<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Will Partin on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Will Partin on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@willpartin?source=rss-1b6c76037763------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 05:46:02 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@willpartin/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Repost: A ‘Dota 2’ Matchfixer’s Plea Shows What’s Really Rotten in Dota Esports]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@willpartin/repost-a-dota-2-matchfixer-s-plea-shows-what-s-really-rotten-in-dota-esports-bf856beb8596?source=rss-1b6c76037763------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bf856beb8596</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Will Partin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Jun 2024 04:06:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-21T04:06:55.009Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>In a global landscape rife with inequality and precarity for aspiring players, packed with gamblers and scam-artists, why do players bear all the blame and punishment?</h4><p><em>This article was originally published in Waypoint on December 14, 2017. It was commissioned and edited by Rob Zacny. Like many articles, it was driven by my frustration with the Dota 2 ecosystem’s focus on individual actions rather than the perverse incentives produced by the game’s economic structures. I cannot make it clearer: the biggest threat to integrity in esports is not individual players: it is the profound material inequalities between the haves and have-nots.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*HaO8u0MhKuRmYnHIPLfabg.png" /></figure><p>Last weekend, Freddy “SmAsH” a disgraced Peruvian <em>Dota 2</em> player posted a <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/DotA2/comments/7iv3ne/open_letter_to_valve_dota2_community_about/">long, open letter</a> on the <em>Dota 2</em> subreddit, petitioning Valve for his reinstatement into the game’s professional scene, and an end to the ban he received as a result of a match-fixing scandal. To make his case, he details the squalid conditions in which he and his teammates lived, and how their destitution left them with little other choice than to bet against themselves.</p><p>“I know that this letter won’t make all the hatred disappear,” SmAsH concludes, “but I hope that those who hate us blindly at least question their feelings before doing so.”</p><p>If you haven’t been keeping score, here’s the situation: SmAsH, along with several teammates on Elite Wolves, were found guilty of matchfixing during a minor tournament in February 2016. Were SmAsH to have won that tournament, he stood to earn around $100 USD. By throwing one series, however, his “guaranteed” earnings through third-party betting sites were upwards of $600.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5NRFHCQGLl6xXA7bZtP7kg.png" /></figure><p>But the deception was found out within a week, and though Elite Wolves initially denied any wrongdoing, an investigation by Valve determined that they were at fault. SmAsH received a lifetime ban from Valve events, a death sentence in <em>Dota 2</em>. Barred from competition, SmAsH turned to Twitch as a kind of afterlife for his career. Most evenings, you can find him streaming to a few hundred viewers, haunting <em>Dota 2</em> like a ghost.</p><p>SmAsH’s open letter is worth reading in full because it’s a revealing look into playing conditions for <em>Dota 2</em> players outside the game’s glitzy upper crust. <em>Dota 2</em> gets a lot of press about its eye-popping prize pools, but that’s often a smokescreen obscuring the deep inequalities that grip the game’s global competitive scene. SmAsH’s letter is a vivid illustration of the chasm between the “haves” and “have-nots” in <em>Dota 2</em>, and what that gap forces players to do to survive.</p><p>“Many days, we were unable to fulfill basic necessities,” remembers SmAsH. “There were even days where my teammates and I had no food to eat and no place to sleep.”</p><blockquote><em>[On Elite Wolves], I had a salary of $90 [a month], which was quite a lot at the time,” he continues. “Back then, a Peruvian pro player earned between $30 and $90 month … Sadly, we could not even cover the basics, especially regarding food. Most days, we ate cold cereal or whatever we could muster.</em></blockquote><p>It’s worth noting that even at his highest income, SmAsH was only making around a quarter of the average Peruvian wage, according to <a href="https://tradingeconomics.com/peru/wages">data from Peru’s central reserve bank</a>. SmAsH also describes an episode in which he and his teammates attempt to leave an organization that wasn’t supporting them sufficiently, only to be cajoled into to paying back what prize money they <em>had</em> earned as penance for mucking up the team owner’s “investment into them.”</p><p>Heart-wrenching though SmAsH’s story is, the reaction from <em>Dota 2</em> writ large has been a shrug. Most commenters <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/DotA2/comments/7iv3ne/open_letter_to_valve_dota2_community_about/dr1yxw2/">have responded</a> with sympathy for SmAsH’s plight, but stop short of taking his side. As one writes: “I understand that man, but [another pro] Febby didn’t even have a house for a year and he didn’t match fix. Iirc rave only ate eggs and didn’t eat when they didn’t win tournies and I didn’t hear them cheat. It’s just not acceptable behavior. Good luck though.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1If5zEOTCKuZxsIOP-dKmw.png" /></figure><p>You can read through the others if you’d like, but they all boil down to the same message: you were in a bad situation, but you made your choice. <em>Now, go do something else</em>.</p><p>This response lacks both empathy and any sense of history. SmAsH’s plea for redemption is a human story, sure, but it’s also a <em>political</em> one.</p><p>Esports often goes out of its way to distance itself from politics, but cases like that of SmAsH are a reminder about how global inequalities shape the conditions through which progamers work. Though we sometimes imagine otherwise, cyberspace was never another world, merely a well-disguised reflection of our own. It reproduces, in altered form, the same inequalities that plague us here on earth.</p><p>SmAsH writes that Peru’s “terrible and unstable internet” forced them to play at a structural disadvantage against wealthy American teams, making near-impossible the very thing (winning) that might have given them a chance at a more stable sponsorship. How are we to talk about this without also talking about <em>why</em> the telecommunication infrastructure in Peru is so uneven? That’s a historical question, not a personal one. It demands talking about how the inequalities of the past shape those of the present.</p><p>What’s more, Valve’s laissez-faire approach to managing <em>Dota 2</em> exacerbates and exacerbates these problems. As the political economist Daniel Joseph <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/s/v55hbuzlf6gz9h4/Daniel%20Joseph%20Dissertation.pdf?dl=0">points out</a>, “videogames idealize and structure experiences of individual freedom and self-empowerment, while themselves being the product of the exploitation of labor made possible through deliberately uneven global development.” He’s talking games in general, but goes for esports too.</p><p>Through Steam, Valve pushes the burden of managing professional <em>Dota 2</em> onto everyone but itself. This includes not only the unaccountable tournament organizers and shady managers, but the cottage industry of lecherous betting sites and ELO boosters (where people pay more skilled players to improve their matchmaking rank on their account) that exist like leeches on <em>Dota 2</em>’s professional scene — and it’s worth acknowledging that SmAsH <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/DotA2/comments/5ff167/professional_peruvian_smash_boosting/">has been accused</a> of taking part in ELO-boosting schemes as well. In theory, the free market should “take care” of these things in time. But free markets, like meritocracies, never really work like that; the rich get richer, and the poor face impossible choices.</p><p>“There were many things that motivated our team to match-fix,” writes SmAsH. “There’s a point when you are close to shutting down due to desperation that you start to make bad decisions. Some people in the team had no money for food, or to live on, and what little we had to share was not enough to help them.”</p><p>A system in which players often live marginal, precarious existences amid bad actors and predatory management threatens the integrity of competitive <em>Dota 2</em> far more than the actions of a destitute 18 year-old. By the time a young player living in squalor is forced to make a choice between matchfixing and eating, doesn’t integrity feel beside the point? The trouble with assigning blame to an individual, as most of the <em>Dota 2</em> community has done, is it absolves the system of any responsibility for laying the foundations for that individual’s supposed moral failings.</p><p>The reality is that for much of the game’s competitive audience, <em>Dota 2</em> is a game of leisure and entertainment. For many aspiring pros around the world, it’s potentially food on the table and a roof over one’s head. That difference in context changes the significance of the “integrity” of things like competition and matchmaking rank.</p><p>Valve could help address this by looking honestly at the ways this system fails the disadvantaged. Instead, one of the most profitable companies in the world hands down draconian and capricious punishments against some of its poorest players, to applause from a community that often doesn’t understand the choices and pressures of poverty, but has heard a little bit about it, and thinks SmAsH should have just gripped his bootstraps a little tighter.</p><p>///</p><p><em>If you would like to follow me on the site formerly known as Twitter, I am @william_partin.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bf856beb8596" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Repost: This Bank Uses Animal Crossing to Sell You Financial Services]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@willpartin/repost-this-bank-uses-animal-crossing-to-sell-you-financial-services-7c03ebbbe114?source=rss-1b6c76037763------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7c03ebbbe114</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Will Partin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Jun 2024 03:57:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-21T03:57:50.706Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Ally Island closes the loop between Animal Crossing’s satirical depiction of endless indebtedness and the financial circumstances of its audience.</h4><p><em>This article was originally published in Waypoint on October 30, 2020. It was commissioned and edited by Rob Zacny. I have made very minor stylistic edits. To be quite honest, I don’t remember much about the conditions of its publication. Forgive me: it was the depths of the pandemic and I suspect you’d rather forget what you did too.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*twqOsFages0nPOKq8pTbpA.png" /></figure><p>For most of the last week, Ally, a financial services based in Detroit, MI, hosted a sponsored island in <em>Animal Crossing</em>. The weeklong “activation” — a marketer’s term for the actual execution of a long-planned marketing campaign — kicked off with a guided tour by charming and affable streamer Kang, who directed his (mostly) delighted audience of 15,000 or so around the island in the hours before it was open to the public. Ally Island was, admittedly, an impressive bit of creativity under constraint, using <em>Animal Crossings’</em> assets to showcase homes, boats, cars, a playable-ish golf course, and “Little Detroit”. (Ally is descended, through a century-long mess of mergers, acquisitions, restructures, buyouts, sell-offs, and rebrandings, from General Motors’ car financing wing). But the main draw of Ally Island was the ludicrous 1,000 bells it offered for turnips, a good enough exchange rate for serious Animal Crossing fans that the island was eventually shut down early <a href="https://twitter.com/ally/status/1321194658375106561?s=21">as a result of congestion</a>.</p><p>Ally is a bank. It’s other things too, which we’ll come back to, but the main thing advertised during Friday’s stream were the most basic of banking services — checking, savings, car financing, etc. As Kang toured his audience through the island, he regaled them with personal stories about the services Ally offers and how those helped him and his wife achieve (what else) financial freedom — or, at least, the illusion of it that cheap debt offers. And with boats, manors, golf courses, and cars on display, the island itself was a catalogue of symbols for wealth — or, more accurately, what prudent wealth management can get you. The motto for the event summed things up nicely: “Visit our island and see how to make your bells work smarter.”</p><p>Like most industries, banking has had to contend with the material and cultural shifts that have accompanied Millennials becoming a plurality of the American workforce. Not only are Millennials considerably more precarious at this point in our lives than our parents were due to the <a href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/B071RQYY8C/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?_encoding=UTF8&amp;btkr=1">predictable effects of policy choices</a> (and not avocado toast), but we also, per Gallup, give considerably less of a shit who we bank with. No doubt these are related. But this creates a marketing opportunity for “millennial-friendly” “all-digital” banks like Ally, which is the simplest reason as to why Ally Island exists. But the basics of banking is, to banks, really the tip of the “financial services” iceberg. Thanks to a lax regulatory environment <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_in_post-financial_crisis_reform_debate">that not even the 2008 crisis could rein in</a>, most companies like Ally are engaged in both commercial banking and investment banking.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RnHjcnmbzpT8mARRioEvmQ.png" /><figcaption>A STILL FRAME FROM KANG’S ALLY ISLAND TWITCH STREAM</figcaption></figure><p>But if most workers (including Millennials) have to put their wages somewhere, it’s <em>also</em> true that Millennials <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/andreacoombes/2018/03/13/millennials-are-good-at-saving-but-investing-not-so-much/#364df11d7266">haven’t taken to investing as readily as previous generations</a>. There are obvious, material reasons for this, but, for Ally, those aren’t worth considering. What’ll make Millennials start investing is little more than the <a href="https://www.accenture.com/_acnmedia/pdf-68/accenture-millennials-and-money-millennial-next-era-wealth-management.pdf">right messaging and a better user experience</a>. As Ally’s “guide to investing” <a href="https://ally.turtl.co/story/guidetoinvesting/page/2">on its website</a> puts it, “you’re hesitant. We get it.” “<em>No,” this imagined reader might reply, glancing at a pile of barely-dented student loans, “I’m just poor.”</em> Undeterred, Ally offers an electronic trading platform, mere swipes away from its standard-issue banking services, featuring “self-directed” and “automated” trading. It might not be as finely tuned as the fully gamified trading platform Robinhood — <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/25/opinion/robinhood-suicide-trading.html">a genuinely horrifying collision of the worst impulses of Wall Street and Silicon Valley</a> — but it’s pitched as an easy point of entry for the skittish, green Millennial investor. So you’re looking for Ally Island on a map, you’ll find it at the intersection of the financialization of games, and the gamification of finance.</p><p>It’s trite, by now, to point out that Animal Crossing is <em>some</em> kind of allegory/parody/critique (your pick) of finance capitalism, a term meant to define an era — our era — in which financial assets (CDOs, derivatives, futures, etc.) are more valuable than tangible ones. On one level, this makes <em>Animal Crossing</em> — he most approachable (and forgiving) “stalk market” in games, after all — a perfect venue for advertising something like Ally, whose value proposition is making trading stocks as painless as trading turnips. And not just Ally, but for the whole system of finance capitalism its product’s assumptions rests upon. Making “your bells work smarter” is a nice way of not having to think about the damages finance capitalism has wrought.</p><p>But there’s something more subtle at work here, too. “Before it’s an ad for shampoo or cat food or cola,” <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/04/pepsi-ad-success/522021/">Ian Bogost observes</a>, “every advertisement is first an ad for capitalism.” His point is that advertising doesn’t just sell you on a product — it sells you, in the first instance, on selling at all. It sells you on the way things are, alongside your (potential) place in that way that things are. Advertising always (also) tries to make a point about what a good consumer is. None of us, after all, emerge from the womb as acolytes of capitalism; we learn to spend, save, and sometimes spree. Consumption is culture; culture is consumption. But if millennials aren’t investing, they aren’t “good” consumers, at least from the perspective of a 360° financial services company. So to dismiss Ally Island as just an ad for Ally (though of course it’s also that) is to miss the deeper ideological work at play here. Ally Island, with <em>Animal Crossing</em> as its medium, defines how it believes millennial-consumers ought to act, their material circumstances be damned.</p><p>Whether or not this gamble works is an open question — great messaging is powerful, but it doesn’t put money in your pocket.</p><p>///</p><p><em>If you’d like to follow me on the site formerly known as Twitter, I am @william_partin.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7c03ebbbe114" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Repost: ‘Artifact’ Isn’t a Game on Steam, It’s Steam in a Game]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@willpartin/repost-artifact-isn-t-a-game-on-steam-it-s-steam-in-a-game-e12a052b4d7a?source=rss-1b6c76037763------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e12a052b4d7a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Will Partin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Jun 2024 03:50:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-21T04:01:26.609Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Imagine if we monetized the rot.</h4><p><em>This article was originally published in Waypoint on December 13, 2018; I am rehosting it here due to a rumor that Vice is going to take its archive online (sigh). It was commissioned and edited by Rob Zacny. I have made some minor stylistic adjustments.</em></p><p><em>Of everything I’ve written, this one seemed to make the biggest splash upon its publication, which surprised and honored me. But, over time, I’ve come to see it as the clearest expression of; (1) the central theme of my writing — the interrelation of culture, computation, and capital—and; (2) pushing the genre of the ‘game review’ to its limits. I’m not sure I’ve written anything sharper.</em></p><p><em>A fun fact: after publication, Valve reached out to me to say they loved the article but wanted a correction: I’d misspelled ‘Reinhart’ as ‘Reinhardt.’</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YLjUlWotGizbGyVnwmdLjw.png" /></figure><p>///</p><p>Proxies don’t exist in <em>Artifact</em>. That’s the point.</p><p>If you’ve ever been involved in competitive <em>Magic: The Gathering</em>, there’s a decent chance you’ve encountered what’s known as proxy cards. Playing <em>Magic</em> seriously is an expensive endeavor, and a competition-ready deck can set you back $1,000 or more. So, if you want to play — but not pay — like a pro, you use a proxy card: A <a href="https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/5/55/MTG_Mox_Pearl_Proxy.jpg">homemade simulacrum</a> of a costly, unowned card that, with two players willing to shake on it, stands in for the real thing. They aren’t strictly legal, but they are pervasive enough to be accepted (one <a href="http://www.mtgpress.net/">online tool</a> will even print an entire deck of them for you). And, in any case, <em>Magic</em> publisher Wizards of the Coast’s provision against proxies is about as impotent as the “don’t remove this tag” message on your pillow. As a result, proxy cards have become part of the experience of competitive <em>Magic</em>. Whether you’re just getting into the scene, or a serious player testing out new permutations of cards, proxies offer something akin to the “real” experience without the financial burden.</p><p>But when it comes time to compete in official tournaments, you’ll need genuine cards. Judges disqualify players caught using proxies, an embarrassing and potentially costly penalty for any serious competitor. To avoid that, aspiring players have two options: one is to buy booster packs and hope the cards they seek are contained within. The other, less chancy approach is to seek cards out on third-party exchanges, like <a href="https://www.tcgplayer.com/">TCGplayer</a> and <a href="https://www.cardkingdom.com/">Card Kingdom</a>. If you need a staple of competitive play like, say, <a href="https://shop.tcgplayer.com/magic/zendikar/scalding-tarn">Scalding Tarn</a>, you can shell out $71.22 and have a well-worn copy in your mailbox by the end of the week. In essence, would-be competitors face a choice: submit either to the whims of cellophane fate or the predictable (if unforgiving) logic of supply and demand.</p><p>Proxy cards and online trading have lowered the practical barrier of entry to competitive Magic, even if the financial one remains daunting. But for Wizards of the Coast, which has published <em>Magic</em> since 1993, they amount to bootlegging and aftermarkets, respectively. The company can, of course, adjust its terms of service and add holographic watermarks, but when your product is, physically speaking, an arrangement of pigment on cardstock, there’s only so much control it affords. As a result, Wizards of the Coast has mostly resigned itself to the status quo. <em>Magic</em>, of course, is an extraordinary game, which accounts for its enduring appeal. Even so, if the real game you’re playing is maximizing returns on investments, it’s hard not to look past millions of happy <em>Magic</em> fans and see a tremendous amount of value being created, and then lost, slipping away like sand through fingers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CfEIrwZEokCNUgPIb-W2kg.png" /><figcaption>GREG FENTON PLAYING ‘MAGIC: THE GATHERING’ IN VICE’S ‘AMERICAN OBSESSIONS’ SERIES</figcaption></figure><p>“A game without a metagame is like an idealized object in physics. It may be a useful construct, but it doesn’t really exist,” wrote <em>Magic</em>’s legendary designer, Dr. Richard Garfield, in a <a href="https://edt210gamestechsociety.files.wordpress.com/2013/09/2000-garfield-metagame.pdf">2000 essay</a> on his design philosophy. Garfield’s point is that games, no matter their format, bleed. Tempting though it is to mark out where a game “ends” and the rest of the world begins, such boundaries always break down under close scrutiny. This is true of all games, in one way or another, but it’s especially clear with <em>Magic</em>, whose aftermarkets and proxies are inescapably “part” of what the game <em>is</em> in the world. It’s also true, then, of Dr. Garfield’s latest card game, <em>Artifact</em>, which was released on Steam last week and will arrive on mobile sometime next year.</p><p>Here’s another truth: <em>Artifact</em> is extraordinary. Dr. Garfield may be a mathematician by training, but a he’s a designer by calling, and Valve is still home to some of the most talented artists and developers in games. To play <em>Artifact</em> is to witness masters at the peak of their craft. Everything about <em>Artifact</em> — from the pleasing rustle of cards as they unfurl across the board and to the ways your held cards respond, ever so gently, to the touch of your cursor — displays unmistakable signs of talented people giving a shit.</p><p>As a longtime <em>Dota 2</em> fanatic, I’ve especially enjoyed the artful translation of <em>Dota 2</em> mechanics into the conventions of card games, of which its three simultaneous lanes is only the most obvious example. It’s hard not to marvel at the depths of <em>Artifact</em>, which, to me, feels like <em>Hearthstone</em> in three dimensions. To be sure, I am not an especially gifted or consistent player of card games, and yet I find myself compelled to go deeper, pulled in as if by magnetism. <em>Artifact</em> is the rare game whose complexity does not make you feel stupid, so much as it inspires you to be smarter.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hMqEdecOXsG2CNaa2uQW_w.png" /><figcaption>:3</figcaption></figure><p>This makes it a bit surprising — and a bit of a tragedy — that the game is being <em>pilloried</em> by its target audience, and, based on its <a href="https://steamcharts.com/app/583950">already declining player base</a>, is on a direct path to an embarrassing free-to-play resuscitation. With <a href="https://store.steampowered.com/app/583950/Artifact/">10,975 reviews in</a> on Steam, <em>Artifact</em>’s score is“Mixed”, which, on Steam, is a sure sign that something has gone seriously wrong. It doesn’t take a lot of searching to uncover the culprit: How <em>Artifact</em> is monetized.</p><p>“This is not a card game, it’s a credit card game,” writes one user in a typical negative review, upset that there’s (a) no in-game currency, the way that most multiplayer games (especially free-to-play) have a currency that you can earn through playing (b) it costs money to compete in a lot of game modes that are designed for advanced and competitive players and © that the game more-or-less forces players to buy and sell cards on the Steam Marketplace. Early estimates suggest that getting a full set of 310 cards will set you back around $300 — less than an elite <em>Magic</em> deck, but 15 times as much as <em>Artifact</em> costs. Most of these reviews concede as a matter of course that <em>Artifact</em> is, unquestionably, a great game. (It is.) It’s the metagame that’s the problem.</p><p>This poses a dilemma for reviewers. <em>Artifact</em>, clearly, is a flashpoint for ongoing debates about the relationship of mechanics to monetization. <em>Artifact</em>’s woes are not just because of how it separates players from their money, but because of how flagrantly it ties these two arenas together, the ritual of play bound and gagged to the vulgarity of buying and selling. This challenges one of the underlying assumptions of what, exactly, we’re reviewing when we review games. Every game may indeed have a metagame, and yet, by common consensus, we reviewers tend to focus on what’s “in” the game, not around or on top of it. <em>Artifact</em> exposes this as the performance it always has been, a distinction as imaginary as any border is. What if, instead, we didn’t review <em>Artifact</em> as the excellent game so many wish it only were? (<a href="https://kotaku.com/i-just-started-playing-artifact-and-already-im-tempted-1830726559">Plenty</a> <a href="https://www.ign.com/articles/2018/11/28/artifact-review">of</a> <a href="https://www.polygon.com/reviews/2018/11/28/18115031/artifact-review-dota-2-card-game">these</a> exist already). What if we reviewed it for what it really is: a market — one <em>Magic</em> could never forge, and only Valve would dare to.</p><p>If you’re interested in understanding Valve, and, how, in turn, this led them to make <em>Artifact</em> the way they did, you need to look at the history and, in particular, its knack for finding novel ways to make money. Valve — which is not publicly traded, maintains one of the smallest workforces of any firm of its prestige, and is <a href="https://www.businessinsider.com/valve-profits-2011-2">thought to have the highest profit per employee</a> of any American company — is not like other game companies, and operates according to a different, but specific, set of principles. That fact makes Valve both fascinating and predictable.</p><p>“Very few of Valve’s innovations center around the creation of original, inhouse IP,” explain game theorists Stephanie Boluk and Patrick Lemieux in their 2017 book <a href="https://manifold.umn.edu/read/metagaming/section/16f3adb8-1460-4705-900c-455b6691d557#ch11"><em>Metagaming</em></a>, a long reflection on the many things we can <em>do</em> with video games in addition to playing them. “Instead, they have developed a business model based on colonizing, expropriating, and assimilating metagames into a framework of benevolent capitalism.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Tl2Nw_LGj-MjF8MrT4WTJQ.png" /></figure><p>When Gabe Newell quit Microsoft to launch Valve back in 1996, the company was, practically speaking, just another game developer. What distinguished it from its competitors was mostly the quality of its products. The game that made Valve famous, <em>Half Life</em> (1998), might have been a watershed moment for game design, but it was made, marketed, and monetized like any other computer game at its moment. Valve’s innovations lay “inside” video games, not in the spaces around them.</p><p>Then Steam hit. Launched in 2004 alongside <em>Half-Life 2</em>, the program that was originally intended to keep Valve’s own games up to date quickly became the most important retailer in computer gaming, capturing some 70% of the PC distribution market within a few years of launch. By 2012, other companies had caught on and began to introduce their own distribution platforms alongside flagship titles, giving us the Origins and Uplays we deal with today.</p><p>Valve, once again, was a step ahead. Taking a cut from every purchase on Steam might have created tremendous profits at minimal expense for Valve, but it only did so at the point of sale. To expand its market, as is the guiding principle of capital, the company introduced the Steam Marketplace in 2012, marking Steam’s transition from a distributor to something much more complex. Consumers could (if they desired) participate in a market of virtual goods, buying and selling skins for games like <em>Counter-Strike</em>, <em>Dota 2</em>, and <em>Team Fortress 2</em>. At that moment, Valve stopped being a company that makes games and became one that makes markets, which means that Valve’s philosophy of management had to change as well.</p><p>“Our job is to maximize the productivity of users in creating digital goods and services,” Newell said in a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t8QEOBgLBQU">frank interview</a> in 2012 at the University of Texas. “The markets will determine what the marginal value add of each of those activities are. The kinds of ways in which people create value and creativity and creating frameworks for that are gonna vary.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6fACQztwT3J3DV5xUhO75g.png" /><figcaption>THE MARKET FOR A SINGLE POPULAR AWP SKIN IN ‘CS:GO’</figcaption></figure><p>Steam stopped being a digital Gamestop and became something more akin to Uber, a massive platform to distribute labor (or, more accurately, it became both). Like “regular” markets, the Steam Marketplace offered familiar financial opportunities — supply and demand, arbitrage, and high-volume algorithmic trading — to enterprising users. Unlike regular markets, however, Valve set the terms of every exchange and skimmed a bit off the top of every transaction. In effect, Valve could keep extracting value for as long as players were willing to buy and sell virtual goods on their platform. If Steam 1.0 connected studios to players for economic exchange, Steam 2.0 did so for players to players. Once again, Valve had devised a way to sit back and make money while pushing the labor (and risk) everywhere else.</p><p>If profit is your ultimate goal, then this logic is nothing short of genius, which is why it’s the guiding principle behind everything Valve does. It’s not enough to say that Valve wants to make money (duh); they only really want to do so in a particular way. In a sense, gaming’s most mysterious company is predictably unique and uniquely predictable. <em>Artifact</em> is only the latest example of a long-running logic, and we shouldn’t be surprised by a company acting like what it has always been. But <em>Artifact</em> isn’t just about Steam — or, really, Steam isn’t just about <em>Artifact</em>. Valve’s platform happens to be the perfect tool for monetizing <em>Magic</em>’s metagames, too.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EsZkXp4AwwdaETmgjVdIkg.png" /></figure><p>When you purchase <em>Artifact</em> ($19.99) and launch it for the first time, you play two tutorial games: one with a <a href="https://playartifact.com/d/ADCJcURIH0De7sBKAGQeF1BQWbdAVhHRwFIMQIECG0CTgIfRlBCdQFSZWQvR3JlZW4gQnJhd2xlcg__">Red/Green Brawler</a> deck, and a <a href="https://playartifact.com/d/ADCJRwSJX2Dc7wBEAN4XUFBcN0BQmQBQWABRCgBCgN0AWUBbQFDbwEISEJsdWUvQmxhY2sgQ29udHJvbA__">Blue/Black Control</a> deck. Upon completion, <em>Artifact</em> grants you each starter deck so that you can get playing right away. For obvious reasons, cards in the starter decks are the cheapest cards to buy in <em>Artifact</em>. Were I to put one of my two Oglodi Vandals up for sale for a $0.03 (the minimum price for which a card will sell), I would receive $0.01 in return. Those other two cents would be profit for Valve.</p><p>Those decks are supplemented by 10 card packs (worth $1.99 each) of 12 cards, one of which is guaranteed to be “Rare.” Alas, my Rare cards haven’t turned out to be worth much more than my common ones, save my prize card, Horn of the Alpha, which is worth (as of now) a respectable $5.09. I’ve also gotten decently lucky on Heroes, given that they determine what color of spells you can play, and thus the breadth of possible decks you can build. I might not have any of the <a href="https://www.artibuff.com/stats/heroes">winningest Heroes</a> — Tinker, Drow Ranger, and Axe — but at least I’m not stuck holding an Outworld Devourer, which currently boasts an abysmal 33% win rate.</p><p>If I wanted to get competitive, though, I’d need <em>different</em> heroes — probably Axe and Legion Commander, by far the most popular heroes <a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ZR0xHSfjxEzE6IlhSJ1rbnstuhieluhCiW8QskOMBcQ/edit#gid=0">in a recent tournament</a>. As in <em>Dota 2</em>, heroes are ultimately what the game revolves around, not simply because they’re far more powerful than the NPC “creeps” that randomly populate each lane, but also because they determine what color of spell you may play in those lanes. As a result, having a strong lineup of heroes is a (the?) central component of a successful deck. If that’s my goal, I’ve got three options for getting them into my collection. Like <em>Magic</em>, I can open packs at $1.99 each until either Axe or Legion Commander show up. Alternatively, I can trade for them on the Steam Marketplace, where demand for top cards like Axe (<a href="https://steamcommunity.com/market/listings/583950/110020">currently $21.71</a>, but sold for as high as $38.73 last week) has pushed the cost of individual cards above the price of <em>Artifact</em> itself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lZ5FDUjjqMdJxhmmMEOxJg.png" /></figure><p>My third option, nominally the most meritocratic one and where most of the ire over <em>Artifact</em> comes from, is to compete. It’s all a bit arcane — enough to <a href="https://playartifact.com/news/1721959164054855755">require an elaborate FAQ with apologia about its complexity</a> — so bear with me. <em>Artifact</em> divvies up all PvP competition into three modes: “Social Play” (challenging your friends and user-generated tournaments), “Casual Play” (bot matches and unranked matchmaking), and “Expert Play” (which I’ll come back to, since it’s really the meat of the matter). Both “Casual Play” and “Expert Play” contain “Gauntlets,” <em>Artifact</em>’s more malleable take on the <em>Hearthstone</em> Arena system.</p><p>You can do as much Casual and Social Play as you’d like without paying a thing, and I suspect many players will. But if you want to win some cards for your collection on the back of your <em>Artifact</em> prowess, you’ll have to do Expert Play: “a series of gauntlets that offer prizes and greater risk vs. reward.” The risk, here, is event tickets and the reward is card packs. Because <em>Artifact</em> doesn’t have an in-game currency, competing in Expert Play requires spending event tickets (you get five when you buy the game, and they’re available in bundles of five for $4.95 thereafter). It’s also the only way to win new card packs.</p><p>Expert Play is broken down into kinds of Gauntlets: Expert Constructed (play with your own cards), Phantom Draft (build a deck from five packs, but you don’t get to keep the cards), and Keeper Draft (same as Phantom Draft, but you get to keep the cards). Expert Constructed and Phantom Draft require one ticket each, and, should you win fives games without losing two, will yield one ticket and two card packs (whew). Keeper Draft, on the other hand, requires buying two tickets <em>and</em> five card packs (meaning it’s ~$12 to play each round of Keeper Draft Gauntlet), but you can win up to three additional packs on a good Gauntlet run. Draft modes aren’t for everyone, of course, and if you want to win cards with your own hard-earned collection, you’re stuck playing Expert Constructed. But it doesn’t take a lot of straining to see the problem: to win (reliably at least) you need great cards, but to get great cards you need to win. And the only way guaranteed to break that feedback loop is to buy what you need on the Steam Marketplace. In essence, there is no way to get new cards in <em>Artifact</em> without paying in one way or another (or two). No wonder <em>Artifact’s</em> critics are calling it pay-to-pay-to-win.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*T88Klnoe6e5iHnwefVd7Mw.png" /></figure><p>Many have wondered whether or not <em>Artifact</em>’s reliance on the Steam Marketplace is an invitation to price gouging. Yet Valve, in contrast to its typically flippant attitude towards media, has gone to some lengths to get ahead of these assumptions, speaking at length on the topic in an <a href="https://in.ign.com/artifact-2012/127429/feature/how-valve-wont-let-artifacts-marketplace-get-crazy-expensive">interview with IGN</a>. Asked whether it were possible for a single card to reach $1,000, no less an authority than Dr. Garfield himself responded that this “cannot happen, and in no way we would want to happen. It can’t happen because [of] the <a href="https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/arbitrage.asp">arbitrage</a>. As long as we’re publishing cards, there’s a maximum value any particular card can have.”</p><p>“We actually do want people to play, and we want you to be able to play with your friends,” added Brandon Reinhart, a programmer at Valve. “So making sure there’s a reasonable price ceiling is really valuable for that.”</p><p>It’s easy to be cynical, of course, and claim that Dr. Garfield and Reinhart are just feeding us a slurry of convenient lies. But I’d prefer to take them at their word, in part because of the distinctiveness of how Valve profits. It’s entirely possible to buy every common and uncommon card in the game for a couple of dollars. <em>Kotaku</em>’s Ethan Gach <a href="https://kotaku.com/artifact-s-controversial-cards-for-money-system-has-bee-1830781980">reports</a> building a viable Black deck for $15.92, and even a tournament-ready deck will, at present, cost only $30 or so dollars — far, far less expensive than <em>Magic</em> ever was. And as more cards enter the ecosystem, the supply of Rare cards will necessarily rise, and prices will, in turn, drop. And, of course, with multiple “casual” game modes, it is possible to enjoy <em>Artifact</em> without spending a penny beyond your initial investment (as I have). Doing so limits you to a few modes — unranked casual games, bot matches, friend-to-friend challenges, etc. — but, for a great many players, that may be enough. The issue is what happens if you want <em>more</em>.</p><p>Like all commodities, <em>Artifact</em> cards have what Karl Marx called “use value” (what you can do with a commodity, e.g. play Axe in your center lane and wallop enemy creeps) and “exchange value” (what you can get for a commodity on the open market). This is true of every virtual good you can find on the Steam Marketplace, from <em>Counter-Strike</em> guns to <em>Dota 2</em> maps, but the entanglement of these two kinds of value is particularly apparent in Artifact. Like most card games, <em>Artifact</em> — through its <a href="https://github.com/ValveSoftware/ArtifactDeckCode">open API</a> and Valve’s willingness to accommodate <a href="https://www.artibuff.com/">third-party analysis sites</a> — embraces tier lists, power rankings, win rates, and all the other hallmarks of data-driven deck-building. But given that every card is, also, a few short clicks away, in-game power and market value are entangled as never before. (This means, also, that balancing cards can itself be a form of price manipulation, one that goes beyond the self-correcting, “invisible hand” logic of arbitrage that Dr. Garfield points to). <em>Artifact</em> encourages you to know the value of every card you have, at every moment, both as a weapon (i.e. use value) and a tradable commodity (i.e. exchange value). Everyone who buys <em>Artifact</em> becomes, like it or not, an entrepreneur too. Now that’s alchemy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Rg-OoKSjBC4OPtcRoz8R3A.png" /></figure><p>Ultimately, I don’t have much interest in arguing whether or not <em>Artifact</em> is “worth it” — that answer lies with each player, who is free to participate as much or as little as they choose. What interests me is the underlying structure of <em>Artifact</em>’s market, and what makes it distinctive from its competitors. <em>Artifact</em>’s supporters are right to point out that the game will very likely cost less to play than <em>Hearthstone</em>, which, for very serious players, can cost <a href="https://www.polygon.com/2017/12/12/16763594/hearthstone-expensive-expansions-cost">up to $400 per year</a>. Yet the <em>Hearthstone</em> comparison misses something important about <em>Artifact</em>’s economy: There is no “trading” in <em>Hearthstone</em> (unless you count buying from Blizzard as a kind of trade), whereas <em>Artifact</em> is built on it. <em>Artifact</em> doesn’t have to cost as much per year <em>to you</em> to be just as valuable <em>to Valve</em>, because it’s players — not <em>Valve</em> — who take on the labor of buying and selling. Skimming two cents off of one million common card transactions ($20,000), is, ultimately, just as valuable as selling 1,000 copies of the base game. (<a href="https://twitter.com/PlayArtifact/status/1068959077990981632">As of December 1st</a>, there have been 6,056,282 cards traded, the fees for which have likely netted Valve around $250,000). And because each card can be traded an infinite number of times (digital cards don’t fade) the long tail of <em>Artifact</em> is very long indeed. Such transactions are very nearly pure profit for Valve, and the company has every reason to keep consumer pricing down to continue extracting rents. Valve isn’t lying when it <a href="https://twitter.com/PlayArtifact/status/1072350816332333056">announces</a>, in defiance of <em>Artifact</em>’s rocky reception and crumbling player base, that they’re “in it for the long haul.”</p><p>But so what? It goes without saying that no one is forced to participate in <em>Artifact</em>’s financial metagames — Casual and Social Play will always be there, and the churning cycles of game news have largely moved on. And it’s no revelation to suggest that video games have economies, whether of the in-game (e.g. <em>EVE Online</em>’s famously treacherous free market) or out-of-game (e.g. the robust trade of <em>Counter-Strike</em> skins) variety. Even so, it’s commonplace for us to regard the latter kind of video game economy as something that a game <em>has</em>, as if it’s supplemental to what, on some ontological level, a game <em>is</em>. And yet <em>Artifact</em> is, in many ways, exactly the opposite: not a game with an economy, so much as an economy with a game. This means that Artifact’s real significance — what, I think, we ought to be “reviewing” — might not have anything to do with games at all. If we want to see <em>Artifact</em>’s real significance, we need to look elsewhere — or, really, everywhere.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*w65NRITsSQpLXwYruIcY0Q.png" /></figure><p>Like most of Valve’s “innovations”, <em>Artifact</em> isn’t any less exploitative than its peers so much as it’s much better at hiding its exploitation, turning play into work and drawing it out over time, across the horizon where intention becomes infrastructure. In that, it has something in common with today’s tech dystopia as it attempts to capture more and more of human life. This is what <em>platforms</em> — from Uber to Facebook to Airbnb to Etsy — do, and <em>Artifact</em> is a game for the age of platforms. In their classic sense, platforms are infrastructures that connect two or more users for social economic exchange, and the ability for algorithms to manage this “labor” at scale with have made them the dominant economic form of our era. This, in essence, is <em>Artifact</em>, and to endorse it is, implicitly, to endorse the entire system it reflects.</p><p>Though we have largely welcomed platforms — because they let us speak farther than our voices can carry, because they have empowered us to be our own bosses, because they open others’ homes to us — the so-called <a href="https://techcrunch.com/2017/10/08/dear-silicon-valley-americas-fallen-out-of-love-with-you/">techlash</a> has made it increasingly obvious that we made a Faustian bargain that gave big technology companies more control over the world than ever before. Whatever new ways of being social platforms offer, they will always be on someone else’s terms, and for their profit. Convenience, as it turns out, was an invitation to even greater form of domination by capital.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lctL8KgANyEy6vhXlxkN_g.png" /></figure><p>“Whereas peasants and serfs were dispossessed of land and forced to urbanize and take up wage labor, internet users are being dispossessed of their time and attention, which are being enclosed through surveillance, then quantified and monetized,” writes Dr. Daniel Joseph, a political economist (<a href="https://waypoint.vice.com/en_us/contributor/daniel-joseph">and Waypoint contributor</a>) at the University of Toronto, who <a href="https://digital.library.ryerson.ca/islandora/object/RULA%3A6820">wrote his dissertation on Steam</a>. “Platforms are the means for this enclosure, mediating activity for the purposes of controlling all forms of exchange around it.”</p><p>Perhaps that all seems far from <em>Artifact</em> — a humble card game, after all, about wizards and shit — but it’s really not. <em>Artifact</em> does to <em>Magic</em> what Facebook did to friendships. Facebook dreams of capturing all that is social, and while <em>Artifact</em> has a different target in mind, the principle of enclosing <em>more</em> is the same. As it turns out, capturing metagames is not all that different from capturing our social lives. Dr. Garfield was right that “games without metagames … don’t really exist.” Yet where he saw metagames as the essence of what made games matter, Valve saw an opportunity to turn <em>Magic</em>’s metagames — its proxy cards, its aftermarkets — into markets of its own, a transmutation only Steam was equipped to do. That, in the end, is <em>Artifact</em> in its iron heart: a machine for capturing metagames.</p><p>///</p><p><em>If you’d like to follow me on the site formerly known as Twitter, I am @william_partin. I don’t post much anymore.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e12a052b4d7a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[As Esports Explores, Will Valve’s ‘Dota 2' Be Left for Dead?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/bboongbboong/as-esports-explores-will-valves-dota-2-be-left-for-dead-2d0745806eba?source=rss-1b6c76037763------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d0745806eba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ecosystem]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[esport]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[finance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[venture-capital]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Will Partin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Dec 2019 15:06:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-09T17:11:40.461Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>As Esports Explodes, Will Valve’s ‘Dota 2&#39; Be Left for Dead?</h3><p><em>This article was originally published in Glixel on May 1st, 2017 and was edited by Miguel Lopez and Simon Cox. As I recall, I started thinking about the topic when I noticed that virtually no new VC money was coming into ‘Dota 2&#39; but going to franchise games instead. That observation grewinto a piece about the idiosyncratic and often self-defeating dynamics of the ‘Dota 2’ ecosystem and how Valve’s idiosyncratic approach to managing it (or not) shapes its professional ecosystem. This was written before I started diving into the platformization literature (e.g. Dan Joseph’s dissertation on Steam), but I see some of the arguments I’m making these days in embryonic form. Suffice to say, most Dota 2 fans still fundamentally don’t understand what makes Valve different from other publishers.</em></p><p><em>One other thing– a lot of people (especially on /r/dota2) took this article to mean that I think Dota 2 should have franchising. This is absolutely not what I was (or am) arguing, though I can see how one would get that from this article. (For the record: I don’t think franchising would work for Dota 2 in its current form). Likewise, Jack Etienne is not the “hero” of this story – Cloud9 is the narrative vehicle here not because they’re “right” but because the company usefully traces this tricky history. In any case, the arguments here have aged pretty well since the changes Valve has made with the DPC have, all things considered, been pretty piecemeal.</em></p><p>///</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*TvMSrJuzeUVq4ODE.jpg" /></figure><p>In 2013, Jack Etienne was a vice-president of sales at Crunchyroll, one of the largest distributors of anime in the English speaking world. But after work — and sometimes during it — he was a team manager for Team SoloMid, one of the most popular <em>League of Legends</em> squads in North America. In another life, Etienne might still be working for TSM or Crunchyroll. But that spring, Etienne was offered a rare opportunity to purchase his own <em>League of Legends</em> team, Quantic Gaming. Sensing destiny knocking, he and his wife paid a reported $15,000 for Quantic, a pittance for esports even in its early days.</p><p>The chance to purchase Quantic Gaming arose because of the sudden disappearance of its previous owner, Simon Boudreault, a millennial scion who bet his inheritance on fielding a winning esports organization. After Quantic’s <em>League of Legends</em> team failed to qualify for the spring split of the 2013 League Championship Series, Boudreault vanished into the ether, leaving behind a host of debts and a broken organization. Acquiring Quantic was a risk for Etienne, but it paid off. Under the new name Cloud9, the team earned its way back into the LCS and went on to have one of the most successful single-season performances in <em>League of Legends</em> history, culminating in a 3–0 sweep of Team SoloMid in the finals of the Summer Championship.</p><p>In a matter of months, Etienne found himself at the helm of one of esports’ most valuable new brands; he quit his job at Crunchyroll, and put his sales training to work, drumming up new sponsors for the team. Importantly, Cloud9 required no outside investment. It was profitable from day one on a simple business model: sponsorship money came in, and slightly less than that in expenses — mostly salaries for players and staff — went out. The model wasn’t especially sophisticated, but it worked well with esports in its infancy, and allowed Etienne to grow his organization without turning to outside investors.</p><p>Etienne moved quickly to build on Cloud9’s success in <em>League of Legends</em>, looking to expand his team into other professional scenes. <em>Dota 2</em>, Valve Software’s remake of the classic <em>WarCraft III</em> mod <em>Defense of the Ancients</em>, was a natural choice. Not only was the game similar to <em>League of Legends</em> — another 5v5 multiplayer game in the same genre — but <em>Dota 2</em>’s competitive scene was on the rise. Equally important, <em>Dota 2</em> had an “open circuit” that offered an easy point of entry for organizations. Unlike <em>League of Legends</em>’ closed circuit — a single league, the LCS, managed by Riot Games with a finite number of teams — professional <em>Dota 2</em> was spread across a large and growing number of tournaments across the globe. Millions of dollars in prize money were up for grabs, and the lightweight, largely unregulated ecosystem made it easy for new organizations like Cloud9 to field teams. And so, Etienne set off to find five <em>Dota 2</em> players to become Cloud9’s second professional team.</p><p><strong>///</strong></p><p>With hindsight, the moment at which Cloud9 first ventured into <em>Dota 2</em> was a golden age for the game’s professional scene. From 2012 to 2014, the number of premier <em>Dota 2 </em>tournaments — an informal designation referring to high prestige tournaments with massive prize pools and an offline LAN finals — rose from 20 to 30. Viewership was strong, spirits were high, prize pools were big, and there seemed to be no upper limit to the game’s potential as an esport.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/808/0*Ob92__YL4OUexYA7.jpg" /><figcaption>the boys @ dotapit (photo: dotapit)</figcaption></figure><p>These days, though, you could be forgiven for thinking that <em>Dota </em>2’s professional scene has stagnated. The number of premier tournaments sunk to 19 in 2016 from 29 in 2014, and, unless more tournaments are announced for the latter half of 2017, a mere 13 this year. Though there are still A-list sponsors like Monster Energy and Comcast in <em>Dota 2</em>, they are increasingly rare and, across the board, sponsorship portfolios are far less impressive than they used to be. Many once-proud organizations have been reduced to taking money from dubious online betting sites and the <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170803173844/http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2017-04-20-g2a-rep-roasted-by-developers-during-live-q-and-a">notorious key-buying</a> service, G2A. Team NP, a leading North American team, is sponsored by an artisan hot sauce company.</p><p>Depending on your perspective, though, the most worrying sign about the health of <em>Dota </em>2’s professional scene is the complete lack of investment into the game by a new generation of high profile, venture-backed, multigame organizations. Founded in the mid-2010s and backed by the likes of Shaquille O’Neal and Rick Fox, organizations like Team NRG, Immortals, and Echo Fox have infused esports with more money than all but the most vivid of dreamers could have imagined a decade ago. To date, none have acquired a <em>Dota 2</em> team. Though all routinely acknowledge a vague interest in doing so, there is little to suggest they will anytime soon.</p><p>Why is that? Esports is not a trickle-down economy, and investments into esports concentrate in whatever scenes investors think will provide the best return on their money. And right now, <em>Dota 2</em> is not one of those scenes. News of multimillion-dollar investments into esports teams have become a weekly occurrence, yet professional <em>Dota 2</em> is not benefiting from this ongoing infusion of cash into the esports ecosystem. The writing on the wall could hardly be clearer — esports is changing, and <em>Dota 2</em> is not changing with it.</p><p>The explanation is simple: Valve has largely shown indifference, if not outright hostility, to the things that motivate this new generation of esports investors. In particular, they’re interested in franchising and media rights, which constitute the majority of revenue for traditional sports organizations (it comes as no surprise that the majority of these investors made their millions in sports).</p><p>What’s at stake in this dissonance — between these investors’ goals and Valve’s refusal to play their game — is nothing less than a battle over what esports should <em>be</em>, and who esports should serve. Whether it’s Valve and <em>Dota </em>2’s open circuit free-for-all, Riot’s mostly closed circuit, Activision Blizzard’s Overwatch League’s <em>absolutely</em> closed circuit, or some kind of hybrid, the shape for esports is very far from set. And few things trace the contours of this shifting order — its many possibilities and its many pitfalls — more closely than the history of Cloud9 in <em>Dota 2</em>.</p><p>///</p><p>While searching for a suitable team to represent the Cloud9 brand in <em>Dota 2</em>, Etienne came across a familiar story. Speed Gaming, a talented but untested <em>Dota 2</em> squad, had been abandoned by its owner only days before MLG Columbus, one of the year’s most prestigious <em>Dota 2 </em>events. Seemingly unaffected by their organization’s collapse, the team won the tournament against all expectations. For Etienne, everything seemed right — here was a young team, seemingly in desperate need of stable and sane sponsorship, playing a game set on an upward trajectory.</p><p>Two months later, Speed Gaming became Cloud9’s first <em>Dota 2</em> team. Once again, Etienne struck gold. Over the next 18 months, Cloud9 would win over $1.5 million in prize money and became one of the most popular teams in all of <em>Dota 2</em>. Its charming players — especially the team’s eccentric captain, Jacky “EternalEnVy” Mao — became superstars in the world of <em>Dota 2</em>.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FqrP4oey2_ys%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DqrP4oey2_ys&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FqrP4oey2_ys%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e3d752f5479059e3bc1a471cf90a3e8d/href">https://medium.com/media/e3d752f5479059e3bc1a471cf90a3e8d/href</a></iframe><p>Alongside the success of Cloud9’s <em>League</em> and <em>Dota 2</em> teams, the organization was able to expand into many other games, signing <em>Super Smash Bros. Melee</em> legend Joseph “Mango” Marquez in May 2014 and a <em>Counter-Strike: Global Offensive</em> squad three months later.</p><p><em>Cloud9’s Dota 2</em> team disbanded amicably after a middling performance during The International 2015; some retired, and some moved on to other organizations. Etienne set out to find a new roster to represent Cloud9, and hopefully repeat the success of the organization’s previous roster. This time, though, things weren’t destined to go as smoothly.</p><p>///</p><p><em>Dota </em>2’s professional scene began in 2011 when Valve organized the world’s first million-dollar esports tournament, The International, which was held at the annual Gamescom convention in Cologne. Shortly after, Valve indicated that the company was only interested in running The International once a year, and that third party companies were free to organize their own tournaments of any format and any scale.</p><p>Within a year, professional <em>Dota 2</em> resembled a virtual archipelago — nearly two dozen tournaments were held in 2012, organized by almost as many companies, all interested in leveraging the growing popularity of Valve’s MOBA. At the time, Valve’s laissez-faire approach to the professional <em>Dota 2</em> scene made perfect sense and fit well with the company’s broader approach to doing business. Not only was <em>Dota </em>2’s professional circuit free marketing for the game, but, like Steam, competitive <em>Dota 2</em> was also a platform that Valve could provide to third parties and take a small cut of any revenues they might generate (in this case, in-game ticket sales and tournament-branded virtual goods). For Valve, this was almost pure profit.</p><p>Valve’s approach stood in stark contrast to <em>Dota </em>2’s largest competitor, <em>League of Legends</em>, whose publisher, Riot Games, took great care to ensure that the game’s professional scene was centered on the League Championship Series (LCS). Closely modeled on traditional, season-length sports and necessitating a major investment of both time and employees for little to no financial return (at least at first), the LCS became the closed model of esports par excellence. What it lacked in expansiveness and flexibility, the LCS made up for in having a consistently high-quality product, stable viewership, easy-to-follow storylines, and major sponsors like Coca-Cola.</p><p>The “open circuit” of <em>Dota 2</em> had its drawbacks, of course. Valve’s calculated absence from the scene meant that there was almost no accountability for teams and tournaments that engaged in fraudulent activities. For years, many high-profile tournaments failed to pay out their prize pools, even as they organized subsequent seasons of competition. Fraud was rampant across the scene, as were bizarre business decisions, like the one-time CEO of Speed Gaming Marco Fernandez making his players contracts <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170803173844/http://www.liquiddota.com/forum/dota-2-general/452654-speed-gaming-contracts">publically available</a> without their consent in the name of “transparency” (and which, incidentally, kicked off the chain of events that led to Speed Gaming being signed by Cloud9). In and out of game, player conduct was (and is) demonstrably worse in <em>Dota 2</em> than any other esport, save, perhaps, <em>Call of Duty</em>, but went largely undisciplined. Broadcast quality varied widely between tournaments, and oversaturation quickly became a major concern. During weeks in which multiple leagues ran concurrently, they often cannibalized each other’s audience, depressing viewer numbers to everyone’s detriment.</p><p>These indiscretions didn’t reflect well on <em>Dota 2</em>. But, strictly speaking, they weren’t Valve’s problem. Why should Valve be responsible for the bad behavior of the players, teams, and tournament organizers when it was merely providing a platform for them to do business? Still, the company <em>was</em> culpable in creating an environment in which this kind of behavior could exist unchecked. Over time, fans began to grow weary of the slow drip of scandals that plagued professional <em>Dota 2</em>, which became all the more embarrassing alongside the professionalization of esports as a whole and <em>League of Legends</em> especially. The very flexibility that had once made <em>Dota </em>2’s open circuit so enticing was increasingly starting to resemble anarchy.</p><p>///</p><p>In August 2015, as Cloud9’s classic <em>Dota 2</em> roster dispersed across the world, Etienne started looking for a new squad to represent the brand in <em>Dota 2</em>.</p><p>By that point, Cloud9 had grown into one of the largest North American esports organizations around and was one of the few teams capable of attracting big-name brand sponsors, which still constituted the majority of the team’s revenue. Given Cloud9’s prestige and wealth, as well as a large number of unsponsored <em>Dota 2</em> players in North America, putting together a new, elite <em>Dota 2</em> team seemed perfectly reasonable.</p><p>But 2015 was not 2013, and Etienne quickly found that the <em>Dota 2</em> ecosystem had changed dramatically and that the North American scene was especially volatile. There was no shortage of talented players, but through most of 2015, they changed teams like they were changing clothes — no lineup seemed to last longer than a few weeks. Because most of these players now subsisted on prize money and streaming revenues — and not salaries — they were strongly incentivized to change teams whenever they thought they stood a better chance of winning. Why would it matter what name you’re competing under as long as you’re earning prize money?</p><p>Eventually, Etienne set his sights on an up and coming team of young, second-tier players from the United States and Canada. They weren’t superstars, and most had never played for a legitimate organization before, but they had potential. With support and stability, Etienne reasoned, they could become a top team. And so, on September 1st, 2015, Etienne signed the second iteration of Cloud9’s <em>Dota 2</em> team.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FUaSuM5dKgx0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DUaSuM5dKgx0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FUaSuM5dKgx0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c985f91232251a7c2d8ca43eaa989354/href">https://medium.com/media/c985f91232251a7c2d8ca43eaa989354/href</a></iframe><p>For a while, it seemed like Etienne might have made yet another great bet. In its first two months of competition, the new Cloud9 qualified for multiple premiere LANs and even won an all-online tournament. Most importantly, though, the team earned a spot at The Frankfurt Major — the first event of Valve’s new “Major” system — a series of big-money tournaments held several times each year.</p><p>But just days before the Major, player EternalEnVy leaked chat logs that showed one of Cloud9’s team members, Ravindu “Ritsu” Kodippili, secretly sharing intelligence about Cloud9’s practice partners. Though not technically illegal, the infraction was a huge violation of the <em>Dota 2</em> scene’s unwritten code of conduct, and many top teams announced that they would no longer scrimmage with Cloud9 — a death sentence for any serious team.</p><p>In the week after the revelations dropped, more allegations of bad behavior from Ritsu emerged, including stalking another player’s sister and fraud. Because it was too late to sign a replacement player, Cloud9 ended up competing with Ritsu at the Frankfurt Major under a haze of scandal but was unceremoniously eliminated early on. One day later, Ritsu was dropped from Cloud9’s roster, and, a week after that, the team disbanded altogether, leaving Cloud9 teamless in <em>Dota 2</em> once more.</p><p>Etienne and Cloud9 actively looked for another <em>Dota 2</em> team, but when no viable options emerged, he gave up the search. At the moment at least, <em>Dota 2</em> was more trouble than it was worth, and Cloud9 — now a powerhouse of esports with a deep portfolio of desirable sponsors — could do just fine without it.</p><p>///</p><p>The short-lived second coming of Cloud9 in <em>Dota 2</em> transpired alongside a major shift in how Valve understood its role in the <em>Dota 2</em> scene. Despite the company’s initial, anti-interventionist stance, Valve reluctantly began to exert more of a guiding hand on the professional <em>Dota 2</em> scene.</p><p>Signs of Valve’s influence came in many forms, big and small. Before 2015, for example, if a player were proven to have fixed a professional <em>Dota 2</em> match for their own gain, it was the responsibility of the corresponding tournament to investigate and discipline that player. But starting in March 2015 with the MalaysianTeam Redemption, which had been found guilty of fixing a match the previous fall, Valve began permanently banning any player caught fixing matches from its own events.</p><p>More significantly, though, Valve began organizing the Dota 2 Majors — $3 million tournaments intended act as mid-season championships in the year-long leadup to The International. Alongside the Majors, Valve also announced designated periods when teams could add and drop players from their rosters. Though teams were free to ignore them, it meant losing a possible invite to the Majors and possibly The International, the huge prize pools of which made them far more important than any other tournament in the scene.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*i2CkINpnHrd1wU2K.png" /></figure><p>This change in policy was widely understood to counteract what many saw as volatility in lineups among high-level players. As prize pools in <em>Dota 2</em> grew — especially in Valve’s own multimillion-dollar tournaments — players increasingly came to depend on winnings over salary for the majority of their livelihood. If a player thought they stood a better chance of qualifying for or winning a Valve event with a team other than their own, they were quick to jump ship. This instability among top teams reached a breaking point in early 2015 when teams would swap rosters after virtually every tournament they did not win; between January and April 2015, for example, the Swedish outfit Alliance cycled through nearly a dozen players before settling on a long term lineup.</p><p>But solutions often create as many problems as they solve. While Valve’s designated roster swaps did, in fact, increase the stability of elite teams’ rosters, the Major system also had deleterious effects, particularly on third-party tournament organizers, who now had a regular series of multimillion-dollar events to contend with. Despite Valve’s best intentions, the <em>Dota 2</em> circuit increasingly seemed as if it were becoming open in name only.</p><p>“It’s a challenging ecosystem that we struggle for relevance in, and, by we, I mean pretty much everyone,” a senior official at a major esports company tells me. “Or everyone but Valve. When there’s $20 million on the line, you just can’t compete with that. These simply aren’t economics that independent companies can compete with.”</p><p>Not only have third party companies on which the <em>Dota 2</em> scene once relied found themselves overshadowed by Valve’s own events, but they’ve also sometimes been in direct conflict. Last fall, Valve announced that the Boston Major would take place in early December 2016, one week after the LAN Finals of DreamLeague Season 6 in Stockholm. Though DreamLeague had scheduled their event months in advance, more than half the teams set to attend dropped out in order to prepare for the Boston Major, forcing DreamLeague to stock its bracket with lesser-known teams.</p><p>“We knew the time conflict was a possibility, but Valve announces the Majors so late that if you want to run an event you either have to gamble or not do anything,” explains Matt Weber, who organizes tournaments at DreamHack, which organizes several <em>Dota 2</em> events on top of DreamLeague each year. “What happened with DreamLeague was a worst-case scenario. I’d imagine that people looking on the periphery are even more scared of running <em>Dota 2</em> events if they were watching that.”</p><p>Small wonder, then, that the number of premier tournaments began to fall in late 2014, not long after The International 4’s prize pool ballooned to $11 million, far more than any other organizer could hope to match, even with crowdfunding. The Major system has only accelerated this decline, and unless more tournaments are announced for the fall, 2017 will have only 13 premiere events, an all-time low. Consequently, players are even <em>more</em> dependent on Valve’s events than they were before. In 2014, 68% of the year’s prize money came from The International; in 2016, a full 81% of prize money was handed out at Valve events.</p><p>Still, the amount of prize money in <em>Dota 2</em> has than doubled over this period, from $16 million in 2014 to $37 million in 2016. It’s hard out there for tournament organizers, but it’s a great time to be a <em>Dota 2</em> player (or, more accurately, it’s a great time to be a great <em>Dota 2</em> player).</p><p>///</p><p>In the weeks after The International 6 in August 2016, top <em>Dota 2</em> teams from across the world began shuffling rosters, looking for the ideal lineup of players to ensure victory in future tournaments. Many in the world of <em>Dota 2</em> expected Cloud9 to sign Team NP, a newly formed organization whose players had all played for Cloud9 at some point. At the same time, multigame organizations like Cloud9 were looking for teams to sponsor. But once again, they found that the <em>Dota 2</em> scene had changed in ways that made it more hostile to organizations than ever before.</p><p>With so much money tied to prize pools in both absolute and proportional terms, very little now mattered to top <em>Dota 2 </em>players besides winning. Even if it guaranteed a salary, signing with Cloud9 or Immortals also meant contracts demanding regular interviews, media appearances, mandatory streaming sessions, all of which threatened to get in the way of practicing. No salary was worth risking a spot at a lucrative Valve event, and so more teams decided to compete without the support of a sponsored organization. In a sense, top <em>Dota 2</em> teams weren’t just exploring the best way to play <em>Dota 2</em> — they were figuring out how to game the<em> Dota 2 </em>system. Metagames exist at least as much out of game as they do in-game, and many <em>Dota 2</em> teams started to realize that signing with an organization like Cloud9 simply wasn’t an optimal strategy anymore.</p><p>This put top <em>Dota 2</em> teams squarely at odds with major esports organizations like Cloud9 and Immortals. Creating behind-the-scenes content, player documentaries, and exclusive interviews were all crucial for building these teams’ brands, but <em>Dota 2</em> players balk at the strong incentive to take part if it gets in the way of practice.</p><p>“We see ourselves fundamentally as a media company,” says one high-profile investor for a major North American team, speaking on condition of anonymity.</p><p>“Any <em>Dota 2</em> player who isn’t willing to do content and interviews just isn’t the right player for us,” said Immortals CEO Noah Whinston in a recent interview. “That kind of content is super important to help build a connection between fans and players.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*LxsYefGtcvk5kprI.jpg" /></figure><p>Organizations interested in getting into <em>Dota 2</em> were left with only a few options, none of which are especially desirable. Cloud9 could offer a heap of cash to a top team and expect little in return in the way of content, or sign a second or third tier in need of a salary because their modest tournament winnings wouldn’t cover their operating costs.</p><p>Etienne eventually settled on the latter approach, and, in January 2017, he signed Danish Bears, a mid-level European team with almost no results to their name. It was Cloud9’s third venture into <em>Dota 2</em>. This time, though, the team was a dud. “We ended up taking a shot with the Danish Bears, and we’re trying to support them and make a strong team,” Etienne says. “But it hasn’t been easy. They haven’t qualified for events like we hoped they would.”</p><p>It’s disappointing, of course, but it’s a low-risk bet for an organization of Cloud9’s stature. Even if their new <em>Dota 2</em> team never qualifies for a major tournament, it’s not the devastating blow it might have been several years ago. Cloud9, like many other multigame organizations, have their eyes on something bigger — even bigger than The International — and, for them, <em>Dota 2</em> need not be a part of it all.</p><p>///</p><p>Last month, Cloud9 announced that it had raised several million dollars in Series A funding from investors like Alexis Ohanian, co-founder of Reddit, Joe Montana, legendary San Francisco 49er quarterback, and Chamath Palihapitiya, co-owner of the Golden State Warriors.</p><p>In an <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170803173844/http://www.glixel.com/interviews/cloud9s-ceo-on-expansion-overwatch-league-and-whats-next-w475815">interview</a> with Glixel, Etienne explained the goals behind the new round of funding, for which he sold a minority share of the company. “Esports could stay as it is now indefinitely,” Etienne says. “But if we want it to grow and become competitive with traditional sports, if we want to get to the next stage for a focus for the future, we need to start seeing franchises. We don’t really participate in revenue from media rights, which is what carries traditional sports. Until we’re part of a league where that’s part of the revenue share, where all the media rights are sold, we’re not realizing the whole potential of our viewership.”</p><p>This is even more true of the generation of venture-backed teams founded in the mid-2010s, who do not have the deep portfolio of sponsorships that teams like Cloud9 and TSM do.</p><p>“Very few of these teams are profitable,” an investor from a venture-backed organization told me. “Most teams are holding out in hopes of getting a share of broadcasting television revenue in a few years.”</p><p>The cloud hanging over all of this is the Overwatch League, Activision Blizzard’s upcoming mega-league built entirely on the principles of franchising and media rights. To subsidize the startup costs for its massive venture, Activision Blizzard has been selling permanent franchises that are estimated to cost up to $15 million in major cities like Los Angeles. Virtually no teams have the capital handy for this buy-in, and the recent spate of multimillion-dollar investments is a prelude to a bidding war for a spot in the Overwatch League among top teams. That’s certainly the case for Cloud9.</p><p>“That money is set aside to make sure we can be involved in some of the franchising going on,” Etienne says about Cloud9’s recent infusion of funds. “Blizzard is getting people to invest in the Overwatch League, and there’s going to be a significant buy-in.”</p><p>A closed ecosystem premised on franchising and media rights is not necessarily the “correct” or even the only model for esports. There are real concerns about player exploitation and monopolistic practices. But, at the moment, this is the model with the most money behind it, and therefore likely to define the face of esports going forward. The International may indeed net Valve a cool $100 million (at least) each year, but one recent Morgan Stanley report estimated that the best-case-scenario for the Overwatch League could see it worth up to $700 million.</p><p>That report has its critics, many of whom see Morgan Stanley’s bullish estimate as dangerously overinflated, and if the history of esports has taught us anything, it’s that the success of Overwatch League is far from assured. Many unknowns remain about the potential consumer base for esports — will fans ever accept pay-per-view content? If so, at what price? And what’s the normal price points fans are willing to pay for merchandise? Does premium content matter to this audience? And how, if at all, should live events be integrated into a franchise esports league? Still, it’s also not hard to see why new investment into esports has concentrated around teams and games interested in franchising and media rights — which lend themselves to as opposed to the wild west of <em>Dota 2</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/912/0*7f4wOFVMPsEBwZQr.jpeg" /></figure><p>Theoretically, any third party organizer could create a franchise league in <em>Dota 2</em>. But in practice, the only entity with the capital to do so in the <em>Dota 2</em> ecosystem is Valve itself.</p><p>“I would love to see Valve attempt a franchise system,” says Etienne. “There just don’t seem to be any plans to have a franchise system and Valve just hasn’t really opened up and had much of a dialogue with the teams yet.”</p><p>“I think the best way to get them interested would be for Overwatch League to be really successful.”</p><p>If you read Valve more closely, however, it’s hard to be as sanguine as Etienne. Even if Overwatch League is the resounding success that Morgan Stanley thinks it could be and so many investors and teams are betting that it will be, Valve has strong reasons for refusing to become involved in a closed circuit league with franchising and ongoing negotiations over media rights. Though the Major system constitutes a move toward an imperfect hybrid model, it’s extremely doubtful that Valve is willing to go as far as setting up a franchise league, no matter how successful Overwatch League is. It simply isn’t in the company’s DNA.</p><p>///</p><p>When Valve was founded in 1996, Gabe Newell and Mike Harrington, two former Microsoft engineers, conceived it as a new kind of technology company unburdened by creativity-stifling corporate hierarchies and meddling shareholders. True to this vision, Valve eventually instituted what the company calls “flatland.” As the company’s new employee handbook explains it, flatland “removes every organizational barrier between your work and the customer enjoying that work.” No managers, no hierarchy, and desks on wheels so that employees can form and disband working groups at will.</p><p>Flatland is dogma at Valve, and it has every reason to be. Reportedly, Valve has the <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170803173844/http://www.businessinsider.com/valve-profits-2011-2">highest profit per employee</a> of any company in the United States. As a private company, Valve is under no obligation to release its financial information, but a low estimate of the company’s yearly revenues is around $1 billion on a workforce of 250 or $4.4 million per employee. (For reference, Blizzard earns around $1.1 billion on a staff of 4700 — about $234,000 per employee).</p><p>Valve’s unmatched efficiency is the result of the company’s emphasis on services and platforms with extremely high profit margins. Steam controls an estimated 50 to 70 percent of the PC gaming market, and Valve takes a 30% cut on every game sold with relatively little overhead. Valve’s cut from purchases on Steam is almost pure profit, as is the company’s stewardship over Steam’s robust economy of virtual goods — “hats,” as most players call them — for Valve’s own games. Valve also takes a small cut from every transaction on the Steam Marketplace, where users and buy and sell virtual goods. The constant movement of <em>Dota 2</em>, <em>Team Fortress</em>, and <em>CounterStrike: Global Offensive</em> items and skins generates tens of millions of dollars annually at almost no cost to Valve.</p><p>“Our job is to maximize productivity in creating digital goods and services,” said Newell in a frank explanation of the philosophy behind <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20170803173844/http://reallifemag.com/code-of-conduct/">Steam-as-a-platform</a> in a recent interview. “The markets will determine what the marginal value add of each of those activities are. The kinds of ways in which people create value and creativity and creating frameworks for that are going to vary.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HuyygIvdfM6lDwlX.jpg" /></figure><p>The “open circuit” approach to <em>Dota 2</em> that Valve originally employed is an extension of this strategy, an extremely labor-efficient way of outsourcing the <em>Dota 2</em> scene to third party companies. Running a franchised system on the scale of Overwatch League, on the other hand, takes a tremendous number of people; by the time it launches later this year, Blizzard-Activision will have hired dozens of employees dedicated solely to the project. Moreover, managing a league like this more-or-less demands a clear organizational hierarchy. Flatland is great for making games and software platforms, but not operating esports leagues. Even if this hypothetical <em>Dota 2</em> league is profitable, it’s all but guaranteed it won’t be profitable on the margins that Valve has made its reputation on, but, more importantly, cutting every employee’s effective earnings since Valve, a private company, shares profits among its staff.</p><p>Thus, arguments that Valve could very likely boost revenues by running its <em>Dota 2</em> scene with a firmer hand are not necessarily wrong but <em>are</em> missing the point. Valve has little reason to change its approach to <em>Dota </em>2’s professional scene because the institutional changes needed to ensure that <em>Dota 2</em> will thrive in the new esports ecosystem would require the company to radically alter both its prized flatland and philosophy of business. Put plainly: as long as Gabe Newell is alive and Valve is a private company, there will probably never be a franchising league in <em>Dota 2</em>.</p><p>///</p><p>This is not to say that <em>Dota 2</em> is dead, or even dying. Though its player base has shrunk by around 20% since February 2016, <em>Dota 2</em> still has the largest player base of any Steam game by a huge margin.</p><p>“Quantitatively, <em>Dota 2</em> still looks very good in number reports for both players and viewers,” Matt Weber from DreamHack notes.</p><p>In 2017, professional <em>Dota 2</em> finds itself at an impasse, increasingly isolated from the rest of the esports world with no obvious way forward. When it comes to franchising, third party organizers like DreamHack have a clear incentive for professional <em>Dota 2</em> to succeed but do not have the capital. Valve, by contrast, has the capital but not the incentive. Meanwhile, the <em>Dota 2</em> scene is stuck in a gilded limbo of explosive crowdfunding, sponsorless teams, and bounced checks, while the game’s market share erodes and the rest of the esports world builds around it like the Lorax.</p><p>Years ago, the influential baseball writer Bill James set out to answer, once and for all, the timeless debate over whether or not baseball is really a sport or a business. James resisted the temptations of cynicism and instead sided firmly with the idea that baseball, at its heart, is a sport. If Americans’ passion for baseball dried up, he reasoned, then baseball would surely be relegated to the vast junkyard of failed sports, like ski ballet and Slamball (and, for that matter, <em>Heroes of Newerth</em>). But if Major League Baseball someday found itself bankrupt even while some people found meaning in the act of putting bats to balls, then baseball wouldn’t die, per se. It would simply change, and be reinvented to fit the contours of its new situation.</p><p>If <em>Dota 2</em> stays on its current trajectory, the latter is the best its fans can hope for. Without the exposure offered by major broadcast deals, it’s unlikely that <em>Dota 2</em> will benefit much from the new audiences esports will reach in the coming years. This is a future for <em>Dota 2</em> in which small, but dedicated, community of spectators still find meaning in watching <em>Dota 2</em>, and professionals play not for money or fame, but because they love the game. This is not necessarily a bad thing; a fantasy of “pure” competition, unsullied by greed, is alluring indeed.</p><p>What seems more likely is that in 2020, <em>Dota 2</em> will look a lot more like today’s fighting games circuit than the LCS. In contrast to the vast apparatus of sponsors, media rights, and franchises that make up LCS and will make up Overwatch League, <em>Dota 2</em> will mainly be built on the passion of fans who are willing to share their eyes (and, of course, their wallets). As long as this is the case, then there will be professional <em>Dota 2</em>, but it will be increasingly isolated from the rest of esports.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*5mV_IFgPoNYnD-b8.jpg" /></figure><p>None of this is written in stone though. For the most part, <em>Dota 2</em> fans, an ornery bunch under the best of circumstances, have reacted to the idea of franchising with outright hostility. They see franchising as an imposition from on high and worry that it would snuff out the very volatility that makes <em>Dota </em>2’s professional scene so fascinating and infuriating to follow. Valve may yet surprise us with a firmer hand on professional <em>Dota 2</em> than anyone thought possible, and work to cultivate a structured, professional circuit, as well as amateur and collegiate scenes. The company may indeed decide that the changes in its organization and philosophy are worth — financially or not — seeing <em>Dota 2</em> become a “professionalized” esport, or it may delegate this work to a third party.</p><p>In the meantime, it’s worth reflecting on why <em>Dota 2</em> is the way it is, and why it steadfastly refuses to change. Things are the way they are because of the ways they were. Being honest about the precarious state of <em>Dota 2</em> can help us avoid disappointment later if franchising becomes the norm and <em>Dota 2</em> is relegated to the margins of esports. But more importantly, it can remind us that things could always be otherwise.</p><p>///</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d0745806eba" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/bboongbboong/as-esports-explores-will-valves-dota-2-be-left-for-dead-2d0745806eba">As Esports Explores, Will Valve’s ‘Dota 2&#39; Be Left for Dead?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/bboongbboong">bboongbboong</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘Dota 2’ Player Arteezy on the Hunt for Big Game at the International]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/bboongbboong/dota-2-player-arteezy-on-the-hunt-for-big-game-at-the-international-fc558c15c1dd?source=rss-1b6c76037763------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc558c15c1dd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[performance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[work]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[esport]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Will Partin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 30 Nov 2019 17:41:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-10-12T13:25:30.563Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>A Profile of Artour “Arteezy” Babaev</strong></p><p><em>This piece was originally published in Rolling Stone in Summer 2017 and edited by Brian Crecente, though it began its life under the editorship of Miguel Lopez. When I was writing lots of Dota 2 profiles in 2017, the one I was most excited about doing was Arteezy. He’s my favorite player in Dota 2 and his cerebral attitude has always fascinated me. It took quite a while to sync our schedules, but, for this piece, we ended up chatting twice over Discord for about 30 minutes, two weeks apart. I had been hoping that Arteezy would write his own epilogue by winning The International that year, but that didn’t happen (and still hasn’t). But I still have faith that our boy will get an Aegis one of these years.</em></p><p>///</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*IZR1zj4Rwe5VlICJ.jpg" /><figcaption>Photo: Evil Geniuses</figcaption></figure><p>Artour “Arteezy” Babaev — age 21 and one of the best <em>Dota 2</em> players in the world today — has a tradition at major tournaments. For hours each day, for several days in a row, until he’s either been crowned champion or eliminated, he listens to a single song. He listens until even the most elaborate compositions are pummeled into a background drone. No one would mistake his choices for “good” music — lately, there’s been a lot of German rap — but quality isn’t part of his equation. It doesn’t matter what Arteezy is listening to as long as he’s listening to <em>something</em>. And when he wins, that something becomes one of a growing number of testaments to glories past. If he loses, he’ll never listen to it again.</p><p>The mind of a professional gamer is a curious thing. Arteezy has every bit of the competitive drive that motivates athletes to build their lives around their sport, but also belongs to the slice of humanity that feels most at home inside video games. The results, so far, have been spectacular. You could lose a week watching highlight reels of Arteezy’s best plays, which go beyond the usual <em>that-was-amazing</em> prase and towards into the more rarefied territory of <em>how is that even possible?</em></p><p>Arteezy’s celebrity in <em>Dota 2</em> is singular. He is the rare figure who has not only changed how the game is played, but defined much of its culture. Amateurs emulate his style of play, listen to his <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20171121174612/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuyV6G6atoQ">signature songs</a>, and copy (to many people’s frustration) his <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20171121174612/http://i.imgur.com/fFpfHrc.gif">profane</a> <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20171121174612/http://i.imgur.com/5WyOdWt.jpg">in-game banter</a>. And though <em>Dota 2</em> has made Arteezy rich — he’s earned north of $1 million since 2014 not counting salary, endorsements, and streaming revenue — being rich was never the point. The joy of competition and self-mastery <em>is</em>, and there, Arteezy, winner of <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20171121174612/http://wiki.teamliquid.net/dota2/Arteezy/Results#Detailed_Results">19 major <em>Dota 2</em> tournaments</a>, has nothing left to prove.</p><p>Almost.</p><p>Four years in, Arteezy still hasn’t won the only tournament in <em>Dota 2</em> that matters: The International.</p><p>It is nearly impossible to overstate the importance of The International, <em>Dota </em>2’s annual championship hosted in Seattle, to the game’s professional players. Some of it is money. TI (as fans call it) has always had the largest prize pools in esports history; right now, it’s $22,000,000 and counting. But mostly, it’s a matter of prestige. TI is sacrosanct, and to win it is to be beatified. Every serious <em>Dota 2</em> player competes with the sole intention of winning TI. Everything else is merely a stop along the way. When teams fail to qualify for TI, they disband; win they win, they become beyond reproach. No matter how successful a single player is in <em>Dota 2</em>, failing to win in Seattle will haunt their legacy. Like Charles Barkley pining for a ring that never came, Arteezy is (for now) a king without a crown. And until he wins TI, his reputation will be as hollow as it is large. He knows it, and everyone in <em>Dota 2</em> knows it too.</p><p>“I don’t care what people think of me,” Arteezy says. “I want to win a TI. That’s all I’m thinking about.”</p><p>To date, Arteezy has had three chances at TI, and three times he’s fallen short. This year, he will get a fourth opportunity. But if Arteezy really is so good (and make no mistake, <em>he is</em>), why does he keep stumbling when it matters most?</p><p>///</p><p><strong>The first time that Artour and I speak</strong>, he’s in Vancouver visiting his parents, who immigrated to Canada from Uzbekistan when he was two years old.</p><p>“The point was for me to go to school and make something of myself,” Artour says. “Of course, that didn’t go as planned, but it ended up pretty nicely regardless. I’m doing what I love.”</p><p>By his own admission, Artour has no other aspirations beyond <em>Dota 2</em>: “It’s the only thing I look forward to.” Right now, he plays for Evil Geniuses (EG), one of the richest and most prestigious <em>Dota 2</em> organizations in the world. Because EG is so well-funded, it has the luxury of choosing what tournaments it wants to compete in. Where other teams are more-or-less forced to compete in every tournament they can, EG can select whichever are most convenient for them. As a result, Artour lives in a surprisingly stable cycle: He trains with his teammates in San Francisco, does a two or three tournament tour across the globe, and he returns to Vancouver for a period of convalescence.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*74fmO437_5oDY0SK.jpg" /><figcaption>Photo: HelloBC</figcaption></figure><p>Ostensibly, the trips to Vancouver are meant to reaffirm the life Artour has outside of professional gaming. In practice, though, they often end up having the opposite effect.</p><p>“When I get home from a long boot camp, I have to stop myself from playing <em>Dota 2</em> because I don’t want to burn out,” he says. “I don’t really know what to do with all this time I have at home. At first, I enjoy it. I wake up whenever I want, and I have nothing to do. But then it becomes boring. I wish I had some kind of hobby.”</p><p>In conversation, Artour doesn’t come across as someone who spends a lot of time on self-examination. This is not to say that he isn’t smart. He absolutely is, and his intelligence is crucial to understanding him as a <em>Dota 2</em> player. In high school, he was an exceptional student (at least until he began traveling for <em>Dota 2</em>) and showed a particular affinity for the sciences. In fact, Artour says the only other thing that has ever captured his mind the way <em>Dota 2</em> does is biology, which he brings up frequently in interviews without prompt.</p><p>“I enjoy memorizing things,” Artour explains when I ask if his two passions have anything in common. “It feels really good to me. I try to understand why something works so I can apply it on an exam. That carries on to <em>Dota 2</em>. It’s a nice feeling to understand concepts and apply them.”</p><p>That answer, of course, could probably apply to a professional in any field. And all serious <em>Dota 2</em> players spend an inordinate amount of time trying to understand their game. Some report they often dream they’re inside it, the same way that multilingual people can dream in several languages. But no other player in <em>Dota 2</em> besides Arteezy would compare it to acing a biology test, nor does any other player seem to take the same quality of <em>joy </em>simply from learning concepts. For Arteezy, the concepts are not simply a means to an end. Part of what draws him to <em>Dota 2</em> is discovering new and better ways to play the game, buried somewhere in its monstrously deep ruleset — ways that have been there all along but needed the right set of eyes to unveil them. That these rules change slightly every few weeks only adds to their appeal.</p><p>“Every patch, there’s always something that’s hidden that’s really strong,” he says when asked what keeps him playing. “Whenever I grow as a player, I feel motivated.”</p><p>An analogy might help here. There’s an old cliché that many elite chess players see their game less as a competition and more as a problem in need of a solution; it just happens to be that winning is the solution’s reward. Artour Babaev would have made a great chess player, but he became Arteezy instead. He sees <em>Dota 2</em> as a contest between opposing teams <em>and also</em> a puzzle, always ready, waiting for him to apply himself and devise a solution.</p><p>“I want to feel like I have something to learn,” Arteezy says when pressed about what keeps him playing. “Every game, I want there to be a new concept I can learn, or a new system I can try.”</p><p>Still, it wouldn’t be quite right to say that this kind of innovation comes as the result of meticulous study. <em>Dota 2</em> is no more its rules than a menu is its meals, and Arteezy sees his concepts not as the result of inductive reasoning, but of experience.</p><p>“Most of what I’ve learned about the game is strictly from playing it. Only rarely have I looked at the mechanical changes in a patch until I figured something out,” he says. “You don’t just sit in your chair and look at the changelog and try to find a diamond. You really just have to play a lot of pubs.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*5tEchjOqHGYNlZ0DWMCgjw.png" /><figcaption>Pub results may vary. Photo: Evil Geniuses</figcaption></figure><p>“Pubs,” meaning public games of <em>Dota 2</em>, as opposed to scheduled scrimmages between elite teams or tournament games. The pub occupies a curious space in esports. It’s a place where pros and amateurs alike compete against each other; imagine visiting the nearest public basketball court, only to find Steph Curry drilling threes. All <em>Dota 2</em> pros play pubs every day to stay in competitive shape, but the reverence Arteezy holds for pubs is singular. Even when he’s travelling the world for <em>Dota 2</em>, he rarely goes exploring with his teammates. “I’d much prefer to be close to a PC so I can walk a couple of seconds and start playing pubs,” he says.</p><p>The countless hours Arteezy has spent playing pubs are devoted to taming an impossibly complex game, ensuring that no in-game situation ever feels genuinely unfamiliar – perhaps not unlike listening to a single song until it’s flattened into sonic goo. The more familiar something is, the easier it is to tell when something’s different, and that, for Arteezy, is when discovery begins.</p><p>“Back in 2014 and 2015, most of my ideas were individually ironed out in pubs,” he remembers. “I did pubs all day and figured out what I thought was the best. Maybe if I’d included my team in the process it would have been even better.”</p><p>This process and mentality has made Arteezy one of <em>Dota </em>2’s most consistent innovators. “I learned concepts people didn’t know, and then I’d do them in games,” he says. “When they worked, I felt like I couldn’t be beat.” Early on, he developed techniques like the “<a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20171121174612/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FYY6_MvfkL0">Arteezy block</a>” and new ways to manipulate the game’s AI, tiny tactical advantages that slowly grew into new strategies like the ‘farming mid,” which revolutionized how <em>Dota 2</em> was played. These days, there is very little in the game that hasn’t felt Arteezy’s influence in one way or another.</p><p>///</p><p><strong>There’s a problem, though</strong>. It’s not hard to see how Arteezy’s approach to <em>Dota 2</em> has put him on the bleeding edge of the metagame for years. But his process is an insular one, and <em>Dota 2</em>, of course, is a team game (and it’s worth noting that Arteezy almost never joins a party to play pubs). It is one thing to discover something for yourself, but quite another to align those discoveries with four other people to defeat an opposing team of five.</p><p>Early in his career, Arteezy earned a reputation as the <em>enfant terrible</em> of North American <em>Dota 2</em>: a brilliant player weighed down by his self-centeredness, in-game and out of it. This assessment contains a grain of truth. In a famous dustup in 2013, a more established <em>Dota 2</em> pro suggested that it was too early to tell if Arteezy would become an elite player. It wasn’t exactly an insult, but Arteezy publicly told him to fuck himself anyway, earning him rebukes from many of the game’s veterans.</p><p>Arteezy concedes that, for much of his career, his ego outpaced his results. “When we’d start losing,” he says, “I’d lose faith in my team.”</p><p>For most of his career, Arteezy has been haunted by what he calls the “1v5 mentality,” a creeping outlook that isolates himself from his teammates, turning a 5v5 game into Arteezy vs. the world. Arteezy stresses that the “1v5 mentality” doesn’t mean he’s ever seen his teammates as useless, but that victory or defeat is ultimately his own responsibility<em>. “</em>It sounds pretty cancerous, this whole concept of 1v5,” he admits. “But that’s what I would think of: the ability of me to carry the whole game if I play well.”</p><p>In some ways, Arteezy’s greatest assets as a player, his intelligence and strategic insight, can also work against him; when you have great ideas (as Arteezy very often does), it’s natural to want them to be taken seriously, especially when you’re not winning. And if Arteezy feels like his voice isn’t being heard, he’s liable simply to quit his team. He is, after all, Arteezy. Any team would be lucky to have him, and it’s telling that Arteezy has never once been kicked from a team. He’s only left them on his own accord.</p><p>At first glance, the ability to suppress the “1v5 mentality” seems like the defining challenge of Arteezy’s career. It is a problem familiar to elite competitors in team sports, and overcoming it is part of what separates the great from the legendary. In Arteezy’s case, the issue has never been believing in himself, but being willing to believe in others, especially after they lose together. And few things illustrate that in Arteezy’s case than his relationship with his team, Evil Geniuses. Twice he has left and twice he has returned, like a couple that breaks up with solstitial regularity.</p><p>The saga goes something like this: in January 2014, Arteezy signed with EG. The team was an instant success on the back of Arteezy’s farming-mid strategy, winning several major tournaments in the first half of 2014 culminating in a respectable third place finish at the International 4. That lineup stuck together through uneven results through December 2014, when Arteezy, along with his teammate Ludwig “Zai” Wåhlberg, jumped ship for European rivals Team Secret. It was the <em>Dota 2</em> equivalent of Lebron abandoning Cleveland for the Heat. Team Secret, unlike that homegrown iteration of EG, was a bonafide international supergroup, built from five of the absolute best individual players in <em>Dota 2</em>. The team utterly crushed its competition in the spring and summer of 2015. Rumors abounded that Secret wouldn’t scrimmage with other teams because they saw themselves as so far ahead of the competition that merely <em>practicing</em> with opponents would be a net loss. Yet the team <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20171121174612/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pwMNCFyxUXg">stumbled</a> when it mattered most, taking a disappointing eighth place at the International 2015. EG, meanwhile, took the top prize, winning over $5 million. Afterwards, EG offered Arteezy his spot back, and the team picked up where it left off, once again winning the majority of the tournaments it entered. That lasted for about eight months until Arteezy left for Team Secret <em>again</em>, citing interpersonal issues on EG. This time, though, was a fiasco. Team Secret collapsed at the International, taking last place and disbanding immediately, while EG took third. Amazingly, EG <em>yet again</em> offered Arteezy a spot on the team, which he accepted. He has been on the team ever since, and (arguably) has posted the most consistently excellent results of his career. Next week, he will compete at the International in an Evil Geniuses jersey for the first time since 2014.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*kwgd4My161cuhxARyM_65A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Evil Geniuses @ The Kiev Major. Photo: Evil Geniuses</figcaption></figure><p>Arteezy is philosophical about each stop on the trajectory of his career. In memory, there are never good times or bad times, only telling ones — as he once Tweeted, “I don’t lose; I win or I learn.” Each permutation of Evil Geniuses and Team Secret (even that second one) has taught him something about playing <em>Dota 2</em>, but, more importantly, it has also taught him something about himself. It all comes back to the “1v5 mentality” pitting his faith in himself against his faith in the teammates he needs to win.</p><p>“The first time I left EG, I learned how to play carry with different people and how to play around different people’s strengths,” he remembers of the 2015 iteration of Team Secret. “I don’t really regret that move at all. I learned that if you have five good players on one team, people have to be willing to sacrifice their ideas for the sake of winning.”</p><p>That team’s Icarian downfall at the International 5 was a turning point for Arteezy. “I became a new person; I learned to play more around the team.” At least at first. Back on Evil Geniuses, familiar struggles re-emerged when the team failed to win consistently in the spring of 2016. “I didn’t feel like I was being fully utilized fully,” Arteezy remembers, “So I reverted to my pre-TI5 character, where I felt like I had to 1v5. It fucked me.”</p><p>Leaving Evil Geniuses for Team Secret a second time contained obvious echoes of the previous year, only this time the team did even worse. “It was a big mistake,” he says. “And I was too spontaneous about it.” If for Team Secret, TI5 was tragedy, then TI6 was farce. “I was ashamed of myself,” Arteezy says of their last place finish. “I’ve deleted that from my memory. It was sad for everyone involved and it’s hard for me to think about it.”</p><p>It’s a testament to the respect professional <em>Dota 2</em> players have for Arteezy that he has twice been invited back to a team he abandoned under acrimonious circumstances. “I basically screwed up two teams for no reason other than myself,” he says. “It was selfish of me. To be on a team again, and to be accepted back… it was eye-opening.”</p><p>This time, though, the harsh lessons of losing at the International (again) fell on a chastened mind. “After TI6, I finally felt like I fully understood myself and what makes being on a team work for me,” Arteezy says of his fall 2016 return to Evil Geniuses. “The way I view losses is less self-centric. Before, I would look at myself and say, ‘I should have been able to ‘1v5.’ But now I try to find a balance. I could have played with this person better. We could have done this move, or I could have helped this guy accelerate his game. I look for ways that I could have played better that could help someone else play better.”</p><p>In his first tournament appearance with Evil Geniuses’ new lineup, the team won the Mars <em>Dota 2</em> League in Xiamen, China. Since then, they’ve entered 12 tournaments, won six of them, and placed outside the top three only twice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*Z4mTW6c47nvFbdBX__gFMQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Shanghai Major. Photo: Evil Geniuses</figcaption></figure><p>It’s not hard to see how Arteezy’s version of each chapter of his story culminates in a resplendent <em>now</em>, the way most of us use our autobiographies to explain and justify our present. Normally, it’s best to be suspicious of such tidy resolutions because life rarely follows straight lines. But to hear Arteezy talk about his team today is to listen to someone whose mentality has been changed by experience, and not simply common sense. When he talks about Evil Geniuses today, he gushes about his teammates, and says “we” much more than “I.” Just listen how he explains when I ask why the team hasn’t altered its roster since TI6.</p><p>“The best part of having a team is that you can share with them too,” he says. “Every person has their own perspective on things. So when I offer what I think is a good idea to Zai, he’ll tell me from his perspective as a support player how it is. Or I’ll give it to Universe [Sahil Arora, EG’s offlaner], because he can be like, ‘What would it be like to lane against this hero?’ It’s a team-building exercise in some ways because everyone is growing an idea and evolving it.”</p><p>To be sure, Arteezy’s “1v5 mentality” is still there — to some degree, it always will be — but it appears in different and better guises. “I think I’m more utilized when my voice is pretty high — like, my voice is important <em>too</em>,” he says. “It was hard for that to happen when I was playing with Puppey [Team Secret’s captain, Clement Ivanov] and PPD [Peter Dager, then EG’s captain and now its CEO] because they followed their voice as the most important one. It’s not a bad thing, it’s just not how I function. I didn’t see it as healthy.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*yQCzIt-S1jpfxgoszJUSQA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Shanghai Major. Photo: Evil Geniuses</figcaption></figure><p>In that sense, maybe the challenge for Arteezy has never been to totally suppress the 1v5 mentality, but harness it and direct it to more productive ends. To wit: when I ask Arteezy how he sees himself these days, he likens himself to a ghost.</p><p><em>A what?</em></p><p>“I enjoy the idea of being a ghost. You train, and no one notices.”</p><p><em>You’re one of the most visible players in the world. Does it ever actually work like that?</em></p><p>“I don’t know. When I picture myself, I want to be the person who silently grinds in his corner of the room and, after a 12 hour session, comes out and says what I’ve learned to my team.”</p><p>A helpful ghost, then. The truth is that you probably can’t change who you are, but you can change <em>how you are</em> who you are. Has Artour done that? It’s hard to say. But perhaps the fact that the best results of his career have aligned with his longest stint on a single team is not entirely coincidence.</p><p><strong>When Arteezy and I speak</strong> for a second time, he’s back in Vancouver. In the intervening month, he has travelled to a bootcamp in San Francisco and tournaments in the Philippines and Russia. The tour was a great success, with Evil Geniuses winning the Manila Masters and taking second place at Epicenter LAN in Moscow. The day after that, Evil Geniuses received its invitation to compete at the International 7.</p><p>Though second place at a major LAN is always respectable, Arteezy can’t help but bemoan the loss in Moscow, an unexpected defeat at the hands of longtime rivals Team Liquid, especially hard. “It was one of those losses where you didn’t get to show how good you are,” he says, punctuating it with a sigh.</p><p>Still, he’s optimistic about the future. The team has hired a coach who has been helping EG play around each other’s strengths even more. “With him, we all know what we’re doing, so it’s way easier to go with the flow,” Artour says. “We don’t have to overthink how we’re playing.”</p><p>For now, at least, Arteezy thinks he’s on the best team in the world. “We can still improve. We haven’t peaked, I think.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*w4yYyYgV7jMuPldHHaE-qw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Narrator’s Voice: In fact, they had peaked. Photo: Evil Geniuses</figcaption></figure><p>In a few days, Evil Geniuses will be heading to Wuhan, China, for the Mars <em>Dota 2</em> League, the team’s last stop before the International. Though it is a major tournament, the team is taking a holistic view of MDL. “We might do some clowny shit,” he suggests. “If we lost MDL, I feel like it would actually be more beneficial than winning. If we do lose, it would probably be to a cool idea or concept that we can learn from.” (In fact, this is exactly what happens).</p><p>When EG returns from China, they will begin team preparations for the International, starting with a multi-week boot camp in San Francisco. Arteezy sounds genuinely excited about the prospect. “It used to be that I hated scrims and I loved pubs,” he says. “But now I enjoy playing scrims and matches more than I enjoy playing pubs.”</p><p>“I quit <em>Counter-Strike</em> yesterday after played against the second-highest rank of teams and got destroyed. I said, ‘OK, I’m never going to be good at this game. I’m never going to play it again.’ Now I’m giving my full attention to <em>Dota 2</em>.”</p><p><strong>For years, Arteezy read</strong> <em>How to be Like Mike: Life Lessons about Basketball’s Best</em> almost every day. The book is a motivational, mass-market paperback loosely constructed as a biography of Michael Jordan with, as far as I can tell, no actual input from His Airness. In it, Jordan’s various trials — his pettiness, self-centeredness, and tendency to bemoan losses more than he celebrates wins — on his path from Chapel Hill to Chicago and beyond are converted into tidy aphorisms, each containing a little koan of wisdom.</p><p>“If you think and achieve as a team, the individual accolades will take care of themselves,” Jordan (maybe?) says. “Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence win championships.”</p><p>The context for that quote is a chapter on the first eight years of Jordan’s career, during which he won virtually every individual award the NBA had to offer, but never managed to convert that into a championship. It wasn’t until 1991 that Jordan, along with his new(ish) teammates Scottie Pippen and Horace Grant — the “Bermuda triangle of defense” as Jack Mccallum once called them — got his ring.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*ch9kmL8WGA9E1OphsALKHQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo: Evil Geniuses</figcaption></figure><p>“I used to read <em>How to be Like Mike</em> every day,” Arteezy remembers. “After a loss, I’d blame myself. So I’d look at the book and move forward. I did that before MLG Columbus, and I did it after Columbus. Eventually, it was in my head. Every time I lose, I still ask myself, ‘Why do you want to play? Why do you want to win?’”</p><p>Maybe now, Arteezy is one step closer to winning forever. But <em>Dota 2</em> is as fickle as anything else in life, and the best you can do is play until it has been pummeled into familiarity, bent to a human will. That’s impossible, of course – but impossible is where the work of fortune begins. I can’t tell you if Arteezy will write an epilogue to this piece by winning the International. But if he does, now more than ever, he won’t do it alone.</p><p>///</p><p>follow arteezy: <a href="https://twitter.com/arteezy">@arteezy</a></p><p>follow me: <a href="https://twitter.com/william_partin">@william_partin</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc558c15c1dd" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/bboongbboong/dota-2-player-arteezy-on-the-hunt-for-big-game-at-the-international-fc558c15c1dd">‘Dota 2’ Player Arteezy on the Hunt for Big Game at the International</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/bboongbboong">bboongbboong</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why bboongbboong? fffpplllrrrttt]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/bboongbboong/why-bboongbboong-fffpplllrrrttt-dc72226ea7f9?source=rss-1b6c76037763------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dc72226ea7f9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[esport]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Will Partin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 25 Nov 2019 16:29:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-08T14:52:21.948Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>where esports writing goes to die</h4><p>This is Choi “BBoongBBoong” Jong Hyuk.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IaP4a-eTe8OASBJeqHffCw.jpeg" /><figcaption>(he lost this one, probably)</figcaption></figure><p>If you’ve never heard of him, you shouldn’t feel bad. Over his entire <em>StarCraft 2 </em>career, BBoongBBoong’s top finish was a silver medal in the not-very-prestigious Asia StarCraft League. In about four years of professional competition, he managed to win a mere $6,698 dollars — roughly the annual income of an esports journalist.</p><p>So why are we, one, shitting on him and, two, naming this publication after him?</p><p>Two reasons.</p><p>First is that BBoongBBoong is the Korean onomatopoeia for fart and we’re basically twelve years old. (Just don’t ask us how it works phonetically).</p><p>Second is that BBoongBBoong’s brief career ground to a halt when, while broke as hell, he was busted for matchfixing and banned from professional StarCraft. (He threw one match for $5,000, or what you’d get for invoicing 200 news articles to DotEsports — at least before they cut their rates).</p><p>Hey, that’s esports! Delightfully unrefined, intermittently fraudulent, and precarious for everyone but publishers. BBoongBBoong (the player) will almost certainly be forgotten, like all the other esports flotsam that sunk instead of rising on the industry’s venture capital-fueled tide. And lost to the waves is a treasure trove of esports writing. We once wrote for a site called <em>The Meta</em>; it died. Then we wrote for <em>Glixel</em>, <em>Rolling Stone</em>’s games pivot; that died too. A bunch of other sites we didn’t write for (<em>Slingshot Esports</em>, etc.) followed suit. Gradually, we watched our portfolios recede into deep water as the whole industry pivoted to video, like cats chasing a laser. But no one likes to think about those things when there’s a new investment into a team, a platform, a tournament. Dwell too publicly on what failed, and you might get accused of spoiling the party before the keg of cheap cash starts sputtering.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*QA8lBDRyKHq5aSCR-SB7vw.jpeg" /><figcaption>him</figcaption></figure><p>We used to think that the esports industry would reach a point where it could sustain the kinds of sportswriting we admire, like (as one of many examples) Frank Deford’s iconic profile of Bobby Knight in <em>Sports Illustrated</em> (<a href="http://grantland.com/features/directors-cut-the-rabbit-hunter-by-frank-deford/">reposted in 2010 by Grantland</a>). We don’t think that anymore. First-class cabins, it turns out, sink too. These days, <em>Sports Illustrated </em>has been taxidermied into a shit-flinging pyramid scheme of <a href="https://www.nydailynews.com/sports/football/ny-sports-illustrated-themaven-high-school-student-bengals-newburgh-20191108-ixm2qbmm6ngzllyfd4so2gz2hq-story.html">unpaid seventeen-year-olds</a>, and don’t even mention what happened to <em>Deadspin</em> (Fuck you, Jim, you miserable herb). The fact is that the ad-supported internet, finance capital, and longform, investigative writing are very nearly incompatible and the whole genre is slowly withering on the vine. So it goes.</p><p>The internet is a graveyard, not a garden — BBoongBBoong merely names the game for what it is. So we’re going to repost articles that have been lost to time, site migrations, unpaid hosting fees, or whatever else. Nothing fancy — just a place to read good writing about esports that ought to have a home somewhere other than the Wayback Machine.</p><p>If you have some writing of your own you’d like to see here, feel free to get in contact on Twitter. At least until <a href="https://www.niemanlab.org/2019/03/the-long-complicated-and-extremely-frustrating-history-of-medium-2012-present/">Medium inevitably goes under</a> – then you can help us find a new grave plot.</p><p>XOXO,</p><p>Will &amp; Justin</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dc72226ea7f9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/bboongbboong/why-bboongbboong-fffpplllrrrttt-dc72226ea7f9">Why bboongbboong? fffpplllrrrttt</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/bboongbboong">bboongbboong</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Repost: On-Air With LA’s Most Wanted Man [Profile of Ice Poseidon]]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@willpartin/repost-on-air-with-las-most-wanted-man-profile-of-ice-poseidon-be01bc7e0573?source=rss-1b6c76037763------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/be01bc7e0573</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[streaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[twitch]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Will Partin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 09 Nov 2019 16:56:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-09T17:40:26.480Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Repost: On Air With LA’s Most Wanted Man</h3><p><em>Some quick background here: The latest round of my portfolio lost to website migrations was all my stories (~35 or so) at </em>Glixel<em> and </em>Rolling Stone<em>, which were supposedly going to be ported over to </em>Variety<em> but that never happened. So, anyway, I’m going to slowly start importing them to here as my schedule allows.</em></p><p><em>This piece was originally published under the title “On Air With LA’s Most Wanted Man” for Glixel and reprinted in Rolling Stone a month later. (The original Rolling Stone link is </em><a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/http://www.rollingstone.com/glixel/news/a-day-with-las-most-wanted-life-streamer-ice-poseidon-w486841"><em>here</em></a><em>). It was edited by Miguel Lopez, Simon Cox, and John Davidson, along with Hearst Media’s ethics team for reasons that will be become clear. I’ve also made some small, stylistic edits of my own for this version, e.g. removing the titled subheadings, which, in my view, messed with the architecture of the article.</em></p><p><em>This story is definitely the wildest thing I’ve ever written but also one I feel most ambivalent about. I knew going in that Ice’s stream represented a lot of the worst parts of gaming culture and that, by giving it coverage, I was, to some degree, giving it visibility over other deserving creators. But I also believed (and still do) that Ice was a gifted entertainer who was pushing the medium of IRL streaming forward. Call it naïve, but my hope was that other writers might pick up and cover the less great aspects of Ice’s show and community (which, to be clear, are absolutely racist and sexist) so that we’d have a fuller picture. That didn’t happen, so lesson learned.</em></p><p><em>Anyway, the less said about what’s happened to Ice’s show in the years since the better – there’s plenty of reporting out there if you want to read up for yourself. (Related: most of the links in the piece are now dead, given that his community was banned from Reddit for what I assume was every possible violation of the terms of use). But he’s still streaming, mostly on Mixer, to a somewhat diminished audience, and I do tune in every once in a while. To be clear: I still believe that Ice is a talented entertainer. But we’re lucky to live in a world where talent isn’t everything. Enjoy.</em></p><p>///</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*mEakPas6VbPe3FF6.png" /><figcaption>Photo: Glixel / Peter Francis Barnett</figcaption></figure><p>This spring, if you found yourself wandering down the Hollywood Walk of Fame, the names of men and women who altered the course of entertainment beneath your feet, there’s a decent chance that you might have seen a loud, lanky twenty-something brandishing a contraption that looked like a broadcast tower crossed with a wizard’s staff. If you did, I hope you smiled. You were on air, and, on a good day, 20,000 people were watching.</p><p>Hollywood Boulevard is no stranger to publicity stunts, but Ice Poseidon — Paul Denino, to his parents — stands out from its legion of two-bit street performers. Since 2015, he has quickly (though not quietly) become one of the most popular livestreamers in the world, after a niche start streaming an MMO. His YouTube channel is approaching 150,000 subscribers, and he has massive communities on Discord — an online chat room aimed at gamers — and a subreddit dedicated to his show. This year, he expects to earn in the low six figures, mostly from viewer donations, ad revenue, and a modest sponsorship from the North American gaming organization, Team NRG.</p><p>Ice Poseidon’s “act” is simple: with a mobile broadcasting rig of his own design, he streams several hours of his conspicuously eventful life almost every single day. He calls the genre “lifestreaming,” and his Twitter brands him as its “god.” At its best, lifestreaming blends improv, reality TV and situational comedy; look closely, and you can catch glimpses of everything from <em>Punk’d</em> to <em>Cops</em>, and maybe even an Allan Kaprow Happening or two. Last week, Ice and some friends <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=26&amp;v=frsI2FKzZiI">set up</a> an impromptu speed-dating booth on UCLA’s campus and waved down coeds with the promise of free candy. It was a classic Ice Poseidon setup, meaning it was mostly an excuse for him to crack jokes at his guests’ expense, mocking their majors, hometowns, and appearance — a roast in real-time. Ice &amp; Co., none of whom have any affiliation with UCLA, kept the act up for around 30 minutes before campus police demanded they leave, citing complaints about “hate speech” from students.</p><p>About that. There’s no way around the fact that much of what goes down on Ice Poseidon’s stream is in very poor taste, or worse. At UCLA, Ice corners an obviously uncomfortable student and tries to debate them about women’s rights, a flimsy prompt that quickly devolves into Ice dropping juvenile, “did you just assume my gender”-type one-liners. When he later <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://twitter.com/REALIcePoseidon/status/870033381924327424">shares</a> the video on Twitter, he describes it as “triggering liberals at UCLA.” Ice’s stream leans on shock humor, and even more so for its hyperactive chat (or at least a very vocal segment of it), a mire of “ironic” racism and misogyny. Ice knows it, and his fans know it. That’s the point, or part of it at least.</p><p>But Ice’s viewers tend to either ignore or celebrate his flagrant disregard for decorum, something, they’d point out, comedians have been doing for centuries. In any case, as long as he isn’t getting banned from streaming, what’s “appropriate” is the last thing on Ice Poseidon’s mind. What <em>is</em> on his mind is the seemingly limitless possibilities of lifestreaming — what it is, what it means, and what tools he can leverage to create something genuinely <em>new</em>. Like him or not, it’s impossible to deny that Ice has succeeded at his goal beyond anyone’s expectations, most of all his own.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*XCIjWUGeIXya8B1F.png" /><figcaption>Photo: Peter Francis Barnett</figcaption></figure><p>When Ice began streaming on Twitch in 2015, he almost exclusively played the 2001 cult hit, <em>Runescape</em>. For viewers, the draw wasn’t <em>Runescape</em>, a sludge of pixelated labor and commerce, but Ice Poseidon’s boisterous personality, which could transform even the most banal interactions into digital theater of the absurd. Within two months, Ice was able to quit his part-time job as a line cook and live off the revenue from his stream. There’s another world where Ice is still streaming <em>Runescape</em>, but the 2016 craze over <em>Pokémon Go</em> gave Ice the chance take his show on the road. From there, it wasn’t hard to drop the pretense of gaming altogether. Lifestreaming was born.</p><p>Ice Poseidon is not the first life streamer, nor is he the only one. At any given moment, Twitch can <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.twitch.tv/directory/game/IRL">connect you</a> to dozens of performers, including <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.twitch.tv/trashm4n">garbage men</a> and <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.twitch.tv/blackbadge">on-duty cops</a>, broadcasting their day-to-day existence. But Ice is the unquestioned king of the genre, due in large part to his ongoing efforts to stay ahead of his competitors, technically and creatively. He experiments with his broadcasting rig almost daily, which has gradually become more complex. At first, Ice just used his phone, then a GoPro connected to an iPad; now, his latest MacGyver-esque contraption, a Sony point and shoot with a wide-angle lens, wired to a 4G modem bonder, can output high definition video in real-time. It’s not perfect — dead spots are a recurring problem, and he’s limited by the modem bonder’s five-hour battery life — but the quality is generally excellent, and, more importantly, it’s light enough to be carried in one hand.</p><p>Ice is always thinking about new ideas for things to do on-air, taking inspiration from documentaries, ghost hunting shows, and solo comedy routines. In January, he relocated from South Florida to Hollywood because he (correctly) thought there would be more interesting content for his stream. He drinks Red Bull nearly every day because it keeps him — and, by extension, his stream — in constant motion (he estimates that he walks up to 10 miles each stream). In short, Ice works hard because lifestreaming is hard work. Above all, he wants to see how far he can take lifestreaming — and, in turn, see how far lifestreaming can take him.</p><p><strong>///</strong></p><p>“Yo, what’s up guys and welcome to my stream! How you doing?”</p><p>It’s May 24th, 2017, and Ice has invited me join him on-air for the afternoon. Currently, I’m sitting on his couch listening to Ice introduce the stream from the desktop computer in his bedroom. Ice lives here with his roommate, Voldesad (real name: Gray Shaw), a childhood friend and frequent on-stream guest. The two met playing <em>Runescape</em> more than a decade ago, and moved into their apartment — a handsome two-bedroom overlooking the Walk of Fame — this January.</p><p>Ice begins at his computer, updating his audience on two of the ever-evolving storylines in his life, which, together, lend the stream a sense of coherence between “episodes.” One is the case of Cornbread, a friend and frequent on-stream guest who has been sleeping at Ice’s apartment without permission. The other is Ice’s ongoing love triangle between Halie Atisuto, a Twitch streamer also connected to Team NRG, and Geisha Montes, an actress who was also Miss World Dominican Republic in 2014. Ice met Halie in April, when the two traveled together to <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GjwYCVXjgIk">stream</a> in Las Vegas. In true Vegas fashion, the two got “<a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GjwYCVXjgIk">married</a>” at the end of the night. Geisha, on the other hand, entered the picture after a chance encounter on the street in front of Ice’s apartment.</p><p>Ice encourages his viewers to post their opinions on the pros and cons of dating each woman, which leads to a deluge of long text posts and hastily made memes on Ice’s subreddit. It is, in effect, a soap opera, and Ice’s fans are eager to weigh in on which woman makes a better fit for him. Ice’s audience has decided that Halie has a child from a previous relationship (incorrect) and doesn’t live in Los Angeles. But she’s also been an emotional rock for Ice during some recent turmoil. Geisha, on the other hand, is ten years older than Ice but is also a professional model. And, anyway, Ice has a date with her this very night and, amazingly, she’s consented to having it streamed. It might not be love, but it’s definitely content.</p><p>After about 45 minutes, Ice shuts off his stream, having pushed two storylines forward. It’s time to start lifestreaming, so Ice grabs his rig, and we head for the elevator. Inside, there’s a sign prohibiting the use of recording equipment. Ice tells me that he was nearly evicted after a neighbor complained about him streaming in the elevator.</p><p>Once we’re outdoors, we take off down Sunset Boulevard, heading west. Ice warms up by talking to passersby, asking for directions or where they’re from; they’re mostly mystified, but they play along. He trains his camera’s gaze on a guitarist, giving the guy the biggest audience he’s ever had. Ice is in his zone, doing what he does best. I, on the other hand, forget to take my lens cap off when I start taking pictures, a GIF of which later makes <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.reddit.com/r/Ice_Poseidon/comments/6d5vum/most_professional_photographer_in_la/">the front page of Reddit</a>.</p><p>It’s hot, and Ice is already thirsty. We step into Ciabatta Bar, a trendy farm-to-table café where he buys an almond milk smoothie. While we’re waiting, Ice strikes up a conversation with the only other customer in the store, a long-haired man with a thick Australian accent. Within a minute, they’re role-playing a therapy session as Ice unloads his romantic woes. I check the stream on my phone. Chat is loving it.</p><p>Smoothie in hand, it’s time for errands. Ice wants to do some fanservice, but he needs a customs shop to do it. There’s a good one a few blocks away; it’s got 4.5 stars on Yelp. Satisfied, Ice hails an Uber, and we get on our way.</p><p>///</p><p>More than anything else, Ice credits the success of his stream to its emotional realism and the strength of the connection between him and his audience. Every fan I talk to says the same.</p><p>“I don’t have a personal life,” Ice tells me. “My personal life is my stream.”</p><p>It’s true. Ice is transparent to a fault with his viewers, talking openly about everything from his finances to his relationship with his parents. Consequently, his fans feel personally invested in his life. They celebrate his successes and commiserate with his failures. For regular viewers, Ice’s stream starts to feel like a much more exciting bonus life. Therein lies the heart of the Ice Poseidon show’s appeal: it’s everyday life in a funhouse mirror, making everything normal seem novel once more.</p><p>Over the last year, Ice has slowly introduced a motley crew of characters whose lives are fodder for new storylines. Alongside Cornbread, Voldesad, Halie, and Geisha, there’s “Victor the cameraman,” “Mexican Andy” and, weirdly enough, the ex-MTV personality Andy Milonakis, who Ice met by chance in the online military simulator, <em>Arma 3</em>. Ice frequently invites fans on stream as well; just as often, they invite themselves — it’s not as if Ice’s location is private, after all. Some have even become regular guests.</p><p>In that sense, it’s impossible to talk about Ice Poseidon without also talking about the Purple Army, the online community Ice has taken great pains to cultivate. Most days, Ice does an on-stream “Reddit recap,” browsing recent posts and selecting his favorites. Over time, this has built a lingua franca for his fans. Anything perceived to be less-than-optimal is “scuffed” — Ice’s fans, for example, call his perpetually embattled manager from Team NRG “<a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://i.redd.it/1t4ad7fnfhwy.png">scuffed Steve Jobs</a>” — while “cx,” an unorthodox smiley face popular in <em>Runescape</em>, is a kind of secret handshake that marks one as an Ice Poseidon fan.</p><p>It’s no exaggeration to say that Ice Poseidon’s stream is, in many ways, a collaboration between him and his community. The “interactive” dimension of Ice’s stream places him in a much longer history in broadcast media that dates back to well before internet livestreaming. In her forthcoming book <em>Watch Me Play</em>, T.L. Taylor notes that as early as the 1970s, television producers were devising ways for audiences to affect content in real-time. The game show format <em>TV</em> <em>Powwww</em> (1978) allowed viewers to call in and issue commands for a primitive on-screen videogame, a precursor to <em>Eurovision</em> and <em>Big Brother</em> today. Then and now, the appeal of quasi-interactive television is its ability to blur the boundary between the viewer and the viewed, heightening the audience’s sense of immersion in the program. Ice Poseidon’s stream takes this feedback loop to an extreme. A week after my visit, Ice permanently broke off his relationship with Halie. In an emotional stream later that night, Halie <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://clips.twitch.tv/EndearingGoldenEchidnaJKanStyle">says</a> “[Paul] told me that the community voted for Geisha, and that’s why we can’t be friends anymore.”</p><p>There’s a dark side, in other words, to the sense of closeness that Ice cultivates with his viewers. Feeling as if you’re part of someone’s life can quickly start to seem as if you have control or even ownership of that life. Dealing with fans who take their passion for their favorite streamers too far is an <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/http://kotaku.com/when-fans-take-their-love-for-twitch-streamers-too-far-1794815112">ongoing problem for many performers</a>. But when it comes to a life streamer like Ice Poseidon, the stakes can be much more dire.</p><p>///</p><p>When we pull up to the customs shop, Ice jumps out of the Uber, abandoning what’s left of his smoothie. He strides past a totaled white Maserati and into the shop. He’s interested in getting his car wrapped with an image of <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://ih0.redbubble.net/image.53560975.2549/flat,800x800,075,f.jpg">TriHard</a>, a Twitch emote based on the face of Mychal “TriHex” Ramon Jefferson, a Twitch streamer known mostly for <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/http://www.glixel.com/news/watch-this-epic-charity-speedrunning-marathon-w460221">speedrunning</a> Nintendo games. The emote is particularly popular on Ice’s stream, where it’s conventional to post it <em>en masse</em> whenever a black person enters the frame. (Sigh).</p><p>While they’re hashing the details, a half-dozen employees gather behind the counter. None of them have ever, <em>ever</em> skipped leg day. They’re staring at Ice’s broadcasting rig and they know there’s something weird going on, but, for the most part, they’re not saying anything. The atmosphere is tense. But Ice and the owner settle on a timeline for the unusual request, and we leave the shop.</p><p>Outside, Ice immediately starts coordinating his next escapade. His viewers want him to go to Skid Row, which contains the largest concentration of homeless people in the country. He doesn’t like the idea — he’s got almost $10,000 worth of gear on him — but chat won’t let it go. One of them even offers to give us a ride, but Ice says he’s too far away. I hear the door open behind us.</p><p>“Hey, you fucking faggots!”</p><p>It’s the guys from the customs shop; they’re surging toward us, and quickly set up in a loose arc around Ice and me. Their de facto leader — he’s about 30, with a close-cropped black beard, ripped skinny jeans, two full sleeves of tattoos, and an Ed Hardy-esque shirt — confronts Ice.</p><p>Ed Hardy guy takes the lead. “Bitch! People are calling my phone. You better make them stop before I knock your bitch ass out.”</p><p>Ice holds his hands up. “Yo, we’re doing a livestream. Sorry. We didn’t mean for this to happen.”</p><p>“Who are we dealing with? Who’s fucking with us?”</p><p>“We’re on YouTube. Sometimes the viewers, they call. And they say stupid shit.”</p><p>Ice starts trying to explain to the guy what’s happening, but it’s not working.</p><p>“Come here,” Ed Hardy’s sidekick commands, pointing at his feet.</p><p>He’s holding something in his pocket. Its outline looks an awful lot like a knife.</p><p>Ice jerks back. “No, I’m good.”</p><p>“Come here, come here, come here! Let me take all the pictures you have.”</p><p>Ice tries to explain that he’s taking live video, not pictures. They don’t get it.</p><p>“What’s your YouTube channel?” Ed Hardy demands.</p><p>“Ice Poseidon.”</p><p>“What?”</p><p>“Ice. Poseidon.”</p><p>“How do you spell that?”</p><p>“Ice and then Poseidon.”</p><p>Ed Hardy fiddles with his phone until he pulls up the stream. For a few seconds, he’s just another viewer, one out of thousands watching this snafu in real-time. I doubt chat is saying anything nice about him.</p><p>“Look at this stupid ass, bullshit fucking subscribers. This shit!”</p><p>Ice tries to apologize again. They’re having none of it.</p><p>“This is a business, bro. I don’t want to knock you out. Stop going live. You’re being stupid.”</p><p>“OK.”</p><p>The “walk” signal comes on behind us, and before they can say anything else, Ice beats a hasty retreat across Sunset Boulevard. I slink after him.</p><p>“Guess I’m not going to get the car wrapped,” he says once we’re out of earshot.</p><p>///</p><p>When Twitch formalized “IRL” as a <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.twitch.tv/directory/game/IRL">genre</a> in late 2016, it was a callback to the site’s origins as Justin.tv, one of the first user-friendly live streaming sites. In 2007, founder Justin Kan brought wide attention to the site by broadcasting his life 24/7 using a backpack laptop connected to a webcam. Though some users (including a <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-XR_SMe5yw">deployed soldier in Iraq</a>) tried to copy Justin Kan’s gimmick, most simply broadcast from their desktop computers, hosting talk shows and live video blogs. Streaming media made it easier than ever before to connect with audiences, sparing broadcasters the hassle of encoding and uploading videos, <em>à la</em> YouTube. But it was Justin.tv’s gaming section, Twitch.tv, that ultimately came to dominate the site. In 2011, Justin.tv spun off Twitch as a separate site, and, in 2014, rebranded around it entirely. Now known as Twitch Interactive, the company doubled down on its identity as <em>the</em> place for gaming and restricted any content that was deemed not sufficiently game-related. Streamers, for example, had to ensure that a live gameplay feed and not, say, their webcam, took up the majority of their screen.</p><p>That stance has softened over the years, and the resurrection of lifestreaming is, in many ways, the logical endpoint of Twitch’s trend toward permissiveness. The nature of good streamers is to experiment with their medium, which has led to brilliant flashes of creativity like <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.theverge.com/2014/2/17/5418690/play-this-twitch-plays-pokemon-crowdsourced-gaming"><em>Twitch Plays Pokémon</em></a> or <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/http://www.glixel.com/news/see-google-home-devices-talk-games-god-w459483"><em>seebotschat</em></a>. Novelty drives viewership, and up-and-coming streamers are always finessing their act to attract a larger audience. Often, that means toying with the boundaries of Twitch’s terms of service. At some point, it became easier for Twitch to simply loosen the rules, rather than try to define every exception. In 2015, the company launched Twitch Creative; streamers were now free to broadcast everything from Pro Tools to oil painting. Audiences loved it. After that, all bets were off. These days, you can find everything from <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.twitch.tv/food">cooking shows</a> to reruns of <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.twitch.tv/misterrogers"><em>Mr. Roger’s Neighborhood</em></a> on the site. And, of course, life streamers across the world.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*3k4AxHYikckfF8jH.png" /><figcaption>Photo: Peter Francis Barnett</figcaption></figure><p>All live streaming runs the risk of the unexpected. For years, <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.reddit.com/r/LivestreamFail/top/">/r/livestreamfail</a> has been collecting on-air blunders, whether it’s in-game cheating, insensitive rants, angry parents, or wardrobe malfunctions. But lifestreaming courts controversy in a way that streaming from a bedroom cannot, and Ice Poseidon has been an object lesson in the difficulty of regulating what happens on air when streamers aren’t tied to their desktops. Ice, in particular, has a supernatural knack for being in the right place at the right time — or, just as often, the wrong place at the wrong time. Providence, after all, cuts both ways.</p><p>In March, Ice accidentally streamed a man’s suicide-by-jumping. The incident recalled one of Justin.tv’s earliest scandals when 19-year-old Abraham Biggs <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.wired.com/2008/11/teen-kills-self/">killed himself on stream</a> by overdosing on benzodiazepine in front of 185 viewers. Ice recognized what was about to happen and quickly left the area, but it was still obvious to viewers when the man jumped. A block away, Ice collapsed to the ground, inconsolable. In a <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X3MQMTdhCk4">very short stream</a> that night, Ice revealed that he is a survivor of a suicide attempt. He also lets his viewers know that Twitch isn’t going ban him; what happened was a terrible accident.</p><p>But it’s not all chance. Ice is no stranger to temporary bans for scandals of his own making, intentional or not. Like most streamers, Ice generates income through a donation button that allows viewers to broadcast any message on air. Normally, streamers see these messages before they appear and can block inappropriate ones. But, last November, Ice was streaming from his pool, too far away to block incoming messages. A viewer took the chance to submit an extremely racist message, which appeared on stream, earning Ice a one-week ban. Barely a month later, at the urging of his chat, Ice asked for a young woman’s number on air. But he forgot to mute his stream, exposing her contact information to thousands of viewers. The slipup led to a 45-day ban, which many saw as a Draconian response by Twitch — here playing judge, jury, and executioner — to the honest mistake Ice insists it was.</p><p>Still, it’s the Purple Army — or a particular slice of it — that’s responsible for many of Ice’s most famous moments, which are not always his finest. The Purple Army has always been a rowdy bunch, but “IRL” streaming has empowered its most committed trolls in previously unimaginable ways. In April, while eating on-air at a Denny’s, a “fan” with a fire extinguisher sprayed Ice’s table, shutting down the entire restaurant. Ice has also been a frequent target for “swatting,” a practice in which a viewer calls in a fake threat to draw police to the “victim’s” location. Swatting has been around as long as livestreaming — Justin Kan, in fact, was a frequent target during his lifestreaming days — but Ice has probably been swatted more than any other steamer in history– 20 times in the last two months alone.</p><p>Inevitably, though, the police figure out that Ice isn’t in danger; he’s just a dude with a weird camera. Swatting is an inconvenience, but it’s rarely a threat to his safety. The same can’t be said for the times when viewers have called businesses that Ice visits. In April, while <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6w_r-64uNz4">trying to charge</a> his phone at a Pizza shop in San Francisco, viewers phoned in to “warn” the shop’s owner about the danger his customer posed. Seconds later, Ice got thrown out. Two weeks later, while streaming in New Orleans, Ice <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oj_AM15g1iA">tried to visit</a> a local restaurant known for its hot wings. Before he can even order, the owner bursts through the front door and smashes Ice’s camera. Minutes later, Ice <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://twitter.com/realiceposeidon/status/855182622661767168?lang=en">tweeted</a>: “they had guns and a gang of people show up when [the stream] turned off. Dude said he had murder charges so we booked it and luckily didn’t get shot.”</p><p>But nothing that ever happened on Ice’s stream could compare to the events of April 28, 2017. Ice and Halie were travelling to the technology festival DreamHack Austin, and, while streaming in Phoenix’s Sky Harbor airport, Ice revealed both his gate and flight number. After Ice and Halie boarded the plane, someone called in a bomb threat tied to Ice, temporarily shutting down the airport. Ice and Halie were forcibly removed from the plane and spent several hours in questioning before being released and given vouchers for a flight the next morning. The incident made national news, and was widely seen as the culmination of the last month’s on-air hijinks.</p><p>Ice was furious. “You swat my house? Whatever, fuck you. You swat a plane? That’s a whole other level!” he yells into his camera during a stream recorded in his and Halie’s hotel room later that night.</p><p>“I’m scared as fuck to stream at DreamHack.”</p><p>///</p><p>Once we’ve put a few blocks between us and the customs shop, Ice and I take refuge in a Jimmy John’s. As we approach, he tilts his camera down, trying to avoid showing anything that might give away our location. I get us some water, while Ice discusses what just happened with the stream. The general consensus is that Ice did nothing wrong because the customs shop didn’t have a sign prohibiting recording. Satisfied, he begins debating his viewers about whether or not we should go to Skid Row.</p><p>The manager walks up to us; I’m half-expecting to get thrown out, but he just asks us to buy something. Ice is busy, so I pick out a bag of barbeque chips. While I’m paying, the phone starts ringing. The cashier picks up; it’s just a to-go order.</p><p>Back at the table, Ice is asking his viewers to weigh the benefits of Skid Row (“better content”) against returning to the apartment to talk about Geisha and Halie (“more feelings”). Out of frame, I’m shaking my head, trying to catch Ice’s attention and convey my disapproval because I really, <em>really</em> don’t want him to go to Skid Row.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*sJct3AP0rC-eIprC.png" /><figcaption>Photo: William Partin</figcaption></figure><p>The front door opens. It’s two of the men from the customs shop, the Ed Hardy guy and his sidekick. Ice sees them first.</p><p>“Oh god, he’s here. Oh god,” he says, and looks intently at his phone, trying to avoid their gaze. They close on us.</p><p>“Your fans are completely screwing our business,” Ed Hardy says.</p><p>Ice’s brow furrows. “What are they doing?”</p><p>“We’ve got over 1,000 one-star Yelp reviews in a matter of five minutes. Our phones are ringing non-stop. We’re going to the police department. You’re liable for all of this. It’s your fault. This is illegal. You realize that?”</p><p>“It’s illegal to livestream?”</p><p>“Yes. You came to our business, you trespassed, you did that. It’s illegal. You want to see the Yelp reviews?”</p><p>Behind us, phones are ringing. The manager appears and tells us to get the fuck out of his restaurant.</p><p>We take up spots near where the customs shop guys have parked their car, a silver SUV with oversized rims. It’s in the middle of the asphalt, impeding the flow of traffic.</p><p>“We’re a family-owned shop and you fucking destroyed us,” Ed Hardy says.</p><p>“No… it’s. Fucking. Some people are just assholes in this world. I know you probably think I’m an asshole,” Ice says, jabbing his chest. “But that’s not what I wanted. I just wanted to get a car wrap.”</p><p>“Look at this, man,” Ed Hardy says, holding out his phone. Their shop’s Yelp score has indeed plummeted to a single star.</p><p>“They’re calling all our phone lines non-stop. You can’t be doing that stuff, man. Someone’s gotta be liable. It’s not right. You can’t do this to people’s businesses.”</p><p>Ice looks directly into the camera. “Some people in my fan base are fucking cancer, I get it. I know.”</p><p>Ice won’t make eye contact with Ed Hardy Guy. He looks at his shoes, then at his phone, reading through the flood of messages in chat. They range from the “walk away you fucking idiot” to “not liable at all learn your rights” to “tell him he shouldn’t have threatened you.”</p><p>The two guys from custom shop are pacing in small circles. They’re still pissed, but whatever aggression they showed before has dissipated. Mostly, they seem frustrated.</p><p>“Your name is Paul, I’m guessing?”</p><p>“Mmhmm.”</p><p>Ice pauses.</p><p>“I don’t know what to do. Some people just… <em>fuck. shit. up.</em> I feel so bad, because some fucking, couple assholes. You know what I mean?,” he says in a bid for common ground.</p><p>“A couple? It’s hundreds. We’re getting nonstop calls.”</p><p>They start arguing again over who is responsible for this mess.</p><p>“I also can’t control every single person who’s watching,” Ice says.</p><p>“All this was caused by you,” Ed Hardy counters. “You literally caused these guys to come and harass us. For no reason. We’re real shocked. And you’re still live!”</p><p>“I am still live, yes. I’m just recording everything!”</p><p>“Turn off your shit!,” the other guy says, incredulous.</p><p>Ice checks his phone again. Chat is mostly telling him to stand his ground. Emboldened, he says “I mean… you also technically threatened me as well.”</p><p>“With what? He had a pen in his hand,” Ed Hardy says, gesturing at his friend. “You realize that, right?”</p><p>“No, you said you were going to kick my ass!”</p><p>“Nobody even attempted to touch you!”</p><p>They keep arguing until Ed Hardy asks Ice to plead with his viewers to stop calling.</p><p>“The people that are calling, they’re not my viewers,” Ice responds. “They’re haters. And they’re trying to fuck me over. That’s what their goal is!”</p><p>“So if you have that type of hatred, why would you enter a business?”</p><p>“This is my job. Livestreaming. Not destroying businesses.”</p><p>“They’re doing it on our Instagram, they’re doing it on everything. Non-stop right now.”</p><p>“Well, because you’re here now. And you’re instigating. You’re instigating it.”</p><p>“We’re trying to fix things with you.”</p><p>“I mean, I know but…”</p><p>“Not cool man. This is … directly ruining our business. And it’s nobody’s fault but yours.”</p><p>“I don’t know if I’d agree with that.”</p><p>“The police will. This is going to be a lawsuit. You realize that?”</p><p>“You’re going to sue me? You didn’t have any signs saying no recording or anything like that.”</p><p>Ed Hardy asks Ice again if he’ll tell his viewers to stop.</p><p>“You don’t think I’ve done that?” Ice explodes. “You don’t think I’ve said that? I’ve had breakdowns because people do this shit and I get fucked over!”</p><p>They start arguing about whether or not Ice had the legal right to stream when the manager of the Jimmy John’s sticks his head out the door. “Can you, like, tell your people to stop fucking calling, man?”</p><p>“You see? Thank you! There you go.” Ed Hardy turns to the manager and tells him that he needs to call the police.</p><p>Flanked and outnumbered, Ice concedes defeat. “Alright. Sorry dude,” disappearing around the corner.</p><p>I’m left with Ed Hardy, his sidekick, and the Jimmy John’s manager. No one’s talking; we’re all wondering why, exactly, we’re still standing here. The guys from the custom shop look exhausted, their shoulders slumped and their breath loud and slow. Their next job, they know, is just beginning.</p><p>Ed Hardy guy breaks the silence. “You need to get away from your friend.”</p><p>“I’m not his friend,” I say. “I’m here to write about him.”</p><p>“I don’t care why you’re here. Just walk away.”</p><p>“I can’t.”</p><p>A pause.</p><p>“He’s going to get himself killed.”</p><p>I have nothing to say, so I offer him my barbecue chips.</p><p>“Get the fuck out of here.”</p><p>///</p><p>Around the corner, out of earshot, Ice is issuing a frustrated confessional into his camera.</p><p>“I don’t know what the fuck to do. I can’t do fucking anything. Live streaming in public is just… not possible. I don’t know. I just wanted to live stream and have fun. That’s all I wanted to do.”</p><p>He turns around, realizing he doesn’t know where I am.</p><p>“This is the worst day for this to be happening too! We have a fucking writer and reporter following us around. What do you think this story’s going to say?”</p><p>///</p><p>When I catch up to Ice, he’s saying goodbye to his viewers. He’s had enough with today (can’t blame him), and, anyway, he needs to start preparing for his date with Geisha tonight.</p><p>After he shuts the stream off, Ice is uncharacteristically quiet. Finally, he turns to me.</p><p>“What do you think?”</p><p>Honestly?</p><p>I want to tell him that I think he has a fucking death wish; Ice Poseidon may very well be the end of Paul Denino. The camera-smashing incident in New Orleans, that shit with the airplane, the swattings, the attempted suicide, and what’s happened today — that’s all in the last <em>month</em>. Does he deserve it? Probably not, but the real question is whether or not he’s enabled it. How much distance is there <em>really </em>between fault and blame? It’s one thing to get threatened on stream once, but this is becoming a weekly occurrence for Ice. And would it be perverse to suggest that he’s not just complicit in his “misfortune,” but that he actually <em>benefits</em> from it? Whether or not he admits it, these misadventures are part of Ice’s appeal for many viewers, even those who would never dream of calling in a bomb threat. Ice’s profile has grown dramatically since April, in step with the steady drip of scandals taking place on stream. Frankly, if Ice’s face hadn’t been plastered across every publication from <em>Motherboard</em> to <em>Heat Street</em> for all the “wrong” reasons, I doubt my own editors would have ever greenlit this story and paid for me to fly out to Los Angeles. And as for the minority of viewers who call in threats, bomb Yelp pages, and everything else? They’re just going to keep doing it. Because why the fuck not? The bigger Ice gets, the bigger <em>their </em>audience gets, too. And what’s to stop these viewers from coming up with worse? Believe it or not, the vast majority of Ice’s fans really do seem to care and worry about his well-being. Many of them also wish the callers would lay off and let Ice stream in peace, the way things once were. But even if, in the event that it came to fisticuffs with some unwilling on-air “guests” and hundreds of fans called for help, would all that really have made a difference? Ice’s ass could still be pulp, beat up, his broadcasting rig scuffed or smashed to bits. If that sounds melodramatic, consider this: when Abraham Biggs killed himself on Justin.tv in 2008, most of his audience was <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.wired.com/images_blogs/photos/uncategorized/2008/11/20/suicide_660x.jpg">laughing</a>. They couldn’t believe — or wouldn’t admit — that it was real. Because of livestreaming’s (let alone <em>lifestreaming</em>’s) immediacy, we tend to see it as an authentic, even intimate, form of media. But I’m starting to think that livestreaming doesn’t transcend the gap that separates the viewer from the viewed; all it really does is hide it. And maybe that’s not such a good thing after all.</p><p>I don’t remember what I ended up telling Paul.</p><p>///</p><p>On April 30th, two days after the airplane swatting incident, Ice Poseidon was permanently banned from Twitch. The given reason was breaking Twitch’s terms of service by leaking his location, a flimsy pretext given that Ice and every other “IRL” streamer had been “leaking” their location for months. The real reason was the obvious one. After a month of bad press, Twitch had enough; whatever viewership Ice brought wasn’t worth the trouble that followed. (Twitch declined to discuss Ice Poseidon’s case, citing a policy that prohibits them from commenting on terms of service violations).</p><p>For Ice, the problem can’t be lifestreaming, because lifestreaming is his livelihood. The problem has to be the haters. To call lifestreaming itself into question is to fundamentally challenge the validity of a creative form into which he’s invested his time, money, and, lately, physical safety. And make no mistake: Ice thinks of it as an investment, because he sees himself doing this for years to come. Life streaming’s possibilities are, after all, exactly as large as the world itself.</p><p>Within a week of being banned from Twitch, Ice had a new home at YouTube Gaming, which was eager to host one of their chief rival’s most popular streamers. Amazingly, almost all of his fanbase made the transition with him, a rarity for streamers who switch platforms. When Ice met with his new partners at YouTube, he made sure to list everything objectionable that might occur on stream. YouTube Gaming assured him that, short of grievous bodily injury or nudity, everything was fair game. (Reached for comment, YouTube Gaming stated that all streamers must abide by their rules and service).</p><p>Still, Ice has taken steps on and offline to prevent the kinds of things that contributed to his ban from Twitch from ever happening again. Offline, he says he’s called nearly every police precinct in Los Angeles and explained his unique situation, which has limited the ability of callers to swat him. Now, when certain police officers see him, they’re <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bPkRDeHefm0">in on the joke</a>. (It’s not a perfect system, though; one week after I visit him, Ice <a href="http://web.archive.org/web/20171114184112/http://www.latimes.com/socal/burbank-leader/news/tn-blr-me-youtube-swatting-20170603-story.html">got held at gunpoint</a> by Burbank police on stream). Online, the moderators of /r/ice_posiedon are under explicit instructions to nuke anything that has even a whiff of a telephone bombardment. In the Purple Army’s Discord channel, there are bots that instantly erase any message that includes the word “call” or “swatting.” There’s more Ice can do, and more he plans to do; he knows his livelihood may depend upon it. He could stream on a five-minute delay, coordinate with businesses in advance, or simply stay out of them entirely.</p><p>None of these options are perfect, though, so Ice’s current solution is to head for Europe, where it will hopefully be more difficult for the haters to ruin his stream. But the truth is that there is no form of lifestreaming that doesn’t run the risks Ice Poseidon’s stream lays bare. In fact, the risks are inextricable from at least some of its appeal. Ice Poseidon is a genuinely gifted entertainer, and yet the effect of his talent — so far at least — has largely been to expose the grotesque limits of the genre he has pioneered, and maybe even the medium as a whole. Lifestreaming has transformed the entire world into content-in-waiting; it’s really too bad that this planet isn’t as pliable as <em>Runescape</em>’s.</p><p>///</p><p>About a block from the apartment, Ice starts yelling at someone. By some wild stroke of fortune, it turns out to be Geisha Montes, heading home from work to prepare for their impending date. She’s separated from us by Vine Street’s five lanes, but that’s no obstacle for Denino. He leaps into the street, dodging late afternoon traffic, and scrambles to the far side, where Geisha is laughing at his show of chivalry.</p><p>I hobble after Denino, clutching my camera. Safely across, he introduces me to Geisha. She’s lovely. Standing next to her, he’s smiling again. Honestly, it’s hard for me not to smile, too.</p><p>When they start talking about tonight, I begin feeling very intrusive. I step away from them and find myself speaking with a homeless man we passed earlier in the day. I give him the bag of barbecue chips.</p><p>When I look up, Denino and Geisha have parted. He’s already half a block away, his eyes focused on his phone. Later that night, at a restaurant whose name he manages to conceal from his viewers, he’ll ask her, on-air, if she wants to go to Europe with him. She’ll say “maybe” tonight, and “no” later. But right now, Ice Poseidon is striding down the Walk of Fame. He looks like he doesn’t have a care in the world.</p><p>///</p><p><em>If you’d like to follow me on Twitter, I am @william_partin</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=be01bc7e0573" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Esports: A Living Bibliography]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@willpartin/esports-a-living-bibliography-82c345c7af8e?source=rss-1b6c76037763------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/82c345c7af8e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[scholarship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[esport]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[academia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[computer-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bibliography]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Will Partin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 09 Feb 2019 19:54:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-11-13T17:15:18.063Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>‘Esports Studies’ Bibliography</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v9hP3q8CexwbCkXUb-Qjwg.jpeg" /><figcaption>via Robert Paul AKA @tempusrob</figcaption></figure><p>For a number of years, Dr. TL Taylor maintained a <a href="http://tltaylor.com/teaching/e-sports-and-pro-gaming-literature/">bibliography</a> on her website that gathered all of the then-marginal scholarly publications on esports. But just as public interest has risen in esports in the last decade, research about professional gaming is very much in vogue these days. So much, in fact, that it was no longer feasible for TL to keep her bibliography up-to-date (“Given the tremendous growth of scholarship now on this topic I am no longer able to update this list”, as she wrote in 2016).</p><p>In the course of writing my prospectus, I’ve had to find and read everything about esports I could find, a good majority of which has been published since 2016. Consequently, I’ve compiled a kind of “updated” version of TL’s bibliography here that I’ll try to keep current at least until I’m done with my doctorate. While the works represented below represent a wide span of perspectives and scholars are very far from agreement about what we’re studying, how, and for what reasons, there can be no doubt about the intellectual ferment taking place around esports. The bibliography below is deliberately permissive, and, as a result, the quality of the works represented varies. And while I won’t claim that the list is perfectly comprehensive it is, as far as I can tell, pretty close.</p><p>It’s worth saying a few things about what I’ve left out: lots of master’s theses, scholarship written in languages other than English, unpublished conference presentations, encyclopedia entries, and, of course, popular writing (N.B. that many esports writers are producing valuable work in general gaming interest publications like Kotaku, Polygon, Vice, and as well as esports-specific ones, like VPEsports and The Esports Observer; academics ignore these sources at their own peril). Master’s theses and conference papers are numerous, can be difficult to locate, and often represent thoughts-in-progress that are later published in more complete form, so I gravitated towards published and peer-reviewed work.</p><p>(That said, there’s still plenty of master’s theses and conference presentations in here and, if you think one I’ve missed is important, I’m happy to add it. This is meant to be a maximalist list, gathered without prejudice, and readers are free to judge the utility and quality of each entry for themselves.)</p><p>Inevitably, I’ve missed something. Lots of things, probably. So if you feel that something belongs in this bibliography that isn’t here, whether it’s your own work or someone else’s, feel free to let me know <a href="https://twitter.com/william_partin">via Twitter</a> (my DMs are open). I’ll add the citation and credit you. Finally, w/r/t typos, (plentiful) misformattings, bad links, etc. — all errors are my own. I’ll clean it up over time.</p><p>I’m hoping to keep this up to date at least until I’m done with my PhD (2021? 22?), at which point someone else can take over lol. In the meantime, this page will hopefully become a public resource for anyone, casual or pro, academic or not, who is interested in understanding any aspect of esports more deeply.</p><p>Happy reading!</p><p>(Last Updated February 10, 2019)</p><p>///</p><p>5th Annual Sports Law Symposium (University of Pennsylvania) bibliography lists a number of legal articles on esports. 2016. (<a href="http://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1048&amp;context=symposia">http://scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1048&amp;context=symposia</a>).</p><p>Abanazir, C. (2019). E-Sport and the EU: The View from the English Bridge Union. The International Sports Law Journal. 1–12.</p><p>Abanazir, C. (2018) Institutionalisation in E-Sports. Sports, Ethics and Philosophy. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/17511321.2018.1453538">https://doi.org/10.1080/17511321.2018.1453538</a></p><p>Abarbanel, B. and Johnson, M. 2018. Esports consumer perspectives on match-fixing: implications for gambling awareness and game integrity. International Gambling Studies.</p><p>Adamus, Tanja. 2012. “Playing computer games as electronic sport: In search of a theoretical framing for a new research field.” In Computer Games and New Media Cultures: A Handbook of Digital Game Studies, J. Fromme &amp; Unger, A. (Eds.),pp. 477–490, Berlin: Springer.</p><p>Andrews, David and George Ritzer. 2018. Sport and Prosumption. Journal of Consumer Culture. 18 (2): 356–373.</p><p>Ash, James. 2012. “Technology, technicity, and emerging practices of temporal sensitivity in videogames.” Environment and Planning A 44(1) 187–203.</p><p>B. Bacic, Q. Meng and K. Y. Chan, “Privacy Preservation for eSports: A Case Study Towards Augmented Video Golf Coaching System,” <em>2017 10th International Conference on Developments in eSystems Engineering (DeSE)</em>, Paris, 2017, pp. 169–174. doi: 10.1109/DeSE.2017.34</p><p><a href="https://www.cabdirect.org/cabdirect/search/?q=au%3a%22Baltezarevi%c4%87%2c+R.%22">Baltezarević, R.</a>, <a href="https://www.cabdirect.org/cabdirect/search/?q=au%3a%22Baltezarevi%c4%87%2c+B.%22">Baltezarević, B.</a> The Impact of Video Games on the Formation of Esports. <a href="https://www.cabdirect.org/cabdirect/search/?q=do%3a%22Facta+Universitatis%3a+Series+Physical+Education+and+Sport%22">Facta Universitatis: Series Physical Education and Sport</a> 2018 Vol.16 №1, 137–147.</p><p>Banyai, Fanni. Griffiths, M. Kiraly, Orsolya. Demetrovics, Zsolt. 2018. The Psychology of Esports: A Systematic Literature Review. Journal of Gambling Studies.</p><p>Bayliss, Hunter. (2016). Not Just a Game: The Employment Status and Collective Bargaining Rights of Professional ESports Players. 22 Wash. &amp; Lee J. Civ. Rts. &amp; Soc. Just. 359</p><p>Bednarek, David. Krulis, Martin. Yaghob, Jakub. Zavoral, Filip. “Player Performance Evaluation in Team-based First Person Shooter eSport.” DATA 2017: Data Management Technologies and Applications: 145–175.</p><p>Boluk, Stephanie. Lemieux, Patrick. 2017. Metagaming: Playing, Competing, Spectating, Cheating, Trading, Making, and Breaking Video Games. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.</p><p>Bonny, J., and Castaneda, L. 2016. Impact of the Arrangement of Game Information on Recall Performance of Multiplayer Online Battle Arena Players. Applied Cognitive Psychology, Appl. Cognit. Psychol. (2016). DOI: 10.1002/acp.3234.</p><p>Borowy, Michael and Dal Yong Jin. 2013. “Pioneering eSport: The experience economy and the marketing of early 1980s arcade gaming contests.” International Journal of Communication, v. 7.</p><p>Bosc, G., M. Kaytoue, C. Raïssi, J-F. Boulicaut, and P. Tan. 2014. “Mining balanced patterns in real-time strategy games.” LIRIS Research Report. (Extended version of paper presented at European Conference on Artificial Intelligence — ECAI 2014.)</p><p>Bowman, Nick. 2013. “Facilitating game play: How others affect performance at and enjoyment of video games.” Media Psychology, 16(1): 39–64.</p><p>Brannon, J. (2018). Are You Not Entertained: Considering the P-3 Visa as an Alternative Option for International Esports Professional Gamers. 60 Ariz. L. Rev. 753.</p><p>Braun, B., Stopfer, J. M., Müller, K. W., Beutel, M. E., and Egloff, B. (2016). Personality and video gaming: comparing regular gamers, non-gamers, and gaming addicts and differentiating between game genres. Comput. Hum. Behav. 55, 406–412. doi: 10.1016/j.chb.2015.09.041</p><p>Brock, Tom. 2017. “Roger Caillois and e-sports: On the problems of treating play as work.” Games and Culture, 12 (4): 321–329.</p><p>Brown, K. A., Billings, A. C., Lewis, M., Bissell, K. (2018). Explicating the electricity of eSports: Motivations for play and consumption. In Bowman, N. (Ed.), Video games: A medium that demands our attention (pp. 178–192). New York, NY: Routledge.</p><p>Brown, Kenon. Billings, Andrew. Et al. 2018. Intersections of Fandom in the Age of Interactive Media: esports fandom as a Predictor of Traditional Sport Fandom. Communication and Sport. 6(4): 418–435.</p><p>Brown, Kenon. Billings, Andrew. Et al. 2018. Explicating the Electricity of eSports: Motivations for Play and Consumption. In Video Games: A Medium that Demands our Attention. Routledge.</p><p>Burk, Dan. 2013. “Owning e-Sports: Proprietary Rights in Professional Computer Gaming.” University of Pennsylvania Law Review, Vol 161, pp-1535–1578.</p><p>Burroughs, B., &amp; Rama, P. (2015). The eSports Trojan horse: Twitch and streaming futures. Journal For Virtual Worlds Research, 8(2).</p><p>Burton, R. Gawrysiak, J. 2017. Using eSports Efficiently to Enhance and Extend Brand Perceptions. 2017 Sport Marketing Association Conference (SMA XV)</p><p>Campbell, Mark. Toth, Adam. Moran, Aidan. Kowal, Magdalena. Exton, Chris. 2018. Esports: A New Window on Neurocognitive Expertise? Progress in Brain Research Vol 240: 161–174.</p><p>Canning, Steven, and Anthony Betrus. “The Culture of Deep Learning in ESports: An Insider’s Perspective.” <em>Educational Technology</em>, vol. 57, no. 2, 2017, pp. 65–69. <em>JSTOR</em>, <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/44430527.">www.jstor.org/stable/44430527.</a></p><p>Carbonie, Amelia; Guo, Zixiu; and Cahalane, Michael, “Positive Personal Development through eSports” (2018). PACIS 2018 Proceedings. 125. <a href="https://aisel.aisnet.org/pacis2018/125">https://aisel.aisnet.org/pacis2018/125</a></p><p>Carter, Marcus and Martin Gibbs. 2013. “eSports in EVE Online: Skullduggery, Fair Play and Acceptability in an Unbounded Competition.” Foundations of Digital Games Conference, 14–17 May, Chania, Greece.</p><p>Chalmet, X. 2017. Sponsorship within Esports: Examining the Sponsorship Relationship Quality Constructs. Masters Degree Project: University of Gothenberg.</p><p>Laura L. Chao, Note, “You Must Construct Additional Pylons”: Building a Better Framework for Esports Governance, 86 FORDHAM L. REV. 737 (2017).</p><p>Charleer, S. Et Al. Real-Time Dashboards to Support eSports Spectating. <a href="https://chiplay.acm.org/2018">CHI PLAY </a>’18 Proceedings of the 2018 Annual Symposium on Computer-Human Interaction in Play, 59–71</p><p>Chee, Florence and Richard K. Smith. 2005. “Online gamers and the ambiguity of community: Korean definitions of togetherness for a new generation.” Internet Research Annual, volume 4. New York: Peter Lang.</p><p>Chen Christensen, Natasha. 2006. “Geeks at play: Doing masculinity in an online gaming site.” Reconstruction 6.1 (Winter).</p><p>Cheung, Gifford and Jeff Huang. 2011. “Starcraft from the stands: Understanding the game spectator.” CHI ’11 Proceedings of the 2011 annual conference on Human factors in computing systems, ACM, 763–772.</p><p>Choi, Eui-Yul. “Investigating Factors Influencing Game Piracy in the eSports Settings of South Korea.” (2013). <a href="http://digitalrepository.unm.edu/educ_hess_etds/9">http://digitalrepository.unm.edu/educ_hess_etds/9</a></p><p>Choi, C. Et Al. 2017. A new approach via level of addiction in eSports: Investigating participation motives from a marketing perspective. 2017 Sport Marketing Association Conference (SMA XV).</p><p>Comerford, Sean. 2012. “Note: International intellectual property rights and the future of global ‘e-sports.’” Brooklyn Journal of International Law, 37, 623.</p><p>Consalvo, Mia, Konstantin Mitgutsch, and Abe Stein (Eds.) 2013. Sports Videogames. New York: Routledge.</p><p>Conway, Steven. 2010. “‘It’s in the game’ and above the game.” Convergence 16 (3): 334- 354.</p><p>Cottrell, C. Et Al. 2018. Sport Psychology in a Virtual World: Considerations for practicioners working in esports. Journal of Sport Psychology in Action.</p><p>Crawford, Garry. 2005. “Digital gaming, sport, and gender.” Leisure Studies 24 (3): 259–270.</p><p>Crawford, Garry, and Victoria K. Gosling. 2009. “More Than a game: Sports-themed video games and player narratives.” Sociology of Sport Journal 26: 50–66.</p><p>Cullen, Amanda. “I Play to Win!” Geguri as a (post)feminist icon in esports. Feminist Media Studies. 18 (5): 948–952.</p><p>Cumming, D. Et Al. 2015. Between places: spectatorship at an Australian esports bar. Proceedings of DiGRAA 2015: What’s Next?.</p><p>Cunningham, George, Fairley, Sheranne, Ferkins, Lesley, Kerwin, Shanno, Wicke, Pamela. 2018. Esport: Construct Specifications and implication for sport management. Sport Management Review. 21 (1):1–6.</p><p>Andrew J. Curley et al., What Motivates Esports Fans? A Data-Driven Approach to Business and Development Strategy, 5 (2016) (unpublished M.A. thesis, Southern Methodist University Guildhall), <a href="https://static1-squarespace-com.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/static/563e65aee4b0e5c">https://static1-squarespace-com.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/static/563e65aee4b0e5c</a> 70f6963c9/t/59e97e8218b27dc94c4aaede/1508474499280/Curley_ThesisPaper.pdf [https:// perma.cc/73DR-HXK9].</p><p>al Dafai, Samer. 2016. Conventions within eSports: Exploring Similarities in Design. Proceedings of 1st International Joint Conference of DiGRA and FDG</p><p>DiFrancisco-Donoghue, Joanne. Ballentine, Jerry. 2018. Collegiate Esport: Where Do We Fit In?. 17 (4): 117–118.</p><p>Dobill, Matthew. 2017. Leveling (up) the Playing Field: A Policy-Based Case for Legalizing and Regulating Esports Gambling. 37 Loy. L.A. Ent. L. Rev. 139 (2016–2017).</p><p>Edgar, A. 2019. Esport (Editorial). Sports, Ethics, and Philosophy. 13 (1).</p><p>Egliston, B. 2015. Playing Across Media: Transtextuality in Competitive Games and eSports. Proceedings of DiGRA 2015: Diversity of play: Games — Cultures — Identities.</p><p>Ekdahl, David. Susanne, Ravn. 2018. Embodied involvement in virtual worlds: the case of eSports practitioners. Sport, Ethics, and Philosophy.</p><p>Engerman, J., &amp; Hein, R. (2017). ESports Gaming and You. Educational Technology, 57(2), 62–64. Retrieved from <a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/44430526">http://www.jstor.org/stable/44430526</a></p><p>Faust, Kyle, Joseph Meyer, and Mark Griffiths. 2013. “Competitive and Professional Gaming: Discussing Potential Benefits of Scientific Study.” International Journal of Cyber Behavior, Psychology and Learning, 3(1), 67–77, January-March.</p><p>Ferrari, Simon. 2013. “Esport and the human body: Foundations for a popular aesthetics.” Proceedings of DiGRA 2013: Defragging Game Studies, Atlanta, GA.</p><p>Ferrari, Simon. 2013. From Generative to Conventional Play: MOBA and League of Legends. Proceedings of DiGRA 2013: DeFragging Game Studies.</p><p>Freeman, Guo. Donghee, Yvette Wohn. 2017. Understanding Esports Team Formation and Coordination. Computer Supported Cooperative Work. DOI 10.1007/s10606–017–9299–4.</p><p>Freeman, Guo. Donghee, Yvette Wohn. 2017. Social Support in Esports: Building Emotional and Self-Esteem from Instrumental Support Interactions in a Highly Competitive Environment. CHI Play ’17: Proceedings of the Annual Symposium on Computer-Human Interaction in Play. 435–447.</p><p>Funk, Daniel. Pizzo, Anthony. Baker, Bradley. (2018) Esport Management: Embracing Esport Education and Research Opportunities. Sport Management Review 21 (1): 7–13.</p><p>Gainsbury, S., Abarbanel, B., &amp; Blaszczynski, A. (2017). Game on: Comparison of demographic profiles, consumption behaviours, and gambling site selection criteria of esports and sports bettors. Gaming Law Review, 21(8), 575–587. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1089/glr2.2017.21812">https://doi.org/10.1089/glr2.2017.21812</a></p><p>Gainsbury, S., Abarbanel, B., &amp; Blaszczynski, A. (2017). Intensity and Gambling Harms: Exploring Breadth of Gambling Involvement Among Esports Bettors. Gaming Review 21 8.</p><p>Georgen, C. et al. 2015 From Lurking to Participatory Spectatorship: Understanding Affordances of the Dota 2 Noob Stream. CSCL 2015 Proceedings. 581–585.</p><p>Gerber, Hannah. 2017. Esports and Streaming: Twitch Literacies. Text &amp; Resource Review Forum: Visual and Digital Texts.</p><p>Gibbs, M. Et Al. Understanding Esports Spectatorship: Players, Fans, Recruits. Selected Papers of #AoIR2017: The 18th Annual Conference of the Association of Internet Researchers Tartu, Estonia / 18–21 October 2017</p><p>Gommesen, Niels. 2012. “The affective audience in professional e-sport: An exploration of spectators, and their impact on video game playing.” MsC thesis, IT University of Copenhagen.</p><p>Griffiths, M. D., Davies, M. N., and Chappell, D. (2003). Breaking the stereotype: the case of online gaming. CyberPsychol. Behav. 6, 81–91. doi: 10.1089/109493103321167992</p><p>Gray, Kishonna. 2013. Collective Organizing, Individual Resistance, or Asshole Griefers? An Ethnographic Analysis of Women of Color in Xbox Live. Ada: A Journal of Gender, New Media, and Technology 2.</p><p>Gray, K. L. (2017). They’re just too urban’: Black gamers streaming on Twitch. Digital sociologies, 1, 355–368.</p><p>Guorui, Zhang. 2012. “Bibliometric analysis on e-sports in China.” Advances in Computer Science and Engineering, AISC 141, 111–118.</p><p>Juho Hamari, Max Sjöblom, (2017) “What is eSports and why do people watch it?”, Internet Research, Vol. 27 Issue: 2, pp.211–232.</p><p>Hallman, Kirstin, and Thomas Giel. “Esports-Competitive Sports or recreational activity?” Sport Management Review 21 (2018) 14–20.</p><p>Hamilton, William, Oliver Garretson, and Andruid Kerne. 2014. “Streaming on Twitch: Fostering Participatory Communities of Play within Live Mixed Media.” CHI 2014, April 26–May 1, 2014, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.</p><p>Hamilton, W. Et Al. 2012. “High-Performance Pen + Touch Modality Interactions: A Real-Time Strategy Game eSports Context”. UIST’12, October 7–10, 2012, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA.</p><p>Hardenstein, Taylor. 2017. Skins in the Game: Counter-Strike, Esports, and the Shady World of Online Gambling. Unpublished Manuscript.</p><p>Harry, Drew. 2012. Designing Complementary Communication Systems. PhD dissertation, MIT Media Lab, Cambridge, MA.</p><p>Harper, Todd. 2014. The Culture of Digital Fighting Games: Performance and Practice. New York: Routledge.</p><p>Jochen Harttung, The Issue of “Deep Control” in Professional E-Sports-A Critical Analysis of Intellectual Property Structures in Electronic Gaming (2015) (unpublished LLM thesis, University of Toronto).</p><p>Hebbel-Seeger, Andreas. 2012. “The relationship between real sports and digital adaptation in e-sport gaming.” International Journal of Sports Marketing and Sponsorship, 13:2, 43–54.</p><p>Heere B (2018) Embracing the sportification of society: defining e-sports through a polymorphic view on sport. Sport Manag Rev 21:21–24.</p><p>Hemphill D (2005) Cybersport. J Philos Sport 32(2):195–207.</p><p>Himmelstein, D., Liu, Y., &amp; Shapiro, J. L. (2017). An exploration of mental skills among competitive League of Legend players. International Journal of Gaming and Computer-Mediated Simulations, 9(2), 1–21.</p><p>Hinnant, Neal. 2013. “Practicing work, perfecting play: League of Legends and the sentimental education of e-sports” MA thesis, Georgia State University, Dept. of Communication.</p><p>Holden JT, and Ehrlich, S. 2017. Esports, Skin Betting, and Wire Fraud Vulnerability. Gaming Law Review Vol 21 No 8. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1089/glr2.2017.2183">https://doi.org/10.1089/glr2.2017.2183</a></p><p>Holden, JT. ET AL. 2018. Esports: Children, stimulants, and video gaming-induced inactivity. 54 (8): 830–831.</p><p>Holden, JT. Rodenberg, RM. Kaburakis, A. 2017. Esport Corruption: Gambling, Doping, and Global Governance. Maryland Journal of International Law. Volume 32. Pages 236–73.</p><p>Holden JT, Kaburakis A, Rodenberg R (2017) The future is now: eSports policy considerations and potential litigation. Journal of Legal Aspects of Sport 27:46–78.</p><p>Holden JT, Kabourakis A, Tweedie JW (2018) Virtue(al) games — real drugs. Sport Ethics Philos.</p><p>Hollist, Katherine E. 2015. “Time to be grown-ups about video gaming: The rising esports industry and the need for regulation.” Arizona Law Review 57:823–847.</p><p>Holt, Jason. 2016. “Virtual domains for sports and games.” Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 10:1, 5–13.</p><p>Howard, Matt. 2018. Esport: Professional League of Legends as Cultural History. MA Thesis, University of Houston.</p><p>Hutchins, Brett. 2008. “Signs of meta-change in second modernity: The growth of e-sport and the World Cyber Games.” New Media and Society 10 (6): 851–869.</p><p>Hutchins, Brett and David Rowe. 2012. Sport Beyond Television: The Internet, Digital Media and the Rise of Networked Media Sport. London: Routledge.</p><p>Irwin, S. V., &amp; Naweed, A. (2018). BM’ing, Throwing, Bug Exploiting, and Other Forms of (Un)Sportsmanlike Behavior in CS:GO Esports. Games and Culture. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/1555412018804952">https://doi.org/10.1177/1555412018804952</a></p><p>Jansz, J., &amp; Martens, L. (2005). Gaming at a LAN event: The social context of playing video games. New Media &amp; Society, 7, 333–355. doi:10.1177/1461444805052280</p><p>Jenny, Seth, R. Douglas Manning, Margaret C. Keiper, and Tracy W. Olrich. 2016. “Virtual(ly) athletes: Where eSports fit within the definition of ‘sport.’” Quest, 11 March.</p><p>Jenny, Seth and David P. Schary. 2016. “Virtual and “real-life” wall/rock climbing: motor movement comparisons and video gaming pedagogical perceptions.” Sports Technology, 11 January.</p><p>Jenny SE, Keiper MC, Taylor BJ, Williams DP, Gawrysiak J, Manning RD, Tutka PM (2018) eSports venues: a new sport business opportunity. J Appl Sport Manag 10:34–49.</p><p>Jin, Dal Yong. 2010. Korea’s Online Gaming Empire. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.</p><p>Jin, Dal Yong (February 2017). <a href="https://www.press.umich.edu/9332415/smartland_korea">Smartland Korea: mobile communication, culture, and society</a>. Ann Arbor, MI: The University of Michigan Press.</p><p>Jin, Dal Yong, and Florence Chee. 2009. “The politics of online gaming.” In Gaming Cultures and Place in Asia- Pacific, ed. Larissa Hjorth and Dean Chan, 19–38. New York: Routledge.</p><p>Johnson, Mark, and Jamie Woodcock. 2017. Fighting Games and Go: Exploring the Aesthetics of Play in Professional Gaming. Thesis 11 138(1): 26–45.</p><p>Jonasson, Kalle. 2016. “Broadband and circuits: the place of public gaming in the history of sport.” Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 10:1, 5–13.</p><p>Jonasson, Kalle and Jesper Thiborg. 2010. “Electronic sport and its impact on future sport.” Sport in Society 13 (2): 287–299.</p><p>Kajastila, Raine and Perttu Hamalainen. 2015. “Motion games in real sports environments.” Interactions, March-April.</p><p>Kane, D. and Spradley, B. 2017. Recognizing ESports as a sport. The Sport Journal.</p><p>Karhulahti, Veli-Matti (2017) Reconsidering Esport: Economics and Executive Ownership. Physical Culture and Sport. Studies and Research 74 (1)</p><p>Kaytoue, Mehdi and Chedy Raïssi. 2012. “Watch me playing, I am a professional.” WWW 2012 Companion. April 16–20, 2012, Lyon, France.</p><p>Kelly SM, Sigmon KA (2018) The key to key presses: eSports game input streaming and copyright protection. Interact Entertain Law Rev 1(1):2–16.</p><p>Kennedy, Helen W. 2006. Illegitimate, Monstrous and Out There: Female ‘Quake’ Players and Inappropriate Pleasures. In Feminism in Popular Culture, ed. Jonanne Hollows and Roberta Pearson, 183–201. Oxford: Berg.</p><p>Keiper, M. Et Al. No reason to LoL at LoL: the addition of esports to intercollegiate athletic departments. Journal for the Study of Sports and Athletes in Education 11 (2). 143–160.</p><p>Kim, S. H., &amp; Thomas, M. K. (2015). A stage theory model of professional video game players in South Korea: The socio-cultural dimensions of the development of expertise. Asian Journal of Information Technology, 14(5), 176–186.</p><p>Ksenia Konstantinova Denis Bulygin Paul Okopny Ilya Musabirov. Online Communication of eSports Viewers: Topic Modeling Approach. ACE 2017: Advances in Computer Entertainment Technology. 608–613.</p><p>Kow, Yong Ming and Timothy Young. 2013. “Media technologies and learning in the StarCraft eSport community.” CSCW ’13, San Antonio, Texas.</p><p>Kow, Yong Ming, Timothy Young, and Katie Salen Tekinbas. 2014. Crafting the metagame: Connected learning in the StarCraft 2 community. Irvine, CA: Digital Media and Learning Research Hub.</p><p>Kozachuk, J. Foroughi, C. Freeman, G. 2016. Exploring Electronic Sports: An Interdisciplinary Approach. Proceedings of the 2016 Human Factors and Ergonomics Society. 2118–2122.</p><p>Lee, C. The Revolution of StarCraft Network Traffic. Self-Published. <a href="http://choongsoo.info/docs/starcraft2.netgames12.pdf">http://choongsoo.info/docs/starcraft2.netgames12.pdf</a>.</p><p>Lee, J.-Y., An, J.-W., &amp; Lee, S.-W. (2014). Factors affecting eSports audience satisfaction-The case of League of Legends. Journal of Korea Game Society, 14(3), 35–46.</p><p>Lee, D., &amp; Schoenstedt, L. J. (2011). Comparison of eSports and traditional sports consumption motives. Journal of Research, 6, 39–44.</p><p>Leonard, David. 2008. “To the white extreme in the mainstream: Manhood and white youth culture in a virtual sports world.” In Youth Culture and Sport, ed. Michael D. Giardina and Michele K. Donnelly, 91–112. New York: Routledge.</p><p>Llorens, M. 2017. eSport Gaming: The Rise of a New Sports Practice. 11 (4): 464–476.</p><p>Lo, Claudia. (2018). When All You Have is a Banhammer: The Social and Communicative Work of Volunteer Moderators. MSc Thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.</p><p>Lopez-Gonzalez, Hibai. Griffiths, Mark. 2016. Understanding the convergence of markets in online sports betting. International Review for the Sociology of Sport. 53 (7): 807–823.</p><p>Lipovaya, Viktoriya. 2019. Esports: Opportunities for Future Ergonomic Studies. Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing. 824, 1937–1948.</p><p>Low-Kam, C., C. Raïssi, M. Kaytoue, and J. Pei. 2013. “Mining statistically significant sequential patterns,” ICDM 2013.</p><p>Lowood, Henry. 2007. “‘It’s not easy being green’: Real-time game performance in Warcraft.” In Videogame/Player/Text, ed. Barry Atkins and Tanya Krzywinska, 83–100. Manchester: Palgrave.</p><p>Lowood, Henry. Forthcoming. “‘Beyond the game’: The Olympic ideal and competitive e-sports.” In Play and Politics: Games, Civic Engagement, and Social Activism, ed. Douglas Thomas and Joshua Fouts.</p><p>Ma, Hu, Yinbo Wu and Xinyu Wu. 2013. “Research on essential difference of E-sport and Online Game.” Informatics and Management Science V, Lecture Notes in Electrical Engineering 208.</p><p>Macey, Joseph. Hamari, Juho. 2018 Investigating relationships between video gaming, spectating esports, and gambling. Computers in Human Behavior. Vol 80: 344–353.</p><p>Macey, J., &amp; Hamari, J. (2019). eSports, skins and loot boxes: Participants, practices and problematic behaviour associated with emergent forms of gambling. New Media &amp; Society, 21(1), 20–41. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/1461444818786216">https://doi.org/10.1177/1461444818786216</a></p><p>Martoncik, 9 M. (2015). e-Sports: Playing just for fun or playing to satisfy life goals? Computers in Human Behavior, 48, 208–211. <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.">http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.</a> Chb.2015.01.056.</p><p>McCrea, Christian. 2009. “Watching Starcraft, strategy and South Korea.” In Gaming Cultures and Place in Asia-Pacific, ed. Larissa Hjorth and Dean Chan, 179–193. New York: Routledge.</p><p>Christopher McCutcheon, Michael Hitchens, Anders Drachen. 2017. “eSport vs. irlSport.” ACE 2017: Advances in Computer Entertainment Technology: 531–542.</p><p>Meadows, Jennifer. 2018. Esports. Communication Technology Update and Fundamentals, 16th edition.</p><p><a href="https://search-proquest-com.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/indexinglinkhandler/sng/au/Menasce,+Rick+M/$N?accountid=14244">Menasce, Rick M</a>.From Casual to Professional: How Brazilians Achieved Esports Success in Counter-Strike: Global Offensive. Northeastern University, ProQuest Dissertations Publishing, 2017.</p><p>Miroff, Max. 2018. Tiebreaker: An Antitrust Analysis of Esports. Columbia Journal of Law and Social Problems. 52: 2.</p><p>Moeller, Ryan M., Bruce Esplin, and Steven Conway. 2009. “Cheesers, pullers, and glitchers: The rhetoric of sportsmanship and the discourse of online sports gamers.” Game Studies, 9 (2).</p><p>Mora, Philippe and Stéphane Héas. 2005. “From videogamer to e-sportsman : Toward a growing professionalism of world-class players?.” In Doom: Giocare in Prima Persona, Matteo Bittanti and Sue Morris, Eds. Milano: Costa &amp; Nolan.</p><p>Marçal Mora-Cantallops &amp; Miguel-Ángel Sicilia. 2018. Exploring player experience in ranked League of Legends. Behavior and Information Technology 37 (12): 1224–1236.</p><p>Muniowski, L. 2018. Geek is the New Jock: The Relationship between Geek Culture and Sports. In Age of the Geek: Depictions of Nerds and Geeks in Popular Media. New York: Palgrave McMillan.</p><p>Nuangjumnong, T. 2015. The Universality of Leadership Behaviors in Virtual Environments: A Case of Esports Players in Thailand. Graduate School of Asia-Pacific Studies, Waseda University. Journal of the Graduate School of Asia-Pacific Studies 30 (3): 105–132.</p><p>Olsen, Anders. 2015. The Evolution of Esports: An analysis of its origin and a look at its prospective future growth as enhanced by Information Technology Management tools. Thesis: Master in Science (M.Scs.) At Coventry University</p><p>Olshefski, Emily. Game-Changing Event Definition and Detection in an eSports Corpus. Proceedings of the 3rd Workshop on EVENTS at the NAACL-HLT 2015, 77–81.</p><p>Owens, M. 2016, What’s in a Name? eSports, Betting, and Gaming Law. Gaming Law Review Vol 20 No 7. 567-?.</p><p>Paravizo, Esdras, and Luvizoto de Souza, R.R. (2018). Playing for Real: An Exploratory Analysis of Professional Esports Athletes’ Work. IEA 2018: Proceedings of the 20th Congress fo the International Ergonomics Association: 507–515.</p><p>Parashakov, Petr, and Zavertiaeva, M. Team Diversity and Performance in eSports. Unpublished Paper.</p><p>Parashakov, Petr, and Oskolkova, M. 2016. Success in Esports: Does Country Matter?. Working Paper. DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.1.3723.9445.</p><p>Parshakov, P. Et Al. Is Diversity Good or Bad? Evidence from esports team analysis. Applied Economics. 50 (47), 5062–5073.</p><p>Parshakov, P., and Coates, D. 2016. Team Vs. Individual Tournaments: Evidence from Prize Structure in Esports. Working Paper.</p><p>Parry J (2018) E-sports are not sports. Sport Ethics Philos. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/17511321.2018.1489419">https://doi.org/10.1080/17511321.2018.1489419</a></p><p>Pereira, R., Wilwert, M. L., &amp; Takase, E. 2016. “Contributions of Sport Psychology to the Competitive Gaming: An Experience Report with a Professional Team of League of Legends,” International Journal of Applied Psychology, 6(2), 27–30.</p><p>Samuel C. Peter, Qian Li, Rory A. Pfund, James P. Whelan, Andrew W. Meyers. 2018. Public Stigma Across Addictive Behaviors: Casino Gambling, eSports Gambling, and Internet Gaming. Journal of Gambling Studies.</p><p>Pluss, Matthew, et al. 2019. Esports: The Chess of the 21st Century. Frontiers In Psychology. <a href="https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00156">https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00156</a>.</p><p>Remco Polman, Michael Trotter, Dylan Poulus, Erika Borkoles. Esport: Friend or Foe? JCGS 2018: Joint International Conference on Serious Games: 3–8.</p><p>Railsback, Daniel. 2019. Investigating the human factors in esport performance. Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing 795: 325–334.</p><p>Rambusch, Jana. 2011. Mind Games Extended: Understanding Gameplay as Situated Activity. PhD dissertation, Linköping Studies in Science and Technology.</p><p>Rambusch, Jana, et al. 2017. Cognitive Challenges in eSports. PROCEEDINGS OF THE 13TH SWECOG CONFERENCE 2017, UPPSALA.</p><p>Rambusch, Jana, Peter Jakobsson, and Daniel Pargman. 2007. “Exploring e-sports: A case study of gameplay in Counter-Strike.” In Situated Play: Proceedings of the Digital Games Research Association (DiGRA) Conference 2007, ed. Akira Baba. Tokyo: University of Tokyo.</p><p>Ratan, R., Taylor, N., Hogan, J., et al. (2015). Stand by your man: An examination of gender disparity in League of Legends. Games and Culture, 10(5), 438–462.</p><p>Reeves, Stuart, Barry Brown, and Eric Laurier. 2009. “Experts at play: Understanding skilled expertise.” Games and Culture 4 (3): 205–227.</p><p>Richard, G. et al. 2018. Collegiate eSports as Learning Ecologies: Investigating Collaborative Learning and Cognition During Competitions. Proceedings of DiGRA 2018</p><p>Robeers, Timothy, van den Bulk, H. 2018. Towards an Understanding of Side-Lining Environmental Sustainability in Formula E: Traditional Values and the Emergence of eSports. Athens Journal of Sports — Volume 5, Issue 4 — Pages 331–350.</p><p>Robertson, Caitlin. 2015. Wandering the World without Leaving Your Chair: Crossing Borders Through eSports. Master’s Thesis: Georgia Southern Univesity.</p><p>Jacob Rogers, Crafting an Industry: An Analysis of Korean StarCraft and Intellectual Properties Law, HARV. J.L. &amp; TECH. (2012), <a href="http://jolt.law.harvard.edu.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/digest/crafting-an-industry-an-analysis-of-korean-starcraft-and-intellectual-properties-law">http://jolt.law.harvard.edu.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/digest/crafting-an-industry-an-analysis-of-korean-starcraft-and-intellectual-properties-law</a> [https://perma.cc/6TCR-WKP2], discussed infra Part V, note 200.</p><p>Rosell M (2017) eSport gaming: the rise of a new sports practice. Sport Ethics Philos 11(4):464–476.</p><p>Rothman, Jennifer. 2013. “E-sports as a prism for the role of evolving technology in intellectual property.” University of Pennsylvania Law Review Online 116: 317–329.</p><p>Rune K. L. Nielsen and Veli-Mati Karhulahti. 2017. Te Problematic Coexistence of “Internet Gaming Disorder” and Esports. In Proceedings of FDG’17, Hyannis, MA, USA, August 14–17, 2017, 4 pages. htp://dx.doi.org/10.1145/3102071.310635</p><p><a href="https://journals-sagepub-com.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/doi/10.1177/0193723518773287">Omar Ruvalcaba</a>, <a href="https://journals-sagepub-com.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/doi/10.1177/0193723518773287">Jeffrey Shulze</a>, <a href="https://journals-sagepub-com.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/doi/10.1177/0193723518773287">Angela Kim</a>, <a href="https://journals-sagepub-com.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/doi/10.1177/0193723518773287">Sara R. Berzenski</a>, <a href="https://journals-sagepub-com.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/doi/10.1177/0193723518773287">Mark P. Otten</a>. 2018. Women’s Experiences in eSports: Gendered Differences in Peer and Spectator Feedback During Competitive Video Game Play. Journal of Sport and Social Issues. 42 (4): 295–311.</p><p>Schaeperkoetter, C. Et Al. 2017. The “New” Student Athlete: An Exploratory Examination of Scholarship Esports Players. Journal of Intercollegiate Sport 10: 1–21.</p><p>Schmidt, M., and Shreffler, M. 2015. Motivations for eSport Consumption: A Road Map for Traditional Sports Online Spectating. 2015 Sport Marketing Association Conference (SMA XIII).</p><p>Scholz, Tobias. New Broadcasting Ways In IPTV — The Case of the Starcraft II Broadcasting Scene. World Media Economics &amp; Management Conference 23–27.5.2012 in Thessaloniki, Greece.</p><p>Scholz, Tobias and Volker Stein. 2017. “Going beyond ambidexterity in the media industry: Esports as pioneer of ultradexterity.” Int’l Journal of Gaming and Computer-Mediated Simulations, 9(2): 47–62.</p><p>Schneider, S. (2015). eSport betting: The intersection of gaming and gambling. Gaming Law Review and Economics, 19(6), 419–420.</p><p>Schubert, M. 2016. Esports Analytics Through Encounter Detection. MIT Sloan Sports Analytics Conference, Boston, MA.</p><p>Sell, Jesse. 2015. E-Sports Broadcasting. MsC thesis, MIT, Cambridge, MA.</p><p>Seo, W. J., &amp; Green, B. C. (2008). Development of the motivation scale for sport online consumption. Journal of Sport Management, 22, 82–109.</p><p>Seo, Y. and Jung, S.U. (2014), “Beyond solitary play in computer games: the social practices of eSports”, Journal of Consumer Culture, Vol. 16 №3, pp. 1–21.</p><p>Seo, Yuri. 2013. “Electronic sports: A new marketing landscape of the experience economy.” Journal of Marketing Management, published online 21 August.</p><p>Seo, Y. (2016), “Professionalized consumption and identity transformations in the field of eSports”, Journal of Business Research, Vol. 69 №1, pp. 264–272.</p><p>Skubida, D. 2016. Can Some Computer Games Be a Sport?: Issues with Legitimization of eSport as a Sporting Activity. <a href="https://www.igi-global.com/journal/international-journal-gaming-computer-mediated/1125">International Journal of Gaming and Computer-Mediated Simulations (IJGCMS)</a> 8(4).</p><p>Max Sjöblom, Lobna Hassan, Joseph Macey, Maria Törhönen, and Juho Hamari. 2018. Liking the Game: How Can Spectating Motivations Influence Social Media Usage at Live Esports Events? In Proceedings of the International Conference on Social Media &amp; Society, Copenhagen, Denmark (SMSociety). DOI: 10.1145/3217804.3217908.</p><p>Song, Yale. Real-Time Video Highlights for Yahoo Esports. 1st NIPS Workshop on Large Scale Computer Vision Systems (LSCVS 2016), Barcelona, Spain.</p><p>Stald, Gitte. 2001. “Meeting in the combat zone: Online multi-player computer games as spaces for social and cultural encounters.” In Proceedings of Association of Internet Researchers Conference, ed. Leslie Shade. Minneapolis, USA.</p><p>Stein, Volker and Tobias M. Scholz. 2016. “The intercultural challenge of building the European eSports League.” In Christoph Barmeyer and Peter Franklin (Eds.) Case Studies in Intercultural Management: Achieving Synergy from Diversity. London: Palgrave, 80–94.</p><p>Suschevskiy, Vsevolod. Marchenko, Ekaterina. 2018. Network Analysis of Player Transfers in Esports: The Case of Dota 2. DGTS 2018: Digital Transformation and Global Society, 468–473.</p><p>Swalwell, M. L. 2009. “LAN gaming groups: Snapshots from an Australasian case study, 1999–2008.” In Gaming cultures and place in Asia-Pacific, ed. L. Hjorth and D. Chan, 117–136. Oxon, UK: Routledge.</p><p>Szablewicz, Marcella. 2016. “A realm of mere representation? ‘Live’ e-sports spectacles and the crafting of China’s digital gaming image.” Games and Culture, 11(3): 256–274.</p><p>Szablewicz, M. 2015. “The Spectacle of Spectatorship: e-Sports events and the crafting of China’s digital gaming image” Games and Culture, Special Issue: Chinese Game Studies.</p><p>Taylor, N. (2009). Cheerleaders, booth babes, Halo hoes: pro-gaming, gender and jobs for the boys. Digital Creativity, 20(4), 239–252.</p><p>Taylor, N. 2018. I’d Rather be a Cyborg than a Gamerbro: How Masculinity mediares research on digital play. MedieKultur: Journal of media and communication research, Vol 64, 10–30.</p><p>Taylor, N. and Hammond, R. (Forthcoming). Outside the lanes: Supporting a non-normative League of Legends Community. In T. Harper, M. Blythe-Adams and N. Taylor (eds.), Queer Studies / Game Studies: Playing Out Binaries. New York: Palgrave-Macmillan.</p><p>Taylor, Nicholas T. 2015. “Play to the camera: Video ethnography, spectatorship, and e-sports,” Convergence, 24 April.</p><p>Taylor, Nicholas T. 2012. “A silent team is a dead team”: Communicative norms in team-based Halo 3 play. In G. Voorhees, (Ed.), Guns, grenades and grunts: First person shooter games. New York: Continuum.</p><p>Taylor, Nicholas T. 2011. “Play globally, act locally: The standardization of pro Halo 3 gaming.” International Journal of Gender, Science and Technology, 3(1).</p><p>Taylor, N., Jenson, J., de Castell, S. and Dilouya, B. (2014). Public displays of play: Studying online games in physical settings. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication. DOI: 10.1111/jcc4.12054</p><p>Taylor, Nicholas T. 2009. “Where the women are(n’t): Gender and a North American ‘pro-gaming’ scene.” In Breaking New Ground: Innovation in Games, Play, Practice and Theory: Proceedings of the 2009 Digital Games Research Association conference, eds. Barry Atkins, Helen Kennedy, and Tanya Krzywinska. London.</p><p>Taylor, Nicholas T. 2009. Power Play: Digital Gaming Goes Pro. PhD Dissertation, York University, Toronto.</p><p>Taylor, T.L. 2006. “Does WoW Change Everything?: How a PvP Server, Multinational Playerbase, and Surveillance Mod Scene Caused Me Pause,” Games and Culture, 1 (4): 1–20.</p><p>Taylor, T.L. 2006. Play Between Worlds: Exploring Online Game Culture. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.</p><p>Taylor, T.L. 2018. Watch Me Play: Twitch and the Rise of Game Live Streaming. Princeton: Princeton University Press.</p><p>Taylor, T.L. 2012. Raising the Stakes: The Professionalization of Computer Gaming. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.</p><p>Taylor, T. L., and Emma Witkowski. 2010. “This is how we play it: What a mega-LAN can teach us about games.” In Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on the Foundations of Digital Game, ed. Yusuf Pisan. Monterey, CA: ACM Press.</p><p>Turtiainen, R., Friman, U., &amp; Ruotsalainen, M. (2018). “Not Only for a Celebration of Competitive Overwatch but Also for National Pride”: Sportificating the Overwatch World Cup 2016. Games and Culture. https://doi.org/<a href="https://doi-org.libproxy.lib.unc.edu/10.1177/1555412018795791">10.1177/1555412018795791</a></p><p>Tong BAJW (2017) A new player has entered the game: immigration reform for esports players. Jeffrey S Moorad Sports Law J 24:351–386.</p><p>Van Hilvoorde, Ivo and Niek Pot. “Embodiment and fundamental motor skills in eSports.” Sports, Ethics and Philosophy, 10:1, 14–27.</p><p>van Hilvoorde, I. (2016). Sport and play in a digital world. Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 10(1), 1–4. https:// doi.org/10.1080/17511321.2016.1171252.</p><p>Vera, José Agustín Carrillo. 2016. “From players to viewers: the construction of the media spectacle in the e-sports context.” Anàlisi, Issue 55, December [in Spanish].</p><p>Verhoef, Geert. Professionalization of esports broadcasts The mediatization of Dreamhack Counter-Strike Tournaments. MA Thesis. <a href="http://geertverhoeff.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Thesis.pdf">http://geertverhoeff.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Thesis.pdf</a>.</p><p>Gerald Voorhees, Alexandra Orlando. 2018. “Performing Neoliberal Masculinity: Reconfiguring Hegemonic Masculinity in Professional Gaming.” In <em>Masculinities in Play</em>. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.</p><p>Wagner, Michael. 2006. “On the scientific relevance of eSport.” In Proceedings of the 2006 International Conference on Internet Computing and Conference on Computer Game Development. Las Vegas, Nevada: CSREA Press.</p><p>Wagner, Michael. (2007). Competing in Metagame Gamespace. 10.1007/978–3–7643–8415–9_66.</p><p>Weiss, T., &amp; Schiele, S. (2013). Virtual worlds in competitive contexts: Analyzing eSports consumer needs. Electronic Markets, 23(4), 307–316.</p><p>Wimmer, Jeffrey. 2012. “Digital game culture(s) as prototype(s) of mediatization and commercialization of society.” In Computer Games and New Media Cultures: A Handbook of Digital Game Studies, J. Fromme &amp; Unger, A. (Eds.), pp. 525–540, Berlin: Springer.</p><p>Witkowski, Emma. 2014. “Competition and Cooperation,” in B. Perron and M. J. Wolf, (eds.) The Routledge Companion to Video Game Studies. New York: Routledge.</p><p>Witkowski, E. Hutchins, B. and Carter, M. 2013. E-sports on the rise?: Critical considerations on the growth and erosion of organized digital gaming competitions. <a href="http://ieconference.org/ie2013/">IE </a>’13 Proceedings of The 9th Australasian Conference on Interactive Entertainment: Matters of Life and DeathArticle №43. Melbourne, Australia — September 30 — October 01, 2013.</p><p>Witkowski, Emma. 2018. Doing/Undoing Gender with the Girl Gamer in High-Performance Play. Feminism in Play.</p><p>Witkowski, Emma. 2013. “Eventful masculinities: Negotiations of hegemonic sporting masculinities at LANs,” in Mia Consalvo, Konstantin Mitgutsch, and Abe Stein (Eds.) Sports Videogames. New York: Routledge.</p><p>Witkowski, E. Et Al. 2017. Esports Futures in Australia. Extended Abstract Presented at DiGRA 2017.</p><p>Witkowski, E., Manning, J. (2018). Player Power: Networked careers in esports and high performance game livestreaming practices In: Convergence The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies, 1–17</p><p>Witkowski, Emma. 2012. “On the Digital Playing Field: How We ‘Do Sport’ With Networked Computer Games.” Games and Culture, 7:349–374.</p><p>Witkowski, Emma. 2012. Inside the Huddle: The Sociology and Phenomenology of Team Play in Networked Computer Games. PhD dissertation, IT University of Copenhagen, Denmark.</p><p>Witkowski, Emma. 2009. “Probing the sportiness of eSports,” in J. Christophers and T. Scholz (eds.), eSports yearbook 2009, Norderstedt, Germany: Books on Demand GmbH, pp. 53–56.</p><p>Witkowski, E. (2018). Sensuous proximity in research methods with expert teams, media sports, and esports practices. MedieKultur: Journal of media and communication research, Vol 34, 31–5.</p><p>Xia, B., Wang, H., &amp; Zhou, R. (2017). What Contributes to Success in MOBA Games? An Empirical Study of Defense of the Ancients 2. Games and Culture. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/1555412017710599">https://doi.org/10.1177/1555412017710599</a></p><p>Xiao, M. (2019). Factors Influencing eSports Viewership: An Approach Based on the Theory of Reasoned Action. Communication &amp; Sport. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1177/2167479518819482">https://doi.org/10.1177/2167479518819482</a></p><p>Yan, Jeff. 2018. How Does Match-Fixing Inform Computer Game Security? Cambrige International Workshop on Security Protocols XXVI: 166–170.</p><p>Yang, Yifan. Et Al. Real-time esports Match Result Prediction. NIPS 2016: Neural Information Processing Systems, Barcelona Spain.</p><p>Yoon, Tae-Jin and Jin, Dal Yong (2017). <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Korean-Wave-Evolution-Fandom-Transnationality/dp/149855556X">The Korean Wave: Evolution, Fandom and Transnationality</a>.</p><p>Young-nam Seo. Et al. 2018. Attention to Esports Advertisement: Effect of Ad Animation and in-game dynamics on viewers’ visual attention. 37. 1194–1202.</p><p>Zhu, Lily. Masculinity’s New Battle Arena in International E-Sports: The Games Begin. In In <em>Masculinities in Play</em>. New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.</p><p>Zolides, Andrew. 2015. “Lipstick Bullets: Labour and Gender in Professional Gamer Self-Branding,” Persona Studies, 1.2, 42–53.</p><p>///</p><p>I haven’t included these because I don’t speak Chinese, but if you are interested in Chinese esports research, this link is a good place to start.</p><p><a href="http://en.cnki.com.cn/Article_en/CJFDTOTAL-JFTY200403042.htm">The Development Way of E-sports Games Industry in China--《Journal of PLA Institute of Physical Education》2004年03期</a></p><p>And a long Twitch bibliography is here:</p><p><a href="https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1TTwGPc3fzSoHYYPZLKDIfNvNtg0jfmxn-bOhK1XVlFU/edit?usp=sharing">https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1TTwGPc3fzSoHYYPZLKDIfNvNtg0jfmxn-bOhK1XVlFU/edit?usp=sharing</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=82c345c7af8e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Recent Issues]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/blink-sas/recent-issues-c8aec063af5e?source=rss-1b6c76037763------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c8aec063af5e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[surveillance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Will Partin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 Oct 2017 17:55:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-23T17:56:20.952Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><a href="https://ojs.library.queensu.ca/index.php/surveillance-and-society/issue/view/authority">Surveillance and the Global Turn to Authoritarianism<br></a>Vol 15 No 3/4 (2017)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/870/1*ZEyKG4x8VS3scotWEoQfMA.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is our first ever special “Responsive Issue,” conceived of as something extra to our usual process of publication. We asked for shorter articles, written in a more punchy and accessible style, to cover specific countries which are moving in an authoritarian direction, and/or transnational issues that relate to the nexus of surveillance and authoritarianism. We would like to thank all of the authors and reviewers who rose so quickly to the challenge.</p><p>The cover image is of stencil graffiti spotted in London in 2017. #FreeAhmed refers to Ahmed Mansoor (or Mansour), the Emirati human rights defender currently serving ten years in prison for his views on the authoritarian government of the UAE (see Manu Luksch’s interview with Mansoor which concludes this issue).</p><p>This issue is dedicated to Ahmed Mansoor, to the late Liu Xiaobo and Berta Caceres, and to all those countless dedicated and courageous people who risk their freedom and their lives to oppose authoritarianism and oppression.</p><p>Read <a href="https://ojs.library.queensu.ca/index.php/surveillance-and-society/issue/view/authority">here</a>.</p><h3><a href="https://ojs.library.queensu.ca/index.php/surveillance-and-society/issue/view/Open">Open Issue</a><br>Vol 15 No 2 (2017)</h3><p>We’re delighted to present another packed issue covering a wide range of ground from surveillance theory and critique, through subjectivities and public opinion, to surveillance history. There are are also six book reviews, which are also available in one document <a href="http://ojs.library.queensu.ca/index.php/surveillance-and-society/manager/files/Books_Open2017.pdf">here</a>.</p><h3><a href="https://ojs.library.queensu.ca/index.php/surveillance-and-society/issue/view/Race">Race, Communities, and Informants<br></a>Vol 15 No 1 (2017)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/978/0*d_m_yVIUUaVRzPp4.png" /></figure><p>Welcome to the first issue of 2017, the beginning of our 15th volume, ‘Race, Communities and Informers’, guest-edited by Simone Browne (University of Austin at Texas), Katherine Mckittrick (Queen’s University, Ontario) and Ronak K. Kapadia (University of Illinois at Chicago). Simone Browne, who was recently awarded the Surveillance Studies Network book prize for her work, <em>Dark Matters: On the Surveillance of Blackness</em>, contributes the editorial.</p><p>Speaking of awards, also in this issue, it is also entirely appropriate that we recognise the pioneering achievements of Oscar Gandy, the great African-American scholar of Surveillance Studies, who has spent his career drawing attention to the racial and other inequities of what he called ‘the panoptic sort’. We present a piece based on the speech he gave in response to receiving the 2016 Distinguished Scholar Award of the SSN.</p><p>We also have three more papers in response to our call on ‘Surveillance after Security Intelligence After Snowden’, edited by David Murakami Wood and Steve Wright (<a href="https://ojs.library.queensu.ca/index.php/surveillance-and-society/issue/view/Intelligence">the first part can be found here</a>) and finally, a selection of reviews of recent books in Surveillance Studies (<a href="https://ojs.library.queensu.ca/index.php/surveillance-and-society/manager/files/book_reviews_2017_1.pdf">the reviews can aslo be downloaded as a single file</a>.)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c8aec063af5e" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/blink-sas/recent-issues-c8aec063af5e">Recent Issues</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/blink-sas">blink-sas</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Two Unreleased Interviews with Arteezy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@willpartin/two-unreleased-interviews-with-arteezy-824e719c9a73?source=rss-1b6c76037763------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/824e719c9a73</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vancouver]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[interview]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[esport]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Will Partin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Oct 2017 22:23:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-18T22:24:28.167Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*l1PgYH4flQtO7Gb7Bq8rMA.png" /><figcaption>t w o f i f t h s o f t h e b o y s (image: evil geniuses)</figcaption></figure><p>Back in July, I published my <a href="http://www.rollingstone.com/glixel/features/dota-2s-arteezy-on-the-hunt-for-big-game-at-the-international-w494565">profile</a> of professional <em>Dota 2</em> player Artour “Arteezy” Babaev in <em>Rolling Stone</em>, one of a number of esports profiles I’ve written this year. Because a few months have passed and the terrain of <em>Dota 2</em> has shifted significantly, I want to share the transcriptions of the interviews I did with him during the process of writing that piece.</p><p>This is atypical as far as publishing goes, but I have a few reasons for doing so. One is simply that I think a lot of what Artour has to say is very interesting, though I don’t think he’s always “right” (even about himself!). The fact that I think people will enjoy reading these is justification in and of itself.</p><p>The other — and I plan to write more about this when my crushing workload at school lets up — is that I don’t think a lot of people in esports know how to write profiles well. I’m certainly not an expert yet (give me a few years), but I do think I have more experience with the genre than most writers in esports, especially in <em>Dota 2, </em>meaning I’ve also had more space to be self-reflexive about the process. And one thing writing profiles well entails is asking questions in a particular way, for particular purposes.</p><p>What follows is an interview, but it was never intended to be published <em>as an interview</em>. Rather, it’s data to be mined in order to write a profile, and all the questions reflect that. Many of these questions are not suitable for a traditional Q&amp;A. Some don’t yield interesting answers, and if this had been published <em>as an interview</em>, I would have simply struck them from the record.</p><p>But insofar as I’d like this post to play a double role as both an interesting piece of content and a record of how writers in esports might approach the process of writing a profile, the questions that don’t work out are just as interesting as those that do. With Artour, I often fished for weirdly specific answers, because that’s how you get wonderful telling details about a player, rather than generalities you could swap into a profile of any player.</p><p>So, just as a last bit of framing, there are two interviews here. One was done on May 9th, just before Artour left for Manila Masters. The other was done about a month later, in between Evil Geniuses’ return from Epicenter LAN and their departure for the Mars Dota 2 League. When it’s feasible, I like to do two interview for profiles. The first is wide-ranging, but I try to give special attention to what I think makes a player unique (call it a proto-angle). In the second, based off of their earlier answers, I try to home in on single theme. That’s more or less what happens here, and I encourage other writers to adopt that formula. Few things make me happier than watching the quality of writing about esports rise, so consider this a small contribution to that.</p><p>At Artour’s request, I’ve removed a couple of passages from the transcripts below (nothing salacious, just strategy stuff). I’ve also lightly edited and condensed this text for readability’s sake, so there may be some very slight differences in some of the quotes between this and the version in <em>Rolling Stone</em>. Any typos are my own.</p><p>///</p><p><strong>Tell me about your family.</strong></p><p>My mother is a legal assistant my brother works at a technical insurance person — not sure of his entire position and makes sure things work. My dad works in a pharmacy and owns a pizza shop with his friend, helps him out there.</p><p><strong>I think I remember reading that they immigrated from Turkmenistan?</strong></p><p>Both came from Uzbekistan.</p><p><strong>And how old were you when that happened.</strong></p><p>I think was two years old when they moved here.</p><p><strong>Why did they settle on Canada?</strong></p><p>At the time, Canada was one of the places that promised a good future. I guess their point of view is that they didn’t feel like Uzbek was somewhere to grow up and have a nice future, and so they wanted to move somewhere and they had an idea that Canada was a really good place and a lot of potential to take it from there. So, they selected between Vancouver and somewhere in eastern Canada; not totally sure why they chose, might have been random. “The whole point was for me to go to school and make something of my life. Of course, that didn’t go as planned but it ended up pretty nicely regardless. I’m doing what I love.”</p><p><strong>And you’ve always lived on the west coast whether in Vancouver or San Francisco?</strong></p><p>Yeah. I had an idea about moving to Toronto back a couple of years ago because I wanted to back then I was not sure of where the scene was going to develop and if there were going to be lots of online tournaments, and playing west coast to Europe is rough. But the way the scene is building now, most of the big tournaments are on LAN and for qualifiers we can just boot camp somewhere that’s convenient, so I didn’t have to.</p><p><strong>Have you noticed any chance as a player based on where you are?</strong></p><p>I haven’t notice much of a difference but I’m away from home, I start to feel homesick. Sometimes these boot camps take a train on me and hinder my performance a bit. Not really sure why. It never used to be the base but I guess I haven’t boot camped for longer than a couple of months before. All my friends are in Vancouver, it’s like a nice welcoming feeling and I reset my mind again. That feels important.</p><p><strong>How much <em>Dota 2</em> do you play at home?</strong></p><p>I play a lot usually. When I get home from a long boot camp, I have to stop myself from playing Dota 2 because I don’t want to burn myself out. After I got home from this whole month’s trip to tournaments and boot camps, I tried to stay away from Dota 2 and tried to recharge my batteries. For like five days, all I did was binge watch tv and go outside. I eventually got pretty bored of it and I’m getting back into Dota 2 right now.</p><p>Generally, the schedule we follow is when we leave we have a string of tournaments, then we go home from 2–4 weeks, then we resume our tournaments and the system we have going on.</p><p><strong>Tell me about a typical day with the team in San Francisco.</strong></p><p>When we settle in after the first initial couple of days, we start booking scrims and talking about the game. We wake up 9 to 11 AM, play a pub or two, start scrims in the afternoon, around 1 pm or 2 pm or something like that, then we play two best out of threes. It was hard to find good scrim partners when we were in San Francisco, so we’d usually just play one Bo3. And then after that, we’d play a couple of pubs and most of the time, like most of the time we end up watching tv together. Some people play pubs. That’s a pretty standard say. Pubs, scrims, pubs, and then watching TV together.</p><p><strong>What are you watching now?</strong></p><p><em>Power</em>. We watched like a full season or two together. After the boot camp was over, I just finished the series on my own.</p><p><strong>Do you go out together?</strong></p><p>Not as much. Most of the time in San Francisco, we lived in the house and that would be pretty much it. We went to a hookah bar in Denmark sometimes, sometimes we went to watch movies. I didn’t really go along. I’m not a big fan of movies, I’d much prefer to be close to a PC. Like after finishing a TV show, I can walk a couple of seconds and start playing pubs again.</p><p>I don’t think I really did that much in SF.</p><p><strong>So from your other interviews, you talk about a lifelong desire to be the best. What are some other examples besides Dota 2?</strong></p><p>I think aside from <em>Dota 2</em>, I really only felt interested in sciences. For me, I have to have some sort of natural interest in it. It has to feel nice for me to give it my all, and that’s why <em>Dota 2</em> is what it is to me. At the time, when I was going to school, I didn’t really enjoy school and wanted something I could look forward to. Right now, pretty much the only thing I look forward to is <em>Dota 2</em>. I don’t really have any other aspirations, which I guess could be a good thing but it’s nice to have some sort of thing that you don’t classify as have to do it. That’s one of the downsides some people see about playing Dota 2 full time, that you need some sort of …. Something that you don’t have to use your brain to do. Some sort of hobby, you don’t need to fully invest your mind into it, that you don’t invest everything you have. I’m running low on that though, which is a problem. I need to address it. I don’t really know what to do with all this time I have at home. For the first initial week of coming home, I enjoy it. I’d wake up whenever I want, I have nothing that I have to do, but sometimes, it becomes rather boring. That’s where I wish I had some kind of hobby. I mean, I don’t mind just playing Dota 2, it’s a hobby for me, it’s something I enjoy, it’s also work. But I would say it’s pretty important to have something that you can fully embrace yourself in. I had some casual games I played on the side, it wasn’t fulfilling for me. Like I wanted to play CS casually, but whenever I started playing I could get upset. It wasn’t fun. I would start losing because I felt like I wasn’t playing well, then it became a downward spiral.</p><p><strong>What’s different about Dota 2?</strong></p><p>I guess with Dota 2, it’s something like … I have to accept it. I have to accept that if I suck, it’s something I have to work on. This is what I like to do and I don’t want to be lazy about Dota 2. In terms of other things, I would prefer to be lazy about a game and just enjoy it, but my personality doesn’t fit.</p><p>Like, I also played For Honor a lot during a break. I played in some tournaments and I got second place and losing that tournament was so disappointing for me that after the tournament I wanted to keep playing and become good. And when I wasn’t able to achieve it because I had to work on Dota 2.</p><p><strong>What’s the appeal of of science for you?</strong></p><p>I enjoy in terms of biology, memorizing things and I like understanding things. So, when I understand something, it feels really good to me. Like, I would try to understand why this works this way and when I would do a fest or exam and I’d get it and it makes sense to me, it could give me some joy. It carries on to Dota 2. This is probably one of the reasons I understand a concept in Dota 2. And like, I can apply I and it works and it’s a really nice feeling.</p><p><strong>And is that something you instinctively came to when you started playing <em>Dota 2</em>?</strong></p><p>Yeah, that was one of the major things. I played a lot of Dota 2 when I was younger and then when I got older I started to believe in the things I was doing, then when they worked, it just felt really like … it was supposed to be this way it felt like natural for me.</p><p><strong>What was the turning point?</strong></p><p>MLG Columbus. I would prepare so much for that tournament individually, I’d try to focus on being the best mid player I could be. I didn’t think about how I could perform on mainstage, I’d just prepare myself the best way I could. And the first day obviously didn’t go so well we lost every day. I was pretty depressed at the time, because I was like “am I just not good enough or whatever” but then day two came and I guess it reaffirmed everything for me …. At the time, I was a really cocky kid, I was thinking there’s no way I’m supposed to be losing to these guys. I wanted all of them play. I watched everything they do. I see their patterns. It should be easy for me. Then it became that way excuse I started doing really well. It’s like I talked about before, where I learned some concepts that people didn’t know, like back in the day it was like manipulating the creep wave, and stuff like that, and I would do them in game s and they would work and I would feel on top of the world, like, renewed confidence. And I didn’t feel like I could be beat.</p><p><strong>What motivates you more — losing or winning?</strong></p><p>I hate losing more than I love winning, to be honest.</p><p><strong>Why?</strong></p><p>Ok so… I think whenever I get into these games, first thing, I think you should always play to win, because playing to lose, you’re always going to hinder yourself. You play a bit scared. If you’re just <em>playing </em>because you don’t want to lose, you’re not using everything you have in your arsenal. I think the way that it should be and the way that I think I played at MLG is playing to win, I never thought about the fact that I do this move, I can potentially lose the game. I had full confidence in whatever I did, you just want to be able to trust yourself. And otherwise risky situations; take this hero, or do this play, and yea if it doesn’t work out, you could use your team the game, but you don’t think about that. You want to keep in mind that these moves can win you the game, rather than that they can lose you the game.</p><p><strong>What’s the thing that people get most wrong about you?</strong></p><p>I think people read my stream personality into how I actually play. They’re not really wrong — of course if you see habits in a pub you can assume that they’ll be the same way in matches. Like, in a pub, I might give up really easily, all these habits that carry over to some degree. But It’s always been this way for me in pubs, and back then, I would only play pubs to learn about a certain thing, and back when I was a mid player at MLG, I only played to learn about mid matchups and laning. After like the initial 7 minutes, I’d do whatever I want and didn’t care about the outcome of the game. That’s probably why I lost a lot of games. Like a 55% win rate, and in leagues, I was known in the seven minute god, because after laning I would feed and do random shit. It’s kind of like, I still have that sort of attitude in pubs nowadays, like I’d only play pubs to learn about item builds, to learn about how to farm efficiently, learn the peak of my hero. It carries ab it now, I don’t really throw all of my games, I have some rhythm I like to follow and if the rhythm gets screwed up I sort of start making these very risky plays and losing my team the game sometimes. But with hose experiences you can only learn. It’s worse to lose a match because you didn’t know what to do, rather than lose a pub because you didn’t know what to do.</p><p><strong>You’re in the middle of your career – nowhere near retirement, but no longer a rookie. What keeps you motivated these days?</strong></p><p>I think whenever I have some growth as a player, that’s when I’ll always be motivated. I don’t think that’s changed — I feel like, at this point in my career I don’t think it’s even close to ending. I have a lot of learn and I’m learning very game, and I don’t feel like I’m the absolute best player but I’m one of the best, and that’s a good thing for me because I don’t want to be the best always. I want to feel like I have something to learn, every game I want there to be a new concept I can learn, or a new system I can try as well. But like every patch is alike a new thing for me, basically I’m not close to the end of my career as well. I have a lot more Dota 2 left to be played, and I don’t really think about that kind of stuff to be honest. I prefer to take it one thing at a time.</p><p><strong>What’s an example of a concept you discovered?</strong></p><p>At TI5, one of the things I felt like I was a pioneer in was the early carry rotations. Back then, I was looking at the idea of these strong carries. Back then, I don’t know if carries rotated that frequently, it was very consistent game everyone played. You’d trilane and try to farm of your supports to make rotations toward their safelane or midlane, and you’d do these objective rotations where you’d rotate to get a kill or get a tower. And I tried to find ways to create chaos, to mess up people’s flow. So I’d play heroes like gyrocopter or shadow fiend, times that people would assume I’m jungling, because back then when carries went off the map they assumed they were just farming the jungle. 7 minutes, people would say he’s farming stacks or creeps or ancients. But I looked at that and what I can do to abuse the fact the information he them has of me. The other team would see me go off the map as gyro and assume that I’m farming stacks or farming ancients as gyro. I would tell my support to show in the lane, and they would assume that I’m just farming stacks. They see the support farming in the lane that I was in, they see me be off the map, so I would smoke to their safelane. I’d be a level 7 o6 6. They’d have a weak carry. I was saying that I think <em>Dota 2</em> is all about information shown and information interpreted. It’s about how they assume what you’re doing influences what they’re doing, so I would try to abuse that to the fullest. I would not do things that people would assume I’m doing, then I’d do something else. At the time, it was really easy to make a move like that because no one had ever anyone do that. I would go to the enemy safelane at a random time, and id kill their safe laner as like gyro and then the supports are underleveled they can’t do anything to a Gyro. So I’d make the first play of the game and I’d influence everything heavily. I feel like that was a pretty new at the time. When I did those things and they worked, I felt on top of the world kind of thing.</p><p><strong>So what about mechanical growth? Where does that fit into this?</strong></p><p>As of now, I feel like I’m mechanically even compared to other people. It’s disappointing to me. Like, after this major, one of the things I wanted to improve on, I felt like my mechanics are even. So I think I’ll be learning other things to boost my mechanics more. Ideas are great and they can help you win games, but mechanics are the fundamentals of <em>Dota 2</em> and I’ve always had the upper hand in them. I think this is how naturally it becomes in <em>Dota 2</em>. Everyone starts out to become better, so you need to focus on being better than those people who are getting better, focusing and finding other ways to improve your mechanics.</p><p><strong>If you were going to break up your career into chapters, what would it be like?</strong></p><p>Well, one obviously it was MLG Columbus and the second one is like … I think when I played, I would say that ESL Frankfurt 2015 is one of them. Where like, we were playing against one of the strongest versions of EG at the time and they brought out some new meta stuff at the time, and the only way we could beat them, is to adapt to their new meta style and figure out how to beat it in a short period of time. And I think we did that, manage to beat their new meta stuff. And that point in the career was when we can win TI really easily, remain calm and believe in ourselves.s of course it didn’t end up that way. And I take a lot of blame in that, back in Team Secret, I had a pretty improper balance of ego and faith in my team. My ego was too high and when we started losing I started losing faith in my team and I have to do some pretty cancerous one v five mentality. I think that’s the biggest thing I’ve learned after TI. I find that you need to have a balance of believing in yourself and also believing in your team and the games that you aren’t really able to 1v5, are like, it sounds pretty cancerous the whole concept of 1v5, but that’s what I would think of, the ability of a carry being able to be in a position to win the game if he played well. That’s how I would describe the term 1v5, not that the team is entirely that your team is useless and you’re supposed to 1v5.</p><p><strong>Is that true of back and forth between Evil Geniuses and Team Secret?</strong></p><p>At the time, I felt like the change from me leaving secret after TI5 was like one of the bad changes, and after the initial ban, the first item I left EG, I learned a lot about myself and play carry and learn with different people and play around different people’s strengths. I don’t really regret that one at all. It was pretty healthy for me. But the second time I left, that was big mistake. I would have stayed in secret after ti5, because I think after ti5 I kind of became a new person, and I learned to play more around the team, and I think that third time I left was a pretty big mistake, I was being too spontaneous about it. I didn’t really have a good feeling about it. I didn’t feel like I was being utilized fully, or feel confidence in the idea of going forward. So I kind of reverted to my pre TI5 character ,where I felt like I have to 1v5, it sort of fucked me, and ended up this way. We did poorly at TI and I was pretty ashamed of myself. After TI6 was where I fully learned about myself and what makes being on a team work, what I need to be on a team for success. Im fortunate that it ended up this way with my teammates. I think like after TI6 I felt like I was pretty screwed up; I guess my career, I screwed up two teams and they didn’t … I basically screwed up two teams for no reasons other than myself, and it was pretty selfish of me. To be on a team, to be accepted back, was eye opening to me at the time. I just tried to be after TI6 the same person I was, the 1v5 idea, but the balance between being able to solo carry and letting my teammates carry me when I’m not able to solo carry. I’m still learning a lot about finding the balance, and I think over time I’ll become like stronger.</p><p><strong>Is that the change in mentality that has allowed you to stay with Evil Geniuses for so long?</strong></p><p>It might be. The way I view losses is less like self-centric. Before, I would look at myself, I could have done, I should have been able to 1v5, I shouldn’t have needed to do this, I could have just chilled and stuff, but now I try to find a balance, I could played with this person better, we could have done this move too, help this guy accelerate his game better and I just look for ways that I could have played better that could helps someone else play better.</p><p><strong>When I profiled him, one of the things that LodA talked about is how important is is to want to win with your teammates. You?</strong></p><p>I’m not sure. First and foremost, I always just want to win. Winning with people I like influences it possibly, of course it does, but I guess I never really thought about it that way.</p><p><strong>What is success to you? Is it different than winning?</strong></p><p>I don’t think there’s been a moment in my career where we didn’t win the tournament where I felt like I’d succeeded. I can’t be happy with the outcome … I don’t think it’s ever happened. You need to win and feel happy about it, and then there are times that you win but you personally don’t perform you feel well, and those are disappointing too. Like even if you win you know you could have played better, and the only thing you can do from there is just figure out what you’ve done, what you’ve played better. Maybe there are things you are aren’t seeing, like, individually you might have played poorly, but you made things happened that helped your team win the game that maybe you didn’t want to do, but it helped you win the game. So you gotta be able to recognize the stuff that you did in the game positively and negatively. Yo should be able to make sacrifices in your place that normally you wouldn’t do but for the win that you would.</p><p><strong>Evil Geniuses has a very stable roster. How do y’all work on that as a team?</strong></p><p>Most of our strategies are about like how to use our individual strengths. And gain an advantage. Like, we’re all pretty good players, we’re all strong players, and when you have that you have people that need to sacrifice parts of their game to enable other players’ parts of their games, like it just natural, like not everyone on your team is going to have the optimal game they would have in a pub, 1v5ing, all the resources are on them. Somebody has to sacrifice for someone else, and it’s important to be able to sacrifice but it’s also important to know when you have to sacrifice yourself or make a sacrifice for you. Not every draft is going to be what you wanted it to be, like some drafts the person that you wanted to carry is the person who <em>can’t carry the game based on the draft</em>, like the idea that some games I would have to play a carry like morph and antimage that will carry the game, like the perfect pick. Some games, I’ll play a carry that will carry the majority of the game but won’t win the game itself. And that is like how I view it at least. You have a style and sometimes in the middle of the tournament you have to change your style and figure out what changes in the whole system ,there’s a formula that follows. I feel, if like you can’t achieve this then someone else has to step it up and carry.</p><p><strong>What’s your biggest strength as a player?</strong></p><p>Knowing how to rotate and I’m trying to figure it out, how to say it actually. I think it’s like conceptually I am, like I think the carry role is all about concepts. So when you’re given this hard lane, you have to know what you can do to stay neutral. Let’s say you’re having a hard time as a carry you have to know what you have to do to come back, you have to tell your supports what to do, like, not everybody sees the game the same way so you need to know when to help your team and no just worry about it, to know that the way the game is going for you, you have to trust in your team if you’re having a bad game, I think I does those pretty well. Im able to identify when I have to play with the team and when I have to carry the game 1v5. I think I’m pretty good at that. And I’m confident in myself that if I have to carry on morph or am, or tb, that I can do it. That my team trusts in me to carry the game even after a bad start or a rough game for one of these heroes.</p><p><strong>Do you like practice or playing more?</strong></p><p>It used to be that I hated scrims and I loved pubs; used to be that way back last patch. Like before 7.00, I enjoyed playing pubs a lot more. But now it’s kind of like — I enjoy playing scrims and matches more than I enjoy playing pubs. Pubs for me are very instantaneous right now, like, before, I was able to pick my hero first pick and I wouldn’t care about what the other team has. But a lot of the things that changed in this patch, it’s pretty easy to just lose a game outright if you pick the wrong first hero, like if I wanted to spam TB first pick, I would pick TB first this patch, and then I’d sort of be in an unwinnable game where my lane gets destroyed and like Batrider or Legion-Warlock. And then I have to rely on my supports to get out of the laning phase. Pubs, you want to be able to find a way to win the game solo because that’s the mentality I used to have in pubs. I think in those situations you just have to persist through it, put yourself in a position where if you play really well you can win, and putting yourself in those positions where you think you can lose that you lose instantly and you win them are pretty rewarding in terms of the experience and the knowledge you gain from it.</p><p><strong>Evil Geniuses as corporate team?</strong></p><p>Well I think that I enjoy the idea of being like a ghost. And you just train and no one notices, and just like no one looks at you. I enjoy that a lot. That’s like the type of situation I would like to be in but it’s not like I’m blind to all these cameras and things.</p><p><strong>What’s the appeal of being a ghost?</strong></p><p>I don’t know, It’s just like when I picture myself, I want to be a person who silently grinds and sits on his own in a corner in the room and like just plays all day and after I’m done with my playing session of 12 hours I come out and say what I learned to my team. It doesn’t leave the room kind of things, just like, it’s a silent grind idea I have about myself.</p><p><strong>Does that actually happen?</strong></p><p>Not so much this much in this patch. If I did more grinding and learned more, then we would have placed better at the major. But I have to look forward and accept that it already happened and there’s not much I can do about it, other than do what I have going forward. I don’t blame any of the cameras for the loss, I only look at myself. It doesn’t matter as much, doesn’t matter at all, really it’s just how I envision myself.</p><p><strong>Is that true of Evil Geniuses these days?</strong></p><p>I like that a lot, where you have the underdog effect. You’re just practicing and you qualify or get invited to a LAN, and no one expects you to come out or something . And you just come out and start destroying and your confidence is super high and no one really knows what you’re doing and they can’t identify what it is that you’re doing better than everyone else. I don’t think… I think we play like a medium about of tournaments — we played a lot of online cups, and we played more than a few officials, but it’s pretty important like … the way that you practice in scrims and play in matches is different. When you with scrims, you’re not sure if the reason that you’re winning is that your strat is good or … usually you feel it. In the game or the sri, if you feel that what you’re doing is right, like sometimes you don’t know why it’s right or why it feels so good. It takes that extra time to take that time to figure out why you did what you did or why it worked. When you lose a match or a scrim, you naturally take a lot more energy to learn why you lost or why you felt like you could have won or lost. That’s why I feel like the teams that play like the qualifiers and own in qualifiers to big tournament they learn more about themselves and the other teams because they actually like play … like in a scrim, you assume that people are playing but not to their fullest (that’s how I see scrims), it’s a bit more laid back than matches. When you win matches everyone is trying their best, if you’re playing a qualifier to TI, then everyone wants to win. They’re busting out their best strates and best in visual performances they can, and if you win in that scenario, then you have a lot of confidence in your strats and a lot of confidence in yourself. I think that’s why most of the time when qualifier teams do well at these big tournaments it’s because they faced like the best of what teams have rather than teams who were just doing scrims and not playing officials.</p><p><strong>So you’re at a disadvantage, in a way.</strong></p><p>There is a small disadvantage of course. All we could do is play scrims against teams and the teams we’re playing against are obviously top tier but like we’d scrim against OG, iG, etc. all these top teams that placed really well at majors and every tournament they play in, but if you win, after the game, look at why you won, you’re not positive if what you’re doing is correct or if like you could be confident regardless because you won, but I don’t think it’s very good to look at scrims, like result wise. Like you shouldn’t look at scrims and go “yeah we’re 16–0 we’re so good” you should try to understand why you’re winning and if it is because they’re playing bad and if you played poorly it’s a really good idea. You’re winning games that you’re not normally able to win. That’s what I think scrims should be about. If you win a scrim, it’s fine good job and stuff, but you should try to understand why you won, like what idea you used to help you win the scrim. Like why you won this game in the manner you did.</p><p><strong>Who are some athletes, musicians, and artists you identify with?</strong></p><p>Back in the day, I used to look at like life lessons fro Michael Jordan. How to be like Mike: 21 life lessons from Michael Jordan. I used to read this every day, and it would help me in times that I didn’t feel good or something like that. Like after a loss, I feel like I’d blame myself and I’d look at this and not read it, move forward. This was pre Columbus, post Columbus, really all the way until … I guess I stopped looking at it as much after TI5, like I already have it in my head, like every time I lost I would think about it and I would read it and refresh, why you want to play, why you want to win, and like … just reaffirm yourself really. It’s a pretty good read I think.</p><p><strong>/// Interview 2 ///</strong></p><p><strong>What are you up to in Vancouver?</strong></p><p>Honestly, this is like the cycle I go through every time I come back from a long trip. I usually just sit at home and I don’t do anything. I just embrace the fact that I don’t have any responsibilities, don’t have to wake up for anything. So I sleep in, and I sleep like 13 hours and that lasts for like a week and then I go outside hang out with friends. As for now, mostly just play Dota all day, play CS all day, and sleeping for 12 hours.</p><p><strong>How much do you sleep on tour?</strong></p><p>Six hours a night. For some reason, it’s easiest for me to function in the the afternoon and in the morning when I don’t sleep much. I don’t know why. When I sleep for like nine hours — I don’t know if there’s a word for it, but I feel like I don’t come to life until like 3 hours after I wake up. I feel like I don’t wake up easily. Mornings are rough. Sometimes the matches are at like 10 AM and I don’t want to deal with it.</p><p>I’ve been fortunate in having business class flights, so all I do is I look up any movies that I haven’t watched because every airline has their own set of movies. But this time I was on an airline I hadn’t been on before, so I watched like six different movies. I grown to actually like flying, it’s the only time in my life when I’m not playing Dota 2 and I don’t have anything to do, aside from like breaks. Free time mentally, not thinking about much.</p><p>I think when we added SVG, when he joined our team as a coach, he really helped up play together, like, we all know what we’re doing so it’s way easier to go with the flow. We don’t have to overthink how we’re playing. There’s not much pressure on us because of that we’re in the best condition currently. We can still improve, we haven’t peaked I think.</p><p><strong>Do you think Evil geniuses is the best in terms of absolute skill?</strong></p><p>Well, first, I do think we’re the best. But there’s like four teams that are pretty even. I think it’s one of those things where on any given day when they face each other one can win. Like, VP, Liquid, EG, and Newbee I believe — those four.</p><p><strong>How did y’all celebrate win in Manila?</strong></p><p>What did we do? Oh, finals ended pretty late for us and we got back to the hotel around 11:30 and we were pretty tired because it went to four and we played three games against NP and those were really long games. I dragged into going to the after party, my team wanted to go but so I went but I was super tired. I also had a flight at 6 AM . Phil doesn’t give us a chance to party, man.</p><p><strong>Is by design?</strong></p><p>I think so.</p><p><strong>He’s looking out for y’all. So how y’all deal with the loss in Moscow?</strong></p><p>That was a really sad loss. At least for me, I felt like one of those losses that you know you didn’t get to even show how good you are. That’s how it goes. It felt like we were feeding and not playing how we did the whole tournament. Liquid definitely played very well, they grew and they evolved and I think they were ahead of the meta. It was a hard match for us. I think the only way we could have won that if is game one hadn’t gone so poorly; I think that messed up our thoughts a little bit.</p><p><strong>[I walk Artour through what more or less becomes the “argument” in the published version of the profile].</strong></p><p>I think it’s very accurate in the Dota 2 world right now. Usually the people that figure out these concepts first are the ones who win the tournament. Every tournament I can think of in the past couple of months — for example, I can think of Epicenter, it’s like, the hero or concept I was trying to abuse was the Bristleback and Ancients thing. Liquid found it out first and they mastered it and no one could beat them because you tried to use the concept yourself and you miss fights because it takes a lot of effort. It’s not just that easy to see it and be like ‘yeah we can play this hero too.’ It takes a lot of thought and a lot of time, and it’s not only you on the team as well. You have a lot of thoughts that you have to — a lot of people that have to agree with your thinking on the hero. So another example would be Manila, there was kind of like the growth of Bristle. But basically my point is concepts are like, a new concept will get everyone’s attention, but the problem with Dota 2 players is that most of them are stubborn. I’m also stubborn. So they see a new hero, they see a Venomancer, it will take a long time for people to actually respect it until it wins, and I guess that’s like solving the puzzle for them too. If they see this Bristle win, then they’ll respect it more. And they’ll respect it more, and they’ll actually try to learn it. But in the tournament while it’s in progress, it takes a lot of willpower. It takes a lot of effort for someone to switch and try to learn the hero; that’s what happens, some teams who are winning, they just find something out.</p><p><strong>So the puzzle solving mentality is general thing in <em>Dota 2</em> and not just personal?</strong></p><p>I think people are always looking for stuff — maybe they don’t look for it intentionally. Maybe they just play a pub and they feel like buying an item on this hero and it feels really strong to them and they’re like holy crap this is actually really good, and they give the idea to their team ,and they like it and try it and something is born. I remember how I found out Naga a couple of years ago, at least how I thought that it should be played, I randomed Naga and then I bought radiance and I felt like “holy shit, this is actually really good.” And I guess something was born there too. Of course as time goes on, there are fewer things that are going to be as easy to find or reinvent or discover, but there’s always going to be something. Every patch, there’s always something that’s hidden that’s really strong and people are trying to find it.”</p><p><strong>This was the Sadboys era?</strong></p><p>Yeah.</p><p><strong>When you lose, do you feel outplayed, outsmarted, or both?</strong></p><p>Most of the time, nowadays, when we lose, I guess I feel like play — I don’t want to be cocky, but most of Dota 2 nowadays is ow much you know about the game. Because everyone has gotten a lot more smarter about how they draft and prioritize their picks, and what they’re willing to give you information for about what they’re going to use against you. Like, when you’re picking a Jugg in the early phase of the draft you know it’s going to get countered and the other team is going to pick this or this, like some counter. So you nurse this, as a result of this hero getting countered, you’re going to have to pick something else. Like, people are way smarter than they used to be and that’s really good for the progression of Dota 2.</p><p><strong>How much does your sense of intelligence figure into how you see yourself as a player?</strong></p><p>I don’t know how to say this. I don’t really overthink about things as much, but rather, I go with what I feel. I don’t know how to say it. [Long Pause]. I don’t think intelligence is that important because it’s possible to be just like feeling all of these things, like you could just feel — do this one game of Bristleback and you feel it has potential, then a lot of things come naturally to you. You don’t just have to sit in your chair and look at the page log and try to find this diamond in the rough, you really just have to play a lot of pubs. Most of the things I’ve learned about this game have strictly been from playing the game and playing pubs and playing scrims and playing tournaments. Only rarely did I actually seek to find something out where I’d just look at the heroes, look at every hero that got buffed and I’d look at mechanic changes and figure something out. I’ve only done it a couple of times.</p><p><strong>So why didn’t that balance work out between 2015 and 2016, when you were swapping between Evil Geniuses and Secret?</strong></p><p>I think it has a place. 2015, I think the year it didn’t really workout was 2016. Maybe it was actually related to the fact that I didn’t play that many pubs, not as much as I used to. I only played six pubs a day compared to the 10 or 12 that I used to play in early 2016. But to answer your question, I used to do a lot of individual playing and thinking; I would always just keep on testing things myself and sort of improve it myself. But now, the best part about having a team is that you can share with them too and give it their … every person has their own perspective on things, a support player thinks about the game, mid player thinks about it this way, mid lane, offlane, they all have their own perspective on how to play the game because the way they play is different, every role is different. So when I offer what I think is good to Zai, he’ll tell me from his support player perspective how it is, and then I would give it to Universe because maybe it’s like a safelane hero, how would it be laning vs. this hero? Then I would try to optimize it, think of item builds, and then it’s kind of like a team building exercise in some ways because everyone is participating and growing an idea and evolving it.</p><p>Like, I didn’t used to do that. Back in 2014 and 2015, most of my ideas were individually ironed out — I just played pubs all day and then I figured out what I thought was the best, but maybe if I’d included my team in the process it would have been even better in some ways.</p><p><strong>What convinced you that that was a better way to do things? A collaborative approach, I mean.</strong></p><p>I’m guessing it’s because I grew up more. I used to just thing, I only gave my idea, I see the game this way, and that’s why this — I asked someone about this and it wouldn’t seem that way. To learn people to have a different perspective, even if it’s a negative perspective, at least you’ll understand why they think that way. You’ll try to see, go half way with them. Because not every idea I’ve ever had has been a good idea — it just comes with this process I suppose, when you’re just playing pubs and you’re owning in this specific game, you’ve got to try to this specific game. Is it because they suck ass, they’re throwing, their heroes are bad, your lane went way too well? If it is, if some of those things are true, you can try to manipulate it. In a real game, you can try to meet the needs you have to have success.</p><p><strong>So you learned that in 2015 Secret?</strong></p><p>For some reason, I think this is what I learned after TI6. I think that loss really like opened my eyes a bit on Dota 2 as a team game, not so much individual. Though I started to see it in a different light.</p><p><strong>Ok, so what did you learn during your first time in Secret?</strong></p><p>[Long pause]. That team was really strange when I think about it. It’s like, I don’t think those five players had ever been on a team like that, Secret at the time. It was like, a team that if we scrimmed we would have internal conflicts or get mad at each other, I can’t remember why, but it was just like super hard to scrim for some reason. We’d only play matches every once in a while after DAC, we never scrimmed, we’d just play pubs, and all of us did our individual testing and after, when we went to a tournament and get beat up, we’d talk about what we learned and try to incorporate all of their ideas or some people would try to be selfless and wouldn’t think their ideas of high value, and then we’d just try to basically — everything that we did throughout the whole year before TI5, after DAC, was play pubs and then bring our ideas together and try to put it together and play tournaments. And it worked out for some reason. Not sure why actually. I think we were just better than everyone at the time. I don’t know if I learned too much about it. I guess what I learned is that if you have five good players on one team and people are willing to sacrifice their ideas for the good of the cause to win, maybe that’s the start. At that point, s4, zai, and Kuro didn’t really — I think actually mostly Kuro and Zai didn’t really like push their ideas, they went with the flow. And that kind of helped us a lot because if there are too many voices in a team, it just starts to get chaotic because every one wants to chip in, but for a healthy team I think not everyone has to chip in, or like, feels forced to chip in. Maybe they trust their teammates and don’t need to.</p><p><strong>So what about your second time on Secret?</strong></p><p>That was probably an example of too many voices I guess. I don’t know, I’ve kind of deleted that one from my memory, it was a sad experience for everyone involved. It’s hard for me to think about it; deleted, just gone.</p><p><strong>Why did you move from mid to carry?</strong></p><p>I guess how I had made up my mind was like when I started practicing mid, it was all about the lane. It was like a 1v1 in my mind, and I wanted to win every 1v1 possible. That was all I trained for. Then it became a thing to gank mid all the time and do all this stuff mid, so i started jungling. So I said, ok, if no one wants to one vs. one then I’m just going to play carry mid and jungle. Then as the patches kept coming it became less feasible, to put a carry in jungle, so I just went to carry. It felt more natural; sometimes I even went mid with carries. Like, I went mid with at the time it was like Shadow Fiend. The best part about Shadow Fiend for me, always the best part, is the 1v1 aspect of it, I would get so hype back then — whenever, now actually, whenever I go SF mid and the other team picks a QoP, it’s like a super QoP favored matchup, but I always feel hype because I feel like I can win with SF. It was one of the best things for me, it would give me such a high. LIke, seeing an enemy pick QoP when I have SF, it’s really exciting. I don’t know why I’m getting excited thinking about it right now. That’s like the only mid hero I like playing nowadays; I don’t like playing any other heroes.</p><p><strong>Tell me about your relationship with the different captains you’ve played with.</strong></p><p>That’s a hard one. I think mostly I feel like I’m more utilized when my voice is kind of pretty high, but I felt like it was pretty high rated — I don’t know how to say it, it’s like, my voice was important <em>too, </em>I guess. I guess it was hard for that to happen when I was playing with Puppey and PPD, because they followed their voice as the most important and it’s not a bad thing, it’s just how I function with it. I didn’t feel like it was healthy. And how it is with Cr1t, everybody has a voice — I think it’s fair to say that we’re pretty equal on this team, if they answer we’ll listen. Some people have a little more priority, but generally speaking it’s a pretty fair — if someone has a thought about a certain team’s draft and wants to talk about it, discuss it, and then we’ll reach a conclusion together. And I think it’s pretty cool to happen that way, since everybody is participating, over two people giving their opinions and the rest not having a chance. I think that’s probably the best way to do it. And also the coach helps too; we get his opinion, like everybody can understand each other’s opinions, and sometimes agree with it, but when people disagree it’s actually really like really healthy too because people can discuss their thoughts. It’s always good to have disagreements as long as they get concluded. You want to know why the person thinks the way they think about something, the person wants to know why you think about something. It’s really nice I feel to have someone’s opinion and then discuss it.</p><p><strong>And what about with EternalEnVy?</strong></p><p>It kind of fell out after TI6, but it’s kind of rebuilding now I think. It’s just a sad time and everybody needed time. I think right now we’re pretty ok.</p><p><strong>I’m guessing it’s hard to talk about game when you’re not on the same team.</strong></p><p>Yeah, thats kind of the problem. That’s kind of why we grew apart, because we haven’t been on a team together and there’s not much you can talk about besides the game nowadays. We still fiend it up, but even that — we both grew up and we don’t fiend that much, and we don’t really talk about Dota 2 at all. Although I consider him a friend we don’t talk that much.</p><p><strong>I heard that you listen to one song only during tournaments?</strong></p><p>Yeah, that’s true. I don’t know. I even do it when I’m not playing tournaments; I find this one song and if there’s a tournament coming, I’ll spam that song through the tournament. It’s weird, I can recall — let’s say I won a tournament and I can recall the song I won the tournament too. And I can recall the times that I lost too, and I would never listen to the song again after a loss. Like, I remember at Summit 2, it was probably the most iconic loss for me. A 3–2 against Cloud9 — I think it was Summit. It went the whole five games and they were pretty long games, the last one was a really long game and I just had this one song on the whole time.</p><p><strong>So what are some of the songs?</strong></p><p>Ok, I can remember… I know the artist but I’m trying to find the song name. The song that I lost to was Gold Gone Girls (Magnify Metric?) I had that song on repeat for like five hours. Frankfurt Major, the song was Wiz Khalifa, got me some more. I repeated that the whole time. Shanghai major it was … I can’t remember that one unfortunately. Fuck. Manila Masters, I listened to a German song that’s called Die Schlange. The unfortunate part is when I lose the tournament I can’t listen to it anymore. <strong>[Note: I’m not linking these busted tracks because they fucking suck].</strong></p><p>Now tournaments aren’t always letting us listen to music. Like, Epicenter — I wasn’t able to listen to music. I’ll bet that’s why we lost. On the low key.</p><p><strong>So what kind of team preparation is Evil Geniuses doing for TI? And what about your individual preparation?</strong></p><p>As of right now, I’m leaving on the 25th to bootcamp in San Francisco for MDL, and I believe after MDL, we’re going to San Francisco. And like officially begin bootcamp, although there’s lots of preparation for TI. The thing about MDL is — not sure we’re going to try out absolute hardest, we might do so some clowny stuff like VP did for summit. We’ll find that out soon. It’s not that good to really tryhard, although it’s nice to win a LAN or to place well at a LAN before TI. In the long run though it won’t help you as much; I feel like we already have a lot of experience in finals and double elimination tournaments and in general tournament experience that it’s fine for us to lose this tournament as long as we learn something from it. So if we lost MDL, I feel like it actually is beneficial for us, more beneficial than winning it. Like, if we lost to something, it’s probably losing to a cool idea or a cool concept that we can learn from. So I always look at it positively before TI. I remember TI6, before TI6 we lost to NaVi and they were doing some pretty cool stuff and we learned a lot from it. Of course it didn’t end up working out for us, but that’s just how it goes sometimes. Then we bootcamp for TI, and the we get it.</p><p>I’m going to keep playing pubs, keep those going as much as I can. I officially quit CS:GO yesterday, after I got destroyed. I got like MGE in like 150 hours or something, but I played against the second highest rank of teams, and i got destroyed and I said, OK, I’m never going to be good at this game, I’m never going to play it again. And now I’m giving my attention fully to Dota 2. I played yesterday for 12 hours straight, probably going to do the same today. I’m just going to keep playing. I imagine there’s going to be a patch again and I really doubt that they wouldn’t touch Birstleback again. I think they’re going to nerf a couple of things. It might be after qualifiers? I think. Probably not before.</p><p>I’m going to keep playing pubs, keep those going as much as I can. I officially quit CS:GO yesterday, after I got destroyed. I got like MGE in like 150 hours or something, but I played against the second highest rank of teams, and i got destroyed and I said, OK, I’m never going to be good at this game, I’m never going to play it again. And now I’m giving my attention fully to Dota 2. I played yesterday for 12 hours straight, probably going to do the same today</p><p>///</p><p>Thanks for reading. If you’d like to follow me on Twitter, I’m @<a href="https://twitter.com/william_partin">william_partin</a>, where I tweet about esports, graduate school, and socialism. If you have questions, my DMs are always open, and I love talking to aspiring writers.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=824e719c9a73" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>