<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Tiberiu Atudorei on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Tiberiu Atudorei on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@tiberiu.atudorei?source=rss-937c3b5cdbc9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 22:02:36 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@tiberiu.atudorei/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Project ALTius: “the ugly truth” for resin 3D printers]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tiberiu.atudorei/project-altius-the-ugly-truth-for-resin-3d-printers-a939ade0d895?source=rss-937c3b5cdbc9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a939ade0d895</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tiberiu Atudorei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Sep 2025 14:59:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-13T14:59:46.647Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The “ugly truth”: this is a “take-down piece”. I wanted to publish it just after the first article with 3D resin printer design because I don’t want you to engage in building a 3D resin printer without a full disclosure of all the technical issues </strong>.</p><p>Let’s start first with the little homework I gave you last time: why my best design (with 400 steps / rotation, 1:256 micro-stepping, double mirrors and fixed laser) is “not so accurate”? The answer is in a hint I gave you last time: “the stepper motors have a circular controlled motion and we need a linear motion”. “Linear” not as in “the laser beam is moving in a line” but something more like a mathematical correlation: “we control in fact the angle of the motor and we need a proportional / linear correlation between the controlled angle and the displacement of the laser beam”. With GT2 belts the correlation is perfect, with the mirror design … not so much. It is ALMOST linear near the center (where the angle of incidence is zero) but the error is significant once the angle has larger values. If the laser beam is positioned at a height H then for an angle A the displacement D can be computed using the following formula: tan(A)=D/H or D=H*tan(A). Indeed y=tan(x) is almost linear near 0, you can put Gemini/ChatGPT / whatever to work and show you a graph. ALMOST a line …but not EXACTLY a line.</p><p>Now that we know the problem we can choose either to fix it (and we have 2 options: change the firmware of MCU OR write a post-processor for G-code to adjust the coordinates) or just ignore it (and find a workaround). For “the fix” we need to adjust X and Y in the G-code based on a parameter H (distance from the laser module to the surface of resin) and this is not very practical (every time you have to fill in the vat with resin to the same height). The workaround is to position the laser module quite high that the angle is small enough. But the intensity of the laser beam decreases with the square of the distance and for this approach the total number of micro-steps available for motion has a rather unpleasant effect on the resolution (I leave you the pleasure to compute the resolution based on H and the angle A and 1:256 micro-stepping).<br> <br>This non-linearity is the least of our problems because we have bigger issues to solve. Remember that the laser spot is not an ideal point but an image of the LED crystal (a rectangle). This small rectangle is elongated and distorted once the spot is not in the center. This means we can’t have dimmensional accuracy with this design. Bye-bye mirrors, we fall back to older designs (coreXY or H-bot or T or + or whatever): we don’t need so much speed, the motion is quite accurate and the spot has higher intensity (it’s closer to the resin surface). And we still have the trick with 2 or even 4 spots printing in parallel … right?</p><p>Ehh …no. Laser beams are very hard to focus. For balsa cutters I used to focus on a black razor blade with the minimum practical percentage of pwer (2–3%). No black razor in this case (or maybe you can use a black razor on the printing surface) but you will not be able to focus multiple spots in the same way and there will be weight differences between segments. A single laser beam?</p><p>Not so fast. Not all resins are the same. The resin I have (and most of the resin types on the market) are formulated for bottom-up printers and quite viscous (not very fluid). The “sink-and-rise” motion creates a large blob of resin on the top and we need to use a “wiper” to keep a thin layer of un-exposed resin on top (so your “fast printer” will get even slower). All good now?</p><p>No. Not by far. There are a lot of other issues and I will just put them (almost) all in the following list:<br>- resin viscosity can be decreased by controlling the temperature to a small range and for this we need a heater (either inside the vat or a temperature controlled closed chamber : this “simple” printer starts to looks more complex compared to a FDM delta printer).<br>- the perforated grill or mesh in the printing bed will be full of exposed resin after every print and we will need to change it frequent; also the wing segment needs to be printed on a raft in order to ensure an easy separation from the bed<br>- the resin has nasty chemicals: always wear protection (nytril gloves) and a very well ventilated area (forget about printing in the bedroom or in the garage).<br>- in long printing session the resin will become more viscous in time ; you can’t keep it in the vat between printing session and you will need a system for pumping out the remaining resin and keep it in the original bottle. Once you start a new print you will have to wait quite a significant time for a clear separation between glycerin and resin<br>- in time belts and bearings and nuts and screws from the Z-axis will be affected by resin. We can design a z-axis motion system outside of the VAT but this will have 2 unpleasant effects: we will need to douuble to the height of the printer (and I’m not sutre that a 2m+ height resin 3D printer is a good idea) and the volume of the submerged parts will vary during printing and it will affect the level of resin (ad we will need to design an overflow solution to keep the level constant). Nope, too complicated.<br>- a PETG/PLA printed part can be used without too much post processing, this is not the case for resin printed parts. After printing there is a good amount of unexposed / uncured resin sticking to the part and we will need a cleaning station (a separate vat with cleaning solution because using the same vat for cleaning is not very practical) and a curing box (with a lot of UV leds). The “normal resin is usually cleaned with isopropyl alcohol (do you fancy a 50 liters vat of alcohol) and there is also a “water washable resin” but this is more expensive<br>- and finally: building not ONE but TWO large vats without leaks will be quite a challenge.<br>Right now after a couple of years of experiments I don’t see any single advantage of printing wing segments with resin — not for a personal / non-comercial use anyway. There are a lot of problems to be solved and the solutions are not trivial and the cost will increase too much. FDM printing looks to be more attractive than ever:</p><p>Speed? For resin you need to have “print =&gt; clean =&gt; cure” and for print each layer you need “print =&gt; submerge =&gt; wipe”. For FDM: just “print” and no post-processing.<br>Cost? A delta 3D printer is easier to build compared to the complexity of a resin 3D printer. (And to be honest, you don’t even need a high printer or even a delta printer, you can use a commercial FDM printer and print several parts for a wing segment).<br>Materials? PLA and PETG are 8–9–10 USD / EUR per kg, resin is at least double.<br>Health hazard? PLA and PETG are much safer compared to resin.</p><p>I’ve noticed in the last year some new filaments like HT-PLA — a special type of PLA easy to print and “high temp” stability (up to 150 Celsius). Still a bit high price but quite promising. Or even some fiber-reinforced formula (either glass fiber or carbon fiber). Or PETG or other special filament you can afford. Still a lot easier and cheaper to print compared to resin.</p><p>That’s why in the last 1–2 years I’ve focused on delta 3D printers and I’ll keep this focus in the future too. I’ll continue this series with two separate branches (“Project ALTIUS — the printer” and “Project ALTius — the glider”) and I hope for more frequent posts (with at least one piece per branch in each month). In the “printer” branch we will deal with design and building the printer, and of course in the “glider” branch the hero will be a 4m F5J 3D printed glider. I’ll show you my solutions but the goal is to give you the tools and the knowledge to enable you to build YOUR printer and YOUR glider. For both branches we will use a lot of OpenSCAD and (who knows) maybe we will spice things up with a little bit of AI.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a939ade0d895" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Project ALTius: designing a resin 3D printer”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tiberiu.atudorei/project-altius-designing-a-resin-3d-printer-2b97881a7b46?source=rss-937c3b5cdbc9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2b97881a7b46</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[3d-printing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[3d-printing-technology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tiberiu Atudorei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 09 Aug 2025 06:37:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-09T06:37:11.133Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Finally a piece about resin 3D printer for 1m wing segments</p><p>After a long time, new series with resin 3D printers. To be honest, I’ve been too lazy, this piece was prepared more than half of year ago but never posted. Finally it’s time to deal with resin 3D printing.<br>In a previous part I’ve mentioned my first version on a resin 3D printer. It was a MSLA printer (i.e. a Masked SLA: an LCD screen masking the UV light used for curing the UV-sensible resin) bottom-up (the resin was in a vat with a flexible FEP bottom and the UV source and LCD mask was below the vat). This approach is used in the vast majority of commercial resin 3D printers. I’ve explained why this approach is not good for printing 1m height wing segments (I will not repeat the arguments here, either you review the previous parts or you have to think about it and figure it out — in both cases it’s a win-win situation).<br>What you need to know about my first version: it was an iPad 3 LCD screen (9.7&quot; diagonal, 2048x1536 pixels, 264 pixels per inch… ok, enough “imperial”, here are in “metrics”: diagonal 250 mm, 0.096 mm pixel size. A similar resolution (2560 x 1440 pixels) was in my first commercial printer (Anycubic Photon) but with a much smaller screen (115x65 mm, pixel size 0.047 mm). Let’s round these values and keep them in mind for “pixel size”: 0.1 mm and 0.05 mm. In “stepper motor language” these are 10 (micro-)steps / mm and 20 (micro-)steps / mm. Also in a previous part I’ve mentioned that for a “laser spot” with 0.1 mm (quite common) we need a 0.1 mm layer height but optimal value is 0.05 mm (similar to the FDM rule “optimal layer height is half of nozzle diameter”).</p><p>Now we have some initial design parameters for our printer: 20 (micro-)steps / mm on all axes (X, Y and Z) — this is what we call “resolution”. Another parameter was computed from the constraint that we want to print a 1 meter segment in a reasonable time (16–20–24 hrs). I’m not writing again the details (please review the previous parts or make your own estimation) but the final result is that we need a “500 mm/sec” class printer. After the delta 3d printers designs detailed in the previous parts we know we can get this speed with “heavy” printing heads (200–300 grams): the laser heads are much lighter (20–50 grams) so reaching this speed will not be a problem (in fact, we will need somehow to limit the speed in order to allow enough time for curing the resin). And the motion speed is not constant (it varies over time) and it will be nice to have a corellation between the speed and the laser power (in this way we will not have areas under- or over-exposed). We’ll come back later to this issue.</p><p>For delta 3D printer we divided the design in 4 major areas: frame / motion / printing / electronics. And in order to keep the budget under control (a total cost of parts of 400 EUR) we allocated 100 EUR for each section. We can have the same approach here but we need to remember that we have some additional costs: for a large container full of glycerin. Let’s put aside 100 EUR for glycerin and limit the printer budget to just 300 EUR (not a big restriction, in fact you will see later a very efficient design). We need to keep costs under control: 75 EUR maximum per section.</p><p>Let’s see what parts are available (just a disclaimer: I’m not endorsing any of these sites, vendors or products, I’m just showing you some options and some prices and I strongly encourage you to do your own research) :</p><p>“Printing”: we need a 405 nm laser module and a perforated sheet / mesh as a building plate. The building plate is easy to build or manufacture, for the laser module we can use something like these: <br><a href="https://www.banggood.com/405nm-100-or-180-or-300mW-Blue-Violet-Dot-Laser-Module-Variable-Focus-TTL-or-PWM-Modulation-w-or-Heat-Sink-2_54-3P-for-DIY-Laser-Engraver-p-1594449.html">https://www.banggood.com/405nm-100-or-180-or-300mW-Blue-Violet-Dot-Laser-Module-Variable-Focus-TTL-or-PWM-Modulation-w-or-Heat-Sink-2_54-3P-for-DIY-Laser-Engraver-p-1594449.html</a><br><a href="https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32958287809.html">https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32958287809.html</a><br><a href="https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4000044180144.html">https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4000044180144.html</a><br>Nice, we can buy 2 (or even 3 or 4) — I’ll explain why later.</p><p>“Electronics”: no need for Klipper here, we can use older Arduino-based modules for GRBL. And no 24v power sources, a cheap 12V 5A is enough:<br><a href="https://www.banggood.com/3018-CNC-Router-3-Axis-Control-Board-GRBL-USB-Stepper-Motor-Driver-DIY-Laser-Engraver-Milling-Engraving-Machine-Controller-p-1994402.html">https://www.banggood.com/3018-CNC-Router-3-Axis-Control-Board-GRBL-USB-Stepper-Motor-Driver-DIY-Laser-Engraver-Milling-Engraving-Machine-Controller-p-1994402.html</a><br><a href="https://www.banggood.com/Laser-Engraving-Machine-Motherboard-MKSDLC32-V2_1-32Bit-Control-Board-WiFi-GRBL-TS24-or-TS35-R-Touch-Screen-Laser-Module-for-CNC-Laser-Engraving-Machine-p-2018825.html">https://www.banggood.com/Laser-Engraving-Machine-Motherboard-MKSDLC32-V2_1-32Bit-Control-Board-WiFi-GRBL-TS24-or-TS35-R-Touch-Screen-Laser-Module-for-CNC-Laser-Engraving-Machine-p-2018825.html</a><br><a href="https://www.aliexpress.com/item/33042243503.html">https://www.aliexpress.com/item/33042243503.html</a><br><a href="https://www.banggood.com/Geekcreit-AC-100-240V-to-DC-12V-5A-60W-Switching-Power-Supply-Module-Driver-Adapter-LED-Strip-Light-p-1441620.html">https://www.banggood.com/Geekcreit-AC-100-240V-to-DC-12V-5A-60W-Switching-Power-Supply-Module-Driver-Adapter-LED-Strip-Light-p-1441620.html</a><br>We can spend just 40 EUR for this part and use the savings for the extra laser modules.</p><p>“Frame”: for a single wing segment we will need a vat with a section of 5 x 30 cm. In case we want to print 2 or even 4 wing segments in the same time we need to increase the section to 10x30cm or better 15x30 cm. The width is not critical but my design is for a 15 x 30 cm section (I’ll explain why, for the moment trust me). The vat is not a critical part, you just need to build one that doesn’t leak. My design is with 2020 profiles: take 4 pieces of 150 cm 2020 profiles and cut them in 105 + 30 + 15 cm. Or you can order 120 / 30 / 15 cm pre-cut profiles. The 105 cm (or 120 cm) will be the vertical pieces and the 30 cm and 15 cm the horizontal pieces. Depending on the slot width (5mm or 6 mm) you can use different variants for walls: 5 mm / 6 mm perspex / plexiglass / policarbonat / OSB or whatever you like. Probably you can spend less than 50 EUR for a low-end solution and up to 100 EUR for something more expensive. Be creative and save some money. And don’t forget: the 2020 profile combined with 5–6 mm perspex in the slot is not leak-proof, you need to use a lot of silicone (this brings back some meories from anther hobby: aquariums).</p><p>“Motion”: this is a simplified 3D printer system. We will need a subsystem to move the printing bed up and down (on the Z axis) and another subsystem to move the laser module on the X-Y plane. Time to put on out thinking caps and do some serious design.</p><p>Let’s start with the basic: the stepper motors have a circular controlled motion and we need a linear motion. For this purpose we can use “belts and pulleys/idlers” or “lead screws”. In general “belt and pulleys” are used for speed (and are cheaper) and “lead screws” are for accuracy (and are more expensive). In FDM 3D printers you will see the lead screws used on Z axis (because the printing bed and the printed parts are quite heavy). In our case the weight is not a concern: the printing bed is a mesh. I’m not even considering the weight of the printed parts (the resin has a density of 1.15–1.20 grams / cm3 but the glycerine is 1.26 grams / cm3 — “Eureka!”). Bottom line: for the Z axis we can use 2 cheap stepper motors with 5 m GT2 belt and 2 pulleys (16 or 20 teeth) and 2 idlers. Some cheap aluminum guiders and 3D printed “bearings”. Probably 20 to 25 EUR in total. I’ll get into detail later. One remark for the moment: we will need a precise motion on the Z axis and this means no slack in the belt: we will need some cheap solution for belt tensioning (either with some screws or with springs mounted on the belt).</p><p>Of course you can use a lead screw solution for the Z axis but you will need to compensate for the backslash (usually the weight is enough but in this case we don’t have too much weight and probably you will need a solution based on double nut with a spring between them) and for non-liniar screws (in this case you can use an Oldham-type coupler or something build with magnets and bearing balls). We’ll get to these solution later — for the moment the KISS design is with belts and tensioner with springs.</p><p>The real design is on the XY motion. If we want to get a high speed we can use (and adapt) a CoreXY design (for instance the Rook by Rolohaun). To be honest a “full” coreXY design is quite expensive and an overkill: you will need an H-shaped motion mechanics (preferably with linear rails) and a lot of GT2 belts. The end result will be very good: we can achieve the desired speed but probably it’s not worth the costs because we can get the same results (speed) much cheaper. For this CoreXY mechanics we will need 2 pieces of 30–35 cm and one piece of 20 cm linear rails with 3 blocks (MGN or MGN12, the H or C variants) plus 2 motors — this parts will cost around 50 EUR at least. And a lot of GT2 belts (mind the plural because CoreXY is a double belt system). And probably the “full” CoreXY design is not a perfect solution here with the small Y travel range and the low mass of the printer head, maybe we can use a simpler “H-bot” or even a “T-bot” design (for differences between each design <a href="https://www.buildlog.net/blog/2017/10/the-midtbot-a-new-flavor-of-h-bot/">https://www.buildlog.net/blog/2017/10/the-midtbot-a-new-flavor-of-h-bot/</a> ). Let’s call this variant V1 (generic, for any of the corexy / H-bot/ T-bot options) and see if we can “improve” the design (maybe not for speed but probably cheaper).</p><p>Let’s start with a remark: we have an asymmetrical motion on X and Y axes. On X axis we need a 25 cm travel and on Y axis only 2–2.5 cm travel. If we use belts on the X axis we will need a belt tensioning solution. For the Y axis we don’t need too much speed but it’s recommended to have a better accuracy. For a 25–30 cm travel range we will need to factor in the carriage size (usual widths are 5 and 7 cm, let’s consider the 5 cm types) and the additional space for mounting the stepper motor and the belt tensioner (another 5 cm) — this will give us a 40 cm 2020 profile for the 25 cm travel range inside the 30 cm log vat. For the Y axis we need to provision in addition also the 5 cm “lost” from mounting the Y-axis 2020 profile on top of the X-axis carriage and we get a 30 cm length (15 cm active travel + 5 cm Y carriage + 5 cm X carriage + 5 cm belt tensioner and motor mount). Let’s call it the T mount (but it’s more like a “elongated T” where the horizontal line is bigger). So for this variant (V2)the cost will be lower (no expensive linear rails) but it will be somehow compensated by belt tensioners and roller carriages. These can be 3D printed (in a budget version) or you can buy some nice CNC versions (with a cost of 10–15 EUR per axis depending on the deal you get and shipment costs). OK, V2 is (somehow) cheaper compared to V1 — can we improve it?</p><p>For V3 we can apply a trick (and to be honest this can be applied both to V1 and V2). If we have these compact laser modules (with a width of 22–23 mm) we can mount 2 modules side-by-side and print 2 pieces of the wing segment in the same time. It’s nice to have a spare wing segment printed in the same time but it would be even nicer if we can print in the same time a mirrored wing segment — we need a left half wing and a right half wing after all. Is it possible?</p><p>Of course it is! If you look closer or visualize the motion of the belt you will see that on opposite sites of the 2020 profile the belt is moving in opposite directions. Here is the trick: we mount the Y-axis profile symmetrical on top of X-axis carriage (in a -+- shape …let’s call this a “+” mount).The X axis we mount exactly on the middle of the vat on top. On the opposite parts of the Y profile we mount roller carriages but on opposite sides (one on the left, the other on the right) and both vertical (considering the X carriage mounted horizontal). In this way the carriages will move in opposite directions and the printed parts will be mirrored but they will be shifted on the X axis — and it will not be possible to print on the whole surface of the VAT, probably you will lose at least 5 cm on the Y axis (the middle band that is obscured by the X carriage) and 6–7 on the x axis (the distance on the X axis between the laser beams on the 2 Y carriages). Probably now you understand why it makes sense to buy 4 laser modules — in this V4 we print left and right wing segments with spares in the same time!</p><p>One disadvantage of this V4 variant is that we are loosing a lot of “real estate” in the vat where we are not able to print due to the width an height of roller carriages. In addition the mounting of 3 roller carriages is not very simple or very easy to do. One way to improve this V4 design is to keep the belt motion on the X axis (with the bulky roller carriage) and to use lead screws for the Y axis — of course with 2 stepper motors mounted in opposite directions (either back-to-back on the central X carriage or face-to-face at the ends of the Y axis). For the Y axis we can use light linear rails (MGN7 or MGN9) or maybe aluminium or carbon rods with linear bearings from polymer or 3D printed or even some light aluminum profiles with DIY bearings (my favorite solution is with a 13.5 mm or 15 mm square aluminum tube and 3D printed bearings with PFTE tube on contact with the profile surface — very light and cost effective). Probably this V5 solution is the best we can get (a mixed design with belt motion on the long X axis and mirrored motion with lead screws on Y axis). There are some advantages to the V5 design but in the same time the design is quite complicated and we need a lot of parts. Can we make it cheaper (and — if possible — in the same time faster)?</p><p>For this next version we will have to think outside the box and get to the basics. For all designs we use 2 (or maybe 3) stepper motors and roller carriages &amp; belts or lead screws &amp; linear bearings to transform the natural rotation of the motors in linear translation — we need this translation to move the laser module all over the vat. But if you think about it we don’t need to move THE ENTIRE LASER MODULE but only the LASER BEAM. Let’s move “outside the box” the laser module and mount it above the vat in a gimbal (similar how the camera is mounted in FPV systems). Maybe we can even re-use a spare FPV gimbal with the controls but probably it’s better to keep the motion controlled with pancakes 400 steps/rotation and 1:256 micro-stepping. No profiles, no carriages, no lead screws — just a gimbal with a couple of bearings. This V6 seems very attractive — can we improve it?</p><p>Well… “Yes, we can”. The thing with the gimbal is that one motor has to rotate the laser module (something around 25–50 grams) and the other motor has to rotate the laser motor and also the other motor (another 50 grams on top of the original 25–50 grams). And these are not very strong motors (but they are accurate). And we need to move them fast and there will be a lot of direction changes — and the inertia of 25 to 100 grams is quite significant at high speeds and accelerations and decelerations. To improve this V6 design we need a little bit of “magic”.</p><p>“Magic” aka “smoke and mirrors”. No smoke for the moment (we don’t build a laser cutter but the design is the same, in fact V2 is based on my previous design for laser cutters for balsa sheets) but we can definitely use some mirrors. After all we don’t need to rotate the LASER MODULE — only the LASER BEAM. With a couple of good quality mirrors we can get the job done (it’s much easier to rotate a 2–3–4–5 grams mirror at high speeds compared to a 25–100 grams mass). The trick in this design is the mirror quality. You can get light and cheap mirrors (like the head of the disposable dental mirrors) but I don’t recommend them (I’m not sure that the glass is very planar and in addition the silver surface is on the back of the glass sheet and you will loose some focus due to the reflection on the glass surface and refraction through glass and reflection on the silver then again refraction … and all of this defocusing doubled because the laser beam travels on both mirrors). Polished metal mirrors (like the one for CO2 laser systems) are a little bit more heavy and more expensive but are more accurate. And the V7 design it’s quite cheap: probably around 10–15 EUR for the whole XY motion system (2 mirrors, 2 pancake motors and one 3D printed mount). Because it’s cheap and very fast we can afford to use heavier laser modules with more optical power output and better optics and better cooling and ventilation (very important for long printing sessions). 50 EUR top. I think we just found the perfect solution to our motion system.</p><p>One of the “flaws” of V6 and V7 designs: they are “single beam” (no tricks like doubling or quadrupling the number of laser modules). Maybe in V6 we can mount 2 compact laser modules side-by-side but I don’t recommend (it will increase the inertia of the moving gimbal with only the advantage of printing a spare part — and V6 is a dead end anyway, V7 is a better design and to be honest I never build a prototype of V6 with stepper motor, i was just contemplating the idea using a spare FPV gimbal). A mirrored wing segment is definitely a better option and the V7 design is very compact and cheap enough and we can use two V7 designs side-by-side. The motors will be controlled in parallel (similar to double lead-screws on Z axis in 3D printers), without any changes the second part will be just identical to the main print but if we reverse the sense on the Y axis on the second V7 (by rotating the 4 pin connector) we will get the printed part by second V7 a mirror of the part printed by the first V7. 100 EUR for the XY system but well spent. Well, no more tricks, we got the best design (“V8 is the best” probably has some truth also in this case).</p><p>If we add the costs of the parts for frame (50–100 EUR), electronics (25–50 EUR), Z motion (25–50 EUR) and XY/printing (50 EUR for V7 and 100 EUR for V8) we can get a total cost of our design between 150 and 300 EUR. We have enough in the initial budget (400 EUR) for the glycerin (we need around 50 liters of glycerin: 3.14 x 1.64 x 9.7 dm3 aka liters if you want an estimation of the volume).</p><p>One more trick in improving the V7/V8 design. Remember my first resin 3D printer (the one with the iPad3 LCD screen). It was not a good printer because the UV back light was quite weak (but now we have cheap 100 W UV floodlights (8 EUR <a href="https://www.aliexpress.com/w/wholesale-UV-100W.html">https://www.aliexpress.com/w/wholesale-UV-100W.html</a>) and LCD ( 27 EUR <a href="https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005007666418579.html">https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005007666418579.html</a>) and driver (10 EUR <a href="https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005005510901114.html">https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005005510901114.html</a>). Throw in a RaspberryPi and maybe a NanoDLP control board (45–68 EUR see details on <a href="https://www.nano3dtech.com/nanodlp-controller-board/">https://www.nano3dtech.com/nanodlp-controller-board/</a>) and you get also an MSLA 3D printer. And if you are not on a tight budget forget the iPad3 LCD and driver (you will need to modify the LCD screen anyway to get out the reflective backend) and get a proper 4K monochrome — you will spend around 200 EUR (<a href="https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005004398952516.htm">https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005004398952516.htm</a>) but you will get better results and a one-of-a-kind MSLA/SLA 3D resin printer. For a cost similar to an Anycubic Mono x you will have a dual-type with larger printed volume (90–95–100 cm height compared to only 20 cm for Anycubic Mono X). But for the monent this is just a crazy idea you can use if you want to experiment also with MSLA printing (the SLA laser variant is very good for sparse structures like the wing segments but for other parts a whole layer exposure used in MSLA makes more sense).<br> <br>Remember when I’ve told you that if you take 3 important criteria for a design (in our case cost, speed and accuracy) you can do good on two of these but a trifecta is (usually) impossible? This V8 design is definitely cheap and very fast … but is it ACCURATE? Think about it… I’ll explain why (and how to fix this flaw in the design) in the next part.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2b97881a7b46" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Project ALTius part X: “YADA — Yet Another Delta Article” … or rather “Annoyance” after all these…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tiberiu.atudorei/project-altius-part-x-yada-yet-another-delta-article-or-rather-annoyance-after-all-these-76345eca1e87?source=rss-937c3b5cdbc9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/76345eca1e87</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[delta-3d-printer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[project-altius]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tiberiu Atudorei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 28 Dec 2024 10:15:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-28T10:15:54.540Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Project ALTius part X: “YADA — Yet Another Delta Article” … or rather “Annoyance” after all these parts</h3><p>A lot of changes in the FDM 3D printers scene in the last year, here is a short list of new models from major vendors: BambuLab A1 and A1 mini (bed-slingers); Creality K1, K1Max, K1C and K2 (CoreXY); Sovol SV08 (Voron 2.4 350 mm clone); Elegoo OrangeStorm Giga (coreXY 800x800x1000mm); Peopoly MagnetoX (coreXY with linear motors); FLSun S1 and T1/T1 Pro (delta) and Prusa HT90 (delta). Do you remember the Olympic motto? “Citius, altius, fortius” means “Faster, higher, stronger”. BambuLab took the downsizing path (X1/X1c were high end, P1P/P1S were middle and they needed the bed-slingers to cover the lower-end market), all other vendors launched “faster / stronger” models with one notable exception (the giant Elegoo OrangeStorm Giga coreXY with 1 m printing height). With the exception of BambuLab entry-level printers all other models are over 500 EUR (the cost of materials for my ALT0 / ALT1meter design).</p><p>FlSun is very aggressive (in a good way) and has very good deals right now. S1 seems to be “the next V400” and T1 (and the recently launched T1 Pro) seems to be “the next SR” (the same printing sizes but improved with Klipper, enclosure, direct drive and CPAP fan). And while they are trying very hard to get a good slice of the upper-end market (Flsun T1 Pro is 500 EUR stable price right now, it was 440 EUR pre-order and T1 is 460 EUR) they are trying to sell the last stock of SR for just 200 EUR including shipping. I don’t need to tell you this is a very good price, barely covering the cost of parts and materials. So if you don’t mind printing the 1m wing segment in 3 or 4 “sub-segments” then SR (and modding it) is the way to go. In fact that’s what I did, I bought the 3rd SR (but it was 220 EUR at that time, now there are even better deals at 199 EUR including shipping inside EU).</p><p>Why do I “need” 3 SRs? Good question. For the moment I will use them for printing the parts for other delta printers (each set of printed parts for a delta printer contains 3 x lower corners + 3 x upper corners + 3 x rail carriages + 3 x lower frame enforcer + 3 x upper frame enforcer frame + 3 x end-stop holders + 3 x endstop part on the carriage + 3 x belt tensioner mounts + 3 x …. you get the idea, I don’t like to wait too much for printing functional parts). And when I’ll no longer print parts for delta printers these 3 printers will have different nozzles (0.2 mm &amp; 0.25 mm &amp; 0.3 mm). The 0.4 mm nozzle will be reserved for the Anycubic Predator — I’ve bought one and this is my current moding project (with klipper and direct drive).</p><p>Let’s come back to the Flsun S1/T1 compared with my designs ALT0 / ALT1x (ALT0 is the design with MGN12 linear rails for 75–80 cm printing height and ALT1x is the design with HGR15 linear rails for over 1 m printing heights). If you look into marketing materials (images and small videos) for S1 you’ll notice that it uses HGR linear rails (probably HGR15..or maybe HGR20). And of course T1/T1 Pro uses MGN12. My choice of linear rails was before S1/T1 launch and it’s just a validation that this is a good solution (for the “motion” subsystem — remember that I’m using also original SR arms). What FLsun printers have (and I can’t just “replicate”) is a very rigid frame: large extrusion profiles screwed on steel plates.</p><p>Probably you’ve guessed by now that I’m partial to precision / accuracy and not to speed. Speed is also nice to have but only if the result prints are looking nice. There are several factors at play in achieving good results in this type of prints (tall prints with small diameter nozzles) and I’ll do a small recap of these factors in each of the sub-systems of a delta 3D printer. What we want to achieve is “rigidity and precision motion”.</p><p>The frame is very important (especially for my type of tall printers): you need to make it as rigid as possible. It’s very easy to work with 2020,2040 and 3030 profiles, these are relatively cheap and you can order them at pre-defined length or cut to order. TLDR: V-slot/T-slot 2020 are fine, if you are on the budget try 20x20 mm square tube (but you have to design your linear carriages with small bearings), if you have a large budget 3030 or 2040. Base can be 300 mm for open-frame printers and 400 mm for enclosed. Corner brackets are a must (I use these in ALT0), enclosing panels are optimal (ALT1x). A good printer starts with a good foundation — and this is the frame. A rigid frame (for a tall printer)- this can be obtained only with corner brackets and (if possible) side panels (enclosure).</p><p>The mechanical part (the “motion” system) depends of course on the frame (type and height). This is the “motion precision” part. TLDR: cheap/budget with 2020 carriages (but you need a V-slot 2020 or 2040), better MGN12 (but AFAIK you are limited to 1000 mm travel = 750–800 mm printing height in ALT0), best HGR15 (in my case 1500 mm lenght, enough for 1m+ printing height — you can use also 1200mm if you find them cheap). Budget DIY mag-bal arms, better FL SUN 315 mm carbon arms (I use these in all my designs), best V400 345 mm carbon arms (but these will be 60+ EUR compared to 25–30 EUR for SR arms and it’s really not worth it for 26 cm printing diameter, you will need them for 30+ cm printing diameter). A precise motion is obtained with linear rails with minimal lateral play (MGN9 / MGN12 are “budget” variants, HGR15/HGR20 are better variants due to double rows of rolling steel balls), carbon arms with the exact same length (mag-balls pre-made or DIY or maybe good quality spare parts from commercial delta printers) and (very important) the belt tension (in fact not the tension per se, we are interested in minimal slack on the belt and this can be achieved by adjusting the belt tension — but within reasonable limits because a higher tension will cause friction and even a bent motor axis with disastrous consequences). In ALT0 I use 6 mm CNCed belt tensioners with some tensioning springs, in ALT1X 9 mm with polyurethane/steel core belts and the belt tensioner with an additional nut for locking the position.</p><p>The printing bed: the FlSun QQS-Pro is a sensible choice (around 30–35 EUR), just one type of printing surface (the lattice printing glass) but it will serve you well for a long time. This type of surface is used also in FLSun SR (but the difference is that in SR the glass is not glued to the aluminium base and can be changed). Or it can be “reversed” and on the verso you can glue the magnetic base and use also a PEI textured sheet (and even a PET smooth surface). The 3rd variant: use the V400 printing bed. Or maybe a hexagonal plate with AC heating and a magnetic steel sheet with PEI coating.</p><p>Electronics: definitely Klipper. With or without a touch screen (it doesn’t matter too much if you have the web interface). With or without CANbus (but personally I prefer the convenience of CANbus with a spiral cable over cable management for 16 long wires — and the build in accelerator sensor chip is worth having too and will help you fine tuning the maximum speeds and accelerations). And if you are considering a printer farm silent power adapters are a must. The electronics can be assembled of parts from different vendors but there are also one-vendor solutions (like Skipr with touch screen from Makerbase or the cheetah from Kingroon or similar). Or you can buy a tablet / pad Klipper (Flsun speerder pad, Creality sonic Pad or BigTreeTech Pad 7 — BTW, this is the best deal right now at 89 USD).</p><p>And (finally) the hotend and extruder (or maybe a “hotend &amp; extruder” combo — in fact some people prefer to call the filament pushing part a “feeder”). This part of the printer is very important. When you print with a 0.2–0.25 mm nozzle you need a well calibrated printer and an accurate bed mesh. A 0.1–0.15 mm layer height is definitely less forgiving for bed adhesion. If you look on the internet for FlSun SR mods (because let’s be clear: my printers are in fact “elongated” versions of FlSun SR, in slicers we can use the same printing profiles with changed printing heights) you will find that there are 2 major types of mods: Klipper and direct drive extruder. The point is: almost all Klipper solutions have the same result (an increase in quality print) but not all the printing heads (hotend + extruder + fan + Z-probe) are the same. And of course there is not a single best solution for our printer — in fact I’m using several solutions (for the same problem).</p><p>Let’s design the printing head starting from what we want to print: a 1m wing segment (or maybe a 1m fuselage segment — but it’s not extremely different). The maximum chord will be around 25 cm (with 1–2 walls — that’s 0.5–1m of long lines with moderate speed) with a 2–4% gyroid infill (that means it will be around 1 m lines with small movements but we don’t care too much about the quality of infill). We will need to print around 2 m per layer. Nozzles will be 0.2 to 0.4 mm (or even 0.15 mm for Revo variants) so the layer height will be 0.1 to 0.25 mm — for a total of 4000 to 10000 layers. Let’s say we want to print it in 16 to 24 hrs: for 20 hrs print and 10000 layers we will get a 7.2 second per layer. We get an average of 300 mm/sec print speed and (considering all the accelerations and decelerations) probably a 500 mm/s capable printer. Well, FLSun SR (non-Klipper) has 150–200 m/sec , Flsun SR (Klipper) 250–300 mm/sec and FlSun V400 has 400–600 mm/sec. Is it possible to get 500 mm/sec from our printer?</p><p>The answer is a re-assuring YES. There are 2 limiting factors for the printing speed: mechanical and thermal. For mechanical we just need (a rigid frame) + (strong motors) + (rigid arms) + (light printing head) — we got almost all of these, we will deal with the light printing head in a moment. For thermal we will need a Volcano-class hot end — or maybe not, thermals are not a concern for us. Why? Because we will not print the wing segment with the 0.4 mm nozzle (this nozzle diameter is good maybe for rigid molds and plugs — or for strong heavy wings).</p><p>A 500 mm/sec printer with a standard 0.4 mm nozzle (that’s very important in our estimation) needs a very performant hotend — capable of melting in every second 500 mm * 3.14 * 0.4 mm * 0.4 mm / 4 = 62.8 mm3/sec. A standard hotend is able to melt around 15 mm3/sec, a performant hotend (Volcano/X1/variants) around 30–35 mm3/sec. For 0.2 mm nozzles we will need only 15.7 mm3/sec — the hotend will not be a problem at all, we can use almost any type of hotend. For a 0.25 mm nozzle you need 25 mm3/s and for 0.3 mm nozzle 35 mm3/sec. These numbers are just a rough maximum estimation — the volume of a cylinder, PI/4 is 0.785 but in fact the volume needed will be lower and proportional with layer height x nozzle diameter (for instance a layer height of 0.15 mm for the 0.25 mm nozzle means a 0.6 multiplier instead of 0.785). Good news: all the BambuLab X1/P1 hotend clones and the Dragon clones with circular ceramic heater (with Revo or normal V6 nozzles) are capable of 35 mm3/sec. And of course you can use a cheap CHF clone for increased flow.<br> <br>The printing head needs to be light (in order to reach high printing speeds) and robust (capable to withstand 16–24 hrs printing sessions). The original Flsun print head is around 270 grams (but don’t forget it’s with a bowden tube, not direct drive). A Voron Stealthburner print head is 480–500 grams. My first version of FlSun direct drive extruder (with dual 5051 blower fans and using the original aluminium platform) was 330–340 grams. My second version for FLSun SR (with dual 4010 fan and ABS platform ) was 260 grams. For ALT0/ALT1x I’ll use the 3rd generation and I’m aiming for a printing head around 250 grams.</p><p>The total weight of the delta printing head is made up of several parts:<br>- the 3d printed platform with 8–10 mm balls — around 40 grams (35–45 grams…maybe 50 for 10 mm balls)<br>- fans — usual dual 4010 blower + 3010 / 4010 standard, for 0.2 mm nozzle we can use 3010 blower &amp; standard fans; 3010 is 10 grams, 4010 is 12.5 grams = let’s say 30–40 grams for fans <br>- hotend — 25 grams for the x1 clone, 35 grams for a Voron/Revo clone<br>- feeder — from 110 grams (a light mini/micro Sherpa with a 17 mm Nema 14 pancake) to 170–180 grams (17–20 mm tall 36mm diameter pancake and 70+ grams CNCed feeder)<br>- tool-board — 10–15 grams<br>… for a total of 210–310 grams range (around our initial target).</p><p>The hotend + feeder can be a combo solution: the lightest is the Roto Revo (only 140 grams but quite expensive , over 160 EUR) or the BiQu H2 V2S (200 grams but a more palatable 50 EUR price, even with a lighter variant 175 grams at the same price but with 0.6 mm nozzle with 4mm thread). Or the BiQu H2 V2S Revo (95–100 EUR … the light variant is over 200 EUR and it’s not worth it). Or maybe my “DIY H2 V2S Revo” for 75 EUR: a standard H2 V2S + 15 EUR Revo heater Clone + 5 EUR Revo clone 0.25 mm nozzle + a 20 mm Alu tube 6mmx3mm threaded with M4 (or if you want to get a commercial variant the Sprite adapter from E3D for around 10 EUR).</p><p>The “DIY H2 V2S Revo” is what I intended to use on ALT1x (where the 7 cm height of combo extruder hanging under the effector platform is not a problem). On the smaller printers I had to use a normal hotend+feeder (with the parts located above the effector platform). In both cases the target weight for the printing head is around 250 grams. Maybe you have noticed that I did not include the weight of the Z-probe — that’s because is a very light touch probe (under 1 gram) for normal V6-style nozzles or a light 2 gram IR diff optical for Revo nozzles.</p><p>This simple type of Z-end stop (with a sponge mounted around the nozzle and 2 thin PCBs with metal contacts similar with what you find in keyboards) is a very effective solution: it’s cheap and quite accurate. I used it for a while with very good results but in time you will find it’s limitations: you can use it only on a cold nozzle (I had to change the probe for my friend because he forgot to take it out and started printing with the probe mounted), you have to mount / unmount every time you want to calibrate or just do a bed mesh (not very convenient if changing often the bed surface, in ALT1x I can use glass / smooth PEI / textured PEO) and finally you can’t use it on Revo nozzles. That’s one of the reasons I’ve demoted my Biqu H2 V2S (with original Revo nozzles or with Sprite adapters) to use in CoreXy printers (Vorons / BLV MGN cube / TwoTree Sapphire) and bed slingers. On these printers I use a Z-probe similar to Voron Tap (Chaotic Lab Tap V1 for Vorons and a simpler DIY Tap-like for BLV MGN cubes).</p><p>There are of course “TAP-like” solutions for delta printers: Duet3D Smart effector (55–60 GBP including taxes) and E3D PZ probe (42 GBP just the probe, or 72 GBP with Voron Revo radiator — all prices including taxes). Both products are based on a piezzo sensor. Probably a good solution for a single printer but very expensive for a printing farm of 14 printers. I’ve just adapted my design of Tap-like sensor for delta printer in a cheaper and simpler solution. (If you don’t want to use my design you can still buy some older non-piezo “Tap-like” effectors for E3D V6 hotends on AliExpress: the mount for the E3D V6 “neck” is articulated, the hotend can rotate a little bit and touch — or dis-engage — a micro-switch or an optical switch; my design is even simpler: it uses pure electrical contacts and its very simple to build.).</p><p>Here is the simplest solution: take 2 pieces of M3 hexagonal brass spacers (I use the 8 mm length in my design but it’s not important) and place them parallel flat on the table horizontally with a 2 mm gap between them (or similar, it’s not critical — what is critical is the parallelism between spacers). Take a M4 nut an place it vertically on the M3 brass spacers (“vertically” means the M4 screw hole is “horizontal”, parallel with the table and the brass spacers, and one of the edges of the nut is on top). In this position the M4 nut is closing an electrical contact between the M3 brass spacers (with the spacers edge touching the nut surface). Any small upward movement of the M4 nut will break the contact. Of course you can use also another M3 nut of M3 brass spacer (the spacers are in fact elongated M3 nuts). And of course you can use gold plated cylinders from RC motor connectors or other similar solution but these are more expensive and you need to solder electrical wires. With the M3 brass spacers it’s very easy: I’m just using some M3 6 mm screws and some PVC-isolated wires.</p><p>My “DelTap” solution uses 3 contacts of this type (2 x M3 brass spacers + M4 nut) mounted in the corners of the effector and in serial electrical connection. This effector is made up of 2 parts:<br>- a “base”: made up of 3 arms and a “tower” ( a triangular prism with fans mounted on the facets); the tower has central vertical hexagonal cutout for the hotend, rounded lateral cutouts for the airflow of the fans (on all 3 faces, but only the axial hotend fan will use it effectively) and angled cutouts at the base for part cooling (3 cutouts but only 2 will be used by radial blower fans for part cooling) and some small cutouts on top for mounting the 3 M4 nuts<br>- a “lift” (or the mobile part): a hexagonal shape prism with the extruder mounted on top, the hotend mounted underneath and the 6 pcs of M3 brass spacers (3 sets of 2 spacers) mounted on 3 lateral faces (positioned on top of the M4 nuts).</p><p>It’s a simple parametric design created in OpenSCAD. Mounting holes for the extruder are 3 pairs simmetrical to center and it allows me to use any of the several types I have (ABS-printed mini-/ micro-sherpa/ Sailfin and CNCed SailFin/HGX lite). Fans can be 3010 or 4010 (no need to bother with 35xx variants because these are not common and are more expensive). The hotend can be Revo Vorons, Dragon, Mosquito, BambuLab clones or even E3D V6 (I have a cloned variant with the cold-end in hexagon shape and the neck is screwed in). Sounds complicated but it’s not.</p><p>I’m using this “V3 DelTap effector” design in all my delta printers now, the only difference is the (fan / extruder / hotend) combination: <br>- (3010 fan / 3d printed Sherpa / Bambu Lab clone) in ALT0 (225 grams)<br>- (4010 fan / CNCed extruder / Voron Revo clone or similar) in ALT1x (250 grams)<br>- (4010 fan / 3D printed Sailfin / RedLizzard K1 and the original heater cartridge and thermistor from the spare parts kit) for Flsun SR and Anycubic Predator (275 grams but with 8 mm steel balls with M4 holes and 6 pieces of M4 nuts and M4 threaded rods)</p><p>And the weight is spot on: 225 grams for the lightest combination (3010 fans with Bambulab clone and a 3D printed micro-Sherpa), 250 grams for ALT1X and up to 270–275 grams for heaviest on SR. 250 grams +/- 10% : not bad at all. The additional 25 grams over the 250 grams target (due to the additional weight of 6 M3 bras spacers, 6 M3 6mm screws and 3 M4 nuts) is only for FlSun SR and it’s worth it (increased precision and convenience of the Z-endstop Tap-like solution).</p><p>If you want to print fast with a 0.4 mm nozzle use 4010 fans, for 0.3–0.25–0.2 mm nozzle you can use 3010 (for the radial blower fans the volume of air is proportional with the squared radius — just like the volume of melted plastic is proportional to the squared nozzle diameter for a fixed printing speed; in other words if you are OK with 40 mm fans for 0.4 mm nozzle you can print at the same speed with 0.3 mm nozzle or smaller diameter with just 30 mm fans — but to be honest we don’t have too many overhangs and you can be fine with 30 mm fans even for 0.4 mm nozzle, a 40 mm fan will be needed only for 0.6 mm nozzle).</p><p>I guess I’ve bored you to death with all these technical details about extruded profiles, linear rails, carbon arms, nozzles, extruders, Z-endstops and flow rates. Probably this is the last piece in the series dedicated to delta printers and FDM printers in general. I will start soon(-ish) a series for my resin printer designs.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=76345eca1e87" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Project ALTius part IX: “MY better / best printers for glider” or “DIY delta printer improved…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tiberiu.atudorei/project-altius-part-ix-my-better-best-printers-for-glider-or-diy-delta-printer-improved-f5af2379a2d4?source=rss-937c3b5cdbc9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f5af2379a2d4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[delta-printers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[3d-printer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[f5j]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[project-altius]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tiberiu Atudorei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 26 May 2024 16:59:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-26T16:59:47.836Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Project ALTius part IX: “MY better / best printers for glider” or “DIY delta printer improved designs for printing wing segments”</h3><h4>In the previous two parts I’ve recommended FLSun as a good starting printer for 300 EUR/330 USD and I’ve reviewed several build options for the 4 main sections (frame / electronics / motion / printing) in a DIY delta 3d printer design (FYI: FLSun SR price dropped to 279 EUR and V400 to 570 EUR). I also gave some details about my first generation delta 3D printer design (made with 2020 v-slots profiles with OpenBuilds-style carriages, DIY mag-balls arms and controlled by Klipper on RPi3 + BTT SKR mini E3). In this part we will try to improve the design but keeping the costs within a reasonable range (around 400–450–500 EUR). Buckle up, in this part we will touch both the technical and economical aspects of these designs. (And unfortunately it’s quite a long and “dry” piece — no pictures today).</h4><p>I have a confession to make: the cost of 400 EUR for my initial design is not REAL. What I mean: if you want to build up that design and buy materials and print the parts (on your printer or on your friends printer or ordered on a printing service) then yes, it’s around 400 EUR (give or take, YMMV). But for ME it was different: I don’t have to spend 400 EUR to build one, and I don’t have to wait 2–3–4 weeks for parts. I have a large “inventory” of parts available and several printers I can use in parallel (I can print all the plastic parts for the delta printer in one day). Some components I have in my “inventory” were more expensive compared to current prices (for instance my stock of 2020 profiles were bought at 10 EUR/m and the current price is around 6.5 EUR/m — or the CNC-ed carriages and belt tensioner I bought them several years ago for laser cutters at around 10 EUR/piece and now you can get them much cheaper — belt tensioners are 3 EUR / piece + shipment, probably 15 EUR for belt tensioners and 15 EUR for carriages). But other components were cheaper (mostly electronic parts — MCUs). In fact the real “investment” (the parts &amp; components I had to buy ) for the first design was initially ZERO (I had everything available) and MINIMAL for improvements (around 50 EUR: 20 EUR for 16 mm steel conduit, 20 EUR for stronger magnets and 10 EUR for LCD touch screen for RPi). I also had the parts for the prototype of the second design (MGN12 and 3030) and I ordered only FLSun spare parts (SR carbon arms and QQS-pro heated bed).</p><p>And another thing: you can save a lot of money in the frame budget and use it elsewhere where it really matters(in the motion subsystem). If you want to upgrade the “motion” system and use linear rails you don’t need expensive V-slot profiles — the cheaper T-slot profiles are good enough. Or even cheaper square aluminum profiles 20x20x2 mm — these are available in my country at 4.2 EUR/m and sold in 6 m pieces (25 EUR 6m piece is exactly what we need for the second design). A word of advice though: you still need a VERY rigid frame so please consider some corener reinforcements and / or some panels to keep the frame straight and vibration-free (no need for expensive poly-carbonate or plexiglass panels, you can use cheap plywood or OSB panels).</p><p>We will combine elements of the first design with components of FLsun SR. Instead of 50 cm MGN12 we will use 100 cm (and if we keep a similar distance between pillars we can expect a printing height extended by 50 cm to the 80–83 cm range). Using the 20x20x2 cm aluminum square tube allows us to use the same 3D printed parts for the corner (or we can easily modify the 3D model) and all we need to do is some precision cutting: the original 6 m in 3 pieces of 2 m, and each 2 m piece in 1.3 m + 2 x 0.35 m. And of course tap some 3 mm holes and M3 threads in these square tubes but this should not be a big problem in this type of material. In this way the original 100 EUR budget can be reduced to 25 EUR (6m of 20x20x2 mm alu square tube) + 20 EUR (PLA/PETG)+ 5 EUR (for M3 screws) = 50 EUR (or even 45 EUR).</p><p>We can use the 50 EUR save for motion upgrade but it will not be enough for a set of 3 x 1m MGN12 rail. On BangGood or AliExpress you can get some good prices for sets of 2 pieces (but with longer delivery times from China) and some good prices for delivery from EU warehouses. Of course you don’t have to use the MGN12 linear rails: you can use cheaper MGN9 or even MGN7. And of course you can get very good prices if you get sets of 2 (or optimal 3) pieces from local EU warehouses. Right now I can see on BangGood MGN12 (with MGN12H slider) 1000mm at 33 EUR (+6 EUR shipping , but I see this price is for “1 piece per customer”) or 35–40 EUR from China on AliExpress. And of course you can get better prices on Black Friday or Cyber Monday or 11.11 or Christmas or Easter or whatever period of discounts you are willing to chase if you are not in a hurry (and maybe if you are willing to buy more pieces). Probably right now the best you can get is around 100–105 EUR for a set of 3 linear rails.</p><p>For the second iteration of the design I had the linear rails ready and I could use the existing 2020 profiles (not used in the first design) OR try the cheap 20x20x2 mm square tube but it was no need to go the cheap route: I already had better profiles for the upgrade. Some time ago I bought some used 3030 profiles for cheap (around 4 EUR for 116cm 3030 ). Some 100cm 3030s were cut in 33.2 cm pieces (with some small differences of course but these can be compensated in assembly). I just ordered some 300mm and 400mm 3030s for testing different base sizes (30–33–40cm). And of course I had to design &amp; print the corners for the 3030 profiles — I just downloaded something from Thingiverse and printed the parts.</p><p>So far we got 2 upgrades for frame (3030 vs 2020) and motion (MGN12 vs 2020 carriages). My advice is that MGN12 upgrade is definitely worth it but you don’t have to go the 3030 route (I just used 3030 because I had these parts available). For a new build I’d recommend the cheap 20x20x2 mm aluminum square tube. In fact if you have a wood working shop (or even if you don’t have one) you can save some money and build a frame out of wood and reinforced with OSB side panels.</p><p>What else we can improve in the original design? The arms were build in the prototype with 2 pcs 6mm diameter 1m length aluminum tubes (cut in 332 mm pieces) and then “upgraded” with carbon tubes ordered from AliExpress. The aluminum tubes were cheap (2 EUR maybe?), the carbon was a little bit more expensive (10–15 EUR for a set of 6 arms, ranging from 10 EUR for small 240 mm and 15 EUR for 400 mm) but a set of 12 strong magnets (10 mm diameter x 20 mm length) was 20 EUR. Plus the cost for the balls: 1–2 EUR for simple bearing balls glued in place or 5–10 EUR for 10 mm balls with M4 threads. Nothing wrong with these DIY mag-ball arms but you can get the set of FlSun SR arms for 25–35 EUR (in my case it was 26 EUR / set when I bought several sets). And don’t forget that you need also 8 mm balls for SR arms (either with a M4 thread or Flsun originals). Probably it will cost around 35–40 EUR in total for arms &amp; balls but it’s worth it — if not for the performance upgrade at least for the better looks (but to be honest mag-ball arms with a rather heavy direct drive extruder mounted on the effector with high accelerations can have sometimes unpleasant effects: even with strong magnets it is possible that the printing head will disengage from the magnets and the print will be ruined — the springs in the SR arms are an extra insurance for this concern).</p><p>What else we can use from FLsun SR? Of course the printing bed but the SR solution (aluminum heated bed + separate printing glass) is more expensive than the integrated solution (glass glued to the aluminum bed) from FLSun QQS-Pro and it’s actually the same size. These are the FLSun parts we will use and include in the budget: 30 EUR for SR arms + 10 EUR for balls + 30 EUR for QQS-Pro bed. These are from the “motion” and “printing” sections. I needed also some other changes for the SR arms.</p><p>In the mag-ball arms I used some 3D printed parts from Rolohaun’s Phoenix design (<a href="http://www.github.com/rolohaun/PhoenixDelta">www.github.com/rolohaun/PhoenixDelta</a>). The design was OK with mag-balls but SR arms gave me some issues. First: the springs in the SR arms were interfering with the belt tensioners using the PhoenixDelta effector. Second: the parts were designed for 10 mm mag-balls (spaced at 56 mm between ball centers) and SR had 71 mm sideways for 8 mm balls. No problem, the solution was simple, I designed some adapters. But these adapters had to be mounted either vertical (and in this case I was losing 2 x 2.5 cm = 5 cm from the vertical range) or horizontally (and in this case it was a similar effect, the delta geometry was changed because the pillar for vertical movement was translated 2.5 cm inwards and the effector radius was increased by 2.5 cm — to simplify the printing diameter range was decreased by around 5 cm).</p><p>We can use the same SR effector (even if I’m not a fan of the volcano clone used by SR) but we will find that the usual 30 cm or 40 cm 2020 v-slot profiles are not a very good fit. For 30 cm base profiles the distance is too short: the solution is to increase the base by using some 3D printed spacers mounted at the end of the base profiles. For 40 cm base profiles the distance is too large: the solution is to use some horizontal spacers mounted on the MGN12 carriage and on the effector. Instead of using Rolohaun’s Phoenix parts with some adapters I opted for a simpler approach. The previous design was for PLA (no heated bed), this version was for PLA and PETG (heated bed without enclosure). The heated bed was no longer limited inside the base triangle and I could use smaller 30 cm profiles. On the other hand I had to reduce the height of the carriage and the radius of the effector as much as possible. I designed a very compact effector using the Dragon and Mosquito mount holes and another version for the BambuLab hotend clones. There was not much need for cooling if I printed with 0.2–0.25–0.3 mm nozzles without overhangs and I used smaller 3010 blower fans. I also translated the hotend mount several centimeters upwards (the hotend was not longer mounted under the effector platform) in order to increase the printing height range (with this change the nozzle was around 1 cm below the effector plane instead of 5–6 cm in Rolohaun’s design).</p><p>Electrical upgrades: the 24V 400W power source (with a noisy fan) was replaced with 2 x slim fan-less for LED strips (these were also rated for 24V 400w but in reality the voltage dropped if the power exceeded 250W, I used them in tandem — one for electronics and motion and the second just for the heated bed activated with a MOSFET electronic relay).</p><p>And finally instead of the small 3.5&quot; LCD with resistive touch I used larger 5&quot; LCDs with capacitive touch for improved readability and responsiveness. Total cost?</p><blockquote><strong>Frame:</strong> 6m 20x20x2mm (25 EUR) + PLA/PETG (10 EUR) + M3 bolts (5 EUR) = <strong>40 EUR</strong><br><strong>Motion:</strong> MGN12 (105 EUR) + FLsun SR arms (30 EUR) + NEMA17 (20 EUR) + GT2 (10 EUR) + belt tensioners (20 EUR) + 8mm balls (10 EUR) + endstops (5 EUR)=<strong>200 EUR.</strong><br><strong>Electronics:</strong> Power (20 EUR) + RasPi3A (27.5 EUR) + 5inch touch (22.5 EUR) + BTT SKR Pico (25 EUR) = <strong>95 EUR</strong><br><strong>Printing: </strong>BambuLab/Mosquito/Dragon hotend clone (15 EUR) + dual-drive light extruder (15 EUR) + fans (5 EUR)+ Flsun QQS-Pro heatbed/glass (30 EUR) = <strong>65 EUR.</strong><br><strong>TOTAL for second design with MGN12: </strong>40 EUR (frame) + 200 EUR (motion) + 95 EUR (electronics) + 65 EUR (printing)= <strong>400 EUR</strong></blockquote><p>The second version is a very good design within a reasonable budget (400 EUR), it is an “extended FLSunSR with Klipper and direct drive”. At this point probably you are wondering why I had the 3rd design — what can be improved?</p><p>The first design allowed me to print 1 m segments, the second only 75–80 cm (limited by the 1m MGN12 rails). There was no real need for the third version but the opportunity came when I found discounted 1500 mm HGR15 linear rails sets in EU warehouses (2 pcs 1500mm HGR15 with 4 pcs HGH15CA sliders). I combined this (2 x linear rails + 4 x slider blocks) offer from a vendor with a (2 x linear rails set without slide blocks) from another to get a final price of 107.5 EUR for a set of 3 linear rails with slider blocks (similar to the current price for MGN12 1m set). I already had the 2020 frame profiles (3 x 1500 mm + 6 x 400 mm), I just had to design some corners with cutouts for HGR15 and corner reinforcements.</p><p>HGR15 sliders mounting holes are different from MGN12 and I had to design a new carriage — an easy task, my previous design was done in OpenSCAD and it was parametric. I also decided to upgrade from 6 mm GT2 belts to 9 mm (and from rubber belts reinforced with glass fiber to polyuretan belts reinforced with steel wires). For this upgrade I needed to change also the GT2 pulleys and the GT2 belt tensioner type for 9 mm.<br>I decided to do some upgrades for the electronics too: a 7 inch capacitive touch screen, OrangePi Plus SBCs (I bought these several years ago and not used yet in any project), BTT SKR Pico and a CANbus toolhead (EBB36 connected via a U2C USB-to-CANbus adapter). The U2C is connected to the OrangePi SBC via a USB-C spiral cable sized for the hotend &amp; extruder power (2 m spiral cables rated for 5A).</p><p>For printing I decided to use the FLSun heated bed &amp; glass and a PEI/PET steel sheet (with the magnetic base mounted on the verso of the glass — in this way I could use 3 different type of printing surfaces) and a compact BiQu H2 V2S extruder.</p><p>Here is a short estimation of the cost for the third design:</p><blockquote><strong>Frame:</strong> the same frame as in 1st design (3 x 1500 mm + 6 x 400 mm) = <strong>70 EUR</strong><br><strong>Motion:</strong> with HGR15 (107.5 EUR) + FLSun SR arms (26.5 EUR) + NEMA17 (21 EUR) + GT2 (15 EUR) + belt tensioners (15 EUR) + 8mm balls (10 EUR) + endstops (5 EUR)=<strong>200 EUR</strong>.<br><strong>Electronics:</strong> Power (20 EUR) + OPiPlus (25 EUR) + 7inch touch (30 EUR) + BTT SKR Pico (25 EUR) + BTT CANbus adapter &amp; toolhead (30 EUR)= <strong>130 EUR</strong><br><strong>Printing:</strong> BiQu H2 V2S (50 EUR) + Flsun SR bed/glass/PEI (50 EUR) = <strong>100 EUR</strong>.<br><strong>TOTAL for the third design with HGR15:</strong> 70 EUR (frame) + 200 EUR (motion) + 130 EUR (electronics) + 100 EUR (printing) = <strong>500 EUR</strong>.</blockquote><p>A little bit pricey (500 EUR) but this version is cheaper and better compared to FlSun V400: it has Klipper with a 7&quot; touch screen (similar with the Speeder Pad), a good direct drive extruder controlled with a CANbus toolhead and 1m+ printing height — the only “downgrade” is the smaller printing diameter (26 cm vs 30 cm).</p><p>It’s time to draw some conclusions:<br>- with 300 EUR you can get a FLSun SR (279 EUR) and upgrade it for direct drive and Klipper. You will get a very good printer but limited in printing height (330 mm).<br>- with the same 300 EUR budget you can build a good delta printer (Klipper / direct drive / heated bed) but with a printing height of 1 m. This is the low budget variant perfectly adequate for personal use or low volume “profduction”<br>- for a “professional” solution you need to consider linear rails (MGN12 or even HGR15) but you have to chase some good prices based on volume and seasonal discounts (for me the additional cost was 74 EUR for a set of 3 x MGN12 1000 mm and 107.5 EUR for a set of 3 x HGR15 1500 mm). Please note that with MGN12 1 m rails you will be limited to 75–80 cm heights printing. You should consider these upgrades in case you share the costs (a club printer) or if the printer is for “production” (i.e. you make money by selling the printed parts).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f5af2379a2d4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Project ALTius part VIII: “MY Printers for gliders” or “ A DIY delta printer budget design for…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tiberiu.atudorei/project-altius-part-viii-my-printers-for-gliders-or-a-diy-delta-printer-budget-design-for-69e40c5d007a?source=rss-937c3b5cdbc9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/69e40c5d007a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[3d-printing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[delta-3d-printer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tiberiu Atudorei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 21 Apr 2024 10:10:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-04-21T10:10:04.568Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Project ALTius part VIII: “MY Printers for gliders” or “ A DIY delta printer budget design for printing 1m wing segments”</h3><p><em>There are 3 major categories of RC models: kits, ARF (Almost Ready to Fly) and PnF (Plug and Fly). (Yes, I know about RTFs — I just choose to ignore them for this comparison). Similar for printers we can have kits, ARP (Almost Ready to Print) and PnPs.</em></p><p>FlSun SR and V400 are ARPs — they came pre-assembled from factory but you still need to deal with 28 screws and 8–10 cables to plug in and do some easy calibration before printing.</p><p>BambuLab X1/P1/A1 and Creality K1/K2 are a little bit more PnPs oriented: less screws and cables to plug in and you can print in 10–15 minutes. <br>Probably the experience will be similar in the next generation of FlSun printers S1 and T1: these are enclosed and probably will come pre-assembled. In fact if I have to summarize the specs I would say that T1 and S1 are enclosed versions of SR and V400 and with double the speed. And the price will be higher: more than double compared to current prices of SR/V400.</p><p>If you compare the current prices (SR 330 USD, V400 650 USD) with the launch prices for the new generation ( T1 600 USD, S1 1500 USD) there is a huge difference. Of course some difference is justified and expected (the enclosure, the CPAP fan for the new generation, the closed loop motors for S1 and so on) — but you have to ask if the S1 is worth 4 times the SR. But let’s not compare the un-released S1 to the SR — let’s look into V400 vs SR. Is the V400 worth twice the money you pay for a SR?</p><p>If you look at the difference in the “official” price of parts (Speeder Pad 150 USD, PEI pad 35 USD without soft magnetic pad, V400 effector 120 USD vs SR effector 40 USD) there is a small difference of 55 USD — but let’s not forget that there are some other materials un-accounted for due to the difference in printing sizes (longer pillars, longer carbon arms, larger printing plate and so on). In short: both SR and V400 in their current offer have exceptional good value.</p><p>And this is more obvious if you compare with what you can still get for 330 USD: the <strong>He3D K280 DIY delta printer KIT</strong>. And it’s a very legit question, what (you / we) get for the same amount of money — <strong>SR vs K280</strong>:<br>- an ARP (SR) vs a DIY kit (K280)<br>- solid (but proprietary) profile columns vs common 2020 profiles<br>- 32 bits MCU and capacitive touch-screen vs (probably) 8bit MCU with ancient display<br>- MGN12 linear rails vs 2020 Openbuilds-style carriages <br>- D260xH330 vs D280xH600</p><p>Not much thinking needed here: the SR is a better product and the only advantage of K280 is the larger printing volume (a little bit more diameter and almost double the height). In fact nobody will buy the K280 for printing plastic — now it is used mainly as a clay printer (TC-280) with some additional accessories (a clay extruder). And I see there are even larger models (TC-500 D500xH430 mm and TC-900 D500xH900 mm).</p><p>Let’s look closer to the build size of TC-280 (430x430x1120 mm) and TC-900 (610x610x1600 mm). Why? It’s obvious: because we are trying to build an FDM printer with the base of TC-280 and the height of TC-900. It’s not rocket science: if you replace the 1120 mm 2020 profiles in K280 with 1520 mm (let’s round it to 1500 mm) you will get a printer for a 1000 mm wing segment. 3 pieces of 1500mm 2020 profile, around 9 m of GT2 belt, some wires, maybe a small/light/cheap direct extruder: around 70 USD for a grand total of 400 USD and we have the parts for the new printer. Now we have the REAL question: IS IT WORTH 400 USD? Not compared to the SR (because I will choose the SR anytime over the K280 kit) but as per se, as a kit we can use for creating the desired “3D printer for 1m wing segment”<br>I have to admit that I’m using this K280 kit (which I don’t endorse or recommend, BTW) to start an analysis of options in designing our printer.</p><p>Let’s start with the basics: a delta printer is moving the printing platform (the “effector”) inside the printing volume using 3 equal arms (in fact DOUBLE arms, but let’s simplify the problem) linked to the columns of a regular triangular prism (the base and the upper floor are regular triangles and the columns are perpendicular on these planes). This is all in theory… in practice not so much. Maybe you can get a good precision and tolerances using industrial processes (that’s why the FlSun SR is such a good value) but with a DYI kit most probably the triangles will be scalene (aka “not regular”) and the columns will not be at equal angles (90–210–330) and not perpendicular on the printing base and the upper plane (with the reference homing switches) will not be parallel to the printing base. We are doomed from the start? Not at all, Klipper has some very fine tuning calibration mechanism in place: <br> <br><em>The SAVE_CONFIG command will update the printer config file with these parameters and restart the printer.<br>stepper_a: position_endstop: 1072.262861 angle: 209.061265 arm_length: 315.000000<br>stepper_b: position_endstop: 1072.012950 angle: 328.868689 arm_length: 315.000000<br>stepper_c: position_endstop: 1071.029898 angle: 90.000000 arm_length: 315.000000<br>delta_radius: 174.142552</em></p><p>But I digress again, let’s come back to the basics and how we estimate the cost of a DIY kit for a delta printer. We can divide the BOM (Bill of Materials) in 4 sections:</p><p>a. “<strong>mechanical</strong>” : the skeleton / frame and other parts non-electrical<br>b. “<strong>electronics</strong>” — the “brains” of the 3d printer<br>c. “<strong>the motion system</strong>” — resposible with moving the effector in space<br>d. “<strong>the printing system</strong>” — responsible with deposing the filament</p><p>In each section we will detail and review the costs for options:<br>1. “<strong>budget / as cheap as it gets</strong>”<br>2. “<strong>middle of the road / balanced between costs and performance</strong>”<br>3. “<strong>performance / money is no concern, we just aim for the best</strong>”</p><p>In this way we will get a low cost, a high cost and a “reasonable priced” configuration. As a general rule I will try to put the best price I can get for that part but this may be either from a local supplier or purchased from abroad (mainly EU countries and China). However please note that due to multiple vendors the shipping costs will escalate quickly and it is much faster (and cheaper and easier) to get a single package in 1 week compared to 10 (or more) packages over several weeks. And I have to admit that I have some parts “on stock” with pre-pandemic prices — so maybe my solution is not the cheapest for you right now but it is the cheapest for me. Let’s proceed.</p><p><strong>a. Frame<br></strong>I will not get into too much details about how I ended up with these numbers but we will need something like 400 mm for the base and 1500 mm for the columns. Just look into the K280-TC500-TC900 dimensions and trust me (in fact I will give a detailed explanation and analysis in the next part).<br><strong>“Cheap”:</strong> we can use some cheap 16 mm steel conduit. In Romania in hardware stores this is 3 EUR/1m or 5 EUR/2m or 7 EUR/3m. Or 16 mm from aluminum (a little bit more expensive at 9 EUR for 2.6 m) or even with a square section of 20x20mm (around 4 EUR/1m). And we need 3 x 1.5m + 6 x 0.4 m = 7 m . Or maybe we can use a hexagon shape and we need 6 x 1.5 m + 12 x 0.25 m = 12 m. They may be cheap but usually the profiles / tubes are bent and we still need a staight piece for the motion. And for assembly we need to tap for holes and screws and a lot of additional work and nuisance. And we need some 3D printed corners so let’s put down some numbers: 20 EUR (for PLA or PETG)+ 25 EUR (for the steel or aluminium)+ 15 EUR (for screws and taps and whatever). <strong>60 EUR</strong> at least.<br><strong>“Medium”:</strong> a kit of (3 x 1500 mm + 6 x 400 mm) is around 40 EUR (for 2020) + 20 EUR (shipping). Again 20 EUR PLA/PETG and 20 EUR for M3/M4/M5 for nuts and bolts (for the 2020 profile). <strong>100 EUR</strong> but the assembly will be easier.<br><strong>“Expensive”:</strong> instead of 2020 we can use 2040 or 3030 profiles. As the cost of the profiles will be almost double we are talking probaly about 75–80 EUR for profiles, 25 EUR for PLA/PETG (a little bit more material to print) and 30 EUR for bolts &amp; nuts. But the transition from 2020 to 3030 or 2040 is not a magical solution, the rigidity of the printer depends also on the printed parts. And for this we can “upgrade” with an CNCed kit for corners (60 EUR for 2020 but 120 EUR for 2040 and 150 EUR for 3030 — ouch!!!). Anyway: <strong>150 to 250 EUR</strong> just for the frame. Ouch!<br><strong>My option:</strong> 3d printed parts (10 EUR) + 2020 profile (59 EUR) + 9 m of 16 mm steel conduit reinforcement (21 EUR) + 10 EUR nuts &amp; bolts = <strong>100 EUR</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/336/1*kTTZxOLJsqQmQturS3C3VA.png" /><figcaption>A simple 2020 profile frame with 16 mm reinforcements</figcaption></figure><p><strong>b. Electronics</strong><br>There are many options here but lucky for us we don’t have to deal with many components: a power source, an SBC (aka RaspberryPi or similar, something able to run Klipper), an MCU (aka “the old school 3D printer controller “ — but this needs to be supported by Klipper), an LCD (but this is rather optional) and a set of endstops and a probe (these are mandatory in all cases). And lucky for us the set of 3 endstops (mechanical switches or optical) plus the probe (mounted on top of the nozzle) are quite cheap, probably 5 EUR — but we will include them with 10 EUR in all configurations because of the shipping costs. Let’s detail:<br><strong>“Cheap” :</strong> no LCD / no heated bed (we can print only PLA) = 20 EUR (a new RapsberryPi Zero 2w / an old RaspberryPi 2 / an OrangePi Zero / an AndroidTVBox installed with Linux) + 20 EUR (a cheap 24 V 200 W power adapter) + 30 EUR (an BTT SKR mini E3 / BTT SKR Pico / Fysetc AOII with 2209 / similar — something with 4 channels with TMC2209) = <strong>70 EUR</strong>.<br><strong>“Medium”:</strong> 30 EUR(RPi3A) + 10 EUR (cheap RPi LCD w/ touch)+ 30 EUR ( cheap &amp; noisy 24V 400W power supply) + 30 EUR (MCU) = <strong>100 EUR.</strong><br><strong>“Expensive”:</strong> several options here: a. an 120–150 EUR 7&quot; tablet like BTT Pad7 or FLSun SPeedPad + 30 EUR MCU + 40 EUR power or b. 50 EUR RPi4 / OPi4–5 + 50 EUR 7&quot; touch HDMI + 40–50 EUR quality/slient power + 30–40 canbus or c. MKS Skipr with 3.5 inch LCD + canbus + power or variants. In any case <strong>150 to 250 EUR</strong>.<br><strong>My option:</strong> 30 EUR (SBC RasPi 3A) + 10 EUR (LCD touch) + 30 EUR (MCU BTT SKR mini E3) + 30 EUR (24V 400 W) = <strong>100 EUR</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/290/1*C9729g5QwJY2R2iAv16G2w.png" /><figcaption>Raspberry Pi 3A with a LCD touch screen on top</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/339/1*FFwdRxW-hz1hEaure4qeOA.png" /><figcaption>BTT SKR Mini E3 V1.2 mounted on the backplate of RPi3A</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/559/1*AnVQ5ftR1ooJ1i6w89MtoA.png" /><figcaption>Mainsail web interface of Klipper</figcaption></figure><p><strong>c. Motion system </strong><br>This means 3 x stepper motors + GT2 pulleys, belts and belt tensioners + some linear motion + 3 x (double) arms + platform. And probably this is the most important part.<br><strong>“Cheap”: </strong>we use cheap NEMA17 motors (probably around 20 EUR for all 3), 10 m of cheap GT2 belt (10 EUR), 3 pcs of GT2 pulleys + 3 pcs of GT2 idlers+ 3D printed belt tensioners (another 10 EUR), 3D printed carriages with delrin rollers (10 EUR), arms made from carbon fiber rods with magnets (20 EUR) linked with threaded balls (10EUR) = <strong>80 EUR</strong><br><strong>“Medium”:</strong> 30 EUR (better quality NEMA17 motors) + 20 EUR (GT2 belts &amp; pulleys) + 20 EUR (CNC-ed carriages) + 20 EUR (CNC-ed belt tensioners) + 30 EUR arms (FLSun SR spare parts) + 10 EUR balls (FLSun SR parts) = <strong>130 EUR</strong><br><strong>“Expensive”:</strong> 40 EUR NEMA17 + 20 EUR GT2 belts&amp;pulleys + 20 EUR belt tensioners + 100 EUR MGN12 + 120 EUR Haydn-Huntley magball arms = <strong>300 EUR.</strong><br><strong>My option:</strong> 20 EUR (3xNEMA17) + 10 EUR (GT2 belts &amp; pulleys) + 10 EUR (delrin wheels mounted on 3D printed carriages) + 20 EUR(CNC-ed belt tensioners) + 30 EUR (mag-ball arms with extra-strong magnets) + 10 EUR (10mm threaded balls) = <strong>100 EUR</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/317/1*nGDkq3MdMGqAS44DjaV4jg.png" /><figcaption>Carriage with (delrin + ball bearing) wheels for 2020 V-slot profile</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/244/1*PN7p4uxiHEN9KMfEDGBooQ.png" /><figcaption>NEMA17 motor with GT2 pulley</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/244/1*x06rG2sJ7qqq7AKR7hTBpg.png" /><figcaption>Mag-ball arms and GT2 belts and carriage</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/244/1*gNALmIdCy5jOPqUe9kMdbQ.png" /><figcaption>GT2 belt tensioners</figcaption></figure><p><strong>d. The printing system</strong><br>= extruder / feeder + hotend + fans + printing bed.<br><strong>“Cheap”: </strong>(Titan extruder + motor) 15 EUR + (the cheapest clone of hotend with PFTE bowden + heater + thermistor) 10 EUR + 10 EUR (2–3 fans) + 5 EUR (a clone of BuildTak surface) = <strong>40 EUR</strong>.<br><strong>“Medium”:</strong> (a light direct drive like mini Sherpa with NEMA14 motor) 30 EUR + (Bambu LAb hotend clone/ VORON clone) 20 EUR + 10 EUR (2–3 fans) + (FLsun QQS-pro heatbed spare part) 40 EUR = <strong>100 EUR</strong>.<br><strong>“Expensive”:</strong> (Biqu H2 V2S) 55 EUR + (FLsun SR heatbed + glass + PEI) 75 EUR + 10 EUR (2–3 fans) = 140 EUR. OK, let’s go crazy: instead of H2 V2S we will use H2 V2S REVO + additional 0.25–0.6 Revo nozzles + blower fan (155 EUR). 140–55+155= <strong>240 EUR</strong>.<br><strong>My option: </strong>(a light direct drive like mini Sherpa with NEMA14 motor) 30 EUR + (BambuLab hotend clone/ Mosquito clone / Dragon hotend clone) 20 EUR + 10 EUR (2–3 fans) + (FLsun QQS-pro heatbed spare part) 40 EUR = <strong>100 EUR</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/217/1*G1zCk6yYvnSsery4HQLhTw.png" /><figcaption>Bird view of the effector (with Biqu H2 V2S integrated extruder + hotend)</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/337/1*cFKEtedR219K7TxTrSDjAQ.png" /><figcaption>A simple heated bed</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Time to draw some conclusions</strong></p><p><strong>“Cheap”:</strong> 60 EUR frame + 70 EUR electronics + 80 EUR motion + 40 EUR printing = <strong>250 EUR</strong>. Yes, we can build a delta 3D printer within a reasonable budget.<br><strong>“Medium” :</strong> 100 EUR frame + 100 EUR electronics + 150 EUR motion + 100 EUR printing = <strong>450 EUR</strong>. A little bit over the budget and we are in the middle between SR and V400.<br><strong>“Expensive”:</strong> (150 to 250) EUR frame + (150 to 250) EUR electronics + 300 EUR motion + 240 EUR. We are in the <strong>800 to 1000 EUR</strong> zone — that’s more than twice our budget.</p><p>The “Goldilocks zone” seems to be somewhere between “cheap” and “medium” with some “expensive” elements. “My option” configuration is very simple to understand: I’ve allocated to each of the 4 sections ( frame / electronics / motion / printing) a “budget” of 100 EUR and made sensible choices for components. And in fact this is the configuration I’ve provided parts last month for a kid in order to jump-start him in the 3d printing hobby (this is a configuration I named <strong>KD2540</strong> aka <strong>K</strong>lipper <strong>D</strong>elta D <strong>25</strong>0 mm x H <strong>40</strong>0 mm — all the photos are made by the kid when he documented the building process):<br>- frame: 2020 3x1m + 6x0.4m + 6x1m 16mm steel<br>- RasPi 3A + LCD touch + BTT SKR mini E3 + 24V 400 W<br>- CNCed carriages and belt tensioners<br>- 400 mm carbon rods with very strong magnets D10xH20mm and 10 mm balls<br>- Biqu V2 H2S integrated (extruder + hotend) + 2x4010 blower fans + FLSun QQS-Pro heated bed covered with a BuildTak-type surface.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/336/1*0s8KWr2YuRD_ndoAT96M5g.png" /><figcaption>The DIY design can be assembled by a kid …</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/653/1*aa_r2YsGK1tdrqaLQetiuQ.png" /><figcaption>…and “the proof is in the printing” (not exactly wing segments but these are not my test prints)</figcaption></figure><p>As you can see it’s basically the “medium” configuration and the small savings we got from using 1m instead of 1.5 m 2020 profiles and 16 mm steel were used for an upgrade of the extruder. And don’t worry about the fact that 400 mm printing height in KD2540 + 500 mm difference in profiles will give us only 900 mm: the printer was designed for 300 mm carbon rods for arms but I had only 400 mm available.</p><p>For a DIY kit we ended with a cost of 400-450 EUR / 450-500 USD. This is 50% more compared to K280 but there are certain “upgrades”: larger printing volume (1m height) + 16 mm tube reinforcements + direct drive with Biqu H2 V2S + Klipper. For reinforcements we can use some 3D printed brackets in the corners with (almost) the same effect. For 30 EUR (20 EUR 3 x 1.5 m 2020 + 10 EUR shipment) + 10 EUR (10 m GT2 belt) we can upgrade to “1m prints”, for 20–25 EUR we can upgrade to direct drive, 25–30 EUR for a 32-bit MCU with 2029 and 20–50 EUR for RPi or similar with a touch screen.</p><p><strong>The bottom line is: a good DIY kit (“good”=Klipper + direct drive) will cost us at least 400 EUR.</strong> That’s why it makes sense to “start” from a 300 EUR / 330 USD FLSun SR and upgrade it (direct drive + Klipper). At this point you may ask “<strong>why bother with a 400–450 EUR design if the SR is only 300 EUR?</strong>”. A valid question but the answer is simple: in order to upgrade to (direct drive extruder + Klipper) you still need some additional components and the cost will go up to 350–400 EUR — and the DIY design will still have the advantage of “3x printing height”.</p><p>And another valid question: <strong>“if the 1st gen DYI design is good and it costs 400 EUR — why bother with the 2nd and 3rd design (probably with higher costs)?”</strong> <strong>The answer will be in the next part …</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=69e40c5d007a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Project ALTius part VII: “Printers for gliders” or “ A delta printer for a (non-)delta wing”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tiberiu.atudorei/project-altius-part-vii-printers-for-gliders-or-a-delta-printer-for-a-non-delta-wing-32ed593ea07b?source=rss-937c3b5cdbc9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/32ed593ea07b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[f5j-gliders]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[project-altius]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[3d-printing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rc-model]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[delta-3d-printer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tiberiu Atudorei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Mar 2024 14:32:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-15T14:32:04.022Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>After the early “demise” of the New RC Soaring Digest I was no longer feeling the “pressure” of a monthly issue and I got lazy. The previous part was published after 3 months, this one after 6 months — for the future I hope to do it on a monthly basis.</h4><p>Probably you are expecting that in this part I will finally start with HAM (my rather stupid acronym for Hardware Assisted Manufacturing — in fact DIY contraptions for building gliders: laser cutters, 3D printers and so on). And I’m afraid I have to disappoint you again: this part is about how to <strong>avoid </strong>HAM. In other words: how we can use what is available on the market (with a focus on 3D printers of course). More specific: why I recommend delta 3d printers for gliders. And even more specific: it’s an honest and objective (I hope) sales pitch for FLSun SR (Super Racer). And just to make things more interesting: I’ll spice it with a little bit of AI.</p><p>There are 3 major types of FDM 3D printers: bed slingers (aka Prusa i3 and derivatives and clones), CoreXY (BambuLab X1/P1 and Creality K1 and so on) … and delta printers. You can also find some cross-breeding like CoreXZ (a bed-slinger but with a CoreXY type of kinematics applied to X and Z axes) but there are few models on the market. And in fact there are not many models for delta printers either (even if they have a history of more than 12 years). And IMHO delta printers have certain advantages over other types.</p><p>I’m a little bit lazy today and I’ll ask my assistant Google Gemini to do the heavy lifting — let’s start with some warm up, a simple prompt in order to evaluate what we can expect from the AI assistant in terms of accuracy and verbosity. The whole series is based on the assumption that 3D printing models makes sense — let’s see if Gemini agrees:</p><blockquote><strong>Prompt: “Advantages of 3d printing aero RC models vs traditional building methods”</strong></blockquote><blockquote>3D printing offers several advantages over traditional building methods for aero RC models:<br><strong><em>Design freedom and complexity:</em></strong><br><strong><em>Complex shapes:</em></strong> Create intricate, lightweight designs that are impossible or difficult with traditional methods like balsa and plywood cutting. This allows for increased aerodynamic efficiency, better strength-to-weight ratios, and unique, customized appearances.<br><strong><em>Internal features:</em></strong> Print integrated spars, ribs, and other structural elements within the model, reducing assembly time and improving overall strength.<br><strong><em>Rapid prototyping:</em></strong> Easily iterate and test different designs by quickly printing new versions, accelerating the design process.<br><strong><em>Material properties and weight:</em></strong><br><strong><em>Lightweight filaments:</em></strong> Use materials like nylon, PLA, or PETG, which can be lighter than traditional balsa wood, leading to improved performance and flight times.<br><strong><em>Tailored material properties:</em></strong> Experiment with filaments offering specific properties like flexibility, strength, or heat resistance for different parts of the model.<br><strong><em>Consistent density:</em></strong> 3D printing ensures consistent material density throughout the model, leading to more predictable flight characteristics.<br><strong><em>Manufacturing and assembly:</em></strong><br><strong><em>Reduced build time:</em></strong> Automate repetitive tasks like cutting and shaping, saving time and effort compared to handcrafting with traditional methods.<br><strong><em>Reduced waste: </em></strong>Minimize material waste compared to cutting sheets of balsa or plywood, making it a more environmentally friendly option.<br><strong><em>Precise parts:</em></strong> Achieve high levels of accuracy and repeatability, ensuring consistency across multiple models.<br><strong><em>Modular designs: </em></strong>Print parts that easily snap together or integrate with other printed components, simplifying assembly and repair.<br><strong><em>Additional benefits:</em></strong><br><strong><em>Accessibility:</em></strong> Design and print your own unique models, independent of commercially available kits.<br><strong><em>Customization:</em></strong> Personalize your model with custom logos, markings, or other features.<br><strong><em>Learning opportunity:</em></strong> Gain experience with 3D modeling and printing technology, a valuable skill in many fields.<br>However, it’s important to remember that 3D printing also has some drawbacks compared to traditional methods:<br><strong><em>Higher initial cost:</em></strong> Requires investing in a 3D printer and filament, which can be more expensive than basic balsa and plywood materials.<br><strong><em>Printing limitations: </em></strong>May be limited by the size and resolution of your printer, and some complex designs might require post-processing like sanding and finishing.<br><strong><em>Material strength:</em></strong> Some filaments might not be as strong as traditional materials, especially for high-performance models.<br>Ultimately, the best approach depends on your budget, experience level, desired level of customization, and performance goals. For those seeking unique, complex, and lightweight models, 3D printing offers exciting possibilities, while traditional methods remain a cost-effective option for simpler designs.</blockquote><p><strong>In short:</strong> our chatty Gemini thinks it’s a good idea to print RC models (but you have to take it with a grain of salt: “use materials like nylon, PLA or PETG which can be lighter than traditional balsa wood”, in fact these are 10 times heavier). But other things are just spot on. Next prompt:</p><blockquote><strong>Prompt: “Best type of 3d printer for printing RC F5J gliders”</strong></blockquote><blockquote>There isn’t a single “best” type of 3D printer for printing RC F5J gliders, as the best option for you will depend on your budget, experience level, and the specific features you need. However, here are some factors to consider when choosing a printer:<br><strong><em>Filament compatibility</em></strong>: For F5J gliders, you’ll want to use a filament that is strong, lightweight, and has good weather resistance. Popular options include PETG, nylon, and carbon fiber-reinforced nylon.<br><strong><em>Build volume:</em></strong> The build volume of your printer needs to be large enough to accommodate the wingspan of your F5J glider. Most F5J gliders have a wingspan of around 3 meters (10 feet), so you’ll need a printer with a build volume of at least that size.<br><strong><em>Print resolution:</em></strong> A higher print resolution will result in a smoother and more aerodynamic finish on your glider. However, higher resolution prints will also take longer to complete.<br><strong><em>Printing speed:</em></strong> If you plan on printing multiple gliders, you’ll want a printer that can print quickly. However, it’s important to find a balance between speed and quality.<br><strong><em>Experience level:</em></strong> If you’re new to 3D printing, you may want to start with a more user-friendly printer. More advanced printers may offer more features, but they can also be more difficult to set up and use.<br>Here are some popular types of 3D printers that are well-suited for printing RC F5J gliders:<br><strong><em>Fused filament fabrication (FFF) printers:</em></strong> These are the most common type of 3D printer, and they are a good option for beginners and experienced users alike. FFF printers work by extruding molten filament through a nozzle, layer by layer, to build up the object. <br><strong><em>Selective laser sintering (SLS) printers:</em></strong> SLS printers use a laser to sinter together tiny particles of powder to create the object. SLS printers can produce very strong and lightweight parts, but they are also more expensive than FFF printers.<br><strong><em>Stereolithography (SLA) printers:</em></strong> SLA printers use a laser to cure liquid resin into the desired shape, layer by layer. SLA printers can produce very high-resolution prints, but they are also the most expensive type of 3D printer. <br>It is important to do your research and compare different printers before making a decision. You can also read online reviews and forums to get feedback from other users.<br>Here are some additional resources that you may find helpful:<br><strong><em>Project ALTius:</em></strong> Working within weight and strength limitations for 3D printed F5J gliders<br><strong><em>“rc f5j” 3D Models to Print</em></strong></blockquote><p>WHAT? Gemini listed my previous piece as a primary source of information for printing F5J gliders (and this looks like some flattering or maybe self-validation — probably I’m the single crazy person in the world to think that a 3D printed F5J glider is a good idea).</p><p>And somehow Gemini avoided the question by listing TECHNOLOGY types (FDM / SLS / SLA) and if I give it a more specific prompt “Best type of FDM 3d printer for printing rc f5j gliders” I get more blah-blah and a sales pitch for Prusa MK3s+, Creality Ender 3 V2 and Bambu Lab X1 Carbon (no thanks, I’ll pass). OK, let’s help Gemini focus on the result:</p><blockquote><strong>Prompt: “explain the advantages of a delta 3d printer compared to a corexy 3d printer”</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Advantages of Delta 3D Printers compared to CoreXY:</em></strong><br><strong><em>Speed and Print Quality:</em></strong><br><strong><em>Faster printing:</em></strong> Delta printers typically offer faster printing speeds due to their simpler mechanics and lack of large, moving gantries. This results in less inertia and quicker acceleration.<br><strong><em>Reduced ringing and ghosting:</em></strong> Due to their design, Delta printers have a fixed print head and eliminate wobbly gantries which contribute to these artifacts. This translates to potentially cleaner prints with reduced ringing and ghosting issues.<br><strong><em>Other Advantages:</em></strong><br><strong><em>Smaller footprint: </em></strong>Delta printers often have a smaller footprint compared to CoreXY printers, especially for larger build volumes. This is because they don’t require large frames for X and Y movement.<br><strong><em>Easy bed access:</em></strong> The open design of Delta printers allows for easier access to the print bed, making it easier to remove prints and handle maintenance tasks.<br><strong><em>Unique aesthetics: </em></strong>The triangular design of Delta printers is visually appealing and different from the standard Cartesian or CoreXY printers.<br><strong><em>However, it’s important to consider the downsides:</em></strong><br><strong><em>Calibration complexity:</em></strong> Delta printers are generally more challenging to calibrate due to their complex kinematics and interdependent movements.<br><strong><em>Material limitations:</em></strong> Dual extrusion and filament changes are less common on Delta printers due to the complex movement system. They usually use Bowden extruders which can pose challenges with some materials.<br><strong><em>Limited build volume: </em></strong>While offering a smaller footprint, Delta printers may have limited build volume compared to similar sized CoreXY machines due to the triangular frame constraints.<br><strong><em>Choosing the Right Printer:</em></strong><br>Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs and priorities. If you prioritize speed, print quality, small footprint, and easy bed access, a Delta printer might be a good option. However, if you need multi-extrusion functionality, larger build volume, or prefer easier calibration, a CoreXY printer might be a better fit.<br>I recommend you research specific models and consider your printing needs before making a decision. There are many excellent communities and resources online dedicated to 3D printing that can help you compare models and find the right fit for your projects.</blockquote><p>Gemini warned us about the disadvantages (but these are not relevant: calibration complexity is not an issue with Klipper, I don’t need dual extrusion and I don’t care about limited build volume — probably what he sees as an disadvantage for cylindrical shape). We’ve played enough, let’s give Gemini a rest.</p><p>Here is MY opinion about delta printers (just some add-on clarification / explanation):</p><p><strong><em>- Delta printers are budget-friendly and easier to build.</em></strong> CoreXY printers are cube-shaped with some additional support structures. To build a modern CoreXY printer like Voron 2.4 you need 18 pieces of 2020 profile, 7 or 8 linear rails (MGN9/MGN12) and 7 stepper motors (6 x NEMA17/1 x NEMA14). For a delta printer you need just 9 pieces of 2020 profile (3 long and 6 short), MAYBE 3 x MGN9/MGN12 (but you can just use 2020 with carriages) and 4 stepper motors (3 x NEMA17 / 1 X NEMA14). The motion controller and the SBC for Klipper are the same but with fewer stepper drivers.<br><strong><em>- Delta printers are faster.</em></strong> It’s very simple: in bed slingers one stepper motor has to move a very heavy mass (on X axis the printing head and on Y axis the printing bed). In CoreXY printers the printing head is moved by 2 motors (with the exception of the 45 degrees motion where only one motor is active — like in rectangular infill). Guess what: in delta printers ALL 3 MOTORS are working for the printing head movement ALL THE TIME. <br><strong><em>- Delta printers have better print quality. </em></strong>In bed-slingers and corexy printers the printing artifacts are due to Z axis lead screws wobling and GT2 belts and idlers imperfection and resonances. Due to the symmetric arangements of the A-B-C axes in delta printers (no Z axis woble) and the specific of assembly (the printing head is linked via rigid carbon arms to the A-B-C axis) this issue are mitigated in a very effective way. Just think about it: if you want to stabilize a very high pole or antenna you use 3 wires and anchors. In delta printers it’s a very similar case but you use double carbon rigid arms instead of elastic wires.</p><p><strong><em>OK, we settle for a delta printer: what model to buy?</em></strong> Mainly there are 3 companies: FLSun (budget / consumer), Trilabs and Wasp (pro-sumer/industrial). Forget Trilabs, they were bought by Prusa and are outside of our price range (they don’t list prices on their web site but you can find on distributors prices in the 3000–5000 EUR range). Forget also Wasp — their entry-level Wasp 2040 Pro is 3000 EUR. FLSUN prices are more palatable — under 1000 EUR (in fact even cheaper, maybe inside our budget).</p><p>FLSUN flagship product (for the moment) is the V400: D300 X H400 X S400 — a fancy way to say 300 mm diameter x 400 mm height with a 400 mm/s speed with Klipper (in fact 600 mm/s in the last firmare upgrade). You can get one now for 600 EUR (at least I can get one for 600 EUR delivered to my door in about one week). Last year this printer was 800–900 EUR (and it’s still listed on <a href="http://www.flsun3d.com/">www.flsun3d.com</a> store for 900 EUR but sold out).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/990/0*j1RkQ6EgKkmHU6T0" /><figcaption>The FLSun flagship (for the moment): the V400.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ov1nXVUAxkmoarQZ" /><figcaption>The V400 effector: dual gear direct drive with a Volcano-type hotend.</figcaption></figure><p>The next printer in line is Super Racer or SR: 260 mm diameter, 330 mm height, 150–200 mm/s but non-Klipper (probably Marlin). 400 EUR on <a href="http://www.flsun3d.com/">www.flsun3d.com</a> but I can get one to my door delivered next week for 305 EUR or 330 USD (brand new) from Banggood CZ warehouse. I actually bought 2 FLSun SRs last year: one brand new for 375 EUR and several months later one “used” for 305 EUR (but probably it was just used for a test print). These SRs are my favorite printers — but I have to admit I just “upgraded” both.</p><p>What you get for around 300 EUR: a very robust frame; MGN12 linear rails; 10mm width GT2 belts; a very responsive capacitive touch screen; carbon fiber arms; a Volcano-type hotend; a dual-drive extruder with bowden; auto bed leveling and calibration; a textured glass heated bed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*oQtOuW6pU4rLlGQh" /><figcaption>The FLSun Super Racer: the little brother of the V400.</figcaption></figure><p>You can use a FLSun SR “as is” and you can even buy a cheap 0.3 mm Volcano-type nozzle (under 5 EUR / USD) for lighter wings. And maybe a larger nozzle (0.5/ 0.6/0.8 mm) if you want to print larger structural pieces (like parts for another 3D printer — but we’ll deal with this on the next part of the series). And after a while you will find that even if FLSun SR is a very capable printer you can still improve it (and in some cases quite cheap). For what (and how) can be improved we can take a look at the differences between V400 and SR:</p><ul><li>nothing we can do about the printing bed SIZE but we can improve the TYPE. V400 has a PEI-covered textured steel sheet. For around 20 EUR you can get a double sided PEI/PET sheet and with a clever trick (glue the magnetic sheet on the back of the SR glass printing bed) you can have 3 types of surfaces to choose from (to better suit the filament).</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/990/0*hLA6V0nCXg0LEdjH" /><figcaption>the PEI steel sheet is a good upgrade for the printing bed.</figcaption></figure><ul><li>V400 has a direct drive extruder. This is a very easy upgrade: buy a cheap ABS 3d printed or even full metal CNC-ed aluminum extruder (and I really mean cheap: you can pay 20–30 EUR including motor or buy the motor sand some gears for under 10 EUR) and 3D print an adapter for this extruder to mount it instead of the bowden tube in the SR effector (<a href="https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:5165006">https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:5165006</a>):</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*bMi7fWOmdK1mvw1-wA730Q.png" /><figcaption>An adapter for a Mini Sherpa extruder mounted on top of the cage protecting the coldend</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L2uMvlFoqXSqUlbvQNnjYw.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>if you want to improve the part cooling you can replace the original dual 4010 blower fans with dual 5015 and some adapters () but for printing with 0.3 mm nozzle this is not necessary)</li><li>if you worry about the additional mass of the direct drive extruder (100–150 grams — depending of the material AB&lt;S/metal and the stepper motor weight) there is a very simple and elegant solution: replace the FLSun steel cage (<a href="https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:4911018">https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:4911018</a>) and aluminum alloy plate (<a href="https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:5155922">https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:5155922</a>) of the effector (110 grams in total) with similar 3D printed parts (30 grams). You can even find some combined cage &amp; extruder designs (<a href="https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:5223840">https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:5223840</a>)</li><li>you can also replace the outdated hotend with a more modern type (Mosquito original or clone, Dragon, Bambulab X1 clone and so on) — you can save additional weight also</li><li>and finally you can convert this 3D printer to Klipper: you can use an existing old laptop with Linux OR an old Raspberry Pi2 OR a new RaspberryPi 3A OR an OrangePi Zero OR an Android TVBox converted to Linux (all these options are in the 20–30 EUR range) OR a more expensive Klipper tablet/pad (for instance BigTreeTeck Pad 7 around 120 USD up to FLSun SpeederPad used in V400 for around 165 USD).</li></ul><p>Both my FLSun SRs are upgraded with direct drive with Klipper and are driven by a single Speeder Pad (I could use RPi2 or RPi3 or Orange Pi or other cheap solutions but I preferred the original SpeederPad for the “V400 experience” (for the price of a single V400 from last year I have 2 upgraded SRs and the SpeederPad used in V400).</p><p>At this point you will notice that the upgraded SR is costing you around 350–500 USD/EUR and you are still very limited in printing volume (just 330 mm height). And this rises a legitimate question: can we build something better (with a higher printing size, let’s say 800–1000 mm printing height for a full wing segment) for the same cost? The answer is (as you probably guessed) positive. In the last 6 months I’ve worked on 3 different designs (all delta printers):</p><ul><li><strong>a very cheap delta 3D printer </strong>(intended to be used in the local RC club for kids)</li><li><strong>ALT0 aka KD2580 (Klipper Delta 25cm x 80 cm)</strong> — with 1m MGN12 linear rails and 120cm 3030 profiles</li><li><strong>ALT1meter aka KD25100 (25cm x 100 cm)</strong> — with 1.5 m HGR15 linear rails and 1.5 m 2020 profiles</li></ul><p>To be honest some of these designs are still WIP (Work In Progress) in some areas, I’m still doing some improvements (in order to reduce costs and complexity of the design) but the initial results are very promising. And of course I will tell you about these designs in the next part.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=32ed593ea07b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Project ALTius Part VI: “Slicers for gliders” or “The Good, the Bad and the Ugly”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tiberiu.atudorei/part-vi-slicers-for-gliders-or-the-good-the-bad-and-the-ugly-c9fe86409b87?source=rss-937c3b5cdbc9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c9fe86409b87</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cad]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[3d-printing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[f5j]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cam]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tiberiu Atudorei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 01 Sep 2023 09:46:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-09-15T07:09:32.474Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LE34Fw2n4-Opb5-3bXb4Og.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>In the previous part we did a lot of test prints (1/16th of the wing from root and tip) with PLA and ABS using 0.4, 0.3 and 0.2 mm nozzles on BambuLab P1p. We even draw some initial (but rather brief) conclusions about weight, printing time and quality (and how they are inter-related). It’s time now to try to understand why we have such large variations and to turn it into specific recommendations for optimizing FDM and SLA 3D-printing for RC sailplanes.</em></p><h4>What we noticed as flaws in FDM printing are no reason for concern in resin printing</h4><p>This is a very important statement and a little complex explanation is in order. Let’s start with the obvious faults in the printing tests.</p><p><strong>“Sagging” and “islands” (in fact it is “sagging between islands”)</strong></p><p>Take a closer look at the pictures from previous part, the first picture above the title and the next picture with the internal infill. In order to minimise retraction (which has a very nasty side effect of drastically reducing printing speed) the slicer decided it is better to continue extruding infill at full speed movement — this had the side effect of creating a doubled wall on some areas (the “islands”). Please note that the islands are not visible at all in 2 walls prints. How can we explain the sagging (present only in 1 wall prints)? Very simple: what happens to a long and very thin string of hot melted plastic (220–270 degrees Celsius) cooled to room temperature (20–25 degrees Celsius)? That’s right — thermal contraction. And what happens if you don’t have enough support around this thin plastic string (no support towards the infill, only a small support on the bellow layer)? That’s right, you get a little displacement that over many layers becomes a visible sagging. One important remark is that “sagging” is less visible with a 0.3 mm nozzle and additional part cooling in enclosed P1p (probably the additional forced cooling leads to a better accuracy due to a minimal thermal contraction later). Should we get something similar for resin printing? <strong>No reason for concern, in resin printing there is no thermal contraction</strong> (there is indeed a volumetric contraction for resin but this is quite small and has no such dramatic effects).(BTW, this “doubling” of the walls by infill is avoidable — in Cura slicer we can set it off).</p><p><strong>“Layer shifts towards the tip”</strong></p><p>These are related to large masses in movement at high speeds generating vibrations. A typical printing head is 250–500 grams (and mass is a measurement for inertia). And my P1P printer (with a rather light printing head probably around 200–250g) is very fast: 500 mm/sec (remember the “500 mm/s class printer” ?). How to reduce these annoying layer shifts due to vibrations? By using “brims” (limited effect) and “links” (very effective). Imagine that your printed piece is a tall tower. A brim is like extending the foundation of the tower so it has a larger base, it helps with the adhesion on printing plate. But the real trick is printing several pieces in the same time and using “links” between them. You can find brim settings in slicer but for links you have to add them in OpenSCAD. A link is just a small “bridge” of around 1 mm between the printed pieces. The best way to explain the “links” is the image of Petronas towers in Malaysia: twin tall towers with a passage between (the “link”). Several pieces and several links (at different heights) and there will be no vibrations. I know it works: take a closer look at the P1P picture from the previous issue. The rounded corners of the printer are actually 3D printed in PLA on this very printer. The tall round corner is in fact composed of 2 pieces that were printed together “linked”. Do you see any annoying layer shifts in the middle of the round corner at half height where is the separation line between parts? The quality is perfect, the “linking” trick is very effective. Do we have something similar (layer shifting due to vibrations) in resin printing? Let’s see: instead of 250–500 g printer head we have a 25–50 g laser module (5x-10x mass reduction: way less vibrations). We can also reduce mass to some mirrors and lens, let’s say 2.5–5 g — even less vibrations. And we have a heavy printer full of glycerin (25–30 kg or even 50–60 kg of glycerin): a very stable printer with a heavy base. And these printed parts are not surrounded by air but immersed in heavy glycerin (1.26 g/cm3) acting like a very good damper. <strong>No reason for concern, in resin printing there will be no vibrations.</strong></p><h4><strong>There is one area we should definitely address: structure</strong></h4><p>Let’s start with a little question: you book a flight for your vacation with the family, later you get an e-mail from the airline telling you they decided to switch to a new type of wings with half of the weight and this will result in savings due to lower fuel consumption and they will partially refund your money. The question is: are you happy for the extra money or are you concerned for the safety of your family? In our case: is the reduction in weight something we should worry about? How low can we get in order to have a significant weight reduction AND a sound structure? Take a good look at the infill gyroids structure from the pictures (I interrupted the printing in order to have a nice section to study).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nPgW6IGevPuCUFL0GjtFAg.jpeg" /><figcaption>0.4 mm nozzle and gyroid infill of 1% (top), 2% (middle) and 4% (bottom)</figcaption></figure><p>The “0.4mm/1wall/1%” was bad because the infill structure was too sparse (a 4 cm period structure was not very good to fill in a thin wing). For “0.4mm/1wall/2%” the structure was denser but not good enough for the job at hand. The “0.4mm/1wall/4%” was very good: rock solid. So was the “0.2mm/2walls/2%” (or at least similar). But the first was 85 g and the second was 69–70 g (estimated weight due to partial print). And this difference in weight comes only from internal infill (which is not very much to start with). Probably for 0.4mm it was “too much” and for 0.2 mm it was borderline between “adequate”/”not enough” and with 0.3 mm “just right” — is the 0.1mm we intend to use with resin “too weak”? How can we adjust this?</p><p>“Infill” means in fact 2 things: “material” (aka mass or volume of the infill multiplied by density) and “geometry” (the distance between infill lines). <br>For a nozzle with diameter D a gyroid infill of N percent the lines are repeated at a distance of D*100/N:<br><em> (0.4 mm nozzle &amp; 4% infill) = 0.4 mm * 25 = 1 cm.<br> (0.3 mm nozzle &amp; 3% infill) = 0.3 mm * 33.3= 1 cm.<br> (0.2 mm nozzle &amp; 2% infill) = 0.2 mm * 50 = 1 cm. </em><br>For resin printing:<br><em> (0.1 mm nozzle &amp; 1% infill) = 0.1 mm * 100 = 1 cm.</em></p><p>That’s why I’ve considered the 1 cm repeating gyroid infill structure as “dense enough” and we have the empirical rule to match the nozzle diameter and the infill percentage (“0.4mm &amp; 4%” / “0.3mm &amp; 3%” / “0.2mm &amp; 2%” / “0.1m &amp; 1%”). But the walls for 0.2 mm nozzle have half of the material for 0.4 mm nozzle: are they strong enough? Probably yes. The geometry for 0.1 mm and 1% is the same “1 cm period” but the walls will be much thinner. What can we do? We can increase the infill to 1.5% or 2% or 2.5% or even 3% — we know that the penalty in weight is acceptable. The structure will be denser but the walls of infill are still 0.1 mm. Can we fix it? Here is the trick: in Cura there is an additional slicer parameter “Infill Line Multiplier”. This one is self explanatory but here is the description: “Convert each infill line to this many lines. This makes the material stiffer but increases print time and material usage”. Problem solved, this is what we needed, we can set up the parameter to 2, 3 or even 4 (that means more “material”) and still keep the same “geometry”. <strong>No reason for concern, in resin printing with this “infill line multiplier” trick we can adjust both the “material” and the “geometry” to suit our needs.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VwegV_YZe6OorvQ5czXaWw.png" /><figcaption>Gyroid infill in Cura with default <strong>“Infill line multiplier” = 1</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pExzWLK8lIuCCvWcGb_RrQ.png" /><figcaption>Gyroid infill in Cura with non-standard<strong> “Infill line multiplier” = 3</strong></figcaption></figure><h4><strong>An important remark about weight estimation</strong></h4><p>For solid-core builds there is little room for adjusting the wing weight. You have the weight of the Rohacell (probably only 30 or 50 kg/m3, I don’t think that builders are stocking 2 types of Rohacell — solid core weight is rather fixed), one or 2 types of Carboline and the resin is quite standard. So the only way to control the weight is by Carboline type and amount of resin. On our build we have a greater flexibility: (resin amount for the surface finish) + (2 types of Textreme 80 gr/m2 or 55 gr/m2) + (variable resin core weight). And for this resin core weight we can adjust: 1. Number of walls; 2. Percent of infill; 3. Infill line multiplier. I guess we can fine tune the resin core weight to suit our structural needs. And this approach is valid also for plastic printing but in addition we have another trick: you can force a line width of let’s say 0.225 mm or 0.25 mm through a 0.2 mm nozzle by pushing a little bit more plastic (and this way we can improve the 0.2 mm structure but at the expense of weight increase).</p><h4><strong>Let’s come back to time estimation</strong></h4><p>My P1P “500 mm/s class printer” is not actually printing at 500 mm/s and speed in fact has to be evaluated together with acceleration (for P1P it’s advertised at 20000mm/s2). From a stand still you move the printing head with a big acceleration in order to get to the “cruising speed” but very soon you have to hit the brakes hard and have a big deceleration in order to change the direction. If your Creality Ender 3 is like a normal (even over-cautious) driver at the wheel of an old (i.e. rather slow) Hyundai pressing gently on the acceleration and brake — this is no longer the case with modern CoreXY printers. These are like the world champion (your choice: F1 or WRC) at the wheel of a Bugatti Veyron / Chiron driving at Nurburgring all the time with “pedal to the metal” (either acceleration or brake). In fact not at Nurburgring (where he knows all the turns and he can drive with his eyes closed) — on an unknown rally track. For this he needs a copilot to read in advance the map for him and to instruct him how many tenth or hundreds of seconds he needs to press on brake and how many on the acceleration, and how hard, and when to turn and when to switch gears. This “copilot” in case of the modern printer is in fact an internal computer who is studying the car in detail before the race in order to squeeze every ounce of performance (you can say it’s a division if work between “planning” and “execution”). This additional computer is a good physicist too and he uses a model: belts on X and Y axis are like springs (or strings) and the printing head is like a mass suspended between these springs/strings and it tries to find the resonance frequencies for the X and for the Y axis in order to compensate vibrations — and for this purpose it uses a digital accelerometer and some induced vibrations. Some years ago we had an upgrade from 8 bit printer controllers to 32 bits but the real quantum leap in the recent years was the new firmware Klipper instead of the good old Marlin (blame it on COVID-19: that’s what you get when you lock some bored nerds in their houses, they take the 3D printing hobby too serious). But I digress again: we were talking about speeds. In fact these cars don’t have automatic transmission, they have a manual transmission, there are different printing speeds for outer walls, inner walls, infill, bridges and so on — these are defined in a “printer profile”. For instance the standard printing speeds for P1P 0.4 nozzle are outer wall 200 mm/s, inner wall 300 mm/s and infill 250–270 mm/s. This is far less than the advertised 500mm/s or our “quick estimation” of 500 mm/s and you should also consider that you will not reach these speeds very often. The slicer estimation for 0.4mm/1wall/2% was 22h, for 0.4mm/1wall/45 was 26h (so probably for 3% infill is around 24h). Probably in the default profile for 0.4 mm we had thermal bounding (the maximum speed was not determined by the mechanical parameters but by the hot-end thermal parameters). And in fact the Bambu P1p slicer was VERY conservative: for the generic PLA the maximum volumetric speed was 12 mm3/s and for Bambu PLA premium was 21 mm3/s. With the CHT nozzles I can increase the volumetric max speed to 35–40 mm3/s — that’s more than enough for our needs. And with a 0.3 mm CHT nozzle probably we can drive this P1p “pedal to the metal” — as fast as it gets(a 0.3 mm nozzle has the “nozzle surface” reduced to 56% compared to the 0.4 mm nozzle and this allows a 75–77% increase in speed for the same “volumetric speed”). What we should expect for resin printing? 2x increase for the number of layers (from 0.2 mm to 0.1 mm), 2x+ increase for the walls and infill (2 walls and the same geometry of infill but at least double the number of infill lines, maybe triple). Probably 5x increase in printing time but with a printer we expect to be faster (no 250 g printing head, just a 50 g laser module). A 5x reduction in print head mass doesn’t mean it will print 5x faster. Forget the Bugatti, we will need the land speed record holder here (ThrustSSC with a jet engine propulsion system).</p><h4><strong>And another thing</strong></h4><p>If you have a sharp eye you have noticed in the picture of the gyroid infill some flaws: there are some additional holes star-shaped. These are not actually defects in printing, the printer is just fine. But something is missing and the legitimate question is if it has any impact on the structural integrity. I know what is missing here because I studied gyroid for a long time, I’ve mentioned before that the gyroid infill is in fact some horizontal wavy lines that are morphing into vertical wavy lines. In the middle between horizontal waves and vertical waves is a layer with a transition between horizontal and vertical lines, in fact it’s a cross pattern. In a period there are exactly 4 such layers (at 1/8, 3/8, 5/8 and 7/8 of the height). What happens if you have a period of 100 layers? Well, tough luck: the EXACT positions are layers 12.5, 37.5, 62.5 and 87.5 — this means you will not be able to see these special layers because they are not present at all in a 100-layer model. The solution to this is to double the total number of layers from 100 to 200 — and by magic you will see these cross patterns on layers 25, 75, 125 and 175. That’s the reason I’ve changed in my slicer the matrix of gyroid values from 100x100x100 cells to 200x200x200 cells (precision was not a factor, I was computing the values with double precision anyway). And for our resin printer this means we will need to consider layers of 0.05 mm instead of 0.1 mm (and this is consistent with the golden rule of “layer height should be half of nozzle diameter”) and the number of layers just doubled. Bad news: forget ThrustSSC, we need to put wings to the damn car and get air-born and reach Mach2.</p><p>And that’s not all: if you want some “good looks” (“no dimples”) for the wing printed with plastic you need to consider 2 walls and this means a 0.2 mm nozzle. In single wall prints the infill has to be “welded” on this single wall and this means the plastic will be molten locally and this will create an imperfect surface. A double wall will “hide” the internal infill structure but of course at the expense of a significant increase in printing time. And there is another parameter you can use (“infill/wall overlap”) because the infill has to be welded to the internal (or single wall) and this means a melting point that sometimes is visible through the wall (not a break-through but just a little deformation due to the heat).</p><h4><strong>Let’s get back to the goals of this project</strong></h4><ol><li><strong>Weight </strong>— pretty good, we can get close to the designed AUW.</li><li><strong>Cheap </strong>— 20EUR (the price of 1kg of plastic — we will not factor in the cost of the printer for the moment) plus electronics (so probably around 150 EUR in total). “<strong>Disposable</strong>” ?</li><li><strong>Time of execution</strong> — one week-end (print on Saturday and build on Sunday). Correction: one week-end for <strong>me,</strong> with your Ender3 I’m afraid you will have to print the whole week. And don’t even think about ABS (no heated chamber) and better forget about PLA (unless you want to be a modern Icarus and have your wings destroyed by Helios), you need to print with PETG (and it will be 20% heavier compared to ABS and for PETG you nee to print at slower speeds compared to ABS &amp; PLA).</li></ol><p><strong>So here it is: a smaller 0.2 mm nozzle is not a magical solution</strong> (in fact it is the opposite — huge printing times and increased risk of clogging the nozzle). It is good if you are looking for minimal weight (and in this case you need just 1 wall and an extra layer of carbon composite) or a nice finish for an all-printed wing (and in this case you need 2 walls and expect some very long printing times). The old 0.4 mm nozzle is still usable (it wins in 2 events out of 4) and probably <strong>the 0.3 mm nozzle is better all around</strong>. (And in case you have a hot-end with a E3D Revo system you don’t even have to decide between 0.2 mm and 0.3 mm nozzles — Revo has only a 0.25 mm nozzle available).</p><h4><strong>An ugly truth</strong></h4><p>I’ve got better results compared to my previous DIY printer and far better printing times — but just few perfect prints. PLA or ABS, small or large brims, open printer or enclosed printer with heated chamber, 60 degrees or 100 degrees printing bed temperature: it makes no difference, the base layer may still warp after some time and it’s not straight (it’s bow-shaped but not excessive and it can be fixed with precision cutting and / or light sanding). I have to do some testing with different settings for temperature or maybe a different print surface and maybe rafts. And if you push your printer to it’s limits and print the wing with a high speed in order to minimize the printing time you are just asking for trouble because the adhesion between layer will not be optimal. The same is valid for layer height: 1/2 nozzle diameter is optimal, 2/3 is still good and 3/4 is not a good choice for default flow settings (but it is valid if you increase the flow and push a little bit more plastic).</p><h4><strong>Time for the final conclusion(s)</strong></h4><p><strong>“Plastic bad / resin good”</strong>? <strong>Things are a little bit more nuanced.</strong> Definitely plastic has a place in this project for printing plugs and molds and even wings — but for wings and tails you have to careful select your nozzle and material and infill percentage. And if you change your 0.4 mm nozzle to something else (valid choices: probably 0.3 mm is way better than 0.2 mm, with 0.2 mm you are just wasting your time) then expect some weight benefits for 0.3 mm and a significant increase in printing time for 0.2 mm. Definitely there is no silver bullet or magic solution but the sweet spot seems to be 0.3 mm with 0.2 mm layer height. So probably you can print a “performance” wing in plastic (i.e. with a good geometry and accurate profile but not very light) for an AUW between 1500 and 1700 g. For a “competition” wing (AUW 1250–1500 g) and better looks you need to consider resin printing.</p><p>I’ve told you that this project was full of surprises — it still is. I knew from several years ago that the 0.3 mm nozzle was the solution but at that time I was limited by materials (just PLA), slicers (gyroid infill was not available) and hardware (CoreXY printers were not widely available and Marlin was the only firmware and available on 8 bits only). Now I have PETG &amp; ABS, 32 bit controllers with Klipper and (last but not least) very fast printers. The recent surprise for me was the good results with 0.3 mm nozzle in all 4 criteria: acceptable weight, good structure, fast printing time AND looking good. <strong>The technology has advanced up to a point where we can print the glider in 24 hrs.</strong> This will be an interesting challenge. The trick is not to print it in a 1000 EUR printer but in a low budget printer like Ender 3 (or my equivalent Tarantula Pro). Probably it can be done but not within 24 hrs. And there is something that it will be <strong>nice to have: to print a full wing segment (90–95 cm) in one piece.</strong> Probably you’ve guessed it: “there is an itsy-bitsy-tiny problem”: no such printer for our budget. And once you have 3d printed your prototype with plastic and validate the design (the “fully 3D printed with plastic” phase) it is natural to promote to the next phase (“covered with composites”) but in order to keep the weight within the acceptable limits you need to consider resin printing (“resin 3D printed core covered with composite”). Two different printers are a little bit too much (and way out of our budget), it would be nice to have a single printer for both plastic and resin. Quite a challenge, isn’t it?</p><h4><strong>And as usual your homework</strong></h4><p>Download one or two slicers and start playing. I recommend OrcaSlicer and Cura (we will use Cura for resin printing and OrcaSlicer is a fork of Bambu Studio I used for printing in my P1P).</p><h4><strong>What’s next</strong></h4><p>For me: more plastic printing of course. These 0.3mm nozzle results means more work for me, now I have to actually print the whole wing and tails and fuselage and test it in flight (a friend saw the test prints and asked me to print one for him — he has 3.8m Explorers and it will be a good test). And also test the printing on a bed-slinger printer similar to Ender 3 (on my Tarantula Pro). And now I have to build an FDM/resin 3D printer for 90–95–100 cm segments (spoiler alert: this project is almost completed).</p><p>For you: if you already have a 3D printer you can do your own test or even print your glider. If you don’t: roll up your sleeves, it’s time to build the resin printer and / or the plastic printer — or maybe a single printer for both plastic and resin?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c9fe86409b87" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Project ALTius]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/project-altius-5d31b121bf28?source=rss-937c3b5cdbc9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5d31b121bf28</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[3d-printing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rapid-prototyping]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aviation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aeronautical-engineering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[june-2023]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tiberiu Atudorei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 31 May 2023 21:14:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-04T16:43:27.961Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YEdH94P5GRBMZWJJCqfxaA.png" /><figcaption>The latest exotic wristwatch from Piaget or Patek Philippe? No it’s actually an early, failed attempt at 3D-printing the mold for a wingtip. The ‘face’ of the watch is the exposed gyroid infill.</figcaption></figure><h4>Part V: Practical experiments in FDM 3D-printing.</h4><p><em>For those who have not already done so, you will likely want to read or at least familiarise yourself with the </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/project-altius/home?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>first four parts of this series</em></strong></a><em>. — Ed.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*INGseNGAKXB7GZ3K8wAhzw.png" /></figure><p>Last time I concluded with “next month, it’s back to the nuts-and-bolts”: I hope you didn’t take that literally. Instead of “nuts-and-bolts” you will have to settle for some “nozzle-and-plastic”. That’s right: time to do some old-fashioned FDM (fused deposition modelling) 3D-printing! Don’t worry, we will have several parts in the future with hardware laser cutters and 3D-printers to help prepare you for the building season which will be upon us by then.</p><h4>Five Reasons for FDM</h4><p>The first reason is quite simple: in our journey between the start point of ‘what’ — that is, the 3D models prepared with SAD/CAD — and the destination point of ‘where’ — the magical 3D resin printer — we definitely need to do a ‘how’ pit stop. In other words we need to get you familiar with a very important tool: the slicer — used for 3D-printing — and its relative the ‘g-code generator’ used with a laser cutter. The purpose of these software tools is very simple: to translate the 3D model or the drawing to the G-code language accepted by 3D-printers and laser cutters. Both are in fact some variants of CNCs with specialised tools.</p><p>The second reason is that we need to re-evaluate somehow the FDM printing with the 3D-printers, software and materials available today.</p><p>The third reason is more practical: previously we have considered two types of building:</p><ul><li>Balsa geodetic ribs covered in composite — ‘low-tech ALTius’</li><li>3D-printed core covered in composite — ‘hi-tech ALTius’</li></ul><p>In fact there are three additional variations:</p><ul><li>Fully 3D-printed with plastic</li><li>Resin 3D-printed core covered with composite</li><li>Fully 3D-printed with resin</li></ul><p>That’s right, for rapid prototyping we need to consider also a quick and cheap build without composites at all. Of the five variations we can consider FDM 3D-printing in at least three.</p><p>And the fourth and perhaps most important reason: we need to validate the use of theoretical recipes derived from quick W1 and W2 weight estimations with practical results. In other words, weight and printing time estimations from the slicer software as compared to the actual, measured weight and time for printing. We also need to evaluate the structural integrity of the printed wing and to extrapolate the findings from FDM printing to resin printing.</p><p>And maybe a fifth reason: you may already have an FDM printer and you want to put it to good use before starting to build and/or saving up to buy a resin 3D-printer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ai1bG5Y7xfZzOBnz5qYf5A.png" /></figure><p>In the previous parts of this series we had a “plastic bad / resin good” vibe. Scratch that, we will start with a clean sleight and draw conclusions at the end of the day. One additional remark: I will do the tests on my best printer (Bambu Lab <em>P1P</em>) because it’s a modern, fast printer and I’ve upgraded it and I can print all sort of materials with 0.2mm, 0.3mm, 0.4mm, 0.6mm and 0.8mm nozzles. We will consider three different materials (ABS, PLA and PETG) and see in which part of the project we can use and what kind of printer we need. Finally we will analyse if you need a state-of-the-art printer like the <em>P1P</em> or you can just do your job on a more common, budget-minded printer like Creality <em>Ender 3</em>.</p><p>About those plastic ‘sausages’ of which I spoke in previous instalments: there is a German saying along the lines of “if you like sausages it’s better not to know how they are made”.† However, we definitely need to know how to make good ‘sausages’ so it’s time to do some printing.</p><p><em>†Don’t laugh, sausages are big business in Germany and these words may be attributed to Bismarck comparing laws and sausages.</em></p><h4>3D-Printing Plugs and Molds</h4><p>I’ll start with a 0.4mm nozzle and PLA on the standard <em>P1P</em> configuration — just the 0.4 mm nozzle and no enclosure. I will print a mold of the tip — not the full segment, of course, but just the last quarter. This first test is a failure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Gq3j2R5Og1E6j7Ah9O5YjQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GUIOd8it8zw26bdwWkpZSw.png" /><figcaption>Mold of the wing tip printed with two different speeds.</figcaption></figure><p>In fact, despite appearances, it’s actually quite good. It’s a failure because I used the rest of an several-years-old PLA roll and the filament was not enough to finish the part — the tip is not closed. Then again, you <em>can</em> see the cool-looking gyroid infill. The mold has some elements not suitable for 3D-printed molds: the wall is a very small structure designed to protect the leading and trailing edges when you polish the mold / plug. It’s almost of no use in 3D-printed molds and plugs. I left it there just to see how my new printer is coping with very small details and fast direction changes. All we can see in the surface are some vertical lines — 2mm apart — that are correlated with the GT2 belts. I probably need to adjust the belts tension — after all, this is a brand new printer. Definitely usable if between this printed mold and the carbon/resin we use a FEP release film to ‘smooth’ the surface. All we need to do is to use an offset in the design of the model to compensate for this FEP film and probably use ABS for printing in order to do some thermal curing of the resin . This way we can use also some prepregs. OK, we can use an FDM 3D-printer for molds and plugs — what about wings?</p><h4>Wing 3D-Printing Test Methodology</h4><p>We will test two ‘quarters’ of a wing: the first quarter at the root and the last quarter at the tip. These are the easiest and hardest quarters to print, respectively. Also, this is just a ‘plain’ wing — no other additional elements like cutouts for control surfaces, servo pockets, joiners or spars. Of course when you 3D-print an actual wing you intend to fly, you will need to consider those and prepare them either in xflrwing and/or <em>OpenSCAD </em>(see Resources, below).<em> </em>No big deal, you will do a difference() between the wing segment and a cylinder or cone or a square-section tube used for spar — remember to do it a little bit larger and not exactly the nominal size of the spar.</p><p>We will compare slicer estimated weight versus printed weight, and then we will estimate the printed weight for the full wing by doubling the slicer estimate for a print of all quarters in a half wing. Note: it is not the ‘virtual’ wing of 75dm² and 6000cm³ we used for weight estimation. It’s a ‘real’ wing with 3.84m span, 24cm chord, 76.12dm² projected area and 6487.80cm³ volume. We will observe and measure three variables: weight, printing time and quality. There is an old saying something like “pick two of them because you will never get all three at the same time” — let’s see if it’s true.</p><p>OK, let’s start the first round of wing parts printing. Remember, this is a standard 0.4mm nozzle on a standard printer without enclosure.</p><h4>PLA+ / 0.4mm Nozzle / One Wall / 1% Infill</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ldm6_2i2KsL5GdXgePqm0Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s a failure. Weight: root quarter 58g, tip quarter 22g, total 80g–81g as compared to 86g estimated by the slicer. Likely there is a small difference in plastic density or my filament if actually a mix of PLA and ABS. Full wing estimation: 615g and about 18h print time. Quality: good airfoil profile on printing bed, not so good — actually, really bad — in the rest. Good adhesion between layers. We notice some 5cm diameter ‘islands’ and a visible sagging of the airfoil between these. Also there is a small but visible ‘layer shift’ toward the tip.</p><h4>PLA+ / 0.4mm Nozzle / One Wall / 2% Gyroid Infill</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*p9UgX9C99TyBF7nrOF2MqQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s also a failure. Weight: root quarter 67g, tip quarter 24g, total 90g–91g as compared to 94g slicer estimation. Full wing estimation: 700g / 22h. Quality: the same but ‘islands’ are smaller and also the sagging is not so bad.</p><h4>PLA+ / 0.4mm Nozzle / One Wall / 4% Gyroid Infill</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ULy_WMM2RJB_5ZPBbiP2WQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s OK(ish) but importantly <strong>not</strong> a failure as there are no structural impediments. Weight: root quarter 85g, tip quarter 29g, total 114g as compared to an estimated 119g. Full wing estimation: 1000g / 26h. Quality: printed parts are tough, no sagging visible, still some layer inconsistencies on the tip.</p><p>After the first tests I received from Bambu Lab the package with the upgraded parts — new 0.2mm, 0.4mm, 0.6mm and 0.8mm nozzles along with camera and LED lamp as well as a fan for additional part cooling. We can do some additional tests. No point in testing 0.6mm and 0.8mm nozzles but we definitely want to test the 0.2mm nozzle. Another type of PLA, first round was on yellow PLA+, second round with grey PLA — that is, what was left in the roll after printing the enclosure for <em>P1P</em>.</p><h4>PLA+ / 0.2mm Nozzle / One Wall / 2% Gyroid Infill</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kcDLpntPHpnG6WhvyXG9Og.jpeg" /><figcaption>‘Mr. Golf Dimples’ (see below)</figcaption></figure><p>Mixed results. Root is OK(ish), tip not so good. Weight: root quarter 44g, tip quarter 16g, total 60g as compared to 63g estimated weight with the slicer software. Full wing estimation: 640g / 3d and 14h. Wow! Quality: OK(ish). Some islands are still visible but similar in size with 4% infill for 0.4mm nozzle and a very small amount of sagging. Definitely can be covered / hidden by the composite surface. If it’s not covered we should not care too much about it — best to think about how dimples in golf balls positively affect their flight, right? Now, how about the quality of the tip? The tip-of-the-tip is almost unusable: the layer shift is significant compared to the nozzle size and there is a visible adhesion problem between layers at the tip.</p><h4>PLA+ / 0.2mm Nozzle / Two Walls / 2% Gyroid Infill</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vnKd0FvrTLLnZiosYcDguA.jpeg" /><figcaption>‘Mr. Nice Guy’ (see below)</figcaption></figure><p>This is just the root — I used the last part of the PLA roll and I estimated that there was not enough filament for both root and tip quarters. However, I was wrong — not even the root was finished, it printed only 19.6cm out of 23.75cm so we will extrapolate the weight and … drum roll … it’s <strong>OK</strong>! Not just OK(ish) but rather it’s fully flyable and airworthy. Weight: this partial print was 58g — so 69g–70g for a full print of the root quarer. No big surprises here, the weight of <em>0.2mm / Two Walls / 2% Infill</em> is similar to <em>0.4 mm / One wall / 2% Infill</em>. Full wing estimation: 980g and a total print time of 5d and 7h.</p><h4>PLA+ / 0.1mm Nozzle / Two Walls / 2% Gyroid Infill</h4><p>Just kidding, I’m not able to print with a 0.1mm nozzle on the <em>P1P,</em> at least for the moment. I have some 0.1mm nozzles and I’ve ordered some aftermarket hotends for the <em>P1P</em> and maybe I’ll have the patience to do some printing with 0.1mm nozzles. But I finally finished the enclosure for the <em>P1P</em> using some PLA printed parts and acrylic panels from China. Let’s try this new enclosure with some black ABS.</p><h4>ABS / 0.2mm Nozzle / Two Walls / 2% Gyroid Infill</h4><p>Actually I started this print but I had to stop because my 0.2mm nozzle clogged due to the old and dusty ABS roll of filament. I ordered some 0.2mm needles used in unclogging the nozzle but what I received are 0.24mm and 0.25mm needles. I probably can unclog the nozzle but in this case it will be a 0.25mm nozzle and the flow of plastic will be increased by 50% (0.2 * 0.2 = 0.04, 0.24 * 0.24 = 0.0576, 0.25 * 0.25 = 0.0625) and the tests will not be relevant any more — we will not be comparing apples with apples. So, I’ll wait for the aftermarket hotend with 0.2mm nozzles. Back to 0.4 mm nozzle and black ABS.</p><h4>ABS / 0.4mm Nozzle / One Wall / 3% Gyroid Infill</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yRU1tMUPtCS7DWM6bmDy3w.jpeg" /><figcaption>‘Mr. Stinky’ (see below)</figcaption></figure><p>Weight: this print was 58g and a full wing estimation of 800g and 24h print time.</p><h4>FDM Face-Off</h4><p>It’s time to pause the FDM printing session and have a contest. So far we had two finalists: <em>Mr. Golf Ball Dimples</em> (PLA+ / 0.2 mm nozzle / 1 wall / 2% infill), <em>Mr. Nice Guy</em> (PLA+ / 0.2 mm / 2 walls / 2%), and right at the wire a new finalist: <em>Mr. Stinky</em> (ABS / 0.4mm / 1 wall / 3%) — ABS has a very bad odour when printing. Let’s order these contestants with regard to four criteria. Three were mentioned previously — weight, strength and printing time — but let’s now add how nice they look.</p><ul><li>Weight: no surprise here, <em>Dimples</em>. But <em>Nice</em> and <em>Stinky</em> are in a tie for second place.</li><li>Strength: <em>Stinky</em> as it was rock solid, two very thin lines of 0.2mm PLA force-cooled can’t beat a single 0.4mm line of 270C-fused ABS without part cooling.</li><li>Printing time: <em>Stinky</em> wins by a large margin.</li><li>Beauty: of course <em>Nice</em>, hands down. Both <em>Dimples</em> and <em>Stinky</em> have dimples — but <em>Stinky</em> subjectively looks better.</li></ul><p>Interesting combination: <em>Stinky</em> wing estimation was 800g and a printing time of 24h. Let’s estimate AUW (all up weight): another 100g for carbon spars, 80g–100g for tails, 250g–300g for fuselage. Another 300g–400g for ‘dead weight’. Estimated total AUW: 1500g–1700g. If I will print this with a 0.3 nozzle I can get the wing weight down to 600g and total AUW 1300g–1500g. Pretty good — the wing was designed for AUW 1380g. Another thing: I printed this segment four times with four different speeds which I will call <em>Silent</em>, <em>Standard</em>, <em>Sport</em> and <em>Ludicrous</em>. What I wanted to test was consistency of weight, extrusion and layer adhesion at high speed.</p><h4>ABS / 0.4mm nozzle / One Wall — Speed and Consistency Test</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QKfuig_lIbJkzJWzm4JOdw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zV8miQtdaeon7HWPKAdLmw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*u3l-obfu42noHJW9KL_Tqg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7_aWWh_nE77_QRQKYgIVPA.jpeg" /></figure><p>There is no big difference between these four prints: actually <em>Sport</em> and <em>Ludicrous</em> look <strong>better</strong>. With this high speed the wing printing time is reduced to 12h –14h. This means I can print the whole glider in one day using 1kg of ABS. The 0.3mm nozzle can print with a layer height of 0.2 mm and the printing time will be the same but with a reduced weight. The problem with this combination: it uses a standard 0.4mm nozzle but not every printer can handle this type of ABS printing. Not your average <em>Ender 3</em> anyway — ABS is notoriously bad at warping. And with extreme speeds there are definitely some adhesion problems, not visible at printing time but rather later — internal tension leads later to some cracks on the leading edge.</p><h4>Good Things Come in Small Packages</h4><p>Meanwhile I received a small package from China with a couple of aftermarket hotends and some nozzles: hardened steel 0.2mm, 0.4mm and 0.6mm along with CHT (core heating technology) 0.4mm and 0.6mm. CHT nozzles are for printing with increased speed. The filament is driven through three different paths inside the hotend in order to obtain a faster, more consistent melting of plastic and hardened steels for abrasive filaments like carbon fiber plastic. The CHT 0.6mm I’ll use for structural parts and CHT 0.4mm for wing parts where I want to obtain the maximum speed. However, the real trick is an old 0.3mm brass nozzle mounted on this aftermarket hotend using standard 6mm nozzle thread.</p><h4>Time for Round Three</h4><p>This round is for tuning in printing with this 0.3mm nozzle. We can achieve the same print time with 0.3mm nozzle / 0.2mm layer height and 0.4mm nozzle / 0.2mm layer height — but our goal now is weight reduction. Back to PLA+ yellow.</p><h4>PLA+ / 0.3mm Nozzle / One Wall / 3% Gyroid Infill</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yt8MSardYIQnNf2mgTgV9A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Weight: 59g root and 20g tip, total 79g as compared to slicer estimated 81g.</p><h4>PLA+ / 0.3mm Nozzle / One Wall / 2.5% Gyroid Infill</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*R2aevZqqxGdSIrJOfza0aQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Weight: 56g root and 20g tip, total 76g as compared to slicer estimated 81g.</p><h4>PLA+ / 0.3mm Nozzle / One Wall / 2% Gyroid Infill</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YMAmiEd9T6GCgpX8sdgN-A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Weight: 52g root and 19g tip , total 71g as compared to slicer estimated 76g.</p><p>Now let’s see how low we can go with the weight by printing with transparent ABS — the layer adhesion is better without any dye in the plastic using 0.2mm nozzle.</p><h4>Transparent ABS / 0.2mm Nozzle / One Wall / 2% Gyroid Infill</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1X_g2MgKTtz7FiGcQUUtQg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Weight: 55 g, as compared to slicer estimation for the whole wing of 600g and print time of 91h — ouch! Even if printed using the fastest speed I can get with this printer it will be two days or similar. But the print looks great and the structure is fine. Probably that’s the lowest value for weight at 600g and maybe I can push it to 550g. But — damn! — printing time is huge.</p><h4>Some Interim Conclusions</h4><p>Weight and structural strength are linked, which is normal after all: more material equals more strength. However, good looks and low printing times are not very good friends, I’m afraid.</p><ul><li><strong>Weight Estimations</strong> — Quite good, for FDM 3D-printing we can trust the estimations of the slicer software. And in some cases what we got from the printing plate is even lighter — around 95% of the weight estimated by the slicer.</li><li><strong>4m Wing 3D-Printed Under 1kg</strong> — This was my original goal many years ago. The answer is yes, definitely, it can be achieved. But if you want some weight savings you need to print with ABS (1.05g/cm³) instead of PLA/PETG (1.25g/cm³). ABS, on the other hand is a lot harder to print. You have to deal with contraction, warping, a heated print chamber and other considerations. Better forget ABS and print PETG instead with a 0.3mm nozzle.</li><li><strong>Print Time</strong> — On the very fast <em>P1P</em> printer times are acceptable for 0.4mm/0.3mm nozzles although significantly increased for 0.2mm nozzle. And it’s not simply doubled. At one end of the spectrum — for 0.4mm / one wall / 2% infill — it’s 22h and at the other end of the spectrum — 0.2mm / two walls / 2% infill<em> — </em>it’s a whopping 127h! The same amount of plastic but with 5.77 times increase in printing time! Note that a four times increase is actually what’s expected — double the layer numbers plus double the walls plus double the infill. However, it looks that there are some additional factors such as how the slicer software is handling the extrusion. Also, the printing times above are for <em>Standard</em> speed. With the <em>P1P</em> I mentioned there are four speed settings of which <em>Standard</em> is the second slowest. The faster <em>Sport</em> and <em>Ludicrous </em>settings will certainly speed things up, but at what cost in terms of quality? Finally, these print times were estimations for standard layer height half of the nozzle diameters but in theory you can print with a layer height up to three-quarters and in this case the total print time will be reduced by two-thirds.</li><li><strong>Quality</strong> As you will see from the pictures above, it is possible to achieve acceptable quality using FDM 3D-printing with the right settings and some simple precautions.</li></ul><p>Next time, I’ll be taking what has been learned with all of this testing and turn it into specific recommendations for optimising FDM 3D-printing for RC sailplanes. If you have any questions feel free to add them in the <em>Responses </em>section below. You get there by clicking the little 💬 below.</p><p>Thanks for reading. Until next time, best of luck!</p><p>©2023 <a href="https://medium.com/u/937c3b5cdbc9">Tiberiu Atudorei</a></p><h4><strong>Resources — 3D-Printers</strong></h4><ul><li><a href="https://anet3d.com/pages/a8-v2?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Anet A8 V2</em></strong></a> — “High cost performance ratio desktop FDM 3D-printer …”</li><li><a href="https://twotrees3d.com/product/corexy-3d-printer/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>TwoTrees Sapphire Pro</em></strong></a> — “CoreXY SP–3 high resolution professional cube 3D-printer …”</li><li><a href="https://twotrees3d.com/product/professional-3d-printer/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>TwoTrees Sapphire Plus</em></strong></a> — “CoreXY SP–5 fast … large scale 3D-printer …”</li><li><a href="https://tevoup.com/en-ca/products/tevoup-tarantula-pro-3d-printer-235x235x250mm?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Tevo Tarantual Pro</em></strong></a> — “3D-printer FDM (235mm x 235mm x 250mm) …”</li><li><a href="https://bambulab.com/en/p1?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Bambu Lab P1P</em></strong></a> — “Fast 3D printing right out of the box …”</li><li><a href="https://store.creality.com/ca/products/k1-speedy-3d-printer?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Creality K1</em></strong></a> — “Speedy 3D-printer …”</li><li><a href="https://kingroon.com/products/kingroon-klp1-corexy-3d-printer-with-klipper-firmware?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Kingroon KLP1</em></strong></a> — “a fast-print-speed CoreXY 3D-printer with Klipper firmware and a protective enclosure …”</li><li><a href="https://vorondesign.com/voron2.4?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>VORON2.4</em></strong></a> — “We build space shuttles with gardening tools so anyone can have a space shuttle of their own …”</li><li><a href="https://www.blvprojects.com/blv-mgn-cube-3d-printer?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>BLV mgn Cubes</em></strong></a> — “an open-source 3D-printer project …”</li><li><a href="https://www.anycubic.com/products/anycubic-photon-3d-printer?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Anycubic Photon</em></strong></a> — “colorful touch screen equipped with Photon system and bring new functions …”</li><li><a href="https://store.creality.com/eu/products/ld-002h-resin-3d-printer?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Creality LD–002H</em></strong></a> — “High precision resin 3D-printer with large printing volume …”</li><li><a href="https://www.anycubic.com/products/photon-mono-x-resin-printer?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Anycubic Photo Mono X</em></strong></a> — “A large build area for your 3D-printed creations: 192mm x 120mm x 245mm …”</li></ul><h4><strong>Resources — Other</strong></h4><ul><li><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G-code?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>G-code</em></strong></a> on Wikipedia. — “the most widely-used computer numerical control (CNC) programming language. It is used mainly in computer-aided manufacturing to control automated machine tools, as well as from a 3D-printing slicer app…”</li><li><a href="https://openscad.org/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>OpenSCAD</em></strong></a> — “software for creating solid 3D CAD models. It is free software…”</li><li><a href="https://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?3341269-project-ALTius&amp;utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>RCGroups</em></strong></a> thread for Project ALTius. — “altius, citius, fortius — sounds familiar? That’s the Olympic motto where ‘altius’ means ‘higher’. But the spelling (ALTius) is related also to my initials — Atudorei Lucian Tiberiu…”</li><li><a href="https://github.com/ALT3dRC/xflrwing?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>xflrwing</em></strong></a> — “STL generator for an XFLR project wing…”</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*INGseNGAKXB7GZ3K8wAhzw.png" /></figure><p><em>All images by the author. Read the </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/soaring-the-sky-podcast-514a66abd0e1?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>next article</em></strong></a><em> in this issue, return to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/twist-distributions-for-swept-wings-part-5-699e14a4b123?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>previous article</em></strong></a><em> in this issue or go to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest?utm_new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>table of contents</em></strong></a><em>. A PDF version of this article, or the entire issue, is available </em><a href="/service/mailto:NewRCSoaringDigest@gmail.com?subject=Project%20ALTius%202023-06%20PDF%20Request"><strong><em>upon request</em></strong></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5d31b121bf28" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/project-altius-5d31b121bf28">Project ALTius</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest">The New RC Soaring Digest</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Project ALTius]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/project-altius-1b3962dd34a3?source=rss-937c3b5cdbc9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1b3962dd34a3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[3d-printing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aeronautical-engineering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rapid-prototyping]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[may-2023]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aviation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tiberiu Atudorei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 30 Apr 2023 19:04:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-04T18:15:14.043Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h-6KT5i_lwZFmiw9X3sgbA.png" /></figure><h4>Part IV: An extended essay to help see the big picture.</h4><p><em>In the </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/project-altius/home?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>first three parts of this series</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><em>the author described performance glider projects as complex with many repetitive operations. The latter can be addressed with CAD software and then automated in standalone SAD (software assisted design) apps and homemade HAM (hardware assisted manufacturing) apps. He then presented some same workflows to illustrate their use. Most recently, he covered working within both weight and financial constraints. — Ed.</em></p><p><em>Project ALTius</em> is a long story of disappointments, failures, dead ends and above all resilience and hope. As any good drama this saga has its fair share of surprises and unexpected turns of events. Here are a few of them:</p><h4>Failure №1</h4><p>In the last part we concluded the easiest way to build this glider was to 3D print it. However the common FDM technology (AKA ‘squished molten plastic sausage’) is not adequate for this purpose and we need to consider printing with resin instead. I advocated this solution based on an analytical argument — taking into account weight estimations — but in reality the change of direction was due more to experimental results. When I got to the printing tests I found out that my DIY FDM 3D-printer was not adequate for the job: a wing printed with a 0.4mm nozzle was too heavy and printing with other nozzles took too much time and it was not structurally sound.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8dNx-0ektvJzCfh3bOvJ2A.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rJar4XKdU3iSm_p6o8A6rg.jpeg" /><figcaption>First print test for alignment and continuity between segments.</figcaption></figure><h4>Failure №2</h4><p>From my estimation a large part of the weight was due to the foil — that is, the surface of the wing — and I switched my focus on making the wing lighter by using <em>Oracover®</em> and some sort of holes and printing without infill. This was done by processing the 3D model in <em>OpenSCAD</em> and cutting some hexagon or square shapes. I also needed to make some important changes in xflrwing to separate the ‘solid’ parts, in the leading and the trailing edge and also the hinge area, from the rest.</p><p>Incidentally this was similar to Kraga’s <em>Kodo</em> but the design was different and my wingspan was not a mere 1.6m but a larger 3.8m–4.0m. The hexagon/honeycomb shapes were nice but not possible to print on my DIY 3D-printer without supports due to overhangs of 120 degrees.</p><p>I finally settled on a rhombic structure, with diagonals 20mm and 25mm that was easier to print. Good results in printing, bad results in covering with film: the PLA (polylactic acid) print filament and hot air are not very good friends. You can likely guess what happened to the trailing edge. ABS (acrylonitrile butadiene styrene) behaves a little bit better but I had no enclosure for my printer to contain the fumes and therefore I could not print with this material.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WxalPThL54D3uAQlxHn5Dw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4xLI-0xeS--2h2T-egA0Xw.png" /><figcaption>Modeling geodetic wing structure.</figcaption></figure><h4>Failure №3</h4><p>And the first U-turn in the project: I am quite stubborn and I decided it was nothing wrong with my idea, only the FDM printing technology was limiting me — so I had to print the wing with resin! The problem was that the resin printers are expensive — similar in cost to a competition glider! — so I decided to build my own resin 3D-printer.</p><p>I needed something able to print 250 mm chords: an iPad 10&quot; retina screen was available on eBay as a spare part, some red <em>Plexiglas</em>® or <em>Perspex</em>® plates, some electronic parts and I was finally able to build the printer. It turned out that the non-UV resin was quite expensive — around €60/kg — and the iPad screen background light was quite weak and I needed longer exposure times. This can lead to all sorts of other problems like ‘bleeding’. When I switched to UV resin I found that the iPad screen filtered a lot of 405nm UV light and my LED array, made from flexible strips with 405nm UV LEDs, was not bright enough.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b-QCI3oTVTa0I2mEuO1KFw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/436/1*fMaZ129CNtbRCak6e0IaJw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Left</strong>: From a Raspberry Pi and an iPad display… | <strong>Right</strong>: … to my first resin 3D printer.</figcaption></figure><p>Another problem was with the slicer: the slicers for resin printing were a joke. You either printed it as a solid form — that is, 100% infill — or you had an option to hollow the model in an external app like <em>MeshMixer</em> and put a hole in the model to let the resin entrapped inside drain. Or — and I think this happened quite recently — there is the option of an internal structure but that’s quite heavy. None of these options was good enough for my needs.</p><h4>The Core Problem</h4><p><em>Rohacell®</em> used for solid-core is very light: 30kg/m³ or the heavier version of 50kg/m³3. The resin is 1150kg/m³ and because of the density difference I had to use an infill of 2.5%–4.0%. In addition I also needed a surface foil printed with resin and in order to compensate for this additional weight — actually bigger than the lattice structure weight — I had to use only 1.0–2.0% infill.</p><p>With such a low infill percentage I definitely needed some extra strength and this was only possible with a composite structure such as carbon fibre and resin. I needed molds and plugs and I had to add this feature in xflrwing and also I had to figure out the easiest way to make these molds and plugs. I considered 3D-printing them or carving a plug in XPS and adding a mix of resin and mineral filler — but I needed a DIY CNC and probably I would have to write a program to generate the G-code for the CNC.</p><p>There was another problem with the infill: all the patterns had closed cells and I needed a ‘drain-proof infill pattern’. This light infill had to resist to all kind of loads during the flight. I used a specialised program — <em>Element Free</em> from nTop — and I designed a complex structure starting from a geodetic rib or a 3D disser and carving drain hole spawns. Modeling this kind of structure was quite CPU intensive and needed a lot of time. I changed the <em>OpenSCAD</em> programs I used before as a starting point to add these additional holes for draining resin.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PsilmjjNOM2U0zZ5JdrFXA.png" /><figcaption>From rendered 3D model …</figcaption></figure><p>At this point I realised it made sense not to over-engineer the geodetic structure and instead of 3D-printing it just cut some geodetic ribs made from balsa which is one-tenth the weight of resin. And I needed an app to draw the ribs. However the idea of this structure was still very appealing and I wanted to test it. The price of resin 3D-printers dropped and now I had a €500 Anycubic <em>Photon</em>. The problem was the screen was quite small — it enabled approximately 10cm (L) x 5cm (W) x 15cm (H) printing volume — and I had to print it at half scale. I did a couple of test prints and everything was fine — the structure was sound and light. But it was obvious that this was a dead end. Printing and assembling a puzzle of 100+ pieces was not something I was ready to take on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*COlKGSn6IX_qBj7rUXFa7A.jpeg" /><figcaption>…to 3D printed with resin in 1:2 scale.</figcaption></figure><h4>An Important Trip to Slovenia</h4><p>Around this time I had another change to the project — maybe the most important change — both in goal and in technology / method. I had the opportunity to meet one of the top composite builders in Slovenia for scale and competition models who was interested in the xflrwing app. When I was demoing the program — it was an early version — and explaining how I was doing everything he was very quiet. This made me uncomfortable, as what I was probably doing was very basic for him and it was a waste of his time. But he asked just one question:</p><p>“How do you model the hinges?”</p><p>This was very important because it was the trickiest part in modeling the wing. I explained about the 30% position for the hinge in the .dat files and how this is used for the long axis. I considered this as a fixed point for the washout rotation in order to keep the hinge on a straight line. He told me that I have a good solution — and it was his turn for explanation:</p><p>Creating the tooling for a glider is very expensive and time consuming. There is the aerodynamic part, of course, but then somebody has to take this and create the mechanical design — 3D model, molds and plugs. This is expensive and you likely will have to hire an engineer with expertise in using the CAD software such as <em>CATIA</em> or <em>SolidWorks</em>. Then you take this design and move to the CAM phase which involves machining the molds / plugs in CNC — and CNC time is even more expensive. Then you start polishing which is also very pricey and time consuming. The combined cost of the CAD project and the CAM part will run to thousands or even tens of thousands of euros.</p><p>The weakest link in this whole chain is the CAD project because it’s very hard if not impossible to verify the results unless you have the finished prototype in your hands. My program was a shortcut for this weak link.</p><p>I was quite shocked when he told me he wanted to be a customer for my program but he needed some additional features: IGES / STEP format instead of STL — the de facto standard for professional CAD and CAM programs — and some additional elements in molds and plugs. He showed me the molds for the wing of his next competition glider — it was hidden on a workbench under a soft cloth.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*m8z-m2haE2pFSCiuTgBAwg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Mirror finish on professional molds … perfection.</figcaption></figure><p>It was simultaneously a high and a low moment for me:</p><ul><li><strong>High </strong>— I knew that my software was quite good, at least for the amateur builder. For pro builders there was some work to be done, but I was on the right path.</li><li><strong>Low </strong>— In that moment I knew for sure that I will not be able to manufacture these kinds of molds and plugs in a reasonable amount of time and with a reasonable amount of effort: a four-segment wing and two-segment fuselage would need something like 16 different molds.</li></ul><p>So, a dead end for molds and plugs. I had to find another way to build my glider. That said, I never abandoned the mold/plug feature in the program and I later added the missing elements. But at least now I had a better understanding of why the competition models are <em>so damned expensive</em>: there is a huge effort and a big cost in getting them to the market.</p><h4>Thoughts on ‘The Market’ and Its Needs</h4><p>I also realised that the market for me was not a handful of composite builders interested in my simple app just to save some costs or the glider enthusiasts who can afford an expensive model. My real market was the tens or hundreds or maybe thousands of hobbyists who can’t afford an expensive model but are interested in building one. I had to create the simplest method to build the glider in the shortest time using the cheapest materials with a still acceptable final result. Not only this specific glider but any glider similar to this type with wing and tails defined in XFLR. In other words: my goal shifted from a single, commercial-quality competition glider — the market was already quite saturated anyway — to rapid prototyping builds.</p><p>After the meeting in Slovenia I worked in parallel on software and hardware. I started working on the fuselage app in order to automate design of a F5J type fuselage. I added a lot of features to the xflrwing app and finally when I considered it good enough I had my ‘IPO’ in RCGroups. I also had to rewrite the whole output section to organise the code better because the number of output files increased a lot and, candidly, the code was a mess. I also wrote the app for the geodetic balsa ribs. After the RCGroups post I was contacted by two builders who wanted to build the glider using my model — the classical path with CNCs.</p><h4>Tug of War</h4><p>The pandemic lockdown also had a big impact. No more business-related travel with a lot of time spent in airports, planes and hotels when I could work on the software. My focus now was finding the method and building the necessary hardware. It was clear to me that 3D-printing with resin was the solution but the method — MSLA (masked stereolithography apparatus) bottom-up, projecting the image through a transparent bottom of the vat — was wrong. It was good for printing small figurines or structural parts with 100% infill but not good for light structures.</p><p>It was like a tug of war: ‘team adhesion on the lifting plate’ versus ‘team adhesion on the vat flexible film’ pulling the ‘light resin structure’ rope. The game is rigged because ‘lifting plate’ has an advantage — increased exposure time for first layers. But it’s not a sure thing: sometimes ‘flexible film’ wins. There are also cases when nobody wins and the resin structure is simply torn apart. With the kind of structures I had in mind this was high risk. It was time for another change in direction.</p><p>‘Bottom-up’ was changed to ‘top-down’ — this solved the adhesion problem on the building plate as there was no more flexible film. MSLA was changed to ‘moving laser spot’ — which solved a lot of other problems. However, I still had two very big issues:</p><ol><li>The complex 3D model of the structure and…</li><li>There was no slicer available I could use.</li></ol><p>In fact it was quite a regular structure and I could bypass the software to generate this complex 3D model and the slicer and just write G0 / G1 / laser on / laser off commands. The extrusion control is the major part for slicers and it was of no use to me. I actually wrote the app to control the laser for printing this structure. But somehow the structure looked very sparse. I started investigating alternative lattice structures.</p><h4>Thank You Mother Nature</h4><p>I started with what Mother Nature already had on offer: carbon, in two variants with one being very strong — diamond — and one being weaker — graphite. The diamond lattice is regular with beams starting in four directions from a central point and repeating in a recursive manner. The graphite lattice is with beams starting in six directions and is weaker but it has parallelism between planes and much easier to code. This led me to a simpler structure with a lattice based on cubes. It was very easy to compute and even easier to ‘slice’ — that is, to write code for the 3D resin printer which is actually closer to a laser cutter. We’ll talk about the HAM part later in this series.</p><p>The infill factor formula was similar with the infill for balsa: (3n — 2) / n³ with an approximation 3 / n². When I was researching graphite and graphene I found an MIT research paper about “a new 3D material with five percent the density of steel and ten times the strength, making it one of the strongest lightweight materials known”. While I was not able to replicate some fancy nano-material what really got my attention was “you can replace the material itself with anything, the geometry is the dominant factor. It’s something that has the potential to transfer to many things”. And they had tested it on 3D-printed models! The gyroid surface was the magical solution to my problems and it was time to abandon other lines of research and use it as infill. Not really a new failure but another change of direction.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Q6x8yVDljxGjDesxsHMxbQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Top view of a cube with gyroid infill.</figcaption></figure><p>I had to create the algorithm to fill the wing with the gyroid surface. It can be approximated by a simple symmetric equation (sin x cos y + sin y cos z + sin z cos x = 0) and it was symmetric in three directions — good for strength — and also full of holes also in three directions — good for draining the resin. It was not something new — it was first published in a NASA paper from the 1970s — and one of the properties was a “triply periodic minimal surface”. Also good, “periodic” and “minimal” was just what I was looking for!</p><p>It had another remarkable property: it divided the space in two equal exclusive regions which gave me an idea about how I could use it to create the algorithm for an infill of 1–2%. It was quite simple: let’s consider the typical laser ‘nozzle’ of 0.1mm — which is actually even smaller, around 0.06–0.07 mm. For a 1% infill you need to have a structure with a period of 0.1 mm x 100 = 1cm The infill line is repeated after 1cm, but this looked dense enough to me. I had to figure out how to draw the laser inside a 1cm x 1 cm x 1 cm cube and then repeat it in every direction needed. I used a 3D matrix of 100 x 100 x 100 cells (later 200 x 200 x 200) and computed the values of the function f(x,y,z)= sin x cos y + sin y cos z + sin z cos x . It sounds complicated and time consuming but it’s not — you do it just once and it’s fast. If two cells close to each other — either horizontally, vertically or in diagonal — had values of opposite signs then between them there is a point where the function was zero — so the point was on the gyroid surface — and I could compute the coordinates of this point with a good approximation using interpolation.</p><p>I was doing the final adjustments and optimisations, for continuous lines and for compacting the number of travel moves and for limiting them inside the wing, when I had to stop and abandon work. Why? Because I was not the only one interested in using gyroid as an infill and somebody else crossed the finishing line before me, soon enough all major open source slicers had gyroid as the new infill. No need to reinvent the wheel. Another failure? Not at all, it was just a confirmation I was on the right path.</p><p>From now on I could use an open-source well-tested slicer. And not only me — every builder could use these free slicers with ease. Almost all of the software pieces were in place and I could focus on the hardware part.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wtYiUa-BVJF_ShNwD6L08Q.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5F4ChC-tBLYiw-jgBLv1mg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ahq4Ow5ah33LPX6KygrL7Q.png" /><figcaption>For my gyroid slicer from output text files…</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/851/1*RPPwbjGNimBA43fdchJyvw.jpeg" /><figcaption>…to QCAD drawing — horizontal waves are morphing into vertical waves.</figcaption></figure><p>The project was about a 3.6m–4m wingspan glider. For practical reasons — the T8 lead screws I had at the time for the Z-axis were 100 cm and I also had some 110cm 1204 ball nut screws with a 100cm active travel — I had to settle to a travel of maximum 96 cm on Z-axis. Scratch off the 4m variant for now. I wanted to print a 90cm or 96cm segment in a reasonable amount of time, let’s say during weekend days in daylight: 15–16 hour outside the window of eight hours sleep. Fifteen hours for 90 cm, 16 hours for 96 cm, that’s 6 cm per hour =&gt; 1 mm per minute =&gt; a layer of 0.1 mm in 6 seconds.</p><p>I needed a vat big enough for the wing and maybe for printed molds and plugs. A minimum 30cm x 5cm x 100cm but better to make it bigger in order to use some tricks to do some ‘mirror printing’ — printing a part and the symmetric mirror which is to say the left and the right segment in the same time. In the end I settled for 30 x 15 cm and the whole volume was 50L. Filling it with resin was out of the question — again, the cost was similar to a competition glider! — so we need resin to float on a liquid with higher density — resin is 1.15g/cm³. A saturated salt solution was out of the question — salts in solution are very corrosive. There was also the possibility of using sugar — I did some experiments and was not completely satisfied. Glycerine (1.26g/cm³) was a good choice but at €2/L means €100 in the budget for a 1m tall vat which would OK for the moment.</p><p>As with liquid, the resin has a significant surface tension. This means that after printing out a layer a ‘small dip / descent’ of only one layer height is not enough and we need a ‘big dip’ of several millimeters, similar to the pop-up in the bottom-up printers but this time with less drama and no ‘tug of war’ game followed by a ‘big rise / ascent’. From the six seconds per layer we need to provision at least one second for this ‘dip and raise’ movement. Better make it two seconds and do it in a smooth move and let the resin rest after this movement — only four seconds left to print a layer. This is like drawing with laser the two walls (that’s 4 x 25 cm = 100 cm) and the infill lines — at least two times some very curvy lines.</p><h4>Final Figures</h4><p>We need a printer able to ‘draw with laser’ two meters in four seconds — let’s call it a ‘500mm/s class printer’ — we need this printer to be robust to sustain 16 hour print sessions, to be easy to build and above all to be cheap because we have a very limited budget. Tough task! In the last part we had left only €200 in the budget for tooling including this 3D-printer. Is it even possible?</p><blockquote>“The best part is no part. The best process is no process. It weighs nothing. Costs nothing.” — Elon Musk</blockquote><p>We will use the same principle and simplify everything. No tooling means no complex molds or plugs. We will use the good old vacuum bagging method but with some improvements: household domestic use products like vacuum bags for clothes and using the vacuum cleaner for suction. Even better, use 28cm vacuum film rolls used for food and the associated vacuum sealing machine. Instead of the traditional mylar film we will use a cheap elastic release film made from FEP (fluorinated ethylene propylene), the same polymer used in the flexible transparent bottom of the resin vat in MSLA bottom-up printers. And in order to keep everything in place we will use some simplified 3D-printed molds: a simple contour of the surface with a width of, let’s say, 2mm. I call this simplified mold a ‘bark’ — as in tree, not the sound dogs make. In detail we will vacuum bag a sandwich of:</p><blockquote>breather — ‘bark’ — FEP release film — <em>TeXtreme® — </em>core 3D -printed with resin — <em>TeXtreme®</em> — FEP release film — ‘bark’ — breather</blockquote><p>I know it sounds crazy but when you think about it — I did think about it for several years! — and you eliminate all that is not really needed and leave ‘just the bare necessities’ … it feels like the right solution so it must be the right solution. The puzzle is almost complete after the bombshells “the easy way to build a performance glider is to print it with resin using a gyroid infill” and “no special tooling needed, just build a cheap 3D resin printer and borrow the food vacuum sealer from your kitchen”. All the pieces are in place except an essential one: the 3D-printer. But not for long.</p><h4>Let’s Pause for a Moment for All Recap</h4><p>In fact this whole part of this series is an extended pause to help you see the big picture. <em>Project ALTius</em> is not about the <em>ALTius</em> glider, as in <strong><em>my</em></strong> glider — it’s about the method and the set of software and hardware tools you need to build a glider, as in <strong><em>your</em></strong> glider. And by choice I’ve set up a set of hard constraints for:</p><ul><li><strong>Software</strong> — open-source, complex yet easy-to-use, multi-platform</li><li><strong>Tools — </strong>cheap laser cutter and 3D-printers that are easy to build</li><li><strong>Materials — </strong>no <em>Rohacell®</em>, <em>CarboLine®</em> or other exotic stuff but rather just UV resin / balsa and affordable spread carbon cloth</li><li><strong>Time of Execution</strong> — all these constraints are derived from my initial target of “€500 glider build in a week”</li></ul><p>However, let’s be candid: we will never get the perfect looks of a commercial competition glider — at least I know I am not able at this time. But we <em>can</em> challenge them in other areas: we can get a similar weight and a similar flight behaviour but with a faster time of execution and much less expensive. When your bird will be up in the sky you will not be able to see its ‘less than perfect’ wing surface. And if we get this right we will pass the ‘affordable’ mark — maybe we will not reach ‘disposable’ yet but we will definitely be near “if I crash, it’s not the end of the world, I can fly it repaired next week or a brand new model in two weeks”. An interesting dilemma because repairing the crash will cost €50 to €100 and building a new one €100 to €200 in materials.</p><h4>An Analogy</h4><p>Here’s a familiar car analogy to compare to F5J competitions: right now on the track there is an exclusive club of Lamborghini / Ferrari / McLaren / Porsche owners. But you can buy (or pimp up your own) Toyota / Hyundai / Ford / Skoda / Renault / Fiat / Dacia / Tata with carbon parts and a super-motor for a tenth of a super-car price. And the brand of the car will not matter anymore but the skills of the person behind the wheel. That person is not just the pilot, they are also the designer of the car and the builder and the mechanic as well.</p><p>Makes sense, no?</p><h4>And a Confession</h4><p>I’m not a pilot nor a builder — due to my travel and job constraints I could not spend much time in the field or in the shop. I see myself more like a ‘technology enabler’. I used my time trying to solve some software or hardware problems. And in the weekends I like to spend time with kids in the local club teaching them CAD or recently writing these articles. There is a famous quote by Ralph Waldo Emerson:</p><blockquote>“It’s the not the destination, it’s the journey.”</blockquote><p>For <em>Project ALTius</em> it’s both, I’ve set up a desirable but distant destination and I’m prepared for a long but also interesting journey. It’s up to you if you decide just to read a travel blog or start to prepare for your own journey.</p><p>Next month, it’s back to the nuts-and-bolts. For now, if you have any questions feel free to add them in the <em>Responses </em>section below. You get there by clicking the little 💬 below. Thanks for reading. Until next time, best of luck with your project.</p><p>©2023 <a href="https://medium.com/u/937c3b5cdbc9">Tiberiu Atudorei</a></p><h4><strong>Resources</strong></h4><ul><li><a href="https://www.3ds.com/products-services/catia/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>CATIA</em></strong></a> from Dassault Systèmes. — “delivers the unique ability not only to model any product, but to do so in the context of its real-life behavior: design in the age of experience…”</li><li><a href="https://www.carboline.com/products/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Carboline®</em></strong></a> — “a global manufacturer of coatings, linings, and fireproofing with offices and manufacturing facilities worldwide…”</li><li><a href="https://www.ntop.com/education/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Element Free</em></strong></a> from nTop. — “The nTop Ed community is bringing together educators, researchers and students … how to access your free non-commercial license of nTop…”</li><li><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G-code?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>G-code</em></strong></a> on Wikipedia. — “the most widely-used computer numerical control (CNC) programming language. It is used mainly in computer-aided manufacturing to control automated machine tools, as well as from a 3D-printing slicer app…”</li><li><a href="https://3dprintedrcplanes.com/kodo?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Kodo</em></strong></a> from Kraga. — “Kodo is a proof of concept that 3D printing can be used for building RC planes. It was designed as a multipurpose glider that does it all…”</li><li><a href="https://meshmixer.com/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Meshmixer</em></strong></a> — “state-of-the-art software for working with triangle meshes…”</li><li><a href="https://www.anycubic.com/products/anycubic-photon-3d-printer?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Photon</em></strong></a> from Anycubic. — “LCD-based SLA 3D-Printer … supreme accuracy for highly detailed prints…”</li><li><a href="https://openscad.org/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>OpenSCAD</em></strong></a> — “software for creating solid 3D CAD models. It is free software…”</li><li><a href="https://www.oracover.de/film/oracover?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Oracover®</em></strong></a> from Lanitz-Prena Folien GmbH. — “our leading product for covering RC model airplanes is patented worldwide … permits re-positioning without fear of colour-layer separation…”</li><li><a href="https://www.perspex.co.uk/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Perspex®</em></strong></a> — “suitable for glazing, furniture and display cases to name a few applications…”</li><li><a href="https://www.plexiglas.de/en/about-us/our-brand/plexiglas-is-not-the-same-as-plexiglass?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Plexiglas®</em></strong></a> — “the first cast sheet made of polymethyl methacrylate … stable, transparent and impact-resistant polymer…”</li><li><a href="https://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?3341269-project-ALTius&amp;utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>RCGroups</em></strong></a> thread for Project ALTius. — “altius, citius, fortius — sounds familiar? That’s the Olympic motto where ‘altius’ means ‘higher’. But the spelling (ALTius) is related also to my initials — Atudorei Lucian Tiberiu…”</li><li><a href="https://performance-foams.evonik.com/en/products-and-solutions/rohacell?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Rohacell®</em></strong></a> — “For 50 years, Evonik’s ROHACELL® structural foam has been offering the aerospace and automotive industries, medical technology, and other markets boundless possibilities for lightweight construction…”</li><li><a href="https://www.solidworks.com/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>SolidWorks®</em></strong></a> — “SOLIDWORKS® and the 3DEXPERIENCE® Works portfolio unite your entire ecosystem…”</li><li><a href="https://www.textreme.com/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>TeXtreme®</em></strong></a> — “spread tow reinforcements are a uniquely adaptable, safe and ultra light supportive solution for your carbon fiber composites…”</li><li><a href="http://www.xflr5.tech/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>XFLR5</em></strong></a> — “an analysis tool for airfoils, wings and planes operating at low Reynolds Numbers…”</li><li><a href="https://github.com/ALT3dRC/xflrwing?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>xflrwing</em></strong></a> — “STL generator for an XFLR project wing…”</li><li><a href="https://www.dupont.com/brands/styrofoam.html?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>XPS</em></strong></a> from DuPont. — “Since its discovery in 1941, Styrofoam™ Brand XPS Insulation has a long and rich heritage as a sustainable building product…”</li></ul><p><em>All images by the author. Read the </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/twist-distributions-for-swept-wings-675d72fb6408?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>next article</em></strong></a><em> in this issue, return to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/cool-new-stuff-4b1fef4f8dcd?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>previous article</em></strong></a><em> in this issue or go to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/2023-05/home"><strong><em>table of contents</em></strong></a><em>. A PDF version of this article, or the entire issue, is available </em><a href="/service/mailto:NewRCSoaringDigest@gmail.com?subject=Project%20ALTius%202023-05%20PDF%20Request"><strong><em>upon request</em></strong></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1b3962dd34a3" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/project-altius-1b3962dd34a3">Project ALTius</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest">The New RC Soaring Digest</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Project ALTius]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/project-altius-73e67d4e9c77?source=rss-937c3b5cdbc9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/73e67d4e9c77</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[aeronautical-engineering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[april-2023]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[3d-printing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aviation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rapid-prototyping]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tiberiu Atudorei]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 Mar 2023 18:44:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-05-05T23:37:46.274Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4lR8grXelopY_WCtiKauoA.png" /><figcaption>Geodetic wing structure.</figcaption></figure><h4>Part III: Working within weight and financial constraints.</h4><p><em>In </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/project-altius/home?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Parts I and II of this series</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong><em>the author described performance glider projects as complex with a lot of repetitive and complex operations. He went on to explain how CAD software can be automated in standalone separate SAD (software assisted design) apps and homemade HAM (hardware assisted manufacturing) devices and then presented some same workflows to illustrate their use. — Ed.</em></p><p>With the information from the RCGroups discussion (see <em>Resources</em>, below, for this and all links reference in this article) and the hints from the previous articles you should have a good idea of what can be done with xflrwing and what needs to be done in <em>NetFabb</em> and <em>OpenSCAD</em>. Also, It’s very important to have a good assesment of your manufacturing tools and skills. If you own or have access to CNC equipment you can use the wing, mold and plug 3D models and start working. That said I still recommend starting with some sacrificial stock like XPS (extruded polystyrene foam) first which you’ll likely know this as ‘pink insulation foam’.</p><p>Subtractive manufacturing via CNCs is not my forte — I’m not a fan. You need a good machine — very rigid and accurate — and it’s very messy. I had some ideas about carving plugs from XPS given its easy-to-machine properties and then topping with resin and mineral filler. However, the volume of work is quite large and involves a lot of elbow grease for polishing the molds and plugs. Also in order to machine solid cores from <em>Rohacell®</em> or XPS you definitely need some perforated molds and a vacuum table or at least double adhesive tape. So no CNC for me for the moment, just ‘simple’ 3D printing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jvuxNsXC4TsPGZnerwGLDQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>A good 3D-printer is affordable (and way less messy than) CNC.</figcaption></figure><p>In fact <em>Project ALTius</em> started as a ‘3D-printed F5J glider’ — in fact, the ALT in ALTius comes from ‘additive layer technology’. I created the wing 3D model and I started printing: first with a 0.4mm nozzle, then 0.3mm and finally 0.2mm. Then I started a different approach — perforating the wing in <em>OpenSCAD</em> similar to Kraga’s <em>Kodo</em> glider. None of these methods had satisfactory results. Why? It’s time for some numbers — that is, weight estimation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TYfD0kG2a-px-sYLTNvsoQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Bad prints with a small nozzle and transition to a geodetic structure.</figcaption></figure><h4>No Precision Scale Required — We’ll Just Run Some Numbers</h4><p>In xflrwing text output you may notice a small section with some numbers: projected area of the wing, total area, volume plus some estimations of the weight depending on the materials. There are also estimations of the weight of fuselage, tails and AUW (all up weight) and wing load.</p><p>Remember that <em>Project ALTius</em> is about a ‘performance glider’ which is to say an ‘F5J competition glider’. Even if we don’t have the wing load as in F3J we still need to have a resilient wing at a reasonable weight. That means AUW something between 1250 and 1500g for a 3.6 to 4m wingspan. Furthermore, this means a wing of 625-750g, a tail of 60-75g and a fuselage of 230-300g.</p><p>Have you noticed the pattern here? I’ve allocated from the ‘weight budget’: around 50% to the wing, 5% to the tail, 20% to the fuselage and 25% for the rest consisting of motor with or without reduction gearbox, spinner, folding propeller, ESC, servos, receiver and LiPo pack.</p><p>Did I just make up these numbers and percentages? Not really, there are an educated guess from what I’ve seen in my F5J gliders: <em>Viator</em> 3.16m, <em>Crozilla</em> 3.45m, <em>Ultima2</em> 3.6m, <em>Shadow</em> 3.65m, <em>Xplorer</em> 3.7-3.8m and <em>Ultima</em> 4.0m.</p><p>The wing weight has three different components:</p><ol><li><strong>Surface</strong> (W1) — the weight of the material used for the wing surface. Of course it is proportional to the total wing surface</li><li><strong>Volumetric</strong> (W2) — the weight of the material used inside of the wing. It is proportional to the volume of the wing — there is a little ‘overlap’ between W1 and W2 but we will simplify the model.</li><li><strong>Structural</strong> (W3) — the weight of the spar, joiners and other elements. It is <strong>not</strong> proportional to either surface or volume.</li></ol><p>Right now there are three methods to build the wing:</p><ol><li><strong>Balsa</strong> (eg. <em>Pulsar</em>) — W1 (surface) is for <em>Oracover®</em> and carbon D-box, W2 (volumetric) is zero for air, structural weight W3 (structural) is spar, ribs and joiner.</li><li><strong>Hollow-wing </strong>(eg. <em>Explorer)</em> W1 is for surface composite, W2 is zero, W3 is spar and joiners.</li><li><strong>Solid-core</strong> (eg. <em>Ultima</em>) — W1 is for surface carbon, W2 is for <em>Rohacell®</em> and W3 is for spar and joiners.</li></ol><p>One important remark about W1/W2/W3 in different technologies: in the latter years I have noticed a transition from hollow-wing — with W2 equal to zero — to solid-core with a significant W2. This was done of course at the attendant benefit of lower W1 and W3. The density of <em>Rohacell®</em> is 30kg/m³ to 50kg/m³ which is similar to XPS. However, this technology — taken from DLG designs — has so far limited application to F3J. To the best of my knowledge a ‘heavy’ 3.16m <em>Viator</em> was the only winch-launched, solid-core design in an F3J competition.</p><h4>Is a 3D-Printed Wing within Our Weight Budget Constraints?</h4><p>Let’s try to estimate the weight of a 3D-printed wing of 75dm² projected area — 1.5 m² total area — and a volume of 6000cm³. For a 0.4 mm nozzle the surface is made up of one or two ‘walls’. One wall results in:</p><p>W1 = 1.5 m² x 100 x 100 (to convert from m² to cm²) x 0.04 (the diameter of a 0.4 mm nozzle in cm) x 1.15 g/cm3 = 690g.</p><p>If we print the interior with a 1% infill we will have:</p><p>W2 = 6000cm³ x 0.01 (1% infill) x 1.15g/cm³ = 69 grams.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xgxyBaiLS7-RdP9T09xAGg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Segments for half wing prepared in slicer — our weight estimation was good.</figcaption></figure><p>With <em>0.4mm nozzle / one wall / 1% infill</em> we are exceeding the weight budget even with a W3 of zero. That means no spars — a very <strong>bad</strong> idea. Furthermore with only one wall the printed wing will definitely have structural flaws. Here are some other options:</p><ul><li><strong><em>0.4mm / one wall / 2% infill</em></strong> — a little bit better with a 10% increase in weight but there are still structural flaws.</li><li><strong><em>0.4mm / two walls / whatever infill</em></strong><em> </em>— way too much.</li><li><strong><em>0.2 mm / two walls / … </em></strong>— is in fact similar to <em>0.4 mm / one wall /…</em> which was already rejected and, in addition, it will probably double the printing time.</li><li><strong><em>0.3 mm / two walls / …</em></strong><em> </em>— is increasing W1 by 50% — 900g instead of 600g — and a greater than 1000g 3D-printed wing is not my goal, at least not for <em>ALTius</em> Mk1 anyway.</li></ul><h4>Dead End? Not Really.</h4><p>The structural flaws of a 3D-printed wing are related to the FDM (fused deposition modelling) technology. What we are printing is a (forgive the metaphor) a ‘squished molten plastic sausage’. The adherence between layers depends on the nozzle diameter, the layer height, the plastic temperature and the printing speed. For a 0.4mm nozzle we need a maximum 0.2mm layer height. In theory you can have two-thirds of nozzle diameter but it’s better to have a maximum of a half, a high temperature and a low printing speed for a good adhesion. We can control some of these factors but we will still result in a heavy wing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*i6aE5QOEyq2HBWhqu8pi4w.jpeg" /><figcaption>A closer look at the infill structure near the plate (no printed walls)…</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PERGZYQWjQzDCMUA0QroKw.jpeg" /><figcaption>…and at the wingtip</figcaption></figure><h4>Resin 3D-Printing to The Rescue!</h4><p>Fortunately, there’s a better alternative with this alternative 3D-printing technology. Consider the following comparisons:</p><ul><li>0.4mm nozzle versus 0.1mm (or less) laser spot to fuse the resin.</li><li>0.2mm layer height versus 0.1mm or 0.15mm or 0.2mm layer. Actually, it doesn’t matter too much — it’s how deep the laser beam penetrates the UV resin.</li><li>One wall / two walls versus any wall width we want with a minimum of 0.1mm. Remember that we may overlap laser paths to get a wall width of 0.25mm, for instance.</li><li>With regard to speed we are no longer limited by the thermal constraint in FDM but we may still have mechanical constraints. We will see later what kind of speeds we achieve.</li><li>It’s no longer ‘sausage over sausage’ — it’s a ‘brick layer over brick layer’ structure while the density of resin is similar: on the order of 1.15g/cm³.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Sw1OC0ixbFmzKHnxMd0qKQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>First test of lightweight internal structure printed with resin.</figcaption></figure><p>With a resin 3D-printer we can get some very interesting results: <em>0.1 mm spot / 0.25mm walls / 1% infill</em> is 375g. We can add a nice layer of <em>TeXtreme®</em> 80g/m² , the R&amp;G Laminate Calculator gives us a 178–180g/m² laminate weight. Let’s round it to 200g/m² for some additional resin and this gives us a 300g layer of <em>TeXtreme®</em> with resin. 675g so far with 75g reserved for joiners and spars for a nice strong wing. I think we’ve got something here!</p><p>However, there is an itsy-bitsy-teenie-weenie problem: there is no affordable commercial 3D-printer with resin — all are large industrial models and very expensive.</p><p>So we’ll have to build the equivalent, instead.</p><h4>Other Options Instead of 3D-Prints?</h4><p>If the idea of 3D-printing a large F5J glider seems a little bit too much — let’s call it ‘the hi-tech build’— maybe I can interest you in some ‘lo-tech’: our good old trusty balsa. Let’s try to evaluate W1, W2 and W3 if we ‘print’ the wing with balsa using two special ‘balsa nozzles: 1mm for the foil (W1) and 2mm for the infill (W2). Competition-grade balsa has a density of 100–120kg/m³ or 0.10–0.12g/cm³. That’s aproximately one-tenth the weight compared to PLA (polylactic acid) or ABS (acrylonitrile butadiene styrene) 3D-printing filament. That means the W1 weight will be W1 = 180g (1.5 x 100 x 100 x 0.1 x 0.12 = 180). So W1 is sorted out and the result is good. Of course we have to add some glue but we can add this weight in the W3 estimation. For W2 we need to estimate first an infill factor. Note the 1% or 2% used for plastic is not an accurate estimation.</p><p>Let’s consider a geodetic rib mesh build up with balsa sheets of B millimeters and with a grid cell size of C millimeters. We will compute first the integer part of the ratio C / B = n. We can draw the cell as a big square composed of n x n smaller squares. The ‘infill’ / ‘balsa’ is the first rows of vertical and horizontal squares, in shape of letter L. That’s 2n — 1 squares out of n x n. Hence the infill factor is (2n — 1) / n * n. As n is in general quite big we can aproximate the infill with 2 / n.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4nuicYTJwpw_ApsWJemLfg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A little visual help for balsa infill estimation</figcaption></figure><p>For instance: 2mm balsa sheets used for a grid with 40mm cell size ➡ n = 20 ➡ infill = 10%. That’s nice, even if the infill is ten times larger compared to plastic this is compensated from the ten times difference in densities and we will have a similar W2: 6000cm³ x 10% x 0.12 g/cm³ = 72g. And a lot of space in the weight budget for W3.</p><p>Maybe the <em>1mm balsa foil</em> approach is not very appealing. Of course you can add some normal covering film or even better with paper laminating film. But I have another idea: why not use a composite surface like glass, carbon, <em>Kevlar®</em> or even a hybrid?</p><p>The <em>resin 3D-printed core with </em>TeXtreme®<em> surface</em> approach seems like a ‘hi-tech solid-core’. We don’t use CNCs and replace <em>Rohacell®</em> with 3D-printed spatial structure. The <em>balsa geodetic ribs covered with composite</em> approach looks like a ‘lo-tech hollow-wing’ or maybe a ‘hi-tech balsa’. In hollow wings, builders are using a sandwich of light fibreglass, <em>Airex®</em> and light carbon. In our case probably the <em>Airex®</em> is not necessary as we have the geodetic grid to support the composite. We can afford to use some heavy fabrics like <em>Kevlar®</em> 170g/m² (laminate weight 420g/m²) or carbon 200g/m² (laminate weight 440g/m²) or we can use two layers of lighter fabric. We will replace the balsa W1 of 180g with a beefier composite 630–660g but the wing will be stronger.</p><p>There is another itsy-bitsy-teenie-weenie problem: the normal K40 and other, cheaper laser cutters have a working area of 30cm x 20cm or 30cm x 30cm and we will need longer geodetic ribs — so we’ll have to build also a larger laser cutter.</p><p>So far we have discussed the weight — our goal for the moment is to achieve something similar to hollow-wing or solid-core technologies. We can definitely achieve this goal with 3D-printers or geodetic balsa ribs but the real benefit in this case is that we expect a better structure compared to hollow-wing or solid-core. I’ll get into the details a little bit later in this series. There is also the time factor to consider. Probably we will spend some significant time in printing† but it will not be <em>our</em> time but rather ‘robot time’. 3D-printers don’t need human operation or supervision for long prints.</p><p><em>†Or maybe not — but let’s keep some surprises for the ‘advanced HAM’ part of the </em>Project ALTius<em> series.</em></p><h4>Money, Money, Money</h4><p>The final factor we need to consider is the cost. When I’m buying or building a glider the first question I have to ask myself: “is it worth it?”. “Big and cheap” is our motto here so let’s consider a ratio between price (in euro using €) and wingspan (cm):</p><ul><li><strong>Foam</strong> — in the range of 0.5–1.0€/cm, with ARF (almost ready to fly) closer to 0.5€/cm and PNP (plug and play) closer to 1.0€/cm.</li><li><strong>Balsa</strong> — in the range of 1–2€/cm with kits closer to 1.0€/cm and ARF closer to 2.0€/cm</li><li><strong>Composite </strong>— in the range of 2.0–4.0€/cm. From my personal experience <em>Viator</em> on the lower price range and <em>Ultima2</em> on the upper part — if you buy it from the manufacturer and not from a specialised shop. In the latter case you can get closer or even past 5.0€/cm.</li></ul><h4>The €1000 Question(s)</h4><p>Can we make a high performance composite glider for a cost similar to a foam or balsa kit? Is the crazy goal of 1.0€/cm within our reach?</p><p>For this project the main cost is related to materials and tooling. Let’s put aside for the moment the tooling — don’t worry, we will get to it on the next part — and evaluate the material prices. For the wing we will need around 2m² of <em>TeXtreme®</em>, plain carbon or hybrid material and another 1m² for the fuselage and tail for a total of 3m². If you fancy a 45° bias with your layup you will probably need to bump that up to 4-5m². 200g/m² carbon is cheap but it is not suitable for the tails. Worst case scenario we can use non-woven carbon or light glass cloth. Or how about a hybrid of <em>Kevlar®</em>-carbon material or the nice look of spread tow <em>TeXtreme®</em>?</p><p>Some estimates for material costs:</p><ul><li>1m x 3m of 12K (12,000 filaments per tow) 80g/m² carbon is €68.21 plus €14.01 shipping for a total of €82.22 for a simple non-biased layout for a single glider. That’s 27.4€/m² —and if if you buy 15m² of carbon the price is 24€/m² which is quite a bit less.</li><li>UV resin for 3D-printers is now 25€/kg. It’s even cheaper at 20€/kg if you buy in batches of 10kg.</li><li>ABS/PLA/PETG 3D-printing filament is 15–25€/kg.</li></ul><p>So it seems like with €200 we can get the materials for the project <strong>but</strong> don’t reach for your wallet or credit card. This leaves only €200 left for tooling in our €400 financial budget. Is it possible?</p><h4>What’s Next</h4><p>We’ll answer that question in the next part(s) of the series. Spoiler alert: probably you’ve guessed that the answer is <strong>yes.</strong> Between now and then, if you have any questions feel free to add them in the <em>Responses </em>section below. You get there by clicking the little 💬 below.</p><p>Thanks for reading. Until next time, best of luck with your project.</p><p>©2023 <a href="https://medium.com/u/937c3b5cdbc9">Tiberiu Atudorei</a></p><h4><strong>Resources</strong></h4><ul><li><a href="https://www.3accorematerials.com/en/markets-and-products/airex-foam?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Airex®</em></strong></a> from Airex AG. — “Sandwich applications with Airex® foams are up to 50% lighter than conventional solutions require less energy while preserving highest strength, stiffness, and thermal insulation…”</li><li><a href="https://www.dupont.com/brands/kevlar.html?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Kevlar®</em></strong></a> from DuPont. — “Extremely strong yet lightweight and durable, Kevlar® provides the perfect balance of form and function — allowing you to redefine performance and explore new possibilities…”</li><li><a href="https://3dprintedrcplanes.com/kodo?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Kodo</em></strong></a> from Kraga. — “Kodo is a proof of concept that 3D printing can be used for building RC planes. It was designed as a multipurpose glider that does it all…”</li><li><a href="https://github.com/3DprintFIT/netfabb-basic-download/releases?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>NetFabb</em></strong></a> — “a free … software for 3D Printing and the STL file format…”</li><li><a href="https://openscad.org/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>OpenSCAD</em></strong></a> — “software for creating solid 3D CAD models. It is free software…”</li><li><a href="https://3dprintedrcplanes.com/kodo?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Oracover®</em></strong></a> from Lanitz-Prena Folien GmbH. — “our leading product for covering RC model airplanes is patented worldwide … permits re-positioning without fear of colour-layer separation…”</li><li><a href="https://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?3341269-project-ALTius&amp;utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Project ALTius</em></strong></a> on RCGroups. — “altius, citius, fortius — sounds familiar? That’s the Olympic motto where ‘altius’ means ‘higher’. But the spelling (ALTius) is related also to my initials — Atudorei Lucian Tiberiu…”</li><li><a href="https://www.r-g.de/en/laminatecalculator.html?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>R&amp;G Laminate Calculator</em></strong></a> from R&amp;G Faserverbundwerkstoffe GmbH. — A handy online tool that will even ‘print out’ the results on a tape so they can be easily printed or PDF’d.</li><li><a href="https://performance-foams.evonik.com/en/products-and-solutions/rohacell?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Rohacell®</em></strong></a> — “For 50 years, Evonik’s Rohacell® structural foam has been offering the aerospace and automotive industries, medical technology, and other markets boundless possibilities for lightweight construction…”</li><li><a href="https://www.dupont.com/brands/styrofoam.html?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>Styrofoam™ Brand XPS Insulation</em></strong></a> — “Since its discovery in 1941, Styrofoam™ Brand XPS Insulation has a long and rich heritage as a sustainable building product…”</li><li><a href="https://www.textreme.com/?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>TeXtreme®</em></strong></a> — “spread tow reinforcements are a uniquely adaptable, safe and ultra light supportive solution for your carbon fiber composites…”</li></ul><p><em>All images by the author. Read the </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/twist-distributions-for-swept-wings-71eb43a3db65?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>next article</em></strong></a><em> in this issue, return to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/flying-back-in-time-6684258a2d99?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>previous article</em></strong></a><em> in this issue or go to the </em><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/2023-04/home?utm_source=new.rcsoaringdigest.com"><strong><em>table of contents</em></strong></a><em>. A PDF version of this article, or the entire issue, is available </em><a href="/service/mailto:NewRCSoaringDigest@gmail.com?subject=Project%20ALTius%202023-04%20PDF%20Request"><strong><em>upon request</em></strong></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=73e67d4e9c77" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest/project-altius-73e67d4e9c77">Project ALTius</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/rc-soaring-digest">The New RC Soaring Digest</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>