<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by TriedByStats on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by TriedByStats on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@triedbystats?source=rss-ebaec2cb0eba------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 13:38:28 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@triedbystats/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[New prosecution expert opinions further undermine allegation Lucy Letby murdered Baby C]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@triedbystats/new-prosecution-expert-opinions-further-undermine-allegation-lucy-letby-murdered-baby-c-2d076f5627ff?source=rss-ebaec2cb0eba------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d076f5627ff</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[TriedByStats]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 05 Feb 2026 08:27:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-05T08:27:28.302Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<ul><li>Lucy Letby was convicted of murdering Baby C by injecting air down his nasogastric tube, causing his stomach to inflate.</li><li>The prosecution cited the presence of post mortem air in the stomach to support this conclusion.</li><li>NEW: In his pretrial expert report radiologist Professor Owen Arthurs wrote about air seen on Baby C’s post mortem X-Rays “<em>in my opinion the degree of bowel gas dilatation is not unusual</em>” and <em>“In my opinion, I would be cautious about inferring a cause or mechanism of death on the basis of post mortem abdominal gas.” — </em>This was not shown to jury.</li><li>NEW: I put this to Dr Evans and he told me, repeatedly, that he believed post mortem air played no role in the case. Dr Evans told me “<em>I don’t think anyone suggested that post mortem abdominal (stomach) gas is useful in explaining the mechanism of death, not only in this case, but in any case.” </em>and <em>“As far as ‘air post mortem’ is concerned, air found in the stomach is, in my opinion, not of diagnostic usefulness.”</em></li></ul><blockquote>[Dr Marnerides] said that <strong>the gas in [Baby C]’s bowel</strong> could not be explained either by an infection, because that was excluded by the histology, or an abnormality of the bowel or, importantly, by post-mortem decomposition. He “confidently excluded”, those were his words, <strong>post-mortem decomposition</strong>. And therefore Dr Marnerides concluded <strong>that air must have been injected into the nasogastric tube, causing a splinting of the diaphragm<br>…<br></strong>[Baby C] had massive gastric dilation and ballooning of the stomach, which he’d not had when he was fed by Sophie Ellis. In the absence of natural causes, it’s obvious what happened, isn’t it? Even if you don’t take into account any of the other cases. When you put [Baby C]’s case alongside the others, it’s as plain as the nose on your face that Lucy Letby must have injected air down the nasogastric tube into [Baby C]’s stomach.</blockquote><blockquote>— Prosecution closing speech</blockquote><p>A brief primer is needed on the Baby C case before we go through the details. In summary, the baby was born on June 10, 2015. During the day shift on June 12, he had an X-ray showing significant gastric distention, or air in his stomach. On the night shift of June 13, Lucy Letby came on duty for the first time since before the baby was born. Baby C died that night.</p><p>The prosecution, naturally, say his death was the work of Letby. Exactly when or how has changed over time. By the end of the trial, the allegation was that someone put air in Baby C’s stomach between 23:00 and 23:15 on June 13, and that this caused him to collapse.</p><p>The evidence the prosecution relied on was the re-interpretation of the autopsy report by their expert witness, pathologist Dr Marnerides. They say there was evidence of air in the stomach found at autopsy, conducted at 10:00 on June 16. Around 60 hours after the alleged attack.</p><p>The prosecution explained their accusation while questioning Letby:</p><blockquote>Q. Do you agree that something caused [Baby C]’s stomach and bowel to dilate between 11 o’clock and his collapse?<br>A. So the air you’re referring to is before the collapse?<br>Q. <strong>That’s what’s found after he died. We’re suggesting that’s the reason for the collapse. </strong><br>A. I think if he was found with air when he’s died, that could be related to the Neopuff resuscitation. I’m not accepting that he had noticeable gas between 23.00 and 23.15.</blockquote><blockquote>— Cross exam of Lucy Letby — Day 117–19.05.23</blockquote><h4>New findings</h4><p>This allegation is directly undermined by a previously unseen report by the prosecution radiologist, who reviewed the post-mortem X-rays. This was never shown to the jury, and he was never asked about it during the trial.</p><blockquote>The degree of bowel gas dilatation is unusual, and could be considered excessive. However, the normal variation in bowel gas dilatation following death is unknown and allowing for the 2-day interval between [Baby C]’s death and the post mortem radiographs being performed, in my opinion the degree of bowel gas dilatation is not unusual</blockquote><blockquote>In my opinion, I would be cautious about inferring a cause or mechanism of death on the basis of post mortem abdominal gas.</blockquote><blockquote>— Report of Professor Owen Arthurs</blockquote><p>Inferring a cause or mechanism on the basis of post-mortem abdominal gas is exactly what the prosecution did. This isn’t a case of “the experts disagree.” In his testimony, Dr Marnerides makes extensive reference to the radiology and to Professor Arthurs’ opinion. Some typical passages from his testimony are below.</p><blockquote>Q.<strong> </strong>You understood, and the jury has heard from <strong>Professor Arthurs</strong>, that his view was that it was the small bowel that we could see dilated in the <strong>radiographs</strong>?<br>A. Yes.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. So bearing that in mind as well, what did you then move on to — <br>….<br>A. … So having considered all this, I came to the conclusion that most likely the<strong> </strong>description about the descending and sigmoid was imprecise and<strong> what we were looking at were dilated stomach and bowel.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Q. <strong>Which would be in keeping with the radiology?<br></strong>A. <strong>Which would be in keeping with the radiology.</strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong>…</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Q. … “Massive gastric dilation… on the X-ray of 12 June 2015 most likely due to deliberate exogenous air down the NGT”?<br>A. Yes. That’s my understanding from the statements and the views expressed.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. By Dr Evans and Dr Bohin?<br>A. Yes. That’s what I said.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. So that forms part of the picture that you rely upon in considering alternative diagnoses, for instance, could this be due to air down the NGT which led to the collapse on 13 June?<br>A. Yes.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. You’re taking what they have said about that X-ray and applying it to the circumstances at the time of death; is that correct?<br>A. They said it and the radiology experts say it.</blockquote><p>In another section of his testimony, Dr Marnerides was repeatedly asked which X-ray he was referring to in his reports, and he said he didn’t know, you’d have to ask the other experts. See page 12 of his <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1TYfSbwLJezRe0EOdB-y3Zl6zIeLPcVM9/view?usp=sharing">cross examination</a>.</p><blockquote>Q. All I’m identifying is you say: “The massive gastric dilation on the X-ray of 12 June was most likely due to deliberate exogenous administration of air down the NGT.” And you make it plain, above that, that is something that both Dr Evans and Dr Bohin consider or regard.<br>… <br>A. That’s what I said, yes. <strong>That’s what they said to me</strong>. I cannot confirm that this is the X-ray though.</blockquote><p>This formed part of my initial work on Baby C, <a href="https://medium.com/@triedbystats/lucy-letby-was-convicted-of-murdering-baby-c-based-on-evidence-from-a-day-when-she-wasnt-on-shift-8fb2bb93e0ef">in which I allege Dr Marnerides was actually referring to the X-ray/distention from 12 June</a>, and was not independently producing a new conclusion separate from the other experts. This new report is strong evidence in favor of that interpretation.</p><p>The second new finding, which I believe has not been reported before, is that even at the pre-trial meeting of experts — just weeks before the trial started — Dr Marnerides is recorded as believing this distention had a natural explanation:</p><blockquote>Although there was no PM evidence of NEC there was an inflammatory response and therefore a natural cause for the gastric distention cannot be excluded.</blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Marnerides position at the expert meeting</blockquote><p>Finally, the third new finding comes directly from Dr Dewi Evans, the prosecution’s chief medical expert witness. In correspondence over a number of weeks, I asked him about Arthurs’ report and Marnerides’ comment. He told me, <em>“I’ve no argument with their qualified views.” </em>and<em> “Interpretation of radiological findings is a matter for the radiologist. I think his comments are fine.”.</em></p><p>Over several emails Dr Evans would repeatedly tell me that post mortem air in the stomach should not be used to conclude anything. A direct contradiction of the prosecutions case.</p><blockquote>EVANS: I don’t think anyone suggested that post mortem abdominal (stomach) gas is useful in explaining the mechanism of death, not only in this case, but in any case.<br>…<br>EVANS: But as far as ‘air post mortem’ is concerned, air found in the <strong>stomach</strong> is, in my opinion, not of diagnostic usefulness. If you can find anyone who has a different view send me their report.<br><em>…<br></em>EVANS: I’ve no idea why post mortem gas in the stomach on x-ray is being discussed. I just wonder whether you are confusing post mortem air in the <strong>stomach</strong> with post mortem air in <strong>blood vessels</strong>! I’ve no wish to be condescending, but I’ve read an awful lot of comment from the denialists that just make no sense.</blockquote><blockquote>TRIED BY STATS: The baby was also given extensive resuscitation with a neopuff, how could we distinguish between air injected into the baby’s stomach as a result of Letby and air in the baby’s stomach as a result of that machine?</blockquote><blockquote>EVANS: As noted above, I’ve no idea where this is taking us.</blockquote><p>For the avoidance of doubt there is no evidence or even allegation of post mortem air in the blood vessels in this case. I asked Dr Evans repeatedly if there was any basis to conclude injection of air down the nasogastric tube or splinting of the diaphragm on the basis of post mortem air and every time he came back with a categorical NO. Absolutely not.</p><p>Important to note: while this contradicts the prosecution’s case, it doesn’t contradict his own testimony; he never suggested post-mortem air could be used. This is a bed made entirely by the prosecution themselves.</p><h4>How we got here</h4><p>In his initial meeting with the police Dr Evans told them that the baby died of infection but highlighted one suspicious finding: a UV line that came out on the 12th of June. Lucy Letby wasn’t on shift.</p><blockquote>His UV line was seen to have come out at 07:00 12/06/15. Can this be explained? Shouldn’t have come out. <strong>Died of infection</strong>. If the UV line being out is suspicious then death suspicious.</blockquote><blockquote><em>— </em>Minutes from police meeting with Dr Evans r.e Baby C</blockquote><p>Even though he told them the baby died of infection, over the next few years the police paid Dr Evans to write a total of five different reports on Baby C. A hint, perhaps, that this was not the expert opinion they wanted to hear. His reports broadly highlight the baby’s vulnerable state and conclude that it is not possible to “state categorically” that the baby was deliberately harmed.</p><blockquote>33. One may never identify the cause of [Baby C]’ collapse. <strong>One cannot ignore the low platelet count or the presence of bile in his aspirates</strong>. Neither would not cause his collapse but both are markers that suggest he was an unwell baby. A raised CRP [of 22] similarly suggests that he was not completely well. There are therefore a number of features, allied to his very small weight, just 717 grams, <strong>that places [Baby C] at great risk of an unexpected collapse</strong>.</blockquote><blockquote>Opinion:<br>34. I have concerns regarding the unexpected collapse of [Baby C] at around 23.00 hr on 13 June 2015, given his reasonable stable condition immediately prior to this. I note also the presence of abnormal inflammatory markers [low platelets, raised CRP] and <strong>cannot exclude the role of infection in his collapse</strong>.</blockquote><blockquote>35. I would advise scrutinising the staffing present at this time. Given the presence of the inflammatory markers <strong>it’s not possible to state categorically</strong> that [Baby C]’s collapse represents inappropriate management at around 23.00 hr on 13 June 2015.<br> — Dr Evans’ 2017 report</blockquote><p>Dr Evans is not alone. All of the prosecution medical experts have at one point in time accepted the baby died of natural causes.</p><blockquote>Having reviewed the materials provided to me, I have not identified any suspicious findings or any morphological or clinical evidence that would justify a view that the death of this baby may have been due to unnatural causes.</blockquote><blockquote>Having reviewed the materials provided to me and on the basis of what I previously discussed herein, it is my opinion, that the most-likely cause of [Baby C]’s sudden collapse and subsequent death would be the histologically identified acute pneumonia with acute lung injury. Acute pneumonia with acute lung injury would be in keeping with the clinical assessments and opinions of Drs Evans and Ward Platt, namely that [Baby C]’s death might have been due to a natural cause (infection).</blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Marnerides, prosecution pathologist expert witness, first report</blockquote><p>Over the course of several years of pre-trial report writing the main theory of harm to emerge from the prosecution experts was that the X-Ray taken on the 12th of June represented a deliberate injection of air.</p><blockquote>In my opinion, whilst [Baby C] could have died of natural causes, there is also radiographic evidence of excessive administration of air via the NG tube.</blockquote><blockquote>— Professor Owen Arthurs report on Baby C (prosecution radiologist)</blockquote><p>The original source of this allegation, like all of the allegations, came from one of Dr Evans’ reports.</p><blockquote>In the context of the clinical presentation of several other babies nursed at the Countess of Chester Hospital during 2015 and 2016 I am suspicious of the gaseous distension reported on the abdominal x-ray of 12 June, and wonder whether this represents inappropriate management, where his attendant inserted excess air into his stomach via his nasogastric tube, doing so in the knowledge that it would cause the infant discomfort and distress.</blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Evans final report on Baby C</blockquote><p>By the time of the expert pre-trial meeting Dr Bohin and Dr Evans agreed their joint position: This was a deliberate injection of air.</p><blockquote>The cause of the gaseous distention of the bowel and gastric dilatation <strong>was not </strong>‘CPAP belly’. The extent of gaseous distention seen on the x-ray of 12 June 2015 is over and above what is seen in infants requiring CPAP. The massive gastric dilatation seen on the x-ray of 12 June 2015 was most likely due to deliberate exogenous administration of air via the NGT.</blockquote><blockquote>— Joint expert meeting, agreed position of Dr Evans and Dr Bohin</blockquote><p>Having listened to the arguments at this meeting, Dr Marnerides wrote a new report concluding the baby died of this deliberate injection of air. This report made extensive references to the opinions of other experts and to the X-Ray from the 12th.</p><blockquote>And <strong>there was</strong> <strong>an assessment of what the massive gastric dilatation that was observed — so ballooning, basically, of the stomach </strong>— meant. So all these were taken into account, and having considered the <strong>reports by the radiologists </strong>… there is also massive gaseous dilatation of the stomach<strong> </strong>and the small bowel<strong>…</strong></blockquote><blockquote>This part was dilated like a balloon and all these loops were dilated. <strong>That’s what the radiologists concluded</strong>. So lots of air in that.</blockquote><blockquote>Having heard the discussions at the meeting, <strong>having considered the potential explanations about how such a dilatation could have been caused</strong>, I reached my — I revisited the cause of death I proposed and reached the conclusion I reached and it’s noted in my report.</blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Marnerides testimony</blockquote><p>Lucy Letby was of course not on shift on the 12th of June.</p><p>In their opening speech the prosecution introduced an entirely new allegation. One never made previously at any point by any expert. Lucy Letby injected air into the baby’s stomach on the 13th of June. As evidence they told the jury one of their experts, Dr Bohin, had identified “excessive air” on the 13th of June.</p><blockquote>Therefore, a rather long run-up to the wicket, leads to the conclusion of Dr Bohin that the only feasible mechanism for <strong>the excessive air</strong> in [Baby C]’s gastrointestinal system, his stomach and his bowel, the only feasible explanation or mechanism for <strong>that at the time of his collapse</strong> was because someone had deliberately put air into [Baby C] down the nasogastric tube.</blockquote><blockquote>In other words, [Baby C] was killed by air injected into his stomach through the nasogastric tube. So this isn’t a case of injecting air into the bloodstream, this is a case of air going in through the NGT.</blockquote><blockquote>— Prosecution opening speech</blockquote><p>The issue is that the prosecution appears to have made a mistake here. Dr Bohin was referring to the same distention as everyone else, the 12th. When Dr Bohin was actually called to testify she actually did not identify any cause of the baby’s collapse, nor made any mention of<em> “excessive air” </em>being present on the 13th.</p><blockquote>Q. […] so far<strong> as 13 June is concerned there is no cause identified?<br></strong>A. That’s correct.<br> — Dr Bohin cross examination<strong> </strong>(Transcript: Nov 2nd 2022)</blockquote><p>You can read for yourself. I’ve attached the transcripts of <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/16fPBRLV3jSWKc4WkC45AD-3W4UHx4Cty/view?usp=sharing">Dr Bohins direct </a>and<a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1s_6-JrBHzS17BzJJohGl87kdUtW_oD3F/view?usp=sharing"> cross examinations</a>. Dr Bohin was not alone here, not a single witness during the trial identified any air present on the 13th.</p><p>The prosecution responded by subtly changing the allegation again. Now Dr Marnerides was the source of the allegation. They suggested now, that after listening to all the experts talking about the 12th, Dr Marnerides took another look at the autopsy photos and then identified <em>a different </em>instance of gastric distention several days after the baby died. In other words there are two distinct allegations, rather than experts agreeing about one.</p><h4>A rather long run-up to the wicket</h4><p>This was always a dubious proposition. First, as I explored in depth <a href="https://medium.com/@triedbystats/lucy-letby-was-convicted-of-murdering-baby-c-based-on-evidence-from-a-day-when-she-wasnt-on-shift-8fb2bb93e0ef">in my original work</a> on this case Dr Marnerides was very clearly referring to the same allegation as the other experts. Again, you can read the transcript of <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1H17SBRHJGI00FCoUzECL-ksI3jRcU_Lm/view?usp=sharing">his direct</a> and cross-examinations. Look out for the references to radiology, X-rays, and other expert opinions.</p><p>Secondly, as Lucy Letby pointed out, after the baby collapsed there was an extensive attempt to resuscitate the baby using a Neopuff. This is a form of mechanical ventilation, a well-documented side effect of mechanical ventilation is gastric distention.</p><p>This was a prolonged resuscitation of over 40 minutes, including chest compressions, multiple failed intubation attempts, and use of a neopuff. The consultant arrived after 20 minutes and was able to intubate the baby. That consultant, Dr Gibbs, accepted the Neopuff could have been blowing air into the stomach.</p><blockquote>Q. But as it happens, intubation with an endotracheal tube can be more effective?<br>A. Yes, particularly in a prolonged resuscitation, because of the problem of blowing oxygen and air down into the stomach and distending the stomach, which squashes the chest a little.<br>…<br>Q. All right. So there may have been some period with the Neopuff blowing air possibly into the stomach before he was intubated?<br>A. Yes, as well as blowing air and oxygen down into the lungs. Even if I hadn’t been able to intubate [Baby C], Neopuff ventilation could have continued.</blockquote><blockquote>—Dr Gibbs cross — Day 020 – 01.11.22</blockquote><p>The interpretation I suggest here is not that Dr Marnerides made a mistake, but that he was dubiously bringing his own opinion into alignment with the other experts who had identified the X-ray on 12 June as suspicious. When they withdrew their opinions about 12 June, the prosecution tried to rely on his opinion alone, something it was never intended to do.</p><blockquote>Q. From the pathology, you don’t assert that the diaphragm was splinted in a particular case, do you, from the pathology?<br>A. <strong>I cannot, and that —</strong> <strong>it’s not doable from the pathology.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>— Marnerides under cross exam — Day 098–30.03.23</blockquote><h4>As plain as the nose on your face</h4><p>The prosecutions case is extraordinary. Firstly all the prosecution experts misidentified the 12th as a deliberate injection of air. Then according to them, by sheer coincidence, it turned out the baby <em>was </em>murdered by the<em> exact same means </em>taking place the next day.</p><p>What a lucky break for the prosecution.</p><p>At trial the prosecution partially disavowed Dr Evans testimony on Baby C, instead directing the jury to rely on Dr Marnerides.</p><blockquote>Dr Evans concluded that the reason for [Baby C]’s collapse and death was an injection of air into the nasogastric tube. Dr Evans was criticised, and we accept justifiably criticised, for not having given a cause of death in his report, but then saying it in the witness box, because experts should and must notify any alteration of their opinion in writing.<br>…<br>But if you think, ladies and gentlemen, that the way that Dr Evans failed to give advance notice of his opinion in the report has or even may have had or caused any unfairness to Lucy Letby, then <strong>we encourage you to disregard what he said in this case</strong>, not least because, when we get to Dr Marnerides, we will see that he gave a much more detailed description and reasons for reaching precisely the same conclusion. <br> — Prosecution closing speech — Day 133–21.06.23</blockquote><p>During Letby’s appeal, the prosecution highlighted this — an attempt to ward off criticism of Dr Evans by diverting attention to Dr Marnerides. In doing so, the prosecution succeeded in rewriting history. Rather than Dr Marnerides taking the idea from Dr Evans they convinced the court of appeals of the opposite: that Dr Evans in fact got the idea from Dr Marnerides.</p><blockquote>The Court was referred by my learned friend to several quotations from Dr Evans, “the child collapsed and died” — that series of quotations. The Court was not referred to page 1503….</blockquote><blockquote>A question from me: “In the context of the child’s death have you seen an expert report written by a pathologist called Dr Marnerides? <br>A. I have. Have you also had the opportunity of discussing this case with Dr Marnerides?” He said: “I think I discussed it”. <br>I then said: “In coming to your view have you taken into account the findings of Dr Marnerides?” And he said: “I have”.</blockquote><blockquote>Then he returns, does Dr Evans, to Dr Marnerides. So, we accepted in the trial — well let us take it stage by stage. When this application was first made at the beginning of 2023, in January, we accepted unequivocally that Dr Evans had not in effect played by the rules. He should have put this in a report, in writing, in advance of going into the witness box. We accepted in our closing speech the same and we said in terms to the jury that if they thought that that was an issue then they should disregard what Dr Evans had said on this issue. Of course in saying that, but we also said to the jury that they, the jury could rely on the evidence of Dr Marnerides on this issue.</blockquote><blockquote>— Letby Appeal hearing</blockquote><p>The prosecution is in this position because they were reluctant to accept Dr Evans’ evidence. During his, extraordinary, testimony he said for the first time on the witness stand that he thought the baby died from an injection of air into the stomach. Transcript of his Baby C testimony here.</p><p>This would, in large part, form the basis of the defence motion to have his testimony excluded.</p><blockquote>MR JUSTICE GOSS: You say: “This was something that Dr Evans came up with when pressed to explain his assertion that air had been forced down the nasogastric tube. There was no evidential basis for it, it had never appeared in any of his many reports.” And then: “It appears to be a hostile and partisan response by a witness who had nothing else to say and could not justify an opinion that had been given without notice and without supporting evidence or reasoning.”<br>MR MYERS: My Lord, that’s correct. It’s beyond doubt it hadn’t featured in his evidence before that point.<br>MR JUSTICE GOSS: No.<br>MR MYERS: There is no dispute as to that.<br>MR JUSTICE GOSS: No, exactly.<br>MR MYERS: It’s a significant matter and not something that was novel, it appears in other cases<br>.… <br>[Much later] <br>MR JOHNSON: The [Baby C] point, of course, was of a wholly different character, we accept that unreservedly. If Dr Evans intended to say what he said in the witness box, he should have put it in a report. So we concede that point completely.</blockquote><blockquote>—Motion to exclude Dr Evans’ testimony- Day 052–09.01.23</blockquote><h4>It’s obvious what happened, isn’t it?</h4><p>In their exchange with Letby the prosecution couldn’t have been clearer.</p><blockquote>A. So the air you’re referring to is before the collapse?<br>Q. That’s what’s found after he died. We’re suggesting that’s the reason for the collapse.</blockquote><p>The air at an autopsy 60 hours after the fact caused the collapse. No one attending to the baby for the several hours between his collapse and death five hours later noticed any distention. It’s quite the claim: one Dr Evans refused to endorse and directly contradicted, and one their radiologist warned against making:</p><blockquote>In my opinion, I would be cautious about inferring a cause or mechanism of death on the basis of post mortem abdominal gas.</blockquote><p>There is now overwhelming evidence that the prosecution’s very clever legal sleight of hand has not, in fact, resulted in a coherent medical accusation. Isn’t it worth just double checking with Dr Marnerides?</p><p>One day they will concede every word of this.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d076f5627ff" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Panorama Complaint]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@triedbystats/panorama-complaint-b6d32f9389d9?source=rss-ebaec2cb0eba------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b6d32f9389d9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[TriedByStats]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 30 Aug 2025 17:38:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-30T17:38:27.167Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The following is the full version of a complaint sent to the BBC regarding their recent panorama episode on Lucy Letby.</em></p><p>I am writing to raise a complaint about a factual inaccuracy in your recent <em>Panorama</em> episode on Lucy Letby, specifically the statement made by Judith Moritz regarding Baby C:</p><blockquote>“Lucy Letby was alone with him when he collapsed.”</blockquote><p>Your response to a similar complaint about this point <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/LucyLetbyTrials/comments/1n307uv/response_from_the_bbc_to_my_complaint_that_lucy/?utm_source=share&amp;utm_medium=web3x&amp;utm_name=web3xcss&amp;utm_term=1&amp;utm_content=share_button">(as circulated online</a>) cites the testimony of Nurses Ellis and Taylor, suggesting their accounts prove Ms Letby was alone at Baby C’s cot.</p><blockquote>“In short, the testimony of Nurses Ellis and Taylor indicates that Lucy Letby was alone at Baby C’s incubator with Baby C when he collapsed while Nurse Ellis and Nurse Taylor were tending to other duties in Nursery 1. The fact that they were in the room does not alter this.”</blockquote><p>This account omits the opposing defence narrative. The defence pointed out that Ellis and Taylor each altered their accounts to include her only after Letby had been named as a suspect, that their versions contradicted one another, and that in their first statements there was no mention of Letby being there at all. Critically, it also excludes the evidence of a key eyewitness, Nurse B, who stated both in her original account and again at trial that when she arrived, Taylor and Ellis were present and Letby came in afterwards.</p><blockquote>She (Nurse B) went to nursery 1 where Sophie Ellis and Mel Taylor were Neopuffing [Baby C]. No suggestion Lucy Letby was there. She wasn’t because they’d been looking after baby JE elsewhere. When asked questions by the prosecution, she made it clear that she and Ms Letby had been occupied in trying to find a doctor to do a septic screen for JE. That’s what they’d been involved with. Ms Letby therefore is in no way near to nursery 1. And she described, [Nurse B] did, assisting Melanie Taylor and Sophie Ellis and she told the police that some time later she became aware that Lucy Letby was in the room. That’s that. With [Nurse B] when it happened, which would explain why in Mel Taylor’s original statement to the police Lucy Letby isn’t there, she was with [Nurse B]. [Nurse B] went over to assist and at some point after that is aware that Lucy Letby has gone there too, but not in the room when it happened. That follows from what Mel Taylor first said to the police and how [Nurse B] has always described this.</blockquote><blockquote>— Defence closing speech — Day 137</blockquote><p>The second piece of evidence the BBC relied upon was an alleged “confession” by Letby in 2019. The BBC response stated:</p><blockquote>“Ms Letby herself told police in 2019 that she was the only staff member in the nursery at the time Baby C collapsed and she agreed that she was seen at his cot side when his alarm sounded.”</blockquote><p>This is misleading. During her cross-examination on day 116 of the trial, Letby explained that she had no memory of where she was at the time. When police put to her that Ellis said she had seen her at the cot, Letby accepted that “on her word at that time” but she made clear in evidence that she did not herself recall this and did not accept it as fact. The BBC response is therefore inaccurate when it claims she “accepted” being cotside at the collapse.</p><blockquote>A. “I don’t recall where I was at the time that I send that text. I might have been at the nurses’ station and then have gone into nursery 1 to do something else [as read].”<br>Q. Yes. They’re not telling you were in nursery 1, are they, at that point?<br>A. Yes, I believe beforehand, Sophie had suggested that I was there — <br>Q. Oh yes, right at the beginning of the interview.<br>A. Yes.<br>Q. You are here accepting, aren’t you, that you were in nursery 1 when you finished that series of texts with your friend, Jennifer Jones-Key, and you were feeling frustrated?<br>A. No, I can’t confirm that I sent that message in nursery 1, no.<br>Q. No, not sent the message, you are confirming that you went — having sent the message, you went into nursery 1?<br>A. No, I’m not saying that, I don’t think. I’m saying I don’t recall where I was.<br>Q. Yes, you say: “I don’t recall where I was at the time that I sent that text.”<br>A. Yes.<br>Q. “I might have been at the nurses’ station and then I’ve gone into nursery 1 to do something else.”<br>A. Yes, because just previous to that it was stated to me that Sophie Ellis had seen me at the cot side and I took that to be accurate.<br>Q. It is accurate, isn’t it?<br>A. It was on her word at that time.<br>Q. You were quite happy to accept it, were you?<br>A. I haven’t accepted it, I’ve said I don’t recall.</blockquote><blockquote>— Letby cross exam — Day 116</blockquote><p>The issue is not which interpretation is correct. The problem is that the programme presented the prosecution’s interpretation as though it were an established fact, without acknowledging that the defence had disputed it. This falls short of impartial reporting. The BBC should have qualified the statement as the prosecution’s interpretation and acknowledged the defence’s contrary case.</p><p>Furthermore, the BBC’s response to a well-founded factual complaint raises concerns. The complaints department appears to have consulted Panorama and returned their justification. That justification accepts the prosecution’s account on trust and overlooks the defence entirely. This is a textbook instance of the implicit pro-prosecution bias that has repeatedly landed the Panorama team in difficulty over the Letby case.</p><p>Kind regards,<br>TriedByStats</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b6d32f9389d9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lucy Letby & Baby P — Room filled with witnesses at time of alleged attack, experts changed their…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@triedbystats/lucy-letby-baby-p-room-filled-with-witnesses-at-time-of-alleged-attack-experts-changed-their-05fd410154cb?source=rss-ebaec2cb0eba------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/05fd410154cb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[crime]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[miscarriage-of-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lucy-letby]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[injustice]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[TriedByStats]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 05 Jun 2025 07:15:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-05T18:03:50.839Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Lucy Letby &amp; Baby P — Room filled with witnesses at time of alleged attack, experts changed their minds, and doctor’s error punctured baby’s lung</h3><ul><li>During the timeframe that the prosecution accuses Letby of attacking Baby P, there were at least three witnesses in the room. Not one of them saw anything.</li><li>The prosecution accused Letby of injecting air into the baby’s stomach via his NG tube, causing him to collapse.</li><li>The prosecution experts acknowledged a long list of failures in this baby’s care, including one mistake by doctors leading to the baby’s lung being punctured, followed by “unacceptable delays” in identifying and treating this condition.</li><li>Another error was that doctors gave the baby 10 times the inital dose of adrenaline that the baby should have been started on. A separate, and later issue, saw the baby receiving double the intended dose of adrenaline at multiple points during the day.</li><li>Paradoxically, the prosecution accused Letby of lying about medical notes, yet the only evidence their experts could point to were the exact same notes. The notes actually contradict their case.</li><li>There is no evidence of gastric distension (air in the baby’s stomach) that the prosecution could rely on that aligns with their timeline.</li></ul><p>Baby P, along with his brother Baby O, was one of the triplets Lucy Letby has been convicted of murdering. The prosecution’s primary allegation is that Letby injected air into Baby P’s stomach around 09:40 on June 24th, initiating a tragic sequence culminating in his death several hours later.</p><p>The prosecution case is that at 09:35, Baby P was well, examined by two doctors who had no concerns. Five minutes later, he crashed, requiring massive resuscitation. The prosecution claims Letby attacked during this window. At that time, at least three medically trained witnesses were in the small room; none saw anything untoward.</p><p>This case involves significant deviation by the prosecution experts from their pre-trial reports. Prior to the trial their theory was about an attack the night before. Letby wasn’t working the night shift. During the trial they changed their mind. On the stand they moved the date of the attack to line up with the prosecutions allegation.</p><p>They also identified multiple hospital errors in Baby P’s care, including administering ten times the appropriate initial adrenaline dose and separately a dosing calculation error led to them giving double the prescribed dose at multiple points during the day. Doctors placed him on excessively high ventilator settings, causing or contributing to his lung collapsing (pneumothorax). An earlier X-ray, which could have identified this issue, wasn’t performed promptly, and when eventually taken, doctors reviewed it 40 minutes late, after the baby collapsed again. Resolving the pneumothorax took several hours.</p><p>All of these errors were accepted by the prosecution experts, with Dr. Evans even writing that the death was a result of complications of the pneumothorax. The consultant responsible for Baby P’s care made headlines for <a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14141149/consultants-helped-jail-Letby-responsible-baby-death-jury-JOHN-SWEENEYS-devastating-expose-broken-hospital.html">“accidentally killing a baby” after a series of failures in another case.</a> She is identified only as Dr B as she can’t be named due to court order.</p><h3>Timeline</h3><p><strong>23rd June – Letby on day shift</strong></p><ul><li><strong>18:00</strong> — Dr. Gibbs examines Baby P, noting the baby’s stomach is “<em>mildly distended.</em>” Letby is <strong>not</strong> accused of causing this. Gibbs orders an X-ray.</li><li><strong>20.09</strong> — X-ray is taken, revealing <em>“moderate gaseous distention”. </em>Letby <strong>is</strong> accused.</li></ul><p><strong>24th June – Letby on day shift</strong></p><ul><li><strong>04:00</strong> — Nurse aspirates 25ml of air from Baby P, noting the bay still has gastric distention.</li><li><strong>06:36</strong> — Nurse Ellis notes, “<em>Abdomen has been soft and non-distended.”</em></li><li><strong>08:00</strong> — Lucy Letby begins her next shift. She will retrospectively record later that evening:<em> “Abdomen full. Loops visible. Soft to touch.</em>” The prosecution allege that this is a falsified record by Letby.</li><li><strong>09:35</strong> — Dr. Ukoh conducts ward round, finds Baby P stable but notes <em>“abdomen moderately distended/bloated, soft.”</em> Letby is explicitly <strong>not</strong> accused of causing this.</li><li><strong>09:40 (approx.)</strong> — Baby P experiences severe deterioration and collapses, requiring resuscitation. The prosecution say Letby caused this collapse by injecting air via Baby P’s nasogastric tube.</li></ul><p>Prosecution expert Dr. Bohin later notes in a pre-trial report:</p><blockquote>“The pressure placed on Baby P via the ventilator post-09:40 incident was unusually high for a baby of his size and may have contributed to the pneumothorax.”</blockquote><p>Letby types up her retrospective note later in the evening of 24th.</p><blockquote>“Registrar Ukoh arrived to carry out ward round. [Baby P] had an apnoea, bradycardia, desaturation with mottled appearance requiring facial oxygen and Neopuff for approximately 1 minute. Abdomen becoming distended.”</blockquote><p>The prosecution allege that this entry is a lie by Letby.</p><ul><li><strong>11:30</strong> — Baby P desaturates again. Letby is <strong>not</strong> accused in connection with this event.</li><li><strong>11:57</strong> — An X-ray is taken showing the baby has a pneumothorax, but this X-Ray is not reviewed by the clinical team at the time.</li><li><strong>12:28</strong> — Baby P collapses again. Letby was accused of dislodging a breathing tube. This accusation was added during the trial and is not part of the expert evidence.</li><li><strong>12:30</strong> — A new X-ray is taken. This one is reviewed. The pneumothorax is identified at this point. The 11.57 X-ray is now reviewed as well.</li><li><strong>15:00</strong> — A chest drain is inserted to treat the pneumothorax.</li><li><strong>15:14</strong> — Baby P suffers a cardiac arrest. A subsequent X-ray confirms the pneumothorax has resolved. Letby <strong>not</strong> directly accused of this.</li><li><strong>16:00</strong> — Resuscitation efforts are ended.</li></ul><p>Key to understanding this accusation is the idea that Letby set off the chain of events leading to the baby’s death. The prosecution claims Letby caused the baby’s collapse at 09:40, and so all of subsequent hospital errors during resuscitation can be blamed on her for causing the collapse.</p><blockquote>… [Dr Bohin] concluded that subsequent resuscitation and intubation involving high pressures from the ventilator, together with vigorous resuscitation, can cause a punctured lung. So it’s the treatment for the problem that was caused by Lucy Letby that had caused the punctured lung…</blockquote><blockquote>— Prosecution opening speech— Day 7–13.10.22</blockquote><blockquote>“My impression of the care afforded to [Baby P] after the collapse on 24 June is that it was muddled. There were unacceptable delays in recognition and treatment of the pneumothorax, the ventilatory strategy used, and the use of a high-dose adrenaline infusion was unusual.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Bohin’s report — Day 94–23.03.23</blockquote><p>Dr Bohin went further than Dr Evans, but Dr Evans was prepared to accept the death was a consequence of that collapsed lung.</p><blockquote>Q. Right. In the three reports that you’ve provided us…. you formed the view that the pneumothorax could have contributed to a failure in resuscitation even after the lung had been re-inflated?<br>A. That was my feeling at the time. I couldn’t think of any other reason why resuscitation was not successful.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. <strong>Your view in all three of those reports was that death was the result of complications from that pneumothorax?</strong> <br>A. <strong>Yes</strong>.<br> — Dr Evans cross exam — Day 94–23.03.23</blockquote><p>Despite the errors, both experts stated that ultimate responsibility was due to deliberate harm. In their pre-trial reports they expressed suspicion about the gaseous distension observed on the X-ray timed at 20:09 on the 23rd of June, theorizing it had “splinted” Baby P’s diaphragm, destabilizing him and causing the collapse approximately 13 hours later.</p><p>This was a consistent conclusion across their reports.</p><blockquote>Q. [Quoting Evans’ report] What you say is this:</blockquote><blockquote><strong>“I remain suspicious of the large volume of air noted in the stomach and intestines found on X-ray. It may be the sequence of events was this: the excess air in the stomach and intestines splinted the diaphragm. This would have compromised [Baby P]’s breathing, leading to his collapse.”</strong></blockquote><blockquote>You’re quite clear there that the splinting of the diaphragm is the excess air in the stomach, aren’t you, when you wrote that report?</blockquote><blockquote>A.<strong> I did, yes</strong>.</blockquote><p>In all of his pretrial reports he stated that the cause of death was complications of the pneumothorax. In all of them he said this X-ray was suspicious, could be injected air, and that the police should look at the night shift staff for the culprit.</p><p>These reports set out the conclusions of five years of medical investigation by Dr Evans, now that he has heard other witnesses speak, and exactly what the prosecutions accuse Letby of, he has changed his mind. Now the air at 20:09 didn’t splint the diaphragm and now his medical opinion is someone gave the baby an<em> “extra dollop of air” </em>at 09:40.</p><blockquote>Q. First of all in your reports, let’s see if this is right, you said clearly three times the air at 20.09 splinted the diaphragm, didn’t you?</blockquote><blockquote>A. I did, but I think the air destabilised him. <strong>I think he had an extra dollop of air in the morning of the 24th. </strong>I have said that now three times and that’s my opinion.</blockquote><p>This is a new allegation introduced on the stand.</p><blockquote>Q. So you’re suggesting [in reports] that air in the stomach and intestines at 20.09 on the 23rd was sufficient and is an explanation to cause splinting of the diaphragm that led to a collapse at about 9.40 the following morning, aren’t you?</blockquote><blockquote><strong>A. That was the option at the time</strong>, <strong>yes</strong>, that was the option at the time. <strong>I don’t think that’s now correct</strong>…</blockquote><blockquote>So I think that there were two events. There were two events. So I think there was excess air given before the 20.09 X-ray, if I could put it that way. Then I think that destabilised the baby, but I think he had even more air given into his stomach on the morning of the 24th. That, I think, is a more accurate way of explaining the sequence of events.</blockquote><blockquote>- Dr Evans Cross Exam — Day 94–23.03.23.</blockquote><h3>The diversionary attack: X-ray at 20:09– 23rd June — the night before</h3><blockquote>Putting it bluntly, ladies and gentlemen, the allegation here is that she deliberately caused a problem for [Baby P] as she was going off duty so that overnight he’d have problems, which would divert attention away from Lucy Letby.</blockquote><blockquote>– Prosecution opening speech</blockquote><p>In a mirror of the Baby C case all the prosecution experts initially converged on an X-ray as being evidence of murder. In that case they dropped the X-ray allegation during the trial after finding out Letby wasn’t on duty. Here, the prosecution faces another issue: They can’t connect the alleged injection of air to any serious harm to the baby.</p><p>At 18:00 on the 23rd, Dr Gibbs and Dr Cooke examined Baby P and found him to be “<em>remarkably well” </em>though they noted “<em>mild distention</em>”. At 20:00, the X-ray is taken that the prosecution say is evidence of injection of air. Dr Gibbs in his testimony comments on this x-ray, suggesting that the air on the X-ray is consistent with the distention he observed.</p><blockquote>[the x-ray] It just showed that there was a fair amount of gas/air in [Baby P]’s bowel all the way down his bowel. I mentioned that — it had been mentioned that during examination, his abdomen was mildly distended, that would be consistent with some air being in his bowel, seen on the X-ray. … It is likely, and I would have assumed, that the air in his bowel, being a little more than you would usually expect to see in a baby, was due to the treatment he’d had to support his breathing in the first 2 days of life.</blockquote><blockquote>- Dr Gibbs direct — Day 93–22.03.23</blockquote><p>No evidence suggests these were separate incidents of distention. The prosecution don’t accuse Letby of causing the earlier distention because Dr Gibbs says the baby was fine at that point, yet they do for the later one.</p><p>Dr Evans in his pre-trial reports was so concerned about this X-ray and the baby’s condition over the night shift that he told the police they should focus their investigation on the night shift staff.</p><blockquote>Q. You also then go on to say, in fact, in your second and your third reports, that it is necessary to<strong> scrutinise nursing care during the night shift of the 23rd and into 24 June. </strong>You’re clear about that?<br>A. Absolutely, yes.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. So you’re suggesting that air in the stomach and intestines at 20.09 on the 23rd was sufficient and is an explanation to cause splinting of the diaphragm that led to a collapse at about 9.40 the following morning, aren’t you?<br>A. That was the option at the time, yes, that was the option at the time. I don’t think that’s now correct.<br> <br> — Dr Evans cross — Day 93–22.03.23</blockquote><p>One of the series of coincidences Letby is supposed to answer is that the suspicious events followed her from night shift to day shift. The problem with that narrative is the prosecution experts flagged the night shifts originally then moved them after they realized she wasn’t on the night shift.</p><blockquote>Q. What you have done, Dr Evans, is, having been very clear as to when you say the air first accumulated in your three reports, you’ve simply now shunted it along the line to a point near to, as it happens, when Ms Letby was on duty after the 8 o’clock handover in the morning. That’s actually what you have done, isn’t it?</blockquote><blockquote>A. It isn’t actually, because if I was trying to put Ms Letby in the frame I would have started my concerning issues not on the night shift where the milk was aspirated, but I’d have started my concern on the day shift of the previous day when I understand she was on a call.</blockquote><blockquote>I didn’t do that, so I can’t be accused of putting anybody in the frame because <strong>my initial concerns related to people on the night shift of 23/24th</strong>. […]</blockquote><blockquote>Looking back on it, I think that the air in his stomach at 20.09 was significant and not the result of anything natural. He was not on CPAP, he was not on Optiflow, so therefore I think he had — what I have said is there’s excess air at 20.09. What I did not say was, “I think somebody’s squirted lots of air into his stomach before that”. I didn’t say that, but looking back on it, I think this is — this was the start of his destabilisation.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. What, the 20.09 air in the abdomen?<br>A. Yes, I think so. I didn’t say that <strong>in my report I stuck with the night staff.</strong> But looking back on it, I think that the destabilisation had occurred before that.</blockquote><p>This passage from Evans is incredible because he says “I didn’t just shift things to put Letby in frame, if I wanted to do that I would have done X Y Z”. Then he immediately proceeds to do X Y Z. He moves 20:09 injection from the night shift staff to the preceding day shift, then he introduces a totally new allegation for the next day shift.</p><p>During their testimony Dr Evans and Dr Bohin both changed their minds about the x-ray. They said it still represented a deliberate injection of air but now say that it didn’t cause the collapse. Each of them suggested that now a second injection of air occurred the next morning. Unlike Dr Bohin, Dr Evans doesn’t even bother trying to identify any evidence to support this new injection of air. He simply gives his clinical opinion that the baby collapsed as a result of receiving “<em>an extra dollop of air</em>” around 09:40.</p><blockquote>A. ….In this particular case, the sequence now for me, clinically, is straightforward: he had air injected into his stomach, which showed up on the X-ray of 20.09, that compromised his feeding, they stopped his feeding correctly, but then he had an extra infusion of air into his stomach because — and that led to the collapse at 9.40.</blockquote><p>Myers grills Evans about this accusation not being mentioned in his reports.</p><blockquote>Q. It’s not just not clear, there was no suggestion of it in any of your three reports, was there?<br>A. We’ve discussed this.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Yes, but there was no suggestion, was there?<br>A. It’s not clear in my report but it’s clear now.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. And what you have done is to invent an extra dollop of air, I think is the expression you used, to try and take your theory over the line?<br>A. No, I have not invented any dollops.</blockquote><p>Dr Evans says since he only had the clinical notes the idea he would get things “perfectly right” was unrealistic.</p><blockquote>As I said, I’ve done this reports years ago and the idea that I could get it all perfectly right from simply looking at notes is a little bit unrealistic as far as I’m concerned, especially as I was not able to talk to any of the local nurses or local staff. I had to rely on the notes completely and you’re never going to get it — I was never going to get everything 100% correct.</blockquote><p>Dr Bohin in her evidence tried to say that despite extensively referencing this X-ray she was always talking about 09:40 the next day. The prosecutions opening speech clearly demonstrates that even they were under the impression her reports were talking about the X-Ray:</p><blockquote>Dr Bohin described the abnormal gas pattern seen in [Baby P]’s stomach, which ran all the way down his bowel to his rectum, and she concluded that it was caused by somebody injecting him with air through the nasogastric tube. She described that as “the only plausible explanation”. That excess air had splinted the diaphragm, compromised [Baby P]’s breathing and had caused his collapse.</blockquote><p>The “<em>abnormal gas pattern</em>” was seen at 20:09 on the 24th. Dr Bohin wrote the exact same phrase (“<em>the only plausible explanation”</em>) about Baby C’s X-ray on the 12th, the one Letby wasn’t around for. She changed her mind on that one too.</p><p>As a reminder the prosecution experts track record on these X-rays is exceedingly poor.</p><ul><li>Baby I — X-Ray said to be evidence of injection of air after Dr Evans, Dr Platt, Dr Marnerides, and Dr Bohin all agreed: <em>“thorough review of [Baby I]’s medical notes failed to demonstrate a natural disease process to which that first clinical deterioration on 23 August could be attributed” — </em>Letby not on shift. Allegation was dropped.</li><li>Baby C — As now has been<a href="https://medium.com/@triedbystats/lucy-letby-was-convicted-of-murdering-baby-c-based-on-evidence-from-a-day-when-she-wasnt-on-shift-8fb2bb93e0ef"> comprehensively demonstrated</a>, all the prosecution experts built the allegation around an X-ray from when Letby wasn’t around then dropped it when this became apparent.</li></ul><p>In another parallel with Baby C, Dr Marnerides, the prosecution pathologist formed his opinion after listening to the other experts discuss the X-ray. Unlike Bohin and Evans, the other experts aren’t listening to the trial live. They aren’t able to adjust their evidence. Dr Marnerides’ conclusion on the cause of death for Baby P relied on a hypothesis now abandoned by the other experts:</p><blockquote>A. … I had no explanation and I could not see how a natural disease would have resulted to that. My understanding of the clinical assessment was that there was no clinical evidence of a natural disease accounting to this and that prematurity, in the absence of an evident clinical or pathological pathway to explain the death, would not be consistent with a natural cause of death.</blockquote><blockquote>So we were looking into unnatural causes and the assessment of the clinicians <strong>and thereafter the assessment of the radiologists, but I didn’t have the radiology the first time</strong>, would indicate that there had been excessive injection/infusion of air into [Baby P]’s stomach and intestines.</blockquote><blockquote>— Marnerides direct exam — Day 98–30.03.23</blockquote><p>Professor Owen Arthurs, the prosecution radiologist expert, gets no mention in the prosecutions opening speech for Baby P but he was called to give evidence. Professor Arthurs confirms that the X-ray shows “moderate” distention.</p><blockquote>Q. [Reading the contemporary x-ray report] … Where Dr Wright describes this as “moderate gaseous” distension of the bowel”, do you agree with that?<br>A. If we can go back to the image.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Yes, sure.<br>A. Yes, that’s a reasonable way of assessing the level of bowel distension.<br> <br> — Professor Arthurs cross — Day 90–16.03.2023</blockquote><p>Not only does he state that this is a relatively common image to see but that you can see sometimes see images like this <em>without ever identifying an apparent cause</em>.</p><blockquote>Q. […] I’m refreshing my memory from the joint report of 14 July 2022.But is what we see there something that is relatively common, a distension like that, a presentation like that?<br>A. Yes, if there are underlying clinical causes for it, yes, that’s right.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Is it the case that sometimes it might be encountered but no apparent cause is found, you may encounter images like this and there’s <strong>no apparent cause?</strong><br>A. <strong>Yes, that’s right</strong>.</blockquote><p>This is exactly why Dr Evans and Bohin’s approach of first “<em>ruling out natural causes</em>” then using that as license to come up with theories is so dangerous. It simply may be the case that it is natural causes yet they remain unidentified due to the fact that we have imperfect information.</p><h3>The main event: 09:40 collapse – 24th June</h3><p>At first glance, the main prosecution’s allegation appears compelling. At 09:35, Dr. Ukoh reviewed Baby P during his routine ward round, noting mild distention but no significant concerns. Yet just five minutes later, Baby P required CPR, adrenaline, and a full resuscitation.</p><p>There’s a few problems with this allegation.</p><p>One problem is the room. Nursery 2 is just 4x4 meters in size. At 09:35 on the 24th of June 2016, it was crowded. Present were, at least, Dr. Ukoh, Dr B, Nurse Morgan, Nurse Booth, and Nurse Letby. Dr B said she left just before the collapse.</p><blockquote>Q. And then it was whilst you were all there, after the original review of [Baby P] a little earlier, that he deteriorated suddenly round about 9.40/9.50?<br>A. I agree with that, yes.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Do you recall whether Nurse Letby went for help at that point?<em><br></em>A. <strong>I think, because the room was full of the people we needed</strong>, that negated the need for calling for assistance because everyone was already there.<br> — Nurse Booth – Day 92–21.03.23</blockquote><p>The room can be seen in this video, courtesy of Cheshire Constabulary. Try to imagine four adults in this room, three of them unaware the fourth is attacking a baby. Dr Ukoh said he was at Baby R’s cot, in the same room. The room also has a large interior window looking in directly from the main corridor.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FJcCusGhImAU%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DJcCusGhImAU&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FJcCusGhImAU%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/fab87d912d1095e25a18d0d0d57b3f23/href">https://medium.com/media/fab87d912d1095e25a18d0d0d57b3f23/href</a></iframe><p>The prosecution argues Baby P was healthy at 06:35, based on Nurse Ellis’ record of no distension. At 08:00, Letby retrospectively noted, <em>“Abdomen full. Loops visible. Soft to touch.</em>” The prosecution claims this entry was fabricated to create an illusion of ongoing problems.</p><blockquote>“Abdomen full. Loops visible. Soft to touch.”</blockquote><blockquote>…It was a<strong> fabricated note</strong> to create the illusion of the ongoing problem, the problem that hadn’t existed at 06.40 that morning…</blockquote><blockquote>If [Baby P] really did have an issue at 8 o’clock that morning, we suggest that Lucy Letby would have escalated it immediately, given what had happened to [Baby O] the previous day. But she didn’t escalate it because <strong>there wasn’t a problem. There was nothing to escalate.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>— Prosecution closing speech</blockquote><p>Dr Ukoh (and Dr B) examine the baby at 09:35 and report that baby is doing well. Dr Ukoh records no problems but noted “<em>abdomen moderately distended/bloated, soft”. </em>Dr B also had no concerns about this, describing it as “<em>a little bit distended</em>”. As such, the prosecution does not accuse Letby of causing this distension, instead emphasising the change between 09:35 and 09:40, claiming Letby sabotaged the baby in this brief interval.</p><blockquote>Q. Do you remember Dr Ukoh saying that in that 5 minutes between the ward round examination and the collapse, [Baby P] was in a very different condition?<br>A. No. Different? No, I don’t understand.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Yes, the baby he saw at 9.35 was in a very different condition to the baby he saw at 9.40.<br>A. Yes.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. And the only conceivable reason for that, I’m suggesting, is because you sabotaged him.<br>A. No.</blockquote><blockquote>- Prosecution cross exam of Letby – Day 126 – 08.06.23</blockquote><p>There’s only one other piece of evidence of distention from around this time. Another of Letby’s retroactive notes.</p><blockquote>“Registrar Ukoh arrived to carry out ward round. [Baby P] had an apnoea/brady/desat with mottled appearance requiring facial oxygen and Neopuff for approximately 1 minute. Abdomen becoming distended.”</blockquote><p>The problem is the prosecution don’t believe this one either.</p><blockquote>Here we have yet another example of Lucy Letby <strong>falsifying</strong> the notes to make the situation of a baby look worse than it was. […] Lucy Letby recorded that [Baby P] had been Neopuffed for a minute before he was examined by Dr Ukoh. It’s right at the bottom, I think. We suggest this is a deliberate misrecording, timing a minor collapse 10 minutes before the major collapse at about 9.40 or so.</blockquote><blockquote>— Prosecution closing speech</blockquote><p>Letby explains that her note describes events chronologically: the ward round, the baby’s collapse, resuscitation, and then distension. Basically: it isn’t saying this happened <em>during</em> the ward round.</p><p>This is Dr B’s note of the same event.</p><blockquote>“Dropping sats 6 and heart rate. Just a few mins earlier had briefly seen [Baby P] and discussion with registrar to do a gas, lactate, ammonia, full blood count and CRP. Shortly after this, [Baby P] deteriorated. Dr Ukoh started to bag. IV access x1 was lost as not flushing. Airway maintained with Neopuff bag whilst getting intubation ready. Few attempts at IV access unsuccessful.”<br> — Dr B’s note — Day 90– 16.03.2023</blockquote><p>The prosecution, however, insist Letby’s note is not about the collapse. They say it is an attempt to invent another collapse that happened before the 09:35 ward round. In other words describing events that never occurred at all.</p><blockquote>Q. [Letby’s note from above] That’s a rather different picture to what’s recorded in Dr Ukoh’s note, isn’t it?<br>A. I’m not sure without looking at his note.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Okay, well, we’ll go back to it. […] <br>A. Yes, this is the note that he’s made on the ward round. The apnoea happened afterwards.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. I know, but the — that’s exactly my point. The impression you are creating in the nursing note is it’s as Dr Ukoh arrives that all these events happened.<br>A. Yes, he was in the room at the time, yes.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. No, no, but you have missed out in your narrative the fact that there was a perfectly normal ward round and it was only after the doctor had moved on that the child collapsed.<br>A. I don’t see what the difference is. He was in the room.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Very well. Just going back to your note[…] That note gives the impression, doesn’t it, that it was the Neopuffing that caused the abdomen to become distended?<br>A. That it was becoming increasingly distended, yes.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Yes. But it’s deliberately written, I am suggesting, to create the impression that the distension is the result of the Neopuffing.<br>A. Okay.</blockquote><p>So what is the evidence for distention in between 09:35 and 09:40?</p><p>Nothing.</p><p>There is no evidence.</p><p>All we have is Letby’s note at 08:00, which the prosecution says is a lie and didn’t happen. We have Ukoh’s note at 09:35, which the prosecution says is before Letby sabotaged the baby. Then we have Letby’s other note, which the prosecution says is a lie and didn’t happen.</p><blockquote>[Re- text sent by Letby around 08:00]… No mention to her friend that there’s a problem with [Baby P].<strong> If there really had been an abdominal issue</strong>, given what had happened to [Baby O] the day before, she would have told him, wouldn’t she? You know from the other evidence she was desperate to get him into the unit. <strong>There was no problem.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>— Prosecution closing speech</blockquote><p>Dr Bohin introduced a new theory during her testimony — that the abdominal distension noted by Letby at 08:00 splinted Baby P’s diaphragm, causing his collapse.</p><blockquote>Q. All right. Did you come to any conclusions as to the reasons why [Baby P] collapsed in the first place?</blockquote><blockquote>A. Well, yes. Prior to collapse that morning, [Baby P] developed abdominal distension. <strong>That was noted by Lucy Letby</strong>, the nurse looking after him. That had been a new feature.<strong> I think it was at that point </strong>that the abdominal distension splinted his diaphragm and adversely affected his breathing, causing his collapse.</blockquote><blockquote>– Dr Bohin Direct – Day 94 – 23.03.23</blockquote><p>Firstly, this is not the conclusion in her reports. She’s produced this new theory on the stand.</p><p>Secondly, Dr Bohin has evidently missed the memo. The prosecution is adamant that Letby falsely recorded the 08:00 distension to cover for her attack later on.</p><p>Thirdly, the reason the prosecution accuses Letby of lying about this is because their whole case is that the baby was doing well prior to 09:35, then suddenly collapsed because Letby injected air as soon as Dr Ukoh turned his back.</p><p>When pushed during cross-examination on what evidence supports her new conclusion, Dr Bohin repeatedly refers to Letby’s “fabricated” note as the evidence she relies on.</p><blockquote>Q. And do you agree the only suggestion we have of abdominal distension, certainly being visible, is that given by Kate Percival-Calderbank at 4 o’clock in the morning?</blockquote><blockquote>A. She notes it, Sophie Ellis then says it goes away, and then <strong>Lucy Letby</strong>, <strong>shortly after her start of her shift,</strong> notes that the abdomen is distended and loopy.</blockquote><p>Well yes she does, but according to the prosecution Letby made it up. Yet when Dr Bohin is pushed and pushed by Letby’s defence this is the only evidence she can produce.</p><blockquote>A. […] over the course of the night the abdominal distension reduced and his abdomen was said to be normal by Sophie Ellis and then, shortly afterwards, his abdomen was said to be <strong>distended and loopy when the morning staff</strong> <strong>came on </strong>and then he had a collapse, which is difficult to explain.</blockquote><p>Again, the only evidence of this is Letby’s 08:00 note. This is what the prosecution had to say about it.</p><blockquote>“Abdomen full. Loops visible. Soft to touch.”… It was a <strong>fabricated</strong> <strong>note</strong> <strong>to</strong> <strong>create the illusion of the ongoing problem</strong>, the problem that hadn’t existed at 06.40 that morning.</blockquote><blockquote>— Prosecution opening speech</blockquote><p>Why is it that Dr Bohin can only rely on fabricated notes? Well quite simply because there’s no other evidence of distention.</p><p>Even leaving that major detail aside, this is still evidence from over an hour before the prosecution say the attack took place. Dr Ukoh’s 09:35 ward round is a key event, the prosecution say the baby was healthy at that point.</p><blockquote>Q. Yes. There’s no indication of an abdomen so full of air that it has splinted the diaphragm, is there?</blockquote><blockquote>A. <strong>Not when he examined him</strong>, but 10 minutes later this baby has a cardiac arrest and has a distended abdomen, so I’ve put the two things together and I think the most likely cause is that this baby has splinted his diaphragm and decompensated at that point.</blockquote><p>This is another change. Dr Bohin is now saying the air observed by Letby at 08:00 is no longer when the diaphragm splinted which is what she just said minutes before. According to Dr Bohin now again it is after the ward round at 09:35. Well if it’s not 08:00 or the air seen by Ukoh at 09:35, when is it?</p><p>The “<em>and has a distended abdomen”</em> Dr Bohin mentions comes from Letby’s second note, there’s no other evidence of distention. In that note Letby recorded: “<em>Neopuff for approximately 1 minute. Abdomen becoming distended.</em>”. At the start of her evidence the prosecution even had Dr Bohin join the pile on about this note not being real.</p><blockquote>Q. There was, of course, no mention in Dr Ukoh’s notes of [Baby P] at that stage having an apnoea, bradycardia and desaturation, was there?<br>A. He doesn’t appear to have been aware of the fact that [Baby P] had been Neopuffed for a minute just prior to the ward round.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Yes. In that context,<strong> if that had happened,</strong> who would have told the registrar that that had happened?<br>A. The nurse looking after the baby.</blockquote><p>Again, the prosecution insist that Letby made this up. The reason they accuse her of making up is because she mentioned the Neopuff which is a machine that pumps air into the baby. This naturally causes the abdomen to become distended. They say she included this to explain away the distention.</p><p>A Neopuff <strong>was</strong> used during the baby’s resuscitation at 9:40. Letby’s position is that her note is describing events during the resuscitation. The prosecution say it is describing events that never happened. How can it be evidence of distention if it never happened? If they accept that did happen why are we to disregard the mention of the Neopuff which all other witnesses testified was used.</p><p>So are we to only believe the second part? We are to cherry pick the evidence the prosecution likes and leave the unfortunate parts behind? It’s an unbelievable level of wishful thinking. Either the note is a lie or it is describing the resuscitation after the collapse. The whole point of the fake note according to the prosecution is to create a natural set of circumstances to explain the distention.</p><p>It’s a paradox: They say she lied about distention in order to cover for the later distention, but the only evidence for later distention is her note. Even at that we then have to ignore the fact that the note is describing events after the collapse, not preceding it.</p><blockquote>…it’s like a game of chess with check, check, check, moving around. It’s not the night before. Okay, it’s not the night before. Well, it can’t be that morning because he’s examined by Dr Ukoh at 9.35. Hmm, no, it can’t be. Ah, what’s happened is, in the 10 minutes after that, the baby has splinted his diaphragm …</blockquote><blockquote>— Defense closing speech, on Dr Bohin’s evidence – Day 140 – 30.06.23</blockquote><p>What we are left with is a completely incoherent allegation that relies on multiple paradoxes being sustained at the same time.</p><blockquote>Dr Bohin concluded that someone must have injected [Baby P] with air. She did not take into account the liver injuries, which you can, or Lucy Letby’s bizarre behaviour, which you can, or the fact that his brother had died in similar circumstances the day before, which you can, or <strong>the false records…</strong></blockquote><blockquote>— Prosecution closing speech</blockquote><p>Actually, she did take into account the “false” records: she thought they were real.</p><p>There’s not a single instance of distention the prosecution can point to that supports their accusation. The medical experts both give some variation of opinion suggesting that this collapse is consistent with an injection of air into the stomach.</p><p>Dr Evans has since accepted in media interviews that he has never heard of this condition before. No one has.</p><blockquote>[…] the idea that injecting air into the stomach via a nasogastric tube could cause collapse leading to death was described as <strong>nonsensical</strong> or “<strong>rubbish</strong>”, “<strong>ridiculous</strong>”, “<strong>implausible</strong>” and “<strong>fantastical</strong>”, by eight separate expert clinicians who spoke to the Guardian […]</blockquote><blockquote><em>— </em><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/article/2024/jul/09/lucy-letby-evidence-experts-question"><em>Felicity Lawrence in the Guardian</em></a></blockquote><p>A professor of neonatology told me (in relation to Baby C):</p><blockquote>“The idea that [Baby C] was murdered by inflating the stomach with gas to the extent that the diaphragm was splinted and stopped the baby breathing is a wild speculation and almost certainly not possible. The stomach has the oesophagus connecting it to the pharynx and any gas under pressure would be burped up there before the pressure became high enough to stop breathing.”</blockquote><p>So the argument being made that the massive resuscitation required is the sort of response you would see if the baby had air injected into his stomach, therefore we can conclude that it happened, is weak. Even if we didn’t have very strong reason to suspect that this would not cause a collapse, let alone a collapse of this scale, we have numerous concessions from Dr Evans that no one has heard of it before and there are no papers on the phenomenon.</p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>These are the main two, medical, allegations the prosecution presented for this baby. The remaining three are overfeeding of milk, tube dislodgment, and liver injury, none of them are alleged to have seriously contributed to the baby’s death and the prosecutions case has similar problems as above. I’ve cut them from this blog to save on space and will address them in a follow up.</p><p>An international panel of 14 experts has looked at this case and concluded there’s no evidence of the baby receiving <em>“an extra dollop of air”. [</em><a href="https://lucyletbyinnocence.com/shoo-lee/International%20Expert%20Panel%20New%20Summary%20Report%20of%20additional%2010%20cases.pdf"><em>Listed as baby 16</em></a><em>]</em></p><blockquote>He was treated with high pressure ventilation and adrenaline despite having no lung disease and requiring only 26% oxygen. Both are harmful because high ventilation pressures impede venous return to the heart, resulting in worsening circulatory failure, and adrenaline punishes the heart by overworking it unnecessarily.<br> —Expert Panel Conclusion</blockquote><p>In this case, we have not just plausible natural explanations for the baby’s death; we have natural explanations accepted by the prosecution. What we don’t have is any evidence of gastric distension, and no evidence at all to suggest Letby caused the 09:40 collapse. The simplest explanation for why none of the three witnesses in the room saw anything is simply because there was nothing to see. All the prosecution could offer was a case based on little more than wishful thinking.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v5DKkYFDrKWpIMlPr4c6SA.png" /><figcaption>Nursery 2 — The small room with three witnesses in it</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=05fd410154cb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Baby N transcripts reveal previously unreported door swipe data error in Lucy Letby case]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@triedbystats/baby-n-transcripts-reveal-previously-unreported-swipe-data-error-in-lucy-letby-case-16ff22254561?source=rss-ebaec2cb0eba------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/16ff22254561</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lucy-letby]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crime]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[TriedByStats]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Dec 2024 10:32:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-12-11T19:34:38.813Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<ul><li><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/article/2024/aug/16/evidence-in-first-lucy-letby-trial-was-incorrect-cps-admits">Police have admitted they made a mistake with the door swipe data used in the trial of Lucy Letby.</a> They wrote IN and OUT the wrong way around for all entries for one of the doors.</li><li>The police have stated that the door data was only significant for Baby K, and that the issue was “fixed” before Letby was retried on this count. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/oct/10/lucy-letby-police-cps-handling-case-raises-new-concerns-about-convictions">After reviewing the data they said it didn’t impact any other case. </a>However, transcripts reveal that this same data significantly contradicts key evidence presented in the case of Baby N.</li><li>There is an enormous level of reasonable doubt inherent in this specific accusation. This post outlines the testimony provided by the prosecution experts and the evidence upon which their opinions were based.</li><li>I shared transcripts with an expert in neonatology who says the supposed attack has far more likely natural explanations and their conclusions are deeply dubious.</li></ul><p>Lucy Letby was convicted of attempting to murder Baby N during the night shift of June 2nd to 3rd. The medical evidence for this alleged attack primarily consists of a nursing note stating that a baby was<em> “crying++”</em> which <em>“subsided within approximately 30 minutes.”</em> Additionally, a registrar/junior doctor, Dr. Loughane, briefly attended to the baby before being called away and described the same incident as “<em>screaming</em>” in her note.</p><p>Baby N’s assigned nurse, Christopher Booth, went on break at 01:00 and asked another nurse to look after the baby in his absence. On his return he wrote a note. As he did not witness this event, this note is relaying the description given to him of events recorded by the other nurse after he returned from his break.</p><blockquote>One episode whilst I was on my break whereby [Baby N] was crying ++ and not settling. He became dusky in colour, desaturating to 40s. Responded to facial oxygen within 1 to 2 minutes. Crying subsided within approximately 30 minutes and colour returned to normal. Pink.</blockquote><blockquote>- Nurse Booth’s note of the incident (Transcript 02/03/23)</blockquote><p>Based largely, but not wholly, on this <em>“Crying subsided within approximately 30 minutes” </em>the chief prosecution expert, Dr Evans, theorized it could be an air embolism induced heart attack, or an “inflicted injury”. Dr Bohin said it was due to an unspecified “inflicted painful stimulus”.</p><blockquote>Q. Is there evidence of physical evidence of inflicted injury in what we see on this occasion?<br>A. From my report of 2019, the answer is yes, and I’ll tell you what they are. There was a sudden deterioration at 40%, the screaming and the crying that lasted 30 minutes.</blockquote><blockquote>- Dr. Evans cross (Transcript: 07/03/23)</blockquote><p>The prosecution’s case hinges on the fact that, as no one knows who took over from Booth, it <em>could</em> have been Letby. Since their experts identified harm you should infer that it was her.</p><p>Under the prosecution timeline the attack took place at 01:05. They presented zero evidence linking Letby to any of this. They claim it was one continuous event, yet right in the middle of it, at 01:15, Letby is swiping into the unit via the main hallway.</p><p>The prosecution said the doctor swiped IN at 01:07 then back OUT at 01:20 via the maternity ward door. Unlike the door Letby swiped through, this is the door the police have admitted was the wrong way around during the trial, meaning actually she swiped OUT at 01:07 and back IN at 01:20.</p><p>This fundamentally breaks the prosecution timeline. Dr. Loughane’s brief note about the baby “screaming” was recorded at 01:10 (though this may be a retrospective estimate), and was associated with swipe data prosecution said showed her arriving to the unit at 01:07.</p><blockquote>“On my arrival 40% oxygen, screaming. Sternal recession. Poor trace on sats probe. Pink. Attempt to settle. Crash bleeped away.”</blockquote><blockquote>- Dr Loughane’s note of the event (Transcripts: 02/03/16 &amp; 06/07/23 &amp; 16/05/23)</blockquote><p>Dr. Loughane told the court ‘pink’ means that the baby was recovering by the time she arrived. The doctor was<em> </em>then<em> Crash bleeped away</em> meaning she was called to deal with another baby, this was associated with a swipe entry the prosecution said showed her leaving at 01:20. At some point after this the doctor returned and recorded an untimed note:</p><blockquote>On return, self-ventilating in air, sats 100%. Asleep. Work of breathing improved.</blockquote><p>Asleep. By the time the doctor returned, the baby was neither screaming nor crying. At trial, it was inferred that the doctor returned sometime between 01:20 and 02:00, based on her having left at 01:20.</p><p>Again, this is the door subject to the police error so it actually shows she returned at 01:20. Since the baby was already asleep when she returned, it would indicate the baby had not been crying for 30 minutes. This discrepancy highlights significant issues with the original timeline, which, as we will see, aligned poorly with the rest of the evidence anyway.</p><p>The original swipe data presented at trial was the following. IN means entering the neonatal unit. OUT means leaving it.</p><blockquote>Dr Loughnane swiped IN through main doors after 00:05 but before 01:00<br>Dr Loughnane swiped IN through labour ward at 01:07<br>Dr Loughnane swiped OUT through labour ward at 01:20</blockquote><p>Only the labour ward door is a two way swipe door, you swipe both in and out. The others swipe in but have a button to exit, so don’t have an OUT entry. What was assumed, or inferred, at the trial was:</p><ol><li>Baby has event, doctor is called.</li><li>01:07 doctor supposedly swipes into unit, <em>inferred</em> to be her responding, baby has recovered. Nursing note says it took between 1–2 minutes to recover so they <em>infer</em> that the event took place at around 01:05.</li><li>Timestamp of 01:10 on the note interpreted to mean she was still there then <em>Crash bleeped away </em>then is <em>inferred</em> to be a reference the OUT entry at 01:20.</li><li>Her return note was then <em>inferred</em> to have been written sometime between her supposedly leaving at 01:20 and a test performed at 02:00. There’s no swipe data for her return.</li></ol><p>The doctor has no recollection of this event but the prosecution are able to launder this timeline into evidence anyway by getting her to accept the — wrong — swipe data.</p><blockquote>Q. […] We have the benefit of the swipe data that was recorded at the entrance door to the neonatal unit. It would appear in comparison to your note that at 01.07 you went into the neonatal unit from the labour ward.<br>A. Okay.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Does that at least assist with why you came to look at [Baby N]?<br>A. Yes, presumably I was bleeped if I’d gone from the labour ward to the neonatal unit.</blockquote><blockquote>[…] <br>Q. We’ve seen from the swipe data you had left round about 01.20 that morning.<br>A. Uh-huh.<br>Q. So you were there for about 13 minutes; is that correct? About 13?<br>A.Yes.</blockquote><blockquote>[…]<br>Q. So do we take it from that that you came back to [Baby N] when you’d dealt with whatever it was that caused you to be taken away?<br>A. Yes.<br>Q. […]We have that swipe data again, which shows you going to the maternity ward at 01.20.<br>A. Yes.<br>Q. Is that consistent with your recollection of the time frame?<br>A. I don’t have a recollection, but it fits with my notes.</blockquote><p>This timeline conflicts with the evidence in several ways. Most notably, Dr. Loughane recorded in her note at 01:10 that she was “<em>crash bleeped away</em>.” While this timestamp could be an estimate, it is reasonable to consider it a rough upper limit for when she might have been paged, as it was interpreted in the trial.</p><p>The original prosecution timeline requires that after being called to respond to another baby, she took 10 minutes to walk from Nursery 1 to the maternity ward. Nursery 1 is a small room located behind the door on the left in this picture, while the double doors to the right, which the doctor swiped through, lead directly to the maternity ward.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EalR810-5TYKV1UtJAx7hg@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>This suggests that, after being beeped, she either took 10 minutes to move between the two doors shown in this picture or chose to stay with the baby she had already noted had recovered, failing to respond to the call she had just received.</p><p>The corrected swipe data would actually mean the timeline is:</p><blockquote>Dr Loughnane swiped IN through main doors after 00:05 but before 01:00<br>Dr Loughnane swiped OUT through labour ward at 01:07<br>Dr Loughnane swiped IN through labour ward at 01:20</blockquote><p>This would imply she was already on the unit at the time of the event and was <em>Crash bleeped away </em>just before 01:07. At 01:20 she returns to the unit. On her return the baby was asleep. So a revised timeline would be:</p><ol><li>Baby has event around 01.05 as before</li><li>Dr responds, then is crash beeped away, leaving the unit to respond to the other baby at 01.07</li><li>Writes 01.10 note retrospectively, either estimating the time or writing it at that point.</li><li>Returns to the unit at 01.20 to find Baby N asleep</li></ol><p>This narrows the timeline for how long the baby was crying to between 01:05 and 01:20. While less than 15 minutes is, to borrow a phrase, ‘consistent with’ the ambiguous hand-wavy phrasing in the original note, it is not ‘consistent with’ the prosecution’s interpretation of that note. A non exhaustive list just from Evans’ testimony:</p><blockquote>[neonates] They cry. They certainly don’t cry for 30 minutes.</blockquote><blockquote>[…]apparently cried for 30 minutes[…] very unusual</blockquote><blockquote>[…] Q. Did the length of time, the 30 minutes […] is that unusual?<br>A. Yes, the length of time is very unusual</blockquote><blockquote>[…] if you suggested that any neonatal nurse would let a baby cry for half an hour because they’re hungry, I think you would upset an awful lot of neonatal nurses, so let’s forget all that</blockquote><blockquote>[…] the fact that it was the nurse, actually, who recorded the crying continuing for 30 minutes. So that is an exceptionally unusual finding in a neonatal unit</blockquote><blockquote>[Defence Q’s]<br>Q. And a neonate of that age can cry or scream loudly because they’re hungry, can’t they, as it happens?<br>A. Oh come on, for half an hour?</blockquote><blockquote>Q. They can cry or scream loudly?<br>A. Come on. for half an hour?</blockquote><p>The case here is simple. The doctor left at 01:07 to respond to the other event, then returned at 01:20 to find the baby asleep. The baby was not crying for 30 minutes. If we know the doctor returned to the unit at 01:20 what was she doing if not checking on the baby she’d just been pulled away from?</p><p>If not simply the cleanest and least contrived interpretation of the facts it is at least a defence Letby could have made. However, Letby was denied this defence by police and prosecution error; their swipe data was wrong.</p><p>Instead the defence were left in the position of pointing out the note was ambiguous and refused to accept that the only interpretation was 30 minutes of continuous crying. They were right it would appear. Yet, at the time, what evidence could they have presented to counter the prosecution’s narrative? The prosecution relied on speculation, and the defence was limited to responding, “that’s speculation”, then it’s off to the jury.</p><p>The other piece of evidence comes from the doctors note: “<em>Screaming</em>”. Other than the problems associated with inferring one specific interpretation from a subjective and emotive phrase, the issue with “screaming” is the doctor who recorded it can’t even remember it.</p><blockquote>Q. [On “screaming” in her note] Is that significant in any way?<br> A. So sometimes when you’re very upset and crying a lot, your sats probe doesn’t always pick up very well, if there’s a lot of movement. On reflection, when I read through the notes again, “screaming” is not a word I tend to write that often in notes, it tends to be “unsettled” or “crying”, so I suspect he was particularly upset.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Why is it not a word you write in your notes very often?<br>A. I don’t… I think… Now when I look back and I think, oh, the baby’s screaming… I don’t know.</blockquote><blockquote>Q.[…] Is that an unusual note for you to have made?<br>A. I don’t recall writing “screaming” very often in neonatal notes, so I presume that means he was particularly upset or particularly distressed, crying.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Okay. But you have no direct recollection?<br>A. I’ve got no direct recollection.</blockquote><blockquote>- Dr Loughnane, direct (Transcript: 02/03/23)</blockquote><p>No one recalls this event at all, let alone as an attempt on the baby’s life. If the baby was screaming, no one on the unit remembered it.</p><p>The doctor who wrote the note had so little memory of the event she was actually surprised in court to see that she had written it — a fact the prosecution then used against Letby.</p><blockquote>Q. Do you remember the look of surprise on Dr Loughnane’s face when she was sitting where you are when she saw that word that she had used? <br>A. Yes</blockquote><blockquote>- Letby Cross (Transcript: 07/06/23)</blockquote><blockquote>Do you remember [Dr Loughnane] sat back as she saw the word she had written, didn’t she? “Screaming.”</blockquote><blockquote>And even — well, when I asked her questions in cross-examination, do you remember I asked Lucy Letby about Dr Loughnane’s response to the word “screaming” and Lucy Letby confirmed that she remembered seeing Dr Loughnane do that when Dr Loughnane read the word that she’d written, her own word. <br> <br> That speaks volumes, ladies and gentlemen.</blockquote><blockquote>- Prosecution closing speech (Transcript 22/06/23)</blockquote><p>I have my own opinions on this chained inference of unusualness. However, I can’t tell if I’m being too subjective and others disagree. So I’ll leave it to the reader to take what they will from this.</p><p>I shared the transcript with an expert in neonatology. They were surprised, to put it mildly, that this evidence was the evidentiary basis for an attempted murder. Some of the things they told me:</p><blockquote>“[Evans said] the evidence was a sudden desaturation to 40%, the screaming and crying for 30 minutes. This is nonsense, babies commonly desaturate and cry hard. There are much more likely causes than air embolism”</blockquote><blockquote>“Premature babies often have desaturations. Down to 40% is not unusual during crying. During the expiratory phase of crying babies expire hard, and can reduce their lung volume and pulmonary blood flow.“</blockquote><blockquote>“Some babies do cry a lot and can be difficult to pacify. It is often put down to ‘wind’ or ‘<strong>colic’</strong> although no one knows what the cause is.”</blockquote><p>The first symptom of colic on Mayo Clinic: <em>Intense crying that may seem more like </em><strong><em>screaming</em></strong><em> or an expression of pain.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6myuwRcBJcE_lGDY9uADqQ.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/colic/symptoms-causes/syc-20371074">https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/colic/symptoms-causes/syc-20371074</a></figcaption></figure><p>The point is not to say “this baby had colic”. The point is that crying for an unknown cause, even crying that <em>“may seem more like screaming”</em>, does not appear to be some black swan medical event as the prosecution made it out to be.</p><p>Even just in this baby’s file, the day before and in the days after the baby had incidents of crying and / or desaturations. June 2nd:<em> ”One desat to 67% on handling and upset. Oxygen with effect.” </em>June 8th: ”<em>Desaturation in the middle of the night, self-limiting, did take a while to saturate.”. </em>June 10th “<em>Awake and crying frequently during the nights.”</em></p><p>In fact, this event is so indistinguishable from the rest of the records that Dr Evans, the prosecution’s chief medical expert, “overlooked” it, identifying no harm in his first reports.</p><blockquote>“There is nothing to suspect any significant problem until the early hours of 15 June.” [Letby was accused of another event on 15th but jury didn’t reach verdict]</blockquote><blockquote>- Dr Evans’ 1st Report from 2018 (cross, Transcript 07/03/23)</blockquote><p>Eventually he circles backs to this event and in his second report says it was an “inflicted injury” of an unspecified kind. In his final report he refines this “inflicted injury” into air embolism.</p><blockquote>“It struck me that this baby might — that something had been done to this baby to cause this episode of screaming.</blockquote><blockquote>And so I went back over my notes, I went back over the overarching view I made in relation to injection of air into the circulation from other scientific papers […] a couple of papers, who described babies who had accidentally received an intravenous injection of air into the bloodstream and screamed…</blockquote><blockquote>[…]</blockquote><blockquote>And secondly, they still have this hole in the heart, this foramen ovale, so any air can get from the right side of the heart into the left side of the heart. If it gets into the left side of the heart, it could get into a heart blood vessel, coronary artery.</blockquote><blockquote>So technically, it could cause a heart attack, you know, which is incredibly painful. I can’t prove any of this by the way.”</blockquote><blockquote>- Dr. Evans Direct (Transcript: 07/03/23)</blockquote><p><em>“I can’t prove any of this by the way”. </em>He’s offering a theory. A hypothesis. Again, what can the defence do but say <em>“this is speculation”</em>?</p><p>The defence pointed out that if it were a heart attack the baby needed only oxygen for a minute and that resolved the problem. Dr Evans also starts to back away from his evidence in direct examination and return to unspecified “inflicted injury”.</p><blockquote>Q.[Reading above heart attack theory] Are you seriously suggesting this is a heart attack that’s taking place?<br>A. I don’t think you can rule that out, actually.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. So you — <br>A. I don’t think you can rule that out.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. It’s a self-correcting heart attack?<br>A. Heart attacks — I don’t want anyone to have a attack, but most people survive heart attacks, you’ve got the option — you’ve got — if it goes to the left — sorry, if a bubble of air gets to the left side of the heart, it can go anywhere. If it goes to the abdomen, you see the skin discolouration. If it gets to a coronary artery it will cause ischaemia to a coronary blood vessel — there are three coronary blood vessels, by the way. If it gets to the brain, it can cause a neurological problem, lack of oxygen to the brain.</blockquote><blockquote>So where the bubble goes can vary, but the key thing is the volume of the bubble and the rate at which it goes there. So therefore, as I have mentioned more than once in other cases, what doctors do, we list what we call a differential diagnosis. Okay? We list all possible options. So therefore, what I didn’t mention this morning was I listed a number of possible options.</blockquote><blockquote>Looking at this again, I think that my opinion, as I expressed in the second of my three reports is correct. [Unspecified inflicted injury]</blockquote><blockquote>Q. There’s not even a recorded change in heart rate, is there?<br>A. Not recorded there.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Or blood pressure?<br>A. Not recorded there.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. It’s an unusual heart attack to have no change in heart rate, for instance, isn’t it?<br>A. Not recorded there. I have — I don’t recall ever seeing from my neonatal practice a heart attack in a baby, but that’s because one tends to avoid injecting air into their circulation.<br>- Dr. Evans cross (Transcript: 07/03/23)</blockquote><p>When Myers gets under Evans’ skin two things happen: firstly, his speeches get longer, and secondly he starts making snide remarks. You can see one at the end here, in the process he is admitting he is diagnosing something he’s never seen before. <em>“I don’t recall ever seeing from my neonatal practice a heart attack in a baby” — </em>So how can you be confident a baby crying for 30 minutes means it had a heart attack?</p><p>On piece of evidence he raised in his reports is a paper that recorded an air embolism. The defence questioned if the case of a baby screaming after an air embolus Dr Evans found is even comparable to what happened here.</p><blockquote>Q. [Citing reference in Evans’ report] ”Death by Error” by Daphne Broadhurst describes several cases, and this is one of the two cases you are referring to:</blockquote><blockquote>“She notes a baby of 8 months who was receiving intravenous fluids. The family reported the presence of air bubbles in the line after the nurse squeezed IV bag. The baby screamed, turned blue, arrested and died. The cause of death was said to be cerebral air embolus.”</blockquote><blockquote>A. Yes.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Clinically, and factually, that has absolutely nothing in common with what we’re looking at here with [Baby N], does it?</blockquote><blockquote>A. I disagree. This baby was 8 months to start off with, so far bigger. A baby of less than 2 kilograms would require far less in the amount of air.</blockquote><blockquote>- Dr. Evans cross (Transcript: 07/03/23)</blockquote><p>In what world can you compare:</p><blockquote>The baby screamed, turned blue, arrested and died</blockquote><p>With:</p><blockquote>He became dusky in colour, desaturating to 40s. Responded to facial oxygen within 1 to 2 minutes. Crying subsided within approximately 30 minutes and colour returned to normal. Pink.</blockquote><p><em>Regardless</em>, the prosecution opted to not pursue this heart attack theory. Their case is simply an unspecified “inflicted injury”. As a result, Dr Bohin provides the main source of evidence for this allegation.</p><blockquote>A. […]This is a life-threatening desaturation. He was noted to be crying and the registrar said was screaming and that he apparently cried for 30 minutes, which is really very, very unusual for babies to cry for that length of time.</blockquote><blockquote>It’s rare for preterm babies to cry for long periods. Of course they cry, all babies cry, but they don’t cry for long periods unless they’re in significant pain or discomfort because they very easily can be settled. […]</blockquote><blockquote>In my experience they don’t continue to cry for 30 minutes and nor would a neonatal nurse let them cry for 30 minutes without trying to comfort them in some way. <br> <br> I have never heard a neonate scream. Babies will cry, but I’ve never heard them scream. So on reviewing the notes, there was nothing to indicate that [Baby N] had undergone any sort of painful or unpleasant procedures immediately prior to that event to account for what was <strong>clearly</strong> <strong>a very prolonged episode of distress.</strong></blockquote><p>Is it clear? Under one specific interpretation you could infer that from the note, but really the note is about a 1 to 2 minute episode. There’s no other evidence of any “prolonged” distress beyond that note. It has been inferred, or assumed, by the experts. Bohin concludes:</p><blockquote>A. I could only conclude that this was secondary to an inflicted painful stimulus because something had caused him to be very unsettled, to desaturate with a life-threatening desaturation, and then cry and scream for that period of time.</blockquote><blockquote>Once he had settled, everything reverted to normal, and that was extremely odd, and the only thing I could think of to account for that was an inflicted painful stimulus.<br>- Dr. Bohin direct (Transcript: 07/03/23)</blockquote><p>The only nurse <em>not</em> involved in the baby’s care that night, ironically, was Lucy Letby. The other two nurses, aside from Booth, either signed for medication or recorded readings for the baby. Letby was assigned to care for three babies: two in Nursery 4 and one roomed with their parents. Baby N was in Nursery 1.</p><p>Had Letby signed for medication or recorded readings, the prosecution would have paraded it as evidence to place her in the room during the shift, as they have done in the other cases. Obviously they didn’t extend this logic to the others.</p><p>I’m not going to claim it definitely was one of the other nurses, it’s not possible to say. How could any jury know beyond all reasonable doubt that it was Letby and not Ellis or Taylor that took over from Booth? However, the only evidence that exists points away from Letby. Isn’t she the least likely as she is swiping into the unit after the event?</p><p>How could the medical experts be so sure about a fairly unremarkable note? “<em>Crying subsided within approximately 30 minutes and colour returned to normal”. </em>They are so sure the correct interpretation is “for 30 minutes”, and that the baby was continuously crying rather than say, intermittent periods of crying over the course of 30 minutes. There are clearly other interpretations.</p><p>Dr Evans gives insight into his thinking during cross examination.</p><blockquote>Q. I suggest you said you didn’t consider it to be significant because it wasn’t actually. That’s the reason. Do you agree or — well, you disagree with that, don’t you?</blockquote><blockquote>A. Right. In my evidence in other cases, I have described in many cases, most of the cases, what I have called standalone cases. What I mean by that is this: that from looking at the clinical notes, only looking at the clinical notes, there were features there that, in my opinion, were concerning and also consistent with one or more of the babies being the victims of inflicted injury<br> […]<br> <br> Now, this event of 3 June is not, in my opinion, a standalone case. In other words, if I’d been presented with this sheet on its own, without knowing about the others, I’d have said: well, this is concerning, interesting, you know, suddenly deteriorating and then suddenly improving, how do I explain that in isolation? This is very difficult to explain.</blockquote><p>This is, by the way, a rose-tinted interpretation of his previous cases. Dr. Evans often proposes a theory of murder that he later recants or changes, or attributes to days when Letby isn’t present. Almost every case has him chopping and changing his testimony to fit the facts to the allegation.</p><blockquote>Now, this event of 3 June is not, in my opinion, a standalone case.</blockquote><p>In other words if Letby wasn’t there he’d think nothing of it. The clinical notes alone aren’t enough to identify harm. Or another way, this isn’t objectively harm. It only becomes harm by — incorrectly perceived — association with the accused.</p><p>As usual the media repeated the prosecution expert witness certainty about the event rather than the contemporary witness uncertainty.</p><blockquote>“The jury was told that in the early hours of 3 June, Child N experienced a “sudden deterioration” and was heard “screaming” and then crying for 30 minutes.”<br>- <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-merseyside-64880004">BBC reporting</a></blockquote><p>Again, “for 30 minutes”. That’s not the evidence; “<em>subsided within approximately</em>”. Also, technically, no one told the jury they heard screaming. My pedantic gripes about the BBC’s phrasing, of course, pale in comparison to the Daily Mail’s outright fan fiction.</p><blockquote>Pre-term baby ‘screamed’ for 30 minutes after injury ‘inflicted by Letby’</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11307469/Lucy-Letby-trying-kill-baby-girl-paediatric-consultant-walked-her.html">- Daily Mail reporting</a></blockquote><p>Reasonable doubt seeps through every aspect of this particular allegation. The police found no evidence that Letby was there, they found evidence that indicated she wasn’t, none of the witnesses have any recollection of the event, and the experts initially ‘overlooked’ it before later crafting extravagant theories in their follow-up reports.</p><p>And yet, she was still convicted of it. What should, or could, the defence have done against such speculation? If reasonable doubt exists it must be given to the defendant, in this case it seems to me that reasonable doubt is inherent in the accusation and no jury could have ever resolved that doubt. They should never been put in the position of speculating.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=16ff22254561" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lucy Letby was convicted of murdering Baby C based on evidence from a day when she wasn’t on shift]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@triedbystats/lucy-letby-was-convicted-of-murdering-baby-c-based-on-evidence-from-a-day-when-she-wasnt-on-shift-8fb2bb93e0ef?source=rss-ebaec2cb0eba------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8fb2bb93e0ef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[crime]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lucy-letby]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[TriedByStats]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Sep 2024 20:29:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-16T03:37:12.061Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<ul><li>Lucy Letby is accused of fatally attacking Baby C on the 13th of June 2015 but the only medical evidence presented to prove this accusation was a “suspicious” x-ray taken on the 12th of June —a day Letby wasn’t on shift.</li><li>None of the prosecution experts identified any harm occurring on the 13th in their reports. In initial reports prosecution experts actually concluded the death was due to natural causes. Only the 12th was eventually identified as a harmful event.</li><li>The prosecution called a pathologist who reviewed the original autopsy report. The new story here is that his findings are actually still based on the evidence on the 12th. He only echos the accusations of others, he does not identify harm himself.</li><li>All other prosecution medical reports submitted for this baby are explicitly about the wrong day, the 12th.</li><li>Letby was arrested three times and charged in 2020 with murder prior to the death being even identified as murder by their experts. Police still told the parents in 2018 that they thought the baby had been murdered. No harm, let alone murder, had been identified at that point.</li><li>I shared my findings with the BBC; they’ve conducted their own investigation and explore this and other issues in this <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0023vnp">radio documentry</a>. Listen to this snippet at <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfjRcXbFnOc&amp;t=679s">the 11:20 mark</a>, Dr Evans, chief prosecution medical expert, again cites the x-ray from the 12th.</li><li>[UPDATE] As a result of that reporting, less than 24 hours of this blog going live, Dr Evans has changed his mind and contradicted his sworn testimony, again. H<a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/10/01/lucy-letby-witness-changed-mind/">e no longer believes the allegation presented to the jury, the allegation the judge sentenced her on, is true</a>.</li></ul><p>Baby C died at the Countess of Chester hospital in the early morning hours of 14th of June 2015. The prosecution accused Lucy Letby of injecting air into his nasogastric tube on her night shift on the 13th/14th, causing a fatal collapse around 23:15 on the 13th.</p><p>There’s a huge problem with this sequence. The entire evidentiary foundation of the alleged murder rests on an X-ray taken on June 12th, which showed “<em>marked gaseous distention of the stomach</em>” and a “<em>stomach bubble</em>”. There is no x-ray from the 13th or any evidence of gaseous distention on the 13th.</p><p>In other words the prosecution presented evidence for a murder which occurred on the 12th but accused her of a murder committed on the 13th.</p><blockquote>…Lucy Letby wasn’t working on the Thursday [11th] or the Friday[12th]… <br>… Lucy Letby murdered him, <strong>we say</strong>, on the night shift of the 13th into the 14th…</blockquote><blockquote>— Nick Johnson KC, Prosecution, Closing speech, (Transcript: June 21st 2023)</blockquote><p>Letby was last in the hospital at around 8am on the 10th, finishing her night shift; the baby would be born approximately seven hours later. She next appears around 8pm on the 13th. The actual alleged attack as identified by the prosecution experts took place when Letby wasn’t around.</p><blockquote>Q. Ms Letby wasn’t on duty that day [12th], was she?<br> A. No.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. And in fact, that day falls within several days when she wasn’t in the unit; is that correct?<br> A. Correct.</blockquote><blockquote>— Baby C’s nurse for the 12th, cross examination (Transcript: 27th October 2022)</blockquote><p>Lucy Letby texted the hospital to offering to work on the 11th or 12th. The hospital declined and told her she wouldn’t be needed until the 13th.</p><blockquote>Lucy: “Hi Yvonne, are you okay for staffing over next few days? I don’t have anything on if (sic) need any extra or need to change my nights x.”</blockquote><blockquote>Yvonne: “Thank you for your kind offer. We are okay until Saturday [13th] night…”</blockquote><blockquote>— Text exchange between Lucy and the hospital on the 11th of June. (Transcript: 26th October 2022)</blockquote><p>Throughout the case, and notably in Judge Goss’s summing up, evidence about the event on the 12th is repeatedly reintroduced without acknowledging that Letby wasn’t on shift. For instance, in his summing up of the testimony of the prosecution pathologist Dr. Marnerides:</p><blockquote>[…]He relied on and took account of the<strong> clinicians’ observations of massive gastric dilatation — ballooning</strong>, basically — of the stomach, and considered the reports by the radiologists, both from the defence and the prosecution, who agreed that there was an infection and pneumonia but <strong>there was also massive gaseous dilatation of the stomach[…]</strong></blockquote><blockquote>- Judge Goss’ summing up. (Transcript: 3rd July 2023)</blockquote><p>This all pertains to the 12th. On face value this evidence should exonerate Letby since it is testimony that the dilatation occurred before she came on shift. Without the context of this being from a different day, the Judge is presenting it interchangeably with the prosecution’s accusation about the 13th, which lacks any supporting evidence.</p><blockquote>An X-ray was taken at 12.38 on 12 June […] <strong>Professor Owen Arthurs told you the most striking thing was the dilatation of the stomach, which was full of gas and unusual.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Professor Arthurs’ evidence was that the radiographs show chest infection but also marked dilatation of the stomach and the small bowel. There were several potential causes, he said, which would include CPAP belly, sepsis, NEC or <strong>exogenous air administration</strong>.</blockquote><blockquote>- Judge Goss’ summing up. (Transcript: 3rd July 2023)</blockquote><p>This is true but none of this applies to the accusation. There’s no explicit mention from the Judge of the most important point: Letby wasn&#39;t there.</p><p>Originally they built the case on evidence from the 12th. This led to their pathologist saying the cause of death was “<em>most likely</em>” linked to that “<em>exogenous administration of air</em>” into the stomach. However, even after they accepted the evidence was from the wrong day they persisted with the charge. Since the pathologist gave his opinion on the cause of death as being linked to stomach air we must now <em>infer</em> that another such event occurred, this time on the 13th.</p><p>The transcripts reveal this interpretation is both inconsistent and incompatible with what the pathologist actually said. He was still talking about the 12th.</p><p>An analogy: Imagine it’s illegal to possess a knife longer than two inches. A police officer searches someone and finds a knife they believe is two inches long. The police testify in court that they found a two-inch knife. Later, the prosecution realize the knife is actually only 1.5 inches, so they turn to the jury and say, ‘Well, since the police told you they found a two-inch knife, they must have been referring to a different knife. You must <em>infer</em> that they found two knives — this one and another one, for which we have no evidence’.</p><p>One knife which inconveniently exonerates the defendant and one knife that condemns them.</p><p>Before we walk through the transcripts, some context on the medical review. The medical reviews in the Letby case follow a consistent pattern.</p><ol><li>Dr Evans, the prosecution chief expert witness produces one or more theories on how he thinks a baby could have been harmed</li><li>Dr Bohin “peer reviews” this accusation and writes a report either agreeing with it or coming up with an alternative</li></ol><p>Then specialist experts are given the reports of Dr Evans and the case file to review. They are always given Evans’ opinion first, they never review blind.</p><p>These specialists don’t produce accusations of harm themselves, they review the proposed accusation of harm and state if that could be consistent with or inconsistent with something identified in their area of speciality. In this case the experts are :</p><ol><li>Dr Marnerides, a pathologist, he reviews: photos of the autopsy, microscopic tissue samples preserved, and the original autopsy report.</li><li>Professor Arthurs, a radiologist to comment on any x-rays.</li></ol><blockquote>Professor Arthurs and Dr Marnerides were conspicuously careful not to go further than their specialist expertise would permit them and emphasised any conclusions to be drawn were for those with clinical expertise. [Clinicians are Evans &amp; Bohin]</blockquote><blockquote>— J<a href="https://emptycity.substack.com/p/new-the-lucy-letby-trial-ruling-on">udge Goss ruling on </a>motion of no case to answer</blockquote><p>In his first two reports, dated 2017 and 2018 respectively, Dr Evans did not identify any harm in this case .</p><blockquote>One may never identify the cause of [Baby C]’s collapse.<strong> </strong>He was at great risk of unexpected collapse.</blockquote><blockquote>— Conclusion of Dr Evans’ 2018 report. (Transcript: 1st Nov 2022)</blockquote><p>By March 2019 Evans’ thinking had changed. While he still has no specific harm for the collapse on the 13th, Evans now has the X-Ray from the 12th firmly in his sights.</p><blockquote>It’s therefore <strong>probable the infection was a significant factor in [Baby C]’s collapse </strong>during the late hours on 13 June.</blockquote><blockquote>I am suspicious of the gaseous distension reported on the abdominal X-ray on <strong><em>12 June</em></strong> and wonder whether this represents inappropriate management whereby his attendant inserted excess air into his stomach via his nasogastric tube, doing so in the knowledge that it would cause the infant <strong>discomfort and distress</strong>.</blockquote><blockquote>— Conclusion of Dr Evans’ 2019 report. (Transcript: 1st Nov 2022)</blockquote><p>Dr Bohin, his “peer reviewer”, concurred with both parts of this assessment. Professor Owen Arthurs, prosecution radiologist, also testified that that X-Ray on the 12th <em>could be</em> indicative of injection of air.</p><blockquote>Both experts agree that the radiographs show left-sided chest infection, but also marked gaseous dilation of the stomach and the small bowel. Both experts agree there are several potential causes, which would include CPAP belly, sepsis, NEC or <strong>exogenous air administration</strong>.</blockquote><blockquote>— Joint Radiologist report on the X-Ray from the 12th (Transcript: 11th Nov 2022)</blockquote><p>Professor Arthurs in his direct examination only testifies to radiographs before and on the 12th. He does not testify to any x-ray on the 13th since there are none. He does not testify to any x-ray from the post-mortem.</p><p>This also highlights one reason defence might have problems calling experts: there is nothing to refute. To refute the allegation put forward any defence witness would have to say “it couldn’t possibly be exogenous air” rather than simply “I don’t think it is exogenous air” as Professor Arthurs doesn’t say it was. (There are other factual issues with Arthurs’ testimony that could have been addressed by an expert however)</p><blockquote>Evans: […] That was the last X-ray, by the way, that was taken — the one on the 12th. That was the last X-ray. So the only X-ray — sorry, so <strong>the only X-ray evidence we have is from the 12th, we don’t have any from the 13th.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Evans under cross examination. (Transcript: 1st Nov 2022)</blockquote><p>Aside from Letby not even being there, the prosecution case has two other major problems. Prior to the joint meeting of experts just two months before the trial started, prosecution experts had only identified “harm” on the 12th, not murder. Even worse the prosecution pathologist said in his report he thought the death was due to natural causes.</p><blockquote>Having reviewed the materials provided to me,<strong> I have not identified any suspicious findings </strong>or any morphological or clinical evidence that would justify a view that the death of this baby may have been due to unnatural causes.</blockquote><blockquote>… it is my opinion the most likely cause of [Baby C]’s sudden collapse and subsequent death would be the <strong>histologically identified acute pneumonia with acute lung injury.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Marnerides, prosecution pathologist, 2019 report. (Transcript: 30th Mar 2023)</blockquote><p>Not only did he say that the baby died of natural causes; he also did not identify any<em> “suspicious findings</em>”, nor any evidence that “<em>would</em> <em>justify a view</em>” that the death could have been to unnatural causes. Needless to say these represent problematic findings for a murder charge.</p><p>To fix this the main prosecution witnesses write more reports. They provide these to the Marnerides with an invitation to take another look. He does and in October 2021 he produces a new report:<strong> Still natural causes</strong>.</p><p>Marnerides also confirms, during cross-examination, that in January 2019 the clinicians believed the baby had died of natural causes. Letby was arrested in 2018 on suspicion of murdering a baby whose autopsy recorded natural causes. Both Dr. Evans and his peer reviewer, Dr. Platt (later replaced by Dr. Bohin), agreed. This completely contradicts the prosecution’s public position that they first looked for suspicious events before identifying a suspect. There was no suspicious event — only the fact that Letby was on duty.</p><blockquote>MARNERIDES: […] To put it in as simple terms as possible, in 2019, when I did my first assessment of the case, the clinical assessment I was given was that this baby had clinically pneumonia and <strong>the clinical view </strong>was that that pneumonia from their review <strong>was sufficient to explain the baby’s death</strong>. That was the clinical view I had back then.</blockquote><p>The transcript containing the three police interviews (<em>20th April 2023</em>) about this baby reveals that the police didn’t put any specific expert accusation to her. A departure from the other charges. They have a big gotcha moments in the interviews about other babies, where Letby is accused of murder and then confronted with Dr Evans’ reports. They do ask if she murdered the baby at the very end of the July 2019 interview, but it’s nonspecific, unlike the other charges. They are mostly just trying to place her in the room on the day she was working, the 13th.</p><p>In Novemeber 2020 Letby was charged with a murder that none of the police experts actually said happened.</p><p>Just <strong>*two months*</strong> before the trial starts all of the trial experts hold a joint conference in August 2022.</p><p>At this conference the experts go over the X-ray on the 12th and debate the various potential causes for the distention seen. At the end of this conference Bohin and Evans sign a new “Joint Report” setting out their final medical opinion.</p><blockquote>The cause of the gaseous distension of the bowel and gastric dilation was not CPAP belly. The extent of gaseous distension seen on the X-ray of <strong>12 June 2015</strong> is over and above what is seen in infants requiring CPAP.</blockquote><blockquote>The massive gastric dilation seen on this X-ray <strong>was most likely due to deliberate exogenous administration of air via the NGT.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>— Bohin &amp; Evans joint report, 24th August 2022 (Transcript: Nov 2nd 2022)</blockquote><p>Evans and Bohin both confirm in testimony that this report does not allege harm on the 13th and only on the 12th.</p><blockquote>Q. […] so far<strong> as 13 June is concerned there is no cause identified?<br></strong>A. That’s correct.</blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Bohin cross examination<strong> </strong>(Transcript: Nov 2nd 2022)</blockquote><p>The conference provides one saving grace for the prosecution. Their pathologist, Dr. Marnerides, having heard all the arguments about the X-ray from the 12th produces a final report. This report now links the harm alleged by others as happening on the 12th to the collapse on the 13th. The murder charge finally has a murder, 4.5 years after Letby was first arrested for it.</p><p>At trial Evans and Bohin change their opinions. Bohin states that she still doesn’t have an alternative explanation for the collapse on the 13th but now believes that the incident on the 12th was caused by CPAP. Evans goes even further, saying he believes harm occurred on the 13th based on Marnerides’ report but concedes the 12th was CPAP.</p><blockquote>Q. What evidence do you have of distension to the bowel or the abdomen post-mortem that indicates this was due to air down the NGT as a cause of death? What’s the evidence you rely upon?<br>A. <strong>I’m going to leave the interpretation of the autopsy to Dr Marnerides.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Q. What is the evidence you — I am not asking you to repeat Dr Marnerides’ opinion. What’s the evidence you rely upon when you tell the jury that the diaphragm was splinted on the 13th? What’s the evidence?<br>A. <strong>Baby collapsed, died.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Q. A baby may collapse for any number of reasons. What’s the evidence that supports your assertion made today that it’s because of air going down the NGT?</blockquote><blockquote>A. <strong>The baby collapsed and died.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Q. Do you rely upon one image of that?<br>A. <strong>This baby collapsed and died.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Evans under cross examination. (Transcript: 1st Nov 2022)</blockquote><p>Now the X-Ray from the 12th isn’t the evidence for the accusation. Now it is the third autopsy report of Marnerides, even though in his first two reports he said it was natural causes.</p><p>In principle this isn’t completely unsound. If it were possible to identify deliberate harm from the autopsy alone then presumably you could say that someone must have caused that.</p><p>Marnerides in his testimony categorically and repeatedly states: It is not possible to diagnose harm from the autopsy alone.</p><blockquote>Q. From the pathology, <strong>you</strong> <strong>don’t</strong> <strong>assert</strong> that the diaphragm was splinted in a particular case, do you, from the pathology?<br>A. I cannot, and that — it’s not doable from the pathology.</blockquote><blockquote>— Marnerides under cross exam, Transcript March 30th 2023</blockquote><p>The main point, however, is that his finding of an unnatural death is simply a reference to the harm allegedly caused on the 12th. It is not a diagnosis of harm itself. It is supposed to be supplementary to an already diagnosed event.</p><blockquote>N.B All following quotes are from Marnerides direct examination. (Transcript March 29th 2023)</blockquote><blockquote>MARNERIDES: So what had changed then is that <strong>I had the benefit of the experts’ meeting</strong> which took place, so experts from the prosecution and experts from the defence that were present in that meeting. I had the benefit of more written statements of the clinical assessment. I was <strong>invited</strong> to revisit my view in light of these new statements…</blockquote><p>Marnerides begins by explaining what precisely at that meeting changed his mind. First he notes Evans &amp; Bohins view that it couldn’t just be pneumonia which he uses to justify moving pneumonia to a secondary cause. Then he explains how he found the new primary cause:</p><blockquote>MARNERIDES: …And <strong>there was</strong> <strong>an assessment of what the massive gastric dilatation that was observed — so ballooning, basically, of the stomach </strong>— meant. So all these were taken into account, and having considered the <strong>reports by the radiologists</strong>, both from the defence and the prosecution, who agreed that there is the infection, the pneumonia, yes, we know that, but there is also massive gaseous dilatation of the stomach<strong> </strong>and the small bowel<strong>…</strong></blockquote><blockquote>This part was dilated like a balloon and all these loops were dilated. <strong>That’s what the radiologists concluded</strong>. So lots of air in that.</blockquote><blockquote>Having heard the discussions at the meeting, <strong>having considered the potential explanations about how such a dilatation could have been caused</strong>, I reached my — I revisited the cause of death I proposed and reached the conclusion I reached and it’s noted in my report.</blockquote><p>There indeed was massive gastric dilatation observed… on the 12th. He states unambiguously here and throughout his testimony that the reason he changed his mind is because of the discussion around the X-Ray from the 12th.</p><p>The <em>potential explanations about how such a dilatation could have been caused </em>have now been completely invalidated. The agreed position at the joint conference was that CPAP could not have been the cause. However, the Crown and its witnesses have since accepted that it was, in fact, caused by CPAP. Which the defence expert Dr Hall had told them.</p><p>The next section is quite technical but essentially he is trying to replace a phrase in the original autopsy and say that actually the original pathologist got it wrong: what it actually shows is a dilated bowel. He’s doing that by matching it to the x-ray from the 12th which shows the dilated bowel.</p><blockquote>A. […]if we go back to the photograph and the description by Dr Kokai [The original pathologist] that we read earlier about what was actually crossing and what was distended or not, on the photographs <strong>you can’t really say whether it’s a small bowel or large bowel</strong>, so I need to take a different approach on understanding — <strong>on whether I could confirm the description was accurate or the view of the radiologists that were saying </strong>it’s the small bowel that is dilated, not the large bowel crossing and so on, was correct. So that was the exercise I had to undertake.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. So you were looking at it as working out whether it was the small bowel dilated or whether it’s the large bowel dilated?<br>A. Yes.</blockquote><p>He works through two possibilities to work out “<em>what was distended or not”. </em>The essence of this is that he is evaluating the reports of distention from prosecution experts, again about the 12th, and pairing them to the autopsy. Since he has accepted the conclusions of the other witnesses he can use that as evidence to say the original pathologist was wrong.</p><p><strong><em>Regardless of his conclusion, on face value, it would exonerate Letby.</em></strong></p><p>If he confirms the distention exists in autopsy, which he does, then he’s only able to say that because its the same as the one the radiologists saw. He would be testifying it existed prior to Letby coming on shift.</p><p>If he doesn’t then 16 prosecution reports later we are back to a natural death.</p><p>He continues in his report ruling out various natural causes which are irrelevant since he is mapping a distention which is now accepted to have a natural cause. As we continue down we see his process returns once again to corroborating the other reports.</p><blockquote>Q.<strong><em> </em></strong>You understood, and the jury has heard from <strong>Professor Arthurs</strong>, that his view was that it was the small bowel that we could see dilated in the <strong>radiographs</strong>?<br>A. Yes.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. <strong>So bearing that in mind</strong> as well, what did you then move on to — <br>A. I said, okay, let’s examine this possibility being the truth. What are the potential explanations for that? So one is deliberate exogenous administration of air via the tube. That’s one explanation.</blockquote><p>Again he is building his theory around the X-ray from the 12th. Professor Arthurs testimony only applies to the 12th.</p><blockquote>A. [cont] … So having considered all this, I came to the conclusion that most likely the<strong><em> </em>description about the descending and sigmoid was imprecise and what we were looking at were dilated stomach and bowel.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Q. <strong>Which would be in keeping with the radiology?<em><br></em></strong>A. <strong>Which would be in keeping with the radiology.</strong></blockquote><p>To be evidence against Letby it would have to be <em>inconsistent with</em> the radiology from the 12th, not <em>in keeping </em>with it.</p><blockquote>Q. All right. Having excluded all other possibilities, what about CPAP?</blockquote><blockquote>A. So CPAP — <strong>and I need to express myself with caution here because I’m not the expert on how CPAP actually works in babies</strong>. My understanding is it’s used in millions of babies and it’s a safe procedure in neonatal care units. <strong>My understanding is that the clinicians felt that it is unlikely that CPAP would explain this dilatation</strong>…</blockquote><p>“This” dilatation. Which dilatation? The only one in evidence of course! The one on the 12th. The clinicians view has also changed. Evans &amp; Bohin now accept that it was CPAP after all. Showing directly again one of the explicit assumptions stated by Dr Marnerides has been invalidated.</p><blockquote>A. On the <strong>basis of what I have explained and the information</strong>, I think that the explanation for the sudden collapse in a background of his pneumonia was <strong>the</strong> excessive injection or infusion of air into the tube.</blockquote><p>“the” excessive injection of air. Not “an” excessive injection.</p><p>The prosecution and its supporters will undoubtedly will try and weasel around what is textually blindingly obvious. Putting the literal textual interpretation to one side, you would have to believe he walked into a meeting about the 12th and produced a report contradicting all the other experts at that meeting, then turned up at court and gave about 23 pages of false testimony stating that his report was in coherence with the other experts.</p><p>Marnerides repeatedly cautions that his testimony is based on the opinions of others, the X-ray from the 12th, and the meeting about the X-ray. They are stated as explicit assumptions upon which he relies. Even on those grounds alone, his report should be considered null and void.</p><p>What is the point of having experts explicitly state the assumptions of their report if the report remains valid even when every underlying assumption is withdrawn?</p><blockquote>N.B All subsequent quotes are from Marnerides cross examination the next day (Transcript March 30th 2023)</blockquote><blockquote>This could be explained as death due to unnatural causes, <strong>having been subjected </strong>to excessive and<strong> apparently deliberate</strong> administration of air into his stomach and intestines via the NGT, against a background of acute pneumonia and with acute lung injury, intrauterine growth restriction and prematurity.</blockquote><blockquote>— Conclusion of Marnerides 3rd report September 4th 2022.</blockquote><p><em>Apparently deliberate </em>is not a phrase you would use if you were the one diagnosing it. He is again referring to a specific event diagnosed by others.</p><blockquote>MARNERIDES: […]The histology that I reviewed confirmed the presence of pneumonia. That did not change, it cannot change, it is there. And my response to that was, yes, I see the pneumonia, given that the clinical assessment is that this is enough to kill this baby, I would agree, yes, this is the cause of death.</blockquote><blockquote>Later on, there was further review of the clinical evidence, more reports were produced,<strong> a radiologist assessed the images, radiology images.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>All this information was brought to my attention and we had a joint experts’ meeting. During that meeting, the new clinical evidence that I was not aware of in 2019 was brought to my attention. And the clinical evidence was that the pneumonia being there was not sufficient to kill this baby for that deterioration at that point in time <strong>and</strong> <strong>there were other factors clinically/radiologically present that could explain this death.</strong></blockquote><p>Needless to say the other factor present is the gastric distention on the x-ray on the 12th. He accepts the clinical view that air was injected on the 12th, then incorporates it into the cause of death. The very next paragraph:</p><blockquote>Reviewing the photographs, I said, yes, <strong>the air you refer to is there</strong>, I will accept the clinical review that there is no sufficient clinical evidence for the pneumonia accounting to death.<strong> I have no alternative explanation for that air being there</strong>.</blockquote><p>The air who refers to? The rest of this section of testimony is about the views expressed at the experts meeting about the 12th. He has no alternative explanation for the air so accepts the view of the clinicians about the 12th as the explanation for the air he can correlate.</p><p>Since he didn’t remark on the air previously and originally said the death was natural causes, is it not fair to say that pathologically the air is unremarkable? It’s only with the correlation with the x-ray on the 12th that is becomes remarkable.</p><blockquote>Q. [Quote from his report] “Massive gastric dilation on the X-ray of 12 June 2015 most likely due to deliberate exogenous air down the NGT”?<br>A. Yes. <strong>That’s my understanding from the statements and the views expressed</strong>.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. By Dr Evans and Dr Bohin?<br>A. Yes. That’s what I said.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. So that forms part of the picture that you rely upon in considering alternative diagnoses, for instance, could this be due to air down the NGT which led to the collapse on 13 June?<br>A. Yes.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. You’re taking what they have said about that X-ray and applying it to the circumstances at the time of death; is that correct?<br>A. They said it and the radiology experts say it.</blockquote><blockquote>[…]</blockquote><blockquote>Q. All I’m identifying is you say [in his report]: “The massive gastric dilation on the X-ray of 12 June was most likely due to deliberate exogenous administration of air down the NGT.” And you make it plain, above that, that is something that both Dr Evans and Dr Bohin consider or regard. That’s right, isn’t it?</blockquote><blockquote>A. That’s what I said, yes. That’s what they said to me.</blockquote><blockquote>[…]</blockquote><blockquote>Q. So do you accept, and it’s said, that on that X-ray of 12 June by Dr Evans and Dr Bohin, so we understand this, on that X-ray when it’s said that that is due to the deliberate exogenous administration of air down the NGT, <strong>is that something you accept and work with in forming your pathological views?</strong></blockquote><blockquote>A. Yes, having considered the alternative proposed explanation. [CPAP]</blockquote><p>Again and again, he tells the court his remit is to assess the reports of others and to state which ones he think are “likely”.</p><blockquote>A. […] To make it more applicable to what we’re discussing here, if we are discussing a case with a distended stomach and distended bowels, in vacuum, no clinical information, and I do a post-mortem, I would have said, “There is air, there is distension of the stomach, there is distension of the bowels”. […]</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Yes. But precisely what that is —<br>A. No, no, I can’t say.</blockquote><blockquote>Q. Pathology can’t say that?<br>A. Unless I have clinical or circumstantial evidence saying, yes, there was somebody pumping air or they were doing something,<strong> I can’t say.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>— Beginning of cross exam, Transcript March 30th 2023</blockquote><p>Marnerides did have clinical evidence someone was pumping air. He had the view of Evans and Bohin and their 12 reports. About the 12th. He had no clinical evidence whatsoever to suggest anything about<em> “pumping air” </em>on the 13th.</p><p>Even if we accepted evidence presented by the prosecution it could only sustain an accusation of harm on the 12th, when Letby is not on shift.</p><p>Through prosecutorial sleight of hand, they maintained the accusation even after the entire body of evidence supporting it fell apart. The only evidence they have is Marnerides’ report, but we can see they cherry-picked a conclusion from a report still fundamentally about the 12th, not the 13th.</p><blockquote>.. Dr Marnerides <strong>concluded</strong> that air must have been injected into the nasogastric tube causing a splinting of the diaphragm…</blockquote><blockquote>— Nick Johnson KC, Prosecution, Closing speech (Transcript: June 21st 2023)</blockquote><p>He didn’t conclude that at all. It is the echo of Evans’ theory about the 12th. Again, when asked if he even <em>could</em> come to this conclusion he said:<em> I cannot, and that — it’s not doable from the pathology.</em> As Judge Goss noted, Marnerides and Arthurs had <em>emphasised any </em><strong><em>conclusions</em></strong><em> to be drawn were for those with clinical expertise.</em></p><p>Even by the standards of the Letby conviction, the prosecution’s case here is incredible. They say since Marnerides diagnosed harm, which he didn’t, the jury must simply <em>infer</em> that there was a <em>massive gastric dilation </em>one<em> </em>day after the<em> </em>only <em>massive gastric dilation </em>which exists in evidence. By sheer coincidence. Of course they never actually tell the jury this. They simply present the old evidence as if nothing has changed.</p><p>Part of the confusion is due to the testimony of the prosecutions chief medical expert Dr Evans. Realizing eight of his signed reports were now invalid he simply reneges on his sworn submissions to the court and introduced a new accusation on the day he is called to testify at court about this baby. The same accusation as Dr Marnerides.</p><blockquote>Q. Well, now you’ve come to give evidence to the jury, on the same occasion that you introduce splinting of the diaphragm, you have today discounted infection in any way, haven’t you?</blockquote><blockquote>A. No, I have not discounted infection. I have explained to everybody that the report of Dr Marnerides, who’s the pathologist, highlights the issue of abdominal distension causing the diaphragm — causing splinting of the diaphragm.<br> <br>— Dr Evans under cross examination. (Transcript: 1st Nov 2022)</blockquote><p>Again, Marnerides said nothing of the sort.</p><blockquote>A. I never in my reports or in my opinions in writing said that the distension splinted the diaphragm or induced the vagal nerve system.</blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Marnerides in cross examination. (Transcript: March 30th 2023)</blockquote><p>Marnerides gave his opinion strictly in support of an accusation introduced by Evans about the 12th. Evans knows full well Marnerides report is not about the 13th but introduces it anyway.</p><p>It is the only evidence he can actually provide for the accusation. Again and again he defers to Marnerides’ report. That report was an echo of Evans’s report. Since Evans’ reports are now invalid, Evans now gives oral testimony which is just an echo of Marnerides report. This is a paradox.</p><p>The evidence which only applied to the 12th was repeatedly laundered back into the accusation as if it applied to the 13th.</p><blockquote>Dr Marnerides referred to <strong>“massive gastric dilation”</strong> and <strong>“ballooning of the stomach”</strong>; they’re his words, not mine.</blockquote><blockquote>— Nick Johnson KC, Prosecution, Closing speech, June 21st 2023</blockquote><p>Actually, they’re not his words either. Marnerides was quoting from the radiologists view about the x-ray from the 12th. Its presented to the jury as if it was a finding from the autopsy photos. It was not. What he actually said was:</p><blockquote>This part was dilated like a balloon and all these loops were dilated. <strong>That’s what the radiologists concluded</strong>.</blockquote><p>Regardless of all that was said in court, the jury entered the deliberation room with a bundle full of evidence about the 12th and multiple signed expert witness statements testifying harm occurred on the 12th. They had no medical evidence related to the 13th in their bundle when they, well, ten of them, voted to convict her of a crime committed on the 13th.</p><p>It’s hardly the main story but look at the date under Child C on the infamous shift chart. The 13th… Their experts diagnosed harm on the 12th not the 13th yet it’s there and the 12th isn’t.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_W_ODXiATpwv_4qZi_GhQg.jpeg" /><figcaption>No mention of the 12th..</figcaption></figure><blockquote>Q. Taking a step back then and helping us with the possible causes of why it was [Baby C] had this bubble in his stomach on 12 June, what conclusions did you reach?<br>A. If the tube — the nursing care of the nasogastric tube meant that the tube was not on free drainage and was not aspirated, <strong>then it could well have been down to accumulation of gas by CPAP.</strong> The alternative explanation is that there was a deliberate introduction of air down that tube.<br> <br>— Dr Bohin under direct examination. (Transcript: 1st Nov 2022)</blockquote><p>Remember the conclusion in joint report she signed two months before? The same conclusion in all three of her reports.</p><blockquote>The cause […] <strong>was not CPAP belly.</strong> The extent of gaseous distension seen on the X-ray of <strong>12 June</strong> 2015 is over and above what is seen in infants requiring CPAP. … most likely due to deliberate exogenous administration of air via the NGT.</blockquote><blockquote>— Bohin &amp; Evans joint report, 24th August 2022 (Transcript: Nov 2nd 2022)</blockquote><p><em>“Was not CPAP”</em>. When they know Letby wasn’t there then it “<em>could well have been”</em> CPAP<em>. </em>If Letby was on shift on the 12th do you think they would have told the jury <em>it could well have been CPAP</em>? Dr Bohin had, or should have had, reasonable doubt. The jury should have had reasonable doubt as well.</p><p>This scattershot approach is how they built this case. “Rule out” the originally identified natural causes and fill that void with any unnatural cause no matter how improbable. Everything must have an explanation.</p><p>In the case of Baby A, Dr Evans first proposed “smothering” or “potassium chloride poisoning” before eventually coming up with air embolism. In the case of Baby B, the baby’s notes contained the event “baby removed prongs”, referring to the nasal prongs holding in the CPAP mask. Dr Evans flagged that as a suspicious event, saying he suspected someone removed them deliberately.</p><p>The nurse who wrote the note saw the event, and wasn’t named Lucy, so Evans produced a new theory. Had it been Lucy rest assured we would have 16 medical reports on the impossibility of babies removing prongs.</p><blockquote>A. […] I thought, mm, unusual this. You see, the trouble is, if you ask me, can babies — could they be displaced accidentally, the answer is yes. But I — all I can do is to say I have concerns and wonder whether they were — whether these prongs were removed deliberately, okay. I’m not taking it any further than that, and <strong>it crossed my mind.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Q. Just to confirm, you heard the evidence of [Nurse A] yesterday who described the arrangement you’re talking about and said it wasn’t unusual for them to dislodge?</blockquote><blockquote>A. Yes, I would accept that. I would accept that. <strong>That’s why I haven’t gone to town on it.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Evans cross on Baby B (Transcript: 25th Oct 2022)</blockquote><p>His basis for the accusation is that he saw a picture of the baby with prongs in and decided the arrangement would make it very hard for them to be dislodged. A nurse turns up and says it happens all the time, oh well then. It goes from a murder accusation he raised with the police in his capacity as their medical examiner to something that “crossed his mind”.</p><p>The threshold for suspicion is alarmingly low. In this case, we can clearly see the catastrophic consequences of this approach to medical investigation. All the experts were wrong about the 12th. If Letby had been on shift that day, she would have been wrongfully convicted of a murder allegedly committed on that date, and we would now be facing four experts with 16 medical reports between them, supporting a seemingly coherent accusation of harm.</p><p>This would also represent the first time anyone has actually died from air being injected into their nasogastric tube — ever. The experts ruled out CPAP, incorrectly, because it has never caused a collapse, yet neither has their proposed form of murder.</p><blockquote>When I asked [Evans] if he could point me to any medical literature about this process, he responded, “<strong>There are no published papers regarding a phenomenon of this nature that I know of.</strong>” Several doctors I interviewed were baffled by this proposed method of murder and struggled to understand how it could be physiologically or logistically possible.</blockquote><blockquote>— <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2024/05/20/lucy-letby-was-found-guilty-of-killing-seven-babies-did-she-do-it">Rachel Aviv in the New Yorker</a></blockquote><blockquote>the idea that injecting air into the stomach via a nasogastric tube could cause collapse leading to death was described as <strong>nonsensical</strong> or “<strong>rubbish</strong>”, “<strong>ridiculous</strong>”, “<strong>implausible</strong>” and “<strong>fantastical</strong>”, by eight separate expert clinicians who spoke to the Guardian, seven of them specialising in neonatology.</blockquote><blockquote>— <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/article/2024/jul/09/lucy-letby-evidence-experts-question">Felicity Lawrence in the Guardian</a></blockquote><p>Talking to the Daily Mail, Dr Evan struck back against the onslaught of experts pouring scorn on his theory.</p><blockquote>Dr Evans admitted to me that injecting air in a nasogastric tube is ‘utterly bizarre’ and something he’d never heard of before. But he added: ‘That doesn’t mean it can’t exist.’<br> <br>—<a href="https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13652275/Lucy-Letby-innocent-madness-stop-trials-evidence-proves-guilt-LIZ-HULL.html"> Liz Hull in the Daily Mail</a></blockquote><p>This is a departure from what he told the Jury.</p><blockquote>Q. And you are coming up with things here now, as we go along, to try to support an allegation of harm on 13 June, aren’t you?</blockquote><blockquote>A. No, I’m coming up with<strong> clinically proven mechanisms</strong> that explain why babies collapse.</blockquote><blockquote>— Dr Evans under cross examination. (Transcript: 1st Nov 2022)</blockquote><p>To put it mildly, I think that it is misleading to tell the jury a medical condition that you’ve never heard of, and think is <em>“utterly bizzare”</em>, is “<em>clinically proven</em>”. All while knowing that there are “<em>no published papers</em>” about it.</p><p>In this case the autopsy and coroner report concluded that the baby died of natural causes. The prosecution experts originally agreed. By falling into a feedback loop of their own reports, they gradually convinced themselves that it couldn’t be “just pneumonia” and that the distention couldn’t be caused by CPAP. They kept escalating until their identified harm of <em>“discomfort and distress” </em>became a means of murder.</p><p>Not only did the experts converge on the same opinion, they converged on an opinion about the wrong day.</p><p>This conviction is undeniably unsafe. That is beyond question. Even with access to all the transcripts related to this charge it still took some time to untangle the prosecutions case. For the jury to have reached a “safe” conviction on this count they would have had to disregard almost everything they had been told. Disregard all medical evidence they were shown. Disregard all expert reports they had at hand.</p><p>They would have had to rely solely on the testimony of Dr Evans. Testimony which explicitly stated it relied on the other expert opinions. Even at that, they would have had to ignore about 95% of it, cherry-picking the assertions that it couldn’t simply be pneumonia and that, since Dr. Evans claimed to be able to rule out all natural causes, it must therefore be an unnatural cause — despite the absence of any supporting evidence.</p><p>The jury would have needed an exceptionally good memory to accurately reconstruct all the nuances as the time between Dr. Evans’ testimony in November 2023 and the verdicts being returned in August 2024 is considerable.</p><p>Whether the flimsy legal sellotape which surrounds the accusation should have been enough to sustain it in court is one question. The more important question to me is: “could any rational person believe this evidence shows this baby was murdered?”.</p><p>Given the above, I believe the definitive answer is no. Marnerides’ report is inseparable from the evidentiary foundation it was based on. It is clear as day that the original plan was to build the case around the 12th. They now have no medical evidence to suggest that anything happened on the 13th.</p><p>As ever free to get in touch with comments, questions and corrections.</p><p>Twitter: https://x.com/triedbystats<br>Email: triedbystats@gmail.com</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ah6HZVo8EZGg6FfBGho1Pw.jpeg" /></figure><p>These two tweets are the only public reporting that exists for what was said in Marnerides direct testimony on Baby C (we have more for cross examination the next day).</p><figure><img alt="His full testimony on Baby C for that day ran to 19 pages" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OmLGqo3t_HVuYcw5KwtbfQ.png" /><figcaption>His full direct examination runs to 23 pages for that baby. (First half is just explaining phrases in the original autopsy and outlining assumptions)</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8fb2bb93e0ef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>