<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by vakibs on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by vakibs on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@vakibs?source=rss-e8bc8466de4d------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 16:16:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@vakibs/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How to bring democracy to the kingdoms of social media]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vakibs/how-to-bring-democracy-to-the-kingdoms-of-social-media-5b327ee98cef?source=rss-e8bc8466de4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5b327ee98cef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[vakibs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Mar 2018 09:07:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-30T09:07:34.732Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*COILLv39zfol-lg215p-6w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Octopus King,<a href="https://micriise.deviantart.com/art/Octopus-King-318954315"> artwork by Micriise</a></figcaption></figure><p>This is a Facebook conversation between my friend Josip and me. Here is an earlier essay I wrote <a href="http://the-redpill.blogspot.de/2015/07/octopus-and-bicycle.html">“octopus and the bicycle”</a> which provides the context for my thoughts. Our conversation is about the mass harvesting of people’s data by social media.</p><p><strong>Vakibs (original post):</strong></p><p>Nice summary of the type of data Google, Facebook etc. collect on you.</p><p><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/mar/28/all-the-data-facebook-google-has-on-you-privacy">https://www.theguardian.com/…/all-the-data-facebook-google-…</a></p><p>We know that mass harvesting of people’s data can be used for manipulating politics. But it can also be used for setting the terms of insurance, real-estate prices etc. Even grocery prices can be adjusted to your disadvantage, based on your social history tracked on the web. Summarizing this according to game theory, your economic adversaries have better models of the economic game than yourself, thanks to all the espionage on your habits. So you lose.</p><p><strong>Josip:</strong></p><p>If police was gathering this much data there would be a massive outrage. But private companies, that provide value… That’s different.</p><p><strong>Vakibs:</strong></p><p>I think people make opinions based on what they consider are realistic alternatives. Luckily, we are living in a society where democratic alternatives exist in politics. So people do not accept police-state surveillance. But unfortunately, we do not yet have credible alternatives for software services that are ethical.</p><p><strong>Josip:</strong></p><p>And even when there are alternatives people prefer to use non-transparent vs. transparent services. Take for example Twitter and Mastodon (maybe Diaspora/FB comparison also works, but I haven’t used Diaspora for some time). Anyone can run a Mastodon instance, source is open, users have much total control over their data. But, most people, even if they care, can’t handle complexity. The other thing is that even if they payed somebody to handle this for them, they would still prefer to have filtered content. Mastodon is a bit messy to an average user, although I like it, because it reminds me of the early Internet. In the end, I think not too many people would be interested to pay for this, and in order to be successful the “social net” must be more massive. So here we are: paying for curated feeds with our privacy. We can do better, but because majority doesn’t care, we don’t. How to break this circle and create critical mass for the alternative: I don’t know.</p><p><strong>Vakibs:</strong></p><p>It is a mistake to think of social media websites like different consumer options in a supermarket. They are more like kingdoms which are created on a landmass of finite extent- which is user attention. The earlier web was akin to small tribal settlements of hunter-gatherers. Just like in the physical world, they are soon replaced by large city states. There is a sharp reduction of democracy, but people willingly trade that for a life of security, better infrastructure and importantly, the semblance of law and order. They are even willing to live like slaves under despots.</p><p>When we see social media like this, it is clear why people don’t migrate to alternate services like Mastodon. They cannot bring their friends, family and neighbors with them. Just like in the physical world, migrants will be mostly adventurers and others who have little to lose.</p><p>There are only two ways to redeem the situation: 1. destroy the kingdom by invasions / revolutionary uprisings. 2. Change the system of governance through democratic reforms. Option 1 is easier. Option 2 will take more time, and actually will be resisted even more by the despots.</p><p><strong>Josip:</strong></p><p>I don’t see revolution if there’s no relevant alternative. With kingdom the people, the institutions, the resources are there, in the psychical world. They don’t disappear. With software systems, if you destroy the system there’s nothing left. Nobody will do that. People would leave if there was relevant alternative. FB is a driftwood floating in the middle of the ocean. People attached to it don’t want to let it go. They will only do so if a boat comes.</p><p>But you’re right: in order for something to be judged as relevant good alternative to FB it has to capture user attention, to serve curated feeds, to send notifications. People want that. Existing alternatives do not do that, maybe because they lack technical infrastructure, and maybe because they do not want to curate anything.</p><p>Secondly, I think that majority of users are not aware of influence of privacy degradation on their life. I am not aware, I can’t because I don’t know what data is shared with whom, and then the decisions are algorithmic based on that data. But if somebody told me I wasn’t considered for a job based on a FB message or browsing history, I would ditch that service. But I don’t know that, so as far as I’m concerned, to the best of my knowledge, I’m getting more than I’m giving, because I can’t factor in opportunity cost.</p><p><strong>Vakibs:</strong></p><p>I wanted to highlight another aspect when I made the comparison with kingdoms. It is about security. Democratic alternatives to social media have to be defended, both from malicious attacks from outside and also corruption from inside. The opposition will not sit quietly, they will attack. Existing alternatives to Facebook, Twitter etc. are unfortunately not strong on security and infrastructure to resolve the problem rapidly. The servers where the data will be stored need to be defended, currently from malicious humans but ultimately from AI launched attacks.</p><p><strong>Josip:</strong></p><p>Data security, data storage, data availability and feed curtaion all require a lot of knowledge and cost a lot, and in future we’ll need autonomous data protection/encryption, data caching &amp; load balancing, data compression and curation algorithms or agents. Agents that can explain their decisions, through conversation in natural language. Agents that can be re-programmed via natural language. Agents that can warn you of possible consequences of sharing private information. Even with current state of technology, how to support all this without money from the third parties that want user data, either raw or distilled, that want to influence curation, I don’t know.</p><p>In some future “social net” the that data will be distributed and the agents could hop from node to node. This is not new, this is “semantic web” vision from 90s, and most probably even before. I’m sure that people are working on a distributed version of “social net” that takes these requirements into account. But that is far, far in the future, I think.</p><p><strong>Vakibs:</strong></p><p>I think the easiest way to finance this data storage and protection is to provide them at the local level, as a service that people have to pay for in the local town hall. This is just like any other utility (water, electricity etc.). We either pay for it directly or indirectly fund it through taxation. We need to look at protecting digital health (security, privacy, protection of digital identity) as similar to protecting bodily health and ecological health. I am optimistic that our society will soon recognize it to be so. Once that is recognized, financing is not that difficult.</p><p><strong>Josip:</strong></p><p>I agree, and also hope that this recognition will come soon!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5b327ee98cef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Yogic Model for Information Processing]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vakibs/a-yogic-model-for-information-processing-51b4e828e7a8?source=rss-e8bc8466de4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/51b4e828e7a8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hindu]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[yoga]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[information-processing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cognitive-psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-interface-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[vakibs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 17 Feb 2018 20:54:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-02-18T09:07:09.317Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Are current user-interfaces encouraging us to consume information mindlessly? Does blocking information help? Can human consciousness be elevated by better interface design for applications? In this essay, I will present a perspective from the philosophical framework of Yoga.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*skn3EKHVigQcJB9I.jpg" /></figure><p>The starting point for my thoughts is a question that I asked myself sometime ago, about whether Shannon’s definition of information as “surprise” is overlooking some basic biological framework of being human.</p><h3>vakibs on Twitter</h3><p>By defining information as &quot;surprise&quot;, did #Shannon bias our understanding of it by sympathetic neural circuit vs. parasympathetic circuit?</p><p>Shannon’s theory for information processing, which was developed first for faithful encoding and decoding of communications e.g, in a telephone network, influenced many other far out domains where it was never intended.</p><p>Here is Whiting’s information processing model for human cognition in sports etc.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*pV8rutd1guNg8ajI.jpg" /></figure><p>A fundamental thing about this model is that it is a linear pathway : input → (pipeline) → output.</p><p>There can be many blocks in the pipeline, but the input/output resemble Shannon’s original diagram for communication in a channel. What if this is a bad way to look at the process ? An alternative way to look at a similar process is to consider this as a homeostasis, like how nature maintains ecological balance, or how a cell maintains pH or temperature.</p><p>Another example is about how a peaceful cognitive state can be maintained in the mind by meditation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/819/0*PUEbEN4mNq04CG4f.jpg" /></figure><p>I will use the Yogic philosophical framework to sketch out how such a theory for cognition and “information processing” might look like. In Yoga, before we deal with the mind, we discuss two things: food and breath. I will discuss them first as metaphors. This follows the understanding that the human body is a “<em>Pancha Kōsha</em>” or that it has 5 conceptual planes: <em>Annamaya</em> (material plane &amp; food), <em>Prāṇamaya</em> (breath), <em>Manōmaya</em> (mind), <em>Vijñānamaya</em> (understanding &amp; awareness) and <em>Ānandamaya</em> (bliss).</p><p>I will discuss the first 3 planes, starting with the material plane. How does the body process food?</p><p>It can be argued as follows: the energy that comes in via food goes into 5 different usages/pathways:</p><ol><li>For digestion and excretion.</li><li>For speaking.</li><li>For acting out in the world through motor organs.</li><li>For using motor organs to bring new food in.</li></ol><p>I didn’t mention the basic and most essential usage.</p><p>0. For letting things just be as they are. For maintaining whatever is within the body which is food (for whichever animal) to remain so as food without deteriorating → this is homeostasis.</p><p>One might say it is a peculiar way to look at the problem. But there is a logic. It becomes clearer when we discuss breath.</p><p>The plane of breath can also be considered to have 5 components. Here, Yogic philosophy gives them clear names.</p><ol><li><strong>Apāna : </strong>The breath that activates digestion and pushes excreta out of the body. This circulates in the lower part of the body.</li><li><strong>Udāna :</strong> The breath that enables speaking, by inhaling and exhaling through the mouth . This circulates in the upper part of the body.</li><li><strong>Vyāna:</strong> The breath that pushes air to all extremities of the body. This regulates blood flow that supplies nutrients everywhere. This nourishes the muscles so that they can move.</li><li><strong>Samāna:</strong> The breath that draws air inwards from all corners. This diffuses entropy: pH, heat etc.</li></ol><p>The counterpart to the usage 0 is the breath itself that maintains homeostasis &amp; keeps the body alive, letting it inhale and exhale further into the future.</p><p>0. <strong>Prāṇa:</strong> It circulates in the most essential circuit to keep the body alive: center of the brain, spinal cord, other vital organs.</p><p>It is important to discuss breath because the plane of breath is the <em>only</em> way a person can control amongst the various modes of vital activities regulated by the parasympathetic neural circuit. All the 5 types of breath can be independently controlled with respect to their pace. It is only by this ability to control breath that other activities can be indirectly controlled: heart-beat, digestive ability, sleep, dream states etc.. which are all possible to some degree by the mastery of breath control. In the Yogic scheme, food nourishes breath and breath nourishes mind. It is an illusion that most people have that they can make their mind go wherever they want. This is absolutely not true. The control of mind is much harder than the control of breath.</p><h3>Five modes of information flow in “mental processing”</h3><p>Now let us discuss the 5 equivalent modes for “mind processing”. This is how information gets consumed and metabolized by the mind.</p><p><strong>Apāna: </strong>Information is digested &amp; excreted. The mind creates no new modalities except excreting it in a less usable form (and slowly decaying).</p><p><strong>Udāna: </strong>Information is used for speaking. In Yoga, this is considered to have the potential to activate a creative source (<em>parā</em>). It is then transmuted into 3 forms: <em>pashyanti</em>, <em>madhyama</em> &amp; <em>vaikhari</em>. A less aware mind is considered to perceive only the outer forms and does not possess creativity. On the mental plane, every activity to produce new information can be considered as an output of Udāna. The vocal pathway with the tongue is the most powerful muscle in the body, but other pathways can channel the <em>Parā</em> as well, pushing the universe into new creative directions.</p><p><strong>Vyāna:</strong> This is about integrating the information into one’s body and one’s own identity. Until the information becomes part of every fibre, it has not really been used. This is the most powerful expression of embodied cognition.</p><p><strong>Samāna:</strong> This causes the discrepancies and imbalances in one’s body and self-identity be reduced to equality by the flow of information. This is the antidote to cognitive dissonance. This is our hope to get over walls of hatred through truly understanding each other.</p><p><strong>Prāṇa:</strong> This is the eternal flow of information that keeps the body and mind in homeostasis. This is what we need to protect : free software, open-source and open-data. This is the divine Saraswati that creates and nourishes all. We need her protection. She needs no protection.</p><p>Most applications for the web and smartphones today might be applying a rather limited model of information processing for designing user interfaces, treating the user as a cog between input and output. That is between (a prejudiced view of) <em>Prāṇa</em> and <em>Apāna</em> only. Such a design for user interface does not imagine the other modes of mental activity. In Yoga, it is considered that people who activate only <em>Apāna</em> will die. It is a death on the mental plane, sooner or later. But even if it is later, it is a slow death with every minute of life being a process of death. Don’t let social media feed your <em>Apāna</em> !</p><p>In the early days of computer applications, full programmability was the norm. It was possible to activate all five modes of mental activity. The current user-interfaces are designed to block your creative agency. Like junk food and opioids that will only keep you addicted, user interfaces are being hacked to hook you into predictable modes of behavior. What way for the future? A full theory of cognitive interfaces is needed, where all the 5 mentioned activities in the mental plane can be modeled and measured: not all clubbed and hidden under a trivial activity like <em>Apāna</em>. Until such a design for user-interfaces becomes the norm, we might need to periodically plug out our minds — out of badly designed interfaces.</p><h3>A Yogic framework of user-interface design to elevate the consciousness of the user</h3><p><a href="http://sequencewiz.org/2014/09/03/5-vayus/">Here is a faithful introduction to the 5 types of Prāna</a> in Yoga, with a few postures and exercises that enable you to control them.</p><p>The author Olga Kabel has wisely disabled her twitter account. But she refers to the book of scholar <a href="https://twitter.com/davidfrawleyved">@davidfrawleyved</a> who is active.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/390/0*btCaTdYs6TjIa6k1.jpg" /></figure><p>The American Institute of Vedic Studies, founded by <a href="https://twitter.com/davidfrawleyved">@davidfrawleyved</a> has <a href="https://www.vedanet.com/addiction-and-the-digital-age-the-need-for-higher-consciousness/">an article that connects tech addiction to the addiction of food &amp; drugs</a>, which I discussed previously in a Twitter thread. In the Yogic framework, these addictions are similar.</p><h3>vakibs on Twitter</h3><p>I am really looking forward to see a comparative study on how using a computer interface (or playing a game or using social media on the internet) compares with taking a drug. Does any exist? It is likely that same brain regions are affected. But how badly? We need to test this.</p><p>Although the nature of tech addiction is still not understood today at the neuro-physiological level, mapping these addictive pathways is the relatively easier part.</p><p>It is more difficult to understand what would be supportive technologies &amp; user-interfaces that amplify Yogic consciousness. We do not yet have a theory to optimize for the “joy” of using a technology, leading ultimately to the most supreme of such joys —<em> Ānanda</em> . But in an old essay on my blog, I gave some wild examples of how such technologies might look like.</p><h3>vakibs on Twitter</h3><p>Can we fix our social and political problems by thinking of them as computer interfaces ? Optimized for joy. https://t.co/qFoovtEkfn</p><p>I think extending the practices of <em>Āsana</em> and <em>Prāṇāyāma</em> of Yōga to the sphere of the mind (<em>Manōmaya</em>) will let us build a framework for designing such technologies.</p><p>In the Yōgic framework, <em>Prāṇa</em> is the most essential of all the 5 planes of existence, encompassing even the mind. In the <em>Brihadāraṇyaka</em> <em>Upanishad</em>, Sākalya (student) discusses with Rishi Yājñavalkya (teacher) on what are the most essential Dēvas. The 33 <em>Viśwēdēvas</em> of ṚgVeda (which encompass all the aspects of the universe) are successively reduced to 6,3,2,1.5 and ultimately to 1 (Prāṇa).</p><p>How to control the five aspects of <em>Prāṇa</em>?</p><p>Firstly, <em>Apāna</em> should not be excessive but has to be integrated with <em>Prāṇa</em>. Stillness and ecologically rich areas amplify <em>Prāṇa</em>, which has to flow freely with the universe. It is said that<em> Dēvas</em> (immortals) feed on <em>Prāṇa</em>, <em>Asuras</em> (who suffer death) feed on <em>Apāna</em>.</p><p>Secondly, <em>Vyāna</em> and <em>Samāna</em> have to be realized. This can happen only in silence. In breathing, <em>Vyāna</em> (expansion) is realized by holding the breath after inhaling. <em>Samāna</em> (dissolution) is realized by holding the breath after exhaling.</p><p><em>Vyāna</em> refers to the deity <em>Vishnu</em> and<em> Samāna</em> to the deity <em>Shiva</em>. <em>Vyāna</em> and <em>Samāna</em> can be visualized as the opening and closing of the infinite lotus that is located at the heart (<em>Hṛt</em>-<em>Padma</em>). This can aid in meditation. I discussed the corresponding imagery in <a href="http://www.pragyata.com/mag/the-infinite-lotus-451">my article here</a>.</p><p>Finally, if these 4 aspects of <em>Prāṇa</em> are in balance, then <em>Udāna</em> can be controlled. This is the means to tap into cosmic creativity that is also present in one’s own body. It will lead to joy of different levels, which is technically the fulfillment of the 7 <em>Chakras</em> located along the spine of one’s body.</p><p>While <em>Prāṇa</em> refer to the sensory organs (<em>Jñānendriya</em>), <em>Apāna</em> &amp; <em>Udāna</em> refer to the organs of motor control (<em>Karmēndriya</em>). In mythic imagery, these two polarities are the worlds of <em>Dēvas</em> and <em>Pitṛs</em>. They define two ways to exercise one’s Karma (action). Both are important. In this framework, a technology that does not exercise the user’s motor control and creative capacity, while forcing the user to be passively consuming information, is considered to create an imbalance of <em>Prāṇa</em>.</p><p>Social media and most apps on “smartphones” fail on these counts. Further, if no distinction is made between mere excretion (<em>Apāna</em>) and creative action (<em>Udāna</em>), users cannot maintain their focus.</p><p>In Yoga, <em>Apāna</em> is controlled by <em>Bandha</em> (blocking) e.g, <em>Mulabandha</em> (contracting pelvic muscles). Meditation is supported by <em>Mudra</em> (posture &amp; finger gesture). Any technology can be interpreted as an extension of the user’s own body. Indeed, such extended body image can be part of one’s own brain and controlled with brain interfaces. This can also be true for virtual interfaces on software. We need a theory of <em>Bandha</em> &amp; <em>Mudra</em> for these user-interfaces.</p><p>Finally, an understanding is needed on how to effectively encode silence (<em>Anāhata</em>). Silence has meaning given the holistic ecological context within which to interpret it. But in Shannon’s information theory, silence has no information. i.e, there is no place for <em>Samāna</em> &amp; <em>Vyāna</em>. In my opinion, a complete theory for the design of user interfaces based on Yogic principles is possible. But this also needs to extend the very basics of information theory. So this is a tall order, but possible.</p><p>Acknowledgement: This essay has been created out of a Twitter thread, which is prepared into an essay using <a href="https://tinysubversions.com/spooler/">Spooler</a> and further edited slightly on Medium. Thanks to Darius Kazemi for providing Spooler.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=51b4e828e7a8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Morality in Language and Dharma]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vakibs/morality-in-language-and-dharma-2320b90b371f?source=rss-e8bc8466de4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2320b90b371f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dharma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[panchatantra]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mahabharata]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mencius]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[vakibs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 May 2017 14:35:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-09T17:22:27.669Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SAnaRN2SzBW4skqXY3l1Qw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Persian miniature painting illustrating a story from the Panchatantra.</figcaption></figure><p>Human culture has evolved two methods to reason about morality. Language is the fundamental tool for reasoning, but it can be used in two ways to debate about what forms the right action and what forms the wrong action, in any given circumstance.</p><p>The first method is the legalist approach — to write everything down as a set of laws. Probably, the first person to codify law in this manner was Hammurabi. The more famous examples were the ten commandments of Moses, or the religious books of Christianity and Islam. Religious scholars will be horrified if anybody argues that humans could be moral without such a codified set of rules. However, it is not just religion that imposes this structure on morality. The notion of a constitution, which supposedly protects the set of rights for citizens (and even all humans, and sometimes even animals), is based on this legalist understanding of morality. Needless to say, this way of thinking is almost universal in today’s world. The debate is merely about how long this list of rights be, and what should be included and what not in this list. Nobody asks the deeper question of whether it is even possible to even completely encode ethical action in all real-world contexts within a language. Non-governmental organizations that battle for human rights also think within this framework. However, in human history, this was not the only way to think about morality.</p><h4>Mencius and Panchatantra provide an alternate way to think about morality, as cognitive training through stories.</h4><p>The second method to reason about morality is to give a set of examples, typically encoded as stories, and to reason how a given circumstance fits into one of these examples. This approach is not rigidly codified in language, but requires an element of human interpretation and imagination. This is probably the most common approach for understanding ethics in all human cultures, including tribal cultures. This approach to morality is beautifully expressed by the Chinese philosopher Mencius. He argued that people should memorize classical texts like the “<em>Book of Odes</em>”, and the examples of conduct from the “<em>Analects of Confucius</em>” and quote these examples in situations of daily life. This is a reinforcement of an earlier injunction from Confucius, who argued about using sacred poems from the “<em>Book of Odes</em>” in daily life. But Mencius gave an important elaboration to this argument, he said that the examples are not applicable literally and immediately to a given situation in life. Instead, people should cultivate an inherent mental capacity known as “moral extension” that lets them generalize the kernel of wisdom in a given example to a new context. Without this capacity for moral extension, Mencius argued that there is no wisdom in a dead text. The genius of Mencius lies in observing two innate aspects of how the human mind works: (i) the mind’s actions are not atomic, but based on the subconscious that is cultivated for a long time by a variety of influences from the environment (ii) the real world is infinitely complex and no amount of codified knowledge from the past can relate exactly to a new situation. Instead, the human mind has to actively generalize known ideas and categories. Both of these observations are justified by the current understanding from neuroscience in how the brain works.</p><p>In India, this understanding is even more elaborated. For example, the fables of Panchatantra invented a method of recursive story-telling, where characters in a story reason about a given situation by relating a different story and arguing about how to extend the moral argument. Like Russian dolls, these stories are embedded at several levels. Such narrative devices were not present in the Chinese example (or in the Aesop’s fables of Europe, which were created much later). Another startling element of Panchatantra is that the characters are fully fleshed out, with even animals having names and personalities. Such narrative devices were not to be seen in Europe till the modern times, like in the literary novel. However, Panchatantra was embedded in the greater corpus of Hindu stories and epics — known as Itihasas and Puranas. In this tradition, the right ethical conduct, termed as Dharma, is known to be ineffable and beyond any form of codification in language. Unique to all ancient civilizations, Indians had a very sophisticated understanding of language, in the form of Sanskrit. This language is of exquisite precision and fecundity, unparalleled to this day in any other language. But even with this extremely precise language, Indians felt inadequate in expressing “truth” or “ethical conduct” in a rigid set of laws. This is probably due to their understanding of the pitfalls of logic, and specifically of the two-sided negation, which completely escaped the Greek tradition of Aristotle. The notion of non-expressibility in language appeared in Western philosophy extremely late, for example, in the works of C.S.Peirce or Ludwig Wittgenstein. In contrast, this question was studied very rigorously in India from the earliest days.</p><p>Indians did have a large volume of literary texts for codifying ethical conduct, which were known as Dharma Shastras. But unlike the Biblical example, these texts come with a warning that they are not to be blindly applied to any context in space and time. Manu, the author of one of the earliest texts, states explicitly to not use his code in any context, but to modify it appropriately. Unlike the code of Hammurabi, Manu Smriti was only meant as suggestive and not a rigid enforcement. Another unique aspect of Dharma Shastras is the emphasis on Prayaschitta (prayah + chitta = prior mind) that is used as a corrective to a crime, in addition to Danda or Vyavahara (external punishment). This refers to a Confucian-like understanding of the subconscious of the mind, which needs to be trained, such that a misconduct will not be repeated. Vedic Yagna (sacrifice) also remains a superlative of Confucian ritual, with exhaustive attention to detail in how to perform the ritual and how to even chant the Mantras. But despite the attention to detail and copious volume of these texts, Indians did not rely exclusively on legal texts like the Dharma Shastras, but debated about Dharma using examples from the epics. The greatest of these epics is the Mahabharata, which ruthlessly discusses the nature of Dharma in many tricky situations. These stories are immensely popular to this day and form part of a living tradition. Such popular depiction of Dharma through stories is known as the “Panchama Veda” or the “Fifth Veda”. This term is used to denote both the Mahabharata and the Natyashastra — the treatise on drama and dance for depicting stories. The comparison with Vedas should not make them similar to religious scripture. Stories can be chosen or left out, because whether they are relevant to any given situation is always open for debate.</p><p>In ancient China, there was a philosophical battle between the different schools of thought, on whether law can be explicitly formulated or not. The first philosopher to argue explicitly for written law was Mozi, who stated that personal bias needs to be minimized in any conduct. Mencius argued back, stating that doing this is impossible, due to the very nature of the human mind. Mencius was in turn critiqued by Xun Zi, who argued that his philosophy is not practical and cannot be applied to a worldly situation. Later philosophers like Shang Yang and Han Fei created a powerful framework called “legalism” that is arguably the origin of Chinese bureaucracy (and all modern bureaucracy). This efficient bureaucracy has unified China under the Qin dynasty, but this process resulted in a lot of violence, including the murders of Shang Yang and Han Fei. Abandoned for a long time, the ideas of Mencius found favor in China at a later time, along with the spread of Buddhist ideas from India. Owing to the Indian intellectual tradition, Buddhist philosophy is intimately aware of the limitations of language and binary logic. Thus, the Chinese popular understanding of ethics is also very closely aligned with the Indian notion of Dharma. This is however not represented in state policy.</p><h4>Asuras and Devas represent two sides of language. Creative action is possible only by a tussle between the two sides.</h4><p>In ancient India, this legalist turn to rigid law never happened. A figure comparable to Shang Yang was Chanakya (Kautilya), who unified Indian polity under the Mauryan empire. In contrast to Shang Yang, who advocated the ruthless manipulation of individuals for the cause of universal good, Chanakya had a nuanced notion of Dharma. He advocated a minimalist state which lets different individuals lead their lives according to their personal Dharma, but which protects the common universal ethic. With this background, it may appear that a literalist interpretation was unknown in India, but actually it was refined to a very great detail. It was known as the Asura perspective. This refers to the Asuras, who confuse their bodies with the true self. They were contrasted with the Devas, who know that their true self is not identical to their bodies, but shared between each other. The perspectives of the Asuras and Devas give two distinct theories about meaning: one claims it is contained completely within the words of language, the other claims it is contained in the holistic context of how words are used. This eternal debate keeps happening between philosophers grounded in Nirukta and Vyakarana perspectives in India. After Ferdinand de Saussure developed European linguistic theory on the basis of the Sanskrit grammar of Panini, a similar debate germinated between structuralists and post-structuralists (deconstructionists) in 20th century Europe.</p><p>Hindu mythography recognizes this to be an eternal unresolvable battle, and represents these two positions through the figures of Vishnu and Shiva. In the Indian tradition, creative action is represented using the mythical image of Samudra Manthan — as an eternal tussle between the Asuras and the Devas, pulling on either ends of the giant snake Vasuki (language). Thus, the Asura perspective was considered essential, even though its limitations were identified. In contrast, the western interpretations of “law” are exclusively Asuric. With Islamic invasions and European colonization, this Asuric perspective replaced the notion of Dharma for the Indian state. However, a corresponding change in the cultural mindset has not happened. In India, even Muslims and Christians have an innate understanding of Dharma as something beyond law.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gDt39AFxWDxvB2h-thq5OQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Samudra Manthan is an ancient Hindu myth, with Devas and Asuras churning the milk ocean by pulling from the two sides of a giant snake (language).</figcaption></figure><p>The two different ways to reason about morality can be measured with respect to their relative success in inculcating moral behavior in people. The contrast is very stark. Starting from the archaeological record from Indus-Saraswati valleys, India shows extremely low amounts of violence as compared to the rest of the world. Unlike the total war in Europe (and ancient China) which engulfed all sections of the society, war in India was restricted exclusively to the warrior classes. The farmers and artisans are protected from violence, as is the fertile capacity of the earth — represented by rivers and cattle. Even in war, enemy is given multiple opportunities to surrender, and no surrendered enemies are murdered. This is in stark contrast to the plurality of incidents of genocide in Abrahamic religions, as well as in western archaeological record.</p><p>India fares better than even China, which is already very humane when compared to the barbarism of the west. Unlike the legalists in China, who advocated the abduction and even murder of philosophers and thinkers from the opposing countries, India had a sharp ban on the murder of philosophers. A trial like that of Socrates has never happened in India because ideological differences were not considered as a threat to social order. The power of the king was not absolute in India, unlike in most other civilizations. And absolute slavery was non-existent. Even in the medieval periods, India showed extremely low amounts of violence (this data is conspicuously absent from the massive tome of Steven Pinker “Better angels of our nature”). Pinker argues that literary novels which encouraged people to take the perspective of different characters have massively reduced violence in Europe. He relates this to corresponding anatomical areas in the human brain. However, he says that this civilizational turn happened for the first time ever in history in Europe. This is absolutely wrong. The data from India is often uncomfortable for any myth-making about Western or Judaeo-Christian supremacy, so this is simply just ignored. This is unpardonable because India is the largest concentration of humans in the world for the most part of history.</p><p>In conclusion, thinking about morality through stories is far better than arguing about it within the prism of legal texts. This removes the power of ethical interpretation from a special class of humans (lawyers) and places it within the reach of all humans. Unlike technical or artistic expertise, which is always specialized, morality should be a universal. An ethical model based on stories and rituals inculcates ethical behavior by molding the subconscious of individuals as well as that of the society. Such an ethical model is completely absent from the western Hobbesian state. With the rise of India and China, this ancient Dharmic model of state might find a rebirth. This will be better for all humanity.</p><p><strong>Additional Reading / Watching:</strong></p><ol><li>On <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/mencius/">the philosophy of Mencius</a> and his debates with literalists like Mozi and Xunzi.</li><li>On <a href="http://the-redpill.blogspot.de/2015/11/the-four-sided-negation-tool-for.html">the four-sided negation in Indian logic</a></li><li>On <a href="http://the-redpill.blogspot.de/2016/11/computational-science-by-sanskrit.html">the scientific nature of Sanskrit language</a></li><li>On the <a href="http://the-redpill.blogspot.de/2016/02/a-comparison-of-confucian-taoist.html">comparison between Daoist-Confucian dichotomy with the Shaivaite-Vaishnavaite dichotomy</a></li><li>This debate of Dharma vs. scriptural law is alluded even in modern Indian films, as <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/baahubali-2-indias-blindfolds-are-off-and-its_us_5911594ae4b046ea176aee9f?ncid=engmodushpmg00000004">Vamsee Juluri reviews on Bahubali</a>.</li><li>Michel Danino’s <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZP1StpYEPM">lecture on the relevance of Indian knowledge systems</a> today.</li><li>Michel Danino’s lectures on <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1GzRboJSr7Y&amp;index=7&amp;list=PLRfu94TCePTtVPR-kC4RpIGIwo7-ViCGP">ancient Indian administration</a> and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oh-RXY8RRpU&amp;index=8&amp;list=PLRfu94TCePTtVPR-kC4RpIGIwo7-ViCGP">ethics</a></li><li>Subhash Kak explains the Indian scientific tradition of Vaiseshika and the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K7FXsMcKxsk">dual interplay of Deva and Asura perspectives</a>.</li><li>Rajiv Malhotra and Sri Louise discuss <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SNpVBfgzPmo">Vedic non-translatables and the non-expressibility of certain concepts</a>.</li><li>Balagangadhara discusses the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Bm4fLpDIos">Indian notion of history (Itihasa) and how meaning is derived from Hindu mythography</a>.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2320b90b371f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How is Sanskrit the mother of Dravidian languages ?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vakibs/how-is-sanskrit-is-the-mother-of-dravidian-languages-5386ab0e8668?source=rss-e8bc8466de4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5386ab0e8668</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dravidian-languages]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kannada]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[telugu]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[language-evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sanskrit]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[vakibs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 26 Nov 2016 12:31:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-12-03T18:33:17.589Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/757/1*QNe36kq3sIR75ulUK1zK-w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Aryāvarta: Extent of the fertile cultivated lands around the Saraswati river during the Vedic period.</figcaption></figure><p>For about ten thousand years, the Indian subcontinent was not only the most populous area in the world, but also its most technologically and economically advanced civilization. But despite this, this region preserved its biological diversity. The forests of India housed vast numbers of tigers and other wild animals, whose numbers started to decline only during the colonial era. The same is true for linguistic and cultural diversity in human societies. One can contrast how Irish and other Celtic languages got exterminated from the British isles with how Dravidian and south east Asian languages thrived despite the dominance of Sanskrit. India may be the only example for a world civilization where tribal languages and customs are preserved, despite being in close contact with literate societies.</p><p>This is all the more surprising because there are very few examples for linguistic and cultural diversity in the world that retained them over history. The richest place in the world for language diversity today is the island of New Guinea, where new dialects and languages can be seen at every mountain and valley. But the vocabulary in these languages is small, reflecting the subsistence lifestyles of the tribal villagers. As these villagers are absorbed into a modern state, their education, religion and technology are conducted in English. Thus, English becomes the ultimate source of technical vocabulary in these languages. But there is a problem. The tribals of New Guinea would have no control on how this vocabulary is generated. English is not a scientific language with a precise grammar of word formation. Instead, its vocabulary is a hodge-podge created by convention and historical usage. Thus, it will not nourish the usage of native tribal languages, which will ultimately perish as people would find no economic utility for speaking them. This is a story that happened repeatedly across the globe, where local languages were annihilated in the course of just a few generations by colonizing powers speaking English, Spanish, Arabic or Chinese. So why is it that we have a dramatic counter-example in India ?</p><p>The answer may be in the computational nature of the Sanskrit language and the sciences nourished by it. Taken together, they are a means to amplifying the consciousness of a person, making him aware of every single aspect of life and his conduct to it. This reinforcement of consciousness is the key to avoiding environmental catastrophe in any age. Often, humans destroy living ecosystems through sheer ignorance and by not paying attention. Greed is a big factor, but stupidity results in greater violence in the longer term. <br> <br> In Indian linguistic theory, the languages and the belief systems that we think in are called as <em>Prakrits</em> — applicable to a specific place and context. A certain type of fish might survive in certain type of waters, but other fish may die. Such is the case with <em>Prakrits</em>, they cannot claim to be universal. Further, if they become polluted (becoming <em>Apabhramsas</em>), they cause suffering to the very creatures that used to live there earlier. The greatest cause of suffering is the ego nurtured by the polluted mind — the trail of cultural and linguistic destruction by colonizing forces is a testament to this ego. For example, after they conquered Bengal, the British have systematically scorched the region with famine to break the morale of people. The Americans exterminated the bison so that they could starve the native Indian tribes that depended on it. Ultimately, such wanton ecological and cultural destruction will bring the civilization to collapse.</p><blockquote>An infinite number of new words can be created in Sanskrit, whose meaning will be unambiguous to a Sanskrit speaker. Like pure waters of an unpolluted river, Sanskrit can be enjoyed by all living beings.</blockquote><p>There is an important lesson to be learned from human civilizations like in India that survived for a long time without ecological collapse (at least until today’s age). The lesson is the open computational grammar of Sanskrit, which makes it modifiable to suit to specific local contexts in space and time, such that the human mind pays attention to the changing constraints of nature. Unlike any other human language (<em>Prakrit</em>), Sanskrit requires no dictionary, but possesses a precise set of computational rules for word formation, given by grammarians like Panini 2600 years ago. An infinite number of new words can be created in Sanskrit, whose meaning will be unambiguous to a Sanskrit speaker. Importantly, Sanskrit requires no local authority to judge on the correct usage of these words. For example, if the tribes of New Guinea adopted Sanskrit, they would need no validation from an authority in India, as they can use the open grammatical rules of Sanskrit to enrich their own local languages. Indeed, this was precisely what has happened in South East Asia (and to a smaller extent in China, Korea and Japan), where the languages borrowed an immense number of words from Sanskrit, but retained their individual <em>Praktit</em> nature. Unlike any other colonization example from history, this spread of Sanskrit language and culture did not happen by military conquest, but by the great desire of people to borrow science and medicine for practical use (spiritual traditions like Buddhism can be understood as a form of psychological medicine, which historically spread together with knowledge in pharmacological medicine). Like pure waters of an unpolluted river, Sanskrit can be enjoyed by all living beings.</p><p>When we compare the Indus-Saraswati valleys with other ancient civilizations like Mesopotamia and Egypt, the first thing that pops out is the sheer difference in size. North-western India was the largest alluvial plain to have been cultivated by early humans and this was nourished by the gigantic melting glaciers of the Himalayas post the ice-age. This was the most fertile territory for the settlement of humans, as it had every single mineral and ecological resource. Because of the sheer size of this area, the rest of the world experienced a huge cultural and genetic influx from here. In contrast, there is little evidence for inflow of people into India until 2000 years ago. There is no genetic, archeological or literary evidence for an invasion/migration of Aryans into India.</p><p>This opens an important question — why are European languages similar to Sanskrit if they were not both sired by the same rampaging invaders?</p><p>Considering the very ancient dates for agriculture and civilization in India, an enormous amount of vocabulary might have been borrowed from India along with the spread of agriculture. Words for numbers, agricultural tools and settled village life could have been borrowed from Indian practices. Even genetic evidence shows a significant migration from India and central Asia towards Europe. These cultures could have evolved into distinct new languages over thousands of years. Even the ancient European mythologies are a partial reflection of the more extensive Indian works. Using the relatively simplistic tree model for language evolution, the Greek Indologist Nicholas Kazanas argues that European ancestors speaking Indo-European languages spread from the Saraswati valley through a northern route, with a stop-over in the Amu Darya basin and further into Russia. There is genetic evidence that Europeans evolved the ability to digest milk protein in this region, which probably gave these tribes an advantage over previous settlers in Europe (along with agricultural knowledge).</p><blockquote>South Indian languages did not borrow Sanskrit vocabulary for numbers and settled village life as in Europe, but they did borrow the infinitely more enriching computational grammars of Sanskrit.</blockquote><p>India may have been the ancestral home for European tribes, but this agricultural civilization did not spread along with a simultaneous awareness of ecological consciousness and respect for nature. This can be contrasted with the parallel spread of civilization towards the south of India. Unlike the frigid north (just recovering from the ice-age), South India was already in a more advanced settlement phase: so these languages did not borrow vocabulary for numbers and settled village life as in Europe. But there is tremendous influence of Sanskrit in providing terminology for all forms of civilized and cultured life. For example, Telugu shares 90% of its vocabulary with Sanskrit, despite being a Dravidian language. As I can personally attest, speaking Telugu provides a significant advantage in learning Sanskrit, not just in terms of vocabulary but in all aspects of grammar. So this arbitrary grouping of South Indian languages into a separate family needs to be severely questioned.</p><p>The current models of language evolution have historically been created to give a rather post-mortem explanation to the overlap of Indo-European languages in terms of simple words and verb inflection patterns. How languages evolve may be far more complex than branching out in a tree-like fashion. Like rivers, languages may have multiple points of origin. Technical words and phrases may spread from one language to another like in fluid dynamics. The wave theory of language evolution was proposed quite early by Johannes Schmidt as an alternative to the more popular tree model used today. But these models are all ridiculously simplistic. In this regard, new computational models have to be developed from large real world data sets, including live evolution and usage patterns in creole languages. These new models have to be universal i.e, they should explain all human languages. In contrast, the current models are so bad that they do not even explain a given set of languages in their entirety. For example, the hypothesized Proto-Indo-European (PIE) language has a common word for butter but not for milk !</p><p>Unlike European languages, South Indian languages did not borrow such simple word structures from the Saraswati valley because they already had a working vocabulary for them. Instead, they borrowed more technical words and computational grammars which are infinitely more enriching. In this regard, Sanskrit is indeed the mother of Dravidian languages, as it has been the source of their vast and expanding vocabularies for 3000 years. It is illuminating to compare with the Finno-Ugric languages in Europe which also borrowed certain terminology for agriculture (these words resemble ancient Indo-Iranian roots rather than words in Germanic languages, despite the geographic proximity). The final clinching evidence is that the names of all Indian rivers (including many in South India) can be traced to Sanskrit etymologically, but very few European rivers have Indo-European roots. So who can actually claim to be children to the heritage of Sanskrit ? <br> <br> Throughout the cultural history of India, all great poets and writers in regional languages studied Sanskrit and were equally proficient in it. The power of Sanskrit in word formation and grammar has penetrated all Indian languages. In fact, the first writers of any regional language (Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam etc.) wrote a technical Paninian-style grammar for their language before composing any literary work. This is because they understood the importance of grammar in imparting consciousness to the literary tradition. This is in stark contrast to European languages whose grammars were woefully inadequate until Sanskrit was discovered in colonial times. Their imperfect alphabets, spelling, and word formation resist change to this day. In this regard, the important question to ask today is regarding the future of Dravidian languages. Why should the creation of scientific and technical terminology in these languages be divorced from their Sanskrit heritage ? In a technical sense, there is no equal to Panini’s grammar in the capacity of word formation for denoting precise scientific terminology. Neither Latin nor Greek (the source languages for modern scientific terminology in English) come even close to the precision and fecundity of Sanskrit. Dravidian separatist politics has been a strong force in South India for the last 70 odd years, but this is a ridiculously tiny fraction of Indian history. A poor and flimsy model of language evolution, coupled with idiotic political mobilization, cannot prevent the speakers of Dravidian languages from claiming their Sanskrit heritage.</p><p>In this regard, Sanskrit is the mother of all Indian languages, just as Saraswati is acknowledged to be the mother of all Indian rivers. Even if the very basin of Saraswati has dried up over the years, the same patterns of monsoon nourish all Indian rivers. We say Saraswati flows in the Ganga, but also in the Narmada and in the Godavari. In this regard, Saraswati keeps flowing forever, though we may foolishly deny it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5386ab0e8668" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Crisis in our understanding of computation:]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vakibs/crisis-in-our-understanding-of-computation-47635a97136b?source=rss-e8bc8466de4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/47635a97136b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[unemployment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[programming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wtfeconomy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aryaprajna]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[vakibs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Nov 2016 14:14:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-26T13:54:52.418Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/563/1*LVUJqC5TReGlw1UDwQT4Kg.png" /><figcaption>Egg: A model for your future computer</figcaption></figure><p>Computers are now in everybody’s pockets, but most people are unaware of what they are doing. Soon, computers will be integrated into people’s clothes and into their own bodies. But for most people, they remain a black box. The renowned journalist Kevin Kelly once stated on Twitter,</p><blockquote><em>“People mistakenly believe an egg is simple. Nice smooth-rounded corner case. No buttons. But simple needs complexity”.</em></blockquote><p>Imagining a computer as an egg is a horrible analogy, although it sounds profound on first glance. Mr. Kelly is a smart writer with informed opinions. So this makes him an especially good candidate to debunk — what we may call a <em>support vector</em> in machine learning parlance. The fact is people are already panicking about how opaque computers have become. Social media like Facebook and Twitter have precipitated awful political decisions, with nobody having a clue about how to find the truth amidst fake news, innuendo and subtle manipulative messaging.</p><p>With growing power of artificial intelligence (AI), this opaqueness of computation is reaching scarier proportions. Even for the technically literate people, the analysis of algorithms is getting more and more complex, especially with data-driven machine learning. How to prove the convergence and optimality of an algorithm that uses a ton of data and encodes it in a multi-layered neural network? When these neural networks are used for financial trading, make insurance policies or evaluate employees, they exhibit complex biases that are much harder to debug than traditional computer programs. But the fundamental problem remains not AI, but our own ignorance. How can we as a society arrive at political decisions about the use of AI, when most people are completely clueless about computers?</p><h3>We as a society do not see computer programs and interfaces as natural language dialogue and literature, where every human being can participate.</h3><p>We have an urgent crisis in our understanding of computers, but there is also a huge opportunity. Computer algorithms are getting increasingly proficient in understanding human languages and interpreting visual images like humans do. With these advances, the borders between programming languages and human languages are getting blurred. New paradigms of computer programming are emerging that imagine computers as partners that speak with humans, and solve problems through mutual dialogue. However, we as a society still do not see computer programs as natural language dialogue and literature — capable of literary beauty and emotive content. Equivalently, we do not see literature as a computational object with hyperlinks between various literary references (apart from rare visionaries like Ted Nelson who see it thus). We do not use computer programs to speak to each other or to investigate our internal psyches. To the extent that we use them, we do it unconsciously. A powerful demonstration of this is the failure of semantic web, which was supposed to provide a rich context specific layer of information on the web that is pertinent to the user. Instead of this, we got a million bots and cookies that spy on the user without his knowledge. Now with the internet of things, this networked espionage on users has penetrated household objects. The principal cause of this dystopia is the lack of human communication between users and computers, capable of encoding computational procedures.</p><p>Along with the spectre of ignorance about AI lies the risk of technological unemployment. The skills of most people are becoming obsolete in an economy driven by AI bots. The reason why this is happening is because the technological progress in computation and AI has been completely de-linked from human education. So most human beings are incapable of participating in a society driven by AI — not only as economic agents, but also as political agents. This is the real risk of AI — not to our economy, but to our democracy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V1Lq_AbtcG58ZgosJA99sg.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Arya Prajna</em></strong><em> in Sanskrit denotes civilized intelligence, with a deep understanding and respect for ecology. This blog is part of a series of articles on how to use technology to live intelligently, with inspiration from the Indian tradition of Sanskrit language and culture.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=47635a97136b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Hiding the Indians behind Artificial Intelligence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vakibs/hiding-the-indians-behind-artificial-intelligence-a505bcead49b?source=rss-e8bc8466de4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a505bcead49b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[virtual-humans]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[virtual-avatars]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-appropriation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[call-center]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[vakibs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Oct 2016 09:33:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-26T13:49:40.944Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*NXnuFuw1mB7IXS-V0Fl8TQ.png" /><figcaption>Puppetry in the film Ratatouille</figcaption></figure><p>When I was visiting Paris several years ago, I made an amusing discovery. There is an Indian working in the kitchen of (almost) every restaurant in Paris. I call this the <strong>Paris Kitchen Theorem</strong>. Whenever I visit Paris and eat at a restaurant, I try to validate this theorem by peeping in the kitchen. There are a few counter-examples, but I find this to be almost always true, irrespective of the type of cuisine.</p><p>I discovered this theorem literally by accident, when I was eating at a South American restaurant (name hidden so I don’t kill their business). The place had a lot of Mexican hats and other kitsch pasted to the ceiling. I settled down to a table and asked the waitress where she was from. “<em>Colombia</em>”, she replied. The menu was a pot-pourri of many Latin countries. I decided to aim for Mexico, and asked for a freshly poured beer of Corona to start the business. That was when the trouble started. The poor girl tried to pull a beer from the tap and it exploded. There was a giant fountain of beer that splashed onto the bar. Customers watched with rapt interest, and a mild sense of worry, over the developing scene. “<em>Help, help</em>”, she cried. Out from the kitchen stepped an Indian man (probably from Sri Lanka, as most “Indians” in France are from) and tried to fix it. He couldn’t and beckoned with a very Indian gesture to the kitchen, wherein, two, three and finally four Indian people stepped out of the kitchen. Together, they did some magic and fixed the tap from exploding any further. Then they quietly went back to the kitchen and attended to the orders from the customers.</p><p>Considering the setting in the rather touristic center of Paris, the food was quite decent. But this incident sparked a curiosity in my head to look in the kitchen of any restaurant I eat at. In France, in good restaurants, the chef talks to the customers at the end of the meal — noting their comments and points for improvement, just as a seasoned artist listens to the connoisseurs of art. Sometimes, I was pleasantly surprised to see even the chef to be of Indian (Sri Lankan) origin. What makes Indians such a fixture in Parisian kitchens ? I think it is not just the low wages (historically attested by George Orwell in <em>“Down and out in Paris and London”</em>) which attract nobody but poor immigrants , but also some innate Indian talent for cooking.</p><p>Nevertheless, Indian cooks are hidden behind the kitchen doors, and rarely step into the service at a restaurant — probably to prevent ruining the illusion on the customers. When I saw the Pixar movie Ratatouille, I couldn’t but relate this to my experience in Paris. The rat Rémi discovers that he can puppeteer a hapless chef into cooking good food. But obviously, customers don’t like to look at rats in the kitchen, so he has to be hidden. Recently, it sank in my head that this illusion is not limited to the food service industry, but is valid for any service industry. Hello, who didn’t have the experience of talking to an Indian call center worker ?</p><p>“<em>Hello, my name is Robert Smith. How can I help you ?</em>”, in posh American accent.</p><p>After 20 minutes,</p><p>“<em>Could you please turn off the computer and turn it on again, Sir?</em>”</p><p>At this point, I would lose my patience and shout “<em>You know what, I am a #*!-ing computer scientist. I know that this problem will not be fixed by turning off the computer and turning it on. Also, you know what, your #*!-ing name is not Robert Smith. You are talking to me now from somewhere in Mumbai.</em>”</p><p>At which point, the guy laughs and tries to talk to me in Hindi, where I apologize as my Hindi is crap.</p><p>The internet and globalization have done many comical things to our lives, but we haven’t seen much yet. Now we have technology for controlling virtual avatars by the body motion of a person. This will revolutionize the service industry, but probably in many creepy ways that we cannot imagine yet: virtual receptionists, virtual maids, virtual baby sitters, virtual sex-workers . You don’t have to put on a giant VR helmet to enjoy these services. You can have a silicone robot that replicates the human in the real world. For poor consumers, this robot will be a cranky metal bot with a display screen for a face. But the illusion can get better and better if you are willing to pay more money.</p><h4>The awful thing with virtualization is that you see a fake person, whereas the real person is hidden.</h4><p>Not every culture has the same brand value in our world. Not every skin color has the same brand value. Not every accent has the same brand value. Inevitably, what will happen with virtualization is that the real person’s identity who is doing the work will be hidden behind a fake profile.</p><p>This fake profile is sustained by data — lots of data. We now have artificial intelligence systems that reconstruct the nuances of a real world object or person. But in order to do this, they have to feed on tons of data that is copied or captured from the real world, often without getting meaningful consent from the rightful owners. In the social sciences world, where the activists are often blissfully ignorant of the trends in technology, they call this cultural appropriation. Imagine a virtual Iggy Azalea that is being controlled by a real black woman. (I don’t have anything against the real Iggy Azalea — she is at least singing her own songs). This virtual avatar will be owned by a “brand” — and our market compensates only people who have a brand recognition.</p><h4>The crux of the problem is that people who do the real work do not have a brand recognition.</h4><p>When we talk of “artificial intelligence” today, we imagine this to be an autonomous super-human entity. But often, as any human product, this “AI” is a lame-system which breaks down. Somebody needs to be summoned to fix it. As in the restaurant incident I narrated, this is when the Indians appear — one, two, three and four, all working together to fix the broken gadget. Then they disappear back into the kitchen. The customers are annoyed at the inconvenience and look at the Indians as a nuisance — thereby, reinforcing their low brand value.</p><p>But this is not a modern phenomenon. All through the middle ages, Indians and other people of color have been exploited with no recognition. The grand blue Bibi-Qanym mosque in Uzbekistan was built by the invader Timur for his glory — but using Indian wealth and Indian slave laborers. The rich architecture of United States has slave labor behind it. But slavery today is virtualised. The stock market hides it. The foreign exchange market hides it. In the future, we will have artificial intelligence and virtual avatar technologies that hide it.</p><p>As George Orwell would put it, what good is a future if it does not have an underclass of people who are willing to work long hours for no job security?</p><p>PS: Historical note — puppetry was first invented in India. I am an Indian scientist who worked on developing virtual avatar technology. So forgive me for all this whining, as I continue to make everything worse.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a505bcead49b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The politics of Artificial General Intelligence]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vakibs/the-politics-of-artificial-general-intelligence-26673ebc3dc5?source=rss-e8bc8466de4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/26673ebc3dc5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[agi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[deepmind]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[vakibs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Mar 2016 10:01:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-09T11:01:28.398Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Today&#39;s news in AI is that Google DeepMind had an exciting win against the World&#39;s champion Go player - Lee Sedol . Go is an ancient Chinese game that has been a challenging frontier for AI, because it has an exponentially higher number of states than chess and cannot be modelled by brute force.</p><p>The founder of DeepMind, Demis Hassabis has an eclectic education and experience: a champion chess player, computer game developer, PhD in neuroscience on the role of Hippocampus in memory and imagination, and now the head of a company of very smart researchers in AI. The mission of DeepMind is pretty simple<em> &quot;First solve intelligence, then solve everything else&quot;</em>. Their motivation is to build algorithms and computational models that scale from one learning task to another. They call this &quot;Artificial General Intelligence&quot; or AGI, to contrast with &quot;narrow&quot; AI that is focussed on specific tasks. The desire is that expertise accumulated in playing games like Go will translate into expertise for solving scientific and socio-economic problems.</p><p>You can hear Demis Hassabis articulating this vision himself. Listening to his lecture is fascinating and gives you more insights than journalists bloviating about today&#39;s game (inevitably on web journals, blogs and newspapers tomorrow).</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4fjmnOQuqao%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4fjmnOQuqao&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4fjmnOQuqao%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=d04bfffea46d4aeda930ec88cc64b87c&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e5913cc5cd8e2ddcc070557c87ee836e/href">https://medium.com/media/e5913cc5cd8e2ddcc070557c87ee836e/href</a></iframe><p>A fundamental question about &quot;Artificial General Intelligence&quot; (AGI) is how different their vision is from &quot;General Intelligence&quot; in psychology (also known as &quot;g&quot;, with the lower-case letter). Before AI researchers came to the scene, researchers in psychology have long been studying the aspects of intelligence. And a fundamental question is whether we can define &quot;intelligence&quot; in singular.</p><blockquote><strong>Is &quot;intelligence&quot; a single holistic concept - possible to be plotted on the single axis of the real line ? Or does &quot;intelligence&quot; involve multiple (possibly conflicting) cognitive faculties ?</strong></blockquote><p>If the answer is the former, then yes, solving a game like Go will translate into real intelligence in solving scientific and socio-economic problems. If the answer is the latter, then no, it need not help. Sure, it does help in solving those aspects of intelligence that need to be modelled by long sequential chains of reasoning (like the states of Go). But that may constitute only a tiny sliver of mental faculties that we collectively term &quot;intelligence&quot;.</p><p>The game of Go has long been part of Confucian education in China. It is considered that training in this game will yield mental and even spiritual benefits. But the benefits that are procured to a computer (modelled, for example, on an approximative model like the LSTM neural network) may not be the same as those that are obtained by the human brain (with a pre-existing architecture of brain anatomy: with a functional brain-stem, hippocampus, temporal, occipital and parietal lobes, and finally the higher cognitive centres in the prefrontal cortex). Demis Hassabis knows this better than anybody else, through his background in neuroscience.</p><p>Now the question is why work on the game of &quot;Go&quot; ? Why not work on modeling the Hippocampus ? Why not work on building computational models of the pituitary gland, amygdala and the Hypothalamus ? What is the right step in achieving human-like intelligence ? If there are multiple steps to be made, what would be the best first step ?</p><p>We can look at locomotion as a simpler analogy before we talk about comparative issues on intelligence.</p><blockquote><strong>A car will over-run a human, but does a car run better than a human ?</strong></blockquote><p>The answer obviously depends on the context. If the goal is about running on an uneven terrain, with many complex and dynamic obstacles, with minimal fuel and recharging capabilities, then a human is still a better &quot;runner&quot; than a car. This may not be the case sometime into the future, where technology may overcome such high barriers. But the current design of cars may not lead to that point in future technology. In fact, this design may be based on an entirely different idea.</p><p>Now coming back to intelligence, the idea of a &quot;general intelligence&quot; or &quot;g&quot; remains controversial in psychology. Many researchers subscribe to the opposite view - that intelligence consists of not one, but many types of faculties. The idea of &quot;g&quot; is also tied with the politics of &quot;IQ&quot; tests, and whether they are a useful metric for assessing the role of people in society.</p><p>How we define &quot;intelligence&quot; has immediate consequences on the relative worth of different people in society. If we value what people offer as &quot;intelligence&quot;, then we will build a machine in this image, by treating them as role-models. Actually, we will build a machine that it will amplify such attributes of people, when used in combination. For example, do we value caring, compassion and ethics ? Are they relatively more important than remembering long sequences of numbers ? Or are they not ?</p><p>At different times in human evolutionary history, we valued and ranked various attributes of &quot;intelligence&quot; in a completely different order. At some point not too long ago, throwing a spear precisely would have counted as &quot;intelligence&quot;. At some other, more recent point in time, rote memory and quick mental arithmetic would have counted as &quot;intelligence&quot;. Both of these attributes are still quite useful, but we would not count them as important in today&#39;s age. But what do we want to value in the future ?</p><p>I will conclude this post by quoting the neuroscientist V. S. Ramachandran, from his book <em>&quot;Tell-tale brain&quot;</em>, where he critiques the idea of &quot;general intelligence&quot;.</p><blockquote>The IQ evangelists (such as Arthur Jensen, William Shockley, Richard Herrnstein and Charles Murray) use the heritability of IQ itself (sometimes called &quot;general intelligence&quot; or &quot;little g&quot;) to argue that intelligence is a single measurable trait. <strong>This would be roughly analogous to saying that general health is one thing just because life span has a strong heritable component that can be expressed as a single number - age !</strong> No medical student who believed in &quot;general health&quot; as a monolithic entity would get very far in medical school or be allowed to become a physician - and rightly so - and yet whole careers in psychology and political movements have been built on the equally absurd belief in single measurable general intelligence. Their contributions have little more than shock value.</blockquote><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=26673ebc3dc5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Open letter to Arne Dietrich:]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vakibs/open-letter-to-arne-dietrich-59c779f2d0f2?source=rss-e8bc8466de4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/59c779f2d0f2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[drugs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[vakibs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 30 Jan 2016 14:09:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-30T17:24:13.579Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Open letter to Arne Dietrich:</p><p>Check out the TedX talk of Arne Dietrich, where he argues that all altered states of consciousness are lower states.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FsyfalikXBLA%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DsyfalikXBLA&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FsyfalikXBLA%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/60df0bcbcd729be36c09c33306384444/href">https://medium.com/media/60df0bcbcd729be36c09c33306384444/href</a></iframe><p>I think this hypothesis poses some important questions that he needs to answer:</p><p>Why is it that musicians, artists and creative professionals produce their best work in altered states of consciousness ? Why do they consider these states to be fundamentally superior ? Their work is there for all of us to evaluate.</p><p>A greater exposition of Dietrich’s neural theory of creativity is here:</p><p><a href="http://hplusmagazine.com/2015/07/22/the-cognitive-neuroscience-of-creativity/">http://hplusmagazine.com/2015/07/22/the-cognitive-neuroscience-of-creativity/</a></p><p>A loose summary of the cognitive neuroscience on creativity is here:</p><p><a href="http://www.creativitypost.com/science/the_real_neuroscience_of_creativity">The Real Neuroscience of Creativity</a></p><p>It is to be noted that all these theories are still quite primitive, producing no functional models of simulated creativity.</p><p>It is not just creative artists. Even many scientists attribute their best works to altered states of consciousness. Why is that ?</p><p>Altered states may result not only through drugs, but also through intense meditation or devotion.</p><p>In an earlier era, people attributed their best works in music and mathematics to “devotional states”, in a state of direct communion with their muses and god. These people longed for these altered states to reappear, and in fact, wrote songs and poems about this longing. Why is that ?</p><p>What makes us so confident of ourselves that we do not value their testimony? If we don’t want to take them by the word, we can evaluate them through the objective artifacts they produced.</p><p>Finally, we need to explain behavior. Even if a person is not gifted in any creative sense, why is it that the person behaves differently in altered states of consciousness. No, this behavior is not primitive — in the sense of a reptilian behavior or a lower mammal behavior. In fact, people are released from the persistent dread of stress and cognitive overload while they are in these altered states. They may not be able to keep time, reason about the division of self from the environment, or some other criterion of cognition, but that does not prove that they are in lower states. While certain cognitive functions are lowered, other functions may be enhanced — similar to how blind people hear music in a better manner. What are the criteria for evaluation ? Who is flying with the pixies (prejudice) here ?</p><p>Another important comment is that the sub-cortical regions of the human brain are not exactly identical to those in the other mammals and reptiles. Human limbic brain had a bad reputation for several decades (with the popular press calling it the reptilian brain). But its functions are substantially evolved and different from those in other animals. The cortical regions of the brain are not the only elements that make us uniquely human. So we need not rate human cognitive functions in a linear hierarchy based on whether they engage cortical regions or not.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=59c779f2d0f2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My comments to the rosy picture about “Technological Unemployment” painted by Steve Morris on the…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vakibs/my-comments-to-the-rosy-picture-about-technological-unemployment-painted-by-steve-morris-on-the-16e9217477c0?source=rss-e8bc8466de4d------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/16e9217477c0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[vakibs]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Jan 2016 19:41:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-01-27T19:41:07.852Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>My comments to the rosy picture about “Technological Unemployment” painted by Steve Morris on the Singularity Weblog:</p><p><a href="https://www.singularityweblog.com/will-technological-unemployment-impoverish-us/">https://www.singularityweblog.com/will-technological-unemployment-impoverish-us/</a></p><p>Well. What’s so special about humans that we look at only the statistics affecting humans (Max Roser style) and ignore the broader picture, about what’s happening to life in general on the planet.</p><p>The picture then is not rosy. A lot of species are going extinct, and this rate of extinction is accelerating. The species facing the greatest selectionary pressure (imposed by our human industrial civilization) are the apex predators who are dependent on a greater surface area and ecological resources. But all species are going extinct, including tiny critters and bacteria. We humans are very good at killing large mammals. A lot of them went extinct just as we spread out from Africa. A further large number of them went extinct when we created agriculture.</p><p>By the time of the industrial revolution, humans are undoubtedly the “apex predator” on the whole of the planet. They were spread on all the continents, though not with equal amounts of technology. What happened as a consequence of industrial revolution can be understood as a selectionary pressure on large human populations. A lot of populations got exterminated (through disease and encroachment of habitat, now termed as colonialism), and among those that survived, significant elements of culture went extinct: languages, customs etc. Thus, the process of cultural and human extinction can be understood as a continuation of natural extinction of biological species.</p><p>With AI and computing, we are now under a new machine age, something far more powerful than the last industrial revolution. The consequences will be profound. We don’t know who exactly in the pool of human populations will survive and benefit from the effects of this AI revolution. How many branches of the human civilization will have to go extinct ? It is very likely that large areas of the earth will be conquered by the industry and the existing biomes will be smashed. All forms of life dependent on these ecological biomes, including humans, will go extinct.</p><p>This is not a Hollywood nightmare scenario. In fact, this is such a mundane reality, lacking any drama, that most people don’t bother to think about. The life of people getting sucked out of pristine green forests and placed into a stinking, poverty-ridden slum is not exactly Hollywood material. But this is what is happening all over the world: the slums are rising in Brazil, New Guinea, Indonesia, India, Bangladesh.. All the biodiversity hotspots on this planet are under extreme stress imposed by the forces of modern capitalism and industry. AI will just expand this sphere to cities of the western civilization. People will lose well paying jobs and move into slums. Welcome to the global third world.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=16e9217477c0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>