<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Tieran Alexander on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Tieran Alexander on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball?source=rss-f20e8b3389a4------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 23:26:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Analyzing EVERY Prospect Traded at the Deadline]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/analyzing-every-prospect-traded-at-the-deadline-f32c891b8071?source=rss-f20e8b3389a4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f32c891b8071</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trade]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[player-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tieran Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Aug 2022 18:16:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-12T18:16:00.230Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VtiNdsTgjhS-ULyBMAiOHw.png" /></figure><p>This year’s trade deadline was insane. We saw big names like Luis Castillo and Frankie Montas change hands. We saw surprising challenge trades like Josh Hader for Taylor Rogers+ and Montgomery for Bader. We even saw the biggest trade in MLB History, as the Padres somehow found a way to acquire Juan Soto. I will not focus on those players since you can read about those anywhere from dozens of different people.</p><p>I will instead cover every single player on the other side of the equation. The prospects that are changing hands in a desperate win now move. There were approximately sixty prospects that moved teams last week. I will break down every single one of them in-depth and tell you what you can expect from them with their new teams and hopefully grant some insight into why your team thought they were worth trading their best players for.</p><h3>The New York Yankees trade Beck Way, Chandler Champlain, and TJ Sikkema to the Kansas City Royals for Andrew Benintendi</h3><h4>Beck Way</h4><p><em>All the pitch movement specifics in this blurb are from 2021, since that is the data I have available. Any current stuff is largely speculation based on industry feedback, what I’ve read from other publications or educated guesses based on the changes in results.</em></p><p>Beck Way is the player commonly regarded as the centerpiece of the deal to bring Benintendi to New York. Beck Way was the Yankees 4th round pick in 2020 and his stock has only risen since that time. Beck Way has made major strides against lefties this year and now actually has a chance of sticking in the rotation.</p><p>The fastball is not particularly good. Beck Way throws it hard, sitting 93–96 MPH and touching as high as 98 MPH. The movement is more sinkerish, but it’s not a good one with 10.6&quot; IVB and 16&quot; HB from a 1.9&#39; horizontal release. The pitch has a low release at just under 5.5&#39; albeit an inconsistent one. The arm action is incredibly lengthy, with a long swinging motion that leads to some struggles to repeat from Way. Despite the velocity, I’m really not sold on the heater being anything better than average. He has somewhat suspect fastball command as well, which doesn’t help in the slightest.</p><p>The slider is the pitch Beck Way is most comfortable with. He uses it the most with it, compiling 47% of all pitches Way threw in 2021. I think he might have decreased his slider usage this year given the decrease in strikeouts and walks both, but I am far from confident in that assumption. Beck Way does have a nasty slider, however. The pitch sat at an inconsistent 83 MPH on average. He showed feel for both sweep and depth, with -0.3&quot; IVB and 11&quot; of sweep on average. He lands the slider in the zone a little over 40% of the time and gets chases 35.3% of the time while also getting swinging-strikes nearly 20% of the time.</p><p>The slider is a nasty pitch that misses bats and should continue to do so at the higher levels. I think it’s more of a plus pitch than an elite one as he gets very firm at times. Beck Way also lacks the arm side command to backdoor it against lefties. Despite that, it should perform and give right-handed hitters fits when they have to stare down Beck Way.</p><p>Before this year, I would have said that there is zero chance Beck Way remains a starting pitcher. He had major walk problems and the most jarring platoon splits I’ve ever seen. Beck Way had a 43.7% Whiff rate in 2021 against righties. That is absurdly good. Against lefties, however, it was just 18%.</p><p>I thought it was because of the arm action that he couldn’t hide the ball at all. I’m not even entirely convinced that is not the case now. However, Way has gone from striking out 18.3% more batters as a righty than as a lefty to striking out just 2.2% more batters as a lefty. To be fair, it’s only actually an 8.6% upswing against lefties; he’s mostly just been a lot worse against right-handed hitters for whatever reason.</p><p>I think the changeup command has made strides based on the one start of his I’ve watched this year. Beck Way is landing the changeup in the zone more often and that change has led to him getting more chases. The changeup has lost a tick which has it more 87–88 MPH than 88–90 like it was often last year. He also has just 3.5&quot; IVB and 16&quot; HB, which is above-average movement on both planes. I’m still skeptical the changeup will translate given the arm action, but there is hope of a third pitch now.</p><p>I still have no confidence in Beck Way’s command and think he probably winds up in relief long term. The slider has been more inconsistent this year- he is seemingly zoning it a lot more against righties when it destroys off the plate. The fastball shape is mediocre. The changeup is probably mediocre. There is obvious potential here, but it&#39;s difficult to claim Beck Way is more than a 40 FV right now.</p><h4>Chandler Champlain</h4><p>There are some things to like about Chandler Champlain, and I can see why the Royals might have targeted him in this trade. However, I want to dump some ice water on the excitement that is building. He is not remotely close to what the statline this year suggests he is.</p><p>Chandler Champlain has a mediocre fastball that he can actually elevate with velocity. As such, it overwhelms lower level hitters, and that leads to these breathtaking results. The shape is much less encouraging. The heater sits at 93.9 MPH and touches 98 with above-average spin rates. The problem is that the pitch is inefficient, so he only gets 15.6&quot; IVB and 4.6&quot; HB on average. When you combine the below-average vertical movement with a 6.2&#39; vertical release, the VAA is very poor.</p><p>Champlain’s gotten chases 43% of the time because Low-A hitters are bad but it’s not likely to be a translatable skill. I suspect this because all his chases are out of the top of the strike zone- if it was horizontal I might believe it is a deception/tunneling thing, but it’s all vertical. He has a 47.4% chase rate on pitches above the zone and just 18.2% on all other out of zone pitches. I think it is very likely that the chase rates fade as Champlain climbs the levels and even against Low A competition; Champlain has below-average in-zone whiff rates with his heater sitting at just 14.4%. There is potential with improved spin efficiency. Champlain supinates significantly naturally, so it’s not an easy path forwards, but there is one.</p><p>The slider is probably the best pitch in Champlain’s toolbox and grades out as above-average. He throws it fairly hard at 84.8 MPH with spin rates of just over 2600 RPMs. The slider has both snap and depth with 0.7&quot; IVB and 7.2&quot; HB this year in Low A. The problem is the arm slot isn’t ideal for missing bats with a slider as Champlain throws his from just a 1.1&#39; horizontal release that kills his HAA. The velocity, spin, and shape are all intriguing, but I’m not sold on the shape being anything special or it playing at the major league level given the slot.</p><p>Chandler Champlain rounds out his arsenal with a curveball that is his primary pitch against lefties. They only throw the curveball at 78.3 MPH with spin rates that are just a tad under 2800 RPMs. He has elite depth with -16.6&quot; IVB from a high release so it might be a dominant offering. Except there are some caveats. First, Champlain has limited feel for his curveball with the pitch only landing in the zone 28% of the time. It’s his top whiff pitch but his lowest pitch by strike rate. The other problem is velocity. If he throws harder or with more command, then it should be another above-average pitch. I think it’s pretty likely one of those comes to fruition.</p><p>I am often one to use walk rates as a major part of grading control, so I might be a hypocrite for saying this, but I don’t really think Champlain has all that good of control despite a 6.5% walk rate. The zone-rate on all three of his pitches is below 40%. He is still regularly spiking stuff in the dirt. The delivery is very violent. The only reason he has so few walks is because low-level hitters chase everything. As the chases stop coming, the walks will pile on. I think given the command and fastball shape issues, Champlain is likely to wind up as a breaking ball reliant middle reliever.</p><h4>TJ Sikkema</h4><p><em>All the pitch movement specifics in this blurb are from 2019 in College since that is the data I have available. Any current stuff is largely speculation based on industry feedback, what I’ve read from other publications or educated guesses based on the changes in results.</em></p><p>TJ Sikkema is probably the best prospect in this trade from where I stand. He does not throw all that hard or have incredible movement, but he throws strikes at a very high rate. He also has an optimal angle from his unorthodox 5.1&#39; RelHeight and 3.2&#39; RelSide (2019). Sikkema missed all of 2021 with a lat strain, but he’s healthy now and should move fairly quickly through the minors.</p><p>The fastball does not have a ton of ride with him averaging just 12.3&quot; IVB in his college days and, to the best of my knowledge, that has not improved at all since then. The tail is above-average at ~14&quot; HB, but the calling card is strictly an unorthodox arm angle. That unorthodox angle lets the fastball at 91–93 MPH work both up and down in the zone as an average pitch. If you’re expecting a great fastball, you will be sorely disappointed, but Sikkema’s does profile as a legitimate MLB-caliber offering.</p><p>The slider is clearly TJ’s best pitch and will probably wind up as a plus pitch. He throws it in the low eighties with extreme angles because of the low slot. The depth is above average, and he has some sweep to it. It’s a single-digit amount of break most of the time, but it’s enough to play on his glove side given the arm slot. The most impressive part of Sikkema’s slider, however, is the fact that he can land it in the zone and on both sides of the plate, which lets it play against righties as much as lefties. There is some feel to change it into a below-average curveball, but I don’t think he ever needs that version of the pitch.</p><p>The changeup is a solid pitch in the low eighties. Sikkema threw it with 14.7&quot; of fade and 5.2&quot; IVB in 2019. The pitch feel has improved since then, but the shape appears to be the same from everything I’ve seen and heard. He has a little under 9 MPH of velocity separation, which is right on the border of acceptable when the heater and changeup have such similar movement profiles.</p><p>If he is elevating the fastball, the changeup might work as a tunnel with the fastball but I think the fastball works best down in the zone so it puts him in an awkward spot where Sikkema is best off deploying his fastball in sub-optimal locations against righties. This is probably why Sikkema allows more hard contact to righties despite missing more bats against them.</p><p>The changeup/slider tunnel is maybe the more interesting option for me. Sikkema probably has too much horizontal separation for it to truly be an elite pair, but it’s just 2 MPH and 6&quot; of statcast drop separating the two pitches. Using the two as a tunnel probably means pitching like Kevin Gausman has to for the FS/SL tunnel to work and using a lot of middle-middle fastballs. That is a risky path because of the contact quality concerns that come with it, but it’s probably what Sikkema needs to do to maximize chases and miss bats at the higher levels.</p><p>Even then, he might just have too much horizontal separation to effectively hide the ball. Command helps Sikkema mask a lot of his flaws and it’s a plus skill, but there are considerable flaws. It also might not translate to low walk rates given that he is only running average chase rates against younger competition. The stuff is around average and while there is upside, I’m not at all confident that Sikkema taps into said upside with his new team. I think Sikkema fits best as a swingman on a contender or an innings eater back of the rotation arm on the Royals. He’s interesting, but the upside isn’t high enough to justify the risk.</p><h3>The New York Mets trade Jose Acuna, and Hector Rodriguez to the Cincinnati Reds for Tyler Naquin and Phillip Diehl</h3><h4>Jose Acuna</h4><p>Jose Acuna has a nasty fastball and if the Reds want more, than I’d advise that they trade a player better than Tyler Naquin for it next time. I’m also a sucker for good fastballs, so I like Acuna a great deal more than I should. I might even assign a low 40 FV to him (Like ~7th round grade if he was in the draft).</p><p>The fastball sits 91–94 MPH right now, but there is some room to add strength to his 6&#39;2&quot; frame and bring the velocity around to at least the major league average. More important, however, is the impact shape of his fastball. Acuna throws the pitch with high spin rates- sitting just a smidge under 2400 RPMs and he has above-average movement on both planes as a result. Albeit barely so with 17.3&quot; IVB and 12.2&quot; HB.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/653/1*pibuXAqDs0lc2ifrtboH6g.png" /></figure><p>The above-average ride on the fastball combined with a 5.6&#39; release height gives Acuna a very flat vertical approach angle. That flat VAA lets Acuna miss a plethora of bats and those whiff rates will only uptick as he further improves both efficiency and velocity. I think this is a plus fastball projection given that Acuna also has some feel for elevating the pitch. (Image above).</p><p>I would probably say that Jose Acuna’s best secondary pitch is a changeup, but I still don’t think it’s anything more than an average pitch and even that is aggressive. The movement is fairly poor, with 9.5&quot; IVB and 12.6&quot; HB. The reason Acuna’s changeup projects as average though is that he’s killing spin (1652 RPMs on average) with decent separation and shows some feel for the pitch. There is an ability to pronate that means you can project on the horizontal part with less efficiency- and more seam-shifted wake as a indirect result. The changeup intangibles are here, it’s just refining the shape right now.</p><p>The slider is not a very good pitch but Acuna shows the ability to spin it and supinate on release, so I’m far from writing it off yet. The slider sits in the low eighties with a somewhat cutter-esque movement at just below 2500 RPMs. He gets just 5&quot; IVB and 3&quot; HB. I think you have two paths here and both have some potential. Acuna could probably develop a sweeping slider, but I think I’d rather make him lean into his strengths and add velocity to turn it into a true cutter.</p><p>Given the extreme horizontal movement of the four-seam, and above-average ride as well; it is unlikely that a sweeping slider would have the deception needed to elicit chases from same handed batters. If he adds velocity, then his slider/fastball tunnels would be in the sweet spot to fool hitters and let both pitches play up.</p><p>Jose Acuna has an advanced feel for throwing strikes and pitchability. The fastball is already good with both the cutter and changeup showing potential. Acuna is a developmental project but I think he can shoot up prospect lists in the coming years. This is an exciting arm talent with lots of upside who scrapes a 40 FV from me.</p><h4>Hector Rodriguez</h4><p>I don’t have enough information on Hector Rodriguez to truly analyze him but I think he probably is in the 35 FV tier for the time being. Rodriguez is a tiny teenager at 5&#39;8&quot; with what looks like solid bat speed on film. He has a precious feel for contact with a hyper-aggressive approach that leads to some more long-term contact rate concerns.</p><p>Hector Rodriguez has primarily played centerfield this year and I don’t know enough to say if that is a long-term fit for him. The contact skills are what you’re buying, but there’s a risk when he has a grand total of two games above the complex level and it’s likely a contact only offensive profile. Upside, but it’s unclear how much or how to get him there from my perspective.</p><h3>The Seattle Mariners trade Noelvi Marte, Edwin Arroyo, Levi Stoudt, and Andrew Moore for Luis Castillo</h3><h4>Noelvi Marte</h4><p>Noelvi Marte is the prospect moved this deadline who I had highest on my preseason top 100 (CJ Abrams graduated a few days before the Juan Soto trade). The Mariners chose to ship him out to Cincinnati for the best pitcher on the market; Luis Castillo. Some scouts have soured on Marte after a slow start to the year but there were never real concerns in that performance and he’s since turned it around.</p><p>I was optimistic that Noelvi Marte would stick at shortstop before the season but I’ve completely backed off of that stance. My misplaced optimism was mostly due to the range he showed as a result of his plus speed and his ability to scoop up ground balls. I acknowledged the plethora of throwing errors and the transfer issues but I thought the Mariners could coach those out of him.</p><p>The errors have gotten worse this year, but I do still mostly believe that to be true. The change that has me pushing Noelvi to third base is that he has gotten bigger and as a result, Noelvi isn’t showing plus range. That makes it a lot harder to overlook the constant mistakes, so I’m sliding him down the defensive spectrum, over to the hot corner, but there is still significant defensive upside. Given the logjam of infielders in the Reds system, him playing the outfield is equally likely.</p><p>Noelvi Marte has gotten better offensively this year despite some scouts claiming the swing has gone backward. The contact rates are up, the top-end EVs are up, Marte is hitting the ball in the air more, and his swing decisions haven’t gotten meaningfully worse. I have no clue where the narrative of swing regression came from, but that narrative has no basis in reality whatsoever. Noelvi Marte still projects as an incredibly high impact hitter with a plus hit tool, and plus power as well.</p><p>Noelvi Marte is not an elite contact threat, but he’s made strides in that regard. The in-zone contact rate is up by over 7% to ~87% this year. He’s made less out of zone contact this year- possibly because of the regressed athleticism, but out of zone contact is bad contact and easy outs, so this is arguably a positive development. He still has no trouble with demolishing velocity and is hitting more consistently at the top of the strike zone now.</p><p>Early in the year, Noelvi was struggling with chasing and whiffing on breaking balls but as he’s gotten adjusted to the level, the plate discipline has improved immensely and Ethan’s model estimates that after the last month of dominance he is down to 23.2%. The standard error bar is roughly 2% which puts him at where he was last year on the low-end and the zone-swing rates are higher than last year as well. I really don’t think that breaking balls are that big of an issue despite the early season troubles. This is a genuinely good contact skill and approach that has some risk, but I think it will remain that way.</p><p>The ability to make flush contact and run high BABIPs is still theoretically here. Noelvi Marte adapts his swing based on pitch location with a very flat swing at the top of the zone and a very steep one at the bottom. This theoretically leads to ideal spin characteristics on batted balls. The BABIP has regressed some because of more frequent popups (Still a prevalent issue of increasing concern but not a crippling one) and more pulled groundballs. I think you can probably iron these things out and, given the power, it’s an above-average BABIP skill, but there is some risk there.</p><p>Noelvi Marte has elite raw power that has only gotten better as he’s grown into his colossal frame. He technically has a 117.5 MPH EV this year, but I’m fairly certain that is a misread. I was told the actual Max EV is 113.8 MPH this year, which is still in the 93rd percentile of major leaguers. His Max of 112.5 MPH last year was in the 87th percentile. The 90th percentile exit velocities are nearly as impressive with Noelvi sitting at ~105 MPH which is already in the 70th percentile of big leaguers.</p><p>Noelvi has a powerful rotational swing with big bat speed that should play in games with improving feel for elevation. The power hasn’t really been that loud in the minors over an extended sample size, but I still don’t doubt for even a second that the power outbreak will come and that time is soon (Now? He’s been insane for a little over a month now and has two homers tonight).</p><p>Noelvi Marte maybe isn’t a shortstop, but he offers both contact and power with good swing decisions. He has all the offensive upside in the world and will be a ton of fun for Reds fans in the next few years. I think Noelvi Marte is probably a top 10–15 prospect in all of baseball and this is a great value for Luis Castillo (As a Mariners fan, I still love the deal). This is what superstars look like.</p><h4>Edwin Arroyo</h4><p>Edwin Arroyo is someone I had a first round grade on before the draft and then dropped a tad after the Mariners took him to avoid appearing biased. That was a horrible process, but that’s beside the point, Edwin Arroyo is a stud. He offers fantastic defense at a premium position and has a 137 PF wRC+ in Low-A this year as an 18-year-old.</p><p>Edwin Arroyo makes contact at an above-average rate from both sides of the plate. He makes more contact as a lefty but it’s not a meaningful enough difference in contact or power to abandon switch hitting and have to face same-handed breaking balls. The contact rates aren’t exceptional, but 72% in his first year of pro-ball is better than it looks. How much better? Of all the prep bats drafted in the first two rounds last year, only Jackson Merrill, James Triantos, James Wood, Joe Mack, Noah Miller, Colson Montgomery, and Izaac Pacheco. If I’m counting correctly, there were 21 prep bats in the first two rounds. Only one of them in the first round proper has a higher contact rate in their first full season. Arroyo’s contact skills genuinely are impressive even if the number feels low.</p><p>The barrel accuracy is what I claimed was the calling card before the 2021 draft, and it remains the primary attraction. I still don’t really know how to verbalize his knack for squaring balls up, but now I have statistical evidence in the form of a 23.7% line drive rate and a 6.6% popup rate. The ability to square balls up in the sweet spot consistently leads to sustainably high BABIPs. He has great posture in his swing and excellent hands. The ability to adjust is there, and he has a larger barrel because of his steep VBAs.</p><p>The natural inclination in Arroyo’s swing also has him tapping into all of his average raw power in games. The feel to elevate is above-average and Arroyo has premium barrel accuracy that could in theory let him exceed his Top-end EVs in-game power output. I still have the power graded as average given the Max EV is only 105.5 MPH, but I think that the feel for the barrel makes further growth very possible; even without notable strength gains which are also likely to come.</p><p>The defense was my favorite part of Arroyo as a prep and it has gotten no worse this year. Statistically, Arroyo has been great with +6 Davenport Runs in 83 games as well as 3.5 FRAA. If you prefer the eye test, I think he’s great as well. There are errors, but he shows plus range and elite arm strength with him getting up to 97 MPH across the diamond. He also can throw 95 MPH off the mound from the left-handed side. Getting off topic, but the ability to move his arm so fast from both sides is why he can switch hit as he has elite top-hand speed (What defines most of bat speed) with either hand. I digress. Arroyo should wind up as a plus defender at shortstop in the long run.</p><p>If Edwin Arroyo doesn’t completely collapse down the stretch, he will be on my top 100 next year. Edwin provides defense at the most premium of positions and should be, at worst, an average hitter with me leaning towards above-average. He’s still aways off, but he looks fantastic. Totally random, but Edwin Arroyo might be better than Jordan Lawlar. The Reds got another great shortstop to pair with Marte and De La Cruz amongst many others. The latter can pick it at shortstop, but I think Arroyo is the future there if they keep all three with the best glove of the bunch.</p><h4>Levi Stoudt</h4><p>Levi Stoudt is someone I was way too high on before the season because I received bad data. (See below). Actually, it’s more my fault than the bad data. I just didn’t quite understand how pitch tunneling and deception worked or how horribly ineffective it would actually be to have all your pitches separated by 40&quot; from the others. I’m not even certain the data Baseball America peddled at the time is wrong now that I think about it. Stoudt’s 2022 has seen significantly decreased whiff rates but elevated swinging-strike rates and a lot fewer walks. If he were to so drastically alter his entire arsenal, the changes would manifest in a similar variation of the statline.</p><h3>Tieran on Twitter: &quot;This tidbit is mind boggling.# of MLB Pitchers with a pitch thrown at least 1 time that has 20+ inches of Induced Break:North: 21South: 1East: 2West: 5That&#39;s out of 3003 pitches from 766 pitchers. And he throws 98 MPH too! If Levi Stoudt ever figures out his command... https://t.co/uxPgOsxuEJ pic.twitter.com/M23gyFmvMz / Twitter&quot;</h3><p>This tidbit is mind boggling.# of MLB Pitchers with a pitch thrown at least 1 time that has 20+ inches of Induced Break:North: 21South: 1East: 2West: 5That&#39;s out of 3003 pitches from 766 pitchers. And he throws 98 MPH too! If Levi Stoudt ever figures out his command... https://t.co/uxPgOsxuEJ pic.twitter.com/M23gyFmvMz</p><p>Levi Stoudt now throws a fastball that is probably an average pitch. The pitch sits at 94 MPH and touches 98 from a generic release height and medial horizontal release at 1.1&#39;. The fastball now has below average ride at ~14.5&quot; IVB. I believe this change was deliberate, in an effort to make the fastball actually playable. He also gets only average horizontal movement. The calling card here is arm strength and the ability to land the pitch for a strike, but it no longer stands out in any way (If it ever did).</p><p>I think the slider is probably the best secondary at this point and it barely scrapes an above-average grade from me. Stoudt throws his slider the most of anything he throws with a 46.1% usage rate and I think that is the optimal approach for him as his tunnels certainly build better off of the slider than the heater. Not to mention, the slider performs better in a vacuum as well.</p><p>The slider sits at 82.7 MPH and has average spin rates from a vertical slot. The movement is above-average but unexceptional as well, with 9.5&quot; HB and just 3.3&quot; IVB. The command of the slider within the strike zone makes the pitch above-average despite only average shape. Oh, and how the changeup plays off of it.</p><p>Levi Stoudt’s changeup does not work off the fastball at all. He throws it 13.5 MPH slower with double the horizontal break and only ~9 IVB more on the heater. The arm speed dips some on the changeup as well which doesn’t help things. The extreme shape variance and extreme velocity variance can’t coexist if Levi Stoudt wants to fool anybody.</p><p>With the slider working as the primary, however, I think the changeup can play up and actually provide utility against batters of both handednesses. The changeup is only 1.6 MPH slower by perceived velocity. The changeup has 0.2&quot; more drop with gravity than the slider does. That is a non-existent difference for all intents and purposes. If he was using the fastball as the primary I would probably advocate for switching to a gyro slider as right now, Stoudt has too much sweep for the slider to effectively tunnel off of the tailing fastball. Especially, with such a stark velocity and vertical movement difference. If he switches to a slider primary, then it could be perfect.</p><p>Twenty-two inches of horizontal movement separates the slider and changeup. They have essentially the same drop and velocity ranges as well. The horizontal tunnel is maybe a bit too much, but the rest of the tunnel is perfect and I doubt hitters can pick up on the horizontal movement enough for it to matter that much. The problem is that Stoudt doesn’t use the changeup against right-handed hitters at all. Rather predictably, Stoudt has extreme reverse splits due to his questionable pitch usage.</p><p>I think if the Reds want to get the most out of Levi Stoudt; they take the unconventional path forwards and have the slider/changeup pairing make up 75% of Stoudt’s pitches. The secondaries already make up 60% of Stoudt’s pitches so I don’t think it’s that crazy to drop him another 10% of so in fastball usage. In a perfect world, I think you figure out how to give Stoudt a power cutter primary but in this one, I’d probably use 42% sliders, 33% changeups, and 23% fastballs with the occasional slow curve early in the count to steal strikes. Against left-handed hitters I’d flip the slider and changeup usage, probably.</p><p>Stoudt throws strikes and has two pitches with great synergy. The lack of fastball ability might push him to the bullpen, but I’d give him the chance to start for now. He would likely only be a five-and-dive guy, but Levi Stoudt could be very effective in that role. I’m lower on Stoudt now, but he’s still probably a high 40 FV at this point.</p><h4>Andrew Moore</h4><p>Andrew Moore was undoubtedly my favorite draft pick by the Mariners last year after the first four rounds. The Mariners 14th rounder has always had ridiculous stuff, and it’s dominated out of the pen in the low minors. I think it will continue to do more of the same as he climbs the ladder. Hopefully, he can eventually slot into a late innings role in a major league bullpen for a contender.</p><p>The fastball is ridiculous. Moore sits 96–98 MPH and regularly will bump up against triple digits at his best. He throws from a low slot with decent enough ride which gives him fairly flat VAAs up in the zone. The pitch also has good tailing shape away from hitters and he pitches down for groundballs just as often as he does up. The pitch is an elite offering with only control holding it back.</p><p>The changeup was Andrew Moore’s best pitch before the draft with 18&quot; of fade at 84–86 MPH. The Mariners have faded his use of the changeup, however, with a much more intense focus on developing a pair of above-average breaking balls. I have a lot less data on the breaking balls, but both the short slider with bite in the upper eighties and the low eighties curveball with depth look nasty on film. In theory, the slider is a much better pair with the fastball from a deception standpoint as well.</p><p>There are command problems for Andrew Moore. He walks a lot of hitters. He also has a 46% whiff rate and is top 10% in the minors by in-zone whiff rate. Oh, and he now also has plus groundball rates as well. As long as you miss enough bats and limit the long ball, you can afford to have a walk issue out of the pen. Given what the Reds have done with Joe Boyle, I’m more than a little curious to see if the Reds want to stretch out Moore’s four pitch repertoire to start but I think he’s probably destined for the bullpen. The stuff will play in whatever role he fits in as the whiffs create a clear pathway to a major league role. He’s the clear fourth best piece in the Luis Castillo trade but he’s still an exciting prospect.</p><h3>The Tampa Bay Rays trade Christian Cerda to the Arizona Diamondbacks for David Peralta</h3><h4>Christian Cerda</h4><p>Christian Cerda’s scouting report is entirely based on film evaluations and stealing other people’s opinions, so this is a low-confidence evaluation. I have no opinion whatsoever about his defense, but he catches for now and has good caught stealing numbers in the DSL last year. The bat is actually very attractive, however.</p><p>Christian Cerda has above-average power that might be a plus. He has a strong muscular frame, but I’m more talking about the swing mechanics. The hip hinge is very prominent and Cerda gets good hip-torso separation when he swings. The hips are explosive and I think he’ll hit the ball hard when he manages to get everything working.</p><p>The contact skills look quite good, though. Cerda shows an elite feel for the strike zone against bat pitching and runs strong contact rates. The bat path is incredibly short and his timing mechanism is a soft leg kick that is a brief movement and easy to time up. That, combined with how quickly the barrel enters the zone means that Cerda in theory will have no trouble with velocity. He also never expands the zone at least against bad pitching with a sub 18% chase rate this year.</p><p>The bat path is short, but I hate everything about it. Cerda loads his hands low and, rather than twisting back as you would normally see, he drops his hands straight into the hitting zone and swings down on the ball. Cerda has admittedly elevated some in rookie ball, but I would be floored if that persists against better pitching. The current bat path also leads to some issues with poor timing on his contact, and that leads to more mishit balls.</p><p>The swing is flat, and the path just isn’t good right now. That can be cleaned up and there is both obvious contact and power potential here, but Cerda has a way to go to get there. I have Cerda as a 35 FV for the time being, but with some tweaks, or just performance in full-season ball, Cerda could move up the rankings rapidly during the 2023 season.</p><h3>The New York Yankees trade Hayden Wesneski to the Chicago Cubs for Scott Effross</h3><h4>Hayden Wesneski</h4><p>Hayden Wesneski throws perhaps the most unique breaking ball in all of baseball. The sweeper sits at 80 MPH with 18&quot; of sweep and -3.3&quot; IVB which is an elite movement profile but it’s not actually a sweeper. Wesneski uses a non-sweeper grip to create sweeper movement. I don’t really think that affects performance significantly, but it is a totally fascinating wrinkle to the pitch. The pitch is elite in a vacuum but doesn’t play that way because of a lack of deception.</p><p>At least that is what I thought before the season but Hayden Wesneski has added a gyro cutter at 87–89 MPH this year and it lets his entire arsenal play up now. The pitch has -0.7&quot; IVB and ~5&quot; of cut. The new cutter helps bridge the gap between the slider and fastball to give Wesneski more effective tunnels. The cutter has good specs in a vacuum (Pitching bot has it as a 57) but the draw of the pitch is the not often quantified deception element.</p><p>I think making the cutter the primary pitch is probably the best path forward for Wesneski as all four of his pitches play off of it. Thirteen inches of horizontal break separate the cutter from the slider, another 15.5&quot; separate it from the fastball moving in the other direction, to top it off, 18.5&quot; separate the changeup from the soon to be primary cutter. That is good horizontal separation on each pitch and all but the changeup (Which has the perfect vertical tunnel) have ideal velocity separation as well. It fits the arsenal a thousand times more to use the cutter as the primary instead of the fastball.</p><p>The changeup is a fine pitch on specs, but like with every changeup, it’s the interaction with the primary that matters the most. The changeup sits just 1.2 MPH slower than the cutter, with only 0.7&quot; more drop with gravity. Wesneski only has average fade by conventional standards but it plays as elite fade because it’s 18.5&quot; more than his ideal primary pitch. Remember that 99% of starting pitchers have a primary moving to their arm side, so they have at most ~15&quot; of horizontal separation between the two pitches. 18.5&quot; of separation is a lot. And then the cutter and changeup are coming out of the same slot at essentially the same speed with essentially the same amount of drop. If he is willing to use the cutter as the primary against OHB, then he can completely dominate them with this two pitch combo.</p><p>The fastball also works fairly well off of the cutter if the latter is the most commonly used pitch. Wesneski doesn’t have a bad fastball per se, it just isn’t one that meshes with the rest of what he throws. Wesneski is hitting 99 MPH at his best and sitting 94–97 MPH. The cutter has twice as much drop and nearly perfect horizontal separation, with 15.5&quot; HB separating the two pitches. It is a two-seam variant with just ~10&quot; IVB, which is an ugly gray area and only slightly above-average tail, but given the velocity from a 5.6&#39; RelHeight, it can still function in his arsenal. Just not as the primary as it is much too distinct from the slider and also bleeds into the changeup a bit too much.</p><p>If Wesneski switches to the cutter as his primary pitch, I think Wesneski projects as a middle-of-the-rotation starter with real upside to be more than that. He throws enough strikes although there have been issues with drawing chases in a big way as Wesneski is in just the 15th percentile of minor league pitchers by chase rate. He has probably been too aggressive as a zone filler this year (95th percentile) which is why the whiffs are down, but he shouldn’t have to be one if he only works off the cutter.</p><p>I have an entire five thousand word blog on Matt Brash sitting in my drafts that is just me begging for the Mariners to turn him into souped-up Hayden Wesneski. (I will never publish it cause it sucks) Wesneski has the super sweeper with the cutter to bridge the gap and let the entire arsenal play around it. He has good shape on three pitches and a hard fourth one with a decent angle up in the zone. The cutter is the foundation to build everything around and there is very high upside if he uses this mix correctly. Not as high of upside as Brash with the same cutter, but he already has the cutter which makes up for the difference in sweeper quality.</p><p>The strikeout upside is obvious in Wesneski if he works off the cutter and he has more than enough pitches to turn over the lineup multiple times and beat batters of both handednesses. There will be some platoon split working off of a cutter, but the repertoire is there for him to find success. If he continues to ride the fastball into the ground, then a bullpen role is more likely, as the sweeper will continue to struggle to get chases at his current velocity ranges. I really like Wesneski and expect that he’ll be getting serious consideration for my top 100 in the offseason. I might even lean towards the likelihood that he is on there, but I’d like a slightly larger sample of pitch data first before I make that jump so he’s just a high 50 FV for the time being.</p><h3>The Milwaukee Brewers trade Josh Hader to the San Diego Padres for Dinelson Lamet, Taylor Rogers, Esteury Ruiz, and Robert Gasser</h3><h4>Esteury Ruiz</h4><p>Esteury Ruiz has broken out in a big way during his seventh professional season and finally made it to the majors this year. I say finally because it’s been a long time, but he’s still just 23. The numbers in the minors this year are astonishing for the first time, but he did it in the least convincing manner possible as it’s primarily a result of elite barrel control and accuracy. Not that there aren’t skills here, simply that I am not fully convinced of their sustainability and Ruiz being much more than an average hitter.</p><p>In AA this year, Esteury Ruiz hit 43% of batted balls in the sweet spot (8–32° launch angle). They moved him up to AAA and in an 84 BBE sample size, he once again hit 40% of his batted balls in the sweet spot. That he immediately sustained it at a higher level even as the approach regressed back to normal has me believing that the changes are probably partially real, at the very least. Before this year Esteury was consistently below 30% but he’s made real adjustments and now has plus barrel accuracy that should let Esteury run high BABIPs despite a popup problem.</p><p>Esteury Ruiz has a bit more shaky contact skills than most will recognize. This is due mostly to a subpar approach. The approach development is likely what will define his long-term role in the majors. The in-zone contact rates were fine in the minors with Esteury sitting at ~84% over the last two years. The problem is the swing decisions. Esteury has pretty consistently been running a 30% chase rate or higher in the minors. Then this year it looked like he finally adjusted as he was chasing just 22.7% of the time in AA. However, after getting moved to AAA, that chase rate was back to 31% which suggests it was just the repeat stint in AA that was causing the pitch recognition gains.</p><p>Esteury Ruiz has a massive problem with expanding the zone in pursuit of breaking balls away from him against right-handed hitters. As a result, he is running a very extreme platoon split this year, as he has every year. There is the risk that he won’t hit enough to be anything more than the weak side of a platoon. He looked better at resisting his incessant need to chase the slider at the start of the year, but that faded in AAA and the risk is still almost as prominent as it was before the season that Ruiz won’t make enough contact to play every day.</p><p>Esteury Ruiz also only has average raw power. His Max EV is 108.6 MPH this year and his 90th percentile EV of ~102.5 MPH is right around the average MLB player. The feel to elevate is above-average and with so many balls at optimal angles, along with the feel to pull the ball, he does still hit some dingers, but it’s never going to be game changing power.</p><p>I think Esteury Ruiz has a solid chance at being an average hitter. If he gets there, Ruiz would likely play every day as a result since he also has 99th percentile sprint speed. Even with a noodle that should lead to above-average defense in centerfield.</p><p>However, I also have to acknowledge the significant platoon risk and the lack of carrying tool at the plate. I think the median outcome for Ruiz is a bench piece who can play against righties but you only are comfortable starting him against lefties on a contending ball club. There is an upside for more than that but the risk is very real that it’s just a bench bat and that risk can’t be understated. Esteury Ruiz gets a high 45 FV for me but he’s almost a lock to at least be a major league role player for a few years.</p><h4>Robert Gasser</h4><p><em>A lot of the pitch movement specifics in this blurb are from 2021, since that is the data I have available. Any current stuff is largely speculation based on industry feedback, what I’ve read from other publications or educated guesses based on the changes in results. There is also some stuff from 2022 based on an interview that Gasser gave with FanGraphs earlier this year.</em></p><p>Robert Gasser is one of my favorite popup arms in the minors this year and in the Brewers system, I’m expecting Gasser to quickly rise to new heights. He has four quality pitches and throws strikes at a high rate with good athleticism and there’s some room for strength gains in the frame. I’m expecting the Brewers to use him in shorter stints at first to try to build up his velocity before stretching him back out like they do with most of their top arms to great effect.</p><p>Robert Gasser has an alright fastball. He gets ~14.5&quot; IVB on the fastball from a very low release height at ~5.3&#39;. That low release with passable ride lets the four-seam fastball play up in the zone even if he’s only sitting 91–94 MPH. He misses bats at the top of the zone but has some contact quality concerns due to limited effective velocity, deception, and horizontal movement with just ~10&quot; HB. Although the fastball has good spin (~2300 RPMs), it is just inefficient spin right now. The fastball is probably an average pitch with the potential for more if he increases the velocity and spin efficiency. All that is just said to pad my word count, I have little interest in developing Gasser’s four-seam fastball.</p><p>I instead would rather that he centers his arsenal around a cutter that he can build more effectively off of. Gasser has developed a new cutter since being drafted that sits 86–88 MPH with very little horizontal movement and ~8&quot; IVB, I believe. I think given the Brewers&#39; track record with cutter development, it makes sense for Gasser to focus on adding velocity to the cutter and build his arsenal around that pitch. He would miss more barrels with a cutter primary and would better position the secondary stuff to miss bats at a high clip.</p><p>The slider has a new grip this year and is nasty. He sits at 82–84 from what i understand and has spin rates of ~2700 RPMs. The slider gets what Gasser claims is 17&quot; of sweep on average. This isn’t a sweeper, though, as Gasser has below-average vertical depth with him sitting at ~+3&quot; IVB. Only one major leaguer (Phil Maton) has a remotely comparable slider shape. This sweeping slider is coming from a 2.5&#39; horizontal release, which makes the HAA even more ridiculous.</p><p>The slider doesn’t work as is because the fastball doesn’t let it get chases near as often as Gasser should. He has 27&quot; of horizontal separation between the two pitches and over 20&quot; vertically. They don’t tunnel for even a second and better hitters will just opt not to swing at the slider. The slider works in the zone for called strikes but it could be a chase pitch with a cutter primary.</p><p>The cutter and slider are separated by ~15&quot; horizontally, with about half that amount separating them vertically. If Gasser is using his cutter on the arm side, then the slider should run away to the other side of the plate against fellow lefties. One team source described the FC/SL pairing as the best left-handed FC/SL they’ve ever seen. I don’t know if I’d go near that far, but they do play remarkably well off of each other and as he increases the cutter velocity, it could be the pair that causes him to sit near the front of a rotation.</p><p>The changeup is nasty too and probably works better off of the cutter than the fastball as well. He got good movement with 16.2&quot; of arm-side movement on the pitch last year. That has changed very little this year from what I’ve seen. The changeup has solid depth as well with just 2.8&quot; IVB on average last year. The changeup is a bit firm at 86.3 MPH on average (2021 college), and with so little velocity separation, a difference that equates to just 6&quot; of horizontal movement and 15&quot; of drop with gravity; the changeup will not actually work at all off the heater.</p><p>Enter the greatest pitch to ever grace Gasser’s life, the cutter. The cutter has much better interaction with the changeup. You trade too little separation out for what is an almost perfect ~18&quot; of horizontal separation between the two. The vertical difference is lesser than with the fastball as well, and given that they’re moving to the opposite sides of the plate, that is probably a good thing. The firm changeup might even be ideal off of a cutter as it lets it function solely as a chase pitch to his arm side if it’s at comparable speed as a hybrid sinker type shuuto pitch..</p><p>The best incarnation of Robert Gasser is probably one that uses the cutter to the arm side against lefties and the slider to the glove side in that situation. Against righties you have, Gasser deploy the cutter to the glove side and changeup to the arm side. Pitch down frequently with all three pitches but less down with the cutter. Use the fastball up occasionally, to keep hitters off balance as well.</p><p>Robert Gasser throws strikes at a high rate and has good stuff. The remaining struggle is just getting it to function at a higher level in games. His makeup is reportedly excellent, so I have faith that he’ll make the necessary adjustments to be successful. The Brewers were trading Josh Hader no matter what, given the worrying trends from this year and the cost, but they didn’t dump him for spare parts. They chose Robert Gasser because they know he has incredibly high upside in their system. He’ll probably start off slow with his new team, but he’s going to make his name known by everyone in 2023 when he shoots up prospects lists around the league.</p><h3>The Los Angeles Dodgers trade Garrett Cleavinger to the Tampa Bay Rays for German Tapia</h3><h4>German Tapia</h4><p>I don’t have much of anything on Tapia but because the Dodgers were willing to give up Garrett Cleavinger for him, he’s probably at least something. On a slightly off topic note, I’m going to predict that Cleavinger is a top ten reliever in all of baseball next year.</p><p>German Tapia is in his second stint of DSL play and has made major strides in every part of his game statistically. The body is well muscled and there is clear rotational ability based on limited film looks. I like the hip hinge and he does a good job with the weight transfer. He looks to have good power. The swing length gives me some pause and I don’t really buy the approach improvements this year, but he’s not nothing. To the best of my knowledge, Tapia is a below-average athlete who will play in a corner outfield spot. There is some upside probably, but I don’t know anywhere near enough to buy in on him yet or buy out either.</p><h3>The Oakland Athletics trade Frankie Montas, and Lou Trivino to the New York Yankees for JP Sears, Cooper Bowman, Ken Waldichuk, and Luis Medina</h3><h4>JP Sears</h4><p>As a Mariners fan who was just getting into scouting back then, I was heartbroken when we traded JP Sears and Juan Then for Nick Rumbelow. I was heartbroken over the wrong piece as it was Juan Then that caused my anguish, but that’s beside the point. Is there a point? Whatever, the point is JP Sears is awesome and re-emerged as one of my favorite minor league arms after dominating the minors in 2021. He isn’t that great, but he is a lot of fun and has potential.</p><p>The fastball is an outlier pitch because Sears throw from a sub 5&#39; release height. Sears only has 13.9&quot; IVB but given the sub 5&#39; release, it is still a -4.1° VAA, which is among the best in the majors. The pitch also has solid velocity, with Sears sitting at 93.7 MPH with an above-average extension to let the heater play up a tad. Sears has the needed feel to elevate the plus heater and can command it within the strike zone some. This is an unconventionally great fastball, but it is a plus pitch, nevertheless.</p><p>The secondaries have desirable traits. The slider is my favorite of the two, with good depth at 80.6 MPH. The changeup has 19&quot; of fade at 84 MPH. Both of them have obvious potential but don&#39;t work right now because of one crucial detail. JP Sears drops his arm slot on the secondaries by 0.37&#39; vertically and 0.27&#39; horizontally. That is a huge departure and makes the secondaries easy to recognize out of the hand. He also really struggles to land the slider on the glove side where it has to be to perform and often leaves both secondaries too high in the zone.</p><p>Let’s imagine a scenario where Sears fixes his arm slot, and it doesn’t affect his pitch movement at all. In that scenario, I love the potential of both of the secondary pitches. The slider has a mirrored observed spin direction of that of the heater. The vertical tunnel works as a result and 18.2&quot; of horizontal separation is basically in the sweet spot to get chases as well. He probably wants to be thrown more 83–85 MPH, but it could function like this with glove side location and a more consistent slot.</p><p>The changeup also would be good with a consistent arm slot. He’s still getting 6.2&quot; more fade on the changeup at nearly 10 MPH slower speeds. JP Sears also has exactly twice as much drop on the changeup compared to the fastball. He has a medial release on the fastball too, which will help with drawing chases to the arm side if he adopts the fastball’s arm slot. I think the changeup is less impactful than the slider because he already gets 12.8&quot; of fade to his arm side with the fastball, but it has real potential as well.</p><p>Changing the arm slot without messing up either of the secondaries shapes is a tall ask, which is why Sears is only a 40 FV for the time being. I think JP Sears likely winds up as a multi-inning reliever in a medium leverage role who only faces the lineup once through and throws a lot of fastballs in the process. There is certainly the upside for Sears to be more than that, but he’s probably just a reliever and that is fine. You could do a lot worse with the fourth piece in the return of a Frankie Montas trade.</p><h4>Cooper Bowman</h4><p>Cooper Bowman is the player in this package that confuses me the most. He was a contact first, power not really at all profile at Louisville and the Yankees spent a 4th round pick on him and gave him less than the slot. Then, once he reported to Low A, Bowman started showing some raw power for the first time. He’s moved up to A+ and is striking out a lot more, but is also walking a lot more because he stopped chasing. Bowman is a second baseman, so the value is inherently limited, but I’m very intrigued by the offensive skills he has flashed over the last two years.</p><p>Cooper Bowman’s calling card is un-questionably the on-base skills and that all starts with the ability to make consistent contact. During the 2021 season with Louisville, Bowman made contact 82.5% of the time. That number has steadily decreased as Bowman has climbed the ladder. He was at 79.2% last year and is down again to just 76% this year. That is still an above-average contact rate, but it maybe is a slightly worrying trend line for Bowman.</p><p>Cooper Bowman has made major strides in the plate discipline department this year, which has helped minimize the impact of the decreased contact rates. Cooper Bowman expands the zone just 12.9% of the time on pitches out of the zone. If we assume Bowman is seeing an average amount of pitches in the strike zone, then he has a 64.4% Z-Swing. That would be some of the best plate discipline in the entirety of minor league baseball. Bowman has incredible feel for the strike zone and the value of that can not be understated.</p><p>The raw power is interesting. In college, Bowman swung a noodle with a Max EV of just 106.2 MPH and a 90th EV of just 99.6 MPH. That is not good power. Then in a 72 BBE sample at Low-A after they drafted him, Bowman hit a Max of 108 MPH and saw his 90th EV climb to 103.7 MPH, which would be above the big league average as well. This year he&#39;s kicked it up yet another gear with a 104.1 90th EV. The power has quickly settled in above-average and we have a nearly 300 BBE sample size to verify that fact.</p><p>The game power and general wOBAcon profile are laughably bad, however. Cooper Bowman has forgotten what a barrel is this year and is running a sub 20% sweet-spot rate. He was at 44.3% in Low A last year. He is putting the ball on the ground 50% of the time after sitting at 34% in Low A last year. I do not know what caused the collapse- the only thing that changed was the swing decisions got significantly better. I don’t think it’s likely, but there is a real possibility that the wOBAcons rebound and when paired with his now elite swing decisions, that could be an amazing player.</p><p>Bowman earns a high 40 FV from me, which is about a ~4th round grade, probably. He has some ability in all of contact, approach, and power with limited defensive value. The Athletics will have to figure out how to make the skills line up and fix the terrible BABIP profile that completely collapsed this year, but there is upside. I came into this expecting Cooper Bowman to be a lame throw in but I was blown away. I think he is probably even the second best prospect in the Frankie Montas trade. This isn’t some random throw in but a future big leaguer with everyday upside.</p><h4>Ken Waldichuk</h4><p>Ken Waldichuk has nasty stuff and 53.3% of all his pitches land in the strike zone. That would be in the 92nd percentile of major league arms this year. The zone doesn’t shrink at higher levels, so surely that feel for the zone would translate to plus control, right? Not in the slightest. Ken Waldichuk has walked 10.4% of batters between AA and AAA this year. Why is that? Ken Waldichuk has zero deception, so he gets chases just 23.4% of the time, which would be in the 5th percentile of big leaguers this year. Chases not zone rates are the primary part of avoiding walks, as strange as that may sound.</p><p>Ken Waldichuk has an above-average heater. He sits at 94 MPH on average and can run it up to 98 MPH. The pitch has above-average spin rates and very high spin efficiency on what is likely a ~1:30 spin axis. As a result, Waldichuk gets 16&quot; IVB and 12.2&quot; of tail to his arm side. They throw the pitch from a 5.5&#39; release height so it still has flat VAAs despite slightly below-average ride and he frequently will elevate the pitch. This leads to Waldichuk having a 31.9% whiff rate with the fastball despite using it in the zone over 60% of the time. It’s a deadly pitch against lower-level opponents and still projects as above-average against MLB ones- even if he will probably run into some hard contact.</p><p>Waldichuk’s signature pitch, however, is very much the sweeper that has -3.6&quot; IVB and 16.4&quot; of sweep. That is basically the Matt Brash slider shape, but you trade some velocity for depth as Waldichuk only sits at 81 MPH. The problem with the sweeper is deception, which leads to Waldichuk only running a 32.4% chase rate- even against lower-level competition. That is technically above-average, but given the quality of his competition, it’s not good by any means.</p><p>Waldichuk has 28.6&quot; of horizontal separation between his fastball and sweeper. That is over 1.5x the width of home plate. That is not fooling anyone decent, even if he has excellent control. Waldichuk also has a poor vertical tunnel given the lack of mirrored axis and him possessing nearly three times as much drop with gravity at 13 MPH slower. Waldichuk can land the slider in the zone at a high rate (45.4%) so it works for now, but it won&#39;t translate to the majors.</p><p>We thought Matt Brash’s slider was nasty too. The specs were off the chart- better even than Waldichuk’s. Brash had a walk issue, but he still missed a ton of bats because he got called strikes with the slider in the zone and whiffs as well. That let us overlook the chase issues because low-level hitters are mostly impotent. We’ve seen at the majors that sliders consistently left over the plate get hit hard. We’ve seen that sliders with no deception get zero chases. Waldichuk is in the same boat but it’s a worse slider that he’s building off of with the same problems. There is also a sweeping curveball that is slower, but I think he should only use the curveball for called strikes early in the count.</p><p>The changeup shape is solid too, but again, you have issues relating to deception. Waldichuk slows his arm on the changeup from what I can tell and has a somewhat suspect feel for the pitch as well. As a result, he has below-average chase rates despite good shape. The cambio is thrown only 10% of the time but it has just 4.4&quot; IVB and 16.7&quot; HB. That leaves him with the changeup dropping 22&quot; more at 12.5 MPH slower. It&#39;s easy to see out of the hand because of the poor vertical tunnel. He needs to get more firm with the cambio for it to play as right now it just drops too early. I think the changeup might work off of the fastball down but the fastball would probably perform significantly worse so I don’t considerate it a worthwhile tradeoff.</p><p>I bring up all these deception problems because I think Ken Waldichuk has amazing potential and not because I think he is bad. Waldichuk has incredible shape on three pitches and he has an elite feel for the strike zone. There is big time swing and miss upside here. He just has to make adjustments to his arsenal to let himself perform. You can probably guess that I am about to suggest that Waldichuk adds a cutter. I think that is one option, and probably the best one, but even a vertical drop-oriented gyro sinker would do the job. There is obvious potential here and I think he will be a #4 starter or high leverage relief option long term, but he won’t be one to start strongly in the majors. There is a learning curve here for Waldichuk to reach his upside.</p><h4>Luis Medina</h4><p>The Yankees traded three pitchers in the trade for Frankie Montas. Can you guess which of those three had the lowest minor league whiff rate at the time of the trade? Here’s a helpful hint: I am writing this in the section for a particular arm for a reason. Luis Medina has a reputation of 80 stuff and 30 command. Honestly, I think the stuff is ridiculously over-hyped and not much better than a plus.</p><p>Luis Medina gets up to 103 MPH while sitting at 97 MPH as a starter with the fastball. Most people would consider than an elite pitch and move on. I’ve gotten lazy in the past and done that myself, to my eternal embarrassment. I don’t actually think this fastball is that good of a pitch. The pitch has elite spin rates with Medina sitting just below 2500 RPMs, but it’s inefficient spin and terrible fastball shape due to what is probably 60% spin efficiency.</p><p>As a result, Medina gets just ~14&quot; IVB. Given that this is also comes from a 6.2&#39; vertical release, the heater has no real bat missing ability. He also fails to get significant horizontal action with him sitting at about league average in that regard. It’s a fastball that won’t miss bats and get barreled regularly in the majors. The velocity is nice but it’s not actually enough to overlook his numerous flaws in the shape.</p><p>I will passionately advocate for Medina adopting a cutter as his primary if it’s possible, but I’m not convinced that it is possible. Luis Medina has the same vertical movement on his fastball and comparable velocity to 2019 Corbin Burnes. The spin rates and spin efficiency are extremely similar as well. I would forgive you for thinking Medina can develop the same way, but that really is not remotely realistic. Medina has low spin efficiency because he struggles to get on top of the ball from his arm slot. Burnes has low efficiency because he’s a natural supinator who did so on the fastball and only had to lean into his strengths.</p><p>Luis Medina actually shows very little feel to supinate as is on any of his pitches, and as such, I’m very skeptical he can add a lights-out cutter as Burnes has. The fastball would probably perform best if Medina switched to a two-seam grip and played to weak contact. There is risk in that though, as you would likely wreck the tunnel with Medina’s best pitch in the curveball. I think the best approach for Medina is to lean into the zero efficiency motif and develop a bowling-ball-esque one-seam fastball that sinks like a rock with elite velocity. The pitch would miss no bats but should get weak contact and would likely let the secondaries play up.</p><p>Luis Medina’s curveball is ridiculous and despite him literally throwing 103 MPH, it’s unquestionably the best pitch that Medina throws. The curveball sits at ~82 MPH with ~-13&quot; IVB. That is elite depth on a high release curve that has limited side spin and good velocity. He has a mirrored spin axis from the current heater and actually gets chases at a healthy rate even if it’s his only pitch that does so. The shape is superb and if Medina could throw his curve for a strike with any consistency, then he could have an elite one.</p><p>The changeup has decent shape. He sits at 90 MPH on most changeups, which is maybe too much power behind it, but the fastball is hard enough to work off of that. Medina gets ~6&quot; IVB on the cambio and 14.5&quot; of horizontal movement. That is double the horizontal movement of the four-seamer with over twice as much drop.</p><p>I think there is some risk with this pitch in switching to the bowling ball I want the primary to be. The changeup depth is not much more than where I want the one-seam to be and I’m slightly concerned that the run difference won’t be pronounced anywhere near enough for the changeup to function. He would likely need to drastically reduce CH speed for it to work in the slightest off of a bowling ball. I still think the one-seam fastball is the best approach for Medina but it’s not a perfect one by any means.</p><p>The control is poor. This is in part because of limited chase rates off of everything but the curveball which is still mostly average. Medina frequently misses his spots badly and buries completely unappealing pitches in the dirt or over by the backstop. Medina technically finds the zone 49.8% of the time but don’t delude yourself into thinking he has any semblance of control. Luis Medina falls off to his glove side and will frequently miss his spots on both sides of the plate. He has major walk problems and I really doubt that they will go away. Luis Medina is destined for the bullpen in any realistic scenario, with only one currently impactful pitch, even if the second one has elite upside as well and the third is solid enough. There is lofty upside, but the odds that everything clicks are really not that high.</p><h3>The Baltimore Orioles trade Trey Mancini to the Houston Astros; The Tampa Bay Rays trade Seth Johnson to the Baltimore Orioles and Jayden Murray to the Houston Astros; The Houston Astros trade Jose Siri to the Tampa Bay Rays and Chayce McDermott to the Baltimore Orioles</h3><h4>Seth Johnson</h4><p>Seth Johnson would have unquestionably been on my top 100 last year if I had his pitch data at the time. If he was healthy, he would be on my top 100 next year. Seth Johnson needs Tommy John surgery, however. Usually, I am mostly unbothered by that need, but Seth Johnson is the exception and his injury actually has me bumping him all the way down to a 45 FV and giving serious consideration to knocking him even further. Allow me to explain why Tommy John is especially irksome for Johnson in particular.</p><p>Seth Johnson will turn 24 this year and has to be added to the 40 Man roster this offseason. Tommy John surgery will completely wipe out Johnson’s age 24 season and he won’t return to the mound until he is 25. Most Tommy John returnees take time to build up. Considering the fact that Johnson has a grand total of 27 innings in High-A and nothing above that, I think it’s fairly reasonable to expect that Johnson cannot make it out of AA by the end of 2024. This means Johnson probably won’t debut in the majors until he is close to his 27th birthday. Johnson losing a year means he really doesn’t have the time to find his footing if he stumbles at all.</p><p>There is also the fact that Seth Johnson is Rule 5 eligible this offseason and that throws a wrench into his development and rehab plan. He will need to be added to the 40 man this offseason because if he’s not, it’s a guarantee he’s drafted and stashed for a year by a lousy team. If he is not debuting until 2025, then you are using a 40 man spot on Johnson for three offseasons before he ever steps on an MLB mound. That is a tall ask when contenders have to prioritize flexibility.</p><p>There is also the service time element in play here. Seth Johnson won’t put at all in 2023. The Orioles will have the choice to put him on the 60 Day IL and open up a spot on the 40 man roster but accrue a full year of MLB service time and push Johnson a year closer to Free Agency. The alternative is to option Seth Johnson to the minors, avoid service time but have him leeching a 40 man spot for the entire regular season. Most teams would choose the first option- especially if they hope to compete.</p><p>Teams are constantly designating players for assignments to clear 40 man spots within the season. Let’s say Johnson comes back in 2024 and his stuff is down in his first few games back from the operation. How long does it take for Johnson’s head to be the one on the chopping block? He might not have broken, but any misstep could lead to Johnson joining a different team after having provided negative value to the Orioles. The Orioles valuing Johnson as a 45 FV like I do would be poor management on their part because of the complications surrounding his likelihood to play for the Orioles.</p><p>There is also the same possibility on the other end. Seth Johnson could have everything break right and make it to the majors in 2025. If he struggles in the majors after already burning a year of service in 2023, he only has two years to impress before the then 29-year-old would be at risk of a non-tender to save a few bucks. I really do think Seth Johnson has amazing upside on the mound as I’ll go into detail on in a minute, but there is a very narrow path to Johnson providing significant value as a member of the Baltimore Orioles.</p><p>Seth Johnson has incredible stuff, however. The fastball in particular is pretty much unhittable. Johnson throws his heater at 95.4 MPH on average and can reach back for 98 MPH when he needs it. The fastball is coming from an over the top arm slot with a -0.8&#39; horizontal release and a 6&#39; vertical release. He gets elite carry on his heater with 19.9&quot; of ride on average. I think that number will probably only get better if Johnson returns healthy as he has spin rates over 2500 RPMs and nothing about the stuff or arm slot suggests the spin efficiency can’t get better. This could be a truly elite fastball.</p><p>The slider isn’t much worse than the heater. The pitch sits at 84 MPH with above-average depth and some sweep to it. -2&quot; IVB and 7&quot; of sweep isn’t anything outlandish on its own but it’s from an outlier medial release and he throws it in the zone regularly. The pitch has elite xwOBAs along with a 50% whiff rate and a 34% chase rate.</p><p>Outlier release? Really? -0.8&#39; horizontal release isn’t exactly common, but it’s not that unusual for a player with his arm slot. Except, trackman uses inverted directional inputs from what you see on Hawkeye. On Trackman, a +0.8&#39; horizontal release point is a coming from a pitcher standing closer to the third base side. With Hawkeye, it’s the first base side. The slider is at -7.1&quot; HB, the fastball is at +9.6&#39; HB. As you can see, if Johnson was throwing from a normal narrow release, he would be at +0.8&#39;, not -0.8&#39;. Seth Johnson is essentially turning himself into a lefty because he hugs the first first base side of the rubber. There is no right-handed pitcher with a horizontal release point less than -0.1&#39; in the majors this year. That one pitcher who is below 0&#39; is James Karinchak at -0.1&#39;. Seth Johnson’s release point is completely unheard of and it gives him completely unique horizontal approach angles that there is no parallels to.</p><p>The fastball and slider are also almost perfect tunnels with each other on top of having already good shape and both pitches boasting impressive results. The slider and fastball have 16.7&quot; of horizontal separation between them, and home plate is 17&quot; wide. The vertical tunnel is solid enough with 31&quot; more drop on an 11 MPH velocity split.</p><p>As long as Johnson is using his fastball way up (Where it plays best)and to the arm side then the slider down and on the glove side (Best place in a vacuum for it as well) corner is completely indecipherable and as a result, both would get chases at some of the best rates in all of baseball. The fastball too often is working on his glove side right now, which neuters the average pitch, but if he can improve his command, then it’s a genuinely unhittable pairing at any level.</p><p>Seth Johnson also throws a curveball that has some promise but probably only grades out as average. The curve sits at 77 MPH with spin rates that are just a hair over 2900 RPMs. The hook has -14&quot; IVB and 11.4&quot; of sweep. In a vacuum, it is a solid pitch, but it gets no chases (19%) because it doesn’t synergize with the rest of Seth’s arsenal. Except it is still a solid pitch because Seth Johnson lands his curveball in the strike zone 47.5% of the time and steals a lot of called strikes that way.</p><p>Seth Johnson has solid average control that I would sooner push higher than I would lower. He finds the zone at an above-average rate with all three pitches and more importantly, has elite chase potential with two of them. His precision could use some work and that is what they need for the stuff to play up further and really start limiting walks, but Johnson has the potential to get there. I like the delivery and he’s a superb athlete for whatever it is worth.</p><p>Seth Johnson threw zero changeups in 2022 before getting hurt. That was only a 27 inning sample size, but that’s not nothing either. He uses the FB/SL just over 85% of the time, with the rest of his pitches being a floating curve he can’t really afford to use too much without it likely getting tattooed. All of that screams that Johnson should wind up in the bullpen.</p><p>If he was healthy, I would disagree. Seth Johnson has a left-handed release point, and that left-handed release point lets his pitches play against lefties. Johnson missed more bats against lefties last year actually and I don’t think that’s entirely a fluke. Seth Johnson’s fastball gets more chases to his arm side against lefties because of his very medial and slightly lefty release. He gets fewer chases with his secondary of choice but it balances out to fairly even splits.</p><p>I would continue to pitch to the glove side with the slider just as he does against righties, in part to maintain the elite tunneling ability. He can catch the inner edge of the plate somewhat consistently for called strikes and still will get some swings running at the hitter below the zone. I think Johnson is more neutral split than reverse, but he actually can beat left-handed hitters, even if things look a wee bit unconventional in the process.</p><p>Tommy John means that Seth Johnson is going to wind up in the bullpen despite the lack of platoon risk, however. If the Orioles&#39; goal is to maximize what Seth Johnson does for Baltimore and the alone, the best approach is almost certainly to stick him in the bullpen and fast-track him to the major leagues. He will make an impact in some capacity with this role and you can theoretically stretch him back out to start if you really want to. I also think he would be an elite late-inning weapon if he winds up in the bullpen.</p><p>If you are valuing Seth Johnson as a pure reliever, which is how most teams probably should be at this point, then he is no better than a 40 FV with a lot of variance for unusual reasons. The upside is huge, but the likelihood is that he actively hurts you. If I’m looking at this from the perspective of just players potential, then Johnson probably belongs in the 50 FV tier even after Tommy John. He might not provide a ton of surplus value but the upside is still immense, and he’s still a very likely MLB arm at some point. I opted to split the difference between the two perspectives, but I like Johnson so much more than any grades I can assign. The upside is huge but the risk management is too complicated for him to have much value to MLB teams by this point.</p><h4>Jayden Murray</h4><p>Jayden Murray is a very difficult player to get detailed information on. Based on film looks and what I’ve read, I believe Murray uses a sinker/slider pairing primarily. There is also a changeup with some promise but I definetly prefer the other two pitches. Murray throws strikes at a high rate and gets groundballs. He has yet to miss a ton of bats but could be a valuable depth starter for as long as he has minor league options.</p><p>Jayden Murray sits 92-95 MPH with the sinker that has some tail and good depth. The slider appears to effectively work off of it towards his glove side with what is mostly gyro spin in the low eighties. His tunnel is fine, and he completely dominates fellow right-handed hitters. There are actually a lot more whiffs against lefties though, which doesn’t make a ton of sense and suggests I’m maybe underrating the changeup. I don’t love what I see, but there’s definitely an MLB arm in here. Hopefully, the Astros assign him to AAA so we can have pitch data on his stuff heading into the offseason.</p><h4>Chayce McDermott</h4><p>The other piece going to the Orioles is Chayce McDermott, and this one is actually coming from the team they traded Mancini to. Chayce McDermott throws three pitches that grade out highly but has issues with getting batters to expand the zone on top of an existing struggle to find the strike zone.</p><p>The fastball is a plus pitch. McDermott sits at 94.3 MPH and touches as high as 97 MPH from the right-handed side. The heater has plus carry as well with 19&quot; IVB from a 5.9&#39; release height and a 1.5&#39; horizontal release. The pitch has elite whiff rates despite McDermott only throwing his fastball at ~2.7 PlateZ as McDermott is at 34.1% whiffs right now. That is an elite rate and not just a byproduct of his weaker competition right now.</p><p>The current fastball usage is a problem, and it’s the primary reason that McDermott allows so much hard contact. I don’t think the bad pitch usage is necessarily the fault of his former team but just circumstance. He frequently throws the fastball down the dick and for a while, this was the correct approach, as strange as that may sound at first glance.</p><p>Guys like Tony Gonsolin and Tyler Anderson use the cement mixer fastball down the middle to enhance the tunnels of their other pitches and let the occasionally elevated four-seamer play up beyond what it would if he sat there. The problem is that McDermott’s no longer a fit as a cement mixer. He has added sweep to the slider and velocity to the curveball since the draft which completely alters the way his pitches play. I know want to see McDermott up and in regardless of the opponent’s handedness.</p><p>The slider is a plus pitch as well. He sits at 83.8 MPH with spin rates of nearly 2800 RPMs. The pitch has above-average depth with just over 0&quot; IVB and is now up to 8&quot; of sweep. The tunnel is actually mostly effective off of the high and inside fastball as long as McDermott works off the down and outside corner against right-handed hitters. This is in part due to 15.4&quot; of horizontal separation. The shape is good with impact velocity and deception. The breaking ball command is better than it feels and I do think that despite only 55 grade chase rates on the slider so far, McDermott can decimate righties with that two pitch combo.</p><p>Lefties are a lot harder for McDermott to face and emerge victorious. There is potential for him to be solid but there is aways some risk that he winds up in the bullpen because the arsenal probably isn’t equipped to adequately counter OHB. McDermott should use his fastball up and in — even on the glove side, as that is both where it gets the most whiffs and where he locates to set up his secondaries.</p><p>The changeup is not a good pitch for McDermott. He throws it in the strike zone at a low rate and doesn’t get chases with his current utilization. The feel is poor, and the shape isn’t great either, with 10.8&quot; IVB and 12.4&quot; HB at 86.6 MPH. The changeup probably needs to develop at least a little for McDermott to actually be viable against lefties. I don’t actually think he’s much more than an improved feel and location away from being good though. The horizontal separation is not great, but it plays up because of the medial release and if he’s locating the fastball in and the changeup away, I think you can manufacture a semi-effective tunnel.</p><p>The curveball has some utility, but the 36% zone rate makes it somewhat difficult to really buy in on. He gets good depth on the pitch with -13.4&quot; IVB and also has 11 inches of sweep. 78.4 MPH is even respectable velocity. The problem is that he can’t land the curve for called strikes with any consistency on top of already getting very few chases with his current usage. However, I think that can change. McDermott should be able to get at least a few chases with the curveball below the zone if he’s locating the fastball in on hitters and the curve middle down. The only way the curve will truly be effective, though, is if his control over it improves. Even if it means subtracting movement, landing for a strike is tantamount to McDermott’s success as a starting pitcher.</p><p>Chayce McDermott is probably destined for a bullpen with his present day platoon issues. There is a road to success against OHB, but it’s a narrow path that is filled with snares. I think McDermott can be an elite righty specialist with the FF/SL combo, but the value of such a limited player is well- limited. Due to those limitations, I only have a 40 FV on McDermott, even with elite stuff. The potential is here for him to take off though and the Orioles development team will certainly enjoy working with him.</p><h3>The Boston Red Sox trade Christian Vázquez to the Houston Astros for Wilyer Abreu and Enmanuel Valdez</h3><h4>Wilyer Abreu</h4><p>Wilyer Abreu is a stud in the making. He offers both power and an elite approach with the likely ability to run high BABIPs as well. His defense draws mixed reviews but Wilyer is a plus athlete with a solid average arm and he has graded out highly statistically in centerfield as he’s logged +7 Davenport Runs in centerfield this year after posting +7 in RF last year. I don’t think that’s a great way to measure defense, but he’s a plus runner who is performing based on crude metrics. As such, I think it’s fairly reasonable to call Wilyer a 45 grade defender in centerfield.</p><p>Wilyer Abreu’s bat is obviously the chief attraction and the most appealing element there is his approach. Ethan’s model estimates that Wilyer Abreu expands the strike zone on just 16.6% of out of zone pitches and still manages to swing at 66.3% of strikes. Those figures rank in the 97th percentile of chase rate and the 29th percentile of zone-swing rate. He is making some of the best swing decisions in the entire minors and has led to ridiculous walk rates and manageable strikeout rates. Those will fall some as he climbs the ladder, but Abreu’s ability to lay off of even tough lefty sliders is enviable.</p><p>Wilyer Abreu’s contact skills leave a bit more to be desired, but I will note that his contact rate is up almost 5% this year with him moving from A+ to AA. The problem for Abreu is primarily the high fastball. This is partially because of the shape of Abreu’s swing. Wilyer has a very steep VBA and lacks the flexibility to get the barrel up in the zone. As a result, he often swings through the high fastball and it’s only going to get worse as he climbs the ladder. Wilyer has the plate discipline to work around it as he rarely chases the high heat, but there are in-zone whiffs against velocity and that creates a substantial hit tool risk for Abreu.</p><p>The raw power is above-average from what I can tell. Wilyer is a rotational player with solid bat speed and a muscular frame. He hits the ball with authority- particularly to his pull side and does so with some consistency. He also hits a lot of balls in the air with a groundball rate of just 30.I have one apple.% in AA with the Astros. He is running a 105.6 MPH 90th percentile exit velocity this year; per source which is well above the MLB average. His .447 xwOBAcon is fantastic as well. Wilyer is older than his average opponent, but he can really hit.</p><p>I like Wilyer Abreu’s BABIP skills even if the results haven’t been there. Abreu has a 94th percentile line drive rate this year which is among the best in the league. He was less impressive in the past but still comfortably above-average and I think I buy in on the barrel accuracy improvements being sustainable anyway as it’s born of newly found immaculate swing decisions. Abreu also only has average popup rates despite some of the highest flyball rates in the minors. He hits too many flyballs to be an elite BABIP guy, but they should be average to slightly above with a healthy amount of dingers.</p><p>If I’m forcing myself to be realistic, Wilyer Abreu is a low-end platoon option on the strong side. He could start on a poor team without killing you, but even with fairly balanced splits, he’s going to be most impactful in a platoon role, where his exposure to high and inside fastballs is limited. If his manager is a chad, the Red Sox will deploy him as a pseudo platoon against non-four-seam fastball pitchers but they likely won’t do that. Being realistic is boring, however, Abreu is a high-variance bat who should be above average at generating all three true outcomes- even the bad ones. There is a road to a good hitter here, but there’s some hit risk that makes it a distant dream for the time being.</p><h4>Enmanuel Valdez</h4><p>Enmanuel Valdez has posted a 161 PF wRC+ between AA and AAA this year. He’s in the 97th percentile of wOBA and his sourced xwOBA is only 0.005 lower. Valdez isn’t a spring chicken, but he’s still just 23 and is hitting. I do not know if the production is sustainable or not. If forced to choose, I might actually lean towards it kind of being so?</p><p>Enmanuel Valdez has fairly major hit tool risk. His swing mechanics are weird and he’s only running a 75% contact rate between AA and AA this year. Both high fastball and same handed sliders in his brief stint at AAA have exposed him. However, he was superb against both in AA this year- albeit after having some exposure to AA last year. Enmanuel has a whole has above-average chase rates with average in-zone contact rates this year. I think that will drop some in the majors, but I don’t think it’s going to collapse entirely.</p><p>Enmanuel Valdez also is showcasing above-average raw power this year. He has a 90th percentile exit velocity of 104.2 MPH between AA and AAA this year. That is down to just 102.1 MPH when you look at just AAA though which might present a red flag. The power plays in games due to barrel accuracy, but there’s still risk in the tool. The BABIP skills are the best part of Enmanuel Valdez. He is a truly elite BABIP guy with an exceptional feel for the barrel and that ability to square balls up is why I mostly buy in on the hit and power tool from Valdez both.</p><p>However, there is some risk in the bat, and I think Valdez probably winds up on the strong side of a platoon role. He has very extreme splits this year, and it makes sense given his struggles with the slider. Usually, the strong side of a platoon could earn a 45 FV, but Valdez isn’t much of a defender. He’s a 35 2B from what I’ve heard, who some scouts are projecting over to LF/1B. The bat has very real potential, but he has to hit to play and there’s risk. That puts him in the low 40 FV range for me, but I understand why one might rank him higher.</p><h3>The Pittsburgh Pirates Trade José Quintana and Chris Stratton to the St. Louis Cardinals for Johan Oviedo and Malcom Nuñez</h3><p>For the record, I think Johan Oviedo is the better piece of this return and that’s not meant to be a knock on Nuñez at all. Malcom Nuñez slots in near the middle of the 40 FV tier. He’s a first baseman who is likely defensively challenged but can really hit. It might not feel like that right now, given that it’s only a 104 PF wRC+ this year, but the upside is there, even if there is work to be done.</p><p>The contact skills are fine. Nuñez is at a 74% contact rate in his second stint of AA play, which is about where he was in his first stint. I like the bat path just fine, but I worry that the lack of athleticism kills his ability to adjust to pitch location and go down and get breaking balls. The hit risk is still there even if he’s technically running above-average contact rates.</p><p>The way for a relatively poor athlete to get on-base is often not through making contact but making elite swing decisions. Nuñez has cut his swing rate by a little over 8% this year. Ethan’s model now estimates that Nuñez is chasing just 21.6% of the time while swinging at 63.8% of strikes. The improved plate discipline helps clear a role for Nunez to provide an impact bat at the major league level. I won’t really buy in on the gains entirely until he shows the same improved approach in AAA, so we know it’s not just an experience thing, but it is incredibly encouraging to see out of him.</p><p>The power is why the Pirates coveted Nuñez, though. Malcom Nuñez has plus-plus raw punch in his sturdy frame and aggressive cut. He constantly hammers the ball and has hit a ball 114 MPH+ before. The exit velocities are consistently loud (I was told he averaged 91 MPH last year). There is not any projection left in the frame, so what you see is what you get. Then again, does anyone actually care when it’s already elite raw power?</p><p>The problem is that the power isn’t at all manifested in games right now. Malcom Baty is hitting 49.6% of his batted balls on the ground and is both failing to hit line drives and home runs as a result. He is a pull heavy groundball hitter who gets eaten by the shift. Nuñez has a 25.4% HR/FB rate. That is in the 97th percentile of minor leaguers. There is elite offensive potential here, but he likely will need a swing change to hit the ball at more optimal angles. Given the limited defensive value as a first baseman and the need for a swing change, Nuñez only lands in the 40 FV tier despite the elite offensive upside. I will note that Nuñez is only 21, so there is plenty of time for him to make the needed adjustments.</p><h3>The Texas Rangers trade Matt Bush to the Milwaukee Brewers for Antoine Kelly and Mark Mathias</h3><h4>Antoine Kelly</h4><p>Antoine Kelly has big time stuff and most people in the game agree that his stuff can get even better still with proper pitching development. There are only two pitches here and the command is not remotely good. This is likely almost exclusively because the sinker and slider don’t tunnel. Antoine Kelly actually finds the strike zone at a higher rate than the average minor leaguer. I think because of those problems; it is probably destined that Antoine Kelly winds up in the bullpen. However, it is far from a lock as with one simple tweak, Kelly could find new life in his hopes of starting games at the big league level. With a few more tweaks, he might become a front of the rotation option.</p><p>The fastball currently sits 93–95 MPH most nights in his first full season back from shoulder surgery. He’s been sitting there as a starting pitcher and you’d have to imagine that if Kelly finds his way into a bullpen, it would tick up even further. I’ve also talked to people in the industry who think with some adjustments he could sit closer to his current max of 98 MPH. The mechanics aren’t efficient enough according to someone with a team’s player development department and they think with improved mobility he’ll be able to live around 98–100 MPH. I haven’t seen where those tweaks are coming from, but I trust the person telling me they are there.</p><p>The sinker is a fairly uninspiring pitch in terms of shape. Kelly sits at just 9.5&quot; IVB and 12.2&quot; HB on average. The angle is good, coming from a 5.2&#39; vertical release and a ~2.5&#39; horizontal release, but that’s all it really has going for it right now. Oh, and the plus velocity that supposedly can become elite. I‘ve seen some people suggest Kelly try to add vertical movement and use a four-seam variant because of his release height. I actually disagree. First, I don’t think that’s possible; but second, I think the sinker has a better interaction with his only other pitch in the idealizer version of Antoine Kelly. I don’t think the sinker is more than a 55 grade pitch in a vacuum, but it’s a good enough piece that could play better with some adjustments.</p><p>The slider is dirty. He throws it 83–86 MPH with high spin rates and nasty break. The slider averages ~15&quot; of sweep to his glove side and he will frequently locate it there where it plays best. I believe he is using the same two-seam fastball grip as he does with the sinker, but it doesn’t actually have the usual sweeper depth; instead, Antoine Kelly gets just ~4&quot; IVB on average.</p><p>Can you guess the problem with the slider? It’s the same thing that’s wrong with the command! That’s right! The problem is a lack of deception! Antoine Kelly has over 27&quot; of horizontal movement separating his slider from his sinker. That is way too much horizontal separation for him to elicit any chases at the big league level; heck, it’s only a 43rd percentile chase rate against High-A+ hitters who are not very good.</p><p>There is a very simple solution to how to fix his lack of chases. Kelly simply needs to add a cutter to split the distance between both the sinker and slider in half. This is easy even easy for Kelly than most because Kelly is already naturally supinating on the fastball and slider. It should just be a simple grip change that sees Kelly get cut on his fastballs. Assuming he can maintain close to the same velocity as the fastball, the arsenal could be incredible around a cutter primary.</p><p>If Antoine Kelly adds a cutter, then he probably looks like a starting pitching option. The slider and sinker would both play up and he would start getting chases off of them. That would lower the walk rates considerably. The cutter developing would also give Kelly a third viable pitch in his arsenal. He might still have some trouble putting away tough lefites, but there is real upside against them as well. I think Kelly might be more likely to wind up in the bullpen, but he earns a low 45 FV because of his upside as a starting pitcher.</p><h3>The Detroit Tigers trade Robbie Grossman to the Atlanta Braves for Kris Anglin</h3><h4>Kris Anglin</h4><p>Kris Anglin is a project, but there is a scenario where the Tigers improve his conditioning and the velocity takes off. He is 5&#39;11&quot; and will have to add a lot of velocity, though, to reach that outcome, as he only sits 87–89 MPH. The fastball has above-average ride from a low release given his height but it will not play without more velocity.</p><p>The curveball is poor in the mid-seventies. It’s a loopy breaker that gets almost no chases out of the zone. As a whole, Anglin struggles to get chases while also struggling to zone both his pitches. Predictably, that leads to high walk rates. There is some upside, given the fastball shape, but he’s only a 30 FV reliever for the time being.</p><h3>The Baltimore Orioles trade Jorge López to the Minnesota Twins for Cade Povich, Yennier Canó, Juan Nuñez, and Juan Rojas</h3><h4>Cade Povich</h4><p>Cade Povich has broken out since the Twins spent a third-round pick on him last year. He is now striking out 33.7% of hitters in his pro career and that is top ten in the minors in K-BB% over the last two years by players as young as Povich with 90+ innings. The stuff has improved since his college days and I’ve heard it has improved more since last year but I only have the data from last year so that’s what I constructed this report around.</p><p>Cade Povich has what at first glance appears to be an uninspiring fastball. Povich used a hybrid two-seamer after the draft last year with ~15&quot; IVB and 14&quot; of tail. He sits at 93 MPH and touches as high as 96 MPH from what I understand. I think Povich is probably best off using his fastball over the heart of the plate against right-handed bats as it would better set up his secondaries. If Povich uses the fastball with generic shape and traits over the plate, he will probably give up quality contact with it. The horizontal and tunnels will limit barrels somewhat, but there will be some rockets. I think the benefits for the strikeout and walk rates easily outweigh those negatives though.</p><p>Cade Povich throws a cutter. He didn’t use it much with the Twins, but in his first start with the Orioles he really showed it off. Povich sat 86–88 MPH with his cutter in his first start as an Oriole. I don’t have the movement data for the cutter, but for the sake of simplicity, let’s presume that Povich has the movement profile of the average LHP cutter in the majors. That would give Povich the perfect movement profile for the rest of his arsenal to mesh splendidly.</p><p>The changeup is a very interesting pitch. He averaged 83.9 MPH on it last year, which gives him 9 MPH of separation from the fastball. He had a very generic movement profile too with just 10&quot; IVB and 15&quot; of horizontal movement. That pitch might bleed into the fastball some and can lead to the whiff rates of both pitches playing down. Enter the living miracle, his cutter.</p><p>Cade Povich with the addition of a cutter with league average movement would have the perfect pitch tunnels off of all three of his pitches. Let’s start with the weaker one. The cutter sets up the fastball incredibly well. He throws the cutter roughly 6 MPH slower with what an average cutter would make into ~16&quot; of horizontal separation and 12&quot; more drop with gravity. They likely come from the same release without a ton of vertical separation and spit the plate vertically. The cutter on the bottom right corner of the plate should play really well off of the arm side fastball, about a foot higher on average.</p><p>This helps set up a changeup/fastball tunnel as well as it bridges the velocity gap and opens up the possibility that the lower pitch is a cutter rather than a changeup every time. It’s not the most practical application of the pitch by any means, but it helps with that tunnel ever so slightly as well. I’d like to see him work the changeup on the bottom left corner of the plate to perfect the vertical tunnel off the fastball while keeping the cutter intact.</p><p>The real draw of the cutter though is what would be an immaculate cutter/changeup tunnel with average movement from the cutter. If his cutter has average movement, he has the exact same vertical drop at 28&quot; on average with an 87 MPH cutter as he does on the 84 MPH changeup. That vertical movement is exactly identical and to top it off, Cade Povich has the perfect horizontal tunnel with 17&quot; separating the two pitches laterally. If he’s locating decently on opposing sides of the plate, then he is completely unhittable.</p><p>The movement profiles aren’t the same so it’s not really comparable, but Erik Swanson throws his slider/splitter with comparable separation velocity and horizontal movement wise. He also has almost no variation in drop between the two pitches. This allows his slider that is on paper a 45 grade pitch on stuff (Pitching bot) to have the 8th highest slider chase rate with a minimum of 100 pitches (320 qualifiers). Erik Swanson actually uses all three of his pitches about a half foot higher than I’m advocating Povich throws his pitches and that might be the correct approach as it gives the fastball more viability, even if it means the secondaries are at more danger of missed spots and hard contact as a result.</p><p>On top of the already brilliant FB/FC/CH pairing, Cade Povich has two other breaking balls. The sweeper was his primary pitch in Minnesota from what I understand. I think it is his worst pitch as it sits in the 79–82 MPH range with just 10&quot; of sweep and 0&quot; IVB last year. The problem is that it doesn’t work off of any of his other pitches except the cutter. Actually, I suppose it’s a better fit for his secondary weapon off the cutter against fellow lefties where the changeup isn’t that viable. He can also mix in the 76 MPH curve with ~-10&quot; IVB on occasion below the zone against lefties. I don’t think either pure breaking ball is any better than average but they could have a useful niche in his arsenal.</p><p>The icing on the cake for the future top 100 prospect, Cade Povich is that he is regularly filling the zone. Povich throws a little over 53% of his pitches over the plate. He has an easy delivery that he repeats and an athletic build. He’s going to throw strikes and is already running above-average chase rates. As he leans more on the cutter he should get even more chases. There is a complete arsenal here that can beat batters of both handedness. There is command, and there is stamina. Povich is a fairly safe #4/5 starter with serious upside. It’s only a 45 FV until I get information on the cutter movement profile but I really like the arm talent here.</p><h4>Juan Nuñez/Juan Rojas</h4><p>Believe me when I say I would love literally nothing more than to not have wasted two hours of my life searching for data and have data on Juan Nuñez and Juan Rojas to share with you. Instead, I spent two hours searching twitter and reading articles to come away without even knowing how hard they throw.</p><p>Here is what I do know. Juan Nuñez is dominating the FCL to the tune of a 36.4% strikeout rate and a 7% walk rate. He is 5&#39;11&quot; so I would imagine the release height is fairly low. 55% of Nuñez’s pitches are in the zone per a source. He has a below-average chase rate but plus in-zone whiff rates. He is in the 73rd percentile of minor league xERA. It’s rookie ball, so I don’t really think any of these matter all that much.</p><p>Juan Rojas is also a short king at only 6&#39;0&quot;. He is a very skinny kid with room to add considerable strength as he grows into his frame. I would also imagine that the left-handed Rojas has a low release height. Unlike Nuñez, Juan Rojas has plus chase rates. Also, unlike Nuñez, Rojas has below-average zone rates and average whiff rates in the zone. Juan Rojas is technically the better of the two statistically as the 18-year-old is in the 90th percentile of xERA- even if he misses fewer bats. Both are probably upside plays but I couldn’t tell you how high or how realistic reaching their upside is.</p><p><a href="https://blogs.fangraphs.com/ranking-the-prospects-traded-during-the-2022-deadline/">Eric Longenhagen at FanGraphs has given us one sentence on both of them</a> that allows some insight into what they are. Nuñez sits in the low nineties with elite spin rates and ride. Rojas is in the upper eighties with vertical shape. I still don’t know anywhere near enough to grade them or this trade.</p><h3>The San Diego Padres trade James Wood, Jarlin Susana, Robert Hassell III, CJ Abrams, and Luke Voit to the Washington Nationals for Juan Soto and Josh Bell</h3><h4>James Wood</h4><p>Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. James Wood is so good he gets his own blog.</p><h4>Jarlin Susana</h4><p>Jarlin Susana is the wild card in this trade. He is a long way from the majors and is part of a risky demographic as a much larger flamethrower with only two pitches. However, the upside is incredibly high on the mound. He has completely decimated the complex league to the tune of a 39.6% strikeout rate and a 95th percentile xERA.</p><p>Jarlin Susana is throwing 102 MPH as an 18-year-old. The list of players to do that is basically just Tyler Kolek, Riley Pint, Daniel Espino, Hunter Greene, and Chase Petty. That is special velocity for a kid this age. He has feel to spin the ball as well. I have to dump some iced water on Nationals fans (Do they still have any?) building excitement. Jarlin Susana has a fastball shape that was described to me as terrible. I don’t have the specs but I can’t call this an elite fastball even with the velocity if he has an awful shape.</p><p>The slider is insane. He is throwing it above 90 MPH with some consistency. The pitch has a 68% whiff rate in rookie ball this year. I have confirmation that this isn’t a deGrom calling the slider a cutter but an actual slider even if it’’s more of a gyro one than a sweeper. I have no clue what Susana’s tunnels are like. Regardless of if they exist or not, it’s a 93rd percentile chase rate in rookie ball.</p><p>The control is fringe in terms of finding the zone, but if you get chases, then you’ll avoid walks at the major league level. There is risk in the profile given that Susana only throws two pitches and has a heavyset build with velocity you never see from this kind of body. The mechanics will require some maintenance and his conditioning will probably need to be top-notch. However, you can’t teach a 90 MPH slider and that along with a 102 MPH fastball is enough to earn Susana a very high 40 FV.</p><h4>Robert Hassell III</h4><p>Throughout the trade deadline, I was live tweeting a quick synopsis of all the top prospects traded. I made a comment in the one about Robert Hassell that said he has plus top-end EVs. My DMs instantly blew up with three separate sources with data access, calling me out for the misinformation and informing me that Hassell does not have good EVs. I was told that last year in my defense, but I should have realized my obvious folly given how little sense it made.</p><p>Robert Hassell III does not have plus top-end EVs. He has below-average ones. His Max EV in pro-ball has been 106 MPH and all of his readings above 105 MPH have been at a negative launch angle. Robert Hassell has 40 grade effective raw power, and it’s down from his prep days considerably. On top of that, Hassell has a groundball rate over 50% and never pulls the ball with more contact driven weakly the other way than to his pullside where he has to go for the power to play. The gap power hasn’t even been there this year with poor sweet-spot rates as well.</p><p>The appeal of Robert Hassell is strictly his ability to get on-base. Robert Hassell has above-average contact rates with him connecting on 77% of his swings this year. The swing is still incredibly appealing with a direct path that should let him continue to make contact at the higher levels, but how far can that go? Hassell hits spin and hits velocity, but there are still whiffs.</p><p>Hassell is not expanding the zone as a 15.9% chase rate this year can testify too, but he is still whiffing more than you would like in the zone. Why? I think it might be a problem with the inside pitch due to how early his optimal connection point is. This would explain why he has struggled so much against lefties this year to an extent. I think the issues are probably fixable and he’ll eventually be a plus hitter with a superb approach, but that is not a guarantee.</p><p>The BABIP profile is probably good, but even if it is, it’s probably not actually a good thing. Robert Hassell has a flat swing that produces very few mishit balls but also very few well hit ones, and very little flyballs. This causes the power to play down considerably. The other draw of the BABIP profile is the ability to pepper to ball to all fields and “hit it where they ain’t.” That also has a negative effect on the power output.</p><p>This is the problem with Robert Hassell. His problems don’t have an easy fix like start doing steroids and add 4 MPH to his EVs. That would help but it wouldn’t make him into a star because it would likely not play in games because of his inability to elevate or pull the ball. The hit tool will play for now but any adjustments to get to more power jeopardizes the sanctity of the hit tool.</p><p>Robert Hassell III still warrants inclusion at the back-end of the 55 FV tier even if he has fallen with the proper EV numbers. Hassell III is an above-average option in centerfield with plus athleticism. Hassell also has above-average offensive potential on the strength of the hit tool. There is more risk in Hassell than most people would admit, but the upside is still there and he looks like a solid average regular.</p><h3>The Miami Marlins trade Anthony Bass and Zach Pop to the Toronto Blue Jays for Jordan Groshans</h3><h4>Jordan Groshans</h4><p>Trying to wrap your head around whatever Jordan Groshans has become is an exercise in futility. He has completely forgotten what power is after he profiled as power over hit during his high school days. I had Groshans as a top 100 prospect entering the season, but with his regression back to 20-grade power, he’s not anywhere near making next year’s list.</p><p>Jordan Groshans has a .292 slugging this year. I shouldn’t have to explain to you how bad that is. I have a good new for Marlins fans though. According to my source, Groshans is underperforming his expected stats based on his contact quality. Groshans should actually be slugging .296! Look at that progress! Groshans is not hitting for any power this year after showing so much power potential in the past. He struggled with power in 2021 as well, to a much lesser extent, but I thought those had to do with some since resolved health issues.</p><p>The weird thing is, Jordan Groshans lack of power makes no sense at all. Jordan Groshans has a 90th percentile exit velocity of 102.7 MPH. That is the same figure as Orelvis Martinez, Alec Burleson, and Oswald Peraza. He has not lost the ability to hit the ball hard. It is still 55 grade top-end EVs. His average have dipped some, but 87 MPH on average is still above average for the minors as well.</p><p>So surely, Jordan Groshans must hit the ball straight into the dirt 70% of the time? That is the only logical reason for above-average raw power to play as a 20. Except, Jordan Groshans has a 43.2% groundball rate, which ranks in the 47th percentile of minor leaguers. So maybe he’s just constantly mis-hitting the ball and running into easy outs? I doubt that too because Groshans has just a 5% popout rate this year and 90th percentile line-drive rate. Is he failing to pull the ball? I mean yes, but also that would be reflected in his expected slugging and his average EV would be a lot lower if that was the entire cause.</p><p>This brings us back to the question of why Jordan Groshans hits for so little power. I might have an answer for that. The only thing I can think of that would explain both the lack of game slugging and expected slugging would be if Groshans is just making all of his hard contact on the ground. This theory makes some sense and given the flatter swing path and early connection point, it is very possible that he’s suffering in the same way as Josh Kasevich does. Kasevich earned a 45 FV from me with better contact skills and more defensive value, so if this is what Groshans is now, he probably belongs a tier lower. Still a very strange profile.</p><p>On a more positive note, the contact skills are superb now. However, if you try to unlock too much power, I think given where his connection point is, you absolutely risk Groshans combusting in this field. Jordan Groshans makes contact with 85.4% of pitches in the strike zone. He shows some plate coverage to get sliders off the plate as well and, because of his connection point, has zero problems with velocity.</p><p>The approach is now excellent too, with Groshans chasing just 16.8% of the time. He is still an aggressive hitter in the zone too with an estimated Z-Swing of 73.8%. His swing decisions are immaculate. His swing decisions also might be a mirage because of the connection point. Because Groshans prefers to make contact deep over the plate, he is waiting a few milliseconds longer to decide if he wants to swing at a pitch or not. I think the discipline will probably be fantastic, but there is some risk it collapses as the Marlins try to fix Groshans power.</p><p>I have a 40 FV on Jordan Groshans. I really like the combination of contact skills and approach. I think he has plus barrel accuracy as well. He’s not a great defender at the hot corner, but he’s certainly a third baseman in the majors. The only concern here is the power. The only concern is that you have to rework his entire swing and risk the on-base profile to get to usable game power. That is a massive concern, even if his previous history of power lessens the risk.</p><h3>The New York Yankees trade Joey Gallo to the Los Angeles Dodgers for Clayton Beeter</h3><h4>Clayton Beeter</h4><p>Joey Gallo had an ugly stint in New York, so the Yankees were eager to get him out of town. I like just about everybody, thought there would be a non-prospect sent in return. The Yankees did a lot better than that in acquiring Clayton Beeter. He is a real quality prospect who has a future at the big league level with the Yankees. That future is probably in relief, but he still could provide significant value.</p><p>The fastball is a plus and arguably better pitch. Clayton Beeter throws it in the 93–96 MPH range and can top out at 98 MPH with very high spin rates. The spin is efficient and nearly pure backspin, so he has historically had some of the best vertical movement on the fastball in the entire minor leagues. The pitch has sub-optimal angle for the shape, perhaps, because of the high release point, but his combination of movement and velocity still plays as one of the better fastballs in the minors.</p><p>The breaking ball is pure filth. He throws it in the low-mid eighties with incredible depth. The pitch is coming from a very high release as well which essentially bolsters his vertical approach angle and makes the pitch even nastier. The problem here is that Beeter can get too sweepy with the breaker at times and will decimate his natural FB/CB tunnel when he has too much sidespin on it. He probably to tighten up the efficiency to let the curveball really cook. The very medial release that helps Beeter hide the ball from hitters slightly redeems the flawed tunnels.</p><p>Clayton Beeter is probably a reliever given that he only really throws two pitches (Dodgers scrapped the slider since it offered nothing extra) and has 40 command. At the same time, Beeter has a feel for finding the zone and misses a lot of bats with the vertically moving heater. If he can tighten up the curveball shape, it could be elite as well. Clayton Beeter looks a bit like James Karinchak lite in relief and could cover high leverage innings for the Yankees as early as next year. There is also a changeup in theory, but he’s likely a reliever who is hell on righties and can beat lefties with better curveball shape. Very intriguing arm who is incredible value relative to what the Yankees were getting from Joey Gallo.</p><h3>The Los Angeles Angels trade Brandon Marsh to the Philadelphia Phillies for Logan O’Hoppe</h3><h4>Logan O’Hoppe</h4><p>I want to preface this by saying that I think the Angels are stupid for giving up on Brandon Marsh already. He is at worst a plus defensive centerfielder with some pop. In the better and not all that unlikely outcomes, he rediscovers the plus hit tool and approach that made him a top 25 prospect. I digress. Logan O’Hoppe is a good prospect on the outskirts of any top 100 list and is a great addition to the Angels organization- even if I hate (Love cause ew Angels) the price that the Angels had to pay.</p><p>Logan O’Hoppe projects for both above-average power and hit tools but there is significant risk in both tools. The hit tool is the less risky of those two, simply because O’Hoppe makes a lot of contact. Logan O’Hoppe is running an 81% contact rate this year. This includes a 86.9% in-zone contact rate. O’Hoppe has feel to put bat on ball and that is clear as day to anyone with a working set of eyeballs. You should only have to watch a singular game from him to realize that skill is present.</p><p>The approach is excellent as well. Logan O’Hoppe only expands the zone, 16.3% of the time. He swings at an estimated 68.4% of strikes as well. O’Hoppe shows feel for recognizing spin and driving it with authority. It’s a rare ability to not only recognize pitches but go after them and hit them with authority. The amount of damage he does against breaking balls probably has a role in his hits having backspin and outperforming their natural characteristics as well.</p><p>Logan O’Hoppe has fascinating power. His power metrics on the surface level are incredible and the expected stats based on his contact quality are as well. Yet, his exit velocities are not. In a 201 batted ball sample this year, Trackman has him failing to top 102.7 MPH. The thing is that O’Hoppe consistently lives in that range with a league average 90th EV of 100.6 MPH and an average EV of 87 MPH which is above average for the minors. The appeal of O’Hoppe isn’t elite top-end EVs but avoiding poorly hit balls.</p><p>Logan O’Hoppe’s batted ball profiles makes very little sense. He has a 61st percentile groundball rate which is terrible obviously. However, he has a lot better feel to elevate than that rate would indicate. He hits zero balls on a line and still only has slightly below-average popup rates. As such, O’Hoppe still has a 36% Outfield flyball rate. Besides that, O’Hoppe pulls 48.2% of his batted balls; and, arguably more importantly, he avoids the middle of the field. This is why he is running such high homer rates despite somewhat tepid EVs. Even if, I make the semi-logical assumption that the power will regress in pro-ball to only average HR/FB rates (Due to mostly to pulling too), he would still hit 20+ homers across a full season because he puts the ball in the air so much.</p><p>My concern with Logan O’Hoppe offensively is that he will rarely hit anything but long balls for a hit. Logan O’Hoppe has a minor popup problem. He also has just a 9th percentile line drive rate and rarely finds the sweet-spot. O’Hoppe is hitting a lot of flyballs and those are the lowest BABIP batted ball event. In addition, O’Hoppe is a very pull heavy hitter. This is less impactful for a right-handed bat and with a likely shift ban, but good defensive positioning will hurt his impact.</p><p>Logan O’Hoppe plays the second most controversial position in baseball as he catches regularly. The value of his position is highly questionable, with ABS just around the corner in 2024. He also only really has an average arm, so there’s a limit to the value he will provide defensively in the world when it’s run by our robot overlords. I will say that I like O’Hoppe’s blocking ability, but it’s not a game changing attribute by any means.</p><p>In addition, catching will absolutely affect the longevity of the bad negatively. The power is already somewhat fringe despite playing in games, and if catching 100+ games a year does any damage to the lower body, the power could quickly become a non-factor. I don’t really think O’Hoppe will hit for that high of an average given the BABIP concerns, so it’s possible he winds up as only a backup. That factor primarily is what keeps him as just a 50 FV. I still like the talent a lot though and there is 55/55 offensive upside here.</p><h3>The San Francisco Giants trade Darin Ruf to the New York Mets for JD Davis, Thomas Szapucki, Carson Seymour, and Nick Zwack</h3><h4>Thomas Szapucki</h4><p>Thomas Szapucki is the biggest name prospect heading to the Giants for Darin Ruf. Despite his notoriety, I actually think Szapucki is the worst of the three prospects in this trade. He still has a future in a major league bullpen. The Giants did incredibly well with the return in a deal exchanging platoon DHs.</p><p>Thomas Szapucki is a lefty who is sitting at 95 MPH and who has hit as high as 98 MPH this year. The fastball has a generic movement profile, however, with just 15.4&quot; IVB and 10&quot; HB. He throws from a lower release at 5.6&#39; and has a wide horizontal release. With more elevated heaters. I think the fastball can be an above-average and potentially even a plus pitch at its best. Lefties with velocity usually have good fastball even with poor shape and Szapucki is more generic than bad.</p><p>Thomas Szapucki’s best pitch is undoubtedly a changeup that warrants a plus grade because of how it works off of the fastball. The changeup only has 50–55 grade movement as he averages just 9&quot; IVB and 15.4&quot; of horizontal action. The appeal here is the potential tunnel off of the fastball with much more optimal locations.</p><p>The fastball and changeup have the same spin rates. The changeup comes out of the hand on a 10:15 spin axis. The fastball comes out on a 10:30 spin axis. The changeup has 95% spin efficiency. The fastball has 97% spin efficiency. Both pitches have what Baseball Savant estimates as 17&quot; of total movement. So surely, the changeup is just the fastball but 8 MPH slower, right?</p><p>The answer is not at all despite so many surface similarities. The fastball has a minor axis shift up to 11:00. The changeup has a much more major axis deviation to 9:30. They end up separated by 90 minutes but start at 15 minutes. Good luck picking those apart. The pitch looks completely identical in every way out of the hand but drops 15.3&quot; more with 7.4&quot; more fade. It is also 8 MPH slower. That is a distinct movement from the same tunnel.</p><p>So why has Szapucki ran below average chase rates in the minors? His location sucks. Szapucki uses the fastball very far to the arm side and often uses a bad sinker that bleeds into the changeup. The four-seam needs to be used up and in the middle of the zone horizontally. Right now, hitters might see fastball but still not swing because it looks like it will dive too far inside. If he more optimally locates the FB/CH combo (And uses the changeup more), I think Szapucki can dominate right-handed hitters in a relief role.</p><p>Thomas Szapucki also has a curveball that is very interesting. The pitch has spin rates in the 2600 RPMs range. The pitch has fairly high efficiency on a 5:00 axis so he get’s -13.2&quot; IVB and 6.7&quot; sweep. He has also added velocity to the pitch and sat at 80 MPH in a brief MLB sample. I’m not sure it blends that well with the fastball and isn’t the best weapon against SHB which is what he needs it for but it has some viability on specs alone. 45 pitch with potential.</p><p>Thomas Szapucki has had walk problems in the minors, but I don’t think they need to persist. Over, 50% of his pitches in the minor leagues this year are in the strike zone. The problem is a lack of chases and I believe that is more because of poor strategy than anything. I think in San Francisco, he can clean up his game plan and start to dominate in a relief role. He won’t be an elite shutdown arm but he has a chance to provide real value out of a major league bullpen. 40 FV talent but health concerns keep him a tier lower.</p><h4>Carson Seymour</h4><p>Carson Seymour was the Mets 6th round pick last year, and it was apparent before he threw a single pitch for them that the pick was a steal. We got to see him in Low A and the results have been incredible. He has a very fun arsenal with improving command and looks the part of a future high impact arm in the major leagues. I think that impact is probably coming out of the rotation.</p><p>The sinker is an alright pitch, and perhaps wrongly the most used pitch in his arsenal with it, composing 60% of the pitches he has thrown in Low-A this year. The pitch comes from a 1:45 spin axis with a limited axis shift. The pitch is more of a two-seam fastball than a true sinker as Seymour has just 12.3&quot; IVB but 14.9&quot; HB still makes it solid enough shape. The pitch functions as a chase pitch- primarily against lefties, but he uses it against batters of both handedness to great effect as he has logged a 40% chase rate with it this season. The sinker sits at 92.7 MPH and works best, located down and away from his 6&#39; RelHeight and 2&#39; RelSide. Coincidentally, that is where Seymour lives with his sinker.</p><p>I actually want to see fewer sinkers- at least against right-handed bats where the four-seam fastball appears to be the better pitch. Seymour throws his heater with a 1:00 spin direction despite it coming out of the hand on a 1:30 axis. The four-seam appears to be thrown slightly harder in a small sample, but the appeal is the revamped shape that leads to Seymour getting above-average vertical movement. Seymour sits at 16.8&quot; IVB and still has above-average tail at 9.6&quot; HB. I also don’t think the four-seam fastball is that great but it’s an average pitch that sets up the ideal secondary mix against right-handed hitters.</p><p>The cutter/slider, or whatever you call it, is beyond the comprehension of the average mortal. Carson Seymour sits at 89.1 MPH with the cutter. He has -0.9&quot; of IVB with 3.2&quot; of cut. To put that into perspective, only two major leaguers this year throw a pitch with as much velocity and vertical depth. Those two are Max Meyer and Tanner Scott with their 70+ grade sliders. This is an unhittable pitch that has viability against batters of both handedness.</p><p>Against lefties it is probably slightly less viable than against right-handed hitters, but it still has viability there. The pitch has very little sweep, so it works off of the sinker as a good horizontal tunnel- although it might have too much depth to be perfect from a chase standpoint. Against righties, it relies on the vertical tunnel instead as he throws the cutter with what starts as 6:30 spin direction before the axis deviates to 8:30. The pitch falls like a rock off of the fastball with so little velocity separation and fie horizontal separation. If he is locating the fastball up and the cutter at ~2&#39; plateZ, then he should be able to get chases with both pitches off the vertical tunnel.</p><p>The cutter also builds into an incredible vertical tunnel with the curveball. The curveball is the cutter, but he doesn’t shift his axis and takes off some velocity while bolstering efficiency ever so slightly. The result is a curveball at 84.5 MPH with -9.4&quot; IVB and 2.7&quot; HB. That is the same horizontal movement almost exactly with another foot of drop with gravity in exchange for a few ticks of velocity. Locate the curve below the zone and build the three-headed dragon of vertical pitch tunnels. Seymour should be able to get chases below the zone at an elite clip if he follows my blue print.</p><p>There is also a changeup that has some use against left-handed hitters. The pitch has 6.2&quot; IVB and 12.8&quot; HB, which is above-average depth but below-average fade. The problem is that Seymour is too firm with his changeup, as he averages 87.3 MPH. That is not enough separation from the sinker and it actually has less horizontal movement. If he is pitching down and away with both pitches, they are just going to bleed into each other and get hit around. If he moves the sinker up to set up the changeup, they will probably hit the sinker harder.</p><p>This leads me to wonder if the sinker primary against lefty bats is actually for the best. The sinker clearly dominates lefties and I have worries about the four-seam fastball performing without the platoon advantage. I’m very confident that the sinker and changeup can both work with the cutter, but I don’t know if the changeup can work with them. I think you probably need a grip change on the changeup at this point to get a lot more vertical depth and prioritize that in order to continue to use the sinker.</p><p>The primary problem with Carson Seymour is command. Seymour has gotten a lot better at finding the strike zone this year as 51.5% of his pitches have been over the plate. The problem is command, not control, though. Right now, none of Seymour’s locations are precise enough to build the tunnels as perfectly as I want them to be.</p><p>Seymour has to revamp his pitch usage and adjust his general locations. He is older than most of his peers; turning 24 this December. There is absolutely work to be done here. The aforementioned reasons keep Seymour out of the 45 FV tier and at the top of the 40s. Despite those factors, I think Seymour offers four pitches with above-average potential and three of them mesh perfectly. I’m fairly confident that Seymour is at least an impact right-handed specialist and he has the upside to be a rotation stalwart. I’m all in on him and am shocked the Mets would trade this talent for the weakside of a DH platoon.</p><h4>Nick Zwack</h4><p>I don’t think Nick Zwack is the high-impact arm that most Mets fans seem to think he is, but I think he’s still a solid prospect and a great fourth piece in a Darin Ruf trade. He’s dominated the minors this year and there are elements of that performance that should translate to major league production.</p><p>Nick Zwack’s best attribute is his uncanny ability to find the strike zone. Amongst all minor league arms to throw at least 50 innings this year, Nick Zwack has the third highest zone rate. The ability to find the zone is rare and is why he has been so absurdly dominant against low-level hitters. Ultimately, though, a 60.1% zone rate in the minors this year is far too much to translate. I have more than a few concerns that it’ll only be plus walk rates rather than elite ones too because Zwack has a 15th percentile chase rate.</p><p>Nick Zwack has an above-average fastball. He throws it at 92.2 MPH and has touched 95 MPH. The fastball has fairly generic vertical movement with 16.5&quot; IVB but his plus run (13.5&quot; HB) lets him still avoid barrels some despite the zone filling approach. The fastball also is slightly better than the movement would indicate because Zwack throws from a 5.7&#39; release height and can elevate his heater at will. I think there’s very little room for the fastball to improve given the body and that he’s already 24, but it’s already a potentially impactful pitch.</p><p>The secondaries are honestly a lot less impressive and the Giants will have work on those considerably. The cutter is the more frequently thrown below average secondary. I call the pitch a cutter because the movement profile aligns with one, but it’s also only thrown at 84.2 MPH. Zwack needs to add at least 3 MPH for the cutter to profile as an impact pitch. The shape is fine with 8&quot; IVB and 4.4&quot; HB but he needs an extra bit of power for it to play off of the heater without killing lift.</p><p>The changeup is probably his best secondary despite being used a lot less. It’s limited to only being thrown against right-handed bats, but it performs in that role- even with limited feel. He throws the changeup at 84.9 MPH with good movement on both planes as Zwack averages 6.1&quot; IVB and 15.3&quot; HB. That is an extra 10&quot; IVB and 2&quot; of run relative to the four-seamer while subtracting velocity as well. The only problem I’ve noticed is that the arm speed is diminished on the changeup so he doesn’t get all that many chases, even when he throws great ones.</p><p>I think the solution to this problem might be to build a tunnel off of the cutter instead. Right now, the cutter has 1.2&quot; more drop with gravity than the changeup. They are separated by 19.7&quot; horizontally. That is probably too much separation for an organic horizontal tunnel, but given the comparable vertical shape, you can still make it work with mirrored pitch locations. The vertical separation will grow if Zwack adds the desired velocity to the cutter, but as long as it is within 5 MPH, I can’t imagine the separation becomes too much. If he adds enough velocity to render this potential tunnel totally obsolete, then he probably won’t need it anymore, anyway.</p><p>Nick Zwack throws a lot of strikes and has some chase potential with refinement of his pitch mix. At the same time, the stuff is only average. Zwack is already 24 and hasn’t made it out of High-A+. There is upside here, but given his age, I think Zwack is likely to wind up in the bullpen. I’m not sure how the stuff plays in relief. I think given the basic control and an above-average fastball, he will at least serve as a long reliever or swing man for a few years. That gets him into the 35 FV tier, but I have to see him make adjustments to parts of his game before I will put him in a higher tier.</p><h3>The Chicago Cubs trade David Robertson to the Philadelphia Phillies for Ben Brown</h3><h4>Ben Brown</h4><p>Ben Brown has two attributes that make him stand out from the pack. Ben Brown throws hard with a fastball that sits 94–97 MPH. Brown also throws the ball in the strike zone at an incredibly high rate. However, Ben Brown is lacking in pitches that have significant viability against left-handed hitters and his stuff doesn’t mesh all that well despite impressive raw stuff so he doesn’t get chases. Those concerns probably push Brown to the bullpen, but starting in the majors is not impossible.</p><p>Ben Brown had subpar fastball shape in Low-A last year. That does not appear to have changed this year based on my film looks and the lack of in-zone whiffs (relative to velocity). The fastball is in the dead zone vertically and it comes from a 6.3&#39; release height. The pitch has some good tail, and he has command of it both up in the zone, and down; but Brown’s fastball is still a bit too flat for my tastes. Above-average pitch on the strength of velocity alone. Best used to pitch to contact down in the strike zone.</p><p>The breaking balls are a lot more fun, even if they probably don’t work with his arsenal as it stands right now. It’s funny because the curveball is a good pitch in a vacuum. He throws it at ~81–83 MPH with average vertical depth and not a lot of sweep, either. He could miss some bats below the zone but the appeal should be in dropping it in the zone for a called strike.</p><p>The problem with the curveball is how much it bleeds into a plus slider. They threw the slider in 2019 with almost the same exact tilt as the curveball. He has nearly perfectly equivalent spin rates as well. The difference between the slider and curveball is just 4 MPH and a small fraction of spin efficiency as Brown sits 84–88 MPH on the slider compared to 81–83 MPH on the curve. The slider is the better version of the pitch and there is pretty much never a situation it makes sense to use the curveball over the slider in. I’m going to suggest the unthinkable and say that Brown should work on subtracting velocity from his curve. If he is sitting 75 MPH with the same tilt as the slider than you have a lethal pairing between them and he can already land both breaking balls in the zone.</p><p>Ben Brown is probably a two pitch reliever. He throws in the zone 57.5% of the time but he won’t get chases because of poor fastball shape and a weak tunnel with the slider off of it. There is obvious upside here, but I think he’s more of a middle reliever than a high impact arm.</p><h3>The Minnesota Twins trade Spencer Steer, Steven Hajjar, and Christian Encarnacion-Strand to the Cincinnati Reds for Tyler Mahle</h3><h4>Spencer Steer</h4><p>The Reds did well in their return for Tyler Mahle. I realize most of the public thinks it is an underwhelming package, especially relative to the return for Luis Castillo. I want to make it abundantly clear that this is good value for Mahle, who is also far from the #1 starter that Castillo can be. I had two separate people who work in baseball for a living message me after the deal went down saying that they thought the Twins got fleeced. I don’t agree, but it’s not the lopsided exchange it might feel like because the Reds didn’t target any high upside future stars.</p><p>Spencer Steer is the best player in the return package and is also very close to contributing in the majors. He doesn’t really have a defensive home, but can play all over the diamond. He’s only an average athlete, so he’s a fringe option at shortstop or centerfield, but I’m comfortable rocking with Steer at second , third, or either corner outfield spot. That flexibility will help get a somewhat boring bat into the lineup regularly.</p><p>Boring is an overly harsh determinator to describe Steer. Spencer only has average power and players without power often end up as boring role players, but that does not determine that Steer will only be that. Spencer Steer is actually a solid bet to outperform his mere 102.2 MPH 90th EV. Steer has plus feel to elevate and pulls the ball over 50% of the time. That lets the power play above his raw. What also helps is the consistency of the power due to Steer’s above-average barrel accuracy. I have an average power projection on Spencer Steer but it is a loose grade that can and probably will settle in slightly above or below that line.</p><p>The ability to make contact is probably the more valuable element in Steer’s game. He makes contact on 84.8% in-zone swings. There have been some struggles with sliders off the plate in my looks, but Steer has elite chase rates, so it’s not a major concern. The leg kick is noisy and could cause some concerns with making contact in the majors against top-end velocity. However, I think given the track record of good quality contact at all levels, he’ll be just fine.</p><p>Spencer Steer has good barrel accuracy as well. His swing is flat most of the time, so he gets jammed and will pop out occasionally. However, Steer still runs plus sweet-spot rates. He has the ability to pull the barrel inside because of great hip flexion and can go down and get balls. The contact is consistently high quality and he can cover most of the plate. There is some struggles to get to pitches on the outside and drive them hard, but if you miss inside at all, he’ll punish you.</p><p>I think Spencer Steer can do everything at what is at least an alright level. He has contact and power, both with a plus approach. Spencer Steer is unlikely to be a star, but he is a low variance regular on your average team. He should post average or slightly above-average offensive numbers while playing all over the field. That is a valuable major leaguer even if a boring one. He is also MLB ready from day one and can help you win games right now.</p><h4>Steve Hajjar</h4><p>Steve Hajjar is tracking as a prospective #4 starter with four quality pitches. If he can figure out how to avoid walks, then he might actually reach that outcome. Unfortunately, I think finding out how to avoid walks might be more difficult than it appears to be and if he can’t do that, it’s probably a leverage relief role. I still have a 40 FV on him because the stuff is good and with few adjustments I can’t really identify he could be a 50, but there’s work to be done now that he is in Cincinnati.</p><p>Steve Hajjar has a dynamic fastball despite only sitting at 91.6 MPH. In terms of results, it has been perhaps the most dominant four-seam fastball by a starting pitcher in all the minors. He has a 36.7% whiff rate with the pitch. Part of this is that he’s a lefty with plus extension who has an effective velocity closer to 93 MPH. There are very few lefties with velocity in Low-A, so it overwhelms a lot of hitters. The other driving factor is that Hajjar has 18.6&quot; IVB and consistently elevates the heater, so even with a generic release height, the fastball has a flat VAA and misses a lot of bats. I think the whiff rates will almost certainly fall as Hajjar climbs the ladder, but I also think he can add velocity, so it balances out in a way.</p><p>The slider is probably Hajjar’s best pitch and actually plays off of the fastball to make it even better. The slider sits at 82.2 MPH with 1.7&quot; IVB and almost no horizontal movement at just 0.7&quot; HB. That sounds like a terrible pitch to most people probably, but I have it as a plus pitch. The slider has a 5:54 spin based axis. The axis shifts by six hours to 12:00 on average.</p><p>That is a complete lie. The axis averages a six hour shift but it doesn’t shift six hours. The problem with a circular clock is 1+11 = 6 on average, even though the median of the two looking at the actual map is 12. Hajjar only actually averages a two-hour shift on his shift shaping slider, the starting and finishing axis just changes each pitch. That is still an outlier axis shift as only Amir Garrett is averaging as much deviation on their slider as Hajjar does.</p><p>The slider shape varies. His movement ranges from -6.3&quot; IVB to +7.6&quot; IVB and the horizontal movement ranges from -6&quot; to +4.8&quot; HB. The slider doesn’t even need a tunnel to get chases because it tunnels off the randomness of his other sliders. The unpredictable nature of such a low efficiency slider is why the slider his only good chase pitch with a 34.1% chase rate. The pitch should also miss bats in the zone at a high clip. The slider is a bit of a double-edged sword as, with even Hajjar unable to predict the movement, he frequently cannot find the zone. I think the slider should have some utility against lefties as well because it breaks both directions at nearly equal rates and Hajjar is throwing it from a very medial release. He only uses it regularly against left-handed hitters right now, but I think it has viability against both.</p><p>The changeup is Hajjar’s primary weapon against left-handed hitters right now and I would be lying if I claimed the pitch was good. He throws the changeup 8 MPH slower than the fastball and has limited movement. Granted, 11.6&quot; IVB is better than it looks in the context of his plus ride but it still is no enough depth or fade at just 12.8&quot; HB. The changeup also gets almost no chases below the zone or off the plate with him sitting below 20%. I think the changeup has a niche but should be used sparingly in deference to the slider.</p><p>The curveball has potential but is hardly used right now. He throws it at 78.5 MPH and has -10.9&quot; IVB. Nothing about that sounds all that special on its own, but it is more about how it synergized with the vertically moving fastball that has me excited. The curveball has a reflected spin axis of the fastball as he throws his curve on a 5:40 movement tilt. Hajjar gets very little sidespin at just 3.2&quot; IVB. I think it is theoretically possible to build a vertical tunnel off of the fastball here. The real appeal, though, is the ability to steal called strikes down in the zone given the tunnel. The only problem is that Hajjar only lands 21% of curves in the strike zone. If Hajjar can hone his command of this pitch, it could provide value to his arsenal, but as is, it is a 45 projection.</p><p>The concern for Steven Hajjar is control, not stuff. I don’t really know how to fix that problem. The only pitch that Hajjar can regularly land for a strike is the fastball and kind of the changeup, I suppose. The slider is the only pitch that gets chases at a high rate and it is a hard pitch to zone. I think Hajjar can dominate with the FB/SL combo in relief, but I’m not sure how to reign in the walks enough for Hajjar to start. There is a path here. I just don’t really see it.</p><h4>Christian Encarnacion-Strand</h4><p>Christian Encarnacion-Strand was the Twins 4th round pick last year and has done nothing but rake since they drafted him. Encarnacion-Strand hit for a 182 PF wRC+ in Low-A Southeast last year, and hasn’t lost a step this year as while splitting time between A+ and AA, he is running a 165 PF wRC+. The hit tool was supposed to regress last year after Encarnación-Strand ran a 30% whiff rate and 40% chase rate in his pro debut. Instead, CES doubled down and hit with the same maddening approach at A+ and AA while seeing no drop-off in production.</p><p>Christian Encarnacion-Strand is on a mission to prove his unique style of hitting works and I’m coming around on the idea that he is actually right about the sustainability of it. The whiff rates are putrid this year with him making contact just 75.2% of the time on pitches in the strike zone. The hit risk is further compounded by an uber aggressive approach that results in a 35.6% chase rate this year. You would expect that he would have platoon issues because he struggles so much with the outside slider, but he’s running reverse splits this year, so maybe it’s not the long-term issue it feels like it should be.</p><p>There are players who make this skill set work in the majors, but it’s not usually so extreme while they are still in the minors and not being pushed too aggressively. There are more chases from Encarnacion-Strand than Elly De La Cruz with slightly less zone-contact. Christian also has a lot less defensive value and power at an older age. Encarnacion-Strand is an outlier and not in a good way.</p><p>However, you can’t just ignore the ridiculous production even with the red flags in the profile. Christian Encarnacion-Strand has ridiculous contact quality. He finds the barrel at a high rate and is one of the best in the minors at avoiding mis-hits. His ability to turn on the inside pitch is enviable. He has great adaptability and can get his barrel on pitches all over the strike zone.</p><p>The power is also a massive difference maker. Encarnacion-Strand has only topped out at 110.8 MPH in live games but given his barrel accuracy, the power plays way above that. Encarnacion-Strand has a 90th percentile EV of 105.9 MPH, which is in the top 5% of minor leaguers. He’s consistently going max effort on his swings and punishing balls as a result. A lot of those barreled balls are coming at optimal angles- ergo both the game power and high BACONs.</p><p>The problem is there is considerable risk that the offensive profile collapses in the majors. He is an all or nothing hitter who will come up empty more in the majors and will have to maintain the elite barrel accuracy he is showing right now against pitches moving three times as much. There is also the defensive profile that kills his value, given that Christian Encarnacion-Strand might wind up first base in the long term. I have 40 FV on CES who is probably a platoon first baseman, but I wonder if I’m underselling the production value of his bat so far.</p><h3>The Cincinnati Reds trade Brandon Drury to the San Diego Padres for Victor Acosta</h3><h4>Victor Acosta</h4><p>Victor Acosta is in rookie ball, so there is obvious risk here. However, Acosta has the potential to be an above-average hitter from the left-handed side with the defensive acumen to play a solid shortstop. The risk is significant and the Padres were probably only willing to move Acosta for Drury because of the former swinging underneath so many heaters at the top of the zone. Acosta also only turned 18 this June, and if you compare him to the prep shortstops taken this year, I think Acosta measures up to most of those taken on day two of the draft. The upside is clear and we have already seen some baseball skills out of Acosta.</p><p>Victor Acosta is actually making contact at an above-average rate in the AZL as he has connected on 83.6% of swings at pitches in the strike zone. The high fastball is a problem because of his bat path and the steeper path created by his shoulder angle. Acosta has struggled with barrel accuracy at times because of how his barrel drags in the optimal zone, and how he can lead with his shoulder. I will also note that his lack of barrel accuracy at all from the right-handed side is dragging down the overall numbers.</p><p>Victor Acosta has very little punch to his bat right now. There is more power from the left-handed side than the right-handed one, but neither swing has produced any exit velocities even close to the big league average. The swing is rotational but disjointed with wasted explosion from the lower half as a left-handed hitter. Acosta also struggles to pull the ball with how he drags the barrel. The genuine appeal to the power profile, however, is that Acosta is very projectable with elite twitchiness. The presumption is that Acosta can get stronger and grow into some power.</p><p>I also like Victor Acosta’s defensive acumen at shortstop in very limited looks- those are admittedly limited mostly to highlights. He showcases plus speed both in the field and on the base paths. His first step is explosive, and he covers a lot of ground in very little time. The arm strength is at least above-average as well and I’ve seen Acosta throw some darts from both a lower arm slot and the more conventional one. I think Acosta is a safe bet to stick at shortstop. Combine that with the offensive potential, and Victor Acosta is at the top of the 40 FV tier.</p><h3>The San Francisco Giants trade Curt Casali and Matthew Boyd to the Seattle Mariners for Michael Stryffeler, and Andy Thomas</h3><h4>Michael Stryffeler</h4><p>Michael Stryffeler was amid his second straight season with the Arkansas Travelers and had a whiff rare of 46% in both of them. He was actually called up to AAA the day before the trade and was scheduled to face the Giants AAA affiliate that very night when the news broke. He walked across the field and pitched for the River Cats later that week. This means we now have pitch data for Stryffeler and can see just how much impact potential he has in San Francisco.</p><p>The fastball is an electric pitch. Stryffeler sits at ~95 MPH with an above average extension that puts him effectively closer to 96 MPH. He also has high spin rates with good spin efficiency on a 12:30 axis. The resulting fastball has 18.8&quot; IVB and just 2.7&quot; HB. This fastball misses even more bats than you would expect, plus ride at 95 to do, because Stryffeler is pitching from a 5.6&#39; release height. On top of that, he has a very medial release point at -0.5&#39; ft that gives him unique horizontal approach angles to go with the already incredible VAA offered by Stryffeler. The fastball command is terrible, so it’s not consistent, but this is a plus heater.</p><p>The slider/cutter hybrid is the only other pitch Stryffeler throws. He sits at 87 MPH and has very comparable spin rates to the fastball. Stryffeler throws the slutter on a 9:30 spin axis with limited spin efficiency. This leads to the slutter getting just 1.6&quot; IVB and 4.2&quot; HB. The pitch misses a lot of bats in the low minors because it’s a hard gyro slider, but I’m skeptical it will perform quite as well in the majors. It is also a pitch much more reliant on in-zone whiffs off of the fastball tunnel rather than chases. This is, in part, what causes Michael’s walk issues.</p><p>I have no clue if he can develop one, but on a speculative level, a sweeper would make this arsenal ascend to a new level. The sweeper works best off of such a straight heater with rise, and you can keep the slutter in the back pocket for when he has to get a lefty out, or is behind in the count. Sweeper development is more nuanced than just wanting one, and I don’t really think Michael Stryffeler has any of the traits you look for in sweeper candidates, but it would take him to a new level.</p><p>Michael Stryffeler has some of the best swing and stuff in the entire minors. He also has major walk problems that are actually caused more by his lack of feel for the zone than his inability to draw chases. (I think that might be there too, though.) Michael Stryffeler is also already 26 and has zero innings above AA at the time of the trade. There is risk here, and the upside is a setup man. I think Stryffeler has a higher chance of reaching that upside than most do, but he’s only ever going to be a 35 FV.</p><h4>Andy Thomas</h4><p>Andy Thomas signed for just $25,000 with the Mariners as a 5th round pick out of Baylor last year. The senior signing has done everything in his power to prove he is worth the slot value of the selection rather than the bonus he commanded. Andy Thomas is hitting .264/.400/.444 in High-A+ this year for a 131 PF wRC+. The problem is that Thomas is 24, and that makes it hard to draw the line between how good Andy is and how advanced Andy is- relative to the competition.</p><p>Andy Thomas has a passive approach. He swings at just 38.1% of pitches this year. Right now, that results in a good approach with a 19.8% chase rate, but I’m skeptical that a 58.4% zone-swing will fly once he gets higher up the ladder. Andy Thomas is running slightly above-average contact rates right now at 75.4% on all pitches, but again, I am naturally a skeptic because of his advanced age.</p><p>Andy Thomas has struggled considerably with left on left sliders in the few games I’ve watched him play in this year. There are too many times I’ve seen him expand the zone in pursuit of them. Thomas has thankfully done a lot of damage on fastballs and off-speed stuff, as well as right-handed sliders. Unfortunately, I must again bring up the quality of the pitching that Thomas is facing. Andy is not seeing too quick of fastballs, and good changeups don’t really exist at this level. We won’t be able to accurately value the approach or hit tool until we see more of it against better competition, but right now I lean towards it, only being a 40-grade hit tool and 55-grade approach.</p><p>I really hate being a Debbie Downer, but I also think Andy Thomas projects for below-average power. He has good average exit velocities and hard-hit rates, but that seems to be a byproduct of his age. Andy Thomas is below-average in terms of his Max EV and 90th percentile EV. I’ll also mention that Thomas has a below-average feel for elevation and hits the ball the other way more frequently than he pulls it. The Dodgers are proof that barrel accuracy matters more than top-end EVs, and Thomas has shown the former in High A+, but I am naturally skeptical of that skill when you’re so much older than your opponents. From my experience, barrel accuracy is often more dependent on preparedness for the level than things like top-end EVs, contact rates , or even chase rates.</p><p>The one thing I will give Andy Thomas props for is that he is a good defensive catcher. I also think catcher defensive is going to be relatively unimportant though, so that can’t really bolster his stock too much. Thomas has been worth +9.6 CDA this year in just 58 games. However, most of that is framing which won’t matter once we submit to the robots. That being said, Andy Thomas is still at +0.7 runs as both a blocker and thrower. Those are the skills that will actually have some value with ABS, so it’s encouraging to see Andy Thomas showcasing both elements in his game right now.</p><p>I am not that big of a fan of Andy Thomas right now, but that could change quickly. I see his performance as a byproduct of being more advanced than his competition. If the Giants send him to AA for the last month and he instantly performs, it would force me to acknowledge that Thomas is more than just his opponents. If that happens, he would rise up the list accordingly. For now, I have Andy Thomas projected as a backup catcher in the major leagues, though with strong defense that lets him stick even when he doesn’t hit.</p><h3>The Boston Red Sox trade Jay Groome to the San Diego Padres for Eric Hosmer, Corey Rosier, Max Ferguson, and Cash Considerations</h3><h4>Jay Groome</h4><p>Jay Groome has fallen a long way since “falling” to the Red Sox at #12 overall in the 2016 draft. His stuff hasn’t really progressed at all in pro ball and the injuries have held him back. There is still a non-zero chance that Jay Groome makes it as a starting pitcher if he can develop the slider, but realistically, Groome is a reliever.</p><p>Jay Groome throws his fastball 91–94 MPH most nights and can reach back for 96 MPH from the left-handed side. I’ve officially run out of methods to positively describe Groome’s below-average fastball. Groome is sitting in the dead zone right now. He throws his four-seam fastball in the dead zone. The heater averaged just 13.7&quot; IVB in his one start with Hawkeye and he has almost no horizontal movement as well. Groome is throwing from a 5.9&#39; release height and that does him no favors.</p><p>In the past, Jay Groome threw a two-seam fastball alongside the four-seam but he has axed it for some reason. I think Groome is best off by converting to a full on sinker primary since it should be obvious by now that Groome will never get the vertical movement needed to use a four-seam. I don’t think a sinker will solve anywhere near all of Jay’s problems, but it will help considerably.</p><p>Jay Groome’s best pitch is a cutter, despite Groome claiming he is incapable of throwing one. I would like to see him multiply his usage of it tenfold. That is not at all hyperbolic. If anything, it is an understatement. In his lone start with statcast, Jay Groome used the cutter 3.1% of the time. The cutter is an actually good pitch that plays up off of the deadzone fastball and probably the only pitch Groome throws that projects as above-average.</p><p>The cutter sits at 87–89 MPH range with spin rates in the same range as the fastball. The cutter has 7.7&quot; IVB over a three pitch sample size and 4.7&quot; of sweep over that same microscopic sample size. Honestly, it is entirely generic cutter shape and velocity. What makes Jay Groome stand out is his arm angle. Groome is throwing from a 2.6&#39; horizontal release, which gives anything with glove side movement a steep HAA and makes it very difficult to hit in left on left matchups. I don’t think the cutter is anything special, but it plays off the dead zone heater and should be above average in a vacuum. The pitch might suffer slightly if he switches to a sinker, like I want him to do. However, that’s not a guarantee, nor is the change I want to see one that will probably be implemented.</p><p>The changeup would work well off of the dead-zone fastball and cutter combination. Especially the latter option. Jay Groome does not get a lot of vertical depth or fade on his changeup. What he offers, though, is spin killing ability with Groome sitting at ~1300 RPMs on average. The other thing that Groome does is perfectly mirror his cutter with the changeup. He only sits at 85 MPH, which you would like to see a tad lower, but it’s workable if Groome pitches smart.</p><p>The real reason I am even remotely excited about the changeup is the tunneling potential is has with the cutter. The cutter has 7.7&quot; IVB in a three pitch sample with Hawkeye. The changeup has 8.2&quot; IVB in a four pitch sample. The changeup also has 8&quot; of fade on average. The two pitches have basically the same drop (I was told IVB is actually better than statcast for this), and ~14&quot; of horizontal separation. The dead zone fastball also provides a middle ground between the two and if he throws it up in the zone, he can split eye level and set up both the cutter and changeup down in the zone. I realize I said earlier that I want Groome to switch to a sinker, but I just changed my mind.</p><p>I don’t know how realistic it is for Jay Groome to turn his below-average curveball into a sweeper, but I would love it if Groome did so. The curveball is very slurvy right now as Groome will at ~82 MPH with -4&quot; IVB and just 8&quot; of sweep. That is fine separation from the fastball with only 5&quot; of tail. My concern is simply that the lack of sweep is wasting the pitch and the depth adds nothing. The arm slot is ideal for a sweeper and if he can start getting ~12&quot; sweep with less depth, he could finally have a deadly weapon against lefties. I still think he should mostly use FB/FC against lefties with more changeups against righties, but a sweeper could have an important niche.</p><p>Jay Groome is on the precipice of the majors, but if the Padres want to turn him into a useful big leaguer, it will take work. Jay Groome has issues with both getting chases and in-zone whiffs. I think a lot of that is due to pitch usage and can be easily cleaned up, but there is some requisite shape development as well. I don’t really think Groome’s stuff plays up all that much in the bullpen, so I’m fully committed to riding or dying with Groome as a starting pitcher.</p><h4>Corey Rosier</h4><p>Corey Rosier is going to be a big leaguer, but I doubt he will be an impactful one. Corey Rosier is that AAA depth guy who gets a thousand plate appearances in his five-year career for six different teams and doesn’t do much with them. He has value as a depth player, but he’s also one of the first guys you DFA once you have to clear a roster spot on the 40 man roster.</p><p>Corey Rosier makes some of the best swing decisions in all of minor league baseball. He is chasing just 13.8% of the time this year and based on how high his swing rate is, we can estimate that he has a 73% Z-swing this year. On top of making elite decisions on location, he is showing feel to recognize and even hit spinning stuff. Even the tougher breaking balls are being taken or hit by Rosier. Rosier is only High-A+ but the swing decisions are too good to just call him advanced and end things there.</p><p>Corey Rosier also makes contact at an above-average rate with a 78% contact rate this year. He is very short to the baseball with a smooth and repeatable swing. His timing mechanism is quiet but effective. There is a feel to get pitches all over the zone and hit them the other way. I don’t doubt that Rosier will make enough contact to get opportunities and, when combined with the approach, this could be a very appealing prospect if he even gets to 30 power.</p><p>Corey Rosier has awful contact quality. His xwOBAcon this year is just .308 this year. His exit velocities are at the bottom of the barrel. The popup rates are slightly below-average and he doesn’t find the sweet-spot all that often at just 24.7%. The contact quality has been better in the past, but there’s limited bat speed and projection here, so I’m not expecting a lot out of Rosier. His best hope of doing damage at the plate in the majors is being fast and hitting the ball the other way, often enough for his approach and contact skills to play.</p><p>The good news is Corey Rosier is probably a genuine 70 grade runner. He can play centerfield, although a poor arm might push him to left field if he was playing regularly. Still, he shows range because of his speed and has value as a pinch runner. He’s a bench piece and depth piece with a very limited upside, I can foresee.</p><h4>Max Ferguson</h4><p>Max Ferguson is not really that dissimilar to Corey Rosier. Ferguson makes a lot of contact and rarely will expand the zone. Ferguson is also an elite runner and can play up the middle- either infield or outfield. He has failed to produce in High-A+ at all, which probably puts Max below Rosier, but I think their long-term roles are most the same.</p><p>Max Ferguson controls the strike zone. He chases just 15.5% of the time this year and still swings at ~61.6% of pitches in the strike zone. Not only is he making great swing decisions based on strike probability, but he is also running an 85% contact rate within the strike zone. Surprisingly, Max Ferguson is striking out 24% of the time this year despite the contact rates and swing decisions. Passivity is a part of it, but I think the real issue is timing and mishit balls. Max Ferguson hits foul balls 52.9% of the time he makes contact. For comparison, the average MLB player is at 47.1%. Even when Ferguson is making contact, he’s often taking strikes, so the contact skills play down.</p><p>It is a rare occasion to see Max Ferguson make quality contact. I think this is less due to a lack barrel control (That is a thing though), and more to do with Ferguson’s swing being mismatched for his skill set. Max Ferguson hits a flyball 44.4% of the time. This would usually be a great thing, but Max Ferguson has a Max EV of 101.2 MPH this year. Because he has such little power, Ferguson rarely turns flyballs into hits but will instead weakly flyout regularly. He also runs below-average line-drive rates but the primary explanation for the .222 batting average is the weak flyballs.</p><p>Max Ferguson is a 70 grade runner who has stolen 56 bases on 61 attempts this year. He’s quick down the line and would really benefit from a swing more natural to his style of play that prioritizes groundballs. That speed plays as plus range at shortstop, but limited arm strength pushes him down the defensive spectrum. I think Ferguson’s best fit is more centerfield because of the speed, but second base and even shortstop remain possible.</p><p>Like with the other player headed to Boston in this trade, I think Ferguson profiles as a somewhat useful bench piece. I think I like Ferguson slightly more of the two because he can play the infield, and makes more contact. I think it is probably very easy to teach a hitter to put the ball on the ground more and that is the biggest change Ferguson needs. The Red Sox could also instead choose to focus on strength development for Ferguson and try to make the power usable instead. I lean towards the former approach, but both are viable. There is obvious talent here, but given the lack of punch, I find it hard to see Ferguson as more than a role player, even with an optimistic outlook.</p><h3>The Detroit Tigers trade Michael Fulmer to the Minnesota Twins for Sawyer Gipson-Long</h3><h4>Sawyer Gipson-Long</h4><p>Sawyer Gipson-Long has a plus slider, and he’s hoping that will be enough to carry him to a major league role. The plus command also helps hide a disturbing lack of pitches beyond the slider. I think Gipson-Long is probably destined for a bullpen role. However, if he finds a few more ticks of velocity, that could change.</p><p>The fastball is boring. Sawyer Gipson-Long sits 91–94 MPH with average spin rates. He had average ride on the fastball last year in Low-A and it doesn’t look like that has changed at all. The pitch had 16.3&quot; IVB and 10&quot; HB last year. Those are both within a half standard deviation of average fastball movement. He throws his fastball from a generic arm slot with average velocity. Surely this is an average fastball? Except, average movement plays a lot worse than average usually because being unique matters in baseball. The average fastball shape is not the average fastball in results. This is a fine pitch and a usable one, but not one you want to rely on.</p><p>Sawyer Gipson-Long also throws a fringy changeup. He throws the changeup in the 82–85 MPH range without killing much spin from the fastball. Gipson-Long also has very limited depth on his changeup. There is good, albeit inconsistent fade, but Gipson-Long won’t really get chases off the plate because he drops the slot slightly. I can see a road to making the changeup okay, but I don’t think it’ll ever truly be a reliable weapon against left-handed hitters.</p><p>The slider might be everything Gipson-Long needs. The slider has ~-2&quot; IVB and 5&quot; sweep. That is elite depth for a slider and the lack of sweep helps set up a horizontal tunnel for the pitch off of the fastball. Gipson-Long just needs to throw the slider harder, as right now he lives in the 79–82 MPH range and that won’t cut it against major league hitters who chase less. The slider is maybe only a 55 on shape because of the velocity limitations, but it plays up because of fantastic feel and command over the pitch.</p><p>Gipson-Long will regularly backdoor sliders for called strikes and locate just below the zone to make everyone go fishing. He can also reliably land the slider for a strike in the zone when he needs to. However, I wouldn’t rely on that too heavily as the lack of velocity limits the in-zone whiff rates significantly. I’ll also note that given his slot and the vertical gyro spin oriented shape, Gipson-Long should not be running any significant platoon splits.</p><p>Sawyer Gipson-Long throws a lot of strikes despite frequently leading with his slider. He is in the strike zone at a very high rate and still runs plus chase rates. Gipson-Long misses very few bats in the zone, which is a red flag for the strikeout profile, but he will at least limit traffic in the form of walks. I think Gipson-Long is probably a reliever given his one pitch look, and not a great one at that, but if Gipson-Long can add two ticks to each pitch then he might look the part of a back-end starting pitcher.</p><h3>The Los Angeles Angels trade Noah Syndergaard to the Philadelphia Phillies for Mickey Moniak and Jadiel Sánchez</h3><h4>Jadiel Sánchez</h4><p>Mickey Moniak is the centerpiece of this trade and for those wondering what Moniak can be, he’s literally just been Jarred Kelenic in AAA this year. Almost the same top-end exit velocities, chase rates, and zone-contact rates. Both of them have major problems with chasing and missing on breaking balls but can do damage against fastballs. They are fairly comparable defensively as well. Neither of them has found major league success for obvious reasons, but they both have obvious potential.</p><p>Jadiel Sánchez would not have fetched Syndergaard on his own, but he is a solid prospect in his own right. The calling card for Sánchez is undoubtedly his ability to hit for power in the low minors. Before the trade, Jadiel Sánchez had the fourth highest hard-hit rate in the FSL at 43%. He was consistently scorching the ball. However, I think that number is in part a mirage of the competition quality that Sánchez was facing as a physically advanced 21-year-old. The top-end EVs suggest only 55 raw power potential.</p><p>The bigger problem is that despite some of the highest hard-hit rates in the league, Jadiel Sánchez only slugged .429. Why did Sánchez hit for so little power when he could clearly hit the ball so hard? The usual culprits are not to blame here as Sánchez hits the ball on the ground at an average rate and pulls nearly 50% of his contact. There are some issues with getting too far underneath pitches which lead to 11.8% of his batted balls being popups. The real reason for such a low slugging percentage, though, appears to be mostly luck as Jadiel Sánchez has an expecting slugging percentage of .497 according to a source.</p><p>Jadiel Sánchez is not just a one dimensional power bat, but he also makes contact at a high rate. Sánchez has connected on 77.9% of his swings this year. He is at 85.2% within the strike zone. He has shown the ability to catch up to velocity with his short load and is hitting pitches all over the zone. There is a lot of inferior quality contact on pitches inside, but he is consistently making contact at least.</p><p>Jadiel Sánchez has no troubles with breaking balls as a switch hitter and given that he offers plus bat speed from both sides of the plate, there is an argument for letting Sánchez continue to switch hit. The problem here is changeups. Sánchez is terrible against the changeup and will constantly go fishing for even the bad ones. He’s young, so I’m not too concerned yet, but it’s something to monitor and leads to some ugly chase rates (Also the high fastball).</p><p>Jadiel Sánchez is probably only a corner outfielder at the next level. He is a 50 grade runner who might lose another step as he grows into his somewhat thick frame. Sánchez has plus arm strength, but he’s still not an impact defensive option. There is risk in a bat-only type without the loudest power who is still stuck in Low-A. However, Sánchez has 55/55 offensive upside. Whenever you have the chance to acquire that alongside Jarred Kelenic in exchange for a rental starter; you take that chance.</p><h3>The Toronto Blue Jays trade Nick Frasso, and Moises Brito to the Los Angeles Dodgers for Mitch White and Alex De Jesus</h3><h4>Nick Frasso</h4><p>Nick Frasso has the chance to be special. A spotty injury history, brief track record of performance, and him turning 24 this offseason all hurt Frasso’s value to teams around the league. In addition, he has a whopping eleven innings above Low-A. I still think Frasso can be special though because he has some of the best raw stuff in the entire minors. The Dodgers are in the perfect position to absorb the risk and gamble on the upside that Frasso brings to the table.</p><p>Nick Frasso has an electric fastball, even if not for the reasons I usually call a heater electric. The fastball movement is distinctly lacking in vertical movement with just 15.7&quot; IVB and the VAA isn’t helped by a 6&#39; vertical release either. The only thing that makes Frasso’s fastball a plus pitch is just good old-fashioned velocity. Nick Frasso is averaging 95.7 MPH and has reached back for as high as 100.3 MPH. That is premium velocity and Frasso makes it play even better because he averages seven feet of extension. For all intents and purposes, it’s a 97 MPH fastball.</p><p>I lied when I said that the only thing that makes Frasso’s fastball good is his velocity. The vertical approach angles might be subpar, but the horizontal ones definetly are not at all. Nick Frasso is throwing from a -3.1&#39; horizontal release point which makes it very tough for hitters to track his pitches. He also has good horizontal movement as Frasso will average 12.4&quot; HB. There is no one in the majors with comparable velocity, angle, and movement. This is an outlier fastball that should be a plus pitch in the big leagues with both bat missing and barrel evading shape.</p><p>The slider is better than the fastball. Nick Frasso doesn’t use the sweeper that most pitchers would foolishly lean on from this arm slot but throws a very gyro reliant slider with riflespin that allows him to miss bats. The slider sits at 84.4 MPH on average with just -0.3&quot; IVB and 3.4&quot; of sweep. That is not a lot of sweep but it still plays up ala Andrew Heaney in the form of his extreme horizontal release point.</p><p>As if Nick Frasso wasn’t already good enough, it gets even better. Nick Frasso has an incredible tunnel between his slider and fastball. Nick Frasso can use the high fastball recklessly and then pull the bottom out with the slider that plummets through the zone. The pitches have almost identical spin rates and are in the sweet spot of ideal horizontal separation at 15.8&quot; of it. The two pitches look the same out of the hand, and break in opposing directions while splitting the plate vertically.</p><p>The scariest part is that the fastball and slider tunnels work best with the fastball up and the slider down- the two places they want to target as standalone offerings as well. Nick Frasso had a 40% chase rate with his fastball and a 49% chase rate with the slider in Low-A before the trade. The strike zone is weird shaped in the FSL but like…</p><p>Nick Frasso is already throwing an elite fastball and slider pairing, but there is still a third above-average pitch in his repertoire. The changeup would be the feature pitch for most of the pitchers I scouted in this blog, for Frasso it is an afterthought. Nick Frasso throws his changeup 250 RPMs higher than the fastball, but it’s also 9.4 MPH slower than the fastball. The changeup has above-average movement on both planes, and naturally pairs wonderfully with the fastball.</p><p>Nick Frasso throws his changeup from a spin axis that is thirty minutes more lateral than the heater. He has comparable spin efficiency on the two pitches. The changeup gets 7.5&quot; IVB and 18.2&quot; of tail to his arm side. That is good separation movement wise and velocity wise from his fastball. There is some drop in arm slot on the changeup, but I don’t think it’s enough of one to be a long-term issue for Frasso. The changeup has gotten chases in a small sample, and I’m expecting the feel to improve in Los Angeles until it’s a wipeout pitch that he doesn’t really need. Okay, he might need it since the slider has some platoon concern due to his arm slot. I digress. The changeup is helpful but not mandated for Frasso to make an impact in the majors.</p><p>Nick Frasso will probably walk just about nobody if he develops. The delivery might be unconventional for a starter, but walks aren’t a concern. The zone rates are below-average by a tad, but again, who cares? What matters most for avoiding walks is the ability to get chases and Frasso does that at an elite rate with all three pitches. Nick Frasso has gotten the batter to chase on 40.3% of out of zone pitches this year. (Normal zone dimensions, it’s even higher with testing zone).</p><p>Here is a fun fact, a source shared with me, that perfectly summarizes why the Blue Jays should not have traded Nick Frasso. With a minimum of ten innings, there are two pitchers above rookie-ball who have a chase rate over 40%, a zone rate over 40%, and an in-zone whiff rate of at least 25%. The first one is Jacob deGrom on a rehab assignment. The other is Nick Frasso. I understand the lack of track record, there is risk here. But this kind of stuff is extremely difficult to find. I think you have to shoot the moon with someone as talented as Frasso and buy in now before the cost is far too great to get him.</p><h4>Moises Brito</h4><p>Moises Brito is still in the DSL where he has been incredibly dominant. He sits at 89 MPH with his vertically moving fastball from a high slot. He also throws a curveball that I’d imagine the Dodgers are high on. The primary appeal of Moises Brito from where I stand is that Brito will walk nobody. In 32 minor league innings this year, Brito has exactly one walk. He fills the zone at a high rate and runs elite chase rates. I don’t know enough to really say what he is, but I think he is something, at least.</p><h4>Alex De Jesus</h4><p>Alex De Jesus is the prospect the Blue Jays receive alongside Mitch White in exchange for Nick Frasso. He is no Frasso by any means, but I think that De Jesus has a future in the major leagues. De Jesus offers power, and a disciplined approach at the hot corner that could let him succeed despite flimsy contact skills.</p><p>Alex De Jesus hits the ball hard and does so consistently at that. His exit velocities are good for his age at an 86.8 MPH average and a 102.5 MPH 90th EV. However, I have questions over how much power is left in the tank. De Jesus is only 21, but he has already completely maxed out the frame and any further strength gains might push him over to first base. I think De Jesus still has 55 raw power but I don’t consider it likely that it grows beyond that. He is more advanced in the power department than projectable there.</p><p>The good news is that 55 power could be enough for De Jesus to have strong contact quality. Alex De Jesus has plus feel to elevate, and he has fantastic barrel accuracy. The power might play down some because he struggles with pulling the ball consistently, but there is obvious impact potential here.</p><p>I want to double down on just how good De Jesus’s bat control and feel for the barrel is. Alex De Jesus is popping out just 3.5% of the time this year. He is also running plus sweet-spot rates and hitting line drives regularly. De Jesus is avoiding mishits and consistently hitting the ball hard at optimal angles. That combined with the advanced power leads to De Jesus posting great xwOBAcons. De Jesus will do damage on contact and that is why he might be an impact major leaguer one day.</p><p>Alex De Jesus is a very patient hitter who has no problem with waiting for pitches he can actually hit. Alex De Jesus is chasing just 19% of the time this year and has no problems with watching the secondary stuff that he struggles with as he hunts the fastball. This would be a good approach in the majors, but isn’t one in the minors. You can’t learn to hit a slider by not swinging at any sliders. When De Jesus offers on secondary stuff, he’s looked foolish in my looks. That might be some small sample bias in all fairness.</p><p>Alex De Jesus also has a major whiff problem. He is whiffing 34.6% of the time this year. The more concerning part of those whiff rates is that he is 5% below average within the strike zone. The most concerning part, however, is that De Jesus saw his whiff rate drop by 5% when he moved from Low-A to High-A+.</p><p>There is a lot of risk in the hit tool of De Jesus. If thing click than the power, patience, and barrel control will turn him into a very productive third baseman. If things don’t click, then he might never appear in the majors. This is a high-risk bat with some defensive questions that only further complicate things. I’m a big believer in contact quality being the most important part of hitting, so I have Alex De Jesus as a 40 FV. That might be too high because the contact skills are truly bad.</p><h3>The San Francisco Giants trade Trevor Rosenthal to the Milwaukee Brewers for Tristan Peters</h3><h4>Tristan Peters</h4><p>Tristan Peters is a hit first corner outfielder with below-average raw tools. He has been incredibly productive for the Brewers with a 134 PF wRC+ in High-A+ this season. I think that production is mostly a mirage, but I think Peters has a chance to be a useful major leaguer. He also really is a steep price to pay for a player you could have had in free agency for free just a few short weeks ago. (Anything more than cash considerations would be)</p><p>Tristan Peters makes a lot of contact. He doesn’t seem to care where the pitch is located- he just hits it. Tristan Peters has a 78.8% contact rate this year. If we isolate to pitches in the zone, it barely increases. I won’t lie and pretend that Peters doesn’t expand the zones for sliders away from him at times. However, I can honestly say it doesn’t really matter since Peters still pokes those sliders down the third base line. The swing decisions are largely above-average and he makes enough contact. You know those two skills in tandem will result in great things.</p><p>Tristan Peters has a problem with contact quality, however. His exit velocities are well below the MiLB average, but his problems go deeper than just not hitting for any power. Tristan Peters also has below-average popup rates (9%) and below-average line drive rates. Given all of that, I struggle to believe that Peters is any better than a league average BABIP guy despite the loud results this year.</p><p>The road to success for a 35 power bat with average BACON skills is narrow. The contact rates and walk rates have to be consistently elite for him to play regularly in the majors. The risk is compounded in this case too because Peters likely winds up in left field. There is more power upside here than I am giving him credit for because there’s some projection in the frame, but I can’t buy in on Peters. He’s a boring one dimensional bat with average athleticism. The upside is limited and I don’t think the floor is that high either.</p><h3>The Toronto Blue Jays trade Samad Taylor, and Max Castillo to the Kansas City Royals for Whit Merrifield</h3><h4>Samad Taylor</h4><p>In perhaps the most shocking move of the century, the Toronto Blue Jays acquired Whit Merrifield when he legally may not enter Canada. In case you forgot, Toronto is in Canada. Blue Jays questionable decision making aside, Samad Taylor is a utility depth/bench piece in the major leagues.</p><p>Samad Taylor is a plus runner with experience at several positions. He is most at home playing second base where you can best hide below-average arm strength and he shows good range there. Taylor isn’t good enough to be an everyday second baseman, though, so he also fills in at shortstop, third base, and the outfield. The speed and versatility make Taylor a sure bet to keep on getting chances at the major league level on a team’s bench, even when he is not hitting.</p><p>I think the most fascinating thing about Samad Taylor is that his wRC+ is down 40 points this year despite both his contact rate and exit velocities improving this year. The reason for this regression is mostly just incredible BABIP luck balancing out. Taylor ran .394 BABIP last year despite below-average popup rates and a 7th percentile line drive rate. Maybe there was some difficult to quantify element to Taylor last year but whatever it was is gone now.</p><p>Samad Taylor is showing roughly league average exit velocities in AAA, which is a tremendous step in the right direction for Samad Taylor. He is still putting the ball in the air at a very high rate, so I suspect Taylor will tap into most of his 45 grade raw power in games. The barrel accuracy is still a large concern that introduces risk but improved bat speed gives Samad Taylor a much greater error margin.</p><p>Samad Taylor, as I already mentioned, also improved his contact rates this year. He is down to just a 27.8% whiff rate this year and has league average contact rates within the strike zone. Samad Taylor is still a patient hitter who works his walks. I have some concerns about the contact skills actually translating and that combined with the BACON concern, has Taylor with a below-average hit tool.</p><p>Samad Taylor is not an exciting player, but he is useful. He has shown some semblance of both contact and power with a disciplined approach. He can go on a tear for a few weeks but will be streaky and have long ebbs as well because of the poor barrel accuracy. I’m confident that Samad is a major league role player, so he earns a 40 FV, but given the lack of upside, it’s a very low 40.</p><h4>Max Castillo</h4><p>Max Castillo is an interesting pitching prospect, but I think a relief role is probably the most likely scenario for Castillo in the majors. There is a road to three quality pitches within Castillo, but there are general stuff limitations for as long as Castillo is throwing with diminished velocity as a starter.</p><p>The fastball is an average pitch as a starting pitcher. Max Castillo is averaging 93.5 MPH out of the bullpen. That is likely closer to ~92 MPH as a full time starting pitcher, but it still plays up some because of Castillo having 6.8&#39; of extension. The fastball is coming from a fairly high release at 6&#39; and a wide horizontal release at -3&#39;. The angle is unique and helps a fastball with subpar vertical movement miss some bats. The appeal here, though, is primarily that Castillo gets 13.2&quot; of arm side movement to go with his 14.7&quot; IVB. The fastball should miss some bats- depending on where the velocity is at and get weak contact with his fastball.</p><p>Most analysts think the changeup is the best pitch that Max Castillo throws. I don’t know that I agree with that assessment. Max Castillo has a few very desirable traits in his changeup. His arm action helps hide the ball, and he shows feel to locate it down in the zone. It looks like a fastball out of the hand, and Castillo can pull the string out from underneath it to as it has 9.2&quot; less IVB than the heater.</p><p>The problem with the changeup is it doesn’t matter if hitters are guessing fastball on the changeup. The changeup is only 5.7 MPH slower than the fastball. He has only 0.5&quot; more horizontal movement on the changeup. No one is swinging through the changeup despite good deception, because it plays as a fastball for all intents and purposes.</p><p>The vertical depth is great, but the problem is that his fastball (Especially with lower velocity as a starting pitcher.) function best down in the zone; in basically the same location as the changeup’s ideal spot. Castillo either has to choose to throw the fastball in a spot where it will be hit hard, or use the changeup near exclusively out of the strike zone, and play for chases. I think the latter is probably the better strategy as a starter, even if it means more walks. However, if he can just add velocity, I’d definetly embrace the high fastball. Alternatively, you could work on subtracting a few ticks from the changeup and let it dominate by getting late swings.</p><p>The slider is not used all that often, but has real impact potential. We call the cutter a slider because he only sits at 83.5 MPH with it, but in terms of shape, it has a lot more in common with a gyro cutter. The cutter is on a 11:00 observed spin axis with an hour of axis deviation on average. He gets just 4.8&quot; IVB and 2.1&quot; of cut on average, because he is throwing the 2350 RPMs slider with only 24% spin efficiency.</p><p>I think the best path to develop the slider is to turn it into a true cutter by adding velocity. He has good vertical on the pitch for a cutter and could build an idealized horizontal tunnel between the slider and fastball. The pitch performs poorly right now, because of velocity constraints. However, the upside is significant with further development in the right direction. There is also a chance that Castillo can add a sweeper, given the feel for gyro spin, the low arm slot, and for seam-shifted wake. However, I think a sweeper would be a mistake unless he finds the harder cutter first.</p><p>Right now, Max Castillo likely projects to slot in as a swing man in the majors. You can start him in a pinch and get serviceable production, but he will not be reliable. The stuff plays up best in relief, without further strength gains. On a team with good development, Castillo could become a useful back of the rotation starter, but I don’t consider that likely anymore. He’s a solid arm and a low 40 FV given that he is already contributing in the MLB. There is limited upside, but he has value.</p><h3>The Oakland Athletics trade Austin Allen to the St. Louis Cardinals for Carlos Guarate</h3><h4>Carlos Guarate</h4><p>Carlos Guarate finds whatever success he has had by throwing six different pitches at opposing hitters. Zero of these pitches even warrants an average grade, but there is something to be said about having a multitude of them. He throws strikes at a high rate and has some strength projection left.</p><p>Carlos Guarate needs to add a lot more strength than you can ever reasonably project, though. He sits at 89.1 MPH with less than 5&quot; of extension. His perceived velocity is about 86 MPH. The fastball has below-average ride, and above-average tail. The fastball should miss exactly zero bats at the major league level, given that it is also a generic release height.</p><p>There is one thing a friend pointed out that might improve his fastball. Carlos Guarate is throwing from an over the top arm slot, and really just steps and throws. If Guarate was to lengthen his stride by at least a foot, it’s a given that extension would improve, and likely velocity would as well. He would also lower the release height considerably. Strider farther would let Guarate generate more power from his lats and come from lower down the mound. Maybe, that is enough to get the fastball useable in the majors.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*S1IPVbq0WbfdkSK_X9vQTQ.png" /></figure><p>I really don’t enjoy breaking down four mediocre secondary pitches with the same suggestion of throwing a zillion times harder. Instead, I’ve inserted a screenshot of his pitch data of every pitch from <a href="https://will-hoefer.shinyapps.io/FSLPCLHawkeye/">Will Hoefer’s board</a>. The appeal of Guarate is that he only cost Austin Allen to acquire. He throws strikes and profiles as a low minors innings eater.</p><h3>The Chicago Cubs trade Mychal Givens to the New York Mets for Saúl González</h3><h4>Saúl González</h4><p>Saúl González is 6&#39;7&quot; and is performing in Low-A this year. He misses a lot of bats right now, and most of those whiffs are coming within the strike zone. Saúl González also throws a lot of strikes. I’m not convinced he has the repertoire depth to start in the major leagues, but there is an upside for some sort of big league role, and it’s not hard to see him progressing into an impact player one day.</p><p>The fastball is a plus pitch that has the potential to be great, but I’ll hedge for now. Saúl sits at at 92.3 MPH and only tops out at 95.2 MPH. However, he has an incredible extension at 7.3&#39; on average, which adds about ~94 MPH perceived velocity. Saúl González is 6&#39;7&quot; need I remind you, and there is still strength projection to come. He also throws the fastball on a 12:45 axis with spin rates of about ~2350 RPMs. Despite his gigantic stature, and standard 3/4 arm slot, Saúl only has a release height of 6&#39;. This standard arm slot makes it easy to imagine that González can move out of the dead zone with his fastball and start showing plus vertical movement.</p><p>The secondary stuff lags behind the fastball. His best weapon is probably a below-average slutter. He throws with an 11:00 tilt and has low spin efficacy. He needs to throw it harder than 82.3 MPH for what is a gyro cutter shape to perform. There is also a slurvy with okay depth but not enough sweep at 78.2 MPH. The changeup rounds out his arsenal with a clear feel to kill both spin and velocity as Saúl González sits at 1521 RPMs and 83.8 MPH. The shape is terrible though as he throws it on a 1:15 spin axis which leads to poor movement on both planes. There is some upside but he probably needs to change his grip. I think a splitter makes the most sense but any fading changeup would do wonders for the profile.</p><p>Saúl González is very much a developmental piece for the Cubs. He only has one pitch that projects to make an impact with fringy secondary stuff. The appeal here is primarily strength projection and the fastball. There is also the added benefit of obvious plus command. González throws a ton of strikes and can elevate his heater regularly. This profile has considerable risk but I think if you can develop just one of the secondaries to an average pitch, the fastball can really play up in a bullpen role. Starting is not impossible either, just not likely at this phase in his development cycle.</p><p><em>Thank you so much for reading over the years. This has really meant a lot to me. Follow me on Twitter </em><a href="https://twitter.com/Tieran711"><em>@Tieran711</em></a><em> for more content in the future. I’m excited for what comes next.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f32c891b8071" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Boston Red Sox Draft Analysis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/boston-red-sox-draft-analysis-562b39cc884c?source=rss-f20e8b3389a4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/562b39cc884c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb-draft]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[red-sox]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[boston]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tieran Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Aug 2022 18:05:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-02T18:05:19.013Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Boston Red Sox had their first selection at #24 overall and went with a player very few people thought would go in the first round in Mikey Romero. They then drafted two more highly expensive prep targets with their next two picks. To facilitate those very early prep selections, the Red Sox had to go with a lot of cheaper options on day two but those players still all have a decent shot at making an impact in the major leagues one day. They also managed to snag some intriguing developmental projects on day three that I think could be something one day.</p><p>In this piece, I will break down all of the players that the Red Sox drafted this year. From #24 overall to #609, here is every player joining the Red Sox organization through the draft and why you should be excited to maybe one day see them in Boston. I will not be grading draft picks or calling any player bad. If a pick is good is defined by your plan to develop them, I don’t have the knowledge to judge that so all picks are fine until we see that they were not.</p><p><em>The FV system is stupid but I use it to clickbait people. Prospects are infinitely more complicated than one number. It’s a loose baseline but I like players with low FVs and dislike ones with a higher FV. The report is what matters, not the number. X is a placeholder for players that I do not have enough information to assess.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/570/1*vejoznQ5Kk2MwBUPvqPWfA.png" /></figure><h3>1.24 2B/SS Mikey Romero, Orange Lutheran HS</h3><p>A lot of my defensive grading is based on crowd-sourced information and athletic profiling. Scouting defense is the most time-consuming part of the scouting process because you can’t just watch ten swings, look at data and make conclusions. You need at least a few dozen plays on defense to accurately assess a player and finding those dozen plays is a pain in the ass because no one makes compilations of every fielding play for a prospect in the public sphere. Because of that, for anybody but the very top tier of prospects, I usually trust consensus opinions that look at the largest sample of plays- unless the consensus is obviously stupid. There is no consensus for Mikey Romero.</p><p>Mikey Romero is either considered an above-average shortstop or a terrible one with zero chance of sticking, depending on who you ask. MLB Pipeline falls in the former camp with Baseball America and Mason McRae falling in the latter. Prospect Live is also on the good shortstop side of things as are most of my team contacts that I’ve asked about Mikey. The athletic testing, however, is quite poor with limited range and only average arm strength. I probably lead towards the not a shortstop outcome but I have no confidence in that assessment.</p><p>The bat is what defines Mikey, however, and it looks to be quite a good one. Mikey Romero has a plus hit tool. The contact rates are superb and the swing is clearly optimized for making frequent contact. Romero’s swing is short and punchy which leads to him hitting velocity and he shows feel for recognizing spin. The bat stays on plane for a while and he shows the ability to adjust to what he is seeing to avoid being beat multiple times. The barrel stays in the zone so the contact window is longer too.</p><p>Mikey Romero also has obvious power potential. He had the best bat speed of any player at the MLB Draft Combine topping out at 84 MPH with a pretty standard 31.5 oz bat. The power potential is there to some degree but Mikey also tested poorly in events like the countermovement jump which calls his lower half explosion into doubt. I think the bat speed is truly elite so there is at least above-average raw power but it’s all hand and torso reliant so it won’t ever be elite power.</p><p>I also don’t think Mikey is that likely to get to all of that power in games, given how contact-oriented the swing is. He has a deep connection point that stops him from building up his bat speed in games and as a result makes it hard for Romero to pull the ball with authority. The swing is also a bit flat and there’s limited feel to elevate. Romero has power potential but it’s hard to see how it will manifest right now.</p><p>Mikey Romero will flash signs of both a plus hit tool and plus power. Those are almost never at the same time and likely never will be but he shows promise in a multitude of ways. If the Red Sox are higher on his athleticism and long term outlook at shortstop then he made sense as a first round pick. It’s also worth recognizing that Romero signed for slightly below the slot value.</p><h3>2.41 3B/SS/P Cutter Coffey, Liberty High School</h3><p>Cutter Coffey played both ways in high school and actually would have been a top 300 prospect for me as a pitcher but it sounds like he is forsaking the mound so I’ll skip over that and only analyze Coffey at the plate.</p><p>Cutter Coffey predictably has a cannon in the infield given that he is throwing 95 MPH off of the mound. There is also some semblance of accuracy and he shows power from multiple slots. Cutter Coffey is a bit of a thicker person without great lateral mobility and speed. He plays shortstop right now but as he ages, he’ll slide to the hot corner and provide quality defense there.</p><p>The power is loud and impactful. Coffey made some adjustments to his swing this spring that let him get a lot more out of his backside and as a result, the power has taken off. There are some explosive movements to his swing with lightning quick hands and a strong lower half. I’m fairly confident that Coffey will grow into plus power in his prime.</p><p>The hit tool has some more questions due to the violent nature of his strike but he still hit for average in high school. The bat path is good- maybe even a bit too short and he shows feel for recognizing spin. I have the hit tool as below-average due to minor swing and miss concerns but only barely. The power and hit combo are potent in tandem and he’ll stick at third. If the Red Sox think the hit tool is just a teensy bit better than I do then Coffey would be worthy of a first round signing bonus.</p><h3>2.79 RF/CF Roman Anthony, Stoneman Douglas HS</h3><p>Roman Anthony is another prep bat that the Red Sox opted to give first round money to in the second round. Anthony has loud tools with the potential for plus speed, arm strength, defense in right field, and of course, power. The concern is the hit tool that will define if he can play in the majors.</p><p>The hit tool has made major strides in the last year, however. Roman Anthony cut his strikeout rate from 19.3% to 11.6% as a senior at Marjory Stoneman Douglas. I actually like the bat path and he makes solid swing decisions so there is hope for the hit tool. The reason I struggle to believe in Roman’s hit tool is that he just gets stiff. Most of that stiffness is in his lead leg and his stiff posture makes it hard for him to adapt to stuff down in the zone. There is also some uncontrolled violence that gives me some pause. I think given the caliber of the athlete, it is very possible I’m overstating that concern and he can clean up his posture issues.</p><p>The main attraction here, however, is Roman’s ability to hit for power. Roman Anthony has electric bat speed and generates a lot of torque with his very rotational swing. His lower half is just as attractive as the upper body with strength and speed. the pelvis can leak early and sometimes the shorter path will gets his arms out in front of the hips but the power potential is incredibly obvious. Anthony also has a fairly steep VBA and hits with positive attack angles so I think the power should mostly play in games.</p><p>Roman Anthony is a plus athlete with strong run times in every event he’s done. The only concern regarding the long term speed- and as such defensive profile is that there is still considerable projection in Anthony’s 6&#39;3&quot; frame and he’ll probably fill in a bit more below the waist. Depending on how the body progresses will decide if he sticks in centerfield or not. If he can’t stick then his plus arm will play in right field where he throws hard and on a line with some accuracy. Anthony also has a short arm action that might hypothetically help the arm play up.</p><p>Roman Anthony is a tooled up kid whose value to the Red Sox will be defined by the hit tool and physical projection. The Red Sox have a habit of taking players with hit questions which I would assume means that Boston thinks they can fix it. If they can then Anthony is great value even at a first round bonus because the tools play. If they can’t then things are a bit murkier.</p><h3>3.99 RP/SP Dalton Rogers, Southern Mississippi</h3><p>If you had offered me a 1000:1 odds that Dalton Rogers wouldn’t have gone in the first three rounds I would have taken them. As in if he goes in the first three rounds I give you a thousand dollars and if he doesn’t you give me one. I don’t really think Dalton Rogers is bad per se, he just doesn’t make sense to me this early- on paper.</p><p>Dalton Rogers pitched exclusively in relief in college last year and only at most three of those guys are drafted in the first three rounds usually. Additionally, he’s a draft eligible sophomore and as a result, probably won’t save the Red Sox that much money. He used one pitch close to 90% of the time and still had control issues. Those are all reasons to not take him early no matter how good the stuff metrics may be. I get why the Red Sox took him so early but also I don’t at all.</p><p>Dalton Rogers has a very modern fastball that should dominate in the majors. The pitch certainly dominated at the collegiate level which led to Rogers throwing it 87.6% of the time and he found great success in doing so with a 1.95 ERA and a 3.31 FIP. Dalton Rogers, obviously, can’t continue to spam the fastball to such a ridiculous degree at the next level though, no matter how good it may be.</p><p>That fastball really is that good though and there are shades of Freddy Peralta in the profile. Dalton Rogers throws from what Trackman has as a 5.07&#39; release height which would be one of the lowest in the majors. He is theoretically, the rare player with above-average vertical movement from such a low release. The fastball, in theory, averages 18.1&quot; IVB and 12.1&quot; HB which would be a fantastic movement profile.</p><p>I have a hard time believing that though when the fastball averages less than 2000 RPMs. Josh Winder has 99% spin efficiency on his fastball that is 3 RPMs higher and gets 17.5&quot; IVB and 8&quot; HB. I think it’s likely that Rogers is playing with a miscalibrated trackman and is closer to average ride than plus movement. The VAA is still incredible because of how low the release height is but it’s maybe not quite generational.</p><p>The fastball velocity is solid and thrown from the left handed side. Dalton Rogers sits at 93.2 MPH and has touched as high as 96.2 MPH. Dalton Rogers also has above-average extension so the velocity plays up. However, there are some concerns that he won’t be able to hold that velocity, if stretched out to start. This is largely because of his 5&#39;11&quot; frame and I don’t think there is much room for further strength projection. In spite, of those minor quibbles, this is still an electric fastball with both velocity and elite angle. He needs to elevate a lot more but even down in the zone, this pitch fucks.</p><p>The secondaries actually have potential, even if they lack feel because of a lack of usage at the present time. The changeup is the best one by far. The pitch has above-average shape with 6.7&quot; IVB and 14.1&quot; HB even if it is nothing spectacular. There is nearly 10 MPH of velocity separation as well while only shaving off ~100 RPMs. There is some deceptive elements here and solid movement but he often hangs them and struggles to find the zone. It is a loose average projection on the pitch but he has to use it more even if it winds up as below-average.</p><p>The slurve is solidish too in a small sample given that he only uses it 3.8% of the time. The hybrid pitch is thrown at 81.5 MPH with just -6.5&quot; IVB and 9.1&quot; HB. I don’t think it’s even an average pitch unless he adds velocity and there is both limited feel and command. At the same time, I wonder if calling it a slider would make it seem good? -6.5&quot; IVB is more than all but one slider this year and 9&quot; of sweep is solid too from a lower slot. At the same time, if it’s a curveball then it’s an awful pitch on both planes with only slightly below-average velo. It’s a weird hybrid slurve that I might buy in on with performance but for now, can’t trust. I totally get it if the Red Sox disagree. The fact that it is another very low spin pitch limits shape projection as well.</p><p>I get why the Red Sox would take Dalton Rogers this early and I don’t even necessarily dislike the pick that much. I just find it hard to properly respect someone using one pitch 88% of the time and walking 15% of batters while spamming the fastball in relief. The stuff is here and if things break right then he is a starting pitcher- possibly even a very good one. A bullpen role is the likely outcome but the fastball should do a lot of work in that role. It’s a fine pick it’s just a surprising and risky one.</p><h3>4.129 2B Chase Meidroth, San Diego</h3><p>Chase Meidroth has probably the best contact skills in the entire draft. He had the highest contact rate of any player with 50+ BBE in a trackman game at 95.2%. As you would expect, the player with the highest contact rate in college baseball strikes out 9.1% of the time.</p><p>How does that make sense? Meidroth simply doesn’t believe in swinging the bat. Chase Meidroth only swung at 33.7% of pitches this year. That is over 10% less than the average hitter and in the 4th percentile. He has no ability to discern if what he swinging at is in the zone or not. His zone swing rate is in the 1st percentile at 50.2% in Trackman games. He only chases 19% of the time but relative to his zone-swing rates that really is not good. The abundance of strikes looking is why he still strikes out some despite having the best contact rates in the country.</p><p>The BABIP skills are not all that strong to the surprise of no one. Nobody not named Luis Arráez has good BABIP skills when making so much contact though. Meidroth does not hit the ball particularly hard as we’ll cover more in depth later. He also has below-average line drive rates, only 55 grade popup rates, and 55 grade spray charts. The spin traits are also below-average.</p><p>Chase Meidroth’s raw power is a complicated element of his game. Meidroth has a top 8th EV of 98.8 MPH and a Max EV of 101.5 MPH in Trackman games when you filter out all batted balls with low launch confidence and a launch angle below 0°. However, a source has told me that they have him at a 90th EV of 101.2 MPH and a Max EV of 106 MPH which would put Meidroth right around the collegiate average. I have no idea what they are looking at but I’m choosing to side with the 117 BBE Trackman sample that I have when judging his raw power. I would assume that the Red Sox are looking at the more optimistic numbers.</p><p>Then again, Chase Meidroth has a 74th percentile ISOcon this year? So maybe the power is really something? He doesn’t hit the ball in the air very often or hit that many line drives so that can’t be why there is some game power. I guess the EVs have to be better than I thought?</p><p>Truth be told I have no idea what to make of Chase Meidroth. I know he makes a lot of contact and the swing mechanics look good. I think he’s probably a second baseman with very little power which is a profile I dislike- perhaps somewhat irrationally. However, I know some people think he has the arm to potentially play third and some reports have the EVs listed higher. I have a 35 FV on Meidroth but I totally understand why the Red Sox like him more and don’t really hate this pick.</p><h3>5.159 RP Noah Dean, Old Dominion</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/exploring-the-most-unheralded-demographic-college-relievers-3c8239930dc6"><em>I already wrote a very detailed scouting report of Noah Dean in my Relievers Blog so if you want more on him as a pitcher, go read that one. </em></a><em>This report is going to go into less detail and work as more of a general overview.</em></p><p>Noah Dean is one of the best pure relievers in this year’s draft but there is no sugarcoating the fact that he is just a reliever. The fastball is electric with Dean averaging 95.6 MPH and touching as high as 99 MPH from the left handed side of the rubber. On top of the velocity, Dean averages 2375 RPMs from a very vertical arm slot.</p><p>The vertical slot with high spin rates leads to Noah Dean getting elite vertical movement on his fastball. The fastball is thrown on a 1:00 axis with very high spin efficiency and as a result Dean gets 21.8&quot; IVB on average to go along with 9.3&quot; of arm side movement. That is above-average horizontal action on a four-seam fastball.</p><p>That is more vertical movement than anyone in College Baseball who averages at least 93 MPH on their fastball. The only minor leaguer I know of with more vertical movement at 93+ is Daniel Espino. There is no major leaguer with more vertical movement than Dean with the same specifications. The release is generic at 6&#39; but who cares when you have that much vertical movement. Obviously, there are concerns about the accuracy of the Trackman, however. Still, the fact that it’s better than all his collegiate peers clearly suggests that the vertical movement is not a fluke.</p><p>On top of the 80 grade fastball, Noah Dean has what might potentially be a plus curveball. The curveball has an incredible shape as he averages -15.4&quot; IVB on average. That is in the 92nd percentile of curveball drop. He also has 10&quot; of sweep. 78 MPH isn’t incredible velocity for a curve but for one with as much drop as Dean, it’s more than enough.</p><p>The problem with Dean’s curve is deception. The fastball and curve are separated by 18 MPH with completely opposite shape. They don’t tunnel for even a second, and as such the curveball gets very few chases despite great shape. Dean has elite feel for spin and depth so this is a high upside breaking ball but he does have to revamp the shape some to cut it as a high leverage reliever.</p><p>The control woes are also an obvious flaw which is why Dean was still available at #159 despite 80 grade stuff. Noah Dean is an uber-talented arm but is too flawed as a reliever to go much higher than this. I do like the value for the Red Sox though and he has as high of a chance as anyone the Red Sox drafted to be a valued contributor in the major leagues one day.</p><h3>6.189 SP/RP Alex Hoppe, UNC Greensboro</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/best-underslot-targets-on-day-two-of-the-draft-a35c5489a7b2"><em>I already wrote a very detailed scouting report of Alex Hoppe in my under slot targets Blog so if you want more on him as a pitcher, go read that one.</em></a><em> This report is going to go into less detail and work as more of a general overview.</em></p><p>I was a bit too high on Alex Hoppe before the draft. I under estimated how common his general profile was and how much of an impact age should probably have. That does not mean I dislike Hoppe in any way, he’s slid from a very late third round grade to a very early fourth round one for me. Based on his signing for only $32,250; I still consider this to be one of the best value selections of the entire draft.</p><p>Alex Hoppe has a plus fastball. The pitch touches as high as 99.2 MPH and averaged 96.3 MPH this year. That was as a reliever but Hoppe was still averaging over 40 pitches per outing so I’m not expecting that big of a dropoff if stretched out to start. The fastball has above-average ride from a generic release height on top of that velocity. Plus horizontal movement at 12.3&quot; HB is just the icing on the cake.</p><p>The slider is nasty too. He throws it at 85.4 MPH with both depth and sweep as he averages 0.2&quot; IVB and 11.6&quot; HB. He throws from a somewhat low slot that helps the slider play up as well. He got swinging-strikes on 25.2% of sliders last year and those whiffs came both in the zone and out.</p><p>The primary problem with the slider is a lack of command. Hoppe struggles to throw the pitch in the zone with any regularity. His zone rate was just below 25% this year. Hoppe doesn’t just barely miss either, he is often throwing sliders way off the plate and in the dirt. Low-level hitters will chase that crap but it won’t fly at the higher levels. This slider has plus shape but it’s only an above-average grade until he figures out where the heck he is going with it.</p><p>The changeup rounds out the repertoire. Alex Hoppe only threw 11 of them this year with Trackman data so take all of this with a grain of salt. The changeup is inarguably a distinct pitch and also inarguably really good pitch specs. The changeup sits at 86.4 MPH with a spin rate of 1848 RPMs. That is 9.9 MPH slower than the fastball. He throws the Cambio on a 2:00 spin tilt with high efficiency and the result is him getting 17.5 HB and 11.7 IVB on the changeup.</p><p>That is 93rd percentile arm-side movement on the changeup relative to the major leagues. The depth is limited but the one plane movement might help him sell it as the fastball before it runs away from them and misses bats/gets weak contact because of poor timing due to the velocity difference. The feel is absolutely abysmal and it will take serious work to develop the pitch but there is real impact potential in the changeup.</p><p>Alex Hoppe has some command woes. Spoiler alert but pretty much every arm the Red Sox drafted this year has below-average command. He has good batted ball traits due to his fastball shape and the potential for three pitches. As such, I want to see him get a chance to start. However, I also think he probably winds up in the bullpen long term, if only because he is already 23. I still love this pick and player but the flaws are larger than I acknowledged last time I wrote about him.</p><h3>7.219 RP/SP Caleb Bolden, TCU</h3><p>Caleb Bolden is another pitcher with command woes but solid stuff that could be good with a velocity boost. This is the favorite profile of teams with more modern pitching development and an analytical focus. Coincidentally, it’s one of my favorite molds as well. Admittedly, Bolden isn’t my favorite version of the profile but he still has the potential to make an impact in the majors one day.</p><p>The fastball is an interesting but highly flawed pitch. Bolden only sits at 92 MPH and tops out at 95 as a right handed starter. I will note that some people in the industry I’ve talked to think he can add a few ticks more velocity. The spin rates are right around league average- maybe a tick above. The fastball has dead zone movement with a tail. He gets 13.6&quot; IVB and 13.8&quot; HB on average. So where is the appeal at all whatsoever?</p><p>Caleb Borden has excellent release traits and that is why I find the fastball intriguing. Borden throws from a low arm slot with a 5.2&#39; vertical release point that flattens his VAA up in the zone. The problem is that at the end of the day this is a dead zone fastball so it will still miss no bats. Except, it doesn’t have to remain a dead zone fastball; I think Bolden is an ideal candidate to transition to a sinker. Not only would such a change help the fastball have some viability but it would also better set up the slider.</p><p>The reasons for believing in the sinker development is he already kind of has one in his changeup. The changeup has 3.9&quot; IVB and 15.2&quot; HB which is good movement for either a changeup or sinker. The problem with his changeup is that Bolden only throws it 5MPH slower than the fastball.</p><p>Subtracting velocity is the path for conventional changeup development but what if we do the opposite? What if we bring it up to where the fastball velocity is and give him a sinking option? Obviously, sinker development is not that simple but the feel to pronate around a changeup and get depth on it, has me believing that Bolden can develop a good sinker.</p><p>The sweeper is a dirty pitch that easily warrants a plus grade. The sweep should probably be thrown a bit harder than 80.7 MPH on average but the movement is so incredible that I don’t think it’s neccesarily mandatory for Bolden to do so. Bolden averages -3.8&quot; IVB and 13.2&quot; HB on the sweeper. The only major league pitches with as much velo and movement in both directions belong to Sonny Gray, Aaron Bummer, Clarke Schmidt, José Berríos, Charlie Morton and Matt Brash (The Knuckle Curve). That is elite company for Bolden to consider himself a part of.</p><p>Caleb Bolden has great slider shape and the potential for a good sinker from the same tunnel with inverted movement. If Bolden can add more velocity then both pitches could take off and he might be ticketed for a high leverage relief role. My concerns boil down to secondary command, and I don’t think the changeup will work if he switches to a sinker. There is a route to starting here but he’s likely a reliever with a sweeper heavy approach.</p><h3>8.249 SP Jonathan Brand, Miami (Ohio)</h3><p>Jonathan Brand is another low release savant who doesn’t throw hard but has a track record of performing and somewhat interesting stuff. I am lower on Brand because I don’t think there is room to improve his velocity with a 5&#39;9&quot; frame that is already pretty much maxed out and Brand is only sitting at 91 MPH and topping out at 95 MPH right now. If you think he can add a tick or two then I can understand being more optimistic.</p><p>My concern is that the fastball movement profile is very poor. The fastball has below-average ride even on the overly generous college trackman units. Brand gets just 15.2&quot; IVB and 10.6&quot; HB. This is a generic spin pitch with efficiency issues from a generic slot and only average spin rates. The fastball has some upside because it’s a 5&#39; release height and 1.5&#39; horizontal release but it’s hard to see the pitch really being all that dominant.</p><p>The slider is probably Jonathan Brand’s best pitch. He sits at 82 MPH with spin rates of about 2600 RPMs. The pitch has generic gyroball shape from a sub-optimal horizontal release and as such only grades out as average. The changeup is there with some depth at 1700 RPMs and 80 MPH but he gets very little horizontal action most of the time. Some upside but fringy pitch overall. The curveball has -12.8&quot; IVB and 12.8&quot; HB but is only thrown at 75.9 MPH. As a result, the pitch is loopy and doesn’t really get anyone to expand the zone in pursuit of it.</p><p>If I’m being totally honest, I don’t think Jonathan Brand projects for much more than average command. The low release is intriguing but I’m fairly underwhelmed by the profile for an 8th round pick, I just think the range of likely outcomes tops out near a AAA depth starter. This is also a 7.5K signing bonus, so I think the Red Sox would be more than happy with that outcome.</p><h3>9.279 C Brooks Brannon, Randleman High School</h3><p>Brooks Brannon has big power from behind the plate and those players tend to stumble into regular playing time in the majors; even when they do not hit. Brannon still could hit but I do think his most likely role is probably as a part time catcher with pop and an above-average arm. He’s not the smoothest blocker of breaking balls and is a bit larger so sticking behind the plate is not a guarantee either. The bat is what you buy on and catching is an arguable bonus.</p><p>As I already mentioned, Brooks Brannon has plus raw power. He has elite max bat speed and also a very strong lower half. His issues in the power deparment primarily stem from him getting disjointed and not far enough into his backside before the hands start to fire. I also have some concerns with his ability to elevate due to swing shape but that is a much more minor concern.</p><p>Brooks Brannon has some swing and miss to his game as well. The approach is patient as a whole in my looks but he struggles with good breaking balls. The bat path is solid and he won’t ever be completely lost at the plate but his timing is off and he swings through stuff as a result. The offensive upside here is loud and he can catch but theere is certainly work to be done. Still good value for this late in the draft.</p><h3>10.309 SP/RP Isaac Coffey, Oral Roberts</h3><p>I had never watched Isaac Coffey or even heard of him before the draft. If I had I probably would have hyped him up way too much because it’s such a fun profile. Fun and good are very different things, obviously, but there is quite a bit to like in Coffey and I think he could provide real vaue in the majors one day.</p><p>Isaac Coffey is your stereotypical unique look reliever in a lot of ways but he has a real chance of sticking in a starter and stands out a bit more than the rest. The fastball only sits at 89.4 MPH as a starter in a limited sample with Trackman data. The pitch is a two-seamer with 11.2&quot; IVB and 19.3&quot; HB. That is 99th percentile horizontal movement and fairly average depth.</p><p>The real draw of the fastball though is the arm angle. Isaac Coffey throws from a 4.3&#39; release height with a 2.9&#39; horizontal release. Those are both extreme outlier figures. Especially with this kind of velocity. Only one pitcher in college baseball throws this hard from as low of an arm slot. That one pitcher is William Kempner who admittedly throws a lot harder.</p><p>Regardless, the pitch has enough vertical movement to function as a flat VAA whiff pitch up in the zone or more optimally down in the zone and to the gloved side for called strikes and a lot of groundballs. This is a deadly hybrid offering that has the velocity to actually translate. He also will occasionally mix in a slightly slower cutter with ~9&quot; IVB and 2&quot; of cut which has some viability as well.</p><p>The breaking ball has obscene movement from the optimal slot for this kind of breaking ball. Coffey averages -3.1&quot; IVB and 18.5&quot; of sweep on his slider. Only one pitch in the majors averages as much movement on both planes- Phil Maton’s curveball. When you combine elite movement with elite arm angle that enhances the HAA you should have and elite pitch. But… Isaac Coffey only averages 72.5 MPH wiht his slider. There is obvious potential here but he needs to add velocity and a lot of it for it to play. We’ll see what the shape looks like after Coffey does that; I’d bet it will look quite a bit different.</p><p>The changeup is Coffey’s least refined pitch with no feel or command but I think it will still eventually become his best one.. The changeup sits at 80 MPH on average which is solid separation from the fastball at a comparable spin rate. The more important element is his 80 grade movement profile as Coffey averaged -0.1&quot; IVB and 20.6&quot; HB on the changeup this year. I think with some work this pitch could do a lot of damage to opposing hitters. He hardly throws it and again feel, but he shouldn’t need elite feel for it to perform in all likelihood.</p><p>The other interesting thing about Isaac Coffey is that he throws strikes at an incredibly high rate despite an unorthodox delivery. He walked just 4.4% of batters this year and 3.7% the year prior. Isaac Coffey has a chance to stick in the rotation despite how weird it looks because he throws strikes at a high rate and has three promising pitches. The velocity holds up in the later innings as well. For Coffey to truly be an impact arm he has to find more velocity but even as is, there is big league upside.</p><h3>11.339 RP/SP Marques Johnson, Long Beach State</h3><p>I think Marques Johnson probably will wind up in the bullpen at the next level due to a lack of pitches that can beat left handed hitters. However, he has three pitches with decent control and weak contact so it’s not impossible he sticks in the rotation. I think the upside is somewhat limited but I do still like the profile.</p><p>The fastball primary is mostly a cutter. He throws it with 14&quot; IVB and 1&quot; of armside run but over half of them are moving to the glove side ever so slightly. He supinates on release and I don’t think you can change that without messing up his breaking balls which are too important to mess with. The spin rates are high at 2534 RPMs on average but it naive to expect him to add rise to the fastball given the way he naturally supinates.</p><p>The fastball velocity is fine but unspectacular. He throws the fastball at 91.1 MPH on average and tops out at 95.5 MPH. I think the velocity will probably uptick if forced into a relief role full time but it also could also improve with better conditioning in pro ball. The other draw is a unique release at a 5.2&#39; release height and a 1.4&#39; horizontal release.</p><p>I’m not entirely sure how this fastball plays with the weird amalgamatioin of traits but I lean towards it working. The pitch is often used down in the zone for called strikes and groundballs due to the horizontal and gyro element. However, he can also miss bats up in the zone with enough ride and a low release that lead to flat VAAs and popups as well. Where the velocity settles will determine a lot but I’m fairly optimistic.</p><p>The breaking balls both show promise but I’m not sure eith of them are as elite as the movement profile suggests. The more curveball esque slurvy sits at 80.5 MPH and has 15.1&quot; of sweep. The slurve also has -6.8&quot; drop (IVB) which is solid enough for the velocity and sweep. The pitch is somewhat undermined by a more medial release but the bigger knock is the lack of ability to land it in optimal spots- or in the zone at all. The deception is limited off of a cutter primary, and as such, he does not get that many chases either. The slurve has potential but it’s probably closer to average than a plus.</p><p>The slider is the better of the two due to the command differential and it probably tunnels better off of the cut-fastball. The slider sits at 82 MPH with average depth and 11.7&quot; of sweep. The pitch has above-average in-zone whiff rates and above-average chase rates. What really separates the pitch though is his ability to backdoor it against lefties which leads to a surprisingly high 41.4% CSW.</p><p>I actually think that Marques might be best off by using the slider more than the cut-fastball. The curveball tunnels infinetly better off of it’s fellow breaking ball and the movement is distinct enough to play as a separate pitch. I’m actually going to suggest something blasphemous and say Marques should subtract velocity from the curve (Even better add velo to slider). I think there are three pitches here but as is, only two of them function.</p><p>All of that plus some control questions and the lack of any pitches that function to the arm side makes Marques probably a reliever long term. By no means does that mean there’s not a chance he can start and I want him to get that chance. Weird profile for sure but I think Marques Johnson is a lot more fun than most 11th round picks.</p><h3>12.369 SP/RP Hayden Mullins, Auburn</h3><p>Hayden Mullins was shut down with a still undiagnosed injury to his throwing arm in May. That injury was finally revealed to be a torn UCL after he was drafted and he now is undergoing Tommy John Surgery. That injury is probably why he was still on the board for the Red Sox in the 12th round.</p><p>Mullins has good stuff that still warranted being selected but there is injury risk on top of very poor control and a highly flawed batted ball profile. Mullins might have a chance to stick as a starter based on the three pitch repertoire but a bullpen outcome is far more likely given the flaws he also has.</p><p>Hayden Mullins does not throw hard. He only sits at 90.7 MPH and tops out at 94 MPH. The velocity has some room to grow but I think some timing issues with his arm action, is costing him in that department significantly. Cleaning up the arm action could go a long way in improving all of velocity, command, and health. It’s possible that the Red Sox have already identified how to tweak that and a healthy Mullins could shoot up the rankings.</p><p>The fastball release is generic but the feel for a high spin and highly efficient heater still gives Mullins a solid fastball. The fastball averages 19.1&quot; IVB and 13.6&quot; HB because it is close to perfect spin efficiency on a fastball with a spin factor of 26.1. There is no pitcher in the majors who averages as much movement on both planes. In the collegiate ranks, only five pitchers average as much vertical movement, horizontal movement, and velocity. The movement profile means that with any velo boost; Mullins would improve immensely and potentially have an impact pitch in the fastball.</p><p>The breaking ball is probably better. The shape is somewhat generic with just ~-7 IVB and 7 inches of sweep as well. The slurve sits at 80 MPH but what really makes it interesting is that he averages 2700 RPMs on it. The specs maybe aren’t all that overwhelming but Mullins has great results with the pitch because he locates it consistently down and off of the plate. It’s an above-average pitch that would also pop with a velocity boost.</p><p>The changeup is solid too but the feel/command element lags behind as Mullins will frequently spike the pitch. In the zone, however, the changeup excells. Mullins throws it at 83.2 MPH with spin rates that sit around 1700 RPMs. The pitch has above-average depth with 7.5&quot; IVB and above-average fade at 16.1&quot; HB. There is promise here for an average pitch but none of the traits are really stand out. In addition, there is considerable danger in a pitch that only really functions in the zone.</p><p>Hayden Mullins has three pitches that all show flashes but look largely average right now. He has a fairly significant issue with walks and more so wild pitches. The command is poor. There is some optimism there but combined with the health risk, it’s not hard to see how Mullins fell this far. If the Red Sox can clean up his mechanics he will be a steal once he gets healthy. That is a sizeable if.</p><h3>13.399 SS/2B Gavin Kilen, Milton High School</h3><p>Gavin Kilen is not signing with the Red Sox but he should make an impact at Louisvile in the next few years. The Cardinals newest infielder has a loud hit tool with a road to developing power and a decent shot at playing shortstop.</p><p>The hit tool is good but might need to be sacrificed for Kilen to develop power. The problem with his power is that his wrists are locked and not really imparting anything impactful on the ball. The hand speed is good and he has good rotational velocity with his hips. The problem is just stiffness that causes him to lose speed in that one part of his swing- also the usual timing issues that cause his hands to get out in front of his hips. Oh, and Kilen doesn’t get particularly deep in his glutes so despite some explosion in his lower half it doesn’t manifest in games.</p><p>Some of the power issues feel like simple fixes- for example the locked wrists. The problem is I think that locking in his wrists and keeping the bat steady throughout contributes to Kilen’s standout bat control and contact skills. You can theoretically fix that issue (And should) but there is risk in doingso. Kilen has good pitch recognition and should hit for average. The attack angles are poor and it’s a flatter bat path so there is some wOBAcon risk that could make it more logical to stick with prioritzing contact.</p><p>Gavin Kilen deserved a hefty bonus because he offers both plus contact rates and above-average bat speed. There is absolutely some mandatory tweaking to get to both of things in game but it’s an exciting combo. The fact that Kilen also has a solid chance of sticking at shortstop (Arm issues maybe pushing him off) is just the icing on the cake. I’m excited to see what Kilen does at Louisville over the next couple of years.</p><h3>14.429 3B/SS Travis Sanders, Copperas Cove HS</h3><p>Travis Sanders also failed to sign with the Red Sox. Texas Tech. has added a potential impact hitter to their lineup who they hope can take Jace Jung’s spot in the heart of the order eventually.</p><p>Travis Sanders is another prep bat with mixed reviews defensively. Some people rave about how slick Sanders is in the field. They call him a great athlete with a good frame. Others disparage his athleticism- call it only average and predict that he will slide to third base.</p><p>I’m not going to pretend to be an expert on Sanders’ defense as I’ve only see him field three groundballs total but based on the athletic testing over the previous summer, I would assume the pessimists are more correct. The arm strength is a plus in all likelihood but the speed is only average and I think he’ll slow down some as he grows into his frame.</p><p>Travis Sanders has some mechanical issues to work out but I do think there is real offensive potential here. The bat speed is above-average and Sanders effectively utilizes his lower half to generate power with good timing that leads to good hip-torso separation and higher top-end EVs. The concern is elevation, however. Sanders tends to flatten out shortly before the point of contact and as such will hit a lot of balls into the dirt and just hit general mishits.</p><p>The hit tool is hard to value. The swing is loose and easy but Sanders gets a little bit long in the back. At the same time, Sander is showing bat control with that length and has good core strength that makes it easy to maintain his posture as he swings. I think you clean up some of the stuff in the back-end and both the contact rates and groundball rates might improve. Sanders doesn’t have the loudest tools but he could still go high in a few years if he produces like I think he has the ability to.</p><h3>15.459 RP/SP Nathan Landry, Missouri</h3><p>I don’t dislike Landry as much as his FV suggests. Nathan Landry checks every box for a solid pitching prospect except for two. That one big box is velocity and Landry probably needs about 4 MPH on everything to get to above-average stuff. The smaller box is changeup development because the current configuration is terrible.</p><p>The fastball has a boyish appeal to it. Landry only sits at 89.4 MPH on average and tops out at 93.2 MPH in games with trackman data. The fastball plays above that because Landry theoretically averages just over 7&#39; of extension but he still needs more actual velocity. The fastball also has above-averge rates at 18.6&quot; IVB and a low release at 5.5&#39;. It is a flat fastball with extension that would probably be a plus pitch with league average actual velocity.</p><p>The breaking ball shows some promise. It’s a bit of gyro heavy pitch but it has impressive depth with -1.1&quot; IVB and still has some side spin. He throws from a lower slot that can make it hard to square up. The problem is that he only sits at 76.8 MPH which is nowhere near sufficient velocity. Add more velocity and the slider might be something, however.</p><p>The changeup is horrible. Landry just throws a slower four-seam fastball with almost no desireable traits. The pitch kills just over 600 RPMs and throws it 7 MPH slower than his fastball. He has high efficiency on a vertical axis so the changeup still gets 16.8&quot; IVB. I think Landry might be an ideal splitter candidate and he at least has arm speed but it’s hard to muster any optimism for this changeup.</p><p>The primary draw of Nathan Landry might actually be control. Landry throws a metric ton of strikes and his ability to elevate the fastball lets it play at a high level. The fastball/slider combo could get him into an MLB bullpen with a modest velocity jump and the control will let the stuff play up. There are things to like here but he needs work and is almost certainly a reliever.</p><h3>16.489 SP/RP Garrett Ramsey, Southern Mississippi</h3><p>Garrett Ramsey has solid stuff but I genuinely have no idea what I would do with his development to make him better and that makes him hard for me to value highly. I don’t know how exactly to make any of his pitches at all better and the results and specs aren’t exactly spectacular for a reliever in the Conference USA. I like him but I’m lost so if I’m running a team he’s on my do not draft list. That does mean I think he is remotely bad and I might even be underselling him.</p><p>Garrett Ramsey has a very low release height at 4.6&#39; on average in trackman games. He has good vertical movement relative to his release height at 14.4&quot; IVB. The fastball might only sit at 91 MPH and top out at 94 MPH but the shape based on those attributes is comparable to Paul Sewald. Sewald throws slightly harder at 92.6 MPH on average but also has a 4.5&#39; release height and 14&quot; IVB. His fastball is one of the best pitches in baseball.</p><p>The thing is Sewald’s fastball is elite just as much because of the HAA. Sewald gets 12&quot; of tail from a -3.5&#39; horizontal release. Ramsey gets 7.9&quot; HB from a 1.8&#39; horizontal release. Paul Sewald having so much horizontal movement makes his fastball a great pitch for jamming hitters and a multi-purposed weapon that Ramsey’s really isn’t. His fastball doesn’t jam hitters like Sewald’s does and can get barreled up at the top of the zone. Yet, at the bottom of the zone it fails to miss bats. The traits are enviable but it’s stuck in the middle of two conflicting profiles and doesn’t really fit either right now.</p><p>The pitch is more comparable to Alexis Díaz’s fastball than Paul Sewald’s in all honesty. Alexis Díaz averages 14.4&quot; IVB and 6.2&quot; HB from a very comparable release with a 4.9&#39; release height and 1.9&#39; release side. Díaz is also one of the best relievers in the game by spamming his fastball 70% of the time. Except, again it’s not comparable because Alexis has a perceived velocity of 98 MPH. Garrett Ramsey has a perceived velocity of ~89.2 MPH.</p><p>If Ramsey adds 10 MPH to his fastball or drastically alters his mound positioning and improves the fastball HAA then he could have an elite one. Neither of those things feel particularly likely so I think he probably will remain stuck in the middle with a fairly mediocre one. I see the upside but I think it’s a tweener pitch without a clear path to dominating with it.</p><p>The slider is actually a disgusting pitch that might need more velocity but has incredible shape. Garrett Ramsey throws his slider at just 80.3 MPH which is plenty fine given where the fastball sits. He throws it with high spin rates that average over 2800 RPMs. Again though, movement is the calling card as Ramsey offers both plus depth and elite sweep. The sweeper has -0.4&quot; IVB and 16.2&quot; of sweep. I shouldn’t need to elaborate on how unhittable that is. The feel is somewhat limited and he struggles with it’s deployment against lefties but the pitch has obvious plus shape, even given the sub-optimal horizontal release.</p><p>The changeup of Gordon Ramsey also shows promise but it is much more of a work in progresss. The pitch stands out because he gets good vertical depth with just 3.8&quot; IVB which is great changeup depth- especially at this level where everything says it drops less than it does. Ramsey also shows some feel to kill spin with him shaving off just about everything else.</p><p>The problem with Garrett Ramsey’s changeup is just about everyting else you could possible critique. He throws the changeup at 85.4 MPH on average which is less than 6 MPH slower than the fastball. He also has just 11.6&quot; of fade which is below-average. The feel is limited and he struggles to find the zone with his cambio. I will once again hammer the table demanding he switch to a splitter but that feels like nothing more than a pipe dream at this point.</p><p>Garrett Ramsey’s command is below-average but he has a general ability to throw strikes at an average rate. I think I’d probably like to see him work on elevating the fastball and backdooring the slider so he’s not 100% reliant on the changeup to beat lefties. Adding velocity has to be a priority here but you would need a significant amount to really let the fastball cook. Garrett Ramsey was a pure reliever in college but I’m intrigued enough by what he offers to give him a chance to start in the minors. There are attractive elements here but Ramsey feels like he’s stuck in tweenerville right now.</p><h3>17.519 LF/1B Deundre Jones, Lutheran South HS</h3><p>Deundre Jones is not someone I am that familiar with so this is a very low confidence evaluation. In my limited looks, I was not all that impressed. Deundre Jones has limited defensive value and I don’t think the offensive upside is high enough to overcome those limitations in any likely outcome for his development.</p><p>Deundre is a hit first prospect with some hit tool concerns. The swing is loose and geared towards contact with a flat and short bat path. The problem is that there are inefficiencies in the hand load that add artificial length to the swing. In addition to that, Deundre only has 45 grade bat speed. The hand movement in conjunction with the bat speed leads to some concerns with Deundre’s ability to hit velocity.</p><p>The power is fairly suspect as you can imagine based on the limited bat speed. Deundre Jones has good strength in his lower half but that can only do so much. It’s a 5&#39;10&quot; frame without much strength projection and below-average bat speed. I like the force exerted by his leg and hips enough to call the raw power average but it still plays down in games because of the flat line-drive oriented swing.</p><p>There is some upside at the plate for Deundre Jones but not enough for me to overlook the athleticism and defensive concerns for too long. Fine value in the 17th without going overslot but my hopes are not that high for him. Maybe I’m completely off-base due in part to very limited issue.</p><h3>18.549 P Austin Ehrlicher, Santa Rosa JUCO</h3><p>Searching for data on Austin Ehrlicher is like trying to find a needle in a haystack. I haven’t found a scouting report on him literally anywhere. I have more video of him playing basketball than throwing a baseball. I can’t tell you how hard Ehrlicher throws or even what pitches he throws. For all I know he could be a knuckleballer.</p><p>Here is a complete list of things we know about Ehrlicher. He is 6&#39;5&quot; with a very projectable frame that could presumably add strength and velocity. Austin also probably has control issues based on his performance. That is the entire list. I obviously do not have enough information to accurately assess Austin Ehrlicher. The Red Sox evidentally agree with my assessment because they opted to designate him as a draft and follow player so they have a year to decide if he’s actually worth giving a pittance to sign him.</p><h3>19.579 RP/SP Jaret Godman, Oklahoma</h3><p>Jaret Godman is only a 30 FV for the time being because only one of his pitches even projects as average as is and he was a pure reliever in college. That being said, Godman could shoot up the ranks if he adopts a sweeper and I think he’s a likely candidate to do exactly that and have a completely nasty one at that.</p><p>Jaret Godman uses his sinker as his primary pitch and for the most part it is an effective starter. The sinker sits at 92.2 MPH and tops out at 95 MPH from the right handed side. The sinker has fairly average depth at 8.3&quot; IVB but it comes from a low release at a 4.8&#39; vertical release point. Godman also has elite tailing action with 17.8&quot; of armside movement from a low slot. The sinker is lively and has potentially but for whatever reason, Godman often lives up in the zone with the sinker and is hammered as a result. The VAA is flat enough to miss some bats up there but not enough to make it a worthwhile decision to lose so much in contact quality suppression.</p><p>The slider is absolutely terrible as is. The pitch has below-average depth with just 3.1&quot; IVB and less than 4&quot; of sweep as well. The pitch also only sits at 79.8 MPH. The only reason to buy in on the slider is a low arm slot right now and that just doesn’t offer enough with how poor the rest of the traits are. If Godman were to switch to a sweeper, however…</p><p>The potential of the slider is the ability to make it into a wipeout sweeper. Godman is a natural supinator with low spin efficiency. He throws with two-seam grip and seam-shifted wake on one pitch already. He has the ideal arm slot for a sweeper and above-average spin rates. Picking up a sweeper would be relatively easy for Godman and would transform the profile.</p><p>The changeup is solid in a vacuum but it might bleed into the sinker a bit too much. Jaret Godman gets 5.9&quot; IVB and 17&quot; of fade on his changeup which are both above-average figures- and barely any different from the sinker. The pitch is thrown roughly 8.5 MPH slower at 83.5 MPH on average. That is maybe enough velocity separation to work with similar movement profiles but I think it probably isn’t. If he can slow the pitch or add more depth it could be deadly but for now, I think it’s not a good pitch. Oh, and he has very little feel for it so the deception element could be completely irrelevant.</p><p>Jaret Godman offers only one pitch that even projects as average right now. There is road to developing two more of them though and one of them has actually elite potential. There is some velocity upside here and Godman throws strikes. The profile is not good right now but with good player development, Godman might look like a steal in a year.</p><h3>20.609 RP Connor Butler, Biola</h3><p>Connor Butler struck out 44% of batters this year at Biola. He also walked 30% of batters. Those control issues as well as him likely only having two pitches probably force Connor Butler to the bullpen. The stuff is incredible though and with even modest gains in control, Butler could have a future in the major leagues.</p><p>The fastball is an electric pitch. Connor Butler sits at 94.2 MPH with the heater from the left handed side and can reach back for 97 MPH in a pinch. The pitch has high spin rates with Butler sitting just above 2400 RPMs and he throws with 98% spin efficiency on a 10:45 spin axis. The result pitch has above-average movement on both planes with 17.2&quot; IVB and 11.7&quot; HB on average. That fastball also comes from what is just a 5.5&#39; release height. Butler offers both a plus VAA and plus velocity as a lefty. It’s not hard to see why he misses so many bats with the pitch.</p><p>The breaking ball is just better. Connor Butler’s curveball is an outlier pitch. Butler only sits at 79 MPH but he averages -18&quot; IVB. There are zero pitches in the majors with as much drop (Min 1 pitch) and as much velocity. There are also zero college arms with as much depth and velocity. There is also no one in the FSL or PCL with a curveball that has as much drop and velocity. (Jack Ralston is 1 MPH from joining the party with his -18.6&quot; IVB curve at 78 MPH). This is an outlier curveball that is incredibly tough to hit.</p><p>The way that Connor Butler acheives so much drop on his curveball is unusual. Most curveballs with crazy depth have high spin rates but that is not Connor Butler. Butler throws his curve with a spin rate of just 2301 RPMs. So how does he get so much drop? Butler throws his curveball with 87% spin efficiency on a 5:15 spin axis. I’m skeptical of how much you can still improve the curveball shape at this point but it doesn’t really matter because the curveball is elite as is. He has to work on landing the pitch for a strike and it maybe doesn’t get as many chases as the shape would warrant but it’s still nearly an elite pitch.</p><p>The changeup isn’t hopeless but I’m not optimistic that Butler will ever develop one. The pitch has very little depth and below-average fade but there is at least good separation and some feel to kill spin. I think Butler is probably best off scratching it entirely though and focusing on the FB/CB combo exclusively in relieif. If he can develop any arm side command than he should have no issues with beating right handed bats with those two pitch.</p><p>Command is what will decide if Connor Butler makes it to the majors. I have very little video so I’m not going to guess on how that could be improved. The stuff is loud and I’m a believer in stuff above all else. However, there is a minimum threshold for strike throwing and Butler probably won’t clear that right now. There has to be at least minor gains in command for him to ever make it in the majors. If he gets to even 35 command than the stuff might propel Butler into a moderately high leverage role. I like the value of this pick here for the Red Sox.</p><p><em>That was way longer than I planned lol. Hopefully, you enjoyed it. I think I’ll wind up taking some time off of draft stuff for the first time in forever and do a piece breaking down every prospect traded. I’ll be back sometime next week with the Yankees draft recap after that.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=562b39cc884c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Toronto Blue Jays Draft Analysis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/toronto-blue-jays-draft-analysis-c72e4f28f8e9?source=rss-f20e8b3389a4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c72e4f28f8e9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb-draft]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[toronto-blue-jays]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tieran Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Jul 2022 18:03:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-27T18:03:51.370Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Toronto Blue Jays had their first selection at #23 overall and went with the riskiest demographic in a prep arm. They then got the player most people expected them to take in the first round all the way down at #77. To facilitate those very early prep selections, the Blue Jays had to go with a lot of cheaper options on day two but those players still all have a decent shot at making an impact in the major leagues one day. They also managed to snag some intriguing developmental projects on day three that I think could be something one day. I don’t like grading drafts from day one, but the Blue Jays&#39; initial haul certainly looks impressive.</p><p>In this piece, I will break down all of the players that the Blue Jays drafted this year. From #23 overall to #608, here is every player joining the Blue Jays organization through the draft and why you should be excited to maybe one day see them in Toronto. I will not be grading draft picks or calling any player bad. If a pick is good is defined by your plan to develop them, I don’t have the knowledge to judge that so all picks are fine until we see that they were not.</p><p><em>The FV system is stupid but I use it to clickbait people. Prospects are infinitely more complicated than one number. It’s a loose baseline but I like players with low FVs and dislike ones with a higher FV. The report is what matters, not the number. X is a placeholder for players that I do not have enough information to assess.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/571/1*FAdp5-B2rmTviSfGAecFOg.png" /></figure><h3>1.23 SP Brandon Barriera, Toronto Blue Jays</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/mlb-draft-top-500-prospects-fba9fe7fceaf"><em>I already wrote a very detailed scouting report of Brandon Barriera on my top 500 so if you want more on him, go read that one</em></a><em>. This report is going to go into less detail and work as more of a general overview.</em></p><p>Brandon Barriera is a player I have very strong but also very mixed feelings about. Barriera is very much a project coming out of high school and I want to revamp the shape of most of his arsenal but Barriera does still possess four pitches with high upside and has some outlier traits. When you tie that all together with above-average command, it’s not hard to muster up excitement for what Barriera can one day be.</p><p>Brandon Barriera can touch 99 MPH from the left handed side. Lefties who can throw 99 MPH before they even graduate high school are incredibly rare but that doesn’t actually mean that the fastball is a good pitch. Barriera has awful fastball movement with 10.3&quot; IVB and 3.9&quot; HB on average and this is with the high school baseball that inflates pitch movement. It’s a dead-zone heater that will not miss any bats with it’s current shape- in spite of the velocity and 5.7&#39; release height.</p><p>That does not mean that Barriera won’t have a good fastball in the future though, it just will take some work. After some talks with people around the game, I’ve come to the conclusion that the best path forwards for Brandon Barriera is an unconventional one. Brandon Barriera will never get that much ride of his four-seam fastball due to how he naturally supinates on each pitch. He would be better off leaning into his wrist orientation and transitioning to a 99 MPH cutter as his primary pitch.</p><p>If he can make the change, there is 70 grade upside but with its current shape he is at best a 50 projection. There is upside here but how do you value the likelihood that he makes the correct adjustments? I’m not sure I can answer that and it’s a large part of why I’ve moved away from tool grades when scouting. There is also an argument for converting him to a bowling ball sinker but I think a cutter would generally be more effective and he’ll never have too much tailing action given the lack of pronation.</p><p>The curveball is salacious. Barriera throws the pitch with very high spin rates and uncharacteristically high spin efficiency. The pitch has elite vertical depth with him flashing up to -22.5&quot; IVB in a bullpen. He is more consistently around ~-15&quot; IVB but that is still incredible by all definitions of the word and he also gets ~10&quot; of sweeping action towards the glove side. The curveball needs to add more power as he only sits in the 76–79 MPH bucket. There is also some concerns with it not being the best pitch shape for how his fastball moves but the pitch is still completely nasty.</p><p>Brandon Barriera pairs the wipeout curveball with a good slider that could be better with a grip change. Barriera has a low efficiency slider with high spin rates and optimal gyro angle. He sits in the 82–85 MPH bucket and will occasionally rip off one with double digit sweep. More often than not though, it’s a vertically moving gyro heavy pitch. Barriera has premium depth and it allows him to miss bats. I think he might be better off in converting to a sweeper but he probably doesn’t need to do so.</p><p>I threw around the idea of Brandon Barriera turning his changeup into a splitter before the draft. I still like the idea but given that lefties don’t really throw splitters, I am backing off on it. He still showcases good depth with very little horizontal movement and elite ability to kill spin. The velocity separation is still right around average and his arm speed is good. I still believe in the intrinsic traits, I’m just not sure how to get them to play in games.</p><p>Brandon Barriera has gorgeous mechanics and moves incredibly well on the mound. He’s a plus athlete who consistently repeats everything. He’s already throwing 99 MPH but I can imagine him throwing harder in the future. He’s going to continue to throw strikes at a high rate. Barriera offers bat missing secondaries and what could be an elite fastball at getting weak groundball contact. Barriera might take some work but the upside is as high as any arm in this year’s draft and Blue Jays fans should be thrilled to have him in their organization.</p><h3>2.60 SS/2B Josh Kasevich, Oregon</h3><p>Josh Kasevich is a complicated enigma. On the surface he looks like a light hitting middle infielder who will hit for average and zero power, leading to below-average offensive contributions as a whole. There is like a 75% chance that Kasevich is exactly that even. The part I want to focus on is the other 25% where Kasevich shows power.</p><p>Josh Kasevich is different from the Nick Madrigals and Chandler Simpsons of the world because he actually has some ability to hit the ball hard. The hardest hit ball of his career is 111 MPH which would rank in the 75th percentile of major league hitters. Kasevich has the capacity to hit the ball hard in theory. His Top 8th EV is worse at 100.7 MPH but it is still above the collegiate average.</p><p>So why does Josh Kasevich hit for so little power? Part of it is an 8th percentile outfield flyball rate but it is more complicated than that. Kasevich has average spin characteristics and actually has above-average spray directions as well. So why the lack of power? Josh Kasevich is capable of hitting the ball hard but none of that hard contact comes in the air.</p><p>The highest EV on Trackman from Kasevich with a launch angle above 20° is a mere 101.2 MPH. Only 12.5% of his aerial contact is hit hard. All of the hard-hit balls are ineffective and it makes it very hard to believe that Kasevich can produce in game power despite the top end EVs being above-average.</p><p>Josh Kasevich’s issues with hard aerial contact are primarily because of his bat path and connection point. I’m not sure those problems are at all solvable without sacrificing the contact rates. I would make that tradeoff but it is far from easy to decide to risk a 99th percentile contact rate that gives him a floor in the majors.</p><p>The thing is, I don’t think Kasevich has enough barrel accuracy to play in the majors with his current highly contact oriented approach. There is a minor popup problem and he doesn’t hit enough line drives or have the speed to make up for it. Kasevich is more of an average athlete so it’s a fringier profile if he doesn’t start tapping into his power. The power is accessible but it is a risky proposition.</p><p>Kasevich is also a fringy fit at shortstop who should move to second or third base in the long run. The ceiling here is lofty and there is a floor but the median outcomes aren’t that exciting. I was probably too high on him before the draft but he still belongs in the 45 FV tier and in this range of the draft.</p><h3>2.77 3B/SS Tucker Toman, Hammond High School</h3><p>Tucker Toman is not my favorite mold of draft prospect, and that might have adversely affected my pre-draft ranking of him. He profiles as power over hit and there is not currently great bat speed which is the biggest thing I look for in prep bats. The target here is physical projection and a few mechanical tweaks that would unlock another gear of bat speed. Given the plus makeup, it’s fairly easy to believe that Toman will max out his frame and tap into the plus raw power upside.</p><p>Tucker Toman is a very twitchy hitter with electric hand speed — especially as a left handed hitter. The lower half is powerful with effective movements as well. The only problem is that Toman easily gets disconnected and his hands get out in front of his hips. He has very little torque when he swings and it wastes all the efforts of his quite powerful lower half. He needs to work on delaying his top half and then the power could jump up.</p><p>Tucker Toman has at least an average hit tool overall and it’s likely above-average from the left handed side. He makes contact at a solid rate and shows an excellent feel for the barrel. The bat path is more hack and slash from the right handed side with a lot more groundballs but it is still not all that bad.</p><p>Toman is a good offensive prospect who could quickly click in pro ball with some small tweaks. He is probably destined for third base long term but is theoretically a shortstop for the time being. The arm strength and athleticism should let him be above-average at third base though- depending on how the body progresses. There is a lot to like here- and a lot more if he stops switch hitting, but I haven’t seen enough yet to grade him as a first round prospect. He’s probably up from 65 on my pre-draft board to about ~45 now.</p><h3>2.78 SS/2B Cade Doughty, LSU</h3><p>Cade Doughty is someone who was in large part ranked as high as they were on my pre-draft big board because he was supposed to move back over to shortstop and possibly even provide above-average defense there. He has good range, actions, and an above-average arm. My film looks were impressive and the sources I talked to all had positive things to say about his glove.</p><p>Then the Blue Jays announced him as a second baseman. Every player drafted is initially announced higher up the defensive spectrum so the Blue Jays calling him a second baseman set off some alarm bells. I didn’t move him in my rankings as a result of Toronto’s weirdness but I am slightly concerned now and think he might be more of a great defender at the keystone rather than a shortstop.</p><p>The bat is interesting. Cade Doughty has below-average raw power. His Max EV this year was just 103.3 MPH and his Top 8th EV is just 99.2 MPH. Both of those figures are below the collegiate average. In addition, his average EV, Hard-Hit rate, and Soft-Hit rate are all below average. In spite of all that, Cade Doughty had 15 homers this year after 13 the year prior. His ISOcon is in the 73rd percentile of SEC hitters. The game power output is significantly outpacing the lackluster raw power.</p><p>Why is that? Above-average feel to elevate helps, as does a very pull heavy approach but it doesn’t explain all of the performance. The real explanation is backspin. Cade Doughty hits his average flyball with a spin rate of 3551 RPMs and 93.5% of them are hit with backspin. He gets lots of carry on his aerial contact and his average EV is also 90.5 MPH on aerial contact compared to 84.9 MPH on everything else. He is basically the polar opposite of Josh Kasevich’s power profile. Will it translate to wood bats and good pitching? I have no clue so we’ll split the difference and call it 40 grade power.</p><p>Cade Doughty’s carrying skill though is the ability to get on base. Cade Doughty has plus contact rates with him sitting at 82.5% this year. Cade Doughty also rarely expands the zone with just a 19% chase rate. There is some concern about him being overly passive in the zone but Doughty still should run strong K/BB rates. There are also some BABIP concerns given his pull heavy ways and his mediocre line drive rates, however, so it is hard to call the hit tool that great.</p><p>I think Cade Doughty is probably only a league average hitter in all likelihood. There are some encouraging signs but without a significant power boost, he will never be a star. Doughty will probably wind up as a somewhat useful utility bench player who serves as more of a tough out than a quality hitter. Again, if the power upticks- or even if he just maintains his ability to spin his batted balls, Doughty might be more than I’m projecting him as.</p><h3>3.98 OF/1B/2B Alan Roden, Creighton</h3><p>I’ve fallen further in love with Alan Roden every time I’ve taken a look at him. At first, I didn’t like him all that much as a power-deficient first baseman but then I realized how much I was underselling the raw juice. Then he tested really well athletically at the combine, showcasing plus speed and solid arm strength. I moved him to the outfield then and up to a 40 FV. Talking to some people in the industry, a number of them think he could play second base. He’s slowly been inching his way up that tier as well and I still am likely underselling what Roden brings to the table because he is already 22.</p><p>The one thing I never doubted from Alan Roden was the contact skills. Alan makes a lot of contact. He had a 95th percentile contact rate this year at 89.5%. Roden is older, but I’m not worried about his contact rates being a byproduct of him bullying less advanced pitching. This is because Roden has an 82.6% contact rate on pitches out of the strike zone. He’s shown the ability to hit tough stuff by location so it’s fair to assume he’ll still run solid contact rates against tough movement. Roden isn’t a hyper aggressive hitter either but one with above-average chase and average zone-swing rates.</p><p>The power is a lot trickier to evaluate. Roden has a max EV of 108.7 MPH this year which is already slightly above the major league average. His Top 8th EV is likely suggesting that it is no fluke as Roden is at 103.9 MPH which is in the 87th percentile of college hitters this year. In addition, Roden has a 92nd percentile hard hit rate.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/782/1*s0mIBCKd6qfG16nTZmptBQ.png" /></figure><p>This combination of contact and raw power is special. Above this paragraph is a graph mapping the contact rate and Top 8th EV of every player in college baseball this year. There are three dots circled above. The red circle is Alan Roden. The black circle is Jacob Gonzalez who most people have in their top five draft prospects in 2023. The blue circle? That is Eric Brown Jr., who was a first round pick this year. That is the company that Alan Roden keeps in terms of the contact and power profile. Alan Roden is older and plays in the weakest conference of the bunch but how far can we knock him for those things? The skills are clearly there.</p><p>This all sounds great but if this is true, then why did Roden only hit four homers this year? I’m not entirely sure of the answer to that question. I will say, however, that it certainly wasn’t bad luck and nothing else, given that Roden only logged a 3.5% Barrel rate this year. Except, that number makes zero sense. Roden has average feel to elevate and hits the ball hard in the air more often than he hits it hard on the ground.</p><p>Alan Roden does have below-average spray directions and batted ball spin rates but not by such a wide margin that explains the lack of power so completely. He’s not getting too far underneath his flyballs either, with him actually having above-average popup avoidance and zero outfield flyballs with a LA over 50°. I genuinely have no clue why there is so little game power but it makes it hard to believe he’ll hit for power at the next level when he hasn’t really done so yet and struggled with the one carrying skills in the wOBAcon profile- barrel accuracy during the cape cod league.</p><p>Alan Roden tests really well though athletically. He posted plus run times and did well in the CMJ and Broad Jump at the combine. There are explosive movements in his lower half and he still has good bat speed to pair with it. The power upside is there and he makes a lot of contact. He should provide some defensive value as well. I just have zero clue how to get his upside to manifest itself in game-time situations. If the Blue Jays can unravel that puzzle then this will be a steal.</p><h3>4.128 SP/RP Ryan Jennings, Louisiana Tech.</h3><p>Ryan Jennings has a ton of low hanging fruit in his profile. I expect that the Blue Jays will address the easy stuff immediately and come the offseason, the senior who signed for just 70K will look like an appropriate pick for the spot even when you ignore the monetary reasoning behind it.</p><p>Ryan Jennings has plus arm strength. He averages 94.3 MPH on the four-seam fastball with the ability to hit as high as 98 MPH. The primary appeal might not be velocity, however, but the fact that Jennings throws his heater from a 5.1&#39; release height which is as low as any starting pitcher at the major league level this year. That low release height lets even a fastball with 14.6&quot; IVB and 13.4&quot; HB miss a lot of bats at the top of the zone.</p><p>There in lies the problem. Ryan Jennings can miss a lot of bats at the top of the zone with his very flat high velocity fastball but he decided that he didn’t want to. Jennings throws less than 30% of his fastballs in the top half of the strike zone. Jennings also makes matters worse by spamming the fastball over 60% of the time. To be fair, Jennings doesn’t actually have to elevate his fastball against weak competition at Louisiana Tech. but he will have to learn to do so to perform in the minors and majors.</p><p>Ryan Jennings has three secondary pitches with above-average potential and it is a borderline criminal offense that he doesn’t use them more often than he does. The slider is the most boring of those secondary weapons but it’s by no means a below-average pitch. The slider sits at 85.3 MPH and has a generic gyroball shape from a somewhat low arm slot. Sure, the shape is generic, but given the velocity, the pitch is still very difficult to hit.</p><p>The changeup also projects as average with the upside to be more if the feel develops beyond the expectation. Jennings throws it 10.3 MPH slower than his fastball and kills 300 RPMs. The appeal though is obviously movement as Jennings averages 6.3&quot; IVB and 17.3&quot; HB. The changeup has double the drop with gravity of the fastball with plenty of separation and should play well off of each other. The changeup works best in the zone though and Ryan Jennings struggles to consistently get the changeup down.</p><p>The curveball is Ryan’s least used pitch but it also might be my favorite weapon in his first aid kit. The curve has solid velocity with Jennings sitting at 79.8 MPH on average. That velocity is maybe a tad on the lighter end but not in consideration to his movement as Jennings averages -14.1&quot; IVB with 9&quot; of sweep towards his glove side.</p><p>There are only two curveballs in the entire draft with more velocity and lower (better) IVB than Ryan Jennings. Those two curveballs belong to Max Rajcic (Cardinals) and JP Massey (Pirates). In the majors, only Dylan Cease, Nick Martinez, Trevor Megill, Adrian Houser, and Aaron Ashby can match him in both velocity and vertical movement. This is a special curveball and Jennings neglecting the pitch is a capital offense. Obviously, feel and command have to improve for it to be a regular feature though.</p><p>There are four reasons to doubt Ryan Jennings. The first is the silliest reason- his pitch usage sucks so the performance hasn’t quite been up to snuff. The second reason is age since Jennings is already 23. That is a somewhat valid concern but it’s not that difficult to isolate age from performance for pitchers so I’m not that turned off by him being older. The stuff still plays. The other two concerns are very valid.</p><p>Ryan Jennings has below-average command. The only pitch he can regularly land in the zone is the fastball, and even that he rarely puts in an optimal location. The delivery has some effort and he’s not the greatest athlete. The other concern is directly correlated to the first in that Jennings’ velocity tends to fade later in ballgames. That could push him into the bullpen in the long run but I still believe that improved conditioning in pro ball is very possible and if Ryan can improve his athleticism that would solve a lot of his problems.</p><p>Ryan Jennings has some risk but the stuff is very high upside. There is a high chance that if Jennings was at the other Lousiana school instead, with better deployment and a bright stage; we would see Jennings have been drafted much earlier. If he was younger I’m not sure he wouldn’t have gone in the first three rounds on the merit of his stuff, even in a weaker conference. It’s rare to find a player with the potential for four above-average pitches, let alone one who is willing to sign for just 68K. I think Ryan Jennings was one of the best value picks of the entire draft.</p><h3>5.158 RP Mason Fluharty, Liberty</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/exploring-the-most-unheralded-demographic-college-relievers-3c8239930dc6"><em>I already wrote a very detailed scouting report of Mason Fluharty in my Relievers Blog so if you want more on him as a pitcher, go read that one. </em></a><em>This report is going to go into less detail and work as more of a general overview.</em></p><p>Mason Fluharty is one of the better relief prospects in this year’s draft. He only has two pitches but he still misses a ton of bats. On top of missing so many basts, Fluharty also has elite walk rates and what FaBIO has as a 94th percentile batted ball profile.</p><p>Mason Fluharty’s primary weapon is an above-average cutter. He throws it 61.7% of the time and at first glance, the specs don’t look like all that. Fluharty sits at just 90.2 MPH and has pretty generic movement in both directions. The spin rates are top notch with him averaging 2497 RPMs but it’s not really relevant when you’re using a fairly gyro-dependent cutter.</p><p>The draw here is that Fluharty has a 5.2&#39; release height and a 2.6&#39; horizontal release point from the left handed side. He might only have 1.8&quot; of cut to the glove side but from such a low slot, Fluharty still has a 3.2° HAA on the cutter which would be one of the most extreme values for a cutter in the majors. The velocity is more than enough for a cutter with that angle and it lets him miss bats all over the zone. Fluharty also gets called strikes down in the zone due to the lower release. The cutter’s angle has led to a CSW% of nearly 40% from Fluharty with it this year.</p><p>The slider is better than the cutter, as strange as that might sound. The slider sits at 83.4 MPH and like the cutter benefits greatly from the unorthodox release. More so even, as Fluharty averages 13.1&quot; of sweep along with 5.5&quot; IVB from that wide release. The two pitches tunnel near perfectly and have enough velocity separation that even in the same spot, guessing wrong results in a mishit.</p><p>Not only does the slider have good shape, velocity, and deception but Fluharty has the ability to land the slider for a strike when he so pleases. Admittedly, Fluharty doesn’t do so all that often given how ridiculously dominant his slider is out of the zone with a 47.4% chase rate but the option is there.</p><p>Despite the two-pitch repertoire with both being very reliant on glove side location and angle, Fluharty has actually run reverse splits in his collegiate career. I suspect that this is because he’s more careful in his pitch usage and throws fewer waste pitches- hence the lower walk rates but it’s still an encouraging sign, even if I expect him to settle in as a more conventional split guy.</p><p>Mason Fluharty throws a lot of strikes and misses a lot of bats. There aren’t a lot of players who can do both of those things without giving up a lot of hard contact as well. I don’t think Fluharty actually has that high of strikeout upside but he’s a well rounded really good reliever. If he can find a third pitch- ideally one with arm side movement then he might deserve a chance at starting games but I am not willing to project that on him at this point.</p><h3>6.188 RP TJ Brock, Ohio State</h3><p>TJ Brock has one elite pitch that should carry him to the big leagues, but it will be the development of his fastball that determine his eventual role once he gets there. He also uses the slider over 15% more often than the fastball so there are some walk problems that crop up as a result of slider spam and those problems will likely have to be addressed in the not so distant future.</p><p>TJ Brock has a completely unfair gyro slider. He throws the pitch ridiculously hard- averaging 86.4 MPH with Trackman. The pitch also has really good depth relative to his velocity with 0.1&quot; IVB on average. The pitch comes from a similarly high and medial release with movement and velocity nearly identical to the slider of Dylan Cease. You know, that pitch with the highest run value in all of baseball. Brock also has the ability to throw his slider in the zone, with him landing it in the zone over 50% of the time with trackman. The command is less precise and he gets firm at times but this is an elite pitch all the same.</p><p>The fastball is thrown hard too. TJ Brock averages 95.5 MPH in Trackman games and has hit as high as 99 MPH. The problem is that the fastball is a dead-zone heater with sub-optimal release traits. He has just 13.8&quot; IVB and 10.3&quot; HB but the Trackman unit that is recorded on, tends to overshoot vertical movement. It’s a dead zone heater from a 6.1&#39; release height and 1.3&#39; horizontal release. The pitch won’t miss bats and probably won’t get that weak of contact when it’s as straight of an arrow. I would like to see TJ Brock switch to a turbo sinker that would play up from his slot, but I’m not sure how doable that is, given the lack of feel for pronation.</p><p>The slider is electric obviously, and he has command over it. One elite pitch can do a lot for a player but you do need more than that to be an actual impact arm. I think switching to a sinker could give Brock a reliable secondary weapon but that is by no means a guarantee or even an easy task. There is upside here given the arm strength in conjunction with the slider but I think he’s most likely to be a low-leverage arm.</p><h3>7.218 1B Peyton Williams, Iowa</h3><p>Peyton Williams is an XL first baseman that will provide almost no value in the field. He also has limited flexibility in my looks and really struggles with hitting the slider. There have been 6&#39;6&quot; 260 lbs sluggers before who have found tremendous success. As such, it is probably fair to wonder if we are overvaluing the body but it’s a risky profile that is flawed beyond his size.</p><p>Peyton Williams has plus raw power. His Max EV is 111.7 MPH but his Top 8th EV is the real reason to buy in on the raw power as he sits at 108 MPH which is in the 98th percentile of all college hitters. I think he’s already maxed out physically and won’t be more than a 55–60 raw power guy (Top 8th will likely drop some at higher levels with wood) but that is still impactful power.</p><p>The game power is probably just as good as the raw power. Peyton Williams has a 20.4% barrel rate which ranks in the 99th percentile of college hitters this year. The reason behind that probably is because of launch angles. Peyton Williams only has a 47th percentile outfield flyball rate. He also has below-average pull rates on flyballs across the entire season. To top it off, the batted ball spin rates are below-average.</p><p>Peyton Williams consistently hits the ball hard and a lot of that hard contact comes at optimal angles but he’s not your typical master game power technician. Additionally, there is the risk that any barrel accuracy regression would cause the game power to slide. I still think he’ll produce plus game power but it’s not a number that is set in stone by any means.</p><p>The hit tool is hard to value. Peyton Williams made contact 80.5% of the time with trackman which is well above the collegiate average. He has zero troubles with whiffing against velocity which is usually a fairly major concern for long levered XL sluggers like him. The actual problem is that he has such significant struggles with sliders off the plate and to a lesser extent curveballs.</p><p>Williams makes in-zone contact a little over 88% of the time but he has limited plate coverage and as such, below-average out-of-zone contact rates. If he can’t hit bad pitches out of the zone then that might be a reason to believe he won’t hit in-zone pitches with better movement in the future. Williams also has a bit of a popout problem and only average line drive rates.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/766/1*ZdYQiBuFkkVw53QXo5R52w.png" /></figure><p>The blend of Williams’ ability to barrel his batted balls and make frequent contact is nearly unmatched in college baseball (See graph above) but there is hit risk all the same. There is also power risk to a much lesser extent. Williams makes above-average swing decisions but even that has risks with his slider struggles. Peyton Williams doesn’t have a fallback if he can’t hit in the majors. There is clear offensive upside here but it’s a risky bat and as a 1B only, the upside is severely limited.</p><h3>8.248 LF Dylan Rock, Texas A&amp;M</h3><p>Dylan Rock is not the Rock that you want to build your franchise on, despite what they might teach you in Sunday school. That does not mean that Dylan Rock doesn’t have the potential to be a valuable MLB contributor, just that he’s not a cornerstone player. (Obviously, I was just way too proud of this joke to not include it).</p><p>Dylan Rock seems likely to wind up in left field despite him getting some run in centerfield in the past. He’s only a 55 runner and has a below-average arm based on everything I’ve been told (I haven’t seen it in action myself). The lack of defensive value means that Rock has to hit to play regularly and despite a 159 wRC+ in the SEC this year, I’m not comfortable saying that Rock can do that. Dylan Rock is nearly 24 and given his lackluster track record of production, and the nature of his breakout, I am very skeptical that Rock will continue to hit at higher levels.</p><p>Dylan Rock has a Max EV of 108.6 MPH which is above the major league average but nothing special. His Top 8th EV of 102.9 MPH is only in the 80th percentile of college hitters. It is above-average raw power out of the Rock but not anything elite by any definition of the word. Dylan Rock does well in all of Hard-Hit rate, Average EV, and ISOcon but given the lack of top-end EVs, and track record; I suspect that those readings are just him being advanced enough to showcase sublime barrel accuracy and avoid softly hit balls as a result.</p><p>Dylan Rock gets some benefit of the doubt though because of the game power skills possibly outstripping the raw output. Dylan’s groundball rate is in the 95th percentile and he hits a lot of batted balls over 3000 RPMs and with backspin. The game power is held back some by below-average spray directions but I do think that Dylan Rock is probably still an above-average power threat.</p><p>I also worry about Dylan Rock’s BABIP profile regressing. On top of the aforementioned poor spray charts that extend beyond flyballs, Rock has concerns. The largest of those concerns is a 2nd percentile popup rate. The high line drive rates balanced those out for the most part but will that last at the higher levels? I’m at least a wee bit skeptical.</p><p>Dylan Rock made contact at an above-average rate this year but again, I have reason to be at least a little bit skeptical. Dylan Rock does not have that strong of a track record in this department and still was only running 50-55 grade contact rates this year. He also was still struggling to hit breaking balls and had poor out of zone contact rates. In fact, most of the improvements in the contact rates this year were still just a byproduct of his swing decisions maturing until they were above average. Another skill improvement that could easily be written off as Rock’s age.</p><p>Dylan Rock improved in a lot of ways this year but none of them are easy to assign a reason to, other than age. That lack of reason makes me skeptical that Rock will continue to hit in the higher levels. I still have a 35 FV on Dylan Rock because I think that he’s improved too much for at least one thing to not be real and justify that grade, but I’m not enamored with this profile. There is an appeal here but left fielders with limited offensive upside and risk are not my cup of tea.</p><h3>9.278 SP/RP Devereaux Harrison, Long Beach State</h3><p>Devereaux Harrison has a deep repertoire consisting of five pitches but he is nevertheless probably a reliever at the next level. Harrison only really has one even league average pitch and some command woes- moreover, he has a very shaky-batted ball profile. There are five pitches but I think Harrison might be better off if chooses 2–3 of them to hone into actual good pitches rather than splitting his attention in pursuing hopeless endeavors.</p><p>Devereaux Harrison has a plus fastball at the very least. The heater sits at 92.3 MPH and he is capable of reaching back for 95.7 MPH at his most desperate. That velocity plays up, however, due to him having elite extension that adds nearly two full ticks to his heater. The four-seam fastball is thrown on a 12:30 axis and is basically exclusively moving vertically through the zone. The fastball has 18.7&quot; IVB which admittedly doesn’t sound like a lot but given the 5.5&#39; release height and 0.6&#39; horizontal release, the pitch still plays really well at the top of the zone. The fact that he only has 4.1&quot; of horizontal movement explains a lot of Harrison’s batted ball problems fairly succinctly.</p><p>The slider is Harrison’s most used secondary pitch but I’m not going to pretend to love the profile. He sits at 81 MPH with good snappy movement on the slider as he gets 9&quot; of glove side sweep. The problem with Harrison’s slider is two-fold. First off, Harrison has limited depth on his slider with well below-average vertical movement at 4.6&quot; IVB.</p><p>Secondly, Devereaux Harrison drops the arm slot on his slider a tad- he does this on three of his secondaries actually. The slider comes from a 0.9&#39; horizontal release which really isn’t the ideal shape for a slider to miss bats and lacks deception as well because the fastball is more vertical. Devereaux has some promising elements to his side piece but it needs a lot of work.</p><p>Devereaux Harrison throws a pair of mediocre changeups as well. The conventional changeup is not any good with only 6&quot; of run and 8.2&quot; IVB. He has 10 MPH of velocity separation and gets down to just 1410 RPMs but it’s coming from a lower slot than the fastball (Still very medial release) and he has no ability to pronate. There is also a splitter that is distinct enough to split but only a marginal upgrade. The pitch sits at just 1100 RPMs with the exact same velocity. The pitch has 10.9&quot; of fade but still just 6.4&quot; IVB and doesn’t look all that impressive aside from velocity and spin.</p><p>The curveball might be Harrison’s most exciting secondary which admittedly isn’t saying a lot. One of the key attractions here is that Harrison is throwing it from the same arm slot as the fastball, unlike the other three pitches. The curveball has an acceptable velocity at 77.3 MPH and good sweep with him averaging 12.4&quot; HB. The problem remains poor depth with Harrison sitting at -3.9&quot; IVB. There is some upside in the slurve but I would still grade it as below-average if forced to do something so arbitrary.</p><p>Devereaux Harrison could get away with four meh secondaries off the back of the plus fastball if he had good command but Harrison doesn’t really have that. Harrison is interesting because a velocity boost could give him a second quality pitch (Slider) and maybe even a third one as well while elevating the already good fastball. All of his stuff has flaws but he shows some feel too and he’s not hopeless. It’s a weird profile that I have mixed feelings regarding. This is probably a fair value for the selection.</p><h3>10.308 SP/RP Ian Churchill, San Diego</h3><p>If you ask me to explain why I dislike the FV system, Ian Churchill is my go to example of how the system fails to properly understand the nuances of the players. Ian Churchill isn’t someone that I can justifiably call higher than a 30 FV right now.</p><p>Churchill didn’t exactly produce at a high level in the WCC this year with a 4.17 ERA and a 4.99 FIP. He only has one pitch that even grades out as average and the other two currently project as 40s. The control is above-average but not elite. I can’t justifiably call an arm with zero above-average pitches who hasn’t performed anything more than a 30 FV. Yet, I actually think that Churchill has a future in the major leagues.</p><p>Ian Churchill’s slider right now is terrible. He only averages 82.4 MPH which is about 8.5 MPH slower than the two-seam fastball and has spin rates below 2000 on the majority of his pitches. The pitch has below-average depth at just 4.4&quot; IVB and no sweep as well at just 0.5&quot; HB. The slider is complete garbage as things currently stand.</p><p>Except, it does not have to remain that way. I am fairly confident that Churchill will pick up a sweeper in pro ball and I think it can be a really good one. Ian Churchill shows a feel for both a two-seam grip (What he uses for the fastball) and seam-shifted wake which he utilizes to great effect on his changeup. His slider already has low efficiency and you should be able to combine those three elements in theory to create a great sweeper.</p><p>Except, you don’t really need a good sweeper from Churchill for the slider to play. All you need is a halfway decent one because of Ian Churchill’s release traits. Ian Churchill throws the current configuration of his slider from a 3.3&#39; horizontal release point. That would give him one of the best horizontal approach angles in the league with even just average sweep. 82.4 MPH is enough velocity for an average sweeper to reap souls from his slot and the velo can likely further improve.</p><p>So how do I grade the slider? The current version of the pitch sucks but if he completely revamps the shape of it, he could have an elite one. In theory, at least. This is why tool grades aren’t an effective method of valuing a pitch. Ian Churchill has a 40 slider that could become a plus overnight but can you actually depend on it getting there? I’m betting the Blue Jays think they can and that is why they took him on day two but it’s still just a theory until he makes the transition to a sweeper.</p><p>The fastball also has an easy way to get better. For starters, he should not be throwing it exactly 70% of the time. If he only used it 69% of the time it would be a much nicer pitch…</p><p>Okay, in all seriousness, he should be using it a lot less than that too. The two-seam fastball has too much efficiency but 15&quot; IVB and 16&quot; HB is still fine shape when it is coming from a 5.6&#39; release height. I would be interested in seeing what the elevated two-seamer could do but I do think it works best with the ideal shape of his arsenal if he is pitching down and starts getting more drop on the pitch.</p><p>The real key for the fastball though is just throwing harder. The pitch shape is fine but he only sits 90–91 MPH and tops out at 94 MPH. Apart from the standard every pitcher adds velocity in pro-ball reasoning, there is plenty of reason to believe that Churchill in particular will add velocity. There is projection in his frame and he moves well with a deep loading mechanism. There are some simple tweaks to his lower body that could unlock another bit of velo out of him.</p><p>The changeup is Churchill’s best pitch right now but there is a somewhat decent chance that it winds up as his worst in the long run. Churchill has an unconventional arm slot for a chase changeup but he has the glove side command that causes me to still believe in the pitch. There is 15&quot; of arm side fade with is only average but 4.8&quot; IVB is good depth. The real appeal though is the seemingly late break to the pitch and the ability to kill spin with him sitting under 1500 RPMs. He probably needs a tad more separation from the fastball than just 7 MPH but it’s a solid pitch.</p><p>Ian Churchill throws strikes at a high rate and has three pitches that with major adjustments could all be quite good. How likely is Churchill to make those major adjustments though? That is not something I have the answer to. It’s a really hard profile to value in one number but I actually like Churchill and think he could shoot up in a year&#39;s time. This was a money saving pick but it could still be a good value selection as well.</p><h3>11.338 SP/RP Pat Gallagher, Connecticut</h3><p>Pat Gallagher needs to add velocity but he has solid upside in all three pitches and above-average strike-throwing ability. The fastball is only thrown at 88–90 MPH and tops out at 93 MPH. Obviously, you need more velocity than that but it is average ride with 13&quot; of tail from a 5.4&#39; release height. The angle and shape are solid enough that league-average velocity would make him interesting.</p><p>The changeup has everything going for it except velocity as well. The changeup is thrown nearly 1000 RPMs lower than the fastball at 1400 RPMs on average. He also has an elite movement profile with just 1.8&quot; IVB and 15.7&quot; HB from a standard 1.9&#39; release side in trackman games this year. The lone issue with the changeup specs is that he throws it only 5 MPH slower than the average fastball.</p><p>You can actually overcome having no velocity separation- possibly even without changing the shape of the changeup but Gallagher doesn’t use his changeup as an all movement no separation pitch should be used. The changeup can still get chases without velocity separation- more of them even as long as the movement is there. The movement is there for Gallagher. However, Gallagher prefers to use his changeup like one that is all separation and no movement. He lives in the zone and pitches it in similar spots to his fastball. This severely cuts his whiff ability and leads to some hard contact.</p><p>The curveball is the most interesting element of Gallagher’s arsenal. At first -7.8&quot; IVB and 4&quot; of sweep don’t look like all that much even when he is spinning the ball at over 2500 RPMs on average. What makes the curve stand out though is velocity as Gallagher is averaging 82.1 MPH in Trackman games. That sounds good rather than elite but that number is lacking context.</p><p>Pat Gallagher throws his curveball only 6.8 MPH slower than his fastball. There is no major leaguer with as little velocity separation between their curveball and fastball. I’m fairly certain there is no one even within 2 MPH of him in velocity separation between the two pitches. The curveball has ~average depth as well. This isn’t some bastardized slider. The curveball drops 33&quot; more with gravity without significant velocity separation. Good luck, you will absolutely need it.</p><p>If Gallagher gets to league average velocity and his curveball velocity increases proportionately, then Gallagher could have one of the best hooks in the game. The fastball shape is solid and the pitch will be defined by velocity. The changeup maybe wants better separation but you could get away just by using it more intelligently. Gallagher is able to throw all three pitches in the zone and has good pitch shape. The only ingredient missing here is velocity and most teams are good at developing velocity these days.</p><h3>12.368 P Nolan Perry, Carlsbad High School</h3><p>I haven’t been able to find much on Nolan Perry despite receiving positive reviews from everyone I talked to about him. The delivery looks awesome in limited looks from poor camera angles. He has good balance and timing throughout from what I can tell. Perry is seemingly athletic and there is projection in the frame. The fastball also hits 90 MPH which is more meh than great but you’d expect him to improve further with time. I’ve been told he has feel for spinning the breaking ball but in limited video, I haven’t been that impressed. There is some semblance of a changeup. I don’t have the video or pitch data to judge Perry so I won’t.</p><h3>13.398 RP Bo Bonds, Louisiana Lafayette</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/exploring-the-most-unheralded-demographic-college-relievers-3c8239930dc6"><em>I already wrote a very detailed scouting report of Bo Bonds in my Relievers Blog so if you want more on him as a pitcher, go read that one. </em></a><em>This report is going to go into less detail and work as more of a general overview.</em></p><p>Bo Bonds has an electric fastball but it’s a one trick pony of a pitch. Bonds only sits at 92.3 MPH with a somewhat high release and below-average extension. Given the 5&#39;11&quot; frame, projection on the velocity and the ilk is a bit limited. The horizontal movement is basically league average. The only thing that makes the fastball a plus pitch is vertical movement and it might be better than a plus because of that one thing as Bonds averages 22.8&quot; IVB. That is a lot, to say the least.</p><p>Bo Bonds also has an above-average curveball. The pitch only sits at 77 MPH but it has great movement with -13.6&quot; IVB and 12.2&quot; of sweep towards his glove side. The movement is great but he needs to add some velocity and he struggles to land the curveball in the strike zone. The shape is there but he needs to either throw more strikes or throw harder for it to really perform.</p><p>I have too much respect for the movement profiles of the fastball and curveball to write off Bo Bonds, in spite of the concerns with the profile. Bo Bonds doesn’t have an obvious route to more velocity but velocity is very much teachable and the Blue Jays are one of the many teams with a history of squeezing out more velocity. The impact of Bonds right now is slim but he can take his time in the minors and be a respectable middle reliever in a few years’ time or with a velocity jump be a high leverage arm.</p><h3>14.428 C Sammy Hernandez, Lakeland Senior (HS)</h3><p>Sammy Hernandez is a prep catcher which is a demographic that I am naturally hesitant to buy in on. Hernandez is not that exceptional of an athlete but he should stick behind the plate. He has sufficient mobility to catch and above-average pop times. The hands are whatever and completely irrelevant with the pending implementation of the automatic ball strike system long before Hernandez debuts.</p><p>The bat is obviously what really matters in any prospect though. I think Sammy Hernandez probably only has average raw power. The bat speed is a 50–55 grade skill but I worry that he won’t get to that power in games. There is present-day strength in his lower half but there isn’t a ton of hip-torso separation in his swing so, despite the strength, the power plays down some.</p><p>The current swing appears to be more oriented towards contact than power. The swing is very flat with a level bat head that should help the contact rates but make it difficult for Hernandez to regularly put the ball in the air. That flat path also makes it easier for Hernandez to mishit balls.</p><p>There is not that much wrong with prioritizing contact quantity over quality but I don’t think Hernandez makes that much contact even with him prioritizing contact quantity. Sammy’s front side gets stiff and it can cause whiffs on pitches he doesn’t read perfectly. Sammy Hernandez has upside but he needs work like most day three preps. We’ll know more about who he is in a year or two.</p><h3>15.458 IF Michael Turconi, Wake Forest</h3><p>Michael Turconi played shortstop in college and I don’t even think that he necessarily can’t play there in the majors. He has average range and above-average arm strength as well. The actions are solid and good enough for shortstop. The problem is arm accuracy and it’s a huge problem that leads to a lot of throwing errors. I think that second base is probably the long-term home for Turconi where he can put less effort into his throws to avoid overthrowing so much but any infield spot- or even the outfield is possible.</p><p>Michael Turconi makes contact at a slightly above-average rate and he rarely chases. The chase rates are more a result of being passive than good swing decisions though as he swings less than 60% of the time in the strike zone. The raw power is also below-average with a Max EV of 105.3 MPH and a Top 8th EV of 100.4 MPH. The average college player is at 105.4 MPH Max and 100.2 MPH Top 8th. The power probably won’t improve much either as a smaller 23 year old but I’ve been wrong before.</p><p>The calling card here though is the batted ball profile. Michael Turconi has what FaBIO has as a 99th percentile batted ball profile and it might allow him to perform in spite of swinging a noodle. The groundball rate is in the 98th percentile and the line drive rate is in the 99th percentile. The popup rate is also above-average; He has optimal spray directions and elite launch angle tightness.</p><p>If you can add power then Michael Turconi could be a huge steal at this point in the draft. I’m not too up to date on how good the Blue Jays strength development is but a team like the Astros could make this into a good player. The problem is that his barrel accuracy is the carrying skill right now and barrel accuracy is often an illusion of age. This was his first year of truly displaying elite barrel accuracy which compounds the risk. There is risk here and the tools aren’t loud but the skills potentially are.</p><h3>16.488 RP/SP Kale Davis, Oklahoma State</h3><p>Kale Davis has four distinct pitches but only one of them is likely to wind up above-average. The problem is that lack of an out pitch and that Kale Davis has below-average command. I’m not a huge fan of the profile but I can see the appeal in him as a day three pick.</p><p>The fastball is his lone above-average pitch. The heater only sits at 92.1 MPH and tops out at 95 MPH with pretty average spin rates. The appeal heare is what Hawkeye has as 18.7&quot; IVB from a 5.55&#39; release height. The fastball is flat at the top of the strike zone and as a result, Kale misses a healthy amount of bats up in the zone. Or at least he would if he elevated regularly. The fastball is a 55 grade pitch as things stand and could move into plus territory with a velocity bump.</p><p>The secondary pitches leave a bit to be desired. Kale Davis only sits at 77.6 MPH on the curveball with average movement on both planes. I’d argue that is probably his best secondary pitch. The slider is the best-positioned pitch to dispute that claim. He throws it at 82 MPH with a pretty conventional gyro ball shape at 1.3&quot; IVB and 5.2&quot; HB. The changeup only has appeal because of the 0.8&#39; horizontal release point. At the end of the day, it is just 11.5&quot; HB though with below-average vertical depth.</p><p>The appeal of Kale Davis is how impactful a velocity increase would hypothetically be. The slider shape is fine just not thrown hard enough. Ditto for the curveball. The fastball would be a plus pitch with an additional 2 MPH. I don’t think adding velocity makes Kale Davis much more than a middle reliever or spot starter, given the low spin rates with command woes but he becomes an interesting prospect all the same and would quickly move into the 35 FV tier.</p><h3>17.518 RP/SP Ryan Chasse, Campbell</h3><p>Ryan Chasse likes to overwhelm hitters by throwing an entire kitchen sink at them. There are five metrically distinct pitches in his toolbox but he only really leans on two of them right now with those two compiling 90% of the stuff he threw on trackman this year. He also has below-average command and needs a velocity boost to become interesting like most of the arms the Blue Jays drafted on day three.</p><p>Ryan Chasse throws his fastball on a strictly vertical spin axis. As a result, he gets 19.3&quot; IVB but only 4.5&quot; tail. The fastball needs more velocity in a bad way as Chasse only averages 91.4 MPH and tops out at 94 MPH with Trackman. The fastball angle is subpar despite the plus ride because he is throwing a 6.3&#39; release height. The pitch has some potential but I find it difficult to project the pitch as more than average right now- even if I expect a small velocity bump.</p><p>The curveball is Chasse’s most used secondary pitch by a fairly sizeable margin. He throws it at 77.5 MPH with fairly generic movement as he averages both -10&quot; IVB and HB. The high release helps the pitch play down in the zone but you probably still need more velocity from it.</p><p>The slider is the more interesting secondary pitch despite being used a lot less and really just needs velocity. Ryan Chasse only throws his slider at 79.7 MPH on average but has great movement. The slider gets 10&quot; of sweep from a generic arm slot. The pitch has great depth at -2.5&quot; IVB from a high release. The only problem is velocity. Throw harder and this pitch could become average.</p><p>Chasse also throws a changeup at 84.9 MPH with spin rates that sit in the ballpark of 1500 RPMs. The pitch has terrible movement though with 16.3&quot; IVB and 8.3&quot; HB in trackman games. Separation is below-average as well and it’s just hard to muster up any optimism when it comes to the cambio. The slutter is also occasionally there at 83.4 MPH with 11.2&quot; IVB and just 0.7&quot; of cut. The pitch has some potential but is stuck in the ugly middle ground and likely won’t amount to much.</p><p>I can see the appeal in Ryan Chasse. If Chasse adds like 4 MPH to all his stuff he could be a leverage reliever or even fringe back of the rotation starter. Both breaking balls and the heater primarily just need more velocity. There are some control questions but ultimately my skepticism surrounding Chasse comes down to the body. Chasse is 6&#39;3&quot; and 250lbs. Maybe I am understating the value of an MLB conditioning program but I find it very hard to envision Chasse adding significant velocity given the frame and he needs that velocity boost to be a major league arm.</p><h3>18.548 Jérémy Pilon, Valleyfield High School</h3><p>Jérémy Pilon is the youngest player to be drafted in a long time. The rule to be draft eligible as a high schooler is that you must be graduating from high school and have turned 17 by the cutoff date. At this time last year, Pilon was supposed to be draft eligible in 2024.</p><p>Then the draft got pushed back a week from where it was in 2021, pushing Pilon beneath the cutoff date with a 9/11 birthday. This made him draft eligible in 2023. Pilon then doubled down and reclassified by skipping a grade. Thus making him eligible this year- despite only being 16 at the time he was drafted. Pilon is more than a teenage gimmick though. Primarily based on the eye test, I actually really like what Pilon brings to the table in small sample looks.</p><p>To my understanding, Jérémy Pilon has a fastball that sits 88–91 MPH from the left handed side. I think there is probably room to improve that velocity too, given how well he moves on the mound — even if it’s a bit of a slighter frame. Pilon gets pretty deep in his glutes and has a strong lower half, I really don’t have any issue projecting here.</p><p>This likely holds almost no value but on film, the fastball looks like it has good ride with some hints of arm side run as well. You can’t eye test fastball movement so please don’t read that much into my statement. The real reason to buy in on the fastball from Pilon though is Jérémy’s size and arm slot.</p><p>Jeremy Pilon throws from a very vertical arm slot that makes it easy to generate backspin with his heater, in theory. There is present spinal tilt to Pilon’s operation and he rides low to the ground; given the 6&#39;0&quot; stature, it’s fairly likely that Pilon has a lower release height than most arms. Pilon also has spin rates north of 2400 at times. I don’t have perfect info here but every data point I’ve seen, and all the bullpens I’ve seen video of have looked impressive to my eyes.</p><p>I have much lower confidence in my evaluations of the rest of Jérémy Pilon’s arsenal. The curveball is a slower breaking ball that sits 72–75 MPH and has spin rates that cross over the 2800 RPMs barrier. The shape looks impressive on film with both depth and sweep but he does slow the arm a tad. The changeup is there from what I’ve heard but I have no data or visuals of it. There is some potential in Pilon’s secondary weapons but the fastball is probably the carrying card.</p><p>I like Jérémy Pilon’s sense of timing and think he will throw strikes. I’m too much of a coward to call it above-average control given his age but there is little reason to believe he won’t get there. The body is good and as Pilon ages past his seventeenth birthday, I’m expecting an uptick in stuff. He should fill out the projectable frame and get stronger.</p><p>This is a good value pick in the 18th round if he signs but that is a sizeable if. My understanding of the situation is that Pilon grew up a Blue Jays fan and is at least open to the possibility but I don’t know if the Blue Jays have the financial muscle to meet Pilon’s demand at this point in the draft.</p><h3>19.578 SP/RP Gage Stanifer, Westfield High School</h3><p>Gage Stanifer is probably not signing at this point but was instead drafted as a contingency pick if their deal with Toman or Perry fell through. He’s an interesting prospect I had a day three grade on before the draft who would have likely cost a bit too much to be drafted earlier.</p><p>The fastball reaches up to 96 MPH already. The projection is somewhat limited but it’s a strong workhorse frame with good on the mound athleticism. He’s already holding low nineties deep into starts and I suspect that will uptick a tad more in the next couple of years. The problem is the fastball has generic shape with more tail than rise and even if he has above-average velocity, it won’t be much better than an average pitch.</p><p>The slider is the primary appeal of Gage Stanifer’s stuff. He throws it in the low-mid eighties with above-average movement on both planes. The pitch is mostly gyro dependent but has good depth all the same and tight late breaking action towards his glove side. The pitch has low spin rates but still projects well. I’m less sold on the mid eighties changeup with 16&quot; of fade but significant issues with getting firm and the depth on the pitch.</p><p>The primary appeal of Stanifer is not stuff, however, but command. Gage Stanifer is a great athlete with a smooth and easily repeatable delivery. He has a low release and consistently throws strikes. The stuff might not jump out at you but he’s just well put together and trending towards a back of the rotation role. He’s too distant from the majors for me to get excited yet but it’s easy to envision him in a major league rotation one day.</p><h3>20.608 CF Gregory Pace Jr., Detroit Edison HS</h3><p>Gage Stanifer is unlikely to sign but given that Toman has already signed, I’d put the odds of a Pace signing at about 0.1%. The tools are there and he’ll be exciting at Michigan rather than Toronto. Blue Jays fans can stop reading here.</p><p>Wolverine fans, let me tell you about your newest top recruit; the local kid I’m sure most of you know at least a little about by now… Anyways, Gregory Pace Jr. is a freak athlete with 80 grade speed and elite arm strength to boot. He ran a 6.23 second 60 yard dash and has thrown 97 MPH from the outfield on a crow hop. He should play an above-average centerfield given the athleticism and possibly be a bit better than that, depending on how the body progresses that is.</p><p>Gregory Pace Jr. should hit for above-average power during his prime. There is projection in the frame and Pace has plus bat speed. The approach angles are regularly positive and he has a somewhat steep bat angle. I even like the way that Pace Jr. engages his lower half. There is real impact potential in the contact quality.</p><p>My concerns for Gregory Pace ultimately boil down to hit risk. The swing is compact and mostly direct but he has some pitch recognition concerns that bring him down to earth. Gregory often expands the zone in pursuit of breaking balls and has struggled in most of my looks against quality arms. There isn’t a ton of flexibility in his swing and he struggles with pitches away from him but he’s young and athletic so development in that regard is far from impossible.</p><p>Ultimately, the concern with Pace is just risk. He has the capacity to have all five tools. I think the hit concerns are fixable, but it’s not likely. The power is above-average but not elite and that means if he doesn’t get to a 40+ hit tool, he won’t be able to play every day. There is an obvious route to stardom in the athletic profile and I would have been fine with taking Pace Jr. in the fifth-round range but the risk has to be acknowledged. Fun player but there is not much separating Gregory Pace Jr. from a plethora of other athletes with the same hit tool concerns in the same tier.</p><p><em>That was way longer than I planned lol. Hopefully, you enjoyed it. The next blog theoretically comes out on Friday where I will break down the Red Sox draft class.</em></p><h4>Other Draft Analysis Blogs:</h4><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/baltimore-orioles-draft-analysis-e5ba71c0454c"><strong>Baltimore Orioles</strong></a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c72e4f28f8e9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Baltimore Orioles Draft Analysis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/baltimore-orioles-draft-analysis-e5ba71c0454c?source=rss-f20e8b3389a4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e5ba71c0454c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[baltimore-orioles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb-draft]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tieran Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Jul 2022 19:55:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-26T07:07:17.878Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Baltimore Orioles surprised a lot of people with their lauded first overall choice in the draft by doing what no one expected: Take the best player on their draft board. Not planning on saving money, they continued to take players at roughly their slot value — not diverging from that much in either direction. An administration known for unexpected picks came out of the All-Star break with a great draft class while utilizing what is a frankly boring strategy.</p><p>In this piece, I will break down all of the players that the Orioles drafted this year. From #1 overall to #587, here is every player joining the Orioles organization through the draft and why you should be excited to maybe one day see them in Baltimore. I will not be grading draft picks or calling any player bad. If a pick is good is defined by your plan to develop them, I don’t have the knowledge to judge that so all picks are fine until we see that they were not.</p><p><em>The FV system is stupid but I use it to clickbait people. Prospects are infinitely more complicated than one number. It’s a loose baseline but I like players with low FVs and dislike ones with a higher FV. The report is what matters, not the number. X is a placeholder for players that I do not have enough information to assess.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/573/1*KF7wlglx8yglij-qfK1n1g.png" /></figure><h3>1.1 SS Jackson Holliday, Stillwater High School</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/mlb-draft-top-500-prospects-fba9fe7fceaf"><em>I already wrote a very detailed scouting report of Jackson Holliday on my top 500 so if you want more on him, go read that one</em></a><em>. This report is going to go into less detail and work as more of a general overview.</em></p><p>I said before the draft that there was a coherent argument that Jackson Holliday is the top player in the draft and evidently that is the argument that the Orioles subscribe to. I only had him #3 overall but the appeal is obvious here.</p><p>Jackson Holliday has one of the best hit tools in the entire draft. He ran elite contact rates during the summer against top prep competition and then set the National prep record for hits this spring. He doesn’t ever expand the zone- even on tougher breaking balls and while general passivity can be a weakness, it’s not a crippling one. Jackson Holliday should have a very strong strikeout/walk profile that might make him a safer hitter than Druw Jones or Elijah Green- the only players I had ranked above Holliday.</p><p>Jackson Holliday has added a lot of power in the last year or thereabouts. He started rocking back into his backside to generate power when he throws himself forward and his leg kick added some flare. He pushes off with more authority and he has been engaging his lower half a lot more. The lower half still probably wants to add some strength but he has great hand speed and elite core strength that is already letting him post above-average power metrics. Jackson Holliday should hit for both contact and power- game power too, not just raw.</p><p>I think Jackson Holliday has a good chance of sticking at shortstop. He’s a plus runner in the present, who is seemingly getting faster and not slower every day. His agility testing is top notch and his lateral movements in both directions are near the top of the scale as well. Holliday offers above-average arm strength and is accurate from multiple angles. There is some risk that filling in the lower half stunts the athleticism but in that scenario, the power is likely significantly higher and you don’t care if he plays third base then.</p><p>Jackson Holliday offers five tools and has a sky high baseball IQ with an understanding of the game and himself. He makes adjustments consistently and most of them have worked out for him. He’s the son of an All-Star so you can check off bloodlines as well. I don’t think the ceiling is maybe as high as Druw Jones or Elijah Green but this is still a great pick given how well-rounded and polished he is coming out of high school.</p><h3>1.33 RF Dylan Beavers, California</h3><p>Dylan Beavers got first-round grades from a number of evaluators and it is not remotely difficult to see why that is. Dylan Beavers hits the ball hard incredibly often and most of his contact is hit in the air. He only has 26 batted balls with tracking this year but he still has a Max EV of 109.6 MPH which ranks in the 60th percentile of major leaguers. I would bet my soul that his raw power is significantly better than that one figure suggests.</p><p>Dylan Beavers in that same small sample size has a top 8th EV of 106.7 MPH. That is in the 96th percentile of college bats this year. I still think that might be underselling him given that he hit eight batted balls at &lt;105 MPH in that same 26 BBE sample. The average college player hits 30.5% of his batted ball in excess of 95 MPH. Dylan Beavers hit 30.8% of his in excess of 105 MPH. Things don’t really compare this way but only Giancarlo Stanton has even hit 30% of his batted balls in &lt;105 MPH this year. I will hammer the over on Beavers&#39;s raw power and given that he had a 97th percentile outfield flyball rate this year, I’ll hammer the over on the game power even more aggressively.</p><p>Dylan Beavers makes above-average swing decisions as well. He walks at an extremely high rate and almost never expands the zone despite being aggressive in the zone. Whiffs are a real concern though and are especially prominent against breaking balls. His hand path is very unorthodox and it’s possible he has to tweak some things. In addition to whiff concerns, he’s not likely to run high BABIPs given that he has below-average popup and line drive rates.</p><p>Beavers is also only a 50 athlete who isn’t exactly fleet of foot and only has a 50–55 arm. He won’t play centerfield and even sticking in right field isn’t a guarantee. The power is the calling card for Beavers and it’s a very attractive calling card but he probably fits best as a three-true outcome-dependent corner outfielder. There is value in that player but it’s a fairly risky profile.</p><h3>2.42 3B/1B Max Wagner, Clemson</h3><p>Max Wagner falls into the same mold as most of the hitters that the Orioles drafted this year. He has power and advanced swing decisions with hit tool questions and in this instance, defensive questions. Max Wagner was the best hitter in college baseball for the final 28 games of the year but up until that point was largely mediocre for Clemson. Depending on how much you are willing to buy in on that small sample data determines where he should have gone in the draft.</p><p>The power is loud and it plays in games. Wagner has a Max EV of 110.8 MPH and a top 8th EV of 104.6 MPH which is in the 91st percentile of college hitters. He also has an above-average feel to elevate. The result is a 98th percentile barrel rate at 17.4% and his actual output of homers exceeds even that due to the ability to pull the ball at what might be too high of a rate. The power is an easy plus projection both now and moving forwards.</p><p>I have a number of questions about the hit tool, however. Those questions are actually not that closely tied to the ability to make contact as Wagner actually has fairly respectable contact rates both in the zone and out- I would likely grade them as a 40 grade projection. No, my concern primarily stems from the BABIP profile.</p><p>I realize how stupid that sounds given the 97th percentile BAcon this year but allow me to explain. Max Wagner has a tendency to pull the ball. That hurts the batting averages less for a right-handed batter like Wagner than it does a lefty but I’m still going to be worried by a 60% pull rate this year- especially when he’s close to 70% on ground balls. In addition, Wagner has a pop-up problem with a 15th percentile popup rate this year. He hits the ball hard and abuses poor defenses as a result but I don’t expect the BABIP excellence to be sustained. He’s very vulnerable to good defensive positioning and runs into too many automatic outs between the strikeouts and popups.</p><p>Max Wagner makes superb swing decisions. He has an 89th percentile chase rate and 75th percentile zone swing rate in Trackman games this year. Only 17 players in the entire country rank as highly in both chase rate and zone-swing rate. Wagner has some trouble with hitting stuff down in the zone but his ability to not chase those pitches minimizes the risk considerably.</p><p>If I thought Max Wagner would stick at third base then he probably would have earned a round one grade from me. The power is louder in games than in batting practice and it’s already loud there. He should walk at a high clip and keep the strikeout rates respectable. The BABIP skills are likely at least partially patchable and if you can do that, he’s an elite offensive threat. (Barring a high tool collapse). I think he’s more likely to wind up at first base but I do still find the profile attractive.</p><h3>2.67 CF Jud Fabian, Florida</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/mlb-draft-top-500-prospects-fba9fe7fceaf"><em>I already wrote a very detailed scouting report of Jud Fabian on my top 500 so if you want more on him, go read that one</em></a><em>. This report is going to go into less detail and work as more of a general overview.</em></p><p>Jud Fabian was the Red Sox second round pick a year ago but they couldn’t sign him. He proceeded to go 27 picks later in his second go around this time to the Red Sox division rivals. His bonus will likely be lower in his second attempt despite the swing decisions improving immensely and the contact rates improving ever so slightly as well while maintaining the same plus game power and plus glove in centerfield.</p><p>Jud Fabian has major hit tool questions he has yet to answer. Jud Fabian has league-average whiff rates against breaking balls and almost never chases them so his swinging-strikes rates are minuscule. The story was the same for Fabian against breaking balls last year. The improvement this year was that he started to dominate off-speed stuff and literally only has one weakness at the plate now.</p><p>That one weakness is the high fastball and it hurts him more than kryptonite hurts superman. He has zero trouble with hitting velocity down and zero trouble with hitting four-seam fastballs inside or outside in the bottom half. The problem is location. If the fastball- or likely any pitch for that matter is elevated, Fabian will not hit it. He has a 28.6% Swinging-Strike rate against fastballs in the top half of the zone this year.</p><p>Jud Fabian has the skills to potentially overcome that weakness and it starts with the best swing decisions in the country (Based on swings/takes and strike probability). The problem is his decisions are tailored to strike probability rather than what he can do damage on and as a result, Fabian swings at 61.2% of pitches in the top half of the zone. It’s better for him to watch the occasional strike than be aggressive up in the zone.</p><p>That is the optimal approach for Jud Fabian to be successful right now at least. However, I subscribe to the Rockies&#39; philosophy that you can’t learn to hit hard pitches by watching them. He should continue to be aggressive in the lower levels, until he learns to at least be useable against four-seam fastballs up in the zone. If things aren’t working then maybe you change course and opt for patience but for his long-term development, it is best to not give up on such a large chunk of pitches he sees.</p><p>Once he is in AAA you adjust the approach so he can succeed in the majors but for now, he should continue to try to hit the stuff that he can’t hit. Unfortunately for me, this is not the philosophy the Orioles preach, so I wouldn’t expect to see this from him in the minors.</p><p>The other concern for Jud Fabian is barrel accuracy. He has a lot of mishits. Fabian has a 7th percentile popup rate this year. He also only has a 25th percentile line drive rate. The amount of extremely high launch angle batted balls leads to very low BABIPs and makes it hard to believe in the hit tool.</p><p>Jud Fabian has exceptional power though. His Max EV is 110.9 MPH which ranks in the 69th percentile of major league hitters and his top 8th EV of 104.7 MPH ranks in the 91st percentile. In addition, Jud Fabian has a 97th percentile outfield flyball rate this year and that combined with the plus raw power has Fabian posting an 18% barrel rate which is in the 98th percentile of college hitters. In addition, Jud Fabian has the highest rate of pulled outfield flyballs in the entire SEC, and as such outperforms even the elite barrel rates. (He also has a below-average pull rate on groundballs somehow).</p><p>The bat is genuinely incredible, it just has one fatal flaw. He’s also an elite athlete who plays a plus centerfield. The one concern is hitting high fastballs. If Fabian can do that then he is a star. If he can not figure that out, most people would tell you he would wash out in AA. I disagree.</p><p>Hitting four-seamers up- or at least not swinging at them is absolutely mandatory to be an everyday player in the majors. That being said, a creative manager can still get a lot of mileage out of Fabian even with that weakness. Not every pitcher in baseball uses the high fastball. Jud Fabian will bully sinkerballers and breaking ball heavy relievers. He will provide value on defense.</p><p>Fabian’s not a normal platoon player (He actually has reverse splits this year) but he could have a workload comparable to the weakside of one if deployed correctly. He’s at worst a lethal weapon off the bench against sinker primaries and a late game defensive substitution. There is a floor here, it’s just an unconventional one that very few teams will recognize the existence of. I love the value here at the end of the second round for the Orioles and think Jud fits their offensive philosophy like a glove.</p><h3>3.81 P/3B Nolan McLean, Oklahoma State</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/exploring-the-most-unheralded-demographic-college-relievers-3c8239930dc6"><em>I already wrote a very detailed scouting report of Nolan McLean in my Relievers Blog so if you want more on him as a pitcher, go read that one. </em></a><em>This report is going to focus much more on McLean as a hitter with a briefer overview of his talents on the mound.</em></p><p>Nolan McLean was drafted as a pitcher but the Orioles have said he will also get some reps at DH in the minors so we’ll cover both halves of his game in this section.</p><p>Nolan McLean is someone I had pegged as a reliever before the draft but I’m warming up to the idea that he could start at the next level. Arm strength is the primary appeal with his fastball sitting at 95 MPH and touching 98. The movement profile is somewhat generic but he has a very unique release with a 5.36&#39; RelHeight and 2.5&#39; RelSide in Hawkeye games. As a result, the four-seam fastball still misses a lot of bats when elevated despite slightly below-average vertical movement. The sinker is used as a chase pitch against lefties to great success and has a generic sinker shape as well.</p><p>The secondaries all project fairly well too. I won’t go into excessive detail for once but he offers all of a cutter, slider, and slurvy curveball. The latter two project as at least above-average and the cutter is also still average even if more used to set up the rest of his arsenal than as a whiff pitch. The control is below-average but he’s athletic and the delivery is pretty well balanced so there is some projection there.</p><p>So why can’t McLean start? The lack of changeup, arm slot, and extreme HAA of his breaking balls are all somewhat valid reasons but looking at them now, they feel kind of hollow. The sinker is a legitimately good pitch against lefties and he’s smart enough in his pitch usage to be at least passable against lefties. I like the athlete and the delivery. He might struggle against left handed heavy lineups but I think he’s probably at least a short-term starting pitcher.</p><p>The bat is fun and likely not very good. McLean has a 50.5% contact rate this year in games with Trackman- the lowest contact rate in all of college baseball this year. That obviously won’t translate to the majors and I won’t bore you with pretending there is hope for the contact skills. There is none, it’s why he’s almost certainly going to pitch at the next level.</p><p>Nolan McLean also has the highest wOBAcon in the entire country. Nolan has a Max EV of 115.1 MPH and a top 8th EV of 109.7 MPH with pitch tracking. 115.1 MPH is tied for the 11th highest Max EV in the nation. 109.7 MPH is tied for the 8th highest Top 8th EV. His 24.6% barrel rate is tied with Ivan Melendez for the best in the country. Is he good? Absolutely not with those contact rates. Does he have potential? Absolutely with that contact quality.</p><p>Nolan McLean will almost certainly not be a two-way player at the next level but he should make an impact on the mound and maybe occasionally hit off the bench. I’m not sure what exactly his role looks like but this is a great arm talent with multiple paths to being a good player and the stuff you can confidently believe in. The third round was richer than I had him ranked, but I have no issues with the Orioles taking a stab at him so early on.</p><h3>4.107 C Silas Ardoin, Texas</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/potential-day-two-draft-steals-b527f1fa7a48"><em>I already wrote a more detailed scouting report of Silas Ardoin in my Day 2 Steals Blog so if you want more on him, go read that one</em></a><em>. This report is going to go into less detail and work as more of a general overview.</em></p><p>Silas Ardoin is one of the best defensive catchers in the entire draft for the little that I consider that to be worth. He has very smooth hands and gently pulls balls into the strike zone- which is completely irrelevant. Ardoin is a good blocker though and has an above-average arm with both good strength and precision. Pitchers like throwing to him and he’s a lock to remain behind the dish.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*F2ATPuHJpR7US97T" /></figure><p>The blend of contact and hard-hit balls is rare as you can see in the graph that I have inserted above. The problem is that nobody believes the power will translate and for good reason. The Max EV is just 105.9 MPH. His Top 8th EV is only 102.5 MPH. There is no projection here. He hits the ball hard consistently due to being a picky eater with good barrel accuracy but I am very skeptical of the power translating to both wood bats and better pitching. There are spray issues that have kept his elite hard hit rates from shining quite so brightly in games</p><p>The hit tool is legitimately great though. Silas Ardoin had a 97th percentile contact rate this year. He hits everything- velocity, breaking balls, and off-speed pitches in a wide array of locations. That being said, his approach could cause him issues. Silas Ardoin is a very passive hitter who only swings 33.1% of the time. He might not chase all that often but he also swings at just 53% of in-zone pitches. His lack of willingness to swing unless it’s the perfect pitch inflates the contact rates and leads to strikeouts looking. He’s a good contact hitter but it’s more of a plus skill than an elite one.</p><p>Ardoin is still a plus defensive catcher with plus barrel accuracy. Admittedly, there are some mishits but you can still bank on the hit tool and glove likely carrying him to the majors. It’s unclear how impactful the bat will be in the majors but he has a non-zero chance at hitting for some power with high contact rates. He’s a high-floor safe pick that has some upside as well. This is a solid value for the Orioles in the fourth round.</p><h3>5.137 SP/RP Trace Bright, Auburn</h3><p>I think I was too low on Trace Bright before the draft, I trusted the data from a bad Auburn Trackman unit far too much. He’s better than I expected. I still have him as just a 35 FV but it is a very high one now and I definitely see why the Orioles were willing to spend a fifth round pick on Trace Bright.</p><p>The fastball is an above-average pitch with both velocity and movement. The fastball has velocity with Bright sitting at 93 MPH and touching 97 MPH at his best with 6.6&#39; of extension that lets the fastball play up. The fastball also has above-average ride with 17.9&quot; IVB in Hawkeye games from a generic release height. The pitch has very little horizontal movement so he likely will always have batted ball defects.</p><p>The heater should be able to add ride as he improves the efficiency of his 2377 RPMs fastball and could potentially move into plus territory. The arm slot and wrist orientation are both conducive to adding spin efficiency so I do expect that to improve. There is also some velocity projection in his 6&#39;4&quot; frame. This fastball has a lot more potential beyond what it already is and it’s already a solid pitch.</p><p>The secondary pitches are solid. The changeup isn’t that good on traits with just 9.3&quot; IVB and 10.2&quot; HB in Hawkeye games. The appeal here is that Bright kills over 1000 RPMs off his fastball and shaves off just under 10 MPH. The changeup has nearly double the horizontal movement of the fastball and over twice the drop with gravity. It is distinct enough from the fastball to play off of it, even if the traits are poor on their own.</p><p>Trace Bright has two breaking balls and both of them look like they might wind up as quality pitches but both currently need some work. The slider has solid velocity with Bright sitting at 84 MPH and great depth for a gyro slider at -0.4&quot; IVB and just 6 inches of sweep. The pitch is probably only average given the generic arm slot but it shows plenty of potential.</p><p>The curveball is worse right now but maybe better in the long run. Trace Bright needs to add velocity to his curveball as he only sits at 76.9 MPH right now. Aside from that, the pitch is incredible with spin rates near 2800 RPMs and exceptional movement as well. Bright averages -15.9&quot; IVB and 12.9&quot; HB with Trackman and as such, could miss bats with more velocity. This is an average grade but it’s a fairly easy pitch to improve.</p><p>Trace Bright hash is command woes but there are four pitches in his toolset with obvious potential. None of his pitches project as quality major league offerings right away but there’s a pretty clear and not that difficult to traverse road to improving all of them. I think it’s unlikely he improves all of them but even just improving two of them should make him a quality MLB arm. Bright is someone who could easily soar up prospects rankings in a year with good player development. I’m not that high on him but I still don’t mind the pick in the slightest.</p><h3>6.167 CF Douglas Hodo, Texas</h3><p>Douglas Hodo’s only plus tool is his speed but even that is more raw speed than game speed. The speed helps in centerfield but he’s probably only a 55 glove and the arm strength is below-average so it’s far from the carrying tool that will get him to the majors.</p><p>Douglas Hodo does not have very loud offensive tools but they are solid enough. The hit tool is probably below average. Douglas Hodo only has a 74.9% contact rate which is slightly below the collegiate average in trackman games. Fortunately, Hodo balances things out somewhat with what is probably an above-average approach as he chases just 19% of the time, even if he’s also a bit passive in the zone with a Z-Swing% of just 58.8%.</p><p>Hodo’s real hit concerns have more to do with the BABIP profile though as Hodo has just a 14th percentile line drive rate and a 23rd percentile popup rate this year. Additionally, Hodo has one of the highest pull rates in all of college baseball. The BABIPs are still solid though. Why?</p><p>Douglas has an elite ability to generate high spin on his batted balls and hit said batted balls with backspin. Hodo is in the 92nd percentile of batted ball spin rate, and in the 90th percentile of the percentage of his batted balls hit with backspin. It’s a weird mismatch of skills that works but maybe won’t always work.</p><p>The power is fringe-average raw as well. Douglas Hodo has a Max EV right around the MLB average at 107.7 MPH and grades out at about an average projection in top 8th EV as well with Hodo currently sitting at 103 MPH. The hard-hit rates are more than a standard deviation above the collegiate average and that power theoretically should be manifested in games. Douglas Hodo might only have 45 feel to elevate but given the spin traits and extreme pull bias in the contact profile, I really do expect him to run much strong HR/FB rates.</p><p>Douglas Hodo profiles as little more than a bench bat right now who doesn’t stand out for any one thing. Usually, I take the lack of carrying tool as a negative, but I’ll be different this time. If Douglas Hodo can add strength and improve the raw power then the entire profile should quickly ascend. Hodo has a good feel to get to his limited power in games (On paper) with an above-average K/BB profile. He also plays centerfield. More power should help the wOBAcons and that’s the biggest knock on Hodo. He has potential and if the Orioles see a route to more power then this is a good pick in the sixth round.</p><h3>7.197 RP/SP Preston Johnson, Mississippi State</h3><p>Preston Johnson is your typical Orioles late round pitcher. He has a carrying tool in the fastball with elite riding action, but needs more velocity. He has three decent secondaries that need one more thing to be considered quality. There are some walk issues but the delivery is clean so it’s likely those concerns get ironed out in the future.</p><p>The fastball only sits at 91 MPH and tops out at 95 MPH. The release is sub -optimal as well with Preston throwing from a 6.2&#39; release height and 1.4&#39; horizontal release. The pitch still plays as above-average though because Preston Johnson averages 21&quot; IVB on the fastball and is the rare college arm who regularly elevates the fastball. Preston misses a ton of bats at the top of the zone and frequently will jam hitters for popups.</p><p>The slider is his most used secondary but there is an argument that it is actually his worst one. Johnson sits at just 81.1 MPH with the slider and has below-average movement on both planes with just 3.8&quot; IVB and 7.5&quot;. The appeal here is that he has flashed up to 20.2&quot; HB on a slider. The larger appeal is advanced slider command with feel to drop the pitch in the zone for a called strike and the pitch somewhat inexplicably gets whiffs in the zone at an elite rate.</p><p>I do worry about the roughly four inch drop in arm slot that leaves to some sliders getting predicted and hammered over the fence. This is a 45 grade sliderfor me but it also had a 25.5% Swinging-Strike rate this year so maybe I am underselling it significantly.</p><p>The curveball might wind up the better breaking ball despite him using it significantly less. The curve needs more velocity as Preston Johnson only averages 76.3 MPH. The rest of the ingredients are in place for Preston, however, with him averaging -12.6&quot; IVB and 8.6&quot; of sweep. More importantly, he is maintaining the fastball arm slot and has comparable arm speed. He also has the ability to land his curveball for a strike at a high clip so at the very least, he should have solid CSW% because of how many called strikes he’ll draw from a high slot.</p><p>The changeup is Preston Johnson’s best pitch by CSW but probably the worst on specs — even if it’s not actually that bad. Preston kills 8 MPH off his fastballs and only 150 RPMs. The horizontal movement is solid at 15.6&quot; HB and the depth is below-average at 12.6&quot; HB. Except, the fastball shape matters. Johnson has 15.7&quot; more drop with gravity on the cambio compared to the fastball and an additional 6.5&quot; of horizontal movement. The fastball being straight and vertically oriented helps a mediocre changeup play up and he actually has the ability to land his changeup in the zone. He should still add more depth but the pitch is still useable as is.</p><p>Preston Johnson has a walk issue but I blame poor coaching more than Preston’s lack of skills. He shows the ability to throw all four pitches in the zone and all of them are located in fairly optimal spots. I think the walks are just him trying to get cute and pitch around hitters. To be fair, Johnson does have a long ball issue that might be even worse by filling the zone more because he gets firm at times but I think as Johnson becomes more efficient, I’m expecting that he’ll be more able to fill the zone. The stuff is there and he has command. There is work to be done but this is a potential impact major leaguer in a few years.</p><h3>8.227 SP Cameron Weston, Michigan</h3><p>Cameron Weston is not a front of the rotation arm by any means and likely never will be one. What Weston is though, is a relatively-probably-back of the rotation arm/spot starter who can provide some value as a result, even if it is not in any way a sexy profile. He has a very diverse repertoire with six distinct pitches that all could work in the majors with some development and throws a healthy amount of strikes.</p><p>The sinker is his primary pitch and is probably an above-average offering. The sinker has heavy tailing action with Weston averaging 18.4&quot; of horizontal movement and just 8&quot; IVB. The pitch is helped even more by his arm slot as Weston throws from what Hawkeye has as a 5.02&#39; release height and a 1.34&#39; horizontal release. The mostly medial horizontal release helps him get chases and the flatter angle helps him get called strikes down in the zone.</p><p>There are some precise location things to work out but he has good movement and the ability to fill the zone at a respectable velocity. More arm strength would be nice but sitting 91.5 MPH and touching 96 MPH at his best is workable. There is also an occasional four-seam fastball with 45–50 grade vertical movement from a very low release but it’s behind the sinker given the lack of velocity and command at the top of the zone. I do think that it’s probably a pitch worth developing though as it is probably the better option against right handed hitters.</p><p>Cam Weston throws a pair of below-average breaking balls to compliment his sinker and probably uses the two far too often. The slider at 80.9 MPH with average depth and 6.1&quot; of sweep is the better of the two but neither is good. The curve sits at 78 MPH with a perfect 12–6 shape and no seam-shifted wake to muck things up but the spin is entirely inefficient so it has no depth. I think the pitch has real impact potential with improved spin efficiency but I’m not sure how doable it is, and Weston might be better off if he just shelved it entirely.</p><p>Cam Weston throws two different and distinct off speed pitches that both project as above-average. The changeup is filthy and probably the better of the two. He sits at just 79.6 MPH and throws it on a 3:00 spin axis with basically the same spin rates as the sinker. As a result, Weston gets 18.7&quot; of tail and just 2.4&quot; IVB. That is lethal movement and can overwhelm hitter from his medial release point. The velocity separation is impactful and combined with the difference in drop, leads to his changeup playing really well off of the similarly tailing sinker.</p><p>There is also a splitter that also looks to be above-average. This pitch is thrown with a lot less spin at just 898 RPMs and a tick harder at 80.9 MPH. The splitter heavily emphasizes vertical movement with an elite figure of -2.3&quot; IVB this year. The pitch only has 10.2&quot; HB but that is still enough to profile. The splitter has the better results of his two changeups but it is also a smaller sample and both have a role to play.</p><p>If I was in charge of Cam Weston’s development, I would split his arsenal down the middle. The sinker and changeup against left handed bats with the occasional slider and use the fastball and splitter with the occasional curve against righties. I think the splitter is more effective off the vertically moving fastball with similar tail, and given the velocity difference, the changeup should have no issues playing off the sinker with comparable horizontal action and an extra 16&quot; of drop with gravity.</p><p>It is unorthodox to use an off-speed primary against both right and left handed hitters but I think it’s the correct approach for Weston and he might be better than the sum of his parts with creative deployment. Weston throws enough strikes and even if he didn’t have a great batted ball profile this year due to some mismanagement, he has the upside for an above-average one. Weston is one of my favorite arms from this year’s draft, even if I don’t think he’s that good. There are so many ways to develop him and with creativity, there is a good pitcher buried inside of him.</p><h3>9.257 SS Adam Crampton, Stanford</h3><p>Adam Crampton from a distance is boring. He’s a light hitting shortstop with a slick glove who is a lock to stick at the most premium of positions and should even be above-average there. Crampton has plus contact rates but they’re not elite and there are at least a dozen players who are similar on the surface in every draft and most of them go unselected.</p><p>So what makes Crampton stand out? He goes to Stanford and Stanford actively tries to ruin players&#39; long-term future’s in pursuit of maybe winning one more game now. At Stanford, they prioritize antiquated concepts like going the other way and putting the ball on the ground with extra emphasis on the first one. To be fair, this is an effective strategy against bad college defenses but they ruin hitters&#39; swings in the long run by teaching them to only go the other way on the ground.</p><p>Crampton is likely a victim of their offensive approach. Adam Crampton doesn’t pull the ball at all. He has a fourth percentile pull rate on groundballs and a tenth percentile pull rate on flyballs. This would be a good approach if Crampton actually had no power but I don’t believe that he does.</p><p>We have no exit velocity data for him given where he goes to school, but back in High School, Adam Crampton hit for some power. A few scouts had him as power over hit back in 2019. A lot of that was due to the projection in his frame but he showed some pop. Then he got to Stanford, put on 20 pounds, and proceeded to swing a noodle. Something doesn’t add up and I suspect that is because he just forgot how to pull the ball. The swing has gone backward and with it so has his upside.</p><p>The same thing happened to Austin Slater at Stanford, albeit to a slightly less extreme degree since he still had the bat path that lead to gap power. It took years for Slater to untangle the mess that Stanford had made of him but Slater has a 148 wRC+ this year. I don’t know if you can untangle Crampton but given the contact and glove, I’m happy to use a 9th round pick in an attempt to find out how to unlock his hidden power upside (He has like average upside, let’s not get too confused).</p><h3>10.287 RP/SP Wyatt Cheney, McLennan (CC)</h3><p>Wyatt Cheney needs more velocity. If he gets that then he will be a steal at a tenth round valuation. The fastballs sits at just 90 MPH while topping out at 93 MPH. The calling card is not velocity though but the fact that Cheney averages 22.8&quot; IVB on the fastball.</p><p>Surely, that can’t be real right? No major leaguer even averages 22&quot; IVB this year. You are mostly right, he’s obviously not going to average 22.8&quot; in the majors but he’s clearly an outlier in vertical movement. Maybe the trackman is broken but Cheney still stands out from the pack. Of all fastballs thrown at McLennan, Cheney owns the top six fastballs by IVB in that ballpark and 41 of the top 100. He is in a league of his own, even if it’s not quite that outlandish of movement.</p><p>I think the fastball shape even has room to grow with more efficiency as Cheney is at nearly 2500 RPMs despite the low velocity and hasn’t perfected the efficiency of his 12:15 fastball yet, as crazy as that might sound. The release height is high but the McLennan Trackman has a lot of high release heights so I’m not reading too much into the 6.2&#39;. The movement is what matters here and with more velocity, this pitch could become spectacular.</p><p>The slider is probably his best secondary pitch. The slider sits at 78.6 MPH with spin rates just over 2600 RPMs on average. He has plus sweeping action with 13.3&quot; of it on average and above-average depth as well at -0.4&quot; IVB. If Cheney can add more velocity then this is very quickly an impactful pitch.</p><p>Cheney also offers a very fringy changeup with 14&quot; of vertical movement (which relative to the heater isn’t as bad as it sounds) and 13.3&quot; HB that is thrown 8 MPH slower than the fastball and 300 RPMs lower.</p><p>The concern with Wyatt Cheney- aside from velocity is that he drops the arm slot on his secondary pitches. The secondaries come from a release both 4&quot; wider and lower than the fastball. This can make him slightly predictable. On the other hand, Cheney is walking nobody and has elite pitch movement. If he gets to league-average velocity on both the fastball and slider then he is an impact arm at the major league level.</p><h3>11.317 SP/RP Zack Showalter, Wesley Chapel (HS)</h3><p>Zack Showalter is a fun prep arm at the start of day three. I was too low on him before the draft, the skillset warrants a 40 FV and a spot in my top 300 prospects probably.</p><p>The calling card here is what could potentially be a plus fastball. The fastball only gets up to 94 MPH from the right handed side but the delivery is athletic and he moves well so I expect improvements there. The real appeal here though is plus vertical movement from a lower slot though. He averaged 21.2&quot; IVB in his one outing with Hawkeye over the summer. That is more ~19&quot; IVB when you adjust for seam height but there is heavy vertical action on the heater that lets him miss bats.</p><p>The curveball needs more velocity as Showalter only sits 75–78 MPH but it also projects as above-average. The pitch gets up to as high as 3200 RPMs and has good movement as well. He averaged -15.4&quot; IVB with Hawkeye but I would estimate that is a tad lower in most outings. He also has 8&quot; of sweep. He occasionally will shift to a sweeping curve with 15&quot; of sweep and only average depth. The feel to adapt the shape makes it easy to believe in the high spin breaking ball translating to the next level.</p><p>The changeup is more fringy with pretty generic traits across the board but I think given the arm speed, you can have some hope for his changeup development. I’m also not sure if the changeup is enough to tamper my excitement. The fastball has elite ride and the curveball has elite depth. He has feel for spin and I like the delivery. Showalter throws enough strikes and has two quality pitches. That is enough for a day three prep arm to be very intriguing.</p><h3>12.347 SP/RP Bradley Brehmer, Indiana</h3><p>Bradley Brehmer has four pitches that project in the realm of average but struggles with control and limiting quality contact because of his command problems. I think with some tweaks though, including increased velocity, you can get Brehmer to be a solid back of the rotation starter.</p><p>The sinker only sits at 91.1 MPH and tops out at just 95.1 MPH. The pitch has solid shape though with just 8.5&quot; IVB and 17.9&quot; of tail from a fairly medial 1.3&#39; horizontal release point during road games. It’s fine shape and fine velocity with a fine angle that should be a fine pitch. Except Brehmer is too aggressive in filling the zone with his sinker despite the strong chase elements and will often catch too much of the plate. He doesn’t have the velocity or drop to aggressively fill the zone as he has been thus far.</p><p>The slider is the most frequently deployed secondary pitch but is also perhaps the worst one. He sits at 83.5 MPH with one plane movement. The depth is limited but it’s still 11.3&quot; of sweep and decent arm velocity so it should be a solid pitch.</p><p>The changeup is maybe his most interesting secondary pitch and naturally the one that Brehmer throws the least often. He has just 6&quot; IVB on average with 20.7&quot; of horizontal movement towards his arm side. I don’t actually think the pitch is all that good right now despite the absurd movement profile. Brehmer throws the changeup only 4.9 MPH slower than the sinker. He has only eight inches more drop with gravity on the changeup. It bleeds into the sinker far too much to be effective. He needs to add velocity separation, or at the very least, vertical separation.</p><p>The problem with Brehmer’s slider and changeup is also that he drops the arm slot on both of them. His horizontal release is about 5&quot; more narrow on the fastball and his release height is 4&quot; higher. The curveball does not have the same problem. He has -13.8&quot; IVB from the same slat as the fastball at 78.9 MPH. I don’t really think it pairs all that well with his sinker but it’s still an average pitch that could be better with improved arm strength.</p><p>I personally find it a tad bit difficult to buy in on a player with zero pitches that project as above-average. Especially when they also have below-average control. At the same time. Brehmer has good shape on all of his stuff and just needs to work on melding it together. Oh, and throwing harder. I think given the feel for both supination and pronation, you have options in how to optimize his repertoire. I don’t particularly like Brehmer but he is clay for good player development to potentially make him into a valuable starter.</p><h3>13.377 P Jared Beck, Saint Leo</h3><p><em>I haven’t been able to find that detailed of information on Jared Beck, or much video at all. As such, this report is mostly just me regurgitating what I have read from other places.</em></p><p>Jared Beck is 7&#39; tall with a high 3/4 arm slot that likely gives him an outlier release point. The fastball sits 89–92 MPH and tops out at 95 MPH from the left handed side. On film, it looks like the pitch has ride but that is baseless speculation. The slurve in the mid-seventies with movement on both planes. Jared Beck has a bit of a walk problem but he does control his long limbs well and is a good athlete, so I’m not too worried. I don’t have enough information available to project his role at all.</p><h3>14.407 C Adam Retzbach, Lehigh</h3><p>Adam Retzbach was the starting catcher at Lehigh for three years but only actually started making an impact this year when he hit .294/.397/.560 for a 129 wRC+. The whiffs were down and he hit for more power. Your guesses as to why are as good as mine.</p><p>Retzbach has elite feel to elevate and that is not really debatable. He has a 96th percentile outfield flyball rate and that lets his probably below average raw power play up in games. I say probably because that is what the bat speed and swing look like on film, but I don’t have the data to verify that. Retzbach has 10 BBE with Trackman this year and maxed out 104.3 MPH. That’s not an accurate representation of his raw power obviously. There might be more raw power than I think but I’m naturally going to be cautious this late in the draft.</p><p>There is an abundance of mishits, however, with Retzbach running line drive rates that are below-average and his popup rate is in the 2nd percentile. He has sub-optimal sprays as well. The ability to control the zone is real but it’s also probably only average K/BB skills at the next level. When combined with the fact that he is a low BABIP guy, it seems unrealistic to expect Retzbach to be an on-base machine or anything of the sort.</p><p>I think Adam Retzbach can probably stick behind the plate but that’s far from a statement I am truly confident in. Retzbach offers both above-average arm strength and good blocking based on numbers. In VERY limited looks, I thought Retzbach looked good back there with some mobility and he smothered a few pitches but it’s mostly just small sample confirmation bias.</p><p>Adam Retzbach has enough athleticism though that he has gotten time at first base and in the outfield and could play there if the bat is good enough to not catch. There are some intriguing elements here, but I’m not that enamored with the very limited data I have on Adam.</p><h3>15.437 SP/RP James Hicks Jr., South Carolina</h3><p>James Hicks Jr. transferred to South Carolina this year after spending the previous two years at Crowder College. Hicks was far from an Ace there but he showed excellent control and pitched to contact. That strategy did not fly with a community college defense but might play better at a high level. We only saw Hicks Jr. for seven innings this year before he blew out his elbow and underwent Tommy John Surgery. However, the data is awesome and I think Hicks might have gone a lot higher than this if he was given a chance to strut his stuff this year.</p><p>The sinker is a nasty pitch. Hicks might only sit 90–92 MPH and top out at 94 but he has a lot of movement. How much? You ask. Try 19.7” of arm side movement. He also has a solid sinking action with 7.3” IVB on average. The sinker is coming from a low release at 5.2’ and has a wider horizontal release at 2.3’. As long as he has some semblance of glove side command, the sinker will play.</p><p>The changeup is in a vacuum a good pitch at 84–86 MPH with 7.1&quot; IVB and 19&quot; HB. The changeup is on the same exact 2:30 spin axis as the sinker and is the same exact pitch but infinitely worse because he throws it 6 MPH slower. You can project some on the changeup development given the feel for pronation but the current iteration of the pitch provides zero value whatsoever.</p><p>The breaking balls are much more exciting pitches. The slider is the lesser of the two and still projects as at least average. Hicks sits at 81.2 MPH with spin rates over 2500 RPMs on average. The shape is solid too with above-average depth at 0.5&quot; IVB and he has some good bite as well with 7&quot; of sweeper from a lowish arm slot. You obviously want more power and he needs to refine some of the shape but the slider has potential.</p><p>James Hicks’ best pitch is probably the curveball. He sits at 79.4 MPH which is maybe on the light end but it is fine for a curveball- especially relative to the fastball. His curve is one of the sweeping variety with him averaging 16.6&quot; of horizontal movement to his glove side in his two outings this year and there is average vertical depth as well with -8.5&quot; IVB.</p><p>All of James Hicks Jr.’s pitches need more velocity but they also all have promising shape. What could maybe separate Hicks from the rest of the similarly shaped arsenals that just need more velocity is that Hicks Jr. might have plus control. James Hicks had a BB/9 under one last year with Crowder. I like the delivery and he consistently repeats it. Tommy John adds some risk to the profile but otherwise, I think Hicks Jr. has a solid chance of winding up as a boring but dependable back-of-the-rotation starter- albeit one with some platoon issues. You could also instead opt to lean on the sinker/breaking ball combination in relief and hope to see a velocity jump with the role change.</p><h3>16.467 RP Graham Firoved, Virginia Tech.</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/exploring-the-most-unheralded-demographic-college-relievers-3c8239930dc6"><em>I already wrote a very detailed scouting report of Graham Firoved in my Relievers Blog so if you want more on him as a pitcher, go read that one. </em></a><em>This report is going to go into less detail and work as more of a general overview.</em></p><p>Graham Firoved is a pure reliever and nobody should harbor any delusions about trying him as a starting pitcher. He also throws the fastballs 92% of the time out of the bullpen. He doesn’t pretend to care about the location but instead just grooves the fastball down the middle without care. The funny thing is that strategy works to the tune of a 26.8% in-zone whiff rate.</p><p>The reason for the fastball’s dominance is that he gets what is somewhere between 20–24&quot; IVB on the fastball. With Hawkeye it’s at 20.2&quot; IVB but his stuff was down in that outing because the velocity was down as well. Firoved is at 21.9&quot; IVB in all Trackman games but if we filter to just road games, it’s 23.9&quot; IVB- the gap in his home and road trackman readings are nearly identical to his teammates which would suggest his home trackman is the problem. Regardless, it doesn’t really matter that much since the movement is still an 80 regardless.</p><p>The release traits are generic and Firoved sits at just 92 MPH while topping out at 95 MPH. The appeal here is elite feel for spin and movement. You can project some velocity development and with above-average velocity, this is an 80 grade pitch. The Orioles are wisely gambling on Firoved adding velocity.</p><p>The slider is solid even if he never uses it. The pitch sits at 81.5 MPH with -1.1&quot; IVB and 11&quot; of sweep this year. The arm slot neither hurts or hinders the pitch. Like with the fastball you want more velocity, but you can still use it more than Firoved has used it without that velocity bump.</p><p>Firoved is a reliever with control and batted ball problems. He’s hit hard and doesn’t throw hard. That being said, Firoved has outlier vertical movement and that movement makes Firoved an extremely intriguing day three selection. You can teach velocity but you can’t teach the feel for rise that Firoved has.</p><h3>17.497 SS Carter Young, Vanderbilt (LSU?)</h3><p>Carter Young probably will not sign this year. He was expected to be a first round pick six months ago, and briefly had helium as a 1–1 candidate 15 months ago. He struggled at the plate this year and fell to the 17th round- in large part due to bonus demands. Carter Young transferred to LSU after an underwhelming season and given how loaded LSU is, he has a good chance at winning a ring by returning to school.</p><p>If Carter Young does sign, the Orioles will be getting a dynamic player who has teased all five tools in some measure before. He even teased all five tools this year! Just not at the same time and I’m not sure he ever will show them all simultaneously. Carter Young is a plus runner who plays an above-average shortstop. That part is difficult to dispute but the bat is why he garners such mixed responses.</p><p>Carter Young’s inconsistency troubles stem from him being a switch hitter. Young is like Ronny Mauricio in that from one side of the plate he makes a lot of contact and from the other side he hits the ball hard. As a right handed batter he has above-average contact rates and chases more. He also has a Max EV of just 104.7 MPH. His BAcon is in the 1st percentile as a righty as well.</p><p>As a lefty on the other hand he has a Max EV of just over 110 MPH but his strikeout rate is in the 2nd percentile. At the same time, he is walking a lot more and hitting the ball at more optimal angles as a lefty. I would lean towards having Young hit lefty full time because of the contact quality but there is a wrinkle in that plan.</p><p>Carter Young dislocated his left shoulder in 2021 and that is when his power output fell off the side of the road. Carter Young came up as a right handed hitter before learning to switch hit. We know that top hand speed is one of the most important things in creating power and with his top shoulder hurt, it’s likely the bat speed fell off. I think it is very possible that given time to heal, Young hits for more power from the right handed side- probably not as much as he does as a lefty but it’s probably a 50+ raw. If the power rebounds, he clearly belongs on the right handed side given the much stronger contact rates.</p><p>I’m not sure how feasible it is to expect Carter Young to regain his power stroke from the right handed side. I think in this range of the draft the upside is absolutely worth minimal risk but I also don’t think it makes sense for Young to sign. If the power does return, Young could re-enter the first round discussion due to his contact prowess as a righty. This is a very high risk profile at the plate but the upside has flashed before- we just have to figure out if that upside still exists.</p><h3>18.527 RP Andrew Walters, Miami</h3><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/exploring-the-most-unheralded-demographic-college-relievers-3c8239930dc6"><em>I already wrote a very detailed scouting report of Andrew Walters in my Relievers Blog so if you want more on him as a pitcher, go read that one. </em></a><em>This report is going to go into less detail and work as more of a general overview.</em></p><p>Andrew Walters has a fastball that sits at 96 MPH and can touch as high as 99 MPH with spin rates that sit just over 2550 RPMs. He has a somewhat low vertical release point but the real draw is his 3.03&#39; horizontal release point. Walters has plus ride on the four-seamer and tough angles that when paired with the velocity make the glove side fastball a very spammable pitch.</p><p>The breaking ball has a decent shape with him sitting at 80.3 MPH on the curve with -8&quot; IVB and 7&quot; of sweeping action towards his glove side. The pitch should play way up given the arm slot, even if it would be better off if transformed into a more conventional sweeping slider.</p><p>The problem is a lack of feel and command over the curveball that leads to Walters throwing the fastball 91% of the time. The pitch dominates in college and should only get better in the majors with improved spin efficiency (Some question of if it can be improved given the arm slot) but it’s not as spammable at the next level as it has been.</p><p>Andrew Walters isn’t that dissimilar from Graham Firoved who went two rounds earlier to the same team. Both of them have an elite fastball with a promising breaking ball that has no feel. Firoved prioritizes vertical movement and Walters’ velocity but the story is the same. Walters has a slight edge over Firoved from me because he throws strikes more but it’s not precise command, more an understanding that no one can hit his fastball in the zone. He’s a quality middle reliever who would be more with an improved breaking ball. There are lots of reasons to believe the breaking ball can improve so I’m probably too high on Andrew Walters.</p><h3>19.557 RF Alden Mathes, Richmond</h3><p><em>Alden Mathes is someone with somewhat limited data but there is at least enough film to craft a low confidence grade on him.</em></p><p>Alden Mathes makes a lot of contact despite a turbo-aggressive approach. The in-zone contact rates are likely great but there is some concern over his willingness to expand the zone in pursuit of breaking balls. The bat path is also a bit long which causes some concern surrounding his ability to hit velocity at the next level and further compounds the hit risk caused by the approach.</p><p>Alden Mathes shows plus barrel accuracy within the strike zone and is seemingly making flush contact consistently. The problem is that Mathes makes contact probably too often when he expands the zone. When Mathes hits the ball off the plate or inside, it is usually mishit that makes it somewhat difficult to believe in the bat translating as is. I believe Mathes has average raw power but I have no way of verifying that fact.</p><p>Alden Mathes has some experience on the mound. I can’t find how hard he throws there but it seems likely that he has at least above-average arm strength given that he threw 82.2 career collegiate innings on the mound. Mathes is a 55 runner who fits best in right field in all likelihood. I don’t think Mathes is anything special but he does damage on contact and is going to one of the organizations that is the best at teaching patience so it’s possible, he sees gains in the Orioles system and becomes a viable hitting prospect.</p><h3>20.587 RP/SP Reese Sharp, Indiana</h3><p>Reese Sharp is one of my favorite relievers in the entire draft. He wasn’t put on my radar until the day before the draft but his data is amazing and he dominated during the cape cod league this year which is what put him on some teams&#39; radars.</p><p>Reese Sharp has a plus fastball. He sits at 92.5 MPH and can run it up to 96 MPH. He has a rare feel to elevate the heater and that makes the 20.2&quot; IVB all the more attractive. Sharp might not have perfect release traits with a 6.1&#39; release height and a 2.2&#39; horizontal release but the combination of movement and decent velocity plays at the top of the zone.</p><p>The secondaries have an argument for outshining the fastball. The curveball is probably the best of the bunch with Sharp sitting at 78 MPH on it. He throws from the same slot as the fastball and has good feel for spin with Sharp averaging over 2570 RPMs. The real appeal here though is -14.5&quot; IVB. The pitch doesn’t land in the zone very often and you probably want more velocity behind it. When Sharp is in the zone, it’s usually hung at the top. The feel is very much not there but the shape is incredible.</p><p>The slider has one major problem and that is a common one among Orioles draftees, Sharp can’t help but drop the arm slot on his sweeping slider. This gives his slider a ridiculous horizontal approach angle with Sharp averaging 13&quot; of sweep from a 2.6&#39; horizontal release but he doesn’t sell it all that well so it’s not the chase pitch it can be. Sharp also has pretty limited depth on the slider and only sits at 81 MPH. There is obvious potential here, but it needs work.</p><p>There is also a changeup that Reese Sharp threw a grand total of five times. The changeup came from the same arm slot as the slider so there are deception issues linked to that. There is also what might be 70 grade pitch movement and 9.6 MPH of velocity separation. Reese Sharp averaged just 5.5&quot; IVB and 19.4&quot; HB on those five changeups. The feel is non-existent but the shape is exceptional and there is upside there. I still have it as a 40 grade pitch to be clear.</p><p>I get why Reese Sharp fell as far as he did. Sharp is a college reliever with a 6.5 ERA this year and only moderately better peripherals. He has major command issues and doesn’t really have feel for any pitch but the fastball. At the same time, he has fantastic shape with four pitches, and I think the velocity should uptick in pro ball. He might get a chance to start with four quality pitches but I do think his long term role is in the bullpen. Reese Sharp is a gamble on pure stuff but this is the 20th round so I have no problem making that gamble.</p><p><em>That was way longer than I planned lol. Hopefully, you enjoyed it. The next blog theoretically comes out on Wednesday where I will break down the Blue Jays draft class.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e5ba71c0454c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Potential Day Two Draft Steals]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/potential-day-two-draft-steals-b527f1fa7a48?source=rss-f20e8b3389a4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b527f1fa7a48</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[values]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[draft]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hidden-gems]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tieran Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 18 Jul 2022 15:54:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-18T15:54:06.466Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Uc1S4SiAk0Pl_lnygIei9A.png" /></figure><p>Wow, day one of the draft was wild. The Orioles shocked the world at #1 when they took Jackson Holliday, only for the Rangers to then make you forget that pick ever happened when they took Kumar Rocker. (They will likely buy down Brock Porter to make that picks decent). And then there is the Rays…</p><p>After one day of the draft, 64 of my 103 first three-round grades are off the board. All but three of the first-round grades have been selected. There is likely going to be a lot less impact major leaguers selected today then there were yesterday. That does not mean that there won’t be any of them though. Here is a piece on 12 players I think could be great value picks today. This is not the best players available right now but ones who could make teams regrest passing on them for what might in hindsight be stupid reasons.</p><p><em>This will not include players I’ve already broken down at length in one of the other blogs this week. If you have any questions, you can shoot me a DM at any time.</em></p><h4>SP Tyler Gough, JSerra Catholic High School</h4><p>Tyler Gough is probably the most underrated prep arm in the entire draft. I understand the reasons for the lack of hype but I disagree that they provide close to enough reason to push Gough out of the first three rounds. Tyler Gough was hurt for most of his senior season and when he came back he pitched almost exclusively in relief. He’s very clearly got a starter’s repertoire and decent enough command but he pitched in relief due to health concerns and no one scouts prep relievers. He dominated in the combine and had the most electrifying pitch data perhaps in the entire prep class last summer.</p><p>The fastball is truly incredible. He sits just 90–93 MPH most nights and tops out at just 96 MPH. There is some strength projection left and I should note that he was more 92–94 at the combine during games though. I also don’t really care about his velocity in all honesty. That velocity plays up because Gough got 7.2&#39; of extension last summer and he has exceptional release traits.</p><p>Tyler Gough’s average release point was 5.21&#39; vertically and a 0.83&#39; horizontally. There is no pitcher with a lower release height and lower (absolute value) release side than Gough in the major leagues this year. Things go even deeper than that though. The narrowest release side by a player with as low of a release height is 1.2 ft by Jake Brentz and Marcus Stroman. The lowest release height by a player with as low of a release side this year is Sonny Gray at 5.5 ft. This is a complete outlier in terms of release point and that alone provides value.</p><p>The fastball spin is ridiculous with a spin factor of nearly 27 and the movement is equally as ridiculous somehow. He averaged 20.9&quot; IVB and 11.5&quot; of arm side movement during the summer circuit. You have to adjust for seam height but it’s still elite vertical action to go with a super low release that gives him what would likely be the flattest zone-neutral VAA in all of baseball.</p><p>Surely this sounds too good to be true right? It’s true that Tyler Gough only made one appearance with Hawkeye (7/17/21 at Tropicana) but I actually checked to see if these numbers were legitimate or if Hawkeye was broken that day. I crosschecked the numbers of three other pitchers to pitch in that game but also appeared in other games with Hawkeye. Those three displayed almost no variance in their average release point and almost no variance in their fastball movement. The only variance is extension appeared to be up by 0.35&#39; in this one game. Even at only 6.8&#39; of extension, Gough stll has a truly special fastball.</p><p>This is only one of Tyler Gough’s pitches and he has three more somewhat quality ones. The curveball is the worst of the bunch according to both myself and Gough. He carved up the opposition with it at the combine. The pitch sits 77–78 MPH and flashes up to -15&quot; IVB. It’s a below-average pitch because the depth is inconsistent but when it’s on it dominates.</p><p>The cutter is nasty. He sits at 85 MPH with 15.1&quot; IVB from a low slot and 3&quot; of cut on average. He probably needs to add more power to it for the pitch to play, but it is projected as an average pitch and pairs wonderfully off the fastball.</p><p>The changeup is the best of the bunch. He sits 77–80 MPH which is solid separation from his fastball and flashes up to 23&quot; of back-breaking fade to the arm side. That fade comes from a very medial release and should elicit a zillion chases. He has below-average depth but 11.7&quot; IVB is not that bad and the fade is too good to overlook for a second. Feel is still developing but the stuff is top-notch.</p><p>Tyler Gough has genuine top of the rotation stuff potential. He might cost a bit to sign away from Oregon State and I get why teams might hesitate to pull the trigger but this is what they look like. There is injury risk with violence in the motion and heavy pronation that puts some stress on the arm but I’m gambling on his upside every single day without hesitation. You can not teach this kind of fastball and the secondaries show promise too.</p><h4>RF Anthony Hall, Oregon</h4><p>Anthony Hall has all the fundamental skills to be a good hitter at the big league level and there should be very little question about how the skills will translate up the ladder. There are still some questions left to answer for the bat but those are more soft skills that are theoretically teachable than inherent flaws.</p><p>The contact skills are a plus and I think the projection is even higher due to how they break down on a fundamental level. A 20.4% whiff rate is above-average and a 7.9% Z-Whiff% is exemplary putting Hall on par with a guy like Jacob Berry (7.6%) and Gavin Cross (8.1%). Again, the best part of the contact skills is where he is making contact.</p><p>Anthony Hall has not whiffed once against a fastball above 93 MPH on 33 of them seen. To be clear, a large part of that is chance. He has three whiffs on thirty fastballs between 92–93 MPH which indicates some good fortune. Even still, the contact skills are clearly present against velocity and given the shorter hand path and plus bat speed it makes sense that he hasn’t struggled against velocity at all.</p><p>Fastballs are the most commonly used pitch in the majors but Hall also bullies the second most commonly used pitch type in the slider. He’s aggressive in swinging at the slider with a 48.8% swing rate against it but only 22.7% of those swings are chases. He’s simply swinging at 79% of in-zone sliders and has zero whiffs on in-zone sliders this year. Bullying the two most common pitches in the major leagues is a pretty strong sign for his contact skills moving up the ladder.</p><p>Anthony Hall also hits curveballs at a high level albeit slightly less so- probably. Like with the slider, Anthony Hall did not whiff once on an in-zone curveball this year in a game with trackman. Unlike the slider, Hall was much less aggressive with the in-zone curveball swinging at only 57.1% of them. He still only chased 20% of curves out of the zone and ran above-average swinging-strikes rates against the curve but his lack of aggressiveness against the pitch led to a 20.3% Called-Strike rate against the pitch which often put him behind in the count or led to an unnecessary strikeout looking. He does fine when swinging at the hanging breaking ball but just too often watches them land in the zone for strikes.</p><p>The changeup is Anthony Hall’s kryptonite contact wise. He has a 20.21% swinging-strike rate against them which is obviously not good. That includes a 20% in-zone whiff rate and a whopping 38.3% chase rate. I don’t really see a mechanical reason to believe he can’t learn to hit a changeup but you rarely do see that in players with the changeup. The issue isn’t the velocity at least because we know he can hit the other softer stuff at a high level so there’s some optimism at least. Lots of young players struggle with changeups at first. Fernando Tatis Jr. still had a 25.6% SwStr% against changeups in 2021 which was the third highest in the entire MLB. He still was a top ten hitter in the game. It’s a flaw but it doesn’t have to be a completely crippling one for Hall.</p><p>Anthony Hall has above-average raw power and you could probably argue it as a plus even if I won’t. He has a Max EV of 110.9 MPH which came on a line drive double to his pullside back in February. That Max EV ranks in the 75th percentile of big leaguers already. Hall also has explosive bat speed both visually and metrically during some sessions with driveline last winter. I have it as “just” above-average raw but if you wanted to put it higher I don’t have any problem with that.</p><p>The game power is more complicated but I do think that Hall will get to most of his power in games. The groundball rate is not good at 51.3% but I’m not really convinced that will persist- or that it matters that much. Anthony Hall has a swing path that naturally creates loft and I don’t see a major issue with the attack angles even if I can’t see exactly what they are. I think his groundball issues are primarily due to his swing decisions.</p><p>Anthony Hall has the highest swing% against changeups at 51.1% followed by sinkers at 47.8%. Those are the two pitches that induce the most groundballs in the majors at 53.5% and 55.1% respectively. If we give the league average major league hitter Hall’s swing decisions then they would be expected to run a 45.1 GB%. The average major leaguer is at 43.7%. The average college player is at 47.5%. He’s underperforming the average college players on groundball rate by just 3.6%. That’s still slightly more than the average major leaguer with his swing decisions but not some glaring red flag that he can’t overcome.</p><p>Again, I’m not sure how much this actually matters if he’s not elite at elevating though. Anthony Hall has elite game power optimization outside of the basic balls in the air part of the skill. The majority of Anthony Hall’s hard contact comes in the air with a 57.5% Hard-Hit rate on non-groundballs. Among all major leaguers with 30+ BBE in the air this year that would rank in the 89th percentile this year. Obviously quality of competition and whatever matters but it’s a special skill for isolating his quality contact to balls hit in the air.</p><p>Anthony Hall is also elite at pulling his aerial contact and pulled flyballs wind up over the fence seven times as often as ones hit to the other field. He actually pulled more flyballs in games with Trackman (46.2%) than he did groundballs (43.2%). I don’t really understand how that’s possible but it does explain the strong home run totals despite lower amounts of aerial contact. If we assume he had the same GB% in non-trackman games then Hall had his aerial contact wind up as a homerun 14.6% of the time. Amongst major leaguers with at least 100 BBE in the last two seasons that would rank in the 92nd percentile. That probably won’t translate perfectly but there’s more ways to game power than just putting the ball in the air and Hall has all the ingredients in place to still achieve above-average or even better game power.</p><p>The concerns with Anthony Hall primarily have to do with his tendency to mishit balls. He hits balls softly far more than the average major leaguer although it’s about average for a college bat at 27.5%. He also has a below-average sweet-spot% and below-average launch angle tightness. The mishits are primarily on groundball contact so they don’t hurt the power output but they might affect the BABIPs. 76% of his groundballs have a Launch Angle beneath 0°. At the major league level balls at that angle have a .173 Batting Average. He’s not mishitting popups but he’s still frequently getting too far on top of pitches and that will deflate his BABIPs quite a bit. BABIP skills are more teachable than making contact or hitting the ball hard but it is something to keep an eye on with Hall.</p><p>The other major concern with Hall’s offensive game is how aggressive he gets when behind in the count. Anthony Hall chases 39.7% of the time with two strikes and still runs the same contact rates in and out of the zone in those situations. His aggressive approach in those situations might inflate the whiff rates relative to the contact skills some and even more so hurt the walk rates. He’s also running a mere 20% Hard-Hit rate (101.3 max) in two-strike counts. This concern could possibly be magnified moving forward as when facing better pitching he’ll more often be in a hole and on the back foot as a result.</p><p>Anthony Hall can absolutely hit but what keeps him in the 2nd-3rd round range for me is his probable lack of defensive value. Hall is a bigger guy with somewhat limited mobility due to only average foot speed. I like him in a corner outfield spot as a slightly below-average option but I know some scouts prefer him at first base as they think he’ll become actually slow as he grows into his frame. The lack of defensive value keeps him out of the first round conversation but the bat will absolutely play.</p><h4>3B/RP Zach Agnos, East Carolina</h4><p>Baseball is in the midst of an epidemic right now. Breaking balls have become too good for most hitters to handle them. The league average breaking ball keeps on getting better and keeps on being thrown more and more.</p><p>This problem is especially prominent in the minors after the pandemic wiped out a year of development. Corbin Carroll whiffs a lot against them, and so does Francisco Álvarez among a number of others. Jarred Kelenic hasn’t produced in the majors- primarily because of that flaw. Even in the draft against not-great pitching, day one picks like Dylan Beavers, Brock Jones, and Daniel Susac had pretty major problems with chasing breaking balls. Enter Zach Agnos.</p><p>Zach Agnos is the best breaking ball hitter in the entire draft by a fairly sizeable margin and it’s why I have him ranked as a top 100 player in the class. Breaking balls have just never phased him in the slightest. He doesn’t flail up there at all- he’s calm, cool, and collected no matter how good of a slider the pitcher throws.</p><p>Zach Agnos’s plate discipline against breaking balls is in a whole other stratosphere. Zach Agnos only chased 16.38% of breaking balls this year. That is an elite rate, to say the least. Compiling a full leaderboard of college players and how often they chase breaking balls is incredibly difficult, so we’ll forgo that and use an MLB one instead. Of all MLB Players who have seen at least 100 out of zone breaking balls this year, here are all the ones with a lower chase rate than Agnos:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1006/1*yqeew21QnN5FiO83QMI9jA.png" /></figure><p>Even against bad college breaking balls, this is an absurdly impressive company to be in. Except, there are other players who never chase in college, Agnos is different than those fools though. He swings at 76.83% of in-zone breaking balls. That is just… wow. Here’s the MLB leaderboard for most in-zone swings at breaking balls.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/847/1*CQqUiXz3-jYVMLaKbVW7oA.png" /></figure><p>29th might not look like but that puts Agnos in the 88th percentile of zone-swing rate against breaking balls and simultaneously in the 97th percentile of chase rate. Of those 28 players with a lower Z-Swing, only four of them even have an above-average (percentile) chase rate with Benintendi leading the way at 23.6%. The only other three who are even average are Jeff McNeil, Kyle Tucker, and Josh Bell. Agnos isn’t just above-average but in the 97th percentile! If you look at the seven players who have a lower chase rate, the best of the bunch (Will Smith) has just a 28th percentile Z-Swing against breaking balls. Agnos is an anomaly.</p><p>I don’t point this out to say that Zach Agnos is going to continue to run historically good Z-O Swing% in the majors against breaking balls. He almost certainly won’t. The quality of breaking balls in college compared to the majors is the difference between dead and alive. My point is that his ability to recognize and track breaking balls so completely and with perfect precision means it’s an easy skill to project on and says a lot about the possibility of his game translating.</p><p>I don’t even think Zach Agnos has the perfect approach against breaking balls. His ability to track them and make the right decision based on the strike probability is the best in the draft and projects as elite but his swing decisions are probably still not perfect by any means. A good approach isn’t just only swinging at high probability strikes but only swinging at pitches you can drive. Agnos might hit and make contact with 86.6% of breaking balls but he’s not going to drive all of them.</p><p>This is the problem with Zach Agnos. His biggest strength might ironically be his biggest flaw as well. Agnos makes perfect swing decisions and can’t whiff against breaking balls and that means 33% of his batted balls are against breaking balls. Agnos hits 56.3% of breaking balls on the ground and 34.4% of them below 80 MPH. He still has good top-end EVs but the average breaking ball batted ball won’t result in a hit. He would be better off taking more of them in the zone and waiting for pitches he can actually drive.</p><p>The other problem with Zach Agnos’s approach is that it doesn’t change at all based on the count. Even in a three ball count, he is swinging 49.2% of the time- that is actually 8.3% more than he swings in all counts. Agnos has an aversion to walking in spite of elite plate discipline and will weakly force some outs by being too aggressive in obvious take situations.</p><p>These are minor quibbles with Agnos’ approach which might be the best in the entire draft to be clear. The only pitch he chases more than 20% of the time is the changeup at 21.4% and the lowest zone-swing against a pitch is 65.4% against the four-seam fastball. He has a 94th percentile chase rate and 69th percentile zone-swing rate against all pitches relative to every college player in the country with trackman. The swing decisions are elite. There are some warts but they don’t seem to be that difficult of fixes.</p><p>The contact quality is surprisingly strong too. Zach Agnos can hit the ball hard. His Max EV is only 109.5 MPH but I think it’s better than the one batted ball event might indicate. Zach Agnos has a 105.6 MPH Top 8th EV (Real Top 8th this time and not 92nd Percentile!) that ranks in the 94th percentile of college hitters and is just 0.1 MPH below the MLB average this year. His Hard-Hit rate is 54.1% which is in the 98th percentile of college hitters. The dude can crush baseballs.</p><p>The BABIP skills are exceptional. Agnos popped up just once all year with Trackman and ran above-average line drive rates. His soft contact rates despite the issues with breaking balls being hit softly were still among the best in the league. He avoids really low launch angle groundballs as well and it leads to a mere 26.8° sdLA. To top it off, Agnos also has elite ability to hit the ball the other way with only a 36.1% pull rate. This is not really an overarching positive given the power). Agnos is hitting the ball hard extremely consistently too so high BABIPs should be a given when paired with elite launch angle control.</p><p>Admittedly, Zach Agnos lags behind in game power but there is still obvious potential there. The barrel rate is only in the 82nd percentile at 8.2% because he struggles with elevation some (25th percentile GB rate). Additionally, Agnos has just 14th percentile spin rates on his batted balls and 20th percentile backspin%. To make matters worse still, Agnos has just a 7.4% pull rate on outfield flyballs.</p><p>When you combine all that with one of the most pitcher friendly home ballparks in baseball, Agnos hitting just seven homers this year shouldn’t be that surprising. You can teach those skills. They kept him from going on day one but they aren’t going to make Agnos a bust.</p><p>Zach Agnos also has a pretty easy fix to a lot of his problems. Start swinging at the fastball more than the breaking ball because right now he’s actually swinging at the latter 0.2% more. We know he has the pitch recognition and pitch tracking skills to effortlessly make this adjustment.</p><p>Zach Agnos is a complete menace against the fastball. He still makes contact over 80% of the time (Yes, he makes more contact against breaking balls, I have no clue how) and never expands the zone. His line-drive rate goes from below-average to plus and his hard-hit rate goes from good to 67.3%. There are no mishits either as Agnos has just a 7.7% soft-hit rate. He also hits just 25% of his batted balls with a negative launch angle against the fastball and still pops out 0% of the time.</p><p>Swing at more fastballs and take more breaking balls. Don’t try to just avoid strikes but swing at only pitches that can actually do damage. With one small tweak, Agnos could fix a number of his issues and it’s such an easy change to make on paper.</p><p>Zach Agnos plays third base at an acceptable level. He has some issues with some of the basic actions and commits a bit too many errors. The range is solid though and he has a great arm. The arm can throw 95 off the mound with ride…</p><p>Off the mound? Oh yeah, Zach Agnos is also a draftable relief prospect. He sits at 92 MPH on the heater with above-average carry sitting at 18.5&quot; IVB and he also has plus tailing shape at 12.5&quot; HB. The changeup is the better pitch with him sitting at 84 MPH with sub 1500 RPMs. The cambio has just 5.5&quot; IVB and 13.5&quot; HB from the same slot as the heater. He throws a healthy amount of strikes and has a fringy breaking ball as well. He has no business ever pitching again but Agnos does have something to offer on the mound and if he goes blind in one eye and can’t hit anymore then he has a fallback plan.</p><p>Zach Agnos has the capacity to be a steal on day two of the draft because of the approach, power, and contact combination that no one in the draft can match. There are skills that still have to be taught and there’s still some risk with him handling higher velocity (Mid results in a very small sample) but that trio of skills is too promising to not be all over him at the start of the third round even with some limit to his defensive value.</p><h4>SP/3B/RP Jack Brannigan, Notre Dame</h4><p>Jack Brannigan would have ranked #264 if I was scouting him exclusively as a position player. I obviously, prefer him on the mound but I think there are teams who will prefer him at the plate so we’ll go in-depth on both players he can be.</p><p>Jack Brannigan’s scouting report probably starts with his defense which is usually an indictment of a prospect’s offensive potential. That is not the case with Brannigan though, he’s just really good at third base. Brannigan is a great athlete with surprising foot speed that has allowed him to even steal home plate multiple times. He moves incredibly well laterally and has plus range at the hot corner- it might even be sufficient to play shortstop.</p><p>Brannigan also has 80-grade arm strength which helps a lot. He throws 99 MPH off the mound and any time you can do that, it’ll translate to the infield. There are some footwork issues to iron out but the throw power is exceptional. As a result of his range and arm strength, Brannigan will fairly regularly make highlight reel plays that leave your jaw on the floor. There is a lot of work to get there so I have him settling slightly below, but the upside here is a gold glove at the hot corner. He also has limited experience at every other infield spot as well as right field.</p><p>The bat has potential but it does need some work. The contact skills are strong. He only whiffs 12.5% of the time in the strike zone. That includes just a 13% whiff rate against 93+. The problem is the approach completely destroys the hit tool. Jack Brannigan chases 33.9% of the time and whiffs 40.2% of the time when he chases. This leads to Brannigan actually having below-average contact rates at just 76.2% and striking out 20.2% of the time.</p><p>The problem doesn’t appear to be pitch recognition perhaps. He has a hyper-aggressive approach that should change but it’s not flailing blindly. He also swings at 74.3% of in-zone pitches. That is almost the same exact distance between Brannigan and league average in both Z-Swing% and Chase%. Could Brannigan just choose to be less aggressive? Perhaps, but it’s not something I’m counting on.</p><p>Brannigan does do incredible damage within the zone though. He has high contact rates and has a 48.3% hard-hit rate with a mere 23.7° sdLA and hits a ton of flyballs with a 41.4% outfield flyball rate. He has exceptional spin traits too when only looking at pitches in the zone.</p><p>The problem is Brannigan is completely useless when he chases. When he chases, Brannigan hits the ball hard just 11.1% of the time and 61.1% of his batted balls are below 80 MPH. 22.2% of his batted balls are pop-ups. He hits the ball on the ground 44.4% of the time. 25% of his batted balls are when he chases. Brannigan would be better off whiffing out of the zone more than he fares by chasing so much.</p><p>Overall, Brannigan has interesting contact quality. He has plus raw power with a Max EV of 111.6 MPH and has two other balls over 110 to verify that it was no fluke. His power is driven primarily by top-end hand/arm speed that lets his bat fly through the zone. There are some disconnected things in his lower half that could be cleaned up and could lead to his power jumping if he’s hitting full time.</p><p>Brannigan has fairly mediocre hard-hit rates though because of the abundance of mishits against out of zone pitches. Those mishits are largely exclusive to out of zone pitches but he still has one of the highest rates of mishit ball s in the country.</p><p>The game power is decent but not what it can be. Brannigan technically has above-average feel to elevate but he frequently gets too far underneath pitches for it play as over-the-fence raw power. He has a below-average barrel rate despite plus raw power and plus feel to elevate. And yet, in spite of those flaws, Brannigan still has .250 ISO. This is because of how much backspin he gets that gives him extra carry. Brannigan is in the 86th percentile of batted ball spin rate and the 92nd percentile of backspin%.</p><p>Jack Brannigan is a weird mismatch of desirable offensive traits that don’t really meld into a good player just yet. He makes lots of contact in the zone but has below-average contact rates because of approach issues. He has plus raw power, with plus spin rates, and plus feel to elevate but it doesn’t work because he hits so many mishits. There is a road to a very good hitter here with great defense at third base but it’s a treacherous path.</p><p>Now onto the much more interesting version of Jack Brannigan- the starting pitcher version. Jack Brannigan has admittedly only thrown 26.1 career innings (including summer league) and has made just one start. He also has a 7.52 ERA in that span. To be fair though, 14.2 of those innings came this year and he struck out 41.2% of batters en route to a 2.14 xFIP in that span. More importantly, he has three quality pitches and hope for future command development.</p><p>The fastball as I already touched on has elite velocity. He sits 96.1 MPH on average in trackman games and tops out at as high as 99.8 MPH. The pitch has elite spin rates as well with Brannigan averaging 2547 RPMs. He throws it from a very unique release as well with an average height of 5.71&#39; and 3.38&#39; horizontally.</p><p>We don’t have a Brannigan start with Hawkeye to verify that ridiculous release but we do have his teammates pitching in a Hawkeye game. (He also only has one Road Game). Alex Rao’s release height is 0.56&#39; lower with Hawkeye. Austin Temple is 0.46&#39; lower. Jack Findlay is 0.33&#39; lower, Bertrand is 0.45&#39; lower, and Liam Simon is 0.65&#39; lower with Hawkeye. I could go on but it’s likely that we’re understating the release height of Brannigan by about half a foot- give or take. We’re also probably overstating how wide the release is by about two inches.</p><p>Jack Brannigan throws two variants of fastballs. The four-seam is the less used one but might be the better of the two. He gets 15.7&quot; of ride from a low release height which should lead to elite VAA’s up in the zone. The four-seam also has good tailing action with Brannigan averaging 14.8&quot; HB. The combination of velocity and angle should allow him to miss bats at the top of the zone at a high rate. Given the spin rates, you might be able to project improvement to the fastball shape as well; although given the arm slot, it’s not a direct path forwards.</p><p>The sinker is maybe slightly worse but it also has a niche and probably offers the higher floor. Brannigan gets just 9.6&quot; IVB and has a ridiculous 18.6&quot; HB on the 2:00 sinker. His sinker likely will only prove viable against same handed batters given the extreme angle he offers from such a wide release side with so much horizontal movement. That is perfectly fine because he has the four-seam that he can beat lefties with.</p><p>What is interesting is that Brannigan throws his fastballs in the zone a combined 60.2% of the time in games with Trackman. He has velocity, unique angle, and the ability to throw the heater for strikes consistently. His command lags behind by a significant margin but this pitch has the foundations of greatness already in place and he’s barely even tried to hone his craft on the mound yet.</p><p>The slider might be better than the fastball. He sits at just 83.4 MPH but given the arm strength, you have to believe he can add velocity to it. He also has an absurd HAA on the slider with Brannigan averaging -13&quot; HB from what is at least 3&#39; horizontal releases point. This gives Brannigan an HAA that might be more extreme than any MLB arm with an optimal location. The slider also has above-average depth at -0.9&quot; IVB on average.</p><p>The slider feel is lacking but the pitch traits are still so dominant that he logged a 30.2% Swinging-Strike rate in a small sample this year. The pitch is far from perfect right now but given the angle, feel for spin, feel for turning said spin into sweep, and natural arm speed; it’s a very easy pitch to project on.</p><p>The changeup has been used very sparingly so don’t read too much into the specs. Based on the 11 pitch sample of changeups with Trackman, Brannigan might have a 70 on stuff. He throws his changeup at 85.4 MPH with spin rates 800 RPMs lower than the heater. The movement is the calling card though. Brannigan sits at just 2.4&quot; IVB and 16.7&quot; HB is plus tail as well.</p><p>Jack Brannigan’s changeup is somewhat limited it it’s utility by the arm slot in theory. He only should be using it against OHB and probably be living in the zone with it the majority of the time. The pitch works a lot better off the four-seamer in all likelihood and can bleed into the sinker at times. I like the pitch but the feel is also complete garbage and he has no command with it so it’s hard to call it any more than average. Huge upside pitch though given the shape and separation.</p><p>Jack Brannigan has a walk problem but I’m not convinced it will persist. Jack Brannigan is a plus athlete and he can control his delivery for the most part. He looks a bit unconventional but he’s already landing the fastball in the zone with consistency. There are bouts of wildness but I’m fairly optimistic he’ll get to average command some day.</p><p>His arsenal is tailored to weak contact as much as it is missing bats. The sinker down will get a plethora of groundballs and his extreme horizontal movement/angle on every pitch should lead to very few line drives. He also is capable of jamming hitters with the four-seam fastball at the top of the zone and getting popups that way. Having 30 present day command and very little feel has led to him getting hit hard on contact to date, but the stuff suggests better stuff is to come.</p><p>Jack Brannigan is a high risk prospect on the mound. He has a case for having the best pure stuff in the college crop but we don’t know how it would work over a normal workload. We’ve never seen him fully committed to pitching. If Brannigan is destined for the bullpen, I’d probably rather have the third base version. If Brannigan has a chance to stick in the rotation then I don’t want him distracted by hitting regularly but to focus on one thing.</p><p>Abandoning the two-way experiment is risky, and it might be tempting to wait him out and try to see which area is best in a year or two. I don’t think you can take that approach with Brannigan because he needs so much work on the mound. I think a drafting team has to choose if the upside as a starter is worth the relief risk or if it’s better to take the more steady outcome of a third base prospect. To me, the upside is absolutely worth it and he’s a starting pitcher until he proves he’s not one but I totally understand why a team might disagree with that assessment.</p><h4>SP Dylan DeLucia, Ole Miss</h4><p>Dylan DeLucia is still on the board because he doesn’t throw hard at all and doesn’t miss bats. He probably should still be on the board for those exact reasons. That doesn’t change the fact that he still has impact potential in the rotation and a lot of similarities to Joe Ryan.</p><p>The fastball has a chance to be special. He sits at just 91.3 MPH and tops out at 94.3 MPH which is an unusual start for a special fastball. As you would probably expect Dylan DeLucia has elite- err… below-average ride at just 15.1&quot; IVB on average. So what is the appeal exactly?</p><p>Dylan DeLucia has elite barrel evading horizontal movement on his heater. The pitch gets 17.1&quot; of arm side tailing action on average. That is more than all but two four-seam fastballs in the majors this year. The horizontal release is fairly generic at 1.57&#39; too so there is no reason not to pitch to the arm side and play for chases. DeLucia currently aggressively fills the zone with his fastball instead. I think the horizontal movement should be more of an asset than it has been so far. That is not why the fastball is so appealing but it certainly doesn’t hurt.</p><p>The primary appeal though is that Dylan DeLucia throws his fastball from a release height lower than any MLB starter over the last two years at 5.02 ft. That low release combined with even just 15.1&quot; IVB” gives DeLucia the capacity for one of the flattest VAA’s in baseball. Joe Ryan throws his fastball from 5.04&#39; and with just 15&quot; IVB at just 91.7 MPH. That fastball has the third highest run value in baseball this year.</p><p>The primary problem is Dylan DeLucia doesn’t use the fastball as Joe Ryan does now. He throws his fastball down in the zone for called strikes rather than elevating and missing bats with only 39.7% of his fastballs being thrown in the top half of the zone. To his credit, the fastball does have a 19.7% called strike rate. If DeLucia had a secondary pitch he can could regularly deploy in two-strike counts for the whiffs then this strategy might even be optimal.</p><p>Dylan DeLucia also has elite barrel evading horizontal movement on his heater. The pitch gets 17.1&quot; of arm side tailing action on average. That is more than all but two four-seam fastballs in the majors this year. The horizontal release is fairly generic at 1.57&#39; too so there is no reason not to pitch to the arm side and play for chases.</p><p>But like Joe Ryan before him- who also pitched down with the fastball in college before the Rays got him straight; DeLucia lacks that reliable secondary to depend on in two-strike counts. Dylan DeLucia maybe does not have the command to live up in the zone without giving up some long balls but I still think it’s a worthwhile tradeoff to try to maximize his whiffs if DeLucia is going to be throwing the fastball so often.</p><p>Maybe that is the key here- if DeLucia is going to be throwing the fastball so often. Quite frankly, there are zero reasons for DeLucia to spam the fastball as often as he does. DeLucia has two secondary pitches with incredibly strong stuff metrics and he doesn’t have to use the fastball anywhere near this frequently.</p><p>The slider hasn’t missed any bats but I think that has more to do with him throwing 45.6% of sliders in the zone than poor shape. The slider has an incredible shape in my humble opinion with DeLucia averaging 14.9&quot; of sweep and 0.9&quot; IVB. That is in the 90th percentile of slider sweep and its above-average vertical depth. The shape is not the problem here.</p><p>Dylan DeLucia sits at just 80.2 MPH on his slider. You probably want to see that number higher but there are good sliders with his movement at lower speed that still miss bats. The problem just as it is with the fastball is vertical location.</p><p>He’s too often throwing the breaking ball up- often times off the plate as well where he doesn’t get chases. He’ll pitch just on the edge of the plate to try to get whiffs in the zone when the reality of it is that sweeping sliders never miss bats in the zone. If DeLucia more frequently pitched to his outs then the slider would find more success.</p><p>Dylan DeLucia’s slider also has almost no viability against lefties as is. He gets just 26.3% chases with the pitch and has a 12.1% whiff rate overall. Probably, as a result, DeLucia throws 61.5% of his sliders in the zone against left handed batters. He still pitches to the glove side primarily which makes this a problem as it’s just free pickings for any decent hitter with his deployment against lefties. DeLucia naturally still uses his slider 20.1% of the time against lefties.</p><p>Dylan DeLucia has a more than a serviceable weapon to dismantle left handed hitters already in place, in the form of an above-average changeup. The cambio is his top whiff pitch with a 57.6% whiff rate and more descriptively, an 18.6% Swinging-Strike rate in Trackman games. The changeup has the opposite problem of the fastball and slider in that he doesn’t throw it in the zone or just often enough in general with only 16.7% of them landing over the plate.</p><p>Dylan DeLucia has elite changeup shape. He sits at 81.4 MPH- 10 MPH slower the fastball which is plus separation. He also has comparable spoin rates and a spin axis that is an hour more lateral than the fastball at 2:45 on average. He has an almost identical horizontal break with him averaging 17.8&quot; HB and can pull the string with an extra 19.1&quot; of drop with gravity. (4.5&quot; IVB). The pitch has a devastating bat missing shape and if the feel improves, it could be a legitimate out pitch.</p><p>Dylan DeLucia on top of having three quality pitches, also has one of the better batted ball profiles in the draft. His groundball rates are close to average (Because he pitches so low in the zone) and while you want that to be exchanged for whiffs, it’s not a bad sign by any means.</p><p>DeLucia also has elite popup rates and some of the best line drive avoidance in the class with the pairing of flat angle and elite tailing action on the fastball. He actually gets popups at a higher rate than he allows line drives. DeLucia isn’t trending one-dimensional yet, and I’m not even that confident he would be one-dimensional by chasing the strikeout (Which I think he should do).</p><p>I have to assume that Dylan DeLucia isn’t elevating his fastball because of command woes and that his slider is often firm more so than that he’s choosing to locate his pitch suboptimally. If it is just a choice and he can alter his locations effortlessly, then he’ll shoot up the rankings. He has three pitches with very promising stuff and shows the ability to throw strikes. I think he’s probably just control rather than a command arm for now, but if I’m wrong- presumably teams are wrong as well and he’ll be an incredible value here on day two of the draft.</p><h4>CF Victor Scott II, West Virginia</h4><p>I think Victor Scott flies under the radar in large part because he has a very old school head coach who preaches speed, bunts, and line drives above all else. This is especially impactful for a 70 grade burner like Scott who plays a plus centerfield but it’s the wrong approach for such a talented player to take and causes his power to go completely unappreciated.</p><p>Victor Scott only has six homers in 55 games during his college career but there is very much plus raw power in the profile. Scott has somewhat underwhelming EV numbers at first but once you clean up the data by removing the far too many bunts and the hit by pitches that trackman randomly logs EVs for, Scott looks really good.</p><p>Victor Scott has a Max EV of 110.8 MPH which already would rank in the 75th percentile of all major leaguers. The Top 8th EV lags a bit behind at 102.6 MPH which is only in the 80th percentile but it’s still solid and his barrel rates are above-average. His 51.4% Hard-Hit rate is in the 94th percentile as well. Scott can sting the ball.</p><p>Victor Scott actually has above-average (Below? It’s the good one) groundball rates. The problem with the game power is actually maybe a positive. Scott is hitting 68.8% of aerial contact hard but the thing is, not all aerial contact can wind up over the fence. Victor Scott II hits 45.7% of his batted balls with a launch angle below 0–20°. You have to hit the ball really hard to hit a ball with a sub 20° launch angle over the fence. The game power has potential but it is clearly behind the raw power.</p><p>Although that range of launch angles is incredible for Scott hitting doubles, and running elite BABIPs so I’m certain you should change it. Let’s expand that range of launch angles to the traditional sweet-spot range of 8–32°, he jumps up 48.6% which is in the 98th percentile of college hitters. Scott not only hits a ton of balls at optimal angles but he also avoids mishits with no popouts or soft contact. His mishit% is in the 97th percentile. Scott hits the ball to all fields and hits the ball hard. He’s going to post elite BABIPs and as a result, hit for an average.</p><p>Victor Scott has some swing and miss problems, however. He only made contact 71.2% of the time this year and isn’t any better in the strike zone at 78.3% contact rate. Except, here is the thing. The whiff issues are solely due to him swinging through pitches. Scott does not have any issue catching up to velocity with 0 whiffs against 93+ on 39 pitches with Trackman. Additionally, his contact rates are pretty consistent against all pitches. I’m not counting on improvements to the contact skills but it is not impossible.</p><p>Victor Scott has an exceptional approach as well which makes him easier to buy in on. Using the accurate Hawkeye strike zone, Scott II chased just 20% of the time. On top of his elite chase rates, Scott swings at an insanely high 79% of strikes. The only pitch he has a chase rate over 22.2% against is the changeup. He makes good swing decisions and is consistent in those swing decisions. He should work walks and he’s done that a lot in the Cape this summer after doing it in college as well.</p><p>Here’s the thing. Victor Scott makes exceptional swing decisions. He has no issue whatsoever with recognizing if a pitch will land in the zone or outside of it. Victor Scott also has elite barrel accuracy as supported by both the sweet-spot rate and the lack of mishits. That would indicate that he has plus bat control. By all accounts the pitch tracking is exceptional, he can control his swing, and there are even some timing skills. So why the whiffs?</p><p>Victor Scott doesn’t show any significant holes in his swing based on location. His swinging-strike rate is only 1.6% higher in the top half than in the bottom half. His swinging-strike rate is only 2.8% higher on pitches over the outer third than the inner third. There is not one weakness. He just misses on everything. But why? He has all the fundamental skills you look for in a contact hitter but just doesn’t make contact. So why the whiffs?</p><p>I have no clue. I’m very optimistic that the hit tool can be improved because he checks every box except actually making contact. I don’t know how exactly to do it but I think with some work, probably mechanical tweaks or something there is a route to him making more contact. If he does start making more contact he’ll be a steal with the wOBAcon profile and approach. If he doesn’t make more contact then he could still be useful.</p><h4>RF Keaton Anthony, Iowa</h4><p>Keaton Anthony is a draft-eligible freshman who won freshman of the year in the Big10 this year. He’s incredibly young for the class and dominated in his only year of college play to the tune of a 165 wRC+. He should be off the board early on day two with his strong hit tool and solid pop.</p><p>Keaton Anthony has what is a clear-cut plus hit tool and there’s a fringe chance that it develops into an elite one. Keaton Anthony makes a lot of contact. He has a 90.9% zone-contact rate but it might be even more impressive that he has a 75.3% out of zone contact rate. On top of the elite contact rates, Keaton Anthony has an elite BABIP profile led by 98th percentile line drive rate and plus rate of avoiding mishits.</p><p>The power is only average raw, unfortunately. Keaton Anthony maxes out at just 107.6 MPH and his Top 8th EV of 101.6 MPH is only in the 67th percentile. He does consistently hit the ball hard but that is more due to barrel accuracy than anything. The raw power is only average. Don’t take that slightly negative statement too harshly though because Anthony gets to every bit of his raw power in games thanks to a 94th percentile groundball rate (FaBIO so full season). Not only that, Keaton also pulls flyballs at an above-average rate and hits with backspin.</p><p>Keaton Anthony has plus arm strength that allows him to pitch on occasion. He’s not the most mobile outfielder but he should stick in right field as long as the bat is good enough. The hit tool is legitimate with his only real issue being expanding the zone for fastballs. He doesn’t chase anything else. He has useable game power and the hit will make that play in right field. I’m not sure how cheap he’ll come but I think he’s a pretty safe major leaguer and will provide value here on day two.</p><h4>SP Gary Gill Hill, Kennedy Catholic High School</h4><p>Gary Gill Hill does not get the respect he deserves from the industry at large. He’s a small school guy committed to an even smaller college in Farleigh Dickinson so he should come cheap and has good present-day stuff with projection.</p><p>Gary Gill Hill is a stick figure who looks like he could be knocked over by a strong breeze. The official measurements are 6&#39;2&quot; and 160 lbs which feels like it might be overstating the bulk he has. Gill Hill actually has good projection in his frame too and because he has such optimal mechanics for force generation, he’s still already hitting 94 MPH. You can easily see Gill Hill adding 3+ MPH to his heater.</p><p>The fastball has an interesting shape. He has elite tailing action with him averaging 18&quot; HB to the arm side and decent carry on the two-seam variant. He also will mix in a bowling ball sinker some with heavy tumble and limited tail. The fastball spin is a plus with him having a spin factor of 25.6 on average. Gill Hill throws from a lower arm slot but keeps his release fairly medial by hugging the first base side of the rubber. As a result, he has really optimal angles on his tailing heater and should rack up chases out of the zone.</p><p>The changeup is exciting too. He sits in the 80–82 MPH range with feel to kill spin on it. He maintains his fastball arm speed and the medial release lets the pitch play up. He also has a longer arm action that can help hide the pitch. Oh, and he gets good fade to the arm side and flashes good vertical depth. The pitch is still a work in progress with consistency issues but I have it graded as above-average.</p><p>I don’t love the slider in the upper seventies but it does show some promise. Gill Hill is a great athlete with the ability to control his delivery and a lot of strong physical and mechanical markers. He has a data-friendly changeup and a good fastball with the ability to throw strikes. I’m very optimistic about Gill Hill’s future. He might not go until the back half of today’s picks but he will quickly prove more than worth that selection.</p><h4>SP/RP Joseph King, Ravenwood High School</h4><p>There are two players named Joseph King on my top 500 and I think both of them have the potential to be good. The Joseph King we are focusing on in this blog is the high school one which I think has a lot more upside.</p><p>Joe King does not throw all that hard but I still kind of like the fastball. He sits 89–92 MPH and topped out at 93.6 MPH with Hawkeye. He also has spin rates below 2000 RPMs on average and is more reliant on seam-shifted wake and a low efficiency two-seamer than your typical fastball from a prep. He gets 14.3&quot; IVB without adjusting for the seam height and 14.7&quot; HB.</p><p>That is fairly generic movement but he has ideal release traits so it still plays with a 5.75&#39; RelHeight and 1.12&#39; RelSide. King should continue to lean into his seam-shifted wake traits and use the angle to get heavy amounts of chases to his arm side. He also teases above-average fastball command and is capable of using the pitch to his glove side for called strikes or even up in the zone on occasion to miss bats.</p><p>I also really like the loose, easy delivery with electric arm and shoulder speed on a mechanical level. There are some things to clean up but I think he has the capacity for significantly more velocity even without a lot of projection. I think he’ll get to at least league average velocity in his prime and that will let the sinker play.</p><p>The changeup during the Hawkeye showcases looked like one of the best pitches in the entire draft. He sat at 89.1 MPH with just under 2000 RPMs and had ethereal movement on the cambio. King throws his changeup with what was on average 21.5&quot; of arm side movement. He flashed as high as 25&quot; of horizontal break. He has average depth as well with 9.2&quot; IVB on average. The pitch plays up even further from his medial release point that helps him get even more chases. This changeup has elite upside and as the feel improves, it could carry him to the majors.</p><p>There is also a fringe breaking ball but it’s the fastball and changeup that will carry him to the majors. I think he’s the ideal candidate to develop a 12–6 curve that plays at the bottom of the zone and can steal called strikes. The command is there, I like the athlete and I think there is already present day stuff. There is some risk, obviously, but I think King is going to be a steal for a lucky team today.</p><h4>C Silas Ardoin, Texas</h4><p>Silas Ardoin is a glove first catcher with good actions behind the plate in almost all facets and plus pitch framing ability that won’t end up mattering. He also has an above-average arm by both strength and accuracy. The bat he potential too! Ardoin showed a completely unique blend of contact and power skills this year with Texas. This circled dot on the graph below was Ardoin last year. Every other dot was the rest of the players in college baseball with 30+ Trackman BBE.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*pTSZ7jzmD84KsA35" /></figure><p>Silas Ardoin absolutely pulverized the ball this season but there are countless reasons to be skeptical of his power translating to the next level. Ardoin only had a Max EV of 105.9 MPH this year which would be in the 27th percentile of major leaguers this year. His Top 8th EV of 102.5 MPH is slightly better but still only falls in the 77th percentile of college hitters and is far behind the MLB average 105.7 MPH. The power appears to be an illusion based on advanced barrel accuracy and a lot of balls hit 95–100 MPH. Losing a tick if only from the switch to wood will cut into the power output significantly.</p><p>Silas Ardoin is genuinely a good contact hitter but that is misleading too. Ardoin struggles with remembering he is allowed to swing the bat. College pitchers are notoriously bad at throwing quality strikes so he can fly with that approach but I’m not sure a 53% Z-Swing will translate in a vacuum. I also think the contact rates in general are inflated by him only swinging at mistakes. Ardoin has good contact skills but if he’s forced to be more aggressive then they might settle in closer to a 55–60 than a plus.</p><p>I have a number of concerns with Ardoin but he still has a high chance of providing good value on day two. There are a number of ways Ardoin can outproduce even first round picks. If the Hard-Hit rates are indicative of his power potential rather than the top-end EVs, Ardoin would be a steal. If electronic strike zones never are made a thing, he’d be a great value. If Ardoin just shows average power and is able to continue to make contact at such a high rate then Ardoin is a steal. I don’t really think Ardoin is some incredible upside play or underrated at all but there’s a high likelihood that he does outproduce his selection.</p><h4>SP Carson Turnquist, Paso Robles High School</h4><p>Let’s pretend velocity does not exist for a second. Carson Turnquist has an 80 grade fastball. He averages 22&quot; IVB in the showcase games which even after adjusting for seam height is phenomenal. He also is throwing from a somewhat low 5.7&#39; release height and has a fairly neutral 1.2&#39; horizontal release as well. Turnquist has exceptional extension as well, averaging 7.4&#39; of it which adds ~2 MPH to his effective velocity. To top it off, Turnquist has a great frame at 6&#39;5&quot; and already has decent preset day strength.</p><p>And… he averaged just 89.2 MPH during the summer circuit. He tops out at 92.8 MPH. The fastball velocity is very inconsistent with some outings where he is 90–93 MPH pretty regularly and other games where he can’t hit 90 MPH even once. There are some mechanical inefficiencies that will need to be reworked to get better timing and you have to find more velocity but this is an incredible foundation to build a pitch out of.</p><p>The secondaries are not on par with the fastball but do show some upside. The best of the bunch is a cutter at ~85 MPH. He sits at ~15 IVB and has very little horizontal movement. It works off the much more vertically moving heater up in the zone but that’s really all that makes it work.</p><p>There are two variants of breaking ball. One is a 71–74 MPH curve that averaged -15.7&quot; IVB with Hawkeye and only has 3 inches of sidespin. The other is a gyro slider at 75–77 MPH that has about equal side spin but a lot less depth. Neither pitch is good but with added velocity there might be potential there.</p><p>Turnquist rounds out his arsenal with a hilariously bad changeup that averages ~18&quot; IVB and sits at 82 MPH. There is some feel to supinate but I have very little hope for this pitch developing. Turnquist needs a lot of work but if the velocity takes off, he could quickly become a steal which is why he’s on this list but also why he won’t be drafted until late on day two- if at all.</p><h4>SP Eli Saul, Sacramento State</h4><p>There are two ways of looking at Eli Saul. You can look at the 5.43 xFIP and 6.5% K-BB% and say: Wow, he sucks. Or you can look at him and say: Wow! The Cardinals are going to make him into an amazing #4/5 starter. I fall in the latter camp and think Saul could be reminiscent of Dakota Hudson (Not a comp, just results). He doesn’t make sense on paper maybe but he’ll be effective.</p><p>Eli Saul’s stuff is not particularly good. None of his pitches even have a swinging strike rate of even 10%, there are some promising traits in both the curve and slider (With feel to supinate on a changeup as well) but neither of them are very effective right now. The appeal of Eli Saul is purely his inhumanly good ability to coax weak contact. Eli Saul has an average launch angle of -2.3° against him. 47.1% of batted balls he allowed last year were hit below 80 MPH.</p><p>Eli Saul throws what is potentially an exceptional sinker. He only sits at 92.6 MPH and tops out at 95.8 MPH but the combination of shape and angle still lets the sinker play. The sinker has elite vertical depth with Saul averaging just 3.8&quot; IVB on his sinker. Only two sinkers have that much sink in the majors (Min 300 this year). Those two are Logan Webb and Jason Alexander. On top of that, Eli Saul gets 17.3&quot; of horizontal movement which is in the 86th percentile of major leaguers. No MLB arm gets that much movement on both planes with their sinker.</p><p>Eli Saul also has extremely optimal release traits. He is throwing from a 5.2&#39; vertical release point and a 1.4&#39; horizontal release that lets the sinker play to both sides of the plate. He has an incredible body and if you rework some things he can likely add considerable velocity.</p><p>The command is better than the walk numbers would indicate. Eli Saul has a keen aversion for the heart of the plate. 38.5% of pitches from Eli Saul are within the width of one baseball from the edge of the strike zone. His ability to hammer the shadow zone leads to walks but it’s also why he gets so much weak contact. If Saul can develop a bat missing pitch he might be more than a back-of-the-rotation starter but even with only one real pitch, it’s a spammable one that should let him be fine at the back of a rotation with a good defense behind him.</p><h4>SP Gavin Van Kempen, Maple Hill High School</h4><p>Gavin Van Kempen has an outlier trait but it’s not one that is typically viewed as a positive trait. Van Kempen can’t create spin on any of his pitches. All of them average less than 1800 RPMs. On non-changeups, only two MLB pitchers have a lower spin rate on a pitch. Van Kempen throws three separate pitches with a spin rate that low. Is that good? Probably not? But it’s unique and unique often finds a way to perform.</p><p>Van Kempen is sitting 91–94 MPH with his fastball and can reach back for 97 MPH. There is plenty of projection left in his 6&#39;6&quot; frame too and he has solid mechanics so I’m expecting him to add more velocity. The fastball has interesting movement on a 1:30 axis because he’s throwing his zero spin fastball with high efficiency. As a result, he gets ~12 IVB and ~15 HB. That is a mediocre shape and borderline dead zone movement. I think this is just poor utilization of his natural skill to not spin the ball. I want Van Kempen to convert to a bowling ball sinker that drops like a rock and has very little side spin to lean into his strengths.</p><p>The secondaries I have very limited data on but they do show some promise on film. The splitter is his best secondary with solid movement on both planes but I’m skeptical of how a split will play off of a zero spin fastball when the primary appeal is killing spin. The slider has some bite with good tilt but sits in the upper seventies and the lack of spin makes it hard to believe in. The curve tells a similar story but in the low seventies with depth rather than tilt.</p><p>Gavin Van Kempen is a wild card. I will note that he has been comically good in High School as he threw three consecutive no hitters this year and struck out 66.7% of batters this year while only walking 7.4%. That is because he goes to a smaller school and what not but still cool to see. I like the delivery and command and think he’ll throw hard at the very least. There is potential for unique stuff and I think in the right organization that unique stuff could become really good stuff. He’s an outlier who won’t cost that much to take a chance on and probably has upside.</p><p><em>Sorry this is so short, the draft happened quickly and some of the players I initially planned to include here were taken already. I hope you enjoyed all of the draft content this week. Make sure to follow me on both Medium and Twitter because starting on July 29th, I will be releasing one blog a week analyzing every single player drafted in each division.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b527f1fa7a48" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[MLB Mock Draft]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/mlb-mock-draft-f7fd0f5938be?source=rss-f20e8b3389a4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f7fd0f5938be</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[predictions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb-draft]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mock-draft]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tieran Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 17 Jul 2022 13:55:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-17T13:55:07.873Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Uc1S4SiAk0Pl_lnygIei9A.png" /></figure><p>The MLB Draft is today! With the draft only a few hours away, I figured now was a good time to finally publish my first and only mock draft. This will cover all of the picks on day one of the draft and be based primarily on what I think teams will do.</p><p>This is my chance to flex that I have sources basically. I’ll give a prediction, a very brief overview of the player that I sometimes skip, and mention any other players that the team might be connected to with their first-round pick. I have a general idea of where most teams are looking in the first round, I have an inkling of like three possible second round picks in total so that will mostly be guesswork.</p><p>Anyways, intros are boring and I’ve done enough of those this week so let’s just get into the mock. If you want more details on who I mocked to your team, <a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/mlb-draft-top-500-prospects-fba9fe7fceaf">I wrote in depth about them here</a>.</p><h4>1. Baltimore Orioles — CF Druw Jones, Wesleyan High School</h4><p>I honestly have almost no idea what the Orioles will do with this pick. I know there are at least three names being seriously considered here. Druw Jones is presumably still the favorite at this pick- not because he’s actually the most likely to be taken but because the odds are like 40% Druw or 550% an under-slot option with a 5% chance at Holliday or Green. Opinions are mixed on if that under-slot option is Brooks Lee or Termarr Johnson.</p><p>I’ve also heard Collier linked to the Orioles here but that’s less substantiated. There have been some Green connections in the past but it sounds like he’s only saving a few hundred thousand over Jones and I think the Orioles prefer Jones over the two on talent. The only other name I’ve heard in passing is Zach Neto who the Orioles love but that feels impossible no matter the price.</p><p>If Druw Jones doesn’t go here, things get tricky. The Diamondbacks really like him but I’ve heard the interest is not mutual and he would give real consideration to going to school. Texas likes him but they also love Holliday and Holliday should be cheaper. Will the Pirates go way over for Jones? Cherington doesn’t really do that. Would the Nationals use 80% of their pool on one player? If he gets past Texas, there’s a pretty high chance that Druw goes to the Mets and they punt #14 to accommodate him.</p><p>Druw Jones is the best player in the draft according to most people, including myself. Jones Jr. offers excellent defense in centerfield with the potential for plus power and shows flashes of a plus hit tool as well. The offensive impact is loud and he’s a spectacular defender.</p><p>Druw Jones is demanding at least the full slot value at #1, and some reports have him commanding 10MM even from certain teams. I think the talent is probably worth it but if the Orioles would rather have Lee/Termarr at ~6.5MM then I’m totally on board with that too. It’s hard for the Orioles to go wrong at #1 overall.</p><h4>2. Arizona Diamondbacks — CF Elijah Green, IMG Academy</h4><p>The Diamondbacks would love Druw but in this scenario, he’s gone, and I’ve heard from multiple places that Druw isn’t interested in them. Holliday has some consideration here, but Jackson again isn’t interested in this spot and likewise has the leverage to conceivably not sign.</p><p>I’ve heard Termarr here some and there are rumors connecting the Diamondbacks to Brooks Lee and Kevin Parada. Ultimately though, I think the Diamondbacks settle on Elijah Green. Green reportedly had a great workout at Chase field back in June and impressed all of the top brass.</p><p>Elijah Green is the highest upside player in the draft. He offers four tools that might warrant 70 grades in his prime. The only question with Green is his ability to hit for average. There are fairly major whiff concerns but the swing decisions are solid and he has made strides with his contact rates as of late. Even if he does strike out 30% of the time or even more, the tools should still make him a quality major leaguer.</p><h4>3. Texas Rangers — SS Jackson Holliday, Stillwater High School</h4><p>For a while, I was hearing that Jackon Holliday was going to be an almost impossible sign but a source with connections to the Rangers suggested otherwise. Jackson Holliday is allegedly demanding just 7.5MM from the Rangers, and according to them, Matt Holliday doesn’t actually want Jackson to go to college. That doesn’t mean he won’t go, but it’s not any external pressure from his father (who coaches at Oklahoma State) to join him.</p><p>I’m not sure who the Rangers would take if both Holliday and Jones are still on the board at their pick. I’ve heard they are enamored with both and there’s a non-zero chance they have their pick of the litter. In the somewhat likely scenario where both are gone, things get really interesting. Parada and Brooks Lee are the favorites in that scenario but Kumar Rocker is a very real possibility.</p><p>Rocker would be an extreme cost saving option who would give the Rangers the flexibility to get more than one prospect out of their draft, even if they don’t pick again until the fourth round. My understanding is that any scenario with them drafting Rocker is dependent on the Rangers being able to buy down multiple preps they like. That feels unlikely given their draft capital but not impossible.</p><p>Jackson Holliday is my third ranked player in the draft which makes for a very strange coincidence where the first three players in the mock are the first three on my board. Holliday has a good chance of sticking at shortstop and makes a lot of contact. He’s grown into some power with the help of mechanical adjustments and projects to make an impact in a number of ways. He’s another more expensive option who is worth the cost at the top of the draft.</p><h4>4. Pittsburgh Pirates — 3B Cam Collier, Chipola College</h4><p>The only player I have anything concrete connecting them to the Pirates is Cole Young but I would be floored if they consider him here. They really like Young but I think they are much more likely to cut a deal here and try to buy him down to their next pick at #36.</p><p>The consensus guy for the Pirates here is typically Cam Collier according to other people which I see no reason to dispute. Lee and Termarr are the other guys commonly mentioned here. Collier is probably the right pick at this spot with his highly advanced contact skills and plate discipline that he pairs with a potential plus raw power projection at the hot corner. I do wonder if they consider reaching for a guy like Neto, Gilbert, or Jung to facilitate spending later again but I’ll stick with the popular opinion and go Collier here.</p><h4>5. Washington Nationals — C Kevin Parada, Georgia Tech.</h4><p>Kevin Parada is pretty much the consensus guy here according to everyone in the industry. If Parada is off the board then Elijah Green is their guy. If both are gone then I genuinely have no clue what the Nationals will do. Parada has loud game power and an above-average hit tool. There are some concerns that he won’t stick behind the plate but he’s a fantastic hitter who still profiles as an everyday player at a different position.</p><h4>6. Miami Marlins — SS Brooks Lee, Cal Poly</h4><p>The buzz on the Marlins has shifted as of late. For a while, they sounded like the favorites for Termarr and that is still very possible but they seem to be leaning more towards college bats with Lee at the top of their list and Neto as a dark horse. Craig Mish also has the Marlins connected to both Lesko and Brandon Barriera which would certainly shake things up, but ultimately I think Lee is too good to remain on the board any longer.</p><h4>7. Chicago Cubs — 2B Termarr Johnson, Mays High School</h4><p>The Cubs will take whichever of Collier and Termarr are still on the board at their pick. If both are somehow gone then Zach Neto is the favorite as an under-slot deal to spend later- possibly on Noah Schultz. In this scenario, Termarr is still on the board so they eagerly turn their card in. I’m lower on Termarr Johnson than most but the appeal is obvious. He has a superb hit tool with solid power even if the defensive value is limited. He’s a relatively safe prep bat who should move fairly quickly.</p><h4>8. Minnesota Twins — 3B Jacob Berry, LSU</h4><p>I have no idea who the Twins will take but that’s not because I haven’t heard anything about them. The Twins have the opposite problem, they are connected to just about everyone. The Twins have been mostly connected to college bats like Gavin Cross, Jacob Berry, Jace Jung, and Zach Neto most commonly.</p><p>I’ve had conversations with a Twins employee about if Cade Horton could be worth a top ten pick and this is probably his ceiling. Cooper Hjerpe is a speculative fit as well because the Twins place a premium on a lot of the model-friendly traits he brings to the table. I know the Twins like Spencer Jones but I don’t think they’ll take him this early.</p><p>Prospects Live also has connected the Twins to Drew Gilbert here as a cost saving option and Baseball America has thrown around names like Chase DeLauter, Jett Williams, and Justin Crawford. There are about a dozen names in play and just one day before the draft, I have zero idea where the Twins will go.</p><p>I opted for Jacob Berry here because the Twins don’t place a ton of emphasis on positional value and Berry can clearly hit but I have no clue what they will actually do here. This is a slightly educated guess and nothing more. If the Twins don’t take Jacob Berry here then their second round pick is probably a fairly reasonable landing spot for Ivan Melendez.</p><h4>9. Kansas City Royals — CF Justin Crawford, Bishop Gorman High School</h4><p>The Royals were an obvious candidate to try to do something like they did last year and go under slot here to spend later but after trading #35, that path seems much less doable. I think the Royals probably just go with the best player available here. I’ve heard they like Gavin Cross and Justin Crawford a fair bit and in the absence of anything more concrete, I went with the latter. In all honesty, that is mostly because I have no idea where he would go otherwise.</p><h4>10. Colorado Rockies —CF Gavin Cross, Virginia Tech.</h4><p>The Rockies are the floor for a lot of players. They’re the floor for Jacob Berry who is already gone in this scenario and like Elijah Green so they might stop his fall too if he gets here. I’ve heard they probably won’t commit their entire pool to one player but only go slightly overslot if necessary.</p><p>The Rockies are the first real suitor for Daniel Susac to my understanding. I’ve heard Gilbert mentioned as a cost-saving option and I know the Rockies like Spencer Jones although I presume they want him with their second pick. I’ve heard Jung here but his overly disciplined approach isn’t really the Rockies style so I am skeptical. One person plugged into the industry mentioned Dylan Lesko here but I’m praying they were joking.</p><p>I think on a theoretical level, both of the top two college arms could be a fit for the Rockies. Cade Horton is dependent on velocity and gyro more so than magnus movement so he shouldn’t be hurt too much by Coors on paper. I also like the very angle dependent Hjerpe as a fit because his release won’t change with his home ballpark.</p><p>I went with Gavin Cross because he’s one of the better college bats available and fits the Rockies&#39; general philosophy offensively. He hits the ball hard and has high in-zone contact rates with tools. If Cross goes at #9 then this pick is a raffle with like ten different names.</p><h4>11. New York Mets — SS Zach Neto, Campbell</h4><p>In this scenario, none of the big three falls to the Mets so they play things pretty simple and boring. I’ve heard that if Druw falls to them, there is a small chance that the Mets exceed their pool and lose two future firsts to go crazy this year and assemble the greatest draft ever but that still feels like a pipe dream.</p><p>The more likely scenario if they get Druw is that they punt this pick with a second or third round talent and use the savings to overpay Druw. I would assume a guy like Ivan Melendez with very limited leverage, who is very good, and also easy to sell the fans on as the reigning Golden Spikes would be near the top of that list.</p><p>I went with Zach Neto here because he’s one of the best players available and likely won’t make it to their next pick. The Mets are connected to literally everyone in the entire draft — prep and college, so it’s hard to pin down exactly what they will do.</p><h4>12. Detroit Tigers — 2B Jace Jung, Texas Tech.</h4><p>The Tigers are the first really serious suitor for Cade Horton which will surely make every Tigers fan happy. Brock Porter is another guy linked here as they prefer him to the injured Lesko and they are realistic suitors for both Rocker and Prielipp. Ultimately though, I have them going bat despite all the links to pitching and grabbing Jace Jung before he can really start to free fall. If Neto is here, he’s the pick because the Tigers seem to love him.</p><h4>13. Los Angeles Angels — SP Kumar Rocker, Los Angeles Angels</h4><p>I think the Angels only looking at arms thing is a bit forced by a lot of people after last year but there is some validity to it. If Neto is still on the board, I’ve heard they’ll take him at the very least. I’m assuming he is gone though and if he is, they do probably go arm here.</p><p>The Angels are interested in a lot of pitchers but they don’t appear to be one of the teams that are extremely high on Hjerpe. I think it’s one of Rocker/Prielipp/Hughes and with only one more year of Ohtani; it’s probably the one closest to the majors. I’ve also heard the Angels linked to Joyce in the later rounds which would be fun and they would love Reggie Crawford but this is too rich for him probably.</p><h4>14. New York Mets — C Daniel Susac, Arizona</h4><p>I’ve already discussed most of the Mets rumors with their last pick but this is the one connection I’ve refrained from mentioning. The Mets like Susac as any sane human does but again, they like everyone. Interestingly enough, they have an interest in moving Susac out from behind the plate to play right field or first base at times which is uh... If Susac gets past 15, then he likely goes at one of 19–22 as all four of those teams seem to like him a lot.</p><h4>15. San Diego Padres — SP Dylan Lesko, Buford High School</h4><p>If you’ve ever read a mock draft, you probably know why this pick makes sense. AJ Preller loves to take risks and Dylan Lesko would have gone top five if healthy. He probably still should. Jett Williams and Cole Young or the other two names commonly linked here.</p><p>A person close to Daniel Susac told me that they thought the Padres were a likely landing spot for Susac as well. They really like the player and if he’s still on the board, is a very real candidate to be selected here. There is a non-zero chance of Rocker here as well to the always splashy Preller ran Padres but that feels like a more distant chance.</p><h4>16. Cleveland Guardians — SP Cooper Hjerpe, Oregon State</h4><p>The data-heavy, model-centric Cleveland Guardians are an obvious fit for Hjerpe. I’ve had a source linking the two but I’ve been speculating about this fir for a long time. The only player I think the Guardians might take over Hjerpe is Zach Neto who will almost certainly be gone. Hjerpe will likely save money for later and become an Ace in the Guardians pitching factory. Horton is a really interesting fit here as well but I opted for the better player.</p><h4>17. Philadelphia Phillies — CF Drew Gilbert, Tennessee</h4><p>I don’t have sources on what the Phillies are doing but based on what others are connecting them to, it seems likely they go pitching with their first pick once more. I have heard seen some Drew Gilbert murmurings in the past though and I think it’s unlikely he falls much further than this. This is pure guesswork but I think the Phillies stop his fall.</p><h4>18. Cincinnati Reds — SP Brandon Barriera, American Heritage High School</h4><p>The Reds have been linked to Barriera by places like Prospects Live and that fills me with joy because I think this is one of the better player to team fits in the draft. Barriera is an extreme supinator with a dead zone fastball that he needs to turn into a real cutter. This is something the Reds have already successfully done with Ashcraft and I think Barriera has better foundations for secondary stuff. The Reds could do a lot of fun things with Barriera. They might be tempted more by Porter if he is still here and they like Gilbert too.</p><h4>19. Oakland Athletics — RF Dylan Beavers, California</h4><p>The Athletics have been closely linked to Dylan Beavers the entire cycle and makes a lot of sense here. The interest has been so obvious from the beginning though that it feels a bit like smoke. If they don’t go Beavers, I have my eye on DeLauter here. Spencer Jones doesn&#39;t feel impossible either but that’s just guesswork.</p><h4>20. Atlanta Braves — SP Brock Porter, Orchard Lake St. Mary High School</h4><p>Brock Porter is not the plan here and almost certainly won’t be available but in this scenario, he falls to them and the Braves greedily snatch him up with their newfound financial muscle. If Lesko is here he is a shoe horn as well. In a more realistic scenario, Cade Horton is the move. If all three arms are gone then they probably cut a deal with Justin Campbell or Gabriel Hughes and go with Noah Schultz or something at #35.</p><h4>21. Seattle Mariners — SP Cade Horton, Oklahoma</h4><p>The Mariners appear to be looking at college arms first and foremost with this pick. I have had conversations with a Mariners scout about Landon Sims, Thomas Harrington, and Justin Campbell. I would assume the first two are more second-round targets than in the first though.</p><p>The Mariners like Horton who may or may not be available when they first pick and will probably require going slightly over-slot. If Jett Williams is on the board like he is in this scenario, they’ll have a tough decision because they love him as well. They also love Cole Young who is again on the board here. I have no clue which of the three they choose in this scenario. I went with Horton but it’s not cut and dry.</p><p>The Mariners also really like Drew Gilbert who already went in this mock. This is the floor for the already gone Cooper Hjerpe. If Dylan Lesko is here (And signable) they’ll run their card to the podium but he won’t be both of those. The pick is likely a college arm but there is flexibility here.</p><h4>22. St. Louis Cardinals — CF Chase DeLauter, James Madison</h4><p>Chase DeLauter should go much earlier than this but teams are weird and he was hurt. The Cardinals once again stop the fall of a talented player and get a steal. DeLauter is the only name I’ve actually heard the Cardinals concretely connected to but speculative fits include guys like Owen Murphy, and Jett Williams if they are on the board. Also, just about anyone who is good because Randy Flores is incredible at his job when the front office isn’t forcing an archetype.</p><h4>23. Toronto Blue Jays — 3B Tucker Toman, Hammond High School</h4><p>Tucker Toman is a good prospect but this is a bit rich for my blood. I don’t have direct connections to what the Blue Jays are doing — the only thing I’ve heard directly is interested in Drew Gilbert who is gone already. Toman has been heavily linked to the Jays and Prospects Live thinks this pick is one of DeLauter, Gilbert, or Toman. Toman is the only one left here so he’s the pick. Prielipp and Sims are speculative fit as well since they didn’t shy away from Hoglund last year.</p><h4>24. Boston Red Sox — SS Eric Brown, Boston Red Sox</h4><p>This is another team that I have no knowledge of their plans. My understanding is they want college performers mostly but I have no confidence in that because it’s just a crowd sourced opinion. They are commonly linked to Sterlin Thompson, Chase DeLauter, and Kumar Rocker but I opted to mix it up and go Brown. I have no clue if they like him but I only know what teams don’t like him so…</p><h4>25. New York Yankees — SS Cole Young, North Allegheny High School</h4><p>Cole Young has suitors at every pick in the first two rounds and no one actually knows where he will go. I’ve heard the Pirates don’t think it’s impossible to buy him down to #36 and the Dodgers would love to somehow get him at #40 for their entire bonus pool. The Mariners also are heavy on him. The Yankees have been connected to Young by other outlets and I think he’s a solid fit for their development program. If Drew Gilbert is here he won’t make it any further.</p><p>There are three commonly connected names to this Yankees pick. I was told by someone with connections to the Yankees that Eric Brown doesn’t have a first round grade from the team about a month ago. Brock Jones is linked here but in recent years, the Yankees have placed more priority on making contact so I’m very skeptical. I suspect Spencer Jones might not be the move either because of that although he’s more likely to override those concerns. Sterlin Thompson gets buzz here but his underlying data isn’t particularly strong and the Yankees value that highly. Young isn’t a concrete connection but I think it’s more probable than some other players and no one really knows what will happen at this point.</p><h4>26. Chicago White Sox — SP Connor Prielipp, Alabama</h4><p>No one knows what the White Sox are doing and if they say they do, they are probably lying. College pitching is a common link but so is just about everything but prep arm from what I’ve seen. This is the floor for Rocker. I went with Prielipp as my shot in the dark because the White Sox have no problems buying in on small sample stuff or injury prone/injured arms. They are probably really tempted with Jett still on the board.</p><h4>27. Milwaukee Brewers — SP Blade Tidwell, Tennessee</h4><p>The only name with real connections here is DeLauter and to a lesser extent Gilbert. Both have already been drafted in this and will not make it to them in the real draft either. A speculative fit could include Eric Brown as well since the Brewers like bad mechanics that they fail to fix. I think they should go pitching here but they’re only rumored to be looking at college guys and there aren’t very many good ones left. I opted to inject the high upside of Blade Tidwell into their system but that’s a blind dart throw.</p><h4>28. Houston Astros — SS Jett Williams, Rockwell-Heath High School</h4><p>Jett Williams getting to the Astros is the apocalyptic scenario for fans of any other team. Jett Williams has exceptional bat speed which the Astros place a premium on. He’s also an exceptional athlete. He tops it off by offering a good hit tool that needs adjustments. He might need to add strength to his lower half, and definitely needs to fix his sprays but that is what the Astros do better than anyone. (Latter part Cardinals are better at).</p><p>I also have a concrete connection to Dalton Rushing here but I don’t think the Astros will pass up on Jett if he’s there. Spencer Jones is another name I’ve heard here and would also be an awesome value pick.</p><h4>29. Tampa Bay Rays — SS Peyton Graham, Oklahoma</h4><p>Peyton Graham feels like a Ray. I don’t have a source connecting the two, but I think this is an incredible fit. The Rays are the biggest team at looking at batted ball spin and Graham is incredible at hitting flyballs with ideal spin. He also has good power and can play shortstop. There’s no one I trust to develop Peyton Graham more than the Rays and the only thing I have here is Eric Brown who is gone.</p><h4>30. San Francisco Giants — CF Spencer Jones, Vanderbilt</h4><p>“Joker! Joker! Joker!” — Roger Munter. The Giants are a hard team to pin down. They like Gilbert but there’s zero chance he’s here and beyond that, no one knows. The Giants haven’t shied away from suspect hit tools under Farhan with them taking Joey Bart, Hunter Bishop, and Patrick Bailey in the first round. Admittedly, none of those have really met expectations but they aren’t shy from hit issues and Spencer Jones has the best power in the draft with elite athleticism. I don’t have anything solid here, he’s the best available and he makes some measure of sense so why not.</p><p><em>For the rest of the draft, I am only including explanations on picks that are based on stuff from sources. If I am guessing, it’ll just be a name. It’s a lot of guessing. If I’m lucky then two of these picks will be correct.</em></p><h4>31. Colorado Rockies — RF Jordan Beck, Colorado Rockies</h4><h4>32. Cincinnati Reds — SP Justin Campbell, Oklahoma</h4><h4>33. Baltimore Orioles — SP Carson Whisenhunt, Eastern Carolina</h4><h4>34. Arizona Diamondbacks — SP Owen Murphy, Oswego East High School</h4><h4>35. Atlanta Braves — 2B Mikey Romero, Orange Lutheran High School</h4><h4>36. Pittsburgh Pirates — SP Walter Ford, Pace High School</h4><h4>37. Cleveland Guardians — SS Max Martin, Moorestown High School</h4><h4>38. Colorado Rockies — CF Gavin Turley, Hamilton High School</h4><h4>39. San Diego Padres — SP Landon Sims, Mississippi State</h4><h4>40. Los Angeles Dodgers — C Dalton Rushing, Louisville</h4><h4>41. Boston Red Sox — LF Sterlin Thompson, Florida</h4><h4>42. Baltimore Orioles — CF Jud Fabian, Florida</h4><h4>43. Arizona Diamondbacks — 2B Tanner Schobel, Virginia Tech.</h4><h4>44. Pittsburgh Pirates — SP Jacob Miller, Liberty Union High School</h4><h4>45. Washington Nationals — LF Brock Jones, Stanford</h4><h4>46. Miami Marlins — 1B Tyler Locklear, VCU</h4><h4>47. Chicago Cubs — SS Josh Kasevich, Oregon</h4><h4>48. Minnesota Twins — CF Jacob Melton, Oregon State</h4><h4>49. Kansas City Royals — SP Jackson Ferris, IMG Academy</h4><h4>50. Colorado Rockies — SP Gabriel Hughes, Colorado Rockies</h4><h4>51. Detroit Tigers — SP Adam Mazur, Iowa</h4><h4>52. New York Mets — SP Robby Snelling, McQueen High School</h4><h4>53. San Diego Padres — SP Reggie Crawford, Connecticut</h4><h4>54. Cleveland Guardians — SP Thomas Harrington, Campbell</h4><p>The only sourced pick of the second round? Probably. Harrington has five pitches with projection and command. The Guardians can work with that. I’ve also had conversations with a Mariners scout about Harrington so that’s another possible landing spot for him.</p><h4>55. Cincinnati Reds — SP Jonathan Cannon, Georgia</h4><h4>56. Oakland Athletics — SP Parker Messick, Florida State</h4><h4>57. Atlanta Braves — 1B Ivan Melendez, Texas</h4><h4>58. Seattle Mariners — SP Carson Palmquist, Miami</h4><h4>59. St. Louis Cardinals — SS Cameron Smith, Palm Beach Central</h4><h4>60. Toronto Blue Jays — JR Ritchie, Bainbridge High School</h4><h4>61. New York Yankees — SP Jacob Misiorowski, Crowder Junior College</h4><h4>62. Chicago White Sox — C Cade Hunter, Virginia Tech.</h4><h4>63. Milwaukee Brewers — SP Jackson Cox, Toutle Lake High School</h4><h4>64. Houston Astros — CF Colby Thomas, Mercer</h4><h4>65. Tampa Bay Rays — SP Caden Dana, Don Bosco High School</h4><h4>66. San Francisco Giants — SP Adam Maier, Oregon</h4><h4>67. Baltimore Orioles — 3B Cayden Wallace, Arkansas</h4><h4>68. Minnesota Twins — RF Roman Anthony, Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School</h4><h4>69. Oakland Athletics — CF Henry Bolte, Palo Alto High School</h4><h4>70. Tampa Bay Rays — 2B Nick Morabito, Gonzaga High School</h4><h4>71. Tampa Bay Rays — RP Ben Joyce, Tampa Bay Rays</h4><h4>72. Milwaukee Brewers — SP Jake Bennett, Oklahoma</h4><h4>73. Cincinnati Reds — 1B Max Wagner, Clemson</h4><h4>74. Seattle Mariners — SP Bryce Hubbart, Florida State</h4><p><em>I am never doing a second round of a mock draft ever again.</em></p><p><em>Anyways, thanks for reading! I’ll be tweeting my thoughts on every draft prospect as the picks happen so make sure to follow me @Tieran711 so you don’t miss that.</em></p><p><em>There is one more blog this week as I’ll talk about some of my favorite day two draft prospects tomorrow morning. Hopefully, they’re all still available after day one. Thank you for all the support this week, it’s been a blast.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f7fd0f5938be" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Exploring the Most Unheralded Demographic — College Relievers]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/exploring-the-most-unheralded-demographic-college-relievers-3c8239930dc6?source=rss-f20e8b3389a4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3c8239930dc6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[relief-pitchers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pitchers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[demographics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb-draft]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tieran Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Jul 2022 17:52:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-16T17:52:36.973Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Exploring the Most Unheralded Demographic — College Relievers</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Uc1S4SiAk0Pl_lnygIei9A.png" /></figure><p>If you look at most public draft boards there is one position that almost always has no one ranked in the top 100 and usually has so few players in the top 500 that you can count them on your fingers. I am of course talking about college relievers- not possible starting pitcher conversions or vice versa but pure relief arms. That means there will be no Jacob Misiorowski even though I think he would be elite in relief and likewise no Alex Rao because I think he can be a starter at the next level, even if he’s a reliever in college.</p><p>Every year teams draft a number of college relievers on days two and three- largely because they are cheap. Relievers are very integral to the success of major league teams in today’s game and they do have value. They are the least valuable position for sure but you’re also a lot more likely to find a big leaguer by drafting relievers on day three than any other position.</p><p>I don’t really think college relievers are that underrated per se, I just find them fun and want to educate people on some of my favorites who I think could be staples in an MLB bullpen. This is the in detail look at the top relief prospects that literally no one has ever asked for but I’m doing anyway. This is not a ranking of the top relief prospects, just the ones I like and want to talk about. I do not care about production at all for college relievers, it’s pure stuff that I am projecting on.</p><p><em>Strike zone parameters are based on height for hitters. For pitchers, I assume every opposing hitter is 6&#39;1&quot;</em></p><h3>Ben Joyce, Tennessee</h3><p>Ben Joyce is easily the most famous college reliever in recent memory. And how could he not be? He throws his fastball up to 105.5 MPH and averages a measly 101.4 MPH in games with trackman. In the statcast era, only Aroldis Chapman has thrown a harder pitch (He did it twice). Aroldis Chapman also holds the record for average fastball velocity which he set at 101.1 MPH in 2016.</p><p>There are caveats to that record breaking velocity, however. Ben Joyce is a reliever who was only asked to pitch back-to-back days once all year. He was often pitching on high rest and is only asked to throw 20 pitches or thereabouts. The fastball velocity is ridiculous but the average will settle closer to 100 than 101 MPH.</p><p>There is this belief among boneheads that Ben Joyce’s fastball won’t translate to the bigs because it’s straight. That he needs some movement for it to actually play as an 80 grade pitch. I have no idea where this theory came from but it has zero bases in reality. The fastball is a great pitch even if he sat sitting 94 instead of 101.4.</p><p>The fastball is likely a two-seam variant. He sits at 2452 RPMs and throws with high efficiency on a 1:45 spin axis. The heater as a result of those two things has 16.3 inches of arm side run on average and will flash up to 20.7 inches. That is above-average tail even if it’s undermined some by a 2.25 ft release side that kills his HAA on the arm side fastball and somewhat nullifies the chase upside.</p><p>The real calling card for the fastball is his vertical approach angle. Ben Joyce throws his heater with 14.1&quot; IVB which is below-average vertical movement for a four-seamer. But when you pair that movement with an average release height of 5.05 ft good things tend to happen.</p><p>Ben Joyce throws his four-seam fastball with an average of pitch height of 2.39 feet which is embarrassingly low. He still has -4.2° VAA which is in the 90th percentile of all major league arms. VAA is largely determined based on pitch height which is what makes that number so ridiculously impressive.</p><p>Let’s look at this in a different way. Edwin Díaz throws from almost the exact same release at 4.98 ft vertically and 2.33 ft horizontally. Díaz gets 13.6&quot; IVB and 13.4&quot; HB on his fastball at 98.8 MPH. Joyce is just an upgrade on that fastball with what is essentially the same location-neutral VAA but he throws 2.5 MPH harder and with an additional three inches of arm-side movement. Edwin Díaz has been one of the best relievers in baseball for half a decade on the back of his 80-grade heater. What does that make Joyce?</p><p>Ben Joyce has a slider that some scouts swear is better than the fastball as well. They are wrong but it is a very justifiable take. The slider has 17.6 inches of sweep on average and decent enough depth at 4.2&quot; IVB. With his arm slot being so low, the HAA plays up even above the 97th percentile sweep on his slider.</p><p>My concerns with the slider stem from how it interacts with the fastball. Joyce sits at just 83.5 MPH with his slider. That is almost 17 MPH slower than the heater. As such, it is very obvious when he is throwing what and it limits his chase potential as a result. He still misses bats because the stuff is obscene but given the lack of ability to throw it in the zone, losing out on that deceptive element is very costly. I think Joyce obviously has the arm strength to add power to the slider and even if it costs him some sweep, it is absolutely a tradeoff I would gladly take. The slider has elite potential.</p><p>There is also a changeup that I somehow do not hate. He only threw it 5 times this year in games with data I have access to but it does have very intriguing traits. Joyce averaged 89.3 MPH with a spin rate of just 1532 RPMs- over 900 lower than the fastball at 12.1 MPH slower.</p><p>The changeup movement is the real standout though with just 1.4&quot; IVB and 12.3 inches of tail. It’s premium depth, separation, spin, and solid enough tailing shape as well. Yes, the changeup is in a very small sample and the feel is not at all present at the current time but there is real upside here.</p><p>Ben Joyce has control issues and even bigger command ones. His approach is kind of just to blindly fire the fastball and pray that it’s a strike. That approach honestly works fine given the stuff quality. He needs to improve his precision a tad to truly be elite probably and maybe should aim slightly higher but he’s not going to be punished all that often on middle-middle fastballs and he should get plenty of chases above the zone or off the plate with the fastball. I’m not expecting good command but as a reliever, he does not need it.</p><p>The batted ball profile should be great even with subpar locations. The flat VAA fastball at the top of the zone will produce popups and he dodges line drives with how much horizontal movement the entire arsenal has. There are groundballs with the fastball down as well because he doesn’t actually have that much vertical movement, just great angles and he throws hard. The command defines a lot, of what the batted ball profile will be but the skills are here for a robust batted ball profile.</p><p>Ben Joyce has major injury questions. He is just coming off of Tommy John surgery and was often hurt in high school as well. That first Tommy John being out of the way makes another one less likely and maybe will help his elbow hold up but I’m not counting on it. He misses out on a 55 FV from me despite the confidence in the stuff because I’m not sure he’ll hold up throwing 60+ innings annually.</p><p>I think Joyce might best be served in the second tier of relievers who throws 40ish innings each year with regular rest and doesn’t allow a single run while doing so. If I’m a contender drafting Joyce then my plan is to wrap him in the bubble wrap for the regular season every year and then unleash one of the game&#39;s most dangerous weapons out of the pen every postseason.</p><p>Ben Joyce is an MLB-ready relief ace who aside from workload concerns that could mandate shutting him down, is ready to step into the MLB bullpen from day one and dominate the world’s best hitters. He has adjustments to make but the stuff is good enough to learn on the fly on the brightest stage.</p><p>There is also the argument to be made that the lack of mileage on his arm as a result of his injuries is somewhat of a positive. Ben Joyce was dealing with nagging elbow issues for years before the Tommy John and now that he’s healthy he can really let go and we’ve seen the talent that was always there. The lack of mileage means barring more injuries, he can last longer and pitch more than most comparable talents. Maybe Tommy John was the final step in his road to greatness and with it in the rearview mirror, we see 2022 Joyce every night. I don’t agree but there is some logic behind it.</p><p>The thing with Ben Joyce is there are only two reasons not to like him. First, you have the positional bias against relievers which will always be there for some people. The second reason is that he is often hurt and there are workload concerns. Everyone gets hurt and even when there are some cues of future injury risk, getting hurt isn’t exactly predictable.</p><p>I knocked Joyce down a tier from where the raw stuff should have him due to the health concerns but I won’t go any further just because he might break. Joyce has elite impact potential as a shutdown high leverage arm and that is to me worth a first round pick.</p><h3>Noah Dean, Old Dominion</h3><p>Noah Dean is the top left-handed reliever in this year’s draft. He isn’t in the same league as Joyce but he is very good even if the production has been fairly mediocre at a smaller school. The stuff will play in the majors even if he’s not quite a plug-and-play guy.</p><p>The fastball velocity is at a premium. Dean sits at 95.6 MPH on average and can reach back for 99 MPH when it is required of him. The fastball comes from a vertical slot with a 5.99 ft release height and a -0.93 release side. This slot is combined with elite velocity, and plus feel for spin averaging 2375 RPMs on his heater.</p><p>The fastball is thrown on a 1:00 axis with very high spin efficiency and as a result Dean gets 21.8&quot; IVB on average to go along with 9.3 inches of armside movement. That is above-average horizontal action on a four-seam fastball. That is more vertical movement than anyone in College Baseball who averages at least 93 MPH on their fastball.</p><p>I would say in the world instead of just in College but Daniel Espino averages 21.9&quot; IVB at 96.6 MPH so that wouldn’t be true even if he’s also better than every major league arm. The pitching bot has Dean’s fastball graded as an 87-grade pitch on the 20–80 scale and I’m inclined to slap an 80 on it as well. This is a special pitch from Dean.</p><p>The curveball in a vacuum is fantastic. If Dean threw the fastball at just 93 MPH with 17&quot; IVB as most plebs do, this would be a plus or even 70-grade offering. The pitch has -15.4&quot; IVB which is in the 92nd percentile of major leaguers and 10&quot; HB which is also above-average. The movement, spin rates, and spin axis very closely mirror Max Fried’s hammer curve- the only difference being that Dean throws his 3.5 MPH harder and gets slightly more spin on it.</p><p>The problem is that Noah Dean’s FB/CB combo has very little synergy. They break too early in completely different directions with nearly 18 MPH of velocity separation. As a result, his curveball doesn’t get nearly as many chases as it should. The curve is still tough to hit but it’s not unbeatable by any stretch. You can make this profile work if you have the command to land the curve for called strikes but Dean has below-average control with it and can’t just steal called strikes when they lay off of the obvious pitch. I actually think the curveball plays as below-average right now.</p><p>That is perfectly fine because I’m not expecting Dean in the majors right now. He can learn to add velocity and alter the shape for a few years until it’s a more optimally shaped and harder pitch that can play off of the fastball. Alternatively, he can kill those 10 inches of sweep and make it a true 12–6 curve that actually tunnels with the fastball and would steal souls with 50+ inches of vertical separation (Statcast drop). I still have his breaking ball assigned a plus grade because of the ability to make the ball move even if the exact shape is still in dire need of refinement.</p><p>Noah Dean really struggles with throwing strikes. He walked 14% of batters in his three years at Old Dominion and showed very little progress in that time span. He is never going to be a big strike thrower but it’s possible that with improved breaking ball shape he gets more chases and that artificially cuts the walk rates.</p><p>Noah Dean is an extreme flyball pitcher that magnifies the effects of those walk troubles. He gets popups at a 99th percentile clip and avoids line drives even but there are too many flyballs and not enough command to avoid the heart of the zone. As a result, he will get hammered and give up the long ball somewhat regularly. If he can’t keep traffic off the basepaths then those won’t be solo homers. He’s likely to underperform his peripherals as a result of pairing both walk and homer issues together.</p><p>Noah Dean is best served as a one inning strikeout specialist. He is a one-dimensional reliever who is very good at his one dimension. This is the ideal profile to use when one run costs you the game and you don’t care if he allows one or four- mostly in extra innings. He can get a lot of outs but he will be prone to blowup outings with the one-dimensional profile. There will be years where the homer luck goes his way and he looks like a true relief ace but in general, he’ll be more good than elite. I like Dean in the 4–5th round range.</p><h3>Eric Reyzelman, LSU</h3><p>There is no one in the country who misses more bats in the strike zone than Eric Reyzelman who ran a 42.5% in-zone whiff rate on 569 pitches this year. I could leave his entire blurb as that one stat and it would probably be enough to show you how good Reyzelman is.</p><p>Eric Reyzelman sits at 95.5 MPH with the fastball and touches as high as 98.7 MPH. The pitch has plus feel for spin at 2311 RPMs and is thrown on a 1:00 axis which leads to 18.9&quot; IVB and 13.3&quot; HB. That is plus movement on both planes for Reyzelman’s fastball to go along with plus velocity. It’s an elite offering.</p><p>There is also likely some other element I’m missing considering how absurdly dominant his fastball is despite generic release traits. The fastball has a 43.7% in-zone whiff rate on 206 in-zone swings this year. I really cannot wrap my head around this level of dominance. He throws the fastball 90.7% of the time and is pitching in the zone 47.7% of the time. Neither of those numbers is high enough in all honesty.</p><p>The secondaries are not particularly good. The breaking ball sits at just 77 MPH with -3&quot; IVB and 11.8 inches of sweep. The pitch grades out as below-average. The changeup isn’t much better. He kills velo and spin sitting at 82.9 MPH and 1671 RPMs but the shape is pretty fringe. He gets above-average depth at 5.7&quot; IVB but also only has 7.2 inches of arm side movement.</p><p>The ideal strategy for Reyzelman is just to spam the fastball in the zone and honestly, I think it is very much a viable one. The control is there for the fastball at least and he gets a lot of weak aerial contact. There will always be a vulnerability to the long ball if you are using one pitch as much as Reyzelman uses the fastball but he should punch batters out in bunches if the previous results are any sign and also post very low H/9 (Even if the XBH% is through the roof). It’s a unique relief profile I probably like in the 5th-round range.</p><h3>Mason Fluharty, Liberty</h3><p>Mason Fluharty doesn’t get much attention at Liberty without much in the velocity department but he is one of my favorite relief targets in this year’s class. There are two quality pitches here and he throws strikes with plus out-gen skills.</p><p>The primary pitch is a cutter. He throws it 61.7% of the time and at first glance the specs don’t look like all that. Fluharty sits at just 90.2 MPH and isn’t a big vertical movement guy with only 10.4&quot; IVB. He’s a cutter guy but only slightly with 1.8 inches of cut to his glove side. The spin rates are top notch with him averaging 2497 RPMs but it’s not really relevant when you’re using a fairly gyro-dependent cutter.</p><p>So why does the cutter warrant an above-average grade from me? It all comes down to the release traits. The cutter comes from a 5.17-foot vertical release point which is obviously very low. He also due to the lower slot has a -2.58 release side as a left handed pitcher.</p><p>Fluharty is aggressive in pounding the glove side down with the cutter and to great effect as he possesses a 3.2° HAA as a result which is among the league leaders. The velocity is more than sufficient for a cutter and he misses bats down in the zone while also getting called strikes due to the flatter angle. The cutter had a 37.6% CSW% for Liberty this year.</p><p>I like the cutter but the slider is arguably the calling card for Fluharty. He throws it at 83.4 MPH on average with the same spin rates as the cutter. The slider also benefits from the same unorthodox release in the same ways. The slider has a solid movement profile as well with 5.5&quot; IVB and 13.1&quot; inches of sweep. The interaction with the cutter is incredible as they look the same out of the hand and have a similar enough movement profile to not be obvious even when they break which it is. Even when the location of the two is the exact same there is enough velocity separation that he still won’t get punished.</p><p>Fluharty has the rare ability to land his slider in the zone with some regularity. He doesn’t choose to do it all the time though as he prefers to work it off the glove side for chases. This strategy has a great effect as he is running a 47.4% Chase% with the slider this year.</p><p>Mason Fluharty’s viability is limited against right-handed hitters but he completely decimates fellow lefties. Because of that, he is limited to a low leverage… Or not? The pitch traits of his arsenal suggest he should have major platoon issues but he’s shockingly running major reverse splits in games with trackman. Against right-handed hitters he has a 68.4% groundball rate with a 39.5% CSW%, a 21.1% SwStr%, and 44.4% Chase%. Against lefties, it is just a 29.4% GB% with a 34.6% CSW, a 19.2% SwStr%, and a 32.6% Chase%. Seriously, what the fuck?</p><p>The slider is at 56% chase% against righties when it should be impotent and he has a 43.5% CSW% with it. I suspect this is because he’s throwing fewer waste sliders. He is putting it in the zone 41% of the time and has an average location of 1.9, 0.33 against right-handed bats. He is less disciplined in his slider usage against LHB because he doesn’t have to be. As a result, only 33.8% of them are in the zone and his average slider location is 1.84, 0.78. I don’t really think he’s a reverse platoon split guy but there is definitely some viability against right-handed bats at the very least.</p><p>Mason Fluharty might not have the strikeout ceiling of most of the other names on this list but he creates value in other ways. Fluharty throws a lot of strikes and very rarely walks hitters. He also has a robust batted ball profile with both groundballs and very low line drive rates. There are even some popups when he elevates the cutter. Fluharty is more good than great but he should be a valuable piece of an MLB bullpen by the end of 2024.</p><h3>Andrew Walters, Miami</h3><p>Andrew Walters has been arguably the single most dominant reliever in college baseball over the last two years with a 1.57 ERA in 57 innings but this year especially. He had a 51.2% K% this year and a mere 5% walk rate. He gets a shit ton of popups and has elite run prevention.</p><p>Walters finds so much success by leaning almost exclusively on an elite fastball as he throws said fastball 91.4% of the time. Andrew sits at 96.1 MPH on his heater and can touch as high as 99.4 MPH with spin rates that average 2567 RPMs. He throws on 1:00 axis with 18.8 IVB and 12 inches of arm side tailing action. The pitch misses a lot of bats in the zone and also gets some people to chase.</p><p>The fastball really stands out though because of the arm angle. Andrew Walters pitches from a 5.7 ft vertical release point and a 3.03 ft release side. This helps flatten his VAAs at the top of the zone and helps him do damage with the glove side fastball. This is more of an elite college fastball that dismantles all but the best of hitters than an elite MLB pitch, but there is also 70 upside as he still has some low-hanging spin efficiency improvements in the profile.</p><p>The only other pitch is a mediocre breaking ball he struggles to locate to his glove side. Andrew Walters throws the pitch at 80.3 MPH with -8 IVB and 7 inches of sweep. That actually isn’t a bad profile even if it isn’t exactly a good one and given the arm angle’s effect on his HAA, he should even have a good one in theory. Except, Walters has a very limited feel for his breaking ball. He lands just 11.1% of them in the zone and hasn’t shown any ability to command the pitch to his glove side. I have it as a very loose average offering.</p><p>The control skills are very much present as the walk rates can attest to and it’s hard to see them not remaining as long as the fastball usage remains so high. He should probably cut back a tad on the heaters but whatever. The batted ball leaves a bit to be desired. Walters is a high flyball guy who doesn’t do a great job dodging line drives because his horizontal pitch locations are suboptimal. That is probably a teachable thing so it’s only a 45 grade. I like Andrew Walters in the 5th-round range and grade him very similarly to Eric Reyzelman.</p><h3>Alex McFarlane, Miami</h3><p>Alex McFarland has gotten some run as a starting pitcher but he’s without question a reliever at the next level given the two pitch repertoire and basic control questions. The stuff is there for him to be an impactful one maybe but that is far from a certainty and he’ll never be in that top tier.</p><p>The fastball is thrown very hard. Alexander McFarlane throws his heater at 96.1 MPH on average and can touch as high as 99.2 MPH. That velocity plays down to just 95 MPH because McFarlane averages just 5.66 feet of extension. The pitch also has elite spin rates with him averaging 2671 RPMs on the heater. The pitch is thrown on a 1:30 spin axis and has middling spin efficiency. The end result is just 14&quot; IVB and 13&quot; HB to the arm side.</p><p>The movement profile is in all honesty probably just fine as is. This is because McFarlane throws from a 5.25 feet vertical release point and a 1.91 feet horizontal release point. In a 39 pitch sample with Hawkeye (5/25 at Truist against NCS), his release traits were actually even better as McFarlane averaged just 5.00 RelHeight and 1.83 RelSide. The extension was also up to 6.31 feet on average. Anyways, the result of such a low release is a very flat VAA all the time even with just 14&quot; IVB. Or at least it should be…</p><p>Alex McFarlane makes the creative decision to tactically use his fastball on the bottom edge of the strike zone with an average pitch height of just 2.03 feet. This is why despite premium velocity and naturally strong zone-neutral VAAs, McFarlane has just an 8% Swinging-Strike rate and a 19.1% whiff rate (14.9% in-zone). The CSW% of 29.8% is a little better because fastballs down get called strikes when they have extreme angles but it’s not enough to justify leaving so many whiffs on the table. This is a plus fastball because the inherent upside in the pitch from velo, spin, and release is so high but it plays like a 40–45 right now.</p><p>The slider is also a plus pitch and this one has the results to back it up. The slider has good power at 86 MPH and a good amount of spin at 2795 RPMs on average. The pitch has gyro shape with a very high gyro angle. He gets above-average depth with -0.8&quot; IVB and some bite on the slider but the real draw is the bullet spin that misses bats.</p><p>The slider results speak for themselves. McFarlane posted a 21.4% swinging-strike rate, a 57.1% whiff rate, and a 42.8% CSW% with the slider this year while using the pitch 45.3% of the time. The in-zone whiff rate of 31.3% might honestly be the most impressive part of the gyro slider. He does struggle to throw the pitch for strikes but the pitch still gets chases at a solid 33.7% clip.</p><p>The two pitch combo is very potent but there also might be a third pitch. Alex McFarlane only threw eight changeups in games with pitch tracking this year. That is just 2.4% of the pitches he threw in those games. But the data is actually really interesting behind the pitch and I’ll admit it makes me somewhat intrigued about McFarlane as a starting pitcher. I still think he’s a reliever for now but maybe in a year after you fix some of the fastball issues you can revisit the idea of plopping him in the bullpen.</p><p>The changeup has fantastic velocity separation with him sitting at just 85.7 MPH- 10.4 MPH slower than the fastball. What stands out even more is that he throws it at 1748 RPMs. That is 923 fewer RPMs than the fastball. The pitch also has ridiculous movement in case you were wondering. McFarlane averages 2.9&quot; IVB and 18.3&quot; HB.</p><p>Let’s put some of those numbers into perspective, shall we? That is 82nd percentile drop on his changeup in the MLB. That is 96th percentile horizontal movement for a changeup in the MLB as well. 10.4 MPH of separation is a plus and bordering on elite. Killing over 900 RPMs is outright just an elite amount of spin to remove between the two pitches. This changeup might genuinely have plus stuff. The feel and command are not there obviously but the upside still exists. It’s a 45 projection but it’s a very exciting 45 that could improve greatly in a year.</p><p>The concern with McFarlane is mostly just that he isn’t optimized and that he doesn’t throw enough strikes. There are batted ball defects but there is nothing in the stuff profile that suggests they’ll remain once properly optimized. There are some strike-throwing issues but they aren’t untenable. Alex McFarlane is an electric arm with big stuff and should go on day two of the draft.</p><h3>Nolan McLean, Oklahoma State</h3><p>Nolan McLean gets more fanfare in the media as a third baseman. I, however, prefer McLean on the mound and since this is a reliever blog, I’m only really looking at him in that role here even if the wOBAcons are absolutely absurd.</p><p>Nolan McLean’s primary pitch is like most pitchers, a fastball. He uses the four-seam fastball more often but there is also a two-seam option in his toolbox. The fastball sits at 95 MPH and can touch as high as 97.7 MPH. The feel for spin is exceptional as well at 2345 RPMs as well on a 1:15 axis.</p><p>The fastball movement doesn’t jump off the page with just 16&quot; IVB and 12&quot; HB. What does jump off the page though is the angle Nolan McLean gets with his heater. The fastball comes from a 5.33 ft vertical release height and a 2.76 ft release side. That low release despite below-average vertical movement still gives him plus VAAs at the top of the zone, and as such, it should come as little surprise that McLean’s fastball has a 25% Swinging-Strike rate when thrown in the top half of the strike zone</p><p>The sinker lags behind the four-seam fastball in traits and performance. The sinker is on a 2:00 spin axis and has 11.8&quot; IVB with 16.6&quot; inches of tailing action. The pitch is used mostly against left-handed hitters as a chase pitch and it works amazingly with a 42.9% chase rate against lefties where he throws it 54.5% of the time.</p><p>When he gets them to expand the zone, he either gets whiffs or groundballs with an average launch angle of -0.2° against lefties and a 13% Swinging-strike rate on the sinker. I have no complaints about the fastball deployment and think the two variants strategy for each handedness is very smart and effective. More pitchers should imitate this and alter their pitch shape based on handedness.</p><p>There is also a cutter at 90 MPH. The cutter is probably best described as a bowling ball sinker rather than a cutter as he only actually gets 0.3 inches of cut. The pitch is clearly distinct from either of his fastballs as averages 2762 RPMs on it and throws on a 12:00 axis with very high amounts of gyro spin. The pitch has just 6&quot; IVB and 0.3&quot; inches of cut. He does not miss a ton of bats but I don’t think that’s the goal. He uses it to set up the sinker against left-handed hitters and for weak contact against right-handed ones.</p><p>Nolan McLean’s best pitch is a slider that he currently only uses 6.6% of the time. He sits at 85.3 MPH and has a fantastic feel for spinning the ball averaging 2863 RPMs. That spin is put to good use as the slider has solid movement. 1.8&quot; IVB is exactly the MLB average and 8.3&quot; inches of sweep is as well. That sweep might not sound like a lot but when paired with the fact that he throws from a low slot, McLean has a plus slider due to the angle he gets paired with above-average velocity.</p><p>Nolan McLean rounds out his repertoire with a very sweepy curveball. The curve has elite spin rates, averaging 2997 RPMs which is in the 97th percentile of major leaguers. He throws it moderately hard at 78.7 MPH and has average vertical depth for a curveball at -8.8&quot; IVB.</p><p>The calling card here though is that McLean gets 18.3 inches of sweep on his curve. When you pair that with his arm slot, that is a -5.4° HAA which would be the third steepest HAA in the majors this year and that could improve further with better location. The power isn’t great but it’s probably enough for the slurve to play as above-average at the very least.</p><p>This gives McLean four pitches that likely project as above-average and a fifth average one in the cutter. So why not make McLean a starting pitcher? First off, there are command issues. McLean struggles to throw strikes and while maybe that is a lack of comfort on the mound due to inexperience thing, McLean is also prone to throwing errors at third base so I think it goes deeper than that. I don’t think he’s putrid or anything but it is below-average command.</p><p>The other concern I have with McLean is the lack of weapons he possesses to beat left-handed hitters. The sinker is surprisingly amazing against lefties but he doesn’t throw a changeup and his breaking balls are both dependent on sweep so you can’t expect great performance against lefties. McLean has good outgen skills as a whole but I can’t depend on that translating when he just doesn’t have a swing and miss pitch against lefties at all. Maybe the cutter can become that but it still feels like a relief look to me.</p><p>I also want to mention that Nolan McLean averages just 5.37 feet of extension and that costs him about 2 MPH in effective velocity on all of his pitches. I think the stride length is likely fixable and actually can be mostly attributed to a lack of mound exposure but it does damper some of the stuff profile. I like McLean as a 6th round guy or thereabouts who I would actually develop two-way with an eye on him moving to the pen full-time in a year if the hit tool doesn’t make major strides.</p><h3>Jacob Watters, West Virginia</h3><p>Jacob Watters should be completely unhittable but for whatever reason, he only posted a 6.22 ERA with a 27 K% this year. I don’t want to overvalue the poor performance but it’s baffling to me because the stuff is good on paper and the locations are mostly decent.</p><p>The breaking ball is the calling card here. Jacob Watters throws a curveball at 85.2 MPH on average. He also has -10&quot; IVB on the breaking ball. To make thing even better, it’s a true 12–6 breaking ball with just 3.4 inches of horizontal movement. The only pitch in the major leagues to average as much velocity and vertical movement is Liam Hendriks’ curveball. Tommy Nance is 0.1 MPH away from joining the party as well at the time of me writing this.</p><p>You would expect a curveball with those traits to be absurdly dominant, especially against bad college hitters but that hasn’t been the case this year. The curveball has a 14.6% Swinging-Strike rate against it this year. That is actually below the collegiate average for a curveball. His 46.2% whiff rate is better but not exactly the holy shit pitch you expect it to be. The problems go deeper too. The curve has just a 7.1% in-zone whiff rate. That would be fine if this was some elite chase pitch but a 31.3% chase rate isn’t exactly lighting the world on fire.</p><p>The lack of world-beating performance from the curveball doesn’t make a ton of sense. The release traits should be optimal for a 12–6 curveball. He’s throwing from a 6.2 ft vertical release height and a 1.05 release side. The locations are mostly fine. He’s averaging 1.88 ft vertically and 0.15 horizontally. It’s not like he’s hanging them at the top of the zone or spiking them all in the dirt either. He’s just not getting results? Maybe a lack of fastball synergy? Maybe?</p><p>The fastball is thrown incredibly hard, averaging 95.4 MPH from the right handed side- although that does play down slightly to 94.8 MPH due to him averaging just 5.67 feet of extension. The pitch is also a very high spin-rate offering with Watters averaging 2361 RPMs on a 1:00 spin axis.</p><p>The spin efficiency on the other hand is likely still a work in progress as despite the high spin rates, Watters gets just 15.3&quot; IVB and 7.6&quot; HB on average. Both figures are slightly below the collegiate average for this year. You would still expect the fastball to miss bats though given the velocity. But it doesn’t. Watters has just a 4% Swinging-Strike rate against his fastball with a mere 12.5% whiff rate, and a 9.8% in-zone whiff rate. He just doesn’t miss bats. This isn’t a location thing, Watters only has a 5.1% Swinging-Strike rate on pitches in the top half.</p><p>There is just some unquantifiable element about Jacob Watters that makes him incredibly hittable. The stuff on paper is amazing but the stuff in practice is not up to snuff. He’s not an elite swing and miss guy or an elite called strike guy. He struggles to throw strikes and often gives up hard contact. There is absolutely elite relief upside here but without knowing what exactly is wrong with him, I can’t diagnose if it is fixable. I’ve watched him pitch for an hour and I see no visual hints to what is going on. Maybe he drops the slot slightly on the breaking ball? That doesn’t explain such garbage production though.</p><p>I don’t think the control is hopeless to be clear. Watters lands his fastball for a strike 50% of the time. The walk issues are a result of the curveball not getting chases when he expands the zone with it. If the breaking ball starts to get chases like the data suggests it should then his walks could diminish to manageable levels. Watters has all the ingredients to be great but I can’t advocate for ranking him in the top five rounds without having a plan to get him to produce. A team with a plan can and should take him much earlier than I am willing to consider.</p><h3>Cy Nielson, BYU</h3><p>Cy Nielson is not your typical relief prospect. He doesn’t have big time arm strength or big time movement. The calling card here is a well rounded profile and the ability to make hitters uncomfortable rather than blowing them away with pure stuff.</p><p>Cy Nielson’s fastball is his primary pitch. The fastball sits at just 91.7 MPH with high spin rates as he averages 2407 RPMs on an 11:00 spin axis. The pitch has mostly inefficient movement with 14.1&quot; IVB and 9 inches of arm side run. So why on earth do I have the fastball graded as above-average?</p><p>The fastball angle offered by Cy Nielson is completely unique across all of baseball. Cy pitches from a 5.81 feet vertical release point which is fairly generic. Huh? How is that a unique angle you ask? You forgot that there are two dimensions to the release point. Cy Nielson has an average horizontal release point of -3.69 feet.</p><p>There are only 12 pitchers (out of 579) this year who pitch from a horizontal release that is so wide. Joely Rodríguez is the only one of those 12 with a vertical release point over 5 feet. It’s not supposed to be possible to get his level of horizontal angle from so high up. When you combine the unique release side with Nielson having above-average horizontal action for a four-seam fastball you get a -3.2° HAA. There are only two major leaguers this year with a more extreme HAA. Those two are Tyler Rogers and Penn Murfee.</p><p>The unique fastball angle has led to big-time results for Nielson. He throws his fastball at the bottom of the zone most of the time with an average fastball height of 2.17 feet which is suboptimal for generating swing and misses. Despite that, Nielson has a 14.5% Swinging-Strike rate, a 33.8% whiff rate, a 20.8% in-zone whiff rate, and a 30.1% CSW%. That is pretty damm good for below-average velocity and movement. So what happens if Nielson elevates? Small sample but he has a 22.6% Swinging-Strike rate on fastballs in the top half this year.</p><p>As awesome as the fastball is due to the unique angle, the slider is thousands of times more so. Nielson throws the slider at 83.3 MPH on average with the same general spin rates as the fastball at 2365 RPMs on average. I’d love to say that Nielson throws some crazy sweeper with 20 inches of horizontal movement and as such an HAA of 10° but sadly that is not the case. Cy Nielson throws a gyro slider that plays as a sweeper because of the angle.</p><p>The slider is a solid pitch movement-wise with 0.2&quot; IVB and just 4.3 inches of sweep. Despite the generic movement, and his locating pretty close to the middle with a 0.08 ft average horizontal location, Nielson has a 4.6° HAA. He ranks in the 92nd percentile despite him possessing both below-average sweep and one of the more timidly located sliders. The slider gets both whiffs in the zone and chases at a high clip. This is a second plus pitch in Nielson’s repertoire because of the unique angle his slider offers along with solid power and depth behind the pitch. Given the feel for low-efficiency and the slot, a sweeper is conceivably possible to develop here and I fear for his opponents what Nielson would do to hitters with a sweeper.</p><p>Cy Nielson is consistently throwing strikes right now with both of his pitches. He walked just 5.1% of hitters at BYU this year. There is some violence in the delivery and it’s more command than control but there are foundational skills here for sure and he should avoid walks for as long as Nielson wants to avoid them.</p><p>Cy Nielson also offers an above-average batted ball profile. His fastball down in the zone has consistently been a source of groundball and his unique horizontal approach angles make it all too easy for Nielson to avoid line drives. There is some risk in the profile but he should show solid multi-dimensional out-generation skills. This is theoretically a low ceiling/high floor middle relief target but ceilings are fictional concepts that are often broken overhead. If Nielson’s velocity or something were to jump, Cy Nielson could move into a higher leverage role. I like Nielson in the last few rounds of day two or else early on day three.</p><h3>Eric Adler, Wake Forest</h3><p>If Cy Nielson is the safe high-floor college reliever then Eric Adler is the complete opposite. This is a boom or bust profile with legitimate top-tier relief ace upside but so many problems that could stop that upside from manifesting.</p><p>Eric Adler has the worst command in the entire draft probably. 30.4 of plate appearances ended in a walk or hit by pitch when Adler was on the mound. He had another 14 wild pitches in 21.1 innings at Wake Forest this year. The control is bad enough to make Kyle Barraclough envious. It’s the primary culprit behind his 8.86 ERA this year and it’s not hard to see how that happened to Adler.</p><p>That has not stopped the fastball from roasting all of the opposition for even a second. The fastball has premium velocity behind it. Adler averages 94.7 MPH and his fastball and can touch as high as 98.1 MPH. The fastball has very high spin rates, averaging 2512 RPMs on average. He throws on a 12:45 axis and has okay spin efficiency to boot. The result is 18.7&quot; IVB and 7.3&quot; HB.</p><p>The fastball comes from a fairly generic angle with a 5.84 ft vertical release point and a 2.03 release side. The pitch plays above the natural traits for whatever reason, probably the unorthodox arm action if I had to take a stab at it.</p><p>The fastball is ridiculously dominant in the zone with a 43.9% in-zone whiff rate. To be fair, that’s only a 41 swing sample but the overall numbers aren’t that much worse. A 16.3% Swinging-Strike rate, 46.4% whiff rate, and a 33.8% CSW% are all quite impressive. He can’t throw strikes if his life depended on it and struggles to elevate but the bat missing ability is absolutely there for Adler.</p><p>The curveball is Eric Adler’s best secondary pitch. On paper, it is a fantastic pitch. Adler throws it at 80.4 MPH with a spin rate of 2708 MPH. The movement profile is spectacular with -14.2&quot; IVB and 10.7 inches of sweep. Yet, the curveball only has 12.9% Swinging-Strike rate and a 32.3% CSW%. So what gives?</p><p>Eric Adler is a victim of his lack of command. The curveball is only in the zone 27.6% of the time. Hitters as a result of knowing that 75% of curveballs won’t be in the zone just don’t swing at the curve as a result. The curveball is recognizable as he throws it from a slightly higher slot than the fastball and the two pitches don’t tunnel for very long either way. He’s only getting chases 26.2% of the time and I’m not sure how to make that better without improving his command. It’s a plus pitch on stuff but it doesn’t play that way at all.</p><p>The slider rounds out Adler’s three-pitch repertoire. He sits at 86.2 MPH with high spin rates at 2779 RPMs. The curveball has a high gyro angle and a fairly lame movement profile at 1.4&quot; IVB and 2.2 inches of sweep. The pitch doesn’t actually miss that many bats and like everything else he throws, Adler struggles to find the strike zone with his slider.</p><p>The stuff is legitimately great here but it doesn’t mesh together and he doesn’t have the command for any of them to work on his own. There is a world where the command comes around and he is a legitimate high lever relief ace or even a non-zero chance he’s a quality starter. However, the likely outcome for Adler might not even see him on a major league team. Adler is boom or bust with the bust being a lot more likely than him making a boom.</p><h3>Matt Keating, USC</h3><p>Matt Keating transferred to Southern California this year after previously pitching for Southeast Community College. He’s not performed at an elite level in his first year against real competition but he’s been good and despite his below-average arm strength, does have plus stuff.</p><p>Matt Keating does not throw particularly hard, sitting at just 91.8 MPH and him only getting 5.42 feet of extension causes that to play down to just 90.1 MPH in practice. The pitch is thrown from a fairly unique 6.22 ft vertical release point and with a 0.54 horizontal release point. That offers some unique angles on the fastball and lets tailing action play up against hitters of both-handedness from such a medial release.</p><p>The fastball’s calling card though isn’t angle but the obscene vertical movement. The fastball averages 20.8 IVB and 8.2 inches of horizontal movement to the arm side. Vertical movement plays and so as you would expect, Keating misses a lot of bats with the fastball…</p><p>Or not? Keating only gets whiffs 19.2% of the time and has a 6.9% Swinging-Strike rate. The CSW% is still good because he is getting called strikes but a 31.5% CSW% is not the world-beating results you want to see. So what gives? Keating is throwing his fastball at an average pitch height of 2.21 feet and an average horizontal location of 0.01 feet. That location explains pretty much all of the fastball troubles. Keating can miss bats he’s just not best positioned to do so right now.</p><p>The breaking ball is filthy and easily warrants a plus grade. Keating sits at 82.7 MPH with 2613 RPMs which is plus feel for spin. The calling card here is very high gyro angle and bullet like spin that lets him miss a lot of bats. Matt Keating gets -2&quot; IVB and 3.8 inches of sweep on average. That is premium depth for a gyro ball and the results back it up.</p><p>Keating gets chases 45.8% of the time while running a 22% in-zone whiff rate with his slider. The pitch is fairly split neutral because of the medial release point and can be used against all hitters effectively. Getting the breaking ball in the zone is a work in progress but he still is running a 23.9% Swinging-Strike rate with his slider so he’s doing something right.</p><p>Matt Keating has below-average control (Mostly of the breaking ball) and struggles with giving up hard contact. There is a lot of line drives hit against Keating and he doesn’t get a lot of popups. I think that is at least partially because of location and are fixable issues. It might cost him some groundballs but Keating would seriously benefit from elevating the heater and wrecking hitters up in the zone. The velocity could use a bump to be a real impact reliever but I think even in the low 90s, the stuff will play its way into a middle relief role.</p><h3>Bo Bonds, Louisiana Lafayette</h3><p>I know <a href="https://medium.com/u/85e9bcfb8887">Mason McRae</a> has Bo Bonds possessing the 12th best stuff in the entire nation this year according to his Stuff+ metric but I’m a bit more skeptical. I don’t even think he’s wrong per se about how it should play in college, I just don’t think it will be elite at the next level. It’s still plus stuff but it is by no means transcendent or anything.</p><p>Bo Bonds sits at 92.3 MPH which although that’s subpar is still plenty of velocity to make the right movement profile work. Except, Bonds gets just 5.53 feet of extension so the fastball plays down to 90.8 MPH. That is workable if your goal is an above-average pitch but it’s hard to have an elite pitch in the MLB sitting below 91 MPH. There is limited strength projection here too from his 5&#39;11&quot; frame. Improving the length of the stride is a possible solution to his woes but it doesn’t fix everything by any means.</p><p>The thing that makes Bo Bonds fastball so overpowering even with the limited velocity is that he averages 22.2&quot; IVB. That is a lot of vertical movement, to say the least. It’s not Rodney Boone levels, but it is also 5 MPH harder so you know… The pitch also has 10.6 inches of horizontal movement on average so there is some barrel evading shape as well.</p><p>The angle on the fastball is surprisingly underwhelming for how much movement he gets. The fastball release is high at 6.11 feet on average but not high enough to be outlier shape, instead just high enough to nerf the VAA. The horizontal angle is nothing special either with a 1.50 RelSide. The pitch is amazing when elevated with a 19.4% Swinging-Strike rate against fastballs in the top half but he only throws 47.9% of his fastballs in the top half and that seems to be more of a command issue than a strategical one.</p><p>The curveball earns above-average grades from me although I do have some questions for it to answer. Bo Bonds sits at 77.1 MPH with his breaking ball and it possesses a very promising movement profile. The curve gets -13.6&quot; IVB and 12.2 inches of sweep to his glove side. That is 75th percentile drop on the curve and 80th percentile sweeping action. Really good movement to say the least.</p><p>My concerns with the curve stem from two things. First and foremost, the curveball needs more power and a longer stride. The effective velocity of his curveball is just 75 MPH. You can make a slower curve with bend work iff you have command but Bonds struggles to land his curveball for a strike, only pitching in the zone 34.2% of the time. Hitters are content to watch the curve in college but that can’t be expected to continue against higher-level competition than he faced with the Ragin Cajuns.</p><p>I have too much respect for the movement profiles of the fastball and curveball to not keep Bonds as a top 500 prospect in spite of the concerns with the profile. Bo Bonds doesn’t have an obvious route to more velocity but velocity is very much teachable. The impact of Bonds right now is slim but he can take his time in the minors and be a respectable middle reliever in a few years&#39; time.</p><h3>Jacob Hasty, LSU</h3><p>My feelings surrounding Jacob Hasty are complicated. He originally was put on my radar because of an interesting sinker but the sinker had a 17.2% CSW% this year and uh yeah. That being said, I still really like Hasty because his sweeper is something that is more at home in a porn magazine.</p><p>The sinker originally caught my attention because of the arm angle he offers. The sinker comes from a 5.89 ft vertical release point and more impactfully, a 0.43 ft horizontal release. For a lefty with such a vertical arm slot, a sinker should dominate on the arm side of the plate. Especially when you also have above-average tailing action at 14 inches of that to go along with 9.7&quot; IVB.</p><p>The velocity is poor. Hasty sits at 91 MPH out of the pen and tops out at 93.8 MPH but even those figures are overrating how useful his velocity is. Jacob Hasty has a completely terrible extension, he averages just 5.12 feet of it and as such the effective velocity is just 89.4 MPH. This is probably why the sinker is so ineffective.</p><p>Actually, let’s think about that. Is the sinker actually ineffective? The 17.2% CSW% is obviously putrid- there are only 11 pitches thrown 100+ times at the MLB level in 2022 at the time of me writing this (1095 Qualifiers) with a lower CSW% than Hasty’s sinker. But what if we’re looking at this the wrong way? Michael Wacha is one of those 11 with his sinker. That sinker has just a 13.8% CSW% but you want to know the crazy thing? Wacha has the third best RV/100 on a sinker in the entire MLB (Min 40 PA) at -3.7.</p><p>There is more than one way to skin a dog (I refuse to support skinning cats) after all, what if Hasty’s goal isn’t to miss bats or get strikeouts with his sinker? What if his goal like Wacha is to maximize how often his opponent swings and generate weak contact on all swings? Spoiler alert but that is exactly his goal.</p><p>Jacob Hasty isn’t Wacha obviously but does get swings with the sinker 50.4% of the time while throwing the sinker in the zone at a below-average 41.7% clip. The sinker gets chases to the arm side regularly with a 34.8% chase rate.</p><p>Hasty has an elite batted ball profile with an average launch angle against him of just -0.4° and he had a 100th percentile groundball rate in 2021 and again he’s done that in 2022. He avoids the sweet spot with just a 23.8% Sweet-Spot% against him and against mostly SEC hitters, a third of his batted balls have an exit velocity below 80 MPH.</p><p>Hasty isn’t conventional but his sinker is still a fine pitch even with a putrid CSW%. The velocity isn’t ideal but he’s a lefty with funky stuff and I’ll still put an average grade on the sinker. If he starts throwing harder it’ll quickly become above-average.</p><p>This sinker deployment strategy wouldn’t work near as well as it does for Hasty if he didn’t have an elite swing and miss pitch. Enter the plus or better sweeper that logged a 46.1% CSW% even while he threw it 50.5% of the time this year. There is not a single pitch in the majors comparable to Hasty’s sweeping curveball.</p><p>The slurve sits at 82.2 MPH with an average spin rate of 2693 RPMs. That is 87th percentile velocity for a curveball and 82nd percentile spin rate. The pitch has even better movement somehow with -10.1&quot; IVB. That is 7% more drop than the average curveball which leaves Hasty with 80th percentile vertical movement on his curveball. He also has 90th percentile sweep on the curveball. There is no pitch in all of baseball with as much velocity, vertical movement, and sweep. There is no one even particularly close in all three. This is a unicorn pitch.</p><p>I do think the sweeper will play a bit below the eye-popping raw specs in practice. The arm slot works miracles on the sinker but it does flatten his HAA to just 2.1° on the slurve which is actually below-average despite 90th percentile sweep. The pitch plays less like a slurve and more of a true curve than the shape would indicate. The pitch is a plus but it probably isn’t the wow best pitch ever vibes it gives off.</p><p>Jacob Hasty has control problems that might be by design and they don’t really bother me all that much. Walks matter a lot less when you constantly get groundballs and as a result, he gets double plays as Hasty does. Hasty limits XBH risk as well which is probably more important. He does this with consistently elite line drive avoidance and a total lack of pulled flyballs. As such, the walks aren’t that relevant in a relief role. The important thing is weak contact with the sinker and strikeouts with the slurve. Hasty probably needs more velocity to be more than a middle reliever but as is, I’m pretty confident that he can at least be a solid option out of the pen.If he finds an uptick in power and starts throwing harder then the sky is the limit.</p><h3>Graham Firoved, Virginia Tech.</h3><p>Graham Firoved is a one-pitch wonder kid without fantastic arm strength as he only averages 91.9 MPH with his fastball and tops out at 94.5 MPH. But Firoved doesn’t have to remain a one-pitch wonder as despite throwing the fastball 92.2% of the time, the second pitch shows serious promise.</p><p>The fastball is special though make no mistake about that. The velocity might be slightly underwhelming but he more than makes up for that in other ways. Graham Firoved throws his fastball on a 12:15 spin axis with an average spin rate of 2583 RPMs. The pitch has close to perfect spin efficiency and that leads to an astonishing 21.9&quot; IVB on the four-seam fastball.</p><p>I’m sorry, that was a complete lie. Firoved technically averages 21.9&quot; IVB but that technical average is wrong. Virginia Tech.’s trackman in their home stadium is badly miscalibrated. The average Virginia Tech pitcher gets 2.83&quot; more IVB on the road than at home, or if you prefer, 16% more IVB on the road than at home with their four-seam fastball. Because of this miscalibrated trackman, when I refer to pitch movement for Firoved in the future, I will exclusively use his numbers in road games.</p><p>Graham Firoved is averaging 23.9&quot; IVB on road games. That feels like a typo but somehow isn’t one. If you just apply the standard adjustment to his home numbers instead of trusting the smaller sample road numbers he still has 23.9&quot; IVB- if you use the percentage instead then it’s an even more ridiculous 24.4&quot; IVB. The fastball has the most vertical movement of any pitch thrown at 90+ MPH in the entire country once you adjust for the broken home trackman. The movement is beyond absurd.</p><p>The fastball does not stand out for anything but the vertical movement. The pitch comes from a 6.2 ft vertical release height and a 1.4 ft horizontal release point. The extension is below-average as well and he only gets 4.1 inches of tail. Do you honestly care about that? He has 23.9&quot; IVB and decent velocity. Nothing else matters when you have that movement profile.</p><p>Graham Firoved does his best to put that philosophy to the test. His average fastball is right in the heart of the plate. He throws it at an average pitch height of 2.48 ft and an average pitch side of 0.01 feet. That is basically the heart of the plate. He still dominates with a 15.8% Swinging-Strike rate against the fastball, and a 26.8% in-zone whiff rate. A reminder that is overusing this pitch as much as humanly possible with a 92.2% usage rate. It just does not matter because the movement dominates no matter what.</p><p>What would happen if he located the fastball more optimally? Firoved has a 23.2% swinging-strike rate on pitches in the top half of the zone. 23.2%! Hypothetically what would happen if he adds a tick to his fastball? On 72 pitches at 93+, Firoved had a 23.6% Swinging-Strike rate even while pumping them down the dick on a regular. This fastball is an elite pitch because the movement is so absurd nothing else matters at this level. He will need to locate some in the majors but he hasn’t had to yet.</p><p>Graham Firoved doesn’t use it often but the slider is his only secondary and it shows some promise. The pitch sits at 81.5 MPH with an average spin rate of 2676 RPMs. The pitch has good movement with -1.1&quot; IVB and 11 inches of sweeping action. That is 77th percentile sweep and 77th percentile drop as well. The pitch has decent enough velocity and obvious bat missing potential. The feel isn’t there- in large part because of a lack of exposure and as such it doesn’t perform but there is real upside here.</p><p>Graham Firoved has a minor walk problem and I’m not sure why that is. He fills the zone at an above-average rate and gets chases with the fastball. He doesn’t get cute with location but just pounds the fastball down the middle. He shouldn’t have the walk problems he has had.</p><p>The batted ball problems make loads of sense. He’s throwing a fastball down the middle 92.2% of the time. Of course, he’ll give up a lot of hard-hit flyballs and line drives. He also gets a lot of popups which makes it manageable but doesn’t redeem him. Firoved is very much a one-trick pony as is which is why he’s only a 35 FV but that one trick is so electric that Firoved might still be awesome in spite of being so one-dimensional.</p><h3>Tyler Legere, Lipscomb</h3><p>Tyler Legere is the least likely player in this blog to get drafted. He’s not your conventionally good reliever but he’s a very fun one who has a lot of funk and should serve a role of some sort in the majors one day.</p><p>The sinker sits at 83.7 MPH and maxes out at just 85.8 MPH. I realize that sounds terrible but allow me a chance to explain why I like Legere even with literally zero velocity. Tyler Legere has an effective velocity of 82.9 MPH. Do you get it now? Total game-changing velocity. In all seriousness, the movement profile is pretty fantastic with Legere averaging 3.4&quot; IVB and 16.2 inches of horizontal movement on the sinker.</p><p>Tyler Legere makes himself a notable name in the draft because he offers a completely unique look on the mound. He’s a very low riding sidearmer with an uncomfortable delivery to time and unique release traits. He throws from a 3.33 ft vertical release point and a 4.21 ft horizontal release.</p><p>Only four pitchers in the majors have a lower vertical release point than Tyler Legere. Those four are Tyler Rogers, Adam Cimber, Tim Hill, and Joe Smith. Only four plays have a higher (Absolute Value) horizontal release point. Those four are Tyler Rogers, Aaron Loup, Scott Effross, and Jose Cuas. Out of 1819 qualified college arms in the sample, Legere has a lower vertical release point than all but 8 of them. He has a wider horizontal release than all but six of them. It’s a completely unique angle for Legere that lets the low velocity sinker play.</p><p>He’s not quite Tyler Rogers but guys like Joe Smith, Scott Effross, and Adam Cimber make sitting the low-mid eighties work due to their arm angles. I think Legere might be able to follow in their footsteps and find success without anything resembling velocity.</p><p>The sinker obviously misses zero bats but he’s a groundball machine with the sinker down in the zone. He has a 63.4% groundball rate this year in games with Trackman this year which is obviously elite. I also think the occasionally elevated fastball (Possibly spit it into two pitches and prioritize vertical movement on the second) would fuck people up like Adam Cimber’s does just because of how flat the VAA is up in the zone. Even with an average pitch height of 2.09 feet, he has an MLB average VAA of -4.93°. The sinker is a below-average pitch but if he sits closer to 86 MPH then I would fully buy-in on it as at least average I don’t think that’s too tall of an ask.</p><p>The breaking ball is amazing even if he’s painfully lacking in power as he only sits at 72.9 MPH on average. He has 3.8&quot; IVB and 19.7&quot; HB which is an elite movement profile for a slider if you ignore the velocity limitations. That is in the 99th percentile of breaking ball sweep (As a slider, curve, or both combined) and it’s a pure sweeping slider with below-average drop. It comes from the same tunnel as the sinker and runs as far in the other direction as is humanly possible.</p><p>The same slider with 99th percentile sweep is also being thrown from what would be the fifth widest horizontal release side in the entire MLB this year. The result is his slider possesses a -6.9° HAA. The highest (Absolute Value) HAA on a pitch in the majors this year is just 6.4° on Scott Effross’ slider. The gap between Legere and Effross is the size of the gap between Effross and the 13th most extreme HAA pitch in the majors this year. Legere laps the field in slider angle. I have it as a plus pitch even with zero velocity behind it because that angle just makes him unhittable.</p><p>Tyler Legere aggressively fills the zone with his sinker and is also capable of landing the slider for a strike. He gets chases at a high rate with both pitches and should limit walks even in the majors- if only because he won’t reach that many three-ball counts before allowing weak contact. The draw here is absolutely the batted ball profile. It’s a lot of groundballs with very few line drives and a lot of pitches that he weakly rolls over. Legere won’t miss bats and is far from big-league ready right now but I think he can be a dependable reliever in a few years as a funky guy out of the pen who doesn’t look sexy in terms of peripherals but consistently runs low ERAs. There is probably a slight velocity hike required to get there but I’m optimistic in the chance of at least a small bump.</p><h3>Michael Prosecky, Louisville</h3><p>Michael Prosecky has some pretty big fans in the scouting community but I don’t consider myself one of them. He’s a one-pitch wonder kid and that one pitch isn’t even necessarily an elite pitch.</p><p>That one pitch is, of course, the fastball. Michael Prosecky sits at 93.5 MPH with his heater and can really spin it with an average spin rate of 2342 RPMs. He throws the fastball on a 11:00 spin axis with high efficiency and the result is Prosecky averaging 19.8 IVB and 9 HB. Prosecky is the rare college arm who actually elevates his fastball with regularity too as he throws it on average at 2.82 feet vertically and 0.22 feet horizontally. He’s a lefty too.</p><p>So why am I not convinced it’s an elite pitch? That 93.5 MPH velocity sounds nice but it’s brought down by him only averaging 5.7 feet of extension which leads to his effective velocity only playing at 92 MPH. In addition, that vertical movement is fantastic but it’s slightly undermined by a 6.2 ft release height that causes him to only have a -5° VAA despite the ability to elevate his fastball.</p><p>For all the hype that the fastball gets, the results are more in line with a 50–55 grade pitch than an elite one. Prosecky throws his fastball 75% of the time to limited success. He has a solid 11.9% Swinging-Strike rate and 23% whiff rate. He misses bats just 16.7% of the time in the zone though although at least his fastball gets chases 30.9% of the time.</p><p>The main problem here is that hitters are very aggressive in swinging at the in-zone fastball from Prosecky with an 81.1% Z-Swing%. He gets very few called strikes and as a result, only has a 24% CSW% this season. The pitch has obvious potential given the feel for vertical movement and above-average velocity but it still needs a lot of work to get across the finish line.</p><p>Michael Prosecky is also severely lacking in quality secondary pitches. The breaking ball is slow and ineffective. He sits at just 74.8 MPH and throws it with solid movement on two-planes. The pitch has -10.1 IVB and 13 inches of sweep, both of which are above-average. The problem is just the velocity.</p><p>Prosecky has a 42.9% CSW% against the curve but it’s the definition of fools gold. Prosecky only has an 8.6% Swinging-Strike rate with the curveball and just a 13.2% chase rate with it as well. Called strikes are a real skill but in this case, I’m pretty confident they are not one. Prosecky only throws the curve in the zone 35.2% of the time. He gets so many called strikes because bad hitters only swing at 32.4% of his in-zone curveballs. Against, competent hitters that won’t fly. There is a feel for spin and solid shape so if you improve the velocity you might have something but right now this is a fringe pitch.</p><p>I don’t really like the changeup but it’s certainly better than the breaking ball. He does not use it all that often at only 5.4% use but it has been his top whiff pitch in that smaller sample size. He throws it at 85.5 MPH- 8 MPH slower than the fastball and kills a little over 400 RPMs off the heater. He then throws the changeup on a 10:00 spin axis and that leads to 12.4 IVB and 14.1 HB.</p><p>That isn’t a good movement profile to be clear. 12.4 IVB is too much lift for the idealized changeup and 14.1 inches of tail is fairly average. He still struggles to land the changeup for strikes with only 31.3% of them being in the zone and he often gets firm with the pitch. The changeup is a long term average projection that is well below that right now. I’m not expecting it to be a high impact pitch but it is the second quality offering Prosecky has desperately needed all year long.</p><p>Michael Prosecky also has control problems to further compound his struggles. He fills the zone at a below-average rate with every one of his pitches and only has average chase rates overall. He walked 13.3% of batters this year and that is unfortunately not a new development.</p><p>Michael Prosecky also has a bit of a line drive problem and an extremely aerial batted ball profile that could lead to future problems with the long ball. I think Prosecky is likely to settle in as a middle reliever and there is obvious upside here but he’s far from solved and I typically prefer my relief prospects to be more finished than this. He’s an interesting day three target, in my opinion, but I’m not going to be the one to advocate for drafting him any earlier on.</p><h3>Dylan Ray, Alabama</h3><p>Dylan Ray is actually the reason why I added this blog to my draft week content. I found him utterly fascinating but he had too many flaws despite the incredible stuff to actually grade him any higher than a 35 FV. I feel that way about a lot of relievers but when Ray was like the 5th guy in 24 hours, I felt that way about, I decided I’d just make a piece talking about all my favorite future middle relievers.</p><p>The fastball is a great pitch. He sits at 93.2 MPH and can touch as high as 97.8 MPH in short bursts. The fastball has plays down a tick as Ray only has 5.93 feet of extension but 92.6 MPH effective velocity is still good for the level. The real draw of the fastball though is the fact that he throws it on a 12:30 spin axis with an average spin rate of 2319 RPMs and very high spin efficiency spin efficiency. As a result, Ray gets 20.1 IVB on average.</p><p>The fastball is made even more interesting by his unique release point. Dylan Ray throws his fastball from an average release height of 6.52 feet. He also has a pretty vertical slot with an average release side of just 1.25 feet. That high release and elite vertical movement combination will make his VAAs quite poor on paper but this is enough movement that the high release is arguably a boon.</p><p>I was going to just use a JP Feyereisen or something as a proof of concept but instead, I stumbled across the most accurate pitch comp of all time. Nick Pivetta throws his fastball from a vertical release that is 0.07 ft higher and his horizontal release is 0.18 ft wider. The fastball sits at 93.3 MPH, just 0.1 MPH more than Ray’s heater. The pitch is thrown with a 2320 RPMs spin rate- just one RPM higher than Ray.</p><p>The fastball is also thrown on a 12:30 axis (Same as Ray) with 97% spin efficiency. The fastball as a result has the exact same 5.1 inches of tailing action and Pivetta gets 0.5 inches more vertical movement on his heater with 20.6 IVB. Nick Pivetta’s fastball is literally the best pitch in the MLB according to Baseball Savant Run Value at the time of me writing this. Seems like that should mean positive things for Dylan Ray.</p><p>The fastball doesn’t perform as it can though despite elite shape and solid velocity because he doesn’t locate the pitch optimally. Dylan Ray opts to pitch down with the fastball most of the time. His average pitch height is just 2.36 feet. Only 40.8% of his four-seam fastballs are thrown in the top half of the strike zone. This is especially unfortunate because Ray has a 16.9% Swinging-Strike rate on pitches in the top half. When Ray misses right now with the fastball he usually misses up and leaves the fastball down the middle. If he were to elevate the heater, most of the misses would be balls, not home runs as well so I think the gains would be two-fold of elevating.</p><p>Ray also suboptimally locates his fastball horizontally. From a medial release he should be working his fastball to the arm side constantly to get chases and whiffs on the inner third. The fastball has a 17% swinging-strike rate on pitches on the right third of the plate (His arm side) but he throws 46% more fastballs to his glove side (11.6% Swinging-Strike rate) than the arm side.</p><p>Ray is aggressive when it comes to throwing strikes, with a 52.8% zone-rate with his fastball this year. He manages to steal a lot of called strikes on the bottom of the edge due to the combination of a steep plane and vertical movement. He has a CSW% of 36.7% with the heater despite just a 12.4% Swinging-Strike rate because he gets so many called strikes. I don’t really think this will translate though as right now low level hitters are content to just not swing (59.8% Z-Swing%) but that will change against better bats and will expose the folly of spamming the low strike as often as Ray does.</p><p>There are two distinct breaking balls and both of them look like good pitches. The slider is the more often used and probably better of the two. He throws it at 85 MPH with heavy amount of gyro angle. The pitch gets just 1.3 IVB and 1.4 inches of cut. The impressive part is how it plays off the fastball and misses so many bats.</p><p>The pitch comes from the same tunnel with little horizontal deviation (An inconsistent axis means some sliders have arm side movement) and a very comparable horizontal location. The pitch just drops an extra 27 inches in exchange for taking off 8 MPH. It has bullet spin and the results speak for themselves. The slider has an obscene 35.7% whiff rate in the strike zone and Ray can throw it for strikes consistently with a 46% zone rate this year. The pitch also gets chases 34% of the time and kind of just dominates the competition in every manner. Plus pitch for sure.</p><p>You probably want a bit more velocity on the slider. Even if that velocity comes at the expense of the vertical depth, it’s likely a worthwhile tradeoff. Adding power would enhance the tunneling ability significantly. Right now the slider works because he’s pitching down with the fastball but elevating the fastball might ruin its deception unless he adds more velocity or something of the sort in its place.</p><p>The curveball lags a tiny bit behind the other two plus offerings but is still a solid pitch in its own right. Dylan Ray sits at 78.5 MPH and can spin it with spin rates that sit at 2545 RPMs on average. The pitch has elite vertical depth with -15.9 IVB and a solid sweeping shape as well with 10.5 inches of that. There are only two curveballs with as much vertical movement, horizontal movement, and velocity. Those two belong to Framber Valdez and Seth Lugo.</p><p>The curveball has a very unique vertical approach angle. There is only one pitcher in baseball who gets as much vertical depth on their curve with as high of a release as Dylan Ray does. That player is, of course, Nick Pivetta who gets -19 IVB with 7.8 inches of sweep on his 77 MPH curveball. Dylan Ray has a very steep VAA and that steep VAA along with the medial release should lead to a lot of chases out the bottom of the zone and a lot of called strikes when he lands the pitch in the zone.</p><p>At the present fixture in time, that is not the case. The -10.2° VAA is in the 69th percentile but it’s a mockery of what Dylan Ray’s curveball could be. The curve is thrown higher in the zone than the fastball on average. That is not hyperbolic, Ray throws his curveball with an average pitch height 0.005 feet higher than the average fastball. That leads to his VAA playing way down and a lot of hanging curveballs are hit hard. To his credit, Ray is still running a 33.3% CSW% with the pitch but it really could be so much more if he just let it do its thing.</p><p>Dylan Ray is very much a control over command arm thus far in his career. He is an aggressive strike thrower but his locations are imprecise and ineffective so it causes major batted ball defects. Ray is a heavy flyball pitcher and that will likely only get more extreme if he elevates the fastball.</p><p>There will always be some homer risk but the goal is to supplement it with more strikeouts and popups; also less hard contact because Ray has a 40.5% hard-hit rate against him this year. This is probably a middle relief look but I really like the three pitch combo and think there is high leverage upside with intelligent player development.</p><p>I know I promised that I wouldn’t list any conversion arms here but after a conversation with a scout employed by an MLB team, I’ve talked myself into looking at Dylan Ray as a possible starting pitcher option. Yes, he lacks the changeup but the FB/CB combo should be enough to beat lefties if he gains some semblance of command. The delivery is relatively low effort and he has solid athleticism.</p><p>On top of the aforementioned similarities to Nick Pivetta’s fastball and curve, he throws his slider at the same speed with a somewhat similar movement profile. It’s not a perfect comp by any means but it’s close enough for an actual comp to Pivetta? Nick Pivetta is a quality starting pitcher using the same 3 pitches that Ray has 97.5% of the time. Can I really knock Ray that heavily for not using a changeup 2.5% of the time? I don’t think I can. I think Ray has a real chance to start in the minors at the very least and I’ve bumped him to a 40 FV because of it.</p><p><em>Thanks for reading! Tomorrow is the draft and we’ll tackle the penultimate piece of draft content in my Mock Draft! If you missed it, </em><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/mlb-draft-top-500-prospects-fba9fe7fceaf"><em>I released my top 500 draft prospects yesterday</em></a><em>. Make sure to check it out.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3c8239930dc6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[MLB Draft Top 500 Prospects]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/mlb-draft-top-500-prospects-fba9fe7fceaf?source=rss-f20e8b3389a4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fba9fe7fceaf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[rankings]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb-draft]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[draft]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tieran Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Jul 2022 18:01:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-15T18:01:26.006Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U7Fxq2u3r1q7WnO2SBN8Og.png" /></figure><p>With the MLB Draft only a few days away it is time for my first and only full draft board. I’ve tweeted out small snippets of the board over the last few months as I go through the process but this will be the only time I actually break down players in-depth and dive into what really makes them tick.</p><p>Usually, this is where I would put a disclaimer about not having sources or access to the data that most draft analysts do. That is not the case this year as I was kindly given access to the entire trackman database for college baseball. Not only that, but I was also given the pitch data for 170 pitchers who participated in the summer showcase circuit. I even had conversations with a few area scouts, team employees, agents, and even draft prospects themselves about players. I’ve had multiple players reach out to me asking for a write-up on them. This draft season has been beyond my wildest dreams.</p><p>This is the first time I’ve ever had full access and as such, I am a lot more confident in my player analysis and I was able to scout a lot more players. My rankings are more driven by pure data this year than in years past as a result but there is still a large weight on video analysis of every player and projection beyond the raw data.</p><p>Obviously, I won’t be covering all 500 players with the usual amount of depth I put into these things. I broke Medium with my compendium; that was barely even a third of the players I plan to include in this piece. This piece will only cover in the full depth you see on the Compendium, all of the players I have a 55+ FV on. Those are instant top 100 prospects coming out of the draft.</p><p>The 50 FVs, are the rest of the players I have a first-round grade on. In theory, I will write about five paragraphs or thereabouts on the players in that tier. Then for the 45 FVs- that is players I have a 2nd or 3rd round grade on, they will get just two paragraphs breaking them down. For everyone else, I will provide a link to a spreadsheet at the end of this article with all my unedited notes on the last 385 players. There are over 150,000 words of brand new original content on there so there is still lots more to read after this.</p><p>I’m sure you have questions about my draft philosophy, or what some of the stats I use mean, and why I value them the way I do. I already answered most of those questions two days ago in this post. I also have more detailed writeups on some of the top seniors that I posted yesterday and you can read. I also broke down some of the underperforming players you will see on this list- particularly on the college side. You can read about them in more depth here. If you want more detail on why I valued a reliever the way I do, I’m publishing a piece where I go in-depth on them tomorrow.</p><p>Anywho, without further preamble, here is my ranking of the top 500 players in the 2022 MLB First Year Player Draft:</p><p><em>Strike zone parameters are based on height for hitters. For pitchers, I assume every opposing hitter is 6&#39;1&quot;</em></p><h3>60 FVs</h3><h4>1. CF Andruw Jones Jr., Wesleyan High School</h4><p>Andruw Jones Jr. is pretty much the consensus top player in the draft. He’s been a popular name for a while because of who his father is but he’s come on strong in the last year and established himself independent of his bloodlines as the premium talent at #1.</p><p>Andruw Jones Jr. doesn’t really have a carrying tool, you could argue any of his tools are his best tool, in fact. That is what makes Andruw Jones Jr. so special, the fact that all of his tools have very real plus upside. There was only one prospect on my preseason top 100 who plays a premium position and was at least a 60 in everything (Except eye). That player is Michael Harris II (Corbin Carroll was half a grade short on arm) who I had as my #15 prospect in the MLB before the season and he’s proven worthy of that ranking with his hot start to 2021 that has now carried him all the way to the majors.</p><p>Andruw Jones Jr. is in that same tier of prospect as Harris II. Harris gets the slight edge due to his proximity but Jones Jr. is only inches behind and is a top 20 prospect in the sport with his well-rounded blend of pluses across the board. If he has a strong debut season in Low A after being drafted he could rise even higher before I release next year’s list.</p><p>He’s the best draft prospect since Adley Rutschman and should go #1 unless there are ridiculous savings to be made by taking another top-five talent at #1. I have sources confirming that at least two of the other players in my top five will offer pretty much no extra savings at #1 so that seems doubtful.</p><p>Andruw Jones Jr. has plus contact skills. He whiffed just 18.5% of the time during the summer showcase games in MLB stadiums and struck out just 6.2% of the time in his senior season at Wesleyan in which he won the State Championship. There’s so much more to the contact skills than just the whiff rates though.</p><p>Andruw Jones Jr. has a flat bat path that is geared towards making contact. He’s got a compact and simple swing he can easily repeat and does often repeat. The barrel gets in the zone early and lives there for a good while which gives him a longer window of opportunity than most hitters have. He has a quiet load without much risk of getting tied up and it’s just going to result in a lot of contact as it always had. There are zero problems with velocity and he shows enough breaking ball recognition to not raise any concerns even if it’s not a standout skill at this point. There’s minimal risk in the swing being exposed as he climbs the ladder.</p><p>The contact quality is honestly just as impressive if not more so than the contact quantity. I’m not even talking about his ability to hit power here but just the ability to hit the ball at optimal launch angles. Druw Jones hits the ball at optimal flight paths at a ridiculously high rate and combines it with hard contact.</p><p>Andruw rarely mishits balls in both the form of popups and the useless super low launch angle groundballs. Jones Jr. shows elite barrel accuracy as well with very high line drive rates in both showcase games against top competition and in regular high school play.</p><p>He has a flatter bat path that allows him to hit with more backspin than a lot of his peers but still puts the ball in the air and has such optimal launch angles because of good his attack angles are. He goes the other way consistently and that also helps the BABIP profile. Druw does damage on contact even independent of his power.</p><p>Let’s make no mistake, Druw Jones has plus raw power and actually a little more on top of that. I have it graded as a 65 and you could argue that’s a tad conservative. The bat speed is electric with top-tier bat speed but honestly, the 90th percentile showings are underselling him. Of the thousands of perfect game showcase participants over the last however many years, Druw Jones has the second-highest impact momentum ever. That is the speed of the bat at contact adjusted for the weight of the bat. It’s a literal measure of how much force Andruw Jones Jr. exerts when he makes contact.</p><p>Andruw Jones Jr. has elite power upside. The ability is there to put the ball in the air at a good enough rate and he hits the ball stupid hard. He has great hip-torso separation in his swing to go with electric bat speed and there is plenty of projection left in his thin 6&#39;4&quot; 180 lbs frame. You can easily imagine him growing into elite raw power without much squinting required.</p><p>So why is the game power so much worse than his raw power? Andruw Jones Jr. struggles to pull the ball in the air. This wasn’t meant to be a comp when I first mentioned him, and still is not one, but Michael Harris II amusingly has that exact same issue holding him back from fully manifesting his elite raw power in games.</p><p>Jones Jr.’s ability to hit the ball the other way with authority is borderline prodigious. He does lose something going the other way like 99% of players do but he still posts above-average exit velocities when hitting it the other way. Even still, it’s a really narrow road to being an impact power hitter without pulling the ball at all.</p><p>My understanding is that the issues with pullside contact are less due to timing and more due to how closed off his stance is but I’m not at all sure about that. The fact that the barrel enters the zone so early probably doesn’t help either because it turns what would be whiffs or foul balls for most hitters when he’s late on something into a ball to the other field.</p><p>That isn’t even necessarily a bad thing but if you are looking for nits to pick about Jones Jr. then here is one of the very few there are- he’s maybe trading contact quality for quantity. This is also generally speaking one of the easier power optimizations to make if the hitter is willing so it’s not really a long-term obstacle at his age.</p><p>The bat is obviously what is going to make Andruw Jones Jr. a star but what makes him the near consensus #1 talent in the draft class is that he pairs the plus bat with one of the best gloves in the class. He’s a no doubt centerfielder even as he bulks up and while he won’t ever be his father, he could still be amazing out there.</p><p>There are some scouts who want to see if Andruw Jones Jr. can handle shortstop and I don’t even think they’re wrong about him being able to handle it. Druw is an incredible athlete with a relentless work ethic and could absolutely learn to play an adequate shortstop.</p><p>But why would you ever want that? Putting Andruw Jr. at shortstop means waiting for the glove to develop and in order to do that, you have to move him much slower than the bat will dictate. You risk stalling his offensive development to take a gamble on him being a good enough shortstop to move him away from the premium position he already offers plus defense at. The reward is potentially massive sure but the risk is way too high for me to give it real consideration.</p><p>I’ll be perfectly content leaving Andruw Jones Jr. in centerfield where he projects as a plus defensive option. Jones Jr. has elite speed with a blazing 6.31 second 60 yard dash in the perfect game showcase. His shuttle times and 10 second splits were just as elite in showcases and really show how multi-dimensional his speed is. He has an explosive first step and covers a ton of ground in centerfield.</p><p>There is more to his defensive ability than just range, however. Druw Jones is an acrobat in centerfield who makes spectacular plays on the regular. He’s not afraid to climb to wall and snag homeruns or lay out to make the diving catch. He plays with reckless abandon and it’s spectacular to watch.</p><p>He also pairs his elite defensive abilities with a 70 grade arm that baseball America coined as the best in the entire draft a few months ago and I’m inclined to agree (amongst outfielders). He’s not quite his father defensively but he’s probably the best defensive centerfielder in the draft and one of the best in the entire minors from the day he’s drafted. There is still some polishing but not a lot to be done defensively. The glove will always be ready for the next step in centerfield and the bat can solely determine his developmental pace.</p><p>This feels absurd to say about a prep player but there is a pretty high chance that Andruw Jones Jr. has five 55 grade or higher tools in his prime. There i an very easily foreseeable path to all of them individually reaching at least a 60. I could make a somewhat convincing argument that any any of them warrant a 70 grade on their own.</p><p>Players with this balance of tools don’t really exist. There is a multitude of optimization paths for Jones Jr. to reach his upside and that makes him safer than most prep bats- even the ones of comparable caliber.</p><p>Jones Jr. isn’t quite perfection incarnate but he’s a few adjustments to the game power away (And a track record of high level production) from quite possibly being perfect. If Elijah Green didn’t exist it would be easy to argue Jones Jr. has the highest ceiling in the draft but instead he has to only settle for a close second. He’s the top talent in the draft and all else being equal should hear his name called first on draft day.</p><h4>2. CF Elijah Green, IMG Academy</h4><p>If James Wood hadn’t turned into a god this year then there’s a good chance that Elijah Green would be considerably lower on this list. Fortunately for Green, Wood has been so successful after I was confident he wouldn’t be able to make enough contact to profile at all has forced a much-needed re-evaluation of how I scout the hit tools of prep players.</p><p>Elijah Green whiffs a lot. There is no questioning that fact. He struck out over 30% of the time in his tenure at IMG Academy and whiffed 39.2% of the time in the Hawkeye showcase games (68 pitch sample so grain of salt). The whiffs are concerning for sure but he cut his strikeout rate from 34.7% in 2021 to 20.4% this year. The why behind the strikeouts is what matters and it has me believing that Green won’t whiff that much more at higher levels.</p><p>Elijah Green’s whiff issues largely have to do with a lack of consistency. The bat path is compact and efficient. There isn’t such much excess movement in his swing when he is settled in. There’s no loud leg kick to tie up Green or throw off his timing. The whiffs are largely a result of his inability to consistently push off his backside, and an inconsistent stride length (Seemingly by accident) that throws off his timing. Finding consistent mechanics could go a long way for Elijah Green.</p><p>Green shows good spin recognition in my looks. He doesn’t expand the zone all that often and is very aggressive in pursuing strikes. He does struggles some with pitches that break away from him and will roll over on those. However, when they get left a little too far in, he takes them over the wall so it’s a risky business trying to bait him into swinging at pitches just off the plate. If they are too far off then he just won’t swing.</p><p>Elijah Green struggles some with the high fastball in my looks. He has a steep bat path geared towards hitting with power and more so, a steep bat angle that makes it hard to get the barrel up in the zone. The vulnerability to high fastballs is a bit scary but he murders everything down and if the high heat doesn’t have velocity, he can usually at least poke it the other way. There is some hit risk and the contact rates will likely always be below-average but they aren’t close to untenable.</p><p>The hit tool I even have graded as average because of how scrumptious I expect the BAcon to be. Elijah Green has elite barrel control. The majority of his contact is hit in the sweet spot where he does ridiculous damage given the titanic raw power. He avoids mishits and rarely will get jammed. Even when he is jammed, he often hits the ball hard enough to still steal some hits. Balls hit at 95+ have an average xBA of .500. Green is going to hit a lot of balls at 95+ and most of them will come at optimal angles because he has both the bat path and attack angles to do so. The BABIP skill is exceptional and will carry Green to a decent average even with a plethora of whiffs.</p><p>The power is the carrying tool here though for obvious reasons. The bat speed is exceptional and it’s not just explosive hands. His entire body is explosive and powerful. His lower half movements are largely simple but still incredibly efficient at transferring his weight and generating massive torque on every swing. The exit velocities are among the top in the entire draft- not just the prep ranks and he’s posted a 110 EV with wood bats in a very small sample size. The power is easily a 70 grade raw and he checks all the boxes you want out of a power hitter.</p><p>The game power is not at all far behind the raw punch. Elijah Green checks just about every box you want to see when it comes to impact power output in games. We’ve already established it’s 70 grade raw but it’s also plus feel to elevate. Green has a steep VBA that creates implicit loft in his swing and given him a cheat code when it comes to making aerial contact. He also has elite hitting posture and consistently positive attack angles that lead to lots of explicit loft coming from the swing as well. Green shows feel for pulling the majority of his aerial contact as well and that only makes him more enticing. He has both 70 raw power and 70 game power.</p><p>The athleticism makes me question if Elijah Green is actually a human. Green has 80 grade speed. His 6.16 seconds 60 yd dash is in the 99.8th percentile of prep outfielders and an easy 80 grade time. His 1.44 second 10 yard split was even better with him actually outdoing the 55m (60 yard) state champion and Perfect Game record holder in the 60 yard dash, Michael Gupton across the first 10 yards. Those initial 10 yards is probably the most important to baseball game speed and Green is the best of the best at that.</p><p>Elijah Green has explosiveness when he runs. That initial burst is incredible to say the least and it plays both in centerfield and on the basepaths. In centerfield that initial first step and quick get off that still leads into plus long speed gives him one of the best outfield jumps of any prospect in the draft or the minors. The routes could probably use some polishing and there is some maybe deserved questions about maintaining the 80 speed in a bigger bodied frame. Even still, he looks the part of a plus centerfielder because he covers so much ground with his speed.</p><p>Elijah Green also has a rocket arm that will make anyone hesitate to run against him. He has some of the best throw velocities in the prep ranks and has both carry and accuracy on his throws. When you pair the 80 speed and elite range with a cannon of an arm, you have an elite centerfield prospect.</p><p>Elijah Green comes with more risk than most players in the first round of the draft but I think it is fairly easy to overstate that risk. Striking out doesn’t mean Green is boom or bust. Even if the hit tool completely flops, and Green is running a 35%- or heck even a 40% strikeout rate; he can still be a valuable player. Look at what Tyler O’Neil did last year. Look at what Miguel Sanó does pretty much every year. Joey Gallo walks a ton but he’s a Role 60 player even with a zillion whiffs. Elijah Green has an advantage over those three too because he’s a plus centerfielder.</p><p>This isn’t a boom or bust profile. It is a boom or still useful profile. The tools are too loud to not play in some capacity. Elijah Green deserves serious consideration at #1 overall. Druw is better but if Green is even 500K cheaper, I probably take Green at #1 instead. Elijah has the highest ceiling in the class and the floor is higher than you think. The tools are off the charts and there is some substance here too.</p><h4>3. SS Jackson Holliday, Stillwater High School</h4><p>There is a coherent argument that Jackson Holliday is the best player in the draft class. I’ve heard it’s the argument his agent is trying to make and as such is refusing a discount at #1 overall. I don’t think Holliday is quite the best player in the draft but he’s in the same tier as both Jones and Green.</p><p>The argument for Holliday over the other two boils down to two things. Holliday has less risk than Green and also plays shortstop. The upside is probably lower but the realistic expectation from the bat is every bit as loud and he’ll still be an impact play defensively. Jackson Holliday can do it all.</p><p>Some people seem to think Jackson Holliday will fill in and move off shortstop but I vehemently disagree. Holliday is an above-average shortstop in my opinion. He checks all the boxes and even if he loses his plus speed and is only an average runner- or heck even below-average; I still think he will be passable at shortstop because he checks so many boxes.</p><p>Jackson Holliday is a really awesome athlete. He might only be a 60 runner, but his agility is amazing. He ranked in the 92nd percentile of agility testing over the summer. He has great lateral movement with his lateral jumps ranking close to the 90th percentile as well off of both legs individually, and his broad jump is solid as well. The reaction times are elite as well. He’s going to move quickly with hop and mobility in both directions.</p><p>Jackson Holliday also has above arm strength and good accuracy. His hands are really good and he glides all over the infield making plays. The actions could use a bit of work and he’s not the smoothest at times, but given the natural mobility and the high work ethic along with the pedigree and bloodlines, I’m more than comfortable projecting on that.</p><p>On the off chance that Holliday does manage to bulk up so much that he is truly incapable of playing shortstop, then I have drastically undersold his power upside as Holliday’s primary concern as a power hitter is a lack of lower half strength. If he is slowing down because he’s added that much muscle, then he might be a 70 grade power hitter.</p><p>Jackson Holliday for most of 2021 looked like he had below-average raw power. The bat speed wasn’t there in testing and he wasn’t getting much separation when he swung. He only hit six home runs in high school play that year. He still had an excellent hit tool but he wasn’t consistently making an impact on contact.</p><p>However, late this summer, Jackson Holliday made one simple tweak to his swing and saw the power explode as a result. Holliday started to rock back into his back hip during the stride and it has greatly improved the consistency and impact of his weight transfer. The extra motion has also helped him delay torso rotation and has seen the amount of hip-torso separation and the rotational speed of swing improve exponentially in response.</p><p>In the video from this spring, Jackson Holliday has a louder leg kick with a more authoritative push-off that seemingly is another tweak geared towards hitting for more power. The bat speed now visually looks really strong and it already tested as above-average even before all these changes that are designed to get more power out of him. Holliday has a whippy barrel and hits the ball with authority to all fields.</p><p>The strength is present to muscle balls over the wall. He has quick hands and incredible core strength. He has powerful hips that rotate really well and impact the ball with potent force. The only concern physically is that Holliday doesn’t generate that much power from his legs. He gets enough power from the rest of his body that it’s still plus raw power even without much strength in his legs.</p><p>This is why the possibility of Jackson Holliday adding so much strength to his lower body that he can’t play shortstop is so exciting. The biggest concern for Holliday in the power department is that he doesn’t have lower half strength. Fix that and the world will tremble at the crack of his bat.</p><p>The game power isn’t quite up to snuff with the raw power because he does struggle some with pulling the ball but there is definite potential here. Jackson Holliday has above-average feel to elevate. He typically hits with a steeper VBA that gives him implicit loft and his attack angles are usually positive so he’s getting explicit loft as well. Holliday hit 17 homers in just 40 games this year and that was not really a fluke.</p><p>You would expect that with all the tweaks to Holliday’s swing to make him better optimized to hit for power, the hit tool would pay the price. You would be horribly wrong. Jackson Holliday hit .685 in his senior year and set the high school single-season record for hits. Not the school record or state record but the national record for hits in a season. The previous record holder was JT Realmuto who set it 12 years ago.</p><p>Jackson Holliday has some of the best contact rates in the draft this year. he struck out just 4.2% of the time at Stillwater as a senior against pretty stiff competition. If we would rather look a little farther back to the summer, Jackson Holliday had an 84% contact rate during the summer circuit (Sourced so this is all games, not just ones with statcast). That is among the best in the prep class.</p><p>Jackson Holliday has added some movement to his swing but at his core, it’s still pretty simple. The hands are short and direct to the ball. He enters the hitting zone early and lives in there for probably too long. He makes a lot of contact deep over the plate and has no issues with timing both fastballs and offspeed pitches. I have little doubt that Holliday will continue to run plus contact rates as he climbs the ladder.</p><p>Jackson Holliday has an advanced approach at the plate. He only ran a 15% chase rate this summer and was still fairly aggressive against pitches in the strike zone. He has no trouble whatsoever with laying off of breaking balls, although he does tend to watch the hangers in the zone as often as he does the ones below it. The approach is hard to project on prep bat but I’m pretty confident that Holliday will continue to make above-average swing decisions in the minors and eventually the majors as well.</p><p>Jackson Holliday can do it all. He should stick at shortstop in the major leagues while hitting for both average and power. Holliday might not have quite the same track record but I’m comfortable putting him on par with where I had Marcelo Mayer coming out of the draft. I’m expecting him to be a very tough sign away from Oklahoma State where his uncle is the head coach and his father is the hitting coach, but I do think he’s probably worth buying out of his commitment. Holliday has franchise-altering talent if he develops and you don’t get the chance to draft a player like this very often.</p><h4>4. SP Dylan Lesko, Buford High School</h4><p>Dylan Lesko was considered by most scouts to be the best prep pitcher this century before he tore his UCL and underwent Tommy John Surgery in April. Now a number of publications irrationally don’t even have Dylan Lesko as the top prep in this year’s draft. I think they are all acting foolish.</p><p>Tommy John Surgery sucks but it’s not what it used to be. The majority of pitchers return to full strength after the operation. I’ve seen the success rate listed as high as 85% returning to what they once were but that’s hard to quantify and I’m a little skeptical that it’s quite that high. But even players like Luis Severino who missed nearly three entire seasons have come back and been largely the same player he was before injury.</p><p>More importantly, one third of MLB pitchers have had at least one Tommy John before. The fact that Lesko is having it now doesn’t mean much because the other arms you could draft instead, in a vacuum have a 33% chance of having Tommy John themselves. I might prefer healthy Brock Porter to injured Dylan Lesko (I don’t) but there’s still a pretty high chance that Porter needs Tommy John himself at some point. There’s not that risk for Lesko- at least not to the same level. Only 8.5% of the players who have a Tommy John, wind up needing a second one.</p><p>Tommy John is not enough to ignore that Lesko is by far the most talented pitcher in this draft and has some of the highest upside in all the minor leagues. The stuff is ridiculous and he pairs it with above-average command, a fluid delivery, on the mound athleticism, and a strong frame. Dylan Lesko has #1 starter upside and Tommy John Surgery doesn’t dampen the upside just slows his ascension.</p><p>The fastball is the best of any prep arm in this year’s draft by a fairly sizeable margin. The pitch might only top out at 97 MPH but his velocity is remarkably consistent with him sitting 94–96 MPH and that is still plus velocity. The pitch comes from a vertical slot with an average stride length that leaves Lesko with a 0.97 RelSide and a 5.90 RelHeight. That latter figure is almost exactly the MLB average release height.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1016/1*tZwQdC_orl73KykFz9SCtA.png" /></figure><p>The fastball can also do this (see image above). Oh, and this (see below).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1010/1*hneP7Xuh1lLA9V2LewjTjg.png" /></figure><p>That pitch movement is beyond ridiculous. He is averaging 21.9&quot; IVB in games with hawkeye and topping out at 25.6&quot; IVB. If we remove his one start in Coors field, Dylan Lesko is averaging 23.2&quot; IVB which is even more unfathomable. There is no major league pitcher with this much vertical movement and the only minor league one with 21.9&quot; IVB that I know of is Daniel Espino. To make things even crazier, he is averaging 10.2&quot; of horizontal movement towards his armside.</p><p>Granted, there is an important caveat to his numbers. This is with the high school baseball. The high school baseball has higher seams than the MLB one and even the college one. The average pitcher gets ~2 inches more movement with the high school ball than they would with the MLB one. That leaves Dylan Lesko with 19.9&quot; IVB and 8.2&quot; HB. There is still no pitcher in the majors with as much vertical and horizontal movement.</p><p>Even amongst his fellow preps, there is no one in the same league as Lesko. Dylan Lesko threw eight pitches with six inches of drop or less. Every other prep arm to pitch in an MLB stadium; 170 pitchers in total, combined for just as many pitches (8) with six inches of drop or less. Lesko is in a league of his own. One of those pitches belongs to the #2 prep arm on my list. The rest belong to Xavier Cardenas III who I covered a few days ago in my <a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/the-numbers-suck-but-19f4ac20a72a">“The Number Suck but…” blog</a>.</p><p>The generational fastball movement profile paired with plus velocity makes this a 70 grade fastball even with a generic vertical release. Lesko’s fastball plays exceptionally well up and to the armside with his movement profile where he collects a lot of whiffs. He also gets chases to the armside due to coming from the medial release point that just makes him even more unhittable.</p><p>The changeup is probably better than the fastball which sounds impossible. There will always be some skepticism when it comes to a prep changeup but Lesko checks every box imagineable with both elite raw stuff and command. Risk is present sure but the upside is higher than quite possibly every minor league changeup- Grayson Rodriguez being his only competition.</p><p>The changeup sits at 82.8 MPH on average is thrown with an average spin rate of 1503 RPMs. The pitch has above-average vertical depth with 9.6&quot; IVB on average. He also has plus tailing action with 16.2 inches of horizontal break on average.</p><p>Time to put those numbers into perspective. That 12.4 MPH gap in fastball and changeup velocity (Hawkeye games only) would have been the 7th highest gap from a starting pitcher during the 2021 season. That 700 RPM gap betwen the fastball and changeup would have been amongst the best in the league as well for a non-splitter.</p><p>The vertical movement might not look like all that but it is 13.6&quot; more IVB on the fastball than the changeup. The average pitch has just 8.5&quot; more IVB on their fastball compared to the changeup. It’s elite vertical depth relatively speaking. The horizontal movement also ranks in the 84th percentile of all MLB arms.</p><p>The changeup plays up above the natural movement too because of his arm slot. Dylan Lesko throws from a 0.97 RelSide which really lets the changeup play up. Changeups from a high slot typically get more chases to the armside because their shape isn’t quite so obvious out of the hand. Lesko has fantastic HAA- against batters of both handedness. It’s the somewhat rare changeup that completely dismembers both right handed and left handed hitters.</p><p>Lesko has elite feel and command over the pitch to both sides of the plate and the pitch is far more consistent than any prep changeup has a right to be. The execution is there and he checks every single box specs wise. This is truly an elite 70-grade pitch and it could allow him to rise through the minors fairly quickly once he returns to the mound.</p><p>The curveball also earns an above-average grade from me. The pitch is somewhat lacking in power but 77–80 MPH from a prep arm is plenty fine and he maintains the armspeed on it so it’s not that obvious. The pitch isn’t going to ever have elite power but it has enough to work.</p><p>Dylan Lesko has elite feel for spinning the baseball. He averages 2800 RPMs with his curveball and although it’s inefficient spin in most areas, it does hint at the upside that his curveball has. The pitch averages just -5.6 IVB right now with 9.2 inches of sweep but the long term appeal is much higher.</p><p>Clayton Kershaw has made an ~74 MPH curveball dominate his entire career despite only decent movement. The reason for that is because his spin axis on the fastball and curveball are almost perfect reflection of each other with the exact same spin efficiency. Trevor Bauer did the same thing for a year. There is a 99% chance that Dylan Lesko never maximizes his spin efficiency on the curveball but he does have a perfectly mirrored spin axis with his curveball just 3° off from being a perfection reflection of the fastball. There is value in that even without the spin efficiency.</p><p>Dylan Lesko on top of having three major league quality pitches also has above-average command projection. Lesko has never really struggled with walks in his time as a prep and rarely leaves pitches over the heart of the plate. He has a smooth delivery that he repeats well with optimal timing. The athleticism is exceptional and he can pitch deep into games. Other than the Tommy John, there are very few red flags health wise.</p><p>Dylan Lesko is the complete package. The injury sucks but the stuff is among the best of any non-MLB pitcher in the country. He offers two genuinely elite pitches in the fastball and changeup with a third above-average upside one in the curveball. He’s still the best prep arm I’ve ever scouted, even with him needing Tommy John. There are only two minor league arms with better pure stuff (Grayson and Espino). I don’t think he’s likely to go in the top ten picks now but he still should. I might have had him ranked at #1 overall before Tommy John, that’s how much I believe in the stuff.</p><h3>55 FVs</h3><h4>5. 3B Cam Collier, Chipola College</h4><p>Cam Collier is someone who my ranking of has varied a lot throughout the draft season. I didn’t particularly like him at first, and then I talked myself into a late first round grade. I soon knocked him back down out of the first round when I went back and looked at the production of most JUCO bats to go in round one and saw how Collier underperformed relatively. Then I got Collier trackman data and realized he was arguably the most talented hitter in the draft.</p><p>Cam Collier has the best on-base profile in the entire draft. The contact rates were not there on the summer circuit for preps during a very small sample which is largely why I had him ranked so low initially. The contact skills were exceptional with Chipola this year though and they have been really good on the Cape this year as well.</p><p>Cam Collier whiffed just 15.8% at Chipola as a 17 year old. That number sounds great but is it actually? Maybe his league was just very whiff adverse. I wondered that at first so I checked and found the league average whiff rate of every player who played a single game in Chipola. The league average hitter had a 29.2% whiff rate. Collier is whiffing almost half as often as the league average player. If we only look at in-zone whiffs then he is at 10.9% compared to the league average 19% whiff rate in the strike zone. Need I remind you that Cam Collier is just 17 years old?</p><p>The contact skills are exceptional in terms of results but Collier also has all the visual cues that you look for in good contact hitters. The bath is unquestionably fantastic. Collier is quick to the baseball without excess noise in his swing and he keeps the bat head flat. The bat path is very much geared towards contact with a flatter swing plane but he still produces some power due to steeper attack angles.</p><p>Cam Collier has good timing throughout the swing and can make adjustments in both his stride and bat angle to consistently make contact regardless of pitch type or location. The lower half movements are fluid and although he gets disconnected at times, that is more of a power problem than a hit tool one. He has made a lot of contact despite being so much younger than his opponents and he will continue to do so moving forward.</p><p>The approach is also exceptional. Cam Collier makes incredible swing decisions- not just for his age but in general. Collier has a 24.3% chase rate in a league where the average player chases 31.9% of the time. He is 17. Collier also has a 73.2% Zone-Swing% when the average player is at 62.4%. He is still 17. Cam Collier has the best plate discipline in his league and he’s the youngest player in the league by two years.</p><p>Collier does have a slight chase issue against breaking balls (31.4%) but don’t mistake that for anything but a minor issue as he’s still barely chasing relative to his 74.5% zone-swing rate against breaking balls. He also only whiffs on 21.8% of breaking balls he swings at. Collier has the bat speed to hit velocity and the swing plane that makes it easy to dream of him developing the ability to hit high heat with authority. Collier has very few weaknesses in the on-base profile.</p><p>Collier also has shown some of the best plate discipline on the Cape where his peers are some of the best college hitters in the country and at least three years his senior with most being closer to five. Cam Collier has an elite on-base profile with a combination of high contact rates and elite plate discipline.</p><p>Cam Collier has not produced like your typical JUCO bat that goes in the first round though. Tim Anderson hit just under .500 and led his league in OPS. Harper had a 1.5 OPS and was inarguably the best player in a JUCO at any age. Spangenberg even hit .477. Collier is hitting a mere .333/.419/.537 which is good to be clear but he is only 39th in his league in slugging and is 65th in OBP. It’s not just a bad ballpark or something because three of his teammates have an OPS over 1.000. Is Collier overhyped?</p><p>The answer is no because it’s important to understand why Collier is struggling relatively. Cam Collier is producing a lot of mishits. He has a 17.3% popup rate and 40% of his contact is hit below 80 MPH. The problem is a lack of consistent barrel accuracy.</p><p>Most of the time when a player is too old for the level, they will dominate through one key skill- barrel accuracy. They will hit lots of line drives and make consistent hard contact. The won’t popup because they are too good for the pitching they are facing. Collier is the inverse. He’s too young for the level so he is struggling with barrel accuracy.</p><p>I don’t really expect Cam Collier’s barrel accuracy woes to last. He’s already shown the ability to put the bat on the ball and the next step in his evolution should be specifying which part of the bat he is hitting with. The swing decisions and swing mechanics are too good to doubt that Collier will develop barrel accuracy.</p><p>Cam Collier has actually already shown elite barrel accuracy too. At the MLB Draft Combine, Collier hit the most batted balls in the sweet-spot of any player in the entire draft with 11. He did damage on contact consistently back when he was still just your average run-of-the-mill high schooler and he posts good attack angles out of game time situations. I think the abundance of mishits is solely a mirage based on him being pushed so aggressively and the BAcons will settle into an above-average skill if given time to acclimate.</p><p>Cam Collier has plus raw power as well and maybe a bit more. If you look at Cam Collier relative to other college bats then a 107.2 MPH Max EV and 103.6 MPH top 8th EV do not look like much. Except Cam Collier is only 17 years old. Relative to prep bats those numbers are utterly insane. Even amongst the good prep hitters, a good chunk of them don’t even max out at 103.6 MPH. Collier’s 107.2 MPH EV comes with a wood bat by the way. It’s incredible raw juice for his age and even just in general. The bat speed is exceptional. He’s twitchy with explosive hand speed and a lightning-quick barrel. He has a very strong lower half and a swing that gets to most of the strength in that lower half when things are clicking.</p><p>There are times that Collier gets ahead of himself and will let his hands fly too early- particularly against pitches away from him and as a result will generate very little power from his lower body. There are also some times when his weight transfer isn’t totally efficiency and the power will leak out the backside. The lack of barrel accuracy hurts the present-day power output but the upside here is a 65. Cam Collier as advanced as he is, is not yet perfect. There are some questions with the game power that he still has to answer.</p><p>Cam Collier will almost certainly play third base in the majors. He’s not spectacular there by any means but he has solid mobility and a howitzer of an arm. There are some scouts who think he might move to first base for some reason but it would take a lot of extra muscle to force him off of third. He has clean hands, a rocket arm, and decent range. That will absolutely play even if it’s not exciting.</p><p>Cam Collier is one of the most exciting and arguably the best bat in the entire draft. He is more advanced than any 17 year old should be allowed to be and could reach the majors by 2025. He offers an elite blend of contact, power, and approach. There is probably a limit to the upside because he won’t provide that much defensive value but an elite hitter is an elite hitter wherever you play them and he won’t be a negative either.</p><p>Collier should get consideration at #1 overall. I wouldn’t take him over the four names I have above him but he stands out in his own way and will probably be cheaper than the Jones/Green/Holliday trio so if the Orioles want to splurge later, he could be their target.</p><h4>6. SS/3B Brooks Lee, Cal Poly</h4><p>Brooks Lee was my top player in the draft this year entering this season. He only got better as he improved his K%, BB%, and hit for more game power this year. However, Lee fell down my board some as players around him rose and I took a deeper look at what really makes Brooks Lee tick.</p><p>The glove is very fringy at shortstop and I, like most people, think he is better suited for third base long term. That doesn’t mean he’s not at least passable at shortstop though- he might play at a Xander Bogaerts level defensively at the most premium of positions.</p><p>Brooks is not a great athlete. His foot speed is well below-average and he’s exactly light on his feet. He has limited range. He does do a good job making plays to his glove side though and has decent enough mobility. The actions are mostly fluid and he has enough arm for the left side of the infield.</p><p>The arm strength is a plus with excellent arm utility. He can uncork throws across the diamond with strong velocities and solid accuracy. Brooks can make throws from multiple arm angles and does so regularly. This is often to his detriment as he tends to drift into a less power and less accurate side arm slot when he really doesn&#39;t need to. This causes his arm to play down a bit to only a 55 grade. Lee is probably only average defensively at the hot corner but there is some defensive upside here.</p><p>The bat is obviously the calling card though. Brooks Lee has the best hit tool in the entire draft. His contact rates are exemplary albeit against weak competition. Brooks Lee is running an 89.8% in-zone contact rate this year after running an 89.6% clip last year. He is striking out less than 10% this year as well.</p><p>Brooks Lee had a chase problem this year but then he just decided to have elite swing decisions instead. He cut his chase rate from 30.1% down to just 22.3% this year. He swung slightly less at pitches in the strike zone with his zone-swing dropping by 4.3%. He still had a 75% Z-Swing even after the reduction from last year. Lee is extremely aggressive at pursuing strikes and also doesn’t chase often anymore. That is a scary combination of skills. Especially when they make as much in-zone contact as Brooks Lee does.</p><p>Brooks Lee has plus BABIP skills to go along with the electric contact hitting profile. Brooks Lee shows an exceptional feel for the barrel and probably as a result, Lee had 95th percentile line drive rates in 2021. He also had plus line drive rates on the cape. The popup rates are somewhat high at ~8% but he’s consistently squaring balls up and hitting them with authority so you can live with the mishits.</p><p>Brooks Lee has an average exit velocity of 90.2 MPH and a 45% Hard-Hit rate during his time at Cal Poly. His Max EV might only be 109.4 MPH but he has a Top 8th EV of 107 MPH which places in the 92nd percentile of all college hitters this year. He hits the ball with authority and 75% of his contact comes in the sweet spot. That leads to some ridiculous wOBAcons from Brooks Lee.</p><p>The plus raw power plays in games for the most part. Lee has above-average feel to elevate despite a flatter bat path due to his approach. Lee has a very early point of contact and then gets underneath pitches that lead to him putting the ball in the air at a high rate and hitting it with authority. His flatter bat path gives Brooks very strong spin traits on his batted balls and enables him to get extra carry on his batted balls.</p><p>The hard-hit rates are there and he elevates. There is some power risk if the barrel accuracy regresses at all but it should still be above-average game power pairs with the best hit tool in the college crop. Oh, and he has a great approach now. Lee is far from a defensive stalwart up the middle but he does provide some value defensively and hits. I have him just outside the top five on my board but I could totally get behind drafting him in the top three- or even #1 depending on price, who the team is, and what their plan is for developing Lee.</p><h4>7. C Daniel Susac, Arizona</h4><p>Daniel Susac has his issues but in terms of pure data, he is better than last year’s #1 overall pick, Henry Davis. Susac offers both exceptional contact quality and exceptional contact rates as a catcher with good defense behind the plate. That is one hell of a foundation and you can figure out the rest later.</p><p>Daniel Susac chases 47.5% of pitches out of the strike zone in games with Trackman. You probably don’t need me to tell you how horrible it is. He’s only swinging at 73.2% of strikes to balance it out. The plate discipline is genuinely putrid, to say the least. I’ve heard the chase rates are only ~34% without trackman but that is still not anything close to good.</p><p>Except, here is the thing. Daniel Susac hits out-of-zone pitches better than anyone else in the draft or anyone in the minors, heck even better than 99.9% of big leaguers- it’s Rafael Devers esque. On pitches out of the strike zone, Susac has a 37.8% Hard-Hit Rate and a 54.1% Sweet-Spot. The average batted ball out of the zone has a 3621 RPMs spin rate and 53.1% of his batted balls are hit with backspin. All of those numbers except for the hard-hit rate are better than his in-zone numbers.</p><p>There are mishits obviously, with a 35.1% softly-hit rate; and he does whiff more but a 68.1% out of zone contact% is still not that bad overall; and is absurd for it being on out of zone pitches. I am by no means saying Susac chasing so much is a good thing, but I am saying that Susac chasing so much is maybe not the colossal problem we make it out to be.</p><p>Daniel Susac for all of his plate discipline woes is still an elite contact hitter. He has an 83.2% contact rate even with all the chases which are in the 79th percentile of college hitters. He also has some of the best in-zone contact rates in all of college baseball with a whopping 94.7% contact rate against pitches in the strike zone. That is exceptional stuff- it doesn’t translate this way but still, it’s higher than every major leaguer with at least 50 PAs this year. Using a standardized zone, the zone-contact rate is in the 95th percentile of college hitters.</p><p>Daniel Susac has a breaking ball problem- at least in theory. Daniel Susac chases 54.5% of breaking balls out of the strike zone. That is a terrifyingly high chase rate. Except, Susac as we established completely obliterates out of the zone pitches, and his overall whiff rate against breaking balls, as such, is only 33.3%.</p><p>Do you know who else whiffed 34% of the time against breaking balls? #1 overall pick and best draft prospect in at least five years, Adley Rutschman. The narrative is that Susac can’t hit breaking balls because he can’t stop chasing them but it’s not the reality. There is more risk in Susac’s breaking ball skills because he chases and they will only get nastier as he climbs the ladder, but this isn’t the kryptonite that some people seem to think it is.</p><p>Daniel Susac on top of making a lot of contact, also has exceptional contact quality. I’m not talking about power even if Susac has that too. Susac hits the ball at optimal angles to produce high BABIPs. The Sweet-Spot rate, that is the percentage of his batted balls hit with a launch angle between 8° and 32° is in the 93rd percentile of all draft prospects. His line drive rate is slightly better at 30.6% and in the 94th percentile.</p><p>Daniel Susac also has a popup rate that is in the 90th percentile at just 2.8%. He has elite launch angle tightness as well with a 22° sdLA which is in the 95th percentile of all college hitters. His tendency to expand the zone does lead to some softly hit batted balls but he is still in the 79th percentile for soft-contact rate. Daniel Susac consistently hits the ball at optimal angles for producing high BAcons. As a bonus, he shows an advanced feel for hitting groundballs to the opposite field.</p><p>The power might be even more impressive- the raw power at least. Daniel Susac has a Max EV of 112.9 MPH that came on a line drive with a 20° launch angle. That would rank in the 89th percentile of major league hitters this year for a Max EV. Daniel Susac also has a top 8th EV of 108.4 MPH this year. That ranks in the 96th percentile of college hitters this year. His hard contact is pretty consistent too with an 89th percentile hard-hit rate.</p><p>The problem is that Daniel Susac is pretty strictly a line-drive hitter. Only 20% of his batted balls are outfield flyballs. That ranks in the 18th percentile for a college bat. He still hits the ball stupid hard but it only results in an 8.3% barrel rate. That is still an 80th percentile barrel rate but it’s not as good as we know he could produce. That barrel rate also plays down because Susac pulls flyballs at a below-average rate and has a slightly below-average batted ball spin profile.</p><p>There is absolutely elite game power upside here but it’s only projecting as an above-average tool long-term. It’s not that I don’t think Susac can learn to elevate, it’s simply that I don’t want Susac to learn to elevate. Daniel Susac’s batted ball profile isn’t perfect as is but it is really good.</p><p>Due to his lower attack angles, Daniel Susac has almost no mishits and hits a lot of line drives. You might get more homers out of putting the ball in the air more. However, there is a very high likelihood that in doing so, you completely wreck that elite BAcon skill. I would rather stick with what we know is so effective until we find out if a change is mandatory. I don’t think one will be.</p><p>Daniel Susac’s bat is why he is a first-round prospect but the glove is more than adequate behind the plate as well. The framing maybe leaves a bit to be desired but Manfred has recently revealed the plan is for Robo-umps in 2024 and Susac will almost certainly not be up before then. The rest of his defense is quite strong. He is decently mobile and can block most pitches. He fields well and as a result ranked in the 87th percentile for catcher DRS in 2022. He was even better in 2021 when he placed in the 99th percentile.</p><p>The arm is more average than you would like but is still sufficient to catch. Susac caught 27% of baserunners this year and ranks right around league average in throw velocity. His pop times can be a bit slow at times but he makes up for it with very crisp arm accuracy. Susac isn’t a glamorous backstop but you can put him behind the dish and not have to worry about a thing. I also think he might be best off at third base or the like to let the bat cook without any added pressure but I’m just weird.</p><p>Daniel Susac offers a combination of contact skills and raw power that no one else in the entire draft can measure up to. There is absolutely risk given then complete lack of anything resembling typically coherent swing decisions but that risk might be overstated given the damage he does on “bad pitches.” Susac can play catcher and has immense offensive upside. That is a profile I will gamble on every day of the week. Susac is a top ten talent easily and him falling out of the top ten would be a critical mistake for every team who passed on him.</p><h4>8. CF Drew Gilbert, Tennessee</h4><p>Drew Gilbert is perhaps the single most enjoyable player in the entire draft. The energy he brings is just different. He plays with swag and flare in all of his actions. He has a tendency to rise to the big moment and hates losing more than anything else in the world. He’s not only a ton of fun but he is one of the best prospects in the entire draft with a lot more upside than anyone will credit him for.</p><p>Drew Gilbert’s least impressive skill often seems to headline his scouting report. I am of course talking about his above-average defense in centerfield. He has easy plus speed and uses it incredibly well with explosive jumps that allow him to cover more ground than most centerfielders with his speed would. Gilbert has crisp routes out there as well. He lays out to make highlight-reel plays and he can climb the fences to bring back home runs. I think the range is somewhat limited by only plus speed so it’s only a 55 glove but he’s closer to a plus than he is an average grade.</p><p>Drew Gilbert also has effortless plus arm strength. Gilbert consistently threw in the low nineties as a reliever in prior years and that arm strength plays in a big way in the outfield. He has pristine arm strength and accuracy. His mechanics are probably a bit long but he can make plays with his arm. Outfield arm is more bonus than anything for a centerfielder with his ability but Gilbert does collect his $200 for passing go.</p><p>On to the fun stuff, Drew Gilbert has one of the highest upside bats in the entire draft. The contact skills are top notch. In games with pitch tracking (Most have Trackman but there is one two-game set in Minute Maid with Hawkeye) Drew Gilbert is running an 80.7% contact rate. That is above-average contact skills.</p><p>That is also horrifically underselling Drew Gilbert. Gilbert has just a 7.3% in-zone whiff rate. That would be in the 99th percentile of major leaguers. It doesn’t really work that way but it still ranks near the top of this year’s draft and Gilbert is doing this against SEC pitching. Using the standardized zone- a terrible method given that Gilbert is only 5&#39;9&quot;, he is in the 87th percentile of college bats in in-zone whiff rate. Gilbert is short to the ball with a compact swing and it clearly works.</p><p>Drew Gilbert has zero problems with hitting velocity. He actually whiffs more against fastballs below 93 MPH than he does against ones above that threshold. He also has very little problem with hitting breaking balls as he whiffs just 27.2% of the time against them. Changeups? Try a 16.7% whiff rate. High fastballs? Maybe a bit of an issue but only a 13.1% Swinging-Strike rate which is nothing insurmountable.</p><p>Drew Gilbert also makes above-average swing decisions. His in-zone swing rate is well above the collegiate average at 70.5% and he pairs that with a chase rate that is also well below-average at 23.2% (He’s actually at ~18% in non-Trackman games apparently). He has a chase rate between 22.2% and 28% against every pitch type. The only pitch he swings at less than 66.7% of the time in the strike zone is the curveball.</p><p>Admittedly, a 28.6% zone swing at the curveball is kind of ugly. Especially, given the fact that he chases 28% of curveballs. There might be an issue brewing in that regard. But also, Drew Gilbert still only has a 21.9% CSW% against the curveball because he only 21.9% of them in the zone this year. I’m not going to read too much into such a small sample.</p><p>On top of his above-average defense, plus arm, above-average contact rates, and above-average approach; Drew Gilbert also has really strong BAcon skills. His launch angles are very tightly clustered with a sdLA of 24.3°. That is in the 99th percentile of college hitters. He has an 83rd percentile sweet-spot%. The popup rate is just 4.7%. Actually, forget about that last one. His popup rate is in the 22nd percentile across the full season per FaBIO which is not great obviously.</p><p>Drew Gilbert also showcases some of the best raw power in the draft. He might only be 5&#39;9&quot; but he packs a serious punch. He has hit a ball 115.1 MPH before. That was in Minute Maid Park with Hawkeye so you know the tracking is almost certainly accurate. <a href="https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/gamefeed?gamePk=700499">I’ll even include a link</a>. A 115.1 Max EV already ranks in the 97th percentile of major leaguers. His Top 8th EV of 108.4 MPH backs up that assessment as he ranks in the 96th percentile of college players in that regard.</p><p>Drew Gilbert has a higher Hard-Hit rate than all but one player with 50+ BBE in front of trackman this year at 60%. He has a higher average exit velocity than all of them at 95.3 MPH. His soft-hit rate is lower than any other player in the country with 50+ BBE at 11.6%. Hitting the ball hard this often and avoiding so many mishits is going to lead to plus BABIP skills at bear minimum.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/765/1*aP-cNF--zxzLwtIq5RFzfQ.png" /><figcaption>Drew Gilbert has a special combination of hit/power</figcaption></figure><p>You are probably wondering how Drew Gilbert is not the #1 player on my board by this point. Every tool is at least above-average and he has 70 grade raw power. What is there not to like? The answer to that question has layers. Drew Gilbert does not have that much in-game power.</p><p>The raw power is titanic but Drew Gilbert hits 48.8% of his batted balls on the ground. That is a lot of groundballs and hurts the power. But surely not that much? Can he really be only hitting 11 home runs in a full season with some of the best raw power in the draft? I mean the answer is yes. Spoilers but Spencer Jones has more raw power and has a lower HR/AB%.</p><p>But also, the quality of Drew Gilbert’s hard contact is not consistent. Flyballs at 95 MPH rarely make their way into the bleachers and a large portion of Gilbert’s hard-hit flyballs are of the softer hit variety. Drew Gilbert has electric bat speed and that is a huge difference maker but it’s not all that determines power. The swing mechanics matter too.</p><p>Drew Gilbert struggles with his weight transfer. He often will get too far into his backside. This is especially true when Drew Gilbert is trying to put the ball in the air. When he steepens his VBA he does so by rocking back and anchoring his back hip. His Max EV on flyballs is just 107 MPH. Gilbert has power no doubt but that power only really performs when he isn’t trying to force elevation and can consistently keep his swing in its natural form.</p><p>Gilbert is only a 55 game power hitter despite 70 raw because I don’t think he’s best when trying to be a homerun hitter. He can hit groundballs and be a wOBAcon menace without hitting long balls.</p><p>I love dudes who make consistent flush contact and Gilbert is technically one. He reaps all the theoretical benefits of flush contact with 99th percentile spin rates and 92nd percentile backspin%. He just also is worse because of it as trying to force being flush kills the power and that matters more than spin.</p><p>Tinkering with Drew Gilbert to try to get to the power feels like an obvious pitfall. He is what he is, and I think trying to change that is going to blow up in your face. Maybe someone smarter than me sees a way to create elevation while maintaining a more efficient weight transfer but I don’t see it and that is why he is only ranked here on my board.</p><p>Ultimately, I think even though Drew Gilbert might not ever wind up tapping into his 70 grade raw power, he is still one of the best players in the draft. He offers above-average or better tools across the board and has a track record of performance. He’s gotten some makeup comps to Jarred Kelenic and scouts question if he can handle struggling on a mental level but Kelenic’s issues go a lot deeper than his head and it’s unfair to paint them with the same brush. Drew Gilbert is his own player and that player is an exceptional one.</p><h4>9. RF/CF Chase DeLauter, James Madison</h4><p>Chase DeLauter was getting attention as a real candidate to go #1 overall before the season started. He hit .437/.576/.828 with a 213 wRC+- the highest wRC+ by any D1 hitter with 100+ PA this year. For 24 games he was literally the best hitter in the country before he broke his foot and inexplicably has been plummeting down draft boards as a result. This is a broken foot, not a torn ACL or torn labrum. Letting him fall so much because of a relatively small injury will be a mistake.</p><p>The swing certainly looks unconventional. He employs a scissor kick which is a move very few major leaguers have in their swings. He also tends to drag his back foot forward before contact. He flies open a bit early but he’s still keeping his hips locked in a hinge even as he opens up so I don’t really think it’s a problematic move even if an unconventional one.</p><p>The hit tool is good. Chase DeLauter made contact on 78.7% of swings this year. 11 of his whiffs came in the first three games of the year. If you remove those his whiff rate drops to an estimated ~17%. He was at an 85% contact rate in 2021. He struck out more this year at 17.8% but was at 13.9% last year.</p><p>James Madison is in in the Colonial Athletic Association which is far from stiff competition so there is some reasonable doubt over the contact profile translating. Or there would be if Chase DeLauter didn’t strikeout just 12.3% of the time during his 146 Plate Appearances in the Cape Cod League.</p><p>Chase DeLauter’s parents might have given him the most inaccurate name ever. Chase literally never chases. He has just a ~15% chase rate this year and one of the highest Z-Swing rates in the country at ~77%. That plate discipline seemingly continued to play in the Cape where he still walked more than he struck out. DeLauter makes elite swing decisions and it allows the hit tool to really perform. The on-base profile is exceptional from DeLauter.</p><p>Chase DeLauter has a ridiculous wOBAcon profile. In 2021, Chase DeLauter ranked in the 95th percentile for groundball rate, 88th percentile for popup rate, and 95th percentile for line drive rate. It should go without saying that those numbers are truly exceptional. DeLauter also hits the ball hard.</p><p>I can’t actually say precisely how hard DeLauter hits the ball given the small sample size of data with trackman but I will say it’s hard. DeLauter has topped out at 107.8 MPH in a very small sample size with trackman data. I realize that’s not a lot but it’s like 15 career BBE with Trackman so it’s not really that representative of who DeLauter is.</p><p>Chase DeLauter has produced elite in-game numbers though with a career .313 ISO in three years at James Madison. He also led the Cape Cod League in ISO with a minimum of 50 PA (Chase had 146) at .290. He is producing elite power with both wood and aluminum and that has to mean something more than he is just putting the ball in the air at a very high rate.</p><p>Chase DeLauter from a visual standpoint looks like he can produce big time power numbers. The bat speed is electric. He’s got a very strong lower half and an effective hip hinge that really locks him in. Things might look a little funky but he is generating massive torque and really throwing his whole weight at the ball. DeLauter also has a steeper VBA with a lofty bat path and steeper attack angles to boot. He’s going to frequently hit the ball in the air and do so with authority.</p><p>Chase DeLauter has sneaky athleticism. During James Madison’s pro day, DeLauter ran a 6.4 second 60 yd dash. That is a 70 grade run time. I’ve clocked him with plus run times on home to first runs on multiple occasions. Maybe he loses a step given how big he is but there are plenty of big players who are fast in the majors and scouts discounted the athleticism of for no reason (See Rodríguez, Julio) so I don’t really think that’s a lock.</p><p>The arm strength is a plus. He sits at 92 MPH off the mound but it plays down in the field due to some issues with his arm stroke. There is absolutely enough arm for right field but with plus speed he has a chance to theoretically stick in centerfield. I don’t love the jumps hence why it’s probably right field but he has the athleticism to theoretically be a fit there.</p><p>There is 60/60/60 bat upside here. I think the hit tool will wind up a bit below that and there is some risk but the offensive upside is incredible. DeLauter also plays a quality right field with a non-zero chance of sticking in centerfield. The tools are exceptional and the production is even more so. DeLauter is an easy top ten talent in the draft for me and if he falls as far as he is being rumored to, someone will be getting a massive steal when they take him in the back half of the first round.</p><h4>10. RF/CF Gavin Cross, Virginia Tech.</h4><p>Gavin Cross is fascinating. He was a fairly one dimensional albeit elite wOBAcon monster in 2021. Then in 2022 he started running plus contact rates but both the power and BABIP profile fell off in turn. Cross has flashed both elite contact and wOBAcon skills but never both at once. Is it possible to meld the two? That is the question any drafting team must ask themselves.</p><p>Gavin Cross had a Max EV of 114.2 MPH in 2021. This year he peaked at only 111.6 MPH. That would be a concerning dropoff but honestly, I think I’m overselling the power decline if anything. Gavin Cross still had a 109.3 MPH top 8th EV which ranks in the 98th percentile of college hitters. His hard-hit rate decreased from the 98th percentile where he was at last year but he’s still in the 87th percentile.</p><p>No, the real concerning drop is that his barrel rate is down from 8% to 5.2%. Gavin Cross. This is hard to pinpoint the exact cause of though. We’ve established that Cross hasn’t really lost power. He’s hitting 4% fewer balls in the air but how much does that matter? Except not all aerial contact is created equally. Gavin saw his popup rate literally double this year.</p><p>His flyballs have in general become less impactful because he is getting too much under them and too far on top of his groundballs. Gavin Cross also saw his sdLA literally go from 86th percentile in 2021 all the way down to the 8th percentile this year. That is an extreme deviation in the profile. sdLA means more for the BABIP skills than the power output but it does affect some power output too.</p><p>As I’ve already touched on, the BABIP skills have collapsed completely. Cross is mishitting the ball a lot more now. We can turn to film to find the reason pretty easily. It appears like Gavin Cross has flattened out his VBA to remove the crippling weakness he had against the high fastball and particularly the hard fastball. I think this change is probably for the better but it’s not the slam dunk it feels like just looking at the surface level stats.</p><p>Gavin Cross is now one of the better hitters in the draft against the elevated fastball. He’s running just a 7.7% Swinging-Strike rate against fastballs in the top half. He also has gone from whiffing 52.2% of the time against fastballs at 93+ to whiffing just 20.8% of the time. Given how omnipresent high-velocity fastballs are in the majors, as well as elevated fastballs; this was a much-needed change for his college production to actually translate to major league production.</p><p>The contact rates as a whole are up from 75.8% to 80.9% but the fastball is the root cause for most of the improvements he’s made. The gains against secondary stuff are much more nominal. He has cut his whiff rate down from 35.9% to 29.8% this year against breaking balls. He’s gotten better across the board at the expense of some contact quality but the fastball is the key issue.</p><p>The swing decisions are above-average as well. Gavin Cross chased just 23.2% of the time this year- down 7% from 2021. He also swung at 73.2% of pitches in the strike zone this year. He is only whiffing 9.8% of the time in the strike zone and has managed to post solid contact rates out of the zone as well, but he does have a bit of a chase issue against secondary stuff that needs to be worked on.</p><p>Gavin Cross is a bit of a fringier fit in centerfield but I actually kind of like his chances of sticking. Cross is only an above-average runner but he has good jumps and covers a surprising amount of ground. His hands are clean and he can lay out for one. I don’t think Cross is a fantastic centerfielder by any means but I am comfortable playing there.</p><p>His best fit though is probably right field though where he profiles as above-average. Gavin Cross has easy plus arm strength with good carry on his throws. He’s on line more often than not and his mechanics aren’t too long or anything. He will create outs with his arm regardless of which outfield spot he winds up in. The defensive profile isn’t sexy but he will almost certainly provide some value of some sort.</p><p>The Gavin Cross we saw in 2021 was probably a late first round pick. He was fairly one dimensional but it was some of the best wOBAcon skills in the entire draft and solid defense in centerfield. The Gavin Cross we saw this year probably belongs in the middle of the first round with the improved contact rates and approach.</p><p>It’s the possibility of Gavin Cross combining his strengths of the 2021 version with the 2022 version that has him just inside the top ten on my board. If we had seen Cross maintain the wOBAcon skills this year while making the same gains he did; Cross would probably be in the conversation to go #1 overall. The upside here is immense and the floor has been raised significantly this year. I don’t think he’ll move that quickly through the minors but he has a chance to make a loud impact and is unlikely to not at least be a useful fringe-everyday player.</p><h4>11. 2B/3B Jace Jung, Texas Tech.</h4><p>Jace Jung falls in a similar bucket as Termarr Johnson. He’s an amazing hitter with very limited defensive value. He’s fairly closer to the majors and was one of the most productive players in college baseball across the last three years hitting .328/.468/.647.</p><p>However, Jace Jung really struggled to end the year as he hit just .214/.343/.339 in the final 30 days of his collegiate career. The why behind those struggles according to trackman appears to be that he started getting too far beneath pitches. The contact rates and swing decisions only showed moderate dips. It’s probably unfair to ding him for one bad stretch but every cold stretch means a lot for a bat only profile without eye-popping tools.</p><p>The contact rates are typically fairly average. Over the last two seasons, Jace Jung has made contact on 80.2% of swings (sourced so not just trackman). The swing decisions are the driving factor behind the contact rates though as his whiff rates in the zone are very average. Jung expands the zone just 14.9% of the time and still manages to swing at 68% of in-zone pitches. The contact skills are more average than anything but he makes great swing decisions so he should still keep the strikeouts in check.</p><p>The wOBAcon profile is interesting. Jace Jung has elite sweet-spot rates over the last two years even if they fell off some in the last month of the season. He was still at 48.3% this year which ranks in the 97th percentile of college bats. That is very good and given the power profile should lead to plus and bordering on elite BABIP skills.</p><p>He also hits a lot of mishits though so the BABIPs aren’t actually all that. The popup rate was in the 13th percentile in trackman games this year. Infield flyballs understate just how bad it is though. Jace Jung hits 30% of his batted balls with a launch angle above 50°.</p><p>The MLB average player has a wOBAcon of 0.017 on balls hit with a launch angle above 50°. The largest percentage of balls hit with what much arc in the majors this year is 21.3% by Austin Hedges. I’m not going to pretend I’m not at least a little worried about this flaw from Jace Jung.</p><p>Jace Jung also hits 20% of his batted balls with a launch angle below 0°. The average wOBAcon on those batted balls is .160. That is a lot more manageable than the previous number the two figures in tandem is still scary. For Jace Jung to have even an MLB average wOBAcon of .359 this year(Assuming he performs exactly to the MLB average on balls with a LA above 50° and LA below 0°); Jung would need to have a .644 wOBAcon or higher on balls hit with a launch angle between 1–49°. That would be in the 89th percentile of major leaguers. That is just for league average numbers on contact overall.</p><p>I actually think Jung is likely to meet that threshold. The average ball in the sweet-spot has a .679 wOBAcon and that makes up 90% of Jace Jung’s batted balls in this range. In addition, Jace Jung has power and hits the ball hard with regularity. Yet, this is only for average wOBAcons. Ideally, you should be aiming for a lot more than average wOBAcons from an early first round pick- especially one without elite contact skills or defensive value.</p><p>Jace Jung simply has to cut down on the mishits. Honestly, I have no clue how realistic of a goal that is. Most of the time when players are mishitting it has to do with poor swing decisions or poor barrel accuracy. Neither of those is remotely applicable to Jace Jung. Jung makes some of the best swing decisions in the draft. He shows barrel accuracy given his propensity for squaring up balls in the sweet spot. Without knowing the cause of the mishits it’s difficult to diagnose and fix the problem.</p><p>If I had to take a stab at it, I think it’s probably a struggle to get the barrel inside and hit the inside pitch with authority but that’s most just based on the eye test and I don’t really trust that assessment. I think it probably isn’t hopeless but it kind of scares me off having Jung at the top of my board as I did at the start of the draft cycle.</p><p>Jace Jung has at least above-average raw power. His max exit velocity is 112.5 MPH officially but given that the 112.5 reading came on a -49° launch angle, I’m more trusting of the 110.7 MPH max on aerial contact. Jung does still have a 90th percentile top 8th EV at 106.6 MPH. His hard-hit rate is also in the 94th percentile. The dude can swing it with power.</p><p>The feel to elevate is elite- probably not a good thing overall, given how many of his flyballs are auto outs but it is elite. Regardless, it does help the game power. Jace Jung has a 17.5% barrel rate which is in the 98th percentile of college players. Jace Jung should hit dingers even with all the mishits. I think the power will fade some as he climbs the ladder but it should still at worst be above-average.</p><p>Jace Jung is a fringy defensive option regardless of where you put him. He’s spent time all over the infield and I’ve heard some people talk about him as a left fielder. I like him best at the keystone but I still think he’s a below-average defender there. It’s average arm strength with not great range or athleticism. With the shift possibly being banned in the future, the defensive value is probably even more questionable. You aren’t buying Jung for the glove but for the bat and the bat alone.</p><p>For all the concerns I have about Jung’s profile, I do still absolutely buy in on the bat. Jung has the ability to get on base at a high clip and hit the ball with authority. If you figure out how to eliminate some of the mishits and automatic outs than this is one of the best hitters in the game. Even if you can’t figure that out, he should still be a pretty good hitter. I have mixed feelings about Jung for sure, but in general, I think he’s a very good hitter. The upside is limited by the defense and the floor isn’t astronomical by any means but he still offers a solid combination of floor and upside.</p><h4>12. C/LF/1B Kevin Parada, Georgia Tech.</h4><p>I’m not a big believer in Kevin Parada’s ability to stick behind the plate which is why he is ranked so low comparatively to other draft rankings out there. I also am a big believer in the bat so he still scraps a 55 FV regardless of the defensive woes.</p><p>Kevin Parada is one of the worst defensive options behind the plate in all of college baseball. He was in the 26th percentile in catcher DRS this year. He allowed 9 passed balls in only 59 games this year and caught just 23% of attempted baserunners. Parada has solid mobility but he kind of just misses on some pitches when he swipes at them. There is some defensive upside- especially with electronic strike zones but anyone expecting more than passable is a fool.</p><p>Kevin Parada does not have the strongest of arms behind the plate. He has just an 8th percentile average throw velocity but it does play above that due to quick transfers and how quick he gets out of the crouch. As such, his pop times are on average only in the 48th percentile of college backstops. Interestingly, the arm strength looked a lot better on his 90th percentile throws where he ranked in the middle of the pack in throw velocity. The arm is playable behind the dish but it’s below-average. The only defensive value Parada really provides as a catcher is the ability to squat for an entire game. (Also I’ve heard some good things about the game calling).</p><p>Kevin Parada is an exceptional hitter who checks the vast majority of boxes. His contact rates are above-average. He whiffs just 17.6% of the time overall and 12% of the time in the strike zone. The ability to hit secondary stuff is particularly impressive with Parada whiffing just 24.1% of the time against non-fastballs.</p><p>Kevin Parada does have a bit of an issue with high velocity fastballs up in the zone though. This appears to be due to his longer hand load. He has shown the ability to hit sinkers down and softer fastballs up but when you pair them he’s overmatched.</p><p>Carter Kieboom had a similar flaw and never fixed it. That doesn’t mean Parada can’t fix it, to my amateur eyes, it actually looks like a pretty simple fix but it does introduce risk. Still, the ability to hit non-fastballs is top-notch and he has the present twitch and speed to hit velocity with one (maybe) simple adjustment.</p><p>Kevin Parada does have a tendency to get jammed inside by the fastball. He has an average exit velocity of just 84.4 MPH (37 BBE) on pitches on the inner third and he’s popping up just under 20% of the time on pitches in that area. He hasn’t got issues connecting with the inside pitch but he does struggle to consistently bring the barrel in. This isn’t to say he lacks the ability to do so though, Parada has a 110.1 MPH EV on a pitch over the inner third so he clearly can do it- just not consistently.</p><p>The primary draw of Kevin Parada is unquestionably the plus game power. Parada actually has just a 43rd percentile groundball rate. A large part of his appeal though is that he has an above-average pull rate on his aerial contact which does make a difference. But even still, his pulled outfield flyball rate is only in the 58th percentile.</p><p>So why is the game power so good? Parada has elite raw power and that makes all the difference in the world. Kevin Parada’s Max EV is an admittedly non-elite 110.6 MPH but he has a much better 107.7 MPH Top 8th EV which ranks in the 94th percentile.</p><p>He also has a 98th percentile hard-hit rate. Because most of his hard-contact is scalded, and at optimal flight paths; Kevin Parada has a 96th percentile barrel rate of 15.4% despite below-average feel to elevate. There is present day game power in the profile because he consistently scorches the ball with a very rotational swing.</p><p>The swing decisions have also matured into above-average this year. In trackman games, Parada is running just a 23.1% Chase rate. As you would maybe expect, fastballs are his worst chase pitch with a 27.9% chase rate against them. He chases just 20.5% of the time against secondary stuff.</p><p>If Parada can learn to lay off the fastball up and in then he could be a truly elite player. It’s very rare that anyone can be as disciplined as Parada against secondary stuff. Parada also swings 71.5% of in-zone pitches. The swing decisions are fantastic aside from a few hiccups.</p><p>Kevin Parada isn’t a perfect player and I think the profile is a bit one-dimensional, but the offensive upside is truly immense. Kevin Parada has a chance to hit for both average and power at a high level while also working his fair share of walks. There might be some kinks to work out but I am more than happy to gamble on the sheer upside of the bat in top half of round one. If a team thinks they can teach him to catch, then he could and probably should go in the top five.</p><h4>13. SP Cooper Hjerpe, Oregon State</h4><p>Cooper Hjerpe looks nothing like your conventional front of the rotation starter but he was exactly that for Oregon State this year. Not only only was he the Beavers Ace, but Hjerpe was also the best pitcher in the entire country. Of all qualified D1 pitchers (1 IP/Team Game), Hjerpe was first in WAR, K%, and FIP.</p><p>Cooper Hjerpe has a weird fastball but I do think it’s an above-average pitch despite its unorthodox nature. Actually, not despite of- because of the unorthodox nature of it. The fastball comes from the most unique release point of any starting pitcher in baseball. He throws from what is on average a 4.43&#39; release height and a -3.55&#39; horizontal release point.</p><p>There is no starter in the majors with a release even close to Hjerpe’s. The release height is the lowest of any major league starting pitcher. There are only two starting pitchers with a sub-five foot release height. Those two are both Giants in Logan Webb and Alex Wood. Both of them are at 4.9 ft. Hjerpe is a half-foot lower than the two of them. The widest horizontal release is 3.31 ft from Max Scherzer. Hjerpe is still significantly wider. The angle is a complete unicorn from a starting pitcher.</p><p>It is totally logical to question if Hjerpe can stick as a starting pitcher as a result. I’m pretty confident Hjerpe will stick though. Hjerpe throws three high quality pitches and has very strong weapons to beat batters of both handednesses. Hjerpe has a well rounded batted ball profile without obvious defects and is able to beat hitters in a multitude of ways. He has command and stuff in tandem.</p><p>More importantly, unlike most players with this low of an arm slot, Hjerpe is pitching deep into games and maintaining his stuff in the process. Hjerpe averaged 97 pitches per start and had just as much velocity in the last inning as the first. The only reason to doubt that Hjerpe is a starter is because no one has ever done it looking like this. That argument falls flat though because no reliever from a comparable slot has ever had three pitches this good or the same command as Hjerpe; yet alone both simultaneously.</p><p>The fastball only sits at 91 MPH and tops out at just 95 MPH with Trackman. That is perfectly acceptable velocity but I’m also not ruling out Hjerpe adding more strength to his 6&#39;3&quot; frame with how athletic he is. The fastball plays up too because Hjerpe gets plus extension (6.8 ft) on all of his pitches. I also am obligated to note that he was hitting 98 MPH according to scouts during the preseason. I tend to assume that was just a hit gun but it might not have been.</p><p>The pitch movement is solid with 12 IVB and 14.5 HB but the movement is largely irrelevant. The release angle is what makes him so unhittable. The fastball even with an average pitch height of just 2.4 ft in trackman games still has -4.35° VAA. When he elevates the fastball for whiffs he is at ~-3.6° (Pitches at 2.8 ft ~MLB average 4SFB height). When he pitches down he gets groundballs and called strikes at a ridiculous clip.</p><p>It is very hard for Hjerpe to lose with his fastball. This pitch is one of the most dominant pitches in all of college baseball with multi-situational utility and elite bat missing shape. The pitch has a 30.4% whiff rate (Full-season not just trackman) while he throws it in the strike zone 58.7% of the time. (These numbers are from like Mid-May so might be slightly off now)</p><p>Cooper knows how to use the heater with command all over the strike zone and he gets weak contact. There might not be impact velocity here but Hjerpe still easily earns himself a plus grade because of how tough it is to hit at the angles he gets. The fastball is the foundation of a deep and highly effective arsenal.</p><p>The slider is absolutely nasty. He only sits at 76.8 MPH which would be the second slowest slider by a major league starting pitcher this year behind only Rich Hill (Tied with Dallas Keuchel). That is a red flag but Hjerpe also has more movement than just about any slider in baseball.</p><p>Cooper Hjerpe averages -3.2 IVB on his slider. That is 96th percentile vertical movement on a slider. He also averages 15.5 inches of sweeping action on the slider. That is in the 92nd percentile of slider sweep. Only Sonny Gray, John King, and Aaron Bummer average as much movement on both planes.</p><p>The slider is even better than the movement though because Hjerpe throws his slider from such a wide release point. The slider has a -5.2 HAA despite an average pitch location of -0.09 ft. That means his average slider is going to the same side of the plate as his arm is coming from. He’s neutering his HAA and still ranks in the 95th percentile of HAA.</p><p>For the sake of simplicity, let’s pretend Hjerpe’s average slider location is 0.00 and undersell him a bit. Jhonathan Diaz has the steepest zone-neutral HAA in the entire league at 3.8°. Hjerpe’s zone neutral HAA is at the very least at -5.2°. Cooper Hjerpe has a generational slider angle and it’s why his whiff rate is over 50% despite lacking in velocity. I think he’ll drop off a tiny bit in pro ball against better hitters but the slider should always miss bats with his angle.</p><p>Did I mention how exceptional Hjerpe’s slider command is? Cooper Hjerpe throws his slider in the zone a little over 50% of the time. He can backdoor his slider for called strikes against right handed hitters or get chases off the plate against lefties.</p><p>Remember, how I was talking about how the average Hjerpe slider goes to the arm side? That is why. He has an average slider location of +0.58 against left handed hitters. When he is throwing to lefties and actually pitching to the glove side he has a -6.5° HAA; that is of course, the steepest angle in the majors. Hjerpe’s ability to command the slider and alter it’s function in each matchup makes him impossible to beat. This is the second above-average pitch in Cooper’s arsenal.</p><p>The changeup is arguably Hjerpe’s best pitch which sounds silly given the quality of his other two pitches. The changeup is thrown nearly 13 MPH slower than the fastball with Hjerpe sitting at 78.4 MPH on average. He throws the changeup with almost the exact same spin rates as the hybrid fastball. The changeup is thrown on a 9:00 spin axis.</p><p>The resulting pitch has 1.3 IVB and 16.3 inches of tailing action. The changeup has five inches more drop than the average changeup at his velocity. That is 94th percentile vertical drop. He also has 80th percentile horizontal movement. The only changeups with more movement on both planes belong to Cristopher Sánchez, Decin Williams, Joe Mantiply, and Dylan Floro. None of them have anywhere near the elite velocity separation that Hjerpe offers on top of the movement.</p><p>Cooper Hjerpe’s wide horizontal release might undermine the changeup movement though. I worry that the changeup will lack deception because he throws from so wide that arm side movement should be able to be picked up on. The pitch plays fantastically off the fastball in the zone but probably won’t be a big chase pitch despite the ridiculous movement profile. That is probably still going to result in an above-average changeup given that Hjerpe throws his in the zone at a well above-average rate.</p><p>I say this but I’m not actually confident it’s true even if it’s theoretically how the changeup interaction should work. Joe Mantiply throws his changeup with a very comparable shape and a 3 ft RelSide. He throws the changeup slightly harder and has a slightly less extreme release but it’s the closest comp you will find.</p><p>Joe Mantiply’s changeup has the highest chase rate of any changeup in baseball. It is very likely I’m overselling the concern with the changeup angle, given that Hjerpe has a 56% whiff rate against it. I have the changeup graded as above-average and as his “worst” pitch but it’s still a really good one with obvious plus upside.</p><p>I don’t know if you’ve realized it yet but Cooper Hjerpe has good command. I’m a coward who is still slightly scared off by the delivery so it’s only graded as above-average but you could easily push it higher. Cooper Hjerpe threw 55.4% of pitches in the strike zone this year. No major league starter fills the zone that often. That isn’t really a good thing and you probably want him to expand the zone for more chases in the future but Hjerpe is capable of throwing strikes at will.</p><p>Cooper Hjerpe also shows the feel to throw to both sides of the plate and pitch both up and down with the fastball. He lands all three of his pitches for strikes at an above-average rate. He gets chases when he does expand the zone and gets whiffs when he stays inside of it. He can backdoor his slider or pitch off the plate. It looks weird and the delivery doesn’t feel like it should result in good command but it inarguably has done exactly that.</p><p>Cooper Hjerpe has one of the strongest batted ball profiles in the draft. His angle makes him impossible to square up and he avoids the heart of the plate despite profiling as a zone filler. As such, he allows almost no line drives. The fastball gets popups when he elevates it and he gets groundballs when he works down in the zone. This is a well-balanced and consistently plus batted ball profile.</p><p>I find it very difficult not to question if I am ranking Hjerpe too low because of pre-conceived opinions and biases on what a starting pitcher looks like. We haven’t seen Hjerpe throw a full workload and there is a theoretical risk that the chases stop coming against higher-level competition. Hjerpe also has a perfectly clean bill of health and gets a lot of in-zone whiffs- especially relative to how often he is in the zone. Cooper Hjerpe has ace-level upside and it looks weird but I don’t really consider the relief risk all that high.</p><h3>50 FVs</h3><h4>14. 2B Termarr Johnson, Mays High School</h4><p>I have very mixed feelings about Termarr Johnson. I have him ranked a tad bit lower than the consensus but I really want to make it abundantly clear that I do not in any way dislike Termarr Johnson. The primary reason he’s ranked so low is that I think he is only an average second baseman. I think the bat is great but I don’t think it’s generational like some people seem to think it is.</p><p>The hit tool is very obviously the carrying tool for Termarr Johnson. People slap the best prep hitter in years moniker on him but I disagree. Termarr Johnson actually had fairly mediocre contact rates during the summer circuit (sourced). He only made contact 78% of the time. His 19% chase rate is good but for all that Termarr’s hit tool is supposed to be generational, he both whiffed and chased more against top competition than Holliday did.</p><p>Termarr Johnson will make his money because of how good his hands are. It’s a plus BABIP profile to go along with what still projects as plus contact rates. Termarr possesses an elite feel for squaring balls up and hitting them at optimal angles to do damage. He makes adjustments mid-at-bat to the shape of his swing and will rarely be beaten twice. He shows both the ability to hit velocity and pick up on pitches with spin. The bat path is clean and efficient, the setup is quiet and effective, and the timing is typically on point. Despite, the whiff issues last summer, I do still think Termarr has the second-best hit tool in the draft behind only Brooks Lee.</p><p>The power I’m a bit more skeptical of and that has nothing to do with Termarr only 5&#39;9&quot;. His hand speed is probably the best in the draft class with him averaging 2800°/second. His hands explode through the zone and it leads to plus bat speed that borders on elite despite the smaller frame. The problem is his power is entirely dependent on his hand speed. The lower half offers very little in the way of explosive movements. In fact, Termarr Johnson had a 1st percentile counter movement jump last summer and opted out of testing in it at the combine. He only tested slightly better in the broad jump. I still think there is above-average raw power and in the right organization, you can probably add strength to the lower body and push that to a plus but it’s by no means a lock. Termarr should be getting to all of that power in games too.</p><p>Ultimately, I think Termarr Johnson is going to be one of the best hitters in the draft. I just don’t think he is that much significantly better offensively than most of the names in front of them- if he is at all. I think the lack of defensive value probably means more to me than getting the slightly better bat.</p><p>Termarr’s profile is not 100% safe, there is certainly risk that he winds up a one tool player and the brief whiff issues don’t even make that tool 100% safe. I don’t think he will be he could. I view Termarr very comparatively to Brooks Lee in profile/value but Lee gets the edge due to proximity and track record. Termarr is still really good and absolutely should go in the top half of round one. If the Orioles take Termarr #1 for under the slot then I won’t hate it at all.</p><h4>15. SS Zach Neto, Campbell</h4><p>Zach Neto is third in all of college baseball in wOBA over the last two seasons and the two players in front of him are both first basemen. Neto plays a passable shortstop. The tools aren’t the loudest but Neto is a do it all producer with both a big bat and defensive value. He has lots of baseball skills and he plays the most premium of positions.</p><p>Zach Neto has plus contact rates. He is making contact on 83.8% of swings this year and is at 82.1% over the last two years combined. The swing decisions are above-average as well. Neto is chasing just 22.5% of the time across the last two seasons and is swinging at 74.4% of strikes.</p><p>Zach Neto has no difficulties with hitting both breaking pitches and high velocity. He demolishes the high fastball and pitches with above-average vertical movement as well. He has some issue with timing offspeed stuff in the zone but given that he doesn’t chase all that often, I’m not too concerned. Neto lacks exposure against top-tier arms at Campbell but he’s hit the good pitching he’s seen and dominated on the Cape.</p><p>Zach Neto also has very good batted ball data independent of power. Neto hits outfield flyballs at a 92nd percentile rate. Unlike with a Jace Jung, Neto is hitting only 8.4% of them with a launch angle above 50°. His flyballs are at angles where they can do damage. Neto unlike most high OFFB% guys actually doesn’t popout much at all. He is running just a 4.2% popup rate which is in the 80th percentile of college hitters. He also has a 78th percentile sweet-spot% and a 94th percentile sdLA.</p><p>What really brings the profile together though is the fact that Neto hits with backspin. Zach Neto regularly makes flush contact and as a result, gets 92nd percentile spin rates on his batted balls. He also hits 54.4% of his batted balls with backspin which is in the 85th percentile. To top it off, Zach Neto pulls 36.2% of his flyballs.</p><p>So in conclusion, Zach Neto has some of the highest flyball rates in the country, the spin profile that gives him more carry on his batted balls than most, and he pulls his flyballs at an elite rate so it takes less work for them to wind up over the fence. Is it any surprise Zach Neto hit 15 home runs this year and finished second in the Cape Cod League in ISO last year?</p><p>Zach Neto only has average raw power. His Max EV is just 108.2 MPH and his top 8th EV of 104.9 is only in the 80th percentile of college bats (MLB average is 105.7 MPH (LIE THIS IS 92ND EV- not comparable to MLB)). Zach Neto still has a 94th barrel rate despite only average raw power because of how much aerial contact he is hitting. He still outperforms even that in the slugging department because of the spin and sprays. Neto only has average raw power and it is all he needs to beat the shit out of baseballs.</p><p>Zach Neto’s swing is a bit unconventional. He has a flamboyant leg kick with a lot of bat waggle. He aggressively throws himself out of the ball and looks a bit wild at times. Whatever he’s doing clearly works though and there are no red flags in the statistical profile. Zach Neto does it all at a solid level and feels very likely to contribute at the big league level even given the smaller school and unorthodox swing risk. If there is one player on this list so far who I am probably too low on, it’s Zach Neto. I don’t see the All-Star upside I usually covet but I think he’s very likely to be a good everyday shortstop.</p><h4>16. SP Brock Porter, Orchard Lake St. Mary’s High School</h4><p>Brock Porter has electric stuff. He’s a tier behind Lesko in both stuff and command but the upside here is massive. He should go early in round one for a lot of money and he’ll be worth every cent.</p><p>The fastball is an electric pitch. The fastball sits 94–96 MPH and has allegedly been up to 100 MPH according to some reports but given how he’s only hit in once to my knowledge, I’m assuming the gun was hot. Regardless, it’s plus fastball velocity. It’s also plus feel for spin as he sits at 2447 RPMs on average. The pitch has above-average extension at 6.5 ft on average and a vertical slot with a 5.78 RelHeight and a -0.84 RelSide.</p><p>The movement profile is the calling card here though. Brock Porter averages 19.5 IVB in games with Trackman from last summer. You have to adjust for the difference in seam height with the high school ball so it’s only actually like ~17.5 IVB but that is still great vertical movement from a prep. The pitch also gets 10.8 inches of tailing action but again, adjust for seam height. Still good movement but not generationally so.</p><p>The problem with Brock Porter’s fastball is consistency. He sits at just 10.9 inches of drop on average but will flash as little as six inches. He will also throw fastballs with as much as 16 inches of drop. This does not appear to be deliberate as the two pitches have almost identical spin-based 1:00 spin axis. Brock Porter has inconsistent spin efficiency. You can argue his fastball has more upside than Lesko’s given the superior feel for spin and slightly lower release/better extension but the optimization is not quite as good. I have the two pitches graded as equal but I personally prefer the one that could dominant in the big leagues today (Lesko).</p><p>The changeup is Porter’s best secondary pitch. He throws the pitch at 75–78 MPH and kills nearly 1000 RPMs sitting at just 1525 RPMs on average. The changeup has 8 IVB and 14.8 HB on average. On paper, that sounds like an elite pitch- especially coming from such a medial release but I have some concerns. To be frank, I think the velocity separation is too much. He throws the changeup 17.8 MPH harder on average. There is no changeup in the majors with a velocity separation that large and the only one close is Spencer Howard. There is a reason for that.</p><p>Brock Porter throws his changeup too slow to actually tunnel with the fastball at all. The arm speed is solid so it works for now, but I’m very skeptical that better hitters won’t see the changeup floating in on them that obviously isn’t a fastball and resist the urge to swing out of the zone. Spencer Howard had great changeup movement but was too slow to play in the majors as well. This is a pitch that will dominate the minors and stumble some against major league hitters. I still have Porter with a plus changeup because he has an elite feel for pronation but I think this pitch needs a lot of work still.</p><p>Brock Porter has a somewhat solid curveball. He sits 77–79 MPH with fairly average spin rates at ~2200. The pitch has average vertical depth with -9 IVB and some sweep with 13.3 inches on average. The pitch probably needs more power but it’s still a solid average pitch. He’s added a slider this spring as well in the 82–85 MPH range. It seemingly has heavy gyro spin with almost slutterish shape and it looks good on film. I don’t have the data on it but I like what I’ve seen enough to at least grade it as an average offering.</p><p>The control has some question marks. Brock Porter has a longer arm action that can throw his timing off. There is some twist and recoil as well that might cause command issues. I still believe in the control being at least average because Porter is a great on-the-mound athlete with a high makeup, and a willingness to make adjustments but it’s not a sure thing by any means.</p><p>Brock Porter has front-of-the-rotation upside. The fastball should be lethal and with some work, you can develop a potentially elite changeup too. He has enough feel for a breaking ball and some very desirable physical traits. Brock Porter is the complete package and he has been healthy. There is work to do and he’s far from safe but he’s a very talented arm with exceptional building blocks to develop an ace out of.</p><h4>17. SS Jett Williams, Rockwell-Heath High School</h4><p>Jett Williams has some of the best tools in the entire draft but is still trying to figure out how they all meld together. That includes the hit tool. In fact, Jett Williams&#39;s best tool right now might be the hit tool.</p><p>Jett Williams is currently using a swing that is purely optimized for hitting for contact. He has a very short and efficient bat bath with no excess movements and without some of the necessary ones as well. He has no problems hitting much of anything as is in my looks but I want to see him trade contact in for more power.</p><p>Jett Williams has elite bat speed- as in it might be the best in the entire draft. Jett Williams topped out at 89 MPH on a swing on a 4/27/21 according to Perfect Game. He was only second to Druw Jones in Impact Momentum at 33.4 so it’s likely he was using a somewhat lighter bat but it’s ridiculous bat speed. Jett Williams also has an above-average broad jump so there appears to be some good explosion in the lower half as well. Or at least the potential for it.</p><p>The problem is that Jett Williams is too short to the baseball. His hands start at chest level and they barely move before he attacks the ball. He’s not building up any bat speed in games because he’s too direct to ramp up the bat speed with continuous motion. Jett lacks physicality given that he’s 5&#39;8&quot; so he’ll probably never be an elite power threat but he should hit for some power and there is absolutely at minimum plus raw power in his tank. It might take some work to get to the aforementioned power but Jett Williams absolutely has the capacity to do so.</p><p>Jett Williams is an exceptional athlete. He runs a 6.47 second 60 yard dash and his acceleration is present as well. Jett has plus run times in the shuttle run and above-average hops off both legs. He is a small dude without a lot of projection so it’s hard to foresee him losing that plus athleticism.</p><p>His athleticism really plays at shortstop. Jett Williams has fantastic range and solid infield actions. The arm strength I somewhat controversially have as above-average. He has health with some shoulder troubles that had the arm strength down significantly in some well-scouted events. Outside of that isolated sample, Jett throws with carry and velocity from across the diamond. He has top-end velocities in a showcase environment too. I think he has both the arms and actions to play a quality shortstop at the major league level.</p><p>The risk of Jett Williams is the likelihood that the ability to hit for contact and power are forever bound together. Jett has such a fantastic hit tool because he doesn’t try to hit for any power. If you change that the hit tool might drop off some. I think the power is worth attempting to unlock but there is risk in that. Jett Williams has five tool superstar upside but he’s more likely to profile somewhat one-dimensionally at shortstop with flashes of brilliance. I would still draft that player in the first round for the upside he offers.</p><h4>18. CF/RF/1B Spencer Jones, Vanderbilt</h4><p>Flashback to three years ago when I had Spencer Jones as the #10 player in the entire draft. Just ignore everything else I said about him or why he was ranked so high. Spencer Jones is very much power over hit despite what my past self might have tried to foolishly peddle.</p><p>Spencer Jones has the best raw power in the history of college baseball. He hit the hardest batted ball in the history of college baseball this year on a line drive single into right field. The pitch had a 6° launch angle and a 119.1 MPH EV. Spencer Jones has the highest Top 8th EV in the draft at 112.1 MPH. Not only is that the highest Top 8th EV in the entire draft, but it would also currently (7/4) be second to only Giancarlo Stanton in the majors this year. If you were wondering, Giancarlo Stanton is at 115.4 MPH so he is still a light-year in front of Jones.</p><p><em>Tieran from the future here: I thought 92nd percentile EV was what Top 8th EV meant but it’s actually top 1/8th EV. Jones is only at 111.6 MPH which is tied with Ivan Melendez for second behind Griffin Doesching. It’s also still higher than every major leaguer except Giancarlo Stanton as of 7/4/22. Vlad Jr. is second in the majors at 111.5 MPH.</em></p><p>Spencer Jones has titanic raw power but he is still figuring out the game-power optimization. FaBIO has Spencer Jones with just a 7th percentile outfield flyball rate. That is not a lot of flyballs. Do we care though? I’m not convinced it matters all that much. Spencer Jones has enough power that even with no flyballs, Jones is still running a 93rd percentile barrel rate. Elevating would help but he doesn’t need to do that much elevating to hit for premium in-game power numbers.</p><p>Spencer Jones also might be made worse by elevating more. Spencer Jones currently has one of the best batted ball profiles in the country for BABIP optimization. His popup rate is in the 92nd percentile. His line drive rate is in the 95th percentile. He has the best raw power in the country. He hits the ball on the ground regularly but he’s mostly hitting high groundballs.</p><p>Spencer Jones had a .468 BABIP in 2022 and that wasn’t really a fluke. It obviously won’t translate to the next level quite so high but Jones has genuinely .360+ BABIP upside as is. The one tweak I would make to the power profile is to focus more on pulling the ball as right now his well below-average pull rates dampen his homer output considerably.</p><p>There is also the fact that more elevation puts the already fringy contact rates in jeopardy. Spencer Jones has a very flat swing path right now. The swing is artistry in action. The problem is it doesn’t actually play that way. Spencer Jones has timing issues and struggles to actually make contact consistently. The contact rate sits at 72% which is manageable but it is sub-optimal. If you add more elevation it might be even better game power, but the whiff rates could turn scary fast. He already has an issue with pitches up in the zone- one that would probably be magnified by changing the bat path to create more loft.</p><p>Spencer Jones has league-average whiff rates against breaking balls sitting at 35% on average while the average player whiffs 34.9% of the time. Spencer Jones obliterates in-zone fastballs and makes above-average swing decisions. He swings at 71.9% of in-zone pitches and chases just 26.6% of the time. More importantly, Jones knows his strengths and weaknesses. He swings at 49.3% of fastballs and just 40.2% of everything else. His chases rates are actually solid against everything but the changeup too.</p><p>I like the swing decisions and think the walk rates will only get better as he matures in his approach and confidence. Right now, Jones is swinging at 62% of pitches with two strikes and has a 35.1% chase rate in those spots. Jones has to learn to be patient and take pitches even when he is on the verge of getting out.</p><p>I’ve had Spencer Jones listed as a first baseman since he was in high school but then Spencer Jones went and tested off the charts at Loden Sports as he ranked in the top 1% of athletes across all sports. Spencer Jones actually has blazing speed and plus acceleration. His 30 yard dash at the draft combine was just 3.60 seconds which is among the best in the draft. He has above-average agility as well. He has plus arm strength as a former pitcher who used to throw 95 MPH off the mound.</p><p>He’s huge but why can’t he play centerfield? He didn’t at Vanderbilt because Enrique Bradfield Jr., is superhuman out there but Jones absolutely has the athleticism to do so. Aaron Judge has done it this year and Jones is the same caliber of an athlete with the same body type. I don’t think Jones will be elite in centerfield or anything but he can play there or be an elite option in right field.</p><p>Spencer Jones is an outlier. There is no first round college bat with more risk but there is also none with close to the same amount of upside. Jones has genuine MVP upside. He should be a wOBAcon monster regardless but the hit tool will determine his eventual role. If the contact rates are even above 60% then he probably will be an everyday player. If they are above 30% he’s an all-star and if they somehow are above-average then Jones might win an MVP. The very concept of a ceiling is not in the picture with Spencer Jones. I think there is some floor though because even with a 40% K%, the strong side of a platoon who is a quality outfielder with elite power has some value.</p><h4>19. 1B Ivan Melendez, Texas</h4><p>Ivan Melendez went in the 16th round to the Marlins last year but wisely declined to sign. How he got to the 16th round, I’m not entirely certain but he was right to rebuff all their offers. He went back to Texas in order to “improve his defense.” Not only did he do that, but he also orchestrated one of the greatest offensive seasons we have ever seen at the collegiate level. He won the Golden Spikes award in a season where he led all D1, D2, and D3 players in WAR and had the highest wRC+ of any player at a Power 5 school.</p><p>Ivan Melendez is often disrespected on draft rankings for three reasons, most of which are bullshit. The first is that Ivan Melendez doesn’t have the lengthy track record of hitting you prioritize in college players without defensive value. That concern is silly in my opinion. Ivan Melendez has two years of D1 play in his lifetime, and has the second highest wOBA in the country over that two year span. That’s largely driven by this year but a 1.041 OPS last year is nothing to sneeze at either. During his two year of JUCO play, Melendez hit .393/.477/.822. Clearly, there is not a track record here guys.</p><p>The second reason is his age. Ivan Melendez is a redshirt Junior who turned 22 in January. I won’t argue that he’s not older than his peers but does one year make that much of a difference? He’s not some 25 year old. He’s a 22 year old who was the best player in the country by a wide margin this year. When he was Jacob Berry’s age, he was in the 87th percentile of run production. Berry was in the 89th this year. The difference is negligible.</p><p>The third and only legitimate gripe is that Ivan Melendez provides very little defensive value. That comment usually comes from the same people who have Jacob Berry ranked in the top ten. Melendez doesn’t do much on defense, but he’s not a DH and he’s the best hitter in the entire draft. People also like to make out the fact that he is a right-handed hitting and throwing first baseman out as a death sentence which makes zero sense. Who cares what side he is hitting from if he mashes like this?</p><p>Ivan Melendez has 70 grade raw power. His maximum exit velocity is 115.2 MPH which is in the 97th percentile of MLB hitters. His Top 8th EV of 111.8 MPH is in the 100th percentile of college bats and second to only Stanton among MLB ones. Metal bats inflate the quantity of top-end EVs, it won’t actually be second in the MLB but still. Ivan Melendez is also in the 100th percentile of average exit velocity and his average exit velocity is actually down this year.</p><p>Ivan Melendez also has a 98th percentile groundball rate this year in trackman games and as a whole, has hit just 29.4% of his batted balls on the ground since the start of 2021. When you combine the 100th percentile EVs with elite feel to elevate, you get the highest barrel rate in the country (Min 60 BBE) at 24.6%. He was second in the country in barrel rate in 2021 too. Melendez actually has even better game power than that though because he pulls his flyballs at an above-average rate as well and hits with elite spin traits.</p><p>Ivan Melendez is more than just one-dimensional power. He also has the best BAcon profile in this year’s draft aside from maybe Spencer Jones. Ivan Melendez has a 100th percentile sweet-spot rate and a 100th percentile sdLA this year. He is consistently hitting balls in the sweet spot and mostly avoiding mishits.</p><p>Ivan Melendez hits the ball as hard as anyone in the country and as a result, even on his rare batted balls at suboptimal angles, he often finds hits. The average hard-hit ball has a .500 average in the majors and Melendez hits the ball hard as often as anyone. Not to mention, Ivan Melendez has 88th percentile spin rates on batted balls and a 94th percentile rate of batted balls hit with backspin. He’s going to be a wOBAcon demon.</p><p>You are probably expecting me to douse you in iced water and proclaim that Ivan Melendez has major whiff concerns right now. I will not do that but instead, gleefully exclaim that Melendez has plus contact rates. Ivan Melendez made contact on 84.2% of his swings this year. That is in the 83rd percentile of college players. If we isolate that to only in-zone swings (Including non-trackman games) then Melendez is in the 78th percentile. He also makes 81st percentile swing decisions. That combination of contact and power skills has Melendez on an island. He is the circled red dot in the graph below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/748/1*4GMlN7Kqsn7bDzvY6pK2cA.png" /></figure><p>Finding a weakness for Ivan Melendez is an exercise in futility. Ivan Melendez has a 5.8% whiff rate against fastballs at 93+. He has a sub 30% whiff rate against breaking balls. He whiffs just 15.2% of the time against the offspeed pitch. He has just an 8% swinging-strike rate against the four-seam fastball up in the strike zone.</p><p>Baseball America suggests that Ivan Melendez struggles with the inside pitch. That is only somewhat true and a temporary flaw if anything. Ivan Melendez averages just 83.9 MPH EV on pitches on the inner third of the plate (And off the plate but in). Except, it’s more complex than that one number. Ivan Melendez maybe has slightly less consistent power but he is still hitting 48% of batted balls in the sweet-spot so it’s not bad contact. He’s also running just a 4.6% swinging-strike rate on the inner third. Oh, and remember that he hits with less power thing? Yeah, Ivan Melendez’s hardest-hit ball ever at 115.2 MPH came on a pitch over the inner third.</p><p>Despite, the lack of flaws in the statistical profile, I do actually have some minor concerns with how the hit tool will translate. There is no statistical evidence to suggest it, but I do suspect that Melendez will run into some problems with actually good breaking balls.</p><p>I think Melendez is more of an average whiff guy than a plus contact one. I also think that is perfectly fine because I genuinely believe the wOBAcons will be off the charts. Ivan is worth a first round pick and possibly a higher one than this to me because he’s going to demolish baseballs and who cares about the rest when you do that. I asked one person in the industry who is not very high on Melendez what more Melendez would have had to show this year to get a first round grade. They didn’t have an answer for me. Yes, the track record is short but it’s not possible to do more in one year to improve your stock then Melendez did this year.</p><h4>20. SP Cade Horton, Oklahoma</h4><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/the-numbers-suck-but-19f4ac20a72a">I went a lot more in-depth on Cade Horton in Tuesday’s blog</a> so I’ll refrain from repeating myself too much. Cade Horton has a fastball that touches as high as 98 MPH and is sitting at about 95 MPH. He has some mechanical tweaks left that could unlock more velocity. The fastball has elite spin rates but poor spin efficiency so the movement profile is fairly bland. Very high release but there’s no reason to believe he can’t improve the efficiency and get to a plus pitch one day.</p><p>The new slider is a fairly unique pitch given that it sits at 88 MPH with ~1&quot; IVB and about 5 inches of glove side movement. It’s basically the same movement profile and velocity as the Gerrit Cole slider from a much higher release point which makes it a very unique and very impossible to hit pitch. He has good command over the hard slider and it’s already a plus pitch with genuinely elite potential.</p><p>I would like Horton to re-add the old sweeping slider he used before developing the new one for the playoffs to give him some semblance of a third pitch. That slider had promising shape but was hurt by the lack of middle ground between the 94 MPH fastball and the 80 MPH slurve. He also would for whatever reason try to backdoor the slider every time.</p><p>Cade Horton throws strikes at a high rate with all three pitches. That being said, there are some injury question marks due to the late arm action and poor posture at foot strike. He’s already had Tommy John but I think you can reduce the future injury risk with some tweaks.</p><p>Cade Horton has maybe the highest stuff upside in the college and the command to truly be an Ace. He has to make some adjustments and there is some risk but I’m comfortable gambling on that upside in the top half of the first round. I don’t have him in the top ten but I’ll have no complaints if he goes that high for that level of bonus. The stuff is genuinely amazing with command as well! <a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/the-numbers-suck-but-19f4ac20a72a">Seriously, go read Tuesday’s article when I went very in depth on him.</a></p><h4>21. SP Owen Murphy, Riverside-Brooksfield High School</h4><p>Owen Murphy had the most dominant season I have every seen from a high school player this year. He threw 51.1 innings and had just a 0.14 ERA. He walked just 4 hitters, allowed 10 hits, and struck out 137 batters. His K% was literally over 80% and his walk rate was just over 2%. Oh yeah, he also played played shortstop and posted a 1.947 OPS while walking 34 times compared to 6 strikeouts in 138 PA. This isn’t some sleazy 2A school, it’s a genuinely solid 5A program. In his conference, Owen Murphy has the highest OPS by 0.738 and the second-best ERA is over seven times as high as Murphy. He leads in strikeouts by 64. There is no one in the same realm of existence as Murphy.</p><p>Owen Murphy is a solid day two prospect as a shortstop. He has electric bat speed and projects for above-average power. The hit tool is solid and he’s a fine defensive shortstop. There is some intrigue in the idea of developing Murphy two-ways but I think he’s too good on the mound to take away from that at all and you can’t play a premium position and pitch without the fatigue killing you. Owen Murphy is interesting at shortstop but he is significantly better at pitcher so that’s all I am choosing to focus on.</p><p>Owen Murphy is not the hardest throwing prep arm as he only sits 90–92 MPH and tops out at 94 MPH but he’s still one of the best prep arms in the class. He’s undersized so maybe the projection is limited but the arm speed is certainly there and he’s an exceptional athlete with superb movements in his delivery.</p><p>Owen Murphy also doesn’t need to throw particularly hard for the fastball to miss bats. Owen Murphy is a bit short at only 6&#39;0&quot; and he creates a low release point with a deep hip hinge. As a result, he has only a 5.2 ft release height. The fastball has a naturally flat angle and Owen Murphy has average vertical movement; averaging 16.7 IVB on his fastball last summer with 8.1 inches of horizontal action. Murphy has flashed an improved feel for spin this spring and if he can improve the spin efficiency then the fastball could really take off- even more than it already has.</p><p>The cutter is his primary secondary pitch. It used to be more of a gyro slider in the low 80s but he’s added considerable power to it this year and is now more 87–88 MPH. The pitch plays beautifully off of the rising fastball with ~8.2&quot; IVB and 3 inches of cut coming from the same tunnel. The pitch misses a lot of bats and projects as at least above-average.</p><p>The curveball has a very promising shape. He can really spin it- running the pitch up to 2600 RPMs and he has promising shape. The pitch has heavy spin and is moderately efficient with Murphy averaging -7.6 IVB and 14.6 HB last summer. The pitch is consistently thrown in and around the zone and overwhelms weaker hitters as a result. The pitch has a heavy sweeping shape and the command to profile as a bat misser. The pitch only sits at 75.1 MPH and needs more power to truly be dominant but given the shape and feel for the pitch, I’m still comfortable grading it as an above-average pitch.</p><p>The changeup feel is still a work in progress but I like it as well- even if slightly less than the other three pitches. He sits at ~82 MPH and kills a little over 500 RPMs off the fastball. The pitch doesn’t have the best vertical depth, averaging just 10.6 IVB but it has heavy tailing action with 17 HB on average. Murphy shows consistently great arm speed and has feel to pronate at a high level so I’m comfortable projecting an average grade on the still developing changeup.</p><p>Owen Murphy throws a lot of strikes. He walked just 2.3% of batters this final year in high school and has always had low walk rates. He has a smooth and incredibly efficient delivery. There is some effort because he rides low and plunges so deep but the delivery is repeated. He’s an exceptional on the mound athlete with mechanics and a history of strike-throwing. That screams above-average control to me.</p><p>Owen Murphy is a velocity jump away from greatness. All of his pitches already project fairly well but they just need a tick more to become truly dominant weapons. I think strength and velocity gains are both very possible and even very realistic. None of his pitches jump off the page as elite offerings but all of them have quality potential and the depth of the package could still allow Murphy to sit near the front of a rotation.</p><h4>22. SS Eric Brown, Coastal Carolina</h4><p>Eric Brown’s swing makes Wiggler’s look normal by comparison. He starts somewhat like Julio Franco with a much more narrow base. He has his bat pointed slightly towards the pitcher and cocked overhead. A guy like Kevin Youkilis uses that unorthodox technique to create extra whip when he flicks his wrists back and moves his hands down to swing normally from the weird setup. Brown does not do that. He instead moves his bat further in that direction as he rocks into his back hip and then throws his body forward as his hands kind of circle around. You know what, words literally can not describe this eldritch horror. Here’s a video instead.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?type=text%2Fhtml&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;schema=twitter&amp;url=https%3A//mobile.twitter.com/pgcollegeball/status/1412198607500029954&amp;image=https%3A//i.embed.ly/1/image%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fabs.twimg.com%252Ferrors%252Flogo46x38.png%26key%3Da19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07" width="500" height="281" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/efe236a6d7f04454f1a6c9a26289c36c/href">https://medium.com/media/efe236a6d7f04454f1a6c9a26289c36c/href</a></iframe><p>Any scout with a working set of eyes would tell you that bat path is way too long and there is no chance he makes contact at a decent clip. Eric Brown isn’t ruled by the logic of mere mortals though, he is beyond human comprehension. Brown has a 99th percentile contact rate and is only whiffing 3% of the time in the zone. He has a 6% whiff rate against power five schools. His whiff rate is just 8.3% against pitches at 93+ and there is just a 2.9% Swinging-Strike rate against fastballs in the top half. Clearly, the length of the bat path has not crippled him.</p><p>I detest everything about Eric Brown’s approach on principle. Eric Brown’s approach is comparable to Max Muncy’s. He has some of the lowest chase rates in all of college baseball because he almost never swings. As a result, Brown takes a lot of strikes looking and is actually running a 10.6% strikeout rate in the Sunbelt despite the lack of whiffs. The lack of aggressiveness probably needs to change at least a little as better pitchers will throw more strikes but there is some value in the willingness to watch pitches, even with two strikes, until you see the perfect one.</p><p>Eric Brown has exceptional raw power. His Max EV is 113.7 MPH which ranks in the 93rd percentile of major league hitters. He is in the 94th percentile in both Top 8th EV and hard-hit rate. The problem is that isn’t actually homerun power. Eric Brown struggles with creating loft. His groundball rate is 45.4% with trackman. More importantly, he struggles to make hard contact in the air. His hardest-hit batted ball with a launch angle of at least 25° is 103.4 MPH (35 BBE with a LA that high). He has feel to hit hard line drives but he’s not a home run hitter because the top-end EVs aren’t there on aerial contact. Eric Brown also has BABIP questions. His popup rate is in the 19th percentile with trackman and he has below-average launch angle tightness. He also pulls a lot of groundballs and despite the elite hard-hit rates has a 49th percentile soft contact rate.</p><p>The skills are here to be a star but as currently built, there is too many poorly hit balls and too little well struck ones in the air to actually be that star. Maybe I am old school, but I can’t help but wonder if that is because of the swing path that makes it difficult to create loft without losing extension and that makes it hard for Brown to consistently square stuff up. I love the swing and selfishly don’t want it to change but it might have to. I would still take Eric Brown in the first round because the raw power/contact combo is unteachable and Brown plays a solid shortstop but it seems unlikely he actually fulfills the amazing upside he has.</p><h4>23. 1B/3B/LF Jacob Berry, LSU</h4><p>Jacob Berry is considered to be a top ten player in the draft by most publications and I’ll be honest and say I don’t really understand why. I can see some appeal but that appeal is largely dependent on him stopping the switch which seems like something I’m pretty sure most analysts won’t consider given that they think switch-hitting automatically makes you better. (Or at least it feels like they think that way sometimes).</p><p>Jacob Berry has plus contact rates. He made contact on 84.3% of swings this year with Trackman and including non-trackman games is at an 88.9% in-zone contact rate over the last two seasons. Those contact skills are particularly strong from the left handed side where Berry has a mere 5.9% in-zone whiff rate. Berry has hit both velocity and breaking pitchers without any significant troubles this year. It’s a safe and effective contact skill.</p><p>The concern is contact quality though. Jacob Berry had elite contact quality last year but this year he traded contact quality for contact quantity. His popup rate went from the 85th percentile to the bottom quartile and his hard-hit rate dropped by over 15% this year. The BABIPs fell off as did the game power, and as such, despite halving his strikeout rate, Berry saw his OPS fall in his first year at LSU.</p><p>Jacob Berry has plus raw power. He also has plus feel to elevate. Berry posted a 112.7 Max EV as a left-handed hitter in 2021. His hard-hit rates weren&#39;t there this season (In part because of injury) but the power potential is still there. At least as a left handed hitter that is. Hitting right handed, Jacob Berry has yet to post an exit velo over 103.5 MPH this year with just a 25% hard-hit rate in 36 BBE. He also makes contact 6% less as a righty. Please for the love of God, stop switch hitting.</p><p>Jacob Berry provides very little on defense. He technically plays third base right now but I’m pretty confident he won’t stick. Berry has subpar athleticism and only average arm strength with somewhat poor actions as well. Jacob Berry has to hit to be worth anything. I do think Berry is highly likely to be at least a league average bat. I also think he has a high ceiling at the plate with a potential plus hit and power combo. I just think Berry will probably have to ditch switch hitting in order to reach that offensive potential he has deep down inside.</p><h4>24. SP Noah Schultz, Oswego East High School</h4><p>I’ve heard that Noah Schultz isn’t actually signable but given that he hasn’t pulled his name from the draft yet, I am including him regardless. Noah Schultz has clear first round talent with a lethal two pitch combo in the fastball and slider with a solid enough changeup to round out the repertoire.</p><p>Let’s mix it up and start with what might be the best prep slider in the entire draft. The slider has silly movement. Over the summer Schultz averaged -0.1 IVB and 17.8 inches of sweep to his glove side. His spin rates sat near 3000 as well. The slider angle is a complicated issue. Noah Schultz throws from a very low arm slot that should give him elite HAAs with such a heavily sweeping breaking ball but it doesn’t because of his mound positioning. He hugs the right handed side of the rubber and as such, Schultz only has a 2.14 RelSide. This helps the sinker probably but hurts the slider somewhat. The slider has added significant power this spring, seemingly without losing the impact shape, and now sits in the low eighties so it profiles as an elite pitch.</p><p>The fastball is probably more of a sinker. Last summer, Schultz averaged 12.1 IVB with 13.6 HB. The pitch has elite spin rates with him averaging 2470 RPMs last summer but on a 2:00 axis with middling efficiency. The pitch given the feel for SSW on the sweeper and impactful gyro spin has great turbo sinker potential but it’s a work in progress. The pitch has added velocity this spring and is now more 93–95 MPH with plus extension. The fastball should be a plus pitch.</p><p>The changeup is interesting. He throws it with solid velocity separation (~10 MPH) from the heater and good arm speed. The pitch has about the same IVB as the fastball (11.5) with very comparable fade as well (14.4). The changeup is reliant on getting timing base swings due to the separation from the fastball- a separation that was probably amplified slightly this spring. The pitch only projects as average but it’s not hard to see the upside here.</p><p>Noah Schultz looks a bit weird for a starting pitcher. He’s 6&#39;9&quot; but throws from such a low slot that his average release point is 5.27 feet. This means the higher sinker can work nearly as well as the old one. Schultz has fantastic athleticism and throws a lot more strikes than most pitchers his age. I fantasize about the possibility that Schultz adds a cutter to bridge the FB/SL shapes and to take advantage of the high spin and low efficiency that he can naturally create. He already shows elite feel for both pronation and arm speed so it can’t be that hard right? There is Ace level upside here but Schultz has considerable risk and will need to be in the right situation to reach that upside.</p><h4>25. SS Cole Young, North-Allegheny High School</h4><p>Cole Young is a prep shortstop who should hit for average and at least flashes above-average power upside. I buy in on the plus athlete with the actions to stick on the dirt and an above-average arm that will play at just about any position. He shows fantastic lateral mobility in all of my looks so even if the present day plus or better speed doesn’t stick, he should still be an average shortstop.</p><p>The hit tool is the calling card here. Cole Young has a simple swing with what seems to be efficient timing. There are some posture concerns that might be adversely affecting the contact quality but the contact quantity is top-notch. Young makes lots of contact and he makes good swing decisions. Cole Young has solid attack angles and feel for the barrel as well. There are a bit too many mishit balls because Young has a knack for making contact against bad pitches that he would be better off with whiffs against early in the count.</p><p>I do think you probably want to see Cole Young trade some of his contact skills in for more power. Cole Young makes so much contact in large part because he has such a late point of contact. Young’s swinging late normally means there is some concern with what he will do with top-end velocity at the next level but more so, it means that most of his batted balls are being hit to the opposite field. It is hard for even players with elite raw power to hit for power when they go the other way. Young has solid raw power but it’s not quite that elite.</p><p>Cole Young has plus bat speed and great torque in his swing after making some adjustments in recent years. The energy generated by his top half is significant but he lacks muscle- especially in the bottom half. I think given the build you can pretty easily project more strength in the lower half and expect the raw power to take off. I still question the game power output given the connection point though. I have graded as a high variance 45 power hitter.</p><p>Cole Young has all the tools to be great in the big leagues. Those tools should make him a first round selection and probably will since I know a number of teams in the back half of round one are considering him there. Young needs some work but the makeup is reportedly very high and he has the body and skills to be successful. I think the hit first athlete offers more of a floor than most preps and with some adjustments, we could see solid game power from Young as well.</p><h4>26. SS/3B Peyton Graham, Oklahoma</h4><p>Peyton Graham reminds me of Tim Anderson. That isn’t really a comp, just a vague feel thing. Okay, it actually is a bit of a comp. If you watch Graham play he looks like the best player on the field and a genuine superstar. Then afterward you pull up the trackman data and he looks extremely underwhelming. At the same time, he had a 142 wRC+and over his last 225 PA hit .365/.453/.698 while playing shortstop.</p><p>The contact rates are not all that. Graham has just a 38th percentile contact rate this year. Graham also chases 30.4% of the time. He got better as the year progressed but those rates were still average at best in the second half. Yet, Peyton Graham still managed to hit .335 which is in the 89th percentile of D1 players. How did he when he whiffs so much? The same way Tim Anderson hit .322 from 2019–2021 despite even worse whiff and chase rates. Peyton Graham has an exceptional BAcon profile.</p><p>If you had told me that a month ago, I would have scratched my head and laughed. Peyton Graham in games with trackman has a 29th percentile line-drive rate, a 17th percentile popup rate, and a 31st percentile softly hit rate. So how the heck are the BABIP skills elite?</p><p>Like Tim Anderson, Peyton Graham is a flush contact monster. Graham consistently adjusts the shape of his swing- flattening out up in the zone and steepening the bat angle to get pitches down. He can get the barrel all over the plate and because he is always on plane, he’s always hitting with optimal spin traits. His average batted ball has an 85th percentile spin rate but the real calling card is how many of them have backspin. Peyton Graham hits 65.6% of his batted balls with backspin. That is in the 100th percentile.</p><p>The power profile is interesting. Peyton Graham has a Max EV of just 109.9 MPH although he has topped 109 four times, all with Hawkeye. His raw power is above-average but it’s nothing elite. Peyton Graham has room to grow into his frame too and add even more power. The build is very projectable and he has the bat speed and rotational ability as a foundation for further strength gains to take him to new heights. Peyton Graham has power consistency issues and as such only has a 6.8% barrel rate (71st percentile). So are the 20 homers a fluke? Not even close.</p><p>Peyton Graham has perfect game power optimization. He has an 87th percentile outfield flyball rate and pulls 31.4% of his outfield flyballs. That helps his flyballs find their way over the wall. What really is the difference maker though is once against the elite feel for spinning his batted balls.</p><p>Peyton Graham hits 91.4% of his flyballs with backspin and has an average spin rate of 3348 RPMs on them. That adds probably close to 15 feet of carry to his average flyball and juiced his HR/FB rates well beyond what the barrel rate would suggest. Do you know who else consistently outperforms their barrel rates in the power department? That’s right! Tim Anderson.</p><p>Peyton Graham clearly fits at shortstop for the time being. He’s a plus athlete with both plus arm strength and plus speed. I like the infield actions fine and he showcases good range. There’s some third base risk if he grows into his frame, but he’s a 45 shortstop projection right now. He also can really hit.</p><p>Tim Anderson is supposed to be a unicorn. Randy Arozarena has some things in common but it’s not the same. It feels unrealistic to expect a random college guy in Graham to walk that very fine line and replicate how Anderson finds his success. The upside here is huge but there’s some risk because the profile is unique. Despite, the risk he earns a first round grade because of the upside and the fact that there’s also a more conventional route to the majors where he just fills in and becomes a big power third baseman, the body and swing both make such a path very possible. Graham is an unconventional player but I think he’s probably a good one.</p><h4>27. SP Jacob Miller, Liberty Union High School</h4><p>Jacob Miller is one of my favorite prep arms based on pure present day stuff quality. There are four pitches of quality here and throws strikes at a healthy enough rate to start. There are warts in the profile but as far as the foundation goes, Miller is about as good as you can find from a prep arm.</p><p>The fastball is the worst pitch in Jacob Miller’s arsenal. The fastball sat 91–93 MPH last summer and topped out at just 95 MPH and had slightly below-average extension. The movement is similarly unspectacular. Miller averaged just 13.8&quot; IVB and 13.7&quot; HB after adjusting for the height of the seams on the high school ball. He has good feel for spin averaging a little over 2300 RPMs but not enough efficiency to really miss bats. The pitch is still solid due to a 5.6 ft vertical release point and 1.5 ft horizontal release but it doesn’t really grade out as any better than average. Then this spring rolled around and MIller sat 93–95 MPH and has hit as high as 99 MPH. That bumps this up to an above-average grade now.</p><p>The curveball is an above-average pitch. Jacob Miller averaged 78.6 MPH with spin rates a little over 2500 RPMs last summer. He gets above-average movement on both planes with -9.9&quot; IVB and 11.7 inches of sweep. What’s interesting is the curveball actually has a 6:30 axis, the sidespin comes from inefficient spin efficiency that leads to seam-shifted wake. I think it’s likely that as he tightens up his curveball shape, the pitch finds itself getting a lot more depth and becomes more distinct. The feel for the breaking ball is top notch and he can land it for a strike with solid regularity.</p><p>The slider has promising sweeper traits, and given the natural feel for the seam-shifted wake he already shows with the curve, I think it’s very possible to make the sweeper special. The pitch is thrown moderately hard at 81.6 MPH but the movement is what sets it apart. The slider averages -1.6&quot; IVB and 9.4&quot; HB. The pitch regularly gets batters to expand the zone and fish them out of the dirt. I think right now, the slider and curve blend together more often than not but they are different pitches, and I think just naturally accentuating the best traits of both in his development will make them distinct without extra work needed.</p><p>The changeup rounds out the repertoire and I somewhat controversially also have it as an above-average pitch. Jacob Miller has somewhat limited command of the changeup and uses it very sparingly. He only threw two of them with pitch tracking. One of them missed arm side for a ball and the other got a chase in the dirt and was weakly rolled over. The command is not there. What is there is the shape. Those two changeups averaged 81.4 MPH and he was sitting in that same range this spring. He also averaged 6.8&quot; IVB and 20 inches of arm side run on those two pitches. Yes, small sample but wow. He has feel to pronate at a high level and creates lots of movement on the changeup. It’s a high risk pitch with a potentially massive payoff.</p><p>Jacob Miller’s delivery has some recoil and an aggressive arm stroke that causes some pause. There is not really any projection in terms of future strength gains but you don’t need those given that he is now hitting 99 MPH. Jacob Miller has the best secondary stuff in the prep class and the fastball is decent too. I could make a good argument that Miller is the second best prep arm in the draft. I don’t actually have him there but you could easily argue it. There are four quality pitches and he had just a 1.7 BB/9 in his final year of high school. There is Ace upside here even though I think Miller probably will not reach it. He’s easily worth late first round money for me.</p><h4>28. CF Jud Fabian, Florida</h4><p>I had Jud Fabian ranked in this exact spot one year ago when he went in the second round to Boston but failed to sign which is a hilarious coincidence. Jud Fabian got better this year so he probably should be higher but despite the skill improvements, the risk remains the same and the upside didn’t actually move significantly ( I also think this year’s draft is a bit better).</p><p>Jud Fabian has a very suspect hit tool- you know, probably. The contact skills are bad. I shouldn’t need to say that. Early in the year, he had league-average contact rates in the strike zone but an ugly May dropped him back down to just 78.8%. Jud Fabian has decent whiff rates against breaking balls and elite swinging-strike rates. He also has added changeup domination to his skillset this year.</p><p>The problem remains the high fastball. Against four-seamers in the top half, Fabian has a 28.6% Swinging-Strike rate in games with Trackman this year. This isn’t a velocity problem- just a location one. Fastball up and Fabian perishes, fastball misses down, and the pitcher is the one to die.</p><p>The BABIP skill is what I would rather focus on. Jud Fabian had just a .222 BABIP this year after running a .283 mark last year. Yet, according to a source, his expected BABIP based on quality of contact was .333 this year. That is not actually that great for a college bat but it is a whole lot better than whatever Jud was this year. So was it bad luck? Not particularly. Fabian had a 7th percentile popup rate and 25th percentile line drive rate per FaBIO. I don’t really know what xBABIP is seeing but I don’t see good BABIPs out of anything but the hard contact in the profile.</p><p>The power is elite in games. Jud Fabian only has a Max EV of 110 MPH in Trackman games but I will always take the over on his power production. Fabian has 96th percentile feel for hitting outfield flyballs and that leads to a 17.7% barrel rate this year (98th percentile). He plays above even that too because Jud Fabian has the highest rate of pulled flyballs in the entire SEC and is at 50% pulled in trackman games. This means he is very shiftable and further kills the BABIPs but it’s why the in-game power production is arguably the best in the SEC. Fabian should continue to run elite in-game power production because he hits the ball hard and in the air to the pullside. This means magical things occur regularly.</p><p>Jud Fabian’s key to success is simply to stop swinging at the high fastball. Jud Fabian swings at 61.2% of pitches in the top half. I think it’s fairly likely that Jud Fabian can stop swinging so much. This is literally the player with the best swing decisions in the country according to Mason McRae. The ability to recognize pitches and only swing when it makes sense is the best in the draft. Now he just has to tailor his swing decisions to fit Jud’s strengths rather than the average player.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?type=text%2Fhtml&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;schema=twitter&amp;url=https%3A//mobile.twitter.com/mason_mcrae/status/1535035587983560723&amp;image=https%3A//i.embed.ly/1/image%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fabs.twimg.com%252Ferrors%252Flogo46x38.png%26key%3Da19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07" width="500" height="281" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/826716b3cc94920caa3ed04026cfd06e/href">https://medium.com/media/826716b3cc94920caa3ed04026cfd06e/href</a></iframe><p>Jud can afford to take the called strike on pitches in the top half. Fabian makes quality contact against secondaries and whiffs just 26.4% of the time against non-four-seam fastballs. Jud Fabian also will punish any four-seamer that misses low. I think that Jud would be limited in some matchups- you never want him hitting against someone like Joe Ryan, but with creative managing would still be an extremely valuable bat.</p><p>Joey Gallo has the same issue, he whiffs 43.2% of the time on fastballs in the top half in his career (And can’t hit breaking balls too!). The key difference between Gallo and Fabian though is that Gallo only swings at 47% of pitches in the top half. There is also an argument for flattening the bat path but I would rather not jeopardize the power by doing so.</p><p>Jud Fabian is also a plus centerfielder. He’s only a plus runner but the speed absolutely plays out there because he has elite burst and crisp routes, with the ability to go up and steal homeruns, or lay out and make highlight reel diving catches. The arm strength is also above-average and he’s pretty accurate too. Here are some fun numbers courtesy of Mason once again:</p><blockquote>“When we look at expected data on balls hit into Jud’s territory, hitters have a batting average 27 points lower than the expected rate, and a slugging percentage 68 points lower. When we look at the rest of the country and on balls hit into CF, hitters have an average 42 points higher than their expected one with a slugging percentage 25 higher. So relative to the average CF, Jud is saving 69 points in batting average, and 67 points in slugging percentage. The difference between the top offense, and the 35th best.” — <a href="https://masonmcrae.medium.com/breaking-down-the-top-22-draft-prospects-analytically-7c6c5cc1bea4">Mason McRae</a></blockquote><p>Jud Fabian is a fourth year junior but he’s still the same age (And experience level) as Jace Jung is this year and Henry Davis was last year when he was taken at #1 overall. His experience isn’t why he’s good. I think Fabian has hit a wall developmentally and any growth has been minimal since the Cape in 2019. That is not his ceiling but he probably needs to go somewhere other than Florida to further develop since they seem content with what Fabian already is. There is tons of hit tool risk here but I think Fabian likely profiles somewhat similarly to Joey Gallo with better defense but slightly less game power as well. It’s hard to shoot the moon with your first-round pick but Fabian is worth the risk because he has the talent to be a superstar even with hit tool questions.</p><h4>29. SP Brandon Barriera, American Heritage High School</h4><p>I have gone back and forth on Barriera quite a bit but I think I’ve learned to love the profile. I don’t trust very many teams to actually develop him into a major league starting pitcher but in the right system, Barriera could be incredible. I tend to assume good player development when ranking prospects so I have Barriera inside the first round despite some ugly black spots on the current projection.</p><p>The fastball is thrown hard. Barriera sits 93–96 MPH and has been running it up to 99 MPH this spring from the left handed side. The fastball is also outright horrendous. The pitch has just 10.3&quot; IVB and 3.9&quot; HB on average and that’s without even adjusting for the elevated seam height of the high school baseball. This is an ugly dead zone pitch that will get hammered at any speed.</p><p>The fastball sucks but it shouldn’t be his primary anyways. I want Barriera to ditch the terrible four-seam fastball for a cutter. After talking with multiple people in the industry, I’ve realized Barriera’s never going to get that much carry on his four-seamer. His wrist orientation doesn’t allow for it. The natural supination though makes him an ideal cutter candidate. Barriera already has no efficiency on his fastball and solid spin rates so it’s just a matter of starting to channel that 0% spin efficiency efficiently. Cutting the ball seems like the best way to do that.</p><p>The curveball has stupid movement. The spin rates are consistently over 2600 and it’s actually a pretty efficient pitch. He’s flashed -22.5&quot; IVB which is just absurd even if he’s more consistently sitting ~-15&quot;. That is still insane by the way. The curve has close to ten inches of sweep as well. He needs more power as he sits at ~77 MPH but the shape is really strong so it still easily warrants a plus grade.</p><p>The slider is a hard pitch to gauge. He often sits 82–85 MPH with plus spin rates. The pitch has high gyro angle and plus vertical depth, averaging -1.8 IVB. The real appeal here though is the sweeper potential. Barriera doesn’t average a ton of sweep but he’ll occasionally break one off with double digit horizontal break and leave batters flailing. The release is somewhat wide and he has an elite feel for gyro spin so it’s easy to see him utilizing SSW to create a wipeout sweeper. It’s only an above-average grade but the upside is high in Barriera’s slider.</p><p>The changeup does two things at a high level. He kills spin and creates vertical depth. The changeup is nearly 900 RPMs lower than the fastball on average while coming in about 8 MPH slower. He also gets just 3.7 IVB on average. That is plus vertical depth. The problem is that Barriera doesn’t even really flash good horizontal movement. He really struggles to create arm side movement with his arsenal.</p><p>I think Barriera should probably switch to a splitter and lean into the strengths of his offspeed- kill spin and kill lift. Of course, just about zero lefties throw splitters so it might not be a realistic ask. I have the changeup graded as average because it’s not going to function at all as is on top of the always present command/feel concerns but its upside is high because he has two very important plus characteristics.</p><p>The command is above-average from Barriera and I suspect that with the fastball shape, Barriera will always have an above-average batted ball profile as well. His mechanics are gorgeous with excellent optimization for velocity without hurting command in the process or creating excessive injury risk. The athleticism is superb as well. Barriera offers four quality pitches and throws strikes but given that he’s a project, he’s more of a late first round target for me. If a smart team takes him in the top 15 or whatever, I will have no problems with him going that high.</p><h4>30. SP/RP Landon Sims, Mississippi State</h4><p>Landon Sims was maybe the most dominant pitcher in baseball over the last two seasons. He posted just a 1.38 ERA with a 46.7% strikeout rate and just a 6.3% walk rate. He was the highest-rated pitcher from a Power 5 school according to FaBIO. However, most of those 72 innings came in relief and his elbow went pop this spring so now he is out a year with Tommy John Surgery.</p><p>Landon Sims has a lethal fastball. The pitch sits at 94.3 MPH and has touched as high as 97.8 MPH in the last two seasons. In that same span, Sims is averaging 18.5&quot; IVB and 5 inches of arm side tail. Sims still dominates with the heater despite somewhat pedestrian movement because he has a very unique approach angle. Sims throws from a 5.67 RelHeight and a 3.00 RelSide. He has an elite feel to elevate the fastball and can command it on both sides of the plate. The pitch has been incredibly effective over the last two years with a 28.2% in-zone whiff rate. I would grade the heater closer to a plus than an elite grade but it is a very good pitch nevertheless.</p><p>The slider traits don’t actually jump off the page. He has 10.7 inches of sweep on average but doesn’t kill any lift so it’s only at 5.9&quot; IVB. The slider sits at 84.8 MPH and he averages 2420 RPMs. The slider HAA plays up because of the arm slot and he completely dismantles right-handed hitters with the glove side slider to the tune of a 27.8% Swinging-Strike rate on the glove side third of the plate.</p><p>Usually, a one-plane slider like the one Sims has that only offers sweep can’t do diddly squat against left-handed hitters. This should be even more true given the arm angle. Except, you’re forgetting the best part of Landon Sims’ slider. Sims has elite slider command and that makes all the difference in the world. Landon Sims lands 29.1% of his sliders on the arm side. Against left-handed hitters, his average slider has a plate location of 0.58 ft. Against righties, it is -0.53 ft for comparison. He pounds the backdoor slider against lefties and holy cow does it work. Sims has a 55.3% CSW on sliders to his arm side.</p><p>Let’s rewind for a second. Landon Sims does the exact same thing with his fastball. Sims has an average fastball location of 0.58&#39; arm side against lefties. He throws his fastball with an average location of -0.10&#39; against righties. The appeal of Landon Sims is immaculate command of both his pitches against batters of both handednesses. He always keeps the fastball and slider on the same side of the plate to maximize their synergy. Landon Sims stuff-wise profiles as a guy who should have a massive platoon split but he really doesn’t have one at all. He’s more dependent on called strikes against lefties but he misses just as many bats and only walks slightly more hitters.</p><p>Landon Sims only really has two pitches. He’s thrown the changeup twice with trackman and the specs are not remotely good. I have very little hope of Sims developing a third pitch. The batted ball profile is highly flawed with him really failing to excel in every area. He’s going to give up a lot of homers with how aggressively he fills the zone and his fair share of singles as well.</p><p>Ultimately, I still think Sims can start though because of exceptional command. Landon Sims only needs two pitches because even if his shape changes (Called Strikes versus LHB, Swinging against RHB), he still decimates everyone he faces and should always have very strong K/BB ratios. There is relief risk in the profile but he looks like a starting pitcher even with just two pitches because of elite command. Tommy John hurts but as I said with Lesko, it’s not that big of a turnoff for me.</p><h4>31. RP Ben Joyce, Tennessee</h4><p>I go much more in-depth on Ben Joyce in tomorrow’s blog on the best relief prospects so I’ll keep this somewhat brief. Yes, Ben Joyce is a pure reliever. I still have a first-round grade on him. I think with the way teams value relievers on the trade market, and in free agency; one with surefire shutdown stuff like Joyce should be in consideration as a first-round pick.</p><p>Ben Joyce throws his fastball with generational velocity. He tops out at 105.5 MPH and averaged 101.4 MPH in games with Trackman. Both of those figures have only ever been approached by Aroldis Chapman. The fastball would still be an elite pitch if he only sits 97 MPH though. The pitch has a 4.2° VAA because he throws from a 5.05 ft release height and has decent vertical movement. His VAA is actually playing down too because Joyce doesn’t elevate the fastball. It’s the same location-neutral VAA as Edwin Diaz with plus tailing action as well. 80-grade pitch without question.</p><p>The slider has such rabid fans that some of the more out there ones try to claim it is even better than the fastball. I disagree but it’s a fantastic pitch as well. Joyce gets 17.6 inches of sweep on average which is in the 97th percentile and from a 2.25 RelSide that plays up even further. The pitch plays down because he’s throwing it 17 MPH slower than the fastball and as a result there is no tunnel but it’s still a plus pitch that would be truly elite if he added more velocity to it.</p><p>I don’t even hate Ben Joyce’s changeup. The command and control are not particularly good. The batted ball profile projects as robust though and even most elite relievers have control woes. They aren’t that much of a detriment. There are workload concerns but even with him only throwing 40 innings a year, if you a contender have him healthy for the postseason every year, then he’s a worthwhile selection because the stuff is going to single-handedly win playoff games. Joyce has risk but he’s going to assuredly be an impact player if he’s even somewhat healthy.</p><p>Even if Joyce’s elbow spontaneously combusts after four years, you still probably are getting more out of Joyce than the majority of first round picks will provide to their team. There is no absurd upside outcome here but the difference between his 90th percentile outcome and the median outcome is primarily just health. This is a plug and play MLB high leverage relief Ace (Who should be shutdown after the draft to protect the elbow coming off of TJS; so plug and play in 2023).</p><h4>32. CF/LF Justin Crawford, Bishop Gorman High School</h4><p>Justin Crawford is the son of Carl Crawford and prior to this spring, I would have forced a comp between the two. Justin is an 80 grade runner with a 6.11 seconds 60 yd dash (Second fastest at the event, something was whack that even since Gupton ran a 5.96). He’s also a plus contact hitter with a below-average arm who might fit best in left field because despite elite speed. Except, something crazy happened this spring. Justin Crawford muscled up and now has above-average raw power.</p><p>Justin Crawford has above-average bat speed. His bat path is more contact-oriented so it doesn’t really play ing names though. He is starting to at least show impact gap power now though as Crawford has filled in. His Max EV last summer was just 88.6 MPH in games and 100.2 MPH in BP. I don’t have the exit velocity to back it up but that appears to not be the case anymore. He has hit some absolute tanks and is stinging the ball regularly. I think given the still projectable build and compact swing, Crawford probably has an above-average raw power projection in his future with the potential for plus.</p><p>The contact skill is the calling card here. Justin Crawford has made contact at an elite rate this spring with a 3.9% strikeout rate at a good school in Bishop Gorman. He whiffed some last summer with Hawkeye but was good in the other games, so I’m ignoring that tiny sample input. The bat path is simple and he has no trouble hitting velocity. I do have some concerns with him topping the ball but groundballs are a winning strategy when you have 80 grade speed.</p><p>Make no mistake, Justin Crawford does indeed have 80 grade speed. He’s filled in some but it doesn’t look like he’s lost a single step. Maybe as he continues to grow the speed will actually decline but I’m not betting on it. That 80 grade speed should play in the form of elite range in the outfield. There is some question on if he has the arm strength to stick in centerfield as his arm is clearly below-average strength wise but I think he has the range to make the lack of arm strength not all that important.</p><p>Slight tweener risk but he’s a centerfielder who shows flashes of a plus hit/power combo. He will likely only settle in with average power but that still will play every day of the week. Justin Crawford is also reportedly a very high makeup kid and he has the bloodlines a lot of teams covet. He’s also a model darling as he’ll be just 17.5 on draft day. I get the early first-round appeal, even if I have graded at the very back of the first.</p><h4>33. C Dalton Rushing, Louisville</h4><p>Dalton Rushing is a slam dunk first round target for me and the fact that some people don’t even have him in the first two rounds will never fail to surprise me. His batted ball data is on par with the last Louisville catcher, Henry Davis. In case you forgot, Davis went #1 overall. Rushing has a better approach at the plate too. You could even argue that Rushing is the better defensive catcher.</p><p>Dalton Rushing was in the 94th percentile of catcher DRS according to TruMedia (Sourced). His framing is maybe a bit rough but who cares when Manfred has promised Robo-Umps in 2024 already? He’s not athletic in the traditional sense and is a lumberer but he clearly is capable of playing behind the plate.</p><p>Dalton Rushing only has a 30% caught stealing rate but steals are often on the pitcher and the arm strength and pop times both grade out pretty highly. Dalton Rushing has an 82nd percentile pop time averaging 1.98 seconds on all throws but if we isolate it to just their top 10% of throws (How statcast does pop time but they separate based on the bag stolen) then Rushing has the highest pop time in the country. Rushing is also in the 82nd percentile of 90th throw velo. The arm strength is clearly there for Rushing to stick behind the plate as long as a team wants him there.</p><p>Dalton Rushing is a good defensive catcher but the bat is what makes him worthy of a first-round pick. Dalton Rushing led the entire country in Hard-Hit rate this year. His Max EV is technically 115.6 MPH but it’s likely a misread. The hardest hit batted ball with a launch angle above 0° is only 110.2 MPH. The top 8th EV is also only in the 93rd percentile. Rushing has plus raw power but it’s not quite as good as the hard-hit rate suggests it to be.</p><p>The game power is more up to speed with the hard-hit rate though because Rushing has elite power optimization. His outfield flyball rate is in the 97th percentile per FaBIO and when combined with the elite hard-hit rates that lead to an 18.6% barrel rate which is in the 99th percentile of college players. Rushing also has fantastic spin traits that enable him to hit for more homers. The average batted ball from Rushing has a 95th percentile spin rate and an 83rd percentile backspin%. He gets extra carry on his aerial contact and he hits everything hard. Predictably, elite results occur.</p><p>Dalton Rushing also makes fantastic swing decisions. Rushing swings at just 22% of out of zone pitches and swings 66% of the time in the strike zone. His chase rates against breaking balls are particularly stellar as he only chases 17.9% of those (Also only swings at 40% in the zone though).</p><p>You would probably expect there to be a 60% contact rate or something to explain why a catcher with such good game power and a good approach is so widely disrespected. Rushing is below-average in that regard but a 77.4% contact rate and 83.8% contact rate in the strike zone are far from terrible.</p><p>But the shape of the contact rates is what matters here. 54.6% of Dalton Rushing’s swings are against fastballs (They make up 44.5% of pitches he sees). Rushing crushes fastballs right now. The problem is that we can’t be certain that will translate because Rushing has a 48.2% whiff rate on 74 pitches at 93+.</p><p>This is not a huge sample size but velocity issues are scary in any sample. There is a chance that the offense completely collapses against higher velocity stuff. We had the same concern with Cal Raleigh out of college and he’s still developed into a top ten catcher. There is also the chance that 74 pitches are way too small of a sample and the contact rates remain solid against fastballs.</p><p>There is some risk here but I tend to think it gets blown out of proportion. Rushing shows advanced pitch recognition and has the ability to hit the ball with authority. He’s a good catcher with both an arm and a glove. You don’t need elite batting averages for Rushing because he can still succeed in other ways. I don’t think the hit tool is particularly good but it’s enough for the power/on-base profile to play even with velocity issues.</p><h4>34. SP Carson Whisenhunt, East Carolina</h4><p>Carson Whisenhunt was the top 2022 draft-eligible pitcher during the 2021 season according to FaBIO and the stuff metrics weren’t that far behind the results. Whisenhunt missed all of the 2022 season with a PED suspension and that hurt his draft stock for some reason. He’s been back to pitching in the Cape and the stuff reportedly grades out about where it was last year. The results haven’t been there because the command is rusty but he still has the same upside. As a bonus, unlike most college arms, Whisenhunt won’t have to be shut down after being drafted to protect the arm. You can instead work on stretching him out now and make immediate changes.</p><p>The fastball velocity doesn’t blow you away but for a lefty sitting 92.5 MPH is perfectly fine. The fastball has fairly average spin rates on an 11:00 axis but is close to perfect spin efficiency. As such, the pitch gets 19.5 IVB and 12.3 HB. His release isn’t special from a 6.13 RelHeight and a 1.52 RelSide but the movement still plays. There is some velocity projection here as well and you would hope that his taking steroids wasn’t in vain and has also improved the velocity. I have an above-average projection on the heater even if it is more average right now.</p><p>The changeup had a 42% Swinging-Strike rate last year on 207 of them with Trackman. That’s all you need to know about it.</p><p>Okay, fine, I’ll give you a little more. The changeup sits 9 MPH slower than the fastball at 83.5 MPH on average and just under 500 RPMs lower at 1708 RPMs. The pitch averages 9.7 IVB and 15.5 HB. The real draw here is the armspeed, fastball tunnel, and arm side command though. He probably won’t get chases 55% of the time at the next level but I doubt he goes from a 42% Swinging-Strike rate to anything less than a plus. The pitch is just utterly obscene in the scope of it’s dominance.</p><p>The curveball rounds out his repertoire and earns average grades. The pitch has -10.2&quot; IVB and 6.2 inches of sweep. He sits at 79 MPH with plus feel for spinning the ball. The biggest draw though is his ability to land the curve for strikes so consistently. The pitch is his worst pitch but given the arm speed, I still like its upside to be at least average.</p><p>The pitch to contact profile is actually probably the most enticing element of Whisenhunt’s game. Carson Whisenhunt uses the low fastball to perfection despite its vertical movement being better suited up in the zone. The low fastball is a large part of why the changeup is so lethal but it also has major benefits in terms of his batted ball profile.</p><p>The low fastball gets groundballs at a 92nd percentile clip as due to the medial release he gets chases to the arm side, and the higher angle helps make him tough to square up down. I think the groundball rate will fall to like ~75th percentile against good hitting but it should always be strong. Whisenhunt is also getting popups at an average rate because of the threat of the high fastball and the ability to jam people inside. Finally, the horizontal action of his stuff lets him miss barrels and have a plus batted ball profile as a whole.</p><p>Carson Whisenhunt does have some control issues that need to be worked out. The lack of changeups in the zone is a bit of a red flag because he won’t get so many chases at the next level. It’s still a 65 grade pitch but he issues out on an elite grade because of it despite inhuman results. Whisenhunt offers elite out-generation skills though with three quality pitches from the left handed side. He’s a somewhat flawed arm but I think he’s worthy of a late first round pick at about slot value.</p><h4>35. SS/3B/OF Cameron Smith, Palm Beach Central</h4><p>Cameron Smith is one of if not the oldest high school players in this year’s draft. He will be 19.4 on draft day and that is adversely affecting his stock which is already hurt by how late Smith bloomed. Cameron Smith was a JV nobody until 2021 when he posted a video of himself hitting 97 MPH off a tee with a wood bat on Twitter with @FlatgroundBats tagged in the post. A few months later he was on his varsity team with a commitment to Florida State. He has not been invited to most showcase games because he bloomed so late but he’s done nothing but mash in a 7A High School this year (Led all Florida 7A players in OPS) and has a very sweet swing with good athleticism.</p><p>The power is the calling card here. Cameron Smith has what appears to visually be plus bat speed and gets fantastic torque in his swing. The way he manages the lower half is incredible. His hip hinge is extremely prominent and his load is efficient. The way he manages his backside stands out more than anything. He has a stable base and collapses the backside once the torso starts to move to give it an extra bit of juice and effectively shifts his weight to his front side. He proved his power with the farthest hit ball at the draft combine and I think he is only going to get stronger as Smith is still very lanky.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?type=text%2Fhtml&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;schema=twitter&amp;url=https%3A//mobile.twitter.com/cameron_smith24/status/1526620278914162688&amp;image=https%3A//i.embed.ly/1/image%3Furl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fabs.twimg.com%252Ferrors%252Flogo46x38.png%26key%3Da19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07" width="500" height="281" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/41fa9785199bc234f30e4da8d5926b5b/href">https://medium.com/media/41fa9785199bc234f30e4da8d5926b5b/href</a></iframe><p>Unlike most people who generate a ton of power with their entire body, I don’t really think Cameron Smith has any hit tool problems. He struck out just 7.2% of the time in a 7A Florida School as a senior and the swing looks great. His bat path is simple and clean with a good plane and he should have no trouble hitting velocity. The spin recognition is a risk because we haven’t seen Smith against good prep arms yet but it’s a risk worth taking. Cameron Smith also shows above-average barrel accuracy and even had the 6th highest sweet-spot rate there. The hit tool has risk but I have zero problems throwing an average grade on it because the upside is also pretty high.</p><p>The athleticism is a bit contested and him not participating in the draft combine’s athletic testing (Still recovering from a hip strain I believe, but not entirely certain) has left things somewhat murky. I’m got some 70-grade run times on him on home to first plays but home to first runs are notoriously volatile. I do like the athleticism and still, have him graded as a plus runner despite the larger build but if he fills in, he could wind up closer to the average projection some have him at.</p><p>I’ve come away impressed every time I’ve watched Cameron Smith play shortstop. He has plus arm strength and excellent arm utility as well- a must for a shortstop. He has some general accuracy issues but he can make throws off balance with enough strength to get it to first in time. Smith is big and that doesn’t say shortstop but he still plays low to the ground and is excellent at charging in for balls. He has some issues when ranging to his arm side as he often will early commit but the overall defensive profile is that of a quality shortstop. There is some third base risk if he gets too big but he’ll be a stellar defender there. I’ve actually seen a few people suggest that he plays centerfield but I don’t really see it.</p><p>Cameron Smith is one of my favorite players in the entire draft. I can and have watched him swing the bat for hours. The swing is incredibly crisp and just as effective as it looks. Smith is a great athlete with projection and present strength as well. He’s older but if he was just a year younger, I’m not sure he makes it out of the first fifteen picks. I’ve heard great things about the makeup and I think better things of his talent.</p><h4>36. CF/RF Jacob Melton, Oregon State</h4><p>Jacob Melton doesn&#39;t really have the tools of any of the other players I have a first round grade on. What Melton offers is just well-rounded goodness and elite barrel precision that makes him highly likely to profile as an everyday player in the majors even if it won’t be a starring role in all likelihood. Melton is just a good ballplayer.</p><p>The contact skills are interesting. Jacob Melton has below-average contact rates with just a 72% contact rate over the last two years (Sourced). However, I’m optimistic that will improve (He was also up to like ~76.1% this year) in time. Melton’s breakdown of whiffs is absolutely fascinating. Jacob Melton has very strong whiff rates against breaking balls (at least in Trackman games this year) whiffing just 21.1% of the time against them.</p><p>Where Melton falters is against fastballs and offspeed stuff. Melton doesn’t look particularly bad against high-end velocity. Melton only has one whiff against 91+ this year with Trackman. He isn’t bad at hitting stuff up in the zone either. What ties Melton up appears to be the concept of arm side movement from same-handed pitchers especially. I don’t really understand it either. I think given that he has no issues with stuff moving glove side or location-wise, the issues are probably solvable? Maybe? Melton does make good swing decisions as a whole with a 70.5% Z-Swing and 23.4% chase rate.</p><p>The raw power is ahead of the game power. Jacob Melton has a Max EV of 111.4 MPH. His 90th EV over the last two years is 107.2 MPH. He has a 49% hard-hit rate. There is plus raw power here. The problem is that Melton can’t put the ball in the air. 47.2% of his batted balls since the start of 2021 are hit on the ground. Melton’s power still plays because he has good barrel accuracy (Lots of LD and lower FB) and optimal sprays but the power isn’t where it could be.</p><p>Jacob Melton is a plus runner with a fringe chance of sticking in centerfield and enough arm strength to stick in right field if center doesn’t work out. The bat is the calling card here with a potentially above-average hit/power combo but he’s only in the first round discussion because he probably can play centerfield. I really don’t think Melton will light the world on fire but he could hit like .260 with 20/20 seasons every year and you would be more than happy with that production.</p><h4>37. SP Walter Ford, Pace High School</h4><p>Walter Ford is probably ranked too low by having him only at the tail end of the first round grades. He’s the youngest arm in the draft and he has an elite feel for spin. He was incredible in his final year of high school. The delivery is artistry in action and he projects for even more velocity despite already hitting 97 MPH. There is a lot to like here for sure but he is very much presently a project arm.</p><p>Walter Ford’s primary attraction might be the delivery. He has elite movements on the mound throughout and it makes it very easy to dream of him developing even more velocity. He gets incredible scap retraction and plunges deep with his arm action to delay the torso rotation. There is excellent torso rotation here and he has elite arm speed. His arm is consistently on time and I think Ford will hit triple digits in his prime. The athlete is incredible and it’s also likely he grows into above-average control.</p><p>The fastball is a somewhat complicated pitch. The feel for spin is some of the best in the draft with Ford sitting at ~2400 RPMs and touching 2700. The fastball also has good velocity at the present time sitting 92–94 MPH and it should only get better. Those two traits make it easy to dream on a plus fastball but it’s a little more complicated than that.</p><p>The fastball shape is not great. He has a tendency to cut the ball and as such only averages 17&quot; IVB (~15&quot; when adjusted for seam height) and 3.7 HB. I don’t think there’s any reason he can’t stop cutting the ball, it’s not a wrist orientation issue or anything but it’s not a guarantee he will fix it either and the current shape is outright bad. He also throws from a higher release at 6.1&#39; which puts him a bit of a gray spot even if he fixes the efficiency.</p><p>The slider is fatal. His is a sweeper due to the heavy seam-shifted wake traits on it. He sits around 80 MPH with double digit sweep and approximately 0&quot; IVB. The pitch has absurd spin rates as well sitting at 2700 RPMs on most of them. The pitch flashes 70 grade stuff when he’s working in the low-mid eighties but he is more consistently in the upper seventies where it looks more flat. The slider is the primary reason for not fixing the fastball as changing the release positioning could destroy the slider&#39;s sweep. I still think it’s a worthwhile change but there’s an argument for keeping him as is and trying to make him a bowling ball pitcher.</p><p>The changeup rounds out the repertoire and earns an average grade from me. I think the feel for creating seam-shifted wake will do wonders and he’s an elite athlete with arm speed. It’s very much a work in progress like the rest of the package but there’s obvious potential here.</p><p>Walter Ford has the upside to make everyone who passes on him look very foolish but he’s so young and unrefined that the risk is probably too great for most teams to take round one. I disagree and have him at the very back of it.</p><h3>45 FVs</h3><h4>38. LF/CF Brock Jones, Stanford</h4><p>Spoiler warning but the next four college hitters on my board all fall under the same umbrella. They all have major hit questions but are gods when they make contact and have other desirable aspects. Brock Jones is at the front of this tier with a slight edge because of the more disciplined approach with Jones only chasing 18.6% of the time in the last two years (69% Z-Swing%).</p><p>He has just a 35% contact rate over the last two years (Sourced so actually a good sample size) but he’s still 15th in wOBA for a variety of reasons. He has perhaps the best game power in the nation with 34.8% of his batted balls with Trackman in the last two-years being hit hard and with a launch angle between 10° and 35°. He has a .522 xwOBAcon in that span. What’s interesting is he only actually has a 43% groundball rate- it’s just all his aerial contact is hit optimally. Jones avoids mishits and that makes him a fantastic offensive force.</p><p>The catch is that the max exit velocity in a 57 BBE sample size is only 109.5 MPH. You can probably say that’s a fluke but if Jones only has above-average raw power then the road to success becomes very narrow. Jones is a plus runner but is still a fringy fit in centerfield with only average range and a below-average arm. There is a road to stardom here but given the general whiff struggles, he’s too high risk for a first round pick unless you’re certain he can play centerfield. I personally think he probably winds up in left field.</p><h4>39. CF Gavin Turley, Hamilton High School</h4><p>Gavin Turley is probably ranked too low given that I have Elijah Green as the #2 player in the draft. Gavin Turley has comparable raw tools to Elijah Green. The arm strength is actually better than Green and he is also an elite runner- even if slightly less so. The defense likewise projects as a plus in centerfield and he has comparable burst there. The bat speed is an 80 grade tool and he has elite raw power with his long levers. There is also feel to elevate although he’s a less consistent rotator than Green in my looks.</p><p>Like with Elijah Green, the contact rates are the concern. Green struck out 23.5% of the time this year at IMG, the best high school in the country. Turley struck out 25.9% of the time at a random 6A school in Arizona. The latter figure is a lot more concerning given the quality of competition difference. I also think Turley has some approach concerns as well. The swing looks more uncontrolled and the bat path is longer. The hit tool is very high risk and it’s not like Green where I’m confident it will at least be playable but I might be overselling the difference in risk as the upside is very comparable.</p><h4>40. RF Dylan Beavers, California</h4><p>Dylan Beavers is another wOBAcon demon. He has only plus raw power with a Max EV of 109.6 MPH but it’s very consistent raw power with some of the top hard-hit rates in the nation. He also has some of the lowest groundball rates and fantastic barrel accuracy. There is some concern here with the power/barrel accuracy translating though because he failed to show any of it during the Cape Cod League with wooden bats. I still like the offensive profile and can certainly see why a team would take him in the first round, but the profile feels a bit too risky for me.</p><p>Dylan Beavers was a first round grade until the very-end of the process where he just barely got bumped down. Ultimately, I find it hard to fall in love with a corner outfielder only who has below-average contact rates- especially against breaking balls where he whiffs 48% of the time. The plate discipline is good but it’s not enough to overcome the defensive limitations. I will also note that Dylan Beavers strike zone according to Hawkeye is a little over six inches smaller (Height wise) than the average player his height. When the MLB switches to the automatic ball-strike system, the odds are fairly high that it’s dependent on height rather than batting stance. Beavers’ eye has some volatility as a result. There’s a good chance that he outperforms this ranking significantly but there’s also a decent chance he doesn’t provide much value at all because he’s really a one skill guy and that one skill is game power.</p><h4>41. SP Connor Prielipp, Arkansas</h4><p>Connor Prielipp was someone mentioned in the top five discussions before he tore his UCL last year and needed Tommy John Surgery. He’s working his way back now and has thrown a few bullpens before the draft where his stuff has been back to where it was before he tore the UCL. The thing is, I’m not actually sure Prielipp would have been a first round grade before the torn UCL even.</p><p>The fastball comes from a fairly high 6.3&#39; release height and only has average vertical movement. Prielipp sits at just 93 MPH and tops out a 96 MPH. The pitch has above-average spin rates but the shape and angle really don’t feel like enough. Yet, against all odds, in his 28 career innings, Prielipp is running a 33% in-zone whiff rate with the heater. The changeup is solid average with solid shape and a medial release but limited feel and inconsistent usage.</p><p>The slider is underwhelming? Sort of? He sits at 84 MPH on average with spin rates just under 2700. The pitch has a standard gyroball shape with average vertical depth and about 3 inches of gloveside movement. So why all the hype? The high release helps but the real draw is how it plays off the fastball apparently. One scout I talked to compared it to the way Robbie Ray’s four-seam and slider play off of each other and let somewhat mid-stuff on paper play up. The in-zone whiff rates support this theory.</p><p>Contractors will argue Prielipp had a ridiculously soft slate of opponents in his career- which is a true accusation. Prielipp threw just two innings against SEC opponents and allowed three runs in those two. Connor Prielipp throws strikes so if you buy in on the fastball/slider tunnel then I can get behind selecting him in the first round- even after TJS. I also think in the right organization, you can do some fun things with the changeup and make him a more well-rounded arm. I still question the individual pitches shapes too much for a round one grade but I am intrigued.</p><h4>42. RF Jordan Beck, Tennessee</h4><p>Jordan Beck is another big power bat with significant questions he still needs to answer. The Max EV is 113.5 MPH and he has a Top 8th EV of 108.8 MPH counting the Hawkeye games which is in the 97th percentile. He’s consistently scorching the ball and doing so in the air most of the time with what FaBIO has as an 80th percentile groundball rate. The game power is a bit worse than that might have you believe because he hits with a 16th percentile spin rate and a 7th percentile backspin% but it’s still plus game power.</p><p>So what warts does Beck have? It’s actually not defense as despite a right field projection, he could provide real defensive value. Jordan Beck has plus arm strength and above-average speed that actually plays up some in the field. There are some proponents of his who actually think he can play centerfield if not blocked by Drew Gilbert.</p><p>The contact skills are in question with a 28% whiff rate but it’s not as bad as it sounds. Beck actually has average in-zone whiff rates. The problem is that Beck chases 33% of the time and those chases lead to him striking out and not walking nearly enough. He also has fairly mediocre BABIP skills with subpar popup rates.</p><p>I totally understand why a team would want Beck in the first round with the power profile and general athleticism without major whiff concerns. I’m out because of the swing decisions but a team who thinks they can get him to stop chasing so many secondaries would be rewarded… Or at least a team would have wanted him in the first round. But then he flipped off his home crowd after hitting a homer to celebrate in the Supers. (That doesn’t actually matter, I just think it’s hilarious).</p><h4>43. SP Justin Campbell, Oklahoma State</h4><p>Justin Campbell doesn’t earn a first round grade from me but he has a lot of buzz in round one and depending on which team takes him, might wind up as one of my favorite first round picks. Campbell has the foundation to be one of the best players in the entire draft with good player development.</p><p>Justin Campbell has obscene vertical movement on his fastball. He averages 20.9&quot; IVB with Trackman and we know that is a legitimate reading because Campbell was also at 20.5&quot; in his start with Hawkeye. The fastball comes from a higher release with Hawkeye putting him at 6.13&#39; on average and a very medial horizontal release at 0.6&#39; (with Hawkeye) that lets his 11&quot; of tail play up. The pitch has incredible shape and should continue to miss a lot of bats at the next level.</p><p>The changeup is filthy and also warrants a plus grade. He throws it 12 MPH slower than the fastball with higher spin rates than the fastball. That is probably too much of a velocity difference to be optimal as he slows the arm a bit but it still has plus upside. Campbell gets 20 inches more drop with gravity, and has 17.7&quot; HB. The pitch plays up from the medial release and he can throw it in the zone.</p><p>The breaking balls are fringy but have upside. The slider is the more effective of the two right now. He sits at 1&quot; IVB and 6.8&quot; of sweep to his gloveside. The pitch doesn’t get a ton of chases but still has some use. The curveball has elite vertical depth with -16.5&quot; IVB and 7.7&quot; of sweep to go with it. In the Hawkeye games it is even better with -17.7&quot; IVB and 5.9&quot; HB. So why is it only average pitch despite 97th percentile vertical movement?</p><p>The reason for that is velocity- the sole reason why Justin Campbell isn’t in the first round. The curveball sits at just 75.9 MPH right now and slow curves don’t perform at the maor league level with a few exceptions. The slider sits at just 81 MPH. The changeup is at 79.5 MPH. The fastball has well-below average velocity with him sitting at just 91.5 MPH on average.</p><p>If Campbell can add velocity he will soar up this list. Given that he is 6&#39;7&quot;, a lot of scouts think it’s likely that he will do exactly that. I’m a bit more skeptical. Campbell has a poor loading mechanism and doesn’t rotate all that well. You need to make some fairly significant mechanical changes to see that much more velocity out of him.</p><p>The good news is Campbell throws a lot of strikes and has seen major gains in his batted ball profile this year. I think he is probably still a back of the rotation arm with upside, I just don’t know how likely that upside is to be manifested so he just misses a first-round grade from me.</p><h4>44. SS Max Martin, Moorestown High School</h4><p>Max Martin is a tooled up shortstop prospect. He’s somewhat lacking in raw power but he still should get close to average. The bat speed is above-average and he gets solid separation in his swing. The bat path is often optimal for creating elevation. He’s slightly built and has some barrel accuracy problems but there is real power upside here.</p><p>The hit tool is the calling card though. He has a very quick bat path (Also hurts power some) with explosive hand speed and has never struggled at all with even triple digit velocity (Chase Petty). His bat path is flexible and Martin loves to adjust his swing to fit where the pitch is and what kind it is. There’s some risk in a prep with a flush reliant approach because pitch recognition is so much harder at any other level but I’m still comfortable betting on his hit tool.</p><p>I really like Max Martin at shortstop and above him projected as an above-average defender. Martin is a plus runner who also shows the ability to move to both sides. The range is impressive and the actions are more than sufficient to stick at short. Martin throws has fairly average throw strength but I still have him as a 55 arm because of his accuracy and the ability he has to throw from multiple platforms.</p><p>Martin is kind of just a do everything prep. It’s a profile that would go very high after three years of performing at Rutgers but given the lack of elite upside, it’s hard to get behind him in round one right now. He’s a safer type of prospect in a demographic where the word safe is often completely inaccurate. I like the profile but not quite enough for a first round grade.</p><h4>45. CF/RF Colby Thomas, Mercer</h4><p>Colby Thomas rounds out this crop of college outfielders who hit the ball hard but have major flaws that create massive amounts of risk. The risk with Thomas is kind of beyond his control as a large part of it is simply that Thomas has not faced great pitching at Mercer. The other part is that Thomas still has below-average contact rates at 72.4% but like with Beck, that’s mostly because of the approach. He’s running an 83.3% contact rate on in-zone pitches but chases 30.2% of the time so he still has whiffs. The other concern is that Thomas has a popout problem.</p><p>Of course, to balance things out, Thomas has the best raw power. His max EV is 116.6 MPH and his top 8th EV is also in the 96th percentile. Colby Thomas also has a 90th percentile groundball rate in trackman games as well and also has the second highest batted ball spin rates in the country (Average backspin%). He’s going to produce high amounts of in-game power. As long as he makes enough contact to get to it that is. Thomas is a plus runner with a plus arm who is a fringe fit in centerfield. There is only really one tool here but it’s a spectacular one and there is the hope of more even if a boatload of risk is also present.</p><h4>46. SS Anthony Silva, Clark High School</h4><p>Anthony Silva had earned a first round grade from me leading up to the combine but he tested poorly in the events we can see the results from so he’s fallen. His stock was in large part based on incredible athleticism so him running a 3.8 30 yd dash is a bit scary. He also had the third lowest max barrel speed at the event. I sincerely hope that Silva was injured or something and that’s why he flopped so hard.</p><p>Anthony Silva had some of the best athletic testing in the class the previous summer. He has 99th percentile agility and 90th percentile speed paired with 90th percentile core strength, and even decent power from his lower half with a 65th percentile CMJ. The bat speed is at least average (inconsistent) and given the athletic testing it was easy to imagine him optimizing his mechanics to unlock more power. That picture is a little murkier now.</p><p>I still like Anthony Silva but it’s a lot more hit tool dependent now. He ran an 82% contact rate over the summer (Sourced so it’s a larger sample) with just a 21% chase rate. He struck out just 7% of the time as a senior. He has a quick bat with a concise bat path and shows the ability to pick up on spin. He’s still very likely to play shortstop as he has a plus arm and is probably still relatively agile. I also have always liked the actions. His stock took a hit at the combine but the upside remains and I still like him in the second round.</p><h4>47. SS/2B Mikey Romero, Orange Lutheran High School</h4><p>On the other side of the room, Mikey Romero probably improved his stock more than anyone else at the combine. He’s a hit first middle infielder who flashed some signs of raw power in the past with above-average speed in everything but the pelvic rotation but at the combine things just clicked. Romero had the fastest max barrel speed there at 84 MPH. He also had the sixth farthest hit so it wasn’t all ineffective contact.</p><p>I still have it as below-average game power because he prioritizes going to the other way with an early (late? Do you judge it on swing timing or how early in the swing it is?) connection point that causes the power to play down- and now that I think about it, might have caused the bat speed to look worse than it was in previous smaller sample showcases. The point is, there is at least above-average raw power here.</p><p>Romero makes contact at a very high rate- especially against pitches in the strike zone. His swing is short and punchy which leads to him hitting velocity and he shows feel for recognizing spin. The bat stays on plane for a while and he shows the ability to adjust to what he is seeing to avoid being beat multiple times. The barrel stays in the zone so the contact window is longer too. He’s a spray hitter with a bit too many mishits for my taste but it’s still a plus hit tool.</p><p>I think Romero will probably not stick at shortstop but he should be a good second baseman with his clean actions and hands. If Romero goes in the first round I will have no complaints but I think he’s probably still just a round two guy for me because he’s only an average athlete.</p><h4>48. SP Blade Tidwell, Tennessee</h4><p>The fastball headlines Blade Tidwell’s arsenal. He will sit at 95.5 MPH and touch as high as 99 MPH from the left-handed side. The fastball has above-average vertical movement at 18.8&quot; IVB on average and good horizontal life as well from an 11:00 spin axis. The angle isn’t fantastic from a 6.2&#39; RelHeight and 2.3&#39; RelSide but the pitch still projects as a plus given the velocity and movement pairing.</p><p>The slider is a plus projection as well, even if the present day value is a bit lower. He has a little over 10&quot; of sweep with 5&quot; IVB in the present that plays up from a somewhat wide horizontal release. He has feel to locate his slider in the zone with some consistency and can occasionally backdoor it. The pitch only sits at 84 MPH but given his feel for creating lift with the slider, he’s the ideal candidate to add velocity and transition to a wipeout slutter hybrid pitch. You could also go the other way and subtract for more depth but I think it plays better off of the fastball as a cutter and it would also help set up a very fringy changeup without much depth.</p><p>Blade Tidwell has first round caliber stuff and throws strikes. If it wasn’t for workload/health concerns he would earn a first round grade but those are pretty significant concerns. Tidwell has dealt with shoulder trouble and isn’t pitching deeper than the fifth inning most starts. He’s also usually pitching just once every six days. He only threw 39 innings over 13 appearances.</p><p>There are warranted questions on if the premium velocity will hold up over a larger workload and that is a lot of the appeal of Tidwell’s stuff- premium velocity. If Tidwell can’t maintain his velocity then what is he? It’s 55–60 movement from a sub-optimal angle. You need the velocity for that to play in a two-pitch arsenal. There is also significant health risk here that has to be considered.</p><p>Blade Tidwell is probably worth the risk but he’s an early round two guy for me because that risk exists. He’ll probably still go round one given the weaker crop of college arms and it’ll be a perfectly fine selection because the upside is loud. He’s more of a project than a plug and play ace but he’s a great arm talent nevertheless.</p><h4>49. SP Kumar Rocker, Tri-City Valleycats</h4><p>Kumar Rocker went #10 overall to the Mets and failed to sign last year because of some medical concerns. My understanding of the situation is that it had less to do with UCL damage (That was there though) and more to do with the fact that Kumar Rocker hid that he had multiple PRP injections from the team (And his agent?) before the draft. He’s also had shoulder surgery since then and that hurts his stock too.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/2021-mlb-draft-board-55953c0bc267">I wrote about Kumar Rocker’s stuff in detail last year</a> when he was my #25 prospect in the class. His stuff hasn’t moved up at all for having more velocity in short starts that he only made every five days. The mechanics are the same from what I can tell and these starts were engineered to make him look as good as possible rather than reflect where he actually is.</p><p>So why is Kumar Rocker down thirty spots from last year? If you read my report on him last year I repeatedly talked about how Kumar Rocker’s delivery creates injury risk and gives him trouble maintaining his top-end velocities. I then said I was choosing to rank him off of the track record of clean health instead. That track record no longer exists and maybe never did. There is long term risk of him breaking down and the stuff is only good rather than elite right now.</p><p>I get why teams are interested in round one and I don’t even hate it if it’s under slot (Likely will be since Rocker has very little leverage to refuse a second time) but he’s not a first round caliber arm for me. He’s getting buzz as early as #3 overall and I kind of see it but the risk feels way too high for what is unlikely to ever be more than a mid-tier #3 starter ceiling and is likely just a back-end guy.</p><h4>50. SS/IF Josh Kasevich, Oregon</h4><p>Josh Kasevich has a 92.2% contact rate this year and was at 91.1% last year. There is a track record of making contact. Kasevich chased just 19% of the time in 2021 and 19.9% this year. He also has a Max EV of 111.2 MPH and plays shortstop. That probably sounds like a candidate to go #1 overall but things are a lot more complicated than those three data points make it out to be.</p><p>Josh Kasevich currently projects as a slightly better Nick Madrigal. His contact is all empty because none of it comes in the air. Kasevich has an 8th percentile outfield flyball rate this year according to FaBIO. Only 12.5% of his outfield flyballs are hit hard. His hardest hit ball with a launch angle of even 20° is just 101.2 MPH. Josh Kasevich also only pulls the ball 39% of the time which doesn’t help the power issues.</p><p>The swing needs to be overhauled to see any in-game power. Kasevich has a flat path that doesn’t create loft and a deep connection point that makes it impossible to hit to the pullside with any power. You risk the contact skills by changing the swing and it’s a risk I would take. Kasevich right now is a low impact bat who won’t even hit for that high of an average because he so frequently mishits the ball at extreme launch angles.</p><p>I’ve also been told that his defense at shortstop is a bit fringy and he might have to move to either second or third. The actions look really good at first glance but Oregon uses a turf infield that makes fielding grounders way easier than it is for most. Most of his highlight reel plays are in home games and he’s more fringe off the turf.</p><p>I think Kasevich is likely to be a low impact major league contributor but there’s a 5% chance everything clicks and he’s perhaps the best hitter from the draft this year. I really like him in the second round and could totally get on board with Kasevich in the first as well. He’s a very talented player but a huge developmental project if you want anything actually impactful.</p><h4>51. 1B Tyler Locklear, VCU</h4><p>Tyler Locklear leads all of college baseball in wOBA over the last two years. He’s a first baseman at the next level but he hits. The contact rates went from average to a plus even if the contact quality dipped a tad in response. Locklear still has 70 raw power and now makes contact. It’s a scary combination, even from a slightly smaller conference in the A10.</p><p>Tyler Locklear has a Max EV of 113.8 MPH with a 97th percentile Top 8th EV. The mishits were up this year with a new knack for popping the ball up that developed as he sold out some for more contact. The line drive rates are low and he only has average feel to elevate. There is 70 raw power so it still lead to a 96th percentile barrel rate but I think the power projects slightly below the elite raw power. I’m not as high on the BABIP skills as I probably should be given the power but he’s still going to be really good on contact.</p><p>The hit tool has some risk but I don’t think it’s significant. Tyler Lockler pretty much never chases- he’s at just 15% over the last two years. Locklear has some minor troubles with velocity in a small sample and the track record of making contact isn’t great. He rarely swings and misses as a whole though and whiffed just 18% of the time against Power 5 pitching in his career. He has very little defensive value but he has hit so far and he should continue to do so at a high level. I’m not as confident in him being an elite hitter as Melendez or even Berry but he’s still worth a second round pick.</p><h4>52. SP Robby Snelling, McQueen High School</h4><p>Robby Snelling has shades of Frank Mozzicato in the profile. The fastball sits just 90–93 MPH and only tops out at 95 MPH but there is tons of projection in the frame and Snelling moves well on the mound. The pitches come from a 5.4&#39; release height and he gets above-average ride on the fastball as he sat at 19&quot; IVB over the summer and also got 10&quot; of tailing action. The fastball should have a very flat VAA and miss a lot of bats as he gets stronger.</p><p>The breaking ball is a weapon. He sits 77–80 MPH and will flash spectacular depth; even if he only averages like ~-5&quot; IVB. The pitch has some sweeping action and it plays up from the slightly steep horizontal approach angle. The curveball has shown more depth this spring too so it’s easy to argue bumping it up to a plus pitch. There is a changeup as well with fantastic arm speed and some feel but the current shape is often terrible.</p><p>Robby Snelling on top of having two good pitches with optimal release traits also projects for above-average control. He has a great delivery and plus athleticism. He already throws strikes and I don’t really see that changing much. Robby Snelling gets a second round grade but he could definitely go earlier if one team falls in love with the projection as they did with Mozzicato. I don’t even have a problem with him going in round one despite this ranking. I will note that I’ve heard he’s going to be a very tough sign as he apparently has a three-year NIL deal worth seven figures lined up if he makes it to LSU.</p><h4>53. SP Tyler Gough, JSerra Catholic High School</h4><p>Tyler Gough is probably the most underrated prep arm in the entire draft. I understand the reasons for the lack up hype but I disagree that they provide close to enough reason to push Gough out of the first three rounds. Tyler Gough was hurt for most of his senior season and when he came back he pitched almost exclusively in relief. He’s very clearly got a starter’s repertoire and decent enough command but he pitched in relief due to health concerns and no one scouts prep relievers. He dominated in the combine and had the most electrifying pitch data perhaps in the entire prep class last summer.</p><p>The fastball only sits in the low nineties but he has 20.9&quot; IVB and throws from a 5.2&#39; vertical release so it will still completely fuck you up. The pitch really plays at the top of the zone and is an elite offering. He dominated with an upper seventies curve at the combine that flashes elite depth but is highly inconsistent. The slutter in the mid eighties has good carry and some cutting action that should play up off of the fastball. The changeup flashes elite tailing action from one of the most medial release points in the entire league. There is legit secondaries with an elite fastball and enough strikes to start. I would gladly give Gough seven figures to sign with my team.</p><h4>54. SP Parker Messick, Florida State</h4><p>Parker Messick is another arm who needs more velocity to profile in the majors but otherwise has first round caliber stuff. The problem is that Messick is a below-average athlete, fully bulked up, and with only average arm speed so it’s a lot harder to envision velocity gains. There are some mechanical tweaks there to improve the timing but the gains from those will likely be more minimal.</p><p>The fastball would be extremely successful if Messick got to even league average velocity. He’s a left handed starting pitcher who throws from a 5.28&#39; release height and gets slightly below average vertical movement (~16.5&quot; IVB in road games, and 15&quot; in Hawkeye games). Messick also has 10.5&quot; of arm side movement from a 1.51&#39; horizontal release. He only sits at 91 MPH but the shape is great and would give him a very flat VAA with the elevated fastball.</p><p>The slow sweeper has fantastic shape. He has just 1.3&quot; IVB and also generates 10&quot; of sweep on average. The only problem is that he sits at 79.7 MPH so it won’t miss very many bats. There is also a slower sweeper at 75.9 MPH with -4.1&quot; IVB and 13.3&quot; HB. Neither of them is all that good right now but both variants of the sweeping breaking ball could be good with more velocity.</p><p>The changeup is a plus as is and wouldn’t be hurt by improved arm strength. Messick sits at 82.2 MPH- roughly ~9 MPH lower than the fastball. He kills some spin and throws on a 2:45 spin axis. The result is just 3.8&quot; IVB and 15.6&quot; HB. He has an elite feel for locating the changeup in the strike zone and it dominates there with a 34% in-zone whiff rate. He also gets chases 45.8% of the time with the cambio.</p><p>Parker Messick is a strike thrower with very promising pitch shape across the board. He needs more velocity to pop up and be what he can be, but there is still a floor here. Messick right now projects as a slightly below-average starting pitcher. I think fixing the velocity will take time but the upside is high if he does fix it and I’d invest the requisite resources to try and find it.</p><h4>55. RF/CF Tommy Specht, Wahlert Catholic High School*</h4><p>Tommy Specht was never really challenged at Wahlert Catholic seeing as it was a 3A school. He was challenged in PG Tournament play though and rose to the occasion with a .451 batting average in 91 PA. He opted out of his senior season this year to train and then participated in the Prospects League against a bunch of college players using wooden bats. He has once again risen to the occasion hitting .294/.405/.412 in 42 PA for the Lumberkings at the time of me writing this with just a 16.7% strikeout rate and as many walks as strikeouts.</p><p>Tommy Specht has plus raw power. He had some of the highest exit velocities in the class last summer and he had 90th percentile bat speed at the MLB draft combine. He has an explosive lower half with the third-best broad jump at the combine (As of day two, more players tested afterward) and has added some upper body strength in the last year or so. He tested a standard deviation above-average in the CMJ at the combine as well. There are some rotational consistency issues- Specht’s torso can fire early at times (Especially common against velocity in my looks) but that is something that should be ironed out in time.</p><p>Not to mention, Specht has a steep VBA that should make it easy for him to adopt a more lift heavy approach. The attack angles aren’t optimal right now as he frequently swings over pitches and tops them but eventually he’ll elevate. He has a deeper connection point that leads to some difficulty pulling the ball. The game power is behind the raw power but it is still solid.</p><p>I’m a believer in Tommy Specht’s hit tool. Detractors will claim that he is a bit stiff but I really don’t see it in any of my looks from the last month. He is short to the ball and hits it hard consistently. He shows some feel to recognize spin and is continually making contact no matter who he is facing. There is an ease to his game and he keeps his composure in the box. He’s just a good baseball player.</p><p>Tommy Specht is a fringy fit in centerfield. He ran a 3.7 second 30 yd dash at the combine and has seemingly lost a step in the last year as he added strength. He was already a fringy fit in centerfield to begin with so it’s probably a right field profile now. He’ll be a great one though as Specht has one of the best outfield arms in the draft. He has thrown up to 99 MPH and has at least a dozen more throws topping 95 MPH. It’s premium arm strength and there’s solid accuracy and carry too.</p><p>Tommy Specht earns high marks for his makeup. He’s a very kind person who loves the game and works to better himself. Specht is very young for the class, turning 18 right after the draft, and he’s already shown the ability to compete with college level competition. His tools are loud and he can really hit. I like Tommy Specht in the second round range and could even talk myself into taking him higher. He’s probably not going to be drafted this high but if he falls to day two as most expect him to then he will be a steal.</p><h4>56. SP Thomas Harrington, Campbell</h4><p>Thomas Harrington is a hard player for me to value. I totally understand why people might have a first round grade on him and would be fine with selecting him there as long as there is a plan in place to raise the ceiling. Thomas Harrington throws five pitches and all of them are fine. If his velo were to uptick at all then he would move up the ranks considerably because his shapes are all solid albeit unspectacular.</p><p>The fastball sits 92.5 MPH and can touch 96 MPH. He throws two variants of fastball with one a four-seamer that has 18&quot; IVB and the other a sinker with 16.6&quot; of tail and mediocre sink at 13.5&quot; IVB. The fastball comes from a low release at 5.6&#39; feet on average and a more moderate horizontal release at 1.54&#39;. He struggled to get the fastball at the top of the zone but has no problem filling the zone at least. I think given how his teammates also pitch down, the lack of fastballs up in the zone might be deliberate and easily fixable. The four-seam is also fairly flat up in the zone and should miss bats. This is an above-average pitch that could take off with a velocity boost that I don’t really see right now.</p><p>The breaking balls are more fringe-average. The slider sits at 83 MPH with some nasty bite as he averages 8.9&quot; of sweep. The pitch is dragged down though by below-average vertical depth. On the bright side, he has above-average command of the slider. It’s the better of the two. The curve sits at 79.4 MPH with -11&quot; IVB and the same amount of horizontal movement. The feel is more fringe but there’s a solid pitch here- especially with more velocity.</p><p>The changeup is interesting. He does not have the best separation from the fastball only averaging 7 MPH less than the heater but that’s still fine enough. He kills spin and gets 16.6&quot; of tailing action to go with decent depth at 6.4&quot; IVB. The pitch doesn’t really work off the sinker but I think it might play off of the four-seam fastball. Oh, and it did log a 24.6% Swinging-Strike rate this year.</p><p>The primary draw of Thomas Harrington is that he has very advanced command over his fastball. He doesn’t walk batters and generally avoids the heart of the plate. He’s a pitchability type with solid enough stuff an if you raise the floor of that stuff, he could take off. I don’t love pitchability types in general but Harrington is a good version of the profile.</p><p>I initially had Thomas Harrington ranked #100 and then while writing about my Draft Philosophy, I noticed my hypocrisy. If Thomas Harrington was a high school arm with the exact same stuff he had now, he would be a first round talent.</p><p>The fastball shape is solid with desirable release traits. Harrington has great feel for a changeup, kills spin, and is a natural supinator. There is projection there. He has feel for spinning a breaking ball and creating movement either vertically or horizontally on the said pitch.</p><p>He checks most of the markers for projecting on a prep arm’s stuff quality evolving. Does Thomas Harrington being in college (Already having decent present day stuff) make those projections no longer applicable? I can’t say that it does. I don’t know exactly how to develop Harrington- aside from a focus on strength development but there is clear upside here and a floor as a pitchability type.</p><h4>57. Caden Dana, Don Bosco High School</h4><p>Caden Dana is one of the more underappreciated prep arms in the class. His fastball and curveball pairing have obscene amounts of vertical movement and you can figure out the rest later when that is your foundation.</p><p>The fastball sits 92–95 MPH with some projection left in his 6&#39;4&quot; frame and above-average extension that lets the velocity play up. However, as I already alluded to, the calling card here is movement. Caden Dana averaged 20.8&quot; IVB on his fastball over the summer. He also had 13.7&quot; of tailing action on the fastball. You have to adjust for seam height so it’s not that crazy and a 6.32&#39; release height hurts a tad. Even still, this is pretty easily a plus fastball.</p><p>The curveball is a hammer. He only sits 76–78 MPH but has an elite ability to create vertical depth from an already high release point. The pitch had -15.6&quot; IVB on average over the summer and just 5.8&quot; of sidespin. The angle is awesome with both a high release and a very medial one at 0.88&#39; release side that also helps a 12–6 curves like his play up. The two look fairly similar out of the hand and break in opposite directions so both grade out as plus pitches.</p><p>Dana has introduced a slider in the spring that I’ve heard very positive things about. It’s a slutter hybrid pitch that ranges from 83–90 MPH depending on the outing and appears to have solid horizontal action. I have it as an average grade without the specs on it but I know some people who think it’s now his best pitch. The changeup is fringe with solid separation but poor shape. You can project on it some because he has a quick arm action that helps with deception but it’s probably a below-average pitch.</p><p>The control comes and goes for Dana. He repeats his delivery and is a good athlete with an optimal frame. There are some mechanical concerns that might lead to future injuries but his mechanics are also good for creating velocity so you take what you can get. The FB/CB combo with a potential slutter is why you buy in on Dana and it’s enough for me to put a second-round grade on him.</p><h4>58. CF Mason Neville, Basic High School</h4><p>Mason Neville is one of the more unheralded prep bats who deserves a lot more attention than he gets. I would be fine with using a first-round pick on him if it was required. The tools are loud and it’s an easy profile to get excited about.</p><p>The power is explosive. Mason Neville has some of the best bat speed in the entire draft with 99th percentile showings in the perfect game showcases and 98th percentile in impact momentum as well. He has a plus feel to elevate too with a steep vertical angle and consistently runs positive attack angles. The power should be a plus in terms of game output during his prime.</p><p>Mason Neville has an interesting hit tool. He has made contact at a high rate in high school but struggled with whiffs against horizontal movement during the showcase games. The swing has some violence but the bat path is generally efficient. There’s some bobble but the hands are good and he shows the ability to make adjustments. I have the contact skills as below-average but it is by no means bad. He’s a big line drive hitter who avoids mishits so it’s still an average hit tool though.</p><p>Mason Neville is at least a plus runner. He has posted 70 grade run times but given the frame, it’s fairly likely he will lose a step or two. Mason Neville also has plus arm strength and good carry on his throws. His arm slot is unorthodox but he’s an outfielder so I don’t actually care that much. It works and that is what matters. I think Neville can play a stellar centerfield and I like the bat a lot. He’s worth spending seven figures to buy out of his Arizona commitment.</p><h4>59. 2B/SS Tanner Schobel, Virginia Tech.</h4><p>Tanner Schobel is not a conventional player. His tools are fairly mid but the production is the opposite and I think it has a relatively high chance of translating into a quality major leaguer.</p><p>Tanner Schobel does not have a lot of raw power. His career high EV is just 106.5 MPH and his Top 8th EV of 102.6 MPH is basically equivalent to the average college player. The game power is a lot better than the raw though. Schobel has a 92nd percentile groundball rate which helps a lot. What helps, even more, is the fact that he has a 98th percentile Pulled Flyball rate. He also has above-average spin rates on his batted balls and the majority of them have backspin. The game power plays well above the raw power as a result. I’m not projecting more than average power given the 40 grade raw juice but it is average power.</p><p>Tanner Schobel stands out for the plus contact skills. He has an 89% contact rate in the zone this year and an 84.7% contact rate. He also chases just 18.5% of the time. The on-base skills are very real and there’s a chance at power. He’s a fringy shortstop due to a below-average arm but even from a second baseman, this profile should play- assuming the power doesn’t completely vanish with the transition to wood (It was down slightly in the cape). He should be solid value as a second or third round pick who won’t be a star but should provide some value.</p><h4>60. SP/RP Carson Palmquist, Miami</h4><p>Everything about Palmquist screams reliever. The delivery is very relieverish and the pitch data made me think reliever at first. Yet, I actually think he can crack it in the rotation. Sure, he might have lost 3 MPH off the fastball in transitioning to the rotation but… Carson Palmquist is better as a reliever than a starter but he can be a starter. He throws strikes at a high level and has a solid batted ball profile. He can miss bats at a high clip and has the weapons to beat hitters of both handednesses.</p><p>The fastball is an above-average pitch even if he only sits at 90 MPH. The draw is obviously the angle. He throws from a 4.5&#39; release height and a 2.7&#39; horizontal release point. The pitch has only 12.7&quot; IVB but it still has a -4.2° VAA because of the low release. He also has elite horizontal movement with 16.7&quot; HB on average.</p><p>The changeup is absolutely disgusting even if it’s possibly undermined some by his slot. The pitch has 17.5&quot; of arm side movement with average vertical depth at 10 MPH slower than the fastball. The pitch is above-average and had a 32% Swinging-Strike rate this year so maybe I am underselling it.</p><p>The slider is what some scouts consider Palmquist’s best pitch but I’m a bit lower on it. The pitch sits at 77 MPH with a very high gyro angle and more cutterish shape without the velocity. The pitch only has four inches of sweep but given the low release and glove side command it still plays an average pitch. Palmquist isn’t conventional and might be a reliever but he has three pitches and command so why not give him a chance to start?</p><h4>61. 2B/CF/SS Nick Morabito, Gonzaga High School</h4><p>Nick Morabito has a lot of helium after a strong spring and an also impressive performance at the combine. Morabito is the closest thing to a Nick Yorke (Not profile but pedigree/attractive elements with risk that causes him to fly under the radar) in this year’s draft and if we’re predicting an out-of-nowhere prep to be a first round pick, Morabito is my man.</p><p>Nick Morabito is an athlete. He ran a 3.65 second 30 yd dash at the combine and has been clocked with some 70 grade run times in the spring. The arm strength is below-average which has second base as his most likely destination but scouts highest on the athleticism often have him in centerfield. Despite, the below-average arm, Morabito has a fringe chance of sticking at shortstop because his actions are good and he has plus range. He’s not really a shortstop with a below-average arm but it’s not impossible.</p><p>I really like the bat too. The hit tool is a plus. He is short to the ball with a whippy barrel and a handy swing that can make adjustments. He’s taken Trevor Bauer deep before, and is constantly peppering line drives all over the field. The power is blooming. He has added strength to his lower half this spring and showed off his above-average bat speed at the combine. He often hits the ball in the air and has the power to do some damage. There is a lack of track record here and he has some positional risk but I like the tools and buy in on the ability to hit. He’s easily worth a second round pick in my opinion.</p><h4>62. CF/RF Henry Bolte, Palo Alto High School</h4><p>Last year I pushed James Wood down to #92 on my draft board because of a major whiff risk despite freakish tools. James Wood is probably the best player in the entirety of the 2021 draft at this point. Bolte has some similar markers and in an endeavor to avoid repeating my mistakes, Bolte is getting a bit more credit despite the risk.</p><p>Henry Bolte has good pitch recognition and solid timing. The bat path is fairly efficient and he shows the ability to recognize spin. He has solid timing on fastballs too and isn’t really out in front of offspeed. The problem is that Bolte just misses with the bat. It’s poor bat control that leads to him swinging through stuff in the zone too frequently. The Padres made a few adjustments to James Wood and he now has an 87% in-zone contact rate.</p><p>If a team sees the same adjustments as possible for Bolte then they could give him the first round money (2.5MM+) he is reportedly demanding. The tools are a bit worse than Wood but he’s still a plus runner, with a plus arm and 70 grade raw power. He gets a second round grade from me but if you have a plan to develop the contact skills then he is worth a lot more.</p><h4>63. 3B/SS Mac Horvath, North Carolina</h4><p>Mac Horvath’s listed birthday on Baseball Reference is wrong so he’s not listed on a lot of draft rankings this year. He actually turns 21 on July 22nd, and as such is eligible this year. The bat is incredible and he’s a very good fielder at the hot corner who has a none zero shot of moving up the defensive spectrum to shortstop.</p><p>The hit tool is not particularly good. Mac Horvath has fairly average contact rates with him sitting at just 76.8% over the last two years and 82.5% in the zone. It’s also worth noting that he is at least above-average against both velocity and breaking balls. Horvath still rarely strikes out too and works a lot of walks in the process because he is only chasing 14.5% of pitches this year and swinging at 65.9% of in-zone pitches over the last two years.</p><p>The BABIP skills suck though. He has a career .263 BABIP with North Carolina and his expected stats (Sourced) say he’s only slightly underperformed a .289 xBABIP based on his contact quality in trackman games. Horvath is a pull heavy hitter who has a popup problem and hits a lot of outfield flyballs which is a boom or bust strategy. He still has elite OBPs because he has an amazing approach but the batting average isn’t ever going to be there.</p><p>The power is the real calling card offensively. Horvath has just a Max EV of 109.1 MPH and an 82nd percentile Top 8th EV. So how in the world is the power the calling card? Elite game power optimization. Horvath has a 31% groundball rate over the last two years which is in the 91st percentile. That power combined with his feel to elevate leads to a 96th percentile barrel rate this year. But Horvath goes deeper still. He constantly pulls the ball and that lets the power play up, he tops off his profile with a 93rd percentile backspin%. The game power is a plus skill even if the raw is a tick below.</p><p>Mac Horvath is a bit of a three-true outcomes profile who should be a frustrating but good hitter. He’ll provide that offense while competing for gold gloves at third base. He has easy plus arm strength with plus arm utility as well. His hands, range, and actions all grade out highly. He’s incredibly slick at third and could even probably play shortstop. The bat and glove is a potent combo and for me, that is enough to earn Horvath a second or third round grade.</p><h4>64. RF Ryan Clifford, Pro5 Baseball Academy</h4><p>Ryan Clifford was the #1 High School hitter in the entirety of the 2022 class according to both Baseball America and PBR during their 2019 and 2020 rankings. His development has stalled a bit over the last few years but the upside is the same as it always has been, even if the risk is higher now.</p><p>The bat is incredible. He has a cinematic swing that is effective too. Clifford is short to the ball with a clean bat path that should produce consistent quality contact. He has hit for contact everywhere but one summer and with team USA he only hit .200 on a big stage except he also only struck out 16% of the time so how harshly are we dinging him? The swing looks fantastic and I still believe in the hit tool.</p><p>The power hasn’t progressed as we once believed it would but it’s still developed into a plus tool. Clifford had the second hardest hit ball in the (prep) Hawkeye showcase games at 109.5 MPH and it was the only batted ball at 107+ MPH with a launch angle above 0°. He has a somewhat limited feel to elevate given the flatter bat path but it is plus bat speed and really good strength. He already has high-end exit velocities and should only get stronger with time.</p><p>Ryan Clifford has a cannon of an arm in right field that makes him likely stick even if he’s only a below-average runner. The defensive value is somewhat limited but he’s an incredible hitter. Ryan Clifford’s makeup is off the charts. He’s incredibly responsible and has a relentless work ethic. His teammates all rave about him and he’s a natural-born leader. When you combine the elite makeup with the already present baseball skills, it’s really hard not to love Clifford. He’s committed to Vanderbilt and will likely cost a pretty penny but he’s easily worth seven figures in my opinion.</p><h4>65. SP Marcus Johnson, Duke</h4><p>If Marcus Johnson threw 5 MPH harder he would be Luis Severino. That’s slightly hyperbolic and obviously a really tall ask but take a look at this table of their pitch movement side by side.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/387/1*rzjMd2J1f_jJSWx22gkl3Q.png" /></figure><p>The release is closer in line with 2018 Severino but most the differences can be explained away pretty easily. The fastball of both of them are on the same axis but the college ball has slightly higher seams and Johnson has slightly better spin rates. IVB is also partially dependent on velocity- it’s easier to post higher numbers at low velocity. The changeup is 7.1 MPH slower than the heater for Severino and 7.04 MPH slower for Johnson. Johnson gets slightly more tailing action but the pitch is largely the same. The slider has some variance but it’s still comparable in shape. So just add 5 MPH and instant Ace!</p><p>Can Marcus Johnson do that? Probably not but he should be able to get a little more out of his 6&#39;6&quot; and 200 lbs frame. He won’t be Sevy but he should still be an effective MLB arm. Johnson has poor fastball deployment right now but he can at least throw strikes and you’d hope that doesn’t fall off too much with a revamped attack plan on the mound. Johnson isn’t an Ace unless a miracle occurs but I think he offers both floor and ceiling in the second to third round range.</p><h4>66. 3B/SS Tucker Toman, Hammond High School</h4><p>Tucker Toman switch hits and that torpedos his draft stock as he would be significantly better if he only hit left-handed. Toman is quite honestly my least favorite form of (good) draft prospects. There’s a bunch of 50s in the profile with a high makeup that could easily raise the floor and with one small gain, he becomes someone to watch out for, just right now there is very limited excitement.</p><p>The contact rates are strong as a lefty with a concise swing that he repeats. He has the ability to put the ball in the air from the left-handed side with efficient rotation and above-average bat speed. There is some power from the right-handed side as well but it is less refined. Toman is a fringe fit at shortstop who seems likely to be above-average at the hot corner. I can’t muster up too much excitement for him but I get the appeal and am totally down to draft him with a ~1.5MM price tag. These types of players have a tendency to outperform their tools.</p><h4>67. SP Ian (JR) Ritchie Jr., Bainbridge High School</h4><p>I’m going to get bullied by a few friends of mine for having JR Ritchie so high. The fastball sits in the dead zone and he doesn’t really have bat missing stuff. There are a few standout traits here though that make him worth a second round pick.</p><p>The fastball sits 92–94 MPH and has hit as high as 97 MPH with above-average extension. Ritchie moves really well and there is velocity projection there as he grows into more strength despite a smaller frame. The fastball movement admittedly sucks. Ritchie averaged just 14.7 IVB (Non-adjusted) and 10.5 HB. The pitch sits in the dead zone and probably should get hammered. There is hope though in the form of a 5.41 release height that could still give him solid VAAs up. I also think he has some promising sinker traits if you choose to go that route.</p><p>There are technically two breaking balls but they often bleed into only one pitch and I expect that he’ll settle in as a hybrid sweeper guy sitting 80–83 MPH. His breaking balls averaged -3.1&quot; IVB and 8.2&quot; of sweeping action over the summer. The sweep plays up a bit from a 2.2&#39; horizontal release and I think given the solid velo and shape it projects as above-average.</p><p>I also have the changeup listed as above-average. Ritchie Jr. kills 10 MPH on his fastball and a few hundred revolutions as well. He has 10.9&quot; IVB which admittedly isn’t great given the fastball but he also sits at 17.5 inches of armside fade and flashes up to 20&quot; pretty regularly. The pitch should still miss bats due to the arm speed and fade even if he lacks in depth oftentimes.</p><p>JR Ritchie throws strikes at an above-average rate and has three pitches of decent quality. There is velocity here and paired with a low release that has me higher on the fastball than the shape. The makeup is reportedly fantastic. Ritchie needs some serious work to be anything more than a #5 starter but he has upside and is also a relatively safe prep arm.</p><h4>68. RP/SP Reggie Crawford, Connecticut</h4><p>Reggie Crawford has thrown 20.1 innings in the last three years. He faced 83 batters and struck out 47% of them in those games. The fastball data is exceptional. He sits 96–99 MPH with spin rates averaging 2500 RPMs from the left handed side. He has 17.5&quot; IVB and 14&quot; HB from a 5.4&#39; release height. The pitch has legitimate 80 grade upside if he somehow manages to hold his velocity. The slider is a plus pitch as well with sweeper shape sitting 85–87 MPH most of his outings.</p><p>There is absolutely a scenario where Crawford winds up the best player in the draft- the stuff is that good. That being said, there is massive amounts of risk given the lack of time actually being healthy and the small sample nature of what he’s shown. Some shades of Garrett Crochet in the profile.</p><p>I’ve also seen some people throw around the idea that Reggie Crawford has the best makeup of any draft prospect this century. Don’t be at all surprised or upset if he goes to your favorite team in the first round. I can’t rank him that high because there are so many unknowns still with him but the talent is obvious even from a distance and don’t get upset when your team takes him much higher than this. He’s an electric player with star upside.</p><h4>69. RF Anthony Hall, Oregon</h4><p>Anthony Hall is one of my favorite hitters in the draft. He has an above-average hit tool and above-average power with an above-average approach. He’s not some defensive stalwart but the dude just hits.</p><p>The contact rates are exceptional within the strike zone as I have him down as whiffing just 7.9% of the time this year on in-zone pitches. Perhaps more impressively, there are zero whiffs against pitches 93+. Anthony Hall also never chases breaking balls and doesn’t whiff in the zone against them either. He’s aggressive in pursuing the hanging breaking ball and does serious damage on them, while also rarely chasing anything but changeups and sinkers.</p><p>The power is present in games despite below-average groundball rates. Hall has a Max EV of 110.9 MPH and plus hard-hit and barrel rates. He pulls his flyballs at an extremely high rate and the majority of his hard-contact is hit in the air. He has strong HR/FB rates and I don’t think him developing loft is all that unreasonable. Hall just does it all at the plate and I will take that at any position.</p><h4>70. SP Jackson Ferris, IMG Academy</h4><p>Jackson Ferris is a top twenty player in the draft according to MLB Pipeline; even Baseball America and Prospects Live have ranked towards the back of the first round. I am considerably lower on Ferris for a variety of reasons.</p><p>I see the appeal in Jackson Ferris for sure. He’s a lefty who sits 92–95 MPH and touches 97 MPH. He has feel for spin and an optimal frame for your stereotypical starting pitching prospect. The thing is the fastball shape is just very mediocre. He only averaged 17.6&quot; IVB over the summer circuit with 11.8&quot; HB. That is below-average movement relative to the event. Ferris has very inconsistent fastball shape that needs serious refinement. There is plus and even elite upside here but it’s not anything close to a certainty he reaches it.</p><p>The secondaries underwhelmed me. The curve is decent with feel for spin sitting 76–79 MPH but it only as average depth and 11&quot; of sweep on average with sub-optimal release traits for a curveball. There is upside given spin and the arm strength but again, it’s a fringier pitch. The changeup is in a similar boat although I like it slightly more. He has mid separation with some feel to kill spin and below-average depth. The pitch has 15.6&quot; HB but it’s not like wow or anything. He also struggles with feel for the pitch.</p><p>I guess at the end of the day, I just don’t believe in Jackson Ferris’ stuff or that he will truly develop. He has the arm strength and general athleticism to make me regret that decision but I don’t really think you can separate him from the lengthy second tier of prep arms. He has good stuff but it’s not exceptional and the performance wasn’t really there this spring. He’s worth probably ~1.1MM and I doubt he’ll sign for so little. If a team takes him early I get it, but it’s not the gamble I would want to take.</p><h4>71. RF/CF Roman Anthony, Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School</h4><p>Roman Anthony has major hit tool concerns but great tools. The hit tool has made strides this spring with just an 11.6% strikeout rate for Stoneman Douglas this year after being nearly double that rate the prior year. There is some issues with pitches down in the zone as his front leg gets stiff and limits his ability to adjust but I think given the athleticism, him improving the posture is very much possible. He does damage on anything up so the hit tool might have blast-off potential.</p><p>The power is the calling card though. Roman Anthony has electric bat speed and elite rotational ability. The pelvis can leak early but the ability to create separation on his best swings is among the best in the class. His power plays down given the lack of flexibility on pitches down but he should still hit for plus game power because it’s very loud raw power. He also has a fringe chance at playing centerfield with plus speed and arm strength. I think Anthony probably is a round two or three guy but you could sell me on the idea that giving him first-round money is a wise investment.</p><h4>72. SP/RP Jacob Meador, Dallas Baptist</h4><p>Jacob Meador profiles somewhat similarly to Bryce Miller last year. He’s a one-dimensional stuff arm with very loud stuff but major control and contact quality questions. I still think he’s worthy of a second or third round pick but like Miller, I expect he’ll fall to day three.</p><p>I should note that I actually like Meador more than I did Miller. The fastball is truly special. He sits at 93 MPH with fairly average spin rates but it is close to perfect spin efficiency. The pitch as a result gets 19.1&quot; IVB and 12.4&quot; HB. The pitch is truly made special though by the fact that Meador’s heater comes from a 5.33&#39; release height. The VAA is obscene up in the zone. Naturally, like most college starters, he uses the fastball down the majority of the time. When he does elevate it though he has a 28% Swinging-Strike rate.</p><p>I also think the batted ball woes are in part because he tries to force pitching down so when he misses it’s over the heart of the plate and tattooed. If he goes up he’ll give up more flyballs but they’ll be at less optimal angles and he’ll give up fewer hits so it should all around serve as a better profile for him.</p><p>The secondaries are really strong too. The curveball sits at 77.8 MPH and has -14.8&quot; IVB on average. That is ridiculous movement and he also gets 10.9&quot; of sweep to bring it all together. I don’t know how well the shape actually works off the fastball and if he’ll get chases at the next level but in a vacuum, it is a metrically superb offering.</p><p>The changeup on the other hand should really work off of the fastball and it was his top pitch by swinging-strike rate this year. He sits at 86.3 MPH- just under 7 MPH slower than the heater. The pitch kills 300 RPMs but again, the movement is the calling card with a 2:00 spin axis and good shape. The pitch has just 9.7&quot; IVB (Average depth) with heavy tailing action at 17&quot; HB on average. The control over the pitch is limited but it still is another very strong pitch on data.</p><p>If Jacob Meador can find the zone at even a serviceable rate, he can be a high-impact arm. If Meador doesn’t learn to throw strikes then he might still be a high-impact arm in relief. He deserves every chance to stick as a starting pitcher given the three pitch mix but if he can’t add more dimensions he’s destined for a very strikeout dependent relief role. I’m totally comfortable gambling on this stuff in the first three rounds even if I understand why most people wouldn’t be.</p><h4>73. SP Gabriel Hughes, Gonzaga</h4><p>Gabriel Hughes has the most dominant fastball in the draft in terms of results with a 38% whiff rate while throwing 55% of them in the zone. He also has the least dominant fastball in terms of traits. The pitch has just 15&quot; IVB from a 5.8&#39; release height. The draw here is above-average but not even elite command- he struggles with location against LHB. The other draw is that he sits at 94.3 MPH and has plus extension. Evidently, fastball spam is a viable strategy in the WCC when you have good velocity. I don’t think it’ll be much more than average at the next level though.</p><p>The secondaries are more impressive than the fastball though. He sits at 82 MPH on the slider with -1&quot; IVB and 9.2&quot; of sweep. He can land the pitch for strikes and it earns itself an above-average projection but it’s nothing special by any means. The 2.3&#39; relside does help it play up some though.</p><p>The changeup is my favorite pitch he throws. He sits 12 MPH slower than the fastball at just 82.3 MPH with only 6&quot; less IVB but 17.5&quot; of fade. This is particularly impactful because Hughes averages just 5.5&quot; inches of fade on the fastball. He throws the two at essentially the same pitch height so there might be some Giolito elements at play letting them both play up but it can’t really be the reason when he uses the changeup less than 8% of the time. I like the changeup as an above-average pitch but the feel isn’t usually there so its’ not much more.</p><p>Hughes offers three pitches with command and gets groundball outs. I totally understand the appeal but he’s so fastball heavy right now despite the fastball being unlikely to translate, there will be growing pains as he switches to a more normal arsenal. He’s a somewhat safe back-of-the-rotation starter with limited upside who I hate but would take in the second or third round with much grumbling in the process.</p><h4>74. 3B Zach Agnos, Eastern Carolina</h4><p>Zach Agnos is one of my personal favorite college hitters in the draft. He has plus raw power with a 57.7% Hard-Hit rate this year which is in the 99th percentile of college players. His raw metrics are slightly less impressive 109.5 MPH Max EV and 105.6 MPH Top 8th EV (85th percentile) but he still has good power.</p><p>The groundball rate is only in the 25th percentile but given the frequent hard contact, Agnos has an 86th percentile barrel rate still at 9.7%. So why does Agnos only have seven homers this year? Part of that is that Agnos plays in the 14th most pitcher friendly D1 school (301 schools) but it also comes down to below-average spin characteristics and only pulling 7.4% of flyballs with Trackman. It’s probably easier to teach those things than power but it’s a bit of a warning sign.</p><p>The real appeal of Agnos though is his on-base skills. Agnos has an above-average contact rate sitting just over 80% and has an elite approach with just a 16.6% chase rate and a very high 74.2% Z-Swing% to go with it in trackman games. More particularly, Zach Agnos is the best breaking ball hitter in the entire draft by a pretty wide margin. The BABIP skills are more fine than elite despite the .407 BABIP this year. Most of his groundballs are hit at higher angles and he never pops up. He’s not a big line drive guy but he hits the ball to all fields and has 99th percentile hard-hit rates so it plays. Above-average hit tool with an elite approach that should see very high OBPs in his prime.</p><p>Zach Agnos is a fine third baseman with a plus arm that makes him a draftable relief prospect. He throws 94 MPH off the mound and gets carry on his throws across the diamond as well. There are some errors but he has enough range to stick and the bat will carry him to relevance. If he starts to get to the raw power in games, then he would take off. Based on how good the swing decisions are, I don’t think that is all that unlikely to occur.</p><h4>75. SP Cole Phillips, Boerne High School</h4><p>Tommy John surgery this spring pushes him down some but Cole Phillips has first round caliber stuff and throws a decent amount of strikes. The fastball velocity was way up this spring and he was hitting 99 MPH while sitting 94–96 MPH each outing. Phillips has 6.6&#39; of extension too so you know that plays up. He only sat 91–93 MPH last summer and topped out at 95 MPH. His elbow immediately popped when the velocity jumped. Does the velocity stay when he returns? That’s why he is ranked so low. The fastball has plus spin and average vertical movement with plus horizontal life from a 5.7&#39; release height and 0.9&#39; release side. The pitch should miss bats regardless but it only has real elite potential if he can hold the velocity gains from this spring.</p><p>The slider took a major step forward this spring. He’s bumping the upper eighties now and it has nasty bite with limited depth. It’s somewhat of a slutter hybrid and might be better served by going full cutter. I have it as above-average but it’s a loose grade. The curveball is average mostly due to the slot that helps him out. He sits 76–79 MPH with average depth and some sidespin. The changeup has flashed plus fading action but struggled with depth and was too slow in the summer. He had more velocity in the spring but I’m not sure if that affected the shape.</p><p>There is four intriguing pitches in Phillips’s toolset and he has a solid delivery with control. There is some risk given the stuff only just popped up right before the elbow popped and we don’t know what he’ll be when he returns, but the upside of spring 2022 Phillips is worth spending seven figures in order to find out.</p><h4>76. 3B Cayden Wallace, Arkansas</h4><p>Cayden Wallace posted a Max EV of 112 MPH in Omaha just last month to remind everyone he has plus raw power to pair with the average in-zone contact rates. The swing is compact and explosive with loud results. The approach is above-average as well in both Z-Swing% and Chase%. There are some concerns with Wallace hitting a bit too many mishits but the bat should be solid even if the upside is not exactly elite.</p><p>Cayden Wallace has very limited experience at third base but don’t let that fool you. Wallace should be an above-average third baseman on the light end. He’s still trying to figure out some of the basics so there are lapses at times but the upside is clear as day. Wallace regularly showcases plus range and makes highlight reel plays. He also has premium arm strength to bind the package together. Cayden Wallace isn’t the most exciting early round pick but he should be productive and absolutely belongs n that range.</p><h4>77. SP Cade Obermueller, Iowa City High High School</h4><p>Cade Obermueller is an unconventional arm but I think he will be an effective one. He’s a very low slot low release starting pitcher who eyeballing it is probably at ~4.5&#39; release height and ~3&#39; horizontally. Those are crude estimates but not that inaccurate of ones.</p><p>Cade Obermueller sits at just 88–91 MPH and tops out at just 93 MPH. There is probably some strength projection given that he’s 5&#39;11&quot; 155lbs but it’s not a given that it actually translates to velocity, regardless of how efficiently he moves due to the slot. The pitch is more of a sinker with a high gyro angle but it’s a bit of a unicorn sinker. This is mostly due to the unique release traits but also because he gets his spin rates over 2600 RPMs at times and sits at about ~2400 RPMs. The sinker has some SSW traits and a four-seamer/rising two-seam fastball might not be impossible given the feel for spin from the slot. It’s an above-average fastball with a lot of variance but I do think that grade is closer to too light than overestimating him.</p><p>Obermueller has a ridiculous sweeper. He sits at ~78 MPH with spin rates that top 3000 RPMs. The pitch has heavy sweeping action with him averaging over 15&quot; of sweep. This slider is coming from a very wide horizontal angle that inflates the HAA’s and only makes him more dominant. The pitch has somewhat limited drop and he needs to work on reducing the active spin ration but if he has semi-decent command with the slider than it should perform.</p><p>The changeup is fringier given the mediocre shape and potentially sub-optimal slot but he kills spin getting down to ~1500 RPMs. The cambio sometimes looks like it’s zig-zagging when he commands it to the glove side and can leave hitters in knots. The changeup is a distant third pitch but it still projects as an average one.</p><p>This is a hard profile to value in any arm but especially from a prep. Obermueller has good stuff but it’s very unconventional and look guys like Obermueller often fall flat against better hitting. If we got to see him at Iowa for two years, I think he would go in the first round then. The stuff should play it’s just weird so it might not. There is sizeable risk but I’ll throw him 1MM to find out if he’s the next Hjerpe.</p><h4>78. SP Adam Mazur, Iowa</h4><p>Adam Mazur had gotten some first round hype earlier in the draft cycle but most people seemed to have since moved off of that absurd take. Honestly, I probably still have Mazur too high.</p><p>The fastball sits at 94 MPH which is good but it plays way down because Mazur only averages 5.6&#39; of extension. The pitch also has pretty average vertical movement at 17.7&quot; IVB in road games and a 6.1&#39; release height in road games. The skill to circle here is that he’s still growing into his frame and putting on healthy weight, I think there’s a chance that in his prime, Mazur is averaging 96+. I don’t think it’ll be a great pitch given the movement profile but it should be above-average.</p><p>The slider is Adam’s out pitch. He sits at 84 MPH with heavy gyro spin and that leads to -1.1&quot; IVB and 4.5&quot; of sweep. The pitch misses bats and should continue to do so. The other secondaries are more fringe with a curve only flashing but frequently showing below-average movement. The changeup has good separation and kills spin but only average depth and fade. The pitch has some potential but feel isn’t usually there so I’m not a fan of calling it more than average.</p><p>Adam Mazur has no problem with throwing strikes and has made strides with his batted ball profile this year. The stuff is more okay than good but he could still fill a role as a back of the rotation starter. I can see the appeal here but in my opinion, he’s not ever going to be more than a #5 starter and I want upside in the first two rounds. I have to respect the safety of his profile but I wouldn’t love selecting him.</p><h4>79. C/1B/LF/DH Cade Hunter, Virginia Tech.</h4><p>Cade Hunter is the son of the Mariners scouting director, Scott Hunter. His defensive home is very much in the air but he can hit. Hunter was a catcher in college but he had the worst average throw velocity and pop time in the country last year (10+ throws tracked) so it seems incredibly unlikely that he will actually catch at the next level. Wherever he plays, he will hit enough to profile as a big league contributor.</p><p>Cade Hunter has explosive raw power. His Max EV is 112.5 MPH and he has a 97th percentile top 8th EV. The power plays in games too with a 96th percentile barrel rate. The power is loud and the hit tool is interesting. Hunter has just a 73.8% contact rate this year but that is misleading. Hunter has average contact rates in the strike zone- sitting at 82.9%. He makes good swing decisions (17% chase rate) and hits for power with respectable contact skills. There is some hit risk since he does most of his damage against lower-velocity fastballs but it should be a solid enough tool. Hunter profiles as a somewhat risky middle of the order TTO masher without a position. He’s a third round guy because the bat is loud but I have a hard time justifying him any higher than this.</p><h4>80. SP Seth Keller, Hanover High School</h4><p>Seth Keller has been a two-way player in High School and according to a closer personal contact of his, if he is drafted, Seth Keller prefers to hit first and switch to the mound if he flops. I can see the appeal in him as a shortstop with plus bat speed and elite athleticism but his talent on the mound is so exciting that I’m not giving him his due at shortstop because I think it’s foolish to waste time doing anything but pitching.</p><p>The changeup is absolutely unfair. He throws it with a circle change grip but the movement profile is very much that of a splitter and an excellent one at that. During the summer circuit, he averaged -3.7&quot; IVB with 16.7&quot; of fade to his arm side. For the sake of being fair, let’s compare that to every MLB changeup thrown 3+ times. Only four pitchers have as much drop as Keller on their changeup. Of those four, no one averages more than 13.9&quot; of fading action. The most drop by a changeup with as much horizontal movement as Keller is the Airbender himself, Devin Williams. Except, Keller very much does not throw an Airbender because he averages just 1300 RPMs. It’s a unicorn pitch that is easily worth a plus grade.</p><p>I’ve heard nothing but good things about the slider this spring too. The slider sits in the low eighties and has sweeping action from a low slot. His mound positioning is somewhat detrimental to his HAA but the pitch is still a low slot sweeper to the glove side that should play off the only slightly lower changeup. It only earns an average grade but I know some people who think it’s better than the changeup.</p><p>Seth Keller isn’t really a projectable build but he moves really well on the mound. His arm timing has been on point this spring and he utilizes the entire kinetic chain effectively. He’s only sitting 91–93 MPH right now but I kind of expect that he’ll still add more velocity. The delivery looks a little violent but when you look at it frame by frame, it looks great and purposeful- probably because of the athleticism that lets him control his motion.</p><p>Seth Keller is 5&#39;10&quot; and throws from a very low arm slot. The result is a 4.9&#39; release height. The fastball is a tailing two-seamer with just 13.2&quot; IVB over the summer and 15.3&quot; of run but the pitch still projects fairly well given the angles he gets from his low slot. I don’t think the fastball will be a big bat misser but it should get groundballs and he has the Changeup/Slider pairing to meet his swing and miss needs.</p><p>Seth Keller has three quality pitches and throws enough strikes. Despite the unconventional look, that sounds like a starting pitcher to me. Seth Keller has a surprisingly high ceiling for how little velocity he has and belongs in the top three rounds for me. He’s an Old Dominion commit so I can’t imagine he’ll be that tough of a sign and whoever lands him will be getting a steal. He’s going to go lower than this ranking and in a few years, it’s likely teams will be scratching their head wondering how they completely missed his obvious talent.</p><h4>81. SP Luis Ramirez, Long Beach State</h4><p>Luis Ramirez is going to be one of the most featured arms from this year’s draft on Pitching Ninja- assuming he makes the majors. That stuff won’t really play at an elite level on the mound but the extreme horizontal movement that he offers makes him very GIFable.</p><p>Luis Ramirez primarily utilizes a sinker. The sinker sits at about 92 MPH and has only average spin rates. The pitch averages 6.9&quot; IVB and 15.7&quot; of armside fading action. The pitch flashes up to 23 inches of tail though. The pitch isn’t anything sexy but he can fill the zone with it and it’s probably why Ramirez had a 99th percentile groundball rate in 2021.</p><p>The curveball is a bit slower than I would like at 79.4 MPH with average spin but he gets a lot of movement. The pitch has -9.6&quot; IVB which is above the MLB average (very slightly) and also gets 16.8&quot; HB. Possibly because of how the sinker works down in the zone as well, Ramirez had a 26.2% swinging-strike rate with the pitch. I’m not sure it’s more than average at the next level but it definitely has that much upside.</p><p>The changeup gets a plus grade from me. He sits at just 83.5 MPH and has good arm speed. The movement is utterly ridiculous with just 1.6&quot; IVB and 16&quot; of fade. That is the same horizontal movement as the sinker but it drops 12 inches more with gravity and comes it 8.5 MPH slower. The changeup is his top chase pitch and it’s not hard to see why given the more vertical slot and the tunneling ability.</p><p>Luis Ramirez is far from the sexiest arm but he should be a safe back of the rotation arm. Except, he’s not safe because he just had Tommy John Surgery. This is a high floor low ceiling profile with the floor at slight risk right now. I still believe in the stuff getting him to the majors but it’s not a lock anymore so he falls to a third-round grade. If he goes higher I understand it though. He’s in a somewhat similar spot to McGreevy last year.</p><h4>82. CF/RF Brendan Summerhill, Whitney Young Magnet High School</h4><p>Brendan Summerhill doesn’t get a lot of hype for whatever reason but he does deserve it. The tools aren’t the loudest per say but he has projection and a present hit tool with athleticism and the skills to maybe tab into them. Also, he hit .541/.667/1.117 in a 6A school. That led his conference in literally every start including average, OPS, stolen bases, home runs, and RBIs. Most of those stats by a pretty wide margin. The production was loud.</p><p>Summerhill has plus bat speed and a ton of projection in his 6&#39;4&quot; frame. He’s an efficient rotator who consistently barrels the ball and has an inclined bat angle that makes it easy for him to create loft. The majority of his batted balls are hit at optimal angles in BP and in regular high school games that is only slightly less true. I think Brendan Summerhill has a chance to grow into plus game power.</p><p>The hit tool is above-average given the propensity for hitting the ball at optimal angles in part, but it’s also why he’s only earning a third round grade. There is hit risk. His contact skills are generally strong, he struck out just 5% of the time as a senior against solid competition while walking 23.3% of the time. Summerhill is particularly dominant against stuff down in the zone but shows some ability to adapt to the location of pitches and can make adjustments. That hasn’t quite translated against high heat yet, but he has the athleticism to think that it will eventually and that minor hole will be patched.</p><p>The only real scary thing here is that Summerhill has a long hand load that gives him struggles with velocity. I think you can coach the hand load smaller which is why the tool is graded as above-average but it creates risk and will probably lead to some initial struggles once he’s drafted and regularly facing guys throwing 90+ MPH.</p><p>The athleticism is a plus. Summerhill ran a 3.68 second 30 yard dash which is a plus run time and he did steal 34 bases in just 32 games this year. He has a good initial burst and it plays in the outfield. He’s a fringe centerfielder right now with shaky routes and even hands but he also played catcher up until 2021. I think he can learn the position, but even still, as he fills in, there’s a solid chance he is forced to right field. Summerhill has plus arm strength so he’s a good fit if he does move there.</p><p>The bat is the calling card but Summerhill should also help out on defense. I understand why he’s not the most hyped prep bat out there but he’s worthy of just under seven figures in my opinion. If he makes it to Arizona, he’s going to go very high in three years.</p><h4>83. RP/SP Adam Maier, Oregon</h4><p>Adam Maier is having a UCL brace inserted this April which puts him on pace to pitch again at the start of 2023. He’ll be just 21 next year and is coming off a season where he threw just 15.2 innings last year. I think it’s fairly likely that he refuses to sign outside of the first three rounds. I also think that despite the lack of work, and the risk, Maier is more than worth a top three round pick to a team with a strong pitching development system.</p><p>There is no one in the entire draft, prep or college arm with more movement in their arsenal. The sinker sits at 92 MPH with just 10.4&quot; IVB and a breathtaking 20 inches of horizontal movement. 20 inches! No major league arm averages that much movement. He’s technically throwing from a 6&#39; vertical release but San Diego’s trackman tends to inflate release heights by nearly half a foot so it’s closer to 5.5&#39;. The pitch has a fairly standard horizontal release and should really play given the movement profile.</p><p>The sweeper is even dumber. He sits at 81.1 MPH and throws it with spin rates that average 2950 RPMs. The pitch movement is the best you will ever see as he averages -8.7&quot; IVB and 20.6 inches of sweep. That is average depth for a curveball with plus power and the second most sweep of any pitch in all of baseball behind only Rich Hill’s 69 MPH slider. I would suggest forfeiting if you ever find yourself facing Adam Maier on the mound.</p><p>Adam Maier also has a fringe-average changeup because of course he does. The pitch sits 85–87 MPH but it kills ~500 RPMs. It wouldn’t be Adam Maier unless he averaged 20 inches of fade- so of course, he averages 19.8&quot;. The depth at 4.7&quot; IVB is solid in a vacuum but that is only 10 inches more drop with gravity than the sinker so it doesn’t really play that well. Maier shows some promise but has to either subtract velo or add depth to the cambio.</p><p>Adam Maier has the stupidest stuff in the draft but I’m skeptical it will actually perform. He might be like Matt Brash and be too good for the majors. That’s not actually how it works but Brash had the problem that all his stuff moved too much and too distinctively to actually get chases at the upper levels.</p><p>I think Maier could be plagued by the same issue. His sinker and curveball look nothing alike despite the same release. The combo should dominate in relief but when you get to see them multiple times, it will be increasingly easy to layoff in multiple looks. Tejay Antone has a similar curve and dominates with it in relief but only used it 16.1% of the time when he was starting games because it fell off so hard in multiple looks. Antone also had a plus slider to provide a middle ground option. Maier has an elite feel for both spin and low efficiency so it’s not hard to see him adding a gyro slider to set up both pitches but that’s an extra risk if you’re relying on it to start.</p><p>Adam Maier has an elite ability to spin the ball and if he can land all three pitches for strikes then you might not even have to change the repertoire much to find a starting pitcher in the rubble. That control is a bit of a question though and I think he’s more likely to profile as a very fun reliever. There is top end starting pitcher upside I would absolutely pursue first and draft early to try to bring to fruition but in the end, it feels unlikely that he sticks. Huge upside college arm on day two of the draft. If he goes back to school he has the talent to be a high first round pick next year.</p><h4>84. C Logan Tanner, Mississippi State</h4><p>Logan Tanner does everything well and nothing exceptionally well. Okay, he does do one thing exceptionally well- pitch framing. Unfortunately for Tanner, that doesn’t matter at all with ABS likely coming to the majors in 2024. Tanner is still a solid defensive catcher, in the 58th percentile of catcher DRS with a rocket of an arm. His average pop time is in the 84th percentile and he has solid accuracy as well.</p><p>Ultimately though, in a post- ABS world, even catchers have to hit. Will Tanner do so? It’s an interesting question. Logan Tanner did not really excel at the plate this year with a 103 wRC+ but he excelled under the hood in some ways even if he wasn’t really getting unlucky. Logan Tanner has an 88.2% in-zone contact rate in Trackman games, he only chases 25.6% of the time while swinging at 70.3% of strikes, and he has a Max EV of 109 MPH on balls hit with a positive launch angle. Those are all above-average numbers and hint at the upside of Tanner’s bat.</p><p>Yet, the bat doesn’t perform. Why? Other than terrible spray directions it is not immediately clear why that is. Tanner has just a 4.9% barrel rate despite above-average max power, and even his top 8th EV of 106.1 MPH is in the 88th percentile. He hits the ball hard and he has only average groundball rates. The problem is that Tanner’s flyballs are rarely hit hard just 28.6% of the time. The majority of Tanner’s hard hits are wasted on low launch angle contact.</p><p>There is upside in the bat and catchers who can hit have a lot of value but he’ll take some work to see manifest it. He’s worthy of a third round pick and I get the argument for higher given the fundamental skills but I do have to disagree. The upside isn’t that high at the plate, just a ~115 wRC+ ceiling which is good but not enough to completely overlook all of his flaws.</p><h4>85. SS/CF Chandler Pollard, Woodward Academy</h4><p>Chandler Pollard is one of the more unheralded gems of the prep class. He’s an elite runner with exceptional home to first times (3.6 on a bunt as a RHB and 4 on a non-bunt) and a 6.4 second 60 yard dash. He stole 59 bases in just 31 games during his senior season of high school. He also has plus arm strength that should when combined with the speed make him a shortstop. I am also intrigued by the possibility of moving him to centerfield where the speed will cook and his throw velos are genuinely a 70 from the outfield when he can just let it rip. He doesn’t have to move but he might want to because he could be better in centerfield.</p><p>The bat is the reason he belongs in the first three rounds though. He has legit plus raw power with most of incoming from elite wrist strength and hand speed. The bat speed is loud and he has good extension. The torso rotation could use some work but there’s still good power. Pollard also never whiffs in the zone. He’s short to the ball and has no trouble with velocity. There is some breaking ball recognition problems but I like the bat’s upside and he should be an asset on defense. Possible five-category contributor who deserves top three rounds money.</p><h4>86. SP Kassius Thomas, Sierra Canyon High School</h4><p>Kassius Thomas is very much a project who would do very well in an organization with a great pitching lab. Thomas is a plus athlete with a lively arm and moves well on the mound with particularly great shoulder abduction and lower half explosion.</p><p>The velocity is up this year with him sitting 93–94 MPH most starts and I think more velocity will come as he adds strength. He also gets 7&#39; of extension on average so the velocity plays up. Due to the long stride and how deep into his glutes he gets, Kassius also has just a 5.4&#39; release height with a 1.31&#39; release side. The fastball shape is a work in progress and the spin rates are largely average but I think given the slot, it’s likely you can improve the spin efficiency, and with his potential velocity and angle, the fastball will still play without elite carry.</p><p>The secondaries only flash but he throws strikes and has a big fastball with huge velocity upside. I love the athlete, delivery, and body. Kassius Thomas is the rare arm I like who doesn’t have overwhelming data but just good traits and hits a lot of the more old school markers you look for. I think you can do a lot of stuff with an arm this talented. He shows feel and has a high makeup. I’m in on Kassius Thomas for third round money and could get behind him even earlier with the right team.</p><h4>87. SP Jonathan Cannon, Georgia</h4><p>I was not a fan of Jonathan Cannon last year when he went undrafted despite frequently earning first three round grades. That has changed this year with the addition of a cutter that has quickly become his best pitch.</p><p>The sinker sits at 94 MPH from a 6&#39; vertical release and 2.8&#39; release side. The pitch has 8.7&quot; IVB and 16.3&quot; of arm side fade this year. He also throws a cutter at 89.7 MPH with 9.2&quot; IVB and 2.3&quot; HB. The pitches on their own suck but together they can be deadly. The two come from the same tunnel and are prepared by 2.6&quot; of drop with gravity and 18.5&quot; horizontally. The velocity difference is just 4.3 MPH. This allows both pitches to play way up since they interact so well and leads to Cannon getting chases aplenty. There is also a poor four-seam fastball that I would recommend scrapping.</p><p>There are two breaking balls. The slider is the better of the two with -0.6&quot; IVB and 7.5&quot; of sweep. The pitch misses some bats and he can locate it in the zone so it scrapes an above-average grade from me. Cannon leaned on the curveball last year but has since de-emphasized it. He has solid velocity at 81 MPH but -6&quot; IVB won’t miss very many bats. The changeup is very fringy with solid separation and average movement but also has poor feel.</p><p>The primary attraction of Jonathan Cannon is that he throws strikes and gets groundballs. The new emphasis on the cutter and slider allows him to miss enough bats and he now projects as a fairly safe #5 starter. He’s not sexy but he’s a role 45 player, even if not one I’m excited about the prospect of drafting.</p><h4>88. SP Jackson Cox, Toutle Lake High School</h4><p>Jackson Cox is far from a finished product. You aren’t drafting him for what he is but what he can be. Cox sits just 90–93 MPH with the fastball but has a projectable frame and moves well on the mound so you expect more velocity to develop. He also has a spin factor over 26 which makes it easier to overlook the fastball efficiency. Issues he throws from a traditional slot with normal wrist orientation so it seems fairly likely he can improve the efficiency in pro ball.</p><p>The breaking ball is the calling card though. He sits 79–82 MPH and can absolutely let them rip with spin rates that frequently top 3000 RPMs. The shape tends to involve sweeping action but as he gets stronger we should see impact velo and spin. There is a high variance plus projection here. There is also a changeup with good movement but he needs to subtract more velocity from it. Cox has had inconsistent control so far but he’s a good athlete with a good delivery so I still like his chances. If he goes to the right team he’ll be a steal regardless of what round he is in, but there are a lot of teams where this arm is very unlikely to develop as Cox requires a very hands on approach to development.</p><h4>89. CF/RF Clark Elliot, Michigan</h4><p>Clark Elliot is going to go in the first three rounds even if it’s not an exciting profile. Elliot is a fringy fit in centerfield with plus speed and an above-average arm but not enough explosiveness to really make an impact there. The power is not there with a top 8th EV of only 101.8 MPH and his barrel rate is just 4.6%. What Elliot does excel at is making contact and making good swing decisions. He’s not an impactful player but he’s a low variance useful major leaguer and those tend to go fairly high.</p><h4>90. SP Jacob Zibin, TXNL Academy</h4><p>Jacob Zibin is nothing like Calvin Ziegler in terms of stuff but he went to the same school and was the same age so he flies a bit under the radar. I’ve also heard from a source close to Zibin that just like Ziegler, Zibin is willing to sign for slightly under the slot value in the first three rounds. The control has variance but he’s athletic and has good movements on the mound. He sometimes gets out of sync and can’t buy a strike but the games he’s pounding the zone with consistency and dominating everyone are what you focus on because that is the long-term upside.</p><p>Jacob Zibin has increased his velocity this spring and is now sitting 92–94 MPH and hitting 97. The feel for spin is above-average from a lower slot with more sinker shape than four-seam. The pitch isn’t sexy but it should still be effective. The changeup is really strong with fade and depth in the low eighties. He has a long arm action that helps sell it and good feel. Plus projection. The slider has some sweeper traits in the low eighties but needs significant work. The stuff is here and he throws strikes so I’m interested in him as early as the second or third round.</p><h4>91. SS/IF Eric Snow, Mary Persons High School</h4><p>Eric Snow set the national prep triples record in 2021 with 18 of them in a thirty-game season. He then added 15 lbs this year and only hit three triples. Why? You ask. Because he hit 17 homers instead in just 28 games instead. He’s at a 3A school so it probably doesn’t matter much but still.</p><p>What might matter more is his loud production and more specifically contact skills in a small sample with Hawkeye. Eric Snow also has above-average bat speed and feel to elevate. The added muscle is letting him start to get to that power in games. The fit is fringy at shortstop. He’s a plus runner with solid-average arm strength but there are some arm accuracy and hands issues that could push him to what would likely be second base. The hit tool is the calling card here but Snow has pop and shouldn’t be a zero on defense. He’s a USF commit who should come fairly cheap and a talented player with a lot of upside who should still be available on day two.</p><h4>92. SP Jack O’Connor, Bishop O’Connell High School</h4><p>Jack O’Connor only sits 90–93 MPH with his fastball but he had 7.3&#39; of extension last summer so it plays up. There is also a lot of strength projection left in his 6&#39;5&quot; frame. The fastball shape is fairly bland with tail over rise but it still has a fairly average ride and a spin factor of 26. The other draw is a 5.4&#39; release height so with improved spin efficiency and arm strength there is the foundation for a great arm.</p><p>The fastball is really the one reason O’Connor is of interest to me as the secondaries are somewhat bland. The changeup is the most interesting pitch and that’s mostly just because he shows flashes of elite shape but lacks feel and arm speed. Still, flashing just 5&quot; IVB with 22&quot; inches of fade is absurd. The breaking balls both lack impact power and can bleed together. There is some sweep and the curve has depth but both are inconsistent and fringy. The appeal here is just a really good fastball with an optimal body and traits. He’s a bit of a project arm but the upside is very high.</p><h4>93. 3B/1B Max Wagner, Clemson</h4><p>Max Wagner is an interesting profile. He provides very little defensive value and his track record of hitting is just one season. That one season really boils down to just 28 games where he hit .398/.504/1.000. The problem is that the measurables aren’t really on par with the all-world production. They are good but not exceptional.</p><p>The Max EV is just 110.8 MPH and his top 8th EV is only in the 83rd percentile. The power is good and he has above-average feel to elevate but it’s not near as elite as the output in games would suggest. The hit tool is above-average and the power is a plus but it’s just kind of meh for not doing much on defense.</p><p>He has an 84.8% zone-contact rate and only chases 19% of the time. The problem is that he also has a popup problem, pulls the ball always, and has average line drive rates. He’s a 50 hit/55 power bat who might wind up at first base. I get why people want him in the first two rounds but I’m not one of them.</p><h4>94. SS/SP Austin Charles, Stockdale High School</h4><p>Austin Charles is a legitimate day two prospect as both a hitter and pitcher. As a pitcher, he is more late day two rather than where I have him ranked as a shortstop. He throws up to 96 MPH on the mound with a very high release sinker that has great angles and some SSW traits. The curveball is in the low eighties with a somewhat slurvy shape and great depth. The changeup is more fringe but his arm action helps sell it and it’ll occasionally flash. I love the mechanics even if there is some effort and think Charles would throw strikes. He’s not the highest upside arm but he’s a solid one nevertheless.</p><p>Austin Charles is the highest upside bat though. Okay, that is slightly hyperbolic but the ceiling here is extremely high. Austin Charles is a 6&#39;6&quot; shortstop which Oneil Cruz proves can work in the majors (5 DRS in less than 200 innings lol). He’s an agile defender with plus or better speed and obviously plus arm strength given his pitching pedigree. His action are as solid as they were before his growth spurt when he was considered a likely shortstop by most of the industry. There is some risk he fills in and loses too much speed to play shortstop but for now, I like his chances.</p><p>Thre is swing and miss as a result of his long levers. He gets beat inside and the bat control can wane at times. Then again, he only struck out 9.4% of the time in one of the better high school conferences in California. He’s more contact quality over quantity anyway. He has a steeper bat angle which helps him achieve optimal angles and puts the ball in the air with some regularity.</p><p>Charles also has elite power potential with exquisite bat speed and strong lower half that he does a solid job incorporating. He’s only going to get stronger as he grows into his very lanky frame.</p><p>I’m a big believer in the impact upside of his bat. There is some approach issues and whiff concerns but the power/speed upside from a shortstop is absolutely massive. He has incredible bloodlines too with a father who played basketball in college, a mom who was an All-American in Volleyball, and a brother who was drafted into the MLB over ten years ago. Charles checks a lot of boxes and could make a huge impact for the club lucky enough to draft him.</p><h4>95. SP Jonah Tong, Georgia Premier Academy</h4><p>Jonah Tong is one of the biggest popup arms this spring and given that he is only committed to North Dakota State, it’s highly likely that he signs and for relatively cheap. The stuff is loud and there is a decent chance I am much too low on Tong.</p><p>The fastball is the calling card. Tong sits 92–94 MPH and touched 96 MPH in the MLB draft league. He has a great feel for spinning the ball and exceptional vertical movement as he is averaging 21&quot; IVB in the MLB Draft League. Don’t quote me on this but I believe that they are using the minor league baseball so it’s really really good vertical movement.</p><p>Tong appears on film to have good extension and given that his only 6&#39;0&quot; it’s fairly likely he has a low release. This is an awesome fastball that should see him drafted very highly. I’m being tentative with his ranking because there’s still a lot of particulars I don’t know but everything I’ve seen on film or in the data is amazing.</p><p>The curveball is also above-average. He sits 74–78 MPH in my looks with -10&quot; IVB and just 2&quot; of sweep from a very vertical slot. It’s a true 12–6 hammer with elite spin rates (~2700 RPMs) and a solid shape that just needs more efficiency. The control over the pitch is lacking and he needs more power but the potential is clearly there for an above-average pitch.</p><p>I haven’t seen much of the changeup but I’ve gotten positive reviews from both sources I asked about it. He kills spin and creates good fading action. It’s a fringe-average pitch because I don’t know enough but it could be better. Jonah Tong has three quality pitches- one of which is potentially elite. He has some sustainability questions because he came out of nowhere but the stuff is legit and someone with more data than me could see him as a day one arm and I wouldn’t be surprised.</p><h4>96. SP Tristan Smith, Boiling Springs High School</h4><p>Tristan Smith has below-average command but I really like the three pitch mix. The fastball sits 92–94 MPH and tops out at 96 MPH. Tristan Smith is also someone who moves efficiently on the mound and has some projection left.</p><p>The lefty starter has plus feel for spin with a spin factor of 26.5 during the Hawkeye games. The fastball also has above-average carry as he sat at 19.1&quot; IVB (Adjust for the ball so ~17&quot;) and he has great tailing action as well at 12.5&quot; HB on average. The fastball plays up a tad too from a 5.7&#39; ft release height and 1.82&#39; RelSide.</p><p>The breaking ball is above-average as well. Tristan Smith primarily utilizes a curveball. Tristan Smith sits 78–80 MPH and at about ~2400 RPMs. The curve has MLB average vertical movement as well at -8.4 IVB and 12.4 inches of sweep to go with it. He probably needs to add more velocity for it to be an impactful pitch but I think that is pretty likely.</p><p>Tristan Smith also throws an average changeup. The pitch kills velocity and spin with him sitting at just 81 MPH with 1700 RPMs but has poor movement and the feel is still developing. I’m mostly just gambling on the arm speed and projecting out. The stuff upside isn’t that far off of most of the round one or two arms but his command keeps him below them.</p><h4>97. SP/3B/RP Jack Brannigan, Notre Dame</h4><p>Jack Brannigan is a legitimate prospect as both a pitcher and third baseman. This is where he ranks on the mound but he would be #172 on my board, purely as a hitter. He’s a fantastic defensive third baseman who has a borderline Masyn Winn level arm and good lateral movement at the hot corner. I like his range and surprising speed as well as obviously the arm enough to project him as a plus defender at the hot corner who could compete for gold gloves if he played there full time. There is plus raw power but he frequently mishits the ball so it plays down. There are also minor whiff and larger approach concerns. He’s a good player at third base but a risky one.</p><p>I want to see Jack Brannigan as a starting pitcher at the next level even if he’s only started one game in his career and had a career 6.94 ERA in 23.1 college innings. I swear this is not a joke. Jack Brannigan throws three quality pitches and given the athleticism and lack of experience on the mound, it’s easy to see the control improving.</p><p>The fastball is a plus pitch. He averages 96.1 MPH with spin rates that sit at 2533 RPMs. Brannigan has thrown as high as 99.8 MPH before! The pitch comes from a fairly unique angle with a 5.4&#39; release height in road games and a 2.7&#39; horizontal release; again isolated to road games because Notre Dame has a very miscalibrated Trackman unit.</p><p>The fastball has two variants. One is a sinker that sits 10.5&quot; IVB and 18&quot; inches of tailing movement to the arm side. The other is a four-seam at 15.5&quot; IVB and 15&quot; of tail. The four-seam is probably the better pitch but both have a use and the upside here is very high. He might lose a tick in the rotation and with a normal workload but it’s a flat fastball with a lot of horizontal movement and premium velocity. This is a heck of a pitch.</p><p>The slider is also a plus pitch. He throws it moderately hard at 83 MPH on average and can really spin it sitting at ~2600 RPMs. The pitch has 13&quot; of sweep on average and plus depth as well with -0.9&quot; IVB. The pitch plays up too due to the extremely wide horizontal release. I might be underselling the slider given that it had a swinging-strike rate close to 30% at Notre Dame this year.</p><p>The changeup is more fringe-average but it has to do solely with a lack of feel and command rather than stuff. Brannigan throws the changeup at 10.5 MPH slower than the fastball and kills nearly 800 RPMs off of it. The changeup has premium depth with just 2.5&quot; IVB and he also averages 17.3&quot; of fade. I have a hard time projecting given that it’s never in the zone and when it is it’s hung but the stuff is excellent.</p><p>That describes Brannigan as a whole for the most part. Jack Brannigan has superb stuff. If he had done this as a starting pitcher for a full season he would go in the top ten picks. He hasn’t done this as a starting pitcher so there is risk. There are huge command questions and relief risk. Because of the relief risk, it might make sense to keep him as a two-way player (At DH not third) until we know if he can make it as a starting pitcher. If he can’t a third baseman with premium defense is more valuable than a reliever probably but the starting pitching outcome has to be priority #1. The sky is the limit for Brannigan but there’s no one on my top 100 with more relief risk.</p><h4>98. SP/RP Evan Chrest, Ostinger Baseball Academy</h4><p>Evan Chrest doesn’t throw particularly hard only sitting 89–92 MPH and he probably never will seeing as how he’s only 5&#39;11&quot; with very little projection and non-elite movement speed on the mound. He might not need much more velocity though with spin rates that sit at about 2400 RPMs. Unlike a Jackson Cox, Chrest has great spin efficiency on his 1:30 fastball so he gets ~17&quot; IVB and 17&quot; HB. The pitch has a lower release height too coming from a 3/4 slot at just 5&#39;11&quot;. The pitch projects as above-average even with velocity concerns.</p><p>The slider is heavenly. He sits in the 78–81 MPH range with sweeper shape and spin rates that average north of 3000 RPMs. The pitch has absurd movement on both planes and misses a plethora of bats. You might want more power out if it but it still projects as a plus pitch. I do wonder if it’s too distinct from the fastball that it hurts the deceptive traits of both but given that the fastball is a hybrid that works down just as much as up, it’ll never put him in as much of a hole as Matt Brash’s FB/SL pairing does with their lack of synergy.</p><p>The changeup is fringe with some splitter traits and good fade. Feel and consistency issues or whatever but there is upside there. I really like the mechanics, he has great timing throughout and excellent upper body flexibility that gives him good separation in his delivery. He is fairly low effort even if the head bobbles and there is at least average command here. You’re drafting Chrest for the hellacious breaking ball, but he offers three potentially quality pitches. He’s a Jacksonville commit too so he should be relatively affordable.</p><h4>99. 2B/SS Robert Moore, Arkansas</h4><p>Robert Moore was ranked as a top ten player in the entire draft by some places before the season and then the wheels fell off this year as he only logged a 101 wRC+. He’s now ranked outside the top 150 by a lot of places which feels like overkill. I don’t think he ever belonged in the top ten but he was a legitimate first round talent and he still belongs in the first three rounds.</p><p>Robert Moore needs to stop switch hitting. He is better as a lefty by a comically wide margin. His Z-Swing is 12.4% higher, his chase rate is 1.7% lower, and his whiff rate is literally halved down from 24.79% as a RHB to 12.4% as a lefty. He also has a Max EV of 105.9 MPH which isn’t a lot but it’s 2.8 MPH higher than as a righty and his Top 8th EV is also up by 1.5 MPH even if it’s still below-average at 101.3 MPH.</p><p>Robert Moore makes a lot of contact and has solid swing decisions as a whole. He’s a tad aggressive but it works. He shows some feel for the barrel and hits the ball to all fields. If he stops the switch I’ll really buy the bat, and even if he doesn’t it might be enough for a bench role. He’s an elite defender at the keystone as well who only might move off of shortstop because he has below-average arm strength. He’s a plus runner as well. Moore is a better prospect in fantasy than in real life but he should be solid in real life too. Especially if he ditches the stupidity that is switch-hitting.</p><h4>100. SP Chase Shores, Legacy High School</h4><p>Chase Shores sits 92–95 MPH with his fastball and gets 6.7&#39; of extension. He can hit as high as 97 MPH and has a 6&#39;8&quot; frame and there is room for mechanical optimization as he learns to open up his pelvis earlier. There is triple digit potential here and possibly more. The fastball is a sinker primarily with good depth but and 15&quot; of fade but he has spin rates that touch 2600 RPMs. Despite his higher release, Shores is throwing from a sub 6&#39; vertical release point which creates some natural deception. I have the fastball as a plus even if it won’t be a big bat missed.</p><p>The breaking ball has made strides this spring. He now sits 83–85 MPH on the slider that flashes nasty bite from a lower slot. It’s still an average pitch because of how often he gets firm but it’s an interesting average. The changeup feel is still lacking but it has a really good shape. He sits at 82–85 MPH with 6.6&quot; IVB and 15.8&quot; HB during a start this February. I have it as an average projection but you could easily talk me higher. Despite his bigger frame, Shores throws strikes and there is obvious stuff upside. I have him as a late third round grade.</p><h4>101. SP/RP Alex Hoppe, UNC Greensboro</h4><p>You can read more about Alex Hoppe in <a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/best-underslot-targets-on-day-two-of-the-draft-a35c5489a7b2">yesterday’s piece on the best senior targets</a>. Hoppe has been a reliever in college but I think despite being nearly 24, he can be stretched out to start. The fastball hits 99 MPH and has above-average ride from a 5.7&#39; release height. The slider has plus sweep and good depth at 85.4 MPH. The changeup sits at 86.4 MPH which is nearly 10 MPH of separation and has 17.5&quot; of fade to his arm side. He barely uses it and has poor feel but the shape is strong. Hoppe throws strikes with the fastball but has very poor secondary command. He’ll sign for cheap and won’t debut until he’s in his mid-late twenties but the impact potential is still very high.</p><h4>102. SP/RP Nazier Mule, Passaic Tech. High School</h4><p>Nazier Mule was a two way prospect entering 2021 with plus power at shortstop but when his velocity exploded last summer, any idea of him playing shortstop was put to death. Nazier Mule has hit 99.9 MPH twice in games with statcast. On 35 fastballs with Hawkeye, Mule is averaging 98.2 MPH. That is not a typo.</p><p>Mule also has an extremely low release height at 5.34&#39; and a generic horizontal release at 1.82&#39;. He has league average extension so the velocity is what it looks like too. The pitch has a dead zone shape with 12.7&quot; IVB and 10.3&quot; HB but also it’s 98+ constantly from a very low release so it still works. It’s still a deadly pitch and I believe the fastball shape can improve even if he’s got low spin rates. He could potentially utilize SSW given the feel for gyro and create a turbo sinker too. That is probably the most optimal route for developing Mule.</p><p>The slider probably needs more power sitting 82–85 MPH but he has solid feel for spin averaging just over 2400 RPMs and a very high gyro angle. The pitch has just 0.6&quot; IVB and 1.8&quot; of cut. I’d like to see him add more velocity and given the arm strength that is very possible, and if he’s sitting 85+ with a gyro curve off of the dead-zone fastball he is going to destroy hitters. Even better, there might be the ability to develop a cutter here- possibly even as the primary in the upper nineties. He has low efficiency and the feel to supinate. I’m not counting on it but it’s a possibility to mention so if it does happen I can gloat excessively about foreseeing it.</p><p>The changeup is much more fringe. The pitch has way too much separation from the fastball as he sits 82–84 MPH with almost identical spin rates. The shape is good with just 5.2&quot; IVB in the Hawkeye games and 15.5&quot; of arm side movement. The pitch is lacking in feel and deception but there is some upside here. Mule also throws a very poor curveball at just 78 MPH with 12–6 shape but no efficiency so it gets just -3&quot; IVB. It’s a show-me pitch that should probably be scrapped entirely.</p><p>Obviously, given how hard he throws Mule has control and relief risk but he is at least a good athlete who keeps his composure. The stuff is the calling card because the potential impact of it is incredibly loud. High risk and high reward target in the third round.</p><h4>103. 3B/SP Cutter Coffey, Liberty High School</h4><p>Cutter Coffey is a two-way player who shouldn’t be allowed to pitch since he doesn’t throw a cutter. In all seriousness, I actually like Cutter on the mound and he would be in my top 300 purely as a pitcher. The sinker has elite fade from a very low release in the low nineties and he has a sweeper in the low eighties that flashes greatness. He’s much more interesting as a third baseman but there is legitimate potential on the mound.</p><p>The power is the calling card. He tested poorly last summer but he’s made some tweaks to his mechanics and is a lot better at using his backside to create power now. The attack angles are typically positive and he shows the ability to elevate regularly so I think he’ll tap into that power in games. The swing is violent which leads to some swing and miss risk but he also has a bat path that is often geared towards contact so it shouldn’t be that bad. The arm strength is a plus and even if he’s a high school shortstop, his thicker build makes it likely he plays third at the next level. He should be a quality defender there though given the arm strength and general actions. I like Coffey later in the third but I can see the appeal in taking him earlier and won’t have a problem if he does go earlier (or later).</p><h4>104. SP/RP Will Frisch, Oregon State</h4><p>If Will Frisch had been healthy this year, I think he would be talked about not too far beneath his teammate in the first round range. Instead, he blew out his elbow before making one start and underwent Tommy John Surgery this year. Given that Frisch has primarily been a reliever in college, there are too many questions to actually grade Frisch higher than this coming off of TJS.</p><p>The fastball is a plus pitch with lots of intriguing traits and the potential to be even better. The four-seam sits at 94.5 MPH with a very low release height of just 5.54&#39;. The pitch also comes from a pretty medial 1.3&#39; horizontal release. The movement is amplified by that release point as he gets 18.6&quot; IVB on average along with 17.5&quot; of horizontal movement. The pitch gets chases to the armside from the medial release and dominates the top of the zone with how flat his VAA is. He’s also showcasing above-average velocity. Maybe he fades closer to 93 MPH in the rotation but the stuff should still play.</p><p>The changeup is a lethal secondary weapon. He sits at 87.8 MPH which is admittedly not great velocity separation but it might be the only knock. Frisch averages just 2.7&quot; IVB and has an exceptionally great 17.7&quot; inches of arm side movement. He sells it really well as the fastball with good arm speed and hides the ball. He gets chasees at an elite rate and in-zone whiffs as well. There are some questions with the changeup command but it still performs even if he can’t find the zone with it all of the time.</p><p>The slider rounds out his repertoire and projects as below-average. He has solid velocity at 84.6 MPH on average and it plays off the changeup from the same tunnel but the actual traits leave a lot to be desired. The slider has just 3.3&quot; of sweep and below average depth as well as he only averaged 4.5&quot; IVB last year. He can lead the slider for strikes so maybe I’m underselling the impact but it’s also clearly his worst pitch.</p><p>The control is below-average oftentimes but it’s not an insurmountable flaw, just a minor knock. He also has an exceptional batted ball profile that was among the best in the country as a reliever. He collects all of groundballs, popups, and line drives at an above-average rate. There is some risk in stretching him out and Tommy John but I think he has a starter’s repertoire with great OHB weaponry and plus outgen skills. He’s a gamble but it could be one with a massive payoff in the third round and beyond.</p><p><em>That’s all for the players with first three rounds grades. You can read the rest of my unedited notes on the top 500 players in this year’s draft </em><a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XwTF5WR1E9cFGb6BogVTyzuMhz7rLxzI356V8bzKwh4/edit#gid=1291381164"><em>HERE</em></a><em>. There are over 150,000 more words of completely new content on the top 500 players in this year’s draft (Including more info on some of the ones in this medium post) if you follow </em><a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XwTF5WR1E9cFGb6BogVTyzuMhz7rLxzI356V8bzKwh4/edit#gid=1291381164"><em>THIS LINK</em></a><em>! Seriously, click </em><a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XwTF5WR1E9cFGb6BogVTyzuMhz7rLxzI356V8bzKwh4/edit#gid=1291381164"><em>THE FUCKING LINK</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>Thanks for reading! Tomorrow is the most fun blog (For me writing it) I’ve ever written as I’ll break down some of the top relief prospects in the draft. Oh and there’s still another 150,000+ words of draft content left to read today by following </em><a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XwTF5WR1E9cFGb6BogVTyzuMhz7rLxzI356V8bzKwh4/edit#gid=1291381164"><em>this link</em></a><em>!</em></p><p><em>One more time, here’s a link to my </em><a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1XwTF5WR1E9cFGb6BogVTyzuMhz7rLxzI356V8bzKwh4/edit#gid=1291381164"><em>draftboard</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fba9fe7fceaf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Best Underslot Targets on Day Two of The Draft]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/best-underslot-targets-on-day-two-of-the-draft-a35c5489a7b2?source=rss-f20e8b3389a4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a35c5489a7b2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[money-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[budget]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[college-baseball]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tieran Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Jul 2022 19:02:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-14T19:02:35.488Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Uc1S4SiAk0Pl_lnygIei9A.png" /></figure><p>One of the most popular and successful draft strategies is to spread the wealth. Almost every team employs it in some manner. MLB Teams can’t just draft the best player available with every pick because they have a limited bonus pool they are allowed to offer and good players cost more money.</p><p>The way teams draft vary team to team and even year to year for each team. Sometimes you have a team like the Pirates who cut a deal at #1 overall with Henry Davis so they could splurge on their next three picks and get four players that got first-round grades from some evaluators. Other times teams go over the slot value in round one to take a falling prep bat like Khalil Watson last year, and cut corners later in the draft in order to afford his bonus demands.</p><p>The one common link in all of these approaches is that to save money one of the most common methods is drafting underslot players in the late rounds with no leverage in signing bonus negotiations. Most of the time these players are seniors who have no choice but to sign even for just 10K or whatever number the team <em>generously</em> offers. The Mets did this with Jake Magnum where he signed for 20K in the fourth round so they could afford to sign Matt Allen.</p><p>The other common archetype of a cash-saving underslot player on day two is someone from a D2 school or an older junior college Player. Ryan Murphy signed for just 22.5K with the Giants in 2020 which allowed them to not only add a very good Ryan Murphy but also sign Kyle Harrison who is a top three pitching prospect in all of baseball. When you have both a senior and D2 guy, you get the travesty that is Riley Martin who signed for just $1,000 with the Cubs out of the draft last year as a 6th round pick.</p><p>There are exceptions to every rule. I will primarily focus on players fitting these two archetype’s in this blog but there are some juniors who are impatient and sign for cheap. There are players who take less than they should because they want to play for their favorite team or with a friend. Even some preps sign for below the slot value. Injured players can decide they want to have an MLB team’s rehab and sign for cheap. Those players are more uncertain about their price tag and often less cheap even if cheap, so I won’t focus on them here but I have to mention they exist.</p><p>Enough rambling intro, let’s get into the list of 19 players who I think should go on day two with big financial savings.</p><p><em>Strike zone parameters are based on height for hitters. For pitchers, I assume every opposing hitter is 6&#39;1&quot;</em></p><h3>SP/RP Alex Hoppe, UNC Greensboro</h3><p>UNC Greensboro is the top-ranked senior in this year’s draft on my board and the only one I have a top-three round grade on independent of his demands or senior status. He’s primarily been a reliever in college which has him flying under the radar but he has three quality pitches and I have him projected into the rotation despite his lack of success in that role in the past.</p><p>The fastball is an above-average pitch that can pretty easily be argued as a plus and I would have it graded as one if I thought Hoppe was going to be a reliever at the next level. Alex Hoppe throws his fastball very hard at 96.3 MPH on average and can touch as high as 99.2 MPH from the right handed side.</p><p>You would presume that velocity will drop some if he’s stretched out to start, and it probably will but that is not a guarantee by any means. Alex Hoppe might have been a reliever but he still had a pretty big workload. Hoppe was asked to face on average 11 Batters each appearance and he averaged 41.3 pitchers each outing. The velocity will probably drop some in relief but I don’t think the dropoff will be as significant as most people are making it out to be. He’ll still sit 94–95 and flash brilliance in the velocity department.</p><p>The movement profile isn’t anything exceptional but it is also quite strong. Alex Hoppe gets 17.8 IVB on his fastball and 12.3 HB. That might not be exceptional movement but it’s still above-average vertical movement and plus horizontal break. That will play, and it can play incredibly well at his velocity.</p><p>The release traits appear to be generic with a 5.94 RelHeight and a 2.24 RelSide but looks can be deceiving. UNC Greensboro has a miscalibrated trackman unit. All of their pitchers have a vertical release point that is approximately 0.3 ft lower on road games than at home ones. Hoppe actually has a 5.68 ft release height and 2.03 ft RelSide. That when paired with the above-average fastball movement gives Hoppe a plus zone-neutral VAA.</p><p>Alex Hoppe is aggressive in throwing his fastball for strikes with 54.1% of them winding up in the strike zone. What Hoppe struggles with though is actually choosing his spots in the zone. Alex Hoppe throws just 42.5% of fastball in the top half of the strike zone even though he has a 15.7% Swinging-Strike rate on pitches in the top half. Elevate more and better things happen with the fastball. Even still, the fastball is performing because its impact velocity in a weak conference and with a flatter VAA. He throws the fastball 69% of the time and it’s easy to see why that is, this is a great pitch.</p><p>The slider has a fantastic shape and loud results with a 25.2% Swinging-Strike rate against it this year. He throws it hard at 85.4 MPH and has above-average movement on both planes with 0.2 IVB and 11.6 inches of sweep to his glove side. The pitch gets chases at a high clip and in-zone whiffs as well. As it should with the lethal combination of velocity and movement.</p><p>The primary problem with the slider is a lack of command. He struggles with throwing the pitch in the zone with any regularity with a zone rate just below 25%. He’s often throwing sliders way off the plate and in the dirt too. Low-level hitters will chase that crap but it won’t fly at the higher levels. This slider has plus shape but it’s only an above-average grade until he figures out where he is going with it.</p><p>The changeup rounds out the repertoire. He only threw 11 of them this year but they are inarguably distinct pitches and also inarguably really good pitches data-wise. The changeup sits at 86.4 MPH with a spin rate of 1848 RPMs. That is 9.9 MPH slower than the fastball. He throws the cambio on a 2:00 spin tilt with high efficiency and the result is him getting 17.5 HB and 11.7 IVB on the changeup.</p><p>That is 93rd percentile arm-side movement on the changeup relative to the major leagues. The depth is limited but the one plane movement might help him sell it as the fastball before it runs away from them and misses bats/gets weak contact because of poor timing due to the velocity difference. The feel is absolutely abysmal and it will take serious work to develop the pitch but there is real impact potential in the changeup.</p><p>Alex Hoppe has a pretty robust batted ball profile. He had a 96th percentile groundball rate and an 85th percentile LD avoid last year. This year it’s a 48.3% groundball rate and 16.6% line drive rate. Popups would come if he just elevates the fastball. Hoppe also has a knack for getting soft contact although that is absolutely in large part due to his competition quality. Hoppe only has an average EV of 77.4 MPH against him this year and 43.9% of batted balls against Hoppe are hit below 80 MPH. That is a lot in case you couldn’t tell.</p><p>The control is still a work in progress for Hoppe. He can throw strikes with the fastball consistently but that is his only pitch. The lack of secondary command leads to some walks and more so a lot of wild pitches.</p><p>There is absolutely risk in this profile. Hoppe is already 23 and needs a lot of work to reach the majors. If you develop him as a starting pitcher then Hoppe is realistically 3–4 years away from the majors. That means by the time he debuts he could be 27. That is a major turn-off for most people and probably should turn me away but it doesn’t.</p><p>I look at Alex Hoppe and see high-end upside with three pitches that all flash plus stuff. I see fantastic out-generation skills and a diverse repertoire that could potentially dominate batters of both handednesses. The upside here is immense and I’m okay with waiting to see him be the high impact arm I know he can be. He’s a 23 year old senior reliever who will come dirt cheap which adds to the appeal but he would be appealing regardless.</p><h3>SP Michael Knorr, Coastal Carolina</h3><p>Any number of people will say that Michael Knorr is the best senior target in the draft and I can easily see where they are coming from. He transferred from Cal Fullerton to Coastal Carolina this year and responded with a 10.5% boost in K-BB%. The stuff has upticked and is now on par with most 4th-6th round college arms.</p><p>The fastball is an above-average pitch. He sits at 94.4 MPH and tops out at 98.2 MPH. The velocity is held deep into outings too and I think it’ll probably translate to pro ball. At first glance, the movement seems spectacular but his home trackman is miscalibrated. He only averages 16.9 IVB from a six foot release height. Both of those numbers are right about the MLB average and that gives him a very average VAA. The fastball is too often grooved down the middle and he doesn’t elevate enough for my tastes (Average height of 2.49 ft) but there is above-average upside here.</p><p>The slider is also above-average and the results indicate it might be a lot more as he has managed to record a swinging-strike rate of nearly 25% against it. He throws a gyro heavy slider in the 81–84 MPH range with above-average depth and some bite to his gloveside. His slider is completely unhittable in the strike zone where it has a 53.3% whiff rate. He fills the zone at a somewhat high rate at 42.4% and it doesn’t take much squinting to understand why as the chase rates only a 55 while he has 80 grade in-zone whiffs. I don’t think that will translate obviously because that’s borderline unfathomable dominance but it’s a genuinely good pitch I might be underselling.</p><p>Michael Knorr also offers a below-average curveball. Velocity is really the only problem with the pitch, however. He sits at ~75 MPH with above-average two-plane movement. The pitch has -11.2 IVB and 12.6 inches of sweep. Both figures are above-average for a curveball. The problem is that Knorr often struggles to find the zone with the slow curve and slow curves without absurd movement rarely profiles. There is an upside with added power but it’s a 45 projection for the time being.</p><p>Michael Knorr rounds out his repertoire with a changeup that has a 20.5% Swinging-Strike rate this year. I’m more skeptical of the pitch despite the results. Knorr sits at about 83.6 MPH on the changeup which is great velocity separation from the heater. He shows a decent feel for killing spin as well. My qualms come from how the changeup moves. He gets just 12.5 IVB and 11.6 HB in road games.</p><p>So why the results? That horizontal movement is 0.07 inches away from the exact same horizontal action as the fastball. The vertical difference in movement isn’t significant but maybe the fact that he locates the changeup so far to his arm side and down in the zone off the middle-middle fastball with such significant velocity separation gives him elite deception. Changeups are weird. He’s only throwing 34% of them in the zone but getting chases 51.5% of the time. This is a loose average grade that will vary more based on how it performs against better competition than how it develops.</p><p>Michael Knorr throws a lot of strikes but that is more due to him aggressively pounding the strike zone with the fastball than anything really projectable moving forward. He’s also largely reliant on chases with his secondaries to avoid balls with them and there’s some skepticism on how their chase rates will translate to better hitters. He has more 55 control projection than the plus it has played at this season. There is some line drive proneness in the profile due to pitch location that I think can be fixed.</p><p>I think Michael Knorr has back-of-the-rotation potential and the price to sign him is just a bonus, not the entire appeal. He offers four quality pitches and he throws strikes. The upside is somewhat limited and he’s older but he still has good stuff.</p><h3>SP Patrick Pridgen, Florida International</h3><p>Patrick Pridgen actually gets a slight edge over Knorr from me on my board. Pridgen is technically a sophomore because he attended a JUCO for two years and rode the pine with Oregon a year before transferring to FIU. He will be 23.3 on draft day and 24 year olds rarely get paid- especially from small schools so he’ll likely sign for cheaper this year to avoid being in that ugly spot.</p><p>Patrick Pridgen reminds me a bit of Chase Silseth. Their pitch mixes are completely different but there is one big-league ready pitch that he just doesn’t use often enough or in the right situations so it holds him back significantly. Like with Silseth he had a bad curveball he used far too often and often drilled batters with it and struggled to find the zone or miss bats. There is literally a quote from Pridgen’s pitching coach confessing to the same problem:</p><blockquote>“Early in the season, Patrick was hitting batters with his curve, and we took that pitch away from his arsenal,” — Willie Collazo, Pitching Coach at FIU</blockquote><p>Sure enough, after his first four starts he saw his HBP rate fall off completely. Pridgen still has a major walk issue but that one small tweak eliminated most of his errant pitches. I don’t expect the walks to go away ever but I think they might be able to become manageable.</p><p>The fastball is an above-average pitch. Pridgen gets up to 97 MPH from the right-handed side and will frequently sit 91–94 MPH. He has high spin rates on the heater and will at least flash plus vertical movement. I don’t have the exact pitch specs from this year but I know that he had a 105 Hop+ on the pitch in the MLB draft league during the 2021 season which means he basically has a location-neutral VAA that is 5% better than the average major leaguer.</p><p>The slider is above average as well. He throws it in the low eighties with high gyro angle. The pitch utilizes SSW to get plus sweeping action to his gloveside. Pridgen misses bats with it but often struggles to throw the sweeping slider for strikes and he doesn’t get enough chases to make up for it. I suspect this is because it doesn’t mesh amazingly with his heater.</p><p>Enter the miracle pitch that could make Pridgen great and take his game to new heights with better situational usage. What else would it be but a cutter? A plus cutter is a possible answer to all the questions you might want to ask.</p><p>The cutter sits in the 88–92 MPH range with solid vertical life. I also know he can get up to 11 inches of cut on the cutter at 90 MPH. I say up to but it’s a one-pitch sample I have the data for and he sat at 11 HB. That doesn’t mean it’s necessarily his best cutter. Considering the best cutter in the MLB is thrown by Kenley Jansen with just 8.5 inches of cut, it’s significant regardless. This pitch has fantastic traits.</p><p>Patrick Pridgen’s cutter usage might be a criminal offense. It’s his third most used pitch. and he doesn’t use it to strike batters out despite it being probably his best swing and miss pitch. According to his pitching coach, he uses the cutter to get ahead in the count and avoid walks while going to the fastball and slider for strikeouts. This checks out with my in-game looks where he was also frequently landing the plus cutter for strikes. I think Pridgen needs to flip his strategy and lean on the cutter significantly more. The pitch is awesome.</p><p>I’ve also gotten rave reviews about Pat Pridgen as a person. He has a very high work ethic and is a methodological thinker who meticulously plans out his starts and how to attack hitters. He often fails to execute with his limited resources and lack of confidence in his best pitch but he puts in a lot of effort to being the best he can be and that probably matters.</p><p>The stuff is very present and with some tweaks could be taken to new heights even if he already has some of the top strikeout rates in the country. He has some relief risk with the lack of control and changeup but I’m more optimistic and him riding the cutter to be viable against left handed hitters. If he does wind up in relief I think the stuff will play up anyways so it’s not that big of a concern. The biggest risk here is that he has zero trackman data but from what I do know, I love Pridgen. I’ll either look really smart or really dumb for this one a year from now.</p><h3>Utility Ben Metzinger, Louisville</h3><p>Ben Metzinger turns 23 before the draft and is a 4th year junior. He has some leverage thanks to the COVID year giving him an extra year so he won’t sign for literal pennies but he should still be cheap. This was his first year as a regular after four years at Louisville and he was a dominant force.</p><p>The contact skills are top-notch. Ben Metzinger whiffed just 10.8% of the time on pitches in the zone in 2022 and the breakdown of how it works is even more impressive. Velocity? Not a problem for Metzinger who runs a mere 16.7% whiff rate on pitches at 93+. Breaking balls? Again, literally no difficulty for Metzinger who has a 15.6% whiff rate against them. Changeups? Even those he only runs an 8.5% swinging-strike rate against. There are concerns that Metzinger is more advanced than inherently skilled at making contact and it’s a viable argument but it’s still a clear plus skill that will translate.</p><p>The swing decisions are also above-average. He is somewhat passive but a 62% Z-Swing% and a 20.1% chase% are still quite good. That is the one skill I’m not sure I believe in moving up the ladder as it might just be him bullying younger competition. The more likely part of why it won’t translate to walks at the higher levels though is because he’s unlikely to be enough of an XBH hit to not attack the zone against him.</p><p>The power is fringe and generously a 40 raw grade. The power still plays in games, however, despite only an above-average feel to elevate. The reason behind this is twofold. First off, he pulls a large chunk of his aerial contact.</p><p>Secondly, he hits the ball with obscene amounts of backspin. The average spin rate on his batted balls is 3302 RPMs which ranks in the 98th percentile of all college hitters. He also hits 53.4% of his batted balls with backspin. That is 6% more than the average college hitter. Balls with high spin and more specifically high amounts of backspin carry farther and outperform expected stats. Metzinger can be expected to outperform his raw power because he pulls his aerial contact and has an ideal spin profile.</p><p>I like the bat of Metzinger but one of the more enticing parts of the profile is his versatility. Metzinger has experience all over the diamond and that includes catcher where he played as recently as 2020. His best spot is second base as he’s only an average athlete with an average arm but he is at his most valuable in that super-utility flex role. I don’t think Metzinger has star upside or anything but he’s likely to be a useful bench piece with his versatility and a solid bat. That puts him in the 4th-7th round range and the cash savings from signing him are more of a bonus than a necessity when drafting Metzinger.</p><h3>SP Connor Noland, Arkansas</h3><p>Connor Noland has fairly bland stuff but he throws strikes and has a really strong batted ball profile so I’m still intrigued with him on day two even if you ignore the likely cheap bonus demands.</p><p>The four-seam fastball is horrible. He sits at 91 MPH from a 6.5 ft vertical release with just 12 IVB and 5.5 HB. He uses it 21.5% of the time which is 21.5% too much of them. The four-seam has literally zero whiffs in the top half of the zone on 96 four-seam fastballs in that half. The pitch should be scrapped entirely in favor of the above-average sinker.</p><p>Connor Noland has a very unique angle on his sinker. The pitch coming from a 6.5 release has just 6.9 IVB and 11.3 HB. The result of that combined with his ability to pitch down in the zone gives him a VAA of -7.3° in road games (Arkansas Home trackman is slightly off). At the time of me writing this, the only major leaguer with a VAA steeper than Noland against their sinker with at least 100 sinkers thrown is Dallas Keuchel (McFarland is tied).</p><p>Keuchel won a Cy young with no velo because of his sinker. Noland won’t do the same but… I’m not considering any but. He just won’t. If he does I will personally apologize to him. I do still like the sinker though because of the unique angle even if it probably needs more power.</p><p>Yet, the vertical angle isn’t even all that stands out. Connor Noland throws from a very medial horizontal release point at just 0.65 ft in Road games (0.73 at home). The pitch only has 11.3 HB but that still gives him a great horizontal approach angle to his arm side and lets the pitch play way up there as a groundball getter. I love this sinker and have a 55 on it even without velo.</p><p>The curveball is actually his most used pitch though even over the sinker and it’s an above-average pitch as well. The pitch has some of the best power of all collegiate curves sitting at 83 MPH on average. He also has average vertical depth at -9.2 IVB and averagish sweep at -9.9 HB. You’re relying on power and angle to carry the pitch here and it does just that.</p><p>Noland also throws a below-average slider at 85.3 MPH. The pitch has solid depth but limited bite and the angle undermines its chase ability to his glove side. It could be made to work out the bottom of the zone but the curve is better in just about every circumstance.</p><p>The changeup is a below-average projection because he barely uses it (Less than 1%) but I can’t help but be intrigued by the potential of him developing one. He has the requisite feel to kill spin losing about 800 RPMs from the sinker and the angle he offers is unique. Right now, it doesn’t work off the sinker as it’s just 4.5 MPH slower with the same basic shape but if you can amplify that velo separation or something, it could be good. Noland is the perfect candidate to develop a splitter in my opinion but obviously, I won’t assume that is happening until it does.</p><p>Connor Noland gets a lot of groundballs and shows above-average control. I think he’ll show some platoon split until he develops a changeup (Or preferably a cutter to balance the sinker) and pair with the hard curve against lefties but he won’t be terrible against them as is. He’s a potential starting pitcher who might be forced to be a unique reliever due to the limited repertoire depth. Very intriguing day two target who should come pretty cheap due to him turning 23 the day after the draft concludes.</p><h3>3B Zach Dezenzo, Ohio State</h3><p>Zach Dezenzo has an argument for having the best raw power in the entire draft. To which you should respond with Spencer Jones. I would then concede in this hypothetical conversation and we’d agree that Dezenzo has the second best raw power in the entire draft.</p><p>Zach Dezenzo hit a ball 115.7 MPH this year. It was a pulled line drive into left field. There are only 11 major leaguers who have hit a ball that hard this year. It would rank in the 98th percentile of major leaguers this season. He also has the 9th highest Top 8th EV in the entire country at 110.3 MPH. This is 70 grade raw juice.</p><p>You probably don’t need any more raw power metrics to get the point across but I enjoy drooling at his raw exit velocities so I’ll give them to you anyways. Dezenzo has a 66.7% Hard-Hit rate this year which ranks 4th in the entire country (The leaderboard counts foul balls, I know for a fact that DiChiara is ahead of the #1 player when you only look at fair balls). Dezenzo has hit 52.2% of his batted balls over 98 MPH. That is the highest rate in the country. His average exit velocity is 96.4 MPH which is in the 100th percentile of all college hitters.</p><p>This is game power too, not just raw power. Zach Dezenzo has a mere 28.2% groundball rate this year. The outfield flyball rate is in the 89th percentile of all college hitters this year. The power plays better on aerial contact than on the ground too with 75% of his aerial contact being hit hard and an average exit velocity of 100.1 MPH on those same airborne batted balls. This all leads to an 18.9% barrel rate which is in the 99th percentile of all college hitters this year.</p><p>Zach Dezenzo also has great BABIP skills on paper. His 48.7% Sweet-Spot rate ranks in the 93rd percentile of all college hitters. He only pops out 1.3% of the time which is in the 87th percentile. He has a 97th percentile sdLA at 25°. He’s not overly pull-heavy or anything either. He’s also hitting the ball obscenely hard and that leads to higher BABIPs as well. There might not be a better present-day wOBAcon threat outside of Ivan Melendez in the entire draft.</p><p>Unfortunately, Dezenzo is dragged down by the on-base skills. Zach Dezenzo is a very aggressive hitter. He regularly will expand the zone in pursuit of pitches away from him and is just trigger happy in general. He’s chasing 34% of the time which is obviously not great. What is great (probably?) is that he also swings at 78.9% of pitches in the strike zone. This would suggest that electric Dezenzo is less blind and more impatient. And honestly who can blame him for being impatient when he does so much damage that walking is counterproductive.</p><p>Zach Dezenzo also has a whiff problem. He only made contact 72% of the time this year which is in the 15th percentile for a college bat. His whiffs aren’t just when he chases, unfortunately, Dezenzo has still not been at all good in the zone with just a 78.6% in-zone contact rate.</p><p>The breakdowns of what he is whiffing at are unusual. Dezenzo’s worst whiff pitch (By Swinging-Strike rate) is the sinker that he chases 47.9% of the time and he whiffs 26.1% of the time in the zone against it. The next worst whiff pitch for Dezenzo is the slider which is the pitch he has the lowest chase rate against at just 26.3%. The chases are mostly against fastballs and offspeed stuff but he doesn’t actually chase the breaking ball.</p><p>The whiffs come against everything but the curveball which he hammers. He whiffs an alarming 42.9% of the time against fastballs at 93+ but given that it’s a 35-pitch sample size I will cut him some slack. He’s actually better against pitches in the top half than in the bottom half. I’m not going to pretend to understand why given that he has a steeper VBA and a bat path geared solely for power. Maybe it’s a vision thing? The whiffs are bad and why he is only a 40 FV but they don’t completely counteract the ridiculous contact quality by any means.</p><p>Zach Dezenzo has primarily played shortstop in college but I think he’ll probably wind up at third base in the majors. He also has some experience at first base and a corner outfield spot so maybe he could fill a utility role instead. Dezenzo is a 40 runner with a quick first step and a strong arm. He’s probably average at third base but I haven’t spent that much time watching him play defense so I could be way off base. Either way, you aren’t drafting Dezenzo for the glove but for the very robust bat. He’s a senior despite only being 22 and should be signable for pretty cheap in the first six rounds.</p><h3>1B/DH Sonny DiChiara, Auburn</h3><p>Sonny DiChiara obliberates baseballs. There are three common knocks against SonnDiChiara that keep him down draft boards. The first is that he has no track record of production and that is a fair concern. DiChiara was at Samford for three years prior to transferring to Auburn this year and in 2021 he had a career best .273/.428/.598 triple slash against much worse pitching. Then this year he found a new gear as he murdered the SEC to the tune of a .384/.549/.777 line.</p><p>The second knock is that Sonny DiChiara is going to provide negative defensive value. This is another concern that makes a lot of sense and is something he deserves to be knocked for. DiChiara is a 20 grade runner with poor mobility and flexibility. He’s not a particularly tall target at first base and his reach is limited. This is a fringy defensive first baseman who is best served as a full time DH in the major leagues. There are very few full time DHs and the ones who do claim that role are usually among the best hitters in all of baseball. That leaves a pretty narrow path for DiChiara to find any semblance of success at the highest level.</p><p>The third and most stupid flaw DiChiara gets slandered with is the fact that he is fat. Sonny DiChiara is 6&#39;1&quot; and 265 lbs. I don’t really see the relevance. Sonny DiChiara has limited defensive value and will likely wind up DH. That might be because he is fat but in practice, it’s not any different than anyone who ends up at DH because they have a bad knee or whatever. He’s not providing less defensive value than someone with the same grades because of his size. The size is already factored into how he performs, you don’t need to double penalize him for it. We’ve seen plenty of XXL players mash in the big leagues and I don’t really view it as an impediment for what matters- his bat.</p><p>Sonny DiChiara obliberates baseballs. Sonny DiChiara has a 66% Hard-Hit rate in 2022 while facing SEC pitching. It is the 5th highest hard-hit rate in the entire country (The leaderboard counts foul balls, I know for a fact that DiChiara is ahead of the #1 player when you only look at fair balls). DiChiara hit 49.5% of his batted balls over 98 MPH. That is the second highest rate in the country behind only fellow senior, Zach Dezenzo. Sonny DiChiara had an average exit velocity of 94.4 MPH, that is also in the 99th percentile among all college hitters with 50+ BBE in games with Trackman.</p><p>DiChiara also has feel to elevate as well with only a 30.9% groundball rate and that when combined with the consistent hard contact leads to an astronomical 19.6% Barrel rate. That is the 9th highest barrel rate in the country. There is a very coherent argument that DiChiara has the best present-day game power in the draft class.</p><p>The key term there is present-day. DiChiara’s power is already perfectly optimized which leads to him dominating at the collegiate level but I don’t think it will thrive so much in the big leagues as it’s only actually plus raw power. That sounds outlandish to suggest about someone with DiChiara’s hard hit rates but it’s the truth. Sonny DiChiara only has a Max EV of 111 MPH. His 106.7 MPH top 8th EV is in the 91st percentile which is great for sure but it’s largely because of elite barrel accuracy and the consistency of his power already. That’s not even some earth shattering figure either. DiChiara only has 60 raw power and it might project above that at 65 game but it’ll probably never broach into that elite threshold.</p><p>Sonny DiChiara has advanced BABIP skills as well for his current level and I think they project fairly well. That is in large part because of the consistently plus power but also because of advanced barrel accuracy. DiChiara has both an above-average sweet-spot rate and avoids mishits. He pops out just 4.1% of the time and avoids low launch angle groundballs for the most part- mostly because he just puts the ball in the air instead. His soft contact rates are very low and he just hits the ball hard which does a lot for him.</p><p>Sonny DiChiara has a fantastic approach. He chases just 15.1% of the time and is below 19% against every type of pitch. The Z-Swing is a little low at just 60.1% but it’s high enough to make never chasing more than a worthwhile tradeoff for DiChiara. He should walk at a high rate and the power/walk combo should lead to good things.</p><p>There is a real concern with DiChiara’s ability to make contact, however. DiChiara only had a 71.3% contact rate this year and that is mostly due to in-zone whiffs as he whiffed at 21.8% of in-zone pitches. There is no easy fix for his problems. Plate discipline is not a problem and it’s not one particular thing causing him trouble. He whiffs against every type of pitch and doesn’t have bad discipline against any of them. The location doesn’t seem to be a determining factor in the whiff rates either. The hit risk is high and why you can be somewhat skeptical of if the power and on-base skills will be allowed to play.</p><p>There is also an issue with DiChiara struggling to barrel up pitches on the inner third. Due to the lack of flexibility in his swing, DiChiara struggles to get the barrel in on the inside pitch and as such only has an average EV of 86.5 MPH and he’s only maxing out at 106.5 so unlike Melendez it’s probably not just a small sample size fluke. I think he can work around that whole given the plate discipline being so good and it might even be fixable but it’s probably something to watch.</p><p>Sonny DiChiara has one of the highest upside bats in the entire draft. The impact potential is through the roof at the plate. However, hit tool questions and a lack of defensive value make the picture somewhat murky. I think DiChiara might wind up as a Daniel Vogelbach type of player who usually is fairly replaceable but will have stretches or even seasons where he is an all-star caliber hitter. He’s not my favorite of the 40 FVs by any means but he hits with authority and as a senior should sign for really cheap.</p><h3>C/1B Dominic Keegan, Vanderbilt</h3><p>I have no clue what I was thinking the last time I scouted Dominic Keegan because looking at him again, a month later, I think he is amazing. Perhaps it’s the extra month of data or perhaps I was distracted or something last time I did this. Keegan is a wOBAcon monster at the plate with solid contact rates and a fringe chance at sticking behind the plate in the long term.</p><p>The raw power is explosive. Dominic Keegan can hit the ball very hard with some of the best top-end exit velocities in the entire draft. The Max EV of 113.7 MPH is already in the 92nd percentile of MLB players. His Top 8th EV of 110.2 MPH is the 10th best in all of college baseball and would have been 8th in the MLB last year, just 0.1 MPH ahead of Mike Freaking Trout. (This is wrong, I’m comparing the 92nd EV to the 87.5th EV) Keegan is an older college player but this is titanic raw power regardless of age and there is no projection needed here. Rewind to 2021 and those numbers are even better with a 113.9 Max EV and a 110.5 Top 8th EV.</p><p>The game power is not quite as strong as the raw power. Keegan puts the ball on the ground 46.9% of the time. That ranks in the 37th percentile of all college players. This is because of his flatter bat angle that leads to very little implicit loft primarily, but also in part because Keegan struggles to post consistently positive attack angles.</p><p>Dominic Keegan is also hurting because he only pulls 10.5% of outfield flyball with 71.1% of them being hit to centerfield. That causes the power to play down as, despite 19 barrels in games with Trackman, Keegan hit just 11 home runs in those games. A 12.5% Barrel rate is also a bit of a letdown as well given how hard Keegan hits the ball and how often he does so- he just doesn’t have the launch component down quite yet.</p><p>Dominic Keegan has an interesting BABIP profile. At first glance, he doesn’t look like all that with a 26th percentile Sweet-Spot% and a popup rate that is just 0.5% above league-average (good). He also hits 75.5% of his groundballs with a launch angle below 0° and when you are hitting as many of them as Keegan does that is especially problematic.</p><p>So why do I have the BABIP skill as an average skill? Keegan hits the ball stupid Hard with a 54% Hard-Hit rate (96th percentile) and when you do that stupid things happen. This is why Keegan was able to run a .423 career BABIP in four years at Vanderbilt. The skill will be slightly less impactful against better defenses but it’s still a difference-maker.</p><p>The other key thing you have to know about Dominic Keegan is that he has really well-optimized spin traits on his batted balls. Keegan has an average spin rate of 3105 RPMs on his batted balls. That is in the 86th percentile of college players. He also has an 86th percentile backspin% at 54.9%.</p><p>The consistent backspin on his batted ball created by the flatter bat path has a somewhat difficult to quantify impact but definitely affects how many of the flyballs to centerfield he is so fond of, get over the centerfielder&#39;s head. There is also the fact that Keegan hits the ball to all fields which helps tremendously with running a high BABIP.</p><p>Dominic Keegan has cut down on the whiffs by a significant margin this year at the expense of some of the game power. He is now making contact 79.4% of the time but perhaps more importantly, it’s an 86.4% in-zone contact rate. Keegan is hitting velocity at a solid clip with a 7.35% Swinging-Strike rate against 93+ and he is hitting breaking balls with just a 22.2% whiff rate against them this year. His worst pitch by whiff% is the changeup at just 30.8%. He’s not great against anything but he is at least solid against everything.</p><p>I do wonder how much of the contact gains are sustainable though. Keegan still has a major chase issue against sliders, expanding the zone for them 39.1% of the time. He still chases sinkers and weakly rolls them over and chases fastballs in on the hands that he struggles to drive with authority. I have some concerns with what will happen when those breaking balls are actually good and he can’t just wait for mistake pitches.</p><p>Keegan also swings through a lot of fastballs in the zone (17%) which even without velocity struggles to data does create long-term worry on my behalf. I don’t think the contact skills are as good as the numbers and think he’ll go back to whiff somewhat regularly. The wOBAcon skills should still make him a good bat but it won’t be an elite one, unfortunately.</p><p>Dominic Keegan is somewhat passive at the plate. He only swings 41.3% of the time and that’s not because he’s suddenly developed elite plate discipline. Keegan is still making average swing decisions, just slightly passive ones. The chase rate of 25.5% is solid and the 61% Z-Swing% is about as far below average as the chase rate is above-average. My concern with the plate discipline in relation to the slider being the pitch he swings the most often at was already mentioned above so I’ll refrain from rehashing that argument.</p><p>Dominic Keegan gets poor reviews behind the plate and I’m not any more optimistic. Runners stole 73% of bases on steal attempts against Keegan last year and the specs aren’t at all good either. The average pop time of 2.22 seconds is in the 8th percentile of college catchers. The 90th percentile pop time of 2.02 seconds is in the 8th percentile as well. His pure arm strength grades out slightly higher in the 47th percentile of average throw velocity and in the 53rd percentile of 90th percentile throw velo.</p><p>The actions behind the plate really are not that much cleaner. He’s a somewhat sluggish defender who struggles with blocking pitches in my looks. He’s a fringy backstop who gets some positive reviews for the framing ability which will be irrelevant by the time he is in the big leagues. I think Keegan probably winds up at first base in the long term given the arm’s limitations and lack of general defensive ability. I think that is probably for the best as it’ll preserve the bat’s potency better.</p><p>I’m not sure Dom Keegan really belongs in this blog. He’s a good prospect who I have a fourth-round grade on but despite his senior status, I don’t think he’s going to come that cheap. Dominic Keegan is really young for a senior. He won’t even be 22 on draft day. He also has the 5th year of eligibility remaining thanks to the pandemic. There is also one more thing to consider- NILs. Dominic Keegan is probably the best hitter at one of the best college baseball programs in the entire country. He stands to quite possibly make more on a NIL deal in college next year than most of the players on this list would get as their signing bonus. Keegan will come at a slight discount but I would be surprised if he even takes 50% of the slot value.</p><h3>LF Angel Zarate, North Carolina</h3><p>Angel Zarate doesn’t play a premium position and doesn’t hit for much power. He’s only a 55 runner also. So what’s the appeal? Mostly the fact that he’s a 5th year senior who will be 23 on draft day and likely sign for very cheap. Also, the fact that he’s hit at least .324 each of the last three seasons with an OPS over .920 in all of them.</p><p>Angel Zarate stands out because of his plus contact skills. He whiffs just 11.1% of the time on pitches in the strike zone. That isn’t a new development this year so it’s hard to argue it’s a product of over-exposure to the same bad competition. The contact rates are strong against every type of pitch too and seemingly all speeds. He’s just a legitimately good contact hitter with a short and compact swing that doesn’t get crossed up or fooled.</p><p>The other appeal of Zarate is swing decisions. Zarate is an aggressive hitter swinging 47.5% of the time but he’s not chasing with him sitting at just 29%. The zone-swing rates are what drive his swing rates as those sit at 73.9%. He’s against not showing major chase issues with any one pitch type or even strengths against any type. Once again, these aren’t a product of overexposure because this has been the case for three years now- if anything the discipline backed up this year.</p><p>Angel Zarate also shows a solid feel for the barrel with a 38.5% Sweet-Spot% and great launch angle tightness with a 26.5° sdLA. He has just a 3.4% popup rate in games with trackman and a line-drive rate just a hair under 30%. He also avoids very weakly hit balls somewhat with just a 23% softly hit rate. That number has to be viewed relatively. The average college player has a 29% softly-hit rate so for Zarate to hit that few balls under 80 MPH when he has such poor power speaks volumes of the barrel accuracy and consistency of it.</p><p>The power isn’t quite at Nick Madrigal levels or anything either. A 105.6 MPH max exit velocity is terrible and a 98.3 MPH 90th percentile EV might be worse. The one saving grace is that he hits the ball surprisingly hard when he pulls it. On 68 pulled batted balls this year he is running an average EV of 90.8 MPH. That still isn’t great for pullside contact but if he can more consistently pull the ball maybe you can dream on like 40 game power or something and the bat might profile in the majors as a result. It’s a long shot but there’s some upside there.</p><p>Angel Zarate is not going to be a huge asset on defense. He plays right field right now but with below-average arm strength, it seems unlikely that he remains there in the long term. Some scouts want to see him in centerfield because of how good his movements are and because of some spectacular plays but I don’t think he has the foot speed to play there. He’s a left fielder in my books albeit a good one. He’s also taken some reps at second base and we know how teams love versatile players. He’s a day three guy talent wise who will probably go on two to save some cash while still adding a draftable talent to your organization.</p><h3>C Tatem Levins, Pittsburgh</h3><p>Tatem Levins is a fourth year junior who will be 23 on draft day. He hit at least .300 with a .900 OPS for all three years he spent at La Salle and then transferred to Pittsburgh in order to face better competition in the ACC. He responded in the form of a career year where he hit .321/.435/.613.</p><p>Tatem Levins’ skillset is an interesting one that looks good at first glance. The catcher is solid or better at all of making contact, making quality contact, hitting the ball hard, swing decisions, and good feel to elevate. At least he is against ACC competition. But is it sustainable?</p><p>The contact skills look impressive at a glance with Levins only whiffing 18.6% of the time. If you zoom in and look at just within the strike zone he arguably looks better with a 12.3% Z-Whiff%. His breakdown in pitch types causes some concern.</p><p>Most players you worry about the inability to hit a particular thing you think of struggle recognizing spin, or catching up to velocity. On some occasions, you’ll see that they’re fooled by the changeup. Levins doesn’t share those plebian concerns. He’s no worse against velocity than he is every other fastball. He whiffs just 18.9% of the time against non-fastballs which is exceptional given that most players in college run a 40% whiff rate against non-fastballs. Tatem Levins? He can’t hit the four-seam fastball at all.</p><p>This isn’t a velocity issue because Levins is running just a 1.5% Swinging-Strike rate against sinkers in the sample size. This isn’t a vertical movement issue because he’s actually better against fastballs with above-average carry than those with below. This isn’t an elevation issue, he isn’t any worse against four-seam fastballs in the top half than the bottom and he still crushes sinkers in the top half.</p><p>The issue is the most curious of things- a lack of horizontal movement- when pitches are too straight he loses. I don’t understand how it works but apparently, that is his fatal flaw. He also struggles against curveballs without that much sweep too, interestingly enough. Maybe his pitch recognition is dependent on seeing the ball move laterally through the zone?</p><p>The issues with the four-seam fastball are bad though. He whiffs upwards of 30% of the time in the zone and chases just over 36% of the time as well. He gets bullied by the four-seam fastball and that’s the most common pitch. Maybe it’s a fixable issue but I don’t know how to fix it if it is because it’s not an issue I think I’ve ever seen before. The rest of the contact profile is fantastic if you think you can teach him to hit the four-seam fastball though.</p><p>The swing decisions are good against other pitches. He’s chasing at a slightly above-average rate while remaining aggressive in the strike zone. He’s particularly aggressive against the slider which does lead to some chases but he’s still whiffing on just 16.7% of swings against sliders so the chase issues are more of an annoyance than a red flag.</p><p>Tatem Levins has average raw power that I could probably successfully argue belongs to be graded higher. The Max EV is just 107.2 MPH but he has a 90th percentile EV of 104.9 MPH and a 105.2 MPH top 8th which is in the 83rd percentile of all college hitters. He hits the ball hard 42.9% of the time and does it in the air 67.9% of the time so he has a 13.1% barrel rate which is in the 93rd percentile of college hitters. The game power is there.</p><p>Tatem Levins is an interesting fit behind the dish. He’s not a great athlete and his framing does not draw positive reviews even if most will agree it’s gotten better this year. I know some people think he will be a first baseman long-term. I would probably agree if I thought catchers would remain a premium position in the world after the Robots takeover.</p><p>The arm strength is legitimately above-average. Levins has a 90th percentile throw velocity of 80.8 MPH and an average throw velocity of 71 MPH. Those figures are both above the collegiate average. The problem is that his transitions and pop is not so smooth. He has the 5th lowest average poptime in the country and the 6th slowest 90th. The arm has potential in the form of both strength and accuracy but doesn’t play due to the slower actions.</p><p>Tatem Levins is an intriguing day two option mostly because of the money he saves but he still offers the chance to make an impact in your organization. There is absolutely risk in the profile but he’s hinted at the ability to both hit for contact and power while also maybe profiling behind the dish. The risk would make him a day three guy without question at slot value but he will almost certainly sign for a lot less so a team will likely jump at him at day two.</p><h3>2B/LF Hogan Windish, UNC Greensboro</h3><p>Hogan Windish is a fourth year junior at UNC Greensboro for all four years. He struggled his first two years, was good his third, and then after a strong summer stint in the Coastal Plains League carried that momentum into an elite 2022 campaign where he hit .370/.485/.681. I’m writing this in early June while he still only has 11 plate appearances in the Cape Cod league but he’s OPSing over 1.000 with just one strikeout. If he keeps up his strong cape cod performance then he might finally get the hype he deserves from other outlets because the dude rakes.</p><p>The contact skills are surprisingly robust. Hogan Windish only whiffed 20% of the time this year and only 12.3% of his swings in the zone saw him come up empty. Windish didn’t see enough quality stuff at UNC Greensboro to get a perfect gauge on his hit tool but he only whiffed once on 51 pitches he saw at 91+. He also only whiffed 28% of the time against breaking pitches. He made contact against better pitching in the Coastal Plains League and hasn’t been overmatched in the Cape this year. There is some hit risk but I’m a believer.</p><p>The real concern here is how often Windish whiffed before this year in his fourth go around at the Southern Conference as a 23 year old. As recently as last year his strikeout rate was just over 27%. His gains this year where also in large parts tied to improved swing decisions as his chase rate dropped below 20% while he still ran a 70% Zone-swing%. You can pretty easily handwave swing decisions off as being more advanced than the competition. The on base upside was there this year but it could be a mirage. Unless he runs a .500 OBP in the Cape Code this month, we probably won’t get to know if it is before the draft.</p><p>The power potential is easier to buy in on despite the lackluster opposition he regularly faced because batted ball data is objective. Hogan Windish has a Max EV of 111.9 MPH which indicates plus raw power. His Top 8th EV of 109.1 MPH is in the 98th percentile of all college hitters and would indicate even better than plus raw power.</p><p>Hogan Windish also is getting to the plus raw power in games despite a somewhat average feel to elevate because so many of his balls are hit at optimal flight patterns. His barrel rate of 14.8% is in the 96th percentile of college hitters. He’s got an extreme pull tendency that turns those barrels into home runs and a lot of extra base hits even if it also causes him to weakly ground out into the shift.</p><p>Hogan Windish is a second baseman right now but he’s not a fantastic athlete and doesn&#39;t have the arm strength to play the left half of the infield. Some scouts see him being pushed to left field or even first base. Windish is a tweener defensively who is only versatile because he doesn’t really fit anywhere. No one is drafting Windish to play defense but because he hits.</p><p>The problems with Windish’s offensive game essentially just boil down to risk. The performance is new and the competition is weak so it probably won’t last. The real question we should be asking is what if it does stick?</p><p>Windish is one of just three players in the draft with a Top 8th EV over 109 MPH and a contact rate of at least 80%. The other two are likely first round picks in Ivan Melendez and Gavin Cross. This bat has big-time upside and on day two for super cheap I will absolutely chase that early round upside. I’d take him on day two even at full price too but I suspect most risk-averse front offices would not.</p><h3>C Tyler McManus, LSU</h3><p>The lack of draft hype surrounding Tyler McManus is one of the world’s greatest mysteries. He put up a 129 wRC+ in the SEC while catching and has even better underlying metrics but he can’t even crack the top 500 on any publications draft list. He’s a 23 year old junior who should be relatively cheap, especially given the lack of buzz surrounding him.</p><p>Tyler McManus hits the ball stupid hard. Like really stupid hard. In fact, Tyler McManus has the second-highest hard-hit rate in the entire country behind only Dalton Rushing with McManus at 59.3% of his batted balls being hit hard. Granted, that isn’t really reflective of McManus’ raw power. The Max EV is only 108.9 MPH (55 grade) and his Top 8th EV is only in the 83rd percentile. It’s good power but not the elite level that the hard-hit rate might suggest.</p><p>The game power is equally as good as the raw juice, however. He has an above-average feel to elevate with just a 37.7% groundball rate and that combined with the frequent hard contact leads to a robust 13.6% Barrel rate. That figure ranks in the 94th percentile of all college hitters (Min 50 BBE with trackman). He is hitting the ball hard at optimal angles and good things should be happening as a result.</p><p>Based on how good the power metrics are, it’s easy to imagine that McManus is a big power guy with swing and miss concerns and that is why he has so little draft hype. Except that is completely untrue. Tyler McManus has above-average contact rates with him sitting at 80.8% this season. Again, this is against SEC competition, not just him bullying terrible low-level opponents.</p><p>There is very little sign this won’t translate. He’s whiffed 40% of the time against fastballs at 93+ but that is a 10 swing sample size and not really that indicative of his true talent. He does struggle some with fastballs relatively- they’re actually his worst pitch by whiff rates this year and that’s not because he can’t catch up to velocity- it’s just a struggle to make contact with vertically moving pitches. He whiffs almost as much at lower velocity fastballs as high-velocity ones.</p><p>Tyler McManus makes up for his deficiency against fastballs by being one of the best breaking ball hitters in the entire country. McManus is only running an 11.4% whiff rate against breaking pitches. That is in the 94th percentile of all college hitters. Unlike most players who hit the breaking ball with regularity, McManus also has a 96th percentile hard-hit rate against breaking balls. There is no player who has a higher hard-hit rate with an equal or better whiff rate.</p><p>Of course, the important caveat here is that McManus despite- (or maybe because of) elite results against the breaking ball, McManus really isn’t that aggressive at swinging at breaking stuff. He swings just 31.3% against sliders and curveballs. McManus isn’t just not chasing although a 22.7% chase% against the softer stuff is encouraging. He is also not swinging at strikes with only a 41.5% Z-Swing% against breaking balls. There is upside here but his hit tool is no guarantee even with the ability to seemingly bully spin.</p><p>The real concern here with McManus is the BABIP profile is pretty pitiful. Tyler McManus for all of his elevated contact has one of the worst sweet-spot rates in the entire country. McManus is at 18.6% of his batted balls hit between 8–32°. That is in the 3rd percentile of all college players this year. McManus also pulls close to 60% of his groundballs and hits popups at an average rate. The BABIPs aren’t going to be there so despite liking the contact skills, I don’t really think he’ll hit for much average.</p><p>Tyler McManus can catch, I’m not sure exactly how good he is back there but he can at least crouch back there every game and hit while doing so. That should be enough with electronic strike zones. There is risk in the bat because he struggles against fastballs and has zero barrel accuracy but there is also a lot of upside here. As a day two target who will likely be significantly underslot I’m all in on Tyler McManus.</p><h3>RP/SP Kristófer Bow, College of Southern Nevada (JUCO)</h3><p>Kristófer Bow is a 22 year old currently enrolled in Junior College without a commitment to a bigger program. Given his age and schooling to date, I think it is pretty likely that Bow signs for somewhere in the range of 100K on day two. Maybe that isn’t the biggest discount on this list but it is still a discount and I want to talk about Bow.</p><p>Kristófer Bow throws pretty hard. He sits at 93 MPH and can reach back for as high as 97 MPH. It’s a plus feel for spinning it as well as he sits at about 2300 RPMs on average. The fastball has two variants he throws an almost perfectly equal amount.</p><p>The two-seam fastball with 10.8 IVB and 14.6 HB is a source of groundballs and called strikes at the bottom of the zone. It’s an average pitch optimistically, and only that because of his velocity though. There are very few situations where it is more effective than the four-seam fastball. The arm slot consistently undermines him and makes it unlikely for the sinker located to his arm side to have any effectiveness at the next level.</p><p>The four-seam fastball on the other hand grades out as a plus pitch in my looks. The pitch doesn’t have all that great of vertical movement but 16 IVB is still close to league average and it has solid tailing action still with 10.1 HB. More importantly, the four-seam fastball comes from a 5.6 ft release height and as such has a flatter VAA up in the zone.</p><p>Kristófer Bow has some struggles with elevating the aforementioned four-seam fastball but when he even locates it in the top half- even the bottom part of that top half, it has a 33.3% Swinging Strike rate in games with Trackman (33 fastballs in the top half). He gets a lot of in-zone whiffs with the heater and finds the zone semi-regularly with it. This pitch projects to miss bats at the game’s highest level as long as the command is respectable enough.</p><p>The sweeper is a second plus pitch in Bow’s repertoire. The slider doesn’t have crazy velocity sitting at just 81.7 MPH but that’s the only downside to the pitch specs. He has great spin averaging 2736 RPMs and even better movement. The slider has -2.2 IVB and 14.5 inches of sweep on average.</p><p>Here is a complete list of MLB sliders that average as much movement as Kristófer Bow on both planes: Aaron Bummer, Matt Brash, Glenn Otto, Sonny Gray, Drew VerHagen, Brad Hand, Justin Grimm, Mike Clevinger, John King, Justin Briuhl, and Yu Darvish.</p><p>That was a lot more than I thought there would be wow. They’re all good pitches but that is a tad bit overwhelming. Let’s filter that to only players who throw as hard of a slider as Bow does now for more accurate and elite-looking results. Here is every player in the MLB: Aaron Bummer, Matt Brash, and Yu Darvish. (Also José Berríos if you include curveballs). That’s much better. It’s a special slider movement profile.</p><p>The slider is made even better by the arm slot. Kristófer Bow throws from a very low arm slot that gives him an average release side of 2.98 feet. This further enhances the already great HAA’s created by the sweeping slider and makes his slider virtually unhittable.</p><p>In a small sample with Trackman this year (45 pitches), the slider results were video game-esque with a 28.9% Swinging-Strike rate, a 57.8% CSW%, a 50% in-zone whiff rate, and a 40.6% chase rate. There is some semblance of feel for locating the slider and the movement profile will absolutely play. This is an easy plus pitch to pair with the plus fastball.</p><p>The changeup is also somewhat interesting. Kris Bow does a decent job killing velocity and spin sitting at 86 MPH and 1939 RPMs. I actually like the movement profile a lot too. 4.6 IVB and 15.7 HB is above-average movement on both planes and would normally miss bats to the arm side. The problem is the arm slot. That same arm slot that makes the slider so elite leads to the arm side changeup getting zero chases.</p><p>If you look at pitchers from comparable release side (or the left handed version), the list of good changeups is far and few between. You have Max Scherzer, Zac Gallen, and Sean Manaea. Those pitches are only really good because of command and even how good they are is debatable as all three are below-average by CSW% this year. There is a road to success with a changeup from this slot but it’s a narrow one and I won’t assume Bow can walk it until he does it.</p><p>Kristófer Bow has control problems. He ran a 7.56 BB+HBP/9 innings at his JUCO this year. He struggles to find the zone and frequently misses spots. The batted ball is likely only average, especially if he follows my advice and ditches the sinker. I’ll give Bow a chance to start with his 2.5 pitch repertoire but I think he likely winds up in relief. The FB/SL combo should dominate in that role though and I have him ticketed for a high leverage gig in the not so distant future. I’ll gladly give him ~100K on day two in the 4th-6th round range and use the savings to splurge early in the draft.</p><p>I’m not scrapping this blurb because I still think it came out pretty well but since writing it, Kristófer Bow has committed to Arizona for the 2023 season so he might command more money now.</p><h3>SP Jared Poland, Louisville</h3><p>What do you think is the easiest mechanical tweak to make? I don’t know exactly what it is but I’d imagine that lengthening your stride length so it’s more than a singular inch is near the top of the list.</p><p>Jared Poland is a senior who has just 4.68 feet of extension on average and it costs him 3.1 MPH in effective velocity on his four-seam fastball and all of his other pitches as well. As a result, Poland is just not that good. Aside from the putrid extension, the stuff is quite good and I think the extension is very fixable so I still want him in the round 5–7 range.</p><p>Jared Poland sits at 92 MPH with plus vertical movement at 19.6 IVB on average and solid horizontal action as well at 12.2 HB. The release is very generic at a 5.91&quot; release height and 2.01 release side but if he lengthened his stride even a little, the release height would almost certainly drop a bit as well and he would have elite VAA’s up in the zone as a result. He needs to improve his dip mobility but if he does the fastball could take off. There is also an occasional sinker with 15.8 IVB and 16.5 HB but I wouldn’t advocate for using it at all regularly.</p><p>The slider is another pitch that is severely hampered by Poland’s lackluster extension. He sits at 80.1 MPH with a spin rate of 2536 RPMs. He has -1.3 IVB on the slider and 13.3 inches of sweep on it as well. The velocity is a bit on the low end but it&#39;s a good shape and that is enough for the pitch to still be at least above-average.</p><p>The problem is, of course, the extension. There is a huge difference between an 80.1 MPH slider and a 76.9 MPH slider. One will play and the other absolutely will not at all. The results have sucked and I’m not at all surprised by that. The thing is, Jared Poland actually has good slider command and can regularly throw it for strikes. He is missing far too few bats because he has no effective velocity but he still has a 34.9% CSW% this year because he can locate. If he were to get to average extension, this could be argued as a plus pitch given the strong specs and advanced slider command.</p><p>The changeup rounds out his repertoire and is the lone pitch that presently has an above-average swinging-strike rate. It has a lot more than that though as his swinging-strike rate on 181 pitches sits at 23.8%. This makes sense, as the changeup should be the lone pitch mostly unaffected by extension. It’s the one that relies on separation from the fastball rather than pure velocity so losing the appearance of velocity does not matter much.</p><p>The changeup is good as is too. Jared Poland throws his cambio 7.1 MPH slower than the fastball and sits at a fairly low 1696 RPMs on average. The pitch has a solid albeit unspectacular movement profile with 8.5 IVB and 15.1 inches of armside run on average. The real appeal of the changeup though is the command at the bottom of the zone. Poland racks up both chases (37.9%) and in-zone whiffs (39%). The pitch dominates and should be at least above-average.</p><p>Jared Poland with one small tweak could have three above-average pitches and I think there is at least average command here as well. There is even a chance at a plus for all of them if adding to his stride length helps him engage the glutes and comes with a velocity jump. Right now, I would only put the changeup as average but I also think it’s really easy to see all of them as being above. I don’t really know how to value this profile. I like Poland in the round 6–8 range discounting his status as a senior citizen. A very intriguing target for a team confident in their pitching development department.</p><h3>RP Brandon Johnson, Ole Miss</h3><p>Brandon Johnson is a 23 year old reliever for the World Series Champion Rebels. This isn’t a conversion arm or a Ben Joyce with stupid stuff. This is, in fact, perhaps the only player in this blog who is not an upside play of some kind which is absolutely what I prefer in this part of the draft.</p><p>The fastball has two standout attributes. The fastball has a lot of vertical movement. Brandon Johnson averaged 21.5 IVB this year out of the bullpen. That is obviously an exceptional movement profile. He also throws his fastball harder than any other pitcher with as much vertical movement in road games (21.3 IVB) at 94.2 MPH on average. He has hit as high as 97.8 MPH this year. This combination of velocity and vertical movement on the fastball is only really matched by Zach Maxwell in this year’s draft. The former gets top three round buzz.</p><p>The fastball has 70 grade upside but make no mistake, it is not a plug and play arm by any means. Brandon Johnson has just 5.29 ft of extension on average. This means that his fastball plays down to just 92.3 MPH in effective velocity. If you scroll up an inch you can see that I think that is teachable. There is also the arm angle to consider. Johnson has fairly generic and probably subpar release traits. He throws from a 6.11 ft release height and a 1.48 ft release side. That hurts his VAA’s ever so slightly and doesn’t let the HAA’s standout either.</p><p>There is also the part where Brandon Johnson like most Ole Miss arms chooses not to elevate his fastball but instead is aggressive with pitching down and focusing on called strikes. This nullifies some of the effects of his fastball movement and even if his too frequent misses would hurt more as a result of elevating, the extra whiffs and weak aerial contact would likely make it a worthwhile exchange for Johnson.</p><p>The secondaries are not quite up to speed for Brandon Johnson. The breaking ball is his best weapon and it sits at just 79.4 MPH with -4.9 IVB and 7.9 inches of sweep. The HAA is generic from his slot and he lacks the power (Especially based on effective velocity) to actually miss bats. Below-average pitch.</p><p>The changeup is also very fringy. He sits at 85.2 MPH without killing more than 100 RPMs off of the fastball. The pitch has very little vertical depth with him averaging 15.3 IVB on the changeup, a number that is higher than some players four-seamers. The real appeal here is that he gets 17 inches of armside fade and has 9 MPH of velocity separation. The feel is completely lacking but there is some upside here probably.</p><p>Brandon Johnson throws strikes at a below-average rate. He only really has one quality pitch. This is a relief only look and probably not a high leverage on unless he develops a plus secondary. The appeal here is strictly an outlier elite fastball that makes him almost a lock to contribute in a big league bullpen someday. Johnson is more of a target because of the floor of the stuff with such a spammable fastball. He’s a senior who will be 23 and is relief only so he’ll likely demand no more than 20K too. That is a huge savings pick at the backend of day two of the draft.</p><h3>LF Carlos Contreras, Sam Houston State</h3><p>Colton Cowser went at #5 overall last year and it was Carlos Contreras, a transfer from Cisco Community College who was asked to fill his shoes in the outfield. Contreras did a lot more than that as he hit .400/.468/.713 in his only year with Sam Houston State which was a high Batting Average, Slugging Percentage, and OPS than Cowser ever put up in his three years with Sam Houston State. Contreras isn’t as good projection wise as Cowser obviously but he really can hit at the very least.</p><p>Carlos Contreras isn’t a data darling like most of the players in this blog. In fact, in the 110 pitch sample of Trackman data we have for Contreras, he looks completely underwhelming at first glance. His contact rates are below-average, he chases 36.2% of the time, and he maxes out at just 104.9 MPH. I disagree with the small sample data here and am instead choosing to primarily trust my eyes and the overall production that suggests Contreras is a stud.</p><p>Carlos Contreras does not have the best contact rates in the world because of how frequently he expands the zone in pursuit of breaking balls. In spite of that flaw, Contreras almost never strikes out with only 10.6% strikeout rate this year and he was even lower with Cisco CC last year. I don’t even think The 78.3% contact rate is that misleading, I think it just speaks volumes of how Contreras adjusts.</p><p>Carlos Contreras is tenacious at the plate. He’ll miss on the breaking ball down and then watch the second one in the same spot. If you are foolish enough to give him a third- even if it’s a great one, Contreras will punish you by collapsing his swing and selling out on the low pitch with a steep VBA and explosive power that will lead to an extra-base hit. If he misses on the fastball above the zone once, the next time he expands he’ll be ready and make contact. He is constantly adjusting and is too good of a hitter to be beaten twice by the same pitch. You have to get creative to strike Carlos out.</p><p>Carlos Contreras is a flush contact savant. He has a very flat VBA on pitches up in the zone and steepens out on pitches down when he is expecting them. He does swing through stuff when he guesses wrong- especially early in counts but he’s constantly optimizing his swing shape based on what he is seeing the pitcher throw.</p><p>The spin characteristics in a small sample are exceptional as a result. Carlos Contreras is hitting 67% of his batted balls with backspin in the small sample and he has an absolutely ridiculous average batted ball spin rate of 3500 RPMs. That doesn’t qualify for the 50 BBE leaderboard as he’s only at 21 BBE but if it did, he would be second in batted ball spin rate and third in backspin%.</p><p>The BABIP monstrosity skills go deeper than just producing a lot of flush contact. Contreras hits the ball at optimal angles with regularity and shows impressive barrel accuracy in all of my looks. He avoids a lot of mishits for the most part too even if there are some popups. Contreras hits the ball to all fields and shows power while doing so. There is major hit tool risk due to the subpar approach and breaking ball problems but there are also a lot of promising signs here so I still have a 55 grade on his hit tool.</p><p>Carlos Contreras packs a serious punch in his 5&#39;10&quot; frame with explosive bat speed and a strong lower half. At first glance, the Trackman data will make you doubt it with a 104.9 MPH Max EV and it came on a pulled flyball. His Top 8th EV is below average at 101.9 MPH. Sure it’s a small sample but that isn’t good in the slightest.</p><p>Except, Carlos Contreras also has one game in Globe Life Field with Hawkeye tracking his batted ball data. That one game he hit a ball at 105.7 MPH and that game is also enough to raise his Top 8th EV to the 66th percentile at 103.4 MPH. Okay, so it’s average power right? So what? That’s not exactly an impact bat.</p><p>Except there is one thing I neglected to mention before. Contreras posted that 105.7 MPH EV on an opposite field hit. The average max exit velocity to the opposite field has an EV roughly 5% lower than the same player’s max to their pullside. That would mean that Contreras theoretically has a 111 MPH EV which would above-average plus raw power.</p><p>This is very much believable to me given how the bat speed looks on film, and how strong he generally is. The production lines up with him having plus raw power as well. The feel to elevate isn’t quite there yet and sometimes he loses something when he collapses for the pitch down in the zone but I do think there is probably 55 game power in the bat of Carlos Contreras.</p><p>So what is the catch? Why does Carlos Contreras get so little draft hype despite both loud results and a potent hit/power combo? Carlos Contreras is probably the single worst breaking ball hitter in the entire draft. In games with trackman he had a 32% Swinging-Strike rate against the breaking ball and chased them 68.8% of the time. That is a small sample but it’s an ugly one to say the least.</p><p>On film, this tracks for the most part. Carlos Contreras is very aggressive at pursuing breaking balls early in the count and usually whiffs in the attempt. He puts himself in a hole early on as a result of his aggressiveness against the breaking ball. But as I said earlier, it hasn’t led to strikeouts because Contreras can adjust and if you throw him too many breaking balls he’ll punish you for it. Will that last at the next level against better breaking balls and smarter pitchers? That is very much up in the air.</p><p>Carlos Contreras is likely going to be limited to a platoon role as putting him in that place allows him to completely cut same-handed breaking balls out of his diet. Contreras pulverizes the fastball- even when it is thrown hard and he has little trouble with offspeed stuff. I think Contreras could be very good in a platoon role but as a left fielder, the value is pretty limited if he winds up in a platoon. Maybe he figures out how to hit breaking stuff and this becomes a moot point but for now, it’s a pretty big question mark.</p><p>I like platoons and as such, I like Carlos Contreras more than most people. He’s a senior who turns 23 this September so he’ll sign cheap. I think he’s likely to be a day two selection for way under the slot value but I would still take him in the back half of day two even if he didn’t save me any money. The bat is legit and he’s a very useful role player in all likelihood.</p><h3>CF Chris Rotondo, Villanova</h3><p>Chris Rotondo is a 23 year old fifth year senior at a not very good Villanova program. He’s been the best player on the team since 2019 but this year he really stepped up and was second in the Big East in both wRC+ and WAR.</p><p>The contact skills are quite strong. Rotondo made contact 85.3% of the time he swung the bat this year. That is in the 86th percentile of all college bats. His contact skills are partially because of advanced swing decisions with just a 9.4% Z-Whiff% but also that is still really freaking good.</p><p>He made contact against everything this year but in prior years he’s been exposed by breaking balls. He stopped chasing them this year with just a 20.8% chase rate but given the lack of exposure to actually good breaking stuff, I think it’s plausible the whiffs come back when he enters pro ball. He has no issues with murdering fastballs though and is one of the best offspeed hitters in the draft statistically.</p><p>The plate discipline is advanced but I think there is a distinct possibility he collapses against higher quality stuff. The 64% Zone-Swing and 22.1% chase rate are both above-average but it feels flimsy. The breaking balls are a real problem. I already mentioned the chase risk but even with his current lack of chases, they are his worst pitch by CSW by a fairly wide margin because he only swings at 45.8% of the ones in the strike zone. His strategy against breaking balls is to never swing and that will work less and less as command improves at the higher levels.</p><p>The power is at least above-average and probably a plus in actuality. Rotondo has a Max EV of 111.5 MPH and a Top 8th EV of 107 MPH. The Hard-Hit rates are good as well at 44.1%. He is making most of that hard contact in the air with a 96.1 MPH average air EV and puts the ball in the air at a league average rate. The result is a 12.2% Barrel rate that ranks in the 92nd percentile of all college hitters. Quality of competition is inflating the game power, but it’s plus raw and 55 game still.</p><p>The BABIPs have been high since his sophomore season so it’s not hard to believe in the skill being real and note a mirage of his age. The launch angle tightness from Rotondo is incredible as he ranks in the 92nd percentile at 23.3° on average.</p><p>Despite that, I have concerns. Rotondo has poor spin characteristics on his batted balls in the college crop. His average spin rate of 2642 RPMs ranks in the 16th percentile. His backspin% of 40.7% is in the 24th percentile. This reduces carry, kills BABIPs, and hurts the game power.</p><p>Rotondo might be an adept hand at avoiding popups and mishits with terrible launch angles but the same isn’t true for his EVs. Rotondo hits 28.8% of his batted balls with an exit velocity below 80 MPH. Those poorly hit balls are easy outs against good defenses, even when the launch angles are solid and tightly compressed. Rotondo also struggles greatly with hitting the ball to the opposite field and I worry that he’ll be eaten up by more flexible defenses. I only have the BABIP ability as average despite elite launch angle tightness and great power.</p><p>The good news is Chris Rotondo should provide some defensive value. He’s probably not going to stick in centerfield as only a 55 runner but I think he’ll be quite good in right field. He’s got a quick get-off and covers a surprising amount of ground out there. Rotondo also has above-average arm strength even if there are some accuracy questions. He’s not a defensive stalwart but he certainly will play the field every day and not hurt you in any way.</p><p>Chris Rotondo is one of just three players in the college crop this year who have a contact rate over 84% and a top 8th EV of at least 107 MPH. The other two are top 25 players in Ivan Melendez and Eric Brown. Rotondo did it against a lot worse competition and is older with less of a track record but he still did what so few players could do. He’s got some risk but I like him as a day three option or a significant underslot on day two. Contact and power is hard to find in the same player but Rotondo offers just that.</p><h3>RP Gordon Ingebritson, UC Irvine</h3><p>This is my super money saver pick ala Riley Martin who signed for just $1,000 out of the draft last year with the Cubs in the sixth round. Ingebritson comes from a smaller program and will turn 24 in August. He’s also exclusively a reliever and one without fantastic stuff so he’ll be very very cheap. He’s not good but he has a relatively high chance of making the majors one day where he could provide some value as a low leverage relief option.</p><p>Ingebritson sits at just 82.6 MPH with his fastball and tops out at 84.7 MPH. He has poor extension at 5.6 ft on average so it actually plays down even further to just 81.3 MPH. There is pretty much no velocity projection in his frame. The calling card here is the arm angle obviously.</p><p>The fastball comes from a 3.03 ft release height. That is a lower release height than any MLB pitcher not named Tyler Rogers or Adam Cimber. That borderline submarine-style delivery and release make him very hard to square up and hit hard even without velocity.</p><p>The sinker also has a very unique movement profile. The pitch is thrown with -6.4 IVB on average. Only four fastballs (Sinker or four-seam) have as little IVB as Ingebritson. He also averages 19.2 inches of horizontal movement which would be the second most horizontal movement on a sinker in the majors this year behind only Phillips Valdez. The combination of drop and tail has never been matched by an MLB arm and probably never will be- even by Ingebritson himself because Gordon is unlikely to reach the majors.</p><p>The curveball is just as interesting. It’s listed as a curveball but more accurately it’s a slider in all honesty. The pitch has less IVB than any curveball in the majors and the fourth most sweep of any curve so it really feels miscast as one since the only label that really fits here is velocity.</p><p>The slider sits at just 71.7 MPH but it should still be an above-average pitch. He has 97th percentile sweeping action on it at 17.8 inches of sweep on average. From a 2.61 RelSide, you can bet the HAA is even more impressive too. The more impressive part of the slider for me, however, might be the vertical action on the slider though as he gets just 5.8 IVB. The slider hangs up in the zone for a long time and even has the illusion of rise.</p><p>Why does this matter so much? To better express the value of this vertical movement profile on the slider we need to convert our movement numbers to consider gravity in the calculation. The slider drops 51 inches on average. The sinker on the other hand drops 47.9 inches on average.</p><p>That is the beauty of Gordon Ingebritson, the pitch tunneling potential. Ingebritson has two pitches with basically the same drop that are separated by 10.9 MPH and move in the complete opposite directions. The slider moves 17.8 inches to the glove side and the sinker 19.2 inches to the armside. That is 37 inches of horizontal movement separating them with almost no difference in the vertical element. Good luck, hitting that. You are going to need it. Ingebritson had a chase rate over 40% against both pitches this year and that tunneling ability is why.</p><p>Gordon Ingebritson also can throw both pitches for a strike with regularity. His walk rates have consistently been among the lowest in the league during his college tenure and it’s hard to see that changing. The batted ball profile should be rife with groundballs and he’ll allow very few barrels I would imagine.</p><p>The profile is a very high risk given the velocity and that neither of the pitches is all that on their own. There is also the fact that the batted ball profile was more above-average than plus in 2021. He’s already 24 and isn’t exactly a plug and play guy. There is upside here for Ingebritson but he&#39;s a 30 FV for a reason. The only reason to draft him on day two is as a super money-saving option- teams go that route every year and Ingebritson is my preferred target if I need to save that much cash.</p><h3>3B/2B Matt Frey, Michigan</h3><p>Matt Frey might be signable for the minimum 1K offer. Actually, there is no might there. Matt Frey is a 5th year senior who turns 26 this November and only had a .986 OPS in the Big Ten. The age is a huge factor but if we pretend Frey is 21, I probably have a third round grade on him. Can the age really mean that much? The answer is almost certainly yes.</p><p>Matt Frey plays 2B/3B and looks to be average at both of them. He’s an average athlete with an average arm. I like him best at third base but second base might be easier due to some arm accuracy questions. He has solid hands and covers ground though so I still like his chances.</p><p>The contact rates are strong with Frey sitting at 83.3% this year and just 8.8% whiffs in the strike zone. There is just a 10% whiff rate on fastballs at 93+. Frey is nearly as good against breaking pitches as well with just a 17.9% whiff rate against them. His worst whiff pitch is actually the four-seam fastball- particularly up in the zone which he also chases too frequently.</p><p>Most players with an issue against the high fastball are steep VBA hitters who can’t actually get the barrel up in the zone. That is not Matt Frey. Frey has a very flat swing, his struggles up in the zone appear to be a vision issue. He just doesn’t see the high fastball well and struggles with actually recognizing it when the pitch is rising above his bat. He also struggles to see arm side movement- particularly when it moves away from him. When the fastball is in the zone he pulverizes it but he doesn’t recognize the late movement and that’s his kryptonite.</p><p>The approach is a tad bit aggressive but overall average and arguably even above. Frey swings at just 27.5% of out-of-zone pitches while swinging at 70.5% of the ones in the strike zone. His Z-Swing% is no lower than 60% against any pitch type (Curveballs) and his chase rate is no higher than 30.8% against any pitch (Sinkers). He’s remarkably consistent against everything and there is some value in that.</p><p>The power is the real calling card here. Matt Frey maxes out at 110.6 MPH on aerial contact. The top 8th EV is 108.2 MPH which is in the 96th percentile of all college hitters. His 49.5% Hard-Hit rate is in the 87th percentile. His average EV of 91.4 MPH is in the 95th percentile. Frey has plus raw juice to say the least.</p><p>Even if we compare him to players his age- aka major leaguers, his Max EV is in the 72nd percentile and his top 8th EV is well above the MLB average 105.7 MPH Top 8th EV. Frey’s top-end EVs should be largely unaffected by his competition so it’s not hard to believe this element of his game is for real at the very least.</p><p><em>That was 92nd EV, not Top 8th but his Top 8th EV of 107.6 MPH still clears the MLB average and is in the 98th percentile of college players.</em></p><p>The game power lags a tad bit behind the raw power even if I’m not entirely sure why that is. Matt Frey hit just 34.6% of batted balls on the ground this year and is in the 82nd percentile in OFFB%. There isn&#39;t a problem with too much elevation here either as Frey hit just one popup in a game with trackman this year. The average spin rate and backspin% are both above league-average. The lack of game power comes down to just one thing. Frey only pulls 7.3% of outfield flyballs. 73.2% of his outfield flyballs are hit out to centerfield.</p><p>The BABIP skills are interesting. Frey is a lefty who pulls 70.3% of groundballs which leads to him getting eaten up by the shift. He also has a below-average sweet-spot rate. Frey avoids mishits at an elite level but he doesn’t have that many well-struck balls independent of their EVs. Given his age, this is especially concerning as barrel accuracy is often inflated by how advanced the player is relative to their competition.</p><p>Matt Frey has a lot of risk. He’s old as dirt and isn’t exactly a premium athlete. The draw here is power and contact though. There were only four players in college baseball this year with a contact% of at least 82% and a top 8th EV of at least 108. Those four were Ivan Melendez, Tyler Locklear, Daniel Susac and Matt Frey. Three of those names are getting some first round buzz. The fourth one might sign for 0.01% of what the cheapest of the other three get. Yes, he is old and hasn’t really produced but the hard baseball skills are strong and there is promise here. He scraps a late day three grade from me, but I’d be tempted on day two in order to save money.</p><h3>Big Names Who Could Go Underslot</h3><p>This section is solely speculation based on what leverage the player has and will absolutely be controversial. I am only writing one paragraph on why they might be cheap and nothing more on these players.</p><h4>SP Kumar Rocker, Vanderbilt</h4><p>Kumar Rocker failed to sign out of the draft last year after the Mets took him at #10 overall due to some medical issues/character concerns that arose in the process. Rocker opted to go to Indy Ball this year instead of returning to Vanderbilt. Rocker has no leverage in signing bonus negotiations whatsoever this go around.</p><p>He doesn’t have a plan B if he doesn’t sign. Going back to Tri-City for a second year won’t boost his stock anymore. He can’t refuse to sign again in hopes of making more money next year. He has to take it or leave whatever is on the table. The one leverage he has is to threaten to follow in the footsteps of fellow Boras client, Carter Stewart and go to the NPB instead before coming over as a real free agent once he turns 25.</p><h4>RP Ben Joyce, Tennessee</h4><p>Ben Joyce has record-breaking velocity but coming off a Tommy John surgery and with no track record of health, him not signing would be the pinnacle of foolishness. Joyce throws too hard for there not to be health concerns and it seems impossible for another year to make his stuff look better. The risk is very high for little to no payoff so he’ll almost certainly take whatever is offered. even if it’s a lot less than he deserves.</p><h4>1B Ivan Melendez, Texas</h4><p>Ivan Melendez is a redshirt Junior who will be 23 next year and it seems impossible for his stock to be higher as he won a Golden Spikes award and is literally the best hitter in the entire draft. He won’t be dirt cheap but I don’t think him only getting ~75% of the slot value is at all unreasonable. Of course, you could easily argue against him being as cheap as some people claim because he just won the Golden Spikes award and if he returned to college would likely make a sizeable heap of cash in NILs.</p><p><em>Thanks for reading! Tomorrow is the big one! My entire MLB Draft Top 500 and over 200,000 words of draft content in one day! If you can’t wait that long to read more, I encourage you to check out my blog on the </em><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/my-draft-philosophy-608626368d0f"><em>ideal Draft Philosophy</em></a><em> or my</em><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/the-numbers-suck-but-19f4ac20a72a"><em> piece on players who haven’t performed but are still future stars</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a35c5489a7b2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My Draft Philosophy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/my-draft-philosophy-608626368d0f?source=rss-f20e8b3389a4------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/608626368d0f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mlb-draft]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[methodology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[how-to]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Tieran Alexander]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Jul 2022 17:50:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-13T17:50:20.736Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Why Drafting the Best Player Available is Stupid</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Uc1S4SiAk0Pl_lnygIei9A.png" /></figure><p><em>This blog will be broken into three segments. The first segment is the actual title, how I think teams should draft and how I judge if a pick is good or bad. The second part is a guide to some of what I look for in a prospect, and why I value things the way I do. The third section is a general overview of a lot of the stats you’ll see in the blogs I publish this week and after the draft as well.</em></p><p>The MLB Draft is the best opportunity teams have to add cheap impact players and every year, every last one of them squanders it. There are certainly teams better at drafting than others but every last one of them is not getting the most they can from the draft.</p><p>Drafting the best player available is a stupid strategy. Assuming you know who is the best player on the board better than anyone else is extremely arrogant and overstates the difference in talent between the #10 and #20 player in the draft (Or whatever, you get the gist) when the difference is usually very negligible.</p><p>Drafting to save money for later and take lesser talents now is a better strategy but still generally, not the best one. You should never want to leave potential stars on the table by taking a lesser talent. The goal should always be to maximize the number of future stars you are adding to the organization.</p><p>So if maximizing the chance of getting one star isn’t the right philosophy, and spreading the wealth to get multiple lower impact players isn’t the perfect strategy then what is? Maximizing your chances to get multiple high probably regulars and star level talents.</p><p>You’re focusing on the wrong things right now. I don’t think the money associated with the pick is the most important thing. You have to make the finances work but you could have an excellent draft by breaking the bank on Jackson Holliday in round one or cutting a deal with Cooper Hjerpe instead. The money isn’t what defines how good a draft is. What defines a good draft is the process behind the draft picks.</p><p>When we are evaluating an organization&#39;s competency we often look at scouting and player development as one unit. A team is good at scouting and player development or they are good at neither. The two have intermarried in the public eye and we have a hard time discerning which is which because they go hand in hand.</p><p>The two are meant to go hand in hand, and I think front offices trying to separate the two is one of their most detrimental mistakes. I have interviewed for multiple scouting jobs in the past and they all ask you to evaluate what a player projects to be, where their skills are now, what the tools are like, how they look, etc. None of them ask the most pivotal question of how can they become better?</p><p>The draft shouldn’t be about scouts finding underappreciated talents. That has a role to play obviously and is a pivotal step in the process but it is just that. A step. Not the conclusion. Player Development is the key to finding success in the draft.</p><p>Most people understand that a team won’t be successful without good player development. Player development is what creates value in the draft, you can find gems late, but the teams who consistently get the most production from their draft picks. The Astros, Dodgers, Rays, and Guardians namely are not the ones with the best initial draft grades. They are the ones who develop a good chunk of the players they draft into quality major leaguers, even if they maybe were not the best player in the draft.</p><p>Except, not every player can be developed just because you have good player development. There are loads of talented players on the Dodgers and Rays who don’t wind up turning into productive MLB players. That might be because those players don’t buy into what they preach but it also might be because they don’t have a good plan for the player.</p><p>Nathan Eovaldi is the best example that sometimes the player buys in but their plan just doesn’t work despite generally great player development. With the Dodgers, Eovaldi was FB/SL/SI 90% of the time with 45% fastballs. He was traded to Miami and brought his FB usage up to close to 70%. With the Yankees, he was back down to 45% fastballs and started to feature a splitter fairly regularly. The Rays further decreased the fastball usage and threw a lot more cutters. He finally went to Boston and swapped the slider for more curves while adding a half foot of extension that he finally became a front of the rotation starter. There were growing pains but they stuck with him and were rewarded.</p><p>Eovaldi ran the gauntlet of elite pitching development teams and while he was with probably the worst team at pitching development that he played for, he finally emerged as the Ace he is today. Sometimes it just doesn&#39;t work out, the player is willing to adjust but your plan is bad. When that is the case, even with your awesome player development, you get nothing out of them. There are countless other examples but Eovaldi is the easiest to illustrate that it wasn’t on the player for being rigid or stubborn.</p><p>In the draft, teams often draft the “best player available” without a plan in place for how they will develop them beforehand. The plan is typically- especially with early round picks to throw them in the minors and make adjustments once they become necessary. Sometimes, you’ll do something small beforehand, but you don’t see early round picks immediately rework their bat path the day they are drafted or ditch their fastball for a sinker on day one. I think this mistake is costing each team dozens of WAR every year and is perhaps the biggest market inefficiency in baseball.</p><p>Teams should only draft players that their player development people have identified a plan to develop before they even join the organization. This is how smart teams operate in free agency and in the trade market. Why should the draft be any different?</p><p>The Yankees didn’t trade for Clay Holmes because his SIERA indicated he was underperforming, they traded for him because they knew exactly how they could make him better. We know this because Holmes made those adjustments the day he joined the Yankees. The Dodgers didn’t sign Andrew Heaney because they thought he had some vague mysterious potential. They signed him because they recognized that if he switched to a slider than from his arm slot, he would become a whole lot better.</p><p>So why do teams not practice the same in the draft? Why do they draft players without a plan on how to let them reach their 90th percentile outcome? Praying is not a viable plan in this case but that seems to be the plan for most draft picks. There are some teams who take players with desirable traits they can develop but very rarely do they have a specific plan for how they will do it.</p><p>Very rarely, do you see pitch mix changes or location changes pre-planned. Almost never, do you see a pre-planned course for how the shape of the slider needs to be altered to play at the next level. The plan is often to wait until it doesn’t work and then you’re years behind when you do finally make the change that was obviously needed from the beginning. Why not? Why do we insist on waiting to make changes?</p><p>I am proposing that teams involve their player development team directly in the draft process. The scout&#39;s job is to identify the players who are good enough to draft in whatever round but rather than put them in a specific order, you leave that to the player development guys. Have your coaches and PD department look over the data, and video, and try to see exactly how they could make those players better than they are.</p><p>Order the draft board within each tier set by the scouts based on your confidence that you can develop them to reach the potential the scouts foresaw. Any player you don’t have a plan in place for should be put on a do not draft list, (In that round/range; obviously, you still take a round one talent in round five even without a plan.) no matter how much the scouts love them. It’s not good for the player or team to let them flounder without a charted course.</p><p>You can also send out the scouts to talk to the players and get to know them. Be upfront with the players that you plan to tweak unspecified things in their mechanics or arsenal and ask if they will be willing to trust the coaching staff to know what they are doing even if it doesn’t immediately bring results. With the draft, you have the opportunity to find out who will buy in on the development plan you have for them, and adjust your rankings accordingly.</p><p>The goal of the draft should never be to take the best players right now or even the best prospects right now. The goal is not to win the draft every year in initial draft grades or have the most top 100 prospects. The goal should always be to get the most long-term productive major leaguers. The ones you have a coherent plan to develop will always be the safer bets to do so than the higher upside player you plan on just hoping will somehow make it one day.</p><p>I have Noah Schultz, Brock Porter, and Owen Murphy ranked higher than Brandon Barriera on my draft board by a pretty decent margin. However, if I am running an organization I’m taking Barriera over all of those three. I think they are the better prospects but I have an idea on how to turn Barriera into a productive major league arm. Give Barriera cutter primary with his wrist positioning, and I think he’ll take off. I have a basic idea of how exactly to do that so he is more attractive to me personally than a lot of the higher-ranked arms on my board.</p><p>I’m not expecting every draft pick to suddenly work out but if you are drafting every player with a plan on how to turn them into a star, you only need 10% of those plans to actually come to fruition and you have the best draft in the league most years. The goal is 100% success and you should never draft anyone expecting anything less than success but you should also understand that not every draft pick will work out. Players get hurt or sometimes your plan just sucks. A bad plan is better than no plan but it doesn’t always work and that’s perfectly fine. This is why you need twenty chances at it and fortunately, there are twenty rounds in the draft.</p><p>Every player drafted has a 90th percentile outcome as a star. That is something that Baseball Prospectus said years ago and it’s something I still very strongly believe today. If every player has a 90th percentile outcome where there is a star then no prospect should be ignored. Invest in developing every player and only draft players you have a plan to help them reach their 90th percentile. There should still be guys you have a plan for in the 20th round because every player has upside. Target upside and take risks with player development, you will likely be rewarded for it.</p><p>There was a tweet that I believe came from Kyle Boddy years ago but I can’t find it. The idea of it was that a year in which every single player in the organization gets exactly 5% every year is a failed year of development because no one has turned into a quality major leaguer.</p><p>Sure, individually they may have all gotten better but no one improved significantly so your system is going backwards. It’s better to have 5% improve by 100% than 100% by 5%. Even if the other 95% get 100% worse. You have to take risks to be successful and as long as you hit big on a few of them, you come out ahead. The big hits are what define MLB success, not the marginal roster filler.</p><p>I genuinely believe this is the largest market inefficiency in the sport. Even with the advances in scouting, and the widespread use of trackman technology to provide data on most draft picks, the draft is still largely viewed as a crapshoot. The draft really shouldn’t be one though. It’s the chance to cherry-pick only the players you really want and know how to develop from a pool of thousands. You should have higher success rates with draft picks than with prospects from trades and that isn’t at all the case.</p><p>A team like the Brewers who can’t develop hitters to save their life and have the best pitching development in the league should only draft pitchers in the first ten rounds. If those pitchers work out you can flip them for already developed major league hitters. Having a deep system without any positional weaknesses is a stupid dream, what matters is getting the most major league talent.</p><p>Talent can be traded just as easily as it can provide value for you. Who cares if you have no catching prospects when you have the prospect capital in pitching to trade for Sean Murphy or something? Don’t ever draft for need or draft something you can’t develop. Draft players you know you can help reach their ceiling and have a plan on how exactly to do that. Those are the picks that will bear fruit.</p><p>My shift in draft philosophy quite frankly makes grading draft picks off rip completely impossible. The only bad draft pick is the one that you don’t have a plan for. Unless someone in the Mariners front office DMs me saying that they took Thomas Harrington because they thought he was perfect as is and doesn’t need any adjustments to pitch in the majors; I can’t call it a bad draft pick. For all, I know they have a plan to add velocity or improve the shape of his stuff.</p><p>I’m not going to grade any draft picks this year. I’ll analyze who the players are and who they are expected to be in a neutral environment with competent player development. I’ll break down why I think they might be a fit and how I think the team might approach developing them but I won’t call a pick good or bad. That is impossible to know out of the draft. Drafting someone highly ranked on my board doesn’t mean it’s a good pick and drafting someone I have low doesn’t mean it’s bad. The only thing that matters is your plan for developing said draft pick.</p><p>When I’m scouting prospects for a general rankings list, I’m obviously not just ranking the players I know how to develop at the top. I am generally looking for the highest average outcome more than anything else like most scouts do. I prefer to assume good player development rather than average player development because anything else is depressing and I hate thinking the worst of players.</p><p>The blurbs tend to focus more on the positives than the realistic outcome. I’ll highlight flaws but in general, I focus on the players upside more than anything else. I think prospects are infinitely more interesting and more valuable when you focus on what they can be and how they can get there. There are a zillion 35 FVs that are maybe a useful bench piece. If I focused on what they will be it would read as “good stuff but probably just a low leverage reliever” a billion times.</p><p>That doesn’t make for enjoyable content nor does it help you understand why they should be of interest. I focus on what they can be because it helps flesh out why a team wants/should want them in their organization. It also helps get fans genuinely excited about the talent they have coming up, even in weaker systems. The future is meant to be exciting. It’s important to be realistic but it’s also important to recognize that every player has greatness in them and you should never write anyone off entirely.</p><p>I don’t know everything. There are times I will be wrong. I focus on the wrong things oftentimes or overvalue things that don’t matter. I can get caught up in flashy numbers and miss the obvious visual cues of failure. I’m as guilty as anyone of writing off players in the past for what traditionally feels like poor pitch shape but is actually exemplary. I like to think I’ve gotten better at checking every angle but when I do this again next year, there will almost certainly be another dozen angles I look at players through.</p><p>That is the nature of this business. Player evaluation is meant to evolve. I’m not going to evaluate players the same way every time- especially not across multiple years. My methods change every year to try to be more and more precise. That will always be the case until I am 100% right about every player.</p><p>I’m perfectly fine with admitting I was wrong. I prefer to be right, obviously, and I always strive for perfection but when a skill changes, I’m not going to dig my feet in and say they aren’t good still. Player development is non-linear and far from predictable. Skill levels change all of the time and you have to adapt or die.</p><p>I don’t believe in judging players from different demographics differently. Circumstances should not influence how you scout. I get why people look for more physical traits and tools over skills in prep bats but for the most part, I disagree with that logic.</p><p>A guy like Tyler Gough falls completely under the radar because he has very little projection. The appeal here is that he has elite stuff. You typically don’t prioritize already advanced pitch shapes in a prep arm but you can’t ignore them either. If Gough was coming out of college, after two years of solid performance where would he rank with the exact same pitch data? I’m betting he would fall in the first two rounds and closer to the first than the second. He’s not your conventional prep target but he’s still really good. You miss that if you only scout the delivery, body, feel, and physical attributes like people often do.</p><p>There is also the inverse that exists. College arms who are just lacking in physical projection or missing a changeup often get disrespected too. Just because they are older now doesn’t mean they can’t get stronger or find a new pitch. If they were a prep that wouldn’t be a major concern at all. Should being two years older make that much of a difference? Development is non-linear, and in general, I lean towards it not mattering.</p><p>We’re often willing to overlook poor hit tools from prep bats but not from college ones. Jud Fabian has plus tools across the board but major whiff and general hit tool issues beyond that. Henry Bolte has very comparable raw tools and strikes out more in high school than Fabian does in college. Can you guess which one is ranked higher on all of MLB Pipeline, Prospects Live, and Baseball America? It’s not the one who has objectively the best swing decisions in the country.</p><p>This isn’t me knocking on Henry Bolte, this is me pointing out how silly it is that Fabian gets beat into the ground for whiff issues but we don’t do the same to Bolte because he’s younger, even if those issues are worse. Does Fabian being three years older make him suddenly unsalvageable? The youth should grant some extra leeway but not that much. Hit tool concerns need to be relevant for all players or none.</p><p>There is a difference in confidence though between the two levels. I totally understand that it’s a lot harder to be confident that a prep has good control than a college arm with a sub 5% walk rate in 200 career innings. In general, I do change my methodology slightly for preps and college players when scouting control/hit tool.</p><p>Production is king for college guys and still matters for preps but good production doesn’t mean much at all for preps. For preps, I’ll lean more on how the delivery/swing looks and look for visual signs on if they will whiff. There are players I’ll miss on because of that but it is generally more accurate than relying on walk rates against high schoolers- literal children. For college players, I trust the track record and the results- more specifically I trust the trackman data that lets me see how good their locations are and what pitches they struggle to locate.</p><p>I’m never going to put a prep over 60 control and very rarely above a 60 grade hit tool. College arms/bats have a much easier time getting there because I can be confident in my assessments when I have both the data and the eye test. I don’t neglect to evaluate the mechanics and swing entirely for college guy but it matters less for them than the numbers. Preps are the inverse scenario.</p><p>You have to be flexible in how you evaluate players and look at them from all angles to really make sure that people don’t fall through the cracks. There is no one mold of player, but a quadrillion ways to be successful. They don’t have to look conventional and they don’t deserve to be dismissed for looking unconventional.</p><p>I value the shape of a fastball much higher than I do the shape of secondary pitches, regardless of the level they are at. The fastball is still the most thrown pitch in the majors by a pretty wide margin even as fastball usage decreases league-wide every year. More than that, it’s the hardest pitch to develop a good one out of nowhere. I could easily name a half dozen pitchers with brand new plus sweepers this year. The amount with a new plus fastball (That used to be average or worse) is like Matt Bush and uh…</p><p>It’s really hard to just stumble upon a new fastball. If the feel for pronation/supination is there then I am more comfortable projecting on them finding a secondary. I would still value them much higher if they had one now but it’s not a death sentence if they don’t have it yet because regardless, of age we know you can always add a new pitch. I won’t rely on them doing so but I will account for the possibility.</p><p>There is more than one path to having a good pitch. Elite VAA four-seamers are the most common variant of elite fastballs but they aren’t the only variant. There are elite sinkers too. There are elite fastballs from a high release point ala Clayton Kershaw. There are elite fastballs with bland movement and there are elite fastballs without impact velocity (Joe Ryan fits both). Just because it doesn’t look conventionally great or grade out perfectly on your model, doesn’t mean it isn’t a great pitch. Every model has blind spots. Obviously, the inverse is also true and fastballs that check a lot of boxes sometimes suck.</p><p>It is also very important to consider how a pitcher’s stuff interacts with the rest of their arsenal. Peyton Pallette is one arm with an amazing curve with specs comparable to Ryan Pressley and above-average ride with velo on the fastball. His problem is that the FB/CB don’t actually tunnel at all because their movement profiles mesh so poorly. As such, Pallette has terrible chase rates with his elite spec breaking ball.</p><p>Connor Prielipp is the inverted version. He has generic movement on his not all that hard fastball from a high release. He throws a low eighties gyro ball that looks good but is still somewhat generic. Yet, the fastball/slider tunnel so incredibly well that he has some of the best in-zone whiff rates with both pitches- individually, and overall, in the entire draft.</p><p>Even when a fastball has terrible specs, and terrible results, that does not mean that it doesn’t have an important role to play and should be replaced. Patrick Sandoval is a prominent example of this in the majors. He has a terrible four-seamer but it’s a needed pitch for the changeup to dominate like it does.</p><p>The changeup and sinker don’t work together because the horizontal and vertical elements are so comparable. Sandoval has one of the best changeups in baseball because he uses the bad four-seamer against right handed hitters. There is optimization potential but scrapping the four-seam is not how you do it. That would only wreck the changeup. You can’t just look at one pitch, see that it’s bad and say get rid of it. A lot of bad pitches are integral to that pitcher&#39;s success. You have to be careful when tweaking a pitcher’s arsenal or else you’ll ruin what made them good in the first place.</p><p>How the arsenal blends is an important piece of the puzzle that must be considered when evaluating a pitching prospect. You can’t just isolate the elements and expect things to work out eventually. If they are not performing up to their stuff then there is always a reason for it. The job of scouts is to find that reason and the job of player development is to fix it.</p><p>I value raw power higher than any other tool for position players. More specifically, the capacity to get to above-average raw power eventually. That might sound strange since players live or die by their hit tool. Almost every top prospect who busts is because they can’t hit. So why put the most value on power?</p><p>I’m not interested in developing bench pieces and having power is what gets you off of the bench. A 107.6 MPH Max EV was the 50th percentile of major leaguers last year. Guess how many qualified players with a Max EV that low had a wRC+ above 105 last year? That would be zero. (It’s one in Josh Rojas at &lt;100)Let’s lower our PA minimum to 300 to be more reasonable. Just Tony Kemp, Kolten Wong, Alex Bregman, and Luis Arraez. Bregman doesn’t count because he still has above-average game power. It is really hard to be successful in the major leagues without some semblance of raw power.</p><p>Raw power can be developed but there’s a limit to reason. I’m not going to expect someone like Chandler Simpson with a Max EV of 97 MPH and a 6.8% Hard-Hit rate to develop into a productive major leaguer. Only like 5% of above-average major league hitters have below-average raw power and never anything close to that low. If you don’t have useable raw power, your upside is probably realistically capped at a bench piece.</p><p>I also prefer to chase upside so the player with plus raw power and whiff issues, due to a hitch in their swing is more appealing to me than the one who will never be able to make impactful contact. I understand why people disagree but I’m not interested in adding players you can always pick up in free agency for the league minimum. I want players who can help a franchise actually win games. If that is the goal, some raw power is an absolute must.</p><p>My goal in my rankings is primarily to predict who has the highest average outcome in the majors but it’s not just that. I want real impact players who can make a difference. A player who is guaranteed to be worth 2 career WAR in ten years at the major league level with no variance in that projection at all, wouldn’t make my top 500 at all.</p><p>I’m not interested in players who are only going to fill space on the roster, no matter how high their average WAR projection might wind up being. If they don&#39;t have the upside to play an important role, it’s not worth wasting valuable resources on acquiring them. Let the upside plays that bust fill in the margins of the roster or get MiLB free agents who are journeymen always available for nothing to fill holes. Homegrown AAA depth is no better than a waiver claim who is AAA depth.</p><p>I was given access to more resources than I could have ever imagined this year. I was given access to the entirety of the Trackman Database for College Baseball. That means for any game played in a stadium with Trackman, I have access to basically all of their statcast data and some more stuff as well- including batted ball spin rate.</p><p>Usually, when I am referring to a player&#39;s whiff or groundball rates, or whatever, it is only in games with Trackman data. I will specify if it is not. This is a limited sample size and sometimes paints an inaccurate picture but it’s more often than not correct because you don’t completely fluke into anything in what is typically a 50+ BBE sample size.</p><p>I was also given access to all of the data from high school and college baseball games played in MLB stadiums. Those games have Hawkeye installed and active so I have just about all of the usual data available on statcast. I have pitch data for 170 different prep arms as well as more accurate statcast data (Relative to Trackman) for 542 college arms. Also, some batted ball data but given the small sample nature, only Max EV has significant value. That data for high schoolers is oftentimes up to a full year out of date so it can’t be the end all be all but it does help a lot in evaluating players.</p><p>I’ve also made a lot of friends since last year, and even just since the Compendium was published. I’ve had conversations will fellow analysts, scouts, and team employees about players. I’ve even had a few players reach out to me, giving me their data themselves and asking me to write a detailed scouting report on them. I’ve bounced my ideas off of a number of connected people and am getting direct feedback on what players are like as humans from people who know them.</p><p>I do not deem it morally acceptable to talk down a player- high schoolers, especially for their personality. Most of these players were children when the incidents I’ve been told of took place. I don’t find it polite to slander who people are. If a player has positive makeup, I’ll mention it but if it’s negative, I will not comment on it. I’ll reflect on the makeup concerns I have in their ranking but not in their reports.</p><p>This is a warning to take prep pitch data with a grain of salt. The baseball used for high school games has higher seams than the MLB one. I’ve been told when I’ve asked around and based on how the averages line up with the MLB, that you generally want to subtract two inches from what it says the IVB is (Absolute value) and about that (depends on pitch type and shape, not really a uniform rule) from horizontal movement.</p><p>In a similar vein, trackman pitch data is not everything. There are probably at least ten pitches in college baseball I could argue are the best pitch in the MLB today based on the data readings trackman gives. They obviously are not that. The trackman baseball also has slightly higher seams which inflates movement some (Less than for preps) but it’s more to do with how many trackman units are miscalibrated in general, and just track differently from Hawkeye especially.</p><p>I do my best to filter out the really bad trackman units and will often just use a player&#39;s road pitch data if it’s evident that their trackman is broken but it’s far from a perfect measurement. Treat trackman pitch data as a range rather than a fixed number. The difference between movement is never as big as it might look and that is doubly true for release points.</p><p>I am one of like five different people in the public sphere with access to an actually scaled properly Barrel% for college baseball players. Most places when they refer to Barrel% for college or minor league players are counting all batted balls with a launch angles between 10–35° and an exit velocity above 95 MPH. Thanks to the wizardry of <a href="https://twitter.com/ydouright?s=20&amp;t=_r63njnWUbgrtI0OQNvu7w">@ydouright</a>, my version of barrel% I will refer to is the MLB version with an expanding range of launch angles based on the exit velocity.</p><p>The strike zone I’ll often refer to for calculating chase%, Z-swing%, and in-zone contact% have changed shape throughout the process of scouting for this list. At first, I was using 1.5 feet for the bottom and 3.5 feet for the top of the zone, thanks to a Baseball Prospectus article years ago that said that was the size of the average strike zone called in the MLB.</p><p>I then experimented with the AAA strike zone they are testing before remembering that I am an idiot. They tested a zone in Low A southeast last year, as well as the AFL that was meant to resemble the shape of the MLB strike zone. The top of the zone is 56% of the batter&#39;s height and the bottom edge is 28% of the height of the batter. For pitchers, I just set every batter to default at 6&#39;1&quot; since trackman doesn’t automatically store batter height.</p><p>In the blogs this week, that will be the zone I am referring to unless I either got data sourced or they appeared in a game with hawkeye. If they appeared in a game with Hawkeye, statcast actually records the exact coordinates of the top and bottom edge of the zone for that player to give me perfect accuracy. Sourced data obviously uses a more accurate player-specific zone as well.</p><p>For the players at a 40 FV and below on my top 500, they will use one of three zones at random and it probably won’t say which one. Treat the plate discipline numbers in those sections with a grain of salt. I don’t have the time or desire to update that data for nearly 400 players. Apologies.</p><p>I will talk about batted ball spin data quite a bit this week. Justin Choi has written <a href="https://blogs.fangraphs.com/the-lurking-influence-of-batted-ball-spin/">two interesting blogs</a> on the value of it already. Batted ball spin helps flyballs carry and is something I’ve speculated about the impact of for a while. It won’t carry a player&#39;s stock but it is something I watch because it’s an unseen element that we know can lead to success and it’s data you won’t see anywhere else since Hawkeye doesn’t even track it. There are inaccuracies in trackman data, as always so grain of salt but it’s a mildly interesting data point most people aren’t familiar with.</p><p>I used top 8th EV instead of 90th percentile EV when examining a players actually impactful raw power. <a href="https://www.drivelinebaseball.com/2019/12/driveline-hitting-kpis/">Driveline found that top 8th EV</a> was the best number to work with for accurately gauging effective raw power and was the most consistent year to year. So, I opted to use that over the somewhat less meaningful 90th percentile EV… or at least, I thought I did. Turns out I’m an idiot who can’t read and Top 8th EV doesn’t mean top 8% but top 1/8. It’s too late to fix it right now but on the post-draft/during the draft content, it’ll correctly refer to the top 12.5% of EVs. Sorry about that.</p><p>I want to take another moment to express my utmost gratitude to <a href="https://twitter.com/NoJay31">@Nojay31</a> for designing the thumbnails for this week’s blogs. This week’s content would also be nowhere near the same quality without the assistance of <a href="https://twitter.com/ydouright">@ydouright</a> who is pretty much the only reason a lot of the trackman data is interpretable. Any graph you see charting how college players compare is probably from him and all of the percentile rankings of how a hitter measures up to the league come from him.</p><p><em>Thanks for reading! Tune back in tomorrow to read about some of the top under slot targets on day two of the draft. If you missed it, I also wrote about the </em><a href="https://medium.com/@tieranbaseball/the-numbers-suck-but-19f4ac20a72a"><em>top players who haven’t performed but are still good prospects</em></a><em> yesterday.</em></p><h4>Other Stats Glossary:</h4><p>GB% — The percentage of batted balls hit by the player that was hit on the ground. <br>OFFB% — The percentage of batted balls that were ruled as an outfield flyball. This does not include popups.<br>LD% — The percentage of batted balls resulting in a linedrive. <br>PU% — The percentage of batted balls resulting in a popup. <br>Pull% — The percentage of batted balls hit with a spray direction &gt;=15° (This is inverted for RHB)<br>Center% — The percentage of batted balls hit with a spray direction &lt;=15° and &gt;=-15°<br>Oppo% — The percentage of batted balls hit with a spray direction &lt;=-15° (This is inverted for RHB)<br>HH% — The percentage of batted balls that were hit in excess of 95 MPH.<br>SH% — The percentage of batted balls hit with an exit velocity below 80 MPH.<br>Average EV — The Average Exit Velocity of all a player’s batted balls. <br>Air EV — The Average exit velocity of a players batted balls that were not defined as groundballs. <br>90th EV — The average EV of the top 10% of a players batted balls. This does include foul balls. Usually when I use this one it’s from a source.<br>92nd EV — The average EV of the top 8% of a players batted balls. This does include foul balls. Was supposed to be Top 8th but I’m an idiot. <br>Max EV — The hardest hit batted ball by a player in a game with Trackman. <br>Sweet-Spot% — The percentage of batted balls hit with a launch angle between 8° and 32°. <br>Barrel% — As defined by Baseball Savant. The percentage of fair balls hit 98+ with an expanding range of launch angles based on exit velocity.<br>sdLA — The standard deviation between the launch angles of a player’s batted balls. This has a high correlation to BABIP. <br>Batted Ball Spin — The average spin rate of a players batted balls. <br>Backspin% — Percentage of batted balls hit by the player on an axis between 135° and 225°. <br>Zone Swing% — Percentage of pitches seen in the zone that the player swung at. The zone is defined as within -.83 — .83 plateX and height is defined as it was during the initial MLB ABS testing at 56% of a batters height for the top edge and 28% for the lower edge. <br>In-Zone Whiff% — Percentage of in-zone swings resulting in a swing and miss. The zone is defined as within -.83 — .83 plateX and height is defined as it was during the initial MLB ABS testing at 56% of a batters height for the top edge and 28% for the lower edge. <br>Chase% — Percentage of Out of Zone Pitches swung at. The zone is defined as within -.83 — .83 plateX and height is defined as it was during the initial MLB ABS testing at 56% of a batters height for the top edge and 28% for the lower edge. IVB — Induced vertical break. The amount that a pitch moves independently of gravity.<br>Drop/Statcast Drop/Movement with Gravity — How much a pitch moves without factoring out gravity. This is the vertical movement you see on statcast. <br>HB — How much a pitch moves horizontally. I typically refer to it as an absolute value like it is listed on Statcast. <br>VAA — Vertical Approach Angle. The vertical angle at which a pitch crosses the plate. Flatter is typically better for fastballs and steeper is preferred for secondary pitches. <br>HAA — Horizontal Approach Angle. The horizontal angle at which a pitch crosses the plate. Steeper (Absolute value higher number) typically results in more swinging strikes but these rules are not hard-set by any means.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=608626368d0f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>