<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Lumbanbatu Kornelius on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Lumbanbatu Kornelius on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@thescrapbook?source=rss-a46f79a1ed6f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 20:47:40 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@thescrapbook/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Christ Is the Image of God?: Reading Colossians 1:15 with Marion]]></title>
            <link>https://thescrapbook.medium.com/christ-is-the-image-of-god-reading-colossians-1-15-with-marion-410f47b12f7f?source=rss-a46f79a1ed6f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/410f47b12f7f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[marion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colossians]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christ]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dogs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[image]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lumbanbatu Kornelius]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 20:46:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-16T20:46:01.523Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2bAdSqYqxEj1YRwo" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@glenncarstenspeters?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Glenn Carstens-Peters</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><h3><strong>The Image and the Original: Marion’s Rendering of “the Image of the Invisible God”</strong></h3><p>In the third chapter of <em>The Crossing of the Visible</em> (2004) titled “The Blind at Shiloh,” the French Catholic philosopher Jean-Luc Marion raises his concern about our post-censorship, image-laden civilization. In an era in which the circulation of images is constant due to broadcasting technology, Marion worries that images cease functioning as representations of reality and become substitutes for reality itself. One example that Marion uses to illustrate this worry is television programs. Whilst the advancement of information-broadcasting technology makes knowledge, entertainment, and shared experiences more accessible, it comes with the risk of making us lose sight of reality. This is because images allow us to perceive the world without truly encountering it. In turn, the overabundance of images blurs the distinction between representation and reality. Indeed, television can easily mislead us: instead of the original (e.g., events, products) that these images represent, what we end up perceiving is the images themselves <em>as original</em>. And because image-as-original does not refer to anything outside of itself, its meaning is at the mercy of our desires, of what we want it to represent. Images thus put us in a self-referential loop whilst suggesting to us that what we are perceiving is reality itself. In summary, Marion is arguing that our image-laden civilization has trapped us in a cycle of idolatry.<em> </em>Marion’s concern becomes even more relevant today with the widespread influence of algorithmic technology built into the social media apps we now use on our phones.</p><p>What is unique in Marion’s critique of this overabundance of images is that he does not merely interrupt the cycle of idolatry by reminding us of what the function of an image is (i.e., representing reality). In the wake of image-as-original, he goes one step further by questioning <em>whether the original reality that the image represents is visible in the first place</em>. This question brings him to Colossians 1:15, in which “Saint Paul does not hesitate” to call Christ “the ‘icon of the invisible God’” (p. 57). Working from the premise that a loving gaze “escapes the image and performs the invisible,” Marion argues that Christ offers himself to us as an image that specifically directs our perception to God by demanding from us “a love not for him but for his Father” (<em>ibid</em>). To further strengthen his position, Marion then refers to Christ’s own statement in John 12:27 and 14:9, arguing that:</p><blockquote>We thus come to understand how Christ Jesus offers not only a visible image of the Father who remains invisible but even a (visible) face of the invisible itself (the Father), a visible image of the invisible <em>as invisible</em>. If one tried to evade this paradox, it would no longer be interpreted according to the logic of the image: if every image offered of the invisible God is a caricatural usurpation, it would be necessary therefore to condemn Jesus Christ to death for blasphemy, which is exactly what happened. (Marion 2004, p. 58)</blockquote><p>Put differently, the way we witness the invisible God in Christ is similar to how we witness the face of our beloved person. In the latter case, we are drawn not to the details of our beloved’s appearance (e.g., their eye color, the shape of their lips, the movement of their cheeks when they smile), but to <em>the person</em> behind this appearance, the one who is gazing back at us (cf. “the other of the visible face,” p. 57). In the former, our gaze does not stop at Christ’s human features but goes beyond them to the very invisible God that he is emulating through his visible works.</p><p>Eventually, this reading of Colossians 1:15 allows Marion to conclude that there is always a gap between the visible image that we see and the invisible original reality that it represents. Like how substances (e.g., humanity) are more than the sum of their accidents (e.g., speech, writing, self-consciousness), the invisible original reality cannot be reduced to the visibility of the image. Consequently, our contemporary situation is one in which images, by their very visibility, have rendered us blind to reality, and continue to tyrannize us through this blindness. The only way to free ourselves from this tyranny, according to Marion, is through a paradox: by “washing” ourselves “in the pool of Shiloh” so that “we are granted a vision of the invisible” (p. 65).</p><p>Marion’s interpretation serves a noble cause. However, given his biblical references, it is easy to say that he read Johannine theology into the Colossians. After all, his interpretation only focuses on one phrase in a particular verse of the epistle, whilst the building blocks come mostly from the Gospel of John. But the latter half of the block quote above suggests an understanding of Christ that aligns quite well with Colossians 1, that is, one which distinguishes Christ from God through its refusal in interpreting the former as “a caricatural usurpation” of the latter. Thus, it is appropriate, I think, to treat Marion’s interpretation seriously by posing this animating question: <em>to what extent does this reading represent the meaning of the passage itself?</em></p><h3><strong>Questioning Marion’s Interpretation: A Close Reading of Colossians 1:15–20</strong></h3><p>The verse that Marion read comes directly after the epistle’s proem, in which the author lauds the church in Colossae for their faith in Christ and their love for their fellow Christians (cf. 1:4). This author is presumably Paul, as Marion contends. Yet such a claim has been subjected to scholarly debate, and it is not in my interest to pursue the authorship question here. Ending with a prayer that succinctly describes the redemptive works of both God the Father and Christ (cf. 1:12–14), the proem gives way to what we now often consider a Christology, that is, a detailed explanation of who Christ is both in his relation to God and to creation. It designates to Christ many identities, including “the firstborn of all creation” (1:15), “the head of the body, the church,” “the beginning, the firstborn from the dead” (1:18), and, of course, “the image of the invisible God” (1:15).</p><p>Given Marion’s interpretation, a relevant question is <em>what explanation the author of the Colossians gives concerning Christ’s identity as </em>“<em>the image of the invisible God</em>.” We need to pose this question if we intend to reveal the original meaning of the phrase. And due to the way 1:15–20 is structured, this question resists easy answers. We can contend, for instance, that the explanation for this identity resides in verse 16: “for in him all things in heaven and on earth were created,” and so on. However, the explanatory clauses in verses 16 through 20 can refer to either “the image of the invisible God” or “the firstborn of all creation,” which are distinct identities. It is also unclear how these two identities relate. Are they two different aspects of who Christ is — like how we identify Paul as both “Jew” and “apostle to the Gentiles” — or are they causally related — that is, the author considers Christ to be “the image of the invisible God” <em>because</em> he is “the firstborn of all creation”?</p><p>If we are to read the whole passage according to these two possibilities, we will yield at least four different potential readings: (1) “the image of the invisible God” and “the firstborn of all creation” are causally related, and verses 16–20 primarily explain the latter; (2) verses 16–20 only explain “the firstborn of all creation”; (3) verses 16–20 only explain “the image of the invisible God”; (4) verses 16–20 develop a unified account that informs the meaning of both “the image of the invisible God” and “the firstborn of all creation.</p><p>The way Marion’s reading covers each of these potential readings determines the extent to which it represents the meaning of this passage. Given that his reading involves the human gaze, it readily accommodates potential reading (2) because this reading does not assign verses 16–20 as an explanation of “the image of the invisible God,” allowing Marion to fill it with both Johannine theology and his phenomenological content instead. Of course, it remains plausible to argue that Marion’s Johannine reference may align with the other readings, since sentences like “in him all things in heaven and on earth were created,” “all things have been created through him and for him,” and “in him all the fullness of God was pleased to dwell” cohere well with Christ’s role in emulating the invisible God through his visible works. However, Marion’s reading has yet to demonstrate how its phenomenological account relates to the epistle’s explanation of Christ’s identity. Therefore, the extent to which his reading represents Colossians 1:15 depends on how we understand the relationship between the image language and verses 16–20. If Marion’s phenomenology accurately portrays the epistle’s author’s understanding, then his reading may cover all potential readings listed. If not, it is plausible to infer that his reading may only cover potential reading (2).</p><p>Having reached this position, I pose the following question: <em>What explanation does the author of the Colossians give concerning Christ’s identity as </em>“<em>the image of the invisible God</em>”<em>?</em> <em>Can we consider verses 16-20 to be this explanation?</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=410f47b12f7f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Care and Capitalism: Questioning Nadasen]]></title>
            <link>https://thescrapbook.medium.com/on-care-and-capitalism-questioning-nadasen-fc6f1f7ddda9?source=rss-a46f79a1ed6f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc6f1f7ddda9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[care]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[empowerment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lumbanbatu Kornelius]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Nov 2026 20:08:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-15T20:08:58.670Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*au3iHnztfMZv0Nvw00YjhQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Excerpted from <a href="https://ssir.org/books/reviews/entry/care-premilla-nadasen-review">https://ssir.org/books/reviews/entry/care-premilla-nadasen-review</a></figcaption></figure><h3>Is care economy the main problem?</h3><blockquote>In the long run, the care economy needs to be abolished. However, it can only be abolished as part of a broader shift away from a profit-oriented system of racial capitalism. Perhaps the dismantling must be piecemeal until more wholesale transformation can take place. Either way, because care is fundamental to human survival, we must always create new forms of caring alongside efforts to transform old ones. (p. 16)</blockquote><p>While I understand how neoliberal capitalism has complicated care by introducing steep structural inequalities through the disinvestment in public sectors of care (e.g., schools, hospitals) and the establishment of a privatized care industry (in which low- and middle-class people, particularly women and people of color, are paid low wages to care for upper-class families whilst also struggling to care for their own families), I do not see how social transformation or a return to a welfare-based economy (or any socialist or communist economy, for that matter) will fully solve the problem that Nadasen has pointed out. Riddle me this: Let us assume that we now live in a society that has abolished private enterprise and has ensured equality in economic, gender, and racial standing. Now, instead of being privatized, care labor falls under the state’s management. But what would become of people assigned to do care labor? Remember: socialist and communist societies will still oblige everyone to work — this is what “to each according to his work” and “from each according to his abilities” imply. Thus, even without low wages and structural inequalities prevalent in the neoliberal economy, care workers would still struggle to care for their own families while caring for the people they are assigned to work for. Members of socialist or communist society would thus be privileged to focus on their work at the expense of care workers. And here I pose my question: what if the root of the problem is not the economic model (whether neoliberal, laissez-faire capitalism, socialism, or communism) but rather the reality of care labor itself, of treating care as work?</p><h3>Is care merely empowerment?</h3><blockquote>Radical care rejects the paternalistic notion that some people are dependent while other people provide care for them, and acknowledges how we rely on one another. It rejects the idea that care givers and care receivers are mutually distinct categories and that policies are needed to encourage people to become caregivers. Radical care moves us from self-care to what Cara Page and Erica Woodland call healing justice. It imagines care as a horizontal practice, while being attuned to how care needs vary from individual to individual. (p. 95)</blockquote><p>Here, Nadasen seems to envision radical care as empowerment. The fact that it is defined as “healing justice” and is exemplified by “horizontal practice” such as “mutual aid programs, disability justice, antilabor trafficking, Indigenous organizing, Black food justice, the Movement for Black Lives, and the prison abolition movement” (<em>ibid</em>)<em> </em>betray such character. While I recognize that empowerment itself is a form of care, doing away with the reality of dependency altogether risks excluding acts of care that occur in asymmetrical relationships. This exclusion is problematic because, as Cristina Traina maintains in her <em>Erotic Attunement: Parenthood and the Ethics of Sensuality Between Unequals </em>(2011), we cannot do away with asymmetrical relationships altogether. It is true that ableism, and structural inequalities can be abolished. But what about the biological inequality between a mother and her baby? This biological relationship resists the imagination of “care as a horizontal practice” because in no circumstances the baby can be expected to care for the mother (unless the mother waits for at least 5–6 years after the baby is born). How would Nadasen account for asymmetrical relationships like this? Is this where her radical care proposal fails? Should we find other alternatives to compensate for this fundamental lack?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc6f1f7ddda9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rethinking Fairness: Lessons on Labor and Inequality]]></title>
            <link>https://thescrapbook.medium.com/rethinking-fairness-lessons-on-labor-and-inequality-3c49d88ba3c7?source=rss-a46f79a1ed6f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3c49d88ba3c7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[labor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fairness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inequality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lumbanbatu Kornelius]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Apr 2026 05:09:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-16T05:09:55.975Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1x3jsemoVKQF6Z_4" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@albertstoynov?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Albert Stoynov</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Over the past six years, overlapping shocks — including the Covid-19 pandemic, inflation, slower growth, and geopolitical conflict — have increased poverty and widened socioeconomic inequality globally. According to the <a href="https://desapublications.un.org/publications/world-social-report-2025-new-policy-consensus-accelerate-social-progress"><em>World Social Report</em> <em>2025</em></a>, published by the United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UN DESA), “Over 2.8 billion people — more than a third of the global population — live on $2.15 to $6.85 a day.” As UN Secretary-General António Guterres notes, “Countless people are struggling to make ends meet while wealth and power are concentrated at the top.” The same report highlights that background-based discrimination (e.g., race, caste, place of birth, gender, family background) remains a major driver of inequality.</p><p>Inequality itself is not new.<em> </em>The <em>WSR 2025 </em>states that it has been rising “in most high-income countries and in some middle-income countries” since 1990. This persistence often leads to a familiar conclusion: the structural reform of economic systems is necessary. At the same time, policy responses have increasingly focused on reducing background-based discrimination and expanding equal access, particularly through merit-based systems of distribution.</p><p>Yet even when such measures are implemented, dissatisfaction with inequality often persists. This suggests that the problem may not be fully explained by economic structures or access alone.</p><p>A less examined factor is how fairness itself is understood. In labor and exchange contexts, fairness is often defined by the relationship between inputs (such as effort and time) and outputs (such as compensation and recognition), typically in comparison to other people. A wage is therefore considered fair when it reflects both individual contribution and relative standing. Those who contribute more are expected to receive more; those who contribute less, less. This logic underpins merit-based systems of distribution.</p><p>However, what appears to be a clear and neutral principle can also reproduce the very inequalities it seeks to address. As political philosopher <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Tyranny-Merit-Whats-Become-Common/dp/0374289980">Michael Sandel</a> argues, while merit-based systems expand access by reducing formal barriers, they also legitimize outcomes by attributing them to individual effort and ability. This creates a moral narrative in which success is deserved and failure is blamed on insufficient effort.</p><p>The result is not only economic inequality, but also what Sandel describes as a “politics of humiliation.” Those at the top may come to view their position as earned, reinforcing a sense of superiority, while those at the bottom experience resentment and diminished social worth. This dynamic can deepen social division, undermine trust, and, in times of instability, contribute to broader conflict.</p><p>Addressing inequality, therefore, requires more than structural reform. It also requires rethinking how fairness itself is defined and communicated.</p><p>Alternative ethical frameworks suggest that fairness cannot be reduced to proportional exchange alone. In contexts of inequality, fairness may also involve considerations beyond measurable input and output, including need, dignity, and social cohesion. In such frameworks, compensation is not determined solely by individual productivity, but also by the conditions under which individuals participate in economic life. This can produce outcomes that appear counterintuitive from a strictly meritocratic perspective — for example, situations in which individuals with different levels of contribution receive comparable levels of support. While such arrangements may seem to violate conventional expectations of fairness, they highlight a different logic: one in which sustaining social relationships and preventing exclusion in any form are treated as central concerns.</p><p>Implementing such frameworks requires policy to address both material distribution and public perception. Prevailing narratives about fairness shape how policies are received and whether they are regarded as legitimate. Expanding the notion of fairness beyond merit-based logic therefore depends, in part, on how these ideas are communicated and understood. This places communication at the center of policy design. Framing decisions in ways that acknowledge differing conditions and shared social goals can reduce resistance and strengthen public trust. Without such efforts, even well-intended policies risk being perceived as unfair, limiting their effectiveness.</p><p>Addressing socioeconomic inequality therefore requires integrating both structural reform and narrative awareness. Policy design should consider not only how resources are distributed, but also how these decisions are framed and understood by the public. Incorporating narrative analysis can help identify how policies are likely to be interpreted, while deliberate framing strategies can improve legitimacy and reduce resistance. Without attention to these factors, even well-designed reforms may fail to achieve their intended impact.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs. <em>World Social Report 2025</em>.</p><p>Michael Sandel. <em>The Tyranny of Merit</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3c49d88ba3c7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From the Messiah to the State: Problems in Giorgio Agamben’s Thinking]]></title>
            <link>https://thescrapbook.medium.com/from-the-messiah-to-the-state-problems-in-giorgio-agambens-thinking-523506160cf3?source=rss-a46f79a1ed6f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/523506160cf3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apostle-paul]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[giorgio-agamben]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bible]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lumbanbatu Kornelius]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Feb 2026 04:12:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-17T04:12:40.171Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/491/1*AVVfwl6f-jzVffH77pkOaw.png" /><figcaption>“Saint Paul” by Giuseppe Vermiglio</figcaption></figure><h3>Preface</h3><p>Allow me to open this paper by stating what it does <em>not </em>try to do. This paper does not try to be simple. It does not try to simplify a complex argument or to make it palatable to the general public. The presence of generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) models in the public sphere has rendered the act of simplifying thoughts, or summarizing, obsolete. Machines can now produce a competent digest of any text in seconds. The only labor that remains irreducibly human is the labor of thinking through, which is slow, recursive, and costly, yet yields what cannot be generated. In fact, the process of writing this short paper proved to be so laborious that it took me two weeks to put it together.</p><p>What this paper <em>tries</em> to do can be gleaned from its subtitle. It is a result of an act of <em>dwelling</em> with a text, namely Giorgio Agamben’s <a href="https://www.sup.org/books/religious-studies/time-remains"><em>The Time That Remains</em></a><em>.</em> I read certain parts of it in a very slow manner, positioning myself as a reviewer or examiner struggling to delve into the flow of its arguments, questioning its underlying assumptions, and exposing parts that I consider problematic. In short, this paper tries to <em>think with</em> <em>and against </em>Agamben. It is my humble attempt — despite how arrogant it sounds — to enact a PhD-level thinking with a brain that has only attained an MTh. Since the attempt itself proves to be gargantuan in my current state, I limit my inquiry to three specific areas delineated below.</p><p>Moreover, this paper presents a result of thinking that has yet to be completed and may be subject to further improvements. Should the reader be a theologian or a philosopher interested in researching Agamben’s thought or topics related to it, I hope that this paper may give them a spark of inspiration or a new perspective in pursuing their project.</p><p>A fair warning before I get to the heart of the matter: because writing this paper costs me something, it will also cost you something to read it.</p><h3>On Methodology</h3><ol><li>Agamben claimed that he intended to “restore Paul’s Letters to the status of the fundamental messianic text for the Western tradition” (p. 1). Seeing the premises that follow from this claim alone, it is <em>not</em> appropriate to consider his method a variation of Ricoeurian “second naivety” (that is, “a reading of the Bible which moves beyond modern criticism and aspires to attain a post-critical attitude,” see <a href="https://ricoeur.pitt.edu/ojs/ricoeur/article/view/606/348">Buzási</a>, p. 41). Agamben realized (and rightly so, New Testament scholars like W.D. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Paul-Rabbinic-Judaism-Elements-Theology/dp/0800614380">Davies</a>, E.P. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Paul-Palestinian-Judaism-40th-Anniversary/dp/1506438148/ref=sr_1_1?crid=13R2FA45W08U2&amp;dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.4H7oV5FNlNrWHuRKFOb56w.5XXDWvGKitc-OnfnsWFa999GIZva0GstAGGkNNGBL0E&amp;dib_tag=se&amp;keywords=e.+p.+sanders+paul+and+palestinian+judaism&amp;qid=1771129071&amp;sprefix=E.+P.+Sanders+Paul+%2Caps%2C329&amp;sr=8-1">Sanders</a>, and N.T. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/What-Saint-Paul-Really-Said/dp/080287178X/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2XQDDAQE6XRGP&amp;dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.A-ezVn9_JS48Mc7HS8NXdrTwz2dA9ekknqY3vq3oeFksf63pTNMikGrKqnXp_7mm9DuprhRH2RPC6bt0lvammqLQRrd3zsUYqH782UP2hM_kt19-RTjIa03bmHurF0-kuZ0_A21JlYt_Jw3h7ptn3Q.6yk4E6WRUGx8yHM_-CE3fLVQwMiFRf241wYEELQMqBA&amp;dib_tag=se&amp;keywords=n+t+wright+what+paul+really+said&amp;qid=1771129090&amp;sprefix=N.+T.+Wright+What+Sa%2Caps%2C350&amp;sr=8-1">Wright</a> would agree) that the two millennia of commentary and translation of the Pauline letters have annulled their messianic character. He also rightly observed that both Christianity and Judaism attempted to frame Paul as a founder of a new religion, which undermines the Jewishness of his thought. His philological analysis was spot on: belonging to the Diaspora Jew community, Paul reworked his Greek in such a way that it ended up becoming <em>anomalous </em>— not Greek enough to be considered among the classics of Hellenism and not Jewish enough to be juxtaposed with the sayings of Jesus in the Synoptic Gospels. Thus, what Agamben intended to do seems coherent with the exegetical standard: uncovering the original meaning of the text that was obscured by time. Were I to use this approach, I would strongly presume that the rest of Agamben’s commentary is <em>faithful </em>to Paul.</li><li>However, as one reads on, one will discover the point at which Agamben’s second naivety began. His main preoccupation is not uncovering the original meaning of Pauline letters; it is rather the retrieval of the notion of “messianic time,” or what he termed <em>ho nyn kairos</em>, the time remaining after the temporal contraction mentioned by Paul in 1 Corinthians 7:29. This is his pivot in interpreting the Letter to the Romans — chosen specifically because the letter represents the total sum of Paul’s thought according to exegetical and theological consensus. What is significant is that Agamben did <em>not</em> try to read and comment upon Romans on its own terms. This is perpetuated further by the fact that his focus was directed only to the <em>first ten words</em> of the letter: “<em>Paulos doulos Christou Iesou kletos apostolos aphorismenos eis euaggelion theou</em>” (Rom. 1:1; Agamben, p. 6). He then performed an extensive analysis of these words (the last three are of utmost importance, as we will see in the subsequent segments) under the assumption that each of them represents what Paul elaborated throughout the whole letter. Add the fact that Agamben’s interpretation also incorporated philosophical notions formulated thousands of years after Paul (e.g., Georg W.F. Hegel’s “<em>Aufhebung,</em>” Carl Schmitt’s “state of exception,” Theodor Adorno’s “as if,” Nikolay Trubetzkoy’s “degree zero”), one can clearly see that what he actually did was uncovering a particular symbol — the messianic — for the sake of constructing a political and historical critique.</li><li>The question is: why would Agamben bother going through the premises delineated in no. 1 if, in turn, what he is attempting is not tantamount to restoring “Paul’s Letters to the status of the fundamental messianic text for the Western tradition?” Or, does “the Western tradition” have something to do here? Perhaps it is an implicit signaling on Agamben’s part that the character of Western philosophy is essentially messianic, and Paul was the progenitor? If it is so, then Agamben has implicitly posited a genealogy of ideas that needs further proving, especially given the fact that the history of Western thought is dominated by the influence of ancient Greek philosophers, and not the proponents of Jewish messianism (keep in mind the complicity of both Judaism and Christianity in neutralizing messianism from Pauline letters mentioned in no. 1).</li></ol><h3>On the Gospel, Faith, Promise, and the Law</h3><ol><li>This section is replete with doublets that may confound us if we do not tread carefully. Agamben began by stating the possibility of treating the Greek preposition <em>eis</em> (“toward”) as a technical term, referring to Immanuel Kant’s use of the German word <em>gleichwohl </em>(“nevertheless”) and Martin Heidegger’s use of hyphens to make his case. Then, he shifted his attention to the word <em>euaggelion </em>(“gospel”), a Greek term not unfamiliar to theology enthusiasts. After ruling out the usage of the term to refer to a series of written works — mainly because Paul wrote his letters <em>before</em> the evangelists (Mark, Matthew, Luke, John) wrote their “Gospel of Jesus Christ” — Agamben clarified that the “gospel” in Paul stands for both the <em>act</em> of announcing<em> </em>good news and the <em>content</em> of such an announcement. Then, he linked these definitions to the term <em>pistis </em>(“faith”), in turn establishing it as the <em>zone</em> of the gospel’s double meaning. Faith thus refers to the <em>good </em>being announced, and <em>that</em> which renders the gospel <em>operative</em>.</li><li>A crucial passage Agamben highlighted to support this interpretation is Romans 1:16, specifically the phrase “the announcement is power [<em>dynamis</em>] for the salvation of he who believes.” The word <em>dynamis</em> here has, again, a double meaning — it refers to both <em>power </em>and <em>potentiality</em>. Focusing upon the latter, this is where Agamben first mentioned the conceptual duality between <em>dynamis</em> and <em>energeia</em> (“act”), accompanied by quite a strong contention that Paul was familiar with this duality (he quoted some passages of the Pauline letters, e.g., Eph. 3:7 and Phil. 3:21, to support his case). Thus, the verse seems to convey that the gospel is a potentiality that can only be actualized by the belief of the faithful. The charge of semi-Pelagianism may seem appropriate here, but Agamben himself never suggested that the power of the gospel comes from the faithful’s <em>decision</em> to believe. His statement that since “the announcement entails <em>dynamis… </em>it needs the complement of faith (‘whoever believes’) for it to be effectual” (p. 90) can be read in monergistic terms: the power of the gospel is <em>made manifest</em> <em>in</em> the faithful’s belief. Therefore, faith is the result — the actualization — of the gospel’s potentiality, not a prerequisite for the gospel to be effectual. Interestingly, this reading opens the possibility of combining the double meaning of <em>dynamis </em>into a single interpretation, something Agamben may have overlooked.</li><li>Another important dimension of the gospel and faith, according to Agamben, is their connection to the term <em>epaggelia</em>, which in English means “promise.” He recognized, albeit implicitly (through the invocation of Abraham), that the term carries a covenantal connotation. Here arises a temporal tension: the gospel concerns the <em>presence</em> of an awaited good, whereas biblical promise concerns <em>future </em>hope. To resolve this tension, Agamben pointed to faith, the zone that encompasses both the content of the gospel and that which makes it operative, as also the site where present and future are unified. He stated that faith “consists in being fully <em>persuaded</em> of the necessary unity of promise and realization” (p. 91). He also added that, in connection to the term <em>plerophoria </em>(1 Thess. 1:5), which he translated as full adherence “to something without any gap left over,” this persuasion should be understood “in the ontological sense,” with the only explanation being “the meaning Michelstädter ascribes to the term <em>persuasion</em>” (<em>ibid</em>). This hardly explains anything. One will only discover what he was hinting at after comprehending <a href="https://yalebooks.yale.edu/book/9780300191516/persuasion-and-rhetoric/">Michelstädter</a>’s concept of persuasion itself, which is quite complex. Put simply, it is a specific mode of living free from the anxieties of the future and the fear of death. Understanding this makes the ties of gospel-promise-faith somewhat clearer: the <em>hos me</em>, or the “as not” (e.g., “those who mourn, as if they did not; those who are happy, as if they were not; those who buy something, as if it were not theirs to keep,” 1 Cor. 7:30), is the mode of living that results when the gospel and the biblical promise converge (see Agamben, pp. 67–69).</li><li>Agamben further increased the complexity of this section by relating promise and faith to the term <em>nomos</em> (“the law”). This brought him straight to the heart of a conundrum that has perplexed Christian theologians throughout centuries: Paul’s obscure treatment of the law. Among the theologians he mentioned (for example, Origen, Ticonius, Marius Victorinus, John Chrysostom, Didymus the Blind, Cyril of Alexandria), he fixed his attention on <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Origen-Commentary-Epistle-Romans-Fathers/dp/0813201039">Origen</a>, one of the earliest and most brilliant exegetes in the history of Christianity. He noted how Origen likened the Pauline letters to a labyrinthine castle, and that this characteristic renders us incapable of understanding the texts, giving us “the impression that Paul contradicts himself when he speaks of the law” (p. 92). Agamben then quoted four passages of the Letter to the Romans (3:19-20; 3:28; 3:31; 7:12) to illustrate the apparent contradiction. However, throughout this part, I have a lingering suspicion that Origen himself had already worked out this conundrum in his commentary. His context seems to support my suspicion: [a] he had facility in both Greek (his native tongue) and Hebrew; [b] he was familiar with Judaic thought (Agamben pointed out that Origen developed his castle analogy from the teachings of a Jewish rabbi); and [c] he was known to work his way around biblical contradictions by resorting to allegorical reading. I do not know the reason underlying Agamben’s decision not to comment on Origen’s take on the Pauline conundrum altogether. Although the duration of his seminar might be insufficient to accommodate a detailed critique, he could have expanded on the written material. (The translator of <em>The Time That Remains</em>, Patricia Dailey, stated that, “The book represents the fruit of these seminars,” see Agamben, p. ix.) It is also unlikely that this decision was based on his awareness that Origen is part of the same tradition that has annulled the messianic character of the Pauline letters. If this were the case, now would be the perfect moment for him to prove the veracity of his realization earlier (see no. 1 of the previous segment).</li><li>Given the occurrence of doublets throughout this section, it is not surprising that Agamben’s solution to this conundrum is to be found in another doublet: <em>nomos ton entolon</em>/<em>nomos ton ergon </em>(“the law of the commandments/the law of works”) and <em>nomos pisteos </em>(“the law of faith”). The former concerns the normative aspect of the law represented by the law of Moses, culminating in the 613 <em>mitzvot</em>. The latter is tied to the promissive aspect of the law, which precedes its normative aspect, since it was established, according to the Letter to the Galatians (3:17–19), 430 years before the Mosaic law. Utilizing this doublet, Agamben argued that when Paul spoke of the law in antithetical fashion (Rom. 3:19–20, 28), he was elaborating on the law’s normative role: not to justify humanity before God, but rather to reveal the <em>impossibility</em> of such a justification. This, however, does not negate the law’s promissive role, which was invoked every time Paul spoke highly of it: “Wherefore the law is holy, and the commandment is holy, and just and good” (Rom. 7:12); “Do we then make the law inoperative through faith? Let it not be! We hold the law firm” (Rom. 3:31).</li><li>Agamben then proceeded to relate this doublet to the messianic, arguing that the advent and the works of the Messiah fulfilled the promissive role of the law <em>by rendering its normative aspect inoperative</em> and <em>recapitulating the latter into a principle of love </em>(Rom. 13:8–9). This, I think, is the most compelling part of his argument. As will be seen in the next segment, Agamben’s excavation of the key term that represents this messianic fulfillment of the law, <em>katargeo</em>, left as much novelty as problems, even when judged according to the standard of second naivety.</li></ol><h3>On the Messianic Suspension and the Empire</h3><ol><li>Agamben noted that the meaning of the Greek term <em>katargeo</em> is along the lines of “to render inoperative,” “to empty,” “to deactivate,” and “to suspend.” It is, according to him, a term unique to Paul: from its twenty-seven occurrences throughout the New Testament corpus, <em>katargeo</em> and its variations appear twenty-six times in the Pauline letters alone. Here, he drew two connections: etymological and thematic. Etymologically, he traced <em>katargeo</em> back to the basic word <em>argeo</em>, which means “not-at-work” (<em>a-ergos</em>). He remarked that this word was significant in the Second Temple tradition (especially among the Diaspora Jewish community), for it was a translation of a Hebrew word that signifies the “sabbatical suspension of works” (he referred to 2 Macc. 5:25 and the Septuagint in general, see Agamben, p. 96). Thematically, he ties the term to the logic of inversion prevalent in the Pauline letters, particularly referring to 1 Corinthians 1:27 and 2 Corinthians 12:9.</li><li>Agamben then put his emphasis upon the latter. He argued that since the Pauline letters are messianic texts, it follows that <em>katargeo</em> carries a fundamentally messianic connotation. Quoting Romans 7:6 (specifically the phrase “but now we are deactivated [<em>katergethemen</em>] from the law”), he claimed to have discovered the core of Pauline thought: the <em>messianic suspension of the Jewish law</em>. Thus, it is through this core that the connection between promise-faith and the law (see no. 4 of the previous segment) must be understood. While the point of the Messiah’s advent is to fulfill the law’s promissive aspect, the mechanism through which this fulfillment is brought about is the deactivation of its normative aspect (the law of the commandments/the law of works). This same mechanism, Agamben maintained, was echoed by Paul himself through his statement that “power realizes itself in weakness” (2 Cor. 12:9), and that “God has chosen weak things of the world to shame things which are mighty” (1 Cor. 1:27). Thus, messianic power is the <em>power of inversion</em>, the capacity to fulfill (or to perfect) something through its undoing.</li><li>Herein lies the first problem of Agamben’s retrieval of <em>katargeo</em>: he connected Pauline messianic inversion<em> </em>to Aristotelian thought instead of the Second Temple tradition, in which Paul’s theology was formed. Specifically, he related the notion to Aristotle’s statement in <em>Metaphysics </em>1019b9–10, 1046a32: “each thing is powerful either through having something or through the privation of this same thing.” He then wrote in the subsequent paragraph: “Only to the extent that the Messiah renders the <em>nomos</em> inoperative, that he makes the <em>nomos</em> no-longer-at-work and thus restores it to the state of potentiality, only in this way may he represent its <em>telos</em> as both end and fulfillment” (Agamben, p. 98). Pay attention to how this logic inverts the gospel-faith logic he employed in no. 2 of the previous segment. By combining these facts, we can infer that Agamben implicitly contended that Paul derived his conception of the <em>dynamis</em>/<em>energeia</em> duality from Aristotelian thought. This is a problematic contention, since it receives little to no support from scholars researching the notion of energy.<em> </em>For instance, in his recent monograph, David <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Divine-Energies-Action-Essence-Energies-Distinction/dp/1735295159">Bradshaw</a> only dared to entertain the <em>possibility</em> of such a connection by asking, “Could there be here [in Eph. 1:19; 3:7; Phil. 3:21; Col. 1:29] an echo of the Aristotelian contrast between <em>energeia</em> as actuality and <em>dynamis</em> as potentiality?” (p. 31). He then established a more convincing link between Paul and Alexandrian Judaism (particularly Pseudo-Aristeas and the Wisdom of Solomon) based on the fact that both sides consistently used <em>energeia </em>to refer to the activity of supernatural agents. Peter <a href="https://www.amazon.com/History-Cultural-Travels-Energy-Aristotle-ebook/dp/B0BZ7KW2NB/ref=sr_1_1?crid=1P7IMQ90MZGIZ&amp;dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.izxScPscxHGPyPVjkiEcHmh3gL42ojPoKu11KbcdcHMaj-SlKsbMMClM8nzKH9rU.w0-bIsUunag8Wy6-KCF-4OljsZoz2unuqTyU8umeYSw&amp;dib_tag=se&amp;keywords=A+history+of+the+cultural+travels+of+energy&amp;nsdOptOutParam=true&amp;qid=1771236180&amp;s=books&amp;sprefix=a+history+of+the+cultural+travels+of+energy%2Cstripbooks%2C324&amp;sr=1-1">Hjertholm</a>’s recent survey on the history of “energy” also makes no mention of Paul (or any other New Testament author) being influenced by Aristotle’s philosophy. Moreover, David E. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Paul-Giants-Philosophy-Reading-Greco-Roman/dp/083085228X/ref=sr_1_1?crid=3DDB6TTI7Q1SC&amp;dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.82wnCHTMfH6BSrt4lgJ7fzcXyJUSBJgnkRqWoaOLySEey-LZxTdPBPibmfLFd3z_d6Fy8Iha_48dSQ7H9UlyolIznv8s0HC09z2MMmnHWbHxJ8E_7WjJitAgf3n_gyEyFn7U-e2m568PXAIunqFwreb0NC4dYfttomQ5o5KoODiTS2Ekg2BMgTnwkBeIR6e5.TbdZplOj2R9ebodjzC2pTs8ytfHEJAohg9ZgAZjDBs8&amp;dib_tag=se&amp;keywords=Paul+and+the+Giants+of+Philosophy&amp;qid=1771235610&amp;s=books&amp;sprefix=paul+and+the+giants+of+philosoph%2Cstripbooks%2C328&amp;sr=1-1">Briones</a>’ warning is, I think, worth heeding: “Some scholars make too much of these parallels between Paul and the [Greek] philosophers — so much so that their work has been labelled ‘parallelomania’ because they list an enormous amount of common words, phrases, and concepts found in Paul and the philosophers and then draw unfounded conclusions” (p. 2–3). The key takeaway is that just because Paul and Aristotle utilized the same conceptual duality does not necessarily mean the former derived it from the latter. Doing otherwise would jeopardize the second naivety, since it entails that the symbol he uncovered is not the same symbol he intended to uncover.</li><li>On the other hand, the etymological connection Agamben drew between <em>katargeo </em>and the sabbatical suspension of works (see no. 1) remains frustratingly underdeveloped. This is a significant loss, for the connection may provide the most plausible explanation as to why Paul thought the fulfillment of the law is achieved precisely through its suspension. It is on the seventh day that God <em>completed</em> his act of creation by <em>ceasing </em>his creative act (Gen. 2:2). The fourth law of the decalogue was then derived (or we can argue the other way around, should we take the JEDP hypothesis seriously) from this theological fact, granting the people of Israel a day of <em>rest</em> to <em>complete</em> the working week. By following the same logic, Paul thus considered the messianic power of inversion to be a <em>sabbatical power</em>; a notion formed by alluding back to his native tradition (both the Messiah and the Sabbath are notions originated in Jewish soil) instead of utilizing a foreign one. Given Pauline scholarship’s unanimous consensus on the Judaic nature of Paul’s thought, this line of argument would have garnered more support compared to Agamben’s Aristotelian one.</li><li>The second problem in Agamben’s excavation of <em>katargeo</em> beset him in his attempt to posit the term into a genealogy of Western philosophy. This attempt confirms my suspicion: Agamben undeniably saw Paul as the progenitor of Western thought (see no. 3 of the first segment). By referring to Martin Luther’s German translation of the Bible, he established the connection between Pauline <em>katargeo </em>and the Hegelian <em>Aufhebung</em>, and in turn declared: [a] that dialectical thinking is the secularization of Christian theology; and [b] that Western philosophy is more or less messianic. “What is essentially messianic and <em>historic</em>,” Agamben said, “is the idea that fulfillment is possible by retrieving and revoking foundation” (p. 103–4). While this statement confirms the uniformity of logic between <em>katargeo</em> and <em>Aufhebung</em> (because for Hegel, “what is sublated is not thereby reduced to nothing,” see Agamben’s quotation, p. 100), it does so at the cost of <em>obscuring the messianic agent</em>. With Paul, the identity of the Messiah performing the suspension is clear: Jesus. However, we cannot say the same in the wake of the secularization of Pauline messianism. Ultimately, I think it is erroneous to consider Western philosophy as “messianic” at all. The messianic presumes the presence of the Messiah, which in turn presumes the existence of a divine anointing agent — a set of presumptions that is at best neglected (and at worst vehemently rejected) by Western philosophers after the “death of God.”</li><li>In relation to the second problem is the problem of the <em>object</em> of the messianic suspension. Agamben rightly said that the <em>nomos ton entolon</em>/<em>nomos ton ergon</em> is the object of Pauline <em>katargesis</em>. But things are not so simple concerning its Western counterparts. I think this is the reason he directed his genealogical discussion to Schmitt’s concept of the “state of exception,” framing the messianic suspension as the <em>radicalization</em> of the aforementioned concept. “In his rendering of the messianic condition of the believer, Paul radicalizes the condition of the state of exception, whereby law is applied in disapplying itself, no longer having an inside or an outside” (Agamben, pp. 106–7). However, taking this direction implies that the object of Agamben’s <em>katargesis</em> will also be a Schmittian category — and this is indeed the case. Enter the <em>katechon</em>, the restraining figure in 2 Thessalonians 2, which Schmitt interpreted as a divinely-sanctioned power akin to the Holy Roman Empire. In terms of second naivety, Schmitt’s symbolic retrieval is problematic right from its outset. Until this short paper is written, New Testament scholars and biblical exegetes have yet to reach a definitive conclusion as to who or what exactly the <em>katechon</em> is. The hypotheses vary — from the Christian Roman Empire (as per Schmitt’s own reading), the Roman Empire before Nero (see F. F. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Thessalonians-45-Word-Biblical-Commentary/dp/0310521998">Bruce</a>, pp. 169–72), to the archangel Michael (see Colin R. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Hope-Despair-Thessalonica-Situating-Thessalonians/dp/0521831423/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.2oKJLYk--UWDK1gC97HEpg.Y1vEDN9DEmS-PHCJqp6hVCId95MRiD-0wTubTApWPm8&amp;dib_tag=se&amp;keywords=From+Hope+to+Despair+in+Thessalonica%3A+Situating+1+and+2+Thessalonians&amp;nsdOptOutParam=true&amp;qid=1771296068&amp;s=books&amp;sr=1-1">Nicholl</a>, pp. 230–35). There was little to no reason for elevating one hypothesis above the others, and indeed, Schmitt did not give sufficient reason to support his case. He stated that “empire” is the only “historical power that is capable of arresting the coming of Antichrist and the end of the current eon” (see Agamben’s quotation, p. 109). In fact, the other hypotheses were posited precisely because each highlighted figure is also capable of playing the same role.</li><li>Since the Schmittian <em>katechon</em> is the object of Agamben’s messianic suspension, it follows that his interpretation exacerbates the hermeneutical problem already latent in the former. Agamben read the <em>katechon </em>as denoting “every theory of the State, including Hobbes’ — which thinks of it as a power destined to block or delay catastrophe” (p. 110). Because messianic power works according to the principle of “fulfilling by revoking foundation” (see no. 5), it is natural for Agamben to position the <em>katechon </em>— a foundational power as per Schmitt’s interpretation — as <em>antithetical</em> to the messianic agent. This is why he contended that “this Pauline passage does not harbor any positive valuation of <em>katechon</em>” (see Agamben, p. 110). What emerges from such a reading is an understanding of the <em>anomos </em>(“the lawless one”) as a signifier of the messianic agent itself. This line of thought is very compelling and quite persuasive, were it not for the fact that it completely disregards 2 Thessalonians 2:8–9, which clearly states that the lawless one works <em>synergistically </em>(Paul made use of the term <em>energeia</em> in this passage) with Satan, and that, in turn, according to the logic of the text itself, the lawless one stands at the opposite side of the Messiah, instead of being synonymous with him.</li><li>Nevertheless, Agamben’s problematic interpretation of <em>katargeo</em> and the <em>katechon</em> proves to be relevant in the wake of the recent Russian invasion of Ukraine (beginning in 2022 and still commencing today). This is because underneath the geopolitical interests that drive the Russian government in executing the invasion is a nationalist ideology, the “Russky Mir,” which frames the state of Russia as a theologically legitimized political institution (see D.J. <a href="https://criticalsocialtheory.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/ip27-2.pdf#page=5">Byrd</a>, pp. 2, 12–17). In other words, this ideology was constructed with the Schmittian <em>katechon </em>as its foundation. It posits Russia as the Third Holy Roman Empire, sanctioned by God to halt the coming of the Antichrist, who manifests himself in the form of the Western world (particularly members of NATO), by whatever means necessary. Put simply, this ideology has mobilized a biblical concept to justify political violence. By positing a critique of its very foundation, Agamben has indirectly exposed a dangerous reading of the <em>katechon, </em>opening the possibility of constructing alternative, more peaceful interpretations of it.</li></ol><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>Agamben, G. (2005). <em>The time that remains: A commentary on the letter to the Romans</em>, trans. P. Dailey. Stanford University Press.</p><p>Bradshaw, D. (2023). <em>Divine energies and divine action: Exploring the essence-energy distinction</em>. IOTA Publications.</p><p>Bruce, F.F. (1982). <em>Word biblical commentary: 1 and 2 Thessalonians</em>. Zondervan.</p><p>Buzási, Á. (2022). Paul Ricoeur and the idea of second naivety. <em>Études Ricoeuriennes</em>/<em>Ricoeur Studies</em> 13 (2): 39–58.</p><p>Byrd, D.J. (2022). The Russian restrainer of the apocalypse: The <em>katechon</em> in St. Paul, Carl Schmitt, and Alexander Dugin. <em>Islamic perspective</em> 27: 1–22.</p><p>Davies, W.D. (1980). <em>Paul and Rabbinic Judaism: Some Rabbinic elements in Pauline theology</em>. Fortress Press.</p><p>Dodson, J.R., D.E. Briones, eds. (2019). <em>Paul and the giants of philosophy: Reading the apostle in Greco-Roman context</em>. InterVarsity Press.</p><p>Hjertholm, P. (2023). <em>A history of the cultural travels of energy: From Aristotle to the OED</em>. Routledge.</p><p>Michelstädter, C. (2004). <em>Persuasion and rhetoric</em>, trans. R.S. Valentino, C.S. Blum, D.J. Depew. Yale University Press.</p><p>Nicholl, C.R. (2004). <em>From hope to despair in Thessalonica: Situating 1 and 2 Thessalonians</em>. Cambridge University Press.</p><p>Origen of Alexandria. (2001). <em>Commentary on the epistle to the Romans, book 1–5</em>, trans. T.P. Scheck. Catholic University of America Press.</p><p>Sanders, E.P. (1977). <em>Paul and Palestinian Judaism: A comparison of patterns of religion</em>. Fortress Press.</p><p>Wright, N.T. (1997). <em>What St. Paul really said?: Was Paul of Tarsus the real founder of Christianity?</em> Wm. B. Eerdmans.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=523506160cf3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Melihat Kembali Kerapuhan]]></title>
            <link>https://thescrapbook.medium.com/melihat-kembali-kerapuhan-8211dde68338?source=rss-a46f79a1ed6f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8211dde68338</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[kristen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teologi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tuhan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pernikahan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kerapuhan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lumbanbatu Kornelius]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 Feb 2026 05:44:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-11T05:44:27.364Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Disusun dengan mengingat ayah akademis saya, Pak Joas Adiprasetya, yang berulang tahun ke-56 tanggal 8 Januari 2026 lalu.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XXpL3TdRnQDMGCaA" /></figure><h3>Deus vulnerabilis</h3><p>Tulisan kecil ini tidak berpretensi untuk menghadirkan suatu gagasan baru atau berkontribusi besar bagi perbincangan teologi Kristen mengenai kerapuhan. Semua yang akan saya uraikan di sini sudah dibahas secara detail oleh para teolog yang mendahului saya, terutama <a href="https://www.google.co.id/books/edition/A_Political_Theology_of_Vulnerability/-Or7EAAAQBAJ?hl=id&amp;gbpv=0">Sturla J. Stalsett</a>, <a href="https://www.google.co.id/books/edition/Narratives_of_a_Vulnerable_God/uvzMVqJ3glYC?hl=id&amp;gbpv=0">William Placher</a>, dan ayah akademis saya, <a href="https://bpkgunungmulia.com/products/gereja-pascapandemi-merengkuh-kerapuhan">Joas Adiprasetya</a>. Maka dari itu, saya akan menganggap bagian ini berhasil mencapai tujuannya apabila ia mampu meyakinkan Anda, para pembaca, bahwa tesis yang diajukan oleh ketiga teolog tersebut valid secara teologis. Bunyi tesis itu sendiri sederhana: Allah yang dipersaksikan oleh Kekristenan adalah Allah yang rapuh, <em>Deus vulnerabilis</em>.</p><p>Bila Anda menilai tesis tersebut keliru, bahkan konyol, maka Anda tidak sendirian. Untuk waktu yang cukup lama (kira-kira 4 tahun), saya pun berada di posisi Anda. Tesis kerapuhan ilahi ini pertama kali saya dengar ketika Adiprasetya menyampaikan sebuah orasi akademis dalam rangka memperingati pelantikannya sebagai seorang Profesor di bidang Teologi Sistematika Konstruktif. Kala itu pertengahan bulan September 2021. Pandemi Covid-19 masih merajalela dan menimbulkan banyak kematian di seluruh dunia, tak terkecuali di Indonesia. Pembatasan sosial yang diterapkan oleh sebagian besar negara memaksa masyarakat untuk beradaptasi dengan mengembangkan kerja dan pembelajaran dalam jaringan (<em>online</em>). Namun, tak semua orang bisa menikmati privilese ini. Para teknisi, pekerja kerah biru, pedagang asongan, dan pemulung, misalnya, tidak punya pilihan selain mengadu nasib mereka dengan keluar rumah setiap harinya. Tuntutan hidup meningkatkan risiko mereka terpapar Covid-19 dan meregang nyawa hingga tewas, sebab saat itu semua rumah sakit sedang dalam keadaan penuh. Lebih jauh, pembatasan sosial juga menyebabkan kesehatan mental masyarakat merosot. Banyak orang merasa kesepian dan depresi berat karena tidak mampu bercengkerama dengan sahabat mereka serta dibombardir oleh berita kematian dari segala arah; apalagi bila yang meninggal adalah kekasih hati mereka. Gelisah akibat situasi mengerikan ini, Adiprasetya pun menggumuli sebuah pertanyaan teologis mendesak: bagaimana gereja mesti bertindak di tengah musim pagebluk tersebut?</p><p>Titik tolak Adiprasetya dalam menjawab pertanyaan di atas adalah teologi kerapuhan. Tesis kerapuhan ilahi — bahwa Allah umat Kristen sejatinya ialah Allah yang rapuh — ia paparkan dengan mengutip banyak pemikir kontemporer, termasuk di antaranya <a href="https://www.wkv-stuttgart.de/uploads/media/butler-judith-precarious-life.pdf">Judith Butler</a>, <a href="https://www.google.co.id/books/edition/The_Window_of_Vulnerability/_PCIAAAAMAAJ?hl=id&amp;gbpv=0&amp;bsq=The%20Window%20of%20Vulnerability%20Dorothee%20Solle">Dorothee Sölle</a> (teolog pertama yang memakai kerapuhan<em> </em>sebagai konsep kunci), Placher, dan Stalsett. Berdiri di atas bahu para raksasa tersebut, Adiprasetya berargumen bahwa “memang, di dalam Yesus Kristuslah, kerapuhan ilahi ini menubuh secara nyata. Di dalam Kristus, Allah yang rapuh menghadirkan kasih dan rahmat bagi ciptaan yang rapuh” (hlm. 19). Namun, tidak hanya sampai di situ, ia juga menggandeng pemikiran <a href="https://journals.co.za/doi/abs/10.10520/EJC165345">Debora van den Bosch</a> untuk menambahkan bahwa kerapuhan Allah tampil nyata dalam karya Roh Kudus yang dengan sengaja “memasuki kerapuhan ciptaan” untuk “menawarkan pertolongan ilahi” (hlm. 26). Alhasil, seperti Stalsett, Adiprasetya pun mengamini bahwa “prinsip <em>Deus vulnerabilis</em> tampaknya lebih layak untuk dipertahankan daripada prinsip klasik imutabilitas dan impasibilitas Allah yang terlalu spekulatif” (hlm. 17–18).</p><p>Yang membuat tesis ini terdengar konyol bagi saya saat itu — dan mungkin juga bagi Anda — adalah konsepsi umum bahwa “rapuh” berarti <em>ringkih</em> atau <em>lemah</em>. Kamus Besar Bahasa Indonesia turut memperkuat konsepsi ini. Konsekuensinya, jika kita berkata bahwa Allah itu rapuh, maka kita secara sadar menabrak pengakuan aksiomatik para pemikir Kristen klasik bahwa Allah itu mahakuasa. Tabrakan ini lantas menimbulkan banyak pertanyaan konfrontatif. Bagaimana mungkin sosok yang bisa menjadikan segala sesuatu dan melawan tatanan-Nya sendiri (melakukan mukjizat) disebut rapuh? Siapa yang sudi menyembah Allah yang lemah? Bukankah penyembahan manusia kepada Allah didasarkan atas kesenjangan ekstrem di antara keduanya — yang satu hina dina, yang lain kudus; yang satu fana, yang lain kekal; yang satu lemah, yang lain perkasa? Bagaimana bisa malaikat Gabriel bersaksi bahwa “bagi Allah tidak ada yang mustahil” (Luk. 1:37), bila Allah itu sendiri ringkih? Lagipula, walaupun Kristus menderita sampai mati, yang menderita hanya kemanusiaan-Nya, bukan? Keilahian-Nya tetap mahakuasa, dan itu terbukti lewat kebangkitan-Nya dari antara orang mati. Bahkan, kita bisa melihat inkarnasi dan ketaatan Kristus sebagai ajang pamer kuasa ilahi yang paling radikal. Dengan mengosongkan diri-Nya, Allah seolah-olah sedang berkata, “Ambillah kemahakuasaan ini daripada-Ku, sebab Aku bisa hidup tanpa-Nya.”</p><p>Dalam perkembangannya, antipati saya terhadap tesis kerapuhan ilahi turut diperparah oleh para kolega yang menyerukan bahwa kerapuhan mesti “dirayakan.” Kendatipun pertanyaan-pertanyaan di atas cukup untuk mendasari oposisi terhadap sikap semacam ini, bagi saya oposisi itu diperkuat oleh pembacaan saya atas gagasan filosofis <a href="https://www.google.co.id/books/edition/BEYOND_GOOD_AND_EVIL/mAJSX5jMeV4C?hl=id&amp;gbpv=0&amp;bsq=Friedrich%20Nietzsche%20Beyond%20Good%20and%20Evil">Friedrich Nietzsche</a> empat tahun silam. Ketika para kolega saya merayakan kerapuhan, pikiran saya penuh oleh ide-ide seperti <em>übermensch </em>dan “Dionysian ‘yes’ to life” yang merayakan kekuatan (baik fisik maupun mental) serta kehendak untuk berkuasa. Di benak saya kala itu, para penyanjung kerapuhan tak lebih dari sekumpulan orang lemah yang berusaha mengangkat diri dari lumpur kelemahan lewat pemahaman teologis yang tidak umum. Mungkin pertanyaan tentang tindakan ideal gereja di masa pandemi hingga pascapandemi penting untuk dibahas, tetapi jawabannya tidak semestinya mereduksi watak dan martabat Allah.</p><p>Namun, belakangan saya menyadari bahwa “kerapuhan” dalam tesis kerapuhan ilahi di atas jauh lebih kompleks dari sekadar kelemahan atau keringkihan belaka. Kesadaran ini timbul ketika saya melihat kembali karya Stalsett dan Adiprasetya yang masing-masing membahas definisi kerapuhan<em> </em>di bagian awalnya. Ketika dibaca secara saksama, keduanya secara tersirat mengandaikan bahwa kerapuhan selalu berkenaan dengan <em>relasionalitas</em>. Kerapuhan hakiki (kefanaan, risiko universal untuk terekspos pada bahaya) dan kerapuhan situasional (distribusi risiko tersebut menurut kondisi sosial-budaya) sama-sama berakar pada kemampuan setiap insan untuk <em>dipengaruhi oleh sang liyan</em> — oleh segala sesuatu yang ada di luar diri mereka. Alhasil, bila seseorang sungguh tidak rapuh, ia akan menjalani eksistensinya seperti makhluk yang hidup di dalam gelembung dunianya sendiri, terpisah dari segala sesuatu yang ada. Bukan hanya tubuhnya yang tidak akan hancur, jiwanya juga tidak akan menunjukkan gejolak yang timbul karena pengaruh lingkungan sekitarnya, seperti rasa khawatir, amarah, bahagia, dan cinta. Dengan kata lain, manusia yang tidak rapuh adalah manusia yang kebal fisik dan lebih dingin daripada para psikopat.</p><p>Jika akar kerapuhan adalah relasionalitas dan bukan keringkihan belaka, maka wajar bagi para teolog seperti Sölle, Placher, Stalsett, dan Adiprasetya untuk menandaskan bahwa Allah Kekristenan adalah Allah yang rapuh. Dalam setidaknya <a href="https://www.google.co.id/books/edition/_/WCUqAQAAMAAJ?hl=id&amp;sa=X&amp;ved=2ahUKEwjsz6is__uRAxWRxzgGHZKdFUgQre8FegQIDBAL">dua</a> <a href="https://www.google.co.id/books/edition/Evil_and_the_Justice_of_God/-MvjWwZUz0kC?hl=id&amp;gbpv=0">karyanya</a>, pakar teologi Perjanjian Baru N. T. Wright menandaskan bahwa ciri khas iman monoteistik (khususnya Yudaisme dan Kekristenan) adalah pengakuannya akan Allah yang menyejarah. Allah monoteisme, menurut Wright, bukanlah Allah yang menciptakan semesta lalu menyingkir layaknya seorang pembuat jam. Ia juga bukan Allah yang sejak awal menempatkan diri sedemikian jauh dari semesta dan tidak peduli pada nasib ciptaan-Nya sendiri. Allah monoteisme adalah Allah yang dalam kedaulatan dan kebebasan mutlak-Nya memilih untuk menciptakan semesta dan memilih untuk dipengaruhi oleh ciptaan-Nya itu. Pilihan inilah yang mendorong-Nya untuk menyusun rencana keselamatan — mulai dari membuat perjanjian dengan Abraham hingga menggenapinya melalui inkarnasi, kematian, dan kebangkitan Kristus di dalam kuasa Roh Kudus. Argumen Wright mengindikasikan bahwa Allah monoteisme adalah Allah yang relasional. Pada gilirannya, Allah yang relasional adalah Allah yang rapuh.</p><p>Lebih lanjut, validitas tesis kerapuhan ilahi juga diperkuat oleh antropomorfisme (penggambaran manusiawi atas Allah) yang berserakan di seluruh Kitab Suci kita. Perhatikan misalnya Kejadian 6 yang menyatakan bahwa Allah <em>menyesal</em> telah menjadikan manusia di bumi. Kendatipun istilah Ibrani yang darinya kata “menyesal” ini diterjemahkan, <em>nacham</em>, hanya menandai perubahan sikap Allah semata (sehingga Ia tidak benar-benar menyesal seperti manusia), tidak bisa dipungkiri bahwa perubahan sikap itu terjadi karena kejahatan manusia di bumi “memilukan hati-Nya” (Ibr. <em>wayyt’atzev el-libo</em>). Allah yang sama sekali tidak rapuh tidak akan mengalami perasaan yang demikian selepas melihat perilaku ciptaan-Nya, apalagi mengubah sikap-Nya karena perilaku itu. Ia akan sibuk dengan kebahagiaan-Nya sendiri, melakukan entah apa yang Ia selalu lakukan sebelum menjadikan semesta.</p><p>Antropomorfisme yang mendukung validitas kerapuhan ilahi juga terdapat dalam teks-teks Kitab Suci yang menyatakan bahwa Allah <em>mengingat</em> (mis. Kej. 8:1; 19:29; 30:22; Kel. 2:24; Luk. 1:54–55). Teks-teks tersebut menunjukkan bahwa ketika Allah mengingat, Ia tidak hanya memanggil ulang memori-Nya layaknya manusia yang sedang menghafalkan suatu informasi atau bernostalgia. Setiap kali Allah mengingat, Ia selalu melakukan tindakan yang membawa keselamatan dan berkat bagi umat-Nya, mulai dari Nuh (diselamatkan dari air bah), Lot (diselamatkan dari kehancuran Sodom), Rahel (dianugerahi anak), hingga bangsa Israel (dibebaskan dari perbudakan) dan seluruh umat manusia (dibebaskan dari dosa dan maut oleh karya Kristus). Jika aksi memanggil ulang memori demi bernostalgia saja sudah mengisyaratkan kerapuhan (sebab memori tersebut terbentuk oleh relasi antara insan yang bersangkutan dan sang liyan di masa lampau), maka terlebih lagi aksi mengingat Allah yang berujung pada tindakan aktif-Nya demi kesejahteraan manusia yang Ia ciptakan.</p><p>Di titik ini, Anda mungkin bertanya: bagaimana kerapuhan yang berbasis pada relasionalitas itu berdampak pada pengakuan aksiomatik bahwa Allah itu mahakuasa? Akankah kerapuhan yang demikian menafikan kemahakuasaan Allah?</p><p>Untuk menjawab pertanyaan tersebut, kita perlu mengklarifikasi satu hal penting. Dengan kemanusiaan Kristus sebagai pengecualian, tesis kerapuhan ilahi tidak menekankan bahwa Allah menanggung kerapuhan hakiki ataupun situasional layaknya manusia. Pada dirinya sendiri, Allah tidak fana sebagaimana manusia fana. Allah tidak terekspos pada bahaya dari ciptaan-Nya sebagaimana manusia senantiasa terancam oleh faktor lingkungan (mis. perubahan iklim, bencana, dan kejahatan moral). Kerapuhan Allah persis terletak pada kemampuan-Nya untuk dipengaruhi oleh segala sesuatu yang bersifat liyan bagi-Nya, termasuk situasi dan perilaku kita, para ciptaan-Nya. Ketika Ia menyesal, mengingat, dan bertindak, itu tidak berarti bahwa keadaan kekal-Nya berubah. Implikasinya, tesis kerapuhan ilahi tidak menabrak pengakuan akan kemahakuasaan Allah sama sekali. Di luar sengsara dan wafat Kristus, tesis tersebut tidak sekalipun menyiratkan bahwa Allah itu lemah dan ringkih layaknya ciptaan.</p><p>Lalu, bagaimana halnya dengan sengsara dan wafat Kristus sendiri? Masih bisakah kita memandangnya sebagai <em>ultimate flex</em> dari kemahakuasaan Allah?</p><p>Mengingat bahwa tesis kerapuhan ilahi sama sekali tidak berdampak pada kemahakuasaan Allah, sebenarnya pandangan yang demikian tetap sah secara logis. Namun, saya kira, bila kita mengakui kesaksian rasul Yohanes bahwa “Allah adalah kasih” (1 Yoh. 4:8) — yang dalam kerangka kerapuhan ilahi bisa dibaca sebagai penekanan bahwa kasih adalah fondasi dari seluruh kerapuhan Allah — maka imajinasi <em>ultimate flex </em>di atas tidak bisa dipertahankan secara teologis. Alih-alih menghasrati pengakuan akan kemahakuasaan-Nya, Allah yang merapuh dalam kasih adalah Allah yang merengkuh penderitaan dan kematian manusiawi sebagai wujud jawaban afirmatif-Nya bagi umat manusia, dan pada gilirannya seluruh ciptaan. Inilah yang Paulus maksud tatkala ia berkata bahwa “Kristus adalah ‘ya’ bagi semua janji Allah” (2 Kor. 1:20). Ia melihat kita, dalam segala dosa dan cacat cela kita, dan tetap berkata, “Ya! Kamu semua adalah milik-Ku, dan Aku mengasihimu senantiasa.”</p><p>Dengan demikian, bagian ini telah mendemonstrasikan bahwa tesis kerapuhan ilahi yang diusung terutama oleh Placher, Stalsett, dan Adiprasetya valid dan dapat dipertanggungjawabkan secara teologis. Penjelasan ini tentu jauh dari sempurna, dan karenanya saya tidak heran bila Anda masih belum bersedia menerima tesis tersebut (meskipun saya berharap Anda mulai memahami nilai argumentatifnya). Saya pun mencukupkan diskusi tentang teologi kerapuhan dari sisi Allah di sini. Pasalnya, perenungan atas kerapuhan ilahi tidak akan lengkap, apalagi relevan, bila kita tidak menarik implikasinya pada pemahaman kita atas manusia — atas diri kita sendiri.</p><h3>Homo vulnerabilis</h3><p>Dalam bab pertama dari <a href="https://banneroftruth.org/uk/store/theology/institutes/">mahakaryanya</a> yang masih dibaca oleh umat Kristen Protestan (khususnya gereja-gereja Reformed) hingga kini, John Calvin menandaskan bahwa seluruh kebijaksanaan secara garis besar terbagi dalam dua kategori: pengetahuan tentang Allah dan pengetahuan tentang manusia. Calvin meyakini bahwa kedua kategori tersebut saling terpaut. Pengetahuan tentang Allah mengantarkan manusia untuk mengenal dirinya sendiri, sedangkan pengetahuan tentang manusia pada gilirannya membawanya untuk menghadap Allah.</p><p>Saya memulai bagian ini dengan klaim Calvin karena, kendatipun diajukan pada abad keenam belas, ia sesungguhnya berakar pada dalil teologis yang lebih tua, yakni citra Allah (<em>imago Dei</em>). Ribuan tahun sebelum Calvin berkiprah, penulis kitab Kejadian sudah bersaksi bahwa manusia diciptakan menurut gambar dan rupa Allah (Kej. 1:26–27; 5:1–3), dan penulis Perjanjian Baru seperti Paulus (Rm. 8:29; Kol. 3:10) serta Yakobus (3:9) kembali menegaskan kesaksian itu seturut teologi dan agenda mereka masing-masing. Secara keseluruhan, dalil citra Allah menegaskan bahwa, tanpa menafikan kesenjangan hakiki yang ada di antara keduanya, Allah dan manusia sesungguhnya saling mencerminkan satu sama lain. Penegasan ini signifikan untuk perbincangan teologis apapun, tak terkecuali teologi kerapuhan, sebab itu berarti pengakuan akan kerapuhan ilahi memiliki implikasi bagi pemahaman kita akan cara memanusia yang ideal.</p><p>Dengan demikian, sudah sepantasnya diskursus tentang kerapuhan ilahi berujung pada perumusan suatu “antropologi kerapuhan.” Bahkan, Stalsett dan Adiprasetya bergerak selangkah lebih jauh dengan merumuskan “politik kerapuhan” dan “eklesiologi kerapuhan.” Bertolak dari <em>Deus vulnerabilis</em>, Stalsett mengkritik keras gagasan liberal klasik bahwa manusia adalah subjek otonom yang terisolasi dari sesamanya dan secara konstan berkonflik dengan satu sama lain demi kelangsungan hidupnya. Dalam pandangan yang demikian, kerapuhan adalah musuh yang perlu diatasi demi menjamin kemampuan manusia — dan pada gilirannya negara — untuk bertahan hidup. Sebaliknya, bagi Stalsett, kerapuhan manusiawi justru merupakan <em>fitur</em> atau <em>kemampuan</em> yang berperan vital bagi kesejahteraan hidup manusia. Sebab, hanya karena kerapuhannyalah manusia bisa menjalin relasi dengan sesamanya.</p><p>Pada gilirannya, perengkuhan kerapuhan sebagai elemen konstruktif dari kehidupan manusia menuntut pendefinisian ulang atas makna kuasa dalam konteks politik. Alih-alih memandang kuasa sebagai hak milik atau kapasitas untuk mendominasi yang lain, Stalsett mengusulkan agar kita memahami kuasa sebagai komitmen timbal-balik antara orang-orang yang saling mengakui kerapuhan hakiki dan situasional mereka. Di tengah dunia yang dipenuhi oleh pemimpin populis dan otoriter, politik kerapuhan Stalsett menawarkan “komunitas-dalam-kerapuhan” (<em>community-in-vulnerability</em>), suatu cara bermasyarakat yang melindungi kebersamaan tanpa membangun tembok pembatas. Di dalamnya, setiap nyawa dianggap berharga dan dilindungi, sebab lewat inkarnasi dan ketaatan Kristus, Allah telah menunjukkan bahwa tidak satupun nyawa di bumi bisa disia-siakan.</p><p>Memakai kerangka kerapuhan yang mirip dengan Stalsett sebagai titik tolaknya, Adiprasetya melontarkan kritik pada sebagian besar gereja di dunia yang masih hidup menurut mentalitas bisnis. Menurutnya, gereja perlu meninggalkan tolok ukur pelayanan berbasis jumlah kehadiran, variasi aktivitas, ukuran gedung, dan nominal kas. Tuntutan pertobatan ini mendesak, sebab ketika gereja-gereja beralih dari peribadahan luar jaringan (<em>on-site</em>) ke dalam jaringan, mereka masih menjalankan mentalitas bisnis yang sama — hanya saja tolok ukurnya berubah menjadi jumlah <em>likes</em>, <em>followers</em>, dan <em>viewers</em> — sembari acuh tak acuh pada kengerian yang meliputi dunia akibat situasi pandemi Covid-19. Sebagai alternatif, Adiprasetya mengajukan model menggereja “proflektif,” suatu cara menggereja yang berpusat pada kemampuannya untuk meninggalkan pola-pola yang tak lagi konstruktif (<em>unlearning</em>), menghadapi kehilangan (<em>facing loss</em>), dan mengkaji ulang nilai-nilai yang diusungnya (<em>navigating</em> <em>competing values</em>).</p><p>Perengkuhan akan kerapuhan hakiki dan situasional manusia menyusupi uraian Adiprasetya atas ketiga kemampuan tersebut. Dalam proses <em>unlearning</em>, merengkuh kerapuhan berarti menyadari bahwa pandemi Covid-19 telah menimbulkan trauma pada banyak orang; dan karenanya gereja mesti menghindari kecenderungan untuk berteologi secara reaktif serta bersedia untuk memproses trauma itu dengan memasuki keheningan. Dalam proses <em>facing loss</em>, gereja yang merengkuh kerapuhan adalah gereja yang menyediakan ruang untuk meratap dan mengakui ketidaktahuannya akan masa depan, tanpa terjebak dalam hasrat untuk segera menyelesaikan ataupun menjelaskan ketidaktahuan itu. Dalam proses <em>navigating competing values</em>, gereja yang merengkuh kerapuhan adalah gereja yang beroperasi menurut kebajikan Kristiani, alih-alih visi korporat; dan karenanya mereka tak boleh lagi membiarkan diri disetir oleh motif-motif pasar. Adiprasetya membayangkan bahwa gereja yang berhasil melaksanakan ketiga proses ini akan berjalan perlahan ke masa depan sembari “menerima kerapuhan komunalnya dan terbuka pada kerapuhan penduduk semesta” (hlm. 52), baik di masa pandemi maupun pascapandemi.</p><p>Saya menilai bahwa penarikan implikasi tesis kerapuhan ilahi oleh Stalsett dan Adiprasetya di atas sudah matang, dan karenanya saya tidak berniat untuk menelaah argumen mereka di sini. Namun (mungkin karena pertanyaan riset mereka yang berwatak spesifik), tampaknya mereka tidak menyoroti dua implikasi yang juga penting dari tesis tersebut bagi cara kita memanusia dalam konteks yang lebih fondasional. Bagian ini bermaksud menambahkan setitik kontribusi pada temuan mereka dengan menelusuri kedua implikasi itu. Keduanya saling terpaut, dan karenanya saya mulai dari yang berwatak lebih umum: bahwa secara <em>teologis</em>, kerapuhan adalah <em>fitur</em> <em>inheren</em> manusia, alih-alih kekurangan yang mesti dibasmi.</p><p>Di titik ini, Anda mungkin mengira bahwa saya hanya mengulang kembali apa yang telah disampaikan oleh Stalsett. Perkiraan yang demikian masuk akal, dan karenanya saya mengklarifikasi bahwa arah dari apa yang hendak saya sampaikan berbeda dengan Stalsett, meskipun poin besarnya sama. Perbedaan ini bersumber dari titik tolak saya: klaim Calvin dan dalil citra Allah. Jika Allah dan manusia saling mencerminkan satu sama lain, dan Allah itu rapuh, maka kerapuhan manusia semestinya dipandang sebagai fitur inheren dari citra Allah. Di sini, kita secara spesifik membahas kerapuhan dalam arti relasionalnya: kemampuan untuk dipengaruhi oleh sang liyan. Allah sendiri memilih untuk merapuh dengan cara yang demikian dalam kedaulatan dan kebebasan mutlak-Nya. Bila kita mengakui bahwa kita diciptakan menurut gambar dan rupa Allah yang sama — yang merengkuh kerapuhan-Nya itu — maka kita hanya bisa mencapai taraf tertinggi dari eksistensi sebagai gambar dan rupa Allah dengan merengkuh kerapuhan kita.</p><p>Merengkuh kerapuhan sebagai manusia berarti tidak menutup diri. Kita perlu membiarkan diri dipengaruhi oleh segala sesuatu di sekitar kita: orang-orang terkasih, si asing, mereka yang dipinggirkan oleh masyarakat, para pengambil kebijakan yang meresahkan, para konglomerat yang menggerogoti bumi, dan bahkan para korban perang serta satwa yang terancam punah. Keterbukaan pada semua hal ini tentu menimbulkan keresahan. Kehidupan sehari-hari kita tidak akan tenang, apalagi di era digital yang di dalamnya semua informasi tersebar begitu cepat. Namun, keresahan itu esensial bila kita ingin hidup sebagai citra Allah yang utuh. Sebagaimana Allah lantas bertindak demi umat-Nya setelah Ia mengingat mereka, demikian pula keresahan yang timbul dari kerapuhan memanggil kita untuk melakukan sesuatu bagi dunia di sekitar kita. Tentu saja, kita perlu memperhitungkan kerapuhan situasional dalam menghayati panggilan tersebut. Setiap orang memiliki kapabilitas berbeda. Yang esensial adalah kita memilih untuk bertindak seturut kemampuan kita. Komunitas-dalam-kerapuhan Stalsett dan gereja proflektif Adiprasetya hanya bisa mewujud nyata bila kita terus-menerus memilih untuk merapuh ketimbang terjebak dalam diri kita sendiri (<a href="https://www.bloomsbury.com/us/gravity-of-sin-9780567031389/"><em>incurvatus in se</em></a>); suatu sikap yang digolongkan sebagai dosa oleh teolog-teolog besar, mulai dari Augustinus, Martin Luther, hingga Karl Barth.</p><p>Implikasi kedua, yang sedikit banyak berkaitan dengan yang pertama, adalah pernikahan merupakan ekspresi paling fundamental sekaligus paling dalam dari kerapuhan manusia. Saya tidak mengetahui secara pasti berapa sering teolog Kristen atau pendeta mengangkat teologi kerapuhan dalam kaitannya dengan pernikahan Kristiani. Namun, bila memungkinkan, saya mengusulkan agar mereka menjadikan kerapuhan sebagai konsep kunci dalam program bina pranikah mereka. Ini karena terdapat paralel yang begitu kuat antara inkarnasi Kristus dan teks-teks Kitab Suci yang menjadi acuan bagi pernikahan, hingga kaitan antara keduanya sulit untuk dibantah.</p><p>Sudah lazim bagi umat Kristen untuk membaca relasi dua sejoli dalam Kidung Agung sebagai metafora bagi Kristus dan gereja-Nya. Dalam sisa bagian ini, saya akan mencoba untuk menunjukkan bahwa pembacaan yang demikian bisa diperluas dengan menafsirkan kedua sejoli itu sebagai metafora bagi Allah Sang Firman dan manusia, serta, pada gilirannya, penggambaran harfiah atas pernikahan yang ideal.</p><p>Izinkan saya memulai demonstrasi ini dengan mengutip penggalan syair Kidung Agung yang cukup terkenal: “Aku milik kekasihku, dan kekasihku milikku” (6:3a). Bila dibaca dalam keseluruhan pasalnya, kita akan mendapati bahwa nyanyian itu dilantunkan oleh sang mempelai perempuan, yang lazimnya ditafsirkan sebagai gereja, sebagai manusia. Pembacaan standar ini mengandaikan bahwa manusia membuat klaim posesif pada Allah, bahwa mereka pertama-tama adalah milik Allah sebelum Allah menjadi milik mereka. Kita tentu bisa membantah paruh terakhir dari klaim tersebut. Allah bukanlah milik siapapun, sebab kedaulatan dan kebebasan mutlak-Nya mencegah manusia untuk mendefinisikan-Nya sebagai kepunyaan atau properti. Namun, pasal selanjutnya lantas membenarkan paruh pertama dari klaim itu: “Milikkulah kekasihku, kepadaku gairahnya tertuju” (Kid. 7:10). Nyanyian ini dikumandangkan oleh sang mempelai laki-laki, yang lazimnya ditafsirkan sebagai Allah sendiri. “Milikkulah kekasihku” — dengan penafsiran umum sebagai titik berangkat, kita bisa menautkan klaim posesif itu dengan jawaban afirmatif Allah kepada seluruh manusia, yaitu Kristus yang, menurut kesaksian Paulus, adalah “ya” bagi semua janji Allah. Dan karena janji Allah sejak awal tertuju pada penuntasan dosa Adam (sebagaimana tercermin dalam tipologi Adam-Kristus yang muncul dalam Rm. 5:12–21), maka Kristus sekaligus juga adalah jawaban “ya” Allah bagi manusia, dan pada gilirannya bagi seluruh ciptaan-Nya.</p><p>Bila Anda mengira bahwa penautan antara klaim posesif mempelai pria dalam Kidung Agung dan status Kristus sebagai “ya” Allah ini hanya cocoklogi belaka, perkenankanlah saya untuk membawa Anda melalui sebuah jalan yang agak memutar dengan merujuk pada salah satu doktrin inti dalam Kristologi gereja, yaitu persatuan hipostatik. Di abad kelima, bapak-bapak gereja sepakat untuk mengaku bahwa Kristus adalah sepenuhnya ilahi, sama seperti Allah Bapa, dan sepenuhnya insani, sama seperti kita. Terdapat perbedaan mengenai bagaimana keilahian dan kemanusiaan itu mesti didefinisikan; dan ini menimbulkan skisma besar di dalam gereja. Tetapi, terlepas dari skisma tersebut, gereja di seluruh dunia sepakat bahwa kendatipun Kristus [seolah] memiliki hakikat ganda (ilahi-insani), Ia mewujud nyata di tengah dunia sebagai pribadi tunggal. Kristus bukanlah persatuan antara Firman Allah yang bersifat ilahi dan manusia Yesus, hingga sosok yang dipersaksikan oleh keempat injil itu memiliki kepribadian ganda. Ia adalah Firman Allah yang mengenakan kedagingan manusia sedemikian erat pada diri-Nya sendiri, layaknya seseorang yang mengenakan baju dan menjadi begitu menyatu dengan bajunya itu, sekalipun tidak bercampur dengannya. Kurang lebih demikianlah bapak-bapak gereja memahami rumusan “Firman itu menjadi manusia” (Yun. <em>Logos sarx egeneto</em>) dalam Yohanes 1:14.</p><p>Signifikansi dari persatuan hipostatik ini sulit untuk dilebih-lebihkan, terutama mengingat kesenjangan yang timbul antara manusia dan Allah karena dosa Adam. Kitab Suci dengan jelas menyatakan bahwa manusia yang mengabaikan kesenjangan tersebut dan berupaya untuk melihat Allah secara langsung akan mati, sebab hakikatnya yang rusak tidak mampu menanggung kekudusan Allah. “Tidak mungkin manusia melihat Aku dan tetap hidup,” firman Allah kepada Musa (Kel. 33:20, bdk. Kej. 32:30; Hak. 13:22; Yes. 6:5). Penulis surat 1 Timotius pun bersaksi bahwa Allah “bersemayam dalam terang yang tak terhampiri, yang tidak pernah dilihat dan tidak dapat dilihat oleh seorangpun” (6:16). Dengan demikian, kemanusiaan Kristus pastilah memperoleh perlakuan khusus dari Allah agar Ia tidak segera mati tatkala bersatu dengan Sang Firman di dalam kandungan Bunda Perawan Maria. Di dalam perlakuan khusus yang misterius ini terselip ujaran Allah yang tampak jelas, sekalipun tak terkatakan secara gamblang. Dalam bahasa Kidung Agung, Ia berkata: “Ya. Milik-Kulah engkau, hai kekasih-Ku.”</p><p>Selepas persatuan hipostatik terjadi, kedagingan manusia Kristus bertumbuh dewasa. Lalu tibalah saat bagi-Nya untuk menjalankan ketaatan yang gagal dilakukan oleh Israel — ketaatan yang membawa-Nya hingga menderita dan mati di kayu salib. Selama karya insani-Nya berlangsung, Ia berulang kali menjangkau para pendosa dan sampah masyarakat, orang-orang yang sama yang semestinya tidak akan hidup setelah melihat wajah-Nya. Dalam satu kesempatan, Allah Sang Firman yang begitu mulia itu mengidentifikasi diri-Nya dengan orang-orang “yang paling hina” (Mat. 25:40). Dalam kesempatan lain, Ia mengangkat manusia yang hina dina itu menjadi sahabat-Nya — “Aku menyebut kamu sahabat” (Yoh. 15:15). Keadaan ilahi-Nya tidak memungkinkan-Nya untuk menderita dan mati; tetapi karena Ia menyatu begitu rupa dengan kedagingan manusia dan mengambilnya sebagai milik-Nya sendiri, Ia merasakan setiap pukulan, setiap cambukan, setiap hinaan, dan setiap tusukan hingga Ia meregang nyawa dan wafat. Sekalipun begitu, Ia membangkitkan kedagingan manusia itu dari kematian dan mengangkatnya naik ke surga. Seluruh rangkaian peristiwa ini menyatakan dimensi kerapuhan Allah yang paling intim dengan umat manusia yang diciptakan-Nya menurut gambar dan rupa-Nya, hingga, bila dirumuskan dalam bahasa Kidung Agung, ia tampak seperti rumusan janji nikah.</p><blockquote><em>Baik dalam lumpur dosa maupun kekudusan, baik dalam penderitaan maupun sukacita, baik dalam keadaan hina maupun mulia, baik di atas kayu salib maupun di sebelah kanan Bapa, baik dalam kematian maupun kehidupan, engkau adalah milik-Ku dan akan selalu menjadi milik-Ku, hai kekasih-Ku; dan Aku akan selalu mencintaimu.</em></blockquote><p>Kini kita kembali ke Kidung Agung, dan saya mengajak Anda untuk membacanya sebagaimana adanya — bukan sebagai metafora bagi Kristus dan manusia, tetapi sebagai ekspresi cinta antara dua sejoli. Di titik ini, Anda mungkin akan merasa bahwa ada sesuatu yang kurang. Nyanyian timbal balik antara mempelai perempuan dan laki-laki itu hampir selalu berbentuk sanjungan. Nyaris tak ada bagian yang menegaskan bahwa mereka akan selalu menjadi milik satu sama lain baik dalam keadaan suka maupun duka. Bila kita kembali mengenakan lensa Kristosentris, kita akan mendapati bahwa karya Kristus pada gilirannya melengkapi nyanyian kedua sejoli dengan penerimaan mempelai laki-laki atas aspek-aspek kedirian yang tak elok dari mempelai perempuan, demikian pula sebaliknya. Dengan menerima satu sama lain apa adanya, cinta yang mengikat kedua sejoli itu kini mencapai tingkatan tertingginya: sungguh-sungguh menjadi satu daging (Kej. 2:24; Mat. 19:5; Mrk. 10:8; Ef. 5:31), sebagaimana Allah dan insan pun sungguh menjadi satu di dalam diri Kristus. Cinta tertinggi, dengan demikian, adalah cinta yang merengkuh kerapuhan manusiawi seutuhnya tanpa sekalipun goyah, “baik dalam keadaan kaya maupun miskin, dalam keadaan baik maupun buruk, dalam keadaan sehat maupun sakit, hingga maut memisahkan.” Ia adalah pilihan bebas yang diambil oleh sepasang kekasih untuk terpengaruh dan memengaruhi satu sama lain dalam tingkat yang paling fundamental, paling intim, tanpa jalan keluar.</p><h3>Coda</h3><p>Seluruh tulisan kecil ini saya mulai sebagai upaya untuk melihat kembali suatu tesis — kerapuhan ilahi — dengan mata yang baru dan menelusuri konsekuensi-konsekuensi teologisnya. Kini, saya menutupnya bukan dengan kesimpulan yang baku, melainkan dengan sebuah undangan.</p><p>Saya mengundang Anda, para pembaca, untuk mencoba memegang kerapuhan sebagai “kunci hermeneutis” dan menggunakannya untuk membuka makna dari proposisi-proposisi iman yang selama ini kita yakini. “Allah adalah kasih,” misalnya, bukan hanya sekadar pernyataan tentang sifat, tetapi juga tentang keberanian ilahi untuk berelasi dan menanggung risikonya. “Gambar dan rupa Allah” bukan lagi sekadar martabat statis, melainkan kapasitas dinamis manusia untuk terpengaruh dan mempengaruhi sang liyan. “Karya keselamatan Kristus” tak lagi terdengar sebagai rencana taktis yang jauh, tetapi sebagai “ya!” yang bergema dari Sang Kekal kepada yang fana.</p><p>Akhirnya, inilah yang mungkin tersisa setelah semua analisis kita: sebuah ajakan untuk berhenti memandang kerapuhan sebagai patologi — baik bagi Allah maupun bagi ciptaan-Nya. Semua ini mungkin akan tetap terasa ganjil, seperti sebuah nada sumbang di tengah simfoni Barok yang indah dan teknis. Namun, saya rasa keganjilan itu justru menjadi pengingat bahwa kita sedang membicarakan sesosok Pribadi, bukan sekumpulan ide belaka. Dalam kedaulatan-Nya yang tak terselami, Pribadi itu memilih untuk membiarkan hati-Nya tersentuh, terluka, dan bergembira oleh ciptaan-Nya. Pilihan itu mengubah segalanya: cara kita memandang salib, gereja, sesama, bahkan cinta. Mungkin, perubahan terdalam yang ditimbulkannya adalah cara kita memandang wajah kita sendiri di cermin. Di sana, kita perlahan tapi pasti belajar untuk berkata — dalam segala kefanaan dan kegetiran kita — “Inilah aku, citra dari Allah yang rapuh.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8211dde68338" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Injil dan Kontradiksi]]></title>
            <link>https://thescrapbook.medium.com/injil-dan-kontradiksi-fa346b95c2e7?source=rss-a46f79a1ed6f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fa346b95c2e7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[alkitab]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[paulus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[injil]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[karl-barth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kristen]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lumbanbatu Kornelius]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Feb 2026 12:51:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-06T12:51:35.105Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*KrxpC2DW6FWEzTmQu0VL8A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Dalam pembacaannya atas Roma 1:16–17, teolog Reformed kondang <a href="https://books.google.co.id/books/about/The_Epistle_to_the_Romans.html?id=dCEDzQhI4R4C&amp;redir_esc=y">Karl Barth</a> (1886–1968) mesti berhadapan dengan fakta pelik bahwa kematian dan kebangkitan Yesus Kristus belum menimbulkan perubahan substansial yang berarti di tengah dunia. Ia berkata bahwa sekalipun Injil “adalah pertanda, alarm bagi suatu dunia baru yang sedang datang” (bdk. 2 Kor. 5:17), “seluruh beban dosa dan seluruh kutukan maut masih memberi tekanan besar atas kita” (hlm. 38). “Kita tidak boleh berada dalam ilusi,” serunya, sebab “realitas eksistensi masa kini kita berlanjut sebagaimana adanya!” (<em>ibid</em>).</p><p>Mengapa fakta pelik tersebut signifikan? Jawabnya adalah karena sejak awal, Barth meyakini bahwa kedatangan Kristus telah menyebabkan perubahan radikal dalam sejarah manusia. Tatkala membaca frasa “Yesus Kristus Tuhan kita” dalam Roma 1:4, ia berkata bahwa, “Nama Yesus mendefinisikan suatu kejadian historis dan menandai titik di mana dunia yang tidak dikenal memotong dunia yang dikenal” (hlm. 29). Perpotongan ini mentransformasi “waktu dan segala sesuatu” (hlm. 31), dan ia memuncak pada peristiwa kebangkitan, yang di dalamnya “dunia baru Roh Kudus menyentuh dunia kedagingan yang lama” (hlm. 30). Layaknya “garis tangen yang menyentuh sebuah lingkaran,” dunia baru ini sama sekali tidak menimbulkan “peleburan atau percampuran antara Allah dan manusia” (<em>ibid</em>). Tetapi, Barth tidak memungkiri bahwa suatu perubahan penting sudah terjadi di dalam semesta. Melalui kehadiran Kristus “di dunia dan dalam hidup kita,” katanya, “kita telah hancur sebagai manusia dan diteguhkan di dalam Allah” (<em>ibid</em>). Manusia tidak lagi menjadi tuan atas dirinya sendiri, dan jerat dosa serta maut tidak lagi mengikat mereka.</p><p>Kembali ke pokok persoalan: dalam cara pandang dialektis yang khas bagi para intelektual Jerman abad ke-20, Barth lantas melihat bahwa kesuraman dunia yang belum terselesaikan selepas kebangkitan Kristus itu menyiratkan secercah pengharapan. “Persis karena seruan ‘tidak’ dari Allah mencakup semuanya, itu juga adalah ‘ya’ dari-Nya” (hlm. 38). Ketika kondisi kita masih tertahan oleh peristiwa kebangkitan (Barth berkata bahwa, “Kebangkitan, yang adalah tempat keluar, juga menghalangi kita, sebab ia adalah jalan keluar sekaligus penghalang”), Injil mendorong kita untuk hidup dalam antisipasi atas datangnya Kerajaan Allah layaknya penjaga yang mengantisipasi datangnya fajar (<em>ibid</em>). Barth memperkuat anjuran tersebut dengan mengutip Habakuk 2:1–3.</p><blockquote><em>Aku akan berdiri di tempat penjagaanku dan bertahan di menara; aku akan meninjau untuk melihat apa yang akan difirmankan-Nya kepadaku, dan apa yang akan dijawab-Nya terhadap pengaduanku. TUHAN menjawab aku, kata-Nya, ‘Tuliskanlah penglihatan ini dan ukirkanlah itu pada loh-loh batu, supaya orang sambil lalu dapat membacanya. Sebab penglihatan itu masih menanti saatnya, tetapi dengan segera menuju kesudahannya, dan bukan tipuan. Meskipun lambat, nantikanlah itu, sebab hal itu pasti akan datang dan tidak akan tertunda’. (TB2 LAI)</em></blockquote><p>Mengingat situasi dunia saat ini, sulit memungkiri bahwa anjuran tersebut masuk akal dan cukup berguna bagi kita, umat Kristen. Akan tetapi, kita tidak bisa mengatakan hal yang sama tentang premis yang mendahuluinya; dan Barth pun tampaknya sadar akan hal itu. Mungkin kesadaran inilah yang menyebabkan ia segera mengalihkan perhatiannya pada kontradiksi yang meliputi penjelasannya tentang Injil. Barth mengutip pernyataan <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/kierkega/">Søren Kierkegaard</a> (1813–1855) bahwa watak asing Kristus merupakan bukti dari keilahian-Nya, dan ia mengikuti pernyataan tersebut dengan argumen bahwa kuasa Allah yang menyelamatkan kita pun begitu asing, hingga “ia hanya bisa muncul di tengah kita, diterima dan dipahami oleh kita, sebagai kontradiksi” (hlm. 38). Argumen ini lantas dilanjutkan dengan kutipan yang cukup panjang atas amatan <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/luther/">Martin Luther</a> (1483–1546) tentang tindakan Allah yang paradoksal di sepanjang Kitab Suci. Tepat setelah mengutip Luther, Barth menyajikan argumen intinya mengenai kontradiksi dalam Injil.</p><blockquote><em>Injil keselamatan hanya bisa dipercayai; ia adalah perkara iman semata. Ia menuntut pilihan. Inilah keseriusannya. Untuk orang yang tidak cukup dewasa untuk menerima sebuah kontradiksi dan berdiam di dalamnya, Injil menjadi sebuah skandal — untuk dia yang tidak mampu menghindar dari keniscayaan kontradiksi, Injil menjadi perkara iman. Iman adalah perasaan kagum di hadapan kehadiran ilahi yang samar-samar (</em>the divine incognito<em>); itulah kasih kepada Allah yang sadar akan perbedaan kualitatif antara Allah dan manusia serta Allah dan dunia; itulah afirmasi kebangkitan sebagai titik balik dunia; dan karenanya itulah afirmasi dari ‘Tidak’ ilahi di dalam Kristus, dari penghentian menghancurkan di hadapan Allah. (hlm. 39)</em></blockquote><p>Dengan demikian, Barth berargumen bahwa Injil dan kontradiksi adalah dua hal yang tidak bisa dipisahkan. Ketidakmampuan dalam menerima kontradiksi logis adalah penghalang mendasar dalam penerimaan Injil; dan solusinya adalah memilih untuk percaya. Inilah yang membedakan antara mereka yang memperoleh rahmat keselamatan dan yang tidak memperolehnya. Ketika orang yang tidak percaya mencap Injil sebagai sebuah “skandal,” umat percaya…</p><blockquote><em>…meletakkan rasa percayanya pada Allah sendiri; yang berarti, orang-orang itu, memandang kesetiaan Allah dalam fakta bahwa Ia telah meletakkan kita dalam suatu area yang berkontradiksi terhadap arah dunia ini, merespons kesetiaan Allah dengan kesetiaan yang sesuai, dan bersama Allah berkata ‘Walaupun begitu’ dan ‘Sekalipun demikian’. (</em>ibid<em>)</em></blockquote><p>Daya persuasif dari rentetan argumen di atas memang cukup tinggi. Sebagian umat Kristen yang membacanya mungkin akan segera menganggukkan kepala mereka; apalagi ketika mengingat pernyataan rasul Paulus bahwa “Allah telah membuat hikmat dunia ini menjadi kebodohan” (1 Kor. 1:20 TB2 LAI).</p><p>Namun, bila kita membongkar retorika yang mengemas alur pemikiran di atas, kita akan mendapati bahwa strategi Barth sejatinya bermasalah. Ia meninggikan problem yang tidak bisa ia atasi dan menghimbau agar kita <em>menerima </em>dan <em>percaya begitu saja </em>akan kuasa kebangkitan Kristus. Himbauan ini diikuti pula dengan upaya mengecilkan hati — jika kita tidak mampu melakukan keduanya, jika kita masih terobsesi dengan ketepatan logika dan tidak membuka diri pada Injil yang secara logis problematik, maka kita bukanlah bagian dari umat yang diselamatkan oleh Allah.</p><p>Kecenderungan Barth untuk memahami Injil dan situasi pelik dunia dalam kerangka berpikir dialektis juga tidak kalah problematik. Pasalnya, fondasi yang membuktikan kebenaran metodologi dan klaimnya belum jelas. Teks Kitab Suci mana yang menekankan bahwa kebangkitan Kristus adalah “jalan keluar sekaligus pembatas”? Apa dasar Barth untuk berkata bahwa kejahatan yang masih merajalela saat ini adalah jawaban “tidak” dari Allah — dan bahwa jawaban “tidak” ini menyiratkan jawaban “ya” di masa depan? Bukankah Paulus sendiri berkata bahwa di dalam Kristus “hanya ada ‘ya’,” karena Ia “adalah ‘ya’ bagi semua janji Allah” (2 Kor. 1:19–20 TB2 LAI)? Mengingat Paulus yang sama juga menulis surat Roma, bukankah itu berarti penafsiran dialektis Barth sudah menyimpangkan makna yang dimaksud oleh penulisnya? Pada gilirannya, pertanyaan ini membuka persoalan yang lebih mendasar, yaitu anakronisme. Benarkah Paulus menulis surat-suratnya dengan memanfaatkan kerangka berpikir dialektis?</p><p>Beberapa di antara kita mungkin akan berargumen bahwa kerangka berpikir dialektis, sekalipun populer di kalangan pemikir Jerman modern, bukanlah produk intelektual baru. <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hegel/">Georg W. F. Hegel</a> (1770–1831), tokoh yang memopulerkan dan mengembangkannya, menyadur kerangka berpikir ini dari para filsuf Yunani kuno yang sudah berkarya jauh sebelum Paulus, seperti Sokrates dan <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/plato/">Plato</a> (429–347 SM). Namun, kita perlu mengingat juga bahwa Paulus sejatinya adalah seorang Yahudi tulen yang merevisi teologinya seturut peristiwa kebangkitan Kristus (Barth sendiri berkata bahwa Paulus adalah seorang Farisi dari “ordo yang lebih tinggi,” lih. hlm. 27). Dengan demikian, teologi Paulus berasal dari kultur yang sama sekali berbeda dengan kultur yang menghasilkan kerangka berpikir dialektis, kendatipun keduanya sama-sama hadir di abad pertama.</p><p>Tentu, terdapat kemungkinan bahwa, sebagai rasul bagi bangsa-bangsa non-Yahudi, Paulus memanfaatkan kerangka berpikir dialektis untuk membuat Injil yang diberitakannya lebih familiar bagi para pendengarnya. Akan tetapi, beban pembuktian (<em>burden of proof</em>) kemungkinan ini ada di atas pundak Barth; dan keenam kata pengantar yang ia tulis untuk tafsiran surat Roma-nya sama sekali tidak memberikan pembuktian yang demikian, sekalipun ia merespons beragam kritik yang dilontarkan padanya.</p><p>Hal ketiga yang juga bermasalah dari justifikasi Barth atas kontradiksi Injil adalah rujukan berulangnya pada watak Allah sebagai sosok yang tak dikenal. Tentu, watak ini memang terindikasi dalam Kitab Suci, sebagaimana terlihat dalam khotbah Paulus di Atena (Kis. 17:23–25). Pemaparan Barth atasnya pun sangat komprehensif dan apik. Saya bahkan sempat menduga bahwa ia mengutip <a href="https://books.google.co.id/books/about/Pseudo_Dionysius.html?id=qFLpXKsNeVYC&amp;redir_esc=y">pseudo-Dionysius Areopagita</a> (kira-kira abad keenam), bapak gereja misterius yang dikenal sebagai orang Kristen pertama yang mengembangkan <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NKdRCBVms3M">teologi apofatik</a>.</p><blockquote><em>Allah adalah Allah yang tak dikenal, dan, persis karena Ia tak dikenal, Ia melimpahkan hidup dan napas dan segala sesuatu. Dengan demikian, kuasa Allah tidak bisa dideteksi di dunia alami ataupun dalam jiwa manusia. Ia tidak boleh dicampuradukkan dengan kuasa tinggi manapun yang bisa dikenali. Kuasa Allah bukanlah kuasa tertinggi dari semua kuasa yang bisa diamati, ataupun gabungan dari seluruh kuasa itu. Karena perbedaan totalnya, ia adalah KRISIS dari semua kuasa, yang dengannya semua kuasa diukur, dan melaluinya ia disebut sebagai sesuatu dan — ketiadaan, ketiadaan dan — sesuatu. …Kuasa Allah tidak berdiri di samping ataupun di atas — supranatural! — kuasa-kuasa terbatas itu. Ia murni dan terkemuka dan — melampaui mereka semua. (hlm. 36)</em></blockquote><p>Masalahnya terletak pada cara Barth memakai premis ini. Karena Allah dan kuasa-Nya tak bisa dikenali oleh manusia, ia berargumen bahwa Injil pun semestinya tak bisa dikenali oleh manusia — dan karenanya mendapatkan dispensasi khusus dari pemeriksaan logis. “Injil tidak masuk ke dalam persaingan dengan banyak upaya untuk menyingkapkan dalam dunia yang dikenal suatu bentuk eksistensi yang lebih tinggi dan kurang lebih tidak dikenal serta membuatnya bisa diakses oleh manusia,” ujarnya (hlm. 35). Lebih lanjut, “Injil bukanlah satu di antara banyak kebenaran. Melainkan, ia menempatkan sebuah tanda tanya melawan semua kebenaran” (<em>ibid</em>). Karena Injil tidak bisa dikenali oleh manusia, wajar bila berita tentang kebangkitan Kristus terbebas dari tuntutan untuk menjelaskan secara koheren alasan peristiwa itu belum menimbulkan perubahan substansial di tengah dunia hingga kini. Kontradiksi lantas menjadi tameng konseptual yang sangat nyaman untuk digunakan di sini — sebab bukankah sesuatu yang tidak dapat dikenali selaras dengan sesuatu yang kontradiktif ketika dipertimbangkan secara rasional?</p><p>Terdapat setidaknya dua kritik yang bisa kita ajukan perihal masalah di atas. Pertama, dengan mengenakan watak “tak bisa dikenali” pada Injil, Barth telah membantah pernyataannya sendiri bahwa Injil merupakan “persepsi yang jelas dan objektif tentang apa yang belum dilihat oleh mata dan belum didengar oleh telinga” (hlm. 28). Nyatanya, satu-satunya yang “jelas” dan “objektif” dalam Injil menurut Barth adalah kontradiksi yang meliputinya — yang mesti diterima bila kita ingin terhitung di antara umat Allah yang diselamatkan. Injil yang Barth paparkan jelas-jelas kabur, dan pembelaan dialektis yang ia berikan tidak membantu mengatasi kekaburan itu sama sekali. Kedua, dengan menautkan dua sifat turunan pada watak “tak bisa dikenali” itu — yaitu bahwa Injil mempertanyakan semua kebenaran dan bahwa ia kontradiktif — Barth secara tersirat telah menambahkan konten positif pada watak yang bersifat negatif. Dengan kata lain, ia mengetahui aspek-aspek apa saja yang tidak bisa dikenali dari Injil. Bukankah ini berarti Barth secara tersirat memiliki suatu pengenalan akan Injil, dan pada gilirannya, akan Allah yang darinya Injil itu berasal? Dari mana pengenalan itu bersumber? Apa tolok ukur dan basisnya?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fa346b95c2e7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Yesus, Ciptaan Belaka?]]></title>
            <link>https://thescrapbook.medium.com/yesus-ciptaan-belaka-4c36173e1834?source=rss-a46f79a1ed6f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4c36173e1834</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[kristen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alkitab]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[yesus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apologetika]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tuhan]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lumbanbatu Kornelius]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Feb 2026 12:48:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-06T12:48:11.449Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1wkr3IX7zJ4br54j" /></figure><p>Sebagai seorang yang berkecimpung di ranah teologi, saya tidak pernah menyukai apologetika. Saya melihat bahwa perdebatan di antara para apologet tidak lebih dari adu jotos intelektual demi ego pribadi belaka. Ironisnya, tak sedikit yang menjadikan aktivitas ini ladang pencaharian mereka — dan tak sedikit pula yang menikmatinya. Para apologet mengangkat nama Allah seraya mencibir pribadi dan kepercayaan lawan bicara mereka, lalu meminta donasi sukarela dari para penonton. Aktivitas seperti ini tidak menghasilkan dampak substansial bagi kehidupan umat beriman. Mungkin, para penonton beroleh kepuasan intelektual. Tetapi, kepuasan itu sama sekali tidak membantu mereka dalam <em>mengerjakan keselamatan mereka</em> (Flp. 2:12; bdk. Rm. 2:13) ataupun <em>melakukan kehendak Allah Bapa</em> (Mat. 7:21–23; bdk. 25:31–46; Luk. 6:46). Alih-alih tenggelam dalam benturan ego yang mengatasnamakan Allah, umat Kristen semestinya memusatkan kehidupan mereka pada dua aktivitas tersebut. Sebab, hanya keduanyalah yang akhirnya menentukan apakah kita ada “di dalam Sang Mesias” dan diperhitungkan sebagai “kawanan domba,” atau di luar Sang Mesias dan disisihkan bersama “kawanan kambing.”</p><p>Dengan demikian, saya sepakat dengan teolog Reformed kondang Karl Barth tatkala ia berkata: “Kecemasan mengenai kemenangan Injil — yaitu, apologetika Kristen — adalah sia-sia, sebab Injil adalah kemenangan yang melampaui dunia” (<em>Epistle to the Romans</em>, hlm. 35). Lagipula, rasul Paulus sendiri bersaksi bahwa Injil tentang Yesus Mesias adalah “kekuatan Allah yang menyelamatkan setiap orang yang percaya” (Rm. 1:16). Kepercayaan itu sendiri adalah karya Allah, bukan hasil jerih payah para penginjil, dan karena itulah Paulus berkata — dalam suratnya yang lain — “tidak ada seorang pun yang dapat mengaku ‘Yesus adalah Tuhan’, selain oleh Roh Kudus” (1 Kor. 12:3).</p><p>Tetapi, seperti dialami oleh para bapak gereja yang telah mendahului saya, situasi hidup terkadang memaksa orang-orang yang tidak suka berapologetika untuk ikut serta dalam aktivitas mubazir tersebut demi menenangkan umat Kristen yang digelisahkan olehnya. Dalam kasus saya sendiri, situasi yang mendesak penyusunan “apologetika minimalis” ini adalah pernyataan seorang imam yang disapa “<a href="https://youtube.com/shorts/EsRmo49LUdc?si=-4eUXOpOB8-Ku-PP">Romo Aldo</a>.” Klip pendeknya yang beredar di media sosial menyinggung kembali perkara keilahian Yesus yang sebenarnya sudah basi, sebab ia telah dibicarakan di tengah gereja sejak berabad-abad lalu hingga kini dengan kesimpulan yang jelas, yaitu bahwa Yesus adalah sepenuhnya ilahi (<em>vere Deus</em>) dan sepenuhnya manusiawi (<em>vere Homo</em>).</p><p>Klaim Romo Aldo berbunyi demikian:</p><blockquote><em>Yesus atau Yeshua itu ciptaan. Loh, kok banyak orang Indonesia Kristennya pada </em>nggak<em> tahu? Karena mereka baca terjemahan yang salah. Ada terjemahan yang </em>ditutup<em>-</em>tutupin<em> sehingga mereka itu </em>nggak<em> baca kebenarannya. </em>Nah<em>, saya menganalisa dari naskah Aramaik dan naskah Yunaninya.</em></blockquote><p>Jadi, apakah benar bahwa Yesus adalah ciptaan? Apakah benar bahwa kita — umat Kristen di Indonesia — telah dibodohi oleh versi terjemahan Kitab Suci resmi yang kita gunakan selama puluhan tahun? Apakah benar naskah Yunani Kitab Suci mempersaksikan bahwa Yesus hanyalah ciptaan belaka?</p><p>Mari kita mulai dengan mengutarakan sesuatu yang sudah gamblang sejak awal: Klaim Romo Aldo sejatinya tidak membuktikan apapun. Pernyataan bahwa umat Kristen Indonesia membaca “terjemahan yang salah” hanya valid bila disertai dengan bukti-bukti kuat dari <em>kesalahan penerjemahan</em> dalam Kitab Suci berbahasa Indonesia yang beredar di tengah masyarakat — dalam hal ini Terjemahan Baru 2 Lembaga Alkitab Indonesia (TB 2 LAI). Pembuktian tersebut menuntut suatu tolok ukur yang autoritatif dalam mengukur benar atau tidaknya terjemahan yang dikaji; dan tolok ukur ini memerlukan basis-basis yang bersifat aksiomatik (diakui secara luas) bagi para penerjemah Kitab Suci. Selama belum ada upaya pembuktian yang jelas dan secara metodologis sahih atas klaim ini, umat semestinya tidak segera menganggapnya sebagai fakta. Sudah menjadi kaidah standar bagi para teolog (dan sebagai kaum klerus, Romo Aldo termasuk di dalamnya) untuk membuktikan klaimnya dengan argumen yang logis, rasional, dan berdasar. Teologi — dari manapun kita mengupasnya — adalah disiplin ilmu, dan disiplin ilmu tidak menerima klaim-klaim bombastis tanpa pembuktian.</p><p>Kini, saya memusatkan perhatian pada klaim Romo Aldo bahwa keyakinannya akan status Yesus sebagai ciptaan belaka berakar pada analisisnya atas “naskah Aramaik dan naskah Yunaninya.” Seperti klaimnya tentang kesalahan penerjemahan Kitab Suci berbahasa Indonesia, klaim ini pun sejatinya tidak berdasar. Romo Aldo tidak menyebutkan secara spesifik salinan naskah mana yang ia teliti, kitab mana yang ia gali, dan nomor pasal serta ayat persis dari salinan itu yang memang mengindikasikan bahwa status Yesus tidak lebih dari ciptaan belaka. Namun, demi menguatkan umat, saya akan mencoba untuk secara ringkas membahas tiga teks Kitab Suci yang menjadi bukti kuat bagi klaim yang sebaliknya: <em>bahwa Yesus adalah sepenuhnya ilahi dan sepenuhnya manusiawi</em>. Berdiri kontras terhadap Romo Aldo, saya akan mengurai ketiga teks tersebut dengan berpedoman pada salinan naskah Yunani yang digunakan secara luas oleh para teolog dan pakar Kitab Suci saat ini, yaitu Nestle-Aland jilid ke-28.</p><h4>Yohanes 1</h4><p>Teks Kitab Suci yang segera membuktikan bahwa Yesus adalah sepenuhnya Allah ialah Yohanes 1. Ayat pertama menandaskannya secara eksplisit: “Pada mulanya sudah ada Firman, Firman itu ada bersama dengan Allah, dan Firman itu ada dalam keadaan ilahi” (Ἐν ἀρχῇ ἦν ὁ λόγος, καὶ ὁ λόγος ἦν πρὸς τὸν θεόν, καὶ θεὸς ἦν ὁ λόγος).</p><p>Penggalan frasa pertama, Ἐν ἀρχῇ ἦν ὁ λόγος, menegaskan kondisi yang sering disebut oleh para teolog dengan istilah “pra-eksistensi Mesias.” Pada titik paling awal dari keberadaan semesta, pada detik pertamanya, Sang Firman sudah ada. Itu berarti keberadaan Sang Firman mendahului keberadaan segala sesuatu yang diciptakan; dan karena Sang Firman ada sebelum penciptaan terjadi, Ia bukanlah ciptaan.</p><p>Yohanes memperkuat penekanannya atas status Sang Firman sebagai <em>bukan ciptaan</em> ini lewat penggalan frasa terakhir, θεὸς ἦν ὁ λόγος. Perhatikan: subjek frasa ini adalah Sang Firman, sebagaimana terindikasi oleh penggunaan awalan ὁ dalam kata ὁ λόγος. Kata θεὸς tampak seolah-olah seperti subjek, tetapi absennya awalan ὁ (sebab θεὸς adalah kata benda maskulin) menunjukkan bahwa ia semestinya dibaca sebagai <em>predikat nominatif</em> yang menjelaskan keadaan sang subjek. Adapun kata ἦν di sini merupakan bentuk <em>imperfect</em> dari kata εἰμί, yang dalam bahasa Indonesia berarti “adalah.” Terjemahan akurat bagi frasa θεὸς ἦν ὁ λόγος lantas bukanlah, “Firman itu adalah Allah,” melainkan, “Firman itu ada dalam keadaan ilahi.” Lebih akurat lagi, “Firman itu memiliki keadaan yang sama dengan Allah.” Berdasarkan frasa inilah Konsili Nikea merumuskan salah satu klausul kredonya, yang menurut beberapa kalangan tidak biblis (entah bagaimana dalihnya): “…diperanakkan, bukan diciptakan, sehakikat dengan Sang Bapa.”</p><p>Pada gilirannya, penerjemahan akurat atas penggalan frasa terakhir dari ayat pertama ini memperjelas makna penggalan frasa yang ada di tengah, ὁ λόγος ἦν πρὸς τὸν θεόν. Yohanes bersaksi bahwa, “Firman itu ada bersama dengan Allah,” untuk menjelaskan perkataan Yesus sendiri dalam pasal-pasal selanjutnya: bahwa Ia bukan hanya ada di dalam Allah Bapa dan Bapa di dalam Dia (10:38; 14:10–11), tetapi juga bahwa Ia dan Bapa adalah satu (10:30). Manusia bisa melihat Sang Bapa melalui Yesus <em>bukan</em> karena Yesus dan Bapa adalah pribadi yang sama, melainkan karena sekalipun Yesus dan Bapa adalah pribadi yang berbeda, keduanya <em>tidak bisa terpisahkan</em> dari satu sama lain, sebab keduanya <em>menyandang hakikat ilahi yang sama</em>. Inilah fondasi biblis bagi rumusan doktrin Trinitas yang berkembang mulai abad ketiga.</p><p>Dalam terang ayat pertama di atas, ayat keempat belas lantas menjadi penting. Di dalamnya, Yohanes menyatakan bahwa “Firman itu menjadi daging dan berkemah di antara kita” (ὁ λόγος σὰρξ ἐγένετο καὶ ἐσκήνωσεν ἐν ἡμῖν). Frasa inti dari pernyataan ini ialah λόγος σὰρξ ἐγένετο. Lewat frasa itu, Yohanes tidak sedang menyampaikan bahwa ketika Sang Firman menjadi manusia, Ia kehilangan keadaan ilahi yang Ia miliki sebelumnya. Yohanes pun tidak mengatakan bahwa Sang Firman (ὁ λόγος) dan kedagingan (σὰρξ) adalah dua pribadi terpisah yang seolah menyatu ketika Yesus lahir ke dalam dunia; hingga timbul pemahaman bahwa Yesus memiliki kepribadian ganda. Kunci untuk memahami frasa itu terletak pada kata kerja yang kedua, ἐσκήνωσεν, yang — sekalipun juga bisa dimaknai sebagai “tinggal” (seperti yang dilakukan oleh LAI) — lebih tepat diterjemahkan sebagai “berkemah” (sesuai akar katanya, σκηνή, yang berarti “tenda”). Menerjemahkannya demikian mengungkapkan kemungkinan kuat bahwa Yohanes memahami inkarnasi Yesus layaknya kehadiran kemah suci dalam sejarah bangsa Israel. Kemah suci Israel dibuat dari bahan-bahan duniawi — logam mulia, benang, linen, bulu dan kulit ternak, serta kayu akasia (Kel. 25:3–5). Ketika kemuliaan Allah memenuhi kemah itu (Kel. 40:34–35), Allah tidak serta-merta kehilangan keilahian-Nya. Demikian juga bahan-bahan duniawi itu tidak menjadi ilahi tatkala Allah bersemayam di sana. Allah tetaplah ilahi, sedangkan kemah suci tetaplah benda duniawi. Akan tetapi, dengan menjumpai kemah suci itu, bangsa Israel mengalami kehadiran Allah secara nyata. Sebagaimana kemah suci Israel menjadi “tempat tinggal” Allah ketika Ia berkarya di padang gurun, demikian pula kedagingan Yesus menjadi “tempat tinggal” pribadi ilahi-Nya — Sang Firman — tatkala Ia berkarya di tengah dunia. Demikianlah salinan Yohanes 1 dalam bahasa Yunaninya membuktikan bahwa Yesus adalah sepenuhnya ilahi dan sepenuhnya manusiawi.</p><h4>Roma 1</h4><p>Teks Kitab Suci kedua yang bisa kita teliti dalam kaitannya dengan klaim Romo Aldo adalah Roma 1:3–4. Sembari memperkenalkan dirinya sebagai “budak Mesias Yesus” (δοῦλος Χριστοῦ Ἰησοῦ) yang “dipanggil sebagai rasul” (κλητὸς ἀπόστολος), Paulus mengklarifikasi bahwa Injil, atau kabar baik, yang ia beritakan adalah “Injil Allah… tentang Anak-Nya, yang lahir dari benih Daud menurut daging, dan dinyatakan sebagai Anak Allah dengan kuasa menurut Roh kekudusan, melalui kebangkitan dari maut, Yesus Mesias Tuhan kita” (εὐαγγέλιον θεοῦ… περὶ τοῦ υἱοῦ αὐτοῦ τοῦ γενομένου ἐκ σπέρματος Δαυὶδ κατὰ σάρκα, τοῦ ὁρισθέντος υἱοῦ θεοῦ ἐν δυνάμει κατὰ πνεῦμα ἁγιωσύνης ἐξ ἀναστάσεως νεκρῶν, Ἰησοῦ Χριστοῦ τοῦ κυρίου ἡμῶν).</p><p>Bila teks ini dibaca sekilas, terdapat kesan bahwa “Anak Allah” bukanlah identitas yang melekat pada diri Yesus sejak awal. Peristiwa kebangkitan tampak seperti momen pengilahian bagi Yesus, yang di dalamnya status “Anak Allah” menjadi suatu hadiah bagi ciptaan yang telah menjalankan ketaatannya pada Allah secara sempurna hingga mati.</p><p>Namun, pembacaan seperti ini sejatinya mengabaikan tiga detail signifikan. Pertama, dalam bahasa Yunani Koine yang digunakan dalam penulisan teks-teks Perjanjian Baru, istilah ὁρισθέντος tidak pernah dipakai untuk menggambarkan upaya mengubah hakikat sesuatu. Maknanya hanya berkisar pada “mengangkat,” “menandai,” dan “menyatakan secara publik.” Kedua, ὁρισθέντος di sini diikuti dengan frasa υἱοῦ θεοῦ. Bentuk genitif frasa tersebut tidak hanya menunjukkan bahwa ia terpaut dengan kata ὁρισθέντος, tetapi juga bahwa ia <em>tidak </em>menandai perubahan hakikat. Ketiga, perhatikan frasa panjang yang mengikuti υἱοῦ θεοῦ: ἐν δυνάμει κατὰ πνεῦμα ἁγιωσύνης. Kemunculan frasa tersebut menyiratkan adanya kontras dengan keadaan yang lebih rendah, tanpa sedikitpun mengandaikan perubahan hakikat. Kontras ini tampak jelas bila kita membandingkannya dengan penggalan sebelumnya, τοῦ γενομένου ἐκ σπέρματος Δαυὶδ κατὰ σάρκα. Alhasil, penggalan τοῦ ὁρισθέντος υἱοῦ θεοῦ ἐν δυνάμει κατὰ πνεῦμα ἁγιωσύνης ἐξ ἀναστάσεως νεκρῶν semestinya diterjemahkan menjadi: “dan dinyatakan secara publik sebagai Anak Allah dengan kuasa menurut Roh kekudusan melalui kebangkitan dari maut.” Tak satupun kata dalam penggalan ini mengindikasikan bahwa peristiwa kebangkitan mengubah Yesus menjadi Anak Allah. Alih-alih demikian, lewat frasa “Injil Allah… tentang Anak-Nya” (εὐαγγέλιον θεοῦ… περὶ τοῦ υἱοῦ αὐτοῦ), Paulus justru mensinyalir bahwa Yesus sudah mengemban status Anak Allah sejak sebelum dunia dijadikan. Peristiwa kebangkitan hanya menyingkapkan keilahian-Nya yang tersembunyi di tengah dunia, hingga kita bisa mengenali-Nya sebagai Ἰησοῦ Χριστοῦ τοῦ κυρίου ἡμῶν, “Yesus Mesias Tuhan kita.”</p><p>Dengan demikian, pembacaan menyeluruh atas Roma 1:3–4 dalam bahasa Yunaninya membuktikan bahwa Yesus adalah sepenuhnya ilahi dan sepenuhnya manusiawi. Kedua ayat ini menggemakan syair Paulus dalam suratnya yang lain (Flp. 2:5–11), yang secara lebih detail menggambarkan kesediaan Yesus untuk menjalankan ketaatan manusiawi hingga mati di kayu salib — sikap yang pada gilirannya membuat Allah meninggikan Dia sebagai Anak-Nya.</p><h4>1 Korintus 8</h4><p>Teks Kitab Suci terakhir yang hendak saya bahas sebagai bantahan terhadap klaim Romo Aldo ialah 1 Korintus 8. Sekilas, teks ini tampak membahas perkara praktis, alih-alih teologis. Sebagian jemaat di Korintus mengalami pergumulan rohani karena hampir semua daging yang beredar di kota itu telah dipersembahkan kepada berhala (τῶν εἰδωλοθύτων) sebelum diperdagangkan. Namun, Paulus merespons perkara praktis ini dengan merombak langsung pemahaman iman jemaatnya. Hasilnya adalah apa yang disebut oleh pakar Perjanjian Baru N. T. Wright sebagai “salah satu formula teologi paling revolusioner yang pernah ditulis” (<em>What St. Paul Really Said?</em>,<em> </em>hlm. 67) — yang mencapai puncaknya pada ayat keenam: “tetapi untuk kita hanya ada satu Allah yaitu Bapa, yang dari-Nya segala sesuatu berasal dan yang untuk-Nya saja kita hidup; dan hanya ada satu Tuhan yaitu Yesus Mesias, yang melalui-Nya segala sesuatu dijadikan dan yang melalui-Nya kita hidup” (ἀλλ’ ἡμῖν εἷς θεὸς ὁ πατὴρ ἐξ οὗ τὰ πάντα καὶ ἡμεῖς εἰς αὐτόν, καὶ εἷς κύριος Ἰησοῦς Χριστὸς δι’ οὗ τὰ πάντα καὶ ἡμεῖς δι’ αὐτοῦ).</p><p>Bila kita membaca salinan Nestle-Aland, kita akan mendapati bahwa ayat di atas ditulis menjorok ke dalam. Penulisan yang demikian mensinyalir bahwa Paulus mengadaptasinya dari sumber lain; bahwa ayat tersebut adalah kutipan, bukan perkataannya sendiri. Dan, jika kita mengingat fakta bahwa Paulus adalah seorang Yahudi, serta membaca catatan-catatan kritis dalam salinan Nestle-Aland dengan teliti, kita akan menyadari — seperti Wright — bahwa ayat keenam ini sesungguhnya adalah adaptasi Paulus atas pengakuan iman mendasar agama Yahudi, yang kerap disebut oleh para teolog sebagai “<em>Shema</em>.” Pengakuan iman itu bisa kita lihat dalam Ulangan 6:4: “Dengarlah, hai orang Israel: Tuhanlah Allah kita, Tuhan itu esa!”</p><p>Yang membuat adaptasi Paulus atas <em>Shema</em> revolusioner adalah ia mempertahankan dalil keesaan Allah sembari <em>menyisipkan Yesus ke tengah-tengah</em> <em>pengakuan iman itu</em>. Bila bagi orang Yahudi, “Tuhan” (יהוה, κύριος) adalah nama Allah Israel (sehingga “Tuhan” dan “Allah” menunjuk pada sosok yang sama, yaitu Allah Israel yang esa), maka bagi Paulus, “Tuhan” (κύριος) menunjuk pada Yesus, sedangkan “Allah” (θεὸς) menunjuk pada Bapa-Nya. Namun, seperti orang Yahudi pada umumnya, Paulus entah bagaimana tetap mengakui bahwa “tidak ada ilah selain Allah yang esa” (ὅτι οὐδεὶς θεὸς εἰ μὴ εἷς).</p><p>Ketegangan antara kedua pengakuan iman ini bisa diselesaikan melalui dua alur pikiran. Pertama, kita bisa menempuh jalan yang serupa dengan Romo Aldo dan berkata bahwa bagi Paulus, Yesus hanyalah ciptaan. Alur pikiran itu, tentu saja, segera menyelesaikan ketegangan dalam 1 Korintus 8:6. Akan tetapi, ia lantas menimbulkan masalah baru, sebab mengklaim bahwa Yesus adalah ciptaan belaka berbenturan langsung dengan fakta keyahudian Paulus. Bagi seorang Yahudi diaspora, κύριος adalah pengganti nama sakral Allah Israel yang tidak boleh disebutkan, YHWH (יהוה). Bila Paulus menurunkan derajat istilah ini dalam formula teologisnya, ia tidak hanya merendahkan rumusan <em>Shema</em> yang dikutip dan diakuinya, tetapi juga menistakan Allah yang ia sembah sejak awal; yang sejatinya tidak pernah berubah sekalipun ia menjadi percaya pada Yesus Mesias.</p><p>Kedua, kita bisa menempuh jalan yang sedikit lebih sulit dengan melihat paralelisme antara nama “Tuhan” dan “Allah” yang digunakan oleh Paulus dan perkembangannya dalam dunia Perjanjian Lama. Bila kita membaca kitab Kejadian hingga Keluaran, kita akan mendapati bahwa para leluhur Israel lebih dahulu menggunakan nama “Allah” (אֵל) ketimbang nama “Tuhan” (יהוה). Ini karena אֵל sudah digunakan secara luas dalam agama-agama Semitik yang terbentuk sebelum Yakub/Israel lahir. Melkisedek menyapa-Nya “Allah yang Maha Tinggi” (אֵל עֶלְיוֹן, Kej. 14:19–20). Ia menampakkan diri kepada Abraham sebagai “Allah yang Maha Kuasa (אֵל שַׁדַּי, Kel. 17:1). Hagar menyebut-Nya “El-Roi” (אֵל רֳאִי, Kej. 16:13). Bahkan, nama “Isra-el” sendiri pun sesungguhnya menyematkan nama אֵל di dalamnya.</p><p>Berbeda dengan “Allah,” nama “Tuhan” sebagai penanda bagi Allah Israel baru mulai digunakan setelah Musa bertemu dengan Allah dalam semak terbakar (Kel. 3). Sebelum kembali kepada bangsanya untuk memberitakan bahwa Allah akan membebaskan mereka, Musa bertanya kepada Allah mengenai nama-Nya. Pertanyaan ini unik, sebab sebelumnya, Musa pun sudah menyapa Allah dengan nama אֵל. Nama יהוה lantas tidak hanya menandai sapaan spesifik saja, tetapi juga menyingkapkan jati diri-Nya, seperti tercermin dalam jawaban-Nya kepada Musa: “Aku adalah Aku” (אֶהְיֶה אֲשֶׁר אֶהְיֶה, Kel. 3:14). Nama yang menyingkapkan jati diri Allah Israel inilah yang lantas dipadatkan oleh Musa dan Yitro menjadi יהוה dan disakralkan oleh orang Yahudi hingga kini.</p><p>Perhatikan: dalam dunia Perjanjian Lama, “Allah” menunjuk pada sosok transenden yang berkarya di antara bangsa-bangsa Semitik secara umum, sedangkan “Tuhan” menunjuk pada penyingkapan Allah itu secara khusus di hadapan bangsa Israel. Sekarang, paralelkanlah kaidah pemakaian nama “Allah” dan “Tuhan” ini dengan cara Paulus menggunakannya dalam 1 Korintus 8:6. Bukankah penegasan bahwa “hanya ada satu Allah yaitu Bapa” (εἷς θεὸς ὁ πατὴρ) dan “hanya ada satu Tuhan yaitu Yesus Mesias” (εἷς κύριος Ἰησοῦς Χριστὸς) menyiratkan bahwa <em>Yesus Mesias adalah penyingkapan dari Allah yang esa ini</em>, sebagaimana יהוה adalah penyataan jati diri dari אֵל? Pemaknaan yang demikian mampu mempertahankan iman Paulus pada Allah Bapa dan Yesus tanpa mengompromikan <em>Shema</em>; yang pada gilirannya mengindikasikan bahwa Yesus ini memiliki watak yang sama dengan Allah, setidaknya dalam taraf tertentu.</p><h4>Penutup</h4><p>Masih cukup banyak bagian naskah Kitab Suci versi Yunani yang bisa dikaji untuk membantah klaim Romo Aldo bahwa Yesus adalah ciptaan belaka. Namun, karena keterbatasan daya dan sentimen negatif terhadap apologetika, saya memutuskan untuk membatasi apologetika minimalis ini hanya pada tiga teks tersebut. Kiranya umat yang gelisah akibat klaim Romo Aldo (dan klaim-klaim sejenisnya) bisa sedikit lebih tenang setelah membaca paparan ringkas di atas. Lebih jauh dari itu, saya berharap agar umat yang menikmati debat para apologet yang kurang berfaedah itu bisa bertobat dan berfokus pada hal-hal yang paling esensial dalam kehidupan Kristiani: mengerjakan keselamatan mereka dan melakukan kehendak Allah Bapa hingga mereka menjadi semakin serupa dengan Sang Mesias.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4c36173e1834" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Little Flower]]></title>
            <link>https://thescrapbook.medium.com/the-little-flower-453c9126a7c2?source=rss-a46f79a1ed6f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/453c9126a7c2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[short-story]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unworthiness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[grace]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[flowers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sacred-trust]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lumbanbatu Kornelius]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jan 2026 05:46:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-03T05:46:14.541Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When I came of age, with little to show for myself, the Absolute Superior visited me. In his hands, he carried a pot containing a small, delicate flower.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/770/1*zKDZRFayS9Z60zFChpyLAw.jpeg" /><figcaption>“Peony Painting” by Ria Hills (US), accessed from <a href="http://www.saatchiart.com/">www.saatchiart.com</a></figcaption></figure><p>Like any flower, its essence was beauty — and it expressed it splendidly. But the beauty of this one struck me differently from any I had ever seen. It seemed humble, yet robust. It did not vie for attention, yet its luxurious glamor was undeniable. These very contradictions drew me in. When I looked at it, I felt captivated, joyful, and at peace, all at once. A part of me longed to possess it — but I knew better than to follow such a selfish impulse. After all, it was the <em>Superior’s</em> flower. And I was of humble stature. I had no right to exert force, especially since all I was, and all I had, came from him. Moreover, as his name suggests, his authority is inviolable. The Superior may be kind, but should he see defiance in me, I am undone. I am content to live within my station. The road ahead may be long and arduous, but the Superior promised he would never give me more than I could bear.</p><p>Or so I believed.</p><p>His bringing the flower to me now stirred the doubts that had always lain dormant in my heart.</p><p>Why bring it here? Why now?</p><p>I am a servant. I own no station. My labor has yet to yield true sustenance. What could he possibly expect of me?</p><p>From the moment I opened my eyes, the Superior has laid claim to my life. Decades later, I became his humble servant, living by his commands. Yet though his authority is absolute, the world does not acknowledge him. And so, the world dismisses his servants — myself included. You may feel a pang of pity for me, but do not trouble yourself, dear reader. I am accustomed to it. To serve the Absolute Superior is to walk the path of righteousness. The road is not always straight. Sometimes it is rough and steep. No matter. One need only remain aware of one’s faults and hold a pure intention not to repeat them. Keep this humble attitude, and you are on your way to everlasting peace.</p><p>Yet nothing prepared me to tend to something as beautiful as the flower the Superior held. To nurture such blooms requires nobility. They need fertile soil and good climate found only in the highlands, places forbidden to one of my standing. If the Superior truly meant for me to tend this little flower, perhaps he was — forgive my offense — not in his right mind. Or perhaps he wished to demonstrate my insignificance once more (though I have known that for ages, so it does not suffice to explain his motives). Or perhaps he was merely toying with my heart. His jokes, after all, are seldom funny.</p><p>“My servant,” he greeted me, a soft smile on his face.</p><p>“Yes, my Lord?”</p><p>“Come here for a moment.”</p><p>“At once, my Lord.”</p><p>I approached, my expression stern, feeling the gravity of the moment. Holding out the pot, the Superior glanced over my face before returning his gaze to the flower.</p><p>“This is my little flower. I had kept it since around the time I claimed your life. What do you think? It is pretty, is it not?”</p><p>I looked down, conscious of my unworthiness.</p><p>“…Yes, my Lord.”</p><p>“I am glad you agree.”</p><p>I raised my eyes to him. Gazing into the distance, the Superior began to recount the flower’s story.</p><p>“I treasure this little one. I take delight in its humility and resilience. You may not know this, but it has suffered greatly. Once, selfish nobles stripped nearly all its petals, leaving it a shell of itself.”</p><p>“I am sorry to hear that, my Lord,” I replied. “It deserved better. It did no harm, yet harm was all it received.”</p><p>“But it refused to wither,” the Superior continued. “Seeing it so wounded, I planted it in good soil, near a benevolent neighborhood. I could still hear the echo of their cheerful voices around it, the careful drip of their water cans. They watered it faithfully, kept pests away, ensured it saw the sun each day. Now, through their care, it blooms once more.”</p><p>“Forgive my rudeness, my Lord,” I ventured. “But why bring it here when it thrived under their care?”</p><p>“I have sensed… a loneliness in it.”</p><p>“How so, my Lord?”</p><p>“It longs for a world that existed before the great tragedy millennia ago — specifically, for a kind of love from that time. I have tried to carry that love into today’s world, but as you know, not all acknowledge my sovereignty.”</p><p>By then, I feared where this was headed. Panic swelled within me.</p><p>“Your point, my Lord?” I asked, too hurriedly.</p><p>“I am entrusting it to you,” he said, his smile unchanged.</p><p>The dormant doubts in my heart sprang to life.</p><p>“But, my Lord! You know who I am! You know my limits! This is madness! Do you not treasure this little flower? Do you not love it? You take delight in it daily. How can you bring something so precious to me? It will wither worse than before!”</p><p>Despite my protests, the Superior remained silent. His eyes held mine, staring deep within my soul, while his hands cradled the flower with unchanged gentleness. I stopped, knowing he would not answer.</p><p>After a long silence, he spoke again.</p><p>“I am entrusting this precious flower to you, dear servant. It must be you. In time, you will understand why. You may refuse — but then another will care for it, and you will never again behold it so closely. You do admire it, do you not? Your eyes revealed your desire to possess it, though you fought that impulse well. Still, you hide nothing from me. I have known you since you were in your mother’s womb — and it is on that basis I choose you.”</p><p>I looked down again, stunned into silence.</p><p>“Besides,” he went on, “this little flower has taken a liking to you. It has seen the fruits of your labor long before you knew it existed. Will you give it a chance? Or, will you refuse and watch it wilt in disappointment — all because of your insecurity?”</p><p>I reflected for what felt like an age before answering.</p><p>“My Lord, the little one has suffered enough. Do not let me add to its sorrow. Let me bring it joy. Let me help it reach its full potential. I will try my best not to fail you. I will consider it my duty, my joy, and my service.”</p><p>Without a word, the Superior placed his treasure into my hands. Seeing it up close, I could scarcely believe what was happening. It felt surreal, like a dream. Even now, as I recount this, it still feels absurd. How could someone like me be entrusted with something so precious?</p><p>But I remember clearly what happened next.</p><p>“Dear servant, listen well.”</p><p>The Superior looked at me with solemnity. I knew that I must heed what followed.</p><p>“This little flower is my treasure, my pride, my joy. I delight in it daily. I have only entrusted it to you — it will always belong to me. Care for it as I have in its darkest hours. Admire it as I admire all my creation. Do not pluck even one petal. Let no other flower distract your gaze. When the time comes, I will return — and <em>I will demand an account of all you have done with it</em>. Be faithful, and greater things will be entrusted to you. Be unfaithful, and you will be punished accordingly.”</p><p>“Understood, my Lord. I will not fail you.”</p><p>My reply was unyielding, resolute. What I did not show — and what he surely knew — was that my doubts had only multiplied. Can I really do this? What if I fail? What if my care makes things worse, despite my intentions?</p><p>Looking back, I should have prayed then, as I pray now.</p><p><em>My Lord, even while you are away, teach me to love this little flower of yours just as you love it.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=453c9126a7c2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Litany of the Wretched]]></title>
            <link>https://thescrapbook.medium.com/litany-of-the-wretched-a9533a920a14?source=rss-a46f79a1ed6f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a9533a920a14</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lumbanbatu Kornelius]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 28 Jun 2025 14:23:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-08T07:21:03.425Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/1*rNTg3iLIDsE4tMh7aJQTNA@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>Still here<br>Cloaked in ash, crawling through ruin<br>A mere whisper of a man<br>A dreg among the people<br>Wretched of the world — yet still here</p><p>I have no legend<br>No tale tells my story<br>No triumph<br>Only breath<br>Only steps<br>Only fire, which refuses to die<br>In a world without care<br>Where no one ever watched</p><p>So I live<br>Not to be remembered<br>But to remember myself<br>If no song is sung of me<br>Then let my body be the music<br>If no one paints my name<br>Then let my scars become the pigment</p><p>I will push<br>I will kneel, only to rise<br>I will lose<br>Again, and lose some more<br>Until even the void whispers:<br>“He is still here”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a9533a920a14" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[One Who Struggles Against God]]></title>
            <link>https://thescrapbook.medium.com/one-who-struggles-against-god-7694ba2893c0?source=rss-a46f79a1ed6f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7694ba2893c0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[existentialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[short-story]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jonah]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bible]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Lumbanbatu Kornelius]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 May 2025 14:00:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-03T14:00:46.924Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hI-m3KJ9Yq_J17p3OOYwEw.jpeg" /><figcaption>“Ships in a Gale” (1660) by Willem van de Velde the Younger</figcaption></figure><p>And so it was that Jonah, son of Amittai, came to the port of Joppa. Before him lay two ships — one bound for Nineveh, the other for Tarshish. As he stepped onto the docks, the word of the Lord, God of Israel, echoed in his mind once more.</p><blockquote>Go to the great city of Nineveh and preach against it, because its wickedness has come up before me.</blockquote><p>Again, Jonah reflected on the word of the Lord, its presence lingering in his head like an inescapable decree.</p><p>“Why must I go to that cursed city? He is the almighty, the Lord of hosts — his power is known to all. The Psalmist spoke of how the nations tremble before him. If he truly desires their end, why not strike Nineveh down, as he did Sodom?”</p><p>“The wickedness of nations shall not go unpunished. Was not King Saul condemned for sparing the Amalekites? Then what fate awaits me in Nineveh? Surely, the Lord wills me to forfeit my life. He expects a lone Hebrew to alter the hearts of an entire city? What folly! The sons of Nineveh will not repent — they will only put me to death.”</p><p>“But what if, against all reason, they chose to repent? Would the Lord not grant them mercy?”</p><p>“No, he should never have even considered redemption for that city!”</p><p>“Why would the same Lord who showed no leniency to the Amalekites grant mercy to Nineveh? Has he lost his resolve? Has justice lost its meaning? Or is he simply unpredictable, choosing punishment one day and pardon the next? Who could revere such a God?<em>”</em></p><p>As Jonah pondered deeply, the voice of the sailors thundered over the din of the bustling port.</p><p>“You there! Move your feet or be left behind—we sail for Tarshish at any moment! Anchors aweigh!”</p><p>Time pressing against him, Jonah made his decision: he would not heed the Lord’s command. He boarded the ship bound for Tarshish without hesitation, abandoning the only path that led him to Nineveh.</p><p>With no path for retreat, Jonah steeled himself. His resolve was set, his course unyielding.</p><p>“I will not cross the gates of that city. They have sealed their fate, and I will not be the one to soften it. No force in heaven or earth, not even the Lord himself, will change my resolve.”</p><p>“I challenge a force beyond reckoning. Perhaps I am doomed. Perhaps my choices were mere illusions, though I still chose this vessel over the one to Nineveh. But it makes no difference. Even if ruin is certain, I will fight. I will defy. I will push myself to the very brink.”</p><p>He retreated beneath the deck, pressing himself into the corner by the door. The burden of his past gnawed at him, turning his mood sour. His expression hardened, his lips tightening into a muttered grumble.</p><p>“For too long, I have bowed to his whims! Is it truly wrong to exercise the will he gave me? If I were meant to be a servant, why grant me the freedom to choose?”</p><p>“If obedience was all he sought, then he should have fashioned a servant devoid of will, reason, ambition, or desire — one who would bow without question, whispering, ‘Yes, my Lord. As you wish, my Lord,’ regardless of the circumstances.”</p><p>“But no — he had to grant free will, only to seize it whenever it pleased him. A ruler who crushes what he creates, feeding his own supremacy. Who could serve a God like that? Who could believe his plans are for their good? Certainly not me.”</p><p>Unbeknownst to Jonah, wary eyes trailed his every step across the deck, judgment heavy in their silent gaze. Rather than risk being branded an outsider, a fool, or a laughingstock, he withdrew to his cabin, seeking refuge in solitude. The last slivers of sunlight danced through the gaps in the cabin door. Darkness deepened, and sleep claimed him.</p><p>“Maybe one day, I’ll escape it all. The chaos, the weight of it, the futility of this fight. The sheer absurdity of it all.”</p><p>Thus Jonah let his eyelids fall. His last wish broke free into the night sky, bound only for the heavens.</p><blockquote>Yet you brought me out of the womb. <br>You made me trust in you, even at my mother’s breast.<br>From birth, I was cast on you.<br>From my mother’s womb, you have been my God.</blockquote><p>Jonah recognized the verse instantly. The lyrics surged through him like an old wound torn open. It is Psalm 22, his favorite song. Once, its melody had drawn tears from his eyes in the shrine of Bethel, stirring something raw and ancient in his soul. It had spoken to the depths of his being, the mystery of his birth, the weight of his existence, the purpose ordained for him before he had his breath.</p><p>He could still hear his mother’s voice, soft yet unwavering.</p><p>“The Lord has molded you for his works, Jonah — the works of God.”</p><p>She had always believed it. His mind, intellect, and talents were divine gifts woven for something greater than himself. His path was carved before he could even walk. His destiny belonged not to him, but to the one who had shaped him.</p><p>But now, as the psalm echoed in his mind, it no longer filled him with reverence. No, it mocked him. It loomed over him like an oppressive hand, forcing him into submission. His talents, his thoughts, his passions, his very breath; they resisted the bidding of the one who gave them. They rebelled against the yoke imposed upon him before he ever had the chance to choose.</p><p>And his mother? He could not blame her. He could not bear to wound her with his defiance. Yet neither could he silence the bitterness that festered within him. Had she known? Had she realized the prison she spoke of so fondly — the vow that bound him like iron chains? Did she see the life she had offered him as something noble, something blessed?</p><p>Without his consent, his fate had been sealed. His path and purpose had been chiseled into stone long before he took his first breath. He was not a man with a choice. He was a prophet.</p><p>And the world had no place for prophets.</p><p>His so-called friends, the men who walked the path of the world — they never said it outright, but he could feel the judgment in their silence, in the way their eyes lingered on him with veiled condescension. He was an outcast, a relic. A man shackled to a fate none would envy.</p><p>Or was it merely his reflection staring back at him?</p><p>The thought clawed at him, deep and unrelenting. What had he gained? What had he sacrificed? His ambition, his curiosity, his dreams of understanding how the heavens and earth moved. And for what? In his late twenties, he had nothing to his name. No home, no land, no scrolls bearing his words. No reputation worth defending.</p><p>All he had was a calling. A calling he never asked for. A path he desperately tried to flee from, even if he could not escape it in the end. Yet escape was all he sought.</p><p>The psalm — the very song that once spoke to his soul — now rang like a cruel jest in his ears. Even in the depths of sleep, bitterness clung to Jonah like a specter, twisting his dreams into something restless and suffocating.</p><p>But beneath the weight of his resentment, he sensed something strange. This unease did not stem from anger, but from something deeper.</p><p>“Why <em>this</em> psalm? Why <em>now,</em> of all times?”</p><p>Was the psalm just one of the remnants of his memory resurfacing in the quiet? Or was it something else? A whisper, or a warning? A hand reaching from the past, pulling him toward a truth he had spent years denying?</p><p>He wanted to dismiss it. But it clung to him, refusing to be forgotten. Something stirred within him — a tremor, faint but undeniable. He knew he was running from something far greater than Nineveh itself. But his resolve was unshaken. He still had no plan to return.</p><p>Jonah woke up to a cacophony above deck — the cries of passengers, the shouts of sailors, the urgent pounding of feet against wood. The air was thick with panic. He climbed the stairs and emerged into chaos. A raging storm had seized the ship, hurling towering waves against its sides. The vessel, once sturdy, now groaned under the strain, threatening to collapse into the abyss.</p><p>His first response was disbelief.</p><p>“How could this happen? The sky was clear when we departed from Joppa. How could the sea turn on us so suddenly?”</p><p>Then, Jonah saw his fellow passengers and sailors clinging to hope, their voices raised in desperate supplication. One pleaded to Moloch. Another to Baal. Another to Shamash, the Mesopotamian sun god. Each called upon their deity for salvation.</p><p>Yet the heavens offered no reprieve. The winds howled louder. The sea surged higher.</p><p>Jonah watched their helplessness, the futility of their prayers. Suddenly, something within him shifted.</p><p>He remembered the psalm from his dream.</p><p>It was, after all, more than memory or mere recollection. The psalm had been a warning. The storm was no accident. Nor was it a natural tempest born from the sea’s fury. It was the Lord’s. Nothing escaped his hand. Nothing moved beyond his will.</p><p>Jonah felt the weight of that realization settle upon him. This storm had been conjured by the very one he sought to defy. And his defiance had consequences, not only for himself but for the innocent souls aboard this ship.</p><p>Yet even as the truth stared him in the face, Jonah refused to yield.</p><p>Then, there was a voice, urgent, raw with fear. The sailor who had called Jonah aboard in Joppa now stood before him, drenched and seething.</p><p>“What in the heavens are you doing?! Do you not see the disaster upon us? How dare you sleep through such peril!”</p><p>Jonah met his gaze, unflinching, unreadable.</p><p>The sailor pressed on, his frustration boiling over.</p><p>“What are you waiting for?!”</p><blockquote>Call on your god! Perhaps he will take notice of us, so we may live!</blockquote><p>Jonah lowered himself to his knees. He folded his hands, closed his eyes.</p><p>But he did not pray.</p><p>He remained silent, still, unyielding.</p><p>The passengers, now at the end of their wits, turned to superstition.</p><blockquote>Let us cast lots to find out who is responsible for this calamity.</blockquote><p>A sailor reached into his bag and drew out a knucklebone. With trembling fingers, he tossed it onto the deck.</p><p>It landed with finality. The marked side faced Jonah. All eyes soon fell upon him.</p><p>“You, the one kneeling!” they shouted.</p><p>“The gods have spoken — you know something about this disaster! Tell us — who are you? Where do you come from? What have you done?”</p><p>Jonah opened his eyes, yet he did not meet their gaze. His voice was steady, calm.</p><blockquote>I am a Hebrew, and I worship the Lord, the God of heaven, who made the sea and the dry land.</blockquote><p>A silence stretched between them. A pause, heavy with realization.</p><p>Then the interrogation resumed, this time sharper and more demanding.</p><p>“Pray, tell us. What sin have you committed that your god would bring such wrath upon us?”</p><p>Jonah did not hesitate.</p><p>“I am innocent.”</p><p>Outrage bursted from the crowd.</p><p>“Nonsense! We have all called upon our gods, pleaded for mercy, yet the storm only grows stronger! Thus, it is not us — it is you! You dare to sleep soundly in your cabin despite facing this precarious situation! The lot has cast its judgment, and it falls upon you!”</p><p>Jonah felt their condemnation swell around him, pressing closer, suffocating. His jaw tightened. His bitterness returned, razor-sharp. Thus, he spoke, his voice edged with defiance.</p><p>“I am only exercising the freedom of will my Lord created in me when I was in my mother’s womb. Is it wrong to use what the heavens had bestowed upon me?”</p><p>The passengers exchanged glances, their fear now laced with grim understanding.</p><p>Then, as if a silent agreement had passed between them, they turned back to Jonah, delivering their verdict.</p><p>“We do not know who you truly are or what you have done, Hebrew man. But one thing is clear to us: you have defied the will of your Lord. In exercising your most prized freedom of will, you have brought doom upon innocent men who have devoted their lives to their gods.”</p><p>“We have no choice. You must be cast away from this ship — at once.”</p><p>“You are the scapegoat we must offer to appease the will of the gods. A single guilty man must perish so that dozens may live.”</p><p>Jonah did not flinch.</p><p>The storm raged. The sea waited.</p><p>A sailor seized Jonah’s right arm. With his firm grip, he intended to restrain the prophet before casting him into the raging sea. But Jonah twisted his body, rotating his left arm behind him, driving his elbow hard into the sailor’s chin. The impact sent the man reeling. His head snapped back, and he collapsed, unconscious.</p><p>Two passengers rushed to subdue him. They wrestled him to the ground, but only for a fleeting moment. Jonah fought with unwavering resolve. He kicked one square in the face, sending him sprawling. Then, he drove his fingers deep into another’s eye, blinding him with a sharp cry of agony.</p><p>In turn, three other sailors, working in tandem, lunged to overpower him. Two gripped his arms, locking them down, while the third struck. Twelve brutal blows to Jonah’s solar plexus, each one precise, calculated. He choked, water spilling from his mouth after the third hit, blood after the eighth.</p><p>A final strike came from a passenger’s fist. It cracked Jonah’s face, darkening his right eye in an instant.</p><p>Pain overtook Jonah. His body betrayed him. His vision blurred. His defiance, so fierce moments ago, now flickered, fragile. His mind wavered, teetering on the edge of oblivion.</p><p>Then came the captain. The leader of the ship stepped forward, silent yet resolute. He lifted Jonah’s battered body over his shoulder, bearing the weight of a man who had fought beyond reason. Step by step, he carried Jonah toward the edge of the vessel.</p><p>The sea still roared below them, its hunger insatiable.</p><p>The crew gathered. The passengers stood watching, waiting.</p><p>The storm raged on.</p><p>Then, the captain raised his voice. His words cut through the chaos surrounding him.</p><p>“O Lord, God of heaven, who made the sea and the dry land. We offer unto you this guilty man. Have mercy upon us. Cease your wrath. Let the waters be calm once more.”</p><p>And with that, he hurled Jonah into the open sea.</p><p>The moment his body plunged into the abyss, the storm that threatened to sink the ship began to subside. The furious winds softened. The towering waves eased. The ship, once on the verge of ruin, steadied upon calmer waters.</p><p>The crowd, sensing the spectacle had reached its end, began to disperse. Passengers withdrew to their cabins, eager to escape the memory of what had transpired. Sailors busied themselves, tending to the wreckage, patching broken timbers, restoring order where chaos had reigned.</p><p>As the sea found its stillness, the captain lingered at the bow. The words that left his lips were quiet, nearly stolen by the wind — but not entirely.</p><blockquote>He trusts in the Lord.<br>Let his Lord rescue him.<br>Let him deliver him,<br>since he delights in him.</blockquote><p>Jonah awoke in suffocating darkness. The space around him was tight, the air thick with humidity, pressing against his skin like damp, suffocating cloth. He could not see. Nor could he move. He only felt the oppressive weight closing in.</p><p>The last thing he remembered was the final blow to his right eye, the world fading into blackness.</p><p>“I am already among the dead.”</p><p>The thought settled into him with chilling certainty.</p><p>“The Lord found no favor in me. He cast me away, just as they did above the ship. My ancestors, too, have disowned me.”</p><p>“Every sacrifice, every act of obedience — undone in a single moment of defiance.”</p><p>Then, pain came over him. It returned with relentless force, coursing through his body, clawing at his ribs, his bruised flesh burning like fire.</p><p>Jonah had always believed that suffering was the mark of the living. Pain was proof of existence. But the pain he was experiencing, that anguish, felt different. To him, it was punishment. Administered by the hand of the tyrant who had shaped him.</p><p>At first, Jonah refused to give in. He drifted in and out of consciousness. His body betrayed him, his mind clawed for escape. Each time he awoke, pain welcomed him. Each time he lost himself in darkness, he thought <em>this</em> must be the release he had sought all his life.</p><p>But the suffering remained.</p><p>With every resurgence, the pain chipped away at his resolve, weakening him, breaking him, eroding every ounce of defiance.</p><p>Until, at last, Jonah surrendered.</p><p>Too weak to lift his voice, he prayed in silence, his heart carrying words his lips could not.</p><blockquote>In my distress, I called to the Lord, and he answered me.<br>From deep in the realm of the dead, I called for help, and you listened to my cry.</blockquote><p>Fragments of memory flooded his mind: his defiance upon the ship, the fury of the passengers, the judgment in their eyes, the storm, the waves, the voices demanding his exile.</p><blockquote>You hurled me into the depths, into the very heart of the seas, and the currents swirled about me; all your waves and breakers swept over me.</blockquote><p>His consciousness wavered again — slipping, unraveling. He felt himself fading, his spirit unraveling into nothingness. His heart cried out.</p><blockquote>When my life was ebbing away, I remembered you, Lord, and my prayer rose to you, to your holy temple.</blockquote><p>But this was not repentance. Jonah was beyond seeking mercy.</p><p>He wanted only release.</p><p>Yet, through the haze of suffering, a single truth returned to him: the Lord’s command. “Go to Nineveh.”</p><p>A bitter determination flared within him, fed by years of sacrifice, by the righteous conviction that he had earned his place before God.</p><blockquote>Those who cling to worthless idols turn away from God’s love for them. But I, with shouts of grateful praise, will sacrifice to you. What I have vowed, I will make good. I will say, “Salvation comes from the Lord.”</blockquote><p>And then, Jonah was not dead.</p><p>The suffocating prison he had believed to be the afterlife was not the realm of the departed. He was not buried beneath the waves. He was inside the belly of a great fish.</p><p>And the Lord, hearing the cry of His servant, commanded the creature to spit Jonah out.</p><p>And so, the prophet was cast upon the dry lands of Nineveh.</p><p>Amid the haze of a dream-like state, the word of the Lord came upon Jonah a second time. His command proved to be unwavering, cutting through even the veil of his broken consciousness.</p><blockquote>Go to the great city of Nineveh and proclaim to it the message I give you.</blockquote><p>Jonah stirred, his body heavy with exhaustion, his mind still entangled in the remnants of his suffering. The suffocating darkness was gone, replaced by a wide, quiet room. He had a bed beneath him and space to breathe. His fingers twitched. He was alive.</p><p>Soon, a stranger entered. His presence carried the air of knowledge and care. His clothing, his movements, and the quiet authority in his voice suggested he was a physician.</p><p>Seeing his patient awake, the man spoke, his words laced with relief.</p><p>“You are in the city of Nineveh, sir. We found you unconscious on the shore yesterday afternoon. Since my home was nearby, the residents brought you here. I am glad to see you have finally awakened.”</p><p>A brief pause ensues.</p><p>Jonah studied the man before him.</p><p>This was <em>Nineveh</em>.</p><p>Yet the physician looked nothing like the villains Jonah had envisioned before he departed from Joppa. His gaze was not cruel. His tone was not laced with malice. His hands had nursed a stranger back to life — not with violence, but with kindness.</p><p>Then came the expected inquiry.</p><p>“Who are you, good sir? Where did you come from? How did you happen to be stranded here of all places?”</p><p>Jonah knew these questions would come. But something within him had changed. He had lost his fear of death. He had tasted torment in the belly of the great fish. No fate could shake him now.</p><p>And so, he seized the moment.</p><p>“Thank you for your kindness. I am a Hebrew, sailing from the port of Joppa. I have been sent here to deliver a message from the Lord, the God of heaven, who made the sea and the dry land.”</p><blockquote>The wickedness of Nineveh is great, and in forty days, this city shall be overthrown.</blockquote><p>He did not soften his words.</p><p><em>“</em>I know this may sound absurd to you. Laugh if you wish. Torture me. Kill me. It does not matter. Your fate remains unchanged.”</p><p>“The only thing that can alter your destiny is repentance. Turn from your wickedness, O sons of Nineveh. Abandon violence, greed, injustice, oppression, and corruption. Believe in the Lord, the God of Israel.”</p><p>Against all expectations, the physician’s expression darkened; not with doubt, but with profound realization.</p><p>“So, our cries for justice and peace have finally been answered.”</p><p>And in that moment, Jonah understood. This man did not resist the word of the Lord. He welcomed it.</p><p>The physician moved swiftly, signaling Jonah to follow him outside.</p><p>“Come, we must spread this message throughout the city. Given your current condition, it will not be an easy task. It takes three days to travel its entirety on foot.”</p><p>Jonah exhaled slowly. A faint smile curled at the edge of his lips.</p><p>“Fear not. I have endured worse things. This will be nothing.”</p><p>And so, with the aid of the physician and his neighbors, Jonah carried the warning throughout Nineveh.</p><p>To his astonishment, the people did not scoff. They did not mock him. Nor did they resist his words.</p><p>Like the physician before them, the Ninevites believed.</p><p>They proclaimed a fast. From the greatest to the least, they donned sackcloth — a solemn symbol of repentance.</p><p>Soon, Jonah’s warning reached the ears of the king.</p><p>The ruler of Nineveh did not dismiss the message. He did not rage. Instead, he stripped himself of his royal robes, covered himself in sackcloth, and sat in the dust. His posture was heavy with remorse.</p><p>Then, the decree was sent forth across the city.</p><blockquote>Do not let people or animals, herds or flocks, taste anything; do not let them eat or drink. But let people and animals be covered with sackcloth. Let everyone call urgently on God. Let them give up their evil ways and their violence. Who knows? God may yet relent and, with compassion, turn from his fierce anger so that we will not perish.</blockquote><p>And when the Lord saw their repentance, when he saw how they turned from their wickedness, he withheld the destruction he had threatened.</p><p>Nineveh was spared.</p><p>And so it came to pass that the sons of Nineveh lauded Jonah, lifting him as a hero, a prophet whose words had saved them from destruction. Even the king and his nobles embraced him with open arms, vowing that the city would forever welcome him.</p><p>Yet Jonah did not revel in their praises.</p><p>Instead of triumph, he felt a creeping unease. It was a dissonance he could neither suppress nor ignore.</p><p>His conscience tormented him.</p><p>He had been wrong. He was wrong about Nineveh, wrong about its people, wrong about his fate. The impossibility he had so fiercely clung to had been shattered, turned to dust before his eyes.</p><p>And then, he felt shame.</p><p>Had he not boasted about his sacrifices? Had he not declared his suffering as proof of his righteousness? But now, after all he had endured, those offerings, those acts of submission, felt hollow. They no longer held meaning.</p><p>A strange perplexity settled over him.</p><p>On one side, there was anger. The Lord had spared Nineveh <em>on a whim</em>. And now, <em>on a whim</em>, Jonah’s burdens would continue. His duty as an obedient servant — mocked, ridiculed, diminished by the world — would remain his mantle. Resistance had proven futile. No matter how deeply he steeled his resolve, the Lord would dismantle it. Jonah could not shake the gnawing thought that his God was toying with him.</p><p>And yet…</p><p>He was grateful.</p><p>These people were idolaters. The sons of Nineveh were a nation steeped in wickedness. As a consequence, they should have been condemned. But Jonah had <em>truly </em>seen them. The caring physician, the trembling cries for justice. The people who had repented without hesitation.</p><p>Thus, Jonah’s bitterness clashed with a strange, reluctant appreciation.</p><p>But beneath it all, the weight of his wounds — both within and without — dragged him down. The pain had not fully faded. His mind begged for escape once more.</p><p>Once more, he longed for death.</p><p>He had long accepted that his life had never truly belonged to him. He had lost his will to fight, but he had not lost his desire to be <em>free</em>.</p><p>And so Jonah fled the city, seeking solitude. He went east, climbing a hill beyond the reach of men.</p><p>Before he arrived, the land was teeming with life. Pigeons and doves filled the air with song. Donkeys and sheep grazed in peace.</p><p>Yet as he ascended, the world silenced.</p><p>The birds vanished. The beasts retreated. Even the wind refused to stir.</p><p>In the stillness, Jonah kneeled. His soul writhed with emotions beyond words.</p><blockquote>Now, Lord, take away my life, for it is better for me to die than to live.</blockquote><p>He knew — <em>he knew </em>— that as long as he breathed, he would never understand the mind of God. He would never see as the Lord saw. And so, inevitably, he would resist. Again and again, his defiance would rise, his rage would burn, and he would rebel against the hand that held him.</p><p>Even if he lost every battle, he would still fight.</p><p>But what was the point?</p><p>Jonah was <em>tired</em> of losing.</p><p>His struggles, his convictions, his agonies — they had lost their meaning.</p><p>Let the Lord end it. Let this hill be his grave.</p><p>Yet the Lord did not take his life.</p><p>Instead, His voice came gently.</p><blockquote>Is it right for you to be angry?</blockquote><p>Then, the Lord provided a leafy plant, stretching its shade over Jonah, easing his discomfort.</p><p>For a fleeting moment, Jonah felt relief.</p><p>But the next dawn, the Lord sent a worm to chew the plant, withering it to ruin.</p><p>Then, the Lord conjured a scorching east wind.</p><p>Heat blazed upon Jonah’s flesh. With his body weakened and his mind reeling, Jonah’s yearning for death intensified.</p><blockquote>It would be better for me to die than to live.</blockquote><p>Yet again, the Lord asked.</p><blockquote>Is it right for you to be angry about the plant?</blockquote><p>Jonah’s grief erupted into fury.</p><blockquote>Yes! It is! And I’m so angry, I wish I were dead.</blockquote><p>But the Lord God did not heed Jonah’s plea.</p><p>Instead, his words fell upon Jonah as they had upon Moses long before.</p><blockquote>I will have mercy on whom I will have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I will have compassion.</blockquote><p>Then he added.</p><blockquote>You grieve for this plant, though you did not tend it, nor did you make it grow. It sprang up overnight and perished just as quickly. Should I not, then, have concern for the great city of Nineveh, in which there are more than a hundred and twenty thousand souls who cannot tell their right hand from their left — and also many animals?</blockquote><p>Jonah closed his eyes. The scorching heat wrapped around him. The dry air filled his lungs with the weight of the world.</p><p>He sat still, unmoving, as the final realization sank in.</p><p>He had <em>lost</em> the rebellion he had clung to so desperately.</p><p>But something stirred within him. It was not a resignation. Nor was it despair.</p><p>It was a fire, a flickering ember, grasped within his own hands at last.</p><p>He exhaled and, with steady resolve, he spoke — to his Lord, to himself, to the heavens.</p><p>“So be it.”</p><p>“If I am bound with a God like you, if my life must be spent as your obedient servant, so be it.”</p><p>“If I will never see as you see, if my heart will always resist you, knowing full well that in the end, you will have the last laugh — so be it.”</p><p>“If the road before me is one of suffering, if pain and sorrow will follow me until my dying breath — so be it.”</p><p>“Like a lone man pushing a round rock up a mountain, my struggle will remain futile.”</p><p>“But if nothing else, let this back and forth between us rise like incense, a fragrance that, in some way I may never understand, contributes to the shaping of your plan.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7694ba2893c0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>