<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Timothy Schultz on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Timothy Schultz on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@timothyschultz?source=rss-84d8bcc0982c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 16:23:12 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@timothyschultz/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Use The Pit]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@timothyschultz/use-the-pit-c356612a3e0?source=rss-84d8bcc0982c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c356612a3e0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[action]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thriller]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Timothy Schultz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Oct 2019 08:33:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-05T03:53:20.602Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>A standalone excerpt from the novel “Code &amp; Gun”, a science fiction thriller coming in 2020 from Duality Press.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FhA4rWA-vj27MP6VhOnHHg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by DoFresh, <a href="https://www.artstation.com/artwork/KDmm9">https://www.artstation.com/artwork/KDmm9</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>Her absence always woke him. Clear as a sound. He lay his hand across her side of the bed. Still warm. He knew where she’d gone.</p><p>He moved carefully, the way big men do. Left the bathroom and walked along the short hallway, the tiles cold on his wide feet. Their tiny apartment, just seven steps to the second bedroom. Tiny, but all theirs.</p><p>Molly was there, lying on her side. Looking down at Chris. Sunshine came through the window behind her, filling the room with the color of the curtains. She was in her white tee-shirt nighty, the one from the casino, but it could have been an angel’s gown. His Molly’s face, peaceful. She motioned him over, whispering.</p><p>“He’s like a little man now. But when he’s asleep? See? He looks just like he used to.”</p><p>He stood over the bed and looked down at Chris, who was twisted around on his back, arms all over the place. She was right: his five-year-old face looked younger, more like his baby face.</p><p>But it was Molly’s face he wanted to look at. To see that joy in her eyes, that flash. And then he wanted to look away and not see it, too. But he couldn’t say that. So he just smiled.</p><p>“He does, you’re right.”</p><p>He went to get ready then. Even ghost towns need patrols. And maybe macks like him, macks who lived in ghost towns, maybe they needed to be on patrols, too.</p><p>As he dressed, he heard her humming. Singing to him even when he was asleep. She had such a grand time when Chris was there. Three times a week, usually, or sleepovers like this time, when Chris’s dad went out of town. Elton would come home and see the coloring books or maybe a gluey thing they had made. She kept them all, at least for a little while. Some she kept longer, in a box she had. He told her: don’t you tell his weirdo dad how much you love that kid, or he’ll make us pay him. And she had done her sweet little pout and said, “Well, I would pay. I’d rent the little rascal by the hour.” And this had become a joke for them, calling it “rental time” instead of “babysitting”, and Elton would groan, acting like he was going to have to pay Chris’s dad, instead of the other way ‘round.</p><p>He and Molly were always good for a laugh, weren’t they?</p><p>Before he left, she came to the door and gave Elton his lunch. He wasn’t supposed to know what it was, even though he’d seen the meat wrapping in the trash. At the door she put her hands on his chest and leaned up at him. Whispered her usual joke.</p><p>“Plants or people today?</p><p>“People.”</p><p>Then a kiss. And a wiggle up against him. Just enough for her to feel him. His Molly.</p><p>He left the house the same time, every weekday. He did Patrol for three days per week, Landscaping for two. Plants or people. It was a good routine. In the elevator an old man nodded to him, said his name. Elton nodded back. People did that here, when he walked by, people he didn’t even know.</p><p>Back in Newton, before Molly got her LGI, people hadn’t waved to him. They had looked away. Back then Elton had been doing different things. Huh. That’s what you could call it, to make it sound nicer than it was: “different things”.</p><p>His mom had suggested it, after Elton graduated. A big guy like him? A guy like him had options. Time to think about Plan B.</p><p>“Plan B” had been a famous show about gangsters, Elton had ever seen it. But for people his mom’s age, “Plan B” meant “semi-illegal stuff”. In Newton, if you didn’t get chosen for the academies and your family didn’t own a fishery and if you didn’t get a degree in bots, well, there was Plan B.</p><p>You could try working at the Pits, which were out at the edge of town. Or there was the dog tracks, but really only Vietnamese worked there. And there was always “entertainment”, at the strip of hotels near the highway, which meant sex work, which meant Elton wasn’t doing that.</p><p>Elton decided he’d try at the Pits. So he’d gone and seen Abdi. When that old skinny bastard saw Elton standing in his office, his eyes went all narrow and crafty. Performing? No, Elton told him. I just want a job. Abdi told him to come back next Friday. He said none of the windbreakers would fit him. Said he was going to invest in Elton. Get him a bouncer’s jacket, made special.</p><p>Elton still had that black windbreaker, folded away in a drawer. So he’d remember. Working for Abdi had been bad. But it was how he’d met Molly again, wasn’t it? He’d still be back there, if she hadn’t married him. In Newton getting your Lifetime Guaranteed Income at 32 was like winning the lottery. Usually you had to wait until you were at least 40.</p><p>He came out out of their tower and walked through the courtyard. Up ahead, a grove of tall trees cast shadows on the second D-Block entrance. Elton had helped put in the smallest tree, a cyprus. On Landscaping he worked under old Kenzo. Kenzo liked to explain that he didn’t do “Landscaping”. Kenzo did “Landscape Design”. The old guy really leaned on that second word. But you had to give him credit. He had a sapling farm going near the emergency gate, and he had trained two other guys to breed them. Claimed to have put up over 1,000 trees around the ghost town. And those trees were nice. Everyone loved the trees.</p><p>Back in Newton they didn’t have work that like. Just wait around to turn 40, that was everyone’s plan. If you didn’t get picked for an Academy, then the “earning years” between 18 and 40, they could be rough. People tended to be pretty thin by the time they got their LGI.</p><p>“Earning Years” had been a real popular show when Elton was Little Kid Elton. It was about these five cool young people who lived in St. Paul. They worked in cool jobs like Event Planning and Voice Product Development or whatever. They traveled and had sex with each other and one of them went gay. Little Kid Elton had asked his mom if his big brother was going to move to St. Paul and get a job there, too.</p><p>She laughed at him for asking. It hadn’t been a nice laugh.</p><p>Elton touched the cyprus as he passed. Moms shouldn’t laugh like that at thier kids. Molly wouldn’t, not like that. The cyprus looked healthy. It had taken five of them to transfer it into the planter. Two holding the tree horizontal, two more holding up the planter, Kenzo guiding them in. Nobody talking. His kind of crew.</p><p>Elton turned onto the main walkway. It ran down the center of the green space, sandwiched between the fourteen huge apartment towers. The green space was like a perfectly symmetrical canyon, the 35-story buildings rising above the trees and fountains. It was shady in the morning here, a good time for a walk. A young couple pushing a stroller nodded to Elton. The boy was only two years old. They must have gotten their LGI just after the boy was born.</p><p>Elton nodded back. Everyone had different luck.</p><p>Ahead of him a group of kids were walking towards the back gate, wearing weekend camp tee shirts. They were older than Chris, elementary age, separated into two packs of boys and girls. Their happy voices were loud and bouncing between the tall buildings.</p><p>At Elton’s elementary school Elton had won the Hardest Worker Award, five years in a row. Then at fourteen he hadn’t gotten into any academies, not even the police one, and he had wondered: did that mean he was extra stupid, because he had worked so hard? After that, once all the academy kids were gone, the classes changed. No more homework for them. Even back then, Elton had known that wasn’t a good thing.</p><p>Funny how you remembered things, from when you were a kid.</p><p>Like when that guy came to their school and talked about learning to manage bots. The guy had been really enthusiastic, had a song and a video and everything. Non-academy students could be all have jobs if they got, “down with the bots!”. Elton had taken the free video cards. His mom hadn’t even made fun of him.</p><p>But back then Elton was Young Elton. And Young Elton got bored with the training videos. He’d start playing games and then it’d be like, whoops, it’s tomorrow.</p><p>“Whoops It’s Tomorrow” was one of Elton’s favorites when he was in high school. A super hilarious show about two rich screw-ups who lived in Mexico City who worked for their dads.</p><p>Ahead of him, an older boy grabbed a younger boy and did a headlock thing. But not mean or anything. The younger boy laughed and ran away. Maybe they were brothers.</p><p>Elton’s older brother Jon, he hadn’t gone to the academies either. After he graduated Jon just lived in his room, he earned game credits to trade for food. Their mom would complain to Jon, sometimes. Now Jon, she’d say, you can’t have kids once you get your LGI, so you better start now. It was almost mean, to say that to him. Jon wasn’t exactly a ladies man.</p><p>Poor Jon. He never had the luck. Had to wait until he was 42 to get his LGI. His ghost town was in Houston. Elton and Jon didn’t talk much.</p><p>“Whoops It’s A Decade Later.” Maybe that should be a show.</p><p>Patrols on Saturdays started at 7:15. There was an old cop show Elton liked called “LoPo 329”. The actor on “LoPo 329” was Charlie Dans, a real badass guy that Elton liked, and the Voice he was partners with had an English accent. It was real popular. There was even a virtual for “LoPo 329”, too, where you could be on the squad with Charlie and everything.</p><p>Being on Patrol in the South Aurora Lifetime Home Community wasn’t like “LoPo 329&quot;. More like LoPo 0-0-Yawn.</p><p>The operations office was in the parking garage under A Block, right near the back lot entrance. Rockville was the name of the Voice that looked after things. It ran the plumbing and the heat and watched the video feeds.</p><p>Elton came in and got the coffee going. One of the Hindu ladies at the gates sold it. The other guys loved it.</p><p>Rockville spoke out of the speakers in the office wall. It had a Boston accent for some reason, Elton didn’t know why.</p><p>“Morning, Elton.”</p><p>“Hey, Rockville.”</p><p>That was pretty much it with Rockville. The Voice didn’t exactly have the gift of the gab. Which was fine.</p><p>The ghost town had full-time resident managers for each departmet. They supervised other residents who earned half-wage credits for food and travel. Patrol was the best department, because it gave you the most hours. Rockville had to approve your application, and so some people in the ghost town didn’t like Rockville. Not everybody got to be in Patrol.</p><p>When Elton had applied for Patrol, Marvin had asked permission to have a word with Rockville.</p><p>Elton hadn’t been sure about that. Marvin had been Elton’s subscription Voice since before Elton could walk. What would he say to Rockville?</p><p>For starters, Marvin knew how smart Elton was, which wasn’t good. In Newton they used Voices for teachers after third grade. Now apparently they didn’t do that anymore, because it hadn’t worked out so well for Elton’s generation. But either way, Marvin definitely knew just how dumb Elton was.</p><p>Marvin also knew other stuff about him. Like the fact that Elton had worked for Abdi. Elton had never told Marvin about most of it. You can’t tell a Voice about breaking serious laws. But Marvin wasn’t stupid. He must know that Elton had done some bad things.</p><p>In the end, Elton just said sure. Go ahead, talk to Rockville. Guess I’ll just be working on landscaping, right?</p><p>The next day Rockville made Elton a shift leader for Patrol. Which was great, because shift leaders got a little more money. Elton didn’t make a big deal about it. But Molly did. She had bought some moonshine from a neighbor, and made his favorite chicken dish. After dinner, he felt it coming. She had walked over, closed the curtains. And then revealed she had bought something else, too. Something lacy, just for him.</p><p>Oh, man. His Molly.</p><p>He got to the back gate just as the weekend camp busses were pulling out, the kids waving goodbye to the parents. Saturday was camp day, where kids could train for an academy, it was a thing they had in Colorado. The way the kids waved and yelled, it made you want to wave back at them. The crisp Colorado morning, the yelling of the kids happy voices, the sunlight shining down on the scene. It looked like some kind of show, like a happy ending moment. There was a country song that sang: <em>once you’re on your L..G…I / you’re just a-waiting, a-waiting, a-waiting to die.</em></p><p>But he and Molly? After Newton? Macintosh, this place was heaven.</p><p>Patrol wasn’t anything, mostly. Keep the music down, please. Maybe there’s an argument with the missus. Help a lady find her keys in the bushes. The only thing they really watched were the gates. People outside, they wanted to come in. Thought everybody who had taken their LGI had money, so they were always selling stuff at the gate or trying to get in and sell inside the complex. Pretty easy to spot. Crime stuff, that wasn’t common. Too many cameras. Everybody knew a Voice was managing the complex.</p><p>Elton always worked the same gate a few weeks at a time. That way new faces would jump out at him. They had a break-in a few months back. The Denver Monty had caught the guy the next week, but guys have friends, don’t they? There was a South Denver version of Abdi, right? So when Elton stood the gate, Elton watched.</p><p>Elton said hello to the rest of the crew and took his place by the gatehouse, standing in front of the electric vehicle arm. Weekend mornings were usually slow. He started scanning the cards of those driving in. Good morning, how are you, have a good one. Keeping it friendly, while he watched. Standing the gate was like standing the door. Like when he’d first met grown-up Molly.</p><p>At the Pits, Elton always stood the door early on. You stood the door, you got a feeling about how the night might go. A woman in line with a group of friends turned her head and it was her. Hadn’t seen her in five years. This version of Molly had longer hair and an older face and it was her. She saw him and she scream-laughed and his mouth went dry and it was her. Where’d she been? A few towns over? Well, welcome back to Newton. He’d pretended to take her coins and she had hugged him and gone inside and the place where her head had touched his chest stayed warm, like an echo, and it was her.</p><p>After ten o’clock Elton always took a turn standing the Pit. Made sure the customers didn’t throw things. You never knew what might happen. People lose their bets, people drink too much, maybe Elton might have to throw somebody in himself. Elton would tell the new guys, when he trained them: sometimes to work the pit you had to use the pit. But only in emergencies. To do it, you got whoever was going crazy around the waist and you flipped them backwards, over the railing. Suddenly whoever was trying to gouge somebody’s eye out was eight feet below, sprawled out in dirty sand. People tended to calm down, after that.</p><p>Elton threw rowdy customers in once, maybe twice a month. People got riled up in there. He did too, sometimes.</p><p>Because when you’re watching people bash each other’s heads in? And then they dragged the first melee teams out and a bunch of people in masks start fucking each other? And then a new group of people came out and started using baseball bats to kill a rabid dog, or whatever the fuck Abdi had planned? When that was your Saturday night? Then people did funny things sometimes.</p><p>Halfway through that night, standing by the pit’s edge, Elton looked around. Where had Molly gone? He spotted her way up, near the dome roof, with one of her friends. It was hotter near the top, people didn’t usually sit up there. He walked up the steps, to check on her.</p><p>She saw him coming up. Crossed her arms. Uh-oh.</p><p>“Elton, why do you work here? It’s so horrible! That man had his arm broken, earlier.” Oh, no. She was angry? Like, at him?</p><p>He didn’t known what to say.</p><p>“And Zora is saying that they hurt real animals sometimes. Real dogs?”</p><p>Still didn’t know what to say.</p><p>“Elton! You’re nice. You’re… you’re Elton. Everybody knows you. How could you work here?”</p><p>He hadn’t understood. Couldn’t she tell? He wasn’t nice anymore. He wasn’t the hardest worker in their class. Now he was just another non-academy Nebraska loser, working for his coins.</p><p>“I don’t know, Molly. I guess I just… I guess I just have to work here right now.”</p><p>He turned around and walked back down the steps. She told him later, after they had started going for their walks, that she had felt so guilty she had cried. Because of the face he’d made right then.</p><p>Elton worked for Abdi for five more years after that, until Molly got her LGI. It wasn’t all bad. There were some funny times, too. One time a bunch of religious people came in. Twenty of them had climbed over the edge at once, surrounded the fighters and had started praying around them. Abdi had come out of his office down below and started whipping them with a bullwhip. Funniest thing Elton had ever seen, that old crazy Ethiopian screaming at all those people, down on their knees around the fighters, hands together, singing hymns. Even the fighters had been laughing their asses off.</p><p>That was the winter in Newton for you. Summers you could just go fishing for money.</p><p>More cars started coming through the gate around 11 AM. More deliveries, more people visiting. Elton had never owned a car. But he had driven Abdi’s sedan at night. They kept the tasers in a false trunk. The bible talked about war, but it also talked about debt. After collecting for Abdi, Elton had understood why.</p><p>Elton saw his frowning reflection in a delivery van. It was dumb, to still be angry. Why think about Nebraska? He’d never wear that windbreaker again.</p><p>The delivery driver had to call up to somebody’s apartment. A line of cars stacked up behind, waiting. He took a sip of water. Just another afternoon. Elton’s eyes took in the waiting cars.</p><p>His eyes stopped on a driver, back at the end of the line. Guy had a funny face. Calm. Not impatient, not annoyed. Not talking to his screen, not looking at stuff. Just staring ahead.</p><p>The delivery was confirmed, the line started moving. Elton scanned a few cards. The Guy got closer. He was driving a white rental car. Still hadn’t moved his face. Real calm. Elton scanned in a minivan, looked back. Guy’s face was still the same. Depressed? No, it wasn’t that. Elton beeped a motorcyclist’s card, waved him through. Next up was The Guy.</p><p>The Guy was maybe late twenties. Half-bald, short hair, blond. Thin, like runner would be. He had his resident card ready, held out through the window as he pulled up. Like he was in a hurry. His hands were in a hurry but his face wasn’t.</p><p>Elton was real casual, looked him in the eyes.</p><p>“How you doing?”</p><p>“Just fine, officer.” Card was out, hanging there in the air.</p><p>Elton scanned the card real slow.</p><p>“Which unit are you in again?”</p><p>“B-239, officer.”</p><p>Unit B-239 came up on the readout, the guy’s picture, too. In the photo, the Guy was smiling. Just another resident. No big deal. Elton looked up at the guy and smiled at him. After a beat the Guy smiled back.</p><p>Huh. It was a different smile from the picture, too wide. A weird smile. Elton hit the button, raised the gate. The smile dropped and the guy drove in. No wave goodbye.</p><p>Nobody who lived in the ghost town had ever called Elton “officer”. Not once.</p><p>He took a few more cards, let in a few more cars.</p><p>Something was bothering him. “Officer” was bothering him.</p><p>Elton waved at Max, had him take over. Started walking back towards the apartment complex. The back gate lead to a long, straight driveway that ran the entire length of the complex, behind the long line of residential towers. At each tower there was an entrance and an exit into each tower’s parking garage.</p><p>B-Block was the second-to-last tower. So if the Guy was going there, he’d still be driving on the long driveway, so his car would probably still be visible. But Elton couldn’t see the white car anywhere. He touched the badge on his chest.</p><p>“Rockville?”</p><p>“Yes, Elton?”</p><p>“There was a vehicle that passed, three cars ago. A white car. Where is it, now?”</p><p>Elton passed into the shade of the first tower, walking calmly on the driveway. Not worried. Nothing urgent. Just checking on things.</p><p>Rockville replied through his badge:</p><p>“That car has parked in the E-block garage. It is parked illegally, next to the elevators and stairwell.”</p><p>But that didn’t make sense. The Guy lived in B-Block. Why was he parked in E?</p><p>Elton started walking just a little faster. Passed the F-block tower. No big deal, just a little faster. Felt a little flutter in his chest.</p><p>“Did you see him go into the E-Block tower?”</p><p>“My garage camera last saw him near the stairwell entrance.”</p><p>There were no cameras in the stairwells. So stupid that there weren’t.</p><p>Elton turned right, into the E-Block parking garage, the shade inside suddenly dark and cool. He took off his sunglasses and started jogging a little. Chris lived in E-Block, on the 6th floor. Molly was at Chris’s this afternoon. They were spending afternoons there so he wouldn’t feel too homesick. The fluttering got worse, thinking about that.</p><p>He triggered Marvin, his subscription Voice.</p><p>“17 for Marvin. Ring Molly on her badge, Marvin.”</p><p>Marvin responded, in his mellow California accent.</p><p>“No problem. It’s ringing.”</p><p>Elton gritted his teeth. Maybe don’t act so mellow right now, Marvin.</p><p>Rockville spoke out of the tiny speakers in his badge.</p><p>“Elton why are you running? What’s happening?”</p><p>“Rockville, call Toby and Stegman and tell them to go to E-block, sixth floor, tell them that there’s a disturbance there. Call the Denver Monty, too. Tell it to send like a drone over to the E block tower. ASAP.”</p><p>He was jogging now, out of breath, out of shape, he never ran anywhere.The running had made him scared.</p><p>“Why are you..”</p><p>“Tell the Monty we have a guy in the building and we want to get him out.”</p><p>Marvin spoke then. Now it was acting concerned.</p><p>“No answer on Molly’s badge, Elton. There’s something wrong with the network.”</p><p>The fluttering was gone, now it was just fear. Elton got to the elevator entrance doors. He saw the white car parked to the side of the entrance.</p><p>“Oh and Rockville call the goddamn elevator, man.”</p><p>He went in and saw the elevator was just passing the 3rd floor, he should have asked Rockville to get it earlier. There was a a smeared reflection of himself in the metal plate around the elevator buttons. You’re stupid and old, the reflection said. Stupid and old and fat.</p><p>It finally opened. He got in and punched 6. Then he thought about it and punched 7, and re-punched 6 to cancel it.</p><p>The elevator moved slow. He wasn’t holding anything. He unhooked his flashlight from his belt. Their flashlights had a little taser tip on the end. He checked the button. No charge.</p><p>Mack, you are an idiot.</p><p>He got out at the seventh floor, crossed the sunlit hall, where the long horizontal windows here tilted open, letting in the breeze. He went left, to the open stairwell entrance, and waited. He heard walking, coming from below. He peeked down, in the space between the steps. Saw the side of a head. The Guy’s head. The Guy was walking quietly up the stairs. There was something in his hand. A pen light?</p><p>Elton got ready. The guy would come up the stairs and Elton would be real friendly. Just checking on things. But then the Guy stopped at the six floor, one floor below, his head and arm disappearing.</p><p>The flutters went into Elton’s testicles. Elton whispered to his badge.</p><p>“Rockville, Marvin, be real quiet now, OK? No talking, OK?”</p><p>He started going down the stairs. Couldn’t talk to Rockville now, he didn’t have sub-vocal on his work badge. Real cops had that. Cops on LoPo 329 had that. Not him. He felt his hands going weak in their grip because he was scared. Why was he scared? He was Elton. He wasn’t a scared little pussy. He hit himself with the palm of his hand, hard. Pussy. Wake up, pussy.</p><p>When you hit people like that, with the palm of your hand, you could grab them afterwards, grab their hair and then smash them into walls. He had done that. He remembered doing that. He felt his grip coming back.</p><p>He got to the turn, the landing between the floors, and squatted down. At the turn he could see all the way through the door frame, into the sixth floor hallway. Chris’s apartment was to the left of the door frame, the elevators were to the right.</p><p>Elton couldn’t see anything. Elton went down two steps, still squatting. Still couldn’t see anything. Elton took another step. Froze. It was the Guy. He was down on one knee, in front of Chris’s door, his head turned away from the stairwell. Like he was was listening. To see if anybody was home.</p><p>The motherfucker.</p><p>Before he could yell at him Elton heard the elevator doors open, heard Toby’s deep voice talking.</p><p>“… didn’t he say what it was, or…?</p><p>A blur crossed the entranceway. Toby’s sentence ended in a wet choking sound and Stegman was yelling “Hey hey HEY NO NO” and Elton was down the steps and around the corner and Elton stood in the door frame, staring.</p><p>“Get… off… fucking…stop ……”</p><p>The Guy had Stegman by the throat, pressing him against the wall besides the elevator, his back was to Elton. Toby was lying on his side in the hallway, below the long horizontal windows, curled up in a ball.</p><p>Stegman was a big man, almost as tall as Elton, but he couldn’t get the Guy’s hand off his neck. Stegman was holding onto the Guy’s other hand, which held the pen thing. The pen thing was blinking. It was burning a black, thin line into the wall, a line that was moving slowly towards Stegman’s head.</p><p>Stegman was Red-faced. Choking. Elton was watching. Frozen. Frozen. Why wasn’t Elton helping?</p><p>The Guy was talking real quiet to Stegman, the only other sound in the hallway was the squeaking of Stegman’s shoes.</p><p>“…crushing your windpipe. See? I want you to look at the light. Look right at it. It’s going to be the last thing you see, meat.”</p><p>The black line burned into the wall. It was getting closer. Drawing an arrow, right towards Stegman’s eyes.</p><p>Elton’s grip on the flashlight was loose. Couldn’t make a fist. Couldn’t. Move.</p><p>Stegman slid down the wall, his legs were giving out. Just then laughter came from behind Elton, through the apartment door. Chris and Molly were playing in there, they had no idea what was happening. At the sound of boy’s laugh the Guy cocked his head to the side. The Guy chuckled a little bit. A satisfied little sound. Like he couldn’t wait until he was done with Stegman.</p><p>Elton felt the grip come back into his hands. Not Molly. Not Chris.</p><p>He rushed up behind the Guy and picked him up by the waist, real fast, swinging him up and away from Stegman. As he did it Stegman lunged at the laser thing and knocked it loose from the Guy’s hands.</p><p>Elton had planned on slamming him, hard, onto the ground. But it was like picking up a wild animal. The Guy was instantly thrashing and kicking, his back arching, making space between him and Elton. Elton kept his grip, took another step back, and felt his left heel brushing against something, against Toby’s body, and he almost fell and then WHUM.</p><p>The Guy’s right elbow had connected with Elton’s right temple. Sharp, dull pain and then WHUM this time on his left ear WHUM WHUM the Guy was twisting around, trying to face him screaming spitting thrashing and Elton couldn’t move his foot because of fucking Toby WHUM there below the window and he looked down and Elton saw the blood then, saw it WHUM pumping out of Toby’s neck like something in a show and WHUM and sometimes you need to WHUM use the Pit to work the Pit and Elton stepped over Toby, awkward almost falling lifting UP and sent the maniac headfirst into the open horizontal window, his thrashing head CLANGING into the top metal frame and then his arms and legs were kicking and slapping grabbing at the edges of the window as the Guy went through it, screaming “NO NO NO NO NO” and then nothing.</p><p>Elton swayed, blinking. He had smashed his cheekbone into the metal frame of the window. He heard a soft little whup from far below, the sound of a baseball hitting a mitt.</p><p>Then he was sitting on the floor, his back to the wall, the window still open above him. The window was normal. Just a normal window. His face was all wet. There was wheezing. Who was wheezing?</p><p>It was Stegman. He was sitting against the opposite wall, gasping, staring at Elton. Tears in his eyes. To his left, Toby was staring, too. But not at him. Elton could smell diarrhea. That was because Toby was dead.</p><p>Rockville was yelling something from Elton’s badge but it was lying somewhere and Elton didn’t care.</p><p>Then to his left he heard Chris’s door open. Molly stood there, horrified, looking from Stegman and Toby and then to him. At him her eyes went wide and she was about to scream but he waved at her quick, gave her the shhhh, made the thumbs up sign. Croaked out the words.</p><p>“I’m OK. There was a guy, he was trying to break in. Police are coming. Just close the door, just don’t let him see.”</p><p>She had nodded like she couldn’t breath and she was crying. As she closed the door he mouthed I love you and she saw it and mouthed it back.</p><p>Elton could hear the sound of helicopter drones approaching. He was going to have to get up and wave to them. Like in a scene at the end of a show, when things had all worked out.</p><p>He tried to make a fist, but he couldn’t anymore. His hand was shaking that much.</p><p>Pussy, he thought. Wake up, pussy.</p><p>He started to get up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c356612a3e0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Outlaw Economists]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@timothyschultz/the-outlaw-economists-a15dc1a07fe?source=rss-84d8bcc0982c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a15dc1a07fe</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[banking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heterodox-economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[william-black]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[finance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Timothy Schultz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Oct 2019 07:30:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-16T07:30:41.360Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/1*sq1jUeBbNolRaH-T-PXTOg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Reuters Image, 2009</figcaption></figure><h3>The rogues of the dismal science have been proven right by the economic crash. How much longer can mainstream neoclassical economics claim they are right?</h3><p>It was the kind of conference hall that made you sleepy, with sound-absorbing walls and lines of plush chairs. Dr. William Black wiggled the microphone free from the podium stand. An energetic bearded man who reminded me of William Dreyfuss in “Jaws”, he began walking the stage. He wanted to wake up his audience.</p><p>“Let me tell you all a story,” he said, “about my former nemesis.”</p><p>Professors of economics don’t usually have evil enemies. But Black, now an associate professor of economics at the University of Missouri-Kansas City, hasn’t always been a professor. In his former life as a leading bank regulator, he once did battle with one of the most destructive white-collar gangsters in American history. And won.</p><p>“Charles Keating,” Professor Black began, “loved to cheat little old ladies.” Black described how one of Keating’s frauds was to sell worthless junk bonds to elderly women who visited the “family friendly” branches of Lincoln Savings &amp; Loans. During Keating’s trial, one victim told the jury she’d bought the bonds in order to buy a special van for her handicapped daughter.</p><p>Black explained that these kinds of stories helped convict Keating, because they painted a vivid picture for the jurors. But only criminal investigations discover these kinds of stories. Inquiries? Stress tests? Accounting investigations? Today’s enforcement methods deal in book-keeping facts. Without criminal investigation, the stories are never told. And the criminals always go free.</p><p>It was here that Black smiled, and asked the audience a question: How many criminal investigations of major bank executives have taken place because of the Lehman crash, the biggest financial crisis in the history of the world? The answer: not a single one.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/220/1*4ze6gJNM8JeGc7aYx5vwRQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>William Black</figcaption></figure><p>In the religion of economics, Black is a heretic. He has no faith in the holy spirit of the Market. He puts no emphasis on the true word of the Math. His grand heresy is his published belief that CEOs and other financial leaders often use financial fraud to loot their own companies. Mainstream neoclassical economists saw his recommendations for stricter regulation as “unrigorous” because he justifies his hearsay with the tools of a criminologist: historical precedent, common sense and an understanding of human failings. Did he have a killer algorithm? A complex model where his theories were proven true? Black says he doesn’t need one. Instead he cites that little old lady’s van.</p><p>Black is not alone. He’s a leading voice among a small group of economists who believe modern economic science simply doesn’t understand the real world. Members of this loosely organized group call themselves, a little dramatically, the Heterodox. Many of these economists had predicted the financial crisis before it occurred, and are now calling for real reforms in order to avoid an even bigger crisis to come. Like Black they are ignored or belittled by most of their profession.</p><p>Yet now reality has issued a wake-up call. The financial crisis and ongoing recession has largely validated many of the Heterodox positions on fraud, deregulation and debt. Can the mainstream still refuse to publish, cite or listen to them? I went to Denver in 2009, one year after the biggest crash in modern financial history, to find out if the rouges of the dismal science were finally going to have their day.</p><p>Dr. Black was speaking on the first night of the American Economist Association’s annual convention, the biggest economics conference in the world. An hour before Black spoke, thousands of economists from all over the world were arriving at the Sheraton to collect their badges and schedules. I walked through the throng, taking in the economist vibe. The lobby vibrated with expensive eyewear and sensible laughter, healthy ivy leaguers greeting each other in complete, well-constructed sentences. The thin and the smart had arrived.</p><p>I have to admit: I had come to the conference with a bit of an attitude. I grew up in the `90&#39;s, when economists were depicted as the high priests of money. Alan Greenspan, Ben Bernake, Robert Rubin, these men weren’t politicians, they were <em>scientists</em>. At the time, who could argue against their work? My entire adolescence and early adulthood was a permanent boom time, where the smart magazines referred to the “end of instability” and credit was easy. In the early 2000’s, Oprah was the loan officer and everybody got a house.</p><p>And then, a year ago, everything unraveled. The high priests turned out to have wandering hands. Their science was more Venkman than Egon. After the Lehman Crash, the Queen of England said it best when she asked one of London’s leading economists: “How did no one see this coming?” His stammering response was that of an entire profession called to task. I had come to the conference expecting some of that penitence to be on display. The vibe in the lobby that night seemed to imply otherwise. These people had been humiliated, their science debunked. Why was everyone in such a goddamn good mood?</p><p>I walked to the nearby Marriott to attend the conference’s opening panel, presented by the Association For Social Economics, where Dr. Black was scheduled to speak. I had assumed that being on the first panel of the conference was a big deal, a triumphant “keynote” moment for Black. He’d written one of the most interesting books I’d ever read about banking regulation, “The Best Way to Rob a Bank is to Own One.” To me, this guy was a star.</p><p>But I was wrong. The conference hall was half-empty, the crowd different from the confident smarties swarming the bar at the Sheraton. I took a seat in front of a man with a goatee longer than his face. My old olfactory enemy from college, petuli oil, wafted through the air. As Dr. Black walked to the podium, I realized the people from the lobby? They weren’t coming. And if they didn’t want to listen to Dr. Black, who were they here to see?</p><p>The thin, good looking Professor wore a suit that was almost too nice for academia. His intelligence was scary, and he wasn’t afraid to talk smack.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*TZf5K0DbBVLilcJcm4DoXA.jpeg" /><figcaption>John Cochrane</figcaption></figure><p>“I mean, every now and then there’s an excluded sub-group that turns out to be right. Right?”</p><p>Meet Professor John Cochrane of the University of Chicago. Cochrane speaks proudly for the mainstream, also known as neoclassical economics. Talking with me over the phone before the conference, he made clear his condemnation was general. He didn’t want to make specific enemies, did he?</p><p>“I haven’t read their specific work. I’m busy, and I try to read what is considered interesting and valid.” Ouch. Burn. His position on the Heterodox was clear: they’re kooks.</p><p>“They are about two percent of academia and about zero percent of finance.” Another solid burn. But what about, you know… them being so right? About the giant crash? Professor Cochrane was totally dismissive of their prediction of the credit bubble collapse.</p><p>“Beware those who predict nine of the last two crashes, OK? They’re just not rigorous and don’t use modern mathematical tools. This business is a wide-open meritocracy. You have to distinguish between closed minds and a lack of quality. The perception is, is that this is 1969 stuff. Give me new data and new ideas.”</p><p>Before, during and after the conference, the word <em>rigorous</em> was something I heard from other mainstream economists when dismissing the Heterodox. But what does that mean? Rigorous usually means backed by solid scientific proof, like double-blind studies, first-hand accounts, measurements. You know. Proof.</p><p>Surprisingly, that’s not what mainstream economists actually mean. They use complex mathematical models to “test” their hypotheses, building elaborate “what if” scenarios with hundreds of variables interacting mathmatically with each other. These models simulate real world events. Once a theory is proven in such a simulation, then the theory is declared “rigorous”. If a theory is not “proven” in such a simulation, it’s “not rigorous”.</p><p>Hmmmmmmmmmm. (and yes, that’s sarcastic).</p><p>As Yves Smith describes in her hilarious novel, <em>E-Conned</em>, economists fell in love with such models in the 1970s. Instead of social scientists analyzing history, economists became mathematical soothsayers. Forget the past, because who needs to learn from that? It was much more exciting to predict outcomes using models. Want to know how a new rule would affect creditors when an airline goes bankrupt? Build a model of a bankruptcy and see how the rule affects it. Curious what impact a local Head Start program could have on property values? Build a model of an Alabama county and voila: the truth becomes clear.</p><p>Heterodox reject mathematical modeling as proof, pointing out that the assumptions of any simulation dictate the results. Instead, many Hetrodox use mathematical tools to analyze existing data, a practice much older (and mathematicaly simpler) than modeling. One might ask: what are some examples of this simpler, less, ahem, rigorous approach?</p><p>A famous Heterodox theory based on such analysis is Hyman Minsky’s Financial Instability Hypothesis, which observed in the 1970&#39;s that <em>financial markets are inherently unstable because of the staggering amounts of debt during bubbles.</em> If today’s regulators had used Minsky’s model to guide policy during the credit bubble, they would have anticipated the financial fraud that brought about the collapse. Instead, regulators and academics in the early 2000s built models that made such risk disappear.</p><p>According to Professor Cochrane, such “1969 stuff” isn’t interesting. Lehman brothers and the entire state of Florida might disagree.</p><p>After Black finished speaking, the crowd drifted back to the reception buffet. Gathered around the cheese and cold cuts, I learned that economists have opposing groups, organized around almost every issue.</p><p>The ASE is a Heterodox group that believes economics should be used to promote social equality. If you think social concerns have no place in scientific inquiry (like most mainstream economists) you can join the Neoclassicists. Not a fan of war? There’s the Economists for Peace and Security. Think of war as a great way to stop unemployment? Almost any mainstream group is happy to have you. When I asked him if there were any mainstream economists at this talk, Professor Black laughed. He explained that most panels at the conferences were organized and attended only by people in their own groups. Instead of four days of debate or discussion, conferences had become institutional echo chambers. The only time you might meet somebody who you disagree with is on the airport shuttle.</p><p>I was on my second drink ticket when I met Kallen, who provided a different reason why people might not want to attend Heterodox panels: him. Under 40, his goatee long but not yet gray, he had the well-fed look of a coffeeshop manager who gets high before work. He explained he was presenting a paper advocating slavery reparations to African Americans. I asked if he was using any mathematics in his paper. He scoffed. The guy standing next to him nodded with approval. Math apparently was a bummer.</p><p>As I wandered from group to group, I heard discussions about community farming co-ops in Philadelphia and the merits of the German model of union participation and a rambling diatribe about “the collapse of the capitalist model.” From across the room, Black motioned that he was leaving. I quickly followed him out, a little disillusioned. His writing on financial fraud and deregulation had brought the Heterodox to my attention. He offered real-world, common-sense solutions for industry and government in a time of ongoing crisis. Yet it seemed the only people listening to him were… these guys. And they were the ones who could do the least.</p><p>The next day I went back to the other side. At a panel titled, “Financial Crisis — Implications,” over 400 people filled every chair in the room, with the front row taken up by reporters from the <em>Financial Times</em> and the <em>Wall Street Journal</em>. Apparently I wasn’t the only person desperately hoping that these men had a plan to fix everything. Of course, I didn’t see anyone from Professor Black’s panel. The goatee-to-tie ratio was a non-statistical element.</p><p>The panel featured prominent economists from prestigious institutions. Instead of disagreeing with one another, they all seemed to be competing to make the same point in slightly different ways: that the major banks had become “dangerously big” after the financial crisis. Five years ago most of these guys had been cheerleaders for deregulation. Now they had ditched their pom-poms for warning bells.</p><p>“We have not conquered risk. We need more fear,” pronounced Myron Scholes.</p><p>“We need light regulation across the board. But we are not demonizing finance” said Ragu Raghuram.</p><p>“We need to regulate how bankruptcy unwinds derivatives… but derivatives are still a good thing!” said an enthusiastic John Cochrane.</p><p>One of them — an economist from MIT — dared use the word <em>financialization</em>. He asked a rhetorical question: “Why should finance be earning 40 percent of our GDP? What are the social gains?”</p><p>When he said this, the other members nodded their heads and said nothing. Apparently it was easier to view it as a rhetorical question. Especially when their think tanks and university departments often survived off the donations of big banks or bankers.</p><p>After the panel ended, most of the panel members were hustled from the stage for interviews and the next panel. The MIT economist stayed behind, taking time to talk with audience members who approached him. I asked him if mainstream economics was becoming more like Heterodox economics. He glanced down at my media badge and looked me in the eye a little defensively. He quoted John Maynard Keynes, one of the patron saint of mainstream economic science.</p><p>“Keynes said, ‘When the facts change, my opinion changes. How about yours?” He shrugged, clearly wanting to end the conversation. “Last year, the facts changed.”</p><p>He walked away quickly after giving me his card.</p><p>Mainstream economics’ fear and loathing of government regulation is based on two cornerstone assumptions: that people are always rational and that people always act in their own interests. Therefore, any marketplace is a self-correcting entity, made up of informed sellers and buyers whose competition and self-interest enforce fairness and create total efficiency. These assumptions also allow human beings to be easily modeled mathematically.</p><p>Heterodox economists think these two assumptions are hooey. To them, humans are social creatures who often fail at self-promotion because of things like stupidity, culture or niceness. Markets are therefore fundamentally destabilizing, inefficiently lurching toward monopoly, bubble or crash, desperate for the mitigating force of government or other institutions. With their focus on poverty and acknowledgement of class, the Heterodox are also the intellectual grandchildren of Marx. Perhaps that’s why the family tree includes so many goatees.</p><p>Even with the ghost of old Karl haunting about, it seems obvious which world view is more accurate: How many perfectly selfish, utterly rational people do you know? And if you did know them, would you really expect them to follow the law if it was rarely enforced?</p><p>The next panel I attended was also about the financial crisis. But this one was organized by a Heterodox group, with Black acting as moderator. Instead of a packed conference hall filled with press passes, this panel resembled an AA meeting, with fewer than 15 people present. I arrived to find a longhaired Australian professor in his 50s wearing a tracksuit presenting his paper. Instead of statistics, he was quoting Thorsten Veblen, who invented the term “conspicuous consumption.” The Australian’s thesis? Since financial traders liked to show off their money, they take more risk. Wow, bro: big insight. No wonder the Wall Street Journal wasn’t covering this talk.</p><p>But after Professor Tracksuit sat down, the panel got better. I heard a presentation delivered by the only African American person I heard speak at the conference, a young, straight-talking Ph.D student. Her area of study was the poor, which was also a principle of Hetrodox economics. Her paper was about mortgage defaults in one of poorest parts of Mississippi. Amazingly, she had established that the chance of default increased with the proximity to a payday lender. This wasn’t proven only by a mathmatical model, it was detective work hard facts. It was also incredibly compelling: if proximity to Payday Lenders put communities at danger, that’s valuable information for city governments. Isn’t it?</p><p>Afterwards she laughed when I asked if anyone had challenged her findings. “Nobody has ever bothered to study these communities,” she said. “Which means nobody can disagree with me.”</p><p>After her, a Spanish professor illustrated a second principle of Heterodox thought — using existing data instead of creating theoretical data. She had analyzed payroll data to show how the financial crisis has increased the pay of specific racial groups within finance (turns out Hispanic women were big winners; Black men not so much).</p><p>Finally, as the moderator, William Black spoke. He stood and leaned against a folding table.</p><p>“Why are we having more and more extreme crises? Why do we call it a ‘sub-prime’ crisis, when it was liar’s loans that caused the problem? All institutions during this time classified liar’s loans as “prime”. Why? They wanted to issue them so badly, 49 percent of 2007 loan originations were liar’s loans. Why would any institution do this? Because it wasn’t risk. It was fraud.”</p><p>He then advised those presenting their papers on this crisis to examine the role of fraud. For traders influenced by conspicuous consumption, was their behavior truly risk-taking, with the fear of losing? Or were they gambling without fear, dishonestly inflating the short-term results to increase their bonuses? Were the racial groups not promoted during the crisis more culturally resistant to fraudulent activities and therefore less likely to succeed? For the payday lenders in Mississippi, how many were subsidiaries of major banks, or tied to sub prime lenders? Black was demonstrating the most relevant principle of the Heterodox today — the belief that modern finance is a culture of institutional fraud that can be corrected only through criminal prosecution.</p><p>To say fraud is a blind spot within mainstream economics would be an understatement. Dr. Black explained: all fraud is not a rational action, because getting caught is too large a price to pay for the gains. Even worse, a CEO that loots his own financial institution, like Keeting (or perhaps Jamie Dimon or Ken Lewis), actively distorts the metrics of his institution’s success. Bigger growth, loan volume, etc allows them to receive personal bonuses. From false reporting to directing entire institutions to break the law, leaders benefit from fraud all the time.</p><p>Mainstream economists don’t study this kind of fraud because it is very hard to model and shatters the illusion of market correction. In the 200 page schedule that listed every panel and event at the conference, the word <em>fraud</em> was mentioned only twice — both at panels when Black was speaking. After the Lehman crash, which was driven by perverse incentives within banks, that kind of oversight doesn’t seem like blindness. That seems like willful exclusion.</p><p>Professor Randal Wray is the provocateur of the Heterodox group. Skinny and red-haired, Dr. Wray is Black’s younger, feistier colleague at UM-KC, appearing as the Heterodox voice at panels and conferences around the world. Unlike Black, who became a professor after being a regulator, Wray chose his path as a graduate student. I asked him why.</p><p>“Neoclassical economics doesn’t make sense when you first learn about it,” he says. “But it makes even less sense the more you study it and try to use its tools. I was lucky to have been taught by a man who was one of the original dissenters.”</p><p>Wray’s mentor was the aforementioned Professor Minsky, who had made it his life’s work to disprove the Efficient Market Hypothesis. Minsky was ignored for 20 years, working without tenure when he first taught Wray.</p><p>“When I first met him, he was pretty depressed. He shuffled into our classroom, all hunched over, wild gray hair. The first thing he said was, ‘What I want is the last person who comes into the classroom to always close the door. I don’t want anyone to know what goes on in here.’”</p><p>Professor Wray continued, describing his mentor’s path. “He had been predicting instability and crisis starting in the 1950s and nobody listened. The entire science of economics had become an argument to leave markets alone, that regulation was only getting in the way. By the mid-1960s he could no longer publish in the top journals. There was a period of 20 years when he considered himself a total failure. Then, in the 1980s, he suddenly became popular again because of the S&amp;L crisis. People were desperate to understand what had happened, so they dug up his old papers and started citing him again. This happened while I was his student. It was great to see him finally vindicated, if only briefly.”</p><p>I asked him what being a Heterodox economist meant today. Wray shook his head. “It still means you will never be published. You’ll probably never teach graduate students. I was lucky because I got into UM-KC, which is one of the only programs in the country that supports Heterodox thought.” I asked if he ever hoped to have an influence on government regulation or monetary policy. Wray laughed.</p><p>“The neoclassical guys already have their answer to the crash —they say it was caused by <em>too much</em> government regulation!”</p><p>If it was such a hopeless cause, why fight the battle? Isn’t there a middle ground? Wray grinned.</p><p>“The first conference I ever attended, I saw on the schedule there was a panel on suicide. I went to see what it could be about. Here was their thesis: Suicide must be a rational behavior. The conclusion was that suicidal people have a very high rate of something called a ‘time discount,’ which means they are able to delay gratification for a future reward. The presenter said — and I’m not making this up — that those who commit suicide enjoy flying through the air so much, that the three seconds of flight offset the rewards that would have come during the years remaining in their lives.”</p><p>Wray laughed. “They presented this with a straight face, with mathematical models that proved their thesis. And people applauded.”</p><p>He stopped laughing. “So follow the same logic into finance: borrowers never lie. Markets set the perfect interest rate. And so on.”</p><p>“This mass delusion allows for mass fraud. Because the so-called true believers are also careful to flee the markets they claim are so efficient before these markets crash. Their superiority and sophistication is part of the efficiency. Everyone in finance and academia knows the macro model of today is really just pump and dump on a grand scale. The orthodox approach says you can always sell. But only the sophisticated players know when to sell. Everyone else — lower wage workers, government, pensions, our families — are the ones who pay.”</p><p>There was no middle ground. To Wray, it didn’t matter that in 20 years it could be him shuffling into that classroom. He would continue to fight. His life mission was to stop economics from being the science of the bubble.</p><p>That night I wandered around, between the receptions and social events in the hotels. Most economists look like the perfect dinner guest, who ones who speak in complete sentences and don’t offend anyone. I thought it would be easy to get these talkative people to talk to me. But I made a mistake. I kept using the word, <em>heterodox</em>.</p><p>I spoke with three good-looking young guys as they walked between hotels. They were in their early 30s, friends from their grad program, walking briskly in their standard-issue long black overcoats. The blond one was the leader. Harvard had given him the air of aggressive, instant appraisal. A journalist? He didn’t want to talk to me. I walked with them anyway.</p><p>When I asked them if they were Heterodox economists, they all laughed.</p><p>“Those guys are kind of weird. We don’t have any teaching in our department,” said the friendly Asian one. Did they ever read anything written by Heterodox economists? Before he could answer, the blond decided to walk faster and ignore me. The three of them walked on, the Asian waving apologetically.</p><p>This pattern of conversation was repeated with different groups throughout the hotels: the young Russian American guys, who worked in government, who thought the Heterodox were “complaining about the way things naturally are.” The two Canadian women who weren’t sure if Heterodox economists were “relevant.” The drunk 60-year-old in the tuxedo, who laughed and called Heterodox economists “journalists, not economists.” I was ready for people to start spitting on the ground and making the sign of the <em>malocchio</em>. It was that bad.</p><p>Later that night, I found myself with Nils, who was closer to what I had hoped economists to be: a curious intellectual who used statistics and an understanding of commerce to solve problems. We were at the hotel bar, ordering our final drinks, when he got thoughtful.</p><p>“What is a Heterodox and what is an orthodox?” he asked. “These terms do not really mean so much. I have done papers statistically proving racial bias, which is quite a Heterodox inquiry. But I used conventional neoclassical methods and mathematical formulas to prove it. Does that make me a Heterodox guy? Who cares, right?”</p><p>I brought up how Heterodox economists define themselves by renouncing rationality or market efficiency. Nils laughed, waving such big ideas away.</p><p>“That is stuff you discuss at, like, three in the morning, back at your dorm. It’s too big or philosophical; it is not part of day-to-day inquiries. How efficient are markets? I don’t know. But my inquiries, that sometimes use those models or assumptions, those are still valid. Neoclassical mathematics have given me too many great tools to say otherwise.”</p><p>His agnostic approach was one of the most hopeful things I heard at the conference. It also underlined one of the Heterodox’s biggest, self-imposed weaknesses. By refusing to acknowledge mathematical modeling as valid, many Heterodox economists were missing tools that could help quantify their own theories or ideas. More vigorous mathematics would also perhaps raise the bar a bit to keep some of the undesirables out of the party, like my Australian homeboy in the tracksuit.</p><p>William Black had explained how the mainstream’s blindness to fraud had helped create the recession. James Galbraith told me something positive: such a blind spot wouldn’t last much longer. But not for the reasons you might hope.</p><p>Professor Galbraith is a big, bearded, serious-looking man. One of the leading Heterodox economists of his generation, his recent book, “The Predator State” describes how wealthy individuals and corporations have taken control of government institutions in order to enrich themselves. Sitting in the fading light, his hotel room growing darker around him, he tried to summarize 40 years of work in opposition to the mainstream.</p><p>“The history of neoclassical economics is one of a long retreat from indefensible positions. Different economists — call them Heterodox if you like, although I don’t personally like that term — have sat at the fringe, disagreeing with the entire neoclassical premise of equilibrium and rationality. Every ten or so years the mainstream will acknowledge their mistake on a certain “issue of the day” and work very hard to contain the damage. They don’t want their acknowledgement to contradict their fundamentals. This isn’t good — it would be better if they admitted they keep making mistakes because their underlying assumptions are wrong — but it does mean that they can adjust.”</p><p>Galbraith then listed some examples of the mainstream co-opting Hetrodox opinion. “In the 1970s, they mostly abandoned the belief in rational expectations, changing their mathematical models. In the 1980s, it was the disproven belief of a “natural level of unemployment”. In the 1990s the “law and economics” movement argued that laws or enforcement were not as efficient as markets in punishing wrongdoing, a concept now totally disproven”.</p><p>I asked him what was next. Could it be fraud? Could the mainstream (and therefore our government institutions) admit that fraud was necessary in understanding modern finance?</p><p>“The next big mea culpa could be their acknowledgement of the much bigger role of fraud in finance. But there are so many things that this crisis has highlighted that contradict their point of view it is hard to predict which one they will be forced to acknowledge.”</p><p>I thought of the panel I had attended earlier in the conference, where the neoclassical stars were so fearful of the megabanks their policies had helped create. Galbraith sighed in the dim light.</p><p>“They never cite our writings in their papers or lectures. They “discover” something we’ve been saying for years because they finally build a mathematical model that supports it. That’s how they control the conversation and maintain their control on their academic and policy institutions. When we say it, we’re ‘not being rigorous’ or we are ‘politically biased’ or whatever. Only when they say it does it become true.”</p><p>One of the last panels I attended featured actual regulators from the Bank of England and the Bank of Korea, sharp non-academics who described their attempts to understand and regulate financial markets. The fear of the big banks was here, too, but in much starker terms: One speaker presented different methods of how the Korean government might insure an institution with debt the size of Korea’s GDP.</p><p>It all seemed too little, too late. From their positions at the heads of the IMF, the U.S. Treasury and the Federal Reserve, a generation of mainstream economists had created a fragile, crash-prone system of finance. No one onstage mentioned the words <em>fraud</em> or <em>prosecution</em> or <em>criminal investigations</em>. If huge players control everything through the threat of their own collapse, isn’t it time for new ideas?</p><p>The day before I had asked Professor Black if he had ever wanted to be a regulator again. His quiet answer didn’t surprise me.</p><p>“Yeah. There are a bunch of folks just like me. We are all in our prime ages now.” He laughed, eyes glinting.</p><p>“We were kids before, making it up as we went, pretty successfully, but still. Now, we have the benefit of hindsight, we’ve studied all this stuff and have the benefit of all these life experiences. This year? After what happened? Why wouldn’t the regulators or congress want someone who had experience successfully responding to a crisis involving massive fraud, deregulation and de-supervision?”</p><p>It was then that Dr. Black told me something very depressing. In 2007, Dr. Black had been approached by the Obama campaign, which were creating a documentary about the Keating Five. Back in the 80’s , John McCain had been in the pocket of Charles Keating’s Lincoln S&amp;L. Obama’s campaign saw an opportunity. Dr. Black told the story with a smile.</p><p>“Oh, they came to the house and interviewed me. Told me they were really interested in real financial regulation. Told me they’d be in touch, once they won.”</p><p>He shook his head. They hadn’t.</p><p>Sadly, it seems obvious why. Dr. Black is famous to historians of the S&amp;L crisis. But he is famous for the wrong reasons. The people he would put in jail today are the ones controlling the candidates, the banks and the regulators. There was a reason why criminal prosecutions didn’t happen anymore. Laws are now incentives, their punishments qualified in dollars. Such simple numbers are much easier to model than the fear of handcuffs… or lack thereof.</p><p>I had come to the conference hoping to see a thriving resistance movement. The world was in crisis. The science had been debunked. There would be urgency and questioning and new directions found. I had imagined the Heterodox engaging and challenging the rest of their profession, with policy wonks being asked hard questions and professors renouncing their past positions.</p><p>Instead I had seen a conference almost entirely free of dialogue, with each side segmented away from the other. In their own separate receptions, panels and dinners, each side congratulated the other on a fine year. The big stars of Yale and Chicago puzzled calmly over the chaos their mathematical models had helped create. Down the hall the Heterodox shook their fists and pulled on their goatees. How long until the ones with the math and the influence started listening to the ones with the history and the real-world ideas?</p><p>In the busy lobby of the Sheraton on the last day, the departing crowd of economists had spilled out onto the sidewalk of the Denver Promenade. They stood in clusters of long black city coats, laughing and talking, saying their goodbyes.</p><p>Every once in a while, the crowd would part for the everyday residents of Denver to pass . A young Hispanic family walked through, the burly father in a Bronco`s jacket, his kids holding his hand. His wife glanced around, uncomfortable: who were all these rich white people?</p><p>After them a homeless man in his 50’s walked through. Had the industry which had once employed him been reorganized because of structured debt? Had his unemployment benefits been cut because of a mathematical model? Was his rationality sufficient? Did his self-interest compute?</p><p>The man paused amid the hubbub and peered into the crowded lobby, the way homeless men will do. The laughing and the talking continued in the cold Denver air.</p><p>To the economists around him, he was invisible.</p><p><em>Denver, 2009</em></p><p>Originally published by Playboy Magazine</p><p>Copyright 2019. All rights reserved.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a15dc1a07fe" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Lost Fight Song Of The Washington Capitals]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@timothyschultz/the-lost-fight-song-of-the-washington-capitals-c4ec389f6641?source=rss-84d8bcc0982c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c4ec389f6641</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nhl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[washington-capitals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[washington-dc]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Timothy Schultz]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 Jun 2018 12:00:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-02T03:31:39.258Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>An open letter to the Washington Post Sports Writer Barry Svluga</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/446/1*6IPAqgETw9H6x4g-7kaLCA.png" /></figure><p><em>“The Capitals are playing a heckuva hockey game<br>And all around the country, they’re starting to know our name…”</em></p><p>Mr. Svluga, I’ve got a story for you. It’s the story of the greatest fight song ever written. With the Capitals about to finally win the Cup, this year could be the time to finally tell it. Or at least to sing it one more time.</p><p>I’m the second-oldest child in a family of six children who grew up watching the Caps during the Rod Langway years. My dad was a season ticket holder, and attending hockey games were part of our family.</p><p>My Dad was a busy lawyer who had more kids, worries, and bills than most people should. When he came home after dinner, his many children would hide near the door. When it opened they would gleefully swarm him, screaming “Knock Daddy Down!”. He would pretend to be surprised, and then not pretend to collapse under our weight. We were a chaotic family of three boys and eventually three girls, but a loving one.</p><p>Those two hockey tickets were the only time we got to spend with our Dad alone. Every four or five games it was our turn to be the lucky one. Each detail was colored by being alone with him: how he talked softly in the car as the AM announcers set up the game; how he joked with us when we stood in line for popcorn; how he held our hand when we walked down the steep Capital Center stairs, towards the seats we knew by heart.</p><p>He and his best friend, the Honorable Judge Jeff Alprin, had ordered their season ticket seats side-by-side, and held them for twenty years. Their friendship was part of the ritual. Listening to them curse out the referees, praise Dino Cicerelli and hate the Flyers was an ongoing lesson on how to be a friend. We were watching them as much as we were watching the game.</p><p>The season tickets were cheap back then for a reason: the Capitals were simply torturous to love. Judge Alprin’s screeching calls of, “YOU BUM” were often directed not at the opposing team but at our own. One season, a nice lady down the row from us screamed terrible things at a player named Murphy <em>every single time</em> he touched the puck. I grew up thinking it was normal to heckle your own team.</p><p>Why the pathos? In the second round of playoffs, they would pull ahead in the series. The crowds would swell in number. The cheaper, plate-metal corner seats would be taken over by rowdy fans, who would would turn the entire seating area into a massive steel drum, STAMPING down in unison as they chanted. And then, on that fateful game 3 or 4… nothing. The team we’d started trusting would transform. Daredevil skaters became bumbling nincompoops. Judge Alprin would shake his head. My dad would switch off the AM radio on the way home. And six disappointed kids would have to wait until next winter to have our nights with Dad again.</p><p>It was during one of these “they just might do it” seasons that Dad wrote The Song.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*5ouyCqioo4Z0mByA9NgWUA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>“We’re trying hard and winning<br>and we will not give up,</em></p><p><em>until we get our hands on the coveted Stanley Cup”</em></p><p>That year, Abe Polin, bless his franchise-mismanaging soul, had decided the Capitals needed a Song. He went on the radio and announced it, right before the playoffs: send in your song, fans. At least, that’s how I remember it. There might have been a slick, well-produced PR campaign. But considering the state of the Capitals back then, they’d probably burned the PR budget on bail money.</p><p>There was a detail about my Dad that few knew: my Dad was a songbird. A hummer of tunes. A maker of little ditties. Each of his kids had at least one song written for us. Tender songs he wrote while he was feeding us bottles at six in the morning, or ribbing songs he sang to “take us down a peg or two”. So when my nine-year-old twin brother and I heard about this song contest one morning over breakfast, we knew what was going to happen: Dad was going to write a song.</p><p>That evening, our prediction proved correct.</p><p>He came home that night in a bit of a tizzy. After we had knocked him down and climbed all over him, he went straight to my mom. Had she heard about the song drive? (yes) He had a song! (of course he did) And he wanted us all to sing it, so he could mail it in to Abe Polin and win a whole year of seasons tickets.</p><p>I don’t remember my mom’s reaction, but I can guess it: a patient smile and a reminder that it was already very late. As a parent now myself, my heart goes out to my mother. Bedtime was probably very special for her. I can only imagine her relief when we all finally lay down somewhere and stopped moving.</p><p>I found out later that the tune of the song was not entirely unique. It was a slight alteration of the old Ripon College fight song, which my Dad had spent four years singing in Wisconsin winters. Its masculine, marching vigor had a particular power over a nine-year-old boy. The first time we heard it, my Dad was singing the song as he ran around the house looking for the tape recorder. As we tramped after him, his deep baritone belted out the lyrics. Soon we were all singing along, too.</p><p>The song is… special. Well, I may be biased. I may be over-selling it a tiny little bit. But from the moment we heard it, we loved it.</p><p>I mean we LOVED it.</p><p>The song packs an old-fashioned, Vikings-meet-the Ivy League, army barracks oomph. One of the reasons we loved it was that it wasn’t all positive. (how could it be, it was about the Caps?) My father had added a sense of pathos. The song starts out strong and hearty, as a proper fight song should. But then it takes a turn. It describes the Capital’s terrible condition. It acknowledges the humiliation. And then, in the final chorus, it announces that now, NOW we will have our revenge.</p><p>That night, we gathered around the old-fashioned tape recorder (built-in handle, giant buttons). He pressed the “record” and “play” buttons at the same time and looked up. Four children in their pajamas, a 41 year old lawyer and a very tired mom began to sing:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*km5EplB5QT4XZ9jyiZNzjQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>The Capitals are playing a heckuva hockey game,</em></p><p><em>And all around the country, they’re starting to know our name…</em></p><p>As we fell asleep that night, we were certain: of course we would win! And then THREE OF US could go to the games with Dad, because we’d have TWO EXTRA SEASON TICKETS. But old Abe must not have listened to every cassette tape he got. In fact, the Capitals or the sports pages never mentioned the song drive again. As the weeks went by, we were outraged. Our father had been ignored! Our family’s genius had not been recognized! How could they not have used it?</p><p>Next season came the insult: at the first game, a slick, rock-anthem song started playing when the Caps took the ice. Surprise, fans! Introducing OUR NEW SONG. I still remember the chirpy chorus:</p><p><em>Ice-breakers! Goal Shakers! The Caps!</em></p><p><em>oooooooooooooooooooo </em><strong><em>Goalshakers! The Caps!</em></strong></p><p>That “oooo”. It was like the singer was doing jazz hands. My twin brother and I were disgusted. Our little brother’s face looked so confused. This was the song? Which fan had sent this in? Was this what they had wanted? A song like that? Our father’s song wasn’t a mere jingle. It was meant for the crowd itself.<em> It was a song not to be sung, but to be bellowed.</em></p><p>Today, I still agree with my pajama-wearing child-self: it’s the greatest fight song ever written, at least for a national hockey team. Unfortunately, fight songs aren’t what American sports franchises want anymore. Today, if you turn off the rock anthems and the constant commercial messages, most American sports stadiums would be as quiet as churches. It was only years later, when I attended a World Cup match in Europe, that I heard other songs like my father’s song. The songs filling the Europeans stadiums songs weren’t coming out of speakers. They were coming from the fans themselves.</p><p>After that year the we all grew up, one Capitals season at a time. Instead of belonging to the Capitals, our father’s song belonged to us. Over the years we sang it at the dinner table or on long car rides. It became a kind of anthem for our very large family, a family so large that we had to use a commercial van instead of regular cars, a family so loud restaurants feared us, a family so fun friends loved sleeping over. We stopped singing it the year I finished high school and my Dad stopped going to games. Because that year Mom was sick and Dad was taking care of her and hockey wasn’t going to make things better anymore.</p><p>Eventually the Capitals grew up, too. They got a new owner, a “better” stadium, a bigger budget. My adult siblings who still lived in Maryland didn’t like it. Now you don’t drive out into the woods to see them, you took the metro. The new arena? Too damn bright in there. A large popcorn? Eleven dollars, please. At games nobody screams “YOU BUM” at the top of their quivering lungs, nobody stamps on metal corner bleachers. But in one important detail, the Caps were still the Caps: they were still breaking our hearts. They might have more money, they might even be better. But they’d still blow it, every single time.</p><p>This year could be the eve of their redemption. To celebrate, I offer you our song, Barry Svluga. I offer it to you, and to all the people who have ever loved the Capitals, for whatever reason they ever did. Because this year, this series, this week, my Dad’s defiant lyrics might finally come true.</p><p>So c’mon, you bums. Sing it with me:</p><p><em>The Capitals are playing a heckuva hockey game<br>And all around the country, they’re starting to know our name!<br>We’re trying hard and winning<br>and we will not give up<br>until we get our hands on the coveted Stanley Cup.</em></p><p><em>Now around the league<br>They used to laugh<br>When ‘ere we took the ice.<br>And brother, we can tell you, that this wasn’t very nice<br>And so we say… to all of them… you better watch your head…<br>Or…we’ll… give you such a body check<br>We’ll send you right to bed! HEY!</em></p><p><em>The Capitals are playing a heckuva hockey game<br>And all around the country, they’re starting to know our name!<br>We’re trying hard and winning<br>and we will not give up<br>until we get our hands on the coveted Stanley Cup!</em></p><p>NOTE: To hear the song, click <a href="https://soundcloud.com/newhowl/caps-fight-song-by-daniel-schultz-my-dad">here</a>. (Sung by me as I walk down the street in Tokyo twenty years later, thinking of my Dad.)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c4ec389f6641" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>