<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Z Nicolazzo on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Z Nicolazzo on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@trans_killjoy?source=rss-60468f47489f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 18:56:37 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@trans_killjoy/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Not Another Gender Binary: A Call For Complexity Over Cis-Readability]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/pulpmag/not-another-gender-binary-a-call-for-complexity-over-cis-readability-3f9d7029b4d1?source=rss-60468f47489f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3f9d7029b4d1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nonbinary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender-identity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Z Nicolazzo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 15 Jan 2020 12:26:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-15T12:26:07.692Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>Why a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy is counterproductive to gender liberation</em></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-f2ego2qfWBJhXVRBotbPQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>// <a href="https://broadlygenderphotos.vice.com/#Relationships">Broadly</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*iiCSnY4cVpPnKr8LVl61Vw.png" /></figure><h4>by T.J. Jourian and <a href="https://medium.com/u/60468f47489f">Z Nicolazzo</a></h4><p><em>Part of </em><a href="https://medium.com/national-center-for-institutional-diversity/nonbinary-identities-and-individuals-in-research-community-and-the-academy-e2b8a3f23684"><em>Nonbinary Identities and Individuals in Research, Community, and the Academy: A Series Beyond the Gender Binary</em></a><em>. Originally published by the </em><a href="https://medium.com/national-center-for-institutional-diversity/not-another-gender-binary-a-call-for-complexity-over-cis-readability-d9eaefdcefc2"><em>National Center for Institutional Diversity at the University of Michigan</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>A s trans people, not much makes us crankier than the insistence of a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy, or the arbitrary dividing of trans people into two camps based on someone’s idea of who is and is not conforming to masculine men’s and feminine women’s presentations.</p><p>As trans scholars and educators, we understand the importance of making trans realities accessible, especially to those out there searching for someone “like them.” But this is <strong><em>not</em></strong> achieved by supplanting one gender binary with another — by making some trans people more like cis (or nontrans) people and others less like cis people.</p><p>Spoiler alert: it’s not about cis people!</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fembed%2F3o6wrrSEp6rFeICCIM%2Ftwitter%2Fiframe&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fgifs%2Flgbt-transgender-trans-3o6wrrSEp6rFeICCIM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.giphy.com%2Fmedia%2F3o6wrrSEp6rFeICCIM%2Fgiphy.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=giphy" width="435" height="244" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7936369069353c1d0aa9df4820d0ef82/href">https://medium.com/media/7936369069353c1d0aa9df4820d0ef82/href</a></iframe><p>Beyond conveying a lack of understanding of what trans is, does, and can do as a way of being and thinking, the supposed nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy relies on normative judgements about who/what is “trans enough” and/or “really trans.”</p><p>We don’t reach gender liberation by prioritizing cis understandings of trans and gender nonconforming identities and experiences. Rather than push for more fluid, dynamic, and intersectional notions of gender expansiveness, the “binary v. nonbinary trans people” fallacy keeps our most simplified and palatable narratives front and center.</p><p>This is yet another practice of <strong><em>cislation</em>, or the translating of seemingly illegible (i.e., not understandable) genders for cis recognition</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*7lhxnxzkz2zfiA5QhsN_-g.png" /></figure><blockquote>“We don’t reach gender liberation by prioritizing cis understandings of trans and gender nonconforming identities and experiences.”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*7lhxnxzkz2zfiA5QhsN_-g.png" /></figure><h3>What is Cislation?</h3><p>Simply put, <a href="http://writewhereithurts.net/2017/08/16/the-cislation-of-transness-in-higher-education-and-student-affairs-scholarship-part-1/">cislation</a> is what happens when trans people feel compelled to create narratives about our transness in the simplest, most reductive of terms.</p><p>The <a href="https://janetmock.com/2012/07/09/josie-romero-dateline-transgender-trapped-body/">“trapped in the wrong body” narrative</a> is one such example.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fembed%2Fl0ErNaV2Z7DLYOhd6%2Ftwitter%2Fiframe&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fgifs%2Flgbt-transgender-trans-l0ErNaV2Z7DLYOhd6&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.giphy.com%2Fmedia%2Fl0ErNaV2Z7DLYOhd6%2Fgiphy.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=giphy" width="435" height="244" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d8f20942b4d29b29b15346d85015bad1/href">https://medium.com/media/d8f20942b4d29b29b15346d85015bad1/href</a></iframe><p>We do this not because we lack complexity, but as a way to be legible (i.e., understandable) to cisgender people, and as a recognition that we live in a world and <a href="https://muse.jhu.edu/article/626125">in an academy</a> that lacks the ability to know us and our transness.</p><p>Some of y’all can’t even deal with <a href="https://www.dictionary.com/e/they-is-a-singular-pronoun/">“they” as a singular pronoun</a>! Cislation signals cisgender people’s lack of understanding, and the omnipresence of a cultural gender binary discourse (explained below) through which we as trans people must wade.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fembed%2Fl0ErE79Ng63oqUS2c%2Ftwitter%2Fiframe&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fgifs%2Flgbt-transgender-trans-l0ErE79Ng63oqUS2c&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.giphy.com%2Fmedia%2Fl0ErE79Ng63oqUS2c%2Fgiphy.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=giphy" width="435" height="244" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/13c903b7aac6b2df5d02f978260a6342/href">https://medium.com/media/13c903b7aac6b2df5d02f978260a6342/href</a></iframe><p>There are various problems with cislation, especially in relation to the oversimplification of trans populations into a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy.</p><p>For a population of people who specifically move across binary constructs of gender, this unnecessary dichotomy rings false, counterproductive, and dangerous. Below, we articulate five arguments for why the creation of a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy is problematic and why we need to move beyond these manifestations of cislation.</p><h3>#1: The “Binary = Bad” Ascription</h3><p>As we have articulated through some of our own <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/17508487.2017.1356340">scholarship</a>, <a href="https://styluspub.presswarehouse.com/browse/book/9781620364567/Trans-in-College">gender binary discourse</a> — the archaic notion that gender consists of two and only two “opposite” genders, between and amongst which there is no movement, overlap, or fluidity — limits the livability of trans peoples’ lives. We and other trans scholars pose gender binary discourse as a negative ascription; a way of thinking that we should avoid and unlearn.</p><p>So when one poses a question about, writes about, or consolidates any group of trans people under the banner of being “binary trans individuals,” the negative ascription carries over to that group. For example, if one is posed as being a “binary trans person,” they are perceived to be upholding dominant notions of gender, and thus, are positioned as not doing “trans” right, correct, or well.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*7lhxnxzkz2zfiA5QhsN_-g.png" /></figure><blockquote><strong>Our insistence that we avoid and unlearn a way of <em>thinking</em> turns into a suggestion that we avoid and unlearn a way of <em>being</em></strong>.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*7lhxnxzkz2zfiA5QhsN_-g.png" /></figure><p>Meaning, there is the accusation that some trans people — the “binary” ones — are not doing trans “right” or “correctly.” In this equation, those consolidated under the heading of “binary trans individuals” are living a life framed by negativity.</p><p>Ironically, this is the flip side of the not doing trans “right” or “correctly” coin that has also been flinged at gender nonconforming and nonbinary people by assimilationist elements of trans populations, who are surrendering to a desire of acceptability by cis society — our own brand of respectability politics. Thus, attempts to be easily explainable to cis people marks all trans people as not “enough” in one way or another.</p><h3>#2: There is Nothing Not Radical about Moving Across Genders</h3><p><a href="https://www.sealpress.com/titles/susan-stryker/transgender-history-second-edition/9781580056908/">Susan Stryker articulated</a> that transgender “refer[s] to people who move away from the gender they were assigned at birth, people who cross over (trans-) the boundaries constructed by their culture to define and contain gender.”</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fembed%2Fl0ErPGPrSmShoPgac%2Ftwitter%2Fiframe&amp;display_name=Giphy&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fgifs%2Flgbt-transgender-trans-l0ErPGPrSmShoPgac&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia3.giphy.com%2Fmedia%2Fl0ErPGPrSmShoPgac%2Fgiphy.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=giphy" width="435" height="244" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7a3b61cf94d093539669767a2ef4c165/href">https://medium.com/media/7a3b61cf94d093539669767a2ef4c165/href</a></iframe><p>In whatever way we as trans people express our genders, however we practice this radical act of self-determination and reclamation in a world constantly seeking to erase us, <a href="http://www.lttr.org/journal/1/dress-to-kill-fight-to-win">there is nothing not radical about this movement across genders</a>.</p><p>To produce the supposed nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy suggests some trans people — again, the “binary” ones — are somehow opting into that gross gender binary (il)logic, thus (re)producing societal forms of gendered hegemonic violence, or how gender is posed as always and only binary, thus limiting gender self-determination.</p><p><strong>The suggestion that “binary” trans movement reproduces gendered hegemonic violence strips our gender-based movement of its radical potential</strong>.</p><p>It suggests some of us — the “binary” ones — are invested in hurting and harming the trans community, because in the end, we are all just (re)producing dominance, albeit in new morphological ways. This (il)logic is trans-antagonistic at best, and violent at worst.</p><h3>#3: What Even is “Binary” Transness?</h3><p>In thinking about the cislation inherent in the creation of the nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy, we ask: who is assuming that “binary trans” is a mode of being in the world?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fembed%2F3o6wrwZq2GqQRs6U0M%2Ftwitter%2Fiframe&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fgifs%2Flgbt-transgender-trans-3o6wrwZq2GqQRs6U0M&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.giphy.com%2Fmedia%2F3o6wrwZq2GqQRs6U0M%2Fgiphy.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=giphy" width="435" height="244" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/394e47413c8d6520d414691210942678/href">https://medium.com/media/394e47413c8d6520d414691210942678/href</a></iframe><p>How is this dichotomy limiting? <strong>What does it even mean to be a “binary trans individual”?</strong>Who determines whether someone is “binary” or “nonbinary”? Is it based on biomedical transitioning? Does it matter if one “passes”? On whose standards of beauty does one define “passing”?</p><p>What about trans people who are biomedically transitioning <em>and</em> claim a nonbinary identity; are they just confused or living a sense of false consciousness? Or nonbinary trans people who do not desire to biomedically transition and do not “pass” based on nontrans people’s standards of beauty?</p><p>How are racism, ableism, classism, and settler colonialism encoded into notions of “passing” and who is able/desires to biomedically transition in the first place, thus framing all of the aforementioned questions?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fembed%2F2UGo07TMdzsre%2Ftwitter%2Fiframe&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fgifs%2Fschool-course-francisco-2UGo07TMdzsre&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.giphy.com%2Fmedia%2F2UGo07TMdzsre%2F200.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=giphy" width="435" height="226" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/2b619bcddaac2f417beb625cb0b05b4e/href">https://medium.com/media/2b619bcddaac2f417beb625cb0b05b4e/href</a></iframe><p><strong>The creation of “binary” transness is foisted upon trans people by the inherent desire for cislation by nontrans people as they try to make sense of our lives</strong>. And yet again, that sense-making is (less directly perhaps) based on cis people’s “preoccupation with transition and surgery [which] objectifies trans people”, as <a href="https://www.salon.com/2014/01/07/laverne_cox_artfully_shuts_down_katie_courics_invasive_questions_about_transgender_people/">Laverne Cox</a> put it.</p><p>In this way of thinking, trans people are posed as gender guinea pigs to be picked apart and prodded, to be judged by standards of beauty and notions of “passing” we never asked for, nor do we have much say in. Simply put: “binary” transness is a cage into which some of us are placed by nontrans people’s desires for cislation, and it needs to stop.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*7lhxnxzkz2zfiA5QhsN_-g.png" /></figure><blockquote>How are racism, ableism, classism, and settler colonialism encoded into notions of “passing”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*7lhxnxzkz2zfiA5QhsN_-g.png" /></figure><h3>#4: Transness Extends beyond Embodiment</h3><p>Suggesting a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy defines transness as being always and only about bodies.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fembed%2Fl0ErDKFRTSp8hEW8o%2Ftwitter%2Fiframe&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fgifs%2Flgbt-transgender-trans-l0ErDKFRTSp8hEW8o&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.giphy.com%2Fmedia%2Fl0ErDKFRTSp8hEW8o%2Fgiphy.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=giphy" width="435" height="244" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3fec495a4b1663f44dee9da3275563f9/href">https://medium.com/media/3fec495a4b1663f44dee9da3275563f9/href</a></iframe><p>However, as trans and queer scholars have been writing about for years, transness is also an <a href="https://read.dukeupress.edu/books/book/23/chapter/97439/Troubling-the-WatersMobilizing-a-Trans-Analytic">analytic</a>, a <a href="https://www.ingentaconnect.com/contentone/aup/tgen/2017/00000020/00000004/art00006">method</a>, a <a href="https://read.dukeupress.edu/glq/article/3/4/437/9940/Punks-Bulldaggers-and-Welfare-Queens-The-Radical">politic</a>, an <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0042085917697203">epistemology</a>, and a lens through which to do <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09650792.2016.1203343">research</a>.</p><p><strong>To affix transness to the body via this false binary limits the expansiveness of the notion itself</strong>.</p><p>While trans may well have started off as a way of making meaning of embodied realities — as Stryker’s earlier quote highlights — it has very quickly proliferated in a wild abundance of divergent possibilities for thinking, being, researching, and activism.</p><h3>#5: Trans is Both Capacious and Specific</h3><p><strong><em>There is no good, logical argument for segmenting off notions of transness</em></strong>. Yes, we all experience our transness differently, and everyone should be cautious not to create monolithic understandings of transness based on categorical claims.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fembed%2Fl1IYcDnXUhue1NqAo%2Ftwitter%2Fiframe&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fgifs%2Flgbt-transgender-trans-l1IYcDnXUhue1NqAo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.giphy.com%2Fmedia%2Fl1IYcDnXUhue1NqAo%2Fgiphy.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=giphy" width="435" height="244" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6b037034c819b3787ea0fce5ed5ae38f/href">https://medium.com/media/6b037034c819b3787ea0fce5ed5ae38f/href</a></iframe><p>We are certainly not calling for a singular and reductive notion of transness. However, we do not have to sacrifice honoring the complexities of transness to honor each of our specificities.</p><p>We can do both; we can have our specific understandings of self while also aligning ourselves politically, socially, and ethically with broader trans communities, or communities of trans experience, or various other signifiers that resonate with who we are.</p><p>The imposition of an “opposite” or binary between/among trans peoples need not exist, and only serves to sever connections across experiences, politically and otherwise.</p><h3>Don’t Cislate Me Bro, Or a Call for Complexity Over Cis-Readability</h3><p>Who we are as trans people is often complex, always beautiful, and infinitely boundless.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fembed%2Fl3vR06t5sk4gtff5S%2Ftwitter%2Fiframe&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fgifs%2Frefinery29gifs-feminism-beard-gender-l3vR06t5sk4gtff5S&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.giphy.com%2Fmedia%2Fl3vR06t5sk4gtff5S%2Fgiphy.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=giphy" width="435" height="242" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0455b56e22bd226a4a6fbc9f5a2a7c34/href">https://medium.com/media/0455b56e22bd226a4a6fbc9f5a2a7c34/href</a></iframe><p>As we have shown, to have our transness codified and limited through the phenomenon of cislation, which substitutes our limitless natures for cisgender peoples’ coherence, is problematic on multiple levels.</p><p>We also understand that our arguments may be challenging for readers in that we stray from easy solutions and digestible understandings of our trans selves for others to consume. This is intentional, lest we fall into the traps of cislation.</p><p><strong>Thus, we close our essay with a call for people of all genders — and especially cisgender people — to embrace complexity over a false sense of readability of trans realities</strong>.</p><p>Embracing our call means focusing not on cis-readability via cislation, but on trans humanity via centering transness in all its boundless potentialities and possibilities. If we care deeply about trans lives, then we need to recognize that the promotion of a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy does more harm than good.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fembed%2Fl0ErH5cIeHYYdaFEI%2Ftwitter%2Fiframe&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgiphy.com%2Fgifs%2Flgbt-transgender-trans-l0ErH5cIeHYYdaFEI&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.giphy.com%2Fmedia%2Fl0ErH5cIeHYYdaFEI%2Fgiphy.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=giphy" width="435" height="244" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/9f213a96643bfe5d43846174f90a912e/href">https://medium.com/media/9f213a96643bfe5d43846174f90a912e/href</a></iframe><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*S6SsepOd8mejF0qucbIO3A.png" /></figure><p><a href="https://lsa.umich.edu/ncid/people/diversity-scholars-directory/tj-jourian.html"><em>T.J. Jourian</em></a><em> is an assistant professor in the Department of Organizational Leadership at Oakland University and a member of the </em><a href="https://lsa.umich.edu/ncid/engagement-opportunities/diversity-scholars-network.html"><em>Diversity Scholars Network</em></a><em> at the National Center for Institutional Diversity. Dr. Jourian’s research interests involve trans* and queer student, staff, and faculty campus experiences and leadership, particularly those of queer and trans* people of color, justice-centered curriculum and pedagogy, and student activism. He is also the co-founder of Trans*forming Higher Education (formerly T*Circle), the only collective by and for trans educators in higher education and student affairs.</em></p><p><a href="https://lsa.umich.edu/ncid/people/diversity-scholars-directory/z-nicolazzo.html"><em>Z Nicolazzo</em></a><em> is an assistant professor of trans* studies in education, co-chair of the Transgender Studies Research Cluster at the University of Arizona, and a member of the </em><a href="https://lsa.umich.edu/ncid/engagement-opportunities/diversity-scholars-network.html"><em>Diversity Scholars Network</em></a><em> at the National Center for Institutional Diversity. Dr. Nicolazzo’s research is focused on exposing and exploring critical gendered perspectives of education. Her first book, Trans* in College, is the first full-length monograph focusing on trans college students through an affirmative-based lens.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eyWrtJBv5k8WjRnDpLPDPg.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3f9d7029b4d1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/pulpmag/not-another-gender-binary-a-call-for-complexity-over-cis-readability-3f9d7029b4d1">Not Another Gender Binary: A Call For Complexity Over Cis-Readability</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/pulpmag">PULPMAG</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Climate Change, Gender Oppression, and Epistemologies of Ignorance]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@trans_killjoy/climate-change-gender-oppression-and-epistemologies-of-ignorance-c032a3237983?source=rss-60468f47489f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c032a3237983</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Z Nicolazzo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Jan 2020 19:15:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-14T19:15:03.846Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Thinking in the End Times</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*COiBhCBAog_VZdAmI4hU5g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Saeed Khan / AFP via Getty Images</figcaption></figure><p>Lately, I have been consumed with fear, dread, and a growing sense of nihilism regarding global climate change. My fear has become so gripping that I have begun to wonder what the point or purpose of my work as a social scientist is. Given my role as an academic, and one whose work is decidedly directed toward expanding possibilities for gender-expansive futures, my current affective stance is distressing. Not only have I begun to worry about the thrust of my work — after all, what good is imagining gender-expansive futures if there is no future for the world? — but it further vexing in the reality that I do not do climate science work, nor would I be any good at it. My grades in science class were rubbish, with the only time I enjoyed them or did well being when we would discuss the theoretical underpinnings of the physics, chemistry, or biology my teachers discussed in my high school class rooms.</p><p>Recently, I was speaking with a friend about the pall of worry in which I have become enveloped. This friend is a fellow educational ethnographer, and as we texted, my mind wandered to a question the two of us — and really, all ethnographer — often find ourselves asking: what’s the discourse at play here? Specifically, I began to wonder how the social discourses that frame out the realities of climate change were at all connected — and if so, how — to those that frame out the realities of transgender oppression. What would such a discourse look, sound, and feel like? How, then, might it make sense to confront, address, or move related to these discourses? I cannot say I felt a sense of hope in that moment, but there was a spark of connectivity that made me wonder how living amongst the rubble of climate change and gender oppression may be intertwined.</p><p>As someone who holds a bachelor’s degree in philosophy, I have become used to people telling me their either loved or hated the required philosophy course they had to take as an undergraduate student. I am also all too aware that many people may question the fecundity of my degree, perhaps assuming that because I teach in a college of education, philosophy is quite far from my current work. In fact, hardly anything could be further from the truth. Over the past decade, I have learned that my undergraduate degree trained me to do the types of thinking and exploration that are quite necessary, including my ongoing investment in exploring how epistemologies animate in/actions on individual, institutional, and societal levels.</p><p>My investments in epistemologies is evident in my work, especially as I push against the social desirability of viewing increased structural diversity as the ultimate form of diversity and inclusion work. That is, while some people are invested in pulling up more seats to the table for diverse bodies, I have become invested in what epistemological structures frame the discussion at the table such that there may be more chairs, but the nature of the discussion — and the behaviors and actions motivated from it — do not shift. For me, it is less about bodies and people — a strange claim, perhaps, for some of my peers in the educational research community — and much more about how one comes to know.</p><p>Inherent in this coming to know, too, is how people are invested in actively unknowing, or what some philosophers have described as an epistemology of ignorance. Philosophers who explore this phenomenon “have made the convincing case that ignorance is no mere lack of knowledge but rather is actively produced and maintained” (Gilson, 2011, pp. 308–309). This actively produced unknowing has the ability to further vulnerability on individual, institutional, and societal levels. An epistemology of ignorance has, then, a directionality and force to it, a weight that does a particular thing, which can be wielded to further injustice and harm on a global scale. For example, when the Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro claimed that “the Amazon is Brazil’s, not yours,” his statement was structured not by a naïveté, but an active unknowing of how the deforestation of the Amazon has dire consequences for the entire planet. As many have claimed, there is a decidedly neoliberal bent to Bolsonaro’s claim, as is there a nationalistic tone that has garnered him the nickname of being the “Brazilian Trump.” However, at its core, it is not that Bolsonaro does not or could not know (I think), but that he does not care to pay attention to that knowledge, nor does he care to allow the possibility of coming to know that knowledge. Bolsonaro’s epistemic reality, then, is structured through a desire and commitment to not knowing particular realities, while at the same time moving toward fantasies of ceaseless growth and the relentless accumulation of monetary wealth for the elite as an inherent good unto itself. It is not that Bolsonaro is a tyrant that is important to me here (though he most certainly is); it is the ways Bolsonaro comes to unknow global climate change and his role in furthering the disastrous nature of our collective current condition.</p><p>The above example with Bolsonaro uncovers a particularly important contour related to epistemologies of ignorance: that of audience. Namely, speakers need audiences to “hear” that which they “speak.” If speakers do not have audiences, then their utterances go “unheard” and, as a result, cannot be acted upon, because there is no audience to do the acting. It would seem, then, that some may actively choose to withdraw their presence as an audience, thus using an epistemology of ignorance as a tool through which to abdicate knowability and responsibility. If one does not provide an audience — to someone or, more to the point for me, to a set of ideas — then there can be no action or movement. The withdrawal of an audience means that which is “spoken” not only does not matter, but cannot matter. Without an audience, the tree may have fallen the forest, but there is the ability to actively deny it fell because, after all, there was no audience to receive the tree as having fallen.</p><p>Writing of the role of audience in relation to epistemologies of ignorance, Dotson (2001) claimed,</p><blockquote>A speaker cannot ‘force’ an audience to ‘hear’ her/him, where hearing refers to an audience fulfilling the demands for reciprocity in a successful linguistic exchange. Indirect motivation and/or ‘force’ maybe used …But a speaker has no direct way to force an audience to ‘hear’ her/him.” (p. 238)</blockquote><p>Reciprocity is necessary for linguistic exchanges to move beyond ignorance as an epistemic standpoint; however, as Dotson aptly pointed out, the “speaker” cannot force an audience to “hear” the message being conveyed. This is why broader claims to the overwhelming agreement in the scientific community to how global climate change is increasing in rapidity, force, and effect are not shifting into political concern or action. If there is no audience to “hear” about global climate change, it does not mean global climate change is not real, but there is the active ability to deny its realities, regardless of how many scientists agree, how pressing the issue is, or how dire the consequences are. In many respects, it also does not even matter how many lines or minutes of reporting are done regarding climate change, then, as the sheer force of volume means little when people are actively choosing to unknow through the lack of granting an audience.</p><p>Dotson (2011) suggested such a lack of granting an audience, itself a mainstay for epistemologies of ignorance, extends into what she termed ‘epistemic violence,’ or that which increases vulnerability for the people whose lives and livelihoods are being “unheard.” It is here that how one comes to unknow (e.g., epistemology) begins to influence who is being unknown (e.g., ontology), and where I would like to spend some time making some connections between the discourses that frame climate change and transgender oppression.</p><p>Climate change has no audience amongst those with the political power and will to enact progressive policies. In fact, neoliberalism has worked so well as an ideology that even most of those who the public collectively has come to know as “liberal” on the political spectrum do not give the climate the audience it deserves. Moreover, when they do, it is through manufactured sound bites they speak in order to gain them points in the latest political polls. In this sense, their utterances are nonperformative, as they do quite the opposite as they suggest to do. That is, they show an ongoing, callous disregard for the severity of the ongoing death and decay planet due to climate change. They project a care that has long since been hollowed out, supplanted instead by a desire to gain political power. It should come as no surprise to many that, since the 1980’s, the Chicago Boys’ influence on international politics has been to move dialogue so far to the right that even most political candidates that suggest they are left are actually, at best, quite centrist, if not just right of center on a variety of issues, the climate being one.</p><p>Another issue that has audience amongst those with the political power and will to enact progressive policies is that of the ongoing effects of transgender oppression. It is not that the nontrans people in power do not care about trans people — although I do think that case can indeed be made — but that before they can even entertain their care, they have made the choice to not give an audience to the concerns of trans people. Take, for example, then President Obama having Jennicet Gutierrez removed from the White House as a way to actively unknow the ongoing violence experienced by trans undocumented women at the hands of the U.S. government. With a gesture and a snide comment, Obama disallowed an audience to a trans undocumented woman and, as a result, to trans undocumented women. Meanwhile, many within the broader gay and lesbian movement — or what Spade (2007) has referred to as the ‘LGBfakeT movement’ — have continued to hold onto a narrative that Obama was incredibly progressive, using moments such as his mentioning Stonewall during a State of the Union address, or hiring some trans people into federal positions, or his “evolving” understanding of same-sex marriage (an “evolution” that would have likely never occurred had his then Vice President not spoken publicly in favor of same-sex marriage) as evidence. However, these actions were also nonperformative, as they did not do that which they named. Instead, the cavalier way he removed Gutierrez from the White House, basking in the loving approval and applause of the largely white, wealthy, gay crowd of men after he had her removed, signals not only his denying an audience to trans people, but the deleterious effects of transgender oppression.</p><p>Lest one think this is just a invective against Obama, the current political campaigning offers a platform to think about the denial of an audience across the political spectrum in the United States. That is, while the right is openly hostile to transgender people — and thus, clearly denies an audience to transgender oppression — the left only calls trans people to the fore as always already dead. In other words, when Democratic candidates for President have invoked transness, it is largely through the specter of the dead Black trans woman. In this sense, they are not giving an audience to the ongoing effects of transgender oppression, but using Black trans women as a way to score political points, make them appear progressive, and garner more votes. No candidate to date has talked substantively about trans women of color, the intermingled violent realities of racism, transphobia, and/or citizenship. They care not to provide an audience to these concerns or our population; to do so would be to risk political capital, and to expose how the base of the “liberal” Democratic Party may actually be much more conservative than it may be good to publicly admit.</p><p>The lack of audience granted to climate change and transgender oppression are sutured together by an epistemology of ignorance. Such an epistemology congeals in a form of epistemic violence that furthers vulnerability, precarity, and social death for human and nonhuman species, as well as the water and land in which all human and nonhuman life are in relation. Moreover, it is not that those with political will/capital do not know (I think), but that they will such a lack of knowing into being. Simply put: they are willfully ignorant. They actively unknow as a way of coming to know otherwise. It is not neoliberalism that motivates them, although such an ideology certainly is the primordial soup from which the current conditions of late capitalism has developed, and is therefore intensely related to such an epistemological stance. Additionally, such an epistemology of ignorance creates the current impossibility of life, both for transgender people as well as the planet. That is, through an epistemology of ignorance, it becomes quite clear that life as we know it is impossible. There is simply no other way to phrase it: the planet cannot continue to exist in such an epistemic moment, nor can trans people. In fact, impossibility is what frames the existence of the planet as well as trans people such that we exist only as impossibilities, as a current conundrum that those invoking an epistemology of ignorance choose not to be able to come to know. Here, epistemologies of ignorance become performative, as they further the social death they desire to bring about through their not granting an audience to the climate and trans people.</p><p>This is not a happy essay. But then again, we are not living in happy times, nor will capitulating to the happiness industrial complex save us in the end. We are in dire times, and no amount of smiling or niceties will change that.</p><p>But…what will save us? Can anything? Or are we forever tethered to our lives, such as they are tethered to the afterlife of chattel slavery, colonization, and their attendant effects (e.g., transgender oppression)? What is the what’s next if our claims to global climate change and transgender humanity have no audience? What good does it do to claim we exist if we are framed through nonexistence, and called to the fore through our nonexistence (e.g., the always already death of Black trans women)?</p><p>Each and every morning, I wake up thinking about the fact that we are, all of us, living in the end times. In many ways, it feels like we have entered a science fiction storyline, as much of what is occurring seems otherworldly. And yet, the fact that this is indeed real life is what is perhaps the most terrifying fact. Moreover, we — those of us who are castigated as abject, especially — are taught to believe we must live in/through the end times in isolation. The vexing nature of neoliberalism, as well as epistemologies of ignorance is that we are situated in a hyper-individualized society that, due to our not being granted audiences, wants nothing to do with our material realities. That is, unless those realities can be commodified, packaged, and used toward certain aims (e.g., allowing some of us — those deemed “passable” — to ‘succeed’ through normative illogics), of course, which then further obfuscates how those of us who are irrespectable are further pushed to the margins of the margins. Fear, dis-ease, and isolation proliferate in these sorts of times, as does scarcity logics, suggesting there cannot possibly be enough for all of us, so one better get theirs before someone else takes it (whatever the ‘it’ is).</p><p>In light of this haunting present/future, I have tried hard to do the exact opposite as epistemologies of ignorance suggest I ought to do, and to do so at each and every turn.</p><p>Where I am taught I and other trans girls, women, femmes, and/or people of color do not deserve an audience, I find ways to bare witness and be in the company of those who do the same.</p><p>Where I am taught to actively unknow the epistemological and material conditions by which I can dream different, I spend time thinking, talking, reading, and being with people who embrace trans-, Indigenous-, and person of color-centered ways of being.</p><p>Where I am taught that I need to get mine before someone else does, I give what I have, and constantly question the assumptions in which my fear about giving more are rooted.</p><p>Where I am taught to feel like we aren’t living in catastrophic times, I am trying, as discomforting as it is, to realize we very much are, and I need to act accordingly. For me, this means not only being mindful of my relationship to the Earth, its natural resources (e.g., water), and human and nonhuman species, but also making connections between the work I am attempting to do — that of gender-expansive, liberatory theory and praxis — and the current conditions of our collective material world. It also means thinking about the affective movements my grief, fear, and angst regarding the utter ruin in which we are living cause. In other words, I am attempting to wrestle with what it is my feelings are motivating/stirring for me, and how can I take this sensorium as an impetus for desiring, seeking, and creating something as otherwordly as the science fiction present/future in which we are mired.</p><p>I am also trying hard to realize the mess we are in is not wholly mine to solve. I do not say this as an abdication of responsibility, but to harness and put to work the notion of <em>trans negativity</em> that Hayward (2017) invoked. That is to say, if we as trans people, as trans women, and as trans women of color are told we are ontological impossibilities, and we are not granted an audience, then ontological claims to the contrary (e.g., “But we do exist!”) make little to no sense. As a result, then, I think there is hope in moving away from ontological responses — and perhaps taking a break from ontological investments, too, at least for a bit — to think, dream, and collect ourselves in new constellations, especially those that occur below the normatively framed world. As I have written about previously, the shadows are robust spaces in which our genders, and indeed, our very lives and livelihoods, proliferate. In the shadows is where we can try, seek, stretch, and cultivate new futures <em>for and by us</em>, rather than seeking to repair and do work in service of those who would claim we do not exist, who seek to use disinformation to claim what we see, the catastrophies in which we live, and the not-far-off futures toward which we are heading are not at all what they seem to be. In essence, I find in Hayward’s suggestion of <em>trans negativity</em> a sort of livable present/future where we can be, build, and think together, enjoying each other in all our excesses, and all of our desires for irrespectability.</p><p>This is not an essay where I share answers about how to solve climate change, or how to rid the social sphere of transmisogyny. Those answers, as much as I desire them, are not answers I can provide. Furthermore, even if I could, they would require an audience, which I have detailed that we just do not have at present.</p><p>And so in the face of not having an audience, I say: we shall be our own audience for each other. We shall gather and develop and grow and love and desire and want and eat and live with, among, for, and in loving tribute to us: the abject, the audienceless, the trans, the queer, the refugee. In the words of Anzaldúa (1987/2007):</p><blockquote>I will no longer be made to feel ashamed of existing. I will have my voice: Indian, Spanish, white. I will have my serpent’s tongue — my woman’s voice, my sexual voice, my poet’s voice. I will overcome the tradition of silence. (p. 81)</blockquote><p>And I will do that overcoming with those who grant me audience, and who I lovingly give audience to in return. We may not be able to change the degradation of the climate, or shift the horrid conditions of transmisogyny, but we can live with, for, and in community with one another.</p><p>And this makes today a bit more possible.</p><p>Which then makes dreaming tonight about a tomorrow all the more possible.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c032a3237983" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Demands on Trans Women]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@trans_killjoy/the-demands-on-trans-women-bdbf11d34f9f?source=rss-60468f47489f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bdbf11d34f9f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[affect-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[white-privilege]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Z Nicolazzo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Nov 2019 13:36:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-25T13:36:50.216Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>From not existing to existing but only in certain kinds of ways, the gender anxieties of nontrans people are played out time and again, plumbing the depths of the impossibilities of life for trans women. In this essay, I explore some of these demands, their affective beginnings, and the ways they further entrench and proliferate trans oppression.</em></p><p>Nontrans people, it seems, want something from trans women. More accurately put, in fact, is that nontrans people <em>demand </em>things <em>of</em> trans women. It is not a mere want, as if to suggest a passive/docile ask. Instead, nontrans people make demands of us, which are many, ongoing, and despite most of these demands saying more about those demanding — rather than those upon which the demands are imposed — they nevertheless produce effects (and affects) which we as trans women must contend.</p><p>We must be beautiful, but not too beautiful. We must signal our existence, but not exist. We must become visible, but only at certain times, or in certain ways, or only when we are warmly invited to be so. We must accept any invitation, must be willing to do the work of educating others, and must always have patience and grace. We must also be comfortable feeding on the scraps of love, affection, and faux inclusion that continually reify our abjection. Any attention, we are told, is good attention, because after all, we are trans women, so what more could we hope to ever have, want, or need?</p><p>The material conditions of transmisogyny that frame our individual and collective (non-)existence as trans girls and women is a rather quotidian fact of life. While this does not dull its material edge, it does bear repeating that it is not unusual or otherwise remarkable in its omnipresence. In fact, those nontrans people who seem to be surprised by such a fact only show themselves to be participating in ideologies that sublimate — at best — and erase — at worst — trans women as always already a part of feminist movements toward liberation and justice. Put another way, when someone falsely presupposes transmisogyny to be “new” or “unbelievable,” they are participating in the reproduction of a world that views trans women as “new” or “unbelievable,” which is to say, they are furthering ideologies that frame trans women of out view (epistemologically, ontologically, and otherwise). To know trans women exist is to know transmisogyny mediates and curtails our life chances. Although the two are not synonymous — we are not only/solely the oppressive conditions under which we navigate life — they are inextricably linked in a messy and violent tango that has asymmetrical effects for our livelihoods.</p><p>But again, this seems rather obvious, and is not really the point of this essay. That transmisogyny exists is axiomatic — or at least it should be for all, and certainly is for trans women — as is the reality of how transmisogyny ensnares trans women. What I am more curious about tracing in this essay are the affective roots of the various demands nontrans people place on trans women through the social discourse of transmisogyny, and how these affective roots promote the ongoing entrenchment of transmisogyny, even — and perhaps especially — amongst “well-meaning” nontrans populations (more of the notion of “well-meaning” in a minute). That is, I want to think through how the affective components of gender, or that gender brings up, or that gender exposes — because, indeed, I argue such gender-based emotionality has always already been present — creates the material conditions of life. In other words, how does the affective affix itself to the material? Moreover, how does the suturing of the affective with the material provide a new way to think about the presence and implications of the many demands placed on trans women? But first, a word on the word “well-meaning.”</p><p><strong>Well-Meaning as Nonperformative<br></strong>To be well-meaning is an aspirational state of being. It is a want, a desire, aimed toward meaning well, and as multiple scholars have noted previously, is always already tethered to discourses of whiteness.* However, as with most desires, it does not outline a commitment to that which it wants to want. In other words, <em>to be well-meaning is to want something to which one is or may not be fully committed to realizing. </em>In this sense, to be well-meaning connotes a nonperformative in that it does not bring about what it names. For example, to be well-meaning about gender-inclusion acts as a way to name a desire for, but not a move toward the actuality of, gender-inclusion. <em>To be well-meaning is thus a way to not perform gender-inclusion</em>.</p><p>Phrases like, “I am trying,” or “I want to do better,” or “Please be patient with me; I am working hard to get it,” all detail how one’s well-meaningness is framed as an always already future-oriented project that will, by design, never be realized. In fact, these phrases are designed to not achieve that which they name to want to achieve. Put another way: at what point does one’s trying, wanting to do better, or working hard transform into actual doing? And, moreover, at what point does the doing not require patience on behalf of those for/alongside whom the actor suggests they are desiring to be well-meaning?</p><p>If being well-meaning acts as a nonperformative vis-à-vis gender inclusion, there is a passivity that always acquiesces to transmisgoyny. Moreover, in that acquiescence, there is a tacit <em>movement toward </em>transmisogyny, as to not actively resist can be understood as a closing of space with problematic, violent, and dangerous ways of thinking and being. So while being well-meaning may not be an active agreement with harmful rhetorics and/or behaviors, it most certainly is not an active refusal of them either. And in that sense, there is a way that being well-meaning, or wanting to want to be better regarding gender, may actually be a way to remain the same as one already is regarding gender, which is to say: reifying normative social stances on gender as a binary. Here, one can see how being well-meaning is akin to furthering gender binary discourses, and with them, the ongoing diminishing of life chances for — and increasing violent erasure of — trans women via transmisogyny. Again, one can see how the ways trans women are un/known — actively and passively, explicitly and tacitly — has a direct and intense influence on the material conditions of (im)possible life for trans women. This is not just a thought experiment. The way nontrans people un/know gender possibilities mediates actual life for trans people, and for the purposes of this essay, trans women.</p><p>A quick side note here: to be/position oneself as well-meaning is indeed be performative, in that it does something, but this does not mean the notion itself is often used — especially by white nontrans people — to <em>not do</em> that which it names. In other words, many nontrans people who suggest they are/seek to be well-meaning do so as a way to not have to do the actual work and thinking required to be trans-inclusive. As such, the performance is that of a nonperformative, or the use of the notion of being “well-meaning” as a shield from actually doing the doing of <em>actually being well-meaning in relation to gender-expansive/trans-inclusive thinking/action/behaviors</em>. If you are looking for an example of how this works in practice, think of white nontrans TERFs. Also, this example may also signal the ways that whiteness is entangled with notions of well-meaning as a nonperformative in relation to gender-inclusion. In fact, the phrase “white nontrans TERF” could well be a redundant phrase, or at least it has been in my non-empirical assessment. Almost all of the TERFs I have occasioned upon are nontrans white people, particularly white nontrans women. I know this is not the case for all TERFs, but from my experience, in the Venn Diagram of white nontrans people, white nontrans women and TERFs, the latter circle does seem to overlap significantly with the first two — especially that of the category white nontrans women.</p><p><strong>Affective → Material</strong><br>What creates the conditions through which trans women experience the social world? This question above all others has consumed me and my work. That is, if we know the realities and material consequences of transmisogyny, then what is it that continues to promote how such material conditions come to be? In other words, if the effects have been shown — and thus are known — to be deleterious, then why wouldn’t there be more traction for them to stop?</p><p>Much of my earlier work has traced how social discourses of transphobia have influenced trans livelihood. Specifically, my work has sought to identify how these discourses mediate attitudes and behaviors, and as such, how educators may want to think and do differently as a way of imagining more liberatory educational contexts for trans people. While I still think there is some good that can come from this work, I have begun to wonder recently how a focus on affect, or the emotionality present within and through the micro-moments of everyday interactions between people (and institutions), could enliven my previous work. I am not seeking some fictions “grand unifying theory” to account for transphobia, or for transmisogyny; instead, I am wondering out loud as to how the affective may provide a lens through which to make new sense out of the material. That is, rather than thinking of attitudes and actions as devoid of feeling, I want to think through feeling as a way to approach anew those attitudes and actions, with a specific focus on how they influence trans people, especially trans women.</p><p>Although some may not (want to) recognize it, affect is always present. Indeed, affect may even be present before I arrive, waiting impatiently for me in the form of expectation. These expectations can slide very easily into demands, for if I do not meet these expectations, or if I cannot or actively resist to do as I am desired to do — I might even say <em>do as I am told to do</em>, as so many women are told to do things by all sorts of people through the rubric of sexism — then I am seen as being unruly, as too much, or, simply put, a bitch.</p><p>Expectations form before I arrive on the scene, congealing into demands. The specific constellations of such demands for trans women are vexing in their contradictions, which I laid above. We must always be enough, but never too much. We must always be a certain kind of woman, even as being a certain kind of woman has been chastised within feminist movements. We much always be willing to be tokenized, but never speak to the damaging effects of such tokenization.</p><p>The demands on trans women are many, and although they share similarities with the demands of nontrans women, they are also quite distinct. Their distinct nature lies in the ways trans women are made out to be…well, not women. Nontrans people tell us consistently and constantly to not exist, and through such a demand, we are deemed not just illegible as women, but as distinctly <em>not. </em>That is, it is not about not being recognized as women — as if such a state could be reached if only people could “do better” or “try harder” — but about our being actively refused as such. There is, it would seem, a different sort of necropolitical calculus happening for trans women, in which we are not only unseen, but undone through the demands on us. In other words, the demands imposed upon us are fashioned to undo our beingness as trans women. They seek to erase and destroy, not just occlude from view. In their evocation, the demands on trans women are structured to be impossible to meet, which then reifies our impossibility, which then bolsters the social desirability of what Hayward aptly pointed out as our “killability” as trans women.</p><p>An example of this is the demand to be beautiful — understood through a cisnormative logic of “passing” as nontrans — but that trans women’s beautiful is always couched in their/our being trans women. So, while there is not a space for trans women to not be beautiful — the demand, after all, is to be glamorous, to be beautiful “like the rest of us,” with us meaning nontrans women — there is also not space for trans women to be beautiful to the point where they can be recognized as women. Trans women are always not-women, in this sense, and thus are cast as less human and less desirable (beyond fetishism). Here, one can see how the “killability” of trans women, especially trans women of color, only increases through nontrans people’s demand for a very particular — and highly unattainable — form of beauty from trans women. This isn’t to suggest that trans women cannot or are not beautiful, but, as I have argued previously, we will never have access to beauty through cisnormative social logics, which only increases the precarity of our lives (and does so asymmetrically along the lines of race, class, disability, and indigeneity).</p><p>Moreover, these demands are themselves rooted in various affectations, including fear, disgust, anxiety, and desire. Take, for example, the demand to not be “too much.” The material conditions of remaining out of the way, or unseen and unheard, or present but only when called upon can be understood as a manifestation of feelings of:</p><p><strong>Fear</strong>: oftentimes an irrational affective response to difference, fear could well be the soil in which the many demands on trans women germinate. It may not just be a fear of trans women as an embodied reality, however, but a fear of what being trans women means to the state of gender. In other words, it may not just be a fear of our bodies, but a fear of what the potentiality of our wanting and desiring more from gender — and thus, from life — may mean for others. In a sense, then, one’s fear could itself be the result of wondering if, perhaps, their gender (and as a result, perhaps their sexuality) may not be as concrete as it was once thought to be. The trans woman becomes a material stand-in for this affective response, and then becomes the focus of the material response.</p><p>In a Sedgwickian move, this fear materializes in, for example, the “trans panic” legal defense. This defense suggests that, upon a nontrans person (usually a nontrans man) learns that his love interest is a trans person (usually a trans woman), he panics and kills her. His panic, which is legally framed as an out-of-body/mind response (and thus it is used as an [irrational] defense), is a result of his fear; a fear that if his victim’s gender is not naturalized, then perhaps his isn’t either…and then what? If his gender isn’t a naturalized phenomenon, then the sand beneath his feet begins to shift, the ground begins to crumble, and all is not as it supposedly seemed to be…or so the defense would have one believe. One’s transness (usually a trans woman’s transness) is the grounds upon which some nontrans people’s fear (usually nontrans men) is used as legal grounds for murder. Here, the “trans panic” defense signals the always already too muchness of trans women, which gives rise — via affective formations of fear — to trans women being less human to the point of being increasingly “killable.” The connotation to the disposability of trans women is utter rubbish, to be sure, and yet is substantiated through legal attempts that take such rubbish as common practice.</p><p><strong>Disgust</strong>: one’s disgust of trans woman may itself come from a revulsion of anything that is seen or constructed as extraordinary or otherwise outside of the normal course of order. To show disgust is a gut response, a revulsion or a pushing away of that which seems overtly beyond or extra. Here, a nontrans person could understood as being disgusted by that which a trans woman desires, and vice versa. Put another way, a nontrans person may be disgusted by trans women’s remarkable desires and wants from gender, whereas trans women may be equally disgusted by these nontrans people’s inability to allow such desires and wants to be. Clearly, to suggest a nontrans/trans binary is not at all what I am suggesting, as to do so would be a misreading of how normativity circulates as a discourse of power, oftentimes without concern for one’s gender. That said, I do think there is something important and worth highlighting in terms of how nontrans populations are animated by such affective investments in their disgust of trans women. Trans women are not killing other trans women, after all.</p><p><strong>Anxiety</strong>: there is something deeply unsettling, it seems, to recognizing that not all is what it appears to be. That is, if gender is not naturalized, but is packaged and sold as such, it would stand to reason that it may be anxiety-provoking to be confronted with this rupture. If one is taught to believe something, such as gender just Is, then it may be stressful, difficult, or irksome to realize that instead, gender might be, but it could also not be. Or maybe gender is, but perhaps it is concurrently not. Or maybe gender could be something else, or much rather like nothing one has ever thought it could be. There are wild profusions opened up through gender, rather than recognizing it as always already a restriction, a boundary across which one cannot or ought not cross. These profusions stir anxiety, which then provides a fertile ground upon which demands of trans women could be made, and that such demands may be made in reaction or response to the disruption of how gender was thought to always Be. If something is and always was a given, and that given is taken without question or wanting beyond, then there is no anxiety to be had. However, when one is met with there being something more, that is when anxiety may start to seep in, and when it seeps in, it may start to provoke attitudes and actions toward trans women that begin to circumscribe the livability of our lives.</p><p><strong>Desire</strong>: While it is true people desire trans women, and that such desire may create certain demands on trans women that curtail our livability, I am interested in thinking about desire more capaciously. That is, I think desire as affect may also be understood as some wanting to want like trans people do. In particular, I have been thinking a lot about how some nontrans women’s desire in relation to trans women (myself and others) may itself not wholly be about a desire <em>for </em>us sexually, but may also/instead be about a desire <em>of </em>us, and specifically, of our transness, of our wanting more from gender. Nontrans women have a specific relationship to gender, in that their lives are also cordoned off by expectations and demands. So, when nontrans women see trans women desiring, wanting, and seeking <em>more</em>, there is an understandable, and yet highly dangerous, way desire may start to operate. Nontrans women may mistake their desire <em>of </em>trans women as a desire <em>for </em>trans women, animating them to think and act in ways that are in contrast to the humanity of trans women. Put another way, to mistake a desire <em>of</em> as a desire <em>for</em> trans women may likely mean nontrans women will objectify trans women, further reifying the omnipresence of sexism and transmisogyny.</p><p>Desire, then, operates on a few registers as it relates to the demands placed upon trans women. The demands we may face might be about not only not being too much, and thereby “outting” someone’s desire for us, but also about shoring up nontrans people’s — and perhaps most notably nontrans women’s — sense that they, too, could seek and have more from gender, that they do not need to settle for the dregs of what has been given to them. The desires nontrans women have of trans women, then, and how they are twisted and turned into desires for us, are a manifestation of objectification. We are made into objects that can satisfy, ameliorate, or somehow absolve the lack of wanting nontrans women have been conditioned to accept. We can also, they think, quell their concerns that in their not wanting more, they are not quite as gender-expansive as they may have hoped; or at least this may be the case for those nontrans women who consider themselves to be feminists.</p><p>The demands on trans women are numerous, compounding, and never-ending. They, as with all demands, must be dealt with in some fashion, whether or not we desire to do so. Moreover, these demands move out from affective percolations. They are not just attitudes and behaviors, but are guided by the affective residue of micro-moments between people and institutions, which then accumulates and hangs in the air like heavy perfume, permeating all it touches. If this is indeed the case, then the project is not so much about changing attitudes and behaviors. Nice as that sounds, it may do little to realize education as a practice of freedom, as the affective structures that give rise to trans misogynistic attitudes and behaviors will have been left untouched. In other words, one may not act a certain way for a moment, but may still feel a way that could give rise to that action later. That, it would seem to be, is the problem. And in the field of Higher Education Studies, where feelings are not so much discussed beyond suggesting one should not discuss feelings, to not focus on affect becomes a way of maintaining the status quo. To not focus on feeling, then, becomes a way of doing well-meaning work, or of trying — or wanting to try, or being committed to trying — to do different. It is the nonperformative stuff that gives rise to the ongoing proliferation of transmisogyny that has deleterious material consequences for trans women.</p><p>In this essay, I was able to stitch together some ways affect and materiality work together, providing a formation for how feeling effects life chances. In the four months since I began my work with the Higher Education Affect Project (HEAP), I have been thinking a lot about how affect theory can expand our understandings of how we come to know that which we come to think and do, as well as how we then come to be. The essay is a brief snippet, a snapshot of some current thinking, and as such, leaves room for further development, theorization, and contemplation. For example, I have collected data that pin the aforementioned affective responses to happenings in higher education contexts, and so it will need to explore these phenomena. That is, beyond them happening through the social sphere, I will need to trace in what forms they arise in higher education, as well as to what effect(s). Not that there needs to be a firm social/educational context boundary, but it will be helpful to elucidate how what has always already been happening off-campus has concurrently always already been happening on-campus, and how the two contexts are mutually reinforcing and animating.</p><p>Again, my affective work is not about going back to some singularity, or a way to suppose an original starting point for gender binary discourse. That said, I do hope the work can animate us all in asking more of the attitudes, actions, and conditions that frame life for trans people, and that in our asking, we can surface, imagine, and dream new and different futures for those we hold dear. Because when everything is collapsing around us — or when everything has collapsed around us, as indeed it already has for many — we will need shifts in perception and feeling as a way to guide us amidst the rubble.</p><p><em>*thanks to Chris Barcelos for reminding me of the important connections between discourses of being “well-meaning” and whiteness. This has been central to some of my other theorizing for HEAP, and it was helpful to tie this back into my thinking here. Thanks also to Chris for reading an early draft of this essay, and providing critical feedback to enhance my argument and writing.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bdbf11d34f9f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[too muchness // desire // nobodies // solidarities // world-making]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@trans_killjoy/too-muchness-desire-nobodies-solidarities-world-making-a1d3346ce9d1?source=rss-60468f47489f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a1d3346ce9d1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[affect-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[solidarity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Z Nicolazzo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 29 Sep 2019 15:42:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-29T15:42:45.123Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/435/1*pyFANEe4gOGcce19Qmdevw.png" /></figure><p>Being excessive is often made into a subject position, as in: “she is too much,” or “her attitude is excessive.” The act of being excessive signals an overflowing, a too muchness that reinforces an othering, or the un/making of those who are excessive into those who are unnecessary and, as a result, can be forgotten, disappeared, or not oriented toward. The un/making of one as too much is a move toward disposability, toward marking somebody as a nobody. Or at least this is what normative cultures may want for us to believe: that those of us who are excessive, who are too much, who desire to desire, and desire to desire <em>more</em>, are nobodies.</p><p>And yet, what if we embraced our too muchness, or being nobodies, or desiring of more? And what if we focused on proliferating what that <em>more</em> could signal? What if the “more” being desired was not solely about desiring more from gender — itself a guiding principle for trans women’s lives — but about the <em>feeling of desiring more as shared across identities and experiences?</em> That is to say, what if excessiveness was understood as decoupled from bodies — one is “being excessive,” with the being forming excessiveness into a bodily experience — and instead understood as an felt reality between people? And, what if that felt reality was able to animate collective solidarities, a way of coming together through our shared experiences of being crafted as “too much” to imagine new worlds as nobodies? Said differently, if trans is desire, and if circuitries of desire mediate our wanting more, and as a result being made to feel we are too much, who else may be experiencing the same felt reality, and how may we come together to revel together in our positioning as queer, subaltern, outside, and too much? How can our moving toward the feeling of being too much be a way to re/craft worlds through new solidarities?</p><p>This is not to say that being too much does not have a bodily reality. Indeed, those of us that are marked as being “too much” know that our excessiveness resides in and is often located on our bodies. Trans as excess is then both a felt and embodied reality, in that it is placed on our bodies in particular ways that require we take it up in such a manner. We may not think of ourselves as “too much,” but we must when our bodies and lives are made to feel excessive through the normative lens of society. In similar ways, others who are de/constructed as “too much” have a similar felt and bodily experience; their excessiveness is both a felt reality and something that is placed upon their bodies in multiple ways.</p><p>One of the things I am curious about is how solidarities can be created across identities and experiences. Although de/constructed according to different discourses, the <em>how</em> of too muchness may be felt in similar ways, and perhaps in ways that allow people who feel these realities to come together were they to recognize the possibilities. Furthermore, because the strictures of being “enough” — as opposed to too much or not enough — are so narrow, there are perhaps more people than one may at first think with whom they could be in solidarity. Take for example:<br><br>“I worry my gender may be <em>too much</em> for you…”<br>“I worry my disability may be <em>too much </em>for you…”<br>“I worry my eating disorder may be <em>too much</em> for you…”<br>“My being a Black woman marks me as always already being <em>too angry</em>…”<br>“People understand LGB, but then say that queerness is <em>too much</em> for them…”</p><p>The <em>experience of excess</em> is affixed to the body through various marginalized subject positions, and is also <em>felt as that which occurs between people</em>, namely as a resulting effect of the machinations of power. Here, bodies are seen as important, and also not the sole field on which the grammar of excessiveness is played out. That is to say, bodies mark a site, but not the final location for, the affective trails of excessiveness.</p><p>Moreover, the way that excessiveness “shows up” may well be connected to desire across populations, as well. Trans manifestations of gender are always imagined through a lens of desire in that transness seeks <em>more</em>; there is a wanting, a yearning, a deep seeking of that <em>moreness</em>, regardless of how it shows up. Even those trans people who want to “pass,” or who seek to “fit in” and no longer wish to even identify as trans, are desirous of a gendered experience that is beyond that which was given to them. To paraphrase Dean Spade’s writing, there is nothing that is not radical about transitioning, regardless of the “end state” (which itself is fictitious, given there being a lack of ending to trans becoming). Thus, excess is a function of desire, which is itself a key element to the lived realities for trans people.</p><p>Desire, too, may operate in various ways to frame the “too muchness” of other populations and experiences. Imagining crip futures, owning and moving into one’s Blackness, changing one’s physical embodiment (including the ways we seek to change our body morphology beyond trans contexts); these are all animated by, in, and through circuits of desire. Importantly, too, desire knows no normative judgements; indeed, what we can and often do desire may not be “good” for us, be it objectively or subjectively speaking. For example, Berlant (2011) noted that</p><blockquote>a relation of cruel optimism exists when something you desire is actually an obstacle to your flourishing. It might involve food, or a kind of love; it might be a fantasy of the good life, or a political project. …These kinds of optimistic relation[s] are not inherently cruel. They become cruel only when the object that draws your attachment actively impedes the aim that brought you to it initially.” (p. 1)</blockquote><p>Therefore, not all of our desires are oriented toward our liberation, nor are all of them directed in ways that provide joy…and that they could is also not the ultimate point here. Instead, I am curious about the fact that desire serves as an animating affect that motivates relational experiences in the world to the point that some are deemed excessive, too much, and, as a result, nobodies. And if we can understand how desire is grounding actions and attitudes in a way that is moving bodies such that we are being framed by normative discourses as too much, then we may then have the ability to ask: and what now?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/435/1*Xh752dJZKv0jcZLcc8uTxA.png" /></figure><p>What worlds can we make as nobodies? What ways can we craft solidarities across bodies of nobodies, and how can we create, then, a body politic that is felt through our bodies when our bodies are de/constructed as impositions to that which is the “normal order of things”? McRuer’s (2006) provocation from an able-bodied society that asks, tacitly and otherwise, “Yes, but in the end, wouldn’t you rather be like me” (p. 9)? And, what might it mean to embrace our nobodyness in a manner than defies the illogics that de/construct us as such?</p><p>It’s not to say one must recognize an experience as “just like” another; indeed, Halley (2000) discussed the dangers of this as a social process (as well as its resultant juridical implications). However, one can seek solidarities without being “just like” another; in fact, one must, as a social imperative, do just that. We who are made nobodies because our desires — cruelly optimistic as they may be — make us such through the normative lens of social life are pushed apart, balkanized into separate bands, much like colors through a prism. However, there are false borders where the colors blur into one another, and even places in those false borders where there is no difference between “different” colors. These spaces, then, are where we can come to find solidarities, where we can seek the commonalities that occur to/on/about us through disparate grammars. They are also the locus of radical potential, a place for under-worlding possibilities to germinate.</p><p>What if we were to think about solidarities that can be made through the ways normative cultures attempt to frame what they may determine to be the wasting of potential life, gendered and otherwise? How could the collective desires of multiple, potentially overlapping, populations create bodies that are framed out through excessive demand, and how could this excess be a way to think bodies together to then dream alternate, underground worlds in which we kiki over our too muchness. In short, what if being too much was a felt reality that pushed us out, but drew us in, and brought us together? What if we embraced and held fast to our wanting to want, and desiring more, regardless of the cruel optimism that motivated such desires in the first (and perhaps second and third) place? That is, if we are always already too much, and if we are always already desirous of that which will be taken as a way to un/make us as nobodies through normative prisms of cultural meaning, then what could we do if we found back alleys, basement clubs, and private phone lines through which we could find each other and be too much together?</p><p>This is not a metaphor. This is not a thought experiment, or at least it is not a thought experiment in the ways such experiments are castigated as unreal and, as a result, lacking significance and meaning and potential. If our being made into nobodies means is a grammar through which normative ideologies attempt to remind us there are no bodies with whom we can converge and convene, then such coming together in dark spaces is exactly the form of world-making practice we need to seek sustained life. It is not a process of “rehabilitating” each other through our shared status as nobody; it is not about answering this ontological claim by saying, “But look here, we are somebody!” Instead, it is about being with, feeling together, and doing differently. It is about cultivating new life in the rubble of a field in which we cannot live. It is about desiring more and being too much together.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a1d3346ce9d1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My Notes from the Trans ± Sex Symposium]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@trans_killjoy/my-notes-from-the-trans-sex-symposium-8a0684554afd?source=rss-60468f47489f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a0684554afd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Z Nicolazzo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 Sep 2019 19:48:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-07T19:48:28.763Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This week/end, the Transgender Studies Research Cluster at the University of Arizona — of which I am a member and Co-Chair — hosted <em>Trans ± Sex: Rethinking Sex/Gender in Trans Studies. </em>This event was a 3-day symposium that brought together scholars, activists, and artists working across the field of Transgender Studies to think through thorny concepts and topics. I was a part of a panel called Trans ± Visibility with Dr. Max Strassfeld and CeCe McDonald. For our panel, we each addressed four central questions we came up with to think about the complexities of visibility. While videos of our panels are all forthcoming, I wanted to share my complete notes below. As is often the case, I had to truncate my notes in the moment — there is never enough time, it seems — so below is the unabridged version. My hope is these may prove useful in sparking further thinking for some.</p><p><strong>QUESTION 1: What has visibility meant in your life?<br></strong>Visibility has meant confusion in my life. Specifically in the context of higher education, and higher education studies in which my work has in part resided, the way people have largely picked up visibility has been to laud it as a desired end state, and as a euphoric realization of transness. Events such as Coming Out Week, which happen across college campuses in October, is one instantiation of this sort of queer — as in odd — embrace of visibility. However, the deeper I get into my relationship with my transness, the more I realize that who I have always been becoming has happened largely in shadows, in dimly lit spaces, and in online platforms that I can — and do — craft as invisible. I have been doing some writing and thinking about the place of shadows in transfeminine becoming as of late, both in relation to the increasing visibility of trans women in television shows. For example, <a href="https://medium.com/@trans_killjoy/gender-euphoria-shadows-online-af6cb555ee8f">I have been thinking and writing a bit about shadows</a> in relation to Jules, the trans girl in the summer HBO show <em>Euphoria</em>, and how shadows play prominently in her understanding of her own trans femininity, as well as in relation to some new research I am doing about trans people’s engagements with online spaces. However, for now, I want to share a couple personal stories that may help elucidate what I am thinking about in relation to shadows and transness.</p><p>When I first came into my transness, I was in my studio apartment, watching television with the lights off. I don’t think this is a mere coincidence, but part of how I allowed myself to hear my self-confession: I am trans. I had moments earlier in my life where I had wondered if I was the girl and woman I know myself to be now, but the light present in those moments made me feel too exposed, and too focused on in ways that disallowed me to recognize myself. For example, when I was a youth, I used to pull back my then long hair and lean into the mirror, staring at my reflection and wondering if I was meant to be a girl. The lights from the bathroom vanity were harsh as I did this, and I always felt scared by them, which I think mediated my inability to see who I was. In a way, the light disallowed me to be visible to myself.</p><p>Then, last year, I had the good fortune to move back to Tucson, and to be in relationship with other trans women. I have to admit, when I made my drive from Illinois to Arizona, I was nervous about if the women I was going to become close to would see me as “like” them. Much of my worry was a response to the ways transmisogyny gets picked up and circulates socially, as well as how we as trans girls and women internalize this socialization. It was also a response to being surrounded by a lot of masculinity, including most of my trans friends, colleagues, and acquaintances before moving to Tucson being trans masculine, trans men, and/or masculine-of-center. What I craved and needed I did not have, which was other trans girls and women to spend time with, and to reflect back that they saw me as I am. In my first evening out with one of my very dear friends, who happens to be in this room now and is a trusted colleague, Dr. Eva Hayward, we tucked into a darkened, small table at The Coronet. The server, as they all often do, misgendered me, and after she took our drink orders, Eva leaned in and asked, “Hunny, I forgot to ask you, which pronouns do you use?” I told her, sheepishly, she/her or ze/hir, which I did mainly because I was worried that me just saying the pronouns I really desired to use may not be taken up well, to which she said, “Oh, good, yes, I always saw you as a she.” There, in that dark little corner of a restaurant, the rest of the world melted away, and I was able to see myself in a new way that light, visibility, and expanding to bigger, broader populations never allowed me to do.</p><p>So now I am in this odd place. My work is largely placed in higher education contexts that vault up visibility as a desired end; and yet, visibility — as a proxy for light, for uncovering, and for sight — has rarely coupled with deeper understandings and explorations of who I am. In this way, I find visibility confusing, and wonder what value it may have as we continue to push the boundaries not just of our theorizing, but of our being and doing trans.</p><p><strong>QUESTION 2: Reclamation projects often use the language of visibility as it relates to finding/holding onto a trans lineage. For example, some attempt to locate trans people as ancestors, regardless of if that word was in use/used by the ancestors in question. From your work an activism, how might the assertion of transness as needing to exist in the past to then exist in the present/future be a trap?</strong></p><p>Is there a point to seeking the first trans college student? Is there a need for us to locate and name a past history that we know to exist, or is the orientation of this seeking a manifestation of a nontrans desire to claim we do not exist? Here, I am picking up on the work of Eva Hayward, who details how the ontological claim that trans people, and in particular Black trans women, do not exist is a mainstay of nontrans life, and using her thinking to wonder if the imperative that we not exist is also what is driving nontrans people to force/wedge trans communities into “finding,” “locating,” or “seeking” past transness. In so doing, I think it is important to say that I am not saying historicizing or seeking our pasts is unimportant or always harmful. Clearly, I believe in the archival and historical work our communities do, including the work several of us in the room — Jules, Susan, and Tourmaline, to name a few — are doing. This, however, is not born from the pushing/forcing of nontrans people, which is what I feel when people in my own field ask the question, “But how many trans people are there anyway?,” and which Dean Spade beautifully interrogated in his piece, <em>Be Professional!</em> This compulsion to answer the nontrans question of “how many” is also a compulsion to answer the nontrans demand of “…and where are they?” In this sense, finding a genesis is less about community building, and more about asserting our humanity and humanness, sometimes for people who always already claim we do not exist.</p><p>In fact, I am not even sure asserting that trans people have always been a part of higher education (a claim I have often made in past talks) makes much sense anymore. I don’t know what that speech act does, and for whom it does anything. That is, when it comes to trans visibility, I am wondering if the claim “we have always already been here” does the work I want it to, which is to ground people in higher education studies to the instability of gender coherency and gender binary discourses many have asserted for a long time, continue to assert, and that have been baked into our college and university campuses (e.g., man/woman, “male”/“female”). I don’t know — maybe I am being too self-critical here, but I wonder if focusing on trans bodies through my assertion that trans <em>people </em>have always already been a part of higher education may not quite be the point I should be making, as it occludes the power and reach of our (under)world-making strategies, as well as the ways we do this in the shadows, and to benefit ourselves, not please nontrans others.</p><p>Again, I am not saying historical projects and archival work is unimportant, but I guess I am just wondering what the work of locating past trans bodies may do in highly modernist, rigid, and nonqueer spaces like educational institutions may limit our living, thinking, dreaming, and imagining of liberatory futures. If I am looking for past trans bodies, or the “first trans college student,” then what I am I <em>not </em>doing? And if I am doing that looking to assuage or respond to nontrans desires, then who am I <em>not</em>doing it for? And how is this <em>not doing </em>orienting my work and life in ways that rip me further from the communities within and to whom I should be responsive, namely trans people? In this way, I wonder if the project of seeking, amplifying, and being amongst a trans lineage in higher education studies is one of intent: for whom are we seeking traces of past transness, and to what ends are these past traces allowing us to do the underworlding that make our lives more livable?</p><p>I am also thinking about Jennifer Nash’s recent book, <em>Black Feminism Reimagined</em>, in which she interrogates the idea that one must retrace the origin story of intersectionality as a way to show one “understands” the term. In doing so, she is not saying that such origin stories are without value, or should be wholesale thrown aside; instead, she argues for an embrace of what she calls theoretical intimacies. Effectively, she asks what connections across theoretical planes we may miss when we have an overt focus — often by people who are not a part of our communities, theoretically and otherwise — on the origin story as singular and necessary? In answering her own question, she suggests that if we let go of the origin story for a moment, then we can think <em>across </em>fields, and <em>across</em>populations in ways that create intimacies around ideas, people, populations, and I would argue, liberatory movements. This seems to link in well with Spade’s notion of critical trans politics, as well, which I may discuss in a later question for this panel.</p><p>All in all, I guess I am doing some thinking about what seeking a trans lineage does, and for whom, and who is driving this need, especially in the modernist/rigid structures of education where trans oppression and the administrative violence Spade discusses in <em>Normal Life </em>thrive.</p><p><strong>QUESTION 3: How does trans visibility relate to current social issues (e.g., #MeToo, gun violence, ongoing political elections, international politics), and in what ways can these relations provide important insights into how we move forward in our work and thinking?</strong></p><p>I’ve been really drawn to the edited anthology <em>Trap Door </em>lately, and am thinking that the metaphor of the trap door itself may be a way to think about how trans visibility is mapping onto social movements. In a number of ways, trans visibility is a trap politically in that it conveys a particular form of violence where politicians use us either as a way to pander to broader — usually white, well-resourced gay and lesbian — prospective donors, or as a physical manifestation of what is wrong with the country — and here, I think it is especially important to note how it is the figure of the trans woman who is most often used to this end, furthering a transmisogynistic discourse that increases the precarity of our life chances. So trans visibility is a trap in the sense that if and when we are made visible, or seen — whether seen as we are or as others craft us to be, in the case of the conservative movement and rhetoric — we are used as pawns, and rarely cared for in ways that a representative government suggests that it cares for its citizenry.</p><p>However, the other part of the trap is that when we are not seen, we are often a part of the ongoing social ills that plague our world. For example, the ways that gun violence is being discussed, while important, occlude how gender + race + sexuality continue to be caught in the crosshairs, as well as the problematic nature of how “trans panic” is an active defense strategy for some in ways that attempt to promote in others a sense that our deaths — especially trans women of color — are nothing to be bothered by, and nothing to attempt to legislate against. Either way, then, we are in a bind; if we are seen, it is for deleterious ends — or at the very least, it is as a way to pander to white nontrans gay and lesbian people who want to project they are “good people” for supporting democratic candidates who use the phrase “trans women of color” in a talking point or two — and if we are unseen, the realities of, and ideologies that ground, our social and material realities continue to go unaltered.</p><p>But, as with the metaphor of the trap door, I think there may be a doorway through which we can cross, a threshold over which we can move, that may allow us to think in new ways about trans visibility in the social sphere. I will talk about the notion of underworlding that Gossett and Huxtable discussed in the <em>Trap Door </em>anthology a bit later, but for now, I wonder if there are ways that our current social and material realities as trans people may allow us to think across and with other marginalized populations who are also facing continued precarity. For example, when Jennicet Gutiérrez confronted then President Obama about his role in regimes of deportation of undocumented people, she was doing so not just because she was trans, but because she was a trans Latina, and also because she was an undocumented trans Latina. Here we have an important reminder of how gender, race, and citizenship are intimately bound together, and how we must be thinking about these bindings as a way to move forward. Going back to Nash’s notion of intimacies, I propose that the door part of the trap door metaphor is not just thinking about these intimacies, but enacting what the thinking about them can mean for political and social affiliations and action. If we are to embrace a critical trans politics, then we need to be thinking about trans ±. Put another way, we need to be thinking about trans <em>plus </em>other identities, experiences, and subjectivities, as well as trans <em>minus </em>who has already been cast aside in the furthering of a more “palatable” or “normalized” agenda, so that we may do the work of reclaiming those folks into a broad-based, cross-coalitional movement. This work, in my estimation, will require new liberation dreams, and very likely will need to operate outside, around, or under the guise of capitalism. In this sense, I think of sharing and gift economies, I think of going back to ways that queer people have always looked out for and protected each other, I think about consciousness raising groups and dinner clubs and asking for what you need and giving what you can when you can, and I think of doing one’s own individual work — myself included — to move beyond the scarcity ideologies that we are socialized to take up as people living during late capitalism. This, to me, seems like the doorway through the trap. It’s not a panacea, nor is it easy, but maybe there are some nuggets that can help us imagine further together in this space, too.</p><p><strong>QUESTION 4: Trans visibility is not always a choice, it is not accessible to everyone equally, and there are various differing consequences for being visible as a trans person. That said, current mainstream political movements rely — perhaps too heavily — on representation and visibility as engines. What do you imagine the relationship between trans and visibility could — and perhaps needs — to be as we learn from the past to build toward the future?</strong></p><p>It seems as though various public spheres are incorrectly equating increased visibility with increased importance. It’s as if various people think that if we can point to a population, and that population continues to grow and expand, then it begins to mean more, hold more weight, and amplify the significance of the population (e.g., as a voting bloc). Thinking about weight as a metaphor for a moment, though, both Tourmaline and CeCe have been important voices in trans activism in addressing the weighty aspects of visibility. Namely, both have pointed to the violent reality that increasing visibility has led not to the utopian liberation many nontrans people seem to imagine occurring — think of <em>TIME </em>magazine’s signaling a “transgender tipping point” five years ago by placing Laverne on the cover — but instead has led to increasing precarity.</p><p>Taking this into a higher education context, I have become curious how the increasing and continued focus on trans visibility may be mediating movements toward trans equity and liberation. For example, if visibility is <em>the </em>project for higher education practitioners and scholars, at what cost are we running toward visibility? How are the gestures and invitations we are making toward visibility further reifying the anti-Blackness, classism, and compulsory able-bodiedness of such a paradigm? In a sense, then, how does the singular focus on visibility as the ultimate good for many in higher education actively work against the sorts of liberatory praxis Che Gossett and Juliana Huxtable, among others, have begun to explore when they discuss underworlding? I am not claiming that what queer and trans educational professionals are doing is wholesale wrong or bad; not in the least. And also, I do wonder the costs of a singular focus on visibility, as well as how such a focus as a panacea for the trans oppression I and others have elucidated through the field of higher education studies may actually get us further from the sorts of liberation we seek, desire, and need in education (as well as other spaces).</p><p>In thinking ahead, then, I have begun to wonder how shadows and what I and my co-researcher Alden Jones are beginning to think about as <em>strategic visibility</em>, and how this may allow for a different view of how we as trans people can — and in many respects already do — live. In our current study, Jones and I, along with our research team, have talked with trans students to explore how they are envisioning future trans selves and developing community in online spaces. In so doing, we are unearthing the underworlding practices of new techno-ontological constructions of trans selfhood. In these virtual landscapes, trans students are folding space and time as they embrace a prismatic proliferation of selves, sometimes even within the same online platform (e.g., participants are discussing having multiple accounts on the same platform, dis/allowing certain people to see each account, and thereby expanding and exploring the contours of their gendered existences online, and as a result, in “real life,” too). One of the most important aspects of this study are that trans people are continuing to find themselves online — something various others in Trans Studies have been discussing for some time, like Tobias Raun — and they are creating the Internet in ways that are not just expanding visibility. In essence, these students are curating privacy settings and communities in ways that signal they are not quite as drawn to being visible, or being “out and proud” in the same ways the project of visibility through the social sphere (e.g., Coming Out Weeks on college campuses) suggest. Now clearly there are ways that such strategic visibility has limits, as every picture posted online is archived and can be used and manipulated by global corporations and nation-states; however, for the purposes of exploring trans selfhood, this concern is not quite germane to how participants are using strategic visibility as a way to push back against the neoliberal packaging of visibility as equating to always being a desired state.</p><p>All this to say, I think there are some nuggets in the work Jones and I are doing that can be of use when thinking about future directions of trans visibility in organizing, as well as through educational life. For example, I would argue our data are signaling how refusing the overtly white, classist, and able-bodied project of visibility is vital for a thriving sense of trans self. Doing so also helps us proliferate possibilities of who we can become, because we are not left with the few options of those of us who make it on the covers of magazines, or get to feature in television shows that may or may not be written, directed, or produced by us…or at least the wide breadth of “us” the asterisk some of us use to denote our capaciousness. In essence, our data may ask the question “why?” Why do we need to promote visibility? What are the ways that living invisibly, of creating and curating lives and cultural content for us, of keeping the best of our multiple selves to and for ourselves may allow for a richer community? I also think our data ask the question “how?,” as in: how does a focus on visibility actually create ruptures within our communities? How is it that focusing on visibility may do the work of erasure that proliferating in the shadows may seek to ameliorate? And how is visibility deconstructing who we can be, both individually and as a trans population, in ways that homogenize us according to the nation-state, which has never been invested in our liberation? Paraphrasing one of my very favorite essays, which Tourmaline wrote, it is hard as hell to be a public woman…and perhaps this hardness is a signal that we need to find mirrors in the shadows, as she did at Jewel’s Catch One, to see our selves in ways that are further away from the racism, sexism, trans oppression, classism, and compulsory able-bodiedness that are organizing principles of the project of trans visibility in and out of educational spaces.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a0684554afd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[gender // euphoria // shadows // online]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@trans_killjoy/gender-euphoria-shadows-online-af6cb555ee8f?source=rss-60468f47489f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/af6cb555ee8f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[affect]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[internet]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Z Nicolazzo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Aug 2019 15:45:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-14T18:03:19.613Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ebCuTxoi3vcX5URR" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@s_sagano?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Sora Sagano</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>This summer has been one full of euphoria for me. Not only have I been coding interview transcripts with trans youth who have used the phrase “gender euphoria” to describe moments of joy they experience in life, but I have also been watching HBO’s breakout series <em>Euphoria</em>. The first season of the show, which ostensibly centers on the sex and drug-soaked experiences of suburban youth navigating adolescence, also weaves a shadow-side narrative in which viewers are treated to a provocative ongoing mediation centering on dis/connection, depression, identity and, as the show’s title suggests, how each character chases euphoria as a desired state of being. The show is intense both in content and production, and that intensity also acts as a performative device to surround viewers in the often-overwhelming press of euphoria as an affective state. In other words, the show both traces and uses euphoria as a device through which to explore the raw and visceral nature of connections between and among people living, loving, and searching for meaning together.</p><p>Although not always the case, euphoria has come to be used as a way to designate “a feeling of intense excitement and happiness.” However, the word, which originates from the Greek <em>euphoros</em>, used to signify the wellbeing produced in a sick person by the use of drugs. In learning this, I paused, wondering what the connections may be between euphoria as an affective state of being-in-the-world and Euphoria as a show. Moreover, I began to wonder how gender mediated both euphoria and Euphoria, being that trans youth had used the term “gender euphoria,” and one of the main characters in Euphoria is Jules, a trans girl played by the trans model and actress Hunter Schafer. What are the gender dis/connections between euphoria and Euphoria? How do drugs act as a metaphor that tethers the these dis/connections? How do drugs-as-metaphor — both from the word’s Greek origins as well as their placement in the show — act as a door through which one can ask questions about trans visibility in the current sociopolitical moment, questions that may encourage us to let go of some of the ways of strategizing we once held to be axiomatic? Additionally, I am wondering how the use of the Internet — the main focus on my current research with trans youth — acts as a form of drug that then induces such euphoria. Might the Internet act as a sort of drug promoting gender euphoria?</p><p><strong>I. Gender Euphoria as a Feeling</strong></p><p><em>Gender euphoria: a feeling of intense gender excitement and gender happiness. A fleeting, always being pursued sense of self, one that feels always already out of reach. A feeling that is always being chased, and once it is caught, it is never for too long.</em></p><p>Euphoria is an escapist fantasy. It dabbles not in the real, or the here and now, but in the imagination, and in that which is yet to come. There is, however, a shadow side to imagining beyond, and that is the loss inherent in the current moment. If euphoria signals a desire for that which has not yet come, then it also signals that which is not, and perhaps may never be, here. If euphoria signals a desire for an unreal future tense, then it also signals an unreal present tense. Connected to gender, then, it may seem that euphoria signals both a multiplicity of future possibilities, as well as an always already loss. This confusion of affect, this crashing sense of loss in the present, is notably acute for those of us who are trans girls, women, and femmes.</p><p>In Eva Hayward’s piece <a href="https://read.dukeupress.edu/tsq/article-abstract/4/2/191/84713/Don-t-Exist"><em>Don’t Exist</em></a>, she reminds her readers of the seeming existential impossibility of trans + woman. Not that we ourselves are not-real, or not-women, but that we are constantly and consistently hailed to not exist. In fact, she goes further than this, suggesting that not only are we always brought into being through death — the counting of dead trans women as a signifier of how anti-Black racism has always been a mainstay of transmisogyny — but that even when we do exist, we are told — by individuals, by governments, by policies, by discourses sedimented over time — that we do not. In this way, our being becomes a lie, a fiction in the worst of ways, and we are erased in/from plain sight. We are not trans + woman because we could/can never become trans + woman. This is not just a bodily fact — think of the ongoing murders of trans women as an assertion of such — but an epistemological one, as well. If the mode of being is cordoned off, then the material for being is, too. Trans + woman becomes [trans] + woman, an insertion into a never-could-be material reality, signaling various forms of loss in the present.</p><p>Euphoria is fleeting, and marks a liminality, both in the present as well as the future-future, after the drug-induced state wears off. For trans women, girls, and femmes, the loss that is the shadow side of euphoria sounds like terror, the omnipresent low buzz of seething vitriol most politely coming across as, “But what are you really?,” which is a hostile answer in the form of a question, so as to provide a level of plausible deniability to the phobic person discharging the utterance. Sure, we seek euphoria. We always have. We just do it in the shadows.</p><p><strong>II. Gender Euphoria in the Shadows</strong></p><p><em>Gender euphoria: the production of a brief, altered state of being-in-the-world as trans.</em></p><p>Shadows feature prominently in the lives of trans people, especially trans women. For example, in two recent television dramas featuring trans women — HBO’s <em>Euphoria</em>and FX’s <em>Pose</em> — there is both the strategic use of shadows in the production of the show (i.e., <em>Euphoria</em>) as well as a discourse of shadows as a gatekeeper to public life (i.e., <em>Pose</em>). In <em>Pose</em>, daytime is ascribed to realness, thus conjuring a tacit connection between darkness and shadows as <em>un</em>real, or perhaps read in a more forgiving way, as superseding the realness imposed by a heteronormative daytime society. In the darkness of the ballroom, trans women can be real on their own terms. They can mock white cisheteropatriarchy through mimicry and play acting, holding the fragility of those who project their nontrans genders to be stable, immutable, and natural as an object with which to tinker.</p><p>These profusions of queer- and transness in the dark are stretched to their limits in <em>Euphoria</em>, a show that takes place mostly in the shadows. Evening parties, the darkness of rooms, a nighttime county fair, and apps hiding behind darkened phone screens are the locations through which <em>Euphoria</em>’s characters come to life. In particular, Jules, a white trans girl who is a central figure through the series, seeks and develops her own sense of (gender) euphoria in the dark. In one episode, she asks her friend Rue — played by the immensely talented Zendaya — to take nude and semi-nude photos of her, all of which are taken in her darkly shadowed bedroom. When she goes back to the city she had lived in previously, Jules shows signs of freedom, of heightened euphoria, upon returning. We, the audience, witness this through Jules’ sticking her legs out of her friend’s car window, and standing up through her friend’s car moonroof, singing and dancing as she does. It is, as you may have guessed, nighttime.</p><p>In one fairly intimate scene, the first in which Jules actively addresses her growth into her trans femininity, she is laying on her back while a new friend (or is she a love interest?) applies eyeshadow and eyeliner. As she is getting made up — having femininity caked onto her, for, as <a href="https://www.dukeupress.edu/the-look-of-a-woman">Eric Plemon’s work</a>would remind us, the face has become the place where gender has moved as a main site of determining femininity — she talks about her trans becoming. She states:</p><blockquote>I remember being in Sears with my first pair of heels in my backpack and my heart was fucking racing…and I got home and went straight to my room and locked the door, put ’em on, and it just felt like I was collecting herbs and making potions in order to up my mana, you know? Like, it started with that and then it was clothes and then it was makeup, and eventually hormones. Um, I just kind of kept leveling up.</blockquote><p>Here, Jules is making a specific reference to Magic: The Gathering. Although there are ways to build decks online, it remains — as it was when I was growing up — largely a tabletop game. And still, Magic: The Gathering is a decidedly virtual world, one to which Jules can — and clearly does — escape to in search of her own gender euphoria. Magic: The Gathering is her virtual conduit, a shadowy nexus through which she can continue to level up her own femininity, becoming the trans woman she is — that is simultaneously foreclosed by society — and desires to be. Shadows converge to shine a light on Jules’ transness. The dimly light room in which she is laying for her makeover; the dark corners of Magic: The Gathering as a virtual landscape, an alternate universe where she collects herbs and mixes potions to level up her transfemininity; the way that she is seen best, and reveals herself most, in the dark palette of the show itself.</p><p>Not only does Jules chase the euphoria of her own transgirlhood in the dark, but she is always shown as being happiest in the shadows. And this, to me, is a vital aspect that must be addressed in thinking about the possibilities for what, where, when, and how gender euphoria may be imagined as any prolonged state of being.</p><p>As Tourmaline has reminded time and again, it is irksome — to put it lightly — that the rise in trans visibility in the United States — particularly for trans women of color — has coincided with the ongoing rise in trans women of color being murdered. In <a href="https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/trap-door"><em>Trap Door: Trans Cultural Production and the Politics of Visibility</em></a> — which she, Eric Stanley, and Johanna Burton edited — there are constant reminders that one cannot make a direct line between visibility and liberation. Not only have trans people been visible for generations — inviting readers to ask, “To whom must one be visible, and in what form, for it to matter?” — but being visible to broader nontrans publics is not a way to generate safety. Similarly, Dean Spade has written painfully about how the exposing of queer death has led to the U.S. nation-state further funding the police and prison industrial complex, both of which continue to harass, arrest, lock up, harm, and kill trans people, particularly trans women of color.</p><p>For Tourmaline, Stanley, and Burton, the trap door of trans visibility that their anthology explores is one that both offers new possibilities and amplifies ongoing violence. The trap door as a metaphor provides a platform for thinking about the ongoing ways trans people are trapped in the violent realities of being visibly trans in a world saturated with transphobia, transmisogyny, and transmisogynoir. And yet, the notion of the trap door also provides a threshold across which we — namely trans people — may be able to move to experience life in fundamentally different, freer, and more liberating ways. Not that such liberation is permanent, but there are ways, places, and times in which we may hold loosely to a visibility that works for us, and on our terms; where we may have our own prolonged experiences of gender euphoria. Enter the Internet as one potential trap door through which trans people may have these prolonged experiences.</p><p><strong>III. Gender Euphoria on the Internet</strong></p><p><em>Gender euphoria: gender wellbeing produced in a person experiencing dysphoria by the use of the Internet.</em></p><p>As I have been thinking about/through euphoria — and doing so while watching <em>Euphoria</em> — I have wondered if the way we can get closest to gender euphoria as trans women is to carve out spaces in the darkness, to find the shadows and steal away there, where we can collect our herbs and mix our potions to up our mana. And, in my research with trans youth, I am beginning to recognize the potential of the Internet as that shadowy place. That is, while there is a lot of justified conversation about the Internet as a mode by which to democratize information and bring things into broader public view, it also acts as a private, highly curatable space through which trans people can seek and experience gender euphoria. And, even though such a seeking signals a present loss, I do wonder if the prolonged time trans people may spend online could be a recognition that perhaps we are able to stretch the fleeting nature out, even just a bit. That is, if the Internet acts as a metaphorical drug by which trans people can chase, find, and try to capture gender euphoria, and if trans people keep on engaging online — and do so in particular ways that fit their/our own particular needs — then maybe the time in which we spend is a signal of trying to have those gender euphoric moments last…longer.</p><p>In the research that grounded my book <a href="https://styluspub.presswarehouse.com/browse/book/9781620364567/Trans-in-College"><em>Trans* In College</em></a>, Jackson, a trans college student, told me, “The Internet is basically my hometown.” In thinking about gender euphoria as affect, how Jules is moving through the shadowy world of <em>Euphoria</em>, and my current research exploring how trans people are using the Internet as a site for experiencing gender wellbeing through curating future possible selves and community with others, Jackson’s comment makes perfect sense. If our current condition as trans is one framed by loss, by the always already inaccessible existential possibility of existing, then why wouldn’t we set up camp in those places where we can hide in the shadows and chase, seek, and experience gender euphoria? Why wouldn’t we use online platforms and virtual landscapes in ways that let us envision beyond our bodies, or allow us to think our bodies in completely new ways? Why wouldn’t we go to the place where euphoria feels a bit more possible, and lingers a little bit longer, and allows us to be with others who are a little bit more like us?</p><p>While there is much more to excavate through the data I and several others are currently analyzing and theorizing around related to being trans online, there is one important point that ought to be made: this isn’t an either/or proposition. What these data, what my theorization, and what these ongoing conversations are most decidedly <em>not</em>saying is that trans people need to exist either on the Internet or “in real life.” This is the trap of the trap door metaphor. Instead, the research, theorizing, and pairing of the two with images of trans women through popular culture provides a trap door through which we can imagine more, different, and beyond the violence framing our lives, that cries out, “Don’t exist.” There isn’t an “easy” answer here. It isn’t about being on or offline. What it is about is perhaps recognizing the possibilities that pervade throughout, while also holding loosely to the complex realities that, for some who are heavily invested in white cisheteropatriarchy, we were never meant to — and indeed do not — exist.</p><p>And yet, here we are, proliferating in the shadows.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=af6cb555ee8f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Introducing HEAP: The Higher Education Affect Project]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@trans_killjoy/introducing-heap-the-higher-education-affect-project-76eca06609f4?source=rss-60468f47489f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/76eca06609f4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethnography]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Z Nicolazzo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Jul 2019 16:44:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-05T16:44:15.190Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RFuOo-j0tVvQdCdkK1Vuyw.png" /></figure><p><em>“We want to want. We desire to desire.”<br>~Eva Hayward</em></p><p><em>“Touch this skin honey, touch all of this skin! Okay? You just can’t take it!”<br>~Venus Xtravaganza</em></p><p>Trans as a prefix denotes desire, longing, and want. Trans is a seeking and yearning, an exploration, an imagining of what may, could, or might be. Trans is excess, is a wanting more than what one has or is seemingly given by repressive truth/knowledge regimes. To move into one’s trans becoming, then, is to actively court a longing that may yet un/do us as people, as communities, and as broader publics. We want to want, and yet, there are many — ourselves included — who may not be able to take it.</p><p>As Green (2017) noted, “Trans is itself a prefix that denotes movement and crossings” (p. 320). If trans is movement, then such movement is motivated by desire and want. The movement of trans — or perhaps better put, the trans movement, which one can understand to be aesthetic, political, and material conditions of being — is animated by the desire, want, and longing that may yet un/do us all. Indeed, Xtravaganza’s words in the epigram above are prophetic; 30 years after her pronouncement, there are wave after wave of evidence offered up for how many nontrans people “can’t take” our transness, can’t handle this excess, can’t handle this skin in which we are creating underworlds (Gossett, 2017), because our current condition is untenable. Our movements — our trans-ing — are those in which we twist, comport, vogue, strut, and swish to the beat of house music. In so doing, we create the conditions through which we can continue to live on our own terms, not waiting for people to accept our movements. It is this unruliness, this scrappiness, this way of cobbling together life through movement — which then begets a movement — in which I am most interested. In particular, I am curious: what animates the movement we do as trans people, and that then sparks trans movements/moments in broader publics? If trans is desire and excess, then what does that desire and excess — and desiring <em>of </em>excess — produce in the world? How do others, those who do not organize their lives around gender deviance, respond to the longing for more, and in what ways do these responses create the im/possibility for livable trans lives? What occurs between people regarding gender, and how does the affective residue of everyday life inform how to un/do gender <em>in situ</em>, such that normalized sedimentations need not become the metric of assessing the distribution of life and death through racialized capitalism? In short: what is the feeling of trans, and how does that feeling ripple out across bodies, histories, and institutions?</p><p>Excess, as a state of being, is untenable, unstable, on the very edge of un/sustainability. Excess will likely spill down, out, and over, seeping across spaces and places previously unwanted. Thinking of trans in this way shows how gender is never just about one subgroup; trans is never just about trans, but spills out across everyone. Trans is, in some ways, all-encompassing. Trans is everything…and yet, trans is also nothing. Due to the state of trans abjection, of trans monstrosity — that which is not theorized out of trans spaces, but placed upon us as being <em>not right</em>, and therefore <em>all wrong</em> — we are reminded regularly of our nothingness. We are, as Hayward (2017) has articulated, told: don’t exist. And to be sure, these are not just external attacks against trans people, but are also coming from inside the communities in which we exist. For example, the desire to be seen as “normal,” and “just like” other (read: nontrans) people, and that it will all “get better” the more integrated one gets into society, and the more we move into positions of mainstream possibility, can also be seen as that which is tinged with a desire for us to not exist. For while things may be “getting better,” we need to wonder actively and loudly: getting better for whom? Under what conditions? And who/how many need to be left behind in order for the getting better to happen for some? Finally, how do we then use those who have been left behind to further protect the resources that some of us have? For example, how many times do we need to call upon those trans women of color who have been killed, but only in their deaths, in their pools of blood, their bodies often both lifeless and nameless, to secure a rationale for the protracted project of visibility and representation? The mandate to not exist, then, also seeps across borders; it, too, seems to be an outgrowth of the desire, excess, want, and longing that mark trans (and that trans marks).</p><p>The verb form of heap comes from the Old English <em>heapian</em>, meaning to collect, heap up, and bring together. It’s noun form was used in the early 19thcentury as slang indicating slovenly women. Both of these origins seem particularly robust for thinking about organizing my thinking around the desiring and excess that is both produced and is a result of trans. For if the act of heaping means to collect and bring together, then perhaps that is the very way I need to think about how I go about answering the aforementioned questions. I will need to heap together in one space, as best I can, those observations and significations that point to how affective relationships influence the distribution of livable life vis-à-vis individual and group understandings of gender. These heaps will likely spill out in untidy piles — noted in the noun definition of the term itself — and thus will mimic the excess of trans. Perhaps heap is a mirror for trans, then. Collecting and compiling and attempting to corral heaps of trans, then, is a tracing of a form of methodology; combing and combining together affective notes on the excessive profusions of trans, and the ways that excess affects others, provides broad contours for the broader project. For now, however, it will suffice to see this as a way through which organizing trans in heaps may make sense.</p><p>The slang for heap, though — the slovenly woman — may also provide an important point of connection. That is, responses to transness have often been tinged with a particular form of misogyny, racialized and otherwise. For those who are not trans, to be trans is made all the more despicable, shameful, and disgusting the closer one gets to femininity. The most vitriolic and violent responses to trans becoming has always already been reserved for trans women and girls, especially those who are trans women and girls of color. Trans women, then, are made out to be slovenly, whether we are or not; whether we want to be or not; whether our slovenliness is by design, out of a desire to live, due to a lack of time, a manifestation of a particular body politic, or not. The trans-as-slovenly-woman troupe, one that Serrano (2007) may mark through the language of transmisogyny, has become an organizing principle for trans necropolitics, and is made all the more unsettling when taking into account how settler colonialism and anti-Blackness have affixed themselves to gender transgression, rendering an illogical matrix through which Black, Indigenous, and Persons of Color trans (BIPOC) trans lives are re/de/constructed as disposable. And while some of us — myself and Stryker (1997), for example — have held loosely onto our monstrosity as trans women, the notion of the slovenly woman, the trans heap, continues to exert an acute pressure on our lives, and the lives of other trans women, especially BIPOC trans women, that is highly <em>un</em>welcomed. No matter how much we may move toward our potential slovenly nature, the making us into slovenly women — that is to say, not “real women,” whatever that even begins to mean — is an act of epistemic violence that then produces the waves of material violence being meted out in asymmetrical ways across trans populations.</p><p>Heaps of data, the trans heap, and trans/heap-as-excess lead me to envisioning what will become my new study: the Higher Education Affect Project, or HEAP. In this study, I will begin to trace the affective components that give rise to the ongoing discourses of gender that pervade educational contexts. In other words, I will look for the circuits of feeling that flow between and across people and populations in ways that reify cultural mis/understandings of gender, and how these circuitries compel the mal/distribution of life chances for trans people, ways of being, and ways of thinking in education. Thinking about the notion of a heap as a cobbling together, I will suture affect theory and ethnographic practice to think through an <em>ethnography of feeling</em>. Just as Ahmed (2012) has followed documents around, Nanney (In progress) is following around policies, and I and others are following around digital selves (In progress), I want to pull on ethnography further to follow around feelings. Specifically, I am curious how the feelings between/across/throughout relationships act as the elements by which cultural discourses of gender congeal.</p><p><strong>An Ethnography of Feeling<br></strong>Geertz (1998) referred to ethnographic research as a form of “deep hanging out.” Rooted in participant observation, ethnographic practice has moved from exploring “others” to being alongside populations with whom we may have strong resonance, commitment, and connection. However, questions abound in thinking about an ethnography of feeling, including: with whom is one hanging out deeply? And who are the “participants” if the observable phenomenon is decidedly about affect? What even is an ethnography of feeling, and how might one begin to explore such a methodology in ways that are consonant with broader conceptualizations of ethnographic practice? Despite multiple ethnographic methodologists asserting the lack of any particular staid methods by which data ought to be collected and analyzed, there are tenets by which one may want to think about any ethnographic practice. Below, I begin to outline how I will respond to these tenets. In so doing, I find it important to state these tenets are ones I have come to through my own ethnographic practice, as well as engagement with fellow ethnographers; they may be impartial and “incorrect,” for whatever that term may mean. However, they seem important to highlight and respond to at the outset of HEAP.</p><p><em>Hanging Out with Feelings<br></em>If ethnography is framed as researchers hanging out deeply with the participants amongst whom they are living, then an ethnography of feeling would require the same with the feelings circulating between and amongst people. Affect theory, as a field, is concerned with the micromoments between individuals, and the curls of emotionality that reverberate in that space between. It is there, in those micromoments between people, where I will need to hang out. I envision spending time thinking not about the people in these exchanges so much as the waves of feeling in which these people are engulfed. What is created as new between people? How are people responding to the cultural practices of gender, of which they may or may not be cognizant, but are always already present?</p><p>Moreover, I am also curious about the conditions by which these micromoments are framed. What is the before, during, and after or gender, and how do these temporal moments go about setting the conditions for the exchanges between and across people as they relate to cultural discourses of gender? For example, what choices are made <em>before </em>interpersonal interactions, but are made <em>as a result of</em>these anticipated interactions? And, after these interactions occur, how does what happens between people further cement the gendered conditions by which individuals will engage <em>in the future</em>, either with each other or different people? In many senses, an ethnography of feeling involves creating an <em>archive of feeling </em>whereby temporality is deeply considered. The before, during, and after of interpersonal exchanges, and the ways these temporally-based moments weave, collide, and bend back on each other requires attention.</p><p>Furthermore, I find it important to rest with various feelings that may come up, be they repeated or singular. For example, much has been written about queer shame, including its racialized contexts. What might it mean to hang out with shame and to think about how it is an animating force in structuring the livability of trans lives? How does the history of shame map onto trans lives, particularly in connection to the ongoing realities of HIV, anti-Black racism, and settler colonialism, all of which force shame onto trans bodies in ways we may not otherwise have picked it up ourselves? What does the current mainstream desiring of (some) trans bodies mean in relation to the ongoing shame of (some other) trans lives, and what are we to make of this as we move forward in dreaming liberation? These are the ways I am beginning to think about what “deep hanging out” may manifest, and as a result, what form an ethnography of feeling might take.</p><p><em>Duration of Fieldwork<br></em>As with many ethnographers, I am hesitant to make definitive comments on how long is “long enough” for fieldwork, as doing so sets up a false equivalency between duration in the field and goodness of a study. This said, I am also mindful that the length of deep engagement is important for exploring cultural phenomena in various contexts. Recognizing the intentional use of the word <em>project</em>as a way to signal an ongoing process by which this study continually unfolds, I envision HEAP as always already occurring. That is, similar to O’Reilly’s (2008) discussing ethnography as a process by which one spirals in and out of the field, doing analysis throughout, HEAP will be a project in which I will be collecting/analyzing/theorizing in a concurrent and ongoing fashion.</p><p>My goal for HEAP will be to collect/analyze/theorize for a year, at which point I will decide if I want to continue. The arbitrary designation of a year will allow me to hang out with feelings over the course of four seasons, providing a variety of angles from which to approach and understand these feelings. Furthermore, a year will provide a significant starting point from which to think about feelings from a temporal perspective; that is, what are the before, during, and after effects of gendered feeling, and how do these frame the livability of trans lives? Additionally, in some ways, HEAP will be beyond the scope of one year, as I will trace gendered feeling back, as well as project it forward. That is, through archival micromoments and the exploration of current cultural manifestations of gendered feeling, I will be able to <em>think feeling forward </em>as a way of dreaming liberation.</p><p><em>Public/Private Engagements<br></em>While there are a variety of practices around the sharing of ethnographic work, I much prefer those who share <em>in situ</em>. And while I will not share all of my work as it comes, I will do some sharing as a way of thinking out loud, and of breaking down — as much as one can — the notion of cloistered researchers who retain power over others due to their holding data. In some ways, then, my intermittent sharing will be a way both of theorizing as well as offering a member check of sorts. It will require me to be prudent and thoughtful in my work, and to be publicly accountable to people across genders with whom I will create contact zones through my writing. That is, even in writing publicly about HEAP, I will be proliferating micromoments through which I can — and perhaps must — further analyze and theorize. In this way, analysis and theorization fold in on each other, creating not just a loop, but folds and contours in which analysis/theorization may meld into one. Together, analysis/theorization will create a heaping excess, an overflowing of meaning through which I can think further about how gendered structures of feeling proliferate.</p><p>I am also flirting with the idea of creating a digital archive of my data trails, most notably my analytic memos and any other tangible “data” I may bump into along the way. Motivated by Fabian’s (2008) <em>Ethnography as Commentary</em>, I am wondering what it may mean — and perhaps more apt for HEAP, what it may <em>feel like</em> — to create this sort of open, digital archive. What, for example, may it mean to open raw data to unknown others? How may my doing this during my process foreclose certain types of collection/analysis/theorization? Or might I do this after HEAP has concluded, as a form of audit trail for those who want to explore the data in more depth? However, if there is no “after” with ethnographic practice, as I have written about previously and is evidenced on the always already presence of cultural discourses of gender and their attendant feelings, then when would be the moment by which I made these data publicly available? While I do not have solid decisions on this specific contour of HEAP, I also do not necessarily think it needs to be decided at this point.</p><p><em>Education as an Archive<br></em>For HEAP, I will envision education broadly, investing time not just in day-to-day educational practice, but also in how education is de/re/constructed on a sociocultural level. That is, along with thinking about what happens within educational institutions, I will also concern myself with what sensemaking is occurring regarding education beyond those cultural locations known as schools. For example, the ways cultural discourses of gender motivate the schooling of high school youth through shows like <em>Euphoria</em>, the schooling of broader publics around gender/sexuality in shows like <em>Pose</em>, and the ways racialized constructions of gender map onto/off of bodies and experiences <em>such that they influence the happenings through educational institutions </em>is an important factor to which I ought to attend. People who work, learn, and live at educational institutions are interacting with these cultural manifestations of gendered meaning, as well as finding themselves (not) reflected through them. Thus, the relevance of these sociocultural manifestations of gender, and what feelings they arise from, create, and will set as the groundwork for future gendered im/possibilities is salient for HEAP.</p><p>I am also interested in what learning about gendered feeling may occur beyond the pale of what has been commonly understood as “education.” For example, in her book <em>Youth Held at the Border</em>, Patel (2013) described contact zones between those youth in and out of school, and what these contact zones may tell us about the porous and false binaries between such a notion (i.e., in/out of school). It is more than recognizing learning happens without needing educational institutions; instead, to think education beyond educational institutions requires one to understand how such institutions have always already been foreclosed to various people and populations due to the palpable presence of trans oppression, anti-Black racism, classism, and settler colonialism. Thus, to confine my thinking to educational institutions would be to confine my thinking to the illogical structures of oppressive ideologies, and to limit my work in ways that reify the violence that keeps many out.</p><p>Finally, if we take seriously the fallacy that is the on/off campus dichotomy, then it must be said that what happens “off campus” is itself a reflection of/speaking back to/teaching about what happens “on campus.” There is a way, then, that the “off”ness of off campus requires an attention that will always speak to/of/about the “on”ness of on campus. In other words, there is no on/off campus, as cultural discourses know no boundaries. While gender may map across time and space differently, this is hardly a rationale for my not thinking beyond the confines of campuses. Thus, I will think about education as an archive, and more specifically, an affective archive. Understood at its broadest, I will think about how cultural discourses of gender are schooled, how we are schooled by them, and how education as an affective process holds possibilities for dreaming liberation into existence.</p><p><strong>Starting without Starting<br></strong>I will commence with HEAP on 1 August 2019. However, in many respects, I feel as though I have already begun the project (yet another way temporalities play tricks on us, that the before/during/after of affect is a bit of a hoax). The plan will be for me to trace affect in my daily interactions in/beyond the academy, as well as pulling on affective strings where gender pools socioculturally. I will continue writing throughout collection/analysis/theorization, with the hope of developing various “products” — what these will be, I am not yet sure, and would prefer not to concern myself with at this particular moment — to share along the way, and most definitely during the 2020–2021 academic year.</p><p>Over the course of the 2019–2020 academic year, HEAP will: travel to/through three continents; engage in various learning communities, including the building of a masculinities initiative responsive to expansive notions of gender; explore the advising of doctoral students; and think through trans pedagogy, among other things. In this way, I envision HEAP as living its name in that it will provide — and reflect — an excess of gendered feeling. It will heap on waves of affect, and will spill over with meaning that may speak to how cultural discourses of gender become sedimented in their current shapes and forms. Far from a going back to the “root cause” of these cultural discourses, HEAP will seek an affective framing by which these discourses continue to proliferate. For, if we can understand the feeling behind/on/around which these discourses rest, we may find new ways of dreaming/feeling forward.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=76eca06609f4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Not Another Gender Binary: A Call For Complexity Over Cis-Readability]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/spark/not-another-gender-binary-a-call-for-complexity-over-cis-readability-69a568ca8e9?source=rss-60468f47489f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/69a568ca8e9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Z Nicolazzo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Jun 2019 03:03:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-06-08T03:03:31.577Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Why a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy is counterproductive to gender liberation by T.J. Jourian and Z Nicolazzo</h4><p><em>This piece has been cross-posted through both author’s Medium accounts, as well as the account for the National Center for Institutional Diversity</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5ZTkjqMbw01BZ9fZMqzX3Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo from <a href="https://broadlygenderphotos.vice.com/">The Gender Spectrum Collective</a> on <a href="https://www.vice.com/en_us/broadly">Broadly</a></figcaption></figure><p>As trans people, not much makes us crankier than the insistence of a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy, or the arbitrary dividing of trans people into two camps based on someone’s idea of who is and is not conforming to masculine men’s and feminine women’s presentations. As trans scholars and educators, we understand the importance of making trans realities accessible, especially to those out there searching for someone “like them.” But this is <strong><em>not</em></strong> achieved by surplanting one gender binary with another — by making some trans people more like cis — or nontrans — people and others less like cis people. Spoiler alert: it’s not about cis people!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*7yBoQh-aPErkMCEZ82I7TA.gif" /></figure><p>Beyond conveying a lack of understanding of what trans is, does, and can do as a way of being and thinking, the supposed nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy relies on normative judgements about who/what is “trans enough” and/or “really trans.” We don’t reach gender liberation by prioritizing cis understandings of trans and gender nonconforming identities and experiences. Rather than push for more fluid, dynamic, and intersectional notions of gender expansiveness, the “binary v. nonbinary trans people” fallacy keeps our most simplified and palatable narratives front and center. This is yet another practice of <strong><em>cislation</em>, or the translating of seemingly illegible (i.e., not understandable) genders for cis recognition</strong>.</p><blockquote>“We don’t reach gender liberation by prioritizing cis understandings of trans and gender nonconforming identities and experiences.”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*Jr4byWY8Y-aYSewiHyIgpA.gif" /></figure><h4>What is Cislation?</h4><p>Simply put, <a href="http://writewhereithurts.net/2017/08/16/the-cislation-of-transness-in-higher-education-and-student-affairs-scholarship-part-1/"><strong>cislation</strong></a><strong> is what happens when trans people feel compelled to create narratives about our transness in the simplest, most reductive of terms</strong>. The <a href="https://janetmock.com/2012/07/09/josie-romero-dateline-transgender-trapped-body/">“trapped in the wrong body” narrative</a> is one such example. We do this not because we lack complexity, but as a way to be legible (i.e., understandable) to cisgender people, and as a recognition that we live in a world and <a href="https://muse.jhu.edu/article/626125">in an academy</a> that lack the ability to know us and our transness. Some of y’all can’t even deal with <a href="https://www.dictionary.com/e/they-is-a-singular-pronoun/">“they” as a singular pronoun</a>! Cislation signals cisgender people’s lack of understanding, and the omnipresence of a cultural gender binary discourse (explained below) through which we as trans people must wade.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*_NNi6rnb40ofdgEdsdG4BA.gif" /></figure><p>There are various problems with cislation, especially in relation to the oversimplification of trans populations into a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy. For a population of people who specifically move across binary constructs of gender, this unnecessary dichotomy rings false, counterproductive, and dangerous. Below, we articulate five arguments for why the creation of a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy is problematic and why we need to move beyond these manifestations of cislation.</p><h4>#1: The “Binary = Bad” Ascription</h4><p>As we have articulated through some of our own <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/17508487.2017.1356340">scholarship</a>, <a href="https://styluspub.presswarehouse.com/browse/book/9781620364567/Trans-in-College">gender binary discourse</a> — the archaic notion that gender consists of two and only two “opposite” genders, between and amongst which there is no movement, overlap, or fluidity — limits the livability of trans peoples’ lives. We and other trans scholars pose gender binary discourse as a negative ascription; a way of thinking that we should avoid and unlearn. So when one poses a question about, writes about, or consolidates any group of trans people under the banner of being “binary trans individuals,” the negative ascription carries over to that group. For example, if one is posed as being a “binary trans person,” they are perceived to be upholding dominant notions of gender, and thus, are positioned as not doing “trans” right, correct, or well. <strong>Our insistence that we avoid and unlearn a way of <em>thinking</em> turns into a suggestion that we avoid and unlearn a way of <em>being</em></strong>. Meaning, there is the accusation that some trans people — the “binary” ones — are not doing trans “right” or “correctly.” In this equation, those consolidated under the heading of “binary trans individuals” are living a life framed by negativity. Ironically, this is the flip side of the not doing trans “right” or “correctly” coin that has also been flinged at gender nonconforming and nonbinary people by assimilationist elements of trans populations, who are surrendering to a desire of acceptability by cis society — our own brand of respectability politics. Thus attempts to be easily explainable to cis people marks all trans people as not “enough” in one way or another.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*IyFq9AoYTEBZ6rfQ3oaBZQ.gif" /></figure><h4>#2: There is Nothing Not Radical about Moving Across Genders</h4><p><a href="https://www.sealpress.com/titles/susan-stryker/transgender-history-second-edition/9781580056908/">Susan Stryker articulated</a> that transgender “refer[s] to people who move away from the gender they were assigned at birth, people who cross over (trans-) the boundaries constructed by their culture to define and contain gender.” In whatever way we as trans people express our genders, however we practice this radical act of self-determination and reclamation in a world constantly seeking to erase us, <a href="http://www.lttr.org/journal/1/dress-to-kill-fight-to-win">there is nothing not radical about this movement across genders</a>. To produce the supposed nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy suggests some trans people — again, the “binary” ones — are somehow opting into that gross gender binary (il)logic, thus (re)producing societal forms of gendered hegemonic violence, or how gender is posed as always and only binary, thus limiting gender self-determination. <strong>The suggestion that “binary” trans movement reproduces gendered hegemonic violence strips our gender-based movement of its radical potential</strong>. It suggests some of us — the “binary” ones — are invested in hurting and harming the trans community, because in the end, we are all just (re)producing dominance, albeit in new morphological ways. This (il)logic is trans-antagonistic at best, and violent at worst.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*CwQgB6-Dp3sYhwIAzJUwxw.gif" /></figure><h4>#3: What Even is “Binary” Transness?</h4><p>In thinking about the cislation inherent in the creation of the nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy, we ask: who is assuming that “binary trans” is a mode of being in the world? How is this dichotomy limiting? <strong>What does it even mean to be a “binary trans individual”?</strong> Who determines whether someone is “binary” or “nonbinary”? Is it based on biomedical transitioning? Does it matter if one “passes”? On whose standards of beauty does one define “passing”? What about trans people who are biomedically transitioning <em>and</em> claim a nonbinary identity; are they just confused or living a sense of false consciousness? Or nonbinary trans people who do not desire to biomedically transition and do not “pass” based on nontrans people’s standards of beauty? How are racism, ableism, classism, and settler colonialism encoded into notions of “passing” and who is able/desires to biomedically transition in the first place, thus framing all of the aforementioned questions?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*T1SeFzBkMwC6fFNBms41uA.gif" /></figure><p><strong>The creation of “binary” transness is foisted upon trans people by the inherent desire for cislation by nontrans people as they try to make sense of our lives</strong>. And yet again, that sense-making is (less directly perhaps) based on cis people’s “preoccupation with transition and surgery [which] objectifies trans people”, as <a href="https://www.salon.com/2014/01/07/laverne_cox_artfully_shuts_down_katie_courics_invasive_questions_about_transgender_people/">Laverne Cox</a> put it. In this way of thinking, trans people are posed as gender guinea pigs to be picked apart and prodded, to be judged by standards of beauty and notions of “passing” we never asked for, nor do we have much say in. Simply put: “binary” transness is a cage into which some of us are placed by nontrans people’s desires for cislation, and it needs to stop.</p><blockquote>How are racism, ableism, classism, and settler colonialism encoded into notions of “passing”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*AEA4BauVE65pnzEp2ucxng.gif" /></figure><h4>#4: Transness Extends beyond Embodiment</h4><p>Suggesting a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy defines transness as being always and only about bodies. However, as trans and queer scholars have been writing about for years, transness is also an <a href="https://read.dukeupress.edu/books/book/23/chapter/97439/Troubling-the-WatersMobilizing-a-Trans-Analytic">analytic</a>, a <a href="https://www.ingentaconnect.com/contentone/aup/tgen/2017/00000020/00000004/art00006">method</a>, a <a href="https://read.dukeupress.edu/glq/article/3/4/437/9940/Punks-Bulldaggers-and-Welfare-Queens-The-Radical">politic</a>, an <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0042085917697203">epistemology</a>, and a lens through which to do <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/09650792.2016.1203343">research</a>. <strong>To affix transness to the body via this false binary limits the expansiveness of the notion itself</strong>. While trans may well have started off as a way of making meaning of embodied realities — as Stryker’s earlier quote highlights — it has very quickly proliferated in a wild abundance of divergent possibilities for thinking, being, researching, and activism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*AJnRrI39a4XirLZF90j32g.gif" /></figure><h4>#5: Trans is Both Capacious and Specific</h4><p><strong><em>There is no good, logical argument for segmenting off notions of transness</em></strong>. Yes, we all experience our transness differently, and everyone should be cautious not to create monolithic understandings of transness based on categorical claims. We are certainly not calling for a singular and reductive notion of transness. However, we do not have to sacrifice honoring the complexities of transness to honor each of our specificities. We can do both; we can have our specific understandings of self while also aligning ourselves politically, socially, and ethically with broader trans communities, or communities of trans experience, or various other signifiers that resonate with who we are. The imposition of an “opposite” or binary between/among trans peoples need not exist, and only serves to sever connections across experiences, politically and otherwise.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*uwF6qh__11vYwvI1S0lJVg.gif" /></figure><p><strong>Don’t Cislate Me Bro, Or a Call for Complexity Over Cis-Readability</strong></p><p>Who we are as trans people is often complex, always beautiful, and infinitely boundless. As we have shown, to have our transness codified and limited through the phenomenon of cislation, which substitutes our limitless natures for cisgender peoples’ coherence, is problematic on multiple levels. We also understand that our arguments may be challenging for readers in that we stray from easy solutions and digestible understandings of our trans selves for others to consume. This is intentional, lest we fall into the traps of cislation. <strong>Thus, we close our essay with a call for people of all genders — and especially cisgender people — to embrace complexity over a false sense of readability of trans realities</strong>. Embracing our call means focusing not on cis-readability via cislation, but on trans humanity via centering transness in all its boundless potentialities and possibilities. If we care deeply about trans lives, then we need to recognize that the promotion of a nonbinary/binary trans dichotomy does more harm than good.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*PVpIPr7IVkvjeHwkeKWRFA.gif" /></figure><p><a href="https://lsa.umich.edu/ncid/people/diversity-scholars-directory/tj-jourian.html"><em>T.J. Jourian</em></a><em> is an assistant professor in the department of Organizational Leadership at Oakland University and a member of the </em><a href="https://lsa.umich.edu/ncid/engagement-opportunities/diversity-scholars-network.html"><em>Diversity Scholars Network</em></a><em> at the National Center for Institutional Diversity. Dr. Jourian’s research interests involve trans* and queer student, staff, and faculty campus experiences and leadership, particularly those of queer and trans* people of color, justice-centered curriculum and pedagogy, and student activism. He is also the co-founder of Trans*forming Higher Education (formerly T*Circle), the only collective by and for trans educators in higher education and student affairs.</em></p><p><a href="https://lsa.umich.edu/ncid/people/diversity-scholars-directory/z-nicolazzo.html"><em>Z Nicolazzo</em></a><em> is an assistant professor of Trans* Studies in Education and Co-Chair of the Transgender Studies Research Cluster at the University of Arizona, and a member of the </em><a href="https://lsa.umich.edu/ncid/engagement-opportunities/diversity-scholars-network.html"><em>Diversity Scholars Network</em></a><em> at the National Center for Institutional Diversity. Dr. Nicolazzo’s research is focused on exposing and exploring critical gendered perspectives of education. Her first book, Trans* in College, is the first full-length monograph focusing on trans college students through an affirmative-based lens.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=69a568ca8e9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/spark/not-another-gender-binary-a-call-for-complexity-over-cis-readability-69a568ca8e9">Not Another Gender Binary: A Call For Complexity Over Cis-Readability</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/spark">Spark Magazine</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hair(,) Loss(,) and Gender]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@trans_killjoy/hair-loss-and-gender-cb340e95e06c?source=rss-60468f47489f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cb340e95e06c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[short-story]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hair]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Z Nicolazzo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 25 May 2019 18:57:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-27T03:31:51.522Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><em>A story about gender and the loss associated with hair loss.</em></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*XcoWpsqie2Bhsp6s_Ip2ww.jpeg" /><figcaption>photo taken by author</figcaption></figure><p>“I don’t know what happened,” I said. “When I was a kid, I had such thick hair, and now, not so much.”</p><p>I was at a new hair stylist; my fourth in two years since moving to Illinois, and I felt defeated. I just wanted to find someone who wouldn’t make me do the work of carrying a conversation and would help me feel decent about the hair I had left. I wasn’t yet sure I wouldn’t need to find a fifth stylist, but for now, I thought, I’ll try to make this one work.</p><p>“Well, sometimes when kids hit puberty, hormones change hair, so I am guessing that may have been what happened with you,” she responded in a no-nonsense way. I winced. There it was; I had been betrayed by my hormones yet again.</p><p>My stylist didn’t know I hadn’t been on speaking terms with some of my hormones for the past few years; how could she have? It wasn’t like I sat down in my new stylists’ chairs and announced my transness. In fact, there weren’t many chairs I sat in and immediately announced this, aside from with my therapist. But regardless of her not knowing, she reminded me yet again that something didn’t quite fit, didn’t compute about/for me. Maybe it was my hormones, the higher levels of testosterone coursing through my body. Maybe it was my family history; the faint memories I had of my mother’s father was that he was angry and bald, although I don’t think the two were related. Maybe it was that I had worn a hat inside too often when I was a kid. At the time, I had made a habit of blaming myself for things in my life, so this seemed like an especially reasonable choice. Whatever the reason, my stylist had picked a scab that had long bothered me, an eczema of thought that was not always inflamed, but never quite went away. My hair, it seemed, would continue to be a problem for me. What a very trans problem to have, I thought, as I walked out of the salon with my hair freshly cut.</p><p><em>The first time I felt a deep sorrow about hair was on my first trip to the National Holocaust Museum in Washington D.C. I remember waiting in a long line that wound around the side of the building with my family — this was before my parents had an acrimonious divorce — not really knowing what to expect. Then, a couple hours later, as I walked around a corner of an exhibit, I saw a large sepia tone photo. I wasn’t quite sure what I was looking at, but was intrigued and walked closer. My family was dispersed throughout the floor, and the closer I moved to the photo, which took up most of the wall it was on, the smaller I felt, until I stood right in front of it. What I saw were piles of hair, human hair, that had been forcibly removed from Jews on their arrival to the death camps. I hadn’t yet thought of the ethnoreligious connections to hair, but there was something about the photo that confronted me with the extreme depths of loss and degradation those in the camps were made to experience. I began to weep, as I had done at various other points in the museum.</em></p><p>I have always admired long hair. My ex-wife had beautiful long hair that went down past her shoulders, and I used to love losing my fingers in it. In fact, many of my exes have had long hair, and the more I have thought about it, the more I am realizing that perhaps I have been seeking that which I have always wanted for myself. I was driving to dinner with someone the other day and we got on the topic of hair. I told her I had had a day, and was trying to decide if my wanting to cut all my hair off was a response to having a day, or was an ardent desire of mine, just to be done with it all, to speed up the inevitable. After all, it was the hormones, or my grandfather, or my own fault for wearing hats too often indoors. I told her that one of the strange things on my want-in-a-future-partner list was long hair. I just loved it, I said, and in the sharing of this comment, I could feel the longing in the telling. I could feel the split ends of past failed attempts. I could see myself in past mirrors hoping for something different, and disappointedly realizing otherwise.</p><p><em>The next time I grieved over hair was when I was in the second year of my doctoral program. I had been growing my hair out ever since coming into my own transness, and had high hopes for what the final results may be. I hoped for the day I could learn how to braid my hair, or put it up in a ponytail or a bun. I loved the way it felt when, absentmindedly, my fingers combed through it as I read article after article after book for my coursework. But then there was a breaking point, a moment at which I knew it wouldn’t happen. The hair on the top of my head wasn’t growing. The curls that fell around my ears, and in the back of my head, belied the reality that my hair just wasn’t growing the way I wanted it to. I tumbled into the arms of my then-partner, who admittedly was never quite good at supporting me emotionally, and cried for what I would never have. Every time we would read together after that point, I would catch myself watching her as she played with her long hair. She had this habit of running her hands through her hair, pulling it to the front of her face and smelling it as she read. She said she liked the way her shampoo smelled, and while we poked fun at this habit — I used to reach over and smell her hair when I caught her doing this, both of us then descending into a bit of laughter and a shared kiss — I grieved for the fact that I would never be able to do this with my own hair. I don’t know if she ever really understood this sense of loss. We never really talked about it. I don’t think I had the words. But then again, what would they have been, anyway? And I didn’t necessarily want a “fix,” but just for someone to hold me and say, “Hormones suck, baby.” Or maybe it was my grandfather. Or maybe it was me. Either way, the result was the same, and I was bereft.</em></p><p>I cut myself shaving the other day. As I moved through the rest of my routine, the blood that leaked from that mark signaled memories that began to leak from my past. I remembered the first time I shaved my legs, and the cooling feel of the inside of my pajamas that night. I remembered finding ways to explain why I shaved — after all, I cycled, and that’s just what cyclists do, innit? I had a memory of talking with a dear friend — the first person I came out to as trans — about shaving off my beard as a way, I thought, to move closer to my femininity, while he gently reminded me that being an Italian Jew meant that I would have a constant five o’clock shadow, and perhaps what I may want to do is unhinge my relationship with my beard with a history of masculinity. I recalled the many women I know across genders who have contested relationships with hair — its texture, placement, thickness or lack thereof, if they work to get rid of it — on their body. I tried to tally the amount of time I gave to thinking about, contemplating, mourning, and working to rectify the ways my hair had betrayed me, the ways I had been held captive by my longing for what I did not, and would never, have. I recalled the times when I told people that I would just buy wigs when I reached a certain level of baldness, but that my telling people this was largely a strategy to use humor to mask my sorrow. I remembered that I had been thinking for some time of just letting go and cropping my hair close in a sort of butch aesthetic, which wouldn’t be off-brand for me, really. I cleaned up the blood, now dried, from my cut and moved along with my day, forcing these memories into the back corners of my mind again. I couldn’t think about it right then; I wasn’t ready to face the rejection of a dream deferred quite yet.</p><p>Hair, it seems, has held an infinity of feelings for me throughout my lifetime. In many respects, the feelings I have had about my hair, and the hair of others, are tinged with the stains of patriarchy and sexism, about what women are meant to look like and do with the hair covering our bodies. The ways I have felt the need to <em>do something </em>with my hair is a byproduct of capitalism, as if I need to buy particular products, pay a certain amount at the salon — always differentiated by binary assumptions of sex/gender — or practice various manipulation techniques in order to do woman right. It’s exhausting, and not just for me, but for many of us, I’m sure. It’s exhausting to even think about how exhausting it is, and I am growing increasingly tired from that exhaustion. Even now, as I type this essay with softball on the television in the background, most of the young women with braids and ribbons adorning their long hair, I am reminded of how exhausting it can be to feel the loss of that which you want, but won’t have.</p><p><em>Today, I woke up thinking about the very thing I went to bed contemplating: cutting my hair. Maybe this can be a practice of reclamation, or bodily autonomy, or projecting a new vision of my own femininity forward. Perhaps, instead of feeling as though I have given up, I can feel like I am working toward something new, a projection of myself as myself, and not as a failed version of who I need to be. Today, I woke up thinking of the femmes and women in my life with close cropped hair, and if they, too, have experienced similar feelings of loss as I have been sifting through. I woke up thinking about how hair, and feelings about hair, are certainly a shared concern across trans experiences, but also are not solely a concern for trans people. I woke up wondering if I had the strength and courage to take my hair into my own hands, and not be held captive by my hair any longer.</em></p><p>Today, I woke up and cut my hair.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cb340e95e06c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Feeling of Gender]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@trans_killjoy/the-feeling-of-gender-596559fa2a39?source=rss-60468f47489f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/596559fa2a39</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[black-studies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[affect-theory]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Z Nicolazzo]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 18 May 2019 14:32:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-05-27T04:27:09.983Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>What feelings rise when one is confronted with gender? What about when one seeks out gender, but it is nowhere to be found? What curiosities, fears, pleasures, and confusions ripple out, and how do these feelings induce particular epistemes that then ground attitudes and behaviors about those genders one does (not) find? How do fantasy and desire project visions of gender, like film on a screen, that speak to who one could is and/or could become? How can gender be both the quotidian residue of everyday life, and also a weighty prospect through which political, social, and cultural occurrences resonate?</p><p><em>I have a specific memory of being in a classroom, the worn carpet that used to be crimson, but is now brown with years of dirt, mud, rain, and snow. We have been split into groups and are tasked with discussing Jeanette Winterson’s Written on the Body, and the student across from me is making desperate accusations of the main character’s gender and sexuality. The student is anxious. The student leans in and says, “Well, this is how I read the character,” defending the choices being mapped onto the character’s body, which really were a mirror image of the student’s own desires, and by proxy, the desires the student had for all other people, despite claims to the contrary. I slump further in my seat, feeling itchy, and eye the clock; how much more of this will I have to endure?, I think. The third student in our group is searching for words, so I help out by saying, “Why does the main character need a fixed identity?” The first student freezes, the previous anxiety ramping up and causing a stuttering and stammering response of “well, I am just so uncomfortable with someone shifting identities from day to day.”</em></p><p>Winterson (1992) wrote that “written on the body is a secret code only visible in certain lights; the accumulations of a lifetime gather there. In places the palimpsest is so heavily worked that the letters feel like braille” (p. 89). What occurs when we go looking for things that are not readily present on bodies, or may be ambiguous, or do not reflect our understandings of how one ought to show up in the world? What racialized and gendered understandings do we place onto others when these may not be seemingly obvious, if they ever can be? Following Berlant and Stewart’s (2019) insistence, what are the races and genders of the students in the memory recounted above? Are they dressed similarly? How are they holding their bodies, and what does that convey about their histories with class, disability, and education? How might the carpet be a metaphor for how sediments are trapped over time, obscuring vision, and muddling the efficacy of visibility as a way of arriving at a knowable subject? How are feelings circulating in that space to create an affect of disconnection, and air of undesirability for all involved, albeit for decidedly different reasons across the three students?</p><p>A girlfriend of mine once told me that we trans women and girls “want to want, and desire to desire.” She told me this after a few cocktails in our first few months of getting to know each other. She rarely ate when we went out, despite ordering food, at least not in those first months. Another time, about five months into knowing each other, we went out. I needed cheering. I was wrecked about someone who I shouldn’t have allowed to wreck me. I felt fragile, vulnerable, and ugly, so I did my best impression of confidence, posting it on Instagram for people to boost me with their double taps and kind comments. I told myself I would only have two cocktails, but she ordered me a third, and then a fourth. We got mouthy, queeny, excessively femme, which feels like both an oxymoron and an impossibility, as if excessive was not synonymous with femme or there could ever be too much of it. We bumped along the streets and made our way to my car, and as I was driving her home, she turned to me, holding my hand, which was gently on her thigh, and said, “There is a golden thread that connects us.” In that moment, I was undone, unraveled, scraping for something to hold onto rather than letting the feelings out. We had such a nice night, and again, as she did months ago, she gifted me with a particular vision of myself, a communal vision of us, that made sense. I’ve been thinking about the golden thread ever since, revisiting it in the dark moments of the evening, the lonely moments of the morning, and the quiet moments on bike rides when I wonder aloud “but what is it that I want and desire?”</p><p><em>I’ve developed this crush. She is so very different than those who I have given myself to previously, be it in mind, body, or both. And even as I realize this, I wish I could unyoke her from previous people who I have been with or wanted. I want those people to never be in my mind or body again, and yet, there are traces of them when I think of her. She is so different, I think…then her, or him, or her…and there they are. Always already present, as shadows and ghosts following my current crush around my mind. Perhaps this is why I do not want to pursue my crush beyond my nascent desire. Perhaps this is why I am unsettled by liking her. And also, maybe it is something else; my wanting to want, my desiring to desire, that has me staying present with the crush rather than seeking more. And also, maybe it is a fear that she — or we — will end up like the others. Past relationships have reminded me that I have not guarded my heart for those who guard my heart nearly as well as I should have. This crush is not benign, even if it doesn’t develop into something more, whatever that “more” is or does. I wonder if she will read this, and that makes me wonder what this may stir for her. I also wonder how other people who read this will un/do the genders, sexualities, and romantic affiliations of my crush and I. I wonder how people will imagine her racialization, and how their imaginings may trade on various fantasies, anxieties, and beliefs about who should be dating whom. I wonder about how others’ desires for me to be in a romantic relationship may crush this crush of mine.</em></p><p>What is the feeling of gender? What does it mean to feel trans? And no, I don’t mean feel trans in an ethereal, not-quite-real sense, although maybe I do, because if gender is relational, and affect resides in the in between of self and other, then maybe gender is both real and not, concrete and decidedly fluid, dripping down the sides of one’s hands when trying to hold tightly to something that never wanted to be contained. What I am searching for most at this moment is the way gender is (un)created through the affective suturing of peoples and happenings.</p><p>When you imagine gender, what do you feel? What is the race of gender? The dis/ability of gender? The class status? Does gender have big hair, a long beard, is it dressed in a loud print, or a short skirt in hopes of warm days ahead? When you think of gender, do you taste vegetarian dishes, do you imagine particular sorts of undergarments strewn about rooms, various sexual acts with certain partners, known or unknown? In asking these questions, I wonder how our individual and collective feelings of gender are intimate portraits of our own internal desires for self and, as a result, others. How we feel gender is a reminder of who we wish to be, and who we wish others to be. There’s a particular sort of violence in this, as our desires for self and others also mean we are also projecting what/who we do not desire at the very same time. The insidiousness of gender constriction through overlapping ideologies of racism, colonization, compulsory able-bodiedness, and classism mean that when we each desire futures, there are likely people, experiences, and subjectivities that are refashioned as not only not present, but through their non-presence, not having a future.</p><p><em>I have had so many conversations with students, colleagues, and friends about affect theory, Black studies, and the overall atheoretical bent in the field of higher education. We seem to be circling around the same question: is our field ready? The more I circle back to that question, I am wondering another one: who am I/are we envisioning as the field when we inquire about readiness? I can think of a lot of people — the abject, the unruly, the ugly, the always already outsiders, the extra ones, both in emotionality and ontological senses — who are ready, have been ready, have desired so much more from “our” field. What would happen, I wonder, if we, the undercommons, just decided we wouldn’t think much about what “they,” those who seem to think “the field” revolves around their needs and wants, are ready for? What if we infiltrated the institution, stole what we could, and redistributed it amongst ourselves to feed and enrich and enliven us? How might it feel, this forceful presence? And if we did turn away from the continual centering of normativities, how might our feeling gender provide a platform upon which to alter the ground under our collective feet?</em></p><p>I am less interested in an argument positing higher education as theoretically rich or vapid. Instead, I am curious about what feeling gender means for the cultural location of college. To feel gender requires a particular kind of space, and as a result, I am interested in turning toward that space, even if it means turning away from portions (or the whole) of the field. Fields have desires, too, which both draw in and repel various kinds of thinking, being, and feeling. Moreover, fields may suggest an openness to something, but in their suggestions, they are enacting a particular form of disavowal. Fields produce and circulate non-performatives (Ahmed, 2012), which then congeal and harden around various bodies, minds, and ways of being in the world posed as dangerous. The non-performatives build up, restrict movement, work to harden hearts and soften minds so that nothing can ever challenge the ongoing colonial project of resource extraction and hoarding of those who pose themselves as central, as knowing what, who, and how is best for the field. So what if we refused? What if we decided to turn toward the affective and feel our way to new futures that need, desire, and crave?</p><p><em>Everyone wants to monetize gender, but to do so means to dilute it. When did women become a synonym for nontrans, and when did men become restrictive in a similar fashion? When did understandings of gender and sexuality stop at the confines of a queer center, or a women’s center, or a gender and women’s studies department? Why did race and racialization not always already reside in these spaces? How does the cordoning off of spaces into single axis analyses of self-in-the-world violently simplify a radical tradition that has forever been complex and full of promise and contradiction? Are we too far gone, or is there possibility yet untapped? And if there is a there there, if there are ways of feeling gender anew, of recognizing how these feelings saturate attitudes and actions and, as a result, are a potential root that we can pull to unearth the gender binary discourses that cover college campuses like a pall (Nicolazzo, 2016, 2017), then why would we not turn away from the field to (re)make the field? Where is gender (not) and how can we feel gender in ways that jackhammer away those residues, cements, and sediments holding us planted in place?</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=596559fa2a39" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>