<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Travis Christofferson on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Travis Christofferson on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@travischristofferson?source=rss-941fcad2145b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 08:30:34 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@travischristofferson/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Future of Healthcare]]></title>
            <link>https://travischristofferson.medium.com/the-future-of-healthcare-e9b2d110dbc3?source=rss-941fcad2145b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e9b2d110dbc3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[prevention]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[keto]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Travis Christofferson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 May 2021 14:56:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-11T15:30:31.470Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The following is the last chapter of my Book: Ketones, the Fourth Fuel. The book was inspired by the life’s work of Otto Warburg, Hans Krebs, George Cahill and Richard Veech; work that culminated in the discovery of Ketone metabolism. Their message within seems especially important as we live through this viral pandemic.</p><p>How will future generations perceive our current health care system, what we, today, call “modern medicine?” Will they shake their heads in disbelief? Will the flaws seem obvious to them, that today are clouded, murky and unclear to us? Will future generations feel a twinge of empathy for us? Modern medicine, to be sure, has miraculous capabilities that our ancestors would marvel at: Imaging technologies like CT scans and MRIs, robotic-guided surgeries, and artificial intelligence programs that can diagnosis cancer far better than humans can. Yet, even with these advanced technologies that transcend human capabilities, something feels…off. We can build AI programs that predict the exact molecular architecture needed to design a new drug that docks to a specific receptor, yet 40% of the population is obese — and over half are pre-diabetic or diabetic. We can visualize our inner selves with CT scans, ultrasound and MRIs yet depression and anxiety run rampant. Perhaps we’ve veered off course. Perhaps we have focused on the trees at the expense of the forest — we have favored technology over simplicity and we have lost sight of something critical — the real meaning of health care.</p><p>Warburg, Krebs, and Veech, each of a different generation, felt the same thing. All three of them entered the world of clinical medicine as medical doctors and paused. All three felt a visceral pull drawing them to look beyond the known science to something more essential yet elusive. Something fundamental. This shared pull may have been communicated at an unspoken, unconscious level. Yet the desire was translated into something real: The continuum of research; from Warburg to Krebs to Veech; ultimately defined the manifest qualities of ketone metabolism.</p><p>Still, the stunning therapeutic potential of ketosis falls into a health care system that has shown little interest in free or dirt-cheap therapies. There is simply no financial incentive for Big-Pharma or physicians to care about low-cost therapies. Unglamorous therapies like fasting, ketogenic diets, or non-patentable ketone supplements attract little money and therefore little attention. The mismatch between the potential value of these therapies and their adoption by the health care system is staggering — it’s like valuing Amazon or Apple stock at close to zero. We spend billions annually on chemotherapy drugs that change outcomes by mere weeks or months; billions on stents, statins, bariatric surgeries and diabetes drugs and devices that don’t even scratch the surface of the core problems of insulin resistance, diabetes and obesity. Big Pharma has spent billions on developing drugs for dementia, Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s and have come away empty handed. Yet, we have this incredibly promising, perfectly safe, and incredibly cheap therapy sitting right in front of us that is largely ignored. This frustrated Veech. “He was optimistic that each publication would convince people of the ester’s importance, but then he often felt let down,” said one of Veech’s closest friends. He truly thought the ester could change the world, changing the lives of billions of fellow humans for the better. He felt the ester was the “equivalent of the discovery of penicillin. If not bigger.” Clarke, the co-developer of the ester, still believes that the ketone ester will eventually be “more or less a general tonic for the general population.”</p><p>Future generations will most likely be befuddled by our current approach to health care. Strangely, we place each disease into its own little-box and wait until it’s entrenched within us, when it’s too late, before we attempt to treat it. Physicians surgically rearrange vasculature or insert stents to treat failing arteries. They make futile attempts to salvage a body riddled with cancer by dripping in toxic chemotherapy drugs or burning with radiation. They prescribe insulin shots for people with diabetes, steroids to quell autoimmunity, and so on. But a sober top-down analysis reveals how misguided this purely reactive strategy is. Consider this: if a pill was invented that cured cancer tomorrow it would only extend the human lifespan by 2.9 years. Why?: The unremitting process of entropy will foist some other age-related disease immediately upon us. The same holds true for all other major diseases. According to an analysis preformed from scientists at University of Southern California, University of Illinois at Chicago, Harvard, Columbia, and other institutions, “Lowering the incidence of cancer by 25 percent in the next few decades — in line with the most favorable historical trends — would barely improve population health over not doing anything at all. The same is true of heart disease, the leading cause of death worldwide. About the same number of older adults would be alive but disabled in 2060 whether researchers do nothing or continue to combat cancer and heart disease individually.” Yet, investing in therapies that combat aging stand to pay <em>enormous</em> dividends. According to the analysis, “Even modest success in slowing aging would increase number of non-disabled older adults by five percent every year from 2030 to 2060.” Proof of this is easy to come by: extending the lifespan of mice by caloric restriction postpones <em>all</em> age-related diseases. To parse disease up and battle each condition individually is trying to reverse entropy at its zenith — it’s a losing game. The efforts of health care should focus on prevention over cure; pharmaceutical research should be redirected toward anti-aging interventions.</p><p>Of course, the power of prevention is nothing new but it remains universally true. The well-known adage once quipped by Benjamin Franklin: “An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure,” is as true today as it was when he first said it in 1736. The idea that a little prevention has much more value than a lot of cure not only makes intuitive sense, it is in harmony with the physical laws of the universe. The second law of thermodynamics states that the universe spontaneously trends toward an increasing amount of disorder, a process known as entropy. A health body has low entropy — it is highly ordered. A body with cardiovascular disease, cancer, or metabolic syndrome, for example, has high entropy, it is rapidly treading toward disorder. Instead of trying to fix the damage while the waters are rising, we should be damming the river. And we know the source of the river. In the world of biology entropy goes by a different term: aging. All of the Western world’s leading killers are ultimately caused by the aging process. To address aging is to address virtually every disease process. It’s difficult to undo entropy. It is far better to try to preserve order as long as possible. And this, Veech claimed, is precisely what ketone metabolism does — preserve the highly structured order of our bodies, keeping it thrumming along optimally — a sophisticated, internally-installed therapy that evolved over eons to keep us healthy and reproducing, fulfilling our Darwinian imperative.</p><p>It’s worth pointing out that the vast majority of the twentieth and twenty-first century breakthroughs in biology do not come from man inventing something de-novo, they arise from man borrowing nature’s intellectual property: genetic engineering, monoclonal antibodies, CRISPR, stem cell induction and cloning; all of these inventions, most of them blessed by a Nobel Prize, are less inventions in the true sense, and more just manipulations of the exquisite biological systems that nature honed over millions of years of evolution. Why re-invent the wheel? And truth be told, we are not yet very good at it. Man-made drugs are typically blunt, clumsy, and indiscriminate. Our attempts to target a specific disease process with drugs almost always come packaged with a litany of unintended side-effects. This is not to say we won’t be better at de-novo drug development in the future — we are just not that good at it <em>yet</em>. Our attempts to slow entropy in one location speeds it up in others. The totality of healthcare seems more like a game of whack-a-mole against entropy: drugs that attempt to undo arterial plaques and untangle neurofibrillary tangles. Surgeries that attempt to “cut out” or “bypass” entropy wherever and whenever it surfaces. Our healthcare system needs to be turned inside-out.</p><p>Heading these lessons from physics, the primary goal of health care should be to preserve our momentary gift of order — prevent entropy as long as possible. To this end, Veech’s final message was that we don’t need to look too far. We don’t need to try to invent something new. We <em>own</em> natures IP. Our bodies have a targeted, preventive-strategy already installed that can be triggered by fasting, a ketogenic diet or by ingesting the ketone ester.</p><p>Richard Veech died on February 2, 2020, shortly after addressing an audience of his peers at a conference in New Mexico, or as he might say, his “great” controlling nucleotides reached their final equilibrium. Genius often appears in unusual packages. Those that knew Dr. Veech well universally describe him as a colorful character. To be clear, he had little patience for fools. He was refreshingly, and at times, shockingly, blunt. He called it exactly how he saw it, using as few words as possible and with little concern for political correctness. “Read the damn papers,” he once told a reporter asking him to explain the ketone ester’s significance. Although some were obviously put-off by his rough edges, others appreciated his straight-forward style. Those I interviewed for this book who were close to him, unquestionably loved him. Veech had no interest in fame or self-promotion: in fact, he felt that it was “unseemly for doctors to promote themselves,” insisting instead to be judged on the merit of his work alone.</p><p>There was another side to Dr. Veech. For those he loved he was gracious and thoughtful, as illustrated in a letter he wrote to the two sons of George Cahill upon Cahill’s death: “It is one of my proudest accomplishments to have been cited as a single co-author with Dr Cahill [on] one of his last publications. Dr. Cahill died at 85 while singing with two of his daughter’s Handel’s Hallelujah Chorus. I related this to a young student studying ketosis in athletes and she exclaimed ‘He must have gone immediately to heaven.’ That is an idea that all of us who knew him would share.”</p><p>The legacy of a scientist is a curious thing. All too often it is not fully appreciated until after they are gone. Many of the scientists in this book: Warburg, Krebs, and Mitchell were fortunate enough to have received recognition in the form of a Nobel Prize while still alive. Although Veech was never awarded a Nobel Prize, in the final analysis time may prove his research — his message — to be just as far-reaching. Perhaps even more profound than his predecessors. It is poetic, in a way, that the human side of this story synchs with Veech’s professional legacy. Warburg took a chance on Krebs — an inexperienced medical doctor at the time — as did Krebs with Veech. Together, in the end, their combined research wove a tapestry that transcended each of their individual careers and accomplishments. Although awards are given to individual scientists, advancements in science are never an individual achievement. It is a collective effort — a canvas that is filled-in over many generations. Science is the most altruistic and unselfish of human activities — an offering — the gift of free and accumulating knowledge. “If I have seen further it is by standing on the shoulders of giants,” said Isaac Newton. And like the transgenerational canvas of science, the first part of Veech’s professional legacy revealed our metabolism to be the same: reactions evolving into pathways, evolving over eons into a single, interconnected whole. A lattice of thousands of harmonically connected reactions controlled by the four “great” nucleotide coenzymes. The second pillar of Veech’s legacy was revealing the potent therapeutic qualities of the misunderstood and often maligned fuel molecule, beta-hydroxybutyrate. Operating through the four-nucleotide coenzymes, it alone could change the complexion of our entire metabolism in ways that were once thought immutable. The legacy of Veech will continue. The fascinating qualities of BHB are still being uncovered.</p><p>What does the future hold? What will health care look like in the generations to come? It might feel excruciatingly slow at times but the vector of human progress is always forward. As physics has taught us, this forward march of societal evolution is baked into the fabric of the universe. It is an extension of the order-seeking eruption of life itself. Gravity is the universal fountain-head of order. The flow of negative entropy from our sun that spurred the formation of life doesn’t stop there. Nature repeats patterns. Bear with me for a moment: Over three billion years ago life began as a self-replicating molecule. This evolved into a self-replicating cell, which in turn evolved into a self-replicating multicellular organism with individual cells performing tasks for a given system. Multicellular life is a collective, if you will, an economy of divided labor. Evolution is a march up a staircase of functionality; molecules to cells to multicellular organisms. Civilization, too, is repeating this same pattern, marching up this same staircase of functionality. We have gone from caves, to cities, to the industrial revolution, the internet revolution, artificial intelligence and up and up. Science is perhaps the pinnacle of this societal evolution — the universe peering into the innerworkings of itself.</p><p>We can <em>only </em>get better at medicine in the future — it is <em>writ large</em> in the universe. But today the flaws in our health care system are substantial and systemic and will be obvious to future generations. We spend enormous amounts of money overtreating with drugs, procedures and surgeries that don’t move the needle much on our overall health. Future generations will instead focus on primary, preventative care — health care in harmony with the laws of thermodynamics. Technology will track outcomes. More convenient, at-home blood tests will be developed that encourage engagement, sustainability and a continuum of care. Cell phone apps will store results, allowing for a much more convenient interface between patients and doctors. COVID-19 has hastened the inevitable change to more efficient health care delivery through telemedicine — a system that is more user friendly, leverages technology to remove friction and is better able to facilitate primary, preventive health care. In time, we will get better at warding off the chronic diseases of aging and lengthening our health span. This is not terribly complicated. It could be implemented now, but we first have to fix the horribly broken incentive structure of our current health care system. If one were able to patent a simple three or four day fast a handful of times per year and put it into pill form it could potentially be a billion-dollar blockbuster drug. Same with a well-executed ketogenic diet or a quality exogenous ketone supplement administered preventively at midlife or when the first signs insulin resistance surface. The potential benefits of ketosis are enormous — initiating a cascade of changes that effects our entire metabolism — the chemical motion that quantifies our perception of time and defines our health; the chemical motion that <em>is</em> our vital spark. But the good news is that none of us have to wait for the system to catch up. Each of us can be a health care system of one.</p><p>https:// youtu.be/ 116WSn2WRLs</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e9b2d110dbc3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[An Old Enemy in the Modern World]]></title>
            <link>https://travischristofferson.medium.com/an-old-enemy-in-the-modern-world-72096d55e7c7?source=rss-941fcad2145b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/72096d55e7c7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Travis Christofferson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Mar 2020 17:26:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-20T02:02:33.098Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A Brief Perspective on COVID-19</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/680/0*JBSbKgroWnHhjWl8.jpg" /></figure><p>The world is in a crisis, both here in America and abroad. A new virus has sparked a worldwide pandemic. The epidemiologists, (and Bill Gates) had been warning us that it was just a matter of when, not if. They were right.</p><p>Reliable information has been scarce. People everywhere are confused, anxious and exhausted. Governments are in crisis mode as the pandemic has spilled over into an economic calamity the likes of which are unprecedented. It feels like we are staring into an abyss.</p><p>But it helps to remember that the book of human history reads as a litany of difficult times that have been overcome. The 1918 influenza pandemic (Spanish flu) that was estimated to have killed as many as 80 million people was immediately followed by the roaring 20’s. We clawed our way out of the Great Depression only to be dragged into World War II. A massive, war-time effort to defeat the Germans was followed by the great post-war economic expansion and Baby Boom. Vietnam, the 70’s oil shock, the Cold War, the sub-prime financial crisis…We are rarely not dealing with something.</p><p>Here’s why I am optimistic.</p><p>This is not an existential threat. This is not a nebulous threat. This is a knowable threat, one that can be fought through collective effort, science and innovation. Already, we know what we are facing down to the level of its DNA sequence.</p><p>Consider an example: After hurricane Katrina hit the Gulf in 2005, oil production was shut down and the price of oil skyrocketed to over $100 per barrel, threatening the economy. The worldwide innovation that geared into motion was awe-inspiring. New technologies to deal with expensive oil came at breakneck speed. Exponential increases in the efficiency of solar and wind power generation quickly followed. New fracking technology allowed for the extraction of hard-to-get-at oil and gas. Electric cars inspired from the crisis are now competitive with combustion engine cars.</p><p>The initial panic from COVID-19 was predictable and justified. A pandemic from a new, exotic and deadly virus is terrifying. However, signs of the same innovation and collective effort that confronted challenges of the past are stirring. People are gathering their breath, rolling up their sleeves, getting creative, and beginning to work together to face the new virus. Ford, GM and Tesla are in talks to pivot manufacturing for much needed ventilators. A 3D-printer company in Italy has designed and printed 100 life-saving respirator valves in 24 hours for a hospital that had run out of them. The world’s biotechnology and pharmaceutical industry has turned its collective muscle toward vaccine development and treatments for the interim. Social distancing efforts are being initiated <em>en mass</em> by corporations and local governments. Grocery stores are setting aside times for the most vulnerable to shop safely. Some power companies have refrained from shutting off power for unpaid bills. Student and medical debt are being put on hold. We are mobilizing. COVID-19 is in our collective crosshairs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/637/0*9zOH2DXS16oyO7k0.jpg" /></figure><p>If history is any guide these types of collective efforts, born from dark times, spark the latent innovative potential within humanity. The small pox pandemic inspired Edward Jenner to invent vaccination. The darkest moment of World War II inspired the Manhattan Project. The Cold War took us to the moon. This time will be no different.</p><p>For sure this is a hard situation. But we will beat this by working together, remembering that the innovation and humanity on the other side will remain with us forever.</p><p>Expect the 20’s to be roaring again.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=72096d55e7c7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Optimal Human Diet?]]></title>
            <link>https://travischristofferson.medium.com/the-optimal-human-diet-c25aff33b0bd?source=rss-941fcad2145b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c25aff33b0bd</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Travis Christofferson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 25 Feb 2020 00:24:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-25T00:24:33.105Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The Controversial New Carnivore Diet is Rattling the Foundations of Dietary Doctrine</em></p><p>A recent documentary titled “The Game Changers” has once again ignited the perpetual debate about what we are supposed to eat. The well-funded documentary, produced by industry heavyweights James Cameron, Arnold Schwarzenegger, and Jackie Chan, asks what on-the-surface seems like a reasonable question: What is the “optimal” diet for human performance? The film crew follows elite Special Forces trainer and decorated UFC fighter, James Wilks, on his quest to answer this seemingly innocent question. Wilks travels a circuitous journey: from studying the diet of Roman gladiators all the way to a slew of contemporary studies. In the end, after citing a handful of elite vegan athletes, personal antidotes of eye-popping increases in his own strength and endurance, studies about the inflammatory molecules produced by meat consumption, studies of the <em>en vogue</em> microbiome and large-scale epidemiological studies, Wilks concludes that a diet composed of exclusively (or mostly) plants is what we, as humans, preform best on.</p><p>Once the doc dropped on Netflix the predictable scrum followed, with meat eaters from every side of the isle raising their forks in staunch<strong> </strong>protest. One such protester, the popular omnivore diet advocate, Chris Kresser, was invited on the Joe Rogan Podcast with the intent of “debunking” the claims made by Wilks in the documentary. After an almost 3-hour marathon of point-by-point debunking, Kresser had done his best to once-and-for-all bury the notion that a vegan diet is optimal for the vast majority of people. Kresser’s position: Meat and animal products are, in fact, good for us as part of a balanced diet.</p><p>Despite Kresser’s best effort, however, the dust up was just getting started. After Kresser’s debunking episode, in the spirit of fairness, Rogan offered to host a <em>mano-a-mano</em> debate between Wilks and Kresser. Wilks and Kresser agreed. From the gate Wilks came out swinging. Accusations were flung, credibility attacked, each one citing study after study to support their argument. In this end, and not surprisingly, it wasn’t clear who won the debate. And herein lies the rub: each side seemingly has ample data to back their argument up. The result is that any debate on the perfect diet tends to deteriorate into a confusing quagmire; with people, even the experts, galvanized with a religious like fervor; or worse, like the two political parties in this country, entirely unable to see the others sides point of view.</p><p>Yet, amidst the din two tiny stepping stones of common ground were found between Wilks and Kresser: first, the Standard American Diet is awful, and second, a new diet most have probably never heard of, called the Carnivore Diet, is a bad idea, too.</p><p>The carnivore diet leaves little room for misinterpretation. The basic tenet of the diet is shockingly simple: Eat animals.</p><p>Only animals.</p><p>Zero plants.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*irxy0Lh55s6TM84_.jpeg" /></figure><p>For someone on the carnivore diet a typical day might go like this: breakfast: 4 egg yolks, a few ounces of raw liver, half a pound of so of ground beef cooked with beef suet (fat), and a spoon full of salmon roe (eggs). Skip lunch. Dinner: a huge ribeye steak — meals that thumb-their-nose at every established dietary guideline. Indeed, the diet is so far to one extreme of the consensus guidelines that even the most open-minded dietitians bristle at the thought of people actually eating this way. In a 2018 article in <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2018/08/the-peterson-family-meat-cleanse/567613/"><em>The Atlantic</em>,</a> Jack Gilbert, the faculty director at the University of Chicago’s Microbiome Center and a professor of surgery, described the diet as “A terribly, terribly bad idea.”</p><p>The introduction of the carnivore diet for many dates back to the summer of 2018 and another Rogen podcast. Rogan’s guest was Canadian author and psychologist Jordan Peterson. Two hours and 40 minutes into their conversation Rogan asked him to talk about his curious diet. “I only eat beef, salt and water…and I never, ever cheat,” Peterson said. Peterson explained that it all started with his daughter, Mikhaila, who suffers from a particularly aggressive case of the autoimmune disease rheumatoid arthritis. The course of the disease had been relentless, affecting 40 joints, deteriorating her hip and ankle to the point they had to be replaced with artificial joints.</p><p>Jordon’s wife, Mikhaila’s mother, had always felt there was a dietary connection. When Mikhaila would eat oranges, for example, her symptoms would flare. And so, heeding the dietary clue, one by one, Mikhaila began to eliminated all the foods she suspected she was reacting to. In the end, she was only left with three things: beef, salt and water. “And then her symptoms began to drop, one by one…until she had no symptoms, zero,” said Peterson.</p><p>Mikhaila then urged her dad, who has suffered from severe depression and anxiety his entire life, to try the diet. It took a while to convince him, but once Petersen committed to the diet a strangely broad and seemingly unconnected list of problems began to resolve―including his crippling depression that he had had since childhood. Peterson gave an account of his improvements: I lost 50 lbs, better sleep, more energy, mental clarity, “I’m intellectually at my best, ” said Peterson, psoriasis cleared up, depression is gone, stronger, the floaters in his eyes went away, and his gingivitis (gum disease) that is purported to be irreversible, is gone. “It’s like, what the hell!?”</p><p>One expert thinks he knows why. His name is Paul Saladino. Saladino, an MD, has become the ambassador for the controversial diet. Saladino, too, became fascinated by the diet when he heard Jordan Peterson’s recount of his daughter’s dramatic recovery, and, for him, it connected his own dietary experimentation and the clinical observations that he had been documenting for years when his patients changed their diets. “<a href="http://blog.hvmn.com/podcast/episode-124-dr-paul-saladino">My first thought</a> was this is crazy. I think it’s most people’s thought, because we come up against so much conditioning when we’re talking about these types of diets and so much narrative connected with the idea that we’ve always been told that plants are so good for us. As I thought about it more and more, I thought, okay. This actually makes some sense.”</p><p>For Saladino, the rational for the carnivore diet starts with a theoretical, evolution-based argument. “Plants are not really on the earth to serve humans and they develop a lot of potentially toxic compounds to defend themselves from animals that are eating them,” says Saladino.</p><p>How our bodies process the compounds (polyphenols) in plants we are told are beneficial is telling. “Our body immediately recognizes them as foreign and detoxifies and then excretes them.” It’s Saladino’s contention that the compounds in plants that we have been beaten-over-the-head telling us that they are good for us; sulforaphane, resveratrol and curcumin, for example, are entirely incompatible with our uniquely human biochemistry. “This is like mac’s and PC’s, plant molecules don’t get used in human biochemistry,” says Saladino. “They are not our operating system; they don’t use the same language we are programed in.” His anthropological argument claims that plants, at best, served as a filler food that humans turned to in times of desperation. They were not our go-to food of choice. Given the choice between a freshly killed mammoth and a patch of berries or edible grass or some wild mushrooms, our ancestors would have chosen the former every time.</p><p>Notable biochemist, Bruce Ames, has spent a good portion of his career studying the compounds in plants and his research has revealed some <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2217210">surprising facts</a> about the plants we eat: They contain a surprisingly rich array of natural pesticides, so many, in fact, that the natural pesticides contained within the plants we eat far eclipse the man-made ones that health-conscious people pay extra to avoid. In fact, 99.99% of the toxic pesticides that a person consumes daily are produced naturally by the plants themselves. Ames says we consume anywhere from 5000 to 10000 different natural pesticides per day, many of which have been shown to cause cancer in laboratory animals just as well as the man-made pesticides we fear. Ames says the levels of natural carcinogens in the vegetables we eat are commonly thousands of times higher than the levels of synthetic pesticides.</p><p>Yet, even so, Ames doesn’t not advocate avoiding plants. Like most, he is convinced there is a net benefit. But according to Saladino’s research and clinical experience, this isn’t the case. While the toxins in plants may not cause clinically recognizable symptoms in a healthy person who exercises, they are doing nothing beneficial and may even be causing sub-clinical harm. And in someone with an autoimmune condition, like Mikhaila Peterson, the effects of the toxic compounds are much more pronounced. “Once these toxins are removed from the diet of someone with autoimmunity, miraculously, they began to heal.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/232/0*P3WL9NS762-IdQj4.jpeg" /><figcaption>Paul Ehrlich, Nobel Prize in Medicine, 1908</figcaption></figure><p>Autoimmunity has confused, fascinated and frustrated doctors for centuries. So-much-so that the question of the very existence of autoimmune disease remained open until the 1960’s. The confusion dates back to a series of experiments preformed in the late 1800’s by the famous, Nobel Prize winning German immunologist, Paul Ehrlich. In his laboratory, Ehrlich injected animals with blood from another species causing the immune system to launch an attack on the foreign blood. Yet when he injected animals with similar blood; either their own blood or the blood from the same species, the animal’s immune systems never formed auto-antibodies, or in other words, self-attacking antibodies. By 1901, Ehrlich was convinced there was enough proof to establish a new biological rule, which he termed <em>horror autotoxicus, </em>translated literally to mean the <em>horror of self-toxicity. </em>Ehrlich’s term described his new biological dictum: The inborn aversion the body has to immunological self-destruction.</p><p>Perhaps no one wanted to question the axiom of someone as respected as Ehrlich; or perhaps no one wanted to accept the revolting idea the body was indeed capable of turning on itself, whatever it was, researchers and physicians seemed to ignore the mounting evidence for autoimmunity well into the 20th century. By the 1960’s, however, enough evidence had accumulated that the existence of autoimmune disease could no longer be denied.</p><p>Today, the burden from autoimmune disease is enormous. <a href="https://www.niehs.nih.gov/health/topics/conditions/autoimmune/index.cfm">The N.I.H estimates </a>more that 24 million American suffer from one of 80 known autoimmune diseases. The American Autoimmune Related Diseases Association (AARDA) thinks the NIH numbers don’t reflect the true burden because the N.I.H underestimates the number of diseases that are autoimmune in nature. The <a href="https://www.aarda.org/diseaselist/">AARDA website</a> lists more than 100 autoimmune diseases and claims that once accounted for, the number of afflicted Americans could rise as high as 50 million. One thing everyone agrees on, however, is that for many postulated reasons, (diet, antibiotics, toxins) the rate of westerners with autoimmunity is rising at a rapid clip.</p><p>Still today, the exact pathological events that lead to autoimmunity remain unknown, yet some tantalizing clues have recently emerged. Most of these clues point to the gut as “ground zero” for autoimmunity to develop. Researchers have found that the microbiomes of people with autoimmune disease are often different from the microbiomes of healthy people, a condition loosely defined as <em>dysbiosis</em>. Dysbiosis occurs when the tenuous harmony of the trillions of microorganisms living in our gut is somehow disturbed. Many researchers believe the upshot of dysbiosis is inflammation, which over time corrodes the integrity of the intestinal wall, rendering it permeable to all kinds of debris including bacteria, a condition commonly referred to as “leaky-gut.” Under this scenario, all hell can break loose. The immune system, just doing its job, attacks the plant toxins or even bacteria crossing the now porous intestinal wall into the blood stream, and if the sites (called antigens) on the plant toxins (gluten, for example) or bacterial membrane look like, or “mimic” the antigens within our own bodies, it sets in motion a cascade of events known as “cross-reactivity.” The end result of cross-reactivity is <em>horror autotoxicus</em> — the immune system fooled into attacking itself.</p><p>Given what we know about the autoimmunity it’s easy to speculate about the therapeutic effect Saladino commonly sees once patients with autoimmunity commits to a carnivore diet: Once all the toxic compounds stoking inflammation are removed and the intestinal wall is finally able to heal thus preventing cross-reactivity, the patients began to feel better.</p><p>Frustratingly, conventional medicine has few good treatments for autoimmunity―with most treatments just addressing symptoms―certainly nothing approaching a cure. As a consequence, many victims are left searching for anything that might alleviate the corrosive disease course. Not surprisingly, given the reach of Rogan’s podcast (190 million downloads per month), many of those suffering from an autoimmune condition themselves, or their loved ones, heard Jordan Peterson recount the story of his daughters dramatic, diet-driven remission from rheumatoid arthritis. The miraculously claims made by Peterson from his strange diet instantly captivated the public’s attention.</p><p>“The diet exploded in popularity shortly after,” recalls Saladino.</p><p>Exploded indeed. Social media groups dedicated to the diet popped up, YouTube videos, blogs; hundreds or perhaps even thousands of those suffering from a spectrum of autoimmune disease began experimenting with the carnivore diet and sharing their results online.</p><p>For those told that Peterson’s evidence is entirely anecdotal; those that have suffered for years or even decades with autoimmunity, the calculus was easy: there is little to lose―perhaps other than a slightly increased grocery bill―from trying the carnivore diet.</p><p>Although far from a controlled clinical trial, after reading through the online personal testimonies, even the most skeptical physician would be hard-pressed to dismiss the effects of the diet outright. Many recount years of gut-wrenching autoimmune symptoms that began to improve once they fully adapted to the carnivore diet. Although anecdotal, one is struck by the consistency of the accounts. “When I read people’s accounts of trying this diet, it’s almost universally positive,” noted Rogan.</p><p>Yet, beyond the eye-brow raising claims being made about the carnivore diet’s ability to invoke enduring remissions in some people with autoimmune issue, Saladino’s claims extend further. He makes the bold claim that by avoiding plants and adopting a well-thought-out carnivore diet, eating the animal from nose-to-tail, including organ meats, collagen from connective tissue, and suet (beef fat), in addition to muscle meat; and including other animal products like egg yolks, fish, or fish eggs, for example, provides humans with the exact nutrients, in the exact amounts and ratios, to optimize human physiology. In other words, the “optimal” human diet. “It’s how we are supposed to eat,” says Saladino. If this supposition is true, it would explain why someone like Jordan Peterson would experience a litany of non-autoimmune-related problems resolving, including his claim that he was “intellectually at my best,” and “stronger” on the diet. “I see it in my patients all the time,” says Saladino.</p><p>When defending the carnivore diet, Saladino notes, one issue seems to come up more than the others: fiber. What about it? A carnivore diet, by definition, is entirely devoid of fiber. “Fiber is a fairy tale,” says Saladino.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*M7ltSl8yJpJhGnD0.jpeg" /><figcaption>Burkitt, HarperCollins Publishers, 1979</figcaption></figure><p>The notion that fiber is good for us goes back to an Irish physician named Denis Burkitt. After traveling to Africa, Burkitt noted that the Africans ate more fiber and had less diverticulosis. Burkitt then stitched the two observations together, making the bold claim that fiber was protective against diverticulosis in addition to a range of other gastroenterological diseases. His message was widely disseminated with his 1979 internationally best-selling book <em>Don’t Forget Fibre in your Diet.</em></p><p>“Except that is not what we see in clinical studies at all. In fact, we see the opposite.” <a href="https://www.webmd.com/digestive-disorders/news/20120123/fiber-may-not-prevent-diverticular-disease#1">The studies </a>Saladino refers to show that the people that eat the <em>most</em> fiber have the <em>most</em> diverticulosis, and vice versa. And with regard to cancer, Saladino says there is <a href="https://www.webmd.com/colorectal-cancer/news/20051213/fiber-not-protective-for-colon-cancer#1">no evidence</a> that fiber reduces your chances of developing colon cancer. “What we’re seeing here is quite contrary to what people have been told,” he says. Additionally, many studies show that the removal of fiber results in less constipation and bloating, two very ubiquitous complaints. And what about the microbiome? “No one really knows what a “good” microbiome is,” says Saladino. Indeed, for many who try the carnivore diet, the proof is in the pudding. One of the first things devotees of the diet seem to observe is improved digestion, with all the nagging problems of bloating, constipation and excessive gas resolving over time.</p><p>To be sure, to make the heretical claim that the carnivore diet is the optimal human diet is merely controversial is an understatement. Most dieticians vehemently oppose the diet, just like Wilks and Kresser do. Most of the opposition hinges on a single question: How does one explain the mountains of data suggesting plants have a positive effect on human health? For example, the so-called French Paradox that links the polyphenols in red wine to cardiovascular health; the numerous studies showing that compounds in green tea can ward off dementia and possible Alzheimer’s; the ability of cruciferous veggies to reduce inflammation and reduce cancer risk.</p><p>The answer may lie in a fascinating biological phenomenon called <em>hormesis</em>. Hormesis is a term that describes how biological organisms respond to stressors. At low-doses, stressors like exercise induce positive health effects. However, researchers have shown that the hormetic response is bi-phasic, meaning as the dose of a stressor increases the effect turns from positive to negative. For example, <a href="https://www.webmd.com/fitness-exercise/news/20140401/too-much-running-tied-to-shorter-lifespan-studies-find#1">research has shown</a> that couch-potatoes and high-mileage runners both tend to have shorter lifespans than moderate runners. The hormetic response explains why studies show that something like ethanol in moderate amounts can have a positive effect but in excessive amounts a negative effect. This effect holds true in experimental models, too. When low doses of ethanol are given to the nematode, <em>C. elegans</em>, the hormetic effect resulted in an eye-popping 50% increase in lifespan. The hormetic effect is so pervasive in biological systems that it even holds true to a stressor like <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3057636/">radon gas,</a> a radioactive gas that when breathed in breaks down into lead within our lungs. Nothing about radon gas sounds good, yet at low doses radon gas appears to reduce the risk of developing lung cancer. However, once a certain threshold is reached, it becomes toxic.</p><p>And here is where the nuance lies, and perhaps the source of conflicting data that seems to muddy the waters of every debate on the optimal human diet. Ames and others (Dr. Steven Gundry, <em>The Plant Paradox</em>) have clearly established that plants are rife with toxins, yet, perversely, due to the strange biological phenomenon of hormesis, certain doses of theses toxins may be beneficial to certain individuals.</p><p>Because of hormesis, it’s easy to imagine how the data Wilks cites supporting vegetable consumption comes to be. The majority of Americans, eating the standard American diet and exercising little, or not at all, would likely benefit from the hormetic response induced by eating the toxins found in vegetables.</p><p>Yet in others, those with autoimmunity or other conditions, (Saladino thinks many more common aliments could have autoimmune origins, even many psychiatric disorders including depression) plant toxins could possibly push these people past the tipping point where the hormetic curve turns negative.</p><p>Saladino, who treats a lot of people with autoimmunity and other conditions, often sees an astonishing clinical benefit simply by removing plants from their diet.</p><p>Perhaps the take home lesson is this: Due to the phenomenon of hormesis, plants could have a dual nature, they could be both good and bad, depending on context and the individual — leaving those who seek to find a once-size-fits-all, “optimal” human diet on a quixotic mission that is destine to fail.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*iKOL0FM_OhyH-QpC.jpeg" /><figcaption>Recon 2, Map of Human Metabolism</figcaption></figure><p>But Saladino humbly disagrees that we have to concede that easily. He is convinced there is a way-of-living (diet and lifestyle) that optimizes human metabolism giving us peak mental and physical health. Saladino contends that a nose-to-tail carnivore diet <em>is</em> the optimal human diet. But it comes with a caveat: As long as those eating a carnivore diet are willing to seek the hormetic benefits that plants may provide from other sources, like exercise, for example. Saladino argues that when a person eats a carnivore diet and exercises regularly then all the inputs the body is receiving from food and hormetic stimuli are in perfect harmony with our “operating system” without the deleterious effects of plant toxins. In other words, all the good with none of the bad.</p><p>“There is still this pervasive notion that plants have unique compounds which are somehow valuable to humans in a singular way. I would argue that is not true. There are better ways to trigger hormesis than ingesting these toxic plant molecules,” says Saladino. “They may have a hormetic effect, but then they often do other things which are detrimental to our bodies because our bodies do not recognize them.”</p><p>It hard to dismiss his point outright. We seem to be saturated with media reports of studies touting the health benefits derived from ingesting the compounds in plants but rarely hear the negative studies. For example, sulforaphane, a sulfur-rich compound isolated from cruciferous vegetables like broccoli and cauliflower is lauded for its health benefits, yet can cause hypothyroidism in even small amounts. One would be hard-pressed to find negative articles about curcumin, the bright yellow compound isolated from turmeric, yet Saladino says that in over 120 randomized, placebo-controlled trials it has never shown a benefit. The molecule is “a fooler” he says. Studies in petri dishes lead people to believe it might have a benefit but these benefits just don’t extrapolate to the complexity of the body. Once curcumin is ingested, it is barely absorbed (1%) and the tiny fraction that is absorbed is recognized as foreign and immediately shunted through detoxification pathways and excreted. Worse, there are many lesser-known studies suggesting that the curcumin that is absorbed can have toxic effects. Saladino contends we are much better off avoiding these supplements, eating a carnivore diet, and triggering hormesis with the things that our ancestors did, things like sunlight, cold and heat exposure, and exercise.</p><p>The never-ending dietary debate comically separates humans from the rest of the animal kingdom. No other species on the planet is confronted by the question of what to eat. No wild species gets to <em>choose</em> a diet. For every species, except us, even the <em>concept</em> of a diet is an absurdity — vegan, vegetarian, paleo, Akins, (I hear keto is all-the-rage with giraffes right now.) It goes without saying that each wild species eats within the biological niche that millions of years of evolution has matched them to. Indeed, some of the evidence for Saladino’s anthropological argument in support of carnivorism might be right in front of our eyes. If one takes a quick visual survey across the animal kingdom virtually every wild species looks healthy — it’s impossible to find an obese lion or chimpanzee or deer in their natural habitat. Conversely, as species, we do seem curiously sickly: obesity, diabetes, depression, and autoimmunity are alarmingly becoming the norm. If Saladino is right, it may offer a singular explanation for our sorry state.</p><p>It’s ironic that the one feature that sets us apart from the animal kingdom, our big brains, may be entirely responsible for divorcing us from our “optimal” diet. Agricultural technology has continuously improved crop yields to cheaply feed humanity, providing us with year-round fruits and vegetables, processed seed oils, high fructose corn syrup, and cheap carbohydrates from grains that didn’t exist until very recently in evolutionary terms. We have constant access to the plant toxins that were at best seasonal in our distant past, or didn’t exist at all.</p><p>If anything can polarize people as much as politics it’s the debate on what to put in their mouths. To be sure, the carnivore diet is the new far-left (or far-right) candidate in the dietary spectrum. With experts already labeling it from “a terribly, terribly bad idea” to “the optimal human diet,” don’t expect a consensus anytime soon. But the good thing about a diet, as opposed to politics, is that it is democratized down to the level of the individual. Anyone of us, at any time, is free to try any diet of our choosing and see what happens.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c25aff33b0bd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Optimal Human Diet?]]></title>
            <link>https://travischristofferson.medium.com/the-optimal-human-diet-40654a8c78f1?source=rss-941fcad2145b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/40654a8c78f1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[autoimmune-disease]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fitness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[longevity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Travis Christofferson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 16 Feb 2020 20:16:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-17T22:54:46.099Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The Controversial New Carnivore Diet is Rattling the Foundations of Dietary Doctrine</em></p><p>A recent documentary titled “The Game Changers” has once again ignited the perpetual debate about what we are supposed to eat. The well-funded documentary, produced by industry heavyweights James Cameron, Arnold Schwarzenegger, and Jackie Chan, asks what on-the-surface seems like a reasonable question: What is the “optimal” diet for human performance? The film crew follows elite Special Forces trainer and decorated UFC fighter, James Wilks, on his quest to answer this seemingly innocent question. Wilks travels a circuitous journey: from studying the diet of Roman gladiators all the way to a slew of contemporary studies. In the end, after citing a handful of elite vegan athletes, personal antidotes of eye-popping increases in his own strength and endurance, studies about the inflammatory molecules produced by meat consumption, studies of the <em>en vogue</em> microbiome and large-scale epidemiological studies, Wilks concludes that a diet composed of exclusively (or mostly) plants is what we, as humans, preform best on.</p><p>Once the doc dropped on Netflix the predictable scrum followed, with meat eaters from every side of the isle raising their forks in staunch<strong> </strong>protest. One such protester, the popular omnivore diet advocate, Chris Kresser, was invited on the Joe Rogan Podcast with the intent of “debunking” the claims made by Wilks in the documentary. After an almost 3-hour marathon of point-by-point debunking, Kresser had done his best to once-and-for-all bury the notion that a vegan diet is optimal for the vast majority of people. Kresser’s position: Meat and animal products are, in fact, good for us as part of a balanced diet.</p><p>Despite Kresser’s best effort, however, the dust up was just getting started. After Kresser’s debunking episode, in the spirit of fairness, Rogan offered to host a <em>mano-a-mano</em> debate between Wilks and Kresser. Wilks and Kresser agreed. From the gate Wilks came out swinging. Accusations were flung, credibility attacked, each one citing study after study to support their argument. In this end, and not surprisingly, it wasn’t clear who won the debate. And herein lies the rub: each side seemingly has ample data to back their argument up. The result is that any debate on the perfect diet tends to deteriorate into a confusing quagmire; with people, even the experts, galvanized with a religious like fervor; or worse, like the two political parties in this country, entirely unable to see the others sides point of view.</p><p>Yet, amidst the din two tiny stepping stones of common ground were found between Wilks and Kresser: first, the Standard American Diet is awful, and second, a new diet most have probably never heard of, called the Carnivore Diet, is a bad idea, too.</p><p>The carnivore diet leaves little room for misinterpretation. The basic tenet of the diet is shockingly simple: Eat animals.</p><p>Only animals.</p><p>Zero plants.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JehXKNAJf1y15lUiC3Ju-A.jpeg" /></figure><p>For someone on the carnivore diet a typical day might go like this: breakfast: 4 egg yolks, a few ounces of raw liver, half a pound of so of ground beef cooked with beef suet (fat), and a spoon full of salmon roe (eggs). Skip lunch. Dinner: a huge ribeye steak — meals that thumb-their-nose at every established dietary guideline. Indeed, the diet is so far to one extreme of the consensus guidelines that even the most open-minded dietitians bristle at the thought of people actually eating this way. In a 2018 article in <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2018/08/the-peterson-family-meat-cleanse/567613/"><em>The Atlantic</em>,</a> Jack Gilbert, the faculty director at the University of Chicago’s Microbiome Center and a professor of surgery, described the diet as “A terribly, terribly bad idea.”</p><p>The introduction of the carnivore diet for many dates back to the summer of 2018 and another Rogen podcast. Rogan’s guest was Canadian author and psychologist Jordan Peterson. Two hours and 40 minutes into their conversation Rogan asked him to talk about his curious diet. “I only eat beef, salt and water…and I never, ever cheat,” Peterson said. Peterson explained that it all started with his daughter, Mikhaila, who suffers from a particularly aggressive case of the autoimmune disease rheumatoid arthritis. The course of the disease had been relentless, affecting 40 joints, deteriorating her hip and ankle to the point they had to be replaced with artificial joints.</p><p>Jordon’s wife, Mikhaila’s mother, had always felt there was a dietary connection. When Mikhaila would eat oranges, for example, her symptoms would flare. And so, heeding the dietary clue, one by one, Mikhaila began to eliminated all the foods she suspected she was reacting to. In the end, she was only left with three things: beef, salt and water. “And then her symptoms began to drop, one by one…until she had no symptoms, zero,” said Peterson.</p><p>Mikhaila then urged her dad, who has suffered from severe depression and anxiety his entire life, to try the diet. It took a while to convince him, but once Petersen committed to the diet a strangely broad and seemingly unconnected list of problems began to resolve―including his crippling depression that he had had since childhood. Peterson gave an account of his improvements: I lost 50 lbs, better sleep, more energy, mental clarity, “I’m intellectually at my best, ” said Peterson, psoriasis cleared up, depression is gone, stronger, the floaters in his eyes went away, and his gingivitis (gum disease) that is purported to be irreversible, is gone. “It’s like, what the hell!?”</p><p>One expert thinks he knows why. His name is Paul Saladino. Saladino, an MD, has become the ambassador for the controversial diet. Saladino, too, became fascinated by the diet when he heard Jordan Peterson’s recount of his daughter’s dramatic recovery, and, for him, it connected his own dietary experimentation and the clinical observations that he had been documenting for years when his patients changed their diets. “<a href="http://blog.hvmn.com/podcast/episode-124-dr-paul-saladino">My first thought</a> was this is crazy. I think it’s most people’s thought, because we come up against so much conditioning when we’re talking about these types of diets and so much narrative connected with the idea that we’ve always been told that plants are so good for us. As I thought about it more and more, I thought, okay. This actually makes some sense.”</p><p>For Saladino, the rational for the carnivore diet starts with a theoretical, evolution-based argument. “Plants are not really on the earth to serve humans and they develop a lot of potentially toxic compounds to defend themselves from animals that are eating them,” says Saladino.</p><p>How our bodies process the compounds (polyphenols) in plants we are told are beneficial is telling. “Our body immediately recognizes them as foreign and detoxifies and then excretes them.” It’s Saladino’s contention that the compounds in plants that we have been beaten-over-the-head telling us that they are good for us; sulforaphane, resveratrol and curcumin, for example, are entirely incompatible with our uniquely human biochemistry. “This is like mac’s and PC’s, plant molecules don’t get used in human biochemistry,” says Saladino. “They are not our operating system; they don’t use the same language we are programed in.” His anthropological argument claims that plants, at best, served as a filler food that humans turned to in times of desperation. They were not our go-to food of choice. Given the choice between a freshly killed mammoth and a patch of berries or edible grass or some wild mushrooms, our ancestors would have chosen the former every time.</p><p>Notable biochemist, Bruce Ames, has spent a good portion of his career studying the compounds in plants and his research has revealed some <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2217210">surprising facts</a> about the plants we eat: They contain a surprisingly rich array of natural pesticides, so many, in fact, that the natural pesticides contained within the plants we eat far eclipse the man-made ones that health-conscious people pay extra to avoid. In fact, 99.99% of the toxic pesticides that a person consumes daily are produced naturally by the plants themselves. Ames says we consume anywhere from 5000 to 10000 different natural pesticides per day, many of which have been shown to cause cancer in laboratory animals just as well as the man-made pesticides we fear. Ames says the levels of natural carcinogens in the vegetables we eat are commonly thousands of times higher than the levels of synthetic pesticides.</p><p>Yet, even so, Ames doesn’t not advocate avoiding plants. Like most, he is convinced there is a net benefit. But according to Saladino’s research and clinical experience, this isn’t the case. While the toxins in plants may not cause clinically recognizable symptoms in a healthy person who exercises, they are doing nothing beneficial and may even be causing sub-clinical harm. And in someone with an autoimmune condition, like Mikhaila Peterson, the effects of the toxic compounds are much more pronounced. “Once these toxins are removed from the diet of someone with autoimmunity, miraculously, they began to heal.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/232/1*aWpKRrGOyawtb8cM_OtYTA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Paul Ehrlich, Nobel Prize in Medicine, 1908</figcaption></figure><p>Autoimmunity has confused, fascinated and frustrated doctors for centuries. So-much-so that the question of the very existence of autoimmune disease remained open until the 1960’s. The confusion dates back to a series of experiments preformed in the late 1800’s by the famous, Nobel Prize winning German immunologist, Paul Ehrlich. In his laboratory, Ehrlich injected animals with blood from another species causing the immune system to launch an attack on the foreign blood. Yet when he injected animals with similar blood; either their own blood or the blood from the same species, the animal’s immune systems never formed auto-antibodies, or in other words, self-attacking antibodies. By 1901, Ehrlich was convinced there was enough proof to establish a new biological rule, which he termed <em>horror autotoxicus, </em>translated literally to mean the <em>horror of self-toxicity. </em>Ehrlich’s term described his new biological dictum: The inborn aversion the body has to immunological self-destruction.</p><p>Perhaps no one wanted to question the axiom of someone as respected as Ehrlich; or perhaps no one wanted to accept the revolting idea the body was indeed capable of turning on itself, whatever it was, researchers and physicians seemed to ignore the mounting evidence for autoimmunity well into the 20th century. By the 1960’s, however, enough evidence had accumulated that the existence of autoimmune disease could no longer be denied.</p><p>Today, the burden from autoimmune disease is enormous. <a href="https://www.niehs.nih.gov/health/topics/conditions/autoimmune/index.cfm">The N.I.H estimates </a>more that 24 million American suffer from one of 80 known autoimmune diseases. The American Autoimmune Related Diseases Association (AARDA) thinks the NIH numbers don’t reflect the true burden because the N.I.H underestimates the number of diseases that are autoimmune in nature. The <a href="https://www.aarda.org/diseaselist/">AARDA website</a> lists more than 100 autoimmune diseases and claims that once accounted for, the number of afflicted Americans could rise as high as 50 million. One thing everyone agrees on, however, is that for many postulated reasons, (diet, antibiotics, toxins) the rate of westerners with autoimmunity is rising at a rapid clip.</p><p>Still today, the exact pathological events that lead to autoimmunity remain unknown, yet some tantalizing clues have recently emerged. Most of these clues point to the gut as “ground zero” for autoimmunity to develop. Researchers have found that the microbiomes of people with autoimmune disease are often different from the microbiomes of healthy people, a condition loosely defined as <em>dysbiosis</em>. Dysbiosis occurs when the tenuous harmony of the trillions of microorganisms living in our gut is somehow disturbed. Many researchers believe the upshot of dysbiosis is inflammation, which over time corrodes the integrity of the intestinal wall, rendering it permeable to all kinds of debris including bacteria, a condition commonly referred to as “leaky-gut.” Under this scenario, all hell can break loose. The immune system, just doing its job, attacks the plant toxins or even bacteria crossing the now porous intestinal wall into the blood stream, and if the sites (called antigens) on the plant toxins (gluten, for example) or bacterial membrane look like, or “mimic” the antigens within our own bodies, it sets in motion a cascade of events known as “cross-reactivity.” The end result of cross-reactivity is <em>horror autotoxicus</em> — the immune system fooled into attacking itself.</p><p>Given what we know about the autoimmunity it’s easy to speculate about the therapeutic effect Saladino commonly sees once patients with autoimmunity commits to a carnivore diet: Once all the toxic compounds stoking inflammation are removed and the intestinal wall is finally able to heal thus preventing cross-reactivity, the patients began to feel better.</p><p>Frustratingly, conventional medicine has few good treatments for autoimmunity―with most treatments just addressing symptoms―certainly nothing approaching a cure. As a consequence, many victims are left searching for anything that might alleviate the corrosive disease course. Not surprisingly, given the reach of Rogan’s podcast (190 million downloads per month), many of those suffering from an autoimmune condition themselves, or their loved ones, heard Jordan Peterson recount the story of his daughters dramatic, diet-driven remission from rheumatoid arthritis. The miraculously claims made by Peterson from his strange diet instantly captivated the public’s attention.</p><p>“The diet exploded in popularity shortly after,” recalls Saladino.</p><p>Exploded indeed. Social media groups dedicated to the diet popped up, YouTube videos, blogs; hundreds or perhaps even thousands of those suffering from a spectrum of autoimmune disease began experimenting with the carnivore diet and sharing their results online.</p><p>For those told that Peterson’s evidence is entirely anecdotal; those that have suffered for years or even decades with autoimmunity, the calculus was easy: there is little to lose―perhaps other than a slightly increased grocery bill―from trying the carnivore diet.</p><p>Although far from a controlled clinical trial, after reading through the online personal testimonies, even the most skeptical physician would be hard-pressed to dismiss the effects of the diet outright. Many recount years of gut-wrenching autoimmune symptoms that began to improve once they fully adapted to the carnivore diet. Although anecdotal, one is struck by the consistency of the accounts. “When I read people’s accounts of trying this diet, it’s almost universally positive,” noted Rogan.</p><p>Yet, beyond the eye-brow raising claims being made about the carnivore diet’s ability to invoke enduring remissions in some people with autoimmune issue, Saladino’s claims extend further. He makes the bold claim that by avoiding plants and adopting a well-thought-out carnivore diet, eating the animal from nose-to-tail, including organ meats, collagen from connective tissue, and suet (beef fat), in addition to muscle meat; and including other animal products like egg yolks, fish, or fish eggs, for example, provides humans with the exact nutrients, in the exact amounts and ratios, to optimize human physiology. In other words, the “optimal” human diet. “It’s how we are supposed to eat,” says Saladino. If this supposition is true, it would explain why someone like Jordan Peterson would experience a litany of non-autoimmune-related problems resolving, including his claim that he was “intellectually at my best,” and “stronger” on the diet. “I see it in my patients all the time,” says Saladino.</p><p>When defending the carnivore diet, Saladino notes, one issue seems to come up more than the others: fiber. What about it? A carnivore diet, by definition, is entirely devoid of fiber. “Fiber is a fairy tale,” says Saladino.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*_ILbdE8vvmOs1T8yu4ccEQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Burkitt, HarperCollins Publishers, 1979</figcaption></figure><p>The notion that fiber is good for us goes back to an Irish physician named Denis Burkitt. After traveling to Africa, Burkitt noted that the Africans ate more fiber and had less diverticulosis. Burkitt then stitched the two observations together, making the bold claim that fiber was protective against diverticulosis in addition to a range of other gastroenterological diseases. His message was widely disseminated with his 1979 internationally best-selling book <em>Don’t Forget Fibre in your Diet.</em></p><p>“Except that is not what we see in clinical studies at all. In fact, we see the opposite.” <a href="https://www.webmd.com/digestive-disorders/news/20120123/fiber-may-not-prevent-diverticular-disease#1">The studies </a>Saladino refers to show that the people that eat the <em>most</em> fiber have the <em>most</em> diverticulosis, and vice versa. And with regard to cancer, Saladino says there is <a href="https://www.webmd.com/colorectal-cancer/news/20051213/fiber-not-protective-for-colon-cancer#1">no evidence</a> that fiber reduces your chances of developing colon cancer. “What we’re seeing here is quite contrary to what people have been told,” he says. Additionally, many studies show that the removal of fiber results in less constipation and bloating, two very ubiquitous complaints. And what about the microbiome? “No one really knows what a “good” microbiome is,” says Saladino. Indeed, for many who try the carnivore diet, the proof is in the pudding. One of the first things devotees of the diet seem to observe is improved digestion, with all the nagging problems of bloating, constipation and excessive gas resolving over time.</p><p>To be sure, to make the heretical claim that the carnivore diet is the optimal human diet is merely controversial is an understatement. Most dieticians vehemently oppose the diet, just like Wilks and Kresser do. Most of the opposition hinges on a single question: How does one explain the mountains of data suggesting plants have a positive effect on human health? For example, the so-called French Paradox that links the polyphenols in red wine to cardiovascular health; the numerous studies showing that compounds in green tea can ward off dementia and possible Alzheimer’s; the ability of cruciferous veggies to reduce inflammation and reduce cancer risk.</p><p>The answer may lie in a fascinating biological phenomenon called <em>hormesis</em>. Hormesis is a term that describes how biological organisms respond to stressors. At low-doses, stressors like exercise induce positive health effects. However, researchers have shown that the hormetic response is bi-phasic, meaning as the dose of a stressor increases the effect turns from positive to negative. For example, <a href="https://www.webmd.com/fitness-exercise/news/20140401/too-much-running-tied-to-shorter-lifespan-studies-find#1">research has shown</a> that couch-potatoes and high-mileage runners both tend to have shorter lifespans than moderate runners. The hormetic response explains why studies show that something like ethanol in moderate amounts can have a positive effect but in excessive amounts a negative effect. This effect holds true in experimental models, too. When low doses of ethanol are given to the nematode, <em>C. elegans</em>, the hormetic effect resulted in an eye-popping 50% increase in lifespan. The hormetic effect is so pervasive in biological systems that it even holds true to a stressor like <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3057636/">radon gas,</a> a radioactive gas that when breathed in breaks down into lead within our lungs. Nothing about radon gas sounds good, yet at low doses radon gas appears to reduce the risk of developing lung cancer. However, once a certain threshold is reached, it becomes toxic.</p><p>And here is where the nuance lies, and perhaps the source of conflicting data that seems to muddy the waters of every debate on the optimal human diet. Ames and others (Dr. Steven Gundry, <em>The Plant Paradox</em>) have clearly established that plants are rife with toxins, yet, perversely, due to the strange biological phenomenon of hormesis, certain doses of theses toxins may be beneficial to certain individuals.</p><p>Because of hormesis, it’s easy to imagine how the data Wilks cites supporting vegetable consumption comes to be. The majority of Americans, eating the standard American diet and exercising little, or not at all, would likely benefit from the hormetic response induced by eating the toxins found in vegetables.</p><p>Yet in others, those with autoimmunity or other conditions, (Saladino thinks many more common aliments could have autoimmune origins, even many psychiatric disorders including depression) plant toxins could possibly push these people past the tipping point where the hormetic curve turns negative.</p><p>Saladino, who treats a lot of people with autoimmunity and other conditions, often sees an astonishing clinical benefit simply by removing plants from their diet.</p><p>Perhaps the take home lesson is this: Due to the phenomenon of hormesis, plants could have a dual nature, they could be both good and bad, depending on context and the individual — leaving those who seek to find a once-size-fits-all, “optimal” human diet on a quixotic mission that is destine to fail.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*o6HphwWfQ9w83xQymTqArw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Recon 2, Map of Human Metabolism</figcaption></figure><p>But Saladino humbly disagrees that we have to concede that easily. He is convinced there is a way-of-living (diet and lifestyle) that optimizes human metabolism giving us peak mental and physical health. Saladino contends that a nose-to-tail carnivore diet <em>is</em> the optimal human diet. But it comes with a caveat: As long as those eating a carnivore diet are willing to seek the hormetic benefits that plants may provide from other sources, like exercise, for example. Saladino argues that when a person eats a carnivore diet and exercises regularly then all the inputs the body is receiving from food and hormetic stimuli are in perfect harmony with our “operating system” without the deleterious effects of plant toxins. In other words, all the good with none of the bad.</p><p>“There is still this pervasive notion that plants have unique compounds which are somehow valuable to humans in a singular way. I would argue that is not true. There are better ways to trigger hormesis than ingesting these toxic plant molecules,” says Saladino. “They may have a hormetic effect, but then they often do other things which are detrimental to our bodies because our bodies do not recognize them.”</p><p>It hard to dismiss his point outright. We seem to be saturated with media reports of studies touting the health benefits derived from ingesting the compounds in plants but rarely hear the negative studies. For example, sulforaphane, a sulfur-rich compound isolated from cruciferous vegetables like broccoli and cauliflower is lauded for its health benefits, yet can cause hypothyroidism in even small amounts. One would be hard-pressed to find negative articles about curcumin, the bright yellow compound isolated from turmeric, yet Saladino says that in over 120 randomized, placebo-controlled trials it has never shown a benefit. The molecule is “a fooler” he says. Studies in petri dishes lead people to believe it might have a benefit but these benefits just don’t extrapolate to the complexity of the body. Once curcumin is ingested, it is barely absorbed (1%) and the tiny fraction that is absorbed is recognized as foreign and immediately shunted through detoxification pathways and excreted. Worse, there are many lesser-known studies suggesting that the curcumin that is absorbed can have toxic effects. Saladino contends we are much better off avoiding these supplements, eating a carnivore diet, and triggering hormesis with the things that our ancestors did, things like sunlight, cold and heat exposure, and exercise.</p><p>The never-ending dietary debate comically separates humans from the rest of the animal kingdom. No other species on the planet is confronted by the question of what to eat. No wild species gets to <em>choose</em> a diet. For every species, except us, even the <em>concept</em> of a diet is an absurdity — vegan, vegetarian, paleo, Akins, (I hear keto is all-the-rage with giraffes right now.) It goes without saying that each wild species eats within the biological niche that millions of years of evolution has matched them to. Indeed, some of the evidence for Saladino’s anthropological argument in support of carnivorism might be right in front of our eyes. If one takes a quick visual survey across the animal kingdom virtually every wild species looks healthy — it’s impossible to find an obese lion or chimpanzee or deer in their natural habitat. Conversely, as species, we do seem curiously sickly: obesity, diabetes, depression, and autoimmunity are alarmingly becoming the norm. If Saladino is right, it may offer a singular explanation for our sorry state.</p><p>It’s ironic that the one feature that sets us apart from the animal kingdom, our big brains, may be entirely responsible for divorcing us from our “optimal” diet. Agricultural technology has continuously improved crop yields to cheaply feed humanity, providing us with year-round fruits and vegetables, processed seed oils, high fructose corn syrup, and cheap carbohydrates from grains that didn’t exist until very recently in evolutionary terms. We have constant access to the plant toxins that were at best seasonal in our distant past, or didn’t exist at all.</p><p>If anything can polarize people as much as politics it’s the debate on what to put in their mouths. To be sure, the carnivore diet is the new far-left (or far-right) candidate in the dietary spectrum. With experts already labeling it from “a terribly, terribly bad idea” to “the optimal human diet,” don’t expect a consensus anytime soon. But the good thing about a diet, as opposed to politics, is that it is democratized down to the level of the individual. Anyone of us, at any time, is free to try any diet of our choosing and see what happens.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=40654a8c78f1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Richard (Bud) Veech, the Unknown Scientist Behind the Ketogenic Diet Craze Dies at 84]]></title>
            <link>https://travischristofferson.medium.com/richard-bud-veech-the-unknown-scientist-behind-the-ketogenic-diet-craze-dies-at-84-ff1f7c9b91ea?source=rss-941fcad2145b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ff1f7c9b91ea</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ketogenic-diet]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alzheimers-disease]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aging]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Travis Christofferson]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Feb 2020 21:56:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-02-20T14:35:38.249Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By Travis Christofferson</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GvcjIcEsFUW0baIKVF3d2A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Richard (Bud) Veech, a biochemist whose research changed our understanding of human metabolism, died, or as he might say, his “great controlling nucleotide coenzymes” reached their final equilibrium on Sunday February 2, 2020, in his home in Rockville, Maryland. He was 84.</p><p>His death was confirmed by his close friends and colleagues.</p><p>Dr. Veech spent over 50 years studying the nuances of human metabolism. His work was highly lauded among his colleagues.</p><p>“He has redefined our understanding of metabolism,” said Dr. Thomas Seyfried of Boston College.</p><p>“There are probably only a few people in the world that are capable of fully appreciating his work,” said another colleague.</p><p><strong>Develops a “magical” elixir</strong></p><p>Most of his career was spent quietly uncloaking the bioenergetics of a handful of the energy coupling molecules, called nucleotide coenzymes, small molecules that act as batteries powering the thousands of reactions that comprise human metabolism.</p><p>He then discovered something profound: a small molecule called <em>beta-hydroxybutyrate</em>, known as a ketone body, had some remarkable properties. Beta-hydroxybutyrate is generated naturally by the liver when a person fasts or adopts a diet called the <em>ketogenic diet</em>. Specifically, Dr. Veech discovered beta-hydroxybutyrate had the unique ability to increase the potential energy of the critically important energy-storing, nucleotide coenzyme called adenosine triphosphate (ATP), thus, in effect, “supercharging” our entire metabolism.</p><p>This feature of beta-hydroxybutyrate, Dr. Veech contended, was essential to human evolution; facilitating our survival through the inevitable food shortages that have occurred throughout history. Our bodies ability to switch to ketone metabolism when food was unavailable allowed an average size person the ability survive 2 months, compared to 2 to 3 weeks under normal (carbohydrate) metabolism.</p><p>The state of <em>ketosis</em>, Dr. Veech believed, was vitally important to human health, yet has been marginalized in the western world simply because of our constant access to food, especially cheap carbohydrates. “…ketosis is a normal physiologic state. I would argue it is the normal state of man. It’s not normal to have McDonald’s and a delicatessen around every corner. It’s normal to starve,” he said in a 2002 New York Times article written by Gary Taubes.</p><p>It was Dr. Veech’s contention that many of the health problems Westerners face today are because they rarely enter the therapeutic state of ketosis. Dr. Veech often referred to ketone bodies as “superfuel” or “magic;” not in the literal sense, of course, but in the sense that they have a strange ability to correct a spectrum of health problems that manifest from a reduced capacity to generate energy efficiently―a state known as insulin resistance―a state many experience gradually as they age. Early on he recognized the potential in developing a “food-like” product that could mimic ketosis and restore the energy status of the nucleotide coenzymes that drive our metabolism.</p><p>He went on to collaborate with Kieran Clarke at the University of Oxford on the development of a molecule called a <em>ketone ester</em> that when ingested gets converted into the same ketone bodies that the body naturally manufactures during ketosis without the onus of fasting or eating a ketogenic diet.</p><p>Dr. Veech held the unwaveringly belief that the ketone ester has the potential to cheaply and safely treat the most pressing chronic diseases of the western world: Alzheimer’s, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease, in addition to a list of other seemingly unrelated conditions like traumatic brain injury, Parkinson’s, and radiation poisoning. In a 2003 publication he asked the question “What are the potential uses of beta-hydroxybutyrate?” His answer: “Theoretically any condition wherein oxygen supply to the cells may be limited is an avenue for investigation. This list would encompass almost <em>every disease state.</em>”</p><p>Recent research has uncovered additional qualities of beta-hydroxybutyrate, specifically, its ability to act as a signaling molecule, altering gene expression in a way that promotes longevity―a quality that Dr. Veech, remarkably, predicted over 15 years ago. “Finally a chemical agent, beta-hydroxybutyrate, that has played such a major role in man’s survival may be expected to have actions other than simple calories. When nature has a beneficial substance, it may become pleiotropic through evolution with other survival advantages.” Dr. Veech described the strangely far-reaching potential of the ketone ester as the “most important discovery since penicillin.” Clarke said in a 2019 article in <em>The Atlantic</em>, that she believes that the ketone ester will eventually be “more or less a general tonic for the general population.”</p><p>Born on September 19th 1935, Veech grew up in Decatur Illinois. After graduating from High School in 1953 he went on to Harvard and was delighted by the inclusive nature of his education. “[It] was a very interesting department. It was founded by a chemist, Charles Eliot, who decided that everyone that was educated needed to have knowledge of the Bible, Shakespeare, Greek history, Greek tragedy, Russian novels, and a foreign language. You had three-hour oral exams. It was very good, very good, very good undergraduate education,” he said in a 2017 interview with Dave Asprey.</p><p>His interest shifted to medicine and he went on to medical school at Harvard University, graduating at the top of his class in 1962. During his residency he had an epiphany that would change his trajectory: “I didn’t know much at all,” about how to treat the diseases that were killing people and thought “I better learn more.”</p><p>After looking into different laboratories, he ended up at the one he thought “was the best in the world.” It was the Oxford laboratory of Sir Hans Krebs, the winner of the 1953 Nobel Prize for mapping out the cyclical sequence of metabolic reactions that are central to cellular energy production, today commonly referred to as the “Krebs cycle.”</p><p>Immediately after arriving in Oxford, Dr. Krebs gave Veech an extremely difficult project: measure the potential energy stored within the nucleotide coenzyme NADPH by measuring the ratio of its oxidized form to its reduced form. The task was incredibly technically difficult due to the vanishingly small amount contained within the cell. After a year of painstaking work, he had the result and presented his data to the group. “That can’t be right,” commented Krebs. “Well, goddamnit it is right,” Veech shot back. In the end, Veech’s results were right and led to him and Krebs co-authoring the longest publication of Kreb’s career.</p><p>In the fall of 1968, while still at Oxford studying under Krebs, Veech was invited to Boston to give a talk about his research. On his way home, his airplane, upon descent, crashed into Moose Mountain in New Hampshire. The crash killed 32 of 42 passengers and crew. Dr. Veech was one of ten others at the back of the airplane that survived. He was credited with pulling two other passengers to safety before the wreckage was engulfed in flames. One survivor vividly remembered standing with a group of survivors after they had escaped the mangled fuselage and then hearing a man yelling, trapped under the wreckage. The survivor recalled Dr. Veech and a man named Robert Kimball, the then assistant dean at Dartmouth, without hesitation rushed back into the burning wreckage to save the man. Dr. Veech then set about caring for the survivors as best as he could with no medical supplies. He did this despite having multiple lacerations, a broken rib and a crushed vertebra. One survivor described Dr. Veech as “The real hero of this accident.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/546/1*KMsHD0CysHF5V78MtB0UJg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Shortly after recovering from the airplane accident he landed at the N.I.H. where he began studying the mechanisms behind cellular energy production and the unique importance of the then obscure form of metabolism known as ketosis. Hans Krebs and the great Albert Lehninger would often stop into his lab to talk about the latest discoveries and suggest directions for future research. Dr. Veech’s research ultimately led to the production of the ketone ester followed by a flurry of publications suggesting the ester’s potential ability to treat a variety of disease states.</p><p>The career of a scientist is a curious thing. All-too-often a great scientific career is only fully appreciated in hindsight. Dr. Veech had no interest in fame or self-promotion. He felt that it was “unseemly for doctors to promote themselves.” He hoped to be judged on the merit of his work in the present. More than anything, he wanted the world to appreciate the importance of the ketone ester and was frustrated that it’s potential to mitigate so many of our most immediate health issues wasn’t fully appreciated. “He was optimistic that each publication would convince people of the ester’s importance, but then he often felt let down,” said his college roommate who remained his close friend until his death.</p><p>But if history is a guide, the full appreciation of medical knowledge is often delayed or even forgotten. The British Royal Navy reluctantly made it policy to stock citrus for naval voyages fifty-years after James Lind provided unequivocal proof it was the cure for scurvy. The ketogenic diet, once the standard-of-care for pediatric epilepsy in the 1920’s, was all-but forgotten until being rediscovered and championed in the 1990’s by Hollywood movie producer Jim Abrahams after the diet instantaneously cured his son Charlie who had failed multiple drugs and was having hundreds of seizures a day.</p><p>The public may not have appreciated the potential of Dr. Veech’s ester as quickly as he would have liked, but by 2004 the Military had begun to take notice. After writing a letter explaining the potential of the ketone ester to improve the endurance and mental performance of Special Forces―citing previous publications including one showing that a mouse heart can pump 25% stronger while using less oxygen when the ketone body beta-hydroxybutyrate is added as a fuel, DARPA, the Defense Advanced Research Projects Administration, cut Dr. Veech a check for 10 million dollars to develop the ketone ester. “N.I.H. have never given money for this kind of metabolic research,” said Dr. Veech.</p><p>It was Dr. Veech’s greatest hope, however, that one day the ketone ester would have use beyond just military application; that it would be fully appreciated for what he felt it was capable of: improving the lives of millions of people.</p><p>In the winter of 2015, with his 55th Harvard reunion fast approaching, Dr. Veech penned a letter to his classmates extoling the virtues of the ketone ester: “As most of us will be entering our 8th decade, far beyond our allotted 3 score and ten, I thought it might be of interest to present to my classmates some of the research findings that have occupied me for the past 20 years concerning the accompaniment of aging.”</p><p>He then listed off 10 publications supporting the ester’s ability to ameliorate age related cognitive impairment.</p><p><strong>A maverick scientist</strong></p><p>Creative collaborations often fatefully fall together and Dr. Veech’s laboratory was no exception. Some aspects of it resembled a pirate’s ship: a crew of unlikely, mavericks that connected accidentally yet somehow fit together in a beautiful harmony. One collaborator, William Curtis, a Parkinson’s patient with a background in biochemistry, came to Dr. Veech’s lab in search of help for his disease after reading an article in the journal Neurology about a small study done at Colombia showing that a ketogenic diet improved the symptoms of Parkinson’s patients by 43%. The diet sounded miserable to Curtis, however, deep in the reference section he found Dr. Veech and went to see him. At first, Dr. Veech didn’t think he could help Curtis. “No, I can’t do anything. I can’t do anything for you. We don’t have enough stuff, go way,” he said. But Curtis stayed. The two eventually became friends and started collaborating. Today, Curtis credits the ketogenic diet and Veech’s ketone ester for taking him from nearly frozen to functional.</p><p>Genius, too, often appears in unusual packages. Those that knew Dr. Veech well describe him as a colorful character. To be sure, he had little patience for fools. He was refreshingly, and at times, shockingly, blunt. He said it exactly how he saw it with as few words as possible and little thought for political correctness. “Read the damn papers,” he once told a reporter asking him to explain the ketone ester’s significance. Although some may have been put-off by his rough edges, others appreciated his straight forward style. “I love how blunt you are,” said Asprey, during the 2017 interview with Dr. Veech.</p><p>There was another side to Dr. Veech. For those he loved he was gracious and thoughtful, as illustrated in a letter he wrote to the two sons of a deeply respected colleague, George Cahill, upon Cahill’s death. “It is one of my proudest accomplishments to have been cited as a single co-author with Dr Cahill [on] one of his last publications. Dr. Cahill died at 85 while singing with two of his daughter’s Handel’s Hallelujah Chorus. I related this to a young student studying ketosis in athletes and she exclaimed ‘He must have gone immediately to heaven.’ That is an idea that all of us who knew him would share.”</p><p>One aspect of Dr. Veech that all his colleagues seem to agree on is that he was a rare scientific genius―on the scale of the greats from the “golden era” of biochemistry; names like Sir Hans Krebs, Otto Warburg, and Albert Lehninger.</p><p>This author was lucky enough to have had a beer with Dr. Veech and a small group of scientists at a conference a few years ago. We had a delightful conversation about many topics. Mostly we laughed. I can still picture Dr. Veech’s crooked smile and his authentic and infectious guffaw. It was one of a handful of moments I will cherish forever. I knew I was in the presence of greatness. Not today’s brand of greatness: celebrities, athletes or YouTube stars, but rather greatness of a different era.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ff1f7c9b91ea" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>