<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Vatsalya Srivastava on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Vatsalya Srivastava on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@vatsalyasrivastava?source=rss-70a8f1ffd90c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 20:56:57 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@vatsalyasrivastava/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Can global solidarity survive the zero-sum game in the market for PPEs?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vatsalyasrivastava/can-global-solidarity-survive-the-zero-sum-game-in-the-market-for-ppes-c27bffaaf76f?source=rss-70a8f1ffd90c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c27bffaaf76f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hoarding]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[inequality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid-19-crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ppe-market]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vatsalya Srivastava]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 01 May 2020 05:44:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-01T05:44:28.079Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>“We are all in it together” — is a common refrain in these troubled times. From local politicians to national leaders to the WHO all have pointed out that we can only overcome this crisis if we all cooperate. From an Indian perspective, nowhere has this sense of global solidarity been more obvious than when shipments of Hydroxy Chloro-Quinine (HCQ) were sent across the world. Many countries conveyed their gratitude with the government of Brazil even invoking the Ramayana, with India playing Hanuman bringing <em>sanjeevani</em> when it was needed most. HCQ is a cheap drug used often in malaria-stricken countries like India. Its widespread availability is why, despite some criticism, the Indian government has maintained that it has sufficient reserves. When supply is not a limiting factor, cooperation and sharing of resources are rarely of major concern. But can this bonhomie extend to resources that are not in abundant supply?</p><p>The suffering of great masses of migrant labour across India brought the vulnerability of marginalized groups into sharp focus. As we grapple with the enormity of our domestic problems, we must not be blind-sighted by the potential fallouts of asymmetry in endowments across countries, both economic and otherwise. All of the 195 countries in the world are in competition to procure equipment, particularly Personal Protective Equipment (PPE), to equip their health workers and it is not a fair fight. Fractures in inter-country cooperation are beginning to show up, with even rich countries like <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/03e45e35-ab09-4892-899d-a86db08a935c">Germany</a> and the <a href="https://nos.nl/artikel/2328673-honderdduizenden-chinese-mondmaskers-teruggeroepen-uit-nederlandse-ziekenhuizen.html">Netherlands</a> voicing their concerns. Countries in Africa are struggling to source from an international market where prices are denominated in <a href="https://www.groundup.org.za/article/covid-19-south-africa-racing-produce-masks-needed-fight-virus/">US dollars</a>. India has also faced problems with sourcing materials in the required <a href="https://english.jagran.com/politics/coronavirus-pandemic-money-isnt-problem-kejriwal-requests-gambhir-to-help-delhi-govt-get-ppe-kits-10010417">quantity</a> and of expected <a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/cabinet-approves-ordinance-to-protect-health-workers-under-attack-during-covid-19-pandemic/videoshow/75293390.cms">quality</a>. The <a href="https://time.com/5823158/china-mask-exports/">USA</a> has complained that many of its firms are facing difficulties in exporting out of their factories in China. In the face of the emerging acrimony, some have continued to <a href="https://eeas.europa.eu/delegations/china/76401/eu-hrvp-josep-borrell-coronavirus-pandemic-and-new-world-it-creating_en">rally</a> global cooperation. But in a situation where cooperation and sharing can jeopardize one’s prospect of survival, we would do well to temper our expectations from the rest of the world.</p><p>Many any countries have placed <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2020/03/27/business/medical-supplies-export-ban/index.html">severe restrictions</a> on exports of critical equipment citing the need to take care of their own first. These moves, along with undermining global solidarity, have also served to severely restrict supply in the global market. Parts of the world with limited manufacturing capabilities cannot manufacture the required equipment, and even among those who can there are few, if any, that can produce all they need. This has led almost all of them to rely on supplies from a few countries, mostly in East Asia. Not only is the supply from these countries limited, it is also precarious. Any indication of another outbreak in these countries and the supply would shrink very rapidly.</p><p>On the demand side, countries that are facing a surge in COVID cases need medical equipment urgently. But the urgency of stocking up before the surge hits is not lost on the other countries. Lockdowns cannot last forever and the inevitability of the spread of the virus in its aftermath means that the urgency of the latter group of countries is not less than the former. The difficulty in predicting the quantity of equipment required makes matter worse. This uncertainty drives countries to build as large a stockpile as they can. The buying patterns that emerge in a situation like this is akin to hoarding.</p><p>The urgency and uncertainty that is driving demand and the concurrent lack of supply have made the procurement of essential medical supplies a zero-sum game between states. In such a game the only way for a player to win is for the others to lose. There are no win-win scenarios. If people are dying in two countries, and both of them cannot have all the PPE they need. Then, every PPE that goes to country A, doesn’t go to Country B putting country B’s medical staff at risk. It would, therefore, make sense for country B to try and get as many PPEs as possible and it can only do that that by denying country A.</p><p>Government’s across the world are under intense pressure to buy equipment and buy them fast. With a few sellers and many, many desperate buyers, this is a seller’s market. In the ensuing bidding war, buyers who can afford to will offer to pay higher and higher prices, <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2020/04/09/why-states-and-the-federal-government-are-bidding-on-ppe.html">driving market prices up</a> for everyone. If every country and state had the same amount of resources, higher willingness to pay would simply signal relative urgency. But that is not the case. An economy the size of India, given the quantity it needs, will struggle to bid and win consistently against US states like California or New York, which are also bidding against each other. Consequently, many of the countries will either end up with less quantity than required or worse, with equipment that will not be of the desired quality.</p><p>The competition on price is not the only problem that has emerged in recent times. The ability of some countries to <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2020/04/03/europe/coronavirus-masks-war-intl/index.html">wrest away supplies</a> by either paying in cash, or by abuse of power remains a constant threat. Allegations of <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/03/mask-wars-coronavirus-outbidding-demand">international piracy</a> is already showing that enforcing international contracts, which is difficult in the best of times, might turn out to be almost impossible in the middle of a global crisis. If the pandemic lasts for as long as the Spanish Flu did, it is not inconceivable that the countries in which most of the suppliers are based will increasingly get to choose winners and losers.</p><p>The need of the hour for a country like India is to recognize the dynamics of this fast-evolving market. We will have to concede that in the short run, the only way to get high-quality equipment will be to match the price being offered by richer countries. But given the limited resources at the government’s disposal, this cannot be sustained for too long. Therefore, there is an urgent need to ramp up the domestic capability to produce medical equipment. Hastening the process of providing permits will go a long way in improving domestic manufacturing capabilities. Some states like <a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/punjab-allows-five-units-to-make-ppes/articleshow/75014466.cms?from=mdr">Punjab</a>, have taken the lead in this regard and others should follow suit. Concerns around quality should be mitigated by the fact that with international shipment severely restricted, the domestic market will have a few large buyers in the form of state governments, creating more of a buyer’s market. In any case, concerns about the quality of the final output should not hinder granting of permissions to firms that are willing to produce the required equipment. Not only will concerted efforts in this direction alleviate the current shortages, it will also create a mechanism for the government to provide some fiscal stimulus to the domestic industry.</p><p>The troubles that emanate from the frantic demand and limited supplies will make global solidarity more difficult to sustain. There will still be cooperation: more shipments of medicines, sharing findings on the vaccine and leading countries might even come together to create a new version of the Bretton Woods. The world will rally in our collective fight against the virus but to expect solidarity to be a solution to all our problems will be unwise. As an old saying goes, the best place to find a helping hand is at the end of your own arm.</p><p>Originally <a href="https://encouragingarguments.blogspot.com/2020/04/can-global-solidarity-survive-zero-sum.html">here</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c27bffaaf76f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the Disease and Lockdown Cure]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vatsalyasrivastava/on-the-disease-and-lockdown-cure-fdb510968231?source=rss-70a8f1ffd90c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fdb510968231</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lockdown-in-india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[counterfactual]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[migrant-crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lockdown]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vatsalya Srivastava]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Apr 2020 07:43:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-14T07:48:26.804Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Counterfactuals to the lockdown in India</h3><p>Originally published <a href="https://bit.ly/3ejsYpQ">here</a> on March 30, 2020</p><p>A crisis of unprecedented proportions is upon us. In the last few weeks, suggestions from experts and requests from governments have been <a href="https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/punjab-man-who-died-of-covid-19-infected-23-met-100s-15-villages-sealed-2201512">unsuccessful</a> in convincing everyone to take all possible precautions. With ill-considered risky actions by many making it infeasible to rely on individual decision making, governments across the world have imposed very stringent restrictions. The consequent impact on the economy has been very severe. Business is suffering, many millions have lost their jobs and by all accounts, many more will. In India, nowhere has the impact of the lockdown been more apparent and more poignant than in the pictures of unemployed migrant workers walking hundreds of kilometers to get home.</p><p>The US President has already called out the possibility of the effect of the lockdown being worse than the disease it is meant to address. Bolsanaro of Brazil has gone even further, stating that a few will die, but most will be unaffected by the virus. The leaders of many other countries though, including India, have acknowledged the economic distress, but have taken the position that the cost of not having a lockdown is too high. Besides creating a unique situation in which the critics of the Indian PM might have the US President in their corner, the immediate consequences of the lockdown across countries have raised the question: if a lockdown was the best response to the pandemic.</p><p>Some have argued that maybe it would be better to let the virus <em>claim its victims</em>, fight the war in the hospitals as best we can and let other aspects of life be. This more extreme opposition harks back to UK’s stated policy until a few weeks ago. Some others, particularly in India, have argued against the way in which the lockdown was implemented, positing that the government should have given people more warning. This, the claim goes, would have potentially avoided the problems that migrant labor is facing. These are both legitimate concerns. The debate around the questions that they raise will determine the decisions that governments will take, and these decisions will continue to affect our lives long after the passing of the pandemic itself. It is therefore imperative that we address both these suggestions as carefully as possible.</p><p><strong>Counterfactual 1: cure worse than the disease</strong></p><p>If the case casualty rate (deaths/no. of confirmed cases) seems to be around a relatively low 4%, is it worth taking destroying the lives of so many; pushing many into poverty and starvation? A recession also claims lives, and particularly in the case of poorer countries, the toll can be severe and long-lasting. In order to determine if the lockdown is indeed a better policy than no lockdown for the situation we find ourselves in, we need to evaluate the counterfactual. A caveat that must accompany any such evaluation is that we will have to rely on many assumptions and there is no way to know with certainty ‘what could have been’. And the uncertainty will increase as the days pass by, making it even more difficult to hazard a guess about what could have been if there was no lockdown.</p><p>Most of the detractors of the lockdown also concede that even without a lockdown it would not have been business as usual. But point out that with the widespread acceptance of some reasonable form of social distancing, the effect of covid19 is not likely to be much worse than a very bad flu season. This implies that hospitals will get a large number of people coming in, but only a small proportion of them will die. In this scenario, even though the number of dead will be quite high, a countrywide lockdown might seem a little excessive given the costs that it imposes. Statistics on the effect of flu from the CDC provide some perspective and lend some credence to this view: each year, in the United States, on average 36,000 people die from flu-related complications and more than 200,000 people are hospitalized from flu-related causes. Even in the 2009 swine flu epidemic which led to almost 60 million infections in the US alone, only 12000 died, and there was no lockdown. Consequently, the economy which was already under tremendous strain did not suffer any significant adverse effects due to the epidemic.</p><p>In order to get a more reasonable estimate of how things would have played out without a lockdown, it is pertinent to check if the numbers underlying this proposition stand up to scrutiny:</p><p>1) Even if we take the proposed 4% as the true case casualty rate, small proportions do not mean small numbers. If the size of the infected population is large enough, the number of people requiring urgent medical attention will be very large. Therefore, the only way to reduce the number of patients requiring urgent care seems to be to reduce the possibility of getting infected.</p><p>2) The comparison of the current outbreak to a very bad flu season misses out a key detail. This virus is not replacing the flu, it is going to supplement it. Increasing the numbers even further. The Swine flu data isn’t particularly useful either, as effective antiviral drugs were made available early on leading to far fewer serious cases.</p><p>The possibility of affected patients overwhelming hospitals is a nightmare scenario for a country like India. However, some of the consternation in India, particularly in the light of the migrant labor crisis seems to be driven by a low number and low growth rate of the confirmed infections relative to countries suffering the worst of the pandemic. This needs to be put in the context of the rate of testing. As of 27th March, India has conducted only about 19 tests per million people, one of the lowest in the world and very likely the reason behind low confirmed infections. The US provides a prominent example of numbers rising with numbers of tests. This should be of particular concern to a country like India, which already has a very high disease burden along with a weak public health infrastructure. The state of Jharkhand, for instance, has 1 doctor every 8700 people. Increased demand on this structure by a rapid surge in numbers of Covid19 patients will lead to high mortality from other diseases which will not get the required treatment. This will be made infinitely worse if health care workers get affected, reducing the size of the already small pool of medical professionals available to treat any disease, not just covid19. In all of this, the worst affected will be the people with low access to high-quality health care.</p><p>These are not new arguments, they have formed the core of the recommendation to flatten the curve. Less severe measures than lockdown were tried in many countries: people were asked to maintain social distance, avoid non-essential travel and self isolate in case of recent international travel or if there were any symptoms. The results were not encouraging. Most of the countries that tried the milder measures in the early days swiftly moved to curtail individual choice. The possibility of huge externalities, with the action of one affecting many others and on the evidence of the indiscretions of many people, the only way to stem to tide seemed to severely restrict movement.</p><p>It stands to reason that if the only way that the virus spreads is by people being in close contact, then fewer people being in close contact should slow it down. Yet the numbers of confirmed infections continue to grow. This also implies that in the absence of stringent measures, the virus would have spread even more rapidly. Now, to expect that the economy would have continued to function as it always has in the face of rising infections and possibly deaths is to presume that people have no regard for personal safety. While a few deviants can compromise a large society to the virus, we would need many, many more to keep the wheels of economy running at anywhere close to normal.</p><p>An Indian media house recently framed the debate as one between lives and livelihoods, this seems to suggest that the choice is between an economic recession and saving lives. However, if there are no lives, there are can be no livelihoods, if lives are lost, livelihoods will eventually be lost, one way or another. The counterfactual to a lockdown, on the basis of the evidence we have coming in from Italy, Spain and other worst-affected countries, seems to be an economy which might have trudged on for a few weeks before collapsing to a position very close to one it is likely to be in right now, with all its concomitant effects. The economic impact of this non-lockdown slowdown will still be disproportionately high for the underprivileged, with a body count that will likely be much higher.</p><p><strong>Counterfactual 2: cure should have been better administered</strong></p><p>Pictures of hundreds of thousands of migrant workers from across India have led many to question the urgency with which the shutdown and the subsequent curfew measures were imposed. How is it that despite having had the information for many weeks, the central government went from requesting a self-imposed ‘people’s curfew’ to full lockdown in a matter of 3 days. If the process was more spread out, people were given prior warning we would not have the situation that we face today. Migrants would have made arrangements to either travel to their native states or have explored ways and means of surviving where they were residing.</p><p>The urgency of the move, whether stemming from incompetence or other more sinister motives, seems particularly baffling as India did not really have an obvious Wuhan like epicenter of the infection that needed to be insulated from the rest of the country. Further, if so many are in standing and cheek by jowl, did the outcome not beat the purpose of the lockdown. Both of these propositions require careful consideration, particularly because this tragedy is playing out as we speak while the threat of the Coronavirus is still in the future. And if the lockdown is going to be longer than currently stated, similar questions will arise again, very soon.</p><p>In order to evaluate these concerns, let us consider a counterfactual in which the shutdown on March 22nd would have been announced 7 days in advance on March 15th. The news would have taken time to trickle down, but in a few days, it is likely that buses and trains would be bursting at their seams. If the mass exodus of migrant labor to (mostly) eastern states around the festivals Diwali/Chhath is anything to go by, 7 days would be inadequate. But these are extraordinary times and maybe arrangements could be made for additional trains and buses to take people to their destination of choice. In this best-case scenario, maybe we would not have had the current crisis. However, even this is not without serious problems:</p><p>1) The most obvious problem is the rush in the trains and buses would also provide fertile grounds for the spread of the virus. This seems to suggest that a mere preponement would not have addressed the problem of large numbers of people being in very close contact. In fact, it is possible that in this scenario more people would have chosen to return ‘home’ due to trains and buses being available. At the moment, it is quite likely that only the most desperate are taking the perilous route home</p><p>2) While it is true that India does not have a Wuhan like epicenter, the virus was imported into the country via people returning from other countries. International travel is limited to certain sections of Indian society and is likely to be highly concentrated in large cities or certain prosperous states. Most of the internal migrants would be traveling from these very prosperous parts of the country to poorer parts with weaker health infrastructure. If it is going to be tough for Maharashtra to deal with the surge of Covid cases, it is going to be almost impossible for Bihar. Facilitating travel to the hinterland would spread the infection to the poorest parts of the country and with more people traveling the spread would be faster.</p><p>3) In times of rapid change, it would be unreasonable to expect that all information would be available to all decision-makers. It is very likely that many who did not choose to travel in the 7 day moratorium period will subsequently change their minds. Driven either by the continual decrease in economic activity or simply by the desire to be home, around near and dear ones in this time of great danger.</p><p>This alternative scenario does not seem to be leading to outcomes that are any better than the one that is currently playing out. Further, the economic impact of the lockdown would not be any less severe in the counterfactual than it currently is. The sight of people cramming into trains might not be as heart-rending as the visual of people walking across state boundaries, but it is not clear that prior intimation of the lockdown would have alleviated the problems we face today. In fact, it might have made things worse. The option to call off the lockdown or to not have had one in the first place would have also likely disproportionately affected the people that are currently suffering the most.</p><p><strong>What now?</strong></p><p>While historical hypotheticals are useful in guiding future policy decisions, and there will be a time very soon when these questions will have to be asked again. But very rarely can the clock be turned back and insights gained be used to address the problem at hand. What might still help address the current problem, if the argument in favor of lockdown is persuasive enough, is setting up temporary camps with provisions of food and water and more importantly, testing. Once it is established that the person carries no risk, arrangements for travel can be made via trains to the capitals of their respective states. These arrangements must be made by the central government to avoid any inter-state haggling. Once in their state capitals, state governments can make arrangements for people to get back home.</p><p>The hurried decision on behalf of some state governments to arrange for buses without adequate measure to test the ones traveling might come back to haunt the government. But it is not without cause, for most of us the pictures and videos are heartbreaking, for elected politicians they can be career-ending. In fact, as the crisis unfolds, the central government seems to be withdrawing many of its initial curbs. Apart from the lack of administrative capacity, it is tough to understand this worst of both worlds approach: we suffer the worst of the lockdown, as the virus continues to spread and will eventually bring more hardships, economic and otherwise. An oft-repeated statement is recent times is that in the fight against Coronavirus, a society is only as strong as its weakest link. The way forward is to strengthen the weakest link and try as best we can to fortify them against starvation and the risk of being infected.</p><p>A friend recently pointed out that societies tend to pass down stories of past calamities to make sure that the next generation is prepared. In government, that institutional memory is codified in the idiom; look back, move forward. In the face of any abnormal circumstances, find previous instances of similar problems and draw on the experience of people who lived through times. In the present crisis, I believe our collective societal memory has failed us. Governments and citizens alike are <a href="https://encouragingarguments.blogspot.com/2020/03/on-decision-making-in-global-pandemic.html">ill-equipped</a> and <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/why-covid-19-testing-has-been-slow-to-take-off/articleshow/74859149.cms">ill-prepared</a> to deal with this crisis. In times like these, it is best to remember that there no good outcomes, only bad and very bad ones. Winston Churchill, after leading the UK to victory in WWII, lost the subsequent election. In this global war against an unseen enemy, the leader <a href="https://winstonchurchill.org/resources/myths/coventry-what-really-happened/">who leads their people to victory</a> may not end up being the most popular one, history though, will remember.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/0*1qAkZVXQiGysbFED.png" /><figcaption>Thoughts and Predictions from March 18th, 2020</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fdb510968231" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the Gift of Time]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vatsalyasrivastava/on-the-gift-of-time-bbb608302eaa?source=rss-70a8f1ffd90c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bbb608302eaa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[time]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gifts]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[valentines-day]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vatsalya Srivastava]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Feb 2017 02:57:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-14T19:41:30.529Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(Why should this busy world waste its time on me?)</p><p><em>Masroof zamana kyun mujhpe,</em></p><p><em>Waqt apna barbaad kare?</em></p><p><em>-Kabhi Kabhi (1976)</em></p><p><strong>Premise</strong></p><p>24 hours in a day, 7 days in a week and 52 weeks in a year. In a world increasingly beset by inequalities, time is an equal opportunity provider. It does not care if you are rich or poor, party-animal or recluse, slacker or workaholic. Warren Buffet, Elon Musk and I, all get the same amount of time. There is no new technology, no app, that can (yet?) increase the time available to us. There is however plenty that modern technology has done to place increasing demands on our time. The choice of things to do available to anyone with a smart phone is enormous: from playing candy crush to writing a book; offering almost endless possibilities to amuse and entertain ourselves. All these possibilities make it very difficult to value time.</p><p>A commonly used measure of value is money. The money value of time suggests that the time of a high-flying corporate executive is much more valuable than of a retiree. But the retiree could spend his time watching a movie instead of indulging his/her grandchild. To the extent that our individual valuations are affected by options available, in recent times the premium on everyones time has gone through the roof. There is always something ‘better’ that we could be doing, learning, being more productive, watching a movie, playing a game, browsing Facebook. 15 years ago, if there was no good show on TV at 6pm in the evening, the most common way to pass-time was to go meet friends (real people, not the show). Today, they could just look up re-runs of friends (the show).</p><p><strong>People and Time</strong></p><p>Spending time with people is messy business. In some case the complaints never seem to end, in others unbounded enthusiasm and zest for living seem to be based on distorted sense of reality. Either experience may trigger a negative evaluations of our own lives. People can also be terribly boring, not all of them funny and almost no one seems to get the idea that timing is the essence of humor. Then there are the troubles of trying to figure out what is appropriate and what is not, leading to many an awkward silence. There are those insufferable know-it-alls, the ones who just cannot stop arguing over trivial matters, the ideologues and if you have spent any time in the US recently, those who cant stop talking about trump. People also seem to have this tendency to impose negative externalities; shrill voice, second hand smoke, body odor, farts, grumbling stomach sounds. Spending time with people also imposes compromises. Its Tuesday and the special at this Chinese place is always great, but no one else seems to like it and so the Thai place it is.</p><p>All of this is made infinitely worse by the possibilities offered by a computer. The comic timing of all the characters in (your show/movie/game of choice) is always spot on. They do not bore you with their problems in life and even when they do, the drama is exquisitely scripted. You can eat anything you like (and can pay for) while watching them and there are no awkward silences. And if a show is too preachy, or a movie is too slow or a game is not engaging enough, its not much effort to change to a different one. You could also choose to be productive instead, why bother with characters when you can gorge on knowledge. Sate your curiosity with something that places no demands on you. You can still eat anything you like (and can pay for), zone out as frequently as you like and wikipedia still lets you click your way through millions of pages of information. Better still you could use the time to make sure that you do better at your job, write a better academic paper, get your PhD quicker. In fact, given how difficult and frustrating it is to spend some time with another human-being compared to the alternatives, it is astonishing to think that we evolved as social creatures.</p><p><strong>The gift of time</strong></p><p>By now this may seem like another bleak prognosis of the impact of technology on human society. But I am trying to address a much more important question: What is a good valentine’s day gift? Is a bouquet of roses the best expression of your love? Or if you are the sort who does not restrict their celebration of valentines day to romantic love, how expensive should a greeting card for your mother be to adequately convey your love for her? Maybe it should it a sari this time, given that you have started earning. Or maybe given your recent wanderlust, a package tour to (fill in a fun/interesting place). How about your friends? A message on the Whatsapp group should be enough. To the really special ones, maybe a pm on Facebook, maybe even an email if its been a while.</p><p>In fact these concerns are not specific to valentine’s day. We frequently struggle with the general problem of valuing relationships. How do we convey to someone that we value them and conversely, how to we figure out how much others values us? My contention is that only reasonable way to convey how much we value a relationship is with time. No amount of money or hard-work will make 1 hour of time less than 1 hour of time. This is specially true today when there is so much else that we could be doing with our time. Every moment spent talking to someone is time that could have been spent watching your favorite show or learning how to program better or working towards that big promotion.</p><p>A rich/spendthrift partner or spouse maybe able to splurge on trip. Does that mean that they value you more that someone who is poorer/stingier? Is the friend who gets you a job a better friend than the one who is struggling to hold onto his own? On the other hand; we all have time, we all have fixed amounts of it and it has become more valuable to everyone given the choices that we have today. Time offers a better way to both convey how much we value someone and to figure out how much someone values us.</p><p>The uncle who spent hours indulging you, the mother who gets up an hour early to make the breakfast you like, the father who spends his evening teaching you how to play cricket properly, the friend who finds time for a call, the sibling who suffers your long stories are the people who are more likely to value you and the relationship you share with them. We are all difficult people to spend time with and its tempting to sit by your computer browsing through valentines day catalogs to find gifts to give away. But this valentine’s day gift some time to the people you love, see how that goes.</p><p>PS: In fact sometimes how much we value a relationship maybe determined by the time we spend on it. Like any precious resource, there is always risks related to investment of time. But the payoffs maybe high, how much of risk taker are you?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bbb608302eaa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On the weak Indian state and Demonetization]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vatsalyasrivastava/on-the-weak-indian-state-and-demonetization-f06941746a0e?source=rss-70a8f1ffd90c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f06941746a0e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[state]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[demonetization]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vatsalya Srivastava]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 23 Nov 2016 13:33:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-23T15:12:56.806Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In recent times, the current Indian PM seems to have become a proxy for the state for both his supporters and detractors. While such a simplification might be useful for the rhetoric used by both the sides, it does little to hide the fact that despite being used often, the concept of the ‘<em>state</em>’ remains nebulous in India. When negotiating compensation for acquired land, PSU officials (even those from private firms in some instances) are presumed to be state actors. While on the other hand, our movies have been telling us for years that the ineffectiveness of our police is down to the ‘system’ (a common pseudonym for the state) being flawed, implying that the police is somehow separate from the state.</p><p>The many discussions on what the state is, its constituent elements and the many forces and counter-forces within it, can at times obfuscate the reality of the Indian state being very weak. The limitations of state capacity are apparent in its inability to ensure that teachers turn up at government schools and that doctors are present at health care centers. The state struggles to provide basic amenities like roads and electricity despite spending huge amounts of money on grandiose projects. This sorry state of affairs in the country has far too often been blamed on the lack of willingness of behalf of the state. But as I have argued before (refer <a href="http://encouragingarguments.blogspot.nl/2015/12/on-mobs-law-and-intent_17.html"><strong>On Tolerance: Intention and Verification</strong></a>), assuming mal-intent where ineptitude is more obvious is more an indulgence for our love of gossip than an exercise of our logical faculties.</p><p>If the state lacks the capacity to implement, what good are policies, irrespective of the intent behind them. This creates a conundrum for a government democratically elected on the promises of better governance and crackdown against corruption. Corruption is endemic due to poor governance structures and governance is poor due to corruption. A vicious circle ensues, which (even if the government has good intentions) is almost impossible to break. In this vacuum of policy options before the government, enter <em>demonetization</em>.</p><p>Fiat currency works purely on trust. I accept a Rs. 100 note because I am certain that when I give it to someone else, he/she too will accept and value it at Rs. 100. The problems of counterfeiting aside, this system of trust works because the state (central bank) provides a guarantee that even if no one else honors a currency note, the central bank will. Therefore, if the state revokes this guarantee for some currency denominations, the trust that underpins its acceptance breaks down. Therefore demonetization offers the government a policy alternative which does not rely on the state’s enforcement capacity. The act of announcing the strategy (withdrawing the central bank guarantee) ensures that it will be enforced (at least in the medium run).</p><p>Does any of this imply that demonetization is a good policy initiative? No, it does not, that’s an empirical question. This article merely offers a view on how this could be one of the few enforceable/implementable policy decisions that are available to a weak state. As for whether it will achieve its stated goals, or if it will cause more harm than good, that is a discussion for another day.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f06941746a0e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>