<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Thera Van Osch on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Thera Van Osch on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@thera-vanosch?source=rss-8b4b03cad76------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 18:56:03 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@thera-vanosch/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to bring peace to a troubled world?]]></title>
            <link>https://thera-vanosch.medium.com/how-to-bring-peace-to-a-troubled-world-ecd12bb34d8b?source=rss-8b4b03cad76------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ecd12bb34d8b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thera Van Osch]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Mar 2026 15:40:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-09T19:42:47.983Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Why the words of an enslaved Greek still resonate after 27 centuries</strong></p><p>In 1985, during the Third UN World Conference on Women in Nairobi (Kenya), a large “Peace Tent” stood at the heart of the NGO Forum. It was meant to be a place where women from around the world could gather to talk about one of humanity’s oldest questions: <strong>how to build peace?</strong></p><p>The discussions in the Peace Tent were passionate and often painful. Much of the debate was dominated by Palestinian and Israeli women. I was present, sitting among hundreds of others, and the tension in the tent was palpable. Speaker after speaker stepped up to the microphone, accusing the other side of terrible injustices. The air seemed thick with anger and grief. I could feel the weight of the hatred in the Peace Tent.</p><p>Then an older woman timidly approached the microphone. She introduced herself as a working-class trade union woman from the United Kingdom. She said she had never been to university and was not an expert in politics or diplomacy. But she wanted to share a parable of the fight between the sun and the wind.</p><p>The tent grew quiet.</p><p>“Once,” she began, “the wind said to the sun:</p><p>‘Do you see that man down there, wearing a coat and a hat? Let’s make a bet. The winner is whoever can make him take them off first.’</p><p>‘Okay’ said the sun. ‘You may start first’.</p><p>The powerful wind began to blow, blowing hard. Strong gusts swept across the land. Down below, the man clutched his coat and hat tightly with both hands so they wouldn’t blow away. The wind blew harder and harder. But the stronger the wind became, the tighter the man held on. Finally, exhausted, the wind gave up.”</p><p>She paused for a moment and continued:</p><p>“Then it was the sun’s turn.</p><p>The sun began to shine, gently at first, then warmer and warmer. It kept shining and shining with quiet warmth and kindness. Soon the man relaxed. He felt happy. Smiling, he took off his hat. As the sun continued to shine, he grew warmer still and slipped off his coat as well.”</p><p>The older woman paused and looked around the tent.</p><p>“Force and violence,” she said softly, “will never solve our conflicts. Only warmth, love, and compassion can do that.”</p><p>For a moment, there was silence. Tears welled up in my eyes, and I was not alone. Many women in the tent were deeply touched. The applause that followed was thunderous and heartfelt, a rare moment of unity in a room that had been filled with anger. Women who had been arguing moments before were clapping together. These moments in the peace tent are etched in my memory as one of the most beautiful moments at the 1985 NGO forum in Nairobi.</p><p>Later I discovered this parable is already circulating for about 27 centuries. It comes from the ancient storyteller Aesop, an enslaved Greek living in the 6th century BCE, who was a famous oral storyteller in his times. His stories circulated for centuries before being recorded in writing. The moral was clear: force and violence cannot achieve lasting change. Only warmth, love, and compassion can persuade. History tells that his cleverness and wisdom eventually earned him freedom. Unfortunately, his fame could not protect him from the jealous and powerful. He died tragically in Delphi, accused of impiety and thrown from a cliff. Yet his fables, like the story of the Sun and the Wind, live on and reflect universal values and timeless reminders that gentleness, love and compassion always triumph over force.</p><p>Why did this parable touch women so deeply?</p><p>There is a long history of women’s peace movements, women against weapons, against militarism, against war, and feminist activists for peace. Women stood there often in their role of spouse, mother, sister or daughter. Most of the time they were ignored and accused of naivety. Their voices were not heard. And yet, their role in giving life to new generations, their awareness of how much care, effort, attention, and love the creation of human life requires, makes that women profoundly understand how fragile life truly is.</p><p>The brutal force of violent war does more than destroy lives with bombs. One of the most underexposed aspects in the history of wars is the physical and sexual violence against women and children by armed forces, which was only declared a war crime in 1993 at the Human Rights Conference in Vienna. In 2008, Patrick Cammeart, a Major General of the Dutch armed forces, declared: “It has probably become more dangerous to be a woman than a soldier in an armed conflict.”</p><p>Moreover, war directly undermines women’s vital contributions in the caregiving roles they fulfil to sustain human life. At the same time, it reinforces women’s roles as a reserve workforce for the jobs of men mobilized for war, while also amplifying the unpaid burdens they already shoulder in society.</p><p>Wars and military spending must be financed, and governments often respond by cutting budgets for healthcare, social services, education, and social security. In practice, these cuts shift the responsibility onto the unpaid care economy: women step in to care for the sick without access to medical care, teach in understaffed schools, and support the elderly and others affected by the shortfalls. Because paid and unpaid work remain so unevenly distributed in our societies, women bear the brunt of these growing responsibilities in times of war and crisis.</p><p>Aesop may have been thrown from a deep cliff in Delphi 27 centuries ago, his words still resonate strongly today, particularly by women who deeply feel the invisible yet profound human costs of conflict and war.</p><p>Since the year 2000, we have a United Nations Security Council Resolution 1325 about Women, Peace and Security. Putting in practice this resolution, including the follow-up resolutions to ensure women’s voice and agency in prevention and protection from war violence, and participation in peace building processes would be a first step in the right direction to bring peace to our troubled world.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ecd12bb34d8b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I lost the struggle against capitalism, but not the meaning of the fight]]></title>
            <link>https://thera-vanosch.medium.com/i-lost-the-struggle-against-capitalism-but-not-the-meaning-of-the-fight-ad01e22bd14a?source=rss-8b4b03cad76------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ad01e22bd14a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[entrepreneurship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anti-capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[volunteering]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thera Van Osch]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Dec 2025 00:39:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-15T00:18:07.789Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bssuC5QndUbd60XPHpOl6Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Main Entrance to the World House in Wetten, Germany (2025)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>I dreamed of creating a School of Caring Economics and putting in practice a paradigm shift in economic thinking. After turning an old monastery into a conference centre and meeting place rooted in care, sustainability, and community, my intention was to create here a living model of a caring economy at the micro level. Now I have to get it let go…</strong></p><p>My struggle against capitalism began fifty-five years ago. I was a young university student then, one of the few women who studied economics, full of questions about the world and even more full of anger at how our economic models ignored half of it. Women’s unpaid labour? Missing. The value of nature? Missing. The cost of destroying rivers, forests, and communities? Nowhere to be found.</p><p>So, in the 1970s I joined the wave of critical students challenging the system at the Tilburg University in the Netherlands. I initiated the ‘<em>Working Group Political Economy of Women’</em>. We criticised the neo-classical economic theory, produced feminist analysis, organised workshops and a national conference to define an agenda for action for the Dutch women’s movement. In our daily lives we became vegetarians, inspired by the early warnings of the ‘Club of Rome’ with their famous publication ‘<em>The Limits to Growth’ </em>(1972). We marched, we argued, we shook things up wherever we could. When supermarkets began wrapping everything in plastic, we staged protests: marching into the store with our own bags and empty bottles, buying our groceries and milk, and then immediately unwrapping every item at the checkout. We left behind mountains of plastic and packages in the supermarket as a reminder of the absurdity of this new marketing trend.</p><p>That spirit shaped the next decades of my life. I worked across Latin America, lived in Honduras, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, and Colombia, supporting women’s organizations, promoting gender-just economic models, and participating in the development of approaches that recognized both unpaid care work and human rights as economic pillars. Together with international experts like Prof. Diana Elson, and local partners, we produced a gender assessment of Central American countries, showing that eliminating discrimination wasn’t just a moral question of social justice and human rights; it improved economic growth and reduced poverty (<em>Crecer con la Mujer, 1997</em>).</p><p>Back in the Netherlands, my work continued in trade unions and in the women’s movement, implementing projects and participating in international conferences, and advocacy networks. I supported decolonization movements, pushed for mainstreaming of the care economy, opposed discriminatory tax regulations, and criticized macro-economic austerity policies in social sectors that shifted the work burdens mainly to women in the unpaid care sector. We had small victories, but not enough. The old boys’ networks stayed intact, and systemic change came painfully slowly.</p><p>Years later, after advising European and international institutions on gender mainstreaming and caring economics, I wanted to prove that my ideas could work not only on paper but in practice. Therefore, at the age of 60, I took a leap: I bought a 100-year-old monastery in the little village of Wetten, Germany. Friends and family helped me with loans, because no bank was willing to finance my plan. I dreamed of creating here a School of Caring Economics and putting in practice a paradigm shift in economic thinking. My intention was connecting people to create new perspectives, by transforming the place into a conference centre and meeting place rooted in care, sustainability, and community. A space where people could gather, debate, create, and collaborate. A living model of a caring economy at the micro level.</p><p>It took three long years just to secure the license to operate. Renovations drained time and energy. But slowly, the place, which I named <strong>World House</strong>, began to breathe. We had a small professional team that run the business as a hotel with 35 guest rooms, conference room, library, teahouse and terraces in the garden. Our guests were mostly people who booked a room at booking.com, and several times a year we had groups for seminars, meditation, workshops, healing festival, meetings, expositions, etc. An annual highlight were the summer holidays of a network of women, called the ‘<em>Begeinigen’</em>, who celebrated a caring togetherness and mutual empowerment in World House by sharing their knowledge, creativity, spiritual practices. In our restaurant, we offered vegan and vegetarian dishes made with produce from our garden and, whenever possible, regional organic ingredients.</p><p>Over the years volunteers from many countries, including refugees, joined to work, share meals, and exchange stories. We renovated the building; we installed a sustainable energy system; we harvested rainwater; and we planted an organic vegetable garden. Every late summer we produced apple juice for the whole year from the apple trees in the monastery orchard. We collected walnuts from old trees and turned them into vegan meals instead of minced meat. Local NGOs such as the Kneipp Verein, could use part of the garden to cultivate their own organic vegetables and teach children about gardening. A network of environmental groups and organisations coordinated by the inspiring beekeeper Claudia Blauert, initiated a bee-project, transforming the old orchard into a haven for wild bees, complete with nesting aids and a sandarium. The garden even won the first prize in Germany for biodiversity in the category of company gardens.</p><p>Artists found space there too. Young creators from Suriname, Dutch and German painters, and even a Syrian refugee artist, Zozan Hamo, whose powerful paintings portray her escape from war, all exhibited their work at World House. During the pandemic, when visitors could not come, we moved everything online. Every summer, at the Land Party, regional artists filled the building with colour and life. A dance ensemble from the nearby town of Kevelaer practiced during the summer months in the shade of the trees on the tea terrace in the garden.</p><p>In short: we built social wealth, cultural wealth, environmental wealth.<br>Unfortunately, we didn’t build enough financial wealth.</p><p>And in capitalism, that is the only kind of value that counts.</p><p>Even within the tax system, only financial values currently count. If the system were to recognise and encourage the creation of social, cultural, and environmental wealth by offering fiscal allowances for those engaged in such activities, a caring economy could flourish for the benefit of people and the planet. That is not yet the case.</p><p>No matter how many community projects flourished, no matter how many volunteers contributed, and no matter how much of my own consulting income I invested, the numbers never added up. It was too expensive to maintain the 22000 m2 garden. Visitors loved the mission, but profit margins in hospitality are unforgiving. I was happy each month that we could pay the salaries of the professional team, all the bills, the VAT and other taxes, and little-by-little repay the loans over the years. After 10 years of operation, there were still two mortgages to be paid, totally €270,000. The lenders have been patient, but the reality was unavoidable: there was no short-term prospect of generating enough profit to pay them off.</p><p>To protect others from inheriting the debt, I could not transform the place into the cooperative I once envisioned. The only ethical way forward was to sell. And so, after years of pouring my heart, labour, and savings into World House, I must let it go… back into the mainstream market system I tried so hard to challenge.</p><p>My conclusion is painful but clear:<br>A company rooted in social, cultural, and environmental values can hardly survive in a capitalist system that recognizes only financial value. Such a model cannot sustain itself financially in the current system, unless partly built on volunteer labour.</p><p>Does it hurt? Yes.<br>Do I feel like I lost the struggle? In some ways, I do.</p><p>One thing I know: every organic upgrade of the garden we promoted, every woman empowered, every artist supported, every wild bee given a habitat, and every conversation sparked in that old monastery created intrinsic value that capitalism cannot measure.</p><p>Maybe I lost the economic battle, but I did not lose the meaning of the fight.</p><p>Thera Van Osch, 11 December 2025.</p><p><strong>Some links (mostly in Dutch and German):</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.world-house-wetten.com/">https://www.world-house-wetten.com/</a> (website will disappear after January 2026)</p><p>Webinar Caring Economics (in Dutch): Een zorgzame economie voor mens en aarde, by Thera Van Osch. Organised by Humanistisch Verbond, Belgium. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vm1-NaZegiE">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vm1-NaZegiE</a></p><p>Zozan Hamo’s Road to Hope: Online exposition of the painting of Zuzan Hamo, organised by World House Wetten (Germany) on 27 March 2021. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NRpRssKwiCk&amp;t=195s">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NRpRssKwiCk&amp;t=195s</a></p><p>Die Honigbienen am World House Wetten (German): Honeybees at World House, Wetten. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ryuQ1JfmcGs">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ryuQ1JfmcGs</a></p><p>Zu Besuch in Wetten | Das BienenBlütenReich auf Tour (German): Visiting the Bee Blossom Paradise in Wetten. Location: Garden of World House, Wetten-Kevelaar, Germany <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9PfjltABfM">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9PfjltABfM</a></p><p>Die Streuobstwiese am World House Wetten (German): The orchard meadow at the World House Wetten (bringing back the original biodiversity of indigenous plants, flowers, wild bees and insects) <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S9Mi07mNa4s">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S9Mi07mNa4s</a></p><p>Die Coburger Fuchsschafe am World House Wetten (German): The Coburg Foxsheep from Dunja Berendsen’s Naturhof are maintaining the orchard meadow at World House in Wetten). <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9keDTvhANiw">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9keDTvhANiw</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ad01e22bd14a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lumumba and Witch Hunt]]></title>
            <link>https://thera-vanosch.medium.com/lumumba-and-witch-hunt-8a7c8c50b15e?source=rss-8b4b03cad76------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a7c8c50b15e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[misogyny]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colonialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patrice-lumumba]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thera Van Osch]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Sep 2024 10:25:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-24T10:25:13.472Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>A Glimpse into the Past</strong></h3><p>I grew up in a village in the south of the Netherlands during the 1950s and ’60s in a family of 9 children. One summer day in 1960, I found myself lost in thought about a name I kept hearing: Lumumba. “<em>Who is Lumumba? Why is everyone talking about him? What had he done?</em>” I was only nine years old, and the world around me seemed preoccupied with his name. The radio crackled with excited voices discussing Lumumba, the 8 o’clock news on our black-and-white television spoke of him, and newspapers were filled with his image and headlines. My oldest brother even laughed at the cartoons mocking Lumumba and other Black people.</p><p>As I stood pondering these things, I looked up through the tiny window in the sloping roof of the attic in my parents’ house. The room was dimly lit, but outside the sun was shining. And then, all at once, I felt as though I had been pulled into a distant, frightening reality — a time when being a woman was dangerous and risky. Dark, heavy emotions of fear and anger flooded me. Faces of anguished women flashed before me, their expressions twisted in confusion and torment. I saw elderly, white women with dishevelled hair, and somehow, I understood — they had been accused of being witches. I could feel their agony, see the despair in their eyes, and sense their utter helplessness; they were broken and tortured into madness.</p><p>This glimpse into the past was deeply unsettling. It was something sinister, and I felt an overwhelming sadness. I was relieved to see the blue sky and sunshine still visible through the small window. I rushed down the stairs, back to the comfort of the present.</p><p>As a child, I didn’t know how to process or even articulate that strange experience. I knew it had been triggered by thoughts of Lumumba, and even now, more than 60 years later, I can recall exactly where I was when it happened. I never spoke to anyone about it because it seemed like just a fleeting moment — something no one would understand, and certainly nothing I could explain at that age.</p><p>However, with the knowledge I’ve gathered over the years, I can now interpret that experience and its connection to Lumumba. Patrice Lumumba was a leader of the African independence movement and became the first Prime Minister of the Democratic Republic of Congo in 1960. He was a staunch advocate for African self-determination, condemning the exploitation and oppression of Belgian colonial rule. His vision of Africanization made the Belgian government and its imperialistic allies uneasy, because they feared the nationalization of foreign industries in Congo. Fearing Lumumba would align with communism, they launched a smear campaign against him, a modern-day witch hunt, which ultimately led to his assassination in 1961.</p><p>This concept of a “witch hunt” is not new. It originated in Europe and became a tool for the internal colonization of women. The women accused of witchcraft were victims of toxic patriarchal norms and values, which justify and legitimize violence against those who did not act, behave or dress conform to the assigned gender roles imposed by the male-dominated hierarchy, in which most power is assigned to men, who are seen as very different from and more highly valued than women. Patriarchy didn’t emerge as a natural process; in Europe, it was violently enforced. Between the 14th and 18th centuries, millions of women were terrorized during witch hunting and witch trials, tortured, and burned alive after being accused of witchcraft. This brutal misogyny laid the groundwork for a gender-apartheid system that relegated women to inferior status, stripped them of property rights, barred them from education and paid work, and excluded them from decision-making processes. Family laws reduced women to the property of their husbands, confining them to unpaid domestic labour while public spaces remained exclusively male domains.</p><p>This patriarchal model was then exported globally during the colonial era, where it fused with racial oppression to create systems of gender and racial apartheid. In South Africa, for example, these dynamics were institutionalized. Black women were confined to their homelands, while Black men were allowed to enter public spaces solely as labourers for the white ruling class. Family structures were torn apart, and even today, women-led households in rural areas suffer from extreme poverty and struggle for survival. In the ruling capitalist industrialised nations however, the gender-segregation evolved into the breadwinner-housewife model, confining women to the home and legitimising a private slave for every married man in exchange of being exploited in the factories of the ruling class.</p><p>Patrice Lumumba sought to dismantle this toxic, exploitative colonial order, one that was deeply rooted in patriarchal and racist oppression.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/678/1*JHFCWQ8Rr3zLp7yPXaeFag.jpeg" /><figcaption>Liberia, 2010, Wall Painting. Photograph by Thera Van Osch</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a7c8c50b15e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Trump’s appeal to the masses]]></title>
            <link>https://thera-vanosch.medium.com/trumps-appeal-to-the-masses-36a5da85d2aa?source=rss-8b4b03cad76------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/36a5da85d2aa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nazis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[republicans]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thera Van Osch]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 31 Jul 2023 23:36:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-06T14:32:08.839Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F016V1yjpqsUnDXeU9C4vw.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Trump’s and Hitler’s appeal to the masses</strong></h3><p>Why is Donald Trump still leading the polls among the Republicans and has millions of supporters and followers? What is the secret of the appeal to the masses of this hate-speaking, lying, and criminal person?</p><p>After the second World War (1940–45) a similar question was raised about Adolf Hitler by many scientists. Why millions of Germans have been supporters and followers of the Nazi-movement and its leader Adolf Hitler, a crazy man whose destructive policies have been disastrous for millions of innocent people.</p><p>One of the scientists who investigated this question was Erich Fromm (1900–1980), a German-American psychoanalyst and philosopher. He analysed the personality of Adolf Hitler and the reasons of his attraction to the German population of that time.</p><p>The similarities between Hitler and Trump are astonishing. In an interview about ‘<em>Who was this person, Hitler?</em>’, which was recorded on 10 April 1975<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a>, Erich Fromm explains the symbiotic relation between Hitler and a great part of the German population.</p><h3><strong>Same characters</strong></h3><p>Like Trump, Hitler was a narcissist. For him only things related to himself were important: “My idea, my words, my property, my body, my image, my feelings…” everything that was not “mine” was not important and didn’t exist for Hitler. He was not interested in other people, only in himself. He was unable to show affection to others, and he hid his longtime relationship with his companion Eva Braun from the outside world. In his vision, women’s only task was to be beautiful and to contribute to the spread of the “Aryan race” by bringing children into the world and raising them according to Nazi-ideology. He disgusted women and her children who were not of the so-called “Aryan race” and millions were sent to the concentration camps where they were gassed. He was not empathic, he was a man without feelings, uninterested, and unconcerned about the millions of Jews, political opponents, Roma people, people with a physical or mental handicap, homosexual people and others who were targeted and murdered by the Nazis. He was only interested in himself, his plans, his power, and his will.</p><p>Trump shows a similar behaviour. He doesn’t care about the feelings of other people when he offends them, or when he spreads slander and lies about people on social media, or when he rages in his rallies with vicious expressions of hatred against people, or when he criminalises and falsely accuses migrants of problems in the USA, or when he throws people under the bus after having used or abused them for his own interests. He doesn’t care about the traumas caused to migrant parents and children when they are separated from each other and locked up in cages near the border. During the COVID-19 pandemic, he didn’t care about the thousands of people who died. In the middle of the pandemic, he was even holding mass rally’s exposing his own fans to high risks of infection. He doesn’t show affection or appreciation for women. He sees women mainly as sex-object — even his own daughter — or as housewives (particularly when they live in the suburbs), and he only want women to adore and to love him, because he only cares for himself, for his money, his properties, his business, his name, his power, his body, his hair, his ideas, his words, his opinion.</p><p>Since their childhood, both Hitler and Trump have been persons without discipline. They didn’t like to work and to have obligations. They lived in a world of phantasy. Hitler wanted to become a famous artist, but his father wanted him to become a civil servant. Trump wanted to become a famous movie star, but his father wanted him to go in real estate. Both were disappointed because they didn’t achieve much and both tried to hide this. Hitler hid that he was not allowed at an Academy for architects. Trump hid his tax-data that would show a poor business performance whereas he pretended to be the most successful businessman. The less they achieved in the real world, the stronger they believed to live in their fantasy world where they had achieved great things. This characteristic remained with Trump until now. After having been dumped in the real world of movie stars, and after having lost the elections in 2020, Trump found new ways of living in his phantasy world by exposing his phantasies as a movie star in NFT-cards.</p><h3><strong>Driven to destroy</strong></h3><p>Besides having a narcissist character, Hitler also hated life. He was fascinated by death and killing. Deep inside, he was driven to destroy. He felt hate against everyone. That’s why Erich Fromm characterised him as necrophiliac; not in the sense of sexual behaviour, but in the sense of his inclination to embracing violence, whether in the form of acts of terrorism or acts of war. Not only did he hate the Jewish people, but he also hated the Polish and the Russian people, and finally he even hated his own people in Germany. Unconsciously he was destructive. His character was inclined to disrupt and derange instead of building up in a constructive way. In case Hitler would have won the war, he probably “would not have known what to do next”, as quoted in the interview with Erich Fromm.</p><p>When Hitler realised, he was losing the war, he wanted to destroy everything. He gave the order to destroy buildings, fabrics, churches, but also social infrastructure for food and medical services before the enemy could walk into Germany. This severely affected the German population. He didn’t care about this. By the end, he even hated himself and his closest supporters, which ended in an “orgy of hate” with his own death and the death of the most loyal people around him, including his longtime companion Eva Braun, as well as Nazi propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels and his wife Magda, who first murdered their little children before committing suicide themselves.</p><p>Trump also feels hate against all those who are not loyal to him or do not vote for him, particularly the voters and representatives of the Democratic Party, the government of Joe Biden, and even Republicans with a critical mind, which he calls RINOs (Republicans In Name Only), or republican candidates for presidency, which he calls ‘clowns’. In his Iowa rally in July 2023 and other recent rallies, he openly embraces conspiracy theories, promising his fans that he will demolish and “destroy the deep state and get them the hell out of government”. In his hate-speeches he not only fulminates against them, but also against the Department of Justice, against migrants, against the Chinese, the World Health Organisation (WHO), the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) and of course against all critical citizens in the USA who are not fooled by him. He lumps them all together by calling them communists, socialists, and fascists.</p><p>He is also inclined to embrace violence to remain in power. This is not only expressed in words in his rallies, but he also showed that he is serious about this. He wanted to destroy the entire democratic system in the USA after realising that he lost the elections in 2020, and after losing over 60 lawsuits to overthrow the election results. He attempted to ‘steal the elections’ by trying to use the army to seize voter machines, and by persuading and intimidating authorities and officials to commit electoral fraud, calling them cowards when he failed to achieve his goal. On January 6, 2021, he called his ‘standby paramilitary groups’, the proud boys, the oath keepers, the cowboys, etc. to march to the capital and to “fight like hell and if you don’t fight like hell, you’re not going to have a country anymore.”</p><p>Back in the White House he enjoyed for more than 3 hours the life broadcast of the violent attack on Capitol Hill by his fanatic followers, seeing that police officers were severely hurt, and knowing that his vice-president Mike Pence was in great danger, as well as all congress men and women and their staff. While he was watching the destruction caused by the aggressive mop that was “fighting like hell”, he refused the repeated requests — from his daughter and other people around him — to simply tell the mob to go home. When he finally sent a message to go home, he embraced the violent mob that caused the disruption and derangements by saying “We love you. You’re very special.”</p><p>As a hint to his fanatic violent followers he recently targeted the prosecuters of his indictment processes by posting their names on social media, shortly after having posted the message “if you go after me, I’m coming after you”. Trump is driven to destroy all and everything that stands in his way to personal power. It’s in line with expectations that he will initiate destructive action if it gets to the point where he ends up in jail. Those who know him best, like his wife Melanie, and other close family members, wisely remain at a distance from the indictment procedures, because they know his destructive side and his unpredictability if he realises that he is loosing all.</p><h3><strong>Saviours of the country</strong></h3><p>Both Hitler and Trump profiled themselves as the saviours of the country.</p><p>Hitler identified himself with Nazi-Germany, calling it the ‘Thousand-Year Reich’, which in fact only existed 12 years until the Allies defeated Germany in May 1945 and ended World War II.</p><p>Trump also profiles himself as the saviour of the county. He identifies with the USA, as if it were his private property. When he lost the election, it felt for him as if ‘they’ had taken the country away from him. He could not accept this and started to fuel hatred to everything and all who in his view had “rigged the elections” and taken away the country from him and his followers. Recently his rhetoric changed into “They want to take your freedom and I am standing in their way” to justify his destructive plans, to mobilise people to join him to “demolish the deep state”, and to mislead his followers about the indictments by telling them that this has only political reasons and picturing himself as a hero who is enduring this “witch hunt”.</p><h3><strong>Performance in public</strong></h3><p>Both Hitler and Trump have shown to be excellent performers in public. Hitler had a certain look that tolerated no contradiction and was therefore attractive to authority-sensitive people, who believed in him and wanted to submit themselves to him as their leader.</p><p>Just like Trump, Hitler also preferred to hold his rallies in the evening, when people are already tired and less critical about what they are told, making it easier to manipulate them. Like Trump, Hitler tolerated no opposition. Everyone had to show allegiance to him with the ‘Heil Hitler’ salute, just as Trump supporters must show their adherence with Maga caps, Trump flags and recently at an Orlando rally even with raising their right hands and taking a pledge to vote for him for president. Journalists who dare to ask critical questions to Trump during a press conference, are insulted in public. If he could, he would lock them up like Hitler did. Instead, he spreads hate messages against his opponents, and let his fanatical supporters do the work of threatening and intimidating people.</p><p>There was a certain relationship between Hitler’s character and his fanatic followers. In Germany the closest followers of Hitler were people from the lower middle class, who had been suffering from the economic crisis of the 1930s and had few prospects because small producers and traders could not compete against the big ones in the emerging industrialization. They were filled with resentment and lost all their hope for a better life. They were mainly set to get power over others and to demolish. They believed Hitler when he pointed to the scapegoats who were to blame for their misery: the Jews, the communists, the socialists, the ethnic minorities, the homosexuals, the weak with a disability, and all his political opponents. Millions believed his words and saw him as their saviour without perceiving his destructive side. His followers didn’t protest when Hitler’s scapegoats and opponents were imprisoned and murdered in concentration camps, when he banned political parties and trade unions, and when he imposed the Nazification of the entire society and invalidated the constitution.</p><p>Trump would also love to put all his opponents in jail, to start with his number one opponent during election time in 2016, Hillary Clinton. Trump feels frustrated that he has not been able so far to come to a similar level of abuse of power as his dictator friends and to get rid of all the ‘nasty’ people who hinder his wishes of ruling ‘his country’ with absolute power. So far, the democratic system, the strong institutions and the ethical non-corruptible attitude of many authorities, officials and lawyers in the USA could withstand Trump’s demagogic harmful fascist power strategy.</p><h3><strong>Fanatic supporters and followers</strong></h3><p>Hitler had two types of supporters, the fanatical active followers, and the stunned silent supporters. Trump also has his fanatical followers who are willing to fight for him, like the ‘stand-by’ para-military groups who were leading the mob during the attack on Capitol Hill, and the silent crowd who believe his words, sympathize with him and vote for him out of disappointment and resentment with the situation in the USA. He can do no wrong in their eyes and they are blind for his destructive side.</p><p>Hitler needed the crowds to make himself feel strong. Without acclaim from the public, he was unable to bring forward his ideas. He needed applause, approval, enthusiasm from the crowd to feel self-confirmed. His feeling of power came from the crowd of supporters to whom he was speaking. Hitler was so self-fulfilled that each word he pronounced sounded for him as the greatest wisdom and truth on earth, but he needed others who believed in him in order to believe his own words. If nobody would believe him, only himself, Hitler would probably have gotten crazy.</p><p>Trump is a similar case. He needs his followers to confirm, applaud, and enthusiastically approve his words. Trumps vision, ideas and statements are not based on evidence, on facts or on research. They are merely expressions of his emotional state and only based on his personal needs for power and control that he seeks to be confirmed by the crowd. He takes his words, his ideas and vision for the truth, because millions of people believe what he says, and not because they are the truth, or expression of his conviction.</p><p>He doesn’t care about the truth. His prove of ‘truth’ lies in the consent and the applause of his followers, and not in the consistency with the facts. The applause of the crowd makes things true, which explains the name of his platform ‘truth social’.</p><p>Like Hitler, Trump also needs the crowds to feel strong. As any demagogue, he is only interested in consent and applause by the crowds. Therefore, he is often inconsistent, because to achieve applause, he adapts his speeches to different crowds, inner circle speeches, NRA, Religious groups, etc.</p><h3><strong>Unpredictable situation</strong></h3><p>Arnold Schwarzenegger who was born short after World War II and suffered from the impact of the war in his early family life, recognised the similarities between Hitler’s and Trump’s approach. He warned for the consequences if Trump is re-elected.</p><p>Currently there is an unpredictable situation in the USA. Despite an avalanche of criminal charges against Trump he continues to have millions of followers, according to the polls. Will this lead to new forms of violence? Will he be able to win the elections or find other ways of grabbing power again? Will the democratic institutions in the USA be strong enough to resist the power game of Trump and avoid that the USA repeats the history of Nazi-Germany?</p><p>One thing is certain. Trump is nothing without his followers. Trump in jail for his criminal behaviour may make him a popular martyr and increase his popularity. It will not take the wind out of MAGA’s sails, because the American society is sick, and it will not take away the sense of frustration and resentment among his followers, particularly the silent masses that are disillusioned and easily influenced by conspiracy theories because they don’t see new perspectives of realising the so-called American dream. After Trump, new ‘Trumps’ will emerge if dissatisfied and outraged segments of the population together with a silent majority continue to feel neglected, undervalued and underserved by the institutions that represent the status quo of vested political interests.</p><h3><strong>What to do?</strong></h3><p>In Germany an investigation into the reasons why Hitler and ‘Nazism’ had so many followers was done after the war. It is to be hoped that such investigation will be done in the USA before ‘Trumpism’ spirals out of control and further undermines human rights and democracy in the USA.</p><p>How to reduce the risk that the USA falls into an authoritarian, patriarchal, fascist, racist, violent system, that threatens the human rights of many women, black people, ethnic minorities, migrants, LGBTIQ+ people, and all those who do not support ‘Trumpism’.</p><p>To reduce this risk, strategies for social cohesion are key, particularly strategies to create safety and an inclusive social and economic security system.</p><p>The creation of safety and security for all is of high priority to take away the culture of violence, fear and distrust that has permeated all walks of life, from family-life, nursery, and primary school to Capitol Hill. This can only be done by disarmament of the population, strong regulation of gun ownership, rehabilitation of members of disarmed para-military groups, spiritual transformation to increase compassion and tolerance in daily life, and healing initiatives to overcome the many traumas caused by senseless violence including gender-based violence, shootings in schools, femicide, and racist violence. It’s high time for the USA to ratify the Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) and enforce its implementation. Security sector reform from a gender equality and social inclusion perspective is needed to create a human-rights based enabling environment for a peaceful and tolerant society. This includes capacity building and training for a do-no-harm-approach at all levels and areas of the security sector, from the police officers till the lawyers.</p><p>The creation of an inclusive social and economic security system that leaves no-one behind should be another priority in the USA. Tax reform to redistribute the most extreme income inequality is required. Universal Basic Income embedded in a privacy protection system could take away the daily tension and survival stress of millions of people in the USA and create time for them to exercise their right of providing care to and receiving care from their close ones, and to develop their talents and creativity. Additionally, equal access to medical care is still an urgent challenge in the USA.</p><p>Thera van Osch, Germany, July 2023</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Erich Fromm: <em>Hitler — Wer war er und was heißt Widerstand gegen diesen Menschen</em>? Interview von Hans Juergen Schulz zur Eröffnung der Sendereihe „Der 20.Juli — Alternative zu Hitler?“ im Süddeutschen Rundfunk Stuttgart. Erstsendung am 20.04.1975. #ErichFromm #Psychoanalyse. Copyright ©2020 by Literary Estate of Erich Fromm; and Copyright der Produktion by SWR.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=36a5da85d2aa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[De Vierde Industriële Revolutie]]></title>
            <link>https://thera-vanosch.medium.com/de-vierde-industri%C3%ABle-revolutie-f63d1a22e280?source=rss-8b4b03cad76------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f63d1a22e280</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[algorithms]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dutch]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[robotisation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thera Van Osch]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 02 May 2021 00:39:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-02T19:52:59.879Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HdA11rjt4E9b-vLNvEg99g.png" /></figure><blockquote><strong>Uitdaging voor een nieuw economisch model</strong></blockquote><h4>Ons economisch systeem vaart nog steeds op de paradigma’s van het oude economische model, waarvan het grondpatroon is gelegd tijdens de 1e en 2e Industriële Revolutie, alsof het kompas van een zeilschip nog steeds bruikbaar is voor het besturen van quantum computers van de 4e Industriële Revolutie. <strong>Dit essay exploreert de economisch veranderingen van de 4e Industriële Revolutie. We zien consumenten veranderen in algoritmes. De markteconomie verandert in een surveillance economie. De scheiding tussen wonen en werken vervaagt. Informatie over ons privéleven wordt grondstof voor computers van Big Tech giganten, en de CEOs van Facebook en Twitter zijn inmiddels machtiger dan de president van de USA. Welke veranderingen zijn er nodig in de economie opdat de 4e Industriële Revolutie[1] bijdraagt aan een vreedzame, rechtvaardige en inclusieve samenleving, waarin de zorg voor mens en milieu centraal staan?</strong></h4><h3><strong>Consumenten: het paradigma van de ‘homo economicus’</strong></h3><p>Het centrale kompas van het huidige neoliberaal economisch denken is het paradigma van de economische mens (homo economicus), het rationeel handelende individu dat de uiteindelijke verklaring vormt voor de efficiënte allocatie van schaarse goederen die dankzij het marktmechanisme tot stand komt. Het kompas wordt theoretisch onderbouwd met de Wetten van Gossen<a href="#_ftn1">[2]</a> over de rationele consument, wiens vraag naar goederen en diensten afhankelijk is van het nut dat hij/zij hieraan toekent. Dit eendimensionale mensbeeld is een theoretische constructie van een autonoom individu, dat uitsluitend handelt op basis van rationele beslissingen om een maximale behoeftebevrediging te bereiken tegen minimale kosten zonder rekening te houden met anderen. In het echte leven zou zo’n persoon ingedeeld worden in de categorie van mensen met een asociale gedragsstoornis<a href="#_ftn2">[3]</a>.</p><p>Dit eendimensionale mensbeeld is echter ‘de norm’ in de markttheorie en wordt verondersteld universeel en ahistorisch te zijn. Vanuit deze norm modelleert en consolideert de economische wetenschap (en het daarop gebaseerde beleid) de maatschappij vanuit een selectief gezichtspunt, waarin het marktdenken centraal staat. Menselijke verhoudingen worden hierin gereduceerd tot ruilverhoudingen. Ruilverhoudingen worden verklaard vanuit het paradigma van de autonome rationele consument (handelend op basis van de grensnutcurves van de Wetten van Gossen), en dat verklaart weer vraag en aanbod op de markt, evenals de efficiënte en rationele inzet van beschikbare middelen, menskracht en kapitaalgoederen. De hele markttheorie staat of valt met dit paradigma, zonder welk het theoretische bouwwerk van de vrijemarkteconomie instort als een kaartenhuis.</p><p>Verschillende economen hebben dit paradigma ter discussie gesteld, waaronder Richard Thaler<a href="#_ftn3">[4]</a>, Nobelprijswinnaar voor de Economie in 2017, die psychologische analyses over menselijk gedrag verbindt met de economie. Feministische economen hebben aangetoond dat het paradigma van de rationele consument op gezinsniveau en in gemeenschappen niet opgaat, omdat het privéleven meer is dan een groep van autonome consumenten. In privé-huishoudingen wordt de besluitvorming ook beïnvloed door de machtsverhoudingen tussen de seksen en tussen generaties, evenals door gevoelens van verbondenheid, zorg voor elkaar, liefde, solidariteit, altruïsme, en andere niet-rationele motieven die indruisen tegen de Wetten van Gossen.</p><p><strong><em>Met de 4e Industriële Revolutie (4IR) wordt het paradigma van de autonome rationele consument geheel om zeep geholpen.</em></strong> Big Tech met gigantische hoeveelheid data over menselijk gedrag laat zien dat mensen geen eendimensionale rationele consumenten zijn, en dat emoties, gemoedstoestanden, idealen, idolen, machtsverhoudingen, spiritueel bewustzijn, en andere ervaringen van invloed zijn op het consumentengedrag. Dankzij de sociale media delen de mensen deze ervaringen. <strong><em>De Wetten van Gossen worden vervangen door de heerschappij van het Algoritme.</em></strong></p><h3><strong>De heerschappij van Algoritmes</strong></h3><p>De 4e Industriële Revolutie (4IR) is in de take-off fase. Productiebedrijven gebruiken algoritmes om hun winst te maximaliseren door vergroting van de omzet en verlaging van de kosten. De nieuwe trends in de industrie betreffen de toepassing van een combinatie van de nieuwste technologieën (zie voetnoot 1) om structurele veranderingen door de hele waardeketen tot stand te brengen, van grondstofdelving tot verkoop van het eindproduct. Het betreft veranderingen om sneller en flexibeler te produceren en te werken met kleinschalige modulaire installaties die producten op maat maken; toeleveringssystemen die zich makkelijk aanpassen aan veranderingen in het productieproces; automatisering op alle niveaus van het bedrijfsproces; decentralisatie van productieprocessen; en ecologische efficiëntie voor naleving van de steeds complexere milieuregelgeving. De industriële voorlopers in dit proces worden “Lighthouse Manufactorers” genoemd, en maken deel uit van het “Global Lighthouse Network”, een platform van het “World Economic Forum”, dat deze 4IR promoot onder het motto van “The Great Reset in Manufacturing”.<a href="#_ftn1">[5]</a></p><p>Of je wilt of niet, bijna iedereen is er direct of indirect bij betrokken. Ongemerkt worden grote hoeveelheden gegevens en beeldmateriaal over ons verzameld en door computers verwerkt, waaruit vervolgens ons “profiel” kan worden vastgesteld, en ons <em>gedrag kan worden voorspeld</em>.</p><p>Door het gebruik van algoritmes kunnen beslissingen worden geautomatiseerd. Dit is kunstmatige intelligentie (AI — Artificial Intelligence). Door het verzamelen en analyseren van informatie over het gedrag van miljoenen mensen kunnen computers de behoeften van (potentiële) klanten voorspellen, zelfs voordat ze zelf hiervan bewust zijn. Bestel je bijvoorbeeld een boek bij Amazon, dan krijg je meteen een serie aanbevelingen van gerelateerde boeken die inderdaad ook je interesse hebben, maar waarvan je het bestaan niet vermoedde. Via je posts op Facebook kan de computer vrij exact voorspellen wanneer de kans het grootst is dat je een bepaald product koopt, zoals een paar schoenen van je voorkeurmerk, die precies passen bij de kleding die je hebt aangeschaft voor het cruciale sollicitatiegesprek over drie dagen. Zodra de advertentie van die schoenen op je beeldscherm verschijnt met de mededeling dat ze de volgende dag gratis bezorgd worden als je nu besluit te kopen, dan is de kans groot dat je bent verkocht.</p><p>Banken en financiële instellingen gebruiken voorspellende algoritmes om de kredietwaardigheid van mensen te laten vaststellen door de computer op basis van gegevens die verzameld zijn over leeftijd, gezondheid, inkomen, eigendom, gegevens van incassobureaus, etc.</p><p>De overheid gebruikt voorspellende algoritmes om het werk van ambtenaren te automatiseren. De belastingdienst kan algoritmes toepassen om de belastinginkomsten te maximaliseren, en belastingfraude te minimaliseren. De politie kan algoritmes toepassen om te anticiperen op crimineel gedrag en preventief toezicht te houden op personen die volgens computeranalyses van data over leeftijd, afkomst, wijk, kleur, gezinssamenstelling, inkomsten, studie, werk, etc., een hoog risico lopen om tot criminaliteit over te gaan.</p><p>Automatisering van besluitvorming met voorspellende algoritmes kan heel nuttig zijn, het leven van mensen vergemakkelijken, en tijd uitsparen. Maar er zitten ook gevaren aan, wanneer vooroordelen mee sluipen in de programmering, waardoor het gebruik van algoritmes kan leiden tot institutionalisering van discriminatie en etnisch profileren van bepaalde groepen van de bevolking. Bijvoorbeeld Facebook geeft adverteerders de mogelijkheid om hun doelgroep te bepalen op basis van sekse, religie, burgerlijke staat, land van herkomst, etc. In 2018 werd Facebook aangeklaagd door het Amerikaanse ‘Department of Housing and Urban Development’<a href="#_ftn1">[6]</a> wegens het schenden van de ‘Fair Housing Act’, omdat bepaalde bevolkingsgroepen in de VS uitgesloten werden van informatie over leegstaande huizen. Vooroordelen kunnen binnensluipen in algoritmes. Bijvoorbeeld, jongeren uit arme gezinnen die hun school niet hebben afgemaakt en een Afro-Europees signalement hebben, lopen grote kans dat de politie hen op basis van hun algoritme vaker gaat verdenken en aanhouden. Ook gender-stereotyperingen sluipen onbewust binnen in de algoritmes, waardoor ongelijke rechten en kansen van mannen en vrouwen worden geconsolideerd of zelfs versterkt.</p><p>Uiteindelijk wordt ons leven zelf koopwaar in handen van een paar Big Tech giganten die onze persoonsgegevens verzamelen, vermarkten en daarmee grote wisten maken. <strong><em>Hoe vrij is de vrije markt nog indien algoritmes in handen van het bedrijfsleven de plaats hebben ingenomen van de autonome consumenten?</em></strong></p><h3><strong>Surveillance economie</strong></h3><p>De econome Shoshana Zuboff van de Harvard Business School beschrijft in haar boek ‘<em>The Age of Surveillance Capitalism</em>’<a href="#_ftn1">[7]</a> hoe de mensen die gebruik maken van de sociale media, waaronder Google en Facebook, in feite ‘<em>grondstof</em>’ zijn voor deze mediagiganten, die de persoonsgegevens verwerken tot voorspelbare gedragsmodellen, ofwel algoritmes. Ze bieden een gratis platform aan miljoenen gebruikers om hun gedachten te publiceren, te communiceren, foto’s en filmpjes te posten, inhoud te delen, ‘<em>likes</em>’ uit te delen en te ontvangen, en het laatste nieuws te lezen. In december waren er dagelijks 1,8 miljard mensen actief of Facebook. Geen enkele krant of tijdschrift bereikt zo’n groot publiek, en doelgericht adverteren in sociale media is daarom aantrekkelijk voor veel bedrijven. De omzet van Facebook in 2020 was bijna US$ 86 miljard, hoofdzakelijk dankzij reclame-inkomsten van adverteerders, en het bedrijf boekte een nettowinst van US$ 11,2 miljard<a href="#_ftn2">[8]</a>.</p><p>Het Surveillance Kapitalisme (Toezichtkapitalisme) houdt toezicht op de gebruikers van de sociale media en eigent zich alle gedeelde menselijke ervaringen toe om te gebruiken als grondstof voor computerprogramma’s die hieruit algoritmes produceren die het gedrag voorspellen. Deze data zijn <em>eigendom</em> van het bedrijf. Voor een deel worden ze gebruikt voor verbetering van de digitale dienstverlening, en voor een ander deel voor de marketing.</p><p>In de concurrentiestrijd om een groot marktaandeel te veroveren en de winst te maximaliseren, zijn mediagiganten genoodzaakt steeds meer informatie aan mensen te onttrekken om hun gedrag beter te kunnen voorspellen. Zuboff noemt dit ‘<em>the extraction imperative</em>’ (de noodzaak van extractie) van het surveillance kapitalisme [9]. Doordat de surveillance economie in de eerste plaats functioneert volgens de logica van het kapitalisme, zal het in de kern streven naar kapitaalsaccumulatie en het economisch rationaliteitsprincipe toepassen. Dat wil zeggen, het vergaren van persoonsgegevens (grondstof) tegen de laagst mogelijk kosten, en het verwerken hiervan tot winstgevende producten of diensten.</p><p>Het surveillance Kapitalisme is dus geen ‘nieuwe economische orde’, maar eerder een ‘nieuwe manifestatie’ van het kapitalisme. Het voltrekt zich sluipenderwijs en stap voor stap, zodat mensen eraan gewend raken dat hun persoonlijke gegevens worden onttrokken en gebruikt voor andere doeleinden. Protesten wegens privacy schending worden zo lang mogelijk genegeerd door de mediagiganten in de hoop dat ze wegebben. Houden de protesten aan, dan worden aanpassingen voorgesteld, en de aandacht afgeleid naar andere zaken. Het uiteindelijke doel, namelijk het onttrekken van persoonlijke gegevens blijft onaangetast. Er worden alleen nieuwe strategieën bedacht voor het bereiken van dit doel. Zuboff noemt dit proces de “<em>dispossion cycle</em>” (beschikkingscyclus), waarbij het doel niet veranderd, maar nieuwe wegen naar dit doel uitgestippeld.</p><p>Directe ‘persoonsgegevens’ worden niet langer verkocht, maar met deze gegevens worden voorspelbare modellen en algoritmes gemaakt, waardoor adverteerders doelgericht potentiële klanten kan bereiken. Daarvoor worden krachtige computers met ‘machine learning’ software ingezet, en AI-specialisten ingehuurd. Het gaat daarbij niet alleen om schaalvergroting (<em>economics of scale</em>), maar ook om vergroting van de reikwijdte van economisch handelen (<em>economics of scope</em>) [10]. Zuboff verwijst hiermee naar het proces, waarbij gegevens niet alleen onttrokken worden aan online-activiteiten, maar ook aan het offline leven van mensen. Dingen worden verbonden met internet om gegevens te kunnen verzamelen. Met de Internet of Things (IoT) die verkocht worden om ons leven ‘te vergemakkelijken’, zoals matrassen, koelkasten, of camera’s met een chip voor internetverbinding, kan in principe alles worden afgetapt. Onze stem, gezichtsuitdrukkingen, slaapgewoontes, gedrag in het verkeer, kijkgedrag op tv, eetgewoontes, tot en met onze intieme ervaringen kunnen worden gescand, geanalyseerd, en opnieuw vervaardigd in voorspelbare gedragsmodules, die in de surveillance economie lucratief zijn [11].</p><p>In de heftige concurrentiestrijd van de 4IR zijn ‘economics of scale’ en ‘economics of scope’ niet meer voldoende, maar zijn ook ‘economics of action’ vereist om een concurrentievoordeel te behouden in het toezichtkapitalisme. Met ‘deep learning’ kunnen computerprocessen niet alleen ons gedrag voorspellen, maar het ook manipuleren en in bepaalde richtingen duwen. Zuboff [12]noemt als voorbeeld het spelletje ‘Pokémon Go’ van het bedrijf Niantic, dat gebruik maakt van Google Maps, en toegang heeft tot de camera, de contacten, en audiogegevens van het computerspelletje, zodat gamers kunnen worden gevolgd en rondgeleid op straat. Daardoor kunnen de spelers ook naar specifieke plekken worden geleid, zoals naar pizzeria’s, parken, of theehuizen. Een Pizza-bar in New York had US$ 10,- voor een advertentie betaald om Pokémon spelers te trekken, waardoor virtuele wezens op de barkrukken en in het toilet van de pizzeria werden geplaatst. In het eerste weekend steeg de omzet van de pizzeria met 30% en later zelfs tot 70%.</p><p>Dit voorbeeldje is een van de velen dat aangeeft dat de 4IR het technisch mogelijk maakt op iedereen toezicht te houden, en het gedrag van mensen te voorspellen en te manipuleren. De digitale architectuur die door de sociale mediagiganten is ontwikkeld vanuit het belang van winstmaximalisatie voor eigenaren en aandeelhouders, heeft echter ook zijn impact op de wereldpolitiek, en kan de democratie ondermijnen door het verspreiden van leugens en het manipuleren van kiezers. Potentieel ligt ook het gevaar op de loer dat gegevens in handen vallen van totalitaire regimes. De geschiedenis van fascistische en nazi-regimes laat zien wat er kan gebeuren als geheime diensten toegang krijgen tot dit soort informatie.</p><p>Iedereen die actief is op internet heeft een algoritme. Dat wordt automatische gegenereerd door de zoekmachines en instellingen van Amazon, Facebook, Twitter, Google, Yahoo, Instagram, Pinterest etc. Voor je het weet zit je in een bubbel en krijg je steeds meer van dezelfde soort informatie voorgeschoteld. De bubbel rondom de twitterende president Trump kon jarenlang groeien, omdat Twitter en Facebook zijn account faciliteerden en daaraan veel konden verdienen, dankzij de miljoenen volgers, die allemaal reclameboodschappen voorgeschoteld kregen. Doordat Trump zijn Twitteraccount onder meer gebruikte om verdeeldheid te zaaien, mensen te schofferen, leugens te verspreiden, samenzweringstheorieën te legitimeren, angst en geweld aan te wakkeren, kwamen zijn volgers in de fuik van samenzweringstheorieën terecht, en begonnen heilig te geloven in de leugens en absurde en angstaanjagende verhalen van obscurantistische groepjes. Pas toen het volledig uit de hand liep met de bestorming van het Capitol op 6 januari 2021, die een bedreiging vormde voor de Amerikaanse democratie, besloot de top van Twitter en Facebook het account van Trump te sluiten, mede onder druk van verontruste klanten en bedrijven die dreigden met stopzetting van hun advertenties.</p><p>Bovengenoemd voorbeeld toont aan dat <strong><em>de democratie op twee manier ondermijnd wordt: Enerzijds door demagogen (zoals Trump), geheime diensten (zoals hackers die verkiezingen willen beïnvloeden), of verspreiders van samenzweringstheorieën (zoals de angst zaaiende QAnon), die doelbewust de massa manipuleren om bepaalde machtposities te behouden, te veroveren, of omver te werpen. Anderzijds door de CEOs van mediagiganten die eigenaar zijn van de digitale architectuur, die met algoritmes en AI grote massa’s kunnen controleren en manipuleren, en die uiteindelijk de macht hebben om een twitterende president het zwijgen op te leggen door zijn account te sluiten.</em></strong> In de praktijk beschikken deze CEOs over meer informatie dan geheime diensten, en meer macht dan regeringen.</p><p>De macht van mediagiganten heeft met name in de Europese Commissie vragen opgeroepen over de controle van persoonlijke gegevens van internetgebruikers. De Commissie wil meer transparantie afdwingen bij bedrijven als Google, Twitter en Facebook, maar loopt een beetje achter de feiten aan, omdat technologische ontwikkelingen in een versnelling zijn gekomen, mede door de COVID-19 pandemie, waardoor online werken een sterke impuls heeft gekregen. De meest recente regelgeving gaat vooral over bescherming van consumentenrechten bij e-commerce. Er staat echter veel mee op het spel, omdat de 4IR het totale leven van de mensheid transformeert.</p><h3><strong>Economische waarde</strong></h3><p>Economische waarde wordt uitgedrukt in geld. Maar wat is geld? Het is een rekeneenheid, fiduciair geld, dat functioneert op basis van gedeeld vertrouwen. De overheid, de Centrale Bank en de financiële sector spelen een cruciale rol om het algemene vertrouwen in het geld als ruilwaarde en rekeneenheid te handhaven.</p><p>De werkelijke waarde van het geld ligt in de reële economie. Over de grondslag van de waarde is er in de geschiedenis van het economisch denken heel wat discussie gevoerd. Grof gezegd zijn er twee richtingen te onderscheiden: De objectieve waardeleer en de subjectieve waardeleer.</p><p>De <strong><em>objectieve waardenleer</em></strong> stamt uit de tijd van de Klassieke Economen (1780–1880). Zij verklaren de prijs uit de hoeveelheid arbeid die nodig is om iets te produceren. De Schotse econoom Adam Smith (1723–1790) onderscheidt gebruikswaarde en ruilwaarde van goederen. Drinkwater heeft een hoge gebruikswaarde (nuttigheid) omdat mensen het dagelijks nodig hebben om te overleven, maar het heeft een lage ruilwaarde omdat het goedkoop is. Diamanten daarentegen hebben een lage gebruikswaarde voor de mens om te overleven, maar hun ruilwaarde is hoog. Met behulp van de arbeidswaardeleer probeert Smith de ‘diamant/water paradox’ op te lossen. Diamant is duurder dan drinkwater omdat de productie ervan veel meer arbeid vergt. Ook David Ricardo (1772–1832) is van mening dat de arbeidswaarde bepalend is voor de prijs van goederen op de markt. Hij ontwikkelde o.a. de wet van het comparatief kostenvoordeel in de internationale handel, waardoor het ene land meer arbeidsuren nodig heeft voor het produceren van hetzelfde product als het andere land<a href="#_ftn1">[13]</a>. Karl Marx (1818–1883) was een van de laatste klassieke economen die arbeidswaardeleer aanhingen. In zijn hoofdwerk “Het Kapitaal” (1867) gebruikt hij de arbeidswaardeleer om de uitbuitingsgraad van de arbeiders aan te tonen en de meerwaarde te berekenen, die de bezitters van de productiemiddelen (kapitalisten) zich toe-eigenen, om van daaruit de klassentegenstellingen te verklaren.</p><p>De objectieve arbeidswaardeleer heeft niet alleen het onderspit gedolven in de scholenstrijd tussen economen, en plaats moeten maken voor de subjectieve waardenleer, maar is in het licht van de 4IR ook minder relevant geworden. Menselijke arbeid wordt namelijk overgenomen door robots en kunstmatige intelligentie (AI). Gegevens over menselijk gedrag zijn in de 4IR waardevoller als ‘grondstof’ voor ‘deep machine learning’ voor gerobotiseerde productieprocessen, dan menselijke arbeid ‘an sich’.</p><p>De <strong><em>subjectieve waardeleer</em></strong> werd ontwikkeld door de Neoklassieke economen (1870-heden) en gaat ervan uit dat elke persoon handelt vanuit eigen belang en op rationele wijze beslissingen neemt met het doel een zo groot mogelijk nut te bereiken. Het is niet de arbeidswaarde die opgesloten ligt in een product, maar het marginale nut of grensnut dat de individuele consument toekent aan het eindproduct, op basis waarvan hij/zij bereid is een bepaalde prijs ervoor te betalen. Met andere woorden, <em>de prijs op de markt is wat de consument ervoor geven wil</em> (subjectieve waarde). Hun theorie is gefundeerd op micro-economische analyses over marginaal nut (grensnut), later uitgebreid met concepten zoals marginale kosten, marginale productiviteit en marginale winst. De subjectieve waardeleer<a href="#_ftn1">[14]</a>, het totaal van de nutsfuncties van alle consumenten die via hun koopgedrag een optimale behoeftebevrediging nastreven, bepaalt de vraag naar goederen en diensten op de markt.</p><p>Deze subjectieve waardeleer, gebaseerd op de grensnuttheorie, die uitgaat van autonome rationeel handelende consumenten, is niet langer houdbaar in de surveillance economie. Allereerst omdat <strong>de algoritmes</strong> aantonen dat mensen allesbehalve autonome rationeel handelende individuen zijn, en dat beslissingen van consumenten vaak genomen worden op basis van emoties, onder druk van bijzondere omstandigheden, of vanuit principes van solidariteit of altruïsme. Op de tweede plaats omdat mensen door de sociale media in een fuik gesluisd worden waardoor ze <strong>gemanipuleerde individuen</strong> worden, in plaats van autonome individuen. Ten derde zien we het verschijnsel dat het <strong>gedrag en de levensstijl</strong> van mensen zelf economische waarde krijgen<a href="#_ftn2">[15]</a>. De ‘waarde’ van mensen wordt bepaald door het aantal volgers dat ze hebben op internet, bij Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, etc., waardoor ze zelf een online business kunnen opzetten, of cash in het laadje brengen van de mediagiganten dankzij de advertentie-inkomsten waarmee ze deze volgers kunnen bedienen.</p><p>Noch de objectieve, noch de subjectieve waardenleer blijken toepasbaar op de nieuwe economische realiteit van de 4IR. Met de 4IR wordt de economische waarde verlegt naar informatie en dataverzameling over gedrag, levensstijlen en <strong>intrinsieke waardes</strong>, die verwijzen naar intelligentie, kennis, gevoelens, en onderlinge verhoudingen. Het toepassen van technologie waardoor machines deze intrinsieke waardes kunnen overnemen, en als mensen gaan leren redeneren, begrijpen, plannen en taken uitvoeren, ligt ten grondslag aan de 4IR. Door het vergaren, verwerken, toe-eigenen en vermarkten van deze intrinsieke waardes beschikken Facebook, Twitter en Google inmiddels over meer macht dan alle banken en de overheid samen.</p><h3>Artificial Intelligence (AI) en Robotisering van de arbeid</h3><p>In ons huidig economisch model heeft arbeid pas waarde wanneer het een prijs heeft op de markt, bijvoorbeeld in de vorm van loon, salaris, bonus, winstdeling of commissie. Op de arbeidsmarkt en in onderhandelingen tussen werkgevers en werknemers komt de prijs van arbeid tot stand. De maatschappelijke status van een persoon hangt samen met de hoogte van haar of zijn ruilwaarde op de arbeidsmarkt. Je doet pas mee aan de samenleving als je een betaalde baan hebt. Mensen zonder betaalde baan staan onderaan de maatschappelijke ladder, en krijgen te maken met een stigmatiserend en discriminerend mensbeeld dat zelfs in de Nederlandse Participatiewet is vastgelegd<a href="#_ftn1">[16]</a>.</p><p>Met de ontwikkeling van AI en de robotisering van de economie, zullen steeds meer werkzaamheden van mensen worden overgenomen door robots, zoals we onder meer zien in de auto-industrie, de klantenservice, transport, logistiek, communicatie, mijnbouw, en de zorgsector. Door inzet van robots en AI neemt de productiviteit van bedrijven toe, en gaan banen verloren. In eerste instantie zullen gemakkelijk vervangbare werkzaamheden worden gerobotiseerd, waardoor de laagbetaalde banen verdwijnen. Het vervangen van banen op besluitvormend niveau en van hoogopgeleiden vergt meer investering, met name in kunstmatige intelligentie, en zal na verloop van tijd ook leiden tot verlies van werkgelegenheid in de top. Uiteindelijk blijft een kleine elite van hoogopgeleide mensen over die nog werk hebben in het productiesysteem van de 4IR.</p><p>Blijft de 4IR doordraaien op de vooronderstellingen van het oude economische model, dan zal dit leiden tot een verdere tweedeling van de samenleving, met toenemende inkomensongelijkheid tussen de kleine elite van hoogopgeleiden, en de grote massa van werklozen en werkzoekenden wiens banen zijn vervangen door slimme machines. De arbeidskosten van bedrijven zullen dalen, waardoor de overheid loonbelasting gaat mislopen. Dit systeem wordt op den duur onhoudbaar, aangezien de overheid niet meer in staat zal zijn het oude stelsel van sociale zekerheid in stand te houden. Reden voor Bill Gates, wiens bedrijf Microsoft een cruciale rol speelt in de 4IR, om te pleiten voor belastingheffing op robots die de banen hebben weggenomen van mensen<a href="#_ftn2">[17]</a>.</p><p>Het economisch denkkader zit nog steeds vast aan het oude mensbeeld dat is ontstaan tijdens de eerste industriële revolutie, waarin productief-zijn een centraal kenmerk werd voor menselijk gedrag. Vanaf die tijd gingen werkgevers menselijke ijver meten in termen van productiviteit, om uit te rekenen hoeveel werknemersuren kosten (arbeidskosten) en hoeveel ze opbrengen (winst). Mensen ontleenden hun identiteit aan hun baan, hun productiviteitsniveau, hun salarisniveau en hun werkgever. De onzekerheid en angst wegens het verdwijnen van banen als gevolg van de 4IR, leidt ertoe dat veel mensen in een identiteitscrisis raken, het gevoel hebben dat hen onrecht is aangedaan, en hiervoor zondebokken zoeken<a href="#_ftn3">[18]</a>.</p><p>De grootste blinde vlek in het economische model is de totale onzichtbaarheid van de omvang van alle onbetaalde levens-essentiële werkzaamheden. Het is juist deze arbeid die<strong> intrinsieke waarde</strong> heeft die niet te koop is op de markt, zoals de waarde van aandacht en liefde voor elkaar, de waarde van ondersteuning en zorg voor familie, vrienden en kennissen. Werkzaamheden die geen prijs hebben op de markt — waaronder huishoudelijke arbeid, opvoeden van kinderen, vrijwilligerswerk, en mantelzorg — tellen niet mee in het BNP, en worden niet genoemd in de economische statistieken, ondanks dat het aantal arbeidsuren in de onbetaalde sector hoger is dan in alle betaalde sectoren samen. In de statistieken van het CPB heeft arbeidsparticipatie alleen betrekking op de beroepsbevolking met een betaalde baan of op zoek naar een betaalde baan. Maatschappelijke participatie wordt pas erkend zodra iemand een betaalde baan heeft. Alleen mensen die (potentiële) ruilwaarde (loon, salaris, commissie, etc.) hebben op de arbeidsmarkt, zijn economisch relevant. Dit is het centrale probleem van de 4IR. Dit stigmatiserende mensbeeld verklaart mensen als ‘inactief’ of ‘nutteloos’ zodra zij niet langer met hun werk en inzet kunnen bijdragen aan winstmaximalisatie en groei van het BNP. <strong><em>We moeten af van dit eendimensionale verouderde mensbeeld uit de eerste en tweede industriële revolutie[19]. De 4IR biedt kansen voor een meer holistisch mensbeeld en spirituele transformatie in een samenleving waarin ieder mens telt en gebruik kan maken van haar of zijn mensenrechten.</em></strong></p><h3>De levens-essentiële thuiseconomie</h3><p>De eerste industriële revolutie leidde tot een scheiding van woon- en werkplaats. Familiebedrijven die ambachten en huisnijverheid uitoefenden waren niet in staat te concurreren met de industrie, en mensen werden de fabrieken in gedreven. Aanvankelijk gingen volledige gezinnen werken in de fabrieken en mijnen, omdat ze gewend waren als familie samen te werken. Door inzet van de arbeidersbeweging werd kinderarbeid verboden, en het kostwinnersprincipe gepromoot met de vrouw als huisvrouw, afhankelijk van het loon van de man, en belast met de onbetaalde huishoudelijke en zorgarbeid voor de dagelijkse reproductie van huidige en toekomstige generaties van arbeiders. Wereldwijd verrichten vrouwen nog steeds 76,2% van de totale uren onbetaald zorgwerk — meer dan driemaal zoveel als mannen.</p><p>In de economische theorie is deze scheiding tussen woon- en werkplaats vertaald in ‘consumptie- en productie-eenheden’. In lijn met de eenzijdige opvatting over de waarde van arbeid, telt onbetaalde arbeid niet mee, omdat het geen prijs heeft op de arbeidsmarkt. In econometrische modellen worden huishoudens weergegeven als Consumptievergelijkingen en voorgesteld als ‘C’ van ‘Consumptiehuishouding’. Op deze wijze wordt in het macro-economisch model het niveau van de consumptie van gezinnen bepaald, gegeven hun inkomen en vermogen. Het idee dat mensen thuis alleen maar consumeren, ontkent en negeert de essentiële bijdrage van de onbetaalde thuisarbeid aan de economie.</p><p>In de 4IR wordt het privéleven grondstof waarmee computers gevoed worden voor het creëren van AI, robotisering en IoT. Huishoudens worden daardoor deel van de productieve waardenketen. In het economisch model blijven ze echter gedefinieerd als consumptie eenheden, zodat deze grondstofleveranties gratis onttrokken kunnen worden onder toezicht van de Big Tech companies.</p><p>De COVID-19 lockdown van onze economie leidde tot de wonderbaarlijke openbaring, dat gezinshuishoudingen meer zijn dan consumptie-eenheden. De verborgen, genegeerde en onbetaalde thuiseconomie absorbeerde in een mum van tijd grote delen van het bedrijfsleven en de overheid, en speelde een cruciale rol bij het draaiende houden van de overheidsinstanties, van de onderwijssector, de gezondheidssector, en grote delen van het bedrijfsleven. De scheiding wonen-werken viel weg en zonder enige kosten voor de overheid hield de thuiseconomie het systeem draaiende, en expandeerde met nieuwe functies, waaronder virtueel onderwijs, zorg voor patiënten waarvoor geen plaats meer was in ziekenhuizen, digitale economische activiteiten zoals administratief werk, klantenservice, online coaching en advies, virtuele vergaderingen van bedrijven en overheden, desktop-onderzoek, journalistiek, virtuele exposities van kunst en online concerten en entertainment. Daarentegen stortten grote delen van de erkende formele bedrijven in als een kaartenhuis, en moesten met miljarden euro’s van de overheid op de been gehouden worden.</p><p>De lockdown heeft aangetoond dat de thuiseconomie meer is dan een optelsom van ‘consumptie-eenheden’. Het is een <strong>fundamenteel levensondersteunend systeem</strong> met een enorme veerkracht en aanpassingsvermogen, waarop de formele economie rust. Deze realiteit staat in schril contrast met de eendimensionale visie van het neoliberale macro-economisch model dat huishoudens reduceert tot een consumptievergelijking.</p><p>De scheiding tussen consumptie- en productie-eenheden is een van de oude economische paradigma’s die niet meer passen bij de nieuwe realiteit van de 3e en 4e Industriële Revolutie, die decentralisatie van werkprocessen mogelijk maakt en nieuwe kansen creëert voor thuisproductie en dienstverlening in een grote verscheidenheid aan banen. De lockdowns van de COVID-19 pandemie hebben dit decentralisatieproces versneld, en met de 4IR zal het aantal zelfstandigen zonder personeel (ZZP’ers) naar verwachting nog sneller gaan stijgen.</p><h3>Aanzetten voor nieuwe economische benaderingen voor de toekomst</h3><p>De 4IR is nog maar net aan de gang. In Juni 2020 waren er 54 bedrijven wereldwijd die deze technologische transformatie hebben doorgevoerd in de hele waardeketen<a href="#_ftn1">[20]</a>. <strong><em>De contouren van de transformatie van de samenleving worden zichtbaar, maar de paradigma’s en vooronderstellingen van ons economisch model stammen nog steeds uit de tijd van de 1e en 2e industriële revolutie. </em></strong>Het is zoiets als een quantum-computer voor “deep learning’ aansturen met de kracht van een stoom machine.</p><p>De 4IR biedt kansen voor een economische reset, en het ontwikkelen van <strong><em>een nieuw inclusief economisch model dat gebaseerd is op mensenrechten en zorg draagt voor mens en planeet, zoals het model van ‘Caring Economics’</em></strong>.<a href="#_ftn2">[21]</a> Hier enkele suggesties die wellicht aanzetten kunnen geven voor de ontwikkeling van een nieuw economisch model voor de toekomst.</p><p><strong>Mensbeeld</strong></p><p>Vervang het paradigma van de “homo economicos”, het rationele individu dat puur eigenbelang nastreeft, door het <strong><em>paradigma van de “caring human being”, een meer holistisch mensbeeld van de zorgzame mens met gevoelens en interactieve relaties, die handelt op basis van vertrouwen, en zorgt voor zichzelf, de naasten en de omgeving</em></strong>. Niet de ‘ruilwaarde’ van de mens op de arbeidsmarkt is bepalend voor de positie van de mens in het economisch systeem, maar <strong><em>respect voor de mensenrechten is bepalend voor economisch handelen en geldt voor elk mens</em></strong> ongeacht leeftijd, sekse, capaciteit, achtergrond, kleur, etniciteit, religie, of andere identietiten.</p><p>Mensen zijn geen algoritmes. Het toe-eigenen van persoonlijke gegevens is een schending van de menselijke integriteit, en wordt daarom verboden. <strong><em>Mensen krijgen zelf controle over de eigen data, en bepalen zelf wat zij hiermee willen doen.</em></strong> Dit kan in feite nu al worden gerealiseerd met digitale IDs, die de privacy van gebruikers beschermt.</p><p><strong>Economische waarden</strong></p><p><strong><em>Tijd en Milieugebruiksruimte </em></strong>worden de nieuwe economische waarden.</p><p>De <strong><em>prijs van producten wordt uitgedrukt in Milieugebruiksruimte (MGR)</em></strong>. De aarde en de natuurlijke rijkdom wordt de basis voor het toekomstig duuzaam ruilsysteem, dat daardoor wordt gekoppeld aan de logica van een natuurlijk en sociaal cultureel systeem. Producten krijgen geen prijzen meer als op de markt, maar de waarde van een product of dienst wordt bepaald door de MGR om dit product of dienstverlening op de markt te brengen.</p><p>Met de overname van menselijke arbeid door robots en AI, wordt betaalde arbeid steeds minder relevant in het economisch systeem. Mensen krijgen steeds meer tijd voor zichzelf, en voor elkaar. Het <strong><em>onderscheid tussen betaalde en onbetaalde arbeid valt weg</em>.</strong> Mensen zijn vrij hun leven te wijden aan de arbeid die het meest betekenisvol is in hun leven, zoals meer tijd aan zorg voor elkaar, kunst, cultuur, verbouwen van eigen groenten, muziek, spirituele ontwikkeling, etc. <strong><em>Economische groei wordt dan groei van de natuurlijke en menselijke rijkdom.</em></strong></p><p><strong>De levens-essentiële thuiseconomie</strong></p><p>De scheiding tussen productie- en consumptiehuishoudingen valt weg. Dankzij technologische ontwikkelingen kan een <strong><em>groot deel van de economie worden gedecentraliseerd</em></strong><em>, </em>zoals duurzame energie, 3-D geprinte gebruiksvoorwerpen, virtuele dienstverlening, entertainment en vele andere taken in de thuiseconomie, waarvan de lockdown al een voorproefje heeft gegeven. De levens-essentiële <strong><em>thuiseconomie wordt de nieuwe basis van de economie</em>,</strong> die naast consumeren ook goederen en diensten aanbieden, terwijl de grotere bedrijven in dienst staan van de productie- en consumptiebehoeftes in de thuiseconomie.</p><p><strong>Universeel Basisinkomen (UBI)</strong></p><p>De enorme winsten die de Big Tech bedrijven nu boeken, en de uitputting van de aarde zijn te verklaren uit het feit dat het economisch systeem nog steeds opereert op basis van de oude paradigma’s uit de eerste en tweede industriële revolutie. De technologische veranderingen van de 4IR kan de levensstandaard van de hele mensheid verbeteren indien er een rechtvaardige verdeling komt van de bronnen van bestaan, gekoppeld aan de grenzen van de aarde. <strong><em>Elke aardbewoner krijgt een basisinkomen gebaseerd op een ‘Fair Earth Share’ (FES)</em></strong><em>.</em> Dat is gelijk aan de totale oppervlakte van productief land, gedeeld door het aantal inwoners<a href="#_ftn1">[22]</a>.</p><p>Met de blockchain technologie wordt de ‘FES’ maandelijks verdeeld onder alle wereldbewoners. <strong><em>Banken worden overbodig</em></strong>. Het doel van het economisch handelen is het bevorderen dat de mensheid meer tijd krijgt voor het bouwen aan een gelukkiger leven, binnen de grenzen van hun “FES” gaan leven, en dat de technologische vernieuwingen hieraan bijdragen. Mensen die naast hun universeel basisinkomen extra MGR verwerven door betaalde arbeid, of door het produceren en verkopen van goederen en diensten, kunnen via een ingenieus fiscaal systeem dat via de block-chain loopt, MGR lenen van hen die onder de FES leven of ze kunnen worden belast door de overheid. Door het belastingsysteem wordt MGR overgeheveld naar de overheid, die deze kan investeren in sociale infrastructuur ter ondersteuning van de thuiseconomie, of in beleid ter bevordering van technologische ontwikkelingen gericht op de groei van natuurlijke en menselijke rijkdom en vermindering van MGR. Mensen die onder de het niveau van het FES leven, kunnen hun MGR in de blockchain tijdelijk uitlenen en opsparen voor de toekomst.</p><p><strong>Democratie</strong></p><p>Decentralisatie van de economie creëert meer mogelijkheden voor controle van productieprocessen op lokaal niveau. <strong><em>Participatieve democratie met zelfbestuur op lokaal niveau, is een belangrijk element van de inclusieve samenleving, die elke inwoner de kans geeft mee te beslissen over de eigen directe omgeving. Bottom-up participatieve democratie versterkt de representatieve parlementaire democratie.</em></strong> Controle over de sociale media ligt niet langer in handen van de CEOs van grote Mediabedrijven, maar komt onder democratische controle te staan, waarbij elke persoon de volledige zeggenschap krijgt over de eigen privé-gegevens.</p><p><em>Thera van Osch, World House, Wetten (Duitsland). 31 Januari 2021</em></p><h3>Voetnoten en literatuurbronnen</h3><p>[1] Onder de <strong>4e Industriële Revolutie (4IR) </strong>verstaan we de transformatie van bedrijfsprocessen door toepassing van de nieuwste technologieën om de efficiency, de flexibiliteit, en winstgevendheid te vergroten. Het gaat om toepassing door de hele waardeketen van combinaties van nieuwe technologieën, waaronder: a) <strong>Kunstmatige intelligentie (AI — Artificial Intelligence):</strong> een technologie waarbij machines op basis van een grote hoeveelheid data en analyses kunnen redeneren, begrijpen, plannen, leren en denken als mensen; b) <strong>Robotisering:</strong> taken van mensen worden overgenomen door robots; c) <strong>Internet of Things (IOT):</strong> dingen die met internet zijn verbonden en gegevens kunnen versturen, zoals de GSM in de auto die de weg wijst, de smart phone, de slimme koelkast die de boodschappenlijst doorgeeft aan AH; d) <strong>3D-printing:</strong> de machine die onderdelen en producten op maat produceert; e) <strong>Blockchain:</strong> een open technologie voor databases met gedecentraliseerde controle door het systeem. Alle computers verbonden met de blockchain controleren en registreren elke transactie op juistheid. De technologie wordt gebruikt voor overdracht van crypto-currency (bijv. Bitcoin), van waardepapieren, of data, en maakt centrale controle op transacties overbodig; f) <strong>Genetische manipulatie:</strong> het manipuleren van het DNA van planten, dieren en mensen om de soort te verbeteren; g) <strong>Virtual Reality (VR</strong>): deelnemen aan een virtuele realiteit die door de computer is gecreëerd, bijv. virtueel uittesten van operaties; h) <strong>Aumented Reality (AR):</strong> de computer vult de echte wereld aan met virtuele realiteit, zoals hologrammen van personen; i) <strong>Quantum Computing:</strong> Het gelijktijdig verwerken van verschillende variabelen en scenarios met intelligente en krachtige computers, die duizelingwekkende hoeveelheden van data en informatie met grote snelheid analyseren en vergelijken. De verwachting is dat AI gaat versnellen zodra deze technologie beschikbaar is</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[2]</a> Hermann Gossen (1810–1858) formuleerde <strong>de Eerste Wet van Gossen</strong> over het afnemend grensnut; bijvoorbeeld als je dorst hebt is het nut van het eerste glas water hoog, het nut van het tweede glas is al lager, en naarmate je meer glazen achter elkaar neemt daalt het grensnut van elk volgend glas. De <strong>Tweede Wet van Gossen </strong>gaat over nivellering van het grensnut, d.w.z. om met een gegeven inkomen een maximaal nut te bereiken zal de consument steeds kiezen tussen producten die dezelfde grensnutwaarde hebben.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[3]</a> Zie ook: Irene van Staveren: Caring for Economics; An Aristotelian Perspective, Delft: Eburon, 1999.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[4]</a> Thaler, R., 2015, <em>Misbehaving; The Making of Behavioral Economics </em>(W.W. Norton&amp; Company) New York/London.</p><p>[5] New Economic Forum, online Davos Meeting, 18–29 January 2021. <a href="https://www.weforum.org/events/the-davos-agenda-2021/programme">https://www.weforum.org/events/the-davos-agenda-2021/programme</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[6]</a> Johnson, Lauren, (2018), <em>The US Department of Housing and Urban Development is blaming Facebook for ‘unlawful’ advertising tactics</em>, In: Business Insider, 18 August 2018. <a href="https://www.businessinsider.nl/facebook-sued-by-us-department-of-housing-and-urban-developement-over-unlawful-advertising-tactics-2018-8/">https://www.businessinsider.nl/facebook-sued-by-us-department-of-housing-and-urban-developement-over-unlawful-advertising-tactics-2018-8/</a> .</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[7]</a> Zuboff, S. (2019). The age of surveillance capitalism. The fight for the future at the new frontier of power. London: Profile Books.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[8]</a> De Standaard, Economisch Nieuws, België (28–01–2021): <em>Facebook sluit 2020 af met 11 miljard dollar winst</em>. <a href="https://www.standaard.be/cnt/dmf20210128_91572142">https://www.standaard.be/cnt/dmf20210128_91572142</a></p><p>[9] Zuboff, S. (2019), ibid, pag. 87</p><p>[10] Zuboff, S. (2019), ibid, pag. 195</p><p>[11] Zuboff, S. (2019), ibid, pag. 201</p><p>[12] Zuboff, S. (2019), ibid, pag. 319</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[13]</a> Door specialisatie per land en ruil van bijvoorbeeld linnen uit Engeland tegen wijn uit Portugal kunnen beide landen een kostenvoordeel behalen, omdat ze efficiënter met arbeidstijd omgaan.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[14]</a> Heinrich Gossen, 1854: Entwicklung der Gesetze des menslichen Verkehrs und der daraus fliessenden Reglen für menschliches Handeln. Hij was de eerste die de subjectieve waardeleer uitwerkte (zie voetnoot 1). Sinds 19e eeuw wordt de subjectieve waardeleer verder ontwikkeld door neoklassieke economen zoals W.S. Jevons (1835–1882), C. Menger (1841–1921) en L. Walras (1843–1910).</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[15]</a> Een voorbeeld hiervan is Kim Kardashian, die onverbloemd haar levensstijl publiek maakt via internet, en daardoor wereldwijd miljoenen volgers kreeg, waardoor ze een lucratieve online business in cosmetica kon opzetten. Forbes’ deelt Kim Kardashian in bij America’s self-made women, en schat haar Netto Waarde (per 13 oct. 2020) op US$ 780 miljoen. <a href="https://www.forbes.com/profile/kim-kardashian-west/?sh=340a156a41d6">https://www.forbes.com/profile/kim-kardashian-west/?sh=340a156a41d6</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[16]</a> De participatiewet onderscheidt 6 treden van de maatschappelijke ladder. Pas als je een betaalde baan hebt sta je boven op de maatschappelijke ladder: Trede 1 = geïsoleerd; trede 2 = sociale contacten buiten de deur; trede 3 = deelname aan georganiseerde activiteiten; trede 4 = onbetaald werk; trede 5 = betaald werk met ondersteuning; trede 6 = betaalde baan.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[17]</a> Sommige banen verdwijnen door robots. Bedrijven zouden over die robots belasting moeten betalen, zegt Bill Gates. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nccryZOcrUg">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nccryZOcrUg</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[18]</a> Deze situatie is een goede voedingsbodem voor samenzweringstheorieën, zoals ook in andere tijdperken met grote maatschappelijke omwentelingen het geval was.</p><p>[19] <strong>Een stukje geschiedenis: <em>Eind 18e eeuw:</em></strong><em> </em><strong><em>Eerste industriële revolutie</em></strong><em> door uitvinding van de stoommachine, die mens- en dierkracht verving door water- en stoomkracht. </em><strong><em>Eind 19e eeuw:</em></strong><em> </em><strong><em>Tweede industriële revolutie</em></strong><em> door uitvinding van elektriciteit, radio, telegrafie, en opkomst van de olie-industrie, waardoor massaproductie kon ontstaan. </em><strong><em>Eind 20e eeuw:</em></strong><em> </em><strong><em>Derde industriële revolutie</em></strong><em> door ontwikkeling en globalisering van computers, informatie- en communicatietechnologie (ICT). </em><strong><em>Momenteel:</em></strong><em> Ontluiking van de </em><strong><em>Vierde Industriële Revolutie,</em></strong><em> die met een combinatie van nieuwe kunstmatige intelligentie technologieën zal leiden tot een omvangrijke transformatie van de samenleving.</em></p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[20]</a> Betti, F., Enno de Boer, Yve Giraud, (2020), <em>The Fourth Industrial Revolution and manufacturing’s great reset, </em>McKinsey &amp; Company, September 13, 2020. Retrieved from internet January 31, 2021.<em> </em><a href="https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/operations/our-insights/the-fourth-industrial-revolution-and-manufacturings-great-reset?cid=other-eml-alt-mip-mck&amp;hdpid=89d4d171-8c71-477b-8281-fb3482549a15&amp;hctky=11900729&amp;hlkid=42f09df38a1c4a729124b6b5f922adc9"><em>https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/operations/our-insights/the-fourth-industrial-revolution-and-manufacturings-great-reset?cid=other-eml-alt-mip-mck&amp;hdpid=89d4d171-8c71-477b-8281-fb3482549a15&amp;hctky=11900729&amp;hlkid=42f09df38a1c4a729124b6b5f922adc9</em></a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[21]</a> Van Osch, Thera, (2013), Towards a Caring Economic Approach. <a href="https://oqconsulting.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/The-Economy-of-Care.pdf">https://oqconsulting.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/The-Economy-of-Care.pdf</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[22]</a> Momenteel wordt dit geschat op 1,45 hectare productief land en 0,55 hectare zoet water per aardbewoner.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f63d1a22e280" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A new tale about herd mentality]]></title>
            <link>https://thera-vanosch.medium.com/a-new-tale-about-herd-mentality-cf8e348f6be1?source=rss-8b4b03cad76------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cf8e348f6be1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tales]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fake-news]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[herd-mentality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thera Van Osch]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Oct 2020 16:28:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-17T16:28:53.401Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-9hagyAFhFM8nvgZfj9crg.jpeg" /></figure><p>The herd gallops through the forest. The thunder of their hooves can be heard from afar. They follow the herd’s king in the front, who is chasing the enemy, the bad enemy, that must be conquered to make the herd great again. The king knows where the enemy is, and the herd just follows him.</p><p>Then a strange object appears and the king roars “<em>Stop!!!</em>” Silence in the forest. The king observes the strange tall rusted iron object that stands against a big tree. “<em>I swear it’s from the enemy!</em>” he bellows. He turns to his followers looking them in the eyes one by one enforcing their loyalty and trying to spot any traitors who might have something to do with this strange object. “<em>I swear it’s from the enemy!</em>”, he repeats with a deep dark voice. “<em>They are trying to block us. They think they can stop us…</em>” he explains with a mysterious tone in his voice. The herd is paralysed, staring at the king and waiting for his orders. They watch the king standing there in front of the strange object. He is brave. He is not afraid of the object.</p><p>The king smashes the big thing on the ground, takes it in his mouth and starts fighting with it. He fights and fights against the big stick, growling and shaking his head up and down to get it under his control. The flock cheers and admires the king’s bravery. With the stick in his mound, the king moves towards the middle of the herd and continues fighting with the stick, showing how powerful and strong he is. He shakes his head up and down again and spins around while sniffing with anger at the thing in his mouth. The stick moves wildly through the air, hitting the heads of the followers around, many got a bump on their head, several followers are badly injured, some are smashed on the ground, and a few don’t survive.</p><p>While the king keeps on fighting with the stick, the number of deaths in the herd increases. Some followers wonder what to do. Should they leave the herd to save their live? The herd’s cheers are slowly fading out. The king stops fighting and drops the strange object from his mouth, calling it “<em>disgusting</em>” as it doesn’t fight back. He looks around. He sees the dead bodies and the injured heads of his followers. Standing in the middle of the herd he shouts “<em>It is the enemy’s fault that so many of you have been killed by this strange object! The enemy is guilty. They put this object here!</em>”</p><p>He explains “<em>I have saved many lives by fighting the stick</em>”, and adds: “<em>If I hadn’t fought with this object, it could have fallen down on the herd, and would have killed many more of you. The enemy’s fault!</em>” He tells the herd about his feelings when he was fighting with the strange object. The herd listens obediently to what he has to say. “<em>I did it for you, for the herd!</em>” he swears. And he proclaims that the object didn’t hit him, “<em>because I am so strong and powerful!</em>” The herd is happy again. This is the king they want to have, a true hero, who sacrifices himself and struggles to save their lives, a saviour king. While the herd is cheering enthusiastically again to their saviour, the king roars “<em>We will win! Follow me and we will be great again!</em>” … and the herd continues galloping through the forest, leaving the dead bodies behind, and following their roaring saviour king straight to the abyss.</p><p>17–10–2020</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cf8e348f6be1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The World’s Wealth]]></title>
            <link>https://thera-vanosch.medium.com/the-worlds-wealth-39bb696986c6?source=rss-8b4b03cad76------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/39bb696986c6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[globalization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender-equality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thera Van Osch]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 27 Jun 2020 15:28:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-27T15:28:25.714Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Manifesto for a new economic order that cares for people and the planet</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/425/1*1OGMJVh7-FYdEOvaG-RvlQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>This manifesto highlights some truths revealed during the COVID-19 lockdown that show that the old patterns of economic thinking no longer match the world in which we now live. It advocates for leaving the old patterns of economic thinking behind, and for constructing a new human rights-based and inclusive economic model that cares for people and the planet.</strong></p><p>One of the deeper insights from the COVID-19 lockdown is that the paradigms and suppositions of current economic thinking are outdated. The basic foundations of our neoliberal economic model were set down in Western Europe between the 17th and 19th centuries, a period of early industrialization and the building of nation states. It was an economy dominated by a patriarchal elite and globalized through colonialization and the transatlantic slave trade. Universal human rights were not an issue at that time. In that context the patterns of economic thinking designed by the founding fathers of economic theory to overcome the feudal society in Western Europe were revolutionary for their times, but now they are out of date. These obsolete patterns of economic thinking are harmful for humanity and the planet when used as the basis of economic policies. The esoteric econometric models nowadays used by economists consist apparently of value-free and neutral formulas about production, consumption, investment, prices, interest, economic growth etc. However, the centuries-old paradigms, assumptions and patterns of thinking behind these mathematical equations are no longer questioned. In fact, they are repeated unconsciously.</p><p>The economic lockdown is the perfect opportunity for a change in economic thinking, and for leaving the old patterns behind. This manifesto lists some of these insights and outlines first steps towards a strategy for change.</p><h4><strong>The paradigm of the <em>homo economicus</em></strong></h4><p>Our current society has been modelled and consolidated according to a selective market-centred point of view of neoliberal economics. This approach reduces human relations mainly to transactional exchanges, which in turn are justified by the paradigm of the <em>homo economicus</em> — a theoretical construction of a one-dimensional, rational economic man in search of maximum satisfaction of his needs at minimum cost, devoid of human emotions. This image of human beings is the cornerstone of the theoretical foundation of neoliberal economics, the starting point of neoclassic market theory and one of the implicit principles of all neoclassic economic thinking and its corresponding neoliberal policies. Epistemologically the paradigm of the <em>homo economicus</em> is derived from utilitarianism — an ethical theory stemming from the late 18th and 19th centuries. The question is: How realistic it this paradigm of human nature?</p><p>The behaviour and attitude of the majority of the population that became visible during the COVID-19 economic lockdown is the complete opposite of the image of <em>homo economicus</em>. Instead of rational, calculating behaviour, we see people concerned for one another, who take responsibility to save lives, who are committed and attentive, and express their feelings of love, affection, warm-heartedness, friendship, esteem and tenderness to overcome this crisis together. The lockdown released deeply rooted intrinsic human values of care, mutual support and solidarity to face the situation and keep society going. Thousands of examples are shared on social media, including maintaining physical distance to protect the health of all, singing from balconies, food distribution, volunteering in the care sector, and collective applause for health care workers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mVd4Km3t227B3_41X5ytHg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Caring Human Being — My happy neighbour with his baby (Germany, summer 2019)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>It is high time that the ‘caring human being’ receives a place in the economic model and is rewarded accordingly. The new economic model must ensure that every man, woman and transgender person on Earth has the right to provide and receive care. All forms of care, whether paid or unpaid, must be recognized and valued in terms of human wealth, which reflects physical and mental health. Investing time and money in people, such as through education and health care, must no longer be conceived as a public cost, but as growth in human wealth.</strong></p><h4><strong>The assumption of ‘consumption units’</strong></h4><p>Households are considered ‘consumption units’ — mainly relevant for creating demand in the economic model. The biggest blind spot in this economic theory is the total invisibility of the magnitude of all unpaid life-supporting care and domestic work, although the number of working hours in the unpaid sector is higher than those in all paid sectors combined.</p><p>Since the late 19th century, economists have focused on explaining economic values of services and products that are sold on the market against a certain price in terms of money. With the advancement of industrialization, artisans and people making handicrafts from home became industrial workers in factories, leading to a separation of home and workplace, and a division of work between women and men. A system of gender apartheid was created in which women were supposed to stay at home doing unpaid work for the daily and generational reproduction of workers, whereas men worked outside the home for a wage. This economic dualism still exists.</p><p>Globally, women still perform 76.2% of the total hours of unpaid care work — more than three times as much as men. The idea of the household as a consumption unit, based on a traditional breadwinner model, is still hidden in the assumptions of mainstream econometric models, and used as a basis for economic policies, although a minority of the population lives in such a situation.</p><p>With the economic lockdown, almost the entire economic system has had to fall back on households, showing that they are more than ‘consumption units’; they represent society’s basic life-sustaining, home-based care system. Thanks to the adaptability and resilience of the home-based economy, people can stay indoors and take over a huge amount of work from the monetary economy.</p><p>Thanks to social media, the unpaid care economy has become more visible, showing clear evidence that it is the biggest and most resilient sector for life-sustaining work in the economy. This is the place where new generations are born, where children grow up receiving pedagogic support from their parents, and where women assume more than two-thirds of the domestic work, including cleaning, cooking, dishwashing, shopping and organizing social and community activities. Since the closure of schools and nurseries, parents have taken on care 24/7 and helped their children with their homework. More people at home means an increase in household chores. Due to overburdened hospitals and medical care centres, more unpaid care work is being done for sick people at home.</p><p>The home-based economy is, however, more than domestic and unpaid care work for generational and daily reproduction of human life. It is also a production unit. In rural areas and in less industrialized countries we see home-based farms and micro-enterprises producing and selling at local markets. Globally, the digital revolution enables decentralization of working processes, and has created new opportunities for home-based production and service delivery in a great variety of jobs, including online shops, training and coaching, administrative work, translation of documents, customer services, helpdesks, desktop research and journalism. Many of these jobs are created by self-employed women and men.</p><p>Centralized companies and governmental institutions have now been challenged by the COVID-19 crisis to transform their rigid structures by allowing their employees to work from home, and by conducting their meetings through video-conferencing. As a result, the home-based economy has absorbed a tremendous additional number of employees, who have to stay indoors and work from home during the lockdown. <em>The old pattern of separation of home and workplace initiated during early industrialization has disappeared during the lockdown of COVID-19.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vs86YDZ2FYp1NKQjyWp8nQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Old factory from early industrailisation</figcaption></figure><p>Extra advantages of the lockdown are that people with jobs in urban areas are spending less time travelling to and from work, traffic jams have disappeared during rush hours, air pollution has fallen in urban areas, stillness in the cities is calming people down, there is more time for private life, society is becoming more relaxed, and nature is returning in cities.</p><p>Additionally, the home-based economy is becoming creative and innovative in many ways, such as inventing new products and performing do-it-yourself repairs around the house, singing and making music together at home, sharing poems online, painting, writing and creating video entertainment on the Internet.</p><p>This reality contrasts sharply with the one-dimensional vision of neoliberal market theory that assumes that households are only relevant as consumption units. The neoliberal economic model does not count the procreation of new generations or unpaid life-supporting care and domestic work. It is all taken for granted. It has no value in the economic system. It is not taken into consideration in economic policies.</p><p>Nevertheless, <em>the entire economic system relies on this life-sustaining economic care system, which has been revitalized since the lockdown, whereas the formal, recognized economy was pulverized in just a couple of weeks and could not stay alive without receiving billions of dollars/euros in bailouts.</em></p><p><strong>The economic shutdown imposed by governments to reduce the spread of COVID-19 has disclosed unexpected new perspectives on the future of households.</strong> <strong>Instead of ignoring the multifunctional life-sustaining, home-based economic system, and reducing it to a one-dimensional consumption unit, the new economic order must recognize, revalue and include the home-based economy as the basis for the market economy in a new comprehensive economic model. <em>Investments in social infrastructure to support the home-based economy contribute to human health and wealth; therefore, they are not a cost in the future economic model, but a benefit that contributes to the quality of life.</em> One of the new indicators of the future economy should be the paid-unpaid-work quote (PUW-Quote) as a tool for the fair distribution of paid and unpaid work. The future social security system must include universal basic income to strengthen the financial basis of the home-based economy.</strong></p><h4><strong>The consolidation of inequalities by the current economic model</strong></h4><p>The COVID-19 lockdown makes the structural violation of universal human rights by our economic system more visible. First of all, it has aggravated the structural segregation of the labour market: women, migrants, minorities and other marginalized groups in society make up the majority of those employed in precarious low-paid jobs without social security or career prospects. These jobs offer no more than survival, and these workers have no reserves to fall back on in times of crisis. <em>These inequalities and traditional gender roles resulting from old patterns of patriarchy and slavery that lead to discrimination, exclusion and stereotyping have grown sharper during the lockdown.</em></p><p>A second manifestation of a structural human rights violation which has been exacerbated in all countries during the lockdown is the increase in violence against women and children in domestic settings. For centuries, no attention has been paid to the unequal balance of power in the home situation. The traditional breadwinner model, where the man is the boss because he brings in the money, reflects the power relations in the economy, where decision-making power rests with investors and shareholders who have money at their disposal. Violence against women and children is the way in which power relations are maintained in the traditional patriarchal, absolutist home model.</p><p>A third group of people disproportionally affected are the precarious and informal workers with less access to health care who have fallen further into poverty during the lockdown. <em>In the USA, African-Americans and Latin Americans have been the worst affected, as they are often poorly insured for health care due to their precarious jobs, or even if they have proper health insurance, they have less access to the overburdened health care system due to entrenched discriminatory prejudices and stigmas.</em> The number of CONVID-19 deaths among these ethnic groups is disproportionately high in the USA.</p><p>Fourth, the crisis shows that the <em>hardest-hit groups worldwide are people living in slums, shanty towns and in refugee camps with inhumane housing, and homeless people</em>. In poor areas the lockdown increases the risks of the poorest of dying from hunger. The economic system doesn’t provide any security to these groups. They are at the mercy of charity and solidarity because they have nothing to fall back on, they are poorly informed about what is going on and what to do, and they have limited options for physical distancing, handwashing and using face masks.</p><p>Lastly, due to structural gender discrimination in the health care sector, women are the ones who are most exposed to the virus. They dominate in the lower-paid jobs doing most of the hands-on work in direct contact with the patients, whereas men dominate in the decision-making jobs at greater distance from the patients. In quarantine at home, women are also the ones who are spending the most time taking care of sick family members. Given the high level of exposure of women to the virus due to their gender role, it is a blessing in disguise that they have a lower likelihood of dying from COVID-19 than men, probably due to their biological strength.</p><p>Access to health care is a human right, and a healthy population is a precondition of any economy in any nation state. This might sound obvious, but in our economic system it is taken for granted. Health as such has no economic value in our neoliberal economic model. Absence of health, however, is considered a cost, a negative value, which affects gross domestic product (GDP). Workers who are ill either cannot produce or have low productivity, which may affect the company’s profits. In this way of economic thinking, medical treatment and health care are considered costs for society that must remain low. This is reflected in the low salaries of workers in the professional health care sector, in the cuts in public expenditure for health care in times of economic recession, and in the tremendous scope of home- and community-based unpaid health care work, which is completely ignored in the neoliberal economic model.</p><p>Since the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), all human beings are considered to be born free and equal in dignity and rights, without distinction of any kind, such as race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth or other status. The COVID-19 crisis shows that our current economic system doesn’t guarantee equal rights for all. The reality shows that discrimination, marginalisation, and inequality, in particular gender inequality, are deeply ingrained in our economic model, and increases during times of crisis.</p><p>The economic model doesn’t have checks and balances to promote equal rights. Instead, it consolidates existing inequalities, which have been exacerbated during the COVID-19 crisis. The following points need attention to anchor human rights and gender equality in the future economic model:</p><p>● Any future economic system should be organized in a way that guarantees equal rights to public services, including access to quality health care. The availability of health care must be integrated into the economic system as a human right and as a function of human need, and not as a public cost dependent on GDP.</p><p>● The right to social security must be incorporated into the economic system to ensure the right to life for every human being in the world. This right is not guaranteed by the current neoliberal economic model.</p><p>● The rights to work, to free choice of employment, to just and favourable conditions of work, to equal pay for equal work, and to protection against unemployment are not being realized in the current economic system. The old patterns of stigmatization, discrimination and stereotyping lead to unfair exclusion and to social segregation in work, income and decision-making.</p><p>● Our economic system should ensure the rights of working people to just and favourable remuneration, to rest and leisure, including a reasonable limit on working hours, and to a standard of living adequate for their health and well-being. The neoliberal economic model does not put these fundamental human rights into practice; it even ignores the tremendous volume of unpaid work carried out in the life-sustaining home-based economic system.</p><p><strong>The post-COVID-19 economic model must be a human rights-based model and must include human wealth as one of its dimensions. It should pursue growth in human wealth by investing time and money in healthy life expectancy, human rights and quality of life for all. <em>Universal basic income</em> must be a first step to create an equal economic base, to ensure the economic independence of all women and men, enhance equal rights for social security, create an equal starting position for all, facilitate a free choice of employment and work for all people in their rich diversity, and create a more relaxed society. In the future economy, all work should be counted, recognized and supported, whether paid or unpaid. Access to health care is a human right for all and must be engrained in the economic model; time and money spent on health care should be defined as contributions to the growth of human wealth.</strong></p><h4><strong>The assumptions of the current economic model that destroy natural wealth</strong></h4><p>The COVID-19 lockdown has had a greater impact than all climate conferences and all emissions trading of the past years combined. In just a couple of weeks, the economic lockdown has cleared the skies, the air and the rivers all over the world, showing the wealth of nature and its resilience. It has proved that we are able to act for climate change in a short time span, and to create conditions for nature to recover from the devastating impact of our economic system.</p><p>Nature, biodiversity and the fragile balance of our ecological system are taken for granted and have no value in our economic model. For example, the air we breathe has no economic value, as it has no price in the market, because it is not scarce; therefore, it doesn’t contribute to the national income. It doesn’t matter for the economy that the air or the rivers are contaminated. Only if clean air became scarce and we had to buy fresh air in bottles for our survival would it contribute to the national income. Extinct species are not scarce in economic terms unless they have a potential market value. This perverse conception of natural wealth originated in economic thought at the time of colonization, and it has been submerged in our current neoliberal economic model.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*x-OiMNW3XoqPwQUcSxZ5TA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The river, the wood, and the quality of the air as such have no economic value in the current economic model. Only the stuf produced by the factory to be sold at the market, is counted in the Gross Domestic Product.</figcaption></figure><p>For the neoliberal economy, nature as such has no value. Nature is only interesting if it has the potential to create market values, such as the exploitation of raw materials, fields where oil or gas can be extracted, forests that can be cut to make furniture, or fields that can be used for cash crops. This economic assumption considers nature as the sum of resources which only have (potential) value if it can be turned into money. This economic view of nature derives from the centuries-old pattern of colonization when the world was exploited and deprived of raw materials by Western European nations.</p><p>The COVID-19 crisis has shown us that the health of people and the health of the planet are intrinsically related; they are the things that really matter, as they constitute the basis of the economy.</p><p>Environmental rights should replace the old pattern of economic thinking about nature. This means that a future economic model should protect and promote natural wealth, consisting of the ecological system of the dynamic living planet with its oceans, rivers, forests, deserts, swamps, ponds, grasslands, wetlands, lakes, coasts and mountainous regions; with its rich vegetation that varies through the seasons and from place to place; and with trillions of livings creatures, all kinds of animals, swimming in the waters, flying in the sky or moving on the land of our planet. All economic activity should be aligned and in harmony with natural wealth. This can be achieved in different ways, and many initiatives have already been taken to initiate this process, including circular economy, energy transition, less traffic and more home-based work, putting in practice the donut economy at local level, transition towns, and putting in practice the Sustainable Development Goals.</p><p><strong>Environmental rights can only be ensured if we act locally and think globally. A paradigm shift in economic thinking is required for the incorporation of environmental rights into the economic models that are used by governments to define their macro-economic policies. Respect for environmental rights should become a precondition for economic activity.</strong></p><h4><strong>The current economic model is hindering international solidarity and a global response</strong></h4><p>Current economic models are designed for the country level, each with their GDP, national accounting system and national balance of payments. The economic thinking in national economies repeats an old pattern that started with the early economic thinkers living in Europe in the 16th and 17th centuries. During this period, European states developed an economic policy focused on promoting a positive trade balance and increasing the state’s gold reserves. This period is called ‘mercantilism’ in the history of economic theory. It was characterized by protectionism of the nation’s own industries, strengthening of the power of the absolutist monarchist state, and trade wars between nations through naval battles between merchant ships that were increasingly equipped as warships. Political changes have taken place since then, replacing monarchist absolutism with democracy; however, in economics the basic patterns of nation-based economic thinking have been maintained over the centuries, and have led to numerous wars.</p><p>The strong nationalistic sentiments in Western European countries during the 18th and 19th centuries remained ingrained in the theories of later economic thinkers that influenced our current economic models, including the classic (1780–1860) and the neoclassic (1870–present) economic schools. Even nowadays, the neoliberal economic model is still focused on strengthening the nation’s competitiveness and national economic growth as the main goals of economic activity. This creates an unfavourable environment for international solidarity and mutual cooperation on equal terms among states. There is no economic model that goes beyond national borders and sees the world as a whole. Although free trade is promoted among the nations, the world economy remains the sum of national economies.</p><p>The COVID-19 pandemic shows that there are no borders and that we are all connected. In fact, the world has always been globalized. Nature is a globalized ecological system that connects all life on Earth, and that is connected to the universe as a whole. The Earth is one planet — not a globe subdivided into countries. Countries are created by people as a result of struggles for power, wars, colonialization and political deals. In economic terms, borders are mainly created to exercise control over the inhabitants, mostly at the benefit of a minority in power, whereas practically the whole of the rest of the economy is globalized, including supply chains, transnational financial markets and borderless digital communication, information streams and e-commerce. However, we don’t have a global economic model. Only multinationals act globally — by playing cleverly with the national economies to obtain the most favourable tax situation, which is not in favour of humanity as a whole.</p><p>To address the current global challenges, including climate change, human health and the economic crisis, we need a global economic system that allows countries to work together in solidarity to create an enabling environment for the world’s wealth. The future global economic model should find a balance between three dimensions of wealth: natural wealth, human wealth and economic wealth.</p><p>The COVID-19 crisis has liberated the world for a while from the patterns of economic thinking that have been in force over the centuries since the early capitalism in Western Europe. We are now in the middle of a worldwide reset of the economy. It’s time for a historic break in economic thinking. <em>The economic lockdown has provided some insights into our obsolete economic system, with its hindering structures and out-of-date patterns,</em> and it provides new perspectives for economic approaches that are better for people and for the planet.</p><p>G<em>oing back to the past and restoring the old, unsustainable economic system, which systematically violates human rights, blocks gender equality, maintains discrimination, and destroys the environment, is no longer an option</em>. Nevertheless, governments are currently providing billions of dollars/euros to restore an old economy that collapsed in just a couple of months. The bill for this operation is being shifted onto future generations, who will have to pay the heavy burden in taxes, which is unfair, particularly because they also have to deal with the consequences of climate change.</p><p>The new reality created by COVID-19 is an opportunity to create a new economic model, which means <em>building a sustainable, inclusive economy based on new principles and values, including environmental rights, human rights, gender equality and the right to receive and give care. A cornerstone of the new global economic model is universal basic income. </em>Investing in basic income will boost bottom-up social and economic innovation, and strengthen the life-sustaining home-based economy that has been shown to be vital and resilient even in times of economic lockdown.</p><p><strong>It requires bold decisions to revitalize the world economy in a sustainable and human-rights-based way without restoring dirty industries and without passing debts onto future generations. New paradigms, principles, assumptions, values and goals have to be defined for a new economic model, a global model, in which each country plays its particular role. New indicators have to be defined to measure the world’s wealth in terms of natural wealth, human wealth and economic wealth. Global solidarity is now more needed then ever. Alignment of national policies with the sustainable development goals (SDGs) is an important step to create a facilitating environment for promoting a new economic model that cares for people and the planet.</strong></p><p>Thera van Osch,</p><p>OQ Consulting, <a href="http://www.oqconsulting.eu/">http://www.oqconsulting.eu</a></p><p>World House Wetten, Germany, 9 Mai 2020</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=39bb696986c6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The gender impact of COVID-19]]></title>
            <link>https://thera-vanosch.medium.com/the-gender-impact-of-covid-19-99b8208174ae?source=rss-8b4b03cad76------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/99b8208174ae</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[basic-income]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coronavirus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[caring]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thera Van Osch]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Jun 2020 10:56:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-08T10:56:11.627Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>How to move to an economy that cares for people and the planet</strong></p><p><em>Thera van Osch, 25 March 2020.</em></p><p><em>This article raises some questions about how the COVID-19 crisis affects women and men differently. It reveals the key role of the care sector, referring to both paid and unpaid care work, and women’s specific roles and risks during the crisis. The article reviews some measures taken by governments to slow down the spread of the virus, and the impact of these measures on women, men and the environment. The central message is that the COVID-19 crisis is a wake-up call for all of us. It’s time for a change. We cannot fall back on the old structures of an economic model that is obsolete for the challenges ahead in terms of climate change, gender equality and human rights for all.</em></p><p><strong>Why are more men dying of Coronavirus than women?</strong></p><p>Coronavirus does not discriminate. Everyone runs the same risk of being affected by the virus without distinction by sex, age, nationality, identity, social class, ethnicity or religion. However, there is a gendered gap in terms of death: the risk of dying is clearly higher for men than for women. In Italy the ratio of men to women is 80:20, with an older median age for women (83.4 years) than for men (79.9 years).<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a> It is true that more than two thirds of these patients had diabetes, cardiovascular diseases or cancer, or were former smokers, but without the Coronavirus infection they would not have died. In China research shows that men and women have been infected in roughly equal numbers; however, almost 65% of the people who died were men. The death rate among men was 2.8%, compared to 1.7% among women (Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, February 2020).<a href="#_ftn2">[2]</a></p><p>Broadly speaking, there are two reasons why fewer women than men die after being infected with Coronavirus. The first is a biological reason: empirical evidence has shown that women have stronger immune systems.<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a> The second is a lifestyle reason: men’s lifestyles are often different, and in general they smoke and drink more than women, which is a learned behaviour of what ‘real’ men are supposed to do. This gender-stereotyping increases the risk factors among men.</p><p><strong>Are women more exposed to Coronavirus?</strong></p><p>Nurses, carers and cleaners are key professions in the survival strategy against the corona virus, and the majority of them are low-paid or unpaid women.</p><p>All over the world women comprise the majority of workers in the health sector. Women represent 70% of workers in the health and social sectors.<a href="#_ftn4">[4]</a> Nurses are working around the clock on hospital front lines. They are the true heroes in the fight against this virus, risking their own health as they are disproportionally exposed to infected patients. Additionally, most care workers in the social sector are also women. They care for pre-school children in nurseries, and for elderly people in retirement homes, and they visit people of all ages in need of care, including persons with disabilities and sick people who are at home. With the Coronavirus outbreak there is an increasing appeal to these care workers to support infected people at home.</p><p>At the moment we are in the middle of the outbreak at global level, and only limited snapshots are available of the number of workers in the health and social sectors who are infected by the virus; these are not always disaggregated by sex. Given the vertical gender segregation of the health sector, women dominate in the lower-paid jobs doing most of the hands-on work in direct contact with the patients, whereas men dominate in the decision-making jobs at greater distance from the patients. Although there is no empirical evidence yet, there is growing concern that women in these sectors will be disproportionately infected by Coronavirus.<a href="#_ftn5">[5]</a></p><p><strong>Access to health and reproductive rights</strong></p><p>No country is sufficiently prepared for an exponential outbreak such as this pandemic. Health systems are overburdened. There is a lack of health workers, and a lack of medical materials for tests, of protective clothing, of hospital beds, of ventilators for respiratory support and, particularly, a lack of intensive care units. Health workers in intensive care units are making over-hours, facing lack of supplies and many get infected and must stay in quarantine themselves after being exposed. They will not only become overburdened but will also face moral dilemmas when they have to decide who will be given priority and who will have to be denied life-saving intensive care. The question is: are these decisions unconsciously influenced by stereotyped opinions about women and men in all their diversity?</p><p>As the virus spreads, the lack of hospital beds and medical facilities increases. In several countries all unnecessary medical procedures have been postponed to give priority to corona patients. In some cases, these measures are used to undermine women’s reproductive rights. For example, in Texas and Ohio, nearly all abortions are labelled as non-essential procedures that must be delayed. “In Texas, providers can be fined or jailed for violating the order.”<a href="#_ftn6">[6]</a> Politicians in Texas and Ohio are using the corona-crisis to undermine abortion rights, which are already rather restrictive in these states.</p><p><strong>The unpaid care economy: the resilient cushion of the crisis</strong></p><p>By far the largest sector of the economy is the unpaid care sector. The work consists of taking care of children and sick family members, facilitating life for elderly people or family members with a disability, managing the home (shopping, cleaning, cooking, washing clothes etc.) and providing long-term unpaid support to the community of friends, neighbours, (ex-)colleagues and other acquaintances who have a disability or suffer from chronic illness. This unpaid support to the community is estimated to be at least four times larger than the professional care sector.<a href="#_ftn7">[7]</a></p><p>Unpaid care work is mainly assigned to women. Globally, women perform 76.2% of the total hours of unpaid care work — more than three times as much as men.<a href="#_ftn8">[8]</a> However, these unpaid working hours are ignored in the neo-liberal economic model of our times; not valued, not included in economic statistics, and never taken into account in any macroeconomic policy, they are just taken for granted. Throughout history, the economy of care has always existed, functioning as a buffer for economic crisis in the capitalist system, working as a placenta feeding the market economy and the State, but never acknowledged as a basic economic system.</p><p>The policy of ensuring physical distance to avoid the spread of Coronavirus led to the shutdown of industries, public places and events, reducing public transport and international air traffic, sending everyone back home and keeping infected persons quarantined indoors. The market and the State were unable to solve this problem and had to appeal to the social responsibility and mutual care of the population. As a result, the entire economy falls back on the unpaid care economy, the area of the economic system that is built on the unpaid work of generations of women and that has been completely ignored in our economic model.</p><p>In every country affected by Coronavirus we see people taking responsibility, acting in solidarity, creating joy by singing together from their balconies, caring for themselves and, where possible, caring for others who need help. It shows that care is one of the deeply rooted, universal human values that manifests in times of profound crisis, and keeps society going under the most extreme circumstances.</p><p>Caring economics refers to an economy that cares for people and cares for the planet. It builds on the concept of care as defined by Joan Tronto, who sees it as an activity that includes “everything that we do to maintain, continue, and repair our ‘world’ so that we can live in it as well as possible. That world includes our bodies, ourselves, our environment, all of which we seek to interweave in a complex, life-sustaining web.”<a href="#_ftn9">[9]</a></p><p>The concept of care refers both to activities in the household or the care sector and to an attitude or moral orientation which expresses specific emotions of inter-relationship among people, such as lovingness, affection, warm-heartedness, friendship, esteem, tenderness, responsibility, concern for someone or something, commitment and attentiveness. Care work is more than an activity that can be expressed in objective criteria such as time or (equivalent) value, as it has an intrinsic human value that refers to the deeper sense of life. The shutdown of the economy creates space to release these intrinsic human values, and to reveal the hidden economy of caring human beings.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mVd4Km3t227B3_41X5ytHg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The caring human being — My happy neighbour with his baby (Summer 2019 in Germany)</figcaption></figure><p>A lot of work in the monetary economy is now being taken over by the unpaid care economy. Schools are closed, so children have to be cared for at home, and parents have to help them do their homework online. More people at home means more domestic work to be done. Restaurants and fast-food shops are closed, so people have to cook more at home. The longer people stay indoors, the more cleaning work has to be done. The more hospitals and medical care centers are overburdened, the more unpaid care work needs to be done for sick people at home. When products or services become scarce in the market or are no longer accessible or available, people become creative and innovative in the caring economy. When theaters and places of entertainment are closed, they start making music at home, singing together from their balconies, making and sharing poems on the internet, painting, writing and entertaining each other on the internet. If they cannot buy the stuff they need, due to a lack of money or because it is no longer available in the shops, they become innovative and start producing alternative products at home. If they cannot pay a carpenter for repairs to their house, or if the carpenter is in quarantine, they find their own solutions. The unpaid care economy is taking over the key functions of the economy and keeping society going.</p><p>The question is whether the increased presence of men at home will also lead to their taking on an increased share of the unpaid work. This is a unique situation to involve men and women in redistributing and equally sharing the burden of unpaid domestic and care work.</p><p><strong>How safe is home?</strong></p><p>We must acknowledge that not everyone knows how to make the best of this economic lockdown. The tremendous pressure on people forced to spend 24 hours a day in their home situation, without knowing how long it will last, has a significant impact on people’s mental health. The fear of becoming infected by the virus, the anxiety caused by financial insecurity, the loss of economic income, the disruption to the daily rhythm, the desperate feeling of being lost, of not knowing what to do, the boredom of being locked up at home, all these circumstances may cause serious emotional stress, which can lead to parents and/or children becoming depressed or falling into aggressive behaviour.</p><p>So far there are no data available on the impact of the crisis on domestic violence. Despite all the wonderful examples we see on the internet, there are also increased risks, which makes the home an unsafe place, particularly for women and children. These negative experiences are not widely shared online.</p><p>Statistics show that the home is the most dangerous place for women and children. Before the Coronavirus crisis, the risk of women dying as a consequence of domestic violence by intimate partners or other family members was at least twice as high as the risk of dying as a consequence of Coronavirus. In 2017 a total of 87,000 women were intentionally killed. Around 50,000 (58%) of them were killed by intimate partners or other family members — meaning that 137 women across the world are killed by a member of their own family every day!<a href="#_ftn10">[10]</a> During the first 70 days of the Coronavirus outbreak (from 11 January to 21 March 2020) the Coronavirus death toll was 12,983. This means that globally 185 people died on average per day. Women accounted for 20–35% of deaths, which means between 37 and 65 women on average every day. This is far below the average of 137 women that are daily killed by their intimate partner or other family members.</p><p>The magnitude of violence against children under 18 years is also tremendous. In 2019 the World Health Organization estimated that up to 1 billion children aged 2–17 years experienced physical, sexual or emotional violence or neglect in the past year.<a href="#_ftn11">[11]</a> Experiencing violence in childhood has a lifelong impact on health and well-being. Many parents are unable to handle the stress related to the current situation. Depression and aggression are ways to regulate stress, creating unsafe family situations for children. For example, in the Netherlands the number of children who have called the kids’ telephone — an emergency hotline for children in need of support — has increased, with hundreds of calls per day, since the schools closed and families have been in quarantine.<a href="#_ftn12">[12]</a></p><p>Domestic violence and violence against women and children are the most frequent forms and most underreported cases of violations of human rights. It continues as long as unequal power relations between men and women keep on dominating society — both the caring economy and the market economy — and as long as governments fail to address and prevent this social problem.</p><p>The question is whether the risks of women being killed by their intimate partner or other family members, and the risk of children becoming victims of violence, will increase now that people are isolated or quarantined in their homes to avoid spreading the virus. So far, no data are available on this issue, but it is an urgent political human rights issue that needs to be addressed now.</p><p><strong>The environmental impact of the Coronavirus crisis</strong></p><p>Air quality is improving, saving the lives of many, particularly in the densely populated industrial areas and cities where road transport has reduced and industry has closed down. In terms of reducing air pollution, Coronavirus has achieved more in a couple of months than international summits and agreements on climate change have achieved in the past five years. Since governments took drastic measures that paralysed traffic and market production, there has been an amazing decline in air pollution due to a rapid fall in nitrogen dioxide (NO2), a gas that ends up in the air from burning fuel, primarily from cars, trucks, buses and power plants. As a result, fewer people have suffered from respiratory diseases such as asthma and bronchitis, and more lives have been saved — probably more than the number of lives lost due to Coronavirus.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G3F5V9_k4sF1tuciaVu1jw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Fresh air and blue sky without air stripes or noise from aircafts — thanks to the COVID-19 lockdown</figcaption></figure><p>NASA satellite images show the tremendous reduction in air pollution resulting from the measures taken by China in response to the Coronavirus pandemic.<a href="#_ftn13">[13]</a> Many little children in China saw a blue sky for the first time in their life. On 24 February 2020 the Nikkei staff writer Yusko Cho wrote, “<em>Blue skies return to China as coronavirus cuts coal consumption</em>”.<a href="#_ftn14">[14]</a> Coronavirus brought China’s economy to a standstill, reducing the amount of coal burnt by Chinese electricity companies by a third from the average in 2015. <em>“Government data shows average concentrations of PM2.5 fine particulate matter dropping to their lowest February levels since 2014 in many cities.”</em><a href="#_ftn15">[15]</a> <em>“Nitrogen dioxide (NO2) pollution concentrations over eastern and central China were 10–30 percent lower than what is normally observed over the time period.”</em><a href="#_ftn16">[16]</a></p><p>Marshall Burke calculated the health benefits from this reduced air pollution, coming to the conclusion that the lives of 4,000 children under 5 and 73,000 adults over 70 have been saved in China due to the reduced pollution, which is much more than the lives lost due to Coronavirus in the country.<a href="#_ftn17">[17]</a></p><p>Not only in China but worldwide, air pollution is decreasing, and the planet is becoming healthier where measures are taken to flatten the curve of Coronavirus incidence. It shows that governments are able to take drastic measures for climate change. Greta Thunberg’s call to “Act Now!” can no longer be criticised as being unrealistic. Coronavirus has forced governments to act now. What we can do to reduce the impact of Coronavirus, we can also do to reduce the impact of CO2 emissions on climate change. The evidence has now been provided.</p><p>Less air pollution will reduce the incidence of respiratory diseases and the anxiety of patients suffering from chronic respiratory illnesses. The gender impact will be positive, as it reduces unpaid care work, which is mostly performed by women who care for people with chronic diseases. It will also reduce medical costs. The well-being of both patients and their family members and friends will increase, which will benefit their capacity to contribute to social and economic development.</p><p>Less traffic means that there is less danger for children to play outside or to walk in the streets. It reduces the time required by parents — most often mothers — to keep children inside the home or to continuously monitor their safety when playing outside. Particularly in areas with heavy traffic, the safety of children playing outside has increased, and women’s unpaid care burdens have decreased, due to the measures that reduced road transport.</p><p><strong>Reorganization of work</strong></p><p>Many offices, companies and institutions have started to transform their organization to enable their employees to work from home.</p><p>Women’s organizations in several countries have been claiming for at least two decades that reorganization, flexible working times and teleworking are needed to reduce time lost in traffic jams at rush hour and to enable workers to better combine their jobs with care responsibilities. In particular, administrative work, research, policy development, training, helpdesk services, customer services, meetings and many other tasks can be organized in a decentralized way with online communication. The Coronavirus crisis is finally forcing companies, offices and institutions to create conditions that allow their employees to work from home. Of course, this is not possible for all jobs, but at least some of the jobs in any company could be done from home.</p><p>Employees who start to work from home for the first time in their life also have to learn how to reorganize their home situation to create the right space and time to carry out their job effectively.</p><p>The current crisis opens the mind for alternative approaches, new forms of organization and decentralized business models. It challenges the assumptions of traditional chief executive officers with regard to their subordinates, as they have to trust that their workers are able and willing to do a good job from home without the controlling presence of their boss behind them.</p><p>This experience is a learning lesson for CEOs, managers, employees and politicians. It shows we can transform rigid economic structures in a short space of time, and create new structures that are flexible and better attuned to women and men who have to combine a job with family responsibilities. Such a transformation is an important aspect of policies to promote equal opportunities for women and men, as it contributes to creating an enabling environment for the redistribution of paid and unpaid work between women and men. It also creates better conditions for persons with disabilities who prefer to work from home.</p><p>Decentralization is also taking place in the education system. Since schools, universities, academies and training centres are closed during the Coronavirus crisis, classes are continuing online, and new forms of communication are being set up between teachers, pupils and students. This transformation of the education system may contribute to the creation of innovative methods for permanent education and distance learning. In times of worldwide migration, such online educations systems can become very helpful to keep all boys and girls of migrant families on board.</p><p>We should continue this transformative process after the Coronavirus crisis, and try to prevent organizations falling back into the old, rigid hierarchical structures that have been harmful to the planet and to people’s equal opportunities.</p><p><strong>The economic effects of the crisis</strong></p><p>The workforce that is hit first and most by the crisis are the self-employed, freelance and informal workers who have no financial buffer to fall back on. It is a highly diverse workforce, active in all sectors of the economy, and comprising women and men of all ages and from a great variety of backgrounds, including visible minorities, migrants and refugees.</p><p>They are the most flexible workforce of the economy, working mainly at their own risk. They function like the transmission oil of the economic machine, responding to any demand; jumping into emergency situations; finding solutions for uncommon problems; providing ideas, advice and training; and assuming any type of work that is being outsourced by the rigid structures of the economy.</p><p>Under normal circumstances, it is the most flexible, most creative and innovative part of the economy which functions as a regulator of economic fluctuations. Together with the unpaid sector, this part of the economy is highly resilient. However, their access to formal social security systems is limited, and they often work in precarious circumstances with fluctuating incomes.</p><p>The creation of an unconditional basic income for this group during the Coronavirus crisis is one of the good measures taken in some countries, including the Netherlands and Germany. It will take away the anxiety about their social and economic insecurity and allow these workers to let their inventiveness and creativity flourish, while contributing to practical solutions for the multitude of problems that are arising and have to be addressed during and after the crisis.</p><p>Basic income is an excellent way to revitalize this segment of the economy, and to promote equal opportunities and gender equality. It is an inclusive social security policy that should be continued and expanded after the Coronavirus crisis.</p><p><strong>Challenges ahead</strong></p><p>So far, Coronavirus has mainly affected countries with relatively good health care infrastructure. When the virus spreads to refugee camps where physical distance and permanent hand washing are simply impossible, or to countries with poor health infrastructure, there will be a humanitarian disaster. We can foresee that this will happen, and we must already start preparing new scenarios and raise the money for drastic measures.</p><p>An inspiring example from the UK could be applied to provide decent housing to refugees: hotels in London offered rooms to homeless people where they could stay in physical isolation. Solidarity taxi drivers took them to the hotels. At the moment there are many hotel rooms available that could host refugees, as all trips, traffic and events have been cancelled for the coming months. To prevent a humanitarian disaster in the overcrowded refugee camps of Greece and Turkey, we could move thousands of refugees into the empty hotels.</p><p><strong>A wake-up call</strong></p><p>The Coronavirus crisis is a wake-up call for all of us. It’s time for a change. For the challenges to come, we need a new economic system that cares for people and cares for the planet. We cannot fall back on the old structures of an economic model that is obsolete and that accumulates money in the hands of a few who dominate the world, destroying our planet for the sake of profit, stock exchange listings and gross domestic product (GDP).</p><p>Coronavirus forced governments to put care for people at the centre of policy measures, which is uncommon, because in the current neo-liberal economic model, the ‘caring human being’ does not exist. This model is built on the concept of ‘the rational economic man’, a paradigm of the ‘homo economicus’ derived from Utilitarianism, an ethical theory stemming from the late 18th and 19th century, used by Adam Smith (1723–1790) and his contemporaries to explain the market theory. Human beings are considered to be independent, autonomous, rational economic individuals who pursue maximum satisfaction with a minimum of costs. In a free market this human behaviour is supposed to ensure the efficient allocation of scarce goods and services. Society is the sum of all these rationally acting individuals. Fortunately, this one-dimensional concept of human beings is only a theoretical construction.<a href="#_ftn18">[18]</a> In real life such a person would have an antisocial behaviour disorder — a socially isolated individual, without emotions, without moral conscience and without relations with others, only focused on taking rational decisions to achieve maximum economic gain without taking into consideration the needs and interests of others.<a href="#_ftn19">[19]</a></p><p>There is however a group of politicians, business leaders, financial investors and advisors who strongly internalised this concept of economic rationality by making a utilitarian calculus of the Coronavirus crisis, justifying that human lives of people over 70 should be sacrificed for the benefit of the stock markets and the economic growth. In a briefing of 24 March 2020 at the White House, president Donald Trump warned that the Coronavirus outbreak “is a medical problem, and we are not going let it turn into a long-lasting financial problem”. Texas Republican Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick followed up this briefing by saying that it is not worth to close the economy for such a low mortality rate of mostly people over 70. “Do we have to shut down the entire country for this? I think we can get back to work.” He suggested that Americans over 70 should be happy to die to restore the American economy.<a href="#_ftn20">[20]</a></p><p>Meanwhile a solidarity economy emerges among the vast majority of people; the economy of care. What we see in the Coronavirus crisis is people caring for each other. The ‘caring human being’ is first and foremost an interdependent person, socially connected, affected by and involved in relations to other persons.<a href="#_ftn21">[21]</a> A caring economy requires mutual trust among interrelated citizens. It is the caring human being that keeps society running, in good times and in bad times, in times of crisis and war, in the formal and informal economy, in modern and traditional societies. The economy of care is always there — every day and everywhere.<a href="#_ftn22">[22]</a> Care is a key feature of the global human context in which the market economy is embedded. Even if markets collapse, the economy of care continues to function. This is what the Coronavirus crisis is showing us.</p><p><strong>How to move to caring economics?</strong></p><p>Why not build our future economic model on these universal values of caring human beings? After this economic break, why should we fall back on the old model of the neo-liberal economy that has proven unsustainable from both human and ecological points of view?</p><p>The model of caring economics is a comprehensive, resilient model focused on maintaining, continuing and repairing the world in which we live, to sustainably improve quality of life for all. Caring economics is aligned with the Sustainable Development Goals. The current economic break provides the opportunity to make a paradigm shift in economic thinking and acting. We now have the opportunity to replace our outdated economic model with a new one. An economic system that cares for people and the planet is possible. The Coronavirus crisis shows that putting ‘care for people’ at the centre of politics generates new dynamics, solidarity, clean air, new ways to combine work with family responsibilities etc. Here is a selection of some of the urgent policy measures that governments should take or continue after the Coronavirus crisis:</p><p>· Keep dirty industries closed. Don’t create a debt burden at the cost of future taxpayers to keep dirty industries going. Let these industries fade out; instead, invest money in creating opportunities for decentralized green energy production units managed and controlled by men and women from local communities and organizations. Many simultaneous local, sustainable energy projects can revitalize the economy, create employment and innovation at local level, and are good for the planet.</p><p>· Continue providing an unconditional basic income to the working population that is currently excluded from the traditional social security system, including self-employed workers, freelancers, informal workers and unpaid care workers, and expand basic income step by step to the whole population.</p><p>· Strengthen teleworking processes to reduce commuter traffic and to create an enabling environment for flexible working hours that allows men and women to easily combine a job and family responsibilities.</p><p>· Monitor the incidence of domestic violence and gender-based violence, and put in practice the Convention on Preventing and Combating Violence against Women and Domestic Violence (the Istanbul Convention, 2011).</p><p>· Ensure that reproductive health and rights are protected during and after the Coronavirus crisis.</p><p>· Include the unpaid care economy in macroeconomic policy, and calculate the impact of any economic policy on the volume of paid and unpaid work of women and men.</p><p>· Move people from refugee camps in Greece and Turkey as soon as possible to the empty hotels all over Europe to stop the spread of Coronavirus to refugee camps and to avoid a humanitarian disaster.</p><p><strong>References in the text:</strong></p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> Andrea Ramussi and Guiseppe Remuzzi (2020): COVID-19 and Italy: what next? <em>The Lancet</em>, 13 March 2020. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30627-9">https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30627-9</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref2">[2]</a> Roni Caryn Rabin (2020): Why The Coronavirus Seems To Hit Men Harder Than Women, <em>The New York Times</em>, 2 March 2020. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/20/health/coronavirus-men-women.html">https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/20/health/coronavirus-men-women.html</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref3">[3]</a> Chris Mooney, Sarah Kaplan and Min Joo Kim (2020): The coronavirus is killing far more men than women, The Washington Post, 20 March 2020. <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2020/03/19/coronavirus-kills-more-men-than-women/">https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2020/03/19/coronavirus-kills-more-men-than-women/</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref4">[4]</a> M. Boniol, M. McIsaac, L. Xu, T. Wuliji, K. Diallo and J. Campbell (2019) Gender equity in the health workforce: analysis of 104 countries. Working paper 1. Geneva: World Health Organization. (WHO/HIS/HWF/Gender/WP1/2019.1). Licence: CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO. <a href="https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/311314/WHO-HIS-HWF-Gender-WP1-2019.1-eng.pdf?sequence=1&amp;amp;isAllowed=y">https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/311314/WHO-HIS-HWF-Gender-WP1-2019.1-eng.pdf?sequence=1&amp;amp;isAllowed=y</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref5">[5]</a> Courtney Connley (2019): <em>How women could be uniquely impacted by the coronavirus. </em>CNBC, 18 March 2020. <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/18/how-the-coronavirus-could-impact-women-in-health-care.html">https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/18/how-the-coronavirus-could-impact-women-in-health-care.html</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref6">[6]</a> BBC-News, 24 March 2020 — Coronavirus: Texas says abortions ‘non-essential’ amid pandemic.</p><p><a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/52012243?intlink_from_url=https://www.bbc.com/news/topics/cvenzmgyl2dt/texas&amp;link_location=live-reporting-story">https://www.bbc.com/news/52012243?intlink_from_url=https://www.bbc.com/news/topics/cvenzmgyl2dt/texas&amp;link_location=live-reporting-story</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref7">[7]</a> In 2004 we calculated that in the Netherlands only 16% of the care work for people who need support is done by professionals; 86% is unpaid care work mainly provided by women to people in their close circle who are elderly, have a disability or suffer from a chronic disease (Thera Van Osch, Sheila Quinn and J. van Beveren (2004): <em>Budgeting for all; Manual for local gender budget initiatives</em>. Utrecht: Vrouwen Alliantie, p. 88).</p><p><a href="#_ftnref8">[8]</a> International Labour Organization (2018): <em>Care work and care jobs for the future of decent work</em>. Geneva: ILO. <a href="https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---dgreports/---dcomm/---publ/documents/publication/wcms_633135.pdf">https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/---dgreports/---dcomm/---publ/documents/publication/wcms_633135.pdf</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref9">[9]</a> J.C. Tronto (1993): <em>Moral Boundaries.</em> <em>A Political Argument for an Ethic of Care</em>. New York/London: Routledge.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref10">[10]</a> United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (2019): <em>Global Study on Homicide; Gender-related killing of women and girls</em>. Vienna: UNDOC. <a href="https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/gsh/Booklet_5.pdf">https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/gsh/Booklet_5.pdf</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref11">[11]</a> World Health Organization (2019): <em>Factsheets: Violence against children</em>, 7 June 2019. Geneva: WHO. <a href="https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/violence-against-children">https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/violence-against-children</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref12">[12]</a> Aaldert Van Soest (2020): Meer spanningen thuis, Kindertelefoon roodgloeiend,<em> Nederlands Dagblad</em>, 19 March 2020. <a href="https://www.nd.nl/nieuws/nederland/961027/meer-spanningen-thuis-kindertelefoon-roodgloeiend">https://www.nd.nl/nieuws/nederland/961027/meer-spanningen-thuis-kindertelefoon-roodgloeiend</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref13">[13]</a> Rafi Letzer (2020): <em>Dramatic effect of coronavirus lockdowns seen from space; The air above China cleaned up faster than ever before in living memory</em>. <a href="https://www.space.com/coronavirus-changes-pollution-over-china.html">https://www.space.com/coronavirus-changes-pollution-over-china.html</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref14">[14]</a> Yusko Cho (2020): Blue skies return to China as coronavirus cuts coal consumption. February air pollution readings drop to 6-year low in many cities, <em>Nikkei Asian Review</em>, 24 February 2020. <a href="https://asia.nikkei.com/Spotlight/Coronavirus/Blue-skies-return-to-China-as-coronavirus-cuts-coal-consumption">https://asia.nikkei.com/Spotlight/Coronavirus/Blue-skies-return-to-China-as-coronavirus-cuts-coal-consumption</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref15">[15]</a> Ibid.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref16">[16]</a> Daily Sun (2020): Virus shutdown clears air pollution over China, <em>Daily Sun</em>,<em> </em>3 March, 2020. <a href="https://www.daily-sun.com/printversion/details/466357/Virus-shutdown-clears-air-pollution-over-China">https://www.daily-sun.com/printversion/details/466357/Virus-shutdown-clears-air-pollution-over-China</a>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref17">[17]</a> “<em>I calculate that having 2 months of 10ug/m3 reductions in PM2.5 likely has saved the lives of 4,000 kids under 5 and 73,000 adults over 70 in China. Using even more conservative estimates of 10% reduction in mortality per 10ug change, I estimate 1400 under-5 lives saved and 51700 over-70 lives saved. Even under these more conservative assumptions, the lives saved due to the pollution reductions are roughly 20x the number of lives that have been directly lost to the virus (based on March 8 estimates of 3100 Chinese COVID-19 deaths)</em>” (Marshall Burke (2020): Stanford University co-blog, 8 March 2020. <a href="https://web.stanford.edu/~mburke/">https://web.stanford.edu/~mburke/</a>).</p><p><a href="#_ftnref18">[18]</a> In Adam Smith’s vision, the rational economic man was not yet considered to be one-dimensional. In his book <em>The Theory of Moral Sentiments</em> (1759), he describes the perfection of human nature as <em>“To feel much for others and little for ourselves; to restrain our selfishness and exercise our benevolent affections”</em>.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref19">[19]</a> For an extensive analysis of the neo-classic paradigm of the ‘homo economicus’ see: Irene van Staveren (2001): <em>The Values of Economics. An Aristotelian Perspective</em>. London: Routledge.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref20">[20]</a> The Guardian, 24 March 2020: <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/24/older-people-would-rather-die-than-let-covid-19-lockdown-harm-us-economy-texas-official-dan-patrick">https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/24/older-people-would-rather-die-than-let-covid-19-lockdown-harm-us-economy-texas-official-dan-patrick</a></p><p><a href="#_ftnref21">[21]</a> Virginia Held (2006): <em>The Ethics of Care; Personal, Political and Global</em>. Oxford: Oxford University Press.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref22">[22]</a> Thera Van Osch (2013): Towards a Caring economic Approach. Paper presented at the Progressive Economics Annual Conference, European Parliament, Brussels, 6 March 2014.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=99b8208174ae" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>