<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by William S. Goldman on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by William S. Goldman on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman?source=rss-540ba7a8f83c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 13:12:39 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Crafting an Agenda]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman/crafting-an-agenda-f044897eb16e?source=rss-540ba7a8f83c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f044897eb16e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[agenda]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[election-2018]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democrats]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[William S. Goldman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Jun 2017 04:18:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-21T04:18:08.761Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gMiVWehgNL1UimJW56qxxQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Democrats need more fighters.</figcaption></figure><h4>The GOP is Trump, and Trump is the GOP. Democrats need to do more than flip voters who love what the president is giving them.</h4><p>I’m not much for moral victories, not when we need real victories, and plenty of them. Today’s Georgia 6th election was a nothing short of a disaster for the Democratic party. It wasn’t even close. Yes, it rained, and yes, the tragic Scalise shooting played a role, and yes, it’s Georgia and reliably Republican and, yes Ossoff is twelve years old, and yes, yes, yes. But that simply isn’t good enough. This was a winnable race, and a race that needed to be won. So it is worth trying to understand why this keeps happening, and chart a path forward.</p><p>Lost in the sturm und drang of a $50 million race is that voter suppression is the giant 800-pound gorilla of a white elephant in the room. The GOP is very, very smart: they don’t prohibit people from voting, they just make it more difficult and let people make the decision not to show up on their own. And this phenomenon simply does not show up in media accounts of the outcome. Frankly, mentioning it sounds like defensive sour grapes: they cheated! Mom, they cheated!!! Except that it’s real and it’s bad. I am not quite sure how to fix it, but one way is to make sure that it is constantly mentioned, over and over again, in every conversation about this stuff. It has been normalized, so we have to un-normalize it. That’s a long-term goal, and we need to start now.</p><p>Ossoff’s strategy in this race was to be a bland, harmless centrist in the Macron style and use dissatisfaction with Trump to do the work for him. But that overlooks a crucial point, one that Democrats need to learn, and fast. The marginal Republican voter does not like Donald Trump. BUT the thing they don’t like is his impulsiveness and his Twitter habit and the fact that those two things prevent him from passing his agenda. They love his policies, and they continually vote for them. The biggest myth in politics and American life right now is the pervasive one that it is racist white working class males who are the main Trump supporters, and all other Republicans are either grudging partisans, or somehow misguided. That’s flat wrong. The Republican Party supports Trump’s policies because Republican voters support his policies. His combination of racism, faux-populism, and dick-swinging grievance-mongering IS the Republican Party. He is not an anomaly; he is the distillation of all that the GOP has stood for since the 1990s. He says the quiet parts out loud, and they love him for it. Case-in-point: Georgia’s 6th Congressional District, where exactly 48% of voters voted for John Ossoff twice, and 52% voted for Republicans twice, with $50 million wedged in between.</p><p>So what is the lesson for Democrats? It’s time for an agenda. Right now. Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour Manifesto is a good example of how a strong message of liberal policies that are achievable can make the difference in close races. And, frankly, that’s all Democrats need: don’t forget that 78,000 votes swung the presidential election, and 50 million eligible voters didn’t bother to vote. The task at hand is not to flip GOP voters: they know what they are voting for, and they continue to vote for it, Trump’s antics and the savage consequences of TrumpCare and tax reform be damned. The task at hand is to give millions of people a reason to vote for Democrats, a reason to have hope that life with Democrats in charge will be better than life with Republicans in charge. We take it for granted that Democrats are better than Republicans. We shouldn’t. We need to come up with a plan that speaks to all people — after all, working class whites have the same needs and wants as working class blacks or Latinos or Asians or anyone else. Those are the people who wonder what a Democratic party that loves Wall Street and never punished the bankers and let their homes get foreclosed on is supposed to do for them. So let’s tell them.</p><p>First: single-payer healthcare. Medicare for All. Democrats are losing the healthcare debate because, while the ACA has some really good parts to it, the main mechanism behind it is to pay private insurance companies public money to provide a service the government can also provide at a lower cost. That’s tough to defend. It lacks coherence. It is a Rube Goldberg approach, and people know it. There are many versions of a single-payer vision, some ending private insurance altogether, some leaving a layer of private insurance for the wealthy, etc. Frankly, it doesn’t matter: we can work out the details when we get the chance. For now, go out and fight for a just, fair healthcare system that covers everyone.</p><p>Second: small dollars work. One thing that Ossoff’s campaign, and Bernie’s before him, showed is that the Democrats are going to have no trouble raising money for 2018 and beyond from small donors. After the AHCA passed the House, liberal groups brilliantly set up escrow accounts for future candidates, to be distributed to whomever wins Democratic primaries to take on the GOP House members who voted for the bill in marginal seats. (Even better would be to invest that money in local infrastructure — year-round GOTV efforts for instance, but one step at a time). The energy is with the grassroots on the Left right now, and they are willing to fund in large amounts. Shifting to a small-dollar strategy leads to…</p><p>Third: fight corporate power. Democrats convince ourselves that we are on the side of the little guy, of the worker, except that we pursue policies that don’t help those workers. Democrats in the 1990s went whole hog for neoliberal policies like free trade and global governance, and contented ourselves that the crumbs of trade adjustment assistance would be enough to cushion the blow for the working class. It didn’t work. Democrats also bought into the lax anti-trust policies that have left us with 4 airlines, 1 search engine controlling all the data in the country, 4 cellphone companies, and fewer and fewer small businesses in nearly every industry. Bankers were bailed out after 2008, but homeowners weren’t. Student loans carry a massive federal interest rate, crushing the hopes of millions. The list goes on. The thread that connects these issues is money: Democrats went to Wall Street and Silicon Valley, got lots of money, and did what they were paid to do. I don’t blame them; it’s how the game is played, especially after Citizens United, there’s no other way to do it. Or there wasn’t. Now there is, and that sort of corporate money is no longer needed, which means it’s time for policies to reflect that. Break up the big banks. Stop allowing mergers in all industries that screw workers and consumers while making private equity rich. The original Progressive Era started with the Sherman Anti-Trust Act and led to income taxes and eventually the New Deal. Let’s replay that in the 21st Century. Trump stole left-populist economic policies from the Democrats. Let’s take them back.</p><p>Fourth: attack high drug prices, and go after the drug company executives who pushed opioids onto patients by the millions. Democrats missed an opportunity to punish financial criminals; let’s not miss the opportunity to punish addiction criminals. Ohio has already started this process, charging several executives at drug companies with crimes for falsifying data and misleading doctors and patients. A Democratic party that takes this issue seriously, that works to lower drug prices for everyone to cushion the pain of healthcare, and who go aggressively against pharmaceutical firms is a Democratic party that shows it has fight in it and is willing to make enemies to do good. That can’t happen unless the party is less beholden to lobbyists and money from industry, so that’s a prerequisite.</p><p>Fifth: Fight on the issues. An Italian reporter, citing a decade of experience with Silvio Berlusconi, the closest the West has seen to Trump since Mussolini, noted that the only politician to ever beat Berlusconi in an election was former prime minister Matteo Renzi, who did so by focusing solely on policy and ignoring the circus act that defined Berlusconi. That’s what we need to do in this country. Pointing out that Trump is an awful human is not going to win votes: everyone has taken a side on that issue, and it’s not remotely rational anymore. It’s tribal. So let’s go after his policies. Let’s show them for what they are. Let’s treat him as the president — not giving up on Russia but realizing it’s not the only issue in town — and let’s fight on the issues. Let’s not back down from calling TrumpCare savage and cruel; let’s not ignore the horror that is the tax reform coming soon. Let’s fight for racial justice and against criminal policing. Let’s argue that immigration is a positive good and that refugees are people. And most of all, let’s stop taking the high road: to invert Clausewitz, politics is war by other means, and until Democrats realize that, we won’t ever win again.</p><p>For many institutional reasons, Democrats have resisted creating the kind of manifesto that Labour created in Britain. But it’s time. It has to happen, or we are all going to wake up on Wednesday, November 7, 2018 with the same feeling we have tonight. Real change starts now.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f044897eb16e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Paris and Why Trump is so Effective]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman/paris-and-why-trump-is-so-effective-8aeda1359935?source=rss-540ba7a8f83c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8aeda1359935</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[paris-agreement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[William S. Goldman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Jun 2017 21:05:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-01T21:22:33.075Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*sNhUF6tPSWsxn47f-klztA.jpeg" /><figcaption>I’ve got a sinking feeling….</figcaption></figure><p>Well, that sucks. President Trump pulling us out of the Paris Accord is the perfect example of the Trump Efficiency Theory: that, in the inverse of the Pareto Efficiency, Trump’s actions seek to provide the least benefit for the fewest people while doing the most harm to the largest number. And pulling the US out of the Paris Accord — even with all it’s important flaws — will have profoundly terrible effects for millions, if not billions, of people while benefiting almost no one, and those not very much.</p><p>But listening to Trump’s speech brought something else into focus for me. Like it or not, he is a fantastically successful politician, and that speech is exactly why. I call it the Fancy Hotel Theory and it goes like this.</p><p>Ever been walking around a foreign city and find you need to use the bathroom? What to do? Well, if there’s no Starbucks around (use your imagination) and you are white and prosperous looking, you find the nearest fancy hotel and walk straight in like you own the place. (Warning: this really does only work for rich white people…and that’s important). No one will question you, and in fact most of the staff will welcome you to the Ritz or the W or whatever, simply because you look like you belong and ooze confidence about what you are doing. In the days before Uber/Lyft, this was also a great way to get a doorman to get you a cab. The reality is that most people don’t know everything about everyone else, and they make snap judgements about who knows what they are talking about or where they belong based on conventions that we all share and can be hacked. This is a Psych 101 concept — Cialdini’s <em>Influence</em> for me in college — and it is eminently true.</p><p>So how does this relate to Trump’s Paris Accord speech? Glad you asked! He uses a mastery of convention, low information, and authoritative speaking to convince millions of people of things that are simply not true. He is a rich white male who acts like what he says is obviously true, and says it with so much conviction that people believe it. And those who don’t believe it at least start to question their own preconceptions. After all, we expect someone spouting facts and figures about the Green Environment Fund and which countries are paying into it to know what they are talking about. I teach classes on Diplomacy and on climate change negotiations specifically, and while I am no climate expert, I certainly have more knowledge than the average voter on these issues. Yet listening to Trump I started to question my own memory. Is the GEF really $100 billion every year? (Yes, in theory) Is the US the only country that has paid into it? (No, not even close) Do we really not know where the money is going (Again, not even close) But, damned if what he said and the way he said it — repeating it, using basic language, literally convincing himself that he is speaking the truth even as he speaks lies — is incredibly powerful. And if you don’t really know much about the Paris Accord or the GEF, those same conventions that convince a doorman that I obviously am staying at the Ritz to let me in convince millions of people that Trump, who personifies the poor man’s version of a rich man in a world where wealth denotes expertise, knows more than everyone else. It is fascinating, and very, very successful.</p><p>And then Trump drops in the kicker: he offers to negotiate a new deal! One that is better than this one! So if you are wavering, if you think, “well, I know that climate change is bad but Trump is kinda making sense,” then a vague promise to make something EVEN BETTER softens the sting of his words, and makes it much easier for fence-sitters to support his pronouncements. If he really is going to get a better deal, why oppose what he’s doing? We don’t want to give everything to China, right? And sending $100 billion to the Developing World (and notice that Trump, in the speech, muddled his words over who, exactly, owes $100 billion making it quite possible that the US has to pay that all by itself) sounds really bad. It’s all a little hard to follow, but certainly bad. And he’s going to make it better. And he knows what he’s talking about because, I mean, who could possibly get up in front of millions of people and simply lie and make it sound so convincing? Put it together, and you get a bare Electoral College win and all the consequences of that disaster.</p><p>The point here is that Trump is very good at relating to low-information voters and people, because he learns just enough to sound credible, plays on the conventions that people with power and wealth are experts, and is a sociopath able to lie without realizing he is lying since he convinces himself that what he is saying is true. (That’s where the verbal ticks “Believe me!” and “You know we’re gonna…” come from. He is convincing himself of his lies in real time, and in the process, convincing you). I think his Paris Accord speech is going to play very well for his base and for those marginally attached. I suspect that the massive backlash that Democrats and those who care about the future of the planet expect is not going to materialize. And part of the reason is that Trump manages to issue propaganda with authority, and relies on our own conventions to convince us he’s right.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8aeda1359935" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Iron Law Strikes Again]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman/the-iron-law-strikes-again-8055c8c7681d?source=rss-540ba7a8f83c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8055c8c7681d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[aca]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[obamacare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ahca]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[William S. Goldman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 May 2017 17:04:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-07T17:04:33.952Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Ryan and McConnell have the measure of their caucus, and the ACA is toast</h4><p>I hate to be the bearer of bad news: Unless an unprecedented upsurge of activism explodes in the faces of the GOP, Obamacare is going to be repealed before August. Let me explain.</p><p>The surprise passage through the House of Representatives of the revamped American Health Care Act has appalled millions of Americans worried that the Macarthur-Meadows Amendment has made a terrible bill even worse. And it has! Now states have the ability to opt out of both community rating — the Obamacare requirement that the healthy and sick pay the same premiums — and essential health benefits, which provide a list of minimum requirements for healthcare to ensure that the plans people buy are worth the cost of the paper they are printed on. Around 24 million Americans are set to lose their current healthcare, mostly thanks to the end of the Medicaid expansion, and premiums are likely to skyrocket. Those with the euphemistically titled pre-existing conditions — i.e. people health insurers don’t think are a good bet to pay them and not need to get paid back — are petrified that they will not be able to get insurance in the years ahead. And don’t even get me started on the embedded misogyny that treats being female as its own special kind of pre-existing condition. What was amazing about the Republican effort in the House is that it managed to pass an even worse version of the bill that everyone hated and died in March. How did they do it? And what happens now in the Senate?</p><p>They did it by relying on two things: speed and what Josh Marshall at Talking Points Memo calls the Iron Law of Republicans: the moderates always cave. The first will likely not be repeated in the Senate, a more deliberative body, but the second will, and that bodes ill for millions hoping that somehow they can keep their health insurance. The speed with which a dead AHCA became law was a deliberate strategy to avoid arousing the same activist ire that sank the original bill in March. It meant breaking with tradition and voting before a Congressional Budget Office score could be procured, which helped smooth the bill’s passage by shrouding it in a haze of lies and misstatements from GOP lawmakers and the president about what it would do. This fog of war was helped along by a media establishment that seemed to willfully forget what the underlying bill would do to the healthcare system and then focused exclusively on minor changes to high-risk pools and the Upton Amendment, a fig-leaf that allowed more moderate GOP lawmakers to pretend that they were sheltered from the ire of their constituents likely to lose health insurance.</p><p>Step 2 was somewhat paradoxical: the original AHCA died because the so-called House Freedom Caucus of rabid radicals on the right balked at keeping the basic machinery of Obamacare intact — exchanges, subsidies, Medicaid expansion (for a while), penalties for not enrolling in insurance. They firmly believe, so they say, that government should have no role in providing health insurance for its citizens, and therefore the original AHCA, as draconian as it was, did not go far enough. But this HFC hissy fit was paired with a more realistic one from a more moderate group of Republicans (more moderate, rather than moderate, because literally no GOP representatives are anything but wildly conservative at this point), who rightly feared the political repercussions of throwing millions off of health insurance, and may even have suffered a tinge of moral guilt about doing so. They generally kept quiet and let the HFC take the heat for killing the original bill. Not incidentally, the moderates looked over their shoulders at the Senate, where there are a number of moderate Republicans and a very tight GOP majority, and figured that any changes would have to come their way. They were wrong.</p><p>Instead of placating the moderates, Paul Ryan moved the bill to the right — far to the right. The Macarthur-Meadows Amendment is straight out of Dickens: thought you would continue to get that diabetes medicine? Think again! Got a transplant through an ACA plan and now take expensive medicines? Tough shit! It is an unconscionable piece of legislation, but it hewed to Marshall’s iron law and skimmed through the House. Moving the bill to the right picked up 33 of 34 HFC members, at which point the moderates were bought off for peanuts. The result is a bad bill made infinitely worse and less popular, but one that successfully passed the House.</p><p>So now on to the Senate, where early moves by Majority Leader Mitch McConnell have signaled his strategy: more of the same. He knows the Iron Law better than anyone, and has gathered a rogues gallery of arch-conservatives to write a new Senate bill. When news arrived that the Senate was not even going to take up the House bill and instead would write a new one, some opponents were heartened. Articles flooded the press noting that Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) had stated that she wouldn’t ban funding from Planned Parenthood, and Tom Cotton (R-Arkansas) claimed he wanted to protect Medicaid for people in his state. The thinking here went that the Senate bill would have to be made more moderate in order to pass, which would make for a more palatable law if it made it to the president’s desk, but also held the possibility of being too moderate for the HFC in conference, and dying within sight of the finish line.</p><p>Forget it. McConnell is the most Machiavellian political operator this country has seen since Aaron Burr, and he is not about to let this bill fail or be watered down. His strategy is clearly to write a narrowly tailored bill that is to the right of Attila the Hun, and then buy off particular senators with small side deals: Murkowski gets state waivers for Planned Parenthood, maybe, plus an Anchorage Accommodation to lessen some of the premium price spikes Alaska is set to face. Susan Collins (R-Maine) might get a longer Medicaid runway, or something similar. Same for Cotton, Rand Paul (R-Kentucky) and others. McConnell is banking on individual senators lacking the spine to stop the train at this point, and he is most likely right. The end result, though, is clear enough: a radical right bill that can buy off a few recalcitrant senators who will fold under the pressure, and then can make it through the House, where those who have voted for it have even more incentive to see it become law, rather than have their vote hung around their necks as well as the opprobrium of not making good on the promise to repeal the ACA.</p><p>Barring some miracle or intensive sustained pressure from progressive groups far and away more persuasive than anything The Resistance has managed heretofore, Obamacare is dead. And it won’t be replaced by anything remotely similar. The short-term future of health care in this country is ugly. Millions will suffer; thousands will die; the rich will use their tax cut to further corrupt the political system to their benefit. Of course, all is not lost: as all good Leninists know, it is only after true collapse that the old system can be relegated to the dust bin of history. So fight the AHCA with everything you have, and when we lose, start working for Medicare for All. The silver lining in all of this is that such a cruel and evil plan cannot stand, and it might just take this sort of misery — which no right-thinking person wants — to convince Americans to join the rest of the civilized world and provide health care to all its citizens.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8055c8c7681d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Follow the Money]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman/follow-the-money-6b6aafa20bf0?source=rss-540ba7a8f83c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6b6aafa20bf0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[citizens-united]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mitch-mcconnell]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[William S. Goldman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Apr 2017 20:57:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-04-11T20:57:14.144Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Why the GOP keeps winning</h4><p>The seating of Neil Gorsuch on the Supreme Court ends one of the most successful political ploys in American history. With Justice Antonin Scalia’s body still warm in February 2016, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell declared that under no circumstances would President Obama be allowed to seat a justice. Over a year later, as Donald Trump’s nominee for the high court takes his seat, McConnell is taking a victory lap. He managed to do the impossible: deny Obama a Supreme Court pick that was rightfully his to make; rally the Republican base to vote for Trump in order to secure “Scalia’s seat” on the Court; keep the Senate in Republican hands when all signs pointed to a Democratic takeover; change the rules of the Senate to allow for majority confirmation of justices; and do it all without suffering even the slightest opprobrium from anyone other than disillusioned Democrats wondering how this all happened. It was a virtuoso performance worthy of Machiavelli himself.</p><p>McConnell’s success brings up important questions: how did this happen? How did Democrats get so completely beaten on what should have been an easy confirmation of Merrick Garland? How did Scalia’s untimely and surprising death — which ushered in the promise of a liberal majority on the Court for the first time since the 70s — turn into the undoing of Hillary Clinton and the Democratic Party? How did McConnell manage to pull this off, and suffer no consequences?</p><p>There are many answers to these questions, mostly revolving around the notion that Republican voters care more about the Supreme Court than Democratic voters; that McConnell is a better politician than just about anyone; and that, in the end, Republicans wanted it more. Their Will to Power is simply greater than that of Democrats. The Democrats have a complicated relationship to power in all its forms, Republicans have no such qualms about abusing norms and rules if it gets them what they want. McConnell, as numerous authors have recently pointed out, is personally responsible for much of the breakdown of the federal government since the election of Obama in 2008. He was uncompromising in his goal of obstructing Obama’s agenda, and has brought his caucus with him. Democrats have looked on in dismay and disapproval as their agenda has stalled and now is being reversed due to endless and pitiless GOP obstruction. The question, then, is why? Why do Republicans have a stronger will to power than Democrats? The answer is as obvious as it is unspoken: money.</p><p>We live in a post-<em>Citizens United </em>and <em>McCutcheon </em>world. For all his army of small donors, even Bernie Sanders could not turn American politics from being the purview of the rich and powerful. But here lies a major discrepancy in the system: while Republican policies benefit Republican donors directly, Democratic policies do not, for the most part, benefit large Democratic donors financially. At least not in a direct way. It is possible to make the economic argument that providing healthcare to millions of people helps the economy perform better, and if you believe that a high tide lifts all boats, then even the rich who donate large amounts to parties will benefit, despite higher taxes. Ditto with racial justice, higher minimum wages, and paid family leave. And climate change mitigation is a lovely moral issue, but not one that pads donors’ pocket books. (The preponderance of the finance industry is the big anomaly here, and it should not be overlooked. However, the uniqueness of finance’s direct benefit from recent Democratic policies is the exception that proves the rule.) These are all moral and ethical imperatives, but they require higher taxes and more spending; they do not make donors money.</p><p>On the Republican side the calculus is completely flipped, and it is this asymmetry that drives American politics today. Trump’s agenda has laid this reality bare in a way that the GOP has avoided since the Bush years. Republican donors benefit significantly from specific Republican policy proposals on tax cuts, spending cuts, environmental regulations, internet privacy rollbacks, and a host of other issues, which just happen to be on the front burner in the Trump administration. Whereas Democrats benefit morally, ethically, and, occasionally, financially from progressive policy changes and regulations, Republican donors benefit directly and heavily from Republican policy changes. Energy companies make billions on a reduction of anti-CO2 regulations; wealthy taxpayers soak up hundreds of thousands of dollars in repealed Obamacare taxes; the private prison system reaps the harvest of Jess Sessions’ increase in immigration detentions. And so on. These are individuals and corporations who see a specific increase in their income and net worth through the enactment of Republican policies. There is no comparable benefit to Democratic elites in the enactment of Democratic policies. And in this world, money talks.</p><p>There is a reason that the Koch Brothers’ Americans for Prosperity and other groups can and do raise hundreds of millions of dollars for Republican candidates and issues each election cycle: they stand to benefit financially from the outcome. One need look no further than the financial incentives of the Republican party elite to understand why Mitch McConnell was able to beat Democrats so badly: he wanted it more because his donors wanted it more. And they wanted it more because they will now all get rich. Ethics, morals, a sense of justice, a concern for the future of the planet: these are excellent reasons to vote for Democratic policies. But never in the history of humanity have those laudable goals trumped cold, hard cash.</p><p>If you want to understand why the GOP is running rings around the Democrats, why McConnell is willing and able to subvert the rules and norms of Congress to achieve his goals, and why Democrats don’t seem to be playing at the same level, just remember that money talks, and ethics walk.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6b6aafa20bf0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Now What?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman/now-what-5497889a7f51?source=rss-540ba7a8f83c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5497889a7f51</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ahca]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democrats]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[congress]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[William S. Goldman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 25 Mar 2017 16:22:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-25T16:22:45.331Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Facing few choices and needing a win, Trump will turn to the Democrats to make his vaunted deals.</h4><p>Blue eyes large and watery, Paul Ryan faced the cameras on March 24 and admitted that his hastily written, cruel and unpopular health care bill could not even pass the House of Representatives, much less the heavier lift of the Senate. After seven years of repeal votes — over 60 during President Obama’s time in office — the Speaker of the House could not push through a bad bill that, for once, had a chance of becoming law. “Obamacare is the law of the land,” he intoned, “and will be for the foreseeable future.”</p><p>On the other end of Pennsylvania Avenue, a seemingly unchastened Donald Trump held an impromptu news conference in which he blamed everyone but himself for the failure of his first major legislative effort, one in which he took so little interest that he was unsure of any major detail of the bill and therefore was woefully unprepared to be “the closer” as many of his adherents boasted he was. It was the Democrats’ fault, he claimed disingenuously; he had done everything he could. His Plan B, intoned with the grace and glee of a Bond villain describing his whole diabolical plot, is to actively sabotage the Affordable Care Act, make Americans suffer, and expect Democrats to come to the negotiating table on top of this intentionally caused human wreckage. Intentionally causing misery for millions in the name of aggregating political leverage may be the name of the game for the GOP, but such plans are usually pursued quietly and with plausible deniability. Trump was downright gleeful at the prospect of the insurance system collapsing and premiums soaring. It was clear that Trump had not yet reckoned with the political disaster he had just suffered, one that puts his entire presidency on a path toward irrelevancy and, with the Russia scandal breathing down his neck, toward a possible quick end, as well.</p><p>Which brings us to the question of what now for Trump and the GOP. The party line in the immediate aftermath of AHCAgeddon was that Ryan, Congress and Trump would move on to “tax reform,” their euphemism for massive tax cuts for the wealthy at the expense of everyone else. Yet the healthcare debacle brought to the fore some uncomfortable truths for Trump and Ryan, most notably that neither of them is actually in charge of the House of Representatives. That honor goes to Mark Meadows, the leader of the House Freedom Caucus of radicals who forced John Boehner from the speakership and are now massively emboldened by their Pyrrhic victory that demonstrated their strength, but ironically saved Obamacare in the process. As of today, the House GOP caucus is ungovernable. The Freedom Caucus maintains an intense level of ideological purity — their resistance to the AHCA was rooted in a belief that it was not draconian enough, and did not fully repudiate the theory that the government had a role in providing health insurance for the American people. And yet it was also GOP “moderates,” a group that believed the bill was simply bad law and would cost their constituents, and their own reelection chances, too much for too little gain. That dynamic — radicals demanding ideological purity to the point of undermining their own leadership against GOP members who are at least willing to play politics to negotiate with their constituents’ needs in mind — is not going away. Legislation that satisfies one group will outrage the other; the lack of earmarks (outlawed in 2010) means the leadership has few tools to convince recalcitrant members to vote their way. It’s hard to engage in log rolling without any logs. And that is without even taking into account the Senate, a more moderate body overall with a much smaller GOP majority and filibuster rules that make governing harder still. There is a reason that Paul Ryan refused for months to take the job as Speaker of the House before finally relenting: it is a thankless task that, in today’s hyperpartisan climate, is nearly impossible.</p><p>One group, however, has been left out of this analysis, and it is here where Trump and Ryan might actually see some movement on their core issues. Democrats are not looking to work with the GOP on anything, and the GOP, despite Trump’s predictable but laughable casting of blame on Schumer and Pelosi’s party, has shown no interest in compromising. But at this point, with Trump besieged on all sides, his Supreme Court nominee facing a likely filibuster, his health care efforts in flames, and a toxic dynamic within the Congressional GOP, his smartest play is to make an end run around the Freedom Caucus and start to work with Democrats in the House and Senate.</p><p>Trump famously has no deeply held views on policy. Any policy. He didn’t much care what was in the healthcare bill for which he made his half-hearted efforts to negotiate, and he has taken contradictory views on nearly every major policy provision. All he wants is to win and to be given credit for it. He wants approval, and does not care about conservative policy goals or the details of, well, anything really. His smartest play now is to ignore Ryan and start talking to Pelosi and Schumer. While the Democrats, newly emboldened by their success in stopping the AHCA, will not be willing to negotiate on much, there is an avenue whereby a tax reform bill that incorporates rollbacks in costly tax expenditures that accrue to the wealthiest Americans — mortgage interest deductions, 529 plans, etc — and some sweeteners like portable benefits packages (to help those trapped in the gig economy, and a step toward some sort of universal basic income in a world of increasing automation) could become the basis for dealmaking. Add in some quiet provisions to stop the growth of military spending, protect Social Security, Medicaid, Medicare, and assure that Tom Price’s HHS would work to make the ACA function well and you could see some real Democratic support for Conservative sacred cows like cutting corporate income taxes and reducing some complexity of the tax code.</p><p>Make no mistake: there are miles between Democratic and Republican ideas of what tax reform would look like. A centrist-style set of priorities would likely get nowhere on either side. And Democrats seem to have learned the lesson the Obama-era GOP that obstruction of everything is the way back to power. These, and others, are all huge roadblocks to any sort of effective deal-making involving Democratic votes for Republican policies.</p><p>From Trump’s point of view, however, it looks a bit different. He is interested in a win, and while he is publicly attacking Democrats in the aftermath of the AHCA fiasco, it is the Freedom Caucus that caused him to lose ignominiously. They run the show now. Unless Trump can make them irrelevant. Enter the Democrats. The ramifications of the AHCA’s failure are just becoming clear. Do not be surprised to see Nancy Pelosi meeting in the Oval Office soon.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5497889a7f51" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Way Forward for Democrats on Healthcare]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman/the-way-forward-for-democrats-on-healthcare-e6cfab89a2a7?source=rss-540ba7a8f83c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e6cfab89a2a7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gop]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democrats]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aca]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[William S. Goldman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Mar 2017 22:25:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-08T22:25:49.973Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The rollout of the fabled GOP healthcare plan has not gone according to plan so far. After seven years in which to put together a replacement for the Affordable Care Act, Republicans in Congress have come up with a derivative that is worse in nearly every way. The American Healthcare Act, or AHCA, keeps the central features of Obamacare — exchanges, Medicare expansion, at least for a while, subsidies — but makes them all less generous, less useful, and is created to provide insurance to fewer Americans. The flip side is a massive tax cut for the top 0.1%, not a politically popular idea.</p><p>The reaction on the right has been apoplectic. In typical Trump Administration style, it looks as if none of the bill’s authors workshopped it with key constituent and interest groups, or worked to get media influencers behind it. The result has been relentless attacks from the Heritage Foundation, the American Medical Association, the AARP, Breitbart, talk radio and a host of other organizations. Astonishingly, the Republicans have managed to come up with a bill that everyone hates, from right, left and center. That is a real feat.</p><p>And it makes sense: the bill is terrible. The Congressional Budget Office has yet to score the bill, but early assessments from the Kaiser Family Foundation, news organizations, and ratings agencies predict drops in coverage of at least 10 million people — and significant numbers of those losing insurance will be in the employer marketplace, not the individual marketplace that the ACA has worked to overhaul. The key provision to require those who have not had continuous coverage to pay a 30% premium penalty for a year — to their insurance company, not the government, incidentally — will incentivize people to avoid buying insurance until they are sick enough that they have to, making the risk pools older and sicker and likely leading to massive premium increases and a possible death spiral. It is, in President Trump’s words, a disaster.</p><p>Most of the attention in the media to date has focused on what Republicans should do with a bad bill that makes no one happy. But the Democrats, out of power though they are, have a role to play here, too. And if they play their cards right they might be able to use this GOP debacle to achieve their own goals of universal coverage in the near future. It will take some Machiavellian short-term political maneuvering but the payoff in the medium and long term should make up for it.</p><p>Democrats have three real choices right now: they can 1) work with the GOP to improve the bill and achieve some short-term policy goals; 2) do what they are doing now, which is to quietly attack the bill while letting the GOP founder all on its own; or 3) attack the bill unmercifully, bringing to bear every bit of their large coalition of interest groups and opponents of Trumpcare to oppose the bill with massive spending and effort. Choice 1 is a cop-out. Choice 2 might benefit Democrats and Americans some. Choice 3 is the way to assure a victory for Democrats, regardless of the outcome of the fight.</p><p>Choice 1 was the default position in the early Obama years, and Republicans have already opened up an opportunity for this sort of bipartisan effort, if only grudgingly. After a meeting with Budget Director Mick Mulvaney, members of the far-right House Freedom Caucus declared that the AHCA would not pass with their votes, but would require Democratic votes to pass the House. That led to guffaws across the political spectrum, as it should have. However, there is an opening for Democratic input that might evolve if the AHCA remains bogged down between competing GOP factions. This might ensure short-term policy gains — more generous subsidies, later Medicaid funding sunsets, and the like — but would, of course, mean that the bill was likely to pass and Democrats would co-own the results with Republicans. Happily, Minority Leaders Pelosi and Schumer seen uninterested in working with the GOP on this, and even red-state democratic senators have expressed no interest in this approach. Sadly, there is evidence that the DNC is not quite over the “let’s all work together” attitude of the early Obama years.</p><p>Choice 2 is the current default. With the rollout going so badly, Democrats are passing the popcorn, lightly criticizing the bill and letting the GOP implode all by its own self. This has the advantage of being in the Democrats’ short- and medium-term interests, especially politically, since the GOP will either pass a bad bill or suffer for not passing it. Either they will own the results by themselves, or Obamacare will continue on and the policy will be good. However, this approach is not optimal politically since Democrats are spectators here and don’t have much influence on the proceedings. The bill might pass, but it will most likely fail in its current form; either way it is Republicans arguing with Republicans, and it will be hard for Democrats to make the argument that they are better at healthcare policy in 2018 and 2020.</p><p>Therefore, Choice 3 is the way to go for Democrats looking to achieve long-held goals of universal coverage, most likely through some sort of single-payer system. Here’s how it works: Democrats should come out loudly against all aspects of the bill. Outside spending groups should sink millions of dollars into ads attacking Trumpcare. They should rally the AMA, AARP, and any other groups they can find to pillory the policy and the process. Create as much noise as humanely possible and make this the defining issue of the first year of the Trump presidency.</p><p>There will then be one of two outcomes, both good for Democrats in their own way. It’s possible that this attack could kill the bill. That would be a victory on policy and, to some extent, politics as it would be a huge win against a Trump-backed policy. Obamacare would survive, though it will be progressively weakened through regulatory changes emanating from Tom Price’s office. The downside here is that it is quite possible that Democrats would continue to “own” healthcare, and that the small-bore measures from the Trump Administration would make the current system work more poorly, reflecting badly on Democrats in 2018 and beyond. That may happen anyway given the difficulties Republicans are having already with this bill.</p><p>The second outcome here is the one that, paradoxically, Democrats should be quietly rooting for. Nothing helps the Right coalesce like a sustained attack from the Left, and it is quite possible that such an effort would cause the GOP to circle its wagons and increase Republican support for the AHCA. After all, if the Democrats really hate it, it must be good! That is certainly how Trump imagines the world works, and he is not alone in his party. If that happens, it is likely Paul Ryan and Mitch McConnell could scrape up enough votes to pass the bill. In the short term, that would be awful for American healthcare. But then Republicans would own the mess that they created as insurance markets collapse, premiums go through the roof, and millions of people are thrown to the healthcare wolves. Come elections in 2018 and, especially, the crucial 2020 battles for House redistricting after the Census, the GOP-led healthcare calamity would be a potent cudgel for the Democrats.</p><p>And that is the key: After a few years of the mess of Trumpcare voters would be eager for a massive change. The plan is so terrible, in fact, that it is possible that there could be a collapse of the healthcare system in many areas, especially rural ones: hospitals closing, doctors fleeing, premiums through the roof. What better position to run on for Democrats than a fix to this mess, one that would ensure universal coverage and could even dispense with some of the massive lobbying power of insurers, who would be losing vast quantities of money and would need a wholesale change to save their business models.</p><p>Even better for Democrats, they would be inoculated from political responsibility for the mess; after all, Democrats fought the AHCA tooth and nail. In the short term, of course, the pain and suffering of millions of Americans would be agonizing, and that is not a small thing. Yet if the outcome is a new system, one that is more equal than Obamacare and distributes technology more equitably — and that finally ends the debate about whether the government should have a role in providing healthcare for all Americans — the benefits will be worth it.</p><p>Republicans have won election after election using devious means to outwit Democrats: ask Merrick Garland how his seat on the Supreme Court is doing. It is time for Democrats to think long-term as well, to understand that there is an opportunity here to win politically while losing on policy. The chance to finally succeed in passing a healthcare system that covers everyone is too big a prize to pass up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e6cfab89a2a7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Entropy and Disorder]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman/entropy-and-disorder-e5fb8bdf32e?source=rss-540ba7a8f83c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e5fb8bdf32e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[paul-krugman]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[William S. Goldman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Dec 2016 18:51:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-12-21T18:51:56.165Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Paul Krugman <a href="http://Entropy and Disorder">wrote</a> a column recently likening our new Trumpian era to the fall of the Roman Republic. I laughed a bit when I read it, not because I didn’t agree, but because I, too, have buried my head in ancient Roman history to escape this modern tragedy. Mary Beard’s <em>SPQR</em> deserves all the praise it has received, a fresh look at the forces that drove the Republic apart and into the Principate. And Colleen McCollough’s <em>Masters of Rome </em>series, while a bit on the pulpy side, is full of excellent research and more or less follows Syme’s thesis on the administrative and norm-destructive causes of the collapse of the Republic starting in around 100 BCE. I can’t say that reading this type of history is helpful right now — Rome was never the kind of democracy we pretend it was, but the High Republic was as good as it gets in a slave-holding, pre-modern society — and its collapse into tyranny offers many lessons, few of them comforting.</p><p>However, beyond Krugman’s ode to an academic’s love of the Age of Cicero is an incomplete reading of the causes of the fall of the Republic. In Krugman’s tale, it is the venality of men and women who are willing to carry out once-unthinkable tasks in order to enrich themselves that led Rome to the Empire — and by extension is leading our republic to its doom. And while there was certainly no end of venality then and even less now, there is a larger principle that leads, inexorably, to a collapse of functioning government: polarized partisanship and the crush of entropy. Republics, like the post-war international order that is under greater threat than at any time since 1945, are a light in the darkness, a beacon that holds together a people against the forces of disorder. And since Democrats, by and large, are concerned with a functioning government that can deliver services to the many, Republicans are able to use the inherent disorder of large polities to their advantage. To the GOP, stopping change and undermining order is a winning political strategy.</p><p>Republics and democracies are about many things; among the most important are the mediation of inherent differences in theories of government, and allowing the many to legitimize decisions made by the few. As far as the role of government in society goes, there haven’t been such vast differences in the United States since Reconstruction. And, like the machinations of Caesar and Pompey and Cato, the ruinous partisanship of the Obama years has done more to discourage those who would see a positive role for government than anything else. It is not the venality of man that causes the end of Republics; it is the universal disintegration of order, compounded by the intransigence of politicians, that invalidates a positive role of government and gives us the anti-government of a Trump.</p><p>As Democrats search for a strategy to combat the unmaking of the social safety net they should bear in mind that, while emotionally powerful and morally right, all-out warfare that renders government ineffective is in the end not a winning strategy. It only makes the hankering for a Pompey or a Caesar stronger, someone who can combat the disorder through strength, create, through sheer force of will, order out of a disordered world. Since the 1990s, Democrats have participated in the undermining of their own political identity, complicit in the GOP-led effort to discredit government and make representation and democracy seem like tyranny to those who do not think they directly benefit from government largesse. The tactical victories that brought about Dodd-Frank and the ACA are built on the unstable foundation of massive distrust of the federal government. And as proponents of a functioning government, Democrats get blamed for problems even when they are not at fault; in this light, the botched rollout of Healthcare.gov was a disaster that overshadowed the subsequent success of the program.</p><p>So how to overcome this problem of asymmetrical incentives in government? First, fight anything and everything that restricts voting rights as hard as possible. There can be no compromise on this issue because it is the last guarantee of free, fair and meaningful elections. After all, Romans eagerly went on voting for annual magistracies for a century after Augustus rendered them meaningless. There were elected consuls until the end, ornamental though they were. If we don’t protect voting rights, fight gerrymandering, and end the Electoral College, we, too, will be voting in meaningless elections we believe are worthwhile. In fact, we are already doing that.</p><p>Second, beware calls to do to Republicans what Republicans did to Obama. Stopping all legislative action feels great, but will be a losing strategy in the long run. This is not a satisfying point: Democrats and others on the left are desperate — rightly — to delegitimize and destroy Trump and the GOP. But the mechanisms of government mitigate against this: the GOP is more than happy to cut taxes, run up massive debts on expensive spending bills, dismantle the safety net, and then blame Democrats for the failure of government to work. They have done exactly this since Reagan, who blew up the debt with unfunded tax cuts and military buildups, then left it to George H.W. Bush and especially Bill Clinton to clean up the mess he left. Sound familiar in the Obama era? Simply stopping the wheels of government will further convince millions of Americans that the the government is more of a hindrance than a benefit, and make them even less likely to support it going forward.</p><p>Third, education. This is increasingly difficult given the proliferation of propaganda — euphemistically called “fake news” — that dominates so much of the discourse today, and the racialist ideology that infects anti-government views. But it is also increasingly important. The biggest mistake Democrats made in the Obama years was to run from the ACA when it became unpopular; by doing so they ceded the field to anti-government forces and convinced people that the ACA would not help them, that it was probably a bad law since those who passed it ran from it. Misinformation about government is rampant, and Democrats need to push back and hard. This needs to be done at a local level, through organizing meetings, explaining benefits, church groups, the VFW and newer veterans organizations catering to younger veterans, family picnics, Thanksgiving dinner tables, Facebook — in other words, we all have to become activists to push through the noise and explain that, no, you cannot get government hands off of Medicare, as the famous sign said. This is a long-term strategy, and it is exceedingly hard. But the moment is perilous in the extreme, and we need to start rebuilding trust in a world without it. Not an easy task, but a necessary one.</p><p>Overall, a strategy that creates more disorder, that allows entropy to flourish, will doom America to a dictatorship. Trump may or may not end up being the man who ends America’s democratic experiment; after all, Julius Caesar was killed to prevent an emperor, only to see his adopted son become exactly that feared ruler. Government must be made to work, at all levels from the DMV to snow removal to Medicare. And the only way to do that is to educate, organize, and incentivize proactive approaches to ruling this country that don’t revolve around Trump Tower.</p><p>We have entered the American era of bread and circuses. Let’s get out of it as quickly as possible.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e5fb8bdf32e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The real fight against President Trump]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman/the-real-fight-against-president-trump-d5bbcbc998da?source=rss-540ba7a8f83c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d5bbcbc998da</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[aclu]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[press-freedom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[William S. Goldman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 14 Nov 2016 21:50:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-11-14T21:50:03.953Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Now that I have gotten out of bed, stacked the empty bourbon bottles in the recycling, and begun to eat again, I can think slightly more clearly about what just happened in this country, and what it all means. To me, there are two related but separate aspects of Trump’s win — beyond the obvious crushing blow for all of us who believed in Hillary and were excited to see the first woman elected president. Those two aspects can be called the Kasich and the Trump. Let me explain.</p><p>Imagine, for a moment, that Donald Trump had never run for president. The GOP primary would have pitted the likes of Jeb! Bush, Marco Rubio, and John Kasich against each other. Now, since we are imagining lots of things, let’s pretend that in the end the wise GOP primary voters had turned to Kasich, the “moderate” governor of a swing state, the man who had served in Congress and in the Bush administration, to run against Hillary Clinton. Again imagining this Earth 2 world, let’s pretend that, in the end, after a hard-fought campaign that centered on policy divisions and was a referendum on the Obama years, Kasich had pulled out a narrow but clear victory, and his coattails had kept the Senate in Republican hands, again narrowly. This was the dream of Republicans coming into 2016, and it would not have been an unlikely outcome. But it would have been a disaster for all that Progressives, liberals and Democrats held dear.</p><p>The policy implications of a Kasich victory are clear: the end of Obamacare, the rolling back of Dodd-Frank, the reversal of most of Obama’s second term. The double-edged sword of GOP obstruction and Obama’s gambit of ruling through executive order is that it doesn’t even take a vote in Congress to sign away the Clean Power Plan, DACA, and so many other progressive triumphs of the past eight years. Immigration reform would be dead. The planet would be heating up as we speak. The great moral arc of the universe, as King said, might bend toward justice, but for the foreseeable future that bend would be reversed. The battles would be ferocious, the outcome clear. Through four or eight years of rule by the radicalized GOP, much of the progress of the past forty years would have been undone, leaving millions without healthcare, reinforcing corporate control of the economy, and entrenching neoliberal foreign policy goals as US policy. Bombs would rain down on Damascus, ground troops would follow them, America would again go to war against an ethereal foe in the Middle East.</p><p>This, obviously, would have been a disaster of the highest order. Today’s GOP is a radical, reactionary party hell-bent on vindictive destruction of the liberal welfare state and immune to diplomatic and communal foreign policy methods. Giving it untrammeled power over the Federal government would be catastrophic for millions of people in this country, and millions more throughout the world. If that were what we were facing today, it would be a catastrophe worse than the Bush Administration, worse than Reagan, worse even then Nixon’s shocking upset during the heyday of protest and liberal ascendency.</p><p>And yet…these would be policy differences. Political differences. George W. Bush’s administration was a tragedy on any number of levels, but, as we saw when Obama took over, things can be fixed, changed, ameliorated, improved. Politics is cyclical and while progressives would undoubtedly lose many important and painful battles, they could regroup, reform, change their message and win elections. The Kasich scenario is terrible, and we would be lamenting it this week as we do in the current situation. But the nation would survive a run of a bad and extreme president. This is not to minimize the terrible toll on millions of the most needy in this country, including, of course, many who have voted in those same GOP for years. It would be awful, no way around it.</p><p>But we don’t have Kasich as president; we have Trump. And that is something far, far worse. Trump is not a politician and not a democrat, small-d. That much is clear. His proposals go past what the GOP has previously stated outright in terms of immigration, anti-Muslim sentiment, and outright racism and misogyny. And far more worrying, his reign threatens to undermine the foundations of American democracy that will make it impossible for the forces of light and progressivism to contest and win elections in the future. In other words, the Trump scenario encompasses all the horrors of a Kasich victory and adds the specter of a collapse of American democracy, as well.</p><p>With Steve Bannon at his side, Trump is now going to set himself on a course to turn the United States into a version of Erdogan’s Turkey, Orban’s Hungary, and, yes, Putin’s Russia. A concerted attack on a free press is coming, as is one on an independent judiciary. To me, that is going to be the major battle of the Trump years: saving American democracy. Without a free press, there is simply no way to rally opposition to Trump’s plans, whether they be on domestic policy or on his disdain for international alliances and trade deals. Without an independent judiciary, the levers of American government cannot function, and there is no way to stop an autocrat in office. This is not hyperbole: on his first day as president-elect, Trump and his minions threatened the New York Times, telling them to watch what they were saying because they could get in legal trouble. Trump’s comments about Judge Curiel are already well known.</p><p>The real nightmare scenario here is something like what follows, and it doesn’t even take into account the Kasich-level disaster of a rollback of Medicare, Obamacare, Clean Power, DACA, etc. Let’s pretend that Trump, after months of attacking the press and cutting off access to outlets that are critical, pushes through a bill — maybe following a terrorist attack — requiring all Muslims to register with the Federal Government. This is, of course, wildly unconstitutional, and in due course the ACLU and other groups win some court cases stopping the practice. Even the Supreme Court, which will be 5–4 conservative again, may not go for this sort of thing. But answer me this: why would Trump listen to the courts? What about his campaign, mindset, advisers, outlook make anyone think that he would take a loss in the courts in stride and realize he can’t do what he wants to? What happens to this country when this constitutional crisis appears? And it will appear, probably sooner than later. That is the real danger of Trump: autocracy making it impossible for the opposition to freely and fairly contest elections in 2018 and 2020. Overturning Obamacare is a nightmare; a strict federal voter ID law coupled with a complete abdication of Justice Department controls over voter intimidation would mean the end of any chance of Democrats winning future elections. A climate of fear predicated on a Deportation Force and an FBI getting to live out its Stasi-like fantasies after throwing the election to Trump. That’s what we have to fight against.</p><p>So what to do? To my mind, the great battles will not be in Congress or even in the States; they will be in the courts and in the court of public opinion. Right now we need to start to strengthen civil society in this country, both in terms of resources and in terms of public opinion. The ACLU, Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights, NAACP, ADL, Brennan Center for Justice, and a whole host of other legal organizations are going to need to be on the front lines of the battles to come. And media watchdogs and free press advocates will need endless levels of support to push back against the Bannon-inspired attacks on a free press. We all need to force the cable news networks, the major dailies, and Facebook and Twitter not to give in to Trump’s heavy-handedness and attacks. That will require public advocacy campaigns aimed at shoring up support for the ACLU and like-minded institutions; it will require real money put into organizing protests and letter/phone call campaigns to Congressional offices. Democrats should do all they can to win on the issues that they have long fought for, but they cannot cede the larger battle of authoritarianism to Trump and his GOP stooges. (Make no mistake, you will not hear a peep from the McConnell’s and Ryan’s of the world when Trump moves to jail reporters.) This is the unique threat of President Trump, and we need to start now to make sure he is not the last freely elected president in American history.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d5bbcbc998da" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Just getting started]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman/just-getting-started-3815c7c96c8?source=rss-540ba7a8f83c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3815c7c96c8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[violence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[William S. Goldman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Oct 2016 15:58:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-10-15T18:27:21.853Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yP-lFoXlGRfJ7Z0AjiyU2Q.png" /><figcaption>Photo credit: Gage Skidmore</figcaption></figure><p>Trump Tower, November 9, 2016. 12:23am</p><p>The hushed murmurs fade away as the doors glide shut with a resonant metallic clink. The turmoil of his office floor, filled with people alternatively despondent and furious, hysterical and resigned, disappears above him as the elevator begins its quiet, giddy, ear-popping descent. Three Secret Service agents stand in a phalanx in front of him, the last time they will protect him. It is their last trip down the vaunted elevator. It is not his.</p><p>He is alone. No one had joined him for what he was about to do. No one can believe it, and no one — not even Bannon, Rudy, Newt, Bossie — can talk him out of it. Despite everything it seemed a bridge too far. But the last month had shown them who was boss. His children are too distraught to accompany him. And Melania…well, she knows her place, which isn’t with him right now. This night will be his greatest triumph, even as it comes in the guise of his greatest defeat. Little did they know that he isn’t defeated, not by a long shot. He is just getting started.</p><p>The last month has been a whirlwind, a glorious, unbridled march through the country; one of the darkest times in American history. Ever since that dumb tape had come out, and then the one with the N-word, and the assault charges, and the grand jury investigation of his charity, his support had collapsed. After stopping the initial exodus of Republicans in early October, by the middle of the month it was in full swing again as he thundered his message of hate and division at rabid crowds. Lock her up! Build the wall! The black and brown people are coming for you! Damn the (((Jewish))) media! And, finally, as the election neared and panic turned into a stunned resignation throughout the GOP, as the realization that Democrats were going to sweep elections throughout the country, the darkest moment of all: attack them. Prevent them from voting. Do whatever you have to, use whatever means at hand, violence is the answer. It was his masterstroke, and it is what led him here, to this elevator, with this speech as billions around the world looked on in awe and horror at the chaos he had wrought. Even in defeat, he would win.</p><p>As the elevator doors open, the lights flood him. Those lights from which he drinks his energy and solace, from which come his joy and purpose, those pulsing lights of hundreds of cameras invading his entire being, giving him strength. He stands unbowed, his face set in his perpetual scowl, alone and bursting with energy. If he knew how to smile, he would have.</p><p>The final tally in the election was reminiscent of a Bosch painting for Republicans. Devils cavorted throughout the land as Hillary Clinton won a landslide bigger than any since Reagan in ’84. The flames of Satan swallowed states like Iowa, Ohio, and North Carolina. Florida was a three-headed rout. And even GOP stalwarts like Utah, Georgia, Arizona and, most shockingly, Alaska had gone for Hillary. With final votes still being counted on the West Coast she was nearing 400 Electoral Votes and 58% of the popular vote. He had only 38%. The Senate was firmly in Democratic hands, and the House hung by a thread as a weary Paul Ryan — his dignity tattered beyond repair — signaled he would not run again for Speaker, even if Republicans held on. Nancy Pelosi had laughed when she heard that; her internal polls said Democrats would end up with a six-seat advantage, and Ryan’s Hamlet act wouldn’t be necessary. The carnage in state houses was almost as bad, with nine legislatures flipping to Democrats, and now an almost equal number of Democratic and Republican governorships. His war against the GOP had worked. There was nothing left. Samson had pulled down the temple. If he couldn’t win, neither could they.</p><p>He stands in front of the elevator and revels in the lights. This had been the most satisfying thing he had ever done. The adoring crowds, the attention, his ability to command 100 cameras to train on him whenever he wanted. It was Nirvana. And he didn’t want it to end. It wasn’t going to end.</p><p>He stalks to the lectern set up for what is supposed to be his concession speech. He hasn’t bothered to call Crooked Hillary; one more political convention lies in tatters at his feet. He knows she is livid, her moment of triumph tarnished as the country gazes more on him in defeat than on her in victory. The lights blaze into his eyes, into his skin, the heat filling him with power.</p><p>Election Day had been a horror. In Philadelphia, Charlotte, Milwaukee, and elsewhere, armed white men, previously relegated to watching Democratic offices and menacing workers, had shed their caution and descended on black precincts and simply attacked those waiting in line to vote. No one in the United States had ever seen anything like it. Dozens were killed in the bloodshed, almost all of them black. Thousands of would-be voters had stayed home due to his increasingly violent threats and incitement; hundreds of thousands more saw the carnage, the pictures of the National Guard poignantly protecting Independence Hall in Philadelphia as smoke billowed over burned down polling places, and stayed home as well. The constant refrain of Russian hacking of elections delegitimized them just enough — despite the fact that the Russians were on his side! — to cast a pall over the entire affair. It is an omen of what is to come.</p><p>The gambit, according to the rigged, Jewish-controlled media, has not worked: Hillary still won big, even though turnout is down throughout the country. It is just as he had hoped. As always, the press is too slow, too precious to understand what he is planning. Election Day is simply the beginning. He is not going to concede anything. Why would he? Now is the time to fight. Now is the time to tear the nation down so it will turn to him to build itself back up, as it should. Law and Order. Him, alone on his cross of gold lamé, railing against a rigged election, a world rigged against the white men who should run it. He relishes the hate, the vitriol, the anger, the violence. He loves it almost as much as he loves the lights.</p><p>He stands at the lectern now, staring at the assembled crowd that throatily roars his name, at the rows and rows of cameras, their LEDs blaring, red lights staring back at him. Despite the electoral drubbing — even because of it — his followers would know that he was right, that their country had been stolen from them by the wastrels, the darker-skinned loafers, the international cabal of bankers. He would never accept Crooked Hillary as their president, and neither would they. Rigged, stolen, illegitimate. No woman could beat him. No woman could become president. He stares out at the lights, the heat searing into his being. Rally them. Excite them. Incite them to riot, protest, destroy. Who would stop them? Would the police shoot at their own? Would the army dare fire on God-fearing midwesterners? The country will soon find out.</p><p>Silence now as all wait to hear what he says, to broadcast his words — they think his last meaningful words — to the entire world. Who would give this up? What kind of person would back down, would go quietly? Never. He is just getting started. He looks up into the lights, drinks of their power, and begins to speak.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3815c7c96c8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When no one is looking]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@williamsgoldman/when-no-one-is-looking-424dab2a87d8?source=rss-540ba7a8f83c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/424dab2a87d8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hillary-clinton]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2016-election]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[William S. Goldman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Sep 2016 17:50:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-09-22T17:50:38.787Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A colleague of mine recently shook his head as we discussed the election. “Hillary,” he said in a resigned tone, head slowly swishing back and forth. “She just doesn’t connect. I don’t think she cares. I’ll vote for her, sure, but she has to find a way to connect.”</p><p>You hear a version of this all the time as Democrats and all those fearful of handing ultimate power to a truly terrible man wonder why that terrible man is doing so well in a race he should be losing badly. Hillary doesn’t connect. Sure, say smart, educated people like my colleague: sure, she may be good in small groups but with large numbers of people…. They trail off, searching for a way to explain that what matters in modern politics — if anything matters in this Looking Glass election — is the ability to give rousing speeches and mesmerize ballrooms and stadiums and cow the press. Somehow, Trump connects to people, and Hillary doesn’t. We can debate the reasons for this, most of which have to do with her gender in one way or another. It never seems to get us anywhere.</p><p>But, as with so many things, the conventional wisdom has it completely wrong about Hillary. She is a lovely person, caring in a deep and serious way, a person conscious of her ability to help large numbers of people and at the same time able and eager to focus on the plight of single individuals. Even when she has all the right in the world to play the star and avoid the difficult, tedious professions of humanity with which we all struggle and with which we would all rather not engage, she doesn’t avoid them. She takes them on. And this country will be much better for having her as president because of that caring nature, that empathy, which is a central part of her.</p><p>To illustrate: I know Hillary Clinton slightly. She and my mother were in the same class at Wellesley, and knew each other in passing. Their acquaintance was rekindled when Chelsea enrolled in my class at Sidwell Friends School in 1993. Chelsea and I were more friendly than friends in high school and the few times we’ve seen each other since. Throughout Chelsea’s four-and-a-half years at Sidwell Hillary came to all of the school functions — back to school night, parents’ night, etc. I was always amazed through high school that Hillary knew all of our names, even kids like me who weren’t that close to her daughter. This was the First Lady of the United States we’re talking about…and she knew my name at a glance! Sure, most of the moms did — and Bill knew everybody’s name because he’s Bill and that’s how he rolls, and because we have the same name, which always helped. She was always ready with a laugh, as much like the other parents as you can be when you’re the First Lady. And she WAS like the other parents: at Chelsea’s birthday party in 9th grade, she and Bill opened up the White House to a bunch of 14 year-olds and handed out popcorn as we went in to see an advance screening of <em>Reality Bites</em>. The setting was surreal — somehow even more so in the retelling twenty years later — but that was part of it: Hillary was different, yet she cared enough to be at her daughter’s events and to be so involved that we didn’t think anything of it.</p><p>Toward the end of our senior year, the mother of one of our classmates and a good friend of Chelsea’s died. The mother had been a fixture at the school. Stricken with cancer in her 40s, she defied the odds and lived for nearly a decade, her boundless energy in the face of despair impressing even us callous teenagers. We all went to her funeral, an event I will never forget, not least because my classmate stood and gave a moving eulogy of his mother in front of several hundred people, something I can’t even comprehend as an adult. My father had died when I was ten and each time there was a death that touched the school I felt like I was the expert and should have answers for everyone. I didn’t, of course, but when I went to that funeral that day I remember being a cocky 17 year-old determined to show how tough I was, and doubly-determined not to cry.</p><p>I sat down, somewhat uncomfortable in my only suit and struggling to breath with a too-small collar and wearing a tie, something that Quaker school didn’t often demand. I looked up when someone tried to get to the open seats next to me. It was Chelsea, followed by her mother. She sat down next to me and asked how I was; I mumbled something indistinct while trying to figure out why the First Lady was there. There was, of course, no reason she shouldn’t have been there: the mother of her daughter’s good friend had died, and she had come to the funeral. Same with all our mothers. Yet she was there nonetheless.</p><p>As soon as my friend rose to eulogize his mother, I started crying. Sobbing really. Full-on nose-running blubbering. As a teenager and a male I had no tissues or handkerchief or anything. Then Hillary touched me on the shoulder. I looked up and saw her eyes were red and tearing, but she had a handkerchief, which she offered to me. I waved it away; she insisted, and I wiped my eyes and, subtly I thought, my nose. She patted me on the shoulder, comforting me as I grieved for my friend’s mother, my friend and, as at every funeral, for my own father. That moment was twenty years ago. Hillary’s kindness made quite an impression.</p><p>The whole scene was nothing special. A classmate’s mother comforts a friend of her child at a funeral. But in 1997 Hillary was First Lady. She didn’t have to be there. There wasn’t a political upside to showing up; we were all Democrats anyway. There were no cameras, no press. There was just a community that she and her daughter were a part of, and there was her kind and caring nature. She was there for her daughter and, in the end, for me as well. Just like all the other moms. She went to that funeral that day not because of some calculated political effort, but because she is a mother, a daughter, a human who knows what it is like to lose a loved one, and understands that it is important to show up even when it isn’t convenient or fun. It was a small thing, really, but as she runs for president and is savaged for her apparently calculating nature — as somber pundits and voters alike opine on her inability to “connect” with voters — some insight into the real person is vital. Hillary showed up that day for all the right reasons. She showed up and cried real tears because she cared about the people around her. Remember that the next time someone says she doesn’t connect or she is too robotic or she is always calculating. When it really matters — which is to say those times when no one is looking — she does the right thing simply because she knows it’s right, even when it costs her a handkerchief.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=424dab2a87d8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>