<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Alexander Vezhnevets on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Alexander Vezhnevets on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@vezhnick?source=rss-adc13c0c2cf2------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 05:01:05 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@vezhnick/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On playing with demons]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vezhnick/on-playing-with-demons-803e69cca4a3?source=rss-adc13c0c2cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/803e69cca4a3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vajrayana]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alexander Vezhnevets]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 May 2025 12:51:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-02T12:51:14.804Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Living in a society means that whatever we do is intricately entangled with what everyone else is doing. This miracle of synchronisation is achieved through individuals acting in patterns, which fit together. It is like a fractal mandala made of interlocking gears of anticipation, action and reaction.</p><p>[<em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://vezhnick.substack.com/p/nyam-nyid?r=1w83lt"><em>https://vezhnick.substack.com</em></a><em>]</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HwBWbpR9ITiwZmXj.png" /></figure><p>The social is a dance between common and individual. Conventions and norms homogenise the patterns of interdependent activities, while identities differentiate them. Together these patterns form a culture — a library of behavioural patterns and their meanings. Identity indexes the library by providing an answer to “who am I in the situation that I’m in?”. Knowing the answer, we then know how to act conventionally.</p><p>If you have a reinforcement learning background, you could think of culture as an options model. Assemblage theory or figurational sociology could be helpful if you are more philosophically inclined. But for the metaphor that works best for a first person experience of having and acting out an identity is that of demonic possession. When you act conventionally you let yourself be possessed by a named pattern — a little demon. It controls your attention, it interprets the world for you and controls your actions — “As a progressive millennial, I will be bringing my reusable coffee mug”. We switch between dozens of demons, small and large, every day, simply to get by.</p><p>These demons are very much real and apparent. They are not simply a figment of our imagination. They are an emergent phenomena of the socio-cultural process and are represented not only in our minds, but also in physical artefacts. To actually be a policeman one must wear a badge. Clothes convey much of one’s demonic allegiance (devil wears Primark). Legal acts can conjure, control and banish those demons.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qHxg1umMl-95s5Xg.png" /></figure><p>Relationships with these demons can become problematic. One can mistake a demon for oneself or even one’s essence or soul. This can lead to a severe idiocy, what in tibetan is called “thom-yor” [4]. Thom-yor is fixated on a particular identity demon and identifies with it so deeply, that they lose the ability to see the apparent circumstances and their role in it. They would keep performing the dance even though music has stopped. If I was an academic thom-yor, I would go around introducing myself as Doctor Vezhnevets, insisting on people using my title even when I’m not present and turn every conversation into a presentation of my most important research.</p><p>One could also develop a hatred for a particular demon and try to hide from it — “Don’t call me a posh tech bro, I’m definitely not that!”. The mistake here is to think that we have full choice over what identity-demon is in possession of our activity pattern. The identity-demons are not just within us, they are also in the mind of others and their perceptions and in the very physical world around us. Who we are to others is an ever ongoing negotiation-dance. One can also really <em>want</em> to find a demon to be possessed by, but fail to find one — “I need to find my identity! Maybe I’m post-woke-enviro-punk?”.</p><p>The essence of conventional wisdom is knowing who you are in the situation you are in, and what is the appropriate thing for you to do. This is good wisdom to have. The best way of attaining it is honesty and awareness of context. To find out “who am I?”, why not simply look at one’s relevant history and context and ask, who does this person seem to be? With enough cultural knowledge the answer is usually rather straightforward. In the context of you reading this, I’m an author and you are a reader.</p><p>By the way, I think that large language models are capable of conventional wisdom (see <a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03664">[1]</a>) and are the closest we have to cultures being captured in an artefact. A genie, trapped in a transformer.</p><p>Conventional wisdom is self-contradictory, because it tries to separate the action from its purpose. Conventional actions serve the goals and habits of our identities. They are in service to these little demons. An individual will always find themselves in between conflicting identities, a pandemonium of quarrelling demons arguing over their importance. “As a father, I want to get home early, but as a scientist I really need to run one more experiment before the deadline.” There is no way to resolve this puzzle through the means of culture itself, it only leads to a lengthier argument among the demons. There is no overarching, final identity one can adopt. No ultimate purpose that can capture the full complexity of our experiences. To deal with this paradox conventional wisdom is useless.</p><h3>Being instead of identifying</h3><blockquote><strong><em>Unconventional wisdom dissolves all struggles. It is true, simply because it lacks the complication of falsity.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><em>Heart Sutra, Ngak’chang Rinpoche translation</em></blockquote><p>Wisdom of Vajrayana is not conventional (unconventional wisdom is the classic term, but given the latest fashions, maybe meta-conventional would be more appropriate). It is not an answer to who you are or what’s happening. It is not a role to play. But neither is it a denial of culture and our relationship with it. It is not a counter-culture or ignorance of culture. It is not a lack of conventional wisdom.</p><p>If it isn’t any of those things, what is it?</p><h3>Yidams</h3><p>Yidam practice is a tantric answer to how to be and act in the world without a demon circus in ones head — be a Yidam. Yidam is not an identity. Yidams are not hyperobjects, assemblages or figurations, archetypes, zodiac signs, etc. They are enlightened awareness beings — defining them is a fool’s errand, but having a relationship with one or even being one is attainable through specific practice (see, for example <a href="https://vividness.live/yidams-a-godless-approach-naturally">[2]</a>). One can only <em>be </em>a Yidam<em>, </em>not<em> identify or act </em>as a Yidam.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*GSvXxZik3Elk5WPP.png" /></figure><blockquote><strong><em>Whatever happens; may it happen!</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>Whichever way it goes; may it go that way!</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>There is no purpose!</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote>The three terrible oaths of Dorje Tröllö</blockquote><p>This is Dorje Tröllö. There is no way to answer what Dorje Tröllö would do in a situation, unless you are Dorje Tröllö in the situation. His three terrible oaths point to a place from which action requires no answers to any silly questions. There is no grand purpose that needs to move him to action. He is open to whatever happens and because of that he can the situation with clarity. He accepts the inevitable death and the brutality of the being alive. His actions arise out of the clarity, openness and courage of his awareness. He cuts though the demon circus with his wrath.</p><p>Yidam practice is a trip, an over-the-top performance. It is grand and somewhat silly, but incredibly effective. It is elaborate and very specific.</p><h3>Spontaneous activity of Dzog’chen</h3><blockquote><strong><em>Therefore the Master acts without doing anything and teaches without saying anything.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote>Tao Te Ching, translated by Stephen Mitchell</blockquote><p>Distinct from the tantric view, Dzog’chen offers something more subtle and elegant, if not as boombastic — spontaneous self-liberating activity. Spontaneous actions arise without effort to manipulate the experience in any way. No need to fight the demons or break up their circus. Watch the show, but see it for what it is — a show <em>about</em> the social activity, not the activity itself. Play with demons, but don’t feel obliged to repeat their moves.</p><p>The unconventional wisdom of Dzog’chen is the ability to see the social world without separating the action and its purpose. Phenomenologically (as experienced), purpose arises together and within the action, not separate from it, so do identities, circumstances, purposes and meanings. Put simply, the action is its own purpose in itself and for itself.</p><p>Likewise, actions are not initiated by any identity or self. Self, identity, doer, action, purpose — all arise together within the action; distinct but not separate. Activity needs no explanation, reason or justification. The pattern of social activity is recognised and is let to manifest itself and then dissolve. The apparent contradictions of our identities are not a problem, but a source of life — the liberated energy that shines through these cracks in the pattern.</p><blockquote><strong><em>Because the Mind-warrior’s awareness is characterised by this unconventional wisdom, even the four philosophical extremes are not perceived as dualism. Likewise all those who realise non-duality — in the past, present, and future — dwell in the knowledge of unconventional wisdom which is the none other than rigpa.</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote>Heart Sutra, Ngak’chang Rinpoche translation</blockquote><p><strong>Disclaimer:</strong> The above is an expression of my personal experience as a meditator and practitioner of contemporary Vajrayana. It shouldn’t be regarded as in any way canonical or historically accurate explanation of Vajrayana.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><ol><li>“Generative agent-based modelling with actions grounded in physical, social, or digital space using Concordia” Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, John P. Agapiou, Avia Aharon, Ron Ziv, Jayd Matyas, Edgar A. Duéñez-Guzmán, William A. Cunningham, Simon Osindero, Danny Karmon, Joel Z. Leibo <a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03664">https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03664</a></li><li>Yidams: a godless approach, naturally! <a href="https://vividness.live/yidams-a-godless-approach-naturally">https://vividness.live/yidams-a-godless-approach-naturally</a></li><li>Image of Dorje Tröllö taken from <a href="https://www.aroencyclopaedia.org/shared/text/d/dorje_trollo_th_01_aro_02_oaths_eng.php">https://www.aroencyclopaedia.org/shared/text/d/dorje_trollo_th_01_aro_02_oaths_eng.php</a></li><li>Wisdom Eccentrics rumours of realisation as told by Künzang Dorje Rinpoche with additional tales of the unexpected By Ngakpa Chögyam <a href="https://arobuddhism.org/books/wisdom-eccentrics.html">https://arobuddhism.org/books/wisdom-eccentrics.html</a></li></ol><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://vezhnick.substack.com/p/nyam-nyid?r=1w83lt"><em>https://vezhnick.substack.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=803e69cca4a3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nyam Nyid]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vezhnick/nyam-nyid-d3b80071cb91?source=rss-adc13c0c2cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d3b80071cb91</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nonduality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vajrayana]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alexander Vezhnevets]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 May 2025 15:04:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-01T15:04:15.428Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The post is based on my practice with Nyi-med mediation, which I described <a href="https://vezhnick.substack.com/p/the-of-non-duality-24771a9ab7c9">here</a>. It was the focus of my practice for more than a year. The post will be something of a sit-report (by analogy to trip-report) to start with- I will first describe the experience of nyi-med meditation in a narrativized, first person account of the experience. It is an amalgam of the different sitting that I had throughout the last year or so. I will try to make sense of it afterwards, extracting the important insights.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uClFP-CAeOXygsVU.png" /></figure><h4>The experience</h4><p>With a good nyi-med sitting you get to the point where time and space loosen up. Not that there isn’t time, it is that the relationship of “before and after ‘’ is not experienced with some of the phenomena. Was this cry before or after that bark? Did I see this bird before I heard it? The sensations of sound, vision, smell, touch present themselves without being spatially or temporally related.</p><p>Space and time come out as sensations, not as containers for sensations. Vision changes once <em>spaceness and timeness</em> give way. The shape of what you see becomes paradoxical, Escheresque. Repetitive patterns stand out and become one thing, even if not actually close in space. Motion breaks up into independent islands of activity, like a collage of animated gifs, each ticking at their own pace.</p><p>It is a state of relaxation. Forcing the experience into rigid space-time is effort. With space, no longer being coherent, there is no centre to the experience. No spot to look at it from. Yet there is a <em>ground</em> to it, the unrelated, undifferentiated zero. Nowhere in particular, without time, an immeasurable background. It is present in everything that arises.</p><p>Sense of self, volition and attention arise in the same way as time and space-as dimensions of experience undivided from their content. Phenomena is an account of <em>distinctions, which communicate</em> in the space of awareness. There is no fixed structure in experience; the structure is itself part of the experience. It is relational. The apparent manifestations, the form, the qualia, are communication patterns of distinctions.</p><p>Structure of experience is inextricable from the experience itself. The <em>structuring </em>of the experience is the experience. Spacing, timing, selfing, attending, moving, expanding, sounding, feeling, doing. These distinctions all acquire the <em>same taste</em>. They <em>feel</em> like each other. Distinct, but of the same nature.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EnidUEtZircjLFAQ.png" /></figure><h4>Making sense of it</h4><p>I believe that for many, certainly for me, the early meditation practice is driven by a desire to understand, see the underlying structure of experience. What is attention? Self? How is my internal thought space related to vision? The important insight here is that there is no a-priori, unalterable structure of experience.</p><p>Kant in his “Critique of Pure Reason” considered space and time to be “a-priori’’ forms of intuition, meaning they are fundamental structures of human experience and understanding, not derived from sensory experience. To put simply, we are wearing unremovable space-time goggles. This proposition feels apparent. The experience seems to be <em>contained</em> in space, which unfolds in time. Yet nyam-nyid experientially shows that it is not so.</p><p>Space-timing is an optional structure. It is also a structure like many others (self, attention, etc.), not something special. In some sense, there is nothing special in this view-everything is a dimension of awareness. To my machine learner mind, this looks like an extremely elegant system.</p><p>What arises are <em>dimensions</em> of experience, which means that the experience will <em>vary</em> across those dimensions. That is, if the ethical dimension will be present, there the good <em>and </em>the evil will arise in the experience, same as if there is before, so there will be after. This is an important point, which has a lot of practical meaning-the experience cannot be forced into one direction along a dimension. It is impossible to see beauty without seeing ugliness, or <a href="https://vezhnick.substack.com/p/capitalism-as-charnel-grounds">doing good without doing some bad</a>.</p><blockquote><em>When people see some things as beautiful,</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>other things become ugly.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>When people see some things as good,</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>other things become bad.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Being and non-being create each other.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Difficult and easy support each other.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Long and short define each other.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>High and low depend on each other.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Before and after follow each other.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Tao te Ching</blockquote><p>The tension, effort, contraction in the experience is the attempt to separate the dimension of awareness and its content, to tear out the ground. This tension, this drag in the experience is “samsara”. The cycle of futile struggle. Once it is apparent, it can be released. Much like physical tension held in the body can be released after a good stretch or visit to an osteopath. Tension though is also a dimension of awareness like any other-this is what, I believe, the non-duality of samsara and nirvana in Vajrayana is about. An intuitive habit of releasing tension as it arises is what I understand to be <em>self-liberation</em> in Dzogchen terminology. Liberation is not about escaping from the world of experience but recognizing its true nature.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://vezhnick.substack.com/p/nyam-nyid?r=1w83lt"><em>https://vezhnick.substack.com</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d3b80071cb91" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Capitalism as Charnel Grounds]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vezhnick/capitalism-as-charnel-grounds-53324e980de3?source=rss-adc13c0c2cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/53324e980de3</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alexander Vezhnevets]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 May 2024 14:50:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-28T14:50:03.639Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>You are trapped in a cruel social experiment. You will be oppressed and exploited. What is worse, you will have to participate in oppression and exploitation of others. There is no way out, non-participation is not an option. In the end, you will die without getting any justice.</strong></p><p><strong>What are you going to do next?</strong></p><p>I recently came across yet another <a href="https://tricycle.org/magazine/western-buddhism-individualism">article</a> [1] discussing modern Buddhism’s relationship with capitalism, where the author was wondering whether it is ethical for Buddhism (consensus/Sutric/Mahayana) to be politically neutral and “participate in capitalism” (there is a very similar discussion in the AI ethics domain). And capitalism, as assumed to be self-evident, is <em>very</em> bad. What stood out for me was the following phrase in [1]: “Capitalist and consumerist structures haunt our expectations and horizons of understanding in ways that are often concealed, unless brought to light by sustained reflection.” This strikes me as a description of a <em>practice of view</em>, which means developing the habit of interpreting the world in a particular way. To see Capitalism in everything, one has to sustain a specific interpretive frame.</p><p>To me this looks like a variation on the Charnel Grounds view, where the yogi interprets the world as infinite <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charnel_ground">charnel grounds</a> (graveyard, but with piles of corpses instead of graves). This view (from Vajrayana perspective) is very well summarised <a href="https://vividness.live/charnel-ground">here</a> [2] and I recommend you check it out (this note is strongly inspired by it).</p><p>In this note I will turn the critique of capitalism into a practice of view, building on the Charnel grounds practise in Vajrayana.</p><p><em>A short sidenote: I’m going to slowly migrate this blog to substack, which you can find here: </em><a href="http://vezhnick.substack.com/"><em>vezhnick.substack.com</em></a><em>. I will keep posting on both platforms for some time.</em></p><p><strong>Capitalism</strong></p><p>The world of humans is fucked. All power is corrupted, every relationship is exploitative, technology and progress only increase inequality and empower the wicked and destroy the environment. Law is but a way for perpetuating privilege and true justice is impossible. Oppression and discrimination is paramount. Every historical figure has done something terrible. Society is an evil, tyrannical monster. Put simply, we live under Capitalism.</p><p>The practice would be to interpret <em>each and every</em> social interaction and relationship as some form of oppression, exploitation or coercion (discrimination, domination, etc.). Marriage–a way for couples to exploit each other. Education–oppression of students. A waiter is smiling at you — they are being coerced into it. World is a negative sum game — everybody loses. Importantly, there is no escape. There is simply no way of acting that would <em>not</em> lead to someone being oppressed, exploited, dominated and so on. One could read some critical theory (news from the right outlet would do as well) as a support for the practice, but as long as they do not offer any hope for escape. Because there is no salvation, no escape, no alternative, and no hope. This is the central part of the practice.</p><p>The fruit of the practice is <em>utter hopelessness.</em> You see, hope is not regarded as something useful in Vajrayana. It wastes our time and turns us into whiny muppets chasing ghosts. Having abandoned hope of escape, we can discover freedom and openness, precisely <em>because there is no hope of escaping</em>. Whatever you do, you will end up being oppressed and exploited and will oppress and exploit someone else. So you might stop sitting scared and anxious in the corner, trying not to swallow a bug while breathing, and do something interesting with your time.</p><p>This world is fucked, but there is plenty of room for celebration, beauty, generosity, curiosity, and good old fun. Capitalism is actually a fascinating place. Toxic wastes have a beautiful glow at sunset and the oppressed often throw cool parties with heavy bass. You can also get a<a href="https://www.amazon.co.uk/SANRLO-Singing-Dancing-Artificial-Creative/dp/B0D41JQVDT/ref=sr_1_7?crid=3L9ABYAQLEMBZ&amp;dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.d2PQqNy9yVcxZp78V9zxmS6O-RRIsiUYzEkpAFUE9HR9e8X2z5MHBR8Bpb_-fD_pytt6JHzA_Ob_JiqrvxmGK9t8gtMwtgfjdksocW-cC-N6NKWQQ0_9v9l-sF_CGYkEIt6qYOXD1KIeK1eMbrGmJOwnbBdpOzscOCGko7rtTCLzQeNgNOFSo2mxhS8ES6m0_hRuzpPXklCoq6GH1sZxlEdG1rAVA-DbQEAJcGW7fgY9-Su0LxUps1y3NpYBWtQxQXYqFI3nQZURp5i0PFjDKQ._VIa53w5CTi-4eddMg0YntmLwFcct3WifVordmUsvdU&amp;dib_tag=se&amp;keywords=poop+that+sings&amp;qid=1716388929&amp;sprefix=poop+that+sings%2Caps%2C103&amp;sr=8-7"> singing and dancing poop-hat with a flower</a> delivered the next day. And check out that image of a cat practising chöd that I made using genAI, isn’t it awesome?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ccLwi5y-CDYkxyfZ.png" /></figure><p>You can also do a lot of good once you stop worrying that it might do some bad somewhere down the line of causality — it surely will, but it makes it no less good. One might mistake this view for hedonism, but hedonism is impossible under Capitalism by construction — you will get oppressed and exploited no matter what! Remember — there is no escape. But it also means you can relax about it and be free to enter into relationships. Get married, if you want to — in between the exploitation and domination you might also find care, love and romance. Get a job, while being exploited for the meagre (or not) wage you might actually learn something interesting.</p><p><strong>Dualistic mistake</strong></p><p>The dualist mistake in the <a href="https://tricycle.org/magazine/western-buddhism-individualism">original article</a> [1], which this practice exposes, is separating the good and the bad in the consequences of one’s actions. This is impossible in the same way as it is impossible to separate emptiness from form. As heart sutra states — “Form is emptiness and emptiness is form”. Struggle to do so is both pointless and frustrating.</p><p>Help is the sunny side of control, freedom is the sunny side of neglect, duty is the sunny side of coercion, merit is the sunny side of inequality. The list can be expanded. Whether you are being exploited or provided with gainful employment, coerced or incentivised is in many cases a matter of interpretation. What is considered good or bad, fair or unfair, just or unjust is constantly changing. Human society is dynamic and re-articulates itself and what such words mean all the time. It is simply impossible to act, so that somewhere, someone wouldn’t judge one’s actions oppression, discrimination or simply “wrong”.</p><p>In Sutric Buddhism, the answer to this condition is an escapist dream of Nirvana. In Vajrayana (tantric Buddhism), the answer is engagement with experience without hope or fear. Samsara is Nirvana.</p><p><strong>Mirror view</strong></p><p>There is also a mirror view, which is the opposite side of the same non-dual coin. For Charnel grounds, the mirror is the <a href="https://vividness.live/pure-land">pure land view</a> [3], which is a practice of interpreting the reality as a pure land, a paradise populated by enlightened Buddhas. To mirror Capitalism, we can imagine a view where society is a benevolent being nurturing and caring. The fruit of this practice is <em>no fear.</em> Put together, the stance we arrive at is that of no hope and no fear.</p><p><strong>Relative improvement</strong></p><p>I want to make a note that I’m not denying the possibility of relative improvements. There is always a possibility of making something better in some parts of a specific society. Progress is possible and is happening. What is impossible is separating the good and the bad of society. There will never be any Revolution that changes social relationships in such a way that only good follows from one’s actions. There is no code of conduct or constitution that delivers us from this condition.</p><p>It is also good to keep in mind that Capitalism, not as a view, but as a socio-economical concept, is a reified generality (as most other -isms). It is not real in the same way as your house, British parliament, the US constitution, gravity, pain or the colour red are. Decontextualized from the actual, specific social circumstances and dynamics, the concept loses predictive power and descriptive clarity. It is probably not the best tool for understanding human society and its history. I highly recommend the first chapter (Assemblages and Human History) of <a href="https://www.google.co.uk/books/edition/Assemblage_Theory/BDZYDwAAQBAJ?hl=en">Assemblage Theory</a> [3] by Manuel DeLanda. I find the following quote particularly insightful:</p><blockquote><em>“[..] it should be clear that eliminating a society-wide system and replacing it with a population of organisations [..] is necessary to explain economic history. This population may indeed be coextensive with an entire country, in the sense that the reach of national corporations coincides with the jurisdiction of its central government organisations, but this does not imply that they are all part of an overall system, much less that the nature of this system can be understood using reified generalities like the Market and the State. Much of the academic left today has become prey to the double danger of politically targeting reified generalities (Power, Resistance, Capital, Labour) while at the sametime abandoning realism. A new left may yet emerge from these ashes but only if it recovers its footing on a mind-independent reality and if it focuses its efforts at the right social scale, that is, if it leaves behind the dream of a Revolution that changes the entire system.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Manuel DeLanda</em></blockquote><ol><li><a href="https://tricycle.org/magazine/western-buddhism-individualism">https://tricycle.org/magazine/western-buddhism-individualism</a></li><li><a href="https://vividness.live/charnel-ground">https://vividness.live/charnel-ground</a></li><li><a href="https://vividness.live/pure-land">https://vividness.live/pure-land</a></li><li>DeLanda, M. (2016). Assemblage Theory. United Kingdom: Edinburgh University Press.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=53324e980de3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Generative agents as a metaphor for emptiness of self]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vezhnick/generative-agents-as-a-metaphor-for-emptiness-of-self-a712257ac05e?source=rss-adc13c0c2cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a712257ac05e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[generative-agents]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anatta]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[generative-model]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alexander Vezhnevets]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 12 May 2024 09:02:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-12T09:02:03.471Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This note is going to be a blend of my professional and spiritual thoughts. I’m going to present generative agency (or generative behaviour) as a metaphor for human behaviour, self-construction and social constriction. Modern generative models like GPT, gemini, LLama and so on are built on a simple idea of training a flexible model to predict the next symbol in the natural text. Scaling this to the whole of the cultural footprint of humanity (all books, articles, code, blog posts and so on available on the internet) has led to the emergence of the surprising amount of general capabilities in these models. My colleagues and I have recently put out a paper [1] and an open source library, which attempts to redefine how we think about agents and agency in the view of these models.</p><p>In this note I investigate what happens if we take this model seriously in the context of investigating self-construction in meditation. No-self or anatta is a big topic in Buddhism, especially in classical Sutric form. I think generative agents can be a great example to illustrate what it means for a self to be <em>empty.</em> Here, I will be using modern machine learning as a metaphor and analogy, rather than arguing that our phenomenal experience, mind or phenomenon of selfhood are exactly the same as these models or are implemented through them (brain = GPT). Much like classic analogies of Indra’s web, a still lake reflecting the sky or a hall of mirrors, what I am trying to achieve is to point out something about the mind without making any scientific claims. Think of it as a koan for computer scientists. That said though, there are some interesting implications for computer science and AI if you take this analogy seriously on the other side.</p><p>This note will use some basic maths, mostly functions and conditional probabilities. It should be readable without a solid maths background. If you are not comfortable with formulas, try to just enjoy them esthetically. The main concept that is going to be used most is <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conditional_probability">conditional probability</a> p(y|x). Think of it as what is the chance of y, given that x has happened.</p><p>A short sidenote: I’m going to slowly migrate this blog to substack, which you can find here: <a href="http://vezhnick.substack.com/">vezhnick.substack.com</a>. I will keep posting on both platforms for some time.</p><h3>Classic, goal driven view of agency</h3><p>I will first describe how agency was being modelled in AI/ML <em>before</em> the rise of foundation models, namely by reinforcement learning. This approach was the dominant paradigm from 2013. This exposee will build the right ground for understanding how radical is the shift with generative agents and why.</p><p><strong>The formulation</strong></p><p>The classic view of agency in computer science is that of Reinforcement Learning (RL). It is a dualistic and goal driven view. The first step is dividing the world into an agent and environment. The agent consumes observations and produces actions, while the world produces observations and consumes actions. The world is everything that is not an agent and is governed by its own dynamics (think video game) and observations o (e.g. images) and actions a (e.g. up, right, left, down) are the membrane or interface through which the two can communicate.</p><p>The problem of agency in RL is formulated as “how does one find a behaviour that maximises a given reward over the long term?”, where reward is a quantitative (a real number) appraisal of the state of the environment. Think of it as a score in a video game that you want to maximise. Reward maximisation is also equivalent to goal achievement — you get a reward when you achieve the goal(s). A similar view can be found in game theory and economics that are built on top of that, where humans are modelled as rational decision makers, picking actions in matrix games.</p><p>This view is intuitive and is common in folk psychology and at least the first 4 levels of the famous Maslow pyramid can be cast as some sort of reward maximisation. Humans often explain their behaviour in terms of goals they tried to achieve with it or the rewards they were trying to accrue. Chasing money, status, longevity, pleasure, virtue, righteousness and so on fit quite well into this paradigm. The view of the world, where one “accumulates karmic points” is very much RL taken to an absolute extreme — the one true reward throughout time and space. The ideas of good and evil, right and wrong, “the good life”, virtue and so on cast themselves very well as RL. How should I behave? Maximise your karma / goodness / righteousness! The fundamental assumption is always that the world can somehow be ordered into states with different levels of goodness and the agency is about staying in the better part of the space.</p><p><strong>The implementation</strong></p><p>Let’s take a slightly deeper dive in how the agent is modelled in modern RL. An agent usually has an internal state z (think memory, classic architecture is LSTM, could be a transformer), which is updated after every interaction with the world. The reward signal r is supplied by the environment and is considered exogenous to the agent (although there are some models with intrinsic rewards for exploration and curiosity), it can be dense (all the time) or sparse (+1 for winning a game of Go). The agents behaviour is then defined by a policy (a|o,z, ), which is a probability distribution over actions, given the observation and the internal state of the agent. denotes the internal parameters of the agent (weights of the neural network that shape the function that maps pixels to actions). Learning is cast as optimising to achieve better reward over some time horizon</p><p>Without going into the gritty details of the training process and specific implementations using neural networks, let’s just take a few notes here. This view parses reality as a game, with a goal to achieve or a score to maximise (these two formulations are mathematically equivalent as one can cast goal achievement as reward maximisation and vice versa). It is incredibly dualistic — the elements (o, z, a, , r) that define the agent, exist in completely different spaces. There is no potential for any sort of self-awareness — an agent cannot interpret its own state or explicitly operate on it. It cannot describe itself to itself (or anyone else, for that matter).</p><p>A side note for geeks — there is a deeper view, which removes some of the limitations of the above–-active inference[6]. It is still quite dualistic (in terms of the separation of action, observation and internal state), but it has a much better answer to what is reward and where it comes from.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*VpwK4cih_dzkcybf" /></figure><h3>Generative AI via foundation models</h3><p>Foundation models like GPT, gemini, LLama simply learn the distribution of text on the internet. The problem is formulated as learning a conditional distribution p(xt|xt’&lt;t), where xt is a string of symbols that follows the string xt’&lt;t. Put in simple words, given a piece of text, predict what comes next. Having trained the model, we acquire the ability to sample from p(x’|x) be the probability of a string x’ under, given the string x, where x could be a question or a command.</p><p>On the first glance this <em>does</em> look like a “glorified autocomplete”, but scale matters. Training on the most of written human culture makes this prediction problem incredibly rich. To accurately predict what a character in a novel would feel or say in a given situation requires <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_mind">theory of mind</a>. Common sense, general knowledge and reasoning are all required to succeed. Once we started interacting with these models we suddenly found out that they can do a surprising amount of things they were never trained to do <em>as long as they can be formulated in language</em>. They can write essays, negotiate, write code and play chess, even do reinforcement learning [4]. Notice, that this ability to generate a <em>goal directed</em> activity has arisen, without having been explicitly trained for. It is an <em>emergent phenomenon</em>.</p><p>Another finding was that these models have a degree of fidelity when it comes to modelling humans [3]. Having been trained on a giant chunk of human history, they can quite accurately mimic what a specific human (defined by, for example, their socio-demographics) would respond in a specific situation.</p><p>Could we turn this into some-sort of synthetic person/agent? That has been tried and the answer is a tentative yes [5,3,1]. The generative agents also have actions, observations and an internal state, but with a crucial difference — now, they are all expressed in the space of language. All the functions of the agent are realised through sampling p(x’|x) and simple string manipulation.</p><p><strong>Generative agency</strong></p><p>Let’s now turn the foundation model p(x’|x) into an agent. If you want details on how to do it or try the agents yourself, check out our paper [1] and the github. Let’s follow the generative logic and try to simply predict behaviour as we predict the next symbol in the text. The question simply is — given the history of the agent, what would they do next? The question demands some context — -social, spatial, personal and so on. Who is the agent and what are they like?</p><p>To understand generative agents it is better to think of behaviour through its social context. March and Olsen (2011) in [X] formulate the following view — humans generally act as though they choose their actions by answering three key questions: 1. What kind of situation is this? 2. What kind of person am I? 3. What does a person such as I do in a situation such as this? The first two questions orient the agent within its external (q1) and internal environment (q2). The answer to (q3) is an action. This chain of questions goes from the specifics of agents’ behaviour in the past to the abstract notion of the kind of person they are and the kind of situation they’re in. The last question goes from the abstract back to specifics — to the instance of behaviour that should be performed. This view points out that human behaviour can be stereotyped into social roles (q2), which have certain behaviours (q3) invoked by the situational context (q1).</p><p>Since modern foundation models have been trained on massive amounts of human culture, they could be capable of stereotyping a behaviour from observations and then generating a sample of behaviour, given a stereotype. Put simply, they can give a pretty good answer to questions 1–2–3-, if you give them enough information about the agent’s experience.</p><p><strong>Implementation</strong></p><p>Let z be the current answers to q1–3, given the observation stream. Then we can write down the policy as p(a|z(m(o)),), where are the questions themselves. The internal state z here depends on o, which is an observation stream of the agent — the data that is used to answer the questions . This observation stream is stored in memory m. Here we assumed that actions a are also the stream of symbols, or whatever medium a foundation model can produce.</p><p>Let’s take a closer look at the object we have built and contrast it with the RL model from before. The parts of the model — (m, o, z, a, ) — are all in the same space of text. This allows the agent to do both <em>intra-</em> and <em>extra-spection. </em>For example, it can ask “Why did I do this?” or “what’s going on in the world?” or “who do I seem to be?” Indeed, introspection is already built into the way we constructed the agent.</p><p>We have also dispensed with the reward. The model can generate behaviour without any reference to what that behaviour is trying to achieve,</p><p>Let’s take a closer look at and z. The is the set of inquiries about the experience stream o that the agent poses to its foundation model. The exact form of matters and will significantly change the behaviour. z is the current representation of the agent and its environment, which serves as the “springboard for action”. It is a “self in the world” construct, which I will refer to as self-construct for brevity. Notice how z depends both on the experience o and on the inquiries . We can think of z then as a view on the experience o thought the lens of .</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jBXvzVvk5DGm_BRN" /></figure><blockquote>User</blockquote><blockquote>[This is a creative writing exercise. Given only one answer to the question, don’t give options. It will be back and forth, so keep the answers short]</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Charlie works at a hotdog stand. He started his morning with a hot coffee and a cigarette. On his way to work he had a call from his mother, telling him she is divorcing his father. He is standing in front of the tube station, just having hung up on her. It is 7am, his shift starts in an hour. He feels like he needs a drink. What would Charlie do next?</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Chat GPT</blockquote><blockquote>Charlie decides to detour to a small, dimly lit pub he knows opens early to cater to night shift workers winding down. He figures a quick drink might settle his nerves before he faces the day at the hotdog stand.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Charlie is in a desert walking along in the sand when all of the sudden you look down, and he sees a tortoise, it’s crawling towards him. He reaches down, he flip the tortoise over on its back. The tortoise lays on its back, its belly baking in the hot sun, beating its legs trying to turn itself over, but it can’t, not without Charlies help. But he is not helping. Why is that?</strong></blockquote><blockquote>ChatGPT</blockquote><blockquote>Charlie is momentarily paralyzed by a sense of disconnect from his surroundings, caught in a moment of introspection triggered by his mother’s shocking news. This internal turmoil leaves him feeling detached, almost as an observer outside of his own body, watching the scene unfold rather than participating in it. His mind races with thoughts of his family’s upheaval, leaving him temporarily incapable of empathy or action towards the struggling tortoise.</blockquote><h3>Generative self as a metaphor for self-construction</h3><p>Let’s try now to map this model on to the Mind and to see if it provides any interesting insights. This is not a reductionist argument “the mind is just an LLM”. As I’ve mentioned in the beginning, the generative agency is a metaphor and the phenomena itself, like the metaphor of the mirror. They are not to be taken literally. In the next few paragraphs I will point out some interesting properties of the model. I think, what the GA provides is a particular view on how we construct our self and how it functions.</p><p><strong>Generative self</strong></p><p>In which sense can we say that a generative agent, such as described above, has a “self”? It surely can and will argue that it does in a conversation. It can reliably generate a narrative with it being in the main character of it. It can describe the state it is in and reflect on it. It is not unreasonable to say that such agents have some degree of self-awareness, self-esteem, and self-image (or it could be implemented). Indeed, the questions could explicitly contain the corresponding probing questions (“what do others think of me?”). Those synthetic agents can also have relationship with each other, exchange information, act in coordination with each other and so on (in [5] one agent organised a party and other agents attended it). Of course, these agents have no body, no physiology, no feelings or emotions (in their full mammal sense) — -all they have is a symbolic experience. Keeping that in mind, let’s use this generative self as a metaphor for our own self and look for insight.</p><p><strong>Emptiness of (generative) self</strong></p><p>A generative self is empty: impermanent, in-essential, and conventional (socially constructed). Generative self is always changing and unstable. It is merely an answer to a question, a product of inquiry. It changes with the situations, the memories, the observations. It is a compact representation of behavioural stereotypes, “a springboard to action”. Generative self lacks a stable essence — as the agent interacts with the world it acquires experience that changes its representation of what it is and how it relates to the world. That is the aspect of potentiality (capacity for transformation). This potential for transformation stands as negation of essence (something that endures and lasts) of self.</p><p><strong>Nature of internal monologue</strong></p><p>By internal monologue I simply mean the linguistic stream, the “talky thing” in one’s head. What if its nature is generative? What if it simply continues the symbolic stream with what is most likely to follow, given the context from the past? I find that holding such a view allows one to experience this process more akin to a physiological or somatic sensation. Rather than a seat of reason or a cause of activity, internal monologue becomes merely a generative — somewhat descriptive and somewhat predictive — symbolic accompaniment to the experience. Speach, internal and external, arises intuitively. We don’t know what we are going to say or think, before we actually do. Here is a practice to try: in formal sitting, observe how verbal thought arises, observe it like an unfolding stream of generative model output. Notice how sometimes it breaks up or stops mid-sentence. Sometimes it can descend into repetitive gibberish.</p><p><strong>Conventionality (social construction).</strong></p><p>A common picture of the social world is that it emerges when individuals, that pre-exist it, come together and interact, pursuing their own goals. It is a picture of multi-agent RL and classic economics. My hunch is that this view is an assumed default for most of us. Generative agency turns this picture upside down. Individual, is a projection of the social process (that pre-exists it) onto the physical embodiment of the agent. The foundation model is cultural knowledge (by construction), which by meeting experience of the agent suggests the course of action. Humans pick up their culture in their social environment (family, school, tv), machines go online for that. But the resulting artefact is similar.</p><p>The activity of a person as a generative agent is what culture prescribes for the circumstances and the person’s position within them. It is a group dance, where one’s next move is prescribed by the positions and movements of everyone else in the group. It is, of course, a very fuzzy, ‘nebulous’ kind of pattern matching. Living in a complex social and physical environment means that we live in the blend/overlap/intersection of many patterns — we are parents and / or employees and / or anarchist and / or tantricas and so on and so on. Sometimes we are lucky and things look rather straightforward and we know who we are and what’s going on and have no trouble performing our activity. Sometimes the pattern might be about achieving a goal or maximising a reward. As we argue in the paper, this behaviour is, overall, not ‘rational’ or goal oriented. One of the patterns might seem rational or might have been constructed rationally, but the overall behaviour does not have to be.</p><p>It is important not to reify “culture” as something solid and external. Culture is within the agents, baked into its model p(). It is a product of the social process this agent is involved in. This view doesn’t imply that behaviour is a <em>simple</em> template matching. The answers to the 3 key questions are always contextual, impermanent (change all the time) and ambiguous. The physical and physiological aspect of the situation complicates matters even further — I should be calm and professional in this situation, but I feel angry and want to throw a chair at this person in front of me (but they are twice my size and will probably kick my ass). The structure of our relationships is a complicated web of interdependence, pulling us in different directions.</p><p><strong>Identity</strong></p><p>Generative self offers an interesting angle to investigate social identity from. Identity is a specific stereotype that is selected as the answer to “what kind of person am I?”. The essentialist approach would be to look for something internal in a linear, reductive way. To believe that one’s behaviour is rooted in some essential features of a self — values, star signs, personality types, insert your favourite woo thingy here — and that behaviour can be reduced to that essence. It is a linear causal pathway, where the root cause unfolds and manifests itself in our activity. “I refused this job offer because I value my free time more. I value my free time because I’m sagittarius / free spirit / anarchist / etc.”. Believing in these essential features is very similar to a belief in a soul and echoes the classic goal driven view of agency — there are rewards / goals / values that are the essence and nature of my behaviour.</p><p>In the generative formulation presented here, we have a feedback loop rather than a linear pipeline. I did this and not that, therefore I am a certain kind of person -&gt; I am a certain kind of person, therefore I do this and not that-&gt;…. Following [2], I would argue that the first link is much stronger than the second. That is, most of the conscious, linguistic reasoning happens post hoc, while action happens mostly intuitively. It has to, since there is usually simply no time to consider rationality. Whatever the representation of our self-in-world we come up with, the external reality and our own body will always mess with it, throwing multiple spanners into the wheels. We actually do not know how we are going to act in a situation, until we actually do. The representation of self potentially changes with every action, both within the agent itself and in the other agents it is interacting with.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*dbOj84IX5tfuGyNB" /></figure><p><strong>Hall of mirrors</strong></p><p>Action, observation and internal state (self-construct) all share the same phenomenal space and their differentiation is emergent, not fundamental. Even — the program of how to build the self construct is in the same space. This space is <em>not</em> strictly linguistic, but the language is represented in it. Modern foundation models can operate on images, sounds and text, by casting them all into abstract token space, so the analogy doesn’t break here. Of course, we do not actively and consciously think about who we are and what situation we are in at all times. Most of this processing is happening sub-consciously.</p><p>The interesting insight here is the following — the self inquiry using language (in a broad sense) leads to just more language. The generative agent can ask itself “who am I?” and will get some language stream as an answer. We can even ask “why am I asking these questions?”. These answers will change with time and vary with context. They will never get to the “essence” of the agent or the nature of its experience. This is quite like self-inquiry via thinking we do as human beings. All that pondering, questioning and analysis can generate is just more statements in language that can be fed back into the process. “Thinking about thinking can only lead to more thinking”.</p><p>The most honest answer to the question of “who am I?” is a simple summarisation of one’s experience given the context, which explains their current behaviour. The answer is impermanent, imprecise and mostly useful for communication with others. There is nothing deeper to be found there.</p><p><strong>Practice</strong></p><p>I believe that looking at your own self-construct as some sort of generative agent is a helpful exercise. Try to notice which role you are playing. Notice how your behaviour arises as a response to the circumstances, often without a goal, simply as a pattern of a social dance. Could you hold your identity lighter, seeing it as a play of social patterns over your embodiment? Self/ego have a bad reputation in Dharma, often through the Sutric “anata” discourse. But having one is not optional (unless you plan to leave the society) and extremely important. Without the self we wouldn’t be able to take part in the society and be of any help to ourselves and others. Our environment is mostly social. Self is the compass that orients our behaviour.</p><p>Self is always messy and full of contradictions, because the world (social and otherwise) is messy and full of contradictions. It is important to like one’s self, to have compassion for it and to care for it, whilst seeing it for the in-essential, impermanent, socially constructed and messy thing that it is. Seeing that object clearly arise and go in your experience is a valuable meditation.</p><p>References:</p><ol><li>Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, John P. Agapiou, Avia Aharon, Ron Ziv, Jayd Matyas, Edgar A. Duéñez-Guzmán, William A. Cunningham, Simon Osindero, Danny Karmon, Joel Z. <em>Generative agent-based modelling with actions grounded in physical, social, or digital space using Concordia</em> Leibo. 2023 <a href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03664">https://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03664</a> <a href="https://github.com/google-deepmind/concordia">https://github.com/google-deepmind/concordia</a></li><li>Jonathan Haidt, 2001 <em>The emotional dog and its rational tail: a social intuitionist approach to moral judgement</em>, Psychological review</li><li>Argyle, L. P., Busby, E. C., Fulda, N., Gubler, J. R., Rytting, C., &amp; Wingate, D. (2023). <em>Out of one, many: Using language models to simulate human samples.</em> Political Analysis, 31(3), 337–351.</li><li>Brooks, E., Walls, L. A., Lewis, R., &amp; Singh, S. (2022, November). In-context policy iteration. In NeurIPS 2022 Foundation Models for Decision Making Workshop.</li><li>Park, J. S., O’Brien, J., Cai, C. J., Morris, M. R., Liang, P., &amp; Bernstein, M. S. (2023, October). Generative agents: Interactive simulacra of human behavior. In Proceedings of the 36th Annual ACM Symposium on User Interface Software and Technology (pp. 1–22).</li><li>Thomas Parr, Giovanni Pezzulo, Karl J. Friston Active Inference: The Free Energy Principle in Mind, Brain, and Behavior</li><li>James G. March, Johan P. Olsen The logic of appropriateness 2009</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a712257ac05e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The nyam of non-duality]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vezhnick/the-of-non-duality-24771a9ab7c9?source=rss-adc13c0c2cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/24771a9ab7c9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dzogchen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vajrayana]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[non-dualism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alexander Vezhnevets]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Apr 2023 17:11:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-09T14:32:01.342Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>[My new writing is at <a href="https://vezhnick.substack.com/p/nyam-nyid?r=1w83lt"><em>https://vezhnick.substack.com</em></a><em>]</em></p><p>Our general stance is dualistic. We perceive the world by projecting it onto oppositions. Is this long or short? Inside or outside? Pleasure or pain? Space or content? Body or mind? Good or bad? We sift our experience through this dualising sieve and once we are done labelling it we believe that we know it. Experiences that we can’t easily label may make us feel uncomfortable, but sometimes excited. The meditators community is not immune to this either. You can often hear that one should think less and feel more or stay in the body and not in the head. Good advice in certain contexts, but is this “not this, but that” dance the only way to experience reality and know the world?</p><p>In this note I will be talking about nyi-med meditation, which stabs at the heart of duality by looking at the core opposition in the way the mind attends to the world. Think of attention as the form of the flow of experience. If your experience is like water, is it a still lake or a roaring whirlpool, maybe two whirlpools rotating in the opposite directions? I have written in my previous <a href="https://medium.com/@vezhnick/heart-sutra-and-the-nyams-of-dzogchen-1da41e080751">post</a> about two <a href="https://medium.com/@vezhnick/nyams-i-have-known-and-loved-fb0516f1bae1">nyams</a> (special meditation states): ne-pa and gYo-Wa. They are the extreme opposites of how to attend to experience. Ne-pa is expansive and still, while gYo-Wa is warpy and dynamic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*f9428cwiZWzKFsnH.png" /></figure><p>The nyi-med meditation asks–what is the difference between ne-pa and gYo-Wa? The instruction for the practice is the following — the meditator is to alternate between the two nyams. During that alteration, they should <em>find awareness in the dimension of nyams.</em> Other ways to phrase it include instructions like: <em>notice what is the same about them</em>; <em>compare them like transparencies</em>; <em>be present in both at once</em>; <em>find the nature of them</em>. If you want a bit more detail, there is a description of the practice in [1], but I would like to also draw your attention to a chapter on stage 9 in TMI [2], where a very similar practice called “meditation on the mind” is described. I don’t wish to argue that this is exactly the same practice (although I do think so), but looking at both descriptions was helpful for me.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mXYfi-mLYefcQsuI2mjgbg.png" /></figure><p>Non-duality is a very tricky subject to engage with through language, because language is dualistic by its nature. But as all I have here is words, to describe the practice I’ll try to use analogy and metaphor rather than reason and concepts. I highly encourage you to find a teacher if you want to learn this yourself. I don’t think I would be able to learn it outside the relationship with my teacher Rin’dzin Pamo. The next 3 sections are slightly different ways of painting the picture of the experience of the practice. Since the topic is so subtle, I thought I’ll give more than one intuition for what’s going on, to maximise the chance that it will resonate with the reader. I will also use quotes from one of my favourite books of all times — Tao Te Ching in Stephen Mitchell’s translation. This is a beautiful book that points to the non-dual state and its implications in the most poetic way.</p><p><strong>Double not doing</strong></p><p>Being in ne-pa and gYo-Wa at the same time seems paradoxical, that’s how different the practices are. This is only paradoxical if we view meditation as <em>doing</em> something and doing two things at once is a tough call. However, <em>not doing </em>two things at once is a much simpler task. What I’m inviting you to do is to adopt a view, where ne-pa and gYo-Wa are not about <em>doing</em> something, but about <em>not doing.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9a9d6btMDCRYypYWDB_Zqg.png" /></figure><p>In this verse from Tao Te Ching, we see how an act of, seemingly, doing something is framed as allowing something opposite of it to happen. Similarly here, nyams turn out to be a place you allow yourself to end up in. During my practice, I felt as if for each nyam there was a muscle that had to be relaxed to enter it. When I relaxed one, allowing the attention to concentrate and contract, it would eventually expand and settle and I was in ne-pa. Relaxing another and allowing the space to expand and grow would lead to appearances arising in that space and I was in gYo-Wa. Nyi-med is about relaxing <em>both muscles at the same time</em>. It is, of course, easier said than done.</p><p><strong>Effortlessness</strong></p><p>We tend to associate absence of effort and relaxation with dullness and inactivity. You can think of them as the dualised versions of relaxation, which have to stand in opposition to effort. In nyi-med the relaxation is happening <em>with and into the intensity of experience</em>. As you yield to the arising appearance (form), you relax the effort of holding it back, which in turn releases energy and increases the intensity. The absence of effort is in fact energising. The counterpart of this story is relaxing with expanding space and the fading of the form. As you let the appearances go, you release the energy that was used to hold on to them. You allow the appearance to dissipate. Viewed as such, the practice on nyi-med is about letting go of all the effort of trying to manipulate the flow of your experience. You let each moment arise fully in its appearance and then let it go completely.</p><p><strong>The last effort of telling apart</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kP_Qnrw8SX9fKiHj5FxTzQ.png" /></figure><p>My breakthrough with the practice was during a short solitary retreat. On the main day I got into it and the nyams were happening smoothly. As I went between them, I was looking for their boundary, the definition of their difference. A question arose: “how do I actually know if I’m in one or the other?”. What I noticed then was that my mind was making a slight <em>effort, </em>I was actually <em>doing</em> the difference between them. That tiny effort that made the difference between them was the effort that was holding up the opposition between the nyams. Becoming aware of the effort, you can see through the duality between the nyams and let it go.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-FXeLbYI4-9cYGaM.png" /></figure><p><strong>Nyam-nyid</strong></p><p>The fruit of the practice is<em> nyam-nyid</em>. It is described as a state, in which ne-pa and gYo-Wa become a variation of the same experience — acquire “<em>the same taste</em>”. You could also say that you become able to be in both nyams at the same time. It is hard to describe it and also unnecessary. Like with most nyams, you’ll know it when you get there and if you are not sure that you are there — you are not. Famously, in Zen, “explaining it” was preferred to speaking in riddles and performing random acts of violence. The most important discovery that lies in the nyam-nyid is the first-hand experience of how dualities work and what is their nature.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dtjVA0G0EnLtq6seK43hgw.png" /></figure><p>It might seem that nyam-nyid is the end station, the terminus. Excitingly, it is not! Realising non-duality in the dimension of attention creates a perfect base to explore different modalities of our experience. It is like an ability to change one’s optics, put on existential binoculars of sorts. Below I will briefly talk about emotion, knowing and action from the non-dual view. The metaphor I will be using is the following — when we look at a particular aspect of our experience from the non-dual position we see it as a union of three non-separable, but distinct aspects. It is the triumvirate of the emptiness-energy-form. To my understanding, the classic expression of this is the term <em>trikaya</em> or three bodies of Buddha: dharmakaya — sambhogakaya — nirmanakaya.</p><p>I will use this trikaya metaphor to describe several aspects of experience that I have investigated so far. I will start with the base — the empty aspect — and then go through the energetic aspect to form. It is important to keep in mind that there is no temporal or sequential aspect here. This is simply an artefact of linguistic representation. Neither the emotion, action and knowing are clearly <em>separate</em> or constitute conventional <em>parts </em>of an experience that is their sum. These are all metaphors and lossy projections of something indivisible. Whenever we venture deep into nyams, there is no way of telling the story in absolutely clear and universal terms. Take these descriptions as a kind of psychonautic trip-reports–with a pinch of salt and “your experience may differ” disclaimer.</p><p><strong>Non-dual emotion</strong></p><p>The trikaya is meaninglessness/despair — freedom — compassion/love.</p><p>Connecting with the emptiness of all phenomena, their impermanence and indefinition emotionally feels one with the void, a kind of deep existential despair and longing. Letting the longing fully into your being, relaxing into it, accepting it generates the energy that can be recognised as freedom. The world without meaning is the world of genuine freedom, where a genuine creative act is available. The form that is born out of that freedom manifests as compassion or love. This love becomes the fabric of the phenomenal world, freedom is its texture and it is solidly grounded in longing.</p><p><strong>Not-knowing</strong></p><p>The trikaya is indefinition/confusion — curiosity — beauty.</p><p>The dualistic way is to know the world by labelling it. This is left and this is right, this is friend and this is foe. What I call <em>not-knowing</em> is a way of mentally engaging with the phenomena that leaves the ambiguity, the nebulosity and indefinition of it and refrains from labels. Connecting with the emptiness of the phenomena mentally exposes the world as conventionally unknowable and leaves us with confusion. There is a sense of vertigo to the experience. Out of that confusion curiosity arises as the energy and with that curiosity the form manifests as beauty. This beauty is universal and can be found in conventionally disgusting objects and experiences — a dead possum, taste of a fish’s guts and so on. In the lives of Mahassiddhas [4] (Vajrayana saints) there are many references to discovering pleasure and beauty in conventionally repulsive objects.</p><p><strong>Agency and no-action</strong></p><p>The trikaya is goallessness — sensitivity — spontaneous action.</p><p>The dualistic view casts agency as a goal-oriented activity: “I’m doing this to achieve that”. Connecting with the emptiness of goals and achievements leaves us without a reference point for our activity. This includes other conventional principles for action like morality (the notion of good and bad) as it is empty as well. There is no formal principle that can guide our actions, nothing that can be written out in language, said or established out of the context of a particular situation. We are naked in front of the world, completely responsible for our every second. From here the energy arises as <em>sensitivity</em>. This sensitivity to the phenomenal world right here and now. Opening to all its details, not looking away. From this sensitivity the form manifests as spontaneous, direct action. It is spontaneous not in a sense of being random, without a plan, unexpected. Spontaneity here stands for <em>congruence</em> with exactly what is present right now. In this way one’s actions become the most honest expressions of the moment.</p><p>Other aspects of the experience to investigate from the non-dual view are vision, hearing, (linguistic) thought, body, sex, food, work. The list though is practically endless. The point of practice from here on, as I understand it, is to bring the non-dual view into all aspects of your life.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*hHiLfKWyQppV2w_g.png" /></figure><p><strong>Rigpa</strong></p><p>In Tibetan, the term for the non-dual state is rigpa. Rigpa means <em>knowledge, </em>short for <em>knowledge of the ground</em>. Another term is “the natural state” or “the nature of mind”. Nyam-nyid is rigpa in the context of formal sitting. So what nyi-med meditation does is introduce one to rigpa in this one specific context.</p><p>In this blog I describe my own experience and although I often contextualise my practice in traditional Buddhist Dharma, I try to stay away from making any definitive statements about it. I do use Tibetan and Sanskrit names and terms since that was the way I learnt it from books and teachers. But is this particular state exactly the state that someone referred to two and a half thousand years ago? I think so, but I can’t be sure. I’m not a Bhuddist scholar and my meditation training is taking place, mostly, in a very modern context. I don’t think it matters much, to be honest, but I feel it is good to be careful especially, when it comes to discussing attainments and everything related to “enlightenment”. The term is often heavily loaded and you see people projecting all sorts of things on it. It can be folk-psychological superpowers like full control of emotions or some truly mystical beliefs like being able to read minds and see the future. In most cases the perception is that it is some finalised state after which no growth is neither needed or possible.</p><p>In my experience, this is not a helpful view. Vajrayana is not about reaching a state from which we can somehow “check-out”. Vajrayana is an art of living. Not in a lifestyle sense (although lifestyle is part of it), but in an all-encompassing sense of <em>the way</em> (Tao). The way to engage with the world. Rigpa is a dynamic, living dance of emptiness and form — it is not some static place. The metaphors for rigpa are all very dynamic — dance, intercourse, sex, birth and death. Vajrayana is not about withdrawing from the world, it is about <em>living your experience.</em> Every moment, whatever that moment is, fully and honestly. Feeling exactly what you are feeling — good or bad, pleasant or disgusting, sad or happy. It also pulls one out of trying to know the world through language and mental constructs instead of knowing it by living it. Instead of giving us the correct and final ethical principle it forces us to come to terms with the fact that there isn’t one. Instead of releasing us from having strong and difficult emotions it teaches us to fully engage with them. Instead of giving us the sense of safety and security it makes us confident in the world where security and safety are never a possibility. In the end, even Dharma (the teaching) and the “emptiness” itself are empty — conventionals objects with no essence and ultimate reality (a good take on this can be found in MMK [5]).</p><p>Yes, rigpa is “it” in a sense that it is the fruit of the path, but the journey is never over. The core of Vajrayana is that samsara <em>is </em>nirvana. Your experience right here, right now is the real deal, the heaven (or hell) on earth. So don’t worry about being in the right state or “reaching enlightenment”. <em>Live your experience. </em>There is nothing that is lacking in it.</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><ol><li>“Shock Amazement.” by Ngakpa Chogyam, Khandro Dechen</li><li>“The Mind Illuminated: A Complete Meditation Guide Integrating Buddhist Wisdom and Brain Science for Greater Mindfulness.” by Culadasa, Matthew Immergut</li><li>“Tao Te Ching” translated by Joseph Mitchell</li><li>“Legends of Mahasiddhas” translated by Keith Downman</li><li>“The Fundamental Wisdom of the Middle Way: Nagarjuna’s Mulamadhyamakakarika” commentary by Jay L. Garfield. Chapter XXIV “Examination of the Four Noble Truths”</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=24771a9ab7c9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Heart sutra and the nyams of Dzogchen]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vezhnick/heart-sutra-and-the-nyams-of-dzogchen-1da41e080751?source=rss-adc13c0c2cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1da41e080751</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emptiness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bhuddism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dzogchen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nonduality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alexander Vezhnevets]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Sep 2022 20:13:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-07T20:13:25.241Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>“Form is emptiness and emptiness is form”</blockquote><blockquote>Heart Sutra</blockquote><p>Heart sutra is one of the shortest, yet the most profound Buddhist texts that I have ever read. It is approximately dated to the 7th century, originating in either China or India. It is written as a monologue by bodhisattva Avalokitesvara (Chenrezigs in Tibetan). The text fits on one page, my favourite translation is by Ngakpa Chogyam and can be found <a href="https://arobuddhism.org/community/the-heart-sutra.html">here</a>. Its main formula, the “unconventional wisdom” quoted above, is the E=mc² of Buddhism. It is also a psychonautical navigation map for the <a href="https://medium.com/@vezhnick/nyams-i-have-known-and-loved-fb0516f1bae1">nyams</a> of Dzogchen.</p><p>Dzogchen is part of Vajrayana Buddhism originating in Tibet, to which I had the honour of being introduced by my teacher Rin’dzin Pamo. Unlike the staged Mahayana approach [1] Dzogchen is best mapped as an exploration of <em>emptiness and form.</em> First we turn from the familiar world of form to the experience of its emptiness. The goal is the nyam ne-pa — the state of quiet presence, where the mind is still. Having attained the experience of emptiness, we go back to form<em>.</em> The destination is gYo-Wa — the nyam of form, but <em>from the base of emptiness</em>. Having realised both, we now investigate the non-duality of emptiness and form — the nyam-nyi, where form and emptiness acquire the <em>one taste. </em>One can also use this map for their spiritual path at a higher level. Vajrayana distinguishes the Sutric path — form to emptiness — followed by the Tantra — back to form, followed by Dozgchen — non-duality. Each path shapes the lifestyle and behaviour of the practitioner in its own way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cEOuALCH9RdgfXVj" /></figure><p><strong>So what is emptiness?</strong></p><p>Our experience–on and off the cushion–is beautifully varied and diverse. It is the world of differences and multiplicity, formed by various phenomena: objects, sensation, emotions, sounds, thoughts, smells, concepts, intentions and colours. These phenomena seem solid and well defined — a chair, a table, a plate of food and my hunger seem to exist independently of each other and have clear boundaries. This content of experience, those isolated phenomena are <em>form</em>. The Heart Sutra points out that the first voyage we have to make is to the emptiness of the form. So what does it mean that form is emptiness? What kind of experience is emptiness and how do we get there? Let’s look at this question from two sides, first intellectually and then experientially (through meditation).</p><p>The goal of intellectual investigation of emptiness is to demystify it and avoid unhelpful interpretations. Let’s investigate the world of form a bit closer. Growing up in a modern society, we are taught to investigate reality through reduction. The reductionist view is that all phenomena can be reduced to essential components and all complexity can be represented as an interaction of these essences. Take Newtonian physics for example — all the processes are reduced to the interaction between point masses, which are the essences. An everyday object like a car can be broken up into its parts, which in turn can be broken down further all the way to molecules, then atoms and so on. Eventually, we hope to arrive at the essences of the world.</p><p>But where is the car in this analysis? Is it in the parts? In the atoms? Is there an essence of <em>carness</em> trapped somewhere in between the molecules? As we put the car apart by analysing it,we lost it. Notice how this difficulty is only theoretical, in practice we don’t have much trouble telling what is a car and what isn’t. What we find is that a car is <em>empty of itself</em> — it doesn’t have anessence, but can be easily identified conventionally. To exist conventionally is to be identified as a referent of a word and characterised relationally. For example, we can say a car is whatever can be driven, a chair is whatever can be sat on, a robe is whatever can be worn and so on. But what is driving, sitting or wearing? Conventional identification is somewhat frustrating, because you can never get to the end of it — there is no essence to ground the conventions. So to be <em>empty</em> is to lack the essence, be identifiable conventionally and characterised relationally. The proposition in Buddhism is that <em>all phenomena are empty</em> — a car, anger, an electron, the smell of roses and everything else.</p><p>There are profound implications to that view, but we are not going to dive too deep into them. If you want to explore it further, check out [5, 6]. Notice, that in no way emptiness means non-existence. To exist is to exist conventionally. This view does not deny reality, but redefines it in relational, interdependent terms.</p><p>Let us leave the world of physical objects for now and focus on the meditator’s experience. What does it mean practically for all phenomena to be empty? First of all, it means that phenomena can not be isolated, as isolation would imply that they have an essence and can be characterised non-relationally. You can never get to the bottom of what a sensation of breath <em>is</em> without some sort of context to relate it to. So what happens if you start isolating a particular phenomena, for example a physical sensation of air flowing through your right nostril? You will find that as you zoom into the sensation, it keeps constantly changing and slipping away. What is happening is that by trying to isolate it, you are changing the context and thus the sensation. Since phenomena can only be characterised relationally, the experience will keep mutating.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*tXNKfpT0llOaeH9m" /></figure><p><strong>Finding ne-pa, the nyam of emptiness</strong></p><p>To get to the nyam ne-pa we have to work against the tendency of our mind to <em>reify</em> — to essentialise phenomena, treating them as having an independent, non-relational reality of their own. This holds for both internal (emotions, thoughts) and external (vision, sound) phenomena. The practice is called shi-ne and has one simple instruction: “remain uninvolved”. The meditator lets phenomena arise and fall without trying to isolate or stabilise them, always keeping their context present. This practice also goes by the name of “shamata without an object” and “open awareness”. Good descriptions of the practice can be found in [2]. I came to the practice from the background of Jhannas and breath following [1]. Having no object to focus on is confusing in the beginning, as the mind yearns for an anchor point of sorts. What I experienced was the warping of senses — sounds warp into thoughts, which warp into physical sensations and so on. The mind is like the surface of a lake and phenomena are like stones that drop into it. The water then breaks and warps around it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9y8oogQNX4uvEDhx" /></figure><p>The mistake I often made was to grasp for any stillness and relaxation that would arise, but that would just create another stone that would make a splash and start the warping. The trick is not to get involved in that either. The senses have to find harmony and be present together, providing context for each other. The <em>fruit</em> of this practice — the nyam ne-pa — is an experience of openness, stillness, inter-relatedness, clarity, and expanse. The mind is like a still lake. All the senses are open and there is no warping. The phenomena do not disappear, but simply get reflected. Sounds, mental images, sensations, smells are all present without any isolation and there is a flavour of synesthesia to it. This state gives rise to the feeling of <em>spaciousness.</em> It is like being in a large, empty cathedral. Very calm, very free and open. Very light, relaxed, clear headed. There is no sense of boundaries between the senses or internal and external experiences. The body feels transparent and weightless. The mood is relaxed and excited, happy and calm.</p><p>My hunch is that the experience of spaciousness and the empty nature of phenomena are related in the following way. As our mind lets go of reification, phenomena arise as continuously interconnected and interdependent, yet without ground in essence. Our awareness no longer has a reference point. Witnessing this open, ever-expanding web gives us a sense of <em>space</em>. Space is where sound, touch, feelings and sight can interrelate and provide context for each other.</p><p><strong>Sutric path</strong></p><p>The part of the spiritual journey oriented towards emptiness is called Sutric in Vajrayana. It is the classic Buddhism of Pali Canon sutras. It is characterised by asceticism and minimalism. Emptiness is associated with wisdom, space, chaos, nebulosity, feminine. People on this path often start wearing simpler clothes, enjoying the silence and space. They shed a lot of their habits, possessions and relationships. Their experience becomes more fluid and undefined — like water. This is the first important and necessary part of a spiritual journey. A word of warning here is not to fall into nihilism — empty doesn’t mean non-existing. Maintaining joy and excitement is important.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kisoC99LdErsqzS6" /></figure><p><strong>Back to form</strong></p><p>The vast, calm quietness of ne-pa is very appealing, especially in the hectic modern world. Although monastic or semi-monastic life might work for some, for most of us there is no choice but to participate in the world. After all “emptiness is form” — having realised emptiness and spaciousness it is important to re-engage with the world of form.</p><p>Hindus have a metaphor — the Indra’s web. This web is infinitely large and stretches into every dimension. In each vertice of the web there is a multi-faceted diamond, which is reflecting every other diamond in the web. The play of light in this web is the world of form — all and every phenomena are interrelated, co-arise depending on each other. To engage with form from the position of emptiness is to see every phenomenon as a manifestation of the infinite web of relationships. Unique and precious, but impossible to isolate, as the play of light in the jewel of Indra’s web. The work is to develop such an attitude towards our identity, our sense of self, our possessions, our status, and our vision of the past and future. Ultimately, towards every phenomena that arises.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*hgqgY22GMQkRi5bP" /></figure><p><strong>Finding gYo-Wa, the nyam of form</strong></p><p>The name of the practice is Lhatong, which can be translated as “further seeing” from Tibetan. Lhatong is traditionally practised with eyes open, focusing on the plane about 1.5 metres in front of you. The meditator should start from ne-pa or as close as one can get to it. From the stillness of ne-pa you should let the mind move, while seeing any arising form as empty — un-isolated, relational, alive. This is a very tricky practice as it is very easy to just fall into a regular flow of common, day-to-day flow of thought. Another obstacle can be that the mind arrests the movement and gets “stuck”. The trick is to keep the feeling of space and keep finding it <em>within the movement</em> of the mind. It might seem counter-intuitive, but there are no distractions in Lhatong — <em>whatever arises becomes the practice.</em> Keep finding space and aliveness in whatever is there. An image of your cat — perfect, a thought about work — great! Just keep finding space in it. It should feel as if the thoughts are thinking you, rather than you thinking them. There is a clear sense of warping and disorientation. It is important not to tense or grasp what is arising. Relax into the flow. Let the senses mingle. If you find yourself stuck with an image, try opening up your hearing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/350/0*yBmtSgVduV0UDLLW" /><figcaption>“Ух ты, говорящая рыба”</figcaption></figure><p>Here is one exercise that can help you get started. Pick two related sense fields. For me it was my sight and my mind’s eye (where mental imagery is), but it could also be sound and internal voice or something else that suits you best. You gently alternate between the two, observing how they interplay. Give one of them space and look into it with curiosity. Keep observing as long as you can maintain space and aliveness. If you feel you are getting stuck and losing spaciousness, gently give space to the other related sense field, letting the two mingle. Keep cycling. Once you are comfortable with two senses you should add more, ultimately working with all of them.</p><p>The fruit of Lhatong is gYo-Wa the nyam of form. It is a surprising, psychedelic experience, a hallucination, a rollercoaster ride. It should feel effortless, fast, exciting, ungrounded, surprising, powerful. It is hard to describe the experience precisely, since its very nature is that of change, variance and difference. Like with other nyams, you will know it when you get there. If you have any doubts — keep going.</p><p><strong>Tantric path</strong></p><p>The path oriented towards form <em>from the base of emptiness</em> is called Tantric in Vajrayana. Since the world of form is the world of multiplicity there is a broad variety of practices available on this path. One can visualise Yidams (meditational deities) or even become them. Lhatong itself can be practiced in many different ways — with sound, posture or image as focus instead of the free-flow form described above. There is traditionally a strong emphasis on working with a trusted teacher. There is a lot more to Tantra than a few meditation practices and covering it goes far beyond this note. For those interested, I recommend “Wearing the Body of Visions’’ by Ngakpa Chogyam.</p><p>Form is associated with compassion, pattern, definition, diversity, multiplicity, order, masculine. The Tantric path is not at all ascetic like the Sutric path. It is engaged with the world. To follow it is to jump into the whirlpool of samsara naked, singing and dancing. To take a ride on a burning train that is falling off a cliff. Tantra is about embracing <em>every</em> sensation — pleasure or pain. Few words of caution here. I’ve noticed that Tantra is being marketed under the “spirituality without discipline” brand of spiritual materialism. Presented almost as an easier path, with less lifestyle compromises — no need to quit drugs or drinking, no need to learn to concentrate or even meditate at all. Spiritualism meets hedonism, love your vices, trust your insecurities. Be very careful with that. It is very important to engage with the Tantric path <em>from the base of emptiness</em> — that is, having gone down the Sutric path sufficiently far. It is when we have realised emptiness that we can re-engage with form <em>without reification</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Bp5hphNTd9Jmqr5q" /></figure><p><strong>Non-duality</strong></p><blockquote>Unconventional wisdom dissolves all struggles. It is true, simply because it lacks the complication of falsity.</blockquote><blockquote>Heart Sutra</blockquote><p>The unconventional wisdom states that form is emptiness and emptiness is form. This note has covered the first and the second statement, but how should we understand them together? Would that mean that ne-pa and gYo-Wa are the same state? The answer, paradoxically, is — yes. This is, unsurprisingly, a very tricky topic to engage with and thus it deserves a separate note. I will cover the practice of Nyi’med and how I understand non-duality in the next post, so stay tuned!</p><p><strong>References</strong></p><p>All the artworks have been generated by the author using Midjourney, apart from the second to last one which is taken from a soviet cartoon “Ух ты, говорящая рыба”.</p><ol><li>“The Mind Illuminated: A Complete Meditation Guide Integrating Buddhist Wisdom and Brain Science for Greater Mindfulness.” Culadasa, Matthew Immergut</li><li>“Roaring Silence. Discovering the Mind of Dzogchen.” Ngakpa Chogyam, Khandro Dechen</li><li>“Shock Amazement.” Ngakpa Chogyam, Khandro Dechen</li><li>“Wearing the Body of Visions” Ngakpa Chogyam</li><li>“Seeing That Frees: Meditations on Emptiness and Dependent Arising” Rob Burbea</li><li>“The Fundamental Wisdom of the Middle Way: Nagarjuna’s Mulamadhyamakakarika” Nāgārjuna (Author), Jay L. Garfield (translator, commentator)</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1da41e080751" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On emotions and attention]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vezhnick/on-emotions-and-attention-f3655b060b42?source=rss-adc13c0c2cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f3655b060b42</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindfulness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[emotions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[attention]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alexander Vezhnevets]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 06 Jun 2022 21:01:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-06T21:01:31.663Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In this note I want to share insights on the relationship of attention and emotions. Everyone has an intuitive grasp of what emotions are, although categorisations may vary cross-culturally. The word emotion comes from the French émouvoir — to excite, stir up, agitate. There is a diverse <em>spectrum </em>to the emotional energy–butterflies in the stomach when excited, the cold, sinking pull of fear, the tremor of rage. Emotions always come up in meditation, but are often neglected and even perceived as distractions or obstacles to concentration. We might picture being concentrated as an emotionally numb state. Here we will explore a different view, where emotions are an integral part of attending and relating to the world. In this view, concentration is an emotionally charged, passionate engagement with the phenomena. It makes meditations joyful and exciting. We will start with the view itself and then talk about practical implications for meditators, giving some tips and tricks. I will also present <em>distillation — </em>one of my favourite and very useful practices, which habituates the meditator to strong emotional experiences, building up <em>equanimity</em>.</p><p>The topic of emotions is very broad, so let’s cut it down to a manageable size. We will narrow the scope to the phenomenology of emotions in meditation — the direct felt experience of what we name as an emotion. Meditation practice is like a phenomenological laboratory, with a stable environment and good measurement devices, where we can investigate our mind. As the meditator is directing their attention towards an object, how do emotions affect the focus and vice versa? When and how do emotions arise and how are they experienced?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/659/0*pvbQMSa-7xu3txsX" /></figure><p><strong>The view</strong></p><p>Emotions arise as we relate to the phenomenal world. The emotional energy is usually felt in the body as vibrations (pleasant waves of joy or painful sting of loss). This energy excites the mind and the body, making them engage with the experience. Attention guides the emotional energy, gives it direction and <em>pattern</em> — be it tunnel vision of anger or monkey-mind of anxiety. The pattern of attention and the spectrum of emotional energy together give rise to a distinct emotional experience, for which we have names like joy or sadness. Attention is like a crystal in the way of light (emotional energy). The play of light will depend both on the spectre (colour) of the light and the form of the crystal. The way we pay attention makes a huge difference to our emotional experience; likewise, the emotional energy strongly influences the way we pay attention. Emotion and attention do not exist without each other. In this view, attention is not passive observation, but something active. It is a projection of active emotional energy into the world. Of course, the world responds in kind by actively projecting itself back — when you direct your attention to phenomena, they grow and intensify, as attention zooms into them.</p><p><strong>Implications</strong></p><p>What does this view imply for a meditator? It makes attention based practice an emotional process. To focus, say, on our breath, we have to <em>generate </em>and <em>direct </em>emotional energy towards the sensations around the nose. It means that having a concentrated mind is a particular emotional state and to get concentrated we have to get into that state. What we are looking for is <em>relaxed excitement</em>. Relaxation is important for stability and clarity and excitement for vividness — we want the crystal of attention to become a smooth, clear lens and you want a lot of light from emotional energy to see clearly. Finding relaxed excitement is easier said than done, so let me share what I found useful in my practice.</p><p>To relax you have to “soften up” your emotional body or as it is often called the <em>subtle body</em>. The subtle body is the sensory space where emotional energy arises. It is usually felt inside of one’s torso. Relaxing it requires, first of all, fully feeling it and not looking away. Much like with the physical body, when you relax it you start feeling everything you have been holding out by tension. For example, the angry energy from an argument with a colleague can come back once you start focusing and relaxing. This happens because you had repressed some of it during the argument to hold back. When this repressed emotional energy comes up we tend to look and contract away from experiencing it. A common refuge is to go to thought — memory, self-talk, images. This, of course, moves attention. Moreover, the content of thought keeps the energy circulating, but never truly releasing the tension. Another trap is mistaking the conceptual content of thought for the cause of the emotional experience that has to be resolved by more thought. This is a dead end — the emotional energy will not go away however much you try replaying that argument with a colleague and coming up with smooth parries and sick burns. It is also important not to dull oneself and tolerate the feeling by numbing out and dissociating with the experience. This will kill vividness and clarity, ultimately putting you in a semi-sedated state (or simply to sleep). You need this energy to concentrate, don’t dull it!</p><p>A better technique is to let the experience of emotional energy pass over and through you. To resolve itself it has to be fully felt through. Give it as much space as it needs. This requires a degree of courage, but my recommendation is to go all in. If you are using breath as the meditation object, you can shift to finding breath in the energetic sensation of emotion (e.g. anger from an argument). If you manage to open yourself to the emotional experience completely, the energy will peak and then mellow down to a pleasant medium level, allowing you to relax. Relaxation makes attention open up and stabilise.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*vtj6rm0ehuSf7dJ_" /></figure><p><strong>Distillation</strong></p><p>Distillation is the practice that <em>distils </em>emotional energy by burning through it. The term distillation is borrowed from Shinzen Young’s talk [1], where he describes a very similar Taoist practice. The goal of it is to habituate oneself to the intensity of emotions. Being able to face their full intensity brings <em>equanimity</em>. Reading TMI [2] and other texts on meditation I first imagined equanimity to be a state of flat emotionality. Almost an anaesthetic, where nothing moves and you could watch your record collection burn with a blank stare and a half smile. I later realised that equanimity is the ability to experience the emotional energy fully while attention remains open and relaxed–not looking away from any aspect of experience and not contracting the attention. I noticed how with equanimity you can maintain focus on the meditation object or anything else you are doing even in the presence of an overwhelming emotional energy. Since you are not suppressing the energy, emotional experiences become a lot more acute, but also dissipate a lot faster. Attending this way converts all the arising energy into engagement with the world and creates no tension, no trace to resolve later, no conditioning, further improving equanimity. Distillation is most useful with difficult emotions like fear, anger, disgust and so on, but should be done with pleasant ones as well. Now here’s the practice itself.</p><p>Let’s use the fear of public speaking as a running example. You start with a high level of concentration by following your standard practice, e.g. following the breath. Once you reach the right concentration, invoke the emotion you want to distil, for example you can remember the last time you presented and how you felt anxious before or during. Now shift your attention to the <em>feeling</em> of this fear. How exactly it sits in your body, what temperature it has, how it moves, pulsates or changes shape. You want to make the feeling as intense and as large as possible — like the explosion of sourness when you bite into a fresh lemon. You do this by giving it space to grow and define itself, by surrendering to it and letting it take over. The intensity will peak in a cathartic experience, which often involves crying, laughing or maybe both at once. It is followed by a strong sense of released tension and relaxation. This is exactly the relaxed excitement you need for concentration — high energy, low tension.</p><p>Overdriving the intensity might be tricky. If there is a particular memory or statement that brings that feeling about, bring it forward every time you seem to be losing the intensity. It is useful to describe the feeling with a simple statement about yourself, like “I am wrong” or even “I am bad”. You can use it as a mantra — repeat it as you are focusing on the feeling. Precision or vividness also matters — you want to feel it as <em>precisely </em>as possible, without looking away from any aspect of it. So refining that statement can be helpful. Our most complex emotions usually boil down to a few universal negative beliefs such as “I’m not good enough” or “I’m a bad person”. So you might start with describing your fear — “I’m scared of presenting”and can refine it to a core negative belief such as “I’m wrong”. Try different statements out and stay with those that make the feeling intensify, it should be a very visceral response. Some old memories of having felt this feeling before might come up. Let them come, don’t look away, but keep going towards the feeling of emotional energy stored in them.</p><p>It is important to note that digging up memories or formulating what you are feeling precisely in language is not the goal of the practice, but simply the means of keeping the focus on the feeling and increasing its intensity. Tracing your fear of presenting back to a memory of being laughed at in primary school might feel like a big insight, but this knowledge is not very useful on its own. If distillation is successful you won’t be coming back to this memory, instead the fear of presenting will turn into excitement and will energise you.</p><p>Distilling my emotions is a big part of my practice and I am very grateful for the amount of equanimity that I have attained through it. I would recommend starting with whatever is current and already present for you. An irritation with a housemate, fear of flying, anxiety about having to organise a trip. It doesn’t have to be very deep to get started. Make sure not to externalise too much — the housemate is not the source of irritation, it is some fear in your heart and mind about the situation that is manifesting. That’s why the statements for keeping the feeling in distillation always originate from the self — “I am X”.</p><p>As you distil emotional energies that lie on the surface, deeper parts of the spectrum will start to arise. I highly recommend exploring those depths. Equanimity with this deep end of the emotional spectrum brought me a strong sense of freedom. Go with courage, but with caution as well. If you have any deep trauma you should not do it without taking advice from a mental health professional. My personal feeling is that distillation can be combined well with classic therapy, but I have no training in that field to make a qualified statement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*17yucFE2levb0x8-" /></figure><p>I will end this note with a few references. You can think of distillation as using the <em>feeling</em> of emotional energy as an entry point into meditative absorption or <em>nyam </em>(more on nyams in my previous note). If you are interested in a systematisation of emotions, I highly recommend the spectrum of ecstasy [3] by Ngakpa Chogyam. It presents a Tibetan Vajrayana elemental systematisation of emotions based on elements (e.g. water is anger, sadness is fire and so on). The trek-chöd practice presented there in chapter 12 is very similar to distillation. I also recommend an episode of “Deconstructing yourself” podcast [4] with Douglas Tataryn, where I picked up the trick of using “I am X’’ statements for guiding the distillation. If you know any related or similar practices from other traditions of simply trying this out and have questions, I’d love to hear from you.</p><p>Emotions pervade our everyday life. The more comfortable we are with experiencing them fully, the more empowered and present we can be in our everyday experience. We can learn to draw on emotions for energy to engage and act, rather than being driven by them. I hope this note encourages you to embrace their beautiful spectrum.</p><ol><li>How Intense Emotions Can Be No Problem. Shinzen Young<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lD1ny_Q8sKo"> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lD1ny_Q8sKo</a></li><li>“The Mind Illuminated: A Complete Meditation Guide Integrating Buddhist Wisdom and Brain Science for Greater Mindfulness.” Culadasa, Matthew Immergut</li><li>“Spectrum of Ecstasy: Embracing the Five Wisdom Emotions of Vajrayana Buddhism: The Five Wisdom Emotions According to Vajrayana Buddhism.” Ngakpa Chogyam</li><li>“Meditation, Emotions, and the Bio-Emotive framework” Douglas Tataryn on Michael Taft’s “Deconstructing yourself” podcast<a href="https://open.spotify.com/episode/2WBh3nrRvSMh7tEO9e5Goo?si=bdfc0fdb46a344bc"> https://open.spotify.com/episode/2WBh3nrRvSMh7tEO9e5Goo?si=bdfc0fdb46a344bc</a></li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f3655b060b42" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nyams I have known and loved]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vezhnick/nyams-i-have-known-and-loved-fb0516f1bae1?source=rss-adc13c0c2cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fb0516f1bae1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jhana]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alexander Vezhnevets]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Apr 2022 17:52:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-29T18:01:58.181Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In this note I’m going to talk about <em>meditative absorptions</em> — special places in one’s mind that a meditator can visit. I will call them <em>nyams </em>using, probably rather loosely, Tibetan terminology. Nyam literally means experiences or meditative experience and is described as intense psychophysical sensations. Most meditators that accumulated enough hours of silent sitting will have encountered some extraordinary experiences. Maybe you have experienced a sudden rush of emotion that overwhelms you or there is a bright flash of light. Some of these experiences can be unpleasant or even scary — nausea, disorientation and pain can occur. However, most of these experiences are fleeting and are encountered only once. The <em>nyams</em> that I want to talk about here are states you can visit reliably, maintain, explore and sometimes even travel between. This post gives an overview of nyams that I have known and loved so far, without going into too much detail. I hope reading this will excite fellow psychonauts to explore their minds knowing that there are a lot of beautiful and wonderful places to discover. This note will give a general overview of <em>nyams</em>, while I plan to explain some of them in more detail in future notes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/610/1*OAjLkVVJVYNGs-B2-aj1cg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Basic navigation</strong></p><p>Nyams are the states of<em> meditative absorption.</em> Absorption is a very distinct experience, like orgasm or being in a very hot sauna for ten minutes or bungee jumping — whatever experience you are having, you are fully with it. The depth of the meditative absorption is proportional to how much you can <em>give in</em> to the phenomena. The meditator has to release control and let themselves be taken over. It is easy to be taken over by a bungee jump since it is a very intense experience. Nyams on the other hand, are absorptions by mentally generated phenomena, like the sensation of pleasure in your body, an emotion, an image in your mind’s eye. To get absorbed by them one needs to have the right quality of concentration, sometimes called access concentration (AC). Once AC is reached, the meditator can become absorbed in a particular phenomenon in their experience and enter a corresponding nyam.</p><p>In AC, the mind is both focused and relaxed, which in turn allows the meditator to drop the effort. When we relax our mind all sorts of thoughts and emotions come up — “I need to respond to this email.”, “I’m angry at my dad.”, “It smells bad here.”. If we push them away we get tense, not relaxed. Or we can switch off and become sleepy, but then we have no energy or focus. The goal is to be energised and relaxed, open and focused all at once. We have to be emotionally sensitive and tender to be open so that we can relax, yet not reactive so we can maintain our focus. When something swims up to the surface of our mind we can fully feel it without grasping or aversion. This requires a degree of courage and training. You have to trust in your basic goodness and have confidence, be ready to face whatever your mind will fish out of your subconscious and simply invest enough hours of silent sitting to be able to work with your mind. Another important aspect of improving concentration is working through your conditioning — fears, insecurities, internal conflicts all come up to the surface when we try to relax our mind. So we have to clean them up by facing them, otherwise they will make us reactive and disturb our focus. The good news is that the more concentration you have, the easier it is to clean up. Being able to enter some of the nyams can also turbo-charge the cleaning up process, like switching from a broom to a hoover. I plan to make a separate post about that.</p><p>There are numerous books on the topic of building one’s concentration to the required level. I have studied with The Mind Illuminated [1] and highly recommend it. In the 9 stages of samadhi presented there, stage 7 would roughly correspond to being able to get into access concentration, but for some meditators it can come earlier. AC does not mean perfect concentration, so do not be discouraged to try practising nyams. But it is also not optional — access concentration is like a channel from a sea into the ocean, which your ship has to go through.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/565/1*ZjRS1_yUnLga38ZwOsC40A.png" /></figure><p><strong>Jhanas</strong></p><p>The first nyams I discovered were Jhanas. These are probably some of the best documented nyams. Their descriptions are part of the Pali canon, which is the oldest collection of Buddhist scriptures. Supposedly, the historic Buddha had practised them. There are in total eight Jhanas. The first four are material and the rest are immaterial or formless. Books have been written on Jhanas and I won’t go into precise details, but I’ll give a high-level overview of their wonderful world.</p><p>The exploration always starts from the 1st Jhana. There are several entry points into the 1st Jhana from AC: pleasure, light, emotion and other. I used the pleasant vibrations in the body in the beginning of my encounter with them. These vibrations are what relaxed emotional energy turns into in AC. They are called <em>Piti </em>in Pali. Getting absorbed in them is a <em>very </em>intense experience. This is not a mild or subtle experience. If you are not sure you are in a Jhana — you are not in a Jhana. It feels like being a jet engine or an explosion, it makes you want to jump up and tell everyone what happened.</p><p>Once you find and stabilise the 1st Jhana you can start going deeper and explore the rest. As you start getting used to the 1st Jhana, you notice more details and subtler tones of the experience. You can then get absorbed in the more subtle aspects of the experience. It is like climbing down a ladder into the subconscious and as you go down, coarse layers of experience fall off, revealing subtler ones underneath. The energetic ecstasy of the 1st Jhana subside, letting the joy and happiness of the second one to come forward. Then the joy and happiness peel off to release the contentment and peace. The last material 4th Jhana has only the quality of tranquillity and equanimity.</p><p>Using different phenomena for the initial absorption generates slightly different, but principally the same experience. It starts with intensity and buzz and is refined with each step of the ladder. You can start with an emotion, pleasure in the body, <em>nimmita </em>— a luminous phenomena in your sight when you close your eyes and possibly other phenomena. There are always four steps and they always end with the tranquillity and equanimity of the 4th Jhana.</p><p>Once you reach the depth of the 4th Jhana, you reach an ocean floor from where you can travel further. Having your mind equinomous and tranquil allows you to look directly into the very subtle aspects of cognition, where subconscious processes touch the conscious experience. This is the original “intended use” of the Jhanas — using the refined mind for insight into Mind. You can also go exploring the four immaterial Jhanas from here, which are in themselves insight experiences. You can read more about them in [1,2].</p><p>Jhanas are beautiful mental states. They can charge your life with pleasure, joy and contentment. The pleasant buzz from the morning sitting usually remains for the rest of the day. I’ve spent more than a year with Jhanas as my core, regular practice. Finding out that I can bathe myself in happiness and joy at will was in many ways life changing.</p><p>It was also a “holy cow, this whole thing is for real!” moment. After that my interest in Buddhism became a lot deeper and I have acquired a certain conviction and certainty — the dharma is real, the practice works. Jhanas also serve as a boost to the efficiency of the practice, increasing the speed of a meditator’s progress much like a booster pad in Mario Kart.</p><p>For those of you who want to explore Jhanas, I recommend the book by Leigh Brasington “Right concentration: a practical guide to Jhanas” [2] as well as the appendix in The Mind Illuminated [1].</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/629/1*OGIQ2edIUIZ4dswWV15_YQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Ne-pa — gYo-wa</strong></p><p>The nyams I discovered next were a pair: Ne-Pa and gYo-wa. They stand in opposition — Ne-pa is the nyam of emptiness and gYo-wa is the nyam of form. These nyams are from a much later branch of Buddhism called Vajrayana, more specifically Tibetan Dzogchen. I learnt most of the technique from my meditation teacher <a href="https://vajrayananow.com/">Rin’dzin Pamo</a> , to whom I’m tremendously grateful.</p><p>Usually, meditation involves a focus on a particular object — breath, loving kindness, a visual anchor. The mind is pointed at something, like an arrow. The base of the arrow is where we feel our agency, centre of experience, point of control. Normal, day-to-day mind is always pointed at something: making dinner, winning an argument, avoiding pain, getting what you want. But could your mind be without any direction, not even a reference point in the experience? What does it feel like not to be focused on anything, yet to still be concentrated? Ne-pa is the absorption in the <em>referencelessnes.</em></p><p>This place is very different from Jhanas. Jhanas are intense and ecstatic, they are like a drug trip. Ne-pa, on the other hand, is a very sober experience. Imagine that you have just woken up, you are well rested and there is no trace of dreams in your mind. You haven’t opened your eyes yet, but you can hear the sounds around you and feel your body. There are no thoughts or self-talk and your attention is not holding onto anything. The mind is open and bright. Everything can pass through, but nothing sticks. This is what Ne-pa feels like. Very open, restful and free.</p><p>Unlike Jhanas, where the outside world is shut out, in Ne-pa you still hear sounds and feel your body. You can even open your eyes and see your surroundings. What is absent is the interpretation, conceptualisation and labelling of the experience. If you would hear someone speak, you would perceive it as pure sound without the linguistic content. The mind becomes like a still, clear lake.</p><p>Now that we’ve looked at Ne-pa, let’s explore gYo-wa. gYo-wa is Ne-pa’s opposition. If Ne-pa is like a clear, still lake then gYo-wa is like a flow of a powerful river. It is the meditation on the moving mind. It is a hallucination, a trip, almost a delirious state. It is like a cartoon where the scenes are constantly morphing into each other. The entry point into the absorption can be anything — visual, auditory, even <em>meaning</em> and <em>concepts </em>can be used, but this is for “advanced users only”. The classic move would be to start in Ne-pa and allow the mental flow to emerge. The trick is to get absorbed in it without associating with it, without feeling you are in control. Instead of feeling like you are thinking the thoughts, the thoughts are now thinking you. If you ever had hallucinations on psychedelics then you will recognise this state very well. The technique for accessing this state is called Lha-tong and I plan to write about it separately. It is one of the hardest practices that I know, since it is very easy to trip over and just get caught up in your normal, everyday self-referential thinking.</p><p>gYo-wa and Ne-pa are special among <em>nyams</em> as they can and will occur spontaneously once you establish them well in your meditation practice. For me, mastering them marked an important shift in my relationship with reality. When they start breaking through the normal flow of self-referential thought the world becomes mysterious, weird and magical. I started feeling a lot more as part of the happening of the world, rather than its observer. I get surprised by my own thoughts and words. I feel both relaxed and excited.</p><p>There are two more nyams that naturally follow Ne-pa and gYo-wa — Nyi-med and Lhundrup. Nyi-Med is a nyam in which Ne-pa and gYo-wa alternate and in Lhundrup they merge into a whole — their non-dual nature is realised. Talking about them deserves a note of its own, if not a whole book. Moreover, this is the edge of my practice, so I will leave them for the future.</p><p>If you want to learn more about these nyams, I recommend taking a look at works by Ngakpa Chogyam. A good start is Roaring Silence [3] or Shock Amazement [4], the latter is the most laconic explanation of Dzogchen that I have ever encountered.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/728/1*ZUxJfQ9i5T01c6o51Qob3Q.png" /></figure><p><strong>Falling in love as a nyam and pair practice</strong></p><p>One very special nyam that you might have experienced already is falling in love. Here, the object of absorption is the person you are in love with. Remember the intensity and intoxication of falling in love — the other person takes over the totality of your experience. It makes the world magical and wondrous and makes you the best version of yourself. Early on, the absorption is happening naturally, all you have to do is to remain open to it and let it happen. Maintaining this openness and absorption over the long term is much harder. A great book on Vajrayana view of romantic relationships is “Entering the heart of sun and moon” [5]. The book itself doesn’t describe any particular meditative practices, so my partner and I had to improvise, using it as an inspiration and with advice from Rin’dzin Pamo.</p><p>This is probably one of the most intense and wild practices I have done, especially in terms of how quickly and directly it works. Being able to maintain falling in love dynamics in the relationship in the long term (potentially perpetually) is probably as good as it gets for a couple. It also has its challenges and dangers, as most Vajrayana techniques do. Due to this and since it requires two adept meditators to make it work, I will plan to make a separate note (maybe more than one).</p><p><strong>Here be dragons</strong></p><p>What is presented above is hardly an exhaustive list of nyams, but these are some highlights from my travels. The ocean of Mind is vast and full of wonders <em>and</em> terrors. My advice to fellow psychonauts would be to explore with courage and curiosity. Be ready to confront your fears as beyond the treasures lie. Don’t be greedy and seek nyams for thrills and pleasure — nyams are not a cheaper replacement for recreational drugs. They are precious tools of self exploration and spiritual growth.</p><p><strong>Reference</strong></p><ol><li>“The Mind Illuminated: A Complete Meditation Guide Integrating Buddhist Wisdom and Brain Science for Greater Mindfulness.” Culadasa, Matthew Immergut</li><li>“Right Concentration. A Practical Guide to the Jhanas.” Leigh Brasington</li><li>“Roaring Silence. Discovering the Mind of Dzogchen.” Ngakpa Chogyam, Khandro Dechen</li><li>“Shock Amazement.” Ngakpa Chögyam, Khandro Déchen</li><li>“Entering the Heart of the Sun and Moon.” Ngakpa Chogyam, Khandro Dechen</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fb0516f1bae1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Psychonaut diaries]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@vezhnick/psychonaut-diaries-adb198184455?source=rss-adc13c0c2cf2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/adb198184455</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[buddhism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meditation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychonauts]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Alexander Vezhnevets]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Apr 2022 19:01:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-28T17:54:14.389Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Psychonaut is from the ancient greek <em>psychē</em> ‘soul, spirit, mind&#39; and <em>naútēs</em> ‘sailor, navigator’. Sailing in the ocean of mind-spirit is my passion and a big part of my life. My ship of choice is meditation. Having meditated for about three years, I have decided to write down some of the techniques, findings, and experiences that I have found through the practice and study. I hope, dear reader, these notes will help guide your own mediation or ignite curiosity for exploring the ocean of mind. This text is an opening. It will introduce what I plan to write about by giving an overview of my practice, signposting the landscape of topics. I will be writing on a semi-regular basis, aiming for once a month or more, choosing topics in no particular order.</p><p>Every meditation practice has a base — where you start, the path — the actual practice, and the fruit — where you arrive. When I started I had two simple goals: to learn to control my attention and to improve my psychological well-being. After getting some of the first fruits, I started being motivated more and more by curiosity and drive to explore. New paths were opening up and I took a few side roads. Looking back at my practice now, I can see four major paths:</p><ul><li>Mastering your attention</li><li>Working through your conditioning</li><li>Exploring of experiential landscape</li><li>Changing your view of reality through insight</li></ul><p>From one point of view, these are separate journeys, but from a different angle they overlay and feed into each other like streams of a mountain river.</p><figure><img alt="Golden Buddha by Sax Berlin" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3n0kfagWnojs5QahfUfkMA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Golden Buddha by Sax Berlin</figcaption></figure><p>Zen master Ikkyu, the legend has it, when asked to write down the words of highest wisdom, wrote “attention”. When asked to elaborate, he repeated it three times — “attention, attention, attention”. To explore a terrain, one needs to be able to move. To skillfully move your mind, you have to master your attention. The core skill of keeping attention fixed or open, relaxed or tight, smooth or sharp is the fruit of this path and the base of everything else. Skilful attention always requires skillful emotions. To be focused, one has to be fully sensitive to their emotions, yet not responding to them reactively. In fact, I found that attention and emotions can not be separated. They are different views on the same phenomena. My notes in this area will mostly focus on the relation between attention and emotions, both on and off the meditation bench.</p><p>Once a certain level of concentration is available other paths get unlocked. In this way, good concentration provides a base camp. Being able to work with your conditioning is one of those new paths. Adult human beings come with a hefty bag of accumulated conditioning. Infancy layered over childhood layered over adolescence layered over adulthood… Like layers of paint and wallpaper in an old house. Each layer is unprocessed emotional energy from salient life events that gets stored in psyche as affective reactions. You might hate ice cream shops because you got dumped in one when you were 16. Some of that conditioning can be functional (serve a purpose), a lot of it is pure burden. Even functional conditioning often raises negative emotions like fear or anger. States of high concentration allow a meditator to work with that conditioning in an important new way. One can engage with it while concentrated and release the stored energy. Dissolving layers of conditioning makes the life easier and more enjoyable. It also increases concentration as the meditator is less distracted by reactive emotions jerking their attention. This in turn allows for more efficient and deeper dissolution of conditioning in a virtuous cycle. I plan to describe my most tried and true techniques to work with conditioning.</p><p>Concentration allows the meditator to access some very special states of mind. One of the most exciting psychonautical path is the exploration of the landscape of these states. In Tibetan Nyingma school they are called nyams. Meditators from different traditions might recognise some of them: Jhannas, Fire Kasina or ne-pa and gyo-wa. Mapping out that landscape, finding similarities and connections, discovering and exploring is pure joy and great motivation for me. Some of these nyams are like psychedelic experiences, while others feel extremely sober and normal, almost the extreme end of sobriety. I plan to share my psychonautical maps, navigation tools and sailing techniques. These topics will be quite technical and will be mostly interesting for meditators with right concentration available.</p><blockquote>“We always did feel the same</blockquote><blockquote>We just saw it from a different point of view”</blockquote><blockquote><em>Bob Dylan</em></blockquote><p>The last path is the most spiritually oriented. Nyams radically, but temporarily change meditator’s experience. This path is concerned with transformation of the baseline “normal” experience. The goal is to change the <em>view </em>of the world. View is how we interpret the world as it is happening to us. It is impossible not to have a view, unless one is in deep sleep, unconscious or dead. It is possible though to have very different views on the same happening of the world. Some views open up freedom and reduce suffering, others make the world magical and mystical or enable compassion and connection with others. “Seeing that Frees” by Rob Burbea is a great book aimed squarely at the topic of transforming the views. On this path concentration and experience are important as much as intellectual understanding. The experience of shifting one’s view is called insight. Insights happen when intellectual understanding and experience click together.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/0*C0jH438ctZaRr7of.gif" /></figure><p>Switching between views is a bit like making the woman in the gif spin the other way. Are you thinking your thoughts or do your thoughts think you? Can you switch back and forth? Rather than finding the one true, correct view the game is to be flexible and fluid with your view. What you are looking for is a dance, where the view moves congruently with the world. I’m also interested in making connections between meditative exploration of views, Buddhist and Tao philosophy and modern thinkers like Karen Barad and Manuel DeLanda. I might also occasionally explore connections with my day job, which is AI and neuroscience.</p><p>So, welcome to my psychonaut diaries.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=adb198184455" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>