<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Cinemyth on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Cinemyth on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@thecinemyth?source=rss-5c2e829806ae------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 17:00:28 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@thecinemyth/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Judging Manhunter By Its Cover]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/theentertainmentbreakdown/judging-manhunter-by-its-cover-789470d283af?source=rss-5c2e829806ae------2"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/2000/1*DGkX8LcfQkHoVjuV3pqhhA.jpeg" width="2000"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-snippet">Two posters for a film nobody knew how to sell</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/theentertainmentbreakdown/judging-manhunter-by-its-cover-789470d283af?source=rss-5c2e829806ae------2">Continue reading on Entertainment Breakdown »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/theentertainmentbreakdown/judging-manhunter-by-its-cover-789470d283af?source=rss-5c2e829806ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/789470d283af</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pop-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[graphic-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Cinemyth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Nov 2026 07:35:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-06T16:09:41.588Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why High Noon Endures]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@thecinemyth/why-high-noon-endures-41725ac5c51e?source=rss-5c2e829806ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/41725ac5c51e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[classic-films]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Cinemyth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2026 12:01:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-02T04:24:40.465Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S6FDxoQ_SUu4WaMOCFyx_g.png" /><figcaption>Gary Cooper as Will Kane, <em>High Noon</em> (1952). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><blockquote><em>A marshal stands in the street, staring at the townspeople in disgust; among them are his colleagues, friends, and neighbors. He grabs his badge from his chest, holds it between his fingers for a fleeting moment, and, without breaking eye contact, flings the badge into the dirt. Without a word, he climbs aboard his buggy and rides away with his new bride. Why is the marshal’s journey edifying? Why is the bleak ending, while unsettling, not entirely devastating? Is this a story about one man’s courage, a town’s cowardice, the inescapability of violence, or something else entirely?</em></blockquote><p>Produced by Stanley Kramer, directed by Fred Zinnemann, and featuring an incredible screenplay by Carl Foreman, <em>High Noon</em> (1952) is an all-time classic Western film. Today, it is also almost universally understood as a political allegory for the 1950s blacklist and the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) pressure. Many argue that this allegorical reading <em>is</em> the reason for the film’s importance and its enduring popularity.</p><p>High Noon has become so thoroughly associated with political allegory that it’s nearly impossible to separate the film from this reading. However, on its release, <a href="https://quod.lib.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/idx/j/jcms/18261332.0061.506/--revisiting-the-blacklist-western-a-reception-study-of-high?rgn=main&amp;view=fulltex">there was no commentary on its connection to HUAC, the blacklist, or the political subtext</a>. Furthermore, the production team and cast were apparently not thinking about this at the time, either. The behind-the-scenes featurette, “Oscars and Ulcers: <em>The Production History of High Noon” </em>from a recent home media release commented:</p><blockquote>Back in Hollywood, it was business as usual. If anyone in the cast of High Noon noticed they seemed to be reenacting Foreman’s nightmare, abandonment, and persecution, none of them remarked on it.</blockquote><p>So, it seems that the allegorical reading did not appear immediately but emerged in the years following the film’s release and picked up cultural steam during the early 1970s. Perhaps it was <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20130823143806/http://pages.shanti.virginia.edu/Wild_Wild_Cold_War/files/2011/11/John_Wayne_Playboy_Int2.pdf">John Wayne’s Playboy Interview in May 1971</a> that brought this topic to a wider audience:</p><blockquote>Everybody says High Noon is a great picture because Tiomkin wrote some great music for it and because Gary Cooper and Grace Kelly were in it…It’s the most un-American thing I’ve ever seen in my whole life. The last thing in the picture is ole Coop putting the United States marshal’s badge under his foot and stepping on it.</blockquote><p>Wayne slightly misremembers the exact ending — Coop (Gary Cooper playing Will Kane) doesn’t step on the badge — but the symbolic gesture is on point.</p><p>Fred Zinnemann, in 1973, discusses<a href="https://thecinemyth.com/p/high-noon-myth-in-naturalistic-clothing#footnote-2">²</a> “that Howard Hawks has said on various occasions that he made Rio Bravo as a kind of answer to High Noon,” while in a 1974 interview Howard Hawks outlines his main objection<a href="https://thecinemyth.com/p/high-noon-myth-in-naturalistic-clothing#footnote-3">³</a>:</p><blockquote>I made Rio Bravo because I didn’t like High Noon. Neither did Duke. I didn’t think a good town marshal was going to run around town like a chicken with his head cut off asking everyone to help. And who saves him? His Quaker wife. That isn’t my idea of a good Western.</blockquote><p>Wayne’s objection is not rooted in the allegorical interpretation, and Hawks’ dislike for the film is rooted in the narrative and whether it’s a good Western or not. It is also interesting that Wayne and Hawks have different (but similar) objections, and that none of them explicitly involve the allegorical interpretation.</p><p><em>High Noon</em> provoked objections from Hawks, dismissal from Wayne, and later became canonical blacklist allegory — three entirely different readings with almost nothing in common. What quality in the film permits such divergent interpretations? What is <em>High Noon</em> actually about? To answer that, we need to set aside the opinions, critical discourse, and conjecture, and watch the film itself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bDLvIFLwTEPXgOtU4jVsrA.png" /><figcaption>Will Kane and Amy Fowler: Kane can’t leave. Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>We first meet Will Kane at his wedding to Amy Fowler. It’s a typical ceremony in front of a justice of the peace. Immediately afterwards, in a quiet one-on-one moment, Kane says, “I’m going to try, Amy. I’ll do my best,” to which Amy responds, “I will, too.” It’s sincere, but it lacks the confidence you’d expect between newlyweds. In the moment, it’s not fully explained what this line means, but it suggests that Kane and Amy are not exactly on the same page, and there is some real chance that this marriage will require work, and perhaps even luck, to survive and flourish. The film initially suggests that the incompatibility is about lifestyle: Kane as lawman versus Kane as domestic store owner. However, this is a red herring. As we will soon find out, the real fracture is more serious — a fundamental disagreement about values that runs deeper than mere profession.</p><p>Upon hearing the news of recently released outlaw Frank Miller’s imminent arrival on the noon train, all of the wedding guests convince a hesitant Kane to keep to his original honeymoon plan of leaving town for his new life. However, traveling on the dusty road gives Kane some time to think, and he realizes that he can’t leave. Amy doesn’t understand, and Will, in a motif that Foreman uses throughout the screenplay, doesn’t have the time or inclination to explain it to her before they head back to town:</p><blockquote>Amy: I don’t understand any of this.<br>Will: Well, I haven’t got time to tell you.</blockquote><blockquote>Amy: Then don’t go back, Will.<br>Will: I’ve got to. That’s the whole thing.</blockquote><p>Kane and Amy’s potential incompatibility is now revealing itself further. She doesn’t understand why he has to go back, and Kane can’t explain it to her.</p><p>So far, <em>High Noon</em> is comfortable operating within the realm of the classic Western genre tropes. A peaceful town, a vicious gang arriving to unleash chaos and seek their revenge on the man who put them away. The marshal is the conventional Western hero: laconic and duty-bound; an archetypal strong and silent type who acts without explanation.</p><p>Once back in town, Kane and Amy have a confrontation where their relationship ultimately cracks. Kane is steadfast in his belief that he has to stay while Amy won’t back down from her Quaker belief in pacifism, which eventually culminates in Amy’s refusal to stand by her husband: “You’re asking me to wait an hour to find out if I’m going to be a wife or a widow. I say it’s too long to wait. I won’t do it.” Amy pleads with him to leave with her and avoid this conflict, but Kane maintains his steadfast resolve: “I can’t.”</p><p>This marks the first point in the film where Western tropes are subverted, and it is through Kane’s refusal to embrace the mantle of hero:</p><blockquote>I’m not trying to be a hero. If you think I like this, you’re crazy.</blockquote><p>It is also the first hint of motivation for Kane and it goes against type and suggests the fundamental conflict the film will explore. Kane is not returning to be a hero or even to save the town — he’s returning because he must.</p><h3>Kane embodies what I call a Mythic Constant — a character who represents an unchanging principle rather than undergoing transformation. In High Noon, this plays out through his clash with Amy over values, through the town’s abandonment, and through Kane’s temptation to flee.</h3><p>Kane next encounters the justice of the peace, Percy, who is busy packing his things. Percy explains why he thinks the community will be of little help, planting the seeds in the viewer for the townspeople’s later refusals. Kane listens, doesn’t argue, and eventually watches Percy leave.</p><p>Following this is Kane’s interaction with Deputy Marshal Harvey Pell. Harvey is aggrieved that he wasn’t selected to succeed Kane as marshal and tries to use this emergency to his advantage by offering his support on the condition that Kane gets him the permanent marshal’s job. Kane flat out refuses, “Sure, I want you to stick. But I’m not buying it. It’s got to be up to you.”</p><p>Kane then tries to raise a posse in the saloon, but with no luck. When Kane is asked about why Harvey quit, he responds, “That’s between the two of us.”</p><p>After failing at the saloon, Kane heads to Sam’s house. Sam, who was present at the wedding, hides in a backroom while his wife unconvincingly lies to Kane about Sam’s whereabouts. Importantly, Kane <em>knows</em> she’s lying.</p><p>The next stop for Kane is at the church. It starts out promising, with many men willing to help, but eventually, the townsfolk talk themselves out of volunteering for one reason or another. It’s a disappointing turn for both Kane and the audience.</p><p>The final stop is Kane’s idol, mentor, and friend, Martin. Martin also refuses and advises Kane to “get out.” In all of Kane’s interactions with the townsfolk, he’s been quiet and accepting of their decision but with his friend Martin, he asks for help again as directly as possible. He is still rebuffed and this rejection hits Kane hard.</p><p>Looking back at all of these scenes, we can see the themes emerge. Kane asks for help and is constantly rejected. At every turn he’s told that he should leave, that he should “get out.” But that’s exactly the one thing Kane <em>can’t</em> do. Kane can’t leave because it would violate his values and, in <em>High Noon</em>, <strong><em>Kane is a Mythic Constant Character representing the principle of integrity.</em></strong> Kane resists the hero’s role, but cannot abandon fidelity to his integrity. His specific values — honor, duty, community — matter less than the structure they create; Kane simply cannot betray who he is. This manifests itself through temptation that tests whether integrity can endure under constant, systemic pressure. Kane isn’t making a difficult choice — he is revealing that, for him, there is no choice at all.</p><p>Kane’s integrity is also tested in other ways besides the strict refusal help. One I mentioned above is Kane refusing to be blackmailed by Harvey in return for his assistance. Another is the small but noticeable gesture of keeping that interaction with Harvey private. And others, such as Kane refusing the help of a young boy and Kane refusing the help of Jimmy — a one-eyed, broken down man who perhaps drinks too much. To Kane, his integrity is his ultimate value, more important than his marriage and, even, his life.</p><p>Now that we know the underlying value that drives everything that Kane does, we can contemplate what makes the story tick. The obvious answer is time: the ever-present clock that imposes constant pressure within the story. It’s an important part of the structure that makes the film work but what really makes the story work, is not the near real-time narrative but a character. And it’s not Kane’s wife Amy or any of the other characters we’ve already encountered. Surprisingly, it’s a character we don’t meet until over halfway through the first act: Helen Ramirez.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AblQ8KuuxhyMd3qswN39Jg.png" /><figcaption>Katy Jurado as Helen Ramirez. Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>We’re first introduced to Helen Ramirez in a brief scene with Harvey Pell, her current beau. Later, in a follow-up scene, Helen and Harvey are still together, eating in her room:</p><blockquote>Helen: Harvey, don’t you think Kane will be looking for you right now? You’re really sore at him.<br>Harvey: Wouldn’t you be if you were me?<br>Helen: I suppose…if I were you.</blockquote><p>This scene hints at Helen’s function within the story and why she is so important. She functions as a Greek chorus, articulating truths that clarify what others cannot see. Not only can she see and understand everyone’s motives, she names them for the viewer. Although, we’ll see the one exception later.</p><p>Helen’s chorus function is more readily apparent in another scene with Harvey, where she explains clearly how Harvey doesn’t measure up to Kane as a man (and probably never will) as well as setting the stakes for the upcoming showdown:</p><blockquote>Kane will be dead in half an hour.<br>And nobody’s going to do anything about it.<br>And when he dies, this town dies too.</blockquote><p>In another important scene, Kane comes to warn Helen about Miller’s imminent arrival.</p><blockquote>Helen: Kane…If you’re smart, you will get out, too.<br>Kane: I can’t.<br>Helen: I know.</blockquote><p>Here, Helen reveals the truth, confirming Kane’s nature; it’s not that Kane refuses to leave, it’s that he is <em>unable</em> because that would violate his core value of integrity — something he cannot do no matter the amount of pressure. And Helen’s resigned response of, “I know” shows how she understands the motivations of everyone involved in the story. With one exception.</p><p>The one blind spot Helen Ramirez has is with Kane’s bride, Amy. Structurally, this is perhaps the key moment of the film. It’s the moment when Helen becomes both chorus and a catalyst for transformation.</p><h3>“What kind of woman are you?”</h3><p>Helen’s next scene following her breakup with Harvey is with Amy. In that scene, she explains to Amy that Kane is not staying for her sake, and as Amy turns to leave, Helen can’t hold back any longer. She accusingly asks, “What kind of woman are you?” In this scene and Helen’s previous scene with Harvey, Helen acts as chorus and the scenes even have slight mirroring. In Harvey’s scene she explains what will happen to the town and in the scene with Amy, she explains that Kane isn’t staying for her — though, she can’t explain <em>why</em> he is staying either. Helen also questions both Harvey’s and Amy’s roles: Harvey’s manliness despite his broad shoulders and Amy’s loyalty as wife. But there is a difference: Helen understands Harvey perfectly and doesn’t really understand Amy at all. Helen only softens after Amy reveals her trauma: she witnessed her father and brother gunned down despite being in the right. From that incident, she became a Quaker, embracing nonviolence as protection. The scene concludes after this admission, and it appears to the audience that these scenes are true mirrors of each other but the screenplay has a trick up its sleeve. After cutting away to scenes of Harvey and Kane, a quick 30-second coda to Helen and Amy’s scene occurs. It’s become clear to Helen that Amy’s pacifism is a response to her previous trauma, and that she is acting not from a deep-seated character flaw but from a false principle. This is when Helen becomes the catalyst for Amy’s eventual transformation by showing Amy what it means to fully choose Kane:</p><blockquote>Helen: If Kane was my man, I’d never leave him. I’d get a gun. I’d fight<br>Amy: Why don’t you?<br>Helen: He’s not my man. He’s yours.</blockquote><p>It’s also worth noting that Helen doesn’t entirely abandon her chorus function when she becomes catalyst. She continues to articulate truth. But now that articulation is directed at Amy’s transformation rather than purely at the audience’s understanding.</p><p>As the impending showdown begins between Kane and Miller’s gang, Amy sits on the train awaiting her departure. But when she hears the sound of gunfire, she realizes she can no longer abandon Kane; she runs back to town and into Kane’s office. Amy sits at Kane’s desk with her head resting in her hands, on his Last Will and Testament. It’s here that Amy finally grasps what Helen didn’t fully explain: that her pacifism applied to Kane is a false principle — it doesn’t spare the righteous but can lead to their death. This realization enables Amy to overcome her absolute pacifist principle, allowing her to act in Kane’s defense.</p><p>By the end, Kane is alone — isolated by his constancy. For those willing to witness it, Kane functions as pure symbolic force: integrity embodied without compromise allows us to experience that value before intellectual judgment takes hold. In the moment, we don’t debate whether Kane should stay; we feel his constancy as an archetypal truth. That felt experience is part of what makes the journey edifying. Yes, the ending is bleak because Kane loses the <em>entire</em> community; the town that should have shared his values abandons him. But it’s not devastating because Kane wins the one person who matters most. Amy’s transformation shows that integrity, though isolating, can create genuine connection with those willing to understand it. We witness Kane’s constancy, and we see it transform someone else.</p><p>High Noon inspired objections from Hawks (on narrative grounds), dismissal from Wayne (on patriotic grounds), and adoption as political allegory, which eventually became critical orthodoxy. But if <em>High Noon</em>’s power derived solely from its HUAC allegory, the film’s relevance should fade as the historical moment recedes. Instead, it remains as urgent and resonant as ever. This suggests the film’s real strength lies not in political commentary, but in mythic structure that transcends historical moment.</p><p>But a question still remains: What makes <em>High Noon</em> inspire such different readings?</p><p>Once again, we look to the film itself. Zinnemann directs <em>High Noon</em> with an almost documentary style, which, with the addition of the perpetually ticking clock, grounds the movie in a dusty, sweaty realism. This naturalistic sheen obscures the mythic qualities of the story that are operating underneath. It’s this gap between form and content — realism and myth — that leaves a vacuum that invites alternate interpretations.</p><p>Another factor is the film’s refusal to explicitly name its themes or answer the big questions. Foreman’s use of this motif can be found in a variety of scenes:</p><blockquote>Kane: I don’t have time to tell you.<br> — <br>Helen: If you don’t know, I can’t explain it to you.<br> — <br>Kane: I can’t do it [leave].<br>Harvey: Why?<br>Kane: I don’t know.</blockquote><p>This is very mythic but also invites allegorical interpretations.</p><p>In a very real sense, High Noon is a myth in naturalistic clothing: that’s why the film endures. But also why its meaning can be so elusive.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://thecinemyth.com/p/high-noon-myth-in-naturalistic-clothing"><em>https://thecinemyth.com</em></a><em> on Mar 26, 2025.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=41725ac5c51e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Natural Is Gorgeous, Iconic, and Ultimately Hollow]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@thecinemyth/the-natural-is-gorgeous-iconic-and-ultimately-hollow-f5416184f74a?source=rss-5c2e829806ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f5416184f74a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mythology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Cinemyth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Aug 2026 18:21:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-10T18:21:15.703Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The Natural</em> (1984) occupies a peculiar place: neither a big hit nor a total failure, remembered as a classic yet strangely overlooked, an emotional powerhouse that somehow leaves the viewer wanting. While few people consider the film outright bad, critics remain split on whether it’s genuinely good or merely competent. In the battle of 1980s baseball movies, <em>The Natural</em> has long ceded cultural territory to the more deeply entrenched <em>Field of Dreams</em>. Even the film’s fondest memories tend to circle back to Caleb Deschanel’s glowing cinematography or Randy Newman’s soaring score.</p><p>So how does the film end up so much less than the sum of its parts? It isn’t Barry Levinson’s direction, nor the production design, both of which are impeccable. And the story itself is one of the most mythically discussed in popular cinema — variously described as a parable, a fairy tale, or an Arthurian legend. But myth demands coherence. It must deliver the meaning it promises, or else even the brightest spectacle rings hollow.</p><p>And that is <em>The Natural</em>’s central issue: <strong>it reaches for myth but never commits to a coherent mythic structure.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UhdH4G3P2yMotCdaAuKUTw.png" /><figcaption>The Natural (1984): Deschanel’s Golden Hour Cinematography. Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>The film definitely puts its best foot forward with the potent duo of Deschanel and Newman. The opening is almost a montage, with Randy Newman’s Americana-infused melodies enhancing the images of nostalgic golden fields while Roy’s father imparts life lessons. The cinematography, the music, and the direction all lend these opening scenes a warm sense of nostalgia. It’s backstory, yes, but it feels infused with meaning even if it’s not apparent what that meaning is yet. But one thing is for sure: the film is really playing up the feeling of halcyon days past: simpler times, better times.</p><p>Later Roy leaves the farm on his way to a tryout in Chicago. He strikes out The Whammer and attracts the attention of Harriet Bird, a literal woman in black, who talks with Roy alone in the dining car. She questions Roy about myths, asking about Homer and specifically about Arthurian myth:</p><blockquote>It was just like watching Sir Lancelot jousting Sir Turquine. Or was it Maldamor?</blockquote><p>Roy’s response of “I’m not sure” reveals him to be unfamiliar with Arthurian legend and the mythic knowledge the film suggests should matter. Roy expresses his desire to have people say, “There goes Roy Hobbs, the best there ever was,” to which Harriet responds, “Is that all?” It’s easy to miss, but when Harriet grabs Roy’s hand and the lights of the train flicker, it looks like Roy moves in for a kiss. But once the lights come up, the moment is lost, and nothing further comes of it. Was this Roy symbolically being drawn into the darkness by the woman in black? Roy asks Harriet if she’ll come watch him play, to which she responds, “Roy, you are priceless,” almost marveling at his innocence. In this scene, Roy doesn’t understand the myths that Harriet mentions, and all of the subtext of their conversation is completely lost on him. He does seem slightly tempted by her, but later, in Chicago, Roy goes alone to Harriet’s room and is equally bemused. He enters her room full of questions: “How’d you know I was staying here? What’s going on here?” before eventually being shot. It seems odd in the early 20th century for a man to go up to a single woman’s hotel room without knowing how that might look or what the reason for the invitation might be. From this we gather that Roy is a simple man who is naive in the ways of the world.</p><p>After the shooting, we fade in from black sixteen years later at Knights Field in New York City. Pop Fisher is lamenting his partner, referred to only as the Judge. He’s described as a “snake,” and whose arrival he calls “one of the darkest days of my life.” Roy Hobbs emerges out of a dark tunnel carrying nothing but a contract and a case containing his bat, Wonderboy. Soon we learn the stakes: if the Knights win the pennant, Pop Fisher can buy out the Judge. But if they fail, the Judge seizes Pop’s shares and takes full control of the team.</p><p>Narratively, this brings us into the middle of the second act, where the myth the film has been quietly constructing finally comes into focus. The fatherless Roy Hobbs leaves home as a young man to chase a dream of baseball glory. On the way he meets a myth-quoting lady in black who challenges his ambitions, tempts him, and ultimately shoots him. This test and fall ends Hobbs’ dream. Sixteen years later he returns with his hand-carved bat sealed in a case to join a team literally called the Knights, managed by a man named Pop Fisher, and eventually aided by a wise feminine character.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0vZe3bhyPwadhamQLY1hlQ.png" /><figcaption>The Natural (1984): Iris — The Wise Feminine. Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>The Arthurian parallels are unmistakable: the direct Lancelot reference, the quest for glory, the sexual temptation, the failed test, Wonderboy as an Excalibur proxy (even housed in a scabbard-like case), Pop Fisher as a version of the Fisher King, and Iris as a healing woman.</p><p>In the opening scene, Roy’s father even names the core element of the quest:</p><blockquote>You got a gift, Roy. But it’s not enough. You gotta develop yourself. Rely too much on your own gift and you’ll fail.</blockquote><p>But this never happens: <strong>Roy Hobbs cannot complete the myth the film sets up, because the story never allows him to fall, struggle, choose, or change.</strong></p><p>Roy’s internal development is almost nonexistent. The biggest problem is that Roy is written and portrayed by Robert Redford as not just simple and naive but almost unaware of what is really going on around him. He doesn’t understand the myths Harriet mentions, and when he fails his initial test, he is not sure what is happening or why. And even after his return, he doesn’t seem to have processed why he failed. In fact, he falls for Memo, who is a mirror of Harriet — even frequently wearing black. Hobbs acknowledges this later in the movie, recognizing the pattern when he tells her, “You were right, Memo. We have met before.” But he never grapples with what this actually means or what it says about him as a person. The film never shows him struggle with that realization or deal with the consequences.</p><p>Another oddity for the character who should be the protagonist is that he’s almost entirely reactive, rarely initiating any of the events of the film. Instead of being the knight on a quest, he feels more like a pawn: in the Harriet Bird encounter, she chooses him; with the Knights, he just sits on the bench, only getting a chance to play when another player is removed from the game; with Memo, he’s interested but doesn’t pursue her, and later he seems to stay with her simply due to inertia.</p><p>Maybe this passivity is the result of the film being terrified of showing Roy’s moral failure. Moments of sin are minimized or only suggested, framed as misunderstandings, or excused outright. One of the reasons why Roy never transforms is because he never truly falls. Some might argue that Roy’s fall is the shooting itself, but a mythic fall is never something that simply happens to the hero. A true fall emerges from flaw, choice, or blindness. Roy’s shooting reveals nothing about his interior life — it comes across as random and spiritually weightless. A hero cannot heal from a wound he doesn’t understand and never reflects on.</p><p>The script overall has quite a few nice touches and some good lines, with many earlier scenes mirrored later on that expand on the original ideas. For example, Gus the gambler echoes Roy’s father’s words, “You had a great gift, a talent. But it’s not enough.” If we could distill all of the issues in the film down to one scene or set of scenes, it would be when Roy falls ill and is recovering in the hospital. Roy isn’t being cared for in a regular hospital; it’s a maternity hospital, which, symbolically, is the perfect place for a rebirth. This is what the film is setting us up for. Hobbs has been stricken down and can’t play, Pops may lose the team; surely this is the moment where Roy confronts his past, heals his (literal and spiritual) wound, and is truly reborn. But instead, nothing happens.</p><p>Well, not quite nothing. During the scene in the hospital between Iris and Roy there are so many mythic doors that are opened during the conversation and never walked through that it’s actually quite astonishing. Roy starts by admitting that he’s still paying for his old mistakes, but he deflects about the girl on the train by saying he “didn’t even know her,” shutting down this line of questioning. Roy then admits that he liked her, but it seems like his main regret is that he “didn’t see it coming.” Roy now ignores contemplating the nature of his temptation or sin and focuses on not being able to avoid the consequences of his action. This time it’s Iris who lets him off the hook by excusing him: “How could you know she’d hurt you?” Finally Roy asks an important question about not seeing it coming: “Why didn’t I?” <em>This</em> is the question that should be the catalyst for introspection and, perhaps, even a transformation, but Iris again makes an excuse for Roy: “You were so young.” Next Roy laments that he could have broken every record, and Iris explicitly echoes Harriet’s earlier question, “And then?” which is the perfect opportunity for us to see what Hobbs has learned. But he literally repeats the exact same line he told Harriet earlier: “There goes Roy Hobbs, the best there ever was.” Iris then tries to guide Roy and takes the opportunity to explain the rebirth that could take place:</p><blockquote>You know, I believe we have two lives. … The life we learn with and the life we live with after that.</blockquote><p>It’s a great line but one that has not been demonstrated in the film at all. And Roy’s response is classic Roy Hobbs: “How? What do you mean?” He just doesn’t get it. Finally it’s Iris who gives him a higher purpose: “Think of all those young boys you’ve influenced. There are so many of them.” But Roy just changes the subject, “That day in Chicago, why did you stand up?” derailing a potentially important understanding. And again, Roy starts to hit on a deep and important topic:</p><blockquote>I wish Dad could’ve… God, I love baseball.</blockquote><p>But he cuts himself off, changing the subject. This is one of the key scenes in the film, and during this one conversation there were <em>six</em> chances to begin a transformative rebirth, but every time the film gets close to the door, it backs off.</p><p>And his pivot back to baseball right when he is on the verge of something deeper is very telling. It signals the film’s retreat from the Arthurian myth and its turn toward a second, competing myth that has been present all along, a myth that the film ultimately finds more comfortable.</p><p>This second myth is a longing for the uncomplicated moral backbone of early-20th-century America, with baseball serving as its mirror. In this myth, Roy Hobbs is less a person and more a symbol of purity, integrity, decency, and honor. The film’s oddities suddenly make sense when viewed through this lens. It explains why Roy doesn’t have a fall and why he leads a life without self-examination. It explains why Roy’s moral compass seems childish because childish innocence is the point. It explains the lack of tension around his “corruption” because he’s uncorruptible. Finally, it explains why Roy can’t grow, because if he grew, he would stop being the symbol the myth demands.</p><p>This is not a flaw in principle. It’s a perfectly valid approach to storytelling, and many iconic characters thrive in this role, with classic examples being James Bond or, more recently, John Wick. The issue in <em>The Natural </em>is that the film is telling two myths simultaneously and that <strong>these two myths are fundamentally incompatible.</strong> Each of these myths demands the complete opposite from the protagonist. The Arthurian legend demands that Roy fall, confront his wound, and transform into something worthy. The baseball-as-America myth demands that Roy not change so that the myth works. These contradictory demands are inversely opposed and contribute to the mythical incoherence; it’s a film laced with Arthurian symbols but deprived of true meaning. And when these two myths clash, the baseball-as-America myth always triumphs.</p><p>This disconnect originates in the adaptation from novel to film. The film inherited the Arthurian myth from Bernard Malamud’s novel but overlaid it with a baseball-as-American-virtue narrative designed for a happier ending, never reconciling the two. The irony is that Arthurian myth doesn’t demand bleakness — a redemptive, even triumphant ending is entirely compatible with the mythic structure, if the filmmakers had committed to it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*65wLxBmDFrWN8KD2XASq2A.png" /><figcaption>The Natural (1984). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>Nowhere is this disconnect more apparent than in the climactic scene. The imagery is magnificent, the music transcendent, and the emotional swell undeniable. But mythically, what is happening? Roy has been struggling all game because of his injury, and moments before his last at bat, he receives a note informing him that Iris’s son is also his son. And somehow this revelation grants him the power to win the game, save Pop Fisher’s legacy, and banish the Judge. But why? What changes? There’s no conversation, no internal conflict, and no resolution.</p><p>The moment is oddly muted. A policeman (a third party!) delivers a letter that Roy reads silently with a slight reaction. It’s perhaps the least mythic way to deliver the most mythic news. But these aren’t just execution failures; they’re consistent with the film’s refusal to show Roy’s internal reckoning. Any satisfying resolution would require Roy to take responsibility for his past and to make a choice and not just pace up and down the dugout looking around. But every path toward arriving at genuine meaning would force Roy to break the baseball-as-America archetype, and the film simply refuses to let him do it.</p><p>Rewatching the scene also reveals another problem: even if the performance had been flawless, there is simply not enough linear time for this revelation to mean anything. Learning that you have a son cannot be digested in a few seconds or even a few minutes. Bad news can crush a character instantly — it’s why the “I am your father” moment in Empire Strikes Back works. It takes time and struggle for meaning to form, for responsibility to take root, and for a person to change. <em>The Natural</em> tries to deliver a full mythic rebirth in the span of a breath, and the result borders on mythic parody: “I have a son? One-one-thousand, two-one-thousand… home run!” Destruction can be immediate; transformation cannot. Myth knows this. The film does not.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7FtMgbc4UObO4ctBXOnyBA.png" /><figcaption>The Natural (1984): Roy Hobbs. Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>I’ve spent the last several paragraphs dissecting why the ending fails mythically. But the truth is that the scene itself is still great. It’s iconic for a reason. It’s one of the most perfectly crafted combinations of direction, cinematography, and music in 1980s cinema. And that perfectly encapsulates the split in how The Natural is viewed; it’s a film built out of extraordinarily mythic baseball scenes that are strung together with an emotional power the script never fully earns. Its images endure, even as the film proves that meaning can’t be conjured through aesthetics alone.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://thecinemyth.com/p/the-natural-a-failure-of-mythic-coherence"><em>https://thecinemyth.com</em></a><em> on Dec 01, 2025.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f5416184f74a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Manhunter: How the Most Influential Movie of the 1980s Failed]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@thecinemyth/manhunter-the-most-influential-movie-of-the-1980s-that-almost-nobody-remembers-7e6c1271dc25?source=rss-5c2e829806ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7e6c1271dc25</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crime]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Cinemyth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Jul 2026 12:01:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-26T17:31:43.180Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/636/1*r2rXz7GsP4F6BtohMbGnYA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Michael Mann’s <em>Manhunter</em> (1986) is the most influential film of the 1980s. On its face, that is a ridiculous claim: Manhunter isn’t quotable, is rarely referenced, and for the general public is mostly forgotten or even unknown.</p><p>Upon its release in 1986, <em>Manhunter</em> received mixed reviews, and fizzled at the box office, earning only $8.6 million domestic gross. Fans of Thomas Harris’s New York Times bestselling novel, <em>Red Dragon</em>, would seem to be a built-in audience, but they didn’t show up; perhaps word of mouth about the modifications to the story kept those fans away. Or perhaps it was confusion about the title. The production team changed the title from the slightly inscrutable <em>Red Dragon</em> to the more direct and accessible <em>Manhunter. </em>Ironically, it didn’t help.</p><p>However, over the years, <em>Manhunter</em> gained a loyal following on home video and cable TV, and received further attention when the 1991 release of <em>The Silence of the Lambs </em>rocketed Hannibal Lecter into the zeitgeist<em>.</em> With the benefit of hindsight, critics are almost uniformly positive — the film has a 90% critics rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Viewers are also positive, with ratings of 7.2 on IMDB and 77% on Rotten Tomatoes. But the gap between the critics and audience tells a story: <em>Manhunter</em> seems to resonate more with those who think about cinema seriously, but it has never really garnered widespread affection.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*q-zT59Feel8j3iCz.png" /><figcaption><em>Manhunter</em> (1986): composition as dialogue</figcaption></figure><p>So, if <em>Manhunter</em> was a commercial flop and only a mild success in the intervening years, how can it possibly be the most influential film of the 1980s? The simple answer is <em>CSI: Crime Scene Investigation</em>. At its peak, it was the number one show in the world and spawned three spin-offs (<em>CSI: Miami, CSI: NY, CSI: Cyber</em>), a reboot (<em>CSI: Vegas</em>), as well as a cottage industry of similar police procedurals. If you trace the origin of <em>CSI</em> back, you end up at <em>Manhunter</em>. The connection is obvious, as both <em>Manhunter</em> and <em>CSI</em> feature William Petersen in the lead, playing a similar sounding character: Will Graham vs. Gil Grissom. In addition, the characters themselves are extremely similar. Grissom can be seen as a calmer, more detached, and scientific version of Will Graham. In other words, a character more suited to the format of a weekly procedural. If that were the only connection, this could be seen as a coincidence. But the lineage runs deeper than casting alone. The more direct influence is in how <em>Manhunter </em>brings the viewer behind the scenes into the investigation and, most importantly, into the lab. This puts forensics at the heart of the drama, with science and reason shown in opposition to the chaos unleashed by the killer.</p><p>Another core idea that <em>Manhunter</em> dramatizes is the idea of profiling — understanding how serial killers think so that they can be stopped. <em>Manhunter</em> was one of the first films to put profiling at the center of the story. This fascination with serial killer psychology has only deepened in the subsequent decades, spawning Criminal Minds, a franchise that survived two failed spin-offs and is currently in its 20th season on Paramount+.</p><p>A third influence that <em>Manhunter</em> presented was the humanized monster. Specifically, taking a serial killer and presenting them as both genuinely monstrous and deeply tragic. Mann interrupts the investigation at the beginning of the third act to focus on Dollarhyde and his life, and has the audience, for a few moments, actually pulling for the serial killer. While not an entirely new tradition, this was rare for a 1980s studio film and has come to be a common approach and, in the realm of prestige TV, the dominant storytelling mode.</p><h3><em>Some may call it influence, others prescience, but the roots it put down are inescapable.</em></h3><p>In a very real sense, <em>Manhunter</em>, when viewed retroactively, is a victim of its own success. Other shows took what it started and became television juggernauts, running for 15 or 20 years and became part of pop-culture. Ironically, when viewed by a modern audience, all of the new elements that <em>Manhunter</em> introduced appear less revolutionary and more familiar, and perhaps even mundane. And because <em>Manhunter</em> failed to cement a legacy early on, it is penalized for this familiarity instead of being celebrated for its innovation.</p><p>Of course, there is a giant shadow being cast over <em>Manhunter,</em> and it’s almost impossible to write about the film without bringing up Jonathan Demme’s <em>The Silence of the Lambs</em>. For the vast majority of viewers, this is how they first saw Hannibal Lecter (and it’s probably true to this day). Anthony Hopkins delivers a memorable, Oscar-winning, performance that for almost every viewer instantly cemented himself as <strong>the</strong> Hannibal Lecter. If viewers come to Brian Cox’s Lecktor performance (<em>Manhunter</em> changes the name of the character), this earlier portrayal appears as a poor copy of Hopkins’. And Cox’s Lecktor, as well as Mann’s film, have an entirely different tone, which is almost the polar opposite of Demme’s film. <em>The</em> <em>Silence of the Lambs</em> delivers everything an audience wants in a serial killer thriller: gothic feel, dark humor, quotable menace, and catharsis. It’s a masterpiece of conventional satisfaction. <em>Manhunter</em> provides almost none of those moments: it refuses easy pleasures, offers nothing quotable, and keeps applying pressure with no clear catharsis. So any viewer expecting <em>The</em> <em>Silence of the Lambs</em> gets something that feels like an unfinished sketch in comparison.</p><h3>Demme and Hopkins’ Lecter makes you wake up in the night sweating. Mann’s festers — asking you what exactly a monster is while you’re quietly chopping carrots.</h3><p>But The Silence of the Lambs was still five years away. To understand why <em>Manhunter</em> struggled out of the gate, we need to go back to 1986 and look at what audiences were actually watching.</p><p>The top 4 box office films for 1986 are very informative. (My apologies for excluding <em>Aliens, </em>which was #5.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1005/1*koUmM8jOvZXWCWQRuykZ0g.png" /><figcaption>Top 4 Domestic Box Office for 1986 (Calendar grosses). Source: Box Office Mojo</figcaption></figure><p><em>Top Gun</em> leads the pack and embodies the 1980s aesthetic and zeitgeist: a Navy recruitment ad dressed as an MTV music video. But even more interesting, <em>Crocodile Dundee</em>, <em>The Karate Kid Part II</em>, and <em>Back to School</em> are all basically the same story. The fish out of water formula is one of the most reassuring narrative structures in cinema: outsider enters unfamiliar world, struggles, adapts, and eventually triumphs, restoring order. <em>Top Gun</em> even fits this same pattern with Maverick as an outsider. Not only did 1986 audiences want to find comfort in their entertainment, but they wanted a very specific comfort. If these were the films that 1986 audiences embraced, then what were some of the films audiences ignored?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1003/1*wHdQ0noRItdH-uUvxad_Aw.png" /><figcaption>#78–81 Domestic Box Office for 1986 (Calendar grosses). Source: Box Office Mojo</figcaption></figure><p>Skipping <em>Crimes of the Heart</em> — a December release that found its audience the following year — the above list is genuinely shocking. <em>Manhunter</em>, <em>Blue Velvet</em>, and <em>Something Wild,</em> all rated over 90% on Rotten Tomatoes, directed by respected auteurs, regarded today as great films of the decade, all sat in the middle of the pack within $300,000 of each other.</p><p>If that was how the general public was voting with their wallets, what about the critics of the time? They’re supposed to see past popular taste. Is there a reason for their divided response to <em>Manhunter</em>?</p><p>One reason might be <em>Miami Vice</em> fatigue. In 1985–1986, Mann’s (as executive producer) <em>Miami Vice</em> exploded as a top TV show. But even more impressive than the ratings climb was the hype and impact it had on the culture. Don Johnson and Philip Michael Thomas, the show’s two leads, were everywhere, along with their signature looks and fashion. The show was also trendy because of its combination of 1980s MTV aesthetic with neo-noir material (a combination so visually distinctive it earned its own descriptor: neon-noir). This is the exact same combination that Mann uses in <em>Manhunter</em>. In addition, in 1986, the television-to-film hierarchy was real and rigid; some critics would look at a film as suspect merely for emulating the hot stylistic television trend of the moment.</p><p>Besides this, the 1980s also suffered from an actual seriousness problem. This became more apparent as what today we think of as 1980s style evolved. Serious films of the 1970s immersed themselves in accepted forms: grit, decay, shades of gray (colors and morals) but a 1980s aesthetic of saturated colors, sleekness, and synths became coded as superficial emptiness. And this view is not without merit. So many 1980s films <strong>are </strong>style-first with a lack of depth. But Mann was making one of the most morally serious films of the decade in precisely the visual language critics had learned to distrust.</p><p>What specifically were the critics of the time saying? A <a href="https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1986-08-15-ca-3956-story.html">Los Angeles Times review by Sheila Benson</a> is informative:</p><blockquote><em>From the first image, a young family pinpointed by the flashlight beam of a murderous intruder, “Manhunter” works like a chokehold. It’s only later, safely out of its grasp, that you begin to notice that for all its perverse fascination, and save for two superlative performances, “Manhunter” has delivered very little. Like the mirrors that dot it, “Manhunter” is all flat, brilliant, reflective surfaces.</em></blockquote><p>And Benson’s final verdict:</p><blockquote><em>With “Manhunter,” there seems to be some danger that style has overrun content, leaving behind a vast, chic, well-cast wasteland.</em></blockquote><p>So while Benson has a variety of critiques (the score, Petersen’s charisma, alignment with the book), the main criticism is that style and form are given primacy over meaning and depth.</p><p><a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1986/08/15/the-gumshoe-glamor-of-manhunter/79f0d601-4699-48b2-914a-4a9e0860fab8/">Paul Attanasio of The Washington Post watched the same film and came to almost the opposite conclusion</a> :</p><blockquote><em>As written and directed by Michael (“Miami Vice”) Mann from the novel “Red Dragon” (by Thomas Harris), “Manhunter” is a gory and gorgeous cop thriller — you’ll forgive it almost anything, so full is your eye with the beauties of its design and photography, and your ear with its supercool electronic music. For all its faults, it’s one of the most sensually thrilling movies of the year.</em></blockquote><p>Both reviewers see the same visuals. One finds a beautiful design. The other finds a stylish wasteland.</p><p>Even more interesting than Benson’s initial review is a <a href="https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1986-08-24-ca-17494-story.html">subsequent analysis nine days later</a>. Here the author digs deeper into <em>Manhunter</em>, sounds more charitable, demonstrates an understanding of Mann’s work, all without backing down from the initial, overall critique .</p><blockquote><em>What a ferocious movie “Manhunter” is. In the hands of director Michael Mann, it’s a dark locomotive of a film, roaring straight ahead, dragging its audience with it.</em></blockquote><p>This follow-up analysis suggests that even a professional critic required some time to process the film (and felt compelled to express this in a follow-up article).</p><p>While critics seemed to be evenly divided, even the detractors admit that <em>Manhunter</em> is a great-looking film with the core question being: to what end? Is it just style over substance bordering on self-parody, as Benson contends, or is it used in service of something deeper and more meaningful? It’s my contention that in <em>Manhunter,</em> Mann has used 1980s style (that he helped define) in service of his story. Every formal element — color, light, blocking, costume, camera — is carefully chosen and deployed. These elements come to form a masterful cinematic grammar that infuses every frame.</p><p>Let’s take a look at an early scene from Act I.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JpKPQ4sE38qJfJmJadgEYQ.png" /><figcaption>Will Graham and the darkness</figcaption></figure><p>Will Graham is in his hotel room viewing video tape of the deceased families. The television forms a black void taking up fully half the frame. It’s isolating Graham from the audience which is a theme that continues throughout the film. The darkness in the frame is oppressive. Even alone in his hotel there is no escape for Graham as that black void presses into his space, an internal shadow that he refuses to outrun. Graham is usually framed as physically separate from other characters, but even here, alone in his room, he is still separate — staring into the darkness. The isolation isn’t social or situational; it’s metaphysical, representing both Graham’s gift and curse.</p><p>This is just the tip of the iceberg in terms of the cinematic grammar that Mann uses — other scenes use multiple design elements as symbols to indicate psychological state or unspoken relationships.</p><p>However, despite <em>Manhunter </em>being a masterpiece of layered visual grammar, it’s not a perfect film. And the main shortcoming is in the finale. The showdown withholds catharsis — deliberately, I believe — and because of that, Graham’s quick reconciliation with his family is too compressed to provide a satisfying emotional coda. The scene with Graham’s wife, Molly, feels too short and wraps up a bit too conveniently, given the stress the relationship was under for most of the film. And the ending matters because it disproportionately shapes the viewer’s memory of the film; how a film makes you feel in its final moments colors everything that came before.</p><p>But the ending is not the only source of audience resistance. The film is calm but unrelenting, Mann builds tension with almost no release. <em>Manhunter</em> prioritizes conceptual and formal coherence over catharsis or resolution. And the film presents its message subtly, it doesn’t explain itself, but instead plants seeds in the viewer’s mind. Seeds that germinate over time, making <em>Manhunter</em> worthy of repeated viewings and reflection.</p><p>Yes, <em>Manhunter</em> lost the cultural battle of the Lecters. But while we couldn’t take our eyes off Hopkins, it was Mann’s measured vision that quietly seeped into the world we’ve been viewing ever since.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://thecinemyth.com/p/manhunter-part-1-reflections-of-failure"><em>https://thecinemyth.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7e6c1271dc25" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Beautiful Lie: Pretty Woman’s Hidden Archetypes]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@thecinemyth/the-beautiful-lie-pretty-womans-hidden-archetypes-3e45a1dc7496?source=rss-5c2e829806ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3e45a1dc7496</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mythology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Cinemyth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Jul 2026 07:25:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-16T07:25:43.471Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*lV8ChwGDbg5hmZXc.png" /></figure><p><em>Pretty Woman</em> is a 1990s fairy tale where a streetwise prostitute with a heart of gold learns how to be a Lady and is swept off her feet by a wealthy businessman. It presents itself as <em>Pygmalion</em> crossed with a modern-day <em>Cinderella</em> story: she gets the makeover, the shopping spree, and, of course, the kiss at the end. It’s a classic tale, updated with designer fashion and a generous dose of wish fulfillment.</p><p>But what if the story above is just a beautiful lie? <br>An illusion. A smokescreen. <br>What if the glossy sheen of this classic rom-com is pure misdirection? <br>What if beneath the fantasy lies a rich symbolic myth far older than Rodeo Drive?</p><p>At every turn, the film masterfully distracts us from what it’s really doing, even naming <em>Cinderella</em> within the story. And yes, the parallels are there: Vivian suffers humiliation (shopkeepers instead of stepsisters), keeps her dignity, and wins her prince. And, in a case of mythic foreshadowing hiding in plain sight, she even sings along to <em>Prince</em>’s song “ <em>Kiss”</em>.</p><p>As the credits roll against black we hear a voice declare, “No matter what they say, it’s all about money.” The image fades in to an extreme close-up of a magician’s hands performing coin tricks. And really, we should know better than to trust a magician.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v96psYFMThe2UR9tdXTBtQ.png" /><figcaption>“No matter what they say, it’s all about money.”</figcaption></figure><p>The film literally begins with a lie — a kind of audacious <strong>metaphysical irony</strong>. The magician’s patter echoes familiar, easy-to-accept clichés like “money makes the world go ‘round”. Yet the story that follows will quietly prove the opposite: that some things are beyond money, that appearances deceive, and that not everything of value is transactional.</p><p>In its first twenty-five seconds, the film both announces its theme and reveals the <strong>meta-blueprint</strong> for how it will achieve it: through cinematic sleight of hand that hides the truth until its final reveal.</p><p>The camera pans, revealing a crowded party. We meet Philip Stuckey and hear talk of Edward Lewis, his client and friend. Stuckey doesn’t know where Edward is but assumes he’s “probably off in a corner somewhere charming a very pretty lady.” Not so much, actually; Edward is in another room arguing on the phone with his girlfriend, who resents being at his “beck and call.” They break up — efficiently. Moments later he bumps into a former girlfriend who reminds him that he was just as unavailable when they were dating, noting that his secretary was one of her bridesmaids. With calm authority, Edward instructs a colleague to check how the Morse stock opened on the Nikkei.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fA1mnwzdLt-ESrc2Ft94OA.png" /><figcaption>Edward breaking up on the phone, saying goodbye even after being hung up on.</figcaption></figure><p>Night is falling. Edward borrows Stuckey’s car, a <strong>Lotus Esprit</strong>, intending to drive himself back to his hotel. This small decision sets the myth in motion.</p><p>At the start, like many films, we’re dropped right into the middle of the action, with information coming fast. Here’s what we learn about Edward:</p><ul><li>He’s popular, in demand, and a successful businessman who others are eager to be around.</li><li>Edward is still focused on work while attending a large party (even if it does involve business networking).</li><li>Edward seems direct and calm and treats people with respect even when in a position of power or engaging in conflict.</li><li>Edward has had <em>many</em> relationships. We meet two of them in quick succession, while Stuckey casually implies that Edward wouldn’t hesitate to charm another woman even while attached (though we never see evidence of infidelity).</li><li>He treated his breakup more like a business meeting than the end of a romance.</li><li>His in-person conversation with his ex-girlfriend is polite and friendly. Edward slightly hesitates when his penchant for communicating with his girlfriends through his secretary is confirmed but he seems to brush this aside quickly.</li><li>We hear mention of Carter and watch how effortlessly Edward evades the topic. Later we find out that Carter is Edward’s recently deceased father.</li></ul><p>This is solid writing and gives us sharp character insights and plot points without relying on clunky exposition.</p><p>Edward heads out in Stuckey’s car but quickly takes a few wrong turns, eventually ending up on Hollywood Boulevard instead of in Beverly Hills. He finally pulls over, flustered and searching for the right gear (“First is here somewhere”). Vivian and Kit spot the car pulling over and Vivian approaches. Edward, clearly lost, asks for directions. Vivian tells him directions cost five dollars; when he balks, she doubles the price to ten. Since Edward only has a twenty, Vivian offers to show him the way herself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*r6iBBLzYO9C-bbXYCm0jOw.png" /><figcaption>Vivian’s first meeting with Edward, a slight smile as he’s offered directions for $5.</figcaption></figure><p>Edward keeps trying to drive, grinding gears and fumbling with the stick shift. Vivian, impressed by the car, remarks:</p><blockquote><em>Man, this baby must corner like it’s on rails! <br>Doesn’t it blow your mind? This is only four cylinders.</em></blockquote><p>Edward doesn’t quite understand. Vivian goes on to explain that he’s not shifting right because it’s a standard H-pattern, and he replies flatly, “Like I know what that means.” Finally, he gives up and tells her she’s going to drive.</p><p>Vivian takes the wheel and drives off, effortlessly and confidently guiding Edward through the city’s darkened streets toward the Regent Beverly Wilshire Hotel.</p><p>A quiet shift happens during Edward and Vivian’s interaction in the car. In a moment that adds little to the plot, Edward realizes Vivian understands the car better than he does and he cedes control, elevating Vivian from navigator to driver. Before this, we’ve only seen Edward in command: telling his associate to check the Nikkei, forcing Stuckey to loan him the car, even insisting on having the last word in a breakup after his girlfriend has already hung up.</p><p>It’s a small gesture, played with a light touch, and maybe it’s just efficient delegation, but symbolically it’s telling. The man who commands companies and conversations yields to someone he’s only just met; someone the world considers both profane and beneath him. The dynamic reverses and he surrenders the wheel of the Lotus to her. It’s a subtle foreshadowing of the mythic dynamic that fully develops later where Vivian guides Edward and drives the moral arc of the story.</p><p>And then there is the car itself: a <strong>Lotus Esprit</strong>. The Lotus flower has long been associated with enlightenment and rebirth, and Esprit in French means “spirit”, so the name Lotus Esprit quite literally suggests spiritual enlightenment.</p><p>Coincidence? In this case… <em>probably</em>. Ferrari and Porsche reportedly declined to feature their cars in a movie about a prostitute, but there were other options that might have been possible: Aston Martin, Lamborghini, Jaguar, and even American convertibles. Yet, somehow, the producers landed on a car where the symbolism is so on-the-nose that when pointed out it almost feels like parody: a car named <strong>spiritual enlightenment</strong>, driven by man who doesn’t know the way or even how to shift gears.</p><p>What’s next, a close-up of the princess in slippers?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dT7ZtDU8OX95YSw_gyZs6A.png" /><figcaption>Vivian Puts on Edward’s Slippers</figcaption></figure><p>Oh, wait. They <em>actually</em> do that later on.</p><p>Both Stuckey and Edward have the wealth to purchase the trappings of enlightenment, but they lack the direction, skill, and insight to attain it.</p><p>Edward doesn’t even grasp Vivian’s description of how the car should drive. Later, he repeats it to Stuckey — “It corners like it’s on rails” — and Stuckey is equally baffled. It’s played for laughs, and it <em>is</em> funny, but the underlying truth is that neither Stuckey nor Edward (at least yet) understands the language of enlightenment.</p><p>During this examination of two of the opening scenes we’ve glimpsed some of their hidden meanings and symbols. It’s impossible to know whether these touches were intentional or simply “felt right” to the filmmakers, but hopefully it’s convinced you that <em>Pretty Woman</em> might be more than just a glossy rom-com. And if you’ve come this far, maybe you’re willing to come a little further to see what myth it leads us to.</p><p>But what myth <em>does</em> it lead us to? In this case, it’s a modern take on a centuries-old myth: the story of a wounded king, a lady from the water, and the healing of the wasteland.</p><h3>Pretty Woman plays like a modern echo of an Arthurian Legend: Edward Lewis is the Wounded King, Vivian Ward is a Loathly Lady and Lady of the Lake, and hotel manager Barnard “Barney” Thompson, the priestly guardian of the inner sanctuary.</h3><p>Writing this essay, I’m amazed by two things: how these thousand-year-old Arthurian legends, despite their age, still find ways to speak to us, and how director Garry Marshall pulled off the biggest trick of all by weaving those archetypes into a little 1990s romantic comedy without ever letting the seams show.</p><p>In <a href="https://thecinemyth.com/p/pretty-woman-part-2-the-mythic-architecture">Part 2</a> we take a deep dive beneath the surface to discover the <a href="https://thecinemyth.com/p/pretty-woman-part-2-the-mythic-architecture"><strong>Mythic Architecture of Pretty Woman</strong></a>, tracing the evidence through the film scene by scene.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://thecinemyth.com/p/pretty-woman-part-1-the-beautiful"><em>https://thecinemyth.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3e45a1dc7496" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conan the Barbarian: Beyond Will and Steel]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@thecinemyth/conan-the-barbarian-beyond-will-and-steel-6d8c3457d7b5?source=rss-5c2e829806ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6d8c3457d7b5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cinema]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Cinemyth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 May 2026 12:53:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-29T07:51:38.048Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Conan the Barbarian</em> (1982). Arnold Schwarzenegger’s breakout role. The finest film of director John Milius’ career. The greatest sword and sorcery story put on film. And for latchkey children of the 1980s, probably the most inappropriately viewed movie ever.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BRJ0r6NiYtOlHK1N7XxbNQ.png" /><figcaption>“If we didn’t have Arnold [Schwarzenegger], we’d have to build him” — John Milius. Conan the Barbarian (1982). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>Essential to the film’s success are Arnold’s charisma and pure physical presence, Basil Poledouris’ sublime score, plus Ron Cobb’s production design that transports you to the Hyborian age. Looking at the sequel, <em>Conan the Destroyer</em>, released two years later, one thing becomes obvious: all of the above are important factors in the original’s success, but something more is required. <em>Conan the Destroyer,</em> despite having Arnold, the same composer, the same world, and a similar aesthetic (and artists), falls so completely flat that, not only is it a lesser film, but it feels like it’s missing almost everything that made the original film so successful.</p><p><em>Conan the Barbarian</em> is built on the back of pure pulp: the works of Robert E. Howard and the fantasy aesthetic of Frank Frazetta most of all. The film overwhelms the senses and appeals to baser instincts, featuring enough blood, nudity, and violence that Paul Verhoeven would, no doubt, approve. In an era permissive enough that a children’s adventure film could feature a shocking frozen corpse in a freezer and receive a PG rating<a href="https://thecinemyth.com/p/conan-the-barbarian-beyond-will-and-steel#footnote-1">1</a>, <em>Conan the Barbarian</em> was rated X three times before finally receiving its R rating. Frankly, this is not the resume of a serious film.</p><p>If <em>Conan the Barbarian</em> is merely formulaic pulp, then why is the similar <em>Conan the Destroyer</em> such an inferior film? Could it be the sheer force of Poledouris’ score? It’s unlikely: a score can ruin as well as elevate but it can almost never create something from nothing. And how do we account for the ending of the film? It’s a final showdown that lacks the expected physical conflict (although it does provide the requisite gore), the score finishes with an elegy instead of a fanfare — a revenge story without any of the triumph.</p><p>Surely part of the answer lies in the execution. Poledouris’ score, Cobb’s production design, the costume design — each is masterfully executed. But it’s Milius’ coherent vision that pulls them into alignment. The result is a film that, despite being set over ten thousand years in the past, feels like a real world that we are immersed in. Or perhaps a dream of a world that could have been; it’s the ancient made visible to modern eyes. This weight is part of how the film overcomes its pulp origins and announces itself as something serious. The other main factor is that the film treats the story and characters with reverence — there are no jokes in the film to break this earnestness. Any humor arises from character moments: a drunk Conan punching a camel or Valeria pushing a passed-out Conan to the floor in the face of danger. The closest moment to a joke is perhaps Valeria’s “the lions ate him” excuse about why Subotai was not found with them, which is immediately shown to be a lie with Subotai’s near instant appearance. But even this “joke” is diffused by King Osric who immediately laughs at the timing, aiming the humor at the characters in the film and not the audience. The film demands the viewer to take it seriously.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DgsSbi8DBUN4fE_IL908mA.png" /><figcaption><em>Conan the Barbarian</em> (1982). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>Opening with a Nietzsche quote (”That which does not kill us makes us stronger”) is an easy reach for instant profundity. But Milius uses the quote to set the tone and to openly declare the film’s philosophical intentions: questions about strength, will, and endurance.</p><p>Milius wastes no time in driving the point home in the opening scene. Conan’s father explains the myth of Crom:</p><blockquote><em>The secret of steel has always carried with it a mystery. You must learn its riddle, Conan. You must learn its discipline. For no one, no one in this world can you trust. Not men, not women, not beasts. This [Steel] you can trust.</em></blockquote><p>Conan’s father describes steel as an “enigma”, “secret”, “mystery”, and finally “riddle”. In this opening scene, the mystery of steel appears to be a practical, physical consideration.</p><p>The next appearance of the riddle of steel is during Conan and Subotai’s discussion about their gods (on the soundtrack this scene is fittingly referred to as “Theology”). Conan describes what Crom demands of his worshippers:</p><blockquote><em>If I die I have to go before him, and he will ask me, “What is the riddle of steel?” If I don’t know it, he will cast me out of Valhalla and laugh at me.</em></blockquote><p>Conan’s father hinted at the riddle in the prologue and now, in Act I, Conan establishes the stakes for the riddle of steel.</p><p>The third, and final, appearance of the riddle is in Act II, where Thulsa Doom finally provides his answer to the riddle:</p><blockquote><strong><em>THULSA DOOM<br></em></strong><em>Ah. It must have been when I was younger. There was a time, boy, when I searched for steel, when steel meant more to me than gold or jewels.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>CONAN<br></em></strong><em>The riddle…of steel.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>THULSA DOOM<br></em></strong><em>Yes! You know what it is, don’t you boy? Shall I tell you? It’s the least I can do. Steel isn’t strong, boy, flesh is stronger! Look around you. There, on the rocks; a beautiful girl. Come to me, my child…</em></blockquote><p>After Doom coaxes the young girl to jump to her death, he continues:</p><blockquote><em>That is strength, boy! That is power! What is steel compared to the hand that wields it? Look at the strength in your body, the desire in your heart, I gave you this!</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fsP8RDczkKQBZWfcvylQ5g.png" /><figcaption>“What is steel compared to the hand that wields it?” — Thulsa Doom. <em>Conan the Barbarian</em> (1982). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>The three appearances of the philosophical question in each act is economic storytelling at its best: set up the riddle, explain the stakes, and offer an answer. All without actually resolving the deeper meaning — because surely the villain’s answer can’t be the final and correct reading.</p><p>Conan’s father expresses a simple view: steel is the only thing that can be relied on. Its innate strength is far superior to the inconstancy of animals and men. Doom argues flesh is stronger than steel — that will exerted over others is the ultimate power. Conan’s decapitation of Doom is the synthesis, showing that both the father’s and Doom’s philosophies are incomplete. Conan’s father wasn’t saved by his steel and, in the end, his sword broke. And even all of Doom’s acolytes and power couldn’t save him. Conan, through action, answers the riddle of steel: will is stronger than both steel and flesh — <strong>it</strong> is the ultimate power. At least, that’s the most common reading of Milius’ riddle.</p><p>But is the difference between Doom’s philosophy and Conan’s really all that different? Conan’s final act could be read as confirming Doom’s philosophy rather than refuting it. Conan does exactly what Doom describes: steel wielded by flesh and directed through pure will as the true source of power. Both ultimately resolve to will as the primary force — Doom’s will over others, Conan’s will over himself. Do we accept Conan’s version of the riddle simply because he is the hero? Or is there something genuinely different operating underneath — something the will reading doesn’t fully account for?</p><p>In the end, Conan achieves his revenge and returns the wayward daughter of King Osric to her home. It seems, as the Nietzsche quote promised, that his strength and will triumph over all obstacles. But is that even true? Let’s rewind the story and see how it plays out. Conan, desperate for revenge, abandons Subotai and Valeria, his friend and lover respectively. He then meets a “powerful wizard” who he also leaves behind, assigning him the menial tasks of oiling his sword and feeding his horse while he’s gone. Conan poses as a priest and attempts to infiltrate Doom’s Mountain of Power. He is exposed as an “infidel”, beaten mercilessly by Doom’s henchmen, and instructed to contemplate the riddle of steel while crucified to the Tree of Woe. Conan’s will — forged on the wheel of pain, tested in the pit, directed entirely toward revenge, fails completely. He doesn’t just stumble or get captured. He dies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Zel528zu9_MJrZjwOtkfrA.png" /><figcaption>“Crucify him” — Thulsa Doom. <em>Conan the Barbarian</em> (1982). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>As Conan fights off scavenger birds on the Tree of Woe, a figure appears in the distance, perhaps an apparition, eventually revealed to be Subotai. However, Subotai arrives too late and can only rescue Conan from the indignity of the vultures. Valeria then chooses to make a fateful bargain:</p><blockquote><strong><em>VALERIA<br></em></strong><em>Do the gods owe you any favors?</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>WIZARD<br></em></strong><em>There are dangers…but I see you care little for those. The spirits of this place extract a heavy toll.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>VALERIA<br></em></strong><em>Then I will pay them.</em></blockquote><p>The spirits come at night and try to take Conan but Valeria fights them off. It’s not until first light that Conan is finally resurrected.</p><p>Conan could not have completed his revenge without the help of Subotai and Valeria. They save Conan from the Tree of Woe and even bring him back from the dead. They aid him in rescuing the princess and defeating Doom’s forces. For all of Conan’s strength and resolve, his will was not enough. The only thing that carries him to his revenge is the devotion of his friends — Subotai pulling him from the tree, Valeria paying with her life to pull him back from death itself. Will is necessary but not sufficient. The missing piece is devotion.</p><p>But isn’t this just semantics? Will. Devotion. What’s the difference?</p><p>There is a difference, and the distinction is important. Will is directed inward. It’s self contained and belongs to the individual. It’s inner strength. Devotion, on the other hand, is directed outward; towards something beyond the self, something worth acting in service of.</p><p>Thulsa Doom represents corrupted devotion. He demands it from others. Parasitic and extractive, it is a total inversion of the genuine article. This is the entire basis of his cult, but it’s most visible in the riddle of steel scene where he asks the girl to jump to her death. A Cult of Set symbol, a snake devouring itself, is made literal through its cannibalistic practices; Doom feeds off his acolytes’ devotion and, literally, on their flesh. In the end, we see how fragile this kind of devotion is — as soon as Doom is beheaded, the crowd simply disperses.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zc51hs96Cy_pZsBBf2XVfg.png" /><figcaption>Parasitic devotion set in stone. <em>Conan the Barbarian</em> (1982). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>Conan’s desire for revenge is fueled by a devotion to the memory of his parents and his people. It’s a devotion to the ghosts of the past. It makes no demands of others and only expresses itself in his quest to find those responsible. From the outside, revenge appears as pure will, but the motive force is driven by a thirst for justice. Ironically, after Conan is released from slavery, his quest for revenge enslaves him again, pushing Subotai and Valeria away, almost costing him his life and forcing Valeria to trade her life for his.</p><p>Subotai’s devotion is that of friend and companion. Unlike Doom’s form of devotion, it is freely given between equals. One of the most memorable scenes in the film has Subotai asked why he weeps at Valeria’s funeral pyre. His answer: “He is Conan, Cimmerian. He won’t cry, so I cry for him.” Subotai supports Conan while maintaining his own identity. Like much of the film, Subotai’s devotion is never directly explained; perhaps it arises from Conan saving his life or because they both share a common desire for freedom — when we meet Subotai, he is chained, awaiting death similar to how Conan was chained for decades. Subotai risks his life for Conan, suffering an injury in the final battle, and, in the end, saves the princess from Doom’s snake-arrow.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Vb7AOE9cisAUlY4pr7UGqA.png" /><figcaption>Subotai weeps. <em>Conan the Barbarian</em> (1982). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>Valeria is thematically the most important character in the film. She embodies the highest form of devotion — transcendent devotion that is freely given. It’s a devotion so powerful and so complete that death itself cannot contain it. Valeria pledges her life in order to resurrect Conan, and upon his resurrection, she announces:</p><blockquote><em>All the gods, they cannot sever us. If I were dead and you were still fighting for life, I’d come back from the darkness. Back from the pit of hell to fight at your side.</em></blockquote><p>At the moment of Conan’s resurrection, it sounds like a confession of love. It uses the same archaic, theatrical language the film has embraced from the very beginning, obscuring that it’s actually a solemn vow — a vow filled with such deep devotion that Valeria is literally able to return from the darkness to honor it.</p><p>In their relationship, Valeria asks nothing from Conan except for warmth. The first time she mentions warmth is when she pleads with Conan to stay with her and forget about Thulsa Doom. However, Conan leaves her to seek the Mountain of Power alone. The second time she mentions warmth is as she dies in Conan’s arms, “I’m so cold! So cold. Keep me warm.” Conan fails to keep her warm on both occasions, but her constancy was not swayed; she seeks Conan out and gives Conan the ultimate gift at the ultimate cost. Her devotion grants her transcendence. As Conan lies on the ground, with Rexor above him, about to deliver a decisive blow, Valeria, dressed as a glowing Valkyrie, keeps her vow, returning to block Rexor’s strike and temporarily blind him, saving Conan’s life for a second time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ArpYHBQ40XZQxH--ZOicwA.png" /><figcaption>Valeria’s vow: “All the gods, they cannot sever us”. <em>Conan the Barbarian</em> (1982). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>Thulsa Doom, Conan, Subotai, and Valeria represent an escalating hierarchy of devotion. Doom’s parasitic devotion is fundamentally evil, marking him as the villain. Conan’s devotion to the dead is a strong motivator, driving the story, but is shown to be ultimately insufficient. Subotai’s devotion is steadfast and unglamorous, the first true human connection we see. Finally, there’s Valeria’s spiritual and transcendent devotion — a connection that not even death can sever.</p><p>But there is an asymmetry in the devotion that Conan inspires; Subotai, Valeria, and even the wizard are all devoted to Conan, but Conan does not reciprocate that devotion. This prompts a question: why are the other characters so devoted to Conan? Milius’ answer is that the prerequisite for devotion is discipline and mastery of the self. Only after the will has been strengthened can it inspire devotion. Furthermore, Conan doesn’t need to reciprocate the devotion given to him. The simple act of being worthy of devotion is a gift that Conan gives but also receives. It’s a gift not because it demands anything of others but because it allows Subotai and Valeria to become more than they were — from thieves to heroes. By weeping Conan’s tears, Subotai becomes more human, more whole. By being someone worth dying for, Conan gives Valeria the opportunity to transcend death. This is the exact inverse of Doom. Doom’s followers jump off cliffs and dissolve into nothing. Valeria dies and becomes a Valkyrie. The same act — dying in service of another — produces opposite outcomes depending on the worthiness of the object of devotion.</p><h3>Devotion to something worthy enlarges you. Devotion to something unworthy consumes you.</h3><p>But what about the riddle of steel? Conan’s father put his trust in steel. But steel isn’t the answer. Doom was right to a point: steel is nothing without the hand that wields it. But flesh isn’t the answer. Strength of will is necessary. But pure will isn’t the answer. Devotion is the missing piece to the puzzle. But devotion is also not the answer. <strong><em>The answer to the riddle of steel is that true strength comes from endurance, will, and self-mastery bolstered by a circle of devotion that makes everyone stronger.</em></strong></p><p><em>Conan the Barbarian</em> was the perfect vehicle for John Milius. The Hyborian age, a world set thousands of years before recorded history, gave Milius a canvas free from modern politics, mores, and other distractions. Stripped of those constraints, his philosophic vision could be expressed in its purest and most uncompromising form.</p><p>Milius famously remarked that if they didn’t cast Arnold Schwarzenegger as Conan, “we’d have to build him.” Schwarzenegger’s physical presence is so overwhelming that the audience instinctively accepts Conan as the ultimate self-sufficient hero even as the film systematically dismantles that assumption under cover of swordplay and sorcery. Similar films are remembered only as empty fun or pure nostalgia but <em>Conan the Barbarian</em> endures because of solemn truth buried beneath the thundering score, giant snakes, and lakes of blood.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://thecinemyth.com/p/conan-the-barbarian-beyond-will-and-steel"><em>https://thecinemyth.com</em></a><em> on May 19, 2026.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6d8c3457d7b5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[GoldenEye: Prisoner of Fashion]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@thecinemyth/goldeneye-prisoner-of-fashion-f6129c37ba87?source=rss-5c2e829806ae------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f6129c37ba87</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-criticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[television]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Cinemyth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Dec 2025 14:07:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-04T03:48:48.507Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LefLQzTq_yeq0D-DcZBW5Q.png" /><figcaption>Pierce Brosnan as James Bond (GoldenEye), Patrick McGoohan as Number Six (<em>The Prisoner</em>). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p><em>GoldenEye</em> (1995) is the best Bond film in the franchise’s history.</p><p>At least that’s how this essay may have started in a slightly different timeline — with apologies for the clickbait opening.</p><p><em>GoldenEye</em> marks Pierce Brosnan’s long-delayed introduction as James Bond. It is undoubtedly his best Bond film and is widely regarded as one of the stronger entries in the series, currently sitting at number ten on <a href="https://editorial.rottentomatoes.com/guide/james-bond-movies/">Rotten Tomatoes’ ranking of Bond films</a>.</p><p>None of this should be surprising since <em>GoldenEye</em> has so many things working in its favor.</p><p>From the stars to the recognizable character actors, the cast delivers. Brosnan reinvigorates the franchise with the look, bearing, charm, and physicality demanded of the role. Sean Bean brings a personal gravitas to the antagonist, Famke Janssen is just delightfully unhinged, Judi Dench’s M provides Bond with an internal obstacle he has to navigate, and “Bond girl” Izabella Scorupco is one of the most unique in the canon.</p><p>The action set pieces are iconic and visceral: the opening dam jump, the tank chase, and the final showdown all linger in the memory.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kR0Mw8L8rcPq-oYXq5Lsnw.png" /><figcaption>The Tank Chase (<em>GoldenEye</em>). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>Most importantly, the script is one of the strongest in the entire series, particularly given everything it is asked to accomplish. After a six-year absence, <em>GoldenEye</em> has to bring Bond into the 1990s and integrate him into a world that reflects changing allegiances brought on by the collapse of the Iron Curtain. It succeeds through smart writing that combines Cold War symbolism and strong characters. General Ourumov and arms dealer Janus keep the Cold War mythology intact while acknowledging its disintegration; this is Bond proving that he is still relevant in this transitional world.</p><p>The screenplay also finds a way to incorporate the franchise’s camp without spilling over into the entire film. The campy excesses are isolated almost entirely within the wonderfully cartoonish Xenia character. It’s a brilliant decision that allows the film to indulge in the over-the-top fun while keeping the rest of the movie grounded and credible.</p><p>And there is Natalya Simonova, who may be the most fully realized character in the series. She is never objectified, consistently challenges Bond, and possesses genuine agency. Her relationship with Bond is not that of seductress or prey but is instead something reciprocal, meaningful, and earned.</p><p>And because the casting and screenplay’s sophisticated reinvention are done so well, the film’s one failure matters. And that failure is the score.</p><p>Éric Serra’s industrial euro-thriller score has been polarizing since the film’s release, and as an admirer of film music, it pains me to identify this as <em>GoldenEye’s</em> one crucial flaw.</p><p>This isn’t a direct commentary on the music as music but is indicative that, on the whole, Serra’s music is ill-suited to the needs of the film.</p><p>The score begins with promise, with the opening cues over the infiltration of the weapon’s plant working extremely well. Starting with delicate percussion, heavier synth, and echoes of the Bond theme played on timpani. Multiple layers of synth and percussion move in and out while some bluesy synth sounds make an appearance from time to time. The rhythmic mechanical sound reflects the operational precision of the mission while providing an underlying and escalating tension. This works very well.</p><p>As Bond makes his escape, we get forceful percussion with fragments of the Bond theme played on different synths and registers, some of them suggesting the brassy Bond sound but again augmented for synth. As the scene progresses and Bond’s predicament worsens, the intensity doesn’t increase, with the exception of the addition of a Russian-sounding male chorus. 007 pulls the plane out of a dive and flies by the exploding weapons factory as Bono and The Edge’s retro-sounding <em>GoldenEye</em> song starts, and, notably, the emotional intensity immediately increases.</p><p>The next musical cue is “Ladies First,” where Bond and Xenia push their cars to the limit (and beyond!) on winding roads while engaging in a flirtatious game of cat and mouse. The scene demands playful danger and seductive energy, but what Serra delivers here can best be described as a very 1990s combination of DJ scratching, jazzy hip hop, and avant-garde pop. Even defenders of Serra’s score are hard-pressed to put a positive spin on this cue.</p><p>The very next scene is the (obligatory?) casino sequence — a moment that functions as a deliberate mirror of Bond’s introduction in <em>Dr. No</em>. In <em>Dr. No</em>, Bond is the dealer and rises from the table first, while in <em>GoldenEye</em>, Xenia deals the cards while deciding to leave the table ahead of Bond. Even the camera work is similar, following the woman until Bond eventually rejoins the frame.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Cn_X9zwBSh761bM4xCWDbQ.png" /><figcaption>Bond and Xenia’s verbal sparring (<em>GoldenEye</em>). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>This mirroring of the scenes is extended to the music, but the reversal removes what made the original scene effective. In <em>Dr. No</em>, the casino scene plays entirely without score until Bond delivers the now famous line, “Bond. James Bond.” The music comes in at just the right moment to emphasize Connery’s swagger and confidence. In <em>GoldenEye</em>, Éric Serra’s romantic theme begins even as Bond drives up to the casino and continues through the scene itself.</p><p>The romantic theme might seem to be a bit too much given that there hasn’t been any romance shown (or even hinted at), but my objection is not about the music per se but that its very presence undermines the scene’s purpose. The scene is built around sexual tension, witty dialogue, and verbal sparring. All of which are enhanced by the relative silence, the rhythm of the dialogue, and the murmur of the crowd. A side-by-side comparison demonstrates how <em>Dr. No</em>’s less-is-more approach can make for a better scene. <em>GoldenEye</em>, however, instead opts for a denser, more modern scoring approach. Whether this was a directorial choice, a producer’s input, or Serra’s instinct, the result is what matters — and what’s on screen undermines what the scene requires.</p><p>There’s one more category of music that reappears throughout the film: action music. In most instances, Serra falls back to variations of the style he used in the opening scene but with more obvious Bond stylizations layered on. These cues are not bad, but they lack the energy and excitement that a more direct orchestral approach would provide. And we don’t have to guess about this because the tank chase provides all of the evidence. The tank chase is the big set piece of the film and probably its most memorable moment. Sure, the image of a tank destroying St. Petersburg leaves an impression, but the bigger impact hits from the replacement cue written by John Altman. This is the moment where <em>GoldenEye</em> truly comes alive and proves how good it can be. The traditional Bond scoring elements are there — the brass, the strings, and the vocabulary — but Serra-influenced percussion and pounding low piano are still included, showing how well a hybrid approach could have worked throughout.</p><p>At the end of the 1980s, it appeared that the Bond franchise may have run its course. Competition from 1980s action movies and the emergence of other action stars had cut into Bond’s cultural cachet as well as box office; 1987’s <em>The Living Daylights</em> and 1989’s <em>Licence to Kill</em> are, to this day, the lowest-grossing Bond films after adjusting for inflation. Production was delayed due to lawsuits involving the sale of rights, contributing to the six-year delay between Bond films. In the meantime, the global political landscape underwent massive changes: the fall of the Berlin Wall followed by German reunification and the collapse of the Soviet Union and the subsequent end of the Cold War.</p><p>With this context, it’s easy to imagine what happened. The series of lower box office results made it obvious that whatever the Bond series was doing wasn’t working and that a reinvention was necessary. This started with an entirely new actor to play Bond, but the theme of change reflecting this new era informs the entire script: the new M being a woman — an obstacle character that even names Bond as a “dinosaur,” a villain named Janus, the god of thresholds and transitions, and a Russia that is internally out of control.</p><p>Although the job of scoring <em>GoldenEye </em>was <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20061017192928/http://www.filmscoremonthly.com/features/barry.asp">originally offered to John Barry (who declined)</a>, it was clear that the production team wanted a new direction. And what was the hot, modern sound of the early to mid-1990s? It was Éric Serra, the composer of choice of Luc Besson.</p><p>Serra in 1995 was not a new commodity — he had been scoring films since the early 1980s — and, with one exception, Luc Besson directed all of those films. Although not commonly recognized, this is arguably one of the longest and most successful director/composer pairings in cinema history.</p><p>No doubt the main scores that brought Serra to the producers’ attention were <em>La Femme Nikita </em>(1990) and <em>Léon: The Professional</em> (1994), Besson’s English-language debut. Both films are stylish thrillers with assassins, and Serra received nominations for Best Music Césars (France’s equivalent of the Oscar) in both of them. Both films also showcase a European flair and modern musical style that seems like a perfect fit for what the producers might hope to replicate in <em>GoldenEye</em>.</p><p>The titular characters in <em>Nikita</em> and <em>Léon </em>are both broken people. The former, a drug-addled murderer with anger issues, is repurposed as a cold-blooded government assassin, while the latter is a simple, naive man who, despite being a violent killer, possesses a childlike innocence. Both scores tend to have two broad approaches: cold percussion and synths for the thriller scenes and tragic strings underscoring the emotional moments. It’s a cold soundscape, with even the strings not revealing excessive warmth. It works perfectly, reflecting the isolation and tragic story of the characters while enhancing the on-screen action and tension. Overall, it’s a fairly straightforward approach, with the music generally reflecting what’s on screen; the main variation is to dial back the tension in order to emphasize the tragedy (e.g., less percussion and more strings).</p><p>The mismatch here is that Brosnan’s Bond is not cold; yes, he’s calculating and composed, but he’s also witty and passionate. Serra’s score never addresses or enhances these aspects of the character. The deeper limitation, however, is systemic: Serra’s default mode is to address what is directly on the screen rather than performing the more important functions in a Bond film — serving the characters, enhancing subtext, and supporting the overall themes.</p><p>Take, for example, the beginning of the final showdown. Bond and Natalya escape out of the lair and back outside to the satellite dish. As Bond runs off to disable the transmitter, Serra contributes a short synth pad before fading out. The next scene of Alec and Boris dealing with the aftermath of the earlier explosion plays completely unscored. As a thought experiment, let’s examine what this scene becomes when we introduce part of the Bond theme.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fpen1xPbz158%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dpen1xPbz158&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fpen1xPbz158%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/40cf259f0c95420f660c93763c4dc69c/href">https://medium.com/media/40cf259f0c95420f660c93763c4dc69c/href</a></iframe><p>This version instantly builds excitement and also signals to the audience that Bond is coming, he’s reasserting control, and that order is about to be restored. After cutting to the control center, the music continues, adding Bond’s presence and reframing the entire moment into a personal confrontation rather than general chaos; Alec’s mounting dread is no longer about the fire and failing satellite — it’s now about Bond. This is mythic alignment, where the music provides pure emotion while communicating more than the visuals alone ever could.</p><p>All of this isn’t to simply criticize Serra — sometimes the score works. For example, the style is ideal for moments of isolation and defeat. After escaping Alec, alone on the beach with Natalya, when Bond is at his nadir, Serra’s score perfectly captures the character’s internal fracture. The love theme here is tender, wistful, full of heartache and regret, and perfectly matched to the scene. However, Bond as a character also needs the score to demonstrate resilience, humor, romance, and power — something Serra fails to do consistently.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nZGgK2c6CUKr_laIHVPl2g.png" /><figcaption>Bond’s Nadir (<em>GoldenEye</em>). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>The story of <em>GoldenEye</em> isn’t unique. Nearly thirty years earlier, another artist creating a classic spy story made a strikingly similar choice: prioritize fashionable aesthetics over what their material actually required. That artist was Patrick McGoohan, and his project was <em>The Prisoner</em> (1967).</p><p>McGoohan’s <em>The Prisoner </em>is a cult classic that initially presents itself as a 1960s spy thriller — perhaps a continuation of <em>Danger Man</em>.<em> </em>But as the series plays out, it reveals itself to also be a Kafkaesque philosophical inquiry into the relationship between the individual and society. The beauty is that it can be enjoyed on multiple levels: pure spy thriller or allegorical commentary. It may sound hyperbolic, but television had never seen anything quite like <em>The Prisoner.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aVQlSZ_fbNO1NuME3cEwfQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Patrick McGoohan as Number Six (<em>The Prisoner</em>). Screenshot by author.</figcaption></figure><p>The typical tone of <em>The Prisoner </em>involves light surrealism, a dose of paranoia, and (bureaucratic, social, and individual) pressure, all in service of breaking Number Six. The show is deadly serious even when invoking strange mind control or other sci-fi psychological oddities. However, the final episode, Fall Out, abandons this entirely and switches to a very 1960s surrealistic and psychedelic style. It’s beyond escalation; it’s a full seismic tonal shift: Beatles songs, a mod character spouting 1960s slang and chanting “Dem Bones,” and a trial that is more farce than mythic confrontation (among other chaos). To be honest, it’s hard to give the anarchy visible on screen justice using the written word.</p><p>This sudden tonal shift is not necessarily a bad thing. The pertinent question is, does it serve the underlying themes and the intended message of the show? And, yes, <em>The Prisoner</em> has some important ideas to convey: the nature of freedom and the nature of the prison — a person, place, or state of mind? The reveal of Number Six as Number One is a bold and subversive idea. The cavern as the location for most of the episode can work as a symbol of the descent into the underworld (of the self). A trial with a chorus could be an interesting exploration of the individual versus the group. These aren’t problems. And the problem isn’t that the show has dated itself to the 1960s, either. The root problem is that the execution and tone of Fall Out are so at odds with the rest of the series that the ideas in the show are overwhelmed. The style and form are so distracting that the substance is lost; instead of processing the message, the audience is processing the form.</p><p>To me, it appears that when Patrick McGoohan was writing the finale, he wanted to incorporate the ideas of revolt and rebellion. On a deadline, he reached for the current representation of those ideas: 1960s counterculture and its dominant aesthetic of surrealism and psychedelia. On some level, this makes perfect sense, but <em>The Prisoner</em> didn’t need to cloak the finale in 1960s visual rebellion to communicate actual rebellion — that was already part of the show’s DNA.</p><p>Here we have <em>GoldenEye </em>and <em>The Prisoner</em>, a movie and a television show made over a quarter of a century apart, making similar decisions. Both are successful in achieving their vision but are held back by one major issue: when reaching for something new, both of them embraced the fashion of the day without considering or questioning whether that was the right aesthetic for their specific project. Hindsight is twenty-twenty, of course, and perhaps they did consider this, but in the moment, and under time pressure, they couldn’t see the issues immediately. Although in the case of <em>GoldenEye, </em>the issue was at least attempted to be corrected with the replacement of the cue for the tank chase. The composer of that cue,<a href="https://jamesbondradio.com/composer-john-altman-explains-what-went-wrong-with-goldeneyes-score-exclusive-by-matthew-chernov/"> John Altman, has said that the producers told him</a>, “We’d have given you the whole film to re-score if we’d known you were that quick,” which, if true, is very telling about their opinion of Serra’s score. McGoohan, on the other hand, never, to my knowledge, indicated any regret about the ending that he wrote. It’s possible that he genuinely thought it worked well, or maybe he valued confounding the audience more than serving the material to the highest degree possible.</p><p>But there’s another factor to consider as well. We all like to imagine the auteur, the lone creator with the singular vision, as a driving force, but maybe this force needs to be tamed occasionally? Part of the issue with <em>GoldenEye </em>is that <a href="https://elsew.com/serra/interv.htm">Serra had only ever worked with Besson in a very specific way</a>: Besson would come up with the emotion of the scene he wanted, Serra would write the music, and Besson would have daily check-ins. However, with <em>GoldenEye, </em>it sounds like Serra, working on his first Hollywood movie at the same time as working with new people using a different process, was given free rein with little supervision. He may have been getting so many notes from different parties (<a href="https://jamesbondradio.com/composer-john-altman-explains-what-went-wrong-with-goldeneyes-score-exclusive-by-matthew-chernov/">according to Altman</a>) that he insulated himself from this feedback as much as possible. Some institutional oversight may have worked wonders for Serra’s score. Likewise, McGoohan could probably have used some pushback from someone (perhaps George Markstein, the series’ script editor and disputed co-creator) to challenge his script ideas.</p><p>Because their foundations are so strong, both <em>GoldenEye</em> and <em>The Prisoner</em> survive their missteps and remain iconic <strong>despite</strong> their flaws. They also serve as cautionary tales: fashion is seductive precisely because it feels contemporary and right in the moment. But recognizing the gap between what the material requires versus what seems exciting and new may be the hardest part of the creative process.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://thecinemyth.com/p/goldeneye-and-the-prisoner-victims"><em>https://thecinemyth.com</em></a><em> on December 25, 2025.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f6129c37ba87" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>