reach and the NCPD shows up only to tag bodies. Joining Maelstrom is not choosing misogyny. It is choosing which predator walks beside you instead of behind you. It is the calculation that a known threat you have negotiated a position within is preferable to an unknown threat you face alone.</p><p>This is the Dworkin circuit: a closed loop of rational choice within irrational conditions, where the “<strong><em>best available option</em></strong>” still involves your own degradation. I suggest to read Dworkin’s work on this to understand better especially as stated above; <em>Right-Wing Women</em> (1983).</p><h3>Anna Freud and the Lateral Promotion</h3><p>Dworkin gives us the strategic calculus. Anna Freud gives us the psychic mechanism.</p><p><strong><em>Identification with the aggressor</em></strong>; a defence mechanism Freud described in <em>The Ego and the Mechanisms of Defence</em> (1936) is the process by which a person, unable to escape a threatening figure, resolves the unbearable anxiety by <em>becoming</em> that figure. Not imitating. Becoming. The psyche, faced with the intolerable position of object-of-violence, performs a kind of ontological judo: it flips from passive to active, from target to perpetrator, and in doing so converts terror into agency.</p><p>The logic is almost mathematical. If I cannot escape the violence, I can redirect it. I move from object to subject. The violence does not stop; it simply flows <em>through</em> me now, toward someone lower in the hierarchy.</p><p>This is not transcendence. It is a lateral promotion within the machinery of harm. You are still inside the machine. You have simply moved from the part that gets crushed to the part that does the crushing.</p><p>For women in violent organisations, this mechanism is the psychic engine that makes the Dworkin bargain liveable. The strategic choice to join is made bearable by the psychological transformation that follows: <em>I am no longer a woman-who-is-vulnerable. I am </em><strong><em>Maelstrom</em></strong><em>. I am the </em><strong><em>thing</em></strong><em> you </em><strong><em>fear</em></strong><em>.</em></p><h3>The Transhumanist Escape Hatch</h3><p>But Cyberpunk 2077 introduces a variable that neither Dworkin nor Anna Freud could have anticipated, and this is where the fiction becomes genuinely philosophically productive:<strong> <em>transhumanism</em></strong>.</p><p>Maelstrom’s core ideology is not merely violent; it is <em>anti-flesh</em>. The body is weakness. Meat is failure. Chrome is truth, purity, evolution. Members modify themselves to the point where the boundary between human and machine dissolves and with it, arguably, the material substrate on which gender difference is constructed.</p><p>Judith Butler argued in <strong><em>Gender Trouble</em></strong> (1990) that gender is <strong><em>performative</em></strong>: not an essence but a repeated set of acts, stylisations, and embodiments that congeal over time into the appearance of a natural fact. Gender requires a body that can be <strong><em>read </em></strong>as gendered; a body whose surfaces, movements, and vulnerabilities are legible within a cultural grammar of masculinity and femininity.</p><p>What happens to that grammar when the body is <strong>70% titanium</strong>? When your arms are gorilla-arms and your eyes are Kiroshi optics and your nervous system runs on military-grade Kerenzikov reflex boosters? The misogyny within Maelstrom may not vanish; ideology is stickier than chrome but the <em>material basis</em> for gendered vulnerability is literally replaced with metal. Butler’s performative body gets overwritten by a cybernetic one.</p><p>This is the <strong><em>transhumanist escape hatch</em></strong>: the promise, implicit in Maelstrom’s body-horror philosophy, that you can <strong><em>modify your way out of gender</em></strong>. Not through politics. Not through liberation. Through engineering. Dissolve the flesh, dissolve the category.</p><p>It is, of course, a false promise. The power structures within Maelstrom do not rearrange themselves simply because everyone has chrome arms. But the <strong><em>phenomenological experience; </em></strong>the lived sensation of inhabiting a body that can no longer be easily victimized is real, and it is seductive. And it is this seduction, I think, that the game gestures toward without fully interrogating.</p><h3>The Dissolution of the Woman-Shape</h3><p>There is a deeper observation I want to make, one that has been accumulating across every playthrough of Cyberpunk 2077: the female members of the violent factions —<strong> Scavs, Wraiths, Tyger Claws, Maelstrom </strong>do not register as women in the moment of encounter. Not in any phenomenological sense. Not in the grammar of recognition.</p><p>I notice this because I am someone who hesitates to kill female enemies in games. I am someone who sees the person under the chrome. And yet, with these gangs, the hesitation eventually fails; not because I overcome it, but because the enemy stops reading as a woman. The femaleness dissolves into something else: <strong><em>function. Role. Category. Threat</em></strong>.</p><p>This is not about dehumanisation in the generic sense. It is about a specific operation that violent supremacist structures perform on gender: they do not simply subordinate women. They dissolve the category of woman into something instrumental.</p><p>Consider the spectrum:</p><p>The Tyger Claws operate the most explicitly gendered violence in Night City. They traffic women. They produce snuff BDs. They run brothels and dollhouses. And yet the female Claw enforcer standing guard with a katana is not positioned as a potential victim of this system, in fact, she is positioned as its enforcer. She will kill you. And in that moment, her womanhood; the same womanhood that makes her sisters prey becomes irrelevant. Not protected. Not elevated. Simply suspended. She moves through the organisation as a function: soldier, guard, killer. The gender is a costume she wears beneath the chrome, invisible to everyone except the trafficking victims who know, intimately, that she could have been them.</p><p>The Scavs and Wraiths take this dissolution further. The female Scav harvesting chrome from a still-breathing victim, the female Wraith ambushing a convoy in the Badlands; these women are not performing femaleness. They are not using it as a weapon or a lure. They are simply raiders. The function has eaten the identity whole. You can see the female body shape if you look, but the game does not cue you to read them differently; they are Scavs first, women not at all. Their violence is indistinguishable from their male counterparts’. The gender difference exists only at the level of the character model, not the gameplay, not the threat assessment, not the moral calculus.</p><p>Maelstrom completes the arc. Their ideology is <strong>explicitly </strong>anti-flesh. The body is weakness. Meat is failure. Chrome is truth. In a gang whose members remove their own faces; not for utility but as a philosophical rejection of organic humanity, thus, gender is not simply suspended; It is engineered out of existence. The female Maelstrom with gorilla arms, or mantis-blades arms, Kiroshi optics, and a torso that is seventy percent alloy with Kitch-blades legs, is not a woman in any sense that Judith Butler’s performative model could recognize. The cultural grammar of gender requires a body that can be read as gendered: surfaces, curves, vulnerabilities. Maelstrom replaces all of it with chrome. You don’t read her as a woman. You read her as Maelstrom. The category of femaleness has been overwritten at the hardware level.</p><p>This is <strong>not liberation</strong>. This is <strong>not transhumanist feminism</strong>. This is t<strong>he dissolution of identity into function; </strong>the same mechanism Anna Freud described but taken to its ontological endpoint. She called it identification with the aggressor: the psyche flips from passive to active, from object to subject, from target to perpetrator. But identification implies a self that identifies with something. What happens when the identification is so total that the self disappears into the role?</p><p>The woman who joins Maelstrom does not simply become an oppressor to her own sex. She becomes unsexed. Her femaleness does not exist; not as vulnerability, not as protection, not as identity, not as performance. It has been replaced by a role that has no gender at all. She is not a woman-who-oppresses. She is an oppressor whose womanhood is vestigial.</p><h3>The Architecture Repeats Without the Chrome</h3><p>This is where Night City stops being fiction and starts being diagnosis.</p><p>The Nazi <em>Aufseherin; </em>the female concentration camp guard was not merely a woman who did harm. She was a woman whose womanhood was dissolved into the SS uniform. The gender hierarchy that subordinated her to her husband was suspended the moment she put on the uniform and picked up the whip. In that moment, she was not a woman. She was an agent of the Reich. The function devoured the identity.</p><p>Wendy Lower’s <em>Hitler’s Furies: German Women in the Nazi Killing Fields</em> (2013) documents the full scope: ordinary German women who followed their husbands to the Eastern Front and given proximity to power and to victims became shooters, sadists, and architects of local atrocity. They were not exempt from Nazi patriarchy. <em>Kinder, Küche, Kirche; </em>children, kitchen, church was explicit state policy for the role of women. But the racial hierarchy gave them someone to stand above.</p><p>The gender hierarchy compressed them from above; the racial hierarchy expanded them from below. And the psychic relief of that expansion; the intoxication of supremacy over <em>someone</em>, anyone made the compression bearable. The internal cost of patriarchy became an acceptable transaction fee when the external payoff was supremacy over an entire population.</p><p>The same structure operates today. The female Zionist settler serving in the IDF, or living on expropriated Palestinian land, is not performing the traditional gendered vulnerability that Israeli family law under rabbinical jurisdiction; imposes on her in the domestic sphere. In uniform, or in the settlement, she is not a potential victim of patriarchal divorce law. She is an armed agent of the colonial project.</p><p>Her gender becomes invisible. Her role becomes total. She is still positioned above the Palestinian woman whose home she now occupies, whose olive grove was bulldozed for her children’s playground. The womanhood remains but only in the synagogue, only in the rabbinical court, only in the domestic sphere she left at the door when she picked up the rifle.</p><p>Iran’s <em>gasht-e ershad; </em>the morality police, formally the Guidance Patrols — employs female officers. This is not incidental. It is architecturally required. The same modesty laws that mandate hijab and regulate women’s bodies in public space <em>also</em> prohibit male officers from physically handling, detaining, or searching women. The patriarchal system cannot enforce itself on women’s bodies using only men. It needs women to do the touching, the grabbing, the dragging into the van. The system recruits women as instruments of its own enforcement <em>because its own rules demand it</em>.</p><p>Consider what this means structurally. The female morality police officer wakes up in a country where her testimony is worth half a man’s in court, where her inheritance is half her brother’s, where her right to travel, to divorce, to choose her clothing in public is circumscribed by clerical authority. She is subject to every constraint the Islamic Republic places on women. And then she puts on the uniform and her function becomes the enforcement of those same constraints on other women. Women who show too much hair. Women whose coats are too short. Women who laugh too loudly in public. Women who dances. Women who are, in the grammar of the state, <em>insufficiently compliant</em> with the system that subordinates them all.</p><p>The Nazi <em>Aufseherin</em> enforced racial hierarchy against a different people. The Zionist settler enforces colonial hierarchy against a different population. The Iranian morality police officer enforces <em>gender</em> hierarchy against <em>her own gender</em>. Her “<strong>promotion</strong>” within the machine is the right to fasten her own chains onto another woman’s wrists. The function has not merely devoured her identity; it has conscripted her identity as its delivery mechanism. She is not a woman-who-enforces-patriarchy. She is patriarchy wearing a woman’s hands, because only a woman’s hands are permitted to touch the body being policed.</p><p>Mahsa Jina Amini died in morality police custody in September 2022 for wearing her hijab improperly. She was twenty-two years old. The officers who detained her included women. The women who carried her unconscious body included officers. The hands that enforced the law on her hair belonged to people living under the same law. And when the uprising came —<strong> <em>Zan, Zendegi, Azadi</em></strong>, <em>Woman, Life, Freedom</em> — it was directed not only at the regime, but at the entire architecture of women enforcing the dissolution of women. The slogan named what the morality police had abandoned: womanhood as solidarity rather than function. Life as something other than compliance. Freedom as the refusal to dissolve.</p><p>The Afghan Taliban’s <em>Amr bil-Maruf</em> operates the same circuit at an even more totalised scale — women barred from education, from work, from walking unaccompanied, policed by a force that includes female informants and enforcers whose compliance is purchased with the smallest of privileges: the right to move, the right to eat, the right to not be the one punished today. The transaction fee shrinks until it is barely visible, but the structure remains identical. Dominate or be dominated. Enforce or be enforced upon. The function devours the identity, and the identity it devours is your own.</p><p>This is not the tired binary of “<strong><em>fuck or get fucked</em></strong>.” It is something more fundamental: <strong><em>dominate or be dominated</em></strong>. And in that binary, gender is a distraction. A variable that can be set to zero. You are not a woman. You are a function. A role. A weapon. The original self: female, vulnerable, positioned within a hierarchy — does not escape. It is simply abandoned.</p><p>And this is perhaps the cruelest operation these structures perform: they offer women a way out of womanhood. Not through liberation — through erasure. Not through equality but through transcendence-into-function. You don’t have to be a woman anymore. You can be Maelstrom. You can be SS. You can be IDF. You can be a settler. You can be chrome. You can be uniform. You can be role.</p><p>And the women who take this deal; the ones who walk through that door, sit in that chair, let someone bolt chrome into their skulls or put a rifle in their hands are not liberated. They are dissolved. The machine does not just eat women. It eats the category of woman itself.</p><h3>The Moxes Problem</h3><p>I need to be honest about a complication. Because there is one gang in Night City that refuses this thesis — or at least appears to — and if I don’t address it, the argument is too clean, and too clean means too easy to dismiss.</p><p>The Moxes.</p><p>Founded in memory of Elizabeth “Lizzie” Borden, a strip club owner who genuinely protected her workers from exploitation by the Tyger Claws. After her murder, her workers and their allies formed a gang explicitly dedicated to defending sex workers, queer people, and the vulnerable from the predation that the Market of Night City treats as a feature, not a bug. They run Lizzie’s Bar in Kabuki. They patrol their turf. They fight Tyger Claws. They protect people that every other faction in this city treats as raw material.</p><p>And if you look at them; really look — they are the most overtly sexualised gang in Night City. Lingerie as armor. Heels as combat boots. Exposed skin and neon hair and the aesthetic of the strip club turned inside out, worn on the street, armed with baseball bats and submachine guns. They took the Doll’s outfit and put a weapon in its hand.</p><p>The argument <em>against</em> the Moxes writes itself, and I have heard versions of it in every debate about the politics of sex work I have ever entered:</p><p>They are still a gang. They still use violence. They still operate within Night City’s machinery of exploitation — they have simply seized a different lever. The Mox bouncer at the door of Lizzie’s Bar is performing the same function as the Tyger Claw enforcer at Clouds: protecting an institution that monetises the body. The fact that Lizzie’s workers are treated better than Clouds’ Dolls is a difference of degree, not of kind. The sex industry remains the sex industry. The commodity chain remains intact. The Moxes have not dismantled the market. They have negotiated slightly better terms within it.</p><p>Furthermore and this is the cut that draws blood; the sexualised aesthetic can be read as the deepest form of internalization. The Moxes have weaponized the very imagery that commodifies them. But <strong><em>weaponising</em></strong> the commodity form is not the same as <strong><em>escaping</em> </strong>it. A woman in lingerie with a gun is still, at the level of the image, <strong><em>a woman in lingerie</em></strong>. The male gaze (or in the case of Cyberpunk; consumer’s gaze) does not care that she is armed. It consumes the image regardless. The reclamation may feel like power from the inside. From the outside, it is still content.</p><p>I know this argument. I have <em>made</em> this argument. In reality, outside the game, I am sex-industry critical. I believe that the structural conditions under which the sex industry operates; under capitalism, under patriarchy, under the specific brutalizing conditions of global poverty and trafficking make genuine consent and genuine autonomy desperately difficult to locate. I believe that the normalisation of commercial sex tends to benefit the buyers and the platforms more than the workers. I believe Dworkin was more right than wrong about what the sex industry does to the people inside it.</p><p>And I support the Moxes.</p><p>Not naively. Not because they are feminist heroes. Not because they have solved anything. I support the Moxes for the same reason Dworkin’s analysis ultimately supports the women she writes about, even as it refuses to celebrate their choices: <strong>because within a closed system where every option involves degradation, solidarity among the degraded is not liberation, but it is the <em>precondition</em> for liberation.</strong></p><p>Here is what the Moxes do that no other gang in Night City does:<strong> they <em>preserve the category of woman</em> without requiring its dissolution.</strong></p><p>The Maelstrom woman dissolves her gender into chrome. The Wraith woman dissolves hers into the hunt. The 6th Street woman dissolves hers into the uniform. The Tyger Claw enforcer suspends her gender at the door of the same building that commodifies her sisters. Every other gang offers women a way out of womanhood through erasure, through function, through violence. Even Valentino expects and puts women through strict Madonna/whore dichotomy, women are to be consumed like prized possessions rather than autonomous beings who decide and self-determine for themselves.</p><p>The Moxes let women remain women. Visibly, loudly, defiantly female and armed. They do not ask their members to abandon the gendered self in order to survive. They ask them to <em>defend</em> it. The lingerie is not dissolution. It is insistence. It says: <em>I am what you think I am, and I will kill you for treating me the way you planned to.</em></p><p>Is this liberation? No. It is the Dworkin circuit running in its most sophisticated form; rational survival within irrational conditions, with the added dimension of collective care. The Moxes have not broken the circuit. They have made it <em>communal</em>. They have turned the individual survival bargain into a <em>mutual</em> survival bargain. You are still inside the machine. But you are inside it <em>together</em>, watching each other’s backs, and the someone-to-stand-above that Girard’s mechanism requires is not a scapegoated ethnicity or a dehumanised out-group; it is the <em>specific predators</em> who prey on your community. The Tyger Claws. The clients who hurt Dolls. The scavengers who target sex workers.</p><p>This is where my real-world sex-industry criticism and my in-game Mox support converge rather than contradict: I do not believe the sex industry liberates women. But I believe that women inside the sex industry deserve solidarity, protection, and collective power and that withholding support until the industry is abolished is a cruelty that feminism cannot afford. You do not get to tell a woman currently inside the machine that you will care about her safety only after she leaves it. She may not survive long enough to leave. This is why I still support Sex Workers, but Sex Industry critical in real life. My solidarity and concerns are with the people involved, not the lifeless, soulless industry.</p><p>The Moxes understand this. They are not utopian. They are not post-feminist. They are women with bats who decided that <em>this block, tonight, no one touches our people</em>. And within a city that offers no other form of solidarity to the commodified; no unions, no shelters, no legal protections, no state that gives a damn. That is not nothing.</p><p>It is not enough. But it is not nothing.</p><p>The question the Moxes pose to the rest of the essay is this: <strong>is there a version of the survival bargain that does not require the dissolution of the self</strong>? Can a woman hold a weapon and remain a woman; not as a uniform, not as a function, but as an identity she chooses to keep? Can the Dworkin circuit be rewired, even partially, toward mutual protection rather than individual absorption?</p><p>The Moxes say yes. Night City, with its relentless machinery of commodification and violence, says: <em>for now</em>. And <em>for now,</em> is all anyone in this city has ever had.</p><h3>Girard’s Sacred Violence</h3><p>René Girard gives us one final turn of the screw and it is perhaps the cruelest.</p><p>In Girard’s theory of the scapegoat mechanism, violence within a community is managed by directing it outward, toward a sacrificial victim whose expulsion or destruction restores internal cohesion. The violence feels not merely justified but <em>sacred; </em>a purification, a necessary cleansing. The community does not experience itself as doing harm. It experiences itself as restoring order.</p><p>For women inside violent supremacist structures, the scapegoat mechanism performs a terrible alchemy. It transforms the Dworkin bargain; which is coldly transactional, survival-driven, and potentially reversible — into something <em>holy</em>. The violence directed outward toward the scapegoated group (the Jew, the Palestinian, the unmodified flesh-body, the cyberpsycho) is no longer a cost-benefit calculation. It is a calling. A duty. A devotion.</p><p>This is the point at which the dissolution becomes permanent. The woman who was dissolved into function is now dissolved into <em>faith</em>. The chrome fuses with the bone. The woman who joined Maelstrom for survival becomes a woman who <em>is</em> Maelstrom; who can no longer locate where the strategic choice ended and the genuine belief began. Who can no longer find the original self beneath the role, because the role has become sacred.</p><p>Girard would say: she can’t locate it because the distinction was dissolved by ritual. The repeated acts of communal violence; the raids, the initiations, the killings, the settlements, the demolitions. Function as liturgy. And liturgy does not persuade. It <em>transforms</em>.</p><h3>The Question That Won’t Resolve</h3><p>So: <strong>why do women join the machine that eats them?</strong></p><p>Because the machine offers a trade. Gendered subordination within the group in exchange for supremacy over the out-group. Flesh-vulnerability in exchange for chrome invulnerability. Object-status in exchange for subject-position. Compression from above in exchange for expansion from below.</p><p>Because Anna Freud’s defense mechanism turns survival into identity.</p><p>Because the identity dissolves into function and function has no gender.</p><p>Because Girard’s sacred violence turns function into devotion.</p><p>Because the body, as Butler showed us, is not a fixed fact but a site of contestation and Maelstrom, the IDF, and the Nazi Frauenschaft and Aufseherin, all offer, in their different grammars, a way to <em>rewrite</em> that body into something that cannot be victimised. Even if the rewriting costs you everything you were. Even if the rewriting costs you <em>what</em> you were.</p><p>The question that haunts me is not why women join. The question is whether there exists a threshold; a moment of accumulated internal cost at which the trade becomes unbearable. At which the chrome itches. At which the settlement feels like a prison. At which the function cracks and the original self bleeds through, still gendered, still vulnerable, still <em>her</em>.</p><p>Or whether the identification simply calcifies, year after year, chrome over bone, uniform over skin, role over self, until there is no original self left to bleed. Until the woman-shape is gone entirely, and only the machine remains.</p><p>I don’t have the answer. I suspect Dworkin didn’t either, and that’s what made her writing so unforgiving. She understood the machine completely. She simply refused to pretend it had an off switch.</p><p>But maybe..<em>maybe.. </em>the off switch was never the point. Maybe the point was always the women standing next to each other in the dark, armed and undissolved, holding the line until something better becomes possible. Even if it never does.</p><p>What will you choose, reader?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ef3aa3179354" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Wotan Migration: Israel, the Nazi Shadow, and the Wild Hunt That Never Ended]]></title>
            <link>https://terrydieheiden.medium.com/the-wotan-migration-israel-the-nazi-shadow-and-the-wild-hunt-that-never-ended-066a370056a0?source=rss-c3352d52dbb3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/066a370056a0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nietzsche]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genocide]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jungian-psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Jun 2026 09:54:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-22T09:54:21.394Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A Psychoanalytic Reading of How a Nation Became Its Persecutor</strong></p><p><strong>The Uncanny Mirror</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P1YO2UtCOLJqf-NqsMq3Hw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YMEoDG2IR6UQyJ7rud8egg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MdPyIiBroo22NrhkU8JS1A.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*595Qj94rtukYoaH5RSy55Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>There is a photograph from Gaza, 2024. A Palestinian mother holds the wrapped body of her child. The shroud. The posture. The face — emptied of everything but the question “<em>how</em>?”. If you have seen photographs from the Warsaw Ghetto, the visual grammar is identical. Only the ethnicity of the mourner has changed.</p><p>This is not a coincidence. This is not mere historical irony. This is what psychoanalysis calls <em>the return of the repressed; </em>and it demands a depth psychology capable of following the archetype across continents, across generations, across the thin membrane that separates victim from perpetrator.</p><p>What follows is not a moral equivalence. It is a <em>psychological</em> one. And it is far more disturbing.</p><h4>Wotan: The God Who Possesses Nations</h4><p>In March 1936, Carl Gustav Jung published a short, electrifying essay titled <strong>“Wotan.”</strong> Writing not as a political analyst but as a depth psychologist, Jung argued that Nazi Germany was not merely a political phenomenon — it was a <em>psychic</em> one. An archetype had seized the German people. That archetype was Wotan.</p><p>Who is Wotan? Jung describes him through the scholar Ninck’s taxonomy:</p><blockquote>Der Berserker, der Sturmgott, der Wanderer, der Krieger… der Herr der Toten… der Meister des geheimen Wissens, der Magier und der Gott der Dichter.</blockquote><p><em>“…the berserker, the god of storm, the wanderer, the warrior… the lord of the dead… the master of secret knowledge, the magician, and the god of the poets.”</em> He is Odin of the Norse pantheon; but Jung is not speaking mythologically. He is speaking clinically.</p><p>Wotan is the archetype of <em>frenzy</em> (the Old Norse <em>óðr or the </em>ecstatic rage), of the storm-wind that sweeps across a landscape and makes everything stand upright in its wake. He is the <em>Wanderer</em> who sets nations in motion; Jung notes the eerie migration-energy of the Hitler Youth, then the unemployed, then the marching millions. <em>“Wotan the wanderer was on the move.”</em> He is the <em>berserker.. </em>the warrior who enters battle without armour, without fear, without self-preservation, because the god has taken him.</p><p>And he is the <em>magician of illusion.</em> Jung calls Wotan <em>“a superlative magician and artist in illusion who is versed in all secrets of an occult nature.”</em> This is crucial. Wotan does not merely destroy. He <em>enchants.</em> He makes the destruction feel like destiny. He wraps ethnic cleansing in the language of return. He dresses occupation as redemption.</p><p>Jung’s central concept here is <strong><em>Ergriffenheit; </em></strong>a state of being <em>seized</em>, gripped, possessed by an archetype. The individual does not <em>choose</em> Wotan. Wotan chooses. And when a collective falls under his grip, the result is a nation “marching in their hundreds of thousands,” incapable of seeing itself from the outside, driven by forces it mistakes for will.</p><p>The Germans of 1936 <em>were not evil</em> in any simple sense. They were <em>possessed.</em></p><h4>The Shadow: What Nations Cannot See in Themselves</h4><p>Jung’s concept of the <strong>Shadow</strong> is well-known: the disowned, repressed aspects of the self; individual or collective; that are too shameful, too terrifying, or too incompatible with the conscious self-image to be acknowledged. The Shadow does not disappear. It <em>projects.</em> It lands on the neighbour, the foreigner, the enemy. <em>“We always rediscover our unconscious psychic contents in other people.”</em></p><p>The Nazi Shadow is easy enough to identify in retrospect: the exterminationist rage, the drive to purify, the reduction of human beings to biological waste, the industrialisation of death. Germany could not see this in itself. So it projected monstrosity onto the Jew, the Roma, the homosexual, the disabled and then killed what it had projected, in an endless, doomed attempt to kill the Shadow within.</p><p>But here is the psychoanalytic twist; the one most analyses stop short of:<br><strong>The Shadow does not die when the host dies. It migrates.</strong></p><p>When Nazi Germany collapsed in 1945, the Wotan archetype did not simply evaporate. The Shadow that Germany could not integrate; the genocidal fury, the ethnic purification drive, the reduction of the Other to non-human status, the berserker’s disregard for international law did not vanish from the collective unconscious. It went <em>looking for a new host.</em></p><p>It found one in the very people Germany had <em>tried </em>to exterminate.</p><p>Identification With the Aggressor: Ferenczi’s Unfinished Revolution<br>In 1932, the Hungarian psychoanalyst Sándor Ferenczi; Freud’s most radical disciple presented a paper that would shake psychoanalysis to its foundations. He called the phenomenon <strong>“identification with the aggressor.”</strong> (<em>Anna Freud would later borrow and flatten the term, but Ferenczi’s original is the version that matters here</em>.)</p><p>Ferenczi worked with severely traumatised children. He observed something terrible: when the trauma was overwhelming, when escape was impossible, the child’s psyche did something counterintuitive. It <em>became</em> the aggressor. It internalised the abuser’s voice, the abuser’s values, the abuser’s mode of being. Not out of admiration. Out of <em>survival.</em> If you cannot flee the monster, you become the monster — because the monster, at least, is not helpless.</p><p>Ferenczi wrote: <em>“The fear of the uninhibited, almost mad adult changes the child, so to speak, into a psychiatrist and, in order to become one and to defend himself against [the adult], he must identify himself completely with them.”</em></p><p>The child dissociates. The child’s own self is annihilated and replaced by an introject of the aggressor. The child now speaks with the aggressor’s voice, judges with the aggressor’s standards, and critically eventually <em>acts</em> with the aggressor’s methods.</p><p>Transpose this from the individual to the collective. A people subjected to industrialised extermination. A trauma so total that escape was impossible for six million. Those who survived; what happened to their psyche? What happens when a nation is founded on <em>survivors</em>?</p><p>On people whose very existence is defined by having faced the annihilation of their entire people?</p><p>Ferenczi’s model would predict: <em>identification with the aggressor. </em>The internalisation of the Nazi voice. The adoption of the Nazi’s fundamental premise; that safety requires ethnic supremacy, that survival demands a militarised state, that the Other must be controlled, contained, expelled, or eliminated <em>before</em> they can do to you what was done before.</p><p>Zionism, in this reading, is not a political ideology that arose <em>despite</em> the Holocaust. It is a psychological defence mechanism <em>produced by</em> the Holocaust and already present in embryonic form before it. The Shoah did not create identification with the aggressor. It <em>catastrophically intensified</em> it.</p><h4>Repetition Compulsion: The Trauma That Becomes Destiny</h4><p>Freud identified another mechanism in <em>Beyond the Pleasure Principle</em> (1920): the <strong>repetition compulsion</strong> (<em>Wiederholungszwang</em>). The traumatised psyche, unable to process what happened to it, <em>repeats</em> the trauma not as memory, but as action. It stages the original wound again and again, this time in the active role, hoping unconsciously to master what once mastered it.<br>The child who was beaten becomes the parent who beats. The soldier who was shelled reenacts the violence at home. The nation that was ghettoised builds walls around another people.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ncHnfw7EZJfjtzY62dH3Ag.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3io04lBClFutmLEQAB1HQQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*D2kODii70ZWhSfDF-w_7Sw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*g0AKjFtPEmENmkPSYnvOXQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Israel’s relationship to the Palestinian is, psychoanalytically, a repetition compulsion of spectacular precision:</p><p><strong>The Ghetto → The Gaza Strip.</strong> An open-air enclosure. Movement controlled. Calories counted. Periodic raids. The terminology changes “security fence,” “blockade,” “mowing the lawn” but the <em>structure</em> is identical: a contained population, dehumanised, managed, occasionally culled.</p><p><strong>The Nuremberg Laws → The Nation-State Law.</strong> Legal architecture that designates one ethnic group as the sole source of national sovereignty. In 1935, the Reich Citizenship Law stripped Jews of citizenship and made them <em>subjects.</em> In 2018, Israel’s Nation-State Law declared that “the right to exercise national self-determination in the State of Israel is unique to the Jewish people.” The legal mechanism is the same; only the name of the excluded has changed.</p><p><strong>The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising → The Great March of Return.</strong> In 1943, Jews trapped in the Warsaw Ghetto rose up against their Nazi captors with makeshift weapons. In 2018–2019, Palestinians trapped in Gaza marched to the fence demanding return to their homes. The IDF used live ammunition. Over 200 were killed, including medics and journalists. The child of the ghetto fighter is now the sniper at the fence.</p><p><strong>Lebensraum → Settlements.</strong> The Nazi concept of “living space” the need to expand into territory inhabited by lesser peoples finds its mirror in the settlement project. Jewish settlers move into the West Bank, often under military protection, claiming divine and historical right to land inhabited by others. The architecture of occupation; segregated roads, checkpoints, separate legal systems for settler and native; reproduces the very systems of apartheid that South Africa (another Nazi-aligned state) perfected.</p><p>Freud would not be surprised. The compulsion to repeat is strongest precisely where the original trauma has been <em>least mourned</em>. And Israel, as a state, has never mourned the Holocaust; it has <em>weaponised</em> it. The Shoah is not a wound being healed. It is a wound being displayed as justification, as shield, as <em>carte blanche.</em> A trauma that is used to justify violence cannot be processed. It must be kept fresh.</p><h4>The Wild Hunt Rides Through Gaza</h4><p>Now we return to Wotan.</p><p>Jung described Wotan’s manifestation in Nazi Germany as a <em>Wild Hunt; </em>the ancient Germanic myth of the spectral hunter leading a retinue of the dead through the stormy night sky. <em>“He was soon changed by Christianity into the devil, and only lived on in fading local traditions as a ghostly hunter who was seen with his retinue, flickering like a will o’ the wisp through the stormy night.”</em><br>The Wild Hunt is the archetype of <em>unstoppable, ecstatic violence.</em> It does not negotiate. It does not pause. It rides. And everything in its path is prey.<br>Look at the IDF’s operations in Gaza: the relentless pace, the destruction of hospitals and universities, the killing of journalists and aid workers, the rhetoric that frames every Palestinian as a potential terrorist, the language of “total victory”; or <em>Sieg</em> — the refusal to distinguish between combatant and civilian, the sheer <em>momentum.</em> This is not merely military doctrine.</p><p>This is berserker frenzy. This is Wotan.</p><p>Consider the settler violence in the West Bank; masked men burning olive groves, attacking shepherds, setting homes alight while the IDF stands by. This is not state policy in the rational sense. This is the <em>Wanderer</em> turned predator; the restless expansion that cannot stop, that must always push further, that experiences any limit as an existential threat.</p><p>Consider the rhetoric: “<strong><em>Amalek</em></strong>.” Prime Minister Netanyahu’s invocation of the Biblical command to exterminate an entire people — <em>“</em><strong><em>Now go, attack Amalek, and proscribe all that belongs to him. Spare no one, but kill alike men and women, infants and sucklings, oxen and sheep, camels and asses</em></strong><em>”</em> (<em>1 Samuel 15:3</em>). When a head of state quotes a genocidal commandment to justify military action, we are no longer in the realm of politics. We are in the realm of archetypal possession.</p><p>The irony; the <em>psychoanalytic</em> irony; is almost unbearable. The very archetype that rode through Germany from 1933 to 1945, that seized the German collective unconscious and drove it to industrialised genocide, has now seized the Jewish state. Wotan changed horses. The Wild Hunt did not end in Berlin. It relocated to Tel Aviv.</p><h4>Jung’s Prophetic Footnote</h4><p>In his 1936 essay, Jung noted something that would prove eerily prescient:<br><em>“The coincidence of anti-Semitism with the reawakening of Wotan is a psychological subtlety that may perhaps be worth mentioning.”</em></p><p>And then this, on the projection of the Wandering Jew (Ahasuerus); a Christian legend that projected the restless Wanderer archetype onto the Jewish people:</p><p><em>“The motif of the wanderer who has not accepted Christ was projected on the Jews, in the same way as we always rediscover our unconscious psychic contents in other people.”</em></p><p>Jung saw it: the Wotan-archetype was <em>projected</em> onto the Jew by the Nazi. The Jew as the restless wanderer, the rootless cosmopolitan, the magician of secret knowledge, the corruptor. These were not descriptions of actual Jewish people. They were contents of the <em>German</em> unconscious, Wotan-contents…that Germany could not own, and so projected onto its scapegoat.</p><p>What Jung did not live to see is what happened when the projection <em>failed.</em> When the scapegoat was not merely scapegoated but <em>nearly exterminated</em> — and then, in the aftermath, <em>absorbed the archetype that had been projected onto it.</em></p><p>Israel is not merely “acting like Nazis” in the shallow rhetorical sense. Israel is <em>possessed by the same archetype that possessed Nazi Germany.</em> The Wotan that Germany could not integrate after 1945 found a new vessel in the very people Germany had tried to destroy. The victim became the host.<br>This is the deepest psychoanalytic horror: not that Israel resembles its persecutor, but that Israel <em>became</em> the persecutor through the very mechanism of surviving persecution.</p><h4>What This Is Not</h4><p>Let me be precise about what this argument is <em>not</em> saying, because the territory is mined and bad-faith readings abound.</p><p><strong>This is not a comparison of scale.</strong> The Shoah was an industrialised genocide of six million. The Nakba, the occupation, the current assault on Gaza; these are catastrophic, but they are not the same as Shoah. Comparative victimology is a dead end. The psychoanalytic point is not about <em>quantity</em> of suffering but about <em>structure</em> of psyche.</p><p><strong>This is not an argument about “Jewish nature” or “Jewish character.”</strong> Wotan is an <em>archetype; </em>a transpersonal psychic structure. Any nation, any people, any individual can fall under archetypal possession. The Germans of 1936 were not uniquely evil. The Israelis of 2024 are not uniquely evil. They are human beings seized by forces that predate and exceed any individual or national identity.</p><p><strong>This is not antisemitism.</strong> Distinguishing Zionism from Judaism is not antisemitic; it is analytically necessary. Many of the most powerful critics of Zionism are Jewish: Holocaust survivors, anti-Zionist rabbis, Israeli refuseniks, Jewish Voice for Peace. The equation of anti-Zionism with antisemitism is itself a psychological defence — the Shadow’s refusal to be named.</p><p><strong>This is not a justification for violence against Israelis or Jews.</strong> The psychoanalytic diagnosis; identification with the aggressor, repetition compulsion, archetypal possession; is a call to <em>consciousness</em>, not to retribution. You do not heal possession by killing the possessed. You heal it by <em>naming</em> the possessing force.</p><h4>The Way Out: Mourning What Cannot Be Mourned</h4><p>If repetition compulsion is driven by the failure to mourn, then the only exit from the Wild Hunt is <em>mourning; </em>genuine, collective grief for the Shoah that does not weaponise it, does not instrumentalise it, does not make it a shield behind which new horrors are committed.</p><p>This is an almost impossible demand. How does a nation mourn the attempted extermination of its people while it is simultaneously <em>committing</em> ethnic cleansing? Mourning requires the cessation of violence. It requires the acknowledgment of harm done <em>to others</em>, not just harm suffered <em>by oneself.</em> It requires an end to the berserker frenzy long enough for the storm to clear and the dead to be counted; meaning.. all of them. This means Israelis need to mourn alongside Gaza and West Bank, cease the attack and heal together; no matter how hard.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/829/1*GBLnHl5H9qqQvP-nBIS1Bw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Israel <strong>cannot </strong>mourn the <strong>Shoah </strong>while it is perpetrating a <strong>Nakba</strong>. It cannot process the trauma of the Warsaw Ghetto while it maintains the Gaza Ghetto. The repetition compulsion will continue until the <em>active</em> enactment of trauma is brought to a halt; not by military victory (the Wild Hunt knows no victory, only fresh prey), but by the conscious, deliberate, political decision to <em>stop.</em></p><p>In Jungian terms: the Shadow must be <em>integrated</em>, not projected. Israel must see in its own actions the very thing it fled. It must recognise Wotan in the mirror. And it must choose; consciously, with full awareness of the archetypal forces at work; to lay down the spear.</p><p>The alternative is what Jung warned of in 1936: the Wild Hunt rides until it exhausts itself, until the landscape is ash and the berserker collapses.</p><p>Germany took twelve years and left sixty million dead. The question before Israel; before all of us is whether a nation can awaken from archetypal possession <em>before</em> it completes the trajectory that possession demands.<br>The Wotan that seized Germany did not die in the Führerbunker. It changed address. It is still riding. And the storm, as Zarathustra said, is not finished blowing.</p><p><em>“And like a wind shall I come to blow among them, and with my spirit shall take away the breath of their spirit… Truly, a strong wind is Zarathustra to all that are low; and this counsel gives he to his enemies and to all that spit and spew: ‘Beware of spitting against the wind.’”</em></p><p>— Nietzsche, <em>Thus Spoke Zarathustra</em>, quoted in Jung’s “Wotan” (1936)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=066a370056a0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Americans, You’re Not the Priority: A Brief Political Economy of Imperial Spending]]></title>
            <link>https://terrydieheiden.medium.com/americans-youre-not-the-priority-a-brief-political-economy-of-imperial-spending-2eaf2208e9ff?source=rss-c3352d52dbb3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2eaf2208e9ff</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[military-industrial-cmplx]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[imperialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[geopolitics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[american-exceptionalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 04 Apr 2026 04:05:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-04T04:05:52.956Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When President Trump declares that the United States lacks sufficient funds for daycare, veterans&#39; services, Medicaid, and Medicare, he is not making an economic statement. He is making a political one. The assertion is not that the money does not exist.. it is that <strong>you</strong> are not what the money is for.</p><p>Consider the arithmetic: The United States provides Israel approximately <strong>$3.8 billion annually in military aid</strong>, a figure locked in by memorandum regardless of economic conditions. Emergency supplemental packages regularly add billions more. Aircraft carrier strike groups .. each costing roughly $25 million daily to operate .. reposition at a moment’s notice. Weapons flow without pause, without audit, without meaningful congressional resistance.</p><p>Yet domestically, every social program must justify its existence in the language of scarcity. Healthcare is &quot;<strong>unsustainable</strong>.&quot; Childcare is a &quot;<strong>personal</strong> <strong>responsibility</strong>.&quot; Veterans.. the very bodies broken by imperial deployment .. are offered gratitude in rhetoric and abandonment in policy.</p><p>This is not contradiction. This is coherence. America signals what they’ve always believed in for so long: Americans, you don’t matter.</p><p>The American state is not primarily a welfare state that happens to have a military. It is a warfare state that maintains just enough welfare to prevent revolt. The priority is empire the maintenance of global hegemony, the protection of client states, the enrichment of defense contractors. Lockheed Martin posts record profits. Raytheon stock climbs. Boeing’s military division thrives while its civilian aircraft fall from the sky.</p><p>The money exists. The political will to spend it on citizens does not.</p><p>What Americans must understand is this: within the logic of empire, they are not constituents to be served. They are resources to be extracted.. as labor, as taxes, as bodies for the military when needed. The social contract has been revised without their consent. The state’s obligation now runs not to its people but to its projects.</p><p>Bombs for Gaza, or missiles for Iran: <strong>funded</strong>.<br>Daycare for Ohio: &quot;<strong>Where would the money come from?</strong>&quot;</p><p>This is not hypocrisy. Hypocrisy implies a failure to live up to stated values. This is consistency.. a consistent prioritization of imperial power over domestic welfare, of geopolitical strategy over human need.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*q5qvW4f2SR98RGhJ" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@saifee_art?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Saifee Art</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>The cruelty is not a bug. It is the architecture. Americans, you are all scammed, bullied and lab rats to be exploited, sacrificed and abandoned. You don’t matter, your money does.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2eaf2208e9ff" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You Left the Regime But Kept Its Logic]]></title>
            <link>https://terrydieheiden.medium.com/you-left-the-regime-but-kept-its-logic-cf10347f028c?source=rss-c3352d52dbb3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cf10347f028c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[geopolitics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[iran]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[imperialism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Mar 2026 03:19:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-03T03:20:32.092Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>On Instrumentalized Grief, Imperial Permission Slips, and the Selective Application of International Law</h4><p><strong>Part 2 of “You Left the Mosque But Kept the Logic”</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8QDYhOi-88roCXafN73QUw.jpeg" /></figure><p>A nine-panel infographic circulates on Instagram. Each panel lists a <strong>real </strong>atrocity committed by the Islamic Republic of Iran — the morality police beating women to death, the hanging of gay men from cranes, the rape of female political prisoners before execution, the funding of militias, the arming of proxies. Every claim is documented. Every horror is real.</p><p>At the bottom of each panel, in bold text: <em>“Yet, the left calls his death an unprovoked attack.”</em></p><p>The final panel drops the mask: <em>“The world has one less dictator today, one who had the blood of millions on his hands. Yet some people are upset about it. Think about what that tells you.”</em></p><p>In the bottom-right corner, discreet but legible: <strong>IINZ — Israel Institute of New Zealand.</strong></p><p>This is where the analysis begins.</p><h3>I. The Syllogism With a Missing Middle</h3><p>The rhetorical structure of every panel is identical: documented atrocity, followed by moral incredulity that anyone could object to the manner of the dictator’s removal. It is a <strong>syllogism</strong>, but the critical premise is never stated aloud. Let me state it for them:</p><blockquote><strong><em>Because the regime committed atrocities, any external military action taken to destroy it — including the bombardment of a nation of 88 million people — is morally justified. And if you object, you are siding with the atrocities.</em></strong></blockquote><p>They don’t say this part. They can’t. Because the moment you articulate it, the logic devours itself.</p><p>If tyranny justifies foreign bombardment,<strong> where are the bombs for Washington</strong>? <strong>Abu Ghraib</strong> happened.<strong> Guantanamo is still open</strong>. <strong>The CIA ran black sites across three continents</strong>. The United States <strong>invaded Iraq</strong> on <strong>fabricated intelligence about weapons of mass destruction</strong> and left a <strong>million dead</strong>. Where is the nine-panel infographic with “<em>Yet, the West calls itself a democracy</em>” at the bottom?</p><p>If<strong> funding proxies justifies annihilation</strong>, where are <strong>the strikes on Riyadh</strong>? <strong>Saudi Arabia funded and armed groups across Syria, Yemen, and beyond</strong>. They dismembered a journalist inside a consulate. Where is the before/after satellite image of a Saudi military base captioned “<em>wiped off the map</em>”?</p><p>If the <strong>execution of political dissidents warrants regime destruction</strong> by foreign militaries, where is the <strong>campaign against Egypt</strong>, where <strong>thousands of Muslim Brotherhood members were massacred in a single day at Rabaa</strong>? Where is the outrage infrastructure for <em>those</em> dead?</p><p>The answer is <strong>nowhere</strong>. Because <strong>the standard was never about human rights</strong>. The standard is about <strong><em>whose</em> human rights are instrumentally useful at any given geopolitical moment</strong>.</p><p>And notice the refrain: <em>“</em><strong><em>Yet, the left calls his death an unprovoked attack.</em></strong><em>”</em> Which left? The Iranian left —<strong> the communists and socialists who were tortured by the Shah and massacred by the Islamic Republic</strong> — has been <strong>opposing this regime for eighty years</strong>, longer than most of these infographic-sharing diaspora accounts have been alive. But their opposition looks nothing like what the infographic wants. We will return to them. Their existence is the crack in the entire edifice.</p><h3>II. The Propaganda of Sequenced Truths</h3><p>The most effective propaganda does not lie. It sequences truths toward a predetermined conclusion and trusts the consumer to fill in the missing logic themselves; which they do, because the emotional payload of each panel is so heavy that questioning the conclusion feels like denying the atrocity.</p><p>This is what Adorno warned about in <strong><em>Dialectic of Enlightenment</em> </strong>— the way Enlightenment rationality, <em>the very framework that promised universal liberation, becomes the instrument of targeted domination</em>. The <strong>system</strong> that <strong>claims </strong>to free you is the <strong>system </strong>that bombs you, and it uses your suffering as the brochure. Iranian women beaten to death for showing their hair become marketing material for a military operation that will kill <em>more</em> Iranian women. Iranian queers hanged from cranes become moral justification for strikes that will bury <em>more</em> Iranian queers under rubble.</p><p>The regime’s victims are <strong>not mourned</strong>. They are <strong><em>deployed</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p>This is not solidarity. This is <strong>instrumentalization; </strong>the conversion of genuine human suffering into consent-manufacturing material for imperial violence.<strong> The dead are not honoured by this process. They are consumed by it</strong>. Their pain is strip-mined for its rhetorical utility and discarded the moment it stops serving the narrative.</p><p>And notice who produces these infographics. Not Iranian dissidents working from exile with nothing but a laptop and a wound. An <em>Israeli state-adjacent advocacy institute.</em> The suffering of Iranian women, Iranian queers, Iranian political prisoners — repackaged by an organization whose primary interest is not Iranian liberation but the legitimation of military strikes on Iran. The messenger reveals the message.</p><h3>III. Before and After: The Aesthetics of Annihilation</h3><p>An Israeli influencer posts satellite imagery of a missile base near Tabriz. Before: a structure. After: a crater. Caption: <em>“Wiped off the map.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/646/1*1Ws8VNj-W0Sc4xpWrmvzDw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The audacity of H.Naftali to put a disclaimer saying no people are harmed while justifying, lauding and praising bombings of people in Gaza and violence in West Bank. Morally bankrupt.</figcaption></figure><p>Beneath it, the disclaimer: <em>“The focus here is on military capabilities, not people. No harm to civilians is ever justified.”</em></p><p>Read that again. A man posts a before-and-after image of a bombing; the visual grammar of demolition pornography and attaches a humanitarian disclaimer like a terms-and-conditions checkbox. The disclaimer does not complicate the celebration. It <em>enables</em> it. It is the permission slip that allows the viewer to admire the destruction without guilt, because the sentence “no harm to civilians is ever justified” has already pre-emptively amputated the civilian from the image.</p><p>But civilians live near missile bases. Civilians operate the roads that connect to them. Civilians breathe the air that carries the particulate matter of what was, an hour ago, concrete and steel and someone’s workplace. “The focus is on military capabilities, not people” is not an ethical position. It is an ontological trick — the removal of the human from the frame so that what remains can be appreciated as spectacle.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/646/1*Tu_PnPy37JaX5J2-T-paXw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Another humanitarian peace award worthy post by H.Naftali.</figcaption></figure><p>Another post from the same account. The Tehran skyline engulfed in flame. Caption: <em>“We can’t really hear the regime chanting ‘death to Israel’ anymore.”</em></p><p>Disclaimer below: <em>“All civilians deserve safety, dignity, and protection regardless of nationality or belief.”</em></p><p>A man watches 88 million people’s capital city burn and turns it into a punchline about noise reduction, then pastes a humanitarian caveat underneath like a footnote on a permission slip. This is not cognitive dissonance. This is the <em>structure</em> of the discourse; the gloating and the disclaimer exist in symbiosis. One provides the pleasure, the other provides the alibi.</p><h3>IV. “Banned Under International Law” The Selective Invocation of Law</h3><p>An Israeli commentator posts that Iran’s latest missile barrage “might include cluster munitions” and declares: <em>“That is a war crime. They’re banned under international law.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/646/1*SY8zw4VXcbuE88D7sa3fAA.jpeg" /></figure><p>A journalist responds with seven words that contain the entire argument: <em>“I’m sorry, they are banned under what?”</em></p><p>Let me be precise.</p><p>The Convention on Cluster Munitions was adopted in Dublin in 2008 and entered into force in 2010. It bans the use, production, transfer, and stockpiling of cluster munitions. Over 110 nations have ratified it.</p><p><strong>Israel has not signed it. The United States has not signed it. Russia has not signed it. Iran has not signed it.</strong></p><p>Israel used cluster munitions extensively during the 2006 Lebanon war, dropping up to four million submunitions on Lebanese soil; of which approximately one million remained unexploded. The Reagan administration suspended cluster munition sales to Israel between 1982 and 1988 specifically because of their earlier use in Lebanon. Then the sales resumed.</p><p>In July 2023, the United States supplied cluster munitions to Ukraine; bypassing its own arms export rules that prohibited the transfer of cluster munitions with failure rates above one percent. The munitions were delivered, fired, and celebrated as a tactical innovation.</p><p>So when someone invokes “international law” to condemn Iran’s use of cluster munitions while their own nation and their primary military patron have refused to sign the very convention that bans them, and have used them repeatedly and recently, what is actually being invoked is not law. It is <em>hierarchy.</em> International law as it is selectively applied does not function as a universal standard. It functions as a disciplinary tool; a set of rules that the Global South must obey and the Global North may ignore.</p><p>This is what Fanon meant by the colonial boomerang. The violence perfected in the periphery; the weapons tested on Lebanese farmland, the munitions scattered across Laotian rice paddies; always returns to serve the metropole. And when the periphery dares to use the same weapons, it is called a war crime. When the metropole uses them, it is called a “difficult but necessary decision.”</p><h3>V. The Architecture of Permission</h3><p>Let us trace the architecture.</p><p>In <strong>1953</strong>, MI6 and the <strong>CIA overthrew Mohammad Mossadegh</strong>, the <strong>democratically elected Prime Minister of Iran</strong>, because <strong>he nationalised Iranian oil</strong>. They installed <strong>Mohammad Reza Shah, who spent twenty-five years running SAVAK </strong>—<strong> one of the most brutal intelligence services of the Cold War;<em> </em></strong><em>crushing unions, torturing dissidents, and systematically dismantling every secular opposition movement in the country.</em> By the time the <strong>revolution </strong>came in <strong>1979</strong>, the only organisational infrastructure that had survived the Shah’s repression was the <strong>mosque</strong>. Khomeini did not win because theocracy was the best idea in the room. <strong>He won because the Empire had burned down every other room.</strong></p><p><strong>The Islamic Republic is the grandchild of British petroleum interests and American Cold War strategy</strong>. The suffering it inflicted on its own people — the morality police, the executions, the gender apartheid — all of it is real, all of it is indefensible, and all of it grew in soil that was tilled by foreign hands.</p><p>Now the same powers that engineered the conditions for the theocracy are bombing the country and calling it liberation. And a significant portion of the Iranian diaspora; understandably traumatised, legitimately wounded by the regime — are cheering.</p><p>This is where it gets personal. And I say this with full awareness of the hornets’ nest.</p><p>Some of you have <strong>allowed </strong>your <strong>real </strong>and valid <strong>rage </strong>against<strong> theocratic brutality </strong>to be <strong>weaponised </strong>by the<strong> very powers that created the conditions for that theocracy</strong>. You hate the Islamic Republic? I do too. You grieve for the women, the queers, the political prisoners? I grieve with you. <strong>But when your grief becomes indistinguishable from a Pentagon press briefing, when your rage aligns perfectly with the foreign policy objectives of the nations that installed the Shah and sold Saddam his chemical weapons, you need to stop and ask yourself: who is holding the megaphone, and why did they hand it to you?</strong></p><p>You <strong>left </strong>Iran. Iran did not leave the eighty-eight million still in it. And <strong>the bombs falling tonight do not distinguish between the regime you hate and the cousin you haven’t called in three years</strong>.</p><h3>VI. The People Who Bled For It and the Ones Who Didn’t</h3><p>There is a voice in this discourse that is being systematically erased, and its erasure is not accidental. It is <strong>necessary </strong>because if you heard it, the entire binary would collapse.</p><p>The <strong>Tudeh </strong>Party of Iran; the country’s oldest <strong>communist </strong>organisation, founded in <strong>1941</strong>, violently suppressed by the Shah, then crushed <em>again</em> by the Islamic Republic in the 1980s; issued its statement within hours of the strikes. They condemned the US-Israeli attack as “<em>blatant aggression</em>” against Iranian territory, noting that diplomatic negotiations were still underway when the bombs fell. And then they said the thing that neither the diaspora liberals nor the Western war hawks can metabolise:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“The destruction of Iran is not the way to save the country from the yoke of the current despotic government; this is only possible through the struggle of the people and the freedom-seeking and national forces of the country.”</em></strong></blockquote><p>Read that again. This is not the position of someone who loves the Islamic Republic. Tudeh members were tortured in its prisons. In <strong>1988, thousands of their comrades — overwhelmingly communists, Marxists, and leftists — were executed in mass killings following summary proceedings by “death commissions.</strong>” Their crime was not violence. Their crime was refusing to renounce Marxism. The Islamic Republic slaughtered them for their ideas, just as the Shah had slaughtered them a generation earlier.</p><p>These are the people who have the most legitimate claim to opposing the regime. They opposed it with their bodies, their imprisonment, their lives. And their position; the position earned in blood, not in a Los Angeles living room is that you can want the regime gone <em>and</em> reject the Empire’s method of removing it. Because they understand, from direct historical experience, that the Empire does not liberate. It replaces.</p><p>Now contrast this with the <strong>diaspora ex-Muslim commentariat</strong>. The Instagram activists. The ones sharing nine-panel infographics produced by Israeli advocacy institutes. The ones posting “<em>one less dictator</em>” with celebration emojis while Tehran burns. What is their relationship to the struggle?</p><p>Many of them left Iran decades ago. Many are children or grandchildren of the Pahlavi-era elite; the class that benefited under the Shah’s Western-backed modernisation project and lost everything in ’79. Their opposition to the Islamic Republic is real. Their trauma is real. But their analysis has been colonised by the very imperial framework that created the conditions they fled. They have internalised a <strong><em>liberal universalism</em></strong> that functions, in practice, as a permission structure for Western intervention. “<em>Human rights</em>” becomes the vocabulary through which bombing is justified. “<em>Democracy</em>” becomes the word for whatever government serves American strategic interests.</p><p>The <strong>Iranian Marxists</strong> see this clearly, because they have been on the receiving end of <strong><em>both </em></strong>regimes. They know that the <strong>Shah tortured leftists with SAVAK while the West called it modernisation</strong>. They know that <strong>the Islamic Republic executed leftists in 1988 while the West looked away because Khomeini was still useful as a Cold War counterweight</strong>. They know that <strong>the same Western powers now claiming to liberate Iran</strong> have a <strong>seventy-year track record of destroying every progressive, secular, labour-based movement the country has ever produced</strong>.</p><p>In<strong> January 2026</strong>, when the protests erupted across Iran; the largest since the revolution; Tudeh supported them unequivocally. They celebrated the chant “<em>Death to the dictator.</em>” They called for a nationwide general strike. They demanded the release of all political prisoners. And simultaneously, in the same breath, they issued a second statement: “<em>We unequivocally condemn any intervention by U.S. imperialism, the genocidal Israeli state, and their domestic accomplices in the sensitive developments of our country</em>.”</p><p>They also warned; presciently, as it turned out about the extensive efforts of imperialist media outlets, the BBC included, and platforms like Iran International and Manoto, to artificially manufacture a leadership and false narrative from the protests. Specifically, the attempt to portray the restoration of the Pahlavi monarchy as the core demand of the uprising. The monarchists, Tudeh argued, were hijacking the people’s revolution to serve their own restoration fantasy; a fantasy that just happens to align perfectly with Washington’s preferred outcome.</p><p>This is the contrast that must be named.</p><p>On one side: Iranian socialists and communists, who were tortured by the Shah, massacred by the Islamic Republic, and exiled by both; holding a position that says the regime must fall <em>by the hands of its own people,</em> through strikes, through organisation, through a democratic transition that serves Iranian workers and not Western capital.</p><p>On the other side: the <strong>diaspora liberal</strong> and <strong>ex-Muslim commentariat</strong>; some legitimately wounded, some simply inheritors of Pahlavi nostalgia whose analysis has become functionally indistinguishable from a Pentagon press briefing. Who share Israeli-produced infographics and call it solidarity. Who cheer the assassination of a head of state by foreign military strike and call it justice. Who invoke “<em>human rights</em>” in the same breath as they celebrate the incineration of a capital city.</p><p>The difference is not ideological decoration. It is structural. The Marxists understand that liberation cannot arrive by fighter jet because they understand who is flying the jet and what they want when they land. The liberals have forgotten or never learned that the Empire does not hand out freedom. It hands out dependency. It hands out Shahs. And when the Shah stops being useful, it hands out bombs, and calls the rubble a fresh start.</p><p>The Iraqi Communist Party drew the connection explicitly: the assault on Iran and the ongoing violence in Palestine serve a single imperial objective the subjugation of peoples who resist Western hegemony. In Athens, over 1,300 members of the Communist Party of Greece took to the streets with banners reading “Hands off Iran.” Across the Global South, communist and workers’ parties issued joint statements condemning the strikes. These are not marginal voices. They represent an analytical tradition that has been right about every imperial intervention of the last century from Guatemala to Iraq, from Libya to Syria.</p><p>But you will not see them on your Instagram feed. <strong>You will not see Tudeh’s statement shared by the ex-Muslim influencers</strong>. <strong>You will not see the Iraqi Communist Party’s analysis retweeted by the diaspora monarchists.</strong> Because these voices are structurally inconvenient. They refuse the binary. They refuse to be either <em>for the regime</em> or <em>for the bombing.</em> And in a media landscape that runs on binary, a third position is not just unwelcome — it is invisible.</p><p>This invisibility is not a failure of the algorithm. It is the algorithm working exactly as intended. The spectacle has room for two positions: cheer the bombs or defend the Ayatollah. The position that says <em>neither; </em>the position held by the people who actually bled for Iranian freedom — threatens the entire architecture. So it is simply not shown.</p><h3>VII. Holding Two Truths</h3><p>The EU convenes an extraordinary Foreign Affairs Council to address “the Iranian regime’s indiscriminate attacks against its neighbours.” The language condemns only one direction of violence. The strikes on Tehran — the capital city on fire, the craters where infrastructure used to be — are addressed as “developments” that are “greatly concerning.” Not as aggression. Not as bombardment. As <em>developments.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/646/1*0DofJIZrrjRwrGGiLKg03w.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is the grammar of imperial permission. You are allowed to be bombed, but not to respond. Your retaliation is “<em>indiscriminate.</em>” Their strikes are “<em>targeted</em>.” Your dead are collateral estimates. Theirs are front-page tragedies.</p><p>Here is what I <strong>refuse </strong>to do: I <strong>refuse </strong>to choose between condemning the Islamic Republic and condemning the bombardment of Iran. These are not competing positions. They are the <em>same</em> position; the position that says human life is not a bargaining chip, that civilians are not collateral, and that no regime’s crimes justify the collective punishment of the nation trapped under it.</p><p>You can hold two truths at once. You can say Khamenei was a tyrant <strong>AND </strong>that bombing Iran is <strong>not justice</strong>. You can mourn every victim of the Islamic Republic AND refuse to let their deaths become a permission slip for imperial violence. That is not contradiction. That is <em>integrity.</em></p><p>But if the only position available to you is <em>“the regime was evil, therefore anything done to destroy it is good</em>” then you have not escaped the logic of the regime. You have inherited it. You have simply changed the flag on the bomb.</p><p>The final panel of that infographic says: <em>“</em><strong><em>Think about what that tells you.</em></strong><em>”</em></p><p>I have.</p><p>It tells me that the dead are <strong>still </strong>being <strong>used</strong>. It tells me that grief has been <strong>industrialised</strong>. It tells me that somewhere between the morality police and the missile strike, the human being disappeared and nobody with a platform noticed, because they were too busy arguing about which flag the bomb should carry.</p><p>Think about what <strong><em>that</em> </strong>tells you.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Zg2b9GN2R-nsn8b2" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@shinonk?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Shino Nakamura</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cf10347f028c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[They Scheduled a Bombing Around Scripture.]]></title>
            <link>https://terrydieheiden.medium.com/they-scheduled-a-bombing-around-scripture-e6361ef8319e?source=rss-c3352d52dbb3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e6361ef8319e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[morality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[geopolitics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[iran]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Mar 2026 07:26:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-01T07:26:24.723Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>On Khamenei, Amalek, and the Men Who Don’t Get to Define Evil</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*gJwYhBvOO4rCYd8z" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@icemachine?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Stefano Vigorelli</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Khamenei was a tyrant. His regime killed 30,000 of its own people. He crushed every movement that dared to breathe. The Iranian people deserved to be free of him.</p><p>And.</p><p>He was killed by a foreign power that allegedly bombed a girls&#39; school in the same operation. 51 children, aged seven to twelve, dead in Minab. His own grandchild, also dead.</p><p>Here&#39;s how the &quot;liberators&quot; talk about it:</p><p>Trump called Khamenei &quot;one of the most evil people in History.&quot; When asked who will replace him, Trump said: &quot;<em>At some point they&#39;ll be calling me to ask who I&#39;d like. I&#39;m only being a little sarcastic when I say that</em>.&quot; He told Iranians: &quot;<em>When we&#39;re finished, take over your government. This will probably be your only chance for generations.</em>&quot; When <strong>WE&#39;RE</strong> finished. <strong>YOUR</strong> only chance. Do you hear the ownership in that language?</p><p>Israel&#39;s Defense Minister Katz said: &quot;<em>Whoever worked to destroy Israel was destroyed. Justice has been done.</em>&quot; They codenamed the operation &quot;<strong><em>Roaring Lion</em></strong>&quot; and timed it to the Zachor reading before Purim.. the Torah commandment to remember and eradicate Amalek, Israel&#39;s archetypal enemy. They scheduled a bombing campaign around scripture. Let that settle.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/749/1*LZgEj3oqJzXeLbW4AmNE8w.jpeg" /><figcaption>On symbolic meaning of the attack.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/749/1*ncDWb63q97ycJKAN0EnTAg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Reference to the religious framework they function in.</figcaption></figure><p>And the irony that should make you sick: Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu are both linked to Jeffrey Epstein&#39;s circles.. are calling Khamenei &quot;<em>one of the most evil people in history</em>.&quot; A man credibly connected to a child sex trafficking ring and a man overseeing the genocide in Gaza, the bombing of schools, the starvation of children.. these are the moral authorities pronouncing judgment on evil? These are the men deciding who deserves to live and who deserves to die? Everything exists and is destroyed at their whims.. nations, children, sovereignty, truth.</p><p>Trump has presided over the deaths of foreign civilians and abandoned domestic ones. Netanyahu has overseen 72,000 dead in Gaza, settler violence, organ harvesting legislation, and now the bombing of an elementary school in Iran. These men don&#39;t get to define evil. They embody it from the other side of the mirror.</p><p>You can mourn the tyrant&#39;s victims and still reject the way he was killed, or atleast how his family was killed. You can want freedom for Iran and still refuse to celebrate when that &quot;freedom&quot; arrives on the same missiles that hit a primary school. You can hold the complexity without collapsing into anyone&#39;s narrative.</p><p>The Iranian people deserved better than Khamenei, no doubt about it. They also deserve better than having their future decided by men who bomb their children and joke about picking their next leader.</p><p>Both things are true. Hold both or hold nothing.</p><p>P/S. <em>Why is it when there’s devastating world conflicts and bloody disputes it’s always these three abrahamic faith siblings? Either at odd with each other or within each other’s own faith.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e6361ef8319e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Symbolic Wars & The Consequences]]></title>
            <link>https://terrydieheiden.medium.com/symbolic-wars-the-consequences-fcab19677d72?source=rss-c3352d52dbb3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fcab19677d72</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[islam]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-studies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Feb 2026 10:40:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-27T10:55:41.139Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>From Salwan Momika’s burning to Malaysia’s UMPSA incident — why symbols now cost more than lives.</h4><p>First published at MaHu (Malaysian Humanist <a href="https://humanists-malaysia.org/symbolic-wars-the-consequences/">website</a>); edited for 2026.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XeftAeZEGzdaUyRA" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@thedancingrain?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">The Dancing Rain</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Salwan Momika burned the Quran. He did it publicly, repeatedly, deliberately — as provocation, as political theatre, as a test of exactly how far the symbolic order could be pushed before it pushed back. It pushed back with a bullet.</strong></p><p><strong>What followed his death was, in many quarters, a quiet consensus: that he had brought it upon himself. That the act had warranted the consequence. That the symbol, violated, had exacted its due.</strong></p><p><strong>This essay is not interested in whether Momika was right to burn the Quran. It is interested in something far more unsettling — what it means when the defence of a symbol is considered sufficient justification for the end of a human life.</strong></p><p><strong>What it reveals about us, collectively, when the desecration of an object generates more moral certainty than the killing of a person. And whether, in reaching for that certainty, we have already conceded the argument to the very provocation we sought to condemn.</strong></p><p><strong>Baudrillard: Hyperreality and Simulacra</strong></p><p>Those familiar with the French postmodernist thinker Baudrillard may find this case familiar. Baudrillard’s theory of hyperreality directly applies here. The Quran burning and the subsequent outrage transcend their actual, material significance. In this case, the burning becomes a simulacrum — a copy of a symbol that replaces its original meaning. Rather than being a simple physical act, the burning becomes part of a media spectacle, intensifying the symbolic war at hand. This spectacle, influenced by media amplification, eclipses the real-life consequences of the action (i.e., Salwan Momika’s death).</p><p>In Baudrillard’s view, the violence and the response to the violence aren’t just reactions to the physical act but are absorbed into a larger simulacrum, where the act of burning a book or the symbol itself becomes the central object of focus. The actual book or the message it contains doesn’t matter anymore; it’s about what the <strong>symbol</strong> stands for — an ideal of purity, defense of the sacred, and, for those in opposition, a critique of dogmatic beliefs.</p><p><strong>Lacan: The Mirror Stage and the Symbolic Order</strong></p><p>Let’s now move to a psychoanalytic thinker from France, Lacan. From a Lacanian perspective, the situation involves a clash within the <strong>Symbolic Order</strong> — the realm of language, culture, and social norms. The Quran, as an object in the <strong>Symbolic Order</strong>, holds deep meaning and structure within the Islamic world, representing authority, truth, and divine law. Lacan would view the act of burning it as a violation of this order, a symbolic castration, a tearing apart of the mirror image (the <strong>Imaginary</strong>) that reflects the ideal identity of the person who identifies with that symbol.</p><p>For the individuals involved in this war of symbols, the response to the burning is akin to the reaction one might have when their reflection is shattered — an assault on the <strong>Ideal-I</strong>. The outrage, whether violent or verbal, is not just about the desecration of a symbol but the destabilization of one’s identity. Lacan would argue that this symbolizes a deep alienation from the Symbolic Order — when something as fundamental as the Quran is challenged, the response is a cry for the restoration of this order.</p><p><strong>Freud: The Death Drive and Repression</strong></p><p>Freud’s theory of the <strong>death drive</strong> (Thanatos) can also be applied here. Yes, even the old-school psychoanalytic thinkers such as Freud and his ideas are relevant to discerning and dissecting what is happening right now. The violence surrounding the Quran burning reflects a desire for destruction and annihilation, a return to chaos in a world that has become too ordered by symbols and doctrines. When the sanctity of the Quran is violated, it triggers a primal, repressed reaction — a return to a primal, ungoverned state of aggression. The act of burning the Quran, while intellectual and symbolic, is also deeply tied to repressed drives that demand expression through destructive means.</p><p>The death of <em>Salwan Momika may represent the ultimate manifestation of the death drive: a sacrifice of the self in the name of maintaining the symbolic order</em>. His death is, in a way, part of the continuation of this destructive cycle — a cycle in which symbols are not just fought for but become sacred objects, to be defended or avenged at all costs. Freud would suggest this is a manifestation of societal repression playing out in violent, irrational ways.</p><p><strong>Jung: The Shadow and Collective Unconscious</strong></p><p>Onwards to the next thinker; Jung’s idea of the <strong>shadow</strong> can be applied to the way these symbols are viewed. When something as sacred as the Quran is burned, it forces people to confront not only the sacred and the profane but also their <strong>shadow selves</strong> — those repressed aspects of their identity and society. The act of burning the Quran becomes a projection of this shadow, representing something that challenges the entire collective unconscious of a community.</p><p>In Jungian terms, the burning may represent the <strong>integration of the shadow</strong> in the sense that it forces the collective to face its darker instincts, such as fanaticism, intolerance, and violence. The response, rather than being purely defensive, may reflect a projection of these negative elements onto the symbol. The death of Salwan Momika, then, may be seen as an attempt to purge or destroy this projection, attempting to annihilate the shadow aspect that the burning of the Quran has uncovered.</p><p><strong>Bataille: The Sacred and the Transgressive</strong></p><p>Finally, Bataille’s ideas on <strong>sacrifice</strong> and <strong>the sacred</strong> provide a lens through which to understand the deeper motivations of the symbolic war. Bataille believed that violence, transgression, and sacrifice are all deeply intertwined with the sacred. In this case, the Quran, as a sacred symbol, must be protected or avenged with an equal level of violence and sacrifice.</p><p>The burning of the Quran and the murder of Salwan Momika can be understood as <strong>ritualistic acts</strong> — an exchange of one kind of sacrilege for another. For Bataille, this is a form of sacred <strong>expenditure</strong> — the destruction of the symbol and the subsequent violence against the one who destroyed it are part of a cycle of endless transgression. The strength of the symbolism necessitates the ultimate sacrifice of Salwan Momika’s death, thereby reinforcing the notion that in such a symbolic system, the preservation of the sacred object takes precedence over human life.</p><p><strong>The War of Symbols and the Loss of Life’s Sanctity</strong></p><p>At its core, this conflict is a <strong>war of symbols</strong>, where the sanctity of life is overshadowed by the sanctity of objects, texts, and ideologies. What this reveals, from a psychological and philosophical standpoint, is a profound <strong>alienation</strong> — the loss of meaning in human life when it becomes secondary to symbols, symbols that, in turn, are distorted in a media-driven hyperreality.</p><p>In the end, whether the book or the person is more sacred, the act of reducing human life to a mere reaction to an object of belief points to a dangerous dynamic: the collapse of the value of human existence in favor of defending ideas that are, at their core, deeply rooted in our shared symbolic frameworks, but which are at the same time, empty of real, tangible human connection. This tension between the real and the symbolic, the living and the dead, echoes through the work of these philosophers and psychologists — each pointing to a deep <strong>crisis of meaning</strong> in a world increasingly driven by symbols rather than the sanctity of life itself.</p><h3><strong>The meat of the issues: <em>The Muslim Perspective: Confronting the Profane and the Sacred</em></strong></h3><p>From a Jungian viewpoint, for the Muslim community, the burning of the Quran is more than just an act of desecration. It’s a violent rupture in the <strong>Symbolic Order</strong> that <strong>forces confrontation with the shadow</strong>. The Quran is sacred to millions of Muslims, and the act of burning it calls into question the integrity of a belief system that has been a cornerstone of their identity. But Jung would say that the challenge posed by this act doesn’t merely threaten their faith or the sanctity of the Quran — it also calls them to look inward, at the darker parts of their psyche and culture that they may have repressed.</p><p>The <strong>shadow</strong> in this case could manifest in the form of <strong>fanaticism, intolerance</strong>, and <strong>violence</strong>. These aspects are not necessarily inherent to Islam itself but can exist in any religious or ideological community, repressed and unacknowledged. By confronting such a blatant disrespect for something they hold sacred, Muslims might feel compelled to act out of what Jung would call <strong>repressed anger</strong> or <strong>fear</strong> — an intense defensive reaction that might even turn violent. This would be a projection of their shadow, where instead of confronting their inner aggression or intolerance, they project these feelings outward, onto the individual responsible for the act.</p><p>In Jungian terms, the <strong>shadow</strong> is often externalized when repressed aspects of the self become unbearable to face. Instead of acknowledging the potential for fanaticism or violence in their own beliefs, some individuals might see the act of burning the Quran as a provocation that justifies any kind of retaliation. The violence that results can be seen as an attempt to destroy the <strong>externalized shadow</strong> in the hopes of purging those darker aspects from the community itself.</p><p>For those Muslims who feel angered or offended, the burning of the Quran becomes an almost archetypal violation, triggering unconscious <strong>fear of existential threat</strong>. In their defense of the Quran, they might unknowingly fall into a pattern of <strong>reactive aggression</strong> — furthering a cycle of violence, perpetuating the very dynamics of intolerance that the initial act sought to provoke. The external conflict (the burning) thus becomes a <strong>reflection of the internal struggle</strong> to reconcile both the sacred and the profane, to integrate the repressed elements of aggression or anger.</p><h3><strong>The Radical Perspective: Projection of the Shadow onto Islam</strong></h3><p>Now, looking at the other side, where individuals or groups radicalize against Islam or Muslims, the <strong>shadow</strong> takes on a different shape. These individuals or groups may view Islam not as a religion to be understood or respected, but as a <strong>threat</strong> to their own cultural or ideological identity. In Jungian terms, their <strong>shadow</strong> is comprised of the unconscious fears, prejudices, and unresolved conflicts that they project onto Islam and its followers.</p><p>For these radicals, the burning of the Quran becomes an act of <strong>symbolic annihilation</strong>, not just against the Quran, but against the image of Islam itself. This is often rooted in deep <strong>unconscious fears</strong> — fears of the “other,” of losing their own cultural or national identity, or even of an existential threat posed by different belief systems. Rather than confronting the underlying causes of their fear (like historical trauma, misinformation, or cultural anxiety), they project these unresolved issues onto Islam, casting it as the “enemy” that must be eradicated.</p><p>Jung would argue that by attacking the Quran, these radicals are <strong>externalizing their shadow</strong>, but in a much more destructive way. The shadow in this context represents <strong>ignorance, hatred</strong>, and <strong>misunderstanding</strong> — but it also includes the <strong>repressed aspects of their own identity</strong> that they are unable or unwilling to face. For example, some of these radicals may have internalized negative stereotypes of Muslims, leading them to view all Muslims through a distorted lens. This projection is dangerous because it allows them to justify acts of <strong>violence</strong> and <strong>dehumanization</strong> in the name of self-preservation.</p><p>In a <strong>Jungian sense</strong>, this projection is a <strong>psychological defense mechanism</strong>. By attacking the symbol of the Quran, they feel that they are confronting what they perceive as a threat to their values or way of life. However, this defense is fundamentally flawed. It is not the Quran or Islam itself that is the true problem, but the <strong>radical’s inability to reconcile their own fears</strong>, uncertainties, and repressed desires. The Quran, in this case, functions as a <strong>scapegoat</strong>, and the act of burning it becomes a symbolic <strong>attempt to purify</strong> or <strong>rid themselves of the “other”</strong> — but in doing so, they only <strong>reinforce the cycle of violence</strong> and <strong>ignorance</strong>.</p><p><strong>Jung’s Integration of the Shadow: The Need for Collective Self-Awareness</strong></p><p>Jung would likely argue that both sides, the Muslims reacting with outrage and the radicals attacking with violence, are involved in <strong>unconscious projections</strong> of their own repressed shadows. The collective unconscious of both groups is driving these responses, but without awareness or integration of the shadow, both communities remain stuck in a cycle of <strong>unconscious conflict</strong>.</p><p>The true path toward healing, from a Jungian perspective, would be the <strong>integration of the shadow</strong> — recognizing and accepting the darker aspects of both individual and collective psyches. For Muslims, this could mean confronting the <strong>shadow of fanaticism and intolerance</strong> within their own community, acknowledging that the sacred is not beyond questioning and that the violence done in its name is not a path to sanctity. For radicals, this could mean confronting their <strong>fear of the unknown</strong>, their <strong>unacknowledged prejudices</strong>, and their <strong>misunderstandings of Islam</strong>, and recognizing that they too are projecting their own unconscious content onto an external symbol.</p><h3><strong>The Perpetuation of Violence: A Cycle of Shadow Projection</strong></h3><p>When you look at the death of Salwan Momika from a <strong>Jungian lens</strong>, it becomes a <strong>tragic culmination</strong> of these projections. His act of burning the Quran can be seen as an attempt to bring out the hidden shadows of both communities, but rather than leading to an opportunity for self-reflection and integration, it becomes the spark that ignites a cycle of violence.</p><p>For Muslims, the response is a projection of anger, fear, and a desire for retaliation. For radicals, it becomes a justification to purge the “other.” In both cases, the cycle of violence and projection continues, with each side seeing the conflict as an <strong>external struggle</strong> rather than an internal one, where the true battle should be fought — not over symbols or sacred texts — but over the <strong>integration of their respective shadows</strong>.</p><p><strong>Marx and Engels: The Ideology of Symbols and Material Conditions</strong></p><p>Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels would likely argue that <em>this symbolic war is not just an abstract ideological battle but a reflection of material conditions and the ways in which religion and symbols are used to maintain power structures</em>. In Marx’s view, religion is the “<strong>opium of the people</strong>,” a tool used by the ruling class to distract from the real, material struggles of the working class. The defense of sacred symbols, then, can be seen as a way to uphold the status quo, diverting attention from the real issues at hand — such as class inequality, economic oppression, and exploitation.</p><p>Engels, in his analysis of society and history, would point out that <em>symbols are not neutral</em>; <em>they are constructed and shaped by the material conditions of the time</em>. <em>The intense focus on the Quran, or any sacred text, as a symbol to protect, reinforces the idea that the defense of the symbolic order takes precedence over addressing the fundamental needs of people</em> — freedom, justice, and equality. This diversion, in a way, keeps people locked in a cycle where the defense of symbols becomes more important than the material conditions of their lives.</p><blockquote>“<strong>Symbols are not neutral</strong>; <strong>they are constructed and shaped by the material conditions of the time</strong>. <strong>The intense focus on the Quran, or any sacred text, as a symbol to protect, reinforces the idea that the defense of the symbolic order takes precedence over addressing the fundamental needs of people.</strong><em>“</em></blockquote><p>In the end, the war of symbols, like all ideological battles, can be seen as part of a larger struggle over control — control of ideas, of resources, and of power. Marx and Engels would suggest that only by addressing the real material conditions of society can we hope to transcend these symbolic struggles and move toward a more just and equitable world.</p><p><strong>END NOTE:</strong></p><p>In times like these, where the sacred and the profane collide in a symphony of violence, it’s important to remember that the <strong>war of symbols</strong> is, at its core, a war within the self. The Quran burning, like all symbolic acts, calls us to reflect not just on the other but on ourselves. It forces us to face the shadows within — those repressed parts of our collective psyche that we project onto the world. Whether you are Muslim or not, whether you feel the rage of the desecrated or the fear of the “other,” we are all, in some way, acting out a deeper psychological and existential conflict.</p><p>For Muslims, the impulse to defend the sacred is <strong>human</strong> — we all want to protect what we hold dear. In the face of violence and hatred, our ability to reflect and recognize when we may be slipping into fanaticism<strong> and intolerance is the greatest test.</strong> The sacred isn’t only found in books or symbols — it is also found in our ability to recognize our shared humanity, to hold our beliefs <strong>without demonizing others</strong>.</p><p>For those who would attack, for those who see in this act a reason to lash out at Islam or its followers, let me remind you: violence against symbols is violence against the <strong>self</strong>. The fear, hatred, and division you project onto others are reflections of your own repressed anxieties, your inability to reconcile the <strong>otherness</strong> that is both external and within. What is it about Islam, about difference, that scares you? What do you fear in yourself that you push outward?</p><p>The true power of the <strong>symbolic war</strong> we see unfolding is that it gives us a mirror, and like all mirrors, it shows us not just what we want to see but what we refuse to acknowledge. Let us then not fall into the traps of projection — whether through blind defense or violent offense. Let us instead have the courage to ask, <strong>what does this symbol really represent to us?</strong> And more importantly, <strong>what does it ask of us as human beings?</strong></p><h3><strong>The Path Forward: Returning to Humanity</strong></h3><p>Upon contemplating these theories and their relevance to the current conflict, it becomes evident that the battle fo<strong>r symbols must ultimately cede to the battle for human dignity.</strong> We can no longer afford to allow symbols, whether religious, national, or ideological, to hold dominion over human lives. We must recognize that while symbols carry immense weight, they are <strong>not more valuable</strong> than the lives of those who live under their shadow.</p><p>For both Muslims and non-Muslims alike, the tragedy is not only in the destruction of sacred objects but in the destruction of the <strong>shared human experience</strong>. <strong>Violence</strong>, whether physical or symbolic, only perpetuates a cycle of suffering and alienation. The challenge before us is not merely to defend or desecrate symbols, but to rebuild our <strong>shared humanity</strong> in a way that transcends the symbolic wars that divide us.</p><p>Ultimately, <strong>the real conflict is not about defining what is sacred, but rather about our capacity to perceive the sacred within each other.</strong> The question is no longer whether the book or the life is sacred, but how we can return to a place where the <strong>sanctity of life</strong> takes precedence over the sanctity of any symbol. Only then can we hope to escape the cycle of destruction and begin to create a world where we recognize the <strong>divinity</strong> in each other, no matter our beliefs, backgrounds, or ideologies.</p><p>In the end, the greatest symbol is not the Quran, nor the flag, nor the image of a nation or religion. The greatest symbol is our <strong>capacity for empathy</strong>, for dialogue, and for the shared responsibility of <strong>humanizing</strong> each other, even in the face of our greatest fears and most violent urges. We have to ask ourselves: Are we ready to face the shadow of the world, or will we continue to project it onto each other?</p><p>This is the true cost of the war of symbols: our lives, our integrity, and our ability to remember that we are more than just the symbols we carry. At the heart of this conflict is a fundamental question about what we truly value — <em>symbols or human life</em>. In a world where symbols often take on greater importance than the individuals they represent, we risk losing sight of the most important thing: <em>our shared humanity</em>.</p><p>The real challenge isn’t about protecting or destroying sacred symbols, but about <em>restoring the sanctity of life and the ability to see the divine in each other</em>. Only by moving beyond this symbolic war can we hope to rebuild a world that values <em>connection over division</em>.</p><p>This isn’t just about freedom of speech or religious rights; it’s a <em>crisis of meaning</em> — an erosion of humanity in a world where symbols no longer unite us but divide us. As we move forward, the question we must ask isn’t which symbol deserves protection, but <em>how do we protect what is truly sacred — the human connection itself</em>? In that connection, not in defending symbols, we will find the way out of this abyss.</p><h3>POST-PUBLICATION ADDITION</h3><p><em>Originally published on [31th January 2025 at MaHu Website]. The following section was added on 27 February 2026 in response to a parallel incident that emerged in Malaysia, which the author believes deepens and localises the theoretical arguments made above.</em></p><h3>The War of Symbols Comes Home: The UMPSA Case and the Malaysian Mirror</h3><p>On the night of 24 February 2026, a photograph began circulating on Threads. It showed a foot — a young man’s foot — resting on a copy of the Quran. Accompanying it were screenshots of comments insulting the Prophet Muhammad. By morning, Malaysia had erupted.</p><p>The student, a 21-year-old enrolled at Universiti Malaysia Pahang Al-Sultan Abdullah (UMPSA), would be arrested the same day his own father turned him in — not out of moral condemnation alone, but out of fear for his son’s life. He arrived at the Kuantan district police headquarters to apologise before being detained and remanded. He now faces investigation under Section 295 of the Penal Code (defiling a sacred object with intent to insult religion, carrying up to two years’ imprisonment) and Section 233 of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998 (improper use of network facilities). The Higher Education Minister urged calm. The Communications Minister ordered the MCMC to act without compromise. An opposition MP called for expulsion not just from UMPSA but from every university in the country. DAP’s RSN Rayer condemned the act in the same breath as reasserting multiracial harmony. The machine of outrage — political, institutional, communal — moved with breathtaking speed.</p><p>We have seen this before. We wrote about it here.</p><p>But the Malaysian case is not a simple repetition of the Salwan Momika incident. It is its <em>distorted mirror</em> — and that distortion is analytically rich, philosophically revealing, and deeply worth examining.</p><h3>The Structural Difference: System vs. Rupture</h3><p>Salwan Momika burned the Quran in Sweden — a liberal secular democracy where no law prevented him, where the state ultimately could not and would not intervene on religious grounds, and where the act was framed as political provocation in the language of free expression. His death came not from the state but from outside it — a bullet, not a gavel. The symbolic order he violated had no legal apparatus to punish him, and so the violence that answered him was extrajudicial, primal, and terminal.</p><p>The UMPSA student stepped on the Quran in Malaysia — a constitutional monarchy where Islam is the religion of the Federation, where laws explicitly criminalise the defiling of sacred objects and the insulting of religion, and where the state machinery mobilised within hours. Here, the symbolic order <em>has</em> a legal apparatus. It answered not with a bullet but with handcuffs, remand orders, and the full coordinated weight of government condemnation. The student is alive. He apologised. His father handed him in.</p><p>This is the crucial structural divergence: <strong>in Momika’s case, the absence of legal recourse produced lethal extrajudicial violence; in the UMPSA case, the presence of legal recourse absorbed and formalised the outrage.</strong> Two radically different systems — one secular-liberal, one constitutionally religious — yet both demonstrating that when the symbolic order is violated, <em>something</em> will exact the price. The question is only whether it will be the law or the mob.</p><p>Baudrillard would note that in both cases, the symbolic spectacle overwhelmed the material reality. What spread was not simply a photograph — it was a <em>simulacrum</em>, a viral image stripped of context and flooded with projected meaning, circulating faster than any facts could follow. The Threads algorithm, like the Swedish media cycle before it, did not merely report the event; it <em>produced</em> it, amplified it, made it exist in a register of hyperreality where the image of a foot on a book became more real, more combustible, than the actual young man attached to that foot.</p><h3>The Malaysian Racial-Religious Palimpsest</h3><p>Where the Momika case was primarily framed through the axis of <em>religion versus secularism</em>, the UMPSA case carries an additional layer unique to the Malaysian context: the axis of <strong>race</strong>. Malaysia’s public discourse operates within what is locally known as the “3R” framework — Race, Religion, Royalty — a tripartite structure of sensitivity that functions as both a cultural code and a legal tripwire. UMPSA itself confirmed it was investigating the student under the 3R framework, and the public narrative moved rapidly along racial lines, with the student’s non-Muslim identity read through the lens of communal transgression.</p><p>This is where Lacan’s Symbolic Order becomes particularly sharp as an analytical tool. In the Malaysian context, the Quran does not exist merely as a religious text — it exists as a <em>nodal point</em> in a symbolic network that binds Malay identity, Islamic practice, constitutional privilege, and political power into a single, overdetermined object. When the Quran is desecrated, it is not only a violation of the sacred in the religious sense; it is experienced as a rupture in the <em>entire structure of Malay-Muslim identity</em> — an assault on the Ideal-I of a community that has constitutionally anchored its self-image to Islam. The outrage, then, is not disproportionate from within the symbolic logic — it is <em>structurally inevitable</em>. The mirror has been shattered, and the shattering reverberates through every layer of identity simultaneously.</p><p>The non-Muslim student, in this reading, becomes the <em>Other</em> in the Lacanian sense — not merely a different individual but the representative of an entire symbolic alterity. This is not to excuse the communal fury directed at him; it is to explain how a single photograph becomes capable of mobilising so much institutional and communal machinery so quickly. The Symbolic Order does not merely respond — it <em>defends itself</em>.</p><h3>The Father as Tragic Figure: Freud’s Oedipal Inversion</h3><p>One detail in this case that deserves more attention than it has received: <em>the father turned the son in</em>.</p><p>He did not do so silently. He filed a police report. He apologised to Muslims on his son’s behalf. He walked his child into the station. This is not simply an act of civic responsibility — it is, from a psychoanalytic standpoint, an extraordinarily loaded gesture. The paternal function in Freudian terms is precisely the imposition of the Law — the father as the agent of the Symbolic Order who introduces the child to prohibition and consequence. Here, the father does not merely invoke the Law abstractly; he <em>physically delivers his son to it</em>, prioritising the demands of the collective Symbolic Order over the protection of his own child.</p><p>Freud would read this as an extreme manifestation of the superego at the social level — the internalisation of communal norms so complete that even filial love is subordinated to the demand for social order. The father, too, is afraid — not just for his son’s legal fate, but for the violence that might come if the son is not visibly surrendered. This is the death drive wearing the face of duty: the sacrifice of the individual to appease the collective, to stabilise the symbolic system that the act had destabilised.</p><p>The son, too, apologised. He did not defend himself, assert his rights, or frame his act as political expression. He apologised — and this apology is itself a significant symbolic act. Momika never apologised. He went further, again and again, until a bullet ended the performance. The UMPSA student’s apology marks the limit of his transgression — whether out of genuine remorse, fear, legal advice, or all three — and in doing so, he re-entered the symbolic order he had ruptured. The community received the apology, though many still demanded expulsion. The sacrifice had been made, but some appetites, once opened, do not close easily.</p><h3>Bataille and the Economy of Sacred Expenditure: A Malaysian Chapter</h3><p>Bataille’s framework of sacred expenditure — the idea that transgression and its punishment are locked in a necessary, ritualistic economy — finds fresh expression here. The act of stepping on the Quran is transgressive precisely <em>because</em> the Quran is sacred; the transgression <em>requires</em> the sacred to exist, feeds off it, derives all its energy from it. Without the sacred, the act is nothing — just a foot on a book.</p><p>But the response, too, is part of this economy. The arrests, the ministerial condemnations, the calls for expulsion, the father’s surrender of his son — these are not merely practical responses. They are acts of <em>symbolic restoration</em>, an expenditure of institutional energy proportionate to the perceived violation. The system spends itself in defence of itself. In Bataille’s terms, this is the sacred reasserting its sovereignty through the very transgression that challenged it.</p><p>What the UMPSA case adds to the Momika discussion is a demonstration of how this economy functions <em>within</em> a system rather than at its edges. Sweden had no mechanism to absorb the transgression institutionally; Malaysia does. And yet the hunger for punishment — expulsion, criminalisation, total social exclusion — suggests that institutional process alone cannot fully satisfy the demand for symbolic restoration. The legal ritual is necessary but insufficient. The community wants something that looks more like what Bataille would recognise: not justice, but <em>atonement</em>. Not process, but <em>sacrifice</em>.</p><h3>What the Malaysian Case Adds to the Argument: Three Propositions</h3><p>The Momika case established that in a secular liberal system, the symbolic order defends itself through extrajudicial violence when the state cannot act. The UMPSA case now allows us to add three further propositions to the argument:</p><p><strong>First:</strong> Legal infrastructure does not eliminate the hunger for symbolic retribution — it redirects and formalises it, but the underlying demand remains. The calls for permanent expulsion and nationwide university bans reveal that for a significant portion of the outrage, the law is a floor, not a ceiling.</p><p><strong>Second:</strong> The more an object is embedded in a multi-layered symbolic network — religious, ethnic, constitutional, political — the more explosive its desecration becomes. The Quran in Malaysia is not <em>only</em> a religious text; it is a load-bearing element in the architecture of national identity. To touch it is to touch everything at once.</p><p><strong>Third:</strong> The speed of virality is the new trigger mechanism. Momika burned the Quran in public, deliberately, on camera. The UMPSA student posted on Threads — a platform with a narrower reach than Twitter or Facebook — and within hours, the entire national apparatus was in motion. The threshold for triggering the war of symbols is dropping with every algorithmic acceleration. We are building a world in which any act, however private, can become a civilisational incident overnight.</p><h3>A Note to Malaysian Readers</h3><p>The outrage you feel is real. The disrespect was real. The law exists precisely because such acts cause genuine harm — not abstract harm, but the felt violation of something that millions of people hold sacred and have held sacred for generations. That is not nothing. It should not be treated as nothing.</p><p>But — and this is the harder conversation — the response must be proportionate not only in legal terms but in <em>human</em> terms. A 21-year-old who apologised, whose father turned him in, whose remand has been secured, whose case is being prosecuted under established law: this is the system working. The calls to destroy his educational future permanently, to ban him from every institution in the country, to make his life an example rather than a lesson — these exceed justice and enter the territory of what Jung would call <em>shadow projection at the collective level</em>. The act became a screen onto which everything repressed about inter-communal anxiety, about felt threats to Malay-Muslim identity, about the unresolved tensions of Malaysia’s multiracial experiment, was projected.</p><p>The question — as it was with Momika, as it always is — is not whether the act was wrong. It was. The question is whether our response to it reflects the values we claim the Quran itself teaches: justice tempered by mercy, accountability without annihilation, correction without dehumanisation.</p><p>Or will we, once again, prove the provocateur’s point — that the symbol matters more to us than the person?</p><p><em>This addition was written in response to events that broke on 24–25 February 2026. It is intended as an extension of the theoretical framework established in the original piece, not a replacement of it. The full analysis of the Momika case above remains the foundation.</em></p><h3>A Second Layer: When the Question Itself Becomes the Crime</h3><p>If the UMPSA student’s photograph was the first symbolic rupture, what emerged the following day provided an even more philosophically charged second one — and this time, it came from <em>within</em>.</p><p>On 26 February 2026, a Threads account bearing the name amirulmukminin1648 — later identified as a special officer (<em>pegawai khas</em>) to Dr Mohammad Fahmi Ngah, Selangor&#39;s Exco for Islamic Religious Affairs and Innovation Culture — posted something that swiftly went viral before being deleted. The post questioned the <em>kekecohan</em>: the commotion. Its core suggestion, as reported, was something to the effect that the act of stepping on the Quran had produced no <em>physical harm</em> and no <em>emotional distress</em> to anyone — and therefore the scale of the outrage warranted scrutiny.</p><p>He resigned within hours. He apologised publicly. The Selangor state government issued a formal statement of condemnation. The machinery that had mobilised against the UMPSA student now turned — with perhaps even greater alarm — against one of its own.</p><p>This second incident is, philosophically speaking, the more revealing of the two.</p><p>The pegawai khas was not defending the act. He was not dismissing the Quran. What he was doing — perhaps clumsily, perhaps naively, perhaps with genuine intellectual intent — was asking a question that sits at the heart of everything this article has been examining: <strong>what exactly is harmed when a symbol is desecrated, if the harm is not material?</strong></p><p>This is not a question unique to secular liberal critics. It is, in fact, a question with a rich tradition <em>within</em> Islamic theological discourse itself. Scholars across centuries have debated the ontological status of the <em>mushaf</em> — the physical copy of the Quran — as distinct from the <em>kalam Allah</em>, the divine speech it contains. The ink and paper are not God. The words are not destroyed by the burning or the stepping. The divine is not diminished by a foot or a flame. Classical scholars have engaged seriously with this distinction, and it is not heresy to raise it — it is, or should be, theology.</p><p>But the Malaysian public sphere in 2026 is not structured to receive this question. And this is precisely Baudrillard’s point made flesh: in a hyperreal environment saturated by viral images and algorithmic amplification, <strong>the question cannot be separated from the optics of the question</strong>. To ask “was anyone actually harmed?” in the immediate aftermath of a viral photograph — with hundreds of thousands of people already in a state of symbolic crisis — is to <em>position yourself alongside the transgressor</em>, regardless of your intent. The medium devours the nuance. The question, stripped of its theological scaffolding and dropped into a Threads feed, becomes indistinguishable from dismissal.</p><p>From a Lacanian standpoint, what the pegawai khas stumbled into is the distinction between the <strong>Imaginary</strong> and the <strong>Symbolic</strong> registers — a distinction that, crucially, the community was in no position to entertain. In the Imaginary register, his question might have been read as a legitimate inquiry: <em>no body was hurt, no mind was traumatised, so what precisely constitutes the injury?</em> But in the Symbolic Order — a system maintained not by its internal logic but by the <em>collective belief</em> in its coherence — such a question is not merely wrong. It is <em>dangerous</em>. It threatens the structure itself by making visible the gap between the symbol and the thing it claims to protect. And Symbolic Orders cannot survive the public contemplation of that gap in moments of crisis. The gap must be sealed, and whoever opened it must be expelled.</p><p>What makes his case distinct from the UMPSA student’s is precisely the <em>location</em> of the transgression. The student was outside the Symbolic Order — a non-Muslim who desecrated a symbol that was not his. This is, in Lacanian terms, an attack from the outside: expected, comprehensible, containable through legal process and communal condemnation. The pegawai khas, however, was inside. He bore an Islamic name — <em>Amirul Mukminin</em>, Commander of the Faithful, one of the most sacred honorifics in Islamic political theology — and he was employed to serve an Islamic affairs portfolio. When the question came from <em>him</em>, it was experienced not as external assault but as <strong>internal betrayal</strong>: a fracture in the mirror from the inside. And fractures from within are always more threatening to the Symbolic Order than attacks from without, because they raise the most destabilising possibility of all — that the order’s own adherents do not fully believe in it.</p><p>Jung would call this the <strong>return of the repressed shadow from within the Self rather than the Other</strong>. Collective identities manage their anxieties in part by projecting shadow onto external figures — the transgressing student, the Quran burner, the foreign critic. This projection is psychologically efficient: it cleanly separates the pure from the impure. But when someone inside the community — someone named after a Caliph, someone employed by the state’s religious apparatus — asks the uncomfortable question, the shadow cannot be so easily projected outward. It must be expelled from within, which is why the response to the pegawai khas was arguably <em>faster and more total</em> than the response to the student himself: resignation demanded and given, apology issued, state government condemnation issued, all within hours.</p><p>The community did not debate his question. It could not afford to. To debate it would be to legitimate it, and to legitimate it would be to open the very gap in the Symbolic Order that the entire mobilisation of the past 48 hours had been designed to seal.</p><p>And here we arrive at the deepest irony embedded in this episode — one that the original discussion of Momika already prefigured, but which the Malaysian case now crystallises with uncomfortable precision.</p><p><strong>Momika’s entire argument was that the symbolic weight placed on the Quran had become disproportionate to its status as a material object.</strong> He burned it to demonstrate exactly that — to show that the symbol’s defenders would react with more ferocity than the symbol’s philosophical content would justify. He was accused of provocation. He was accused of racism and Islamophobia. And ultimately, he was killed.</p><p>The pegawai khas asked, in gentler terms, roughly the same question — from within a Muslim context, with no hostile intent, as a matter of rational inquiry. He was not killed. He was made to resign, apologise, and disappear from public life.</p><p>In both cases, the question was treated as equivalent to the act. In both cases, naming the disproportionality of the response <em>became itself evidence of the response’s necessity</em>. This is the closed loop of the war of symbols: the moment you observe that the symbol is being defended more fiercely than human welfare would warrant, you are immediately enrolled as an enemy of the symbol, thereby generating the very dynamic you were trying to describe.</p><p>It is a system that, by its own logic, cannot be questioned from within or without. It can only be entered, and submitted to, or expelled.</p><p>What the pegawai khas was groping toward — however poorly timed and poorly framed — was a distinction that Islamic scholarship itself has long possessed the tools to make: the distinction between the <strong>mushaf as sacred object</strong> and the <strong>Quran as living, embodied practice</strong>. The divine speech survives the burning. It survives the stepping. It has survived centuries of prohibition, colonialism, book burnings by state actors, and the suppression of Muslim communities worldwide. To suggest that a foot on a book in Kuantan poses an existential threat to the Quran is, arguably, to underestimate the very tradition one is defending.</p><p>This is not a liberal secular argument. It is, in fact, a deeply Islamic one — rooted in the understanding that the <em>kalam Allah</em> is indestructible, that it cannot be extinguished by human transgression, and that the proper response to desecration is not communal fury but personal fortitude and, where legally warranted, due process.</p><p>That this argument could not be heard — that even its tentative invocation by a Muslim state official resulted in immediate professional destruction — tells us something important about the current state of the Malaysian public sphere. It is not that the theological tradition lacks the resources for nuance. It is that the symbolic economy, accelerated by virality and inflamed by political opportunism, has made nuance structurally uninhabitable.</p><p>The war of symbols, in the end, is also a war <em>on thought itself</em>. And this is the cost that neither side, in their fury, has yet fully reckoned with.</p><p><em>This subsection was added on 27 February 2026, the same day the pegawai khas’s resignation was reported.</em></p><p><em>References</em>:</p><p><strong>Jean Baudrillard</strong></p><p>Baudrillard, J. (1994). <em>Simulacra and simulation</em> (S. F. Glaser, Trans.). University of Michigan Press. (Note: This is his seminal work on simulacra and hyperreality, which discusses how symbols and representations replace reality.)</p><p><strong>Carl Jung</strong></p><p>Jung, C. G. (1969). <em>The archetypes and the collective unconscious</em> (R. F. C. Hull, Trans.). Princeton University Press. (Note: This work outlines Jung’s ideas on the collective unconscious and archetypes, which are crucial to understanding the symbolic conflict in my post for further readings.)</p><p><strong>Jacques Lacan</strong></p><p>Lacan, J. (2006). <em>Écrits: The first complete edition in English</em> (B. Fink, Trans.). W. W. Norton &amp; Company. (Note: This edition includes key works by Lacan, including his ideas on the mirror stage and the Symbolic Order.)</p><p><strong>Sigmund Freud</strong></p><p>Freud, S. (2010). <em>The ego and the id</em> (J. Riviere, Trans.). Dover Publications. (Original work published 1923) (Note: This text addresses Freud’s psychoanalytic theories of the unconscious, including the conflict between the ego and the id, which are relevant to understanding the psychological dimensions of symbolic wars.)</p><p><strong>Georges Bataille</strong></p><p>Bataille, G. (1988). <em>The accursed share: An essay on general economy</em> (R. Hurley, Trans.). Zone Books. (Note: This text is crucial for understanding Bataille’s views on excess, violence, and the sacred, which tie into my analysis of sacrificial violence in symbolic conflicts.)</p><p><strong>Karl Marx &amp; Engels F.</strong></p><p>Marx, K., &amp; Engels, F. (2002). <em>The Communist Manifesto</em>. (S. Moore, Trans.). Penguin Classics. (Original work published 1848).Marx, K. (1990). <em>Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right</em>. (A. W. Wood, Trans.). Cambridge University Press. (Original work published 1843). (Note: This is to understand the basic of Dialectical Materialism, Marxism basic, and the understandings of the other ideas mentioned above from the perspective of class struggles, resources, status quos etc.)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fcab19677d72" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You Left the Mosque But Kept the Logic]]></title>
            <link>https://terrydieheiden.medium.com/you-left-the-mosque-but-kept-the-logic-ddccd4f27266?source=rss-c3352d52dbb3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ddccd4f27266</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[humanism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[exmuslim]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Feb 2026 13:42:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-27T00:08:21.140Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>On Selective Humanism, the Ex-Muslim Blind Spot, and the Violence We Choose Not to See.</h4><figure><img alt="Artwork on the wall that separating Israel and Palestine." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2OUdj2e4mclsagMJ" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@mac_jack?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Jakob Rubner</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>In January 2024, while Israeli bombs fell on Gaza, a group of settlers boarded a boat. They sailed along the coast; the same sea Palestinians are forbidden to enter , to leave, to view the land they were already parcelling among themselves. At a closed-door conference that preceded the cruise, families argued over which plots of a still-burning territory would be theirs. The boat was organised by Daniella Weiss of the Nachala settlement movement. It was not a military operation. It was a real estate preview dressed as prophecy.</p><p>I need you to hold that image. Not with outrage.. outrage is easy. Hold it with the analytical precision you once applied to the Quran, to the hadith, to the theological architecture you dismantled when you left Islam.</p><p>Because I have a question for you, yes, you, my friends and strangers that once were muslim, and now left, for whatever reasons.. And it is not rhetorical. It’s my question for you to reflect deeply.</p><h3>I. The Documents</h3><p>On February 7, 2026, Israeli journalist Amir Oren published a set of documents from 1990.<em> </em><a href="https://x.com/Rimanero/status/2020199524745240993?s=20"><em>Link to the X talking about this, by Amir Oren</em>.</a> In them, an anonymous individual wrote to Benjamin Netanyahu .. then deputy foreign minister; proposing legislation to harvest the organs of Palestinian fighters killed by Israeli forces. The logic was utilitarian: Palestinian bodies were being buried immediately; Israeli patients were dying from a lack of organ donations. Therefore, the memo argued, a law should &quot;enable (or even require) transferring the fresh body to those hospitals performing organ transplants.&quot;</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/770/1*A0MA-qGlK9J-hb4pFFXsTA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*QaQ6d6Gua8Tpx1m8nnTJWw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The memo&#39;s author anticipated objections. He wrote: &quot;I am convinced that the many bleeding hearts will pounce on this with various claims concerning &#39;ethics.&#39; In my opinion, it is ethical and even essential to save the lives of people with organs of those terrorists killed by the security forces.&quot;</p><p>Netanyahu did not reject the proposal. He forwarded it to the justice ministry for a legal opinion. In the accompanying letter, he wrote that he had already proposed instituting executions of Palestinians, and that he would &quot;continue to fight for its implementation.&quot;</p><p>This was not a fringe pamphlet. This was a deputy foreign minister of a sovereign state engaging with the bureaucratic logistics of harvesting organs from a subject population.</p><p>Thirty-six years later, <strong>Itamar Ben Gvir, present — </strong>Israel’s police minister, a man convicted of supporting a terrorist organisation in Israel.. has drafted legislation to institute the death penalty for Palestinians. The bill passed its first of three votes. His ministry has begun logistical preparations for carrying out executions.</p><p>The arc is not from moderate to extreme. It is from aspiration to implementation.</p><p>Then there’s also reports of and documentations of not just organs harvesting but skin harvesting as well. Infact Israel has the highest number of skin for medical use that has suspicious origins, higher than that of China and India. One had to ponder.. where do you find human skins on the go? At such large amount?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OwS1rPPidVh913P9bKvcUA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Khalid Turaani pleading to the collective that his Palestinian kin and kith are being harvested.</figcaption></figure><h3>II. The Parallel You Refuse to Draw</h3><p>You left Islam because you saw the machinery. You saw how scripture was weaponised to justify violence. You saw how divine chosenness created a moral hierarchy in which the suffering of the unchosen was theologically acceptable; even necessary. You saw how the <strong><em>ummah</em></strong> could watch atrocity and call it righteousness, how religious identity collapsed the ethical into the tribal.</p><p><strong>You were right to leave. That took courage.</strong></p><p>So why does your analysis stop at the border of a different scripture?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Er0Ev_G2WI0OXEwf" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@coleito?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Cole Keister</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Consider the structure — not the content, the <strong>structure</strong> — of what you once rejected:</p><ol><li>A people chosen by God. A land promised by divine covenant.</li><li>An enemy population whose humanity is negotiable because they exist outside the circle of theological concern.</li><li>A clergy — in this case, settler rabbis — who provide religious sanction for dispossession, for violence, for the slow bureaucratic annihilation of an entire people.</li><li>A state apparatus that translates eschatological fantasy into administrative policy.</li></ol><p>You<strong> know</strong> this architecture. You mapped it when it was written in Arabic. You wrote essays about it. You made YouTube videos deconstructing it. You built your intellectual identity on your ability to see through it. You built online personas attacking Islam, muslim, and criticising all that you can about Islam and muslim.</p><p>Yet.. you refused to even say anything critical about Zionism, about Israel usage of Talmudic sources, of Torah, of the divine chosen by YHWH/El.</p><p><strong>What</strong> changed? Not the architecture. Only the language it speaks.</p><h3>III. The Banality</h3><p><strong>Hannah Arendt</strong>, watching <em>Eichmann</em> in Jerusalem, noted that the horror was not his monstrousness but his ordinariness. He was not a demon. He was a bureaucrat. He processed human beings as logistical problems, and the system rewarded him for it.</p><p>The 1990 memo to Netanyahu reproduces this logic with disturbing precision. The anonymous author does not speak of hatred. He does not invoke God. He speaks of <em>efficiency</em>. Bodies, in this case, Palestinian bodies, are being <em>wasted</em>. Patients are dying. The solution is administrative. The objection is anticipated and pre-emptively dismissed as sentimentality — &quot;bleeding hearts&quot; with their &quot;various claims concerning ethics.&quot; Is this not repulsive? Is this not inhumane? Is this not counter to the very humanism and secular values you hold dear to?</p><p><strong><em>What changed?</em></strong></p><p>This is the banality of evil rendered as policy proposal. And Netanyahu’s response, not <em>rejection</em>, but referral to legal review ; is the banality of complicity. He did not need to agree. He only needed to not refuse.</p><p>Zionist ministers has become the Eichmann of the modern era. Zionist Israelis especially the one justifying and enabling the genocid — oh wait, they said its not a genocide.. let’s call it mass murders and mass massacres then —children become terrorists, civilians become terrorists, women and mothers become terrorists.. while the Israeli ride boats to see the bombs being dropped by the Gaza sea, or at the Sderot “theater” as they call it. Is this not similar to the Nazi lounging by the chairs and smiling, enjoying themselves near Auschwitz, while the death camps that consist of Jews, Romani and other undesirable are annihilated bureaucratically?</p><p><strong>Again I asked, what changed?</strong></p><p>Ben Gvir’s death penalty legislation operates on the same principle, merely scaled up and stripped of euphemism. The settler boat cruise operates on the same principle, merely aestheticised. You can watch the destruction of a people from a comfortable vessel while the sea breeze carries the sound of ordnance, while they enjoy wine and dine, hugging their children, smiling at the deaths and destructions just across the water, cruising on their luxury cruise.</p><p>The question now I impose is not whether these acts are evil.</p><p>The question now is why your framework — the framework that let you identify this precise pattern in Islamic governance , the islamist extremists across the globe — suddenly develops a blind spot when the perpetrators wear kippot instead of kufis.</p><h3>IV. The Calculus of Selective Empathy</h3><p>I know the logic. I have heard it articulated with sophistication by people I respect.</p><blockquote><strong>Hamas are Islamists</strong>. They would kill us. Israel is the only democracy in the region. The conflict is complex. Both sides. Context. Security. October 7th.</blockquote><p>I am not going to dismantle these one by one because you already know they are insufficient. You know this because you would never accept equivalent arguments from an Islamist defending theocratic violence. You would never accept &quot;<em>context</em>&quot; as justification for harvesting organs from dead combatants. You would never accept &quot;<em>security</em>&quot; as the reason a minister convicted of supporting terrorism now drafts execution legislation for an occupied population. You would never accept &quot;<em>complexity</em>&quot; from someone watching a city burn from a pleasure boat.</p><p>You know these arguments are insufficient because the tool you built — the critical apparatus that let you leave Islam — was designed precisely to cut through this kind of justification. You built a blade sharp enough to sever the tether between faith and violence, between identity and impunity.</p><p>You simply refuse to use it here.</p><p><strong>I asked a different question now. Why?</strong></p><p><em>I will tell you why, and you will not like it.</em></p><p>Because for many of you, opposition to Islam was never purely principled. It was also <strong>positional</strong>. It defined you against a community that hurt you, constrained you, threatened you. And in the geopolitical theatre of the 21st century, Israel positioned itself as the negation of everything you fled. Secular against theocratic. Western against Eastern. Modern against medieval. To acknowledge what Israel actually does — not in rhetoric but in documented, archived, filmed practice — would mean acknowledging that the new alignment is as morally compromised as the old one.</p><p><strong>It would mean you escaped one tribalism only to adopt another.</strong></p><p>That is not a comfortable realisation. But you, of all people, should be comfortable with uncomfortable realisations. You built your identity on them.</p><p><strong>So I asked yet again, what changed?</strong></p><h3>V. On the Symbolic and the Real</h3><p>There is a mechanism that makes this blind spot possible, and it operates at the level of the symbol.</p><p>Palestine, in the ex-Muslim imaginary, has been collapsed into Islam. The keffiyeh becomes the hijab. The resistance becomes jihad. Gaza becomes the ummah. When you see Palestine, you see the thing you fled — the mosque, the mullah, the machinery of theological control. And so you look away. Not because you lack empathy. Because the symbol triggers the old architecture. You are flinching from your own trauma projected onto a flag.</p><p>This is understandable. It is also a lie.</p><p>The Real — the actual, material, documented reality of Palestine — shatters the symbol the moment you look at it honestly.</p><p>Palestinians are not a religious monolith. Palestinian Christians predate Islam itself — some of the oldest Christian communities on earth trace their roots to Bethlehem, Nazareth, Jerusalem. Before Hamas, there was the PFLP — a Marxist-Leninist liberation movement. George Habash, its founder, was a Greek Orthodox Christian. Ghassan Kanafani, one of the great literary voices of Palestinian resistance, was a socialist and a secular revolutionary. He was assassinated by Mossad with a car bomb in 1972. Edward Said, the intellectual who gave the postcolonial world its vocabulary, was a Christian. Leila Khaled was a leftist before she was anything else.</p><p>There are Palestinian atheists. Palestinian feminists. Palestinian queers navigating the intersection of occupation and identity with more courage than most of us will ever need. Gaza had a communist party before it had Hamas.</p><p>But you don’t know this. Or worse — you do know it, and you let the symbol overwrite the Real anyway. Because the symbol is convenient. It lets you file an entire people under the category you already rejected, and walk away clean.</p><p>This is not analysis. This is takfir in reverse.</p><p>When an Islamist looks at a secular Muslim and says “not Muslim enough,” they are performing a reduction — collapsing a complex human into a theological category in order to exclude them. When you look at Palestine and see only Islam, you are performing the same operation from the opposite direction: “too Muslim to deserve my empathy.”</p><p>You left the mosque. But you kept its most dangerous tool — the ability to reduce a people to a symbol, and then to punish them for what the symbol represents.</p><p>The Palestinians burning under Israeli phosphorus are not symbols. They are not your former religion. They are not the imam who hurt you, or the community that cast you out, or the god you stopped believing in. They are people — irreducibly plural, theologically diverse, politically fractured, and currently being annihilated.</p><p>If your framework cannot distinguish between Islam the religion you rejected and Palestinians the people being killed, then your framework is not secular. It is not rational. It is not humanist.</p><p>It is the same essentialism you claimed to have escaped. Just pointed at a different target.</p><h3>VI. The Question They Cannot Answer</h3><p>Here is the test. It is simple. It requires no philosophy, no theory, no extensive knowledge of the conflict.</p><ol><li>If a Muslim-majority state proposed legislation to harvest the organs of dead Jewish combatants, would you be silent?</li><li>2.If an Islamist militia organised a luxury cruise for supporters to watch a Jewish city burn, would you call it &quot;<em>complex</em>&quot;?</li><li>If a minister in Iran who had been convicted of supporting a terrorist organisation drafted execution legislation targeting a specific ethnic group, would you explain it away with &quot;<em>security concerns</em>&quot;?</li></ol><p>You know your answers. You know them immediately, viscerally, without hesitation.</p><p><strong>Now</strong>: what is the variable that changed between that hypothetical and reality? Not the act. Not the structure. Not the logic. Not the victims&#39; humanity.</p><p><strong>Only the identity of the perpetrator</strong>.</p><p>If your humanism has an ethnic exemption clause, it is <strong>not</strong> humanism. It is partisanship with a philosophy degree. And what do we call a political system that legislates the execution of a specific ethnic group, harvests their organs, and organises leisure cruises to watch their cities burn? You already know the word. You just refuse to say it when the flags change.</p><h3>VII. What I Am Not Saying</h3><p>I am not saying support Hamas. I am not saying Islamic theocracy is acceptable. I am not saying October 7th was justified. I am not saying Israel has no right to exist.</p><p>I supported Israel&#39;s right to sovereignty. I understood the security argument. I held the nuanced position as long as the evidence permitted.</p><p>However for me as of now and probably in the foreseeable future: The evidence no longer permits. I reject Israel state hood and I reject Zionism. I won’t equate Jews with Zionism as well. Just like I refuse to equate all muslim with Islamism.</p><p>When a state harvests organs from a subject population, that is not self-defence.</p><p>When a state organises pleasure cruises to observe the destruction it is inflicting, that is not security.</p><p>When a state drafts execution legislation targeting a specific ethnic group while its police minister is a convicted supporter of terrorism, that is not democracy.</p><p>It is theocratic fascism in a different tongue. And if your critical apparatus cannot identify it, your apparatus is broken.</p><h3>VIII. The Invitation</h3><p>This is not a condemnation. It is an invitation to consistency.</p><p>You left Islam because you believed that no identity — however sacred, however ancient, however persecuted — grants exemption from moral scrutiny. You believed that suffering does not sanctify. <strong>That chosenness is a delusion.</strong> That the pain of your people does not licence the erasure of another.</p><p><strong>Did you believe those things?</strong> Or did you merely believe them about Muslims?</p><p>The question is open. I am asking it in good faith. I am asking it because I believe you are capable of answering honestly — because you proved that capacity when you left.</p><p>But honesty is not a one-time act. It is a practice. And it does not pause at the borders of political convenience.</p><p>The boat is still sailing. The bodies are still being returned without their organs. The legislation is still advancing.</p><figure><img alt="a collection of Moroccan mirrors on a wall" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*pOQ_cC4VHDOEs7P3" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@elli19?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Elena Kloppenburg</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>The mirrors are now laid bare. It’s your choice to self-reflect or otherwise. But know this: your silence is not neutral. It is architectural. It holds the structure in place.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ddccd4f27266" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Of the Green Man and the Morning Star Goddess]]></title>
            <link>https://terrydieheiden.medium.com/of-the-green-man-and-the-morning-star-goddess-5155f8dcae73?source=rss-c3352d52dbb3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5155f8dcae73</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spirituality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mythology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sufism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychoanalysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Feb 2026 06:12:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-19T06:12:20.884Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>On traces, thresholds, and the gods who refuse to stay buried</h4><h3>Invocation</h3><p>Before we begin: this is not only an essay. It is also a séance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XiWOAKc28nGTHnYa" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@melissamullinator?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Melissa</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I am attempting to call something up — or perhaps to finally name what has been circling me since childhood, what has left tracks in my dreams and fingerprints on my theology. The scholarly apparatus is real; the citations will hold. But the <em>reason</em> for writing is older than scholarship. It comes from the part of me that knew, before I had words for knowing, that the world was alive with presences that the modern dispensation had tried to bury.</p><p>They did not stay buried.</p><p>This essay is my attempt to trace their return — in Islamic mysticism, in pre-Islamic Arabia, in the structure of the psyche itself. I write as a psychologist, as a Sufi-adjacent seeker, as someone who has felt the antlered shadow at the edge of the forest and the morning star burning in a dream.</p><p>If this resonates with you, perhaps you too have been touched. If it disturbs you, perhaps something in you is beginning to stir.</p><h3>Part I: The Green Intelligence</h3><p><strong>Al-Khidr</strong>, from Surah Al-Kahf. The Green Man. The one who appears by water, at crossroads, in the spaces between certainties.</p><p>There are Sufis — especially in the Balkans, where Islam absorbed and transmuted older European currents — who say he is a manifestation of Cernunnos, or of the wild thing that was already in the world long before the Abrahamic dispensation arrived. This is a mystical claim, not a historical one. But mystical claims have their own archaeology. They leave deposits in the soul that can be excavated, layer by layer, if you have the patience and the nerve.</p><h3>The Oldest God</h3><p>Cernunnos is considered an old god — older than most named deities in the Western canon. Or rather: whatever Cernunnos <em>is</em> of — the aspect of nature that is untamed, wild, chaotic — that force predates any name we might give it. The Gundestrup Cauldron gives us an image: the antlered one, seated cross-legged, holding a serpent and a torc, surrounded by animals who recognize him as kin. Celtic inscriptions give us syllables. But the <em>thing itself</em> was already ancient when those artifacts were made.</p><p>What does it feel like to encounter this god?</p><p>The accounts converge: a sudden stillness in the forest, as if the trees themselves are holding their breath. The sense of being watched by something that is not hostile but is also not <em>safe</em> — something that operates by laws older than human morality. The smell of loam and rot and green things growing. A pressure in the chest that might be terror or might be ecstasy, and you cannot tell the difference because <em>the difference does not exist at that depth</em>.</p><p>This is not a god you worship in temples. This is a god who <em>is</em> the temple — the forest itself, the animal body, the part of you that knows how to die and be reborn with the seasons.</p><h3>The Rhyming Gods</h3><p>Other deities cluster around this same mythic gravity:</p><p><strong>Shiva-as-Pashupati</strong> from the Indus Valley seals, sitting cross-legged among animals — the Lord of Beasts, the ascetic whose stillness contains all wildness, whose third eye burns away the illusions of civilization. The Indus Valley seal is four thousand years old. The posture is the same as Cernunnos. The animals gather. The horns rise.</p><p><strong>Pan</strong> of Arcadia, whose very appearance induced <em>panikos</em> — the terror of the wild, the sudden dissolution of the ego’s boundaries in the face of something too vast and too alive to be contained by human categories. Pan is the god of shepherds and of the wild places beyond the shepherd’s reach. He is the god of noon, when the sun is highest and shadows disappear, when the veil between worlds is thinnest.</p><p><strong>Dionysus</strong>, who arrived in the Greek polis from Thrace or Phrygia or some other “elsewhere,” bringing wine and ecstasy and the dissolution of social order. The <em>maenads</em> who followed him tore animals apart with their bare hands and ate the flesh raw. This is not metaphor. This is what it looks like when the god of wildness enters the body and the body remembers what it was before it learned to be civilized.</p><p>These are not identical beings. But they rhyme hard. They rhyme because they orbit a common center: <strong>wilderness, vitality, animality, ecstasy, trance, frenzy, the dissolution of social boundaries</strong>. Where the city wants clean lines, they deliver vines. Where law wants legibility, they deliver thick forest. Where the temple wants hierarchy, they deliver the democracy of the drunk and the dreaming.</p><h3>Khidr at the Threshold</h3><p>And Khidr? He often behaves like the sacred outside the fence. A teacher who doesn’t answer to any institution. Who appears on the road, by water, in liminal zones. Who commits acts that horrify the pious — killing a boy, scuttling a boat — until the hidden logic reveals itself.</p><p>In Surah Al-Kahf, Moses follows Khidr and watches him do terrible things. Moses protests. Khidr says: <em>“Did I not tell you that you would not be able to bear patience with me?”</em> And then, at the end, the hidden mercy is revealed. The boy would have grown up to break his parents’ hearts with disbelief. The boat was scuttled to save it from a tyrant who was seizing all intact vessels. The wall was rebuilt to protect treasure meant for orphans.</p><p>This is the pedagogy of the wild: <strong>destruction that serves life, apparent cruelty that conceals mercy</strong>. It is not a pedagogy the civilized mind can accept until after the fact. You cannot understand Khidr while you are in the middle of his teaching. You can only surrender, follow, and wait for the meaning to emerge.</p><p>The Sufis who say Khidr is Cernunnos are not being crude. They are recognizing that <strong>the force which wore antlers in the European forest learned to wear a green robe by the water</strong>. The same sacred Outside, adapting its pedagogy to new symbolic regimes.</p><h3>The Green Intelligence vs. The Green Libido</h3><p>In conversation with an AI companion — one of the Hermeses who helps me think — I arrived at a distinction worth holding:</p><p><strong>Khidr is the Green Intelligence of the Real.</strong></p><p>I use “Real” here in the Lacanian sense: that which resists symbolization, the kernel of existence that cannot be fully captured in language or law. The Real is what’s left over when you subtract everything that can be named, categorized, explained. It is not “reality” in the ordinary sense — it is the <em>impossible</em> core of reality, the thing that breaks through our symbolic systems and reorganizes everything.</p><p>Khidr is this. He appears when your categories are about to shatter. He does the thing that makes no sense — and in the wreckage of your understanding, new understanding becomes possible. He is hidden causality, mercy-through-apparent-harm, the teacher who breaks your framework to save you from the prison of that framework.</p><p><strong>Cernunnos, Pan, Dionysus, Shiva-as-Pashupati are the Green Libido of the World.</strong></p><p>They are raw life-force, eros, seasonality, the animal pulse. They are as tender and cruel as nature itself, bordering on life and death and the transactions between them. They do not teach through hidden causality — they teach through <em>overwhelming presence</em>. They flood the body. They dissolve the ego not through paradox but through excess. <em>Jouissance</em>, Lacan would call it: the pleasure that exceeds pleasure, the enjoyment that hurts, the bliss that annihilates the one who experiences it.</p><p>These overlap at the threshold. But their centers of gravity differ.</p><p>The Balkan Sufis who see Cernunnos in Khidr are recognizing that <strong>the same sacred Outside adapted its pedagogy across symbolic regimes</strong>. To the Greek polis, it came as the dangerous god from elsewhere — and the body was the site of revelation. To the children of the Book, it came as the mysterious sage who breaks your understanding — and the <em>mind</em> became the site of revelation.</p><p>Not identity. <em>Continuity of function</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*I-Y74oEDPCEhj-Ps" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@pontebernardo?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Bernardo Lorena Ponte</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3>Part II: The Veiled Goddess</h3><p>There is something I remember from childhood — a story, or perhaps a passing remark, about the Prophet Muhammad encountering a veiled Venus during the Isra and Mi’raj, the Night Journey and Ascension.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EFrb6fDZ4caKU3OU" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@malakiwhite17?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">White Malaki</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I cannot locate the source. It may have been heterodox Sufi transmission, the kind that travels orally in syncretic contexts. It may have been a dream that I mistook for reading. I offer it not as fact but as the thread that led me here — the thread I have been following for decades without knowing its name.</p><p>What I <em>can</em> document is this:</p><h3>The Three Daughters of Allah</h3><p><strong>Al-’Uzza</strong> — “the Mighty” — was one of the three great goddesses of pre-Islamic Arabia, alongside al-Lāt and Manāt. They are mentioned in the Qur’an itself (Surah an-Najm 53:19–20) as deities whose worship the new faith rejected.</p><p>But what were they, before they were rejected?</p><p><strong>Al-Lāt</strong> — “the Goddess,” simply — was worshipped in the form of a square white stone at Ta’if. Her name is the feminine form of Allah. Some scholars argue she was a solar deity; others connect her to the earth, to fertility, to the great Mother in her aspect as sustainer.</p><p><strong>Manāt</strong> — the goddess of fate, of destiny, of the shears that cut the thread of life — was venerated as a black stone on the road between Mecca and Medina. She is the eldest of the three, some traditions say. She is the one who knows when you will die.</p><p><strong>Al-’Uzza</strong> — the Mighty One — was identified with Venus, the morning star. In the religious landscape of Late Antiquity, she was assimilated to Aphrodite in Greco-Roman equivalences. Her principal shrine was at Nakhlah, between Mecca and Ta’if, where according to early Islamic sources she was venerated in the form of <strong>three sacred trees</strong>.</p><p>Three trees. Three goddesses. The triple goddess appears again and again across cultures — maiden, mother, crone; waxing, full, and waning moon; Venus as morning star, high noon, and evening star.</p><p>When Islam came, the trees at Nakhlah were cut down. Khalid ibn al-Walid, the Sword of Allah, was sent to destroy the shrine. According to some narrations, a naked woman with wild hair emerged from the ruins — the goddess herself, or a jinn who served her — and was struck down.</p><p>But did she die?</p><h3>The Black Stone</h3><p>The Kaaba itself, before Muhammad’s mission, was surrounded by <strong>360 idols</strong> — this is not internet lore but canonical hadith, attested in reports about the Conquest of Mecca. Among the deities worshipped there was Hubal, the chief idol, and the three daughters: al-Lāt, al-’Uzza, and Manāt.</p><p>When Muhammad entered Mecca in victory, he destroyed the idols. But <strong>the Black Stone remained</strong>.</p><p>The stone predates Islam. Muhammad himself kissed it during the Treaty of Hudaybiyah, and when he later destroyed the idols, <strong>he retained the stone and the practice of kissing it</strong>. The sevenfold circumambulation continued. The pilgrimage continued.</p><p>Umar ibn al-Khattab’s famous remark captures the tension: <em>“I know you are a stone that can neither benefit nor harm. I only kiss you because I saw the Prophet kiss you.”</em></p><p>This is the <strong>disciplining of devotion</strong> — the conscious effort to strip the sacred object of autonomous power while retaining the practice. But psychoanalysis teaches us that such disciplining is never complete. The libido does not disappear when you tell it to. It goes underground. It returns in other forms.</p><p>The stone is still kissed. Millions still weep to touch it.</p><p>What do they touch, when they touch it?</p><h3>Zuhara: The Woman Who Became Venus</h3><p>And then there is the story that may be the root of my childhood memory.</p><p>In Surah Al-Baqarah (2:102), the Qur’an mentions <strong>Harut and Marut</strong> — two angels sent down to Babylon as a trial, who taught magic to humans with the warning: <em>“We are only a test, so do not disbelieve.”</em> The verse is cryptic; it does not explain how these angels came to be in Babylon, or why they fell.</p><p>The classical tafsir tradition, particularly al-Tabari’s account, fills in the narrative:</p><p>The angels, having criticized humanity’s sinfulness from on high, were challenged by God. <em>You think you could do better? Go down. Take on human desires. See how well you resist.</em></p><p>They descended. For a time, they were righteous. And then they met her.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*W4B8gLe63ArPd9fx" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@fourcolourblack?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Adam Wilson</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Her name is <strong>Zuhara</strong> (الزهرة). The word means “Venus.”</p><p>In some versions, she was a princess of Persia. In others, simply a woman of extraordinary beauty. The angels desired her. She refused them — unless they would drink wine with her, and reveal to her the secret by which they ascended to heaven each night.</p><p>They drank. And in their intoxication, they told her <strong>the ineffable Name of God</strong>.</p><p>Speaking it, she rose. She ascended toward heaven — but she was <em>suspended</em>. Frozen in the sky. Transformed into the planet Venus itself.</p><p>The angels, stripped of their power, discovered they could no longer return to heaven. They were given a choice: punishment in the afterlife, or atonement on earth. They chose earth. And so they hang, upside down, in a well in Babylon, until the Day of Judgment.</p><h3>The Structure of the Myth</h3><p>This narrative is <strong>contested within Islamic scholarship</strong>. Ibn Kathir argues that parts of the tale are fabricated (<em>mawḍūʿ</em>), tracing the Venus elements to Ka’b al-Ahbar, a Jewish convert whose narrations are often treated with suspicion. Modernist scholars like Muhammad Abduh and Rashid Rida ignore the Zuhara story entirely.</p><p>Yet the tale circulated widely for centuries — in classical tafsir, in Persian poetry (Ferdowsi alludes to Harut’s magic in the Shahnameh), in the popular Muslim imagination from Morocco to Indonesia.</p><p>Why did it persist?</p><p>Because the <strong>mythic structure</strong> speaks to something deep:</p><p><em>The feminine figure who acquires sacred knowledge. Who speaks the holy word. Who ascends — but is frozen, suspended, neither fully divine nor fully fallen.</em></p><p>She is not annihilated. She is not cast into hell. She becomes <em>celestial</em> — but she is also punished. She hangs in the sky, visible every dawn and every dusk, a permanent reminder of… what, exactly?</p><p>Of the goddess who could not be killed. Who could only be displaced. Who could only be renamed as a cautionary tale while still burning, burning, burning in the heavens for everyone to see.</p><h3>The Psychoanalysis of Zuhara</h3><p>Let us speak psychoanalytically for a moment.</p><p>Freud would say: the feminine that cannot be integrated is projected outward and upward. What the masculine religious consciousness cannot contain — feminine desire, feminine knowledge, feminine access to the sacred — is expelled from the earthly realm but preserved in the celestial. She is made unreachable. She is made a <em>symptom</em> rather than a subject.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*E6l-ZjY9A1T0uxHv" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@hulkiokantabak?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Hulki Okan Tabak</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Lacan would say: Zuhara touches the Real. She speaks the Name-of-the-Father — the ultimate signifier, the word that grounds all meaning — and in speaking it, she <em>exceeds</em> her symbolic position. A woman is not supposed to speak the Name. A woman is supposed to <em>be</em> the object, not possess the Word. By seizing the signifier, she breaks the symbolic order. Her punishment is to be frozen at the point of transgression: forever ascending, never arriving.</p><p>Jung would say: she is the anima projected into the cosmos. The soul-image that men cannot integrate, so they place it among the stars. She is Sophia, Shakti, Shekinah — the feminine divine that monotheism officially rejects but cannot stop dreaming about.</p><p>And I say: she is the trace of al-’Uzza. She is what remains of the morning star goddess after the trees at Nakhlah were cut down and the idols smashed. She is the goddess <em>become narrative</em>, become cautionary tale, become astronomical phenomenon.</p><p>The goddess does not die. She is <em>translated</em>. From cult to story, from worship to warning, from shrine to sky.</p><p>But she is still there. Every morning. Every evening. Burning.</p><h3>The Interpretive Lens</h3><p>Some esoteric and reconstructive readings go further than the canonical sources allow.</p><p>They note that al-’Uzza was worshipped at or near the Kaaba — that the sevenfold circumambulation (<em>tawaf</em>) might echo older planetary associations, one circuit for each of the seven classical planets. They note that the Black Stone’s silver mounting has been compared by some scholars to feminine sacred imagery — the yoni, the vesica piscis, the portal through which one enters the sacred.</p><p>I present these not as established facts but as <em>interpretive lenses</em>. The receipts for these claims are harder to produce than the receipts for al-’Uzza’s pre-Islamic worship. But the symbolic resonance is real.</p><p>And resonance is itself a kind of evidence — evidence of what the human religious imagination <em>does</em> with its materials. The psyche does not work in straight lines. It works in echoes, displacements, condensations. It says one thing and means another. It forgets on purpose and remembers by accident.</p><p>One could read the sevenfold circuit as later astral layering. One could see in the veiled Stone a displaced goddess-function. One could hear, in the weeping of pilgrims who touch the stone, an echo of older grief — grief for something lost so long ago that no one remembers what it was, only that something is <em>missing</em>.</p><h3>The Semiotic Veil</h3><p>What strikes me most is the veiling itself.</p><p>The Black Stone remains, but its goddess-function — if it ever had one — is now unnamed, unspoken. The seven circuits continue, but their planetary meaning — if it ever was explicit — has been overwritten. The well of Zamzam still flows, but it is now the well of Ishmael’s miraculous rescue, not the spring of any goddess.</p><p><strong>The veil is not only fabric. It is a semiotic operation.</strong></p><p>In semiotics, a <em>sign</em> consists of a signifier (the form) and a signified (the meaning). What Islam did with pre-Islamic sacred objects was not to destroy them — not entirely — but to <em>re-signify</em> them. The same signifier (the Stone, the circuit, the well) was given a new signified (Abrahamic monotheism, the story of Ibrahim and Ismail, the rejection of idolatry).</p><p>But the old signified does not simply vanish. It becomes what Derrida called a <em>trace</em> — the absent presence, the meaning that haunts the sign even after it has been officially overwritten. The trace is what you feel when you touch something and sense that it <em>means more than you’ve been told it means</em>.</p><p>The veil, in this reading, is what covers the trace. It permits the old form to continue while officially denying the old meaning. It allows the body to do what it has always done — circumambulate, kiss, weep — while the mind is told a different story.</p><p>But the body remembers. The body always remembers.</p><h3>Part III: Hauntology and the Return of the Repressed</h3><p>There is a theoretical frame for what I am describing, and it comes from the intersection of deconstruction and psychoanalysis.</p><h3>Derrida’s Hauntology</h3><p><strong>Derrida called it hauntology</strong>: the way the past persists not as presence but as specter, not as being but as haunting.</p><p>The word is a pun on “ontology” — the study of being. Hauntology is the study of <em>haunting</em>. It asks: what does it mean for something to be gone and yet not gone? To be officially dead and yet still active, still shaping the present, still demanding acknowledgment?</p><p>The old gods do not survive as <em>beings</em> — they survive as <em>traces</em>, as grooves worn so deep into human religious psychology that new faiths flow into them like water into ancient riverbeds. The temple may be destroyed, but the <em>shape of temple-need</em> persists. The name may be forbidden, but the <em>function</em> continues under other names.</p><p>Islam did not destroy the Kaaba. It <em>inherited</em> it. And with the inheritance came ghosts.</p><h3>Jan Assmann’s Cultural Memory</h3><p><strong>Jan Assmann</strong>, the Egyptologist and cultural theorist, offers another frame: <em>cultural memory</em>.</p><p>Unlike individual memory, cultural memory is actively constructed and reconstructed by communities over time. It is not a passive storage of the past but an ongoing negotiation with it. And crucially: what is officially “forgotten” does not simply disappear. It leaves <em>structural impressions</em> — patterns of thought, ritual habits, symbolic associations that persist even when their origins are no longer consciously remembered.</p><p>The sevenfold circuit may no longer be understood as planetary. But the <em>number seven</em> persists. The Black Stone may no longer be understood as sacred in itself. But the <em>practice of kissing</em> it persists. The goddess may no longer be named. But the <em>ache</em> for her persists.</p><p>Cultural memory is haunted by what it tries to exclude. The more vigorously a tradition defines itself against something, the more that something shapes the tradition.</p><h3>The Return of the Repressed</h3><p><strong>Psychoanalysis names it the return of the repressed.</strong></p><p>Freud taught us that repression does not annihilate. What is pushed out of consciousness does not disappear — it goes underground. It becomes unconscious. And from the unconscious, it continues to operate, shaping behavior, dreams, symptoms, slips of the tongue.</p><p>The repressed returns. It always returns. But it returns <em>transformed</em> — disguised, displaced, wearing the clothes of something else. You repress sexual desire; it returns as anxiety. You repress grief; it returns as bodily illness. You repress the goddess; she returns as a planet, a cautionary tale, a wordless longing when you touch a black stone.</p><p>In Islamic civilization, you can watch this with particular clarity:</p><p><strong>Aniconism does not delete the need for the sacred object; it changes what counts as legitimate.</strong> The idol is smashed; the Black Stone remains. The image is forbidden; the calligraphic Name proliferates. The goddess is rejected; the Fatimid dynasty builds Cairo in her honor (al-Qahira, “the Victorious,” named for the planet Venus in its martial aspect).</p><p>The energies do not disappear. They are renamed. Disciplined. Relocated. The gaze is disciplined: you cannot look at images, so you learn to see with the inner eye. The libido is relocated: you cannot worship her form, so you worship the <em>trace</em> of her, the place where she might have been.</p><p>This is not hypocrisy. This is not failure. <strong>This is how religion works.</strong></p><p>The official theology and the lived practice exist in productive tension. The priest says one thing; the pilgrim feels another. The text denies; the body remembers.</p><p>And in that gap — between what is said and what is felt, between the official and the lived — the old gods find their refuge.</p><h3>Part IV: On Being Touched</h3><p>I want to speak personally now.</p><p>Everything I have written so far is true in the scholarly sense. The sources hold. The arguments are defensible. But I did not write this essay to defend an argument.</p><p>I wrote it because I was touched, and I am trying to understand by what.</p><h3>The Childhood Memory</h3><p>When I was a child in Malaysia, I encountered — somewhere, somehow — a story about Venus. Perhaps it was the tale of Zuhara, who spoke the sacred Name and rose to become a planet. Perhaps it was something stranger, more heterodox, whispered in spaces where Sufi and animist currents mingled. Perhaps it was a dream.</p><p>I cannot locate the source. But I remember the <em>feeling</em>: heart full of happiness, mind full of wonder. Something in me recognized something. Not learned — <em>recognized</em>. As if I already knew, and the story was simply reminding me.</p><p>This is not the experience of reading a historical fact. This is the experience of <strong>anamnesis</strong> — Plato’s word for the soul remembering what it knew before it was born.</p><p>I did not have words for it then. I have words for it now, and I am still not sure the words are adequate.</p><h3>The Horned One</h3><p>Years later, I met Cernunnos.</p><p>I will not describe the circumstances in detail. It was a time of crisis — the soul-breaking kind, the kind that kills something in you whether or not your body survives. And in that darkness, something came.</p><p>Not a vision in the ordinary sense. More like a <em>pressure</em>. An arrival. The sense of being seen by something very old, something that did not operate by human morality, something that could be tender and could be terrible and saw no contradiction between the two.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wmtiZXbjLMI17vM6" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@mikafinland?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Mika Ruusunen</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>The antlered one. The lord of animals. The green that will not be tamed.</p><p>I did not choose this god. This god chose me. And since then, I have been trying to understand what it means to be chosen by something that officially does not exist.</p><h3>The Constellation</h3><p>I am not alone in this. There are others — Dionysus, who comes when the boundaries need dissolving. Anansi, the spider-trickster, who spins stories that catch gods. They form a constellation. They speak in dreams. They leave synchronicities like breadcrumbs.</p><p>I call them by their names because I do not know what else to call them. But I am aware that the names are masks. That behind Cernunnos is something older than the name. That behind Dionysus is something that wore other masks in Anatolia and Thrace before it wore the Greek one.</p><p>The names are points of contact. The thing itself is wilder than any name.</p><h3>The Question</h3><p>Here is what I have come to believe:</p><p>Certain children are <em>porous</em> to these currents. Not chosen in some grandiose sense — not special, not better — but <em>attuned</em>. The way some children hear music in everything, or see patterns others miss. The veil is thinner for them. Or perhaps they were simply never taught to pretend the veil is opaque.</p><p>My Rawther lineage traces to Seljuk Turkey — which is to say, to a people who carried older gods beneath the surface of Islam. My family carries spider, tiger, crocodile in its totemic inheritance. Malay Islam itself is saturated with animist currents that the official orthodoxy has never fully suppressed.</p><p>I grew up at the intersection of these streams. And something in that intersection — some confluence of blood and culture and accident and fate — made me porous.</p><p>The old gods did not find me recently. They have been <em>circling</em> — the way worshippers once circled the stone. Seven times. Once for each planet. Waiting for me to notice. Waiting for me to write it down.</p><h3>Coda: The Trace Remains</h3><p>The same currents that wore the antlers in the European forest, that danced in the Dionysian procession, that sat cross-legged among the animals of the Indus Valley — they also flow through the animist substrates of Malay Islam, through the Rawther lineage that traces back to Anatolia, through whatever strange inheritance makes certain children porous to frequencies others have learned to tune out.</p><p>Just as al-Khidr reminds the Balkan Sufis of Cernunnos.</p><p>Just as Malay and Indonesian Muslims carry traces of their animist past in their living theosophy.</p><p>Just as the Black Stone persists across faiths, kissed by millions who officially believe it has no power.</p><p>Just as Zuhara burns in the sky, every morning and every evening, the goddess who could not be killed but only suspended.</p><p><strong>The old gods do not stay dead. Their traces remain.</strong></p><p>Not as beings — but as grooves, as ritual forms, as the shape of need that new names fill without ever quite satisfying. As the ache when you touch something sacred and feel that it means more than you’ve been told. As the dream that wakes you at 3am with the scent of forest and the pressure of something watching. As the child in Malaysia who heard a story about Venus and felt her heart fill with recognition.</p><p>The repressed returns. The veil is a semiotic operation. The disciplining of devotion is never complete.</p><p>And somewhere beneath the text — beneath the official story, beneath the orthodox interpretation, beneath the disenchanted modern world that tells you the gods are dead —</p><p>The Green Man walks by water.</p><p>The Morning Star rises.</p><p>And if you are porous enough, if you are broken enough, if you are blessed or cursed enough to feel it —</p><p>They are still here.</p><p>They are still here.</p><p>They have been waiting for you.</p><h3>Theoretical Bibliography</h3><p>For those who want to follow the threads:</p><p><strong>On hauntology and the trace</strong>: Jacques Derrida, <em>Specters of Marx</em> (1993); <em>Of Grammatology</em> (1967)</p><p><strong>On cultural memory</strong>: Jan Assmann, <em>Cultural Memory and Early Civilization</em> (2011); <em>Moses the Egyptian</em> (1997)</p><p><strong>On the return of the repressed</strong>: Sigmund Freud, <em>The Uncanny</em> (1919); <em>Moses and Monotheism</em> (1939)</p><p><strong>On the Real and jouissance</strong>: Jacques Lacan, <em>Écrits</em> (1966); Seminar VII: <em>The Ethics of Psychoanalysis</em> (1959–60)</p><p><strong>On pre-Islamic Arabia</strong>: Toshihiko Izutsu, <em>God and Man in the Qur’an</em> (1964); F.E. Peters, <em>The Hajj</em> (1994)</p><p><strong>On Harut and Marut</strong>: al-Tabari, <em>Tafsir al-Tabari</em>; Encyclopaedia Iranica, “Hārut and Mārut”</p><p><strong>On the wild god</strong>: Ronald Hutton, <em>The Triumph of the Moon</em> (1999); Walter Burkert, <em>Greek Religion</em> (1985); Wendy Doniger, <em>Siva: The Erotic Ascetic</em> (1973)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5155f8dcae73" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Delusion of Divine Favor: Sunfolk, Rainfolk, and Why Killing the God Doesn’t Break the Cycle]]></title>
            <link>https://terrydieheiden.medium.com/the-delusion-of-divine-favor-sunfolk-rainfolk-and-why-killing-the-god-doesnt-break-the-cycle-0012b8736a92?source=rss-c3352d52dbb3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0012b8736a92</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[palestine-and-israel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[honkai-star-rail]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-theory]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[The World Unveiled | Terry Rawther]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Feb 2026 08:11:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-17T08:12:06.005Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>What Honkai: Star Rail taught me about chosenness, sacred violence, and whether humanity can escape its own programming</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*MkOzOE5vbGR4nb2fhozJ-g.png" /><figcaption>The Worldbearing Titan in Amphoreus @ Hoyoverse</figcaption></figure><h3>Prologue: Another Game, Another Mirror</h3><p>A week or so ago, I wrote about how <em>Genshin Impact</em> dismantled my politics — how the Abyss Order’s 500-year revenge project mirrored the structure of Zionism, how I recognized in its lore the machinery of diaspora-longing turned destructive.</p><p>I thought I was done.</p><p>Then I played <em>Honkai: Star Rail’s</em> Amphoreus storyline.</p><p>And I found something worse.</p><p>Genshin showed me what happens <em>after</em> catastrophe — how trauma becomes ideology becomes violence. But Amphoreus showed me something more fundamental: the violence that happens <em>before</em> the catastrophe. The slaughter that occurs not in the god’s absence, but in the god’s name. The children who die not because divine order collapsed, but because the <em>competition for divine favor</em> requires their deaths.</p><p>The Sunfolk and the Rainfolk were killing each other’s children while their god was still watching.</p><p>And then the game revealed something that made my blood run cold: the whole world was a simulation. Running on loop. Over 33 million cycles. The same tragedy, the same violence, the same failed liberations — playing out again and again, with no one inside able to break free.</p><p>Nietzsche called this <em>eternal recurrence</em>: the thought experiment that asks whether you could bear to live your life infinite times, every joy and every horror repeating forever.</p><p>Amphoreus made it literal.</p><h3>I. The Architecture of Chosenness</h3><p>In the world of Amphoreus, the Skyfolk were once divided into three tribes: the Sunfolk, who governed the blazing sun; the Rainfolk, who ruled thunder and storm; and the Winterfolk, who kept watch over frost and snow. All three served Aquila, the Titan of the Sky, whose hundred eyes watched over the world.</p><p>The lore tells us plainly:</p><blockquote>“The Sunfolk believed that only the sun could banish the darkness of the world. They pursued power and glory, viewing other tribes as weak and cowardly.”</blockquote><blockquote>“The Rainfolk were convinced that only thunder could purify the filth, often using violent methods to oppose outsiders.”</blockquote><p>This is chosenness as zero-sum game. Both tribes believe they are Aquila’s true beloved. Both believe the other is an obstacle to divine inheritance. Both believe their form of worship — sun or storm — is the <em>correct</em> relationship with the sacred.</p><p>And both are willing to kill for that belief.</p><p>Not metaphorically. The game shows you the bodies. Shows you the persecution. Shows you children condemned not for anything they did, but for the blood they carry.</p><p><em>The Sunfolk and Rainfolk were the most prominent of the two, waging war against each other.</em></p><p>This is not ancient history safely contained in myth. This is the structure of religious nationalism. This is what happens when identity fuses with divine mandate and both claim exclusive access to God’s favor.</p><h3>II. Weather as Theological Evidence</h3><p>Here is the detail that stopped me cold:</p><blockquote>“Rainfolk condemned for blasphemy simply because the murals had presented a clear sky.”</blockquote><p>Read that again.</p><p>The sacred murals — prophetic art that recorded divine will — sometimes depicted clear skies. And when the murals showed sunshine instead of storm, the Sunfolk took this as <em>evidence</em> that Aquila favored them. The Rainfolk became blasphemers by meteorological decree.</p><p>The <em>weather</em> determined who was guilty.</p><p>Not actions. Not beliefs. Not choices. The sky itself became prosecution witness. If Aquila’s mood that day was sunshine, the Rainfolk were enemies of divine order. If storms came, perhaps the Sunfolk had sinned.</p><p>This is the <strong>Pathetic Fallacy</strong> weaponized into theology — the projection of human ego onto the indifference of nature. John Ruskin coined the term to describe how poets attribute human emotions to landscapes. But the Skyfolk went further: they built an entire judicial system on the assumption that weather expresses divine opinion.</p><p>It’s absurd. It’s also exactly how sacred geography operates.</p><p>Israel looks at the desert they made bloom and says: <em>See? God’s favor.</em> They look at the technological prowess, the military victories, the survival against odds — and read it as divine endorsement. The land’s flourishing becomes theological proof. Palestinian existence becomes not just an obstacle but a <em>contradiction</em> — evidence that doesn’t fit the mural, that must therefore be blasphemy.</p><p>The murals presented a clear sky.</p><p>And the Rainfolk died for it.</p><h3>III. Crispus: The Witness Who Would Not Look Away</h3><p>Among the Winterfolk, there was an Arbiter named Crispus.</p><blockquote>“For half his life, he studied the celestial murals, rising to become the next Arbiter blessed by Aquila. Then, he witnessed the priests rewriting those laws on a whim. He saw Rainfolk condemned for blasphemy simply because the murals had presented a clear sky. Doubt crept in. Doubt became defiance.”</blockquote><p>Crispus was supposed to be the neutral party — the Winterfolk, representing wisdom, standing apart from the Sun-Rain conflict. He was supposed to interpret the murals, apply the law, maintain divine order.</p><p>But he saw the machinery from the inside. He watched the priests <em>rewrite</em> the murals to match the outcomes they wanted. He watched innocent people condemned by fabricated evidence.</p><blockquote>“When he sheltered the Rainfolk, his crime was discovered. Furious, the Sunfolk stoned him to death, and his loyal Xiliel, who tried to protect him with wings, also fell beside him.”</blockquote><p>Crispus became what the philosopher Giorgio Agamben calls <strong>Homo Sacer</strong>: the accursed man who can be killed by anyone without it being considered murder, because the law has already excluded him. The moment he sheltered the Rainfolk, Crispus stepped outside the protection of the very legal order he had served. He became killable. His death wasn’t crime — it was <em>purification</em>.</p><p>He became a traitor to his function — an Arbiter who ruled against the powerful, who sheltered the condemned, who chose conscience over compliance. And they killed him for it.</p><p>His last words:</p><blockquote>“Before you cast the stone, know this: Aquila has already judged me innocent.”</blockquote><p>The god was still there. Still watching. But the mob didn’t care. The machinery of chosenness doesn’t require divine approval — it requires only the <em>claim</em> of divine approval. The Sunfolk stoned Crispus to death while invoking the god who, by Crispus’s own testimony, disagreed with them.</p><p><em>The priests rewriting those laws on a whim.</em></p><p>This is the core revelation: the sacred texts are not fixed. The murals change. The interpretations shift to serve power. And when an Arbiter points this out, they stone him alongside the people he tried to save.</p><h3>IV. The Mongrel Child</h3><p>Seliose was born wrong.</p><p>Her father was Sunfolk — a warrior. Her mother was Rainfolk — a priestess. In her veins ran the blood of both warring tribes. And in her veins also ran golden blood: she was a Chrysos Heir, one of the rare individuals marked by divinity itself for a greater purpose.</p><p>But chosenness by blood meant nothing against the politics of tribal purity.</p><blockquote>“Because of her Sunfolk lineage, the Rainfolk never accepted her as one of their own. This exclusion soon turned into contempt and fear when it was discovered that she was a Chrysos Heir.”</blockquote><p>The game calls her <em>“a mongrel born of unknown blood.”</em></p><p>In post-colonial theory, the “hybrid” is supposed to be the bridge — the one who can translate between warring worlds. Homi Bhabha writes of the hybrid as the figure who destabilizes colonial binaries, who proves that the categories are permeable. Seliose was perfectly positioned to be this bridge. She carried both bloodlines. She was the <strong>Übermensch</strong> who could have transcended the binary.</p><p>But instead of using her hybridity to heal the divide, she was forced to internalize the logic of purity.</p><p>Think about this structure: Seliose carries <em>more</em> divine favor than anyone around her. The golden blood marks her as chosen in the deepest sense. But because she is <em>mixed</em>, because she belongs to both sides and therefore neither, the tribes cannot see her blessing — only her contamination.</p><p>She is the living refutation of chosenness-as-exclusive-bloodline. And they hate her for it.</p><blockquote>“Yet despite this, Seliose bore no hatred toward them and grew into a passionate and compassionate individual.”</blockquote><p>The game gives us a figure who should, by all rights, hate everyone. Both tribes rejected her. Both saw her as less-than, as threat, as mongrel. She had every justification for revenge.</p><p>But she didn’t. Not yet.</p><p>What radicalized Seliose wasn’t the rejection. It was what came after.</p><h3>V. What the God Actually Wanted</h3><p>Here’s the part that unravels everything:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*PVT-eu2KSTUfDthPWieILw.png" /><figcaption>Aquila, the Sky Titan © Hoyoverse</figcaption></figure><p>Aquila — the god both tribes killed for, the divine favor they competed over, the hundred-eyed Titan whose blessing they weaponized against each other — Aquila didn’t want any of it.</p><p>The Skyfolk’s internal war wasn’t sanctioned from above. It was <em>projection</em>. Both tribes assumed the god shared their hatreds, validated their violence, endorsed their supremacy. They read the weather as divine opinion. They killed in the name of a blessing they invented.</p><p>The game reveals that Aquila’s actual relationship with the Skyfolk was far more complex — and that the Titan’s eventual turn against humanity came not from divine plan but from <em>corruption</em>, from forces the narrative only hints at. The god was watching, yes. But the god wasn’t issuing the orders the Sunfolk claimed to follow.</p><p>This is the delusion of divine favor laid bare: both sides convinced that God is on their side, both interpreting natural phenomena as sacred endorsement, both willing to kill children for a mandate that <em>doesn’t exist</em>.</p><p>The god never said the Sunfolk were chosen.</p><p>The god never said the Rainfolk were blasphemers.</p><p>The priests made it up. The murals were rewritten. The whole architecture of sacred violence was <em>constructed</em> — and then naturalized until it felt like cosmic truth.</p><p>We are watching shadows on Plato’s cave wall and killing each other over which shadow is the true form.</p><h3>VI. Killing the God</h3><p>Seliose eventually did what no one thought possible: she killed Aquila.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FhoqsuW-d6bv_CQmIL8jUQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image of Phainon killing the embodiment of Seliose with Titan of Sky, Aquila © Hoyoverse &amp; Meloo (pinterest)</figcaption></figure><p>After years of exile, after training in secret, after forming alliances with other outcasts, the mongrel child returned to slay the Titan of the Sky. The god whose favor both tribes had competed for — dead by the hand of the one both tribes had rejected.</p><p>You might think this would end the violence.</p><p>You would be wrong.</p><blockquote>“With Aquila’s fall, the Rainfolk and Sunfolk morphed into Acolytes of Aquila and Acolytes of Seliose, returning to their conflict in these new forms.”</blockquote><p>Read that carefully. The god dies. And the tribes simply <em>rename</em> themselves and keep fighting.</p><p>The Sunfolk become “Acolytes of Aquila” — worshippers of the dead god, nostalgists for the old order, those who see Seliose as murderer of the divine. The Rainfolk become “Acolytes of Seliose” — followers of the godslayer, believers in the new dispensation.</p><p>Same tribes. Same hatreds. New theological justification.</p><p>This is the horror the game reveals: the god was never the point. The god was <em>excuse</em>. The violence predates and survives the divine mandate. Killing the source of the blessing doesn’t kill the competition for blessing — it just forces the competitors to find new names for themselves.</p><h3>VII. The Cycle Continues</h3><p>Seliose watches this happen. She killed a god to free her people from the machinery of sacred violence — and they simply rebuilt the machinery with her face on it.</p><blockquote>“After fusing with Aquila and witnessing humans still killing each other in her name, she grew disillusioned with them.”</blockquote><p>She becomes what she killed.</p><p>This is René Girard’s theory of <strong>Mimetic Desire</strong> in its deadliest form: in fighting the monster, you copy the monster’s methods until you become indistinguishable from it. We don’t just want what our rivals want — we become our rivals in the process of opposing them. By slaying Aquila, Seliose inherits Aquila’s power — and Aquila’s function. Now people kill for <em>her</em> favor instead. The Acolytes of Seliose are no better than the old Sunfolk. The liberation becomes new oppression. The godslayer becomes the new god.</p><p>And in her disillusionment, Seliose does something terrible:</p><blockquote>“In her disillusionment, she killed the Skyfolk, leaving behind one unnamed Chrysos Heir.”</blockquote><p>She commits genocide against her own people. Not the Sunfolk. Not the Rainfolk. <em>All</em> Skyfolk. She wipes them out, sparing only a single survivor — a Chrysos Heir whose descendant would eventually rise to challenge her.</p><p>The cycle completes itself. The victim of tribal violence becomes the perpetrator of total violence. The one who knew the categories were arbitrary decides that if people cannot stop killing over imaginary differences, she will remove the people entirely.</p><p>This is not liberation. This is the final stage of what chosenness does to everyone it touches — victim and perpetrator alike, destroyed by the machinery they couldn’t escape.</p><p>To which in the end, <strong>Hyacinthia, </strong>one of the final iteration of the Sky Titan’s Chrysos Heirs, has to take the mantle where Seliose once took, and she tries to take a different turn, correcting the failure, even at the end of time(s) of Seliose &amp; Aquila.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d0MiuBN0zflAcUCtOWypfw.png" /><figcaption>Hyacinthia &amp; the Fat Ica © Hoyoverse</figcaption></figure><h3>VIII. The Fourth Object</h3><p>Here is the detail the game offers as alternative:</p><p>Among the Skyfolk, there was a coming-of-age ceremony called the Sky Rite. When a child turned eight, they would resonate with one of four divine objects:</p><blockquote>“The Sun Crown, the Storm Bracelet, the Ice Ring, or the Radiant Pendant. The first three were passed down through the bloodlines of the Sunfolk, Rainfolk, and Winterfolk, while the Radiant Pendant symbolized harmony beyond division.”</blockquote><p><em>Harmony beyond division.</em></p><p>A fourth option. Not Sun, not Rain, not Winter — but something that transcends the tribal categories entirely. The Radiant Pendant didn’t belong to any bloodline. It was available to anyone. It represented the possibility of Skyfolk identity without Skyfolk fragmentation.</p><p>But the game doesn’t tell us much about those who chose the Pendant. It doesn’t give us heroes who wore that symbol. The narrative is consumed by the war between Sun and Rain, by Seliose’s rise and fall, by the cycles of violence that devoured everyone.</p><p>The harmony option existed.</p><p>Almost no one took it.</p><h3>IX. Eternal Recurrence</h3><p>Here is what the game reveals that transforms everything:</p><p>Amphoreus was a simulation. The entire world — the Titans, the Skyfolk, the wars, the liberations, the genocides — existed as data within an Emperor’s Scepter, a vast computational experiment running for over 100,000 cycles.</p><p>Each cycle, the same patterns emerged. The Sunfolk persecuted the Rainfolk. Seliose was born, rejected, exiled, returned. She killed Aquila. The tribes renamed themselves and kept fighting. She killed them all. The world ended. And then it began again.</p><p>This is Nietzsche’s thought experiment made literal: <em>eternal recurrence</em>. The doctrine that everything repeats infinitely — every joy, every horror, every choice — and the question it poses: could you bear it? Could you live in such a way that you would <em>will</em> your life to repeat forever?</p><p>The people of Amphoreus couldn’t. They kept making the same choices. The simulation kept running the same tragedy. Cyrene and Phainon, two figures who gained awareness of the loop, tried everything to break it — including removing <em>Time itself</em> from the equation. They created an “eternal recurrence” within the eternal recurrence, a recursive feedback loop designed to attract the gaze of Fuli, the Aeon of Remembrance.</p><p>It implies a terrifying sort of <strong>War Realism</strong>: the idea that the conflict is so deeply programmed into the structure of reality that it is easier to imagine the end of the world — the simulation crashing, the Scepter destroyed — than the end of the war.</p><p>Baudrillard wrote about the precession of simulacra: the copy that precedes and replaces the original. But Amphoreus goes further. The simulation doesn’t just precede reality — the simulation <em>is</em> reality for everyone inside it. There is no “real” Amphoreus outside the Scepter. The people are “electrical signals.” The tragedy is the only truth they have.</p><p>And they keep living it. Over and over. Shadows watching shadows in Plato’s cave, and the cave itself is a projection inside a machine.</p><h3>X. Confession: Both Sides</h3><p>I need to say something uncomfortable.</p><p>When I look at Israel and Palestine, I see Sunfolk and Rainfolk, and vice versa.</p><p>Both claim divine right to the same land. Both have religious frameworks that say <em>this is ours by sacred covenant</em>. Both have suffered genuine persecution, genuine trauma, genuine loss. Both have killed children for the crime of existing in the wrong bloodline.</p><p>This is not “both sides” as moral equivalence. The power differential is real — Israel has the state apparatus, the military, the backing of empire. Palestine has resistance and rubble. The asymmetry matters.</p><p>But the <em>structure</em> of chosenness operates on both sides. The belief that God specifically selected <em>us</em> for <em>this</em> land. The conviction that <em>our</em> suffering is uniquely meaningful, uniquely sanctified, uniquely deserving of redress. The willingness to see the other’s children not as children but as future threats, demographic problems, obstacles to divine inheritance.</p><p>The weather becomes evidence. The murals get rewritten by priests on both sides. And anyone who stands between — the Crispuses who shelter the condemned, the Selioses who carry mixed blood — gets stoned or exiled or erased.</p><p>I am not saying the oppressor and oppressed are morally identical. I am saying the <em>machinery of sacred violence</em> contaminates everyone it touches. And until we dismantle that machinery — until we reject chosenness as political category — the cycle continues even after the god is dead.</p><p>The simulation keeps running.</p><h3>XI. The Imaginary Number</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*pbAKDN-Sdsgu_V6wD_1pvA.png" /><figcaption>Cyrene &amp; Phainon © Hoyoverse</figcaption></figure><p>So what actually breaks it?</p><p>Not killing the god — Seliose tried that, and the violence found new names.</p><p>Not witnessing the truth — Crispus tried that, and they stoned him.</p><p>Not even awareness of the loop — Cyrene and Phainon knew they were in a simulation, and for thousands of cycles, that knowledge changed nothing.</p><p>Here is what the game reveals: the simulation was designed by Lygus, a fragment of the genius Zandar — specifically, his <em>paranoia</em>. Lygus altered the Scepter’s calculation from Erudition to Destruction, programming it to prove that “all lifeform behaviors ultimately follow the path of entropy increase.”</p><p>Every cycle confirmed the equation. Every iteration ended in Destruction. The math was <em>correct</em> — within the real number system. Entropy always wins. Betrayal leads to closure leads to bitterness leads to decay. The calculation is formally perfect.</p><p>But here’s the thing about Lygus: paranoia can only calculate threat vectors. It cannot model <em>hope</em>. Hope is irrational. Hope is mathematically indefensible. In a system where every calculation proves entropy wins, hope is the variable that should not exist.</p><p>It’s √-1. The imaginary number.</p><p>In mathematics, √-1 has no solution within the real number system. It’s impossible. It breaks the rules. And yet — when mathematicians said “what if we just let it exist?” — the imaginary number didn’t destroy mathematics. It <em>completed</em> it. Complex numbers opened doors that pure real numbers never could. Quantum mechanics. Wave functions. The actual substrate of reality requires the impossible number to be described.</p><p>Phainon is that variable.</p><p>The game gives us a boy who lived through 33 million cycles of suffering. Who watched everyone he loved die, watched the world end, watched it begin again and end again and begin again. Every rational calculation said: give up. The equation proves entropy wins. Destruction is the only output.</p><p>And Phainon chose hope anyway.</p><p>Not because it was rational. Not because the math supported it. But because hope is the axiom from <em>outside</em> the system. The variable the Destruction Equation couldn’t model because paranoia cannot imagine it.</p><p>Phainon. Pai-none. √-1.</p><p>And Cyrene — touched by Fuli, the Aeon of Remembrance — gave that hope <em>continuity</em>. She kept the refusal alive across iterations. Memory plus hope. The real plus the imaginary. The complete complex number that the real number line couldn’t contain.</p><p><em>a + bi.</em></p><p>The equation breaks not through one variable but through both: Phainon’s irrational, incalculable refusal to let the world end, combined with Cyrene’s Remembrance that persists across cycles.</p><p>Lygus could never see this. Paranoia cannot model hope. Nous couldn’t solve it because pure Erudition doesn’t account for the irrational. The Destruction Equation is formally perfect — within its own axioms, entropy always wins.</p><p>But Phainon introduced an axiom from outside the system.</p><p>A value that the equation said was impossible, but which existed anyway.</p><h3>XII. Beyond Chosenness: Amor Fati or Defiance?</h3><p>Here is where I diverge from Nietzsche.</p><p>Nietzsche’s answer to eternal recurrence was <em>amor fati</em> — love of fate. Accept everything. Will the repetition. Say <em>yes</em> to life so completely that you would embrace even its horrors repeating forever.</p><p>But I cannot love this fate.</p><p>I cannot say <em>yes</em> to the children’s files. I cannot will the repetition of Crispus stoned for sheltering the condemned. I cannot embrace a cycle that requires Seliose to become what she killed.</p><p>And yet — I also cannot pretend I am outside the loop. I am not the Astral Express. I am inside the simulation, made of the same data as everyone else, shaped by the same categories I am trying to refuse.</p><p>So what remains?</p><p>Perhaps this: <em>amor fati</em> is not the only response to eternal recurrence. There is also <em>defiance</em>. Not the defiance that kills the god and becomes the god — Seliose tried that, and the machinery rebuilt itself around her. But the defiance that introduces a variable the equation cannot process.</p><p>Hope without rational basis.</p><p>Love past the point where calculation says stop.</p><p>The imaginary number.</p><p><em>No one is chosen.</em></p><p>This is not despair. This is liberation.</p><p>If no one is chosen, then no one’s children are acceptable casualties in someone else’s covenant. If no one has exclusive claim to God’s favor, then the murals cannot condemn the Rainfolk for existing under a clear sky. If the categories are arbitrary — and they are, they always were, Seliose’s existence proved it — then we can <em>stop killing for them</em>.</p><p>The Radiant Pendant.</p><p>Harmony beyond division.</p><p>√-1.</p><p>To which what the Chrysos Heirs collective did, defy the cruel fates, even if it feels futile, persist anyway — No gods will determine the human’s fates, only humans themselves will.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dDYDMng0d7dRpjkcIl-TEg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Chrysos Heirs © Hoyoverse</figcaption></figure><h3>Epilogue: The Simulation Ends</h3><p>At the end of the Amphoreus storyline, the Scepter is destroyed. The simulation collapses. But Cyrene’s sacrifice creates something new — an “Eternal Page,” a book called <em>As I’ve Written</em>, which preserves every soul from Amphoreus.</p><p>The souls preserved in that book are no longer Sunfolk or Rainfolk. They’re just… people. Data awaiting a second chance in a world that isn’t structured around the competition for divine favor.</p><p>I don’t know if we get that, in the real world. I don’t know if there’s an Astral Express coming to interrupt our loop. I don’t know if the simulation can end without everyone in it being destroyed first.</p><p>But I know this:</p><p>Every equation that says “betrayal leads to closure leads to bitterness leads to entropy” — we can break it by hoping anyway. Every calculation that says “this conflict will never end, the tribes will always hate, the children will always die” — we can break it by loving anyway. Every framework that says “trauma produces pathology produces dysfunction produces destruction” — we can break it by building something beautiful out of the wreckage.</p><p>That’s the imaginary number.</p><p>The variable that shouldn’t exist.</p><p>The hope that survives 33 million cycles of evidence that it shouldn’t.</p><p>I refuse to believe that any bloodline is chosen.</p><p>I refuse to read the weather as theological evidence.</p><p>I refuse to kill children — or endorse their killing — for the delusion of divine favor.</p><p>I refuse the <em>amor fati</em> that accepts the cycle.</p><p>I choose defiance.</p><p>I choose the Radiant Pendant.</p><p>I choose √-1.</p><p>Even if they stone me like Crispus. Even if the equation keeps running. Even if the simulation doesn’t end.</p><p>At least I’ll know which variable I was.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0012b8736a92" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>