<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by George M. Garcia on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by George M. Garcia on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@theopneustos-writer?source=rss-446f9887eae0------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 13:31:41 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@theopneustos-writer/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Apologia for Gregory Thaumaturgus]]></title>
            <link>https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/apologia-for-gregory-thaumaturgus-bf5e6b7ec96e?source=rss-446f9887eae0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bf5e6b7ec96e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[orígen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-testament]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patristic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apologia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trinity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[George M. Garcia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Nov 2024 03:46:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-18T04:24:55.885Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Responding to COG Writer’s Fanciful Objections</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/125/1*YPiDnO346qcV-MMr8VTfgQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><h4>Source</h4><ul><li><a href="https://www.cogwriter.com/news/church-history/gregory-thaumaturgus-was-affected-by-demons-and-changed-greco-roman-church-doctrine/">Gregory Thaumaturgus was affected by demons and changed Greco-Roman church doctrine - Church of God News</a></li></ul><h4>Introduction</h4><p>In the great words of Gregory, <strong><em>“neither in that period have I heard any other compose or utter anything in private, or deliver in public any laudatory or controversial orations, with the exception of those admirable men who have embraced the noble study of philosophy, and who care less for beauty of language and elegance of expression. For, attaching only a secondary importance to the words, they aim, with all exactness, at investigating and making known the things themselves, precisely as they are severally constituted”</em></strong> (<strong>Oration to Origen Argument 1</strong>). In like manner to this address and in my experience of Gregory, I too feel that Gregory, a disciple of Origen, is one of these admirable men who pursue truth at the expense of being fixated on mere words, and even rhetorical polemics. I have read both the undisputed and disputed writings of Gregory that renders me convinced of his apostolic succession, philosophical radiance, and mystical authority. In my time with reading about this man, and reading his works of wisdom and education, I cannot deem him any less than apostolic inspiration; in fact, I have read certain things from his literature that have reflected my views, whether in part or in totality.</p><p>However, whether Gregory’s profile is extremely awesome or not, there will always be pawns of the Devil, or un-Christlike cynics that throw mud in the face of goodness and truth. While it is not wrong to be skeptical, it is not in synonymity with being radically prejudiced or even cynical. A skeptic is someone who questions without doubting, and a cynic is someone who doubts without questioning. In my intentional search for Gregory Thuamaturgus (aka the Wonderworker), I came across a YT video that denounced this great man, and even slandered him as a satanic prophet, because of their radical dogmatism, misguided eschatological views, and their misuse of Pauline literature. I chose to ignore it and move on from such an offensive take; however, I came across a website that slandered this great man as well. Because of this double occurrence and my love for Gregorius, I decided to respond to whatever nonsense or ill informed rhetoric was propagated as truth. And surely, the ill informed rhetoric did not come to surprise me when I read it in-depth. It is a shame that these kinds of Christians exist and have nothing better to do but to slander other denominations over one great man, and assert their own as having apostolic dominance — though a delusion — to reaffirm their faith against good principle. I present to you my review of their ill informed website.</p><h4>Marian Vision &amp; the Trinity</h4><p>The writer behind this blog has a certain prejudice against Marian apparitions due to its similarity with their research of Fatima, which doesn’t demonstrate on whether the apparition is demonic or not. The blog makes accusations such as: <em>“Gregory was also a factor in the Marian cults that began to rise up around that time. His writings teach praise and excessive devotion to the ‘Holy Virgin,’ including the blasphemous teaching that Mary ‘blotted out’ Eve’s ‘transgressions’.” </em>First of all, when the blogger says “his writings”, he likely means the homilies which are disputed writings. Second, homilies tend to employ rhetorical language, which appears in the homilies as being reverent and even excessive. Lastly, Mary, assuming you believe in the virgin birth, is the main reason why Christ, the Incarnate Word, was able to deliver evildoers from their sins. If I am being honest, I did not find this reference of Mary blotting out Eve’s transgressions since the blogger doesn’t cite their sources well. The same blogger then addresses one of the homilies: <em>“The Bible does not teach that Mary led an “incorruptible life.” The Bible teaches that all have sinned (Romans 3:23), except Jesus (Hebrews 4:14–15).” </em>Again, the author of the Homily is employing excessive and non-literal language, as is evidenced here: <strong><em>“For she was called Mary, and that, by interpretation, means illumination. And what shines more brightly than the light of virginity?”</em></strong> (<strong>Second Homily</strong>). Does Pontic Gregory actually think there’s actual light from her virginity? Of course not! And Gregory calls her an <em>“ever-blooming paradise of incorruptibility,”</em> because he explains that she is <em>“the ever-flowing fountain, wherein the water of life sprang and produced the Lord’s incarnate manifestation”</em>. In other words, she is the vehicle to which the Incarnate Word came from; that is not to say that He did not exist prior to Mary (<em>cf. John 1:1</em>).</p><p>The writer also assumes that the doctrine of the Trinity was derived from Gregory’s vision of Mary and John; however, Gregory expressed Trinitarian notions before said event: “<strong><em>For as He is Himself the Truth, and the Wisdom, and the Power of the Father of the universe, and He is besides in Him, and is truly and entirely made one with Him, it cannot be that, either through forgetfulness or unwisdom, or any manner of infirmity, such as marks one dissociated from Him, He shall either fail in the power to praise Him, or, while having the power, shall willingly neglect (a supposition which it is not lawful, surely, to indulge) to praise the Father. For He alone is able most perfectly to fulfil the whole meed of honor which is proper to Him, inasmuch as the Father of all things has made Him one with Himself, and through Him all but completes the circle of His own being objectively, and honours Him with a power in all respects equal to His own, even as also He is honoured; which position He first and alone of all creatures that exist has had assigned Him, this Only-begotten of the Father, who is in Him, and who is God the Word” </em>(Oration to Origen 4). </strong>The blogger<strong> </strong>says that the Bible does not teach a “holy Trinity”; however, this is based on the assumption of what the Bible does and doesn’t teach. The Bible may not explicitly teach the Trinity, but the Trinity has an inferred, “phantom” presence in the New Testament, unlike the dogma of inerrancy, which is neither taught nor inferred in the New Testament scriptures, especially when Paul taught that the mosaic customs were human traditions and principles of the world, and Hebrews argues that the old covenant was not without error, yet its regulations were in need of reform, meaning there were indeed errors (<em>cf. Colossians 2:14–22; Hebrews 8:6–7; 9:6–10</em>). <a href="https://medium.com/@theopneustos-writer/christ-and-the-law-n%CE%BF%CE%BC%CE%BF%CF%82-867f2c672ef1"><strong>Before anyone attempts to doubt the scriptural citations, I explain in detail why Paul did not believe in textual inerrancy here (as was custom in the Early Church).</strong></a></p><h4>Paganism &amp; Immortal Soul</h4><p>It seems this blogger doesn’t seem to fathom that Christianity was always Hellenistic, even since its emergence among Jesus, Paul, and the apostles. Christianity is not a monolithic continuation of mosaic Judaism, but it is a refined amalgamation of ideas; Paul quoted the Greek poets <em>(e.g. Acts 17:28, 1 Corinthians 15:33, &amp; Titus 1:12)</em>, reinterpreted Hebrew scripture via Hellenistic allegory <em>(e.g. 1 Corinthians 9:9–10, Galatians 3:16, &amp; 4:21–25)</em>, and held an ontological distinction between soul and spirit <em>(cf. 1st Thessalonians 5:23).</em> 2nd Peter 2:4 taught the concept of Tartarus, which is a Greek concept, and Jude appeals to Jewish books composed during the Hellenistic period <em>(cf. 1:9, 14–15)</em>. And Paul and Hebrews use Platonic language when they say the law is a shadow of good things, that is, the realities themselves <em>(cf. Colossians 2:16–17; Hebrews 10:1)</em>. So then, simply rendering Gregory as some defiled pagan that corrupted the apostolic churches is nothing more than wishful ignorance fueled by deluded prejudice against apostolic denominations, and fueled by a pathological relationship with the Bible.</p><p>The blogger then cites a work dubiously attributed to Pontic Gregory, which is called “On the Soul”. While it is possible that Gregory held that the soul is ontologically immortal, this does not mean that such a teaching is anti-scriptural as there are certain passages that infer it, and would make no sense if it did not. In 1st Peter 4:6, Jesus preaches the gospel to the dead, which is not feasible if there are no conscious souls to perceive the message. Some might dispute with the meaning of “dead”, but the passage states: <strong><em>“For this reason the gospel was preached also to those who are dead, that they might be judged akin to [kata] men in the flesh, but live akin to [kata] God in the spirit.” </em></strong>The author of 1st Peter distinguishes between those who are alive <em>(i.e. men in the flesh)</em> and those who are dead, which renders the non-literal usage of “dead” unlikely (if not impossible). The souls in Hades cannot be judged like men in the flesh if they cannot perceive the Gospel message. In another passage, Paul says in Philippians 2:10–11:<strong><em> “Therefore God exalted Him to the highest place and gave Him the name above all names, that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth, and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord…,”</em></strong> which means that those who are under the earth <em>(i.e. an allusion to Hades)</em> are in reference to conscious souls. But some might dispute that this could be in reference to demonic spirits, so in another passage, Paul confirms, <strong><em>“Therefore it says, ‘When he ascended on high he led a host of captives, and he gave gifts to men.” In saying, “He ascended,” what does it mean but that he had also descended into the lower regions, the earth”</em></strong> <strong>(Ephesians 4:8–9)</strong>. In Paul’s reinterpretation of the psalm, he infers that Christ traversed <em>“under the earth”</em> to liberate imprisoned spirits, who are the conscious souls ensnared in Hades. 1st Peter 3:19–20 also confirms a similar teaching that Christ went to make proclamation to the imprisoned spirits. In a final attempt for the blogger to refute the ontological immortality of the soul, the book of Ezekiel is quoted where it says <em>“the soul that sins will die”</em>. However, the term ‘Nephesh’ in Hebrew, often translated as ‘soul’, actually means ‘person’. The concept of an immortal soul is a later concept expressed in the parable of Jesus, the author of 1st Peter, and Paul himself. The author of Ezekiel had no concept of the soul losing its continuance after death, nor is this teaching relevant today concerning Christian doctrine since the fate of humans in Ezekiel is physical death, not an eternal hell or total annihilation of being.</p><h4>The Lawless Man &amp; Ecclesiastical Authority</h4><p>The blogger then attributes to Gregory the label of the lawless man found in 2nd Thessalonians, which is a dubious claim. The prophecy of the lawless man, assuming Paul wrote this, was likely the Roman Emperor who defiled and desolated the Jewish Temple. Our Lord said that we will do greater works even than Himself, and rebuked the Pharisees for accusing Him of doing demonic miracles, which is very reminiscent of the blogger accusing Gregory of demonic miracles <em>(cf. John 14:12 &amp; Matthew 12:24–26)</em>. This blogger claims to follow the Scriptures, and yet, commits the same sin of the Pharisees. Biblicists are filled with nothing but irony. If the Early Church could not preserve the teachings of the apostles past the second century, but were unanimously or predominantly in error, and if the great figures of the Church were demonically inspired, then there is no reason to believe that the Holy Spirit ever guided the Church, but rather He failed to guide from antiquity to modernity; thus, Christianity is a greater failure than any other religion if this blogger’s estimate were to be hypothetically factual, even if the Bible is supposedly inerrant since Christians today cannot even agree on the age of the earth, the continuation of the charisms, the deity of Christ, the structure of an ecclesia, the meaning of the Passion of Christ, and even the eschatological view of the apostles.</p><p>I would rather not quote in detail what the blogger has said, as it can be a bit redundant. Instead, I am merely responding to certain themes and objections that the blogger is spouting arbitrarily due to prejudice against certain dogmas. But I would like to end this post with certain passages from the patristic writers concerning their praise of Gregory:</p><blockquote>“All hail to you in God, most excellent and reverend Sir, son Gregory, from Origen. A natural quickness of understanding is fitted, as you are well aware, if it be diligently exercised, to produce a work which may bring its owner so far as is possible, if I may so express myself, to the consummation of the art the which he desires to practice, and your natural aptitude is sufficient to make you a consummate Roman lawyer and a Greek philosopher too of the most famous schools” (Origen to Gregory).</blockquote><blockquote>“But where shall I rank the great Gregory, and the words uttered by him? Shall we not place among Apostles and Prophets a man who walked by the same Spirit as they; [ 2 Corinthians 12:18 ] who never through all his days diverged from the footprints of the saints; who maintained, as long as he lived, the exact principles of evangelical citizenship?…Thus not a practice, not a word, not a mystic rite has been added to the Church besides what he bequeathed to it” (On the Holy Spirit 29 by St. Basil the Great).</blockquote><blockquote>“Gregory, Bishop of Pontus, was first in the world in philosophy and outstanding in eloquence; but afterwards greater and more outstanding in his miracles, to the extent that — as the faith of our history relates — among the other signs of his extraordinary merits, through his prayers and supplications a mountain is said to have moved and a lake to have dried up” (On contempt for the world and secular philosophy, lines 371–377 by Eucherius of Lyons).</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bf5e6b7ec96e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My Short Treatise #1]]></title>
            <link>https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/my-short-treatise-1-b390cfb78583?source=rss-446f9887eae0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b390cfb78583</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[anthropology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christian]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theosis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[treatise]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[George M. Garcia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Apr 2024 22:53:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-07T23:33:16.763Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>On Anthropos &amp; Theotetos</h4><h4>Preface (Sans Serif)</h4><p><strong>𝖨𝗍 𝗁𝖺𝗌 𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝗆𝗒 𝖺𝗍𝗍𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗒 𝖻𝖾𝗅𝗂𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗋𝗌 𝖺𝗋𝖾 𝗆𝗂𝗌𝗎𝗇𝖽𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗍𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝗈𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝗎𝖻𝗃𝖾𝖼𝗍 𝗈𝖿 𝖺𝗇𝗍𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗉𝗈𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗒 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁 𝗂𝗍𝗌 𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗅 𝗂𝗆𝗉𝗅𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇𝗌 𝗈𝗇 𝗌𝗈𝗍𝖾𝗋𝗂𝗈𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗒, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗐𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗂𝗌 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝗂𝗇 𝗋𝖾𝗅𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝗍𝗈 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗆𝖺𝗇. 𝖬𝖺𝗒 𝗆𝗒 𝗍𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗌𝖾 𝗌𝖾𝗋𝗏𝖾 𝖺𝗌 𝖺 𝗆𝖾𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝗍𝗈 𝖾𝖽𝗂𝖿𝗒 𝗒𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝗆𝗂𝗇𝖽 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗉𝗎𝗋𝗀𝖾 𝗒𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝗆𝗂𝗇𝖽 𝗈𝖿 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗒 𝗆𝗂𝗌𝖼𝗈𝗇𝖼𝖾𝗉𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗆𝖺𝗇. 𝖯𝖾𝗋𝗆𝗂𝗍 𝗆𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝖽𝖾𝖺𝗅 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁 𝖾𝖺𝖼𝗁 𝗌𝗎𝖻𝗃𝖾𝖼𝗍 𝖻𝗋𝗂𝖾𝖿𝗅𝗒 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒.</strong></p><h4>Chapter One: Good God, Chaos Theory, &amp; the Aggressor</h4><p><strong>[1] 𝖨𝗇 𝗈𝗋𝖽𝖾𝗋 𝗍𝗈 𝗎𝗇𝖽𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗄𝗂𝗇𝖽 𝗈𝗋 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗄𝗂𝗇𝖽, 𝗐𝖾 𝗆𝗎𝗌𝗍 𝗏𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾 𝖿𝗈𝗋𝗍𝗁 𝗂𝗇 𝗎𝗇𝖽𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖽𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗐𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝖼𝖺𝗎𝗌𝖾𝖽 𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝖾𝗑𝗂𝗌𝗍𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗂𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖻𝖾𝗀𝗂𝗇𝗇𝗂𝗇𝗀; 𝖿𝗈𝗋 𝗂𝖿 𝗐𝖾 𝗐𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝖻𝖾𝗀𝗈𝗍𝗍𝖾𝗇 𝖻𝗒 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝗈𝖽, 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾 𝗂𝗌 𝖼𝗈𝗆𝗉𝗋𝗂𝗌𝖾𝖽 𝗈𝖿 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝖺𝗍𝗍𝗋𝗂𝖻𝗎𝗍𝖾𝗌, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗂𝖿 𝖻𝗒 𝖺𝗇 𝖾𝗏𝗂𝗅 𝖽𝖾𝗂𝗍𝗒, 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝗐𝖾 𝖺𝗋𝖾 𝗌𝗎𝖻𝗃𝖾𝖼𝗍𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝖺𝗅𝗍𝖾𝗋𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗏𝖾 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾. 𝖨𝗍 𝗂𝗌 𝗌𝖺𝗂𝖽, 𝖾𝗌𝗉𝖾𝖼𝗂𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒 𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝖻𝖾𝗅𝗂𝖾𝖿 𝗂𝗇 𝖺 𝖦𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝖦𝗈𝖽, 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗐𝗈𝗋𝗅𝖽 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖽𝖾𝖼𝗅𝖺𝗋𝖾𝖽 𝗂𝗍 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝖺𝖼𝖼𝗈𝗋𝖽𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗍𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝗎𝗍𝗁𝗈𝗋 𝗈𝖿 𝖦𝖾𝗇𝖾𝗌𝗂𝗌 (𝗂𝖻𝗂𝖽. 𝟣:𝟥𝟣). 𝖳𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗂𝗇𝖽𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗍𝖾𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗇𝗈𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗂𝗌 𝗈𝗎𝗍𝗌𝗂𝖽𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝖦𝗈𝖽’𝗌 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝗈𝗋𝗂𝖾𝗇𝗍𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇; 𝗁𝗈𝗐𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗋, 𝗐𝖾 𝗆𝗎𝗌𝗍 𝗂𝗇𝗊𝗎𝗂𝗋𝖾 𝗈𝗇 𝗁𝗈𝗐 𝗌𝗂𝗇 𝗈𝗋 𝖾𝗏𝗂𝗅 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝖺𝗆𝖾 𝖺 𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗅𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝗂𝗇 𝖻𝗈𝗍𝗁 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝗇𝗀𝖾𝗅𝗌 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝗋𝖺𝖼𝖾. 𝖤𝗏𝗂𝗅 𝖼𝖺𝗇𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖾𝗑𝗂𝗌𝗍 𝗂𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝗆𝖾𝗋𝖾𝗅𝗒 𝖾𝗑𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗌, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗂𝖿 𝗐𝖾 𝖺𝗋𝖾 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝗈𝖽, 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝗌𝗂𝗇 𝗌𝗁𝗈𝗎𝗅𝖽 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖾𝗑𝗂𝗌𝗍 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗂𝗍 𝗅𝖺𝖼𝗄𝗌 𝗌𝗎𝖻𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖼𝖾, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 “𝗂𝗍 𝖾𝗑𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗌” 𝗌𝖺𝗒𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝗀𝗀𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗌𝗈𝗋.</strong></p><p><strong>[𝟤] 𝖲𝗂𝗇 𝗂𝗌 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗆𝖾𝗋𝖾𝗅𝗒 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝖻𝗌𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝗈𝖽, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗋𝖺𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝗂𝗍 𝗂𝗌 𝖺 𝖿𝗈𝗋𝗆 𝗈𝖿 𝖼𝗁𝖺𝗈𝗌; 𝗂𝗍 𝖼𝖺𝗇 𝗈𝗇𝗅𝗒 𝖾𝗑𝗂𝗌𝗍 𝗂𝗇 𝖺 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗌𝗂𝖻𝗅𝖾 𝗎𝗇𝗂𝗏𝖾𝗋𝗌𝖾, 𝗈𝗋 𝗐𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗐𝖾 𝖼𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝖺 “𝗌𝗒𝗌𝗍𝖾𝗆”. 𝖲𝗂𝗇 𝗂𝗌 𝗐𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝖼𝗈𝗆𝗉𝗈𝗇𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗎𝗇𝗂𝗏𝖾𝗋𝗌𝖾 𝖺𝗋𝖾 𝖽𝖾𝗍𝖺𝖼𝗁𝖾𝖽 𝖿𝗋𝗈𝗆 𝖾𝖺𝖼𝗁 𝗈𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖽𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗈𝗋𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝖺𝗀𝖺𝗂𝗇𝗌𝗍 𝗂𝗍𝗌 𝗈𝗋𝗂𝗀𝗂𝗇𝖺𝗅 𝗉𝗎𝗋𝗉𝗈𝗌𝖾; 𝖿𝗈𝗋 𝗂𝗇𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖼𝖾, 𝗐𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗐𝗂𝗅𝗅 𝗈𝖿 𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝗂𝗌 𝖺𝗂𝗆𝖾𝖽 𝗈𝗎𝗍𝗌𝗂𝖽𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗆𝗈𝗋𝖺𝗅 𝗀𝗋𝖺𝖼𝖾 𝗈𝗋 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗉𝗋𝗈𝗏𝗂𝗌𝗂𝗈𝗇, 𝗂𝗍 𝖺𝖼𝗍𝗌 𝖺𝖼𝖼𝗈𝗋𝖽𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗍𝗈 𝗆𝖺𝗅𝗂𝖼𝖾 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗂𝗅𝗅𝗎𝗌𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝗈𝖿 𝗐𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗂𝗍 𝗉𝖾𝗋𝖼𝖾𝗂𝗏𝖾𝗌 𝖺𝗌 “𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽”. “𝖡𝗎𝗍 𝗐𝗁𝗒,” 𝗌𝖺𝗒𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝗀𝗀𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗌𝗈𝗋, “𝗂𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗐𝗂𝗅𝗅 𝗈𝖿 𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝗌𝗎𝖻𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖣𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾? 𝖥𝗈𝗋 𝗌𝗎𝗋𝖾𝗅𝗒, 𝗂𝖿 𝗂𝗍 𝗐𝖾𝗋𝖾, 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝗇𝗈 𝖾𝗏𝗂𝗅 𝗐𝗈𝗎𝗅𝖽 𝖻𝖾 𝗉𝗈𝗌𝗌𝗂𝖻𝗅𝖾.” 𝖨 𝖺𝖽𝖽𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗐𝖾 𝖺𝗋𝖾 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽, 𝗌𝗈 𝖺𝗌 𝗅𝗈𝗇𝗀 𝖺𝗌 𝗐𝖾 𝗐𝗈𝗋𝗄 𝖺𝗌 𝗂𝗇𝗍𝖾𝗇𝖽𝖾𝖽 𝖻𝗒 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖣𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝖺𝗀𝖾𝗇𝖼𝗒, 𝗐𝗁𝗂𝖼𝗁 𝗆𝖾𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝗐𝖾 𝖺𝗋𝖾 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝗍𝖾𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗈𝗇𝗍𝗈𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒 — 𝗈𝗇𝗅𝗒 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝗌𝗎𝖼𝗁. 𝖡𝗎𝗍 𝗍𝗈 𝖺𝖽𝖽𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝖺𝗀𝗀𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗌𝗈𝗋, 𝗂𝖿 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝗎𝗌 𝗈𝗇𝗍𝗈𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽, 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝗐𝖾 𝗐𝗈𝗎𝗅𝖽 𝗁𝖺𝗏𝖾 𝗇𝗈 𝗉𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗈𝗇𝗁𝗈𝗈𝖽, 𝗇𝗈𝗋 𝖼𝖺𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗎𝗅𝗍𝗂𝗆𝖺𝗍𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝖻𝖾 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝖺𝗀𝖺𝗂𝗇. 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗁𝖺𝗌 𝗇𝗈 𝗇𝖾𝖾𝖽 𝗈𝖿 𝖺𝗇𝗈𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗂𝗍𝗒, 𝗐𝗁𝗂𝖼𝗁 𝗂𝗌 𝖾𝗌𝗌𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗂𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒 𝖧𝗂𝗆𝗌𝖾𝗅𝖿 𝖺𝗀𝖺𝗂𝗇. 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝖺𝗌 𝗂𝗇𝖼𝗈𝗆𝗉𝗅𝖾𝗍𝖾 𝗂𝗆𝗂𝗍𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖣𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾, 𝗐𝗁𝗂𝖼𝗁 𝗂𝗌 𝗐𝗁𝗒 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗒 𝖽𝖾𝗉𝖺𝗋𝗍 𝖿𝗋𝗈𝗆 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝗈𝖽. “𝖡𝗎𝗍,” 𝗌𝖺𝗒𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝗀𝗀𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗌𝗈𝗋, “𝗂𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖣𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖼𝗈𝗆𝗉𝗋𝗂𝗌𝖾𝖽 𝗈𝖿 𝗉𝖺𝗋𝗍𝗌, 𝗐𝗁𝗂𝖼𝗁 𝗆𝖾𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝖧𝖾 𝗂𝗌 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖺𝖻𝗈𝗏𝖾 𝗇𝗈𝗋 𝗂𝗆𝗆𝗎𝗇𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝗌𝗂𝗇 𝗈𝗋 𝖼𝗁𝖺𝗈𝗌?”</strong></p><p><strong>[𝟥] 𝖨𝗇 𝗆𝗒 𝖿𝗂𝗇𝖺𝗅 𝗋𝖾𝖻𝗎𝗍𝗍𝖺𝗅 𝖺𝗀𝖺𝗂𝗇𝗌𝗍 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝖺𝗀𝗀𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗌𝗈𝗋, 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖣𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗂𝗌 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖼𝗈𝗆𝗉𝗋𝗂𝗌𝖾𝖽 𝗈𝖿 𝗉𝖺𝗋𝗍𝗌, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗉𝖾𝗋𝖿𝖾𝖼𝗍𝗅𝗒 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗂𝗇𝖿𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗍𝖾𝗅𝗒 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗀𝗎𝗅𝖺𝗋. 𝖠𝗌 𝖨 𝗁𝖺𝗏𝖾 𝗌𝖺𝗂𝖽, 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝗐𝗈𝗋𝗅𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝖺 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗌𝗂𝖻𝗅𝖾 𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗂𝗍𝗒, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝖺𝗌 𝖺𝗇 𝗂𝗆𝗉𝖾𝗋𝖿𝖾𝖼𝗍 𝗂𝗆𝗂𝗍𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖣𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾, 𝗐𝗁𝗂𝖼𝗁 𝗆𝖾𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝗈𝗇𝗅𝗒 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗀𝗎𝗅𝖺𝗋 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗌𝗂𝖻𝗅𝖾 𝖺𝗌 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇. 𝖳𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝖽𝖾𝗆𝗈𝗇𝗌𝗍𝗋𝖺𝗍𝖾𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝗇𝖾𝗂𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝖺𝗇 𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝗐𝗁𝗈 𝗂𝗌 𝗌𝖾𝗉𝖺𝗋𝖺𝖻𝗅𝖾 𝖿𝗋𝗈𝗆 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝗌𝗎𝖻𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖼𝖾, 𝗇𝗈𝗋 𝖺𝗇 𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝖿𝗅𝗂𝖼𝗍𝗌 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁 𝖧𝗂𝗆𝗌𝖾𝗅𝖿. 𝖶𝗁𝗂𝗅𝖾 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝗀𝗀𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗌𝗈𝗋 𝗆𝖺𝗒 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖻𝖾 𝗌𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗌𝖿𝗂𝖾𝖽 𝗂𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗌𝖾 𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗉𝗈𝗇𝗌𝖾𝗌, 𝖨 𝖺𝗆 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗈𝖻𝗅𝗂𝗀𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗈 𝗉𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗎𝖺𝖽𝖾 𝗁𝗂𝗆 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝖺𝗋𝗀𝗎𝗆𝖾𝗇𝗍𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇.</strong></p><h4>Chapter 2: Apologia for Humans &amp; Restoring Proper Exegesis</h4><p><strong>[𝟣] 𝖭𝗈𝗐 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝖨 𝗁𝖺𝗏𝖾 𝖽𝖾𝗆𝗈𝗇𝗌𝗍𝗋𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝖺𝗋𝖾 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝗍𝖾𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗈𝗇𝗍𝗈𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗐𝗁𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝗌𝗂𝗇 𝖺𝗋𝗂𝗌𝖾𝗌, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗁𝗈𝗐 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝗂𝗆𝗆𝗎𝗇𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝖾𝗏𝗂𝗅, 𝗅𝖾𝗍 𝗆𝖾 𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗉𝗈𝗇𝖽 𝗍𝗈 𝖼𝖾𝗋𝗍𝖺𝗂𝗇 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝗐𝗁𝗈 𝖺𝗋𝖾 𝗌𝗎𝗋𝖾𝗅𝗒 𝗆𝗂𝗌𝗀𝗎𝗂𝖽𝖾𝖽 𝗈𝗇 𝗐𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝗉𝗈𝗌𝗍𝗈𝗅𝗂𝖼 𝗌𝖼𝗋𝗂𝗉𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾𝗌 𝗌𝖺𝗒. 𝖳𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝗉𝗈𝗌𝗍𝗅𝖾 𝖯𝖺𝗎𝗅 𝗌𝖺𝗒𝗌 𝗂𝗇 𝖱𝗈𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖿𝗈𝗅𝗅𝗈𝗐𝗂𝗇𝗀: <em>“𝖳𝗁𝖾𝗋𝖾𝖿𝗈𝗋𝖾 𝖺𝗌 𝗌𝗂𝗇 𝖾𝗇𝗍𝖾𝗋𝖾𝖽 𝗂𝗇𝗍𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗐𝗈𝗋𝗅𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗎𝗀𝗁 𝗈𝗇𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖽𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗁 𝗍𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗎𝗀𝗁 𝗌𝗂𝗇, 𝗌𝗈 𝖽𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗁 𝗉𝖺𝗌𝗌𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗈 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗆𝖾𝗇, 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝖺𝗎𝗌𝖾 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗇𝖾𝖽”</em> (𝗂𝖻𝗂𝖽. 𝟧:𝟣𝟤). 𝖲𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝖺𝗋𝗀𝗎𝖾 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗐𝖾 𝗁𝖺𝗏𝖾 𝗂𝗇𝗁𝖾𝗋𝗂𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝗌𝗂𝗇 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗀𝗎𝗂𝗅𝗍 𝗈𝖿 𝖺𝗇𝗈𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋’𝗌 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗌 𝖻𝗒 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗂𝗌 𝗌𝗁𝖾𝖾𝗋 𝗇𝗈𝗇𝗌𝖾𝗇𝗌𝖾! 𝖶𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝖽 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗂𝗇𝗁𝖾𝗋𝗂𝗍 𝗌𝗂𝗇 𝖻𝗒 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗈𝗇𝗅𝗒 𝖻𝗒 𝖾𝗑𝖺𝗆𝗉𝗅𝖾. 𝖠𝗇𝖽 𝗐𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝖽 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗂𝗇𝗁𝖾𝗋𝗂𝗍 𝗀𝗎𝗂𝗅𝗍 𝗈𝖿 𝖺𝗇𝗈𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋’𝗌 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗌 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝖯𝖺𝗎𝗅 𝗌𝖺𝗒𝗌<em> “𝖽𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗁 𝗉𝖺𝗌𝗌𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗈 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗆𝖾𝗇, 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝖺𝗎𝗌𝖾 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗇𝖾𝖽”.</em> 𝖧𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝖽 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗌𝖺𝗒 𝗐𝖾 𝖺𝗋𝖾 𝗀𝗎𝗂𝗅𝗍𝗒 𝖿𝗈𝗋 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝖺𝗇𝖼𝖾𝗌𝗍𝗈𝗋𝗌, 𝗈𝗋 𝖽𝗈𝖾𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖻𝗈𝗈𝗄 𝗈𝖿 𝖤𝗓𝖾𝗄𝗂𝖾𝗅 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗌𝖺𝗒,<em> “𝖳𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝗈𝗎𝗅 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗌, 𝗂𝗍 𝗌𝗁𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝖽𝗂𝖾. 𝖳𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝗈𝗇 𝗌𝗁𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖻𝖾𝖺𝗋 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗊𝗎𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖿𝖺𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋, 𝗇𝖾𝗂𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝗌𝗁𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖿𝖺𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝖻𝖾𝖺𝗋 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗊𝗎𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝗈𝗇”</em> (𝗂𝖻𝗂𝖽. 𝟣𝟪:𝟤𝟢)? 𝖠𝗇𝖽 𝖽𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗁 𝗐𝖺𝗌 𝗂𝗇𝗁𝖾𝗋𝗂𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝖻𝗒 𝖼𝖺𝗎𝗌𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇, 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝖺𝗎𝗌𝖾 𝖽𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗁 𝗂𝗌 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖺 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝖽𝗎𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝗌𝗂𝗇 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁 𝗂𝗍𝗌 𝖼𝗁𝖺𝗈𝗍𝗂𝖼 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗇𝖾𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗆𝗌, 𝗂𝗍 𝗌𝖾𝗉𝖺𝗋𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾 𝖿𝗋𝗈𝗆 𝗂𝗆𝗆𝗈𝗋𝗍𝖺𝗅𝗂𝗍𝗒, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗆𝗈𝗋𝖺𝗅 𝗀𝗋𝖺𝖼𝖾 𝗉𝗋𝗈𝗏𝗂𝖽𝖾𝖽 𝖻𝗒 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖣𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗐𝖺𝗌 𝗆𝖺𝗂𝗇𝗍𝖺𝗂𝗇𝖾𝖽; 𝖿𝗈𝗋 𝗐𝖾 𝗐𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝖽𝖾 𝖻𝗈𝗍𝗁 𝗂𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗂𝗆𝖺𝗀𝖾 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗅𝗂𝗄𝖾𝗇𝖾𝗌𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝖦𝗈𝖽, 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝖺𝗎𝗌𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗌𝖺𝗂𝖽, <em>“𝖫𝖾𝗍 𝗎𝗌 𝗆𝖺𝗄𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗄𝗂𝗇𝖽 𝖺𝖼𝖼𝗈𝗋𝖽𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗍𝗈 𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝗂𝗆𝖺𝗀𝖾, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖺𝖼𝖼𝗈𝗋𝖽𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗍𝗈 𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝗅𝗂𝗄𝖾𝗇𝖾𝗌𝗌,”</em> 𝗌𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗂𝗆𝖺𝗀𝖾 𝖺𝗌 𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝗁𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝗉𝗋𝖾𝖿𝗂𝗀𝗎𝗋𝖾𝗌 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗄𝗂𝗇𝖽’𝗌 𝖦𝗈𝖽-𝗀𝗂𝗏𝖾𝗇 𝗂𝗆𝗆𝗈𝗋𝗍𝖺𝗅𝗂𝗍𝗒, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗅𝗂𝗄𝖾𝗇𝖾𝗌𝗌 𝗁𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝗉𝗋𝖾𝖿𝗂𝗀𝗎𝗋𝖾𝗌 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗄𝗂𝗇𝖽’𝗌 𝖦𝗈𝖽-𝗀𝗂𝗏𝖾𝗇 𝗆𝗈𝗋𝖺𝗅𝗂𝗍𝗒 (𝗂𝖻𝗂𝖽. 𝟣:𝟤𝟨). 𝖨𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗐𝖺𝗒, 𝗐𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗂𝗇𝗍𝖺𝗂𝗇 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗅𝗂𝗄𝖾𝗇𝖾𝗌𝗌 𝗂𝗇 𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝖼𝗎𝗋𝗋𝖾𝗇𝗍 𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗍𝖾, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗂𝗆𝖺𝗀𝖾 𝗂𝗍𝗌𝖾𝗅𝖿 𝗂𝗌 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝖼𝖾𝖺𝗅𝖾𝖽 𝖿𝗋𝗈𝗆 𝗎𝗌. 𝖵𝗈𝗅𝗂𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝗂𝗌 𝗈𝖻𝗌𝗈𝗅𝖾𝗍𝖾 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁𝗈𝗎𝗍 𝗆𝗈𝗋𝖺𝗅 𝗀𝗋𝖺𝖼𝖾. 𝖨𝖿 𝗐𝖾 𝗁𝖺𝗏𝖾 𝗇𝗈 𝗆𝗈𝗋𝖺𝗅 𝖼𝖺𝗉𝖺𝖼𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝖽𝗎𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝗀𝗋𝖺𝖼𝖾, 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝗐𝖾 𝖼𝖺𝗇𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖻𝖾 𝗁𝖾𝗅𝖽 𝖺𝖼𝖼𝗈𝗎𝗇𝗍𝖺𝖻𝗅𝖾 𝖿𝗈𝗋 𝗐𝗋𝗈𝗇𝗀𝖽𝗈𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗐𝖾 𝗁𝖺𝗏𝖾 𝗇𝗈 𝗈𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝖺𝗅𝗍𝖾𝗋𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗏𝖾; 𝗂𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝖺𝗆𝖾 𝗐𝖺𝗒, 𝖺 𝗅𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝖼𝖺𝗇𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖻𝖾 𝗁𝖾𝗅𝖽 𝗆𝗈𝗋𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒 𝖼𝗎𝗅𝗉𝖺𝖻𝗅𝖾 𝖿𝗈𝗋 𝗄𝗂𝗅𝗅𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝖺 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝗂𝖿 𝗂𝗍 𝗂𝗌 𝖿𝗈𝗅𝗅𝗈𝗐𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗂𝗍𝗌 𝗈𝗐𝗇 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾. 𝖨𝖿 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗋𝖾𝗇𝖽𝖾𝗋𝖾𝖽 𝗌𝗎𝖼𝗁 𝖺 𝗉𝗈𝗌𝗌𝗂𝖻𝗂𝗅𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝗐𝗁𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗈𝗋 𝗌𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝖼𝖺𝗇 𝗇𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗋 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝗆𝗈𝗋𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒, 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾𝗌 𝗀𝗎𝗂𝗅𝗍𝗒 𝖿𝗈𝗋 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾𝗌 𝗐𝗁𝗈 𝖾𝗇𝖽𝗅𝖾𝗌𝗌𝗅𝗒 𝗐𝖺𝗇𝖽𝖾𝗋 𝗂𝗇 𝗆𝖺𝗅𝖾𝗏𝗈𝗅𝖾𝗇𝗍 𝖼𝗁𝗈𝗂𝖼𝖾𝗌.</strong></p><p><strong>[𝟤] 𝖳𝗁𝖾𝗌𝖾 𝗌𝖺𝗆𝖾 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝗆𝗂𝗌𝗎𝗇𝖽𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖯𝖺𝗎𝗅 𝖻𝗒 𝖼𝗂𝗍𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝖱𝗈𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝖺𝗀𝖺𝗂𝗇, <em>“𝖲𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝖺𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗎𝗀𝗁 𝗈𝗇𝖾 𝗍𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗉𝖺𝗌𝗌, 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗆𝖾𝗇 𝗐𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝖽𝖾𝗆𝗇𝖾𝖽; 𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗇 𝗌𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗎𝗀𝗁 𝗈𝗇𝖾 𝖺𝖼𝗍 𝗈𝖿 𝗋𝗂𝗀𝗁𝗍𝖾𝗈𝗎𝗌𝗇𝖾𝗌𝗌, 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗆𝖾𝗇 𝗐𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝗃𝗎𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖿𝗂𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗈 𝗅𝗂𝖿𝖾”</em> (𝗂𝖻𝗂𝖽. 𝟧:𝟣𝟪). 𝖳𝗁𝖾𝗒 𝗐𝗋𝗈𝗇𝗀𝗅𝗒 𝖺𝗋𝗀𝗎𝖾 𝖿𝗋𝗈𝗆 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗉𝖺𝗌𝗌𝖺𝗀𝖾 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗄𝗂𝗇𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝗀𝗎𝗂𝗅𝗍𝗒 𝖿𝗈𝗋 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗂𝗋 𝖺𝗇𝖼𝖾𝗌𝗍𝗈𝗋𝗌 𝖽𝖾𝗌𝗉𝗂𝗍𝖾 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝗍𝗋𝖺𝖽𝗂𝖼𝗍𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗐𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝖨 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖯𝖺𝗎𝗅 𝗌𝖺𝗂𝖽 𝖾𝖺𝗋𝗅𝗂𝖾𝗋. 𝖨𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝗍𝖾𝗑𝗍, 𝗐𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝖯𝖺𝗎𝗅 𝖾𝗆𝗉𝗅𝗈𝗒𝗌 “𝖼𝗈𝗇𝖽𝖾𝗆𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇,” 𝗁𝖾 𝖽𝗈𝖾𝗌 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗆𝖾𝖺𝗇 𝗀𝗎𝗂𝗅𝗍, 𝗒𝖾𝗍 𝗁𝖾 𝗆𝖾𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝖻𝖾𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗌𝗎𝖻𝗃𝖾𝖼𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗈 𝖽𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗁. 𝖠𝗇𝖽 𝖿𝗋𝗈𝗆 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝖺𝗆𝖾 𝗌𝖾𝗇𝗍𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾, 𝗁𝖾 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝗍𝗋𝖺𝗌𝗍𝗌 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝖽𝖾𝗆𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁 𝗃𝗎𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖿𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝗍𝗈 𝗅𝗂𝖿𝖾 — 𝗈𝗋 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝗇𝖼𝗂𝖾𝗇𝗍 𝖦𝗋𝖾𝖾𝗄 𝖺𝗅𝗌𝗈 𝗍𝗋𝖺𝗇𝗌𝗅𝖺𝗍𝖾𝗌</strong> <strong>𝖺𝗌 “𝗅𝗂𝖻𝖾𝗋𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝗍𝗈 𝗅𝗂𝖿𝖾”. 𝖨𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗌𝖾𝗇𝗍𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾, 𝖯𝖺𝗎𝗅 𝗂𝗌 𝗌𝖺𝗒𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗃𝗎𝗌𝗍 𝖺𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝗒𝗆𝖻𝗈𝗅 𝗈𝖿 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝖼𝖺𝗎𝗌𝖾𝖽 𝗎𝗇𝗂𝗏𝖾𝗋𝗌𝖺𝗅 𝖽𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗁 𝖿𝗈𝗋 𝖺𝗅𝗅, 𝗌𝗈 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍 𝗐𝗂𝗅𝗅 𝗂𝗇𝗌𝗍𝗂𝗅𝗅 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗎𝗇𝗂𝗏𝖾𝗋𝗌𝖺𝗅 𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗎𝗋𝗋𝖾𝖼𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝖿𝗈𝗋 𝖺𝗅𝗅. 𝖨𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗇𝖾𝗑𝗍 𝗌𝖾𝗇𝗍𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾, 𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝖺𝗒𝗌, <em>“𝖥𝗈𝗋 𝖺𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗎𝗀𝗁 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗈𝗇𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇’𝗌 𝖽𝗂𝗌𝗈𝖻𝖾𝖽𝗂𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗒 𝗐𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝖽𝖾 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗇𝖾𝗋𝗌, 𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗇 𝗌𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗎𝗀𝗁 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗈𝖻𝖾𝖽𝗂𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗈𝗇𝖾, 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗒 𝗐𝗂𝗅𝗅 𝖻𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝖽𝖾 𝗋𝗂𝗀𝗁𝗍𝖾𝗈𝗎𝗌,”</em> 𝗆𝖾𝖺𝗇𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗋𝗒𝗈𝗇𝖾 𝗉𝗋𝗂𝗈𝗋 𝗍𝗈 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍 𝗐𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗇𝖾𝗋𝗌 𝗈𝗋 𝗏𝗂𝖼𝗍𝗂𝗆𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗉𝗋𝖾𝖽𝗈𝗆𝗂𝗇𝖺𝗇𝗍 𝗌𝗂𝗇 𝖽𝗎𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗌𝖾𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗍𝗂𝖼 𝗎𝗌𝖺𝗀𝖾 𝗈𝖿 “𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗒” (𝗂𝖻𝗂𝖽. 𝟧:𝟣𝟫). 𝖠𝖼𝖼𝗈𝗋𝖽𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗍𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗌𝖺𝗆𝖾 𝗉𝖺𝗌𝗌𝖺𝗀𝖾, 𝖠𝖽𝖺𝗆 (𝗈𝗋 𝗆𝗈𝗋𝖾 𝖺𝖼𝖼𝗎𝗋𝖺𝗍𝖾𝗅𝗒, 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗄𝗂𝗇𝖽) 𝗂𝗇𝗌𝗉𝗂𝗋𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗒 𝗍𝗈 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝖿𝗎𝗅, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍 𝗂𝗇𝗌𝗉𝗂𝗋𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗒 𝗍𝗈 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝗋𝗂𝗀𝗁𝗍𝖾𝗈𝗎𝗌, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖽𝗈 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖺𝗌𝗌𝗎𝗆𝖾 𝗅𝗂𝗄𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗒 𝗆𝗂𝗌𝗀𝗎𝗂𝖽𝖾𝖽 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝗉𝗋𝗂𝗈𝗋 𝗍𝗈 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍 𝗐𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝗂𝗇𝖼𝖺𝗉𝖺𝖻𝗅𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝗐𝗈𝗋𝗄𝗌; 𝗁𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾, 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗂𝗋 𝗆𝗂𝗌𝗀𝗎𝗂𝖽𝖾𝖽 𝖻𝖾𝗅𝗂𝖾𝖿 𝗂𝗇 𝗍𝗈𝗍𝖺𝗅 𝖽𝖾𝗉𝗋𝖺𝗏𝗂𝗍𝗒. 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍 𝖼𝖺𝗆𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝗉𝗎𝗋𝗂𝖿𝗒 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗆𝗂𝗇𝖽𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗇𝖾𝗋𝗌, 𝗐𝗁𝗂𝖼𝗁 𝗂𝗌 𝗐𝗁𝗒 <em>“𝖻𝗒 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗈𝖻𝖾𝖽𝗂𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝗈𝗇𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇,”</em> 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗒 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝗋𝗂𝗀𝗁𝗍𝖾𝗈𝗎𝗌. 𝖤𝗏𝖾𝗇 𝗂𝖿 𝗈𝗇𝖾 𝗂𝗌 𝗌𝖺𝗏𝖾𝖽 𝖻𝗒 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝗐𝗈𝗋𝗄𝗌, 𝗐𝖾 𝗌𝗍𝗂𝗅𝗅 𝖼𝖺𝗇𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖻𝗈𝖺𝗌𝗍, 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝖺𝗎𝗌𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝗈𝗎𝗋𝖼𝖾 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖾𝗌𝗌𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗋𝗂𝗀𝗁𝗍𝖾𝗈𝗎𝗌𝗇𝖾𝗌𝗌; 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗆𝗈𝗋𝖺𝗅 𝗀𝗋𝖺𝖼𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗇 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗌, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗌𝗈, 𝗍𝗁𝗈𝗌𝖾 𝗐𝗁𝗈 𝗅𝗈𝗏𝖾 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗂𝗋 𝗇𝖾𝗂𝗀𝗁𝖻𝗈𝗋 𝖺𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗒 𝗅𝗈𝗏𝖾 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗆𝗌𝖾𝗅𝗏𝖾𝗌 (𝗐𝗁𝖾𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝖺𝗌 𝖺 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖺𝗇 𝗈𝗋 𝗇𝗈𝗍), 𝗂𝗌 𝖻𝖾𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝖿𝖺𝗂𝗍𝗁𝖿𝗎𝗅 𝗍𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗅𝖺𝗐 𝗈𝖿 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍 (𝖼𝖿. 𝖬𝖺𝗍𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗐 𝟤𝟧:𝟥𝟣-𝟦𝟢). 𝖧𝖾𝗋𝖾, 𝖧𝖾 𝗋𝖾𝗀𝖺𝗋𝖽𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗋𝗂𝗀𝗁𝗍𝖾𝗈𝗎𝗌 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖺𝗌 𝗆𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝖻𝖾𝗅𝗂𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗋𝗌, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗂𝗇 𝗀𝖾𝗇𝖾𝗋𝖺𝗅.</strong></p><p><strong>[𝟥] 𝖡𝗎𝗍 𝗒𝗈𝗎 𝖺𝗌𝗄: “𝖶𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗂𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝖽𝗏𝖺𝗇𝗍𝖺𝗀𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝖻𝖾𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝖺 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖺𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝗂𝖿 𝗌𝗎𝖼𝗁 𝖺𝗋𝖾 𝖺𝗅𝗋𝖾𝖺𝖽𝗒 𝗋𝗂𝗀𝗁𝗍𝖾𝗈𝗎𝗌?” 𝖲𝖺𝗅𝗏𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝖾𝗑𝗍𝖾𝗇𝖽𝗌 𝖻𝖾𝗒𝗈𝗇𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗃𝗎𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖿𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝗂𝗇𝗇𝖾𝗋. 𝖠𝗌 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖺𝗇𝗌, 𝗐𝖾 𝗌𝗁𝗈𝗎𝗅𝖽 𝖻𝖾 𝗅𝗈𝗈𝗄𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝖿𝗈𝗋𝗐𝖺𝗋𝖽 𝗍𝗈 𝖼𝗈𝗌𝗆𝗂𝖼 𝗌𝖺𝗅𝗏𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇, 𝗐𝗁𝗂𝖼𝗁 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗎𝗇𝖻𝖾𝗅𝗂𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗋 𝗁𝖺𝗌 𝗇𝗈 𝗂𝗇𝗁𝖾𝗋𝗂𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗈𝗏𝖾𝗋 𝗒𝖾𝗍. 𝖠𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖺𝗉𝗈𝗌𝗍𝗈𝗅𝗂𝖼 𝗐𝗋𝗂𝗍𝗂𝗇𝗀𝗌 𝗌𝖺𝗒: <em>“𝖧𝗂𝗌 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗉𝗈𝗐𝖾𝗋 𝗁𝖺𝗌 𝗀𝗂𝗏𝖾𝗇 𝗎𝗌 𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗋𝗒𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗐𝖾 𝗇𝖾𝖾𝖽 𝖿𝗈𝗋 𝗅𝗂𝖿𝖾 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗀𝗈𝖽𝗅𝗂𝗇𝖾𝗌𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗎𝗀𝗁 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗄𝗇𝗈𝗐𝗅𝖾𝖽𝗀𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝖧𝗂𝗆 𝗐𝗁𝗈 𝖼𝖺𝗅𝗅𝖾𝖽 𝗎𝗌 𝖻𝗒 𝖧𝗂𝗌 𝗈𝗐𝗇 𝗀𝗅𝗈𝗋𝗒 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖾𝗑𝖼𝖾𝗅𝗅𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾. 𝖳𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗎𝗀𝗁 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗌𝖾 𝖧𝖾 𝗁𝖺𝗌 𝗀𝗂𝗏𝖾𝗇 𝗎𝗌 𝖧𝗂𝗌 𝗉𝗋𝖾𝖼𝗂𝗈𝗎𝗌 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗆𝖺𝗀𝗇𝗂𝖿𝗂𝖼𝖾𝗇𝗍 𝗉𝗋𝗈𝗆𝗂𝗌𝖾𝗌, 𝗌𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗍𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗎𝗀𝗁 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗆 𝗒𝗈𝗎 𝗆𝖺𝗒 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝗉𝖺𝗋𝗍𝖺𝗄𝖾𝗋𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾, 𝗇𝗈𝗐 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗒𝗈𝗎 𝗁𝖺𝗏𝖾 𝖾𝗌𝖼𝖺𝗉𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖼𝗈𝗋𝗋𝗎𝗉𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝗂𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗐𝗈𝗋𝗅𝖽 𝖼𝖺𝗎𝗌𝖾𝖽 𝖻𝗒 𝖾𝗏𝗂𝗅 𝖽𝖾𝗌𝗂𝗋𝖾𝗌”</em> (𝟤𝗇𝖽 𝖯𝖾𝗍𝖾𝗋 𝟣:𝟥–𝟦). 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍 𝖽𝗂𝖽 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝖻𝖾𝗌𝗍𝗈𝗐 𝗀𝗋𝖺𝖼𝖾 (𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗐𝖾 𝖺𝗅𝗋𝖾𝖺𝖽𝗒 𝗁𝖺𝗏𝖾), 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝖧𝖾 𝖼𝖺𝗆𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝖻𝖾𝗊𝗎𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗁 <em>“𝗀𝗋𝖺𝖼𝖾 𝗎𝗉𝗈𝗇 𝗀𝗋𝖺𝖼𝖾,”</em> 𝗐𝗁𝗂𝖼𝗁 𝗂𝗌 𝖺 𝗁𝗂𝗀𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗍𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝖻𝖾𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗅𝗂𝗄𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝖽, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍 𝗂𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗆𝖾𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝗍𝗈 𝗎𝗇𝖼𝗈𝗏𝖾𝗋𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗋𝖾𝗌𝗍𝗈𝗋𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗂𝗆𝖺𝗀𝖾 𝖾𝗂𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝗂𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖿𝗎𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾 𝖺𝗀𝖾 𝗂𝗇𝖾𝗏𝗂𝗍𝖺𝖻𝗅𝗒, 𝗈𝗋 𝗉𝗈𝗍𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗂𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒, 𝗂𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗉𝗋𝖾𝗌𝖾𝗇𝗍 𝖺𝗀𝖾 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖿𝖺𝗅𝗅𝖾𝗇 𝖼𝗈𝗌𝗆𝗈𝗌 (𝖼𝖿. 𝖩𝗈𝗁𝗇 𝟣:𝟣𝟨). 𝖳𝗁𝖾 𝗀𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗇𝗀𝗌 𝖺 𝗆𝗒𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗅 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖺𝗇 𝗂𝗌 𝗍𝖺𝗌𝗄𝖾𝖽 𝗈𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖾𝖺𝗋𝗍𝗁 𝗐𝗂𝗅𝗅 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖻𝖾 𝖾𝗅𝖺𝖻𝗈𝗋𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝖿𝗎𝗋𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝗁𝖾𝗋𝖾; 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗂𝗌 𝗍𝗈 𝖺𝗏𝗈𝗂𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖽𝗈𝗎𝖻𝗍 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖿𝖺𝗅𝗅𝖾𝗇 𝗐𝗈𝗋𝗅𝖽. 𝖨 𝗐𝗂𝗅𝗅 𝗈𝖿𝖿𝖾𝗋 𝖺𝗇 𝖾𝗇𝗀𝗂𝗆𝖺 𝗁𝗈𝗐𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗋: 𝖳𝗁𝖾 𝗍𝖺𝗌𝗄 𝗀𝗂𝗏𝖾𝗇 𝗍𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝗐𝗁𝗈 𝗐𝖺𝗌 𝗍𝗈 𝗍𝖾𝗇𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗀𝖺𝗋𝖽𝖾𝗇, 𝗐𝗁𝗂𝖼𝗁 𝗅𝖺𝗍𝖾𝗋 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝖺𝗆𝖾 𝖺 𝗐𝖺𝗌𝗍𝖾𝗅𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖻𝗒 𝖿𝗈𝗋𝖿𝖾𝗂𝗍𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝗂𝗍, 𝗁𝖺𝗌 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗅𝖾𝖿𝗍 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇’𝗌 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗉𝗈𝗐𝖾𝗋. 𝖫𝖾𝗍 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾 𝖻𝖾𝗅𝗂𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗋 𝗎𝗇𝖽𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝖾𝗇𝗂𝗀𝗆𝖺.</strong></p><h4>Chapter 3: Fathoming Divinity and Deity</h4><p><strong>[𝟣] 𝖣𝗈 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝗋𝖾𝗀𝖺𝗋𝖽 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝖺𝗌 𝖺 𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝗐𝗁𝗈 𝗐𝖺𝗌 𝗈𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝖾𝖺𝗋𝗇𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾, 𝗇𝗈𝗋 𝖻𝖾 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖼𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝗆𝖾𝗇 𝗐𝗁𝖾𝗇 𝗎𝗇𝗂𝖿𝗂𝖾𝖽 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁 𝖦𝗈𝖽, 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝗎𝖻𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝖫𝗈𝗋𝖽. 𝖳𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗂𝗌 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖺 𝗍𝗋𝗎𝖾 𝗍𝖾𝖺𝖼𝗁𝗂𝗇𝗀, 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝖺𝗎𝗌𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗒 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝖿𝗅𝖺𝗍𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁 𝖽𝖾𝗂𝗍𝗒, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖺 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁 𝖺 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗊𝗎𝖺𝗅𝗂𝗍𝗒, 𝗇𝗈𝗋 𝗂𝗌 𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗄𝗂𝗇𝖽 𝗍𝗈 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝖾𝗌𝗌𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾. 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝖺𝗆𝖾 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇, 𝗌𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗁𝗎𝗆𝖺𝗇𝗌 𝗆𝖺𝗒 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗓𝖾𝖽; 𝖿𝗎𝗋𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋𝗆𝗈𝗋𝖾, 𝗐𝖾 𝖽𝗈 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗇 𝗉𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗈𝗇 𝗈𝗋 𝖾𝗌𝗌𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝖼𝗁𝖺𝗇𝗇𝖾𝗅𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖣𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾. 𝖨𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗐𝖺𝗒, 𝗐𝖾 𝗁𝖺𝗏𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗍𝗒, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗈𝗇𝗅𝗒 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝗍𝗋𝗎𝗅𝗒 𝖽𝖾𝗂𝗍𝗒.</strong></p><p><strong>[𝟤] 𝖡𝗎𝗍 𝗒𝗈𝗎 𝗐𝗈𝗇𝖽𝖾𝗋 𝗐𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝖺𝗋𝖾 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖾𝗉𝗂𝗌𝗍𝖾𝗆𝗂𝖼 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝗌𝖾𝗊𝗎𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾𝗌 𝗍𝗈 𝗁𝗈𝗅𝖽𝗂𝗇𝗀 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝗍𝗋𝖺𝖽𝗂𝖼𝗍𝗈𝗋𝗒 𝗏𝗂𝖾𝗐𝗌. 𝖨𝖿 𝖺 𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾𝗌 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗇 𝗉𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗈𝗇, 𝗁𝖾 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾𝗌 𝖺𝗇𝗈𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝗆𝖾𝗆𝖻𝖾𝗋 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖳𝗋𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗍𝗒; 𝗁𝗈𝗐𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗋, 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖳𝗋𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝗂𝗌 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖼𝗈𝗆𝗉𝗋𝗂𝗌𝖾𝖽 𝗈𝖿 𝖿𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗍𝖾 𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗂𝗍𝗂𝖾𝗌 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁 𝗌𝗒𝗇𝗈𝗇𝗒𝗆𝗈𝗎𝗌 𝗇𝖺𝗍𝗎𝗋𝖾𝗌, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗍𝗋𝖺𝗇𝗌𝖼𝖾𝗇𝖽𝗌 𝗌𝗉𝖺𝖼𝖾-𝗍𝗂𝗆𝖾, 𝗁𝖺𝗌 𝗇𝗈 𝗉𝖺𝗋𝗍𝗌, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝗐𝗂𝗍𝗁𝗂𝗇 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝖺𝗌 𝗐𝖾𝗅𝗅. 𝖠𝗇𝖽 𝗂𝖿 𝖺 𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝖾𝗌𝗌𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾, 𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗉𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗈𝗇𝖺𝗅 𝖺𝗀𝖾𝗇𝖼𝗒 𝗏𝖺𝗇𝗂𝗌𝗁𝖾𝗌. 𝖡𝗎𝗍 𝗂𝗇 𝗅𝗂𝗀𝗁𝗍 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗍𝗋𝗎𝖾 𝗏𝗂𝖾𝗐: 𝗐𝖾 𝖽𝗈𝗇’𝗍 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗇 𝗉𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗈𝗇 (𝖺𝗌 𝗂𝖿 𝗐𝖾 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝖺 𝗉𝖺𝗋𝗍 𝗈𝖿 𝖺𝗇 𝖺𝗇𝗍𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗉𝗈𝗆𝗈𝗋𝗉𝗁𝗂𝖼 𝖳𝗋𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗍𝗒) 𝗈𝗋 𝗂𝗇 𝖾𝗌𝗌𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾 (𝖺𝗌 𝗂𝖿 𝗐𝖾 𝗅𝗈𝗌𝖾 𝖺𝗅𝗅 𝖽𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗂𝗇𝖼𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇), 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗋𝖺𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗋 𝗐𝖾 𝖻𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗆𝖾 𝖼𝗁𝖺𝗇𝗇𝖾𝗅𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖣𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 (𝖺𝗌 𝗂𝖿 𝗐𝖾 𝗁𝗈𝗅𝖽 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝗂𝗓𝖾𝖽 𝖺𝗍𝗍𝗋𝗂𝖻𝗎𝗍𝖾𝗌), 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗈𝗇𝗅𝗒 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗂𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗌𝗎𝖻𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖼𝖾.</strong></p><h4>Resolution</h4><p><strong>𝖶𝖾 𝗄𝗇𝗈𝗐 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖺 𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝗐𝗁𝗈 𝗂𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝖾𝗌𝗌𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾, 𝗈𝗋 𝗍𝗈 𝖻𝖾 𝗍𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝖺𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗍𝗋𝗎𝖾 𝖣𝖾𝗂𝗍𝗒, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗌𝖾𝗋𝗏𝖾𝗌 𝖺𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗈𝗇𝗍𝗈𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗅 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽, 𝗐𝗁𝗂𝗅𝖾 𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝗌𝖾𝗋𝗏𝖾𝗌 𝖺𝗌 𝖺 𝗍𝖾𝗅𝖾𝗈𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗅 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽. 𝖶𝖾 𝗄𝗇𝗈𝗐 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖺 𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝗐𝗁𝗈 𝗂𝗌 𝗍𝗈𝗍𝖺𝗅𝗅𝗒 𝖽𝖾𝗉𝗋𝖺𝗏𝖾𝖽, 𝗈𝗋 𝖺 𝗆𝖺𝗇 𝗐𝗁𝗈 𝗂𝗌 𝗀𝗈𝗈𝖽 𝖺𝗉𝖺𝗋𝗍 𝖿𝗋𝗈𝗆 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖽𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾 𝗀𝗋𝖺𝖼𝖾, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝖦𝗈𝖽 𝗌𝖾𝗋𝗏𝖾𝗌 𝖺𝗌 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗌𝗈𝗎𝗋𝖼𝖾 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖾𝗌𝗌𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗈𝖿 𝖺𝗇𝗒 𝗉𝖾𝗋𝗌𝗈𝗇’𝗌 𝗆𝗈𝗋𝖺𝗅𝗂𝗍𝗒 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖼𝗈𝗇𝗌𝖼𝗂𝖾𝗇𝖼𝖾. 𝖶𝖾 𝗄𝗇𝗈𝗐 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖺 𝗌𝗎𝖻𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝗐𝗁𝗂𝖼𝗁 𝗂𝗌 𝖾𝗏𝗂𝗅 𝗈𝗋 𝖺𝗅𝗂𝖾𝗇 𝗍𝗈 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖣𝗂𝗏𝗂𝗇𝖾, 𝖻𝗎𝗍 𝗐𝖾 𝖺𝖼𝗄𝗇𝗈𝗐𝗅𝖾𝖽𝗀𝖾 𝗂𝗍 𝖺𝗌 𝖺 𝖽𝗂𝗌𝗈𝗋𝖽𝖾𝗋 𝗈𝗋 𝖺 𝖽𝖾𝖼𝗈𝗇𝗌𝗍𝗋𝗎𝖼𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇 𝗈𝖿 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝖼𝗋𝖾𝖺𝗍𝖾𝖽 𝗐𝗈𝗋𝗅𝖽. 𝖠𝗇𝗒 𝖢𝗁𝗋𝗂𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖺𝗇 𝗐𝗁𝗈 𝖽𝗈𝖾𝗌 𝗇𝗈𝗍 𝖺𝖽𝗁𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝗍𝗈 𝗐𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗂𝗌 𝗐𝗋𝗂𝗍𝗍𝖾𝗇 𝗁𝖾𝗋𝖾 𝗐𝗂𝗅𝗅 𝖻𝖾 𝗆𝗂𝗌𝗍𝖺𝗄𝖾𝗇 𝗂𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗂𝗋 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗈𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗒 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖺𝗇𝗍𝗁𝗋𝗈𝗉𝗈𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗒, 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝖾𝗏𝖾𝗇 𝗌𝗈𝗍𝖾𝗋𝗂𝗈𝗅𝗈𝗀𝗒 (𝗌𝗂𝗇𝖼𝖾 𝖨 𝗆𝖾𝗇𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇𝖾𝖽 𝗍𝗁𝖾𝗈𝗌𝗂𝗌 𝖺𝗇𝖽 𝗃𝗎𝗌𝗍𝗂𝖿𝗂𝖼𝖺𝗍𝗂𝗈𝗇). 𝖳𝗁𝗂𝗌 𝗐𝖺𝗌 𝖼𝗈𝗆𝗉𝗈𝗌𝖾𝖽 𝗂𝗇 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗁𝗈𝗉𝖾 𝗍𝗁𝖺𝗍 𝗇𝗈 𝗈𝗇𝖾 𝗐𝗂𝗅𝗅 𝖻𝖾 𝗆𝗂𝗌𝗅𝖾𝖽 𝖻𝗒 𝗍𝗁𝖾 𝗏𝗂𝖾𝗐𝗌 𝗈𝖿 𝗈𝗎𝗋 𝗍𝗂𝗆𝖾.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b390cfb78583" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ignatius the Universalist?]]></title>
            <link>https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/ignatius-the-universalist-58011494dadc?source=rss-446f9887eae0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/58011494dadc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christian-universalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eschatology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ignatius]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apostolic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universalist]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[George M. Garcia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Apr 2024 03:04:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-08T00:29:07.145Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Was Theophorous a universalist?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/642/1*685PSpTrpeBv9njrIvtS0A@2x.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Preface</h3><p>People often retort that Ignatius was not a universalist, but either an annihlationist or infernalist; on the contrary, there is much implicit evidence that neither Ignatius, Clement, nor Polycarp were post-mortem exclusivists. Though the center of discussion here will be on Saint Ignatius. This is dedicated to a friend as well.</p><h4>The Passages in Question</h4><blockquote><strong>“Such a one becoming defiled [in this way], shall go away into unquenchable [ἄσβεστον] fire, and so shall every one that hearkens unto him” (Ephesians 16).</strong></blockquote><p>The term “unquenchable” does not denote an eternal duration, but indicates the quality of the fire instead. Eusebius the historian records martyrs of Alexandria being killed by a fire, which he termed as “unquenchable”: <strong>“After them Epimachus and Alexander, having remained in bonds for a long time, and endured countless agonies from scrapers and scourges, were also consumed in an unquenchable [ἀσβέστῳ] fire”</strong> (<em>Ecclesiastical History, Book VI, Chapter 41</em>). And this is in reference to an earthly temporal fire, and not an eternal flame. Some translations dishonestly render Ignatius’ use of <em>asbeston </em>as eternal unfortunately.</p><blockquote><strong>“From whence all sorcery was undone and every bond of wickedness was destroyed; ignorance was abolished, the old kingdom was dissolved when God was humanly manifested unto newness of eternal [aidiou] life; and the beginning of that which was established by God was being received. Therefore, all were provoked together through the mediation of the abolition of death” (Ephesians 19).</strong></blockquote><p>Ignatius employed the term “eternal” in reference to the newness of life for all beings since he argues that all were provoked through a mediation of the abolition of death. Ignatius did not employ the scriptural language for the fate of the righteous like <em>aionios</em>, which conveys an indefinite duration; however, he employed <em>aidiou</em> which strictly conveys an eternal duration. If Ignatius were an infernalist dogmatically, then he would have employed <em>aidiou</em> in reference to the fate of the wicked. Based on this reading, there is no infernalist passage, but only a subtle universalist direction. In chapter 18, he does employ <em>aionios</em> concerning salvation and life, which the text should be rendered as <strong>“Let my spirit be counted as nothing for the sake of the cross, which is a stumbling-block to those that do not believe, but to us salvation and life <em>unto the ages</em>.” </strong>Ignatius is saying that an immortal life (salvation) will be given to the Church in the future since he elaborated this in chapter 17: <strong>“For this end did the Lord allow the ointment to be poured upon His head, that He might breathe immortality into His Church,” </strong>so my rendering of <em>aionios</em> as <strong>“unto the ages [futurity]”</strong> is an accurate translation.</p><blockquote><strong>“I salute in the blood of Jesus Christ, who is our eternal [aionios] and enduring joy, especially if [men] are in unity with the bishop, the presbyters, and the deacons, who have been appointed according to the mind of Jesus Christ, whom He has established in security, after His own will, and by His Holy Spirit” (Philadelphians preface).</strong></blockquote><p>Some might appeal to this translation as rendering <em>aionios</em> as eternal; however, this appeal is faulty. There is no reason to add the term “eternal” in the same sentence with the word “enduring”. The term <em>aionios</em> in this context should be rendered as “long-lasting” which renders “enduring” reasonable in this context. Christ is our long-lasting and enduring joy, but if he wanted to convey “eternal,” the usage of “enduring” is misplaced, redundant, or unnecessary. Because the word “long-lasting” or <em>aionios </em>might imply a temporal duration (<em>which is rare</em>), or an indefinite duration (<em>which is typical</em>), he modifies it with enduring to convey something that continues beyond its perceived limited duration. The term “eternal” needs no word modifier.</p><h4>Partial Eschatology and Doctrine of Reserve</h4><p>The Ante-Nicene Fathers were universalists, but they did not openly proclaim it to those who were spiritually infantile in their faith. This tradition of reserving some dogmas of the faith was a very common strategy that Ignatius himself employed. He says: <strong>“Am I not able to write to you heavenly things? Yes, but I am afraid that I should do you harm ‘seeing you are babes.’ Pardon me, for I refrain lest you be choked by what you cannot receive. For I myself, though I am in bonds and can understand heavenly things, and the places of the angels and the gatherings of principalities, and ‘things seen and unseen,’ not for this am I a disciple even now, for much is lacking to us, that we may not lack God”</strong> (<em>Trallians 5.1–2</em>). The Ante-Nicene Fathers concealed their universalism by proclaiming a partial resurrection to the infantile (<em>while knowingly deviating from Paul on Romans 5:18, 1st Corinthians 15:26–28</em>), which essentially means only the righteous experience salvation in the body. A universal resurrection, to them, implied universal salvation since if the body of the wicked needed to be restored, then their souls also needed to be restored back into its original condition. This kind of rationale inevitably leads one into apokatastasis lest the belief itself seem purposely inconsistent. Ignatius, Clement, Polycarp, and the Didache demonstrate a partial eschatology:</p><blockquote><strong>“Now, He suffered all these things for our sakes, that we might be saved. And He suffered truly, even as also He truly raised up Himself, not, as certain unbelievers maintain, that He only seemed to suffer, as they themselves only seem to be [Christians]. And as they believe, so shall it happen unto them, when they shall be divested of their bodies, and be mere evil spirits” (Smyrnaeans 2). — The Docetists will have no resurrection but remain incorporeal.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>“But He who raised Him up from the dead will raise us up also, if we do His will, and walk in His commandments, and love what He loved, keeping ourselves from all unrighteousness…” (Polycarp to Philippians 2). — The resurrection is conditional upon good works.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>“And then shall appear the signs of the truth; first, the sign of an outspreading in heaven; then the sign of the sound of the trumpet; and the third, the resurrection of the dead; yet not of all, but as it is said: The Lord shall come and all His saints with Him. Then shall the world see the Lord coming upon the clouds of heaven” (The Didache 16). — The resurrection is reserved for the elect or the righteous, but the wicked are excluded.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>“Do we then deem it any great and wonderful thing for the Maker of all things to raise up again those that have piously served Him in the assurance of a good faith, when even by a bird He shows us the mightiness of His power to fulfill His promise? For [the Scripture] says in a certain place, ‘You shall raise me up, and I shall confess unto You,’ and again, ‘I laid me down, and slept,’ ‘I awoke, because You are with me’; and again, Job says, ‘You shall raise up this flesh of mine, which has suffered all these things’ ” (1st Clement 26). — He limits the resurrection to only the righteous or pious as well.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Methodius of Olympus: “[Origen] speaks in order, explaining in the Psalms, in the tenth verse of the first Psalm: ‘From here, the simpler believers, starting their argument, believe that the impious will not experience the resurrection. What do they think about the resurrection?’ ” (On the Resurrection, Book 1, Chapter 20 edited by Georg Nathanael Bonwetsch).—This is an extra, but Methodius reports Origen’s account of infantile believer’s perspective on the resurrection. I will be honest that I couldn’t find this quote in an online English edition, but apparently this Greek passage is found in Nathanael Bonwetsch’s edition, which was published by De Gruyter. I used the Bellerophon app which confers me access to this edition, so whether this Greek passage is included, omitted, or translated into German in the other accessible mediums of his edition, I don’t know.</strong></blockquote><h3>Resolution</h3><p>The Ante-Nicene Fathers concealed their universalism away from the immature Christian masses by asserting a partial eschatology on the resurrection, in the hopes of immature Christians not becoming too morally sluggish or an apostate. Because the majority of Christians could not read at the time of the patristic era or apostolic era, the educated bishops had an advantage over them. Origen himself also elaborates on the doctrine of reserve in <strong>Contra Celsus <em>Book 1, VII</em></strong><em>.</em></p><p>The universal resurrection (along with salvation) was taught by Paul in Romans 5:18 where he argues: <strong>“Consequently, just as one trespass resulted in condemnation for all people, so also one righteous act resulted in justification to life for all people,”</strong> and in 1st Corinthians 3:14–15, Paul distinguishes saints and sinners who are part of the Church, <strong>“If anyone’s work which he has built on it endures, he will receive a reward. If anyone’s work is burned, he will suffer loss; but he himself will be saved, yet so as through fire.”</strong> Those who lived according to the love of God, Paul affirms their reward, which is an early resurrection and a Christological reign (<em>cf. Revelation 20:5</em>). Paul affirms those who are sinners, especially of the Church, will undergo the divine fire, suffer a loss of time since they will not partake of the first resurrection, but he says they will be saved in regard to resurrection and liberation from sin.</p><p>In regard to the patristic era, the Ante-Nicene Fathers did not wish for the immature to understand the doctrine of apokatastasis, but it was limited to prayers for the dead since the Epistle of the Apostles (<em>120–150 CE</em>) affirms this principle: <strong>“I am the ​word: I became flesh, and I wearied myself (or, suffered) and taught, saying: The heavy laden shall be saved, and they that are gone astray shall go astray for ever. They shall be chastised and tormented in their flesh and in their soul. 40 And we said unto him: O Lord, verily we are sorrowful for their sake. And he said unto us: Ye do rightly, for the righteous are sorry for the sinners, and pray for them, making prayer unto my Father”</strong> (<em>Epistle of the Apostles 39–40</em>). While this passage is not strictly universalist, it is more towards the universalist direction. In this case, if certain immature Christians were close to grasping universalism, they would have most likely been taught a soft form of universalism in the guise of praying for the dead. And because the Nicene creed affirmed a universal resurrection with no particular distinction, nor condition for the resurrection, this partial eschatological tactic employed by the Ante-Nicene Fathers became obsolete after the time of Origen. However, the doctrine of reserve persisted beyond Origen and the Ante-Nicene Fathers with examples like Gregory Nazianzus (<em>4th century</em>) or Maximus the Confessor (<em>7th century</em>) (<em>cf. Oration 40.36; Ad Thal. 11.3</em>). In context with everything said, Ignatius along with the other Apostolic Fathers (and documents) I have mentioned were universalists in a private sense, but not public about it.</p><h3>Recommended Websites</h3><ul><li><a href="https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2017/10/08/sometimes-eternity-aint-forever-aionios-and-the-universalist-hope/">Sometimes Eternity Ain&#39;t Forever: Aiónios and the Universalist Hope</a></li><li><a href="https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2021/02/02/the-deep-patristic-roots-of-harts-universalism-a-response-to-fr-lawrence-farley/">The Deep Patristic Roots of Hart&#39;s Universalism: A Response to Fr Lawrence Farley</a></li></ul><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FvvEVV9qNias&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DvvEVV9qNias&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FvvEVV9qNias%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3441548036bc3a39b8b746d3ac334bc7/href">https://medium.com/media/3441548036bc3a39b8b746d3ac334bc7/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=58011494dadc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Christ and the Law (Nομος)]]></title>
            <link>https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/christ-and-the-law-n%CE%BF%CE%BC%CE%BF%CF%82-867f2c672ef1?source=rss-446f9887eae0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/867f2c672ef1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[allegoresis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-testament]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[torah]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[church-fathers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[prophetic-fulfillment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[George M. Garcia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Apr 2024 00:46:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-08T02:00:34.385Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How Christians Should Fathom this Relationship</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-pfT4Q1XuXu36Ln2" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@timothyeberly?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Timothy Eberly</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h4>Preface</h4><p>Since the deviation of the Western Church from the East, and then the deviation of the Reformation from the Catholic Church to this present century, the relationship of Christ and the Law or Torah has been understood (erroneously) as this monolithic tradition where all the supposed prophecies and the ordinances of the law based on the authorial context points to Christ, and it has been presumed that the ethics between the old and new covenants do not contradict (despite this being a delusion). However, this kind of theological notion is faulty and detrimental for various reasons. Christian fundamentalism propagates this kind of theological system where the law was fulfilled in totality by Christ, and that somehow the Jews were too psychologically blind to the advent of Christ. But according to Hebrew scholarship, and even my own literary research of the Hebrew Bible, it has been concluded that none of the so-called prophecies in their original context refers to Christ as the messiah. And for many years, many Christians have misunderstood the nature of the prophetic fulfillment of Christ, to the degree that Christians have slandered Jews as being too proud to concede or ignorant to understand, and even to the shameful extent where <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disputation_of_Barcelona"><strong>medieval Christians (from the Dominican Order) sought to banish a medieval Jewish scholar when he demonstrated their exegesis in search for Jesus in the Hebrew Bible was fallacious, and published the proceedings after the Dominicans claimed victory despite the King’s favor over Nachmanides.</strong></a></p><p>Moreover, as a consequence of this mistaken “Christian” tradition, seeing Jesus with the Law as being linearly compatible, there are movements like Messianic Judaism (<em>i.e. Semi-Ebionite Christianity</em>) which has advocated Christian Jews in keeping the mosaic rites, and some sects of this occurrence would also extend this kind of bondage to Gentiles. This has been the result of the Christian fundamentalist understanding, which not only proposes paradoxical ideas of God and ethics, but has also provoked some Christians to adopt a semi-Ebionite mindset. In summary, my attempt is to demonstrate how Paul (and Hebrews) perceived the Law and the Prophets in light of Christ, how the Early Church understood Christ’s fulfillment, and how certain scriptures (<em>i.e. Gospels</em>) disagree on the portrayal of Jesus concerning the Law.</p><h4>Those Detrimental Human Traditions</h4><p>Upon examining Paul’s language and perceiving many examples of his usage of allegoresis, he doesn’t perceive the mosaic laws as being strictly divine from the letter (or authorial context). Instead, he fathoms the mosaic tradition as being humanly invented, which demonstrates that the mosaic tradition are not injunctions and oracles dictated by the divine. Paul, who is among Hellenized Jews, spiritually reinterprets the law and the prophets in light and primacy of Christ (<em>cf. Colossians 2:16–17; Galatians 4:21–31; 1st Corinthians 9:9–10</em>). Before this point is demonstrated, permit me to cite certain Pauline passages.</p><p>In the epistle to the Ephesians, Paul proclaims that Christ negated the law of commandments containing ordinances, which separated both Jews and Gentiles from each other. This could be conveyed as merely pagan traditions invoking separation from the Jews; however, the mosaic tradition prescribed to them that they should not intermarry with Gentiles (<em>cf. Deut. 7:3</em>), that they may enslave certain foreigners for life unlike their fellow Israelites with a temporal enslavement period (<em>cf. Lev. 25:45–46</em>), and that they may annihilate certain tribes along with their women, children, and cattle (<em>cf. Deut. 20:16–18</em>). Paul in likelihood means both traditions derived from Jewish and Pagan culture. Anyway, let’s observe and retain Paul’s language in Ephesians to compare with his other epistles for now:</p><blockquote><em>“But now in Christ Jesus you who once were far off are made near in the blood of Christ. </em><strong><em>For he is our peace, who made both one, and broke down the middle wall of separation, having abolished in his flesh the hostility, the law of commandments contained in ordinances, that he might create in himself one new man of the two</em></strong><em>, making peace, and </em><strong><em>might reconcile them both in one body to God through the cross</em></strong><em>, having </em><strong><em>killed the hostility</em></strong><em> through it” (</em><strong>Ephesians 2:13–16 WEBUS</strong><em>).</em></blockquote><p>In the epistle to the Colossians, Paul says to his audience that they were morally dead (as in predominant sin, not total depravity), mentions Jesus’ revelation of God’s forgiveness towards them, and he claims that Christ negated the <em>“the handwriting in ordinances,”</em> which opposed both Paul and his audience. This phrase has often been mis-translated as a legal debt to God, or some sacrificial law by Reformed crowds, but the most appropriate translation should be rendered as “certificate” or “handwriting”. And so, based on the language of Paul from Ephesians and Colossians, the ordinances or decrees are human precepts or man-made customs. If we read Colossians in context to <em>“the handwriting in ordinances,” </em>the identification is made clear by Paul’s reference to mosaic rites, self-abasement, and angelic worship as the precepts/dogmas of man:</p><blockquote><em>“You were dead through your trespasses and the uncircumcision of your flesh. He made you alive together with him, having forgiven us all our trespasses, </em><strong><em>wiping out the handwriting in ordinances which was against us. He has taken it out of the way, nailing it to the cross.</em></strong><em> Having stripped the principalities and the powers, he made a show of them openly, triumphing over them in it. </em><strong><em>Let no one therefore judge you in eating or drinking, or with respect to a feast day or a new moon or a Sabbath day, which are a shadow of the things to come; but the body is Christ’s. Let no one rob you of your prize by self-abasement and worshiping of the angels</em></strong><em>, dwelling in the things which he has not seen, vainly puffed up by his fleshly mind…</em><strong><em>If you died with Christ from the elemental spirits (stoicheiōn) of the world, why, as though living in the world, do you subject yourselves to ordinances, (all of which perish with use), according to the precepts and doctrines of men?” (</em>Colossians 2:13–18, 20–22).</strong></blockquote><p>In the epistle to the Galatians, Paul explains to the Galatians that when both him and his audience were immature (or rhetorically <em>“children”</em>)‭‭, they were in captivity to the elemental principles of the world. And Paul elaborates that when Christ came by means of a woman, He sought to redeem those under the law, so as to be adopted as children. After this explanation, Paul rebukes and asks them on why they seek to return to being in bondage to the elemental principles of the world, while mentioning their observance of seasons. He writes:</p><blockquote><em>“But I say that so long as the heir is a child, he is no different from a bondservant, though he is Lord of all, but is under guardians and stewards until the day appointed by the father. </em><strong><em>So we also, when we were children, were held in bondage under the elemental principles (stoicheiōn) of the world. </em></strong><em>But when the fullness of the time came, </em><strong><em>God sent out his Son, born to a woman, born under the law, that he might redeem those who were under the law, that we might receive the adoption as children</em></strong><em>…But now that you have come to know God, or rather to be known by God, </em><strong><em>why do you turn back again to the weak and miserable elemental principles, to which you desire to be in bondage all over again? </em></strong><em>You observe days, months, seasons, and years” (</em><strong>Galatians 4:1–5, 9–10</strong><em>).</em></blockquote><p>Since we have explored the Pauline passages, allow me to disclose even further. In Colossians, Paul mentions Christ abolishing the handwriting of ordinances, which separated the Jews and Gentiles according to Ephesians. Paul identifies the ordinances as the mosaic laws, angelic worship, and so forth, and he attributes these matters as <em>“elemental principles of the world </em><strong><em>(stoicheion)</em></strong><em>”</em> and <em>“precepts and doctrines of men”</em>. In Galatians, he attributes the mosaic laws to the Galatians as <em>“elemental principles of the world”</em>. In case some do not consider the letter of Colossians to be associating the mosaic laws as <em>“elemental principles”</em> and <em>“precepts of man”</em>, allow me to explain why the fundamentalist interpretation fails. If Paul identifies pagan tradition as elemental principles (in Colossians), and identifies mosaic observance as elemental principles (in Galatians), then by logical inference, he is saying that the mosaic tradition is also a precept and dogma of men. This theological and semantic pattern in Paul’s epistles not only address pagan traditions as elemental principles of the world (or as precepts of men), but also mosaic observance. In addition, Paul uses <strong><em>“stoicheion”</em></strong> and <em>“precepts of man”</em> interchangeably in Colossians 2:20–22, which demonstrates that mosaic observance is part of the precepts of man, and in 2:8, he interconnects <em>“elements (stoicheia) of the world”</em> with <em>“traditions of men” </em>in the same anti-divine influence category.</p><h4>Allegoresis &amp; the Black and White Dichotomy Concerning Law</h4><p>While Paul considers the Torah (and the rest of the books) to be detrimental and uninspired by God, this is not entirely accurate; for instance, Genesis claims that humans are made in the image and likeness of God, Proverbs warns readers from seeking sexually immoral women, and even Paul uses the Old Testament typologically, indicating that he believes that spiritual allegory discloses its transcendental inspiration. When discussing with inerrantists about how the Old Testament is spiritually detrimental, they typically perceive this instantly as rejecting any degree of divine inspiration found in the Hebraic scriptures. According to their logic, if one passage is wrong, then all of them are fallacious, which is a naive epistemology. Despite having this naive epistemology, they don’t apply this same criteria with other areas of knowledge like science, history, and personal relationships. And their excuse is that God didn’t inspire any of these things, but I do believe that God inspired within humans: the progressive discipline of science, historical interest and accuracy, and even inspiring the spark of good friendships.</p><p>Anyway, Paul fathomed the inspiration of the Old Testament as an amalgamation of humans, daemons (<em>i.e. kinds of spirits</em>), and the divine. And for this reason, Paul often cited the Old Testament by the means of allegoresis to disclose the will of God in light of Christ. Beforehand, I said that Paul attributed the mosaic laws as elemental principles or precepts of men, but before he made this claim, he said to the Colossians: “<strong><em>Let no one therefore judge you in eating or drinking, or with respect to a feast day or a new moon or a Sabbath day, which are a shadow of the things to come; but the body [or substance] is Christ’s” (ibid. 2:16–17). </em></strong>He believes that the mosaic laws, when pneumatically interpreted rather than by regular exegesis, prefigures or symbolically portrays the advent of Christ. In another occasion, Paul reinterprets a mosaic command for oxen in reference to believers receiving a fair wage for their service. He says: <strong><em>“Do I speak these things according to the ways of men? Or doesn’t the law also say the same thing? </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/1_corinthians/9-9.htm"><strong><em>9</em></strong></a><strong><em> For it is written in the law of Moses, “You shall not muzzle an ox while it treads out the grain.” Is it for the oxen that God cares, </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/1_corinthians/9-10.htm"><strong><em>10</em></strong></a><strong><em> or does he say it assuredly for our sake? Yes, it was written for our sake, because he who plows ought to plow in hope, and he who threshes in hope should partake of his hope. </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/1_corinthians/9-11.htm"><strong><em>11</em></strong></a><strong><em> If we sowed to you spiritual things, is it a great thing if we reap your fleshly things?”</em></strong> (<strong><em>1st Corin. 9:8–11</em></strong>). When Paul cites the law of Moses as not according to the ways of men, he means the spiritual reading rather than the law in its bare state. Paul asks a dichotomous question on whether God inspired the mosaic command for the oxen to be for the care of oxen, or for the care of believers; in other words, Paul is asking did God inspire the authorial reading or the spiritual reading, and he answers that God fully inspired it for believers while ignoring the historical context of that command. So Paul considers the pneumatic reading to be divinely inspired, instead of the original context of that command (which was obviously commanded for the care of oxen since Christians didn’t exist at the time of the mosaic law, nor are they the subject of the command).</p><p>In another instance, Paul in Galatians cites the Old Testament narrative with similar language he employs in Corinthians, but this, again, is in regard to spiritual allegory. He writes: <strong><em>“Tell me, you that desire to be under the law, don’t you listen to the law? </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/galatians/4-22.htm"><strong><em>22</em></strong></a><strong><em> For it is written that Abraham had two sons, one by the servant, and one by the free woman. </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/galatians/4-23.htm"><strong><em>23</em></strong></a><strong><em> However, the son by the servant was born according to the flesh, but the son by the free woman was born through promise. </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/galatians/4-24.htm"><strong><em>24</em></strong></a><strong><em> These things contain an allegory, for these are two covenants. One is from Mount Sinai, bearing children to bondage, which is Hagar” (Galatians 4:21–24). </em></strong>Whenever Paul cites the Old Testament in an authoritative sense towards those who seek to be in bondage to the law, he appeals merely to the pneumatic, allegorical interpretation. This is where the notable Church Father Origen derives his allegorical method towards the Jewish scriptures (<em>cf. De Principiis IV.12</em>). Origen writes, <strong><em>“For we find the expression, You shall not muzzle the mouth of the ox that treads out the grain. And afterwards, when explaining what precept ought to be understood by this, he adds the words: Does God take care for oxen? Or says He it altogether for our sakes? For our sakes, no </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05141a.htm"><strong><em>doubt</em></strong></a><strong><em>, this is written; that he who ploughs should plough in hope, and he that threshes, in hope of partaking. Very many other passages also of this nature, which are in this way explained of the law, contribute extensive information to the hearers… Now a spiritual interpretation is of this nature: when one is able to point out what are the heavenly things of which these serve as the pat­terns and shadow, who are </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08399a.htm"><strong><em>Jews</em></strong></a><strong><em> according to the flesh, and of what things future the law contains a shadow, and any other expressions of this kind that may be found in </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07386a.htm"><strong><em>holy</em></strong></a><strong><em> Scripture…He composed a texture of both kinds in one style of narration, always concealing the hidden meaning more deeply; but where the historical narrative could not be made appropriate to the spiritual coherence of the occur­rences, He inserted sometimes certain things which either did not take place or could not take place; sometimes also what might happen, but what did not: and He does this at one time in a few words, which, taken in their bodily meaning, seem inca­pable of containing </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15073a.htm"><strong><em>truth</em></strong></a><strong><em>, and at another by the in­sertion of many”</em></strong> (<strong><em>ibid. IV.12–15</em></strong>). According to Origen, there are certain narratives or passages that must not be read according to its plain reading, but should be read in transcending the text to avoid theological incoherence and immoral notions. In another work, he writes in like manner: “<strong><em>[We] would say that we both agree that the books were written by the Spirit of God, but that we do not agree about the meaning of their contents;…we are of opinion that the literal acceptation of the laws is not that which conveys the meaning of the legislation. And we maintain, that “when Moses is read, the veil is upon their heart,” because the meaning of the law of Moses has been concealed from those who have not welcomed the way which is by Jesus Christ. But we know that if one turn to the Lord (for “the Lord is that Spirit”), the veil being taken away, “he beholds, as in a mirror with unveiled face, the glory of the Lord” in those thoughts which are concealed in their literal expression, and to his own glory becomes a participator of the divine glory; the term “face” being used figuratively for the “understanding,” as one would call it without a figure, in which is the face of the “inner man,” filled with light and glory, flowing from the true comprehension of the contents of the law” (Contra Celsum V.60). </em></strong>Origen demonstrates that the textual surface of the law is not inspired by the Spirit, but only by spiritual, figurative interpretation can the law endow a genuine understanding of its contents. In case an anti-Origen spirit condemns the interpretive work of Origen, let us hear what Gregory the Wonder-worker (a student of Origen) think of his interpretive method:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“And he himself became the interpreter of the </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12477a.htm"><strong><em>prophets</em></strong></a><strong><em> to us, and explained whatsoever was dark or enigmatical in them. For there are many things of that kind in the sacred words…Now that greatest gift this man has received from </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06608a.htm"><strong><em>God</em></strong></a><strong><em>, and that noblest of all endowments he has had bestowed upon him from heaven, that he should be an interpreter of the oracles of God to </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09580c.htm"><strong><em>men</em></strong></a><strong><em>, and that he might understand the words of </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06608a.htm"><strong><em>God</em></strong></a><strong><em>, even as if God spoke them to him, and that he might recount them to men in such wise as that they may hear them with intelligence” (</em>Panegyric to Origen, Argument 15 by Gregory Thaumaturgus<em>).</em></strong></blockquote><p>Here again, Paul applies the spiritual interpretation concerning Abraham and his offspring: <strong><em>“Now the promises were spoken to Abraham and to his offspring He doesn’t say, ‘To descendants’, as of many, but as of one, ‘To your offspring’, which is Christ”</em></strong> (<strong><em>Galatians 3:16</em></strong>). If Paul intended a grammatical argument, he would certainly be a fool, because offspring or seed doesn’t just mean one child, but it can extend to mean many. And here is some context: <strong><em>“Yahweh said to Abram, after Lot was separated from him, “Now, lift up your eyes, and look from the place where you are, northward and southward and eastward and westward, 15 for I will give all the land which you see to you and to your offspring forever. 16 I will make your offspring as the dust of the earth, so that if a man can count the dust of the earth, then your offspring may also be counted. 17 Arise, walk through the land in its length and in its width; for I will give it to you”</em> </strong>(<strong><em>Genesis 13:14–17</em></strong>). When verse 15 for offspring is read in context to verse 16, the argument for a single seed becomes evidently false to a diligent reader, and the land has more relevance for the children of Israel than Jesus does. Here’s another example: <strong><em>“Abraham said to him, “Beware that you don’t bring my son there again. 7 Yahweh, the God of heaven — who took me from my father’s house, and from the land of my birth, who spoke to me, and who swore to me, saying, ‘I will give this land to your offspring — he will send his angel before you, and you shall take a wife for my son from there”</em></strong><em> (</em><strong><em>Genesis 24:6–7</em></strong><em>)</em>. Again, the offspring is identified with Israel since the land is relevant to them, even Genesis 26:3b — 5 says, <strong><em>“For I will give all these lands to you and your offspring, and I will confirm the oath that I swore to your father Abraham. 4 </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/2233.htm"><strong><em>I will make your descendants</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/7235.htm"><strong><em>as numerous</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/3556.htm"><strong><em>as the stars</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/8064.htm"><strong><em>in the sky,</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/5414.htm"><strong><em>and I will give</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/2233.htm"><strong><em>them</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/3605.htm"><strong><em>all</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/411.htm"><strong><em>these</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/776.htm"><strong><em>lands,</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/2233.htm"><strong><em>and through your offspring</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/3605.htm"><strong><em>all</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/1471.htm"><strong><em>nations</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/776.htm"><strong><em>of the earth</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/hebrew/1288.htm"><strong><em>will be blessed,</em></strong></a><strong><em> 5 because Abraham listened to My voice and kept My charge, My commandments, My statutes, and My laws,” </em></strong>which indicates that the offspring is Israel again due to the plurality of the stars mentioned. Since Paul implicitly means a figurative method of interpretation concerning the seed of Abraham, we must not render his argument as grammatical. The pneumatic mode of interpretation often appeals to symbols, and sometimes solecisms (akin to this Pauline example above) to make an interpretation in favor of Christ and the Church.</p><p>In the Book of the Hebrews, the author renders the old covenant as being faulty, in need of correction, and he narrates the Old Testament, modifying its meaning by means of spiritual allegory; for example, he says: <strong><em>“But now he has obtained a more excellent ministry, by as much as he is also the mediator of a better covenant, which on better promises has been given as law. For if that first covenant had been faultless, then no place would have been sought for a second”</em></strong> (<strong>Hebrews 8:6–7</strong>). The author blames the covenant as being fallible, and he blames the people as well in verse 8, but he places ultimate blame on the covenant for its inadequate nature since he alludes to the Jeremiah covenant, while giving it a new meaning contrary to the authorial intent. Again, he writes: <strong><em>“Now these things having been thus prepared, the priests go in continually into the first tabernacle, accomplishing the services, but into the second the high priest alone, once in the year, not without blood, which he offers for himself and for the errors of the people. The Holy Spirit is indicating this, that the way into the Holy Place wasn’t yet revealed while the first tabernacle was still standing. This is a symbol (parabolē) of the present age, where gifts and sacrifices are offered that are incapable, concerning the conscience, of making the worshiper perfect, being only (with foods and drinks and various washings) fleshly ordinances, imposed until a time of reformation (diorthōseōs)”</em></strong> (<strong><em>ibid. 9:6–10</em></strong>). The author of Hebrews narrates the old priesthood, and employs spiritual allegory into it (again) by saying <em>“the Holy Spirit is indicating”</em> and <em>“this is a symbol of the present age”. </em>He then argues that these regulations from the old priesthood (or covenant) were imposed until a time where Christ would correct them. There cannot be a reformation for a system if there’s no error in the system; the purpose of a reformation is to correct or rectify present errors. When believers forcibly attempt to make the author of Hebrews suggest that the people were the sole fallible cause and not the covenant, render his allegorical interpretations as grammatical readings, and conflate his narrations of the Old Testament as historical opinions, they have created a narrative that’s not only alien to Hebrews, but to Paul and the patristic world. And if their reading was supposedly valid, then the whole theme of the old covenant being faulty, inferior, and in need of a reformation, and his parabolic language being employed throughout the letter would all be meaningless readings, and the text itself would be unintelligible, devoid of literary structure, and paradoxical. This being said, their reading of Hebrews is gibberish nonsense, whereas my reading of Hebrews renders their interpretations as being impossible and purely fanciful.</p><p>One of the greatest orthodox Fathers, defender of the Nicene Creed, Athanasius himself, denied the narrative where God commands sacrifices, and his scriptural appeal was Jeremiah, Colossians 2:17, and Hebrews 9:10 (the same references I made). He writes, <em>“</em><strong><em>Now it appears to me — may God grant, by your prayers, that the remarks I presume to make may not be far from the truth — that not at first were the commandment and the law concerning sacrifices, neither did the mind of God, Who gave the law, regard whole burnt-offerings, but those things which were pointed out and prefigured by them. ‘For the law contained a shadow of good things to come.’ And, ‘Those things were appointed until the time of reformation…Therefore neither at the beginning, when God brought the people out of Egypt, did He command them concerning sacrifices or whole burnt-offerings, nor even when they came to mount Sinai”</em> (<em>Letter 19, section 3–4</em>). </strong>Athanasius believed God inspired the pneumatic reading behind the law, instead of the historical-grammatical reading. Just as Paul and Hebrews deny complete inspiration of the grammatical reading of the Old Testament, so does Origen, the great Athanasius, and myself.</p><h4>Mystical Fulfillment of Christ</h4><p>The grammatical reading is often appealed to by Christians to suggest that Jesus fulfilled the so-called prophecies, which convinces the average person that has never read the Hebrew Bible. And once they become Christians, regardless of the amount of textual evidence and superior exegesis, they resort to denial, slander, and persistent apologetic tactics (<em>or manipulation — I laugh</em>). As I have demonstrated through the Pauline epistles, he reinterpreted the Old Testament in light of Christ (<em>Book of Hebrews in 10:1 as well</em>). To find Christ in the scriptures by the aid of allegoresis (or spiritual allegory), we must appeal to the symbols and solecisms or subtleties that are remain in the Judaic writings. Here is a selection of quotes from the Fathers who affirmed this kind of fulfillment:</p><blockquote>Origen of Alexandria (AD 185–256):</blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>“Many, not understanding the </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/bible/index.html"><strong><em>Scriptures</em></strong></a><strong><em> in a spir­itual sense, but incorrectly, have fallen into </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07256b.htm"><strong><em>heresies</em></strong></a><strong><em>. These particulars, then, being briefly stated regarding the inspiration of the sacred Scriptures by the </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07409a.htm"><strong><em>Holy Spirit</em></strong></a><strong><em>, it seems necessary to explain this point also</em></strong><em>, viz., how certain </em><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11726a.htm"><em>persons</em></a><em>, not reading them correctly, have given themselves over to erroneous opinions, inasmuch as the procedure to be followed, in order to attain an understanding of the </em><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07386a.htm"><em>holy</em></a><em> writings, is unknown to many. </em><strong><em>The </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08399a.htm"><strong><em>Jews</em></strong></a><strong><em>, in fine, owing to the hardness of their heart, and from a desire to appear wise in their own eyes, have not </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02408b.htm"><strong><em>believed</em></strong></a><strong><em> in our Lord and Saviour, judging that those statements which were uttered respecting Him ought to be understood literally,…</em></strong><em>And </em><strong><em>seeing that, according to history, there was no accomplishment of any of those things predicted of Him, in which they </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02408b.htm"><strong><em>believed</em></strong></a><strong><em> the signs of </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08374c.htm"><strong><em>Christ’s</em></strong></a><strong><em> advent were espe­cially to be observed, they refused to acknowledge the presence of </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08374c.htm"><strong><em>our Lord Jesus Christ</em></strong></a><em>” (</em><strong>De Principiis IV.7–8</strong><em>). </em>When Origen says “literal”, he means the grammatical reading and not excessive literalism since he addresses the divine intention of the scriptures and not the authorial intention of such in De Principiis.</blockquote><blockquote>Clement of Alexandria (AD 150–215):</blockquote><blockquote><em>“</em><strong><em>This, then, is the type of “the law and the prophets which were until John”; while he [John], though speaking more perspicuously as no longer prophesying, but pointing out as now present, Him [Christ], who was proclaimed symbolically from the beginning</em></strong><em>, nevertheless said, “I am not worthy to loose the latchet of the Lord’s shoe.” For he confesses that he is not worthy to baptize so great a Power; for it behooves those, who purify others, to free the soul from the body and its sins, as the foot from the thong. Perhaps also this signified the final exertion of the Savior’s power toward us — the immediate,</em><strong><em> I mean — that by His presence, concealed in the enigma of prophecy, inasmuch as he, by pointing out to sight Him that had been prophesied of, and indicating the Presence which had come, walking forth into the light, loosed the latchet of the oracles of the [old] economy, by unveiling the meaning of the symbols” (</em>Stromata 5.8<em>). </em></strong>Clement teaches that Christ was prefigured or predicted merely by the symbols of the [old] economy (or Hebrew scriptures), and he demonstrates this example even through John the Baptist.</blockquote><blockquote>Irenaeus of Lyons (AD 130–180?):</blockquote><blockquote><em>“But Jeremiah also says, In the last days they shall understand these things. (Jeremiah 23:20)</em><strong><em> For every prophecy, before its fulfillment, is to men [full of] enigmas and ambiguities. But when the time has arrived, and the prediction has come to pass, then the prophecies have a clear and certain exposition.</em></strong><em> And for this reason, </em><strong><em>indeed, when at this present time the law is read to the Jews, it is like a fable; for they do not possess the explanation of all things pertaining to the advent of the Son of God</em></strong><em>, which took place in human nature; but </em><strong><em>when it is read by the Christians, it is a treasure, hid indeed in a field, but brought to light by the cross of Christ,</em></strong><em>…</em><strong><em>”</em></strong><em> (</em><strong>Against Heresies: Book IV.26.1</strong><em>). </em>According to Irenaeus, all of the prophetic expressions for Christ were hidden within the scriptures, rather than being exposed by its bare or textual state; some have ventured on elsewhere in Irenaeus’ volumes to suggest that he meant the authorial reading, but Irenaeus did not have grammatical awareness of the Isaiah chapter, and this appeal from Irenaeus was polemical in nature (polemics are often bias) and this was previous to when he composed book 4 since he likely changed his mind overtime due to his current assertion of all predictive expressions for Christ being hidden; hence, the counter-argument in question doesn’t work.</blockquote><blockquote>Didascalia Apostolorum (AD 250+):</blockquote><blockquote><em>“But this (the Sabbath) has been set as a type for the times, even as many other things have been set for a type. The Sabbath therefore is a type of the (final) rest, signifying the seventh thousand (years), but </em><strong><em>the Lord our Savior, when He came, fulfilled the types and explained the parables,</em></strong><em> and He showed those things that are life-giving, and those that cannot help He did away, and those that cannot give life He abolished”</em> (<strong>Chapter 26 translated by R. Hugh Connolly</strong>). According to the Didascalia (an authoritative church document), the only fulfillment ever mentioned by it is typological or symbolic in nature, and there is no citation of any grammatical or contextual appeal for prophetic fulfillment.</blockquote><blockquote>Fortunatianus of Aquileia (AD 300=370):</blockquote><blockquote><em>“</em><strong><em>Whatever the Old Testament contains figuratively (figuraliter)</em></strong><em>, the New has fulfilled through the very reason of truth”</em> (<strong>Fortunatianus, Commentary on the Gospels, lines 181,182</strong>). The author of this commentary declares that every figure or symbolic expression of the Old Testament was fulfilled by the Advent of Christ, yet he makes no comment on the grammatical reading.</blockquote><blockquote>Novation (AD 200–258):</blockquote><blockquote>“<em>But how perverse are the </em><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08399a.htm"><em>Jews</em></a><em>, and remote from the understanding of their law, I have fully shown, as I </em><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02408b.htm"><em>believe</em></a><em>, in two former letters, </em><strong><em>wherein it was absolutely </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12454c.htm"><strong><em>proved</em></strong></a><strong><em> that they are </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07648a.htm"><strong><em>ignorant</em></strong></a><strong><em> of what is the </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15073a.htm"><strong><em>true</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03777a.htm"><strong><em>circumcision</em></strong></a><strong><em>, and what the </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15073a.htm"><strong><em>true</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/13287b.htm"><strong><em>Sabbath</em></strong></a><strong><em>…Therefore, first of all, we must avail ourselves of that passage, that the law is spiritual; (</em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/bible/rom007.htm#verse14"><strong><em>Romans 7:14</em></strong></a><strong><em>) and if they deny it to be spiritual, they assuredly </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02595a.htm"><strong><em>blaspheme</em></strong></a><strong><em>; if, avoiding </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02595a.htm"><strong><em>blasphemy</em></strong></a><strong><em>, they confess it to be spiritual, let them read it spiritually. For divine things must be divinely received, and must assuredly be maintained as </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07386a.htm"><strong><em>holy</em></strong></a><strong><em>. </em></strong><em>But a </em><strong><em>grave fault is branded on those who attach earthly and </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09580c.htm"><strong><em>human</em></strong></a><strong><em> doctrine to sacred and spiritual words</em></strong><em>; and this we must </em><strong><em>beware of doing</em></strong><em>. Moreover, we may beware, </em><strong><em>if any things enjoined by </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06608a.htm"><strong><em>God</em></strong></a><strong><em> be so treated as if they were assumed to diminish His authority, test, in calling some things impure and unclean, their institution should dishonour their ordainer. For in reprobating what He has made, He will appear to have condemned His own works, which He had approved as good; and He will be designated as seeming capricious in both cases, as the </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07256b.htm"><strong><em>heretics</em></strong></a><strong><em> indeed would have it; either in having blessed things which were not clean, or in subsequently reprobating as not good</em></strong><em>, creatures which He had blessed as both clean and good. And </em><strong><em>of this the enormity and contradiction will remain for ever if that Jewish doctrine is persisted in, which must be got rid of with all our ability</em></strong><em>; so that whatever is irregularly delivered by them,</em><strong><em> may be taken away by us, and a suitable arrangement of His works, and an appropriate and spiritual application of the </em></strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09071a.htm"><strong><em>divine law</em></strong></a><strong><em>, may be restored…</em></strong><em>And thus there was a certain ancient time, wherein </em><strong><em>those shadows or figures were to be used, that meats should be abstained from which had indeed been commended by their creation, but had been prohibited by the law. </em></strong><em>But now </em><strong><em>Christ, the end of the law, has come, disclosing all the obscurities of the law</em></strong><em>”</em> (On the Jewish Meats, Chapter 1–2, 5). Novation would consider certain Christians who believe God prohibited certain meats as impure, contradicting the divine decree of them being good or pure, to be heretics, because he emphasizes from the Apostle that the law should have always been understood in spiritual interpretation, instead of indulging the bare text. He explains these ritual procedures as being obscurities needed to be disclosed by His advent typologically to inspire the Jews apart from their literal adherence by abolishing the law. Novation and patristic Barnabas share the same view: God did not literally forbid pork, but sought to teach spiritual lessons through them (<strong>cf. The Epistle of Barnabas 10.2–3, 9</strong>).</blockquote><h4>Exegetical &amp; Theological Confusion</h4><p>Some will venture on to argue that Jesus fulfilled the mosaic law in totality (and without contradiction) by citing Matthew 5:17–18, which says: <a href="https://www.bible.com/bible/compare/MAT.5.17-18"><strong><em>“Do not think that I came to destroy the Law or the Prophets. I did not come to destroy but to fulfill. For assuredly, I say to you, till heaven and earth pass away, one jot or one tittle will by no means pass from the law till all is fulfilled.</em></strong></a><strong><em>” </em></strong>But this argument fails entirely, because Jesus is most likely exaggerating the manner of fulfillment since letters (as in the bare alphabet) can’t be prophetically fulfilled. Another point of interest is that Matthew’s gospel has a significantly distinct portrayal of Jesus versus Mark’s gospel; for instance, Mark narrates Jesus contradicting the kosher laws, while Matthew alters this same narrative to present a Jesus who is consistent with the mosaic laws (<em>by replacing kosher laws with hand washings</em>). Permit me to share these two contrary narratives:</p><blockquote>So Jesus said, “Are you also still without understanding? 17 Do you not yet understand that whatever enters the mouth goes into the stomach and is eliminated? 18 But those things which proceed out of the mouth come from the heart, and they defile a man. 19 For out of the heart proceed evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, fornication, thefts, false witness, blasphemies. 20 <strong>These are <em>the things</em> which defile a man, but to eat with unwashed hands does not defile a man.</strong>” — Matthew 15:16–20</blockquote><blockquote>He said to them, <strong>“Are you thus without understanding also? Do you not perceive that whatever enters a man from outside cannot defile him, 19 because it does not enter his heart but his stomach, and is eliminated” — [<em>thus He]</em> purified all foods? </strong>20 And He said, “What comes out of a man, that defiles a man. 21 For from within, out of the heart of men, proceed evil thoughts, adulteries, fornication, murders, 22 thefts, covetousness, wickedness, deceit, lewdness, an evil eye, blasphemy, pride, foolishness. 23 <strong>All these evil things come from within and defile a man.</strong>” — Mark 7:18–23</blockquote><p>Some have argued that Mark 7:19 was later interpolated, that Jesus in Mark supposedly meant hand-washings, or that the translation is inaccurate, but none of these objections resolve the issue. I have handled these objections prior in a <a href="https://medium.com/@theopneustos-writer/mark-7-19-interpolated-or-faithful-e4b8ebe6b86d"><strong>previous medium post</strong></a><strong>.</strong> Mark 7:19 was not interpolated since the earliest manuscripts (including the<strong> </strong><a href="https://codexsinaiticus.org/en/manuscript.aspx?book=34&amp;chapter=7&amp;lid=en&amp;side=r&amp;verse=2&amp;zoomSlider=0"><strong>Codex Sinaiticus</strong></a>) contains it, Jesus in Mark 7 was understood by the earliest Christians like Gregory Thaumaturgus (<em>AD 213–275</em>) as being in reference to the dietary laws, and finally, this translation is conceptual since certain Koine Greek phrases or sentences make no intelligible sense if translated verbatim (<em>cf. Canonical Epistle, Canon I</em>). I have already addressed the other lengthy objections in my previous post (<em>the link is provided above</em>).</p><p>The Gospel of Matthew employs a polemical route since its audience is plausibly a Jewish audience, especially for unbelieving Jews. But the Gospel of Mark propels itself in the Pauline direction, which is why Paul argued for the mosaic customs as being humanly concocted and needing to be abolished by the advent of Christ. It is not an aberration for Matthew to alter narratives contrary to other New Testament narratives; for example, Matthew demonstrates a remorseful and troubled Judas returning the money to the chief priests, which he earned by betraying Jesus, while <em>Acts of the Apostles</em> narrates Judas employing this same money he had received to buy a field (<em>cf. Matthew 27:3; Acts 1:18</em>). Some have ventured to argue that Judas returned some of the money to the chief priests, but Matthew narrates that Judas returned the full sum, so this theory is false. Even if it wasn’t the full sum (since some Christians are stubborn), if Judas returned some of the money, then this would have contradicted his remorseful sentiment; thus, the narrative would be contradictory and the emotional flow would be inconsistent. It’s better to leave this narrative alone lest you ruin the literary flow with your inerrantist dogma. If this contradiction didn’t suffice, both Judas and the chief priests buy a field bearing the same name after similar reasons with the same money, and this isn’t possible to reconcile (<em>cf. Acts 1:18; Matthew 27:6–10</em>). Matthew altered the narrative of Judas to present him as a “spiritual” fulfillment of a certain Old Testament passage despite the Book of Acts displaying a contrary narration. Some even argue that Judas bought the field (<em>with “the money glitch” — a video game phrase where money is duplicated after violating gaming mechanics</em>) to commit suicide, which is not a realistic narrative. No one needs to buy a field to commit suicide; this whole narrative is unrealistic if one attempts to reconcile these legitimate contradictions. Matthew’s motif is not historical accuracy, instead it’s driven by polemical motivations.</p><p>The Gospel of Matthew due to its Judaic tendencies was upheld by a small, early Christian sect (<em>i.e. the Ebionites</em>), while Paul’s epistles were shunned by them. If we end up prioritizing the Gospel of Matthew above the other written Gospels and Paul’s epistles, then the temptation of adhering to the mosaic laws becomes more plausible (<em>cf. Against Heresies I.26.1; reported by Irenaeus of Lyons</em>). But we know that the author of Hebrews has considered the mosaic customs (especially the sacrificial laws) to have been abolished (<em>cf. Hebrews 8:13</em>).</p><h4>Deciphering Paul on Romans 7 (&amp; Galatians 3)</h4><p><strong>Romans 7.4:</strong><em> “In the same way, my friends, you have died to the law through the body of Christ,” —</em> Paul explains to the Jewish audience (since he names his recipients in verse one) that Christ abolished the cultural application of the law. <strong>Romans 7.5–6:</strong> <em>“While we were living in the flesh, our sinful passions, aroused by the law, were at work in our members to bear fruit for death. But now we are discharged from the law, dead to that which held us captive, so that we are slaves not under the old written code but in the new life of the Spirit” — </em>Paul expresses that the cultural application of the law aroused sinful tendencies due to its permissive attitude towards slaughtering children, plundering virgins, polygamy, ruthlessly treating Gentile slaves, etc., but Christ elevated them to transcend these cultural norms by exemplifying them to live according to the divine Spirit. <strong>Romans 7.7–12, 14: </strong><em>“What then should we say? That the law is sin? By no means! Yet, if it had not been for the law, I would not have known sin. I would not have known what it is to covet if the law had not said, ‘You shall not covet.’ 8 But sin, seizing an opportunity in the commandment, produced in me all kinds of covetousness. Apart from the law sin lies dead. 9 I was once alive apart from the law, but when the commandment came, sin revived 10 and I died, and the very commandment that promised life proved to be death to me. 11 For sin, seizing an opportunity in the commandment, deceived me and through it killed me. 12 So the law is holy, and the commandment is holy and just and good…14 For we know that the law is spiritual; but I am of the flesh, sold into slavery under sin.” </em>Paul first affirms the morally detrimental aspects of the law, but then he affirms that the law is spiritual, but this does not mean that the bare contents of the law are always benevolent since he means the spiritual, allegorical aspects of the law, including the Decalogue to some extent. Paul elaborates that they were captives to the old ordinances of the law, but also that he was a captive under sin to justify the [<em>pneumatic reading of the</em>] law latterly, while blaming the [<em>cultural ordinances of the</em>] law formerly. Paul makes a similar commentary on the law in the epistle to the Galatians: <strong><em>“What purpose then does the law serve? It was added because of transgressions, till the Seed should come to whom the promise was made, and the law was appointed through angels by the hand of a mediator. Now a mediator is not one, but God is one. Is the law then against the promises of God? Certainly not”</em></strong> (<em>3:19–21</em>). Why did Paul inquire suddenly that the law is against the promises of God — and then respond with a negative? Because he said that the law was given by angels initially (and then a medium), and he contrasts the role of a mediator with God’s singular nature, because he is arguing that the mediator has a mixed (daemonic-human) message (thus it’s faulty), while God has a unanimous revelation. Eastern Orthodox scholar, David B. Hart, agrees with my assessment on Paul, so he writes:</p><blockquote><strong><em>“We, though, tend to read right past Paul’s remarks to the Galatians that the old law was imperfect because it came not directly from God, but from his angel (the angel who reigned over Israel and who appeared to Moses) and was passed through a human mediator (Moses himself). The promise of the new age, by contrast, is that now all of these heavenly powers have been subdued again, under the foot of Christ, and in the age to come Christ himself will rule over all of creation directly”</em></strong><em> (</em><a href="https://www.firstthings.com/web-exclusives/2011/04/the-power-of-the-sword"><strong>The Power of the Sword</strong></a><em>).</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>“[T]he Law of Moses was flawed and devoid of saving significance because it was written only by angels (Galatians 3:10–11, 19–20)” (</em></strong><a href="https://davidbentleyhart.substack.com/p/which-gnosticism-whose-orthodoxy"><strong>Whose Orthodoxy? Which Gnosticism?</strong></a><strong><em>)</em></strong><em>.</em></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>“They are cursed by a law that was in fact ordained by lesser, merely angelic powers. Galatians quite clearly says the law was written by angels and delivered through human mediators. So even the law comes to us in a defective form because the angels that govern the nations, even the angel that governs Israel apparently — the Angel of the Lord, is defective in his rule” (To be honest, I have seen this quotation twice, but I don’t know the source for it: </em></strong><a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/AcademicBiblical/comments/16vllm3/what_role_did_the_angels_play_in_the_giving_of/"><strong>On Reddit</strong></a><strong> &amp; </strong><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/59741485"><strong>Kenogaia: A Gnostic Tale</strong></a><strong> [under Matthew Winbow’s comment]<em>). I assume it’s in his NT translation; I don’t own it yet.</em></strong></blockquote><p>Furthermore, the apostle distinguished the law in two manners: <em>“we are discharged from the law, dead to that which held us captive…slaves not under the old written code,”</em> indicating its somatic state as being malevolent (particularly the cultural ordinances), and <em>“the law is holy…spiritual,”</em> indicating its spiritual state as being benevolent. This kind of interpretation is made by Origen when he said:<strong><em> “In accordance with this the Apostle everywhere prefers the spirit and repudiates the flesh or that which belongs to the flesh. After all, he himself praises the spirit of the law but spurns the letter as if flesh when he says, “The letter kills but the spirit gives life,” </em>[2nd Corinthians 3:6]<em>…It is on account of these laws that the law is weak according to the letter, that is, according to the flesh. For that reason, the Apostle says, “For the law is spiritual,”…And Moses and Elijah appeared in glory, speaking with Jesus on the mountain. In this the law and the prophets are shown to harmonize with the Gospels and to shine forth with the same glory when viewed and interpreted spiritually”</em></strong> (<strong>Commentary on Romans, Book I, Chapter 10</strong>). Novation likewise (as cited prior) said, “<strong><em>the law is spiritual…[if] they confess it to be spiritual, let them read it spiritually”.</em></strong></p><p>To summarize all this, here is Origen’s interpretation of Romans 2:</p><blockquote><strong><em>Natural law is able to agree with the law of Moses according to the spirit but not according to the letter. </em></strong><em>For </em><strong><em>what natural insight shall there be in the command, for instance, that a person should circumcise his infant son on the eighth day; or that wool ought not be woven together with linen</em></strong><em>; or that one must not eat anything with yeast in it during the feast of unleavened bread? </em><strong><em>At different times I have presented such texts to the Jews and demanded of them that if there is something of benefit in such laws, let them make it known. We know that they usually give only this answer, “This is what has seemed good to the Lawgiver.” But we who are aware that all these things must be understood spiritually believe therefore that it is “not the hearers but the doers of the law who will be justified, “but not the law according to the letter, since, because of its unattainableness, it cannot have any doer. Rather it is according to the Spirit, through which means alone is it possible for the law to be fulfilled.</em></strong><em> This, then, is the work of the law which the Apostle says even the Gentiles are able to fulfill by nature. For when they do the things of the law it seems that God has written the law on their hearts, “not with ink but with the Spirit of the living God” [</em><strong>2nd Corinthians 3:3</strong><em>] (</em>ibid. Book II, Chapter 9<em>).</em></blockquote><p>My brethren, from now on, let us interpret the sacred writings of the old covenant in a manner worthy of God, and by the spiritual method of interpretation. When patristic tradition (including Paul and Hebrews) has conferred a means to interpreting the scriptures, it should not be neglected for the emphasis of biblical inerrancy or the grammatical reading, which leads to death and mental insanity. I pray that you heed the oracles of God given by the apostles and spoken by the apostolic fathers — and myself. Amen.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=867f2c672ef1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Responding to Kevin G Smith]]></title>
            <link>https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/responding-to-kevin-g-smith-8dab9ce51fdd?source=rss-446f9887eae0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8dab9ce51fdd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christocentric]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[synopsis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gospel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christian-faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christocentricity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[George M. Garcia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 08 Feb 2024 04:15:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-08T04:15:48.238Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Brief Synopsis on the Christocentric Principle</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cZOB9qbuEcad9Lwy" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@devasangbam?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Dev Asangbam</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h4>In Response to:</h4><iframe src="https://drive.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=https%3A//sats.ac.za/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Smith-The-Christocentric-Principle-Promise-Pitfalls-and-Proposal_0.pdf&amp;embedded=true" width="600" height="780" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/fd6ae9d8d20736aff1b0bcf91f37c4c9/href">https://medium.com/media/fd6ae9d8d20736aff1b0bcf91f37c4c9/href</a></iframe><h4>The Christocentric Principle (1st Section)</h4><blockquote>I will be quoting Keith’s work in this manner. And I’ll be responding without using this format. Keep in mind, I don’t wish to comment on all of the material but in particular, his view of the pitfalls of the Christocentric principle.</blockquote><p><strong>Kevin: </strong><em>Dr Christopher Peppler founded the South African Theological Seminary (SATS) on three pillars, summed in our by-line as Biblebased, Christ-centred, and Spirit-led. As an evangelical seminary offering Master’s and Doctoral degrees in theology, we have stressed the Bible-based aspect, partly to distinguish ourselves from the more liberal approaches that predominate in the theological departments of South African universities.</em></p><p>Kevin implicitly conflates the actual Christocentric principle (not the evangelical conception) with some Christian-liberal innovation, which is a biased argument derived from his sensibilities to his theological tradition. Some liberal Christians like Matthew Vines would affirm the doctrine of inerrancy. This kind of address demonstrates his ignorance on how the Gospels, Paul, Hebrews, and how the patristic tradition view Christ’s relationship with the Hebraic scriptures (<em>cf. Matthew 17:1–8; John 12:34–36; Romans 10:4; 1st Corinthians 9:9–11 by Paul; Hebrews 8:7, 9:6–10, 10:1; Philadelphians 8.2–9.2 by Ignatius; Barnabas 10:2–3, 9; Contra Celsum V.60 by Origen</em>).</p><p><em>The idea was simple. Since the words and works of the Lord Jesus Christ constituted the climax of God’s acts of self-revelation, providing the clearest picture of the nature, will, and purposes of God, we should begin a topical study by considering what Jesus said and did. We should then turn to the Old Testament, which enables us to contextualise Christ’s words and works within the unfolding plan and purposes of God. The Old Testament provides the rationale for Jesus’s words and works; it helps us to understand ‘the why’ behind his revelatory life and deeds.</em></p><p>Simply learning and studying the life of Jesus does not cause anyone to understand the context of the Old Testament, which is why many Christian denominations (including Judaized Christians) cannot agree on the topic of atonement, eschatology, anthropology, morality, soteriology, exegesis, etc. Israelite religion (not-to-mention its gradual evolution) is very distant and foreign to many Christians when Hebrew scholars or exegetical experts expound upon it. The Old Testament does not disclose on why Jesus abolished the kosher principle, why He died on the cross, and why He preached the gospel to the dead. The authorial reading has no room or conception of a crucified, divine, and resurrected messiah. The early Church employed spiritual allegory or allegoresis to express Christ through the old scriptures since they believed in transcendental inspiration being disclosed by allegoresis. The Lord taught this pneumatic mode of interpretation to the disciples (<em>cf. Luke 24:27</em>). Kevin doesn’t seem to understand that their understanding of the Hebrew scriptures was not a purely exegetical or authorial manner; it was a Hellenistic mode of surveying the old writings/scriptures.</p><h4>2nd Edition: So-called Pitfalls</h4><p><strong>Kevin: </strong><em>The christocentric principle might leave us vulnerable to forming a canon within a canon. We might develop a two-tier approach to the scriptures in which we treat the gospels as superior revelation to the remainder of the scriptures. As evangelical interpreters, the whole canon of scripture, soundly interpreted, is our norm for belief and behaviour. The completed canon is the Word of God to the people of God. We are the people of the book, and the completed canon is our final and sufficient record of God’s revelation to us. Therefore, we have a canonical approach to theology. The completed canon is the locus of theology…In emphasising Christ as the full and final revelation of the God (which he is), the christocentric principle can lead to a theological praxis in which the gospels are treated as more inspired than the other scriptures. What Jesus said and did is ‘grade A’ revelation. What Moses or Paul wrote is ‘grade B’ — still inspired, but less important. This could lead to the glorification of the gospels, and theology based on a canon within the canon. Theologians who do not accept the full inspiration and authority of all scripture sometimes adopt a similar approach, viewing the gospel (the Christ-life or the Christ-event) as the true revelation that corrects the misrepresentation of God in earlier writings.</em></p><p>Firstly, Christians of the three mainstream branches (<em>e.g. Protestantism, Roman Catholicism, &amp; Eastern Orthodoxy</em>) cannot even agree on what the Old Testament canon is, so this argument of <em>“the completed canon is our final and sufficient record of God’s revelation to us” </em>is problematic for Protestants if they cannot determine what the canon list should really be. This then renders their theology or record of God’s revelation limited or incomplete based on Kevin’s assumption.<strong> [And saying the Protestant canon is universally acceptable is an obvious fallacy; if some books are taken away from the larger canon in order to argue that one’s canon is universally acceptable predicates on sheer nonsense]</strong>. The whole grade or level of inspirations is a matter solved by Origen and the Fathers, because they believe that transcendental inspiration was imparted throughout the scriptures while being disclosed by spiritual allegory, which renders the authorial reading (if uninspired) as being irrelevant (<em>cf. First Principles IV.15 by Origen; Confessions 6.4 by Augustine on Ambrose; Ad Constantium 9.2 by Hilary; The Responses to Thalassios 65.33 by Maximus</em>). But I would argue that while the revelation of Christ should serve as a magisterial guide over the misrepresentation of God in the Old Testament, there are other means to discerning the nature of God like sapient philosophy, mysticism, and church tradition (<em>cf. Ephesians 1:17–19; 1st Corinthians 2:13–16; 2nd Thessalonians 2:15, e.g. “hold to the traditions which you were taught by us, either by word of mouth…”</em>). I advocate the Quadrilateral approach, instead of a misguided scriptural approach in discovering truth, which is akin to a car missing three other tires.</p><p>Secondly, Kevin believes holding the Gospels superior to the Old Testament writings is problematic despite giving no valid premise for this conclusion. However, the revelation of Christ was understood by Ignatius of Antioch (disciple of the apostles) as being superior to the Hebraic writings:<strong> “For I heard some men saying, ‘If I find it not in the [magisterial/ἀρχείοις] records, I do not believe in the Gospel,’ and when I said to them that it is in the Scripture, they answered me, ‘That is exactly the question.’ But to me, Jesus Christ has become the [magisterial/ ἀρχεῖά] record: the inviolable charter is His cross, and death, and resurrection, and the faith which is through Him…” </strong>(To the Philadelphians 8.2). Ignatius disagrees with those who see Hebraic scriptures (presumably) as being magisterial, but he explains to them that full incarnation of Christ is the magisterial and inviolable record. “<strong>But the Gospel has its own preeminence: the appearance of the Savior, our Lord Jesus Christ, His passion, and the resurrection, because the beloved prophets proclaimed into Him, but the fulfillment of the Gospel has become incorruptible” (</strong>ibid. 9.2<strong>). </strong>The theme of Christ’s revelation being superior to the Hebraic writings is well established in his epistle to the Philadelphians. The true Christocentric principle was affirmed even by a disciple of the apostles, so Kevin’s disagreement with early Christianity is not only unorthodox, but an alien deviation from it.</p><p>Lastly, when Ignatius says Christ is in the scriptures, he means the pneumatic reading but not the authorial reading that modern Christians presuppose, which the fulfillment is also understood by Paul, Irenaeus, Origen, and Fortunatianus as being pneumatic. I say this in case readers misunderstand what Ignatius is saying. Here are some examples:</p><blockquote><strong>“Therefore do not let anyone judge you by what you eat or drink, or with regard to a religious festival, a New Moon celebration or a Sabbath day. These are a shadow of the things that were to come; the substance belongs to Christ” (Colossians 2:16–17). — Paul</strong></blockquote><blockquote>“<strong>But Jeremiah also says, In the last days they shall understand these things. (</strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/bible/jer023.htm#verse20"><strong>Jeremiah 23:20</strong></a><strong>) For every </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12473a.htm"><strong>prophecy</strong></a><strong>, before its fulfillment, is to men [full of] enigmas and ambiguities. But when the time has arrived, and the prediction has come to pass, then the prophecies have a clear and certain exposition. And for this reason, indeed, when at this present time the law is read to the </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08399a.htm"><strong>Jews</strong></a><strong>, it is like a fable; for they do not possess the explanation of all things pertaining to the advent of the </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14142b.htm"><strong>Son of God</strong></a><strong>, which took place in </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09580c.htm"><strong>human</strong></a><strong> </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10715a.htm"><strong>nature</strong></a><strong>; but when it is read by the </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03712a.htm"><strong>Christians</strong></a><strong>, it is a treasure, hid indeed in a field, but brought to light by the cross of </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08374c.htm"><strong>Christ</strong></a><strong>,…” (Against Heresies IV.26.1). — Irenaeus</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>“The </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08399a.htm"><strong>Jews</strong></a><strong>, in fine, owing to the hardness of their heart, and from a desire to appear wise in their own eyes, have not </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02408b.htm"><strong>believed</strong></a><strong> in our Lord and Saviour, judging that those statements which were uttered respecting Him ought to be understood literally…And seeing that, according to history, there was no accomplishment of any of those things predicted of Him, in which they </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02408b.htm"><strong>believed</strong></a><strong> the signs of </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08374c.htm"><strong>Christ’s</strong></a><strong> advent were especially to be observed, they refused to acknowledge the presence of </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08374c.htm"><strong>our Lord Jesus Christ</strong></a><strong>…And yet, indeed, the more simple among those who profess to belong to the </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03744a.htm"><strong>Church</strong></a><strong> have supposed that there is no deity greater than the Demi­urge, being right in so thinking, while they </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07672a.htm"><strong>imagine</strong></a><strong> regarding Him such things as would not be </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02408b.htm"><strong>believed</strong></a><strong> of the most savage and </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08010c.htm"><strong>unjust</strong></a><strong> of </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09580c.htm"><strong>mankind</strong></a><strong>. Now the </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03459a.htm"><strong>cause</strong></a><strong>, in all the points previously enumerated, of the false opinions, and of the impious statements or </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07648a.htm"><strong>ignorant</strong></a><strong> assertions about </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06608a.htm"><strong>God</strong></a><strong>, appears to be nothing else than the not understanding the </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/bible/index.html"><strong>Scripture</strong></a><strong> according to its spiritual meaning, but the interpretation of it agreeable to the mere letter” (De Prin. IV.8–9). — Origen</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>“[And] whatever the Old Testament contains figuratively, the New has fulfilled through the very reason of truth…” (Commentary on the Gospels, Lines 180–181). — Fortunatianus</strong></blockquote><p><em>The Old Testament as a whole finds its full explanation in Christ, and the whole New Testament interprets the significance of Christ. Christ is the key to understanding the full canon correctly, but the gospels are not the ‘real’ canon. The life of Christ is the supreme locus of revelation, but the canon must remain the locus of theology…According to the christocentric principle, any interpretation of Numbers 15:35 that does not harmonise with the clear teaching of Jesus must be deemed inadequate. The Numbers text cannot mean that God was a vindictive, pedantic legalist in 1400 BC, since the life and teaching of Jesus Christ clearly show that he is not.</em></p><p>The Old Testament does not find its full explanation in the life of Christ; this is not a grammatical argument, but a theological presupposition which is not compatible with the Old Testament narratives. The Fathers like Origen, Barnabas, and even Athanasius would agree that there must be a spiritual or transcendental meaning, but they would also agree like Maximus the Confessor that the authorial reading of the mosaic law contains superficial nonsense and various contradictions until Christ provides us the pneumatic mode of interpretation, while no longer heeding to what the text says (<em>cf. Response to Thalassios 65.33 [again cited]</em>).</p><p>According to the actual Christocentric principle, if any passage in the Old Testament misrepresents God like commanding the slaughter of children or the plundering of virgins, it must be rejected in favor of the revelation of Christ along with wisdom and mysticism (<em>cf. Deut. 20:16–17, 21:10–14</em>). And to render his argument even more ineffective, Christ contradicted the principle behind the dietary laws, violated the stoning of the adulterer, and even the Jews argued that the messiah is not supposed to die according to their scriptures, which Jesus did not counter or deny (<em>cf. Mark 7:1–23; John 8:1–11, 12:34–36</em>). Instead in verse 35 and 36, Jesus advises them to focus on His incarnation since He fulfills it typologically and not grammatically; thus, He confers more authority to His incarnation as a guide rather than the old scriptures. Even in the Gospel of Matthew, we see Peter equating Jesus with the law (Moses) and the prophets (Elijah), but God hides the two prophets and says, “This is My Son; listen to Him,” which demonstrates that Jesus has more authority than the law and the prophets (<em>cf. Matt. 17</em>).</p><p><strong>Kevin’s</strong> <strong>Footnote:</strong> <em>Theologians who do not hold a high view of scripture would say that the Numbers text is in error, and Jesus’s teaching is corrective. For those of us who believe that the Holy Spirit stands behind all scripture as its ultimate Author, such an explanation is unacceptable.</em></p><p>The author of Hebrews certainly did not consider the old covenant (<em>i.e. Mosaic laws</em>) to be infallible. He argues, <strong>“For if there had been nothing wrong with that first covenant, no place would have been sought for another”</strong> (Hebrews 8:7). Some will argue that he meant the covenant observance of the Jews, but this is only feasible in verse 8 and not verse 7, which means he blames both the covenant and the people (assuming the English translation for verse 8 is correct, but irrelevant either way). And to further prove verse 7 means what it says and not their extrapolation of the text, he writes: “<strong>Now these things having been thus prepared, the priests go in continually into the first tabernacle, accomplishing the services, 7 but into the second the high priest alone, once in the year, not without blood, which he offers for himself, and for the errors of the people. 8 The Holy Spirit is indicating this, that the way into the Holy Place wasn’t yet revealed while the first tabernacle was still standing. 9 This is a symbol of the present age, where gifts and sacrifices are offered that are incapable, concerning the conscience, of making the worshiper perfect, 10 being only (with meats and drinks and various washings) fleshly ordinances, imposed until a time of reformation” (</strong>ibid. 9:6–10<strong>). </strong>He reinterprets the old priesthood through spiritual allegory based on phrases like <em>“the Holy Spirit is indicating”</em> and <em>“this is a symbol of the present age”</em>. And then he says that the mosaic customs (or fleshly ordinances) were imposed until a time of reformation; in other words, God awaited the day that Christ would reform or rectify the Mosaic religion or Mosaic Judaism. It was indeed a correction of the old, Kevin. It was not a continual progression from the old, which somehow does not imply ineffective or inaccurate revelation.</p><p>Kevin ends his remarks with, <em>“For the sake of argument, let us imagine that there were no texts in the gospels in which Christ taught about eternal judgement. Let us also imagine that an interpreter concludes from her study of the gospels that eternal judgement is incompatible with the love of God as embodied in the life of Christ. When the same interpreter then encounters Revelation 20:11–15, she may wrongly conclude that it cannot be teaching eternal judgement, since that would be incompatible with her view of Christ. This hypothetical example illustrates the potential pitfall — assuming that the natural meaning of a text of scripture cannot be the intended meaning because it does not seem to fit our view of Christ.”</em> No Kevin, the apostolic Fathers like Mathetes, Origen, Gregory, Diodore, and even Maximus the Confessor did not believe in eschatological infernalism due to their innate understanding of the Koine Greek from the New Testament. Christian scholars like David Bentley Hart, Dr. Illaria Ramelli, Jordan Daniel Wood, and even Fr. John Behr understand <strong>aionios kolasis</strong> as being an indefinite duration of correction. Therefore, your hypothetical example perfectly supports the inadequacy of inerrant presuppositions, especially when potential English mis-translations are present in the text.</p><h4>More Assumptions and Conclusion</h4><p>Kevin writes that some argue against male headship by asserting Jesus as the domain of authority and interpreting the other verses as egalitarian, which classifies this as <em>“a dubious assumption about Jesus abstracted from indirect evidence to nullify the plain meaning of other scriptures”</em>. However, the plain reading of the scriptures (specifically the Old Testament) does denigrate the value of women despite exceptions like Genesis, which is why Kevin admits that<em> “Jesus Christ affirmed the dignity and value of women and opposed all forms of abuse and exploitation,”</em> and Christ’s opposition would include how the Torah treated women in the Ancient Near Eastern world (<em>cf. Deut. 20:14;</em> <em>21:10–14; 22:28–29). </em>As for the New Testament, the plain reading is misleading towards women’s role in church, so we must be more textually critical of whether there’s possible interpolations, external context, and faulty translations at display. The Christocentric principle becomes an epistemic paradox if we are to affirm the Old Testament’s flawed ethics and philosophies.</p><p>Kevin writes, <em>“If the Gospels read in isolation, they might believe that Jesus wants wives to convert their husbands aggressively,” </em>which is nonsense and ironic; fundamentalist believers do this anyway, and this is why we need the Quadrilateral method. The canonical scriptures require patristic tradition, sapient philosophy, and useful mysticism to be utilized in conformity to the mind of Christ (<em>cf. Philippians 2:5</em>). Then he says, <em>“As formulated, the principle advocates that we interpret all scripture in the light of what the words and works of Jesus Christ reveal about the nature, will, and purposes of God. Since the life of Christ is the climactic self-revelation of God to man, it rightly serves as a framework and a lens for understanding God’s other acts of self-disclosure.”</em> If the Old Testament is to be understood in light of Christ, it must also be understood in primacy of Christ. Kevin believes God is immutable, so to believe in a god that commanded infanticide, polygamy, and violence, but not anymore, demonstrates a god that is not immutable; it’s a ‘<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dispensationalism">dispensationalist</a>’ fallacy (<em>cf. Hebrews 13:8</em>). If God is to be morally immutable, He cannot command actions that are in stark contradiction; for example: polygamy contra monogamy, communal violence contra exemplary peace, infanticide contra pro-life, and mosaic legalism contra anti-nomianism (<em>cf. Deut. 20:16–18; Matt. 5:9; 1st Sam. 15:3; Didache 2; Deut. 30:16; Hebrews 8:13, 9:6–10</em>). Then Kevin writes, <em>“The first is the danger of allowing the gospels to become a canon within the canon, treating them as superior revelation to the rest of the Bible, even to the rest of the New Testament.”</em> The actual Christocentric tradition isn’t suggesting that we should dismiss the Pauline or the Catholic epistles altogether, leaving the Gospels as the supreme canon of the whole canon. As I have said, the Quadrilateral method refines our theology more effectively than relying on a solo-scripture method. The god that Kevin submits to is not a Christocentric understanding; it is an evangelical notion that contradicts the actual principle yet it pretenses subtly.</p><h4>Recommended Sites</h4><ul><li><a href="https://kylerhughes.com/2013/08/20/were-the-fathers-inerrantists-a-response-to-kevin-deyoung/?source=post_page-----a6b7ba7ab98a--------------------------------">Were the Fathers Inerrantists? A Response to Kevin DeYoung</a></li><li><a href="https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/apologia-for-origen-of-alexandria-15c2ddce7719">Apologia for Origen of Alexandria</a></li><li><a href="https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/isaiah-53-isnt-a-crucified-messiah-pt-b-59faad381d83">Isaiah 53 isn’t a Crucified Messiah (Pt. B)</a></li><li><a href="https://reknew.org/2017/05/the-problem-with-christocentrism/">The Problem with Christocentrism - Greg Boyd - ReKnew</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8dab9ce51fdd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Modern Inerrancy ≠ Patristic Inerrancy]]></title>
            <link>https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/modern-inerrancy-patristic-inerrancy-a6b7ba7ab98a?source=rss-446f9887eae0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a6b7ba7ab98a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[biblical-inerrancy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inerrancy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patristic-theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patristic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apostolic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[George M. Garcia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Jan 2024 04:52:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-03T00:27:15.876Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Restoring the Apostolic View of the Scriptures</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*lnzvHdw5a4QEnT-w" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@glenncarstenspeters?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Glenn Carstens-Peters</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h4>Textual Inerrancy vs. Anagogical Inerrancy</h4><p>Recently within this era, some Christians have desperately attempted to defend their faith by creating false promises for the Bible, and so, they have claimed that not only is the Bible infallible in terms of theology and ethical practice, but also the human author’s opinions on science, history, and even geography. Such claims are appealing at first glance, but such notions are very deceptive in nature. It is an appealing notion to the naive and infantile believer, which in return, deprives them of exegetical honesty, theological self-improvement, and spiritual maturity. This post is not intended to offend any of these individuals, but to disclose a strong deception that believers have mistakenly embraced out of insecurity, constant indoctrination, and out of diverse sophism.</p><p>The biggest issue with Fundamentalists is their insistence on scriptural inerrancy. They attempt to use the Church Fathers to argue for the belief in biblical (textual) inerrancy like citing Augustine, Irenaeus, Clement of Rome, etc. Although, it’s true that they held to some form of inerrancy, yet it was never an attempt for them to suggest that the biblical context and the human authors as being infallible or without contradiction to others. The patristic view of inerrancy did not regard a plenary, verbal, infallible form of inspiration (e.g. word-for-word), and it acknowledges that the context of the Old Testament was not always inspired, yet only occasionally. The patristic form of inerrancy would regard the Scriptures as always being inspired in symbolic and typological fashion. The patristic view acknowledges that the thoughts of God could be revealed by a typological reading, instead of using a contextual-grammatical reading. When the context of Scripture presents a theological or exegetical contradiction, exemplifies an immoral practice, has similarities to Christian doctrine, and/or appears as an ambiguously, lost grammatical reading, this is where the mystical interpretation is applied.</p><p>Keep in mind, people confuse the Church Fathers’ use of allegory as being contextual or grammatical, but this is not what the Fathers mean by “allegory”. It is interpretive allegory or allegoresis, which is an ancient literary device used to disclose a philosophic truth and to disclose a deeper form of inspiration. Religious and philosophical traditions used this kind of literary method, which modern audiences have neglected for a quarter of two millennias.</p><h4>The Epistle of Clement of Rome</h4><p>There are popular apologists who have attempted to distort the teachings of the Fathers to suggest that they were inerrantists of the grammatical reading. I will be commenting on the quotes that each Christian apologist has made, which inaccurately portrays the Fathers. There’s a famous apologist by the name of Alisa Childers who has a plethora of wrong teachings that she assumes is orthodoxy; unfortunately, like the many of her stream, they aren’t individual thinkers but she succumbs to the majority opinion of her day. She cites Clement of Rome in teaching contextual inerrancy, but I will demonstrate as to what she is missing:</p><blockquote>Here’s what he said about the Bible:</blockquote><blockquote>Let us act accordingly to that which is written (for the Holy Spirit saith, “Let not the wise man glory in his wisdom)….Look carefully into the Scriptures, which are the true utterances of the Holy Spirit.(2)<br>​Clement equated the words of Scripture with the very words of God.</blockquote><p>Alissa’s quotation of Clement is a bit distorted, in which she quotes a passage from Chapter 13, then she quotes a phrase from Chapter 45 to present the Scriptures as some unquestionable and infallible source, but this is not Clement’s understanding of the Scriptures. Though Clement quotes from Jeremiah, he is not saying that we can’t challenge the Old Testament scriptures, but he demonstrates in context of this quote, <strong>“[let us therefore, brethren]…being especially mindful of the words of the Lord Jesus which He spoke teaching us meekness and long-suffering. For thus He spoke: Be merciful, that you may obtain mercy; forgive, that it may be forgiven to you…”</strong> (<em>1st Clement XIII</em>). Clement quotes from Jeremiah to demonstrate that we should be in humble submission to the teachings of Jesus. Clement presents himself as a Christocentricist from what it seems. Ignatius of Antioch, a contemporary of Clement and a direct disciple of the apostles, was also a Christocentricist (<em>i.e. the belief that the Old Testament must be read in primacy of Christ, rather than in equal degrees of authority</em>). He said: <strong>“For I heard some men saying, “If I find it not in the <em>[magisterial/</em>ἀρχείοις<em>]</em> records, I do not believe in the Gospel,” and when I said to them that it is in the Scripture, they answered me, “That is exactly the question.” But to me, Jesus Christ has become the <em>[magisterial/</em> ἀρχεῖά<em>]</em> record: the inviolable charter is His cross, and death, and resurrection, and the faith which is through Him…But the Gospel has its own preeminence: the appearance of the Savior, our Lord Jesus Christ, His passion, and the resurrection, because the beloved prophets proclaimed into Him, but the fulfillment of the Gospel has become incorruptible”</strong> (Ign. Philadelphians 8:2–9.2). The theme of Christ’s revelation as being superior than the Old Testament is a constant affirmation in his epistle to the Philadelphians. In this same epistle, he argues with those who don’t see the Gospel in “the archives” (τοῖς ἀρχειοῖς) or in the Hebraic scriptures presumably, which they affirm these archives as authoritative or magisterial, yet Ignatius explains that Christ is in the Hebraic scriptures, though he does not mean in a grammatical or contextual sense. Furthermore, Ignatius disagrees with their interpretive premise by saying: <strong>“But to me the charter (ἀρχεῖα/archeia) are Jesus Christ, the inviolable charter is his cross, and death, and resurrection…” </strong>(Phil. 8.2). Ignatius argues that Christ is the magisterial record, or the “charters” as translated in the J. B. Lightfoot translation. Ignatius suggests that between the old priesthood and the new priesthood, Christ is the superior priesthood that was entrusted as the door to the Father in revealing the secret things of God, and he makes a subtle typological appeal to Christ when he first mentioned the priests while symbolizing Christ as the high priest from the Old Testament. And then, Ignatius states that the Gospel has its own preeminence or superiority (ἐξαίρετον/exaireton), and he specifies that these would be Christ’s appearance, passion, and resurrection. Ignatius affirms that the beloved prophets foreshadowed or prefigured Christ, presumably by typology instead of authorial context, and that the Gospel is the incorruptible fulfillment. So far, Ignatius seems to imply heavily that Christ in the Gospels retain a higher authority (in an ethical and theological sense) than the Hebraic scriptures, just as Clement might be implying.</p><p>The second phrase that she quoted is from Chapter 45 where Clement seemingly says that the Scriptures are the oracles of God, but this claim by Clement can be easily misunderstood. The Greek manuscript in this chapter doesn’t use the term for “word” or “utterances” but it can be simply understood as <strong>“Carefully examine into the Holy Scriptures, which are true, because of the Holy Spirit” <em>(ἐγκεκύφατε εἰς τὰς ἱερὰς γραφάς, τὰς ἀληθεῖς, τὰς διὰ τοῦ πνεύματος τοῦ ἁγίου)</em></strong>. Clement demonstrates that the Holy Scriptures are inspired with truth, but he also regards his own epistles as being inspired by the Holy Spirit. We read this in Chapter 63, <strong>“For you will give us joy and gladness; if you are obedient to the things which we have written through the Holy Spirit, and root out the wicked passion of your jealousy according to the entreaty for peace and concord which we have made in this letter.” </strong>The claim to Holy Spirit inspiration doesn’t necessarily imply infallibility unless Alisa wishes to say Clement’s epistle is infallible.</p><p>The problem I often see with fundamentalists is their tendency to quote a passage out of context, and use it to prove something that isn’t really there. This is often what I see with their treatment of the Bible and now the patristic literature. To understand Clement’s view of inspiration, we must understand how he uses the Old Testament and what he derives from it. Clement quotes the Hebrew Scriptures by giving it a moral reading, which is characteristic of the anagogical principle of interpretation. “<strong>You understand, beloved, you understand well the sacred Scriptures, and you have looked very earnestly into the oracles of </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06608a.htm"><strong>God</strong></a><strong>. Call then these things to your remembrance. When </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10596a.htm"><strong>Moses</strong></a><strong> went up into the mount, and abode there, with </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05789c.htm"><strong>fasting</strong></a><strong> and humiliation, forty days and forty nights, the Lord said to him, </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10596a.htm"><strong>Moses</strong></a><strong>, </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10596a.htm"><strong>Moses</strong></a><strong>, get you down quickly from hence; for your people whom you brought out of the land of </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05329b.htm"><strong>Egypt</strong></a><strong> have committed iniquity. They have speedily departed from the way in which I commanded them to walk, and have made to themselves molten images. And the Lord said to him, I have spoken to you once and again, saying, I have seen this people, and, behold, it is a stiff-necked people: let me destroy them, and blot out their name from under heaven; and I will make you a great and wonderful nation, and one much more numerous than this. But </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/10596a.htm"><strong>Moses</strong></a><strong> said, Far be it from You, Lord: pardon the </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14004b.htm"><strong>sin</strong></a><strong> of this people; else blot me also out of the book of the living. </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/bible/exo032.htm#verse32"><strong>Exodus 32:32</strong></a><strong> O marvellous </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09397a.htm"><strong>love</strong></a><strong>! O insuperable perfection! The servant speaks freely to his Lord, and asks forgiveness for the people, or begs that he himself might perish along with them. Who then among you is noble-minded? Who compassionate? Who full of </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09397a.htm"><strong>love</strong></a><strong>?” </strong>(<em>1st Clement 53–54</em>). Clement quotes the narrative of Moses to inspire his audience of his moral example, but some fundamentalists might take this as a historical embrace from Clement; however, in Chapter 55, Clement mentions the moral example of Judith, which many Christians consider as historical fiction and non-canonical. The purpose of his quotations is to give a moral reading of the Scriptures, not a historical embrace and grammatical reading of the Scriptures.</p><p>When Clement says <strong>“the oracles <em>[logia can also translate as thoughts/expressions]</em> of God,”</strong> he means the anagogical, conceptual inspiration of God and not a plenary form of verbal inspiration. Clement also mentions Rahab where he demonstrates an anagogical reading of the Scriptures; hence, he says, <strong>“Moreover, they gave her a sign to this effect, that she should hang forth from her house a scarlet thread. And thus they made it manifest that redemption should flow through the blood of the Lord to all them that </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02408b.htm"><strong>believe</strong></a><strong> and hope in </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06608a.htm"><strong>God</strong></a><strong>. You see, beloved, that there was not only </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05752c.htm"><strong>faith</strong></a><strong>, but </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12473a.htm"><strong>prophecy</strong></a><strong>, in this </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15687b.htm"><strong>woman</strong></a><strong>”</strong> (<em>Chapter 12</em>). The events of Rahab become a prophetic foreshadowing of Christ’s blood, which is not normative for a contextual understanding of the Bible. Alisa needs to be cautious in making assumptions and she needs to read these passages in context with the overall patristic tradition. Because I have demonstrated the interpretive methods and applications of Clement, there is no reason to assume that he held a fundamentalist or grammatical view of inerrancy. I shall concede that this may not seem convincing at first glace, but this is why we need to address other examples. In the writings of Origen of Alexandria, he believes that the textual surface of the Mosaic law does not reveal the divine will, but only by turning to the revelation of Christ in the spirit of mystical allegory, does the divine will become exposed. He says: “<strong>[We] would say that we both agree that the books were written by the Spirit of God, but that we do not agree about the meaning of their contents;…we are of opinion that the literal acceptation of the laws is not that which conveys the meaning of the legislation. And we maintain, that “when Moses is read, the veil is upon their heart,” because the meaning of the law of Moses has been concealed from those who have not welcomed the way which is by Jesus Christ. But we know that if one turn to the Lord (for “the Lord is that Spirit”), the veil being taken away, “he beholds, as in a mirror with unveiled face, the glory of the Lord” in those thoughts which are concealed in their literal expression, and to his own glory becomes a participator of the divine glory; the term “face” being used figuratively for the “understanding,” as one would call it without a figure, in which is the face of the “inner man,” filled with light and glory, flowing from the true comprehension of the contents of the law” (Contra Celsum V.60). </strong>Or in Origen’s letter to Gregory Thaumaturgus,<strong> “And, focusing on the divine reading, earnestly seek, with unwavering faith towards God, the hidden meaning of the divine writings among the multitude” (Philocalia Book 2, Chapter 13, Sec. 4). </strong>And likewise in the words of Hilary of Poitiers, he says<strong>, “Likewise, Manichaeus and Marcion despise the law because the letter kills, and the prince of the world is the devil. All scriptures speak without the sense of scripture and feign faith without faith. Scriptures are not in reading but in understanding, nor are they in prevarication but in charity” (Ad Constantium 9.</strong>2). Hilary notes that Marcion and Manichaeus deny the law, because of the Pauline arguments from 2nd Corinthians 3:6 and 4:4, but Hilary responds to such arguments by saying that all the scriptures are without the mystical sense if read according to its text. He says that scripture becomes its true self if read in spiritual contemplation. Here’s a conceptual translation of Hilary<strong>: “[The] Scriptures are not [found] in reading [according to text], but in [mystical] understanding</strong>.”</p><h4>The Work of Irenaeus of Lyons</h4><p>Alisa Childers makes another attempt to argue for inerrancy through the work of Irenaeus, <strong>“<em>The Scriptures are indeed perfect, since they were spoken by the Word of God [Christ] and His Spirit; but we, inasmuch as we are inferior to, and later in existence than, the Word of God and His Spirit, are on that very account destitute of the knowledge of His mysteries”</em></strong><em> (Against Heresies </em>2.28.2). The term ‘perfect’ used in Against Heresies doesn’t mean “without error” in Latin. This term in Latin is ‘<strong>perfectae</strong>’, which conveys completion, wholeness, or it implies a state of sufficiency, but a state of completion and sufficiency doesn’t imply infallibility in the slightest.</p><h4>A Quote from Justin Martyr</h4><p><em>But when you hear the utterances of the prophets spoken as it were personally, you must not suppose that they are spoken by the inspired men themselves but by the divine Word who moves them. (</em>First Apology, XXXVI).</p><p>Alisa, like the rest of the apologists, misinterpret this quote to be an affirmation of their view of inerrancy, which the quote does not seem to teach; in fact, Justin seems to distinguish two forms of inspiration: the authorial intent and the divine intention. Justin seems to be affirming two forms of inspiration embedded in the Scriptures, but the divine intent (i.e. the anagogical reading) being superior over the authorial intent (e.g. contextual reading), or else, why would he need to say that these prophetic men were inspired but also moved by the Divine Word which already captures this idea? What’s interesting about Justin is his belief that the Jewish people enjoined sacrifices as God accommodated their practices, instead of legislating such things to them. This is a view that Alisa herself would disagree with since she always agrees with the letter of the Scriptures. Justin wrote in his dialogue with Trypho, Chapter XIX, <strong>“Therefore, God harmonized with the people, and they commanded offerings as to bear His name <em>(Ὅθεν ὁ θεὸς ἁρμοσάμενος πρὸς τὸν λαὸν ἐκεῖνον καὶ θυσίας φέρειν ὡς πρὸς ὄνομα αὐτοῦ ἐνετείλατο).” </em></strong>There’s an official translation by Phillip Schaff that somewhat concedes to the idea that God accommodated the Jews and their offerings, instead of prescription. <strong>“Wherefore God, accommodating Himself to that nation, enjoined them also to offer sacrifices, as if to His name,” </strong>which by the phrase “as if” implies that their offerings honored God in appearance (or from their perspective), but not from God’s perspective (or in reality).</p><p>Even Saint Athanasius acknowledges the narrative of Moses enjoining the law of sacrifice as a divine instrument, yet also believing in the prophets denying such a narrative, but Athanasius of Alexandria resolves this dispute by saying,<strong> “Now it appears to me — may God grant, by your prayers, that the remarks I presume to make may not be far from the truth — that not at first were the commandment and the law concerning sacrifices, neither did the mind of God, Who gave the law, regard whole burnt-offerings, but those things which were pointed out and prefigured by them. ‘For the law contained a shadow of good things to come.’ And, ‘Those things were appointed until the time of reformation. Therefore, the whole law did not treat of sacrifices, though there was in the law a commandment concerning sacrifices, that by means of them it might begin to instruct men and might withdraw them from idols, and bring them near to God, teaching them for that present time. Therefore neither at the beginning, when God brought the people out of Egypt, did He command them concerning sacrifices or whole burnt-offerings, nor even when they came to mount Sinai”</strong><em> (Letter 19, Sections 3–4).</em> Athanasius knows he’s denying the grammatical reading of the Torah, so he requests a prayer from his audience since he is worried that they disagree with his anagogical exposition since the immature of the faith, according to Origen and Gregory, merely interpreted the Scriptures as to the letter <em>(First Principles, IV.8–9; Homilies on the Song of Songs, Prefac</em>e). However, he explains that God did not prescribe the command of offering, but allowed them to use their offerings to prevent them from idolatry and reoriented their customs to symbolize Christ (<em>i.e. hidden form of inspiration</em>). Even the Didascalia, an early Christian document that represents most of the Early Church, states the followin<strong>g: “Wherefore He does not say, ‘Make for me’ but, ‘If thou shalt make an altar’. He did not impose this as a necessity, but showed what was about to be. For God had no need of sacrifices; as neither of old was it commanded Cain and Abel, but they of their own accord presented offerings: and their offering achieved a brother’s murde</strong>r” (Didascalia 26). So my interpretation of Justin’s understanding of the command of sacrifice aligns well with the teachings of the Didascalia and saint Athanasius of Alexandria. And so, if Justin denies some portion from the contextual reading of the Old Testament as did Athanasius, then it is clear that both of them weren’t believers in textual/authorial inerrancy.</p><h4>The Book of Hebrews (Apostolic Scripture) &amp; Conclusion</h4><p>The Book of Hebrews is more explicit in revealing the fallibility of the old covenant. The author of Hebrews uses spiritual allegory in reinterpreting the Old Testament passages like Jeremiah, the Psalms, and even the Levitical priesthood (cf. Hebrews 10:1). The author demonstrates the fallible nature of the old covenant, <strong>“For if that first <em>covenant</em> had been faultless, then should no place have been sought for the second” </strong>(Hebrews 8:7). But some Christians attempt to argue that the author meant the covenant observance of the Jews, but this reading is absent in verse 7 and is more feasible in verse 8, so the argument of a fallible covenant still remains. Here is another passage from Hebrews: “<strong>Now these things having been thus prepared, the priests go in continually into the first tabernacle, accomplishing the services, 7 but into the second the high priest alone, once in the year, not without blood, which he offers for himself, and for the errors of the people. 8 The Holy Spirit is indicating this, that the way into the Holy Place wasn’t yet revealed while the first tabernacle was still standing. 9 This is a symbol of the present age, where gifts and sacrifices are offered that are incapable, concerning the conscience, of making the worshiper perfect, 10 being only (with meats and drinks and various washings) fleshly ordinances, imposed until a time of reformation”</strong> (9:6–10). The author of Hebrews is utilizing spiritual allegory based on phrases like <em>“the Holy Spirit is indicating”</em> and<em> “this is a symbol of the present age,”</em> and most importantly, he mentions such carnal ordinances were imposed until a time of reformation. There can’t be a reformation without there being errors in the system (nor is it a mere improvement), so God awaited for Mosaic Judaism to be rectified by the advent of Christ.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>Therefore, every Christian apologist who adheres to the fundamentalist stream does not understand the notion of patristic inerrancy, but conflate it as their own doctrine of inerrancy. And to demonstrate that I am not the only person who distinguishes patristic inerrancy from modern inerrancy, in one of <a href="https://kylerhughes.com/2013/08/20/were-the-fathers-inerrantists-a-response-to-kevin-deyoung/"><strong>Kyle R. Hugh’s blog</strong></a><strong>,</strong> he cites a source, saying: <strong>“But the Fathers had an entirely different view. As patristics scholar D. H. Williams summarizes, ‘As a generalization about the patristic mind, it is fair to say that the fathers affirmed an infallible Bible, although it was not an infallibility of the text so much as it was an infallibility of the divine intention behind the text’ (<em>Evangelicals and Tradition</em>, 91)”</strong>. And he also cites:<strong> “Similarly, Frederick Norris observes that “The Fathers’ sense of the trustworthy character of Scripture can have them speak about its lack of errors, but they never protect the Bible with the doctrine of inerrancy that was developed in seventeenth-century Protestantism.”</strong></p><h4>Extra: My Review of Kyle’s Piece</h4><p>In Kyle’s blog, I comment the following: <strong>“This article beautifully conveys what Christianity of antiquity really stands for, rather than those fundamentalist or biblicist Christians who don’t realize that the letter or context of the old often lead to senseless, anti-Christian, or detrimental readings. They [church fathers] obviously didn’t believe the OT as being always inspired by the letter/context, but the symbolic/spiritual reading. It’s probably accurate to say they affirmed mystical/anagogical inerrancy but not textual/human-authorial inerrancy.”</strong></p><h4>Recommended Websites</h4><ul><li><a href="https://kylerhughes.com/2013/08/20/were-the-fathers-inerrantists-a-response-to-kevin-deyoung/">Were the Fathers Inerrantists? A Response to Kevin DeYoung</a></li><li><a href="https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/the-christian-use-of-allegoresis-9f738ba7bdfb">The Christian Use of Allegoresis</a></li><li><a href="https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/the-apostolic-hermeneutic-revived-e9357738044f">The Apostolic Hermeneutic Revived</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a6b7ba7ab98a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Apologia for Origen of Alexandria]]></title>
            <link>https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/apologia-for-origen-of-alexandria-15c2ddce7719?source=rss-446f9887eae0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/15c2ddce7719</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[apologia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[origens]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[orthodoxy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christian]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[George M. Garcia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Jan 2024 03:37:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-04T22:25:25.824Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The Christian Orthodoxy of Origen</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/220/0*iFOX7t8nkR7_niwZ.jpg" /><figcaption>Origen of Alexandria (b. AD 185–253)</figcaption></figure><h4>Preface</h4><p>In this simple medium article, I hope to express why Origen is a saint and not a heretic, and to convey an Origen not twisted or defamed by supposed experts of church history. Origen is often defamed by Protestant “literalists” (<em>though their literalism varies</em>) for using allegoresis as if a sound biblical interpretation does not require it, accused by the Orthobros (<em>i.e. Eastern “Orthodox” radicals deviating from E. Orthodox tradition</em>) in embracing a false postmortem eschatology (<em>with the inclusion of believing in pre-existent souls</em>), and even damned by these so-called church experts as a heretic. After constantly hearing and seeing so many misinformed comments on Origen, I have decided to compose an informative piece.</p><h4>Defense for Allegoresis</h4><p>It was common for the Early Church writers like Paul the apostle, Clement of Rome, Irenaeus of Lyons, Clement of Alexandria, and Origen of Alexandria to use an ancient rhetorical device like spiritual allegory into the sacred writings, or what Classicists term ‘allegoresis’. Whether we like it or not, the Jewish people were influenced by the Hellenistic culture, and so were the apostolic and patristic writers. In Paul’s epistles, he mentions to the Colossians that the mosaic customs prefigure the Lord Jesus via type and shadows; he writes, <strong>“</strong><a href="https://www.bible.com/bible/114/COL.2.16.NKJV"><strong>So let no one judge you in food or in drink, or regarding a festival or a new moon or sabbaths, which are a shadow of things to come, but the substance is of Christ</strong></a><strong>”</strong> (Colossians 2:16–17). This does not mean that the authorial reading or historical context plainly pointed to Jesus, but spiritual allegory when applied to the types and shadows. In Corinthians, he writes concerning the mosaic command, <strong>“For it is written in the law of Moses, “You shall not muzzle an ox while it treads out the grain” [</strong><a href="https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Deut.25.4&amp;version=WEB"><strong>Deuteronomy 25:4</strong></a>].<strong> Is it for the oxen that God cares, 10 or does he say it assuredly for our sake? Yes, it was written for our sake, because he who plows ought to plow in hope, and he who threshes in hope should partake of his hope. 11 If we sowed to you spiritual things, is it a great thing if we reap your fleshly things?” </strong>(1st Corinthians 9:9–11). Pay attention. Paul takes the mosaic command and asks a dichotomous question concerning it: Was this mosaic command given by God for oxen, or was it given by God to the Church? He says this command was written for our sake, which implies he believes God inspired the spiritual or anagogical reading of this mosaic command, rather than the authorial or contextual reading, because the command in its original context was written for the care of oxen, not believers. In another instance, Paul says,<strong> “It is written that Abraham had two sons: the one by a bondwoman, the other by a free woman. </strong><a href="http://biblehub.com/galatians/4-23.htm"><strong>23</strong></a><strong> But he <em>who was</em> of the bondwoman was born according to the flesh, and he of the free woman through promise, </strong><a href="http://biblehub.com/galatians/4-24.htm"><strong>24</strong></a><strong> which things are symbolic. For these are the two covenants: the one from Mount Sinai which gives birth to bondage, which is Hagar — </strong><a href="http://biblehub.com/galatians/4-25.htm"><strong>25</strong></a><strong> for this Hagar is Mount Sinai in Arabia, and corresponds to Jerusalem which now is, and is in bondage with her children — </strong><a href="http://biblehub.com/galatians/4-26.htm"><strong>26</strong></a><strong> but the Jerusalem above is free, which is the mother of us all”</strong> (Galatians 4:22–26). Paul is not saying that the narrative is authorial allegory for the two women, but rather he is appealing to spiritual allegory by reinterpreting the narrative of Genesis contrary to the authorial intent. Paul’s allegoresis is evident throughout his epistles, which many Christians misconstrue as regular exegesis.</p><p>The Book of Hebrews also demonstrates a similar interpretive usage like allegoresis. The author writes, <strong>“The law is only a shadow of the good things that are coming — not the realities themselves”</strong> (Hebrews 10:1). The author reinterprets the Old Testament priesthood against the authorial intentions. He says, <strong>“Now these things having been thus prepared, the priests go in continually into the first tabernacle, accomplishing the services, 7 but into the second the high priest alone, once in the year, not without blood, which he offers for himself, and for the errors of the people. 8 The Holy Spirit is indicating this, that the way into the Holy Place wasn’t yet revealed while the first tabernacle was still standing. 9 This is a symbol of the present age, where gifts and sacrifices are offered that are incapable, concerning the conscience, of making the worshiper perfect, 10 being only (with meats and drinks and various washings) fleshly ordinances, imposed until a time of reformation”</strong> (9:6–10). The author mentions the Levitical priesthood, and then he uses spiritual allegory to reinterpret the sacrificial system; for example, he says <em>“the Holy Spirit is indicating”</em> and <em>“this is a symbol of the present age”</em>. The author also says that these fleshly ordinances were imposed until a time of reformation, meaning God didn’t confer the mosaic customs, yet He repurposed these to be decoded by spiritual allegory, and awaited the advent of Christ to correct the errors of this system (<em>i.e. Mosaic Judaism</em>) through the ministry of allegoresis by the Logos. The author teaches that both the old covenant and the people were at fault, but he uses spiritual allegory once more to argue for a new covenant to abolish the old despite the fact every new covenant in the Old Testament built upon the old instead of abolishing it (ibid. 8:7–13; <em>Genesis 15, 17; Exodus 19–24; 2 Samuel 7:8–16; Jeremiah 31:31–34</em>). The Jeremiah covenant says nothing about an abolishing of the mosaic customs in its original context, instead it claims that the Jewish people will follow the laws (<em>plural), </em>because God has instilled it into their minds as the new covenant. The author of Hebrews is not interpreting the passage of Jeremiah exegetically, but typologically.</p><p>In the epistle of patristic Barnabas (dated around 90–120 AD), he writes, <strong>“Moreover Moses says to them in Deuteronomy, “And I will make a covenant of my ordinances with this people.” So then the ordinance of God is not abstinence from eating, but Moses spoke in the spirit. He mentioned the swine for this reason: you shall not consort, he means, with men who are like swine, that is to say, when they have plenty they forget the Lord, but when they are in want they recognize the Lord, just as the swine when it eats does not know its master, but when it is hungry it cries out, and after receiving food is again silent…Moses received three doctrines concerning food and thus spoke of them in the Spirit; but they received them as truly referring to food, owing to the lust of their flesh” </strong>(Barnabas 10.2–3, 9). Barnabas (not the apostle) teaches that God never forbade the eating of pork, but how one should manage their company with others. He believes that the mosaic law should be fathomed according to the spiritual reading, rather than the literal or authorial reading. Barnabas, like sacred writings and the patristic authors, did not believe that God inspired the mosaic customs as they are written, and neither should we as <strong>Origen claims in Contra Celsum, Book 5, Chapter 60</strong>:</p><blockquote><strong><em>[We] would say that we both agree that the books were written by the Spirit of God, but that we do not agree about the meaning of their contents;…</em>we are of opinion that the literal acceptation of the laws is not that which conveys the meaning of the legislation. <em>And we maintain, that “when Moses is read, the veil is upon their heart,” because </em>the meaning of the law of Moses has been concealed from those who have not welcomed the way which is by Jesus Christ.<em> But we know that </em>if one turn to the Lord (for “the Lord is that Spirit”), the veil being taken away, “he beholds, as in a mirror with unveiled face, the glory of the Lord” in those thoughts which are concealed in their literal expression<em>, and to his own glory becomes a participator of the divine glory; </em>the term “face” being used figuratively for the “understanding,” as one would call it without a figure, in which is the face of the “inner man,” filled with light and glory, flowing from the true comprehension of the contents of the law.</strong></blockquote><h4>His Orthodoxy Among Saints</h4><p>The modern antagonists of Origen always appeal to church figures like Methodius of Olympus, Epiphanius of Salamis, saint Jerome, Augustine of Hippo, and so forth to discredit the Christian orthodoxy of Origen. But they never cite great church figures who not only noticed Origen’s orthodoxy, but revered him for his intellect and his writings. Permit me to name a few figures of the Early Church. Origen of Alexandria is always accused of being a heretic, yet no one seems to correlate Origen with Gregory Thuamaturgus, because had Origen not existed, Gregory the Wonder-worker wouldn’t have existed or become one of the most respected saints in church history. This Gregory (b. 213–270 AD) was a student of Origen of Alexandria, and Gregory wrote a panegyric in favor of Origen, saying:</p><blockquote><strong>“And this revered man coming from Egypt, from the city of Alexandria, where previously he happened to have his home, was moved by other circumstances to change his residence to this place, as if with the express object of meeting us…” (Argument 5). [Gregory identifies and reveres Origen]</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>“This man, however, was the first that induced me to philosophize by his words, as he pointed the exhortation by deeds before he gave it in words, and did not merely recite well-studied sentences; nay, he did not deem it right to speak on the subject at all, but with a sincere mind, and one bent on striving ardently after the practical accomplishment of the things expressed, and he endeavoured all the while to show himself in character like the man whom he describes in his discourses as the person who shall lead a noble life, and he ever exhibited (in himself), I would say, the pattern of the wise man…” (ibid. 11). [Origen taught Gregory to rationalize]</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>“Now that greatest gift this man has received from God, and that noblest of all endowments he has had bestowed upon him from heaven, that he should be an interpreter of the oracles of God to men, and that he might understand the words of God, even as if God spoke them to him, and that he might recount them to men in such wise as that they may hear them with intelligence” (bid. 15). [He credits Origen as a sound interpreter of the sacred writings by spiritual interpretation]</strong></blockquote><p>Saint Athanasius, the man who defended the deity of Christ against the Arians, was not only fond of Origen as a church father, but appealed to him as a proponent of the deity of Christ. Origen is often accused of Arianism, but such a claim is invalid. He writes:</p><blockquote><strong>«And concerning the everlasting co-existence of the Word with the Father, and that He is not of another essence or subsistence, but proper to the Father’s, as the Bishops in the Council said, you may hear again from the labour-loving Origen also…straightway he introduces his personal belief, thus:</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>“If there be an Image of the Invisible God, it is an invisible Image; nay, I will be bold to add, that, as being the likeness of the Father, never was it not. For when was that God, who, according to John, is called Light (for ‘God is Light’), without a radiance of His proper glory, that a man should presume to assert the Son’s origin of existence, as if before He was not? But when was not that Image of the Father’s Ineffable and Nameless and Unutterable subsistence, that Expression and Word, and He that knows the Father? For let him understand well who dares to say, ‘Once the Son was not,’ that he is saying, ‘Once Wisdom was not,’ and ‘Word was not,’ and ‘Life was not,’”…we are proving that this view has been transmitted from father to father» (De Decretis 6.27).</strong></blockquote><p>Then we have Gregory Nazianzus (b. 329–390 AD), one of the Cappadocian Fathers and the indirect legacy of Gregory Thaumaturgus, who did not declare Origen as a heretic, but helped redact the Philocalia in honor of Origen of Alexandria. He mentions it in one of his letters:</p><blockquote>(Sent about <a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05224d.htm">Easter</a> a.d. 382 with a copy of the Philocalia, or Chrestomathy of <a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11306b.htm">Origen’s</a> works edited by himself and S. Basil.)</blockquote><blockquote><strong>“You anticipate the Festival, and the letters, and, which is better still, the time by your eagerness, and you bestow on us a preliminary festival. Such is what Your Reverence gives us. And we in return give you the greatest thing we have, our </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12345b.htm"><strong>prayers</strong></a><strong>. But that you may have some small thing to remember us by, we send you the volume of the Philocalia of </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11306b.htm"><strong>Origen</strong></a><strong>, containing a selection of passages useful to students of literature. Deign to accept this, and give us a </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/12454c.htm"><strong>proof</strong></a><strong> of its usefulness, being aided by diligence and the Spirit” (Epistle CXV).</strong></blockquote><p>In conclusion, if great members of the Early Church like Gregory Thaumaturgus, Athanasius of Alexandria, and Gregory the Theologian held honor and praise of Origen, then the anti-Origen narrative has evidently, authentically, and immutably erred.</p><h4>Apostolic Universalism</h4><p>Since some people suggest that Origen’s universalism was condemned in the 5th ecumenical council, I will be discussing this briefly before I mention universalism as being present in Church history. Justinian the Emperor is regarded by many as a saint who supervised the council, but I would deny his sainthood and say he is not someone we should be adhering to. Justinian may be the emperor, but he is a wicked person, even by the report of his historian, Procopius of Caesarea (found in his writing, <em>Secret History</em>). The council did not condemn Christian universalism since neither Gregory of Nyssa, Diodore of Tarsus, nor Clement of Alexandria were ever condemned over this subject. To know what actually happened in the fifth ecumenical council,<a href="https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2020/05/31/did-the-fifth-ecumenical-council-condemn-universal-salvation/"><strong> I address you to Father Aiden’s blog.</strong></a><strong> </strong>And in another brief instance, Epiphanius of Salamis and Hippolytus of Rome wrote a list of heresies after Origen, but neither of them cited Christian universalism as one of them.</p><p>Here are some brief examples of Christian universalism throughout Church History:</p><blockquote>Paul the Apostle (1st Century):</blockquote><blockquote><strong>23 “But every man in his own order: Christ the first-fruits; afterward they that are Christ’s at his coming. 24 Then comes the end, when he shall have delivered up the kingdom to God, even the Father; when he shall have put down all rule and all authority and power. 25 For he must reign, till he hath put all enemies under his feet. 26 The last enemy that shall be destroyed is death. 27 For he hath put all things under his feet. But when he saith all things are put under him, it is manifest that he is excepted, which did put all things under him. 28 And when all things shall be subdued unto him, then shall the Son also himself be subject unto him that put all things under him, that God may be all in all” (1 Corinthians 15:23–28). — God will be “all in all,” which demonstrates Paul’s emphasis on universality.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Mathetes/Disciple (dated around 2nd century):</blockquote><blockquote><strong>“[It] is reserved for those who shall be sentenced to the indefinite [aionios] fire, which shall discipline and imprison them to it until an end. Then you shall marvel at those who endure the seasonal fire, which is for the sake of righteousness, and you shall consider them blessed when you know what the fire does.” (To Diognetus, 10.7–8). — Even if aionios was translated as eternal, this contradicts the passage saying, “imprison them to it until an end”. He indicates that they will endure the fire for righteousness to prevail, and for them to be blessed in a later time.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Gregory of Nyssa (b. 335–395 AD):<strong> </strong><a href="https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2020/08/23/st-gregory-of-nyssa-teacher-of-eternal-damnation/"><strong>In case anyone argues he’s anti-universalist, here’s this link that refutes it.</strong></a></blockquote><blockquote><strong>“Wherefore, that at the same time liberty of free-will should be left to nature and yet the evil be purged away, the wisdom of God discovered this plan; to suffer man to do what he would, that having tasted the evil which he desired, and learning by experience for what wretchedness he had bartered away the blessings he had, he might of his own will hasten back with desire to the first blessedness …either being purged in this life through prayer and discipline, or after his departure hence through the furnace of cleansing fire” (Orat. pro Mortuis). — According to Gregory, some will be purged in this life, or in the next by means of the cleansing fire.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Diodore of Tarsus (b. 300?-390 AD): Solomon of Basra (early 13th century), an East Syriac writer after the fifth ecumenical council, quotes Diodore of Tarsus in his Book of the Bee.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>“But if punishment is to be weighed out according to sin, not even so would punishment be endless. For as regards that which is said in the Gospel, ‘These shall go away into everlasting punishment, but the righteous into life eternal;’ this word ‘eternal’ (le-`âlam) is not definite:…And of Babylon He said, ‘No man shall dwell therein for ever and ever,’ and behold many generations dwell therein.” Source: The Book of the Bee, Chapter LX. — Diodore argues that since olam in Hebrew means indefinite and not strictly eternal, then the judgement of sinners aren’t definitively endless.</strong></blockquote><p>There are many examples of universalism from the apostolic writings and patristic literature, whether explicit or implicit, but I will refrain from citing more for the sake of time.</p><h4>Origenism wasn’t Monolithic</h4><p>According to the antagonists of Origen, he held to the belief of the pre-existence of souls, and they appeal to patristic literature to support this narrative, but are they aware that the report of Origenism in the Early Church was inconsistent and even blatantly wrong? In one of the earliest reports of Origenism, Methodius of Olympus comments on Origen’s supposed belief in pre-existing souls, so he writes, <strong>“Οrigen, whom you refer to as “Kentauros,” claimed that everything is consubstantial with the only wise and self-sufficient God. He argued that if there is a Creator without creations, a Maker without things made, or an Almighty without what is subject to His power (since the Creator is called such due to creations, the Maker due to things made, and the Almighty due to what is subject to His power), then these must have existed from the beginning by God’s necessity, without a time when they did not exist. If there were a time when these creations did not exist, considering that there is no creator without things created, he saw such a notion as impious” (De Creatis 2.1, fragments derived from Photius). </strong>Methodius assumes that Origen held to the doctrine of eternal pre-existing souls, which is inconsistent with not only Rufinus’ report of Origenism, but also contrary with what Origen actually taught in First Principles, Book 1, Chapter 3, Section 3. Origen denies the past eternity of creation. Rufinus reports Origenism as, <strong>“Others assert that God is every day making new </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14153a.htm"><strong>souls</strong></a><strong>, and infusing them into the bodies which have been framed in the womb; while others again </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/02408b.htm"><strong>believe</strong></a><strong> that the </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14153a.htm"><strong>souls</strong></a><strong> were all made long ago, when God made all things of nothing, and that all that he now does is to plant out each </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14153a.htm"><strong>soul</strong></a><strong> in its body as it seems good to him”</strong> (<strong>Rufinus’</strong> <strong>Apology 6</strong>). Origenism is often understood as temporal pre-existing souls, but some from church history understood it as eternal pre-existing souls, which demonstrates that Origenism was not monolithic or universally agreed among Origenistic proponents.</p><p>Paulus Orosius the Historian erroneously attributed Origenism to one of the most respected Capadoccian Fathers, saying, <strong>“However, these two Auitus and the holy Basil the Greek, who were teaching these things, my most blessed father, have handed down certain teachings from the books of Origen that are not correct, as I am now learning for the first time. Firstly, they asserted that all things existed eternally in the wisdom of God before they appeared, saying this in these words: ‘For God, whatever He has made, did not begin by making it’” (Paulus Orosius’ Reminder to Aurelius Augustine Concerning the Errors of the Priscillianists and Origenists, Section 3). </strong>There are list of errors except a few correct ideas that Orosius continues to attribute to Basil and such. Based on this, if the Origenistic proponents could not argee on what Origen taught, and if historians like Orosius wrongly conflated Basil the Great with Origenism, then there is less and less reason for us to presume that Origen ever taught it. Origenism is likely a grand misrepresentation of Origen’s thoughts, which later patristic writers like Methodius, Epiphanius, Orosius, and the rest perceived to be the supposedly true doctrine of Origen. Even Fr. John Behr, Eastern Orthodox scholar, attributes blame to Paul Koetschau for interpolating patristic critiques of Origen into Rufinus’ Latin translation. <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/35553050">If anyone wishes to read Origen on First Principles, I suggest Fr John Behr’s new translation and revised edition.</a></p><p>So then, based on all the evidence, Origen is not a heretic, nor is he an inventor of the doctrine of Christian universalism, and the presence of allegoresis in his writings is orthodox in the early Christian tradition.</p><h4>Linked Websites</h4><ul><li><a href="https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2020/05/31/did-the-fifth-ecumenical-council-condemn-universal-salvation/">Did the Fifth Ecumenical Council Condemn Universal Salvation?</a></li><li><a href="https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2020/08/23/st-gregory-of-nyssa-teacher-of-eternal-damnation/">St. Gregory of Nyssa-Teacher of Eternal Damnation?</a></li><li><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/35553050">Origen: On First Principles, Reader&#39;s Edition (Oxford E...</a></li></ul><h4>Unmentioned Websites</h4><ul><li><a href="https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/facebook-comment-5d2ed9b35107">FaceBook Comment</a></li><li><a href="https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/anti-pauline-theology-5155b23f36a2">Anti-Pauline Theology!?</a></li><li><a href="https://www.google.com/search?q=youtube+basil+universalist&amp;rlz=1CAKCSV_enUS821&amp;oq=youtube+basil+universalist&amp;aqs=chrome..69i57j69i64.8263j0j7&amp;sourceid=chrome&amp;ie=UTF-8#:~:text=Was%20Basil%20of,8%20months%20ago">youtube basil universalist - Google Search</a></li><li><a href="https://www.google.com/search?q=dr+ramelli+on+basil+the+great&amp;rlz=1CAKCSV_enUS821&amp;oq=dr+ramelli+on+basil+the+great&amp;aqs=chrome..69i57j33i160j33i299l2.6022j0j4&amp;sourceid=chrome&amp;ie=UTF-8#:~:text=BASIL%20AND%20APOKATASTASIS,%E2%80%BA%202020/02">dr ramelli on basil the great - Google Search</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=15c2ddce7719" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Apologia for ‘Greek’ Ignatius]]></title>
            <link>https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/apologia-for-greek-ignatius-a140bd81e286?source=rss-446f9887eae0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a140bd81e286</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[early-church]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[faith]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ignatius-of-antioch]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patrístic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[George M. Garcia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Jan 2024 07:31:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-08T02:50:38.797Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Syriac &amp; Middle Greek Variations</h4><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FiFE8UjzWsKI%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DiFE8UjzWsKI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FiFE8UjzWsKI%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/eeebfe7673d34bf34fcf2e84acbe1100/href">https://medium.com/media/eeebfe7673d34bf34fcf2e84acbe1100/href</a></iframe><h4>Introduction</h4><p>In this post, I will demonstrate why Nathan’s claims that the “middle recension” aren’t as convincing as he claims. Though I understand I am disagreeing with a perceived scholar, I do not find his rebuttals on the Greek middle transmission compelling. I find his assertion of Ignatius and the Syriac collection to be misleading, if not unpersuasive. Due to time constraints, I will not be highlighting his exact words with a specific time stamp as I did in previous posts. I am here to simply respond to certain points he made throughout the video.</p><h4>Subject #1 — The Dating Priority</h4><p>According to Nathan and other sources, the Syriac collection was estimated to be around the fourth and fifth century. And he contends that the Greek collection (including the longer Arian collection) are dated to be older and even interpolated after the death of Ignatius of Antioch. And so, his whole argument is that the Syriac collection must be genuine, because not only does the Greek collection (specifically the longer recension) retain interpolations, but it seems to indicate that the Greek collection should likely contain interpolations even in the middle collection due to a late dating and similar manuscript tradition.</p><p>While this theory might seem convincing initially, it doesn’t seem effective at retrospect. The two earliest witnesses of the Greek collection (<em>e.g. Eusebius and Athanasius</em>) are dated around the middle third and late fourth century, which surpasses the Syriac collection by a century or somewhat less. Despite having later transmissions of their writings (due to some concerns), Eusebius and Athanasius do not support the Syriac collection. Nathan and the host speculate that these two early witnesses are too late or distant to be accurate witnesses of the Greek Ignatian collection, but the same objection can be made against the Syriac collection due to being a century older than the two witnesses. Although, their writings are later transmissions, there is no valid reason to speculate that someone interpolated Eusebius and Athanasius to support the Greek collection of Ignatius since not even Origen or Irenaeus (i.e. earlier patristic witnesses) were interpolated to support this cause. The given dating priority by Nathan simply has no effective cause for changing our minds about the Middle collection unless the Syriac collection were as early as the 2nd century. But again, the dating objection isn’t sufficient to refute the Middle collection.</p><h4>Subject #2 — Theological Contents</h4><p>Nathan argues that the longer recension was likely interpolated by the Arians to support their cause in the controversy. I am inclined to agree that the Longer collection was interpolated due to noticing deviations from Ignatius’ thought found in the Middle collection. And interpolations are most noticeable in a collection that is part of the longer corpus. He argues that since there was a theological controversy concerning the divinity of Jesus, orthodox Christians likely interpolated Ignatius’ letters while the Arians fabricated the longer corpus; however, this objection as well seems implausible.</p><p>The Middle collection of Ignatius represents beliefs prevalent in the early days of the Early Church prior to the theological controversy of the Arians. These beliefs demonstrated in the middle corpus are Docetism (<em>i.e. early gnostic heresy</em>), anti-torah observance (<em>e.g. as evidenced in early writings like the Apology of Aristides XIV, the Epistle to the Hebrews 8–10, Epistle of Barnabas 9–10, Epistle to Diognetus 3–4</em>), the Christocentric exegesis of Scripture (<em>i.e. the Old Testament is read in primacy of Christ instead of in equal terms</em>), mono-episcopacy, and a partial eschatology commonly shared by Polycarp 2 and the Didache 16:7 (<em>i.e. only the justified are resurrected except the wicked due to concealing universalism from the masses</em>). If orthodox Christians wished to fabricate the middle corpus of Ignatius, then why add theologies that are no longer relevant to the late theological controversy like Docetism and anti-torah observance? It seems extremely unlikely for orthodox Christians to interpolate that many theological subjects with most subjects being irrelevant to the Arian controversy. This accusation by Nathan that Ignatius wasn’t theologically oriented seems implausible due to his role as a bishop and his apostolic succession from the apostles.</p><blockquote>Citations from Greek Ignatius:</blockquote><p><strong>Docetism, Smyrnaeans 5:2–3.</strong></p><p><strong>Christo-exegesis, Philadelphians 8:2–9:2.</strong></p><p><strong>Anti-Torah, Magnesians 8:1–9:2.</strong></p><p><strong>Partial Eschatology (denying their resurrection), Smyrnaeans 2.</strong></p><p><strong>Doctrine of Reserve (due to concealing universal resurrection), Traillians 5:1–2.</strong></p><h4>Subject #3 — Style of Writing/Composition</h4><p>Nathan seems to think that since the middle corpus doesn’t flow as naturally as the Syriac collection, it is likely that the middle corpus was interpolated due to an unsound structure. While this assertion seems defensible, this claim is somewhat misleading, because authentic Ignatius was plausibly under distress and too constrained by time to compose a sound structure of his thoughts; hence, we find run-on sentences and so forth. Ignatius most likely had no secretary, so this might explain the lack of natural literary flow.</p><h4>Subject #4 — Quotations Derived From Limited Data</h4><p>Nathan and the host believe that Origen and Irenaeus did not quote portions only unique to the Greek corpus, but portions that are found in both manuscript traditions, which concludes that the Syriac collection was known by the earliest witnesses instead of the Greek collection. This argument stems from the appeal of probability and improbability due to the unlikely nature of quoting portions not unique to the Greek corpus. But this argument doesn’t seem convincing, because Irenaeus and Origen merely used Ignatius as an example of his love and mental fortitude for Christ. If Irenaeus and Origen gave full commentaries on the epistles of Ignatius, and there happen to be no trace of the middle corpus, this argument would be more compelling than citing small portions of Ignatius. While this appeal against the middle corpus might have some merit, I don’t find it fair to classify this as an effective objection due to limited data on Ignatian quotes during the early centuries of the Church. If Nathan and the host have a full commentary of the Ignatian epistles by Origen or Irenaeus, then the case would be closed, but they certainly don’t possess this kind of evidence or data. In other words, it’s a bit more speculative.</p><h4>Personal Objection on the Syriac Community (&amp; Closing)</h4><p>The Syriac collection of Ignatius seems to be a limitation on material resource and transmission, or perhaps the transmitter could not accurately convey Ignatius’ deeper thoughts on theology due to limited Greek education. But despite these speculations posed by me, the Syriac tradition or community had limited resources; for example, no Syriac Christian writer had any knowledge of the Shepherd despite its fame in the Greek and Latin communities (nor was it ever quoted), there’s more patristic writers exemplified by the Greek and Latin communities than the Syriac community, and even the four Gospels in their independent forms weren’t accessible to the Syriac community, which led them to rely on Tatian’s harmonized text of the four Gospels, the Diatessaron, for a few centuries until Theodoret confiscated and replaced them in the fifth century (<em>cf. Jonathan E. Soyars, The Shepherd of Hermas and the Pauline Legacy (Brill, 2019), pp. 9 — 10; Cross, F. L, ed. The Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church. New York: Oxford University Press. 2005, article Diatessaron</em>). Based on these three major premises, there’s no compelling reason to suggest that the Syriac collection is a byproduct of a resourceful transmission, nor is there any reason to conclude that the Syriac community always had complete texts that were faithfully transmitted from the Koine Greek. If the four Gospels and the Shepherd, both of which are famed texts, weren’t known or reliably transmitted until the fifth century, then it is likely that the Greek collection of Ignatius failed to be transmitted in its entirety; hence, why we have abridged epistles and a heavy absence of most Ignatian theological content.</p><h3>Extras</h3><ul><li><a href="https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/mark-7-19-interpolated-or-faithful-e4b8ebe6b86d">Mark 7:19: Interpolated or Faithful</a></li><li><a href="https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/correcting-the-biblical-mind-3a399a36aecf">Correcting the “Biblical Mind”</a></li><li><a href="https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/christians-denying-the-mystic-tradition-they-shouldnt-291ac4eda7b2">Christians Denying the Mystic Tradition — they shouldn’t</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a140bd81e286" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mark 7:19: Interpolated or Faithful]]></title>
            <link>https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/mark-7-19-interpolated-or-faithful-e4b8ebe6b86d?source=rss-446f9887eae0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e4b8ebe6b86d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[church-fathers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biblical-exegesis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gospel-of-mark]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mark-7]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mosaic-law]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[George M. Garcia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 11 Dec 2023 03:57:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-03T00:49:06.925Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How the Gospels Diverge on Jesus’ Teaching</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MELFHpleqSLvAGjZREpjPg@2x.jpeg" /></figure><h4>My Refutation Towards these Websites:</h4><ul><li><a href="https://davidwilber.com/articles/did-jesus-reject-the-torahs-dietary-laws-mark">Did Jesus Reject the Torah&#39;s Dietary Laws? (Mark 7:1-23) - David Wilber</a></li><li><a href="https://joshuaensley.org/2018/03/19/mark-7-did-jesus-change-the-biblical-dietary-laws/">Mark 7 - Did Jesus Change the Biblical Dietary Laws? - Joshua Ensley</a></li></ul><h4>Additional Websites:</h4><ul><li><a href="https://www.neverthirsty.org/bible-qa/qa-archives/question/was-thus-he-declared-all-foods-clean-inserted-by-man-mark-719/">Was &#39;thus He declared all foods clean&#39; inserted by man? - Mark 7:19</a></li><li><a href="https://codexsinaiticus.org/en/manuscript.aspx?book=34&amp;chapter=7&amp;lid=en&amp;side=r&amp;verse=2&amp;zoomSlider=0">Codex Sinaiticus - See The Manuscript | Mark |</a></li></ul><h4>Introduction</h4><p>A common error in fundamentalist Protestantism is the vain attempt to reconcile contradictory texts in the Bible. And even these Christian websites cannot agree on what the Gospel of Mark says. One website in affirmation of the mosaic rites will presuppose that Mark did not say that Jesus taught that all foods are clean, whereas another website denies the interpolation theory and says that Jesus according to Mark did teach this. In my own assessment, I will mostly be refuting the article that proposes the “articulation theory” and will argue at length why Matthew and Mark do not agree. Jesus rejected the dietary laws and this understanding does not conflict with Christian orthodoxy.</p><h4>Responding to the Articles (quoted in italics)</h4><blockquote><strong><em>Here’s Mark Chapter 7 in the NRSVUE:</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>7) Now when the Pharisees and some of the scribes who had come from Jerusalem gathered around him, [2] they noticed that some of his disciples were eating with defiled hands, that is, without washing them. [3] (For the Pharisees, and all the Jews, do not eat unless they wash their hands,” thus observing the tradition of the elders, 4 and they do not eat anything from the market unless they wash, and there are also many other traditions that they observe: the washing of cups and pots and bronze kettles and beds.”</strong></blockquote><blockquote>[5] So the <strong>Pharisees and the scribes asked him, “Why do your disciples not walk according to the tradition of the elders but eat with defiled hands?” </strong>[6] He said to them, “Isaiah prophesied rightly about you hypocrites, as it is written, ‘This people honors me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me; [7] in vain do they worship me, teaching human precepts as doctrines.’</blockquote><blockquote><strong>[8] “You abandon the commandment of God and hold to human tradition.”</strong></blockquote><blockquote>[9] Then <strong>he said to them, “You have a fine way of rejecting the commandment of God in order to keep your tradition! [10] For Moses said, ‘Honor your father and your mother,’ and, ‘Whoever speaks evil of father or mother must surely die.’ [11] But you say that if anyone tells father or mother, ‘Whatever support you might have had from me is Corban’ (that is, an offering to God, [12] then you no longer permit doing anything for a father or mother, [13] thus nullifying the word of God through your tradition that you have handed on.</strong> And you do many things like this.”</blockquote><blockquote>[14] Then he called the crowd again and said to them,<strong> “Listen to me, all of you, and understand: [15] there is nothing outside a person that by going in can defile, but the things that come out are what defile.”</strong> [Verse 16 omitted in this translation]</blockquote><blockquote>[17] When he had left the crowd and entered the house, his disciples asked him about the parable. [18] <strong>He said to them, “So, are you also without understanding? Do you not see that whatever goes into a person from outside cannot defile, [19] since it enters not the heart but the stomach and goes out into the sewer?” (Thus he declared all foods clean.) [20] And he said, “It is what comes out of a person that defiles. [21] For it is from within, from the human heart, that evil intentions come: sexual immorality, theft, murder, [22] adultery, avarice, wickedness, deceit, debauchery, envy, slander, pride, folly. </strong>[23] All these evil things come from within, and they defile a person.”</blockquote><p>Now, let’s hear the articles before I rebut them:</p><blockquote>A common interpretation of these verses is that Jesus abolished the Torah’s distinctions between clean and unclean food at that moment. The end of verse 19 (“Thus he declared all foods clean”) is often understood as Mark’s parenthetical statement explaining Jesus’s teaching. Thus, the Torah’s commandments against eating meat from unclean animals (e.g., Leviticus 11) are no longer relevant to Christians. These comments from R. L. Solberg, an outspoken critic of Pronomian (pro-law/Torah) theology, are representative of the traditional perspective:</blockquote><blockquote>Jesus taught that all foods are clean and, as God incarnate, all foods became clean at His word. Thus, any of His listeners who decided to begin eating previously unkosher foods at that time would not have been in violation of the Law.</blockquote><blockquote>Solberg is certainly not alone in saying that Mark 7:18–19 is an example of Jesus doing away with the Torah’s dietary laws. But although this interpretation may be popular, numerous New Testament scholars soundly reject it.According to Dr. Matthew Thiessen, “Nothing suggests that the Gospel writers intended to portray Jesus rejecting the Jewish dietary laws.”</blockquote><p>The appeal to majority as being valid is certainly a epistemic fallacy, which has often shifted depending on the mutable theological culture and new available data that later refutes many misguided interpretations. In relation to Mark 7, Jesus is conferring a principle that nothing we eat can defile our hearts, which is aimed at the status of the food ingested instead of whether one’s hands were washed or not (<em>cf. verses 18–23</em>). Now, allow me to refute the following points:</p><blockquote><strong><em>1) The traditional interpretation of this passage makes Jesus a hypocrite.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>One of Jesus’s criticisms of the Pharisees in Mark 7 was that they were hypocrites who “leave the commandment of God and hold to the tradition of men” (7:8).</strong> He said they “reject” and “nullify” God’s commandments/word (7:9, 13). <strong>Does it make any sense for Jesus to criticize the Pharisees for rejecting God’s commandments while at the same time doing away with the Torah’s dietary laws? Wouldn’t Jesus himself be a hypocrite if he invalidated God’s commandments immediately after condemning the Pharisees for invalidating God’s commandments?</strong></blockquote><p>No, Jesus would not be a hypocrite for rejecting the dietary laws, because the dietary laws didn’t come from God, but rather from the Ancient Near Eastern culture. God did not confer the mosaic laws to the Jews, instead He allowed them to adopt these customs, so as to reorient them for the future by giving us the spiritual (<em>aka pneumatic</em>) reading. In other words, imagine I wrote a book about folklore intending to communicate my own religious ideas about the afterlife and so forth, but God, rather than inspiring the contextual contents, inspired the symbolism and subtleties to point to His Son. God did not inspire the origin of the customs, but only its symbolic features. This theological view was commonly known by Paul and the Early Church (<em>cf. Colossians 2:16–17; Hebrews 8:7, 10:1; Epistle of Barnabas </em><strong><em>[not the gospel of Barnabas!]</em></strong><em> 10:2–9; Contra Celsum V:60</em>). Christ is subtly arguing that the dietary laws in the mosaic law weren’t divinely inspired by origin.</p><blockquote><strong><em>2) The controversy was over ritual handwashing, not the Torah’s dietary laws.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>The Pharisees confronted Jesus <em>not</em> because his disciples disregarded the Torah but because they disregarded “the tradition of the elders” (7:5). One of the traditions of the elders was that a person must ritually wash his hands before eating regular meals. </strong>Where did this tradition come from? As Jacob Neusner explains, the Pharisees reinterpreted many of the priestly laws to apply outside of the context of the Temple:</blockquote><blockquote>The Pharisees were Jews who believed one must keep the purity laws outside of the Temple. Other Jews, following the plain sense of Leviticus, supposed that purity laws were to be kept only in the Temple, where the priests had to enter a state of ritual purity in order to carry out such requirements as animal sacrifices. They likewise had to eat their Temple food in a state of ritual purity, while lay people did not. To be sure, everyone who went to the Temple had to be ritually pure. But outside of the Temple the laws of ritual purity were not observed, for it was not required that noncultic activities be conducted in a state of Levitical cleanness. But the Pharisees held that even outside of the Temple, in one’s own home, the laws of ritual purity were to be followed in the only circumstance in which they might apply, namely, at the table. Therefore, one must eat secular food (ordinary, everyday meals) in a state of ritual purity as if one were a Temple priest.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Although the Torah does command priests to wash their hands when serving in the tabernacle (Exodus 30:17–21), there is no commandment for non-priests outside of the tabernacle to wash their hands. Indeed, Mark explicitly identifies the Pharisees’ ritual as “tradition,” in contrast to God’s commandments. In any case, the context of this conflict between Jesus and the Pharisees in Mark 7 gives no indication that the Torah’s dietary laws are in view. The controversy concerned ritual handwashing. Thus, there is no textual basis for importing the Torah’s dietary laws into this passage.</strong></blockquote><p>There’s many assumptions being displayed here. Jesus intended the dietary laws and not the washing of hands. He changes the subject from washing of hands to dishonoring parents by offering to God, so it’s not inconsistent for Jesus to speak of the dietary laws in the final instance. The fact that Jesus compares the dietary laws to the washing of hands or neglecting parents indicates that He believed the dietary laws were “human traditions”. While it’s true in the beginning, Mark goes into length concerning the washing of hands, Jesus changes the subject casually and ends with a rebuttal for the logic behind the dietary laws. Jesus didn’t judge them for not knowing what wasn’t from God (i.e. mosaic tradition), but He judged them for knowing what wasn’t from God — their recent traditions like hand washing or their neglect of their own parents. Jesus was judging them for their inconsistency in their own beliefs.</p><blockquote><strong><em>3) Mark’s earliest readers did not understand Jesus’s teaching in Mark 7:1–23 to be a rejection of the dietary laws.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Most scholars recognize that both Matthew and Luke used Mark’s gospel as a source for their writing. When copying from Mark, Matthew is known to make adjustments and additions to Mark’s account to be more precise. </strong>Notably, when Matthew records his version of this conflict in Mark 7, he makes explicit the fact that the controversy concerned hand washing:</blockquote><blockquote>But what comes out of the mouth proceeds from the heart, and this defiles a person. For out of the heart come evil thoughts, murder, adultery, sexual immorality, theft, false witness, slander. These are what defile a person. <strong>But to eat with unwashed hands</strong> does not defile anyone.” — Matthew 15:18–20</blockquote><p>While it is plausible that Matthew and Luke borrowed some elements from the Gospel of Mark, there is no consistent evidence to suggest that it was entirely for the reason of accurate articulations or additions. The Gospel of Matthew was intended as a polemic against the Judaic rejection of Jesus, so the author of Matthew made adjustments suitable to the Jewish audience regardless of validity due to its polemical nature. The Gospel of Mark is more accurate in this scenario due to it being a closer address to past events than Matthew or Luke; it also lacks the polemical nature that Matthew was employing.</p><p>In the same article — though not quoted here, the author argues that they may have had different theological approaches, but the author dismisses this proposition in favor of the articulation theory with no compelling reason. It is plausible to suggest that the author of Matthew was closer to the spectrum of Judaized Christians instead of Mark, which explains his numerous typological quotations of the Hebrew Bible and his reinterpretation of Mark 7 suggesting hand-washings. In evidence of my proposition, Mark and Matthew diverge on a few points, whether Jesus said “Moses” in Mark or said “God” in Matthew as the delegate of the commands. Mark claims that Jesus meant the dietary laws while Matthew meant the washing of hands. Mark is the oldest written document, so he orchestrates a narrative where Jesus diverged from the mosaic laws; on the contrary, Matthew is polemical to the Jews, so he orchestrated a narrative in favor of the mosaic laws. This is why Mark mentions Jesus saying “Moses” to dilute or limit the mosaic laws as having divine influence, but Matthew mentions Him saying “God” to affirm their divine influence.</p><p>In another instance, a gentile woman requires Jesus to deliver her daughter from demons as recorded in Matthew 15:</p><blockquote>“A Canaanite woman from that vicinity came to him, crying out, “Lord, Son of David, have mercy on me! My daughter is demon-possessed and suffering terribly.” 23 Jesus did not answer a word. So his disciples came to him and urged him, “Send her away, for she keeps crying out after us.” 24 He answered, “I was sent only to the lost sheep of Israel.” 25 The woman came and knelt before him. “Lord, help me!” she said. 26 He replied, “It is not right to take the children’s bread and toss it to the dogs.” 27 “Yes it is, Lord,” she said. “Even the dogs eat the crumbs that fall from their master’s table.” 28 Then Jesus said to her, “Woman, you have great faith! Your request is granted.” And her daughter was healed at that moment.</blockquote><p>The Gospel of Matthew depicts Jesus as being more exclusive due to ignoring the woman when she speaks, claims He was sent only to the Jews while excluding the Gentiles as a possibility, and then asserting that only Jews have the right to salvation or healing despite Jesus honoring the woman in the final instance. However, the Gospel of Mark omits all these elements in Chapter 7:</p><blockquote>25 In fact, as soon as she heard about him, a woman whose little daughter was possessed by an impure spirit came and fell at his feet. 26 The woman was a Greek, born in Syrian Phoenicia. She begged Jesus to drive the demon out of her daughter. 27 “First let the children eat all they want,” he told her, “for it is not right to take the children’s bread and toss it to the dogs.” 28 “Lord,” she replied, “even the dogs under the table eat the children’s crumbs.” 29 Then he told her, “For such a reply, you may go; the demon has left your daughter.”</blockquote><p>The Gospel of Mark depicts Jesus as being more inclusive, and He even says let the Jews have their blessings first before you receive your blessings. While some will try to argue that the Jews had a special relationship with God, this is not at all what Jesus means. Jesus was trying to test the woman’s heart and debunk a myth that His disciples believed in by demonstrating that even a Gentile woman can be faithful and not just a Jew. Even in the Old Testament, the prophet Amos believes that God gave exoduses to other nations, and it records that God gave salvation for healing to a Gentile soldier, which of course required a test of his heart (<em>cf. Amos 9:7; 2nd Kings 5:1–17</em>).</p><blockquote><strong><em>4) Jesus’s earliest followers did not understand Jesus’s teaching in Mark 7:1–23 to be a rejection of the Torah’s dietary laws.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Acts 10 is another passage that sheds light on Jesus’s teaching in Mark 7. Here, Luke records that Peter received a vision in which he was told to “kill and eat” unclean animals. Peter was shocked by this instruction and refused to violate the Torah’s dietary laws: “By no means, Lord; for I have never eaten anything that is common or unclean” (Acts 10:14). </strong>This is significant because Peter witnessed the conflict recorded in Mark 7 between Jesus and the Pharisees and heard Jesus’s private explanation of his teaching (Matthew 15:15). <strong>If Jesus abolished the dietary laws several years earlier in Mark 7, Peter’s response in this passage doesn’t add up. Some might argue that Peter’s vision in Acts 10 teaches that the dietary laws were nullified, suggesting that Luke understood Jesus to have abolished the Torah’s dietary laws when he read Mark’s account.</strong></blockquote><p>It is interesting that this person presumes that the Torah, specifically the mosaic customs, still apply to the Gentile Christians which is very misguided and contrary to Paul’s arguments. This person then adds that if Peter understood the dietary laws to be mentioned by Jesus, he would have adhered to what Jesus taught; on the contrary, Jesus tried to show him that salvation of healing and deliverance extends to the Gentiles, yet Peter did not retain these lessons in mind (<em>cf. Mark 7:25–29; Luke 7:1–10</em>). Even Gregory the Wonderworker (b. 213) in his canonical epistle understood Jesus “cleansing all meats” rather than washing hands as some suggest: <strong>“But the Saviour also, who cleanseth all meats, says, ‘Not that which goeth into a man defileth the man, but that which cometh out’”</strong> (Canonical Epistle, Canon I).</p><p>Anyway, the article is pure speculation, because Paul certainly understood Jesus abolishing the mosaic customs in Ephesians; for instance,<strong> “For He Himself is our peace, who has made the two one and has torn down the dividing wall of hostility [15]</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/2673.htm"><strong> by abolishin</strong></a><strong>g</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/1722.htm"><strong> i</strong></a><strong>n</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/846.htm"><strong> Hi</strong></a><strong>s</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/4561.htm"><strong> fles</strong></a><strong>h</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/3588.htm"><strong> th</strong></a><strong>e</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/3551.htm"><strong> la</strong></a><strong>w</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/1785.htm"><strong> of commandment</strong></a><strong>s</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/1722.htm"><strong> an</strong></a><strong>d</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/1378.htm"><strong> decrees</strong></a><strong>.</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/2443.htm"><strong> He did this t</strong></a><strong>o</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/2936.htm"><strong> creat</strong></a><strong>e</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/1722.htm"><strong> i</strong></a><strong>n</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/848.htm"><strong> Himsel</strong></a><strong>f</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/1520.htm"><strong> on</strong></a><strong>e</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/2537.htm"><strong> ne</strong></a><strong>w</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/444.htm"><strong> ma</strong></a><strong>n</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/1519.htm"><strong> out o</strong></a><strong>f</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/3588.htm"><strong> th</strong></a><strong>e</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/1417.htm"><strong> two</strong></a><strong>,</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/4160.htm"><strong> thus makin</strong></a><strong>g</strong><a href="https://biblehub.com/greek/1515.htm"><strong> peac</strong></a><strong>e [16] and reconciling both of them to God in one body through the cross, by which He extinguished their hostility…,”</strong> and<strong> “In that he says, ‘A new covenant’, He has made the first old. But that which is becoming old and grows aged is near to vanishing away,</strong>” and<strong> “Now these things having been thus prepared, the priests go in continually into the first tabernacle, accomplishing the services, [7] but into the second the high priest alone, once in the year, not without blood, which he offers for himself, and for the errors of the people. [8] The Holy Spirit is indicating this, that the way into the Holy Place wasn’t yet revealed while the first tabernacle was still standing. [9] This is a symbol of the present age, where gifts and sacrifices are offered that are incapable, concerning the conscience, of making the worshiper perfect, [10] being only (with meats and drinks and various washings) fleshly ordinances, imposed until a time of reformation</strong>” <em>(cf. Ephesians 2:14–16; Hebrews 8:13, 9:6–1</em>0). In the book of Hebrews, the author of Hebrews is stating that the old covenant was abolished or nullified in primacy of Christ’s covenant, and he is reinterpreting the old system by spiritual allegory which is why he says<em> “the Holy Spirit is indicating</em>” and<em> “this is a symbol of the present age</em>”. The external regulations or<em> “fleshly ordinances</em>” were imposed<em> “until a time of reformation</em>”, meaning God allowed these human customs to preside over the Israelite people until Christ came to correct or revise these human traditions attributed to Moses. A reformation can only exist if the system itself is in error, which means the Mosaic customs and the Levitical priesthood were in error; Christ came to reform Mosaic Judaism, and not just the present Judaisms in His time.</p><p>The author of this article or blog attempts to appeal to the Didache in favor of enjoining the mosaic dietary laws onto the Gentile Christians based on the scholarly reading of Kurt Niederwimmer. But based on the Didache, such a reading is purely speculative and unverifiable. The author then appeals to another scholar, saying, <strong><em>“The dietary laws were not clearly condemned in the Gospels, Acts of the Apostles, or in the first-century Pauline tradition.”</em></strong> But I have demonstrated in Ephesians and specifically in the book of Hebrews that such mosaic customs or laws have been abolished and concluded as human traditions. The author of the blog then appeals that the second century writers changed their attitude towards the Mosaic customs due to avoiding <strong><em>“the repressive and punitive measures (fiscal, military, political, and literary) aimed at the Jews”</em></strong> according to his appeal of someone named Lawrence Geraty. However, such appeals are ignorant, because none of the Christian writers of the second and third century named this as the cause; in fact, Saint Ignatius of Antioch, who was a student of the apostles like Peter and Paul, argued against the continuation of the mosaic observance. He writes,<strong> “Be not led astray by strange doctrines or by old fables which are profitless. For if we are living until now according to Judaism, we confess that we have not received grace,”</strong> and <strong>“But if anyone interpret Judaism to you do not listen to him; for it is better to hear Christianity from the circumcised than Judaism from the uncircumcised. But both of them, unless they speak of Jesus Christ, are to me tombstones and sepulchers of the dead, on whom only the names of men are written. Flee then from the wicked arts and snares of the prince of this world, lest you be afflicted by his device, and grow weak in love; but come all together with undivided heart”</strong> (Ign. Magnesians 8:1; Philadelphians 6:1–2). Ignatius is repeating Paul’s accusation against the Galatians when they obey the mosaic or ritual customs at the expense of grace, and Ignatius borrows Paul’s symbolic sense of circumcision derived from Romans while comparing the ways of Judaism as an example of a demonic de<em>vice (cf. Galatians 5:4; Roman</em>s 2:29).</p><p>The author of this same article tries to explain away the phrase <em>“[Thus He declared] all foods to be cleansed”</em> as a mention of food being purged out of the body as excrement; however, this reading conflicts with the whole context of Mark 7 in relation to the dietary laws. Even another article also attempts to argue against the translation:</p><blockquote><strong>The next part of the problem lies within the supplying of words that are simply not in the text. Literally the clause reads, “purifying/purging all foods.” Most translators supply a subject (Jesus), verb (declares/declared), and a conjunction (thus) when rendering the clause (“Thus, Jesus declares all foods clean”). Though I am not a fan of the King James Version, I propose the idea that the KJV translators translated this verse correctly, while the modern translations did not</strong>.<strong> I believe this is because the KJV translation is nearly four centuries old and the influence of this anti-Torah doctrine was not as prevalent back then.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Since then, the majority of English translations supply non-existing subjects, verbs, and conjunctions to this clause, <strong>thus rendering it inaccurately.</strong> The most accurate way to translate this verse would be to continue it as the words of Jesus and to render it as: <em>“</em><strong><em>Do you not see that whatever goes into a person from outside cannot defile him? (19) Because it enters not into his heart but his stomach, and is expelled, cleansing all the foods?” </em></strong>The point that Jesus is trying to make is that everything we eat will eventually be expelled by our bodies’ natural cleansing methods, but the problem with our hearts is that they will never purge the wickedness within unless we surrender to God and his will for our lives, which includes keeping his commandments and not our own, as Jesus has so eloquently told the Jewish leaders in this text.</blockquote><p>But this is another vain attempt to reconcile the text. Some Greek sentences or idioms cannot be translated word-for-word or literally, because it would cause confusion to the reader, so the translators appeal to conceptual translations instead to better represent the Greek sentence, not to deceive anyone due to some Judaic “prejudice”. It is most plausible to suggest that Mark is commenting on what Jesus said: “<strong>He said to them, ‘So, are you also without understanding? Do you not see that whatever goes into a person from outside cannot defile, [19] since it enters not the heart but the stomach and goes out into the sewer?’— [Thus He declared] all foods clean.” </strong>Very few argue that the last phrase “all foods cleansed” does not exist in early manuscripts of Mark from the third and fourth centuries; however, the Codex <a href="https://codexsinaiticus.org/en/manuscript.aspx?book=34&amp;chapter=7&amp;lid=en&amp;side=r&amp;verse=2&amp;zoomSlider=0">Sinaiticus</a> contains this phrase: <strong>καθαρίζων πάντα τα βρώματα</strong> (<em>literally: purifying all foods, or: rendering all foods clean</em>). While two of these articles I have quoted against are Judaic Christians, there’s another article that believes otherwise:</p><blockquote>In verse 18 Jesus tells us that what goes into a man’s mouth and into his stomach cannot defile him. What defiles a man is what is in the heart. <strong>Therefore, verse 19 concludes that all foods are clean. Thus the Mosaic food laws no longer exist.</strong> We can now eat any food, including those from the <a href="https://www.neverthirsty.org/bible-qa/qa-archives/question/is-it-a-sin-to-eat-unclean-animals-today/">animals</a> that the Mosaic law consider unclean.</blockquote><p>The two articles represent Judaic Christian fundamentalism, and the last article I quoted above me represents an Antinomian Christian fundamentalism, but both of these systems are erroneous. Christian orthodoxy was aware that God never delegated the mosaic law, nor did He ordain it so as to abolish it later, but God allowed them to use their human customs to re-purpose them by conferring the spiritual reading when the Hellenistic culture invented allegoresis, and when Christ appeared to reform them. The Early Church Fathers like patristic Barnabas believed that God never commanded the Hebrews to not eat pork, but conveyed a spiritual lesson through the spiritual reading. <strong>“Moreover Moses says to them in Deuteronomy, “And I will make a covenant of my ordinances with this people.” So then the ordinance of God is not abstinence from eating, but Moses spoke in the spirit. He mentioned the swine for this reason: you shall not consort, he means, with men who are like swine, that is to say, when they have plenty they forget the Lord, but when they are in want they recognize the Lord, just as the swine when it eats does not know its master, but when it is hungry it cries out, and after receiving food is again silent…Moses received three doctrines concerning food and thus spoke of them in the Spirit; but they received them as truly referring to food, owing to the lust of their flesh” <em>(Barnabas 10.2–3, 9). </em></strong>Saint Athanasius taught that God never commanded nor appointed sacrifice, but rather inspired the types and shadows to point to Christ rather than the authorial context. He quotes from Colossians 2:17 and Hebrews 9:10 in the same manner as I did in this medium article: “<strong>Now it appears to me — may God grant, by your prayers, that the remarks I presume to make may not be far from the truth — that not at first were the commandment and the law concerning sacrifices, neither did the mind of God, who gave the law, regard whole burnt-offerings, but those things which were pointed out and prefigured by them. ‘For the law contained a shadow of good things to come.’ And, ‘Those things were appointed until the time of reformation’…Therefore neither at the beginning, when God brought the people out of Egypt, did He command them concerning sacrifices or whole burnt-offerings, nor even when they came to mount Sinai” (<em>Letter 19, Section 3–4, Athanasius of Alexandria</em></strong><em>).</em></p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>So far, the Early Church were not fundamentalists of either the Judaic or Antinomian traditions. I have explained why Mark and Matthew diverge in their interpretation of Jesus’ teaching, and how the apostolic scriptures disagree with the Judaized and Antinomian fundamentalist ideas of the mosaic law. They simply did not believe that the mosaic laws were divine by origin, but appealed to the pneumatic reading of it as being inspired (<strong><em>e.g. Paul the apostle, Book of Hebrews, patristic Barnabas, Origen [on contra Celsus V.60], &amp; Athanasius</em></strong>). The phrase in Mark 7 is faithful to the Christian message, and not an interpolation. If we attempt to prioritize the narrative as portrayed by Matthew over Mark’s narrative, not only are we falsely propagating the doctrine of inerrancy, but also such a claim dangerously leads to Judaized fundamentalism.</p><p>Even the Ebionites (some early Christians who advocated continual mosaic observance) relied on the Gospel of Matthew for their understanding of Christ, whom were against Christian orthodoxy. Irenaeus of Lyon records that the Ebionites used the Gospel of Matthew exclusively while neglecting the other gospels (<em>cf. Against Heresies I.26.2</em>). Because most misguided Christians have declared that the mosaic law as being divine in origin and in practice, some of them have become advocates of continual mosaic observance and have become like their unorthodox predecessors, the Ebionites. We must be textually critical and theologically discerning, instead of being naive to uphold a dogma invented in the sixteen century, and proposing a theory like the Matthean priority, which conflicts with good scholarship.</p><h4>Recommended Websites</h4><ul><li><a href="https://kylerhughes.com/2013/08/20/were-the-fathers-inerrantists-a-response-to-kevin-deyoung/">Were the Fathers Inerrantists? A Response to Kevin DeYoung</a></li><li><a href="https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/correcting-the-biblical-mind-3a399a36aecf">Correcting the “Biblical Mind”</a></li><li><a href="https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/isaiah-53-isnt-a-crucified-messiah-pt-b-59faad381d83">Isaiah 53 isn’t a Crucified Messiah (Pt. B)</a></li></ul><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F2Mo52Ew2G_U%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D2Mo52Ew2G_U&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F2Mo52Ew2G_U%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/553c2520d91d71eec9cd36206f7fe7ed/href">https://medium.com/media/553c2520d91d71eec9cd36206f7fe7ed/href</a></iframe><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e4b8ebe6b86d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[FaceBook Comment]]></title>
            <link>https://theopneustos-writer.medium.com/facebook-comment-5d2ed9b35107?source=rss-446f9887eae0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5d2ed9b35107</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[universalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patristic-theology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-testament]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[facebook-comments]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[second-temple-judaism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[George M. Garcia]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Oct 2023 03:25:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-13T01:24:22.278Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Responding Contra Infernalism</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SfejRf0n1eYvWP7TvrHkww@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Deeksha Pahariya on Unsplash</figcaption></figure><h4>Preface</h4><p>There was a day where I received criticism for quoting the Fathers <em>(i.e. Clement of Alexandria &amp; Hermas the mystic)</em> in support of Christian universalism <em>(or a purgative hell/post-mortem redemption at least)</em>, for quoting Corinthians and 1st Peter as well, and this same individual made empty appeals to Second Temple Judaism; in addition, this person <strong>(we’ll assume it’s a he and call him Josiah)</strong> said that <em>“the predominant or consensus view in Second Temple Judaism was eternal perdition.”</em> Josiah seems overly confident in his misguided assertions and seems desperate, and even insecure for his attempts in refuting Christian universalism, so here’s a list of things I’m going to cover in this post:</p><ol><li><strong>The Universalist Interpretation of 1st Corin. 3:12–15</strong></li><li><strong>1st Peter 4:6 in Light of Post-mortem Redemption</strong></li><li><strong>2nd Temple Judaism &amp; Why the Consensus View Fails</strong></li><li><strong>Saint Clement of Alexandria</strong></li><li><strong>The Shepherd of Hermas</strong></li></ol><h4>The Universalist Interpretation of 1st Corin. 3:12–15</h4><blockquote><strong>Now if anyone builds on the foundation with gold, silver, precious stones, wood, hay, or straw, 13 each one’s work will become evident; for the day will show it because it is to be revealed with fire, and the fire itself will test the quality of each one’s work. 14 If anyone’s work which he has built on it remains, he will receive a reward. 15 If anyone’s work is burned up, he will suffer loss; but he himself will be saved, yet only so as through fire.</strong></blockquote><p>From this Pauline passage, it seems he is discussing an eschatological and post-mortem event where God will expose the works of every person, specifically those of the Church due to <em>“the Day will show it”</em>. The old and bland argument is that this passage is only in reference to Christians in general aside from non-believers and wicked people. This is a dubious argument, because it assumes that everyone in the Church are righteous or blameless, yet in the Gospels, we find Jesus exposing evildoers being part of the faith or church community (<em>cf. Matt. 7:21–23</em>). If there are sinners <em>(i.e. predominantly evil people)</em> in the Church, then this principle for them doesn’t exclude those who are not part of the Church yet are sinners. The apostle Paul is addressing two kinds of people in the Church: justified and unjustified believers. Also, Paul makes a distinction between spiritual and carnal believers, and addressing the carnal as, <em>“Are you not fleshly, and are you not walking like mankind?”</em> (verse 3). This demonstrates how they remain in their sins while professing the name of Christ as Jesus has stated in the Gospel of Matthew. With this in mind, Paul warns but encourages them, <strong>“Do you not know that you are a temple of God and that the Spirit of God dwells in you? If anyone destroys the temple of God, God will destroy that person; for the temple of God is holy, and that is what you are”</strong> (verses 16–17). The given destruction for those who defile their temple is purgatorial suffering and delayed redemption from the totality of their sins (<em>cf. verse 15</em>).</p><p>Verse 13 demonstrates that this is speaking of an event where the just and unjust will be judged. Verse 14 is a description of the righteous or the saints receiving a reward, which is the first resurrection and a Christological reign on earth (<em>cf. Revelation 20:6</em>). Verse 15 reveals that those that weren’t faithful in good works will suffer a loss of time, which is a delayed resurrection, and they will be saved, indicating surely that they will be raised as the saints from the dead, but only after their purgatorial suffering due to <em>“so as by fire”</em>. Another pointless objection would be that Paul simply meant Christians, that is, those justified by virtue since Paul refers to them receiving a reward for their labor (<em>cf. verse 8</em>). However, verse 8 serves as a parallel to verse 14 due to <em>“receiving a reward”</em> while both verses are addressing faithful Christians, but verse 15 serves as a contrast and as a reference to malice believers (i.e. sinners in the Church).</p><p>So then, if sinners partake of the Church, and Paul is addressing them, it stands to reason that this same purgatorial principle applies to those outside of the Church as sinners. It extends to all sinners since Paul has said, <strong>“And when all things shall be subdued unto him, then shall the Son also himself be subject unto him that put all things under him, that God may be all in all”</strong> (15:28). God cannot be in all hearts or souls of their own volition if some perish by total, ontological destruction or by perpetual torments. Now, in earlier verses (9–11), people have argued that Paul intended believers who are righteous, whether mature or immature due to his expression: “<strong>9 For we are God’s fellow workers; you are God’s field, <em>you</em> <em>are</em> God’s building.” </strong>However, verse 15 and Paul’s warning to malice Christians in general cannot be narrowed to the fate of faithful Christians (<em>cf. 16–17</em>). He calls them holy to encourage them apart from sin, and not as a realized fact. In verse 10, Paul explains that he laid a foundation, which means he provides a path to righteousness as an example, and inspires believers to do good works due to his assertion <em>“and another builds on it” (cf. 1st Corinthians 4:15)</em>. Verse 11 is when Paul transitions to the idea that there is no other moral foundation or criteria other than Christ. Verse 12 is where Paul elaborates that everyone will be measured by this same standard or Christ’s foundation since he makes no specific mention of the Church.</p><p>Finally, Maximus the Confessor separates people into two groups, the righteous and sinners. For the righteous, he says fire will reveal their good deeds as well as the wicked in his commentary of 1st Corinthians, Chapter 3:</p><p><strong>“And in the case of sinners, the works are completely consumed while discernment renders conscience righteous and diminishes the sins through repentance and saves the human being; and he is responsible for the loss of time that has passed as a result of the neglect of the virtues. But also, in the future age, the works of sin give way to nothingness and nature saves its own powers by taking them through the fire of judg­ment”</strong> (Q. et Dub. 159, trans. Despina Prassas).</p><h4><strong>1st Peter 4:6 in Light of Post-mortem Redemption</strong></h4><blockquote><strong>5 But they will have to give an account to God who stands ready to judge the living and the dead. 6 For this is the reason, the gospel was proclaimed even to the dead, so that they might be judged like/similar to [kata] men in the flesh, but live in the spirit like/similar to [kata] God.</strong></blockquote><p>Peter writes to his audience that they should strive to be like Christ by ceasing from their sins, and to not be deterred from this path due to discouragement from sinners (<em>cf. 1–4</em>). However, Peter explains that everyone will be judged, whether living or dead, and he makes no moral-metaphorical distinction with these two terms. He states that the Gospel was preached not only to those alive in the flesh, but also to those who died since he makes an inclusive statement. The Gospel was preached to the spirits in prison, so that they may be judged akin to men in the flesh being judged as well, and in hopes that they would be spiritually alive akin to God. The term <strong>kata</strong> derived from Koine Greek has been used to mean “like” or “similar to” rather than just “according to” (<em>e.g. Ephesians 4:24</em>).</p><p>Now, Josiah naively attempts to argue that 1st Peter 3:19–21 is actually in reference to Enochian elements due to scriptural examples similar to 2nd Peter and Jude; however, both of these books make mention of fallen angels in chains or in Tartarus, but not in reference to Christ preaching the Gospel to spirits. In other words, these examples have no substantial aid to 1st Peter 3:19 unlike 1st Peter 4:6 having more resemblance and more contextual correlation. I argued that if Peter meant demons or satanic spirits, he would have used the term <strong>daimon </strong>and not<strong> pneuma.</strong> However, Josiah, in his last desperate attempt, argued that <em>pneuma</em> always refers to angelic, demonic, or God’s spirit (<em>note: I am not sure if he’s subconsciously using an absolute statement out of frustration, then I pardon his nonsense</em>). The term <em>pneuma</em> has been used in reference to human spirit, or a metaphysically animating force, or simply breath belonging to a human; for example, <strong>“But Jesus cried out again with a loud voice and gave up his spirit,” </strong>or<strong> “And may your whole spirit and soul and body be kept blameless,”</strong> or <strong>“For if I pray in a tongue, my spirit prays, but my mind is unfruitful,”</strong> or <strong>“My soul exalts the Lord, and my spirit rejoices in God, my Savior” </strong>(<em>cf. Matthew 27:50; 1st Thessalonians 5:23; 1st Corinthians 14:14; Luke 1:46–47). Pneuma </em>is such a broad term, so it’s evident that Josiah is blatantly wrong and ignorant. Another example where spirits are mentioned as human souls is found in 1st Enoch, chapter 22, <strong>“These beautiful places are intended for this, that upon them may be assembled the spirits, the souls of the dead; for they have been created, that here all the souls of the sons of men might be assembled”</strong> (<em>cf. verse 3</em>).</p><h4>2nd Temple Judaism &amp; Why the Consensus View Fails</h4><p>An interesting but faulty objection used against Christian universalism is the annoying appeal from infernalists, concerning the “consensus” views that Second Temple Jews embraced. Josiah arrogantly stated that the consensus view in Second Temple Judaism supports eternal perdition; on the contrary, such an objection fails entirely. The philosophical issue here is that this person seems to think that majority predicates on validity, except this a logical fallacy since truth has no correlation with a large population.</p><p>The theological appeal to Second Temple Judaism is actually an arbitrary and ineffective objection against Christian universalism. There was no suffering and resurrected messiah as a consensus view in Second Temple Judaism, especially in the Old Testament or Hebrew Bible. There has been maybe a few outliers in the academic community like Israel Knohl, but he was refuted by a <a href="https://www.academia.edu/10023760/A_Critical_Review_of_Israel_Knohl_s_The_Messiah_Before_Jesus_The_Suffering_Servant_of_the_Dead_Sea_Scrolls_London_2000_?auto=download">critical review</a>. Even if eternal perdition was the consensus view of Second Temple Judaism, it wouldn’t be validated since the Christian concept of the messiah was neither the consensus view, nor the minority view. The assumption that primitive or biblical Judaism(s) retained all spiritual truth is at best misleading and at worst theologically detrimental to the Christian faith. Josiah asserts theological nonsense, and wrongly renders a primitive but flawed religion as the doctrinal basis for Christian post-mortem eschatology. These kinds of appeals are seriously blinding and laughable.</p><p>Many proponents of Infernalism often appeal to Second Temple Jewish books like 1st Enoch and 3rd/4th Maccabees. The first book of Enoch has often been used to validate eternal perdition, but there are also universalistic notions in 1st Enoch. Permit me to bestow a universalistic passage from Enoch. However, before I elaborate on this passage, Enoch has a vision in <em>“the middle of the earth”</em> where <em>“branches rooted in and sprouted out of a tree that was cut”</em> (<em>cf. 26:1</em>). He sees <em>“a holy mountain”</em> and towards the east, he saw <em>“beneath the mountain…water that flowed towards the south”</em> (<em>cf. verse 2</em>). Towards the east again, Enoch saw <em>“another mountain of the same height”</em> and a deep valley was between them, though it wasn’t broad; it also had water that flowed along with it (<em>cf. verse 3</em>). He then envisioned a mountain which was “towards the west” and “not high” (<em>e.g. it was described as being lower than the former</em>). And between them was another valley, which included other sterile but deep valleys at the end of the three. Then Enoch envisioned all valleys being deep, not broad, and of hard rock, but trees were implanted on them, which left Enoch amazed (<em>cf. 4–5</em>). So then, Enoch inquires for insight and the angel responds in 27th chapter, verses 2–4.</p><blockquote><strong>2. Then answered Uriel, one of the holy angels, who was with me, and said to me: “This cursed valley is for those who will be cursed to eternity, and here will be assembled all those who have spoken with their mouths unseemly words against God, and speak insolently of his glory, here they will be assembled, and here will be their judgment.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>3. And in the latter days there will be the spectacle of a just judgment upon them in the presence of the just, in eternity forever; for this reason they who have found mercy will bless the Lord of glory, the Eternal King.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>4. And in the days of their judgment they will bless him for his mercy, according to which he has assigned to them their lot” </strong><em>(</em><strong><em>Enoch 27:2–4</em></strong><em>).</em></blockquote><p><strong><em>Explaining the Symbolism of Enoch 26:</em></strong></p><p>Let me provide an interesting analysis of Enoch 26. The middle of the earth signifies the affairs of humans or our current life being the premise for how the afterlife will transpire. The branches that are rooted in and sprouted out of the tree, which was cut, signifies an event where humans will receive their own resurrection despite the fact their mortality was once their reality, and their immortal conditions were taken from them. The first mountain is described by Enoch as being holy and only this mountain is given this description, so the first mountain symbolizes the saints, or the righteous in Christ with the waters being their good works.</p><p>On the next mountain, Enoch describes it being of the same height but separated by a valley yet the valley isn’t broad; in other words, he is perceiving non-believers due to the lack of a holy title, and who lived in righteousness, because there were waters that also flowed along with it, signifying good works. The not-so broad valley that divides them symbolically means that there is hardly any distinction between the holy Church and non-believers who work in love.</p><p>But the mountain that he envisioned towards the west must be of the wicked due to it having an inferior height, signifying a life that didn’t reach the moral goal; in addition, there was no current of water mentioned for this mountain to indicate any presence of good works in the conduct of their lives. In other words, it demonstrates that these must be the wicked. There were valleys that divided them, which indicate the afterlife, but trees were present upon these valleys to signify the potential for post-mortem redemption. All the mountain imagery highlights the eschatological event of the resurrection due to the rising or tall nature of these mountains.</p><p><strong>Explaining the Symbolism of Enoch 27:</strong></p><p><strong><em>Verse II:</em></strong> The angel explains that the purpose behind these valleys is to imprison wicked souls and for them to receive suffering for an indefinite duration/ages (<em>i.e. aionios</em>) instead of <em>“to eternity”</em>. The angel also mentions their malice words towards God and the divine glory. <strong><em>Verse III: </em></strong>The angel explains that in a later time, they will receive a fair judgement in the presence of the righteous, because they have found mercy in this moment from the Lord and shall bless God for it. <strong><em>Verse IV: </em></strong>The angel mentions that during this additional or sequential judgment where the wicked souls who have been morally refined will praise the Lord for granting them mercy.</p><p>Some will try to render those who have found mercy from the Lord as being the saints or righteous, but remember, the preeminent subject from verse 2 to verse 4 are the wicked souls being given the judgement and the <em>“just judgement”</em>. The mention of an additional judgement or a<em>“just judgement”</em> also indicates that another verdict has been passed onto the wicked, which is described as finding mercy from God. There is simply no indication from the text that suggests otherwise, which Christian infernalists would erroneously attempt to say that the righteous will see the wicked being tortured forever while the saints will be finding mercy as their idea of a just judgement. Finally, the last verse suggests that the wicked who have found mercy during the days of their judgement will bless God for His mercy towards them. If the author meant the righteous blessing God for mercy while assigning <em>“the days of their judgement”</em> to the wicked, he would have specified this, but fortunately, he means the wicked who have now repented and blessed God for bestowing divine mercy.</p><p>In a comment, Father Kimel Aiden mentions a universalist direction in Enoch concerning Dr. Ramelli’s analysis of Enoch, <em>“</em><a href="https://afkimel.wordpress.com/2014/05/21/the-universalist-hope-in-the-early-church/?mibextid=Zxz2cZ"><em>I don’t know how Ramelli would respond (though she does mention a passage of the Enochic Book of Parables as possibly pointing in the universalist direction)</em></a><em>”</em>. This further validates my analysis of 1st Enoch retaining universalist tendencies. Every usage of <em>“forever”</em> or <em>“eternity”</em> found in 1st Enoch can be explained away by the Greek term <strong>aionios</strong>; however, there are a few passages that seem to indicate that fallen angels and demons will be condemned <em>“for all eternity </em><strong><em>[correction translation: ages/eons]</em></strong><em>”. </em>(<em>cf. Enoch 10:13</em>). I am not claiming an inerrant consistency of Hell in Enoch since I could acknowledge that there are possible infernalist passages in 1st Enoch due to it possibly being written by multiple authors with their own post-mortem viewpoints. The purpose for mentioning Enoch and for displaying a universalist passage is to demonstrate that using Second Temple Jewish books like Enoch does not exclusively support eternal perdition, while deny Christian Universalism as a possible view. It’s a cheap attempt in ridding away Christian universalism, including Josiah’s childish insistence that eternal perdition must be a valid dogma due to some <strong>“consensus view”</strong> within Second Temple Judaism. The appeal to antiquity and majority certainly have limitations in discovering genuine Christian dogma, and his theological appeal to a primitive religious tradition, which was used <strong>“selectively”</strong> by the New Testament authors and the patristic era, as if it’s some super, magisterial, pre-Christian creed is blatantly flawed.</p><h4>Saint Clement of Alexandria</h4><p>In this section, I will be responding to Josiah’s accusations against my universalist interpretation of Clement’s post-mortem view. I stated in a comment towards a genuine learner (not Josiah) that Clement believed that Christ had preached the gospel to all those in Hades, including the wicked (<em>cf. Stromata, Book VI.6</em>). Josiah replied against my statement by using a fragment that contains Clement’s exposition of 1st Peter 4:6, thus saying:</p><blockquote><strong>These are trained through previous judgments. Therefore he adds, “For this </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03459a.htm"><strong>cause</strong></a><strong> was the </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06655b.htm"><strong>Gospel</strong></a><strong> preached also to the dead” — to us, namely, who were at one time unbelievers. “That they might be judged according to </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09580c.htm"><strong>men</strong></a><strong>,” he says, “in the flesh, but live according to </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06608a.htm"><strong>God</strong></a><strong> in the spirit.” Because, that is, they have fallen away from </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05752c.htm"><strong>faith</strong></a><strong>; while they are still in the flesh they are judged according to preceding judgments, that they might repent. Accordingly, he also adds, saying, “That they might live according to </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/06608a.htm"><strong>God</strong></a><strong> in the spirit.” So </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/11567b.htm"><strong>Paul</strong></a><strong> also; for he, too, states something of this nature when he says, Whom I have delivered to </strong><a href="https://www.newadvent.org/cathen/04764a.htm"><strong>Satan</strong></a><strong>, that he might live in the spirit” (<em>From the Latin Translation of Cassiodorus</em></strong>).</blockquote><p>Josiah’s usage of this fragment was genuinely interesting, but failed to compel me to reshape my exegesis of 1st Peter 4:6 and of Clement’s Stromata. It seems likely that we should interpret this potential fragment of Clement in light of the doctrine of Reserve (<em>i.e. the belief that certain doctrines should not be recklessly taught to the infantile believers for the sake of their moral progression</em>). However, Josiah responded as if the doctrine of Reserve is some arbitrary appeal that is used when it isn’t convenient for universalist affirmations within the text of the Fathers or of saint Paul; on the contrary, such a claim is presumptuous and desperate since the doctrine of Reserve (if we are to faithfully judge the views of the Early Church) is a major variable when it comes to assessing patristic or Christian literature in general, concerning their post-mortem, eschatological views. It’s such an ignorant and ill-tempered response to something that is essentially plausible and has patristic support; in fact, the most influential figures like saint Ignatius of Antioch and Origen of Alexandria made use of the doctrine of Reserve (<em>cf. Trallians 5; Contra Celsus Book 1, VII</em>). Josiah was not impressed due to his theological prejudices.</p><p>Moreover, Clement of Alexandria demonstrates a reading that cannot be dismissed in his Stromata Book 6, Chapter 6. I believe this key passage should be used to highlight or disclose certain hints or subtleties that Clement makes regarding the post-mortem condition of all souls. Here, he says:</p><blockquote><strong>“Therefore, the Lord preached to those in Hades. For the Scripture says, ‘Hades says to Destruction: We have not seen His form, but we have heard His voice.’ Certainly, it was not the place itself that received the voice, but those who descended into Hades and surrendered themselves to destruction, just as if they willingly cast themselves from a ship into the sea. Therefore, these are the ones who have heard the divine power and voice. For who in their right mind should suppose the souls of the just and of the sinners in one judgement to be accusing Providence of injustice?</strong></blockquote><p>In this passage, Clement does not specify who is in Hades initially, but towards the end of this paragraph or section, he highlighted two kinds of people: virtuous and wicked souls. Clement is stating that it is unreasonable, after his explanation that Christ preached the Gospel to all those in Hades within the scriptural narrative, for anyone to think that the souls of the just and wicked to be accusing God of injustice, as if the gospel was not preached to them in their astral states. But since the Gospel was preached to the dead, according to Clement, he inquires over the matter of how can anyone think that the souls in Hades to be blaming God for the lack of moral oversight. However, an infernalist will (wrongly) interpret this as the supposing mind to be charging God with injustice for having both kinds of souls in one judgement as being irrational, but Clement means the souls in Hades are accusing God — though it’s hypothetical — rather than the theorizer accusing God of injustice. Some will venture on to say that Clement was simply being theoretical when he mentioned the souls of sinners, but why mention them at all if he simply believed that the just souls heard the gospel preached to them only? Here’s the original Greek in case some readers wonder why there’s “one,” “to be,” and “mind” in this English translation since I wasn’t using the common translations that are available online:</p><p><strong>ἐπεὶ τίς ἂν εὖ φρονῶν ἐν μιᾷ καταδίκῃ καὶ τὰς τῶν δικαίων καὶ τὰς τῶν ἁμαρτωλῶν ὑπολάβοι εἶναι ψυχάς, ἀδικίαν τῆς προνοίας καταχέων.</strong></p><p><strong>Since/For (επεί) who (τις) in their right thinking (αν ευ φρονών) and in one judgement (και εν μια καταδίκη) should suppose (υπολάβοι) the souls of the just and of the sinners (Τάς ψυχας των δίκαιος και των ἁμαρτωλῶν) to be charging (είναι καταχέων) Providence of injustice (πρόνοιας της καταχεων)?</strong></p><p>Since Clement has admitted that Christ preached the gospel to everyone in Hades, specifically the virtuous and wicked souls, let us now observe the words of Clement further. He then adds to his rhetorical question with another question by explaining that Scripture reveals His preaching of the Gospel: <strong>“But how? Do not the [Scriptures] disclose the Lord preaching to those who perished in the Deluge, rather than bind those in chains and watch over them?”</strong> It seems Clement affirms Christ preaching the Gospel in general, but denies the notion that Christ went to imprison them and keep them under guard. If Clement wished to demonstrate an infernalist understanding to his readers, why did he not simply state the no soul of the wicked nature in Hades has received the Gospel, nor can they be delivered from their bonds after death? He makes no exceptions and implies post-mortem redemption for the wicked in Hades, so then, in the next passage, Clement makes mention of the righteous souls in Hades receiving life despite living away from sinless perfection. He re-accounts a passage from the Shepherd of Hermas where the Disciples like the Lord descend into Hades to preach the Gospel, and though, Clement omits the wicked in this specific passage, he does not claim eternal perdition for these same souls.</p><p>After these claims, he does mention rational souls as being the upright, but he does not deny the wicked of possible redemption from Hades. He states a principle concerning divine intent and judgement: <strong>“If, then, in the deluge all sinful flesh perished, punishment having been inflicted on them for correction, we must first believe that the will of God, which is disciplinary and beneficent, saves those who turn to Him.”</strong> As Clement teaches, if God’s will or judgements are always intended towards edification, then we must believe that Christ proclaimed also to the wicked, because for God to deny such a possibility would indicate that this principle as being false; also, since Clement has stated that all those in Hades (even the wicked) have received the Gospel, denied the interpretation that Christ only bind those in Hades, and has conferred not a single interpretation that wicked souls remain in permanent ruin, then Clement’s interpretation of Christ in Hades is universalist, whether hopeful or confident. There are few instances where he is conceding to the wicked receiving possible redemption via implications, which, due to the practice of Reserve, is his style of obscuring his universalism from the masses. Even if some or all wicked souls refused to repent towards the preaching of Christ, intending to argue for infernalism, Clement has stated that this salvific administration continues through the disciples of Christ, which implies that the wicked souls in Hades don’t have a single chance at possible redemption but many chances.</p><h4>The Shepherd of Hermas</h4><p>The final literature in this post for Christian universalism will be discussed; the Shepherd of Hermas was commonly respected in the Early Church, as was other works like 1st Clement and the epistle of Barnabas (not the gospel of Barnabas). Josiah made attempts to argue that the Shepherd of Hermas did not belong to the universalist camp but was indicating a redemption for righteous souls who died prior to receiving the Gospel or who died in enmity towards it. Here’s his assumption:</p><blockquote>On the contrary: When Hermas asks the meaning of this image, and of the stones who came “from the depths, already having the seal,” the Shepherd replies: “For they died in righteousness and great purity-only they did not have this seal.” (Similitudes 9.16.7)</blockquote><blockquote>Those who were given the seal (viz. baptism, in some sense) did not include “the unjust,” as you contend, those who departed this life in a state or state of enmity; but were those who were righteous when death came (those who were disposed toward God in this life and yet hadn’t had the opportunity to receive the sacrament of initiation into the Church (the Tower) that is baptism. Your claim — that in 9.16 “the unjust” were given “the seal of preaching” — is a confused and flatly untrue statement of fact with respect to the content of the text you refer to.</blockquote><p>But all this is based on his own speculation, which is deeply flawed and seeks to distort what Hermas is recording or what the Angel is relaying to Hermas. Let’s start with the exact passage and permit me to bestow a unique numbering to avoid confusion:</p><blockquote><strong>Section 1:“Explain to me a little further, sir,”</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>I said. “What is it that you desire?” he asked. “Why, sir,” I said, “did these stones ascend out of the pit, and be applied to the building of the tower, after having borne these spirits?” “They were obliged,” he answered, “to ascend through water in order that they might be made alive; for, unless they laid aside the deadness of their life, they could not in any other way enter into the kingdom of God.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Section 2: Accordingly, those also who fell asleep received the seal of the Son of God. For,” he continued, “before a man bears the name of the Son of God, he is dead; but when he receives the seal he lays aside his deadness, and obtains life. The seal, then, is the water: they descend into the water dead, and they arise alive.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Section 3: And to them, accordingly, was this seal preached, and they made use of it that they might enter into the kingdom of God.” “Why, sir,” I asked, “did the forty stones also ascend with them out of the pit, having already received the seal?”</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Section 4: “Because,” he said, “these apostles and teachers who preached the name “of the Son of God, after falling asleep in the power and faith of the Son of God, preached it not only to those who were asleep, but themselves also gave them the seal of the preaching.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Section 5: Accordingly they descended with them into the water, and again ascended. [But these descended alive and rose up again alive; whereas they who had previously fallen asleep descended dead, but rose up again alive.]</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>Section 6: “By these, then, were they quickened and made to know the name of the Son of God. For this reason also did they ascend with them, and were fitted along with them into the building of the tower, and, untouched by the chisel, were built in along with them. For they slept in righteousness and in great purity, but only they had not this seal. You have accordingly the explanation of these also” (The Shepherd of Hermas, Book 3, Similitude 9.16).</strong></blockquote><p>In section 1 and 2, or in the beginning, Hermas inquires the Angel as to why stones came out of the pit and were fitted into the building of the Tower; the Angel responds that if someone walks apart from the name or character of Christ, then he is dead, but if he repents by “laying aside his state of death,” then he is able to enter the Kingdom of God. The criteria for this divinized life is repentance from dead works, and moral commitment in imitating Christ’s love. The seal is mentioned as being the water where souls traverse from death to life (<em>i.e. probably baptism</em>).</p><p>In section 3, those in the pit make use of the seal to enter the Kingdom of God, but Hermas inquires on why the 40 stones ascended with them since the 40 stones already possessed the seal. In section 4, the Angel explains that the 40 stones represent the apostles and teachers of the Church, and not only did they preach the Gospel, but also gave the seal or baptism.</p><p>In section 5,<em> “they descended with them into the water, and again ascended”</em><strong> </strong>implies the holy saints descending and ascending with their audience, but an additional exposition tells us that<em> “these descended alive and rose up again alive,”</em><strong> </strong>which implies righteous, non-believers due to descending with moral life, and <em>“whereas they who had previously fallen asleep descended dead, but rose up again alive,”</em> which implies wicked souls repenting due to descending without moral life yet they were revived. I believe the Angel is relaying a contrast of just and unjust souls receiving life from the preaching of the apostles and teachers.</p><p>In section 6, the identity of those who were made alive and made to know the Son of God, and were added to the Tower is narrowed down to the unbelieving, righteous souls due to <em>“they slept in righteousness and in great purity, but only they had not this seal”</em>. Based on this whole passage, the apostles and teachers already retained the seal as they ascended, but the Angel claims that the righteous non-believers did not possess the seal, so then, who received the seal of preaching if not the just souls, according to the Angel? The only plausible reading would be to deduce that the wicked souls that repented, had received the seal or baptism from the apostles and teachers. The purpose behind the seal or baptism is to make a pledge towards God that one will devote themselves to a pure conscience. This is also taught in 1st Peter,<strong> “Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you, not as a removal of dirt from the body but as an appeal to God for a good conscience”</strong> (<strong>3:21</strong>).</p><p>Based on my exegetical exposition, let’s address Josiah’s misguided claims. He says, “<em>On the contrary: When Hermas asks the meaning of this image, and of the stones who came “from the depths, already having the seal,” the Shepherd replies: “For they died in righteousness and great purity-only they did not have this seal.” </em>Josiah is creating a false correlation between the righteous non-believers with the 40 stones that ascended with them, which symbolically represents the apostles and teachers, since the righteous souls (i.e. non-believers) do not retain or receive a seal unlike the disciples of Christ. And to quote his second argument: <em>“Those who were given the seal (viz. baptism, in some sense) did not include “the unjust,” as you contend, those who departed this life in a state or state of enmity; but were those who were righteous when death came (those who were disposed toward God in this life and yet hadn’t had the opportunity to receive the sacrament of initiation into the Church (the Tower) that is baptism.”</em> How does it not include the unjust souls when the disciples of Christ already possessed the seal, while the justified non-believers did not receive the seal, even after their ascension according to the Angel’s last statement in this chapter? The sacrament of baptism is intended for those who are repenting from predominant sin, meaning that the righteous non-believers have no need of promising to God for a good conscience due to already retaining a pure conscience. Josiah’s exegesis in interpreting the Angel in Hermas’ book is incompetent and contradictory, and even desperate.</p><p><strong>There are many objections as to why the two-tier (<em>i.e. Christian disciples and justified non-believers only</em>) understanding of this account fails:</strong></p><ol><li><strong>It doesn’t address or demonstrate as to who received the seal after death since the disciples already retained the seal prior, and the non-believers, specifically the just in Hades, never received nor possessed the seal.</strong></li><li><strong>The passage in section 5 demonstrates a three-tier understanding: those who descended with them in the water and ascended, those who descended dead but arose alive again, and those who descended alive but arose alive again.</strong></li><li><strong>The seal/baptism, according to the first epistle of Peter, is intended as a pledge unto having a pure conscience before God, which is absurd if it’s applied to justified non-believers since they already possess a pure conscience. According to the Angel, only they had not this seal; this proves the logic that they don’t need to promise God for a pure conscience.</strong></li><li><strong>Though it is assumed that both souls from righteous and wicked groups ascend into the water, implying that the righteous non-believers also receive a seal from this, would exegetically contradict the Angel’s last statement about them not having the seal. So then, we must conclude that the Angel around sections 1 and 2 is speaking generically about the souls in Hades becoming alive, but divulges into detail around sections 4 and 5.</strong></li></ol><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>Josiah made many desperate and flawed attempts to project his infernalism towards the data. The first epistle to the Corinthians illustrates that the righteous and sinners among the Church will receive their outcomes, but ultimately being redemptive at the end, as supported by Maximus’ reading. The first epistle of Peter demonstrates that Christ did indeed preach the Gospel to the dead, as evidenced by Melito’s, Clement’s, and Hermas’ books. Clement based on the Stromata and Hermas’ Angel both insist a hopeful universalist fate (if not confident).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5d2ed9b35107" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>