<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ágoston Török on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ágoston Török on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@torokagoston?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 22:19:40 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@torokagoston/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[FIFA’s $13 Billion Tightrope]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/fifas-13-billion-tightrope-87d990801243?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/87d990801243</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[data-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fifa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ágoston Török]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Jul 2026 13:36:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-20T13:36:43.702Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How the world’s most powerful sports organization funds 110 developing-nation football associations, concentrates 68% of revenue in 39 days, and structures itself so its own leadership cannot be held accountable — and why those three facts are the same story</h4><p>Iran’s World Cup team competes on American soil while US aircraft strike their homeland. A red card is overturned after a presidential phone call. Tickets cost $11,000 while staff from participating nations cannot get visas. At the same time, FIFA’s Forward program has funded <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/advancing-football/fifa-forward/fifa-forward-report">94 pitches in Africa</a>, delivered <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/advancing-football/fifa-forward/fifa-forward-report">144 infrastructure projects</a> across the developing world, and keeps <a href="https://web.fifaclearinghouse.org/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials/2025-financial-statements/notes/8-development-and-education">110 member associations</a> solvent — many of which would otherwise have no functioning football ecosystem at all. These are not opposite facts. They are outputs of the same revenue engine, and the article’s argument is built around the tension this creates, not around pretending it does not exist.</p><p>The most powerful sports organization in history operates on a single <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/tournament-organisation/commercial/fifa-tv/media-releases/china-media-group-official-broadcaster-world-cup-2026-2030">39-day revenue engine</a> that generates <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">68% of its $13 billion cycle</a>, a patronage machine that converts financial dependency into political loyalty, a legal edifice being dismantled by <a href="https://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2024-10/cp240172en.pdf">three European court rulings</a> it cannot appeal, and a technology strategy that outsourced its only direct fan relationship to a single streaming partner. Each vulnerability is manageable alone. Together they form a convergence that no single election can fix — and that the man who keeps winning those elections has no incentive to address. The question that runs through every chapter is whether the development funding that 110 associations depend on can survive the system that produced it — or whether the system is the price of the funding.</p><h3>How Iran at the 2026 World Cup Exposes Everything</h3><p>Iran’s national team stands for their anthem at a US stadium while the two countries are at <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Iran_war">war</a>. Their training base was relocated to Mexico. Their ticket allocation was revoked. Their staff were denied visas. Yet they play on, because withdrawing from the World Cup would cost more than staying at home.</p><p>The mechanism of that cost is instructive. Iran’s federation receives approximately <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/advancing-football/fifa-forward/fifa-forward-report">$8–10 million per cycle</a> through FIFA’s Forward development program — roughly half of its annual operating budget. Withdrawal would forfeit not just the tournament revenue share but the patronage pipeline that keeps the federation afloat. FIFA’s response to the crisis — “we cannot control visa decisions,” a statement issued without attribution by a Zurich communications officer who does not speak Farsi — is technically true and strategically revealing. The US State Department controls visa issuance. But FIFA chose the host knowing the geopolitical landscape; it signed the hosting agreement knowing the diplomatic assumptions baked in; it collected the <a href="https://apnews.com/article/world-cup-draw-kennedy-center-payment-trump-af64d2123ad9c021da699edc21255304">$2.4 million Kennedy Center “donation”</a> from the Trump administration while negotiating the draw venue. The organization that claims political neutrality has entangled itself with a host government so deeply that it cannot protect a participating nation’s basic operational access.</p><p>The $11,000 final tickets while that same nation’s staff cannot enter the country is not hypocrisy. It is the business model operating at full capacity: revenue extraction optimized to the point where the thing being extracted — the game itself — becomes an afterthought. The Iran situation is not an anomaly. It is the logical endpoint of a governance model <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/about-fifa">120 years in the making</a>.</p><h3>From 24 Francs to $13 Billion: The 120-Year Hustle</h3><p>To understand how a governance model produces outcomes like Iran in 2026, start at the beginning. FIFA was founded <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/about-fifa">in a Paris sports union office on 21 May 1904</a>, with <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/about-fifa">seven European members</a> and no money. For <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/about-fifa">70 years</a> it was a scheduling committee. Then came Joao Havelange in <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/about-fifa">1974</a>.</p><p>Havelange saw what the European establishment did not: that the developing world’s football passion was convertible into political power and, through that power, into revenue. He brokered a Coca-Cola sponsorship through Horst Dassler — the Adidas patriarch who effectively controlled global football sponsorship for two decades — and turned $24 in the bank into a multibillion-dollar enterprise by <a href="https://www.fifa.com/about-fifa">1998</a>. The mechanism was not simple. It was a three-circuit machine. Circuit one: World Cup broadcast and sponsorship revenue flowed into Zurich. Circuit two: Zurich distributed that money to African, Asian, and Caribbean associations via development programs, infrastructure grants, and per diems. Circuit three: those associations delivered bloc votes for Havelange’s re-elections, hosting approvals, and institutional legitimacy. The money circled from the global commercial market through Zurich, out to the member associations, and back as political capital. Patronage was not a side effect of governance. It was governance.</p><p>Sepp Blatter, Havelange’s lieutenant for <a href="https://www.fifa.com/about-fifa">17 years</a>, scaled the same machine. He expanded the World Cup from <a href="https://www.fifa.com/">24 to 32 teams</a>, added tournament inventory, and presided over explosive revenue growth. The corruption that followed was not a deviation from the model — it was the model operating without guardrails. The <a href="https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/nine-fifa-officials-and-five-corporate-executives-indicted-racketeering-conspiracy-and">2015 US Department of Justice indictments</a> documented <a href="https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/nine-fifa-officials-and-five-corporate-executives-indicted-racketeering-conspiracy-and">well over $150 million in bribes over 24 years</a>. The pattern was not sophisticated: bribes for World Cup broadcast rights, bribes for marketing contracts, bribes for hosting votes. When the FBI raided the <a href="https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/nine-fifa-officials-and-five-corporate-executives-indicted-racketeering-conspiracy-and">Baur au Lac hotel</a> in Zurich and arrested <a href="https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/nine-fifa-officials-and-five-corporate-executives-indicted-racketeering-conspiracy-and">seven FIFA officials</a>, the organization’s response was threefold: blame individuals, promise reforms, and… preserve the structural machinery that enabled the abuses. The <a href="https://publications.fifa.com/en/vision-report-2021/the-journey/the-journey-2016/">2016 Carrard reforms</a> — term limits, independent ethics committee, transparency requirements — looked comprehensive on paper.</p><p>They began unravelling within <a href="https://apnews.com/article/fifa-statutes-committes-infantino-2f724ef9e023493acf772c6b66cae5f8">18 months</a>. Standing committees expanded from <a href="https://apnews.com/article/fifa-statutes-committes-infantino-2f724ef9e023493acf772c6b66cae5f8">7 back to 35</a>. The independent ethics committee was hollowed out, its investigative powers transferred to a body appointed by the same Council it was meant to police. Term limits were reinterpreted to allow <a href="https://www.newsday.com/sports/soccer/fifa-statutes-committes-infantino-c12532">15 years</a>. Every reform was absorbed and neutralized by the patronage imperative.</p><p>The contrast with the International Olympic Committee is instructive. The IOC faced its own existential crisis after the Salt Lake City bribery scandal in 1999 — a legitimacy shock arguably deeper than FIFA’s 2015 indictments. Its response was Olympic Agenda 2020, a binding reform program that capped administrative costs at 10% of revenue, mandated 90% distribution to sport worldwide, adopted a “no new venues” policy for host cities, and established term limits that actually ended. Revenue grew <a href="https://www.olympics.com/ioc/news/olympic-agenda-lays-solid-long-term-financial-base-for-ioc-with-revenues-up-by-60-per-cent-during-the-period-of-implementation">60% over the reform period</a>. Commercial partners locked in <a href="https://www.olympics.com/ioc/news/olympic-agenda-lays-solid-long-term-financial-base-for-ioc-with-revenues-up-by-60-per-cent-during-the-period-of-implementation">$7.5 billion for 2025–28</a> before the Paris Games concluded. Kirsty Coventry became the first female IOC president in 2025 — a genuine transition of power, not a reinterpretation of term limits. The IOC proved that sports governance reform is possible when the leadership treats reform as survival rather than public relations. FIFA’s reforms failed not because change is impossible but because the organization’s leadership never intended them to succeed.</p><p>None of which diminishes what the commercial machine has also funded. The same revenue engine that enabled the abuses has financed football development at a scale the sport had never seen — the <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/advancing-football/fifa-forward/fifa-forward-report">94 pitches built in Africa</a>, the youth competitions created across Asia, the coaching infrastructure established in the Caribbean, the operational budgets that keep small associations from collapsing between World Cup cycles. These outcomes are not fictional. They are the output of a system that has been genuinely developmental for the majority of its 211 members, particularly associations that had nothing before Havelange made the developing world the center of FIFA’s political strategy. The patronage machine and the development program are the same mechanism; acknowledging one does not require denying the other.</p><h3>The $6 Million Man and the Phone Call That Rewrote the Disciplinary Code</h3><p>Infantino was elected in <a href="https://publications.fifa.com/en/vision-report-2021/the-journey/the-journey-2016/">2016</a> as the reform candidate — UEFA’s general secretary, the technocrat antidote to Blatter. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/football/2025/may/27/fifa-more-poorly-governed-open-letter-football-politics">Ten years on</a>, FairSquare rates FIFA “more poorly governed than 10 years ago.” The caveat is real: governance metrics are normative, and no charges have been filed against Infantino. But the structural evidence accumulates.</p><p>Consider the sequence. Term limits meant for <a href="https://apnews.com/article/fifa-statutes-committes-infantino-2f724ef9e023493acf772c6b66cae5f8">12 years</a> were reinterpreted to <a href="https://www.sportsbusinessjournal.com/Articles/2024/04/18/fifa-to-create-dozens-of-new-committees">15</a>. Standing committees expanded from <a href="https://apnews.com/article/fifa-statutes-committes-infantino-2f724ef9e023493acf772c6b66cae5f8">7 to 35</a>, each distributing per diems [daily expense allowances] and titles to loyalists — a committee seat at FIFA is worth approximately <a href="https://www.newsday.com/sports/soccer/fifa-statutes-committes-infantino-c12532">$50,000–100,000 annually</a> in travel, accommodation, and prestige. The <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/organisation/divisions/finances">2018 code revision</a> removed “corruption” as an enumerated ethics violation, replacing it with vaguer language that requires the Ethics Committee to prove intent rather than pattern. Infantino’s compensation quadrupled from approximately <a href="https://apnews.com/article/world-cup-sports-qatar-3551b3dacd7c35a4f7b50ecbb69abec5">$1.5 million to $6 million</a> over the same period that Forward program distributions to the most vulnerable associations remained flat as a share of total spending.</p><p>Then comes the Trump relationship — not the friendship itself, which is a personal choice, but the structural compromises it produced. Infantino created the FIFA Peace Prize with no criteria, no jury, and no oversight, and awarded it to Trump. FIFA hosted the World Cup draw at the Kennedy Center at zero rental cost; the <a href="https://apnews.com/article/world-cup-draw-kennedy-center-payment-trump-af64d2123ad9c021da699edc21255304">$2.4 million donation</a> that accompanied the arrangement was not a sponsorship — it was a political contribution structured as an event fee. When Folarin Balogun’s red card was overturned after Trump’s phone call, it became the first World Cup red-card reversal since <a href="https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/revisiting-1962-world-cup-red-215150325.html">1962</a>. <a href="https://www.uefa.com/news-media/news/02a7-2109c8e9ef81-de5a993db109-1000--uefa-statement-on-the-balogun-case/">UEFA called it a “crossed red line.”</a> The disciplinary code was not followed; it was suspended. FIFA’s rules are not applied consistently — they are contingent on who calls, and on whose behalf that call is made.</p><p>The bear case says these are coincidences, not a conspiracy. Infantino wins elections by wide margins — <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/">three uncontested victories</a>. <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/advancing-football/fifa-forward/fifa-forward-report">Forward distributed $2.8 billion across 144 projects</a>. Associations freely choose to re-elect him.</p><p>The bull case is not that the elections are rigged. It is that they do not need to be. FIFA has <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/advancing-football/fifa-forward/fifa-forward-report">211 member associations</a>, of which approximately <a href="https://web.fifaclearinghouse.org/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials/2025-financial-statements/notes/8-development-and-education">110 receive $8 million per cycle</a> through Forward plus <a href="https://web.fifaclearinghouse.org/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials/2025-financial-statements/notes/8-development-and-education">$1.2 million in operational subsidies</a>. For a federation whose total annual budget is <a href="https://web.fifaclearinghouse.org/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials/2025-financial-statements/notes/8-development-and-education">$2–5 million</a>, losing Forward funding means insolvency. Voting against the incumbent is not an expression of preference — it is a decision with financial consequences that most associations cannot afford. The question is not whether Infantino is popular. It is whether an electoral system in which <a href="https://web.fifaclearinghouse.org/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials/2025-financial-statements/notes/8-development-and-education">52%</a> of voters are also direct financial beneficiaries of the sole candidate can produce the kind of accountability that governance reformers claim to want.</p><p>The ICC [International Cricket Council] confronted a version of this same structural problem and chose a different path. After the failed “Big Three” power grab of 2014 — when India’s BCCI, England’s ECB, and Cricket Australia attempted to enshrine permanent control of revenue and governance — the ICC installed an <a href="https://www.livemint.com/Politics/PaK4mHrlpN7BALpmCbMdvL/ICC-meeting-BCCI-outvoted-on-new-governance-structure-reve.html">independent chairman, Shashank Manohar</a>, who promptly outvoted the BCCI, the world’s richest and most powerful cricket board, on both governance reform and revenue redistribution. The BCCI was defeated <a href="https://www.livemint.com/Politics/PaK4mHrlpN7BALpmCbMdvL/ICC-meeting-BCCI-outvoted-on-new-governance-structure-reve.html">9–1 on governance and 8–2 on revenue</a>. An independent chair with no national federation affiliation proved capable of doing what FIFA’s Council — entirely composed of federation presidents who depend on Forward funding — cannot: representing the institution’s long-term interests against its most powerful member’s short-term demands. The ICC’s revenue distribution remains deeply unequal — the BCCI still receives <a href="https://www.sportspro.com/news/bcci-icc-revenue-earnings-distribution-model-2024-27/">38.5% of all ICC revenue</a> ($230 million annually), more than the next five boards combined — but the governance check exists. A council of dependent voters cannot counterbalance a president who controls their funding. An independent oversight body, properly empowered, can.</p><p>The same Forward program that creates electoral dependency also funds real, measurable outcomes: <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/advancing-football/fifa-forward/fifa-forward-report">144 completed infrastructure projects</a>, youth tournaments that did not exist a decade ago, coaching licenses, referee development, and operational budgets for federations whose annual spending would otherwise cover little more than a single staff salary and an office. For an association with 50,000 registered players and a <a href="https://web.fifaclearinghouse.org/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials/2025-financial-statements/notes/8-development-and-education">$2 million annual budget</a>, <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/advancing-football/fifa-forward/fifa-forward-report">$8 million per cycle</a> is not a bribe — it is the difference between having a functioning football ecosystem and having nothing at all. The dependency this article describes and the development it enables are the same mechanism, seen from different vantages.</p><h3>Operations &amp; Brand — “The 39-Day Cash Machine”</h3><p>The governance model described above exists to protect one thing: the revenue machine that funds the patronage pipeline. That machine is a marvel of concentration. FIFA generates <a href="https://www.insideworldfootball.com/2025/05/16/fifa-reports-2bn-upward-budget-revision-11bn-2023-26-cycle">$13 billion over the 2023–26 cycle</a>. <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">Sixty-eight percent — $8.9 billion</a> — comes from a single <a href="https://www.fifa.com/en/tournaments/mens/worldcup/canadamexicousa2026">39-day tournament</a>. Everything else — every development program, every competition, every sponsorship tier — fits into the remaining <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">$4.1 billion</a>. This is not diversification by any measure. The World Cup is not FIFA’s flagship product; it is FIFA’s only product with a capital structure attached.</p><p>The geographic concentration matches the temporal one. <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">14 of 26 commercial partners are US-based</a>, contributing an estimated <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">52% of sponsorship revenue</a>. Canada and Mexico contribute $0 despite co-hosting — their domestic markets are treated as extensions of the US broadcast footprint rather than independent revenue streams. This asymmetry creates a structural dependency: FIFA cannot push back against any US government action because the US is not just the host market; it is the only market that matters for sponsorship. When the State Department denies visas to Iran’s staff, FIFA’s commercial team does not want to escalate because the commercial relationship with the US is order-of-magnitude larger than anything the Iranian federation represents.</p><p>Total broadcast revenue rose <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">32% this cycle</a>, but per-match value fell <a href="https://www.theglobalstatistics.com/fifa-world-cup-broadcast-rights-statistics/">19% with the expansion from 64 to 104 matches</a>. The <a href="https://www.fifa.com/en/tournaments/mens/worldcup/canadamexicousa2026">40 additional matches</a> generate less revenue per unit than the core <a href="https://www.fortuneindia.com/business-news/inside-fifas-13-billion-business-model-why-the-world-cup-is-no-longer-its-only-cash-machine/143327">64</a> — a classic volume discount that threatens long-term value as the tournament grows further. Asian rights are collapsing: <a href="https://apnews.com/article/world-cup-fifa-china-tv-rights-c516a5e27392e6220afdb433351c5f9b">China declined from $250 million to $60 million</a>, <a href="https://www.reuters.com/sports/soccer/fifa-faces-class-action-over-player-transfer-regulations-2025-08-04/">India from approximately $100 million to $10–15 million</a>, total broadcast deal volume from <a href="https://www.carettaresearch.com/">60 to 24</a>. This is not a cyclical dip. The Asian rights model assumed that growing middle-class audiences would translate into growing broadcast fees. Instead, piracy, changing viewing habits, and the shift to digital platforms have destroyed the premium cable model that Asian broadcasters depended on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7JjSiou3m6NGFMWgHpWEAQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 1. FIFA’s 2023–26 cycle revenue splits 68/32 between the 39-day World Cup and all other activities across four years. The tournament is not a product line — it is the only product. Source: Mappr analysis of FIFA budget data.</em></figcaption></figure><p>The competitive landscape compounds every weakness. UEFA’s Champions League generates <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/1413269/champions-league-prize-money/">$2.47 billion annually</a> — not per cycle, annually — rivaling FIFA’s per-annum World Cup revenue while running on a fraction of the overhead and without the governance baggage. The <a href="https://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2024-10/cp240172en.pdf">Diarra ruling at the European Court of Justice</a> struck down FIFA’s transfer rules as unlawful no-poaching agreements, dismantling the legal architecture that underpins the entire player-market system. FIFPRO filed an antitrust complaint against the international match calendar. A <a href="https://www.reuters.com/sports/soccer/fifa-faces-class-action-over-player-transfer-regulations-2025-08-04/">100,000-player class action</a> challenges the transfer system in Dutch courts. Private equity — CVC, Silver Lake, Apollo — is building parallel competition structures that bypass Zurich entirely.</p><p>The bull case is simple and not wrong: the World Cup remains the most valuable single sporting event on earth. Cyclical recovery is normal. FIFA posted a <a href="https://publications.fifa.com/en/annual-report-2022/finances/2019-2022-cycle-in-review/balance-sheet-2019-2022">$1.2 billion net surplus in 2022</a>. Revenue grew <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">72% from the prior cycle</a>. The brand sells itself.</p><p>World Rugby shows where this trajectory ends. A <a href="https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5cacbb42a568278dd5430feb/t/68c15d64d343e8496df9ef12/1757502820281/2025+Oliver+and+Ohlbaum+-+Reinventing+Rugby+-+Summary.pdf">2025 Oliver &amp; Ohlbaum report</a> found the sport’s “World Cup bubble” model “inherently unstable”: the men’s Rugby World Cup is the sole engine of profit, while the top 10 national unions posted a <a href="https://insidersport.com/2025/09/11/report-exposes-rugbys-financial-crisis/">combined operating loss of $137 million in 2023/24</a> and Premiership and Top 14 clubs collectively lost $100 million. International rugby matches generate $12 million per game; club tournaments generate $1–2 million. The gap between the quadrennial cash machine and the everyday sport is so wide that <a href="https://www.brabners.com/insights/sport/is-rugby-union-on-the-precipice">seven of ten English Premiership clubs</a> are balance-sheet insolvent. The IRFU <a href="https://d19fc3vd0ojo3m.cloudfront.net/irfu/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/17153603/IRFU-Financial-Report-2024_25.pdf">gets 80% of its revenue</a> from the men’s national team alone. “We certainly cannot continue to have World Cups every four years that have such a major impact on our finances,” its CEO told reporters in 2024. FIFA is not rugby — the World Cup’s revenue scale is an order of magnitude larger — but the structural pattern is identical: a single quadrennial event funding an ecosystem that cannot survive without it.</p><p>What the bull case does not address is that every previous cycle assumed growing per-match value, growing Asian rights, and a cooperative European ecosystem. All three assumptions are now inverted. The World Cup will likely survive any single shock. The question is whether the margin for error is narrowing faster than FIFA’s governance model can adapt.</p><p>It is also true that the revenue figures exist because billions of people genuinely care. The <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">$8.9 billion</a> in tournament revenue is not manufactured by marketing — it is the aggregate expression of real passion, in every country, across every income level. That passion has funded infrastructure, coaching, and competition pathways in places that would otherwise have neither, and it is the foundation on which any future FIFA — reformed or not — will have to build.</p><h3>The $1.3 Billion Hole in the Balance Sheet</h3><p>Between <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials/2025-financial-statements">December 2022 and December 2025</a>, FIFA’s reserves fell from <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7330307/2026/07/09/fifa-finances-bookkeeper-analysis/">$3.97 billion to $2.7 billion</a> — a <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials">$1.25 billion drawdown</a> across three loss-making non-tournament years. The pattern is cyclical by design: tournament years produce surpluses, non-tournament years burn cash. But the drawdown is accelerating relative to prior cycles.</p><p>The mechanics are straightforward. In tournament years, FIFA swims in cash. In the three years between tournaments, it burns approximately <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials">$400 million annually</a> to fund Forward program distributions, administrative overhead, and an expanded headcount that has grown from approximately <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/organisation/divisions/finances">700 to over 1,000 staff since 2016</a>. The projected recovery to <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials">$5.5–6.5 billion</a> after 2026 would exceed the previous peak — if broadcast revenue holds, if Asian rights do not decline further, if the Club World Cup generates meaningful returns, and if no geopolitical disruption affects the North American tournament.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6wUsdPETm5csCA1CmPM7DA.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 2. FIFA’s cash reserves follow a boom-bust cycle: tournament years produce surpluses, non-tournament years burn $400M+ annually. The $1.3B drawdown from 2022–25 is the largest between-cycle decline on record. The projected recovery to $5.5–6.5B assumes broadcast revenue holds, Asian rights stabilize, and no geopolitical disruption hits the 2026 tournament. Source: FIFA 2022 Annual Report, FIFA 2025 Financial Statements, PARG/Carleton University estimates.</em></figcaption></figure><p>The <a href="https://legal.fifa.com/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials/2025-financial-statements/notes/27-contract-liabilities">$5.2 billion in contract liabilities</a> represents prepaid future revenue — money FIFA has already collected from sponsors and broadcasters for tournaments that have not yet been played. This figure grew <a href="https://legal.fifa.com/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials/2025-financial-statements/notes/27-contract-liabilities">12.7x from $410 million</a> in a prior cycle, meaning FIFA is borrowing against future events to fund current operations. The accounting is legal and standard for event-driven organizations. It is also a measure of how much of the balance sheet depends on future tournaments delivering as projected.</p><p>The most revealing number is not the reserve drawdown but the capital allocation. Development’s share of total costs fell from <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials">44% to 29% across three cycles</a>, even as absolute Forward dollars rose <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/advancing-football/fifa-forward/fifa-forward-report">7x</a>. The gap did not close. It widened. Meanwhile, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7330307/2026/07/09/fifa-finances-bookkeeper-analysis/">over $5 billion sits in financial market investments</a> — bonds, equities, alternatives — generating market-rate returns rather than football development returns. The opportunity cost is not theoretical. At an average 6–7% annual return, the investment portfolio generates $300–350 million per year in financial income. If that same capital had been deployed through Forward at FIFA’s stated development absorption rate, it could have funded approximately <a href="https://leadership.ng/fifa-forward-programme-invests-2-8bn-in-football-development-worldwide/">3,000–4,000 additional infrastructure projects</a> or covered the entire annual operating budgets of 50–60 member associations. The implicit message is not subtle: financial reserves matter more than the development Forward was created to deliver.</p><p>The bull case: <a href="https://publications.fifa.com/en/annual-report-2022/finances/2019-2022-cycle-in-review/balance-sheet-2019-2022">$1.2 billion net positive in 2022</a>, a projected <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials">$3 billion+ surplus in 2026</a>, and a balance sheet that would be the envy of any NGO. Cyclical drawdown is normal for event-driven organizations. FIFA has never missed a development payment. These are all true. They are also the arguments a management team makes when it believes the revenue cycle will never turn against it.</p><p>The IOC comparison makes the financial gap starker. The IOC maintains <a href="https://www.thesportsexaminer.com/intl-olympic-committee-ioc-releases-2025-financial-statements-showing-near-650-million-in-revenue-assets-up-to-6-97-billion/">$4.9 billion</a> in reserves against <a href="https://www.thesportsexaminer.com/intl-olympic-committee-ioc-releases-2025-financial-statements-showing-near-650-million-in-revenue-assets-up-to-6-97-billion/">$7.0 billion</a> in total assets, with liabilities of only <a href="https://www.thesportsexaminer.com/intl-olympic-committee-ioc-releases-2025-financial-statements-showing-near-650-million-in-revenue-assets-up-to-6-97-billion/">$2.1 billion</a> — a 70% equity ratio. Its administrative costs remain within the <a href="https://www.olympics.com/ioc/news/olympic-agenda-lays-solid-long-term-financial-base-for-ioc-with-revenues-up-by-60-per-cent-during-the-period-of-implementation">10% ceiling</a> set in Olympic Agenda 2020 — $213 million operating expenditure on $650 million revenue in a non-Games year. The IOC has already <a href="https://www.olympics.com/ioc/news/olympic-agenda-lays-solid-long-term-financial-base-for-ioc-with-revenues-up-by-60-per-cent-during-the-period-of-implementation">contracted $7.5 billion for 2025–28, $6.9 billion for 2029–32, and $4 billion for 2033–36</a> — meaning its revenue pipeline extends three Olympiads into the future, underwritten by commercial commitments rather than prepaid tournament tickets. FIFA’s $5.2 billion in contract liabilities are prepaid future revenue from tournaments that have not yet been played; the IOC’s forward commitments are bankable commercial agreements its partners have already signed. Both organizations face cyclical non-event years. Only one built a reserve structure and cost discipline designed to survive them comfortably.</p><p>To balance the critique: FIFA has never missed a <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/advancing-football/fifa-forward/fifa-forward-report">Forward payment</a> to any member association, tournament year or not. The <a href="https://carleton.ca/news/story/world-cup-profit-fifa-finances/">$5 billion reserve buffer</a> that looks like hoarding in a development-focused frame looks like prudence when a pandemic or geopolitical crisis disrupts a tournament year. The reserves exist to ensure that the 110 associations most dependent on that funding are never cut off — and they have served that purpose across every cycle since their creation. Prudent balance sheet management and underinvestment in development are not the same failure, but the article’s framing has treated them as interchangeable.</p><h3>DAZN, Saudi Arabia, and the Sovereignty Problem</h3><p>FIFA+ launched in <a href="https://www.plus.fifa.com/">2022</a> promising <a href="https://www.plus.fifa.com/">40,000 live matches per year</a>. By <a href="https://www.fifa.com/">June 2026</a> it was fully absorbed into DAZN. The retreat from owned streaming was not gradual — it was a capitulation. FIFA spent approximately <a href="https://publications.fifa.com/en/annual-report-2022/finances/2019-2022-cycle-in-review/2019-2022-investments-expenses/">$50–100 million building FIFA+</a>, failed to secure the content licensing and technology infrastructure to make it viable, and handed the entire operation to a single streaming partner that now controls FIFA’s only direct digital fan relationship. No reversion clause was negotiated; when the DAZN deal expires, FIFA starts from zero.</p><p>The diagnosis is not that FIFA chose the wrong streaming platform. It is that FIFA does not have a technology strategy; it has a procurement department. FIFA Connect [the member association digital portal for player registration and transfers] reached only <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/official-documents/annual-report/2025">118 of 211 members</a> after a decade, meaning nearly half of FIFA’s own member associations are not integrated into the digital infrastructure FIFA claims to operate. FIFA Collect migrated blockchains <a href="https://collect.fifa.com/">three times in four years</a> — Algorand to Polygon to Avalanche — each migration fragmenting the user base and destroying whatever community had formed on the previous chain. The technology decisions follow the funding, not the strategy: Algorand paid for the initial sponsorship; when that deal expired, Polygon offered better terms; when Polygon’s crypto market position declined, Avalanche was next. Each decision optimized for short-term sponsorship revenue at the cost of long-term digital coherence.</p><p>The Club World Cup — a <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/tournament-organisation">32-team tournament</a> positioned as a direct competitor to the Champions League — is FIFA’s boldest structural bet. The logic is sound: create a second revenue pillar so that <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">68% of revenue</a> does not depend on a single <a href="https://www.fifa.com/en/tournaments/mens/worldcup/canadamexicousa2026">39-day event</a>. The execution is problematic. The Club World Cup escalates an open cold war with UEFA, which walked out of Congress over the scheduling conflict. The Champions League generates <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/1413269/champions-league-prize-money/">$2.47 billion annually</a>; the Club World Cup currently generates a fraction of that. For the Club World Cup to become a credible second pillar, it would need to generate at least <a href="https://www.insideworldfootball.com/2025/05/16/fifa-reports-2bn-upward-budget-revision-11bn-2023-26-cycle">$2–3 billion per cycle</a> — which means competing directly with the Champions League for the same clubs, same broadcast windows, and same sponsorship dollars.</p><p>Then there is Saudi Arabia. The kingdom serves simultaneously as FIFA’s top-tier sponsor (Aramco), tournament partner (PIF, the sovereign wealth fund), development financier (<a href="https://apnews.com/article/fifa-saudi-arabia-club-world-cup-09bcc982e20ec4562572a4c8fba54a97">$1 billion committed</a>), and uncontested <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/">2034 host</a>. One nation-state is simultaneously FIFA’s largest commercial partner, its largest development donor, its next World Cup host, and its most important institutional patron. No formal check exists on this concentration. A single diplomatic rift, regional conflict, or succession event would simultaneously hit FIFA’s sponsorship revenue, development funding, tournament operations, and sovereign backing. This is not the risk of a single bad quarter. It is the risk of a balance sheet tied to a single sovereign credit rating.</p><p>The bull case is undeniable at its core: the World Cup sold itself in <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">2022 for $8.9 billion</a> with no streaming platform, a fragmented NFT strategy, and <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/official-documents/annual-report/2025">half of member associations not on FIFA Connect</a>. The brand’s value is resilient. The question the bull case does not answer is whether resilient brand value survives structurally declining per-match broadcast revenue, a retreat from owned digital channels, and a commercial future tied to a single sovereign balance sheet.</p><p>And yet the 2026 World Cup is the most technologically ambitious tournament ever staged — <a href="https://meshworld.in/blog/ai/fifa-world-cup-2026-ai-technology/">16 cameras per stadium</a> collecting 150 million data points per match, AI-generated player digital twins for every offside review, a ball sensor operating at <a href="https://www.fifa.com/en/tournaments/mens/worldcup/canadamexicousa2026/official-match-ball">500Hz with sub-millisecond precision</a>, and sub-5-second IPTV latency across 16 stadiums in three countries. FIFA’s event-level innovation is genuinely world-class. The gap is not between FIFA and its peers at tournament time; it is between tournament-time FIFA and everything else the organization operates.</p><h3>The Map: FIFA’s Corporate Battlefield</h3><blockquote><a href="https://agostontorok.github.io/strategy/stratmap/">Strategy Map</a> Reader Guide</blockquote><blockquote>The following map plots FIFA’s strategic position across a battlefield defined by two axes. The horizontal axis runs from Idea (left) through MVP (center) to Commodity (right) — measuring how standardized or differentiated each element is. The left vertical axis runs from Internal (bottom) through Customer (middle) to Cultural (top) — measuring how visible each element’s value is to the outside world. The right vertical axis runs from Structural (bottom) through Frontline (middle) to Emerging (top) — measuring how immediate or future each threat or challenge is.</blockquote><blockquote>Positions are fixed targets on the battlefield — the goals FIFA is trying to hold or capture. Forces are the assets and threats moving across the terrain. Arrows show where each force was (dashed) and where it is heading (solid). A threat moving from Emerging toward Frontline is becoming real. An asset moving upward is gaining cultural visibility. A force moving downward is losing public prominence.</blockquote><blockquote>Two groups divide the map. The Revenue group clusters the World Cup, the Club World Cup, the Forward Program, and Saudi concentration — the money engine and its dependencies. The Power group clusters the Patronage Machine, Regulatory Autonomy, the 211 Member Associations, the Forward Program, and the Reserve Buffer — the political infrastructure that converts money into control.</blockquote><blockquote>Three viewpoint windows zoom into specific sectors of the battlefield. Each is described below.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2249FMs1Wd1eRpcI52i5AQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 3. Full strategy map showing FIFA’s three goals (World Cup Revenue, Patronage Machine, Regulatory Autonomy), five assets (World Cup, Forward Program, Club World Cup, 211 Associations, Reserve Buffer), and five threats (UEFA Champions League, ECJ Diarra Ruling, Private Equity, Broadcast Value Decline, Saudi Concentration Risk). Red group = Revenue circuit; blue group = Power circuit. Solid arrows = future trajectory; dashed arrows = past position. Source: </em><a href="https://agostontorok.github.io/strategy/stratmap/"><em>StratMap analysis</em></a><em>.</em></figcaption></figure><p>FIFA’s $13 billion strategy maps onto a battlefield with three positions to defend and five forces advancing on them. The positions are fixed — FIFA cannot move them without abandoning what it is. The forces are in motion. The question is whether the forces reach the positions before FIFA can nonethelss somehow reposition.</p><p>The first goal is World Cup Revenue — the central objective the central and most customer visible product, in fact basically their only product. This is the asset that generates $8.9 billion from 39 days. It is not differentiated enough to be unchallengeable (the Champions League generates comparable annual revenue) and not commoditized enough to just exist without pressure on reinventing its detailed sourcing. It sits in the exact middle of the battlefield: visible enough that everyone can see its value, standardized enough that competitors can chip away at it.</p><p>The second goal is to maintain the Patronage Machine — sitting in the right, at the intersection of Commodity standardization and Cultural visibility. This is FIFA’s real moat: the system that converts revenue into power of the sport. The Forward Program feeds it, the 211 associations sustain it, and the Reserve Buffer protects it. The Patronage Machine is the the driver of the power — every developing-world football official knows exactly what it does — but it is also in commodity zone, because any organization with money can run a development program. UEFA does it. The IOC does it. The difference is that FIFA’s version comes with a vote attached.</p><p>The third goal is the Regulatory Autonomy — sitting in the top right, at the intersection of Commodity standardization and Structural challenge. This is FIFA’s claim to be the sole governing body of world football: the transfer rules, the licensing system, the international match calendar, the disciplinary code. It is the most visible to the public. Without regulatory autonomy, FIFA is a tournament organizer with a development fund — powerful, but not unique.</p><h3>The Cash Making Machine</h3><p>FIFA’s revenue is 68% the world cup, and that require organizing and continuously redefining the world cup format. Every four year, a new ball, new venues, new song, format or rule changes etc. Latest change is the extension to 104 teams, which finally gives more airtime to more developing nations’ eleven.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YpIrUDICpzfiJrnxCqPqHg.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 4. Revenue Machine viewport. The World Cup sits at center, flanked by the Club World Cup (speculative, unproven) and Broadcast Value Decline (advancing from the Emerging band). Per-match value is falling, Asian rights are collapsing, and the Club World Cup has not yet proven it can generate a fraction of the Champions League’s $2.47B. The question mark near Private Equity marks the one force that could reshape the entire revenue landscape.</em></figcaption></figure><p>The second asset is the Forward Program, moving down recently in relative terms. However, the program is losing efficiency: FIFA takes a bigger cut of the revenue, associations receive less net value, and the dependency deepens. The Forward Program is simultaneously the most important asset and the most fragile one.</p><p>The third asset is the more than 25 yr old FIFA Club World Cup, a more speculative asset moving upward. Its future arrow points toward the World Cup position — the ambition is to create a second revenue pillar that rivals the World Cup. But the Club World Cup is still finding its way: unproven, contested by UEFA, and generating a fraction of the Champions League’s $2.47 billion. So that arrow is aspirational, not confirmed.</p><p>On the threat side, the most important factor is the Broadcast Value Decline, a threat moving quickly from the Emerging band toward Frontline. Its past and future arrows are both signalling the past and probably continuing “Asian collapse”: China from $250 million to $60 million, India from $100 million to $10–15 million, per-match value down 19% with the expansion to 104 matches. This threat is advancing on the World Cup position from below — it does not kill the tournament, but it erodes the revenue foundation on which everything else depends.</p><p>Yet another threat is the Private Equity supported challenger formats that are building parallel competition structures (CVC’s multi-billion-dollar sports portfolio, Silver Lake’s City Football Group stake) that bypass Zurich entirely. Although this is still more in the emerging zone, the threats on the unique position of FIFA as the regulatory body of football/soccer, it’s far from certain that it’s going to stay like that. Finally, almost like a ticking timebomb, there is Saudi Concentration Risk sits in the middle the Revenue group — a reminder that the kingdom serves simultaneously as FIFA’s largest commercial partner, development donor, and next World Cup host, with no formal check on this concentration.</p><h3>The Power Converter</h3><p>The Patronage Machine goal is protected by the entire setup. The 211 Member Associations sit locked at the Commodity end of the standardization axis, with no arrows — no exit from the dependency, no upward movement toward Cultural visibility, no trajectory toward independence. They are the most static element on the map. Every other force moves; the associations do not. They depend on the Forward Program, which is the critical link between the World Cup revenue machine and the only financial cushion: the Reserve Buffer. But the trends are not favorable. The relative share of Forward Program costs is shrinking, and so is the Reserve Buffer. This means the 211 associations are increasingly sliding from sovereign members toward dependent recipients. They have little leverage to change this — at least not yet. That is precisely why the next zoom-in is critical.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pR5YFw4YrDQCv8q-_sH4sw.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 5. Patronage System viewport. The Forward Program channels $2.8B to 211 associations — but FIFA’s cut is growing, the Reserve Buffer is shrinking ($1.3B drawdown), and the associations sit locked at the Commodity end with no arrows. This is the loyalty engine that converts money into votes, and it is fed by a revenue stream that is itself under siege.</em></figcaption></figure><h3>The Light Switch</h3><p>FIFA does not position itself as an event organizer. It acts as the primary governing body of world football — and that position has gone unquestioned for over a century. The crux of that governance is control of one of the most important value allocation: player transfers. But the map shows the terrain shifting. Active court proceedings (ECJ Diarra Ruling and FIFPRO’s class action and the Dutch court challenge are extending the Diarra logic) do not just challenge one rule; they dismantle the legal architecture that makes FIFA’s regulatory authority enforceable. The relationship with UEFA, the second-largest football association, is deteriorating, pushing UEFA to deploy its lobbying power against FIFA wherever possible.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-JEG-el_cEH-T2J5HGYIKQ.png" /><figcaption>Figure 6. The Crux of FIFA: it’s sport governance body status. It’s attacked by substantial challenges both from the legal and influence angle and FIFA doesn’t seem to have any meaningful response options to these.</figcaption></figure><p>In other sports where the incumbent governing body faces challenges, there is typically an asset that cements the governing position — a broadcast contract, a stadium network, a legal monopoly. In FIFA’s case, other than system inertia, the wildcard is unclear. And if FIFA loses regulatory authority entirely, the question becomes what exists in the cultural tier — the next position it could hold and try to reach. The cultural tier still offers two advantages: FIFA remains the world’s largest sport-development association, and decades of history have fused the FIFA brand with football itself in the public mind. But translating brand association into the same level of control that regulatory authority provided — the control over transfers, licensing, the international match calendar, and the disciplinary code — is the unsolved problem. That control is what makes the World Cup exclusive, what makes it the one tournament billions follow, and what generates the revenue that funds the entire patronage system. The regulatory authority is therefore the battle FIFA must fight hardest to preserve, even if it is already losing ground. Salvaging what remains of that position is the difference between a governing body with enforceable power and a brand association with a quadrennial tournament.</p><h3>What Needs to Happen: Five Priorities</h3><ol><li>Rebrand FIFA as a democratic sport development association — not a regulator, not a commercial empire, but a representative body for 211 nations that competes as a political bloc against UEFA and private equity.</li><li>Restore development’s share of total spending to 40%+ — reverse the decline from 44% to 29% by capping administrative overhead and redirecting reserve investment income through Forward.</li><li>Build a mutual defense compact among the 110 dependent associations — convert patronage dependency into collective bargaining power, so that no single president controls the funding and no single election determines the outcome.</li><li>Cap any single sovereign’s commercial exposure at 15% of total revenue — eliminate the concentration risk that ties FIFA’s sponsorship, development funding, tournament hosting, and sovereign backing to a single nation-state.</li><li>Launch a fan-owned digital platform — reclaim the direct fan relationship outsourced to DAZN, built on the 16-stadium data infrastructure already deployed for 2026, owned by the member associations rather than a single streaming partner.</li></ol><h3>The President’s Speech</h3><p>An imaginary address from Gianni Infantino, the FIFA President to the 211 member associations — the speech that acknowledges every operational constraint the article has identified, then explains why inaction costs more than transition.</p><blockquote>Delegates. Presidents. General secretaries.</blockquote><blockquote>I will not stand here and tell you the World Cup is not working. It generated $8.9 billion this cycle. It funded your federations, your pitches, your youth tournaments. The machine works.</blockquote><blockquote>But the machine is losing power. Per-match broadcast value fell 19% when we expanded to 104 matches. Asian rights collapsed — China from $250 million to $60 million, India from $100 million to $15 million. The reserve buffer dropped $1.3 billion in three years. Development’s share of total spending fell from 44% to 29% across three cycles — even as absolute dollars rose. The money is growing. Your share is shrinking.</blockquote><blockquote>And the threats are not future threats. The Diarra ruling struck down the transfer rules. FIFPRO filed a class action. Private equity is building parallel competition structures. UEFA is lobbying against us in every capital where we need support. Saudi Arabia is simultaneously our largest commercial partner, our largest development donor, our next World Cup host, and our most important institutional patron. One diplomatic rift hits four things at once. No check exists on this concentration.</blockquote><blockquote>I cannot fix this by cutting Saudi exposure to 15%. That would cost $1 billion in development commitments already promised. I cannot restore development to 40% without reducing the administrative headcount from 1,000 back toward 700 — and those 300 staff are the network that keeps you on side. I cannot launch a fan platform when DAZN controls our only digital distribution channel and no reversion clause was negotiated. The operational constraints are real. I will not pretend otherwise.</blockquote><blockquote>But here is what I can do.</blockquote><blockquote>First, we rebrand. Not the logo. Not the slogan. The identity. We are not a regulator. We are not a commercial empire. We are 211 nations, the largest democratic bloc in global sport — more members than the United Nations, more than the IOC. No private equity fund, no UEFA, no sovereign wealth fund can outvote us if we vote together. We stop begging for Forward payments. We negotiate as a collective.</blockquote><blockquote>Second, we restore development’s share to 40%. Not by magic. By capping administrative overhead. By redirecting reserve investment income — $300 million annually from financial markets — through Forward instead of into bonds. The reserve buffer earns more in a year than half of you receive in a cycle. That gap is the distance between what FIFA claims to be and what it is. We close it.</blockquote><blockquote>Third, we build a mutual defense compact. The ICC proved it works. An independent chair outvoted the BCCI 9–1 on governance and 8–2 on revenue. The BCCI was the richest, most powerful cricket board in the world. It lost to a coalition of smaller boards that voted together. You are those smaller boards. You have never voted as a bloc because no one gave you a reason to. I am giving you one. Instead of each association negotiating individually for Forward payments, you negotiate collectively for a share of revenue proportional to your membership. The patronage machine survives. The control shifts.</blockquote><blockquote>Fourth, we cap any single sovereign’s commercial exposure at 15% of total revenue. No one nation-state should simultaneously be our sponsor, our donor, our host, and our patron. That is not sovereignty. That is dependency dressed as partnership.</blockquote><blockquote>Fifth, we launch a fan-owned digital platform. We already have the infrastructure — 16 stadiums, 150 million data points per match, AI-generated player digital twins, sub-5-second IPTV latency. The technology exists. The fan relationship was outsourced to DAZN because we could not build it ourselves. You can. A platform owned by 211 associations, funded by a fraction of reserve income, built on the data infrastructure already deployed for 2026. Not a startup. A cooperative. Cooperatives scale when the members have a shared interest in their success.</blockquote><blockquote>The revenue machine works. The threats are real. The transition costs are real. But the cost of inaction is higher. The map shows five forces advancing on three positions. The forces are in motion. The positions are fixed. We move before they arrive — or we wait and hope the next cycle is kinder than this one.</blockquote><blockquote>I am not asking you to abandon what works. I am asking you to save it before it stops working.</blockquote><blockquote>— Gianni Infantino, President, FIFA</blockquote><h3>Key Facts and Metrics</h3><ul><li>2023–26 Cycle Revenue: $13.0 billion — <a href="https://www.insideworldfootball.com/2025/05/16/fifa-reports-2bn-upward-budget-revision-11bn-2023-26-cycle">FIFA Revised Budget 2023–2026, Inside World Football</a></li><li>World Cup Share of Revenue: 68% ($8.9 billion from 39 tournament days) — <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">Mappr analysis of FIFA budget data</a></li><li>FIFA Reserve Decline: $3.97 billion (Dec 2022) to $2.7 billion (Dec 2025) — <a href="https://publications.fifa.com/en/annual-report-2022/finances/2019-2022-cycle-in-review/balance-sheet-2019-2022">FIFA 2022 Annual Report, FIFA 2025 Financial Statements</a></li><li>Contract Liabilities: $5.2 billion (prepaid future revenue, 12.7x increase from $410M) — <a href="https://legal.fifa.com/official-documents/annual-report/2025/financials/2025-financial-statements/notes/27-contract-liabilities">FIFA 2025 Financial Statements, Note 27</a></li><li>Forward Program Distributions: $2.8 billion across cycles 1 and 2 (2016–2022) — <a href="https://inside.fifa.com/advancing-football/fifa-forward/fifa-forward-report">FIFA Forward Report</a></li><li>Infantino Compensation: $6 million (2025), quadrupled from ~$1.5 million (2016) — <a href="https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/fifa-details-infantinos-6m-pay-200349385.html">AP News via Yahoo Sports</a></li><li>UEFA Champions League Annual Distributions: ~$2.47 billion — <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/1413269/champions-league-prize-money/">Statista / UEFA Financial Report</a></li><li>CJEU Diarra Ruling (2024): Struck down FIFA transfer rules as unlawful no-poaching agreements — <a href="https://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2024-10/cp240172en.pdf">CJEU Press Release 172/24</a></li><li>FIFA Committees: Expanded from 7 to 35 standing committees since 2016 reforms — <a href="https://apnews.com/article/fifa-statutes-committes-infantino-2f724ef9e023493acf772c6b66cae5f8">AP News</a></li><li>US Sponsorship Share: 14 of 26 partners, ~52% of total sponsorship revenue — <a href="https://www.mappr.co/fifa-world-cup-2026-revenue/">Mappr analysis</a></li><li>Asian Rights Collapse: China $250M to $60M; India ~$100M to $10–15M — <a href="https://apnews.com/article/world-cup-fifa-china-tv-rights-c516a5e27392e6220afdb433351c5f9b">AP News</a>, <a href="https://www.reuters.com/sports/soccer/fifa-faces-class-action-over-player-transfer-regulations-2025-08-04/">Reuters</a></li></ul><blockquote>Disclosure Statement</blockquote><blockquote>This article was prepared with the assistance of multiple AI tools for literature review, drafting, editing, and data analysis. The author reviewed, edited, and verified all AI-generated content and takes full responsibility for the final text.</blockquote><blockquote>This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. The author is not a financial advisor, has not received any payment or compensation for the content of this article, and has no professional investment qualifications. Readers should consult a qualified financial professional before making any investment decisions.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=87d990801243" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/fifas-13-billion-tightrope-87d990801243">FIFA’s $13 Billion Tightrope</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/">DataDrivenInvestor</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Space Church: Can the Math Justify the Faith?]]></title>
            <description><![CDATA[<div class="medium-feed-item"><p class="medium-feed-image"><a href="https://medium.com/the-investors-handbook/the-space-church-can-the-math-justify-the-faith-5b4d5530e8e4?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2"><img src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1906/1*FkBLCqmuzkEr32OOXGea1A.png" width="1906"></a></p><p class="medium-feed-snippet">The market is betting $2.4 trillion on SpaceX; a company with one profitable division, a grounded flagship rocket, a CEO who answers to no&#x2026;</p><p class="medium-feed-link"><a href="https://medium.com/the-investors-handbook/the-space-church-can-the-math-justify-the-faith-5b4d5530e8e4?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2">Continue reading on Investor’s Handbook »</a></p></div>]]></description>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-investors-handbook/the-space-church-can-the-math-justify-the-faith-5b4d5530e8e4?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5b4d5530e8e4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spacex]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[investing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ágoston Török]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Jun 2026 13:46:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-30T13:46:16.403Z</atom:updated>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Sound of Silence: Deconstructing Ferrari’s 2026 Strategic Pivot]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/the-sound-of-silence-deconstructing-ferraris-2026-strategic-pivot-3ea883ac3fcb?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3ea883ac3fcb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[formula-1]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[investing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[automotive]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ágoston Török]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Jun 2026 03:07:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-15T03:07:32.188Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Faced with volatile trade tariffs, changing emission targets, and the transition to silent electric supercars, Ferrari launches the Luce EV to defend its luxury brand exclusivity. Can the Maranello pioneer protect its premium moat?</h4><p>The Ferrari V12’s roar is not a simple design choice — it is the foundation of a €7 billion empire. That engine note is why customers pay $640,000 for a car, why the order book extends to 2027, and why Ferrari commands margins that make luxury peers envious. Now the company is launching the Luce EV, its first fully electric vehicle. And an electric motor is silent. Ferrari must invent a new sound, a new identity, and a new business model — all while defending the old one. This analysis maps Ferrari’s operational assets across the three fronts where this battle will be fought: the fortified luxury combustion core, the capital-intensive electrification vanguard, and the high-visibility racing halo. It culminates in a hypothetical CEO speech that names the tradeoffs Maranello’s leadership must confront.</p><h3>The Ghosts of Maranello</h3><p>The unveiling of the Ferrari Luce on May 25, 2026, marked the most controversial moment in the automaker’s modern history. As Ferrari’s first fully electric vehicle, developed in collaboration with the design firm LoveFrom, the Luce represents a radical departure from heritage. Starting at approximately $640,000, the vehicle boasts a quad-motor configuration delivering 1,050 horsepower, powered by an 880-volt architecture and a 122-kWh battery pack. Despite these extreme performance specifications, public response from the loyal fan base (tifosi) has been polarized, centered on the absence of the visceral roar that has defined the brand for nearly nine decades.</p><p>This tension is not new; it reflects a cyclical pattern that has defined Ferrari since its founding. Enzo Ferrari originally built and sold road cars for the sole purpose of funding his true passion, the Scuderia Ferrari racing team. Throughout its history, Ferrari’s survival has relied on maintaining a self-reinforcing flywheel: racing prestige drives road-car demand, which in turn generates the capital to fund racing R&amp;D. Historically, when this relationship fell out of balance, the company suffered. During the 1990s, President Luca di Montezemolo resolved a prolonged Formula 1 drought by hiring Jean Todt, who shielded technical operations from political interference, culminating in five consecutive Drivers’ Championships (2000 to 2004) under Michael Schumacher.</p><p>In 2014 the cycle turned to its business side, Sergio Marchionne initiated a commercial revolution by expanding production volumes past Montezemolo’s strict 7,000-unit cap, spinning Ferrari off from Fiat Chrysler Automobiles, and listing the company on the New York Stock Exchange in 2015. While purists feared brand dilution, this listing unlocked premium luxury valuation multiples (trading at approximately 50x earnings) and established Ferrari’s modern financial independence. Today, CEO Benedetto Vigna, a tech-sector veteran appointed in 2021, faces the challenge of adapting this historic legacy to a decarbonized future, concentrated at the historic Maranello campus. A difficult act because the cycle would demand racing to dominate the next decade while the market urges for an answer to the electrification challenge.</p><h3>Who Really Holds the Keys to the V12?</h3><p>Real decision-making power at Ferrari is shielded from public market pressure by a dynastic voting alliance. The company is controlled under a shareholder agreement renewed in January 2026 through 2029 (with an automatic 3-year extension option) between Exor N.V. (the Agnelli family holding company led by Chairman John Elkann) and the Piero Ferrari Trust. Through Ferrari’s loyalty voting program, which grants double voting rights for shares held longer than three years, Exor holds approximately 32.32% of voting power and the Piero Ferrari Trust holds approximately 16.17%. Together, they command a 48.49% voting majority, securing management from hostile takeovers and short-term earnings pressure.</p><p>This governance structure allows the board to enforce a unique executive incentive system. Compensation is heavily performance-based, with variable incentives representing over 80% of total executive packages. Under Vigna, short-term cash bonuses are tied directly to operational performance: Adjusted EBITDA Margin carries a 20% weight, while Industrial Free Cash Flow carries a 40% weight. Long-term incentives are awarded through Performance Share Units linked to relative Total Shareholder Return and ESG milestones (including carbon-neutrality targets). So revenue, volume, or directly the share price are all secondary.</p><p>To streamline execution under these targets, Vigna flattened Ferrari’s corporate structure in 2022. He removed middle management layers and reduced bureaucratic overhead, ensuring that Product Development, Research &amp; Development, and Digital Technologies report directly to the CEO. This structure is designed to integrate Ferrari’s three primary business segments: racing, road cars, and lifestyle brand collaborations. This helps in creating a consistent brand voice and strategy… It’s just not certain that the current challenges need exactly that or the opposite. More about this later.</p><h3>The Veblen Fortress: How Ferrari Turns Scarcity Into 30% Margins</h3><p>The question of structure matters because of what Ferrari actually sells. Ferrari does not sell transportation; it sells exclusive status. Its operational model is based on the principle of controlled scarcity. Rather than scaling production to meet market demand, the company deliberately limits deliveries to preserve brand exclusivity and pricing power. This strategy maintains an order book backlog that extends into late 2027, transforming vehicle ownership into a high-switching-cost status symbol that functions as a classic Veblen Good.</p><p>This scarcity supports exceptional operational margins. Ferrari commands a dominant market share of over 44% in the global hypercar and exotic vehicle segment. Rather than relying on traditional marketing, the company leverages Scuderia Ferrari’s F1 presence as its primary brand vehicle, eliminating advertising expenses. To capture incremental value from its existing customer base, Ferrari runs bespoke customization programs (such as Tailor Made), which contribute approximately 20% of Cars and Spare Parts revenue. This high-margin loyalty loop ensures that approximately 84% of new vehicles are sold to existing registered clients.</p><p>Such focus on exclusivity separates Ferrari’s economics from traditional luxury automotive peers. As shown in Figure 1, Ferrari’s operating return on sales (operating margin) of 29.5% for the fiscal year 2025 operates far above the luxury automotive benchmark (25.0%) and traditional manufacturers like Volkswagen.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zj3AyKijeZInLXYuTNHrpA.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 1: Ferrari Operating Margin (EBIT %) compared to luxury and volume automotive peers for FY 2025. Ferrari’s 29.5% operating margin operates far above the 25.0% luxury benchmark, separating its economics from traditional volume manufacturers like Volkswagen (3.3%) and luxury peers like Porsche (14.7%). Source: Company Financial Disclosures &amp; Investor Relations 2025–2026.</em></figcaption></figure><p>This is the Veblen Fortress in its purest form: a business model that turns scarcity into margin and margin into brand mystique. The mechanism works only as long as Ferrari controls supply tighter than demand pulls. The question ahead is whether electrification forces the company to break that rule. But before examining that technological pressure, it is worth understanding the financial arsenal Ferrari brings to the fight.</p><h3>The €7 Billion War Chest</h3><p>Ferrari’s financial profile is defined by cash surplus and capital efficiency (the dream combination of all investors). For the fiscal year 2025, the company reported net revenues of €7.146 billion and an operating profit of €2.11 billion. This momentum continued into Q1 2026, with the company achieving a pre-tax operating margin (EBITDA margin) of 39.1%, targeting a full-year EBITDA margin of at least 39%. As of March 31, 2026, Ferrari reported a net industrial cash surplus of €388 million, alongside €1.86 billion in total cash.</p><p>This cash surplus allows Ferrari to fund a capital-intensive transition without external borrowing. The company has committed €4.7 billion in capital expenditures between 2026 and 2030, dedicated to hybrid and electric vehicle R&amp;D, alongside facility upgrades like the new Maranello e-building. To manage this transition without diluting shareholder value, Ferrari is executing a €3.5 billion share buyback program (2026 to 2030), supported by an annual industrial free cash flow of €1,538 million in FY 2025.</p><p>To manage model transitions, Ferrari delivered 3,436 units in Q1 2026, a planned decrease. The company’s revised shipment mix targets for 2030 (Figure 2) reflect a balanced approach: 40% hybrid, 40% internal combustion engines, and 20% fully electric vehicles, halving its initial electric ambitions to align with cooling global luxury EV demand.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JWxAnRLr0JIUvEXWtRn4lw.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 2: Ferrari Shipment Mix Targets scaling toward 2030. The chart details the transition from 52% Hybrid and 48% ICE in FY 2025 to a revised target mix of 40% Hybrid, 20% BEV (Electric), and 40% ICE by 2030, reflecting the October 2025 strategic plan revision that halved electric ambitions to align with market realities. Source: Ferrari Strategic Plan &amp; October 2025 Update.</em></figcaption></figure><p>But financial strength alone cannot solve the existential threat of silence.</p><h3>Making Silence Scream: Ferrari’s Bet on Chassis Resonance and Hydrogen</h3><p>To mitigate the risk of engine silence, which threatens the brand’s performance DNA, Ferrari has developed proprietary acoustic technology. The company patented a mechanical sound synthesis system (<a href="https://patents.google.com/patent/EP4112384A1/">EP4112384A1</a>) that uses accelerometers on electric motors and axles to capture natural powertrain vibrations and amplify them mechanically through the vehicle’s structural chassis, avoiding simulated speaker noise.</p><p>The production of these electric drivetrains is housed in the new “e-building” in Maranello, inaugurated in June 2024 and fully operational in 2026. This flexible facility integrates the assembly of internal combustion, hybrid, and fully electric platforms on a single line using automated guided vehicles. To optimize battery weight and energy density, Ferrari signed an R&amp;D partnership with South Korea’s SK On in March 2024, securing pouch-format Nickel-Manganese-Cobalt (NMC) cells with an energy density of approximately 305 Wh/kg, which are assembled in-house. It also partners with NXP Semiconductors at the University of Bologna’s E-Cells Lab to research battery electrochemistry.</p><p>As a highly needed strategic hedge against a pure electric transition, Ferrari is investing in hydrogen combustion patents (featuring inverted engine layouts and chassis-integrated storage) and sustainable e-fuels. The company utilizes Formula 1’s transition to 100% sustainable fuels in 2026 as a testbed to extend the viability of its high-margin ICE vehicles.</p><p>These R&amp;D bets, the balance sheet that funds them, and the governance that shields them all converge on a single strategic picture.</p><h3>Three Fronts, Two Wars, One company</h3><p>To visualize how Ferrari is deploying its operational forces, securing its supply lines, and countering emergent threats, we mapped the group’s strategic posture using the <a href="https://agostontorok.github.io/strategy/stratmap/">StratMap tool</a> (see tool Help for a quick guide on how to read these maps).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*igOIVvbqVxbxZH4gH8SKgA.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 3: Ferrari Group 2026 Strategy Map (Full Zoom-Out). This battlefield view displays all goals (white), assets (blue), and threats (red). The map reveals how Ferrari must defend three strategic goals simultaneously.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Ferrari’s strategy map is anchored by three critical goals that define what is at stake. Farthest on the right is Brand Exclusivity; the business crown jewel, the reason customers pay $640,000 for a car. However, it’s a moving target as the world and Ferrari buyers are changing with it. Below that, on the left sits Maranello E-Building Capacity. Normally a factory modernization wouldn’t be so high on the value visibility scale, but in this case it acts also as a crucial identity challenge: can Ferrari scale flexible assembly of hybrid and electric powertrains without losing the bespoke craftsmanship that justifies its pricing. Finally, on the top left there is the ultimate brand voice channel, the Formula 1 World Championship. It presents the racing halo that feeds the entire brand flywheel — without it, the Ferrari mythos erodes.</p><p>The map reveals relatively few external threats, but the battlefield is structurally challenging. The three goals stretch the battlefield wide and one of the goals is even moving. Still, these are not three separate wars: Maranello’s expansion and the changing expectations of ultra-high-net-worth buyers are closely connected. The F1 World Championship, however, is a more complex story — how much is it part of the redefinition journey, and how much should it be first and foremost about building the best car and winning with it?</p><p>On face value, the situation is tight but winnable: Ferrari’s financial fortress and dynastic governance provide stability that most automakers lack, but the window to execute the EV transition without breaking the exclusivity moat is narrow.</p><h3>Front 1: The Maranello Electrification Front</h3><p>On this active front, the Flexible Maranello E-Building asset represents the tactical coordination hub. Stationed in the internal infrastructure tier, it is maturing and gaining fame, interestingly both being critical to achieve manufacturing scale. This building coordinates the assembly of ICE, hybrid, and electric models on a single line, feeding the Maranello E-Building Capacity goal at the customer visibility level.</p><p>To defend against the Soundless Electric Engines threat vector bearing down from the emerging tier, Ferrari deployed the Luce EV (w/ the EP4112384A1 Sound). This flagship vehicle is moving from custom reveal to product launch. It utilizes a unique patented mechanical chassis resonance to deliver authentic acoustic feedback. The mechanical resonance approach is a clever bet: Ferrari will be able to craft an EV that provides even more exclusivity than their ICE cars — the kind of visceral acceleration that only a $640k price tag can unlock, and once experienced, belongs only to the owner.</p><p>e-Fuels and Hydrogen are interesting but the SK On Battery Cell R&amp;D asset is even more consequential. It moves towards becoming the sole standard battery cell for Ferrari’s future lineup. Whether this exclusive-supplier relationship is an asset or a structural challenge is worth examining. Although Ferrari has another exclusive major supplier, Brembo, SK On lacks the same racing heritage, which carries both collaboration and image risk. Nonetheless, SK On has already proven itself in Ferrari’s plug-in hybrid supercars.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_esFavMG57or-bmAwcQGCQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 4: Maranello Electrification Front Viewpoint. Ferrari’s electric transition: combining the flexible e-building, Luce EV acoustic patents, and SK On battery partnerships to bypass the EU combustion ban and counter silent EV commoditization. Source: StratMap Server, Viewpoint 1.</em></figcaption></figure><h3>Front 2: The Luxury Core Front</h3><p>This front secures the primary revenue flow on the right side of the map. The ICE V12/V8 Production (i.e. the Cash Cow) asset is stationed as a massive, highly standardized, and mature asset at the customer value visibility. It acts as the fortified home base that generates the cash and margins required to fund the electrification transition. This asset feeds primarily today the Veblen Moat (Waitlist Backlog) asset to maintain artificial scarcity. The waitlist composition though has to change and Ferrari must find the right composition (ICE v. hybrid v. EV) of it, predicting their customer base of the future. The e-building certainly helps to fine-control and support this transition and wayfinding.</p><p>Ferrari notably did not simply exploit its ICE moat after the U.S. Vehicle Import Tariffs were absorbed by customers and the EU backtracked on the EU 2035 Combustion Engine Ban. This is a rare moment of strategic foresight: not losing sight of the bending curves of Brand Exclusivity while momentary changes shift the playing field.</p><p>The only challenge that is not momentary is the brilliant overtaking maneuver of Lamborghini, which has found a refreshed identity with its fleet of plug-in hybrids. The race is not over, and Lamborghini — the company created to compete with Ferrari — understands that better than anyone.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pHxqZ2MaFl-3Aq4vp9_Cyw.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 5: Luxury Core Front Viewpoint. The V12/V8 cash engine and waitlist backlog act as static moats, while strategic pricing campaigns are deployed to neutralize the U.S. import tariff threat. Source: StratMap Server, Viewpoint 2.</em></figcaption></figure><h3>Front 3: The Racing Prestige Front</h3><p>This cultural front details the brand halo at the top of the map. The Scuderia F1 Team asset is stationed at the cultural tier. Under previous periods, it suffered from organizational underperformance, drifting farther away from winning the championship. However, under the current strategy, it seems to be executing finally a major pivot: acquiring Hamilton and HP for the team are the kind of calibre moves that you need in order to have a chance for the Formula 1 World Championship goal.</p><p>This pivot represents a significant investment in custom engineering and elite talent (leveraging the Lewis Hamilton recruitment and the HP title sponsorship) to revitalize Scuderia Ferrari. The arrow shows a maneuver around the Mercedes engine +20 HP signalling that there is now customization work needed before the team could cross the barrier that the Mercedes team’s superior technology means.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IN7tkOfRZF--y9FwzldnBw.png" /><figcaption><em>Figure 6: Racing Prestige Front Viewpoint. Scuderia Ferrari F1 team executing the Championship Drive: leveraging elite technical and driving talent to maneuver around internal turf wars and secure the F1 World Championship. Source: StratMap Server, Viewpoint 3.</em></figcaption></figure><h3>Battlefield Scenarios: Testing the 2026 Strategy</h3><p>To evaluate the resilience of Ferrari’s strategic layout, we modeled two critical scenarios:</p><h4>Scenario A: Escalation of U.S. Import Tariffs (to 25%)</h4><ul><li>The Threat Shift: If geopolitical trade conflicts escalate, the <em>U.S. Vehicle Import Tariffs</em> threat vector reverses and push down the attainable brand exclusivity.</li><li>The Action Flow: With tariffs rising to 25% in Ferrari’s largest single market (accounting for 25% of shipments), absorbing the cost becomes impossible without eroding margins. Ferrari is forced to test the limits of customer price elasticity, raising MSRP across all North American models by 12% to 15%. If order cancellations exceed 5%, Ferrari must redirect shipments to European and Asian markets, shifting allocations to protect its global margin profile at the expense of North American market share. This poses additional risks on the already tricky balancing act on their backlog composition and probably pressuring a review of R&amp;D efforts in Maranello. Overall, the scenario is not severe enough to push Ferrari off its strategic course.</li></ul><h4>Scenario B: Regulatory Enforcement of EU 2035 strict Zero-Emission Ban</h4><ul><li>The Threat Shift: If the EU repeals the proposed e-fuel exemptions and reverts to a strict 100% emission phase-out by 2035, the <em>EU 2035 Combustion Ban</em> rock becomes a permanent legal wall, blocking the path of both <em>ICE V12/V8 Production</em> and <em>e-Fuels &amp; Hydrogen R&amp;D</em>.</li><li>The Action Flow: Ferrari’s hedging strategy through sustainable e-fuels in F1 is cut off from the road-car division. The company is forced to accelerate its electrification roadmap, redirecting capital from share buybacks and e-fuel testing to scale the Maranello e-building’s EV capacity. This will certainly make the company reevaluate its priorities. One speculative option: Ferrari could use its lobbying power to reshape Formula E regulations (e.g. custom chassis with standard battery) to create a racing series that feeds road-car EV development — much like F1 did for ICE a century ago. Unlikely, but an instructive thought experiment.</li></ul><p>The map reveals a company fighting on three fronts with one army. Ferrari’s financial and governance foundations are solid, but the cumulative weight of defending all three goals simultaneously is the real risk. The scenarios show that no single threat is fatal — it is the combination that demands prioritization. From that analysis, three specific moves emerge as the most urgent.</p><h3>The Three Moves That Matter: Ferrari’s Strategic Priorities</h3><p>The following three actions are ranked in order of urgency and each traces directly to a named element on the Strategy Map:</p><ol><li>Neutralize competitor engine advantages — overcome the Mercedes engine +20 HP rock by executing the Hamilton + HP drive toward the Formula 1 World Championship goal.</li><li>Scale in-house powertrain resonance — expand production of the EP4112384A1 system so every Luce EV (EP4112384A1 Sound) defends against the Soundless Electric Engines threat and justifies the luxury price premium.</li><li>Protect the exclusivity cap — hold deliveries below the 14,000-unit ceiling to keep the Veblen Moat (Waitlist Backlog) intact and the Brand Exclusivity goal reachable.</li></ol><p>These three moves are the minimum viable response to the map’s pressures. Individually, each is achievable; together, they demand an organizational discipline Ferrari has not consistently shown. Executing them would shift the strategy map from defense toward offense — but only if the organization is willing to hear what the strategy requires.</p><h3>The Speech Maranello Needs to Hear</h3><p>What follows is not a transcript. It is a recommended scenario, the speech we believe Ferrari’s leadership should deliver if the strategic priorities outlined in this analysis were to be adopted in full. Our analysis suggests that several of these priorities run directly counter to the current public posture of CEO Benedetto Vigna, who has emphasized continuity, gradual electrification, and brand optimism in public statements. For that reason, the most credible delivery of this speech might not come from Vigna himself; it could come from a newly appointed Chief Strategy Officer or an incoming successor, someone with the authority to name uncomfortable truths without being politically exposed by having previously said the opposite.</p><p>Imagine a late-afternoon closed session in the main assembly hall at Maranello, the same floor where the V12s are hand-assembled. The hall is cleared of its normal workforce. Around sixty people are seated in folding chairs: the full senior leadership team, the Scuderia sporting director, the heads of powertrain and design, and the board members who flew in from Amsterdam. There are no journalists, no slides, no recorded livestream. The speaker stands at a bare wooden podium placed directly in front of a partially assembled Purosangue, its unpainted carbon fiber chassis visible under the factory lights. The speech begins without applause.</p><blockquote>“Let us be completely honest with ourselves. We are sitting on record revenues of 7.1 billion euros, an operating return on sales of 29.5 percent, and an order book that extends into 2027. Wall Street looks at our stock price and calls us a luxury miracle. But the ground beneath us is shifting, and if we do not adapt, our myth will dissolve.</blockquote><blockquote>“Our brand was built on the mechanical symphony of our V12 and V8 engines. The sound of a Ferrari is our primary emotional hook, the heart of our exclusivity. But we are now entering an era where governments are forcing us to transition to electric power. And an electric motor is silent. If we build silent supercars, we become commoditized. We become just another fast electric vehicle, indistinguishable from a Tesla or a Porsche. We cannot allow that to happen.</blockquote><blockquote>“We have built the new e-building in Maranello. We are investing 4.7 billion euros over the next five years to build electric motors, high-voltage battery packs, and new architectures. This is a massive capital risk. We are not outsourcing this to the lowest bidder. We are doing it ourselves because we must own the technology that makes a Ferrari a Ferrari. We have patented systems to capture and mechanically amplify motor vibrations through the chassis. It is not simulated speaker noise; it is real, mechanical feedback. If this technology fails to convince our customers, our luxury pricing power will collapse.</blockquote><blockquote>“At the same time, we face trade wars. The United States, our largest market, has introduced tariffs on our cars. We have responded by raising prices on select models. But there is a limit to how far we can push our clients’ loyalty. We must optimize our logistics, protect our margins, and accept that the days of frictionless global trade are over.</blockquote><blockquote>“In Formula One, we are in a historic drought. We have not won a Drivers’ Championship since 2007. This is unacceptable. Our racing heritage is the halo that allows us to sell road cars for half a million euros. But our racing team has suffered from a toxic culture of blame and constant management turnover. That ends now. We are going to protect our engineering team, give them the stability they need, and focus on winning.</blockquote><blockquote>“We are not going to chase volume. We will not dilute our brand by building cheap cars. We will continue to build one car less than the market demands. Our execution must be flawless. If you are here for easy stock options or corporate comfort, your time is up. We are going to make hard choices, invest in technology, and defend our exclusivity at all costs. Let’s get to work.”</blockquote><blockquote>Benedetto Vigna, CEO, Ferrari N.V., June 2026</blockquote><h3>Key Facts and Metrics</h3><ul><li>Profitability — EBIT Margin (FY 2025): 29.5% (Operating return on sales) — <a href="https://www.ferrari.com/en-EN/corporate">Ferrari Investor Relations</a></li><li>Operating Cash — Q1 2026 EBITDA Margin: 39.1% (Pre-tax operating margin) — <a href="https://www.ferrari.com/en-EN/corporate">Ferrari Q1 2026 Financials</a></li><li>Cash Reserves — Net Industrial Cash Position: €388 Million surplus (cash exceeding industrial debt) — <a href="https://www.ferrari.com/en-EN/corporate">Ferrari Q1 2026 Disclosure</a></li><li>Capital Expenditures — Transition CapEx (2026–2030): €4.7 Billion committed to hybrid and electric R&amp;D — <a href="https://www.ferrari.com/en-EN/corporate">Ferrari Capital Markets Day</a></li><li>Demographic Shift — Buyers Under 40: Increased from 30% to 40% of new clients in 18 months — <a href="https://motor1.com/">Motor1 Analysis</a></li><li>Competitive Threat — Lamborghini Global Sales (2025): 10,747 units (record), exceeding €3B revenue via plug-in hybrid electric vehicle [PHEV] pivot — <a href="https://www.lamborghini.com/en-en/news">Lamborghini News</a></li><li>Shareholder Payout — Multi-Year Share Buybacks: €3.5 Billion share repurchase program (2026–2030) — <a href="https://www.ferrari.com/en-EN/corporate">Ferrari Share Repurchase Plan</a></li><li>Product Margins — Personalization Revenue Contribution: ~20% of Cars and Spare Parts sales (bespoke tailoring) — <a href="https://www.ferrari.com/en-EN/corporate">Ferrari Annual Report</a></li><li>Exclusivity Moat — Order Book Backlog: Waitlist extends through the end of 2027 (controlled scarcity) — <a href="https://www.ferrari.com/en-EN/corporate">Ferrari IR Presentation</a></li><li>Technology Patent — Electric Sound Synthesis System: EP4112384A1 (Mechanical chassis resonance amplification) — <a href="https://patents.google.com/patent/EP4112384A1/en">European Patent Office</a></li><li>Battery Supplier — Primary High-Voltage Cell Partner: SK On (Nickel-Manganese-Cobalt cells, ~305 Wh/kg density) — <a href="https://www.sk.com/">SK Group Communications</a></li><li>Sovereign Control — Exor &amp; Piero Ferrari Voting Rights: ~48.49% combined voting power (via loyalty share program) — <a href="https://www.ferrari.com/en-EN/corporate">Ferrari Shareholders Meeting 2026</a></li></ul><blockquote>Disclosure Statement</blockquote><blockquote>This article was prepared with the assistance of multiple AI tools for literature review, drafting, editing, and data analysis. The author reviewed, edited, and verified all AI-generated content and takes full responsibility for the final text.</blockquote><blockquote>This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. The author is not a financial advisor, has no professional investment qualifications, and has not received any payment or compensation for the content of this article. Readers should consult a qualified financial professional before making any investment decisions.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3ea883ac3fcb" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/the-sound-of-silence-deconstructing-ferraris-2026-strategic-pivot-3ea883ac3fcb">The Sound of Silence: Deconstructing Ferrari’s 2026 Strategic Pivot</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/">DataDrivenInvestor</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[3 Reasons Why Friends Are Better at Strategy than Business Executives]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/3-reasons-why-friends-are-better-at-strategy-than-business-executives-cc33a91e6bd9?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cc33a91e6bd9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-visualization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wardley-maps]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mapping]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership-skills]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ágoston Török]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 17 Nov 2025 11:32:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-17T11:32:54.383Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Because purpose beats process — and most companies get that backwards.</h4><p>Imagine the following: Albert, Tobias, Günther and Leni are highschool friends. Today, they are all in their thirties and live in different parts of Europe, but this year they decided to visit the Oktoberfest together. They planed it, executed it and nailed it. No strategy deck. No MBA. No management consulting.</p><p>Now imagine the same four as executives, heading different departments of the same company planning next year. Dozens of slides. Yet misalignment in execution. So:</p><blockquote>Why do people who’ve never studied strategy outperform people who get paid to do it?</blockquote><p>The thesis I’m making here is that friends align through a shared <strong>purpose</strong>. Executives align through a shared <strong>process</strong>. The first creates strategy. The second creates bureaucracy.</p><h3>Reason #1 — Start with the purpose</h3><p>Simon Sinek sketched the concept of the <a href="https://simonsinek.com/golden-circle/">golden circle</a> in his book Start with why. The core tennet there is that leaders should start with explaining their purpose (“Why”) before explaining “How” they want to reach that and “What” the team have to do. This is a model well known to executives too, what is less known how much it’s not the presentation but the <em>understanding</em> that matters. For the friends well before the Oktoberfest they had a shared why: Friendship brings joy. The Oktoberfest was only part of the how: Spend time together there. And the organizational aspects all derive from that: Some may need to fly, others can take a train, others will drive and in our example, Leni decided to bike from her hometown.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yXun-nwlmlqTwhAVH3zR2Q.png" /><figcaption>Fig 1. Tobias, Günther, Leni and Albert decided to visit the Oktoberfest this year. They wanted to maximize the time spent together so they did the following. Tobias took the train to Nuremberg where Albert picked him up with his new Porsche Taycan. They drove then to Munich airport to meet Günther who was just arriving from London. Leni lives next to Munich so she had the most flexibility, therefore she took the bike and cycled — enjoying the amazing alpen views- to Munich to meet them.</figcaption></figure><p>In companies, ‘why’ turns into quarterly OKRs. ‘How’ becomes frameworks. ‘What’ becomes KPIs. Everyone’s busy, no one’s aligned. See, on a purpose level a “successful next year” means different things for the CFO and the CTO. The CFO is going to think along words such as revenue, profit or cost saves, while the CTO is going to think along scaling technology, new disruptions, connecting components. Even their incentives are biased so they think like this, few CFO gets bonus based on key patents filed. This is where a CEO will come to picture and makes either a deal where everyone’s incentives are part of the strategy or where they make a “deal” with the executive whose own incentives are going to suffer so the company makes a great year.</p><h3>Reason #2 — Shared mental representation</h3><p>When the four friends plan the trip, they probably have a totally different mental model from Fig 1. While Fig 1. displays the geographical relations, it says very little about two key components of the “What”: the effort and the timing. The mental model of the friends is something more alike (but definitely not exactly :D) the below <a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/how-to-draw-a-strategy-in-4-steps-2e6232e4578f">Wardley-Torok map</a>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tYG2vEMofg9GhotZfT-Djw.png" /><figcaption>Fig 2. The strategy to have the most fun on together this autumn. The figure shows in red the Value components of the strategy. Their position on the y axis is how much their value is visible from the goal’s point of view. Their distribution along the horizontal axis goes from uncharted territory to everyday commodity. With blue some example threats are shows that can affect how the team reaches their goal. Note, the visibility axis of threats in inverted. Figure made with the free online <a href="https://wardley-torok-map-creator.windsurf.build/">Wardley-Torok map creator.</a></figcaption></figure><p>Look at how different this representation is from the above conventional map. All of a sudden the story is not dominated by Günther’s travel from London. Instead we start to see much better that Tobias, Günther and Albert will need to coordinate so Albert can pick the other two up with his car. Also, it will become clear that actually Leni - who is otherwise the closest to the venue - chose the most risky way of travel and the other three will pray so she arrives safely.</p><blockquote>If you can’t see the same landscape, you’re not on the same journey.</blockquote><p>It’s also clear that different purposes (i.e. “Whys) yield different representations of the “What”. Imagine that our executives are doing the planning and one of them — Günther, Chief Marketing Officer — wants to show how important his contribution to the success is. Which kind of representation would he use? The one where his journey dominates or the one where he’s seemingly playing only a supporting role?</p><p>Executives rarely share the same map. Marketing sees brand reach, finance sees runway, product sees roadmap. Different terrains, different coordinates, different executions.</p><h3>Reason #3 — Zooming in and out</h3><p>Once you have a shared and aligned purpose, it’s much easier to zoom in and out along the golden circle dimension. Let’s say Tobias starts to worry that it’s might be raining on one of the days. That on our Wardley-Torok map is a threat that risks the goal, that is enjoying the Oktoberfest. However, it’s very likely that one of the others are going to zoom out and say <em>“but the main goal is to have fun together”</em> — from here refining the How and What is much easier — <em>“so we can get umbrellas or raincoat or even find a place that we can approach with minimal exposure to the rain.”</em></p><blockquote>When friends zoom out, they adapt. When executives can’t, they escalate — because hierarchy replaces perspective.</blockquote><p>This kind of democratic process rarely works well in the executives setting. Often you need either a process or more often a CEO who owns the Why-How-What picture ultimately and can keep the discussion focused. This is no easy job, so much so that many CEOs cannot effectively cope with this task. This results in something I call P<strong>owerPoint cartography</strong>: lots of slides and complex figures with zero relation to the actual <a href="https://medium.com/agileinsider/strategy-vs-situation-misfit-how-to-recognize-it-858c95cb0c2c">terrain</a> where the business operates.</p><p>Without clear knowledge of the different levels of golden circle, you end with a representation (typically a long document) that contains everything… and it’s opposite as well. These documents are useful for</p><ul><li>(1) making a strategy inclusive of everyone’s own angle.</li><li>(2) divert blame from management because ___ (insert failed component of success) was also part of strategy and it was the people who didn’t understand it well.</li></ul><p>And these documents are definitely cannot be used for</p><ul><li>(3) executing on a common strategy together</li></ul><p>This is because there is a finite envelope of attention, so people have a limited bandwidth of what they can process as information. Heck, even the above Wardley-Torok maps can easily breach that limit. A painful lesson that I learned many times over.</p><p>Level Friends (Purpose-driven) Executives (Process-driven) <strong>Reason #1</strong> Start with “why” Start with frameworks and KPIs <strong>Reason #2</strong> Shared mental model (“we see the same map”) Shared model of procedure (“we use the same template”) <strong>Reason #3</strong> Zoom naturally between purpose and action Zoom mechanically between slide levels</p><h3>Purpose without illusion</h3><p>Friends succeed because they share a clear purpose.<br>Now ask yourself: does your company have one — or just a plan that looks like one?</p><p>When people truly share a purpose, everything else — priorities, trade-offs, even setbacks — align naturally. That shared understanding becomes your biggest advantage.</p><p>If it is not there, don’t pretend it is. Purpose at the cultural level is extremely hard to retrofit. Only a rare few leaders manage it. Most companies don’t really share a purpose, and that’s fine — someone just has to own it. That person has to keep the ‘why’ alive, align the ‘how’ and ‘what’ around it, and treat friction and small misalignments part of the terrain, not a failure.</p><p>A good strategy doesn’t need perfect unity — it needs coherence, solid processes, and a leader who stays anchored while adjusting the course as reality shifts. Authentic belief in the purpose scales better than forced consensus.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cc33a91e6bd9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/3-reasons-why-friends-are-better-at-strategy-than-business-executives-cc33a91e6bd9">3 Reasons Why Friends Are Better at Strategy than Business Executives</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/">DataDrivenInvestor</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Ten Patent Cases That Formed History]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.productcoalition.com/ten-patent-cases-that-formed-history-67f9bffc782e?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/67f9bffc782e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[product-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[intellectual-property]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patents]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[legal]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ágoston Török]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 10 May 2025 19:10:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-26T08:08:06.557Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Ten Patent Cases That Shaped History</h3><h4>Beyond legalese, there is a clever system for intellectual property protection</h4><p>Working together with researchers, engineers, and lawyers on inventions and patents is among my favourite activities in my job. Early on, I had the fortune of learning from some very clever inventors and patent attorneys how a patent is built up and gaining a good understanding of the patenting language. No, I still can’t say I speak <a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/legalese">legalese</a> but there are inventions, patents and patent dispute cases that I admire for their striking examples of human ingenuity.</p><p>The cases we are going to cover:</p><p>· <a href="#e08d">1. Infringement Without a Product: NTP v. Research in Motion</a><br>· <a href="#af88">2. Function or Fashion? Apple v. Samsung Electronics</a><br>· <a href="#4c53">3. The Fine Line Between Brilliant and Trivial: Amazon v. Barnes &amp; Noble</a><br>· <a href="#fd55">4. The Patent War of Attrition: Nokia vs. Apple</a><br>· <a href="#d788">5. Pricing Out the Competition: Google Inc. v. Art+Com</a><br>· <a href="#8af4">6. The Longest Process in Instant Photography: Kodak v. Polaroid</a><br>· <a href="#604c">7. The Local Inventor Bias: Chint vs. Schneider Electric</a><br>· <a href="#455d">8. Meanwhile in Europe: Panasonic v. Oppo</a><br>· <a href="#bda5">9. Can You Infringe a Patent in Your Own Backyard? Bowman v. Monsanto</a><br>· <a href="#6037">10. HeLa Cells: Discovery v. Invention</a></p><h3>1. Infringement Without a Product: NTP v. Research in Motion</h3><p>I guess you haven’t heard about NTP, but if you are over 30, you know very Research in Motion (RIM), the producer of BlackBerry phones. If you don’t know what those were, then in short, in the 2000s, every business person was fidgeting with one while they were talking about how important people they were. NTP, though never produced phones, in fact they don’t have any business other than holding and enforcing the <a href="https://patents.google.com/?assignee=NTP+Inc&amp;oq=assignee:(NTP+Inc)">patent portfolio</a> of the founder, Thomas Campana. Campana was a smart inventor and a good patent expert; he patented some key technology steps underlying telecommunications and then tried licensing these technologies to big firms like<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_J._Campana_Jr."> AT&amp;T and RIM</a>.</p><p>Since RIM didn’t buy the license, NTP <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-story-behind-the-blackberry-case">sued</a> them in 2001 for infringing five of their patents covering the push-email technology that was BlackBerry’s unique selling point. The stakes were high because the court could have stopped RIM from using the technology, which would have been a disaster for all <a href="https://www.cbc.ca/news/science/blackberry-leads-handheld-pack-in-2006-report-1.644329">3.5 million users in the US</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9-gMmxAOOrxD26Ha" /></figure><p>An iPhone 4 and a Blackberry Q10 next to each other. While the world was turning towards iPhone at this time, I did everything to get a Q10 for myself. I loved it! Image from <a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/janitors/9190573959">Karlis Dambrans</a></p><p>The situation was so severe that the US Department of Defense (another heavy BlackBerry user at the time) also intervened and told the court that stopping the use of technology would cripple national telecommunications. RIM also tried everything; they spent a fortune getting the best lawyers and reasoned that because the servers are in Canada, the US patent law doesn’t apply; but none of these helped.</p><p>The resolution was ultimately to settle outside of court in 2006, and RIM agreed to pay NTP <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NTP,_Inc."><strong>$612.5 million</strong></a> for a perpetual license on their patents. This was the largest settlement to date at that point showing how even tech giants are vulnerable to smaller entities holding essential patents.</p><p>Companies like NTP are an integral component of the patenting world today. They show that patents protect not only a company’s products or revenue streams but also its inventions. While NTP managed the portfolio of its founder, many similar firms just buy patents from inventors or bankrupt companies. These latter types are often referred to as patent trolls. If you are interested in how effective these companies can be, check out <a href="https://sulleelaw.com/intel-vs-vlsi-case-study-important-case-study-implications/">VLSI Technology</a> (LLC, not Inc) and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniloc_USA,_Inc._v._Microsoft_Corp.">Uniloc USA</a>.</p><h3>2. Function or Fashion? Apple v. Samsung Electronics</h3><p>When you hold an Apple or a Samsung phone in your hand, their shape and layout have some characteristics that are unique to the brand e.g. Apple had the circle home key while Samsung had a more rectangular one). At the same time, they are very similar, e.g., the bottom row and the rest of the screen have icons in a grid. Importantly, you can protect your design also with patents (e.g. the <a href="https://www.lexisnexisip.com/resources/pop-culture-patents-coca-colas-bottle-design/">Coke bottle</a>). So when you’d see a competitor coming out with a very similar look and feel you could assert your rights to the design invention.</p><p>This is precisely what happened in <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Inc._v._Samsung_Electronics_Co.">2011</a> when Samsung came out with their response to the iPhone and iPad, and Apple sued them over patent infringement. In fact, they not only sued over strictly design but also over essential functional elements (e.g. the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8JZBLjxPBUU">pinch-to-zoom</a> functionality). The saga travelled around the world and was trialled from the US through Germany to South Korea and Australia. Shortly after the initial filing, Samsung countersued Apple to make the story not so one-sided, importantly, they didn’t sue on the basis of design but over wireless technology patents.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*gj2CjXwXqhZkpvVT" /></figure><p>Indeed, the question is valid why the Samsung design language changed so much? Image from <a href="https://images.iphonemod.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/samsung-pay-apple-539-million-for-infringing-iphone-patents.jpg">iphonemod.net</a></p><p>Headlines were full of updates; my favourite one was a quote from the <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2012/jul/09/samsung-apple-cool-ipad-tablet">UK Judge</a> who said Samsung tablets were “not as cool” as iPads. Although Samsung made design changes to avoid the worst outcome of injunctions (i.e. sentence of stopping selling devices), the court in <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Inc._v._Samsung_Electronics_Co.">Germany</a> banned the Galaxy Tab 10.1. Interestingly, in <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Inc._v._Samsung_Electronics_Co.">South Korea</a> on the home turf of Samsung, the court gave rights to both companies. In 2012, the US case initially ended with $1.05 billion sentence. Luckily for Samsung, it was later reduced to <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Inc._v._Samsung_Electronics_Co.">$539</a> million by the court. The parties finally settled outside of court, and the actual amount remained confidential.</p><p>There are some crucial legacies of these proceedings. One is that today companies meticulously document design and UX research processes to build a strong case against accusations from competitors that they are infringing other’s designs. Another is that since then, design cross-licensing deals mushroomed industry-wide. <a href="https://www.theverge.com/2012/8/30/3279628/apple-pinch-to-zoom-patent-myth">Fun fact</a>, the pinch-to-zoom functionality is still on Samsung devices because Apple just patented one specific way of doing that.</p><h3>3. The Fine Line Between Brilliant and Trivial: Amazon v. Barnes &amp; Noble</h3><p>While you can patent a design, there are very valuable processes you cannot. In order to be an invention, it has to include some kind of technological innovation. Take the example of clicking on the “Buy now” button on Amazon. On other websites, you’d enter a funnel of filling out shipping details, adding payment method, verifying all details and clicking the send order button. I hate it, and to be honest, it happened several times that I just decided to abandon the whole purchase because it was so cumbersome to place my order. The <a href="https://patents.google.com/patent/US5960411A/en">brilliant idea</a> of Amazon was that since address and payment rarely change for most users, they could just automatically add those securely to each order and so improve massively the likelihood that the user purchases a product. Great, isn’t it?</p><p>Indeed, it’s so great that the US patent office granted this patent to Amazon (a bit of a trivia knowledge that Jeff Bezos was among the inventors). Amazon made — presumably good money — not only from actually using it for its own marketplace but also from licensing it to other companies such as <a href="https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2000/09/18Apple-Licenses-Amazon-com-1-Click-Patent-and-Trademark/">Apple</a>. Of course, having such an essential technology patent meant that Amazon had to actively look out for infringements and enforce its rights, motivating others to license the technology.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*YrRJRZyzmNW3Vjys" /></figure><p>One of the inventors of the 1-click patent. Image from <a href="https://flickr.com/photos/163370954@N08/32878819397/in/photolist-S6oxwv-2mAWTqu-4agg8-cUeh4-7C21Fq-8Pg25W-2iufHVo-feKmF4-2hVmHjM-A5hR-KnTpuD-KnTprn-KfWsgx-KnTpCp-KnTpvF-rSdRz-KnTpAF-rSdQ8-jNH9MR-dtztdK-4GCRQK-cUegF-2ibhAGk-2mMKRcP-pW4E1F-2kQmdhP-2kGQsPd-GXcx7-27ff4Lh-fsxB23-2mSV2KM-2kdFK15-rT63p-s3etE-2kQ32KU-RkPqrr-577uen-aAqp8d-dEXt13-63mStz-2md97Wa-CJuuK-fsigpF-2m4CZin-2mMFNv5-2knXrKG-e8hcNw-GSRpc-2mSV2kZ-2iK9nLj">Daniel Oberhaus</a></p><p>They were eagerly waiting for the patent granting because Barnes &amp; Noble introduced an Express Lane solution similar to Amazon’s 1-click technology. So, right after the patent was granted in 1999, they <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amazon.com,_Inc._v._Barnesandnoble.com,_Inc.">sued Barnes &amp; Noble</a>. Barnes &amp; Noble claimed that although the idea is great, it’s also trivial, that is, anyone who knows web programming would do precisely that if they were tasked with speeding up the process of placing the order. Interestingly, the 1-click process patent wasn’t even granted in many countries for similar reasons outside the US. Nevertheless, it didn’t convince the district court, and they ordered Barnes &amp; Noble to stop using the technology.</p><p>So, they had to change their process to a two-click version, where you still had to verify the details with an additional click. However, Barnes &amp; Noble didn’t want to give up the fight so easily and appealed, bringing the case to the Federal Circuit Court. That court was not convinced by the inventive value of Amazon’s patent and cited a previous system by Compuserve almost a decade before that allowed for a similar single-action experience. They didn’t invalidate the patent, but they allowed Barnes &amp; Noble to use their technology again.</p><p>This didn’t mean the end of the story, though. Both parties knew Amazon could still appeal the decision, so they settled outside of court in <a href="https://patentyogi.com/latest-patents/amazon/amazon-1-click-patent-was-worth-billions/">2002</a>. The settlement details are not public, but it seems Barnes &amp; Noble didn’t license Amazon’s technology in the end because they continued using their 2-click system.</p><p>The big lesson from this case is that it’s often difficult to tell retrospectively whether an invention was trivial or brilliant. Inventors typically approach this by conducting extensive research on past technologies and clearly defining how their solution is novel compared to those. Of course, having these essential technology patents in one’s portfolio is a critical strategic advantage.</p><h3>4. The Patent War of Attrition: Nokia vs. Apple</h3><p>Some essential technologies become even part of standards (e.g. 3G/4G/5G), and they will be labelled as standard-essential patents (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Essential_patent">SEP</a>). The good thing with those patents is that — since they are part of the standards — every company must license them. This is a serious advantage to the patent holders, luckily not infinite, as they are also required to license it under Fair, Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasonable_and_non-discriminatory_licensing">FRAND</a>) terms. This is supposed to level the playing field and while in many cases it works, it can also lead to lengthy patent disputes.</p><p>That’s what happened in 2009 when Nokia sued Apple over infringement of 46 of their patents on GSM, Wi-Fi and touchscreen technologies. They demanded Apple to pay <a href="https://www.cnet.com/culture/nokia-sues-apple-for-patent-infringement/">a royalty per iPhone</a> as a contribution to the creation of these mobile standards. Apple was in deep trouble because Nokia had a portfolio of more than<a href="https://patents.google.com/?assignee=Nokia&amp;country=US&amp;before=priority:20090101"> 40.000 patents</a> and had a strong patent and IP protection strategy at the heart of their business. This is so much so that in 2023, Nokia’s patent portfolio generated more than $1 billion in revenue (<a href="https://www.nokia.com/system/files/2024-03/nokia-annual-report-2023.pdf">page 30</a>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*l2nmSG8_-lOZKvQx" /></figure><p>Nokia has a long history of telecommunications innovations amassing an astonishing amount of patents. Image from <a href="http://www.tuquesabesdeesto.com/">www.tuquesabesdeesto.com</a></p><p>Having so many patents is a very powerful asset because the sheer amount of patents can make a court case simply too costly and time-consuming for anybody. Because although the news picks up more the size of the fines or settlements, there are <a href="https://www.copperpodip.com/post/how-much-does-patent-litigation-cost">millions of dollars</a> in costs, even for simple cases. Now, in the case of 40.000 patents, this is obviously much bigger. And that’s not even mentioning the time, in court proceedings, they not only read the patents of the parties but do a discovery process which extends to both extensive research in the literature and into investigation of company internal documents. This latter is necessary to prove whether an inventive process was really taking place.</p><p>The dispute expanded globally, and in Germany and the Netherlands, Nokia even managed to get the courts to order Apple to stop selling iPhones. Ultimately, Apple accepted defeat and <a href="https://www.apple.com/fi/newsroom/2017/05/nokia-and-apple-sign-agreement-settle-all-litigation/">settled</a> outside of court for <strong>$2 billion</strong> <strong>and ongoing royalties </strong>(the exact terms remained confidential) in 2017.</p><p>The lesson of this case is that the size of a patent portfolio matters. Although Nokia was no longer dominating the smartphone markets, its strong patent strategy became a financial lifeline for the company. Patents grant 15–20 years of protection, so companies can still profit massively from their past innovations even if their present innovation declines.</p><h3>5. Pricing Out the Competition: Google Inc. v. Art+Com</h3><p>We have just touched upon the costs of intellectual property disputes. The next case shows a clever but very dark side of this story. In 1995, a German design firm Art+Com filed a patent to protect their spatial visualisation method, Terravision, which is very similar to the latter product of Google Earth.</p><p>Google Earth launched in 2001, and the Art+Com team was discussing with Google to license or sell their patent to them; however, once they agreed on the general terms, the communication suddenly dried up. Initially, there were afraid to go against Google on court but ultimately, they did file a lawsuit in 2014.</p><p>They were seeking $100 million in damages for infringing their patent. They claimed that Google copied their solution after a 1994 demo the future Google Earth founding team attended. Furthermore, that they didn’t only use the method but also copied the code from Art+Com. If you want more details, I suggest watching the quite (i.e. not entirely) accurate Netflix series about it: <a href="https://www.netflix.com/title/81074012">The Billion Dollar Code</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1PDt4sQA3xWgQ596" /></figure><p>See a great mini-series about this story on Netflix: The Billion Dollar Code. Image from <a href="http://sefiks.com/">sefiks.com</a></p><p>Google’s legal team followed a clever and dark strategy. They hired high-profile key witnesses and provided the Art+Com legal team with an obscene amount of documentation of the Google inventive process, trying to cripple them both financially and effort-wise. They also found a project called SRI Terravision from the Stanford Research Institute that showed a similar method for flying over geographical scales. The Art+Com team claimed that the SRI Terravision solution <a href="https://legal-patent.com/patent-law/did-google-earth-steal-code-from-terra-vision-netflix-plot-reality-check/">lacked key elements</a> of their patent, most notably the tree-like representation of different zoom levels. Both the jury was not convinced and, in the end, deemed Google didn’t infringe the patent and that Art+Com’s patent invalid due to this prior art.</p><p>There are two main bitter but essential lessons from this case. First, patent litigation can be costly, and in some cases, the current practice favours patent holders with large enough budgets. Second, inventors should be very careful when sharing information with anybody outside of the inventor team. Demos should be constantly under <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-disclosure_agreement">NDA</a> before the patent is filed and early documentation of actions (emails, discussions etc.) serve crucial evidence in a legal fight.</p><h3>6. The Longest Process in Instant Photography: Kodak v. Polaroid</h3><p>Let’s see now another case which has a similar David vs. Goliath vibe to it but ends differently. Edwin Land, the founder of Polaroid, was one of the greatest inventors in history. His dream was to make instant photography reality and despite how simple these instant cameras look today the technology is highly complex and sophisticated. Just think about it: the shutter exposes the film to light, which should create a photo positive BUT the film shouldn’t be light sensitive anymore when seconds later it exits the camera.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/605/1*JCO8Xg0hgeR9K2IXPuS1jA.png" /></figure><p>Many consider Edwin Land the greatest inventor of the 20th century. Besides of instant photography inventions, he pioneered polarized sunglasses too. Image from <a href="http://brewminate.com/">brewminate.com</a></p><p>Land and his team worked on the technology for a span of <a href="https://patents.google.com/patent/US2609296A/en">30+ years</a> by the time when Kodak came out with their instant camera. Kodak knew a lot about Polaroid and in fact they worked together in the past as Kodak was producing the films for the Polaroid cameras. They were also aware of the patents that Land and his team held but thought that on the one hand they are not strong enough and on the other the size of Polaroid does not allow a lengthy fight which would be peanuts for the world’s largest photo company, Kodak.</p><p>Kodak also cleverly implemented some solutions in their EK6 camera that made it not a simple copy of the Polaroid cameras. Unfortunately, those details made the camera heavier, less usable and the pictures more fragile. Nevertheless, the strategy was to gain market from Polaroid with aggressive marketing and discounts.</p><p>Polaroid had a strong patent strategy though from its inception and went on fighting for 14-years. Ultimately, the jury ordered Kodak to pay <a href="https://library.torontomu.ca/asc/2013/08/kodak-versus-polaroid-the-battle-for-instant-photography-2/">$925 million in damages</a> and stop selling instant cameras and films for the existing ones in the market. This left an estimated <a href="https://www.upi.com/Archives/1986/10/06/Kodak-loses-high-court-appeal-in-Polaroid-case/8357528955200/">16.5 million</a> Kodak instant camera owners in trouble. This was a textbook example of a devastating defeat. Speaking of books, <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/23420288-a-triumph-of-genius">A Triumph of Genius</a> provides a detailed and engaging recollection of the case. It was one of the most best books I’ve read last year.</p><h3>7. The Local Inventor Bias: Chint vs. Schneider Electric</h3><p>One interesting subplot of the Kodak v. Polaroid case was how much they strategized about when to submit the case and which patent court to file it in because, on one, Kodak was expected to have an advantage, while on the other, Polaroid was expected to have an advantage. The obvious question is how much this is only part of the story and how much it’s common knowledge in patent cases.</p><p>Let’s look at one outside the US patenting courts. In 2006, Chint sued Schneider Electric in China for infringing their <a href="https://patents.google.com/patent/CN2322256Y/en">patent</a> on a circuit breaker solution. The court relatively quickly reached a verdict and, in 2007, ordered Schneider Electric to pay ¥330 million (~$50 million). Although this appears small relative to the previous verdicts but in China, this was the largest award at that time.</p><p>Schneider Electric tried to turn back the decision by invalidating Chint’s patent by citing earlier circuit breaker designs that do the same thing. However, the patent reexamination board upheld its validity because <a href="https://www.usitc.gov/publications/332/pub4199.pdf">there was no previous use or sale</a> of that mentioned technology in China. In the end, the parties <a href="https://www.reuters.com/article/world/europe/schneider-settles-3-yr-chint-patent-suit-xinhua-idUSPEK195803/">settled</a> outside of court in 2009, and Schneider Electric agreed to pay Chint $23 million.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uzxsl39uJHQoNBQD" /></figure><p>Circuit breakers may look simple but even in relatively well established fields there is room for innovation. Image from <a href="https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/6a/Circuit_breaker_2_pole_on_DIN_rail.JPG">wikipedia</a></p><p>One could easily say that looking at only local patents is unfair, but the situation is a bit more nuanced than that. There is no such thing as a global patent, the closest to that is the so-called Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) which provides a unified procedure for filing applications BUT the granting of a patent remains the exclusive responsibility of nations. National decisions are also independent, so they can make even opposite calls. For instance, the above-mentioned goldmine 1-click patent of Amazon was granted in the US but was <a href="https://www.williamfry.com/knowledge/amazon-one-click-patent-application-refused/">rejected</a> by the European Patent Office for lacking an inventive step (precisely the point Barnes &amp; Noble made). Still, the US patent office and courts have the right to deem it otherwise (which they did).</p><p>The lesson from this is that when you file a patent in a country and want to enforce your rights, you should be aware of the local regulations, policies and history of patent disputes. Patents are not only legal constructs but they are the result of legal, cultural, political and economic contexts. This means not only national differences but even regional ones.</p><h3>8. Meanwhile in Europe: Panasonic v. Oppo</h3><p>In an interesting initiative, Europe is working on a patent office (UP) and court (UPC) system that would operate over most European countries, making filing and litigation both streamlined and cheaper. Although the UPC only started in mid 2023, it already showed signs of its <a href="https://www.juve-patent.com/cases/oppo-infringed-panasonic-sep-says-local-division-mannheim-in-first-frand-ruling/">effectiveness</a>.</p><p>It recently closed the case Panasonic v. Oppo case, where the earlier claimed that the latter was infringing its standard-essential <a href="https://patents.google.com/patent/EP2568724B1/en">patent</a> on 4G technology. Since it’s an SEP technology, Oppo must have used it to comply with the standard. Oppo’s defense was saying though that Panasonic didn’t provide a license under fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms (FRAND), which is a requirement for SEP patents.</p><p>The judges considered this argument but found that according to the evidence, Oppo didn’t engage in good-faith negotiations. They didn’t provide enough information on the products or their sales and were inconsistent about which jurisdictions they wanted to obtain a license. To use an everyday analogy, this is like going into the grocery store and saying, “I want to buy apples; tell me the price?” and then complaining that the staff said, “It depends on what kind of apples and how much”.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.juve-patent.com/cases/oppo-infringed-panasonic-sep-says-local-division-mannheim-in-first-frand-ruling/">awarded</a> amount was not too significant (€250,000), but it came with — the much more important — order to stop selling their devices in Germany, France, Italy, Sweden and the Netherlands. It might not seem significant but previously there was no court that could have ordered such a thing in a list(!) of countries.</p><p>The parties ultimately settled shortly after. Still, the case shows a precedent of how the UPC — a supranational patent court — handles these quite delicate SEP disputes. It’s still too early to make far reaching conclusions, but it will be interesting to follow the further developments of the UPC to see how a world with more “global” patents would work.</p><h3>9. Can You Infringe a Patent in Your Own Backyard? Bowman v. Monsanto</h3><p>All the previous cases had one thing in common: they were disputes between companies when one launched a product infringing a patent. For a long time, I didn’t know that you can actually infringe a patent as an individual, too, at your home, without trying to sell anything. The next case is a good example of exactly this.</p><p>Vernon Bowman, a farmer in Indiana, purchased Roundup Ready soybean seeds produced by Monsanto each year for his season’s first crop. Roundup Ready is a <a href="https://patents.google.com/patent/USRE39247E1/en">genetically modified soybean</a> that is resistant a glyphosate, a kind of herbicide used to kill weeds contaminating the crops. However, for the <a href="https://www.wipo.int/web/wipo-magazine/articles/in-the-courts-monsanto-v-bowman-supreme-court-upholds-patent-holders-rights-38500">second, riskier late-season planting</a>, he had the idea in 1999 to buy soybeans from a grain elevator where he suspected that there will be some Roundup Ready beans were mixed into it. He went home and planted the seeds, then applied glyphosate on them to kill all others except the resistant Roundup Ready plants. He then waited for them to grow and harvested their seeds to be used for replanting in the following year.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*UjNXvD9zNFTavx_7" /></figure><p>If you also wondered why it is called Roundup Ready, here is the answer. Image from <a href="http://bearmarkethealth.blogspot.com/">bearmarkethealth.blogspot.com</a></p><p>You could rightfully ask: Why go through all this grain elevator nonsense when he could have just used the seeds from his own first Roundup Ready harvest and reached the same result? Well, not exactly. Monsanto sells the Roundup Ready seed with a limited-use license, which tells that farmers cannot use the harvested seeds for replanting. He reasoned though, that because he didn’t use his own seeds but bought the seeds from an elevator without any license he basically found a workaround for the Monsanto patent and license.</p><p>Monsanto didn’t think so, though. When they learned what he was doing, they told him that he was in fact infringing the patent and they sued Bowman in 2007. Bowman’s argument was that there are limitations to the patent holder’s right, they can set conditions how the license may be acquired but cannot control what the buyer will do with the product. And although the license controlled that the original owner of the Roundup Ready seeds cannot replant his or her own harvest, they also didn’t do that: they sold it to a grain elevator… from where the clever Bowman bought it and used it for planting but the license did not control that.</p><p>This is a neat argumentation. But what Bowman didn’t consider fully is that even though he could even plant those bought soybeans, what he cannot do is create additional patented soybeans without infringing the patent. Bowman’s argument was that he also didn’t create them as the plants were creating their crops themselves. This argument didn’t convince the court though, and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bowman_v._Monsanto_Co.">they ruled in favor of Monsanto</a>.</p><p>Of course, the case remained quite controversial not only because it was a David and Goliath story but also because it has shown that patent law has to be reflected upon and even sometimes revised as new technologies (e.g. self-replicating technologies) stretch the boundaries of what previously was possible.</p><h3>10. HeLa Cells: Discovery v. Invention</h3><p>The last case I’m bringing to you is also about the limits of what one can patent. The story is quite sad but brings some very important lessons from the frontiers of patenting.</p><p>In <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HeLa">1951</a>, Henrietta Lacks, an African-American woman was diagnosed with cervical cancer in the John Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore, Maryland. The doctors treated her with radiotherapy and performed a cervical biopsy to sample tissue from her tumour, without her consent. At first, she responded well to the therapy but soon her health deteriorated and she died the same year.</p><p>The hospital’s researchers found though, that the cells show a remarkable property: they doubled every <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HeLa">20–24 hours</a> in vitro, making them the first immortal cell line ever to discover. This meant that they could use them for scientific study in various applications. So much so, that HeLa cells are an integral part of every medical and biology lab today. They enabled the development of countless drugs and vaccines, for instance, thanks to the HeLa cells, we have a polio vaccine. They used them to develop treatments for various viral infections and cancers and to study genetics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/539/0*wRzb-NSOj9ARxHSU" /></figure><p>One of the few photos of Henrietta Lacks, whose cells are now fundamental to the discovery of so many life-saving medications. Image from <a href="http://medbunker.it/">medbunker.it</a>.</p><p>This also means that these cells are the foundation of the multibillion-dollar industries of pharmaceutics and biotechnology. Still, when the writer <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Immortal_Life_of_Henrietta_Lacks">Rebeca Skloot </a>searched for the family she found that they live in poverty because they never saw any profits from this exceptional discovery. They tried numerous angles to receive at least some revenue from the astronomical value that their relative’s cells enabled. One of these was to consider whether the cell line could be patented.</p><p>Unfortunately, there are several obvious issues. For one, the patent should have been filed before the discovery was shared with the public. Second, a utility patent only provides protection for 20 years, and there is a 6-year statute of limitation for infringement in the US. So this means that even if they had filed a patent before it was disclosed to the public in 1951 they still had to file a civil action no later than 1977. Nobody explained patent law either to Henrietta Lacks or later to her family so they didn’t think about a patent in time.</p><p>Another question is whether the HeLa cells qualify for the definition of an invention. For a long time, the USPTO allowed these discoveries of naturally occurring cells and DNA segments. This happened in <a href="https://patents.google.com/patent/WO1996005307A2/en">1994</a>, when Myriad Genetics filed a patent on a cancer susceptibility gene, the patent office granted it and then Myriad created a quite lucrative monopoly from this asset. It took almost 20 years until in 2010 the Association for Molecular Pathology tried to invalidate this patent. The court also agreed with them, at the end of the trial (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_for_Molecular_Pathology_v._Myriad_Genetics,_Inc.">2013</a>) they concluded that discovery or even isolation of naturally occurring DNA sequences is not patent-eligible. The same holds for the HeLa cells.</p><p>The lesson from this is that inventions require some kind of inventor initiated change in things. E.g. large rock that you can use to hammer nails into a wood cannot be patented, if you attach that <a href="https://hausoftools.com/blogs/news/the-history-and-evolution-of-the-hammer">rock to a stick</a> to create a stonage hammer that can. If you find that chewing a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salvadora_persica">stick</a> can help making your teeth clean that cannot, but if you take a piece of animal bone and weave hog bristles in it to create a toothbrush that <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toothbrush#Toothbrush">can</a>. And finally, if you figure out a new way to find the minimum of a linear function that can’t, however if you figure out a way how on a computer you can do this in a memory efficient way that can (btw this is known to be the <a href="https://patents.google.com/patent/GB1039141A/en">first-ever software patent</a>).</p><p>I hope you enjoyed my selection of the 10 most interesting patent law and infringement cases. For the sake of accessibility to a wider audience I simplified some complex legal and technical details but if you are interested click on the links and go down the rabbit hole. And if you are interested in working at a place where you can work on patent applications yourself, check out our <a href="https://careers.promaton.com/">open positions</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=67f9bffc782e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.productcoalition.com/ten-patent-cases-that-formed-history-67f9bffc782e">Ten Patent Cases That Formed History</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.productcoalition.com/">Product Coalition</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Vibe Coded a Game That Attracted 10k+ Players In a Single Weekend]]></title>
            <link>https://generativeai.pub/i-vibe-coded-a-game-that-attracted-10k-players-in-a-single-weekend-6cff508bad58?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6cff508bad58</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[generative-ai-tools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[indie-game]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vibe-coding]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ágoston Török]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 07 Apr 2025 08:25:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-07T08:25:26.667Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Here are the tough lessons I learned so you don’t make the same mistakes</h4><p>When I started developing <a href="https://ceosimulator.vercel.app/">my first online game — CEO Simulator —</a> as a hobby ‘vibe coding’ project, I had no idea that a few weeks later it would attract thousands of players in a single weekend. This surprise success taught me valuable and humbling lessons about game development, user engagement, and the power of AI-assisted coding. Here’s my journey and what I learned along the way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/591/1*kPtLv6mi0j1aKuEvQqVGKg.png" /><figcaption>Vibe coding in the original definition by Andrej Karpathy. Source <a href="https://x.com/karpathy/status/1886192184808149383">X</a></figcaption></figure><h3>The gameplay of an impossible game</h3><p>Creating balanced gameplay was critical to the game’s success. I couldn’t outsource this to Generative AI, but I leaned on DeepSeek R1 and OpenAI o1 (both advanced reasoning-optimized AI models) to review iterations of my rulebook. These reasoning models acted as a second or third pair of virtual eyes, catching inconsistencies and awkward phrasing that I might’ve missed.</p><p>Balancing the gameplay was trickier. I wanted a mix of randomness and skill, avoiding any “degenerate” winning tactics that could break the experience. To test this, I built a reinforcement learning (RL) setup with <a href="https://codeium.com/windsurf">Windsurf</a> (an agentic IDE) and Claude 3.5 that played the game repeatedly, learning and improving over time. I could have set it up to only operate with the game&#39;s internal state and actions, but I opted for actual browser interactions. This helped me find some strange UX behaviors, though actual game mechanics insights were limited. I had to opt for traditional playtesting, which in turn brought precisely the kind of learning I sought.</p><blockquote>“Love it. Good work.” — Carson, an investor</blockquote><p>Reflecting on it, I see multiple reasons why RL didn’t really bring good insights. For one, I should have paid more attention to the design of the modules so that they’re more compatible with an RL paradigm. Those strange UX behaviors, e.g. meant that I often found the agent stuck in stupid interaction patterns. Second, RL can be very powerful, but the learning curve is typically steep, so unless there are obvious degenerate winning tactics, it will take quite some games until the agent figures out the rules. Third, we humans still have an edge when it comes to gaining insights from a few exposures, so I could learn a lot more from playtesting it myself around 200 times. I recorded the data from these games, and the analysis helped me tweak variables like hand size, meeting durations, and game length (14 days).</p><blockquote>“The no-reward, stressful nature of the game suits well for a CEO game.” — Fahad, a founder and CEO</blockquote><p>The final rules go against everything I learned about board games. The cards demand a lot of reading, and 77% of the games end in a loss. Even more, winning the game happened only in 3% of the cases, and the remaining 20% of “not lost” games were won by just surviving. I deliberately kept these challenging elements because they mirror real startup executive experiences. You have to quickly digest lots of information, and if you don’t play for the long run — recognizing when to manage technical debt and avoid burnout — you’ll likely fail.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*30t_hqlfp1n2yNi6gM5dFg.png" /><figcaption>The look of the game at the start of the playtesting. Initially, I wanted to call it Crazy Startup CEO, but then, searching for the vibe, I realized it’s actually a minimalistic Simulator.</figcaption></figure><p>Similarly, a core part of the gameplay was the introduction of overtime and its connection to mental health. This resonated especially well with previous or current founders and startuppers.</p><blockquote>“Surprisingly accurate.” — Ramon, a co-founder and CTO</blockquote><h3>Designing a simulator with cards</h3><p>Design was where AI truly shone. Inspired by the word simulation, I aimed for an 80s retro aesthetic with synth vibes and low-resolution graphics. This was an ideal loosely defined task for vibe coding with Windsurf; I’d describe the vague idea (e.g. <em>“Something like an 80s style arcade game”</em>), and it’d churn out assets that nailed the look. This was the place where I also enjoyed it when it went overboard. For instance, at one point while implementing my request, it proactively and unwantedly added a neon highlight to the message box. I was like, hmm, that’s interesting, looked at it for another 10 seconds and decided to keep it because it was so on point.</p><p>I also wanted to keep the game lightweight. Therefore, I opted for SVG files over PNGs for card backs, slashing the footprint, and limited myself to just two custom fonts. I tried initially to generate the SVGs also with Claude and it was in the ballpark but ended up designing it myself for the intended look. Music was also a part where AI couldn’t help much other than implementing the code that handles music.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*onD1omf_FGX_CbtqaeyPmw.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://ceosimulator.vercel.app/">Release 0.1.7</a> looks already retro, with a neon highlight around the message box on the bottom and the dark tutorial box below the cards.</figcaption></figure><p>Localization added another challenge. Here I mean not only translation, let me explain. When I shared the game with my brother in Hungary, he remarked that some US startup scene references (e.g. WeWork or Theranos) could also be replaced with local references (e.g. French in France). I could describe what I wanted Windsurf to do, and it translated in Turbo mode all the cards and UI elements to 7 languages, including local references. Vetting these localizations is still some place, though, where I’m still seeking feedback from players, especially in the Spanish and French versions.</p><blockquote>“The aesthetics are awesome and I love the simplicity” — Alex, an engineer</blockquote><p>I also added a tutorial that shows below or next to the object that you should click on next, with a text that explains that action (see image). I got pretty good feedback from early playtesters on how important the tutorial part is, so I recorded a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dSpE4wgQGnY">walkthrough video</a> that complements the step-by-step real-time tutorial. Importantly, although the game starts with a big link to the video, only 31% of the players clicked on the video. Watching a video is friction, so it&#39;s best if you can get started without that.</p><h3>Code: the good, the bad, the ugly</h3><blockquote>“Vanilla javascript + html? That’s sick!” — Niels, an engineer</blockquote><p>Thanks to generative AI, I didn’t need to rely on my knowledge. Normally, as a Python dev, I’d have leaned on Python tools — possible, but clunky for a web game. Instead, I picked the right stack for the job: React + Node.js + Vercel. Windsurf made this choice a vibe-coding dream for me. I could “discuss” a basic security audit of the solution and deployment was a breeze with Github Actions, MongoDB/Cosmos DB and Vercel. I didn’t become an expert on any of these frameworks, but I still could confidently use my architectural and design knowledge to identify parts that were designed suboptimally.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/573/1*O8NoYe3I_21frhEVsoUB-A.png" /><figcaption>The application’s stack. Diagram made with Draw.io</figcaption></figure><p>Speaking of which, there were lots of things designed suboptimally. Vibe coding suffers from some serious flaws:</p><ul><li>Bias for local solutions</li><li>Training data bias</li><li>Half-baked ideas</li></ul><p>Let’s see them one by one. Bias for local solutions means that unless you say it explicitly in the prompt (which is not vibe coding anymore), the LLM will implement a solution in one place. For instance, at one point, I noticed that it started to put all functionality in the GameView.js file rather than separating concerns for game display, state management and menu behavior, for instance. This led to a high degree of coupling, low separation of responsibilities, and inappropriate intimacy. It would be good if these were issues affecting only humans trying to work with smelly code, but I assess that LLMs are even worse at dealing with poorly written code.</p><p>Training data bias is another issue. See, LLMs are trained with the commit history of public repositories. This means that the “mistakes” we humans often make in a commit will be carried over to AI-generated code. One such thing is when a commit also contains some small additional changes on top of what the commit message describes. This in vibe coding means that when I said “Implement a Special Card class based on the Card base class”, the model not only touched the Special Card class code but also refactored the Card class. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYJ2w82WifU">Aladeen</a>. I didn’t like it this at all and ended up reviewing every proposal line by line before committing to see what I wanted and what was just the LLM being too eager. This means some slowdown but ultimately I was still much faster than coding it myself.</p><p>Finally, half-baked ideas. Probably the most obvious when you start thinking about what could go wrong with vibe coding. We see that <a href="https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpreview.redd.it%2Fi2aeyrivmjoz.jpg%3Fwidth%3D640%26crop%3Dsmart%26auto%3Dwebp%26s%3Db92dc174a27bbef5174ef120c8b2b6df42227a95">understanding requirements</a> (i.e. prompts) is difficult already when people put effort into phrasing them. Imagine what happens when, in vibe coding, you say “Make it better” instead. Mayhem. The solution for me was to implement quite some tests that verified the end-to-end behavior of the system (so not unit tests).</p><h3>An unreal Sunday afternoon</h3><p>Imagine the following: I’m in the playground with my son, and I get a notification from MongoDB that my database is soon reaching the quota limits. I didn’t even know I had limits at first; I had to think about where I used MongoDB. Also, I never thought that the stupid little game logs were going to be this big, so I rather suspected some kind of hacker activity. I had to learn the hard way -again- this forever lesson of scalability:</p><blockquote>Small things that might not be an issue when done twice start to become THE issue when you do it ten thousand times</blockquote><p>Still from the playground, I checked a few things and found that the game is trending on <a href="https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43102414">Hacker News</a>. I looked at the comments and immediately saw some good feedback about usability issues, as well as issues with the database filling up (high scores not added). So we went home quickly and I started looking into what I could do:</p><ul><li>I could start compressing data or removing superfluous fields</li><li>I could look into whether I’m saving maybe even several copies of the game logs, hence filling up the database so quickly</li><li>I could delete data to save time</li><li>I could just pay for a bigger plan to save even more time for debugging</li><li>I could switch to another provider with more free quota (I did this later, Cosmos DB provides 25GB for free)</li></ul><p>I opted for the last option as that was the quickest and cleanest solution (although not the cheapest but <a href="https://www.business.com/articles/fast-good-cheap-pick-three/">you can always choose only 2</a>). Side track, that you can’t update the plan without ~5 minutes downtime, luckily the game used buffering so this meant people could still score only eventual consistency will be a b*tch at one point.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4A3bqCXwIRnpi1dexPENdg.png" /><figcaption>Soon after the MongoDB message, I got a similar lovely notification from Vercel, too, because I had forgotten to lazy load the “tiny” music files I added to the game.</figcaption></figure><p>I had some tough choices to make also after the database fix, do I do any functionality improvement while the game is trending? As I said, some people in the comments indicated usability issues:</p><ul><li>Cards on mobile were hard to read (too small fonts), and this led to accidental clicks (33.8% of users)</li><li>The tutorial was distracting as it covered half of the screen (~100% of the users)</li><li>Selecting an already moved objective at the end of the round led to an infinite dice roll glitch (?% of users)</li></ul><p>My thinking was the following: this is a unique opportunity to iterate and learn how to make the game better. I can let these flaws stay, but that’s risking that, due to more and more people joining the bug reporting, the game will stop trending. I can try to fix these flaws, but I may cause regression and worsen things. I had some tests, but with that test coverage and my adrenaline in the sky, this was a real risk. I opted to take it anyway as I was here to learn and iterate.</p><p>Although the tutorial affects more users, I opted for fixing the mobile usability first, as the tutorial could be switched off easily, while the mobile usability was a persistent issue. I pushed these changes while the number of players was only around 3000, and by the end of the day, these bug reports didn’t populate, and I gained another ~7000 players. 80% luck and 20% skill. I also engaged in the comment section on Hacker News to make sure people feel that their feedback is valuable and being addressed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6PwIie-1ihd_Pj8mGl3tGw.png" /><figcaption>The looks of <a href="https://ceosimulator.vercel.app/">version 0.1.9</a>. Notice the glow around the cards, this is the new, much less intrusive tutorial</figcaption></figure><p>Although I’m still not proud of the codebase, it’s certainly telling that I was able to make these changes quite quickly with no regressions at all. For a long time, I have believed more in these real-life code quality measures (i.e. ease of change) than e.g. cyclomatic complexity.</p><h3>5 Things I Wish I’d Done Differently</h3><ol><li><strong>Set up testing and CI pipeline early</strong><br>The flow of vibe coding fooled me, so I skipped a proper CI setup with test coverage — a rookie move. AI eagerly overhauled code beyond my prompts, forcing me to manually analyze diffs before commits. A test suite would’ve caught regressions faster, especially after two buggy prod releases. Next time, I’ll prioritize this from day one.</li><li><strong>Start using MCP sooner</strong><br>Still, to the testing topic, but at least here I have an excuse: It was added to Windsurf after I started the project. Nevertheless, once I set up MCP servers (most importantly for Puppeteer), the otherwise painstaking browser interaction testing tasks became fun.</li><li><strong>Learn earlier how to undo changes</strong><br><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ecxU0fzwbs">Reverting changes made by the AI</a> is not entirely trivial in Windsurf. This is especially problematic when I’m pair coding in turbo mode. Learning about that revert button happened embarrassingly late in my case so I was double doing quite often changes because my go to method was git reset --hard .</li><li><strong>Scalability planning</strong><br>I underestimated traffic. Sound downloads and move-logging hit Vercel and MongoDB limits fast — 35,000+ games clogged the system, locking leaderboard access. I scrambled to optimize, but early planning (or paid tiers) would’ve kept it seamless. You know the saying “dress for the occasion”. Another part of this planning was that I realized a bit late that although the leaderboard is a good retention feature once it’s filled up by really great scores (e.g. one player played close to 3 hours once to land on the top) it’s not motivating anymore for the remaining 98% of players. Saving thought was the implementation of the daily leaderboard.</li><li><strong>More proper risk modelling</strong><br>Some people noticed that they can submit any score to leaderboard using the API call. I manually deleted fakes mid-viral spike before coding a proper server-side validation — lame oversight. The sad thing is that I had all sorts of validation to mitigate the probability of a successful DOS attack but I didn’t think of these much more likely types of misuses. All in all, one of the “hackers” was a colleague of mine who was quite happy to find this vulnerability so I guess the game brought fun in unintended ways too :)</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/761/1*Owxf-qfPHEcedv_mvj1YcQ.png" /><figcaption>The <a href="https://ceosimulator.vercel.app/">daily leaderboard</a> on 1 Apr 2025. The identity of the first player is unknown.</figcaption></figure><h3>Closing Thoughts</h3><p>Vibe-coding <a href="https://ceosimulator.vercel.app/">CEO Simulator</a> became an unexpected lesson in modern indie game development. What began as a personal experiment — combining my limited web development skills with AI assistance — evolved into something that resonated with thousands of players within days. The game’s topic, brutal difficulty and retro aesthetics resonated with people in ways I hadn’t anticipated.</p><p>The journey wasn’t smooth, yet watching the player count climb past 10,000 that first weekend was worth every bit of frustration during the development. Moreover, this experience has transformed how I think about building software. The traditional barriers between “knowing how to code” and “being able to create” dissolve. With the right tools and mindset, the distance between concept and execution is getting shorter and shorter — though the fundamentals of good engineering, testing, and user experience remain as crucial as ever.</p><p>For anyone considering their own AI-assisted side project: embrace the imperfections, plan for unexpected success, and remember that even with AI’s help, the vision and decisions that make something worth experiencing still come from you.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/369/1*3o-r8zevBIlnXz7I6jabdg.png" /><figcaption>Number of players by 2 Apr 2025.</figcaption></figure><p>This story is published on <a href="https://generativeai.pub/">Generative AI</a>. Connect with us on <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/generative-ai-publication">LinkedIn</a> and follow <a href="https://www.zeniteq.com/">Zeniteq</a> to stay in the loop with the latest AI stories.</p><p>Subscribe to our <a href="https://www.generativeaipub.com/">newsletter</a> and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/@generativeaipub">YouTube</a> channel to stay updated with the latest news and updates on generative AI. Let’s shape the future of AI together!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*bCLugAr5nr0bcOpB.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6cff508bad58" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://generativeai.pub/i-vibe-coded-a-game-that-attracted-10k-players-in-a-single-weekend-6cff508bad58">I Vibe Coded a Game That Attracted 10k+ Players In a Single Weekend</a> was originally published in <a href="https://generativeai.pub/">Generative AI</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strategy vs. Situation Misfit: How to Recognize it?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/agileinsider/strategy-vs-situation-misfit-how-to-recognize-it-858c95cb0c2c?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/858c95cb0c2c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[visual-storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lean]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[product-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wardley-maps]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ágoston Török]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Feb 2025 16:31:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-05T16:31:11.810Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Discover why your struggles might have nothing to do with your skills — and everything to do with the terrain.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZD3zHVE7KQUtf4NhdbCGjg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Fig 1. The secret sauce of startup success is the people. However, it’s a bit more complicated when you look at bigger companies. Image by <a href="https://www.pexels.com/photo/group-of-people-watching-on-laptop-1595385/">Hillary Fox</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>Our company was <strong>crushing it</strong>. No clickbait tools or fancy processes — just raw enthusiasm and quick wins.</p><p>Or so I thought. Because when a senior engineer joined us he explained this is not how tech giants succeed. He introduced a brilliant methodology called <a href="https://www.oreilly.com/library/view/implementing-lean-software/0321437381/">lean product development</a>. His wisdom was compelling, and I became a convert, learning every lean practice until it became my religion.</p><p>Armed with this knowledge, I became the lean prophet at my next job. But something was off — the team kept accumulating “waste” during our greenfield development, and our releases crawled. I blamed them for not following the lean gospel properly.</p><p>My saving grace?</p><blockquote>I value people over methodologies.</blockquote><p>When I finally let go and allowed the team to break every lean principle in the book, they delivered. I was happy but also wondered: maybe we would have delivered even better with lean? Who knows.</p><p>Now, 15 years later, I understand it a bit better: sometimes the cost of being lean outweighs its benefits. Counter-intuitive as it sounds, there are phases in a business where “waste” is just background noise.</p><p>Let me explain with a metaphor…</p><h3>The Map of Business Evolution</h3><p>Let’s start by <a href="https://medium.com/datadriveninvestor/how-to-draw-a-strategy-in-4-steps-2e6232e4578f">drawing a horizontal line that shows the evolution of a</a> business: you start with an idea, develop a Proof of Concept (PoC), and then get funding to create a Minimum Viable Product (MVP). You iterate on it to reach a mature product state, and if you’re lucky, you’ll iterate even more until you can produce what you sell so efficiently that you become what we call a commodity.</p><p>Okay, this isn’t a groundbreaking concept yet, but now try to imagine it not as a line but as a map of a land (see Fig 1).</p><h4>The Desert: The Birth of an Idea</h4><p>An idea is like finding yourself in the middle of a <strong>desert</strong>. There are no obstacles so you can go in any direction. But there’s also no food, shelter, or water (i.e., no $$$), so you’d better find a direction that gets you to a better place fast. Your advantage here is <strong>speed</strong> (think of marathon runner not a sprinter though) and a good sense of direction. So much, that you don’t even need to open your eyes just follow your instincts (i.e. no need for extensive user research… I know: heretic!). You need to run with your idea and build that proof of concept because <strong>time is of the essence</strong>.</p><p>With your proof of concept, you reach a transition. Transitions are gradual, so it easily happens that you haven’t even noticed that you are on a different land (i.e. in a different stage of business evolution) and still use skills and processes that were only advantageous earlier.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*aRlC-bqGDOt8IAkJALdrcw.png" /><figcaption>Fig 2. The difficult terrain of business evolution. Image by the Author.</figcaption></figure><h4>The Savannah: Building the MVP</h4><p>Next, you enter the <strong>savannah</strong>. The savannah is different from the desert. There are obstacles like trees and animals (i.e., challenges like securing funding and hiring a team), but there’s also food, water, and opportunities for shelter (i.e., some $$$).</p><p><strong>Speed</strong> is still valuable, but now you need more. You’ll have to look around and <strong>react</strong> to obstacles. The kings of the savannah are the <strong>traceurs</strong> — practitioners of parkour — who can turn obstacles into opportunities. They see a tree not as a barrier but as something to climb to get a better view and an animal as a potential source of food.</p><h4>The Highlands: Strategic Navigation</h4><p>Moving forward, you find yourself approaching the <strong>highlands</strong>. You’ll quickly notice that running up hills is tough. You need to <strong>optimize your route</strong> and use your energy wisely. The key to this place is a good <strong>navigator</strong>. This is where you start differentiating between <strong>tactical moves</strong> (dodging a tree) and <strong>strategic planning</strong> (choosing the best path through the hills).</p><p>You’ll look at the savannah people now as opportunistic, but remember, they are acting in a different environment.</p><h4>The City: Scaling Operations</h4><p>Eventually, you arrive at a busy <strong>city</strong>. Here, you can make <strong>real money</strong>. Not only can you find customers, but you also have access to suppliers and partners to help scale your operations. Success in the city depends on how well you know the streets (operational challenges) and the people on them (staff, suppliers, customers).</p><p><strong>Salespeople</strong> thrive here. They sell what you do and provide immediate market feedback to be able to sell more. It’s less about those visionary ideas and more about <strong>execution and efficiency</strong>.</p><h4>The Mountains: The Realm of Giants</h4><p>The city is a great place to be but you hear people talking in the tavern: they tell stories about a magical castle up in the <strong>mountains</strong>, where the floors and walls are made of gold (think <strong>Google or Amazon</strong> levels of success). That sounds wonderful but beware: the mountains are not just large hills. They are dangerous; one misstep can send you plummeting.</p><p>Climbing these peaks requires meticulous planning and <strong>specialized skills</strong>. Progress is made through small, precise steps, supported by robust processes (think Six Sigma methodologies). The people who thrive here are <strong>experts</strong> who rely on detailed procedures and a clear chain of command. I’m not talking about the bureaucrats who enjoy the mountain views; the expert is of a different pedigree.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bKKZETOAcOibZAkiAKlwhA.png" /><figcaption>Fig 3. The five terrains of business evolution. Figure created with <a href="https://app.napkin.ai/">Napkin</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>Interestingly, the leaders of these skilled groups are often experts themselves. It might seem surprising, considering how Big Tech CEOs appear to make swift seemingly abrupt choices, but they embody the archetype of this kind of expert. They have to know how to gain an overview in the mountains and how to communicate when the echo converts lengthy speeches into a garbled mess. They give loud, clear and timely commands that make the daunting seem doable — but make no mistake, attempts to replicate their commands would likely end in chaos for a non-expert.</p><p>I think you start to see how the terrain makes some places just better for certain kinds of R&amp;D.</p><h3>The Waste of Not Knowing Where You Are</h3><p>Looking back at our early startup days, I smile at our naivety. We were desert runners who didn’t know we were in a desert — but that was our superpower. The senior engineer wasn’t wrong about lean practices; he was just showing us a mountain climbing technique… while we were sprinting across sand dunes. We were enthusiastic though so we tried that too.</p><p>Today, when I consult with teams, I don’t start by preaching methodologies. Instead, I ask them to look at their terrain. Are they in a desert where speed and instinct matter most? Or are they climbing mountains where every step must be calculated? The best method isn’t always the “right” method — it’s the one that matches your terrain. Our greatest waste isn’t in our processes; it’s in fighting against the natural advantages of where we stand.</p><p>Sometimes the most lean thing you can do is to stop trying to be lean.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0Sv_IzqG3oGOpctmQBKf8A.png" /><figcaption>Fig 4. The environment defines what the optimal methodology is. Figure created with <a href="https://app.napkin.ai/">Napkin</a>.</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=858c95cb0c2c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/agileinsider/strategy-vs-situation-misfit-how-to-recognize-it-858c95cb0c2c">Strategy vs. Situation Misfit: How to Recognize it?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/agileinsider">Agile Insider</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Power of a Single Week Dedicated to Innovation]]></title>
            <link>https://blog.promaton.com/the-power-of-a-single-week-dedicated-to-innovation-585c2721de17?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/585c2721de17</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[company-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup-lessons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dentistry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[corporate-culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ágoston Török]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Dec 2024 13:28:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-04T13:28:57.443Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How learnings from our growth and hack week helped kick off Inno Week at Straumann Group</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*iZCrbyLpd6-kCpgc" /><figcaption>Straumann has built a reputation of advancing dentistry through innovation. Image from Straumann.com</figcaption></figure><h3>Transforming Dentistry Through AI and Innovation</h3><p>At Promaton, our vision has always been to revolutionize dentistry by harnessing the power of AI-driven workflows. But our goal isn’t just to release AI products into the field; we aim to make a tangible impact. This journey began in 2020, when we forged a strategic partnership with Straumann Group, a global leader in tooth replacement and orthodontic solutions. This partnership recently achieved a significant milestone: launching a quarterly innovation event across the Group called <strong>Inno Week</strong>.</p><p>In this post I will explain the motivation behind this, the benefits we already see, the challenges we had to overcome and the things we would do differently.</p><h3>Innovation is in our DNA</h3><p>Straumann’s journey began in 1954 as a family business with a strong pioneering spirit, a commitment to science and a desire for innovation and change. The company had grown into a collection of businesses, and amongst them dental implants. Today the Straumann Group hosts numerous brands that extend beyond implantology into various areas of dental innovation.</p><p>Straumann has built a reputation of advancing dentistry through innovation: if today you are facing implant treatment your safest and most reliable choice is unquestionably the Straumann family of implants. Straumann Group continues to define industry standards in dental implant and restorative design, and over the years extended more and more into the digital side of dentistry with sophisticated softwares like <a href="https://www.straumann.com/en/dental-professionals/products-and-solutions/cares-digital-solutions/software/codiagnostix.html">coDiagnostix</a> or services like <a href="https://www.straumann.com/en/dental-professionals/products-and-solutions/cares-digital-solutions/services-and-solutions/smile-in-a-box.html">Smile in a Box</a>.</p><p>However, <strong>as a company grows the way to foster innovation also has to change</strong>. While in a 10-person startup, good ideas are easier picked up and brought into the roadmap, a &gt;11.000 people company works differently: executives have to oversee changes of a much larger scale and be much more careful with taking risky bets. This is why strong corporations have <a href="https://www.straumann.com/group/en/home/about/our-business/innovation.html">established processes</a> to nurture truly novel ideas.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0vhP8YOKRZvx_XVltxRU3w.png" /><figcaption>Fostering innovation requires a good balance between encouraging risky bets and managing risks</figcaption></figure><p>Straumann already runs a solid <a href="https://www.straumann.com/group/en/home/about/our-business/innovation.html">innovation program</a> to foster ideas that have a chance for a big impact from inception to prototype. At the same time we felt that we could help the very early steps of innovation even more, for two reasons:</p><ul><li>There are innovations that may lack the potential for industry-wide impact but would make people’s (employees or users) work or life easier.</li><li>Giving a little bit of extra room for an early experiment on a product innovation can help the innovators to build a much better defined case for their idea.</li></ul><p>Luckily, such initiatives have already been independently implemented in some sites: Montreal, Chemnitz and in our team too. And since these brought some quite visible success stories (you can read about one that we liked very much <a href="https://blog.promaton.com/point-cloud-registration-using-fully-convolutional-geometric-features-fa1c1b2627b7">here</a>), two brave site leads (Bas Verheij (Promaton) and Claude Sasseville (Montreal)) could make the proposal to introduce this format in the entire digital arm of Straumann Group, which has several hundred employees.</p><p>On top of the above two points, performing such an introduction has the potential to bring in a third benefit too, which is:</p><ul><li>Cross-pollination between teams and departments. Even if you haven’t been working in a big company, you could probably imagine how difficult it could be to get to know people, processes and products outside of your day-to-day connections.</li></ul><p>And this is where my involvement as CTO of Promaton started.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-AXwJWY01bWcvgo2G0SS4w.png" /><figcaption>Improving early stage innovation has three key benefits</figcaption></figure><h3>You just have to implement it, right?</h3><p>One could think:</p><blockquote>“So you had two implementations already; just take the best of both worlds and kick it off. Bamm! Success!”</blockquote><p>Well, it’s not that easy. First of all an organizing committee was created, consisting of Mathieu Guindon (Straumann Montreal), Julien Marbach (Straumann Montreal) and me, with the task to define how the Inno Week should look. We all had useful learnings from previous implementations:</p><ol><li>We saw that both of our versions attracted lots of very creative ideas. The key was to really let people come up with their own innovations, be that improving a product or a process or even just learning about a cool new idea.</li><li>We also saw that bringing novel ideas to the roadmap required lots of effort. So we wanted to make sure that with the bigger implementation, we had well-defined processes to support that.</li><li>We also saw that engaging people, mentoring, detailed reviews and different prizes (e.g. Best Clinical or Most Visionary) mean that such an Inno Week concept is much more than just a kickoff presentation. We had to think about how to extend the group of organizers and which “features” of the previous implementations we really wanted to keep.</li></ol><p>We also looked at implementations at other companies and learned from their insights too. Some quite interesting formats to support innovation are (or were in the past) the <a href="https://www.atlassian.com/company/shipit">Atlassian ShipIt</a>, <a href="https://abc.xyz/investor/founders-letters/ipo-letter/">Google’s 20% rule</a> and <a href="https://www.wired.com/1998/01/the-15-percent-solution/">3M 15%</a> solution.</p><p>After some iterations involving Bas and Claude too, we arrived at a presentation that, on one slide, explained the concept (i.e. who, when, why, what) and were ready to start pitching it to all relevant stakeholders. Even though we had the top management’s buy-in, we still had to make sure that everyone understood the benefits of doing the Inno Week, since the cost (i.e. 1 week is diverted from the <a href="https://scaledagileframework.com/">program increment</a> delivery) was clear.</p><p>Our pitch was the following:</p><ul><li><strong>Goal</strong>: testing, proving &amp; pitching new ideas with rapid prototypes, cross-pollination of knowledge &amp; skills, make sure we are at the forefront of digital innovation!</li><li><strong>Participation</strong>: anyone in the organization can participate, but please make sure you have managerial approval before the Inno Week.</li><li><strong>Topics</strong>: Inno Week topics can be either rapid prototyping, process improvement, or research on a hypothesis. Projects can be performed in a team or individually.</li><li><strong>Results</strong>: each team or individual participating in the Inno Week should end with a demo (preferred), presentation (max 10 slide) or a video (max 3 min) of their results, this should be submitted to be considered for evaluation &amp; rewards.</li><li><strong>Governance</strong>: Inno Week is governed by the Innovation Committee and executed with the help of ambassadors who support participants &amp; champion innovation culture in the different locations.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GkXM6gYSntU6k1siBOrAnw.png" /><figcaption>The 5 keys to a successful Inno Week</figcaption></figure><p>This way, we clarified that the goal is not only direct innovation but also indirectly facilitating innovation by building bridges between teams that otherwise wouldn’t work together. On the participation side, we made sure that managers are an active part of the journey by giving them an overview of who is participating from their teams and the option to keep critical things in progress if needed. We made sure that it’s clear that while there are little limitations on the topics we have clear expectations on the outcome formats. This way people focus on reaching a presentable state by the end of the week. Finally, we started mapping the people who are committed to innovation in the different teams and onboarded them as ambassadors or asked them to join as organizers (this is how the great Albrecht Schnappauf joined us with his 30+ years in tangible innovation).</p><h3>The first run of the new concept</h3><p>The first iteration of the Inno Week was scheduled for the final week of the Q1 2024 program increment, just before the planning of the next quarter. We advertised it in the Software and Tech All Hands meeting, we connected with the overall Straumann innovation initiatives, we made sure that all questions were promptly answered and then we embraced for Monday, 18 Mar 2024, when the first run commenced. I was nervous that week because the stakes were high; we asked for one week from everyone, in return for bringing bottom-up innovations to processes and products.</p><p>Luckily, we had quite promising signals: people submitted more than 80 ideas, and more than 250 colleagues checked them out, engaging in different ways: likes, upvotes and comments. This meant we had quite a good chance of booking some success already in the first iteration because one thing we were sure of: we were going to learn a lot about what we would have to change in the next iteration. Probably the most important highlights are the following:</p><ul><li>We managed to involve <strong>almost all of the sites</strong> in the first iteration! Due to the timing (doing the Inno Week just before the planning of the next quarter) some teams opted for finishing their quarters rather than trying out this new format.</li><li>We had some quite visible <strong>collaboration between sites,</strong> providing clear evidence of effective cross-pollination. I myself was even collaborating with a team I didn’t know beforehand, this helped me a lot in understanding better what kind of different experts are working in other sites.</li><li>We had a few <strong>extremely promising projects</strong> that fitted perfectly the Group-wide innovation program, so we started preparing them together with the teams for a submission.</li></ul><p>There were also some lowlights that we had to think about:</p><ul><li>The <strong>timing</strong> of the first Inno Week was not ideal. Before the PI planning, everybody is still in the crazy last push to meet the goals. In this context, the Inno Week could come across as a distraction, so we had to work with the software portfolio management team to get a better timing for the next iterations.</li><li>Our <strong>onboarding of the ambassadors</strong> was not perfect. Some of them said they weren’t sure about what they should do, and a few of them admitted that they didn’t get the concept clear either. While we did our best, we learned that you should never underestimate the difficulty of communicating something in a simple narrative so everyone understands it.</li><li>Our communication about the aim and definition of the Inno Week was not clear enough in some areas of the <a href="https://erinmeyer.com/books/the-culture-map/">culture map</a>. Some cultures would participate to win prizes, some simply to try out new things, for others the idea of bottom-up innovation does not come naturally. This means, again, that we had to be very clear with our communication and, for some sites, do additional onboarding sessions.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NAEjCwrbBiaG1RiO18cj-A.png" /><figcaption>Reflection on the first Inno Week</figcaption></figure><p>Three highlights and three lowlights, so was it a success? We were introducing a new concept, so the most important KPI for us was to have enough traction/success for this first iteration to make a second iteration possible. And that was clearly there. As a matter of fact, I’m writing this during the third iteration when I chose this blog post as my project.</p><h3>An environment that fosters innovation</h3><p>Now, almost one year after we started working on the implementation of the Inno Week, we see it as a stable part of our culture. There are some solid successes fueling it; both with building bridges between teams and with product enhancements already being rolled out to users of our digital portfolio. We also see many smaller daily reminders of the benefits of bottom-up innovation, like an easier request form, a more stable CI, or an updated tooling. We are still not at the point where everyone is participating in the Inno Week, but ultimately, it’s not the goal either. The aim is to provide a format that allows ideas to be tested quickly and learn from people you would otherwise not necessarily meet. These small things make big companies enjoy some of the most important benefits of smaller startups, while also having the resources and maturity to make a stable global impact.</p><p>On a more personal side, I’m proud that this crucial component of Promaton’s culture is flowing into the culture of Straumann Group. It’s a good thing and it fueled so many of our innovations, so it is amazing to see it working now on a much bigger scale too. Obviously, this couldn’t be done without the support of key members of the Executive Management Board of Straumann (Thomas Friese and Florian Kirsch) and without the hard work and dedication of Mathieu, Julien, Claude and Bas (see above).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=585c2721de17" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://blog.promaton.com/the-power-of-a-single-week-dedicated-to-innovation-585c2721de17">The Power of a Single Week Dedicated to Innovation</a> was originally published in <a href="https://blog.promaton.com/">Promaton</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Copying Tech Giants May Hurt Your Startup]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/the-google-trap-why-copying-tech-giants-may-hurt-your-startup-3b36aae9dc9c?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3b36aae9dc9c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[product-management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[management]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[agile]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ágoston Török]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Nov 2024 02:54:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-24T12:07:40.252Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Explained with a Dead Simple Analogy</h4><p>At my first startup, we eagerly looked to adapt the latest methodologies from tech giants like Google, Netflix, and Amazon. We thought, if it works for them, it should work for us, right? But over time, I became more and more cautious. Don’t get me wrong; their solutions are smart. However, I began to realize that they might be smart solutions for the challenges of a different company.</p><h3>David vs. Goliath</h3><p>I’m not talking about differences in geography or market. I’m talking about the difference in <strong>age and maturity</strong>. I started to feel that perhaps some simpler methods would be more effective at the stage our company was in. Sure, they might not scale in the long run, but is that a good enough reason not to adopt them while they still work?</p><p>The thing became most clear to me when I wanted to invite a friend — a product manager at one of the FAANG companies — to give a talk about their methods. She told me she could share their secret in just one sentence:</p><blockquote>“We spend an unfathomable sum on R&amp;D”</blockquote><p>To put this into perspective, Google’s parent company, Alphabet, spent <strong>$45 billion</strong> on R&amp;D in <a href="https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/GOOGL/alphabet/research-development-expenses">2023</a>. Given a headcount of 180,000 employees that <a href="https://tradingeconomics.com/goog:us:employees">year</a>, they spent around <strong>$250,000 per employee</strong>. Obviously, only a fraction of those employees work in R&amp;D, so the actual spend per R&amp;D employee is much higher.</p><p>Let’s take it one step further: for your startup with just <strong>ten people</strong>, you’d need to spend <strong>$2.5 million annually on only R&amp;D</strong> to match that per-employee expenditure. For reference, consider that <a href="https://bwdisrupt.com/article/health-tech-startup-healthify-secures-funding-of-20-mn-537267">Healthify</a> recently received <strong>$20 million</strong> in funding. Given their size, that amount would fund their R&amp;D for just <strong>over two weeks </strong>with the Alphabet rate.</p><p>Of course, this isn’t realistic for a startup. But does this mean we’re all just waiting to join the <a href="https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31377826">list of companies</a> killed by Big Tech? Oh, far from it. Quite the opposite. Let me share a helpful analogy and some strategic considerations that helped me understand why this isn’t the case.</p><p>Of course, this is not realistic. But is it then that we are all just waiting to join the <a href="https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31377826">list of companies</a> killed by Big Tech? Oh, far from that. Quite the opposite; I’m going to present you a helpful analogy and some visual strategy considerations that helped me understand why this is so true.</p><h3>The $250,000 Per Employee Question</h3><p>Suppose you and your friend decided to create a startup in your garage and got a $100,000 investment from an angel investor to develop your MVP in 12 months. In that case, you’d roughly spend $50,000 on R&amp;D per employee (assuming no sales, marketing, and other <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operating_expense">OPEX</a>). That’s one-fifth of what Google spends. So can you compete with Google? Or could they just decide tomorrow to build your product faster and better with their world-class team?</p><p>Yes and no.</p><p><strong>Yes</strong>, because Big Tech companies strive to preserve their agility. For example, after the release of ChatGPT in November 2022, Google was beta-testing Bard with 10,000 users by February 2023. They can move quickly when they need to.</p><p>But also <strong>no</strong>, because Big Tech operates in the commodity space — they are <strong>“corporate agile.”</strong> Some of you may be surprised to hear this but yes they are innovative companies but yes also their consumers expect a quality-level that is the standard in the commodity space. They have to navigate complex processes and contexts that just don’t exist for you. Releasing a product as a tech giant involves media scrutiny and the risk of affecting stock prices. Their very size slows them down in ways that you, as a startup, are not hindered by.</p><blockquote>On the other hand, you and your friend in your fresh startup can take paths that don’t exist in Big Tech anymore.</blockquote><p>You can move faster and take risks without worrying about shareholder reaction. It’s just the two of you, so so <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parkinson&#39;s_law">that’s what it’s going to take</a> to build the MVP.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*siLksRleGLiRMnZ_EhhuLg.png" /><figcaption>Fig 2. The Innovator’s Dilemma. Google’s (1) strategy to the growth of ChatGPT meant launching a comprehensive generative AI solution designed to compete directly and recapture users for the Google ecosystem. On the other hand, for a startup like Anthropic (2), an entirely different but perfectly reasonable strategy involved focusing on a specific market segment — namely, customers sensitive to safety and security concerns (notice the slight difference in the position and size of the customer). Notation according to the <a href="https://medium.com/p/2e6232e4578f">Wardley-Torok model</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>The crazy thing is that although both you and Big Tech need to move to different terrains to release a product, your motion will be rightward while Big Tech will need to do a leftward move (Fig 2). The natural progression is rightward — toward growth and complexity. So even without $250,000 per employee, you stand a fair chance of being successful with your disruptive product.</p><blockquote>This is the essence of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Innovator%27s_Dilemma"><strong>innovator’s dilemma</strong></a>.</blockquote><p>It’s partly why ChatGPT <a href="https://www.statista.com/statistics/1454331/united-states-chatgpt-gemini-app-downloads/">wins</a> over Gemini today, and why Google <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2005/11/20/big-jump-in-search-engine-use/">won</a> over Yahoo in the 2000s.</p><h3><strong>The Charm of MVPs</strong></h3><p>One downside of commodities is the lack of any level of personalization. Think about how annoying it is to carry a travel adapter every time you visit a different continent. <strong>MVPs still offer diversity and specialization</strong>.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.synetiq.net/">first startup</a> I was part of used sensors to measure people’s reactions to ads, helping brands understand which videos resonated with their customers. We had a significant “competitor” in the US: <strong>Affectiva</strong>. I use the term “competitor” loosely because we quickly realized that while Affectiva operated in many countries (they measured consumer reactions in 90 countries on 53,000 ads), there were other areas where our product could better address local needs.</p><p>There, I worked alongside the best salesperson I’ve ever known. Her skills helped us thrive in <strong>Central Europe</strong>, measuring <a href="https://www.synetiq.net/solutions">12,000 ads for more than 80 customers like <strong>Ikea, HBO, Tesco</strong> etc</a>. The key was knowing the area we operated in and tailoring our message and approach to that.</p><p>The reason I’m telling this is that you should first have a plan to win in your niche before you aspire to build a castle in the platform and commodity space. Understand your market, your customers, and your unique advantages. And when you look for methods, consider searching for successful companies of your size and business stage instead of just copying the wisdom of experts in the commodity space.</p><p>Visit us at <a href="https://www.datadriveninvestor.com/"><em>DataDrivenInvestor.com</em></a></p><p>Subscribe to DDIntel <a href="https://www.ddintel.com/"><em>here</em></a>.</p><p>Join our creator ecosystem <a href="https://join.datadriveninvestor.com/"><em>here</em></a>.</p><p>DDI Official Telegram Channel: <a href="https://t.me/+tafUp6ecEys4YjQ1">https://t.me/+tafUp6ecEys4YjQ1</a></p><p>Follow us on <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/data-driven-investor"><em>LinkedIn</em></a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/@DDInvestorHQ"><em>Twitter</em></a>, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/c/datadriveninvestor"><em>YouTube</em></a>, and <a href="https://www.facebook.com/datadriveninvestor"><em>Facebook</em></a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3b36aae9dc9c" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/the-google-trap-why-copying-tech-giants-may-hurt-your-startup-3b36aae9dc9c">Why Copying Tech Giants May Hurt Your Startup</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/">DataDrivenInvestor</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to Draw a Strategy in 4 Steps]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/how-to-draw-a-strategy-in-4-steps-2e6232e4578f?source=rss-798a10893c3e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2e6232e4578f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[strategy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wardley-maps]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[management]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ágoston Török]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Oct 2024 13:49:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-24T12:10:01.233Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>How to Draw a Strategy in 4 Easy Steps</h3><h4>One strategic picture says more than a thousand strategic words</h4><p>It took me writing three bad strategies before I finally started looking beyond my excuses and discovered the contours of a solution. With the following 10-minute read, I’d like to save you three months of work. That was the time I invested in writing those strategies, and although I learned a lot, I wish someone had told me what I’m about to share with you.</p><h3>Why Is It So Difficult to Write a Strategy?</h3><p>One of my first tasks as a CTO was to write an engineering strategy. I learned about our business, our technology, and the competitive landscape, and then wrote down an amazing vision of where we should go. The document was well-structured (i.e., it had three strategic pillars), featured all the buzzwords, and I was proud of myself.</p><p>However, when I presented it to the CEO, he was not impressed. He told me that it should be connected to the company and product strategies instead of being a standalone document. I didn’t understand this comment because I thought I had done exactly that.</p><p>Anyway, I revised the document and paid extra attention to connecting it to the product strategy. I included all the capabilities we discussed in meetings so the strategy wouldn’t have blind spots. When I felt ready, I showed it to the CEO… who was again unimpressed. His comment this time was that he missed tangible actions on what we should do. I was clueless again; I spent entire pages describing where we should be with the specific capabilities we have in one year. He acknowledged that but still felt this was not the holy grail.</p><p>So I started again, this time from scratch. I’ve read <a href="https://lethain.com/eng-strategies/">Will Larson’s</a>, <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/42414767-technology-strategy-patterns">Eben Hewitt’s</a>, <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/44144493-fundamentals-of-software-architecture">Mark Richards’</a>, <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/33369254-the-manager-s-path">Camille Fournier’s</a>, and <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/11721966-good-strategy-bad-strategy">Richard Rumelt’s</a> guidelines. You know, I’m the kind of person who, once he sets his mind to something, leaves no stone unturned in his efforts to accomplish it. And I was sure this time I was going to ace it. I looked at each of the things in motion, selected the ones that would lead us to the Promised Land, and wrote them down. I also learned from my mistake of writing a 12-page monster last time and wrote only 6 pages with lots of bullet points. I was ready to present it and collect the — by this time, really well-deserved — applause, flowers, and whatever authors of good strategy documents get.</p><p>But I didn’t get any of those; instead, the CEO noted that it’s again a step in the right direction but lacks the overarching narrative and, more importantly, how we are going to address our most important challenges. I was devastated.</p><blockquote>I just couldn’t understand how I could have failed at it three times and why it is so difficult to write a good strategy.</blockquote><h3>Because You Have to Draw It</h3><p>Amidst my desperation, I came across a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcp6YMAmI3M">talk from Simon Wardley</a>, creator of the Wardley maps. He started by describing his first strategy which was full of buzzwords and led nowhere. I felt he was describing mine. Then he showed how maps differ from graphs. It clicked immediately. I thought, “OMG, I’ve got the solution: it’s difficult to <em>write</em> a strategy because you have to <em>draw</em> it.” And then he explained Wardley maps in the remaining 40 minutes, and I immediately understood it and felt:</p><blockquote>“Yes! Finally! I’ve got the solution to my problem! I have to create a Wardley map”</blockquote><p>The whole idea is based on the notion that we have excellent visual reasoning skills in actual physical spaces where position and motion make sense. Therefore, Wardley maps use a 2D space (see Fig 1), where one dimension represents the <strong>Visibility of Value</strong> and the second one represents the <strong>Evolution of the Capability</strong>. Genius.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/567/1*gpPep-Crk_7lmViwqPJ1Pg.png" /><figcaption>Fig 1. An example value chain for an Artisan Tea House. Your main value offering could be the cup of tea, <em>whose value is supported by the prototype homemade artisan design of the cup, the well-trained staff, and commodities such as tea from a supplier. These further depend on other commodities such as cups from a ceramic maker and water from the utility provider. The connecting lines help map the value chain.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Visibility of Value combines the actual value with its visibility; this helps resolve the conflict that often happens between engineers and salespeople: one says something is of high value, and the other says, “Okay, but it is not visible.” Imagine this dimension as something like the time of day: night is low visibility, and noon is high visibility. This helps explain why it’s so difficult to get feedback and make things work smoothly together when they are buried deep in the value chain. At night, we have more trouble seeing the details of an object. Of course, if your eyes are used to the dark, you can be pretty efficient there, but a customer would have quite some trouble navigating it.</p><p>Evolution is even more interesting. On the left-hand side, you have the spark that starts everything, and gradually you go through iterations to reach PoC (Proof of Concept), prototype, MVP (Minimum Viable Product), evolution, and finally become a commodity. This doesn’t mean that you always travel through the entire dimension; it’s just that, in principle, things can <strong>evolve</strong>, and in fact — on a global scale — things typically evolve into a commodity over time. But this is not an isometric space; in fact, moving from a mature product to a commodity and from PoC to prototype requires quite different approaches.</p><p>Then what usually happens after a Eureka moment happened: I calmed down and started to think about it a bit more. Yes, the CEO would understand <strong>a</strong> map, but surely he wouldn’t watch the 40-minute “Learning About Wardley Maps” on YouTube to understand my map. And it’s valid; Wardley maps make perfect sense, but are they really intuitive?</p><p>The problem is not really the axis labels (i.e. genesis to commodity) or that figures can include <a href="https://x.com/swardley/status/1640794194112577537">lots of capabilities</a>. If you have ever seen a <a href="https://smarts-ef.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Gainess_Mill_1430.png">military strategy visualization</a> then that is also often full of labels which are similarly difficult to understand unless you know the geographic area. However, what they do very clearly is representing dynamics and challenges (in the case of military maps, those are typically the enemy).</p><h3>When an Image Works Without Explanation</h3><p>So I sat down and started to think about how I could show dynamics and challenges in an immediately accessible way. Luckily, during my PhD, I did quite a lot of research with my father on <a href="https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-319-95996-2_3">cognitive data visualizations</a>.</p><p>The thing that military strategy figures do well is to represent opposing forces: us and our threats. This is one of the things that is missing from regular Wardley maps. It is easily fixable though, I just have to mirror the space vertically and then I have a place (with an inverted Visibility axis) for the threats. Another thing missing is an intuitive visualization of time. But military strategy maps visualize nicely time too, either by using different <a href="https://kosmossociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/Gaugamela-Two.jpg">type of line</a>, or <a href="https://www.battlefields.org/sites/default/files/styles/wysiwyg_original/public/Brandy-Station--Fleetwood-Hill-Fight--June-9-1863-%28May-2024%29.jpg?itok=6OqawOm9">different type of arrow</a>, or other notation (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_strategy#/media/File:Waterloo_Campaign_map-alt3.svg">e.g. numbers</a>). I opted for using simple arrows for the past and double-sided/filled arrows for the planned movements.</p><p>So let’s see see how to draw strategy in four steps now (see Fig 2).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*bJQgyOgpdE9mNW3NC2gOUg.png" /><figcaption>Fig 2. First (1) you map you value chain. Then (2) you map your threats and challenges. Then (3) you add how those items changed in the past. Finally, (4) you add how they would/should move in the future.</figcaption></figure><ol><li><strong>Map your value chain</strong>: follow the tutorial by <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IJcLmoKR6v8">Ben Mosior</a> to map your value chain in a Wardley-map.</li><li><strong>Map your threats:</strong> there are multiple ways to do it; the easiest is to just think about what could make it more difficult (or impossible) to meet the customer demand. It could be that there are some hypothetical threats (Less evolved, Low visibility), or something is a risk in the PoC stage but we are confident we will fix it (More evolved, higher visibility), or you know that the cloud provider is going to increase prices next year; you just don’t know by how much (Highly evolved, low visibility).</li><li><strong>Add past movements:</strong> it’s time to add dynamics. Think about how things changed over the past few months. At this point, you should start to watch out for introducing too much clutter to the image. Are there any connecting supply lines that you can remove because they are self-explanatory? Or are there lines which are not so well established in reality (especially, threats may not form one single “threat-chain”)? Are there any past motions that you can leave undisplayed without altering the overall picture? E.g. small movements could mean practically that the capability was “at rest” rather.</li><li><strong>Add future movements</strong>: look at the figure and imagine the system’s inertia: things that were moving continue to move, and things that were at rest would stay at rest. Draw these in with blue for threats and red for assets. Now think about where you would need to redirect the arrows to make sure you meet the customer&#39;s need. The point is not to get all your capabilities where the customer is, you just have to provide enough support for your product that it can deliver.</li></ol><blockquote>Now, you just have to figure out what you need to do in real life to make those changes in direction. These are your <strong>strategic actions</strong>.</blockquote><p>Done. I call this <strong>Wardley-Torok mapping</strong>.</p><h3>Let’s See Some Practical Examples</h3><p>My favorite is <strong>the case of feature overengineering</strong>. Let’s say a manager asks an engineer to develop a feature. The engineer starts to work on it and is giving only low-level updates. Meanwhile, the manager&#39;s fear is increasing that we will run out of time before the feature works. Finally, they meet, and the manager says that there is no more time; we have to show something. Then in the presentation, it turns out that the feature has all sorts of bells and whistles but is just not doing exactly what the customer minimally wanted.</p><p>Let’s see where strategy mapping could have helped. You can see what the engineer would have drawn at the meeting before the presentation in Fig 3.1. In his representation, there were no issues; it was just a matter of showing the great and mature product. In reality, though, despite the product’s high evolution, it didn’t include the features the customer needed (Fig 3.2). So the optimal choice would have been to learn what the customer actually wanted and make the necessary changes, even if that means incurring technical debt (i.e. making the product less mature).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*XSxPsMv1iwwv6zFBptIMkg.png" /><figcaption>Fig 3. Perception matters. On the left (1) you can see a view of the engineer working on a capability, who believes the customer wanted all the implemented features and now they have only to show the ready work. On the right (1) you see an example when this is actually overengineering, here the capability has higher evolution than the customer wanted. Here it’s clear that the previous “strategy” would not be the right choice. Rather, they have to learn about what the customer wanted and modify the design.</figcaption></figure><p>You can also see that I’m not talking here about the strategy of the company or the manager. Many think that strategic thinking is only required for people high up in the management ladder; I believe the opposite:</p><blockquote>We need easier ways to talk about strategy so that everyone can participate in the discussion.</blockquote><p>Let’s think a bit more about how important is how we place things in this space. Take another <strong>example: a wrong estimate</strong>. Here your manager comes to you and asks how much it would cost to manufacture 1 million units of the prototype you’ve just put together. You look at the price of putting together the prototype, divided it by two (i.e., economies of scale), multiply by a million, and say that it’s probably in that ballpark. Your manager forwards it to her manager without too much thinking, and you both consider the job done. However, at the next meeting, you find yourself in a crisis meeting because it turned out that you just killed the product before even launching it as the company can never make a profit at scale with these numbers.</p><p>Now, depending on how you represent the threat, the chosen actions will differ. If you perceive (see Fig 4) the wrong estimate as an evolved (x-axis) and highly visible (y-axis) threat that indicates a substantial chance that the product would not scale, you might be tempted to go ahead and optimize it, cut costs, and ensure that you release something that would scale. The cost of this is that you waste time and miss your early adopters, who would have been happy to buy it even at a higher price or would have given you enough marketing so that it’s worth it to lose money on the unit price.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*CD8raGeh4n5GmO5MAvgoBQ.png" /><figcaption>Fig 4. <em>Perception primes action. On the left (1) we see a situation where the threat is perceived as quite an evolved threat with relatively high visibility, and it attracts the team’s focus away from the customer’s immediate needs. On the right (2) we see another representation of the situation with similar visibility but much less evolved, which requires a different action from the team.</em></figcaption></figure><p>On the other hand, you could also see that this wrong estimate drew attention to the fears behind the scalability of the product. But at this point, you could address these fears simply by making a better estimate, without investing any work into premature optimization and committing to delays. Which perception is right? Depends on the situation.</p><blockquote>Your strategy is a hypothesis for the best action based on the analysis of the situation</blockquote><p>Also, you don’t necessarily have to fight threats. Like in the example of Fig 5, you can simply say to the stakeholders that, yes indeed, we have concerns about the scalability of the product, but an even bigger challenge is to find product-market fit. And that’s our focus with the release of the MVP to the first 1,000 users. We will deal with all other priorities later.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/567/1*cstZKC-z9cwWAnDeiZdnmw.png" /><figcaption>Fig 5. <em>Representation drives strategy choice. In the above case, one could easily see the fears about lack of scalability as addressable but still opt for delivering a “non-scalable” MVP to get early customer feedback before embarking on optimization for scalability.</em></figcaption></figure><h3><strong>So What Did I Learn from My Three Failed Attempts?</strong></h3><p>Now, thanks to Wardley-Torok maps, I can show <strong>exactly</strong> what the issues were with my strategies. And of course, in hindsight, it all makes perfect sense.</p><p>In the first strategy (see Fig 6), I wrote down things that are all cool and would probably be the right steps for one company or another, but I totally missed understanding our company (i.e., what our value add is to our customers).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8nbZP9FVwACnFkb6U2lQZQ.png" /><figcaption><em>Fig 6. Simplified Wardley-Torok maps of my three strategies. Dashed lines indicate the missing components. First (1) I just wrote up all cool and shiny things but didn’t understand our value offering to customers deeply enough. Then (2) I understood the value offering and described an optimal target state of our capabilities but didn’t write down how to get there. Finally (3), I collected all critical parts of our value chain and indicated the forces we have in the system, but I didn’t specify which strategic choices about changes of direction we have to make.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Then in the next one, I understood that correctly and even our specific value chain, but I mostly mapped the target states and not how to get there, which is a vision and not a strategy. Then, in my last one, I correctly mapped the dynamics and in some cases recognized that we should make some fine-tunings. But without the strategic actions, I just made a good snapshot of our organization’s inertia. Luckily, from here you can see that I’m very close to the actual strategy; it just took three months of work to get there without the mapping I described above. So I thought I would save you some time by just showing it to you.</p><p>This model is licensed CC BY-SA 4.0</p><p>Visit us at <a href="https://www.datadriveninvestor.com/"><em>DataDrivenInvestor.com</em></a></p><p>Subscribe to DDIntel <a href="https://www.ddintel.com/"><em>here</em></a>.</p><p>Join our creator ecosystem <a href="https://join.datadriveninvestor.com/"><em>here</em></a>.</p><p>DDI Official Telegram Channel: <a href="https://t.me/+tafUp6ecEys4YjQ1">https://t.me/+tafUp6ecEys4YjQ1</a></p><p>Follow us on <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/data-driven-investor"><em>LinkedIn</em></a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/@DDInvestorHQ"><em>Twitter</em></a>, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/c/datadriveninvestor"><em>YouTube</em></a>, and <a href="https://www.facebook.com/datadriveninvestor"><em>Facebook</em></a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2e6232e4578f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/how-to-draw-a-strategy-in-4-steps-2e6232e4578f">How to Draw a Strategy in 4 Steps</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.datadriveninvestor.com/">DataDrivenInvestor</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>