<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM) on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM) on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@warwickcim?source=rss-6d585659350------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 06:00:46 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@warwickcim/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Uncovering inequalities across disciplines — intersectoral approach]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@warwickcim/uncovering-inequalities-across-disciplines-intersectoral-approach-fc4f118441ab?source=rss-6d585659350------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc4f118441ab</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM)]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Nov 2022 11:05:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-14T11:05:02.648Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Uncovering inequalities across disciplines — intersectoral approach</h3><p><a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/people/zofia-bednarowska-michaiel/">Dr Zofia Bednarowska-Michaiel</a>, Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies, University of Warwick</p><p>CIM finished the 2020/2021 academic year with a series of research workshops. The final one was called “Uncovering social and regional inequalities using spatial data and interdisciplinary methods”. During that workshop I talked about an interdisciplinary approach to inequalities, using spatial methods and regional approach. Here in this blogpost, I reflect on the researching inequalities, as well as briefly discuss implementing it in a workshop setting.</p><h4>1 Introduction. What are inequalities, how do we define them?</h4><p>Reducing Inequalities is one of the Sustainable Development Goals of the United Nations (United Nations, 2022). If you look at the full list of UN’s goals, you can notice that the rest of goals also concern inequalities of various kind e.g., gender or education inequalities, although the goals themselves are not called this way. Why do some inequalities receive more attention than others in research and policymaking?</p><p>I believe the reason for that is a common perception of inequalities primarily in economic terms, hence income inequalities attract the most attention. However, there are many more types of inequalities, often defined slightly different by various stakeholders and they are strongly linked to each other.</p><p>During CIM workshop, I drew my typology of inequalities. This includes social, economic, political and what I called — sectoral inequalities. If we were to start with social inequalities, we can differentiate inequalities based on gender, age, race, sexual orientation, ethnicity, nationality, class. These and other social categories of identity usually do not exist independently and require intersectional recognition in order to understand overlapping inequalities and discrimination.</p><p>Sectoral inequalities group those occurring within a given sector: health, education, income, environmental, transportation, technology. Most of inequalities touch upon a few sectors e.g., digital inequalities and they require intersectoral approach.</p><p>Following this typology further, all of inequalities can be understood at various scales — local, regional, national, or global. The question we discussed during a workshop is how we can research and then tackle inequalities within the regional scale. There’s a growing interest in inequalities, in particular urban inequalities as a research subject (Nijman and Wei, 2020). However, the benefit of regional outlook is a holistic approach to inequalities, regardless of region being more urban or rural, or a bit of both.</p><p>The concept of ‘inequalities’ is, in my opinion, just the first phase of disparities that eventually lead to exclusion and discrimination. This brings us to the conclusion that is essential to find effective way of researching inequalities in order to grasp their complexity and interdependency.</p><h4>2. Methods. The trinity of interdisciplinarity</h4><p>The workshop discussion was built around how interdisciplinary approach can help in researching complex inequalities. I have introduced three concepts that encompass the interdisciplinarity itself, as seen on the chart below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xevZWqteROSIgObFG8HFGg.png" /><figcaption>Figure 1. The trinity of interdisciplinarity when researching inequalities. Author: Zofia Bednarowska-Michaiel</figcaption></figure><p>The multi-dimensionality of inequalities requires a multi-level approach in research. I introduced the foundations of regional science and spatial methods during the workshop. This showed how they can work in recognition of complex inequalities that touch upon various sectors and scales.</p><p>Mapping inequalities with a regional outlook reveals significance of distance — how neighbourhood, borders, and spillovers affect and sustain inequalities. Introducing spatial component reveals different ways of looking into inequalities — we will see for instance, how social and racial inequalities are intertwined, together with economic or political inequalities.</p><p>The regional aspect of inequalities already has an interdisciplinary element engrained within. By focusing on a given region, we can then expand into different research areas. Regional science uses various disciplines — geography, urban studies, economics, transportation studies among others and is strongly linked to local policymaking to support better understanding of inequalities.</p><h4>3. Ideas. Interdisciplinarity in design</h4><p>Overall, this “trinity” embodies interdisciplinarity because regional science and spatial methods derive from multiple disciplines. Embracing this interdisciplinarity in a good research design often supports tackling complex research problems.</p><p>During workshop we talked how remaining open to new methods and theoretical perspectives outside of our disciplines can support our research. Spatial methods are strongly connected to regional science, as they are designed to uncover the regional aspect of what we are looking at. When using spatial methods we add space — another dimension to our research and usually use regional data. As a result, we inevitably analyse an area or region which would constitute as a unit of observation in our research. This helps to build more localised policies that are more targeted and, hopefully, easier to apply.</p><p>The benefit of the regional approach was shown in an example from my research project about inequalities in cycling in London.</p><h4>4. Workshop as a method: Mapping inequalities</h4><p>These theoretical discussions were followed by interactive workshop. All the participants contributed to a map of inequalities in the regions they lived at the time (see below). Each person briefly presented their region and what were, in their opinion, key urging inequalities. This helped them realize how much inequalities are connected to each other across different countries and regions.</p><p>We looked at inequalities from the perspective of people who live in a specific region. Using the brainwriting method, we identified general reasons for uneven access to cycling. This exercise helped to identify reasons, why inequalities matter in research and policymaking. The output of this discussion was a board of virtual post-its, where we talked about the role of regional science and spatial data in stimulating policy discussions around inequalities.</p><p>Then I briefly presented my research project on London cycling where I used cross-disciplinary theories and iterative research design to support uncovering inequalities. This steered a discussion on how research design can help with such inequalities.</p><p>Using a tool called SCAMPER delivered by Miro, the participants brought their solutions to cycling inequalities, which could be grouped into the following themes: “A better and more balanced social structure”, “Law and policies”, “Breaking the cycle of inequalities”, “Education”, “Interdisciplinary impact”, and “Methodology impact”. Some of the outputs of the workshop are presented below: the map of inequalities at the top, brainwriting post-it notes at the bottom.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/208/1*7KqvDnO4ACkzrhSNLiQxNg.png" /><figcaption>Figure 2. Workshop outputs. Authors: CIM Research Workshop participants.</figcaption></figure><p>The final part of the workshop was moved outdoors to stimulate a more out-of-the-box mindset. This brought discussions of how everything participants learnt during workshop can help them with their own research projects. Using the mind mapping, participants mapped their research problem in one (or multiple) level(s): local, regional, national and global. The idea was to show participants what impact their research problem has on various levels of regionality, and how often space is interwind with research in social sciences.</p><h4>5. Workshop as a method: a hybrid teaching in a workshop setting</h4><p>The workshop was a chance to explore hybrid learning techniques with online and offline participants in Spring 2021. Given the change of Covid-19 government guidelines when the workshop was happening, we were able to meet in a classroom after a long break. Not all participants could join us in person, so I tried to bridge together participants on campus and those joining online. Using a dedicated room for hybrid teaching I was able to connect socially distanced participants in a lecture hall with participants dialling-in to our meeting app. I extensively used Miro’s online solutions to further enable collaboration. Some of the physical accessories stimulating the discussion in the room were not available due to the Covid-19 restrictions, but altogether we made the most of the situation.</p><h4>6. Final outcome: Map your research</h4><p>CIM Research Workshop on inequalities brought various learning outcomes. Participants learnt more about inequalities and how intersectionality and intersectoral approach can unfold their complex nature. By mapping inequalities, each participant had a chance to reflect on local inequalities visible in the regions they live or come from.</p><p>This brought the discussion of how research design can address complexity and intersectionality of inequalities. By introducing “trinity of interdisciplinarity”, participants learnt about regional science and spatial methods. Hopefully this gave them some inspiration for their own research projects.</p><h4>Contact</h4><p>The detailed results of my research project that I mentioned here are to be published in the <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/toc/rsrs20/current">Regional Science, Regional Studies</a> in 2022. Please follow my <a href="https://twitter.com/ZBednarowska">Twitter</a> for updates or contact me if you are interested in more details about the workshop or my research project.</p><h4>References:</h4><p>United Nations. (2022). Goal 10: Reduce inequality within and among countries. <a href="https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/inequality/">https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/inequality/</a></p><p>Nijman J., Wei Y. D. (2020). Urban inequalities in the 21st century economy, Applied Geography, Vol. 117(102188), doi.org/10.1016/j.apgeog.2020.102188.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc4f118441ab" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dapps Vs. Apps]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@warwickcim/the-relationship-of-big-tech-platform-incumbents-to-blockchain-infrastructures-is-complicated-baeb43d9875?source=rss-6d585659350------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/baeb43d9875</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM)]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Mar 2022 10:45:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-09T10:53:41.158Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Michael Dieter, (Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies, University of Warwick)</p><p>The relationship of Big Tech platform incumbents to blockchain infrastructures is complicated. For every experiment like the<a href="https://twitter.com/TwitterBlue/status/1484226494708662273"> ‘soft hexagon’</a> profile pic on Twitter, there’s an<a href="https://www.theverge.com/2021/10/15/22728425/valve-steam-blockchain-nft-crypto-ban-games-age-of-rust"> outright ban</a> of NFTs and crypto-gaming on platforms such as Steam. Despite the ambitions of crypto-evangelists to reach mass adoption, large segments of users are resistant to anything blockchain-related, often to the point of<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/15/technology/cryptocurrency-nft-gamers.html"> open hostility</a>. Despite this tension, crypto-subcultures continue to evolve into labyrinthine, highly inventive and often baffling formations. Keeping up with these developments, let alone making sense of them, is a full time job. Hype and misdirection is part of the hustle, while reliable empirical studies and critical research are often in short supply.</p><p>Last month, I took a first foray into blockchain research through a short project for the<a href="https://wiki.digitalmethods.net/Dmi/WinterSchool2022"> DMI Winter School</a> at University of Amsterdam. Having worked on<a href="http://appstudies.org/"> app studies</a> for some time, I was curious about so-called decentralized apps or ‘dapps’ — that is, software applications that utilize a blockchain. The goal was to empirically explore some of the different emerging relations between apps and dapps, between the apparent incumbents and challengers. Rather than accepting at face value web3 discourses of centralized vs. decentralized, the idea was to investigate the entanglements, dispositions and tendencies that are shaping these distinct, yet overlapping domains.</p><p>The term dapp can be read in part as a strategic framing to guide blockchain development by riffing on the known and highly successful commercial format of apps.<a href="http://cryptochainuni.com/wp-content/uploads/The-General-Theory-of-Decentralized-Applications-DApps.pdf"> Some even now re-categorise Bitcoin as the first dapp</a>. The term, however, also supports a diversification of blockchain-based services and the application of user-experience design (UX) techniques to ‘onboard’ new users and build growth. In this sense, it represents the rise of new processes of platformisation and related forms of control. Some dapps, for instance, work only by processing transactions on a decentralized blockchain like Etherium, while other user interactions like content creation or gameplay are logged elsewhere on a centralized database. This helps reduce cost, but also affords the developer particular kinds of oversight. Due to the need to access nodes on the blockchain to process transactions, third-parties have emerged to handle these data-flows, essentially concentrating infrastructural power behind the scenes, as noted in a widely circulated blogpost by Signal developer<a href="https://moxie.org/2022/01/07/web3-first-impressions.html?s=09"> Moxie</a>. All this troubles the ideology of web3 as pure disintermediation.</p><p>Meanwhile, discovering and accessing dapps through mobile app stores is not straightforward. This is partly because Google and Apple maintain strict policies for how Android and iOS apps can interact with blockchains in order to mitigate against fraud and protect their established payment provisions/services (although there is speculation this could change after the anti-competitive case of<a href="https://appleinsider.com/articles/20/08/23/apple-versus-epic-games-fortnite-app-store-saga----the-story-so-far"> Epic Games against Apple</a>). Many users, in fact, access dapps as websites with a crypto-wallet browser plugin. Portals like<a href="https://dappradar.com/"> DappRadar</a> or<a href="https://www.dapp.com/"> Dapp.com</a> provide catalogs of dapps via hyperlinks, mimicking app stores with classic grids of bite-sized icons, familiar categories and algorithmic sorting. Interestingly, however, these sites function more like financial dashboards by aggregating transaction-based data sources and metrics from public blockchains. Supporting this web-based approach, the web browser Opera (which already has an internal crypto-wallet) has<a href="https://press.opera.com/2021/12/22/opera-polygon-layer2-partnership/"> recently announced</a> it will integrate support for the Polygon blockchain to deliver over 2,000 dapps directly to users. The Brave browser also offers a similar kind of<a href="https://brave.com/wallet/"> ‘native’ crypto-wallet</a>. Another avenue to access dapps is through browsers built into popular crypto-wallet services such as MetaMask and Trust Wallet, which — to complicate matters further — themselves can be accessed as mobile apps on GooglePlay and Apple’s App Store, but sometimes with limited functionality (for instance, in June last year, Trust Wallet was<a href="https://support.trustwallet.com/en/support/solutions/articles/67000670234-dapp-browser-removal-on-ios-version-of-trust-wallet"> forced to delete their dapp browser</a> from their iOS version to comply with Apple’s policies). Consequently, with these various access points hedging for dominance, there is quite some competition to control the means of distribution to dapps across different infrastructures and platforms, both old and new.</p><p>Approaching this complicated domain in our short digital methods project, we decided to scope out some similarities or differences between these different access points. Using the simple query ‘NFT’, we contrasted the top 50 results from GooglePlay and the App Store with the kinds of dapps tracked by DappRadar. Methodologically, we used a mixture of app store scraper tools developed by DMI and performed a manual, bottom-up categorization of results.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NfwNWpsXP88UPdJ9oCibAQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Fig 1. App Store (left) vs. GooglePlay (right) NFT Categorized</figcaption></figure><p>In the traditional app space, we found a predominance of what we call ‘NFT Creator’ apps; these afford users the possibility to design and mint NFTs, often using kitschy filters, generative algorithms or simply by uploading a photograph or image. With names like<a href="https://apps.apple.com/us/app/nft-pixel-creator/id1601368737?uo=4"> NFT Pixel Creator</a>,<a href="https://apps.apple.com/us/app/nft-creator-sell-your-nfts/id1594177454?uo=4"> NFT Creator</a> or<a href="https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ai.art.nft.creator.generator&amp;hl=en&amp;gl=us"> Meta NFT Maker</a>, many contain fees and ongoing subscriptions. They capitalize on the crypto-hype by mixing genres of user-generated content with the promise of monetization. ‘NFT Browsers’ are also common, allowing access to NFT collections on the blockchain, but not necessarily the possibility to make purchases or transactions. The restrictive policies of Apple and Google can be felt here, perhaps conveyed most dramatically by ‘Portfolio’ apps like NFT Gallery which provide users the option of simply displaying already owned NFT collections within a viewer, gallery or even as smartphone wallpaper. In such cases, the functionality of the smartphone is reduced to that of a display cabinet or picture frame, rather than opening up innovative means of exchange. In general, there is a sense of <em>distancing from dapps</em> in both stores, with ‘Wallets’ being the key point of access into crypto-development.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eICCS4e76vR7To881qDVPA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Fig 2. DappRadar — NFT (left) vs. DappRadar Top January (right) Categorized</figcaption></figure><p>The NFT query for DappRadar, meanwhile, tells a much different story. We are immediately taken into the weird space of software development and services offered on blockchain. The space recalls Manovich’s concept of<a href="https://www.bloomsbury.com/uk/software-takes-command-9781623567453/"> deep remixability</a> as familiar software techniques or ‘ways of doing’ are merged into monstrous, financial forms. In mapping DappRadar, we contrasted the NFT query with the most popular for the month of January 2022 (Fig 2.). For NFTs, popular traded collectibles like<a href="https://boredapeyachtclub.com/"> Bored Ape Yacht Club</a>,<a href="https://www.larvalabs.com/cryptopunks"> CryptoPunks</a> and<a href="https://www.artblocks.io/"> Art Blocks</a> all prominently surfaced. While perhaps considered colloquially as the genre of cartoon ape GIFs, these kinds of collectibles can technically be considered dapps since they layer interfaces onto smart contracts and aim to popularize blockchain infrastructure in the process. This kind of ‘dapp store’ research also opens up the possibility of mapping popular NFT aesthetics, from the tropes of street art to pop generative art and 8-bit cyberpunk iconography. As<a href="https://spikeartmagazine.com/?q=articles/spike-70-web3-out-now"> Ruth Catlow has recently observed</a>, NFT aesthetics are highly expressive of the communities from which such originate, particularly with the predominance of game cultures, and their associated notions of worldbuilding and gaming mechanics, which are readily translated into the context of crypto-markets. Indeed, this influence is clear in DappRadar’s listings, where games such as<a href="https://dappradar.com/multichain/games/splinterlands"> Splinterlands</a>,<a href="https://dappradar.com/multichain/games/alien-worlds"> Alien Worlds</a> and<a href="https://dappradar.com/wax/games/farmers-world"> Farmers World</a> have become some of the most popular dapps. As a final stage of our analysis, we focussed on one of largest crypto-games,<a href="https://dappradar.com/ethereum/games/axie-infinity"> Axie Infinity</a>, to examine how relations between apps and dapps are unfolding within this important genre.</p><p>While doing our research, Axie Infinity was listed the most popular NFT dapp with around 660,000 active users. The game was developed by Vietnamese studio<a href="https://skymavis.com/"> Sky Mavis</a> in 2018 and was<a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/youngjoseph/2021/10/06/metaverse-heats-up-how-axie-infinitys-30b-valuation-led-crypto-game-frenzy/?sh=973e36725c66"> valued at $3 billion</a> in October last year. It’s essentially Pokémon on the blockchain, where players earn tokens by training and fighting the ‘Axies.’ It has been widely reported that around<a href="https://www.theverge.com/2021/10/13/22725083/axie-infinity-sky-mavis-blockchain-economy-game-pokemon"> 40 percent of Axie players are based in the Philippines</a>. The developer says<a href="https://www.coindesk.com/business/2021/10/05/axie-infinity-nears-2m-daily-active-users-as-creator-raises-152m-series-b/"> 25 percent of its players are ‘unbanked,’</a> so Axie wallets have become their first access to financial services. In some cases, people have been paying their rent using the SLP token in the game.<a href="https://naavik.co/business-breakdowns/axie-infinity"> While major questions have been raised regarding its sustainability</a>, Axie Infinity nevertheless offers a sobering glimpse into the possible acceleration of playbor, exploitation and hyper-financialization enabled by dapps.</p><p>For this case study, we asked: are there support apps or third-party apps developed on traditional mobile app platforms for the dapp? And if so, what kind? What do they reveal about Axie Infinity?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EFILugsERfEL-0u8m6_WVA.png" /><figcaption>Fig 3.‘Axie Infinity’ Query GooglePlay and App Store Categorized (Network)</figcaption></figure><p>To answer these questions, we scraped 50 entries for the query ‘Axie Infinity’ in both GooglePlay and the App Store, and then categorized the results using a bottom-up taxonomy. Interestingly, while the game is not itself available on GooglePlay or the App Store, there is a significant amount of app development to support it. Fig. 3 visualizes the results as a network graph, revealing clusters of app types which provide a sense of the culture of play around Axie Infinity. From guides to assist players learning the game to price tracking of the game’s crypto-token, from clones from other developers trying to parasite on the trend to gameplay managers and even training simulators. More support apps have been produced on GooglePlay, perhaps because of the larger user base for Android across South East Asia.</p><p>One type of support app worth noting is <em>the scholarship manager</em>. Due to the high cost of entry into the game, more established players have begun lending new players crypto to play, but then taking a cut from any winnings in return. This is called granting them a ‘scholarship.’ It essentially turns some users into assets or sources of rent — they become assetized — revealing another aspect of the hyper-financial character of dapps, but one that spans both blockchain and mobile app infrastructures.</p><p>With this quick dive into dapps and apps, it’s obvious the situation is far more complicated than incumbents versus challengers, web2 versus web3, centralized versus decentralized. As a complex cultural and socio-technical process, it might be more accurate to consider the<em> cryptofication of apps</em> and<em> appification of crypto</em>. Significantly, this is happening on multiple levels, from aesthetics to protocols, from the composition of dataflows to cultural practices like play, at times being mutually reinforced, at others being closed off or redirected through platform governance. How this ultimately will play out, and what kind of new tensions and cultural forms will emerge with increasing regulatory interventions, is ultimately an open question that demands ongoing ‘dapp studies’ research.</p><p><em>Many thanks to contributors to the DMI project: Michael Ashong, Issaka Adams, Saratu Abiola, Dilara Akdemir, Aleksandra Sevastianova, and the designer Andrea Benedetti (DensityDesign)</em></p><p><a href="https://networkcultures.org/moneylab/2022/02/15/dapps-vs-apps/">This post first appeared on the MoneyLab blog, February 15, 2022</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=baeb43d9875" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“The Godavarius”: Lost and Found — A field note]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@warwickcim/the-godavarius-lost-and-found-a-field-note-39b2f0313017?source=rss-6d585659350------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/39b2f0313017</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM)]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Oct 2021 09:28:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-28T09:29:26.386Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“The Godavarius”: Lost and Found — A field note</h3><p>Noortje Marres, (Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies, University of Warwick)</p><p><em>A short report of a </em><a href="https://coventry2021.co.uk/what-s-on/the-godavarius-lost-and-found-and-lost-again/"><em>guided walk</em></a><em> organised as part of the CIM project </em><a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/sampling-sounds-of-the-future"><em>Sampling Sounds of Coventry’s Future</em></a><em>.</em></p><p>Last Sunday the musician <a href="https://sarahmfarmer.com/">Sarah Farmer</a> took us for a walk along Coventry’s Music Mile.</p><p>She had brought along several speaker-balls which she handed out to us, quite casually, and, after a quick explanation, they pretty much turned themselves on, waking us up with strings rumbling and reassuring blue light.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*0IMull2Fojp66xfu_Gw6ew.jpeg" /></figure><p>We were pulled along by this sound emanating from the little speakers, sound that I have a weakness for, slow strokes along violin strings reveberating, as we walked from FarGo Village, into Gosford Park, and up along Walsgrave Road, us following the sound, and Sarah Farmer, who, like a piped piper, walked in front, except she seemed quite unconcerned with us following her.</p><figure><img alt="Image of trees in Gosford Park, Coventry" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*uLVvHFwY5o9fvnyCOpcvkg.jpeg" /></figure><p>She, or rather the instruments she has brought along, let us hear different sounds of Coventry, as if picking up signals from the environment around us — Dub, Jamaican steel drums, folk violin play. As we walked, different melodies would emerge from the violin strings reveberating from our little speakers, then fade away, into the background.</p><p>I know Dub and steel drums from different places, but these were unfamiliar sounds, almost all unknown to me, a visitor of Coventry, still, after coming here regularly for six years now.</p><p>The different sounds had a searching quality, as if they too, were looking still, to figure out how to inhabit this city, which for several of us on this walk, though certainly not all, remains quite unfamiliar. Some of us just arrived in Coventry, literally from the other side of the world.</p><p>“Somewhere there.” Sarah, gesturing vaguely, across that wall, is <a href="http://www.planetstudios.co.uk/">Planet Studios,</a> world famous, for the Asian artists who recorded there, Bhangra music, Asian fusion, and continue to do so, the studios are still going strong.</p><p>She points in the direction of the bandstand in Spencer Park, on the other side of the city centre — a park I know, a place to play, to hang out — and tells us the Godivarius may well have been played there, along side T.E. Dunville, who was described by Charlie Chaplin as “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T._E._Dunville">an excellent funny man</a>.”</p><p>We hear other strings, played by a British Folk legend, unknown to me, who stuck the speaker part of a phone to his violin. Several of us nod, they know him well. He lived in Coventry for some years.</p><p>Sarah tells us about a remarkable habit of string instruments in general and violins in particular: when no-one one plays them and they are just sitting in their box, their strings may start resonating with sounds they pick up in their surroundings, when they recognise the pitch of their own strings — G, D, A, E. The technical term, I learn later, for this way of a violin being played by its surroundings is ‘sympathetic resonance.’</p><p>We walk into Ball Hill. I believe it is here my partner’s mother lived for several years, right after the Second World War, when she, age 10, arrived as a refugee from Lithuania. I only recognise it now, as we walk up the hill, past the Library, closed and with much reduced opening hours announced on the door, a sombre reminder of a cultural life not quite happening, so much reduced now.</p><p>And so we walk, in stops and starts, getting closer to the <a href="http://www.covmm.co.uk/">Coventry Music Museum</a>, and the instrument we are drawn towards, the Godivarius, on display there. This mythical instrument, so it turns out, is also quite real, and can be found in a vitrine on the second floor of the museum, half hidden behind the label describing the man who created the instrument.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*kMwMhfcR6CFTNX2q683Buw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Godivarius, a 19th Century violin, was crafted by a Coventry-based master, Arthur Rowley, who had trained in Italy with a tutor from Cremona (Italy) where Stradivarius is from.</p><p>Next time, when I hear “manufacturing” and “Coventry” in one sentence, I will think “violin.”</p><figure><img alt="Entrance to the Two Tone village in Coventry" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*E_OnyVLsRxLyLauoxDHsPA.jpeg" /></figure><p>We arrive in 2 Tone village, where the Coventry Music museum is based, and I have a brief encounter with a man with a twinkle in his eye — he asks, how was it? I registered for this walk, he says, but then I realized it was people who are not from here who are behind it.</p><p>There it is, a line drawn between those who are and those who are not, from Coventry, or as Elena Ferrante has it, between those who stayed and those who left. He has a point, in questioning whether we know what we are doing: the Web page announcing the guided walk suggested a very long duration for this relatively short walk.</p><figure><img alt="Cardboard cut out of Delia Derbyshire surrounded by instruments" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*84tKc13Y07pSoZV-1RoFIA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Onwards, into the museum, where we find Delia Derbyshire, a lifesize cut-out figure, the sound artist and composer of electronic music, also from here, Coventry, and who worked in the illustruous BBC Radiophonic workshop.</p><p>She could become that person, at a time when electronic music was not yet the world of famous (mostly) men that it is now, well done. I think of <a href="https://www.metamute.org/editorial/articles/deaf-2003-data-knitting">Data Knitting</a>, the book by Sadie Plant about the women coders who programmed computers before coding became associated with the male heroism that marks it now. She worked at the University of Warwick, did she write this in Coventry?</p><p>We walk back, past the pub where, appararently, the Specials played Ghost Town, to which I danced as a 16 year old, in a different country, a different city (Hilversum), loving the song without knowing the city it mourns, calls out and celebrates all at once.</p><p>23 October 2021.</p><p>Photos by Nirmal Puwar (Sociology, Goldsmiths).</p><p><em>The </em><a href="https://coventry2021.co.uk/what-s-on/the-godavarius-lost-and-found-and-lost-again/"><em>guided walk</em></a><em> by Sarah Farmer took place on Sunday October 17, 2021, and was organised as part of </em><a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/sampling-sounds-of-the-future"><em>Sampling Sounds of Coventry’s Future</em></a><em>, a series of events created by the Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies and the Warwick Institute of Engagement, University of Warwick, for Coventry City of Culture.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=39b2f0313017" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Small Folk Found Sounds, First Meet Up]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@warwickcim/small-folk-found-sounds-first-meet-up-794dd5ee036b?source=rss-6d585659350------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/794dd5ee036b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM)]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Aug 2021 10:58:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-02T15:25:00.796Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Adele Reed, 3 August 2021</p><p><em>What does the future of Coventry sound like? Artist Adele Reed reports on the first meet-up of the project, “Small Folk Found Sounds”, part of the Warwick Institute of Engagement-funded </em><a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/sampling-sounds-of-the-future"><strong><em>Sampling Sounds of Coventry’s Future</em></strong></a><em>.</em></p><p>On the morning of Sunday 13th June, five mothers and children met at Spencer Park in Coventry to begin a collaborative work between each-other and their small folk. In attendance were project leader Adele Mary Reed, Warwick University academic Noortje Marres, who is part of the team of researchers posing the question “<strong>What does the future of Coventry sound like?” </strong>and Coventry based parents and creatives Geeta Sarcar, Rachel Lumsden and Claire Coughlin. However, even more central to the project are the young folk: from youngest to eldest Bodhi aged 3, Kitty aged 3.5, Rubin aged 4, Violet aged 5 and also helping to facilitate today Audra aged 11. Rather serendipitously, Jay Vincent and Eole aged 2.5 and the new youngest of the small crew, joined the project towards the end of the meet up as they happened to be in the park at the same time and are super enthusiastic about its themes. Jay has joyously called the task in hand ‘sound busting’.</p><figure><img alt="A group of women sitting on grass discussing something" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/806/1*_XHvPRFqaKpVTpQjkrJF1w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Firstly we sat talking. The adults reflected on our creative practices and interests, certain noises harsh and gentle and the subsequent responses, that are regular parts of our children’s lives and sensory registers, but perhaps most importantly: how welcome we felt with our children at arts events. Part of the inspiration behind <strong>‘Found Sounds with Small Folks’ </strong>was to disrupt the typical “art project” or “artist commission” status-quo. In thinking about the future of the city, through the lens of cerebral concept-driven proposals, where were the future folk at, the literal future of our local humanity? This project seeks to ask the young ones themselves the very question — what does your city sound like? What do you want it to sound like? What might we hear next? How do we experience that, dream for it, like or dislike it?</p><p>A participant kindly shared her notes on the day: “Rachel described her daughter hearing birds in the morning, and then ticking on the metal bed to play with this sound. Claire mentions car alarms and the anxiety they sometimes invoke for her son, which they deal with by making sounds along with the car alarm, which makes it less awful. Geeta mentioned the awful saying that children should only be seen and not heard, saying that she lives in a boisterous, loud household and that is a conscious decision.”</p><p>Following our conversation the children were encouraged by their parent to respond to certain prompts, each child picking a prompt from a hat. The prompts were designed to introduce ways in which to perceive sounds in a given environment, ahead of participants carrying out self-directed exercises away from the meeting, in their own relaxed time without too many distractions. These were the practise prompts we offered:</p><figure><img alt="Images of Questions that were asked for the project" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/806/1*m1XaEckxujhArK-KPfpTSg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Bodhi responded to: How many noises can we hear all at once?</p><p>Kitty answered: What is the loudest noise in the park?</p><p>Rubin thought about: What do we hear when we get really close to something?</p><p>Violet: Does the park sound different at different times of the year?</p><p>Here is an example of one of the responses.</p><p><a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/sampling-sounds-of-the-future/new_recording_does_the_park_sound_different_at_different_times_.m4a">https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/sampling-sounds-of-the-future/new_recording_does_the_park_sound_different_at_different_times_.m4a</a></p><p>Noortje reflected: “The university is envisioning the future through new technologies like cars and scooters, but this is done from the university campus: what does the future look like from the standpoint of living in the city? Using sound as a way of working through perception. Children have an ability to perceive and detect, an openness that we lose as adults, let’s listen with them and perhaps we can regain some of this capacity?”</p><p>In addition to the practice prompts we also decided which parent + child team would head where during the summer to collect sounds and make marks for an added visual element. It was interesting to consider viewpoints from different ages of early years folk, different genders and backgrounds, and also to situate them in their own area of the city for reflection and pondering. Bodhi chose the train station, Eole the busy area of Foleshill and the park, Kitty the domestic home environment, Rubin the local woods and Violet the city centre. It was felt that this would generate a rich cacophony of ideas and attempt to encompass the varied aspects of a city. Coventry is a place of contrasts and surprises, of quiet natural beauty as well as high levels of traffic and pollution. How does a child receive the city’s infrastructure and its wildlife and how do they envisage their sense of self amongst it, especially as they imagine the future?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZnuUnIBG_KPW9PFrfZoRxw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CW6fVxkm3S2Bj867lmJwHA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KWIsIGYMYgbXG7x-t-JxSA.jpeg" /></figure><p>We are hoping to encourage an active listening in young children, broadening their horizons of the expansive world of sound and their sensory awarenesses and attention in general but not only for the child’s benefits, for an adult audience’s. Who gets to decide what belongs in galleries? Research projects and cross-discipline thinking groups like Warwick’s Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies who commission this project should invest in novel modes of thought, should disrupt the typical systems. Perhaps the kids respond with surreality, with play, with performance and in turn we learn ways in which to consider afresh as adults. The collected small folk findings will take on a form centre stage, tearing the envelope open on the conventions of ‘art’, assembling within an original audio composition formulated by Adele for a performance at Just Dropped In in October alongside the other commissioned works within the wider project.</p><p><a href="https://blog.cim.warwick.ac.uk/2021/08/02/small-folk-found-sounds-first-meet-up/">https://blog.cim.warwick.ac.uk/2021/08/02/small-folk-found-sounds-first-meet-up/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=794dd5ee036b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Celebrations in troubled times]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@warwickcim/celebrations-in-troubled-times-da0c21bad523?source=rss-6d585659350------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/da0c21bad523</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[interdisciplinary]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM)]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Sep 2020 08:48:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-28T05:32:08.151Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/727/1*zoNPZ8s7byCgfFVPy6-riA.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/pause-for-thought/">Pause for Thought: Media Literacy in an Age of Incessant Change</a></figcaption></figure><p>As the new academic year is about to start, it is difficult to ignore the anxious uncertainty looming over universities, staff and students. Even the lovely mid-September weather felt uneasy, like a warning. What will this year bring? What we know already is that 2020–21 is an academic year we will not forget and probably not for the best reasons. As CIM prepares to welcome new students and resume term activities we share many of these troubles and concerns with colleagues and communities all over the UK and beyond.</p><p>But in spite and because <em>of</em> these troubled times and worrying futures, and to power up the enormous energy they are going to require from everyone! celebrations of things to which we look forward, however fragile they might be, are something we are going to need more than ever.</p><p>This is why we are starting the year with a post celebrating our enthusiasm to continue nurturing CIM as an interdisciplinary space for research that is as exploratory and experimental as it is connected to these complex times and conditions. The projects and ongoing research that we are undertaking or initiating this autumn are a demonstration of this commitment as well as a manifestation of interdisciplinarity in action — reflected not only in the varied topics and types of methodologies at play, the range of partnerships and collaborations, but also by a variety of funders of a range of recent awards obtained this summer by CIM staff, unusually found together in one small department — AHRC, NERC, ESRC, EPSRC, the Alan Turing Institute, UKRI, Wellcome and ERC.</p><p>Maybe the most time-appropriate is to start highlighting research that relates to the upheaval brought by the COVID-19 pandemic — funded by this summer’s UKRI Covid-19 Emergency call. Michael Dieter and Nate Tkacz are currently co-investigating with colleagues at the University of Amsterdam, the emergence of apps as a <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/covid-19-app-store-and-data-flow-ecologies">key response to COVID-19</a>. They draw on an interdisciplinary set of ‘multi-situated’ app methods to investigate these apps as media ecological artefacts, that is, not as isolated tech devices but as part of an interrelated ecology of data and infrastructures. They aim to provide an assessment of the governance risks and ethical challenges posed to the public by these new apps. At the same time, Cagatay Turkay is co-leading a <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/visualising-contact-networks">project</a> with colleagues at Swansea University and the Zeeman Institute at Warwick, investigating the temporal, spatial and social aspects of contact networks. Developed through a human-centred approach, the resulting visual analytics methods will aim to inform public health policies and be vehicles for informing the public on policy decisions in informative and transparent ways.</p><p>Many of our projects demonstrate the continuous efforts of CIM researchers to track and analyse rapid technological change. Scott Wark, in collaboration with Tom Sutherland at the University of Lincoln has obtained funding for an AHRC network calling to “<a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/pause-for-thought/">Pause for Thought</a>” to collectively explore ways of reconceiving media literacy. They ask “how we as individuals can navigate the fluctuations of our hyper-mediated world” as a broader public concern that media studies can help understand and challenge. Together with colleagues in the Internet and Society Institute in Berlin and Sciences Po in Paris, Noortje Marres, Michael Castelle and James Tripp have also obtained funding to analyse and challenge technological determinist accroaches to the current “<a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/research_themes/intelligent-futuring/">AI tsunami</a>” and explore AI as a socio-technical phenomenon that is underpinned by fundamental constructions not least that of the “problem-solving capacity” of technology. The project will create a baseline of sociological data to contextualize the initial proliferation of 21st-century AI and conduct experiments in participation in AI with design researchers. As AI technologies permeate every aspect of everyday life it becomes urgent to demonstrate that multiple integrations of AI into society are possible!</p><p>Meanwhile Matt Spencer enters the second year of an <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/scaling-trust">UKRI Leadership fellowship</a>, dedicated to tackle another issue that will not go away, cyber security and the challenges that it poses to our trust on digital infrastructures. Shifting the problem of trust from the user to the sociotechnical context, and using of ethnographic and participatory methods, this project explores how professional cyber security practices work to win and maintain trust, to question it and manage it across scales. Also timely as ever in an era where data science is increasing used for the capture of multiple and complex temporalities is Turing Fellow Emma Uprichard’s research in this area, currently testing and developing ways in which linked data can be used to capture the multiple “momenta” and multi-dimensional ‘rates of change’ within a system, in order to improve the modelling of future trends for policy <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/modelling-future-tempos-for-complex-policy/">purposes</a>. Also trying to help us navigate the data age, is UKRI funded <em>WAYS of seeing</em> project, led by Greg McInerny and James Tripp, with the goal to develop tools which enhance people’s capacity to visualise data, by letting them <em>see what can and can’t be seen </em>in the visualisation, leading to greater capacity to understand the properties of those visualisations. Finally, Celia Lury and Scott Wark continue their Wellcome funded interdisciplinary research project <a href="https://peoplelikeyou.ac.uk/">People Like You</a> with colleagues at Goldsmiths and Imperial college on how taken-for-granted concepts of the person are being challenged by data science, medicine and digital culture with consequences for individual and collective health and well-being.</p><p>Current ecological concerns are also at the heart of a number of projects in CIM. Nerea Calvillo continues looking to transform the ways we engage with our changing environment through data-driven environmental mediations, a unique combination of creative and theoretical research. Invited by <em>LAZNIA Centre for Contemporary Art</em> and with support of Warwick’s <em>Centre for Digital Inquiry,</em> her piece Sensors Feeling in Lockdown will be presented at the international “<a href="https://ars.electronica.art/keplersgardens/en/sensory-orders-exhibition/">Sensory Orders</a>” exhibition this fall. Transformations of ecological relations are also at the heart of Maria Puig de la Bellacasa’s research on conceptual, aesthetic and practical dimensions of <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/0038026119830601">relations with soils</a> which she will continue this year with support of an AHRC Leadership Fellowship for a project aimed at exploring more than human re-inventions of ecological belonging across scientific, artistic and eco-activist practices. In a time where biodiversity is under increasing pressure, Greg McInerny and Cagatay Turkay advance visualisation research in a <a href="https://www.ceh.ac.uk/news-and-media/news/innovative-digital-projects-boost-environmental-research">NERC funded project</a> to enhance existing biodiversity information by enabling citizen scientists understand where their recording efforts would be most valuable. This collaborative project will produce fine-resolution distribution models for about 1000 insect species of moths, butterflies and grasshoppers across the UK using earth observation sensor data. The models help inform ’adaptive sampling’, which proposes individualised areas and species for recording to citizen scientists. Finally, WIRL-COFUND/CIM Research Fellow, <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/people/alex-stingl/">Alexander Stingl</a>, continues critically analysing the emergence of the Bioeconomy at the interstices of biotechnological development, policy-making, and legal adjudications focusing on the co-constitutive intertwinement of the bioeconomy discourses with legal practices.</p><p>Finally, other pressing contemporary issues, brought to the fore by an atmosphere heavy with political unrest and protest voicing injustices and demands, are at the heart of Naomi Waltham-Smith’s research and her new monograph entitled <em>Shattering Biopolitics: Militant Listening and the Sound of Life </em>out in 2021. She also continues her research <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/listening-democracy-deconstruction">on listening and democracy</a> with a project funded by Warwick’s Faculty of Social Sciences Research Development Fund that seeks new ways to think the relations between aurality, participation, and society by combining philosophical approaches with sound studies, as well practice-based sound methods — which are also core to her project <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/cart-otographies-of-cities">soundmapping urban political economies</a> funded by Warwick’s Productivity and Futures of Work Global Research Priority. David Stark, meanwhile, is continuing his ERC funded research on <a href="https://blindspot.cim.warwick.ac.uk/">Diversity and Performance</a> and together with colleagues is now embarking on new projects of large-scale data analysis working with Mechanical Turk and Wikipedia data sets.</p><p>The variety of intersecting disciplines, approaches reflected in these and between these projects shows how CIM acts as an incubator for atypical combinations — including environmental, computer social and data science, media studies, philosophy, architecture, design, sound studies, sociology, anthropology, data visualisation, history of science and cultural theory. And while this lively cohabitation is far from straightforward, most of the time these collaborations, synergies, and exciting experimentations keep us looking forward and excited about the worth of research, for itself and as a way to participate in tackling the social, political and ecological challenges our worlds are facing.</p><p>Wishing you all the best for the start of this academic year. We hope you will be in touch.</p><p>Take care,</p><p>CIM</p><p>(To know more about all these projects and more, you can browse our <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/research-projects/">Research Projects page</a><a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/research-projects/).">).</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=da0c21bad523" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[#Locations #Devices #Relations:‘Corona Testing on Twitter’ workshop report 22–23 June.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@warwickcim/locations-devices-relations-corona-testing-on-twitter-workshop-report-22-23-june-9953b83f4871?source=rss-6d585659350------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9953b83f4871</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM)]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 10 Jul 2020 13:27:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-10T16:43:41.972Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Shona Lee (DiaDev Research Fellow, University of Edinburgh)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/910/1*lphfyewQPzlUEaDD0GfWNA.png" /><figcaption><em>How can Twitter data be used to “tease out” relational figurations of testing beyond the laboratory?</em></figcaption></figure><p>Over 22–23 June, in collaboration with King’s College London <a href="https://www.kcl.ac.uk/ddh">Department of Digital Humanities</a> and <a href="https://www.publicdatalab.org/">the Public Data Lab</a>, <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/">the Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies</a> convened a two-day online workshop, ‘<a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/news/covid-19-testing-on-twitter/"><em>Corona Testing on Twitter: Surfacing testing situations beyond the laboratory</em></a><em>’, </em>to collaboratively analyse Twitter data and facilitate a dialogue about the social life of Covid-19.</p><p>As a research fellow with the <a href="http://www.diadev.eu/">DiaDev project</a> (investigating diagnostic devices in global health) at the University of Edinburgh, I signed up for the workshop just as we embarked on launching our rapid research project <em>Testing and Trust</em>, a qualitative study examining the social value of COVID-19 testing and public trust in the pandemic response in Scotland. Having recently adapted our own methods to digital platforms, the workshop came as a timely and welcome opportunity to reflect on research approaches, and learn from experienced colleagues long adept to digital methods before they became the unexpected centrepiece of our daily working lives.</p><p>The workshop<em> </em>invited participants to contribute to two days of collaborative research to reveal, or ‘surface’ the multiplicity of COVID-19 testing situations that arise and unfold outside of the laboratory environment. Our trove, a vast database of over 75 million tweets captured using T-CAT, was compiled by the CIM Academic Technology team since the end of April 2020. While querying and sifting through the kinds of testing situations described on Twitter was one objective, another would be testing the kinds of articulations made possible, and shaped by the Twitter architecture. As prominent voice on the Coronavirus pandemic on Twitter, KCL’s Carlo Caduff commented recently on the appearances and expressions of judgement facilitated through Twitter:</p><p>“<em>In Twitter, life assumes a particular form of appearance: an ongoing series of events in search of a caption. People are commenting online about things that occur in their life or in the world […] People bear witness, express themselves, and let other people know whether they agree with something or not — or how they think about it — and that frequently takes the form of an opinion or a judgment” </em>(<a href="http://www.americananthropologist.org/2020/07/02/covid-twitter-and-critique-an-interview-with-carlo-caduff/">Caduff and Bonilla, 2020</a>).</p><p>Tweets as expressions of judgement, it turns out, would be a key observation and point of discussion across our parallel forums of analysis. Caduff remarks that Twitter’s limitations as a mode of communication can limit our critical analysis of its content, in that it <em>“reduces critique to the idea of judgment, rather than seeing critique as something that is about conditions of possibility.”</em> Dr Jonathan Gray’s workshop presentation on ‘curating datasets and environments of interpretation’ was perhaps more optimistic in this respect, encouraging us to consider the utility of tweets in the context of critical analytics to elicit conversations and “surface a more diverse ecology of practices and conceptions of testing in society”. Finishing with the interesting etymology of the word ‘tease’ (pluck, pull, tear; pull apart, comb fibres of wool etc.), he described a process of “teasing out” relational figurations of testing from the data. The tactility and associations of this analogy stayed with me throughout our activities.</p><p>We were also encouraged to undertake detailed ‘collective note taking’ to explore the possibilities of different styles of data analysis, documenting our process and progress, the breakthroughs and frictions that arose from our individual and collective experiments. To facilitate this curation, organisers established collaborative environments across multiple modes of communication and recording: Zoom breakout chat rooms, google doc diaries, slack channels and presentation slides — each assembling and compiling an inventory of collective discussion points, reflections, data drops and visualisations from our respective working groups’ excavations. Each group has a Slack channel to post links to document folders, datasets, images, and questions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cWuuJlITcLE_90eLdf0Kfw.png" /></figure><p>The #anecdotal-situations Slack channel created a space for sharing testing situations outside of our dataset. I was intrigued how this post depicted how ‘critical testing infrastructures’ take shape in rural settings.</p><p>The Zoom platform would be our digital meeting place, with the format emulating the physical workshop in its agenda and group work structure. Simple gestures became familiar and comforting reference points we could draw in our new socially distant working environment. One of the organisers volunteered to be our ‘roving’ facilitator, monitoring each group’s Slack channels and responding to questions and providing technical support where needed. When re-joining the main call ‘room’ after breakout sessions, participants found themselves transplanted into other groups’ overlapping discussions. Someone jestingly remarked how these abrupt re-entries into shared digital spaces were not unlike returning for a plenary in our more familiar face-to-face workshop, where “there is always that one group” running over time and taking over the lecture hall, while others filter in with their own unfinished conversations.</p><p>The workshop began with a round of engaging and accessible presentations from Professor Noortje Marres and Dr Jonathan Gray introducing the concept note framing the theoretical framework and questions for the workshop (helpfully illustrated with key readings and examples from our dataset).</p><blockquote><strong><em>What type of testing situations can be surfaced through an interpretative analysis testing on Twitter?</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>What can this tell us about the ways in which Corona testing puts social relations, and society, to the test?</em></strong></blockquote><p>Dr James Tripp’s informative introduction to the T-CAT dataset explained how the large dataset were made more manageable by creating three subsets, or ‘bins’, and allocating them to different groups to analyse over the course of the workshop. These would allow us to split up and explore the data in more depth around three topics, or ‘situations’ of testing, and the primary methods each group would be testing:</p><pre>┌────────┬──────────┬─────────┬─────────────────┐<br>│<strong> Topic </strong> │ Location │ Devices │ Relations       │<br>│ <strong>Method</strong> │ Lexicon  │ Images  │ Topic Modelling │<br>└────────┴──────────┴─────────┴─────────────────┘</pre><p>After a fascinating round of presentations from group facilitators on the topics and methods involved, I opted to join the ‘Relations’ work group.</p><p><strong>Topic Modelling #Relations</strong></p><p>Topic Modelling is a type of data mining technique that uses “unsupervised” learning algorithms to scan and extract (or tease?) ‘hidden’ topics from large volumes of text. The topic model then produces probabilistic maps of topics, or collections of words, that are semantically related under a theme. The first day’s afternoon session primarily focused on gaining some familiarity with the capabilities and limitations of the Topic Modelling tool. Three further topic queries were created from the Relations query dataset:</p><p><strong><em>Query-1:</em></strong><em> family OR granddad OR grandfather OR grandma OR grandmother OR grandpa OR granny OR mother OR mum</em></p><p><strong><em>Query-2:</em></strong><em> boyfriend OR girlfriend OR husband OR wife OR partner</em></p><p><strong><em>Query-3</em></strong><em>: society OR state OR community OR nation OR divide</em></p><p>For our fellow ‘Relations’ group members, the sub-queries relating to family members and partners presented an opportunity to explore situations of domestic violence. For others, behavioural or moral situations expressed through hashtags such as #COVIDIOTS could potentially reveal how Twitter can be used as a medium for social policing and passing moral judgement on others. My own interests piqued at the mention of a sub-query on state and society relations, which I hoped might surface situations of institutional trust and biological citizenship conferred by testing.</p><p>Individual examination of each subset in our bin to draw out prominent or surprising terms as an exercise to understand topics. By interrogating the groups of words that appeared closely together on each topic, through both ‘distant’ and ‘close’ reading of tweets, we were able to identify overarching situations elicited by the keywords (e.g. waiting for a test) which opened further avenues of investigation and narrow the queries to re-run back to T-CAT. Our ‘Topic Modelling Experiments’ folder became the ledger for this iterative exercise.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*140YHVxf_rBNWgO748gDNQ.png" /><figcaption>The Topic Modelling API interface displays words grouped closely in relation to each other. Each topic (circle on the left) broke these groupings down (bars on the right).</figcaption></figure><p>This zooming in and out, from the ‘distant’ to ‘close’ reading of data epitomised for me the processual ‘teasing out’ of data; as a collaborative attempt to not just comb through and map these situational ‘webs’, but to identify and contest what “counts” as a situation when analysing Twitter data. Documenting what counts in this collaborative note taking process, as well as what is discounted helps us to think about how our interpretive readings can shape the data we co-produce (in this case running new queries and subsets), or as one participant raised, “what do we do with what’s missing?”</p><p>We found topic modelling an excellent way to situate analysis on the level of expression and frequency, using other methods such as word trees used to visualise word frequency and roots.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oezK8Ol2a-wLBAvti2DizA.png" /><figcaption>Word tree from judgement term ‘should’, created by Jason Davies (https://www.jasondavies.com/wordtree/)</figcaption></figure><p>In terms of technical limitations, the algorithm typically scans large documents, and as we analysed tweets as individual distinct documents in the data set (rather than collated into one large document), this could lead to a certain amount of noise. For example, we found retweets created some distortion and topics to cluster around particular news stories. These tensions highlighted both the strengths and limitations of topic modelling; while the interface could not necessarily facilitate a close critical analysis of tweets, considering the sheer size of the dataset at hand it was extremely useful in signposting and directing avenues of in-depth investigation. By mapping out possible situations, we could then use other methods, such as image grids or word trees as ways to further explore probable situations.</p><p><strong>Teasing the Magic from the Machine</strong></p><p>When we were transported and re-assembled one last time into our virtual lecture hall on the second day, each group presented the fruits of their experimentations. Our respondent Christian Nold then wrapped up the workshop thoughtfully by reflecting on whether there was something ‘natively digital’ in the ‘magic of the machine’. Is it the process of interpretive discovery and returning to the data, where human researchers bring sociological understanding to terms found by the algorithm, or the nature of these online methods that makes digital collaboration among researchers plausible and smooth that makes them truly digitally native?</p><p>As for my own take away from our online workshop experience, tugging on the thread of Jonathan Gray’s analogy I’m reminded of a visit some years ago to Knockando Woollen Mill in northern Scotland. Alongside the modern working machinery, the mill houses an impressive display of original Victorian mechanical teasel gigs that semi-automated the artisan practice of refining wool since local farmers brought their fleeces for yarning 230 years ago. While these seemingly complicated machines appear to produce patterns merely through repetitive automated motions under instruction, their magic is in the close attention of their operators that know their limitations intimately enough to work creatively within them.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zyEfIwtO7vFILwjoIdpHkg.png" /><figcaption>Teasels at Knockando Woollen Mill, Scotland. Photo © <a href="https://www.geograph.org.uk/profile/9616">Julian Paren</a> (<a href="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/">cc-by-sa/2.0</a>).</figcaption></figure><p>As we adapt to a rapidly evolving research landscape with new technological possibilities, I think on the magic to be found in digital tools and datasets like Twitter. Over the course of the workshop I gained a superficial understanding of what these can offer, and a renewed appreciation of the expertise of researchers who hone and share their craft so that the knowledge we weave can be teased apart and re-traced, to reveal both what is counted and what is missing. It is perhaps not only the surfacing of situations that Twitter data can facilitate, but the texture, or <em>surface</em> of data; the clusters, trees, clouds, and graphs that digital tools can shape the Twittersphere landscape into and gesture to conditions of possibility. Tweets can be “<em>a kind of public notebook […] orientations, diagnostic, or suggestions for another politics of life” </em>(Caduff and Bonilla, 2020)<em>,</em> which can be used as departure points to elicit conversations about Covid testing and society. In our group’s experience using topic modelling, they can even articulate different <em>ways of</em> starting such conservations. Some of the conversations elicited during this workshop will continue at the DMI Summer School, and through collaborative publications. I have certainly taken away a great deal from these conversations and research approaches to inform my own work on COVID-19 testing beyond the laboratory.</p><p><em>Dr Shona Lee is a Medical Anthropologist and Postdoctoral Research Fellow at the University of Edinburgh. She works on the EU funded DiaDev project, where she is currently leading the project Testing and Trust (‘Building trust in a global pandemic: Public perceptions, expectations and experiences of COVID-19 testing in Lothian, Scotland’) funded by the Chief Scientist Office’s </em><a href="https://www.cso.scot.nhs.uk/rapid-research-in-covid-19-programme/"><em>Rapid Research in Covid -19</em></a><em> programme.</em></p><p><em>The author wishes to thank the organisers and participants for delivering an engaging workshop and supportive working environment in challenging times.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9953b83f4871" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Coronavirus-19’S 2 Metre Rule As A Grid Reaction]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@warwickcim/coronavirus-19s-2-metre-rule-as-a-grid-reaction-4ddbd8003887?source=rss-6d585659350------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4ddbd8003887</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM)]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Apr 2020 20:15:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-27T20:15:48.530Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>First published on the<a href="https://peoplelikeyou.ac.uk/blog/coronavirus-19s-2-metre-rule-as-a-grid-reaction/"> People Like You blog</a></p><p><strong>Sophie Day and Celia Lury</strong> (Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies)</p><p>We are all now familiar with what 2 metres looks like, as we go for solitary walks in parks or stand in queues to shop for family and friends. We draw lines, we stand aside or behind or in front of others; we walk around and in parallel to each other.</p><p>Improvising, trying out ways to be ‘close up, at a distance’ (Kurgan 2013), we leave food outside doors and put our hands to windows separating us from friends and relatives who cannot leave their homes. Participating in group chats, we appear to ourselves and others as one talking head among others. We sing across balconies, we mute ourselves in synchronized patterns. Our actions producing insides and outsides, we appear alone together.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/381/1*IL2JuEUwwVJUiZ1EtO6SEQ.png" /></figure><p>In describing 2 metres as a <em>social</em> distance, we acknowledge that we are part of a bigger picture. But who is it a picture of and how does it come about? How is the compulsion of proximity (Boden and Molotch 1994) — the need to be close to others — being reconfigured as proximity at a (social) distance? And what kind of social is this? Does it add up to a society? Who is included and who is left outside? Are we all in this together?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/393/1*VA3gHWjsiaY2DMQu20o_tg.png" /></figure><p>In the 2 metre rule and the complicated guidance about who has to stay indoors and who can go out and why, we see <em>grid reactions</em>. This is a phrase used by <a href="http://somatosphere.net/author/biao-xiang/">Biao Xiang</a> in his discussion of the management of the COVID-19 epidemic in China by already existing administrative units. <a href="http://somatosphere.net/forumpost/from-chain-to-grid-reaction/">He says</a>, ‘Residential communities, districts, cities and even entire provinces act as grids to impose blanket surveillance over all residents, minimize mobilities, and isolate themselves. In the Chinese administrative system, a grid is a cluster of households, ranging from 50 in the countryside to 1000 in cities. Grid managers (normally volunteers) and grid heads (cadres who receive state salaries) make sure that rubbish is collected on time, cars are parked properly, and no political demonstration is possible. During an outbreak, grid managers visit door to door to check everyone’s temperature, hand out passes which allow one person per household to leave home twice a week, and in the case of collective quarantine, deliver food to the doorstep of all families three times a day.’</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/645/1*u3QWBMW4aEhZI5FRyDXlug.png" /><figcaption>Image posted by Adam Jowett, April 20th, 2020, adapted from Fathromi Ramdlon, via <a href="https://pixabay.com/illustrations/physical-distancing-social-distancing-4987118/">https://pixabay.com/illustrations/physical-distancing-social-distancing-4987118/</a></figcaption></figure><p>While gridding has long been a core technology of rule through centralised command and control according to the priorities of military, state and industrial logistics, the pandemic is leading to a multiplicity of grid reactions. In the UK, some grids are imposed, while others are improvised. We (variously) wear face masks, choreograph meetings in Zoom (faces within faces, faces on their own, face by face, just <em>not face to face</em>), and order goods on-line while governments refuse to let cruise ship passengers disembark, impose 2 metres outside care homes but not inside, divert PPE from one country to another, and close borders to people, but not to goods. There is no single grid in operation. We are all making neighbours differently.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/718/1*c9sR85pJBDEuDPNMFvKeew.png" /></figure><p>As we do so, we learn about grids; they can be creative, they can be fun, but grid reactions also make visible the social of social distancing and the politics of proximity. For example, watch a man from Toronto wearing a so-called “<a href="https://globalnews.ca/news/6812047/coronavirus-toronto-social-distancing-machine/">social distancing machine</a>” (a hoop with a 2 metre radius that a person can wear around their middle) while walking around the city.</p><p>The aim of this machine was to show that sidewalks (the North American word for pavements seems especially appropriate right now) are too narrow, particularly when people are being asked to socially distance. Its creator, Daniel Rotsztain, who is part of the Toronto Public Space Committee, a group that advocates for more “inclusive and creative” public spaces, said to Global News Radio AM 640, ‘I think even before COVID, you could say that pedestrians are jostling for space in Toronto, but COVID really exposed that’. He proposes that some streets should be closed to traffic to give pedestrians more room to maintain distance. In the grip of a pandemic, the grids of family, household, and district — the negotiation of which are so fundamental to social life — can no longer be taken for granted. Some grid reactions are described in terms of shielding the vulnerable, but who are they really shielding — those inside or those outside? For whom does a home become a prison, and when does a cruise ship become a floating container?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/674/1*kX8OG0J-PrLJ6UA1kaZgog.png" /><figcaption>Still, Ryan Rocca, “Coronavirus: Man wears ‘social distancing machine’ to show local sidewalks are ‘too narrow’. Global News, April 13, 2020: <a href="https://globalnews.ca/news/6812047/coronavirus-toronto-social-distancing-machine/">https://globalnews.ca/news/6812047/coronavirus-toronto-social-distancing-machine/</a></figcaption></figure><p>A grid seems to freeze time within spatial relations but it is a way of managing mobility. We move up the queue outside the supermarket in sequenced intervals rather than as and when we like. While the grid seems fixed, it calibrates movement — the transmission of a virus, for example — assigning spatial and metric values to this temporal process in an interplay of number based code and patterning (Kuchler 2017). In the UK, 2 metres is the measure that is being imposed to mediate the Ro or basic reproduction number, the number that indicates how many new cases one infected person generates. Recognizing 2 metres as a social distance acknowledges that transmission is not simply a matter of biology, but of <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/datablog/ng-interactive/2020/apr/22/see-how-coronavirus-can-spread-through-a-population-and-how-countries-flatten-the-curve">how social life is gridded</a>. But while the Ro conventionally takes the individual person as the unit of transmission, the examples above suggest that it is the operation of <em>multiple</em> grid reactions — and the failure or success of the interoperability of their metrics — which matters. We need to ask: what kinds of families fit into what kinds of households into what kinds of schools? how do they inter-connect? how differently permeable are private homes, second homes and social care homes? how will apps measure social distance? And perhaps most importantly, how do grid reactions change the ways in which the virus discriminates? In what has been described as a very large experiment, the interoperability of grids is being tested in real time across diverse informational surfaces — models, materials, walls, windows, screens, apps and borders — to create new grids with as yet unknown consequences.</p><p><strong>Bibliography</strong></p><p>Boden, D. and Molotch, H. L. (1994) The compulsion of proximity in R. Friedland and D. Boden (eds.) <em>Now/Here: Space, Time and Modernity</em>, University of California Press, pp. 257–286.</p><p>Jowett, Adam. (2020) Carrying out qualitative research under lockdown — Practical and ethical considerations. At<a href="https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2020/04/20/carrying-out-qualitative-research-under-lockdown-practical-and-ethical-considerations/">https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2020/04/20/carrying-out-qualitative-research-under-lockdown-practical-and-ethical-considerations/</a></p><p>Kuchler, S. (2017) Differential geometry, the informational surface and Oceanic art: The role of pattern in knowledge economies, <em>Theory, Culture and Society</em>, 34(7–8): 75–97.</p><p>Kurgan, L. (2013) <em>Close Up at a Distance: Mapping, Technology, and Politics</em>, The MIT Press.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4ddbd8003887" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Indicating Interdisciplinarity in Artificial Intelligence workshop]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@warwickcim/indicating-interdisciplinarity-in-artificial-intelligence-workshop-fef2e49f27fa?source=rss-6d585659350------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fef2e49f27fa</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM)]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 28 Feb 2020 19:46:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-02T17:11:52.735Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>A day of looking at interdisciplinarity through an interdisciplinary lens</em></p><p>Maria Petrescu (Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies)</p><p>On February 6th, the <em>Indicating Interdisciplinarity in AI </em>workshop brought together partners of our collaborative project <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/inventing-indicators-of-interdisciplinarity"><em>Inventing Indicators of Interdisciplinarity</em></a>, developed by Noortje Marres in collaboration with colleagues at the Centre for Science and Technology Studies (CWTS), University of Leiden. Aligned with one of our core research themes, <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/research/research_themes/interdisciplinary-methods-and-methodologies/"><em>Interdisciplinary methods and methodologies</em></a>, the project aims to find ways for indicators to be more than “instruments of measurement”, but sites of methodological innovation, participation and creativity which would “not bracket but enable the exploration of the differences and asymmetries between disciplines” (Lury, Lammes, Uprichard et al, 2018).</p><p>In the first talk after the introduction, Tommaso Venturini (Centre for Internet and Society, CNRS) presented his <a href="https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1NJK0yIecPx0Xc0hdpSpeg5ybqKAwwmecD9nlm6OAttg/edit#slide=id.g5fda19e4d7_0_68">work</a> (in collaboration with Axel Meunier from SciencesPo médialab) for the Global Forum on Artificial Intelligence for Humanity (Paris, 2019). In order to frame Humanity as more than “general ideas of ethics”, but as including humanities and social sciences, they produced a “mapping of the field of AI”, encouraging dialogues between natural sciences, social sciences and information sciences. By visualising networks of co-citation (pairs of academic articles cited together in a third paper) for articles and conference proceedings from ISI Web of Science and superimposing metadata (including authors and institutions related to each article), they presented the public with possibilities to recognise themselves, their academic departments, and emergent disciplinary areas, and enabling new ways of interpreting the maps. Specifically designed to be a “political intervention in a political space” (as Venturini later clarified in the brief Q&amp;A session), this work brought several design “twists” which I believe deserve special mention, starting from forgoing the suggestion to project the maps on an interactive screen and using not-so-high-quality paper and highlighters instead, thus abandoning the god-like viewpoint implied by traditional network visualisations with clear node/edge delimitations.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UMGST68g5Y0Yd5Sc6-18iw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 1 Tommaso Venturini (CNRS)</figcaption></figure><p>Following this, Ludo Waltman (CWTS) initiated a provocation for us to reflect together on how questions about interdisciplinarity and AI can be answered from a scientometric point of view and how we can use bibliometrics more productively. With a clear emphasis on the black-boxed nature of the act of field delineation (he later noted his own refusal to delineate the field of AI), Waltman suggested a move from the traditional bibliometric approach (as shown in the pipeline in Fig. 2) to a model where the last two steps are replaced by<em> indicators of scientific fields</em> and <em>mapping of scientific fields (relationships between fields)</em>, respectively. In the end, Waltman clarified that even if the acts of labelling undertaken along the pipeline are subjective, his aim is to “provide tools” to facilitate discussions about what AI might mean and thus to “arrive at a <em>number of different perspectives about what AI could be</em>” (emphasis added).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YWN5oc5ddnMdwi7Bm22UFA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 2 Ludo Waltman (CWTS)</figcaption></figure><p>Just as thought-provoking as Venturini and Waltman’s presentations, the brief discussion that followed raised a broad range of pertinent considerations. These included comments about the potential usefulness of dynamically visualising the evolution of field delineations over time (Alexander Stingl, CIM) and notes on the possibility to delineate “the AI that we care about now” by “following the historical track of connectionist resurgence” (Michael Castelle, CIM).</p><p>Throughout this discussion, however, the <strong><em>constructedness</em></strong><em> of disciplines, interdisciplinarity and of measures of interdisciplinarity themselves</em> emerged as the leitmotif. This became apparent in comments on the researchers’ role in labelling disciplines (Cagatay Turkay, CIM), on interdisciplinarity potentially becoming invisible if the research process begins from already-delineated fields (Matt Spencer, CIM), in clarifications of the value of interdisciplinarity as highlighting “knowledge in formation” (Prof. Noortje Marres, CIM), and in Tommaso Venturini’s remark (which elicited a round of smiles in a room full of researchers of interdisciplinarity) that “there is no such thing as interdisciplinarity” because “disciplines are constructs” and we are all “playing a <em>language game</em> of creating boundaries” (emphasis added).</p><p>After this discussion, Ismael Rafols (CWTS) moved the discussion further, into the realms of decision-making. More specifically, addressing the question of <em>“How can we help decisions be made while preserving diversity?”</em>, he explained how the trade-off between conventional indicators and mapping (of interdisciplinarity, in this case) is one between pluralising the discourse on the one hand and helping close down the debate, on the other hand. He later clarified that he is not interested in fostering closure, but in helping each user find their own closure. As such, he proposes using maps “together with the decision makers” and approaching them from “the toad’s view”, thus “produc[ing] an understanding which is specific, but which <em>can be traced to a series of subjective choices</em>” (emphasis added). In this process, one could start by learning about the different understandings of interdisciplinarity for such maps. <em>Is it about the distribution of different bodies of research across diverse topics? Or about the engagement between distant methodologies? Or between disciplines which are very far apart? </em>Through this type of questions, indicat-ing (as a verb) becomes a way of helping users and decision-makers <em>dive into the map</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pc4XPuIAhMCC_kCPMSH5GQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 3 Ismael Rafols — from mapping to indicating</figcaption></figure><p>The lunch break was followed by a round table discussion with presentations by Rodrigo Costas Comesaña (CWTS), CIM’s Greg McInerny and CIM academic alumna (now at Leiden University) Prof. Sybille Lammes, moderated by Thomas Franssen (CWTS).</p><p>Rodrigo Costas Comesaña started the session by introducing altmetrics and advocating for a move beyond science-science interactions, towards looking at science-society interactions. In this regard, altmetrics represent a potential enrichment of typical metrics with data gathered mostly from social media (Twitter, LinkedIN, blogs <em>et cetera</em>). In this scenario, the type of insights derived from Ludo Waltman and Tommaso Venturini’s projects would be taken beyond the realm of scientific literature by detecting “heterogenous couplings” in social media debates about science and innovation, articles shared and tagged (for example, in the same tweet or by the same account) and so on.</p><p>Greg McInerny continued the discussion by bringing to the foreground assumptions made when visualising bibliometric data, especially in the form of networks. More specifically, he pointed out that in this type of visualisation it is impossible to see what is missing in the data (i.e. network visualisations are built around the existing data, and space/clustering are but functions of data and algorithms). Then, drawing on Barry, Born and Weszkalnys’ (2008) <em>Logics of interdisciplinarity</em>, he suggested looking <em>closer</em> at the different <em>types of interactions (synthesis, subordination</em> and <em>agonistic-antagonistic</em>) between disciplines, as opposed to entire networks of knowledge. In the end, he proposed that Visualisation should not be subordinated in this type of work and that conceptualising the types of interdisciplinary interactions would be a great source of enrichment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0cjlhQGEMK6O6yNVg-tZ9A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Figure 4 Prof. Sybille Lammes (University of Leiden)</figcaption></figure><p>For the last presentation of the round table, Prof. Sybille Lammes considered bringing <em>play</em> back into methods. With an analogy drawn from a conversation on deep neural networks, in which the layer right before the end result was pointed out as the most interesting level of the process (“<em>where there’s still a bit of mess[…] at the level where there’s still play</em>”), she argued that we should make room for <em>ludo-epistemology </em>to bring out different ways of interdisciplinarity which are “<em>less stable and less fixed</em>”.</p><p>Perhaps the highlight of the workshop, the prototyping exercise led by Sarah de Rijcke and Tjitkse Holtrop (CWTS), presented us with three case studies of AI deployments (self-driving cars, AI for mammography data, and face recognition). In small groups, we were encouraged to look at the unfolding of these cases in the news and to discuss specific events by adopting fictional roles including those of observers, engineers, regulators, industry and user representatives, as well as public philosophers. This shifted our attention to the disciplines being brought into (and also ignored by) public discussions and discourses, how attitudes and alliances between specific types of actors emerged naturally in each group (for example, between industry representatives and engineers) and how interdisciplinarity is present (and indicated, or not) in each case.</p><p>In the final discussion, CIM Prof. Celia Lury insisted on the importance of considering the questions of <em>What do we want from indicators?</em> and <em>What do indicators want from us?</em> together, pointing out that throughout the workshop discussions two understandings of <em>objectivity</em> were deployed (as “objective representation independent of the observer” and as “shared reference point”). Stemming from this, the room launched into a conversation about the generalisability of indicators, the need (or lack thereof) for indicators to be stable, the <em>language</em> of interdisciplinarity (and on how good indicators of interdisciplinarity should achieve a certain <em>polyvalence</em>).</p><p>Personally, I think some of the open-ended questions that emerged in the last few minutes of this conversation are the best take-away and the natural choice for summarising the event:</p><ul><li><em>If we don’t want indicators to feed into rankings, what do we want them to feed into? Trajectory of choice? Visualisations? Games? Stories?</em></li><li><em>How, if at all, would these help interdisciplinarity evolve?</em></li><li><em>If we care about interdisciplinarity, how can we sustain it?</em> (and here I will include a somewhat amusing answer someone whispered loud enough for only a few of us to hear: “<em>Perhaps by not indicating it at all?</em>”)</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fef2e49f27fa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Rights as Methodology?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@warwickcim/rights-as-methodology-4eb32c52076b?source=rss-6d585659350------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4eb32c52076b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM)]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Sep 2019 10:34:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-25T08:10:26.348Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Next steps in data-intensive research at the intersections of technology, law and society</strong></p><p><strong>CIM Blog, Sept 2019</strong></p><p><em>Noortje Marres (University of Warwick), Matt Spencer (University of Warwick) and Gloria González Furster (VUB)</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/1*2jUmnOxw11yZthAvLsqdcQ.png" /></figure><p>“Are you the gentlemen coming for the algorithms?” asked a nursery manager of CIM PhD student Loup Cellard and his informant during fieldwork on the French government’s algorithmic accountability initiative.</p><p>Changing infrastructures of knowledge transform relations between citizens, governments and researchers. In Loup’s case, designers and an ethnographer were brought into the world of public administration and policy, tasked with making algorithms ‘transparent’ for citizens.</p><p>New data infrastructures and new data regimes — open data, algorithmic accountability, the GDPR — create methodological possibilities as well as new objects of study. The <a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/events/rightsasmethodology/">“Rights as Methodology?” workshop</a>, at which Loup relayed this encounter, brought together scholars from legal studies, science and technology studies, philosophy and social research, and was designed to explore possibilities for collaboration between the Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (University of Warwick) andthe Research Group on Law, Science, Technology and Society (Vrije Universiteit Brussel).</p><h3>Intersecting research interests</h3><p>The workshop was informed by the following research interests.</p><p>First, for those coming from the methodological side, that of designing and doing data-intensive research in digital society and cultures, there is increasing interest in and concern with how regimes for data governance shape contemporary research agendas. With recent changes in regulatory frameworks, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), and shifts in social norms about what constitutes legitimate data use, the mutual influence of methodological and legal frameworks for “data in society” is clearer than ever before.</p><p>This can be contrasted with older concerns that used to animate debates about data-intensive social research: Since the 2010s, much work in this area, especially public interest-oriented research, used to rely on the Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) of online platforms, such as Twitter and Facebook, for data access. In relation to this research, a primary concern was that, by adopting online platforms’ data structures when conducting social research, this work was at risk of uncritically replicating ontological assumptions designed into them, such as the notion that sociality can be equated with “network-ing”. However, in the wake of recent societal scandals about data collection by social media platforms, and resultant changes in online platform settings and permissions, researchers are increasingly looking for alternative ways of accessing platform data and prominent among these are approaches which rely on individual platform users’ rights to access information, such as through data subject access requests. While rights-based research methodologies predate APIs, their increased prominence in platform research makes computational researchers much more aware of the ways methodology intersects with rights frameworks. This raises a different set of methodological questions, about the interactions, not just between social science and digital technology, but between law, social research and computation.</p><p>Second, coming from the side of a social, legal, ethical and philosophical engagement with regulatory frameworks for data governance, what is striking about our contemporary moment is a possible change in our understanding of how these frameworks can be deployed in relation to research, and whether their role is understood as constraining or enabling: Privacy and data protection law have traditionally been portrayed as an obstacle to, or at least a limitation on, the access and further processing of data in this context. There are, however, indications that thinking about the role of data protection rights is evolving, and, to some extent, being reversed. (Legal) tools are not merely or exclusively directed towards the defence of an individual’s rights and interests, but can be regarded as targeting more generally the pursuit of common goals, such as, for instance, enhancing transparency of contemporary data practices, or fighting against data-based bias and discrimination. In this context, the use of data subject rights, such as the right of access to personal data, <strong>for knowledge purposes</strong>, opens up a different, <em>constructive</em> approach to a possible exchange of properties and features of methodological and regulatory frameworks.</p><p><em>It was against this backdrop that the workshop organisers asked: under what conditions are and can “rights” be deployed “as methodology” to conduct social and cultural research in data-intensive societies?</em></p><h3>Contributions</h3><p>The day started with a presentation by <strong>René Mahieu (VUB)</strong> entitled “The right of access to personal data as a methodology.” Adopting a practice-based perspective on who uses access rights, Mahieu’s research deploys data access requests as a methodology to investigate organisational processes of transparency: his study asked 100 participants to send access requests to diverse organisations in the Netherlands, from a plastic surgery clinic to a B2B data broker. They found a great variance in the provision of information by organisations in response to these requests. The ensuing presentation, by <strong>Loup Cellard (Warwick)</strong>, was based on fieldwork in Etalab, the French government’s open data task force, and similarly analysed information requests to the French administrative data agency [CADA]. Cellard’s study focused specifically on algorithmic transparency: the commitment of the French government to make public the algorithms that underpin government services in areas as diverse as tax to the allocation of nursery places. He discussed a performative effect of these transparency initiatives: as a consequence of the public policy commitment to explain algorithms, government services are increasingly defined in algorithmic terms.</p><p>The follow-up discussion offered interesting reflections on methodological conditions of studying organisations through transparency requests: both studies bring us face to face with the <strong>relative opacity</strong> of organisational processes, as a condition for the study of transparency regimes. Both studies ended up adopting a pragmatist approach: they establish the properties of organisational transparency regimes through a study of the <strong>effects </strong>of the implementation of these regimes (which type of requests are honoured by whom and how?). Such an approach faces challenges of validity and reliability, as Dr. <strong>Rosamunde van Brakel</strong> <strong>(VUB</strong>) pointed out. But it can also be understood as extending the empiricist impulse of a big data methodology by different, experimental means: big data analysis, just as investigations based on data access requests, operates under conditions of the relatively opacity of data’s origins, and a relatively lack of knowledge about a baseline population. <strong>Cagatay Turkay (Warwick)</strong> noted that computational methods can also be used to break the opaqueness of algorithms. Taking advantage of this requires more reflection on, and a practical reworking of, explainability as not only a legal principle and a social scientific project, but as an interdisciplinary methodology.</p><p><strong>Laura Drechsler</strong> <strong>(VUB)</strong> offered lucid reflections on the research exception contained in the GDPR, and the new kinds of tests emerging as a consequence, attempting to evaluate whether research would be rendered impossible by the absence of data. <strong>Ine van Zeeland &amp; Jonas Breuer (VUB)</strong> followed this with report on their current research into the intersection of rights, design and technology in the tricky case of consent in situations under CCTV surveillance, and the potential for smart wristbands in museum settings. In his response, Professor <strong>Joris van Hoboken (VUB)</strong> reflected on wider possible ramifications of the GDPR for both academic research, focusing on the question: who gets defined as the data controller of personal data collected and analysed for research purposes? The higher education institution, or the researcher? This will make a potentially huge difference for how and by whom the relation between the researcher and research subjects is constructed. <strong>Matt Spencer</strong> <strong>(Warwick)</strong> arrived at a similar question, asking about the possibly increasingly widespread conditions under which research gets formatted as a legal process. Asking about the consequences of the leakage and/or spread of this formatting into moments and occasions previously defined in methodological — not legal — terms, Spencer asked about the likelihood of law emerging as a new master discipline in the datafied society?</p><p>The next session on Data Rights as Feminist Methodology was kicked of by <strong>Helena Suarez (Warwick)</strong> who presented her doctoral project on the digital mapping of Feminicide. Helena drew attention to the role of data visualisation in the mediation of this issue in feminist activism, noting that it inevitably mediates not merely the fact, but the <em>attribution</em> of feminicide, and thus has methodologies for the identification of victims built into it, methodologies which require explication and critical reflection. In her commentary, <strong>Naomi Waltham-Smith (Warwick)</strong> raised the question of whether and how constructivist epistemologies are capable of broaching the question of violence, as a phenomenon or event that takes us beyond questions of definition, labelling, shaping, and discursive contestation. At the same time, addressing feminicide “the interface”, in this case of digital mapping, requires de-individuating the question of violence, and not assuming “women” as already constituted subjects of the recording of deaths.</p><p><strong>Alessia Tanas (VUB)</strong> mapped privacy design approaches for the group, laying out the contrasting visions of Privacy Enhancing Technologies, Privacy by Design, Data Protection by Design, and Privacy Engineering. <strong>Richard Terry (Warwick) </strong>walked the group through the methodological possibilities of reverse engineering user data schemas through interface analysis. Later in the day <strong>Simone Casiraghi</strong> <strong>(VUB)</strong> gave his presentation “Opening the back-box of identity in biometrics practices”. Investigating what concept of identity is presupposed in biometrics, Casiraghi argued the technology enforces a reductionist approach to identity, and flagged the gap between technological and social scientific understandings of identity: between identity defined in terms of a correspondence among unique markers, versus identity as enacted and projected and fundamentally creative. The ensuing discussion opened up the question of what happens to this opposition if we adopt a practice-based perspective on the implementation of bio-metrics: as biometrics is implemented in social environments like airports, isn’t it likely that we will be able to observe the enactment of social identity with biometrics (the “privium member”) and indeed the cobbling together of the bio- and socio- processes of identification?</p><p>The final session consisted of commentary by Dr. <strong>Michael Castelle</strong> <strong>(Warwick)</strong> and Professor <strong>Mireille Hilebrandt (VUB)</strong>. Castelle outlined his conceptual framework of en- and de-textualization, the ways in which phemonena are loaded into -and out of -text as part of processes of data-fication, arguing that research based on data rights access requests will have to operate under this constraint. He noted that there is still a real clash between accountability initiatives and the dominant logic of information system production. Prof. Hildebrandt began by pointing out that there are many different types of law that must be considered in relation to machine learning, including the Machinery Directive, which regulates safety, and the GDPR, which has as one of its purposes to make consent meaningful again. She foregrounded the importance of the designed environment in the structuration of data subject-research relations: if we are to deploy data-rights pragmatistically, as discussed above, then we must take into account the choice architectures scripted in the back-end of digital architectures in societies.</p><h3>Next steps</h3><p>While there was no more time to reflect on next steps at the end of a full day, conversations during the day suggested there was broad agreement that emerging transparency and data protection regimes present both an important topic and resource for interdisciplinary research on data-intensive societies and culture. The deployment of data access requests for social research purposes presents an especially fruitful focus on this regard. This still experimental approach points towards a broader, innovative, methodological strategy: that of deploying practice-based, empiricist strategies for researching data-intensive social formations. At the same time, it must be recognized this is a methodologically challenging undertaking, as the “objects of research” surfaced by the means are marked by ambiguity: when conducting social research by means of data access requests, are we studying organisational practices, or data infrastructures? However, we do well to remember that this is a long-standing issue in digital social research, that is unlikely to just “go away’’, and unlikely to be rendered manageable through simple methodological checks in the absence of a stable baseline population. There are several precedents in social research traditions that may be helpful points of reference here, such as ethnomethodology and STS-informed work in political sociology on “trials of explicitness” (Muniesa and Linhardt, 2015) on the empirical elicitation of properties of institutions and government in public events (public ceremonies, police arrests, ..).</p><p>In this regard, one of the principal take-aways of the workshop is the proposal that the deployment of rights can enable the development of <strong>alternative methodological frameworks for analysing and specifying accountable and explainable data systems in society</strong>. Instead of assuming “”the transparency of transparency” — the ideas that AI can be made fully transparent — and readily explainable — if only the right protocol gets implemented, this approach treats data access as a <strong>methodological occasion</strong> <strong>for making public socio-technological data practices, </strong>which are likely to be marked by dynamism, ambiguity and complexity. That is, rather that presume full transparency of systems as an epistemic horizon for data-intensive research in a computational society, we would seek to develop rights-based methodologies that achieve intelligibility or “explainability” — of data-intensive social formations — under conditions of relative opacity.</p><p><em>The one-day workshop Rights as Methodology? was co-organised by Professor Noortje Marres (Warwick), Professor Gloria González Furster (VUB), and Dr. Niels van Dijk (VUB) and was supported by EUTOPIA, the European research alliance.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4eb32c52076b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Doing with/in digital]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@warwickcim/doing-with-in-digital-2b28a9be24bf?source=rss-6d585659350------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2b28a9be24bf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[conference]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Centre for Interdisciplinary Methodologies (CIM)]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 20 Aug 2019 10:23:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-08-28T13:48:10.546Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*owcXnGNSG4RmgGFr.jpg" /></figure><p><em>A blog post on the PGR conference last June by our very own Wenhao Bi.</em></p><p><a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/people/wenhao-bi/"><em>https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/people/wenhao-bi/</em></a></p><p>After roughly half a year of preparation, from setting the theme and calling for proposals to organizing panels and arranging logistics, our one-day postgraduate conference finally took place on 27th June, 2019 with two keynote talks and eleven presentations from masters and PhD students from CIM, LSE, University of Salford, University of Pittsburgh and Delhi School of Economics. On the day, the panels were structured around four main topics — participation, political economies, politics and aesthetics — and covered a range of specific issues, from tech literacy, crime-scene reconstruction, food delivery platforms, hackathons and tagging. Despite the conference being over, I see the discussions — not only <em>at</em> the conference, but also <em>for</em> the conference — as ongoing and long-lasting since the digital environment we are dealing with has become thoroughly part of our everyday lives.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*3tUYH5sxu7-3XF96hw5MBw.jpeg" /></figure><p>The decision on the theme of “with/in digital” stemmed from the different layers we experience the digital: We equip ourselves <em>with</em> digital gadgets, get involved <em>in</em> ‘the digital sphere’, and form habits and datafied personas <em>within</em> digital structures. It is more than an everyday phenomenon to be observed; it includes actions and reactions to be practised, and subjects and areas to be researched. It can involve methods and approaches we follow, but which are questioned and challenged at the same time. It is an acquaintance, if not an intimate, but at times dangerous and problematic as well. With such shared concerns, the organizing committee called for proposals — not necessarily formal academic papers — as responses to or further questions on the meaning of being with/in digital, and the role both human and non-human actors play with/in digital.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*mWtxqB6IG0Nv8zwC.jpg" /></figure><p>Many presentations at the conference some shared perspectives and approaches to the theme. Presentations on ‘Tech Literacy for Digital Natives’ by Sophie Fitzpatrick and ‘A Critical Discussion of Addiction in Digital Practices’ by Yang Qin, for instance, did not take the involvement and participation with/in digital for granted. Instead, they demonstrated an awareness of the ambiguity around narratives of user empowerment. As Christian Nold pointed out in his keynote talk with the example of RFID card, moreover, a focus on digital hardware and infrastructure should not be neglected when it comes to such critical questions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*YoGqkuFHGPVU7OAw.jpg" /></figure><p>Some proposals explored alternative presentation formats, like ‘There’s Nobody Here: On Music (Playing from another Room)’ by Jack Wilson, who performed the experience of being with data through the concept of the ghost and a visual essay. Others led us through the methodological challenges faced in their research, opening up questions about accuracy and the translation between different forms of data, like ‘Youth Participation and Power Dynamics on Social Media’ by Jessica Ussher.</p><p>In the panel on political economies, the presentations ‘The In/Expert in Digital’ by Stacy Wood, ‘Give Data, Get Work: An Overview of Data Usage on Food Delivery Platform Workers’ by Mohammad Sajjad Hussain and ‘Unpacking the Black Box of Cyberpolitics: A Literature Approach on Political Reflection in Social Media’ by myself, discussed participation, populism, ludification, truth, efficiency, and how all those play different roles in diverse configurations of digital political economies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*BaYtZt-bvC88Yt4H.jpg" /></figure><p>After lunch, the politics of data collection, and the design and mobilisation of digital platforms, were unpacked in detail in the paper ‘Where Digital Worlds Meet-Exploring Civic Hackathon Events and Data Through an Ontological Framework’ by Ville Aula alongside ‘Feminicide and Open Data’ by Helena Suárez Val in the politics panel.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*K9KolQzZ6l_-if-g.jpg" /></figure><p>And lastly, after rich exchanges during the coffee break, issues around digital aesthetics were discussed in terms of processes of tagging and labelling as forms of identity construction through ‘A Cultural Critique of Tagging-Politics and Aesthetics of Categorisation in the Age of Social Media’ by Nicola Bozzi, and the effects of the capitalisation of aesthetic trends in social mobility in ‘Microcelebrity: Gaining the Fame and Wealth on Social Media’ by Bella Shi.</p><p>As a member of the organizing committee, I appreciate all participants for sharing their work and engaging with the themes of the conference. And in particular our keynote speakers, David Garcia and Christian Nold, for their generous comments throughout the day and their inspiring talks and closing panel.</p><p>Last but not least, a big thank you to those who yielded time and effort on our conference: Michael Dieter, Sarah Doughty, Gheerdhu Mohan Kumar, Tracy Thompson, James Tripp, Nerea Calvillo, Maria Puig de la Bellacasa, Noortje Marres and Nate Tkacz.</p><p><a href="https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/events/pgconference2019/">https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/cross_fac/cim/events/pgconference2019/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2b28a9be24bf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>