<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Vassilissa Semouchkina on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Vassilissa Semouchkina on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@vsemouch?source=rss-7bb49d0a049b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 09:11:33 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@vsemouch/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Advancing Visual Design Culture in STEM Laboratory Groups]]></title>
            <link>https://vsemouch.medium.com/advancing-visual-design-culture-in-stem-laboratory-groups-8e2d45a69de0?source=rss-7bb49d0a049b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8e2d45a69de0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[scientific-communication]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critique]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vassilissa Semouchkina]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Apr 2021 05:15:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-28T05:28:06.936Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Master of Design Thesis — Design Phase</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*APxPM6fZqNNdRR6kxFToIg.png" /></figure><p><em>Problem Space<br></em>It’s been a while since I’ve last updated on the progress of my graduate thesis work. In the few months since my last blog post, the overall trajectory of my work has remained largely the same, though the scope and focus are now significantly more defined. However, I feel that it’s important to touch on and reiterate the groundwork of my pursuits before launching into new developments. My thesis seeks to improve visual design culture within STEM laboratories. I intend to do this by exploring and proposing ways in which researchers can more naturally and intuitively self-educate themselves about visual design, without the presence and guidance of a designer-educator. In addition to providing guides for learning basic design principles, I believe that this might be done through introducing and encouraging researchers to engage in design critique. In order to determine what methods or tools might be most effective, I have conducted weekly observations of laboratory and graduate groups to evaluate their existing laboratory practices and overall internal culture. It should be noted that most research labs do review scientific visuals as groups, however, these evaluations are often unstructured, imprecise, and randomly conducted.</p><p><em>Read more about this </em><a href="https://medium.com/p/8fb65b1f9d04/edit"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Between the months of September and December 2020, I reviewed existing literature to define the existing scope, areas of study, and current pursuits in the field of scientific communication through relevant books and published academic articles. At the same time, I was also reaching out to different labs across campus in order to observe their regular lab sessions so that I could see how they currently conduct feedback sessions and how often, if at all, visual feedback was a part of this process. Observing these labs and offering advice on their visuals for several months allowed me to build a working relationship and rapport with the students and P.I.s, as well as enable them to behave more naturally with my presence over time. When asked, all groups were receptive when I proposed using a pair of lab meeting sessions to teach a visual design and critique workshop. I elaborate on this more below, but to put it succinctly — I conducted introductory design workshops and measured the student’s interest and confidence in visual design before and after the workshop sessions through a pair of surveys. I did this in order to determine what elements of visual design are most specifically helpful to researchers, as well as what teaching methods are most effective and result in the most information retention. These insights from the workshops and surveys would inform the creation of my design solution, a scientific communication toolkit meant to help researchers self-teach themselves visual design methodology as well as learn the importance of and practice critique.</p><p>—</p><p><em>Overview<br></em>This academic quarter, the focus of my work was gathering the data necessary for creating an effective and desirable scientific communication toolkit and guide. Some of the main areas of concern I hoped to address were what areas of design or specific materials researchers were most interested in improving, what material resources they would find helpful or desirable, and what aspects of visual design they found most confusing and difficult to retain. This process consisted of hosting the aforementioned workshops, as well as conducting surveys with and gathering a selection of figures from participating groups. Below, I elaborate on the reasoning behind each of these steps, and how their results inform the rest of my thesis process.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5rpFj9GTR1nE88ora3iL6A.png" /><figcaption>2021 Visual Design Workshop Dates and Material Deadlines</figcaption></figure><p><em>Workshops and Pre-Readings<br></em>After conducting research on the current scope of scientific communication and the efforts that have been made to improve it, as well as building a working and observational relationship with several labs across campus, I ended the last quarter by organizing a series of design workshops with these labs that would occur between February and April 2021. These workshops would consist of two separate sessions and introduce the labs to both foundational design principles as well as visual critique theory and practice. Before the workshops, students were also asked to complete a reading and watch a short video which discussed basic visual design principles and the importance of practicing visual critique.</p><ul><li><strong>The Main Workshop</strong> : a 1-hour workshop centered on how advancing visual communication skills can help researchers improve and make clear the meaning of their scientific visuals. This was done through exploring various visual elements, as well as arranging, composing, and drawing attention to these elements. This workshop explained the importance and use of various foundational design principles, such as contrast/hierarchy, space/proximity, unity, flow, and color. Following the definition and exploration of these foundational principles, examples of scientific visuals before and after they were improved through utilizing these various design principles were shown. In addition to showing the improved scientific figures to show a positive change in informational clarity, the group was asked to comment on the original scientific figures beforehand in order to postulate their own best guesses on how to improve them. This workshop also briefly covered more literal design issues, such as general visual design guidelines for layout, text, and images. Following the workshop, researchers were asked to submit a figure that they would like to improve for use in the follow-up critique workshop, and were given a visual design “cheat sheet” to help them remember the various design principles.</li><li><strong>The Critique Workshop</strong> : a 30-minute workshop centered around the benefits and process of visual critique. This workshop first covered what design critique is and how it could be a critical and easily introduced step in STEM labs for improving scientific visuals without the presence of a design professional. In addition to covering critique structure and practice, the majority of the workshop focused on a peer critique of the submitted figures from the previous session, during which students could reference their design “cheat sheets” in order to better focus their suggestions. Following the workshop, students were asked to consider their peers’ advice and submit a reworked figure in two weeks’ time.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HQS4zum1yw1A3LJf9fEBvQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Visual Design Workshop Slides</figcaption></figure><p><em>Surveys and Figure Submission<br></em>While the workshops were the primary way to directly engage the laboratories in visual critique and discussion, the labs were also provided with a series of surveys in order to measure their understanding of visual design before and after the workshops. In addition to these surveys, participants were also asked to submit any scientific figures they’d like to develop or improve before the start of the main workshop.</p><ul><li><strong>Pre-Workshop Survey : </strong>This 15-minute survey was given to participants a week before the main workshop. The survey gathered and documented the participants: 1) general background information and academic rank, 2) current utilization of and experience with scientific figures, 3) knowledge of visual design, 4) training in visual design, 5) opinion of what makes a successful figure, 6) a personal assessment of their own visual design skills, as well as other important foundational information. In addition to these more personal and opinion-based questions, participants were given 5 pre-selected figures to visually assess and critique, in order to measure the quality of their comments and understanding of design flaws before being introduced to foundational design theory.</li><li><strong>Post-Workshop Survey :</strong> This 10-minute survey was given to participants directly after the conclusion of the critique workshop. This survey modeled similarly to the pre-workshop survey, but removed more constant background questions. The similarity was intentional, in order to document variances in participants’ responses before and after the workshops and ascertain the change in their understanding and confidence in using visual design principles.</li><li><strong>Cheat Sheet Survey </strong>: This 4-minute survey was given to participants a month after the conclusion of the critique workshop. This brief survey asked participants if they had been using the visual design cheat sheet since the conclusion of the workshops, and if so, what about it they found helpful as well as what they thought might improve the cheat sheet and make it more desirable for future use.</li><li><strong>Figure Submission </strong>: Figures were collected from the workshop participants in two parts: 1) before the main workshop, and 2) two weeks after the conclusion of the critique workshop. The first submission was done in order to gather unedited, ‘baseline’ figures from the participants. After going through both workshops, participants were then asked to rework and resubmit their improved figures, which would hopefully be somewhat improved and easier to understand.</li></ul><p><em>Cheat Sheet<br></em>Between the main and critique workshop, students were given a visual design cheat sheet to help them during the latter workshop, as well as for general use when improving their own figures. This cheat sheet offered reminders on how to structure and conduct critique sessions, as well as an overview of the visual design principles covered during the main workshop. The cheat sheet consists of four pages: an introduction to visual critique and how to use it, a summary of critique structure and template for listing critique goals, a page for the participant to evaluate their own work, and a page briefly covering the elements of visual design.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qqpRrzPb9WHhSXaT7cdfiw.png" /><figcaption>Visual Design and Critique Cheatsheet</figcaption></figure><p><em>The Labs<br></em>The labs and graduate-level communications course I was observing since the middle of last quarter were the groups that participated in these workshops. Each group was given the same workshop, with the only thing differing element being the student-submitted figures discussed during the critique workshop. The labs and communications-course involved were as follows:</p><ul><li><strong>The Engage Seminar</strong> : a science speaker series and seminar focused on training graduate students communication skills in order to help foster public understanding of the sciences.</li><li><strong>The Averkiou Lab </strong>: a biomedical science lab focused on developing imaging and therapy ultrasound technologies in order to bring image-guided ultrasound-mediated drug delivery in clinical trials.</li><li><strong>The Pun Lab</strong> : a bioengineering lab focused on developing bioinspired materials to advance drug delivery and molecular imaging technologies, utilizing techniques from engineering, chemistry, and cell biology.</li><li><strong>The Cossairt Lab </strong>: a synthetic inorganic chemistry lab focused on building up inorganic nanostructures for targeted applications in light emission, energy harvesting, and catalysis.</li><li><strong>The Swann Lab</strong> : an ecoclimate lab studying how plants and climate interact with one another by understanding the physical climate system and the underlying biological process that govern ecosystems and characterize their response to environmental variability and change.</li></ul><p><em>Next Steps<br></em>With the workshops completed, the after-workshop surveys being filled out, and the figures being resubmitted, there is a significant amount of data to sort and weave through in order to flesh out the next steps in moving towards an effective intervention. The next and final steps in this process are structured and will flow from one step to the next:</p><ul><li><strong>Evaluating Improvement in Student Figures</strong> : After all labs and groups have submitted their improved figures, it will be important to have designers and scientists not familiar with the details of the workshop review the figures without signifying which variations are ‘before’ and which are ‘after’. To ensure further fairness in terms of judging, those who will be reviewing the figures will also be given a rubric so that I might better and more fairly compare and consolidate the designers’ and scientists’ respective grades.</li><li><strong>Gathering and Sorting Researcher Insights and Areas of Interest</strong> : In addition to the evaluation of scientific figures mentioned above, it will be essential to sort the data gathered from the surveys in order to determine what parts of the workshop were most effective and important to the participants. These insights will help inform what subject areas and materials are most essential to cover when creating materials for researchers to self-educate themselves in visual design, as well as learn, practice, and retain critique practices.</li><li><strong>Building the Scientific Communication Toolkit</strong> : After gathering and sorting the participant’s insights and preferences regarding design materials and education, it will be time to create the product of the 4 months of observations and workshops: the scientific communication toolkit. This toolkit will include a selection of materials meant to help researchers quickly learn and review various visual design principles, guides for reviewing their personal work in relation to the criteria, critique guidelines, as well as other materials related to practicing engaging and helpful critique. This toolkit will be designed to be available both physically and digitally: the digital components will be convenient and easily portable as well as generally accessible through digital means.</li><li><strong>Preparing for the Henry Art Gallery Exhibition</strong> : Following the affirmative from the Henry Art Gallery regarding the graduate thesis exhibition, I will also be developing a way to showcase the breadth of my research and survey results, as well as the resulting scientific communication toolkit, in the physical space of a gallery.</li><li><strong>Preparing Results and Product for Publication </strong>: In addition to all of the previous steps mentioned, I hope to document the research I’ve conducted over the course of the academic year and the resultant findings through a formal publication. This publication would be submitted to an academic journal, such as the <em>Information Design Journal</em> or <em>Design Studies</em>.</li></ul><p>With a busy quarter ahead, I’m excited to dive into these final steps in my thesis. The journey has been incredibly rewarding, and it’s been a joy to work with a variety of interdisciplinary academic labs, even as we remain physically separate during the time of COVID-19. If you have found this work interesting, stay tuned for updates and discussions as I approach the final chapters of my graduate career.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8e2d45a69de0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Advancing Visual Design Culture in STEM Lab Groups]]></title>
            <link>https://vsemouch.medium.com/advancing-visual-design-culture-in-stem-lab-groups-8fb65b1f9d04?source=rss-7bb49d0a049b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8fb65b1f9d04</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[design-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critique]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scientific-communication]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vassilissa Semouchkina]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Dec 2020 23:55:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-22T17:00:09.625Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Advancing Visual Design Culture in STEM Laboratory Groups</h3><p><em>Master of Design Thesis — Research Phase</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K2br0wquy2VJuqg-y3mv7Q.png" /></figure><p>In my life, I have always been surrounded by science and academia. My grandparents were professors and engineers, all but a few of my relatives are faculty, and my parents — well, I’m sure you can guess by now. Before I started graduate school, I even worked as a designer and scientific communication specialist for Michigan Technological University, a leading STEM university. All that to say, I have spent my life immersed in the scientific community — and though my own academic interests took a different turn (hint: design), I wanted to be involved in the sciences as much as possible.</p><p>There was just one problem. While my parents and relatives took the time to help me understand their work, drawing out explanatory diagrams and schematics on napkins at the dinner table, when I would tag along on academic conferences, it was like walking into an intellectual brick wall. The posters, the presentations — nothing made sense. Nothing, well, communicated.</p><h4><strong><em>The Research Problem: Poor Scientific Visualizations</em></strong></h4><p>Clearly, there are issues with scientific communication, and unfortunately, these issues are widespread. Not only do researchers have trouble <a href="https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/effective-communication-better-science/">explaining their work to their own communities</a>, but there is a <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/19/science/science-journalism-fake-news.html">growing public distrust of science</a>. I experienced this firsthand when working for the aforementioned STEM university, which boasted an impressive research reputation while being nestled in a remote, rural community. The population there was like a microcosm of American society. While at my job, I was constantly surrounded by essential, innovative work and the university researchers who did it, however, in leaving campus and interacting with community locals, there was a disconnect. Many so-called “townies” didn’t understand, trust, or even believe in the science that was being worked on just blocks away from their homes.</p><p>I’m not the first to notice this problem. Many universities and communication specialists focus their attention on bettering scientific communication — there are <a href="https://www.aldacenter.org/workshops">workshops</a>, <a href="https://biorender.com/">online resources</a>, <a href="https://www.asbmb.org/career-resources/communication-course">classes</a>, and even <a href="https://alliance-primo.hosted.exlibrisgroup.com/permalink/f/lvbsh/TN_cdi_plos_journals_2219590692">help desks</a> available to assist researchers in creating better scientific graphics. Clear, informative visuals are a tried and tested pathway for furthering accessible, memorable scientific communication — we associate many of the most profound ideas in modern science with corresponding visuals, from Crick’s <em>DNA Double Helix</em> to Mendaleev’s <em>Periodic Table</em>. However, despite widespread agreement that visual communication can be essential to advancing science, the overall level of visual design in scientific communication (i.e., in figures, posters, and presentation) remains relatively low. I believe that the existing approaches to visual design education for researchers may be too limited, and that in order to be more effective, a more robust solution that encourages long-term self-education may need to be embedded in the natural working process of researchers and their research laboratories.</p><h4><strong><em>Hypothesis: Encouraging Critique in Research Labs</em></strong></h4><p>Considering my background in visual communication design, data visualization, and scientific communication, I think the key is to change the culture and attitude of researchers towards visual design, starting in their research laboratories. I believe that research labs are unique, collaborative environments that structure and sustain scientific progress and learning. These labs are hierarchical, meet weekly or biweekly, and already induce a certain level of critique, though this is seldom focused on the quality and communicative value of visuals.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gixL5brUmUcuEftBsYMd3Q.png" /><figcaption>Principle Investigators (PI) act as the lead researchers for laboratory studies or clinical trials</figcaption></figure><p>Specifically, I believe that learning to participate in visual design critiques could greatly improve a researcher’s attitude toward visual communication while also building their visual design skills. In short, by inducing critique culture in research labs, an entire lab group can collectively self-improve the quality of their visuals over time.</p><p>In order to teach effective visual critique skills to lab groups, I propose conducting a workshop and creating a series of tools and resources that help researchers to learn and remember visual principles and to give and receive visual feedback based on these principles. The workshop, tools and resources will be based on existing literature, interviews with sci-viz experts, and observations of the operation and structure of research lab groups. I plan to test this workshop and toolkit intervention on five lab groups at UW to see if it actually works — if it increases the skills and abilities of STEM researchers to produce effective visual designs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*10sd7uh_mVg7weUWa1gG3A.png" /><figcaption>UW 2021 MDes Poster Show: Research Progress</figcaption></figure><h4><em>Potential Solutions</em></h4><p>Considering the problem space and my research thus far, I want to propose a solution that is enduring and internal to research culture — an intervention that would be both realistic and able to more easily assimilate into scientific culture. I argue that it is important to create tools for researchers to learn, maintain, and self-critique the visual qualities of their work, so that design might become less of an extra obligation and more of a sustainable, organic step of the process. While there are existing interventions, these are often external, single-instance, or short-term efforts that are not reinforced once the participant leaves the workshop environment. Instead, I propose intervening in a way that would integrate easily with research process and procedure. This intervention would need to occur in an environment that can voluntarily sustain continuous practice and learning. Specifically, I propose intervening at the level of the research laboratory. Utilizing this environment, I hope to introduce a multi-step intervention that will include tools that encourage researchers to create and discuss visuals critically on an ongoing basis.</p><h4><em>Initial Research</em></h4><p>In order to find effective ways to create an initial workshop and future intervention, I conducted primary and secondary research through reading theoretical literature and related research, participated in expert interviews, and met weekly to observe four research laboratories.</p><p><strong>1. Secondary Research on the Scope of the Problem<br></strong>I began my research by reviewing related theoretical and research-based literature on the subjects of scientific visual communication, critique culture, and public perceptions of science. This research assists me in better framing the problem space, gaining an understanding of the successes and shortcomings of existing resources, and theorizing on new and potentially impactful solutions.</p><p><strong>2. Primary Research through Interviews<br></strong>I conducted expert interviews with four researchers and professionals who have practiced or participated in scientific communication training, including a Rice University Visual Communication and Design Instructor, an experimental physicist who specializes in creating scientific visualizations for STEM researchers, and a climate change post-Doctoral researcher who has taken visual design courses and organized design+science workshops. These interviews have given me further insight into the current status of scientific communication education — most significantly, what resources are currently popular, what labs I might reach out to, what has and hasn’t worked in the past, as well as what solutions might be more effective than others.</p><p><strong>3. Primary Research on the Setting/Laboratory Environment<br></strong>In order to determine what solutions and assets might be most conducive to laboratory environments, I connected with four laboratories across the University of Washington campus, which focus on biochemistry, ecoclimate, bioengineering, and chemistry. I have reached out to an additional lab and hope to connect with others during the winter quarter. Most labs meet weekly, with the exception of the bioengineering lab that meets every two weeks, and conduct sessions lasting between one and three hours. Thus far, I have attended four meetings of each lab. During laboratory meetings, I observe how laboratories currently operate, maintain internal structure and hierarchy, and conduct feedback-focused sessions. These observations help structure and frame my future intervention. I also occasionally observe a design course focused on introducing non-majors to introductory principles of visual design, in order to see what early design lessons are most important and effective.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iqGRj8zdebhPFZ3b-bG5fA.png" /></figure><h4><em>Lab Observation Findings</em></h4><p>Through conducting extensive lab observations, I have gained significant insight into researcher’s pain points and opportunities in visual design and will use this information to help frame my future intervention.</p><p><strong>1.</strong> Many researchers are openly interested in visual communication. They want to be able to talk about and improve their visuals and graphics, but often lack the skills to do so. And while there are some existing resources available, most researchers don’t seem aware of them. The availability of these resources is not adequately communicated to them, and even if researchers do find ways to participate, there are often no follow-up sessions or ways to assist them in retaining learning.</p><p><strong>2.</strong> Overall, researchers prefer ‘quick fix’ solutions to their design problems. They often don’t have time to commit to extensive, extracurricular training. Most researchers don’t seem interested in design theory or more open-ended solutions and instead prefer just being told what they can do to ensure consistently successful visuals, almost like a checklist.</p><p><strong>3.</strong> While most researchers appear to know that visual design and the communicative qualities of their work are important, they don’t seem to know how to best put this understanding into practice. When P.I.s [principle investigators] and students discuss improving their visuals and graphics, they veer towards hosting a single day workshop or session, often close to a submission deadline for an important deliverable. There is no continuous visual education or critique sustained throughout lab meetings when discussing research progress, although frustrations with the clarity of text and graphics are often brought up extraneously.</p><p><strong>4.</strong> When researchers present, they rely almost exclusively on graphics and diagrams to explain their work. There seems to be a general consensus across labs that having walls of text is an inadequate way to communicate research findings, however, these visuals are most often used as placeholders for detailed talking points or text. Most P.I. and peer feedback on presentation slides is centered on elaborating the meanings of different visuals. This suggests that the graphics are not effectively helping the researcher as a visual aid.</p><p><strong>5.</strong> When reviewing figures with the intention of improving them, the visual qualities of a graphic are seldom the focus. Most critiques concentrate on content, making sure that figures show all necessary information and intended concepts. While this may seem like a move in the right direction, most P.I. and peer suggestions focus on packing a figure with extra information, leading to issues with overcomplicating and over-explaining with a single figure, instead of perhaps using multiple related, but separate, figures.</p><h4><em>Future Directions (Next Steps)</em></h4><p>I will next use my gathered data, topical knowledge, and theory-based insights to develop what I hope to be an effective and enduring design intervention. In forming connections with four University of Washington laboratories, I’ve found myself with a unique design opportunity to create, refine, and ensure that the workshops and materials I create are effective, enduring, and interesting to both graduate and professional students and faculty.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XLMOi_wOuYSTab9WfF8gIg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Workshops</strong><br>In addition to surveying researchers, I will conduct workshops with the labs I’m observing in order to introduce them to visual communication design methods and principles. I hope to use these workshops as a form of research to glean what methods, lessons, and approaches are most helpful, retentive, and effective for researchers. These additional insights will be important in developing a final intervention, and I have already garnered research lab interest in these workshops. I have been (enthusiastically) invited to run visual communication workshops in all of the laboratories I’m observing. I will also be running a workshop at Engage, a UW Science Speaker Series and Seminar.</p><p><strong>Surveys<br></strong>Through observing research laboratories, I have informally gathered insights on how researchers currently utilize visual design in order to help shape my future intervention. In addition to these observations, I hope to formally survey research laboratories’ P.I.s and groups before and after my intervention in order to get a more concrete understanding of their baseline and post-observation experiences, resources, knowledge, and comfort in using visual communication principles. I will evaluate how researcher’s answers have changed between the before and after surveys and measure to what extent. While these surveys have been created, I haven’t been able to share them with researchers yet, having just been approved to do so after an IRB review. An IRB [Institutional Review Board] review entails the University of Washington Human Subjects Division evaluating the surveys to verify that they are an ethical form of research.</p><p><strong>Toolkit<br></strong>Based on my primary and secondary research, as well as the results of the workshops and surveys, I plan to create a comprehensive toolkit which will help research laboratories sustain and practice visual critique. This toolkit will be an essential part of my intervention, in that it will help foster ongoing visual critique without the presence or instruction of a designer. In order to better embed consistent visual design practice in research culture and laboratory procedure, this toolkit will contain a variety of materials and assets designed to help researchers learn critique methods and engage in constructive feedback sessions.</p><p><strong>Publication<br></strong>To summarize the results of my research, workshops, and surveys, I hope to write and publish an academic paper. This paper will cover my methods and contributions to the scientific communication community and explore the process, research, and reasoning behind the development of the scientific communication toolkit.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8fb65b1f9d04" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Visual Communication Design: The Poster as an Essential Asset for Future Protest Dialogues]]></title>
            <link>https://vsemouch.medium.com/visual-communication-design-the-poster-as-an-essential-asset-for-future-protest-dialogues-525db35c9b2d?source=rss-7bb49d0a049b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/525db35c9b2d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[poster-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[future-of-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[protest]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[visual-communication]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Vassilissa Semouchkina]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Dec 2019 20:36:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-18T20:36:26.212Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Introduction<br></strong>In 2013, I was active during a series of vibrant protests moving through the Russian Federation. These protests petitioned for the release opposition leader Mikhael Khodorkovsky from what was widely recognized as unlawful custody. As a visual communication designer, I wanted to use my skills to contribute what I could to the movement — I created a series of brochures and pamphlets. I distributed these with the intent of disseminating information about the issues at hand to the external public, both within the Russian Federation and the United States. While those protests proved successful, culminating in the release of Khodorkovsky in December 2013, I couldn’t help but wonder if I’d done enough, and if the small, self-instigated part I played really mattered. As a visual communication designer, I wanted to know if my contribution was actually effective, or simply the lost product of an isolated designer vying to help.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/1*ozvO9vIw4r-_T4ronBW7Ww.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>fig. 1</em> | Plague of Posters, M. Vedhan, 2015</figcaption></figure><p>My frustration with the nature of my involvement in the Free Khodorkovsky Movement is understandable. When creative media like posters are made in the vacuum of a designer’s own perception, and with the added detriment of having no concrete way to disperse the work effectively, the product will seldom reach the desired point of completion. I argue the success of protest poster design is an important factor of the triumph of social movements — while the death of protests can be attributed to a multitude of complex factors, I argue that a more thoughtful and methodical approach to protest poster design will bolster the effectiveness of future protests. Protest poster design methodology must evolve to match the quicksilver growth of contemporary protest movements. In this paper, I will look at four central principles gathered from researching past and recent protests: that poster design must have a strong, central visual identity; that poster design must be created internally through a collaborative and equitable process; that poster design must be collected and distributed by a generated central network that gathers and sort the work of participants; that poster design must hold public attention in order to prevent the death of movements through the consistent release of conceptually diverse and attention-grabbing work. In the age of the internet and click-based activism (clicktivism) (White, 2016, pg.123), it is more important than ever to think about the way in which protest posters are created, viewed, and distributed. In the words of Jorge Frascara, “The public must be made more aware of their basic rights and obligations. This awareness is now affected by the excessive noise created by the media, and by the lack of interest of most governments in long-term efforts, particularly when these have no consequence on immediate elections.” (Frascara, 1997, pg. 32) The design of posters can do more, and has in the past.</p><p>Visual communication design has long had ties to protest and political movements. (Triggs, 2011, pg. 2) As a tool used to disseminate ideas to the wider public, the products of a visual communication methodology are an asset in helping display ideas through bold and memorable visual formats. In both contemporary and past protests, these displays most often appear as banners, crudely made but vibrant and striking. Before the advent of the internet, posters and placards would often be plastered across walls, hoping to spark conversation and intrigue. The idea of using the wall as a space for visualizing ideas is prevalent and more popular than ever — where there was once a small number of distinct posters, there are now hundreds — political, cinematic, musical, graffiti-based, and more. (fig. 1) The visual noise created by this cacophony of posters is palpable and emphasizes the need for a change in strategy — protest posters must stand out from the chaos and must be created to command visual authority in an increasingly designed world.</p><p>In developing future strategies, it is vital to look at both the historic and contemporary use of placards and posters in successful and failed acts of revolt. Beginning with protests from the past 200 years and looking to the revolutionary placards and posters from both the period of the Great Fear of the French Revolution and the Russian Empire’s political uprisings of 1917, in which visual communication and verbal dissemination were key players in dissident information dispersal, I will introspect on the successes and failures of revolutionary imagery and how it might influence future posters to come.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/963/1*dJz-SD2iaPAqLlvWFurs7g.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>fig. 2</em> | Unité, Unknown, 1793–94</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Past Protest<br></strong>During the French Revolution of 1789, there began a significant redesign of the country’s political structure. (Lefebvre, 1973, pg. 35) Institutions of absolute monarchy and the existing feudal system were being reimagined — as these emerging ideas gained traction and spread, the people’s revolution grew. Discontent with the aristocratic class and a lack of transparency around the happenings of government culminated in the Great Fear (la Grande Peur), a period of widespread panic which is attributed as the start of the French Revolution and the eventual famed storming of the Bastille. (Lefebvre, 1973, pg. 169) Throughout the turmoil of the Great Fear, the distribution of posters and visual materials (fig. 2) became a way to effectively distribute dissident information. (Markoff, 1986, pg. 332) Posters communicated a sense of alarm and discontent to both large, more literate cities, as well as small villages and their peasants — these posters of revolt, as well as the people behind them, pushed civilians to take charge and stand up for their own freedoms. Occasionally, rebels even supported their claims by falsifying or exaggerating the information written on posters, unbeknownst to those who could not read or truthfully interpret their content. (Lefebvre, 1973, pg. 96–97)</p><p>Though this troubling fact taints the purity of intent, these protest placards, whether truthful or libelous, were effective in helping rally the discontented masses. With a significantly illiterate population, a highly representative aid was beneficial in acting to visualize specific ideas through a pictorial language, as a necessary compliment and asset to word-of-mouth dialogues (Markoff, 1986, pg. 332). The placard, therefore, became a tool for discourse. Through extensive distribution, placards were a poignant example of the mass production of posters around a singular concept, armed with the intent to dissipate information — there was even a notable report of posters appearing in Pérrone which were printed, as opposed to hand drawn like most. (Lefebvre, 1973, pg. 97) Placards, in the period of the Great Fear, were one of a group of important players working to bring together members of the working and marginalized classes under a common, if not occasionally hysterical, belief that things needed to change. The Russian Revolution of 1917, though taking place more than a century later and within a different country, echoed kindred principles.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*7fP1hDSJLkZTiDg3QDFh_A.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>fig. 3</em> | Parus Publishing, V. Mayakovsky &amp; A. Radakov, 1916</figcaption></figure><p>Leading up to the events of the Russian Revolution of 1917, there was a significant rise in posters and signage as a way to speak to and visualize the frustrations among working class citizens and serfs of the Russian Empire. (Jangfeldt, 2007, pg. 544) Many former serfs, soldiers, and low-level workers were frustrated by the perceived opulence and luxury of the Russian upper and middle classes. (Avilov, 2017, pg. 7–8) With Marxist ideology gaining traction, and minding the size of the Russian Empire, there came the issue of discreetly communicating a unifying message of dissent to a country that spanned almost half the globe. A major asset emerged in the advent of leftist publishing houses, which played a major role in the distribution of independent posters (fig. 3), poems, and zine-like publications. (Lenkhart, 2017, pg. 657)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HsGMNU6oGUsnLB8MwIWC7g.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>fig. 4</em> | Ukraine: Vote for the United Jewish Socialist Workers’ Party Unknown — Ne Boltai Collection, 1917</figcaption></figure><p>The posters from these publishing houses were translated into the Russian Empire’s different languages, such as Armenian, Georgian, and Hebrew, in order to be effectively distributed, often with culturally different yet interconnected visual elements. (fig. 4) (Lenkart, 2017, pg. 656) Posters were commonly circulated with messages expressing worker’s concerns and portraying a disillusionment with the aristocratic class, and would be easy to understand even without accompanying text. These story-like visuals helped create a narrative for the often-illiterate peasant class. (Avilov, 2017, pg. 8) The imagery was vivid and bright — reds, blacks, and pale cremes were a popular and memorable color scheme, and the hammer and sickle motif emerged to symbolize the working class. (fig. 3) Following the Russian Revolution itself, propaganda posters adopted the bright color scheme more uniformly and explicitly, using it to communicate a central message and identity for what would become the classic Soviet-era propaganda poster.</p><p><strong>The Follies and Successes of Past Protests<br></strong>In both these examples, protest posters and placards act as historical visualizations to look to when trying to understand and research revolutionary events. They communicate a message and an atmosphere — we can start to understand how people might’ve felt during various events through the appearance of line, color, and message. Visual mediums are a powerful way to express the voices of those without the agency or means to stand up for their values. In terms of both the early French and Russian Revolutionary periods, considering the atmosphere of the era is especially poignant — vivid protest posters and placards enable the viewer to visualize and experience some of the frustrations felt by past revolutionaries.</p><p>The reasons behind choosing these two examples, though rather different in nature and location, are because of the heavy visual presence and eventual success of both periods. In terms of the Great Fear of the French Revolution, the countrywide distribution of visualized written placards spurred a powerful reaction, even going so far as to use the peasant class’ illiteracy as a way to push an untruthful agenda. (Lefebvre, 1973, pg. 96–97) While the Great Fear is known to have partially been an instance of overreaction and miscommunication, the anger and fear which spearheaded the revolt were powerful and noteworthy. While this affect cannot be exclusively tied to revolutionary placards, the visualization of national unity and discontent were powerful mechanisms in spreading an emergent insurgent ideology.</p><p>The Russian Revolution of 1917 was one of the first revolutionary events defined by its attributed visual media. (Williams, 1977, pg. 4) The vivid contrasting color schemes, bold typefaces, and working-class design approaches helped create a centralized identity which assisted in cohesively communicating dissident messages widely and nonverbally. This distribution was assisted through the emergence of designated leftist publishing houses whose sole purpose was to dissipate new and growing Marxist propaganda. (Lenkhart, pg. 655, 2017) While the outcome of the Russian Revolution is highly controversial, the success and power of protest poster-based communication within the movement is undeniable.</p><p>Looking into the histories of protest posters and the way they helped shape revolutionary events is essential for analyzing and understanding contemporary protest movements. Spurred by new and growing demographics and technologies, contemporary protest poster design is no stranger to using posters as a tool for communicating agendas and garnering interest in social movements. However, in an increasingly digitized world full of designed spaces, the calls for protest must find new ways stand out in order to avoid being lost among a swarm of other visual information. (Bruinsma, 1999, pg. 301)</p><p><strong>Contemporary Protest<br></strong>The contemporary protest poster designer faces a wicked challenge — they must find ways to best lend themselves as assets to the causes they support, as well as to reach greater recognition and circulation of their work. While in an increasingly designed and finance-driven world, the solution to this problem is unclear, the additional analysis of the successes and failures of recently past contemporary movements could help unveil the direction towards a shift. The internet has accelerated information dissemination — ideas for protest emerge, conglomerate, and grow quickly, prompting designers who have the time and passion to swiftly generate rough yet noticeable visual representations in the midst of a fast-growing movement. These responses are valid — interesting, diverse, and desperate. However, while it is important to acknowledge the romance and humanity of spontaneity, this current approach to designing for protest does come with issues. There is a lack of cohesion; protests rarely have a central identity. Notable posters in the public eye often come from firms or established designers outside of the revolting masses, and movements seemingly grow and fade at breakneck speed. In looking at modern examples of protest, it is imperative to observe and reflect on contemporary movement structures, as well as analyze the aspects which can be improved.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*xCSr14PciW1JK0qW15hFhQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>fig. 5</em> | Occupy Wall Street, Adbusters, 2011</figcaption></figure><p>Occupy Wall Street was a protest movement which emerged explosively in September 2011. The protest grew quickly, spurred on by internet activism and the use of a unified, popular social media hashtag. The movement spoke out against economic inequality, proclaiming that the majority of the world’s finances were held by the wealthiest 1 percent of the population — in response, the movement took on the rallying cry, “we are the 99 percent”. (Gelder, 2011, pg. 1) In the words of its initiator, author and activist Micah White, “We released the idea of Occupy Wall Street on July 13, 2011, with a two-page tactical briefing and a surrealist poster of a ballerina balanced on the Wall Street Bull (fig. 5), a famous public sculpture near the financial district. Floating above the ballerina was a tantalizing question­­ — “What is our one demand?” In the smoky background, militant protesters linked arms and seemed to move toward the viewer. The ballerina-and-bull poster was inspired by a photograph by the conceptual artist Joan Fontcuberta purporting to show a mujahedeen balancing atop a donkey in Afghanistan… fearless, playful, revolutionary joy.” (White, 2016, pg. 14–15) This poster was distributed alongside gathering information for the Occupy movement, its popularity resulting in many of the movement’s poster variants congregating around the visual theme of the bull. (fig. 6) The movement was massive, drawing a significant amount of international attention and branching off into smaller subsets, such as Occupy The Farm, which protested development near Berkeley, and Occupy Sandy, which looked to establish a system to provide greater hurricane relief.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*VqxwYLfmqi2mhXZQXqV8jQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>fig. 6</em> | Occupy Wall Street: The Beginning is Near, A. Clotfelter, 2011</figcaption></figure><p>However, how much of this was due to the central motif of the ballerina poster? Designer Michael Beirut argues that “the ballerina didn’t matter. The bull didn’t matter. The headline didn’t matter. Only one thing mattered: that hashtag at the bottom.” (Bierut, 2012) However, I would argue that the effect was the product of a combination of the two — a powerful, short statement and a dynamically subversive poster. Regardless of whether the draw of Occupy Wall Street was a trendy hashtag or a surrealist poster, the bulk of the movement faded quickly in November 2011, with protesters being forced out of their central meeting space in New York and participants growing frustrated with the lack of a central ideology. (White, 2016, pg. 30)</p><p>White argues that this movement was not a total failure, but a constructive failure — “Occupy Wall Street failed to live up to its revolutionary potential: we did not bring an end to the influence of money on democracy, overthrow the corporatocracy of the 1 percent or solve income inequality… I call Occupy Wall Street a constructive failure because the movement revealed underlying flaws in dominant, and still prevalent, theories of how to achieve social change through collective action.” (White, 2016, pg. 26–27) Despite massive gatherings and a hefty collection of protest posters, Occupy Wall Street’s failure leaves room for analysis and introspection on how movements might maintain consistency and a strong, central voice in the age of the internet.</p><p>On July 1, 2019, massive protests erupted in Hong Kong on the anniversary of the city’s handover from British colonial rule to China. The protests, which had started in June and are ongoing, and considered pro-democracy and oppose an extradition bill which would “enable the [Hong Kong] chief executive and courts to handle fugitive transfer requests to jurisdictions where there are no prior agreements — such as China — without legislative oversight.” (Creery, 2019) On the first day of the protests, more than 550,000 demonstrators gathered. (Lam, 2019) These protestors were ready for vehement political opposition and even violence, though the focus of the event was peace and protestor turnout.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1YUhVwiPEsBC9oD7cIY3TQ.png" /><figcaption><em>fig. 7</em> | Me &amp; My Parents Go Protesting, J. Li &amp; V. Chan, 2019</figcaption></figure><p>With the numbers of participants and the riot police overwhelming and intimidating, some chose to support the protest’s cause through alternative mediums. In interviewing Hong Kong activist Atom Cheung, author Tiffany Lam describes Cheung as standing in the crowds on July 1, overwhelmed by the magnitude and listening in to others prepare for the riot police’s tear gas attack. Cheung, who is aged 39 and no longer felt particularly capable in confronting the police, was inspired to search for a different way to contribute to the movement against perceived authoritarian rule. He, along with other Hong Kong artists and designers, chose to respond to the demonstrations with an international exhibition: Freedom-Hi, whose “collection represents a different entry point for understanding the ongoing demonstrations in Hong Kong. …these pieces are meant to be a more intimate way into the protests, featuring titles like “Me &amp; My Parents Go Protesting.”” (fig. 7) (Lam, 2019) In addition to design exhibitions like Freedom Hi, protest posters are also circulated virally on the internet — and while free agents create their own work to distribute across social media, pro-democracy organizations emerging within Hong Kong, like Demosisto, centralize and disperse in-house designs (fig. 8) from within the heart of the movement.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/677/1*D3c5PRHiulwJVa6slV7ETA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>fig. 8</em> | Withdraw ELAB, Demosisto, 2019</figcaption></figure><p>Throughout the duration of the protest, posters appear frequently and with astonishing diversity, put out by both individuals and organizations, tied together with common slogans such as: “Oppose sending to China”, “One More Person”, “Defend Press Freedom”, and more. (Creery, 2019) The presence and voice of the people, as communicated through a visual medium, is loud in Hong Kong, transfiguring and evolving daily. While there are many messages and many sides to the Anti-ELAB protests, the frustration and vocal discontent of the people are both loud and palpable.</p><p><strong>Analysis<br></strong>In both Occupy Wall Street and the Anti-ELAB protests, the movements evolved and grew rapidly — they drew powerful reactions and attracted large amounts of participants. The movements were fueled by the belief that democratic governments are swayed by massive, urban, non-violent, and unified protests (White, 2016, pg. 25). However, with time, one of the protests simmered out, and the other is ongoing with no sign of the accused government budging.</p><p>While Occupy Wall Street and Anti-ELAB are historically massive in size, their effectiveness isn’t absolute, and desired responses aren’t guaranteed despite the volume of community voices. In the words of White, “Western democracies will not be swayed by public spectacles and mass media frenzy. Protests have become an accepted, and therefore ignored, by-product of politics as usual.” (White, 2016, pg. 27) I argue that this notion applies to more than just western democracies — in general, the world has grown to see protests, movements, and revolutions erupting in a cacophony of nations — most, if not all. Protests, while important, attention-grabbing, and public, are now expected. While technology has expedited the speed at which protests grow, I observe that the structure of the contemporary protest — in terms of massive gatherings and vocal opposition — are virtually the same as those of the past. In order to reinforce the power, authority, and effectiveness of the future protest, and keeping in mind that with a growing and diversifying population the amount of protests and subjective diversity will grow, the way social movements are staged must evolve and adapt.</p><p>To see where we must go from here, we must look to the past and present of protest and analyze failures and successes. In observing the French Revolution of 1789, the success could be attributed to the novelty, ferocity, and surprise of the revolt, stemming from the hysterical rise of fear in the countryside. (Lefebvre, 1973, pg. 163) However, using fear as a tactic for spreading information in a space of oral culture gave rise to false information, ultimately leading to further revolutions, violence, and public discord. (Lefebvre, 1973, pg. 73) For the Russian Revolution, the success can be attributed to the passionate aggression, vivid propaganda, and violence of the revolution. (Lenkart, 2017, pg. 655) While these factors also created a new kind of governmental distrust, the powerful, central Soviet identity was potently intimidating and difficult to challenge. While Occupy Wall Street possessed the excitement and rapid growth necessary for a successful movement, White attributes the national protest’s failure to a variety of factors — the fragmentation of the central message, protestor conflict, and an ultimate police raid on central meeting grounds. (White, 2016, pg. 30–32) And while the Anti-ELAB protests are vibrant, visual, and ongoing, the movement faces challenges of its own — governmental resistance and divided ideologies as peaceful and violent protestors separate into movement factions. (Hernández, Yu, 2019)</p><p>Though some of these issues are unfortunately unavoidable, post-protest analyses create opportunities to look into moments of failure and success, to understand the breaking points and climaxes of protests, and to create ground to work on them. It is hard to say for certain which methods are appropriate and truly applicable when considering the future, however, it is important to start the discussion and attempt to ideate possible solutions. The following strategies I present are formed out of reflecting on past and contemporary protest poster use and dispersal, as well as looking into the flaws and successes that carried them. The technology with which we make posters in the contemporary has evolved significantly — computer programs and websites make the creation of graphics simpler and faster, and available to almost anyone. The diversity of posters has also expanded, with formats, colors, and directions beyond what anyone would’ve anticipated 50 years ago. And while this progress allows a wider variety of contemporary creatives to produce both visually stunning and conceptually diverse work, this also highlights the visual saturation of the world. The thoughtful consideration and application of future poster media is essential in bringing forth poignant social issues, and must be carefully designed to stand out amongst the sheer quantity of existing posters.</p><p><strong>Central Visual Identity<br></strong>Within both the Anti-ELAB and Occupy Wall Street protests, issues arose in the absence of a cohesive, unified dialogue. While both protests began with a central idea, they splintered into differing factions and interest groups. While it can be argued that hosting and projecting a variety of ideas is important, within protests this process often creates a dialogue which is inconsistent and hard to follow. In the case of Occupy Wall Street, this fragmentation lead to the movement’s downfall. (White, 2016, pg. 26)</p><p>As the population of the world grows, and with that the nuance and diversity of ideas, I argue that it is imperative to maintain and push a central, uniting message in protest dialogues — this message must be enforced through protest poster design in the form of a central visual identity. Protest poster design should be cohesive, but not identical; the designed messages can be nuanced and derived from a central voice. In drawing inspiration from the posters of the Russian Revolution (fig. 3, 4), future protest posters should be connected through elements of color, stylistic approach, and mood. It is hard to argue that Soviet propaganda posters, while controversial in message, lacked a central, widely recognizable identity. This sense of place gives strength and cohesion to protest movements, while allowing for visual diversity. It is as important to emphasize identity through visual means as it is through verbal means.</p><p><strong>Unified Creative Network<br></strong>Protests draw in people from all walks of life, to come together and implore society to consider a central idea or problem. Protests thrive and capitalize on passion — when I participated in the 2013 ‘Free-Khodorkovsky’ demonstrations, I was enthusiastic and ready; I wanted to do all that I could to help. However, in creating brochures and pamphlets in the bubble of my own perception, I was generating work in a vacuum — while some people may have been drawn to the creativity of the materials I distributed, I was one person with a few brochures in a much greater, already-vocal crowd. My work, while visually engaging and displaying factual information, could’ve been more powerful had it been distributed through an official central publication network tied to the protest itself. Looking to the leftist publishing houses of the Russian Revolution (Lenkhart, 2017, pg. 655) and to the internal publishing of the Anti-ELAB protests (Creery, 2019), I argue that future protest posters must be collected and strategically dispersed both digitally and physically by emergent movement-specific distribution networks, whose purpose is the tactful dissemination of inter-movement visual and news media. The instigators of future protests must work to create spaces for collecting the work of involved artists and designers, in order to more effectively utilize the movement’s human assets through a centralized platform.</p><p><strong>Co-Design and Collaboration<br></strong>Creating spaces for designers to communicate personal ideas is the first step of a successful information dissemination process. When design firms are hired to create visual identities for protests, this externalizes the design of protest posters to a group who may not even be participating in the dialogues they’re creating for. Occupy Wall Street’s use of Adbusters is a poignant example — while the organization is focused on creating dissident works, they do so for a variety of causes in which they act as anti-capitalist observers, but not necessarily participants. (White, 2016, pg. 12) For a poster to truly represent the movement it belongs to, the work must be designed and ideated by individuals partaking in the movements — both designers and non. During the Russian Revolution, Vladimir Mayakovsky, a poet, and Alexei Radakov, an artist, created some of the movement’s most circulated posters through their collaboration within the leftist publishing house, Parus. (fig. 3) (Williams, 1977, pg. 137) The design of protest posters must be collaborative, allowing for designers and other participants to share and collectively ideate on the most effective mediums for visualizing important ideas. This co-design process (Sanders, Stappers, 2008, pg. 6) should be conducted as often as the hectic growth of a movement permits. Protest poster design should not be created by the designer in the lone context of their own perception, but rather be made together with non-designers in order to best capture and project an equitable and effective movement vision.</p><p><strong>Failure Prevention Through Attention<br></strong>The ultimate failure of a movement is in its death — death here referring to a movement that ends prematurely or without any real resolution. While the French and Russian Revolutions ended with the revolting groups’ desired shifts in power, Occupy Wall Street experienced an untimely and abrupt end, and even though the Anti-ELAB protests are ongoing, they are experiencing their share of challenges. While there are many difficulties that movements can face in their attempted path towards success, in the contemporary, I observe a critical reason for failure: the loss of public interest and visibility, and the corresponding movement’s dissolution by existing governments and forces. Public interest can be lost for a variety of reasons, however in terms of protest poster design, I argue that the stagnation of visual communication and the output of new media are major contributors. In the case of Occupy Wall Street, the fragmentation of the cohesive central idea and the lack of a clear end goal ultimately lost the public eye. (Bierut, 2012) Oftentimes, a movement is documented extensively by the news and internet media during its initial occurrence, and fades from public attention as global media loses interest and directs attention to other, newer stories. In considering future poster design methodologies, I argue that protest posters must be methodically produced and released to the public in order to help maintain a consistent visual energy and garner continual attention. A lack of attention, and therein public support, is the ultimate nail in the coffin for contemporary protest movements.</p><p>In looking at past and contemporary examples of placard and poster design within protest movements, I have theorized four central ideas in helping boost the effectiveness of future protest posters: protest posters must push a united message supported by a central visual identity; protest posters must be shared, accepted, and developed in a dominant publication network; protest posters must be ideated and created collaboratively by teams of designers and non-designers involved in the movement; protest posters need to be released consistently and innovatively in a way which helps keep public attention on the movement. As the global population grows and national cultures change and evolve, protests are bound to occur with increasing frequency. With this in mind, helping protests maintain their effectiveness as a vessel for the will of the people is imperative — free and public speech are the essence of a democratic society. Protest posters have a large and valuable part to play in this discussion and are one of the many factors of contemporary protests which must be strengthened in order to help push public revolts into a more successful future.</p><p><strong>Conclusion<br></strong>Poster design is a popular field in the contemporary age. Bright, colorful, and diverse, the medium presents a wide variety of ways in which to represent products, opinions, and more. However, poster design is a multidimensional field that pushes beyond mere aesthetic — it has a rich history tied to the public expression of ideas, both the anodyne and controversial. In the contemporary, the use of posters in protest is widely applicable, however, I would argue that posters can have a greater affect and that protest poster designers can better utilize the medium’s inherent power. As society charges forward into the future, it will be evermore important to change the way we think about protest and protest posters. Through new and evolving methodologies, the future techniques for designing protests posters must amplify their effectiveness, create stronger and more successful movements, and enforce the voice of the public.</p><p>—</p><p><strong>Bibliography<br></strong>Avilov, R. S., &amp; Сергеевич, А. Р. (2017). From Soldiers’ Illiteracy to Revolutions: Low Soldiers’ Educational Level as one of the Causes of the Russian Revolutions of 1917. RUDN Journal of Russian History, 16(1), 7–19. doi.org/10.22363/2312–8674–2017–16–1–7–19</p><p>Beirut, Michael. (2012, April 30). The Poster that Launched a Movement (Or Not). Design Observer. Retrieved from designobserver.com/feature/the-poster-that-launched-a-movement-or-not/32588</p><p>Bruinsma, Max. (1999). An Ideal Design Is Not Yet. ten Duis, Leonie, Annelies Haase, ed. The World Must Change. Amsterdam: The Sandberg Instituut, pp. 301.</p><p>Creery, Jennifer. (2019, July 25). Wilting Bauhinias and Widemouthed Tigers: The Evolution of Hong Kong’s Protest Posters. Hong Kong Free Press HKFP. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.hongkongfp.com/2019/07/25/wilting-bauhinias-widemouthed-tigers-evolution-hong-kongs-protest-posters/">www.hongkongfp.com/2019/07/25/wilting-bauhinias-widemouthed-tigers-evolution-hong-kongs-protest-posters/</a></p><p>Frascara, Jorge, et al. (1997). User-Centred Graphic Design: Mass Communication And Social Change. CRC Press.</p><p>Gelder, Sarah Van, and Yes! Magazine. (2011). This Changes Everything: Occupy Wall Street and the 99% Movement. Berrett-Koehler Publishers.</p><p>Hernández, Javier C., and Elaine Yu. (2019, Dec. 8). Hong Kong Protests: Hundreds of Thousands Turn Out for Largest March in Weeks. The New York Times. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/07/world/asia/hong-kong-protests-us-chamber-commerce.html">www.nytimes.com/2019/12/07/world/asia/hong-kong-protests-us-chamber-commerce.html</a></p><p>Jangfeldt, Bengt. (2014). Mayakovsky: A Biography. University of Chicago Press.</p><p>Lam, T. (2019, Fall). Freedom Hi: When the tear gas clears, Hong Kong’s masses of protesters remain strong. So do their zines. Broken Pencil, (85), 12+. Retrieved from link-gale-com.offcampus.lib.washington.edu/apps/doc/A602462642/ITOF?u=wash_main&amp;sid=ITOF&amp;xid=6993aa7</p><p>Lefebvre, Georges. (1973). The Great Fear of 1789; Rural Panic in Revolutionary France. [1st American ed.], Pantheon Books.</p><p>Lenkart, J. (2017). Russian Revolutions in Print: The Fate of the Ethnic Press. Slavic Review, 76(3), 655–663. doi:10.1017/slr.2017.173</p><p>Markoff, John. (1986). Literacy and Revolt: Some Empirical Notes on 1789 in France. American Journal of Sociology, vol. 92, no. 2, pp. 323–49.</p><p>Sanders, Elizabeth B. N., and Pieter Jan Stappers. (2008, Mar.). Co-Creation and the New Landscapes of Design. CoDesign, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 5–18. Taylor and Francis+NEJM, doi:10.1080/15710880701875068.</p><p>Triggs, T. (2011). Graphic Design History: Past, Present, and Future. Design Issues, 27(1), 3–6.</p><p>White, Micah. (2016). The End of Protest: A New Playbook for Revolution. Alfred A. Knopf Canada.</p><p>Williams, Robert. (1977). Artists in Revolution: Portraits of the Russian Avant-garde, 1905–1925. Indiana University Press.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=525db35c9b2d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>