<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by victoria waddle on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by victoria waddle on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@waddleido?source=rss-2074a784ab2c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 13:11:06 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@waddleido/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What’s the Point of a Book Review?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@waddleido/whats-the-point-of-a-book-review-f7bce354e5ed?source=rss-2074a784ab2c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f7bce354e5ed</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books-and-authors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authorship]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[victoria waddle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 10 Oct 2021 03:10:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-10T03:10:33.421Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GtY8VgpkIKYb7dC8gKsjDg@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>CC licensed from rawpixels.com</figcaption></figure><p>The book review star rating system is meaningless. The sole purpose of a book review is to inform the potential buyer about the contents of books. A good review allows that buyer to know if the book being reviewed is one they’re looking for. The object of a review is neither to support nor attack the author. One that does is not worth reading.</p><p>I recently wrote about a <a href="https://victoriawaddle.com/2021/09/16/book-reviews-cancel-culture-and-sex-cults/">kerfuffle</a> over an author’s response to a book review — one that caused a pile-on of GoodReads reviewers giving one-star reviews to a book they hadn’t read. These indignant folks did so as a way to support the bruised reviewer. The story is complicated by the facts that:</p><ul><li>the reviewer had been very positive about the book.</li><li>the (Twitter famous and bestselling) author was punching down — always a bad idea.</li><li>the author’s upbringing and childhood trauma might have affected her response.</li></ul><h3><strong>Forget the Stars</strong></h3><p>Think about it: Amateur — and sometimes professional — book reviewers don’t follow any particular standards. We all have different criteria for the stars given. Those stars are essentially meaningless.</p><p>I wish all review sites would eliminate the option of giving stars to books, so reviewers would stick to writing about what works, what doesn’t work, and why.</p><p>I often see reviewers give three stars to books they truly enjoyed because those books are not literary masterpieces. They feel it’s not fair to treat a who-done-it like a literary classic, and so three stars is a great review. But the thing is, most books are not attempting to be literary masterpieces. And a book with a review average of three stars will be passed over by readers. I have often reviewed books that would never have been reviewed by professionals in trade journals — books that have no literary significance, will never be bestsellers, and whose authors are virtually unknown. I do this because I think there are readers who have need of all sorts of reviews. Reviewers who give crappy three-star reviews, and then follow the three stars with all the reasons they enjoyed the book, are helping neither readers nor authors.</p><h3><strong>Think of a Book’s Purpose</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/232/1*Op5sknXyMN00mMxKLIewug.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/243/1*xioL98lhjVeMsLC9VbsQOA.jpeg" /></figure><p>A good example of a type of book that isn’t professionally reviewed is the ‘hi-lo’ for teens who have below-grade-level reading skills. Many books written at low lexile levels have subject matter meant to appeal to teens. Lots of teachers and librarians want to know which of these titles their students will enjoy. I’ve reviewed this sort of book in the past. (Here are <a href="https://schoollibrarylady.com/2014/10/31/orca-soundings-tell-lockdown-and-jacked/">three reviews </a>in one post. Here’s one with a <a href="https://schoollibrarylady.com/2017/11/25/orca-limelights-the-frail-days/">female main character</a>.)</p><p>Other books I enjoy reviewing often have a niche audience and a Southern California focus.</p><h3><strong>Straight-up Unfair Book Reviews</strong></h3><p>Another problem I’ve seen is reviewers reducing the number of stars for a review of a good book when it’s not the book the reviewer wanted to read. (Well, okay, I’ve seen professional reviewers do this as well.) For me, that’s a ‘get over it’ situation. Worse, I’ve seen one-star reviews because books arrived in the mail with the cover bent. To think that an author may have toiled over a piece for years only to have its rating dropped over something that has nothing to do with the quality of the writing — and something they have no control over — is deeply unfair.</p><p>Most terrible of all are the trolls who haven’t read the book but have a grudge against the author. This is the case mentioned in the first paragraph. I’ve also seen it happen to feminist books. A good example is Julie DiCaro’s Sidelined: Sports Culture and Women, which I reviewed <a href="https://schoollibrarylady.com/2021/03/24/sidelined-sports-culture-and-women/">here</a>.</p><h3><strong>I’m Easy</strong></h3><p>I tend to write a lot of five-star reviews, including for books that are far from literary masterpieces. Because I think reviews should answer this question: did the book meet its goals? So, if we look back at the hi-low teen books: does this easy read appeal to teens who are struggling with a second language? Do they come back to the library to get a second book from the series? Goal met. Five stars.</p><p>Apply this rating system to all books. A who-done-it with enough red herrings and a real culprit who is active enough in the book that the reader might be able to guess who they are? Five stars. Inspirational books that do inspire? Five stars. How-to books that helped you make a significant change? Yup.</p><p>So, honestly, it’s the star rating system that’s the problem. The system makes it seem like every book receiving five stars is a treasure to be passed down to the grandkids. I don’t eternally treasure most of the books I give five stars. After I read them, I promptly give them away to my book club, or donate them to the <a href="https://www.claremontforum.org/prison-library-project/">Prison Library Project</a> or my local library for their used-book sale. Goal achieved. Onward and upward.</p><h3><strong>You May Say I’m a Dreamer</strong></h3><p>If we just skipped the stars and wrote a few paragraphs about what we feel the book’s goals are and whether they’re achieved, we would be giving truly useful information to the reader of the review. All authors deserve better than snap judgments.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f7bce354e5ed" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Realty]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@waddleido/realty-91b0c11c7a24?source=rss-2074a784ab2c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/91b0c11c7a24</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mwc-space]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[california]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wildfires]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[environment]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[victoria waddle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 22 Aug 2021 02:35:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-22T02:35:03.435Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RnZdjM14dv0yQjFFTsg1Zw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Claremont Hills Wilderness Park (photo by Victoria Waddle)</figcaption></figure><p>My first escapes began at age five. With no paintings on the walls (my parents worried about nail holes) and no stereo (there was no room for it), my childhood home might have been a metaphor for a hallucinatory chamber of sensory deprivation. That is, if I had been an only child.</p><p>However, with seven of us in 1200 square feet, the only aloneness to be had was in the closet, behind my five school dresses and those of my two sisters.</p><p>Once allowed to rove the neighborhood on my own, I favored the elementary schoolyard caddy-corner across the street, easily accessible through a gate secured only with a chain. Every day I squeezed between it and the red brick wall of the building, launching myself past the blacktop toward the field. In lonesome enactments of dungeon escapes, I was both the captive in her pink silk gown and the rescuing hero.</p><p>I grew out of my medieval captive-hero fantasies just as my parents jumped counties to move to a four-square-mile city, a self-satisfied enclave of conservatism that was the exemplar of Ronald Reagan’s quip: Orange County is where the good Republicans go before they die. My own emerging values persistently pulled me in another direction, and though I found a few lifelong friends, I, who sewed all my own clothes, was never comfortable in a school where privileged classmates took ski vacations in the winter and spent spring break in Honolulu.</p><p>The last thing I wanted to do was repeat my parents’ journey. I became a high school teacher and found a soulmate, one who also felt a need to dedicate his life to social good and believed education was the key to success for young people from all backgrounds. Which is to say, we were pretty idealistic.</p><p>When David and I decided to purchase a home together, I realized I did have something in common with my parents: a continual striving to escape my surroundings, to move toward a space that nurtured and comforted me.</p><p>I began my quest during those Reagan years, a time when home loan interest rates increased so rapidly that buyers were not given the option to lock in. In 1984, the average interest rate, down from nineteen percent the year before, hovered at just under fourteen percent. Though David and I both worked full time, our teacher pay was lousy. Like many people needing money, we couldn’t afford to borrow it.</p><p>Our opportunity came through a low-income condominium complex in Long Beach with a special loan rate of nine percent. In order to qualify, the buyer’s income couldn’t exceed $40K. Ironically, if the potential buyer made less than that, there would be no way to make the payments. Our combined income just met the mark, though to qualify, we paid for mortgage insurance, our down payment being less than twenty percent.</p><p>During the first year, despite our luck in earning exactly the top income that would qualify, I could only make my part of the payments by dipping into savings. In a second stroke of good luck, our school district raised our salaries by twenty percent the following year, not because they valued the work of their teachers, but because pay was so low that when enrollment increased, no new teachers applied. We had our thousand square feet, our tiny balcony with a power line cutting into its corner, and our own stacked washer and dryer. Our gamble having paid off, we looked confidently toward our future and married in 1985. Three years later, our first son arrived.</p><p>Still, we dreamed of a nurturing space. Parking was a nightmare, and I frequently got tickets for having my car on the wrong side of the street on street sweeping days. We had been sternly warned by the homeowners association not to encourage panhandling outside the building, asked to ignore real people with real troubles.</p><p>The complex was between the on and offramps for the 710 freeway. Traffic was so loud we couldn’t open the windows, but depended on a table fan to keep us cool enough to sleep. Drunks regularly slammed into cars lining 7th Street, and then fled — except when so deeply embedded into the parked vehicles that no amount of gunning the engine extricated them. Although fresh air was shut out, the screams of fighting couples came through the closed windows. One night, David and I stood at the window dialing 911 as we saw a man trying to cut another man in half with giant bolt cutters. My childhood fantasy of escape was rekindled. After the birth of our son, I wanted a yard for the baby and ached for trees and grass.</p><p>In 1989, interest rates on home loans were running above nine percent. Though David and I were still teaching full time, we’d both entered grad school, I for a master’s in English, he for a PhD in counseling psychology. Despite our tuition costs, we patched together a down payment for a house being built in Ontario, a San Bernardino County city, one adjacent to the largest dairy preserve in the country. People from Orange County loved to ridicule this section of Southern California, referring to it as “the 909” — the area code — as a pejorative to dismiss a diverse and growing population. But it was close to David’s aging parents, a consideration that was beginning to matter, yet still within twenty-five miles of my mom and dad. Despite the fact that the smell of cow dung was ubiquitous and flies danced in every square foot of atmosphere, there was a line of people waiting for the builder to open sales. David queued while I stayed with the baby.</p><p>He called me midday. “We bought a house,” he said.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gqkae8dmydhLEKUz3tgmNg.jpeg" /><figcaption>photo by Rawpixel (used with permission)</figcaption></figure><p>We painted and decorated and eventually filled the home with three boys. Though we had a yard — the very reason for being there — the flies were far too thick for a summer barbeque or picnic, the experience, an audition for <em>Fear Factor</em>. For the first time, I understood clearly how human choice degrades the environment.</p><p>Fly excrement covered cars and patio furniture. The smell could often be overwhelming, but when I was pregnant, it was debilitating. Every morning, when I went to the preschool to drop off my older sons, I was overcome as soon as I opened the car door. I would dip as low to the ground as I could, quietly puking. Sometimes, my sons would shout. “Mom’s throwing up!” and other mothers, also dropping off their kids, would look at me and then away — I hoped out of respect and not repulsion. Perhaps they had been there.</p><p>In commercials, California cows dig the sunshine and clover. In truth, there’s no clover, but they do play a game I call ‘Queen of the Dung Heap,’ where one stands atop the highest pile of manure and defends her position.</p><p>I’d known for a few years that it takes 5,000 gallons of water to produce a pound of hamburger, and that each year, a cow belches 220 pounds of methane. I’d stopped eating beef because the local effects of the cows — out of sight, out of mind for most people — were a harbinger of our climate future. Like many Americans without directives, we still believed we could escape permanent damage with simple changes to human activities. We cut down plastics, followed water-saving tips, and when appliances had to be replaced, looked for the most energy efficient. I dragged the boys to recycle aluminum and glass.</p><p>Passing the years next to the diary preserve, in 2000, we saw a light at the end of the climate change tunnel. Al Gore understood the reality of a warming world and would lead the fight against it.</p><p>Instead, with the country in crisis, the Supreme Court ruled George W. Bush would be president, pushing environmental issues to the back burner. My idealism waning, but still intact, I couldn’t imagine a less serious, less intellectual leader. Having hit bottom, our only direction was up.</p><p>Though I believed time remained to course correct on climate action, my own environment had become untenable. Adjacent to 330,000 cows and the millions of pounds of manure they produced daily, we were breathing the worst air in the country. My middle son had sinus problems. My youngest had asthma. Running away from a major cause of climate change wasn’t an answer. Neither was living in it.</p><p>Money being ever the issue, we remained next to the dairy preserve. During the recession of the early 1990s, the housing market plummeted. For a time, our place was worth far less than we’d paid. This was our life, and, unless we left education for more lucrative careers, it would always be so. At the twelve-year mark, having the chance to play outside seemed as far off as ever. But in 2001, we had another stroke of luck. The housing market hadn’t fully recovered, and the price of more expensive homes dropped. Interest rates followed, plummeting to half of what we’d originally paid. We set our hearts on a mid-century modern neighborhood in a nearby city, known for its excellent private colleges, its homey craftsman bungalows, its small town vibe, and its commitment to trees and natural spaces.</p><p>We stretched as far as our reach could grasp and bought a house in the foothills of the San Gabriel Mountains. Two months later, the market was back up. It was as if we had leapt through a dream portal just as it closed. We remained near enough to visit most of our numerous siblings, to spend holidays with our extended clans, and to care for our parents as they aged.</p><p>Built in 1964, our new home was a model of eccentricity. In a bathroom sized for gnomes, I knocked the shower door open when I raised my arms to wash my hair. In the master bedroom, a wallpaper path made its way from bed to ceiling, acting as a headboard. The den walls were textured with straw. Popcorn ceilings sparkled. The white carpet throughout had pathways trodden black and was moldy in the bathrooms. The external light fixtures rivaled those of a Harry Potter movie — huge, wrought iron, with a medieval flair.</p><p>But outdoors! A pool. A patch of grass. The slope of the foothill meant the neighbor behind us was also above us. I would no longer look out a window into someone else’s bedroom.</p><p>Hummingbirds loved both the trumpet flowers and the lemon tree. The mockingbirds sang; the finches flitted in and out. An occasional deer strolled on the slope as did the more frequent coyotes, who hid in the shade during midday heat. Periodically, a bear lumbered by.</p><p>A walk straight up the neighborhood artery took me into a designated wilderness area. It had the peculiar, parched charm of inland Southern California: chaparral with sage, scrub brush, live oaks, and Jeffrey pines. The steep hills, covered in long grasses, were often brown and gray. A frequently dry creek bed was the victim of persistent drought.</p><p>This pinpoint on the map of my existence held no grandeur. Yet I found many angels dancing there. It became my deepest source of both physical and spiritual renewal. Hiking with my wolfish dog, I felt I’d become the hero of my childhood fantasies, having rescued myself through hard work and persistence.</p><p>I sparked with happy recognition at the landmarks — the little pine hikers decorated with Christmas bulbs in December, the stand of oaks in the pasture. A space for walking meditation, I sometimes centered on its sights and smells; at others, I focused on an audiobook. But always, I wove myself into the landscape. In the open-air solitude I’d craved since I was five, at times I blurted out, “I love you,” overcome with emotion for the landscape, for the worn path of my very local travels.</p><p>Back home again, I’d release the dog to the fenced-in yard. Periodically, the bear was nearby, and, barking as if possessed, Fletcher drove it up the tallest pine tree — the one that survived the Grand Prix Fire a year after we’d moved in.</p><p>***</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZLLVviQZv_6I3XH-R17qKA.jpeg" /><figcaption>photo by Victoria Waddle</figcaption></figure><p>Our dinner venue had to be moved. That was my first reaction to the Grand Prix Fire, which was nearing a friend’s home, twelve miles from my own. Katina and I had planned to have dinner with a third friend, Marla, to celebrate Marla’s return visit to Southern California after moving to the state of Washington. A trio of chatting and catching up, we made plans, over the phone, to meet at a local restaurant — out of the way of fire personnel, their trucks and equipment. But as dinnertime neared, I received a second call. Katina was evacuating and would spend the night at her brother’s. I offered my spare bed to Marla and went to Katina’s to retrieve her.</p><p>Following fire trucks up the road, I couldn’t enter Katina’s street, instead meeting my friends further down the hill. “Don’t worry,” I reassured Katina. “We went through this last year.” The hills behind our separate neighborhoods had already burned, but no homes across that long stretch had ever been lost to wildfire.</p><p>At 1:00 AM, I heard sirens and a voice over a bullhorn demanding immediate evacuation. The fast-moving Grand Prix had ‘wicked’ through an unburned route and found its way to my neighborhood. We grabbed a few clothes. Marla pulled pictures off the walls and threw photo albums in the car. David and I went outside. Whipped by Santa Ana winds, Grand Prix flames leapt 200 feet into the sky, setting up a wall of fire just outside our neighborhood. We squeezed everyone into the cars, putting Fletcher across the kids’ laps, knowing we weren’t coming back that night, and possibly not at all.</p><p>After dropping Marla off at a hotel and settling the kids at David’s parents’, we returned to watch the fire from a safe distance. Late into the night, the flames moved in three directions around our house — from the north, the south and the east. Its most aggressive front moved west to our street.</p><p>There would be no helicopters dropping water, night work being unsafe for them. Yet I wondered why not a single fire truck had responded in those first hours. I later learned none were available. As we squinted through the ash at the wall of flame, I called my mom. “I think our house is gone.” I folded in half. She joined me in grieving.</p><p>With winds whipping around us at fifty miles an hour, we turned away, hopeless. I thought of all the things I should have taken, items stitched and quilted, journals detailing the lives and growth of our three children — but there had been no time.</p><p>Hours later, when it was light, we stood outside the barricade to see that some of the houses had burnt to the ground, but many had survived. Fire crews and smoke jumpers were there, having arrived right after we left. However, we were not allowed in. Seeing smoke coming off our street, we waited to attend a community meeting at the local high school, after which we would be released to view our homes.</p><p>“When you go back, there will be things you won’t like,” the fire chief began. “But all of you are here. That’s what’s important.” Yes, we were all safe, and the room erupted in gratitude for the heroics of the firefighters. In such an inferno, some had come from as far away as San Francisco, arriving late to find dry and low-pressure hydrants due to power outages that had affected the water pumps in our area. Having resorted to pumping water from swimming pools, they now bowed to a standing ovation.</p><p>A neighborhood of fifty-four homes in a nearby canyon had been destroyed overnight. The firefighters had arrived to 100-mile-per-hour winds, an unmanageable situation. Yet residents were critical of them. When attendees objected, one woman said, “Well, you didn’t lose your homes. We did!”</p><p>The mood of community and celebration had been snapped. We walked out as separate families to assess individual losses.</p><p>Flashlight in hand, David and I stepped into what appeared to be a fireplace, the smell of smoke and the black clouds dense around us. But there was the house, fully intact.</p><p>As we moved through the yard inspecting by flashlight beam, we saw where the firefighters had tossed the patio furniture, its webbing having been melted by falling embers. A tree in the dog run had caught fire, bringing flames into our yard. I stood over a very large pile of ash, asking, “Why is all this here?”</p><p>“It was the dog house,” David answered. We turned to look at the windows to the kids’ rooms and saw that the wood around them had been singed.</p><p>That we were lucky was beyond question. The rain of ash disappeared a few weeks later. But fire threat from a warming climate and its resulting permanent drought has engulfed the Southwest ever since. Vast regions of California are currently on fire.</p><p>The year following the Grand Prix Fire, our neighborhood paid a goatherd to bring his animals into the hills where they consumed the invasive mustard plants that would be tinder. Over time, we replaced our worn out cars with hybrid and electric. We xeriscaped our yard to save water. These solutions seem hopelessly naive now.</p><p>As I write this, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change released a report indicating we’re too far gone to reverse the consequences of global warming we now experience. If governments and the private sector from around the world work very hard, we can slow change, allowing us more time to adjust, and an opportunity to avoid further calamity. In view of the past eighteen months and society’s unwillingness to work together through a world-altering pandemic, I worry about our odds.</p><p>My kids have grown. Coming into adulthood in a period of skyrocketing housing prices, a pandemic, and perpetual wildfires, they see no future for themselves in this region where their forebears lived for generations. When David and I reminisce about the hardscrabble journey that landed us in a nurturing space, they can’t see such a result for themselves, hard work or no. They see a historical route that has been burned away.</p><p>I still imagine my adult children in a nurturing environment, but I’m decades from the young woman who believed she could alter the world with idealism and hard work. It takes effort not to imagine the butterfly of hope at the bottom of Pandora’s box being replaced with the beetle of existential dread. Yet to give in to climate despair guarantees failure.</p><p>Inside my kitchen pantry, persistently visible, I have my list of what to grab during evacuations. It begins with people and dogs, moving on to treasured but inessential things. It avoids the larger question: where do we escape to? I know the answer lies not in the juvenile fantasy of the power of my own actions but in the solidarity that comes with shared objectives. As aptly put by James Baldwin, “Not everything that is faced can be changed, but nothing can be changed until it is faced.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=91b0c11c7a24" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Perfectly Constructed YA Novel — Victoria Waddle]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@waddleido/the-perfectly-constructed-ya-novel-victoria-waddle-534edf1d5ff4?source=rss-2074a784ab2c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/534edf1d5ff4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[writing-tips]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ya-literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writers-on-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ya-fiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[victoria waddle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Sep 2020 23:31:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-12T01:09:06.696Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The Perfectly Constructed YA Novel — Victoria Waddle</h3><p>Meg Medina’s <em>Burn, Baby, Burn</em> is an example of A perfectly constructed YA novel. It’s great storytelling. This didn’t surprise me as I’d loved Medina’s <a href="https://schoollibrarylady.com/2014/07/07/yaqui-delgado-wants-to-kick-your-ass/"><em>Yaqui Delgado Wants to Kick Your Ass</em>.</a> I’d recommend <em>Burn</em> to any teen looking for a good read. I’d also recommend it to any writer looking for an example of a perfectly-constructed novel. It’s a particularly good choice right now because the world Medina recreates has many of the same issues we struggle with today.</p><h3>Great Storytelling</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/525/0*DUbBa2WcnnWjqYtQ" /><figcaption><em>Burn, Baby, Burn is a book to be digested. Note: Medina mentions that Nora and her best friend, Kathleen, collect buttons with slogans. During the period that the book takes place, I also collected and wore buttons. I thought it would be fun to bring out a few that remind me of the book and of Nora, because they fit the ideas and themes of the book.</em></figcaption></figure><p><em>Burn</em> has great characters, plotting, and pacing. Medina achieves this trifecta by creating a sort of Venn diagram of three overlapping problem areas, each with stakes for the protagonist, Nora López. While most writers introduce these three problem areas-societal, close-to-home, and romantic-Medina maintains the stakes for the protagonist in all three areas throughout. Her ability to keep each one in the foreground throughout the novel assures that all the important characters are well developed. Plotting and pacing rely on this balancing act, so when done well, the story moves as it should.</p><p>Nora is a high school senior living in Queens (New York City) during the spring and summer of 1977. That’s a tough place to be at that time. The city appears to be on fire with frequent arson and blackout incidents, followed by looting. There is constant heat and racial tension. A serial killer is on the loose and targeting young girls. In addition, Nora is shouldering too much responsibility for her dysfunctional family. She hopes that turning eighteen and getting out on her own will be the answer to her problems. She and her best friend, Kathleen, budding feminists, want to be free to dance and fantasize about the deceased TV star Freddie Prinze. But Nora is adrift about future plans and has very little money, despite having a part-time job at the local deli. Her first experience in love was a disaster. But when Nora meets Pablo, a new coworker at the deli, she is smitten. However, Nora is unable to share her family troubles with either Kathleen or Pablo, as this feels like an act of betrayal. Her silence creates distance from those she needs most.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/525/0*fRSbUG8wn2s44Zt0" /><figcaption><em>Nora is a big fan of disco music and dancing. I’m afraid I didn’t relate.</em></figcaption></figure><h3>Societal Problems</h3><p>An infamous serial killer known as ‘Son of Sam’ was on the loose in New York City for the year in which the novel takes place. Nora and Kathleen, as well as Kathleen’s parents, are afraid every time the teens leave the house because Son of Sam kills young girls. The girls’ fears intersect with their dating lives: Son of Sam kills couples who are making out in cars. Nora continually has this in mind:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/525/0*7BPlhMo6f0Fc8lVf" /><figcaption><em>The intersection of the three problem areas show a chaotic world, one the author must resolve.</em></figcaption></figure><p>“I think sheepishly of Mima [Nora’s mom], who always tells me not to walk this way alone, especially not at night. A thousand times she’s warned me, and I always sneer at her dramatic lectures about this patch of weeds and broken glass, about the dark corners where a girl could be pushed, dragged off to the dead end, and then God Knows What. It has always seemed so stupid, so Mima. But now . . .”</p><p>Though plainclothes police women hang around the neighborhood, Nora doesn’t feel any safer. “Fake lures don’t fool the prize fish you’re trying to catch. It’s always the real worm, hopelessly writhing on the hook, that draws what you want from the dark.”</p><h3>Close-to-home Problems</h3><p>Nora’s close problems center on family life with Mima and Hector, Nora’s brother. Equally important is her father, Papi, who is utterly outside her family life.</p><p>Nora lives with her mother and her brother Hector in their small apartment in Queens. Nora shares a bedroom with Hector. Yet her father lives with his new wife and new son in a high rise with a doorman-in greater safety than his first family. He rarely speaks to his older kids and is often late in paying their rent. Meanwhile, the son he has with his new wife goes to “private kindergarten for geniuses.” Even though he ignores his older kids, everyone tiptoes around him. Nora’s mom never speaks to him but commandeers Nora’s mediation.</p><p>“My parents haven’t spoken directly since the day they signed their divorce papers. Guess who’s their messenger pigeon?”</p><p>Papi says over and over that rent checks are lost in the mail. Nora pretends to believe him. Papi has no idea how anything is going including Hector’s bad and even criminal behaviors at school and at home. Meanwhile, Nora’s relationship with her mother is complicated by the silence surrounding Hector’s problems and Mima’s endless judgment of Nora.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/525/0*_EneVJufeg3vzgMk" /><figcaption><em>Nora’s mother’s attitude: for her to continually intervene and act as the family adult.</em></figcaption></figure><p>“Hector snaps like one of his lighters. His cheeks go blotchy, and he shoves past me into the entry hall, where Mima’s purse hangs in the coat closet. He grabs it and digs inside, tossing out her eyeglass case, her pens, her citizenship card, used tissues. ‘¡Pero hijo!’ Mima stands helplessly at the doorway as he empties her purse. Soapy water drips from her hands onto the floor. ‘¡No lo tengo!’ My stomach squeezes into a familiar knot as I try to figure out the puzzle, fast. I could give him the ten bucks to cool things off, or I could hide in our bedroom and let them combust.”</p><p>Explaining why Nora hides this from Kathleen and Pablo, she says, “How can you make people understand about brothers who hit and spit? How do you explain why you listen at your own front door before going in? How do you explain that it’s not only parents who beat kids, but sometimes the other way around, too?”</p><h3>Romantic Problems</h3><p>As Nora is beginning to date her coworker, Pablo, there’s real suspense in her efforts to keep him from learning about her family. In addition, any possible make out scene has the Son of Sam lurking in the background.</p><p>Of a recently murdered couple, Nora says, “They were eighteen and twenty years old, more or less like us. They went to the movies and found out that the city isn’t huge at all. In fact, it can shrink down to the size of a gun barrel, just like that.”</p><p>Pablo eventually learns more about Hector’s behavior. Nora tells him it’s none of his business. This appears to be a romance breaker.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/525/0*Lx0b1G_kxZt0Olab" /><figcaption><em>Nora overcomes the many obstacles to her romantic life.</em></figcaption></figure><h3>Add Problems Together to Create Suspense</h3><p>Writing teachers will warn that surprise or shock is not suspense, and that’s true. But sometimes writers have a suspenseful story in hand without understanding where the suspense comes from. In the case of Nora’s universe-1977 New York City-there is the suspense of a serial killer roaming the streets and killing young couples. But when Nora learns about arson, burglaries, and drug dealing in her neighborhood and apartment building, the problems of society at large hit home. A writer might think the suspense lies in the question of whether Nora’s brother, Hector, is involved in criminal activity. But really, Medina is showing her hand in placing hints early and often. The suspense for me, as the reader, was in something I really didn’t know: what will happen to the family when they learn what Hector has done? How can an absent father and a mother who refuses to see her son’s behavior for what it is (partly because she isn’t empowered to change it) have any influence over the future? They are unjustly placing the burden in Nora’s lap. What will happen to her? This sort of suspense is the best because Nora doesn’t deserve to be made responsible, doesn’t deserve to be harmed. What teen hasn’t felt the same impotence in facing their parents? Everyone who reads this novel will be in high tension about Nora’s future throughout. We want her to tell Papi what he needs to know because, in a sense, this would be speaking truth to power. We are wanting it, waiting for it, will revel in it. That’s high stakes suspense.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/525/0*kaxZjHe7T1k8iZ6O" /><figcaption><em>Nora is afraid of anyone finding out about the extreme dysfunction in her family.</em></figcaption></figure><h3>Finish with Important Questions-and Answers</h3><p>A good YA novel comes to some resolution. In order to do so, mentors and friends have to be introduced early and show up repeatedly. Nora has adults who care about her, and more importantly, act to direct her into a better future. Ms. Friedmor, the school’s head guidance counselor, and Mr. Melvin, the woodshop teacher, are two of the most important. Kathleen’s parents are always welcoming and are ultimately instrumental in her plan to become independent.</p><p>Some of the larger societal questions create conflict: The fear, fires, and looting bring disagreement between Stiller (an African American feminist and activist) and Kathleen’s father (a firefighter) to the surface. Their argument over safety and privilege will strike a cord, mirroring today’s news. Equally familiar is the characters’ exhaustion with what feels like innumerable, endless issues:</p><p>“But here’s what’s really weird. We’re all too hot and tired to even care. In fact, no one acts surprised because, face it, what disaster hasn’t happened this year? We’re burning. We’re broke. We’re laid off. We’re ripping each other off or being murdered or pulling the trigger.”</p><p>“Every rule I know is gone, and we’re in chaos. There are no rules for how a family should work. No rules for how far loyalty should reach. No boundaries on stealing or looting. No limits on how people ruin one another’s lives or how we blame one another for our pain. . . . Now no rules for how we kill each other, either.”</p><h3>Answers</h3><p>I don’t want to give away all the many resolutions, but ultimately Nora finds her way-with help, but on her own terms.</p><p>“Maybe the things that scare us seem more powerful than they truly are when we keep them secret.”</p><p>Ms. Friedmor’s words are something of a theme for<em> Burn, Baby, Burn</em>. They can be a reminder for writers as well: “Remember to reach. You’ll surprise yourself.”</p><h3>Afterword</h3><p>Medina includes an afterword about the setting and action of <em>Burn, Baby, Burn</em>. As writers are living through the same sorts of tension and social justice issues today, they may take to heart her purpose in writing the novel and get to work on a similar exploration of their own.</p><p>“In so many ways, this is a novel about people at their worst. It is a story of family pain and of juvenile domestic violence, a chronically underreported issue. It’s the story of community pain — and all the ways that people try to cope in the face of fear. But for me, this novel is a celebration of people who find their strength even in the worst circumstances. I wrote this story because young people everywhere sometimes find that they have to fuel their hope against a bleak backdrop and outpourings of rage.”</p><p>Note: For other examples of great YA fiction writing, I posted about <em>The Miseducation of Cameron Post</em> <a href="https://victoriawaddle.com/2018/08/15/literary-quality-ya-miseducation-cameron-post/">here</a> and <em>Challenger Deep </em><a href="https://victoriawaddle.com/2017/11/07/neal-shusterman/">here</a>.</p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="http://victoriawaddle.com/2020/09/11/the-perfectly-constructed-ya-novel/"><em>http://victoriawaddle.com</em></a><em> on September 11, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=534edf1d5ff4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Teen Voices and The Poet X: Keep a Journal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@waddleido/teen-voices-and-the-poet-x-keep-a-journal-17b940792513?source=rss-2074a784ab2c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17b940792513</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elizabeth-acevedo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journal-writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[victoria waddle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 31 Aug 2020 21:32:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-31T21:32:49.259Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/688/1*9UdgczqK4Vi6SOGdE2pKDw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Submerged by Shaina Boal, who won the Inlandia Teen 2020 art contest. This was the issue’s cover.</figcaption></figure><p>A recent experience with a teen writer had me going back to<em> The Poet X</em> by Elizabeth Acevedo. I’d originally purchased and listened to <em>The Poet X</em> on audiobook — a powerful narration by the author herself, which I highly recommend. A few months ago, I finished putting together the third teen issue of <a href="https://inlandiajournal.com/"><em>Inlandia: A Literary Journey</em></a>, the journal sponsored by the <a href="http://inlandiainstitute.org/">Inlandia Institute</a>. These two experiences connected for me when one of the teen authors emailed to ask that I remove her work from the issue.</p><p>With the two previous teen issues of <em>Inlandia</em>, wrapping up the experience meant having an in-person celebration on the library lawn in downtown Riverside, California. I’d spend the weeks before the gathering making all sorts of cookies. On the evening of the live reading, I’d meet with the institute director, the programs coordinator, the teen editors and several of the teen authors, who read from their work to a live audience. It was a joy to meet the authors and connect their voices to their published work. It was a joy to meet their proud parents and siblings, and even some of their teachers who had encouraged their writing journey.</p><p>This year, because of the pandemic, we had an online gathering. While I missed meeting the writers, parents, and teachers (the online audience had the opportunity to chat by text only and were not visible), it was fun to have some of the distant authors read. We even had girls from Shanghai, China and Bristol, England.</p><p>Still, the pandemic had a depressing effect on me as I was working on the teen issue. Having been both a teacher and high school librarian, I know what the daily routine of school means to teens whose family life is broken. Some of these teens were submitting work to us. About seventy-five percent of them were being rejected by the teen editors. The letters declining their work would come from me. What would I say in the midst of these losses? My draft of the decline letter grew ever longer.</p><p><em>Thank you for sending us your work. We are very sorry, but it does not quite fit with this issue. We realize that this season is difficult for so many of us and in so many ways. And while your work was not chosen for this issue, the editors enjoyed its admirable qualities. You are doing the hard work that creative endeavors require. Thank you for your willingness to offer your work to others, to contribute to the artistic conversation that means so much to us right now.</em></p><p>And then I added notes on what we liked about each piece and suggested edits. Because here’s the thing: most teen work truly is work in progress and, if continued, will find its way to an audience.</p><p>“If continued” is the key. Think of <em>The Poet X</em>. It’s a work by an adult about the experience of a teen.</p><p>The girl who withdrew her short story from the teen issue of the journal had been delighted to have it accepted. She was one of the few authors who wrote to me to talk about it when she received the acceptance letter. Her byline included her first, middle and last name. Her fiction was a sweet story about two young lesbians who meet accidentally and over time, realize that they are in love. It was innocent stuff, but ended tragically, in a way that keeps the lovers apart. When I first read it, I thought of the influence of <em>Romeo and Juliet</em> since its required reading in most US schools.</p><p>But I came to see this ending differently as my correspondence with the author continued. After I sent her the unpublished link to her story for a final review, she worried about having her full name in her byline. Would it be too much trouble to remove her middle name and use just her first initial? “I’m sorry,” she said. “I have a relative that I don’t want to see it. I’m thinking about the person searching my name online.” <em>No problem</em>, I told her.</p><p>The story was published, the online celebration was over and recorded. This author did not read her work or even attend. But a few days later, she emailed me again. Would it be too much trouble if I removed her story from the issue? She was having difficulty with the relative and needed the story to disappear. Though young, she understood specificity of language, and I thought her use of the words “a relative” rather than ‘mother,’ ‘father,’ ‘uncle,’ or ‘cousin’ was telling.</p><p>I told her how sorry I was, but ultimately, I removed both her story and her author bio. I was not her teacher, a trusted adult who could advocate for her with her parents. I’d never even met her. I’d only read her story and was glad to see that the teen editors had selected it. We emailed a few more times. I told her I hoped that she would continue to write. I hoped, too, that she was keeping a journal of her experiences because the time would come when she would be able to speak and write freely. She would need to reference her teen emotional state. She answered that she was, indeed, keeping a journal. That she would continue her writing journey.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*u03XS8wflcgQagDvlzSg-A.jpeg" /><figcaption>“Serenity Facing the Storm” another of Shaina Boal’s images for the Inlandia 2020 Teen Issue.</figcaption></figure><p>My hope for, and her assurance of, the journal writing is what triggered thoughts of <em>The Poet X</em>. As the novel tells us “Xiomara” (the protagonist’s name) means one who is ready for war. What better readies a writer for the fight for their voice than journal writing? I decided to get a print copy of the novel and look back at the language and passages that had moved me in the audio version.</p><p>Xiomara is a high school sophomore living in Harlem with her ultra-religious (Catholic) mother, her reformed but previously philandering father, and her twin brother. Her mother cleans an office building in Queens. Xiomara says “I look at her scarred knuckles./I know exactly how she was taught faith.” (17) Xiomara and Twin (Xavier) were conceived years into their parents’ marriage and considered to be answered prayers. Nonetheless, Xiomara’s delivery was very difficult and she has been considered difficult ever since. “‘Pero, tú no eres fácil.’/You sure ain’t an easy one.” (10)</p><p>A major reason her mother finds her difficult is that Xiomara does not have the religious fervor of her mother, but would rather write poems. Religion, the Catholic Church is “A friend I just don’t think I need anymore.” (13) The Confirmation instructor, Father Sean is sympathetic, but clearly has no intention of confirming Xiomara if she doesn’t feel it’s right. (Quick note: The sacrament of Confirmation is one in which the recipient accepts God — particularly the Holy Spirit — of their own free will. The Catholic Church has infant baptism and other sacraments for the young such as Reconciliation and First Holy Communion, but Confirmation is the first time the person will choose the church of their own accord.) Xiomara asks, “What’s the point of God giving me life/if I can’t live it as my own?//Why does listening to his commandments mean I need to shut down my own voice?” (57)</p><p>In the fight to use her own voice, Xiomara has an ally in Ms. Galiano, her English teacher, who is also the advisor for the poetry club. She sees Xiomara’s talent and creativity and encourages it. Xiomara’s other allies include Twin and Caridad. Twin is a slight, church-loving altar boy and excellent student who has skipped a grade and goes to high school for gifted kids. He’s also gay, and Xiomara suspects it but is afraid of openly discussing it — and really afraid of what will happen if her parents find out. Caridad, Xiomara’s best friend, is deeply religious and still follows the rules of her parents and the Church. The girls are the opposites that attract and have known one another since they were babies.</p><p>It is her desire to attend the poetry club meetings, which happen to be at the same time as Confirmation class, that brings Xiomara to break her mom’s rules regarding piety. “Tuesday has become my equivalent/to Mami’s Sunday. A prayer circle.” (283) It is Aman, Xiomara’s lab partner in biology class, for whom she breaks her mother’s rules on not dating.</p><p>At first, Xiomara finds her voice in her journals, gifts from Twin. Later, she will fight to have that voice heard at poetry slams. The things she writes about would drive her mother crazy if she saw them. Her lack of conviction in the face of Confirmation. Her first period and how her mother told her that only <em>cueros</em> (whores) use tampons. Her feelings about having a mature body, curvy and busty, one that makes her stand out in all the sophomore class and drives male response about her.</p><p>I am unhide-able.</p><p>Taller than even my father, with what Mami has always said</p><p>was “a little too much body for such a young girl.”</p><p>…</p><p>The other girls call me conceited. Ho. Thot. Fast.</p><p>When your body takes up more room than your voice</p><p>you are always the target of well-aimed rumors,</p><p>which is why I let my knuckles talk for me.</p><p>Which is why I learned to shrug when my name was replaced</p><p>by insults. (p. 5)</p><p>Sometimes it feels</p><p>All I’m worth is under my skirt (14)</p><p>I should be used to it.</p><p>I shouldn’t get so angry</p><p>when boys — and sometimes</p><p>grown-ass men —</p><p>talk to me however they want,</p><p>think they can grab themselves</p><p>or rub against me</p><p>or make all kinds of offers.</p><p>But I’m never used to it.</p><p>And it always makes my hands shake.</p><p>Always makes my throat tight.</p><p>The only thing that calms me down</p><p>after Twin and I get home</p><p>is to put my headphones on.</p><p>To listen to Drake.</p><p>To grab my notebook,</p><p>and write, and write, and write</p><p>all the things I wish I could have said.</p><p>Make poems from the sharp feelings inside,</p><p>that feel like they could</p><p>carve me wide</p><p>open. (52)</p><p>(<em>I love the way this part of the poem looks on the page — it’s centered to appear much like a curvy girl.</em>)</p><p>See, a cuero is my skin. A cuero/is just a covering. A cuero is a loose thing./Tied down by no one. Fluttering/and waving in the wind. Flying. Flying. Gone. (206)</p><h4>Readers of <em>The Poet X</em> will also fall in love with the poetic language:</h4><p>That incense makes bow tie pasta of my belly./That all the lit candles beckon like fingers/that want to clutch around my throat. (62)</p><p>And their words are like the catch of a gas stove,/the <em>click, click </em>while you’re waiting/for it to light up and then flame big and blue. (110)</p><p>On the train ride home/Twin steps into his feelings/like they’re a gated-off room/I don’t have visitation rights to. (176)</p><p>My mother’s face scrunches tight/like someone has vacuumed all her joy. (229)</p><blockquote>Ultimately, writing (in a larger sense, one might substitute “creating”) matters. It is the creative life which often presses against the spiritual life, that engenders faith and hope.</blockquote><p>Hiding in my journal</p><p>is the only way I know not to cry.</p><p>My house is a tomb.</p><p>Even Twin has stopped speaking to me</p><p>As if he’s afraid a single word</p><p>Will cause my facade to crack. (237)</p><p>Because so many of the poems tonight</p><p>Felt a little like our own stories.</p><p>Like we saw and were seen.</p><p>And how crazy would it be</p><p>If I did that for someone else? (282)</p><p>My experience is that there are not many outlets for teen voices, almost none during a pandemic. As adults, our goal for teen voices is that they be heard. I hope teachers and school librarians are talking up books such as <em>The Poet X</em> to remind their writers of the value of their work. I hope school libraries have found a way to check out books to students even when they are distance learning. And I also hope that teachers and librarians have devised contests where all the participants receive journals. Because, again, most teen work truly is work in progress and, if continued, will find its way to an audience.</p><p>Note: The page numbers given above are from <em>The Poet X</em> by Elizabeth Acevedo (New York: HarperCollins, 2018).</p><p>I’ve discussed previous teen issues of <em>Inlandia</em> <a href="http://victoriawaddle.com/2020/06/01/inlandia-journeys-teen-issue-is-live/">here</a> and <a href="http://victoriawaddle.com/2018/05/17/teen-issue-inlandia/">here</a>. I’ve written about books centered on teen voices on my <a href="https://schoollibrarylady.com/">School Library Lady blog</a>. Some of the earlier ones, such as Laurie Halse Anderson’s <em>Speak</em>, still have much to say.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17b940792513" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>