<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Thomas Mann House on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Thomas Mann House on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@vatmh?source=rss-2fdb0b3df75f------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 10:14:31 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@vatmh/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Opera & Democracy: Listening to Exile]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/vatmh/opera-democracy-listening-to-exile-2a9d22d32c95?source=rss-2fdb0b3df75f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a9d22d32c95</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[goethe-institut]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[opera]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Mann House]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 May 2024 22:44:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-17T16:53:07.176Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>For the Thomas Mann House Blog, 2023 Fellow Kai Hinrich Müller wrote a recap of the four-day festival that took place in New York in April 2024 as part of the transatlantic concert and conversation series “Opera &amp; Democracy.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*A90D6iOa7yu_qIANlazNxA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Performers from the Manhattan School of Music at the Leo Baeck Institute New York. Images: Jamie Isaacs.</figcaption></figure><p>It was “this very speech in 1933,” Thomas Mann reflected on the pivotal moment that drove him into exile, in a letter to the editor of <em>Common Sense</em> (1940), “which determined my emigration, or, more correctly, my failure to return to Germany. Its enthusiasm [for Richard Wagner] was so faint that it put the Nazis into a transport of rage. This vermin is affected by shades of difference as is a bull by a red rag. Yet it is these very nuances of difference that are the most indispensable part in any discussion of Wagner.” And indeed, it was Thomas Mann’s monumental essay on Richard Wagner, <em>Leiden und Größe Richard Wagners</em>, that laid the groundwork for his emigration, a text on his operatic hero written in 1933 on the 50th anniversary of Wagner’s death. Mann was accused of denigrating Wagner, which was utter nonsense, especially since some critics hadn’t even read the book. It provoked public protests joined by composers such as Richard Strauss and Hans Pfitzner. The Manns read the signs and decided to go into exile. Some 80 years later, this brief episode opened the <em>Opera &amp; Democracy: Listening to Exile</em> festival, held April 16–20 in New York City, a week of talks and concerts dedicated to the operatic world of exile and its enduring relevance. Beginning with the music of nazi-persecuted artists, the events sought to connect the past to the present, with a special focus on today’s challenges and how we can support them — a central aspect of the overarching <em>Opera &amp; Democracy</em> series at the Thomas Mann House, Los Angeles. “Opera has historically always been the most political of art forms. In these times, we must actively use the power of music and opera to contribute to a democratic world. Nothing can spread the message across borders and languages more passionately than the language of music”, says Markus Klimmer, Chairman of the Board of Villa Aurora &amp; Thomas Mann House, who gave introductory remarks at the concert in the Austrian Cultural Forum on April 18th.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DHXZeReTsSHpBn3LNFM5wA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QUkmqVoPB8XFpVK5kgVKwQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Opening talk with Brigid Cohen, Michael Steinberg, Gracie Golden, and Olivia Al-Slaiman at the Goethe-Institut New York. Images: Jamie Isaacs.</figcaption></figure><p>Kicking off the week at the Goethe-Institut New York on April 16th, a panel discussion featuring Brigid Cohen, Michael Steinberg, and Gracie Golden of the Artistic Freedom Initiative, moderated by Olivia Al-Slaiman, delved into the intersection of opera, community, and forced displacement. It sets the tone for subsequent events, exploring the challenges faced by artists in exile and the role of art in fostering democracy. “When displacement disrupts lives and scatters dreams, art remains a powerful, resilient force. The skillfully curated series brought together wonderful partners and showed how opera can become a beacon of hope, weaving communities together and championing the essence of democracy in the past and in our present day”, underlines Joerg Schumacher, Director of the Goethe-Institut New York. The festival continued with concerts at the Leo Baeck Institute / Center for Jewish History on April 17th and the Austrian Cultural Forum, showcasing the music of composers persecuted by the Nazis: Erich Zeisl, Ruth Schonthal, Paul Aron, Ernst Toch, and Rosy Geiger-Kullmann. Accompanied by musicians from the Manhattan School of Music and facilitated by Jeruscha Strelow and myself, these performances unearthed rarely heard repertoire and — in the case of Rosy Geiger-Kullmann — even premiered works.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cXkNE44CfF8gkoMqp_Mh8Q.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*f6Y_TkrMwA97PoBIeMMBlw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Performers from the Manhattan School of Music at the Austrian Cultural Forum. Images: Jamie Isaacs.</figcaption></figure><p>Geiger-Kullmann was a prolific composer of the Weimar Republic, born in Frankfurt, who found refuge in New York and Monterey. Her works include cantatas, chamber music, a symphony, and operas. A highlight of the festival was the rediscovery of three of her stage works, excerpts from her operas <em>Columbus, Emanuela and Sir Lancelot</em>, also a testament to her creative spirit in the face of prejudice as a female composer. According to her memoirs (in the LBI archives), the first premieres were rejected because those in charge thought a woman’s opera was too demanding. She also tried to get her operas on the big stages in Berlin. Here, too, she hit a wall, as the register of operas recommended to the Berlin theaters between 1919 and 1943 (Landesarchiv Berlin) shows, a largely unknown source that still needs to be explored. “I was thrilled that my great aunt’s musical compositions were revived and heard by the audience. It was a very special and memorable evening and an honor to listen to the music”, Jennifer Kopatz, Geiger-Kullmann’s great-niece who came from San Francisco to attend the concert, shared her hope for a revival of her ancestor’s work. The festival concluded with a dance performance and panel discussion at 1014, a transatlantic program space in the former Goethe-Institut. Miro Magloire and Carl Bettendorf joined young composer Alyssa Regent to discuss home, belonging, and composing today. The New Chamber Ballet presented choreographies based on works by Alyssa Regent, Tania León and Ursula Mamlok, bringing the program back to the present. “We wanted to take listeners on a journey from today’s challenges to refugee artists, on to historic biographies and composition and end the program in the present featuring contemporary composers,” summarizes Benjamin Bergner, Program Director at 1014.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LnDccFTSjA8T68Te0RIPaQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*p56gpaJMZ00oM_8wcmbtPA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Performers from the New Chamber Ballet at 1014: Space for Ideas. Images: Sarah Blesener.</figcaption></figure><p>The success of the <em>Listening to Exile</em> festival hinted at a possible sequel, fueled by the enthusiasm of both performers and audiences alike. In a world grappling with new challenges to artistic freedom, the festival served as a reminder of the enduring power of music to transcend borders and inspire change. Looking back on the rich program that unfolded over the course of the week, it becomes evident that the festival not only celebrated the resilience of artists in the face of oppression but also underscored the urgent need to preserve their legacies for future generations. By shining a spotlight on the works of composers who were once silenced by dictatorship, the week offered a way to reclaim their voices and honor their contributions to the cultural tapestry of humanity.</p><p>The next events in the <em>Opera &amp; Democracy </em>series take place in Dresden, Berlin, Brown University, and Hamburg. <strong>Find more information </strong><a href="https://vatmh.org/en/opera-democracy.html"><strong>here</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><p><strong><em>Kai Hinrich Müller</em></strong><em> works at the intersection of scholarship and practice, fostering cultural dialogues across continents. He is currently the director of the BAUHAUS MUSIC FESTIVAL in Berlin and the TEREZÍN MUSIC ACADEMY in the former ghetto of Theresienstadt, an initiative of MUSICA NON GRATA, for which he has developed numerous programs on artists persecuted by the Nazis. He also serves as the academic lead for a number of projects related to the historically informed performance of Richard Wagner’s “Ring”. Kai has held several international fellowships and lectures at the Cologne University of Music and Dance. His current research interests include Wagner and the Bayreuth Circle, interwar and Nazi musical life, musical migration, and transatlantic opera traditions.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a9d22d32c95" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/vatmh/opera-democracy-listening-to-exile-2a9d22d32c95">Opera &amp; Democracy: Listening to Exile</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/vatmh">vatmh</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Democracy & Vulnerability: Recaps by the Student Council]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/vatmh/democracy-vulnerability-recaps-by-the-student-council-5e48d270fc31?source=rss-2fdb0b3df75f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e48d270fc31</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Mann House]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Jan 2024 14:04:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-25T20:43:29.524Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AfbosZcjw6RzmLELIy8HYA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>The </em></strong><a href="https://wendemuseum.org/?gclid=Cj0KCQiA54KfBhCKARIsAJzSrdr-1gvCP4x3IQQf1Hl1EqNp1ym2cYufV5BxPw5FmcJFAOatbq4vxBMaAgFHEALw_wcB"><strong><em>Wende Museum</em></strong></a><strong><em>, </em></strong><a href="https://www.dublab.com/"><strong><em>dublab radio</em></strong></a><strong><em> and the </em></strong><a href="https://www.vatmh.org/en/home-en.html"><strong><em>Thomas Mann House</em></strong></a><strong><em> are continuing their monthly virtual program series! This year’s series focuses on the annual topic of the Thomas Mann House, Democracy &amp; Vulnerability.</em></strong></p><p>The Student Council consists of a team of highly engaged, talented, and diverse high school, undergraduate, and graduate students who invite prominent guest speakers to discuss topics relating to art, culture, politics, and society. In conversation with academics, journalists, politicians, and artists, the students will explore the various threats to democratic institutions and principles worldwide, as well as strategies to potentially overcome these threats.</p><p>Democratic processes are dynamic, inclusive, and human-centered but at times also messy, arbitrary, and even contrary to democracy itself. How should a democracy deal with its own vulnerabilities? What are the responsibilities of a democracy toward the most vulnerable in its populace? How do democracies need to evolve to deal successfully with increasing global levels of ecological, geo-political, and economic precarity? How much vulnerability can a democracy endure?</p><p><strong>Watch all previous student council interview on our </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLGeYTLhhjxQQnmuanY9BVRHwK3bgJFRFU"><strong>YouTube channel</strong></a><strong> or listen to them as podcasts on </strong><a href="https://www.dublab.com/search/student-council?type=broadcasts"><strong>dublab radio</strong></a><strong>!</strong></p><h3>October: Jonathan Homola &amp; Martha Stone</h3><p>This October, the Wende Museum and Thomas Mann House Student Council hosted an in-person discussion with scholars Jonathan Homola and Marla Stone, joined by a live audience, to address a subject more relevant than ever: the looming threat of far-right populism and fascism. Dr. Marla Stone, a professor of History at Occidental College, specializes in European history, with a focus on genocide, fascism, and anti-communism. Her forthcoming publication, <em>The Enemy: The Politics and Propaganda of Italian Anti-Communism</em>, examines anti-Bolshevism and anti-communism during Italy’s fascist First Republic. Dr. Jonathan Homola, an Assistant Professor of Political Science at UCLA, explores issues of electoral preferences, representation, gender, and xenophobia, particularly in Western democracies and Eastern Europe.</p><p>Acknowledging the complex and often contentious nature of defining fascism, we asked both scholars to share their perspectives. Stone highlighted the ongoing debate among historians but offered her own working definition: emerging after World War I, fascism seeks to mobilize the masses, demanding that citizens surrender their individual agency to an all-powerful leader and state. Homola expanded on this by addressing contemporary forms of fascism, such as neo-fascism and post-fascism. He noted that these ideologies can adopt more moderate stances on certain issues while still using democratic electoral systems as a means to gain power, rather than resorting to violent overthrow.</p><p>A key aspect of fascism, of course, is the use of propaganda and misinformation. Both scholars emphasized the crucial role propaganda played in historical fascist regimes like those in Italy and Germany, but they also pointed to significant differences in how propaganda is produced, distributed, and consumed today. In the past, fascist regimes controlled state media without much opposition, with minimal ability for individuals to access counter-narratives. Today, while alternative perspectives are more readily available, modern technologies — such as AI-generated images and videos — allow for the creation of highly convincing but misleading content. As Stone and Homola pointed out, one of the hallmarks of fascist rhetoric is the construction of a so-called “enemy” — a group demonized to rally the public against a perceived threat. For example, according to Trump’s rhetoric, immigrants are portrayed as a threat to the “American way of life,” with harmful falsehoods circulating to fuel this narrative.</p><p>In the midst of this uncertainty, particularly with the approaching election, one valuable takeaway from the discussion was a sense of hope — even in the face of anti-democratic outcomes. Both Stone and Homola observed that while many of their students have become disillusioned with electoral politics and even the capitalist system, they have not become apathetic. Instead, young people are increasingly engaging in politics outside traditional electoral channels, such as working with NGOs and demonstrations.</p><p>The Council asked for guidance on how to speak with moral clarity in an era of deepening political polarization. Stone and Homola advised that the focus should be on addressing the material issues fueling insecurities in people’s lives — issues that can make individuals vulnerable to far-right rhetoric and the false solutions it proposes. While bridging political divides must remain a priority, Stone also warned that “if things go in an anti-democratic direction, we may have to go into the streets,” also citing the historical efficacy of general strikes in countering fascist power. As I reflect on this pre-election interview, now faced with the reality of a second Trump presidency, I find the discussion both clarifying and energizing. It provides direction for the necessary work ahead: countering the rise of fascism and addressing the divisions, instability, and violence it threatens to bring.</p><p><em>A recap by Sara Abrahamsson</em></p><p><strong>About our speakers<br>Jonathan Homola</strong> is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Political Science at the University of California, Los Angeles. Most of his research deals with questions of representation and electoral preferences in Western democracies. Among his main fields of interest are xenophobia and support for right-wing extremism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*V6WDCk94Y-aanuoZzcnTeA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Marla Stone</strong> is professor of history at Occidental College and specializes in the history of fascism and in questions of dictatorship and genocide in the modern era. Stone’s work emphasizes the relationship among culture, politics, and the state in the 20th century. She has published on a variety of topics in European history, including Italian Fascist cultural politics, anti-communism, the contemporary far right in Europe, Italian Holocaust memory culture, and the continuities and ruptures between historic fascism and its contemporary manifestations. She has taught at Occidental College since 1994 and received her M.A. and Ph.D. from Princeton University.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*qsig23rLwSDZwq9PkqUVhg.png" /></figure><h3>September: John E. Echohawk</h3><p>In September, the Student Council had the privilege of speaking with John Echohawk, a distinguished Native American attorney and a trailblazer in advocating for Indigenous rights. As one of the co-founders and the Executive Director of the Native American Rights Fund (NARF), Echohawk has dedicated his career to using the law as a tool to defend Native sovereignty, protect tribal resources, and ensure justice for Native peoples. Throughout the interview, Echohawk shared his perspective on how advancing the rights of Native communities is a crucial aspect of fostering a more democratic and equitable society.</p><p>One of the first statements made by the esteemed attorney was “Native Americans have the right to determine their own future,” a sentiment that echoed a theme central throughout our conversation: the right of Native American Communities to self-determination. Many legal battles over land, water, and treaty rights are part of a larger movement to reclaim and uphold Native nations’ right to self-determination, which is a key pillar of democracy. The discussion of sovereignty was deeply intertwined with the relationship Native Americans have with state and federal governments, as well as the importance of holding these parties accountable for their obligations.</p><p>Another common thread that made its way into our discussion was the pivotal role of education in upholding and protecting Native American legal rights. Education in this context is essential not only for raising awareness among non-Native Americans about historical and ongoing legal injustices, but for Native communities to understand the legal rights they are entitled to and be able to defend them. As tribal leaders began gaining access to academic resources and institutions of higher education, US policy shifted from extermination and assimilation to self-determination and sovereignty in response. Echohawk explained to us, however, that unfortunately many Americans are not informed about the history and status of tribes throughout the United States due to an absence of Indian studies programs in schools and universities. Even legal victories are often insufficient to educate the public as schools and governments lack the resources or will to enforce these changes. As an example, he pointed out the 1999 Indian Education for All Act in Montana, which ensured citizens a right to learn about Native history in schools, but only led to minimal curriculum reform.</p><p>Later in the interview, we touched on the tribal principle of living in harmony with the earth and how tribes convey these values through legal actions they take in protecting and preserving their land. Notably, Native American communities often collaborate closely with environmental organizations, as their mutual commitment to preserving the environment aligns with the fight to combat climate change. Echohawk went over some key legal victories such as the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act of 1990 and the Winters Doctrine of 1908, both of which played crucial roles in ensuring Indigenous communities the right to their ancestral lands.</p><p>The conversation concluded on one of the most pressing issues currently facing not only the Native American community, but many marginalized groups across the globe: voting rights. Voter suppression is a significant barrier indigenous communities face to participating in democratic processes, limiting their influence on policy decisions. We spoke about the common tactics used to suppress the Native American vote and the challenges that accompany living on remote reservations. A detail that stood out to me and my peers was the fact that requiring a street address to vote is an inherently discriminatory practice, due to many homes on reservations not having formal addresses. This realization emphasized the urgent need to invest in the education of marginalized groups and ensure indigenous representation in decision-making spaces.</p><p>Our conversation with Echohawk highlighted that true democracy requires that every community, especially those historically marginalized, have access to the political and legal mechanisms necessary to defend their rights. The attorney’s lifelong dedication to justice serves as a powerful example of how the legal system can be used to challenge inequality and build a more inclusive society for future generations.</p><p><em>A recap by Elsa Coony</em></p><p><strong>About our speakers<br>John E. Echohawk</strong>, Pawnee, is the Executive Director of the Native American Rights Fund. He was the first graduate of the University of New Mexico’s special program to train Indian lawyers and was a founding member of the American Indian Law Students Association while in law school. John has been with NARF since its inception in 1970, having served continuously as Executive Director since 1977. He has been recognized as one of the 100 most influential lawyers in America by the National Law Journal and has received numerous service awards and other recognition for his leadership in the Indian law field including the 2023 Thurgood Marshall Award from the American Bar Association. He serves on the Boards of the Association on American Indian Affairs, the Indigenous Language Institute, the Natural Resources Defense Council, the Grand Canyon Trust, the Native Ways Federation, the Water Foundation, the Keystone Policy Center, and the National Center for American Indian Enterprise Development.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*G1nyIrUDJtrPoJFkNr4hrA.png" /></figure><h3>August: Irfan Nooruddin</h3><p>This month the Student Council had the privilege of speaking with Dr. Irfan Nooruddin, the Hamad bin Khalifa Al Thani Professor of Indian Politics at Georgetown University. Dr. Nooruddin’s research focuses on economic development, democratization, and civil conflict, and his most recent book,<em> The Everyday Crusade: Christian Nationalism in American Politics</em>, explores which particular US religious or religion-adjacent beliefs are most indicative of nationalist attitudes. Dr. Nooruddin’s work is characterized both by forceful critique and thoughtful resilience — he is clear about the internal and external threats to democratic governance but advocates against ceding political agency in despair.</p><p>Our conversation touched on many themes, but I want to highlight two concepts that have remained at the forefront of my thoughts since the interview. The first is the importance of framing a nation’s democracy less in terms of its elections (though they are, of course, essential) and more in terms of its governance in between its elections. Despotic regimes the world over have elections — what defines a true democracy is thus the way it treats its minority populations when their votes are not being courted. Dr. Nooruddin argues that the US has often prioritized what he calls democracy <em>promotion</em> over actual democracy and that this prioritization can act as a smokescreen that obscures the ways in which anti-democratic sentiments and policies are taking root. Dr. Nooruddin thus commended us to the hard work of real democracy: holding our elected officials accountable to moral governance throughout their entire tenure.</p><p>The second concept that struck me was Dr. Nooruddin’s characterization of democracy as, ultimately, a form of self-control. Though much nuance is necessary, there is an intuitive connection between believing politics to be primarily a way to extend one’s power — rather than as a system designed to <em>limit</em> power and protect vulnerable communities — and a readiness to deny election results or employ political violence to achieve one’s goals. Indeed, Dr. Nooruddin suggests that one of the great challenges facing the US is the fact that many citizens, some of whom might not even realize it, no longer want a democracy and would happily give themselves over to authoritarianism.</p><p>It is important to reiterate that the US government itself is complicit in spreading these insufficient frameworks and toxic definitions that now make our democracy so vulnerable. The US has frequently used pro-democracy interventions in other countries as cover for economic imperialism and power-grabs. Advocating for a flourishing democracy in the 21st century requires being brutally honest about the ways US democracy has lacked integrity, and depends upon the hard work of addressing fundamental attitudes toward politics and power. Dr. Nooruddin did not shy away from the difficulty of the task but he nevertheless reaffirmed that it was worth the effort — that our vulnerable democracy, and the vulnerable populations it ought to protect, is worth fighting for.</p><p><em>A recap by Matthew Jones</em></p><p><strong>About our speakers<br>Irfan Nooruddin</strong> is the Hamad bin Khalifa Al-Thani Professor of Indian Politics at Georgetown University in Washington, D.C. He studies problems of economic development and globalization, democracy and democratization, and civil conflict. His books are <em>Coalition Politics and Economic Development</em> (2011); <em>Elections in Hard Times</em> (2016, with T.E. Flores); and <em>The Everyday Crusade </em>(2022, with E.L. McDaniel and A.F. Shortle), all published by Cambridge University Press. Irfan received a Ph.D. in Political Science from the University of Michigan, and a B.A. in Economics and International Studies from Ohio Wesleyan University.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/230/1*kZs_jSGwlRwvpbKGMc6xUg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>July: Radical Daughters</h3><p>This July, the Wende Museum and Thomas Mann House generously hosted an in-person conversation between the Student Council and Radical Daughters. Radical Daughters are a group of educators that use political art to encourage activism and engagement with politics and social affairs. They organize hands-on workshops with community members inside and outside of Germany, reinforcing the importance of engaging in political conversations, prioritizing democracy, and upholding equality and respect.</p><p>Our conversation began with introductions to two founders of Radical Daughters, Cesy Leonard and Josephin Haardt. We learned that Radical Daughters was created as a movement that drives members to take unique action to approach our world’s democracy and politics. These encounters with the world encourage participants to actively and creatively engage in the democratic processes. Here, art is a powerful medium to challenge social norms, inspire political change, and promote equality and freedom across diverse communities.</p><p>As explained by Haardt, action art is used “as a very accessible tool to encourage political engagement.” This specialized practice is used when working in rural areas with younger participants in hopes of establishing a deeper connection to democratic values and fostering a sense of responsibility towards active citizenship. Establishing engagement at such a young age and through an accessible medium such as art is an important tool that aids the preservation of democracy.</p><p>Notably, when asked about the role that the youth play in the Radical Daughters’ mission, Leonard highlighted the importance of maintaining an interested and engaged youth that can carry forward the principles of democracy. She emphasized that young people are not just participants, but will one day be vital leaders in the political moment–introducing, nurturing, and encouraging fresh perspectives and energy is crucial in sustaining long-term political and social change.</p><p>Focusing on the important language and meaning of words such as “radical,” Leonard and Haardt answered a question about how listeners can “grow their capacity to be radical and take political action” to develop everyday practices that are more and more “radical.” They discussed the development of daily tasks and exercises that employ one’s courage, as well as “doing something better than doing nothing;” emphasizing that even small, consistent acts of resistance can lead to significant change. They encouraged listeners to start with manageable actions–such as questioning norms, speaking up against injustices, or sparking conversation with friends and family–actions that collectively contribute to a broader movement.</p><p>Ultimately, the conversation concluded with a thought-provoking question about the Radical Daughters’ views on the necessity of coexistence, collaboration, and coalition among various social and political movements. They highlighted the essential role of a vibrant democracy that actively brings together different movements, people, and beliefs. By fostering collaboration, they aim to find common ground in the pursuit of justice, equality, and social change, emphasizing that a healthy democracy thrives when it brings together diverse voices in a shared commitment to universal values.</p><p><em>A recap by Lexi Tooley</em></p><p><strong>About our speakers<br>Cesy Leonard </strong>is an action artist, speaker, and founder of the “Radikale Töchter” — inspiring people through political art to act and stand up for democracy, freedom, equality, brotherhood, and sisterhood. She studied acting in Berlin and worked in film, television, and theater. Often experiencing what it meant to have to conform to a clichéd image of a woman led her to start directing her own films. Her 2012 film “Guilt — The Barbarism of Europe” awarded her various prizes, such as the Web Video Award. In 2012, she joined the artistic staff of the collective “Center for Political Beauty,” which promotes pressing political issues through their art. Seeing how art, in particular, has the power to mobilize people to act is the inspiration behind the “Radikale Töchter.” Funded by the “Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung” as a model project, the team works to strengthen democracy in the former GDR.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*tEtELOuV7gcMl9cPcdbpxA.jpeg" /><figcaption>© Maike Kenn</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Josephin Haardt</strong> studied International Relations and Economics in Erfurt. She has been working as a project manager and managing director of the “Radical Daughters” since April 2019. This is where her interests in democracy, sisterhood, and organizational talent come together.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*cPwoYzJWoyOpyIjTS4rUmA.png" /><figcaption>© Christiane Deibel</figcaption></figure><h3>June: Ajuan Mance</h3><p>In June, the Student Council was lucky enough to speak with the immensely talented and extremely thoughtful Ajuan Mance, a lifelong artist and professor of African American literature at Mills College in Oakland, California. The Council used the opportunity of an interview with Mance to focus in on how building a more democratic world requires us to consider the impact that mass culture has on society. Throughout the conversation, Mance explained how diverse representations in art can encourage members of democracies to push back against discriminatory narratives that keep marginalized groups from accessing the benefits of an allegedly free and open society. By creating and popularizing diverse images of Black lives in America, Mance aims to complicate the stereotyped and objectified images of Black communities that have long characterized cultural representations of Black Americans.</p><p>The conversation began with a discussion of Mance’s distinctive artistic style. In all of her works, ranging from the portrait series <em>1001 Black Men</em> to the children’s book <em>What Do Brothas Do All Day?</em>, Mance aims to engage with artistic forms that, in her words, “are seeking to tell a story.” As a result, her art is often reminiscent of comics, relying on vibrant colors and heavy-black outlines. When asked about her artistic inspirations, Mance revealed that her choice of color is twofold: on the one hand inspired by an interest in stained-glass windows, Mance also uses bright colors to connect the figures in her works to the African ancestry they carry.</p><p>When pushed to explain the specific kinds of figures she aims to represent, Mance told the Council that intersectionality is one of the driving forces behind her artistic practice. She explained how various forces (both historical and contemporary) have created a series of one-dimensional images used to not only disingenuously represent Black Americans, but also push forward discriminatory cultural codes that reinforce the racism riddled throughout American life. In response to such images, Mance’s art aims to provide counter-representations that depict Black people as diverse, multifaceted, joyful, and free as everyone living in a true democracy deserves to be.</p><p>It was interesting to hear Mance discuss some of the challenges she faces in her work, especially while writing for younger audiences. She reflected on the ways that even she can be caught off guard by the discriminatory representations she has internalized. It was powerful to hear Mance tell Council members that it’s okay to make mistakes; the most important thing is to be open to keep learning.</p><p>In my eyes, one of the conversation’s greatest takeaways was Mance’s deep belief that one does not need to actually produce artistic forms in order to work towards the goals that drive her artistic practice. Mance explained that everyone has the power to work to diversify their understanding of marginalized groups and she encouraged Council members to critically reflect on the kinds of people represented in the culture they consume in order to ensure engagement with a wide variety of perspectives. Doing so is one small, yet concrete way, to work towards building a stronger democracy.</p><p><em>A recap by Emma Larson</em></p><p><strong>About our speaker:<br>Ajuan Mance</strong> is a Professor of African American literature at Mills College in Oakland, California as well as a writer and artist. Throughout her comics and illustrations she uses the elements of humor and bright colors to explore race, gender, and power, and the people and places in which they intersect. Her work has appeared in a number of digital and print media outlets, including most recently <em>The Women’s Review of Book</em>s, <em>Blavity.com</em>, <em>BET.com</em>, <em>Transition Magazine</em>, <em>Buzzfeed.com</em>, <em>KQED.org</em>, <em>The San Francisco Chronicle</em>, <em>NYTimes.com</em>, <em>KPIX News</em>, and <em>Publisher’s Weekly.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*1LclmEWoxB-Pk-YziRyzVQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3>May: Catherine Opie</h3><p>This May, the Wende Museum and Thomas Mann House had the exuberant pleasure of hosting a conversation with photographer and professor Catherine Opie. Opie’s work on redefining the portrait, as well as her deep profile in picturing the queer community all over California, set the stage to discuss the role that photography plays in our current social climate as well as to explore the ways she has navigated through photography.</p><p>The conversation began with a short anecdote about Opie’s recent travels to Norway to capture portraits of blue mountains. She explained the ways in which she has continued her experiment of ‘poking holes’ in the natural way of understanding language as it pertains to photography. This idea is key to understanding much of the artist’s work, as the audience is tasked to question and reorganize their preconceived understanding of a photograph already at the first glance at one of her pieces. Opie’s thought process can be perceived as <em>dada-esque </em>in its delivery– a sort of twist at your arm, forcing you to look again and again until you think you really understand what the piece entails. A sort of democratic, impartial viewing experience is presented to anyone who has the opportunity to see her pieces.</p><p>Near the beginning of the interview, Opie posed a question to the Council that informed much of the language and conclusions to be had for the rest of the conversation: “How are all of you?” In the midst of nationwide college campus protests, strikes, and calls to action, the topic of photography does not just exist as a medium of visual artistry but as a bastion of social struggle. Democracy and vulnerability within photography is explained through the truth sought from a photo. As photography has become more and more accessible, its use as a cultural means of communication has transformed exponentially in recent years–especially in the presentation of human experiences all around the world. Social media and the internet play a deceptive role in undermining the once high-held presumptions of photography, which Opie feels to be so detrimental to the further denaturing of the photo.</p><p>Opie later explained her strategy with respect to the subjects of her photos. Subjects are asked to move into an “interior space” by Opie asking them to “close their eyes” and “think about their favorite place in the world.” This allows for the sense of vulnerability and ultimate humanity found in her portraits. Opie sees that this vulnerability of her photography makes the audience want to know and be with the subject of the photo.</p><p>Opie’s understanding of and science behind the photograph is something that could be translated to anyone’s life, to fully experience. Her attention to vulnerability and questioning what is known in her photography provides anyone with the tools to not only stop and take a second look at her photography, but to reexamine everything they once felt they already knew.</p><p><em>A recap by Biruke Dix</em></p><h4>About our speaker:</h4><p><strong>Catherine Opie</strong> is an American fine-art photographer and educator. Opie studies the connections between mainstream and marginalized society. Merging conceptual and documentary styles, she creates pieces relating to sexual identity; to the relationship between the individual and the space they inhabit; and to the tensions between the constructed American dream and the diverse realities of its citizens. Opie has had numerous solo shows, including at the Museum of Contemporary Art Los Angeles; Walker Art Center, Minneapolis; Museum of Contemporary Art, Chicago (2006); Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, New York; Los Angeles County Museum of Art; Institute of Contemporary Art, Boston; and Hammer Museum, Los Angeles, CA. Her work has appeared in the Whitney Biennial, the Melbourne International Biennial, and SITE Santa Fe Biennial (2006).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*hSkPxvc8BvqIXJ61yJV8ug.png" /><figcaption>Catherine Opie | Image: Dustin Aksland</figcaption></figure><h3>April: Allison Lee</h3><p>In our interview with Allison Lee, we travel back in time as she speaks admirably of her grandfather, revealing the most important thing that he owned: his library card. He believed “that’s how he could open more doors and travel,” she expressed to us in our discussion. This library card, as simple as it was, served as a gateway into knowledge and inspiration. With her lifelong dedication to promoting human rights, Allison Lee has made it her mission to discover the intersection between the literary world and social justice through serving as PEN America’s Director of Los Angeles.</p><p>Allison describes the journey we take through personally encountering literature, as a “discovery in what a book or a story could mean for a person, and how important those stories are.” She explains that PEN America is dedicated to highlighting those stories, ultimately granting her a “gift to serve and return to herself.” With the rise of book-banning legislation in the United States, the council discussed the urgency of combating harmful laws that suppress unheard or marginalized voices, especially those from LGBT, POC, and female-identifying communities. This led me to then wonder the role of the writer, the pen, and PEN America, in regards to social justice, inclusion, and times that call for difficult conversations. Allison expressed her belief in the highlighting of all voices, as she stands for the right of freedom of expression for all, being not just the “unification for one voice, but allowing for the multiplication of all voices to exist, be protected, and be heard, which includes protesting PEN America.”</p><p>So, what are we called to do in the midst of this everlasting war on the pen? How do we remain unfiltered in a democracy under the looming fear of censorship and erasure? Even with the pen being fought against, we as a council were reminded of the significance of our humanity, its beauty and intricacies alike, as we shared our personal joys with one another. I personally was reminded of this essence during a special moment in the interview, as Allison shared with us two poems by Palestinian poet Refaat Alareer and Israeli poet Yehuda Amichai, that reminded her “you can not ever take away the intimacy of a single human life.” Allison emphasized the crucialness of recognizing this intimacy as she reminded us that, “at our very core when we encounter humanity with a curious spirit there’s a joy and a beauty to that connective tissue.” With this, we discovered that maybe the answer is remembering humanity, whether that be through writing, learning from one another, or simply just existing in harmony.</p><p><em>A recap by Zora Nelson</em></p><h4>About our speaker:</h4><p><strong>Allison Lee </strong>serves as PEN America’s Los Angeles Director. She was the Chief Development Officer for TIME’S UP, a non-profit organization dedicated to promoting gender equity and ending sexual violence in the workplace. She has previously served as Vice President of External Affairs at Bet Tzedek Legal Services, where she worked, among other things, to launch their Rapid Response Family Immigration Project and Transgender Advocacy Program. Prior to that, Allison served for eight years as the founding Executive Director of American Jewish World Service — Southern California. Allison received her B.A. in Political Science and American Studies from Tufts University.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*6O3i2GysSHrOZYWeQQY5cA.jpeg" /></figure><h3>March: Triston Ezidore</h3><p>March was a special month for the Student Council. We had the pleasure of interviewing Triston Ezidore, who is not only the youngest speaker so far to visit the Council, but also, at 19 years old, the youngest elected official in the history of Los Angeles County. Currently studying Political Science at USC and serving as Vice President on the Culver City School Board, Ezidore exemplifies the passion and drive that is characteristic of today’s youth. Throughout the hour-long conversation, the Council was able to see how well-spoken, observant, and devoted Ezidore is.</p><p>Much of the interview touched upon the significance of and necessity for representation in education. Children spend immense amounts of time at school, and it is there where they meet role models and find inspiration. Ezidore told the Council about the district’s Black Literature Camp, which was part of his Black Student Achievement plan. In addition to working with its students to reach expected reading levels, the camp offered students the opportunity to engage with Black authors. He mentioned that most kids left that program wanting to be writers and concluded: “you can’t be what you can’t see.” This was an example of Ezidore’s fight for equitable education and against the educational discrimination that many students, including himself, have endured. His core belief that “those closest to the pain should be closest to the power” aligns with his focus on increasing minority representation. He went on to explain what this saying meant to him and how it frames his work: “How we unlearn and uproot racist and harmful policy is not to exclude those who have been affected…who have suffered the repercussions of harmful legislative practices and priorities.”</p><p>The Council and Ezidore continued the conversation by discussing how the 2020 pandemic and the Black Lives Matter movement led him towards political activism. He explained how these two events “put a spotlight on government and how government can affect our communities.” He joined other young people in ensuring their voices were heard and continues to do so.</p><p>When asked about other factors that can make a democracy weaker and thus vulnerable, Ezidore had an interesting answer: exhaustion. He argued that “There are so many campaigns and elections to focus on, we ask people to vote, we tell people that everything’s on the line in every single election…I’m not sure that our communities are seeing the outcomes that they were promised…and so asking them to show up and show out with the same amount of urgency and fierceness can lead to a lot of exhaustion.” This observation proves Ezidore’s closeness to the people in his community and the attention he dedicates towards them.</p><p>Finally, Ezidore described how he and numerous other young politically involved individuals have encountered skepticism and lack of support because of their age. Ezidore’s response to this, and his recommendation for other young activists, is that “this conversation about age […] is second to the issues at hand. […] Young people are qualified and professional every day.” This further shows Ezidore’s genuine interest in working towards bettering his community with all the resources and power available to him.</p><p>Triston Ezidore was a unique and wonderful guest speaker. He is a noteworthy example of Gen Z’s power and potential to be(come) strong figures in the future of our democracy.</p><p><em>A recap by Amy Cabrales</em></p><h4>About our speaker:</h4><p>At 19 years old, <strong>Triston Ezidore </strong>made history as the youngest elected official in the history of Los Angeles County and the first black male to serve on Culver City Unified Board of Education. As a recent high school graduate, Board Member Ezidore is a staunch advocate in building a school district in which all students can thrive. He currently works as a Youth Employment Manager with the Housing Authority of the City of LA, and has served his community as an Equity Specialist, Legislative Organizer, and committee member on the District’s Equity Advisory Committee, Restorative Practice’s Committee, Positive Behavior and Intervention’s Support Committee, and the Sexual Assault and Misconduct Reform Committee.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*UVu0pifRzNbhsgA62FQEwA.png" /></figure><h3>February: Friedemann Karig</h3><p>For the second episode of the <em>Democracy and Vulnerability</em> series, the Student Council spoke with the Thomas Mann House fellow Friedemann Karig, a journalist and author from Berlin whose recent work focuses on the histories and practices of protest movements. Karig became interested in the topic during the 2019 climate protests that swept across Germany, wondering what kind of effects such protests could actually achieve, whether certain tactics resulted in more policy changes than others, and how protesters sustained their pursuit of political transformation. This research has become a book, <em>Was ihr wollt: Wie Protest wirklich wirkt</em> [What You Want: How Protest Really Works], that was just released on March 14, 2024.<br> <br>This is not Karig’s first book, however, and the Council opened up the conversation by asking him how his creativity and love of writing influences his politics. He responded that he lives off of stories, that they nourish him and shape his worldview. Stories, he said, train the human “muscle” of fantasy, which he described as the ability to see the world as it could be. Hope and fantasy are thus deeply connected, and he suggested that contemporary protest movements could benefit from a return to some of the more utopian boldness of the 1960s.<br> <br>The majority of the Council’s questions invited Karig to dig a bit more deeply into his research’s findings, asking about which protest strategies seem the most effective and what advice he would give to organizers dealing with heightened cultural polarization and the growing presence of extremist ideologies in the political mainstream. Even as he emphasized the importance of maintaining a utopian vision, Karig noted that successful protests usually begin with raising awareness at a local level and adapting to each unique context, slowly breaking the status quo and helping people believe that a better future is actually possible. Karig said that generating political momentum was less about convincing one’s opponents than about persuading people in the opportunistic middle. This perspective sharpens a movement’s focus and makes change seem more achievable, an essential part of preventing burnout and cynicism.<br> <br>The conversation ended with a reflection on what sources of hope Karig and the Council’s panelists turn to in their daily lives. While each answer was different, they shared a belief in the importance of community and cultivating a deep connection to all the living things that surround us. This commitment to hope was perhaps the most prominent theme in Karig’s talk, reminding listeners that although the constant news of surging extremism is both terrifying and exhausting, we do not have to give extremists the power to define what futures are imaginable, and through strategic, local actions it is possible to build solidarity and political will that can change the world for the better.</p><p><em>A recap by Matthew Jones</em></p><h4>About our speaker:</h4><p><strong>Friedemann Karig</strong> is a journalist, author, and moderator from Berlin. He studied media science, politics, and economics and has written for <em>Süddeutsche Zeitung</em>, <em>Die Zeit</em>, <em>Spiegel Online</em>, and <em>Deutschlandfunk</em>, among others. His nonfiction book <em>Wie wir lieben</em> was published by Blumenbar in 2017, followed by his debut novel <em>Dschungel</em> (Ullstein, 2019) and the nonfiction bestseller <em>Erzählende Affen: Mythen, Lügen, Utopien — Wie Geschichten unser Leben bestimmen</em>, (Ullstein, 2021). His novel <em>Die Lügnerin</em> will be published in September 2023 by Ullstein.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*5-4INJ1loQ5Va82o419pyg.png" /><figcaption>Friedemann Karig | Image: Marie Staggart</figcaption></figure><h3>January: Sophie-Charlotte Opitz</h3><p>For the very first episode in our <em>Democracy and Vulnerability</em> series, the Wende Museum and Thomas Mann House Student Council welcomed media scholar and curator Sophie-Charlotte Opitz. The Council opened our discussion by asking Opitz to define memory studies and its role in her work. She insightfully described the field as one that explores individual and collective perceptions of social, political, cultural, and technological shifts throughout history. Memory studies isn’t necessarily about the past, but how we use it — in this sense, memory studies holds a correlative relationship with visual culture. Evoking George Orwell’s words, “Who controls the past controls the future; who controls the present controls the past,” Opitz argues that who controls the image controls society.</p><p>The Council shifted to the topic of protest art and technology, another defining focus of Opitz’s work. She connected past movements with contemporary struggles, by linking the momentous Greensboro Lunch Counter Sit-Ins during the Civil Rights Movement to the more recent virtual sit-in model — in which activists simultaneously access targeted websites, causing them to crash with an overflow of traffic. During the COVID-19 lockdown and simultaneous Black Lives Matter protests, virtual sit-ins expanded into the gaming sphere, spreading such actions across games from World of Warcraft to Animal Crossing.</p><p>Deepening our reflections on technology and justice, Opitz explained how Artificial Intelligence systems often produce discriminatory patterns and materials. This is no accident, given that such programs pull from image databases and internet archives which naturally mirror our human-made visual culture — and of course, such sources are undoubtedly biased toward the representation of white males. Highlighting its need for a radical overhaul, our discussion came to the conclusion that AI can perpetuate oppressive structures given the high probability that we, as viewers, remember and internalize such content. To combat its replicable systematic silencing of marginalized narratives, Opitz stressed the dire need for creative resistance and the inclusion of global perspectives in AI advancements.</p><p>As the episode drew to a close, Council members sought Opitz’s opinion on a critical debate: Is there hope for the future of AI? Her response was less than optimistic. AI poses several concerns, including its aforementioned inclination to discriminate, its inaccessibility, and its dangerously deceptive qualities. However, not all hope is lost — Opitz recognized artists and activists who seek to revolutionize AI, such as Computational Mama, who holds accessible and educational workshops on AI artmaking, with a pointed awareness of its shortcomings.</p><p><em>A recap by Sara Abrahamsson.</em></p><h4>About our speaker:</h4><p><strong>Sophie-Charlotte Opitz</strong> is a media and memory studies scholar and curator. She studied philosophy and art education at Goethe University Frankfurt and subsequently completed her doctorate. In 2019 she began her curatorial practice as a fellow at the Akademie Schloss Solitude in Stuttgart and afterwards worked internationally as a curator and director in museums in Germany, Switzerland, and England. In addition to her monograph „Bilderregungen. Die Produktionsmechanismen zeitgenössischer Kriegsfotografie“, she regularly publishes in academic journals, exhibition catalogues, and photography books, especially on aspects of collective memory cultures and global image politics. She is a 2023 Thomas Mann Fellow. In her project, she is researching new forms of protest which strengthen political visibility during critical times.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*0g8g8v70Wy82taQ6okiz5Q.jpeg" /></figure><h3>The 2024 Student Council</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mXHz1BLupZLH-yL07dEC5Q.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Sara Abrahamsson</strong> is a fourth-year student at UCLA studying Art History and French. As a culmination of her artistic and academic interest in political graphics, Sara is currently writing her senior thesis paper on the internationalist poster art of post-revolutionary Cuba. Upon graduating, she plans to continue working in museums before pursuing graduate studies in Art History or Art Conservation.</p><p><strong>Amy Cabrales</strong> is a First-Generation fourth-year undergraduate student at UCLA, studying Sociology and the Russian Language. She is a Mexican-American, Los Angeles native born in Lynwood, California. Her career interests include cross-cultural education via museum work or language instruction and immigrant resettlement, while her academic interests include immigrant integration and self-identity across immigrant generations. She is anticipating returning to Almaty, Kazakhstan for the 2024–25 academic year to inform these interests and advance her Russian proficiency.</p><p><strong>Elsa Coony</strong> is a fourth-year student at the University of California, Los Angeles double majoring in Global Studies and German. She has previously worked at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum as both a docent and translator and is excited to join this year’s council. In the future, she hopes to pursue a career in international development.</p><p><strong>Biruke Dix</strong> is currently a 2nd year student at UCLA studying Applied Mathematics. He joined the Wende Student Council in 2024 and is deeply invested in the ever-changing properties of art as well as social habits. He hopes that he can create language and conversation that promotes the spread of cultural shifts and social justice.</p><p><strong>Matthew Jones</strong> is a third-year PhD student in Claremont Graduate University’s Cultural Studies and Museum Studies program. His research currently explores how sites connected to authoritarian regimes function as pilgrimage destinations and what strategies states and institutions employ to reduce extremist attachment at these sites. He is thrilled to continue his training with the Wende Museum through this collaboration with the Thomas Mann House.</p><p><strong>Emma Larson </strong>is a master’s student at Columbia University’s Harriman Institute of Russian, Eurasian, and Eastern European Studies. There, she focuses on the gender, social, and political history of Central Asia. Before starting at Columbia, Emma taught English in Kazakhstan with the Fulbright Program. She graduated from Williams College with degrees in History and Russian in 2021.</p><p><strong>Zora Nelson</strong> is a current undergraduate student at New York University, where she is studying Harp Performance and Media, Culture, and Communication. As an east coaster born and raised in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, she discovered the Wende Museum in the summer of 2022 and is honored to be a part of the council. With a passion for writing, Zora sees a future in storytelling to promote social justice.</p><p><strong>Lexi Tooley </strong>is a current sophomore at the University of Pennsylvania majoring in Political Science and Art History, minoring in Chinese Language and Culture. She is originally from Los Angeles, California, and attended the Archer School for Girls. Lexi has been working with the Wende Museum for the past 2 years. She looks forward to continuing the search for truth and examining the vulnerability of democracy through this program!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e48d270fc31" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/vatmh/democracy-vulnerability-recaps-by-the-student-council-5e48d270fc31">Democracy &amp; Vulnerability: Recaps by the Student Council</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/vatmh">vatmh</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Political Mandate of the Arts: Recaps by the Student Council]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/vatmh/the-political-mandate-of-the-arts-recaps-by-the-student-council-5009d8be590b?source=rss-2fdb0b3df75f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5009d8be590b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Mann House]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Feb 2023 20:47:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-31T09:33:50.110Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hVGUGnFmLw6D5DHNotN8XA.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>We are excited to announce that the Student Council series will be continued in 2024! Stay up to date with the latest recaps on our new blog which you can find </em></strong><a href="https://vatmh.medium.com/democracy-vulnerability-recaps-by-the-student-council-5e48d270fc31"><strong><em>here</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></p><p><em>In 2023 the </em><a href="https://wendemuseum.org/?gclid=Cj0KCQiA54KfBhCKARIsAJzSrdr-1gvCP4x3IQQf1Hl1EqNp1ym2cYufV5BxPw5FmcJFAOatbq4vxBMaAgFHEALw_wcB"><em>Wende Museum</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://www.dublab.com/"><em>dublab radio</em></a><em> and the </em><a href="https://www.vatmh.org/en/home-en.html"><em>Thomas Mann House</em></a><em> started a new monthly virtual program series that focused on art and politics in times of crisis. High school, college, and university students invited prominent guest speakers to discuss topics relating to art, culture, politics and society.</em></p><p><em>The freedom of art is one of the imperatives of every democracy. But does this freedom make art inconsequential? Does art have a role in addressing social issues, promoting social justice, or in defending democracy when it comes under pressure? In short: does art have a political mandate and what is the role of art in weakened democracies?</em></p><p><em>The series aimed to answers these questions. It took place every last Wednesday of the month and for every episode, one of the students from the council would write a recap. Please reference this blog page to find reports for all the 2023 episodes.</em></p><h3>Episode 1: David Horvitz. A recap by Amy Cabrales</h3><p>“We found out that much of Horvitz’s ideas for his work are spontaneous, come from daily life and public interactions, and are often born in ‘a moment of inspiration’. When asked how radicalism and Zen play into art and political change, he answered how it’s a matter of ‘finding the balance between the two…how to remain clear-headed while still having the energy and urgency to make something.’</p><p>The conversation also touched upon the connection of his approach to art with the Fluxus movement’s emphasis on process over product, about accessibility in the art world, and about his unique and humorous interaction with the concept of copyrights. Moreover, Horvitz reflected on the important role of nature in his work and on art as a medium for social change”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/288/1*jm8blQp6e84p5WZn3Bau_A.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Amy Cabrales is a First-Generation third-year undergraduate student at UCLA, studying Sociology, Anthropology, and the Russian Language. She is a Mexican-American, Los Angeles native born in Lynwood, California. Her career interests include museum work, social science research, and teaching English abroad in a Russian-speaking country.</em></p><h4>Guest speaker David Horvitz</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/230/1*0tnrRdzfG-a7PVQyZXVRLw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>David Horvitz</strong> uses art, books, photography, performance art, and mail art as a media for his work. He is known for his work in the virtual sphere, and is part of the Wende Museum’s current exhibition <em>For Ruth, The Sky in Los Angeles: Ruth Wolf-Rehfeldt and David Horvitz</em>. His work has been exhibited at the Museum of Modern Art, New York, the New Museum, New York, the Tate Modern, London, and the Art Metropole, Toronto, among many others.</p><h3>Episode 2: Ebow (aka Ebru Düzgün). A recap by Anya Nyman</h3><p>“Our conversation with Ebow about her work, life, and politics revealed the distinct way she balances creative joy with an earnest commitment to the political practice of her music. “I make music for my friends,” Ebow responded to a question about her audience. This theme permeated throughout the rest of the interview, with Ebow expressing her simultaneous awareness of the political implications of her work, including her songs that are less explicitly political but are public and defiant nonetheless, and her desire to produce art that is enjoyable, danceable, and empowering on multiple levels. This was also echoed in her discussion of balancing theory with life, that is, her focus on creating music that both challenges broad norms and systems <em>and</em> remains committed to the individual and collective experiences of emotion and joy that music provides.</p><p>We also discussed the specifics of her experience navigating Kurdish, Turkish, German, and other linguistic, national, and ethnic identities, as well as her experiences as a queer-woman. Identity has been central to Ebow’s political and artistic practice, and throughout our conversation, she emphasized how important it has been for her to be surrounded by communities of shared and parallel identities. “I would be easier to approach if I just went for one style,” she said about her gender and sexual expression, but her work has not been about appeasing those who do not support her activism and authenticity. Rather, she has been committed to being artistically playful, politically determined, and creative in ways that allow people to feel seen and heard”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/216/1*dGbf8riJaKspn17U9xm2rA.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Anya Nyman </em></strong><em>is a current sophomore at Scripps College (Claremont, CA), currently studying History and Africana Studies. She joined the Wende student council in 2023 and is excited to add to the work the council has already done. Her academic interests include anticolonialism, twentieth-century West and Central African history, and international histories of and from the Global South</em></p><h4>Guest speaker Ebow (aka Ebru Düzgün)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/230/1*3VFmD3KOoajnkdmROOywkA.png" /></figure><p>Ebow also known as Ebru Düzgün is a Berlin-based German rapper of Kurdish descent. She first attracted attention through guerrilla performances in laundromats, supermarkets and on streetcars. Today, Ebow performs on more conventional stages, but her message remains provocative and political. Solo, but also as a member of the Berlin-based music collective Gaddafi Gals, she raps against sexism, racism, and homophobia, for an open, caring, and equal society. Ebow is currently a 2023 Villa Aurora Fellow in Los Angeles.</p><h3>Episode 3: Ghayath Almadhoun. A recap by Emma Larson</h3><p>Ghayath Almadhoun’s interview with the Student Council was truly special. I believe that all of us were blown away by Ghayath’s candid sense of humor and unfaltering honesty. Many of the topics he concerns himself with in his poetry, such as identity, expulsion, ignorance, and the crises of history, are complex and do not give up easy answers. Ghayath himself is no stranger to the heavier sides of humanity, being born as a Palestinian in a Syrian refugee camp and subsequently seeking political asylum in Sweden. Yet through it all, Ghayath retains his composure, using poetry to better understand the world and its pain. Ghayath ‘poetries the world,’ as he would call his relationship between himself, reality, and his art.</p><p>Our conversation additionally touched upon the delicate nature of translation. Ghayath explained that he only writes poetry in his native Arabic; translations and their diffusion are an afterthought. Though more confident as an Arabic writer, Ghayath is no stranger to collaboration and we enjoyed learning about some of the works that he has done with artists of other cultural backgrounds. Ghayath credited these opportunities to the international and multicultural status of his home in Berlin.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/216/1*ouoQLyGKjlJlFnkdlX0GOw.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Emma Larson </em></strong><em>graduated from Williams College in 2021 with degrees in History and Russian, and is currently teaching English in Kazakhstan with the Fulbright Program. Emma hopes to use the future of her professional and academic career to answer important questions about the entirety of the post-Soviet world.</em></p><h4>Guest speaker Ghayath Almadhoun</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/294/1*GScN-Avk7Uqi7U4-HcxS1w.png" /></figure><p><strong>Ghayath Almadhoun</strong> is a Palestinian poet born in Damascus, Syria, who emigrated to Sweden in 2008. Ghayath Almadhoun collaborated with other poets and artists, and his poetry has been part of work by US artist Jenny Holzer and German musician Blixa Bargeld. His latest collection <em>Adrenalin</em>, published in English by Action Books 2017, was among SPD Poetry Bestsellers in the US and was nominated for the 2018 Best Translated Book Award. His selected poems <em>Ein Raubtier namens Mittelmeer</em> (Predator called the Mediterranean), Arche Verlag, 2018, ranked top of the Litprom-Bestenliste 2018 of best books translated into German. Ghayath is currently a Fellow at the Thomas Mann House in Los Angeles.</p><h3>Episode 4: Heidi Duckler. A recap by Natalie McDonald</h3><p>A recurring theme during the Student Council’s wide-ranging conversation with Heidi Duckler was the power of seeing the mundane with new eyes. “Inspiration can be found everywhere,” Duckler said. “The role of the artist is to make us more conscious and to expand how we see the world around us.”</p><p>With site-specific choreography, Heidi Duckler Dance (HDD) explores ideas including freedom, disparity, and activism. “Dance is about the body, which is what makes it democratic — we all have bodies!” Duckler exclaimed. “It’s a universal language or way of communicating.” The company’s many projects have focused on underrecognized people, under-told stories, and historical sites that are forgotten or abandoned. For example, Duckler described a project that provided diaspora communities in greater Los Angeles and indigenous communities in Portland the opportunity to share stories of expulsion. “A performance is only one day,” Duckler said, “but it can awaken memory and connect past/present/future.”</p><p>Our conversation also touched upon the challenges the Covid-19 pandemic posed to a company founded upon the principle of human connection; the necessity of adaptation in a world facing climate change; and the importance of listening. “Listening is so important!” Duckler said, when asked about the role of dance in times of political polarization.</p><p>Bringing the conversation full circle, Duckler encouraged the audience to “take the time to notice things. The ordinary can lead us to the sacred.” One of the ways HDD dancers develop sensory awareness is with “acts of noticing,” a process that the public is invited to participate in on May 20th, when the company will stage <a href="https://heididuckler.org/event/time-for-a-slow-dance/">a culminating performance</a> exploring health, wellness, endurance, and imagination following an eight-week workshop series at the Martin Luther King Jr. Community Hospital.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/224/1*ugW6tf2JqjIVrQVqLQ7hhA.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Natalie McDonald, </em></strong><em>a 2019 graduate of Pomona College (Claremont, CA) is currently pursuing her Master of Arts in History at California State University, Northridge. Her academic work focuses on migration, citizenship, empire &amp; memory in twentieth-century Europe. Natalie plans to undertake doctoral studies in International/Global History within the next couple of years.</em></p><h4>Guest speaker Heidi Duckler</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/208/1*w9yhOAWkdRDwDwxOD0DZ4Q.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Heidi Duckler </strong>is the Founder and Artistic Director of Heidi Duckler Dance in Los Angeles, CA, the pioneer of site-specific place-based contemporary practice. Titled the “reigning queen of site-specific performance” by the LA Times, Duckler has been awarded the Distinguished Dance Alumna award from the University of Oregon School of Music and Dance, the Dance/USA and the Doris Duke Charitable Foundation’s Engaging Dance Audiences award, and the National Endowment of the Arts American Masterpiece award. Duckler has created more than 500 dance pieces all over the world and she is currently on faculty at the University of California, Santa Barbara in the Film and Media Studies Department.</p><h3>Episode 5: Steven D. Lavine. A recap by Meghana Halbe</h3><p>Steven Lavine was an amazing guest for our May episode of <em>The Political Mandate of the Arts</em>. Through his reflections on the history of the California Institute of the Arts (CalArts) and the role of art education in changing our political and social climate, our conversation addressed questions of how people can express themselves through the arts, how art should be taught, and if art should be political. I loved how Mr. Lavine emphasized the role the arts play in helping us discover our identity and the messages we want to convey to those who will listen. “Given an opportunity to express yourself through the arts,” Lavine said, “what you really discover is that you do have something to say, you do have a difference that you can make.” He explained that “once you know that, you then have a reason to learn all the other things they want to teach you because they become tools for how you are going to make your contribution to the world and make your presence felt and valued.”</p><p>As the former president of CalArts, Lavine was extremely attuned to the power of an arts education and the way strong artists are created. He explained to the student council that there is no formula in which a good artist is made, but rather, “the role of the teacher is to help students discover what’s already in them” and then teach them how to communicate what they feel effectively. Within this process, they can find strength, Lavine says, and be “self-critical without being self-denying.” This statement particularly stood out to me. There is something so powerful about how the arts enable us to become the best versions of ourselves and understand how to effectively communicate our ideas and make people listen. This process of self-discovery goes hand in hand with inspiring real world changes.</p><p>Another recurring theme throughout this program was whether the arts had a responsibility to be politically and socially engaged. In answering this question, Lavine evoked the words of Thomas Mann, who believed that “nothing that is alive can sidestep politics. Even a refusal of politics is political.” When reflecting on past social movements, Lavine explained that these movements stemmed from a place that was both political and personal — a politics enacted by who you are and what you have become. Inevitably, these two entities intertwine. In his last words of the program, Steven Lavine emphasized the importance of our voices, a topic he continually referred to throughout the conversation. What especially inspired me was when he asserted that “all of us who want to live in a decent world really have to stand up right now and raise our voices because right now, they are not getting adequately heard.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*pFjRG4NSJYcABG8lhSqzGg.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Meghana Halbe</em></strong><em> is a first-year student at the University of Chicago studying Public Policy. She is from Los Angeles, California and her interests include politics, music, and history. She plans to pursue law school in the future and work in government.</em></p><h4>Guest Speaker: Steven D. Lavine</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*gdMlsrzgfkAqo3IL_mtTEA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the Spring of 2017, Steven Lavine stepped down after serving for 29 years as President of the California Institute of the Arts, becoming President Emeritus and an Honorary Doctor of the Arts degree. Shortly thereafter, he was appointed as the Founding Director of the Thomas Mann House in Los Angeles.</p><h3>Episode 6: Cauleen Smith. A recap by Lexi Tooley</h3><p>For our sixth episode, we met with artist, filmmaker, and educator, Cauleen Smith, to discuss her connection with, and personal philosophies about art and education. Our opening question revolved around Smith’s connection to the past, present, and future, as well as the connections between history, memory, and legacy. Smith noted, “art is a form of haptic discourse, a way to really engage with our world and with each other, but through a means [in which] language is not sufficient and your other senses are required.” She emphasized that language is insufficient in this endeavor and that our other senses are essential to fully comprehend the depth of artistic expression.</p><p>This notion of delving into the essence of art from within served as the foundation of our dialogue, and propelled us into a broader exploration of the intricate relationships between art, memory, and life. In touching upon the role of memory in her work, Smith discussed America’s “memory problem”; a problem that stems from the “traumas that rot this country” and in turn “produces a refusal to confront” America’s history and affected present. She noted that “a failure to remember is impacting our ability to imagine possible futures that are possible”.</p><p>Nonetheless, Smith acknowledged that the act of remembering is not devoid of challenges.</p><p>In looking to the past, one must look “without nostalgia, but instead looking for tools, or mechanisms, or devices that can teach […] or be utilized in the present” to tell stories. It is through this process that stories can be imbued with timeless relevance, resonating with audiences across generations.</p><p>As the discussion unfolded, Smith illuminated the capacity of art and storytelling to transcend language and foster a profound connection with the world. She emphasized the importance of remembering and confronting history as a means of gaining valuable insight and shaping a future for all rooted in progress. Through her artistic endeavors, Smith ultimately encouraged us to reconsider our relationship with memory as well as understanding art that goes beyond the realms of social justice and activism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/216/1*HyxX42AjWObRfISqnXPNLA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>Lexi Tooley</em></strong><em> is a current freshman at Howard University majoring in Art History and Political Science, and minoring in Chinese Language and Culture. She is originally from Los Angeles, California, and has been working with the Wende museum for the past year. She looks forward to continuing the search for truth through these student panels, as well as through learning about and from the curated art currently on display at the Wende.</em></p><h4>Guest Speaker: Cauleen Smith</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/252/1*iQ7I1l8keKk9astAsH702Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Raised in Sacramento, California, and now based in Los Angeles, Cauleen Smith is a prolific and critically acclaimed artist specializing in film, installation, and object art. Currently a faculty member at the UCLA School of Arts and Architecture, Smith’s work disrupts traditional representations of image and language, inviting contemplative engagement from her audience. Her work has been showcased in esteemed institutions like The Whitney Museum of American Art, MassMoCA, and LACMA, and she has received numerous awards, including the 2021 Guggenheim Fellowship and the inaugural Ellsworth Kelly Award in 2016. Smith’s innovative practice underscores the transformative potential of art, as she continuously pushes boundaries and invites audiences to consider new perspectives​.</p><h3>Episode 7: Sonali Kolhatkar. A recap by Zora Nelson</h3><p>After a dynamic interview with Sonali Kolhatkar last Wednesday, the student council and its audience members felt the urge to start “calling people in.” The self-identifying “well-rounded troublemaker” spoke about how her multi-disciplinary journey ultimately led her to a fulfilling and awe-inspiring career in social justice and humanitarianism. As a scientist, journalist, and artist, in our discussion she went into great depth about the intersection between art, culture, and science.</p><p>Reminiscent of last year’s theme, “In the Search of Truth,” Sonali explained that “ultimately, science is the search for truth…[and] journalism is about uncovering the truth.” With a robust background in astrophysics, she detailed her process of using the scientific method to uncover these truths within her journalism, as social justice serves as the driving force of her writing. Within her narrative work, Sonali expresses that as a writer, she feels a responsibility to shine a light on the voices of the unheard, ultimately uplifting them. As a writer who is influenced by art-activism myself, this sentiment was especially significant to me and a concept that I thought to be quite powerful in regard to art as a whole. As future change-makers within the council and beyond, she encouraged us all “to be unafraid of doing the things that aren’t popular or troublesome, tackling things that are sacred or touching on the things that people don’t wanna say,” a value she practices not only within her writing, but also implements as she moves about in the world. This theme of being unapologetic resonated deeply with myself and my fellow council members, as we were reminded of the sacredness of one’s voice. Through her remarkable work, Sonali also hopes to educate and inform those who may be ignorant of the social issues she remains passionate about, focusing on what brings us together and to “start rejecting our polarizing culture, because we have a lot more in common than we think.” This concluding remark lingered on long after our interview with Sonali, as it greatly aligns with our current times and serves as a reminder that we must hold onto it now more than ever before.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*1Nzn1IMfq9y3EHE13jsABg.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Zora Nelson</em></strong><em> is a current second year undergraduate student at New York University, where she is studying Harp Performance and plans to also pursue Media, Culture, and Communications and Public Policy. As an east coaster, born and raised in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, she discovered the Wende Museum in the summer of 2022 and is honored to be a part of the council. With a passion for writing, Zora sees a future in storytelling to promote social justice.</em></p><h4>Guest Speaker: Sonali Kolhatkar</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*CpxTInlKvvjWvpeEKAeomg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Sonali Kolhatkar is an award winning journalist and host and executive producer of “Rising Up With Sonali”, a weekly radio and television program syndicated to dozens of radio stations and available on Free Speech TV. She is the racial justice and civil liberties editor at YES! Magazine and Senior Correspondent of the “Economy For All project” at the Independent Media Institute. Her new book is called Rising Up: The Power of Narrative in Pursuing Racial Justice (City Lights, 2023).</p><h3>Episode 8: Amanda Beech. A recap by Gianna Machera</h3><p>The Wende Museum’s Student Council welcomed artist, writer, and educator Amanda Beech to our eighth episode of <em>Political Mandate of the Arts</em>. Ms. Beech is an internationally renowned artist who brings critical thought into art, for instance reflecting on how power interacts with human agency. She uses her art to ignite critical conversations. Ms. Beech interacted with the student council in a unique and inspirational way by asking as many questions of the student council as they did of her! This was an enlightening and memorable episode. <br> <br> The conversations centered on art and its political illumination, but Ms. Beech took everyone a step further into the awareness of how the process of creating art contributes as much as the finished product. Ms. Beech referenced her work as an ongoing practice of discipline as much as artistry. The Council was intrigued by the idea of sequencing the creation of art. Both the Council and Ms. Beech pondered whether the idea comes first, or if the choice of medium inspires the idea. Ms. Beech identified that there seems to be an ebb and flow of creation for any artist, which she described as a series of thoughts with commas instead of periods. Ms. Beech went deeper into the ebb and flow metaphor by stating that it is more important to complete the process than the thought. The idea is that the path is traveled and interrogated simultaneously. The pathway through the practice of art leads the artist from the unknown to the possibility of what could be. Ms. Beech described this practice as a continuum that is part of a commitment and responsibility to the artist’s lens of the world, creating a dynamic reality of agency of thought and process.<br> <br> As the episode concluded, what was most powerful was the conversation of intentionality. The critical question is: What is intentionality for the artist and the art that is created? For Ms. Beech, many factors can determine how art becomes the hope of what could be communicated if everything aligns. The Council and Ms. Beech ended on the revolutionary idea that once this particular type of hope is discovered, art is less about a finished product and more about a continued expression of growth and, therefore, a foundation of truth telling.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*2RDGIsheRRE7-UtpZOaX8w.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Gianna Machera</em></strong><em> is currently a junior at Culver City High School. She was born and raised in Los Angeles, California, however she spends most of her holidays and summer traveling various places. She joined the council in 2022 and has absolutely loved the experience and growth she has had so far. She is very excited to see what the next year entails and feels privileged to be part of the council once again.</em></p><h4>Guest Speaker: Amanda Beech</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/255/1*e_OYzoJxvvRtkRMICwNTKw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Amanda Beech is an artist and writer. Her work collides narratives of power, cause and alienation from philosophical theory, literature and real political events, exploring how these accounts of human agency enforce and render our experience of reality. Artworks are “arguments” that prosecute another form of force that surpasses the notion that art simply reflects and reproduces the status quo. Amanda’s work has been exhibited internationally in Biennales and other arts projects. This includes,<em> Covenant Transport Move or Die</em>, solo exhibit, Baltic Contemporary, UK, 2018, <em>Map of the Bomb</em>, video work, Havana Biennale, 2022, <em>Asymmetrical Equations</em>, a book project for Manual for a Future Desert, 2022, and “Messages from the Inside”, an essay on Lyotard’s Les Immateriaux, for the exhibition, <em>Beyond Matter</em>, ZKM, Karlsruhe, Germany. Her new book <em>The Intolerable Image</em>, is forthcoming with MIT.</p><h3>Episode 9: Sasha Razor. A recap by Emma Larson</h3><p>Last week, the Student Council was honored to speak with Sasha Razor, a Belarusian-American lecturer in Germanic and Slavic Studies and Film and Media Studies at UC Santa Barbara, for our September episode of <em>The Political Mandate of the Arts</em>. Our conversation was vast and thought-provoking. We began by discussing Sasha’s work as a part of the Russophone Los Angeles Research Collective. Born out of Sasha’s search for new archival sources after completing a Ph.D. in Slavic Languages and Literature from UCLA, the Collection uses local archives, many of which include items found in people’s homes, to study Russophone migration to Southern California. It was inspiring to hear about the historical and sociological discoveries that Sasha has made as an “archival activist,” who aims to tell the story of Russian-speaking emigres in the region many of us call home.</p><p>The second part of our conversation focused on themes spurred by Sasha’s 2020 article and exhibition “The Code of Presence: Belarussian Protest Embroideries and Textile Patterns.” The intersecting works, which consider pieces of textile and embroidery that have played a role in recent protests in Belarus, encouraged conversation about the communal nature of craft, the boundary between art and non-art, and the effectiveness of art as a means of activism. Sasha explained that citizens living in the post-Soviet world have to be imaginative in their method of protest and that art can often provide a fruitful means to achieving broader societal goals.<br> Overall, Sasha’s interview left us asking ourselves two important questions: what are the stories we can tell, and what new methods can we use to tell them? The intersecting answers may provide a productive jumping-off point as we consider the mandates that each of us brings to the “art” we make each day.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*XGHrpBq6X0pvUNxVO3qtBw.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Emma Larson</em></strong><em> graduated from Williams College in 2021 with degrees in History and Russian, and is currently teaching English in Kazakhstan with the Fulbright Program. Emma hopes to use the future of her professional and academic career to answer important questions about the entirety of the post-Soviet world.</em></p><h4>Guest Speaker: Sasha Razor</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*JL8N0epAPjDspMCvYcMFlw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Sasha Razor is a Belarusian-American lecturer in Germanic and Slavic Studies and Film and Media Studies at UC Santa Barbara. She earned her PhD in Slavic Languages and Literatures from UCLA in 2020, with a dissertation focused on Soviet screenwriting in the 1920s and 1930s. Her research interests include avant-garde cinema and literature, Belarusian and Ukrainian culture, decolonial movements, diaspora studies, activism, visual arts, and women’;s studies. Razor is also a curator, journalist, and co-founder of the Russophone Los Angeles Research Collective, which promotes the study of Russophone migration to Southern California. She is currently curating a digital archive of Belarusian Contemporary Art at the University of Michigan Library and working on her first book dedicated to Belarusian protest textiles. Razor serves on the advisory board of the Belarusian Council for Culture.</p><h3>Episode 10: Elizabeth Ai. A recap by <strong>Anya Nyman</strong></h3><p>The Student Council was thrilled to speak with Elizabeth Ai, Los Angeles-based producer, writer, and director, for its October interview. The beginning of our conversation centered around Ai’s work creating a public archive of Vietnamese American cultural history, which she has worked towards since recognizing the absence of that history in traditional institutional archives. Speaking about the ways her public archive has led to the formation of new community connections, Ai emphasized the real-time change, and exchange, made possible by social media.</p><p>After this thoughtful discussion of community history in public, the Student Council turned to questions about Ai’s background and personal relationship to her work. When asked about her position as an artist, she said that she does not seek to be a hero. Instead, she emphasized that heroism is most often found in everyday people. “I’ve always been drawn to the outcasts,” she said when asked about the throughline of her varied body of work. These themes of everyday heroism and community carried throughout our entire question and answer, which ended with Ai speaking about her collaborative, interactive process, and ultimately the centrality of community to filmmaking. By the time we closed our interview, we had arrived at a deeper understanding of the importance of connection and histories in, and as, community.</p><p>Personally, as a student of history who is deeply interested in the relationships between marginalized and racialized people and the ways the past lives in the present, I was very inspired by Ai’s discussion of collective and public archival work. Her wide-ranging, yet thoroughly focused, answers to our questions have ultimately offered us a profound sense of the power of this work to build and transform communities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*nCpUsWcetSiKCR5S7wImTw.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Anya Nyman</em></strong><em> is a current sophomore at Scripps College (Claremont, CA), currently studying History and Africana Studies. She joined the Wende student council in 2023 and is excited to add to the work the council has already done. Her academic interests include anticolonialism, twentieth-century West and Central African history, and international histories of and from the Global South.</em></p><h4>Guest Speaker: Elizabeth Ai</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/230/1*AHt63mjN9AGr-Oio0sLopw.png" /></figure><p>The guest speaker for our October program is Chinese-Vietnamese-American Los Angeles- based Emmy award-winning producer <strong>Elizabeth Ai</strong>. She writes, directs, and produces independent narratives as well as branded content for companies such as National Geographic, ESPN, and VICE. She is currently directing and producing two in-progress feature documentaries. She’s a fellow of Berlin Talent Campus, Film Independent, Sundance, and Tribeca. Her film projects are supported by California Humanities, Firelight Media, Knight Foundation, and ITVS.</p><h3>Episode 11: Joes Segal. A recap by Amy Cabrales</h3><p>The month of November greeted the Wende Museum’s Student Council in more than just one special way. For the first time this year, the Council had the chance to meet each other in person and conduct the month’s interview with their very own, Joes Segal! Adding on to the month’s excitement, the interview was hosted on-site at the Wende Museum a week after their new exhibition <a href="https://wendemuseum.org/exhibition/creatingspace/"><em>Visions of the Transcendence: Creating Space in East and West</em></a><em> </em>opening as well as during the kickoff weekend for the Villa Aurora and Thomas Mann House’s Conference <a href="https://www.vatmh.org/en/eventreader/arts-in-times-of-crises-the-role-of-artists-in-weakened-democracies-conference.html"><em>Arts in Times of Crises: The Role of Artists in Weakened Democracies</em></a>. Amidst such an eventful weekend where numerous conversations and panels about art and politics were held, below was one:</p><p>Joes Segal is currently Chief Curator and Director of Programming at the Wende Museum; he previously held a Guest Professor position in the History Department at UCLA and an Assistant Professor position in Cultural History at Utrecht University. In addition to these experiences, he is also the wonderful coordinator of this Student Council. It was a pleasure for us to hear about the perspectives and ideas about art that Joes has produced throughout his career. The conversation began with Joes describing how he got into the field, how to design an exhibition, and how he places both past and present, or both historical and contemporary, pieces into play within the museum’s exhibitions. Joes had a unique interest when entering the art and political world; he wanted to understand more about the “historical context of art” and how art could have “meaning in social and political life.” Within his university, art was not so much treated with a historical as with a stylistic or theoretical approach. Such critical thinking assists Joes to excel in museum curation, particularly at a museum where art, politics, and history are always interacting. To design an exhibition, there is never a clear path because “different exhibitions have different stories.” Thus, one may begin first with a concept and then search for materials related to it, or sometimes one starts with the material and then thinks about how to narrate it for an exhibition. Regarding the combination of current and past artworks, Joes emphasized that history cannot simply be presented and left on its own because “facts do not speak for themselves,” and history always needs “an interpretation, a perspective, and a background story.” With this in mind, the Wende team’s goal is to produce thematic exhibitions where the past and present are always speaking to one another in a complementary or contradictory way, so that viewers can see the parallels and “creative tensions between them” instead of one singular message.</p><p>As the conversation continued, Joes informed us about the various strategies artists use to express not only their personal feelings and perspectives on the world, but also their intentions for their viewers, which, according to Joes, can change over time, based on the context. The Council further discussed when art pieces become political (to which Joes explained that it is not one moment but rather subsequent phases), when art pieces shapeshift their meaning, who gives art its meaning, and the “political mandate” that curators themselves have towards their audience.</p><p>Notably, Joes answered a question about dealing with ethical and/or political concerns that arise while constructing historical interpretations for a broad public audience. He emphasized that curators have to remember the concept of representation: “Who are we to represent works by people in a situation, for instance (referring to the current exhibition on display) in prison or being unhoused, that is not our situation, or artworks from a community we don’t belong to ourselves?” With the current exhibition, a commendable strategy he employed as a curator was giving the incarcerated artists the opportunity to write their own exhibition labels, thus showing respect to the artists themselves by not overstepping and by further expanding their voice.</p><p>If you would like to hear more in detail about the vast role of museums, how art is interpreted by artists and viewers, and how art and history are constantly at an interplay, we welcome you to watch this month’s interview on the Wende Museum’s YouTube channel!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/222/1*ULhTlgYOUqL-tuZhbq1O9A.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Amy Cabrales</em></strong><em> is a First-Generation third-year undergraduate student at UCLA, studying Sociology, Anthropology, and the Russian Language. She is a Mexican-American, Los Angeles native born in Lynwood, California. Her career interests include museum work, social science research, and teaching English abroad in a Russian-speaking country.</em></p><h4>Guest Speaker: Joes Segal</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*CWTJaZPriK2ZtPKgzjM6bA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The guest speaker is the Wende’s chief curator and director of programming since 2014, Joes Segal. Segal is an art historian and historian who has published about Cold War cultural history, German cultural history, and art and politics since the twentieth century.</p><h3>Episode 12: Myriam Boulos. A recap by Natalie McDonald</h3><p>When Myriam Boulos was a young child, she asked her mother what would happen if all her problems went away. How, she wondered, would she create art? Many years later, the professional photographer continues to explore the world — and its many problems — through images, with a particular emphasis on “denounce[ing] normalized violence and oppression.” The Student Council had the immense privilege of speaking with Boulos about her photography during our twelfth and final program in the 2023 Political Mandate of the Arts series.</p><p>For Boulos, the personal is political. “Images are my diary,” she told the Council, noting that the themes explored in her work are always linked to her own life. However, Boulos notes, documenting her personal experiences took on collective stakes during the 2019 revolution in Lebanon. This is when she became acutely aware that photographs are the products of encounters between artist and subject(s). So, she began asking for her subjects’ consent — essential, as in any interpersonal encounter — and to prioritize their agency. In the four years since the revolution, Boulos’ work has become increasingly collaborative, with subjects often weighing in on composition. “We create the image together,” she said.</p><p>This inclusive, participatory approach is particularly important given photography’s patriarchal and colonial history. All too often, images have been used to oppress. But for Boulos, photography is a means of resistance. With her camera, she can shed light on the oppressed and silenced. She can also resist conventional depictions of the Arab world that normalize pain. How? By photographing joy. “Joy,” Boulos reminded the Council, “is an essential tool for resistance.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/200/1*narti2y7EpM1WCVNsvtVvA.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Natalie McDonald</em></strong><em>, a 2019 graduate of Pomona College (Claremont, CA), is currently pursuing her Master of Arts in History at California State University, Northridge. Her academic work focuses on migration, citizenship, empire &amp; memory in twentieth-century Europe. Natalie plans to undertake doctoral studies in International/Global History within the next couple years.</em></p><h4><strong>Guest Speaker: Myriam Boulos</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/230/1*Fgfas2rhLJ-kWpQ3anIX1w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Myriam Boulos was born in 1992 in Lebanon. At the age of sixteen, she started to use her camera to get closer to reality. She graduated with a master’s degree in photography from the Lebanese Academy of Fine Arts in 2015. She has taken part in both national and international collective exhibitions, including Close Enough at ICP, NY; Infinite Identities at Huis Marseille, Amsterdam; and Troisième Biennale des Photographes du Monde Arabe, at l’Institut du Monde Arabe, Paris. Her work has been published in <em>Aperture</em>, <em>FOAM</em>, <em>Time</em>, <em>GQ Middle East</em>, <em>Vogue Arabia</em>, and <em>Vanity Fair France</em>, among other publications. In 2021 she joined <em>Magnum</em> as a nominee. Her book, <em>What’s ours</em>, was published in November 2023 by Aperture.</p><h3>The 2023 Student Council</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/648/1*TnNBgPASlIyB5MykNwo0MQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Amy Cabrales</strong> is a First-Generation third-year undergraduate student at UCLA, studying Sociology, Anthropology, and the Russian Language. She is a Mexican-American, Los Angeles native born in Lynwood, California. Her career interests include museum work, social science research, and teaching English abroad in a Russian-speaking country.</p><p><strong>Meghana Halbe</strong> is a first-year student at the University of Chicago studying Public Policy. She is from Los Angeles, California and her interests include politics, music, and history. She plans to pursue law school in the future and work in government.</p><p><strong>Emma Larson </strong>graduated from Williams College in 2021 with degrees in History and Russian, and is currently teaching English in Kazakhstan with the Fulbright Program. Emma hopes to use the future of her professional and academic career to answer important questions about the entirety of the post-Soviet world.</p><p><strong>Gianna Machera</strong> is currently a junior at Culver City High School. She was born and raised in Los Angeles, California, however she spends most of her holidays and summer traveling various places. She joined the council in 2022 and has absolutely loved the experience and growth she has had so far. She is very excited to see what the next year entails and feels privileged to be part of the council once again.</p><p><strong>Natalie McDonald</strong>, a 2019 graduate of Pomona College (Claremont, CA), is currently pursuing her Master of Arts in History at California State University, Northridge. Her academic work focuses on migration, citizenship, empire &amp; memory in twentieth-century Europe. Natalie plans to undertake doctoral studies in International/Global History within the next couple years.</p><p><strong>Zora Nelson</strong> is a current second year undergraduate student at New York University, where she is studying Harp Performance and plans to also pursue Media, Culture, and Communications and Public Policy. As an east coaster, born and raised in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, she discovered the Wende Museum in the summer of 2022 and is honored to be a part of the council. With a passion for writing, Zora sees a future in storytelling to promote social justice.</p><p><strong>Anya Nyman</strong> is a current sophomore at Scripps College (Claremont, CA), currently studying History and Africana Studies. She joined the Wende student council in 2023 and is excited to add to the work the council has already done. Her academic interests include anticolonialism, twentieth-century West and Central African history, and international histories of and from the Global South.</p><p><strong>Lexi Tooley</strong> is a current freshman at Howard University majoring in Art History and Political Science, and minoring in Chinese Language and Culture. She is originally from Los Angeles, California, and has been working with the Wende museum for the past year. She looks forward to continuing the search for truth through these student panels, as well as through learning about and from the curated art currently on display at the Wende.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5009d8be590b" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/vatmh/the-political-mandate-of-the-arts-recaps-by-the-student-council-5009d8be590b">The Political Mandate of the Arts: Recaps by the Student Council</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/vatmh">vatmh</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Division Everywhere? Christoph Bieber at the Transatlantic Media Forum]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/vatmh/division-everywhere-christoph-bieber-at-the-transatlantic-media-forum-31ca4dd1269e?source=rss-2fdb0b3df75f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/31ca4dd1269e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[division]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[midterms]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[germany]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transatlantic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Mann House]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Oct 2022 21:57:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-28T22:07:44.570Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>On September 8, 2022 Thomas Mann Fellow &amp; political scientist Christoph Bieber opened the </em><a href="https://www.1014.nyc/events/transatlantic-media-forum"><em>Transatlantic Media Forum</em></a><em> in New York at </em><a href="https://www.1014.nyc/"><em>1014</em></a><em> with remarks about the main topic of the conference “Democracy Disrupted: Ever More Divided?” — “Division” functioned as the leitmotif of the event, where an international group of journalists, scholars and activists discussed different aspects of the current global mediascape. In the U.S., a polarized political public sphere divides the country in two distinct and clearly separated segments, colored “blue” and “red.” Meanwhile in Europe, the Russian assault on Ukraine sheds light on divisions all over the continent — pro-Ukrainian voices are countered by pro-Russian interventions, revealing sharp trenches in national public discourses and debates. And then, there is a divide between the analogue and the digital — characterizing the habits of older and younger generations of media users.</em> <em>Bieber kicked off the conference with a very personal account of selected experiences from his time at the Thomas Mann House in Pacific Palisades. Describing a journey from the West Coast to the East, he describes some scenes where divisions in current U.S.-American everyday life are visible, tangible and — at least to the eye of a visitor from abroad — meaningful. Christoph Bieber´s opening keynote shares some thoughts on current issues before the upcoming midterm elections, reflecting the continuously polarized state of an ever more divided and heavily shaken union.</em></p><p><em>The Transatlantic Media Forum was organized by 1014 and the Institute for Media and Communication Policy, in collaboration with the M100 Sanssouci Colloquium and with generous support from Stiftung Mercator.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nu7MtaX3fbc2T2hBvfWWnA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Christoph Bieber at the Thomas Mann House in July 2022.</figcaption></figure><p>At first — thanks for having me! It´s a pleasure to join all of you here at the East Coast, I am honored to be part of this conference! And thanks again for the title “Division Everywhere”, which allows me to start literally anywhere…</p><p>But you will not be surprised that I choose my current workplace on the other side of the continent as a starting point to some of the divisions I was confronted with since the beginning of my fellowship at the Thomas Mann House. From there I will take you on a short journey, ending a few hundred miles south from here.</p><p>So, yes, this is a personal account, but it´s also an outcome of my fellowship — we shall engage in issues that are relevant on both sides of the Atlantic, and that´s what I am talking about. (Anyway: In Germany, we often expect things that are being discussed in the U.S will cross the ocean — the sooner or later.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lmIl-mvEzIzmnlI-shzgLQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>The </em><a href="https://www.1014.nyc/events/transatlantic-media-forum"><em>Transatlantic Media Forum</em></a><em> in New York at </em><a href="https://www.1014.nyc/"><em>1014</em></a><em> on Octoober 8.</em></figcaption></figure><p>“Division Everywhere” — Now let´s get started on 1550 N San Remo Drive, here stands the Thomas Mann House in Pacific Palisades. The Mann family decided to set up shop in a newly developed area called “The Riviera” with mostly Italianized street names (“it´s CaPRI, not Capri”), meanwhile dotted with mansions of different (and sometimes suspicious) styles. Today, it is a homogenous area, only slight differences between the super- and the super-super-rich people. But when you look closer, you will find a division here — because in the morning hours the neighborhood is quite busy. But it´s not the occasional movie star walking his dog or the tech entrepreneur doing her workout. It´s scores of gardeners, cleaners, plumbers, service workers of different kind flooding into the “Riviera” to fulfil their duties and to keep this part of town in shape. There is a food truck around, catering the workers with breakfast burritos, tacos and the like (right now, it´s Kikiz Food Service, also serving German scholars walking by).</p><p>Let´s move on and leave the Riviera — but not by car, as almost everyone here does, we take the bus. First, you have to walk for about 10 minutes down the hill (be careful, no sidewalks!) and then there is the 602-bus, connecting either to Pacific Palisades in the West or to UCLA, a 45-minute-ride to the East, into the City of Los Angeles. Of course, only once every hour, so better be on time. The bus has air conditioning, stable WIFI and a mask mandate. And it is almost empty. During daytime, you will travel with maybe 3 or 4 other patrons, in the evening, it might get a little more crowded — but also scary. Sooner or later, riding the bus (or one of the few trains of the light rail), you will encounter many of the “working poor,” and occasionally a drug user. I guess, the message is clear: L.A.´s traffic infrastructure or “Autopia” (how architectural historian Reyner Banham called it) is divided. In LA, you drive a car, period. And although public transport has to be improved for the 2028 Olympic Games, there is public dispute and lobbying against new rail tracks and bus connections.</p><p>Our little city tour continues, we leave the 602 for the 9 to Downtown Santa Monica Station and take the E-Line eastbound to DTLA. Then we switch to the rapid bus 720, and only 1 hour and 54 minutes later we arrive at Skid Row (to be fair: it is a 19 mile-trip, but by car, it usually takes about half an hour in off-peak traffic). In the shadow of the glass towers that mark LA´s most vertical part of the city, you will find the epitome of a division that currently fuels a lot of discussion in and around LA City Hall. During the pandemic, Skid Row became the nucleus of the housing crisis in Southern California. Entire blocks are still lined with tents, cardboard shelters and other constructions providing a little privacy and shade. This part of the city is especially hard to take, just half a mile away from bustling downtown and even closer to the new “arts district,” a gentrification hub with galleries, bars, boutiques and loft apartments. According to the 2020 “Homeless Count” for the City of Los Angeles, the number increased to more than 40.000 people experiencing homelessness or living in temporary shelters. Due to the pandemic, there was no count in 2021, the numbers for 2022 are slowly trickling in.</p><p>Of course, measures have been taken to improve the situation of the homeless — there are experiments with temporary housing, tiny homes, housing vouchers. Some of these initiatives have become subject of research during my stay at the Thomas Mann House: The City of LA and Los Angeles County make use of digital data and an innovation team at the Mayor´s office engages in new forms of providing shelter and temporary homes. Thus, a rather unexpected branch of “Smart City”-activities has developed, aiming to address homelessness with civic tech solutions. Nevertheless, the housing crisis is one of the most visible divisions one can encounter not only in Los Angeles, but also in San Francisco´s Tenderloin district or in the Downtown part of Seattle. And of course, this issue also is relevant elsewhere — my co-fellows Doris Kleilein and Friederike Meyer, two architects-turned-journalists researched housing policies after COVID-19 as a possible blueprint for activities in Germany.</p><p>Already speaking of other Cities in the West, our little journey continues — I skip the “county”-level (although there would be a climate/water/resources-division to mention) and continue to the state level. A quick glance towards Sacramento brings us to the political dimension of “Division Everywhere”: Gavin Newsom, current Governor of California, is testing the waters for a potential presidential campaign. The democratic-leaning “golden state” seems to be a good testbed for his ambitions, yet there are also ideological divisions around — let´s take Silicon Valley-icon Peter Thiel as one (of many) counterparts: the investor is known for his ultra-libertarian attitude, spoke at the 2016 Republican National Convention and now is supporting a number of republican candidates in the 2022 election cycle. Although there is no direct political conflict, both men can be seen as two sides of the political medal the Golden State still is.</p><p>If you want more direct political conflict — let´s move on to some other states, as there is plenty of “divisionist” rivalry unfolding on the way to the Midterm Elections in November. And I don´t mean political campaigns of democratic and republican candidates against each other. No, there is a much more subtle, but also much more dangerous antagonism around. The main battleground for this division is electoral law, which has turned out to be a battlefield as soon as the ballots in 2020 had been counted. Let´s take the “Badger State” as an example: The Wisconsin Elections Commission is responsible for organizing the electoral process and has oversight of the routines before, on and after election day. It is a bipartisan construct, with 3 members of each party — and yet, it is under siege by other political actors in the state. Republican gubernatorial candidates have turned on the commission, and even the Wisconsin Supreme Court got into play by banning drop boxes for early voting — overruling the decision of the commission to use this feature for expanding voter turnout. Similar schemes also apply in other states, take Ohio, Georgia, or Michigan. Radical Republicans, often bolstered by the former president, try to take over key positions in state administrations, such as Attorney General or Secretary of State. Their final goal is to get control over the voting process — we do know what redistricting and gerrymandering can do to election results, but this unfriendly takeover of institutions in the electoral process might go even farther. Here, “the platform of democracy” is at stake, to use the words of President Joe Biden.</p><p>When getting closer to Washington, the republican pursuit for institutional control of political institutions reveals another division — this time <em>within</em> the republican party. As Donald Trump continues to support candidates adapting his “agenda” he has fueled competition between “trumpist” and “moderate” republicans in the primaries — in some races this might lead to weaker candidates in the general election, not able to attract a broader electoral base on the republican side. Spurred by Trump´s interventions, there are a lot of un-experienced candidates in the field, who never have run for any office before. At the end, that might bring profit for some democrats, who could turn out successful although the overall political sentiment in one state is actually more republican-leaning. (Nevertheless, most polling sees an advantage for the republican party to re-take at least the House of Representatives.)</p><p>Finally, we arrived in Washington, where on November 8th the Midterm Elections will set the switches for the second half of president Bidens term — maybe he will face divided government, maybe not. When it comes to discussions about the overall political climate, the recent Supreme Court decision on Roe v Wade is seen as a pivotal moment that shifted support into the democrats´ direction. And there is more: legislative success of the Biden administration (think of the infrastructure and climate bills, the inflation reduction act, or student loans) and possible effects of the ongoing January 6th hearings add on to some serious electoral dynamics. Yet, there is still time until election day, and what we know from past elections is — we never know for sure.</p><p>As you might have noticed, I did not use the word “media” one single time. When talking about “division everywhere”, this also functions in a mediatized society. Let´s do this with two small <em>encores</em> to my opening remarks.</p><p>The idea of “divisions” can easily be transferred to the media landscape — with a usefual and valuable division of the mediasphere in Germany into a public service media side and a commercial media market. This model of the “two columns” is still considerably healthy, although the “öffentlich-rechtliche Rundfunk” is going through a severe crisis — self-induced and close to something one might call “institutional corruption” (Lawrence Lessig) it is fueling the debate about the future of this allocation. In comparison to the U.S., where we can see the effects of a widely polarized, almost entirely market-oriented mediascape, the importance of public service media seems inevitable, yet it has to adapt to the affordances of digital transformation.</p><p>And finally, I would like to add one thought about a special kind of public sphere, that is desperately needed in the next couple of months. As the British media studies scholar Martin Moore has pointed out, there is a need for “a new electoral public sphere” that secures information about candidates, parties and the voting process and thus contributes to a healthy public discussion before individual political decisions are being made. Many of the divisions I have been talking about indicate the difficulties for political actors to ensure the integrity of the electoral process. When members of one political party try to get hold of key positions and aim to turn formerly neutral institutions into partisan power centers, it is time to put this moves and schemes under scrutiny and enable a public discussion and protest. This “Plot against America” has to be stopped.</p><p><strong><em>Christoph Bieber</em></strong><em>, born 1970 in Laubach/Hesse is Professor of Political Science at the NRW School of Governance, University of Duisburg-Essen, Germany. The position is funded by the Johann-Wilhelm-Welker-Stiftung. His main area of research is ethics in political management and society. Christoph Bieber has published widely on the effects of online communication for political actors, a special focus is addressing the effects of digitalization for the US political system. Since 2018 he has been delegated to the Center for Advanced Internet Studies (CAIS) in Bochum, where as a research professor he currently directs the program “Digital Democratic Innovations“ that runs from 2021 until 2026. On Twitter he is known as </em><a href="https://mobile.twitter.com/drbieber"><em>@drbieber</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=31ca4dd1269e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/vatmh/division-everywhere-christoph-bieber-at-the-transatlantic-media-forum-31ca4dd1269e">Division Everywhere? Christoph Bieber at the Transatlantic Media Forum</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/vatmh">vatmh</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Division Everywhere? Christoph Bieber at the Transatlantic Media Forum]]></title>
            <link>https://vatmh.medium.com/division-everywhere-christoph-bieber-at-the-transatlantic-media-forum-27a086c895db?source=rss-2fdb0b3df75f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/27a086c895db</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transatlantic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[midterms]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[division]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Mann House]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Oct 2022 20:58:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-28T20:58:42.377Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>On September 8, 2022 Thomas Mann Fellow &amp; political scientist Christoph Bieber opened the </em><a href="https://www.1014.nyc/events/transatlantic-media-forum"><em>Transatlantic Media Forum</em></a><em> in New York at </em><a href="https://www.1014.nyc/"><em>1014</em></a><em> with remarks about the main topic of the conference “Democracy Disrupted: Ever More Divided?” — “division” functioned as the leitmotif of the event, where an international group of journalists, scholars and activists discussed different aspects of the current global mediascape. In the U.S., a polarized political public sphere divides the country in two distinct and clearly separated segments, colored “blue” and “red.” Meanwhile in Europe, the Russian assault on Ukraine sheds light on divisions all over the continent — pro-Ukrainian voices are countered by pro-Russian interventions, revealing sharp trenches in national public discourses and debates. And then, there is a divide between the analogue and the digital — characterizing the habits of older and younger generations of media users.</em> <em>Bieber kicked off the conference with a very personal account of selected experiences from his time at the Thomas Mann House in Pacific Palisades. Describing a journey from the West Coast to the East, he describes some scenes where divisions in current U.S.-American everyday life are visible, tangible and — at least to the eye of a visitor from abroad — meaningful. Documenting Bieber´s opening keynote via the Blog of the Thomas Mann House we share some thoughts on current issues before the upcoming midterm elections, reflecting the continuously polarized state of an ever more divided and heavily shaken union.</em></p><p><em>The Transatlantic Media Forum was organized by 1014 and the Institute for Media and Communication Policy, in collaboration with the M100 Sanssouci Colloquium and with generous support from Stiftung Mercator.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nu7MtaX3fbc2T2hBvfWWnA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Christoph Bieber at the Thomas Mann House in July 2022.</figcaption></figure><p>At first — thanks for having me! It´s a pleasure to join all of you here at the East Coast, I am honored to be part of this conference! And thanks again for the title “Division Everywhere”, which allows me to start literally anywhere…</p><p>But you will not be surprised that I choose my current workplace on the other side of the continent as a starting point to some of the divisions I was confronted with since the beginning of my fellowship at the Thomas Mann House. From there I will take you on a short journey, ending a few hundred miles south from here.</p><p>So, yes, this is a personal account, but it´s also an outcome of my fellowship — we shall engage in issues that are relevant on both sides of the Atlantic, and that´s what I am talking about. (Anyway: In Germany, we often expect things that are being discussed in the U.S will cross the ocean — the sooner or later.)</p><p>“Division Everywhere” — Now let´s get started on 1550 N San Remo Drive, here stands the Thomas Mann House in Pacific Palisades. The Mann family decided to set up shop in a newly developed area called “The Riviera” with mostly Italianized street names (“it´s CaPRI, not Capri”), meanwhile dotted with mansions of different (and sometimes suspicious) styles. Today, it is a homogenous area, only slight differences between the super- and the super-super-rich people. But when you look closer, you will find a division here — because in the morning hours the neighborhood is quite busy. But it´s not the occasional movie star walking his dog or the tech entrepreneur doing her workout. It´s scores of gardeners, cleaners, plumbers, service workers of different kind flooding into the “Riviera” to fulfil their duties and to keep this part of town in shape. There is a food truck around, catering the workers with breakfast burritos, tacos and the like (right now, it´s Kikiz Food Service, also serving German scholars walking by).</p><p>Let´s move on and leave the Riviera — but not by car, as almost everyone here does, we take the bus. First, you have to walk for about 10 minutes down the hill (be careful, no sidewalks!) and then there is the 602-bus, connecting either to Pacific Palisades in the West or to UCLA, a 45-minute-ride to the East, into the City of Los Angeles. Of course, only once every hour, so better be on time. The bus has air conditioning, stable WIFI and a mask mandate. And it is almost empty. During daytime, you will travel with maybe 3 or 4 other patrons, in the evening, it might get a little more crowded — but also scary. Sooner or later, riding the bus (or one of the few trains of the light rail), you will encounter many of the “working poor,” and occasionally a drug user. I guess, the message is clear: L.A.´s traffic infrastructure or “Autopia” (how architectural historian Reyner Banham called it) is divided. In LA, you drive a car, period. And although public transport has to be improved for the 2028 Olympic Games, there is public dispute and lobbying against new rail tracks and bus connections.</p><p>Our little city tour continues, we leave the 602 for the 9 to Downtown Santa Monica Station and take the E-Line eastbound to DTLA. Then we switch to the rapid bus 720, and only 1 hour and 54 minutes later we arrive at Skid Row (to be fair: it is a 19 mile-trip, but by car, it usually takes about half an hour in off-peak traffic). In the shadow of the glass towers that mark LA´s most vertical part of the city, you will find the epitome of a division that currently fuels a lot of discussion in and around LA City Hall. During the pandemic, Skid Row became the nucleus of the housing crisis in Southern California. Entire blocks are still lined with tents, cardboard shelters and other constructions providing a little privacy and shade. This part of the city is especially hard to take, just half a mile away from bustling downtown and even closer to the new “arts district,” a gentrification hub with galleries, bars, boutiques and loft apartments. According to the 2020 “Homeless Count” for the City of Los Angeles, the number increased to more than 40.000 people experiencing homelessness or living in temporary shelters. Due to the pandemic, there was no count in 2021, the numbers for 2022 are slowly trickling in.</p><p>Of course, measures have been taken to improve the situation of the homeless — there are experiments with temporary housing, tiny homes, housing vouchers. Some of these initiatives have become subject of research during my stay at the Thomas Mann House: The City of LA and Los Angeles County make use of digital data and an innovation team at the Mayor´s office engages in new forms of providing shelter and temporary homes. Thus, a rather unexpected branch of “Smart City”-activities has developed, aiming to address homelessness with civic tech solutions. Nevertheless, the housing crisis is one of the most visible divisions one can encounter not only in Los Angeles, but also in San Francisco´s Tenderloin district or in the Downtown part of Seattle. And of course, this issue also is relevant elsewhere — my co-fellows Doris Kleilein and Friederike Meyer, two architects-turned-journalists researched housing policies after COVID-19 as a possible blueprint for activities in Germany.</p><p>Already speaking of other Cities in the West, our little journey continues — I skip the “county”-level (although there would be a climate/water/resources-division to mention) and continue to the state level. A quick glance towards Sacramento brings us to the political dimension of “Division Everywhere”: Gavin Newsom, current Governor of California, is testing the waters for a potential presidential campaign. The democratic-leaning “golden state” seems to be a good testbed for his ambitions, yet there are also ideological divisions around — let´s take Silicon Valley-icon Peter Thiel as one (of many) counterparts: the investor is known for his ultra-libertarian attitude, spoke at the 2016 Republican National Convention and now is supporting a number of republican candidates in the 2022 election cycle. Although there is no direct political conflict, both men can be seen as two sides of the political medal the Golden State still is.</p><p>If you want more direct political conflict — let´s move on to some other states, as there is plenty of “divisionist” rivalry unfolding on the way to the Midterm Elections in November. And I don´t mean political campaigns of democratic and republican candidates against each other. No, there is a much more subtle, but also much more dangerous antagonism around. The main battleground for this division is electoral law, which has turned out to be a battlefield as soon as the ballots in 2020 had been counted. Let´s take the “Badger State” as an example: The Wisconsin Elections Commission is responsible for organizing the electoral process and has oversight of the routines before, on and after election day. It is a bipartisan construct, with 3 members of each party — and yet, it is under siege by other political actors in the state. Republican gubernatorial candidates have turned on the commission, and even the Wisconsin Supreme Court got into play by banning drop boxes for early voting — overruling the decision of the commission to use this feature for expanding voter turnout. Similar schemes also apply in other states, take Ohio, Georgia, or Michigan. Radical Republicans, often bolstered by the former president, try to take over key positions in state administrations, such as Attorney General or Secretary of State. Their final goal is to get control over the voting process — we do know what redistricting and gerrymandering can do to election results, but this unfriendly takeover of institutions in the electoral process might go even farther. Here, “the platform of democracy” is at stake, to use the words of President Joe Biden.</p><p>When getting closer to Washington, the republican pursuit for institutional control of political institutions reveals another division — this time <em>within</em> the republican party. As Donald Trump continues to support candidates adapting his “agenda” he has fueled competition between “trumpist” and “moderate” republicans in the primaries — in some races this might lead to weaker candidates in the general election, not able to attract a broader electoral base on the republican side. Spurred by Trump´s interventions, there are a lot of un-experienced candidates in the field, who never have run for any office before. At the end, that might bring profit for some democrats, who could turn out successful although the overall political sentiment in one state is actually more republican-leaning. (Nevertheless, most polling sees an advantage for the republican party to re-take at least the House of Representatives.)</p><p>Finally, we arrived in Washington, where on November 8th the Midterm Elections will set the switches for the second half of president Bidens term — maybe he will face divided government, maybe not. When it comes to discussions about the overall political climate, the recent Supreme Court decision on Roe v Wade is seen as a pivotal moment that shifted support into the democrats´ direction. And there is more: legislative success of the Biden administration (think of the infrastructure and climate bills, the inflation reduction act, or student loans) and possible effects of the ongoing January 6th hearings add on to some serious electoral dynamics. Yet, there is still time until election day, and what we know from past elections is — we never know for sure.</p><p>As you might have noticed, I did not use the word “media” one single time. When talking about “division everywhere”, this also functions in a mediatized society. Let´s do this with two small <em>encores</em> to my opening remarks.</p><p>The idea of “divisions” can easily be transferred to the media landscape — with a usefual and valuable division of the mediasphere in Germany into a public service media side and a commercial media market. This model of the “two columns” is still considerably healthy, although the “öffentlich-rechtliche Rundfunk” is going through a severe crisis — self-induced and close to something one might call “institutional corruption” (Lawrence Lessig) it is fueling the debate about the future of this allocation. In comparison to the U.S., where we can see the effects of a widely polarized, almost entirely market-oriented mediascape, the importance of public service media seems inevitable, yet it has to adapt to the affordances of digital transformation.</p><p>And finally, I would like to add one thought about a special kind of public sphere, that is desperately needed in the next couple of months. As the British media studies scholar Martin Moore has pointed out, there is a need for “a new electoral public sphere” that secures information about candidates, parties and the voting process and thus contributes to a healthy public discussion before individual political decisions are being made. Many of the divisions I have been talking about indicate the difficulties for political actors to ensure the integrity of the electoral process. When members of one political party try to get hold of key positions and aim to turn formerly neutral institutions into partisan power centers, it is time to put this moves and schemes under scrutiny and enable a public discussion and protest. This “Plot against America” has to be stopped.</p><p><strong><em>Christoph Bieber</em></strong><em>, born 1970 in Laubach/Hesse is Professor of Political Science at the NRW School of Governance, University of Duisburg-Essen, Germany. The position is funded by the Johann-Wilhelm-Welker-Stiftung. His main area of research is ethics in political management and society. Christoph Bieber has published widely on the effects of online communication for political actors, a special focus is addressing the effects of digitalization for the US political system. Since 2018 he has been delegated to the Center for Advanced Internet Studies (CAIS) in Bochum, where as a research professor he currently directs the program “Digital Democratic Innovations“ that runs from 2021 until 2026. On Twitter he is known as </em><a href="https://mobile.twitter.com/drbieber"><em>@drbieber</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=27a086c895db" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Thomas Mann Invented Podcasting]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/vatmh/when-thomas-mann-invented-podcasting-4a885e539f21?source=rss-2fdb0b3df75f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4a885e539f21</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fellows]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[podcast]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bieber]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thomas-mann]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Mann House]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Aug 2022 17:01:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-15T17:02:42.791Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>For the Thomas Mann House Blog, 2022 Fellow Christoph Bieber explores the Mann family’s relationship to media and how they made use of modern technologies. He suggests Thomas Mann’s famous anti-fascist BBC radio speeches which he addressed to the German public during World War II can be seen as an early form of today’s podcast. Christoph Bieber, a research professor at the Center for Advanced Internet Studies (CAIS) in Bochum, where he directs the program “Digital Democratic Innovations”, has published widely on the effects of online communication for political actors and dedicates his time at the Thomas Mann House to doing research on moral questions related to digitalization of urban spaces or so-called “smart cities.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XHy_hQqo-XpjmPlh0FMeqA.png" /><figcaption>Thomas Mann in his apartment in Munich looking at his gramophone. 1932. Source: Bundesarchiv, Bild 183-R15883 / Unknown author / CC-BY-SA 3.0, CC BY-SA 3.0 DE, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption></figure><p>The Twitter account <a href="https://twitter.com/DailyMann">@DailyMann</a> is currently causing a stir in Germany. Felix Lindner, a germanist from Berlin, is publishing what seems like randomly selected excerpts from Mann’s diaries every day. “Coffee from new own-cup,” “Strong mucus secretion. Should probably not smoke” or “Perplexity and daily enervation after 3 hours of work” are typical tweets delivered to more than ten thousand followers. The number of retweets, mentions and replies is growing steadily. The success is certainly not entirely coincidental, because Lindner is a member of the DFG Research Training Group “Small Forms” and knows what he is doing. In his dissertation, he is researching, “The Preparation of the Work: Body Protocols and Writing Optimization Around 1900.” His collection of “diet plans, hygiene rules, constitution checks or endurance precautions” serves to develop a concept of literary efficiency — according to a central thesis of the research work. With this, Lindner quite obviously hits a nerve, because “self-improvement” is also a topic of our time.</p><figure><img alt="Screenshot of of a post from the @DailyMann Twitter account reading: Habe wieder begonnen, morgens nackt ein wenig zu turnen.” (20.7.1934) English translation: “Started again to do a little gymnastics in the morning naked.”" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wssvxCwNB31g-AJgtzDjaA.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://twitter.com/DailyMann">@DailyMann</a> posts short snippets from Thomas Mann’s diaries. An excerpt from July 20, 1934 reads “Started again to do a little gymnastics in the morning naked.”</figcaption></figure><p>Thomas Mann is not usually considered to be an expert of the “small form”, but this kind of access to his diaries shows that the Nobel laureate can be embedded in current research and media contexts in unexpected ways. Interestingly, this also applies to another type of media that has gained popularity in recent years: Mann can also be connected to podcasts — digital audio content that is usually conceived as a series and can be subscribed to via corresponding online services. With a more daring thesis, one could claim that Thomas Mann helped to develop and implement a very early precursor of this content — maybe he was podcasting “avant la lettre.”</p><p>This refers — of course — to the 55 radio speeches that Thomas Mann addressed to a German audience between 1940 and 1945. With the broadcasts titled <em>Deutsche Hörer!</em> (<em>Listen Germany!</em>), the exiled man of letters produced statements between five and eight minutes long, with which he tried to reach the German population during wartime. Unlike today, however, recording and distribution were much more complicated. At first, Mann merely wrote the texts at his desk in Pacific Palisades, sent them to London, and a “German-speaking employee of the BBC” read them out for broadcast. Transatlantic transmission at that time was still by telegram, and the first speech was “cabled” to London as a 500-word message. Originally, Erika Mann, the Nobel laureate’s daughter, who worked for the BBC as a war correspondent, had wanted to do the narration, but the broadcaster preferred the man of letters himself to provide the voice.</p><p>And so, from March 1941, Thomas Mann took over the recording himself. At the recording department of NBC on Vine Street in Hollywood, a record was produced as a buffer and sent to the East Coast. In New York, the soundtrack was transmitted by telephone to London, where it was pressed onto vinyl a second time. Only then were the messages broadcast via longwave so that the German “Volksempfänger” could be reached — with a shortwave transmission, BBC officials also feared hostile interference. Due to this pre-digital workaround, the quality of the transmisson suffered considerably. Yet, the preserved speeches make it clear that Mann was very aware of his effect — especially the sound of his own voice. The cadence is even and self-confident, the enunciations precise, the mockery and the many sarcastic remarks against Hitler and his henchmen hit exactly. And of course, the language is remarkable — anything else would be surprising for a Nobel Prize winner. Thomas Mann lived up to his reputation as an influencer of world-class format.</p><figure><img alt="Historic postcard showing NBC studios on Vine Street in Hollywood, a modernist office building." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RM9L1mS-LCyQTrP_pazL4A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Historic postcard of NBC studios on Vine Street in Hollywood. Image: Western Publishing &amp; Novelty Company, Los Angeles. Uploaded by We hope at en.wikipedia, Public domain, via <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Radio_City_West.JPG">Wikimedia Commons</a></figcaption></figure><p>In his book <em>Thomas Mann’s War</em>, historian Tobias Boes devotes a long passage to the speeches — under the appropriately chosen title, <em>The Voice of Germany</em>. Right from the first sentence of the first speech in October 1940, Mann makes his point: “A German writer speaks to you, whose work and person are ostracized by your rulers and whose books, even if they deal with the most German of things, with Goethe, for example, can now only speak to foreign free peoples in their language, while they must remain mute and unknown to you.” Speaking in the third person may at first sound like restraint (and in fact the opening speech was not delivered by Mann himself, after all), but right after that it becomes clear: Here is a German author who is known to the world, whose works find a huge audience, and who takes on the Nazis. Even the reference to Goethe as the “other” great poet is by no means accidental — we might call this “Mannsplaining.“</p><p>Mann is also aware of the special nature of his words conveyed through the media. In his article on the Mann family’s broadcasting strategies, Robert Galitz quotes him: “Today, however, this audience to which I am speaking is not only spatially separated from me, but it is removed from me in time, and I am speaking to a future audience — into time. That’s the fantastic and eccentric almost, I want to say, that I feel in this situation.” Lecture tours with large audiences in his mother language had become impossible due to exile — this break with the German reading public should not be underestimated, especially in the early days of mass media. Although matured and definded by the written word and having achieved world fame, Mann recognizes very precisely the effects of his messages conveyed by speech: “The feeling I had then (at the first radio recording in 1929 on the occasion of a ceremonial speech for Gotthold Ephraim Lessing) is repeated today to an intensified degree. I experienced it then for the first time that the audience to whom I was speaking was not in sensual and social presence before me, not gathered together by the four walls of a hall, but that they were invisibly, inaudibly scattered far over the whole world listening to my words, which came to me from time to time as I spoke.” In this respect, Mann’s radio broadcasts also function directly as a counterpart to the Nazis’ radio strategy of using the <em>Volksempfänger</em> as a propaganda tool. The Nobel Prize winner confronts the Führer on the same media terrain.</p><figure><img alt="Historic photo from October 1938 showing Gau Propaganda Leader Wächter distributing Volksempfängers to the German public." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/799/1*pFh4u4LKG8XBcGCttOLg_g.jpeg" /><figcaption>On the occasion of the birthday of Reichsminister Joseph Goebbels in October 1938, <em>Volksempfängers were distributed to the German public. </em>The purpose of the <em>Volksempfänger</em> program was to make radio reception technology (as a Nazi propaganda means) affordable to the general public. Image: <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Bundesarchiv_Bild_183-H14243,_Berlin,_Verteilung_von_500_Radios_(Volksempf%C3%A4nger).jpg">Bundesarchiv, Image 183-H14243</a> / Nau / <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/de/deed.en">CC-BY-SA 3.0</a>, via Wikimedia Commons.</figcaption></figure><p>Tobias Boes is also convinced that the special mix of content, presentation and technical distribution increases the impact of the speeches, “Overlain with static, Mann´s disembodied voice, which he exploited to such great rhetorical effect in his messianic diction, was a direct outcome of the transnational and transmedial processes by which military matériel was shuttled from one end of the world to the other during the early 1940s.”</p><p>In stark contrast to the “messianic” elements of his speeches and the tone, which at times shifts into preaching, are the striking insults for Hitler and his “quislings” from the leadership: the “Austrian smear comedian,” the “hollow zero” is a “badly turned out individual” with a “misshapen brain.” Of course, Mann brings bitterness about his own life situation into play here; he holds Hitler directly responsible for the situation as a writer silenced in exile and deprived of his reading audience.</p><p>The speeches also feature other recurring components. For example, Mann comments on current war events, denounces Nazi atrocities, or laments the victims among resistance groups. He refers to speeches by U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt, who is introduced as a counter-figure and democratic hero. In general, the U.S. (and Great Britain) are seen by Mann as prime examples of democracy, thus reflecting Germany’s current role as a stronghold of evil in the world. In the process, Thomas Mann also attempts to shed light on Nazi propaganda and describes the reality behind glossed-over or exuberant messages about the course of the war to his radio audience. Mann exposes the misinformation and disinformation policies of the Nazi regime.</p><figure><img alt="Photo shows President Franklin D. Roosevelt and Prime Minister Winston Churchill sitting and talking at a conference table with coffee cups in front of them at the Yalta Conference 1945." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7ijaozXSWB_VOqMP_4MQgg.jpeg" /><figcaption>President Franklin D. Roosevelt and Prime Minister Winston Churchill at the Yalta Conference 1945 discussing Europe’s post-war reorganization. Image: National Museum of the U.S. Navy, Public domain, via <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:LC-USZ62-56505_(24669550296).jpg">Wikimedia Commons</a></figcaption></figure><p>It is also interesting to note that Mann’s reflection on radio takes place just as Bertolt Brecht publishes several texts dealing with “radio as an apparatus of communication.” Indeed, Brecht’s reflections from around 1930 show a certain proximity to current media constellations with a more active audience, while Mann’s perspective emphasizes the speech act (and its author, of course). In the historical run-up to today’s media configurations, Brecht is definitely following the right track — however, his reflections are largely denied a practical influence at the time, which would certainly have pleased Thomas Mann.</p><p>Yet, can the series of <em>Listen, Germany!</em> really be called a forerunner of today’s podcasts? If you take the digitally automated subscription structure as a yardstick, then certainly not. However, the differentiation between content, production and distribution that can be seen in the historical example can also be found in a similar form in the emergence of modern podcast formats in the early 2000s. There also was an interplay of provided audio content and a new type of technical distribution system that led to an auditive innovation. The starting point were journalist Christopher Lydon’s interviews with blogger and software developer Dave Winer, writes Katharina Lührmann in her study on <em>Podcasts as a Space for Political Media Communication</em>. But it was the connection with another step of automation by MTV host and broadcaster Adam Curry that laid the foundation for the podcast boom. Curry developed software that searches for audio files, downloads them from the web, and transfers them to a music management system. This process heavily relied on products from a company now headquartered just a few hundred miles north of Mann’s home is another story. There is a key difference here in the technical setting — while modern podcasts are subscribed to from the receiving end, this was not yet possible in terms of transmission technology in the 1940s. The Mann-NBC-BBC production network remained a mass media unit limited to the transmission of audio signals — and yet here we can already find some components of a globally successful variant of the production of publicity today.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/381/1*znS4Gcu1om_pi1jKnZF3Fg.jpeg" /><figcaption>MTV host and podcaster Adam Curry, 2006. Image: Nick Starr, <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0">CC BY-SA 2.0</a>, via <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Adam_Curry_portrait.jpg">Wikimedia Commons</a></figcaption></figure><p>The media history of political crisis and war communication still continues to be written. Since February, the format of the mediated speech has been frighteningly up-to-date even in today’s wartime, and it has long since ceased to be confined to the soundtrack. It is probably worthwhile to understand the video messages of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Selenskyj as a similar source, even if the author is not a Nobel laureate in literature, but argues as the President of Ukraine. For the most part, Selenskyj has been addressing other heads of state and government leaders of important allies since the beginning of the war. Nonetheless, there are also speeches addressed directly to the Russian people, and these are also about the correction of propaganda and disinformation, describing atrocities in Putin’s name, and developing a narrative that seeks to drive a rift between the Russian people and the Kremlin. Unlike Mann, Selenskyj does not have to overcome complicated media disruptions, but can draw on a digital infrastructure that functions even in times of war. It would be exciting to see what use Thomas Mann would have made of today’s media environments to mark his position in public discourse. Print, radio, and television would probably have been crucial elements in a comprehensive platform strategy of a highly visible media family.</p><p><em>Literature mentioned</em>:</p><p>Boes, Tobias (2019): <em>Thomas Mann´s War. Literature, Politics, and the World Republic of Letters</em>. Ithaca/London: Cornell University Press.</p><p>Brecht, Bertolt (2002): <em>Radiotheorie: Dialektik von Produktivkraftentwicklung und Produktionsverhältnissen</em>. In: Helmes, G./Köster, W. (Hg.): Texte zur Medientheorie. Stuttgart: Reclam. S. 148–154.</p><p>Galitz, Robert (2018): <em>A Family against a dictatorship. Die Rundfunkstrategien der Familie Mann</em>, in: Raulff, U./Strittmatter, E. (Hg.): Thomas Mann in Amerika. Marbach, 2018. S. 40–60, hier S. 42f.</p><p>Lührmann, Katharina (2019): <em>Podcasts als Raum politisch-medialer Kommunikation</em>. Essen: Tectum.</p><p>Mann, Thomas (1987): <em>Deutsche Hörer! Radiosendungen nach Deutschland aus den Jahren 1940 bis 1945</em>. Frankfurt/M.: Fischer Taschenbuch Verlag.</p><p><strong><em>Christoph Bieber</em></strong><em>, born 1970 in Laubach/Hesse is Professor of Political Science at the NRW School of Governance, University of Duisburg-Essen, Germany. The position is funded by the Johann-Wilhelm-Welker-Stiftung. His main area of research is ethics in political management and society. Christoph Bieber has published widely on the effects of online communication for political actors, a special focus is addressing the effects of digitalization for the US political system. Since 2018 he has been delegated to the Center for Advanced Internet Studies (CAIS) in Bochum, where as a research professor he currently directs the program “Digital Democratic Innovations“ that runs from 2021 until 2026. On Twitter he is known as </em><a href="https://mobile.twitter.com/drbieber"><em>@drbieber</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4a885e539f21" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/vatmh/when-thomas-mann-invented-podcasting-4a885e539f21">When Thomas Mann Invented Podcasting</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/vatmh">vatmh</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Transatlantic Dialogue on Trust in Museums: Sunhild Kleingärtner and Scott Miller in Conversation]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/vatmh/a-transatlantic-dialogue-on-trust-in-museums-sunhild-kleing%C3%A4rtner-and-scott-miller-in-conversation-e3969677a758?source=rss-2fdb0b3df75f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e3969677a758</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[museums]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-discourse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transatlantic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dialogue]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trust]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Mann House]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Jun 2022 15:40:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-17T15:54:39.128Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Museums as public institutions play an important role in the presenting, conserving, and shaping of cultural narratives. In today’s politically charged times, it is not easy for museums to navigate the political discourses that are quickly and constantly changing. At the same time, due to a focus on transparent provenance, research and educational programs, museums still enjoy a great deal of public trust today according to a recent study by the American Alliance of Museums. Thomas Mann Fellow Sunhild Kleingärtner, an archaeologist with museum-based expertise, met Scott Miller, the Director for Research Management and Innovation at the Smithsonian Institution — the world’s largest research museum complex — at the library of the Thomas Mann House to discuss political issues pertinent to the question of museums as trusted institutions: Is it even possible to think of museums as inherently nonpolitical? What are key factors that foster trust in museums?</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/938/1*I8UGJrpmzjxcZXqfU25zKQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Scott Miller and Sunhild Kleingärtner at the Thomas Mann House, Pacific Palisades. Photo: Andreas Nitsche.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Sunhild Kleingärtner</strong>: Our conversation today centers around the political dimension of museums and its connection to public trust in cultural institutions. We are sitting here in the former office of Thomas Mann, a prominent German political figure during the 20th century. Having a look around you see Thomas Mann’s bookshelves with his original books, that remind you of him as a professional writer. Having another look around you notice the way the inside of this office protects you from everything outside, such as the lovely Californian sun which could distract you from work, the smell from the lemon tree outside, and some thought-provoking conversations on the terrace. It’s a so-called ‘closed-shop,’ and I think this is a great link to start our conversation about public trust in the institution of the museum in the U.S. and Germany Since Thomas Mann was a political man, it is important to talk about the political dimensions of museums related to trust. We know the world of museums is huge and we cannot talk about all types of museums and that is why we are focusing solely on research museums [<em>The term research museum refers to museums that conduct research to provide insight on scientific processes to the public</em>]. I come from the Leibniz Association of the Leibniz Research Museum in Germany and you, Scott, are a representative of the largest research institution and museum organization in the world. I would like to begin by looking at the pictures that depict the January 6, 2021 insurrection at the Capitol. It was an attack on democracy and it shows mistrust in politics, or rather democracy and its instruments. According to surveys on both sides of the Atlantic, trust in governments and politicians is not very high at the moment, which is leading me to my first question. These signs of distrust in politics can also influence the public’s trust in museums. Now, most of the Smithsonian museums are very prominently situated between the White House and the Capitol since they are located on the National Mall. What is your opinion on this issue of fading public trust in relation to museums and their politics?</p><p><strong>Scott Miller</strong>: It is interesting having a transatlantic dialogue on the Pacific but it feels good because I grew up two hours up the coast from here in Santa Barbara, so it is nice to be back in California. As you have said, there is a level of distrust in institutions of all kinds in the United States that is at a new level especially in my lifetime. That stands not just for political institutions but also the medical institutions, or science in general. We saw a huge distrust of basic medical science during the COVID pandemic, in a way that is relatively new in the United States. But I think museums and libraries still have a fairly high trust from the American public. The level of trust has probably gone down from what it once was, but I do not think it is going down as much as the distrust in political institutions and science in general. At the Smithsonian, we try very hard to not be seen as a political entity and to stay clear of politics. However, it is challenging because the Smithsonian is much more than the iconic museums on the National Mall in Washington D.C. Yet that is how people identify us and identify <em>with</em> us. Being in the shadow of the Capitol, it is easy to be drawn into political arguments in Congress or elsewhere. We try very hard to be honest and direct in presenting the facts as we understand them but avoid advocating a particular side in political arguments. The English word “advocacy” has multiple meanings, but it has a specific meaning of “political advocacy” and even more specific than that, “lobbying,” or trying to affect political outcomes by influencing members of Congress. One of the other things that we have learned over the years, particularly with the Enola Gay incident [<em>The Enola Gay is the US aircraft that dropped the nuclear bomb on Hiroshima. The Enola Gay incident refers to the critiques on its exhibition value since it was the first weaponized nuclear technology used on human beings</em>], is how exhibitions can be seen in a negative light. Rick Potts, who is the head of the Smithsonian’s Human Origins Program at the National Museum of Natural History, explains how we try to not be objectionable or unnecessarily offensive to any potential stakeholders in the way we present the facts. For example, when dealing with human evolution, Potts’ team consulted very extensively with a variety of religious groups in their worldviews and how to present the scientific view in a way that, while they might not accept it, they would not find it offensive. In many of our exhibits and programs, there are alternative ways to look at the particular subject, so it is not easy in today’s world. However, we try to maintain that standard of pursuing impartial “truth.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/664/1*NBx49E432OXSbfuuZEfuOw.png" /><figcaption>Natural History Museum, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. / Library of Congress, Prints &amp; Photographs Division. Photo: Harris &amp; Ewing, [LC-H27- A-613 [P&amp;P]]</figcaption></figure><p><strong>SK</strong>: Although you are not advocating or lobbying, I think museums are not non-political places. In an ideal world, we should perhaps have two different levels or clear roles of political dimensions in museums that are separated from each other. On the one side we have the people within the institutions making the decisions, like the board of Regents at the Smithsonian or the advisory boards at the Leibniz research museums. We, as museums, do not want them to decide what kind of content we display in our exhibitions. We are the museum specialists while they carry the general direction and secure administrative processes. However, they are not the ones who decide what is shown and how to show it in detail. On the other side you have the visitors’ expectations making science museums relevant. In the National Museum of American History, I saw an exhibition that was named “Food in Transition,” and I think it was quite interesting who is eating what from where and how to show a political protest by eating a certain kind of food or not eating anything. Do you think one can understand and address these two political issues­­ — the museum boards and their visitors’ expectations — that are pertinent for museums?</p><p><strong>SM</strong>: We at the Smithsonian adhere to that concept of academic freedom of the curators and the people who are actually designing the exhibits and educational programs. But that is a delicate balance because if you have that trust and that responsibility, you have to use it well and respect the trust that the public and the governing body have given you. Then in turn, the governing body has to have the trust of the private funders as well as the government funding body — in this case, Congress — to prove that we are using the funds well. That is where we can get accidentally involved in political issues. With the public, that, too, is challenged because we do not only want to show them what they expect to see, but also what they do not necessarily expect, so we can give them an opportunity to learn something different. We just have to anticipate where particular issues might be controversial or political and make sure that we are presenting them in a fair and balanced way. That is getting more complex because of the political situation and because of America’s much needed and renewed national interest in addressing diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility issues. We are now more sensitive to a lot of those topics than we would have been historically.</p><p><strong>SK</strong>: There is a similar situation in Germany: We have a great responsibility due to the trust that is given to our institutions. The American Alliance of Museums published a study in March this year and they claimed that museums are highly trusted institutions. They say that the reason why trust is so high is because museums are seen as nonpolitical places. But when I talk to colleagues at museums in Germany, nobody wants to have ‘just a neutral place’; they want to send messages and take active part in forming society through scientific and scholarly questions, methods, and results. They want their museums to have an impact on the society to help people make good decisions for their own life. They want museums to matter in a relevant way for society by offering contextual information or backgrounds to issues which are also politically discussed. In comparison to the Enlightenment era when science provided impulses for developing society, whereas today, would you say research museums contextualize what research can mean in society? What is the role of science at the Smithsonian today compared to its beginnings?</p><p><strong>SM</strong>: I actually wonder if maybe we are defining the term ‘political’ in a slightly different way. It has something to do with that term “advocacy” as I defined earlier. We certainly want our exhibits and outreach to be relevant and get people to think about how they have been influenced by the world, how they are influencing the world, and how to make informed decisions. For example, when you think about green lifestyles or other healthy food decisions, we do want it to inform people’s choices.</p><p><strong>SK</strong>: This reminds me of the <em>Outbreak: Epidemics in a Connected World </em>[Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History, May 2018–October 2022] exhibition that focused on diseases and pandemics through history to now. This exhibition included background information on vaccinations, intended to combat conspiracies and negative perceptions surrounding vaccines in general.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/785/1*BOvwCYdnM0jbM4poEq-CEw.png" /><figcaption>Exhibit “Outbreak: Epidemics in a Connected World” at the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History / Photo: James Di Loreto, Lucia RM Martino &amp; Fred Cochard, Smithsonian</figcaption></figure><p><strong>SM</strong>: We launched our website that promoted vaccination, but it was more oriented towards providing information about vaccinations. It stopped short of taking an aggressive stance on vaccination and there was a lot of debate on how far to go with that topic. We are not the National Institute of Health or the CDC, so we left those advanced promotion roles to those organizations. There is a line we do not cross in trying to influence government policy in a particular way or working with the political agenda of a particular political party. But it can be a fine line in there because we do want Congress to be aware of what we are doing. We want our research to influence the best possible policy, but there are strict limits in how far we go to do that. When I say “political”, I mean that we do not enter into the political process in a strict sense. That is where advocacy — in the way I am using it — is strongly influenced by the political process as opposed to trying to educate people — whether they are the public or even members of Congress — about how they might think about things and why they ought to consider things in a particular way. It is a very tricky line, but we definitely want to influence the country, and the world, and help people make it a better place with the best information.</p><p><strong>SK</strong>: Unlike the Enlightenment era when we had no museum sciences, we have a lot of museum sciences today such as researching about exhibitions, preventative conservation, monitoring studies, provenance research and so on. I think questions have very much arisen in the last couple of years. For example, provenance research is federally funded, at least in Germany —</p><p><strong>SM</strong>: And here too.</p><p><strong>SK</strong>: — These issues are socially demanded by the society. In Germany, museums are requested to do provenance research to make sure that they do not have objects from unjust contacts not only from colonial times but from the Nazi regime or from the German Democratic Republic (“East Germany”). Doing provenance research means fostering trust not only on a visitors’ level but on a diplomatic level as well between countries. But there are many different interests and arguments of the museums — and not only the museums but also the cities — on why they should not restitute certain objects. This leads us to the very last question: would you agree to say that the more restitution that takes place in the political space, the more closely it establishes trust in the museums?</p><p><strong>SM</strong>: Yes, in the sense that the public needs to see that we are presenting and promoting what we believe is true and factual and just, regardless of what the political flavor of the month might be. We change political administrations at the federal level every four years, which could theoretically have a major influence on the topics that we display or promote at the Smithsonian. We try very hard for that not to be the case. It is also worth noting that yesterday, we announced a new ethical returns policy which is a big step for the Smithsonian as it is for museums in general. In modern times, we have always had the policy that if we had objects in our collections that had come to us illegally either in the country of origin or in the United States, we would return those to the appropriate owner, which is not always easy to determine. But we generally limit it to those sorts of specific legal issues. We have now said that we will consider returning materials to their “rightful owners” — assuming those can be determined — when there is a sort of appropriate ethical argument to be made. We do not have all the implementing policies in place yet but those are currently being developed. This came out of the issues surrounding the Benin bronzes [<em>The Benin Empire existed during the 11th century and was well-known for its man-made walls that were destroyed by British soldiers in 1897</em>].</p><p><strong>SK</strong>: All around the world the Benin bronzes plays a major role on the restitution.</p><p><strong>SM</strong>: It is a case of a sufficient magnitude that it tips the scale.</p><p><strong>SK</strong>: And it is a kind of indicator on how to deal with the Benin bronzes because you can compare between the U.S. and Germany. It is a kind of attitude on how to deal with the Benin bronzes.</p><p><strong>SM</strong>: I think those are the sort of big, high-level issues. Obviously, the other thing about trust is that, when you are a public institution like a museum, trust is hard to earn and easy to lose. But once you lose it, it is really hard to regain it. We have to keep that in mind as museums.</p><p><strong>SK</strong>: When I was at the Smithsonian in Washington, I learned that communication and leadership are the main important issues for fostering trust although it takes a lot of time. Thank you so much, Scott Miller. It was a pleasure to talk to you and thank you so much for coming.</p><p><strong>SM</strong>: My pleasure to be here. Thank you so much.</p><p><em>Edited &amp; Transcribed by: Emily Wysocki</em></p><p><strong>Scott Miller</strong> is the Director of Research Management and Innovation in the Office of the Under Secretary for Science and Research at the Smithsonian Institution. He has written and published over 230 publications and is the co-editor of four books, mostly on insect diversity and ecology, but also on bioinformatics and topics as diverse as ivory. His previous positions include Interim Director of Smithsonian Libraries and Archives, Deputy Under Secretary for Science, associate director for science at the National Zoological Park, and chairman of the departments of entomology and systematic biology at the National Museum of Natural History.</p><p><strong>Sunhild Kleingärtner</strong> is the outgoing Director of the German Maritime Museum/Leibniz Institute of Maritime History and Professor of Maritime History and Maritime Archaeology at the University of Bremen, and the incoming Director of the German Mining Museum/Leibniz-Research Museum of Georesources in Bochum. Her publications include her 2017 book, <em>Die Wikinger und ihre Schiffe</em> (Konrad Theiss Verlag) and a co-edited book entitled <em>Landscapes and Societies in Medieval Europe East of the Elbe. Interactions between Environmental Settings and Cultural Transformations </em>(Pontifical Institute of Medieval Studies) with Timothy P. Newfield, Sébastien Rossignol, and Donat Wehner. Sunhild Kleingärtner is a 2022 Thomas Mann Fellow.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e3969677a758" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/vatmh/a-transatlantic-dialogue-on-trust-in-museums-sunhild-kleing%C3%A4rtner-and-scott-miller-in-conversation-e3969677a758">A Transatlantic Dialogue on Trust in Museums: Sunhild Kleingärtner and Scott Miller in Conversation</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/vatmh">vatmh</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mithu Sanyal on Identity Struggles and Trust]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/vatmh/mithu-sanyal-on-identity-struggles-and-trust-4983d8811e44?source=rss-2fdb0b3df75f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4983d8811e44</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trust]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mithu-sanyal]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Mann House]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 Apr 2022 19:49:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-06T14:57:55.746Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Cultural studies scholar, journalist and author Dr. Mithu Sanyal is one of Germany’s most prolific voices on feminism, identity and postcolonial theory. In her interview with the Thomas Mann House Dr. Sanyal discusses racism and public trust in Germany, the role of the media and the state and what can be done to move forward.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WSb5i0zX6LSC19UkNy_fIQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Thomas Mann House: </strong>A few years ago you mentioned in <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/commentisfree/2020/mar/03/hanau-terror-attack-germany-racism-angela-merkel">an article for the Guardian</a> the ubiquity of the word “Ausländer” (foreigner) in Germany and asked: “How long do we have to live in Germany before we stop being foreigners?” Where does this racism and mistrust come from that upholds these categories even for second or third generation Germans?</p><p><strong>Mithu Sanyal: </strong>There is a specific situation in Germany, for example because we used to have a law that you could only become German if your father was German. This changed in the 1970s, and my mother was actually among the women who fought to reform this. So, honestly, my first memory is getting a German passport when I was three years old, because my mother was so incredibly relieved. And in the 2000s, laws were changed again so that people who live and work here can apply to become German. Many people protested, saying “they are not real, they are just passport-Germans.” — How ridiculous! They are not fictional Germans, they are real!</p><p>The other big issue in Germany is that we think Germany has always been a white country, which is not the case. Thinking that is actually the result of Fascism because so many people fled or were killed in Nazi-Germany and during the Second World War. That plays a big part in why our government has only now accepted the fact that we are a migration country. We produce a past that has never existed. If we really want to look back, let’s take a look at the turn of the millennium, the year 1000. The German Empress, Theophanu was a Byzantine princess and, basically, my skin tone: a person of color. Likewise, Thomas Mann’s mother was from Brazil. So Thomas Mann is mixed race. He knew that and his brother wrote about it, but we somehow erased this dimension from our view of Thomas Mann. And he has in some ways become the quintessential German author.</p><p>So yes, Germany’s situation is special. And yet, whenever we do any anti-racist work, we tend to import a lot of the theory from the United States, which themselves have a very specific situation.</p><p><strong>TMH: </strong>Is it a positive that we look to places where discourse might be more progressed in some ways? What can we learn from that? Or in how far do we need to find our own responses within the German context you just described?</p><p><strong>MS: </strong>I think it’s brilliant that we look to other countries. And the U.S. has developed a lot of research and theory, while it has never really been central to Germany’s political agenda. Even the word we use to talk about race is the English word, because “Rasse” (race) in German denotes a biological concept and does not carry the same meaning. These words did not develop and progress in the same way in Germany, because the Nazis were so keen on using them. <br> <br> So we produced a new German image that was unlike its past — not fully voluntarily, of course; we were forced to do it. But still, we looked at our past very critically. And growing up in a Germany that did that was special. But with all this talk about “Weltmeister im Erinnern” (world champions at remembering) it has only been recent that Germany is realizing that our memory has to include the German colonial past, has to include how we treated Sinti and Roma. We are finally able to give back cultural artifacts we stole from all over the world. Before it was legally impossible, even if we wanted to. These are all massive steps forward. But when you listen to the media, you think it got worse. Negative news is usually the only kind that’s regarded as news.</p><p>But to come back to your question, a lot of people have worked on these themes of racism and inclusion and have done a lot of research and activism in Germany. And I find it sad that that seems to be forgotten, that the anti-racist movement now knows more about what goes on in the U.S. than about the people who have fought for this here.</p><p><strong>TMH: </strong>You touched on the role of the media and our current news culture. In what ways does this proliferate certain stories and ideas more than others and shapes social perceptions and public trust?</p><p><strong>MS: </strong>There was a study done in Germany around media stories: people who are Muslims are most commonly mentioned in the media in connection with a crime. Only very rarely, in contrast, were they mentioned as individual people doing nice things. In Germany, if there was a crime, the media were not supposed to report about the nationality or the assumed race. That changed after the assaults on New Year’s Eve in Cologne in 2015, when media were massively accused of being biased because they omitted the perpetrators’ backgrounds. Since then, the probability that a crime is reported in the media and the perpetrator to be either a refugee or a Muslim increased drastically. For example, in 2016 a refugee had raped and murdered a woman in Freiburg, and at roughly the same time, a white German had raped his neighbor and murdered her. And I was reading a lot about the case in Freiburg but rarely was the other case mentioned at all.</p><p>So people who read the news naturally assume, that Muslims rape. They assume, of course, refugees are dangerous. And when in 2015 one million or one and a half million refugees came to Germany, the media called it a crisis. Now we have two million Ukrainians coming and nobody is talking about a crisis. That’s a good thing, of course; I don’t want the media to make the same mistakes again, but it is interesting how certain people are framed as dangerous, while the media say for others, these are so much closer to our culture, they are Christians, and so on. In a way, that is what I wanted to explore in my book, that there is all this negative stuff, but it is also a lack of being able to create another narrative.</p><p>We know that you can show people every statistic in the world and they might still stick to alternative facts. Because when the reason to their reaction is fear, facts don’t change that. And at the moment we are in a situation where people reduce one another to positions, no matter from which side you look at it. While in reality of course we all are complex. This reducing people to an identity is a problem. Actions, even crimes don’t equate to your identity. We need to introduce complexity to the way we think about others. I also think we need a different way of talking to each other in order to build trust in society. Trust isn’t something that is there <em>per se</em>, but has a lot to do with the way we communicate. An example are talk shows in Germany. I have been uninvited because I am too uncontroversial. They say: “You’re friendly, you want to understand the other side. We want someone who can really make someone else angry. Otherwise it’s not good TV, it’s just boring.” Yes, well, I am sorry.</p><p><strong>TMH: </strong>It seems that more often than not, people of color, refugees, and other marginalized groups in Germany remain a subject only in the sense of being a topic, not in the sense of subjecthood, of having positive agency or being a part of society.</p><p>As this program is about “restoring public trust” now might be a good time to ask who those publics are. Who do we actually mean, when we talk about having public trust? Because if we just ask how we can reduce racism towards these marginalized groups, are we not once again othering them or excluding them from the publics we construct?</p><p><strong>MS: </strong>When I talk about racism, I mainly talk about structures. I mainly talk about things like racist knowledge and the way it affects society. And first of all, just because you are affected by racism, doesn’t mean you don’t reproduce it. So I am not that interested in discourse around evil people who commit racism. That makes an institution like the police, for example, incredibly interesting, because it is an institution that is incredibly volatile for being racist, because they mainly encounter people as criminals. And the people they encounter as criminals are to a very high percentage either poor people or people of color, or both, not because those are inherently criminal but as an effect of racism, of society, and so on. But that reaffirms those views. And we can also look at who wants to become a police officer, which is a certain type of person who needs a lot of security. So there is a whole structure that needs to be understood before we can change it.</p><p>That’s not the same as othering, because if you are a police person of color you will have those same encounters, because the structures are the way they are. So you are bound to go in a similar direction. And nobody can reflect all the time so we all grow up with racist knowledge. There was a great story where they asked kids in primary school to name the capitals of German states. Some of them knew them, but most of them didn’t. And then they asked them what kind of prejudice they could hold against Blacks, against Jews, against Muslims, and so on. And they knew all of them. So the racist knowledge, even though it is not taught at school is transmitted, while the knowledge that is taught at school is not. And it didn’t mean that they believed it, but they have the knowledge already. And that they acquire a lot of this knowledge.</p><p><strong>TMH: </strong>Can we think of all people in Germany to be of the same sphere of public to which trust can be restored? Or has trust in a way never been distributed equally? In which case, what is it that is to be restored if it was perhaps never granted to some in the first place.</p><p><strong>MS: </strong>That’s an interesting question. If I look at people from my father’s generation for example, their relationship to Germany might have been different. When he came to Germany in the early 1960s, he didn’t expect much. So his trust was never really violated, he genuinely was grateful that he was allowed to be here and work for a lower salary than his colleagues. And so my father wouldn’t say that he lost trust at all.</p><p>The second generation, myself, expects a lot more from Germany. We got a promise of fairness and equality. I also remember these racist attacks after the “Wende” (the fall of the Berlin Wall) and how we were talking about them. And how Kohl, our chancellor said, “I’m not going there. I’m not doing condolence tourism.” That was a big moment of feeling like we don’t belong. Like we are not important, we are not the people of this country. It was a Turkish family in Solingen that had been killed. But everyone felt like it was one of us, no matter what background or nationality.</p><p>Another big erosion of trust were the NSU (national-socialist underground — a far-right terrorist group in Germany) murders between 2000 and 2007 and the way the police handled them and criminalized the victims and the whole community. The victims were dehumanized, calling the incidents “Döner-Morde” (doner murders), — those were human beings that were killed! And they might still go on doing that if the NSU had not been found out as the killers. It would be a massive step towards trust, if the public was granted access to the files. But they are still under lock and key.</p><p><strong>TMH: </strong>In your answer you connected public trust and public expectations. Do you think public trust is going down whenever public expectations are rising or aren’t met? Does it make a difference to talk about meeting public expectations rather than restoring public trust?</p><p><strong>MS: </strong>Looking at expectations and public trust you could say that society has become a lot less secure, in the sense of job security. But looking at how much people are earning, we are still quite a rich country. So quite a lot of expectations are met and a lot of people should be very secure. I mainly do research on racism. People are more afraid of foreigners when there are no foreigners around them. What I am saying is that so much comes back to how things are being perceived or presented to us. I definitely think that at the moment we are playing social groups against each other to a large extent. Women have been played against migrants by saying that they are coming here and will commit rape. At the beginning it was only the far right but now it is the mainstream media. They are using fear to mobilize; either fear of losing your income, fear of losing security, fear of any kind of violation.</p><p>And speaking about meeting expectations, one thing marginalized groups need is material support: securing a living standard. That helps a lot. But I don’t know whether that would build trust. My father for example is by no means afraid to starve. And yet, I noticed that in the last couple of years he has become more afraid; of war, of foreigners… He is in his late eighties and does not leave the house too much anymore, so he gets his information via the media. Studies suggest that watching or reading the news is worse than smoking. I certainly feel that I have to dose my exposure to news and social media, even though it is part of my work.</p><p><strong>TMH: </strong>You mentioned the importance of more transparency and reforms within the media landscape. What concrete steps or political solutions should be taken to build and restore public trust?</p><p><strong>MS: </strong>One way to build trust would be a clear approach to how to report, for example, when reporting about crimes, especially about murders. Dr. Park Dietz, a psychologist who works a lot with the police, advises journalists to keep reports local, to not try to offer 24-hour coverage, to only report for the people it concerns and not for the rest. To not portray the perpetrator as an antihero because then other people will copy their behavior. But the opposite happens at the moment. It seems like a celebration of all that. That is why I do think we should talk about media guidelines.</p><p>During the pandemic, fear stories were offered on repeat, but we could have also needed reports to balance that. What we can hope for, for example. Or when we talk about identity politics we always talk about differences, which there are. But obviously, there is a lot more we all have in common than what is different.</p><p>Personally, I have been thinking a lot about love politics, about the role of love and politics. It is something that the left has kind of ruled: They can talk about sex and break taboos all day. But what I mean goes back to Martin Luther King and Ghandi. Love was central to their way of making politics but also to the idea that if we win the political fight, we need to be able to talk about forgiveness and resolution. And we are missing that at the moment. Instead we only think of perpetrators who need to be punished. As a result, nobody will admit that they did something wrong, out of fear to be exorcised from society. And it makes us unable to see how people can come back into society. How they can learn from what they did. Our justice system at the moment is heavily built on the Christian idea of suffering to become a better person — that is a belief, not a system of justice. We need a sense that if you do something wrong you can learn from your mistakes, which would be incredibly helpful in social media, for example.</p><p>And I would love for us as a society to speak about utopias, for which you also need love. For the past few years, I have written a lot against things. And it is really hard to write <em>for</em> things. What do you want? Where do you want to go? What kind of wealth do you want to live in?</p><p><strong>TMH: </strong>You speak about love and utopias. I am reminded of Octavia Butler’s work. For your next novel, then, can we expect a science fiction?</p><p><strong>MS: </strong>That would be lovely. But no. In fact, it is the other way around. It will be a time travel, back in time to the year 1908 and the “India House” in London!</p><p><strong>Mithu Sanyal</strong> is a cultural scientist, journalist and author who writes about sex, gender, post-colonialism, power and racism. Since 1996 Sanyal has written features and radio plays for the German broadcaster WDR, and publishes essays and articles in publications such as <em>The Guardian</em> and various German magazines. In her debut novel <em>Identitti</em> (2021), Sanyal addresses identity politics in a story that involves a student and her Postcolonial Studies teacher, who is not the person of color she pretends to be. Her book “Rape. From Lucretia to #MeToo” is published at Verso Books (2019).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4983d8811e44" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/vatmh/mithu-sanyal-on-identity-struggles-and-trust-4983d8811e44">Mithu Sanyal on Identity Struggles and Trust</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/vatmh">vatmh</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Citizens In Conversation: what brings us back to the table?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/vatmh/citizens-in-conversation-what-brings-us-back-to-the-table-d460e233f918?source=rss-2fdb0b3df75f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d460e233f918</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trust]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[citizenship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Mann House]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 Apr 2022 19:48:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-04T19:18:50.670Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Four voices from Germany and the United States take stock of their relationship to public institutions and democracy. What has changed in recent years? And what needs to happen next to regain the trust of the constituents? An interview with citizens of diverse backgrounds from Los Angeles and Texas to Berlin.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*e4AUOqaA4RgtfcivGEGpHA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/980/1*HMF8OGkpW0B1Qf9fGgFoiQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>From left to right: Dilek, Harlan, Matti, and Richard.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Participants:</strong></p><p><strong><em>Dilek</em></strong><em> grew up in small town near Stuttgart, Germany. Her parents came to Germany from Turkey as “guest workers” through a government program in the 1970s. The 30-year-old works for the IMF in Washington, D.C.</em></p><p><strong><em>Harlan</em></strong><em> was born 80 years ago in Riverside, California and grew up on the Westside of Los Angeles. The retired architect lives with his wife in Pacific Palisades and is a proud father and grandfather.</em></p><p><strong><em>Matti</em></strong><em> moved to the United States eleven years ago and lives in Austin, Texas. He is 25 years old and is currently completing a Master’s degree.</em></p><p><strong><em>Richard</em></strong><em> was born in Vogtland, Saxony, in the former GDR in 1985. The engineer and reformed Christian now lives with his wife and son in Berlin.</em></p><p><strong>Thomas Mann House: Do you feel like you have lost hope in the government in recent years and, if so, in what way?</strong></p><p><strong>Matti: </strong>As we are speaking I’m going to the funeral of my girlfriend’s father. He was very sick and was on government disability. And the government barely supported him… Back in 2015, my house in Houston flooded. We were basically homeless at that point and the only people that helped were religious groups. It was quite strange to have them step in instead of the government. Finally, the governor of Texas just made abortion illegal here. He completely took away the rights of women on his own. All this disappoints me greatly, of course.</p><p><strong>Richard: </strong>I wouldn’t say that I have lost hope in the government. But I think people have generally lost trust in the moral integrity of politicians. So politicians are no longer the type of role model that is leading society, but I wouldn’t say that I have lost trust in politics in general. I would say that with the Ukraine crisis, political trust in our liberal, free, democratic society, pursuing happiness and freedom in the sense of John Locke, actually increased because we saw what the alternative looks like.</p><p><strong>Dilek: </strong>The government outsources more and more of its services to the private sector. Although this worries me, it doesn’t have to be a bad thing. Compared to Germany, the vaccine roll-out in the US relied heavily on private providers but worked very well and was very efficient. But I also see other sectors being handled by private corporations, that were traditionally the government’s responsibility. This makes me wonder what the government’s role will be in the future.</p><p><strong>Harlan: </strong>Personally, I have reservations about the government, but I have not lost hope.</p><p><strong>Thomas Mann House: Are you growing more cynical or tired of politics? Or do you think people in general have that kind of sentiment?</strong></p><p><strong>Harlan: </strong>In general, I have gotten to the point where I try to avoid discussing politics with most people. There are just too many touchy subjects, on both sides of the political spectrum. I’m a Democrat and have been for many years, but I started out as a Republican, and I tend to listen to and respect and even agree with some Republican views, especially on issues of what I would call financial issues. I still think we have a good system in general. But maybe we need a third party, because the two extremes are now leading everything. Despite the fact that people in the middle, if you combine the people who are to the left of center on the Republican side and to the right of center on the Democratic side, probably make up a majority of Americans.</p><p><strong>Matti: </strong>When I was younger and had just arrived in the U.S., I was more involved in politics. But now that I voted a few times and I have been to protests, and nothing has changed, I’d rather just go on with my life.</p><p><strong>Richard: </strong>There is a lot of polarization. In the United States, but also in Germany and in other countries. Society seems to move towards the extreme right or the left. Jonathan Haidt pointed out that during the pandemic, the right was leaning into conspiracy theories, and the left was practicing “wokeism.” And I think social media loops served as an amplifier, probably because people spent more time online.</p><p><strong>Dilek: </strong>What I’m tired of is how complex problems are reduced to one-dimensional issues and how the phrase “this is a scientific fact” has been used and misused too many times. We tend to judge the veracity of statements based on the personalities in the political landscape associated with them and not by data-driven facts. I had the feeling that many restrictive policies that were enacted during the pandemic were either blindly followed or rejected based on who proposed them rather than factual knowledge.</p><p><strong>Thomas Mann House: What could be steps to regain that trust?</strong></p><p><strong>Matti: </strong>I am not sure my trust can be regained easily. With Donald Trump, I think a lot of people lost trust. Regardless of what you think of him, just the fact that anyone could become president, no matter their qualifications was shocking. Then our alternative was Joe Biden, who now doesn’t seem too competent either. I understand that that’s my political opinion, but I think that trust requires a sense of someone’s competency. Competent Republicans would have instilled more trust in me than what we are looking at now.</p><p><strong>Dilek: </strong>I find it difficult to present a full-fledged plan on how to regain trust. Perhaps, if politicians based their decisions on publicly available data, it would help make the decision-making process more transparent and arguably rebuild some trust.</p><p><strong>Richard: </strong>One thing I would say is honesty. Honesty also about your own faults. Even though I’m politically more conservative, I think a good example for this is Robert Habeck (Germany’s vice chancellor and member of the Green party). He is very honest in dealing with the crisis, and when expressing his concern for the Ukraine.</p><p><strong>Thomas Mann House: Do you think the issue could be a lack of involvement? Do you see opportunities for getting involved yourself?</strong></p><p><strong>Dilek: </strong>It is not easy to find the time to get involved in politics. But we can shape policy by getting involved in our communities on a local level as well, which is what I personally have been doing.</p><p><strong>Harlan: </strong>As a candidate? No, I would never do that to myself or to my family. The ordeal that politicians have to go through is just disturbing. And you get pushed into the extreme, either left or right, just to be accepted by your own party. It’s so absurd.</p><p><strong>Matti: </strong>I stopped getting too involved, and I think a lot of it comes down to “if no one’s gonna help me, then I need to help myself.” I have been in need of help from the government at various times. And I understand that there might be rich people who never have to rely on help. But I’ve been through that system, and I had to learn the hard way not to rely on it. And as someone who believes that the government should reach out and proactively help people, it was a bit of a shock to think that I’m on my own.</p><p><strong>Thomas Mann House: What are your expectations of the current administration?</strong></p><p><strong>Harlan: </strong>I don’t want to say that I’m against Biden, but I’m disappointed that he’s not more in control of what he says and what he does. I think the Ukraine situation shows the importance of a really good statesman who can can speak his mind and not miscommunicate or cause confusion. He’s communicated well with European allies and the rest of the world but he’s made some pretty bad blunders in terms of off the cuff remarks.</p><p><strong>Richard: </strong>In Germany, the previous government was already a crisis government. The Merkel administration was navigating the Corona crisis. And on top of this, we now have the war in Ukraine. So I would say right now it’s mainly a crisis government and my expectation is to lead us through this crisis in a good way.</p><p><strong>Dilek: </strong>I am worried about the rift between the left and right. Leading public discourse has become increasingly difficult, as the loudest voices on the extremes drown out the center. I hope that the current administration can make more space for the segment of the population whose voices are hardly heard and foster more nuanced discussions.</p><p><strong>Matti: </strong>Most of my expectations are on the state level. I am disappointed that we just illegalized abortion. And I expect us to have better social programs. Texas is one of the richest states so money should go to preventing crimes, to preventing illiteracy, to helping healthcare. Healthcare is a massive issue, of course, I think on the state and federal level. I just don’t see things changing on a federal level. Nationwide, in the short term, I just want someone that everyone could get behind as a human being.</p><p><strong>Thomas Mann House: What importance do you give to international cooperation in times like these?</strong></p><p><strong>Harlan: </strong>With the Ukraine situation, I think European countries should address it first and foremost. I think we should have our say and be supportive of our European allies. In terms of policy I actually don’t think Biden has made any grave error with the Ukraine situation. I don’t think anybody really wants to go to war over there. America has done this too often. Being the policemen of the world has never served us terribly well.</p><p><strong>Matti: </strong>I think we already delve into other people’s politics so much. Afghanistan, Ukraine… We’ve always got this high opinion of ourselves. But we don’t seem to react when people look at us critically. For example when it comes to police treatment of people of color. And the treatment of Mexican or Haitian migrants. We should learn more from our neighbors, like Canada who have a lot of stuff figured out that we don’t. Including a president who when he meets with other presidents around the world doesn’t completely embarrass himself on social media.</p><p><strong>Dilek: </strong>I believe that international cooperation is more important than ever. Our economies are deeply intertwined in many ways, and we have already witnessed the economic repercussions caused by supply chain disruptions at the onset of the pandemic. Governments must work together to maintain wealth and foster growth.</p><p><strong>Richard: </strong>The Ukraine crisis has shown how important of an ally the U.S. is to Europe. Not only for us, but also for the French and for the UK, and other countries. It is an important factor that we are still a united free, democratic Western world. And I’m also happy for our, economic ties, that I get to have an Apple computer and an iPhone and that they are driving cars from us and so on. But I also value this alliance in itself, not only economically.</p><p><strong>Thomas Mann House: Where do you want your country and society to go in the coming years?</strong></p><p><strong>Richard: </strong>First of all I am hoping for a positive resolution of the COVID-19 pandemic and the war in Ukraine. The other big topic to me is demographic change. It is already a big problem in the Baltics and in China. And of course, a society that is decreasing will die sooner or later. So as a society, I guess that’s probably the biggest challenge, to make it attractive again to have a family and kids.</p><p><strong>Matti: </strong>There are parts of Texas where I am not able to say certain things or have a bumper sticker on my car without feeling unsafe. And those same people, if I’m being fair, are not welcome on the University of Texas campus, because of their beliefs. Other countries don’t seem to have this kind of divide. Think of places like South Africa and Germany and what they managed to deal with. So I hope we can overcome this divide. And then I hope we adopt at least the very basic principles that have been adopted everywhere: environmental issues, women’s rights, the fact that people of color deserve equal treatment.</p><p><strong>Harlan: </strong>I certainly want to see us continue and succeed as a democracy. I would also like to see us not be going to any more wars unless they are really laid on us. Ultimately, too, I think there needs to be more equality in the world. I don’t think we need a world government. I don’t think that would be any better than the U.S. getting involved. I don’t want to see us lose our influence, but I want to see us use it more wisely.</p><p><strong>Dilek: </strong>I see that the generation now eligible to vote for the first time, has different priorities than older generations. Generally speaking, they care more about sustainability, embrace diversity and are digital natives. All of this gives me hope. I am confident that we already are going into the right direction and that things will only get better.</p><p><em>The interview was conducted by Josh Widera.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d460e233f918" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/vatmh/citizens-in-conversation-what-brings-us-back-to-the-table-d460e233f918">Citizens In Conversation: what brings us back to the table?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/vatmh">vatmh</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Edvard Beneš, Czechoslovakia and Thomas Mann’s Vision of Democracy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/vatmh/edvard-bene%C5%A1-czechoslovakia-and-thomas-manns-vision-of-democracy-837c3281008?source=rss-2fdb0b3df75f------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/837c3281008</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jan-vondracek]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thomas-mann-house]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thomas-mann]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[czech-republic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[edvard-benes]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Thomas Mann House]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Mar 2022 18:34:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-16T16:54:58.317Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>On March 15, 1939, Prague was occupied by German troops. The same day, Thomas Mann met former Czechoslovakian President Edvard Beneš in Chicago. Historian Jan Vondráček tells the story of the friendship between Thomas Mann and Edvard Beneš. The sociologist and politician Beneš not only played an important role in granting Mann Czechoslovakian citizenship, but also had an often overlooked impact on Mann’s understanding of democracy.</h4><p>In recent years, Thomas Mann has been increasingly perceived as an important champion of democracy. Texts such as <em>The Coming Victory of Democracy</em> and his fight for democracy and against Nazism in American exile have been the subject of numerous studies. Yet it is often overlooked that Thomas Mann, who emigrated to the United States with a Czechoslovak passport, was also significantly influenced by this democratic state and its second president, Edvard Beneš.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M_aJKgsn5j2sje2DiYNCVQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Beneš and Mann at Hotel Windermere in Chicago. Copyright: Shutterstock Permission No. USTAX-0EA00A85C-1</figcaption></figure><p>On March 15, 1939, Prague, the capital of Czechoslovakia, was occupied by German troops. This was the last act in the gradual destruction of Czechoslovakia, which had been founded only 20 years earlier and from 1933 on, this democratic state served as a refuge for thousands of victims of political and racial persecution from Nazi Germany, including numerous intellectuals.</p><p>On that March 15, 1939, thousands of miles away from Prague, two important personalities met at Hotel Windermere in Chicago. Both of them had a strong relationship with Czechoslovakia: Thomas Mann and the former president of Czechoslovakia Edvard Beneš. It would be no exaggeration to say that, without the help of Edvard Beneš, Mann would never have been able to emigrate to the USA.</p><p>Before 1939 for German intellectual émigrés, Prague offered what Paris and Amsterdam did not: a German-speaking readership and an environment in which they could exchange ideas in German. After all, Czechoslovakia was also home to a strong German minority of about three million people. The majority lived in the area bordering the German Reich, but thousands of German-speaking citizens also lived in Prague and Brno. Of these, many classified themselves under the laws of Czechoslovakia as of Jewish nationality. Young émigrés had the opportunity to continue their studies in German at the German university in Prague. Unlike in Switzerland, the emigrants in Czechoslovakia could also continue their political activities. For this reason, hundreds of communists fled into Czechoslovakia. The Social Democratic Party of Germany also moved its headquarters to Prague after the Nazis took power; the important party newspaper <em>Neuer Vorwärts</em> was published in Prague until 1938, as were other important journals and newspapers like <em>Neue Deutsche Blätter</em>.</p><p>After the Austrian Civil War in February 1934 and the establishment of the “Austrofascist” regime, many Austrians also came to Czechoslovakia, making Czechoslovakia the most important country for German-speaking emigrants in Europe.</p><p>The Nazi takeover of Germany in 1933 drastically affected life in Czechoslovakia as well, leading to severe tensions between the German, Czech and Jewish ethnic populations. The Sudeten Germans in Czechoslovakia increasingly sympathized with the Nazi regime, and this affected the lives of the between 10,000 and 20,000 German émigrés, who often lived in the border regions because life in Prague was too expensive. As early as the late nineteenth century, this region of Bohemia was a center of <em>völkisch, </em>anti-Slavic, anti-Semitic movements, and it was here that the precursors to the National Socialist movement had their roots.</p><p>The political orientation of the Sudeten Germans represented one of the most serious problems of the young state. In Liberec/Reichenberg, the unofficial capital of the Sudeten German minority, the Sudeten German Henlein Party had ruled since the mid-1930s, preventing émigrés from obtaining domicile there, which was a precondition for applying for a Czechoslovak passport. Heinrich Mann tried to obtain a domicile and passport and failed due to the political mood in the city council.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*31pV5XWoX6Hh850mFCVSzw.png" /><figcaption>Sudeten Germans greet German soldiers with the Nazi salute in Saaz, Czechoslovakia, 1938. Photo: Bundesarchiv, Bild 146–1970–005–28 / CC-BY-SA 3.0, Creative Common.</figcaption></figure><p>Since the process was widely reported in the press, the Jewish Czech entrepreneur and admirer of Thomas Mann Rudolf Fleischmann became aware of the strive of Heinrich Mann and it was thanks to him that the entire Mann family received the right of domicile in the small town of Proseč and subsequently, through the action of President Edvard Beneš, Czechoslovakian citizenship in 1936.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/1*tGZZSn5A8Q2iteSW2awOyw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Thomas Mann arriving in Proseč, December 1, 1937. ETH-Bibliothek Zürich, Thomas-Mann-Archiv / Photographer: Unknown / TMA_0405</figcaption></figure><p>At that time, Thomas Mann was living in Switzerland, where he had failed to receive citizenship, and the Nazi regime had revoked his German citizenship, rendering him stateless. Without the new passport from Czechoslovakia, Thomas Mann would not have been able to leave Switzerland, and he and his family would not have been able to emigrate to the United States. He expressed his gratitude publicly in his lectures <em>The Coming Victory of Democracy </em>in 1938:</p><p><em>Even more do I owe thanks to the Republic of Czechoslovakia, which most generously made a gift of its citizenship to me who was robbed of my German nationality. Especially at this moment, when the heavens of central Europe are darkening so threateningly, it is a heartfelt necessity to give expression to my faithful loyalty to this courageous and lovable democratic republic.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*CD1Zu_6Ll9lGjE3JtGQ5iQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The first edition of “The Coming Victory of Democracy.” Knopf, 1938. Photo: Benno Herz</figcaption></figure><p>Mann came to Prague and Czechoslovakia several times to vocally support the democratic Czechoslovak state and government against the German nationalist Sudeten German movement. For Edvard Beneš and his government, this support was worth its weight in gold, as he desperately needed popular allies who also represented an international authority to stay in control of the situation: On the one hand, the Sudeten German minority was pushing for autonomy from Prague and annexation by Nazi Germany; on the other hand, conservative Czech forces accused Beneš of bringing German communists into the country, and Czech national forces in turn accused him of courting German émigrés instead of taking care of Czech problems. Considering these extreme political tensions, the question arises as to how this democratic system could withstand such pressure.</p><p>As is well known, at that time Thomas Mann was deeply concerned with the question of the functioning of democracy, and it is hardly surprising that the debate about democracy in Czechoslovakia also left its mark on him. What is new however, is that Thomas Mann’s concept of democracy was influenced by Edvard Beneš’ work, as I have recently discovered in archival materials.</p><p>Edvard Beneš is typically perceived more as politician than as thinker, political theorist and originator of the concept of socializing democracy. Edvard Beneš had been the co-founder of the state of Czechoslovakia in 1918, then foreign minister and head of government, and finally president of Czechoslovakia from 1935. But Beneš also studied in Prague, Paris, and Dijon and received his doctorate in law in 1908 with a thesis on Austria and the Czech Question. In 1912 he received his <em>Habilitation</em> in Prague in sociology under Masaryk, later president of Czechoslovakia. During the First World War, he lectured at the Sorbonne in Paris alongside his political activities. Beneš then became a professor of sociology and throughout the 1930s wrote extensively on democracy, including publications in German.</p><p>On December 3, 1937, he received a typewritten letter from Thomas Mann:</p><p><em>“It may not be seemly to write too often to one’s head of state, but it becomes me to express my great appreciation for your last letter and the extremely valuable gift that accompanied it, and to express this appreciation most emphatically. I have been reading a great deal of late in the three silver volumes. They are a true fount of political wisdom and powerful moderation, and will be a refreshment to everyone who desires to be strengthened in the conviction of the human primacy of democracy as a form of state and society above all other solutions of the social problem.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*foR3UNWNuVwfWip2c38bFQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Unpublished letter from Thomas Mann to Edvard Beneš. Courtesy of the Masaryk Institute and Archives of the Czech Academy of Sciences. Source: MÚA, AÚTGM, fond E. Beneš I (EBI), inv. č 1186, sign. R 175/4, kart. 251.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CzMLKgy6djKdD92UH91TQg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Last page of the letter. Courtesy of the Masaryk Institute and Archives of the Czech Academy of Sciences. Source: MÚA, AÚTGM, fond E. Beneš I (EBI), inv. č 1186, sign. R 175/4, kart. 251.</figcaption></figure><p>From the first lines we can conclude that Mann and Beneš often exchanged ideas. The gift mentioned in the letter refers to the work <em>Thought and Action (Gedanke und Tat)</em>, a three-volume work published in 1937 by Beneš, which included numerous collected speeches and publications by Beneš (<em>Politics as science and art, The construction and life of the state, The cooperation of the nations/ Die Politik als Wissenschaft und Kunst, Vom Bau und Leben des Staates, Die Zusammenarbeit der Nationen</em>). Mann continues:</p><p><em>I find the German title of your writings, “Gedanke und Tat”, extraordinarily well chosen, because this combination of words is indeed the formula for all spiritual democracy. It is the shortcoming of undemocratic and democratically untrained nations that in them thinking takes place, as it were, in a vacuum, without any relation to reality, without responsibility to reality and without sense for the consequences of reality which result from thoughts. Goethe once said: “One who acts is always without conscience; only the observer has a conscience.” This is true, and precisely because it is true, the observer must also have a conscience for the one who acts, whereby the happiest case is, of course, when the one who thinks and the one who acts are one and the same person, as was the case with your great predecessor, esteemed </em>Herr Präsident<em>, and is the case with yourself.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xUA07VOCUUVvrsmG9ej7bw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Courtesy of the Masaryk Institute and Archives of the Czech Academy of Sciences. Source: MÚA, AÚTGM, fond E. Beneš I (EBI), inv. č 1186, sign. R 175/4, kart. 251.</figcaption></figure><p>The remark by Mann linking the first president of Czechoslovakia, Tomáš Garrigue Masaryk, with Edvard Beneš illustrates the importance he attributes to both personalities for the functioning of the democratic state. Indeed, many features of the state, such as the militant suppression of anti-Semitism, which was also a problem in Czechoslovakia, especially in the early 1920s, were due to Masaryk’s energetic political work.</p><p>Both figures played a central role in the establishment of Czechoslovakia. The importance of Beneš’s writings for Thomas Mann can be seen from the further text of the letter.</p><p><em>“Early next year I will embark on a lecture tour through the United States, during which I am to speak on the “Coming Victory of Democracy.” I may assure you that in the preparation of this address the study of your writings has been a great stimulus and moral help to me.”</em></p><p>From February to May 1938, Thomas Mann was on his reading tour, with his lectures and speeches broadcast by radio throughout America. They were published in September 1938. Reading the book, one notices that the quotation of Goethe quote invoked a half year earlier in the letter to Beneš now reappears in a broader context. We also find arguments that Mann recorded in his letter to Beneš in the context of the title <em>Thought and action</em>:</p><p><em>We call the recently deceased founder and first President of the Czechoslovak Republic a great democrat. Why? Because he embodied a new and modern relationship between mind and life, because he represented the organic association of the philosopher and the statesman — a philosopher as statesman, and as a statesman a philosopher. Plato’s insistence that philosophers should rule the state would create a dangerous Utopia if it merely implied that the ruler should be a philosopher. The philosopher must also be a ruler — for that, primarily, creates the relationship of mind and life which we call democratic.</em></p><p>Although it is hard to summarize the argumentation of Edvard Beneš’ discussion of democracy in a few sentences, it can be said that the integration and consideration of social and economic issues played a crucial role for him. The idea of social democracy also forms the core of Thomas Mann’s political thinking. What is certain is that for both of them the Aristotelian principles of democracy, humanism and the social question represent central points of their argumentation. The crisis of democracy, including National Socialism in Germany and the danger of fascism in general, are of course central themes, but how democracy should defend itself against these phenomena is met with philosophical and cultural arguments.</p><p>The now Oxford political scientist Giovanni Capoccia concludes that while cultural and social factors are crucial for the long-term stability of a democracy, they play little role in resolving short-term or spontaneous political crises. In this context, the structure of the political system, the constitution and the state institutions and their actors — first and foremost the government and the head of state — become much more important. In states that have a strong democratic tradition and self-image, with a political system built on a broad social foundation and with a basic democratic consensus, institutional responses to short-term political strategies and methods-such as fascism-will only be effective if these extremists are weak. At the same time, however, this renders state responses useless. By contrast, if the extremists are strong, none of these strategies can achieve their intended goal. If we look instead at the short term, we are forced to ask what conditions must be created for political and institutional responses against anti-democratic and anti-state extremists to be successful.</p><p>It is precisely these conditions and institutional and political responses to the multifaceted threat of fascism to the European states that analyzed an old acquaintance of Thomas Mann from his time in Munich, the German-Jewish political scientist and jurist Karl Loewenstein. Loewenstein was one of the few who had been able to correctly interpret the signs of the times as early as 1933 and emigrated to the United States, where he soon taught political science and law, first at Yale and then at Amherst College. Thomas Mann met Loewenstein several times in the USA. In his articles written in the 1930s, Loewenstein analyzed the ability of European democracies to protect themselves from the danger of extremist parties, but above all fascism as a “political method,” by means of special legislation and constitutional interventions. In doing so, he addresses all European states whose democratic systems he examines in a comparative perspective under these aspects. In his eyes, no European state had such a model character as Czechoslovakia: “In Czechoslovakia, the postulate of democracy at war is fulfilled to the letter.”</p><p>Loewenstein modeled his concept of <em>Militant Democracy</em> on the example of Czechoslovakia, which was to become groundbreaking for all Western democracies after 1945.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/728/1*euSmtTG5nAeySLqdM_FfZw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Portrait of Karl Loewenstein, no date, Karl Loewenstein Collection, Amherst College Archives &amp; Special Collections.</figcaption></figure><p>The state structure of Czechoslovakia worked until the betrayal of Munich in September 1938 by the Western powers that Thomas Mann addressed in his essay <em>This Peace</em>. Munich was thus not only a foreign policy disaster for Czechoslovakia and Europe, but above all an international rejection of democracy.</p><p>How could Beneš defend democracy against his domestic opponents, when even the states that stood at the cradle of this political system, England and France, were sacrificing it? He resigned and all anti-democratic forces took advantage of the moment and democracy crumbled only two months after the Munich Agreement. In the days after Munich<em> </em>Beneš received a telegram from Thomas Mann asking him to join him in the United States:</p><p><em>“In this tragic moment I and my house would like to offer you our heartfelt homage to the venerable victim of foreign weakness and disloyalty we have suffered with you in these horrible weeks and admired you and your people more and more, come to this country where high-mindedness is still known and where you will be celebrated and honored.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RpaoeTQMfu_TRbxpFow-Ag.jpeg" /><figcaption>The telegram Mann sent to Beneš from Princeton, October 6, 1938. Courtesy of the Masaryk Institute and Archives of the Czech Academy of Sciences. Source: MÚA, AÚTGM, fond E. Beneš I (EBI), inv. č 1186, sign. R 175/4, kart. 251.</figcaption></figure><p>Edvard Beneš followed Thomas Mann to the United States, where from February to July 1939 he was a visiting professor at the University of Chicago. Here he lectured on democracy. His lecture was published later that year under the title “Democracy Today and Tomorrow.”</p><p>Meanwhile on December 15, 1938, an authoritarian, anti-Semitic regime was installed in Prague by Beneš’ political enemies. Although the destruction of democracy in Czechoslovakia received some international notice, it was soon overshadowed by the invasion of German troops three months later on March 15, 1939.</p><p>While Thomas Mann fought in literature against Nazi Germany after the outbreak of World War II, Beneš did so politically. He moved to Great Britain and became president of the Czechoslovak government-in-exile. On the orders of Beneš, Reinhard Heydrich was killed in Prague by Czechoslovak special forces, which, after brutal retribution and the destruction of the villages of Lidice and Ležáky by the Germans, led to the annulment of the Munich Agreement in 1942 by Great Britain.</p><p>The German emigrants in Hollywood also reacted: Already in the winter of 1943, the film <em>Hitler’s Madman</em> by Douglas Sirk was shot, which dealt with the Heydrich assassination, the same year <em>Hangmen Also Die!</em> by none other than Fritz Lang was produced, the story was co-written by Bertolt Brecht, the Music composed by Hanns Eisler.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/796/1*1eW0oWIx_h_g7pMB8nl-Wg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Poster for “Hangmen also Die!”, 1943.</figcaption></figure><p>The international recognition was bought by the blood of about 2000 people murdered by the terror of the German occupiers in the aftermath of the Heydrich assassination. The Sudeten Germans paid a catastrophic price for their alliance with Nazi Germany: between 1945 and 1948 they were almost completely expelled from Czechoslovakia.</p><p>Although it was undoubtedly to Edvard Beneš’ credit that Czechoslovakia re-emerged as a democratic state after 1945, his naïve policy led to growing Stalinist influence of the Soviet Union. After not even three years of democracy, which included many of the features of the socializing democracy discussed in Beneš’ writings, the Communist coup of February 1948 put an end to these democratic ideas.</p><p>Beneš died a short time later, and with him democracy in Czechoslovakia.</p><p>Due to his central role in the acceptance of the Munich Agreement in 1938 and the decision not to fight against Hitler, the assassination of Heydrich in 1942, the expulsion of the Sudeten Germans in 1945, and his role in the Communist takeover in 1948, Edvard Beneš is perceived very differently and controversially today in the Czech Republic and in Germany. His role in the above mentioned events led to his writings and influence on Thomas Mann and others being forgotten. As the correspondence between Thomas Mann and Beneš that I have discovered shows, it is well worthwhile to study Beneš’ sociological and political writings, because they can contribute a great deal to the debate about democracy that was being conducted in the United States at the end of the 1930s.</p><p><strong>Jan Vondráček</strong> is a researcher at the Masaryk Institute and Archives of the Czech Academy of Sciences and an assistant professor at the Faculty of Humanities, Charles University. The research for this article was funded by the Czech Science Foundation (GAČR), project №22–36226O, “Militant Democracy: A History of the Shaping, Defense and Perception of the First Czechoslovak Republic, 1918–1938.” His award-winning dissertation on the everyday life in the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia was recently published in German and Czech.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=837c3281008" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/vatmh/edvard-bene%C5%A1-czechoslovakia-and-thomas-manns-vision-of-democracy-837c3281008">Edvard Beneš, Czechoslovakia and Thomas Mann’s Vision of Democracy</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/vatmh">vatmh</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>