<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Luke Muench on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Luke Muench on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@unstableshelf?source=rss-d6f6896b3fdb------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 02:41:20 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@unstableshelf/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unstable Shelf: W. Maxwell Prince, Martin Morazzo, and Chris O’Halloran]]></title>
            <link>https://unstableshelf.medium.com/the-unstable-shelf-w-maxwell-prince-martin-morazzo-and-chris-ohalloran-af0feff09016?source=rss-d6f6896b3fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/af0feff09016</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[comic-books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[image-comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dc-comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[superman]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ice-cream-man]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Muench]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Oct 2026 15:04:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-02T14:20:18.484Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/473/1*YSfSa5YFukzUdOqkG4OseA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo of W. Maxwell Prince from Image Comics</figcaption></figure><p>Welcome back to the Unstable Shelf, where today we’re going to be discussing the works of the comic book all-star team of W. Maxwell Prince (writer), Martin Morazzo (artist), and Chris O’Halloran (colorist). When I initially set out to put this article together, my intent was to highlight interviews and discussions featuring all three creators, but as I dug deeper and deeper, I found that Prince has largely become the spokesperson of this trio. Morazzo has occasionally appeared in interviews alongside Prince but spoken sparingly, and I didn’t find any interviews with O’Halloran. So while the comics we read and will be discussing today features all three of these creators, we’ll be viewing them primarily from the lens of Prince.</p><p>This feels fitting in some ways due to how this team initially formed around Prince and his unrelenting desire to create comics. Living in Brooklyn, Prince did his best to surround himself with the comic book medium, both for the purposes of inspiration and to make the connections needed to break into the comic book industry. Prince <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXK6ufTf4R4">shared one story with <em>Let’s Talk Comics</em></a> that highlights the lengths he was willing to go to be seen by other creators and the reception he often received:</p><p><em>[There was a] certain popular artist who hasn’t had anything come out recently that I know of, for a while he drew some Image books, some DC books, his wife owned a coffee shop in Brooklyn […] he was putting on an exhibit of his pages of his original art at this coffee shop on a night when New York had a terrible snow storm, like 12 inches, trudging up to your thighs. I was very far from this event, but I was like, I’m gonna go, it was a Friday or Saturday […] There was pretty much no one there by the artist, his wife, and a couple of close friends of theirs […] One of them was paging through [a draft of my work] and didn’t realize I brought it and said ‘oh god, who drew this, it’s fucking terrible’.</em></p><p>Prince was often met with this hostility by other creators, who viewed his methods as incorrect and not worth their time. Gradually, Prince began to pull away from his peers and the negativity that they brought, focusing on his vision of the kinds of stories he wanted to explore.</p><p>Prince has always been interested in writing more experimental work, playing with the medium in ways that he hasn’t seen before. As he <a href="https://chachor1.medium.com/an-interview-with-w-maxwell-prince-8dde9486df27">explained to Richard Chachowski</a>, he often finds it easier to work within a framework of limitations that he creates for himself:</p><p><em>Those issues are actually easier for me than standard stuff. I’m a problem-solver by nature, so presenting myself with a kind of structural puzzle gets me excited and pushes me forward in a way that a more traditional script doesn’t.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/667/1*0a5YEZuSszIXin19_oZj2g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Due to the weird ideas Prince looks to play with, short-form writing became his default, allowing him the flexibility to bounce between ideas without an overarching narrative restricting his creativity. You can see this as early as <em>One Week in the Library</em>, with each issue following a character who gets sucked into a variety of books. Each issue reframes how the story is told, playing with the medium in ways that Prince would further explore years later in his <em>Ice Cream Man</em> series.</p><p>A big motivation to write, <a href="https://chachor1.medium.com/an-interview-with-w-maxwell-prince-8dde9486df27">he told Richard Chachowski</a>, was the want to contribute to a medium that he had already invested his time into:</p><p><em>I think certain people do enough reading and start to think they should be giving as much as they’re taking. I started to feel selfish, consuming so much art and not offering anything in return.</em></p><p>Even when Prince’s work began found traction through Image Comics, he still found himself struggling to find success, needing <a href="https://chachor1.medium.com/an-interview-with-w-maxwell-prince-8dde9486df27">another job</a> to support his work:</p><p><em>I have a full-time job outside of comics, so I don’t write as much as I’d like to. I average about 3 days a week, maybe four hours at a time. But I also get a lot of important work done — be it editing or writing or just thinking — on the subway, or at the gym.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*k2kP1U3Lu9uGCtmH_02_Pg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Prince <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8KtxArHrN98">told the Comic Book Club</a> how he first met Martin Morazzo when searching for an artist for <em>Art Brute</em>, a series that features a team of characters leaping into famous paintings and adjusting the characteristics of those works. Having admired Morazzo’s work for some time, he sent him a cold email seeing if he would be interested in the project, laying out the difficult nature of having to mimick the art styles of various well-known paintings. Morazzo accepted, and the pair went to work on this ambitious project. Unfortunately, the project landed poorly when it was released; a last minute name change to <em>The Electric Sublime</em> combined with a lack of advertising led to the series launching without much fanfare. It was only after the duo saw success with <em>Ice Cream Man</em> that the series was rereleased in 2023 with its original title intact.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JVcqV0GsMk_QX69qvA1yqQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>It was here that Prince and Morazzo joined forces with Chris O’Halloran to put begin one of their most ambitious projects to date, <em>Ice Cream Man</em>. A series constantly working to reinvent what comics are, the team has used the platform to present some of the most ambitious comics in the past decade. Perhaps their most inventive idea to date, in November of last year, the team released a deck of cards, titled <em>The Mortal Coil Shuffle</em>; it’s an issue of <em>Ice Cream Man</em> told through the medium of cards designed and formatted to look like <em>Magic the Gathering</em> cards.</p><p>Prince <a href="https://www.comicsbeat.com/interview-w-maxwell-prince-ice-cream-man/">explained to Comics Beat</a> about how he pulls a lot of inspiration from his own life to explore the dark, brutally honest struggles his characters grapple with in the series:</p><p><em>I grew up in the suburbs, in New Jersey. They were down the middle, middle class suburbs. When you’re a kid, you start to realize your quaint little town is a lot more messed up than you think. My most shocking memory as a child: my mom was driving us somewhere and there were a lot of dirt roads in my hometown. My mom was in a fun mood, and she was like, ‘why don’t we go down it?’ So, we go down it and what we discover at the end of it is a shooting range, and it was a shooting range run by a local chapter of the KKK. That was the juncture my mom had to explain to me who the KKK is and what hate for other people is. It’s similar to the Goonies finding an underground world: your little town has stuff that is just beyond your comprehension. The suburban focus is that. Beyond the ice cream man being a horrific presence, there are horrific things going on in these towns that have nothing to do with him.</em></p><p>This only became more pronounced when <a href="https://www.comicsbeat.com/interview-w-maxwell-prince-ice-cream-man/">Prince’s daughter was born</a> right around the time he began writing the series:</p><p><em>I had a daughter two-and-a-half years ago. It’s cliche, but your perspective and priorities change. With the kind of world we’re living in right now, it’s really anxiety inducing to have a human life you’re responsible for. I found that all these ideas about the way people are, the way the world works, how certain things are unfair, how certain things don’t make sense, how certain things are beautiful — I’ve always been a person who thinks of that stuff anyway, but once I had a daughter, it all started to bubble up. It was pretty raw. I was worried about doing right by this person. I’d have something I was worried about over the course of a week, and I would find it would make its way into my book.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/585/1*hN0gcsT3TZk_mkC58vKfrg.png" /></figure><p><em>Issue four is about a person who is not sure if they want to be a dad, but he’s also negotiating his friend who just died, and that friend’s dad wasn’t there for him. He then has to see this man have this regret at the end of his life for not being there for his child. That was all culled from stuff I was going through, being really nervous about being a new father, and then seeing friends of mine having relationships with their fathers that were strained or non-existent. That’s one example, but there’s actually a lot of child anxiety in these issues. There’s a baby in the neapolitan issue and issue seven is about what if your kid gets lost. All this stuff makes it way into the book.</em></p><p>Of all of the <em>Ice Cream Man</em> series, I chose these first 2 volumes in part because for many new readers, it would be off-putting to start anywhere else (although I don’t really think it’s much of a hurdle to jump volumes), but also because the second volume, <em>Strange Neapolitan</em>, is easily my favorite of the series to date. It has some of the most successful and interesting premises for its issues and is one of the more consistent stand-alone volumes across the series. And as the title suggests, it’s largely anchored by the beloved neapolitan issue, issue #6, <a href="https://www.comicsbeat.com/interview-w-maxwell-prince-ice-cream-man/">an evolution</a> of one of Prince’s earliest works:</p><p><em>Going back to </em>One Week in the Library<em>, there was a silent issue in that, and that chapter got nominated for an Eisner. I wanted to revisit that format, and I had a whole story setup where it was just one story being told silently. For some reason, in my head there was a panel where he got three scoops and they were neapolitan. I thought, what if that could be a motif of this whole issue? I just worked through it. I could tell three silent stories where these different exceptional things are happening, but they are all in a way the same story. Another part of this is I feel almost guilty writing a whole silent issue, so I want to make sure there’s a lot of meat for someone.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*HwoAwuktriqbslAziq6_jw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ice Cream Man “Ptoo!” (Issue 6), Page 4</figcaption></figure><p><em>Once I had the idea, I worked through my notebook, trying to figure out where the stories split, how I could pace them to somewhat match each other, and then also pace them to land on certain pages at a similar note. A lot of it was taking pages four through seven and getting them on the same track. I really told the story in increments to make sure none of the narratives deviated too far in pace, scope, and tone. It was trying to figure out what I would show to make them all run at the same speed.</em></p><p>To me, <em>Ptoo!</em> captures everything that this team of creators is trying to capture in the series in an immediate and easily understood way. You don’t need the context of the world at large, as you get a sense of the unsettling horror and creepiness, and melancholy and frustration with a world that doesn’t make sense, and there’s a human element to the framework that grabs you. Everyone has considered the roads not traveled, and this helps us to process and ruminate on those considerations while leaning into the fantastical and absurd.</p><p>Issue 8, <em>Emergencies</em>, is another all-timer for me, as we follow a pair of irresponsible and flawed paramedics as they navigate an evening of chaos with an eerie detachment while they try to sort out their own self-destructive behaviors, which work to feed into the awful things occurring around them. There’s an intimacy to the story that, while framed around the ridiculous, draws me into this world every time and makes me hurt for these broken people, even as they make terrible decisions that impact themselves and those around them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/290/1*uYBAfRl-G8e94BZ105f3-A.jpeg" /></figure><p>This issue is actually called back to in a separate anthology book, <em>Haha</em>, written by Prince but drawn by a variety of creative teams. While each of these issues are their own standalone stories of clowns who are grappling with personal issues while embracing the madness of life, the final issue of the collection tells the story of a dead clown discovered in the pages of <em>Emergencies</em>, with Morazzo and O’Halloran on art duty. Prince loves tying his various works back into <em>Ice Cream Man</em> in silly but fitting ways; he does the same thing with <em>Swan Songs</em>, an anthology about the “endings” in its various definitions, with the final issue once again reuniting this dream team in the world of Riccardus and his nightmares.</p><p>While I mentioned above that you can really jump into any issue of <em>Ice Cream Man</em> and get something out of it, I will admit that there is something gained from reading the series from start to finish. There are various entities that exist within the borders of the story that jump in and out of each issue, tools of Riccardus’ machinations, with call-backs to previous issues. Certain characters will also reappear sparingly, and occasionally Prince will self-insert himself into the stories in a very literal way, speaking to the struggles he’s facing or experiencing in a more direct way than typical.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*pMDgueVYbTP4juwEpqGHhA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I can’t say that every issue of <em>Ice Cream Man</em> is a success; the very first issue is a great example of a book trying to find its footing. I remember reading it years ago as a part of an Image Comics sampler and not thinking much of it; it was only after hearing about the hype surrounding the series years later that I gave it a proper chance, and wow am I glad that I did.</p><p>But regardless of the success of any one issue, I think the series as a whole speaks to the want to explore the boundaries of this medium and what can be done with it in a way few other creators can claim to be trying. It’s natural that not every experiment will succeed, but when this team is trying something novel nearly every issue, it can be impressive how well it all works as a whole. I will admit that I’ve begun to fall off of the series around issue 30 or so, with a feeling of repetition, but I think the team feels that to some extent as well. Issues are released very occasionally, with only 3 or 4 released over the course of a given year. And I think that’s okay, for them to take their time to find the things they really want to say rather than just pumping out empty issues while they try to find something worth expressing.</p><p>Something that I find really endearing about this team’s work, outside of the vision and creativity they channel, is how they work to use this platform to highlight other creators or to make important statements about social change they want to see. Sometimes it’s within the text of the book itself, with issues tackling touchy subjects like abortion in thoughtful and nuanced ways that are respectful of the topics and the people they impact while feeling fitting within a fantasy world. But other times, this is done through the way in which the series is released, the statements the creators make, or the people they choose to highlight.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/384/1*FMDIpdeZ9tO240nmcuwz1g.jpeg" /></figure><p>The easiest example would be the Quarantine Comix effort; in the early days of COVID when comic books couldn’t be made in the traditional sense by publishers, Prince, Morazzo, and O’Halloran worked to put together a series of web-comics, both in an effort to cheer up readers through safe means and to raise donations for charity, as 50% of the proceeds went to the Comicbook United Fund and BINC. Post-COVID, you’re still able to buy these issues (now in a physical format), and the same donations will be made on your behalf through the purchase.</p><p>Another more sensitive example is how the <em>Ice Cream Man </em>team responded to allegations against one of the artists contributing the variant art covers for the series, as was <a href="https://comicsxf.com/2020/07/02/writer-w-maxwell-prince-on-dropping-cameron-stewart-his-ice-cream-man-plans-and-remaking-the-world/">reported by Will Nevin</a>:</p><p><em>Prince said it was 3 a.m. when [Deniz Camp sent him an article regarding] artist Aviva Maï Artzy’s description of [Cameron] Stewart’s attempts to groom her when she was a teenager. That same early morning, he sent an email to Image Publisher Eric Stephenson saying the </em>Ice Cream Man<em> team would be dropping Stewart because, as Prince told me, ‘I don’t want to work with people who perpetuate trauma.</em></p><p><em>‘What I do know deeply is that I don’t want to work with people who perpetuate trauma. I want to be a force, in either a small or big way, toward creating an even playing field for all artists. … the thing to do (or the thing I feel is most useful to do) is put your money where your mouth is. That could mean donating to charities/funds, or hiring women and people of color, or marching in favor of these causes. There’s also a kind of quiet activism one could partake in: getting to know your neighbors and coworkers that fall into any of these persecuted demographics, talking to them and “listening” in a way that isn’t performative and online, but local and intimate. And then restructuring the way you operate based on their candor. It’s important for me to get all this as right as possible, and soon, because I want to teach my daughter to be a decent human being in a world where it’s very easy to avert your gaze from real suffering and injustice. It’s incumbent on all of us to get it right, too, because the stuff we (so-called progressives) preach ain’t exactly what we’ve been practicing.’</em></p><p>It’s clear from the way that Prince speaks about these topics that he cares deeply about making a positive impact on the world when making comics, and I’m sure that extends to Morazzo and O’Halloran as well, being such close collaborators with the more outspoken member of the trio.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*PjCm0Yiftkdh9Iv2k744Qg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Superman: The Kryptonite Spectrum</em> is the most surprising twist in the history of this creative team to date; for years, Prince has spoken about how much he prefers short-form writing for its flexibility, allowing him to jump between ideas without needing to linger on something too long. And he’s been resistant to working with publishers other than Image Comics due to the restrictions that come with working on IPs and well-established characters. Yet, here we have a 5-issue mini-series set in the world of DC and featuring one of the three biggest characters the publication writers. In fairness, I think what makes this a far more appealing proposition for the team is the fact that it’s a “Black Label” book, meaning it doesn’t have to work within the confines of the “canon” of DC Comics. In other words, this book essentially takes place in an alternate universe, although in many ways it feels rooted in the lore we’re all familiar with.</p><p>And just because this is a DC book doesn’t hold anyone back from playing with the medium in similar ways that <em>Ice Cream Man</em> has for years. Don’t get me wrong, it’s not particularly dark or gruesome, but the way in which it toys with the formatting of comics, how stories are told, and the human roots to the story all calls back to the team’s strengths. This is a story about how our homes affect who we are, sometimes in unexpected and dramatic ways, and it touches on an earnestness that touched me personally. The cast of characters are chosen thoughtfully rather than simply because they are well-known or popular, and the emotions that are expressed throughout the series struck a chord and made what can often feel like an alien figure and made him far more relatable to me.</p><p>I particularly love the creative ways in which the new strains of kryptonite toy not just with how Superman operates, but how the comic tells us its story, messing with how the reader views time or space, resulting in a whimsy that tickled me endlessly. Issue 4 is likely the highlight for me, when Superman is drawn into the cartoony realm of Mr. Mxyzptlk, which allows for some incredibly creative visual gags and moments that have stuck with me well after I finished reading.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FyT9NtUERRrfCFbdFmFEGA.png" /></figure><p>It’s easily my favorite thing this trio of creators has worked on, and thankfully, I’m not the only one who saw just how dang good that book is. Since then, the team was greenlit for a Deadman series, which has been so successful that the series has been extended beyond it’s initial 6-issue run due to the “fan response.” In an industry that can be plagued with bad actors, it really warms my heart to know that this team, that’s working so hard to make a positive difference with their writing, are seeing such success and the love of the community.</p><p>One such creator who’s been touched by Prince’s work in particular is Deniz Camp, a creator who has been on a tear recently with a number of successful comics releasing in the last couple of years, and this is partially in thanks to Prince’s willingness to put Camp’s work in front of Image Comics, insisting that they give him a chance. Because of this, next month’s reading assignment is going to be the recently finished <em>Absolute Martian Manhunter</em> series by Deniz Camp, as well as the first volume of <em>Assorted Crisis Events</em> (a series with a lot of similarities to <em>Ice Cream Man</em>, interestingly enough). We’ll also touch on Camp’s and Prince’s blossoming friendship and how they have supported one another in their creative endeavors.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/994/1*fo-qPNpR2tlVwggqEBlvgQ.png" /></figure><p>But for those of you looking for more work from Prince, Morazzo, and O’Halloran, I’ve largely covered everything the team has worked on up until now; they’re still cranking out issues of <em>Ice Cream Man</em> every few months, but there’s a pretty sizable backlog for you to check out. You can take a look at <em>Haha </em>or <em>Swan Songs</em>, Prince anthologies that feature Morazzo and O’Halloran in the final issues. There’s always <em>Art Brute</em> if you want to see Prince and Morazzo before they got in touch with O’Halloran. And obviously there’s <em>Deadman</em>, which is still actively being written, but the first volume should be released sometime soon.</p><p>Thanks again for taking the time to follow along and read these amazing comics with me; I hope you’ve been enjoying what we’ve been covering, or at least getting something positive from the experience. As always, this series is only made possible due to the many talented people who have done interviews with Prince and company in the past; if you’re so inclined, check out some of the interviews I’ve pulled from throughout the article (links provided throughout) and show those creators some love too. Feel free to let me know your thoughts about any and all of this down below, as your feedback is always welcome, and I look forward to chatting with you again in a month’s time.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=af0feff09016" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unstable Shelf: E.M. Carroll and A Guest in the House]]></title>
            <link>https://unstableshelf.medium.com/the-unstable-shelf-e-m-carroll-and-a-guest-in-the-house-c64355f9e3d6?source=rss-d6f6896b3fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c64355f9e3d6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[halloween]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[graphic-novels]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[horror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[em-carroll]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Muench]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2026 14:16:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-01T14:16:59.960Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/490/1*AmBXGQanSUbUNLzi47GP3A.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://emcarroll.com/">E.M. Carrol Self-Portrait</a></figcaption></figure><p>Welcome to today’s issue of The Unstable Shelf, where we’re going to be talking about E.M. Carroll and their career thus far as a comic book creator. This month’s comic book reading assignment was Carroll’s most recent graphic novel, <em>A Guest in the House</em>, which we will be reviewing/discussing below. If you didn’t get around to reading it yourself, I highly recommend you give it a shot, as it’s an incredibly special book. There will be spoilers below, and while I don’t think spoilers should ever take away the value of a truly well-made book like this, I do think it is worth experiencing <em>A Guest in the House</em> organically if possible.</p><p>E.M. Carroll, previously known as Emily Carroll, began creating webcomics back in 2010, many of which are catalogued on <a href="https://emcarroll.com/">their website</a>. Their breakout hit, <a href="https://emcarroll.com/comics/faceallred/01.html"><em>His Face All Red</em></a> was released on Halloween of 2010 and became a viral hit online, drawing a lot of attention to their work. While they continued to focus on their online portfolio, Carroll began compiling an anthology of short stories centered around that work, which eventually became their first physical release, <em>Through the Woods</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/719/1*EKuPVaHXcscFjUDy1Y1Xyg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The first panel of <a href="https://emcarroll.com/comics/faceallred/01.html"><strong><em>His Face All Red</em></strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>Over the years, Carroll has built an impressive catalogue of webcomics that they offer for free on their website, with a focus on dark fairy tales, identity, and the subversion of traditional comic tropes. A highlight that you should check out if you have a few minutes is <a href="https://emcarroll.com/comics/darkness/"><em>When the Darkness Presses</em></a>, a webcomic that is as horrific and introspective as their other works, but is framed by colorful, fake ads that juxtapose the topics being discussed.</p><p>General influences for their work are children’s books like <em>Goodnight Moon </em>and the works of Dr. Seuss, both of which terrified them as a child. Illustrators such as Henry J. Ford and Chris Blain have also been noted as influences for their more heightened, fantastical styles.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WHA_-Zs8uzuScS2lpzucGA.jpeg" /><figcaption>An excerpt from <strong><em>Through the Woods</em></strong></figcaption></figure><p>If there’s one thing I’ve noted over the past year when I’ve taken the time to get acquainted with Carroll’s work, it’s their incredible attention to detail. And while this can be seen in everything they work on, this month’s reading assignment, <em>A Guest in the House</em>, is emblematic of their work ethic and care when creating art.</p><p>It’s worth noting that a lot of the behind-the-scenes information I discuss below was learned by listening to an <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4JKT5tbh3jI&amp;list=WL&amp;index=6"><em>Off Panel</em> podcast interview</a> with Carroll. If you want to learn more or just want to support the podcaster who hosted that interview, consider giving it a listen when you’re done with this article.</p><p><em>A Guest in the House</em> feels like the culmination of the years Carroll has put into their craft, pulling from a variety of their earlier works to build a narrative that is both fresh and reflective of the creator’s history and bibliography. This is immediately apparent when Carroll discusses the lead character, Abby, who shares both physical and emotional traits with many of the protagonists from Carroll’s earlier webcomics, notably the leads of <em>His Face All Red</em>, <em>Out of Skin</em>, <em>Some Other Animal’s Meat</em>, and <em>Beneath the Dead Oak Tree</em>. All of these characters are reflective of underlying themes that permeate Carroll’s writing; the struggle with unfulfilled desires, the questioning of identity, and the disconnect from their own bodies and reality.</p><p><em>His Face All Red</em> is especially notable, not just because it was one of Carroll’s earliest literary successes, but because both lead characters have the same stylized button eyes. This was intentional, a choice Carroll made early on in the process of creating <em>A Guest in the House</em>:</p><p><em>I was having such a hard time figuring out how she looked when I was drawing the comic because I just couldn’t take her seriously. Because she was just a cartoon I was drawing! So I was like, she just looks like a cartoon, I can’t draw her realistically enough, and I realized that the issue I was having is that every time I tried to draw her eyes, she looked wrong, like her eyes just looked wrong. So Abby is the only character in the comic who just has, like, circle eyes. I gave her little orphan Annie circle eyes, which is extremely cartoony, but for some reason it allowed me to take her seriously and see her like a person.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1020/1*NUVwljJxAR_5HY7p-L8dDA.jpeg" /><figcaption>An excerpt from <strong>A Guest in the House</strong></figcaption></figure><p>A large part of what makes this book so successful is how earnest Abby feels; she feels lived-in, a person you’ve met in your day-to-day life. It’s clear that bits and pieces of Abby have been pulled from Carroll’s life, either from themselves or the people around them, and it lends the story an authenticity that is hard to match.</p><p>And I don’t just mean emotionally; Abby is drawn like a real, human woman, not one of the hyper-sexualized, Adonis-like superheroes that often feature in Marvel and DC comics. We, the audience, take Abby more seriously because, on some level, we *know* her. Her struggles are honest, even when Carroll dips into fantastical ideas and imagery, making the stakes that much more meaningful, and giving the narrative beats a heavier impact.</p><p>The art of <em>A Guest in the House</em> is staggering in quality; Carroll is a self-proclaimed perfectionist, a fact that’s clear from the moment you look at the cover for this book. When talking about their process, Carroll has expressed the lengths they’ll go to ensure their work meets their expectations and vision. When conceptualizing their writing, they often start by creating fully finished art for the opening section of the story:</p><p><em>I want to know what the limits of my mechanical skills are or how I can realize the thing that I’m imagining in my head […] that form and those abilities will impact how I will tell the story.</em></p><p>This can lead to fully finished art, countless hours of work, getting scrapped in the process:</p><p><em>In </em>Through the Woods<em>, there were 40 finished pages that just weren’t working and got thrown out. There were cool sequences and stuff, but if they aren’t serving the story, I don’t really care.</em></p><p>There’s a willingness to not “be precious” about the work and know when to cut content because it will drag down the pace of the narrative or mess with the flow of the story. To me, that’s more impressive than a long-winded story filled with superfluous content. That tightness of focus allows for the book to communicate its messages more clearly and elevate the material by drawing your eye only to what’s important.</p><p>That attention to detail extends to the text used in the story. When first working on <em>A Guest in the House</em>, Carroll felt like the font they were using didn’t work well with their art, as if it sat overtop the art rather than melding with it. Eventually, they used Photoshop to write over the font, modifying it with their own handwriting so that the text would fit more naturally with the rest of the work. When certain characters talk in the book, Carroll uses their own more stylized script to give characters a stronger “voice” within the story.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*NIXh_-T_ueND6sCyUFCWtg.jpeg" /><figcaption>An excerpt from <strong>A Guest in the House</strong></figcaption></figure><p>While all of Carroll’s art is stunning to behold, some of the highlights of <em>A Guest in the House </em>are the gorgeous illustrations used for Abby’s dreams, with the brilliant colors and fantasy imagery heavily juxtaposing the grey that fills Abby’s humdrum daily life. It’s a visual representation of how Abby views themselves and the world they live in, creating an immediate understanding of the mindset this character sits in without having to say a word.</p><p>As Abby’s mental state gradually deteriorates throughout the story as she tries and grapple with her unfulfilled desires and the expectations put on her by her role as dutiful wife and stand-in mother, these illustrations become more bombastic, and more telling of Abby’s true feelings. It’s as if the fantasies are trying to break out of her skull, and become more aggressive in their imagery as they fight to escape into reality. In denying herself her own identity and the needs that come with that, Abby begins to fall deeper into her own delusions to try and make up for what’s missing, leading to some of the most tense and emotional moments the book has to offer. This stark contrast works to make us appreciate both halves of Abby’s life and see her struggle between two worlds personified in a way only comics can.</p><p>The centerpiece of the narrative is the lingering ghost of the wife Abby has replaced. Her husband having lost his previous partner a couple of years prior, Abby begins to see this apparition follow Abby as she tries to adjust to her new life and role. Sometimes, there’s the feeling that the ghost is angry and resentful, but other times it feels like there’s an mutual understanding of the doubts and anxieties Abby goes through. That same complexity that makes Abby such a compelling lead extends to her spiritual “companion”, both helping to inform Abby’s feelings while becoming a character in her own right.</p><p>The ghost also serves to question reality; is the ghost an actual spirit haunting Abby, or is she just another delusion that stems from Abby’s imagination? The book goes out of it’s way not to answer that, a choice that goes a long way in allowing the reader to be an active participant in the story rather than a passive observer. We get to choose how to interpret things, and the author never wants to stand in the way of that.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*VuT-j0J5ihBNnoEJwJgyTA.jpeg" /><figcaption>An excerpt from <strong>A Guest in the House</strong></figcaption></figure><p>When speaking about one of her indie comics <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZFIY1rFlBo&amp;list=WL&amp;index=7">years earlier</a>, Carroll talked about their intent when it came to ambiguous conclusions to her stories:</p><p><em>I just wanted to leave it open-ended because I kinda like that kind of stuff, so that readers can take ownership over certain elements of it.</em></p><p>That mentality and intention is prominent in <em>A Guest in the House</em>, and it serves to make the story feel more personal. This is how *I* choose to read this story, and that allows me to feel more invested in what’s happening. It also lends the story a re-readability, allowing us to go back and consider multiple interpretations that help to inform our experience with the story.</p><p>An important component of any horror story is timing. The way in which we internalize and experience information can inform how scary a scene is. And while that’s easy to control in a movie, where the director and editor control what the audience sees precisely, that’s a lot harder to balance in comics:</p><p><em>You can’t control time, so the page turn is one of the few things you have to create that tension, or the closest approximation to a jump scare that you could have, or reveal, so page turns are very important to me.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*v2QF23rL4L5t-0vVJKpItw.jpeg" /><figcaption>An excerpt from <strong>A Guest in the House</strong></figcaption></figure><p><em>A Guest in the House</em> is very mindful of how the pages are framed, allowing for tension to build and grow, so that when you turn the page you are hit with startling and gut-wrenching reveals. These are moments that have stuck with me weeks later, and it allows the story to become a part of your life rather than something you experience and forget about days later. The thrills are never cheap, always purposeful in implementation, but when they are used, it’s to great effect.</p><p>One of my favorite examples of this is the attic scene towards the latter half of the story, a scene only made possible by a unique technique used in the creation of the book. Carroll used 3D visual models of various rooms of the house featured in their story to help determine what perspectives they wanted to present different scenes from, created with the help of Carroll’s wife, <a href="https://www.katecraig.net/">Kate Craig</a>, a video game artist. This helped especially when placing the “camera” the audience sees through in ways that might have been otherwise hard to conceptualize, providing the book with a dynamism and depth that lends to the horror.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/713/1*JP1nn3NWloqgF-mCktxQZw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Promotional image from <a href="https://emcarroll.com/art/guestinthehousesplash.jpg">E.M. Carroll’s website</a></figcaption></figure><p><em>A Guest in the House</em> is dripping with love and care, with every facet of the story handled with precise attention to detail. Again and again, Carroll went the extra mile to frame the story in such a way to tell a wholly unique and thoughtful story in a way only they could, making it stand out on the shelves and showing readers why they are one of the modern comic creators you should be keeping your eyes on.</p><p>If you enjoyed this and want more from E.M. Carroll, I’d first and foremost recommend <em>Through the Woods</em>, the anthology book emblematic of their start as a comics creator. It’s a different type of book, feeling more like a selection of Grimm’s Fairy Tales with a Carroll twist, but it’s still excellent in all the most important ways.</p><p>The other major book Carroll has published is <em>When I Arrived at the Castle</em>, which I liked well enough but didn’t fall in love with as much as their other two published works. Still, it is good and worth checking out if you’re hungry for more.</p><p>Carroll has done some other works where they’ve only provided the art, such as the graphic novel adaptation of the 1999 novel <em>Speak</em>, which is a YA novel designed to educate about and discuss sexual abuse and its impact.</p><p>In terms of their webcomics, you can read a plethora of their stuff <a href="https://emcarroll.com/">on their website</a>. I personally recommend <em>The Prince and the Sea</em>, <em>Out of Skin</em>, and <em>When the Darkness Presses</em>. They’ve also released a number of <em>Bloodborne</em>-inspired comics on their <a href="https://emcarroll.itch.io/">itch.io page</a> that you should give a look if you have a fondness for the video game franchise.</p><p>While they haven’t announced any new projects on the horizon as of writing, Carroll has a habit of releasing a physical book every 5 years (<em>Through the Woods</em> in 2014, <em>When I Arrived in the Castle</em> in 2019, and <em>A Guest in the House</em> in 2024), so I would hope for a new release in 2029 at the earliest, though I’ll keep my eyes peeled for any announcements.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/254/1*59AdyJp0gN3-FVOknxCBMQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cover for <strong>Ice Cream Man Issue #1</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Next month, we’ll be focusing on a team of creators; writer W. Maxwell Prince, artist Martin Morazzo, and colorist Chris O’Halloran. This team has worked in tandem on a few different series, but we’ll be looking to highlight Volumes 1 and 2 of <em>Ice Cream Man </em>(8 issues total), as well as <em>Superman: The Kryptonite Spectrum</em>. I plan on posting my next article on October 1st, so you have until then to read along if you’re so inclined.</p><p>Thanks for taking the time to read this, and let me know your thoughts below. What did you think of <em>A Guest in the House</em>? Do you have any feedback about my write-up today? And what creators would you like to see be put in the spotlight in the future? Happy reading, and I’ll see you next time.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c64355f9e3d6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unstable Shelf: A Monthly Guide to Comic Book Creators]]></title>
            <link>https://unstableshelf.medium.com/the-unstable-shelf-a-monthly-guide-to-comic-book-creators-0f494689f5e8?source=rss-d6f6896b3fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0f494689f5e8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[reading-club]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marvel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[image-comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dc-comics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Muench]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Aug 2026 17:25:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-11T17:27:17.541Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IJr25GElmUZZkD4m5EAThg.jpeg" /></figure><p>I love comic books. Have since I was 8 years old. I remember it clearly; it was my birthday, and my cousin/role model surprised me with a gift; <em>Marvel Masterworks: Amazing Spider-Man Vol. 1</em>. by Stan Lee. At the time, I had never really dabbled in comics, let alone comics from well before I was born, but I found myself hooked by the world, the characters, the *wham* *pow* action. And it just so happened that later that year, Sam Raimi’s first <em>Spider-Man</em> film came out, a screening that I excitedly attended. It’s hard to express, in retrospect, to pinpoint my feelings in that moment, whether or not that film was transformative or in some way altered to course of my life. The most memorable thing about it, thinking back, was how my younger sister needed to be escorted out of the theater, terrified by Willem Dafoe’s terrifically cheesy portrayal of the Green Goblin. But what I do know is that, from that day on, super heroes became a part of my life.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UwKH3D78KiHYqf8NS5DO1A.png" /></figure><p>I began to ravenously devour what comics my local library had. Typically, these came in the form of the then very popular Ultimate comics. Obviously, Ultimate Spider-Man was a big draw, but I loved the canon as a whole. I began learning about the X-Men, the Fantastic Four, and the various characters that inhabited this world. And in the meantime, I dabbled in whatever else I could discover. I have a strange memory of <em>Hatter M Vol. 1: The Looking Glass Wars</em>; not a particularly well-written or gripping book in its own right, but I was entranced by Ben Templesmith’s unique brand of art. I also recall chugging through the first 18 or so volumes of <em>One Piece</em> before my library ran out, putting a sudden end to my journey, as I didn’t have the sense or interest to go digging for more.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*E-4udtSXoMKl3dpWE0w34A.jpeg" /></figure><p>You may note that, despite how my cousin gifted me my first comic book, he has largely be absent from this narrative otherwise. That’s because, by and large, I was left to my own devices to discover comics. Sure, he would provide some tangential guidance by gifting me a comic now and again (sometimes one I already owned, little did he know). But by and large, I was on my own to figure out what to read, what made a “good” comic, what knowledge or background I needed to engage with a particular book. Thankfully, this was an era of comics where years of history were being gently nudged out of the way in favor of more accessible books, which I think made a huge difference in my exploration. The fewer barriers to entry, the easier it was for me to stumble my way into the stuff that spoke to me.</p><p>I’m not sure when, but at some point I had a falling out with comics. I think due to how much literature I consumed in general, I found my interest in reading sputter out for a little bit. My visits to the library decreased from weekly to bi-weekly to every now and then. Anime was the new craze, another medium my cousin introduced to me, and I was falling down the rabbit hole of Bleach. It was only just before I went to college that my childhood best friend recommended we go check out that new <em>Avengers </em>movie everyone was talking about. I was resistant, thinking that it would be a waste of time, but he encouraged me to give it a shot. Once again, seeing some of Marvel’s greatest heroes on the big screen threw me back into comics, and I’ve never left those glossy pages since.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/1*sQ8idptNgt2y1yEqgNqkIw.jpeg" /></figure><p>All of this is in an effort to give you some background regarding how I came to become wholly invested in the medium. Of all my hobbies, this is perhaps the one I am most passionate about. Not only is it a style of storytelling that I love wholeheartedly, but it’s also one I had to learn for myself. I did the research, trudged through truly bafflingly bad books in an effort to learn how to identify the best the medium had to offer. I began to recognize the techniques artists used to guide your eyes across a page, learned the power of how a comic’s panels are framed. It’s taken a long time to get where I am, and I’m still learning every day. But it’s hard to understate how that hard work has led to me loving the medium that much more.</p><p>Which is what brings me to this; a series of articles I intend to release monthly to help aspiring comic book readers get into what is typically a niche hobby that is, on the surface, intimidating and uninviting. And, for those of you who are veterans of the medium, this will act as a way to introduce you to new creators who are actively making interesting things that are noteworthy and worth your time.</p><p>There’s a stigma surrounding comics that suggest you need to have years of history and understanding to read comics. Marvel and DC particularly perpetuate this perspective, as they are the publishers who prominently tout their long-running worlds and the histories associated. While this was once the case, these days this is far less important or applicable. Sure, there are plenty of books out there that expect you to have knowledge and understanding for a particular character, but more and more often, comics are written to be easy to pick up. And in this series, we will be talking about comics from every publisher, including Image, Vertigo, Dark Horse, and so on. These publishers don’t usually have massive amounts of lore like Marvel and DC, making it that much easier to just pick up a book and start reading.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*csoiPgT1rMTZ1EQoHFSbkg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Now, some might wonder why I would focus on creators instead of characters. I hear so many people talking about how they just want to read more books about Thor or Wolverine or whoever, and that’s an entirely valid way of reading. If a specific character does something for you, I’m glad you’re taking the time to invest your energy in those stories. However, I find that this can lead to many disappointments as well. Thor, for example, has been featured in countless stories, written by countless writers, and each of those writers has imagined Thor differently. The way he speaks, acts, interacts with his fellow Avengers, changes from book to book because someone else is giving him a voice. To me, no one character is good or entertaining in their own right, but there will always be certain authors that bring life to a character. I love, for example, Jason Aaron’s interpretation of Thor, specifically in the God Butcher Saga. It’s a specific incarnation of the character that speaks to me personally. No other author has written him in quite the same way, and while I don’t mind other interpretations of that hero, Aaron nailed it for me. And thus, I went and explored other Jason Aaron works and discovered other stories he wrote that I loved, because his writing speaks to me in specific ways.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/360/1*p-n37y7rThlwLXW8Uf3zFg.png" /></figure><p>Additionally, focusing on a single character locks you into a single publisher, which I find to limit your horizons in ways that can be detrimental. I spent so much of my youth reading Marvel comics, I never really gave DC much of a chance, outside of the occasional run of Batman or Wonder Woman. I would dabble, but never look particularly deep in the DC catalog. These days, I actually far prefer DC comics to Marvel’s, though I think that’s indicative of certain writing trends and the creators each publisher employs rather than anything regarding the characters. But if I was so focused on a specific Marvel character, I would have never given myself the opportunity to discover Animal Man or Mister Miracle or any number of other characters, written by creators that I fell in love with as well.</p><p>So, here’s the plan: each month, I’ll be releasing an article that highlights a particular creator who is currently working in the comic book medium. In part, it will be a brief history lesson, highlighting the creator in question. In part, it will be a book club; I’ll let you know what comic I’ll be highlighting as one of their stronger works, and I’ll provide a brief review of that comic in the article. At the end, I’ll provide some more recommendations of comics that creator worked on so that you can go out and read more if you enjoyed the comic of the month. And at the end of each article, I’ll let you know what we’re reading next time so that you can follow along. This is obviously new, so this format may change over time, but this is how I’m imagining it. If you want to follow along, great! If not, that’s okay to, or you could always skip a month if you’re not interested in a particular creator. I’ll probably post other articles here now and again, but this monthly “book club” of sorts will be a focus on mine moving forward. It’s something I’ve been wanting to start for months, and I’m excited to start doing the work, giving folks a resource to more easily read comics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/718/1*yNWxo1QcwFWOaZZLpyKPGQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>So, our first creator spotlight will be focusing on E.M. Carroll, with the reading assignment being <em>A Guest in the House</em>, released in 2023. It’s a stand-alone book, so you don’t need any additional context, but this story does deal with some heavy, sensitive topics, so please be mindful of that and take reading breaks if you need to. Due to the nature of this being the first reading assignment, I’ll be posting my next article on September 1st; typically, I’ll give a full month for folks to read, but this is a shorter assignment anyway. You can read this on Kindle if you’re reading digitally, or you can track down both trade paperback and hardcover copies if you’re reading physically.</p><p>Thanks for taking the time to read along, and I look forward to seeing you again soon!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0f494689f5e8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unstable Shelf: One Bad Day Reviews/Ranking]]></title>
            <link>https://unstableshelf.medium.com/the-unstable-shelf-one-bad-day-reviews-ranking-2a7f129acaef?source=rss-d6f6896b3fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a7f129acaef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[eisner-award]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[batman]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dc-comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Muench]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Jun 2026 20:06:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-23T20:06:41.054Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TCv9gFYFTupAAZqvaX89Ug.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit: </strong><a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/comicbooks/comments/16m11dv/how_would_you_rank_the_one_bad_day_books_from/">Reddit Spread</a> of the Various <em>One Bad Day issues</em></figcaption></figure><p>Back in 2022, DC Comics decided to do a somewhat novel series of premium one-shot stories featuring 8 different Batman villains, showcasing a day in their lives. While lightly based on the language/premise of The Killing Joke, these stories lacks any of the offensive and problematic elements of that original story, which is a much-welcome adjustment.</p><p>On a whim, I decided to read them all to see how they held up, and I enjoyed the experience enough to want to make a ranked list so I had an excuse to discuss them more thoroughly than I otherwise would have been able to. While not every one of these are bangers, I think there’s enough good at work here to highlight the series as a whole, as I think this is the type of comic book project I would want to promote. These are stories that feel universal to the characters featured, with little outside context needed and largely feel like fully fleshed-out narratives on their own.</p><p>While I do have my preferences, I do think all of these stories try and do something interesting, which makes this a far more enjoyable list to compose than something where there are clear stinkers, allowing for some internal competition as well. It’s also been interesting reading some of the internet dialog surrounding the series as well, as it seems there’s some clear division between what books people have engaged with.</p><p>Enough of the babbling, let’s get into the thick of it.</p><h3>#8: The Last Vengeance of Bane</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gNgOfoQvYJTM7TRaxx7Ddg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Writer: </strong>Joshua Williamson</p><p><strong>Penciller/Inker:</strong> Howard Porter</p><p><strong>My Rating: </strong>2/5</p><p><strong>Premise:</strong> Retiring from being a villain, Bane has found success as a pro wrestler, though he doesn’t find the work overly fulfilling. So when a young boy brings him news that the Venom drug is being newly manufactured, he goes on a quest to destroy the remaining supply, facing the past he left behind in the process.</p><p><strong>What It Does Well: </strong>Porter’s art is easily the strongest part of the series, a rough, brutal style that feels fitting with a character that is so physical. There are certain page spreads that showcase some fast-paced fisticuffs that makes the action feel visceral and fierce, taking rather basic fights and elevating them to be something more eye-catching.</p><p>Beyond that, Bane is given the opportunity to have a clear character arch, which can be hard to accomplish within a short page count. It’s nothing revolutionary or especially groundbreaking for the character, but it’s nice to see it working as a strong connective tissue to tie the narrative together.</p><p><strong>How It Falls Short: </strong>The story itself is fairly basic and unsurprising, with nothing that I found to be particularly easy or surprising. Bane is mostly fighting goons, and the big bad isn’t anyone that I found to be compelling. His relationship with his “sidekick” character feels forced and unnatural, and even with Porter’s art, I never found the fight sequences to be anything especially noteworthy. At times, the art could actually make it harder to tell what was going on, with certain panels being drawn exceptionally small; yes, this is an interesting stylistic choice, but I can’t say that it worked for me.</p><p>That being said, I feel like I’m a little biased in this ranking; Bane is a character I typically find to be relatively flat and uninteresting, a fact that I do think comics try and address from time to time. This book clearly acknowledges this, both in its premise and through the above panel, but I don’t think it effectively circumvents the feeling that Bane peaked years ago as a hero, and more so in being a barrier for Batman than being a compelling character in his own respect.</p><h3><strong>#7: <em>A Great Man</em> (Two-Face)</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1BNdvT7w5IWKw2zEVpCPPg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Writer: </strong>Mariko Tamaki</p><p><strong>Penciller/Inker:</strong> Javi Fernandez</p><p><strong>My Rating: </strong>2/5</p><p><strong>Premise: </strong>Harvey is once again reforming his ways, returning to being a politician and fighting against the prejudices weighed against him. When he receives a threat against his father and his upcoming 80th birthday celebration, he contacts Batman to help keep his family safe.</p><p><strong>What It Does Well: </strong>The premise is interesting enough to have kept me engaged throughout the story; while a brief mystery, the book is given enough time to lay out some clues for the reader to follow, and the narrative feels fitting to Two-Face and his struggle to return to normalcy in spite of his accident. The framing and pace gives something of a <em>Batman: The Animated Series</em> vibe, which is always welcome, and some more “obscure” Bat-Family characters like Spoiler and Cassandra Cain are used effectively here.</p><p><strong>How It Falls Short: </strong>At times, this feels more like a Batman story than a Two-Face story, with a number of asides where Bruce thinks on his relationship with Harvey and watching him struggle to get better. At times, Two-Face feels like a side character in his own story, which is frustrating. While the premise of the story is interesting, the conclusion feels relatively predictable, and I can’t say that I would rush to pick up this story again.</p><h3><strong>#6: Last Bullet (Penguin)</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/780/1*1aY7GtgD7LfMTakrapsjVg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Writer: </strong>John Ridley</p><p><strong>Penciller:</strong> Giuseppe Camuncoli</p><p><strong>Inker:</strong> Cam Smith</p><p><strong>My Rating: </strong>3/5</p><p><strong>Premise: </strong>A disgraced Oswald Cobblepot returns to Gotham in an attempt to reclaim his criminal empire, a single bullet to his name.</p><p><strong>What It Does Well:</strong> What a fantastic idea for a story; seeing Penguin face how everyone truly thinks of him without his influence and empire brings a character I typically find to be aggressively flat and gives him a ton of character. We get to see him humbled and repentant, but we also get to see his history and motivations in a way that makes us sympathize with him at certain points.</p><p>If you’re familiar with Dan Slott’s <em>Superior Spider-Man</em> series, this will feel strikingly similar in some respects, especially because they share an artist, but I found Penguin to be far more likable, possibly because he only gets a premium issue versus having his story drag for 30 issues. For most of the story, there’s a nice pace that keeps the narrative flowing, and that progression leads to a very natural flow that takes over for parts of the story.</p><p><strong>How It Falls Short:</strong> While I really love the bones of this story, there are some very strange and awkward writing decisions that bring this story crashing down. There’s a side character introduced early on who’s clearly written to be a comic relief figure, and every time he speaks it feels so forced and unnatural it takes me completely out of the story. Batman as a character feels poorly written in a way that is distracting as well, feeling like he’s filling out a role for the plot rather than a fully fleshed out character himself. The ending is also incredibly rushed, with the final few scenes feeling jarring and unearned.</p><p>I feel like if this book had been made into a standalone mini series and been given a few more issues, it could have been something really special, but as it is it’s a fun enough read if you can overlook some of the bigger problems.</p><h3><strong>#5: Ra’s Al Ghul</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*r3TAvVfqVEd86m_VEePvzA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Writer: </strong>Tom Taylor</p><p><strong>Penciller:</strong> Ivan Reis</p><p><strong>Inker:</strong> Danny Miki</p><p><strong>My Rating: </strong>3/5</p><p><strong>Premise: </strong>Ra’s begins an elaborate crusade against the corporations responsible for the destruction of the planet, confronting the Dark Knight in the process.</p><p><strong>What It Does Well: </strong>At times, this book is surprisingly emotional, exploring the toll that time takes on someone who has lived many lifetimes. We get to see the world from the perspective of someone that has learned abundant patience, with every decision and move being made with intension.</p><p>I also really enjoy the use of relationships within the story, with Batman’s and Ra’s’ complex dynamic on display. Damian is also fittingly present, being the grandson of Ra’s, and while he is underutilized, his involvement serves the story well enough.</p><p>What I appreciate about it most is that there’s a clear message to what’s being said, with a discussion about our treatment of the planet that challenges the cut and dry assumption that Ra’s is a villain. His motivations are relatable and we get to see the emotions behind them that inform who he is more fundamentally than most stories allow.</p><p><strong>How It Falls Short:</strong> Somewhat fitting to the character, the story at times can feel a little static, with the actual narrative suggesting change that I never felt particularly as a reader. I think that’s kind of the point, but it led to an unsatisfying read at times. There’s also a drawn out fight sequence that I found didn’t add much to the story and took up some real estate that could have been better used in other ways. As mentioned above, I wish Damian was used more effectively here, and personally this wasn’t my favorite art, especially when compared to the other books on display here.</p><p>This is a book that felt ideas-forward, but I’m not sure that it effectively capitalized on those ideas. It’s somewhat telling that this One Bad Day story doesn’t have a proper title like the others, again showcasing how it feels like there’s something missing from the overall narrative experience.</p><h3><strong>#4: The Darkest Winter (Mr. Freeze)</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2fAOiZ0Mh-FYhY3jlIlEHg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Writer: </strong>Gerry Duggan</p><p><strong>Penciller/Inker:</strong> Matteo Scalera</p><p><strong>My Rating: </strong>4/5</p><p><strong>Premise: </strong>At the behest of Robin, Batman gives Mr. Freeze another chance to redeem himself and save his wife as he grapples with his memories of the life he once had.</p><p><strong>What It Does Well: </strong>This is effectively an unofficial episode of <em>Batman: The Animated Series</em>, both in terms of tone and cast. Taking place during the Christmas season, it feels like the Christmas Special and Mr. Freeze episodes from the first season are smashed together while exploring more of Victor’s past and inner demons. To some, this may be a damning statement, but I’ve been searching for a decent comic that translates the show back to the comics that inspired it, and I think this is the closest I’ve ever seen it done.</p><p>While the Victor we meet here will feel very familiar, there’s a distinct melancholy and turmoil that makes this interpretation of the character stand out, obsessed with control in a way can be both shocking and difficult to watch (in a good way). Looking into his past and his relationship with Nora, you get a sense of the man and husband he was even before the accident, and his tragedy at times feels all the darker for it. And what makes it all work is the book still allows Fries to be a villain; he is undoubtedly someone who is distasteful in his attitude and behavior, which clashes nicely with the want to sympathize with his loss. It creates a complexity that originated with <em>The Animated Series</em>, but is expanded here through the heavier subject material.</p><p>This is nicely juxtaposed by the hopeful presence of Dick and the snarky attitude of Alfred, which lends a lightness to the book the balances out the overall tone. There’s the want for redemption, to persevere, and that push and pull informs a lot of how the story progresses.</p><p><strong>How It Falls Short: </strong>Ultimately, it’s hard to argue that this isn’t treading familiar territory, however solid that source material is. Mr. Freeze has been frozen in place (pun intended) ever since his new origin was conceptualized, and he’s struggled to evolve or grow. While this story expands on it, there’s no denying that it lives within that same space and feeds on our memories of it to some extent.</p><p>I also feel that some of the conclusion isn’t entirely earned for reasons I can’t get into without spoiling some of the plot threads that are tugged at throughout the story. I think, in part, this choice was largely due to the want to recreate the tone of the show this issue clearly borrows from, but it was hard to feel emotionally satisfied by it when all was said and done.</p><h3><strong>Tied for #2: No Small Scores (Catwoman)</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/999/1*xn4NfYQ50lBDhyFe7ssbvQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Writer: </strong>G. Willow Wilson</p><p><strong>Penciller/Inker/Colorist:</strong> Jamie McKelvie</p><p><strong>My Rating: </strong>4/5</p><p><strong>Premise: </strong>Catwoman is determined to steal a pendant from her childhood, once thought to be worthless but is now being sold to the wealthy elite.</p><p><strong>What It Does Well: </strong>While Ra’s Al Ghul’s story tries to say something meaningful and falls short in certain departments, <em>No Small Scores</em> is exceptional in how it tackles its topic, exploring how we value things and the impact that perceived value has on us. Catwoman has over time become one of my favorite DC characters, and watching her grapple with her feelings about her family and the world she occupies is endlessly satisfying. Unlike a lot of these other characters, Selina feels immediately relatable, and the world she lives clearly expresses some social commentary about our own right now. And because of this, she’s allowed to be more vulnerable and expressive as she struggles with real-world problems, which just makes her all the more compelling as our lead.</p><p>This is all tied together nicely with one of my favorite artists in the industry, Jamie McKelvie, best known for their work on <em>The Wicked + The Divine</em> and <em>Young Avengers</em>. The style, colors, and feeling that the art evokes just really speaks to me, and while I think both of those other series offered more creative freedom, there are some eye-catching sequences here that has stuck with me well after closing the book.</p><p>To top it all off, we get to see Catwoman’s relationship with Batman from her point of view in a way that more immediately empowers her and establishes a kinder, softer romance that other books allow for. Batman is often looked into being this male fantasy, rugged and in control, and while Tom King’s interpretation of the characters inject some intimacy into their interactions, it’s Batman’s name on the cover. There’s something to be said of how Wilson navigates the space so easily and creates a subtle but memorable dynamic between the two, reminding us who’s the main character of the story. Bruce never forces himself into the spotlight, and is respectful of Selina, her desires and needs, rather than strong-arming her with his moral high ground as he’s often shown to do.</p><p><strong>How It Falls Short: </strong>While the book has a villain of sorts, they aren’t really the antagonist of the story, yet the book spends a little too much time focusing on them, all while suggesting a deeper layer to the character that we never see. The book even acknowledges this, but still we need to have a fight sequence to close out the book. And while again the art really sells it for me, it feels juxtaposed to the messaging the book is trying to convey. Still, it’s a relatively minor gripe for an otherwise stellar book.</p><h3><strong>Tied for #2: Dreadful Reins (Riddler)</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jJdqMGq6DqKvdvJlVkICJA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Writer: </strong>Tom King</p><p><strong>Penciller/Inker/Colorist:</strong> Mitch Gerads</p><p><strong>My Rating: </strong>4/5</p><p><strong>Premise: </strong>One day, The Riddler walks into the middle of a street and kills a man. No riddle, no games, no explanation. The story follows Nygma as he navigates his own arrest at the hands of the GCPD, who is desperately trying to understand his motivations.</p><p><strong>What It Does Well: </strong>Of all of the books in this series, this is the most “What If?”-adjacent, presenting a version of the Riddler that we haven’t seen before, but this world and the narrative feels true to the character. King has worked with Nygma during his lengthy stint as the head writer of <em>Batman</em>, and the ideas on display here shows his deeper understanding of the character as a whole.</p><p>This book is absolutely dense, packed to the brim with thoughtful dialog that makes you reflect on the meaning of words, navigating Nygma’s speech as he talks in roundabout ways. And this wordplay is cleverly used in multiple instances for seamless transitions when moving from page to page. It makes the story flow so easily and thus makes it hard to put down until you’re done.</p><p>Gerads also worked with King on the aforementioned <em>Batman</em> series, and the two clearly have a working repoire that lends itself to how well the story is presented and framed. Every page feels meticulously framed and placed in a way that compliments the dialogue and creates a foreboding feeling. Color palettes are selected to differentiate between the past and present, and it makes the visual language of the story easy to pick up on. Arguably, this may be one of the best looking books of the lot.</p><p>This is a book that will leave you musing on the events of the story days later, pondering particular phrases that were used or the way in which a scene is presented. It won the Eisner award for Best Single Issue/One-Shot for a reason, even if it doesn’t get the top spot for me.</p><p><strong>How It Falls Short: </strong>As much as I feel Riddler is well presented here, there are a lot of folks who have issues with King’s writing, and I don’t entirely blame them. As an author, he has a tendency of taking characters from DC’s history and rewriting them for his own purposes, such as Booster Gold or Adam Strange. While I personally haven’t had any issues with this, I also have never had a particular attachment to those characters, though I did feel this when revisiting his <em>Vision</em> series from some time ago. As someone who is a huge Riddler fan, I didn’t feel this disconnect, but your mileage may vary.</p><p>The other “complaint” that I would have is that the book can be exhausting to read. As I mentioned, it’s dense, thought-provoking, and encourages you to read it in a single sitting due to the framing of the book and the way the story flows so easily. By the time I was done rereading it recently, I found myself physically tired, but I was also reading it close to my bed time.</p><p>To put it in another way, this is a great book, but its one I need to be in the mood for. I should be game for a “What If” style story that asks a lot from my mind and attention. While basically every other book in this series is relatively breezy, King demands your attention fittingly in the same way that Riddler would.</p><h3><strong>#1: No Notes (Clayface)</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/446/1*3mr0axhFr06D09Se3IrTmg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Writers: </strong>Collin Kelly and Jackson Lanzing</p><p><strong>Penciller/Inker:</strong> Xermanico</p><p><strong>My Rating: </strong>5/5</p><p><strong>Premise: </strong>Clayface has returned to Hollywood, determined to get the lead role in an upcoming blockbuster film, and he’s willing to do anything to get the part.</p><p><strong>What It Does Well: </strong>Clayface has always been a tragic figure, a desperate performer cursed to forever be taking on the forms of others rather than being recognized for his own work, and this comic perfectly encapsulates this idea. There’s some commentary on the state of Hollywood for young up-and-coming actors and the types of films that are being made that creates a realistic backdrop to our story, but Basil is always at the heart of the story, carrying us through his struggles to be recognized.</p><p>Art featuring Clayface is always interesting to see artistically as there are so many ways to present his powers, and Xermanico does a phenomenal job presenting how he moves, transforms, and holds himself. The setting is glossy and clean, neatly juxtaposing our messy, muddy lead, and the framing of scenes are impeccably set to feel like something out of a movie.</p><p>And this is clearly done with intension, as the entire story is presented like a script for a film. The interjections of stage prompts works to sell the idea, and it presents the idea that Clayface is always acting, cursed to pretend forever if he wants to be accepted by your average person.</p><p>It’s hard to gush about this book without giving specifics away, but the last thing I’ll say is that this story retains a perfect sense of tension, gradually growing throughout the story until it reaches a breaking point. Sincerely, this is one of the best comics I’ve read in some time.</p><p><strong>How It Falls Short: </strong>I’d like to say that there’s something I could think of to put here objectively, but every time I think it over, I come up with a blank. For the kind of story being told, I can’t think of a single thing I would change.</p><p>Well, those are my lengthy thoughts, but feel free to let me know your favorites if you’ve had a chance to read the series yourself. Thanks for taking the time to read along, and I hope that in the process you’ve found a story that might one day enter your own personal collection.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a7f129acaef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unstable Shelf: A Showcase in Oversaturation]]></title>
            <link>https://unstableshelf.medium.com/the-unstable-shelf-a-showcase-in-oversaturation-058f0edd9f2d?source=rss-d6f6896b3fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/058f0edd9f2d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[yacht-club-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[paradox-of-choice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[summer-game-fest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[geoff-keighley]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Muench]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Jun 2026 19:35:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-15T19:35:35.690Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*bVb7nrAM5CmDjHZDYYx-iQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> Summer Game Fest Logo for the 2026 Season</figcaption></figure><p>Over the course of the first 8 days of the month, video gamers were inundated with a jaw-dropping 22 video game showcases, courtesy of Summer Game Fest. For those unfamiliar, Summer Game Fest has largely replaced E3, the once prominent convention designed to present what games folks should be excited to see over the next few years. While E3 was a physical space where reporters and players could demo games at various booths and attend in-person presentations, SGF is broadcast across the internet for all to witness, with a small portion of the press attending some of the major presentations in person.</p><p>One such presentation, Summer Games Fest Live, was hosted by the head of the company, Geoff Keighley, who has been presenting video game news since the days of Spike TV back in 2003. Early in this presentation, Keighley presented his audience with a chart showing the number of games released via Steam, the primary PC store front for video games, within the first 5 months of 2026 in comparison to the past 5 years.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lmdEq0waStGJw-84cjdamw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit: </strong>Summer Games Fest Live 2026</figcaption></figure><p>I feel like the chart speaks for itself, with a staggering increase in video game volume for the past 4 years, but it’s clear based on the rhetoric Keighley employed in response to his chart that he and I had a very different takeaway on what these numbers mean. As if calling me out specifically, Keighley stated:</p><p><em>Now sure, a cynic might look at these numbers and think, how can anyone break through with their game?</em></p><p>At which point, the stream cut out and repeated itself momentarily, as it was wont to do throughout the presentation, before it returned with people applauding and Keighley asking “isn’t that great?” While I spent a decent amount of time searching for that context, reporters understandably didn’t share what that would have been, instead desperately trying to summarize the ever-growing mountain of games they’re meant to cover.</p><p>While we don’t have the specific context of what Keighley intended on say to his wider audience, it’s clear that he was looking to celebrate the volume of titles being released in 2026, suggesting that we should be thankful that we have more selection to pick through than any other era of the still relatively new medium. It’s a frustrating and obnoxious statement that completely ignores some of the glaring issues with this argument in favor of simply stating big numbers as a good thing.</p><p>The volume of the media we consume has become daunting, an avalanche of “content” that are all warring violently for our eyes and money. Films were perhaps the earliest victims of this, with the countless streaming surfaces looking to own at least some of the movies you want to watch, so eventually you’re stuck paying for five streaming services just to have reruns of your favorite 90’s TV shows playing in the background while you work. There is no medium that is safe from this, and we are progressively seeing more and more stuff made for the sake of making it rather than out of passion or a want to entertain or challenge audience perceptions.</p><p>Video games have certainly suffered from this in particular, with a large portion of that 9,000+ games released this year being halfhearted shovel ware cobbled together with AI and pre-made assets. It is becoming a constant struggle to find and identify games that are actually worth my time, even with creators and reporters doing their best to sift through the chaff. And while these showcases are designed to bring our attention to the better choices, the amount of time and effort it takes to sort through even those is baffling.</p><p>I watched 8 of the 22 showcases personally, as well as the Nintendo showcase that isn’t even noted on the above list, and in a lot of ways it felt like a second job. What’s more, my Steam Wishlist ballooned to an alarming 125 games, yet I struggle to remember a third of the titles when scanning through the list after the fact. I know, factually, that many of these games are things I’ll simply never purchase because there’s so much out there. Them being on my wishlist is simply a convenient way for me to be reminded of when it’s eventually released and reevaluate if I’m really all that interested.</p><p>And even now I’ll see reports and emails from some of my favorite reviewers that mention games that were recently announced that I didn’t even hear of because I happened to not watch this showcase or that stream. While some of the streams clearly define the genres they’re looking to present, like the Wholesome Direct or the Story Rich Showcase, others work to highlight various groups of peoples that are less often represented in gaming. This is certainly important and worth celebrating, but it can also lead to games getting lost in the chatter because there’s no indication of whether the actual games in one showcase or another will align with the types of things I enjoy playing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/664/1*IVjBkjpiACU3LxBKf2DjGg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> The Paradox of Choice by Barry Schwartz</figcaption></figure><p>I’ve become fond in recent years of bringing up <em>The Paradox of Choice</em> to those who care to listen (yes, I am fun at parties), as I think it’s an idea that has become increasingly more prevalent with every year. Published in 2004, Schwartz highlights that the increasing volume of options people are offered:</p><ol><li>Creates decision paralysis.</li><li>Makes us second-guess and regret our choices when the results aren’t satisfying.</li><li>Makes us less satisfied with what we have when considering alternatives.</li><li>Our expectations become higher, making us more easily disappointed</li><li>There are no surprises, with our overinformed lives leading us to be let down if our experience doesn’t meet the expectations our research creates.</li><li>We are made to feel at fault when our decisions don’t reach our expectations, making us feel worse about ourselves.</li></ol><p>It’s startling just how prominently this reflects how I experience life today, with a seemingly endless to-do list not only composed of work and the chores I need to do, but of my hobbies and the endless amount of content I’m expected to keep up with. I’ve outright given up on some of my hobbies simply because I can’t be bothered to keep up with books, comics, movies, TV, video games, board games, and more while also being a productive person.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2Vg7hVKziBXlYMcTKmmFrw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit: </strong>Yacht Club Games</figcaption></figure><p>And as I reflect on the hobbies I do keep up with, I do recognize a weird sense of frustration and dissatisfaction with what I have. Being a fan of <em>Shovel Knight</em>, a fairly popular debut title by Yacht Club Games, I backed their recently released game <em>Mina the Hollower</em> years ago before putting it out of my mind. Finally digging my way through the mountain of games I still have to play, I carved out a space to play <em>Mina</em> and found myself quick to find dissatisfaction with my time. It’s not that the game is poorly made, that there’s any inherent issues with it, but rather that it works to challenge my understanding and preconceptions of the genre in question. I certainly have my gripes that I don’t think the game will resolve, but I quickly found myself looking for excuses to jump ship so that I can keep working through my backlog and find something that would make me that much happier.</p><p>In reality and put within the context of this article, though, I recognize that this is exactly what I should be celebrating about a new video, something that’s weird and feels experimental within the sea of chaff. There are things that I do enjoy about the game, and while I may not “love” every second of it, I owe it to myself to experience more of it before choosing to write it off entirely. Don’t get me wrong, it’s okay to just not enjoy something while still recognizing that it’s well-made (there’s a good chance <em>Mina</em> will fall into that category for me in the long-term). But I think it’s easy to quickly write stuff off in favor of not having to worry about another thing on our growing to-do lists.</p><p>So no, the sheer quantity of stuff that are dumped in front of us every day to assess is not somehow benefiting our lives. Over 9,000 new video games only makes our job harder to try and find games we deem enjoyable and to feel satisfied when we make those choices, all while making it harder for indie companies to break out and succeed amidst the overwhelming competition. It only works to highlight the prevalence of junk being constantly generated in an effort to squeeze a few more dollars out of us before moving on to the next grift. My advice? Try and follow creators or companies, not brands or genres. Yacht Club, while it may not hit gold with every release, is a company that’s at least looking to create something new and experimental. I may not find it to be the next best thing worth praising, but I know it’ll be a game that I remember, both for what it does well and for what it fails at. And that’s far more interesting than another safe, calculated carbon-copy of <em>Hollow Knight</em> or <em>Dark Souls</em> or any other popular title from the last 10 years.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=058f0edd9f2d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unstable Shelf: Exquisite Corpses is Safely Innovative]]></title>
            <link>https://unstableshelf.medium.com/the-unstable-shelf-exquisite-corpses-is-safely-innovative-2992f243d416?source=rss-d6f6896b3fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2992f243d416</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[james-tynion-iv]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[serial-killers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-deviant]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[image-comics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Muench]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 May 2026 18:25:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-28T18:25:31.374Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PEIBBHnxFCOW3UkuQchr3A.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> Michael Walsh, Image Comics</figcaption></figure><p><em>Exquisite Corpses</em>, the recently wrapped comic series by James Tynion IV and his Corpse Crew, is my Schrodinger’s Story, a book that I can’t decide whether it’s dead-on-arrival or if it holds something special that’s worth celebrating. It’s creatively considered in some regards and predictably safe in others, and as the authorial team gears up for more content in this world, I wanted to get down into the muck with the cold-blooded killers featured in this tale to try and illuminate my thoughts on one of the more prominently discussed comics of the past year.</p><p>For those not in the know, <em>Exquisite Corpses</em> is a 13-issue standalone Image series that’s been compared to a variety of different killer competition stories, like <em>Hunger Games</em> or <em>The Purge</em>. A secret cabal of ruthless rulers, each representing one of the 13 original American states, hire a collection of killers to represent them in a bloodbath, taking place in a Podunk town of their choosing filled to the brim with innocents. Whoever’s killer survives to the end wins, securing their state’s undisputed rule for the following 5 years. While these comparisons are fairly apt, I would sooner reach for <em>Cabin in the Woods</em>, as readers are also introduced to a collection of the civilians trapped in the crossfire of this competition. Each fills a stereotypical role that speaks to how they engage with the chaos that ensues, informing how they react when the bodies begin to hit the floor. It also speaks to how <em>Exquisite Corpses</em> leans on its stereotypes, with some of the heavy lifting left to our familiarity with stories like this.</p><p>As the series has been released, each issue is listed internal as “Season 1, Episode __,” clearly creating the parallel between this and your typical competitive TV show, like a more visceral interpretation of Survivor, and to me it reads rather similarly. With so many characters to keep track of and the breakneck pace and cadence of the story, we aren’t meant to become overly attached to most of the figures featured. This is probably one of the biggest complaints that I’ve seen in discussions about the series, and I largely echo the sentiment as someone who is more often drawn in by character studies and the like. We do get a handful of characters who are given a bit more depth, evolving into something resembling leads for our story, but this is a rarity, and they don’t rival more focused stories. But within the context of this being a shlocky horror-focused bloodbath with a bunch of eclectic characters, it’s impossible to deny that I had a good time with the light nature of the story, ever so gently turning off my brain and someone’s guts splashed across the page.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_FGBlWHIkutlfWMzdacOTQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> Michael Walsh, Image Comics</figcaption></figure><p>Perhaps the most interesting element of this story, contributing to the series’ namesake, <em>Exquisite Corpses</em> is designed to be a team effort; while Tynion IV and his primary art collaborator, Michael Walsh, are the core writers of this experience, the aforementioned Corpse Crew is a selection of other creators who were asked to work on individual issues throughout the run. So while Tynion and Walsh set the framework and characters at the start of the story, each issue features a team of folks looking to make their mark on the story, tackling the characters they are most enthusiastic about while setting up plot points for other creators to tinker with later down the road. Don’t get me wrong, this isn’t some kind of guerilla writing warfare at work; the narrative as a whole was plotted out in the writers room, but how the story progresses was a more collective effort than a traditional indie book. Tynion IV has stated in interviews that he was attempting to capture the energy of the events of cape-comics, a huge collaborative effort across the various books that company headlines, in a smaller, self-contained setting. In some respects, I do think this can lend to some interesting choices, with certain issues having more prominent themes that feed into the archs of some of the characters. It’s also fascinating to see plot points teased in earlier issues, essentially passing the ball for someone else to catch and do with what they will. On the other hand, I found a couple of instances where characters felt like they didn’t sound “like themselves”, their voices distorted by someone who just didn’t get how the character had been growing thus far. I think that’s a natural consequence for a creative process like this, but I don’t think it inherently services the story at large.</p><p>Surprisingly, the art feels relatively consistent across the entire series; while you can tell when another artist is at the helm, most issues look stylistically coherent with one another in a way that doesn’t distract nearly as much as some of the artist changes in Marvel or DC books. While I had my artistic preferences, at no point did I find any artist that I outright didn’t like, though I do wish the different art styles could have somehow be attributed to some form of in-world logic, like having each issue be “narrated” by a different character and the art being representative of that character’s perspective.</p><p>Narratively, it’s hard to place exactly how I feel. Tynion IV is a man that I’ve had a rocky relationship with in regards to his work. I often describe him to others as a man that is great at presenting concepts and ideas but rarely sticks the landing when it comes to the conclusion. I felt like most prominently in his take on DC’s <em>Detective Comics</em>, with some phenomenal ideas at the start of the run that ultimately feel wasted by the time the series came to an end. Recently, however, <em>The Deviant</em> was a 9-issue mini-series Tynion IV wrote that blew my socks off, easily one of my favorite reads in recent memory. A very personal story for the writer, is was a story that was exceptionally effective in the themes and ideas that it seeked to communicate. <em>Exquisite Corpses</em> never reaches those same heights, largely devoid of that personal touch that made <em>The Deviant</em> one-of-a-kind, but it’s also a distinctly different story with entirely different goals.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9xTq5ReTe9xjHMN6iGVO_A.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> Joshua Hixson, Image Comics</figcaption></figure><p>My point in bringing this up is that it feels like Tynion IV is lightly pivoting in my mind as a writer. Where most of his works have come up short for me, <em>The Deviant</em> was a clear departure from this pattern, and within the framework of <em>Exquisite Corpses</em>, I do think his writing within the bookends of the series are the strongest parts, creating a unified voices that reigns in some of the chaos and allows for the story to feel more purposeful. The opening issue hooks you in very effectively, and the final 3 issues capitalizes on the themes and ideas his cowriters set up in a way that allows the story to crescendo in its final moments. I do think the story suffers from some predictability, but based on the premise and framing, I think folks would be setting themselves up for failure if they expected something deep and subversive here.</p><p>The series has clearly been a success, as <em>Exquisite Corpses </em>has been gearing up for a variety of spin-off content, as well as a “Season 2&quot; series. A recent Kickstarter campaign has been marketing the shallow-looking and overpriced board game implementation of the series; as someone who has worked in the industry for some time now, it’s can still feel jarring to see the various attempts to take niche but popular IPs from comics and video games and reapply them in the board gaming sphere.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zQXaAPC-e7lkCXa4R_L3Wg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> Michael Walsh, Kickstarter</figcaption></figure><p>There’s also set to be a couple of mini-series focusing on select killers from this Season, presumably giving some of these characters the depth they were lacking in the comic proper. While others lament this choice, I find myself enthusiastic about the idea, potentially creating an alternative reading order for me if I choose to revisit the series down the road. I could see interspersing these side stories in between issues or volumes of Season One to help provide some context to some of the less explained conflicts that were presented, assuming that these mini-series turn out well.</p><p>As much as I hate to admit it, I’m kind of excited about the future of the series, in spite of its flaws. With the Corpse Crew set to return for the second season, I think that there’s a lot of opportunity to strengthen the formula they’ve found here and make this a series worth following. And while I don’t outright love <em>Exquisite Corpses</em>, I house a grudging respect for what it is and how it’s giving me the feeling of watching silly, mindless TV but without the time-wasting tropes that modern television often employs (the very things that has made me turn more and more to comics over the years). The series is, if nothing else, ambitious enough to keep me invested in what else this team decides to cook up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2992f243d416" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unstable Shelf: Owning Your Stories]]></title>
            <link>https://unstableshelf.medium.com/the-unstable-shelf-owning-your-stories-9124233faefb?source=rss-d6f6896b3fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9124233faefb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Muench]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 12 May 2026 19:49:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-12T19:49:59.579Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Being born in the 90’s, I grew up in a world that encouraged me more and more to abandon physical possessions in favor of digital media with each passing year. As someone who has struggled with anxiety, some claustrophobia, and a touch of undiagnosed OCD, having a lot of stuff gradually made me feel less and less happy. Over the years, I’ve abandoned a lot of things that I had grow bored of; physical comics would instead be cataloged on my tablet. Video games could be emulated or simply weren’t worth returning to. Stuff needed to go in favor of the much needed space that it would free up, allowing for me to have all the things I liked catering to a simpler life free of distraction and clutter.</p><p>Today, I spend more and more of my time glued to various screens, and I don’t own any of my stuff anymore. It’s a stark realization that has shaken my perspective, and it’s about time I start reclaiming the media that brings me joy and informs who I am.</p><p>The phrase “techno feudalism” has become something I refer more and more to as of late, emblematic of my growing fears of the world in which we currently exist. For those unaware, the idea is that, much like how serfs in feudalist Japan needed to pay rent on the land they worked, we are now forced to pay “rent” on the media we consume through the various services we source them from. We pay subscription fees to Spotify and Netflix for music and movies we don’t own. We pay Amazon and Steam for the licenses for books and games that we are only allowed to have temporarily, and only through their proprietary programs. Everything that we consume isn’t ours, and they can be taken away at a moment’s notice.</p><p>Film and TV rights move between streaming services regularly, so while you started a subscription with one service to watch, say, every season of The Office, that can transfer to another service without you being aware. Music is often taken down from Spotify due to artists not being compensated properly. And even edits can be made to various products so you only get to consume the “correct” versions of your favorite things, according to the companies that made them. You get no choice, you’re simply forced to accept what these gargantuan companies allow us.</p><p>Over the years, I had purchased a lot of comics via a website called Comixology, easily over $1000 worth of reading material. The website felt user friendly, it had a reading app that worked well and offered a ton of features, and I was under the impression at the time that I did in fact own the comics that I bought. Little did I realize that Comixology was bought by Amazon in the mid-2010’s, setting up the dominos to ultimately topple. Towards the end of 2023, all of Comixology was merged with the less-than-stellar Amazon marketplace, converting all my purchases into the Kindle app and forcing me into an ecosystem I never signed up for. Not only was the app worse, the experience slower and more tedious, and my position within this ecosystem far clearer than in the past, but now Amazon could, if they ever found a reason to shut down my account, deprive me of all those comics in one foul swoop.</p><p>Similarly, I own over 440 games on Steam. Many of them have been acquired for relatively cheap via Humble Bundles, groupings of games sold at a low price to benefit charity. Plenty of them have been bought piecemeal as well, typically when they are on sale. But a vast majority of them are locked into the Steam app, meaning they can only be played through Steam’s system. And up until now, this hasn’t been a problem; the owner of Steam, Gabe Newell, is celebrated as a patron saint of video gaming in a world that frequently looks to strip us of our possessions. Steam has very consumer-forward practices and takes care of its customers… for now. Because eventually, for one reason or another, Gabe will no longer run Steam, and whoever takes over the company could very well be someone who does not have the customer’s experience in mind, who only looks to squeeze us for every dollar we have, especially on those games we’ve “owned” for all these years.</p><p>Stories are a huge part of my life (as if this series wasn’t a clear indicator of that), and the idea of all these stories gradually falling out of my possession is something that I cannot abide by any longer. Gradually, I’ve begun the process to reclaim my stuff, without even realizing it at first.</p><p>The first step was to begin buying movies again. As yet another streaming service had appeared on the scene, desperate to part me from my dollars once a month, I threw up my hands in annoyance and decided that I would start gathering the films I truly loved in a more permanent fashion in an effort to circumvent Disney+, Netflix, and all the rest. While I haven’t revisited them recently, I now have plenty of my favorite films and shows lined up like dutiful soldiers, waiting for me to call them to action. I also no longer have any streaming services.</p><p>Next was music, something that I find myself indulging in during my commutes to work. While I had been leveraging Spotify, I’ve been working to pivot to owning an eclectic selection of CDs to better support artists directly, as well as using my iPod again to store and curate the digital files I’ve held onto for years. I’ve even begun to dabble in mix-CDs again in an effort to flex some long-languishing mental-muscles of mine.</p><p>Now, I’ve been rebuilding my library, slowly and deliberating looking through my backlog of digital files to determine which works are worth hunting down. And similarly, I’ve been reviewing my video games to try and determine which titles I’d like to see adorning my shelves in a more permanent manner. This has been perhaps the trickiest step in this process, and one that, much like everything listed above, is still ongoing. Slowly, corporations have been pivoting away from physical ownership, favoring techno feudalism by removing the physical option altogether. Fewer and fewer games are provided physical releases, and when they do its through a limited release via specialty websites. Books can be especially hard to track down in some instances, racking up some ridiculous prices. The industry is trying to force us back to our screens, back to their online services, if only to lock us into how they want us to consume their works.</p><p>And ultimately, this process looks to devalue the media we enjoy. Out of sight, out of mind, as the saying goes, and the more things we own digitally, the more likely we’re to forget some of our favorite works in the hustle and bustle of our day to day. Artists see less support because of how they’re forced into corporate systems that treat them as cogs in a machine rather than creators in their own right. The systems, as they exist, look to deprive artists of support and a fair wage while making us pay more to the middle men to “allow” us the permission to experience these works.</p><p>I’m done allowing the world to dictate how I experience media, and I’m willing to pay the price for my previous ignorance, if only to build a future where I no longer worry over whether my media will just amble off into oblivion one day. That’s not to say that digital markets don’t have their value; personally, I’ve grown to view them as a rental system, giving me the opportunity to sample stuff before I take the leap and make a purchase. Between this and using resources like the library and charity shops, we can make a change in our own lives to allow art to flourish in a world that constantly works to devalue the stories that makes our lives brighter. With any luck, some of you will take this journey with me too, but for now I’ll simply say to take care of yourselves and stay safe out there.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9124233faefb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unstable Shelf: Joining the Ravenswatch]]></title>
            <link>https://unstableshelf.medium.com/the-unstable-shelf-joining-the-ravenswatch-1d6c9b7fd81c?source=rss-d6f6896b3fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1d6c9b7fd81c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ravenswatch]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[childhood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[passtech-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[multiplayer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Muench]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Apr 2026 15:31:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-21T13:04:47.559Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2iKFn2YMoDUFzq-5hxC_Qg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> Valentin André-Terramorsi, Passtech Games</figcaption></figure><p>I’m someone who struggles to get excited; it’s a behavior that I’ve noticed more and more as I grow older, and I’m oftenjealous of those who feel larger emotions in their day-to-day lives. When I was a kid, I was criticized and bullied by my peers for being too emotional, crying in public in middle school or not knowing how to contain bursts of panic or joy. This coupled poorly with my thirst for attention, as my parents overwhelmed me with love that juxtaposed to how I felt like a social outcast. It made me feel like I was undeserving of the affection my parents gave me, that they did it out of duty, and everyone else saw me for who I really was; unremarkable, unimportant, useless. Some of my closest friends at the time told me that I needed to get over my emotions, that we were too old for that kind of thing and that it was embarrassing. Progressively, I became more and more scared of showing my real self to other people; there were occasions where I felt safe to be more expressive, particularly in college, but because of how pent-up I felt containing myself for so long, I often came across as overhwelming.</p><p>Today, I walk through most of my life content, but without the highs or lows that dominated my youth. Tragedies will happen around me, and I’ll acknowledge them, say the appropriate things to comfort others, but rarely will I feel their impact or meaning. I will have moments of triumph at work or in my social circles, and while I’ll occasionally feel the rush of accomplishment, more often I’ll accept any congratulations and move on with my day. I’m not unhappy, far from it, but I do think that life can at times feel muted. It’s only recently that I’ve found some relief from that burden in part thanks to <em>Ravenswatch</em>.</p><p>Released in late 2023 in early access, <em>Ravenswatch</em> is a multiplayer rogue-lite video game in which players take on the roles of various fairy tale characters in an effort to defeat hoards of enemies corrupted and led by Baba Yaga. There’s a respectable diversity within the cast of characters you can play, with 5 of the 12 heroes being women, and with a number of cultures and races being represented in a way that feels inclusive; fitting for a game about comradery framed around the tales that various peoples have told for centuries.</p><p>Some will note that this game can be played solo, but I rarely if ever do so, as I find it to defeat the fun of the thing. Each character has various abilities that will benefit not just themselves but the players around them; Melusine, a pregnant mermaid, can heal others with massive tidal waves or shield them with her wisp. Aladdin and Merlin can call on ancient magics to resurrect fallen heroes. Geppetto and Snow Queen can create puppets and ice sculptures respectively to create distractions that enemies will target instead of the players. There’s even a pair of characters, Romeo and Juliet, who are designed to be played side-by-side, their abilities powerful but requiring a lot of coordination. So yes, you can play this game on your own, but you lose out on some of the magic this game offers.</p><p>When I first discovered <em>Ravenswatch</em>, it was off the heels of Passtech’s previous title, <em>The Curse of the Dead Gods</em>, a solo rogue-lite game that saw you delving into Aztec temples to survive and ultimately escape the tomb you are trapped within. I found a decent amount of enjoyment in that first game and was excited to see what new things the company was cooking up. Playing <em>Ravenswatch</em> on my own for an hour or so, I wasn’t impressed, with a gameplay loop that was hard to pick up and with my failures feeling punishing and discouraging. I returned the game on Steam, a bit miffed, and moved on to other games.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9297sV-7T2Xs8xE5hh0pmQ.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XBTODd0s_8s">Ravenswatch Launch Trailer</a></figcaption></figure><p>I’ve always struggled with playing multiplayer games, worrying that I won’t be able to enjoy them if other players decide they have no interest after a year or so. A lot of my time as a kid was playing games by myself, including multiplayer focused titles like <em>Mario Kart: Double Dash</em> and <em>Super Smash Bros. Melee</em>. Over time, I just came to assume that games that required others to enjoy just weren’t for me. But since being married, I’ve found a lot of fun bonding with my significant other over games, both digitally and and on the tabletop. More and more, I set aside games I purchase from Steam so we can experience them together. So when my SO expressed interest in <em>Ravenswatch </em>when it officially released, I figured it might be worth returning to these twisted fairy tales. I picked up a copy, intending to figure out how to play some couch co-op when we found the time.</p><p>Little did I know, there is no couch co-op for this game; in order to play together, we would both need to own a copy of the game. Not wanting to push the extra expense on her when we had no idea whether or not we’d enjoy it in the first place, we shelved it for the time being, the game gathering dust in my Steam collection.</p><p>Enter one of my best friends, Phil, who I play tabletop games with online on a fairly weekly basis. We tend to play games for work, but with a lull in work, we were looking for other things to play in our free time. I mentioned <em>Ravenswatch</em>, hoping that I might finally get some use out of the game, and being an exceptionally agreeable person, he bought a copy soon after. Within the week, we booted up the game, picking whatever characters we fancied, and started delving into the haunted forests of Reverie.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h4UX3SljQyD3aJ7vS1ylVA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> <a href="https://www.artstation.com/artwork/zxPaZZ">Max Maury-Martineau</a>, Passtech Games</figcaption></figure><p>As I had realized previously, <em>Ravenswatch</em> is a difficult game to learn. The tutorial provided is a series of slides hidden in the start menu that feel only passingly helpful, teaching basics that we had mostly already figured out by the time we discovered it. The gameplay loop doesn’t provide many guideposts outside of experimentation, and we found ourselves dying often. But certainly less often than when playing solo, as multiplayer enables you to have buddies save you if you’ve been knocked out rather than using precious feathers, revival resources needed to defeat the game’s tough-as-nails bosses.</p><p>We gradually learned the basics of how to explore the game’s three maps effectively; there are various points of interest on the map organized by difficulty (green, yellow, and red), with like color locations being positioned near one another. Certain things, like Vision Towers and Dream Crystals, provide the players with information or currency, allowing you to jumpstart your character’s abilities while earning XP. Quests and Blood Rituals are some of the last things you look to do before confronting the area’s boss, providing big boons but requiring players to play quickly and effectively in order to defeat them in a timely manner.</p><p>Each hero also has an entire learning curve in and of themselves, as you have to understand how to build them into successful members of the watch. As characters level up, players choose between two of that character’s randomly selected skills, providing with new ways to engage with the game or empowering the tools you already have. Scarlet, a lycanthropic Little Red, can allow her human form to become more agile and sneaky or her wolf form to become more vicious and blood-thirsty. Snow Queen balances defensive options, slowing her enemies and becoming tanky, with her ability to deal swathes of damage to any Chilled enemies around her.</p><p>Then there are those heroes who present radically different playstyles, transforming how you approach combat. Melusine controls a wisp that, when used to attack, locks her in place, requiring her to carefully plan her positioning and when she needs to make a quick escape. Rather than attacking enemies directly, Geppetto builds puppets that he treats like makeshift projectiles, smacking them into enemies with his big hammer, allowing them to autonomously fight while he runs around the battlefield repairing them or providing buffs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rin3Yb0JGZHoWnRuLN4LGg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> <a href="https://www.artstation.com/artwork/0l4y0y">Max Maury-Martineau</a>, Passtech Games</figcaption></figure><p>I quickly found myself drawn to Geppetto in particular, with the strange cadence of playstyle mixed with the relative safety his puppets offered, allowing Phil and I to better explore the game space, gradually earning ourselves a victory at the game’s earliest difficulty level. Soon after, we piloted Romeo and Juliet to victory, mowing down enemies by the end of our run. Rather than walking away satisfied, we were thirsty to experience more of what the game offered, ramping things up and throwing ourselves at the second difficulty level of four.</p><p>Soon, I was doing research in my free time, looking up tips and tricks, learning entire mechanics that we hadn’t realized in our hours of playtime, and began understanding some of the ins and outs of how certain characters operated. I began expanding my scope of what characters I could play effectively, and soon I had a repertoire of heroes that I would rotate between. And while each played differently, I found that they all shared a commonality; each of these heroes, in some way or another, looked to support the other players battling alongside me.</p><p>And yes, I mean “players” with an “s”; as Phil and I spent more and more time playing, my SO watched and picked up a copy for themselves, joining us for 3-player runs, as well as practicing solo and attempting some runs just the two of us. Eventually, a mutual friend of Phil’s began joining in on the fun, and we’ve very occasionally experienced massives 4-player games. <em>Ravenswatch</em> ramps with player count by adding more enemies and providing them with extra health, making 4-player games chaotic, raucous fun as hoards of enemies swarm from every corner of the map to beat us to a bloody pulp.</p><p>In our earliest games of <em>Ravenswatch</em>, I at times became critical, both of myself and of the team, regarding how we operated as a team and how often I was knocked out, requiring another player to rescue me. At the end of the run, certain statistics are highlighted, including who died the most, and if I was that player, I took that as an indictment of my skills. I would say sorry for my failings, which was met with “no need to apologize” and the like, everyone else taking it in stride. But I knew, deep down, that I needed to do better.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*scIZ8BM1aub34mG7I8fa0Q.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XdF3S4g8ubI">Ravenswatch Gameplay Overview Trailer</a></figcaption></figure><p>This, of course, wasn’t the high bar I held others to. Naturally, I wasn’t the only one who would hold the coveted spot of “most deaths”, and while I might be disappointed or annoyed if a run went particularly south, I would internalize it as that we needed to work on our teamwork rather than something that fell on the shoulders of anyone else. In my mind, it was partially my fault they died because I wasn’t supporting them well enough.</p><p>There was one point where I took a break from the game for about a week, feeling burnt out as we struggled against the daunting wall of the third difficulty, in which players finally get to confront the game’s final boss, Baba Yaga herself. With fewer feathers, less XP, and a powerful enemy waiting for us at the end, it was tougher than ever to get a grasp on how we needed to improve to succeed. Yet, I couldn’t help but feel more confident in my abilities, more comfortable with everyone else on the team, and I gradually became less and less concerned with winning or losing. Our failures often birthed funny moments where we would digitally turn to each other, laugh off that spectacular face-plant we all just made, and then attempt another run.</p><p>The more I grew comfortable with failing, the more I allowed myself to start expressing myself freely. Nowadays, I can often be heard babbling incoherently as we play, switching between noises to try and articulate whatever’s going through my head, commenting on the same two or three attacks my character is effective at, and screaming about the dreaded healers and that they need to be wiped off the face of the earth if we have any chance of surviving. It’s a cacophony that is often coupled with a giddiness that feels almost foreign to me, at times infecting the other players in turn.</p><p>That’s not to say I don’t still apologize too often or have my moments of annoyance when we get especially demolished after I’ve made a rather reckless decision, which is more often than I care to admit. There’s a certain carefree mentality that I can embrace at times, running off into the woods by myself when I feel like the game is moving slowly, hoping that I don’t get into too much trouble in the process. I make mistakes, some if not most of them stemming from my own silliness or impatience. But that’s the thing about <em>Ravenswatch</em>; it gives me that safe space to be ridiculous, to do silly things, and while there are consequences if I get too out of hand, they’re never something so egregious or dire that there are repercussions. My fellow players are always gracious and patient, and their presence is often the salve needed when I think too hard about my own shortcomings.</p><p>It’s been a while since I’ve discovered a deep comradery in a shared activity; it’s perhaps ridiculous to fell this about a video game, but it would be dishonest if I didn’t acknowledge this game’s impact on my life. <em>Ravenswatch</em> has awakened the curious child in me once again, giving me space to run around and play recklessly with my friends and loved ones without fear of judgement. As with anything in life, this hinges on the people I surround myself with, and thankful I find that those people continue to be kind and supportive in ways that five-year-old me could only dream of. And while good friends can make any game special, the way in which <em>Ravenswatch</em> allows me to play with characters and stories that I’ve known since my youth is something that stands out amidst so many other things in my life as special and without compare, at least not yet.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pqvT4YkGlhxiKZOK2YnA6A.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> <a href="https://www.artstation.com/artwork/V2JAO5">Max Maury-Martineau</a>, Passtech Games</figcaption></figure><p>We’ve finally beaten the third difficulty multiple times and find ourselves standing at the precipice of the final difficulty mode, Nightmare. Once more, we journey into the unknown, not alone, but as a united front to face whatever horrors are left undiscovered.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1d6c9b7fd81c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unstable Shelf: History Repeats Itself Too Often]]></title>
            <link>https://unstableshelf.medium.com/the-unstable-shelf-history-repeats-itself-too-often-8a29b88cdda2?source=rss-d6f6896b3fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8a29b88cdda2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[spider-man]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marvel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dc-comics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[batman]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[comic-books]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Muench]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Apr 2026 15:31:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-13T15:31:01.408Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/662/1*JzK4F5l90Yo8j3w5qb_MKg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> Chris Samnee, DC Comics</figcaption></figure><p>Comic book companies have been reciting their own histories for decades now, obsessed with themselves in a way that feels narcissistic. The most recent example of this is <em>New History of the DC Universe</em>, which looks to condense and compile nearly 100 years of lore that has been written and rewritten and re-rewritten to modernize stories that no longer resonates with today’s audiences. It is dense, like reading a history textbook in middle school, a list of factoids about various events and characters that you’ve never heard of, interspersed with the classic heroes you already know too much about. It’s self-indulgent, insisting upon itself with a laundry list of artists and one of DC’s most beloved writers, as if these talented creators will make the facts held within any less dull.</p><p>It’s happened many times before, and it will happen many times again, because cape comics are nothing without its history, or so Marvel and DC would have us believe. Characters now have legacies, with families of characters that then have their own legacies, and so on. Before the Justice League, there was the Justice Society of America, composed of a whole cavalcade of heroes that have since been pushed aside. While a handful have stood the strenuous test of time, many are relics that have been replaced, reimagined, or cannibalized for narrative bits and pieces. Yet, the stories of those characters still feed into this overarching worldbuilding that’s at the core of cape comics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mH7_HyTr916hsCMnTIBoDw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit: </strong>Joe Quesada, Marvel Comics</figcaption></figure><p>Then there are the retcons, more than anyone can count, that rewrite the histories of characters to conform to whatever is hot and popular now. The most infamous of these is <em>One More Day</em>, in which Peter Parker had his marriage stripped from him in an effort to return the hero to being a young, struggling bachelor. It’s an adjustment that fans are still in an uproar about today, almost 18 years later, because of how damaging it was (and still is) to the legacy of the character. But Marvel has stood by their decision, seeing a single Spider-Man to be more profitable and in line with the vision of the character, despite what fans long for.</p><p>Plenty of these changes are made for profit, but takes many forms; Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch losing their mutantdom and their paternal relationship with Magneto allowed them to legally appear in <em>Avengers: Age of Ultron</em>, at a narrative cost that undermines their histories. Quicksilver is built around his inadequacy, fueled by constantly being looked down on by his disapproving father, a father that no longer has any connection to him.</p><p>That’s not to say all retcons are inherently bad; Scarlet Witch has been retconned more than most, but to greater success due to how poorly she was characterized in the 2000’s. Once the pariah of mutants and murderer of her friends, Wanda has been shown a lot more respect in recent comics now that she’s not characterized as unstable and out of control.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*A16CPRsDfadS0RDOmgMN2A.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit: </strong>Ryan Ottley, Marvel Comics</figcaption></figure><p>But this comes at the cost of the reader trying to keep track of it all. Just try and understand the lineage of certain characters, especially mutants, and you can get lost in decade-long webs of countless writers trying to tie up loose ends, only for more to be created. It’s a part of the beauty of cape comics in that they are a collaborative process, but it means there’s no universal voice for any one character. Countless authors have penned the adventures of Spider-Man, each with their own impression of who he is and how he acts. Some writers go out of their way to contradict those who came before; Nick Spenser, the writer of <em>Amazing Spider-Man</em>, went out of his way to denounce how Dan Slott, the previous author of Spidey’s adventures, characterized Peter Parker in his opening storyline, separating Spider-Man and Peter into two entities to highlight his issues.</p><p>With how much change can gradually build over the course of a single character’s life, let alone the world they reside in, these history book comics feel almost inevitable, a means of teaching new readers the ins-and-outs of a respective universe while compiling all of the changes that are now considered “canon.” Like DC, Marvel has their own <em>History of the Marvel Universe</em> series, serving as a list of Sparknotes for the major events in Marvel’s publications. Some titles focus on particular groups rather than summarizing the entire canon; Marvel’s <em>Grand Design </em>books focus on the X-Men and the Fantastic Four specifically, whereas DC’s <em>The Other History of the DC Universe</em> highlights marginalized characters from minority groups within its world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/686/1*5eeirX-eM1v2wGzEeRQrNA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uX0USly6Oto">Thomas Judge</a>, YouTube</figcaption></figure><p>Perhaps the most digestible type of these books are the “early days” reflections. Marvel’s Season One series and DC’s Year One series look at the earliest days of a particular character or team, ripping away the cumbersome history to tell more grounded stories of uncertain, novice heroes. These don’t look to educate readers so much as make these books more accessible and welcoming. Yet, after they turn the final page, readers are often left in the lurch with no clear path forward in their reading journey. There’s typically no follow-up or direct sequel to these stories, meaning readers have to figure out what they feel comfortable reading with what little knowledge they now have.</p><p>As someone who is a self-taught comic book reader (yes, it is a skill), it was hard to navigate all of these barriers to entry. Comics don’t make it easy on newcomers, and it often feels like their efforts only highlights the inherent gatekeeping that comics facilitate. When I was 10, my cousin bought me the Masterworks Collection of the earliest Spider-Man comics, right around when the first Spider-Man movie was released in theaters. I was hooked, and very quickly found myself scouring my local library for more to read. I read whatever I could get my hands on with very mixed results. But I kept reading because I would find enough of what I enjoyed to outweigh what I didn’t. And eventually I came to appreciate the stuff I didn’t like, as it helped inform why I liked the books that I did.</p><p>But my biggest takeaway, and the thing that I think every aspiring comic book reader needs to hear, is that <strong>*you don’t need to know it all to enjoy cape comics.*</strong></p><p>It’s a hard thing to grasp at first, considering how often it’s pushed in our faces. And sure, there will be conversations or interactions in certain books that won’t make 100% sense all the time when reading a particular series. But the best comic stories, while informed by the histories of the characters and the world, aren’t so reliant on them that new readers can’t grasp what’s going on.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*GcFfrBEHintlK5SsyJrhvA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> Hayden Sherman, DC Comics</figcaption></figure><p>This is the beauty of alternate universes; they are fast tracks to reintroducing characters to new fans while providing enough of a spin for older fans to be invested. Those early comics I read as a kid? A lot of them were from the Ultimate Universe, Marvel’s revolutionary spin-off that looked to modernize their heroes and make them more approachable than ever. It’s the franchise that created the building blocks for the films, and they retained the core ideas of many of its heroes, namely Spider-Man. With last year seeing the debut of the phenomenal DC Absolute Universe and a new Marvel Ultimate Universe, it’s clear that fans are still looking for stories like this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/675/1*vUmBbqp4MQ8V1ewyI6KDLg.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> Greg Capullo, DC Comics</figcaption></figure><p>But even if you’re looking for books that take place within the main canon, there are plenty of books out there that can be easily understood by just about anyone. Batman is as popular as he is in part because he is a universally understood character, with his lore and world becoming easily identifiable, and a lot of his comics reflect this. The New 52 <em>Batman</em> run by Scott Snyder is one of my earliest experiences with the character outside of films and TV, and it strikes a nice balance between serving it’s long-time fans and welcoming in the new. It’s also the series that introduces the Court of Owls, one of the most interesting modern Batman villains in recent memory. Similarly, James Tynion IV’s run on <em>Detective Comics</em> introduces a whole Bat-family of characters I had never heard of before but made them lovable and understandable from the first pages.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*88IrUKkmnsLzRNWqm7daaw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> Esad Ribic, Marvel Comics</figcaption></figure><p>Thinking of Marvel, Jason Aaron’s Godbutcher arch from <em>Thor: God of Thunder</em> is a breathtaking 11-issue story that feels like a traditional Norse myth brought to a modern era. Tom King’s <em>The Vision</em> series explores what a Frankensteined family of Visions would look like, cleanly explaining the character’s otherwise labyrinthian family tree. And Luke Cage had a mini-series written and drawn by Genndy Tartakovsky of <em>Samurai Jack</em> fame, a goofy romp that shows off the creators immense skill while distilling the character down to his most basic form.</p><p>All of this is to say that these history books do both readers and the source material a disservice. Comics can be approachable if Marvel and DC get over themselves and don’t obsess over making sure readers perfectly understand their precious canon. There are so many great stories out there that readers are missing out on because of how imposing the hobby is. Yes, there are plenty of bad ones too, or books so steeped in its own lore that it loses itself in the details. But that’s the nature of every medium we consume; we watch bad movies or see disappointing shows, but then we learn what we like and what we don’t. Comics are no different, just more foreign in how they are created and presented. I firmly believe there’s a comic out there for anyone willing to give them a chance; you just have to take the time to look for it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8a29b88cdda2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Unstable Shelf: Rising to the Tabletop]]></title>
            <link>https://unstableshelf.medium.com/the-unstable-shelf-rising-to-the-tabletop-f134034b809d?source=rss-d6f6896b3fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f134034b809d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[red-rising]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fantasy-realm]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stonemaier-games]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Luke Muench]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Apr 2026 15:31:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-06T15:31:01.342Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*cxOHobSBEd-Q0hzlGoImlQ.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://boardgamegeek.com/image/5960554/red-rising"><em>Red Rising (the board game) cover</em></a> on BoardGameGeek</figcaption></figure><p>Stonemaier Games has been one of the pillars of the board game industry since the company’s inception in 2012, releasing the hit wine-making title <em>Viticulture</em>. While many of their games have bounced off me over the years, it’s important to recognize the company’s importance to a relatively niche hobby, with <em>Wingspan</em> being one of those touchstone games that even those not heavily invested in dice and cards may be familiar with.</p><p>One of the many games Stonemaier has released over time is <em>Red Rising</em>, based on the popular young adult trilogy of books penned by Pierce Brown. Jamey Stegmaier, the owner of Stonemaier Games, has gone on record stating that this game was a passion project for him. He waxes poetic about his love for the books in the opening passages of the rulebook for his game:</p><p><em>Red Rising is one of my favorite book series ever. Years ago I reached out to the author, Pierce Brown, to express my interest in the tabletop rights. They weren’t available at the time, but that began a multi-year process of trying again, failing to design the game, accepting design submissions, and ultimately having a eureka moment while playing Fantasy Realms with Alex [Schmidt] at my game night. A lot of design work with Alex, playtesting with the help of Stonemaier Ambassadors, and communications with Pierce and his team followed. This is my dream IP, and I’m incredibly excited to share this game with you.</em></p><p>So it feels like a low blow to heavily critique what I would describe as an overcomplicated, messy game, but my intent here isn’t to pick on a passionate person and their dream project. Rather, I think <em>Red Rising</em> the board game can teach us a little about how one’s passion for a project can lead to a worse overall product.</p><p>When I first played <em>Red Rising</em>, I had no familiarity with the books, nor would I for many years. I was a wannabe board game reviewer, provided a copy of the game for free by Jamey to cover on <a href="https://boardgamegeek.com/">BoardGameGeek</a>, the hub of all board gaming news and content. At the time, I <a href="https://boardgamegeek.com/thread/2818823/1-2-punchboard-reviews-red-rising">talked up the game a bit</a>, in part because I wanted to look good to the company giving me free stuff, and in part because I liked the game well enough after only a couple of playthroughs. It also helps that I had never experienced <em>Fantasy Realms</em>, one of the noted inspirations for the game (more on that later).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/664/1*jIhb8fX4qgideyTnfC24Vw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> Red Rising (the book) cover on Amazon</figcaption></figure><p>It was only in January that I got around to reading the book series for a reading club with some old college friends and my wife. It was, in fact, my recommendation to read it, as I had received it for Christmas over a year ago and never got around to actually picking it up. In all likelihood, I had asked for <em>Red Rising</em> due to my curiosity in relation to its board game counterpart; what book could be so impressive that Jamey would jump at the opportunity to design a game around it?</p><p>Turns out, a book that I didn’t find to be overly noteworthy. <em>Red Rising</em> is the first in a trilogy that looks to highlight the plight of the working class and their systematic manipulation by the rich elite in ways that younger readers can make sense of. The prevailing moral of the story is that if we all work together and get along, we can break the system that hurts so many people to the benefit of the few. In the year 2026, this theme feels hollow and childish to me, only further supported by framing that feels reminiscent of <em>Hunger Games</em>. Beyond the surface-level plotline of kids battling kids for the amusement of the rich, the way in which rebellion is presented across each of the trilogies feels strikingly in line with one another (although how much I remember of <em>Hunger Games’ </em>plot is hard to say).</p><p>The sequel books, <em>Golden Son</em> and <em>Morning Star</em>, see Brown improve his writing style and pacing, but also showcases very similar story structures and plot devices, to such a degree that I could often call out when a “twist” was about to happen based on signposting Brown lays out two pages prior. At odds with the assessment I just made, the conclusion of the trilogy rankled me and left a sour taste in my mouth, leaning on a couple of revelations that are intentionally omitted in ways that feels inauthentic to the reading experience. It feels unearned, juxtaposed to how the entire series had been written up until that point, turning me away from exploring any more of Brown’s on-going story.</p><p>Nothing I say here will harm the monumental success the series has seen since its creation, and I’m glad for that; I love to see people be passionate about things, even when I’m not (though I can be a tad jealous of the enthusiasm). What’s important to this discussion, though, is that I returned to <em>Red Rising</em> the board game with fresh eyes and a new perspective, now armed with the knowledge of the series it was born from.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/441/1*s3llswGO7JM5tayHiGolag.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> <a href="https://boardgamegeek.com/image/6177962/fantasy-realms">Fantasy Realms cover</a> on BoardGameGeek</figcaption></figure><p>Jamey’s mention of the board game <em>Fantasy Realms</em> above is important, as a lot of the framework of this game relates to it and its spiritual successor, <em>Marvel Remix</em>. For those unfamiliar, all three of these games are hand-sculpting games, meaning that players will be scored at the end of the game based on the collection of cards they have in their hand. Each of these cards will score a certain amount of points simply for being in your hand, but will also provide bonus points based on how they relate to the other cards in your hand. Throughout the game, you’ll sift through cards in a public display or draw blindly off the top of the deck, throwing away unwanted options in order to make room for your new, better cards. But the cards you throw away are made publicly available to your opponents, potentially allowing them to scope up those cards and score more points than you based on what they’ve been collecting. Enter the push and pull of gathering things that are good for you and denying your opponents things they could use.</p><p>While <em>Fantasy Realms</em> and <em>Marvel Remix</em> are relatively simple implementations of this idea, a typical game running 15 to 20 minutes, <em>Red Rising</em> takes this a few steps further, giving every card special abilities and adding a bunch of mechanics on top of the card sorting. While cards are still worth points, both on their own and in combination with others, you also get points for gathering three communal resources types; players will move up a Fleet track, earning points based on how high you are on the track, gather Helium, which are worth 3 points each, and will race to have the most influence in the Institute, gaining points based on their ranking compared to their foes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*sS-yjKJ7lEMfdiZSHjkMQw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> <a href="https://boardgamegeek.com/image/6095748/red-rising">@sverbeure</a> on BoardGameGeek</figcaption></figure><p>Different cards play into each of these strategies, allowing you to excel in particular action types or making particular actions more valuable; Blue pilots, for example, will accelerate how quickly you move up the Fleet track, and will provide you with extra points based on how high you are on the track at the end of the game. The twist is that in order to use a card’s ability, you need to put it into the public display, making it available for other players to take before it’s your turn again. And based on where you place your abandoned card, you have to replace it from a different column, providing you with an effect based on where you’re drawing it from.</p><p>In theory, this leads to a lot of thoughtful decisions, as you have a lot of factors to balance, both in terms of how to cultivate your hand and how to mess with other players. In practice, there is way too much information available at all times, leading to lengthy turns of players reading through a ton of text. Beyond the 5+ cards in your hand, there’s the many cards in the central display, with players needing to move cards around to read the cards tucked underneath each other. And each card has so much info to digest that it eventually becomes a game where you just do whatever thing seems decent in the moment, regardless of how other players might benefit from it. Or, if you’re my friends, you’ll do the thing that is most inconvenient to everyone, including themselves, because they think it’s funny (it kind of is).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*7WDKeEwDxbo2CKZBPOg2jg.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> <a href="https://boardgamegeek.com/image/6071383/red-rising">@GrAlutka</a> on BoardGameGeek</figcaption></figure><p>There’s a bunch of other elements and mechanics I haven’t explained, like how the Sovereign token works or how the game ends, but there are plenty of other posts about the complete ins and outs of how this game functions. Rather, I think it’s about time we got around to the book series’ narrative implementation in the game, which is what I find to be so fascinating. <em>Red Rising</em> the board game is slavishly loyal to the original trilogy, in a way that I found surprising. Nearly every named character in the series makes an appearance, with their abilities and scoring paramters relating to their aspirations and relationships. An easy, non-spoilery example is Sevro and the Howlers. In the book, Sevro is a Gold (the upper class of this world) dressed in a wolf pelt who leads a guerilla warfare unit called The Howlers. In the game, both Sevro and The Howlers are cards, getting bonus points for being in your hand together at the end of the game. Additionally, if you play Sevro to the display and reveal you have the Howlers in hand, you can add a bonus card to your hand that turn, which is a huge boon in a game where every card can provide upwards of 40 points, all while giving you more flexibility.</p><p>The trouble is, every card in the deck is unique. There’s only one Sevro card and one Howler card amidst the 112 cards in the deck. And there are many, many named characters all vying for other named characters, which poses a big design problem. Getting any of these two cards together can be a headache, let alone when some characters want multiple named companions. To solve this, Jamey took one of the factions of the series that is never given much attention in the book, Orange, and it made so many if not all of them (no, I haven’t checked each) can be treated as any named character. The Orange faction largely being characterized as basic military units, this is a weird anti-thematic choice in multiple ways, but is necessary for the game to otherwise work. So many effects and scoring parameters simply wouldn’t happen if this wasn’t the case.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/733/1*v3yp0bxzA7nNOWF6eheC1g.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit:</strong> <a href="https://boardgamegeek.com/image/6218188/red-rising">@starvinmartian_games</a> on BoardGameGeek</figcaption></figure><p>In this way, the game shines a critical light on how Pierce Brown largely ignores huge chunks of his society in his original trilogy. While the caste system of his world operates around 14 colors, the vast majority of the cast come from either the very top (Gold) or the very bottom (Red), with other colors, like Blue or Obsidian, getting some minor representation via the supporting cast. Arguably half the colors see little to no representation in the form of named characters, as is reflected in the game. Many cards are just job descriptions, like Chef, Gambler, etc., to fill in the gaps that otherwise are void of any applicable names. And while mechanically all colors can be useful in the right circumstance, players are more inclined towards the named characters because they tend to have more interesting and nuanced effects. Additionally, special editions of the game see cards of the Gold caste shine in the light due to golden foil printed on them, making them more appealing to look at and interact with.</p><p>There are a few other thematic oddities; while the game is framed around a competition in the Institute that occurs in <em>Red Rising</em> (the first book of the trilogy), the Sovereign (the equivalent of galactic president) is a title that can pass from player to player through the fourth board action. Beyond this role not being introduced to the story until the second book, it’s also not a title that any person can have, let alone students participating in a scholarly competition. Narratively, it becomes a sticking point that one character has held onto the title for far longer than they should, making the mercurial nature of the token in the board game odd. Additionally, players take on the roles of houses with the Institute, named after Roman gods, meaning that the title would be passed to organizations rather than individuals. There are plenty of other examples of things like this, but that’s the nature of translating a book to a board game. I don’t begrudge Jamey for making these concessions, but it only makes the elements he did hold on to stand out all the more.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*ZTTeIqVJOCo8BcPqDbfDmw.png" /><figcaption><strong>Credit: </strong><a href="https://boardgamegeek.com/image/6342839/red-rising">@Gryffinka_</a> on BoardGameGeek</figcaption></figure><p>So what we’re left with is a board game that overwhelms the player with mechanics and information in service of maintaining a storybook framework that crumbles under scrutiny. While there are aspects of the narrative that are maintained through the scoring mechanisms of the game, potentially spoiling major plot points, they remain in the game at the expense of the player experience. It’s an admirable effort that feels doomed from the start, but in some ways I like the game a little more than I did before this write-up. Seeing what Jamey does manage to accomplish, despite how frustrating I find the gameplay itself to be, is awe-inspiring in a labyrinthian kind of way. The more I stare down the various corridors, the more passageways I find, many of which lead to dead ends. While I wouldn’t recommend either the books or the game, I can’t help but stare in bewildered amusement as my friends, ignorant to any context that would illuminate what they’re doing, work tirelessly to make Mars as inhospitable as possible to everyone else at the table.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f134034b809d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>