<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Justin Fleming on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Justin Fleming on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@the-typer?source=rss-4c5509ad50b6------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 13:13:09 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@the-typer/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In Big Walk…(spoilers)]]></title>
            <link>https://the-typer.medium.com/in-big-walk-spoilers-38f52f14171b?source=rss-4c5509ad50b6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/38f52f14171b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[puzzle]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[big-walk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[friendslop]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Fleming]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Nov 2026 05:08:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-03T05:20:35.010Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ivPw2DaTMejNhWCaBYLoZA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>In Big Walk, expression of self is fundamental.</em> In the training area, the player is provided two primary means of expression.</p><p>First they are given the ability to speak (or type) and hear each other.</p><p>Second, in the tutorial area, the player has the ability to use a color palette and a paint brush to customize the three body parts of <em>other</em> characters.</p><p>The means of communication, verbal, non-verbal, and self identification, are how players are first shown how to express themselves in Big Walk.</p><p>It is noteworthy that <em>in Big Walk, neither of these forms of expression have much function in a vacuum</em>. Without the presence of another, communication is pointless as there is no one to talk to. And without the presence of a friend to help, you cannot paint yourself the colors you will use to distinguish yourself amidst peers that aren’t there. <em>In Big Walk, you cannot do things alone.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XgOV1-hDHYuecHJtY4iKTg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The experience of playing Big Walk is a series of puzzle exercises that rely on the interdependence of people and these forms of expression: Talking to people you know. You know who you’re talking to by their voice, the way they speak and sound to you, and how you recognize them visually. It’s noteworthy that apparently Big Walk has no actual terms for *anything* in the game’s patches or guidance, only a description of the item, its function, or locations. So, the paintbrush, for example; if the game were updated where the paint brush was twice as big as before, the notes would say, “The <strong>object that lets players change the colors of each other’s bodies</strong> has been doubled in size.” The only reason I can imagine for this approach to naming things (by not naming them) is because it is a playful way to take advantage of player-chosen signifiers to <strong>let </strong>everyone communicate better. The best example of this is “<strong><em>the bean</em></strong>”. It’s the reward unlocked when solving puzzles, you use them to place in slots on top of towers and in other various places to unlock more of the island. That’s their <em>function. </em>In my first session of Big Walk, we called it a Kong (named after the dog toy). My second session of Big Walk, a different group called it a bean. I don’t see it. But others I’ve seen online call it a pear. Wikipedia has several listed possible names. It doesn’t matter so long as everyone can agree on what they’re talking about. This is the genius of Big Walk’s fundamental approach to communicating with other people: It gives you the freedom to start with a fairly clean slate, the game will not tell you “This is a bean. These are strobe lights. Here’s what they are for.” and the end result is you and a group of people start making terms that become your language for the duration of your Big Walk. <em>In Big Walk, terms and definitions are not dictated to you, but agreed upon as a collective.</em></p><p>The biggest critique I heard leveraged against Big Walk in the early days is that its proximity chat voice functionality is extremely short ranged. This complaint went down over time as I continued to play with people who started to understand what Big Walk is all about. While unrealistic, the way in which voices don’t travel far feels tuned to bring challenge to the communication in the game. The game and its puzzles will separate you and your friends, requiring you to find ways to overcome those distances imposed. While you may not be out of aural range of your friends so easily in reality, distance distorts the way we keep in touch with our friends in real life. And the same is true in Big Walk. Players will quickly learn that without the ability to hear each other, they will need to rely on other tools at their disposal to communicate. Walkie talkies, megaphones, hand gestures, white boards, flares, all of these can be utilized to try and communicate over greater distances. And the puzzles require players to overcome unique changes to the communication norms. Sometimes players can’t speak through radio waves while “in” the puzzle, other times players can’t see much but can talk to each other and need to guide each other. One of my favorite puzzles in the game felt built to try and enrage the players against each other as four players in different rooms could only send their voice into the next room ahead of them in a circular loop, no one could talk back to the same person and so it involved a fun game of telephone to communicate a series of symbols <em>twice </em>to fully complete the puzzle. Voice chat being short ranged in Big Walk only serves to reflect the ways in which we struggle to really understand our friends despite hearing each other all the time. <em>In Big Walk, you learn how important it is to understand each other more than just hearing them.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OhNKsYZ3pVwr5sDK-0P_Jg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Then, in Big Walk’s final challenge, you enter a giant sphere, and the game strips the player of the forms of self expression it gave you to begin with, removes the difficulties of greater distances, and asks you to solve seven more puzzles. No voice chat. No way to figure out who is who. You’re all the same, you all can’t speak or type to each other.</p><p>Figure it out. Together.</p><p>The game tries to pass on to the player just how disturbing these changes should be. When you enter this final zone, voices change pitch and frequency until they’re no longer audible to you, colors degrade and everyone becomes monocrhome (head, body, legs, all of it), a constantly shifting singular color for everyone at the same time. Big Walk strips you of the things you’ve been using to identify yourself to your peers, something that has already required the presence of your peers to appreciate. And without voice chat, you cannot rely on those signifiers from before. This is, on its face, creepy, scary, difficult. And yet, the music in this area and the experience of solving these puzzles together with your group is a steady course that will humble you. At some point through the process you’ll realize you don’t know who it is you’re looking at anymore, who you’re making gestures to and how you’re trying to make things clear. You might have some idea based on how your friends have solved puzzles up to now, but you’re not really <strong>sure</strong>. And yet, despite these gaps, the music that you’ve been finding across the game communicates its own message to you. In this scary, stark white environment, the music is sending you a calm and reassuring message that it believes you can do this. It is tranquil, organic, <em>peaceful</em>. For about an hour the rest of the world vanished and several friends of mine put everything aside so we could work together and see this through. As we solved the puzzles together I felt so proud of our ability to collectively make sense of things. Every floor up the black orb became a rallying moment. The gap in our ability to understand each other shortened and we would not be defeated. Because <em>in Big Walk you believe in each other.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cHh6YDsUO6LuDmnHrYoSGQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>House House developed Big Walk in response to the pandemic. The popularity of games like this are historically tied to those days. Fall Guys, Among Us, and Phasmaphobia <strong>exploded</strong> in popularity in 2020. But Big Walk came out six years later as the genre has been firmly established now as “friendslop”; a sort of endlessly replayable game activity that expands and grows with a developer’s wishes and the game’s success. Friendslop games don’t really <strong>end</strong>. Fall Guys had different map challenges. Phasmaphobia got new ghouls and monsters. As a pandemic lockdown extended and these games became more popular, a service could continue to be provided. Some games like PEAK created an “ending” as a sort of stopping point, but even PEAK has a recursive nature in its roguelike design with new mountains every day. Big Walk though? Before we finished it I predicted to my friends that it might end similarly to The Witness, with the world resetting and the game starting anew with nothing having changed. Maybe you’d end up right where you started, suggesting you go do it again.</p><p>But <em>in Big Walk…the journey ends.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sQtR5EbEFzsUbBFKPUEL0w.jpeg" /></figure><p>It has a fixed set of puzzles with a fixed number of possible (intended) solutions and it has two endings that you can achieve across one save. In the first ending you sit down and watch the credits with your friends in front of a big screen and then you go to a train station of sorts. The turnstile at the station prompts you with colors matching each character’s identity and only they can go through. Not since Gandalf turned back to Frodo at the Grey Havens has a farewell been so immediately understood. One at a time, you all leave the server and say your goodbyes as you walk off into a white void and then receive a message from House House saying they hope you enjoyed your time with the game.</p><p>Despite some variables and the ability to play it again with different people, Big Walk is a singular experience that, like a good work of art, stays with you long after you’ve closed the book on it.</p><p>Big Walk made me appreciate how it’s so important great journeys come to a close. Their ending necessitates you reflect back on what the experience contained for you.</p><p>I’m still thinking about what it left in me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DxI_cZdGswI9iY0u0ugpPA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>In Big Walk…I learned different people can accomplish quite a bit together despite all the boundaries a world will put in between them.</em> Distance. Silence. Anonymity. <em>Ego.</em> You can overcome all of these here and some people experience the same from getting together, having a good time, and solving some puzzles.</p><p>In the game’s final “secret” ending, you sit down in a circle and the game delivers some pamphlets to you. For me I was playing with three other people. And the pamphlets asked the four of us to share with each other a fond memory of our time in Big Walk. And then, as a nice little treat, the game lets us all walk off into a white void <em>together </em>in contrast to how the game initially ends, separately.</p><p>In Balk Walk, expression of self is fundamental.<br>In Big Walk, expression has little function in a vacuum.<br>In Big Walk, you cannot do things alone.<br>In Big Walk, terms and definitions are not chosen for you, but agreed upon as a collective.<br>In Big Walk, you learn how important it is to understand each other more than just hearing them.<br>In Big Walk, you believe in each other.<br>In Big Walk, the journey ends.<br>In Big Walk, different people can accomplish quite a bit together despite all the boundaries a world will put in between them.</p><p>In Big Walk…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CiLe-XCn46eWZeoHzBnSCA.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=38f52f14171b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Story About Me Told Through Three Video Games]]></title>
            <link>https://the-typer.medium.com/a-story-about-me-told-through-three-video-games-342c6b248c1e?source=rss-4c5509ad50b6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/342c6b248c1e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[night-in-the-woods]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life-is-strange]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[firewatch]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Fleming]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Sep 2026 16:01:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-22T16:21:01.726Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This piece features some heavy spoilers for Life is Strange (the first one), Firewatch, and Night in the Woods. This is the only spoiler warning. I will spoil each game’s twists and some of their contents, but not necessarily every part. The games are worthwhile experiences even if spoiled, so I’d recommend you try them out anyways if you like narrative heavy video games. But if you’d rather not but still like what I write, feel free to read on.</p><p>It’s also available as a video essay on <a href="https://youtu.be/2Fpi32EMegc?si=m_ZUmBH_gYlvNKC6">YouTube</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5PJe_7UjvapTlCpt6tT4Tg.png" /></figure><h4>Life is Strange</h4><p>Life is Strange is a 2015 adventure video game by DontNod Entertianment. It tells a coming of age story from the perspective of Max Caulfield, a senior high school student who has returned to her home town of Arcadia Bay after her family moved away five years ago. She discovers she has acquired time travel powers and reconnects with her childhood best friend (Chloe) while unraveling a mystery involving a missing teenage girl (Rachel).</p><p>The game design features a segmented time travel of appreciation. It’s built to allow players all the freedom to enjoy map chunks filled with artistic renderings of the world and the characters within it while being 100% limited by the timeliness of any one moment, because progressing to the next loading screen restricts how far back you can go in time. Your moment to move on as the point decisions are locked in is well telegraphed. You can rewind time in any given map and undo, redo, rethink, or alter decisions but only in that space. Once you move on from that space, there is no going back narratively and mechanically.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/525/1*Csu1nUOf5VTGF7P2i8mkrg.png" /></figure><p>The origins of Max’s time travel powers stem from her unknowingly saving Chloe one afternoon when she is shot by a rich student in the girls’ bathroom. While players experience this from the “egg” of a “chicken vs. egg” type time scenario, the reality is that this divergence in paths of Max saving Chloe through time travel powers likely gave her the powers to begin with. However, these quandaries of how Max got her powers aren’t that important to the story because it’s <strong><em>a coming of age story</em></strong>. The central design of this time travel isn’t to talk about physics, it’s to engage the player in what it feels like to be a <strong>teenager</strong>. You will endlessly replay choices in your head and in the game only to realize sometimes not all that much changes despite your efforts. In fact, sometimes the opposite is the result. Small ripple effects may have some concerning moments the day of but by the next day the impact is much more minimal compared to changing what happens in a given moment.</p><p>When I was a kid there were so many times I’d have arguments with friends over the most senseless things but because we were kids it would be a “friendship ending” declaration. By the next day that would mean nothing, as if the argument never happened. These themes also double as a wonderful fit for the constant complaint of the mid-10s adventure games polished by the Telltale formula: “My choices don’t matter”. I’ve said before that what you choose and what you feel is why these games gave you choices to begin with, not because of your ability to alter the world around you or to change mostly predetermined outcomes. It was always less about making a difference, but instead about <em>self-reflection</em>; what those choices mean to you and the consideration of them being a fun experiment players get to explore. But Life is Strange was the odd one out in the 2010s with its time travel designs because the intent was to remind players how it feels to be a teen playing out arguments and debates in your head about what was said, what you didn’t say, what you did or chose not to do every single day for every single tough scenario. You could end an interaction with “I treated my bully like a bully” and, in many ways, still arrive at the same destination at the end of a chapter or the whole game. A game where time travel empowerment is a lesson to be learned was exactly the type of “your actions won’t matter” counter the genre needed. Because the experience of repeated doubt makes players think more about what they’re choosing than what happens after the choice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8ykjroRwEqdZsnUmeCUWDw.png" /></figure><p>Life is Strange is an exploration of the desire to rewrite the story of our lives. By the time you get to the back half of the game, Max has toyed and played with time in some <em>very concerning</em> ways. She tries to explore a reality where Chloe’s dad never died and thus Chloe never goes into her dark rebellious phase that damages her future further and wounds her friendship with Max; but instead, Chloe alone experiences a car accident and is a paraplegic slowly dying from her condition and ends up begging Max for peace through euthanasia. Back in the game’s main reality, Max’s investigations only end in Chloe getting shot in the head by the culprit as they get close to finding the truth; and Max gets drugged before she can rewind time to save Chloe. This same culprit has also murdered another student to cover their tracks of abusing students as Max got closer and closer to the truth of the matter. In the last episode, Max is hopping through realities to try and unravel the mess as her little corner of the universe is having a geological reckoning in the form of a storm that will wipe out Arcadia Bay. Like many coming of age stories, we grapple with Max’s foolishness from her young mind and the teen perspective that “if I can just rewind time, I can save my friend without repercussions.” <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=19xgdLF5agU&amp;pp=ygUeaW5udWVuZG8gc3R1ZGlvcyBzdXBlcnBvc2l0aW9u">Innuendo Studios</a> covers the way this game forces players to decide between what genre the story is going to be by the end, but needless to say there’s a definite theme at play of “playing god with time and fate is a <strong>bad </strong>idea”. And that’s what makes both endings so dang tragic. In one ending, Max chooses to use her powers one final time and permit Chloe’s death, which unravels the mystery at the center of the whole game and brings justice to light <em>immediately </em>because of a student getting caught shooting a girl in a high school bathroom. Max and Chloe say goodbye having mended their friendship, Max learns how dangerous powers can be and what an everyday hero is, while Chloe comes to terms with her self-centered behaviors (and yes, the game makes a bad implication that the paradox is fixed by Chloe unjustly dying and that this potentially queer romance must suffer an end, it’s a trope, <strong>a bad one</strong>). The alternative? Seemingly, everyone else in the entire town just dies so Max and Chloe can live. The <strong>journey </strong>of learning these truths you can choose is <strong>what’s really important though</strong>. If the time paradox were never real and everything were to proceed “as intended”, Life is Strange is actually a brief short story about Max coming home and her childhood best friend getting shot and killed in the same room before Max can even reconcile her strained and distant relationship with Chloe. That’s not as compelling a story as “A girl uses time travel powers to unravel a murder mystery and learns some things along the way”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AFxALX6w06TzRskF0OnYTQ.png" /></figure><p>There’s some strong feelings out there about which ending is better or preferred, and I think DontNod did a good job at kindling those feelings. It’s a choice no teen, or adult for that matter, should <em>have </em>to make.</p><p>When I say Life is Strange is an exploration of the desire to rewrite the story of our lives, <em>this </em>is what I mean. Chloe dying without she and Max mending their friendship is one I’d want to rewrite too. In fact, I think Max already did in some advanced vision of all this. If you open Max’s diary in the game you can read the entries before the game’s narrative begins, before the time paradox has taken place. But right before the start of the diary entry that begins the game’s plot and the change of events, there’s a sticker right next to the date. It reads “THIS DOES NOT EXIST”. Oh to be able to just blot out that awful memory of horrors like it never happened. Forget the horror here.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/994/1*7SeUdEXoGr2gdjls37rsjQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QV3AKFXNoLlsnZ7bBSWQig.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Firewatch</h4><p>Firewatch is a 2016 adventure video game from Campo Santo. In it, you play Henry, a 40-something man who has come to Shoshone National Park in Wyoming to work as a fire lookout. You have a radio and spend various days across the summer of 1989 exploring the park via your map and using your radio to talk to your nearby fire lookout, Delilah. The game’s primary mechanics are pretty straightforward. You can walk and climb, take some pictures, use your map and compass to make sense of your way around the park, you can pick up small objects and put them down elsewhere. And you can use your radio to talk to Delilah. Conversations often involve anything you might notice going on in the park or getting to know each other every now and then. Players are given a couple dialogue responses to choose from any time a conversation is ongoing. Since there’s not that much else to do here in the woods all alone, talking to someone on the other end of the radio feels good.</p><p>I should make it clear that Campo Santo worked really hard to make sure the dialogue in this game feels fantastic. Just expertly done stuff. Two people in the middle of their lives chatting about literally anything for a game that lasts about 2–5 hours. That’s not the easiest thing to make <em>entertaining</em>. Of course, there is the <em>fire</em>, and the <em>mystery snooper</em>, and the whole private area potentially observing everything Henry and Delilah are talking about. But I’m getting ahead of myself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zXYH5aNuXgxEYqu32X6XOw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Firewatch was a video game coming out at the <em>tail end </em>of an adventure game revitalization across the 10s. Adventure games were really popular in the 90s, then they mostly fizzled away by the turn of the millennium until a company that had been carrying the torch (earlier mentioned as “Telltale Games”) found massive success with a video game called “The Walking Dead” in 2012. Some people who made the first season of that game left Telltale and formed Campo Santo. The 2010s had a lot of variations on The Walking Dead, made by Telltale and other companies. Some games stripped away The Walking Dead’s more <em>cinematic</em> storytelling with its detached perspective and animated characters and instead opted for storytelling by letting you explore a space. These were eventually called “Walking Simulators” because you mostly walk and interact with your environment, observe it, maybe read some journal entries. The breakout hit of the “Walking Sims” was a game from 2013 called Gone Home where you came home from being away at college for a year and discover what your family has been up to by looking at the things in the house and finding diary entries left everywhere by your sister. The house is void of people, they’re away while you explore your home. It’s a <em>little </em>unrealistic as a story is built to unfold, but the detailing of the space in Gone Home really sold the genre for people. It feels lived in and has charm. No matter how many ways you slice it, most seem to consider Firewatch as <em>one of </em>the best if not <em>the </em>best Walking Sim. Firewatch, Gone Home, and What Remains of Edith Finch tend to be high up on “best walking sim” lists. And I’m saying <strong>all this </strong>because if you looked at what people online were saying about Firewatch at the time of its release in early 2016, you wouldn’t think people liked it.</p><p>Firewatch had a really clever first trailer that was mostly setting up some unsettling vibes. It showed footage of Henry finding people from a distance watching him. The end of the trailer had Henry slowly descending into a cave while Delilah tells him over the radio that there are some things he can’t prevent and that he just needs to sit in his tower and watch the forest burn. Locked gates and hidden passages. It hinted at a video game about an everyday job that had all the secret spooky aspects of how weird it can be out in the very empty and isolating woods. A mystery at the center of the story implies a shadowy organizations observing us. The final trailer for the game reinforced this mindset. It really seemed to get people excited for what was in store, myself included. It was compelling. And then a lot of people on the internet threw a <strong>fit </strong>when it wasn’t about these things at all. They felt the rug had been pulled out from underneath them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*33dqi4WmTinsC21djwkeWA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Firewatch begins with an emotional text sequence, light piano plays as you read out the past several years Henry has spent married to Julia and their happy life together. But recently, Julia has developed dementia and after a bad incident and an extended amount of time trying to care for Julia alone, her family shows up and takes her to be with them in Australia. Henry has been doing his best but it was clear in the intro that he couldn’t do it alone anymore, Julia’s condition was worsening and this would eventually take her. But instead of following his wife to Australia, Henry went to the middle of no where in Wyoming and volunteered to be a fire watcher.</p><p>The shadowy mystery at the center of the game begins with Henry spotting someone watching him from afar the same night his tower is ransacked while he’s away. Weeks pass and two girls go missing. Two months pass and a fire in the forest has started and Henry discovers a log of all the things he and Delilah have been saying lately in conversation with each other. Henry digs into it and thinks a nearby government research zone in the park has been spying on them, maybe <em>it</em> knows about the missing girls. Meanwhile, Henry finds a bag belonging to a kid who left the park with his dad years back. The kid’s name is Brian Goodwin, and his dad was a survivalist named Ned who had trauma from Vietnam. Brian and Ned used to live in Henry’s tower before they up and left one day.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kaxA1ZpevlaWqRXOCtWz6g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Things amp up. Henry breaks into the government property area that’s fenced off, finds more documents suggesting a conspiracy and tracking equipment including typed reports on Henry and Delilah. Validation! Henry considers burning the camp down, doesn’t, but shortly after leaving finds it too has caught fire on its own. Now two fires threaten the forest in a horrible rage of smoke and ash. Henry is convinced the answers to this government spy case are tied to a locked cave and when he finally makes his way down there, he finds a body. Brian Goodwin’s. He died in a climbing accident.</p><p>There was no conspiracy.</p><p>Brian died carelessly in an accident and Ned ran into hiding out of shame of what happened to his own son. But when Henry arrived, Ned took to listening in to his and Delilah’s conversations as a means of human connection. Ned used deer tracking equipment from the government site to play on Henry’s paranoia about seeing someone in the woods months back all as an attempt to scare Henry away from finding Ned, or Brian. Delilah accepts some degree of culpability for Brian Goodwin’s death. The camp isn’t supposed to allow children to live there with the fire watchers but Delilah allowed it because she liked Brian. Now Brian was dead. Everyone in Firewatch is running from something. Delilah in her own ways was also running from a failed relationship in her own past. Ned instead retreats further from the world, leaving Henry an explanation on a tape and ventures further into the forest, asking Henry to not look for him. And Henry is left wondering what to do next with his life now that the fire has engulfed this part of the forest and forced him into leaving.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oisKixunQ3JNmvF-KksmOQ.png" /></figure><p>Firewatch’s game design and mechanics don’t hold a mirror up to human experiences as much as the <em>story </em>and the way people in real life reacted to it does. I loved the game when it came out but I wasn’t quite sure why I liked it so much. The world throwing a fit that Firewatch had no mystery and instead was a story about tragic errors in judgment and human beings running from reality was too fitting as angry people on the internet flaunted screenshots of the game rolling credits and refunded the game for being something they could speed through in less than two hours. People wanted a mystery, they didn’t get one, so they showed their disdain and buried their head in the sand with the belief that the game is bad because it wasn’t what they <strong>wanted </strong>and went right for the refund button after finishing it. <em>So close</em>.</p><p>It was so lost on those players that they were actually Henry: Looking for something that was ultimately never there, despite some marketing material that implied otherwise. An escape. Or maybe it was an escape, but the wrong kind. The funny part is that <em>all</em> video games can be an escape if you let them carry you there. Firewatch, mechanically, invites you into that escapism at times. It’s beautifully rendered and has a very large map to explore for the game’s average runtime. I played Firewatch three times. The first time I’ll admit, I was bolting for the answers but also exploring as much as I could, simply sprinting through it a lot as I made my way through the game’s many paths. On my second run I did the same, but used my knowledge of the map from my first run to explore things earlier here and there.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aooxc-ArGhQVkagBL75IWg.jpeg" /></figure><p>On my third run of the game, I escaped by simply being. I just took it all in. A lot. My need for escapism on the third run wasn’t there anymore and instead the game managed to be a different kind of escape. One of reflection. One that inspired these words you read now. Escape does not always need to mean fantasy after all. Today it’s an escape of calm. A decade ago it was an escape to briefly shut out what was happening in my life. Like Henry.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BQk5FgAwG0OjBdrUvcOMdA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Night in the Woods</h4><p>Night in the Woods is a 2017 platform narrative driven video game about Mae Borowski, a young 20-something that has dropped out of college and returned home. The game’s core mechanics involve exploring the town from a side view with platforming. You’re portrayed as a zoomorphic cat and are nimble enough to scale the rather hilly town of Possum Springs in your adventures. There’s a quickly established loop you get in with Mae. You wake up, explore the town, and often pick a friend to go hang out with that night on an activity. But I think many people don’t quite reach that loop because they bounce off of the early game. After your first full day home, you find yourself at a party, get drunk, vomit at the party, and make a fool of yourself in front of a childhood best friend (Bea) that you have forgotten that her mother passed. A drunken mess, you bawl your eyes out in embarrassment on the car ride home <strong>in front of Bea </strong>and Bea’s the one that ends up consoling you. The core game afterwards is the aforementioned daily loop with brief moments pondering a variety of themes: Dying nowhere-towns crumbling under old sources of wealth that are now irrelevant, failure to escape these towns with dead-end jobs that don’t pay anyone enough or provide health insurance, homelessness, life, death, faith, and Mae’s regular <em>problematic moments</em>.</p><p>I think most people don’t like Mae, at least not at first. Even at times in sections later in the game Mae will, every once in a while, mess up. She’ll say something stupid. Some people compared the game to a visual novel in the sense that you begin many conversations, engage in small mini games, and your conversations sometimes have branching options but it mostly plays out the same way. Sometimes the player can choose between two really stupid things to say to friends or family and you don’t have a way out of it. Mae is living with her parents again and they’re struggling to pay the bills and then suddenly their 20 year old daughter is home without an explanation as to why college wasn’t “working out” for her, but sending her there wasn’t cheap either. Meanwhile Mae doesn’t quite get why her friends have these difficulties in life being at work all the time and not having the energy to hang out or having to run the family business to keep your one remaining parent alive stopping you from going to college. The differences from what was at home two years ago when she left for college also seem to <em>disturb her. </em>Restaurants and stores that she grew up around have shut down and changed for bigger corporate-chain type places further away from home. This bothers her, greatly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*e1aLpgHv_lf3MWugkaVhfw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’ll give you an example: Mae is spending some time with Bea at her family’s house. Her dad is clearly a depressed drunk who hasn’t gotten past the loss of his wife yet, and Bea’s keeping the family business afloat and taking care of him while he doesn’t do as much work as he used to. Mae sees all this and, without player choice, just tells Bea that she just<em> shouldn’t do all that.</em> There’s variations inside that dialog, like telling Bea she’s stronger than this and should stand up to her non-abusive dad, or that it’s wrong to just take this treatment. But Mae’s <strong>so </strong>disconnected from all this that she thinks its about some worker-respect managerial issue or a “dad is taking all the credit for his family business”-issue instead of a reality where a tragedy happened, lives are now changed and people are trying to survive it. Bea doesn’t really have a way out of this horrible mess but as a much more mature adult, she’s not abandoning the dad she loves to this fate either.</p><p>Mae struggles to grasp how the social ties of love, friends, and family mean we care for these people and sometimes even limit our options in life to work through these situations. So yeah, people don’t <strong>love</strong> Mae. Anyone who’s matured enough to understand how life works sometimes is going to see her as jerk, or naive. And then when things feel at their worse, when you have this big blowout with Mae’s mom about potentially losing the house in this dying town while you’re wasting all that college money and are back home just hanging with friends every day, <strong><em>jobless</em></strong>, that’s exactly when you go to a town festival, see a teen get knocked out, taken hostage, and carried beyond the city limits by a shadowy figure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7StN9k_czZxxXgu31G3nzQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The horror waiting in the game’s back 30% is a spiral of awful stomach-churning discoveries. Mae is deeply shaken by what she saw and has been having strange dreams even before all this started. With her friends Mae is able to piece together some town folklore about an old “ghost” but really doesn’t find any answers. What she does find is that the figure that took someone before has been stalking them as they searched old places to learn town history. Eventually the group go investigate the woods and find the entrance to the old mines and a cult. Discovered by the cult, a chase gives way across fields, Mae is shot at, falls a great distance, nearly dies, and she and her friends are confronted with the realization that the little town they live in is not safe. It’s hunting them. They’re being targeted but they don’t know by whom.</p><p>Mae grows sickly, headaches and pain wrack her body as she yearns for answers. After some recovery Mae stays up late with a friend and tells the story about a town rumor: Mae once bludgeoned another kid at a baseball match. Mae explains how once she had a traumatic dissociative episode where all joy and all sense of seeing other living things as these important personal connections dissolved in front of her. They became <em>shapes </em>in her mind. Utterly wracked by this sensation all at once during the game, she took the baseball bat to another kid in pure terror. <em>“They weren’t people anymore. They were just shapes”. </em>Mae experienced this horrific episode at a younger age and spent her teenhood marked by the town because of it. There was no possible future for Mae in Possum Springs, she’d always be “the girl that nearly killed a kid”. Sending Mae to college out of town was the best shot at a normal life she had, but her dissociative disorder only <strong>worsened </strong>in the isolation of a new environment and new faces. With only poor therapy exercises provided by her home doctor as a means of help, Mae didn’t grow, she <em>spiraled </em>out further and shut down. So she came home hoping “shapes” that she recognized better than new ones would help her feel better only to realize home has changed considerably in the last two years and her episodes are getting worse again.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TEeOMi4lruNrZsN7r2-Byg.jpeg" /></figure><p>After unburdening this story to a friend, Mae leaves in the middle of the night and heads for the woods to confront her town cult and learn the devastating truth. The cult secretly operates within the whole town and sets up operation out of the old town mine. The legend has it that about 20 years ago someone fell into a deep chasm in the abandoned town mine and some sort of a cthulhu-esque god was found deeper inside. It speaks, it sings. Some people <strong>hear</strong> it. <strong>Mae </strong>hears it. The ones that can hear it are told to find people and feed them to the mine god. The stomach-churning realization leads to an even greater pit in your stomach as you understand that for decades people of your home have occasionally disappeared Possum Springs’s “unfavorables” to feed it into the pit; including a runaway friend of yours. They tell you that doing this has bounced the town back from prior poor times and they want to recruit <strong><em>you</em></strong> to do the same now for the town. A new generation, a new cycle. I can’t really do the entire climax sequence of this game justice in terms of its writing. The cult leader goes on this big rant about the town returning to its glory and what has befallen it. “We lost what our world was built around. Used to be you provided for a family, bought a house. Now you’re stocking shelves at the grocery store. Kids leavin’ more than they’re stayin’…No opportunity here. Old people dyin’, house left empty. You ever seen that? A *home* become a tumbled-in pile of wood and plaster? A *job* become a burned out brick box or a hole in the ground? But we can change that. We can put this place back together, where it won’t be just…”</p><p>And Mae finishes their sentence: “Shapes”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1WhUDjZ_ahNLAv4ccSr6jQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>The story entertains the possibility that Mae’s dissociative disorder may not be unlike the sensation the cult leader describes in watching your home, your world, your town, crumble away. Whether it be under the gravity of capitalism sucking money from everywhere or it be the generations of people deciding to leave and things just changing and growing into something else, it feels unreal to watch everything around you change. To age. To see the map of your known world alter in front of you, revealing something that was always there and you never knew, or something new growing in its place, it can be uncanny.</p><p>Through a series of events the cultists are “defeated” and Mae briefly blacks out afterwards when she and her friends are leaving the mine. She confronts “the hole at the center of everything” in a speech I’m going to save for later but seems to come to terms with her disorder much better than before. The deepest secret behind Mae and why she is the way she is is hard to find, hard to piece together. But it <strong>is </strong>revealed in her journal book. Across the game, you put new scribble memories in this journal. The origins of this journal are that she was given it as a means of therapy exercise after she had her dissociative episodes. This journal, and a bit of poetry that starts the game, reveal the truth of Mae’s problems. When the credits on the game finish you can flip through the pages of the book from back to front one more time and find on the very first page:<br> “RIP Grandad ❤”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hbX-_EvUNlDgcpkDWv6iyA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Mae’s troubles began when she lost the person she speaks fondly of more than anyone in the game, the one who read her ghost stories as a child, the one who she watched die.</p><p>Night in the Woods is about <em>a lot of things</em>. But I think deep down, it’s a video game about ghosts, it’s about confronting the thing that haunts you, whether it be a dying town or grief that changes how you see life and death, or the linking of the two things. After all, what makes you feel like home is gone more than losing those who make it home for you?</p><p>For me, Night in the Woods was about realizing I wasn’t okay after my dad died.</p><p>This is what I’ve been working up towards the whole article. Trigger warnings: Sad cancer stuff, the tragedy of life taken from us before we feel they’ve lived the full life, all that jazz.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8AwdhBBeuTAkor3VPLrchA.png" /></figure><h4>The Twist</h4><p>Life is Strange, Firewatch, and Night in the Woods were games that, through their designs and through their narratives, mirrored some of the harshest times and moments in my life. They are dots in a timeline of the reveal of cancer, the caretaking, loss, and mental recovery of losing my dad and step-mother, all in the span of just a couple years.</p><p>In 2015 as I played through Life is Strange my internet friends coaxed me out of my shell and insecurities. I traveled by plane to meet up with all of them for my first convention experience. Also that summer my friend, my now-wife, my mom and I drove down to Nashville for a sort of weekend celebration event to visit a new shop that doesn’t exist anymore; we experienced live music and comedy and watched The Princess Bride in the park at a live showing. My mom had unexpected surgery later that summer but she was okay and I regaled her in the hospital about my trip to Austin, the hilarious times I had, and I told her about the two hour wait for the best pizza I ever ate. It was, at the time, the best summer of my life. I was frustrated that progress on my degree was taking forever but in 2016 I would finally transfer credits and start a strong push to finishing my Bachelor’s, graduate hopefully by 2018 or earlier and move forward with my life (marriage, kids, etc.) And then my step-mom, who I had spent the last five years getting to know by living with, was diagnosed with cancer. <em>Again</em>.</p><p>By October when Life is Strange was ending, things around me looked grim. Sandra went through a 10 hour surgery where surgeons opened her up, removed over twenty tumors from her body of various sizes, put hot bags of chemo in her body for a time, and then stitched her back together afterwards. I don’t think she came home for over a month. Recovery. Unavoidable infection for a surgery of that size and length. The sign that this one long shot wasn’t working. I was 23. My dad ran a one-man IT business support company out of our basement and I helped him when he needed me to. His business wasn’t very lucrative so there was also the very real possibility that if Sandra didn’t make it (and odds were slim), we would also lose the home my dad and I had moved into. I was taking on extra work for him that fall. He wasn’t home much and most of his clients understood what he was dealing with but he took calls late at night or worked from the hospital as much as he could. I watched the dogs at home. Christmas came. And not long after, bad news. My dad noticed a discomfort at night while wearing his CPAP mask. It was pressing up against something on his head. A tumor. Skin cancer. My dad developed cancer while taking care of his wife who was dying of cancer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sUbzkyLBXz6bfStLHVy22A.png" /></figure><p>The designs of Life is Strange are tinkering with indecision and time travel to one’s benefit and while I know I wouldn’t alter my past, the version of me that walked through hell across 2016 and 2017 would probably exit into 2018 and ask for a do-over. It’s so easy, maybe too easy in this world, to second guess yourself.</p><p>The ending of Life is Strange, the one I chose, was one of an unavoidable horror that forever scarred Max. When I first experienced it, heard Spanish Sahara play, it felt so parallel to my <strong>dad</strong>’<strong>s</strong> life and experiences in those times. A storm just showing up and ripping his life apart and the alternative timelines where this never happened could be even worse, not better. The game was, for sure, a favorite of mine that year. A fresh approach to the genre and something that reflected the dark times of my father’s life while tapping into the years where I felt choices weren’t really available to me to forge a future I wanted. I had no idea I’d feel the same by the end of 2016. And yet I didn’t feel that way at first. After all, wasn’t Max’s time travel wish fulfillment that she then took back when she realized how dangerous it was? I spent the 2010’s coasting through college, taking my time of it instead of putting my social life aside and just grinding for money and speeding through college. I had no idea that Life is Strange would live on in my memories to serve as an omen of what was to come and a design lesson that reflects the importance of critical choices being ones that define a story moreso than those choices <em>changing</em> things. The storm comes for Chloe and Max no matter what. It’s what the player chooses to do when it’s there that feels important. In late 2015, I had no idea yet what 2016 would entail for me but I already wanted to forget it all, wipe it clean off the map the way Chloe and Max wanted to either erase the town, and by extension the world, or the the memories of what Max had to decide. Forget the horror.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CXFUzqMs_Vn3n2D9L6cgzw.png" /></figure><p>Later in February of 2016, the challenges of taking care of my dad were setting in. Restless nights, my dad shedding pounds, vomiting, hearing Sandra vomit from the living room where she and her mother were laid up regularly. Later in that year my dad would knock on the wall of his bedroom to wake me up just down the hall in the middle of the night when he needed more painkillers and didn’t have the energy to get them. I lived in fear of not waking to those knocks. Firewatch was an escape I couldn’t help but run towards, much like Henry and all the other characters in the game. I remember having a class that involved a rather large group project across an entire semester. We had to design a business idea that aligns with a career path and “sell it” with supported research, websites, etc. I couldn’t touch it. I had no focus. I was 24 now. There was only taking care of Dad, work, one day a week with my girlfriend (often at home while caring for Dad), and unravelling the mystery at the center of Firewatch. The promise of a mystery I could escape into turned into a fire that consumed my initiative to focus on the very classes that I paid money for. I dropped the class before February was over. I stopped going to college, putting in for a need to delay things to take care of family. The “crowd” reaction to Firewatch was so transparent to me. I could tell they hated it for being what they didn’t expect, didn’t want, running from its very themes and demanding the story be something that it isn’t. And yet I was too numb to everything going on to really process how I felt about the game and about my life in 2016 until years later. I had already finished the game before Sandra died in March of ’16 but it wasn’t until maybe 2017 that I understood Firewatch’s harder drama: Running away from our difficulties is <strong>wrong</strong>. They put people in <strong>danger</strong>. And if we’re not careful, we’ll concoct narratives in our heads that hurt us instead of confront the truth of adversity or failure. And while I didn’t run away from my difficulties, I sure felt like it at times.</p><p>There was a night. Not long before my dad passed away. He fell. I had helped him reach the bathroom and was attempting to help him over a lip at the doorway but it went wrong, he fell back and bumped his shoulder. He was okay, but it was terrifying to me. I was ready to dial the in-home nurse despite there being no blood and no bruises. He insisted I don’t. He was already on hospice care. I helped him back into his bed and that was the end of it. Nothing bad came of it. I could barely sleep out of fear of what might happen though. That night lives on in my memories. For a time, a long time, taking care of my dad lived on as something that haunted me; I would regularly weigh how well I took care of my dad against that night. If I could’ve done more, if I could’ve quit work earlier, asked for help from family sooner. I was 24 when all this happened. Six months earlier in March I had watched my dad say goodbye to his wife of five years, someone I could just <em>tell </em>he was in love with so much. I carried and touched her casket before it went in for cremation. In June, three or four months before he died, after chemo and radiation treatments, it became clear my dad’s cancer had returned. I remember getting the news over the phone from his friend who was free to take him to the doctor that day, and I sat in my room on my bed, crying. I told myself I couldn’t keep doing this. I got in my car and drove. I drove as far east as I could to a coastline, banked south and made my way back to my girlfriend’s work and waited for her to get out. I think I wasted a full hour just driving in a rough circle away from home and then back to my side of town. I was trying to get away, to go somewhere, <em>anywhere</em>, even when I knew I wasn’t going to abandon what was happening. My dad would die on his birthday in September of 2016.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*y5-ktImg77Yyf3WDbcDZHg.png" /></figure><p>Despite all my feelings in the time after, I <em>didn’t</em> fail that night, or in general. I was an adult still trying to get his life together watching the supporting structures of it burn away as the wider world around me found a new way to be on fire compared to ever before in the 2016 US presidential election. Two fires. I wanted to disappear, to not be needed, to escape like Henry. Henry is on the verge of abandoning everything he is but is confronted with people who he could turn into if he doesn’t change his course. It’s so very critical to Firewatch’s storytelling that there isn’t some magical happy ending or deep twist because it’s a story about escaping from something everyone is afraid of confronting: Losing someone you love. It’s an experience that can burn away the very life inside you; quench your heart with smoke. Not seeing what Henry does after leaving Shoshone allows for the idea that returning to your loved one’s side as they’re dying isn’t<em> </em>something <em>triumphant</em>. It’s not a climax of great mysteries come to a revelation. It’s not some beautiful painterly sunset of a story about two people loving each other. It <strong>is</strong> sad<em>. </em>And that’s okay. Life is full of sad moments. The revelation of Firewatch is that the drama of human life is more important than a grand story concocted in the woods. Escapism can morph into the isolation and abandonment of whatever future you may have left on this earth.</p><p>Another reason I think Firewatch’s ending is so fitting is that it just ends. Henry takes a rescue worker’s hand, he gets on the helicopter, and he leaves. The journey you and Henry go through is the important experience the game is exploring; what one summer in the woods can do for a man running away from something that shapes who we are as humans. That’s what Henry takes with him.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FmN2EpKUvtyOqh9mStWhmg.png" /></figure><p>In the year after my dad died, I did not grasp what I was taking with me out of the forest. Grief, pain, self-resentment. Across 2017 I experienced bouts of insomnia, chilling moments of emptiness or frustration, a general tiredness of a retail job I had worked for probably too long at that point (six years in ’17). I still hadn’t returned to college. And what’s worse is that I couldn’t understand it. Sure, my dad was dead, but I had made peace with it and generally speaking I wasn’t dwelling on it all the time. I didn’t grasp that what I had been through at 23 and 24 could leave a mark on me the way it did. It took me time to even piece together that deep down, I wasn’t happy with how my whole life had been derailed for a year by those events (and then it took me a year to figure <em>that out </em>before I got back on track in college and made a plan for getting my life sorted). But once again life handed me a precursor, a video game with a story and experience that, upon multiple runs of it, I began to feel the shape of my grief, of how I had been changed and set back. No doubt anyone who’s experienced the quarter-life crisis of college/career struggles, dead end home towns, and dissociative episodes can relate to Mae Borowski in Night in the Woods. I was 25.</p><p>For me, I’m not <em>really </em>Mae. At most in 2017 I was struggling with some temporary depression and self-imposed blame for how things went the year prior. I don’t have and never have experienced a dissociative disorder or moments of self harm. But when I first played and beat the game, I was sick. It was also about six months after my dad had died and a month after I had moved out of my step-mother’s house and into my brother’s house. I think my body caught up with me. I spent a week beating the game while fighting a cold, laid up in bed any time I wasn’t working, I could <em>feel</em> the burnout all over Mae. My bouts of sleeplessness that year were no doubt brought on by a general discomfort with the mundane life I found myself returning to after a year of what one might call “heightened purpose”. I’ll be clear: Caretaking for sick family is not heightened purpose, but if you’ve ever been in that position before you know what I’m talking about. It’s something you just <em>do</em> and people admire you for it, they recognize the struggle you’re going through and you grasp that it <strong>is</strong> more important than a lot of things. But we don’t want a pedestal. We want this to not have happened while accepting what’s happening.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XPakVt459HWT7xz789pPVg.jpeg" /></figure><p>There’s a disconnect between what Mae wants to do and what she actually says or does, the path she takes. I would go on to slowly unravel the disconnect between what I wanted my life to be and what it became the year after Dad died. Mae’s a mess. Her college plans that her family made for her didn’t pan out, her childhood best friend Bea resents her for squandering that opportunity when she would’ve had that chance if Bea’s mom didn’t die. Mae can’t hang out with her friends the way she used to because they’re grown ups now with responsibilities. She’s coasting on her parents’ income that is barely holding it all together as it is because she doesn’t know what to do with her life, and deep down: She’s depressed. She suffers a dissociative disorder that surfaced sometime after she watched her grandfather die. And leaving for college only isolated her more and made her start regressing with these dissociative episodes. What can you do?</p><p>Well, in reality, maybe get some help if you think you need it. In Night in the Woods, Mae confronts a cult treating the world the way Mae’s disorder made her treat a very unlucky kid one baseball afternoon. And then she has a heart to heart with the embodiment of her disorder, which might be the depression, an outer god, death itself, or her grief, it’s not explicitly said, you just <strong>feel it all</strong>. But the speech brings me to tears just thinking about it so I saved it for now after explaining the significance of these games to me. I don’t think anything I can say about my realizations from Nights in the Woods can do better than this quote.</p><blockquote>“I know what you are now. I think I knew before. But, you know, after I sent that kid to the hospital, years ago, they said I had an anger problem. But that’s not true. I was angry because of something else. Something I’d lost. Trying so hard since not to be angry got me all defenseless and I lost more, and more, and more…That’s not getting better. I want to be angry. When I ran home from college on the bus I had this dream, or maybe I saw it out the window. Last leaf on the tree finally blowin’ off. I’m so scared. All the time. And the fear *hurts*. Feeling like everything is over, was over long before I got here, so long, hiding or trying to outrun this. I get it. This won’t stop until I die. But when I die, I want it to hurt, when my friends leave, when I have to let go, when this entire town is wiped off the map, I want it to hurt. Bad. I want to lose. I want to get beaten up. I want to hold on until I’m thrown off and everything ends. And you know what? Until that happens, I want to hope again. And I want it to hurt. Because that means it meant something. It means I am…something, at least…Pretty amazing to be something at least.”</blockquote><p>Night in the Woods helped me realize that I had spent a year of my life putting “me” aside to care for someone who still died and helped me come to terms with that before agreeing that I didn’t want to keep waiting for the rest of my life to happen. After 2017 I figured things out, for real. I made a plan to save up money in 2018 so I could quit my retail job, accelerate my college plans, and finish in just two more semesters and have a degree by Spring 2019. I nearly went broke in the process, living a little foolishly at first, but it would’ve taken me even longer to do the same while keeping the job, one class a time. I got a full time job after graduation and while I didn’t get to move out of my brother’s house right away, a pandemic happened, I did get married, we have a dog, and I got to chase the life I set aside.</p><h4>What You Don’t Notice</h4><p>I replayed Life is Strange, Firewatch, and Night in the Woods again this year. I wanted to revisit these games that really defined so much of my mid 20s for me. It’s rare we replay video games because they just take a lot more time to experience, but I can’t recommend it enough for story-based games. Like a painting you’ve only observed once, you can’t remember all those finer details. And to wrap up this essay, I’d like to give you three little details that stuck with me and what I took from them. This time, in reverse order from Night in the Woods back to Life is Strange.</p><p><em>Night in the Woods — The Janitor</em><br>The morning after Mae’s journey into the old mine she has a brief run in with the local “janitor” (a potential god figure of his own who seems to be omnipotent about Mae’s struggles despite them never formally meeting). When he asks her if her home is how she remembers it (two weeks after she’s back), she remarks that something big did happen and she’s not sure she learned anything from it. The janitor remarks, “Well, in my experience the big things don’t teach you anything, but they make you something. And sometimes you gotta wait a while and see what come of it.” It struck me so well, the truth of it. The person I’ve become due to the things that happened, where I’ve gone with that. These experiences in life mold us so much and sometimes, oftentimes, we don’t choose it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ls-_ecmlCT3TurrP8epD1w.png" /><figcaption>Credit for the screenshot: <a href="https://youtu.be/GuITG8pJCs4?list=PLhuTNAac8NW5GANo2aIcP3OqK7nmlrPDd">https://youtu.be/GuITG8pJCs4?list=PLhuTNAac8NW5GANo2aIcP3OqK7nmlrPDd</a></figcaption></figure><p><em>Firewatch — A Pause in the Hallway of Time<br></em>At the end of Firewatch, Henry goes to Delilah’s watchtower. For most of the game, her tower is not available to you due to the great distance between the two of you and your job requiring you to generally stay in your tower’s area. The evacuation from the two fires means leaving from a helicopter pad at Delilah’s tower, but first you get the chance to sit down and put on a headset and talk to Delilah one last time. You won’t hear from each other again after this, it’s the end of your time doing this job and even if you ask Delilah to stick around, she won’t. She’s ultimately not comfortable with Henry throwing away whatever time he might have left with Julia now that the summer job is over. Delilah suggests Henry not think about coming back next summer just yet or planning to meet up right away. While in Firewatch there’s some opportunities for Henry to pursue a romantic spark with Delilah, no matter what Delilah at the <em>end</em> of the game seems to think it’s not worth pursuing further. She tells Henry, “We shouldn’t focus on this summer. Next year will roll around, and then the year after that, and then it’s just a…I don’t know. My Aunt Judy called it a pause in the hallway of time.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RIWGupDqAhxk2E9qJbA99Q.png" /></figure><p>In times past, I often saw Firewatch to me as the way I described it earlier: An escape, a story about the desire to escape our responsibilities in the midst of great big fires. What I never considered is the fact that time spent being a caregiver isn’t too different from that pause in the hallway of time either. As demands increase you put more and more on the back burner to ensure the well being of someone else, sometimes someone who won’t survive the ordeal. You don’t stop aging in the hallway, but a lot of whatever life you were working on during those days pauses and when you leave that hallway you’re somehow hoping to go back to normal no matter what the outcome and no matter what happened inside the hallway. My dad hit a critical state where he was barely clinging to life, the “death rattles” is what it’s called. It sadly went on for a few days before he passed. I took my leave of absence from work when this last phase started. That friend from earlier was regularly stopping by, and she and I made sure he was getting morphine droplets every so many hours, kept him company, kept him as comfortable as we could, made sure friends or family could visit if they wanted to. It was a blur of days after the first one. When he passed four days into all this, I then had an additional week and change off for the funeral as well to grieve and get things in order. Returning to work was strange and in the year after there was so much reflection of how so little of my life had moved while everything had changed in the span of a little less than a year. That nine month hallway had the most unexpected impact on my life and yet I did so little to change my life during that time and even after for a while. <strong>I</strong> could only really do anything <em>after</em> I had exited it.</p><p><em>Life is Strange — Wish Granter<br></em>I said earlier that Max’s time travel is a form of wish fulfillment. She saw a girl get shot, instinctively reached out to “stop” it despite it already having happened, and found that she could stop this awful thing from happening. It’s fairly easy to say that by the last episode of the game Max wishes none of these things would’ve ever happened to her. The burden of having to choose between saving an entire town of people or saving your best friend means <strong>condemning </strong>the other. Time travel isn’t a wish granter, it’s a curse.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/525/1*BZ6quSvq_ttMoFLamFkekg.png" /></figure><p>In the first episode of Life is Strange, you explore the Blackwell High School’s front lawn and interact with students and teachers and take in the beautiful scenery. There’s a fountain in the center of the field with cement pathways dividing chunks of green grass leading towards and away from the fountain. The fountain has coins in it and small sharpie graffiti marks written around the rim of the fountain as wishes to some magic fountain god. One of the pieces of graffiti reads a simple plea: “Can my dad be okay?”</p><p>One can imagine this being written by Chloe if her dad didn’t die instantly in a car crash.</p><p>I can also imagine myself having written it, or having read it back in 2015. I didn’t though. I only saw it now in 2026, ten years after my dad passed. I dare not make some wishes for a different today lest it sacrifice so many others. All I can do, all I could do, is accept the horror, leave the hallway, and find out what I’ve become. The person he raised me to be.</p><p>Rest in peace Dad. ❤</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9rO1CHhKzeI1QYQVTJgJfg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Additional images gathered from DeadEndThrills on the <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20181201152851/http://deadendthrills.com/gallery/?gid=130">Internet Archive</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=342c6b248c1e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My Many Harrys of Disco Elysium]]></title>
            <link>https://the-typer.medium.com/my-many-harrys-of-disco-elysium-387ad13e247?source=rss-4c5509ad50b6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/387ad13e247</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rpg]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disco-elysium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Fleming]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 May 2026 02:53:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-18T03:40:53.009Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Two hundred and seventy four hours. That’s how much time I’ve spent playing Disco Elysium. It is the most-played RPG of my life now. I had more time for video games when I was a kid so I recall playing through Knights of the Old Republic 2 at least three times before I turned 18. I know I played it two more times since then with the Restored Content Mod. I spent so many of my days in the 2010’s socializing with friends while playing Team Fortress 2, accruing nearly 500 hours of playtime there. I’ve spent half that time over the past twenty years playing Audiosurf for 250 hours. And in playing almost every Soulsborne game to completion twice I think I’ve spent over 1000 hours playing those games combined (700 if we toss out Elden Ring and its DLC). But Disco Elysium is a game you’ll complete, similarly to Knights of the Old Republic, at around the 30 to 40 hour mark. And yet somehow I have played this game for almost 300 hours now. For a singular one-player RPG in the 2020s while I’m in my 30s, that feels <em>significant.</em></p><p>It’s a game I hope developers are going to be studying for years to come. It’s a small(ish) game with big ideas to talk about. And it’s a game you can spend <a href="https://youtu.be/n_7ngJDbUQE?list=PLmHtnz9uuqfaCLZBtcscFyAvyqOAs5FaM">hour</a> <a href="https://youtu.be/Md5PTWBuGpg?list=PLmHtnz9uuqfaCLZBtcscFyAvyqOAs5FaM">after</a> <a href="https://youtu.be/cSmZcN7AgHQ?list=PLmHtnz9uuqfaCLZBtcscFyAvyqOAs5FaM">hour</a> <a href="https://youtu.be/lkNrfTUO1NM?list=PLmHtnz9uuqfaCLZBtcscFyAvyqOAs5FaM">after</a> <a href="https://youtu.be/cdW7Cp0iV0A?list=PLmHtnz9uuqfaCLZBtcscFyAvyqOAs5FaM">hour</a> discussing. And I have. And I’ve spent at least three years occasionally coming back to this piece to keep updating it and writing it until I think I’ve found an end point.</p><p>I <strong><em>love </em></strong>this game.</p><p>I’ve played through it five times, I’ve spent almost twelve days exploring Martinnaise, I’ve watched others do it, I’ve reveled in its meme-ification and the art that it has inspired. But in the almost 300 hours I’ve spent playing this game and talking to others about it, I haven’t figured out what I’d want to distinctly say about it that hasn’t already been said that I’ve read or listened to.</p><p>Until I got near the end of my fourth run of the game.</p><p>I want to talk about Harry.</p><p>Or more specifically: I want to talk about the versions of Harry I experienced in this game and walk through those experiences of how this game opened itself to me. How, like the best art, Disco Elysium served as a mirror to look inwards and find something about myself in it. So let’s do it.</p><p>So so many spoilers ahead. Leave now if you’re not ready.</p><figure><img alt="A blue and white artistic rendering of Harry and Kim sitting on the swing set by the water, a car half submerged into the ice, the pale and the Revachol off in the distance" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1X7l2QaFlo4Q28SEQ2GZNQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.tumbex.com/tumblinggnome.tumblr/post/696538031303294976/snippit-crickit-guess-who-played-disco-elysium-a">https://www.tumbex.com/tumblinggnome.tumblr/post/696538031303294976/snippit-crickit-guess-who-played-disco-elysium-a</a></figcaption></figure><h4>Harry #1 — The Sorry Cop (2020)</h4><p>I originally played Disco Elysium in the middle of 2020. Take note that this was before The Final Cut released, so the game was lacking the political vision quests and the later released Jamais Vu update. For anyone’s first time through Disco Elysium, it may be particularly challenging to get your bearings. I went into this game fairly blind so there was a lot of confusion about why my skills had lines but weren’t really doing much talking, why there were skill checks I wasn’t even activating, how the thought cabinet worked, how and when you should spend your skill points, etc. And to make matters more challenging, I wasn’t taking advantage of any drugs or alcohol in the game. And I was the Sorry Cop. The picture this game painted of Harry’s antics before losing his memory was one that I felt rapidly more apologetic of. I never judged Harry. After all, I was playing this character and also had no real memory of what happened because I, as the player, was experiencing this all for the first time. All I could do in the face of all the things Harry had done over the course of days, weeks, and months to the people around him was say “I’m sorry”. The particular standout for me was when Sylvie, the bartender of the Whirling-In-Rags, clearly so upset and uncomfortable with me on the phone, expressed just how awful of a customer I was to her. There may have been five choices, but my heart could only pick “I am truly sorry for everything, Sylvie.” The Sorry Cop I played at the start of the game was getting his bearings on <strong>so </strong>many things because I as the player was also getting familiar with this world in this game. The history of it was such a puzzle that I couldn’t internalize on my first run because I was too busy internalizing the murder to solve and how to best walk in the game’s mechanics. I didn’t even have the dream where you talk to your ex or understand the pale and the 2 mm hole in the universe that had started sprouting.</p><p>Sorry Cop was too busy apologizing for everything he had done wrong to remotely comprehend the picture beyond the strike, the murder, the hanging treatment, and how the vying power players were truly involved in <strong>everything </strong>I was encountering. The only thing I knew was that I was sorry, and that I was struggling. I didn’t have my dance in the church, though I moved the hooligans into it. I didn’t tap into the sound of the swallow, though I was aware of it. I didn’t uncover the drug trade that Ruby was involved in at all. Klaasje was maybe the rare enigma that I mostly made sense of. But I still barely had any money to afford rent. I couldn’t muster enough skill points in physical instrument to get the ice cream freezer open with Soona’s wrench and retrieve the off site backup. I couldn’t get the body out of the tree without help from the harbor. I didn’t even manage to take a picture of the Phasmid because I legit thought the flash would scare it off! Most of these failures aren’t even interesting ones. They’re boring ones that lock you out of experiences. Much like the amnesiac, I didn’t know why I was so awful in my past. I could tell that I <em>was </em>awful in my past though. I could also tell Harry was hurt, badly. And I could tell this game was reading me. This lack of context and searching for an understanding of just the surface level answers to who you are and what happened here in Martinnaise in the ten days before the game starts was the first highlight for me in playing Disco Elsyium. It was this strange and difficult synchronicity between myself and Harry that kept me on my toes. It also meant I decided to inhabit Harry.</p><p>My first run of this game is <strong>also </strong>marked by a strange “true to self” approach to the game. I don’t drink or do drugs, so my Harry didn’t. I also try to be an honest person in life, Harry did. I felt like Harry got himself into his mess, so I didn’t ask for others to fix my mess for me. I’ve always tried to be a patient, understanding person, so Harry tried.</p><p>And then the game proceeded to call me out on <strong>all of it.</strong></p><p>First, Electrochemistry kept trying to persuade me, for two days straight, to get my drink on, smoke, or get my speed on. It called me lame for not doing it. I kept apologizing to everyone, and so the game called me a “Sorry cop”. Suddenly I began wondering to myself just why I’m so apologetic all the time in reality. I don’t really think I’m sorry for things, but I try to always be considerate of how others perceive or experience my own words and actions. I’m practically sorry before I do anything, thinking I’m just going to offend everyone.</p><p>Suddenly, I felt <strong>read.</strong> It was around this point that I started to understand what Disco Elysium was doing, how it functioned, what made it unique. The game was not <em>just </em>reacting to what I did, but <em>commenting </em>on it. This alone was rather impressive for an RPG. So often the nature of choice in video games is about externalizing the results of our actions to another part of the game. This has gotten stale and even disappeared in recent years (at least in 2022 when I wrote that) simply because the mechanisms of this design are now all too transparent in an overly connected world, we can see the choice trees in our mind and how it all connects. The design’s boundaries are also visible to those who have repeatedly exposed themselves to it because we already know what’s on the other branches. Meanwhile, Disco Elysium is an RPG about internalizing our actions, molding over them, asking what it meant to our character when we did something. For anyone’s first run of the game you’re going to start feeling the possibility space <strong>increase</strong> instead of decrease. I think video games generally don’t manage to do this very well. The more games you experience, the more you understand what games can do and how far variety can go. So as you play <em>most </em>games and unlock abilities or see how big the world is, the possibilities in your head mostly decrease as you start to find your own way to navigate the game and get a better feeling for the scope of it. Sure, there’s a time where the game’s mechanics and abilities slowly expand. But eventually it shows you all there is and you get the gist that there won’t be more to show in terms of the game’s toolset. Then you play your big open world game for another 40+ hours with those tools. The variety of how you can do things in other games feels more like a “preference of approach” instead of an entirely different way to play the game. It makes an entire genre stale on top of the game itself.</p><p>My first run of Disco Elysium was the opposite. I was unlocking thoughts like Rigorous Self Critique while the game was telling me there are <strong>other</strong> cop-o-types and the game hadn’t revealed those to me yet. Because that’s not who I was playing as. This realization is the <strong>first </strong>reason I wanted to start the game over so quickly after finishing it, it’s designed for you to go “wait, what would’ve happened if I chose this instead of that” or “what passive rolls are happening that I don’t get to read at all because they missed?” for at least your first two runs. “Oh there are entire lines of thought and experience I haven’t seen yet. And I missed<em> so much</em>”. Unlike having some abilities that just impact gameplay in different ways, being a different-to-the-core person in Disco Elysium felt like it would be a vastly different experience with unique dialog options and different motivators. This mental image of how different your game could be only got stronger when I heard you could lose Kim after the shootout or that he could leave earlier in the investigation. I think that last bit turned out to be false, but still! This was an incredibly refreshing change of pace akin to the starkly different experiences you get with a light or dark alignment in Knights of the Old Republic and the various gameplay types based on what type of character class you are. Sure choosing the dark side and having easier access to Dark Force powers in KotOR 2 is <em>fun, </em>but what’s more interesting was the conversation you’d have with Kreia if you choose to be a senseless brute exerting power over the weak, or just how bonkers the character dynamics change if you choose to be a Sith in KotOR 1. With Disco Elysium this is all about <em>unlocking</em> a <strong>personality type</strong>. And it’s not just a binary or three-tiered system. That’s…kinda crazy. It’s akin to the immersive sim game but for a character sheet. I loved seeing that. And in 2020, before the world experienced Baldur’s Gate 3, that felt <em>revolutionary</em>.</p><p>So the game was reading how I played (as honestly as I could) and giving me a definition of that play, which felt opposite to trying to find an ability tree and sticking to it but instead feeling like the game had a method of play and approach that <strong>adopted </strong>my preferences. That came off as really cool! And then the game started to not just provide commentary on the decisions I was making, but <strong>challenging me.</strong></p><figure><img alt="You: But what about all the things that are wrong *now*? Empathy: *Tsk, tsk*. Just because you live in the *present* doesn’t mean you have the right to place your needs above the needs of the *future*.. You may never live to see the Kingdom of Conscience. Your children may not. Even your *grandchildren* might not. But that’s no excuse not to keep working…" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/369/1*Dqdvgi68vm4DlUwgw5qQpg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="You: Wait, is the Kingdom of Conscience really about doing things, or just preserving the status quo? Empathy: Do you believe the status quo is preferable to chaos and bloodshed? You: No. Empathy: Then you’ve never lived through *real* chaos…Sometimes, in the face of great disaster, defending the status quo *is* progress." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/365/1*qibwd77G_YVYdoR0TwAUFA.png" /></figure><p>We’re going to discuss more of this very subject matter with Harry #4. But this little conversational piece up above was one of the first “the game just literally slapped me into sitting back in my chair and thinking” moments. I was playing Disco Elysium for the first time ever in the <em>summer of 2020</em>, in the midst of the largest mass protest I’ve seen in my entire life (the largest we may see for generations). For greater context, I grew up among conservative religious people and (in 2020) had spent the better part of a decade analyzing my faith and this background and getting angrier and angrier about the treatment of black lives in America. And while there’s another tangent you could put in this same paragraph for Harry #2, I think it’s worth just pointing out that even before The Final Cut came out, Disco Elysium was still provoking thoughts here in my first run. I, a straight white guy who desired to be an ally before and during 2020 and still today, still sat by and mostly tried to reason with family in those tough times in the pandemic. I donated money to some causes, like so many other people who felt motivated, I bought some books and started truly educating myself. I still am. We always are. But I never actually went out to my local groups and tried to make a difference with my hands and feet. I could try to say I didn’t know where to start, but that’s not always an excuse. It certainly wasn’t one I could use. Suffice to say Disco Elysium was challenging me even in the midst of all my outrage. Go back and read that dialogue again. Deep down I was still pulling the “but violence is bad” card when it came to who <strong><em>I</em> </strong>was when I should’ve been getting my voice out there and pushing for change in the real world with real action if I meant it so much. Disco Elysium confronted me with that reality, called me out on it for vocalizing the peaceful options when deep down I knew chaos was what you get when the status quo is bad for too many for too long. I don’t defend it, but even MLK understood it when he stated that “a riot is the language of the unheard”. Deep down, sooner or later, Disco Elysium will <strong>inevitably </strong>ask you some harsh, fundamental questions as you position yourself somewhere. And it’s only when the game and writers decide to be <strong>graceful </strong>that you get to choose “I don’t want to share an opinion on the above, please take me away from these politics.” (and it still calls you out on that one) Otherwise: Pick a side, start digging, see what kind of a person you unearth in the process. You’ll probably find you’re more nuanced than your emotions let you think. Or you won’t learn anything at all.</p><p>For doing something like this in 2020, Disco Elysium jettisoned itself into the stratosphere alongside Pathologic 2 as one of the most thought-provoking experiences a video game has ever had on me. And here I was, bumbling around the coast of Martinnaise not really understanding that I was going to play this game four more times and think about it deeper and deeper with each run.</p><figure><img alt="An artistic painting of Kim Kitsuragi walking away from the perspective, a white halo enshrines his head much like his character portrait in the game, swirling clouds in front of him. His head slightly bowed in his walk." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*u-HZ1d1qFas3sODsIKHhyQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://tischotter.tumblr.com/image/706236757091516416">https://tischotter.tumblr.com/image/706236757091516416</a></figcaption></figure><h4>Harry #2 — The Cop of the Apocalypse (2021)</h4><p>Disco Elysium’s “Final Cut” was a heavily anticipated release for both fans of the game and the video game streaming community at large. Already-converted fans of the game were excited to listen to Kim Kitsuragi chime in across the entire investigation and the streaming community was excited to finally have the opportunity to play the game live. Disco Elysium is a game known at this point for having the most written text in any game in history and the herculean effort of having to provide voice for its decently sized cast would make any live stream of the game nearly impossible. Can you imagine trying to regularly read a million-word novel live for three to four hour chunks? The Final Cut released in March of 2021 and offered new political vision quests that would tie in the game’s themes a bit more dramatically, additional side quests, integrated streaming features that would offer viewer interaction if the streamer so chose, and most importantly: Full voice acting. It’s hard to tell exactly how much more exposure this release gave the game, but it’s clear that there was a 1–2 punch of release and celebration for Disco Elysium in each year of its release. First in 2019 the game was quickly heralded as one of the most fantastic games released in decades, winning accolades aplenty. Then in 2021 entire communities of people were able to rally around streamer after streamer as they exposed themselves to this game changer of an RPG. I was one of those rallying fans.</p><p>But also, for me, 2021 was the year <em>after 2020</em>. The year <em>after</em> I played Disco Elysium and the year <em>after</em> those protests that I felt so moved to physically engage in but ultimately chose not to. What did I do? I started Disco Elysium over. I couldn’t stop thinking about it. In the winter of the new year I slowly crept my way back to the cold room at the Whirling-in-Rags and this time tried to understand the world around me a bit more than before. The big kicker on my second run was <strong><em>history </em></strong>and <strong><em>failure</em></strong>. If you’ve read the art book, you’d know that Disco Elysium cares about history perhaps more than the game’s central protagonist. To quote an excerpt near the end:</p><blockquote>Elysium is a collection of ideas into which we poured all of our love of the world. And its history. It’s what we think is worthwhile in all this — recollected, resequenced, and reconceptualized.</blockquote><p>This undeniably remixed and substituted version of our own world, but not, was something I couldn’t get my mind off at the very beginnings of my second run in the game. I talked to Renee outside the Whirling-in-Rags and tried to piece it all together. I read wiki entries involving the timeline of monarchies that ruled Revachol before it was as it is now. I spoke to Joyce and started to comprehend what was happening here and what <strong>had </strong>happened here. It was during this run that I became curious what other experiences were out there that others had found. Knowing the game’s spoilers now, I started watching some streamers who tried playing the game back in 2019 and stopped because of that no-voice-barrier. I also watched critical analysis videos on it. In both cases, I <em>saw </em>and <em>heard </em>what some might consider a critical theme in Disco Elysium: Failure. Interestingly, my second run of the game would have less failure in it compared to my first. But the run would be defined by an understanding of the concept itself so strongly that it shifted my perspective on the game all over again.</p><p>I got to the end of day 1, began my questioning of Klaasje in day 2, and by this point I had fully internalized the major events of history in the 50 years before Disco Elysium started. The history that massively impacted Revachol and Martinaise. What I <em>hadn’t</em> internalized was that the Final Cut release was just days away and so I started my second run all over again if I really wanted to hear all that sweet sweet dialogue and avoid any update bugs. So I did it. I wasn’t that far in anyways. What followed was a fantastic experience playing the game ahead of and alongside various other streamers, a heyday release whirlwind I haven’t felt the likes of since 2016 with Dark Souls 3. It was fantastic. And this time: I fully committed to the communist arc. I also fully committed to Cop of the Apocalypse.</p><p>Cop of the Apocalypse isn’t some smarmy funny run that takes the “doomer” perspective most millennial and Generation Z people joke about these days: This idea that life has enough suffering that we’re all ready to be threatened with death by the actions of others openly, (yet not from our own hands because it’s sarcasm). No, Cop of the Apocalypse is really about cataclysmic doom for humans that can’t be predicted or stopped, but it’s coming. This “herald”-like role the player takes involves providing some very “John the Baptist” style warnings if clashed with some of the imagery in the book of Revelation. A bloodletting. A massive ill omen. While I didn’t find this perspective to be one that really matched wits with what the Communist political vision quest was really about, it was particularly telling that <strong><em>my </em></strong>Cop of the Apocalypse <strong>S</strong>TILL wasn’t able to figure out what it was that created the Swallow, the 2mm hole in the universe that was forming at the top of a church, what destroyed Fortress Accident’s big project and tanked the company: The Pale. Every attempt I had at figuring that out I just…failed. I had the big rave in the church and danced so hard that the city spoke to me. But I couldn’t figure out that the Pale was the big destruction deep in my soul I was so worried about. I think I never got Joyce to express what it is and so I could never put two and two together at the church. This, in essence, feels like part of what the Communist political vision quest is getting at. <strong>Understanding something is wrong and yet not knowing what to do about it or where to start.</strong> (note: I’m not saying that’s what communism is about, but the vision quest <em>is</em>)</p><p>As the conversation with yourself when proposed with Communism goes…</p><figure><img alt="Rhetoric: Failure. It’s about failure. You: Failure? Rhetoric: Yes! Abject failure. Total, irreversible defeat on all fronts! Absolutely vanquished, beaten, curb-stomped and pissed on — until *you* came along! *You* will reverse the fortune of the workers of the world." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/349/1*G5Ug8vi6bUvv0JMm2q9s6w.png" /><figcaption>Failure is at the heart of it all</figcaption></figure><p>It’s hard to show the description of how this is all about failure and just say that’s enough though. There’s a framework at play that needs illustrating so allow me to spend some more time doing so. The entirety of the game takes place literally stepping through the ruins of history. Martinaisse was the front of an attempt by the Communards to build a new nation after overthrowing a monarchy. The greater world surrounding it said “uhm, no”, and destroyed what little had managed to exist within six years. Comprehending this utter destruction of something that tried to come about and navigating the usual critiques of socialist or Marxist theory took up a great deal of my experience tapping into this understanding of “failure”. My Harry’s sorted thought on the idea revealed this depressing and enraging thing. To quote:</p><blockquote><em>0.000% of Communism has been built. Evil child-murdering billionaires still rule the world with a shit-eating grin. All he has managed to do is make himself *sad*. He is starting to suspect Kras Mazov *fucked him over* personally with his socio-economic theory. It has, however, made him into a very, very smart boy with something like a university degree in Truth. Instead of building Communism, he now builds a precise model of this grotesque, duplicitous world.</em></blockquote><p>The stat changes you get because of this realization are that you can’t <em>visually </em>analyze the world as good as before because you’re too busy <em>reacting </em>to <em>everything. </em>But you will react <em>faster. </em>If there was ever a real description of the angry, lost, and uncertain person I was after seeing the intolerance toward injustice boil over in 2020 while I did nothing, there it was. I don’t think I’m particularly alone in that depiction either. In our more connected and socially aware world, we’re all angry and unsure of how to advance. In many ways, what happened at the end of the mass protests and calls for change in 2020 is considered by some to be a failure to change much of anything. Black bodies are still over-policed and even as I write this our country is once again responding to such an incident with the brutal murder of Tyre Nichols, a person just two years younger than I whose life was cut short because six police officers decided the man deserved to be beaten to death for reckless driving and fleeing from the officers. Despite legal changes, the broader picture of injustice in this country mostly is unchanged (and now in 2026 while revising: It has gone backwards). Some days we wake up and find ourselves very aware of this grotesque, duplicitous world and all we can do is react. My Harry was very much that person, constantly reacting, pining on about what to change in this world while having done very little to change much of anything. Besides catch a killer <em>after </em>the murder had already happened (fat lot of good that did, no one really seems at peace over this discovery either). I was becoming this Harry in ’21 and ’22 that was only angrier at the failure of it all.</p><p>Now that we’re equipped with an understanding of the framework of Communism and failure from my perspective, we can look at Harry’s. Part of what has to be understood about Disco Elysium’s exploration of failure is in the deconstruction of identity. After all, the game does have an amnesiac at the center of the plot. <strong>All </strong>of the vision quests are very much this exploration of what you are and why Harry seems to be so <em>interested </em>in one school of political thought or the other. It doesn’t answer all the questions about Harry’s history, nor the world’s, but all of the vision quests very much spend some time entertaining a school of thought before Harry takes that school of thought to critical task and finds something else on the other side, <em>if he’s successful</em>. For example: The Communist political vision quest, the first one I experienced, involved finding a secret meetup of two students of Mazovian socioeconomics (i.e.: Marxism/Communism). And despite all the teachings of previous leaders in this school of thought, even these students aren’t really certain on how to proceed beyond secret meetings, they just spend time <em>studying </em>and <em>theorizing</em> while ignoring practical application. The difference, of course, lies in age and perspective. At almost 30 the angry person inside me that wanted to rebel was starting to slow down a little. By this point in 2021 I was engaged, planning a wedding, trying to live through a pandemic, all the while the world failed to massively improve or give more left-leaning ideals a remote thought. Just a year prior I had seen incredible amounts of effort put forth with the largest protest I’ll probably ever see in my life and it only amounted to so much in terms of results. Or, to put it another way:</p><figure><img alt="You: “If communism keeps failing every time we try it and and the rest of world conspires to invade and massacre us when we dare to stand up for our beliefs…” Steban: “Yes?” Volition: Say it. You: “…What’s the point?”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/357/1*LS7ucqPwpTGSOlUTLsawZg.png" /><figcaption>“…what’s the point?”</figcaption></figure><p>The <em>history </em>of failure, the <em>reality </em>of the problems that plague our own world despite humanity’s efforts to resolve them, is incredibly disheartening. My Harry during my second run was the example of this form of spiritual burn out over the idea that we can still make an impact in this world. As a millennial, I was promised this reality and then it got dashed quickly and loudly as I neared the end of my high school years. We were encouraged to go to college, promising it would grant us a future we could afford and it didn’t, not for most at least. And yet <em>my</em> Harry sought out these two young communards to try and address something deep within himself he still didn’t understand. Ironically, most consider the failure roll around this plot point to be <strong>more </strong>revealing of Harry’s deeper motivations here while a successful one maybe covers it all up. The successful roll means Harry asks “What’s the point?” and the communards express to Harry that at a certain point the originators of these philosophies believed Communism would ascend to a sort of religious status (which can be true of <strong>any </strong>socio-political philosophy in this day and age). They suggest that to be true to the mindset at heart, you have to believe in it <strong>even </strong>as it repeatedly fails. On the flip side of the coin, if Harry fails to remotely grapple with his questions, he just thinks Communists exist to overthrow the bourgeois and that the bourgeois are…women. <em>All </em>women. In both results it’s pretty clear Harry might not actually be a Communist at heart. He’s either someone who can’t completely commit to the idea after a history of failure or someone wildly disconnected from what it’s really all about. But in one result, players are keenly aware Harry has something very far from Communism on his mind and just wants a scapegoat for it. My Harry didn’t have this failure point, which means in my successful roll, Harry <strong>failed </strong>to realize <em>why </em>he had become so obsessed with Communism: Because his ex’s name reminds him of the symbol of an ideology that Communism would stand in opposition to. It’s <em>fascinating </em>trying to consider which Harry is the “real one” at this point. Harry DuBois the communist that believes a series of massive economic and political changes will cure his heart and fix the world around him? Harry DuBois who wants to overthrow the status quo because a rich female hurt his heart some long time ago? Both? Interestingly, Harry’s successful questioning of “what’s the point here?” still gets to the root of the matter for Harry: His doubt in there being a point means he might be struggling to see eye to eye with the ideology. And that maybe he’s involved in this for reasons to ease his sanity instead of out of faith in what improvements he could bring into the world by choosing a certain path. This is a recurring thing in <em>every </em>political vision quest.</p><p>My Harry eventually had the dream with the ex-something but didn’t know quite how vile the situation had become. That wouldn’t happen till my third run. Harry #2, cop of the apocalypse, cop of the environmental end of our world, cop of wanting radical change so that lives wouldn’t be subjected to such awful realities under cop-regimes and capitalism, he couldn’t really find hope in <em>much </em>when all he could see and say was how bad everything <em>is</em>. But he did get a snapshot of such a rare Phasmid (and even spoke to it!) that maybe he’ll start to look inward and accept what’s come to pass, the history of our world, and believe in occasional miracles. It might not all make sense, he might not even know what The Pale <em>is </em>still, and he knows it is all very <em>sad, </em>but Disco Elysium is a game that encourages you to live with that failure, embrace the comedy, beauty, and resolve in those failures. If ever there was a game more interested in comprehending failure, it was this one. And there’s not a run more revealing of it than the Communist one.</p><figure><img alt="Dark purples and blacks contrast a scene of four silhouettes sitting in the wreckage of a church. It’s Kim and Harry looking at the broken glass image of Dolores Dei. Behind the d uo ghostly visages of him and Kim dance under a disco ball." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ofZeNYq3m38SOXfTRl-ENw.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.tumblr.com/clownne/693043199817728000/my-part-of-the-video-for-the-feitsmontage?source=share">https://www.tumblr.com/clownne/693043199817728000/my-part-of-the-video-for-the-feitsmontage?source=share</a></figcaption></figure><h4>Harry #3 — The Superstar Cop (2022–23)</h4><p>My third run of Disco Elysium wasn’t actually mine. It was my wife’s instead. I was so wrapped up with this game’s design and its story and characters I just knew my wife would find parts of the game charming or interesting. So she did a run of the game with me helming the controls since she wasn’t used to games like this. What resulted was a really interesting and eye-opening experience of this game’s wider array of mechanics.</p><p>Most runs of this game that I had experienced on my own or through word of mouth or through others playing it were almost <strong>universally all</strong> <strong>sober. </strong>That included my second run of the game as well. Not my wife; she sought to play as the coked-up, drunk superstar cop that wanted to get <em>all the cool clothes</em>. I knew drugs and alcohol would boost or lower certain stats on use. But I had no idea just how effective they were at boosting your ability to get through so many sequences from the little boost here and there on your lower-level stats. For me this run was a fantastic time sharing a game I loved with someone I love. The humor was off the charts in this run as I got to see so many dialogue paths I hadn’t explored before thanks to being under the influence <em>all the time</em>. Each type of substance you get in the game has its own reveal and introduction dialogue that is hilarious and crazy to think about. The mental connection of being a homicide detective that’s just turning around and snorting some speed in front of suspects while the straight-faced Kim Kitsuragi watches on and does nothing to stop you has a bit of an unbelievable aspect to it in a game that feels incredibly grounded that you can’t help but laugh.</p><p>Meanwhile my wife also did the unspeakable and looted the boots off the dead body. This outcome I <strong>did </strong>know all about, not that it has much to it. We got the boots, cleaned them, put them on, and called it a night in-game since you can’t take the boots off the body while Kim is there. We started up the next day and my wife turned to me, having now become acquainted with the game’s reactive dialogue and commentary, she wondered out loud, “Wait, isn’t Kim going to notice you took the boots off and are wearing them now?”</p><p>I turned to her, and saying nothing, smiled. She burst into laughter.</p><p>Disco Elysium is a game that I’ve only come to see fascinate every human with its design the more you become comfortable with it. My wife also managed to do the lorry drug ring quest, which I had seen others do but I never gave it much attention. What was great was seeing how my wife took that evidence and used it as leverage against Titus Hardy to make her white checks against him even easier. She also unlocked Inexplicable Feminist Agenda rather quickly, a thought I didn’t even know existed in the game.</p><p>My wife’s run of the game was a fun time, something that didn’t reflect my own journey through the game as much, but it definitely shaped and influenced my next run of the game. Now knowing how much the game looks away while winking to the player when it comes to doing drugs and alcohol as an almost core-supporting-mechanic, I knew exactly what kind of Harry I wanted to try being in my fourth run.</p><figure><img alt="Harry du Bois stands on top of a giant horse statue easily 50 feet in the air. A bright sunsest in the distance brightens the sky behind him in stark exciting imagery. Harry is holding a bottle, almost assuredly this is a crazy drunken escapade by Tequila Sunset." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9MpKcsPzeDvKu7Bt_z9bPA.png" /></figure><h4>Harry #4 — The Hobo Moralist Cop (2023)</h4><p>My fourth (or third) Harry was an attempt at making a bit of a joke at religion in my country, and by that extension a joke at centrism. Christianity in the US is so key to so much of its culture and politics (or vice versa) that the belief itself has lost its meaning in the hands of this wider culture. Many who claim the religion don’t really follow through in its spiritual foundations of peace and restorative justice found in its figurehead: Jesus Christ. Many just adopt pieces of Christian culture and hold so dear to their own warped version of this religion that they’ll enact the very aggression and injustices necessary to push that culture on others in the pursuit of that figurehead they’ve been worshiping. Except they aren’t really worshiping the same figurehead at that point. There’s a much deeper rabbit hole behind that prior statement involving an exploration of how politics in this country has co-opted religion (<strong>and </strong>vice versa!) and when, exactly, that started. This article is long enough so I’ll just say it goes back to before the country existed, but I’ve found most scholars point to White Supremacy as the excuse justifying chattel race-based slavery in the US as a really defining period for what we still see and experience today when it comes “Christianity in America is messed up”. But the key things I want you to keep in mind is this: I’ve met some truly wonderful, loving, and faithful people who claim the name of Christ. I’ve also met some of the most spiteful, hateful, intolerant and unwelcoming people who do the same. It’s no secret to many Americans who <em>don</em>’t practice the faith what evangelical Christianity in this country <em>can mean. </em>One of the largest group of people you’d find at the January 6th insurrection was that of evangelical Christians. For me, having grown up being taught a faith and about a love that knows no bounds only to see the opposite in preach and practice has made religion’s politically parallel reality in this country a painful and disheartening truth. It’s a nasty corruption mirroring the way Jesus criticized so many religious people in scriptures. It’s a truth I’ve had to walk for over a decade now. It was increasingly hard to stomach over the 2010s and early 2020s.</p><p>So with my Moralist Harry, I wanted to poke at that mindset a little. By this point my own awareness of how the game functioned meant there was a driving interest in seeing what full commitment to that thought I unlocked on my first run would truly <em>mean</em>. I wanted to see what the game would say about a Harry who <strong>constantly </strong>breaks his own moral rules that he assigns on society. From a start there’s a perception that the Kingdom of Conscience (the motivating idea behind moralism/centrism) is this radical thing because of its commitment to being beyond all the struggles society faces in the present. If you side with the notion that the status quo is preferable to chaos and bloodshed and ask what the Kingdom of Conscience will be like, you get this breakdown of all the things it <em>won’t be.</em></p><figure><img alt="You: Okay, but what’s the Kingdom of Conscience actually *like*? Empathy: The Kingdom is difficult to comprehend and even more difficult to describe, artly because humanity will need to discard many of the categories that define and limit it today. The Kingdom of Conscience is post-capitalist, post-national. It’s also post-industrial, post-ideological, and even *post-sexual*." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/345/1*vuCAm_ZfBk9MSbISUr4JRQ.png" /></figure><p>The inciting thought tagline ends with the question, “What will it be like, once their nuanced plans have been realized?” From here, we can explore and consider the perspectives of that of other moralists we encounter in the game. Two, in particular, and then a third in vagueness.</p><p>First, there’s the most level-headed man in all of Martinnaise and perhaps Revachol: Kim Kitsuragi. Kim’s perspective on moralism is uniquely detached from the organization that furthers its normalcy (the Moralintern), while still maintaining some of the same approaches to reality that the notion of being “in the middle” provides. He once appealed to the Moralintern but has found himself in recent years favoring them less.</p><p>For me there’s an undeniable degree of contradiction in certain avenues of centrism or moralism. Kim no doubt faces the same sometimes. Taking any sort of a stance (in our world at least) is never without an opposing stance. Even on some of the most tame of concepts, you’ll find disagreements. No matter how many people agree that dogs are good, some people will never see it that way. Someone will eventually disagree. So with moral issues, we experience it in greater extremes. As political ideologies in the US are pushed towards more and more extreme ends, finding some universal moral agreements become impossible. Even if those disagreements are sometimes spurred by people taking opposing sides <em>purely</em> for spite. And for someone to stand in the middle of two extremes and try to argue that both sides have merit, you’re going to seem like a person playing devil’s advocate for a monster at some point or another, sometimes on both sides.</p><p>Returning back to what we saw in 2020, trying to take a nuanced “We need police but something revolutionary also needs to happen” stance wasn’t really a conversation you could find yourself having without being a labelled outcast in the conversation. In a world that demands you pick one morality or another, as a moralist you would go through life a hypocrite no matter how hard you try. Therein lies the inescapable reality of hypocrisy and contradiction for any centrist. <em>Centrism today is the incapacity for a person that identifies closer to the middle of the political spectrum to live without offending anyone. It’s the capacity to say you don’t want transgender affirming care allowed in </em><strong><em>specific </em></strong><em>contexts while also turning to those trying to criminalize transgender affirming care universally and saying, “No, trans right are human rights.”</em> In a world that <strong>demands </strong>you pick a side, centrism is envisioned oftentimes as <em>cowardly</em>. And yet, Kim navigates this reality with a resolve that most players don’t see as cowardly, but endearing and memorable instead. Part of this is at the credit of the game’s subject matter not steering too close to some of these topics, but the other part of the credit is in recognizing that Disco Elysium is a detective game, and Kim Kitsuragi finds his solace in discovering truths. Who killed whom? Who did what? In uncovering truths, the world feels more solid.</p><p>But when it comes to Kim and his likability as a moralist, I think it all boils down to one very important facet: Intolerance. The moment you are intolerant of another, you breach Kim’s approach to moralism. We see this pretty regularly. In Kim’s very strong attempts to not take a side, he is heavily committed to the notion of keeping both sides from killing each other. Any side that doesn’t want the other around is in danger of violating his rules. In Kim’s eyes: Everyone’s allowed to stand around. No one’s allowed to say you shouldn’t be here. Kim is the literal ideal of a peacekeeper, despite using the rule of law as his moral compass, he’s just as ready to use his own sense of morality for a compass from time to time. Everyone can think of a law that is reasonable to bend and don’t think its punishments fit their sense of criminality. But prejudiced intolerance, in Kim’s eyes, and the eyes of many, is a form of evil that threatens the notion that we all deserve to exist free of intolerance. And at the end of the day, Kim is capable of looking straight in the eye of an intolerant person and saying “That intolerance isn’t tolerated here” and squaring up for a fight. Why Kim seems to be moving away from holding the Moralintern in a favorable light I’ll discuss later. But if you were wondering: There’s one side of the political machine in Revachol and in our world that seems to <strong><em>explicitly</em></strong> target people based on skin color or what nations their ancestors came from or if they conform to hetero-normative relationships. Kim doesn’t tolerate that type of behavior. And the Moralintern and our real-world version of it absolutely has people like that. It is an evil that has wormed its way into schools of thought for millennia. This problem is ancient.</p><p>Next, there’s the Sunday Friend. He’s a beaurocrat representing the financial sector of the Moralintern that’s been snooping around and observing potential property values. You find him in the capeside apartments but he’s not actually <em>supposed</em> to be there, preferring to not let his presence in the smoker’s apartment be known. Much like what we’ll see later regarding “responsibility”, he spends time constantly talking about “*ze price stabilitè*” without really ever explaining what this stability is all about or how to attain it. He only reinforces that it’s very very important. There’s also the suggestion that despite his presence in Martinnaise, he shouldn’t be seen here, in the apartments with the smoker (almost implying that he has a relationship with the smoker and it’d be something the Moralintern would frown upon, non-hetero relationship that it would be, or maybe because the smoker on the balcony is working as a prostitute). One might presume his discretion isn’t about the relationship with the smoker, but Sunday Friend is found later out and about in broad daylight hanging around other old buildings. Just not the Smoker’s Apartment. The most we can glean from the Sunday Friend about moralism is its very obfuscation and the vague idea of some form of stabilization (back to that idea of maintaining the status quo, but with economics instead).</p><p>So far the perspective of moralism has been presented as this highly specific individual experience of towing the line between two extremes (Kim’s) and keeping the status quo in the vaguest, widest concept possible (the Sunday Friend). What <em>is </em>Disco Elysium really trying to say about moralists or centrists that commit to it (even if they so regularly contradict it)? Time to walk the Moralist Vision Quest for that third perspective.</p><p>The quest begins with Harry waking up fed up with the way things are going, but convinces himself this isn’t on the smaller scale. It’s larger, wider, bigger than just the murder that Harry is so desperately struggling to understand. And so someone has to take on responsibility for improving things around Revachol and Martinnaise. It should be noted that immediately the moralist mindset is convincing Harry that all of this is <strong>not </strong>about singular individuals or one individual problem. It ignores those things, or obfuscates them behind wider problems to concern yourself with (we’re going to see that word “obfuscate” quite a bit on this part of the journey).</p><figure><img alt="You: “I thought I *was* assigning responsibility, for the murder?” Empathy: Harry, Harry. You’re thinking about this too narrowly. La responsabilité isn’t concerned with trivial questions like *who killed who*. It’s about the real issues: the human welfare index, the price of staple goods, the transition to real democracy…" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/368/1*K34V1dfXjjm_V0UtIpdjmA.png" /></figure><p>Up until the vision quest, my moralist drug-chugging Harry was a walking contradiction who refused to live up to the values he proclaimed. He was the moralist we all like to hate. He’d morally point like so many do, while simultaneously breaking all the rules that he morally aligned against. He’d talk bad about drugs and swipe them the next second. He’d beg for hand outs anywhere he could and then tell you to go get a job. We know these people. Someone who states values but is selective in the ones they follow, picking out the values that are <strong>easy </strong>for <em>them </em>to follow and others are so vile for not doing the same. Personally I’ve found most people proclaiming some right or left leaning ideals to actually be centrists in a lot of ways and I include myself in there. I did after all admit to not really doing anything during the George Floyd protests, not <em>physically</em>. Sure I had arguments, but what does that amount to when the cry made at centrists is to get on a side or get out of the way? I voted later but most people seem to agree that voting is only doing so much when politicians aren’t making great strides.</p><p>So Harry wakes up and decides to do something about this, once and for all. Go find the Moralintern by way of some believers. First he turns to Kim, but Kim really doesn’t have any involvement with them. So we go to the Sunday Friend. He expresses that while he’s not technically<em> in town</em>, we might have some luck contacting the Coalition Airship, one of several that constantly patrol Revachol and the great island. Through a series of events we build an antenna out of the statue of King Frissell and a group of factors determines how long we can stay in communication with Coalition Warship Archer, or more specifically a radio operator on it.</p><p>What follows is a diverse set of questions you can ask them ranging from “When will democracy come to Revachol?” to reporting the literal situation of the murder mystery to the operator. Getting all the dialogue here was such a painful chore that I have to share my experience of save scumming. I stumbled upon a save bug that kicked in about 50% of the time. I’d climb the antenna but my conversation was shortened or even ruined if I broke the antenna after climbing it, which meant I’d load into the bug 50% of the time, quit and restart the game and work my way through it all again so I could experience the most variations of this conversation. And sometimes I’d fail the rolls entirely, requiring me to start it all over again. It was a pain well worth it because it’s so interesting based on what your stats are at the time. A lot of the conversation takes place in the midst of an electromagnetic storm, pale frequencies are tapped into and you hear things destined to happen in the future (or not).</p><p>First to observe is the radio operator, Elena, a moralist who is able to, at length, express what the Moralintern are, what they want and how they plan to achieve it. Finally, some answers! You can spend time getting her to see you from her view and it turns out she can’t quite stomach looking at Martinnaise for long, she doesn’t like how dirty and run down it is, which implies a bit of a privilege or a wealthier background that would restrict her exposure to how the Moralintern’s ruling impacts other regions of Revachol. From her perspective the Moralintern want humanity to endure through mutually assured destruction, extremely slowly planned change, and navigating the reality of different ideologies. You can pick her brain for opinions about fascists, communists, and social democrats (i.e. liberals), she seems to like the last the least. Her answer expresses some of the same issues most have had.</p><figure><img alt="Coalition warship archer: “We don’t resent them. It’s more that we are… *disappointed* that they have chosen to emphasise certain points of dispute over broad areas of accord…” Empathy: She speaks of them like a family member she’s abandoned hope of ever maturing." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/355/1*Krb88eByau4Z_N9TMljXRQ.png" /></figure><p>Elena goes on to express a place called Advesperascit where a large modern art piece allows a mesh of shadows and light to fall in a way that all these various pieces of architecture interlink together. The writers of the story seem very aware of the hypocrisy of centrism while still managing to paint a centrist mindset as something…understandable. Aspirational even. The wider organization of the Moralintern is painted as utterly evil, something we can all comprehend in this day and age. But Elena is a <em>human voice</em>, capable of empathy <em>and </em>discomfort. And the dangers that lead to this evil reality are even hinted at in the person we meet that is the good voice coming out of the Moralintern. It’s hard to fathom this type of voice in an American political landscape where everything is so reactionary, so bifurcated into a pure duality instead of considering the nuances of human thinking. But I think the writers paint a really honest picture of where your head can go wrong living in the moralist landscape: Everything’s right and wrong, everything’s bigger picture, it becomes a cultural mindset that escapes reality entirely like Elena is capable of looking away from the things that discomfort her from her place high in the sky while still believing in this attainable future instead of recognizing just how hard it is for the people on the ground. You probably can’t accomplish Moralism’s goals or mindset while flying the zeppelin. It’s just too grand.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/191/0*r0kUCyKUcSma8DOr" /><figcaption>The portrait for Elena</figcaption></figure><p>When you discuss how the Moralintern can control the timing of this change, there’s talk of contingency spreads, a not-completely-confirmed-lore-adjacent idea that involves using machines and people to try and predict the future based on brief glimpses. The bi-product of these attempts to look into the future is the generation of what we know in the game as the Pale. This technical breakdown of contingency spread studies and Pale generation is <strong>not </strong>part of the conversation. It doesn’t really happen. After reading Sacred and Terrible Air, the first published piece of fiction in the Disco Elysium universe, it honestly feels a little up to debate how Pale functions from one published work to the next. But that’s a matter for another discussion. As for contingency spreads, Elena breaks down the idea of trying to predict water running down a hill and the various ways it’ll get there. The Moralintern specializes in doing everything it can to make sure the water doesn’t go down the hill too fast or spread too thin or in a direction that won’t befit them, even if Elena won’t admit that last bit. At this point I was still struggling to comprehend <em>what </em>this Harry was failing to accept in his life that meant he leaned towards moralism or centrism. But then I told the warship about the things going on in Martinnaise and discussed the discovery of the Pale in the church.</p><p>Suddenly the conversation shifts more seriously. Elena reads from a series of questions on pages.</p><ol><li>“Are you currently in the vicinity of Sereglee, the North Arcade Islands, or Near Pale Offshore Platform ‘Insulindico’?”</li><li>“Would you describe the phenomenon as *internal* to the isola, or *external* to the isola?”</li><li>“At the time, did you experience *sense objects*?”</li><li>“Were you <em>alone</em>?”</li></ol><p>As you answer the questions and conclude, Elena has the airship drop down into the region and offers you to speak to her superiors in the Moralintern. They rope a ladder down to you. It’s here that suddenly the quest started to make sense because the possibility space increased a ridiculous degree. What happens if I get on the ship? Kim believes you’re literally about to get wrapped up in a series of work so monumental that you won’t be able to continue the quest. When Kim asks you “What now?” in regards to the murder case, you’re prompted with these options:</p><figure><img alt="Option 1: “Kim, have you ever considered that maybe our case isn’t that important?” Option 2: “Kim, I’m tired of feeling like I don’t have any *normal reasonable* options.” Option 3: “But I’m afraid, Kim.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/355/1*HQokkC0FjQ2jAB3b58GuTw.png" /></figure><p>And there it is.</p><p>What is Harry truly pursuing? What does Harry really want in trying to assign responsibility?</p><p>He’s looking to escape the weight of his current reality in a bigger, wider, vaguer calling. His ex left him, all he does is solve murders, nothing has changed. What’s the <em>point</em>? How about pursuing something that lets you get by on a purpose bigger than the things that make you sad every day and the things that are hard? It’s the easier way to live life while still believing you’re genuinely making a difference. Follow the rules, change very little, and if you fit the mold it’ll be <em>easy, </em>there won’t be any consequences, things won’t be weird and out of control. You’ll <strong>belong</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="Kim Kitsuragi: “I don’t know where this case will lead us, detective, but in a sense that doesn’t matter. Our job is to follow the evidence where it leads, consequences be damned. Because that’s what it means to be an office of the RCM!”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/315/1*WUiJcVdLNXPHes-3uqlpZQ.png" /></figure><p>To the Hobo Moralist Cop, this Harry I played was searching for a way to comprehend the contradictions and challenges of pluralism and is offered something bigger by a stand-in for an angel (in my opinion at least, it’s a faceless, voiced presence that represents a higher power). Kim is the one who has to talk Harry back down to the ground; <em>that </em>Harry has obligations here on Earth still. My hobo moralist Harry found that subscribing to centrism is something very difficult, it <em>i</em>s<em> </em>something admirable to pursue. So you can choose to get on the ship, or stay. Harry is (seemingly) never heard from again if he gets on the airship. The “game over” card suggests the Moralinern <em>disappeared </em>him. This notion of ascendancy is either suggesting the Moralintern has silenced him for the discovery he’s made or a sort of escapism Harry has achieved for finally uncovering something worthy of pulling him away from the trappings of his history. The big machine is less trustworthy, but the cause at heart is admirable.</p><p>To a world of people who have stability in their life and want to find purpose without getting their hands dirty or have to put in the greater effort, why not step on the ship? Why not become part of something bigger? Who needs the ground anyways when you’ve got God in the sky?</p><p>On the ground, you <strong>cannot</strong> ignore the individual cases, the experiences, the problems of human beings in their livelihood. When you’re up high in a place detached from those realities, that stuff doesn’t matter. Only big sweeping, but carefully tinkered, change will make any sort of a difference to the millions below. I think this is why Kim fell out of love with the Moralintern, but not <em>moralism</em>. He’s been around too much to see how faith in any sort of a larger system (religious or otherwise) isn’t going to cut it, not when they’re not where he is day in, day out, riding the line of what it means to stand in the middle in any particular day, during any particular moment, trying to accomplish any particular task. His ability to compromise rules when he’s maintaining the most important of his morals (the golden rule, I’d imagine) is what makes him, in the eyes of many, simply <strong>the best.</strong></p><p>I set out in my Moralist run to make a mockery of moralism, of people who are a walking oxymoron. Instead I learned I need to be more critical of the Moralintern itself and all its rules and plans instead of the Kim Kitsuragi’s of the world who realized they don’t need the Moralintern to be a good person.</p><figure><img alt="An artistic rendering of Harry letting go of the note from his ex, it flies away on the wind, upwards." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9o1r3OhmkLOtVrwjbZQ5nQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.tumblr.com/youraveragejoke/703823172690214912/my-piece-for-the-cleaning-out-the-rooms">https://www.tumblr.com/youraveragejoke/703823172690214912/my-piece-for-the-cleaning-out-the-rooms</a></figcaption></figure><h4>Harry #5 — The Hardcore Fascist (2024)</h4><p>This was (for now at least) my last run of Disco Elysium. For an added thematic weight I decided to do a run of the game not only as a fascist, but as a fascist with the game’s built-in hardcore mode turned on. Because fascists shouldn’t get to live life easily. Fascism Harry was never something I really looked forward to but always saw as an inevitable exploration. <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/paultassi/2020/02/22/youll-be-surprised-what-percent-of-mass-effect-players-chose-paragon/">If Mass Effect choices were anything to go on</a>, most players probably stick to trying to be kind in video games. At least as far as a game will let them. Disco Elysium seems to be no exception to the rule when you look at Steam achievements and see that I am one of 0.7% of the people who unlocked the fascism achievement for completing its political vision quest. I didn’t have the best time playing the game this way and I don’t think the developers wanted you to. And yet I <em>had to know</em> if something was in there, I had to know what kind of Harry is in this run. But I want to make it clear over this next little chunk that a “Fascism Hardcore” run is actually just about the hardest way to play this game except maybe a Sober Hardcore run. I can’t imagine what it’d be like to do something like this on a first time playing the game, some of the mechanics in Disco aren’t telegraphed early enough and while there are some definite perks to playing it this way, I was so routinely getting failed rolls in the early game that the biggest advantage I had going for me was that baked in knowledge from having beaten this game four times before already.</p><p>For starters, doubling down on saying “traditionalist” (i.e. fascist) things once you’ve internalized the thought means you take morale damage every time you say something in that political alignment. It seems even deep down Harry isn’t really in love with the ideals so much as he just wants to get drunk and numb it all. This almost feels like a reflection of how fascism as a concept is a painful thing to stomach, an unnatural inhumane mindset. The internalized thought is peppered with instructions to drink at the end of every sentence. I took copious screenshots of things said across the fascism vision quest not really sure what I’d share in this article and so much of it is discomforting or humorous. There’s one screenshot where I titled it “Time Travel 11 (My Stomach Actually Churned)” and that was followed by “Time Travel 12 (And Then I Laughed)”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/552/1*kqHWMTA3ejtJXCQoq-2mRg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/521/1*wM1RaA6zDX8xgR9UbKxicg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/491/1*uIyoxF28qdk_dLu0cWHXCA.png" /><figcaption>Just some fascism dialogue from Disco Elysium where women are blamed for everything and an incel racist is deeply upset but tells you that no, he knows no way to travel to the past.</figcaption></figure><p>Luckily you get double the Physique boost you normally get for drinking booze. There’s hints through your old cases in your clipboard that maybe Harry <em>was</em> quite the fascist back before his memory was lost and I think the moral damage you take in the game with the fascism thought internalized actively reflects that perspective: Harry is falling back into his old ways after annihilating his identity and it’s painful every time he heads towards it again. So he should drink to get rid of that pain. It’s not so different from trying to talk to your ex on the phone or in your dreams. You shouldn’t. It’s only pain and misery and the drinking Harry did for years up to the start of the game was his attempt to drown all that pain and misery. That’s why it’s actually kind of poetic to throw away the note Dora left Harry if you find it in the clipboard during this run specifically.</p><p>I still can’t quite make up my mind whether or not this version of Harry I played that has thrown the letter away and does everything in his power across this run to avoid thinking of Dora or Dolores has truly obliterated his ex from his mind. It’s actually easy to just “re-trigger” Dora in Harry’s head. Part of what makes the fascism run so fascinating is in the understanding that Harry was and is, deep down, an awful human being and simply never stopped being that way. At some point that type of toxic thinking about a relationship gone bad can turn against the gender or sex of the former partner entirely. Did Harry stop wanting to be the person that hates women before he endured the mother of all hangovers and forgot about the world? Or did he stop wanting to be so mopey about her and truly forget her? There’s so many arguments for both ends. The clipboard was in the trash, so Harry was either annihilating himself or the thing he held close to him as a reminder of his ex all the time. A conversation with Measurehead and the Pale driver about time travel (y’know, cause fascism wants to return to when “they” were in power) implies that the entroponetic elements of the Pale may have the capacity to experience old memories forever, even ones from so called “traditional” times that fascists would love to cling to. Did Harry make sense of this, try it, and simply lose his mind in the process? Did he do it to try and destroy all memories of his ex? Again, it’s really hard to be sure and that’s part of the beauty of Disco’s varied approaches to the age-old amnesia-problem in video games. It’s actually a curiosity to delve into and consider.</p><p>My Fascism Harry naturally was a physical beast demanding respect to his authority and all about the things fascist influencers love to harp on. His knack for exerting his physique was emphasized only further by also unlocking a skill partner through the story: Coach Physical Instrument. A manly man that doesn’t like namby pamby adjectives or pronouns. To great comedic effect Coach Physical Instrument gives you a +2 to your rolls <em>so long as you take your shirt off</em>. You gotta show it off to become stronger. You won’t be as smart, permanently, but it reflects Harry’s past in a slightly less harmful way: He <strong>was</strong> a gym teacher and body builder. That part of him never really left even if the weird hyper-masculine mindset stays silent in other runs. Don’t be mistaken though, Coach Physical Instrument <em>is</em> problematic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/956/1*i3AABd9pwN-81F8vibYHBA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/894/1*ctNq5BVPRGAponBAMt3UCA.png" /><figcaption>In the images above Coach Physical Instrument says he’s going to “turn you into an athletic bench-mark” and that you don’t need to dilly dally or be careful when discussing sexual assault with a victim.</figcaption></figure><p>And yet, a Fascist Physique Maxed run of the game is almost <em>too</em> convenient a picture of Harry to express for me. I’m not the fittest most athletic or muscular man you’ll ever meet. I believe during a physical exam a doctor in training told my physician I am “unremarkable”. I was raised by parents that didn’t encourage my exercise enough and my dad’s work kept him out of shape and indulged some bad eating habits in himself. Those habits rippled down to me over the years. But to top it off I have a weird disconnect when it comes to my gender. I was never dysphoric but I also wasn’t raised around a bunch of guys that got me into the “traditional manly activities” like sports, cars, guns, and hunting. I enjoy a live sports game. I’ve relaxed a handful of afternoons with my brother at a dragway watching car after car go past. We used to go fishing for fun. But once I had more freedom I kept my nose in books and video games and visual entertainment and escaped onto the internet to find others like me. I wrote fan fiction in my teens. I’ve enjoyed board games now and then. It’s fair to say these things technically developed alongside each other, but I clearly made a specific choice. Playing a Harry that was a beefy tough guy who <strong>healed</strong> every time he beat up inanimate objects and had a voice in his head telling him to not be a p*@#y every now and then was funny, and incredibly suiting for the way Harry looks. He even got super wrapped up into mansplaining the importance of a boxer’s history to Acele, thinking it was disrespectful or something that she not know who Contact Mike is. I don’t <strong>get </strong>this type of thinking that’s so omnipresent with Coach P.I., so it felt validating to see the gross side of it while having fun with its class perks.</p><p>That being said, the fascism run and writing about it has been a struggle. It was so fitting that this Harry struggled at everything again like in my first run. I knew how to game the skills and rolls right to accomplish everything, but it was still hard to successfully convince Kim to dance with you in the church. Deep down Kim is keeping track of your various racist remarks and it requires a really high authority roll to get him to dance. When it fails, you call him a slur so bad that he’ll fail the shootout later in the game and be gone for the rest of the story. I faced down that moment, saw it play out, and tried my best to walk it back. But I couldn’t accept it. The conversation feels awful even when it feels like you convince Kim you’re not a bad person. Deep down even if you can engage in hardcore mode, overcome its negative die rolls, fight against your inner moral compass to not say horrible things while role playing as a fascist, you still have to face the music of <em>Kim not liking you</em>. And that’s a challenge I just couldn’t overcome. So I save scummed it till I kept him. If that means I failed at completing the Fascist Hardcore run, so be it. My experience playing this run was truly becoming disconnected from reality for me. Not in a strange, alien way but moreso that this run of the game wasn’t an experience reflecting that much about my current political situation back at me. 2024 was awful for me in completely <em>different </em>ways and reasons that I struggle to fairly map onto the fascism run I went through. If there’s anyone I felt similar to in 2024 it was the The Deserter (i.e. he couldn’t look away and accept defeat, not the other creepy stuff). I started my fascism run that year, but I didn’t <em>finish </em>the run until early 2026. I had taken it all the way through the shootout and just stopped. I don’t even remember what stopped me, but there was definitely a sensation that I had mostly tapped the well of experiences and was running out of gas. Did that mean there wasn’t interesting things to talk about in the fascism vision quest?</p><figure><img alt="Measurehead: “I’M GOING TO DO YOU A KINDNESS, PUPA. I’M GOING TO SHARE A SECRET WITH YOU. HERE IS THE SECRET:”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/436/1*TddQRFsAYUwdVylAxuVmZQ.png" /></figure><p>No, of course not.</p><p>Playing a fascist actually resulted in some of the most interesting dialogue in <strong>all </strong>of my runs, but it happened often in pockets before it got to the vision quest. The reason for this is because, well for starters it’s just the polar political opposite of the norm that you tend to experience in this game. But there’s also just a spectrum of ways people react to what you say as you play, almost as if people are interested in expressing their own motivations or beliefs more than before in the face of your counter perspective (or shared of course). Plus there’s those lingering questions about the extent of Dora’s impact on this version of Harry. Here’s just a handful of dialogue bits I had no recollection seeing in prior runs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/868/1*N69hkpSMtmMETtUTl6pkrw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/958/1*IsbAiPeUkGQQb9004yRmmw.png" /><figcaption>In one passage Klassje contemplates how she and the murder victim hated their home country. In another passage Harry considers “Hmm, aren’t all women devil women?”</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/862/1*rPRN41jaIZeuPZ58HZit-Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/842/1*lSgsJ9Ya5xwnSU5gIZ5qZw.png" /><figcaption>In one image Harry sees Kim do a respectful sign of worship to Dolores Dei and Harry tells himself “No, I am not your bug. I’m not doing that cross either.” In another images, Harry discusses how he is “the Lawbringer” to Lilienne and she remarks how men constantly need to assert their authority.</figcaption></figure><p>In some ways I think part of what stalled out my fascism run at that last little chunk of gameplay was in the realization I’d have to somehow summarize that vision quest here in this article. I don’t remember exactly when I started writing this anymore. I know it was probably after my third run, but I don’t remember more. I know just that I slowly added more to it, refined each run breakdown and added each Harry as I completed each run. There’s so much to discuss across the fascism vision quest but at nearly 300 hours I’ve run out of gas and energy for the game on my own. If my estimates are right, I’ve been tinkering away at this article for 3 years. At nearly 30+ minutes this article and my thoughts in it become a pool of ink creeping to a halt as it has soaked into the page. Why can’t I summarize the fascism vision quest? I’ve come this far…</p><p>Maybe because while there are things to glean from this fantastic work, sometimes the time has passed and it is time to move forward with today and tomorrow. Or maybe because, unlike the others, fascism is something I can’t reflect back on myself at all.</p><p>There’s some pieces I had in mind for this article that I kept at the bottom of the edit, little scribbles or things I wanted to include somewhere but I never knew <em>when</em> I would, if at all. Finally, I have found use for some. When I was keeping these notes, I told myself to: <em>“Use each Harry experience as an opportunity to express what experience you began to like.” </em>And then I gave a breakdown of them.</p><p>Harry 1 — The Sorry Cop Harry. A sorry cop that was given questions that legitimately provoked my brain. What an experience.</p><p>Harry 2 — The Cop of the Apocalypse Harry. A Communist Harry that understood the broken world and couldn’t stop reacting. This game is beautiful.</p><p>Harry 3 — The Superstar Cop. A Communist Harry that understood the broken world and couldn’t stop dancing and laughing. This game is hilarious.</p><p>Harry 4 — The Hobo Cop. A moralist Harry that found himself struggling to escape only to comprehend the challenges of pluralism and the most disturbing of endings. This game still has something left to show me.</p><p>I wrote a summary for Harry 5. But I think I’ll finally keep that one for myself. You’ll no doubt see my summaries don’t quite match what I really wrote about that much. Instead I spent a lot of time using Disco Elysium to look in my mirror. You can spend a lot of time looking in the mirror in Disco Elysium, literally and metaphorically. Harry uses it to understand the face he makes of pain and sorrow as well as consider no longer hiding that pain. What you see in your own mirror is what I often argue makes video games so great: Yourself.</p><p>On my second or third run, I was curious what that quote from the opening of the game means or is from. Disco Elysium originally was going to be called “No Truce with the Furies” and the opening quote reads:</p><p><em>“The furies are at home in the mirror; it is their address. Even the clearest water, if deep enough can drown.” — R.S. Thomas</em></p><p>I did a little searching of that quote and found a wonderfully profound summary of its meaning in this game.</p><figure><img alt="Test alt-text" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/792/1*zpDWns6bEoprE4aGah3phw.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/DiscoElysium/comments/doqp8c/furies_and_truces_with_them/">https://www.reddit.com/r/DiscoElysium/comments/doqp8c/furies_and_truces_with_them/</a></figcaption></figure><p>I think the way Disco Elysium portrays existence as both a sad and hopeful thing is altogether remarkable, endearing, and captivating. The game’s decision to constantly monitor your choices and react to them was an inventive idea that gave me the video game experience of a lifetime. And I think if you want to find out what’s so remarkable, endearing or captivating in the fascism run, you might just have to put in the work yourself this time. I can’t look in your mirror, I’d just see myself.</p><p>Go find your Harry and tell me what you saw.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CnL1khJGSTGPJ-9Ht2MrmQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://nonbinarypunkk.tumblr.com/post/693028226248933376">https://nonbinarypunkk.tumblr.com/post/693028226248933376</a></figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=387ad13e247" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[2025 Recommendations]]></title>
            <link>https://the-typer.medium.com/2025-recommendations-632b7b8a93e9?source=rss-4c5509ad50b6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/632b7b8a93e9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[indiana-jones]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[routine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[favorites]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Fleming]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 27 Dec 2025 07:13:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-27T15:17:00.364Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Video Games</strong></h3><p>I rolled credits on 20 games this year. That’s a lot more than I have in prior years, mostly keeping it to about a game a month. You can quick link to my thought on each game below.</p><p><a href="#64f8">Celeste</a></p><p><a href="#31d1">Indiana Jones and the Great Circle</a></p><p><a href="#c488">Chicken Police: Paint It RED!</a></p><p><a href="#e046">Killer Frequency</a></p><p><a href="#a6da">Venba</a></p><p><a href="#9056">Lies of P: Overture</a></p><p><a href="#e25e">Tunic</a></p><p><a href="#98b1">Genesis: Noir</a></p><p><a href="#8b73">Stasis: Bone Totem</a></p><p><a href="#4247">Dredge</a></p><p><a href="#d834">Still Wakes the Deep</a></p><p><a href="#b902">The Last Case of Benedict Fox</a></p><p><a href="#6e63">Alan Wake 2</a></p><p><a href="#ec76">Routine</a></p><p><a href="#31d2">S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2: Heart of Chernobyl (concluded)</a></p><p><em>The other games I finished but have nothing really to say about them:<br>-Resident Evil Remake<br>-Resident Evil 2 Remake<br>-What Remains of Edith Finch<br>-Breath of the Wild<br>-Broken Age</em></p><h4>Celeste</h4><p>I think better things have been said about Celeste that I haven’t read. It’s a really good platformer, it’s a wonderfully thematic game about self-doubt and self-imposed challenges. Part of me wishes Celeste almost had that whisper-whisper word-of-mouth talking campaign around it the way most people said “Go play Mouthwashing” and didn’t explain much else beyond that. Mainly because as great as Celeste is, by the time I got around to playing it most of those spoilers were already omni-present for me. I’m not saying the game’s plot isn’t some revelation but if all I heard about Celeste was that it was a really challenging and fun platformer and I only ever saw action footage of it, I probably would’ve found the game’s plot to engage with me a bit more directly. Instead it’s just a really great platformer for me. It’s also a beautiful tale for those who need to hear its affirming words from the windy peaks of difficulty.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Z5dnAcmOpErnkKQm.jpg" /></figure><h4>Indiana Jones and the Great Circle</h4><p>This one was a challenge game given to me by one of my best friends. He told me to play Act I and we’d talk about it. I wound up playing about 80% of the game by the time the challenge window was up. I <strong>really</strong> enjoyed my time with it and simultaneously would probably say Yahtzee’s review is <strong>spot on. </strong>It’s a game that gradually gets worse as you go, I found myself similarly inundated with too many collectibles to find, some of which weren’t that tied to interesting exploration or puzzles to engage with. Tying that exploration in the game’s third major area with the stifling boat mechanics made me give up on exploring all together at that point. It also made me really consider how these type of “franchise branded exploration AAA games” feel akin to copying the Batman/Spider-Man formula that has proven successful without weighing what’s there to draw fans and what elements are really engaging with that brand. I personally don’t feel like it totally works for Indiana Jones. I know it probably does for some people but I realized after a certain point in the game I’m not that invested in Indiana Jones’s connected fictions outside the movies (the books are collectibles and tie-in threads used here, for example). It’s a good story! And by definitions the archeology aspect of Indy should be compelling but I think that requires a different approach closer to what we see in this game’s story-based puzzles.</p><p>And yet, I loved a lot of this game. MachineGames deserve some particularly high praise for making environments made for exploration in first person that are so good I constantly sought ways to abandon the stealth and action elements of the game because I just wanted to poke around more. Feels like they took some huge lessons from Arkane while working on Wolfenstein: Youngbloods. Don’t get me wrong, the stealth was enjoyable, though it had its quirks. A key consideration is how much I wanted to avoid detection in the second and third zones because I knew it’d draw more and more enemies, and yet both of those zones don’t really offer you much in the way of disguises right away. The combat wasn’t bad but it also wasn’t something I sought to engage with constantly. But the environments, the first act’s level design, the dungeon designs in acts 2 and 3, phenomenal! I don’t think I’ve played a better example of a “discount immersive sim” up until this game. And while MachineGames could maybe sharpen some of the harsh edges in the script next time, the story was pretty good with really enjoyable characters all around.</p><p>I’d gladly play a game half this length with two or three densely explorable areas that require playing it stealthy until you can find disguises to creep deeper and deeper into zones, with the fulfillment of that exploration being more and more puzzles in the process. I think there’s not too many scenarios where an Indian Jones game exists <em>without</em> combat but the fact that engaging in it felt like such an afterthought to me just demonstrates how strong MachineGames nailed the other aspects of this title’s gameplay.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*m-zZRSx01w_o6rWr" /></figure><h4>Chicken Police: Paint it RED!</h4><p>Point and click adventure games (for me) have always been an eternally shifting genre in my memories that only shift more as time goes on. I think this is because it’s a genre that was mostly declared “dead” by the time I started playing games more regularly in my life (late 90s). I missed out on the P’n’C’A heydeys of Monkey Island and Day of the Tentacle. Grim Fandango was constantly on my mental radar but I never actually played the full game that wasn’t just the demo until a decade or so later. Between those points in time I had played the two seasons of Sam &amp; Max from Telltale. I watched the genre morph into something else with the release of Telltale’s The Walking Dead and Life is Strange. And then when I could finally replay the oldies through remasters in the 10’s, I found myself critically disengaged from the narratives because the mechanics were so divorced from the story at times. I <strong><em>loathe</em></strong><em> </em>admitting that my attention span for those mechanics that made games worth their investment in terms of time is…not good. I ran into similar problems playing Resident Evil Remake last year and finishing it this year: I loved exploring but I hit a point where I didn’t want to figure out what to do in a game that barely explained any of your next moves. This sort of play conditioning from modern game trends that have quest trackers, maps, or a set linearity have eroded the wiggle room of enjoyment for people like me who enjoy games truly made in the style of the originals where the fun was in rubbing every item in your pockets up against anything the player could investigate. Games like Outer Wilds have perfect solutions to these problems.</p><p>Maybe that’s why Chicken Police is something I liked so very much. It hits all the right buttons of the old genre tropes (observe, click to observe actions, talk to character actions) without streamlining your objectives too hard or opening up the actions too much. It’s a point and click “visual novel” in many ways and this feels like a really great balance of how to do a game like this. The visual noir style, the full commitment to the silly aspects of its dialogue with earnestness, the unwavering dedication to its world and lore, these all sculpt exactly the type of response out of me I always expected from the 90s point and click adventure games: I couldn’t put this sucker down for three nights.</p><p>And it’s not that short! I think if players were a little less thorough than I was and only observed everything once, spoke to everyone once per chapter, the game would still probably take you about 6–9 hours to complete. With explorations and exhausting the dialogue but still skipping some lines because, let’s be real, some of it is beautifully-written fluff as a detective fiction piece, it still took me around 12–14 hours or so to beat. For a game that feels like a part of an episodic series or anthology, Chicken Police: Paint it RED! is actually a really good value. I was honestly anticipating a 4–6 hour game and walked away with a complete experience. I do feel like the game let some narrative threads draw out only in the way Sonny &amp; Marty were going to realize. Writing dynamic discovery of facts and conclusions to align with the player is <em>tough. </em>This game will make you realize how Disco Elysium is a high-wire act of insanity, even if it were heavily reduced to just the main case, with the way it enables the players to figure things out. I found myself figuring out the mystery at the center of it nearly a full act early and was a little tired waiting for the main character to catch up with me. But that didn’t make talking to the game’s new characters introduced afterwards any less interesting. And that’s all thanks to this game’s utter devotion to its unique setting. I want more conversations with the hummingbird receptionist of the Clawville Police Department. I want to ask Filmar Low more questions about his private detective investigations. I want to talk to the night owl under-the-table-doctor that’s well past his wingspan in this life treating ruffians instead of opening a private practice so he can settle down with his bear of a wife (that’s not a metaphor, the owl and bear are married). The anthropomorphic style is <em>odd</em> but works well enough for permitting the unique “animal kingdom” setting that has sort of cross-species relationships that create conversations of their own. Predators and prey together cohabitating in a world that’s been wrong for so long there’s no conversation about when it was <em>good, </em>just what’s driving it worse right now compared to yesterday.</p><p>The real stunner though was the credits. At the start of it, the credits list a variety of species that weren’t present in the game. And then goes on to explain that the reason they weren’t here in the game is because they’ve gone extinct over the game’s dev cycle, emphasizing the needless nature of these extinctions. Suddenly the game’s visual character design and thematic noir overtones felt like a backdrop to a much more grim world we face in our present. These types of games have always existed but I think it’s fitting I’m experiencing games like this a little more frequently in this day and age. Art is being built in adverse times and places and it’s important that the art we experience every now and then remind us that our forays into worlds unknown don’t eternally put those problems on the backburner. You don’t have to stop eating meat and become an animal rights activist, nor do the credits imply you should, but they do serve as a reminder of our world’s problems the same way finishing Sherlock Holmes: The Awakened did for me back in 2024 and how those problems in turn inform or impact the art we love.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*hEiuClGBcEfGI6Y7.jpg" /></figure><h4>Killer Frequency</h4><p>I don’t think I have too much to say about this one. It’s good, the story and baseline mechanics are enjoyable and have their fun. It’s a unique setup: You play a radio host whose late night show finds itself being the go-to “9–1–1” line in a small town on the night of a serial killer’s return. The things you can do “for fun” or to pass the time during dialogue in your studio gets a little monotonous but that feels almost appropriate for the setting of being a radio show host. I just kind of wish the game had its own built-in “mystery board” that you could always have setup. Within a couple hours you’ll be feeling the edges of this game’s mechanics and loops so much so that you’ll almost be begging to be let out of your booth to explore before conversations even end. It’s also worth stating games like this, while very difficult to develop in it, would <strong>thrive </strong>in VR. It’s got exactly the sort of “safe railroads” design that means the game will manage to be thrilling and immersive in its interactivity and choice designs while not requiring the sort of twitchy responsiveness that would lead to regular failure states that’s a little bothersome in VR. It’s also got the same “Gone Home”, “Firewatch”, “you can poke around with some office space physics” design well suited for VR where it’s all about touching things and minimal quick responsiveness. Good time. I’d recommend it.</p><h4>Venba</h4><p>Oh my gosh Venba! I spent a lot of 2023 playing games I didn’t get the chance to play in 2022 due to hardware limits and just generally getting parts of my life together. Had I been a bit more “caught up” in 2023 I would’ve maybe bought Venba and found myself struggling to decide whether I love Lies of P or this game more. It’s <em>that good</em>. That “so good we’re capable of comparing it to some of the most delightful mechanically satisfying souls-likes built in a hot minute” type of experience. The same way Mouthwashing has layers of depth and perspectives to consider and critique, Venba is something <em>remarkable</em>. I feel like if I did a quick search I’d find a lot of really great perspectives on Venba with ease, ones better than mine. It’s a game with some really specific topics that mean I, a white guy whose family has been in his country for I think four generations, don’t have much perspective to offer on one of the game’s core topics (first generation immigrant experiences). But I <em>can</em> comment on two things. I’d recommend just skipping and playing to avoid some spoiler talk below. It’s short (like less than two hours short), inexpensive, and beautiful.</p><p>1) The mechanical progression and artistic support of cooking over the years blew me away. I haven’t seen this in a video game before like this. There’s similar things in Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, for example, but not when it comes to <em>cooking </em>in particular. The fact that Venba (the character) lays things out in a fairly organized fashion and is comfortable in the kitchen but still has to recall how to make dishes from memory holds importance at the start of the game. She’s gaining confidence in being a parent. Later on in the game’s emotional low-point when Venba makes the feast for her son, we don’t even have to follow instructions because Venba’s been cooking for her family for so long she doesn’t need directions anymore. It’s as natural as breathing. And yet, in that sequence, Venba’s physical actions are a bit more drawn out. Dropping oils or batters into dishes, lifting lids, breaking herbs up, these all take her a little longer, no doubt just the experience of getting a little older and slowing down a little.</p><p>In making so many dishes for Kavin, there’s even a pause where the camera cuts to show Venba wiping her brow. Cooking is <strong><em>work</em></strong>. It can take a lot of time to stand, prepare, and wait and cut and wash and pull out ingredients and put them away, all of it with so many items at once can take hours. And then afterwards when Kavin goes to do his own cooking, he’s even more lost than his mother ever was (in an aching metaphorical way). There’s the cultural aspect where he didn’t keep up his Tamil well over the years and then past that even as he lays out items or uses them he carelessly lets them fall over, sets them aside without much concern for where things are going or if they spill at all. Classic chaotic 20’s mode. Then there’s the details. The slight additional weathering of the hardware that’s now been passed down to him one or two generations in a row is a beautiful visualization of how we carry the people of our past with us. He’s cooking with hardware, books, and food that are his history, cultural or familial.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*1McvSJFEPmh4Yn4V" /></figure><p>And then there’s 2): Cooking, love, relationships. I think this game just generally speaks to people who love cooking and so by association, it hits me right in the feels. Food is one of those <em>mostly</em> universal human experiences that demonstrate connections. At the start of the game, Venba makes it clear to Paavalan, her husband, that him having a negative attitude towards cooking as something <em>unnecessary to learn</em> will impact more than just him, but her, and their marriage. By not cooking a simple meal for himself ahead of time so he can take lunch to work, there won’t be lunch for his sick wife either. It makes Venba feel like she doesn’t have an option but to cook while she’s sick because her husband isn’t interested in learning how to cook even simple dishes. He takes this emotional lesson from Venba well and participates in cooking later in the game. Later, Kavin’s abandonment of his culture means in many ways often abandoning his own mother. He undergoes complex cultural shame and erasure. It’s a weighty subject matter that I’ll let the game do the talking on. But even the game’s more loose dialogues surrounding this subject matter hits so well. After a conversation where Venba talks to Paavalan about her fears surrounding Kavin’s cultural struggles, Paavalan considers to Venba if they made the right decision raising Kavin in Canada. Venba says “I have Kavin. And I have you. Home is where you two are.” This is <em>after</em> Kavin has had his big storm-out moment with his parents as he departed for college, opting to abandon his culture as much as possible to fit in with those around him outside of home. It makes the unexpected loss of Paavalan and the fact that Kavin doesn’t come home for the big dinner all the more gut wrenching on a second play.</p><p>When I was in my 20s, I was once driving around with dad and the conversation of cooking came up. My dad’s cooking was loved by many and I asked him why he went into computer work instead of cooking if he was so good at it. He had chosen the self-employed life after a layoff in his 40s so he <em>could’ve</em> gone for cooking. And he told me he only ever wanted to cook for people he loves. From then on, I understood that someone preparing you food was <strong>special</strong>. For Venba to have that experience so tarnished by her own son was devastating for me. The phone text messages you can read make it clear Kavin doesn’t hate his mother. The love is there, but it’s so clear the shame he felt in his childhood creates a distance between them that can only be solved by Kavin finding his way to balance his history and his present. And he starts that by doing what no one in the story had done yet: Cooked for Venba. After Venba teaches Kavin how to make Dosa, he offers her to eat what he made while it’s still warm and he’ll cook more for himself. At first she counters this, saying his food will get cold but he expresses Venba would just experience the same thing if he ate what’s there already. This completes the flip of making the “narrative dosa” that is Venba. At the start, Venba, newly pregnant, dealing with sickness, has to make lunch for her and her husband because he’s adverse to cooking. The son they have together avoids her food out of shame for his culture and won’t embrace it. Kavin, years later, cooks a meal for his mother and embraces the food and culture he ran from in the years before. Venba, for once, gets to just sit and enjoy a meal made by someone who loves her. As Venba simply concludes at the end, “…this is very nice.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Tzt0Pnz7Ljy7rfvE" /></figure><h4>Lies of P: Overture</h4><p>Those magnificent developers. Lies of P: Overture has jettisoned this game into the stratosphere for me. And it’s not by nature of being <em>perfect</em> because it’s not. Most seem to agree the bosses in this one go a little too far sometimes. Then again many felt that way in the base game too. The “Sekiro” nature of this game and the DLC is daunting and extra-challenging if you go the dexterity route. So why am I calling Round8 Studio magnificent and worthy of such praise with the arrival of this DLC? Well. It’s because this time around it feels like Round8 is pointing directly at the competition and daring them to up their game. That’s some mighty high horses considering A) Round8 has only made one game so far (Lies of P) and B) the competition is <strong><em>FromSoft</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p>Joseph Anderson made some brilliant implications in his review of Shadow of the Erdtree that FromSoft is probably next on the chopping block of developers whose name we heavily respected right up until they started getting too big for their britches and started becoming a joke of a name synonymous with that way we think of “Bethesda”. Lies of P: Overture at times literally feels like Round8 were making a good standard “Bloodborne/Sekiro”-like DLC (much of the DLC’s plot and lore mirror that of the Bloodborne DLC “The Old Hunters”) but then certain parts feel clear Round8’s team played “Shadow of the Erdtree”, watched Joseph Anderson’s videos, and said “What if we actually just kept improving on things From should’ve been adding to their games as QoL features this whole time? What if we look at some of the <strong>worst</strong> things going on in the latest FromSoft action RPG and manage to pull it off without any issues?” Because they do it. Lies of P: Overture added easy modes that don’t interfere with normal difficulty. They added boss rematches from your safe zone menu and you can fight them at different difficulties unlocked. For most of Lies of P’s runtime you’ll go through boss fights and realize that the camera is <strong>expertly programmed</strong> because you so rarely have camera issues compared to a FromSoft title. And so in Lies of P: Overture one of the first major fights is a duo-fight that is hands down the best duo boss fight design in any Souls-like I’ve seen. And then if that didn’t feel like enough of a call out against FromSoft (after already experiencing The Black Rabbit Brotherhood in the base game), then you’ll get to the half-way boss fight where Round8 Studio tries their hand at the largest monster boss fight they’ve done yet and <strong>it has bright golden light attacks that flash on the screen with an AOE you need to run out of and it feels balanced completely fairly. </strong>If you played Shadow of the Erdtree you’ll know from what I’ve just said that Round8 has tried to directly compete with Shadow of the Erdtree’s final boss, a boss design that FromSoft actually wound up nerfing less than a month out from launch because it was kind of impossible to handle a few attacks at all.</p><p>I recognize the developer has chosen some specific limits that make this a slightly unfair comparison. For starters, Elden Ring/Dark Souls support a much wider build variety than Lies of P but the obscene boss fights often struggle against that design principle. Lies of P has three primary builds with supportive elements and weapon designs holding up those builds through varietal expression. Elden Ring/Dark Souls have a deep, albeit often busted, multiplayer system. Lies of P doesn’t have one at all, you can summon bot helpers for <em>some</em> boss fights and that’s it. So in some ways Round8 has it easier on designing these fights. And yet I still can’t help but think to myself that of the four Souls-like games I’ve played in the past three years (Elden Ring, Shadow, Lies of P, and Overture), Round8 comes out on top <em>twice</em>. That’s definitely some preference and bias showing, but Elden Ring felt like a Dark Souls expanded into a Breath of the Wild while Lies of P and Oveture felt like FromSoft went and did their homework for a change rather than just continuing to follow Miyazaki’s design principals. I look forward to the crazy ideas FromSoft is going to put out into the ether in the coming years (especially from other directors), but it’d be disingenuous of me to not give the high praise Round8 Studio has earned for finding ways to improve on recurring fatal flaws FromSoft keeps choosing to double down on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*x1CDjpNx3gnYb8-_.jpg" /></figure><h4>Tunic</h4><p>I think I experienced Tunic in the best way possible. I played something like 8–10 hours of the game last year, getting through one of the three major bosses and then set it down probably around the time Shadow of the Erdtree dropped. Never getting back to it, I returned to it this year during some down time between major releases. This was a great idea and I found myself starting a new save because I knew I’d struggle to remember how the world works with all of its hidden secrets in the game’s built-in manual. For context: The game slowly reveals to you how to play it through manual pages you find scattered around the game world. As you find pages you’ll either be helped along with tutorials of basic mechanics or larger guide pieces such as a zone map or a kind of “area guide” that tells you what to look out for with certain enemies. That is until you find the guide reveals mechanics to things you’ve seen five times already and you just didn’t know how to interact with them and you realize you could’ve used those mechanics all along. Tunic is a genuinely fun video game of exploration and discovery that also can blur from your mind if you let it.</p><p>I reached what felt like near the end of the game and I was given a cool twist surprise that I still had about another 25% of main game to experience and so I got started on that, got another 10–15% through that extra game that was left and then Lies of P: Overture shadow-dropped on me.</p><p>A month later after beating the Lies of P DLC, I returned to Tunic, aware of more or less where I was with the game but unsure of what was <em>left to do. </em>This led me to just seeking out the game’s most straightforward ending, which I was aware was a sort of DS1 “bad ending” and then I proceeded to do the digging necessary to unlock the “good ending”. This good ending work involves making sense of a few key puzzles around you in the world followed by one last major puzzle called “The Golden Path”. I won’t spoil it obviously but needless to say spending a month away from Tunic only to come back near the very end and then have that very end be “The Golden Path” was one of the coolest video game experiences I’ve had since the “E” ending in Nier: Automata. It’s not quite <em>on that level</em> but it is particularly mind blowing in a way that had me delving through YouTube for the <strong>secret secret </strong>“puzzle nerd” ending and deep dives available to players. It’s absolutely wild the depth of the secrets in this game and I really hope Tunic’s creator Andrew doesn’t feel the need to overdo it next game. Because Tunic is so good at this, trying to replicate this or top it would be a challenge. I think if I were to play Tunic without a month-long interruption the game’s core gameplay hiccups would weigh on me more. Using the inventory with combat is really janky. The lock-on system is just <em>okay</em>. There’s some frustrations with the combat and how <em>some things like charms</em> never really find a solid explanation unless you do some crazy experimenting or search the internet. But that’s not the Tunic I experienced. And as a game trying to replicate a really particular joy that Andrew experienced playing games in a certain way when he was younger, let’s just say I’m grateful to have returned to Tunic for that last little chunk. It’s incredible.</p><h4>Genesis: Noir</h4><p>A strange and beautiful work of vibes and interactive tinkering. I had seen pictures and trailers of this game and then at PAX East 2024 I played a demo of the follow-up: Nirvana: Noir. That demo actually gave me a false impression of what Genesis: Noir was going to be. Wheras Nirvana: Noir appears to be a more straightforward experience of storytelling for the genre, Genesis is an almost dialogue-free interactive piece of art. It’s a jazzy interpretation and meditation on the creation of our world, history, and at times celebrates all that we’ve been. It’s a game best served with lower expectations and instead you need to let it all wash over you. There’s beautiful experiences across the game involving music that are touching and incredible, but you’ll find yourself impatient with them if you think there’s a wider format of the game beyond what you experience in that first hour or two. It’s got variety, but Genesis: Noir is a story told in images and feelings almost exclusively.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Bs5Iva5ZvlzbgPZn.jpg" /></figure><h4>Stasis: Bone Totem</h4><p>Here I set off for a series of underwater horrors in video games. A trilogy, if you will.</p><p>This is a dark, disturbing point and click adventure game set in a sci-fi reality not too far from what you can imagine in the Alien films. Instead of space like the first Stasis game, Bone Totem is set deep in the ocean. Bone Totem retains more of the frustrations of the genre every now and then (puzzles) but structures them in a way that’s way more helpful than predecessors. It also brings unique mechanics to the board with a quantum device that lets you send items to other characters and those characters have unique abilities such as combining or breaking down items into other components. It’s a neat concept and given some decent legs from a design perspective. It could use some support with more help prompts, but there’s far worse games out there with this genre.</p><p>There’s also a really cool mechanic in the game inspired by Disco Elysium’s “right click” that shows you all the interactable and visually-relevant things on screen. I like this since they decided to not constantly shine or outline these things in the game. But I have two minor gripes about it. 1) it goes away after a few seconds instead of letting you just toggle it on/off or hold for it. So you’re constantly refreshing it in frustration. 2) The visuals on their own. There’s a lot of objects in the game that have writing that describe what you see, but the game is already beautifully rendering most of the things you’re being shown. It’s overall unnecessary. It seems the developer wanted writing as expressive and descriptive of a world in the way Disco Elysium did, and it has that sort of “narrator breakdown” of things you’re seeing, but what the developer didn’t grasp is that in Disco Elysium the writing reinforced a textual painting of a country and a world beyond the immediate for a character with amnesia who needed to grasp it all. In Bone Totem, writing on that level mostly happens during one large expositional staircase, and it’s REALLY GOOD, and actually supported by characters that explain things. It’s just that the visuals and <em>visual design </em>of this game do so much heavy lifting that the amount of flavor text writing actually doesn’t supplement it much. It’s also worth noting that the voice actors here are doing <strong>superb </strong>work.</p><p>Overall, I’d recommend it if this seems like your cup of tea. It’s pretty horrific and I’d recommend not reading every “mouse over” description you see as they start getting wordy. But it’s hard to find adventure games like this one that remain true to the formula, go new places, and thread the needle well.</p><h4>Dredge</h4><p>This was a fantastic palette cleanser of a game for me. I could grind my way into oblivion trying to do everything in the game, find all the entries, optimize everything about my daily loop and boat and tools. And it’d be so easy to get stuck in that mindset because this game has <em>the most satisfying loops</em> I’ve ever experienced. Daily cycles are FAST, maybe less than five minutes of active gameplay. But then again, mini games where you fish or try to get resources are ALSO fast. It’s an impressive <em>hook </em>of a game design principle and a favorite quick burn when I had only an hour or less before I needed to go do something else. Wanting to not get too lost in the mire of everything this game has to offer, I decided to just mainline the story at a certain point. I explored each zone pretty well but left most of the mysteries unresolved. The game has a pretty impressive “wait <em>what</em>?” as a reveal at the end of it all if you play it this way. And I was honestly expecting more incentive to go fishing at night and to deal with the sanity mechanics. Instead I mostly avoided night out of general concern for losing stuff. But regardless, an incredibly easy game to pick up and enjoy. I’ve never felt an enjoyable “production” loop be more simplified with such expert design.</p><h4>Still Wakes the Deep</h4><p>Completing my foray into the underwater horrors, I decided I’d knock out Still Wakes the Deep while I was at it. I think with the recent release of Vampire: The Masquerade 2, thechineseroom are starting to be recognized as a unique developer in the industry. On the one hand, they seem to be capable of taking a tight production deadline and cranking out <em>something</em> worthy of critical discussion that’s passable to play and not a train wreck of code failures and feature creep (V:TM2, Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs). Even if those titles aren’t critically lauded today, their short schedules are leaving people impressed now with what’s there and working well. When this isn’t the criticism, the positive things said are in the realm of the genre they tackle to begin with. Dear Esther was either “overly pretentious” or a intriguing beginning to the “walking sim” genre. And “Everyone’s Gone to the Rapture” was considered the same but people had more widely adopted the walking sim genre by that time and most really liked it. Meanwhile “Still Wakes the Deep” feels like it has ventured into an improved version of thechineseroom making “an Amnesia-like”. A first person horror survival game. There’d be another one of these I played this year that was much more heavily anticipated by me. But I think Still Wakes the Deep merits attention too because it’s, for me, maybe my favorite of theirs I’ve played now. A dreadful experience of a game taking hints from John Carpenter’s <em>The Thing </em>and mixing them with explorations of the dangers of working on oil rigs. <a href="https://youtu.be/AsKeFp5-rnI">RagnaRox</a> and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63OqrjbT5M0">Casey Explosion</a> both have phenomenal videos covering the game if you want to get a little deeper on it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*fsEFRMoUywjpsYUb.jpg" /></figure><h4>The Last Case of Benedict Fox</h4><p>Silksong? Nah. Don’t get me wrong, I plan on playing it. But it seems like the devs are still making additions, balance patches, and changes to the game itself (a DLC got announced, lol). On top of that, the critical conversation around Silksong seems to <em>roughly </em>agree that you’ll have an easier time with Silksong if you play it right after Hollow Knight in terms of mechanics and skills. Thing is, I played Hollow Knight twice already. And it’s been a pretty active year in games. So I’ll wait. The “quick and easy” metroidvania itch was there shortly after beating Breath of the Wild though so I started this one. This is the fourth game by Plot Twist, a Polish developer that has mostly stuck to more arcade-like experiences ranging from top down action party games to a drift-focused car game. So the shift to a moody metroidvania game with a Lovecraftian wrapper around it is <em>quite the ambitious shift</em> for a team of 30 people. I won’t recommend you buy this one at sticker price unless you’re a die hard of the genre (but if you are, you probably already know about it). But it’s <em>constantly</em> going on sale for much more reasonable prices and if you think the art style is something you’d want to wade around in for about 15 hours, this is a pretty good choice.</p><p>The Last Case of Benedict Fox is maybe the first “eurojank” metroidvania I’ve put significant time into. It really lives up to that description with some odd control schemes, and a range of issues that most would chalk up to “not enough polish”. In the US, when games aren’t polished the massive complaint is bugs, but for eurojank it tends to be more about the ways in which designs are done or considerations aren’t made about something that get overlooked and ultimately make for a unique experience. In this game’s case, the rough edges are the lackluster combat mechanics, a few puzzles near the 25% mark that felt <em>really confusing</em> until something became really clear (text wasn’t really discernible enough on a wall of text), control schemes that feel weird, a couple subtitle bugs near the end, really bad volume mixing (there’s 5 audio logs in the game to find, and they’re all about 60% quieter than the game itself, music feels even quieter honestly), and maybe the worst one of all: What feels like a memory leak bug. This one technically isn’t <em>that bad</em> since it fixes on quitting and relaunching a game that takes very little time to load, but it seems to be a result of playing long enough and doing enough quick travel or menu opens, which will happen a lot as the game doesn’t have a HUD-based map for you without pausing the action. It gets tedious to explore and that tedium will start crawling the game in what will feel like literal frame issues. That’s your sign to save, quit, relaunch, or maybe step away for a bit.</p><p>And yet, I liked this game! The story is pretty basic, Benedict Fox, a begrudging member of a secret order that studies occult objects, has found evidence of where to find his estranged father. Benedict has a sort of cthulhu-like-attachment to his mind or soul. Upon finding the house of his parents, he finds his father dead and a mystery to unravel behind why his parents were absent from his life. This isn’t the normal type of subject matter for a Lovecraft, but it works pretty well as a form of diving into psychological storytelling. I’ll say Benedict himself is a little underdeveloped compared to his parents across the game, voice acting is also at times quite <em>stilted</em> but it’s enough for me to get through the at times bland combat. The game struggles to feel engaging maybe for that first 20% (it’s not the best tutorial you’ll experience) but then you start acquiring puzzle items that you use across the game. I gotta say I could play an entire game with these puzzle mechanics expanded and deepened with a de-emphasis on the combat. I know that’s not what most metroidvania fans would expect, and that’s fair. But Plot Twist may have found a different strength that they didn’t realize was so well done. Just work on the polish, the teaching some mechanics more, and a puzzler video game in this setting would be a blast.</p><p>I definitely enjoyed my time playing this one, but less because of the things we tend to look for in the genre. You’ll have to squint through the production value issues here and dig for something worthwhile. But it’s <em>regularly</em> on sales down to about $5–10, and I’d say that’s not a terrible cost for something like this.</p><h4>Alan Wake 2</h4><p>Remedy is maybe the most unique developer building games in this industry right now at the higher budget level. And yet understanding why requires some process of elimination. It’s <strong>not </strong>that Alan Wake 2 is tapping a unique genre, this is a survival horror. Alan Wake <strong>isn’t</strong> some household name franchise, it was a game released late in the 7th console generation, it had some DLC and then it went away. This <strong>wasn’t</strong> a smash hit like Halo. Instead, it’s the way Remedy approach genre and making a sequel that has felt like an anathema to every conversation on big budget video games. Many modern successful AAA titles like God of War or the Horizon series stick to common standards while feeling overblown, and yet people still buy them in droves and seem to like them. Meanwhile Remedy pushes those molds to chase their own storytelling ideas in ways most people I talk to kind of hate. I feel at times the average person plays games for the mechanics. Mechanics and design are king. And I don’t blame them for it. Maybe that’s part of the trick: Remedy don’t forget to make some kinetically satisfying experiences from time to time and when they’re doing their usual storycraft with FMVs and embedded media shorts they also make sure it’s at least entertaining or manages to be something you’ve never visually seen before. Alan Wake 2 has some of the most impressive couplings of fidelity and aesthetics we’ve ever seen in video games and there’s literal song and dance numbers in their more recent games; marriages of progressive rock and gameplay in wonderful synchronicity. Maybe Remedy knows better than most other AAA developers that this is a video game and we’re allowed to have some fun.</p><p>As time goes on and the stories of how Remedy games come about are revealed, Alan Wake 2 only feels more miraculous that it landed the way it did when so much of what’s there was planned in another fashion years back and then more or less canned or tucked away for another day. It’s hard to tell how much is planned one game to the next. There’s a chance the painted background details are retroactively fit into the woven tapestry of Remedy’s fiction and we just don’t get the whole story of it here and there and that makes Sam Lake &amp; Company look like geniuses who dreamt all this stuff up a twenty years ago. Or maybe they really are geniuses who’ve managed to get recognized for their special knack for a video game.</p><p>What I do know is that finally getting around to Alan Wake 2 was a good time. It’s exactly up my alley and while I’m confident it’s one of my favorite games from 2023, I don’t necessarily have too much to say about it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*dMwBie7kr3PBtMJl.jpg" /></figure><p><em>The Lake House DLC on the other hand…</em>phenomenal. It takes the A+ experience of Alan Wake 2 and boils down into 3 hours a cutthroat game that left me boggled at its implications, personal touches, and horribly creepy vibes. In the strata of Remedy games I’ve played now, Control and the Lake House are practically tied at the top. It’s <em>that good</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Db44bnD8rEQBDMeN" /></figure><h4>Routine</h4><p>We all know what happens when a big budget video game goes through a long development cycle, is delayed several times over, and is hyped up by its fans as this really special thing that is going to be a unique experience. Success in the end is likely. It might come over time. But there’ll be almost assuredly a mad mob of angry people that the game wasn’t the Second Coming of Jesus.</p><p>So what happens when the game <em>isn’t</em> big budget? When it’s not marketed <em>that </em>widely over tons of social media? When all the hype is mostly built up by early previews and literally just three videos from a decade back when the game was in its early phases and looked promising and people who thought it’d be exactly their type of game waited around for that game to eventually release? We’re talking about a low budget indie game that just took a <strong>really </strong>long time to come out. An Amnesia game in space, basically. What would playing that game, 13 years after initial previews, feel like?</p><p>It’s kind of the best Christmas present to, I’m guessing, about 10,000 people. Routine hasn’t changed the industry. It won’t. It’s not destined to. Instead, it’ll change <em>you</em>. In ways, Routine’s storyline is really straightforward and not too deep: A space station on the moon went really wrong. With its 2001: A Space Odyssey meets Alien influences you can imagine the storyline going two or four directions and that’ll be it. There’s robots and a rogue AI and stealth and really well done diegetic mechanics. You can see how refined the mechanics and visuals became when you compare this game to its earliest videos so long ago. The camera is <strong>so much</strong> more stable. There’s a much more defined <em>vibe</em> by really leaning into the 80s aesthetic. It’s good! Years of patience paid off in a satisfying game, it’s what we hoped for given the grounding of the reality that three people struggled to make this thing for over a decade.</p><p>So what makes it change you?</p><p>I won’t spoil too much but there’s a shift half way through the game where we get a much creepier, older horrific vibe in the game and it’s unspeakably gripping. That’s what might be this game’s silver bullet: How much this game grips you while not holding your hand through the experiences. The <em>lack </em>of public media to show for this game before it launched winds up being its biggest helper in an experience you can kind of predict but don’t necessarily know how it’ll run from start to end. That sensation these days is hard to come by in horror. My jaw was dropping at one point. I literally didn’t know where I was anymore or how I got there. I had to message my friend and just say “Man. This game!”</p><p>It’s also an experience where the sound design just <strong>kills it. </strong>It turns out Mick Gordon was a long time friend of the developer and aided a lot of the game’s sound and music up until last year. The basslines are filled with high pitched glitches you hear from the Type 05’s as they scan areas looking for you. Doors have several layers of ka-chunks and whirs and hisses opening and closing. The visual/audio experience of the ASN core is unforgettable from beginning to end. Routine is best experienced like an Amnesia game: Lights off. Headphones on. No other distractions. If you can stomach it. Unlike Amnesia, it’s not the journals and active story and slow descent into madness that’ll make you scared when a brick falls from a shelf. Routine disturbs you because that space display of a rotating moon in the middle of a mall is scraping against its enclosure and the sound of your own footsteps can be mistaken for the pitter patter of something behind the paneling nearby. Space is a hostile void. The void is scary.</p><p>Routine’s lunar base is pretty empty. You can tell it was intended for larger populations than any hints of what actually wound up inhabiting its spaces. The same goes for the scale and population of the game’s player base too. I’m sure Lunar Software hoped to release this game earlier in its dev cycle when more eyes were freshly on it and the sort of genre the game is was more popular (first person survival horror) and they had a lot more in the game as they added more and more to it before they cut stuff. And that’s maybe so important a lesson here to every perfectly filled cup that is a video game beverage. In big budget video games, we’re almost terrified of the surface tension breaking, the map getting bigger than before and more game showing itself that demands more time, more attention, more gameplay to go before rolling credits; the liquid spills over the limits of the cup and onto your desk. It gets messy. Routine’s occasional sense of emptiness is scary to experience. The sense of isolation is off the charts, even more than a Frictional game. By having less in it, you feel what’s there more than in most other games. Every scrap is important. Every carefully placed piece of sound pulls you inwards to its secret at the center. But it’s also a scary cup to drink from in general because Lunar Software put a half-full cup in front of you and said “Drink” and you’ve got hydrophobia. It’s just plain scary anyways.</p><p>I applaud Raw Fury for encouraging this team to finish this game. And I applaud Lunar Software for making sure I remembered this feeling. For some, it’ll be a new sensation. For those people, don’t run away. Embrace it.</p><h4>S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2: Heart of Chernobyl (concluded)</h4><p>̶I̶ ̶f̶e̶e̶l̶ ̶b̶a̶d̶ ̶a̶b̶o̶u̶t̶ ̶t̶h̶i̶s̶ ̶o̶n̶e̶.̶ ̶I̶ ̶h̶a̶d̶ ̶e̶v̶e̶r̶y̶ ̶i̶n̶t̶e̶n̶t̶ ̶t̶o̶ ̶b̶e̶a̶t̶ ̶S̶.̶T̶.̶A̶.̶L̶.̶K̶.̶E̶.̶R̶ ̶2̶:̶ ̶H̶e̶a̶r̶t̶ ̶o̶f̶ ̶C̶h̶e̶r̶n̶o̶b̶y̶l̶ ̶t̶h̶i̶s̶ ̶y̶e̶a̶r̶.̶ ̶I̶’̶m̶,̶ ̶s̶e̶e̶m̶i̶n̶g̶l̶y̶,̶ ̶q̶u̶i̶t̶e̶ ̶c̶l̶o̶s̶e̶.̶ ̶I̶f̶ ̶m̶a̶j̶o̶r̶ ̶p̶l̶o̶t̶ ̶q̶u̶e̶s̶t̶ ̶i̶n̶d̶i̶c̶a̶t̶o̶r̶s̶ ̶a̶r̶e̶ ̶a̶n̶y̶t̶h̶i̶n̶g̶ ̶t̶o̶ ̶g̶o̶ ̶b̶y̶,̶ ̶I̶’̶m̶ ̶i̶n̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶l̶a̶s̶t̶ ̶1̶5̶%̶ ̶o̶f̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶g̶a̶m̶e̶’̶s̶ ̶s̶t̶o̶r̶y̶.̶ ̶A̶n̶d̶ ̶I̶ ̶d̶o̶n̶’̶t̶ ̶w̶a̶n̶t̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶f̶a̶c̶t̶ ̶t̶h̶a̶t̶ ̶I̶ ̶h̶a̶v̶e̶n̶’̶t̶ ̶b̶e̶a̶t̶e̶n̶ ̶t̶h̶i̶s̶ ̶g̶a̶m̶e̶ ̶t̶o̶ ̶s̶w̶a̶y̶ ̶y̶o̶u̶ ̶a̶w̶a̶y̶ ̶f̶r̶o̶m̶ ̶m̶a̶y̶b̶e̶ ̶p̶u̶r̶c̶h̶a̶s̶i̶n̶g̶ ̶i̶t̶ ̶a̶n̶d̶ ̶e̶x̶p̶e̶r̶i̶e̶n̶c̶i̶n̶g̶ ̶i̶t̶ ̶f̶o̶r̶ ̶y̶o̶u̶r̶s̶e̶l̶f̶.̶</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eRwy0dmDtOkPuf6QdAaK6g.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7pQbMI_cMmeqxLJNBvyJ2A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Edit: Since my last edits on this article, I have since finished the game. What I have to say below still stands, basically. Glad I got it done before 2026.</p><p>The STALKER franchise disappeared after Call of Pripyat in 2010, it’s influence living on in variations on the Eastern-European-Apocalypse-Shooters like the Metro series or Escape from Tarkov or STALKER-mod-turned-solo-game Misery. Naturally, for STALKER to return 14 years later in “Heart of Chernobyl” isn’t too far flung an opportunity for new audiences the way Routine released; or more appropriately the way Witcher 3 released (a game trying to exist for both its own legacy as a sequel and the many newcomers). STALKER and its two standalone expansion packs Clear Sky and Call of Pripyat, in many ways, live on inside STALKER 2. The locations are there, expanded outwards and embedded into one of the largest world maps I’ve touched in a few years. The vibes of a broken world groaning in existence and shifting under your feet haven’t really left this series yet, in fact the updates GSC have added over the past year have only improved the more dynamic sensations at play. You don’t quite experience the buggy “sudden spawning not too far from you” problem as constantly that I encountered quite a bit in the first four or five months of playing the game. (<em>Edit</em>: However it is a bit of a problem during railroaded sequences near the end) Instead they’ve tweaked the original game’s well known “A-life” to allow for some of those more dynamic experiences that made the original so special and brought back NPC behaviors like looting that helped push STALKER ahead of its time in 2007. It’s hard to realize in retrospect just how much that game was managing to be ahead of the curve back then. But when you compare STALKER to games like Fallout or Far Cry 2, STALKER 1 did some really unique things.</p><p>Further improvements include balances that at first I was worried about but now feel were the right call; stuff like what’s available at loot, how much things cost, slight changes to your inventory UI so you can better comprehend how artifacts are affecting your body or more easily comprehend stat differences in weapons and armor with degradation vs. others in your inventory. You can now harvest beast parts from the monstrous mutated creatures you fight and sell them for a decent price to vendors. Vendors rotate what they sell more regularly, which can make hunting for a pair of night-vision goggles annoying but at the same time the game launched day 1 without the goggles and thus all dark sequences are balanced right for using your flashlight in the fights. The goggles just give you an advantage. It’s hard to say the lack of these things (aside from the A-life improvements) made STALKER 2 an <em>incomplete </em>game but a routine experience for open world creations today is considering there’s more that can be done to give players a reason to return or buy the game. It certainly worked for me. Seeing some updates release that added new anomalies made me want to load up the game and see them in action. And even today as I edit this, GSC have just added a new side quest that’s about five hours long and adds a permanent hub in the game world <em>exactly</em> where I wish I had one from my last few sessions. All in all, there’s reasons to go back if you didn’t finish this the same way I put this game on the back burner for <em>months</em>.</p><p>But if there’s anything I want to give more attention to in STALKER 2 this year, a year later where I’m ̶n̶e̶a̶r̶l̶y̶ done with the game, it’s the <strong><em>story</em></strong>. And that’s a strange thought considering STALKER 1&#39;s story was this rote thing of playing an amnesiac. STALKER 1 was predictable and mainly interesting at the end of the game where it contended with the same philosophical conversation taking place in the film “STALKER” but given the science fiction vibes of the book “Roadside Picnic”. It wasn’t <em>bad </em>but there was a severe disconnect at play between the greater themes available in the game’s setting that could have been tapped to great appeal. STALKER 2’s story, while meandering and filled with similar “go chase this character and then that character” vibes for a great deal of the first half, is in fact pulling a mixture of Halo 2 and Witcher 3 all at once in preparation for a mid-game story sequence that demonstrates STALKER 2 is a “capital S” Sequel to Shadow of Chernobyl in ways stronger than STALKER 1 ever was. The “home is destroyed” theming that’s present at the beginning of the game isn’t something the writers lose sight of and there’s intention put behind the use of characters and factions present in the original game that have been brought back in this story. The mid-game-story piece specifically presents the ideological debate that serves as STALKER 1’s emotional climax but given the perspective of Ukraine’s current war-torn world. And then the dust settles on the whole affair and you’re left in the wake of those decisions and actions, a whole new conflict having begun that is the back half of the game. It’s a phenomenal setup and an utterly gripping series of events that changes the entire dynamic at play just as the game was starting to feel a little stagnant. I dare not spoil it but I sure hope someone gets a great essay out covering its topics one day because video games haven’t really covered topics like this in this way since Call of Duty 4 and Spec Ops: The Line. It is ultimately worth the rather lengthy run-around the game gives you in the first half just so you can appreciate the game’s massive world and the board they’re setting.</p><p>There is one major complaint I found against the game in my time with it this year, which is a boss fight around the 75% mark in the story. The sequence leading <em>up </em>to the fight is as phenomenal as the other story bits I’ve discussed. But the mechanics of the fight didn’t work out in the design, leading you to expect to have precision in an environment that constantly pushes you away from it. Don’t be ashamed to just cheese it with a good shotgun. GSC would’ve benefitted from making the second phase of the fight more like Clear Sky’s climax fight and cut out the hallucinations. It would’ve felt more streamlined and earned. I can’t say any of the boss fights in this game really fare well. But the two that followed it weren’t nearly as disastrous for me. There is a minor complaint worth lodging but I do have to throw it out there with a “experience may vary” statement. I didn’t really put the consideration into this article regarding it, but then I beat the game and took some pictures. This is my Steam time with the game upon completion:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*y4loM9RylhTnzxy14b2UWg.jpeg" /></figure><p>And this is my last auto save before the final sequence, probably 15 minutes extra tops.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jlvxn9wGf4jBrUT21p-JEA.png" /></figure><p>If you do the math, there’s about an extra 24 hours of game time in Steam in STALKER 2 than there is in the game itself. I think I ran the game running for six hours once while I was out of the house, but <em>most</em> of that 20+ hours of time is likely due to the game’s still rather terrible load times. It’s a big game with some fairly unoptimized shader compilation times and unoptimized <em>updates</em>. I have my gripes about using tools like FSR and DLSS to make games these days, but I don’t want to go down that rabbit hole. The most I’d say is that I haven’t spent so much time tinkering with graphics settings like this since Crysis. Instead, I want to draw attention to that shader compilation time spent before the game launches. It’s true that the more you play this game in repeat sessions, the faster that load time is before you get to the main menu. Some people modded in ways to skip that compilation because an update broke that loading back in the game’s earliest days last year. The mods came with the warning that loading your save will take extra long now. But the save load was already pretty hefty for modern games, so we took our chances. That got patched and load times balanced out to “still long but improving the more you play the game, but still kind of annoying if you die to a fight that you keep having to reload quickly”. And God help you if GSC releases an update. There can be updates ranging a couple gigabytes in size, but it feels like the game is entirely reinstalling every time these updates come out because I’ll watch my machine spend the next hour installing the update across what Steam calculates to be “16 minutes”.</p><p>STALKER 1 and its expansions had atrocious load times for their day. I played Battlefield 2 in 2005, where load times were so bad you’d choose a server and join to find it right at the end, just in time for the next map to load. At least you were in the server now and would join the next map late together with everyone else. I understand the use of shader pre-comping and using it to allow for a game world as huge as STALKER where I don’t need another load screen if I tell a guide to take me from one area of the map to the other. But from where I sit, if the pre-comp load times that are longer than any other game doing this today, I better <em>instantaneously </em>load into the game world the way you can in something like Spider-Man 2 or Dead Space. I give STALKER 2 plenty of slack: War torn country of development. A dev that hadn’t made a game like this in a long time trying to make it appealing to many people while staying true to its “simulation” style mechanics. But there’s a part of me that wonders just how much inflated time I’ve spent in that game and out of that game watching the update progress on Steam every time GSC releases an update or how much time I spent watching that shader compiling loading screen.</p><p>Do I think it’s still worth trying? Absolutely. If this game remotely tickles your aesthetic funny bone and you like a challenging tactical shooter, try it. It’s a reward well worth the investment if you can get through it. The game’s 40% off right now with the Steam holiday sale. If you like this genre, don’t miss out. But I’d say that 40% off would’ve made it easier for me to stomach a game so big and unoptimized I spent an extra 20 hours of my life on the load screens.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=632b7b8a93e9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[2024 Things]]></title>
            <link>https://the-typer.medium.com/2024-things-10eb4c58ca2d?source=rss-4c5509ad50b6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/10eb4c58ca2d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[year-in-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2024]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[games]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Fleming]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Dec 2024 01:49:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-14T01:49:33.641Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Another year has passed and I write to share what I’ve experienced, mostly good, some not that good. More or less the same rules apply as before: It won’t cover everything because I’d be here all day. I’m talking about things that stuck out to me, that I feel are worth me writing about. Things unfinished I’m not going to talk about <em>as much </em>because I don’t like recommending stuff I haven’t seen through to the end.</p><h3><strong>Games:</strong></h3><p>(games will be ordered in the order in which I played them)<br>I finished like 13 games that I hadn’t played before this year and I feel pretty good about that pace all things considered. I built a spreadsheet somewhere in the middle of 2023 to track what I own, what I don’t, what I’ve started, what I haven’t, what needs a restart, etc. Really great tool to help me be intentional about focusing on games and getting through them.</p><h4><strong>mundaun</strong></h4><p>A spooky game with some slightly bothersome stealth mechanics, mundaun is all about the vibe and the game’s interesting embedded mechanics (inventory, use of brewing coffee to give you a bigger sanity bar, that sorta thing). I should’ve written about it back in early 2024 when I was playing it so I had more to say, instead I’m working off recollection almost a whole year later. But that also leaves me with mostly positive memories. Hiding from hay monsters while navigating the world in the dark isn’t really engaging at all after dealing with troublesome mechanics. So that first couple nights of the game are frustrating. However all the details zooming in on photos where you hear things, the presentation of creepy nights as you open or close windows or see the man with the hat from far away but then he’s not there up close, <em>those </em>things are fantastic. The story, the world, the audio design, are all top notch and, like one other game on this list, you’ll find yourself saying “we need more games like this that feature aspects unlike anything you’ve ever played before.” In this case, mundaun comes from a Swiss developer. And its charcoal art style is uniquely unforgettable.</p><h4>Dead Space Remake</h4><p>Playing Dead Space remake this year not long after playing the System Shock Remake last year was such a good call. I think the best remakes are ones that make you say “there’s actually no reason to go play the original now” and come out for games <em>like </em>the original System Shock; a game so old the concept of mouse movement didn’t exist yet. For Dead Space this felt weird because, as far as I could experience, the original Dead Space was still <em>very playable</em>. Sure it was a mid-gen release for consoles but outside the well-documented vertical synch issue on PC, the original Dead Space wasn’t some massively outdated game riddled with bugs or design flaws. So why would I say Dead Space Remake is a good remake? Well, because it’s just a massively improved version of the original in almost every way. It maintains the almost constantly increasing sense of dread the original gave players by way of making its safe zones less and less safe, increasing the sensation that the Ishimura’s systems are struggling more and more as you play the game.</p><p>The seamless level design is one of the rare cases of modern AAA level designs not feeling hamstrung the way a game like the Jedi series or God of War do: You’re not corridor squeezing as a replacement for a loading screen so much as spending time traversing a wide corridor that might or might not spawn enemies on you this time around. Or you just take the tram, a free standing loading screen that doesn’t feel slower or faster based on load times (I do appreciate how this game does a lot of its loading so that once you’re at the main menu the game feels fully loaded). Tram rides are also not a constant necessity for exploring the game, so you don’t feel like the game is constantly shoving you into those tighter spaces to load more of the game. This is the version of the Ishimura I <strong>dreamt of</strong> as a teenager, a structured experience given room for semi-dynamic scares and simultaneously meeting out its internal consistency the way System Shock games (and Prey) have done in the past. There’s still scripted spooks, and they’re great. But because the Ishimura is so corridor-focused, the load times are stellar while the game can get away with not actually forcing the player down to a thumbstick press. The story and gameplay expansions are also fantastic. A useful Flame Thrower, who would of thought?! I feel like it’s a bug but there’s this thing in this remake where if you enter some rooms, the entrance/exit doors into that space that you didn’t enter yourself are already open (most doors are always closed in this game) and usually once you catch a glimpse of the doors they’ll close in your eyeline. Bug or not, it creates a tension in this game that I haven’t felt for a while now and the remake has proven itself a worthy entry in the dead franchise.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/825/0*hj0AKvraTfZXaiGq" /><figcaption>I had no idea this quest would be this good</figcaption></figure><h4>Spider-Man 2</h4><p>Following the line of fulfilled wishes, Spider-Man 2 is the actual Spider-Man 3 movie a younger me wanted. While Spider-Man 3 is a weird campy experience, its production issues are pretty well known at this point: Raimi wanted to make it more about Peter, Harry, and Sandman. But Sony pushed for Venom to be in it. The result was a mess. Here, <strong>Marvel Spider-Man 2</strong> manages to have the multi-villain trick going on again just like the first game, but you can see it coming a mile away. The Venom aspect of the game is on the cover while Kraven was advertised all over the game. Unlike the movie Spider-Man 3, Marvel Spider-Man 2 had a planned Venom story. It’s naturally a much better setup.</p><p>The main plot is, more or less, what you want out of a story like this, the needled threaded in a way that feels better than we’ve seen before. How this game took me by surprise was in <em>every single Miles quest.</em> It’s insane how good his story actually works through this game. There’s definitely some plot convenience nonsense happening near the end but that’s such a minor element in a wider game that’s clearly playing up passing up the torch to Miles. What makes you want that torch pass comes through Miles’s quests. His character represents the embodiment of the “friendly neighborhood Spider-Man” character one hopes for in this sort of fiction. Quests involving ordinary citizens are given so much more room to breathe in this game and are less about citizens reporting crimes as they are about human beings needing some help or just needing someone to talk to. It’s about life, death, and love. We’re all too familiar with stories where the hero becomes a villain of sorts and the other hero has to save the main hero. But Spider-Man 2 is the one where you <em>do</em> the saving, you <em>feel</em> the desire to fix things and maybe knock some sense into Peter. And it’s all the more satisfying because of it. And when the game goes full Venom mode it’s as over-the-top as video games can allow for in some fantastic ways.</p><p>Just, please, redesign that ugly Adidas suit at the game’s climax for Miles. It’s awful. We all know it.</p><h4>Wolfenstein: Youngblood</h4><p>Not necessarily one I’d recommend that much. The first 25% of the game I played I tried playing it a bit closer to a normal Wolfenstein experience and had a good time. And then it started looping more and more, areas repopulating the way it is designed to and I started losing interest. I beat the game but its last boss fight is just boring as can be and the game itself, while earnestly fun, isn’t what anyone was truly interested in from a Wolfenstein standpoint: It’s a miniature Borderlands. The biggest saving grace is the game’s level design (outside sewer maps). Arkane helped develop the game’s map design and the verticality and detail really shows. I’m excited for what MachineGames cooks up next but this one-off experience is rather mentally throwaway in a series that has otherwise been so intentional.</p><h4>The Outer Worlds</h4><p>I finally, <strong><em>finally </em></strong>got around to Outer Worlds. And its DLC. I had attempted two different runs of this game. The first run got me over to Monarch but I stalled out at some point exploring that planet’s open world section. My second run was stopped shortly as my graphics card had somehow gotten worse at playing the game and I couldn’t get a stable framerate on it, must’ve been aging poorly or something. Either way, I finally did it. And while I think Noah Gervais makes some really great points about the game’s predictability and the ways in which it struggles to escape its own comparisons to modern Fallout, I still really enjoyed most of my time with the game. Everything about the combat is just as throwaway as Wolfenstein: Youngblood but in entirely different ways. However the characters, the world, the history, the backdrop, it’s all pretty good. Tacoma <strong>does do </strong>this sort of future capitalism idea better because Outer Worlds fails to drip itself in Capitalistic Irony <em>well</em> while Tacoma is instead painting a picture through a smaller lens and providing a story of hope within a jaded and cynical system. But that didn’t stop me from liking the debates at play across the first two main planets. That didn’t stop me from liking <em>everything</em> going on in the Groundbreaker and its past. I didn’t expect to like Pavarti and Ellie so much but I really did. The third planet Byzantium was appropriately scaled down after Monarch being so big but definitely feels like aspects of the story there were entirely rushed. For the planet that’s all supposed to be about the high society you really don’t see much of it.</p><p>Playing the DLC Murder on Eridanos right after Monarch and Peril on Gorgon right before the end game felt so thematically appropriate. Murder on Eridanos might be where the game shines its brightest, taking advantage of RPG, conversation, and observation aspects in ways that let these types of games shine so well (it’s where Outer Worlds feels closest to New Vegas). A murder mystery at the center of it all is also so gripping. It’s all really well done. Meanwhile Peril on Goron, while a little lengthy, taps into something much more important to the overall story of The Outer Worlds, so much so that I’m actually surprised it’s <em>not </em>the climax of the game. The stats needed to get the best ending in that DLC are <em>absurd</em>. But the destination at the heart of it is a much better experience than the nothing-walk that the last chunk of the main game is.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*D-wJ6RO8tt5nbVT2" /></figure><h4>Shadow of the Erdtree</h4><p>I don’t want to dwell on this one for long because I have spent too much time in Elden Ring over the past 18 months. Don’t be trickled by that phrase “DLC”. This game is very much so “Dark Souls 7” to Elden Ring’s “Dark Souls 4, 5, and 6 in one package.” Shadow of the Erdtree is great. Despite Elden Ring being the driving force of what we experience in Shadow of the Erdtree, I can’t help but look back on the 60–100 hours I spent in Shadow in a much greater light than the 200+ hours I spent in Elden Ring. The discovery aspect of Elden Ring on a first run is incredible and there’s a very interesting world there. But that world is only <em>more </em>interesting in Shadow of the Erdtree. That gameplay is only <em>more </em>varied and supports build variety better in Shadow of the Erdtree <em>without</em> filling so much of that time in far too many caves and less interesting worlds and dungeons. At the same time, we wouldn’t have these expansive setups without the original game’s foundation. It’s also a DLC most people will struggle to enter on a bum rush through the core game (one of the few advantages for me was that I finished Elden Ring back in early January so I didn’t feel the need for a fresh save to prep for the DLC, anyone else would and that sucks). The map is maybe the one fatal flaw in this “DLC” as it struggles to handle this design of verticality in a way that was pretty easily addressed in the main game. And yet Shadow of the Erdtree manages to be (outside its ending and a few sticklers) rigorously good throughout. And just like after finishing Elden Ring back in December of 2023, I never want to think about Elden Ring again. I want FromSoft to explore the stars next. I want them to get away from fantasy grounds. And I want the next game to be the size and scope of what we’ve seen before Elden Ring happened. Not for many reasons more than just that I like having time.</p><h4>Chorus</h4><p>What a cool take on the dogfighter genre. It’s a semi-open game where you’ll traverse and explore about four larger space areas that are filled with quests and encounters but entirely from the 3rd person dogfighter space perspective. The hubs are all cool and big enough to have dynamics that make them exciting. The quests are mostly fine except for the ones that fill up dead time between large travel jobs. They’re basically brief stops and really offer nothing interesting to the player and unfortunately start looping more and more as you wrap up more of the game’s main quests. That constant appearance of brief quests or enemies made me feel like the game didn’t trust me to enjoy just flying about its vaster spaces without something to shoot every five minutes. A sad thing in a game so beautiful honestly. Meanwhile the mechanics are also really solid with a sort of mystical power to you and your ship that allow you to pull off cool stunts across fights. The “ship build” elements aren’t that deep, pick what you like and what help you overcome the game’s challenges. I think all this game is missing is some more flight challenges. The game gives you some really great tools that provide specific in-flight maneuvers that make fast shifts really fun, but you only use it in tighter high-speed experiences so often. The largest weak point, unfortunately, is a story that is steeped in almost <em>too</em> much lore that the player is carried through without enough background for it. I wouldn’t call the lore or writing bad so much as just we’re inundated in it in a game that doesn’t have enough breathing room to fill it into a game like this. If you miss stuff like Starfighter, Rogue Squadron, and the like, don’t miss this one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*F4iQ_gJZmIHGgVNO.png" /></figure><h4>Kenzera: Tales of ZAU</h4><p>I think you should buy this game if you love Metroidvanias or if the aesthetic of the game interests you. It’s one of those games where I genuinely think you won’t find many games out there like this with this setting. The mythical storytelling present is really unique and worth putting the game in the native language with subtitles. I can’t say I was crazy about the more complex execution of some of the core mechanics here; dashing, for example, moved too far past enemies you’d try to dash through to avoid attacks, getting hit knocks you back in annoying ways as the game gets harder, and the time between hitting lethal pitfalls and starting again is maybe just a smidge too long. But the earnestness of this game and its message from a developer who lost his dad and is trying to reconcile that, yeah, I know that feeling. This is one of those developers that struggled to keep the lights on financially and then the game got a lot of hate for having a person of color on the cover or the developer trying to share his culture with the world so you’d help some people who struggled for unreasonable reasons if you bought this one.</p><h4>Hyper Light Drifter</h4><p>I finally beat it. I had two prior earnest tries in this game like The Outer Worlds. A good time. I liked it. Not a lot to say outside that.</p><h4>Sherlock Holmes: The Awakened</h4><p>At this point I’d recommend a Frogwares game to anyone with a passing interest. Sherlock Homes: Chapter One had some truly frustrating bits in its “scenario recreations” and I wasn’t fond of the vague conclusions you’d arrive at, but it still had my recommendation last year. The Awakened I feel even more comfortable urging you to grab and experience. For starters it’s not open world. This is a series of chapters where you have smaller semi-open map hubs and each hub lets you explore out some smaller investigations in addition to your main case. That means there’s no combat encounters, no “pick an outfit for disguise” stuff, and next to no city exploration investigating in the way that that takes up a great deal of the last two Frogwares games (collectibles in The Sinking City were great, but not in Chapter One). And while there’s definitely something cool about how those games let you tap into the city in so many ways (maps, talking to people to gather info, digging deeper), enough of those mechanics are retained here and even given better tutorials so you’ll have a better time puzzling through things. Normally after each miniature hub you’ll progress into a story-focused larger investigation that gets complex with each new area of the game. One middle game investigation involves recreating a violent incident across two floors of a mansion and it’s just the best. By not being locked into one larger city this time around you get to see several unique areas in the game instead with great dynamics. Unlike Chapter One, The Awakened won’t leave you grasping at straws for which of the two potential answers is the right one, except where it counts (this is, after all, a Cthulhu mystery). The best improvement they’ve made here has to be the Mind Palace, smartly color coding different types of evidence so players can put it together and comprehend what <em>type of evidence</em> is missing when your deductions are rejected.</p><p>The presentation aspect of this game is so much better too, each new chapter presenting itself with a fantastic sense of foreboding, the scenery shot in such stark ways cut against the title cards that introduce it. The story works out really well too. There’s one or two moments where I felt like I wanted more but then I checked out the art book for the game and found an entire section in the art book dedicated to showing you what the devs (from Ukraine) have gone through with the conflict with Russia, including family members they haven’t found yet. This company has been through the ringer for the past decade including a legal battle over The Sinking City where they probably weren’t getting most of the sales money for three years until the start of 2024. To know The Awakened is an entirely crowdfunded project and that The Sinking City 2 will be crowdfunded the same way is an impressive feat. This team is efficient at what they do, even with this newer engine of theirs and I look forward to putting some cash towards their development of this next game in 2025.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*o6P114gh6iSw_vZi" /></figure><h4>Amnesia: The Bunker</h4><p>I kind hate games like Amnesia: The Bunker. Or so I thought. I’ve never been a fan of “monster roaming” scary games like Outlast or Alien: Isolation (I tried to, I played something like 15 hours of Alien: Isolation). At the end of the day there has always just something really bothering about these games to me. But I <strong><em>love</em></strong> Frictional titles. They’re one of the most consistently “I liked it”-level devs for me. And The Bunker was reportedly a big success and really well done. So getting to this game was inevitable. Leave it to Frictional to make me finally like one of these types of games.</p><p>Approaching The Bunker like any prior Amnesia game with an immersive sim twist is just enough of what I needed to push through these types of experiences. I don’t know if there was any one particular aspect that helped me through it or if it was moreso a combination of the elements at play. The map. The tools at your disposal that you’ll find more of as you keep playing. The desire to explore out more and more of the map to get the story. Frictional’s interactivity and your greatest tool: Your brain. Outsmart the beast. Hide. Distract. Evade. It’s comforting to know that this type of game does really well with the same type of market that loves Resident Evil games (less the action-ones and more 1–3 and 7 and 8) because hopefully more people will give more Frictional titles a try and see they’re still the king at this corner of the horror street: First person. Kinetically grounded. Vulnerably terrifying. It’s really good and just when you’re reaching the right levels of confidence in this game you’ll dive into even scarier experiences. One in particular that sets up the endgame is just the absolute worst. It creates the same sort of frantic nerves that the sewer section in Amnesia: The Dark Descent provided.</p><h4>Resident Evil Remake (not finished for now)</h4><p>I didn’t finish this one and won’t this year. I picked it up post-Amnesia: The Bunker because part of me wondered how well I’d enjoy this now that I found something to like about this type of game through The Bunker. And it was great! I sunk close to 20 hours into the game in a pretty short time span. There’s something really satisfying about exploring every room and mapping it out and figuring out the intricate puzzle that is this game’s mansion. It <strong>is </strong>long though and so I wasn’t ready to commit another 10 or more hours getting through this game. Besides, there was “Bloodborne at home” to play.</p><h4>Lies of P (not finished yet)</h4><p>Yeah. Instant winner for me, even when I played the demo I could feel it right away. You should play Lies of P if you like Bloodborne and/or Sekiro. It <strong>is </strong>harder. It <em>does </em>have aspects that are a tad more punishing than some Souls games (on par with Sekiro basically). But so much on the table here is an <em>improvement </em>over a lot of normal things in Souls games now. The improvements to the Souls designs and formulas here are consistently so good that part of me wants to even recommend you play the demo if you like any <strong>single </strong>Souls game. It’s that fresh and different and unique. It’s not all perfect. I’m also not done with the game. But I think my urging you to try it despite not being done with it speaks to how strong a title this game is. I <strong><em>definitely </em></strong>have Bloodborne bias. But I think I can leave this recommendation with these two simple ideas from the game. 1) You can change the hilt and blade part of every weapon to mix and match them to create unique styles of play and plays of style. 2) This is the first game <strong>ever </strong>(not just souls-game) to have a durability system that I actually like and it feels well implemented as part of the gameplay experience.</p><h4>Oxenfree 2: Lost Signals</h4><p>Oxenfree is my jam. Teenage drama amidst a radio frequency horror experience that also deals with time loops? <strong>Awesome. </strong>But Oxenfree 2 is interesting because it’s <em>not </em>that (a teenage drama). It focuses on a different age range for the character drama (opting for people in their middle to late 20s-ish? Older?) while they’re following the antics of some teenagers that are involved with these time loops. It definitely makes the experience feel a little more bland compared to the dynamics of the teens from the first game. Partially because you’re just adults now so you’ve got some years and responsibility on you. But also because it’s just you and one other person for the game’s duration and it feels like the dialogue between the two of them is <strong>really awkward</strong>. Absent at times even. Honestly the player character Riley isn’t routinely confronted about what’s happened to them and what <em>is </em>happening to them. Alex had people regularly around her in the first game to confront herself with the things that haunt her but in this Riley just regularly sees visions of the future and converses with characters there. The thematic point makes sense but the emotion isn’t given a lot of weight honestly because the dots aren’t quite connected in the ways that make this as compelling. It’s hard to feel as invested in it when Riley’s conflict isn’t even apparent.</p><p>Oxenfree 2 has definite improvements! You get sign posts that conversations will carry on from one map load to the next, which is assuring in a way prior games lacked. There’s radio frequencies that have different people to check-in on and that’s a nice way to provide more characters without having to model them or have them all doing something <em>on the map </em>(having to choose who to take with you in Oxenfree <em>did </em>feel a little limiting if you wanted to see it all, here you’re guaranteed some experiences so long as you explore thoroughly). I like the Night School Studio approach to these type of games so I’m here for it, but it’s currently hard to tell if this sequel is stronger than the original knowing half of the mystery already. The half-way twist is <strong>really great</strong> though and the spooks are done in a genuinely more exciting way than they could’ve been able to back in the day. It just felt so deflating to barely know what my main character was struggling with emotionally while she mostly kept quiet about things for <em>most </em>of the game. By the time the end game decisions showed up, one main character didn’t even <em>say anything </em>until I was pretty confident about my decision. Oxenfree is built to be played more than once though so part of me wants to see what’s out there in a second run of this game as well. I’d recommend this if you really loved the first and want more of the spooky vibes, but if you’re new, go play the original first, Night School are great at their craft regardless.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*gDFdA8IG5-vA-6Ip" /></figure><h4>S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2: Heart of Chornobyl (very unfinished, very dedicated to finishing it)</h4><p>I’m so glad this game exists. Half-Life: Alyx in 2020 was of incredible importance to me, a moment I had been waiting for from Valve for 13 years that I had mostly given up on because Valve had moved on from who they were in the past into something else. That’s why Alyx, incredible as it is, didn’t feel like a sequel (I mean, it’s not, but in more ways than just when a story takes place). S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2, on the other hand, is <strong>truly </strong>a sequel to a game <em>17 years later </em>that I never even felt <em>hope for</em>. I held on to the possibility that Valve would come around for more of what I loved in Half-Life until I couldn’t anymore. The story of S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2 before its announcement is as lost to time as the Zone is to the world. The active development of the game has been told online in a <a href="https://youtu.be/Fg620kmD6Dc">fantastic doc</a> I’d recommend you watch to 1) understand what the dev has gone through and empathize with them and 2) to comprehend what frame of perspective that can provide you before playing this game. But there’s a longer story involving this IP, the studio behind it, and the lineage of games that cropped up in the wake of the original S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chornobyl that is harder to find now. <a href="https://youtu.be/o3BmubIQklU">Raycevick’s video on Metro 2033 and Last Light </a>covers a fair chunk of it if you want to dig deeper but there’s more out there. S.T.A.L.K.E.R. having a full fledged massive sequel like this could’ve gone the way of Disco Elysium (and it seemingly almost did). In that story, the original developers were completely disbanded by fate and time and capital, and several other studios popped up in the original studio’s death, and all laid their claim that they were the next studio that would build something worthy of the comparison to the original. But GSC Game World’s founder’s <em>brother and wife</em> picked up the ashes of the company after so much fallout across the 2010s, made some more strategy games, and assembled and revived this franchise and delivered this sequel of a game.</p><p>Much like Lies of P, I’ve got some hefty bias for a game called “S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2” coming out and existing. It’s not some sort of a revelation, but I never needed it to be. The original game’s revelation was its incredible dedication to being something different in a scene that was so blandly becoming the same. S.T.A.L.K.E.R. maintains the formula that no one else out there could figure out, makes some modern changes, and grows the game to what technology can permit in scale and scope today. It ups some challenges in ways I love. The devs put out a day-one patch that fixed a lot of issues and since then the devs have put out even more patches to fix and tweak more of the game.</p><p>So long as GSC Game World remains safe it looks to be that this company is going to continue helping this game be stable, beautiful, and polished. I realize I’m not saying too much about the experience of the game and that’s because these Eastern European developed games get a reputation for being broken, janky, and (by association) terrible. This game just isn’t that for me. I’ve experienced some stuff like you would in a Bethesda game but not THAT MUCH in 25 hours. What I have experienced…is S.T.A.L.K.E.R. 2. A game set in a world that feels alive around you. The very earth groans to swallow you whole in this rusty, cold, stormy landscape created with a massive passion by people who grew up in admiration of their home country and one of modern history’s most horrific disaster stories. It’s a game that I expected it to be but never believed in my wildest dreams that it would happen given the state of <em>everything surrounding S.T.A.L.K.E.R. </em>as a franchise. I should’ve known better really. The Ukranian spirit is stronger than the Zone.</p><h3><strong>Music:</strong></h3><p>(for flow reasons, music here is arranged basically by rank of music I thought were the best to the “worst”, but it’s good stuff don’t worry, don’t forget this is out of things I listened to)</p><h4>Jon Hopkins — Ritual</h4><p>Ritual is just perfect? It really doesn’t need more explaining than that. It’s a simple concept given form: A therapeutic meditation session depicted through an everchanging, growing, evolving musical soundscape that just builds and builds until it ends on poignant piano. Jon hasn’t stripped things back this well since his debut album Opalescent, which wasn’t really “stripped back” so much as just “simple”. And to contrast Bo Burnham’s “original does not mean good” joke, <strong>simple never needed to mean boring or bad</strong>. And Ritual proves that statement again 23 years after Opalescent did but in the way Jon Hopkins makes music today. One honest listen is all you need to comprehend quickly how this is, without a doubt, an S-Tier release. It’s so good I don’t need to explain it any further.</p><h4>wavedash — Tempo</h4><p>This was the one that took me by surprise. My friend Chris introduced me to wavedash a few years back, they had opened for or performed at Porter Robinson concerts and had an album called “World Famous Tour” I listened to. It was all right for me, didn’t change my perspective or anything. But “Tempo” fundamentally works differently for me. Their sophomore album is one of the leanest, meanest 35 minutes I’ve heard in a minute and I think why it works so well for me is two-fold. For starters, the style of music varies from a sort of high-spirits disco house in the first half cutting over to brash and wild hard dance and dubstep in the back half. The instrumentation, sampling, and pacing are detailed, slickly introduced, and quickly discarded often within 3 minutes or less. This allows the group to take you through an assortment of 12 tracks and give each track breathing room if appropriate (see: SKYFALLING and U Dont Know How). The dividing line between styles in music is clearly delineated in the first half (the house half) with track titles that are a mixture of upper and lowercase letters while the back half (the dubstep, the hard dance, the wub wubs) being in all caps for each title. You know the energy being brought just by <em>looking </em>at the titles. And then there’s the other half of the equation: Nostalgia (maybe?). Tempo is out in 2024, a decade after the year I started broadening my style horizons by picking up releases from Monstercat. The label was no doubt in its big heydey around then with tons of artists getting their real start there (Marshmallow would be getting releases like “Alone” there two years later, Noisestorm’s “Crab Rave” two years after that). Tempo feels rooted in that eclecticism we were seeing in varieties of music back then; Harsh. Varied. Quickly cut. DJ party music. Tempo doesn’t need to be more than that. It manages to be a little more than that by playing with style and format in some delectable ways. It and the next album were easily my most listened to albums this year, worthy of something like an A- out of me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*T1dMjMRQ38emJ3uj.jpg" /></figure><h4>Porter Robinson — SMILE! :D</h4><p>I love nuance. And yet I feel like I can know where people sit on this album based on their opinion of <em>one </em>song: Year of the Cup. Porter, in promotional material, called it the best song on the album. I saw him write that, and I felt locked into the wavelength of this album’s meaning and vibe so well, because I too felt it was maybe the best song here right next to Russian Roulette. Most I’ve talked to, however, disagree, they don’t like the flow interruption from the interview clip and can’t fathom this album standing up against Porter’s priors outside a few stellar tracks. I, however, love Smile (sorry, SMILE! :D). The reason I love Smile is three-fold. Reason 1: Despite my unnuanced take on other people’s feelings about the album, I love the album BECAUSE it’s all about the nuance. Porter said this album came about when he tried to make something meaningless, nihilistic, something overblown with detachment and then the lyrics written presented something else going on that he needed to finally say. Year of the Cup is the litmus test for whether or not you can look past the facade and catch onto Porter trying to talk to you. Can you appreciate a beautiful piece of music that is draped in elements that don’t usually jive with a stereotypical Porter Robinson song? Year of the Cup is pushing against the expectation grains. I saw him perform it live and he sat on a giant fake blue solo cup. He strummed his guitar with an endlessly brooding expression similar to his look in the song’s music video. In interviews he talked about how he hates that people purely see him as wholesome. Year of the Cup is Porter Robinson’s “Problematic” (another Bo Burnham reference today I guess) wherein he gets his apologies out before the world can hate him and simultaneously discusses substance abuse, artistry, and the gap between audience and performers. The question posed at the end of “Year of the Cup” is if the contents of the cup is anybody’s business or not; but if you remember the horrible stories of Porter’s bad behavior across the song, as Porter loops “the answer was obvious”, it’s hard to imagine any other answer.</p><p>Reason 2: This album is just a phenomenal change up. SMILE is bursting with new influences for Porter, but mainly emo and indie rock bands. “Cheerleader” is an emo boy band slam dunk. “Knock Yourself Out XD” is a hip hop grand entrance. “Is There Really No Happiness” is Keane with a little less piano. It’s easy to feel across the album and for the millennial crowd that there’s this fantastic late-pass retrospective for Porter (who didn’t get into a lot of this music until recently, apparently). Reason 3: It’s the first album where it feels like the album landed in Porter’s target zone and I love that sensation here. With WORLDS it felt like he regurgitated things he was trying to run away from and was too scared to embrace what he was doing so well at the time to at least mark it in his history. It was the successful debut he was ashamed of and didn’t need to be. The trick worked but so much of what Porter is addressing at times on this album deal with the terrible place he was in during WORLDS and there’s an inescapable aspect of that being the start of his album journey, both in real life and in the album. Nurture is really good but oddly paced in the back half, the tragic reality of an album built through the difficult process of writer’s block. The album tracks even got shifted a few times before coming out. It’s got amazing songs but struggles with that whole cohesion equation. “SMILE! :D” though? Fully formed. Complete. Unstoppable. Porter laid this one all out on the floor and it feels there’s not an ounce of hesitation to show it all. It sounds and feels like Porter hit exactly the target he was aiming for once he realized what he needed to talk about this time around. And I love it. There’s nothing like an emotionally present creation, and Smile is in that space.</p><h4>The 2024 House Album Roundup</h4><p>I complained to my friend Michael that I need more good trance albums out again. We get trance albums but it’s definitely a genre struggling to find strong ground here in the modern electronic music era. House albums though? No shortage of them right now honestly and they’re all pretty solid. Not even in this listing you’ll find new albums this year from Tinlicker, Dosem, Ben Böhmer, Nicky Elizabeth, the yearly Anjunadeep Compilation, and on and on. Dosem’s album nearly made the “let’s talk about it for a paragraph or two” cut but there’s three specific ones that stood out with a lot of strength that I’ve gotta bring up. Oddly enough, it’s in the embrace of some of the strengths of trance albums (or just good electronic music albums in the past) that provide these next three albums such a bump in their experiences.</p><p><em>Luttrell — Life at Full Speed<br></em>Luttrell has a pretty immaculate album record. When Lane 8’s melodic house was first being coined “back rub dream house” I didn’t expect Luttrell to actually run with the idea but his sort of grungy basslines slithering alongside the varied textures and instruments in his albums have really run the gamut for listeners. Meditative and peaceful moments (May 25th, Find Me, Fill My Heart) contrast against odd and interesting introspection (Quiet Even Dark, Lucky Ones) and occasionally allow for bombastic club room monsters (Out of Me, My Friend the Sun, Snoop Dawk). His albums have been a well balanced package <em>every </em>time. And yet, he has <strong>never </strong>been this good before. I hope Life at Full Speed is as transformative to the scene and to Luttrell as fatherhood has become for him because this one is exactly what we need to see more of out of electronic albums in general. An impressionistic intro cuts into the heart of the album with the second track as the title track propelling the album into its heart, each track afterwards carefully considering how to pace things right from what came before and what’s coming after. It doesn’t always need to be a mix album to be good and this album proves it. The atmosphere of tracks like “French Bulldog”, “Make U Happy”, or “Space” sell the sort of joyous new experiences Luttrell is seeing through his child’s eyes that this album is all about. It’s still a Luttrell album, but it’s deeply woven with a wealth of human experiences that have been missing from most trance albums lately. Don’t miss this one, seriously.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1-seT-HpWDYZNHYv.jpg" /></figure><p><em>Lane 8 — Childish<br></em>Similarly inspired by watching his kids grow up, Lane 8 nearly stole the long built up thunder Luttrell had been generating by releasing this album a week before Life at Full Speed. And yet, it’s great that these two albums came out at the same time, they wonderfully put you in the mood for each other. The only way I can describe Childish is with the phrase “Back to basics.” In a lot of ways Childish sounds like what a Lane 8 album would’ve sounded like if he never made “Rise” the way he made it. It has the approach to music that he was flirting with on his earliest singles like “Be Mine” or “Every Night”. Playful. Simple, but not lacking depth or a fantastic sense of progression. “Higher”, “Merry Mary”, and everything from “Say the Word” onwards are a must listen on this one. But overall this album’s bedrock is a sound Daniel has been venturing away from in a pursuit of some larger artistic expression, yet this sound speaks louder than any album he’s made yet, just like Luttrell’s.</p><p><em>Eli &amp; Fur — Dreamscapes<br></em>This one is a great “sum of its parts” album where I’m not entirely sure I felt a cohesion here that makes an unforgettable experience. But the flow of the album is great anyways and boasts a larger track count. Eli &amp; Fur have been in this game a long time so the tracks are good, but this time the album is focused with its soundscape start to finish. Dreamscapes really starts to shine in how nearly <em>every single track </em>feels single-capable (and a lot of these songs <em>did </em>come out as singles). Eli &amp; Fur are also <em>experimenting</em> in great ways here. “Insomnia” is a pretty dirty darker house track as strong as “Pegasus” from last year. “Monsters” explores some fantastic breakbeats as a change-up for the team. In fact, breakbeat and an enjoyable chilled vibe is a really welcome presence on this album in a few places. Tracks “Golden Eyes &amp; Tears” and “Missing You” are such an awesome formula change-up while still retaining the duo’s strengths. Meanwhile tracks like “Love Again” brush against the more poppy big house sensations for larger stages. It’s a fantastic collection of tracks showing all of Eli &amp; Fur’s strengths start to finish, including new ones. And more singing on it this time around! I feel like their vocals in the past have sometimes been hidden more as samples instead of full on verses or hooks and I far prefer what they’re doing on this one.</p><h4>Nox Vahn — The World Keeps Turning EP</h4><p>I have less to say about this EP than I do about Nox Vahn in general. This is another killer EP from a guy who keeps releasing stellar tracks every single year. I’d recommend this one for tracks “Don’t Think About It Too Much”, “When I’m With You” and “The World Keeps Turning”, but in general this is an artist crafting some really specific emotive soundscapes each year. This year went dark and I’m looking forward to what Nox Vahn cooks up next year. Hopefully he’ll make it to Detroit soon.</p><h4>Myon — Silence is Underrated</h4><p>A beautiful chillout EP. Apparently Myon produced this record to help him with his insomnia so he can drift off to sleep better, and you can definitely catch that sensation as each track sonically becomes more and more mellow while retaining some sense of sounds. Richly textured with truly colorful pads and synths. I’d take several more of these from Myon in the future if this is the sort of non-club setting music they can put out. It’s hard to find stuff like this that I latch on to so I really loved this one.</p><h4>Mat Zo — Disco Boy &amp; Blueish Yellow</h4><p>More fantastic single work from maybe my favorite name in someone who would probably hate to be called an “electro house” artist but I feel like he’s been striking something perfect between “house” and “electro” over the past three years.</p><h4>OCULA — Lost Horizon EP</h4><p>Before Lane 8 announced Childish, this was, in a way, the Lane 8 album I was waiting for this year. Just a fantastic 4-track experience that feels like a mini-mix set, featuring a nice complete variety of melodic club sounds but not overly complex. It feels like having just 4 tracks put OCULA under pressure to build something really specific and it feels great as a result. An easy listen that carries 20 minutes so well.</p><p><em>Runner-Ups<br></em>I love Hybrid Minds so their debut album “Tides” is worth checking out if you asked me. Darren Tate has a beautiful album “Metamorphasis”, it wasn’t completely memorable for me but I enjoyed it in its release month. Kyau &amp; Albert and Ferry Corsten both released albums that serve as decent track collections, “All in Good Time” and “Connect”, respectively.</p><h3>Movies/TV:</h3><p>I didn’t watch a lot of new stuff this year in the public commercial arena of television and film. The stuff I like is pretty boilerplate most of the time honestly. I really wanted to play and finish more games because my backlog there got stupidly big after PAX and the crazy year that was 2023. So, here’s a rapid fire of recommendations:</p><p><em>-Godzilla Minus One</em> (saw it in theaters last year in December, it’s perfect)<br>-<em>The Haunting of Hill House</em> (finally saw it just recently, I think I love Mike Flanagan cinema in general, after Doctor Sleep and then this it feels like he’s always going to be up my alley)<br>-<em>Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga</em> (the actual best Mad Max story, the fact that Furiosa screams “give it back” is a chef’s kiss of retroactive confirmation of what Fury Road is about at its heart)<br>-<a href="http://www.youtube.com/@HauntHounds"><em>Haunt Hounds</em></a> (I just promote most Olan Rogers projects, the man helped me propose to my wife so I’m just eternally grateful)<br>-<em>The Acolyte</em> (watch it for some amazing fighting choreography if nothing else<br><em>-Fallout is good, it toes the line just right</em><br>-<a href="https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUBKwq0XD0ue33z9bbhjnLE2lfSxk31Ob&amp;si=fYPfDKUhCDq1CQiw"><em>Adventure is Nigh</em></a><em> (</em>never thought I’d get into this but the remaster of the series on Second Wind is great and Jack really knows how to make a fun adventure for YouTube that’s not stupidly long)<br>-<em>Dune Part Two </em>(much better than the first, great watching in conjunction with each other, the ending framing makes me really confident in Dennis handling the third film because he gets it)<br>-<em>The Thing (perfect)<br>-Alien (also perfect?)<br>-A Quiet Place: Day One</em> (I think I liked this one better than the sequel)<br>-<em>Judas and the Black Messiah </em>(great movie, what a ripoff that award was)<br>-<em>Lady Bird</em></p><h3><strong>Books:</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/0*rDbx1aKTUbA72fL3.jpg" /></figure><h4>Saga Book Three — Brian K. Vaughan and Fiona Staples</h4><p>Saga book three is, in a word, devastating. This series was already a revelation in science fantasy comic fiction long before book three hit shelves. Fiona Staples’s art is unmatched. Brian takes us on a series of pivotal events this time around and by the end you’re left wondering how it’s going to continue. But continue it does, as of writing this we’re in the middle of “Book Four” releases and I can’t wait to get my hands on the finished copy.</p><h4>The Witcher — Blood of Elves &amp; Time of Contempt</h4><p>Last year I didn’t write about reading the first two Witcher books (The Last Wish and Sword of Destiny) but I did talk about how much I enjoyed season 3 of the show. It struggled at the start but at its height it managed to be exactly the sort of thing that makes this franchise great. And then this year I got to read the two books that make up seasons 2 and 3. Blood of Elves was good but definitely struggled with finding a way to reestablish concepts that were loosely structured in the two prior books. Time of Contempt, however, has fully shed its pre-saga skin and morphed into what feels like Andrzej Sapkowski was initially crafting. Time of Contempt is a blast to read. The very lengthy chapters are at a constant simmer until the war breaks out and then it is a rapid boil. It’s The Witcher at its best and while it’s not a great entry point in the series, it’s as rewarding as all the other best Witcher moments when it comes to espionage, political moves, and action fantasy. There is, however, a moment near the end that has become gravely controversial and casts the entirety of the series in a pretty dark shadow for me, I had no clue it was a thing until I read it. In short: There’s a sequence in this involving sexual assault.</p><p>I had to dig around a lot to try to grasp all the possible opinions of it and this book’s writing about female characters. A lot of people seem to suggest that the framing of the SA scene as well as how things are generally translated in the whole book were poorly done and thus leave a lot to be desired. Others seem to take a stance of “once you read the other books you’ll understand why that is there” (which I kinda of get, knowing what I know about the character and their role in the wider Witcher story). However, this would have been a book that had three more entries released across the next four years at its initial release. I can’t imagine critics at the time saying “wait till later, you won’t feel as angry about it” because they didn’t know yet what was to come. People would’ve been upset. Some people do seem to come to the consensus that Andrzej Sapkowski is just a bad writer for female characters. I don’t think my book criticism is particular strong so if he is it’s probably getting over my head. Personally the passage involving the dark subject matter wasn’t written in any way that felt careless towards the victim or gratuitous in how it was discussed. It <em>i</em>s<em> </em>empathetic, and it <em>i</em>s<em> </em>in theme with what the book is chasing after. It is an uncomfortable read for a page while not being graphic. The sequence of events afterwards, however, removed from an understanding of the wider Witcher story and what is to come (which again, I kind of know about having played Witcher 3 and watched the shows and consumed video essays), could be taken to mean something almost <strong>opposite</strong> of what should be implied after an SA sequence involving a key character. Quite a few people seemed to take the writing after the scene as an implication that the person who was assaulted was <em>fine with it</em> but I find that to not be quite the case. The fact that it’s unclear to readers is definitely alarming. I’ll be blunt: Sexual assault or rape in fiction should never be <em>endorsed </em>or given a positive perspective. In the bubble of not knowing where this series of books goes I can immediately see why people would think the writer was endorsing it. I’m roughly confident he wasn’t, but you’ve been warned.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/0*dmqw_THd90Y4XAqw.jpg" /></figure><h4>Spider-Gwen 0–4</h4><p>The more I think about Spider-Gwen the more I really like it, maybe more than Miles comics. The Miles Morales comics quickly get tangled up with annoying multi-verse stuff, making Miles’s residence as a character feel like a back seat to exploits with the Marvel franchise instead of someone with his own problems to be given spotlight (outside some specific really good arcs). Meanwhile, Spider-Gwen’s first series of issues and crossovers feel properly balanced between an arena of wider happenings compared to the more prevalent and important forefront of Gwen’s <em>very challenged life. </em>The Robbi Rodriguez art style has this incredible angular look going on and has a lot of fun with colors that lend it a noir look even though it’s not in black and white. But what really sticks with me even months after the last time I read an issue is that deep down the first major arc of Spider-Gwen comics is kind of about police violence. The outset of the series is that Gwen went too far with her powers and killed Peter Parker (The Lizard). That’s her “great power, great responsibility” moment. And her dad’s the chief of police. It hits the nail on the head of problems surrounding super hero comics and power fantasies clashing with the way we romanticize the institution of police as heroes when they so regularly take power into their own hands. Sure, Watchmen is better at this than Spider-Gwen, but it’s still <em>good. </em>Spider-Gwen’s first set of issues up through <em>Long Distance</em> and the Miles Morales crossover volume are all really good. Spider-Women is kind of worth looking at as a decent crossover too. The first run of her character eventually encounters the usual “problems implemented don’t have an easy way to unravel them later”, which is where we get <em>Predators</em> but supposedly the follow-up volume <em>Gwenom</em> is really popular so I look forward to reading that when I get my hands on it. Either way, I really appreciate the debates this goes into at the outset. It is this push and pull Gwen has between recognizing that she has a problem where she’s in love with the power she has and choosing to atone by living a life in service to others and keeping that power in check. Sure that runs into the usual problem of any narrative like this: “Keeping your power in check after doing a crime is not justice”. And it’s true. Kind of like in real life. But at least it’s confronting the debate routinely and regularly across those first several books. It’s great. Don’t sleep on it.</p><h4>The Ballot and the Bible — Kaitlyn Schiess</h4><p>If you’re religious I’d recommend it. It’s a tougher read in the first half as several sections can feel pretty academic. But it’s an important read for American Christians to comprehend the historical ways people have utilized scripture for good or ill. Some sections in the back half will surprise you!</p><h4>Dune Messiah — Frank Herbert</h4><p>I’m honestly not entirely sure how I feel about this one. I don’t dislike it. I enjoyed the more political espionage stuff going on throughout the story. I know this one was written in response to people not really grasping that the original book was meant to be a warning about characters like Paul. I definitely like these books and what Frank Herbert was doing with Paul in this one metaphorically. It’s also interesting in how so much of this one’s plot uses perspectives of those plotting against Paul. Mainly I read it to get an idea of what Denis Villeneuve is up against in the third and final movie he plans to make.</p><h4>How Far to the Promised Land — Esau McCaulley</h4><p>This one was good but I didn’t expect it to be <em>this good. </em>Esau McCaulley writes this book out of two striking moments in his life. The first was the death of his estranged father and having to write a eulogy for him. The second was being at a talk panel and being asked “What’s the most racist thing you’ve encountered in your life?” and deciding to not answer the question that day. In this book Esau shows you how that question can’t be answered so simply. He will walk you through his family history to frame a history of people no longer slaves but victims of poverty and cycles of addiction and violence that still kept young kids often trapped within it if not outright murdered routinely. It’s also stories of profound humanity from that same family, seeking justice or finding ways to provide grace and mercy to those who would often not deserve it. By providing family stories grounded in their emotional experiences, Esau helps shed the usual conversation about systems that have routinely made black lives difficult and what to do about it. This isn’t one of those books that follows a common set structure. This one is about people, families, it brought me to tears in ways I wasn’t expecting. Don’t sleep on this one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/667/0*26H-S1iyD73kD5sT.jpg" /></figure><h4>The Hivemind Swarmed: Conversations On Gamergate, the Aftermath, and the Quest For a Safer Internet — David Wolinski</h4><p>The Hivemind Swarmed is an oral history from a group of informed (and sometimes uninformed) voices spiraling across a docummentary-style series of conversations with the origin point being Gamergate. If you know what Gamergate is, you can imagine what sort of a book this is and you might be misled. If you don’t know what Gamergate is, but have exposed yourself to the amazing and terrible things you can encounter on the internet, you still can imagine what sort of book this is and also find yourself surprised where it goes.</p><p>This one I’ll admit some bias on, I was introduced to this author through an interview series he was (and still is) doing called No Don’t Die. Eventually he and I started exchanging e-mails because I thought what he was doing was rad (I still do) and we had a couple calls and our conversation got saved on the site. The conversations David and I had back in 2016 were helpful for me to talk about some things that had bothered me about spaces on the internet for a while and were reaching a new boiling point that year. When he and I talked about it back in 2016, we both knew it was something we saw in Gamergate. When he had finished his book around 2018 or so and we touched base again, it was clearer the problems I brought up in that first conversation was more rooted in something broader. David’s been asking questions about this vague and diverse issue for over a decade now. And The Hivemind Swarmed is a book that provides conversations from key perspectives about the things David and I talked about those days but in a more focused and structured way.</p><p>I thoroughly recommend it. While it starts off discussing Gamergate itself each chapter helps paint the broader picture of problems so many of us are aware of but struggle to pinpoint on any one thing if we get into nitty gritty conversations. The standout feels like Chapter 3 wherein it opens on the Atari Founder stating that they often take claims about sexism in the industry with some skepticism followed up by a quote from another person saying how that founder will never change. Chapters 3 and Chapter 6 offer a variety of perspectives around and from women and how the internet and video game companies and culture have impacted them in these negative ways, but doesn’t make a spectacle of them sharing stories. David isn’t here to really talk much in this book in fact. He’s asking questions. And you’re reading the answers.</p><p>It’s also a fairly quick read compared to other books out there so don’t hesitate!</p><h4>The Devil in The White City — Erik Larson</h4><p>This one’s pretty well known so I don’t feel the need to go too in-depth about it. My mom read it, told me about it, I asked to borrow her copy, it’s great! It’s a crime history about two people in the late 1800s: One an architect that designed the World’s Fair and how that came about, the other a serial killer that used the World’s Fair as an opportunity to kill even more people in a systemized fashion. Erik has such a fantastic way of telling history it is no wonder people tried to turn this into a miniseries, but the book does it so fantastically you really don’t need anything else. Worth reading if you like this sort of thing.</p><p>If you like this sort of thing, I also did similar stuff for the below years and I’ve linked to them.</p><p><a href="https://the-typer.medium.com/2019-things-i-loved-689618ab4337">2019</a><br><a href="https://the-typer.medium.com/video-games-in-2020-an-awards-journal-d3ad4e5d7e0c">2020</a> — This one’s a sort of journey log/awards thing<br><a href="https://the-typer.medium.com/january-may-a-handful-of-reviews-9da2de2c6072">First half of 2023</a><br><a href="https://the-typer.medium.com/things-ive-consumed-in-2023-74b482e135ba">Rest of 2023</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=10eb4c58ca2d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Untangling Across the Spider-Verse]]></title>
            <link>https://the-typer.medium.com/untangling-across-the-spider-verse-a93316f3f48b?source=rss-4c5509ad50b6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a93316f3f48b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[across-the-spider-verse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spider-man]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[miles-morales]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sony]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[into-the-spider-verse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Fleming]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Jul 2024 21:01:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-26T21:01:37.625Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In 2019 I poured out my love for Into the Spider-Verse into a medium article. It was a brief, 15 minute read that I remain pretty proud of because in 15 minutes I didn’t have the space to write anything too particular while still getting some fine details across. It didn’t feel too gushy for a movie I clearly gush over. Since that piece came out nine months after the movie came out, having it be any longer also felt a little senseless. The world had beaten me to saying all the things about Into the Spider-Verse that I wanted to say. The movie has remained a favorite of mine since then and still seems to shatter my emotions.</p><p>Meanwhile the sequel was a phenomenal experience that dominated theaters all summer in 2023. It also surpassed the box office revenues of the first film and is a big conversation piece in super-hero movie circles. This sequel has left me equally emotionally shattered <em>and </em>speechless. I saw it three times in theaters and countless times since then. With the first film my writing boiled the movie down to three things: The music dominating the experience for me, a meditation on our own cultural relationship to Spider-Man being reflected in the film, and this fantastic exploration of Miles’s desires for approval and the struggles to find it from his family members in the ways that he needs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aPWUEN8BEFZ8_UBdFHs_1w.png" /></figure><p>Now, years later, it’s time for me to sculpt words about Spider-Man again. Not because the world needs these opinions but because I need to find the way to express it. <em>What</em> I need to express is a lot of things. Emotions, opinions, experiences, it runs a gamut. I think it took me the entire experience of writing this essay to even understand why both of these movies have impacted me so much. But even when not exploring my emotions, Across the Spider-Verse is just too dang cool for me to have found a video that sums up all the little things I’d love to say about it. In the interest of trying to make sure the world I inhabit is better off, I’m putting a couple things up front.</p><ol><li><a href="https://www.vulture.com/2023/06/spider-verse-animation-four-artists-on-making-the-sequel.html">100 or more animators on this movie quit</a>. Animators are often some of the worst treated workers in the film industry without the same union protections that the rest of Hollywood sees. Much like the terribly maligned quality assurance aspect of the video game industry, <strong>animators deserve better</strong>. The animating division behind Marvel Studios went on strike and I can only hope that the people behind Across the Spider-Verse who still <em>want </em>to work with Sony Animated Pictures can do the same. Because the best thing about the third part in this Spider-Verse trilogy that can happen is that the movie releases, it’s amazing, <strong>and </strong>the crew go to the news outlets saying “It was so much better making this one.” Wouldn’t that be awesome? Instead I have to put this point in here so that I don’t gush about this movie for an hour straight and then feel bad because I only sang the praises of a film while ignoring the people it harmed in the process. I’d love to do a similar talk about the third movie and not need this paragraph in here. I think you would too.</li><li><strong>Spoilers. So. Many. Spoilers</strong>. The movie’s on Netflix, I’d encourage you to go watch on DVD because the visual quality of this film is immensely drowned out by streaming but I’d rather you see it on Netflix than not at all so just, go see it, be spoiled with a great time, come back to this after.</li><li>Some of this stuff I heard from YouTube videos or memes and tumblr posts and all sorts of fans talking about the movie not long after it came out. I’ll include credit for perspectives I got from elsewhere where they come up.</li></ol><p>Across the Spider-Verse is <strong>dense.</strong> So dense in fact that I’m going to do something different. Usually when I write about a piece of media I try to focus on one aspect at a time, focusing the summary and fun stuff first, the more nuanced stuff that has my criticisms second, and then maybe a peaceful place of affirmation third. I can’t do that here. There’s too much going on and it’s overwhelming sometimes. Instead, I will provide the numerous things I’m going to be talking about here in a brief list and then I will talk about those things in order of the movie: Start to finish. Talking about all the things separately several times over would just feel stilted and ignore the way this movie hits bit by bit. So here it is, the things I’ll be discussing, in alphabetical order:</p><blockquote>Animation That Says It All<br>Breaking My Feels-Barrier<br>It’s Actually Gwen’s Movie<br>Miles’s Story<br>Mythos &amp; Meta<br>Parallels, the Poetry that Rhymes<br>Parents &amp; Teens <br>The Secret One<br>Score &amp; Soundtrack</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bTeAxdPGsxSNqfYqD9pNRA.png" /><figcaption>“I didn’t know…how to tell you.”</figcaption></figure><h3>Act 1 —Earth-65 &amp; Spider-Gwen</h3><p><em>Parallels, the Poetry that Rhymes </em>| S<em>core &amp; Soundtrack<br></em>I’m going to be giving this score and soundtrack praise a lot. Daniel Pemberton just knocks it out of the park in specific ways I love on the regular. But here in the intro, I can at least talk about some structure and theming and “sequel” stuff. Across the Spider-Verse is the “dark” sequel to the uplifting Miles Morales origin film. The approach in the music is the same for the opening credits shots while being different; we get hints of The Spot’s whining cry, Miguel O’Hara’s dystopian future, and then when it’s time to start showing anything visually, we get the rock-focused introduction from Gwen Stacy and The Mary Janes. Here’s a fun fact I don’t have too much time for: Many of the comic stills in this intro are quite literally lifted from the comic panels of <em>Spider-Gwen #0: Most Wanted?</em> The intro is similar to how Peter Parker introduced us to the idyllic Spider-Man in the first film, but this time the guitar and Gwen’s drum patterns that get more and more out of control scream that this is a story of how things got bad, how they fell apart, how it went all wrong. It’s a tragedy. I just love setups like this one and Daniel’s score helps set that tone a lot. Easter eggs are <strong>littered </strong>across this opening sequence that express new details we didn’t know before, speak to how canon events are being broken (or were maybe never really there to begin with) and the message at the end of the film will suggest how all of that is <em>good. </em>But make no mistake, this is Spider-Man’s “Empire Strikes Back” and the opening is sending a message of foreboding stakes through flashy sonic imagery, music and a hint of narration from Gwen. “I didn’t want to hurt him. But I did. And he’s not the only one.”</p><p><em>It’s Actually Gwen’s Movie | Parents &amp; Teens | Mythos &amp; Meta<br></em>We’re also going to see a lot of this one, but ATSV is every bit a movie about Gwen Stacy from Earth-65 (aka: Spider-Woman/Spider-Gwen) as it is about Miles Morales, maybe even more so. She’s the first character we get to spend time with in this movie and she’s the last character on screen at the end. She has an entire arc in this film and the writers start off trying to hone the edges of what was defined for her in the first film. In <em>Into the Spider-Verse </em>(hereafter called ITSV), it’s made vaguely clear that Gwen was best friends with Peter Parker in Earth-65 and fighting him as The Lizard resulted in Peter’s death. In <em>that </em>movie Peter visually looked like the same Peter framed across the whole movie from both Miles’s dimension and Peter B. Parker’s dimension, but this movie semi-retcons this to make Peter smaller, seemingly closer to Gwen’s age, and expand the complications of the whole situation (much like her original comic).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xdm1KXa2S4VWr8n8D456eg.png" /><figcaption>A shot that we’re going to see repeated later</figcaption></figure><p>In short: Gwen is hounded by the chief of police for killing Peter Parker when in truth Spider-Woman of Earth-65 fought Peter Parker as The Lizard, who turned himself into The Lizard and attacked a school dance in an attempt to get back at a bully. Peter was clearly out of control at that point and fought Gwen in the process and got himself killed under the rubble resulting from the fight. It’s a <strong>yikes</strong> of a situation only given more “yikes” when Gwen finds out Peter knew about her secret identity all along, and then further complicated by the fact that Gwen’s dad is the cop who was on the scene shortly after the fight and found Spider-Woman (Gwen) mourning over Peter’s dead body. In classic Spider-Man fashion: Spider-Woman is publicly blamed for killing Peter Parker and Captain Stacy is now constantly hunting Spider-Gwen, his own daughter, but he doesn’t know it. Gwen now continues to live in Earth-65 wracked with guilt over Peter’s death, and frustrated by the fact that a new friend she made that can deeply relate to this whole mess lives in a completely different dimension. They’re both stuck, separated. He’s a Spider-Man, elsewhere. Understandably: Gwen is upset about, uhm, <strong><em>everything?</em></strong></p><p>This situation for Gwen hits its natural inflection point that drives <strong>the entirety of the movie’s plot</strong> when Gwen gets in a fight with a villain from another dimension and her dad gets the drop on her as Spider-Woman. Unable to escape her dad’s gunpoint, she does the unthinkable thing as a Spider-Person and reveals her identity to him. Her dad does the <em>next</em> unthinkable thing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0OX0ilAunzFvIES2R81g9w.png" /><figcaption>“Right?”</figcaption></figure><p>He rejects her, aligning with his version of the truth instead of hers, and tries to place her under arrest.</p><p>The lasting legacy and origins of Spider-Man are a story about coming of age, about being a teenager, about adolescence and the changes that come about from it. Romance. Puberty. Emotions. All that jazz is dialed up to 11 by having the person experiencing these things be a teenager with <em>superpowers</em>. Another aspect of teenage fiction in general is identity, the idea of figuring out who you are in this world and who you want to be, coming to grips with who you are and trying to be accepted by the world around you for it, and y’know, contributing to the world, etc. Spider-Man’s mythos is that he has problems while developing that identity. In ITSV, Miles’s problems begin with taking up the mantle while not wanting to and losing his Uncle Aaron literally and metaphorically in the revelation that he’s a criminal, who is quickly gunned down at the moment he might turn things around.</p><p>In Across the Spider-Verse, Gwen, child to a single father with no siblings, lost her best friend to becoming a villain and watched him die in the process. She is now hunted by her own dad due to her secret identity. Gwen’s version of the mythos works like any other in script, but we’re implanted in it in an incredible way because visually and thematically it centers around identity <strong>challenged </strong>by those problems. Miles questions if he wants to be this. Gwen questions <em>h</em>ow to be this. Through an introductory sequence we repeatedly see Gwen’s reflection cast as Spider-Woman instead of Gwen or vice-versa, point being that Gwen is not just the one person but both identities. She remarks how this line of work is usually one where she works alone. This feels like a neat animation trick to quickly ensure you know who is who here but it takes on stronger meaning when Gwen approaches her home apartment from the fire escape. We’re shown Gwen from behind as she approaches a slightly open window, her dad cleaning and preparing for a day of work and Gwen observes her own reflection, showing back Spider-Woman instead of her human face. Gwen comes home every day worried that <strong>today </strong>is the day her dad has inspected the drum kit and happened to find her costume in there. She can’t be herself around her dad because she fears what will happen if he finds out: Judgment, arrest, abandonment. All things that also reject this identity of hers that she chooses to keep locked up. What other choice does she have?</p><p><em>Animation that says it all | Parents &amp; Teens<br></em>Over the next set of frames, note how Gwen is staged in distance with her dad and the contrast in her blue shades that demonstrate her continuing sorrow over her situation regarding Peter, her dad, Miles, and <strong><em>everything.</em></strong> Even take note that these color shades are almost “bloomed away” when she and her dad briefly throw the arguments about Spider-Woman and Peter aside and hug. It’s a phenomenal sequence of shots that establish everything you need to know about her relationship with her dad without words (even though there <em>are </em>words). Gwen is distanced to avoid the debate over Spider-Woman as a hero or a villain. She’s isolated from her source of warmth in this world due to this position and generally overly sorrowful.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DeQs1a4G491afeE0_O7dtg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*at73XzlVMF_assrVsnCZZA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ah1uKqEV9BAHu1QdpF9Y5Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CK6BxrIDblNlGEHULkehbA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3ASrJDuJwqGTw-dMWrvK0A.png" /></figure><p>And I love that this movie plays with this concept three distinct times for her and her dad because, as I said earlier, this is actually Gwen’s movie.</p><p>Just about anyone who struggled through personal identity in the teenage years can relate to these concepts. And while I don’t have the authority to speak about Gwen as a trans icon to fans, the color scheming and “set design” put in place by no doubt the couple hundred people involved in everything Gwen-related seems to do enough speaking on behalf of the struggles many people no doubt go through in our own world when it comes to this particular identity.<em> It’s not subtle.</em> It’s clear in this film Gwen got adopted as a trans icon. Icons rarely get to choose who they represent in the fictional world and since Gwen is entirely fictional, she doesn’t. She just is at this point.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ugabmr3IOIaqZb6qUU2bow.png" /></figure><p>Emotionally the art does so much of the heavy lifting in Earth-65 and the weight is at its heaviest when she has to reveal who she is to her dad. While we see similar paint behavior earlier in the movie when she’s arguing with her dad in the bedroom, it’s so much more emphasized when she’s revealing her identity to him. The way colors start to look like paint rippling down walls and the way it starts splashing the backdrop behind Gwen as she reveals her identity to her dad, the color palettes behind her during the reveal match the colors of the trans flag. It’s so easy to <em>comprehend</em> feelings in this moment. And look, if you think all of this is dumb then go enjoy some other multi-verse movie, I guess? If you think some kids and teens don’t struggle with this stuff and go through the same emotions Gwen does in this sequence then you need to spend some more time listening to other people’s experiences, whether they be trans in particular or identify as part of the LGBTQ+ community, there’s a clear cut attempt to empathize with a person who experiences this painful reality that Gwen does and the emotions of the sequence are gut wrenching while the visuals do so much heavy lifting to carry you into this moment further.</p><p>In addition, this is the scene where everything unfolds. It’s the part where Across the Spider-Verse (hereafter called “ATSV”) defines itself as<em> Gwen’s movie</em>. In a moment of extreme vulnerability, Gwen professes that need from her dad to “not be a cop for a moment and just listen.” And he doesn’t. It may not be for the entirety of her speech, but he eventually falters from his pain of realizing she’s been hiding herself from him, and leans back on feeling threatened by his daughter, he chooses not to believe her.</p><p>So she runs away.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yCrwNk7YXjfpOiZW3ayh6Q.png" /><figcaption>^ Gwen stands at a portal #1. This happens a few times.</figcaption></figure><h3>Act 2 — Guess Who’s Back</h3><p><em>Score &amp; Soundtrack | Parallels<br></em>Daniel Pemberton’s score on ATSV is undoubtedly one of the strongest things about the movie. I said it at the start of Act 1, I’m saying it again for Act 2. When a sequel is made to a movie that had a “cinematic musical moment” the way ITSV did with its blending of <em>What’s Up Danger</em> and the other motifs all at once during the movie’s high point, it would probably be easy for any composer to say “I need to top that moment”. There’s even parts of this screenplay that might offer up that opportunity. Instead, Danny P. seemingly said “Eh, how about I just make a freaking good score instead?” and we’re going to see a lot of that throughout but not quite yet. Instead act 2 starts off strong with the booming (pun intended again) Miles Morales version of the Spider-Man introduction I wasn’t anticipating but so excited to hear after Gwen’s opening act wrapped. Much like the end of this movie, it’s a moment where you feel “all in” for what this experience suggests. It’s interesting that Gwen starts the movie off saying we’re going to do things so different this time but so reliably are structures and formats from the first movie brought up again and again in terms of music and visual montage. “Numerous logo realities”, “It’s time for Spider-Man title cards montage”, and even more are repeated in this film but differently. When Miles first confronts The Spot during the start of this act we get Miles’s Spider-Man theme as he does the breakdown of where he is as a person instead of the previous Spider-Man’s perfect “‘the only’ Spider-Man ” that we got last time. In ways this film is <em>canonizing</em> the first film’s style and approach. But before all of that I want to draw attention to the <strong>soundtrack.</strong></p><p>Not the score that’s so amazingly composed by Daniel, but instead this selection of music that’s published outside the score to implement into this film by Metro Boomin’. Because there’s some specific focuses going on here and I don’t know if it’s Daniel’s choice or the director’s choice but I can’t help but talk about it. In both films whenever we inhabit Miles’s world for a time like we do here in act 2, we are <strong>inundated </strong>with diegetic music and non-score pieces. Our act kicks off with Rakim’s “Guess Who’s Back”, a pull not featured on any of the soundtracks that fantastically sets the tone for Miles’s love for New York and an excitement that we’re back in Miles’s shoes. Whenever we’re in Earth-1610 in <strong>both films </strong>we regularly get diegetic music at a pace we don’t experience anywhere else. In ITSV it made sense, we’re on Earth-1610 for the duration of the film. But this happens again in ATSV and the diegetic music <em>mostly stops</em> whenever we leave Earth-1610’s presence. The times it <em>is </em>diegetic in this film mostly resonate when we are exploring a character’s emotional state to set the backdrop of the film. Music is important to Miles, just like Gwen, and the movie uses that to ground us in Mile’s life. Once the action picks up this is mostly abandoned in exchange for a score with soundtrack pulls that fit scenes as expertly as before. I bring this up now and can point out the entirety of the sequence where Miles leaves his school campus to go visit Aaron and go spray painting in the first movie (a scene hip hop fans adored for the actual scratching and live mixing of three to four different popular songs used in maybe a forty-five second sequence of shots); but more of these songs will show their faces further in this act. There I won’t be quite as detailed as I am being now, but it’s worth also noting at this juncture just how many songs are used from this film’s soundtrack for these diegetic moments for the audience and Miles. I think it demonstrates just how strong the soundtrack is this time around. I loved it.</p><p>Further demonstrating the strength of the soundtrack woven into the film score is Metro Boomin’s actual work. In the first film soundtrack pieces were scattered all throughout the film but Danny and company also relied on more pulls from <em>outside </em>sources for that diegetic music. This time though Metro’s original soundtrack is relied on <strong>again and again</strong>, it feels so much more in line with the film’s moments while still demonstrating the musical interests Miles might have in this phase of his life. “Take it to the Top” is used while Miles runs to his meeting with his parents and the school counselor. “Silk &amp; Cologne” sets the vibes at Jeff Morales’s promotion party. And don’t get me started on the one-two punch of “I Can’t Stop” and “Hummingbird” moments later.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8bjWUHDpH1lUXb0N-ygM1A.png" /></figure><p><em>Miles’s Story | Parallels | </em>M<em>ythos and Meta<br></em>Since the movie spent 20 minutes setting up Gwen’s arc that’s so critical to this story, it gets right to the action setting up Miles’s villain and story at play too. It’s been a year, we get to catch up to Miles’s life simultaneous to his first fight with The Spot where he disregards The Spot’s importance while also trying to balance a personal meeting with his parents. We get to see Miles’s current struggles with debating telling his parents about being Spider-Man, we also get glimpses of how he’s developed his powers further to defeat villains, tried to modernize the Spider-Man presence with social media (YouTube, pictures) fused with his art style (regularly tagging villains he defeats the same way he did with Kingpin at the end of ITSV). These struggles are so forefront to what he’s dealing with that The Spot is just this nuisance to tie up and leave in place so he can go deal with the other things going on in his life right now. Sidebar: I love how there’s still some natural elements of teens being a little careless with things here. Gwen leaves her drum kit open when she leaves the apartment with a confidence that she’ll be back to close it before her dad finds it. Miles tries to juggle both stopping a villain that seems to want to talk to him while also semi-blowing-off his parents, thinking a little commitment to both is fine.</p><p>At the meeting with his parents and throughout the introduction we quickly comprehend just how much the events of becoming Spider-Man in ITSV influenced who he’s becoming. This plays more into the Spider-Man mythos and how to develop it for Miles. In the early comics Peter Parker was mostly wrapped up with being concerned for his aged Aunt May and some girl troubles every now and then. I’d call that a reductionist perspective for sure, and I will correct that perspective later, but Peter’s episodic problems in comics were still every day problems people deal with all the time (money shortages, responsibilities, etc.). But for Miles, he’s regularly concerned with the events surrounding the loss of his uncle, hiding who he is from parents that genuinely care for him, and what he’s going to do with his future. At the meeting with the counselor it’s clear he has fully embraced studying science not because he’s a nerd (the way Peter Parker was stereotyped) but because it’s the way to connect with others who understand what it’s like being Spider-Man, by traveling to other dimensions and meeting them again. This is a more reliable modern translation of creating connections and friendships the way many teens wind up doing in the omnipresence of the internet. While not universal, the experience of a teenager veering off into a community that parents don’t know about or don’t want their child to associate with is undeniably common. Wheras Peter Parker defined the power and responsibility dynamic, Miles is defined in part by the individuality dynamic for Spider-Man. He has his own way of doing things (as do all the Spider-Peeps) but the movie draws particular attention to these desires Miles carries with him daily. He wants to be with his friends again so much so that he’ll go into an entire field of science to make it happen (<a href="https://www.tumblr.com/kindaorangey/718969469518626816/miles-literally-chose-to-pursue-physics-instead-of?source=share">credit to that one tumblr post</a>). He wants to tell his parents about being Spider-Man so they’d understand his struggles and the reasons he’s late or messing up in front of them, but he’ll get into an argument with an attitude before he can let that truth come out for fear of rejection. His dad is a cop and has repeatedly spoken out against vigilantes. We’ve been here before.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gzf4isPQOzcenJ7kyeX7gg.png" /><figcaption>“Sometimes I just wish I wasn’t the only one. I don’t dwell on it.”</figcaption></figure><p>This central conflict for Miles is established and how he plans to resolve it is presented right as he walks into the counselor’s office. The counselor is remarking “You can’t have your cake and eat it too” and Miles walks in and proclaims casually: “Unless you bake two cakes.” This multi-tasking or accomplishing multiple things through the means of an inventive “why didn’t we just think of that” solution is maybe the second most important thing in the movie next to this being Gwen’s movie. I have to give credit to <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9nRzAjyqHQ&amp;pp=ygUjYWNyb3NzIHRoZSBzcGlkZXItdmVyc2UgY2luZW1hIHdpbnM%3D">CinemaWins</a> for pointing this out and then continuing to bring it up across their video. It’s a perspective I hadn’t considered before and I’m going to be bringing it up later. In this opening sequence for Miles involving The Spot and then his family, we’re establishing Miles’s own duality. He’s trying to be Spider-Man <em>and </em>Miles. His roomie Ganke suggests he’s being stretched a little thin, trying too hard to do everything. The counselor doesn’t really know who Miles is at all. He’s missing classes and got a lower grade on a language he’s seemingly fluent in. Later Jeff will remark to Rio “It’s like we got a whole other kid now” in regards to Miles’s changes and growth in his teenage years. Jeff even expresses some of this struggle to Miles as Spider-Man after a second fight with The Spot. “You think you’re getting pretty good at being a parent. You think you got it licked. And then they go and grow up.” We’ll talk about this duality element later with <strong>all other Spider-Characters</strong> when we get into the canon events as well as with Earth-42 Miles. Just remember: “Unless you bake two cakes.”</p><p>Let’s move on to parallels. These are some quickies but I feel like they stand out so much in the first half of act 2 the more I think about them. In Miles’s argument with his dad on the rooftop party, he practically cries out to his dad, “Just listen to me!” Jeff berates Miles while he’s trying to explain his behavior lately. Gwen goes through a similar “I need you to listen to me” moment when she unmasks in front of her dad and reveals her secret identity. Both events end in the characters distancing themselves from their parents, but to different effects. With Gwen she was going to be arrested so she runs way. With Miles, he shuts down, accepting the two-month grounding punishment handed to him. Not that the punishment matters much as Miles considers it over in his bedroom, “Two months. Psh. I’m Spider-Man, I’m not grounded.” Separately in The Spot’s development, we learn more about his past as a scientist at Alchemax that stole the spider that bit Miles from Earth-42. In these visions we get a brief glimpse of a photo that suggests he knew Olivia Octavius directly (who gets hit by a truck near the end of the first movie), though to what effect it’s not completely clear. He has a photo of the two of them together. When The Spot kicks himself into his own inter-dimensional travel state, he recognizes his ability to traverse dimensions in the multi-verse. Upon returning to Earth-1610 he remarks “The Power of the Multi-Verse in the Palm of My Hand”. I felt this interestingly tried to echo the film version of Doc Ock in Raimi’s Spider-Man 2 wherein Octavius experienced a personal tragedy at a technological disaster involving technology of his own making (wife dead) and wants to tap into the power from that event even more (“power of the sun in the palm of my hand”). The Spot may not have been the husband of this universe’s Doc Ock (who had a relationship with this universe’s Aunt May at one point), but he did suffer this massive technological failure and wants to reach into that technology more to unleash his capabilities. I just found it an interesting parallel.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7UiBAc7ex7sKUbvcUkPf3w.png" /><figcaption>Speaking of interesting parallels</figcaption></figure><h3>Act 2.5 — “Miles, You Got a Minute?”</h3><p><em>Gwen’s Story | Music &amp; Score | Animation That Says It All<br></em>Gwen is lying to Miles. It’s something I have to remind myself on rewatches because the chemistry between these two characters, even though animated and voiced, is so enjoyable despite there being some clear differences in their upbringing. Fans liked to point out how Gwen rudely sits on the bed with her shoes on, immediately is poking around in Miles’s privacy by looking at his drawings and removes a collectible toy from its box. With some subtle differences in character and the big reveals later in the movie, part of me wonders if the two of them <strong>won’t</strong> pursue this unspoken thing after the events of this film and instead just remain friends by the end of the trilogy. Separately it comes off as just this funny thing that happens where teens are oblivious to their surroundings or awkward because they’ve got a crush.</p><p><em>But </em>Gwen is also avoiding answers. At first the confusion of how she’s visiting is brushed aside, reasonably so because Gwen’s used to hopping dimensions and she’s not (per Miguel’s rules) supposed to be here. Miles asks how she’s been and she also brushes that aside the way most people in general greeting exchanges do (“I’m fine, look at you!”). Everything here is <strong><em>technically </em></strong>okay but Gwen <strong>has</strong> to avoid any attention to the two reasons she’s here: 1) she’s run away from her problems at home by joining a Spider-Society that rejects Miles for his “anomaly-status” and 2) she’s actually here to catch The Spot and not supposed to see Miles at all. It’s the animation and voices that spells it all out so well here and in the proceeding sequences. She truly starts deviating from the conversation after initial exchanges. Miles finally gets to ask, “So what are you doing here? I mean, I thought I’d never see you again.” Gwen has no answer, sits on the edge of the window, and simply asks, “Wanna get out of here?” She’s still running away, turning Miles away from his questions with the enticing safety in their own friendship; Gwen’s running from having to tell Miles something he deserves to hear about his past and powers because she’s believing some lies we’ll get into later. But also because Gwen is still trying to just be with someone who gets her. For now, Gwen’s misdirection works and she’s able to go have some fun with Miles swinging across New York.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*x_5O7LREUbJMivqWqnwRKQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YWgs7ocCaXEA-j0ofJBczA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s-79a3cyxYmv2EwOz5rZqw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*u84nfqg1xjNStKCHex89vg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qKKEVbV_k3_MSPrXpAW6AA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vDIhi4yNVgURMizlzo7Pag.png" /></figure><p>Here I want to call attention to a string of musical choices and compositions that just carry you across this mini-act in the film. “Hummingbird” provides that darker undercurrent of Miles’s emotional isolation as part of his initial reaction to the fight he has with his dad. For now, he can’t explain his double life and withdraws as a result. The score piece “Miles Sketchbook” during Gwen’s arrival brings back that familiar whistle motif dealing with the strangeness of Miles’s sudden adolescence that started when he got bit. Then “Mona Lisa” is so perfectly <em>in the moment</em> to the time Miles and Gwen spend having fun as themselves for just an hour. It’s bumpy, acoustic, it features just the right balance for that evening out during a New York spring. “Another Dimension” carries that happy vibe from Mona Lisa straight into the neon-tinged comic-colors of the upside down view of Miles’s New York skyline. It’s slowing down for a heavier heart to heart talk about <em>all the things</em> for a little bit. Daniel takes over the music afterwards in “Under the Clocktower” for a beautiful piece further underlining the romantic tensions here and how they’re not quite ready to share more than what’s been shared. The way the music strings you from Hummingbird to Under the Clocktower is the sort of thing that I can’t wrap my brain around but love. Things by the end move as slow as when we started on Hummingbird but we’re transported to a whole other place.</p><p>And we’re back here at the reality that this is Gwen’s story. Maybe if Gwen was a little more open things would move faster between her and Miles but the last time she was utterly truly vulnerable, her dad tried to arrest her. Gwen is informed by her experience of being rejected by her dad so much that the only solution she has found to this problem is still the run-away, avoiding what took place before and hoping to find entire solace within the Spider-Society. The dialog between Miles and Gwen makes it clear she caught Miles up on what happened to her recently and Gwen confirms she can’t really go back because the problem seems impossible to solve to her. Miles mentions he’s been considering doing the same as she did, revealing who he is to his parents. But Gwen, still without an answer as to how to solve this for herself, projects, and tells Miles he shouldn’t.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w-zoHr7uNlD94sbClorI0A.png" /><figcaption>“There’s a first time for everything, right?”</figcaption></figure><p>This is right when Gwen goes under the clocktower and it creates distance between them briefly and we get to visually see that distance created. Miles is uncertain about what she warned about. The conversation then goes on to how some conversations are probably only for between Spider-People, Miles following what Gwen’s laying down for him. But here’s the thing: Gwen’s <em>wrong</em>. Jeff’s speech at the party while Miles is absent only reinforces that Jeff and Rio would ultimately support Miles at the end of the day, even if they have difficulty doing it. But this is Gwen’s story, about how she messed everything up, and so this is the second action Gwen has taken to hurt Miles without realizing it. The first step was not telling him about Miguel’s rules about Miles, the second step was telling Miles not to tell his parents. I’m saving a nugget here for Act 4. Just remember “Authority Figure”. But Gwen being misguided here is part of the big picture is all I’m getting at.</p><p>The rest of the clocktower sequence is <em>everything</em> we love about this movie. Miles, Gwen, a beautiful landscape perceived in a unique way. The brief mention of “Gwen-canon” and Miles’s own response to it (“there’s a first time for everything, right?”) is another example of our beloved two-cakes-theory at work, even if I haven’t completely explained it yet. Miles is recognizing that in a multiverse, <em>anything</em> is possible, while the world continues to live by the constraints that things will always go a certain way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1uEfF4TB7Hc6nn28hCe7Hw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OhPXWcPzvIGT1GhclNzJ-w.png" /></figure><p><em>Mythos &amp; Meta<br></em>To get a head start on the debate that takes place in Act 4: It should be noted that Gwen was sent here because of The Spot’s presence <em>elsewhere </em>in the Spider-Verse after he kicked himself into himself. Holes have been opening around the universe before The Spot uncovered this power and <em>Miles </em>hasn’t left the multiverse ever, so we already have evidence supporting that The Spot or something else is our troublemaker; the cause for all these problems that the Spider Society keeps having to clean up. This is important later on when we engage the massive conversation that’s central to Act 4.</p><p>Oh, unrelated but I needed to mention this before I moved to the next act. <a href="https://youtu.be/JHfoV0YvTwA">This shot.</a> Watching this shot frame by frame is mind blowing every time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gj9Tofmr49ehj-U1pETvhQ.png" /></figure><h3>Act 3 — “You have to promise me Miles.”</h3><p>Okay technically I’d say Act 3 doesn’t really start until Miles leaves his dimension for Mumbattan but we can call this little chunk after the clocktower as setup for the third act, otherwise it’s sadly shortened as Act 4 really starts when they go to Neuva York. Rio’s speech is also so central to giving the film a little restart on its action and onset. You can tell the story is really getting a setup here and once Miles takes the fire escape we’re taking our first real steps on a bigger journey.</p><p><em>Parents &amp; Teens | Miles’s Story<br></em>Let’s back pedal though to Miles &amp; Gwen’s return to the party for Jeff and we get some good development between Miles &amp; Gwen and Jeff &amp; Rio. It’s a fun “meet the parents” sequence even though Miles &amp; Gwen aren’t a couple. The speech that follows though is such a foreshadowing moment. At first I didn’t get why Rio’s speech to Miles was splattered all over the trailers other than the implications that the Spider-Society wasn’t going to be what he had hoped for and to set up a theme of the bond between Rio and Miles. But those that have seen the movie a couple times now recognize that Rio’s speech is so important because <em>every word of it comes true</em>. Her worries are all accurate and even though that’s some movie magic it works so well in retrospect. Allows us to go line by line for a moment. <strong>Concern</strong>: “…What I worry about most is they won’t look out for you like us. They won’t root for you like us.” <strong>Reality</strong>: Mile’s friends don’t back him up enough and the rest of the Spider-Society have no interest in protecting Miles. <strong>Concern</strong>: “You have to promise…he never doubts that he’s loved. And he never lets anyone at those big fancy places he’s gonna be in tell him that he doesn’t belong there.” <strong>Reality</strong>: Miles feels abandoned by people he thought cared about him more than they have and will. Peter B. Parker won’t stand-up to Miguel. Gwen does but only after she follows his orders first and realizes he’s wrong later. Miguel outright tells Miles he doesn’t belong there and that he was never supposed to be Spider-Man. <strong>Concern: </strong>“And when he comes home (and he better come home!)…Just, don’t get lost.” <strong>Reality: </strong>Yeah, he doesn’t make it home, he thinks he does until the twist is revealed. And he gets lost in an entirely other dimension.</p><p>Miles is rejected by the Spider-Society that he so desperately wants to join, told he will never fit in, betrayed by his closest friends, and he gets literally lost in the wrong dimension. Every worry Rio has for her son comes true. It’s a parental nightmare and a key point in Miles’s journey later when he gets “home” and recognizes everything she said was right, further bringing him in alignment with his family over the Spider-Society.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HjJChDIuKw2G4Jsra4Vgqw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JPWMCXhU8bslEQFBQ0yGKg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Unrelated but the visuals underneath the watertower are some of my favorite “grounded” visuals in the film. Miles is looking out at the city at night and you can see the visual splendor that allures to what Miles yearns to experience more as night is falling, you hear the echo of the party on the rooftop below him, but he’s stuck, refusing to go back to his family while yearning for something beyond the amazing view in front of him. I’m a suburbanite who has always lived close to the city, but never constantly lived in it so it’s another situation where there’s something beautiful here for me that I can’t quite put to words.</p><p><em>Animation that Says it All | Score + Soundtrack<br></em>The next sequence of scenes after Rio lets Miles go I feel are so expressive and easy to put together in conversation here. The track “Annihilate” that plays as Miles rushes to chase after Gwen visually blends with the dark neon-tinged lighting to express the thing Miles is eager to run towards; it sets the hint that this is going to get him in a world of trouble, but as the lyrics say: “Nothing can shake me now”. The sensation that this is a turning point for Miles venturing out into the unknown is growing across the entirety of the next five minutes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*80f5wDp4tq6OqGC0Z8IOPg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The plot progresses on camera; The Spot begins universe-jumping while Gwen was hanging out with Miles, Miles (and by extension the audience) learns Gwen wasn’t supposed to go see him and that Gwen is in trouble with her mentor figure Jess Drew (Spider-Woman) for doing so. Lastly Gwen vows to never see Miles again. The framing of the sequence before Miles hops into her portal to chase after Spot is able to say more without words. The circular holes left behind by Spot and the semi-destroyed building allows for a framing of the world beyond the problems of the immediate. Miles is being drawn away from that world to chase after Gwen and his future as a Spider-Person. We’re enclosed in this now. There’s even a little “Spider-Man Mythos” play on Gwen turning away from the upside-down Spider that’s in front of her face (albeit he’s invisible); a little play on “the kiss” moment from Raimi’s Spider-Man 1 while the moment isn’t being expressed as romantic and instead as one of an uncertain ache on both the parts of the Miles and Gwen dynamic, but for separate reasons. Miles is uncertain of what his friendship with Gwen means if she is following rules to never see Miles again. Meanwhile Gwen is uncertain because she knows in her heart this is wrong. But she’s been told by authority figures to not do that (again, more on that in Act 4). What they both want is in front of them, but there’s a lack of awareness happening on two fronts. Miles continues to look at Gwen and the portal to another universe behind her, but he doesn’t know what he’s getting himself into (as if the warning signs are invisible to him, get it?). And Gwen is looking at Miles without <em>her</em> knowing it, her gaze set on the city behind him as a representation of her heart’s desire for friendship, something Miles doesn’t even realize until he turns around and sees the city. While Gwen is certainly aware that she wants Miles’s friendship, she doesn’t realize it’s closer than the vista in the distance, it’s not some impossible dream. And while Miles is aware of what he wants, he doesn’t show himself right away and his spidey-senses aren’t telling him to stay here. It’s funny how in this moment, if they did just talk, all that comes after might’ve been avoided. But Gwen hid behind her misdirection earlier, and left without resolving things with Miles, and Miles didn’t reveal himself to Gwen before she could leave, choosing only to follow after spying on her.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vUBciGARhfXOfgCNmyJn2w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Mbz0WoVrgy96adXq266-ng.jpeg" /><figcaption>Gwen in front of portals again ^</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FvO1Dh4G69vKwVYimZgYPQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Miles remaining invisible during Gwen’s investigation is interesting in the fact that many “just talk” critics don’t show up here like they normally would. I feel in ways this is because the plot has, for the audience, properly given us the breadcrumbs to not trust everything going on here. Jess and Miguel had a separate on-screen conversation about why Gwen can’t join, but they let her. And then Gwen is clearly acting suspicious and not being entirely honest with Miles about her going after Spot. Miles is a quick study and seems to catch on pretty quickly that Gwen’s being dishonest but his affection makes him excited to go help her all the same. It’s a choice he makes and that shapes his character even better when you see him casting off those doubts and excited to help Gwen in Mumbattan. Interestingly, there’s an alternate version of this sequence as a deleted scene on the DVD and Miles uncloaks there during a conference call and meets several characters who outright reject him without a full explanation. Whether his hesitance in the final version of the film is because he’s already aware of Gwen’s dishonesty without having full answers or because he’s heeding the advice his mother gave him, I think what Miles is most blind to is what he’s potentially running away from by so quickly leaping into the portal. He’s made aware of it with Gwen’s departure, but chases his heart first and throws caution to the wind in that moment.</p><p><em>Animation that Says It All | Mythos &amp; Meta | Miles’s Story</em><br>Continuing the “Animation that Says It All” category, Mumbattan is a visual feast to behold and the point of “ramp-up” in the story’s rising action. Features on the DVD tell the story of how the initial animation passes of the city were disappointing to many animators of Indian heritage and wanted the opportunity to improve it. The end result is a work of immense passion and love for Indian culture. It’s the city that never stops from a vertical perspective and a perfectly placed experience in the story. Things are quickly ramping up in Mumbattan after about 15–20 minutes of taking things a little slower during Act 2. While we don’t spend more than 14 minutes here, we get so much in that time. Here the movie shows a couple new characters, ups the stakes, and delivers some action set pieces. The fast paced action allows for so much of the city to be shown and we condense more information in a montage introducing Pavitr Prabhakar aka: Spider-Man India. For the first time in a while we get to have a Spider-Person introduction akin to what we saw back in Into the Spider-Verse. It’s funny, quick, and establishes how new to all this Pavitr is. Later we get an absolutely astonishing introduction to Spider-Punk (Hobie Brown) and an animation style that breaks my eyes every time I watch it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3ihuybSIqUCAulh8PPJGag.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s here in the third act that the 2-movie villain for Miles (The Spot) really starts to take form. It’s worth noting how villainy is kind of complicated in these movies up to this point. For ITSV, Miles’s villain is more himself than anything, holding himself back from facing down Kingpin until he’s fully risen (by falling) to meet his identity. For ATSV, The Spot is the larger scope villain and he represents <em>something</em> but it’s hard to place because it’s seemingly empty at first (like a hole!). Spot wants to fight Miles because he places blame on Miles for what’s happened to him, but also just kind of because? He’s clearly aware of their symbiotic existence. That importance isn’t really clear to Miles until The Spot powers up and Miles recognizes just how out of control the situation is getting after he leaves home. In the fight against The Spot in Mumbattan, Spot is on cloud nine with how he’s tapped into his powers but there’s one little moment that demonstrates his primal rage. The collider is powering up and he’s briefly stopped all the other characters and he walks up to Miles. “This is going to be good for us Spider-Man. You and me, we’re finally going to live up to our potential. You’ll finally have a villain worth fighting for. And I won’t be just <strong>a joke to you.” </strong>The Spot explained in his big speech earlier in the movie that everyone has laughed at him after his injury transformed him. In an early scene that got cut, The Spot was supposed to go to a villain bar in New York and try to join them only to be laughed out of the room. When The Spot first revealed himself to Spider-Man, he also laughed at his goofy looks and powers. In “Lego Movie” fashion, Spider-Man attempts to stop Spot at the last second in a similar fashion to that of the other Lord &amp; Miller films: “You’re not a joke”. He tries to reason with The Spot and give him the whole “You don’t have to be the bad guy” speech but it’s too late. The Spot knows what he has to do to be taken seriously. The Spot’s funny presence as a villain not being taken seriously across Act 2 means that when he’s showing his strength here in Act 3, we may not quite feel the stakes of what he can do. But we get the vision of potential future realities where Spider-Man’s dad will die at the hands of The Spot and can understand <em>this </em>danger. But Spot also <strong>disappears </strong>for most of the movie after this point. As I said: Getting the danger of villains across in these movies is kind of complicated.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6jUe0rjKDpJ8rPQbG1TKnA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CQEmjq0-VMmfkWIqp2RJhA.png" /><figcaption>“Our future”</figcaption></figure><p>Despite that, the real motivation behind Spot’s villainy is also a present monster in the film for Miles to face down: Rejection. While The Spot was laughed out of every interaction post-hole-event, never to be taken seriously as either a human, a villain, or archnemesis, Miles is soon to realize all of his closest friends have or will be lying to him, practically belittling him, or rejecting his status as a super hero. While Act 4 will show this stuff, the conflict finally getting stakes in Act 3 is excellently placed to mirror image what Miles did wrong with regards to The Spot against what is about to happen to him. Miles didn’t take The Spot seriously. And now everyone else is about to do the same to him. This is a story that spirals outwards into reality in ways. ITSV was poorly marketed by Sony before release, demonstrating a lack of faith on behalf of the publisher in the project. While the relationship between Lord / Miller and Sony seems to be fine at the end of the day, one can wonder what the dividing line is between The Spot and Miles. How far removed is Miles from turning into a villain just like The Spot? Exactly how much kindness from Miles instead of ridicule would’ve stopped The Spot in his tracks and changed his ways? ATSV really pushes us towards asking these questions about how we proactively treat others before they’ve had a chance to prove anything, or more importantly: Before they’ve even had a chance to prove everyone wrong.</p><p>Lastly, on Miles’s story for Act 3: It’s cool to see him quickly take comfort in a leadership role during the big disaster sequence. The teamwork is great to see in motion. Also a note here in advance of act 4 is that the hole that shows up in the bottom of Mumbattan is indeed, a <strong><em>hole, </em></strong>and not a glitch-out-of-existence that Miguel knows about from the world he destroyed. Glitching in the Spider-Verse movies historically have a colorful distortion effect followed by multiple versions of a thing layering over each other in an explosively artistic way. What shows up in Mumbattan isn’t that, it’s a hole. This is <strong>not</strong> canon breaking<strong>. </strong>It’s another string in the web of mistruths being spun by Miguel that I have to mention here so I can talk about it soon.</p><p>Act 3’s time in Mumbattan is quick, action-packed, and I have no particular category for this but there’s just so much to love. Seeing Spot with his powers unleashed is fun, Spider-Punk is cool in every frame, Pav’s young and uplifting energy consumes the scenes so well, and you gotta love that chai joke. It ups stakes and transitions things over to Act 4 with ease.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XyL1FqLkWmlbIMyxXZIZIg.png" /><figcaption>“My dad is about to be Captain”</figcaption></figure><h3>Act 4 — “I’mma Do My Own Thing”</h3><p>Oh jeez. Uhm. Let’s start with the <em>fun </em>stuff, I guess?</p><p><em>Score &amp; Soundtrack | Animation that Says It All<br></em>Daniel Pemberton didn’t get a single Grammy nomination for his work on Across the Spider-Verse. And that’s a shame. Sony submitted it for a few awards, one of which included his work on the final piece in the film “Start a Band”, which got plenty of fanfare as the movie hit theaters because it’s this fantastic layer cake that you hear being built piece by piece. But honestly this movie’s score shows tremendous strength here in Act 4 where Daniel carries us through seven minutes of music for the Canon Event explanation followed by a chase sequence that has to take a three minute breather in the middle to give an important character some room to try and rationalize some things for Miles before the chase can continue into its moonshot climax. Part of the beauty of Danny’s work on this score is in its simplicity to use motifs and themes that are recognizable and/or stirring. This is what makes his work in Act 4 so unbelievable, because Act 4 is anything <em>but</em> simple. Neither is this movie at times. Across the Spider-Verse is the longest animated film built by an American studio and features five <strong>non</strong>-distinct acts and the chase sequence following the Canon Event scene is so <strong>pivotal</strong> to setting up the true stakes of this film and its inevitable sequel. So much so that there’s not much else going on in Act 4 in terms of plot. It’s all about the Canon Event conversation and how Miles is going to react with some added fun by having a thousand different Spider-Characters on screen. And when that chase is done you still have 30 minutes of movie to get through. If the music doesn’t hit here like it’s the climax of a whole movie that still has some gas left in the tank, it could’ve fallen apart.</p><p>But Mr. Pemberton pulls it off stupendously. The “Canon Event” suite gives us the name for specific motifs we’ve been hearing for the past 90 minutes and carries us through the wonder of the multi-verse, the delicate way all of it weaves together, how Miguel has done achingly bad things for his own self-interest and done irrevocable damage to entire realities, it hints at the very dark possibilities of Miguel’s controlling personality, and the overwhelming response by Miles that rejects the whole operation with a devastating strike to Miguel’s authority. The fusion of string and synth work here is majestic and the bassline is foreboding as can be when the tension in the room starts ramping up. The chase sequence music phenomenally blends “Light the City Up” with Daniel’s own score piece so seamlessly it took me two viewings to realize that they were actually two distinct pieces of music. And what a pull! Light the City Up feels directly written by Miles making a statement of being underestimated and forced into the corner, with his only response to, well, “throw some gas on it”. And then the six minute “Nueva York Train Chase” score piece expresses the frenetic, frantic rush by Miles as he attempts to escape an entire world that’s out to stop him from doing the right thing, no friends to help him any longer. It’s fast, it’s dazzling, and it trails off into a drop from space when Miles realizes the betrayal by his friends runs deeper than he knew even ten minutes prior: They knew <strong>everything</strong> and chose to keep him in the dark.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YIpXMAQfYl7c21BSMmwdEA.png" /><figcaption>“Then why didn’t you come see me?”</figcaption></figure><p>On the animation side of things, people are going to be enjoying the chase sequence for years to come. The team on this movie made sure the most important thing is center frame but there’s just so many Spider-People on screen it’s impossible to catch it all without freezing the movie every few seconds and just taking in all the art. One of the rumors I heard is that the animation team spent almost an entire year on scenes involving the Spider-Society, and it’s hard to think that might be a lie when you watch all the scenes that have <strong>all the Spider-People</strong>. They must have spent two to three weeks alone just looking for different people in the real world to bring into this fiction in different ways, including Dayn Broder’s spdiersona creation of the Spider-Person that uses crutches and a wheelchair, voiced by Danielle Perez, a comedian, actor, and writer that also uses a wheelchair. The finely tuned detail in these shots is immaculate and sometimes on screen for mere <em>frames</em>. The burgers in the Spider-Society cafe have Miguel’s Spider-Mask-face on them. There’s a Spider-Cat, a Spider-Dino, a Spider-Therapist that deals with the grief of all the Spider-Characters, a Spider-Practice-Course where they fight holographic displays and prepare for their big “be on a bridge holding two heavy things” moment. Nueva York is a dazzling place to observe. Miles falls from the Spider-Society tower that defies internal physics down to a city below through flying car traffic, falls through the ground into an underground system of machines and finds a way to escape into underground highway traffic and then rides a train that drives vertically towards the moon on a skyrail. It’s a crazy amount of movement through a world’s various different sectors and blends seamlessly, all while dancing to the tune of a constantly flashing cyberpunky color scheme. Don’t rush the next movie. Take your time. Don’t crunch the animators. Please. It’s so pretty. Just look at all this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WbCkNoBNuGX-A6v5Fxn77A.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Zov-fxUNkZXHZSYL33y9eA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_9mXJDqDmyoJycbLUUFKcg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fQMB5G05PgpmdVwxMOHBeQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Mythos &amp; Meta | Mile’s Story | It’s Actually Gwen’s Movie | Breaking the Feels Barrier | Parents &amp; Teens</em></p><p>Time to talk about <strong>the big thing</strong>. Act 4 is particularly hard to talk about because it bears importance on defining every main character, who is also present within the Canon Event scene itself. I’m not going to lie, I can’t watch Miles burst out of that trap set by Miguel, or stand up to that train of people after saying “I’mma do my own thing”, or watch Gwen get that smirk on her face at the end asking the audience “You in?” without either tearing up or just bawling big crocodile tears. I couldn’t understand why my feelings were always so overwhelming to me until I started writing this paragraph and then it became so unbelievably clear. So let’s try to tackle all of this, this act 4 insanity, in three runs. First, the mythos &amp; meta, then we’ll cover Miles’s perspective, and <strong>then </strong>Gwen’s. For reasons.</p><p>We have to talk about the mythos and meta here because the canon event sequence is about more than Miles or Gwen or even Spider-Man. It’s about hero stories in general and the way we choose to tell them. Fantastic writing was done not long after the poorly-received “The Flash” movie came out and how that movie is a direct failure to recognize the very things ATSV tackled so well. In “The Flash” the protagonist comes to the realization that he shouldn’t try to do the impossible and change the world for the better, he instead accepts that things that have happened already cannot be changed. It’s the entire crux of the story with Michael Keaton’s Batman standing in as the older generational voice trying to teach a younger hero character how the world works. While “The Flash” has a complicated element of time travel messing with the conversation (because no time travel fiction is complete without the precautionary warning of “if you change the past, you break reality or the future”), the writers forgot one stupidly important thing: It’s a superhero movie.</p><p>Audiences are routinely given superhero stories that reinforce narratives about the real world around them; that tragic loss cannot be avoided and that despite having powers, we are somehow powerless to change <em>anything</em>. I do have to admit that this conversation varies from character to character, writer to writer, and so on. But it doesn’t have to be the norm. We get lost in the idea that what <em>has been </em>always <em>should be</em>, structurally and universally. But we forget that before Frank Miller changed the face of Batman forever, Batman was, at one point, a guy dangling off a helicopter ladder trying really hard to use his shark repellent. Frank changed the character from an established, very successful norm that had been going for decades. Sure, superheroes can experience tragic things, but not because they <strong>have </strong>to, it should make for an interesting or gripping story. I think that’s why it’s so easy for people to get lost in the weeds on this when thinking about someone like Bruce Wayne. Because Batman is <strong>defined</strong> by a single tragedy, it creates him. And that’s interesting! But that’s one origin story that’s just been accepted as the norm for a long time now. In the wider cultural conversations about myths and hero stories, “canon” is often weaponized to erode variety in favor of singular realities instead of exploring why a change is interesting.</p><p>With Spider-Man, Stan Lee humanized superheroes, as we all know, by giving the <em>superhero</em>’s identity <em>human-sized </em>problems. In a series of early comics, Peter Parker/Spider-Man dealt with this string of issues: His aunt was sick. He couldn’t get enough money from ever-stingy JJ to pay for his Aunt’s hospital stay. But Peter didn’t want to give JJ photos that he’d just use to make Spider-Man look bad. Peter caught a fever once and it messed with his ability to stop crime for a couple days while people he cared about were in danger. The comics were about <em>adolescence</em> and <em>responsibility</em>. Somewhere in there, we confused the idea of “<strong>this superhero suffers a lot</strong>” with “<strong>heroes <em>have</em> to suffer to be heroes. It has to be in the script, it has to be the story.</strong>”</p><p>This is a lie. And Miguel believes it. So do many people who love heroic stories. This is a rogue personal opinion (but then again most of this is all my opinion so who cares?), but it seems like different generations want to hear these hero stories told in a way that reflects their own values. It works because we desire these stories oftentimes to see ourselves in them, the self-insert, instead of trying to inhabit a person’s experience. And while I can’t speak for my entire generation, I can confirm that <strong><em>a</em></strong> perspective millennials seem ever so abundantly capable of dolling out in these narratives is “Jaded sarcasm.” We care about what’s happening but can’t act like we care too much or we become too powerless to it. We joke about it instead and try to carry on. This is probably a bad approximation, but let’s think about Miles and Miguel and this whole “canon event” debate but from different value sets. The comparison was already made when “The Flash” came out that it’s trying to take the stance Miguel does in this movie, something understand vaguely as “older generational” even if the generation isn’t clear cut “Boomer” or “X” (and “X” has its own sub-sets honestly), but imagine if ATSV was written where the dominating perspective from Miles would be one of just some plucky response, pretending to not care too much about the implications of his dad becoming a Captain soon and just going “Eh, what does it matter? I’ll save the day. Let’s go stop Spot.” and then he has a funny but angry conversation about it with Peter later. Or what if we leaned a little more on the jaded end Miles would maybe be outwardly as indifferent as Miguel and accept the story being told? But that’s not what happens in Act 4. Instead, ATSV provides that perspective as the opposition (jaded sarcasm, and others, through Miguel) but ensures that a <strong><em>specific </em></strong>one shows its face by the time the credits roll. And I want to make the case that this perspective is what we need more of.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eOQdI_SsCVgi7tDKBM91cw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Heroes suffer because <em>humans </em>suffer. It’s just an aspect that makes them interesting: <strong><em>How </em></strong>do they respond to struggles? Bruce Wayne was born out of experiencing something that made him suffer for the rest of his life and it changed him. That’s what made him interesting. Peter Parker was awkward around girls and one day he got bit by a spider, and he continued to be awkward around girls. The bite didn’t change much and had nothing to do with who he was before. Spider-Man isn’t defined by his suffering, but by responsibility. That’s what made him interesting. He’s defined by the highs and lows of human existence all while juggling being a superhero. In the comics, Peter <em>did</em> eventually get married. He <em>did</em> find a way to pay for Aunt May’s surgery. Sometimes Spider-Man looked good to most of society and Peter chose to focus on that instead of JJ smearing him. He had good days that worked out for him. It just wasn’t every day. That’s what made him <em>dynamic </em>a<em>nd interesting.</em></p><p>Trying to decouple these warring perspectives (heroes must suffer terribly “because it’s the job” vs. heroes are humans choosing to do their best and trying to help everyone they can and that some suffering is just a part of their life) is what is central to the argument about canon events. Why must every Spider-Person experience the <strong>same</strong> traumas over and over? Is it because it makes them interesting? Or is it because that’s what’s been done before? Is it because we are confusing “this super hero suffers a lot” with “heroes have to suffer to be heroes”? Miguel O’Hara is a stand-in for the <em>answer </em>that heroes are destined to suffer to become heroes. It works as both a self-referential thing, making all Spider-Characters part of a shared canon, but also a conversation with the audience about whether or not we <strong>want </strong>to keep telling these stories again and again, both literally and metaphorically. “Do we want more Spider-Man?” Also “Do we want the same themes in every Spider-Man movie about someone dying because of responsibilities and sacrifice? Does it always have be <em>this</em> character?” Sure, the Spider-Verse stories remix these origins constantly. Miles’s uncle dies by being a villain, thereby complicating Miles’s desire to fight him. In Gwen’s story, Peter dies by being a villain (but in the comics they explore Gwen’s rage and not holding herself back when fighting him leading to her killing him). But in <strong>both</strong> it’s loosely because of who Miles and Gwen are and how they’re getting their personal lives tangled up with their heroic lives that makes it feel special and unique. It’s contrasting versions of the original Peter story mainly for the sake of telling the same story from a perspective that others might prefer or resonate with. The comics for these characters did this too in their own unique ways. But does someone <strong>have to die </strong>to teach a story about responsibility to a wider world compared to your own friends and family? Does it <strong>always </strong>have to be a police captain, thus stringing Miles and Gwen’s stakes to this canon in a specific way? Some movies may stray from these questions that just build and build. Many movies are lauded for just managing to <strong>ask</strong> them without answering. But a lot of us are tired of hearing the same answers every time. ATSV sets up these questions here in this act and our protagonists and the film don’t shy away from providing answers to those questions a little bit at a time, leaving us dangling for the remaining ones by the time the credits roll. Personally, I’m dying to know what the answers will be. I’m worried because the writer might might walk it back. It’s pretty rare for trilogies to end phenomenally. In many ways I and others are still reeling from the backtracking of “Rey Skywalker” five years ago at the end of Rise of Skywalker; it was the sign that an industry can’t escape nostalgia and follows Miguel’s stance that “what once was <strong>must </strong>continue to be”. My response to that statement, personally, is barf. Miles’s response is defiance. And even if the dust settles in a way I hate later, I love that the writers allowed this framing of the perspectives. Miles is right in his defiance.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YG18_nyhoBie9M2SA0nGFQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Now that we understand what this scene really is about, let’s start with Miles and his response. Act 4 is this culmination of everything we’ve been building up to for Miles. He’s amazed and excited to be where he is and ready to show Miguel that he can join this club. He has this interesting moment where he seems to connect with Margo Kess (aka Spider-Byte) and Gwen gets a little jealous. But then we get to the meat of the canon event sequence and Miles begins to comprehend all of this for what it is. First he’s on the defense, shielding himself from Miguel’s blame about “blowing another hole in the multi-verse” (as if he was the one doing the collider experiments back in the first movie; he wasn’t), and as discussed earlier, The Spot is responsible for what’s happening in Mumbattan. There’s a brief reunion with Peter B. Parker to catch us up on what he’s been up to. But we then get into the full breakdown of how canon events work. By the time we see the web collapse, Miles is clearly shaken with this knowledge. It’s understandably unnerving to think everything about what you do is predestined and that you can’t change any of it or the universe will collapse. How do you know you’re making the wrong choice? Miguel frames this first through how Miles saved Inspector Singh followed by Miguel’s own mistakes in the past regarding canon events. For Miles, he was just doing what came naturally to him and saving someone. For Miguel, Miles is risking destroying everything. There might be something interesting here in terms of parallels to modern technology for older generations vs. newer ones, and that very famous Jurassic Park quote definitely comes to mind, but I won’t dive into that.</p><p>Miles realizes following this canon event logic means his dad is bound to die. What I love about this moment is that Miles starts asking for answers everyone is scared to give, “When will it happen?” Sure, there’s some general concern for knowing the future and trying to stop it from happening, but what I love more is that Miles is already thinking about saving his dad. He asks when it’s going to happen and how and has no hesitation: “Send me back.” Miles’s stance on all of this is straight defiance. “You can’t ask me not to save my father”. His perspective is one of loyalty and love to his family and one of defying the accepted norm that canon events have to be followed every time. This gets meta-textual when he expresses “…all because some <em>algorithm </em>told you. You realize how messed up that sounds, right?” This almost alludes to the way these stories keep getting told is practically machine-based and has little to do with putting humanity into them. Having Miles’s dad becoming a Captain wonderfully complicates the question posed in Act 4. Heroes suffer sometimes because they’re human and that makes them interesting. Do heroes need to suffer because that’s the <strong>lore</strong>? The <strong>canon</strong>? Do we have to follow the canon <strong>this time</strong>? How bad will the fans react if we don’t do it that way? Miles even tries to rationalize this with Gwen, knowing her dad is also a Police Captain and faces similar certain death if this theory is true. Gwen’s response is a stoic but clearly rattled “Yeah”, making it clear she knows this is going to happen but either accepts it or simply knows no other thing to do. (and by the way how is Gwen leaving her current life behind not a canon breaking event?) Miles breaks loose when Miguel tries to lock him up and then during the escape there’s the larger revelation that the spider that bit Miles was from Earth-42, which <strong>suggests</strong> Miles was never meant to be bit and that him being Spider-Man in any reality is an anomaly itself. <strong>Your existence breaks lore. </strong>I wrote about it back when I wrote about the first movie, but I heard people negatively react to <em>that </em>movie existing by positing “Spider-Man can’t be black”, to which someone else replied, “Dude Spider-Man is a PIG. He can be anything”. Clearly some people didn’t hear the movie’s ending message of “Anyone can wear the mask” and to this day likely still don’t get it. Miguel telling Miles he’s not supposed to be Spider-Man is revisiting this conversation I heard all over again, acknowledging the awful cultural pushback we still see every time these stories are told again with a different spin. People reject the change, they go up in arms about some historical accuracy or lore-related version of a piece of fiction as if things have to be the same every time. I can’t imagine how tough it was for the first movie to be mostly ignored by Sony only for it to turn around so hard with accolades and fanfare, but even worse must’ve been the toxic reaction at Miles taking center stage for a Spider-Man movie.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8CeFUwEK8IeUeJpGz3UR5w.jpeg" /></figure><p>In-story, this theory about canon events doesn’t hold water the more you think about it because <em>something </em>has been creating more portals and sending characters across the Spider-Verse since before The Spot grew his powers. And Miles hasn’t been building a bunch of colliders that we know of. Something else is at play but ignored because Miguel already drew his conclusions and has blamed Miles for all of this. <strong>He’s not “supposed to be” Spider-Man.</strong> Miles suffers betrayal in layers from this mindset as he realizes no one wants to stand up with him except for Hobie (we’ll get to Hobie in a minute). First, no one came to him this whole time. As he mentions to Peter, they never came and found him when they had the ability to travel. Second, Gwen coming to see him meant Miles ran after her into other dimensions, leading Miles to this situation where he’s being pressured or physically restricted from saving his family, all leading up to the largest heartsink (#3): His friends believe this lie that Miles is dangerous and <strong>chose </strong>to shun him without his knowing, months ago. They all agreed Miles should never join the Spider-Society and never be visited by his friends. “You talked about this?” They all made this decision <em>about </em>him, <em>without </em>him, and then kept him in the dark. It’s gut wrenching to see him unfold just how much he’s being rejected for who he is.</p><p>In other translations, fans have rallied around Mile’s rejection of Miguel (“Nah, Imma do my own thing”) as a metaphor for generational divide conflicts. Miles, this young man, being told he’s just a kid who has no idea what he’s doing while Miguel accepts the old hero narratives and forces it onto Miles. Miles is told that to be part of the club you have to accept certain truths about the universe, one of those truths being “Yeah your dad has to die because he just happens to be making Captain, and you have to lose yet another parental figure because Spider-Person uncles die too.” If there’s anything I identify with easily these days, it’s younger generations expressing what an absolutely crap deal they’ve been dealt constantly by people who have power over them, for absolutely bogus reasons. They don’t want to be listened to. They don’t even get to change the world around them a lot of the time. But Miles does. And I <em>really </em>hope the writers continue to let him do that. Back in Miguel’s lab, Miles is interrupted but expresses “I can do both! Spider-Man always-(does both/saves the day)”. And while it’s true Spider-Man historically at times failed to save <em>everyone</em>, Miles is framed as the <strong>right person </strong>here in the lab and up on the train fight because Miles, being a young person who doesn’t have that dollop of jaded sarcasm us millennials have, knows <strong>it’s wrong to sit back and do nothing </strong>while his family, his emotional world, is about to be destroyed. The creators of this film seemed to recognize that younger generations are tired of people having this stance that just because things are terrible or bound to get worse means that we should just give in and give up. If I were as young as Miles, yeah, I’d be tired of stories being told that we can’t try for something better. It’s different for everyone, but my experience with this was first being asked what I wanted to do with my life, as if the whole world was available to me. Then as I got older, I was told that so long as my grades were good, I could go to college and do whatever I wanted with my life. By the time I was nearing high school graduation, the conversation had turned into “You want to pick a college degree for a field that’ll pay you well so you can have the nice life you want.” Affording college stopped being a conversation by then. I got to watch all those “promises” slowly disappear. And if you noticed, I didn’t mention anything about being told to expect school shootings. While they were absolutely a reality while I was in school, they were somehow on the periphery for me and the schools I attended in (both private and public) never put me through the mental strains and exercises of preparing for an active shooter event. I don’t know what it’s like to be told from the outset that everything’s already ruined. Younger generations <strong>love </strong>this movie, this <strong>moment</strong>, this stance Miles has on it. Miguel is wrong. We know it. And now Miles does too. And Miles proves them all wrong.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jn5zQDoG-OFMFLcHIhY1cA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Nah</figcaption></figure><p>Or so we hope. He definitely shows the Spider-Society he’s a force to be reckoned with, not just a kid to be belittled, but someone who has ideas and capabilities just like anyone else sitting at the table. Whether or not Miles can save the day in the third film remains to be seen, which is to say, the writers can still walk this back in the same way we experienced the writers walking back Rey’s lineage not being important to who she is in Rise of Skywalker. It sure would suck though. How Miles would pull it off is questionable, but I’ll leave that for Act 5. There’s still that whole “Two cakes” thing to talk about there.</p><p>For now, let’s briefly talk about parents &amp; teens because I feel like there’s something here about how every individual treats Miles that reflects the different things parents or adult figures may do to a teenager in a situation like this. It also lets me ease into the <em>Gwen </em>part of this act. Miles wants to accomplish something, something big, and he’s got a room full of adults, friends or otherwise, telling him to not do it. The story version of this is that they all believe Miguel, they all buy into this myth about Spider-Man failing to save a police captain in fiction. But everyone looks at and treats Miles differently throughout his time in Nueva York. Miguel, for example, <strong>controls </strong>and <strong>blames</strong>. He controls the narrative, he wants to lock Miles up and either wait this out or hopefully Miles will just see things his way. When they fight on the train, Miguel gets into straight-up gaslighting and abusive approaches to this, saying all the things Miles was warned about when his mother gave him the big speech in Act 3. Jess Drew, meanwhile, has little direct interaction with Miles but is along for the ride in what Miguel says for the most part, following along with these narratives and trying to be led by common sense more than emotions. Miguel also <strong>blames </strong>incorrectly. How could Miles be both an anomaly but Spot is simultaneously causing damage in cities that <em>create </em>canon events (like the threat to Inspector Singh’s life)? These characters that are related can’t be both causing canon events and also breaking them. They’re either anomalies when they’re doing things in other universes or aren’t. But Miguel is comfortable putting it all on Miles.</p><p>Next, Peter B. Parker is maybe the biggest disappointment next to Gwen. Miles notices Peter again and again <em>passively belittling</em><strong><em> </em></strong>Miles instead of truly recognizing Miles’s value. When Miguel blames Miles for what’s happening in Mumbattan, Peter first defends him, “Hey, go easy on the kid. He had a terrible teacher.” But this self-ridicule doesn’t last long and Peter tries to defend Miles to Miguel by explaining “He wasn’t thinking.” Peter sees this as Miles’s strength, that he goes with the flow to make things happen and save the day, but for Miles he finds that offensive and false. Miles <em>does</em> think about what he’s doing, even if it is on the fly a lot as the job of Spider-Man requires. But it’s not like Miles has the wrong idea when he tries to absorb the energy gate in Mumbattan’s Alchemax facility, he just doesn’t know how to use his powers in that way yet. In another scenario he’s mostly trying to get to the “Go Home Machine” when escaping the facility, but knows he can’t do that with everyone on his tail and so his constant escape turns into a plan of misdirection and losing the chase. He keeps briefly touching Miguel’s suit while Miguel has him pinned down so he can confirm if Miguel’s suit can be absorbed by his venom drain. When Miguel has Miles “captured” and everyone is arguing about what to do regarding Miles (a conversation he isn’t allowed to partake in), Peter calls him a kid, which is what Miles responds to vocally as he breaks out “Stop calling me that”. Later while Miguel has Miles pinned, Miles also expresses regarding how everyone has handled him, “Who decides that? I’m not a kid.” But Miguel only agrees and uses this point of pain for Miles to belittle him further.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4CJIcBBOBjhl629k2jHUaw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Meanwhile Hobie is the movie’s secret MVP. The man is Mile’s only true ally in this weak moment and enables Miles every step of the way. He tells him how to use his powers better, cheers him on when Miles tells everyone else off about saving his father, he even <em>warns </em>Miles as he goes to meet Miguel to not sign up until he knows what war he’s fighting, which is respectful considering Hobie doesn’t know Miles too much yet. So he shouldn’t be the one to tell Miles what’s going on, it’s probably why he asked Gwen how much Miles knows, because <em>she </em>should’ve told him. But Hobie is responsible enough to at least <em>warn </em>Miles about what’s about to take place as best he can. Hobie tells Miles he’s mostly sticking around to look out for Gwen, he quits the society when it’s clear all of this is falling apart and a sham that has unmasked itself, and then he was stealing equipment the whole time to build a watch(es) that can be used without needing Miguel’s control. Hobie Brown, punk at heart, is the only ally Miles has, even though he does kinda leave Miles stranded instead of helping him out during the big chase.</p><p>And then there’s Gwen. Gwen gets to serve two perspectives here because she too is a friend of Miles’s who’s buying into the lie and perpetuating Miguel’s control. When Miguel brings up how Miles wasn’t supposed to save Inspector Singh and Gwen tried to stop him, Miles says, “I thought you were trying to save me.” And Gwen replies “I was doing both.” Here Gwen presents her answer to this perspective of how canon events work out: <em>Collectively, we can control that myth, I can misdirect and simply not tell you something you deserve to hear. With all of us working together, we can keep Miles in the dark and preserve the canon.</em> But it doesn’t work out. It’s time to talk about that authority figure thing from way way earlier in act 3.</p><p>Gwen buys into the lie while simultaneously trying to maintain her friendship with Miles. It breaks everything as a result. Because this is Gwen’s movie, about how she hurt Miles, how this all falls apart, and how she feels like it’s all her fault. And she did it because of her relationship with two different authorities. Gwen leaves behind an authority figure, her dad, that rejects her identity as Spider-Woman and a hero. If there’s anything worse than future generations being <em>doomed</em> by older ones, it’s younger generations being <strong><em>rejected</em></strong> by older ones for how they see themselves. I will say the writers clearly have some empathy for parents, being parents themselves. Gwen’s dad is written in a somewhat sympathetic light in the shock of Gwen’s reveal, she <em>has </em>been keeping the truth from him about something awful that happened. Rio and Jeff clearly have a love for Miles that’s expressed in a more patient and empathic light when Miles isn’t around (which isn’t how it should be but it is). But the writers also don’t forget who the audience is going to be cheering on at the end of the day. Gwen’s dad <em>failed </em>her in a moment of vulnerability. So Gwen leaves her dad and walks into the shadow of another authority figure, Miguel, that accepts her as Spider-Woman, a hero, who was <strong>there </strong>in that vulnerable moment. But she learns the wrong lessons from him because of that acceptance. She believes Miguel’s opinion about Miles and the Spider-Verse. She believes Miles has to be protected from hurting the world around him. Gwen doesn’t tell Miles <em>anything</em> about this as she visits him in act 3, believing the lie that Miles can’t handle it, and then pushes her own experiences onto Miles in terms of what works out / doesn’t work out when talking about revealing Miles’s identity to his parents. She <strong>doesn’t know</strong> what will happen. Just like Miguel doesn’t actually know what’ll happen if Miles stops The Spot and saves his dad. What Gwen has been doing all movie is complex. In projecting her own experiences onto Miles, she gives Miles advice that’s not necessarily accurate regarding Miles talking to his parents. In hiding why she’s in Miles’s dimension and not telling Miles <strong>the whole truth</strong>, she unknowingly lures him away to join her and falls into an experience of mass rejection by his peers. Just imagine if she told him why she was there, why he can’t join, and so on, he probably would actually think twice before jumping in. And by keeping this truth from him, for months, she betrays Miles’s friendship and trust in her the same way Gwen’s dad felt betrayed in realizing his daughter has kept a massive secret from him. If Gwen has a conflict she’s fighting in this movie, it’s the fear of losing those close to you. And at this juncture in act 4, Gwen has lost <em>everyone</em>. She lost Peter through not seeing what he was turning into. She lost her dad by hiding who she is from him (and more importantly his rejection when he finds out). And she loses Miles because she tried to protect him in an attempt to not lose another person close to her. For each time it happens, it’s happening all because of issues with who she is or isn’t being. A best friend that sees the signs. A daughter that’s accepted for her real identity. A best friend that does the diligence of being openly honest. You’ll hear it later, “I can’t lose one more friend.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Z67ItIAcZTIOhYADwtJMqg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Later, Miles stands up to all of them, including Gwen, and you can briefly see it all hits her on the train. First you see her realize how much she has hurt her friend through the lie of omission, deciding what’s best for him without him even being in the conversation, visiting him, being dishonest with him the whole way, and then not standing by his side when the time comes. Then, she realizes Miles is stronger than Miguel, that he knows Miguel is wrong deep down. There’s a look on her face that recognizes they’ve been going about all this wrong and she starts to wonder “what if…” Gwen’s journey isn’t done because there’s still another act to go, but her perspective on this meta-myth conversation is so interesting because this is also <em>her </em>movie. Her journey. And in act 4, her best friend shows her that she’s learning the wrong lessons. Your identity shouldn’t <em>need to be </em>a secret to those you love. If your parents reject who you are, that’s not your fault, it’s theirs. Not all parents are the same. We aren’t limited to one outcome in life, but many. Heroism isn’t about doing what we’re told, but what’s right. Friendship isn’t maintained by deceit, it’s harmed by it. It’s hard to blame Gwen for all the mistakes when she has suffered so much loss and a strike of rejection that melts our hearts. (do we need to go back to Act 1 and think it over again?) It’s hard to blame her when we know she just doesn’t want Miles to go through the rejection she did, she’s informed by that rejection deeply. But it’s clear she’s made a grave mistake exchanging one authority for another that perpetuates something just as sinister. After all, who ruined an entire world? That isn’t a question just for Gwen. It’s a question for the viewer. How did we get to a point where we’re tired of superhero movies because they’re generic and bland and overdone? How did culture come to accept the same hero myths again and again? Who told us that’s how it has to be? When did we just decide to accept it? Gwen realizing Miles might be right and that she has ruined her friendship with him is the movie knocking down the first dominoes on these questions: Gwen realizes Miguel is wrong. He’s excluding Miles from the conversation and his ideas for how this doesn’t have to end the way everyone says it does. He has fresh ways of handling problems, he can outsmart any of them, so why can’t he be included?</p><p>And just like that, the first dominoes have fallen. <br>Miles rejects the perspective outright.<br>Gwen realizes it’s wrong to go about doing it this way.</p><p>Soon doubt will be cast everywhere.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Fhqx_MDWPFqmTvGkDMYbNA.jpeg" /><figcaption>I love the fact that they reversed/mirrored this shot. Spider-Woman is now looking in to Gwen’s face, approached upside-down. This is the opposite of the before shot where Gwen is on the outside looking in at Spider-Woman.</figcaption></figure><h4>Act 5 —Home Isn’t Home</h4><p>So my breakdown of this movie into “Acts” isn’t necessarily following the traditional meaning of an act in a film or play but mostly built on just larger pieces of story taking place and how they, at times, feel cut into chunks in terms of rising and falling. Act 1 clearly ends right before the credits roll (or you could call it a prelude). Act 2 and 3 sort of have this muddy lack of clarity but I feel like Miles jumping in the portal to go to Mumbattan is a pretty big “okay another story is starting” moment because we’re leaving so much behind and starting a new journey. The time in Mumbattan is short but everything starting from Miles going to Nueva York up until he’s standing up in victory on that train feels so cohesive and put together, not to mention the finality of the score in that scene, it all feels like it is its own act. On rewatch once Miles is back in the lab in stealth mode you can feel yourself mentally going “Okay, we’re on the falling action of this movie now”. This is why, for me, Act 5 starts here. Because this act plays out in a specific fashion, I’m going to put <strong>Miles’s</strong> stuff front, sandwich a lot of goodies in the middle, and then put Gwen’s stuff at the end. It’ll make sense when we get there.</p><p><em>Mile’s Story | Parents &amp; Teens | Animation That Says It All<br></em>So if there is ever a bigger hint that Miles and Gwen may not work out in the end, it’s right after he says “Goodbye Gwen”, jumps off the train, and makes his way back to Miguel’s lab in Nueva York. Miles activates the Go Home Machine, and in all this chaos as Miguel is trying to rip his way into the machine and stop Miles, Margo and Miles exchange this brief look. The two of them interacted for less than maybe two minutes earlier, but Margo looks at Miles and sees this scared young man and lets him escape. Margo is later shown joining Gwen’s band that’s going to go save Miles at the end of this movie, but there’s something here between Margo and Miles that the two immediately seem to have empathy and compassion towards each other with ease. When Margo earlier tells Miles about her living situation and how it’s nicer here, Miles simply replies, “I hear that.” Margo had no explanation as to why she should help Miles. Miguel told her to stop him. Maybe seeing Miguel be this violent was a bad sign. Maybe it’s their humanity. Maybe it’s simply the fact that this (at least for American audiences) ethnic minority knew this look of fear Miles had; there’s a compassion there that Gwen didn’t show Miles. And I’d be willing to bet that comes up in the next movie, even if just briefly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VC8bcmPMWbDX8XTWD_D51Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Their eyes almost evenly align in frame as well</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*llRCayvD1AgHLdTpf5l6rQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>We get a great sequence of Miles swinging home and all his doubts flooding over him. I do love the detail all throughout his journey home that his world is shaded a different color of purple and green, hinting at you constantly that this isn’t Miles’s universe. The same happens when he’s home, the room looking slightly different in color and in what’s in the room, not to mention Rio’s eye color being different. Overall the tones are green, purple, and <strong>black </strong>almost like they’re on charcoal paper. Even the clothes Miles throws on as Rio enters his room are purple and green, covering our hero in Prowler colors. Miles’s big speech to Rio is so heartbreaking knowing that he completed this emotional arc with his mother, but not with the Rio that raised him. There’s a concern on my end that Miles’s Rio won’t ever really hear that speech, but a fleeting one. There’s a brief moment in Miles’s speech that concerned me more on my first couple watches too.</p><p><em>Miles’s Villain Origins (surprise category!)<br></em>Okay look, I don’t think Miles will actually be a villain in the third movie. But there’s a bit of something here where Miles tells his mother “I let ’em have it”, a confidence that Miles gleans from being right in having beaten Miguel in their conflict and it sort of shows this side of Miles that’s getting a little cocky, a little proud of how he got away and no one else in the Spider-Society matters to him now. Miles, his parents, that’s it. No one in any other universe matters. This internally-facing mindset of “protect me and my own” is exactly the sort of thing that would, in other fictions, lead characters towards a life of crime. His friends lied to him, rejected him, tried to let his dad (and probably mom) die. They tried to capture him, hold him back, and tell him he shouldn’t even have the powers that he has. If the movie didn’t go where it does, I’d be concerned Miles was actually turning into a villain by the end simply due to the experiences he’s been through in this story and how he’s walking away from it with a brief flash of arrogance. In the first movie triple validation from parental sources gives Miles the push he needs to become Spider-Man. This time, parental validation is a murky, scary subject that has implications far more painful and gut wrenching than last time. Because it admits children, teens, sons, daughters, those people need their parents more than they can recognize yet. And if all parents do is push and pull instead of sit and stay, the kids might run away and become villains. That’s part of what makes the alternate Miles Morales so genius. It allows us to explore the idea of Miles becoming a villain without <strong>our </strong>Miles actually being one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_zFuTzZMsVDhjYm9WyAmOQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Parallels, the Poetry that Rhymes | Score &amp; Soundtrack | Odds &amp; Ends<br></em>Okay, time for the last things to talk about before Gwen’s chunk of Act 5 and wrap it all up. One of my favorite little parallel nods in this movie happens when Miles wakes up after Earth-42 Miles knocked him out. The visuals match that of when Peter B. Parker wakes up in ITSV, Miles having knocked him out with his venom blast unintentionally in that movie. It’s a first person perspective that peers around Uncle Aaron’s apartment, seeing first a little cat figurine and then more of the apartment before Peter realizes he’s chained up to a punching bag. There’s also a parallel of the way Aaron adjusts the EQ and volume on his speakers but this time for a specifically sinister action of masking the pained cries of someone he and Earth-42-Miles are about to interrogate on a rooftop. The parallels here draw you towards the realization that either A) Miles in that movie got this from Aaron in a sort of “we’re not so different you and I” comparison because Aaron did the same to Miles here in Earth-42 or B) Miles in Earth-42 did it to this alternate version of himself, suggesting how much the two Mileses think alike. Regardless I love this little callback that just emphasizes similarities in different universes.</p><p>Now everyone has no doubt seen or read or heard the various ways in which “Start a Band” is such a fantastic finishing score piece for the movie. And I don’t disagree. The various character themes play as they’re introduced as members of the band and there’s an incredible way in which the Miles and Prowler themes are engulfing and overtaking each other in a way we’ll no doubt see hashed out in a real conflict in the third film. Someone even figured out the Prowler’s theme is built out of a reverse scratch of Miles’s Spider-Man theme. But I want to call attention to <strong>whoever picked this needle drop in this scene</strong>.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F38OOUDTsqM0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D38OOUDTsqM0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F38OOUDTsqM0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0984cbf4d0828f17c62b697034d27055/href">https://medium.com/media/0984cbf4d0828f17c62b697034d27055/href</a></iframe><p>I didn’t know about this song until I saw the movie but then I listened to this song (and all songs in the movie in their entirety) and read the lyrics and couldn’t be more astounded. The placement of this song in the movie carries so much weight and potential meaning. In one interpretation, Earth-42 New York has no love in its heart because it doesn’t have Spider-Man, thus there’s no hero here to solve its problems. In another interpretation, this song reflects Earth-42’s Uncle Aaron, a man pushed further towards crime because his brother, a police officer, was killed, and so he turns his heart towards crime more and enables it in his adopted nephew Miles. The lack of Jeff’s existence unbalances what little goodness was left in Aaron’s heart, and our Miles is facing a truly dangerous person that won’t hesitate to kill him. Unless Aaron killed Jeff; something to think about there. In another interpretation, Miles from Earth-42 is the emotional core of the needle drop, having no love in his heart due to his dad’s unexpected death and lacking the bite of the spider meant for him that would’ve possibly given him powers to save his dad. Powerless in this city, Miles’s love is gone, turned “Batman-esque” and relying on tools to accomplish his goals but driven for his own self-interest. Regardless of interpretation, this song also stands in stark contrast from where we started this journey. Rakim’s “Guess Who’s Back” illustrates a love for the cultural melting pot of New York that Miles has but this song is a bluesy jazz for the city not having the love that Miles knows. It’s a needle drop that plays simple but can serve every possibility of emotion that this movie’s ending opens up for the viewer’s thoughts. This will no doubt narrow when the third movie comes out because there will only be one version of the story. But for now, this song in this scene only makes me mentally applaud the more I hear it.</p><p>Okay, I think we’re there.</p><p>It’s time for the last section of stuff.</p><p><em>Parents &amp; Teens | It’s Actually Gwen’s Movie | Breaking My Feels Barrier<br></em>Gwen gets an arc this movie; a beginning, middle, and end. Her <em>old</em> stability is that she is all alone and can’t tell her dad about her life, her struggles losing Peter and that she’s not the person he thinks she is. This discomforting version of stability is thrown into chaos when she has to show her dad who she really is and he rejects it. She runs away, goes on this big experience for a few months, and then she stands up to Miguel. She <em>knows </em>he’s wrong about Miles and how to handle this situation. She even starts voicing this a little earlier in Act 4 talking to Jess, her hearts says this is wrong. Miguel sending her home forces Gwen to talk to her dad again and we get another gut-wrenching sequence that really codes things pretty explicitly as a trans-experience. It’s only ever really being able to be half of any identity and each identity just winds up hurting someone else. As hard as that conversation is to hear, it really makes me shed tears when her dad expresses that he can’t arrest Gwen because he quit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JAbT_ypOW_fUJyiLcwvWBA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*t8A8dU2u2eR75Eh6TtYo3w.jpeg" /></figure><p>One of the bigger themes in this movie is adult characters not fostering an environment that invites teens to talk to them. Gwen never feels like she can tell her dad about her because he has always been outwardly against vigilantes. Miles has always been in the same boat and when he wants to talk to his dad in act 2, it turns into a shouting match instead. Miguel, similarly, only wants to force his perspective on Miles and Gwen instead of listen to what they think. It’s only when Gwen is finally able to talk to her dad in frustration and at greater length that things come together again. Later, when Gwen is listening in on a conversation between Rio and Jeff, they talk about how they have to make some adjustments to how they’re raising Miles, at least a little, compared to how it’s worked before. Both parents and teens are growing up, the parents having to learn what the teen needs from them, while the teen has to learn how to communicate some of the harder stuff to talk about. In the sequence leading up to this as Miles swings “home”, MJ expresses this in a way that works metaphorically for the film too: “There’s no handbook for raising someone like her (referring to Mayday, her and Peter B’s daughter, who has super hero powers). You just have to make the right adjustments at half-time.” This idea works for teens yes, but these movies as well, recognizing that ATSV has to be this movie that is about more than one thing at a time to serve both this movie and its sequel well.</p><p>Gwen’s resolution with her dad knocks another domino down in that list of questions posed earlier in Act 4 about hero myths and the stories we tell. Gwen realizes that telling her dad didn’t mean things would be disastrous the way she warned Miles about. She also realized telling her dad and having this conversation she was scared to have actually meant her dad stopped being a cop, as Captain Stacy is more willing to renounce the job and stop hunting Spider-Gwen than to actually arrest his daughter. Gwen has found her new stability. This would, canonically, take him <strong>out of the danger</strong> that he’s in in the world of Canon Events. So not all Police Captain characters have to die. Gwen is starting to recognize another way Miles was right and that she has potentially steered him all wrong. Caught up in a desire to fix it, enabled by Hobie’s secret watch, she sets off to fix things. But Miles is in the wrong dimension so she talks to Miles’s parents and tells them about how much Miles loves them. Remarking on being able to find Miles and bring him home, Gwen expresses the things Miles taught her in this movie: “One thing I’ve learned from Miles…It’s all possible”.</p><p>Bake two cakes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1BGlrp9nh86M9YkgcAtQOg.jpeg" /><figcaption>One last “in front of it” shot for the read.</figcaption></figure><p>I have to get a little “theory-crafty” to talk about the ending of the movie so here it goes: I think this paradoxical problem of the spider being taken from Earth-42 before Miles in that universe was bit is going to be solved by our Miles being semi-present in that universe. In a sort of “Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End” situation, Miles is going to have to two-time his job and fill in as being Spider-Man in <strong>both dimensions. </strong>Either that or he’s going to have to convince his other self to be a hero instead of a villain. Miles’s inventive thinking about the two-cakes conundrum is and always was the answer though to <em>every </em>problem posed here. “I was doing both”, “I can do both”, there’s many Spider-Characters talking about doing both in this movie but not by <strong>being both</strong>, not by working together every time it comes up, not by living a life that fuses both identities of Spider-Person and the person under the mask. Rarely are characters recognizing the strength of how they can do more together. Gwen is starting to realize that Miles was right and he may not even see how yet. While Gwen doesn’t know about the other Miles, we can see how these elements might fit together in a way where there being more than one Miles or there being so many Spider-People can address this problem. And that <em>mindset</em>, that approach to these conundrums, it’s a positive one. It’s a proactive perspective that thinks of solutions that are inclusive and doesn’t work in a reality that says “You can’t have your cake and eat it too.” It instead says “How can we think of stories, solutions, myths that teach good lessons without <strong>demanding </strong>senseless suffering?” <em>Bake two cakes. Work together.</em></p><p>I don’t know if Miles will have to kill his other self. Or simply never redeem him. If he’ll wind up losing his dad. If he’ll even need to beat Spot in a fight to the death or if Spot can be saved. But I know the answer I want doesn’t lie in just sitting back and letting things roll out like any other Spider-Movie. I also know the movie is telling us that no matter what, he won’t be alone. When Gwen talks about never having found the right band to join, and she looks on to the portal waiting for her, and asks us, the audience, if we want to join her band, “You in?”, I feel something overwhelming hit me every time. I alluded to it earlier in act 4. I remarked these questions that have plagued hero stories have been given a response for a while now in a way that millennials fall into way too often: Jaded sarcasm. We go “don’t take it too seriously”, or provide witty banter to serious questions in our stories. It takes the seriousness out of the situations so that we don’t feel bad for going along with the continued narrative that “heroes must suffer to be heroes” instead of accepting <em>any other possibility</em>. It’s ultimately, a <strong>deadening </strong>feeling, because you bury the part of you that asks “Is that what I want?”</p><p>What I feel when Miles breaks free, what I feel when Gwen has resolved things with her dad and he tells her that she’s the best thing he’s ever done, what I feel when Miles stands up to everyone who tries to stop him from doing the right thing, what I feel when Gwen offers us, the audience, involvement in this gang of heroes that’s going to help Miles chase his ideas, and bake two cakes instead of accept someone telling him that it’s unreasonable to ask for more, I feel the hero stories I’ve always wanted to feel. And that feeling is the opposite of jaded sarcasm.</p><p>I feel hope.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*unsPcL22zF8NXCXaIhXYaw.jpeg" /><figcaption>They’re gonna do it.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a93316f3f48b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Things I’ve Consumed in 2023]]></title>
            <link>https://the-typer.medium.com/things-ive-consumed-in-2023-74b482e135ba?source=rss-4c5509ad50b6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/74b482e135ba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2023]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[retrospectives]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Fleming]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Dec 2023 17:20:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-21T17:20:37.832Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I want to try and make this one quick primarily because I still have things to consume and things to continue writing. I’m no where near done with Elden Ring and the closer I get to the end of the game the more I start consuming the loosely connected media to the game from all the various YouTube channels I follow, slowing me down further. I also want to write this because I’ve got two pieces I’ve been working on for a long time now and I’m still no where near done with them in the long run so I’d rather put out something quick and easy.</p><p>Qualifications for the List:</p><ul><li>Something I liked that I think is worth mentioning</li><li>Something I didn’t like that I think is worth mentioning.</li><li>Something I definitely finished consuming.</li><li>Something I definitely <em>didn’t </em>finish consuming, because who cares?</li><li>I consumed it in 2023.</li><li>I also won’t talk about it if I wrote about it this year (with an exception I’ll get to). So if you want my opinions on <a href="https://the-typer.medium.com/january-may-a-handful-of-reviews-9da2de2c6072">albums released in January — May</a>, <a href="https://the-typer.medium.com/star-wars-jedi-survivor-d32341c46d9e">Jedi: Survivor</a>, <a href="https://the-typer.medium.com/jack-white-gave-me-the-answer-on-ai-a-decade-ago-20b3c891be7b">BT’s new album</a>, and <a href="https://the-typer.medium.com/spencer-brown-the-road-to-equanimity-album-review-5d859044e939">Spencer Brown’s new album</a>, you won’t find them here.</li></ul><h3>Movies/TV/YouTube</h3><h4>The Witcher — Season 3</h4><p>During Christmas season this past year I fell ill and binged The Witcher: Blood Omen. Don’t watch it, it’s terrible. But upon watching it, realizing I wasn’t going to get much Witcher content until summer when The Witcher season 3 was going to release, I decided to bite the bullet and thoroughly watch Joseph Anderson’s two Witcher reviews to try and fully comprehend those games and their stories. Then I spent the first half of this year reading The Last Wish and Sword of Destiny (consider this a double-book-review insert). I really enjoyed the first two Witcher books and maybe the best thing about reading them was re-contextualizing my opinion on the TV show. Everyone was constantly trash-talking the show as something “only good because Henry Cavill was there demanding certain things”. But reading the books has only shattered the illusion. Changes made across those first two books to slot into the first two seasons of The Witcher have pretty fair reasons for their re-writes. It’s about smooshing stories together simultaneous to the canon of Geralt raising Ciri to save for time. If we followed the books there’d be two entire seasons of stories before Ciri was even in the picture. The writers took advantage of the fantastic episodic nature in the first two books to work as interstitial themes for the TV show’s overarching plot about the man killing monsters who finds it his fate to raise someone who thinks herself maybe a little monstrous in this great big world. It works pretty well but maybe I’ll change my mind after I read the main series of books (I’ve finally started Blood of Elves).</p><p>Also, watching the world have a fit over Henry Cavill departing from the series now feels different. Yes, I think he played a fantastic Geralt if you enjoyed the video game(s). The author thinks he played a fantastic Geralt too. There’s some sidebar allegations that seemed to not be pushed more that Henry was kind of a jerk to women on set but that didn’t have the sort of “public response” that we see when allegations go supported by the rest of Hollywood. Regardless it’s pretty rare for Netflix to keep a show running well for too long so for many this thing with Henry leaving looked like an easy way for people to call it quits on the show. Personally, after reading those first books I was way more impressed with Joey Batey’s performance as Dandelion/Jaskier, he felt so much closer to the dialogue of the character on the page than even Henry as Geralt. Lastly, I feel like most people looked at Cavill’s departure from the series as a way to color their opinion of season 3. Where most seemed ready to be done with the show because “what’s the point? He’s gone!”, for me season 3 felt like a fantastic exploration of all the pieces on the board finally moving in the way late-game Witcher 3 feels exciting. With Geralt, Yennefer, and Ciri now a trio of heroes working together across the season we have a gripping series of events while they play chess with multiple kingdoms, societies, and personal arcs. It has its shortcomings but honestly every season has so far. Season 1 had a timeline problem. Season 2 had a climax-abrupt-ending problem. And season 3 has some production woes that made the visual work at the start of the season…a problem. But so much of the budget and work started showing up immediately after that first episode or two. The siege at the end of the season is a massive set piece they clearly spent a lot of time on. I enjoyed it, I’m curious to see how they manage changing Geralt in the next season but more important to me is the return of Joey Batey in season 4. And now I need to move on to the next thing because there’s no time.</p><h4><a href="https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLIhLvue17Sd70y34zh2erWWpMyOnh4UN_&amp;si=gj_eM808mfzCYI-L">PsychOdyssey</a></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*q0dVKce9DUxxndpX5HMxtg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Oh my gosh just go watch it. If you like video games you owe it to yourself to watch this masterpiece of a video game documentary. It hits harder as a longtime fan of Double Fine and a backer of Broken Age who watched that game unfold in its own documentary. This is, in many ways, a sequel to the Double Fine Adventure, exploring the uglier side of a game’s development. But you don’t have to watch that to comprehend this at all. Words won’t do this documentary justice. Just watch it. There’s even fantastic coverage of the documentary you can go watch on <a href="https://youtu.be/sft8nDjunK4">MinnMax’s YouTube channel</a> where he gets to interview the filmmakers about exactly how honest this production was. Do it. Watch it. I could go on and on about it but just a few episodes in and the documentary will speak for itself.</p><h4>An odd YouTube recommendation</h4><p>I honestly can’t believe I’m recommending this one but if, for some reason, you enjoy “ghost hunter TV” then I’d recommend you go check out <a href="https://www.youtube.com/@FearProject">Project Fear</a> on YouTube. The series is a new addition to the YouTube space after the main crew behind it suffered a TV-show cancellation likely at the hands of everyone’s latest villain to creativity: David Zaslav. You can also check out their TV show “Destination Fear” over on Max to get a good idea of some of the stuff they’ve captured on camera before to understand these people have been doing this for a while. Project Fear is four close friends (two of them are siblings even) taking a road trip to multiple haunted locations across the span of a week or so. The hook is that on the road trip, each of the four cast members get to pick a location that the others don’t know about (yet) and determine the rules for the location. One crew member may pick on another and force a person to be the first to explore the location alone. Another crew member may put up a fan vote without context and then a cast member has to stay cuffed to a door for half the night. A recent hot trend is pushing for spending the night without flashlights involved, just night vision. After initial explorations, the show takes its self-inflicted twist when the crew writes down the four scariest spots in a haunted location on paper, puts the places in a hat, and then each crew members draws their fate. From that point on until sunrise, each person has to go to their location and stay there alone. The isolation and lack of light in these places that often saw a bunch of human suffering creates added fear and an interesting time. What really drew me to Project Fear over other ghost hunter shows (though before this summer I had never really watched a single show before) was how, especially after shedding their TV network, these people really seem to get along well when they’re not putting each other through utterly terrifying experiences sometimes tapped into their own major fears. It’s like watching four siblings bicker, get on each other’s nerves, and take care of each other through crazy spooky explorations. It’s fun as far as ghost hunting shows go and you’re helping a small team find their bearings again after getting fired, something all too common these days in creative spaces. They’ve done three full road trips already and are working on getting the third one published (it’s in the edit phase for now). Check it out if you’re interested. I don’t blame you if you’re not a fan of these things though.</p><h4>Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse</h4><p>This is one of the two large pieces I’m currently working on so I won’t say too much here. Across the Spider-Verse was the movie I was waiting for over the past two years. It’s one of the most visually stunning things I’ll ever see in theaters. It’s a Russian nesting doll of a movie about Miles Morales from Dimension A struggling to balance his identities as a son and as a Spider-Man who misses his friends nestled inside a movie about Gwen Stacy from Dimension B struggling with her identities and the repercussions of opening up to her family about her identity and how she lets that inform her worldview nestled inside a movie about Spider-People from Dimensions C through Infinity and the larger threat the multiverse faces nestled inside a movie about superhero narratives, the way in which we engage with them, and decide what’s acceptable and not in our wider culture as people who enjoy stories in the dimension we call “reality”. I can’t contain my emotions when I watch this movie. Over 100 people quit while making this movie and it’s a big shame. In a time where more and more people, oftentimes creatives, are realizing the fact that they shouldn’t have to live so terribly to make their art that the world profits on, I really hope the creatives behind this film get to do the same so that Beyond the Spider-Verse can be just as incredible AND be made under better conditions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c2WFUra7ZZWtA0rC9vREPg.png" /></figure><h3>Books</h3><p>I technically read more books last year when I went on an absolutely unstoppable comic book frenzy from summer onwards after getting out of a terrible working situation. But here’s some rapid fire reads and recommendations.</p><p><em>Fables </em>by Bill Willingham and Mark Buckingham<em><br></em>I finished reading the Fables series this year. I liked it. But the author seems to be a bit of a weirdo jerk with some odd values that sometimes insert themselves into the narrative. However some of the darkest and exciting storytelling for Fables hides in its later books. After enough time has passed since finishing the series, the cream of the crop is definitely Cubs in Toyland, a story of its own while the main story is gearing up for the grand finale that takes turns that utterly churn the stomach and break the heart. It’s incredible and worth the 17 books of building before it (okay 16, The Great Fables Crossover is <em>half bad </em>because Jack is in it and a central character).</p><p><em>Slave Religion</em> by Albert J. Raboteau<br>A <strong>dense</strong> historical / anthropological work that explores how key religion was to the numerous slave populations across the United States and even outwards to include other chunks of the western hemisphere across its hundreds of years as an institution. I’d only really recommend it if you’re a dedicated reader of historical texts and critical essays about topics like slavery and religion. The hook that drew me towards it was when my best friend discussed how the text demonstrated how important religion was to slaves and even survived the journey to the West. In an age where religion in my country is oftentimes associated with conservatism, and thereby oftentimes associated with systemic racism, Slave Religion is both encouraging and discouraging. If you want an easier (but still not necessarily easy) read of the same subject I’d recommend…</p><p><em>White Too Long</em> by Robert P. Jones<br>I’m not done with this one yet but I’m about half way there. This one is an easier read but not necessarily less dense or easy if you’re white and/or a Christian. It is an utter evisceration, by a Christian, of Christianity’s utter complicity and even involvement with white supremacy for the past four hundred years. Reading just the intro of this book floored me and I couldn’t return to it out of difficulty grappling with the horror stories inside it. But the utter rigor with which Jones is holding his own religion accountable for in this book is admirable, even going so far as to state:</p><blockquote>“Until we find the courage to face these appalling errors of our recent past, white Christians should probably avoid any further proclamations about what ‘the Bible teaches’ or what ‘the biblical worldview’ demands.” — <em>Robert P. Jones, White Too Long</em></blockquote><p>If you’re a white Christian in America, this one feels essential.</p><p><em>Gotham Central, Book Two: Jokers and Madmen</em> by Ed Brubaker &amp; Greg Rucka<br>Batman fans are missing out if they haven’t read Gotham Central. Jokers &amp; Madmen is one of the strongest of the four books (maybe only beaten out by book four, Corrigan) with classic “Batman villain” stakes but given the unique perspective of the people on the ground who are in so much of the danger. It’s one of those series that after reading I was instantly appalled we don’t have a TV show like this. I don’t know that TV would ever get it quite right in terms of narrative and storytelling, but even getting a third of this comic series right on a TV screen would be a major addition to the serial crime drama genre.</p><p><em>Solutions and Other Problems</em> by Allie Brosh<br>The follow up to Allie Brosh’s “Hyperbole and a Half”, Solutions and Other Problems is a wild ride of a story book filled with builds, conclusions, disappointments, and at other times a sensation that something is missing. At other times it feels fantastically fulfilling. Most importantly the book has a moment that made me get up and go hug my wife. It’s magically affecting one moment and utterly hilarious the next.</p><p><em>The Sandman: Book Two</em> by Neil Gaiman<br>I’m really looking forward to how Netflix is going to adapt this one. They managed to do book one fairly well, and included two of my favorite stories from it (the man who had no interest in Death and the one with the cats), but Book Two <em>goes places</em> in terms of the ugly and the graphic. So we’ll see. It’s…interesting. If you haven’t read Sandman though do it, there’s a reason it’s so prevalent.</p><p><em>Batman: Gothic</em> by Grant Morrison &amp; Klaus Janson<br>After Gotham Central, this might be my new favorite Batman book. You’ll probably never see a Batman movie made like this book unless it’s a cartoon. It’s got some…questionable material in it but it also has a ghost story hidden inside it all. Batman sparring with the supernatural is supremely underappreciated and the operatic themes across the book are even greater appreciated if you go read up on the play being shown off at the book’s outset. What a cool little scary Batman story. I love it. Batman needs to be dealing with ghost stuff way more often.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/1*_MtH2Jcc06-hQNdaIsTwCw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Music</h3><p>I’m not including singles because I’ll be here all day.</p><h4>Across the Spider-Verse — Score &amp; OST by Daniel Pemberton and Metro Boomin’</h4><p>The only way the Spider-Verse music could improve was by having an OST with more than four songs I want to listen to. They fixed that this time with Metro Boomin’ at the helm of the soundtrack and Daniel Pemberton just continued to up his game with his score. Best release, I’ve been binging both in a playlist that matches the movie incessantly since June. The more people reveal about the score the more you realize that Daniel is also just phenomenally stretching use out of some of the same notes all the time. It’s crazy good.</p><h4>Lane 8 — Brighest Lights</h4><p>For some reason I stopped listening to new Lane 8 albums around the time Brightest Lights came out. So I finally started catching up this year. Daniel Goldstein is our generation’s “godfater of melodic house” in such a clear cut way. Brightest Lights feels like an amalgamation of ideas from his first two eras (Rise and Little by Little) smooshed together with a variety of tunes you can easily tune in and out to. His albums make for really great “push play and forget”, except some will infect your ears for days. Title track “Brightest Lights” is a wonderful poetic little anthem and “Two Yard Stone” can’t help but be noticed in its sullen tones. I wanted to also delve into Reviver (album 4) but honestly I couldn’t stop repeating Brighest Lights so Reviver will just have to wait.</p><h4>Grabbitz — Let Them Only See Butterflies</h4><p>Really more of an EP than album since it’s only 8 tracks and lasts less than 30 minutes but this was the first full Grabbitz EP I ever gave attention so I want to mention it. I always liked his music, bought singles, so now I really want to go all in on his EPs and albums. His blend of rock and electronic vibes is unmistakable in an industry filled with sound-alikes. “SURRENDER PEACE!” has the bravado presence of Brandon Flowers on a Killers album filled with ten gallons of angst and I can’t help but scream that chorus with him. “The World is So F****d Up” plays with distortion as a guiding presence in a clever way. And “Slow Dance” manages to be the first 80s-wobble-pad song I’ve heard in a while that didn’t make me want to instantly skip it because it’s just so catchy with the lyrics. Topped off with Grabbitz’s usual rap-light breaks pieces “Let It Bloom” and “Can You Feel It Now”, this EP is such an easy treat. I kept coming back to it over the past four months so I can’t help but recommend it.</p><h4>Le Youth — About Us</h4><p>I keep joking to my friend Chris that Le Youth’s “About Us” is like a discount Lane 8 album we got this year to tide us over between new Lane 8 albums. But honestly I may like “About Us” more than “Reviver” when the time comes for me to listen to the later some more. Lane 8’s productions tend to have a mixed bag of vocals, some harder to make out than others whether it be for intentional edit/processing reasons or just an aesthetic choice of singers/songwriters. Lane 8’s albums also tend to have one or three songs that are a bit more mystic or non-romantic in nature (though there’s a clear trend towards love from Brighest Lights onwards, no doubt a result of Daniel’s marriage and subsequent fatherhood).</p><p>But Le Youth’s sophomore album “About Us” probably deserves better attention and words than a “discount Lane 8 album”. It’s a great collection of songs exploring emotions, parting relationships, and heart. Something about Le Youth’s audio work serves better to create a sort of pop sensibility with the songwriters he worked with. They’re clearer, more forefront, and yet the album still manages to be occasionally memorable when it’s not all about the lyrics. While the album may not carry Lane 8’s knack for extended club journeys, we know Le Youth’s capable of it thanks to his remix of Lane 8’s “I’ll Wait”. The two artists collaborating together for the anthemic “I Will Leave a Light On” for this album <em>signed</em> to Lane 8’s album “This Never Happened” only demonstrates the hopefully bright future ahead for this artist. Definitely a good listen for the year.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*P7KVUjsyteRgW9u2o02jmw.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Video Games</h3><h4>Immortality</h4><p>I started this over the holidays last year but didn’t really get that far into it before the New Year arrived. This one is <em>something else</em>. Sam Barlow games definitely strike that chord many would consider pretentious and “not a game”. But personally I’ve enjoyed each of the Sam Barlow releases up to this point and Immortality is no exception. It offers the usual “what happened here?” mystery with just a stupid amount of extra layers to be considering. It’s fascinating to approach the game from a “how did they make this game?” standpoint, a “look at these actors being actors” standpoint, a “look at these actors acting like actors that are acting” standpoint, and something that feels sinister even beyond that. Immortality is an interesting conversation about art and creativity hiding beneath the various reels of films across three film generations that I couldn’t help but keep peering through. Once I felt I couldn’t find anything else I went out there and looked over every YouTube clip possible to see if I missed anything else. It’s enticing to say the least.</p><h4>Afterparty</h4><p>The follow-up to Night Dive’s “conversations adventure game”-formula they started with Oxenfree, Afterparty is a fascinating attempt to explore new mechanics for the formula. It’s enjoyable but it feels like the setting is a bigger point of interest compared to the main characters. The dual nature of its dialogue and choice mechanics makes you feel like you’re missing out on potential paths in a more pressing way than Oxenfree, possibly because the game keeps ushering you along its story instead of leaving free time to revisit places and explore. It’s a charming game and its version of the underworld is funny and a unique perspective on the usual Heaven/Hell mythos. It doesn’t feel as exciting or significant as Oxenfree, but it’s fun. The opening sequence, the dance party, and all the taxi rides in particular all stand out for me.</p><h4>Subnautica: Below Zero</h4><p>I didn’t complete this one but played it for enough hours to complete it. I finished my character’s main reason for starting her journey, which was to find out why and how her sister died. All that was really left was a series of grinding tasks to solve a predicament and get off planet. Something about the first Subnautica game kept me from getting too far past the first “orbital defense” sequence. It was probably all the grind without much of a present narrative. Below Zero having a voiced protagonist you’re playing with her own voiced journal notes is nice, the added characters to the story make it an experience I was more willing to see through. I’ve heard this one also just solved a lot of lengthy grind problems in the first game but I think that has more to do with the rate of research discovery. Both Subnautica games do something not enough video games do, which is why I tried to get through the first game three separate times. I just wish the sense of progress and making that feel more feasible was more omnipresent. Maybe next game.</p><h4>Pyre</h4><p>This is a “work in progress” game that I see myself completing before the year is over. Pyre is really cool and the more underappreciated Supergiant Game. Part sports-game, part RPG, its world is one I always appreciated but I think most found the sports game inside it to be the thing that stopped entertaining players. That was certainly the case for me. Since it seems we may not be seeing Hades 2 for a time, going back to Pyre and finishing it is well worth it in my opinion.</p><h4>Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One</h4><p>This one is fresh on my mind since I finished it just a couple weeks back. I was happily surprised by The Sinking City when I played it in late 2021. Frogwares found a neat way to make an open world detective experience that we’re now seeing in a more dynamic fashion with early access game Shadows of Doubt. Sherlock Holmes: Chapter One is Frogwares taking that design from The Sinking City and rebooting their Sherlock Holmes catalogue of games into that new design.</p><p>This game takes place on the British-occupied Spanish Isle of Cordona and, sadly, doesn’t quite hit as well as The Sinking City. For starters, Cordona’s constantly bright, clean, and sunny streets aren’t nearly as exciting to traverse. The Sinking City’s Lovecraftian background made for a constant eeriness and uncertainty of what was around the next corner and takes place in the dirty, disheveled city of Oakmont. It took some getting used to to realize how much of what you were seeing was mostly just window dressing but the atmosphere of the game never really went away and you’d encounter creepy violent encounters even on seemingly safe street spaces sometimes. Sherlock Holmes doesn’t work that way and is, by its nature, a mostly pleasant world with gruesome cases you stumble into. The cases were always engaging but by creating a world that didn’t have an immediately concerning sense of space and location, the world map mostly became irrelevant except when trying to find out where the case was taking me. That design still hits great. You go into police stations, city halls, or newspaper outlets to dig through records and find out where the case needs to take you next. You place a marker on your map and make your way to those locations to investigate further. But by stripping the various street encounters, SH: Chapter One has removed some of the dynamics of The Sinking City that made it feel like such a unique place to be in video games. The story isn’t anything to gawk at but the pieces weaving it together are engaging enough and the cases attached are really interesting. It is a little frustrating that these cases never have defined “right and wrong” answers, especially considering we’re talking about master of deduction Sherlock Holmes.</p><p>The game still has a variety of collection quests like The Sinking City and a lot of needless clothing items to buy. I’d honestly rather trade all these quests for a few extra cases that reward you with costumes, especially since every case was pretty interesting or engaging. Considering the follow-up game from this Ukranian dev is Sherlock Holmes facing down a Cthulhu-esque cult in “The Awakened”, I’m excited for what’s in the future for these games. Chapter One is a good reboot of these games after The Sinking City set an excitingly high bar. Just expect a couple aspects of this game to not quite get to the same heights. Speaking of open world games though, let me tell you about this other one…</p><h4>Elden Ring</h4><p>I’m not done with Elden Ring. I have a complicated history with <a href="https://medium.com/@the-typer/star-wars-jedi-survivor-d32341c46d9e">open world games</a> that <a href="https://the-typer.medium.com/horizon-forbidden-west-quests-progression-36dcc2dfe41c">only seems to be getting more complicated</a>. So starting Elden Ring was more of a regrettable “It’s finally time, let’s do this” experience for me. I think what most critics have said about the game is true in terms of it being a one of a kind fantastic open world experience. I’m someone who suffers a little from the checkbox video game design with open worlds (see my Horizon: Forbidden West article up above for a more detailed breakdown) but I still enjoy them. So Elden Ring being a “Dark Souls 4, 5, and 6” video game in the style of the “no checkboxes” open world design of Breath of the Wild is a <strong>good thing </strong>in my book. Sort of. But I can’t gawk at games that boast this scale anymore or find much praise for it in my heart after Horizon last year, Jedi: Survivor this year, and now Elden Ring. It’s really cool. I can’t muster up amazing words for it.</p><p>I think Elden Ring has maybe the best “Dark Souls story” since Dark Souls 2 (ignoring Sekiro and Bloodborne), it’s rare a game has me drawing out family trees and jotting down notes about every character and lore drop I encounter. But simultaneously I almost find that a con for a game too large and too big while not maintaining a wiki or any sort of a quest log for you to track NPC side quests. Not <em>all </em>discovery should be organic if you’ve already got the ball rolling. It’s not fun to keep a roster of 40 NPCs in your head. It’s in the open world of this scale and scope where some of the modern-era FromSoft action-RPG designs start to truly sour. Sellen, for me, was, and always has been stuck to a wall from the first time I met her in the first twenty hours. I’m up in the snowy mountains now and Sellen is still stuck for no reason I can figure out. I feel like I didn’t like the first 50% of the bosses in this game aside from a couple standout moments where Elden Ring flouts its newer boss design of “no movesets are completely set in stone now”. The recycled bosses are definitely a problem that I heard coming way before I even touched the game. The concept of an open world that is an expertly crafted series of discoveries that keep surprising you at how big the world is <strong>is </strong>a lot more interesting than the current norm of “Here’s the whole map, look how big”, but I think the truly incredible part of this game’s scale is in understanding how dense some legacy dungeons are inside the larger overworld. It’s a little telling for me that this massive video game strikes my interest most in uncovering secrets and parts of the game that remind me of the intricate map designs of prior FromSoftware titles and less of Breath of the Wild or Horizon or Nier: Automata or Hollow Knight. I think the game is simultaneously cool and also takes forever to show you the amazing things it has in store for you.</p><p>I love this game and once I’m done and the DLC is here and I’ve finished that too, I never want another FromSoftware game like this again. Maybe if I’ve spent a year or two avoiding games of this scale but 2023 also had Marvel’s Spider-Man 2, which remains untouched, and I still haven’t played last year’s God of War: Ragnarok. By the time I get to those and finish them, I’ll be looking another massive open world in the eye again.</p><p>You know what I’ve played this year that I’d love to see more of though?</p><h4>System Shock Remake</h4><p>Night Dive’s System Shock Remake is a wonder to behold. It’s been in development for what felt like eons and yet it’s such an impressive modernization of an old game dedicated to the style of its time while updating the game to have such a more eerie tone that matches the way we enjoy video games like it today. System Shock was a video game so deeply in need of modernizing and yet it having a remake release like this quickly demonstrates how much of the immersive sim genre is still carried in the genre today: Intricate map design that allows for different approaches to reach the same end goal. Toolset variety (granted it was a bit simpler back then to “here’s different guns” but still heavily varied in this game). The remake’s atmosphere of “you’re a lonely virus worming its way through Shodan’s station-wide body” is a creepy game of isolation, fear, and claustrophobia. Getting the “explore the maze” elements right that I find so rewarding in modern immersive sims (Deus Ex &amp; The Arkane Games) is so appealing in this remake because at its core that’s what so much of this game is really about in its gameplay loop. It even has a scrapping system to get money rewards so you can upgrade your weapons, similar to the vaporizing system in Prey (but no where near as complex). Prey’s circular influence can be felt here too as System Shock Remake is a game that takes place on a space station that is spinning in real time in orbit around Saturn so the occasional lighting that breaks through windows in the game might be lit up by the nearby planet reflecting light off our sun, or it might just be the sea of stars flickering because the station hasn’t spun past the celestial body just yet.</p><p>I’m only in the second zone of the game and yet I already want another one of these. Let them do System Shock 2, I’d buy it in an instant.</p><h4>A Plague Tale: Requiem</h4><p>This one is hard.</p><p>I <strong><em>really </em></strong>liked it. Except when I really didn’t. I kind of hated its stealth and combat gameplay updates over the first game. They were infuriating in the first third of the game. The systems got more complex this time around and the controls were unweildly. The AI felt a little too persistent in that first third as well, refusing to give up on trying to find me in bushes, forcing me out of hiding too often. When the AI wasn’t impossible to work around, the map was, offering little to no cover to make things work. In giving the player character tools to fight back but only so much, being found out at times made me want to restart encounters altogether because the tools you have before you’re discovered are so much more capable of taking out enemies if you can manage switching between tools well enough. But I couldn’t. I’d just scroll through the wheel of tools and panic a lot, forgetting that the hot wheel would slow down time well. It’s weird how much I struggled with this but I think this game and Horizon: Forbidden West are decent examples of how you can have too many layers of tools available for players to think about all of them.</p><p>Ultimately this sequel to A Plague Tale: Innocence felt at its strongest during its puzzling, during sequences where you’re just trying to find ways through the rat-infestation zones or exploring. The game’s greatest sequence is maybe right around its midpoint where you’re entreated to stay at a castle on the Island of La Cuna. You, your brother, and a friend get to traverse a massive landscape and explore to find secrets tied to the story’s lore. The visuals in the game help define just how far you’re traveling and what you’re seeing out there and you watch a beautiful summer solstice go from day to dusk to night in the process of three chapters. This naturally has an end result with the entire festival being decimated by the swarm of rats. It’s a series of levels in the story that are hard to forget, transporting the player and the characters to an entire other world in a wider story that spans nations but is, at its core, about a small handful of relationships in a very <em>very </em><strong><em>very </em></strong>grim story.</p><p>The story and sound design are the reasons I found myself being won over despite my hang-ups with the game. The sound design is simply immaculate for me. And the story is something else. It’s an ending you can see coming but don’t feel sure it’s going to quite go there the whole time. There hits a point though where you start to feel the story can’t really be going anywhere else unless it were to end on a cliffhanger. The game’s clearly running out of steam after a certain point. The natural conclusion being one that you really don’t want to see after two games of journeying. I hope the devs here get some time to improve and even refine or simplify the stealth and action mechanics, because if their suggestion post-credits becomes their next title, I’d rather not relive the gameplay frustrations I did this time to experience whatever next tragic horror they have in mind up for me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IlByaHOaAChPuE1dcY2neQ.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=74b482e135ba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Spencer Brown — The Road to Equanimity (Album Review)]]></title>
            <link>https://the-typer.medium.com/spencer-brown-the-road-to-equanimity-album-review-5d859044e939?source=rss-4c5509ad50b6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5d859044e939</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[edm]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[house]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[progressive-house]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[techno]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Fleming]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Oct 2023 21:00:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-16T21:00:15.391Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Spencer Brown — The Road to Equanimity (Album Review)</h3><p>It’s been five years since I reviewed Spencer Brown’s debut album “Illusion of Perfection” and so much has happened for the San-Fran resident over those years. Illusion of Perfection was a sort of lightning-in-a-bottle moment for both the growing musician and the Anjuna family at large. The mix album put together as a nice string of musical pieces that would carry the listener on a nice journey for a debut album wound up being a better representation of some of Spencer’s great strengths during his debut album tour: DJ-ing. The quality of the experience of being carried from start to finish on a musical journey sort of became his “thing” for a while after this album. The first tour featured numerous open to close and extended sets and if you were one of the lucky ones such as myself, catching an entire open to close experience with Spencer, you were probably quickly swept up in a whirlwind of wanting to see where this man’s career was about to go.</p><p>Later Spencer hit another tour with SBxID, a tour comprising of mostly extended sets and a desire to hone in on and experiment with the numerous club tracks he had yet to release (aka “ID”s). It was a great way to extend the success of his first tour and see exactly what kind of music would become the strong suit on tours and what catches all the big requests by fans. Fast forward four years and Spencer Brown has quite the record sheet: He has his own label, he’s experimented wildly with the formats of his primary genres with pandemic-designed tracks like “18 Minute Loop”, he fulfilled career dreams by releasing music on deadmau5’s “mau5trap” label, collaborated on vocal anthems with Above &amp; Beyond, released a second album “Stream of Consciousness”, toured again and again, and as of last week, released his third album “Equanimity”.</p><h4>Catching Up</h4><p>I didn’t review “Stream of Consciousness” at the time because there was a pandemic on and other things were occupying my mind but also because other music was wow-ing me at the time. I did buy the album and listened to it several times over, it wasn’t bad at all. But it has become clear, even moreso now with Equanimity, that Stream of Consciousness is in many ways a sort of “realignment” for Spencer Brown after his Illusion of Perfection and ID tours. The album structurally follows suit for what’s there in Illusion of Perfection but instead focuses on current collaborations in Spencer’s wheelhouse (which is what you expect out of any new album for an electronic artist) and the genres that Spencer decided to turn towards after spending enough time touring in the years leading up to that album: Melodic house, techno, progressive house. Alternatively Illusion of Perfection was much more varied with melodic house, progressive house, and the type of progressive house that’s oftentimes labeled in the west as “Trance”. From post-Illusion of Perfection onwards Spencer strongly shifted his focus towards that techno and house arena, collaborating around deadmau5, Qrion, and more. Stream of Consciousness was a new starting point for this development to sort of restart what people can expect out of his production wheelhouse. It was a good time, it wasn’t necessarily a major progression but instead a <em>refining</em>. I particularly enjoyed it as a contrasting album to Illusion of Perfection, opting to look at is as a sort of opening set that leads into Illusion of Perfection wonderfully.</p><p>Now, on his third album Equanimity, we get what truly feels like a sequel to what Spencer Brown did with his first two albums, an evolution of his mix albums and changes that feel much more substantial for the artist, if maybe a tad bit more cautions than I’d have hoped for. Let’s dive in.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7pODfl6NFx8gx6moEuon-A.jpeg" /></figure><h4>A Strong Start</h4><p>Equanimity starts off with its best foot forward: Awu Wemadoda, a collaboration with Grammy-winning vocalist group Ladysmith Black Mambazo driven by a memorable vocal hook. Both leading single and culturally-relevant, Spencer has used the track to place recognition on the multi-generational multi-ethnic nature of music’s history and dance music’s past in particular. It’s also the most “no-frills” and to-the-point a Spencer Brown intro has ever been. Where his first two albums kick off with patient beautiful starts that set tone wonderfully, this one cuts that start time in half and doesn’t want to waste much time establishing its beats. This isn’t <strong>bad</strong> either, in a way that I’ll explain in the coming tracks. But “18 Minute Loop” Awu Wemadoda is <strong>not. </strong>It’s a track that unfortunately exists in a space just a couple years after the astounding release of Lakou Mizik and Joseph Ray’s “Leave the Bones”; I say “unfortunately” because this wonderful album starter will inevitably draw up comparisons to “Leave the Bones”, which it really shouldn’t, for so many reasons not really worth exploring here other than to say: If you’re working with some new talent that represents another facet of dance music in your album that’s cool. The productions behind Awu Wemadoda are sleek, enjoyable, and work in the male-choir’s patterns effectively to the Spencer Brown template. The journey begins here and quickly hops through three hoops of tracks that are sure to impress.</p><p>SF to Córdoba continues a new naming convention of tracks that I think are going to retroactively rename “Airplane Tekno” to something like “SF to Germany” and get reconsidered as the origin of it all. Here his collaboration with Ezequiel Arias has an air of an Anjunadeep compilation to it; strong mid pads, light playful synth work and a steady guiding bassline. This track that hits closer to the 5-minute length compared to Awu Wemadoda’s sub-4 minute intro is the beginning of a trio of tracks that demonstrate how Equanimity sort of exists as a “mid-set” album, something very much worth praising. While Illusion of Perfection and Stream of Consciousness serve as a sort of “open to close but quicker” journey, it’s easy to feel both albums exist as the main set due to where <em>they end </em>in terms of strong jumpy finishing tracks. But Equanimity starts quick as if a DJ has already been playing for 90 minutes and a new one wants to get you dancing right away, SF to Córdoba and these two tracks following it don’t waste time <em>maintaining </em>that dance for you, ushering in that this album isn’t one that’s going to start with some nice vibes and take a really peaceful break the way Spencer’s first two albums did around “Airplane Tekno” and “LA ID”. No time, keep dancing. Mid sets like this are hard to demonstrate in album fashion as they maintain a night out at the club, keeping pace with what was already established but still needing to build up and amp up the experience for what’s coming without necessarily being <strong>the end of the road</strong>. It’s a difficult experience to manage, and even harder to squeeze into an album that’s supposed to feel like a journey that has an end point. But Spencer Brown makes the experience clear in this trio of tracks with how fast they move and how they don’t want to let you go for long.</p><p>We dash right over to 20ms, a playful techno number with Qrion that features a synth bar that’s clearly having its timing messed around with constantly, speeding up, slowing down. There’s even a few laser “pew pews” in the track’s bridge creating for what will inevitably be a blast to hear live as you can imagine Spencer playing around with this track’s loops to have a lengthy live edit. It takes me back to the first set I saw of his, an open to close hot after Illusion of Perfection’s release and he played what I presume to be an ID that featured numerous iPhone sound effects like the instant messaging bubble played at various loops and frequencies to mess with builds and breakdowns. 20ms is a fun variation on this idea that’s just a blast to mix with I’m sure. But no time to stay, 4 minutes later we’re over to track four with what’s maybe the most impressive number for me. Spencer Brown &amp; iLan Bluestone have collaborated before to decent reception but Amber Leaf is a whole different beast. A meaty track that is perhaps the absolute darkest impression of a Vintage &amp; Morelli track. The triple wind pipe flair, the deeper-trance drums, and that strange and foreboding growl synth imitate the Serbian producer in a way I really wasn’t expecting. I can’t wait to get my hands on the full cut of this track and one other from the album, it’s an irresistible vibe and to think that it comes from poster-boy mainstage presence iLan Bluestone is all the more impressive. I love it when this guy makes a track outside the box.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iWHNDhqtUnBUf2X-Z6Pr5Q.jpeg" /></figure><h4>The Middle of the Mid-Set</h4><p>Speaking of outside the box, at this point the album has fully moved you into its “mid set vibes” with the quick run through the first four tracks so it’s time to keep walking away from the borders of the box and go full-weird with Anjunadeep’s top-tier “weird melodic house” chief: Luttrell. Masonic &amp; Webster is the darkest the album gets with its thunderously deep bass and strange blurps and chirps. The high pitched loops only give a little air of anxiousness, you can easily imagine this played when you want your set to start feeling a bit “steady”. This track is also not afraid to drop it all for a moment to have some of that organic Luttrell flair sound off for a little bit.</p><p>Just past Masonic &amp; Webster is the album’s most daring moment that I’m sure Spencer and Wilt Claybourne must’ve been so excited to finish: Loccou serves as this album’s “LA ID” moment where the tempo is allowed to rest and adjust for a monent, shifting keys or genres a little more starkly in a way that doesn’t feel too drastic. What makes Loccou so astonishing is that it’s a breakbeat, the first one taking front and center in a Spencer Brown album. It also seems to feature what sounds like live sample productions a bit more with claps and some straightforward drum snaps. Loccou is elegantly mastered and slowly speeds up at its start to lift you out of the deeper techno vibes established across Amber Leaf and Masonic &amp; Webster, which is good because past this mid-way point the album chills out for a little bit here and again on Papi’s Cenote so it can have a couple more dances before farewell.</p><p>Papi’s Cenote may technically seem like a simpler track on an album filled with some interesting numbers, but it feels so much more significant than that. My ears picked up some of the styles common on Intricate Records back in the mid to late 10’s like Orphyd’s “Hypnosis”. While not necessarily similar all around, both tracks have a sense of presence and calmness to them that feels very central to the peaceful mindset suggested in Equanimity’s title. Surely Spencer values this track considerably in the album since it’s one of three to have the longest running time despite it being not the most dynamic of tracks. Much like mid sets, since Spencer has ushered you past the half way point on his album, he’s allowing himself the chance of letting you inspect some of his music for a longer period of time; hoping you’ll appreciate the technical qualities and the opportunity to just “be” during this track. For that Papi’s Cenote may be the most personal and important track here.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RaUgaLv7cUxmXURPDtA_DA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Dance Again</h4><p>But if you just want to dance hard, Spencer’s got plenty of the ol’ reliable progressive and melodic house for you here. Good Times <strong>is</strong> the longest track here and feels like a B-side from Illusion of Perfection that just never made the cut. Slower, ready to let those arps loop, and featuring that classic middle-EQ focused vocal hook, the track feels like his best version of a disco-tinged Toolroom tech house track, but <em>not</em>. Something you’d swap “J2” for right after “Nightwalk ”if you were looking back and tinkering with that 2018 album again. But don’t do that, just listen to Good Times and enjoy it today. I feel like sped up this number can also function well closer to the peak of a mid set if you’re trying to have the crowd ready to roll around for the main act. As it is on Equanimity, it’s such a steady bump to enjoy.</p><p>Curve brings back that Intricate Records familiarity but this time with Sergey Tkachev’s “Matorral”, a really wide mid-pad providing variety on a leading bassline makes for a track that makes you sense that build again that you get out of mid sets. This all gives way for a piano-led bridge briefly before springing right back to the loops. Curve is a neat track but not necessarily the most remarkable thing you’ll ever hear. But no DJ set will ever blow you away 100% of the time, it’s about a journey, and Curve is delicately placed here to build and build and <strong>build</strong>. Any trance fan such as myself can appreciate when house artists like a good bridge too. The mix hits its peak moment with Little Wane, a track teeming with punkier vibes, a simple “ey!” vocal chop and a blistering synth element that reminds me of GRUM’s “Stay” but with less noise, a little more restraint for the moment. Little Wane is the moment in the club night when you realize the set is about to wrap, this is <em>just </em>about it, and if Spencer Brown were playing you a <strong>main </strong>set he’d have his big moment next and then wind down. But this is a “mid set”, wind-down is just the beginning. So wind down the album does, almost quicker than the album starts, this time with Paavo’s alias “P.O.S.” and the track Afterparty Healing. While I wasn’t wild on this track on first listen, it’s unmistakable just how much Paavo’s P.O.S. alias has shined a light on the relevance of Paavo’s presence in the Above &amp; Beyond trio. His knack for emotive piano touches and production flairs that set tone so well are a welcome way for Spencer Brown to close the album, to signify his recognition of the person who helped get him signed to Anjunabeats and propelled his career forward. The two made tracks together that released across the year with “Polar Bears” for Paavo’s album and there’s even b-side-style tracks releasing already for more support of Paavo’s “Deeper Tales”. Both albums connected to a sort of healing experience, Afterparty Healing ties the two together in a way that’s simple and effective.</p><h4>What’s Missing</h4><p>Equanimity is quick, to the point, a rugged version of a mid-set on an album that properly follows up what Spencer Brown began with his first two albums. While Stream of Consciousness may have been a realignment, this is absolutely an evolution forward. Spencer’s touting some upcoming live shows for the Equanimity tour, some of which will be able to support a much more robust experience aligned with what he has in mind for taking this album on the road (I imagine cool lights and displays). You can see there’s a bigger picture he wants to present here with Equanimity and the forthcoming tour. But I am, unfortunately, left a little wanting from the producer’s new album. I have a profound respect for what this album manages to pull off. Like I said earlier, doing an album version of a mid-set DJ mix isn’t easy. There’s no doubt some of this album developed across the past three years where being a DJ wasn’t exactly a stable certainty for a time and Spencer pursued a more peaceful and hopefully affirming place in his life. I can’t deny this album accomplishes what he’s searching for there and there’s more collaborations than ever before. As a DJ that had some issues with self-hatred and had a bad relationship with his sexuality, Spencer Brown reaching the place he’s in now is a healthy thing and I want more music from that healthy life balance. I just hope there’s room for some more songwriting exploration on his part. He’s proven to collaborate fantastically with songwriters already, “Stuck” was a highlight for me last year and I’d love to see more emotive written songs attached to Spencer’s fantastic workings. Paavo’s Deeper Tales album wasn’t a revelation but the album’s biggest moments carried emotional weight the same way we remember Group Therapy did so many years ago. I wouldn’t be surprised if Spencer could find ways to do the same if he took some more time working with Paavo and finding a singer/songwriter or three to collaborate with to explore some stories together. It’s worked out excellently for Above &amp; Beyond, Andrew Bayer, and so many others before.</p><p>Overall I’m happy with Equanimity, it’s always a great time when Spencer Brown puts out a new album. If you wanted the next version of what Stream of Consciousness provides, something similar but different, look no further. If you wanted to know when Spencer Brown will start breaking his own molds for something starkly different, the time isn’t here yet. You can’t complain about it too much tough, a new tour, a new label, a Spencer Brown that has survived the pandemic, we weren’t going to see an entirely new style yet either. I’m comfortable saying Equanimity and the supporting tour are worth your time and money. It’s got its surprises waiting for you and the DJ has been a constant supporter of no radio edits for the sake of demonstrating the beauty of the full cut. That hasn’t gone away and so my support remains as always.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1WHjaN25yPDa70fFWxPkLA.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5d859044e939" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Jack White Gave Me the Answer on AI a Decade Ago]]></title>
            <link>https://the-typer.medium.com/jack-white-gave-me-the-answer-on-ai-a-decade-ago-20b3c891be7b?source=rss-4c5509ad50b6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/20b3c891be7b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[electronic-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[monstercat]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[machine-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Fleming]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 20 Jul 2023 21:01:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-07-20T21:01:38.952Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Jack White bit comes near the end. Spoilers: Most of this is not actually about Jack White.</p><p>July 11th marked the release for a new studio album by music producer and composer BT. Sadly, this is not a review of BT’s new album “The Secret Language of Trees”. I say “sadly” because from 2013 to 2020 I’ve found a way to write, podcast, or overall just discuss every new BT album. Ever since I started listening to his music around 2012 he quickly found a place among one of my favorite artists to listen to, carving out a variety of albums focused on different musical purposes: Dance, meditative, or music experiments that serve as journal logs for the creator that occasionally grabs the attention of the mainstream dance music scene. I say “sadly” about this release because I don’t feel comfortable reviewing a new BT album, giving it attention and praise in the way I normally would in a world where BT seems to have aligned himself with certain cultures and conversations surrounding subject matter over the past three years that a lot of the creative industry consider anything from “the new normal” to “a blight on the industry”.</p><p>I’m, of course, talking about NFT’s and AI. BT has very firmly established himself as a part of the NFT / blockchain wave over the past couple years and despite it mostly not being central to the cultural conversation at large anymore, he hasn’t really stopped promoting anything in the blockchain marketplace if he’s involved in it. Meanwhile his new album “The Secret Language of Trees” is firmly rooted in inspirations from machine learning and uses his own coded machine learning to generate art related to the album (or maybe even music? That part is less clear).</p><p>So while I won’t be reviewing the new BT album, I’ll instead be turning my normal release discussion towards BT himself, the position he has carved himself regarding NFTs and AI over the past three years, why some of it troubles me, and how I came to the conclusions I came to. I hope you’ll find my stance is actually fairly moderate towards BT all things considered, which means you might really dislike my stance by the end of this if you’re remotely against NFTs and machine learning. Just know that at this current juncture I can’t in good conscience say “Go buy and listen to the new BT album, it’s worth your time”. Not because BT is some immoral person or something, but because AI, at this very moment in time, is being used as a prop to disenfranchise an entire workforce of writers in an industry. And a musician like BT should know (in fact, <strong>does know</strong>) the dangers of how this very tool will get used in the future. And I want to write about how right now is a <em>really </em>bad time to be touting the amazing possibilities of machine learning while still giving the man some credit for what he seems to actually be doing.</p><p>Let’s dig in. I promise the Jack White part will come up near the end. If you’ve read my stuff before you probably know where I’m going already.</p><h4>BT —Technologist First, Artist Second</h4><p>BT has always been a major proponent of some sort of a new or potentially up and coming technology. When he was new to the dance industry he was using computers to create sounds alien to the scene (or sometimes going backwards and just futzing around with acoustics or live recordings, providing his hippie-side to trance music with field recordings and dolphin samplings). In the mid-00s with This Binary Universe he was putting his methods to the test with stutter edit programming and trying to turn it into a product he could market to the world, which he did, with Stutter Edit from iZotope. His return to dance music and release of Stutter Edit in the early 10s was followed later with BreakTweaker in 2014. By the mid-00’s, computers as the instrument for making dance music was a lot more common (deadmau5 certainly served as the sign it was becoming mainstream), but by the first half of the 10’s they had clearly become the mainstay for the foreseeable future. BT’s work probably felt really realized in a wider cultural sense at that point.</p><p>BT then spent a large chunk of the mid 10’s overhauling his production methods and suites, and separately working on an analog album for a change (more on that one later). Stutter Edit 2 came out in 2020 and almost simultaneous to that release was his new album The Lost Art of Longing (aka: TLAOL), BT had an interesting conversation about AI in a <a href="https://youtu.be/4bT4vsIqdRI">podcast</a> right at that time. I linked to the podcast in my review of TLAOL and this article will dive into some of the statements BT said then and what he seems to be doing right now. But between then and now, there’s the NFTs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RGAJHA9KN7TgC9gaTfsB7w.png" /></figure><p>In May of 2021, BT started composing music for auctioned NFTs, the big advertised one being Genesis.json, a 24-hour piece. In September he released a dance-focused album built and released exclusively on the blockchain called “Metaversal”. His twitter became enamored with posts and reposts fully supporting NFTs as a space for artists to support themselves. I’d like to talk about this, but not much. I want to overlay the NFT frezny and overlay it with the reality BT has been dealing with for a long time. If you want another one of a hundred articles or videos about NFTs being a scam and a grifting space, sorry: <a href="https://youtu.be/YQ_xWvX1n9g">Dan Olson covered the “NFTs as grifter space” in a video</a>, that’s not really needed here. Most people joke that Dan’s video single-handedly killed the space but really there were other factors at play that made the bubble burst (like laws). He’s done the work there, I think Dan breaks down the NFT problem really well and you can even see some of the things Dan talks about in that video reflected in BT’s own approach to this culture in the way he carries on today when discussing them or engaging with NFT content (mainly that only positive attitudes are allowed, critiques aren’t welcome). But I really don’t have time to get into the wider thing, partially because I didn’t give it as much attention as Dan Olsen did, and also because when BT was in the midst of this, I was unsubscribed from him on Twitter (I think his early-on mild prediction that COVID wouldn’t be that big a deal soured me on him by the time 2020 had ended). I didn’t listen to Metaversal out of principal for how unclear this marketplace seemed to be from the outset. And by the time it was on digital platforms I was turned off altogether. So I don’t have enough information to provide about BT and NFT’s other than I don’t like NFT’s and don’t care for BT’s adoration of the blockchain.</p><p>Instead: I’m interested in BT’s perspective as an <strong>artist </strong>when it comes to those early NFT days. For those not aware: One of the contributing ideas behind NFTs is personal ownership of a piece of digital content. The way that ownership is proven is through a digital cryptographic key, a token. The token, when provided to the work, will then spend hours or even days to decrypt the proof of ownership. People value ownership of these pieces of content in online cryptographic spaces because it’s not available outside those spaces. Well, it can be, pending on the type of media we’re talking about. But the execution, in essence, is that if I put up a digital scan of a painting I made up into the digital space where NFTs are bought and traded, no one else can “own” it in that space or others. Sure, someone could copy the image where it’s hosted, but I have the opportunity to sell something I made in a space where the primary idea is <em>supposed</em> to be about ownership being a heavily encrypted reality. And only those with the NFT (the token) own said piece of art. It’s pseudo-ownership as a marketplace for whatever you want to sell or own. Despite the way people talked up the importance of what they own, what was more important was and is what you are selling.</p><p>What does this mean for an artist like BT?</p><p>BT releasing “Metaversal” on the blockchain space meant the album wasn’t published by anyone else and it wasn’t immediately available on Spotify or YouTube or Amazon or iTunes. People had to buy it from him in the NFT space until it would inevitably make its way into pirating spaces. And it would, obviously. Music is regularly “pirated” through various means, from non-official streaming channel uploads to actual pirating across various torrent feeds. These things serve as a means of providing access to art outside of the “main channels” that directly feed revenue to the artist, in both official and unofficial capacities. It breaks copyright law, though most would agree that copyright law is both archaic and broken in the modern era. For example, there’s people out there that upload extended mixes of dance tracks to YouTube because the label that owns that music only puts up a radio edit of the song. The channel uploading that extended mix of the dance track has no rights to ad revenue of that music on YouTube because they don’t own the copyright for that music. Rarely do they get sued, the videos sometimes just get removed from YouTube or the account receives penalties if the actual publisher of the music pursues such a thing. Things like this meant that Metaversal eventually getting released on BT’s YouTube was inevitable if only to make sure the wider audiences out there would listen to the album on his channels so he can get the tiny tiny revenue involved in streaming. In today’s day even those “main channels” aren’t really doing much for the artist in terms of revenue. When discussing this, I’m drawn to a quote near the end of the podcast I referred to earlier. In the last chunk of the podcast BT starts talking about the future of artistry and has this to say about the present state (we’re back in 2020 for the “present state” conversation):</p><blockquote>The only people that make money from something like Spotify are 1% of 1% of artists and Daniel Ek and everyone at Spotify knows that. He even speaks to it. And everybody else might make twenty-five bucks a month, sometimes for millions of listens too…(brief gap in the conversation)…I had a conversation with my publisher the other day, this will give you an idea of how well you do from these kind of things. And like I said, we are so lucky, we have other ways that we’re able to support ourselves. And so we’re very very lucky in that way. I have a lot of friends that don’t, so when in that big jump from iTunes to Spotify, they’re gone, they have regular jobs now. And these were A-list electronic music artists. So I’m not going to call out by any names but it literally destroyed the livelihoods of many many people.<br><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bT4vsIqdRI">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bT4vsIqdRI</a></blockquote><p>So you can easily see how BT would’ve made this jump over to NFTs as this marketplace that was booming in the early 20’s. The pandemic was still raging in 2021, touring is still limited or dead (not that BT tours a lot but it’s probably a bigger revenue stream than streaming), streaming demands constant releases and doesn’t promise much in terms of revenue even if you maintain it. You’d need to be a signed artist with a label that promises a much better share of the money to have a remote chance at stability and success. And BT’s never been one to sit with any label permanently. He had some early signing mistakes with his first few albums and he’s lost a lot of the album rights to the music on Ima and ESCM (his first two albums). Since then he’s label-hopped regularly depending on what sort of a market his album might attract and what he can get signed. So naturally NFTs would seem like this fantastic opportunity: He can make the art, choose how many copies he wants to give out into that marketplace (naturally he’d want as many copies out there at a reasonable price), and all the revenue (aside from whatever fees in the NFT marketplace exist) goes to him. That’s a much more interesting venture than dealing with a publisher, trying to sign an album to a label, haggling over ownership elements, charting out a release date, etc. etc.</p><p>This reality still doesn’t excuse aligning with NFTs for me thanks to the way NFTs were being weaponized for grifting. For BT, the guy who has always been pushing whatever the new technology boundary is, this wasn’t a surprising move. But it certainly screamed that for once <strong>BT was making a move that spoke about a revenue and ownership-motivated technology he wants to support more than the art he was trying to show the world</strong>. Before NFTs, BT’s technology moves served the music he was making first and then he’d find ways to sell his toolsets to the public for revenue. That all changed in 2021. And while I’ve not listened to Metaversal because of this move, I have heard from critics with similar tastes as I that Metaversal as an album wasn’t…really interesting at all.</p><p>Now let’s rewind the tape just a little bit and go back to that quote. I left a little bit out for dramatic effect but also because what BT was saying was, in essence, a voice of concern for the artistic community and how new technology traditionally has been really destructive for the creative community at large. BT briefly alludes to how large corporate ownership of a platform is taking all the profits by being another middle man in the process of trying to sell your art. But then he has this to say at the end of it that I left out and now I’m ready to talk about:</p><blockquote>And so we’re very very lucky in that way. I have a lot of friends that don’t so when in that big jump from iTunes to Spotify, they’re gone, they have regular jobs now. And these were A-list electronic music artists. So I’m not going to call out by any names but it literally destroyed the livelihoods of many many people. <strong>And artificial intelligence is going to do that ten-thousand-x if we do not curate what that means in so far as the creative community. So I’m waving a big red flag for everybody.<br></strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bT4vsIqdRI">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bT4vsIqdRI</a></blockquote><p>Back in 2020 BT was already waving a big flag around AI, but the environment he was waving it around in back then was mostly ignoring the question at the time. It wasn’t the conversation yet. The interview (which I’ll continue to quote) goes on to discuss AI as an incredible opportunity, but also an incredibly dangerous one. And now we’re here in 2023 where AI is the predominant conversation surrounding the future of how art is going to be made and sold and BT has released an album that nods towards AI repeatedly. It’s time to get nitty gritty with the album’s release and BT’s conversation around it. Doing so I think will reveal much of BT’s stance on AI that he had back in 2020, how he’s talking about it now in 2023, and why I’m taking this stance of “I’m not a fan of how BT’s doing what he’s doing” while still not necessarily condemning the guy altogether.</p><h4>Talking about the new album</h4><p>At first glance so much of The Secret Language of Trees spoke “AI built” in conversation. When talking about the track “Ember” on Twitter, for example, he talked about the visualizers made for the album.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/608/1*MP-UOdPNHes_cjxN3a9mww.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://twitter.com/BT/status/1678169407137230848">https://twitter.com/BT/status/1678169407137230848</a></figcaption></figure><p>So he very clearly has been using machine learning to create the music videos and album artwork that are tied into the album’s release. One look at it and it seems evident. What’s interesting is it seems he has sculpted his own machine learning to make this happen in a way that he prefers. Ever the technologist, this is maybe the most focused BT has gone towards the visual aspects of his albums. But it’s not a first. This Binary Universe had several video projects created by others. These Hopeful Machines has a fantastic booklet art piece attached to it that got sold in a limited edition poster later (I own one of the last ones sold, I still need to get a nice frame built and find a place to hang it). The Underscore album in 2016 had accompanying drone footage that he hired some people to capture while listening to the music of the album. But a lot of BT’s album artwork has left much to be desired in my eyes, which is why this at least looks very <em>dedicated</em> on BT’s part. He’s got an opportunity to spend some time making a thing himself and instead of just doing a quick AI creation he instead went out of his way to build a complex filming rig to utilize that various stuff fed into machine learning. And apparently this work will go into the blockchain for use. I’m not crazy about how often the art in these videos does weird hands and feet stuff, AI art in general that looks like this just discomforts me a bit. And I don’t want to begin the conversation around how many of those images were paid for copyright use or scraped across the internet. That’s a whole can of worms you can consider yourself. Besides, this isn’t a review of the album.</p><p>The bigger question is if the album <strong>music </strong>is, y’know, made using machine learning. Maybe? Maybe not. When talking about the track “Deep Fake” on Twitter, we got this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/602/1*G9I8z0qKbrtUIhkXV6fr1Q.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://twitter.com/BT/status/1677773081262055427">https://twitter.com/BT/status/1677773081262055427</a></figcaption></figure><p>From this post I get the idea that BT is more making some of this music in the inspiration of the things that we’re afraid of that mean drastic scary change (the way sampling was a concern as he talks about), but those things turn out to not be a problem in the end. It’s more “the spirit of future changes” I suppose. But saying “not because it’s using AI compositionally…” suggests he did use AI to compose the music? Well, according to his interview with Echoes on their podcast when they asked if the album was made with artificial intelligence, no, he didn’t.</p><blockquote>“That’s a great question. So, it’s not. And…it is not an album that is utilizing machine learning. However, parallel to writing this body of work I’ve been developing some unbelievable applications that utilize machine learning and generative artificial intelligence. And I’ve been working on those things for the past six years, starting with some what we call ‘MIR algorithms’, so things for audio feature set identification like ‘parsing out sounds into different piles’, simply. You know, saying like ‘these are snare drums and these are cellos and these are cymbals and these are vocals’. Right? But none of them are used on the record but a lot of the titles are inspired by things I’ve been working with in that space from like a technology and development perspective.”</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://echoes.org/2023/07/13/echoes-podcast-bts-nature-in-wires/">https://echoes.org/2023/07/13/echoes-podcast-bts-nature-in-wires/</a></blockquote><p>So, that’s a plus for me in terms of responsibly <em>listening to</em> or consuming the album. If you buy the album it sounds like BT didn’t make the music with any sounds irresponsibly captured. Which is the norm for most of BT’s more electronic and introspective works, they’re usually more solo-made and collaborate with other artists a little less. To continue the conversation surrounding this though, I want to back track a little further. Back to that 2020 interview. That interview was hot on the release schedule for The Lost Art of Longing and so part of the conversation in that podcast was about the age of digital streaming music and how Spotify is using machine learning or artificial intelligence to try and better understand what makes people listen to music in more immediately gratifying ways.</p><blockquote>…Secondly, now what you have is an entire generation of people creating music for, it’s really kind of a double plus (time?) Orwellian type thing, they’ll say “Well for the algorithm you gotta make sure something really interesting happens in the first 30 seconds”. And you’re like “Hang on a second here. So you’re telling me that you’re making a piece of music to appease artificial intelligence. Are you hearing yourself? You’re making music for computer.” And I would argue it’s made people feel less happy. It’s made people feel less connected. It’s made people more bored with music. It’s made the turnover rate of music higher…I would argue that it’s why people are so hungry for music experience. Because they’re experiencing-their experience of music now is exactly what you said. It’s this ephemeral, passing experience, and it’s in the background. So it’s “music to chill to”, what does that indicate? You’re chilling. You’re doing something else. It’s “music to run to” or “work out to”, what does that indicate? You’re doing something else. It’s “music to study to”, same thing. So I would say that people are dying for authentic music experiences.<br><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bT4vsIqdRI">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bT4vsIqdRI</a></blockquote><p>The Lost Art of Longing, in my own review of it, very much so met that definition of an authentic music experience head on. As the months rolled on after release, TLAOL seemingly never became a product touting radio edits, short cuts that feed a more instantly rewarding or “algorithmically interesting” listen. BT’s music has never really been that for sure. He’s almost always veered on lengthy, experimental music that rewards repeat listens and people who sit through the entire experience thematically. But if he’s been working on something in the machine learning space for musicians, what good will come of it? Since we don’t know what it is right now, here’s more from that interview three years ago. This is a big chunk.</p><blockquote>You said something that is one of the most important things that we need to be thinking about and it’s what the musical community needs to rally around. I privately talk to people about this all the time, I’ve never talked about this publicly, I’m going to seed this idea here. And I’ve never heard anyone else ever talk about this. I would argue that an artist is the sum total of their life experience expressed creatively in decisions. So, our preferences are expressed creatively as decisions, right? And it would seem really really complex. “Well this person wrote this really sad piece of music when their father passed away”, right? Like how is that a hierarchical tree of decision making? It is. And I can tell you from looking at the way that particularly convolution-based neural networks analyze these massive data sets of material, they don’t need names for variables like we do, they’re not thinking like “attack transient, or timbre, or aperiodic or periodic signal”. They’re just thinking “I see similarities in this data set” across tens of thousands if not thirty, fifty thousand variables. So an artist is this sum total hierarchical tree of decision making. So what is that actually in the artificial intelligence space? I would call that a training set. <strong>I believe that an artist should legally have the right to patent their training set.</strong> So when we make this quantum jump, and it’s going to happen, not inside fifteen years, not inside fifty years, inside ten. More like inside five. When we make this quantum jump from non-generative music and humans making music to generative music, <strong>if an artist is not legally protected as a training set that artist will be cloned in this space and music like their works will be enjoyed for people and people in silicon valley will decide what that’s worth.</strong> And I guarantee you like Daniel Ek paid himself more than the sum total of all royalties in Spotify for almost the entire duration of Spotify, <strong>those kind of decisions will be made and they will not benefit the artistic community.</strong> So I would say that artists need to rally around this idea, that their preference has value. (gap reiterating the training set value idea) Eventually these two things will collide and if artists are not protected as a training set, um, there won’t be artists anymore.<br><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bT4vsIqdRI">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4bT4vsIqdRI</a></blockquote><p>BT hasn’t seemed to have changed his stance from 2020 to now in 2023. Here’s that Twitter bit again:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/584/1*hQF4r8uXrNYQr7QyB1fs-Q.png" /></figure><p>So if you’re trying to be fair to the man, and I am for sure: BT’s pro-AI but <em>also </em>pro-artistic rights around AI. So why don’t I buy it? Why don’t I hop onto Medium and give this album a review and say “yeah, here’s what I think about this music and why I do and don’t like it?” Is it not enough that BT is pro-artistic rights around AI? Well, it has to do with three points.</p><h4>Point one: My experience with The Lost Art of Longing.</h4><p>In my review of TLAOL, I made a point near the end of the review that despite BT expressing the album being about people appreciating the sense of longing and an attachment to antiquated things in a digital era, he also was hyping up his own album in a manner that suggested I don’t wait for the antiquated thing. He kinda broke his own messaging. Basically the CD was taking a while to get to me in the pandemic and BT said I shouldn’t wait for the CD and listen to it online and enjoy. That felt so in contrast to the very theme central to his conversation about the album. Here’s an excerpt from my review:</p><blockquote>But it’s not gonna topple the machine and make people enjoy it ONLY in ways that are better for us. The mechanism of TLAOL’s release and delivery don’t adhere to the means that focus for longing in the eyes of this millennial who so often stands on that dividing line between the physical and the digital.</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://the-typer.medium.com/bt-the-lost-art-of-longing-album-review-c3ee96a8f7e9">https://the-typer.medium.com/bt-the-lost-art-of-longing-album-review-c3ee96a8f7e9</a></blockquote><p>Reason number one behind why I can’t stand behind a release like The Secret Language of Trees and publicly say “go out and buy it” is because I have my doubts at BT’s ability to approach the AI problem and not becoming the very thing he fears. His previous albums didn’t change the world in people craving more thorough and lengthy experiences or in people seeing the benefit of NFTs industry-wide. Maybe it wasn’t meant to though, after all it’s an album. It maybe changed some people in that aspect, but not the industry at large. That leads right into point two.</p><h4>Point two: The AI Plans</h4><p>AI though, <strong>is going </strong>to impact many industries at large. BT has been working on <em>something</em> and I’m guessing it’s an AI that can (or tries to) replicate artist data sets to create music for them. BT’s technology has always enabled artists with toolsets, rarely has it ever been about any sort of a licensing system. But who needs licensing and legislation when you’ve got <strong>the blockchain</strong>?</p><p>I imagine BT’s new AI technology he’s been developing has been trained to try and build an artist’s dataset out of whatever back catalog you decide to feed it, then that dataset can <em>only be used</em> with the blockchain securely. You can then keep it for yourself but use it or sell it at your own will on the blockchain so you can create new music or have your sound or style memorialized in the interesting dystopia this sort of technology envisions.</p><p>What do I think about this? Do I think it would make it so artists en masse can make music that sounds like their own stuff but not have to do the same type of work involved? Sure. Do I think it’ll actually work and change the industry as we know it? No. Whatever tools BT builds have to be mass adopted and the blockchain space just isn’t what it was a couple years ago. I think if BT wants to accomplish the thing he’s talking about, he’d have to already be using this technology and taking it to labels that can help their signed artists generate data sets out of their legally copyrighted tracks (record label copyrights can go down to the sample level) and then <em>maybe </em>preserving that dataset on the blockchain. I think speed and mass adoption of a technology is a great way to make fast progress, but it never really comes <strong>without </strong>silicon valley and big corporate interests <em>also </em>gobbling up those toolsets for their own short sighted gain. What happens when an artist parts ways with that label? Or, imagine when Spotify will release their own in-house version of these tools that people jump on and have briefly lived “careers” making AI-generated music and it only floods the market more, taking away attention to people actually spending time trying to learn about how to make music. This already happened in the video game spaces on Steam with asset flip games and that never really went away. Valve just kind of ignored the problem for the most part. Never mind how many artists will make decisions that ultimately make them lose rights to their music or their own curated and crafted sound over the past decade.</p><h4>Point three: That Jack White thing</h4><p>Watch from 6:49 to 14:56</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FAJgY9FtDLbs%3Fstart%3D3140%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D3140&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DAJgY9FtDLbs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FAJgY9FtDLbs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7e5945ad132ad90ed2db32da3ecd5914/href">https://medium.com/media/7e5945ad132ad90ed2db32da3ecd5914/href</a></iframe><p>I’ve gone back to this interview so many times over the years. I only included a seven minute snippet but the whole interview covers the range of topics about pursuing authenticity, the temptations of settling for certain comforts in the process of creating art while being an artist. And now, ten years later, the breadth of this interview answers the questions in my mind about AI and how it could be used vs. how it will be used, even when not directly talking about it. Because it’s an interview that primarily deals with creativity and being an artist.</p><p>AI is one of the biggest temptations that is building and showing itself out of creating art, it’s the reason I think AI won’t do something good and different and preserve the existence of artists but instead it’ll give people shortcuts to try and make something good without knowing enough about how to make something in the first place. We consider the same things when it comes to food, our hopes for a career or four, our passions, so why not the art someone makes? To put it in a more succinct way Mat Zo has made several critiques on AI and how it’ll impact art. Here’s one and a follow-up response about a conversation he and Kill the Noise had:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/606/1*JgBVb3xdsCYyuTDTRZAWbg.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://twitter.com/Mat_Zo/status/1640948073751781376">https://twitter.com/Mat_Zo/status/1640948073751781376</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/604/1*ctHWr7adrwinOP3h4BT8Cw.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://twitter.com/killthenoise/status/1640949668376096769">https://twitter.com/killthenoise/status/1640949668376096769</a></figcaption></figure><p>That’s how it starts.</p><p>Electronic music is one of the industries regularly at odds with itself over scandals and arguments about authenticity. It happens with any industry that’s booming, which meant in the early 10’s there was a lot of talk about ghost producers and fake DJs. Those conversations still happen today but less often. The reason people make a big deal about it is two-fold. 1: People looking around seeing others achieve success for doing less than what they themselves are doing (not necessarily a healthy behavior, but that’s what it is). And 2: People dedicating a lot of their time being passionate about an artist only to realize that artist wasn’t who they thought in terms of their honesty about what they say they’ve made. “That’s how it starts”.</p><p>Mat Zo has also made the fair point that others have, which is that AI still can’t make something <strong>new</strong>. No matter how much data you feed AI, it’s only going to base all of its construction off of things it has experienced or been shown in the past. It’s only finding unique combinations that weren’t around before. So when you decide to make something off the rails as an electronic artist and say go make an entire album dedicated to the new wave music of the 80s in the vein of Depeche Mode after ten years making trance and electronica, what will your AI do then? If you’ve been nothing but an electronica producer for ten years and want to make an acoustic album, where do you start? What will your AI generate for you based off your own dataset?</p><p>The temptation to rely on AI to streamline your workflow or overwrite the hard parts of the process removes all the growth you go through in learning <em>anything</em>. I know I sound ancient when I say this, but “hard work” does matter even in art. You don’t need to suffer to make your art, but good things rarely come easily. Getting outside your comfort zone and trying the new stuff or dealing with the parts of the creative process that you struggle with is part of what makes your work unique. My first season of my DJ mix show Typer Tyme was <em>awful, </em>riddled with design and approach mistakes. I was manually building continuous mixes in REAPER by forcing immediate tempo adjustments on the master mix and then calculating how I should adjust those tempo changes on the individual track playback rates. I was using envelope points to change 4-band EQs on every track during the transition, applied in linear pathways instead of the more dynamic approach you get when you actually DJ. It was <strong>really </strong>bad. But I learned so much from the process and it helped me immensely when I started actually DJ-ing for the show. It also made that first season <em>what it was. </em>Searching and working towards your art is important because when you’re cheesing it, when you’re making the quick bang for your buck, it comes out as boring a lot of the time. In my review of Daggers by All Hail the Silence (a new wave revivalist duo composing BT and Christian Burns) I spend a fair amount of time harping on how tired I am of 80’s ripoff EDM in the industry. And then I have this to say about this album BT and Christian made entirely out of analog equipment from start to finish:</p><blockquote>I don’t know that anyone has asked that question (should we stop trying to love the 80s so much because we’re eating it to death?), but I’ve got a feeling that if BT &amp; Christian Burns keep trying, their All Hail the Silence project could wind up answering that question in the minds of a lot of people (creators and otherwise), and get everyone finally tired of using the 80s as an easy-mode tool for sounding <em>cool. </em>Because make no mistake, All Hail the Silence’s debut album “Daggers” is a phenomenal example of two passionate people working their tail feathers off to replicate (not tap into) the new wave genre and the musical experiences that so richly filled their childhood. It’s still got some pieces missing that would become the “White Stripes” of new wave music. And I’m not exactly sure BT &amp; Christian Burns are interested in being the stalwarts of the genre so much as “living it out a bit”, but Daggers is a debut album to celebrate for some fans of the genre and definitely worth a look at for anyone new to it.</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://medium.com/@the-typer/all-hail-the-silence-daggers-review-dd47d5e7e6f9">https://medium.com/@the-typer/all-hail-the-silence-daggers-review-dd47d5e7e6f9</a></blockquote><p>Whatever your opinion is regarding machine learning and what kind of a role it’s going to play in the future, there’s a role it’s playing right now that <strong>should not </strong>be ignored, and that’s the writer’s strike going on right now. From what it sounds like, AI is only part of the whole conversation. But AI is definitely being looked at as a potential tool to try and keep revenue flowing for the corporations as is while the people who write the shows and movies you love aren’t being paid fair wages. If music labels at large were trying this right now for music, pushing for AI-generated music by producers to churn out creations faster than before or try to use AI to create music to sell while its producers go on strike, where would you sit on this? Where would BT sit on it? How would the labels and publishing groups respond? Spotify already has an interest in this but they don’t really publish music so much as provide it to you through their platform. Most electronic music labels don’t seem too interested in pushing this element at all, they mostly seem to want to continue to support artists. But what if your favorite artist stopped getting tracks signed to a label because they only make one EP a year that’s really good while another artist signed to the label used AI to make four EPs with two hits each year, generating more money for the label and more reason for the label to not sign a diversity of creators?</p><p>I can’t in good conscience tout or review the efforts BT has put forth on this new album while he talks up the incredible opportunities of machine learning and AI in the music and creative industry while livelihoods in other creative industries are threatened by this subject matter. If he wants to make a bigger difference, and fast, I think he might want to involve himself in a space where others benefit more than he does.</p><p>Despite his intentions seeming good, time will only tell if whatever BT has coming in the future is geared to benefit creators or not, whether it’s short sighted in a world where corporations have the revenue to get ahead of these issues or if somehow it’s a magic bullet that’ll fix everything. I must be jaded because I don’t see it happening. BT knows how to make some good art, he even clearly knows how to use technology to support his art in ways he can sell to the world, but he’s not the person I look towards when I want someone to address or have an answer to a problem plaguing the industry, at least not an answer that I think will work at large. It might work for BT, but not everyone.</p><p>I’ll leave you with another Jack White quote from that interview, this time from a few minutes past the last bit. Again, from 2013:</p><blockquote>And it’s going to get worse because the technology that’s available now is all about, as technology has always been, making things less labor intensive and removing the labor from the ‘whatever the thing’ is, whatever idea [it] is. So as technology gets more and more down the line of “you don’t need to sing in tune, we can sing in tune for you, press this button and it will tune you”, I mean, it’s going to get worse and worse. And it’s up to every- I have a big chip on my shoulder about “responsibility for technology”…And I think for a long time technology, even victrolas, you know, how that was done, there was a manners and politeness attached to it. Responsibility for the new technology. But I think nowadays I think the new technology is “here gimme the toy” and you know “I don’t give a damn anything to do with anything rules. No rules about the toy at all. Just gimme the toy”.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=20b3c891be7b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Star Wars — Jedi: Survivor]]></title>
            <link>https://the-typer.medium.com/star-wars-jedi-survivor-d32341c46d9e?source=rss-4c5509ad50b6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d32341c46d9e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jedi-survivor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[video-game-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[star-wars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[souls-like]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[respawn-entertainment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin Fleming]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Jun 2023 21:02:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-16T21:02:07.605Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Star Wars — Jedi: Survivor</h3><p>I love Star Wars. There was a time somewhere across the past decade where I was convinced I wouldn’t like most Star Wars stuff coming out. It was probably between 2007 and 2015. Despite liking the sequel trilogy as it happened, I was definitely skeptical in the leading years until that momentous December in 2015. By the time 2019 rolled around “the discourse” surrounding Star Wars had turned me back towards Star Wars so hard I’ve caught up on most things Star Wars visual media and found a new appreciation for so much of what’s out there. Rebels is definitely one of my favorite Star Wars things now and Ahsoka lands in a few months. I’m excited and it’s been nice to at least have regular Star Wars ideas coming out now.</p><p>All this to say I have a bit of a Star Wars bias that’s backwards against what others will often say. Ignoring The Last Jedi (which I loved), I liked Obi-Wan more than most. Boba Fett had an empty protagonist but I appreciated it for that emptiness because Boba Fett has always been the guy that looks cool and does very little (except in Clone Wars). And it turns out the same opposite approach applies to the newest Star Wars game. The world rails against Jedi Survivor for the bad release it <strong>absolutely has had</strong>, but I kinda don’t care because <strong>Star Wars video game again. </strong>It’s been a month since release and I’m finally ready to start putting all my thoughts and notes on this game together after beating it. Answer? It’s good! I think I won’t be walking away from Jedi: Survivor considering it a revelation or anything in the years to come, but the highs are higher this time around. Unfortunately the lows are maybe a few rungs lower too for me to say I enjoyed every aspect of this game more than the first. Like always, I start at the good.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VMbS_nW0Ge84V_z3aFFLzA.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Checking the Improvement Boxes</h4><p>In playing Jedi: Survivor, I would go back and read my old review of Jedi: Fallen Order from 2019 and I kept getting surprised by Respawn every time I had a session playing Survivor. For the first two weeks I consistently found complaints I had lodged against the first game getting quickly checked off as “fixed” in this one.</p><p>First there’s the gameplay. Originally I complained in ways about Fallen Order’s combat struggling to work in tandem with animations. This was a rather sticky problem for me because I had just finished Sekiro, which is kinda <em>peak </em>sword-style gameplay that tries to replicate this idea that sword fights are enjoyable when they’re this rhythmic back and forth of dodging, blocking, parrying, and taking the offensive only when you can to break down an enemy’s guard. Fallen Order had similar gameplay but didn’t get the “feel” of it quite right when it came to higher difficulties and (more importantly) the harder boss fights. It was frustrating at times, but awesome when firing on all cylinders. I don’t know what Respawn did but it feels 100% gone here. I still played this game on a higher difficulty like last time (one notch up) and yet the blocking vs. parrying differences almost always felt tangible and like something I could manage. Boss fights that got more intense in second or third phases felt dangerous yet passable if I could just learn the timing right.</p><p>Taking more inspiration from Nioh’s (and Jedi Outcast/Academy’s) stances, Survivor has multiple stances you unlock across the game and they almost all feel <em>purposeful. </em>They’re also different ways to modify your lightsaber. I almost felt spoiled for choice here. Before you leave the opening of the game you’ll have three stances already available to you: The first game’s traditional single-blade stance with revamped moves to unlock, a two blade stance that moves fast and packs a high damage output while lacking in range and defense, and the ever-famous double-bladed stance that has high defense and range, but won’t knock over every enemy quite as quickly. I almost immediately abandoned the solo blade once I got my hands on the later two stances. By the time you’re about a quarter of the way through the game you’ll unlock a sort of rapier-styled stance featuring one blade and a blaster and then about half way through the game you get a crossguard stance that works very much like a greatsword in the Souls games; high damage, long wind ups. In this wide range of skills available you’ll likely find two or three stances to stick to and upgrade them across the game. I had a blast with it and was surprised that the blaster stance wound up being a favorite of mine. It was an easy contender against the dual blade stance regularly. The additional ability to charge up a shot or fire off quick blasts that take out ranged enemies just became way too useful in this game, especially at harder difficulties. Your abilities make a quick return with most of your abilities from the first game readily present for the player right at the start. It’s refreshing to not spend so much time in a sequel reacquainting oneself with all the abilities from the first. AAA games of this scope and scale often have to deal with the concern that players who missed the first game will be utterly helpless the second time around, bigger sequel, more things to learn. Luckily the extended tutorial mission on Coruscant provides almost all the training wheels the player needs. I found particular joy in some of the later abilities permitting the player to lift multiple enemies into the air and allow you to prioritize crowds in your own way. I only wish it would last longer, even when maxed out it felt a little hampered.</p><p>Next check box: Level design and traversal. In Fallen Order this was a particular grief for me since Fallen Order clearly seemed to be trying its hand as a Souls-vania. Map design that creates forced circles / little to no way of backtracking? Almost entirely gone this time. Not only are there very few times where you’ll stumble into an exploration that <em>requires </em>you to go forwards to find a way out, but there’s fast travel now for almost the entire game. This addressed one specific complaint I had about the first game with <strong>two </strong>solutions. Survivor worlds are often larger than Fallen Order (I was often making the Akrham City/Knight comparison to Fallen Order’s Arkham Asylum, the former is wider, the later is closer and layered), the result of that scale change means map design is often more open-ended and allows for players to just leave areas with ease, but if you find yourself not wanting to bother with longer traversal as well, the fast travel is your friend. You can’t fast travel between planets, but that’s just a ship loading sequence away. Outside of the game’s lengthy introductory hours, you can leave to another planet at almost anytime you wish. Map design overall feels so much more thought out and segmented in big chunks in a way that feels natural and enjoyable. Some of my favorite memories of this game are tied to being able to finally traverse a zone and deciding on a whim to just go through it before the story ever takes you there. To my surprise the game enables this behavior better than ever before with optional chunks of the map that act as larger bridges between story areas on the main planet of Koboh. This results in some zones of the game existing just for the fun of discovery. There’s even a few places to go to that never cross paths with the story at all. At one point I decided to try exploring a mountain pass during a part of the game that takes place at night on Koboh. I expected the mountain pass to have something blocking my way and there were definitely a few paths I couldn’t take yet, but I actually went all the way to the mountain summit and took an elevator back down, I even unlocked a new tool that let me explore more of the game. This was entirely optional at the time and, true to the metroidvania fashion, the game just kinda let me do it once I could. I did this in Jedi: Survivor at least three or four times throughout my experience and every time I enjoyed it.</p><p>One of the other points I levied against Fallen Order’s map design was that the lack of fast travel made me think traversal should’ve felt so much more important in that game’s mechanics and controls. Granted Fallen Order had its traversal strengths, but you’re also hampered for a lot of the game as you relearned your abilities and the controls were too sticky. Traversal feels so much better this time around. Controls feel less sticky and this is a rare case of a sequel not removing the player arsenal from the start. So right from the beginning you can already double jump and wall run and hop to new heights. You’ll still pick up new abilities as you go too, adding to your growing range of tools available to you (an early zip grapple, followed later by a point launch jump, a dash, and more) . This creates a greater sense of that freedom to explore since so much is a capability of yours right off the bat. Having the option to fast travel addresses a problem from a previous game while better traversal controls this time around make you happy to explore or skip the fast travel in some cases anyways. As this review progresses you’ll see I kinda don’t love how utterly open this Jedi game feels and what Respawn feel they need to do to because of it, but when the metroid elements come out, remember that those complaints kinda vanish. The open elements simply start swallowing the metroid elements whole.</p><p>I think the only thing that <strong>consistently</strong> bothered me about this game’s traversal is a design and programming choice that I imagine was something Respawn might’ve gone back and forth on for a long time: Fall damage. Anytime the player falls into a death pit or somewhere the devs don’t intend you to go, the game considers it a failure and the player takes a small amount of fall damage while being set back to the last safe place where they were standing. That’s a mechanic we’ve seen in a lot of in other games. The fall damage can be disabled, which is nice for accessibility. You just keep trying with no damage. But here we’re playing an open world souls-vania with a lot of traversal capabilities. We have double jumps that can be delayed between jumps significantly, a dash that extends your distance reach during those jumps, and even sliding or extended wall slides. So how do you know when fall damage should trigger? You don’t want to just program every single place where if players fall “here” it’s considered fall damage because it’s a big game. That takes too long. And sometimes players will jump from a location way too high but not “out of bounds” and it won’t feel reasonable for a person to fall that far and not take damage. This isn’t Borderlands. Respawn’s answer to this <em>appears to be </em>(I’m not an actual programmer, but my constantly running into this seems to confirm the idea) to give players a set “fall length” and if players have fallen a certain distance, even if they’ve seemingly mitigated how bad that fall distance is with a jump or a double jump to interrupt that fall, the game still assumes you’re taking the damage if you haven’t hit terrain. Even if where you land is in-bounds. By normal human physics I’m pretty sure this makes sense. Using the force to interrupt your fall with a jump won’t negate the drop, right? But for “game feel”, it doesn’t quite add up. There’s a lot of moments in this game where a fall almost within control for Cal and the screen starts to fade to black around the edges, you can dash, jump or double jump to prolong that, but ultimately you hit the ground, Cal takes damage, and you’re reset to a ledge again. I’d rather just take the same amount of damage and roll to the place I was trying to reach so long as it’s not out of bounds for gameplay. Instead Respawn chose to do both and it sorta slows me down sometimes by taking non-optimal paths. If the damage scaled based on fall distance and exceeded a certain amount, maybe then reset me? I didn’t love it.</p><p>Puzzles are much better this time around. They weren’t a massive complaint in the first game but since the puzzles were so directly tied to your discovery of powers in Fallen Order, it was this sort of prolonged version of the starting area in Breath of the Wild. A tutorial that ran across an entire game as Cal got in touch with his powers again. Forget all of that now. Puzzles are a constant, both small and large, tying together story quests or side quests, allowing exploration and a means to uncovering items to add to your ever growing swag collection. Having additional tools like an electric bolt or Koboh seed sprayer that BD-1 can utilize also added to the various tools Respawn could use to build up puzzles here. Pair that with later abilities you get (like dashing or barrier skipping) and Respawn’s capacity to build a variety of puzzles and challenges grew really well. So they instituted challenges throughout the game to explore what they could build. My only sorrow here is that BD-1 can’t use his bolt ability as a combo link during Cal’s attacks. Just hear me out: It’d be rad.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9x2gz0nBE3E4az7E_ujpvw.jpeg" /></figure><h4>A Bigger Jedi Game</h4><p>Once I start talking about challenges I think it’s safe to wade into the waters of how Jedi: Survivor is just ultimately a bigger game than before and I’m not entirely happy about it. I think it took me close to 60 hours to do everything I could. I got all the collectibles aside from whatever lies at the end of the double rancor challenge and I unfortunately encountered a bug locking me out of half of the bounty missions for now. Respawn are working on a patch but I consider my time with the game done at this point. I play games slower so my time investment isn’t a fair comparison for most others out there. 60 hours for me might be 30 to 40 for you. How about a <strong>scale </strong>to better paint the picture? Jedi: Fallen Order had four main planets you’d spend most of the game on and a couple segment-specific planets. Jedi: Survivor has four as well, this time it’s Coruscant, Koboh, Jedha, and Shattered Moon with two other segment-specific planets tied to the plot. The first game did take place on Zeffo and Bogano quite a bit, but there was a <strong>lot </strong>to explore on Kashyyyk and Dathomir too. If you charged through this story you’d probably get a game about as long as Fallen Order. <strong>Most</strong> of this game’s plot takes place between Koboh and Jedha, the story this time taking a keen focus on a settlement in Koboh where our old pal Greez has set up a saloon. Meanwhile your time spent exploring Koboh will contain encounters with various characters you invite back to the saloon. Over time the place becomes lively with a robot DJ and various characters that act as salespeople to provide you with upgrades or customizations. A similar setup exists on Jedha to a smaller scale, you won’t invite people to the hideout there though. Where Jedi: Fallen Order was about traversing the galaxy to unlock answers across multiple planets, Jedi: Survivor is about setting down roots to try and build up a community. Or, it <strong>should be.</strong> But I’ll get to that complaint later. Much in the vein of Horizon: Forbidden West or Metro: Exodus, a great deal of your time in Jedi: Survivor is going to be spent going back to Pyloon’s Saloon and talking to all the various characters there. Everyone has their favorite. Current fans are debating whether Turgle is the best or Skoova. Turgle is a sort of standing turtle character that’s lost his shell and constantly gets into trouble with others with his various schemes. Skoova is some sort of a squid fisherman type that rests in his lovely diving suit and regales you with stories aplenty of his times traversing the galaxy. You can find him across the game at various ponds and pools and he’ll go fetch a fish to go put into the tank back at the saloon. I always loved finding his little hoverboat in unexpected places as the story progressed because sometimes he’d be on entirely different <em>planets </em>as if he was stowing away on my ship. Yes indeed, Pyloon’s Saloon very much acts like your trips back to the Normandy between missions in Mass Effect games. It’s a great time hearing tales, picking out music for the DJ to play (and I was surprised at how much I liked the music my robot DJ would spin, I’ll have to go get the in-game music officially for my library and spin them myself). I will say this about Koboh though: It’s visually boring a lot of the time. It’s a planet that has a lot of neat <em>destinations</em> on it (a trip to a luchrehulk in the swamps, an ancient array in a basalt forest, a sky satellite), but so much of the main landscape for <em>most </em>gameplay is yellow-tinted dry grasslands that sometimes make you feel like you’re playing a video game that takes place completely on Dantooine when we could be off exploring a Shattered Moon at least half the size of Koboh. Instead that Shattered Moon is maybe a fifth of Koboh in scale. Koboh has its varieties, don’t get me wrong, but even Fallen Order’s Zeffo and Bogano had more fascinating landscapes regularly. Zeffo had stark green and gray mountainous scales at harsh angles, constant vistas with ominous statues, and a lurking Imperial presence in the foggy distance. You just don’t get that in this game much on warm, comfy Koboh.</p><p>Jedi: Survivor isn’t bigger with a core base and lots of characters though. In fact, if we didn’t have the characters and the saloon to regularly visit on Koboh, I’d argue the total map size in Survivor equates to roughly the same as Fallen Order. It’s skewed differently towards two planets this time. But Survivor is bigger through a lot more <strong><em>stuff </em></strong>than before. Here I’ll stop for a minute or three and lodge some nitpicks. Jedi: Fallen Order had eight different lightsabers with various materials to unlock and twenty one different ponchos to wear across a 30 hour game. Jedi: Survivor has nineteen different lightsabers, twenty-four material sets for them, and just as many outfits with different color combinations (for EACH outfit) for a <em>massive variety</em> set here. It’s a little astounding. For a 60 hour game I didn’t find this well ever running dry, which actually kind of bugs me a little. I don’t want this to be a big point later but we’re all (okay, <strong><em>I am</em></strong>) a little tired of games made big by just having too much filler in it, and the collectibles definitely strike that chord a little bit here. I never <em>disliked </em>the collectibles here, I just felt there were too many compared to how much story and game there was. It overshadowed the game. There’s a seed collecting aspect that lets you plant a garden, I’m sure plenty of people liked it in this game but I wasn’t a fan. The seeds are hard to notice in such a visually grounded game, you’d have to be looking at every bush as you play for signs of little fireflies to indicate it’s a plant you can harvest and take with you. The game sees the return of its built-in codex where BD-1 lets you know there’s something he can scan and players can read to learn more about. In addition to that there’s still Cal’s psychometry ability, allowing him to touch things and experience memories through the force left in the object (serving as quick audio logs for the player). Both of these features should’ve been merged into one: Audio logs. We don’t really need flavor text to paint out the details of the Star Wars world. I was often pausing the game every few seconds to read four entries I unlocked in one room. Some were literal story summaries of what I just experienced. We either let Cal talk about the thing he just felt/saw/heard, maybe BD-1 calls attention to it, and then that’s that, or we just let the art speak for itself. The only reason people enjoy reading item descriptions in Souls games is because they’re so geared around combat and exploring and not conversations. So the only ways we absorb world lore is through the art around us and the very quick flavor text (literally three sentences or less), or NPCs telling us about the world. In Souls games, that flavor text is also always <em>optional</em>, it’s not a notification of lore that we’ve just unlocked that shows up every ten seconds as we play, we go find it on our own in the menu if we feel like it.</p><p>It doesn’t end there though, there’s different hair styles to buy and unlock, different perks to buy or find from vendors that can alter your playstyle, chests containing any of these items, and challenges to find and overcome in the form of actual challenges or a tactical holotable game to play (I actually loved the challenges because they’re gameplay all to their own, but I’ll leave my nitpicks on <strong>those </strong>a few minutes down the way). At the end of the day this is just a little too much collecting for a game a little bit smaller than the rest of that stuff. I hit a point where I realized I had progressed enough to basically go everywhere in the game unless the story kept me from it. I was probably 70% done with the game. So I set off on getting every last collectible I could at that point because there were simply too many I wasn’t finding organically anymore. I was amazed at how many I had missed because the world is just a little too big and the side quests a little too scarce to drive me towards those places. The holomap comes out in a quick flash but feels a little too unclear this time around and the game would even list red locked doors as “Open paths” sometimes. What would that mean? Did I have an ability that could solve it? Was the game just wrong? What is the map not telling me? It was making the challenge of finding all these items too daunting. Equally frustrating was that <strong>after </strong>the process of trying to find almost everything, I progressed the story just a smidge further and started finding the terminals for “here, we’re now going to put everything on the map for you”. Just a little too late Respawn, sorry. I feel it would’ve been safe to just provide us with the map scans through some arbitrary reason right after our first trip to the Shattered Moon, which is basically half way through the story. By the time you’re that far in you’ve visited everywhere once aside from the story-locked planets. I feel if we got that item map half way through the game and also scaled back materials to just unlock automatically with each costume and hair styles were just always available, it wouldn’t have been a big deal. Finding all the things was a bit more of a joy in the last game. This time it felt like a little bit of a slog. However, I will say doing this led me to explore more of the world again and find maybe my favorite little zone in the game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3KuDgq0sEWw-xqkvev8oJw.jpeg" /></figure><p>In said zone you work your way down into underground caverns in Koboh, dark foggy places. You keep running across rooms where Mercenaries appear to be in some sort of a prison? There’s energy barriers and they warn me once they get out they’re gonna kill me. Exploring these caverns involves going down holes that feel like the ground gave way (in one case you even make the hole yourself), which makes the descent feel unnatural and out of control. In one room you’re navigating through a field of explosive pods that grow naturally along the cave walls and floor. Then, a trap. You fall in, find what you think is an escape but in fact all of the mercenaries you encountered on your way to this place were using a network of caves here to ambush you, three lightsaber wielders at once. A fight I won’t forget having barely survived it by the skin of my teeth first try.</p><p>It isn’t all bad. Up until I realized the collectibles were outpacing the game, all the various adventures I’d go on were delightful. A surprise return of Ogdo Bogdo with “Spawn of Ogdo” was infuriating and hilarious. I mentioned the challenges earlier and they’re really cool and there’s two different types. One is a traversal challenge where you’ll use various abilities in vague liminal spaces that push your traversal responsiveness to the limit. The other is a combat challenge type where you’ll be pitted against specific combinations of enemies, often in waves, and sometimes even restricted to a specific weapon stance to make the challenge more interesting. Specific highlights for me here involved one against an endlessly spawning wave of B1 battle droids until you killed 100 of them. Another was an absolute troll of a moment where I realized the game was putting me up against both the original Ogdo Bogdo and Spawn of Ogdo. I was infuriated all over again, but I still had to do it for the sake of ending their reign of terror. There was one traversal challenge and two fight challenge nitpicks I had. For the traversal challenge it was “Fractured Momentum”, it has to deal with ziplines where you grab onto BD-1 and slide along ziplines and can switch lines or even zip up to other lines from a grapple point. All cool. But this particular challenge really failed to telegraph what they were trying to teach you because they were trying to teach you three or four things at once. First you’re just jumping ziplines left and right to avoid some static electric obstacles. Then you grapple up to a single zipline and it seems like the rest of your path is facing behind you and upwards. So your natural instinct is to TURN AROUND (a thing you <em>can </em>do). But on this single zipline is an electric ball that <strong>isn’t </strong>static, and shortly after you get on the zipline it zooms straight at you. Only once, and only on your first grab to that line. If you turn around to go the right direction you’ll get hit, you’re too slow on a turn. I couldn’t understand what I was doing wrong because <em>sometimes</em> I would grapple up to the zipline and Cal would be facing the right direction and I’d be able to get to the next grapple point before the electric ball would hit me. But I couldn’t do it <em>consistently enough</em> so I wasn’t sure if I was doing something wrong or if the game was just landing me on this line wrong. Eventually I learned that the key was to get on the zipline, start sliding the wrong direction first, jump OVER the electric ball, then turn around, and go do the same thing again on two ziplines elevated from each other. There was further timing puzzling going on there that drove me utterly mad. I think I spent an hour on that challenge and hated every minute of it. Meanwhile, what drives me crazy about the combat challenges is that there’s no quick respawn. If you fail the traversal challenge you’re just kicked right back to the start of it. If you fail combat challenges you’re forced out back into the game world via a load screen, then to get back in you have to sit through a second load screen. For challenges you can fail in an instant this is really frustrating. Making matters worse, the first combat challenge I came across was one that involved too many enemies while I was still fairly early on in the game. I beat my head against it for probably thirty minutes. There was just no way for me to easily beat the odds with my abilities at the time. In many ways challenges almost encapsulate everything there is to say about Jedi: Survivor. Because it’s really good and fun. Until it isn’t.</p><h4>A Loreless Start (Story — Part 1)</h4><p>By far Jedi: Survivor’s biggest points against it are its own performance issues (saving it for the end) and the “go bigger” AAA aspect that just means a lot of filler collectibes (I like changing my outfit and lightsaber every session, but not everyone will). These are just nitpicks and annoyances in the face of a game where the developers clearly put in a lot of time trying to improve on the first game. So much of Survivor feels like a natural evolution of the great starting point we had in Fallen Order. I think at times they failed on execution here and there but “more of the same” is a safe bet for some people, myself included when it comes to some Star Wars things. However, despite its launch performance issues, the nitpicks, my preferential problems with open world designs, despite <strong>all of that</strong>, what I think is going to make people forget about Survivor in a year’s time is the story.</p><p>Because it tried just a little too hard without putting effort in the most important places. It didn’t know what it wanted completely.<br>It’s spoiler time. First we’re doing early spoilers, bigger spoilers will come later.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hM8b16C9V_E_3siZ010X6w.png" /></figure><p>Jedi: Survivor takes place five years after the first game. Cal has a new crew, almost all of that crew dies after a mission on Coruscant except for a blaster-weilding jetpack dude named Bode. You get separated but you both make it out. Cal learns from the intel gained on Coruscant that the Empire has only gotten much stronger in the ten years since Order 66. All of his efforts have felt fruitless. He and BD-1 make their way to Koboh to get some repairs from Greez. While waiting for Greez to make some repairs to the ship, Cal stumbles upon an old Jedi ruin and a droid named ZN-A4 (Zee for short). Cal finds Zee’s last memory before being wiped involves a High Republic Jedi Santari Khri telling Zee to get to the array on Koboh to unlock the secrets of Tanalorr. At the array Cal taps into a memory where Santari Khri converses with another Jedi, Dagan Gera, they’re on Tanalorr and discuss how the planet is hidden from the galaxy behind a nebula right outside Koboh called “the Koboh Abyss”. Enemies arrive, Dagan Gera stays behind to fight and at the top of the array, Cal realizes he tapped into Dagan Gera’s memories because he’s alive in stasis here. Cal lets Dagan Gera out of stasis but Dagan Gera is all angry about being abandoned by the High Republic Jedi back in the day and thrown into stasis, he bleeds his lightsaber crystal red, turns villain, and attempts to kill Cal. Cal is now on a race against Dagan Gera to get the tools and information needed to fly through the Koboh Abyss and reach Tanalorr, a potential haven for Cal, his friends, and any resistance movement against the Empire. Simple enough.</p><p>That’s the setup. It takes maybe 15 to 20% of your time with the story to get that setup rolling. If it sounds flat, that’s because it unfortunately is. There’s some really cool developments across the game’s middle, the story and setting ultimately working to reward people who were here for the first game’s development. You head to Jedha looking for assistance from Cere, who has built up an underground network of people trying to restore as much Jedi historical data as possible (called the Hidden Path). You have some trouble with the Empire on your way in, and you’re surprised by Merrin! Merrin was one of my favorite characters in the first game and I’m really glad Respawn seemed to like her just as much, they take time to let you see how much Merrin has grown in the past five years, even taking months or years of absence from our team in the first game to try helping out the galaxy on her own. We see the depths of her abilities across the game and just how much more resolved she is in her personal quest to try and bring that justice for others. It’s fantastic. It’s worth mentioning here that in the gameplay whenever you get to play out a finisher in Survivor, the animations always feel excellent, but when you have a buddy with you (Bode or Merrin) they feel extra special as the game will involve the second character in a flurry of awesome animations. I couldn’t get enough of every time Merrin was there and I ran a finisher on an enemy. Her Dathomir magic is just teeming with a unique style that’s a little more cutthroat and dangerous when the weapons come out. She’s definitely one of my favorite expanded Star Wars characters out there. To top it off, when I’d go and explore more of Jedha, I was thrilled because Merrin would join us!</p><p>Merrin and Cal have a little catching up in the desert and it seems to suggest they were romantic during the conquests Cere, Greez, Merrin and Cal went on in the past five years, and that Merrin needed to go off and do her own thing for a while. The longing is there, but there’s an uncertainty if they should try this again. After a night hiding from a storm in Jedha, Merrin takes us to the Hidden Path hideout only to be surprised by Eno Cordova. He’s alive! He works with Cere in the Hidden Path and we have a similar conversation with Cere: She is supportive of Cal’s mission against the Empire, but is honest about her desire to try and rebuild what was lost after Order 66 instead of trying to fight back. The knowledge the Jedi held is just as valuable to her as fighting might be to Cal. With the evidence of Tanalorr as a destination that can be reached, Cere and Eno turn their focus to providing Cal with the information he needs to reach Tanalorr so the Hidden Path can go there and build up their resources away from the Empire. Bode’s in too since he has a daughter named Kata and wants the same thing.</p><p>So where does it fall apart? How does it fall flat?</p><p>The game’s story is too flat while trying to do too much. Jedi: Fallen Order I equated to a lot of previous Star Wars stories all about discovering some sort of historical element and the context of that element in relation to the game itself. Fallen Order took after KotOR in a goose chase to learn more about an old civilization that knew a thing or two about ancient powers and it turned out those ancient powers were maybe related to the downfall of that civilization. It worked well as a way for Cal to get in touch with his powers again and with one cautionary tale of a Jedi that slaughtered the Nightsisters on Dathomir, and with the game’s overarching plot, Cal came to the conclusion that the important mcguffin at the end of Fallen Order (a holocron with the location of force sensitive children across the galaxy) needed to be destroyed. So he destroyed it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VBQqdRfHob0JeJ1mE7Rr2g.png" /></figure><p>If there’s any theming going on in Survivor, it’s this continuation of fallen Jedi being a problem (but not really for any reason) and a theme of escape. The former seems <em>fine </em>but the second is where the story kinda just gets muddled even though it’s got potential. Dagan Gera almost instantly turns dark after being revived, lashing out against Cal as a remaining Jedi, a representation of something he hates but his qualm really isn’t with Cal. Dagan Gera is about 500 years out of his own time. The shock of this reality and what to do next should be a bit more prevalent to him but it barely comes up until near the end of Dagan Gera’s part in the story. He’s incredibly one note, talking about Cal being weak at every confrontation, but not really discussing much regarding Tanalorr other than it being “mine” and (during your final fight with Dagan) how he’ll personally raise a new generation of force users against the Empire since Cal failed to fight them. The story with Dagan severely suffers what most people would call a “just talk” issue, but personally, the story suffers a lack of what Fallen Order had so well: History to sink into. Despite the game being the first to really try and look back to the story of the High Republic (Disney/Lucasfilm’s next big Star Wars interest so they can try and get away from the Skywalker lore and make some new stuff that’s not constantly invalidating someone’s favorite lore points), there’s almost nothing here suggesting anything interesting about Tanalorr or Koboh other than the fact that Tanalorr is hidden behind an abyss that’s impossible to navigate. There’s a particle that infests certain areas of Koboh, sometimes it’s present like a swarm of bugs, and in other areas it’s a weed almost tainting the ground and growing around the landscapes. “Koboh Particles” it’s called. And the history of it never really comes to light. Koboh has a shattered moon, the result of some unfortunate cosmic event the High Republic Jedi did to the galaxy at the height of their explorations. But this also never really gets explored, just that it’s a major screw up they did. I was really expecting Dagan to keep hinting at the possibility of Tanalorr being some untapped power that Cal couldn’t even begin to comprehend. It could’ve been a cautionary tale again that this power is something untrustworthy. It would’ve been interesting to see Cal almost blind to the danger this time around because he’s desperate for a solution. Maybe <em>h</em>e <em>thinks </em>he can control it. The game even hints at this at one point with Cal’s obsession being a concern to himself and others. But that never happened. Dagan, unfortunately, feels incredibly one note. He’s evil mostly for the sake of being betrayed by his friends a long time ago. So he’ll stand in your way even though you both technically want the same thing. And then you’ll kill him 4/5 of the way through the game.</p><p>All the High Republic aesthetics and hints in this game are interesting. Zee is a cool droid who could provide us with lots of details about the High Republic times and more about Santari Khri and Dagan, but outside three story quests, Zee is mostly a shopkeeper and conversation person for us back at the Saloon. She could slowly reveal so much information to us over the course of the game as we try to restore her memories or something, but nope.</p><h4>Unraveling the “Mass Effect 2” Problem (Story — Part 2)</h4><p>Here in the middle chunk of the game’s story I can also talk about how this game is too afraid to be Mass Effect 2 or other games that feature a main hub family dynamic aspect. We have the Saloon with its ever expanding cast of characters that can act as our stand-in for the Normandy in this game. Cool. And you do talk to these characters, mostly hearing stories from them. Jedi: Survivor even gives you the chance to give Cal an opinion when prompted once in a blue moon, sometimes those characters ask Cal to weigh in on the story and you get to choose what he says. It’s nice. But all those characters do is tell stories and act as vendors. That’s it. One character, Caij, will give you bounties to do as quests. You even suggest she should get involved, help you out on those quests. But she says the bounties aren’t high enough for her. Technically finding Skoova in all those locations is a bit of a quest too, more a collectible than a quest. But I think this game could’ve gone one step further and given you the chance to go on quests <em>with</em> these characters. There’s a character named Mosey who acts as your information point on animals you fight in the game. Why not have her join you for the bigger monster hunts that she keeps telling you about? Why not teach her some things about animal taming that you learn in the game? You find a droid in a sort of exploration quest and the droid had been trapped in a cave under a building for something like 20–30 years. Once the droid is back at the main outpost in Koboh, the droid tells you it’s leaving to go help the galaxy elsewhere. A door is unlocked, you get an item and that’s it. Why not recruit the droid for your ship? A pair of scavenger characters keep talking about trying to avoid going for items out on Koboh because of heightened dangers. A local raider crew in the game and the Empire are present in growing numbers. Eventually though the Empire’s kicked out by the raiders and you put an end to the leader of the Raiders. One of those scavengers goes out on his own and dies. The other friend mourns the loss but that’s it. We don’t go get revenge with that friend and have any sort of a ceremony for the loss we’ve experienced. Koboh’s a really large overworld in this game and I feel so much of what could’ve been is robbed by not going out with these characters and doing things.</p><p>What made Mass Effect 2 special was three fold. 1) The premise of Shepard’s resurrection and recruitment by Cerberus allowed us to explore the criminal underside of the Mass Effect galaxy. We’re a crew trying to hire and gear up for a galaxy “heist” (that heist being to go somewhere dangerous and blow some stuff up). We won’t have the backing of the “good guys” this time so we make more interesting friends. 2) Galaxy missions are scaled back to primarily focus on missions recruiting members of your crew and missions helping your crew resolve their life issues before doing the heist that might kill them. And 3) Conversations before, during, and after all these quests tie into the sensation that the story is developing. It’s all about the characters. The big plot of the Reapers takes a back seat here to allow characters to take the front. This way, when you get back to that heist, you’re excited and worried all at once. Will anyone make it out alive? Who knows! It’s noteworthy that Mass Effect 2 also stripped back a lot of the elements present in the first game’s gameplay. RPG elements and various weapon mods and even character build stats were reduced to focus the gameplay, but plot and story elements still had the dynamics that the BioWare series was looking for. The difference there being that Mass Effect 2 was a game filled with character-driven sequences with larger plot moments taking up the defining arc of the game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*J-V5d8Kauc9nDSBWWEss8Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’d like to make the argument that the story about the Koboh Abyss and Tanalorr either should’ve been a central lesson about searching for a power too strong for anyone to wield, or it should’ve been about building up a resistance by putting down roots in a community so you can defend what’s important to you and escape to Tanalorr when it’s time. Let me break it down a little more. I’ve already established Tanalorr is literally all they say it is: A hidden planet. Instead the story <em>could </em>be about building up that resistance by just trying to build a community first. Imagine if you spent major plots points in this game chasing after the secrets of Tanalorr but without Dagan Gera as your antagonist. Like, maybe he’s there, but instead you’re spending more time trying to put down roots, establish a base and try to figure out more about Tanalorr first, taking companions with you as you do so. You don’t know it’s a hidden planet, it’s just something <em>important </em>that Dagan keeps yacking about while not telling you everything. You delve into its past, what the High Republic actually did to the galaxy (and what they were doing on Koboh, specifically). Meanwhile Cal’s building up a community of people with Greez. First Greez just asks Cal to do a couple things in repayment for the needs of Cal’s ship, but the promise of Tanalorr feels just as impossible as fighting the Empire. So Cal takes an interest in it but does the first few odd jobs for Greez before realizing a lot of the people on this planet prefer to avoid Imperial entanglements too. So Cal starts working with these people, they move into the town where Greez’s saloon is, doing jobs with them, and talking to them about the opportunity of Tanalorr. The short terms goals of the community is to build up enough strength to take on Rayvis, the leader of the mercenary group in the game that makes life a pain for the rest of Kobh’s residents. I already regularly found myself going to the saloon in this game, why not swap out a fair chunk of the collectibles for more quests from these characters. You already get a couple here and there, expand it to cover your exploration of Koboh’s more hidden sectors that have collectibles in them. There’s also several story beats throughout the game already where the town or saloon comes under attack but you’re almost never there for it, leading to it feeling like too much action happens off screen. I’d be invested in action happening at my “character-talk-home-space”, especially if we seem to be building teams together. As the promise of Tanalorr gets closer, some larger attacks by the Empire can take place and the town’s ability to handle these challenges can be like in Mass Effect 2’s suicide mission. Or at least <em>feel</em> like that. Stakes feel higher. And then it’s revealed: Tanalorr is a planet hidden beyond that abyss near Koboh. The desire to find out the way to Tanalorr grows and as the planet becomes less safe everyone wants to go. We encounter something similar at the end of the game when a Star Destroyer shows up over Tanalorr, almost everyone you brought to the cantina just wind up leaving for their own reasons in the actual game. It felt kinda hollow there, “Welp, you finished the video game. These side characters will now go on and do their own thing. Coming to Pyloon’s Saloon regularly was a waste of time, you’re not gonna see most of them again.” Building up a team in a more remote and stable place feels like an awesome change of pace for <em>most</em> Star Wars stories and can go hand in hand with the family theming in Cal’s arc.</p><p>But as a point of resistance, well, you’re not really spending time building a team in this game. So how about that other version of the story? Tanalorr having a cool secret mcguffin that can be a weapon against the Empire. The one about power and obsession. Without Dagan Gera’s depth of character, the story still continues to suggest Cal’s pursuit of Tanalorr is reckless. There’s a moment around 60% into the story where Cal realizes Dagan was blinded by his ambition for utilizing Tanalorr and Santari didn’t catch his turn for the worse with this ambition. When she does discover it, he threatens the Jedi so she cuts his arm off and throws him into stasis. Cal fears he’ll wind up like Dagan in his pursuit of a way to hide or fight the Empire. Merrin reassures Cal that she and his friends will be there to pull him back from that place if he ever goes there. This sort of works (especially with a spoiler in part 3), but Tanalorr is flat as can be in terms of things to discuss. It’s just a hidden planet. Cal also doesn’t seem entirely bent on <em>just </em>escaping the Empire. I feel like the game could’ve taken some interesting twists near its end where the crew venture to Tanalorr and fight Dagan there, but Cal becomes too blinded by its powers and then you have to play Merrin and fight him (yourself!) to bring him back. It makes for an interesting boss fight because suddenly you’re playing against a dark version of your own character that you’ve been building up the whole time. The story taps into Cal’s venture towards a quest for power to control things rather than the quest for safety he should be on. Merrin maybe has to wound Cal in an irreversible way, do something that would destroy Tanalorr’s power mcguffin, the relationship splits in a weak place, leaving us on even more unfamiliar tides than where we were at the start of the game. And (BIGGER SPOILER SPOILER!) you can still kind have the whole plot point where the Empire finds the Hidden Path on Jedha and just have Vader kill both Cere and Eno instead of the big betrayal.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MgsLRz0qOa_2A6fF2Ytp2Q.jpeg" /></figure><h4>It’s All About Family (Story — Part 3)</h4><p>In a recent interview Alanah Pearce has with lead writer Danny Homan, you pick up on the fact that most of the inspiration behind Survivor’s story links up less with your stereotypical Star Wars quest story and more an exploration of a group of characters that Cal considers family. Survivor is a parallel relationship exploration between Cal and his self-declared family members in the game with that of our villains. First Cal looks at the relationship between Santari Khri and Dagan Gera, seeing Dagan’s actions as obsessive and a betrayal that he doesn’t understand because she didn’t see it coming. But then after beating Dagan with Bode by his side, they take the compass back to Jedha, Bode seems a little uncomfortable letting the Hidden Path go to Tanalorr with Cal and the crew, and then the next day Bode reveals he’s a double-crosser. First he’s someone who’s been working for the Empire all along as a spy, he shoots Eno dead and runs with the compass for Tanalorr. But then when we chase him down Bode reveals he’s a former Jedi hiding <em>as a spy</em> within the Empire. Bode leaves Cal for dead while the Empire (Vader in the lead) crashes down on the Hidden Path. Cere duels Vader, nearly beats him but still dies in the process. Cal experiences her death through psychometry. Greez has a very stirring talk with Cal and Merrin about how this is <strong>not </strong>Cal’s fault and that this is all on Bode.<strong> </strong>I’ve always liked Greez because he’s this interesting picky character. In Fallen Order he gets us into some royal trouble and tries to really make up for his mistakes, simultaneously he’s really picky about what he eats or how people treat his ship in that game. He’s a reluctant ally to Cere’s crew in that game but you get the sense that he knows he can’t keep playing with one foot out the door in this galaxy anymore. So by the time you meet him in Survivor his concerns are moreso in keeping the family alive and being confident that he still has what it takes at his age. His speech to Cal while Cal’s wrestling with Bode’s betrayal was particularly moving as someone who always felt like he wasn’t quite as committed to the fight.</p><p>The trio tracks down Bode to an Imperial spy base in an asteroid, we learn Bode and his daughter have been staying there as a pawn of the Empire after they killed his wife, waiting for an opportunity to escape. Cal’s cover gets blown, Bode gets away while the Empire there tries to stop Cal, Cal taps into the dark side to escape the horde of troops trying to stop him and almost force chokes the administrator there out of pure wrath. Merrin brings him back to the light. A last minute reveal shows there’s still a way through the abyss. They go to Tanalorr, realize if they kill Bode they’d just be leaving his daughter an orphan like the both of them have previously experienced. They both agree this is pretty messed up and kindly ask Bode for the compass, not looking for a fight. Bode looks for a fight anyways because this <strong>very hard to find planet</strong> that’s the size of a <strong>planet </strong>is still not remote enough unless literally no one else is here but him and his daughter. It’s pretty unreasonable at this point for Bode to rationalize that this is how remote he needs to be to avoid the Empire on the opposite end of an unavigable abyss. So Merrin and Cal fight Bode, Cal taps into the dark side once more to overpower Bode at a point of desperation, kills Bode. They adopt Cal’s daughter (who seems really okay with all this for her very young age, saying her dad wasn’t the same after her mom died). A fire is held to burn the remains of Bode, Cere, and Eno. Cal mourns Cere finally, leaving Cal at the end of the game in a much darker place than before.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AYaWCK0RmpLlzqce0Hr06A.png" /></figure><p>Roll credits.</p><p>The big thematic element the game was <strong>truly </strong>going for this time around was trying to wade further into that family dynamic. At the start of the game, Cal is clearly hurt by his family members that all went their separate ways for a while. Cal lost his other new family at the start of the game so he’s done trying to beat the Empire on a large scale. He instead wants to search for a way to protect what he has in hiding. This lines him up with Bode’s interests and Cal slowly learns about this dynamic between Santari and Dagan, two friends who also trusted each other deeply. Santari didn’t see Dagan’s turn towards the dark coming and has to stop him. Cal experiences the same thing with Bode. Parallels! Across the middle of the game Cal is coming to grips with what Cere, Greez, and Merrin all want, but then those characters also kinda slip into alignment with Cal’s interests too. It all seems to be coming together well, which is why the family unit needs to be betrayed by one they believe to be their own so we can have the big “Dark Cal” scary sequence after Cere dies. The story is exploring Cal’s darker experiences getting the better of him after he tried to get back together with his family. It works, but much like Fallen Order a lot of it suffers from the same problem as before: Characters talking more about their experiences than what they are feeling in any given moment. It’s not <strong>bad. </strong>But the promise and curiosity of Tanalorr and Koboh’s mysteries got me confused about where the game was going. Bode’s betrayal happens late and since Dagan felt like such a major villain for the whole story, it felt weird when I defeated Dagan, went off and spent hours on more gameplay and another hour or so of story only for Bode to finally betray me <strong>then. </strong>He could’ve done it right after we killed Dagan, stolen the compass then, and the attack on the Hidden Path could’ve been a coincidence (or FELT like it until we realized Bode made the call <em>early</em>). Dagan’s one dimensional villainy is instead replaced late in the story by Bode’s two dimensional betrayals.</p><p>There’s some interesting points at play. Bode is someone trying to hide his powers the entire game. He’s a survivor just like Cal and willing to do anything to protect the important people in his life. For a universe of stories mostly about broken familial ties and bad parents, Jedi: Survivor seems interested in a father character that’s doing everything he can to give his daughter a chance at a world away from the Empire. I saw a fairly strong response from parents with regards to Bode’s actions, but a Joel, this one isn’t. He’s literally selling out his friends when he, his daughter, and his friends could all drop off the galaxy map in an instant. In many ways I think a great deal of these issues stem from the story of Dagan and Santari being the story we’re being shown for most of the game’s runtime. Sure we get plenty of scenes with Bode and a lot of dialog from him about their chances, about his daughter, about the fight. But none of it feels like this complex conversation around the insanity of protecting the ones we care about in the age of the Empire. Am I bothered because Bode isn’t given enough time to develop more as a villainous foil to Cal, or because it’s kinda difficult to make a character like him interesting in Star Wars, a fiction that’s often oversimplified the experience of war and a zealous fascist overrule? Probably a little of both.</p><p>I think if we got more time in this game with Cal brooding over his family splitting and the sense that he hasn’t truly reconciled things over that split that the loss of Cere would’ve felt stronger. Even without that I feel like Cal and Bode still don’t get a real conversation about Bode’s actions. Bode’s fear of losing his daughter control him to an impossible end, Cal’s anger over Bode taking from Cal in a way that’s unforgivable when they both want the same thing. The dialog at the very end of the fight is well rounded, Cal telling Bode to not put this on his daughter, Merrin pointing out that both Merrin and Cal know what it’s like to grow up as orphans and that they don’t want this for Kata and it’s wrong to hold this over them. Bode is asking if they’d be able to care for her, keep her safe from the Empire. The theming is all there, but much like Fallen Order I’m waiting for the emotional dialog blow-outs that make human drama like this something we love watching. It’s still fairly stilted despite some really good performances at other points in the game. Here’s to Respawn taking Cal and crew in a more interesting path in the last Jedi game because this one is at least setting up a much closer family than before.</p><h4>Nitpicks and Other Praises</h4><p>Yes. The game launched poorly. And that means I’m sure even now a couple months post launch the game probably still has optimization issues. Personally I didn’t run into too many problems on PS5. The screen tearing was pretty constant but having grown up on GPUs that never could achieve 60 FPS for years this never really bothered me in my 60 hours with the game. The framerate was never <strong>bad </strong>on PS5 for me in performance mode. Respawn definitely has some problems using Unreal Engine 4 here but I never crashed once. The problems I encountered in this game are ones I’d encounter on the best running games on PC too. During the first couple weeks I encountered quite a few bugs though. There was one complete freeze up for 5 seconds loading in the main village in Koboh as the characters and shops seem to get loaded in as you approach it. It kinda scared me for a second. Graphics glitches at the end of a long session when going to modify my lightsaber had strange shader corruption. That happened once or twice. In Koboh I once saw a character moving without walking or animating at all, just hovering. But the bigger creeps for me are the bugs that lie to me. Moves being displayed in my move list that I haven’t even unlocked yet, my souls / XP pickup vanishing in the real world but being visible on the map, the map telling me something is blocked when in actuality it isn’t, etc. It wasn’t a particularly long list of issues after the first couple weeks and if you’re reading this (a review from a non-published critic) hopefully you’re someone who knows not to buy most AAA games at launch. That’s been the rule for a long time at this point, it’s not any different here. There were far worse launches this year, but this wasn’t a good one either.</p><p>If I want to praise the game for a minute, the settings are really good! There’s FOV adjustments they offer you even for a third person game so if you’re used to a more pushed out camera perspective like in Souls games you can have it here. They even ask how far you are from the TV to gauge that. Something tells me God of War: Ragnarok doesn’t offer me this at all. I will say maybe my complaints against the map were more specific to time I’d spend playing on the TV instead of streaming my PS5 to my computer screen where I was closer to see everything.</p><p>Going back to nitpicks about the gameplay though, flight is kinda <strong>awful</strong>. At first it appears to be this mechanic that might play a wider part of the game so you’re first shown the flight controls for this winged animal you grab onto from the legs and the controls just feel <em>bad</em>. It feels laggy and strange and confusing. You can’t really pick up wind so much as you fly over air currents. Then, the game proceeds to never show you those controls again wheras in other games creatures you ride in an open world game have steering controls almost always showing on screen. Then the more you play the game the more you realize the creatures you ride on for flight purposes basically replace ziplines that go down, only you can’t fly back. It’s just for variety. Meanwhile I didn’t get quite enough time to nitpick the combat. I really enjoyed this game’s combat but on the harder difficulty mobs became a pain fairly regularly. There’s just one too many enemies that can shoot with blasters in most larger fights and suddenly my ability to control crowds with the Crossguard stance became impossible because there’s just too much wind up time. Not only did reflecting blaster fire back at more advanced enemies just not work (because they have dodge abilities too), but the melee mobs of enemies don’t operate with any sort of an attack cadence that tries to give you times to respond. The game borrows from Sekiro more than Souls in its combat fundamentals, which means it should be about 1 vs 1 more than crowds. To top it off the game has attack guidance, so you can try to dodge through enemies and try to attack certain enemies in a group while not locked on and Cal kinda automatically still tries to pick out the enemy for you rather than letting his saber just swing in the direction you want. The saber <em>can </em>do that, but you’re more likely to miss if you’re not in a stance for it (double-bladed or crossguard having the range) or sometimes it’d happen “just because”. This “just because” comes from deeper within the game’s systems that want you to fight melee enemies like Sekiro: Parry, attack back, etc. Combine all these problems at once and crowd fights kinda get worse as the game goes on at higher difficulties. The finishers are all pretty awesome though, different for each stance and particularly gruesome despite not having blood and keeping a T rating.</p><p>Let’s talk about bosses! I mentioned earlier how I liked them (even if they were trolling me), but Dagan Gera feels <strong>AMAZING.</strong> Survivor had a particularly tough uphill battle because Second Sister quickly became labelled one of the best Star Wars fights in any video game. A fight you learn and get better at, one you try to perfect while the game amps up the experience towards the end by leaving you little room for failure compared to before. That was memorable and fun. This time, Dagan Gera is this progressively cool fight that taps into more as the players do. So in the start of the game Dagan will use a strong one-blade stance that looks different because you’re fighting someone who’s only got one arm. Immediately different, right? When you fight Dagan a second time he’s modified his lightsaber and switches between a force-holding two blade stance and the double-bladed. Sometimes he’ll use the second blade in a circular throw move where you either parry it to force it back to Dagan’s hands or jump past it and get stuck in this closer circle fight with Dagan with one blade to fight you and the other a constant hovering threat. The double-bladed stance feels normal but most double-bladed enemies in this game have this cool “feint” where they shut off the blade for a time while spinning it past you, tricking you into blocking for a parry when the attack actually comes after. This is some phenomenal programming work that’s recognizing how players get into the cadence of attack patterns and trying to force players out of that comfort zone. I was surprised Respawn managed to do something just as interesting and exciting as the Second Sister fight, but Dagan Gera definitely does that. It’s not easy to build a boss fight you want to just keep learning from and trying to beat the way a Souls games does but Jedi: Survivor certainly has those moments.</p><p>Overall I’d recommend Jedi: Survivor if you’re a big Star Wars fan or, if you want an okay souls-vania, maybe wait till it’s on sale. Honestly Lies of P looks and feels far more on-the-money for these sorts of gameplay experiences without nearly as many issues in the way. But Jedi: Survivor also leans harder on that open world spectrum than Fallen Order so if you want something like this, I’d say go for it. On PC it’s hard to recommend given the litany of issues it had on launch. I definitely feel less hopeful for the third and final installment of this series after playing Survivor because I don’t know what Respawn want to do next: Make it even bigger and abandon most Sekiro-Souls links? Or scale it down, make it more like the first game’s designs? It tried to go too wide for a personal story and didn’t provide enough sustenance for me. I felt a lot more hopeful for the future with Fallen Order, but I can’t act like I didn’t have a blast throughout much of it. Merrin/Cal ship fans will be very pleased as I was too. People looking for some fantastic boss fights will definitely pleased. And at the very least: There is indeed a poncho to unlock again. And a lot of time you can spend just building lightsabers.</p><p>And Skoova.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d32341c46d9e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>