<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Venkateshan K on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Venkateshan K on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@venky.physics?source=rss-ec8abb248db6------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 14:08:57 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@venky.physics/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dispelling the misunderstandings of lack of free will]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@venky.physics/dispelling-the-misunderstandings-of-lack-of-free-will-54bea0be384a?source=rss-ec8abb248db6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/54bea0be384a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[determinism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[free-will-vs-determinism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Venkateshan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 27 Dec 2024 10:00:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-30T12:13:59.794Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>We’ve all come across the determinism vs free will debate: do human beings have have genuine free agency or are all our actions and decisions an inevitable consequence of our past history ? From a scientific standpoint, there is very little evidence to suggest that free will in its strict form exists. There is no process sitting inside ours brains that is decoupled from dynamics of the rest of the universe and arriving at decision in splendid isolation. In that sense, there is certainly no free will: the laws of physics are almost entirely deterministic (and where they aren’t, there are no non-material causes) and the neurons in our brains function in accordance with these laws and therefore there is no reason to assume that we can <strong>somehow escape the conclusion that there is no real free will.</strong></p><p>Nonetheless,<strong> simplistic interpretations</strong> of lack of free will implies a startling and nihilistic shift in how we understand human beings. The proponents of this view would have us believe that this naturally eliminates any notion of <strong>individual responsibility, makes regret a meaningless emotion and that we are no more in control of our actions or be held accountable for them as the waves in a turbulent sea.</strong></p><p>I am going to argue that this perspective is mistaken and is largely driven from an incorrect understanding of determinism.</p><h4>Continuity of human traits</h4><p>However before I even get to that, let’s first consider something more commonplace and assumed to be true even though we don’t often appreciate its consequences fully. As humans, we work on the assumption that people don’t change dramatically from day to day and there is a continuity in their personality and behavioral traits. We can often predict with reasonable accuracy how our friends or family would react in a certain scenario. Why is this the case? Well, if we spend some time thinking about it, we would probably attribute it to the fact that these individual traits arise at some level from the neuronal patterns inside the brain and since these doesn’t undergo radical transformation on day to day basis, there is no reason to expect anything drastic at the behavioral level either.</p><p>Well, we have expressed a mild form of determinism right there. Maybe someone might object (rightly) to describing it as determinism, but what the above tells us is that <em>our history until this moment places certain constraints</em> - in practice at least — on what we are likely to do in the immediate future. That the notion of cause and effect is not some abstract principle that applies only to inanimate objects but even to an extent, <strong>even at our level of observation</strong>, to human behavior. If someone is terrible at remembering faces, then it is unlikely that that will change tomorrow or a week from now.</p><h4>Environment shaping anti-social behavior</h4><p>The above is not unusual or controversial and in fact it is so mundane that one might wonder what is even the point of stating it. Let’s go one step further. We’ve all heard discussions around the nature vs nurture contribution when it comes to skills, abilities, health, subjective well-being and other significant traits. In this context, we know that difficult or abusive childhoods can lead to anti-social and criminal behavior in adults. So much so that anyone who has thought seriously about this has wondered how fair it is to judge someone for their actions when their personality has been deeply scarred by some traumatic past.</p><p>However recognizing the realities of the above does not require us to accept thoroughgoing determinism. In fact, we probably aren’t even thinking of the free will question when considering such issues. And yet, regardless of whether free will exists or not, we are more than wiling to see that there are forces that shape us that our outside of our control and our actions are in part determined by that. Furthermore, there is continuity to these traits and psychological profiles that in reality narrows the space of realistic choices for us whether we accept it or not.</p><p>It’s useful to first recognize that we implicitly accept that we don’t have, in practice, the spectrum of choices that we may assume are theoretically available to us. The fact there is an significant element of predictability in human behavior should at least give us some intuition already that free will perhaps does not exist in all its glory.</p><h4>The “Narrowing of Choices” vs. Free Will</h4><p>Now the most crucial element in the above examples is the narrowing of choices <em>in practice, as opposed to in theory</em>. It’s one thing to insist that given what you know of your sister, she will always choose a chocolate drink regardless of the 10 minutes spent staring at the menu. It’s another matter altogether to assert that the decision is a <em>foregone conclusion</em> with no scope for error and that she will invariably order that drink. The universe, according to this view, cannot function any other way.</p><h3>What Determinism Is and Isn’t</h3><p>That of course if the classic notion of determinism that people find so unsettling. However, as we’ll see, it doesn’t have to be and in order to appreciate that, we need to explore more and understand what exactly is determinism and more importantly what it isn’t.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/270/1*yOEWXwhAllebvUNIC2CicQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Imagine you are at a road intersection and you have the option to take either left or right turn. Let’s say you chose to take the left turn for whatever reason. Now, someone denying the existence of free will will argue that there is no way you could have chosen the right turn. There is no possible way you could have done otherwise. Is that true? Perhaps. Depends on details that are as yet missing. Let’s fill that in.</p><p>Let’s consider an alternate parallel universe <em>almost </em>identical to our own. In that universe, all your personal experiences, memories, events, individuals in your life are all the same. Likewise, assume that at the level at which you can observe, everything happening around is also the same: history is the identical in every way, all the natural disasters are occurring at the same time and have identical impacts, the leaders of the world happen to be no different, Einstein published the four famous papers in the same year, etc. Now, when you stand at that same intersection in the parallel universe, is there anything definitive that prevents you from making the right turn?</p><p>The answer — and this may surprise you — is no. You can at least <em>in principle make the right turn</em>. And no, that is<strong> not a violation of determinism.</strong></p><p>Before unpacking the above, let’s clarify that this is not based on some cheap trick or clever phrasing. Consider the following statement for example:</p><p>If the world at this moment were to be fully measured and characterized at some reasonable level -knowing the locations and movements of living and non-living objects, physical variables like temperature and pressure and density, electric and magnetic fields, etc — then we would be able to determine what precisely what happens at all subsequent times in the future.</p><p>The above is <em>false</em> and <strong>does not represent the principle of determinism</strong>.</p><p>Well, what exactly is determinism anyway and more importantly what is wrong with the formulation above? Determinism is defined in a very similar way except there is a crucial difference: the state of the universe at any given time <em>must be fully</em> specified at any given point in time for the future to be determined based on it. In particular, there is a unique future trajectory, and therefore, the present state fully determines what that future would be. <strong>Full specification of the state at a given time is a paramount for determinism to hold</strong>.</p><p>Full specification would mean that we know everything there is to know about the system at all levels, from the sub-atomic to the cosmological (in the case where the system is the universe) . This is of course more of an abstract idea that works well in a thought experiment because in practice it is impossible to specify a system let alone the entire universe thoroughly.</p><h3>Microscopic vs Macroscopic Descriptions</h3><p>In the above thought experiment involving the choice of taking turns at an intersection, the world was not specified completely. It was specified at a level <strong>that could be observed and recorded in everyday life</strong>. In other words, it was an approximation and determinism does not hold at that level of detail. Now, that may seem like either nitpicking or an academic point but it is central to gaining a correct perspective on lack of free will. To understand that better let us introduce the more technical distinction that lies at the heart of the issue: the duality of the microscopic and the macroscopic world.</p><p>Macroscopic description refers to characterization in terms of aggregates whereas microscopic refers to the characterization of the individual components. For example, still water in a container represents the macroscopic description (there is no movement of the liquid, no waves or ripples) whereas at the microscopic level, we know that the molecules are in constant motion, colliding and scattering against each other at varying speeds. In fact, the single macroscopic state of the water in the container corresponds to millions of different microscopic configurations of the molecules of H20.</p><p>Well, why is all this relevant? As in the case of the example with the water above, in general, most objects and phenomena can be described at a macroscopic and microscopic level. Consider thoughts for example. These arise in your consciousness when you are debating which ice-cream flavor to pick (or the turn to take at the intersection). This is the macro-level picture. Microscopically, we know that there are neural correlates to these thoughts with signaling and transmission involving synapses and electrical potentials. Here’s the thing though: as with water, there can be multiple configurations at the microscopic level that all lead to the same macroscopic phenomena. <strong>So while you may be experiencing identical thoughts it doesn’t necessarily mean that microscopically, it is all the same inside the brain</strong>. And the same is true for every other phenomena we see around us from the movement of celestial objects, the dust that that is blown from the surface of the road by a speeding vehicle, the cooling of a room when turning on an air-conditioner, the capturing of a photograph, etc.</p><p>Now we have two important facts: one, determinism requires full specification of the present state in order for the future to be determined, and the fact that a single macroscopic state maps to multiple microscopic configurations. Full specification implies that the present state be specified at the microscopic level. <strong>Hence merely a macroscopic description will not imply determinism: in other words, if the present were to be specified at some macroscopic level, then it is not the case that this determines the future uniquely. More technically, the fundamental laws of physics are (largely) deterministic but that does not imply that coarse-grained descriptions always will be.</strong></p><p>This may sound rather abstract but let us add a little more color to it. Given what you — or anyone else for that matter — know of your life history until now does not uniquely specify the future (even keeping everything else in the universe the same). Another way of stating this is that there is a <em>genuine</em> choice. No, I am not merely saying that this is a real choice because there is no way for you to know the future. I am stating something far less obvious: making distinct choices is perfectly compatible (at a purely physical level) given the knowledge of your life history. And you can include everything you care to include in that life history such as the half a second long lucid dream you had when you were 6 years old. These are <em>all</em> macroscopic descriptions.</p><p>You may want to read that again: we are saying that even if you had solved the unification problem and possessed infinite compute power, if the information that you have access to is only at the level of what you observe and record about your life history (as opposed to well.. the full quantum state), regardless of how detailed it may (recording events that happened every second since you were born for example) you will still not be able to necessarily determine whether you will make the right turn at an intersection; you have free will so to speak <em>conditional on that knowledge.</em></p><p>One very important consequence of the microscopic-macroscopic distinction is that humans, and say higher animals at least, behave like agents possessing a degree of free will at the macroscopic level even though their microscopic dynamics are governed by deterministic laws. What do I mean by that ? If one were to model the behavior of humans at the level of their interactions and activities, that model would be most accurately described if there is an element of free agency associated with them (again, it is useful to remember that, regardless of existence of free will, human beings can often be very predictable in many circumstances)</p><p>Having clarified this, let us look at some of the claims that have been made with respect to the consequences of determinism.</p><h3>Implications of Lack of Free Will</h3><h4>Responsibility and Accountability</h4><p>How can we hold a person accountable for their actions if everything they do as an adult is already determined from the time they were born? The problem with this picture is that it is extremely reductionist. As described earlier, at the macroscopic level, not only do humans behave as though they have free will but also that macroscopic specification of the universe is insufficient for determinism. To take the view that humans have no accountability would be to assume that there are no such thing as thoughts or deliberations or decision making whatsoever or that they are ultimately pointless. However, even the proponent of this view cannot actually claim that thoughts and seemingly real choices are meaningless for the simple reason that they are the apparent reasons that humans decide to choose a particular course of action. It is of course true, as the advocate of this position will point out, that these thoughts have causal precursors tracing all the way back to when the individual was born (or even earlier for that matter), but that does not make the thoughts themselves irrelevant. You cannot get rid of thoughts and deliberations because there is no free will! One might say that I’ll do whatever I please and not overthink something but therein is a thought and a decision making criterion!</p><h4>Regrets and Guilt</h4><p>If every act of commission and omission is predetermined, then where is the real choice to feel any sense of guilt or regret? The notion of regret rests upon the assumption that one could have done something differently but determinism informs us that we could not have behaved any other way.</p><p>First, let’s first recognize that feeling regret about some action in the past does<strong> materially change</strong> what we may do in the future. We do learn from our mistakes or myopic thinking especially when the consequences were rather severe. So the feeling of regret <strong>has a causal role</strong> (at least at the macroscopic level at which we are considering human behavior) and therefore to suggest that it is somehow a fundamentally flawed emotional response makes no sense. To be clear, this is very different from arguing that a lot of regret or guilt or shame is unhelpful and perhaps leads to worse outcomes but that’s the domain of value judgment and therapy. All we are saying here is that regret does have a real consequential impact. Also, I am referring to deep regret that cannot merely be reduced to “learning from mistakes”.</p><p>Second, it is perfectly rational to feel some sense of regret or consider counterfactual “what-ifs” after decisions that led to something undesirable. As emphasized earlier, at the macro level, there is free choice, and one can imagine going back to that point in time where the decision was made (at which point, I repeat, there is genuine free will if we only consider macroscopic description) and wonder how things would have been otherwise. It shapes our thinking process and influences how we act in the future.</p><h4>Should knowledge of lack of free will change anything?</h4><p>If anything we should be amazed that becoming aware of the fact that we don’t possess genuine free will suggests that we should somehow behave differently than what we already have been. Or rather, I don’t understand how one can rationally justify doing something different simply because one has now come to possess the knowledge that one doesn’t have free will.</p><p>For example, one line of reasoning might be that since everything is predetermined, there is no point in putting any thought or effort into doing or deciding anything (because, well, things are already going to happen as they are meant to happen). I hope what I have explained so far will reveal the flaw with this line of thinking but anyway let’s be explicit about it: determinism applies just as strongly to the efforts, thoughts, subjective experiences and emotions that you encounter as they do to the final actions and decisions; <strong>you are no more likely to escape the desire to win the next point in the game of tennis with your buddy as the outcome of that game is causally determined</strong>. Obviously, if you are planning an expedition to Antarctica and suddenly learned about lack of free will and decided not to do anything about it reasoning that if you were meant to go then you will, it is unlikely you will end up getting on one. Even something like overthinking cannot be helped with this knowledge: lack of free will does not imply that going by the first choice will be identical to the one following long deliberation because the future is uniquely determined!</p><p>Again here, I want to point out that it is still meaningful to argue that we can minimize our guilt or regret by recognizing that we are part of broader forces that shape us and that our actions follow cumulatively from events that we may not be consciously aware of and whose influence is perhaps stronger than we imagine. However, as I highlighted at the beginning of this article, we don’t need to embrace lack of free will to see that this is generally true.</p><h3>Limited imagination of what determinism entails</h3><p>Part of the reason why people find it hard to accept lack of free will is that they imagine determinism plays out in some very simplistic manner. It is more often thought in terms of some secret script that comes along with a new born that encodes all of the child’s future and in particular the key moments,from taking the first steps to uttering the first words to experiencing the first crush, the major in college to illnesses, accidents and losses to marriages, friends, accomplishments, etc.</p><p>Too bad no one can decipher that script.</p><p>The reality of determinism is nothing like that of course. There is an extraordinarily complex system co-evolving under a system of deterministic laws with literally trillions of constituent entities (those distinctions don’t even make sense at a certain quantum level) and yes, that implies that, if we do know the state of the system (universe in this case) fully at the current time, then its future trajectory can (mostly) be determined in principle. And you the human being happen to be a small subsystem (interacting with the rest of the system) whose configuration can also be inferred as a consequence.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>There is little evidence to suggest that libertarian free will exists and there are several reasons why that is conceptually at odds with our fundamental understanding of laws of nature. This has led to people describing what we perceive to be free agency so strongly to be nothing more than an illusion.</p><p>In a way, they are absolutely correct, but that is a slightly misleading description too.</p><p>At the level of human observations, behaviors, subjective experiences and perceptions, what we experience as free will for all intents are purposes is just that: it arises from processes inside our brains and while determinism operates at the microscopic level, it doesn’t preclude the macroscopic reality of human choice.</p><p>More significantly, contrary to what most people think, lack of free will in the strict sense of the term does not change any of our understanding and there is no rational reason why it ought to change our behavior in anyway.</p><p>Even at a philosophical (dare I say metaphysical?) level, I am not convinced it changes much although very simplistic characterization can make it seem like our fates are somehow already sealed regardless of what we may can do about it!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=54bea0be384a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My foray into mindfulness with Waking Up]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@venky.physics/my-foray-into-mindfulness-with-waking-up-13acdde07a02?source=rss-ec8abb248db6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/13acdde07a02</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[waking-up]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[non-dualism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Venkateshan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Nov 2023 12:35:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-09T07:59:48.064Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By the time I decided to give the meditation app Waking Up a try, like everyone else, I had heard a lot about the benefits of mindfulness and meditation practice. These included studies showing its impact on stress and anxiety reduction, improved focus and better relationships and an overall improvement in mental health. I’ve encountered anecdotes on its transformative power in dealing with difficult circumstances in life and also its role in psychotherapy, etc.</p><p>While I was more than willing to admit that such purported benefits could withstand the tests of empirical scrutiny, I had been quite skeptical about the metaphysical claims and dogmas associated with the traditions from which such practices arose.</p><p>Despite being from a country known for its spiritual traditions (or precisely because of it), I am generally wary of worldviews that makes vague claims about the nature of reality (including its denial) or refuses to acknowledge the benefits of material, scientific and technological progress or advances some notion of an ultimate truth about the universe that supersedes — or lies outside the bounds of — scientific inquiry and that can be attained only through some “spiritual endeavors”.</p><p>This runs counter to my conception of objective reality as one firmly rooted in reason, science and the framework of empirical positivism.</p><h4>An approach free of mysticism and religious dogma</h4><p>Thankfully, Waking Up takes the approach to the subject that is closely in line with my basic worldview. And at the same time, it also doesn’t treat meditation as a mere tool to attain a greater sense of equanimity. In fact, besides the practice of mindfulness through guided sessions, there is an equal if not greater focus on the conceptual theory and philosophy surrounding it. Although such ideas have their roots in religious schools — primarily Buddhism (Tibetan form in particular) and Hinduism — the discussions are mostly free of any dogma or unverifiable assertions. This is largely thanks to the fact that Waking Up was created by Sam Harris, a person well-known (or one may say notorious) for being a crusader against organized religion and championing secular and scientific perspectives. Sam Harris holds a PhD. in neuroscience and curiously enough had spent several years in ashrams in India and Nepal learning meditation under the tutelage of several prominent meditation teachers.</p><p>A key element that Sam Harris reminds listeners during discussions is that the insights from mindfulness, such as the clarity and freedom that accompanies bare awareness or the illusory nature of the self, need not be accepted as truths without evidence but can be experienced by anyone through practice.</p><p>When I downloaded Waking Up, my own narrow interest was more on the personal improvement front — being less edgy, less anxious, and reacting less intensely to events and situations. However, right in the Introductory Course, Sam Harris mentions that that shouldn’t be the reason to meditate. Yes, some of those changes may come about because of the practice, but mindfulness is so much more than a solution for relaxation or paying better attention. It’s really about greater insight into the functioning of our mind and the nature of our consciousness (from a subjective experience; there are no claims being made about solving the hard problem of consciousness).</p><p>And indeed that is true.</p><p>A distinguishing trait of the practices here is the encouragement towards adopting a non-dualistic approach to meditation. Dualism in meditation draws a conceptual distinction between the self ( the “meditator”) and awareness/consciousness and the objects contained within it. Non-dualism is the recognition that the conception of the self that seems so central to human experience is an illusion, a construct that arises within awareness, and that self can drop out from awareness under certain circumstances. The absence of the self — or its perception likened to that of a mirage — may initially sound somewhat bewildering, counter-intuitive and more than a bit dubious. It is also one of the central themes that runs through the content on Waking Up. Yet, a discussion between Sam Harris and Prof. Jay Garfield was extremely insightful on this topic and I came away with the view that, whatever may be the subjective experience, the notion of the self is more of a problem when thinking about it carefully from first principles than its absence.</p><p>As far as my own experience goes, I have had some glimpses of this lack of self during practice and the primacy of raw experience (without conceptual overlays or narratives) but it is not something that I have managed to sustain let alone immediately recognize.</p><p>Much of the philosophy (both ancient and contemporary) around the self holds that as being central to a lot of needless suffering that we experience. The illusion of the self is closely tied to our relationship with thoughts and narratives. If only we can cease to be identified with thoughts so tightly, and loosen their grip on us, we can be more free and less burdened by the past or worries of the future. This of course, doesn’t sound very unique and the idea that thoughts can be our worst enemies has been echoed by disparate sources of varying ideologies and is central to various schools of of therapeutic procedures.</p><h4>Facts vs experiential reality</h4><p>And this brings us to a very important point. It’s one thing to gain new insights that may provide us with greater understanding and we may seek more of it for intellectual satisfaction or curiosity. It’s another thing for it to impact our everyday life in significant and meaningful ways.</p><p>For example, here are a few indisputable truths about our lives:</p><p>1. If you are reading this, you are most likely in the top 1% globally in terms of income and wealth. You ought to be enormously grateful every moment of your life for this privilege.</p><p>2. Likewise, your quality of life would have been worse had had you been born with some significant disability like loss of vision or mobility. Again, this was not in your control and you should count yourself fortunate for not suffering from such impairments.</p><p>3. When deciding, choose actions not based on immediate gratification but in favor of those that would be more considerate to your future self.</p><p>4. Most things in life aren’t worth worrying about and unfavorable outcomes in the short term are probably irrelevant in the long run.</p><p>If we accept these truths — and most will — then it would seem that any rational person would act in accordance with them. And yet, it doesn’t quite work as powerfully most of the times, does it? How many of us feel grateful for all the ways in which our lives are good when dealing with no-so-good circumstances? We are wired in certain ways and our behaviors are conditioned by habits and patterns that have hardened over years if not decades and so however true these facts may be, it is not easy to change how we react. None of this is to say that we should accept that a divergence between actions and our knowledge as a given; certainly learning to be grateful for example is undoubtedly useful (and discussed on Waking Up too) but it does not come naturally.</p><p>In the same way, insights about the nature of the self or consciousness may be very interesting, but the real question is how much does it translate to how we behave when we are caught up in the moment. And here is where the practice is important — not merely the understanding — and by practice I don’t mean just the formal practice offered by the guided sessions but actually taking a mindful approach in real life situations especially in those where we feel unpleasant. Indeed, there is no point to any of this if we are going to stay mindful only during the formal practice and revert to being consumed by our thoughts in the remainder of the day.</p><h4>My mindfulness journey</h4><p>Personally, my experience of applying the mindful approach in real situations has been an uneven one. There are days where I am aware of my thoughts and tendencies to react in unhelpful ways and there are others where I am in the grip of the emotions. This is to be expected however and it would be magical if 20 minutes of practice everyday can turn you into a wholly new person. More significantly, there is progress, even if that progress may not always be evident, and there are periods of seeming relapses into default behavior. Again, I didn’t expect anything different as any lasting change isn’t going to happen in a linear way.</p><p>Through both the discussions and practice, I have also come to realize how little we know our minds and its workings. It strikes me that we are giving precious little importance to this aspect of our development in society. We barely seem to understand the nature of our own thoughts and feelings — cravings, aversions, assumptions and reactions. Again it is not obvious that mere recognition of this will lead to actual change in behavior, but surely, it seems wrongheaded not to be educated about them.</p><h4>Mindfulness in the wider world</h4><p>Another stand-out aspect of Waking Up is the fact that it does not treat the topic in an isolated manner. Very often mindfulness ideas are embedded in a universe that is far removed from the social, cultural, economic and political realities of our world. One does wonder what help does mindfulness or the entire collection of “spiritual practices” do for the real problems of this world — global poverty, human abuse of billions of sentient beings, eradication of diseases or climate change? Even setting those questions aside, it is also not immediate how the practices and ideas relate to our current understanding of neuroscience, cognitive development or philosophy of mind. Again here, Waking Up not only delves into some of these questions through discussions with experts in these fields, Sam Harris and several of the guests appearing in the conversations acknowledge the limitations of such practices. The range of topics covered during these discussions are fairly broad and include evolution, effective altruism, protests and injustice, cognitive behavioral therapy, stoicism, guilt and free will.</p><p>Despite the fact that Waking Up has convinced me that mindfulness is far more important than its role in solving narrow personal problems, I have no desire to relinquish my existing life and take up residence in some monastery. And while I see that mindfulness can be quite powerful in terms of how we deal with both day to day challenges as well as adverse life events, I am still quite agnostic on questions of how well even an advanced practitioner can escape being swept away by the self during traumatic events. In the course of the discussion in “The Whole Of Life” Christopher Titmus notes that mindfulness is not the end goal but rather it is the non-reactive state from where one can think clearly about oneself and the world and go on to do other things.</p><p>That’s the closest representation of what I want from my mindfulness journey.</p><p>The limitations I have described above are not reasons to avoid trying Waking Up or mindfulness practice. If anything, the fact that someone still so firmly grounded in material realities of the world and for whom skepticism is always round the corner believes that mindfulness can be quite transformative should be seen as nothing less than a resounding endorsement of it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=13acdde07a02" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Are plant based diets optimal?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/post-darwinian-speciesist/are-plant-based-diets-optimal-fdaeb4c5c5e?source=rss-ec8abb248db6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fdaeb4c5c5e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vegan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[plant-based]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nutrition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diet]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Venkateshan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Jun 2023 10:22:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-10T01:26:16.011Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There is a growing body of scientific evidence to support both the adequacy of plant based diets and its multiple health benefits. However, there are many who go further and argue that it is <strong>the most</strong> healthful diet there possibly is.</p><p>How far is that claim true?</p><p>Although sounding similar, it is one thing to assert nutritional adequacy of a diet or even its positive impact on health outcomes, but another matter altogether to claim that it is <em>optimal</em> in the strict sense of the term. The sheer volume and form of scientific evidence required to substantiate these two claims is vastly different.</p><h4>When is a diet optimal?</h4><p>Let’s first recognize that a given diet can be regarded optimal only if is better than practically any other alternative, including those that are minor deviations from it. In the case of a plant-based diet, the claim that it is optimal would require one to also establish that it is superior to an alternative that is identical in every way except for small addition of specific animal products — for example, half a serving of wild-caught fatty-fish or 2 free range eggs per week. In fact, we need to <strong>demonstrate that any animal based addition to an exclusive plant-based diet, in any form and in any frequency, is going to lead to worse outcomes in terms of health and well-being (all else being equal).</strong></p><h4>Scientific limitations</h4><p>Now, there is no possible way one can meaningfully find support for such a hypothesis. Reliable conclusions based on scientific studies comparing diets can be reached only when there is a significant difference between them (unless of course that difference includes an important nutrient that is absent in one, or the small deviation is a known toxin, etc). If we are comparing two patterns of eating that are nearly identical, it is unlikely that science would be able to come to findings that are robust and reproducible.</p><p>And even if we could somehow carry out large population studies or trials comparing nearly identical diets, we would need a very large number of them to explore all combinations of minor deviations from a given diet to demonstrate that it is the optimal way of eating.</p><p>In practice, it is safe to say that cannot possibly <strong>hope to even prove that a diet is optimal because we cannot empirically test all of these minor </strong>variations.</p><p>And that is true for any diet, not just a plant-based one.</p><p>Furthermore, there are individual variations to consider. There are certain diets that work very well with certain sub-populations and less so with others. This is more likely to happen when we consider people having food allergies that forces them to restrict what they eat over and beyond what is already a restricted diet (such as a plant-based one). In these cases, getting all the necessary nutrients on the plant-based diet becomes challenging.</p><p>To be clear, well-planned plant based diets are indeed healthful. Indeed, across a range of health outcomes such as protection against <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1050173818300240">diseases</a>, <a href="https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/148/4/624/4965931">reduced mortality</a>, physiological parameters such as <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/1559827619875411?journalCode=ajla">blood pressure</a>, BMI or <a href="https://academic.oup.com/advances/article/10/3/433/5428016">inflammatory markers</a>, plant based diets have shown to confer several health benefits in individuals who have made a switch away from animal products.</p><p>However, it should be noted that while there is <strong>overwhelming evidence that a primarily plant-based diet is healthful for the vast majority of the population, there is almost zero evidence that exclusive plant based eating is optimal for even one individual.</strong></p><h4><strong>Is it even important that plant-based diets are optimal?</strong></h4><p>There will always be individuals for whom following a strictly plant-based diet is going to be hard or that adherence to the diet doesn’t lead to the associated health benefits. These variations are true for any dietary or lifestyle interventions and there is no reason to believe that a vegan diet would be any different. In fact such variations are true even for efficacy of drugs in pharmacological interventions for various medical conditions.</p><p>When animal activists make the <strong>health argument</strong> for going vegan, the more accurate approach is to advocate for a diet that eliminates vast majority of animal foods. To claim that one can prevent/reverse Type 2 diabetes <em>only</em> on an exclusive plant-based diet simply doesn’t make sense.</p><p>There is yet another important but understated aspect to this. While we do often talk about making healthier eating or lifestyle choices, we rarely seek perfectly optimal decisions or more precisely, we are unwilling to make sacrifices required for optimal health. For example, let’s say that we somehow knew what is required for optimal health and that includes, among other things, specification of calorific intake everyday, the distribution of macros across those calories, the type of foods to be eaten raw, cooked or fermented, the exact number of times in a week to exercise and for how long, the number of hours to sleep and the need to stick to bedtime routine and limiting, if not eliminating alcohol altogether. It is <strong>impossible to see anyone aiming to achieve these targets precisely</strong>; we are often willing to operate away from that optimal zone because we value other things in life — freedom (from being obsessed), socializing, adventure, etc — besides optimal health parameters.</p><p>In much the same spirit, even if one could somehow argue that a plant based diet is optimal, that is rarely a clinching argument for people to stick to it because we do often make choices — and rightfully so — that are somewhat sub-optimal for a particular objective (health in this case) because we care about other things in life.</p><p>There is little sense — and no evidence to support — in claiming universal optimal diets even though, for a given individual, there might be a temptation to identify the one diet that will work perfect.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fdaeb4c5c5e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/post-darwinian-speciesist/are-plant-based-diets-optimal-fdaeb4c5c5e">Are plant based diets optimal?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/post-darwinian-speciesist">Post Darwinian Speciesist</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My  struggles with an undiagnosed running conditio]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@venky.physics/my-struggles-with-an-undiagnosed-running-conditio-8e0761de34bf?source=rss-ec8abb248db6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8e0761de34bf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[running]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[neurology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[running-injuries]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fitness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Venkateshan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Dec 2022 14:36:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-26T14:36:46.355Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>My struggles with an undiagnosed running condition</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jfuOIW-OUzACHn_cOJGD2Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by sporlab on Unsplash</figcaption></figure><p>This concerns long-distance running, an activity that gives me considerable joy and plays a key role in my psychological wellbeing. If you’re a runner, you are likely to relate to that.</p><p>For more than 2 years now, I have been battling a very unusual problem that defies categorization let alone diagnosis. I have discussed and sought advice from fellow runners, scoured internet forums, YouTube videos and reddit threads, visited physiotherapists, experimented with various regiments of strength training, adjusted or tried to adjust running biomechanics, deployed psychological hacks and yet, I am no closer to finding the solution than when it all started. Or nearly so.</p><p>Here, I want to share my experiences dealing with the problem: everything from the the unique characteristics of the condition, the symptoms and its impact on my running, the steps I have taken in the hope of mitigating it, the explanations offered by physiotherapists along with a brief description of my running and injury history for context.</p><p>The hope here is two-fold. One, there may be other runners out there with the same affliction who’ve wrestled with it without any clear diagnosis or direction — I’d be really interested to learn more and exchange notes. Second, the various specialists in medicine, treatment and surgery- neurologists, neurosurgeons, orthopedics, physiotherapists, movement specialists, etc — may potentially be able to glean something in terms of the origins of the problem by reading this, or at the least, be aware of the existence of it (possibly linking it to some cases they may have encountered).</p><h3>Short summary</h3><p>Given the length of this write-up, it makes sense to provide a summary of the key points:</p><ol><li>The problem is characterized by a sensation of <strong>partial loss of motor control </strong>over some part of the leg. Both legs are affected.</li><li>One or more muscle groups feel weak and “off”; sensation of <strong>inability to execute specific movement</strong>; running form degenerates.</li><li><strong>No sensation of pain </strong>— no aching, throbbing, burning or tingling sensation. Distinctly uncomfortable nonetheless.</li><li>Symptoms <strong>occur only when running</strong> (almost non-existent the moment I stop) .</li><li>Uncertain benefits from strength workouts; almost none from stretching or massaging.</li><li>Seemingly uncorrelated or weakly correlated with variables like weekly mileage or periods of rest.</li><li>Weekly mileage in the last 2.5 years is about 40–75 km.</li><li>Despite this issue, my running times for all distances from 5K to half (technically, even full) marathon have improved.</li><li>Could possibly be the rare disorder known as <a href="http://www.runnersworld.com/health-injuries/a20865203/runners-dystonia-mysterious-malady-causes-mind-and-muscle-to-lose-touch/">runner’s dystonia</a> or a <a href="https://runningwritings.com/2015/07/loss-of-leg-coordination-while-running.html?utm_source=pocket_mylist">similar condition</a> that is apparently undiagnosed too</li><li>No known injury in the past; no other neurological problems manifested or identified by professionals during basic examination (no MRI, EMG or nerve conduction tests done)</li></ol><h3>Problem Description</h3><p>The set of symptoms I encounter during my runs is so odd and unrelated to anything else I have experienced that even describing it is rather difficult. It is as if the vocabulary I am familiar with is inadequate to capture what I feel. It is characterized by a distinct sense that the ability to control the lower limbs has been significantly reduced. It is the impairment of something so basic that we don’t even think about it in normal circumstances — the muscular movements that happen as and when we will it. And yet this impairment is not like the feeling of pins-and-needles, nor does it involve any muscle actually being paralyzed. And although there is a<em> sense</em> of loss of motor control the symptoms are almost completely absent the moment I stop running. The symptoms are in fact not reproduced in any activity (including cycling and swimming) though some <em>very</em> mild form of it can occasionally be felt (may not even be the same thing)</p><p>The condition also involves a sensation that the power in the legs has been greatly diminished. This may not even necessarily be true as I am often able to able maintain the same pace (at least initially) following the onset of the symptoms. There is also seemingly a partially involuntary spasm-like tendency for the feet or the joints around the knee, ankle and occasionally the hips to assume (or tend to assume) a certain position that is at cross-purposes with running motion (such as ankles “locking” the mobility of the feet or knees unable to execute the full dynamic range of the swing-phase).</p><p>Another distinctive feature of this condition is that it is delocalized — it is often (though not always) hard to pinpoint where exactly I experience it. The sensation tends to start somewhere in the bottom (plantar surface) of the foot together with the outer (lateral) part of the lower leg traversing upto to the knee but as it develops the ankles and the Achilles tendon are also affected. I often describe these areas going “numb” but it is not quite like the numbness associated with or arms ‘falling asleep’ (parasthesia) nor is it by any means paralysed (in the strict sense of the term).</p><p>The sensation might reduce in some parts while intensifying in others, and it is not uncommon for the situation to improve during the run (although very rarely does it completely disappear). It can progress to the quads or hamstrings but that is not typically where it starts and more often than not these are the areas that develop symptoms when the condition gradually worsens. The problem is generally bilateral — I have experienced debilitating versions of it in both my legs that have made running next to impossible. In the recent past though, it has been more often in the left leg (although I am quite certain that the first time I ever encountered it was in the right). There are times when I simultaneously experience it in both legs.</p><p>As one may notice, the observations above are accompanied by significant qualifications such as “more often than lot” and “generally bilateral” and that’s because there is <em>no single consistent pattern</em> to it. One illustrative example of the difficulty of characterizing this condition is the applicability (or not) of the term “heaviness” to describe the sensation: sometimes, I feel that that’s a good descriptor, but there are times when I think “lightness” is equally apt! More likely than not, the sensation is along axes that are orthogonal to conventional experience of light or heavy legs.</p><p>Typically the<em> condition worsens when I pick up the pace</em> to a point where my legs essentially just flop around and I cannot do much other than cease running altogether. Occasionally, the condition improves as the run continues (more on that later) or when I gradually progress from a general aerobic run towards a more threshold effort.</p><p>Oddly enough, there is <strong>no pain</strong> accompanying any of this. Plenty of discomfort, yes, but no pain in the usual sense of the term — no ache or throb. Not even soreness or any sharp or burning sensation that may be suggestive of injury. No sprain or cramp (I suffer considerably from cramping but more on that later) or even a sense of fatigued muscles necessarily.</p><p>The condition is more likely to happen on longer runs, or more accurately, both the probability of occurrence and the intensity of the impairment increases as the distance increases. In a typical scenario, I would run about 8km problem free before the symptoms begin to develop — initially mildly — and worsening quickly around the 12th km. If I continued — as I would with longer runs — there will likely be a reprieve and the condition improves although it should be noted that it is very rarely absent altogether. I may be able to continue in this manner (with remnants of the condition) for about another 10 to 15 kms until the symptoms worsen again. When they resurface after having covered over 25kms, their impact is significantly greater, partly because there is the (expected) muscle fatigue from having run that distance which makes everything worse.</p><h3>Source of triggers/amelioration</h3><p>Another significant difficulty with this condition is that the patterns surrounding its occurrence, the duration and the severity of the symptoms seem almost unrelated to several attributes that one may intuitively imagine to be relevant. For example, increasing or decreasing the weekly mileage does not seems to have much impact on the condition. Dynamic stretching drills involving the quads, hamstrings and calves before the run also appears to make little difference. Likewise, I have not seen any benefit from post-run static stretching. In much the same way, using a foam roller regularly after runs or even getting a deep tissue massage barely has any impact.</p><p>There are however some vague patterns I have observed over time but these must be treated with some skepticism. Even setting aside the fact that mere correlation does not imply causation, there is another factor that undermines the evidence in this case: having suffered without any clear diagnosis let alone treatment, the mind is likely to conjure up patterns and draw links where none exist in the desperate hope of discovering or stumbling upon something that might alleviate the symptoms.</p><p>That said, there may be some long-term benefits with strength and resistance training. My gym workouts have centered on the lower body and the exercises include squats, lunges,single-leg and regular deadlifts, Bulgarian split squats, unilateral and bilateral calf raises, leg extensions, leg press, hamstring curls, side glute workouts (clam-shells, side leg raises), glute bridges, etc. These workouts are performed twice or maybe even thrice a week for an hour or a little longer. Even if one assumes that muscle strengthening is helpful, it is <em>hard to identify which among these contributed towards the improvement</em>. Furthermore, sudden increase in the resistance workouts or an intense session performed close to a long run has been weakly correlated with worsening of the symptoms.</p><p>There is some indication that <em>plyometric workouts have the biggest benefit amongst all</em>. Part of this may be related to the fact that plyometric drills are almost the only activity that seems to reproduce the symptoms of the condition, albeit in a <em>far weaker </em>fashion. As these drills are highly controlled movements that individually involve greater impact than what running generates, presumably the body learns to adapt to them. Again, I want to emphasize that this may have mitigated the symptoms somewhat at best. And at worst, it is another one of the non-existent associations my brain has forged with scanty evidence.</p><p>More recently I have wondered whether it has something to the muscles/nerves alon the lateral segment of the lower leg — <em>peroneus longus/brevis</em> and <em>anterior tibialis</em> amongst others. Not only is that the area where the sensation is first experienced in most instances (along with the bottom of the feet), the muscles there are control the biomechanics of the foot including eversion/inversion and plantar/dorsiflexion. Furthermore, while I have trained other muscle groups and in particular the larger prime movers such as quads, calves and hamstrings, I almost never target these muscles in any of my routines (they may secondarily be involved in various exercises though).</p><h3>Runners Dystonia?</h3><p>The clinical diagnosis whose symptoms come closest to what I have experienced is the very rare type of task-specific dystonia known as <a href="https://www.runnersworld.com/health-injuries/a20865203/runners-dystonia-mysterious-malady-causes-mind-and-muscle-to-lose-touch/">runner’s dystonia</a>. Runner’s dystonia is characterized by a similar disconnect between the intended and actual movement of the leg muscles. Runners diagnosed with it report not being able to control the posture of their legs and as the condition progresses they even have trouble walking. The origins are likely neurological leading to involuntary muscle contractions brought about by repeated activity.</p><p>All this does fit quite well with my symptoms too. Nonetheless there are notable differences. Most of the reported symtoms concern the akle joint and feet (foot inversion and plantar flexion), and while I do find impairment in those regions, it also extends to the calves and the knees and sometimes the quads and hamstrings too. Furthermore, the prognosis for runners dystonia appears quite dire with several individuals eventually struggling to walk but in my situation the problem has been relatively stable (with sporadic improvements and relapses). There is almost no symptom while walking or any other activity. Finally, the symptoms related to runners dystonia appear to be more severe than what I experience. For example, the onset is often earlier in the run and some even report not being able to maintain any balance which isn’t the case with me.</p><p>A related problem, and an equally rare one has been <a href="https://runningwritings.com/2015/07/searching-for-answers-on-loss-of-leg.html">described in significant detail</a> (<a href="https://runningwritings.com/2015/07/loss-of-leg-coordination-while-running.html?utm_source=pocket_mylist">short summary</a>). The review is based on surveys of runners on the online forum <a href="https://www.letsrun.com/forum/flat_read.php?thread=1644998">letsrun.com</a> (the thread is very long and even a cursory examination of it will indicate the enormous extent to which runners have been trying to solve the problem including consulting multiple specialists, undergoing various treatments and rehab programs, drugs and surgeries, changing their gait, etc.) The symptoms in this case are similar to runner’s dystonia but there are nonetheless significant differences. As for its relation to what I experience, there is a lot of overlap but one important distinction has been the region where symptoms are most prominent: the runners covered in the review mention hamstring/hip-flexor as focal areas of challenge but for me the symptoms are quite delocalized but the calves, feet and around the knee would be where I experience it most often.</p><p>Another significant point of difference is also that while runners dystonia and the issue described in the review typically (though not always) cite problems with only one leg, I have had symptoms in both (as discussed before, it is predominant in the left currently but does affect both legs from time to time).</p><h3>Seeking professional help</h3><p>I have consulted two physiotherapists (both very well known in the running community in Bangalore) and explained the problem as well as I could. Both of them seemed to suggest lack of strength in the lower body, particularly the glutes, hamstrings and groin muscles as the primary reason for it. I even went through, following the recommendation of one of them, a 6-week strength and release based rehab program where I did a range of exercises under supervision. If there was any improvement from this, it was hardly noticeable and if anything, the symptoms seemed to have become a little worse.</p><p>I have reasons to be skeptical of the view expressed by the physios that lack of strength is the primary source of the problem. First, measures of absolute strength in terms of the weights used for lower body exercises would suggest that I don’t lag far behind a typical runner. To give some indication, I perform my squats with 45–55kg, deadlifts around 75–95 kg, bilateral calf raises around 70kg. Admittedly, none of these would give me an entry slot into a powerlifting competition but at the same time I doubt that someone with significant muscle weakness would be able to handle those weights. And even if one makes the argument that some of these movements may be performed less than perfectly, it still seems unlikely that corrective adjustments that would dramatically reduce the weight range. Second, it is extremely common for physios to find recreational runners to have weak glutes (and less than ideal strength in other muscle groups too). And yet, almost none of them have the symptoms that I do. Of course, the fact that some variable X does not cause symptom Y in the vast majority of the population does not imply that X does not cause Y for me. It may very well be that these are down to some specific muscle weakness but I have not been able to isolate it so far (or perhaps have not strengthened it sufficiently) to be able to see distinct and consistent benefits.</p><p>Another key reason for my skepticism has to do with the fact the physios didn’t give me much confidence that they actually understood the uniqueness of my problem. Rather, it seemed that they identified certain muscular shortcomings that are otherwise known to inhibit running ability or cause injury and assumed that focusing on correcting those would automatically solve the problems.</p><p>I have also visited a neurosurgeon who performed a quick examination and determined that there are no obvious neurological problems. Both the physios also ruled out neurological problems.</p><h3>Running History</h3><p>Although I have on occasions run a few kilometers on the road or on treadmill before, running with any regularity started only around 2015. I ran around 10k about twice a week, often on the treadmill but sometimes on road/trails too. I ran my first half-marathon in late 2016 without any systematic training and don’t recall running more than 25km/week leading up to it. Over the next two years, I ran mostly once every week (longish run around 15–20km) but was quite regular with strength training/general fitness sessions at Cult (not running specific). In 2019, I ran somewhat more frequently, maybe twice or thrice a week with a mileage of around 20–25km/week.</p><p>Towards the end of 2019, I prepared for a full marathon and increased my weekly mileage to about 55 kms or more, and while I don’t recall that period very well, there may have been some initial signs of this problem during the training runs.</p><p>The qualitative shift in my running happened a little after the start of the pandemic (May 2020) when I started training with a friend and became more systematic. I started incorporating speed workouts for the first time in my schedule and increased my mileage to 45–60km/week. I added warm-up and cool down routines, became more regular with strength workouts and understood aspects like pacing and recovery needs. These changes dramatically improved my times (unsurprisingly).</p><p>Over the next few months, I did experience some vague muscle soreness or lack of responsiveness but nothing out of the ordinary. The first distinct sign of the issue described here happened <strong>sometime in November 2020</strong> when I felt the sensation 20km or so into the run — I remember being quite bothered by how odd it felt but chalked it up to the new shoes. However, I experienced the same problem in the next long run and then shortly afterwards even when running about 12kms. I changed shoes, tried to learn more about it online, switched the lacing on shoes to ease up pressure on the front of the foot, switched to the cheapest pair of socks that I could find at Decathlon (because they applied least pressure). All this happened as I was training for the marathon. The problem occurred during all my long runs (over 30kms) and I figured out some ways to deal with it: slowing down; avoiding segments involving too much elevation changes, consciously ‘forcing’ one step after another however awkward it was, stopping briefly, taking walking breaks, etc. As noted elsewhere, the extent of symptoms varies quite a bit over the course of the long run.</p><p>The problem seemed to have worsened in the first half of 2021. Although I was quite frustrated and cut back on weekly mileage, I continued to do the speed sessions, and my running times were still improving (10k in under 43 minutes in March 2021 when only a year ago I was struggling to go under 49 minutes).</p><p>Towards the end of 2021 I ramped up the mileage training for the next marathon (65–80km/week) and again I went through the tortuous experience of dealing with these symptoms on long runs. I tried all manner of tricks to get around it — resting more before long run, changing running stride, experimenting different shoes, exploring new strengthening exercises — but the benefits were uncertain, if any.</p><p>Surprisingly, at race distances of half-marathon or less, while the problem did get in the way, I was not only able to complete the race but finish with a time that may not have been much better had the problem not occurred at all.</p><p>After a relatively quiet first half of 2022, I focused on improving my 10km/half-marathon times. This was roughly the period from around June to August 2022 while continuing to struggle with these problems ( its impact is lesser at shorter distances). Simultaneously — against general advice — I also increased my strength regiment, and my workouts featured higher weights and lower repetitions. I was noticing some improvement. After about a month of limited running at altitude (Ladakh), I again prepared for a marathon that was only a month or so away. This time the long runs were better and interestingly enough my right leg was problem free and I seemed to be able to handle the symptoms in the left leg. I continued to focus on strengthening and plyometric workouts and I thought I was getting better. I was even able to finish the marathon without any major issue (first ever). That was the middle of October 2022.</p><p>Unfortunately, between then and the time of this writing (mid December 2022) the situation appears to have worsened. The symptoms are more frequent, their onset occurring earlier during the runs and their impact greater. I have not been able to do a single long run satisfactorily since then. And now the symptoms have reappeared in the right leg (although not as bad as the left).</p><p>Not sure what has gone wrong and what I am doing differently. Or is this how the condition manifests itself — occasional improvements and then backsliding to some baseline? As I noted, through all this, my running times have improved and I managed to go under 40 minutes (10km) and 90 minutes (HM) in the last few months. These are not times that can be considered truly competitive but for an amateur runner nearing 40 (with no significant prior experince in endurance sport), they are well above average.</p><p>Nonetheless, my training runs, including threshold workouts have been well below expectations. I very recently suspected it may be because of insufficient recovery but I don’t believe that to be the case.</p><h3>Injury history</h3><p>Besides niggles here and there and the expected soreness and tightness from longer and harder workouts, I have never had any significant injury through all this. Or at least none that I am aware of and the physios who examined me also didn’t point to any. I have had my share of occasional aches and pains from some resistance workout that went wrong (or right).</p><h3>Relation to cramping?</h3><p>The other major impediment to my running is severe (exercise-induced) calf cramping and indeed, my failed races were all on account of locking up of the calves (and not the condition described here). Are these related? I think not.</p><p>To begin with, the symptoms of lack of muscular control can and does happen on easy efforts and their onset can be as early as 6km whereas I don’t cramp unless I am running hard and even so, never before 18km or so. Second, the symptoms have nothing in common — one is a delocalized sensation of partial impairment to motor control with no pain whatsoever and the other is highly localized and extremely painful. Cramping is mostly (there is an exception but will not describe here) preceded by a distinct sense of fatigue and the sense that I am pushing against the limits whereas lack of muscular control has no apparent relation to it (although it does feel worse when I am fatigued). Fourth, they don’t generally occur together and when they do it just seems mostly coincidental. Fifth, cramping pre-dates loss of muscular control: during runs, as early as 2016 and around the same time, in the pool as well. I also suffered from night cramps briefly.</p><h3>Final Thoughts</h3><p>I decided to write this because I am battling this bizarre problem for more than 2 years and despite significant effort and resources devoted to it, I am no closer to finding out either the origin of it (if there is one at all) or any definitive treatment strategy that has worked in some consistent manner.</p><p>It is very frustrating to have a condition that is without a clear diagnosis and whose symptoms are such that they make people wonder whether it is all inside my head. And yet those veritable symptoms not only prevent me from running at a level commensurate with my aerobic fitness, they turn the act of running itself from being enjoyable and liberating to something that is often tiresome, disappointing and frustrating.</p><p>At the time of this writing, I have signed up for another marathon but I have little reason to feel confident. I still believe that there is a fair chance that I’ll be able to overcome this but the horizon may be several years.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8e0761de34bf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The fundamental problem with Longtermism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@venky.physics/the-fundamental-problem-with-longtermism-33c9cfbbe7a5?source=rss-ec8abb248db6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/33c9cfbbe7a5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[effective-altruism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nuclear-war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[animal-welfare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[catastrophic-risk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[probability]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Venkateshan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Sep 2021 14:32:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-10T05:43:53.537Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4FbK9FsbTi2teXasPFBs9w.jpeg" /><figcaption>The expanding universe ultimately ends in heat death (all life would have ceased well before then). Source [NASA/Wikimedia]</figcaption></figure><p>Longtermism represents the philosophical position that the welfare and value of future generations of humans far outstrips that of the existing population and therefore we collectively ought to devote significant time and resources to positively influence the long-term future. More specifically, the argument draws attention to the fact that there will be far greater number humans who would have lived say 500,000 years from now (as compared to the present) and assuming that their lives are a net positive, a potential catastrophic event may extinguish such a possible future. And if we accept the premise that we should focus our charitable efforts on those areas which have the greatest possible (estimated) benefits, it follows that minimizing an extinction risk event should get high priority. Furthermore, if we could reduce that risk even a little bit, the impact will be immense simply because of the large mass of humanity that the future will deliver.</p><p>The ascendancy of longtermist thinking in the<a href="https://www.effectivealtruism.org/articles/cause-profile-long-run-future/"> effective altruism community </a>has been pronounced in the last 5 years or so. While there are several thought-provoking arguments that are made to support this perspective, I believe that there is something fundamentally problematic with it.</p><p>This is my attempt to characterize the problem and explain why it severely undermines the central claim around longtermism. Now, it’s quite possible that there is a very strong and convincing response to this. Yet I am not aware of any discussion on this and hence this post.</p><h3>Standard counter-arguments</h3><p>To be clear, my objection to longtermism has <strong>little in common standard counter-arguments</strong> for which the proponents have provided a clear and adequate response.</p><ol><li>I <strong>don’t </strong>have a problem with longtermism being <strong>counterintuitive</strong> — a lot of abstract ideas and principles are counterintuitive such as the cardinality of real numbers and mathematical properties of infinity.</li><li>In much the same way, I don’t quite accept the objection that the <strong>value of people who aren’t yet born do not count or should be heavily discounted </strong>in comparison to our own.</li><li>I’m also <strong>not</strong> persuaded by the claim that we don’t <strong>have any obligation</strong> to generations that may come into existence hundreds of thousands of years later.</li><li>I also do <strong>not</strong> in general have a problem with using <strong>expected value as a measure of assessment </strong>of an intervention or activity. At least not in the sense that I would dismiss it out of hand because it carries significant risk. Probabilistic outcomes are a fact of life and while we are all intrinsically risk-averse, the terrain of possibilities we explore should not be constrained by our biases.</li></ol><p>Longtermists are the first to acknowledge that the chance of preventing a catastrophic existential risk such as an all-out nuclear war well into the future may be rather small, maybe 1% or even less than that. Or the probability that we can increase the chance of survival of mankind 10 million years from now may be around 0.001% (or two orders of magnitude smaller). The exact number is not very important to the central (and indisputable) claim of the longtermist that <strong>even a small positive change </strong>would be <strong>disproportionately</strong> valuable given the future generations encompasses such an immense amount of people.</p><h3>Beyond expectation value: probability distribution</h3><p>While expected value in and of itself is not a problem, it does not convey the full picture. To get the full picture, we need to consider the probability distribution, i.e., the likelihood of various outcomes from whatever interventions we do in the interest of longtermism. Naturally, we prefer positive outcomes such as better average welfare or happiness of the future population rather than say, living under a totalitarian regime. It is when we consider the <strong>probabilities of distinct outcomes</strong> that longtermism runs into some crucial difficulties.</p><p>To understand the importance of probability distribution, let’s start with a simple example. Imagine for a moment that you are playing a game where you will earn $200 with probability 10% and there is no loss or gain for the remaining 90%. The expected value from such a game is $200*0.1 = $20.</p><p>Would you play such a game? Perhaps yes, because even though the chance of winning any money is 1 in 10, the payoff of $200 seems worth the effort or time to you.</p><p>Now imagine a slight variant of the above, where once gain, you earn the same $200 with probability 10% but in addition, you <strong>gain $2000</strong> with 1% probability and <strong>forfeit $2000</strong> with 1% probability. The remaining 88% represents an outcome with no gain or loss. The <strong>expected value is still the same:</strong></p><p>$200*0.1 + $2000*0.01 — $2000*0.1 = $20</p><p>How willing are you to play this game now? Maybe you are still inclined, but very likely you have a very different perspective of it. In the first case, you almost have nothing to lose (aside from the time and effort) but now there is considerable financial loss at stake (and large potential gain too). So e<strong>ven if you choose to play this game, you are certainly weighing the consequences of those possibilities and not just the expected value.</strong></p><p>And in this case, it is perfectly rational to do so. Despite expected value being the same, you may refuse to play because the <strong>downside is too large</strong>.</p><p>Now imagine yet another variant — quite an unusual one — where you are not <strong>even aware of the different outcomes or their probabilities.</strong> Here the rules of the game depends on several arbitrary factors such as the mood of the host, the weather at the venue, the food or drink that is served, the age of participants with the possibility that the risk and reward can swing wildly due to unforeseen events well beyond your control. Yet an Oracle tells you that the expected value from playing the game is $20. Assuming the Oracle is speaking the truth, would you play? Perhaps not.</p><h3><strong>Distribution of outcomes in the longterm</strong></h3><p>Something very similar as the final variant of the game is happening with longtermism. The <strong>reality is that whatever happens several thousand years from now will depend on a plethora of events between now and then</strong>. There is great deal of uncertainty not only about the events but also their consequences. We might choose to influence some of those events but what is the chance that <strong>our actions have the desired effect given the large amount of variability </strong>about how the epoch may evolve? And even if our present actions did have the desired effect at some intermediate time-point, why do we believe that a million years from now the march of humanity will fall in line with what we desire today?</p><p>Chaos theory deals with similar ideas albeit formulated in a more mathematical way. At the heart of it is the simple idea that starting from two <strong>very similar initial conditions</strong>, the evolution of the system (a set of particles, a mathematical function, etc) may, with time, diverge exponentially. For example, if you strike the billiard ball with a little extra force at the start of a game, the scenario at the table may look radically different half hour later as compared to what it may have been otherwise. To be clear, a lot of examples of chaos theory (including the above) is not very technically sound, but the idea remains powerful and correct: with progress of time, the consequences of a minor initial change will rapidly diverge when there are a lot of intermediate unpredictable forces at play during the period in between.</p><p>Indeed, people in EA are perhaps familiar with this which is why they come up with <a href="https://globalprioritiesinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/MacAskill_Mogensen_Paralysis_Argument.pdf">apparent paradoxes such as why one should never leave the house.</a></p><p>One may be thinking that while uncertainty for sure is real with longtermism, <strong>what is the equivalent of losing $2000 in the game</strong>, i.e, how could it be that we not only not end up saving or improving people’s lives but actually make things worse. There are two ways:</p><ol><li>Following the reasoning I’ve made so far, we just cannot be sure that a seemingly positive action today will necessarily lead to a positive outcome many, many generations later.</li><li>Opportunity cost: the resources spent on the long-term future could have been utilized for some near-term goals and there is every chance the overall long-term impact of those immediate concerns (such as improving access and quality of education) could be far greater, even insofar as stopping a catastrophic nuclear war is concerned. Think that’s far-fetched? It is, but no more so than the assumptions embedded in longtermism.</li></ol><h3>Mind-boggling level of future unpredictability</h3><p>I want to focus more on the first point above just to drive home that this is not merely some narrow, technical, academic objection but a very real and serious problem.</p><p>Imagine that an<strong> all-out nuclear warfare</strong> were to happen sometime in the next few years. We can all agree that it would be horrific, of course. It will not only result in the untimely death of millions of people who otherwise may have possibly lived a happy and meaningful existence with high welfare, it will also decimate the future generations.</p><p>Nonetheless, if you were to <strong>turn your mind to a million years from now</strong>, and wonder what the effect of a near-term nuclear warfare may be, can <strong>you be certain that it is net negative</strong>? I am not so sure.</p><p>Contrary to what most people may think, an <strong>all-out nuclear war will not kill everyone</strong>. Indeed there is an <a href="https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/david-denkenberger-allfed-and-feeding-everyone-no-matter-what/">80000 hours podcast exactly on how to prepare for such a scenario</a>. The survivors of such a conflagration (and there will plenty left) despite unprecedented hardships will very likely sustain human race. Not only that, there is a possibility that the future generations that emerge from such a calamity will be an enlightened one, assuming they have learned from the foolhardy human politics and tribalism that likely led to the event in the first place. In face, let us take this one step further and assume they are so much more enlightened that they <strong>no longer farm animals for food </strong>and are aghast that such a morally abhorrent practice was once regarded as acceptable. In doing so, such a future generation may be <strong>sparing the lives of over 80 billion land animals</strong> (not to mention fish and marine life) every year compared to us. If we extrapolate from such a scenario is it not reasonable to think that a million years later, this generation of humans <strong>may have transcended our present failures as a race far better </strong>precisely because of the catastrophe.<strong>Would not such a future be preferable, and besides, in the broad scope of cosmic timescales, what is one nuclear event anyway but a minor blip?</strong></p><p>Does this suggest that we should be rather indifferent if not complacent about the possibility of a nuclear war today? Of course not! The immediate horrors of such an event can be predicted with <strong>very high certainty</strong>. And the consequences of it say 5 years on, while <strong>somewhat less predictable</strong> in terms of the details, is still overwhelmingly awful. 50 years on, while things may have reached some stability, the nuclear war would still be seen as the worst tragedy for mankind. 500 years, perhaps still so. How about 5000 years on ? 50, 000 years on? Do you see that the actual<strong> long-term consequences of the event</strong> will depend on other events, actions, decisions and scenarios that humanity will bear witnesses to during the intervening period? It’s entirely possible then that future generations have not learned anything at all and are in general more benighted than us condemning each other to horrible torture and abuse. We just can’t be sure. Therefore, <strong>both from a practical and philosophical perspective, there is a strong case to be made for striving to avert an event that we know for certain would be disastrous from the perspective of the next 100 years. </strong>Not doing so in the hope that there is a possibility of some radically different world in the long term future does not seem very defensible and is…far-fetched.</p><h3>What would a persuasive case for long — termism look like?</h3><p>I can certainly get behind longtermism if it can be argued that specific present day action(s) have some positive impact with some non-negligible probability and can establish bounds on the probability of unfavorable outcomes.</p><p>As a crude example, if a longtermist were to state that the expected number of lives saved (by a present day intervention or series of interventions) in say T (say 100,000 ) years is N (say 1,000,000) and that the probability of saving <strong>at least</strong> M (say 10,000) lives is 25% and that the p<strong>robability of causing more deaths</strong> (or harm engendered) is less than 1%, <em>all things considered</em> (i.e., counter-factuals with opportunity cost), then I’ll put all objections aside.</p><p>As far as I know, there is no longtermist view that can provide evidence for a distribution of outcomes that is along the lines of what is described above.</p><p>In the absence of that, the uncertainty (as measured, statistically, say with standard deviation) of an intervention for the distant future is so much greater than the expected value that it is hard to imagine any context (personal, economic, political) where it would seem like a good idea to take decisions based on it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=33c9cfbbe7a5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why the lockdown of 1.3 billion people in India is unlikely to solve the pandemic problem]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@venky.physics/why-the-lockdown-of-1-3-billion-people-in-india-is-unlikely-to-solve-the-pandemic-problem-42977a087710?source=rss-ec8abb248db6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/42977a087710</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[covid-19-india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lockdown]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid-19-crisis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[covid-19-testing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[flatten-the-curve]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Venkateshan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Apr 2020 09:15:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-03T09:15:57.621Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Covid-19 pandemic has led governments across the world to take dramatic measures to arrest the spread of the disease. Even though the absolute number of cases in India seems relatively small (around 2000 at the time of writing), the government announced<a href="https://scroll.in/article/957564/not-china-not-italy-indias-coronavirus-lockdown-is-the-harshest-in-the-world"> one of the most severe lockdowns</a> on March 25 for a 21-day period.</p><p>Lockdown is one among a broader class of strategies deployed to reduce the spread of the disease known as non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPI). There is significant ambiguity about what these NPIs seek to accomplish, and in particular the <strong>distinction between suppression or containment and merely flattening the curve</strong>.</p><p>There is a rather straightforward way to understand that even if it may be a bit simplified.</p><h3>R0: They key to understanding disease evolution</h3><p>The variable that fundamentally characterizes the outbreak of a disease is<strong> R0, </strong>known as basic reproduction number, which represents the <em>average</em> number of individuals that a <em>typical </em><strong>infected</strong> person will infect (over the course of time that they are infected).</p><p>A critical threshold of interest for R0 is unity: if R0&gt; 1, then the number of infected cases over time will increase (and will do so exponentially); if R0 &lt;1, the number of infected cases will eventually decrease to 0. We can see this quite simply as follows: if we assume that the <em>infected period is 14 days</em> on average and if we are starting with 2 infected individuals in a population , and taking R0=2, then at the end of first infection cycle — i.e.,14 days, we have 4 new infected cases. In 28 days, these 4 individuals will have infected 8 others. Proceeding in a similar fashion, in n cycles — i.e 14*n days, we’ll have 2^(n) new infections in the last cycle alone. For general R0, the equivalent quantity would be R0^(n).</p><p><strong>Now if R0 is less than 1 then obviously that number decays to zero as n increases and conversely explodes exponentially when R0 &gt;1.</strong></p><p>(There are quite a few assumptions above which are discussed in Additional Notes section)</p><p>The R0 for Covid-19 appears to be somewhere between 2.3 and 4. The different interventions — be they lockdowns, social distancing, quarantines, closing off borders, etc. — are therefore efforts to reduce R0.</p><p><strong>What if an intervention reduces R0 but it is still greater than 1?</strong></p><p>Depending on the severity of the intervention, R0 may or may not be reduced to less than unity.</p><p>Let’s consider what happens when we reduce R0 but not to less than 1. The good news is that reducing R0 will <em>slow the rate</em> of exponential growth and this is what is called<strong> flattening the curve</strong>. The number of new cases everyday would be relatively lower and the health system would be in a better shape to handle the crisis. The bad news is that we would <em>still</em> have exponential growth if this happens.</p><p>On the other hand, disease suppression in a population would require interventions that reduce R0 to less than 1 . In that case, the number of active cases would eventually go to 0. This would naturally be the desirable outcome but it may be too difficult or too costly or both to achieve R0 less than 1.</p><h3>Effectiveness of temporary lockdowns</h3><p>Lockdown is one of the more extreme measures to reduce R0.</p><p>In the case of India, the first thing to recognize is the <em>temporary</em> nature of the lockdown — a period of 21 days. While the lockdown will undoubtedly reduce R0 and hence slow the spread of the disease, we need to explore this more thoroughly.</p><p>To grasp the situation better, let’s understand what we would ideally want to achieve during the lockdown. Of course, we want to eliminate the disease altogether but let’s see how exactly we might get there.</p><p>A successful lockdown strategy would involve efforts to identify all the infected individuals, isolate them, followed by tracing their contacts and quarantining them in turn. In due course, each of these cases would either lead to recovery or, in a few instances, death. Regardless, these cases will be closed and given that no one else in the population has been infected, the outbreak has been completely eliminated in the population.</p><p>That of course an ideal situation and impossible to attain in the real world. Nonetheless, a lockdown can be effective even if we relax some of these requirements. While it is impossible to identify all the individuals who are infected and their contacts (given that a lot of them asymptomatic), it would help a great deal if we manage to trace most or enough of the infected individuals such that, at the end of the lockdown period, the <strong>number of non-quarantined but (active) infected cases is less than at the start of the lockdown.</strong></p><p>How exactly do we accomplish this? As it has been clear in the case of China, South Korea, Taiwan and some other countries, the idea is to do massive testing while aggressively carrying out contact tracing and imposing isolation on those suspected to be infected.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/704/1*9sNp4dq59yN6oiG3FHsPzA.png" /><figcaption>Comparison of number of tests (per million) for Covid-19 (March 31 data).</figcaption></figure><p>Unfortunately, neither of that is happening in India where the testing rate so <a href="https://www.thehindu.com/data/data-to-reduce-coronavirus-spread-india-needs-to-test-more-lockdown-notwithstanding/article31201640.ece">far has been less than 50 persons/million</a>, one of the lowest in the world, and by comparison those number are over 8000 in South Korea and Italy.</p><p>Contact tracing is happening in India but nowhere as comprehensively as it is being done in some of the east Asian countries.</p><p>Compounding the problem is the massive migration of laborers across the country by foot in the days following the lockdown which led to government hastily setting up <a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/centre-orders-quarantine-camps-for-migrant-workers/articleshow/74880761.cms">quarantine camps at state borders</a>. The very purpose of a lockdown is defeated with such mass movement of the population.</p><p>And the number of active cases has risen from around 500 at start of the lockdown to over 1800 at the time of this writing.</p><h3>Returning to exponential growth at end of lockdown</h3><p>Just to reiterate, lockdown would certainly have slowed the spread of the disease. <strong>However given that we are clearly staring at a scenario where more people will be infected and remain unidentified at the end of the lockdown, those infected cases will subsequently lead to further infections and we go back to the exponential growth.</strong></p><p>In that case what have we gained?</p><p>Actually, we have gained something even then. We have <strong>bought time</strong> to ramp up the healthcare facilities, procure medical devices and protective gear, induct more healthcare workers, establish quarantine centers etc in order that we are better prepared to deal with the scenario that follows.</p><p>While no one should underestimate the importance of extra time for pandemic preparedness, we should also examine how much of progress is being made in that regard. Given the remarkably low testing rates, the issues plaguing <a href="https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/india/doctors-the-vanguard-of-covid-19-response-face-crippling-shortage-of-protective-gear-5101091.html">procurement of protective gear</a>, the migrations triggered by the lockdown it is hard to make the case that India has been making the most of the valuable time that has been obtained at an extraordinary cost.</p><h3>What should be done during the lockdown to make it more effective?</h3><p>Naturally, the first and most important step is to vastly expand the number of tests. The argument given by Indian Council of Medical Research for low testing rate is that the limited testing kits should be preserved for later use lest we run into shortages when the situation worsens.</p><p>While that argument may have some merit, what it ignores is that testing the population at an <strong>earlier stage has far </strong>greater potential to limit the spread of the disease. Again, this is easy to understand with some simple math. For instance, if testing is done when 0.01% of the population is infected and if we manage to identify 50% of all the cases (using a fixed number of kits), then we have reduced the <strong>disease burden by half</strong> but if we carried out the same number of tests when the infection rate is 0.1% of the population, then we could probably identify only about10–15% of the population.</p><p>To be sure, in and of itself, even reducing the disease burden by half will not solve the problem (for the simple reason that we will have exponential growth following it) but that’s where the second step comes in. <strong>Identification of disease clusters and extensive contract tracing</strong> so that we can then establish a more limited, but more effective, quarantine system that will require fewer resources and be far less chaotic.</p><h3>What happens after the lockdown?</h3><p>At the moment,there is no clarity on what the government intends to do. but Considering that the lockdown has come at an enormous cost to the most vulnerable segements of the society (not all of which has not feel fully accounted yet), it is unlikely that it will be continued. At least not in its present form.</p><p>An argument could be made in favor of imposing a more tightly controlled but far more localized lockdown in areas identified as hotspots. Resources can be concentrated in those regions to better handle the logistical challenges while restrictions are eased in the rest of the nation.</p><p>A more extensive testing (and population surveillance using serological tests) would help map out areas that require focused mobilization of resources. More thorough testing will also give a better estimate of how the outbreak is evolving and help guide preparedness of the health care system.</p><p>Regardless of the strategy, social distancing practices should be maintained by the entire population. Whatever may be the on ground scenario, reducing R0 will further flatten the curve, and social distancing will help in achieving that.</p><h3>Additional Notes</h3><ol><li><strong>Basic Reproduction Number: R0</strong></li></ol><p>a. R0 as defined above is rather simplified. In general the <em>number of individuals </em>an infected person will infect over the course of their infection will depend on a lot of factors such as the number of people that the person comes into contact with, the duration of exposure of those contacts, and the setting where that happened.</p><p>b. Further that number varies greatly across the population depending on age, location, the living conditions, profession (if it applies), etc.</p><p>c .Also it matters significantly how geographically widespread a person’s infection is transmitted. If only neighbors are infected, then the disease spread would be highly localized. Indeed that’s the reason for quarantining different regions as was done in Italy initially with the northern parts.</p><p>d<strong>.</strong> Crucially, even though different scenarios may have the same R0, the extent of severity of the outbreak will depend considerably on the distribution and spread of infection.</p><p>e. Strictly speaking R0 is a theoretical concept, and applies when only one person in the population is infected. At some stage in the evolution, the equivalent quantity is R which will also change.</p><p>2. There are epidemiological models and <a href="https://cddep.org/covid-19/">simulations</a> that have led to somewhat similar <a href="https://arxiv.org/pdf/2003.12055.pdf">conclusions</a> with regard to the lockdown. In general there are several assumptions with a model and these can change their predictions considerably. I wanted to argue that there is a fairly straightforward reasoning involved here that does not depend on the specific details of the models being used.</p><p>3. A <a href="https://science.thewire.in/health/scientists-coronavirus-post-lockdown-plan-migrant-labourers/">statement</a> signed by over 600 health professionals and scientists has argued how the lockdown is only “a stratagem for winning some time for the healthcare system”, urging the government to do more testing and the necessity of a post-lockdown plan.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=42977a087710" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Enduring myths about privacy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/swlh/enduring-myths-about-privacy-86238d2a37ab?source=rss-ec8abb248db6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/86238d2a37ab</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[surveillance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Venkateshan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Oct 2019 13:57:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-12T11:59:52.477Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*E3qOVitMUmND1rADmS7bOQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@papaioannou_kostas?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Papaioannou Kostas</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/s/photos/silhouette-group?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>When I talk to people about the dangers of ubiquitous surveillance, from tech companies tracking our online movements to governments collecting and storing our personal records, I am often met with refrains that sound very similar to each other. Even in this post-Snowden, post-Cambridge Analytica era, people seem to wonder why any of this is even a problem. What possible harm come your way if Facebook for example maintains a record of every single activity on its platform ?Some appear to believe that whatever privacy is lost when engaging with online services is outweighed by the benefits they gain from it.</p><p>Underlying these responses are a set of assumptions about the role that privacy has in one’s life and how privacy, or lack of it, mediates our relationship with each other, corporations and government. When you dissect these to the fundamentals, you uncover a set of myths that explains the attitude of indifference to these concerns.</p><h4>1. People who have nothing to hide have nothing to fear</h4><p>I am going to first say that it is very unlikely that anyone actually believes this to be true. <strong>Almost everyone cares about their privacy whether they realize it or not. </strong>Ask anyone who disagrees whether they are fine if every single conversation they have ever been a part of were to be broadcast on the internet? Ask them if there is something about their lives that they don’t feel comfortable discussing with friends, or even close family. How do they feel about recording every single movement of their lives and sharing the same on social media?</p><p>I doubt if anyone would be comfortable with these scenarios. And yet, that does not mean that they have committed a crime or done something unethical. For example, it is perfectly normal to share some viewpoints only within a trusted group, just as there is nothing illegal in wanting to keep private some innocuous but embarrassing event in your life. <strong>The idea that anyone who insists on privacy has something terrible to hide has to be one of the most pernicious ideas to arise from this debate.</strong></p><p>In fact, it is in a private space that we can explore new patterns of thought, understand ourselves better, develop novel ideas, hone our creative instinct and cultivate meaningful dissent. Privacy plays an important role in identifying and shaping the inner voice which defines our personalities.</p><h4>2. Implicit faith in the organizations that access or store the data</h4><p>Even though the recent few years have made people skeptical of the tech giants and their ability or even willingness to guarantee the privacy and security of our data, there is still the general idea that most organizations — and government — that has access to our data do not use it for malicious purposes. If anything, the experience of using the platforms and services improves when you choose to share more data with them, a point they never fail to remind you when requesting for more permissions.</p><p>The reality however is<strong> fundamentally incompatible with this viewpoint.</strong> First, given the fact that firms make a ton of money from user data, they have little incentive to limit their usage, unless there are strong regulations they are forced to abide by. <strong>Further, the data that you provide across different websites and services, are often collated, either through third party trackers or more direct partnerships resulting in far greater personal information than what you might assume.</strong> Second, this data is shared with governments upon request (under <a href="https://thewire.in/law/paytm-data-theft-cobrapost-sting">vague legal mandate</a> depending on the <a href="https://www.hongkongfp.com/2016/12/17/facebook-sees-212-increase-in-hong-kong-govt-user-information-requests/">region and government)</a> and if there is any reason for governments to learn more about you, they have access to large volume of your online activity. Third, even if the companies have the best intentions, and ensure the best data protection practices, there is nothing to guarantee that there are no bugs that will leak user data or prevent hackers from breaching their systems. To be sure, this is not some far-fetched scenario because <a href="https://www.csoonline.com/article/2130877/the-biggest-data-breaches-of-the-21st-century.html">major data breaches</a> are <a href="https://digitalguardian.com/blog/history-data-breaches">far more common </a>than you may think. Even if you assumed that the firms themselves were acting in your best interests, that can no longer be true with those who now access the leaked data.</p><p>And the situation with a national citizen registry project like Aadhar is far worse. The <a href="https://www.medianama.com/2018/05/223-aadhaar-leaks-list/">number of data breaches are staggering</a>, and given the fact that it represents the vast majority of the population, the risks are far greater.</p><p><strong>3. I am fine with my data being available and accessed</strong></p><p>Even if you truly do not care about who has access to your data, you would agree that there are others such a<strong>s journalists and their sources, lawyers and clients, medical professionals and patients who should be entitled to appropriate measure of privacy. </strong>One of the greatest dangers today is how easily you are compromising someone else’s privacy when you do not care about it yourself. What truly enabled Cambridge Analytica to harvest such a large amount of user data is that the original study was able to access not just the participants who had consented to provide their data, <a href="https://www.vox.com/2018/3/17/17134072/facebook-cambridge-analytica-trump-explained-user-data">but that of all their friends on FB </a>as well (this was enabled by default on FB in 2014). <strong>Likewise, when you allow an app to give permission to access your contacts, you’ve just handed over the data of hundreds of people without their consent to a third party. </strong>This is also what enables apps like TrueCaller to detect your number even though you may not be using it and do not wish to have your details with them.</p><p><strong>4. Privacy is my personal preference</strong></p><p>It would be a serious mistake to frame the debate on privacy in terms of purely personal preference. <strong>The importance of privacy extends beyond that of any individual and to the wider society, playing an essential role in democratic process and protecting the rights of minorities and vulnerable communities.</strong></p><p>Dissident political activity may not be something that may please the government it is aimed at but that is precisely why it is a critical part of a healthy democracy. Protests and agitations involve coordinating strategies, discussions on tactical approaches and resolving differences among various factions. If the government can spy on any individual with<a href="https://www.rt.com/usa/271108-xkeyscore-nsa-training-documents/"> just their telephone number or email address</a>, that immediately confers an enormous leverage in terms of limiting the effectiveness of nascent or even established movements. One cannot overstate the importance of major social movements in history including that of abolishment of slavery, advancement of women’s rights, LGBT equality, ending racial segregation and apartheid, defending the environment and vulnerable indigenous communities, etc. <strong>Had the government been able to learn every detail of dissident activity, the trajectory of social progress may have looked very different.</strong></p><p>This is exactly why the Chinese government has been <a href="https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/05/human-rights-watch-reverse-engineers-mass-surveillance-app-used-police-xinjiang">experimenting with its more extreme surveillance technological</a> capability in Xinjiang, a province that comprises primarily of the minority Uyghur community, who have faced persecution by the government for a long time. China imposes several restrictions on what the residents in that province can do and the surveillance dragnet aims to identify any behavior that is not deemed ‘normal’.</p><p>While Chinese policy shows a particularly callous disregard for privacy, that does nothing to assuage the concerns of expansion of surveillance capabilities elsewhere.</p><p>One of the chilling consequences of undermining privacy of communication is the silencing of potential whistleblowers who may otherwise have chosen to come forward with information on corruption or wrongdoing by the most powerful people in government.</p><p>Even if you live in a country where you completely trust the government and agree with all its policies (I strongly doubt there is anyone like that), you should still be concerned about privacy because that government can change and the successor may not be as much to your liking. <strong>The fact that privacy is given a short shrift by a government, even one that you trust immensely, implies that a precedent has been created providing legal justification and the technological infrastructure and capability to carry out surveillance by all governments that follow. </strong>Your politics may be on the left or right, <strong>but if you believe in the principle that those in power should be held accountable or that citizens have a right to free speech and organize protests and demonstrations, then you should recognize that privacy is indispensable.</strong></p><p>These issues have even greater relevance today as the tech companies integrate themselves more and more in our lives happen to share information about <a href="https://www.hindustantimes.com/tech/facebook-received-over-22-000-data-requests-from-indian-government-in-2017/story-3JbVAUNSgpeWOOI1hRo5jI.html">users with the government</a>, and often do so without notifying the users of the fact. It is difficult to know the type and extent of personal data that ends up with the government without consent, partly because few people are aware of — or can control — the extensive tracking that is carried out across the cyberspace. This explains <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/oct/03/facebook-surveillance-us-uk-australia-backdoor-encryption">why governments are</a> <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2019/oct/03/facebook-surveillance-us-uk-australia-backdoor-encryption">desperately fighting against </a><a href="https://thenextweb.com/security/2019/06/18/india-is-still-hounding-whatsapp-to-make-its-messages-traceable/">end to end encryption</a> because that form of cryptographic security guarantees that even the firms running that service would not be able to access the content of the conversations.</p><p>While privacy of any individual is very important, focusing exclusively through that lens would lose sight of the wider picture, which has much greater consequences in the long term. <strong>Someone may not care much about their day to day texts or conversations being spied upon but some reflection would reveal that this capability poses a grave threat to democratic freedoms.</strong></p><h4>5. <strong>Ignoring the fact that Data is Money</strong></h4><p>For those who assume that services like Facebook or Google are free, remember that these firms literally make billions of dollars with the users data through ad revenue. <strong>Without the data we provide, their business model would collapse.</strong></p><p><strong>Even if the principle of privacy as such does not persuade you, then surely the fact that personal data has enormous monetary value should imply that there are well defined restrictions on collecting, storing, processing, accessing, sharing and using it. </strong>This would be natural if we are talking about important physical resources like oil or precious metals. Why should it be any different with data?</p><p>It is therefore a matter of concern if details on what data is being collected, and how it is being processed or who is it being shared with is not made transparent to the user or is hidden behind lengthy terms and conditions that nobody in practice reads. As pointed out earlier, most of us are often unaware of the <a href="https://medium.com/s/story/the-complete-unauthorized-checklist-of-how-google-tracks-you-3c3abc10781d">extent of tracking </a>when <a href="https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/01/guided-tour-data-facebook-uses-target-ads">using popular services online</a>. Indeed, this was the motivation behind formulating GDPR, the data protection law in Europe that came into force a little over a year ago, and unsurprisingly Google has been<a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/google-fine-privacy-eu-laws-gdpr-rules-data-protection-france-a8739411.html"> slapped with fines for violations</a>. It would appear that more such violations will be uncovered and fined in the future.</p><p>If we really think through the far-reaching consequences of issues related to privacy and specifically how technology and the internet has fundamentally changed the modes by which privacy is secured or lost and the vast amount of digital trails that we leave behind (far greater than at anytime in human history), we might begin to appreciate the need for taking it seriously both as individuals and as a society. The Cambridge Analytica scandal for example alerted a lot of people to the potency of large collection of personal data but that is only the tip of the iceberg. Failure to act decisively on this matter may soon find us heading towards a full fledged surveillance society, the forerunners of which are to be seen in China’s Xinjiang province.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=86238d2a37ab" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/enduring-myths-about-privacy-86238d2a37ab">Enduring myths about privacy</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/swlh">The Startup</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Recalling my arguments for going vegan nearly a decade ago]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/post-darwinian-speciesist/recalling-my-arguments-for-going-vegan-nearly-a-decade-ago-c4ee2f659acd?source=rss-ec8abb248db6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c4ee2f659acd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[animal-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vegan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Venkateshan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Sep 2019 03:50:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-24T03:50:55.619Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MsYYuPIV_AsLRgXxvaIbWQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>It’s been nearly 10 years since I decided to ditch dairy and go vegan. In the years since, a lot has changed — the number of vegans has grown considerably, there is greater familiarity with the concept and the surrounding issues, wider recognition of the significance of the diet and lifestyle in the context of health, environment and sustainability.</em></p><p><em>I was living in the U.S. when I made the switch and being close to New York enabled me to connect with a community of committed vegans and animal rights activists. In fact, it was the arguments with some of them that had prompted me to examine my assumptions in the first place. To be clear, I was aware of the animal abuse prevalent in factory farms for a while but for some inexplicable reason,was relatively sanguine about the dairy industry. As a vegetarian — and especially Indian — you tend to somehow assume that you are not really complicit in animal abuses. Further I never thought about the myriad ways, besides food production, in which humans systematically exploit animals. Discovering and understanding more about these issues led me to re-evaluate these presuppositions.</em></p><p><em>I am the sort of individual who is uncomfortable with dogmas. I felt that if I were going to adopt a strong stance, I would need to consider the issue thoroughly, examining it from different angles. I wanted to hear the counter-arguments and the objections and determine whether I would be able to address them convincingly.</em></p><p><em>But it didn’t take long for me form an opinion.</em></p><p><em>It became fairly clear to me that there was not only an </em><strong><em>unassailable ethical basis to animal rights but also that it was a severely neglected issue </em></strong><em>even though the scale of animal suffering is unimaginable.</em></p><p><em>Below, I recount the original arguments I had formulated nearly 10 years ago to justify my position. Remarkably, aside from a few minor points, I wouldn’t stray too far from it even if I were to rework them. More importantly, nothing that I have come across in the last decade has been compelling enough to change my mind.</em></p><p>It is also important that I describe the scope of this discussion. First, the case I am making here is that meat-eating in contemporary society is unacceptable because it is cruel to the animals. There are many other valid reasons for avoiding meat — improved health, less harm to the environment and eco-system, protest against horrible labor conditions in the meat industry, decrease in overall starvation in poorer countries etc. While each of these has a solid empirical and philosophical basis to it, I am not going to be discussing any of them here. Second, although I say ‘meat-eating’, I use the term as a general reference to how animals are abused by humans for food which includes eggs and dairy products. There are also other, equally unacceptable, ways in which animals are used in entertainments and pet industry but that shall not be the focus here in this article. Third, I use the term “animal-rights” loosely and what I mean will become clearer as we go further but nonetheless it can become a point of some confusion because those involved in the movement take the notion to different degrees. It would be useful to remember this fact.</p><p><strong>INVALID REASONS</strong>:</p><p>Before I launch into the actual arguments, I believe it would be very useful to first state what my views on animal rights are NOT about:</p><p>(a) <strong>Religious/Cultural:</strong> This is obvious because religions or cultural norms don’t have consistency. Muslims avoid pork, Hindus avoid beef, and Jews have a specific dietary constraints encoded in kosher laws. While all these religions have paid some attention to animal rights (most notably Jainism, Buddhism and Hinduism) the question of acceptability can and should be addressed independent of any religious ideology.</p><p>(b)<strong>You should be an animal lover:</strong> There is a very common notion- popular among advocates and critics- that you need to adore animals and admire them for their uniqueness in order to sympathize with the cause of animal rights. This view is dangerous because it assumes that the concern for animal welfare is based upon OUR feelings for them. That it is our patronizing mercy based upon how we relate to them that makes a case for valuing their life. Many advocates of animal rights somehow subtly imply this themselves thereby undermining the more universal idea that inflicting pain on animals is unacceptable independent of whether these are endearing pets or wild, hideous and repellent creatures.</p><p>( c) <strong>Humans are designed to eat only plants and eating meat is basically unhealthy:</strong> As it stands, this statement is not scientifically accurate. While it is true that there is a strong correlation between vegan diet and good health this does NOT imply that eating moderate quantities of meat is necessarily going to clog arteries, lead to overweight, or cause other disorders. Likewise, it is true that meat has a greater chance of being contaminated with infectious germs or chemicals that undermine the immunity defence of our body, but majority of meat available in supermarkets and such is likely to be safe.</p><p>(d)<strong>Inherent value in life OR it is unethical to kill a life form</strong>: This is very problematic because it is quite an arbitrary principle that is not based on any clear foundations. More importantly, from a biological standpoint, plants have life and so do algae, bacteria, yeast and — depending on which biologist you speak to — even viruses. If the property of being alive, i.e., demonstrating the characteristics of life — growth, repair, reproduction, nutrition etc — , were given a special value one would have to extend this to all the biological life forms and clearly that is not necessary. Thus terminating life — in and of itself — is not a significant issue.</p><p>(e) <strong>Animals and humans are the same OR animals deserve the same rights as man: </strong>Few facts can be more obvious than broad areas of differences between humans and non-human mammals, let alone other categories of species that inhabit our planet. It would be silly to argue that animals must be given the opportunity to participate in our dysfunctional democracies or be given the promise of progressive taxation. Or provide them exact status and identification in society as the rest of us. Clearly neither is this practical nor would the animals desire it, even if they had a choice of some sort. So when I say use the term “rights” I mean in a more restrictive sense.</p><h4>THE CENTRAL PRINCIPLE</h4><p>This naturally leads us to the question of what is the basis of animal rights? The strongest -and arguably the only -concern that underlies this case is the question of whether our actions inflict physical pain on sentient organisms. That forms the basis for all the arguments in favor of animal rights. Having stated it this way, the debate then reduces to an argument over the morality of such actions — those that result in suffering of living beings endowed with pain perception.</p><h3>THE OBJECTIONS</h3><h3>1) Nature is blind to right and wrong.:</h3><p>An immediate question that may pop in your mind at this point would be my tacit assumption of some pre-ordained moral code in a “mechanical” universe that behaves according to value-neutral natural laws. You may wonder, while pain is clearly an avoidable feeling, there is no basic principle which states that we should not be responsible for causing more of it. This line of reasoning is perfectly rational — albeit quite perverse — and yes, there is nothing in nature that informs us that this is an unethical behavior. However, at the same time, there is nothing in nature that forbids torturing innocent human beings either. Or anything that argues in favor of human rights or promotes individual liberty. And yet, these are the foundational aspects of modern civilization that most reasonable people are willing to agree upon. Despite this, you may be persistent — and more cynically perverse — and claim that these human-related “values” were created in order to advance the human race and it is a rational choice rather than a moral one in that it helps to strengthen the community end ensures safety and security of the majority. To respond, I first claim that this interpretation is evidently false because the primary reaction of people to murders or mutilation of human beings is not based on cold reasoning and assessment that such actions are damaging to the society but rather as “immoral” in a more basic sense. Naturally, this begs the question of what is meant by “basic sense” especially when I have discarded any nature-derived rules and dismissed religious arguments. I’ll admit that it is fairly difficult to pin down this ‘basic moral sense’ in any unambiguous and objective way but instead, I will provide some counter-examples to this line of argument.If protecting one’s own community/society is the most important goal, then there would no objection to exploiting other societies and benefiting from it. Retail goods being available cheaply in the U.S. cannot be valid reason to promote sweatshops in developing countries even if — as is unfortunately the case sometimes — such practices are unregulated in those countries. Slavery benefited the slave-owners and the ruling elite but that is not a reason for insisting on its continuance. Autocracy and authoritarian regimes always favor the wealthy and the powerful at the expense of the masses but would you regard the actions of dictator and his cohorts as “moral” because it is done to promote the self-interest of their class? No, it is fairly clear that the basic principles of civil liberties and human rights are based upon a sense of morality — however hard it may be to define that — and not on a rational consideration of the impact of such decisions on variables as the GDP.</p><h3>2) Animals are distinct from humans:</h3><p>If we accept that respect for basic human rights is a fundamental ethical principle that must be universally enforced, then what are the reasons for eliminating other sentient organisms from such considerations? Is it because humans can talk? Is it because we are more intelligent? Is it because we are capable of showing moral consideration that a lion in a jungle would not? What is the special property of humans that animals lack which gives us authority to abuse them as much as we do? As can be noted, my central thesis here is not so much about changing value system of society but <em>demanding consistency</em> in the application of the most basic ones we cherish.</p><p>Let me take up each distinction that is noted between humans and animals and dismiss them as valid justifications for our abusive behavior by providing appropriate counter-examples.</p><p>(i) <strong>Humans are a higher level species with abilities that are unique to them</strong>: This is unquestionably true as we can see that no other species is known to communicate as we do or have complex reasoning faculties that has led humans to discover science and develop technology that we enjoy today. It is also true that we have a very sophisticated social setup that is uncommon among other species. However, it is far from obvious that such progress gives us special privilege to treat animals in a way that would be unthinkable if the victims were fellow human beings. If we regard intelligence as the primary trait that sets us apart from our lower species, what about those humans whose intellectual prowess are so abysmally low that they cannot carry out simple tasks. Does it become acceptable, given their severe retardation, that we treat them violently, confine them in narrow spaces, deprive them of basic care and turn them into slave laborers for benefit of other, more advanced people? Quite obviously, this conclusion is ridiculous. Worse, there are individuals in an extremely vegetative state while remaining conscious and the extent of incapacitation makes them less able, broadly speaking, than the more advanced non-human mammals. Should we permit mutilating parts of their bodies for reasons of convenience as we do to pigs and chicken? Again, these rhetorical questions have an unequivocal answer.</p><p>(ii) <strong>Humans are moral but animals are not</strong>: Detractors point to the fact that the moral code we have in society is something mutual, or contractual. If I am armed but I choose not to kill someone, it is generally true that my restraint would be reciprocated by others in society. However, if I were to spare the life of a tiger in the woods while carrying a rifle, it is unlikely that this generous consideration would be reciprocated were I the one to be defenceless. The argument goes on to state that the moral framework is closed within the human society. To address this, first observe that majority of livestock animals are not predatory. Pigs or cows are unlikely to attack humans let alone the possibility of chicken and turkey hunting us down. So, even if one were going to justify eating meat of based on this reasoning, one would have to brace oneself for more dangerous hunting trips. Second — as I stated earlier -it is not so much the killing itself as the conditions in which animals are kept that is most objectionable as far as modern day livestock industry is concerned. Thus the more apt comparison is not a tiger mauling a person but keeping one in captivity for several years while tearing muscle by muscle and limb by limb, dismembering slowly, all done while the person is conscious. Third,at any rate, this point is fundamentally disingenuous. We have the capacity for moral reflection and so we can take a broader view of things. Animals are simply incapable of doing that and in that way they are like children. It is not uncommon for toddlers to inadvertently act in a way that acutely affects someone, but those are not regarded as a violation in the same manner as that of deliberate action by a normal adult. Animals have an instinct to protect themselves from threats and carnivores have an instinct to hunt and feed. They have little choice over such instincts.</p><h3>3) The naturalness fallacy</h3><p>If our superior average intellect or our special talents as social beings does not give us the right to treat non-human animals in an abusive way, what else does? Well, our ancestors have all eaten meat. It is likely to have been the primary source of food for a long period of time in our evolution. Meat-eating is still the norm in most cultures in the world. So, even though we may cause undue trauma to animals in captivity, it is only reasonable that we do what we have been doing for ages. To address this point, it may be first useful to make an important distinction in the nature of assertions, something that is usually identified in most philosophical discussions. Any claim concerning the world falls into one of two broad categories, descriptive and normative.</p><p>(a) A <strong>descriptive statement</strong> is an empirical claim about the world. It can verified by observation, examination or simple experimentation. Canada lies to the north of the US is a trivial example of such a statement. Stating that euthanasia is a contentious issue is most societies is a descriptive fact — it can be verified. Noting that possession and sale of marijuana is outlawed in some developed countries is a third example. Recognizing that financial recessions are known to occur from time to time in all economies is an observation about the world.</p><p>(b) <strong>Normative statement</strong> is one that claims what <em>should be</em> or <em>ought to be</em> in the world. It expresses a certain value. For example, saying that government should promote scientific literacy and eliminate superstition is a normative statement. Euthanasia should be tolerated in society is another example. Arguing that marijuana, and most drugs, must be legalized also falls within this category. We should try to prevent or at least minimize recessions by developing policy framework that keeps the economy more stable (and not be swept away by the illusion of market self-correction) is a normative claim.</p><p>As you can see, in many of these instances, the normative stand on an issue is not identical to the descriptive details. While some of the examples I have provided may be more controversial, consider the relatively uncomplicated case of global poverty. Starvation has been a scourge of mankind throughout its history (a descriptive fact). However, despite this strong evidence, we have a collective responsibility to minimize it by trying to reform the production, distribution and pricing of food and other basic resources (normative statement). In a similar manner, there are several other issues where we choose to act against or prevent something that has known to occur in nature or societies over long periods of time (natural disasters, wars, infant mortality, pandemic and even extinction of species) . It would then be a poor excuse — and very hypocritical one — to defend a specific practice on the sole basis of the observation that it has been this way all along, i.e it is “natural”. It follows then, that merely stating that <em>homo sapiens</em> have eaten meat for most part of their history cannot be regarded as a valid justification for continuing to do so.</p><h3>4) Yet another appeal to nature</h3><p>If our “natural” behavior does not constitute sufficient justification for our actions, what else can there be? How about the observation that non-human carnivores would anyway continue to hunt and kill other animals? Even if we all stop eating meat, what happens to the millions of other animals that are attacked and have their flesh ripped apart in the wild? How does our position square against fact? In response, in the first place, recall that the worst aspects of the meat industry are the appalling conditions of housing, transportation and feeding of animals rather than the slaughter itself. Carnivores pouncing on lower level organisms in the food chain and killing them is, on an average, a lot quicker than the near endless amount of intense trauma we cause to chicken and pigs kept in tiny cages covered in bruises, filth and noxious gases. If our meat-eating involved just slaughtering alone (after the animals live a life in a normal environment) , it would be an immensely more acceptable practice. Second, and I don’t have exact data here, consider the number of birds and mammals that are killed every year in the livestock industry with the total number of their deaths in the wild. The former is a staggering 40 billion — for each year! — and it is so massive that the UN estimates that 30% of land area is devoted in one form or the other to the industry. On the other hand, the total number of wild birds on the planet is estimated to be about 100–200 million and I imagine the number of mammals to be about the same. Of these the numbers that are attacked and killed during the lifetime would be about a quarter or less. Put together, one can be fairly certain that less than 1 billion mammals/birds are falling prey to carnivores/omnivores in the wild. (What about insects…?) Third, it is unreasonable to point to other instances of suffering in Nature to justify us torturing and causing more of the same (the descriptive-normative distinction again). It is like saying that yes, there is extreme malnutrition and hunger all over the world — it is only “natural” — and so I won’t do anything to help someone I see starving. Finally, it is absurd to compare ourselves with animals in this context. We don’t take all our hints for a good life from animals do we? Despite the contrivance of evolutionary psychologists, and to a lesser degree, anthropologists, in explaining our behavior based on our more bestial ancestors, or the glib and wholly unscientific talk of “unnatural” suppression of animal instincts that appears in popular culture and the grotesquely misinterpreted catchphrase “survival of the fittest” — or its sophomoric variant “greed is good” or other ludicrous Randian-esque doctrines — we obviously don’t follow rules of the jungle.</p><h3>5) Challenging the pain hypothesis :</h3><p>Critics often wonder how animal rights activists are so dogmatic in their insistence that pigs feel pain while wheat crops don’t. Certainly plants are living organisms, and consequently the state of being alive and dead applies equally well to them, but how do we know they don’t feel pain? The most accurate answer to this is yes, there is ABSOLUTELY NO WAY of PROVING that cows and turkeys are undergoing enormous physical stress if you shear off their legs whereas pulling a twig from a tree does not affect it in any way. But, at the same time, there is NO WAY of PROVING that prisoners held under indefinite detention in American military bases overseas are capable of feeling pain. Equivalently, there is no way to prove that Muslims feel pain in much the same way that Jews do. I am being completely serious here. The sensation of pain — as opposed to the origin, symptoms and effects of pain — is a mental state and mental states cannot be detected in any way.</p><p>If you were to be bleeding, I can only INFER that you are experiencing pain — the bleeding itself or the cut vessels or the damaged tissue and other observable features does NOT represent pain — and this inference comes from imagining my own reaction in a similar situation. In other words, knowledge of pain to anyone other than oneself is a purely inferential thing and it cannot be rigorously proved. And I recognize that you have a similar nervous system as I do — the brain, spinal chord, nerve endings, nociceptors etc — and I put things together and conclude that you ought to feel pain. In much the same way, mammals and birds not only exhibit similar external behavioral symptoms when trapped in adverse conditions, but also have anatomically similar structure which enables us to infer — with as much (or as little) accuracy as I did when you bled — that they feel pain. On the other hand, plants don’t have a nervous system and hence incapable of sensory perception whatsoever. Is it possible there are other mechanisms by which they feel pain, mechanisms that have different system? Highly unlikely. We have a tremendous level of understanding about the structure, functioning, survival and development of plants — photosynthesis, transportation of nutrients, reproduction, evolution — and had there been an additional component which enabled plants to experience pain, we would almost certainly have discovered it by now. Another reason to assume plants don’t feel pain comes from observing that plants are stationary. Pain developed, along the evolutionary road in advanced organisms, as a survival tactic -to instinctively run away from adverse conditions. However since plants are immobilized, pain as such would not confer any such evolutionary advantage and so it is unlikely to have taken root in them. Still, even if we accept that we cannot determine whether plants can or cant feel pain, that does not give us reason to be cruel to organisms that we know for sure feel pain. Also even if rice and corn crops were to experience pain, it would still be more humane to eat them directly because of the inefficiency associated with feeding that to livestock and eating the animals.</p><h3>6) More Perversion</h3><p>A meaningful question that may arise at this juncture is the nature of classification of living organisms in terms of their ability to experience pain. This is a very pertinent point because the entire thesis here rests on the premise that animals are sentient and hence ought to be treated in a more humane way. The common refrain from opponents is the rhetorical barrage of mock-questions: Is mosquito sentient? Can bacteria and amoeba feel pain? How about E coli? These questions are intended, quite obviously, to challenge the entire presumption(s) on which the animal welfare claims rest. It is essential to emphasize that the case for animal welfare of those organisms whose sentience is substantiated with solid evidence -mammals and birds, for example- is independent of the precise boundary — if there is one at all — between the sentience and lack of it in the spectrum of animals ranked accordingly. The justification for this, yet again, is that the the possibility that certain mid-level organisms — insects — may feel pain and our corresponding inability to adequately prevent harm done to them gives us no reason to brutalize creatures that certainly feel pain. Addressing the question more directly though, the current scientific consensus holds that fish feel pain and lobsters and shrimps most likely do too. Insects are believed to be insensitive primarily because of the nature of their nervous system and the behavioral responses to negative stimulus. Protozoans, amoeba and fungi are as likely to be as sentient as pine trees.</p><p><em>Apart from my rather hastily formed views wild animal suffering (involving claims that are either wrong or cannot be justified), much of the basic reasoning framework that I had espoused then is what I still believe in. Part of the reason their endurance is the due considerations I had given to the potential merits in the objections. The other was dismissing what I believed to be rather unconvincing arguments I often heard — and still hear — to support the cause which does not hold up to careful scrutiny.</em></p><p><em>Despite the fact that my fundamental positions have not changed much, I do feel quite differently about how change happens in human society. I had earlier assumed that, armed with correct facts and arguments, one can convince humanity to move away from deeply entrenched habits and practices. Once people became aware of the realities of animal agriculture and the self-serving justifications are exposed for what they truly are, I thought that it would only be a matter of time before the world stopped abusing animals.</em></p><p><em>The reality is that arguments are however just a small part of it. There are several factors that needs to come together to bring out broad based transformation of society. Interestingly, we may be at just the right moment to bear witness to such a coalescence of factors as veganism (and animal rights) is at the verge of breaking into the mainstream discourse.</em></p><p><em>At a personal level though, the arguments have been very important in sustaining the commitment to the philosophy and lifestyle, and also staying firm in one’s beliefs when confronted with challenges.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c4ee2f659acd" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/post-darwinian-speciesist/recalling-my-arguments-for-going-vegan-nearly-a-decade-ago-c4ee2f659acd">Recalling my arguments for going vegan nearly a decade ago</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/post-darwinian-speciesist">Post Darwinian Speciesist</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is AI marching steadfast to human level intelligence?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/swlh/is-ai-marching-steadfast-to-human-level-intelligence-d066fb02843a?source=rss-ec8abb248db6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d066fb02843a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-general-intell]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technological-singularity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[data-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[deep-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Venkateshan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Aug 2019 14:55:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-07T07:21:53.804Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nbb3RDyngLOVB0AeHmNVQw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Max Pixel</figcaption></figure><p>Artificial intelligence (AI) has proven to be remarkably successful in a number of fields — beating the<a href="https://techcrunch.com/2017/05/24/alphago-beats-planets-best-human-go-player-ke-jie/"> best human player of Go</a>, identifying faces in a video, engaging in an<a href="https://www.theverge.com/2018/5/9/17334658/google-ai-phone-call-assistant-duplex-ethical-social-implications"> eerily human-like conversation</a> and generating<a href="https://openai.com/blog/better-language-models/"> entire paragraphs of meaningful text</a>.</p><p>Even more remarkably, most of this development has occurred in the last few years highlighting the other aspect of AI — <em>its exponential rate of progress,</em> with rapid improvements in performance on specific tasks and overall explosion in the domains of its application. In fact, this pace of growth has been true more generally with the digital age but the gains seem particularly pronounced with AI.</p><p>If we were to extrapolate the exponential growth of AI capabilities, it may seem that in the not too distant future, we would have AI systems first attaining, and then surpassing, human level intelligence. Such runaway AI intelligence could possibly mean that we would have a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_singularity">super-intelligent AI system that controls everything</a> in the world leaving the fate of humanity unclear.</p><p>What should we make of such prognosis? Is it true that we are very close to the threshold of breakout in human level AI or could it be possible that, despite all the impressive achievements of AI, the sort of intelligence that humans take for granted is still far out of the reach of AI technology?</p><p>To answer that question, we need to first distinguish <em>two intertwined issues</em> here — the first, the continuation of exponential growth in AI, and the second, the progressive emergence of artificial human level intelligence.</p><h3>Exponential growth is an exception, not a rule</h3><p>While the trajectory of electronics and communications technology strongly suggests that <em>all technological</em> progress is exponential, the reality is far less exciting. In fact, there are a lot of areas where development has been significantly slower than what one may have hoped for.</p><p>Consider the following examples of technologies that held a lot of promise at some stage but actual advances have been quite uneven: development of fusion reactors, advances in quantum computing, development of personalized medicine, space exploration,novel modes of transportation, harnessing alternative forms of energy, etc.</p><p>This isn’t to say that there hasn’t been progress in these areas or that the effort is somehow lacking or that there cannot be an exponential breakout in the future. It is merely to counterbalance the incorrect view that exponential growth characterizes all technological advancements.</p><p>In fact, the exponential progress that we see in digital technology <strong>ultimately traces to that very fortuitous scenario where every bit of extra room in silicon is being squeezed to create paths for electron flows with the result that</strong><a href="https://www.technologyreview.com/s/400710/the-end-of-moores-law/"><strong> Moore’s law</strong></a><strong> — a prediction based on extrapolation, not a law in the sense of physical laws — continues to be useful heuristic more than 5 decades after it was pronounced.</strong></p><p>Of course, Moore’s Law cannot be sustained forever and the growth will eventually plateau. The exponential progress that we have seen is <strong>not only exceptional but has a finite time window.</strong></p><h3>Narrow AI vs Artificial General Intelligence</h3><p>Despite Moore’s Law, there cannot be any doubt that neural networks have proven formidable at specialized tasks and this upward trajectory is likely to continue. In the not too distant future, we will probably have<a href="https://medium.com/@firstmilevc/avlandscape-8a21491f1f54"> autonomous vehicles on the roads</a>, personal assistants getting more versatile, <a href="http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20180730-could-robots-do-our-household-chores-like-laundry">household robots</a> taking care of the dull chores,<a href="https://healthitanalytics.com/news/how-artificial-intelligence-is-changing-radiology-pathology"> AI systems diagnosing diseases and detecting malfunctioning organs</a>, etc.</p><p>Nonetheless, this is <em>quite different from general intelligence</em> which represents a single autonomous system <strong>capable of performing a diverse range of tasks, and being able to integrate the information and experience gained along the way towards future performance. This is basically how human intelligence, and to a great extent, that of several animal taxa, functions.</strong></p><p>The question then is, how far away is existing AI technology from achieving the goal of artificial general intelligence (AGI) ? A related question: are the current methods involving deep learning the right approach if we are seeking to develop AGI? <strong>The mere fact that deep learning is outdoing itself on specialized tasks regularly is not evidence that we are any closer to general intelligence.</strong></p><p>To be sure, machines outperforming humans at certain tasks is hardly new. Calculators can determine the product of two 6 digit numbers faster than almost any human can. The original floppy disk, despite the limited storage by today’s standards, could very easily store 1000 numbers with 6 decimal precision, something that majority of humans struggle to do. More than two decades ago, IBM’s<a href="https://theconversation.com/twenty-years-on-from-deep-blue-vs-kasparov-how-a-chess-match-started-the-big-data-revolution-76882"> Deep Blue</a> defeated Gary Kasparov in chess, one of the greatest champions of the game in what was then considered to be another human frontier being breached by computers.</p><p>Is there any reason to believe that the recent successes with deep learning is somehow fundamentally different that they hold the promise of an<a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/1705.08807"> AGI takeoff</a> that was earlier absent with the development of the calculator or the success of DeepBlue? Or is this another chapter in the development of AI that revolutionizes technology, society and economy but is still far away from attaining AGI?</p><p>To be able to answer that, we’ll examine the fundamental ways in which the training and computation of neural networks is different from the learning, behavior and characteristics of human cognition and intelligence.</p><h3><strong>1. Enormity of deep learning models</strong></h3><p>But before we do that, let’s just examine how much of the recent breakthroughs have been achieved by “brute-force” increase in number of computations.</p><p>Turns out the number of computations used in training recent deep learning models have outpaced even Moore’s law in terms of exponential growth as seen in <a href="https://openai.com/blog/ai-and-compute/">the interesting post on OpenAI.</a> The models have certainly been able to scale newer peaks in terms of performance but it appears to have been driven, at least partly, by sheer increase in the computational steps required to train them.</p><p>To get a sense of the massive architecture, the<a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.04805"> language representation model BERT</a> uses 110 million parameters, and takes 96 hours to train on 16 Tensor Processing Units (TPU) consuming about 1500 kWh of energy in the process. That should give some hints about why it is quite dissimilar to the human brain.</p><p>There is no reason however to assume that the process of attaining AGI is similar to how intelligence evolved in humans or even that the architectures are likely to be the same, let alone energy consumption.</p><p>Yet, this is only the beginning of the divergence between deep learning approaches and intelligence that is observed in humans.</p><h3>2. Large Training Data</h3><p>The amount of training data needed to train typical neural networks is far greater than what a human needs to learn to perform a comparable task. The number of images that deep learning models are trained on for image recognition problems is of the order of hundreds of thousands if not more, but a five year old exposed to only a tiny fraction fraction of this, achieves equal or better results.</p><p>This again illustrates something fundamental — however clever the architecture of neural networks may be (usage of convolution filters, sustaining memory of earlier states, attention mechanism), the performance is driven primarily in a narrow brute-force manner where all the primary variations that is found in the data is encoded in the network.</p><h3>3. Lack of understanding</h3><p>More than anything else, the greatest limitation of neural network models is that they do not understand the world irrespective of how good their performance with classifying images or translating text may be.</p><p>For example, if we came across a video showing an unrestrained stone moving upwards in the air instead of undergoing free fall, we would think that something is odd — either the video is being played backward, or it is a trick, or maybe it is taken in an environment outside the influence of gravity. Each of these possible interpretations is based on our accumulated knowledge and experience and our disbelief of the phenomenon is almost reflexive.</p><p>Likewise, if we observed that a shattered tea-cup re-assembling to form the original object, we don’t need to know the second law of thermodynamics to determine that some trickery is afoot. Would neural networks be able to recognize this when it is analyzing videos? Imagine how one should train the neural network to be able to identify these anomalies? <strong>We can of course hard-code these are rules but that is not the same as human understanding.</strong></p><h4>3A. Inability to identify metaphors</h4><p>If I told you that someone was given a blank check to pursue their interests, you don’t literally think that an empty check was handed to them (even if you’ve never heard the expression before). That’s because you immediately recognize that the sentence doesn’t make a lot of sense if we interpreted the word <em>check</em> literally because we understand<em> the meaning</em> of the rest of the sentence. Neural networks simply have no mode of doing the same.</p><h4>3B. Awareness of context</h4><p>Imagine looking at a photo of a living room with a television displaying a person riding a bike. Now you would think it absurd if somebody suggested that the bike is actually present in the living room. However, the neural network ( while possibly identifying the make and model of the bike) would most certainly not be able to make that distinction.</p><p>This is the basic awareness of context that is necessary for correct interpretation of visual elements based on learning the relations between different individual facts/entities to create a coherent understanding of the whole.</p><h4>3C. Abstractions</h4><p>In predicting when AI will be able to outdo humans at math research, the<a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/1705.08807"> median time-frame of the responses</a> of researches (in AI) was about 25 years.</p><p>How reliable is that estimate?</p><p>To do any mathematical reasoning or problem solving, one needs to deal very high level of abstractions. Even basic algebra requires understanding of what a variable is, conception of a set (of rational numbers, say), the notion of family of solutions, etc. (Note: none of this is to be confused with existing computational approaches like simulations or numerical approximations where we explicitly define what the solution procedures are).</p><p>However, deep learning as it exists today would have difficulty getting a grasp of even basic abstractions such as <em>commercial vs personal </em>transportation, the various notions of a <em>contract</em>, or the <em>idea of a government or society</em>.</p><h3>Human learning is not merely statistical correlations</h3><p>The primary reason for these failings is due the fact that deep learning models learn and encode <em>statistical associations among inputs and outputs</em> (both within and between) and this forms the basis for most of the successful performances. This also explains the need for enormous amount of data and immense parameter size because the number of such associations grows very large (think higher order correlations) with the number of features in the data. Models of shallow learning did poorly at problems like speech recognition because they were not meant to capture such a wide range of statistical associations across temporal and frequency domains.</p><p>However, statistical correlations can go only so far and that is certainly not the mechanism by which human intelligence works. Besides the well-known fact that statistical associations fail to detect any causal pattern, they are also devoid of structural understanding of the data. While convolutional filters may have greatly enhanced the detection of objects in images, it is <em>merely a feature transformation</em>, and enables encoding a more useful set of statistical correlations. <strong>But statistical correlations they remain nonetheless</strong>.</p><p>Although I have primarily discussed supervised learning, the same argument applies to unsupervised and other modes of applications of neural networks. The Generative Adversarial (GAN) model, one of the more interesting formulations using deep learning, is unique in many ways (much of the deep fakes phenomena owes to it), but they are not devoid of the problems of generic deep learning discussed above. Deep Reinforcement Learning, the sub-field using reinforcement technique (the algorithm in Alpha Go, for instance), sets up learning as an iterative process where decisions are taken based on projection of discounted future rewards (the projection in turn depending on the evidence observed until that point). While this procedure is likely to generalize learning in a more complex and dynamic environment it shares the failings of run-of-the-mill neural networks discussed above.</p><p>Similarly, although there has been a lot of work on <a href="http://ruder.io/transfer-learning/index.html">transfer learning</a> — where the models learned on a certain type of task are used to predict something different —it does little to change the fact that ultimately there is no real understanding of the input data; the reason that transfer learning works is because the features encoded in the higher layers are usually relevant for more than one task.</p><p>More to the point, despite the incredible advances of deep learning (and they truly are incredible), there is no reason to assume that we are anywhere close to being able to achieve<a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-019-11786-6"> human (or even mouse) intelligence</a> today than we were even a couple of decades ago. There is no strong evidence to believe that incremental progress in deep learning or approaches such as GAN will lead us to AGI at some point in the future.</p><p>Is is also not quite clear that we can <em>reproduce the capabilities of the brain even if we could mimic the connections at some level.</em> For example, even though the number of neurons in fruit fly is around 200,000, we still have not been able to simulate something with comparable competence at variety of tasks. In reality, it is not merely the connections that matter, it is about how signals are propagated, i.e., the specific functional form of the relation between the neuronal inputs and outputs. There are (in principle) infinitely many of these, but even assuming that those are sufficiently close lead to similar qualitative characteristics still leaves too large a space to be explored exhaustively.</p><h3>Hype vs Reality</h3><p>Part of the problem today is that machine learning, and in particular deep learning is often portrayed as an all-conquering force that will not stop until all human activity is replaced by artificial agents and robots. This may or may not be true, but the uncritical reproduction of this view without any reflection of the ground realities of the status of the field leads to amplification of the hype, and drowning out skeptical voices. Further, the conflation of narrow AI performance with that of more ambitious but unrealized goal of developing systems capable of broad reasoning ,thinking and cognition adds to the problem.</p><p>Ultimately, it is very difficult to predict if and when humanity will be able to create artificial general intelligence. Some argue that there will be<a href="https://sideways-view.com/2018/02/24/takeoff-speeds/"> very little time</a> between the early, poor versions of AGI and an all-powerful super-intelligent AGI. If that were to be the case, we may not be able to prepare and react in a meaningful way to its rapid emergence. It would appear advisable that we stay several steps ahead of such a potential phenomenon and be wary of the consequences of current research.</p><p>While it is important that we devote appropriate resources to better understand and prepare for that eventuality, there is equally good or even better reason for us to sit back, reflect and re-examine how much of actual progress we have made towards getting to AGI in the first place.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d066fb02843a" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/swlh/is-ai-marching-steadfast-to-human-level-intelligence-d066fb02843a">Is AI marching steadfast to human level intelligence?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/swlh">The Startup</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How much should we be concerned about suffering in the wild?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/post-darwinian-speciesist/how-much-should-we-be-concerned-about-suffering-in-the-wild-a3d2e106fd47?source=rss-ec8abb248db6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a3d2e106fd47</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[population-ecology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wild-animal-suffering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consequentialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[animal-welfare]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Venkateshan K]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Jul 2019 17:55:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-07-29T16:41:30.788Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KKj7XBQKl3l1IrJ6uMeUqQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Source: Avel Chuklanov on<a href="https://unsplash.com/search/photos/predator-chase?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText"> Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Animals in the wild suffer in a <a href="https://www.animal-ethics.org/wild-animal-suffering-section/wild-animals/">variety of ways</a> — attacks by predators, exposure to diseases, physical injury, indefinite starvation and thirst among others.</p><p>Despite increasing attention to the enormity of suffering inflicted by humans in factory farms , animal testing laboratories, etc., there remains the more ambiguous issue that most animal rights advocates would have considered at one point or the other — <a href="https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/persis-eskander-wild-animal-welfare/">what should be done about wild animal suffering?</a></p><p>This is difficult to answer and there is a great deal of uncertainty about what, if anything, can be done to minimize the harm to wild animals. Whatever the position one may choose to take on this issue, there is one aspect that is no doubt paramount: <strong>the importance of establishing the relative magnitude of wild animal suffering.</strong></p><p>Eliminating all suffering would be the ideal, but effective animal advocacy involves identifying areas where there is the greatest scope for improvement in welfare. From that perspective, it makes a lot of difference whether there is only a tiny amount of suffering in the wild or it accounts for the predominant misery of all sentient species.</p><p>A natural benchmark for comparison is the totality of pain inflicted on domesticated animals from factory farms to animal experimentation. However, we encounter two problems with this approach: first, how do we compare the suffering of two different species when science isn’t developed enough to provide straightforward metrics, and second, how many of each species are there in the wild?</p><p>My focus here is to address both of these issues. Part of the reason why we need more focus on these questions is that currently we rely on estimates that could be wildly off and are using assumptions that may be very flawed.</p><p>A scenario where wild animal suffering is 0.001 that of domesticated animals is very different — from a consequential perspective — from one that is 1000 times.</p><h3><strong>Understanding capacity to experience pain</strong></h3><p>The modes of physiological, chemical and behavioral response to stimuli varies a lot across species. While only the most solipsistic would argue that chimpanzees are merely exhibiting a reflexive programmed response to negative stimuli instead of experiencing pain, the situation become <a href="https://was-research.org/paper/invertebrate-sentience-urgent-understudied/">more uncertain as we go down the species hierarchy.</a> To an extent, the presence of a central nervous system serves as a good proxy for ability to experience pain. But almost all organisms that show bilateral symmetry (bilateria) have a <a href="http://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Nervous_system#Neurons">nervous system with some rudimentary form of a brain.</a> Bilateria includes not just vertebrates but also crustaceans, insects and worms.</p><p>One way around this difficulty has been to use the number of neurons as a proxy for the degree of sentience of the animals. Not just the raw number of neurons (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_animals_by_number_of_neurons">because they range over orders of magnitude</a>) that would perhaps place too small a weight to species like insects. For example <a href="https://reflectivedisequilibrium.blogspot.com/2015/11/various-functional-forms-for-brain.html">in this discussion</a> 0.5*log[#Neurons] is used (among others) as a weighting factor when considering the relative importance of a given species.</p><p>Even if one accepts this as a crude representation of the capacity to suffer, there is something wrong in defining the utility function by merely multiplying this factor by the population size of that species. <strong>We can all agree for example that 10 units of suffering by one individual is much worse than 10 individuals suffering one unit of pain. </strong>Going further, a universe with 1 unit of suffering by 10 individual is much worse than an alternate one where a million individuals each suffering 10^(-5) units even though the total amount of pain is the same in both cases (assuming simple additivity of pain). In fact, one can set a threshold such that when an individual’s pain is less than that threshold, it is so negligible that we can ignore it.</p><p>If we accept the above argument, then how much importance should we accord to the suffering of 10^(18) (billion trillion!) insects each of whose capacity to experience pain may only be a small fraction of mammal’s? If, for example, an insect were to suffer 10^(-3) of a mammal, then a naive estimation of the total suffering would be 10^(-3)*10^(18) = 10^(15) in mammalian terms! But maybe that 10^(-3) factor of suffering that we have assigned to the insect is perhaps too little and that, as a species, it cannot be compared to mammals or birds.</p><p>Obviously one will rightly object that all this is very speculative. The point here however is not the so much accuracy of the estimate, but the fact that we will arrive at <strong>radically different conclusions depending on distinct methodological approaches</strong> — (1) we simply sum a certain negligible suffering by a large enough population, then the result can be arbitrarily large that it can outweigh all mammals and birds and (2) recognize that negligible suffering does not count and we place no moral significance regardless of the population size.</p><p>To be sure, the two cases represent only extremes, and one can consider other intermediate ways to define the total negative utility. It may be somewhat tempting to consider using a concave function on the population size itself — say square root of the population, for example- but that is problematic (the importance of an individual depends on the size of the population of the species it belongs to!) . We could use instead a second weighting factor that explains the relative importance of that amount of suffering. For instance, in the above example where insect capacity to suffer is assumed to be 10^(-3) that of a mammal, we can introduce a second factor, square of the first, 10^(-6) , that quantifies the significance of that extent of suffering to the individual. This effectively gives a weight of 10^(-9) for each insect. Even so, if we now multiply by the total insect population of 10^(18) we get an amount equivalent to a billion mammals. If the insect populations were larger than that estimate, we will soon be attributing most suffering to insects than all mammals and birds.</p><p>Given the highly divergent scenarios that different choices lead it, my personal inclination would be to focus first on those animals whose suffering is far less ambiguous. And this naturally brings us to the top of the hierarchy and the second issue where uncertainty reigns — the estimation of wild population of birds and mammals.</p><h3><strong>Estimation wild population of birds and mammals</strong></h3><p>There seems to be a <a href="https://animalcharityevaluators.org/advocacy-interventions/prioritizing-causes/causes-we-consider/#wild-animal-suffering">general consensus that the number of wild mammals and birds is far greater than their domesticated counterparts.</a></p><p>I will<strong> argue against this</strong> and more specifically, demonstrate the numbers used in most analysis is very likely to be systematically overestimated.</p><p><strong>Biomass Comparison</strong></p><p>To begin with, let’s state a fact that is beyond any doubt — if it is the total biomass that we are interested in, then the contribution of domesticated species is most certainly higher. In <a href="https://www.pnas.org/content/115/25/6506">their work</a> on estimating the global biomass distribution, Bar-On et al have determined that the domesticated mammals have a biomass of 0.1 Gigaton Carbon (roughly 10–15% of body mass is in the form of carbon compounds) as compared to a mere 0.007 GtC for the wild (see figure below). Likewise the numbers for domesticated and wild birds is 0.005 and 0.002 Gt C respectively (see Supplementary material).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*FtbOEvp-Upxu_hl6" /><figcaption>Source: Bar-On et al<em>,PNAS Jun 2018</em></figcaption></figure><p>The question then is, given the disproportionately larger number of smaller animals in the wild, are their total numbers overwhelmingly large?</p><p><strong>Current Estimates</strong></p><p>In <a href="https://reducing-suffering.org/how-many-wild-animals-are-there/#Birds">his article</a> on wild animal populations, Brian Tomasik refers to the analysis found in <a href="https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/abs/10.1098/rspb.2002.2303">Gaston et al (2003</a>) where they estimate the typical number of birds globally to be <strong>86 billion (with lower and higher estimates 40 and 135 billion, respectively)</strong>. The authors arrive at these numbers by using the estimates for density of birds in different biomes/land-use classes from multiple sources. Despite identifying and using only the most reliable of studies, they acknowledge, and Brian Tomasik notes, that these estimates could be biased because the studies are usually carried out in high density areas. It is a<a href="https://besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1046/j.1365-2664.1999.00401.x"> well-known problem </a>that <strong>population density estimates are negatively correlated with study area</strong>. The primary reason for this appears to be that the location chosen for smaller study areas tends to have a higher abundance and this selection bias is significantly weaker when the study areas are larger (something alluded to earlier as well). In fact, this issue is so important that <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2FBF00328735">it explains most of the variation in the estimated population densities of species</a>. If this trend were to be extrapolated, it would suggest that the overall population density of a given species is probably less than what most estimates obtained from study areas.</p><p>Also, note that the areas of the land-classes (temperate forest, boreal forest, tropical woodland, etc) over which we estimate species population (using density estimate in a given study area) extend to millions of square kilometers. For reference, the areas of India, California and France are about 3, 0.42 and 0.64 million sq. kilometers respectively. Given the variations in density across these regions, one can imagine how a biased estimate much can affect the final number.</p><p>In the same article, Brian Tomasik reports that the total wild mammal population is <a href="https://reducing-suffering.org/how-many-wild-animals-are-there/#Mammals">about 100 billion</a>, based on different types of estimates from various sources. Again, none of the estimation methods described in the sources is very reliable, even up to an order of magnitude.</p><p>More doubts on these numbers are raised indirectly from further examination of the Bar-On et al (2018) paper on <a href="https://www.pnas.org/content/115/25/6506">estimating the overall global biomass distribution</a>. The authors use the data in <a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/geb.12617">Novosolov et al (2017) </a>to estimate the biomass of birds and mammals. One of their methods involved fitting a linear model to this data to explain the population numbers of a given species (in the particular study) in terms of the reported study area and the body mass of the species (see Supplementary material and their <a href="https://github.com/milo-lab/biomass_distribution/blob/master/animals/chordates/wild_mammals/wild_mammal.ipynb">Jupyter notebook</a> on this analysis).</p><p><strong>Mammals</strong></p><p>I re-analyzed the estimates for mammals obtained from the linear model using the original data in Novosolov et al(2017)(paper is under a subscription firewall but I reached out to Marie Novosolov, the lead author, who kindly shared all the raw data ). There is some ambiguity in the Bar-On et al’s work because they don’t specify the units in which the variables are meant to be entered in the linear model. Through trial and error, I settled on those units that led to the best fit of the data. The resulting equation is given below (the coefficients are identical to what they have used):</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mlZUH_MoE11FQ5X-eBZ-Ig.png" /></figure><p>Shown below is the scatter plot of the log of the actual population of mammals in the study area and the estimate from the model (the red diagonal line represents the curve corresponding to equality between the two) .</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/0*KzMH8Mv71AefVyt0" /><figcaption>Scatter plot of the log of actual population estimated in study area (x-axis) and that obtained from the linear model (y-axis) for mammals in the Novosolov et al (2017) dataset. The red line is the 45 degree diagonal.</figcaption></figure><p>If we take that model fit to estimate the total population of a given species by replacing the study area by the geographic range size (as Bar-On et al. have done, without much justification, to estimate the biomass of mammals) then we can estimate the total population of the nearly exhaustive list of mammals in the <a href="http://esapubs.org/archive/ecol/E090/184/">PanTHERIA</a> data-base (over 5000 extant or recently extinct mammals).</p><p>Th<strong>e total number of mammals in the wild based on that calculation is about 25.4 billion</strong>.</p><p>Again, we should certainly consider that estimate with a grain of salt, but it is likely to be more accurate than most of the other, even less well-justified methods described.</p><p>(This calculation applies only to terrestrial mammals but the number of marine mammals is much smaller. Bar-On et al estimate the total biomass of marine mammals is about 0.004 GtC, which is approximately 30 billion kg of wet mass. The smallest of marine mammals<a href="https://deepoceanfacts.com/smallest-marine-mammal"> weigh on an average at least 10kg</a> and even if we assume that they contribute the all the biomass, we get the upper bound of 3 billion.)</p><p><strong>Birds</strong></p><p>I repeated this analysis for birds for which Bar On et al have provided a similar model but the fit in that case turned out to be quite bad. And this was true despite trying different units for body mass and study area.</p><p>I then independently determined the best fit by running the regression for log of population on the log of study area and log of body mass and obtained the following:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qPFidW73DrqYLfBC_GIiWQ.png" /></figure><p>(In order to focus more on the region corresponding to higher population and avoid underestimation , I fit it only on the data points where population was greater than some threshold. The R² on the full data-set was around 0.4 although despite the correction one can see below that it is somewhat underestimating the higher higher population numbers).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*63nTq72SARcABYQ_H8jjDA.png" /><figcaption>Scatter plot of the log of actual population estimated in study area (x-axis) and that obtained from the linear model (y-axis) for birds in the Novosolov et al (2017) dataset. The red line is the 45 degree diagonal.</figcaption></figure><p>When extrapolated by substituting study area by geographic range size (as in the case of mammals), I obtained the total population of the 830 species given in Novosolov (2017) database to be <strong>less than 150 million</strong>.</p><p>A further extrapolation to the nearly 9000 extant species of birds identified (assuming similar distribution of populations for those species), <strong>we get the total abundance of all birds in the wild is less than 2 billion.</strong></p><p>Admittedly, this is quite likely to an underestimate but I don’t see any reason why it is less accurate than estimates of about a 100 -400 billion.</p><h3><strong>Population Density-Body Mass</strong></h3><p>As I have shown, if it is the biomass that if of interest, then there is no question that domesticated animals are the dominant contributors. Therefore the claims of larger numbers of animals in the wild rests on the accuracy of estimating animals that are relatively small.</p><p>One common approach to extrapolating population densities is allometric scaling (referred in <a href="https://reducing-suffering.org/how-many-wild-animals-are-there/#Mammals">mammalian population estimation</a>). Allometric scaling is the hypothesis in biology and population ecology that different quantitative characteristics of a species (such as its metabolic rate, embryonic growth, life span etc. ) scales as an exponent of the body mass.</p><p>The most relevant instance of allometric scaling that is of importance to us is the negative scaling between population density and body. In other words, population size and the body mass of a species are <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/351312a0">believed to be inversely related</a>, i.e., smaller the body mass, the greater the abundance of the species, and the relation is of the approximate form</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/749/0*pjphzRp270mZXZhg" /></figure><p>To understand why it is important to test the validity of this hypothesis, consider a hypothetical selection of species whose body masses are 0.01kg, 0.1 kg, 1kg , 10kg and 100kg. Assuming that the exponential factor (gamma) in the above equation is unity then the relative population of the different species might look like something in the following table (<strong>not real data</strong>)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/786/1*mjADeJuP2fdIV7OVXIHwHA.png" /></figure><p>Observe that the abundance of the species whose body mass is 0.01kg is <strong>nearly a factor of ten more than all the other species put together</strong>!</p><p>Given the remarkable significance of the scaling relation, let’s examine how accurate it is. To do that, I once again use the data in Novosolov et al. and consider the scatter plot of the log of population density and the body mass of a given species for birds.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/628/0*u3OAxnEqqa_GGqB-" /><figcaption>Plot of log of population density (y-axis) against log of body mass. The red line is the fit obtained by the model.</figcaption></figure><p>There is a clear negative slope relating the two quantities, but the slope of the line (gamma) in the equation is quite small -0.19.</p><p>A closer examination of the above plot reveals more. Observe that for small body masses (log values less than 1.5) the negative dependence is even weaker (if it exists at all). We’ll narrow our focus on that region and replot the dependence</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/638/0*UI9vRy9a6FS1ZwPq" /><figcaption>Scatter plot of log ode population density and log of body mass of birds (where body mass is less than 100 grams)</figcaption></figure><p>There is almost no perceptible relation (a linear model confirms that (not shown)) between the two quantities whenever the body mass is less than 10² =100g! This fact has a considerable bearing on our calculation. Indeed, as we pointed out earlier, if allometric scaling were to hold across the entire spectrum of body mass sizes, then the greatest contribution to the total number of individuals would come from species with the smallest body masses. However it is precisely this small body mass range where there is little to no scaling dependence and hence, the estimated numbers when this correction is taken into account will be <strong>reduced by orders of magnitude!</strong></p><p>A similar analysis with mammalian masses and population densities reveal the same property. In fact, the issues of allometric scaling has been reported in literature (see <a href="http://doi.wiley.com/10.1046/j.1523-1739.1994.08030732.x">Silva et al </a>(1994)).</p><h3><strong>Conclusion</strong></h3><p>I have shown here that claims that the total numbers of wild birds and mammals being 100–200 and 100–400 billion respectively is most likely an exaggeration with the true numbers closer to 20 billion or less. At least for these two vertebrate classes, presumably the most important in terms of our confidence in their ability to experience pain, the numbers in the wild are not far greater than their domestic counterparts.</p><p>As for the numerous species that science is unable to conclusively decide on the sentience, our estimates of their overall contribution to suffering is highly unreliable. More to the point, there is a virtually infinite variation in our estimation of total suffering when it comes to animals in the wild.</p><p>There is no doubt that wild animal suffering is an important issue and is often neglected in the animal advocacy community. Nonetheless, before we commit resources towards developing strategies to minimize it, we should recognize the great uncertainty in our estimates of the relevant quantities in this area.</p><p>The case for liberation of domesticated animals is very strong and can be summarized by the followed key arguments: (a) mammals and birds most certainly experience pain and constitute the 70 billion (land animals) are slaughtered globally every year for food ( b) humans can live perfectly healthy lives without depending on animal products (c) the lives of vast majority of farmed animals is horrible to say the least, with scant regard for their welfare from birth to death ( d) the treatment of animals is antithetical to other progressive values humans claim to uphold (e) there is a clear potential and scope to minimize if not completely eliminate animal agriculture.</p><p>Most of these points do not apply to wild animals, unfortunately. Given that we are still very, very far from ending human exploitation of animals, one way to strengthen the case for wild animals is by improving our methods to estimate the severity of the problem.</p><h3><strong>References:</strong></h3><ul><li><a href="https://www.animal-ethics.org/wild-animal-suffering-section/wild-animals/"><strong>The situation of animals in the wild</strong></a><strong>, </strong><em>Animal Ethics</em></li><li><a href="https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/persis-eskander-wild-animal-welfare/"><strong>80000 Hours Podcast: Animals in the wild often suffer a great deal. What, if anything, should we do about that?</strong></a>, Host:Robert Wiblin, Guest: Persis Eskander</li><li><a href="https://was-research.org/paper/invertebrate-sentience-urgent-understudied/"><strong>Invertebrate Sentience: Urgent But Understudied</strong></a>, G. Ray</li><li><a href="http://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Nervous_system#Comparative_anatomy_and_evolution"><strong>Comparative anatomy and evolution of nervous systems</strong></a>, W. Skaggs, Scholarpedia</li><li><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_animals_by_number_of_neurons"><strong>List of animals by number of neurons</strong></a><strong>, </strong>Wikipedi<a href="https://reflectivedisequilibrium.blogspot.com/2015/11/various-functional-forms-for-brain.html">a</a></li><li><a href="https://reflectivedisequilibrium.blogspot.com/2015/11/various-functional-forms-for-brain.html"><strong>Brain-weighting functional form</strong></a>, Carl</li><li><a href="https://animalcharityevaluators.org/advocacy-interventions/prioritizing-causes/causes-we-consider/#wild-animal-suffering"><strong>Cause Prioritzation: Wild animal Suffering</strong></a> , Animal Charity Evaluators</li><li><a href="https://www.pnas.org/content/115/25/6506"><strong>The biomass distribution on Earth</strong></a>, Yinon M. Bar-On, Rob Phillips, Ron Milo, <em>PNAS Jun 2018, 115 (25) 6506–6511</em></li><li><a href="https://reducing-suffering.org/how-many-wild-animals-are-there/#Birds"><strong>How many wild animals are there?</strong></a>, Brian Tomasik</li><li><a href="https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/abs/10.1098/rspb.2002.2303"><strong>Habitat conversion and global avian biodiversity loss</strong></a><strong>, </strong>K. J. Gaston,T. M. Blackburn, K. K. Goldewijk, <em>Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B</em></li><li><a href="https://besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1046/j.1365-2664.1999.00401.x"><strong>Does variation in census area confound density comparisons?</strong></a>, Gaston, K. J., Blackburn, T. M. and Gregory, R. D. (1999), Journal of Applied Ecology,</li><li><a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2FBF00328735"><strong>Scaling population density and spatial pattern for terrestrial, mammalian carnivores</strong></a><strong>, </strong>Smallwood, K.S. &amp; Schonewald, C. <em>Oecologia (1996) 105: 329.</em></li><li><a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/geb.12617"><strong>Population density–range size relationship revisited</strong></a>, Novosolov et al, <em>Global Ecol Biogeogr. 2017; 26: 1088– 1097.</em></li><li><a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/351312a0"><strong>The relationship between abundance and body size in British birds</strong></a>, Nee, Sean and Read, Andrew F. and Greenwood, Jeremy J. D. and Harvey, Paul H., <em>Nature, volume 351, pages, 312–313 (1991)</em></li><li><a href="http://esapubs.org/archive/ecol/E090/184/"><strong>PanTHERIA</strong>:</a> a species-level database of life history, ecology, and geography of extant and recently extinct mammals, Kate E. Jones et al, <em>Ecology</em> 90:2648.</li><li><a href="http://doi.wiley.com/10.1046/j.1523-1739.1994.08030732.x"><strong>Allometric Scaling of Minimal Mammal Densities</strong></a>, Silva, M.,Downing, J. A.,<em>Conservation Biology</em></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a3d2e106fd47" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/post-darwinian-speciesist/how-much-should-we-be-concerned-about-suffering-in-the-wild-a3d2e106fd47">How much should we be concerned about suffering in the wild?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/post-darwinian-speciesist">Post Darwinian Speciesist</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>