<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jayar La Fontaine on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jayar La Fontaine on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@themeta?source=rss-6c3550e3c560------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 20:03:19 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@themeta/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Next Futures]]></title>
            <link>https://themeta.medium.com/the-next-futures-5731b13a7540?source=rss-6c3550e3c560------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5731b13a7540</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[strategic-foresight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[values]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[circularity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jayar La Fontaine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Aug 2023 16:50:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-17T17:10:38.346Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Below is the full text of a talk I delivered at a conference titled The State of Foresight Studies in the World. The conference was organized by ICESCO and the Policy Center for the New South and was held in Rabat, Morocco in May 2023. In this talk, I sketch a potential evolutionary path for corporations — one which would see them becoming much more future-aware than they are today.</em></p><p>Thank you very much. I first want to thank ICESCO for the invitation to be here. It’s impossible to keep up with everything that is happening in our field — even just in North America, which is where I do most of my work. So having the chance to learn from my colleagues on this side of the Atlantic is invaluable, and I greatly appreciate the opportunity.</p><p>In the next few minutes, I want to share two things with you. First, I want to talk about the state of foresight as I see it in the Fortune 500 companies with whom I do most of my work. Then I want to make the case that we’re on the cusp of some big changes that could make these organizations much more future-aware than they are today.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UDO6SL59XUx85e_iLOwx7Q.png" /></figure><p>To begin, I’d like to share something that the biologist E.O. Wilson said which I return to again and again. When asked whether humans would be able to rise to the complex challenges that we face, he replied: “The real problem of humanity is the following: we have Paleolithic emotions, medieval institutions, and futuristic technology.” I think what he was trying to convey is that our minds, our institutions, and our technologies each operate on different <strong>clocks </strong>and at different <strong>scales</strong>, and so addressing our biggest problems would require getting these three things working together harmoniously.</p><p>This isn’t an easy thing to do, obviously, because the interaction effects between our minds, institutions, and technologies are difficult to anticipate — and often the results are very counterintuitive. Let’s take the case of social media.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cTSb1uqpS1jZ49Mmm1MySw.png" /></figure><p>Its early pioneers saw the technology as a catalyst for creating a more open and connected world; as a means of placing freedom of expression beyond the reach of censors; and as a commons where everyone could be seen and heard.</p><p>We now know that the real impact of social media has been far more mixed. It has spread misinformation, deepened political polarization, and created vast privacy issues. It has reshaped communication in ways that have led to serious social and psychological consequences for its users. And it has fed the ad-driven model of the Internet and created an Attention Economy in which our data, mental energy, and impulses are exploited for profit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gBhuV2bviNnn96SWQbBF0A.png" /></figure><p>What happened? The early innovators of social media forgot that humans and digital technologies work on different <strong><em>clocks </em></strong>and <strong><em>scales</em></strong>. For the majority of human history, our social lives were contained within small, tight-knit groups. Our interactions were time-bounded, and regulated by a web of mutual community obligations. The design of social media took account of very little of that social inheritance. So these impacts are the results of design choices <em>made along the way </em>that resulted in social media being an imperfect technology for encouraging healthy, positive, and productive human interactions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S9xoYTc3unomVWNNLu84ew.png" /></figure><p>There is another vision of social media that’s possible: one that values privacy, promotes healthy interactions, and even provides fair compensation for user data. There’s reason to hope that we will get there. I think you are already seeing that in the retreat from the big, open social media platforms to what the tech writer Venkatesh Rao calls the Cozy Web — these are things like small, friendly WhatsApp and WeChat groups, Slack channels, and Discord chats. You might think of the Cozy Web as <em>social media on the human scale</em>.</p><p>I use this design problem with social media as an illustration because I believe there is a similar design issue when it comes to building future-aware organizations — particularly in the business world. It’s quite a difficult task because foresight and modern corporations operate, again, on different <strong><em>clocks </em></strong>and at different <strong><em>scales</em></strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lQt0WVMJPfHfRpH0lNMs1w.png" /></figure><p>Anyone who has worked in the private sector has felt the sense of urgency that attends life inside a business. There’s always a clock ticking away in the background toward some deadline or event: it could be counting down to a review cycle, an investor update, an IPO, an impending product launch, and so on.</p><p>Most businesses are built for speed and fixated on near-term results. If they’re a startup, they might be preparing for another funding round. If they’re publicly traded, they’re laser-focused on quarterly earnings.</p><p>And so often what you’ll find is that foresight gets operationalized as an input into one or another of these near-term objectives. Weak signals of change might be used to inform a new product or feature. A scenario exercise might make its way into an annual report. And so on. In this way, they miss the actual value that foresight can bring to an organization.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Z0-v0g5eIjcUgJpIaQDxyw.png" /></figure><p>My colleagues and I advise our clients to view foresight not as a standalone initiative with a static outcome, or as an input into planning or innovation initiatives, but as an ongoing <em>sensing </em>function with the primary purpose of being <em>curious </em>and <em>critical </em>about the future, and of spreading this future-awareness into the <em>culture </em>of the organization. This type of function has a difficult time finding a home in the modern corporation, which is an imperfect institution for creating and maintaining a <em>motivating vision</em> of the long-term future.</p><p>I want to stress that I don’t think these are discouraging results. When I started doing this work I was often in the position of having to <em>explain </em>foresight to my clients, most of whom had never heard of it. We’ve come a long way since then, but I think on the whole we’ve yet to see the full flowering of foresight in the business world.</p><p>I believe getting there will require asking a different question. If we ask how to convert foresight into action the issue with that framing is that it can potentially subordinate our long-term vision and aspirations for the future to the short-term goals that dominate the business world today. The question should instead be: how do we develop and maintain a motivating vision of the future, and ensure that every action we undertake pays homage to, and is in service of, that vision?</p><p>As in the case of social media, I think there are good reasons to be optimistic that things are changing — both within the practice of foresight and more broadly in the way we do business — that will lead to a future with many more organizations whose actions are directed by a long-term vision for the future.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IT71JmkntuDKrDU6WVhUkg.png" /></figure><p>Let’s talk briefly about changes happening within foresight. It’s always been something of an artisan’s trade in which highly trained practitioners combine their craft and intuition to vividly bring the future to life alongside their clients. Despite our occasional protests, we are still a discipline of “experts”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RZuNiZpLObd-xoiz4NT0kw.png" /></figure><p>Now, we <em>have </em>learned how to make foresight more participatory to those outside our community of practice through things like trend immersions, multi-media scenario projects, and forecasting tournaments. But the scaling problem of making a workforce comfortable and competent with using the tools, methods, and mindset of foresight in their day-to-day is still a significant barrier.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MPBK1S5ifWW0wkiFqwGAOA.png" /></figure><p>Now I think we are seeing the dawn of a powerful new set of tools that will change this. In the past decade or so, many functions of organizations like accounting, project management, and human resources were streamlined and automated by the rise of the Software-as-a-Service and cloud computing markets. Today, we are living through the first wave of commercialization of incredible technologies like large language models and generative AI that will have a similar impact on the <em>strategic </em>functions of organizations.</p><p>Already, these technologies can do things like help identify patterns in trend data, auto-generate scenario matrices, and perform rapid visualization and prototyping activities. You may have already guessed that I used a generative AI called MidJourney to create the illustrations for this presentation — using sections of this talk as prompts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uCrq2WeBqcewePOB-ZuT7g.png" /></figure><p>There is a variation of chess called Centaur Chess, in which teams of humans and AI <em>jointly </em>decide on which moves to make. Typically in Centaur Chess, the AIs play one another and the human players have the opportunity to intervene and set their AI teammate down a different strategic pathway. I think foresight is evolving from an artisan craft into a “centaur” discipline that will combine the strengths of humans and AI — and that will make organizations much better at maintaining a long-term vision of the future</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Bsnm4aUxgJVeQQWXNWcaUQ.png" /></figure><p>The other reason that I see corporations becoming more future-aware is simply because they will <em>have to be</em> to effectively compete in the next global economy. Corporations have been focused on short-term business cycles because <em>historically </em>they have not been held to account for many of the externalities created by their activities. So you have to think on a different <em>clock </em>and at a different <em>scale </em>when you become responsible for the entire life-cycle of your product, or when every node along your supply chain needs to be transparent and traceable. And that seems to be where things are headed.</p><p>Maybe you’ve heard the expression from the satirist Jonathan Swift, “You can’t reason someone out of a position that they didn’t reason themselves into in the first place.” Something similar applies here. The kind of thinking that led us to this place where short-termism rules the business world cannot be used to develop long-term views to guide us through the next turn of the global economy.</p><p>I’ll end on this thought. The psychologist Thomas Suddendorf has done some fascinating work studying foresight in the lab — not the discipline of foresight, but the human ability to mentally travel forward in time. He believes that this open-ended ability to imagine and reflect on the future has been one of the two significant factors in the success of our species. The other is our insatiable desire to link our minds with one another in common pursuits.</p><p>Corporations have been honing their cooperative abilities through technologies and processes as long as they’ve existed. We’re really good at that part. I think when we institutionalize that other unique human ability to engage in open-ended explorations of the future, we’ll be a step closer to corporations that operate <em>on the human scale</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1ztsGvqpCnyphnWUx3iGPA.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5731b13a7540" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The New Counter-Urbanization]]></title>
            <link>https://themeta.medium.com/the-new-counter-urbanization-74d5039cf312?source=rss-6c3550e3c560------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/74d5039cf312</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[urbanism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[remote-working]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[housing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rural-revitalization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[starlink]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jayar La Fontaine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Jan 2021 20:23:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-03T21:23:17.691Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>On why more people will live outside cities in the 2020s.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/848/1*KiTRXf5c32YFLJYRR709Jg.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Starlink’s receiver, Dishy McDishface, on a rural property in central Montana (Credit: Nickolas Friedrich)</em></figcaption></figure><p>One of the most striking trends of 2020 was the sharp decline in the movement toward ever-greater urbanization. According to an <a href="https://www.brinknews.com/how-covid-19-is-impacting-where-people-decide-to-live/">Oliver Wyman Forum survey</a>, nearly one in five American urbanites is now planning or considering leaving their city.</p><p>Available listings in San Francisco’s rental market have <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/ellistalton/2020/09/03/people-fleeing-big-cities-may-spur-economic-growth-in-smaller-metros/?sh=676f547252d6">nearly doubled</a> since last year as tech workers take advantage of remote work opportunities and decamp to more affordable cities and towns around the country.</p><p>Home sales in New York’s adjoining suburbs are up nearly fifty percent over the same period, driven by the hundreds of thousands of New Yorkers who’ve left the city, <a href="https://nypost.com/2020/12/15/nycs-mass-covid-19-exodus-reportedly-cost-34b-in-income/">taking tens of billions of dollars in high-marginal rate tax revenue with them</a>. Vacancies in Manhattan are at a sixteen-year high.</p><p>Here in Canada, things have followed a similar trajectory. Rents in Toronto’s investment-driven condo market fell nearly 20% in 2020, leaving many new landlords with negative cashflow on assets that had virtually been a license to print money for the past decade. The average price of a home in the city’s surrounding counties rose up to 80% over the same period. A Millennial-aged couple started a hugely popular blog called <a href="https://ninetyminutesfrom.com/">Ninety Minutes from Toronto</a>, which provides economic and demographic information and offbeat real estate listings for often-overlooked communities surrounding the city. Overnight, it seemed like Toronto was no longer the center of the Canadian universe for young people.</p><p>None of this <em>did </em>happen overnight, of course. This wave of counter-urbanization has been gathering momentum for a decade, or perhaps longer. Looking back, we may understand the COVID-19 pandemic as a period that drastically accelerated the trend while at the same time solving thorny coordination problems that have forestalled departures from the world’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_city">global cities</a>.</p><p>This abrupt migratory shift from metropolitan to non-metropolitan areas clashes with typical expert predictions for future human settlement patterns. The UN Department for Social and Economic Affairs, for instance, <a href="https://www.un.org/development/desa/en/news/population/2018-revision-of-world-urbanization-prospects.html">has forecasted</a> that nearly 70% of the world’s population will live in cities by 2050. Nothing in history is a straight line. Periodic downturns in prevailing trends aren’t just normal — they’re expected.</p><p>Nor would the COVID-19 pandemic mark the first time people have fled the threat of disease in cities for the relative safety of the countryside. Giovanni Boccaccio’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Decameron">The Decameron</a> and Daniel Defoe’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Journal_of_the_Plague_Year">A Journal of the Plague Year</a> provide details of the hollowing-out of 14th century Florence and mid-17th century London, respectively, as the well-heeled took to their country estates — and the poor to the woods.</p><p>The evidence remains overwhelmingly on the side of those predicting a dense urban future. The periods during which trends in settlement patterns have tilted toward counter-urbanization are often brief, and their effect mild.</p><p>On the other hand, it’s an underappreciated fact that a significant number of urbanites would prefer <em>not </em>to live in big cities if given the option. According to a <a href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/245249/americans-big-idea-living-country.aspx">2018 Gallup poll</a>, only 12% of Americans express a preference for living in big cities, while 27% say they’d prefer to live in rural areas. The percentage of Americans currently living in these environments is 20% and 15%, respectively. Americans, on the whole, like living in less dense places.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/1*3l18N9hthORW6_5qlRNFjw.png" /></figure><p>All things being equal, a transfer of roughly 8% of Americans from big cities and 12% into rural areas would bring the country’s settlement patterns in line with Italy and Switzerland — and with the UN projections for the mid-21st-century global average. That would mean 36 million more Americans living, working, and building community in the small towns that have struggled to adapt to their post-industrial reality.</p><p>If we examine the current counter-urbanism trend’s underlying drivers, a migratory shift of this magnitude might not be so far-fetched. There are good reasons to believe we may be in the early stages of a new equilibrium in settlement patterns.</p><p>In the future, more of us may choose to permanently live outside our densest cities.</p><p><strong>The Varieties of Counter-Urbanism</strong></p><p>There are complex reasons for counter-urbanization’s ebb and flow pattern. In Canadian geographer Clare Mitchell’s paper “Making sense of counterurbanization,” she offers three sub-types, each with its own socio-cultural drivers: <em>ex-urbanization</em>, <em>displaced urbanization</em>, and <em>anti-urbanization</em>.</p><p>Let’s explore each of these counter-urbanization sub-types, and examine how emerging technological, economic, and cultural trends are changing their dynamics in ways that suggest the 2020s may be a counter-urban decade.</p><p><strong>Ex-Urbanism and the Digital Economy</strong></p><p><em>Ex-urbanization</em> is a migratory trend driven by urbanites moving to the countryside to enjoy access to its amenities — like its recreational spaces and relative tranquility — while maintaining economic ties and deriving income from the city.</p><p>Ex-urbanites do not typically participate in the productive activities of the countryside. They are unlikely, for instance, to take up commercial farming or logging as a vocation. However, they are invested in preserving their adopted communities’ character and traditional lifeways and will resist the incursion of coarsening developments like big-box retailers and open quarries to protect their chosen community’s <em>heritage-scape</em> and <em>leisure-scape</em>.</p><p>Historically, ex-urbanism as a lifestyle strategy has only been possible for the wealthy. Imagine a white-collar professional in a senior managerial role who can avoid a daily commute, or someone in a position to live either partially or entirely off passive income streams, or wealthy retirees, and you have some idea of the typical ex-urbanite.</p><p>The ongoing worldwide experiment in remote working may change that. Before the pandemic, employers typically provided remote working privileges for employees reluctantly and mostly in exceptional circumstances or as a negotiated perk. Employers’ unease with remote work came down to a raft of productivity concerns. For example, remote employees might be more likely to misuse or falsely report work hours, and sparsely populated physical office spaces may damage the morale of remaining on-site staff.</p><p>Early studies suggest that these fears are unfounded. A survey of 9000 knowledge workers conducted by Slack found that <a href="https://fortune.com/2020/12/06/offices-covid-workers-returning-never-want-to-stats-data-2/">two-thirds</a> would either prefer to work from home all or most of the time post-pandemic. A move away from offices would also significantly reduce businesses’ ongoing carrying costs. A <a href="https://www.capgemini.com/research/the-future-of-work/?utm_source=pr&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=none_none_link_pressrelease_none&amp;utm_campaign=other_hybrid_workforce">Capgemini survey</a> of 500 companies found that 88% of them realized real estate cost savings in the third quarter of 2020, with 92% expecting additional savings over the next two to three years.</p><p>On the productivity front, the same survey also found that 63% of companies reported <em>increased </em>productivity during the third quarter of 2020 due to “less commuting time, flexible work schedules and the adoption of effective virtual collaboration tools.” At the level of individual workers, <a href="https://scholar.harvard.edu/eharrington/publications/working-remotely-selection-treatment-and-market-provision-remote-work">a recent paper</a> by Natalia Emanuel and Emma Harrington, two doctoral students in economics at Harvard, found that remote working <em>increased </em>worker productivity in call centers by 8–10%.</p><p>Not every job can be made remote, but the size of the digital economy and the workforce required to run it continues to grow. Already, it accounts for <a href="https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/der2019_overview_en.pdf">nearly 20% of GDP in some developed nations</a> — which is, in some cases, a larger share than legacy sectors like mining or oil and gas extraction. And as it grows, so too will the number of workers who can perform their duties from any location with a reliable, high-speed internet connection.</p><p>The lack of high-speed internet access in rural areas has been a significant limiting factor in ex-urban growth. That may be about to change — and quickly — due to the arrival of near-Earth-orbit satellite internet services like SpaceX’s high-profile project, <a href="https://www.starlink.com/">Starlink</a>.</p><p>Over the past few months, a small group of Starlink beta testers has begun submitting the service’s first consumer-reported speed tests to its <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/Starlink/">fan-run subreddit</a>. So far, its performance relative to traditional satellite internet and cell tower-based services is astonishing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*rt5hQ0_F4rWcaTQg777-gw.png" /><figcaption>A Starlink beta tester’s side-by-side speed tests comparing the service with their existing provider</figcaption></figure><p>As the near-Earth-orbit satellite sector continues to expand, hundreds of millions of people living outside the world’s cities will go from having Internet connections that struggle to load simple web pages — or worse, from having no Internet access at all — to connections that can handle high-definition media streaming, videoconferencing, and large file transfers with ease.</p><p>A worldwide broadband blanket will provide <a href="https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/thunder-bay/pikangikum-spacex-starlink-1.5824234">isolated communities </a>with improved access to desperately-needed services like healthcare and education. At the same time, it may also lower the barrier-to-entry for ex-urbanism, significantly closing the gap between where people live and where they <em>want </em>to live.</p><p><strong>Displaced Urbanization and Financialization</strong></p><p><em>Displaced urbanization</em> describes the migratory patterns of people “failing” out of cities — a group sometimes referred to as “distress movers” or “urban dropouts” that leave cities for “new employment, lower cost of living and/or available housing,” according to Mitchell.</p><p>Among the most significant contributors to the rising costs of city living — and, ultimately, urban displacement — is housing prices.</p><p>To understand why housing prices are out of control, we need to briefly touch on the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qWSVG9nsRa4&amp;t=894s&amp;ab_channel=TVODocs">financialization of global real estate</a>. Financialization describes a process in which something is purchased primarily as an investment vehicle rather than for its intended use — in the case of homes and condos, as a dwelling. When an area’s real estate market undergoes financialization, it creates artificial housing scarcity, which decouples housing prices from the real wages of people living and working in those markets.</p><p>Both local and global speculators drive financialization. In Manhattan, half of the luxury condos built since 2015 <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/10/realestate/new-york-decade-real-estate.html">are vacant</a>. The borough’s upscale condominiums are a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potemkin_village">Potemkin village</a> disguising the unattainability of a well-heeled, cosmopolitan lifestyle. Large swaths of Vancouver’s condos are <em>pieds-à-terre</em> for the global ultra-rich who use them as safe places to <a href="https://thetyee.ca/Analysis/2020/02/13/Gov-Real-Estate-Vancouver-Housing-Unaffordable/">hide money from confiscatory home governments</a>. And then there are the <a href="https://nowtoronto.com/news/airbnb-exacerbates-toronto-vacancy-rate/">ghost hotels</a>: the invisible, mostly unregulated, and unregulatable swarm of short-term rentals that have transformed mid-market condominiums into <a href="https://thelogic.co/news/the-big-read/i-regret-buying-a-unit-in-this-building-how-the-rise-of-airbnb-turned-twin-toronto-condo-towers-into-a-battleground/">crash-pads and party-pads</a>. Toronto has over 10,000 of them. That’s 10,000 fewer places Torontonians can rent, let alone own, which means artificially high price tags for doing either.</p><p>Some cities have little hope of fixing their <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/f5b4b912-46e3-11ea-aeb3-955839e06441">severe housing shortages</a> unless they completely overhaul their strict zoning laws. Toronto, arguably, is <em>not</em> one of those cities. The roof of my old office in Toronto’s Chinatown had a panoramic view of the downtown core. We would sometimes go up there to smoke, chat, and count the many construction cranes around us.<strong> </strong>According to the RLB Crane Index, in 2019, Toronto had 120 cranes operating in residential and mixed-use construction, which is more than double the next two cities on the list — Los Angeles and Seattle — <em>combined</em>. In 2020, <a href="https://www.craneandhoistcanada.com/toronto-tops-construction-crane-index-with-almost-a-third-of-all-north-american-projects/">one-third of all such active cranes</a> in North America were in Toronto.</p><p>Developers will complete many of these projects in the next few years, which will moderate housing prices. And the pandemic has reversed some of these pricing trends, if only likely temporarily. The price tag on the smallest condos in Toronto’s market — those units which are easy prey for investors and which feel cramped during stay-at-home orders — shrunk 10% in 2020.</p><p>But what does price moderation or reversal mean in this context? Today, the average price of a new condo build downtown is <a href="https://www.blogto.com/real-estate-toronto/2020/01/toronto-house-condo-prices-skyrocketed/">nearly $700,000</a>, which is up almost 20% from two years ago. If Toronto represents our best effort to keep pace with housing demand in our Tier 1 cities, we are in trouble.</p><p>As housing prices continue ever-upward alongside growing healthcare and education costs, real wages have been flatlining for <em>over half a century</em>. Based on nearly 200 years of economic data, the investment group Schroders found that the gap between housing prices and real wages <a href="https://www.schroders.com/en/uk/private-investor/insights/markets/what-174-years-of-data-tell-us-about-house-price-affordability-in-the-uk/">hasn’t been this large since before the First World War</a>. Even middle-class people are being displaced from urban spaces by housing markets that have become dizzyingly decoupled from local labor markets. Much of that decoupling has occurred in the past decade, as global investors and private equity firms pulled out of the collapsing subprime mortgage market and trained their sights on desirable urban real estate as their next undervalued investment class.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*rj4q6ywyYvVNZ98pqUnEig.jpeg" /></figure><p>As city real estate’s financialization continues largely unchecked, younger generations are also falling further behind their elders in age-adjusted wealth accumulation. You’ve probably heard people say that Millennials and Zoomers care more about experiences than ownership because they are less material and more enlightened than previous generations, and that their fondness for minimalism is a mark of refined, understated tastes. It must simply be a coincidence that people under forty control less than five percent of the world’s wealth. The reality is that many of them can’t <em>afford</em> to own and invest, even if that’s what they wanted.</p><p>A lot of this is down to bad generational timing. Many Millennials graduated during a massive worldwide recession into the worst job market in nearly a century. As they enter their peak earning years, we may all take the <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/08/millennials-are-screwed-recession/596728/">plunge</a> <a href="https://fortune.com/2021/01/06/covid-pandemic-recession-unemployment-mortality-rate-increase/">again</a>.</p><p>There’s more bad news. Like the trillion dollars of unforgivable student debt hanging over our collective heads. Why so much? Because education is shot through with <a href="https://www.mercatus.org/system/files/helland-tabarrok_why-are-the-prices-so-damn-high_v1.pdf">Baumol’s cost disease</a>; it’s gotten twice as expensive since the early 90’s because we need to pay legions of college administrators <em>not</em> to be investment bankers.</p><p>If we draw each of these trend lines forward, we arrive, according to geographer Joel Kotkin, at the conclusion that the “future of the luxury city — the pride of both Trump and Bloomberg — is an extraordinarily limited one, promising to return to the bad old days when the urban centers were largely abandoned except for visitors, the wealthy and people too young to buy a house or start a family.”</p><p>Taken together, real estate financialization, wage stagnation, high personal debt loads, and the compounding effects of rolling recessions — especially on young people’s earning potential during crucial periods of their early careers — strongly suggest that more people will have no choice but to build their lives outside of cities.</p><p><strong>Anti-Urbanization and Social Influencers</strong></p><p>Finally, <em>anti-urbanization</em> describes the movement of people who wish to reject urban life in favor of a more “Jeffersonian” existence in the countryside. Mitchell suggests that anti-urbanites also often desire to find work or practice a trade outside of dense urban centers and fully integrate into rural communities. Unlike ex-urbanism or displaced urbanism, both connected to a set of preferences — attainable or unattainable — for urban life, anti-urbanism involves its explicit rejection.</p><p>Anti-urbanism has a long history in American social and religious culture. Early American <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transcendentalism">transcendentalism</a> — as articulated by its sages: Thoreau, Emerson, and Whitman — has become canon. The philosophy of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Distributism">distributism</a> — which promotes cultural traditionalism and agrarianism, as evidenced by one of its key slogans: “Three acres and a cow.” — continues to exert a strong influence over American political Catholicism. Of course, American Protestantism has always contained a streak of the counter-urbanism movement that was an essential driver for the country’s founding. Anabaptists like the Hutterites, Mennonites, Amish, and Bruderhof are among the fastest-growing communities in North America. In the secular world, the back-to-the-Earth commune movement dovetailed with the American counterculture of the 1960s and 1970s to form the foundations of contemporary anti-urbanist trends.</p><p>Many previous generations of anti-urbanites have turned away from cities due to their perceived vices — like crime, immorality, degradation, and pollution. By contrast, modern anti-urban movements seem to reject cities due to their growing cultural <em>homogeneity </em>and <em>predictability</em>, criticisms which, historically, have more often been leveled against the countryside.</p><p>Phenomena like the <a href="https://www.architecturaldigest.com/story/what-exactly-is-cottagecore">cottagecore</a> aesthetic, back-to-the-land influencers like <a href="https://www.instagram.com/thebiggestlittlefarm/?utm_source=ig_embed">The Biggest Little Farm</a> and <a href="https://theelliotthomestead.com/">The Elliot Homestead</a>, and anti-modern collective <a href="https://dark-mountain.net/">The Dark Mountain Project</a> each point to a persistent desire to seek creative and vital ways of thriving outside of cities. Social media communities extolling <a href="http://fastcompany.com/90498018/covid-19-has-made-living-off-the-grid-irresistible-are-these-self-sustaining-homes-the-future">off-the-grid living</a> and <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/petersuciu/2020/03/23/preppers-are-sharing-tips-on-surviving-covid-19-via-social-media/?sh=2b7ae81514cf">prepping</a> have grown significantly in popularity during the pandemic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/933/1*zje7Kwqsbl4ixg_gMUJnIg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Web developer Simon Sarris’ web-presence draws together many threads of modern anti-urbanism</figcaption></figure><p>For these anti-urban movements, the countryside is a space to exercise their creative expression and self-determination, which is increasingly difficult to do in big cities where time pressures, distractions, space constraints, and regulations conspire against them. Woodworking, crafting, hunting, gardening, canning, preserving, bushcraft, foraging, animal husbandry, parenting, and cooking-from-scratch all feature heavily in the new anti-urbanist’s vision of a fully realized life.</p><p>Comparatively, city life seems drab and threadbare to modern anti-urbanists — and they may have a point. Writer and theorist Kyle Chayka has noted how cities are converging on a predictable shared visual aesthetic and hermetic service-based economy under the influence of globalization and big tech. He believes the interior design trends, goods, and services catering to hip tastes that are so prevalent on social media sites have led to the adoption of a standard feature list for luxury city spaces:</p><blockquote>“We could call this strange geography created by technology “AirSpace.” It’s the realm of coffee shops, bars, startup offices, and co-live / work spaces that share the same hallmarks everywhere you go: a profusion of symbols of comfort and quality, at least to a certain connoisseurial mindset. Minimalist furniture. Craft beer and avocado toast. Reclaimed wood. Industrial lighting. Cortados. Fast internet. The homogeneity of these spaces means that traveling between them is frictionless …”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oOlhjTyIIMeAY7sG0mvaKw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A typical Airspace</figcaption></figure><p>The feeling of sameness that permeates urban spaces today is based on a style and feature set that appeals to people who are <em>just passing through</em> — whether for a layover, a work secondment, or a stint in grad school. Airspace is unlike Jane Jacob’s preferred style of urbanism, which provides us opportunities for an encounter with strangers and “the strange.” Instead, Airspace allows the modern global citizen to travel from city-to-city, state-to-state, country-to-country, or continent-to-continent without ever feeling out of place — or <em>in </em>a particular place.</p><p>At the same time that urban spaces are converging in their look and feel, the growing digital service economy centered in large cities is making the fulfillment of our moment-to-moment desires trivially easy — all too easy, for anti-urbanists.</p><p>Smartphones overflow with apps built to swiftly bring the world’s goods and services to our doors with minimal effort required. We can conjure media, games, food, cars, and on and on with a few clicks and swipes. Often, on the other side of these transactions are gig workers who move through the city in response to algorithms calculating their next pick-up and drop-off — an arrangement that workers describe as <a href="https://hbr.org/2019/08/what-people-hate-about-being-managed-by-algorithms-according-to-a-study-of-uber-drivers&#39;">isolating and dehumanizing</a>. For customers, the digital service economy’s endgame is idleness; for workers, it’s digital <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/01/18/whats-wrong-with-the-way-we-work">serfdom</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/597/1*W4REyVozg56PGOula96mDw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The new wave of anti-urbanists exhibit a complex set of motivations. A typical origin story among modern anti-urban influencers begins with an episode of burnout brought on by overwork — often, in some tech-mediated profession — and an intense urge to escape the city’s entanglements for something more immediate and open-ended.</p><p>But while many new anti-urbanists wish to put some daylight between themselves and the digital world, they seem unlikely to be neo-Luddites judging by their social media presence. Their back-to-the-land approach is rooted as much in a desire for constructive hardship and immediacy as it is any primitivist ideology. They may profess a faith or set of conservative values that are well-suited for rural environments, but they do not tend to belittle people’s lives in the city. They adopt rural vocations like farming without turning their backs on the wisdom of YouTube instructors and homesteading bloggers.</p><p>Social media is catalyzing a strain of anti-urban movements that will spread much more efficiently and effectively through mainstream culture. As the conditions that motivate anti-urban sentiment increase in cities and the community’s influencers grow in reach and number, we should expect more people to adopt anti-urban lifestyles. When they are ready to leave the city, they will have the added benefit of cheerleaders and advisors that previous generations of anti-urbanists may have struggled to find.</p><p><strong>The Future of Counter-Urbanism</strong></p><p>The most lasting legacy of the COVID-19 pandemic may be its role in helping to solve a society-wide <a href="https://fs.blog/2020/06/coordination-problems/">coordination problem</a> that establishes a new set of employment standards for the workday and shifts our values toward a greater appreciation for stable and creative home lives. If so, we could see a wave of counter-urbanism that results in a long-term shift in the numbers of people living in metropolitan and non-metropolitan areas.</p><p>Counter-urbanism at the scale discussed here would likely have far-reaching and transformative effects. An influx of new residents and investment would lift struggling rural communities. In bigger homes than they could afford in the city and with fewer financial pressures, families newly in the country could have more children, which would help close the one-child gap between <a href="https://www.plough.com/en/topics/life/parenting/the-case-for-one-more-child">our actual and preferred family size</a>. Greater counter-urbanization would force cities to compete more consistently with close-by geographies for residents, incentivizing them to improve services and livability. It may even help heal our current political schisms by weakening the association between settlement geography and ideology — a Big Jumble to reverse the <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-10-25/how-the-big-sort-is-driving-political-polarization">Big Sort</a>.</p><p>Further envisioning what a new wave of sustained counter-urbanism could mean seems like a worthwhile undertaking. I don’t yet have a clear sense of what that future may look like, but I am personally invested in its arrival.</p><p>After a decade of living in downtown Toronto, my partner and I decided at the end of 2019 that we would hand in the keys to our third-floor walkup rental apartment and move out of the city.</p><p>Our new full-time residence was a small chalet we’d bought several years earlier in rural Grey Highlands, two hours north of Toronto. We’d been using it as a getaway where we’d invite city friends to hike the Bruce Trail, climb in the Beaver Valley, and enjoy unspoiled night skies as we sat around the backyard firepit. Now it’s home.</p><p>We had faced a choice that so many young urbanites today confront. We could stretch ourselves to buy a fixer-upper far outside the downtown core, but then we’d be tethered to an outsized mortgage and forced to commute into work. Or, we could purchase a modest condo downtown, but then we’d likely have to pay for a parking spot and condo fees for amenities we’d never use. And all this for the privilege of owning “a box in the sky,” as a good friend puts it.</p><p>In the end, we chose neither.</p><p>Our counter-urbanization story contains facets of each of the phenomenon’s socio-cultural motivators outlined above. We were displaced by city housing prices. Then again, we genuinely enjoyed the countryside’s amenities and planned to maintain our economic ties to the city through remote work. Finally, we were animated by a growing anti-urban streak in our ambitions that led us to search for a new pace to life and connection to place.</p><p>I don’t think we’re the only ones with too many good reasons to build a life outside the city.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1014/1*aRC4VCw3q99VZAmOJjYlIw.jpeg" /><figcaption>‘Bowles Bluff Road, Beaver Valley’ by local artist David Marshak</figcaption></figure><p>The fall after settling into our new home, we spent a day helping our friend Jonathan prepare his sugar shack for the coming maple syrup season. We cleared brush that had grown over the paths that wound from the shack to the maples and loaded his beat-up pickup with dry logs cut from trees felled in past seasons. Others would split the logs we’d gathered into firewood to feed the shack’s evaporator — a large cylindrical oven that dominates its floor.</p><p>That night, we gathered at the shack to celebrate the opening of the season. We drank cider and spirits around the crackling evaporator, chatted about local goings-on, and plucked at the webs of rumor and conjecture spun, as naturally as spiders do, by people who live in small towns.</p><p>Later that evening, while standing outside the shack, my eyes drifted to the horizon. Trees — dark and jagged against a clear night sky — covered the valley’s high walls, which loomed over us.</p><p>Skimming through the sky along the treetops, I saw something odd: a chain of bright lights — perhaps a half-dozen or more — moving steadily and synchronously from east to west. After a moment of confusion, I realized that I was seeing something I’d been hoping to spot for a long time: a Starlink train.</p><p>Sipping bourbon outside of Jon’s sugar shack and watching the satellites pass overhead, I felt as though I was glimpsing the future I’ve been writing about here.</p><p>If you’re interested in discussing that future, or if you’ve been considering whether to join the current exodus from big cities, let’s talk.</p><p>You can contact me at <strong>jayar@themeta.io</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wnBenRj9QP0BCLVUt8ttEA.png" /><figcaption>A train of recently launched Starlink satellites</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=74d5039cf312" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[COVID-19 and Epistemic Hygiene]]></title>
            <link>https://themeta.medium.com/covid-19-and-epistemic-hygiene-d14db1205f26?source=rss-6c3550e3c560------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d14db1205f26</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[foresight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pandemic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[belief]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rationality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jayar La Fontaine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Mar 2020 22:20:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-21T14:13:18.476Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SK9CEQiJ0U9kcwqbEmGVkQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Lineups at Costco. Mario Tama. Getty Images.</figcaption></figure><h4>What the pandemic can tell us about how we ought to believe</h4><p><em>Note: This piece discusses distressing events that have transpired during the COVID-19 outbreak.</em></p><p>As of this writing, we are heading into Spring Break amid a global pandemic.</p><p>South Florida beaches are <a href="https://www.local10.com/news/local/2020/03/14/south-florida-beaches-packed-despite-coronavirus-fears-as-spring-break-arrives/">packed with young revelers</a>. Bars in <a href="https://twitter.com/jake_bittle/status/1238585779166863360">New York</a> and <a href="https://twitter.com/SportsPundette/status/1239054374791512064">Nashville</a> are full of patrons celebrating St. Patrick’s day, talking and drinking in close quarters. If your Facebook feed is like mine you are seeing a distressing amount of sentiments like “It’s just the flu!” and “It’s cooked-up media hysteria!” circulating. Arizona, Florida, and Illinois are planning to proceed with their primaries which will bring out tens of thousands of people — many of them members of high-risk populations — into high-school gyms, public libraries, and auditoriums.</p><p>Across the Atlantic but a mere tweet away, Italy has been under <a href="https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/03/italy-tightens-lockdown-coronavirus-death-toll-soars-200312004301790.html">full lockdown</a> for the better part of a week. All non-essential services like bars, restaurants, and salons have been ordered to close. Only grocery stores and pharmacies remain open. The streets are empty. <a href="https://twitter.com/NaomiOhReally/status/1238868163208634371">In a video posted to Twitter</a>, an Italian man compares the obituary sections in two editions of his local newspaper. The February 9 edition contains one and a half pages of obituaries. The March 13 edition contains ten full pages.</p><p>Europe no longer has the luxury of disbelief. In North America, we seem determined to hold on to it until the last possible moment — which is perhaps mere weeks or even days away. As Dr. Fabiano Di Marco, head of the respiratory unit of the Hospital Papa Giovanni XXIII in Bergamo, said in a recent episode of <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/17/podcasts/the-daily/italy-coronavirus.html?action=click&amp;module=audio-series-bar&amp;region=header&amp;pgtype=Article">The Daily</a> as he fought back tears: “I have some colleagues in other parts of Italy who are not prepared. They are doing the same thing we did three weeks ago. This is incredible. This new reality we are living in started on the 23rd of February. Fuck three years ago. After three weeks we are living in another dimension. For me, it is difficult to think about my life before this. No one can be prepared for this. Impossible.”</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normalcy_bias">Normalcy bias</a> is a significant driving force of this pandemic. Most people don’t want to believe that everything is going to change because it is too painful and scary to contemplate. Discovering the truth is also difficult and time-consuming, especially in a highly polarized and degraded media environment like ours. The average person’s beliefs about global issues typically don’t matter much. Except right now, there are few things more important to our collective future.</p><p>Today, we are rightly focused on improving people’s awareness of personal hygiene practices. We should bring the same focus to improving our collective <em>epistemic hygiene — </em>the<strong> </strong>processes we use to develop accurate beliefs and discard inaccurate beliefs, both personally and more broadly in society.</p><p>As we grapple with the consequences of widespread disbelief that continue even in a declared pandemic, I want to take a bit of time to examine how one person saw the possibility of COVID-19 going global early on.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/u/f5a2e83d6d8f">Balaji S. Srinivasan</a> was one of the first, clearest, and loudest voices on the Internet in North America to sound the alarm on COVID-19. Balaji is an angel investor, former CTO of Coinbase, and former General Partner at Andreesen Horowitz. He also founded a molecular diagnostics company and taught bioinformatics at Stanford where he holds a Ph.D. in Electrical Engineering.</p><p>Balaji started writing and tweeting about the virus back in <a href="https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1222921758375927808">late January</a> when it was still mostly confined to Wuhan. He seems to have written and tweeted about little else since then. At that time, he kicked off a lengthy tweet thread this way:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/895/1*PeWd779NhS3tn4RzSgfJig.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s hard to imagine from the vantage point of mid-March, but Balaji’s speculations were initially received in some corners of digital media as <a href="https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/danvergano/coronavirus-cases-deaths-flu?bftwnews&amp;utm_term=4ldqpgc#4ldqpgc">irresponsible alarmism</a> shaded with <a href="https://www.vox.com/recode/2020/2/13/21128209/coronavirus-fears-contagion-how-infection-spreads">anti-Asian xenophobia</a>. Many users on social media ridiculed what they saw as the overreach of cocky “tech bros” and VCs who thought they knew it all because they’d made some money in software. Now those speculations have become our shared unfolding reality.</p><p>In a recent conversation with Reason’s Nick Gillespie, Balaji briefly outlined the process by which he came to believe that the coronavirus would become a <em>history-altering pandemic</em>. I want to share Balaji’s process here with a bit of commentary because I think it is a clear account of how to identify weak signals of change in the informational environment and how to begin substantiating and extrapolating trends.</p><p>Gillespie’s first question to Srinivasan during their conversation — which you can watch in its entirety <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yLSKtUHUx7M&amp;t=609s">here</a> — was about how he came to learn about the coronavirus and why he was early in sounding the alarm.</p><p>Here is his full transcribed response, lightly edited for clarity:</p><blockquote>“I had been following the coronavirus out of my peripheral vision as one of many stories until I saw the lockdown on January 23rd. That was unprecedented. It was an unthinkable signal. The Chinese government is completely focused on economic development, so to quarantine millions of people — which would soon become hundreds of millions of people — that made me pay attention to what was going on.</blockquote><blockquote>And so I began talking to many friends of mine — Chinese engineers, entrepreneurs, angels, and the like — and the qualitative picture that I got from this was hair-raising. We’re talking videos and photos of people being blockaded in their apartments and dying on the street. Even one of a man throwing himself off a bridge because he couldn’t get to the hospital and he didn’t want to bring the virus home to his family.</blockquote><blockquote>I didn’t know what to believe from this. Some of it could be fake. But on the other hand, those images seemed fairly difficult to fake even with today’s technology and they seemed to match the general circumstances.</blockquote><blockquote>Even if some of them were true, these were sci-fi movie-level events happening in China. If I was too skeptical, I would remind myself that there was an officially acknowledged scale of the lockdown which was unprecedented and that was an independent reference point of ground truth that one could anchor on. I also have a background in bioinformatics, molecular diagnostics, genomics, and so on.</blockquote><blockquote>The third thing I did is I dug into the literature and read all these dispassionate medical reports. These kinds of articles in the New England Journal of Medicine and the Lancet are written in a style which is almost like the opposite of clickbait.</blockquote><blockquote>The first U.S. case study written up in NEJM said something like ‘thirty-five-year-old patient with no pre-existing conditions contracted bilateral pneumonia and by day ten we pursued compassionate use’. In English, that means ‘a healthy 35-year-old man was brought to death’s door and we needed an experimental drug to save his life’. I mean zero insult whatsoever toward folks writing these articles. That’s an accepted style. But when you translate them it’s eyebrow-raising. Here’s a healthy 35-year-old about to die and it took ten days and a team and an experimental drug to save him. And that was the first case in the U.S. That’s a contagious disease, so you start mapping that to not just one person but to ten people or a hundred people or a thousand people and that starts to get very expensive in terms of suffering and in terms of medical resources and so on.</blockquote><blockquote>So the combination of (A) China’s official state action, (B) unofficial social media reports from people in China and (C)articles in biomedical journals — that’s what made me triangulate on this early as something of potentially critical importance.”</blockquote><p>Let’s examine how Balaji thought about (A), (B), and (C) so that we can extract some practices and principles that everyone can adopt to improve their epistemic hygiene and, in turn, their ability to develop more accurate forecasts.</p><p><strong>(A) China’s official state action</strong></p><p>Balaji uses a ‘vision’ metaphor to explain the field of awareness in which he seeks signals of change. Practically speaking, this means consuming information on a wide range of topics across media spectra and not allowing ourselves to become too blinkered by our current area of focus. Simple enough. But consuming a broad diet of information is not enough. We also need to learn how to notice things and what’s worth noticing.</p><p>When news broke that China was <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2020/01/23/china/wuhan-coronavirus-update-intl-hnk/index.html">suspending all highway traffic and public transport</a> in three large cities in Hubei province it struck Balaji as immensely odd because the action ran against his strong <em>prior </em>conviction that the Chinese government was laser-focused on economic growth. Wuhan is the largest city in central China and the commercial, cultural, and transportation hub for the region. Shutting the city down could not be done without serious economic consequences for China.</p><p>A <em>prior </em>is a concept from probability theory that describes the beliefs we hold <em>before </em>receiving new information. Priors can be strong, weak, or something in between. Typically, the more evidence we have for our priors, the stronger they are.</p><p>If we are striving for accurate beliefs — which is the point of epistemic hygiene — the quality of the evidence we gather matters a great deal. It is possible to have strong priors based on very poor quality evidence. Someone who has earnestly watched thousands of hours of Flat Earth videos on YouTube has likely developed very strong priors that the Earth is flat; so strong that satellite images from space showing the Earth’s curvature do not put an appreciable dent in that prior.</p><p>Our <em>priors</em> are critically important when it comes to noticing change because to be surprised by new information we first need a good sense of <em>what we believe and why we believe it</em>. Priors help us to smartly process new evidence, so we ought to consume information not just to stay informed but to form strong beliefs and opinions that calibrate our ability to sense when things are changing.</p><p><strong>(B) Unofficial social media reports from people in China</strong></p><p>The next thing that Balaji does is explore his real-world and virtual social networks to get a sense of the reality unfolding on the ground in Hubei province.</p><p>I would venture that — from an epistemological perspective — Balaji is seeking what we might call <em>informational contrast</em>. Moving from state bulletins to social media posts allows him to examine the situation from two vantage points that are radically distinct from one another in tone and content.</p><p>The sources for the initial reportage on the shutdowns appear to be Chinese state media outlets and statements made by Chinese government officials. While in this case — given how unfavorable this news would be for China’s perception abroad — there may have been little reason to doubt the veracity of these sources, they still likely presented a sanitized view of the situation that leaned heavily on bare statement of fact and the language of objectivity.</p><p>Going to his social media feeds and whisper networks for information derived from experience, testimony, and good old-fashioned gossip would give him a better sense of the lives of the Wuhanese dealing with the reality or threat of COVID-19 infection during a city-wide quarantine.</p><p>These media sources and testimonies also furnished Balaji with a feel for the <em>affective features</em> (“the qualitative picture that I got from this was hair-raising”) of the facts he was learning. In strategic foresight, which I practice professionally, we employ storytelling and design techniques to create an imaginary encounter with the future which engages the affective components of our belief formation processes. Sometimes — as in the case of an emerging global pandemic — press reports, charts, figures, and graphs do not drive home the potential real-world impact of change. For that, we need stories, like the story of the man on the bridge.</p><p>We also should be mindful of how stories can lead us astray. Balaji understands that these types of networks often contain high-value information hidden among baseless speculations, insinuations, and outright falsehoods, and so he proceeds with a measure of skepticism. At the same time, his skepticism is tempered by the mind-bending nature of what he has already learned.</p><p>This tells us something important about the interplay of our beliefs, especially as it occurs across informational types. When immediate comprehension fails, we should weigh the pieces of evidence we’ve gathered against one another. We do our best to see the whole in light of its parts and vice versa, cycling through “big picture” and “street-level” information in an interpretive cycle.</p><p><strong>(C) Articles in biomedical journals</strong></p><p>Once Balaji felt he had a grasp of the official line and the reality on the ground in Wuhan, he turned to peer-reviewed medical journals to better understand the nature of the disease itself.</p><p>Generally, peer-reviewed papers published in prestigious journals are an oasis of high-quality information. Reading journal articles and other technical sources of information like patent filings and policy papers allow us to step out of the world of clickbait journalism and knee-jerk social media posts to further round out our knowledge base with dispassionate research which has been pre-vetted by experts in the author’s field.</p><p>Peer-reviewed journals are by far the most overlooked source of information in our epistemic practices. There are at least two reasons for this.</p><p>First, many of them are sitting behind paywalls that are prohibitively high for most people. But <a href="https://sci-hub.tw/">there’s no such thing</a> as a wall that can’t be scaled.</p><p>Second, the language of peer-reviewed journals is often prohibitively technical. Abstracts can help to demystify the details but sometimes even these summaries elude our understanding. Talking to experts in the field in question can help. When all else fails, try to render it in plain language for yourself as Balaji does in his response. In the retelling of his epistemic practice, it’s this plain language rendering that gives him the final pieces of the puzzle which lead him to the belief that a pandemic was likely to follow.</p><p>Because journal articles and other pieces of technical writing are written by professionals <em>for </em>professionals, the insights they contain often do not circulate outside of a niche profession or academic sub-discipline. Informed generalists with some ability to translate technical language into digestible takeaways for the laity provide a valuable public service in connecting the dots between mainstream media ecology and walled-gardens of institutional research.</p><p>Note that even with peer-reviewed journals, it is important to read widely and critically. Since so few people read studies in peer-reviewed journals, the mere existence of such a study can be used as <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2017/06/nejm-letter-opioids/528840/">an intellectual cudgel to silence dissenters and to create a veneer of respectability</a>. So we should keep our critical hackles up even when we’re consuming peer-reviewed information. If we do, there is enormous potential for the information hidden behind paywalled peer-reviewed journals and in other sources of technical writing to drastically improve our beliefs about the world.</p><p><strong>Final Thoughts</strong></p><p>If you’re like me, you might be wondering what it is that people who are going about their lives as if nothing is happening are seeing and hearing when they watch the news or browse social media. The only thing that could make the reality starker is for it to arrive — as it inevitably will and as it already has — on our doorstep.</p><p>Many of us are failing to take the necessary measures to contain COVID-19 on a personal level because the situation as it exists elsewhere simply defies belief. It exists as an abstraction mediated through phones, computers, and TVs. We don’t feel it as an imminent danger to ourselves and our loved ones.</p><p>The inertial tendencies of our minds are safeguarded by a phalanx of defenses: denial, deflection, ridicule, vitriol, self-deception, conspiratorial thinking, and so on. We fight against changing our minds because it often comes with real-world costs. Publicly admitting wrongs can be status-lowering; this is why politicians so rarely do it. It can damage the trust others invest in us. It can mean admitting to ourselves that we’ve made bad investments — with our time, money, passion, and so on — or that we might not be as smart as we think.</p><p>Having accurate beliefs about the future is no easy feat. The human faculty of foresight is not evenly distributed, but it seems at least somewhat trainable. Practicing a bit of epistemic hygiene can help.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d14db1205f26" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Their Future, Our Future: How strategic foresight is imperiled by ideology]]></title>
            <link>https://themeta.medium.com/their-future-our-future-how-strategic-foresight-is-imperiled-by-ideology-4ab7cdcfdb4?source=rss-6c3550e3c560------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4ab7cdcfdb4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[future]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ideology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[polarization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[foresight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[forecasting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jayar La Fontaine]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Jan 2020 23:46:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-14T23:46:44.683Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*KD9O6v15c4dhmi2a" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@killerfvith?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Alex wong</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><blockquote>The future is not the realization of our hopes and dreams, a warning to mend our ways, an adventure to inspire us, nor a romance to touch our hearts. The future is just another place in space-time. Its residents, like us, find their world mundane and morally ambiguous.</blockquote><blockquote>Robin Hanson</blockquote><p>Over the past several years, two independent research efforts have been making substantial contributions to our understanding of <em>how</em> and <em>why</em> humans think about the future, and how we might become better at identifying and training people to more accurately forecast it.</p><p>A small cottage industry of researchers from the biological and psychological sciences is trying to solve the puzzle of where the human ability to think about the future came from, and how much that ability impacts the future itself. Among the intriguing ideas coming out of this community is the <em>Janus Hypothesis, </em>which states that human memory evolved for the purposes of planning for the future rather than cataloguing the past <em>for it’s own sake</em>. In other words, humans have long-term memory so that we can remember the past and draw on its lessons to guide our future actions. “The past is totally irrelevant unless it impacts survival and fitness,” the psychologist Thomas Suddendorf — a key researcher in the areas of human and animal foresight — told me during an interview, “and from a fitness perspective what matters is foresight.” This is a provocative notion, since in the history of psychology its been memory — rather than prospection — that has long fascinated researchers.</p><p>The field also contains substantive disputes that directly challenge the use and limits of future thinking. Some researchers, like Suddendorf, believe that future thinking was a key factor in driving the evolution of human culture from small hunter-gatherer bands to the vast and interconnected nation states that exist today. Others, like psychologist Alex Mesoudi, argue that culture evolves quite apart from the intentions and wishes that humans might have for the future.</p><p>Quite a lot hangs on this, like whether the future of culture can be created through human intention or it lay outside the realm our meddling, like an itch in our collective experience that we can’t scratch. Anyone interested in how we think about the future and why foresight matters should be watching this developing field closely.</p><p>We’ve also been learning a lot about the skills that make up a good future thinker. The publication of <em>Superforecasting: The Art and Science of Prediction </em>marks a major milestone in social scientist Philip Tetlock’s decades-long project to understand why some people are better than others at making accurate predictions. In some ways, his findings are prosaic: great forecasters — or “superforecasters” as he dubs them — ensure they get a balanced media diet from sources that represent all points on the ideological spectrum, tend to be concerned with accuracy and fine-tuning rather than making grand proclamations, willingly adjust their confidence about their future claims when new information comes along, collaborate well with others, and are attuned to their own biases and knowledge blindspots.</p><p>What’s surprising, however, is <em>how</em> much better superforecasters are at predicting the future. During a CIA-sponsored forecasting tournament focused on geopolitics, Tetlock’s team of identified superforecasters performed 50–70% better than an average, un-weighted crowd of participants. They also substantially outperformed prediction markets staffed by professionals from the intelligence community itself, many of whom no doubt had very particular geopolitical domain knowledge and experience that the superforecasters lacked entirely. In other words, a keen, open-minded, non-partisan citizen doing Google searches may well be better at predicting the future of the Kim regime in North Korea or impending massacres in warlord-controlled African states than a seasoned intelligence sector veteran.</p><p>Together, these lines of research represent real progress in understanding the limits and possibilities of human future thinking. It’s an exciting time to be interested in human foresight.</p><p>You’d assume that the futurist community would be alive with buzz about the work of researchers like Suddendorf, Mesoudi, and Tetlock. And if futurists were genuinely interested in improving their ability to think clearly about the future and help others to do the same, I suspect you’d be right. But here’s how this research has really been received.</p><p>Other than a few voices in the wilderness, Tetlock’s work has been criticized, ridiculed, and ignored by professional futurists. Some painted his findings as representing a return to the notion of forecasting as a form of prophesying that doesn’t take seriously the sheer complexity of the modern world. Others — especially those whose forecasts tend to stretch a decade or further into the future — blanched at Tetlock’s claim that even the abilities of highly skilled superforecasters were ineffective for timelines longer than eighteen months, and insisted that his methods drastically restricted the human imagination.</p><p>Things get even more puzzling in the case of Thomas Suddendorf’s work on the evolution of human foresight. During our conversation, Suddendorf was surprised to find out that that the discipline of strategic foresight existed <em>at all</em>. It was alarming to me that I could be the first member of my profession to reach out to one of the leading researchers who was scientifically investigating the very skill in which we claimed superior ability and expertise.</p><p>You might find these receptions puzzling, but as someone familiar with the professional milieu of futurists I can tell you that none of this is surprising. The mantra of the modern futurist is that the future is simply unpredictable — moreover, that it is somehow more unpredictable today than it was yesterday — and therefore the only reasonable course of action is to tell stories of multiple futures and develop strategies that somehow function well in each, which is just what they claim to do.</p><p>The main controversy within the world of futurists over the past several years has therefore not been over whether their methodology is actually <em>effective</em> for making consistently good predictions about the future, but rather over <em>what types of stories get told</em> and <em>who gets to tell them</em>.</p><p>This battle is being waged between two broad groups of futurists: what I’ll call <em>classical futurists</em>, who tend to be older, whiter, and more male, and whose view of the future tends to turn on supra-personal domains like technology, economics, and geopolitics, and <em>critical futurists, </em>who tend to be younger, hipper, artier, and more diverse, and whose view of the future tends to turn on human-centric domains like culture, values, and social movements. Allow me to issue a status report on this tempestuous teapot: the critical futurists are either gaining ground or supplanting classical futurists, depending on where you look or who you ask. The classical futurist’s preoccupation with technological innovation, the fruits of entrepreneurship, and continued economic growth are increasingly seen as stodgy, myopic, dated, and politically conservative in outlook in contrast with the critical futurist’s focus on understanding and articulating futures that have at their heart a vision of social justice, environmental and economic sustainability, and widespread cultural change in keeping with the generally progressive worldview that defines public intellectual discourse among young, educated, city-dwelling professionals.</p><p>I recently had a conversation with a well-known futurist about why it seemed that <em>critical</em> <em>futures</em> was becoming an essential tool in the business world. Her perspective was that as the gender balance among managers and directors tilts for the first time toward women, management styles are moving away from tech-driven, trend-focused futures preferred by men in leadership positions and toward futures built around broadened cultural awareness, empathetic listening methods, and collaborative, creative visioning preferred by women.</p><p>If my colleague is right, then something like the critical futures perspective will likely be in the mental toolkit industry leaders for years to come. To which I say: <em>great, but so what? </em>It doesn’t much matter what domains you explore, whose voices you include, or which political vision you articulate if — as is the case with classical and critical futurists alike — you’re not really serious about doing good future thinking in the first place and would rather tell a ripping good yarn about how your team wins and everything is great or they lose and everything is terrible.</p><p>There are professionals that are serious about future thinking. They’re just not futurists, mostly. Those bores who make a living exploring how the future might plausibly turn out — actuaries, forecasters, statisticians, and so on — are keenly professionally interested in how their forecasts map to the eventual reality, and are obliged to discard their models of the future should they fall short. That’s how the predictive power of forecasting models improves: error by error</p><p>Futurists, on the other hand, often exhibit the opposite tendency; they are keen to <em>think</em> about the future in its <em>un-arrived</em> state, but care less about how things turn out <em>in fact</em> because the reality is often far less interesting and frustrates their expectations. “Futurists as a subculture seem to organize their lives as future-experience theaters,” Venkatesh Rao wrote on his blog Ribbonfarm, ”these theaters are perhaps entertaining and interesting in their own right, as a sort of performance art, but are not of much interest or value to people who are interested in the future in the form it might arrive in, for all.”</p><p>When unmoored from quantitative methods, investigations of the future come to reflect the personal sensibilities and political sympathies of futurists rather than the comparatively drab facts of the matter that actually shape the future. A futurist’s secret wish is that the world comes to resemble the one in their imaginations rather than, as the historian Arthur Toynbee characterized everyday life, the march of “just one damned thing after another.” Unfortunately for them, the future doesn’t care what we think or want.</p><p>For classical and critical futurists alike, much of the furniture of the universe — from brute probabilistic facts and statistical realities on through to our evolved human nature — is reduced to kindling. Strategic foresight as its practiced today represents a drift away from the centuries-long project to improve our ability to ascertain the nature of risk in an honest and rigorous way. The disciplines of quantitative forecasting and risk analysis ought to keep futurists in check; without their guidance the project of imagining the future in good faith is replaced with “art-piece” futures, hamstrung by ideology and marred by blind spots.</p><p>This form of “future art” has nothing to do with sound future thinking. Art is often a means of expressing a yearning or dread for a world to come, but it can tell us little about the way the world will be <em>in fact</em> in any kind of reliable way. An artist’s statement of intent at least labels his or her art as an expression of their personal perspective; the scenarios and artefacts of both classical and critical futurists carry no such disclaimer. It doesn’t matter if your future has jetpacks or post-genderism if both are nothing more than artistic wish fulfillment.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4ab7cdcfdb4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>