<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Robert Shepherd on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Robert Shepherd on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@vegetablelove?source=rss-d4d0de093bdc------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 17:23:26 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@vegetablelove/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[People don’t know about the reality of Dyspraxia.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vegetablelove/people-dont-know-about-the-reality-of-dyspraxia-91409a8876da?source=rss-d4d0de093bdc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/91409a8876da</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[representation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[doctor-who]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dyspraxia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Shepherd]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Oct 2018 19:08:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-08T19:08:51.850Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>People don’t know about the reality of Dyspraxia. That’s why we need fictions like Doctor Who’s Ryan Sinclair</h3><p>I am 31 years old and so this anecdote is embarrassing, but I was woken up this morning by my father excitedly telling me that Doctor Who has a new companion that has dyspraxia. And <em>I</em> have dyspraxia! Loads of people do! But not very many fictional people, until now. Indeed, Ryan what travels with the Doctor is the only character with the condition I’m aware of in anything at all, so him turning up in a massive franchise feels a very significant thing.</p><p>There’s an obvious reason, of course, why there aren’t very many fictional characters who have dyspraxia – most people have no idea that the condition exists, or that it persists beyond childhood and on through the rest of your life. And that in turn means that there are more or less no resources for adults with dyspraxia at all – very few self-help books, not many online resources, no real prominent ambassadors of any kind. Last year I had to organise an adult dyspraxia awareness session, and it took forever because we couldn’t find anyone who was aware enough of the condition to run it. Against this, it’s easy to feel like the world’s forgotten you exist, and to think your struggles really are only in your head after all. So it’s great to see any kind of fictional character with the condition anywhere at all, because this is a condition that does not have a representative.</p><p>I’m happy that he’s this specific fictional character, though. I remember first watching Doctor Who back in 2005, the last time the Doctor was northern. And I imagined what would happen if I was that Doctor’s companion, which was obvious: I would die. More than that, perhaps, I would cause a galactic level catastrophe; I’d imagine Christopher Eccleston looking at the burning ruins of the Earth while I tried to explain I’d pushed a button wrong. When that Doctor said that he’d only take the best, in my head the implication was clear – he would only take someone who wouldn’t invite disaster, and so he would never take a young man who was anything like me.</p><p>Because this is what living with the condition is like. Graham’s line in Doctor Who about blaming an alien invasion on your dyspraxia is painful because catastrophe really does seem to follow in our wake. Having it has meant having to run into a packed classroom to tell the teacher I’ve set her office on fire with a blender; that I’ve turned up to job interviews with all the buttons of my shirt done up wrong. Not crossing a road except at the lights, having to give up science when you pour mutant flies over your face. Dyspraxia is a slow stream of disasters that make it difficult to live in the world, which mean you have to let go of any concept of pride or dignity to have any hope to survive.</p><p>And it’s smaller things, too. For Ryan, it means he’s an adult that can’t ride a bike, even though managing to is of great personal importance to him. For me, it means I can’t tie my shoelaces or click my fingers, will probably never be able to drive or put on a tie. It means a lot of small things that everyone can do are things that I can’t do, and that the reason that I can’t isn’t obvious or even easy to understand. It means you spend a huge amount of time hiding what you can’t do, and it means you end up being very tired.</p><p>And you end up very anxious, too. As last night’s <em>Doctor Who</em> accurately shows, even people who love you may believe you can overcome dyspraxia by trying hard enough, and this means you will always be in fear of <em>judgment</em>. It’s one of these conditions that has the misfortune to affect the bits of you people imagine are controlled by free will – and that means you’re <em>not trying enough</em> if nothing you do will make it better. But the situations dyspraxia affects can turn up suddenly and unpredictably enough that you never know when they’ll happen; when a thing you can’t do will stream along and you’ll have to find a way to try and explain it. You end up always on edge, never quite relaxing. It’s hard to explain the reality of a condition that no one knows is real.</p><p>So I want to see Ryan be a hero with dyspraxia, because even now I don’t know what that means. The everyday world can be a terrifying place for us anyway, but lord knows what the Whoniverse would be like: when dimensions can be even weirder than they are almost all the time, where the Daleks can handle the stairs and you’re afraid you’re about to fall down them. It can feel an achievement and an adventure just getting through the day, but I want to know that we can have adventures, too: that the skills we have and the things we can achieve are more important than the things we’re always reminded are beyond us. I want Ryan to save the entire universe, and I want him to keep his dignity when he does. I want him to be the hero I wish existed when I was a child, and who only started to exist yesterday. There are unspoken and unknown things that so many of us are going through.</p><p>I want to see that this one can be overcome.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=91409a8876da" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A property company told us some vital things about nuclear war]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vegetablelove/a-property-company-told-us-some-vital-things-about-nuclear-war-edfaf1f0c0c1?source=rss-d4d0de093bdc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/edfaf1f0c0c1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nuclear]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nuclear-war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[north-korea]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nuclear-weapons]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Shepherd]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Aug 2017 22:42:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-11T22:42:50.371Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/582/1*jl_PSp_rkoqs_Wrw48IB_g.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>(</em><strong><em>Content warning</em></strong><em>: this article is depressing, and discusses the annihilation of you and everyone you love.)</em></p><p>So I saw recently that property company <a href="http://emoov.com/">emoov.com</a> have taken advantage of current tensions between America and North Korea by <a href="http://www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/news/bizarre-map-reveals-best-place-in-yorkshire-to-avoid-ww3-nuclear-missile-strike-1-8696740">putting out a press release</a> suggesting some places to move within Britain to avoid the effects of nuclear war. The release shows a map of the island with its 20 largest cities all hit by nuclear bombs, with the area each bomb affects mapped out in a giant circle. In so doing, it indicates which places you might move to avoid a firey end — perhaps through using the services of emoov, whose material you’re reading right now! This is a very crass thing to do, of course, and it’s been rightly and widely condemned. What interested me, however, wasn’t that was ill-judged — but that it got things very wrong.</p><p>The most obvious way in which this is the case is that the press release overestimates the size of a nuclear blast by an insanely massive degree. The bomb they’ve detonated 20 times is the one with the largest yield any warhead’s ever had — the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsar_Bomba">Tsar Bomba</a>, which has over 50 times the yield of the largest nuke the US has, let alone anything in the North Korean arsenal. And, well, it’s not entirely clear where esteemed military analyst emoov thinks these bombs are being fired from. Presumably it’s North Korea, but the most generous estimate of the number of atom bombs they have is about 60 — so they’ve fired a third of what they have at a country that’s not the US or any of the South-East Asian countries they have tensions with. That doesn’t seem like a very probable scenario, property purchasing site!</p><p>A few journalists and other people on Twitter raised objections to the release along the lines of “This is silly”, so I guess that’s good. What concerned me a little, however, was that some of the objections were also wrong. Someone said that if the UK did come under nuclear attack, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMNB_Clyde">Faslane</a> would certainly be a target, while others thought that bombing less glamorous cities like Aberdeen or Hull would be a bit of a waste of precious missiles. Both of these ideas betray serious misunderstandings about how a real nuclear war might play out, but sadly the reasons why are very depressing.</p><h3><strong>Two depressing facts about nuclear war</strong></h3><p>An important note before these depressing facts: what follows is based on imagining the UK comes under attack by a country with hundreds of very powerful nuclear missiles, and this doesn’t describe North Korea now. Really it would probably only apply if we were attacked by Russia, which <a href="https://www.vox.com/2015/6/29/8845913/russia-war">is sadly not a completely impossible scenario.</a></p><h4>A nuclear attack might focus on cities, not military targets</h4><p>There are two broad ways to fight a nuclear war: taking a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counterforce">counterforce approach</a> or taking <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countervalue">a countervalue one</a>. These are very bland names for two very horrible things: <em>counterforce </em>means “destroying the places of military use in a country” and <em>countervalue </em>is a psychopathic term meaning “destroying all the cities where hundreds of thousands of people live”. Why would you ever do the second thing?</p><p>Well, there are two reasons. The first is that your state might have already been totally destroyed by the warheads of the country you’re targeting, or be about to be destroyed by warheads that are already on the way. It makes a lot of sense to blow up a place full of nuclear missiles while they’re sitting there about to be launched at you, but it doesn’t make any sense to destroy somewhere that’s fired them all already. In that situation, you’d focus on doing as much damage to your enemy as possible: destroying as many heavily populated places as they could.</p><p>The second is the possibly questionable idea that targeting cities makes nuclear war less likely. If you only aim at military targets, your enemy might think “Well, if I fire my missiles now I’ll destroy my adversary’s entire military and make it much less likely he can retaliate — why, I might just be able to <em>win</em> this nuclear war!” Targeting cities is supposed to make them think that nobody wins: that regardless of how much damage they could do, the losses they’d end up incurring are far too great to contemplate. So threatening such a horrific level of destruction means it doesn’t happen at all, until of course it does in an unimaginably horrendous way.</p><p>It’s quite possible that a real-life nuclear attack on a country would involve a mix of counterforce and countervalue: Faslane gets hit, but so does Sheffield and everybody living there. But the point is that an attacker doesn’t necessarily consider Faslane a more <em>important </em>target than Sheffield, because “killing lots of people and destroying all their things” might actually be their main priority. And in a nuclear war between two powers with thousands of missiles, quite a lot of places are going to get hit:</p><h4>Yes, Hull gets hit in a nuclear war</h4><p>Nobody really cares about Hull, unless of course it has huge military importance and I don’t know about it. But let’s imagine that it doesn’t: why are you firing nuclear missiles at it? Well, because if you’re firing the missiles at all, <em>very soon you’re not going to have any anymore</em>. If you’re engaged in a nuclear war with a power with a large enough arsenal, your state is about to cease to exist; there isn’t much point in keeping missiles back to guard the charred hellscape that remains. So you fire everything you have: several at places like enemy capitals to make extra sure they get hit, but some at more minor cities as well, more or less as an afterthought.</p><p>I think this is one of the most depressing things in the famously quite-depressing field of nuclear war, and I don’t think it gets discussed enough. I find it unbearably sad to think of hundreds of thousands of people dying and hundreds of years of culture destroyed more or less because someone thought they might as well use up their weapons, but that may indeed be the fate that many of us end up meeting.</p><h3>Property company emoov and our blindness to nuclear scale</h3><p>Of course, Hull probably isn’t going to get hit in a nuclear war with North Korea, unless China and/or Russia get sucked in as I guess they might. But that in itself illustrates something important: emoov’s press release was able to show lots of British cities getting hit because of how one nuclear war is much the same as another in our minds. I saw lots of people share <a href="http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1946/08/31/hiroshima">this article about Hiroshima</a> as the current nuclear threat began to escalate, and that makes sense: what happened there is so horrific that it seems to sit beyond the most awful thing any of us can comprehend. But that’s a problem, because modern nuclear war is much worse — if warheads are dropped on Pyongyang, they will likely be 100 times more powerful than the bombs that fell on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.</p><p>And turning things the other way: because every nuclear war is already beyond the level of maximum awfulness we can accidentally assume that all possible nuclear wars would lead to the annihilation of civilisation. But one between the US and North Korea probably wouldn’t; it would “just” lead to several cities being destroyed and an entirely new geopolitical landscape. We don’t really have the mental language to process this, and it shows. The National Interest rightly got a lot of stick for <a href="http://nationalinterest.org/feature/dont-believe-the-hype-about-the-north-korea-threat-21825">its article that treated the prospect of a US/NK war in a fairly blasé way</a>, as people effectively thought it was saying the total destruction of Seattle wouldn’t be so bad. And of course it would be unthinkably awful, the most horrific thing to have happened on American soil ever. But compared to what a nuclear war with Russia would mean — where <em>all </em>major cities are destroyed… well, it <em>wouldn’t </em>be so bad, because there is still a scale of how awful something is that operates at this magnitude of awfulness. I’m not sure we’ve thought much at all about how to live in a world where America survives a very limited nuclear war, and if that’s the world we’re enter we’re going to have to start thinking about this whole subject in a different way.</p><h3>Nuclear war as a fact in the world</h3><p>Let’s go back to emoov’s press release as it pings its way to the horrified newsdesks of our isle. Why do the people who open it find it shocking? The obvious answer is that nuclear war <em>is </em>shocking, but I think there’s more to it than that: I think it shocks us because on some level we think of it as fantastical. Our lives are relatively secure, and it’s easy to think they’ll continue to be so: that most of us will live on and grow old and die in the way the people around us do right now. Nuclear weapons exist only as images; greyed out photos we turn away from, or cartoon apocalypses we file next to zombie uprisings and alien invasions. It’s embarrassing to admit, but as someone born in the late eighties I’m not sure I really <em>knew </em>nuclear weapons existed until I read Eric Schlosser’s harrowing <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/6452798-command-and-control?from_search=true">Command and Control</a> weeks before Russia annexed Crimea in early 2014. It’s one thing to read that a nuclear weapon can destroy a city, but quite another to realise there’s not anything stopping that from happening to <em>your</em> city, then mapping out through geography you know the extent of the destruction that would be caused. But of course, those weapons had been pointed at me all my life. <a href="http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-40901746">Trump’s comments that the US military is locked and loaded to fight North Korea</a> are intemperate to say the least, but nuclear weapons are <em>always</em> locked and loaded, ready to fire at more or less a moment’s notice. Very possibly one is aimed at you now, very possibly many are. It’s the reality of living in most big cities in the Northern Hemisphere, and its one many of us are unaware of or deny.</p><p>This becomes possible, I think, because of the <em>invisibility </em>of the nuclear threat. There are missiles trained on us now, but they’re thousands of miles away, and as long as they don’t fire they have no real impact on our lives at all. But a worrying addition to this is that if the missiles <em>almost </em>fire they don’t have any real impact either, even if we were all briefly in the most terrible danger. This week I saw someone on Twitter say we were closer to nuclear war than we have been in 55 years. It’s terrifying that this can be said and be widely accepted. Nuclear war has almost happened by accident a number of times: in <a href="http://gizmodo.com/the-computer-simulation-that-almost-started-world-war-i-1686123550">1979</a>, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1983_Soviet_nuclear_false_alarm_incident">twice</a> in <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Able_Archer_83">1983</a>, in <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norwegian_rocket_incident">1995</a>. In all these cases, had war erupted it would have been far more deadly than one between America and North Korea would probably be, to the point that very possibly there would be no humans on the planet at all. But we don’t tend to talk or know about that astonishing fact — <em>that everyone almost died through accident, at least four times in living history</em> — and the lack of impact something that huge has suggests to me that there is something within us that resists accepting it. And I have an idea as to what it might be:</p><h3><strong>Nuclear war and the narrative of history</strong></h3><p>We like to think of ourselves as rational people, and to an extent we are. But we’re also creatures who are very fond of stories, and sometimes our stories overwhelm our rationality without us even realising what’s going on. History, to a lot of us, is one such story. It’s easy to think of it as a process of inevitable human progress, where we start out in caves and end up conquering the stars. The fact we have a standard mental image of the future as full of spaceships and astronauts probably compounds this — on some level we can start thinking that this is where history is going, even as an increasing amount of evidence begins to suggest otherwise. But of course, history can just stop: an asteroid could slam into us right now and wipe everyone out just like that. Or, more probably, a malfunction in the vast network of city-destroying missiles that have existed on our planet for years ends up killing us all, in a manner that has almost happened several times before.</p><p>But, well, that’s a rubbish story. “Humans built a global civilisation that progressed for thousands of years, then suddenly ended due to an administrative inefficiency in Russia” doesn’t resonate in the way “Humans built a global civilisation that endured for millions of years” is. I guess that’s largely because of how we fit in to all this: an enduring civilisation is one we can influence or even save, whereas one which just uncontrollably <em>ends </em>without warning is one that can annihilate any sense of purpose at all. And of course it’s worse than that, because the annihilation also takes place on a personal scale. The accidental nuclear war destroys the business you built from scratch, obliterates the screenplay you’ve been working on for years, kills your children and terminates the concept of their future. That’s, well, that’s <em>depressing, </em>so it’s not surprising we push the evidence away. We are narrative animals before we are rational animals — it’s fundamental to us, and its what will destroy us in the end.</p><p>It’s not just simpletons like me who fall into the narrative trap. Steven Pinker’s <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/11107244-the-better-angels-of-our-nature">The Better Angels of our Nature</a> documents a trend throughout all human history that shows violence steadily decreases throughout time. I have no idea if the trend is real or not, but I don’t really care: what interests me is that in the book Pinker also claims rational thinking resolved the Cuban Missile Crisis. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3lrH7RtiobQ">That’s not what the US Secretary of Defense at the time thought</a>, to put it mildly, but the important point is that <em>these two claims have nothing to do with each other</em>. It’s entirely possible for there to be a trend for human violence to decrease over time, then for an enormous amount of violence to happen suddenly due to accident or dumb luck; the nature of nuclear weapons suggests it’s magical thinking to assert otherwise. But I think the narrative of progress is strong enough that this slides by. Because of course some forms of progress can be real to the point we can look at the evidence and see things tangibly getting better — and that makes it easy to forget that there are things that annihilate progress that can’t actually be measured, because they only happen once in a way that destroys everyone who’d do the measuring.</p><h3>Does any of this matter?</h3><p>The standard response to the thousands of words I’ve just written about a stupid press release is that all this probably isn’t much worth thinking about. If you don’t die in a nuclear war then worrying about it was a waste of time, and if you do then the worrying didn’t actually solve anything in the end. I think that’s true on a personal level, and important: the implications of what it means that nuclear weapons exist in the same world as your television or your job can crush a human mind to bits, and certainly have done to mine in the past. On a society-wide level, though, I think the illusion of unreality that exists around nuclear weapons has had two fairly corrosive effects.</p><h4>Nuclear policy matters in a democracy</h4><p>“Not dying in a nuclear war” is something I imagine most voters would like to do, so is a relevant thing to discuss before a democratic election. But if people don’t really believe in nuclear war, then it might not be taken as seriously as it should be. I noticed before the election that a lot of people were joking about the idea Trump’s volatility making him more likely to start a nuclear war, even though it was something that was probably true. I think it was a joke rather than a fact because of the sense of unreality we’ve had around this subject, although of course in the present circumstances it seems very like a fact indeed.</p><p>But I think us all having knowledge beyond “nuclear war is a thing that can happen” is important, too. During the 2016 Presidential Election, I saw an alarming number of Americans say that someone would stop President Trump from launching nukes if he ever decided to do it, <a href="https://www.vox.com/2016/8/3/12367996/donald-trump-nuclear-codes">even though the system is more or less set up to stop that happening</a>. Here in Scotland, meanwhile, with a lot of the 2014 Independence debate centering on <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMNB_Clyde">the presence of nuclear weapons on Scottish territory</a> it was concerning to me that a lot of people didn’t seem to know that we’d likely be attacked even if those weapons weren’t here. In the UK more broadly the idea we’d be threatened by any nuclear power is often met with incredulity, but that’s because a lot of people don’t know we’re part of a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_security#Collective_defense">collective defence treaty</a> — under which if, say, China attacked Portugal we might be bound to go to war against the Chinese, even if that ended with nuclear bombs raining down upon our cities.</p><h4>Nuclear weapons affect what it means to be human now</h4><p>This is a more pretentious matter, but then I am a pretentious man. We live in a world that can be destroyed at any time—which almost <em>has </em>been destroyed at any time — but I’m not sure we really have a broad awareness of what that means. On some level we know that we might be killed in a car crash or by some terrorists, but I think most of us expect that the majority of people we know and love will live relatively long and healthy lives. But this might not be true! It might be <em>likely </em>that everything might end suddenly without us really knowing why, and it might be that all of us have far less time left than we’d assumed. That thought can be crippling, but I think it can also be humbling — and more importantly, it can change the way we see the world. In a weird way I’m far more relaxed about the aging process since beginning to think in this way, as before I imagined me slowly approaching my own death in the semi-distant future. Thinking that everyone might die in two months anyway means I don’t really give a shit about that any more; I live more intensely because I know that future might not actually come.</p><p>And also: it makes you aware of the fragility of things. A lot of what I come across in my life is fairly old and has a long history, and it’s easy to think it’ll go on forever because of that. But of course we live in a world where we’ve developed the power to destroy everything, however old or precious it is, and where we might not actually have developed the power to stop it. Being aware that even things that seem very solid and everlasting may actually be ephemeral has made me more keenly appreciative of the world as it exists now, and that, I think, is ultimately a positive thing.</p><h3>An end and a beginning</h3><p>I’m writing this now just before midnight on August 11 2017, looking at the news as nuclear tensions increase. Very possibly, the first nuclear weapons used in war in 72 years will be used in the next 7.2 days. The world and worldviews I’ve been describing might be about to break apart, because we might all be about to be faced with nuclear weapons as an undeniable reality. If that happens, I guess everything I’ve written will describe how we were rather than how we’re going to be, and emoov’s press releases might not work as well as they did before.</p><p>I hope that won’t happen. But I hope as well that more of us confront nuclear weapons as real things, become more aware of the mundane people doing boring jobs and the horrible world they could unlock through turning two keys. I don’t know if it’ll make us happier, and I doubt it’ll make us wiser enough, but I think it would make us more aware of ourselves and the world we live in. It’s astonishing to be part of a species that can invent something like a hydrogen bomb and then forget it exists. I hope I will live to be astonished by that for a great many years still to come.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=edfaf1f0c0c1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A.N. Wilson in the wrongness zone: Defending Charles Darwin]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vegetablelove/a-n-wilson-in-the-wrongness-zone-defending-charles-darwin-17d42d36db2d?source=rss-d4d0de093bdc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17d42d36db2d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[charles-darwin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[darwinism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nature]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Shepherd]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 06 Aug 2017 14:52:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-06T14:52:02.626Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AZhnihGBwwPP-mXiHBco7Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Like a lot of aspiring comment writers, I spend a lot of time writing about things I have no technical or personal knowledge of in the hope that no one will ever come along and notice. Largely, that’s because my life has been a combination of making terrible mistakes and having enough privilege to get out of the craters that they made: writing about my personal experiences is rage-inducing both to readers who didn’t make any mistakes or who didn’t have the blind luck to have the ones they made be rectified. But once in a while the stars align and writing about my own idiocy can be productive instead of self-loathing, and that seems to have happened thanks to some journalist having terrible views about Victorian scientist Charles Darwin.</p><p>I’ll explain: I see that A.N. Wilson has written this article in <a href="http://www.standard.co.uk/comment/comment/it-s-time-charles-darwin-was-exposed-for-the-fraud-he-was-a3604166.html?amp">the Evening Standard about how Darwin is a terrible fraud</a>. Wilson says he’s spent five years mastering Darwin’s ideas, which is a bit alarming given the quality of his piece, and I guess that’s a similar length of time to the one I spent studying evolution and natural selection at university. My own experience was fairly miserable in a way I hope that Wilson’s wasn’t, but it illuminated an important way in which I think he’s got a small thing right, but in doing so ended up getting a much larger thing wrong.</p><p>In his article, Wilson says that Darwin is more or less worshiped by a lot of people, and loads a lot of rhetoric behind this claim. I think that this is probably true. In hindsight, the reasons I chose to study evolution at university were probably also based on rhetoric; I read a lot of Richard Dawkins’ work and got a bit swept away by it. I think in my head I thought being an evolutionary biologist would involve spending about 90% of my time shouting at religious people and 10% looking smug at dinners.</p><p>But this, of course, is not the case. The obvious fact I’d overlooked is that evolutionary biology is an actual science, and a fairly hard one, and that what it mostly involves is reams and reams of peer-reviewed evidence that doesn’t mention Darwin much at all. To actual evolutionary biologists, the mechanisms Darwin postulated aren’t held to be true out of reverence to the man — who no one really gives a shit about; evolution students are actively discouraged from reading <em>The Origin of Species</em> — but out of them being observed in multiple different ways in multiple different species, often in ways that are searingly mundane.</p><p>Because the key thing I think Wilson is wrong about is that <em>actually being an evolutionary biologist isn’t very sexy</em>. It’s about looking at genetics or fossils or flies that end up jumping over your face and drawing inferences based on those. It’s probably true that if we stopped to think about the implications of evolution and natural selection we’d all stop and say “Gosh”, but the honest truth is that those fade into the background against the day to day process of science. I know this because I didn’t understand it would be the case; I <em>wanted </em>to be the sort of person Wilson poo-poos in his article. But in the end it turned out being a scientist isn’t anything like that, so I decided to give up and do something entirely different instead.</p><h3>But A.N Wilson is wrong in loads of other ways</h3><p>While I ended up getting out of evolutionary biology because I’d got into it for incredibly stupid reasons, I did study hard as an undergraduate, and I do remember at least some of what I learned along the way. And so when reading A.N. Wilson’s article I was still able to go “But that’s <em>wrong</em>!” at several points. I will now go through all these, on the off chance you are interested. It’s worth saying that it’s eight years since I studied all this and will very possibly make some errors along the way, so if any actual evolutionary biologists tell you something I’ve said is wrong they are very probably right. I’m not an authority on any of this; I just know enough about it that I’m not going to claim myself as one in a widely distributed newspaper.</p><h4>Evolution and natural selection are not the same thing</h4><p>This is the most important thing that Wilson slides around in his article. He correctly says that loads of people before Darwin had the idea that organisms might change over time, but carefully omits that this insight isn’t the heart of what Darwin’s theory was about. Darwin was (sort of) the first person to advocate <em>natural selection</em> — where some traits are statistically more likely to survive than others, and these traits spread through a population of organisms over time. Wilson mentions “natural selection” once in his article, which is weird, as it’s natural selection we all focused on as science students rather than anything Darwin himself thought or said or did.</p><p>It’s probably fair to say that some people are overly adamant in saying natural selection is the only driving force in evolution — indeed, at evolution school we spent some time talking about cases where the process could be wrongly assumed to be operating. But it’s not fair to say that natural selection isn’t the major driving force in the process, or that it doesn’t exist at all! Evolutionary biologists would reject that idea, but they’d reject it because there’s loads of evidence of natural selection happening — whether that’s over the vast span of life’s history or literally in their own laboratories.</p><h4>There are good reasons why genetics revitalised Darwinism</h4><p>Wilson’s article says, correctly, that Darwin’s star faded a bit in the early 20th century then sparked up again at the advent of genetic science. The incredibly important thing it <em>doesn’t </em>say<em> </em>is that the reason this happened is that genetics was amenable to the concept of natural selection. Darwin’s theory is about traits in an organism being passed down to its offspring, but for that to actually work there needs to be a mechanism that allows it to take place. When Darwin was writing nobody knew that anything like this existed, so the idea that it <em>did </em>had to be more or less taken on faith. That changed with the discovery of DNA: it turned out that traits could be passed on in a manner that could be both quantified and studied. And the establishment of genetic science revealed — in a really important development Wilson doesn’t mention — that natural selection could be directly observed, in a way Darwin would have had no idea of!</p><p>A lot of Wilson’s article slides round mentioning important facts, and this is one of them. Darwinism became more relevant with the advent of genetics — but it did so because that advent allowed his ideas to be verified in ways that couldn’t have happened before. Natural selection is NOT universally acknowledged, says Wilson — but among evolutionary biologists it kind of is, because genetics allows us to investigate the processes of evolution as well as its results.</p><h4><strong>The rapid change of species isn’t a challenge to natural selection</strong></h4><p>Wilson alludes to Stephen Jay Gould’s concept of <em>punctuated equilibrium </em>without mentioning it by name, but badly distorts what that idea actually is. The way the article is phrased suggests that Gould believed species literally spontaneously changed — that at one point in the history of life you’d see a ray-finned fish, and then you’d come back the next day to see it had grown legs. But that’s not true: Gould just believed that natural selection would only drive significant observable change in certain situations, but would do so rapidly whenever those situations arose.</p><p>For example. Take a population of hares in a big field of grass. For ages, they stay the same colour because there’s no reason they shouldn’t: they’re relatively well-camouflaged against the predators that might be searching for them. But OH NO: suddenly there’s an Ice Age, and the grassy field is covered in snow! Now the hares stand out against their environment, so natural selection begins to act on their colour — but when it does so, it does so <em>rapidly. </em>In this (and many other) cases, natural selection hasn’t happened in a gradual way because the changes driving it haven’t been gradual; it happens in a stop-start way because the wider forces influencing it happen like that too.</p><p>It’s really important to stop here and say that “gradual” in evolutionary terms still means “a really, really long time” in normal-speak. Punctuated equilibrium is about change happening over thousands rather than millions of years. It’s also important to mention that Wilson is wrong when he says there are no transitional forms — there are lots, but when you show them to someone who doesn’t believe in them they say “Ah, but what about the transitional form between <em>that </em>fossil and this frog I am looking at right now?” There’s no way to satisfy that argument without having a fossil of literally all the animals in a long evolutionary line, but I’m not sure it follows that the argument is especially strong.</p><h4>“Survival of the fittest” doesn’t mean what Wilson thinks it means</h4><p>Wilson says something lots of people say, which is that natural selection inherently implies ruthlessness. But that’s not really true; it just implies that whatever’s good at surviving over a long period of time tends to survive. If ruthlessness is really bad at surviving, it won’t endure — I guess that’s also true of “being a member of the English aristocracy” if you wanted to boil that down to the language of genetic transmission, although I think that would be a silly thing to do for quite a lot of reasons.</p><p>When Wilson says “Stubbornly, the unfittest survived”, he’s saying something that’s an oxymoron if fitness is used in its technical sense. Members of a population whose offspring survive more than others <em>are </em>the fittest, whatever our cultural notions of what “fitness” means might be. An incredibly fat cheetah is the fittest if it outbreeds all the thinner ones, however ridiculous we might think that is, and a really kind sloth is the fittest if it outbreeds a really ruthless one, too.</p><p>I guess you could apply this to people who live now and say that a group of people who tend to have three children is fitter than a group of people who tend to have none. But if you were to do that you’d have to be careful, because generational fitness isn’t the same thing as fitness in the long-term. If someone has three children, those children have three children, then all those children have none, then in the end the first person’s fitness didn’t predict anything about long-term survival. You’d also have to be careful to make sure what you were witnessing was actually happening for genetic reasons. But even then I’m not really sure you could draw a broad lesson about how people “should” be or the way society “should” be structured. Part of the reason is because those decisions also factor into fitness: an effective program to kill blue-eyed people will reduce the fitness of genes for blue eyes, but that doesn’t mean there’s no view of the world where blue-eyes can’t be seen to be worthwhile. As that philosopher whose name I don’t remember said, you can’t draw an ought from an is, and I’m not sure fitness existing as a scientific concept really does anything to change that.</p><h3>My exciting conclusion</h3><p>I think there’s a fairly profound point to be drawn out of my stupid and boring life, which is this: venerating a thing and studying it are two entirely different things, and the existence of loads of veneration for a subject doesn’t mean the people who study it do much of the venerating at all. I think if you want to see that evolution by natural selection is a fact about the world in the same sense anything we experience is, you can do it by spending ages in academia until you want to flame your eyes out with a Bunsen burner. A lot of what you learn will be too technical or boring to end up in a newspaper, and very little of it will entail talking about Darwin or his lovely beard. But you’ll at least understand evolution by natural selection as a technical subject rather than a rhetorical tool, and understand that it actually exists. You shouldn’t actually do that; it’ll be terrible. But at least you’ll end up being able to write a better article for the Evening Standard than someone who didn’t engage with any of this at all.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17d42d36db2d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Knocking and being knocked: On being afraid of doorbells]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vegetablelove/knocking-and-being-knocked-on-being-afraid-of-doorbells-59e0e54fd384?source=rss-d4d0de093bdc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/59e0e54fd384</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[millennials]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Shepherd]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Aug 2017 15:48:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-03T15:48:10.553Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jlS08WB87rGa6x2vNvvSJA.jpeg" /></figure><p>So over the past few days a few people on Twitter — mainly journalists, but some others alongside — have been talking about millennial fear of answering doorbells in a sort of laughing tone of disbelief. Some millennials text in advance before they ring or knock, and this seems incomprehensible: a way of sheltering the snowflake generation from a very mild blast of air.</p><p>I guess from the outside looking in it’s easy to see why. In a similar way to how a learned phobia might seem like an overreaction to someone who doesn’t know about the trauma that underlies it, being afraid of answering a doorbell might look silly if you don’t know what’s really driving the fear. “Young people fought at Dunkirk, and now they can’t answer their doors!”, you might say, without wondering much about the reasons why. And in saying that you might come to think the fear is down to a flaw within young people themselves; that what you’re witnessing is a product of individuals getting worse at dealing with the world. Why, pluck from time the babies who would grow into the boys who fought the World Wars and throw them into the last fifteen years of the Twentieth Century, and today they’d be answering doorbells like there was no tomorrow!</p><p>I don’t think this is actually true, but I’m going to have to draw on my own experiences to say why. And in doing so I’m obviously drawing massive generalities. Certainly, what I’m about to say won’t apply to all millennials, and very possibly it will apply to people who aren’t millennials, too. Someone on Twitter has already pointed out that I don’t speak for everyone, so I thought I’d better point it out myself as well.</p><p>And so: I got the sense from discussion on Twitter that people saw “being afraid of doorbells” as an isolated quirk; a strange quirk of millennials that doesn’t really relate to the position we tend to hold in society. I don’t think that’s true. I think it’s something that’s come about as a result of a particular problem: that wider society does not talk about the challenges in our lives, or validate the feelings we have as a result.</p><p>I think this comes about in a few ways. While on average being we find being adults more of a struggle than our parents did — we have less money in real terms than our parents did, find buying houses to be hard to near-impossible without outside help, and have no real positive view of our future in which we can realistically believe — society’s view of what an adult is doesn’t really seem to have changed. I think social expectations — both our own and other people’s — are still that an adult is someone who has savings and owns a house, who’s able to have children and support them and who’s able to retire after a long working life. Because one or more of these things isn’t true for a lot of us, we start to face dissonance between our own knowledge of who we are and our sense of what everyone thinks we should be — and over time that can begin to have crippling effects. Journalism and politics definitely add to this, I think: if both are full of older people telling you your worries are stupid and your reactions to the world are pathetic, it’s hard not to begin to believe that they must of course be right. If everyone in a position of power in our lives and society believes it’s our fault we can’t achieve unspoken expectations, it’s not that surprising if our internal voices start to say the same.</p><p>And so I don’t think it’s surprising that we begin to dread the times we have to present ourselves as adults. If we have time to prepare, we can think of ways to pretend to people in the outside world that we are successful adults in the manner society still defines, but if we <em>don’t </em>have time to prepare we can begin to panic. If society sneaks up on us they will see through us, to the person we really are. They will see we are not capable of being adults in the world.</p><p>And so when we’re scared of answering the doorbell, I think what we’re really afraid of is <em>having to put on the disguise, and that our disguise is not good enough</em>. The person on the other side of the door may ask why your house is so small, or why you look like shit, or why you’re in your thirties and don’t have all of the things some other people did when they were that age. The person will judge like society judges, and they’ll do it when you have your defences down; in your own house before you’ve had time to prepare yourself for the day ahead. In its loud, shrill alert, a knock or a doorbell turns that fear into something tangible: a horrible sound that’s akin to — that <em>is </em>— an alarm.</p><p>In that context, I think texting ahead to say you’re at the door is a completely reasonable thing to do. It lets someone know that it’s not society knocking at the door to come and laugh at them for a while, but a friend who actually understands and accepts their situation. I think it’s a kind act, and in its own way a powerful one — because it tells them that their reaction is one that’s okay, whatever Hugo Rifkind might say as he writes away in The Times. It’s understandable that it isn’t understood, with the way society talks to itself now. But I think it’s also important to understand that this situation — where one section of a society is basically traumatised by existing in it, and another mocks the ways in which it manifests — is a very dangerous one to be in. Because as time goes on more and more Millennials are going to question their own internalisations of what being an adult means, and at some point we will begin to assert that we should get a say in it. When our voices get loud enough, and when the older generations respond, I think we may end up in tensions between the generations that I can’t really think of a precedent for, and the evidence suggests that many older people are totally unaware of this as a rising problem.</p><p>I guess if I could say anything to people who are older than us, it would be this: sometimes, things we do that appear strange really are peculiarities of ourselves that you probably don’t have to take an interest in. But sometimes they’re symptoms of something deeper, about the way society is and not the way we are, and sometimes they’re signs something damaging to us and to you may happen when that deeper thing starts to rise. Sometimes, it’s better not to laugh at a thing you think is silly. Sometimes, it’s better to be worried about it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=59e0e54fd384" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A letter to older people: Voting for the Tories is no longer in your best interests]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vegetablelove/a-letter-to-older-people-voting-for-the-tories-is-no-longer-in-your-best-interests-461972bbb54c?source=rss-d4d0de093bdc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/461972bbb54c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[general-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2017-general-election]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Shepherd]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 06 Jun 2017 15:57:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-06T15:57:14.809Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>If I were trying to persuade an older person that they shouldn’t vote for the Tories this time round, I would probably say something like this:</p><p>As someone under thirty, when I see people my age asking their parents and grandparents not to vote Conservative I see that they often focus on the future. “Do it for us!”, we might say, and I think we’d be right to say our generation will find things harder if we spend more years under the Tories. But I think this is maybe the first time we could also say “Do it for yourself!”, and that’s the argument I want to focus on here.</p><p>Older people, of course, are the backbone of the Conservative vote, and so Conservative governments tend to do things in their interest. While the past seven years have seen real wages decline in the UK, pensions have held pretty steady: the wealth of the average pensioner has grown while the wealth of the average worker stagnated. And so for the past seven years it’s been in your interest to vote Tory; they’ve kept you stable financially while quite possibly listening to your social concerns as well.</p><p>But you are not, first and foremost, the people who the Conservative party is for. They are, first and foremost, an ideological party: they believe that taxes should be low and the State should be small, that public services should not exist on the scale they currently do. And although it’s not mentioned much, the people who most public services are directed to are people like you: in the UK, they pay towards your pension, your good health, and the social care you may need in the coming years.</p><p>There’s a really big and terrifying misconception a lot of people have that I have to address at this point. You might think that while your pension and healthcare will cost the State a lot in the years to come, they’re costs the State is already equipped to deal with. You’ll likely have paid National Insurance for all your working life, and the idea behind NI is supposed to be that it goes into a big pot of money that pays for things like pensions at the end of your working life. But this isn’t what happens in practice: Governments of all parties have for years spent the money raised through National Insurance in the same way as any other revenue; to maintain the level of public services we’ve been used to in the post-War world. That means that the money set aside for your latter life <em>isn’t there</em>; it’s money people my age will be expected to raise for you. And it’s a pretty vast amount of money: something like half the entire National Debt is a shortfall in payment of future pensions, the level of funding we’ll need to maintain an NHS for an older generation as large as yours is some way beyond the level of funding we have now. Your retirement is going to be expensive, and for it to be of a similar standard to the retirement people enjoy now will place a huge demand on state resources.</p><p>That means that the Tories are now in a situation where your interests no longer coincide with theirs. The cuts of the last seven years have mostly focused on the poor and the young — people who’ll vote for other parties or who can’t vote at all. But we’ve seen in the Tories’ 2015 manifesto that <em>this is no longer enough</em>; for the first time cuts are being proposed that will have a significant effect on your life. Rises in pensions will no longer be as generous as they’ve been before, but more attention has been given to the <em>dementia tax</em>; the proposed policy where the cost of social care for older people will be paid in part by the assets of the old people themselves. The backlash against this policy has limited its scope — at least for now — but I think it’s important to understand that it is the sort of policy that will almost inevitably be advanced in a state where tax revenue shrinks as the cost of social care increases.</p><p>I know a lot of people — perhaps including you — vote for the Tories out of a belief that hard work gets you on: that if you spend a life working long hours and paying your taxes, it’s fair to have a good retirement and to pass the money you’ve made onto your family when you’re gone. And I think politicians do a lot to try and convince people that this is the kind of society low taxes and a small State will create. But I don’t think this is actually true, and I think the dementia tax shows why. I heard there was a caller into a radio show — I don’t remember which one it was — who was horrified at the idea she might need to sell her house to fund her social care. “I’ll burn it down before giving a penny of it to Theresa May!”, she said. But it’s important to understand that there’s a sense in which she wouldn’t be giving any money to Theresa May, because the proposal is simply that the State should stop funding social care to the extent that it does. The idea that you’d have to fund it yourself has nothing to do with Theresa May: it’s what happens when she gets out of the business of care completely, when a person with the misfortune of poor health in their old age has to fund themselves without the State assistance they’d have had in the past. And often what that means is that all the money goes: that you’ll have to sell your house and more besides, that your family won’t inherit much of anything at all. This isn’t a reflection on how hard you’ve worked or how careful you are with your money; it’s just what happens when a system designed to cope with stupid accidents of chance and genetics suddenly goes away. A lot of these systems are already gone, for people my age. I think you should be outraged at the idea they’ll go for you, too.</p><p>I know most of my generation don’t expect any kind of retirement at all. We think things are going in such a way that when we’re old the State funding that exists now for the oldest in society will be a distant memory — if there’s much of a society left at all. We will be expected to work longer hours for less pay in order to fund services that will be available to you and not to us, and the political impact of that may be that services you might assume will exist for you will no longer be there when the time comes. But that’s okay, because the vast majority of us younger people will be voting on Thursday for society to spend more money on these services — so you and your friends and the people you know can spend your retirement in the way you expect and deserve. All that needs to happen is for you to vote in your own self-interest, even if that means not voting for a party that has respected your interests in the past. For my part, I hope you will. I hope you will not vote for the Conservatives.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=461972bbb54c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The UK nuclear deterrent isn’t sensible — it’s a terrible international example]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vegetablelove/the-uk-nuclear-deterrent-isnt-sensible-it-s-a-terrible-international-example-fbca2e24e6c6?source=rss-d4d0de093bdc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fbca2e24e6c6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ge2017]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trident]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[uk-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nuclear-weapons]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Shepherd]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jun 2017 01:31:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-03T01:35:03.984Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pt8HzmdbHrWor1_n5oq9pA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I always get frustrated with discussions about Trident because they seem to take place in a hypothetical world where the only countries involved in a nuclear war are the UK and some other country who happens to be attacking us, but tonight’s Question Time made me think that was dangerous in a way I hadn’t really considered before.</p><p>Background: The UK couldn’t actually defend itself if a foreign army rocked up on our shores and started shooting everyone. But that’s okay, because we’re part of a collective defence agreement that means loads of other countries are obligated to come and shoot that army on our behalf, on the condition that we’d also do the same for them. People ask why we need nukes when Portugal or Germany don’t, and you can sort of kind of argue this is why — that the fact we have them effectively means they do too, because we’re supposed to use them in those countries’ defence should we ever need to for some mad reason. But then America is also part of this agreement, and it has loads of nuclear bombs. Is there a reason we need them as well?</p><p>My understanding is that the answer to this is the obvious one: the government that committed to a UK nuclear deterrent did so because they didn’t think collective defence was real. It’s pretty easy to see why; it’s one thing for the USA to say it would treat an attack on Birmingham the same way it would on New York, but quite another for it to actually follow through. The government that committed to the UK’s nukes did so because they believed — when push came to shove — that the U.S. would not risk its own destruction to save ourselves.</p><p>This, though, means that our defensive position is incoherent in a pretty fundamental way. The reason we don’t spend vastly more on the military than we do is because we believe collective defence works, but the reason so much of what we spend goes on nuclear bombs is because we really believe it doesn’t. I guess one of the reasons discussions around Trident fudge this is because politicians are reluctant to spell out that we could launch nukes because of a threat to a country most of us couldn’t locate on a map, but I realised tonight that it’s also fudged because it’s an argument in favour of nuclear proliferation.</p><p>It’s fairly straightforward, I think. Our argument is that having the hydrogen bomb effectively gives us greater sovereignty; the PM can make a decision to massively retaliate against a country in a way the President of Spain cannot. But if we accept that the PM should have that power — even though there are lots of perfectly good American bombs ready to be fired on his or her behalf — then it’s hard to see why the President of Spain shouldn’t have it, too. It begins to become hard to see why every country in a collective defence agreement shouldn’t have atomic bombs — but then one of the reasons such agreements were set up in the first place was to stop such a situation from happening. A large number of countries with pooled nuclear weapons makes it easy to understand what happens if you invade any of them, but if some of the countries develop their own weapons and some don’t the situation gets more ambiguous. And the more countries that have nuclear weapons, the more complex it becomes to prevent a situation where any of them are used: the number of moving parts increases, the number of potential accidents grows. The step the UK took with Trident is one the other countries of Europe cannot repeat, but when we argue our deterrent is needed for our own defence there’s a sense in which we’re encouraging exactly that.</p><p>I worry about nuclear weapons because I can see collective defence collapsing, and collapsing suddenly. I think there may come a point where a great number of people in the U.S. and UK realise they may be asked to die to defend a small country somewhere, and if that does happen I think the response of the public will be politically devastating. If this does happen then we need to argue that other countries shouldn’t make the decisions around nuclear weapons we did, and that the example we set around them wasn’t noble or sensible or the grown-up thing to do, but an incredible act of irresponsibility in terms of the precedent it sets. I think that becomes less likely the more we talk about our deterrent standing alone, our PM pushing the button, our military independence prioritised. And I think that makes our position a threat; very possibly a global one. It is not Jeremy Corbyn who is promoting these narratives. He is not the one who is making us more unsafe.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fbca2e24e6c6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Annihilation is ecological science fiction. This is why its message matters.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vegetablelove/annihilation-is-ecological-science-fiction-this-is-why-its-message-matters-25fb2fba4f21?source=rss-d4d0de093bdc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/25fb2fba4f21</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jeff-vandermeer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[animals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-book-day]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Shepherd]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 02 Mar 2017 21:42:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-02T21:43:37.639Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NkDMyNeAK-JRZgrYz1tURw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Imagine, if you will, that one day our world began to be radically transformed by creatures with totally alien minds. Further, imagine that they could alter reality in ways we couldn’t explain or even fully understand, and could change the fabric of nature in ways that were ruinous to us. We couldn’t hope to understand their goals: they would exist inside a conception of reality vastly different from our own. All we could do is hunker down, and prepare to try and survive the destruction that would surely follow.</p><p>For all other animals on Earth, this scenario is playing out right now. Their realities frequently alter for reasons that are utterly outside their understanding of the world, because these reasons are ones you would need to be a human being to understand. For example, it’s hard to see how a great crested newt could ever know what Brexit is, <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/83cf8ff0-eef0-11e6-ba01-119a44939bb6">even though it may have a great impact upon her</a>: the concept rests on top of a mountain of other concepts that only humans have, and which an amphibian could never stand any chance of unravelling.</p><p>It’s worth thinking about what this implies. The human world is more alien to a newt than the alien worlds of fiction tend to be to us humans: this maybe has to be true, because the stories any creature creates can only contain concepts and ideas she is capable of conceiving of. But if <em>that’s</em> true, it suggests our experience of real alien minds might be incomprehensible to us, involving our world changing in ways which we simply wouldn’t have the capacity to understand. This is the sort of alien encounter that Jeff VanderMeer’s <em>Annihilation </em>is about.</p><p>The premise of <em>Annihilation</em> is more or less this: some time in the past, a great chunk of America started to <em>change </em>in indefinable ways. This area of land — now referred to as “Area X” — has been evacuated, and now appears to be at once reclaimed by nature and remade by alien artifice, with the natural world within its border being <em>wrong </em>in subtle and not-so-subtle ways. Periodically, an organisation called the Southern Reach sends expeditions of people into Area X to try and chronicle the world within its borders — but the survivors of these expeditions always come back changed, riddled with cancer and devoid of personality.</p><p>The experiences of the all-female expedition we follow in <em>Annihilation </em>are chronicled by a character referred to only as “the biologist”, who seemed to me a convincing depiction of someone with a passion for ecology. The biologist is intimately aware of the life cycles of plants and animals in their natural environments and how these are disrupted by human activity — and through her eyes, we see how these are disrupted in alien ways, too. The biologist’s knowledge makes it easier for us to make the connection between the changes we bring upon the world and the changes brought about by aliens — both are presented as profound and incomprehensible from the point of view of an undisturbed ecosystem.</p><p><em>Annihilation </em>is the first book in a trilogy, and seems to have always been conceived of as such. This isn’t a case of a novel whose popularity caused an entire series to emerge: all three books of what’s called <em>The Southern Reach Trilogy </em>seem to have been written alongside each other and released relatively close together. This is quite strange to me, as I feel <em>Annihilation </em>is more powerful when read as a standalone work. It sets out its stall in such a clearly defined way — here is a landscape being altered in an incomprehensible way, here is why the nature of that incomprehensibility matters — that it felt to me that there wasn’t much else for the next two books in the series to do. It would undermine the themes of <em>Annihilation </em>more than a little if its sequels explained everything that happened in it, so this for the most part doesn’t happen — instead, for the most part they restate the inhuman nature of the events in the first book with different characters and in new narrative styles. They’re not badly written, but they are a bit inconsequential, and it’s weird to see them tagging along after a work of as much consequence as <em>Annihilation</em>. I guess you could argue that it’s appropriate that a story about incomprehensible things happening to reality itself exists in an incomprehensible form — but I’d be lying if I thought that this was intentional in any way.</p><p>However, I have come across works by other authors that expand on <em>Annihilation’</em>s themes. I read VanderMeer’s work at around the same time as I read another science fiction book about aliens who were truly alien — Adam Roberts’ <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/26187256-the-thing-itself"><em>The Thing Itself</em></a><em>. </em>Roberts — <a href="http://strangehorizons.com/non-fiction/reviews/the-southern-reach-trilogy-by-jeff-vandermeer/">himself a fan of <em>Annihilation</em></a><em> </em>— draws on Kant’s idea that space and time are constructs of the human mind to imagine an alien race who exists independently of both those concepts. It’s a fairly mind-blowing idea, but it occurred to me upon finishing the book that we might live among creatures as alien as this anyway — we just tend to refer to them as “animals”. Frans de Waal’s recent work <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/26530322-are-we-smart-enough-to-know-how-smart-animals-are"><em>Are We Smart Enough to Know How Smart Animals Are?</em></a><em> </em>argues that animals may often display cognitive abilities that go unobserved by scientists simply because those abilities are too far beyond our reference frame for humans to meaningfully analyse. It’s not a massive leap from this view to one that argues that some animals may see the world in radically different ways to ourselves, perhaps to the extent that concepts as fundamental as space and time are not experienced in analogous ways. In other words, our experiences of the world may be a woefully tiny subset of all animal experiences of the world, and we may simply be unable to understand the extent of that incompleteness.</p><p>In its way, science fiction that invites this view is antipathetic to scientism, the view that science can ever provide a complete description of the universe that we live in. After all, no amount of experimentation could ever reveal a fact that was as far outside your own frame of reference as Brexit is to that of a great crested newt. In this sense it differs quite strikingly from a certain other strand of science fiction, where every person of every species encountered views the world in a way that seems suspiciously similar to the way the author does. In a completely unfair way, I think it’s possible to see science fiction that looks to illustrate a perfect society or describe what an “advanced” alien species would look like as hewing to the spirit of the physical sciences as popularly understood rather than the ecological ones. By this I mean that theoretical physics is often characterised as a quest to unravel the fundamental forces that underpin everything, with the knowledge of which often held in almost religious reverence. In a similar light, some science fiction can be read as looking for a single and final answer to questions that probably don’t really have them: this society is structured in the one True and Correct way, this alien race is more advanced than us because they are further down the sole possible path of Inevitable Technological Progress. As <em>Annihilation </em>shows us, science fiction reflective of the science of ecology might take a rather different view. If physics could be defined as a quest to find fundamental truths that underlie everything, ecology could be contrasted as a discipline where it’s rapidly apparent how little we actually know. It’s about the limits not just of our minds, but of the fiction we create with those minds, and serves as a reminder of how much larger the universe could be than our own imaginations. I’m fond of the GK Chesterton quote that goes:</p><p><em>A turkey is more occult and awful than all the angels and archangels. Insofar as God has partly revealed to us an angelic world, he has partly told us what an angel means. But God has never told us what a turkey means. And if you go and stare at a live turkey for an hour or two, you will find by the end of it that the enigma has rather increased than diminished.</em></p><p>Stephen Hawking once said that the ultimate triumph of human reason would be to know the mind of God. I would side with VanderMeer that reason’s greater triumph is to know we will never understand the mind of a turkey — and to know, as far as is possible, what that says about the universe where we both live.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=25fb2fba4f21" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The MOON is an EGG. This is why that matters.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vegetablelove/the-moon-is-an-egg-this-is-why-that-matters-24798d516b84?source=rss-d4d0de093bdc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/24798d516b84</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[kill-the-moon]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[doctor-who]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Robert Shepherd]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 12 Feb 2017 00:17:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-12T00:17:58.810Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ve wanted to write about <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kill_the_Moon">the <em>Doctor Who</em> episode where the MOON is an EGG</a> for some time now, really more or less since it aired. When I first saw it I thought it had something quite important to say — about <em>Doctor Who</em> itself, but also about our culture and society — and it’s something that’s become more important in the months and years that have followed. I haven’t actually watched the episode since it aired, so I imagine I’ll make loads of mistakes about the plot and characters and structure of the thing. Hopefully that won’t matter, but if it does you can feel better by shouting at me online.</p><p>I remember the basics of the episode, at least. In <em>Kill the Moon</em>, the Doctor, his companion and a little girl travel to the moon in 2049. There, they discover that unusual tidal activity caused by the moon has become a threat to humanity, and a group of astronauts has come to destroy the satellite with nuclear bombs. However, it turns out that changes to the moon’s behaviour have come about because — improbably — it’s really an enormous alien egg which is in the process of hatching. At the end of the episode the moon shatters apart as a giant, dragon-like alien emerges from it, an alien who — the Doctor says — will fascinate humanity so much that they feel they’ll have to go out and explore the universe again.</p><p>Below the surface, however, I thought <em>Kill the Moon</em> was about something else entirely. After the episode had first aired, I heard that people on the <em>Doctor Who</em> discussion forums had wondered if the moon from the 1967 serial <em>The Moonbase </em>was an egg too, and asked why no-one had ever thought to mention this at the time. This, I thought, is almost exactly the wrong question to ask about <em>Kill the Moon</em>, because the whole point of the thing is that the moon of 2014 is not the same as the moon of 1967. In the sixties, the idea that human civilisation would one day expand out to space was more or less taken as read: bases on the moon and inhabited wheels in space were things that could quite conceivably exist in the real future as well as the one the Doctor poked around in on-screen. Against this backdrop, the race to put a man on the moon is symbolic of a wider assumed future — and one which adults and children could both conceivably believe in.</p><p>Subtextually, I think <em>Kill the Moon </em>is about what happens when this future no longer seems real. In it, the weapons of the sixties — the Earth’s last ever nuclear bombs — are intended to destroy the imagined future of the sixties, here represented by the moon itself. Significantly, the episode portrays the moon as being a bit rubbish; grey, breaking apart, literally covered in cobwebs, coded as something from our past instead of our future. It’s there as the spent remains of what the future was <em>going to be </em>rather than what any of us now think the future really is, and there to remind us that the symbols of that future are not ones that hold real power or appeal for our society any more.</p><p>This, the episode has realised, presents something of a problem for <em>Doctor Who</em>. As a cultural artefact that is itself from the sixties, the future as a place where human expansion and exploration beyond Earth is something that actually <em>happens </em>is more or less hard-coded into the show’s DNA. However, <em>Who </em>has now been around for long enough that the future depicted in its earlier years is either already close to becoming the past — the 1967 serial <em>The</em> <em>Enemy of the World</em>, for example,<em> </em>is set in the distant era of 2018 — or is manifestly not going to become a reality in the years to come. Half the men who walked on the moon are now dead; it’s 45 years since a human set foot on the place. The expansion that seemed inevitable in the sixties has dissipated away, and the symbology of the future has stayed the same more or less through sheer inertia.</p><p><em>Kill the Moon</em>, then, alludes to the simple fact that this state of affairs cannot continue. Post the 2008 financial crisis, it seems like the future is a place where we all work longer hours for less money in increasingly precarious ways, which isn’t really a recipe for an exciting series of adventures in space and time. This view of the future hasn’t changed since <em>Kill the Moon</em> aired in 2014. Indeed, if anything the future it portrays now seems over-optimistic: it seems rather less likely in 2017 that our future will contain global nuclear disarmament and a black, female president of the USA. Given this, what can a show whose stock in trade is showing us our future actually do? How can it find a way to be optimistic about what lies ahead, at a time where this seems to be ignoring the facts of reality?</p><p>Well, it can do it by changing the facts of reality. Apparently a lot of people criticised <em>Kill the Moon </em>after it aired because most of the things that happen in it are very unscientific. That’s true, but I’m not sure it matters — it’s a text about the way we conceive of the things that exist in the world, rather than one about what those things might or might not actually be. The episode says, in effect, that the future can only be reconceptualised — and by extension, can only be saved — if our perception of the universe changes in a radical way. It’s not enough to continue on with the same tropes around what the future is or what it means. Rather, we need to be able to inhabit a world radically different from the present in basic ways — such as coming to think of the moon as an egg, and the future as a place inhabited by fantastical dragons.</p><p>It all falls down, of course, when you ask what this radical new way of viewing things actually <em>is</em>. Here in the UK, I remember in 2015’s Labour leadership contest Yvette Cooper ran on a platform of saying young people needed to be engaged in politics in ways that were quite different to the ones stuffy old people were doing at the time. This is probably true, but an old woman at one of the party’s hustings punctured things by asking what these new ways of engagement might look like, exactly. I think the simple answer is that most of us don’t know, and in the end I don’t think <em>Kill the Moon </em>does, either — it asks the question “what, exactly, should the underlying narrative be for an optimistic view of the 21st century?”, then tries to convince us that the answer is “taking inspiration from a CGI dragon.” That’s not to say it isn’t saying worthwhile things — contrary to some, I think it’s fine and valid to articulate a problem you yourself have no solution to — but to say that it defines a new space for science fiction to be in rather than doing much within that space itself.</p><p>In 2017, however, I think we might be closer to articulating an answer. Just as it was impossible that a dragon could hatch from an egg, it was impossible for Donald Trump to become the president of the United States. Now that the second of these impossibilities is our reality, it’s worth thinking about how this was able to happen, and how some of the forces that enabled it could be used to bring about rather more positive changes. In the days after Trump’s inauguration, I found myself thinking about how those of us who were against him had reacted to his proposals to build “The Wall” — an unbroken barrier stretching over 2000 miles intended to close the border between Mexico and the USA. The Wall, we said, was a patently ridiculous idea, and in many ways it still is. But while I think we were correct to criticise the attitudes that would lead to The Wall being seen as desirable, I now think we were wrong to criticise the ambition. Just as we now don’t send people to the moon or expect ourselves to ever travel to outer space, we’ve come to believe that a public infrastructure project on The Wall’s scale just isn’t something people <em>do </em>anymore. Yet this science fiction is becoming reality: The Wall will be built, and the impossibilities that need to be put into place will become possibilities.</p><p>I think this sort of place is perhaps where hope of a kind can be gleaned. The dying future criticised in <em>Kill the Moon</em> is now surely dead; our immediate future is one of a fractured humanity on a single planet, not a united species headed towards the stars. In many ways, to me it’s the stuff of nightmares — the only comfort I can think of is that nightmares are built of the same material of dreams, and that in the sheer scale of what lies ahead we may allow ourselves to think in truly radical ways again. If we can actually achieve tasks like the construction of thousand-mile barriers and the negotiation of leaving the European Union, it surely follows that we can achieve things that match their ambition while rejecting their intent. And I think telling stories about that is crucial, too, because we need to set out visions of what our future can look like that draw from the stories and experiences of our lived present, and not from the desiccated husks of an aesthetic over half a century old. Real originality in fiction is needed to forge a reality that’s better than this one — I think that was the message of <em>Kill the Moon</em>, when boiled down to its basic form. Act and create, it says, and do it now– because we live in a world where the moon can be an egg, and we live in a world where the future can be saved.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=24798d516b84" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>