<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jenny H Winfield on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jenny H Winfield on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@winnyltd?source=rss-942dfddf96fc------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 08:42:36 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@winnyltd/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How can we make quantitative research more trauma-informed?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@winnyltd/how-can-we-make-quantitative-research-more-trauma-informed-29ab48f3b6b9?source=rss-942dfddf96fc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/29ab48f3b6b9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-informed-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[surveys]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quant]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny H Winfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 31 Jul 2024 08:01:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-06T06:43:38.277Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How Chayn designed a survey about abuse that over 50k people responded to</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pWf5HmZVBz5GyLKyxWbUFQ.png" /><figcaption>An illustration of a woman smiling, sitting at her laptop</figcaption></figure><p>Last year, as part of the ongoing work <a href="http://www.chayn.org/">Chayn</a> are doing to deepen our knowledge about technology-facilitated abuse, we ran a major survey to hear from survivors around the world. We wanted to gather insights about the degree to which people using online dating apps had experienced tech abuse <strong>— </strong>and we worked with our partner Bumble Inc., to reach out to them.</p><p>What is tech abuse? It could look like old-fashioned harassment and stalking but delivered via digital means, such as on WhatsApp, email or social media. It could be abuse that was inherently digital, such as doxxing (personal info being shared online without the person’s consent), sharing of intimate images online without consent, and <a href="https://www.internetmatters.org/resources/what-is-a-deepfake/">deepfakes</a> (creating and sharing images and videos that manipulate a person’s likeness using AI to make them appear to be saying/doing things that they never did). Ultimately, being an organisation that offers support at the intersection of technology and abuse, Chayn wanted to identify how we can do more for survivors in this space.</p><p>The specific insights from that survey will hopefully come out soon, but for now I’d like to share some more process-related tips about running a large quantitative (quant) study in a trauma-informed way. Researchers don’t always take the same amount of care when we ask questions of someone in a survey, as we would when we talk with them. I have been thinking a lot about why, and I think we can do better. I hope this piece will help to change that.</p><p>If you’d like to learn more about our approach to trauma-informed design, check out Chayn’s user research <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/tagged/user-research">blogs</a>, our <a href="https://www.notion.so/chayn/How-we-practice-trauma-informed-design-at-Chayn-1-Feb-2024-6f5211828e4a4a1db9735fe371febb79#69014a0a77ce478694e7d1d9b6226353">free public workshops</a> and <a href="https://assets.website-files.com/60fdc9111506063bb9fe8e49/64b081438e3221d7ffc92b12_Trauma-informed%20design_%20the%20whitepaper%20by%20Chayn.pdf">our white paper.</a></p><h3>1. Consider informed consent as carefully as you would with qualitative research</h3><p>Often when it comes to quant research, researchers are under pressure to get a large number of responses. There’s an assumption that the more data you have, the more reliable the results (and the more people will take your insights seriously). One way that researchers try to achieve that high completion rate is to reduce the amount of time that the survey takes to complete. The hope is that people get all the way through questions before they get distracted, bored or annoyed.</p><p>So to bring this overall time down, we review how crucial each question is, and we might make the case for removing some. I’ve also seen researchers limit the amount of up-front information given, so that respondents can quickly get to the main survey questions. But I would caution against doing this, if the focus of your survey means that you’ll touch on trauma.</p><p>That’s because in quant research, the introductory information is where you’ll be setting respondents up for informed consent.</p><p>In our survey, we shared a content warning about what the survey questions entailed, including the fact that we would be asking respondents about abuse. The wording we used was:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4GBhF9XdOE2BIKQgy8er8Q.png" /><figcaption>ALT: Within this survey, there are questions focused on the topics of sexual abuse, assault or harassment. We ask about the experiences that people using the Bumble app may have had of these things. Answering is entirely voluntary, anonymous and we encourage you to only share what you are comfortable to share with us.</figcaption></figure><p>When the results started to pour in, Typeform warned me that we had a 10% drop off when people read that text. I really welcomed it.</p><h4>Drop off is considered the enemy in surveys. It’s dreaded. But in this recent case, I was very happy to see it. And, we still had 56,649 people respond (helped along by Bumble’s massive reach).</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*J0PkRYUKwgb9NlxVpahwLA.png" /><figcaption>ALT: A slide from our results deck, which highlights the fact that we had a 10% drop off when we gave a content warning — which is a good thing.</figcaption></figure><p>I’d recommend that you do everything you can to ensure that people know what they’re getting into when completing a quant survey about any topic, but especially if it’s going to ask highly sensitive questions or touch on trauma. The goal is not to have respondents race to the end, it’s to have them take part in an informed and empowered way.</p><p>If you think that sharing information may cause people to drop off, then don’t conceal this information — share it upfront. Yes, you may achieve fewer responses, have to leave your survey open for longer, or think about incentivising it differently. But remember, if someone starts your survey and then begins to feel unsafe and quits, you will have an incomplete response anyway. Sharing upfront and inviting informed consent means you can go some way to avoid causing harm with your survey. You can also build trust in this moment, by sharing your approach to how data will be stored, anonymised, and who will have access to it.</p><p>In trauma-informed quant research, we should always be empowering respondents to decline answering questions, and invite them to stop the survey completely at any time if they want to. Having a consent check in mid way through is nice, as well as having section headers which explain which questions are coming next.</p><p>We talk more about how we approach informed consent for qualitative (qual) research in our trauma-informed user research blog series — particularly in the pieces on <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/keeping-survivors-safe-during-ux-research-eb20c1ee1f04">Safety</a>, <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/sharing-power-with-survivors-in-ux-research-e984c250fcb7">Agency and Power Sharing</a>.</p><h3><strong>2. </strong>Tell respondents why you’re asking those sensitive questions</h3><p>So often in quant surveys I see people launching into highly sensitive questions without enough care and consideration for how these will impact the way the respondent feels. I even see surveys about trauma being labelled as ‘exciting’, which just feels so off.</p><p>Considering that so many of us work in UX, we could be much more thoughtful about the user experience of completing our surveys.</p><p>Designing your questions and your copy with care is really central to a trauma-informed approach. Are we asking questions with the context that reveals why we want to know those answers? Are we transparently sharing where this data will go, how it will be used, what all of this is for?</p><p>Sharing the reason for your questions can help respondents to see a bit about who you are, and it’s another opportunity to build trust. Since we are not there in person to answer questions that a respondent might have as they go, we can try to anticipate questions and provide good answers throughout.</p><p>In the example below from our survey, you can see that we explained why we were asking about gender identity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4zdifgh5LO0W6BPoT3QTrQ.png" /><figcaption>A screenshot from a survey question that asks ‘Please select one or more options that reflect your gender identity’, with the description underneath ‘We’re asking this to better understand how our users identify, with a view to designing even more inclusive and gender affirming resources. You can select ‘prefer not to answer’</figcaption></figure><h4>We gave the description of why we are asking about gender, because it needs saying. Often people who have been marginalised based on their gender have experienced disproportional violence, and have also been excluded from support services based on their identity. What we are doing at Chayn is the opposite — we’re asking in an effort to <em>include them and center </em>their needs.</h4><p>We should be able to clearly justify each question in a survey — if we can’t do this in a way that would make total sense for a respondent, then we should not be including the question. This goes for all quant research but especially trauma-informed quant.</p><p>If you can’t think of a reason for a question that you’d be happy to share with a respondent, then don’t ask it.</p><h3>3. For multi-language surveys, work with a localisation team who understand trauma</h3><p>The survey work I’m talking about in this piece was a collaborative effort between a team of many people within Chayn and Bumble. We launched our tech abuse survey in English, French, German, Spanish and Portuguese, and this meant that we received responses from people in 87 countries.</p><p>Our approach to the project was to build each of the surveys as a distinct piece of work, led by either a staff member or volunteer from within Chayn. This meant that we worked with 5 individuals (plus additional proofreaders) who speak each of the respective languages natively and who, crucially, understand gender based violence.</p><p>In short, we did not design the survey in English and outsource it to be translated by another organisation or individual freelancers who were disjointed from our mission. We knew that to create a trauma-informed survey experience in multiple languages, this would not work.</p><p>Straight translations are often inaccurate, miss context and sound clunky. The last thing we wanted survivors to think when answering our survey, was that Chayn as an organisation could not be bothered to get the content accurate for their language — it would create a feeling of being unseen, and unimportant. This is where our trauma informed principle of accountability helped to guide us.</p><p>There were many words and phrases that we discussed as a team in the design phase of the survey. There were descriptions of abuse that just didn’t make sense in all languages. Some words are unknown in one language but not in another, or there wasn’t a literal translation — for example ‘Gaslighting’. With this one, we discussed that Gaslighting as an experience does exist across multiple cultures, even if there isn’t a specific name for it, so we used the English word and gave the term some extra description in the non English surveys.</p><p>We discussed terms that are gendered in languages such as Spanish and French, but not in English, such as “abuser” or “agresor”. These required a conversation between translators, to explore how we could try to keep terms gender neutral. We decided as a first option to re-phrase the description in a way that implied a neutral form (so, ‘the person who…’).</p><p>One of the big challenges was balancing the fact that we were aiming for a single cohesive data set at the end of the project to make sense of, with allowing for enough nuance in the language for the survey to feel right locally. We wanted to honour the needs of survivors in different countries and languages while creating results that could be compared to each other fairly easily.</p><h4>Working with a team of people who share Chayn’s mission and really understood the purpose of the work, as well as the regional and cultural nuances of abuse, was vital. It helped us to succeed in hearing from so many survivors in a sensitive but structured way.</h4><p>I was so lucky to work with and learn from <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/pazromero/">Paz Romero</a> on this translation and localisation piece.</p><h3>4. Don’t over-probe just because you can</h3><p>Quant research has this strange aura of being more detached and mechanical than qual which can persuade us, on our less caring days, to ask for more than what’s reasonable. When we’ve finished asking the core questions in our survey, we might be tempted to start asking some broader questions, just out of interest. Or, we might ask multiple questions that needlessly delve into painful experiences. This is extractive, and harmful.</p><p>Of course, in qual we can also be guilty of over-probing, but there are usually signs of participant discomfort which can act as a deterrent. With quant, we don’t see or hear these signals.</p><p>I’ve noticed this over-probing a lot with surveys about women’s health. Do you need to know all of my specific conditions, or are you mainly interested in whether I am managing multiple medications? If it’s the latter, just ask about that, and share why it’s relevant. Do you need to know how happy/unhappy I am generally with my doctor’s level of care, or are you interested in whether I’d accept some level of care from an automated service? If it’s the latter, just ask about that and share why it’s relevant.</p><h4>Every time we probe more, we raise the potential to cause a harmful memory to resurface. We should ask ourselves, do we really need to know this?</h4><p>In our survey we could easily have asked a question about how many times a respondent had experienced sexual abuse or assault, in total in their life, or how much their experiences had affected their overall confidence, just because it’s interesting. I found myself drafting a question like this:</p><p><em>Thinking about the instances of abuse that you’ve experienced, how have they affected your overall feelings of confidence?</em></p><p>But, we knew that answering these kinds of questions was likely to be very painful, and there was no real need for us ask them. Instead, we thought about what we were really trying to learn about confidence. We decided that it was whether A) survivors felt confident to challenge perpetrators online who were making them feel uncomfortable, and B) whether they would appreciate more support in building this confidence. This information is much more specific, relevant to our mission and actionable by our team, so we asked those questions instead.</p><h4>We should limit the number of questions we ask about sensitive topics, because each one costs something for the participant to answer. We should be careful not to add in broad questions about the impact on someone’s life, or very detailed questions about trauma, if we don’t really need that data.</h4><h3>5. End on a helpful, hopeful note</h3><p>Think about how your last few questions will feel for the participant to answer. If you’ve covered some difficult areas, could the questions now ease into a lighter topic or tone? At Chayn we often ask questions such as ‘What makes you feel hopeful?’ and ‘What kind of support would you like to explore in the future?’ at the end of our survivor surveys. Think about the emotional arc of the survey and the experience you’re hoping to create.</p><h4>On your end screen, always thank the participant warmly for their contribution, acknowledging (as you hopefully did at the start) that sharing is not always easy, but that you’ll do your best to make it worth it — with whatever you’re designing or improving.</h4><p>If you can, offer good resources for them to turn to at the end. Maybe it’s those that your organisation provides, or maybe you take the time to research, vet and signpost to some relevant ones. Don’t leave someone without a caring ending, when they may be feeling quite vulnerable and exposed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Lb_zHLfcMgyxL7P_U0M06A.png" /><figcaption>A screenshot from the end of our survey where we directed people to further resources and thanked them for taking part. We said ‘Your responses will help us provide relevant content and safety support for poeple who have traumatic online dating experiences’</figcaption></figure><h3>6. In your analysis phase, be mindful of secondary trauma</h3><p>Often when we talk about vicarious trauma as user researchers, we zone in on the risks posed by qualitative work; the sessions where we sit down with someone to hear their story. We mentally prepare for hours of chatting and rich conversations veering in directions we need to stay steady for. We think about our resilience (I personally try to sleep a lot during qualitative research weeks, and remove potential stressors such as working away from home). We schedule breaks. We buddy up for emotional support after a particularly tough session.</p><p>But I don’t think we talk about vicarious trauma often enough with quant research, and our experience of analysing data about trauma. To me, data analysis on the topic of abuse feels like it poses a very high risk for secondary trauma in researchers.</p><p>Sitting alone and silently scrolling through tens of thousands of data points, all with a person and a story behind them of abuse, can be horrifying. The potential for this to activate our own traumas, if we are someone who has experienced anything akin to what we’re reading, is very strong.</p><p>The sheer scale of the abuse, and reading open ended responses with people asking for help, can feel overwhelming. When I first started working at Chayn, I really appreciated how they named this.</p><h4>Chayn said, there’s potential for you to feel secondary trauma just from doing desk research or reviewing data. In fact, when you’re doing any task related to your job.</h4><p>It helped me to bring this up when I was briefing our freelance data analyst for this work. I asked her to specifically keep an eye out for the signs of vicarious trauma and to take her time with the analysis. This is an excerpt from the brief I wrote for her:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EjSI6OhwI7Sw-iWDzu5SkA.png" /><figcaption>A screenshot of the briefing that I wrote for our freelance data analyst. It outlines that this work may be upsetting, as well as some options for support, including group and individual therapy sessions</figcaption></figure><p>We must take care of ourselves and each other while navigating this work. Embedding our processes with more of a relational approach (vs an extractive mindset) should normalise the tendency to thoughtfully consider our respondents’ feelings too. We can almost always do more to design a positive experience of taking part in a research project.</p><p>Overall, it’s clear to see how the trauma-informed design space is gathering pace, and that the role of UX researchers is critical within that. So many of us are becoming more aware of the steps we can be taking to practice safe-enough qualitative work around traumatic topics. I’m excited to see more critical conversation around how we see quantitative research fitting in to this overall picture. We will be doing more writing soon about trauma-informed quant — given that survey tools are so heavily relied on in our sector, and data carries so much power, it’s a topic that deserves a lot more thinking and care.</p><h4>Our 6 tips for doing trauma-informed quant research are:</h4><ul><li>Set up informed consent, just as you would in qual</li><li>For sensitive questions, offer the context for why you’re asking</li><li>Don’t over-probe, just because you can</li><li>Work with a localisation partner who understands the topic</li><li>End surveys on a helpful, hopeful note</li><li>Be mindful of vicarious trauma in your data analysis phase</li></ul><p>What did we miss?</p><p>Get in touch with jenny@chayn.co if you’d like to talk more about trauma informed quantitative research.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=29ab48f3b6b9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unlearning my way to a Head of Research role]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@winnyltd/unlearning-my-way-to-a-head-of-research-role-92126cbbb85a?source=rss-942dfddf96fc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/92126cbbb85a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[user-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminist-tech]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny H Winfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 Jan 2024 10:12:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-12T09:57:40.352Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UdYkldL3ma73LJgsDFA6mg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A person diving into the sea, feet poking out, with mountains in the distance. Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@07lista?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Amy Lister</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/person-in-blue-water-during-daytime-Gck455DlpPI?utm_content=creditCopyText&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_source=unsplash">Unsplash</a>. .</figcaption></figure><p>As I transition into my new role as Head of Research at Chayn, I’ve been reflecting on four major shifts in my research practice over the past few years.</p><p><strong>The shifts are:</strong></p><ol><li><strong>The purpose of research – From profit seeking to movement building</strong></li><li><strong>My ways of knowing – From ‘hot takes’ to slower, somatic sensing</strong></li><li><strong>My mindset – From extractive to impact-driven</strong></li><li><strong>My engagement with topics – From shallow dips to deeper dive</strong></li></ol><p>I’ve been professionally working now for 16 years and in that time I’ve explored a range of different research and design roles. I’ve been a brand strategist, a market researcher, a trends reporter, a multi-disciplinary design researcher, and a UX researcher. Now I’m practicing trauma-informed research.</p><p>For the past 7 years, I’ve primarily freelanced as a researcher in design agencies, tech firms and non profits, while honing a sensitive research practice. I’ve sought out projects on socially taboo issues (think menopause, or sexual dysfunction) and designed services for people who have experienced traumas such as incarceration, suicide bereavement, and opioid addiction. Since November 2021, I have also been leading User Research at <a href="https://www.chayn.co/">Chayn</a>, part time. Chayn is a global, feminist non-profit organisation providing resources and support for survivors of gender-based violence (GBV).</p><p>Sitting at home (since WFH became the norm), and working across the design, tech and non-profit sectors, often at the same time, I’ve felt my way around the norms and expectations of being a researcher in each. Chayn exists fairly uniquely as a blend of all three, being a non-profit that is both design-led AND tech-first. This vantage point has helped me to identify the mindsets and methods that tend to lead to good quality research outcomes wherever you are, and those which are inappropriate and even harmful if applied in the wrong context.</p><p>In lots of ways I’ve started from scratch over the last couple of years, and it’s been as much about unlearning as learning. As I move into a research leadership role at Chayn, I wanted to share four transformational shifts in the way I approach research that have helped me to get here.</p><h3>1. A shift in the purpose of research: From crafting insight for commercial gain, to crafting insight to help build a movement</h3><p>While working as a research lead in design and innovation consulting for five-plus years (mainly at IDEO but at other firms too), private sector clients were often focused on having us define ‘the future of’ their industry. Projects required us to explore and prototype what say, travelling for business, driving a car, shopping for home furnishings or cooking for your family might look like in 10 years’ time. Then, as a design team, we would go on to define the role that our client could ‘uniquely’ play in that imagined future.</p><p>The research insights gleaned from this kind of design exploration were a big part of the intellectual property that clients paid us for, and ultimately owned. Insights were to be protected and kept a secret, lest any other organisation benefit from them — and have an equally ‘big idea’. Insights were expensive to craft, treated as a competitive asset, and they were bought and sold as such.</p><p>Now that I work for a non-profit (<a href="http://www.chayn.co/">Chayn</a>), it’s been inspiring for me to see that insights are generated and shared not for commercial advantage but to advance a community towards their mission. For us, that means the community of people working to end gender-based violence.</p><p>Chayn shares insights generously and openly because our sector doesn’t have the funding to justify having many organisations all doing duplicate work, let alone doing it in secret. We also share insights because our feminist mission is to build a movement to end gender-based violence, something that can’t be achieved by one organisation alone. The move from generating insights for competitive advantage to sharing them generously for movement building was a major mindset shift for me.</p><p>That said, early on in my role at Chayn it was quite uncomfortable for me to learn that I would be expected to share my work publicly as part of this culture. Sharing forced me to explore some less-than-welcome feelings about being ‘seen’ and having my work be viewed as imperfect. It helped me to see how an organisation that expects you to share publicly, will also need to have a supportive culture rather than a judgmental one.</p><p>For me, sharing work openly has shifted from being something to fear (and which was not expected of me anyway) to being a contribution that I seek to make.</p><h3>2. A shift in my ways of knowing: from ‘hot takes’ to slower, somatic sensing</h3><p>In my work for agencies and corporate companies, particularly in tech start-and-scale ups, colleagues have made it plain that my key value lies in my ability to turn around strong research insights, fast.</p><p>In tech orgs in particular, it feels there’s an obsession with conducting research at speed — because, <em>why would you do anything slowly?</em> This means that my immediate ‘hot take’ on an interview or issue is all that I’ll have a chance to prepare for a team, and usually this is seen as good enough to begin designing with. It’s easy to start taking pleasure in delivering ‘good enough’ insight at high pace and I have felt strongly incentivised to do so — it’s directly connected to company growth goals.</p><p>In design and strategy firms around 10 years ago, I noticed that the already relentless pace of consulting projects took on a new dimension when, inspired by tech giants such as Google, we also started to run projects as ‘sprints’. These were projects lasting just one week, which took many shortcuts to developing problem-solving ideas. This pattern of working meant squeezing an entire research window into one day, and made a researcher’s ability to produce a ‘hot take’ on an issue even more valuable. But no one (me included) seemed to be asking the question<em>‘who is suffering when researchers and designers are cutting corners?</em>’.</p><p>‘Hot takes’ encourage bias and stereotyping, leading to things like badly conceived user needs and uninspiring personas. When your culture prioritises speed, it also deprioritises the critical development and interrogation of your learnings.</p><p>Hot takes in design and tech are about using the brain — and only the brain — to take in what a user has said, think fast about the human ‘why’ behind it, and define the insight through smart, snappy words. Whatever that insight is, it has to fit onto a post-it in order not to lose your team’s attention. Reflecting now, it is all so cerebral. It is also highly individualistic, albeit under the guise of collaborative working.</p><p>One thing that I learned very early on at Chayn was that if I interviewed survivors of sexual violence and came back to my team with a round of speedily formed insights (aka my ‘hot takes’), I would feel a prickle of unease in the (virtual) room.</p><p>Rather than delighting in my speed, colleagues would rightly question how I’d got to those conclusions and whether they were trustworthy or biased. It just seemed too fast, and too much about <strong>my take</strong> on the issue, rather than a reflection of the issue that the community might see themselves in. The key difference here is that in design agencies and tech companies, I’ve noticed that stakeholders are rarely the communities being designed for — whereas in Chayn, we are — so my colleagues feel rightly entitled to challenge research learnings as they’re being formed.</p><p>Something that KA McKercher talks excellently about in their book ‘<a href="https://www.beyondstickynotes.com/tellmemore">Beyond Sticky Notes</a>’ is that in design consulting, we can value ‘professionalism’ too highly, and tend to prefer the way brains compute over the way bodies sense and know. Often, the culture of designing at speed and the tools used to communicate ideas quickly — e.g., sticky notes — are also incredibly excluding. KA says:</p><p><em>“Relying heavily on sticky notes privileges those who can think quickly, are highly literate and literary and are well versed in thinking in headlines. Anyone who can’t do that is generally excluded and left bewildered by the pace of commercial design methods.”</em></p><p>In those uneasy virtual rooms at Chayn, I was warmly encouraged to slow down, and explore quite confronting ideas. Why did I feel the need to work so fast? Was the insight I’d put forward a bit of a leap from what the quotes said? Did it feel too ‘Global North’? (In truth, I’d never belonged to a team diverse enough for anyone to entertain this global north question, let alone ask it). In my experience outside of Chayn, there has also been little focus until recently on considering the neurodiversity of team members or service users, and different ways of learning.</p><p>Now, I’m much less likely to associate speed with feeling good about my work. In research interviews, I will make a point of sensing how the energy feels, and this helps me to stay more in tune with survivors. Doing this, I feel more able to say things like<em> “I can sense a dip of energy, is there something that’s not sitting right here? Would you like to take a break or change topics?”.</em> I think that this leads to better quality research outcomes. If I’m developing research insights and they don’t feel right to me, in my brain or my body, I am more confident to slow down, review and identify where I might be making a jump. The risk of implementing a hastily conceived insight into our design work is too big.</p><p>I have never had more conversations about pace than I have at Chayn. As colleagues, we know that if our bodies feel reactive or on high alert all the time, and if we are rushing our work, then that means work isn’t working for us. Somatic practices are important to us; at the start of every company-wide meeting we do a breathing exercise or stretch all together. This not only helps to calm our nervous systems as we navigate traumatic content, but it sends a clear message to us individually that it’s part of our work to be focusing on our bodies and honouring what they know. Normalising somatic sensing (alongside cerebral learning) is something I’ll be more confident to do, and try to promote when working with others as I step up.</p><h3>3. A shift in my mindset: from extractive to impact-driven practice</h3><p>Ever been asked to ‘mine’ a resource or group of people for insight? Me too.</p><p>The hustle and grind culture in the consulting, tech and agency worlds creates an attitude to research (and research participants) that could be summed up as: <em>Get in, get your insight, get out, next up.</em></p><p>That’s a pretty extractive mindset, and is problematic when you’re working with communities who have already had their resources heavily and historically extracted. And it’s not just material, but spiritual and non-tangible resources such as attention, energy, time, ideas that are further taken from people when they engage with innovation projects.</p><p>Community-led design, relational design and co-design practices are mindful of this, and make extra effort not to see people’s time, expertise and ideas as free for the taking, or even commodities to buy. These practices are more focused on defining what kind of positive impact a collaboration could realistically result in, before fairly assessing what kinds of skills, support and ideas can be shared. Designers spend serious time considering what (if anything) it is essential to ask people for support with — especially those who are already underserved and/or traumatised.</p><p>Working for an organisation that seeks to drive impact rather than revenue, my user research mindset has moved from: ‘<em>What knowledge can I gather from people in order to build profit?’</em> to <em>‘What can we learn with people to support them in their healing journey</em>?’</p><p>Measuring success is much harder in an organisation like Chayn. In for-profit companies, success usually boils down to growth. In a feminist tech org like Chayn, measuring success means understanding healing — something that ebbs and flows, has set-backs and growth spurts. It is wholly un-linear, and so it resists boiling down. As our founder Hera Hussain noted when she <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/trauma-informed-design-understanding-trauma-and-healing-f289d281495c">wrote about our approach</a> in 2021: <em>“Where there is trauma, there is room for healing — but the route to heal will look different for everyone.”</em></p><p>At Chayn, the way we create insights from raw research material also challenges the mindset of extraction. In design and tech firms that I’ve worked in, the insight itself is <em>designed</em> to be reductive. Learnings are crunched down to their smallest possible form whilst holding the most meaning per ‘bite’. Fewer insights are better for stakeholders with short attention spans, while user stories are selected, chopped into slides and used to make a case for the right business decision.</p><p>At Chayn we resist the idea of crunching down research stories about people until they fit into neat patterns. I care deeply about clear and directional research insights, but I am now more careful not to flatten survivor stories to try and make them fit so tightly into insight themes. We’re more pluralistic in our search for insight.</p><blockquote>Just last week, we learned that survivors have concepts of ‘expertise’ that are very pluralistic. They understand ‘an expert’ to mean many things — even things that are contradictory. To some survivors, an expert means someone who has lived experience of abuse, to others it is someone who has professional therapist qualifications. To some it’s simply someone who identifies as a woman, while for others it’s a person who campaigns on the issue of GBV. This kind of learning gives rise to particularly hard design challenges; how do we clearly communicate our expertise, when it means so many things to survivors? Instead of forcing the analysis, we will make space as a team to discuss that reality and find a way forward.</blockquote><h3>4. A shift in my focus: From shallow dips to deeper dive engagement in topics</h3><p>This is where I’ve probably done the most unlearning.</p><p>When I first started supporting clients with highly sensitive research projects, I felt that I could just hop in and out of projects and do a good job. Often times I was supporting charity organisations pro-bono, in order to deepen my exposure to more challenging research topics — so there was a financial incentive to treating these projects as shallow dives; I needed to dip into other, higher paid work to support myself at the same time, often with tech orgs.</p><p>Design Thinking implies you do not need to be an expert in <em>anything</em> except following the Design Thinking methodology in order to do great work. So in my mind, I was just bringing this mentality to lots more meaningful projects.</p><p>But Chayn has helped me to see that you cannot do a ‘good job’ of challenging gender-based violence by seeing it as another topic to roll up your sleeves and apply Design Thinking to. And as I’ve come to learn, the Design Thinking methodology does not lend itself particularly well to trauma-informed design work.</p><p>Sarah Fathallah and Anne-Laure Fayard co-wrote <a href="https://ssir.org/articles/entry/design_thinking_misses_the_mark#">a must-read piece</a> on the limits of (and harm done by) applying Design Thinking to complex social issues. In it they talk about how Design Thinking tends to oversimplify issues and produce solutions that are decontextualised — which lessens their chance of having positive, lasting impact. They say:</p><p><em>“We reject design thinking as a singular tool kit prescribed to solve social problems. [In what follows] we explain why design thinking as typically practiced has not been able to create impactful and sustainable solutions to complex social issues. Instead, we call for a critical stance on design, where critical means both discerning and important.”</em></p><p>One reason for the mis-match between Design Thinking and trauma-informed design lies in <strong>the beginners mindset. </strong>This is lauded for leading to the type of new and excellent creative ideas that only Design Thinking can produce.</p><p>Design Thinking posits that bringing fresh eyes to a challenge (aka bringing on a smart, eager design team with no prior knowledge of the issue) generates a different perspective that’s long been missing. But this process can be harmful when you consider its application in trauma-informed research. I might go into research about hospitality or shopping centre design as a total beginner, but how safe or even useful is it going to be for me (or my participants) to go into research about rape or domestic violence as a total beginner? When you’re cycling through different projects at speed, you lack the depth of engagement, the critical context and the trauma-informed methods that will help you avoid doing harm. Especially if your company mantra is anything like ‘move fast and break things’.</p><p>Until recently, I’ve spent 1.5 days a week in my role at Chayn and honestly, the amount of reading and learning that I’ve done around the edges probably matches that time. I‘ve wanted to explore and understand how trauma (broadly), public health, social justice, race, gender, the history of colonialism (particularly in design), digital developments such as AI, and violence against marginalized genders — all intersect. This is just to get my head around the systemic nature of gender- based violence, and the many oppressive structures at play that reinforce it — not to mention enable it online.</p><p>That said, the discomfort of really engaging with the topic of structural violence has, at times, felt too much. I have often felt overwhelmed by the sheer scale of the violence that people are experiencing. It has felt tempting to just move onto the next project as I have been taught so well to do. I’ve also learned that this temptation to look away is part of the work to overcome. Now that I‘m more knowledgeable and committed to learning, I’m more at home within the discomfort of this sector, and less likely to want to move onto the next shiny thing as a beginner. Frankly I’ve also learned too much to throw it away.</p><p>Rachael Dietkus, founder of Social Workers who Design, <a href="https://art.illinois.edu/people/meet-students/rachael-dietkus/">encourages us</a> to centre a trauma-informed and responsive framework of practice as its own entity, rather than trying to recast Design Thinking with a trauma-informed lens. What I’m learning more and more is that even though it was a pre-cursor for my career personally, Design Thinking is not the logical pre-cursor to Trauma-Informed design. The latter is not just a more sensitive approach to the former, with knottier topics to tackle, and more meaningful impact. Rachael has helped me to learn that trauma-informed and responsive design has a long history, and roots in trauma-informed clinical practice, social justice and the feminist politics of care. This is a very different set of perspectives and histories than that of commercial design as an industry.</p><p>What I believe we’re doing in our trauma-informed design work at Chayn is drawing on the best aspects of A) design as a <strong>discipline</strong> (vs an industry), and B) technology’s affordances, to build a mission-driven organisation that has a strong social impact.</p><p>From a design perspective these ‘best bits’ include a culture of curiosity and openness, prioritising creative ideas and problem solving, handling ambiguity with confidence, multi-disciplinary working, continual experimentation and delivering beautifully crafted services. From a feminist technology perspective, this means building services with the values of free access, global reach, community building, open source sharing, user agency and organisational responsiveness at their core.</p><p>If you’d like to read more about how we practice trauma-informed research and design at Chayn, check out our<a href="https://assets.website-files.com/60fdc9111506063bb9fe8e49/64b081438e3221d7ffc92b12_Trauma-informed%20design_%20the%20whitepaper%20by%20Chayn.pdf"> 2023 Whitepaper</a>, and<a href="https://blog.chayn.co/tagged/user-research"> a series of posts on our methods that I wrote last year</a>. If you’d like to know more about our critique on extractive research practices, and how to build survivor centred interventions to tech abuse, read<a href="https://endcyberabuse.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Orbits-full-guide-designed.pdf"> Orbits</a>.</p><p>Get in touch (jenny@chayn.co) if you would like to talk to us about trauma-informed research projects, knowledge sharing, partnerships or movement building activities.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=92126cbbb85a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Is your zoom background trauma-informed?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/design-bootcamp/is-your-zoom-background-trauma-informed-30e7014bce8f?source=rss-942dfddf96fc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/30e7014bce8f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-informed]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny H Winfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Aug 2023 09:55:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-02-10T13:46:13.699Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ENLY8e5Fa6TEHWQer0Vu_w.png" /><figcaption>A white wall with shelves holding books and a plant</figcaption></figure><h4>How you can put UX research participants at ease by managing what they can see and hear in your background</h4><p>In my old flat, I used to work in a small corner of my living space, and behind me was a shelf loaded with all of my bottles of alcohol. I was quite proud of this ‘bar’. It was pretty to look at and fun to consider the possibilities of weekend cocktails. Having this as my background was generally never an issue and it was even quite a good ice breaker on work calls - people would often comment on the collection and we’d talk about the drinks we liked to make.</p><p>But then, last summer, I worked on a UX research project about addiction, running interviews on zoom with people enrolled on a recovery program, and I had a rethink about this set up. I thought it was likely going to be triggering for people who are in recovery to see those bottles in the background of my zoom. So I decided to move my set up (for all of my research calls) so that my personal bar was not visible in my background.</p><p>I’ve since been working on creating a neutral, friendly background that’s much more trauma informed. You don’t need to remove all personality from your home (in fact a home-working set up can feel much warmer and human than an office background) but you do want it to feel free of distractions and triggers.</p><p>Here are my tips on making your zoom background at home more trauma-informed:</p><ol><li><strong>Make it clutter free</strong></li></ol><p>Working in a space that’s visually clear of distracting clutter will help you and your participant(s) feel more at ease. If that’s not available to you on this day, then it’s an idea to consider blurring your background to avoid any distraction caused by whatever is going on in your space. Be mindful that blurring your background can take up extra bandwidth on your connection. If you do blur your background, I’d recommend telling participants why you’ve done that, so they know that the only thing you’re hiding is mess. I’d say:</p><p><em>“Today, my house is messier than I’d like, and I wanted to ensure that the view you see when we talk is calm. So I’ve blurred my background out.”</em></p><p>You can even click ‘off’ blur to prove to them, for a moment, that your house really is messy. Simple and human.</p><p><strong>2. Neutral colours and plants</strong></p><p>Who doesn’t like to see a plant? Plants are beautiful, calming, and grounding. If you can’t do anything else, get a plant for your space. Many people give these away for free on marketplace style forums. If you have the choice of where to work, set yourself up with a wall behind you that’s a neutral, calming colour.</p><p><strong>3. Removing visual triggers</strong></p><p>Think about moving any of your artwork that has loud, clashing patterns, brash colours, or film posters that depict violence (more common than you’d think). These things can cause unnecessary stress, even if it’s low level or subconscious.</p><p>Then, think specifically about triggers that may be relevant to your project. The alcohol bottles that I mentioned earlier were clearly not appropriate to have visible, when I was meeting with people working through addiction. If you’re working on a brief around fertility challenges and you have a child, you might want to remove those baby clothes, family photos or kids toys in the background.</p><p>You can never know people’s individual triggers, but you can think about the things that are very likely to be difficult for them to see.</p><p><strong>4. Consider your background noise</strong></p><p>Whilst living in that same flat, I had a construction site opposite my home for almost a year, creating a lot of annoying noise during work hours. On zoom interviews, I might struggle to hear and concentrate on what the participant was saying due to this noise and I wondered how to manage it. I decided that it was a good idea to tell participants up front that I may find it hard to hear them at times. That way, if I had to ask them to repeat a point that they’d just made, it would be more believable that I’d struggled to hear, rather than that I just wasn’t listening. I think this is especially crucial if the person is trusting you with quite difficult and personal things.</p><p>If you have other people in your household, ask them to be quiet during your session. If you think it’s likely that they will make noise, let the participant know that there are other people in your house that they may hear coming or going, tell them who that person is, and reassure the participant that they won’t be able to hear the conversation.</p><p>I’ll often say something at the start of the session like:</p><p><em>“Just to let you know, while we talk, you might hear someone going up or downstairs through that door (pointing to door). That’s my partner, he will be going out soon. He can’t hear what we are saying, and there is no one else in my home who can hear us as we talk.”</em></p><p>You might also want to think about the potential for specific sounds to be triggering. If you’re working with people who have spent time in prison, or survivors of domestic violence, think about how triggering it might be for them to hear doors slamming loudly, or shouting voices.</p><h4><strong>Why this stuff matters</strong></h4><p>These tips should help you to create a sense of trust and safety between you and your research participants — both key principles of trauma-informed working. Before your research begins, you can also encourage your participant to spend time choosing where they are most likely to feel safe — physically and psychologically. Read more about that in this <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/keeping-survivors-safe-during-ux-research-eb20c1ee1f04">article</a>.</p><p>Remember, it’s unwise to just declare that the space you’re creating for participants is ‘safe’. Safety is a subjective feeling — you should try your best to help your participants feel it, but you cannot promise that your research interview is safe for them.</p><blockquote>A ‘safe space’ being declared without a mutual agreement from all parties is often a warning sign about an extractive research process — the researcher is using the term to try and get the participant to share without always being mindful of their needs. You can read more about ‘safe’ and ‘brave’ spaces <a href="https://www.thetherapygroup.com/thetherapygroupblog/stop-saying-this-is-a-safe-space">here</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@elise.k.ahen/safe-and-brave-spaces-dont-work-and-what-you-can-do-instead-f265aa339aff">here</a>.</blockquote><p>If you have tips for making your set up for remote interviews feel calmer and safer for participants, I’d love to hear them in the comments below.</p><p><em>I’m a trauma-informed UX researcher, working freelance and at </em><a href="https://www.chayn.co/"><em>Chayn</em></a><em>. Follow me for more writing on practicing research with trauma-informed methods. Find my work on </em><a href="http://www.jennywinfield.co.uk/"><em>www.jennywinfield.co.uk</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=30e7014bce8f" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/design-bootcamp/is-your-zoom-background-trauma-informed-30e7014bce8f">Is your zoom background trauma-informed?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/design-bootcamp">Bootcamp</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is it about surviving?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@winnyltd/what-is-it-about-surviving-17fc05328d51?source=rss-942dfddf96fc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17fc05328d51</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny H Winfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Jul 2023 12:57:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-23T12:38:08.854Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>On mountain climbing and trauma</h4><p><em>CW: References to death, including parental and baby death. Please read with care.</em></p><p>Last week, I went walking in Scotland with my dad</p><p>Climbing mountains, actually</p><p>His favourite view on earth is from the Black Cuillin ridge on Skye</p><p>He intends to have his ashes scattered there</p><p>So I asked him to take me</p><p>Since it may be me who ends up doing the deed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mmH9NupwgzTvqhnth9yK2Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>A picture of the scene, setting out for the Black Cuillin ridge walk. My dad is left and my partner, right. The peak of Sgùrr nan Gillean is in the background, the top obscured by cloud</figcaption></figure><p>As we walked, and climbed, many of my thoughts fell away</p><p>But I thought about death, obviously</p><p>And about life</p><p>And that space in between, survival.</p><p>Four hours in.</p><p>Up, up, up, up</p><p>As I peered into the eerie mist ahead,</p><p>with so much further to go</p><p>I felt fear threading through my veins</p><p>And my body asking questions of me…</p><p>“What if you can’t make it?”</p><p>To that place</p><p>that resides on top of this mountain</p><p>and inside your father’s heart?</p><p>What if you can’t complete this walk</p><p>that’s been months in the planning?*</p><p>Moreover, what if none of us</p><p>actually survive it?</p><p>-</p><p>No, no, I thought</p><p>reminding myself</p><p>of the 50 years of experience</p><p>this man, my dad possesses.</p><p>As my thighs continued to</p><p>burn at the incline,</p><p>I thought about a phrase</p><p>an old friend of mine shared recently</p><p>“We can do hard things”</p><p>Her baby had died at birth</p><p>and she was completing</p><p>a major hike</p><p>in her name.</p><p>I <em>know</em> it’s not the same, I thought</p><p>My feet sliding on the scree</p><p>I know it isn’t.</p><p>But “We can do hard things”</p><p>lodged itself into my head</p><p>and kept me climbing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nvwFccBHj9CLtK9rb1bXhQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>A picture of the peak we’re to climb, closer up. Leaving grass behind is daunting. The ascent onto the black rock, a particularly rough, grippy type called gabbro, begins.</figcaption></figure><p>What is it about survival?</p><p>I mused.</p><p>it’s everywhere</p><p>it’s there in almost all my work</p><p>and in my time off too.</p><p>But today’s kind of ‘survival’</p><p>the walking-up-a-big-mountain type</p><p>is different</p><p>it’s something you choose</p><p>and you (kind of) enjoy</p><p>because you know what’s coming</p><p>The wildness</p><p>The exhaustion</p><p>The sheer elemental force</p><p>The achievement.</p><p>.</p><p>It occurred to me then, that</p><blockquote>Trauma survival</blockquote><blockquote>is like being put on top of a mountain</blockquote><blockquote>without the choice of being there</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VxNtirUhPhxkumqTMpgmrA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The ridge approaching Sgurr nan Gillean, My partner just visible on the left. The bleakness and sense of hostility is visceral especially in low cloud.</figcaption></figure><p>Trauma survival is like finding yourself</p><p>in a wild and inhospitable place</p><p>like this</p><p>with no equipment or kit</p><p>no compass or confidence</p><p>no knowledge of this landscape</p><p>And no one else around.</p><p>You didn’t choose it</p><p>That wildness</p><p>That exhaustion</p><p>That sheer elemental force.</p><blockquote>Choice is the difference.</blockquote><p>And even when you choose it</p><p>It’s hard as hell.</p><p>-</p><p>As we clambered across the ridge</p><p>gnarly, exposed and menacing</p><p>to the final 30 metres</p><p>of that boulder field on high,</p><p>we admitted to each other</p><p>what we’d feared all day deep down</p><p>when we’d dared ourselves to look up</p><p>at that peak obscured in cloud</p><p>We weren’t going to make it</p><p>my partner, my dad and I</p><p>to the very, very, very top</p><p>We weren’t going to see the</p><p>‘worth being laid to rest here’</p><p>view.</p><p>It was too much of a risk.</p><p>We’d have to do a technical climb</p><p>up a ten foot, wet,</p><p>sheer piece of rock.</p><p>We got to know this damn rock</p><p>Touched it from every angle</p><p>Imagined wedging ourselves into, onto</p><p>and upwards within it</p><p>Thought about sacrificing</p><p>our backpacks below it.</p><p>Discussed how we’d do it in reverse</p><p>We’d read about it in the books</p><p>this rock that could ruin your day</p><p>‘Look’s ‘orrible’ I said</p><p>‘Nasty thing’ dad said</p><p>With not enough grip holes</p><p>And too much freezing rain</p><p>drenching our gloves.</p><p>It wasn’t worth it.</p><p>Dejectedly we stopped,</p><p>sat down,</p><p>and had a cup of tea.</p><p>(I know that sounds like a joke</p><p>But we did.)</p><p>As a couple of black crows</p><p>circled in the silence,</p><p>I tried to remember the bravery</p><p>it takes to stop</p><p>in a moment like this.</p><p>-</p><p>Finally standing up,</p><p>with an increasingly</p><p>wet sandwich in hand</p><p>rain pelting in our faces</p><p>we started our descent.</p><p>On the way down, we saw circular piles of stones</p><p>The ancient way to say</p><p>“This way”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*c5KWoqQCPuH-qDeBZQ4KjA.jpeg" /><figcaption>A picture of a pile of stones, a cairn, which is an ancient way finding tool. On passing by the cairn, you place another small rock on the top.</figcaption></figure><p>Another, a little way ahead</p><p>They know where you need to go</p><p>these man made wonders,</p><p>these friends made of stones.</p><p>They’re hopeful</p><p>when you’re weary</p><p>of being in charge.</p><p>And dog tired with disappointment,</p><p>we tracked barely visible paths</p><p>down and down</p><p>Down again</p><p>Following our cairns</p><p>until we felt grass</p><p>Soft, bouncy. Welcoming underfoot</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Gp9Vwog2x12h6_c0uokMcA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Joy in the flowers</p><p>Orange and yellow</p><p>Some with white bits of fluff</p><p>Almost comical in their cuteness.</p><p>Relief began to seep around my body</p><p>since we’d ‘survived’.</p><p>And we knew a little bit more</p><p>of ourselves. What we’re made of.</p><p>-</p><p>It was hard to swallow</p><p>Never seeing the view from the top that day</p><p>That spectacular, ‘reason to do the hard thing’ one</p><p>That’s how it goes.</p><p>But is a walk for nothing</p><p>if you don’t make the summit?</p><p>What if, when I ‘survive’ my dad</p><p>I’ll know that I can make it up there again</p><p>clutching a sacred vessel,</p><p>because we did it once</p><p>Almost all of it once.</p><p>Together.</p><p>— — —</p><p>Notes.</p><ol><li>I recognise that choosing to do difficult things, like walking up mountains, is embedded with privilege.</li><li>I’m a researcher and designer, focusing on trauma and taboo topics. I work with and learn from people who have experienced trauma, from sexual violence to suicide bereavement, from opioid addiction to incarceration. Common amongst the experiences I’ve encountered in my work with survivors is them having a prolonged sense of feeling dislocated, alone, emotionally bleak and desperate to find or return to safety. These, as well as finding a sense of hope, are the themes that cropped up in my head on the top of this mountain, and I hope it is clear that I acknowledged the sensations and feelings with interest, in an analogous way.</li><li>In 2024 I partnered with SlabLab to lead a research project with the back country skiing community, with a view to understanding risk taking and improving avalanche safety. We experimented with borrowing from the world of modern sex education (think, active consent and clear boundaries), encouraging people to be candid with partners about the level of risk they were comfortable with. I <a href="https://www.americanavalancheinstitute.com/the-human-factor-how-it-affects-communication-and-decision-making/">learned</a> that Commitment (as in, <em>‘I took a flight to be here’, or, ‘I planned this trip for months’</em>) and Scarcity (as in ‘<em>I may not get many more chances to do this with my dad</em>’) are two of the major human factors that lead people to take more risks. I definitely felt these pressures on this walk. Check out the work <a href="https://www.slablab.co/research/2023-24-report">here</a>.</li></ol><p>As I continue to look to nature, particularly the wild, elemental experiences of it that I love, and which help me to find balance in my life while doing trauma work, I think a lot about the intersection between nature and trauma. About, for example how the natural world can be traumatic as well as healing, and that we talk about trauma often as though it is ‘unnatural’ or errant, despite its commonality.</p><p>I would love to talk more about the topics in this piece, if it connected with you.(jenny.h.winfield@gmail.com)</p><p>Ps. My dad is 75 and yes, something else. He does relax sometimes….</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rsAW2Y7dN2nsj4_SwpV_TA.jpeg" /><figcaption>My parents enjoying a picnic on low ground, at Loch Coruisk</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17fc05328d51" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nurturing hope in UX research with survivors]]></title>
            <link>https://blog.chayn.co/nurturing-hope-in-ux-research-with-survivors-e2eebae3b709?source=rss-942dfddf96fc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e2eebae3b709</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-informed]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-experience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny H Winfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Mar 2023 09:37:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-16T10:54:11.410Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="A banner that says hope and has a small circle with two hands raised inside it, and a heart in between them." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hYMlrmNoHFLmJIuo-RO9mg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The trauma-informed design principle of hope</figcaption></figure><h4>How I use the trauma-informed principle of hope while working with survivors of sexual assault</h4><blockquote>“When I started using Bloom, I was thinking it was a bit different from the other things I’ve read before. It’s not telling you what to do. I feel like it’s by my side so I can kind of ‘grow’… step by step with you guys. Does that make sense?”</blockquote><p>At Chayn we’ve been talking (and writing) about our trauma-informed principles and how they shape the work we’re doing. Specifically, we’ve been exploring how we bring these principles to life our service design and in the UX research we carry out with survivors.</p><p>You can find the full set of articles <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/tagged/user-research">here</a> — they cover our principles of<a href="https://blog.chayn.co/keeping-survivors-safe-during-ux-research-eb20c1ee1f04"> Safety</a>, <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/centring-equity-and-plurality-in-ux-research-with-survivors-ccc87c9290e9">Plurality and Equity</a>, <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/practising-accountability-in-ux-research-with-survivors-edc7a9eb2435">Accountability</a>, <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/sharing-power-with-survivors-in-ux-research-e984c250fcb7">Agency and Power Sharing</a>. This is our last piece in the series on trauma-informed UX research, and in it, I talk about hope.</p><p><strong>Why does hope matter?</strong></p><p>Hope, as one of our trauma-informed principles, is tangible across Chayn. We know how important it is for survivors to feel hopeful, and how hard this is, thanks to hope’s twin shadow, despair. When survivors come to us, we imagine they are carrying pain with them, and they have been through trauma. They need somewhere that feels hopeful, where they can find the support to heal.</p><p>As I discuss in this piece, growth is intertwined with hope. So, when I spoke with a survivor recently and heard her remark that <a href="https://bloom.chayn.co/">our Bloom service</a> seems to support a type of ‘side by side’ growth (rather than promoting an instructive, fixed action plan), I knew that it was a sign we were doing a good job with it.</p><p>At Chayn we’re driven by the hope that we can create a world free from abuse, and that we can support survivors to find themselves again, even if we cannot support them with their material challenges such as lack of safe housing and access to finances.</p><blockquote>We do this because having hope can be the difference between a survivor wanting to stay alive, and not. Hope — something which might sound intangible, even throwaway, is essential for recovery and survival.</blockquote><p>Abusers know that hope is powerful. That’s why they try to strip it away from us, often successfully. It might be by telling us lies about how no one cares about us, that we’ve caused the abuse to happen, or that no one will believe us if we share our story. Chayn supports survivors so that they come to see that these things aren’t true.</p><p>As people working in this sector, of course we want to provide hope and give rise to hopefulness. But recently I’ve found myself asking, can hope actually be ignited or shared? And what role can a UX researcher play in this, given that a key touchpoint of our work is speaking with survivors about the services we’re designing for them?</p><p>In this piece I share my thoughts on how hope can’t be given, but it can be encouraged to emerge on its own terms. We support that idea in two main ways:</p><ul><li>Providing validation</li><li>Supporting growth</li></ul><p>For both of these, I’m going to share how we do things at Chayn, and then how as a UX researcher, I bring hopeful practices into my day-to-day work with survivors.</p><h3><strong>1. Providing validation</strong></h3><p>At Chayn, we see our role as providing a safe space for survivors, a sanctuary, that will meet them where they are. We help people feel <strong>welcomed,</strong> <strong>seen, and validated</strong>. As survivors ourselves, we know that a big part of hope is the relief of discovering that we are not at fault, not alone, and not powerless to live a good life.</p><p><strong><em>In our language and design decisions</em></strong></p><p>Because we know this, at Chayn we prefer the term survivor over victim, even though we acknowledge it may be validating for some of us to use the word victim. As an organisation, we decided on “survivor” because we feel it signals moving forward with resilience.</p><blockquote>The word “survivor” speaks to strength. We think it is, in a word, hopeful.</blockquote><figure><img alt="Feel low? Is past trauma affecting your life? Want support to get out of abusive relationships? You are in the right place. We support those experiencing gender-based violence because we deserve to be free, and happy. Our resources will help you spot abuse, collect evidence, stay safe, get well and connect to local services." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*oUuKjuLNrp6Wzb7M" /><figcaption>An image of the Chayn homepage with calming colours, friendly feminist illustrations, and the affirmation ‘You’re in the right place’</figcaption></figure><p>Front and centre on our Chayn homepage, alongside our calming colours and our friendly, feminist illustrations is the affirmation that “You’re in the right place”. We let survivors explore our resources on their own terms, honouring the amount of time and attention they feel able to commit. They tell us that they love being invited to find out more about who we are, as a team of survivors too.</p><p><strong><em>In our content</em></strong></p><p>In our resources, we do everything we can to <strong>legitimise survivors’ feelings</strong>. We talk about the range of emotions that a survivor might be feeling, from grief to rage, heartbreak to terror, sadness to total detachment. We provide grounding exercises that call out the relationship between PTSD and feelings of anxiety in the body.</p><p>As any therapist will say, all of these feelings are normal responses to trauma and sitting with them, however discomforting, is part of healing. That’s why connecting to other survivors and hearing their stories — sitting with the pain together — is so effective.</p><p>A central theme in our free resources is clarifying what abuse actually is and reassuring survivors that it is never their fault — challenging the dominant narrative of many cultures, and ideas about control that many women and marginalised genders internalise. This can help survivors feel validated, that the gut feeling of fear, loss or anger they had was in fact a normal reaction to abuse, and they were right to sense that something was very wrong.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*4ETY4AL3huYNp2Rq" /><figcaption>An image from our Manipulation is Abuse guide, on the topic of Isolation. It depicts two people in a rowing boat as a group of people watch from the land. The person rowing the boat is saying to the other person “I just want you all to myself.” Underneath this, there are more examples of words someone may use to isolate us.</figcaption></figure><p>For example, in our <a href="https://manipulation.chayn.co/">Manipulation is Abuse</a> guide, we give specific examples of what a range of manipulative behaviours look, feel, and sound like. This example is about how abusers are experts at isolating a person from their support network and gaslighting survivors when they question it.</p><h4><strong><em>In our UX research, w</em>e validate without promising relief</strong></h4><p>In UX research, as you listen to a survivor’s thoughts and feelings, I think it’s important not to promise that “you’ll be okay”, as this can sound dismissive and truly, you don’t know if someone will be OK.</p><p>Note that on our homepage we say “we deserve the right to be free, and happy” — we do not promise survivors freedom and happiness.</p><blockquote>It can be very tempting to hasten to provide a solution to someone’s pain and make it all better. But I’d say that is a reaction to our own discomfort — and UX researchers in this space need to be ready to work on managing that reflex. Instead, saying “we are with you, and we get it” is a much stronger message — and more authentic.</blockquote><p>So, building hope is firstly about making space for survivors to just <strong>be as they are</strong>, acknowledging their suffering and not making any big promises. This is hugely validating. You can check out our earlier <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/keeping-survivors-safe-during-ux-research-eb20c1ee1f04">blog on Safety</a> for more tips on helping survivors feel safe during UX research.</p><h3>2. Supporting growth</h3><p>At Chayn, we know that if you feel seen and heard, you might feel better, but it takes a bit more than that to start to feel truly hopeful. That’s why<strong> supporting survivors to grow</strong> is also such a big focus for us. We’ve learned that people start to feel hopeful once they can imagine a change happening for themselves. So, <strong>we provide examples of how life doesn’t have to be this way and tools for survivors to start to take action.</strong></p><p><strong><em>In our language and design</em></strong></p><p>Firstly, we communicate growth with our design, look and feel. We deliberately stay away from images of abuse or suffering which can be triggering, instead opting to illustrate survivors with colour, movement, uplifting poses and alongside plants.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/792/0*O9DZmgTaLZ2f8Ysy" /><figcaption>An illustration from Chayn’s website, depicting a woman using a technology device with vibrant colours and uplifting sense of movement</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3DmmfRVLHMGfpd5beA-UmQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>An illustration from our Bloom programme which depicts a person at peace, their head surrounded by green leaves, plants and flowers</figcaption></figure><p>We think it’s hopeful to see a survivor in a dynamic, colourful setting, so long as that style is balanced with a sense of safety and calm. That’s why using natural references like plants can really help — and we’ve had so many positive comments on this from survivors.</p><p><strong><em>In our content</em></strong></p><p>Then there’s our content; <a href="https://soulmedicine.io/en/pathways/domestic-abuse/notes/week-5-session-2-living-well-trauma-tools-and-therapies">learning how to cope with triggers</a>, support with <a href="https://soulmedicine.io/en/pathways/how-to-open-your-own-bank-account">opening a bank account,</a> <a href="https://ysmysm.co/resources/rape-culture-and-consent">understanding the socio-political context of misogyny</a>, <a href="https://chayn.gitbook.io/how-to-build-a-domestic-abuse-case-without-a-lawye/">getting free legal advice for leaving an abusive partner</a>. These are all things that Chayn helps survivors to do — practical life skills and coping mechanisms that help them to move forward and grow towards peace. These are the essential components of our services.</p><p>Is there anything more hopeful than the prospect of regaining access to your children by building your own domestic violence case with our help? Or gaining financial independence from an abuser?</p><h4><strong><em>In our UX research we h</em>onour survivors’ unique growth pathways</strong></h4><p>Firstly, we recognise that growth is different for everyone, and that survivors will find different content useful depending on where they are in their healing journey. Therefore we spend a good amount of time in UX research just understanding how survivors want to <strong>navigate</strong> around our resources, to create the <strong>right mix of experiences</strong>, whether that’s within a single session or over long periods of time.</p><p>Our UX team is constantly discussing how best to share (all of the many options for) the support we provide, with the need to keep our resources clear and calming.</p><p><em>“It’s the strangest things that can overwhelm you when you’ve just gone through (abuse) particularly. (What I liked was that) it was plain language, I was glad to see I didn’t need to make any big decisions.”</em></p><p>Just like this survivor, we’ve heard many people comment on how grateful they were that we didn’t ask them to make big decisions or navigate overwhelming content, just letting them explore as they wanted.</p><p>In UX research, we also focus on talking about the <strong>types of specific content, </strong>resources and support that survivors <strong>might need from us for their growth and healing.</strong> In our sessions, I’ll ask survivors about what they have found useful, and often that’s our practical guidance around things they can actually do differently in their day-to-day lives. For example, our guidance on <a href="https://soulmedicine.io/en/pathways/creating-boundaries">how to create and maintain boundaries</a> is really popular.</p><p>You might think that asking survivors about UX concerns isn’t very trauma informed — don’t they just want to talk about their trauma? We’d say no. They want to heal. If your UX research is focused on making improvements that will help survivors to find, navigate, and make use of the available resources for healing, in the way that suits them, I’d say you can be confident you’re providing a hopeful experience.</p><p>What survivors almost always say to me is that a big appeal of taking part in research is providing insights that will help other survivors. There’s a strong sense of hope in that too.</p><h4><strong>Hope isn’t always predictable, because healing isn’t linear</strong></h4><p>Triggers, part of living with trauma, as well as the structural challenges survivors face in getting out of abuse, mean that hope is tough to maintain as a survivor. It can come and go — a survivor might feel hopeful, only for feelings of guilt, sadness and hopelessness to wash back over them. Finding hope is not something you achieve and are done with.</p><p>Recently, a survivor said to me, <em>“There is a common thread throughout the video that says ‘It’s not your fault’ and because I have moments where I feel that (it is) … I will go back to that to remind myself it isn’t.”</em></p><p>This is a good reminder that the focus of our work should be long-term, sustained impact. It reminded me of activist Mariame Kaba’s quote,<strong> </strong>“Hope is a discipline”.</p><p>Hope needs upkeep. Hope is hard.</p><p>But hope does also follow some patterns that, as we work to support survivors, we can embed into our practices. I recommend focusing on offering validation and supporting growth if you’re trying to contribute meaningfully to a survivor gaining hope — that is, on their own terms.</p><blockquote>By being the person or organisation who doesn’t promise to fix it — you may well provide more hope than the ones who do. You might even save a life.</blockquote><p>This marks the end of our <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/tagged/user-research">series on trauma-informed UX research</a>. We hope you’ve learned some things along the way with us. If you would like to speak with <a href="/service/mailto:team@chayn.co">Chayn</a> or<a href="/service/mailto:jenny@chayn.co"> Jenny</a> about supporting your team with trauma-informed UX research practices, do reach out.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e2eebae3b709" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://blog.chayn.co/nurturing-hope-in-ux-research-with-survivors-e2eebae3b709">Nurturing hope in UX research with survivors</a> was originally published in <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/">Chayn</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Practising accountability in UX research with survivors]]></title>
            <link>https://blog.chayn.co/practising-accountability-in-ux-research-with-survivors-edc7a9eb2435?source=rss-942dfddf96fc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/edc7a9eb2435</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-informed-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[accountability]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny H Winfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Dec 2022 12:45:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-07T10:25:41.234Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OJCso1N8BzpwE86Bax9u8A.png" /><figcaption>Accountability is one of Chayn’s trauma-informed principles</figcaption></figure><h4>How I practice the trauma-informed principle of Accountability, while leading UX research with survivors of sexual assault</h4><p>Hi, I’m Chayn’s User Researcher, Jenny. I help the team to design and build products and services that truly meet user needs. You can read more about me <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/meet-our-user-research-lead-jenny-54938a891bd3">here.</a></p><p>Recently I read this quote from Molly Smith Metzler, who wrote the screenplay for the Netflix show ‘Maid’:</p><p><em>“I think [Stephanie] didn’t want to see exactly her story onscreen. I think she wanted to see an emotionally true version of it. And that’s what she said when she watched it.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/959/1*tdMfX_-trmUoklDORQHCqQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>RYLEA NEVAEH WHITTET as MADDY and MARGARET QUALLEY as ALEX in MAID (Photo credit: RICARDO … [+]</figcaption></figure><p>Molly is talking about how Stephanie Land, whose memoir ‘Maid: Hard Work, Low Pay and a Mother’s Will to Survive’ forms the basis for the Netflix adaptation, reacted when she watched the show. This idea, of creating an <strong>emotionally true representation</strong> of an experience, without including specific, identifying details, rang so true for me.</p><p>It’s exactly what I try to do as a researcher at Chayn, working with survivors to understand and then convey their needs. There’s a fine line between sharing enough of a story’s detail for it to be compelling, and leaving out the kind of details that could sensationalise it, or even put people in danger. Walking that line with care is what Accountability means to me, and how as one of our trauma-informed principles, it comes to life in my work.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*D2sTgsqtM7QRFlSgmEQ84w.png" /></figure><p>I want to create learnings that resonate for survivors, and in which they can see a version of themselves, as they hopefully would if they saw a painted portrait. But I don’t want to make them feel as if they’ve been exposed — like Molly, I don’t want that portrait to be photo-realistic or a mirror image of that individual. So how do we go about doing this?</p><p>In today’s piece I’ll be sharing some of my tips for holding ourselves accountable as UX researchers, especially if we’re working with overlooked and underserved groups such as survivors of abuse. This is the 4th blog in our trauma informed UX research series. The other ones have talked about Safety, Agency &amp; Power Sharing, and Equity &amp; Plurality. The last one will be Hope.</p><h4><strong>Accountability matters when your trust has been exploited</strong></h4><p>Many people who have been through trauma have had their trusting nature exploited. They have been let down, and even abused — often times by the same people or institutions that they were encouraged to trust. As anyone who works with survivors will know, services do not always work together holistically or follow up on promises for survivors. This lack of accountability can mean that people end up in cycles of requesting support but seeing nothing come through.</p><p>Recently I’ve been reading the book ‘Future Ethics’ by Cennydd Bowles and a line I love within it is:</p><p>‘<em>There will always be outcomes we overlook, but unintended does not mean unforeseeable. We can — and must — try to anticipate and mitigate the worst potential consequences’</em>.</p><p>He describes how being accountable is part of being ethical, and increasingly, it doesn’t just mean owning up when you messed up. It means having the foresight to imagine the consequences of your actions (intended and unintended) and doing more to prevent harm from happening.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0_Ev1vWYNmfh0uKg1yAXtQ.png" /></figure><p>At Chayn, accountability and openness are two sides of the same coin. We recognise that services can cause harm by doing nothing, or doing specific things, and they must be held accountable for enabling harm. At the same time, it’s not possible to be everything to everyone, so we need to be open about our own capabilities — what we can actually do. This idea is central to Orbits, our report about technology facilitated gender based violence.</p><p>Because a lot of this work is about imagining and projecting, it’s impossible to do alone. At Chayn we practice accountability by creating and nourishing constructive <strong>feedback loops that catalyse change</strong>. In part that means we make an effort to speak regularly with survivors, but we also create feedback loops within Chayn (for example, in the way our volunteer team is part of our decision making) and with other stakeholders in this sector, who can support us to keep improving and who in turn we can help to improve.</p><p>One of the ways that we create that feedback loop in the sector is with our commitment to working in the open, and inviting others to comment on and use our work, as we did this year with our <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/chayns-organisational-strategy-is-out-for-comment-c20d707ee9e2">2022–2025 strategy development</a>.</p><h4><strong>Not available ? You can still be accountable</strong></h4><p>One of my favourite everyday examples of being accountable through service design is within Bloom, our remote support service for survivors. We offer a 1:1 chat service that survivors can tap into and use for reflection while they’re exploring our learning materials. We can’t offer the service 24 hours a day (it’s not a bot), so we’re careful about how we communicate our availability. We make it clear when we’re offline, and what time we will be back online and available to chat.</p><p>We also say who is running the chat service that day, and since we created a page on the Bloom website with little bios of our team (something survivors had asked us for) — they can check out who they’ll be chatting with when we come back online. This kind of accountability — taking steps to communicate when we’re around and who is behind the screen — helps to build trust.</p><blockquote><em>It’s also worth saying, it’s hard to be accountable(!).</em></blockquote><p>We recently realised that we weren’t going to be able to keep a promise that we’d create a new Bloom course as our team was really stretched, and we got together as a team to discuss what the best way forward was. We decided to honour our trauma-informed ways of working (which prioritise safety and rest), and contact survivors to share what had happened, giving them some alternative options for accessing the course material. We had a good response to this — survivors understand that things can change — what they don’t appreciate is being left in the dark or ignored.</p><p>Viewed through a UX research lens, the goal of being Accountable is tied to honesty, safety and trust; we try to create insights that honour the stories of survivors while protecting their identities.</p><p>There’s the obvious Research Operations stuff, like managing data properly, gathering informed consent and following up with helpful resources. If you want to go deeper, and design more accountable research experiences, here are 5 tips for you.</p><h4><strong>Five tips for boosting accountability in UX research</strong></h4><h4><strong>1. Be consistent</strong></h4><p>When it comes to engaging with participants, remember that they may have had their trust broken before by services and systems that didn’t do what they said they would do. Clear, consistent and calm communication goes some way to helping them build trust — believing that yours is different.</p><p>It might be that you give the participant a single point of contact throughout the research process (before, during, after) to connect with and ask questions. Responding to their queries such as ‘<em>can we talk with the camera off</em>?’ consistently (for example, always within 24 hours, and with a warm, reassuring tone), can spell the difference between survivors feeling up for taking part (aka showing up for their portrait painting), and their interest dwindling.</p><p>One of the easiest things you can do to create consistency is to create a participant information sheet which outlines exactly what you’d like to do, why, and what the participants can expect. This covers things like how much compensation will be offered and how long it will take to arrive, and how you plan to take care of the participant through the process. You can also highlight the key areas where you’d be looking for them to have input, and what prep they might need to commit to. You can check out one of ours <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1o4nNePI6uTlUv8CBxzeq50VTwcsrtmZh/view?usp=sharing">here</a>, feel free to adapt and use as you wish.</p><blockquote><em>Then, reinforcing this information when you speak with them is key; setting out a plan and sticking to it communicates that you are a trustworthy person that does what they say they will do.</em></blockquote><p>If different team members are doing the recruiting and planning vs the research itself then it’s nice to introduce the participant to who those team members are, and the role they’ll be playing. Sometimes research teams can’t promise that a certain person will be running interviews on a particular day in advance. In that case, I would suggest that whoever does run the interviews just drops the participant a note on the day to say hi and create a point of personal contact before the session starts.</p><p>Going to efforts to make sure that participants are compensated within the time frame you’ve set out can help to reduce anxiety and show the participant that you’re accountable, too. This matters because ultimately they’re trusting you with not just their time and energy, but their story.</p><h4><strong>2. Do your homework</strong></h4><p>There are small things you can do to prepare yourself for sessions:</p><ul><li>A 30 second Google to find out how to pronounce your participants’ name, for instance, if they’re from a different country or culture to yours.</li><li>Chatting with friends and contacts with lived experience of your topic</li><li>Putting out a quick online call for experts</li><li>Checking out articles on Google scholar</li><li>A search for community posts on reddit</li></ul><p>If you have more time, it can be a good idea to explore and understand the identity groups that your participant belongs to, so that when they’re sharing their story, you are not asking them to educate you around basic norms at the same time.</p><p>For me doing research for our Bloom and Bumble partnership, that might mean exploring and understanding how people from a variety of religions and cultures approach dating. This has helped me understand how in some cultures, online dating (meeting someone for a date who is totally unknown to you and your community) feels particularly unsafe, or even taboo.</p><p>I’ve done homework to understand how being trans or cis gender might have impacted a survivors’ experience, for example learning that safety concerns for a non cis person might limit the number of options they feel they have for meeting in public places, and make them more likely to suggest a first date at home. When a non binary person described exactly this scenario during an interview later on, and how they’d been assaulted at home — it meant that this idea wasn’t brand new to me.</p><p>Understanding a bit more about neurodivergence recently meant that I was prepared for an autistic participant to share her frustration at the unwritten rules of dating, like people playing hard to get and not always saying what they mean.</p><p>In our <a href="https://medium.com/hack-for-chayn/centring-equity-and-plurality-in-ux-research-with-survivors-ccc87c9290e9">Equity and Plurality blog</a>, we talk about how to use carefully written screener questions to recruit participants from underserved and marginalised communities (if they’re the users of your services). If you know a bit about your participants’ identities before you begin, the next step is to consider how these identities may have affected the experience that you’re going to be discussing.</p><p><a href="https://www.userinterviews.com/blog/navigating-gender-religion-and-politics-in-ux-research-zoe-glas">This podcast </a>from Google User Researcher Zoe Glas gives some good tips on how to do your homework, and also how to be realistic about how much this can prepare you for who you’ll meet.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0MUnXFQCWn5GfEykI4y8nQ.png" /><figcaption>Screenshot of the awkward silences Episode 106 summary: Navigating gender, religion and politics in UX research, with Zoe Glas of Google.</figcaption></figure><p>She says:</p><p><em>“The first thing is to know as much as you can, so if you are going to be leading sessions on religion (…) get as much knowledge as you can, going in (...) Reach out to some rabbis. Reach out to some priests. Read as much as you can online to get a background (…) The other side of it, though, is to be really generous with yourself. It’s not going to be perfect. We’re going to mess up (…) There are things you’re going to say that you just never imagined could have been an issue, and that’s not your fault.</em>”</p><blockquote><em>Even giving identities a bit of thought will help the participant feel that you’ve made an effort to understand their context, and that’s a good example of accountability.</em></blockquote><p>It will also help you, because you’ll have a clearer sense of what they’re talking about when they share their needs. Think of it like creating the background for the portrait you’re painting, and selecting the right kinds of tones.</p><h4><strong>3. Sense check as you go.</strong></h4><p>Here you’re really getting into portrait painting mode. While you chat with your participants, play back what you’re hearing, to sense check that they recognise themselves in it. In your guide, build in moments to pause and reflect, saying something like:</p><p>“Can I take a moment to summarise what I think I heard there? It sounds like XYZ are important to you…. ”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YpIKa_YkTieenWeofmuLmg.png" /></figure><p>Be aware that you’ll bring bias into what you instinctively notice (and therefore capture) about people, and what you think their needs are. You might want to try a positionality exercise (a good one I recently tried is <a href="https://app.mural.co/template/f938753d-c323-4397-a462-f67d0f09fd3e/f79119d4-da91-41ad-a16d-b1e95ac8ad00">here</a>). With this, you can map out the identities that you’ll be bringing into the research, and think about how that might influence the stories you notice more than others.</p><p>If you’re still more junior, and synthesising while you moderate is too much, then you can take a moment at the end of your sessions to try and play back a few key points. As I’m taking notes, I like to put a big star by 3–5 things that I think are most interesting, that way it’s easy to scan back and ask participants about those points. Some researchers take notes within a template that has marked out spaces for insights and new ideas, so inputting your notes directly into a framework like that can help you find them for a quick recap too.</p><h4><strong>4. Share your insights</strong></h4><p>When you’ve done your synthesis and created a deck of insights and (anonymised) stories, you can share these with your participants to get their thoughts.</p><p>This might sound icky, especially if you work in a culture that strongly rewards perfection, individualistic working, and detached researcher expertise over lived experience. Also, if your organisation is built on urgency culture — it will feel like there is no time to do this. Read more about that <a href="https://www.whitesupremacyculture.info/characteristics.html">here</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lmQmZB8m8JCOs2sbIlBZyg.png" /></figure><p>It’s easy to think… <em>‘I don’t want to share my work! What if participants disagree with what I wrote?’</em></p><p>Well…. exactly.</p><p>Remember, if a participant does not recognise themselves in the stories you’ve captured about them (aka the portrait you’ve painted), it is far better to know soon and fix it, than start to design based on assumptions that are way off. Being accountable in research means being responsible for capturing correctly and no one is better at letting you know if you’ve managed this than your participant.</p><blockquote>If you feel nervous, try to remember how much generosity it took for the participant to sit down with you and let you in to their story.</blockquote><p>It’s a good idea to frame this ‘checking the insights’ request to participants as optional rather than part of the research requirement, unless your incentive covers this.</p><p>Creating a feedback loop with participants (and the wider community working on your topic) is central to community-centred design, participatory design and co-design — which are sometimes described as trauma-informed principles in their own right.</p><h4><strong>5. Make it worth it (make it actionable)</strong></h4><p>This is the biggie for me. As a researcher, being accountable means recognising my responsibility to make research count; that is, to make it worth the survivor having opened up their mind and heart to us. To actually make improvements based on what we’ve heard.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pEamkKFTdG2gZuXyzUELpw.png" /></figure><p>Design research is not just an exercise in gathering stories, it’s about using stories as powerfully evocative data points to improve what we’re designing.</p><p>To do this well, you need to be in the room with a voice, when people are discussing changes to services that survivors need. You need to communicate insights with clarity and creativity — to make research inspiring to listen to.</p><p>There’s real hope in all of that. But that’s a story for the next (and last!) blog in this series.</p><p>That’s it for now. If you’re working for an organisation that’s doing its best to be accountable, especially with research practice, I’d love to chat. You can reach me at jenny@chayn.co</p><h4>PS — thanks to Chayn for keeping me accountable, in writing these blogs.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=edc7a9eb2435" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://blog.chayn.co/practising-accountability-in-ux-research-with-survivors-edc7a9eb2435">Practising accountability in UX research with survivors</a> was originally published in <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/">Chayn</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Centring Equity and Plurality in UX Research with Survivors]]></title>
            <link>https://blog.chayn.co/centring-equity-and-plurality-in-ux-research-with-survivors-ccc87c9290e9?source=rss-942dfddf96fc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ccc87c9290e9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[service-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-informed]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny H Winfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Nov 2022 10:03:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-30T10:40:21.893Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0UuKJcvBovsXMH1u1LRtMg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The trauma-informed principles of plurality and equity</figcaption></figure><h4>How I practiced the trauma-informed principles of Equity and Plurality, while leading UX research with survivors of sexual assault</h4><p>Hi, I’m Chayn’s User Researcher, Jenny. I help the team to design and build products and services that truly meet user needs. You can read more about me <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/meet-our-user-research-lead-jenny-54938a891bd3">here.</a></p><p>In this piece I talk about how to recruit the right research participants for trauma-informed UX projects, something that people ask me about a lot. Essentially I share advice around three C’s — giving <strong>context</strong>, assessing what’s <strong>critical</strong>, and using <strong>careful </strong>language.</p><p><em>“I thought that that [assault] couldn’t have happened to me, because, well I was quite an open person… and I’d shared my situation with [the man I met], that my husband had died. It was already quite difficult for me to meet new people… I was already coming from a fragile point of view…”</em></p><p>During a recent round of research for our Bloom and Bumble program, a participant who had lost her husband to cancer (we’ll call her Aisha) told me her story. She described how she couldn’t believe she’d been assaulted when she first explored dating again, because she’d already lived through such a tragedy.</p><p>At Chayn we’ve been talking (and writing) about our trauma-informed principles and how they shape the work we’re doing. Specifically, we’ve been exploring what they mean for the services we design and the UX research we do with survivors of gender-based violence (GBV).</p><p><strong>This piece is our third in this </strong><a href="https://blog.chayn.co/tagged/user-research"><strong>series</strong></a><strong>, and it’s about our principles of Plurality and Equity. Plurality means acknowledging that survivors bring with them a variety of different experiences of GBV, and therefore that their needs from a service like ours are not one-size-fits-all. Equity, for us, means designing services first and foremost for people with marginalised identities.</strong></p><p>(You might notice that these principles vary from other lists of trauma-informed design principles. That’s because we have created our own, building them out with the specific challenge of gender-based violence and tech in mind. You can find out more about them in our project, <a href="http://c.chayn.co/orbits">Orbits</a>).</p><p>I found Aisha’s reaction — being surprised by her trauma — really intriguing. Over time, more participants shared similar feelings. One woman shared how shocked and confused she was that she’d been assaulted because it had happened on her first ever romantic date — and the year of her 40th birthday. Other participants shared that they were surprised to find themselves a survivor of abuse because they were intelligent and had a Masters degree.</p><blockquote>It seemed that survivors themselves were making biased assumptions about who is affected by gender-based violence.</blockquote><p>When you work in this sector and speak with survivors as much as we do at Chayn, you know that sexual assault and abuse reaches into all communities and cultures. But <a href="https://www.svri.org/our-priorities/nature-and-prevalence/marginalised-groups/lgbtqi?link-section=reports">research shows</a> that it particularly affects people who belong to marginalised groups, and further still, those who identify with multiple intersecting identities of oppression: a disabled, queer Black woman, for example, is more likely to be the target of sexual abuse (and less likely to be believed and supported if she reports) than a white cis woman.</p><p>At Chayn, we recognise that people’s life experiences and identities affect how trauma impacts them and the help they can access. Survivors with both previous trauma and oppressed identities are most in need of resources to support them in healing. Our work is all about honouring survivors as individuals, and knowing that they are more than their trauma. Inviting them into our process, hearing their stories, and discussing their needs is what helps us to design <em>with, </em>not<em> for,</em> them.</p><p>People in the GBV sector can often place survivors at extreme ends of the trauma spectrum (assuming either they’re at no risk or lethal risk), and design interventions with those scenarios in mind, rather than exploring survivors’ realities with user research.</p><h3>What does this mean for UX research?</h3><p>One of the big misconceptions about doing research about traumatic experiences like sexual assault is that it will be really hard to find people willing to talk with you. But I’ve found in this work (and many other projects where I research sensitive or taboo issues) that people actually really do want to talk, and even more so, feel heard.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O1nwPWJN_oU427FlloxblQ.png" /></figure><p>It’s often the UX practitioners who are worried about how to handle the emotional load of interviews, or who are afraid of doing harm by saying the wrong thing. If you approach your research in a trauma-informed way, you will be well equipped to find the right participants and go into these conversations with confidence.</p><h3>Tips for recruiting with confidence</h3><p>It’s my job to invite a mix of survivors with all kinds of experiences of GBV to join our user research, but particularly to centre the needs of (and design with) those survivors who have marginalised identities. Recruiting is a key opportunity for me to bring our principles of Plurality and Equity to life in my day-to-day work.</p><p>Here are three tips you can use in your recruiting process to include the right people. We’ll call them the three Cs: give <strong>context</strong>, assess what’s <strong>critical</strong> to know about people, and ask with <strong>care</strong>.</p><h3>1. Give the context</h3><p>For our recent recruit on the Bumble and Bloom research project, we knew we needed to speak with people who had experienced different types of sexual abuse, from cyberflashing to harassment to rape. So in our screening survey for the interviews, we asked people to share a few details about what happened specifically. You can do this even if you’re asking about a difficult experience<strong> — </strong>just remember to go gently and provide some context.</p><ul><li>Instead of writing ‘<em>Tell us what happened to you</em>’, which feels cold and could even be triggering, help people understand your intentions better by sharing why you’re asking. You can say: <em>‘As we design our services, it’s important for us to hear from survivors with a range of experiences, so that we understand how people’s needs differ. Please describe what kind of sexual assault and/or abuse you experienced.”</em></li><li>You might want to provide a list of answers for them to choose from, to make it even clearer what you’re asking for details on (e.g. Our list provided examples that included: ‘Non consensual touching’, ‘stalking’, ‘gaslighting’, ‘receiving indecent pictures’). Doing this makes reviewing answers and selecting a mix of respondents simpler, but you will lose some of the nuance of their experience that you might otherwise gain if you give people an open-field option.</li><li>Always allow people to provide their own answer, through giving an ‘other’ and an open-field option. This shows that you understand Plurality — you may well not have imagined all of the experiences they’ve had.</li><li>Making answering optional helps to make people feel safer. You can say something like: ‘<em>If you feel able to, please select/share a bit more about your experience’</em>. There will be people who don’t want to share these details, and that is totally fine — they will simply not complete the screener and apply to take part.</li></ul><h3>2. Only ask for critical data</h3><p>We know that gender-based violence is more likely to affect people who have been and are being oppressed, and so if we’re going to use our research to design equitable services, we need to invite those people to speak with us. Centring their needs is not possible without including them in research.</p><ul><li>Again, it’s okay to ask questions about identity as long as it’s clear why you’re doing so. Too many research practices are extractive, collecting personal data that’s not needed in the context. We know from our work that gender identity, race, ethnicity, sexuality, and ability do impact survivor experience of sexual abuse and their recovery pathways. They’re relevant to our work, and so they’re relevant for us to screen for in recruiting. Don’t leave finding (and therefore including) these people up to chance.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4vRAP8UgLEhk_ug2mn_vtA.png" /></figure><ul><li>Once you’ve decided what factors are really critical to ask for, think about how you ask for this data. At Chayn, instead of demanding ‘What is your race/ethnicity?’, we ask ‘What country or culture feels like home to you?’ with an open field into which people type their preferred descriptor. As a global team, we know that people’s cultural identity cannot be reduced to a drop-down list.</li><li>We ask questions about other identities, such as neurodivergence and sexuality, because we know that they’re relevant, and this helps us design better services. By speaking with survivors who are non-binary, for example, we hear about how seen they have felt when they see our illustrations, which don’t depict all survivors as women. Speaking with people who are neurodiverse, we’ve been able to highlight the importance of providing content suitable for different learning styles.</li><li>Sometimes, I’ve seen screeners that ask, ‘Do you identify with any marginalised or oppressed groups?’ and allow people to select yes/no and self identify that way. You might want to try this option.</li><li>I explicitly try to select participants who have multiple marginalised or oppressed identities, with some places given to people who just have one or two (remember, identifying as a one of the marginalised genders, such as a woman, trans or non-binary person counts).</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7cmHYOL_Pv9T1L1m7fDbng.png" /></figure><ul><li>It’s wise to be aware that underserved and marginalised groups may not be in the more obvious places like a recruiter’s database of participants. They may also respond less keenly to calls for research since their experiences and needs are likely to have been ignored in the past. If you need to use an agency to recruit and you’re designing equitable services, it’s a good idea to prioritise recruiters that are working hard to include marginalised voices, allow for more time, and be willing to pay more money for incentives. This <a href="https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/when-researchers-build-trust-hard-reach-undocumented-communities-arent-so-hard-reach?utm_medium=facebook,linkedin,twitter&amp;utm_source=urban_social">great article</a> shares more tips on including people successfully in research who might ordinarily be assumed too ‘hard to reach’.</li></ul><p><em>* I’d love to see more examples of trauma-informed principles being applied to quant research and recruiting.</em></p><h3>Take care with language</h3><ul><li>Try to write your recruiting communications (e.g. your screener, your email follow ups) in a human way that conveys solidarity and warmth. It’s a good idea to write your questions with the help of members of an in-group (in our case survivors) and to say “Thank you for being willing to share your experience with us”.</li><li>Don’t dance around words, as this can add to taboo and stigma. Name what you mean and give examples for clarity — e.g. by saying sexual assault (including non-consensual touching).</li><li>Try to avoid using words like ‘more’ and ‘less serious’ as descriptors of an experience if you’re giving drop down options for people to review, as this is subjective. Someone can be traumatised by being harassed without ever being touched, and someone else may have a less severe reaction to a physical attack than you might expect.</li></ul><p>You might be worried that hearing from lots of different people will give you insights/user needs that feel too varied or too niche to put into action. But I’ve found that it’s actually a strong method of building confidence in insights. If you can identify clear patterns across people with significantly different experiences and identities, you can then put those into action knowing that they are more likely to serve a wider group. Conversely, when you hear about needs that are unique to a certain group, then you can discuss whether you’d like to work towards meeting them.</p><p>Limiting your sample, either deliberately or by feeling afraid to recruit the actual people you’re designing for, won’t help you on your mission to be equitable.</p><blockquote>At Chayn we don’t assume that ‘underserved’ means niche. By designing for the underserved and meeting them where they are, we know that there’s a clear pathway to scale.</blockquote><h3>Where else can you explore Plurality in UX research?</h3><p>Most researchers know that it’s good practice to get together after qualitative interviews with a team-mate (ideally the person you’ve asked to join your interview to listen/take notes) and discuss what came up.</p><p>Doing this acknowledges a kind of ‘plurality of experience’ in the research process; if I bring 3–5 points of note to the debrief, and the other person does the same, it’s unlikely that they will be the same exact points. Hearing reactions and musings from team mates goes a long way to making sure that your insights reflect a rounded ‘take’ on the data, rather than just your own, which could be biased.</p><p>With multidisciplinary teams, it’s fascinating to hear what kinds of user stories strike a chord with different team members. Everyone’s brain takes in data in their own way.</p><p>This debriefing practice also really helps from a peer support perspective, as you can share emotionally tough moments (and even make a plan for dealing with vicarious trauma).</p><p>Then, taking learnings to a wider group in the synthesis stage helps to flag any areas where you might be making biased assumptions about what people’s needs are. At Chayn, we are set up to easily and quickly bring groups of survivors and allies together who are deeply experienced in GBV globally, and can support the critical analysis of research insights that will inform our service design work.</p><h3>How else do we think about Equity at Chayn?</h3><p>Our services, being free and online, are central to our mission to be equitable. Our usage data shows that people use our services around the world, even in places where our work isn’t localised. For example, creating content in English means that anyone, anywhere who is connected to the internet and who can read English (say, a woman in Pakistan who has her own phone) can access our support. If we’d just considered English to be relevant in countries where English is the dominant language, like the USA or UK, we’d be massively limiting our reach. Conversely, and more interestingly, the UK and USA are the biggest sources of traffic for all of our different languages (we’re now at 13).</p><blockquote>This demonstrates that survivors seek to work through their trauma in their mother language. The fact that resources for doing this haven’t been easily available was part of the origin story of Chayn, and why language justice is so important to us.</blockquote><p>One thing we’re excited about at Chayn is hearing more stories from survivors by conducting research in their native languages. This is of course an equitable move, demonstrating that we don’t expect everyone to want to, or be able to share their experiences in English. We’ve long done UX research in multiple languages (such as English, Arabic, and Urdu) with our global network of staff and volunteers. Now that we’ve just completed a big project to translate Bloom into 4 more languages, we’re excited to be planning more in depth research with users in those. If you are or you know of any trauma-informed qualitative researchers speaking French, Spanish, Portuguese, or Hindi, then please get in touch.</p><p>That’s it for now. If you want to hear more about our work, or chat about recruiting, screening, and setting up sensitive research that maximises your chances of hearing from a well-balanced mix of participants, <a href="/service/mailto:jenny@chayn.co">get in touch</a>.</p><p>The other blogs in this trauma-informed UX series have been about the <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/keeping-survivors-safe-during-ux-research-eb20c1ee1f04">Safety</a>, <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/sharing-power-with-survivors-in-ux-research-e984c250fcb7">Agency and Power</a>. And the next ones will be about Trust and Accountability, and Hope.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ccc87c9290e9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://blog.chayn.co/centring-equity-and-plurality-in-ux-research-with-survivors-ccc87c9290e9">Centring Equity and Plurality in UX Research with Survivors</a> was originally published in <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/">Chayn</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sharing power with survivors in UX research]]></title>
            <link>https://blog.chayn.co/sharing-power-with-survivors-in-ux-research-e984c250fcb7?source=rss-942dfddf96fc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e984c250fcb7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-informed-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research-methods]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny H Winfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Sep 2022 07:58:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-04T19:48:25.828Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V9W69zDvBHCrsNIfDHb5YQ.png" /><figcaption>The trauma-informed principles of agency and power sharing</figcaption></figure><h4>How I practiced the trauma-informed principles of Agency and Power sharing, while leading UX research with survivors of sexual assault</h4><p>Hi, I’m Chayn’s User Researcher, Jenny. I help the team to design and build products and services that truly meet user needs. You can read more about me <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/meet-our-user-research-lead-jenny-54938a891bd3">here.</a></p><p>Since I joined Chayn, I’ve been running some qualitative research with survivors of sexual abuse and/or assault, gathering insights to inform the service design of the <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/bloom-for-bumble-and-badoo-the-online-dating-industrys-first-ever-trauma-healing-service-is-now-a7f7cc4d4e69">Bumble and Bloom partnership</a>, which has recently launched.</p><p><strong>This is the second piece in a series that shares tips and advice for anyone doing UX research around sensitive topics. The first one was about Safety. In this one I share a) how researchers can rethink consent to offer more choices and power, and b) how we can use language to offer participants more power in our research experiences.</strong></p><blockquote>Typing…. “Is it OK if I type, instead of talking?”</blockquote><blockquote>Oh man, I’m thinking. This person has agreed to a research interview and they don’t want to talk. How am I going to make this work? I nervously picture this chat petering out in the Zoom chat box, about five minutes in.</blockquote><blockquote>But then I think to myself, “What’s the worst that can happen?” And say</blockquote><blockquote>“Sure! Yes, if that would feel better?”</blockquote><blockquote>(Types….) “Yes, it would”.</blockquote><p>It’s January, and I’m just back from the winter break. It’s 4pm in the afternoon and I’m at my kitchen table, settled in with a cup of Yorkshire tea warming my hand. I wait for today’s participant to pop into the Zoom waiting room, feeling that slight jangling of nerves that comes before any research interview about a tough topic, like sexual assault.</p><p>This interview is a really important one to get right. My research will inform the service design of Chayn’s Bloom and Bumble partnership, and this is going to be my only interview with someone who identifies as a man.</p><p>So when he logs on, and tells me that he doesn’t want to talk — not with his voice anyway — I’m definitely thrown for a loop, at first. But one thing I’ve learned in doing this work is that curveballs will come at you, and being able to flex around them in the moment is all part of it.</p><p>Requesting to use the chat box, on that day, was what worked for this participant. And with a little speedy adjusting from my side, this interview actually turned out really well. We chatted for about 20 mins using the chat box, and then he felt comfortable enough to start speaking (with video chat, no less).</p><p>Working in a trauma-informed way means recognising that people often feel pretty different day-to-day, making it hard for them to anticipate how (or whether) they’ll want to take part in research in a specified way, like a video call. That said, there was definitely more I could have considered going into this research, to offer different options before the chat box suggestion came my way.</p><p>After the session ended, I started thinking more about the <strong>kinds of choices and degree of agency</strong> we can offer as user researchers when doing sensitive work like this, and what more we can do to consider and address the <strong>power dynamic that we have</strong> with our participants.</p><blockquote><em>These principles matter so much because traumatic incidents strip people of their power and agency. Trauma removes choices from people, both in the moment and in their life afterwards. Trauma-informed design solutions should be working to build power and agency back up with survivors, and our research interactions play a key part in that too.</em></blockquote><p>As an organisation, Chayn prioritises survivor agency, and power sharing.</p><p>We exist to help people who have been manipulated or abused feel as though they have choices in their lives, and we work hard to make survivor-<strong>agency feel tangible</strong> in all of our product decisions. For example, our self-guided Bloom courses are designed to be explored in any order and at any pace that a survivor wants.</p><p>The information, community, and material support we offer to survivors exists to <strong>give them power.</strong> We recognise how important this is in the context of the systemic oppression and abuse of power that many survivors have experienced, at the hands of other people or organisations, even those (sometimes especially those) which are supposed to help.</p><p>One small way that we bring this principle of power sharing to life is with our <a href="https://soulmedicine.io/">Soul Medicine project</a>, which sends survivors messages containing supportive bite-sized information and tips. We recognised our power in choosing the timing and subject lines of emails, and that not being in control of this could be stressful for survivors. So instead, we decided to give survivors the power to choose the timing and disguise the subject lines of these emails.</p><p>When looking through a research-specific lens, these trauma-informed principles of power-sharing and agency have their own implications. In this piece, I’ll share a couple of my tips for putting them into practice.</p><h3><strong>Rethinking consent, to offer choices and share power</strong></h3><p>Anyone who read <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/keeping-survivors-safe-during-ux-research-eb20c1ee1f04">my last piece about Safety</a> will know that something we like to do at Chayn is give research participants an overview of discussion topics in advance. A natural follow on from this is to call out that the participant has some choices in what we discuss, as well as how the session will be captured.</p><blockquote><em>I’ll say something like:</em></blockquote><blockquote>“When it comes to your privacy and consent, there are some things that we always do to protect our participants — for example, we strictly limit access to recruitment information in our team, we anonymise all research notes and recordings, and we store our data securely and confidentially, before deleting it after 12 months.”</blockquote><blockquote>“But there are choices that you can make too. I’d like you to think of this as your session, and therefore you’ll be in control. You’ll get to choose which questions you answer. You can choose whether to have your camera on/off while we chat, whether a note taker joins our call, and whether the session is recorded (using notes, audio and/or video) or not.”</blockquote><p>One way to give participants more agency is to design your interview sessions in a way that creates space for <strong>flexibility and choices.</strong></p><ul><li>Are you offering people the chance to review your topics in advance and pushing back on any they’re not keen to discuss?</li><li>Could you consider offering different formats for people who, as I experienced, may not want a video chat but could take part confidently via text box or phone? Are you flexible enough to change this on the day, depending on how they’re feeling?</li><li>Are you offering the widest possible selection of interview dates and times that enable them to take part when they’re more likely to feel mentally able to?</li></ul><p>Giving participants choices is trauma-informed in itself, but there’s a step further you can go; you can really encourage participants to take you up on them. I think one of the most powerful examples of this is how you design your consent process.</p><h3>Presenting choices vs encouraging choices</h3><p>Now, consent is a lot bigger than consent forms, but they are a good place to start since most UX teams use them, and many could improve them.</p><p>Our consent forms at Chayn are <a href="https://forms.gle/PeKcUwMSHNJp5hUg6">friendly Google forms</a> which centre the participant and their choices, while explaining clearly what our intentions and needs are. They are also easy to ‘sign’ digitally, taking away the headache of printing and scanning. You can feel free to read and adapt ours.</p><p>Our form tries to take into account that people who have been traumatised and/or exploited may well have had a bad time filling in forms. They’re often long, scary things that users can easily ‘get wrong’ and which exacerbate power disparities; a form might withhold services unless you fill it in right, or simply be impossible to complete without help, through language that’s rock solid to navigate.</p><blockquote><em>Many organisations say, </em>“You must read and sign the consent form before the interview begins.”</blockquote><blockquote><em>It’s more trauma-informed to send your consent form well in advance (I like to do it about a week before) and say:</em></blockquote><blockquote>“Please take some time to look over our consent form, and give me a shout with any questions or concerns. It’s entirely up to you whether the session* is joined by anyone else on our team and/or recorded, so just let me know your preference. I’m here to help.”</blockquote><figure><img alt="An illustration of a person with pink hair, wearing a yellow polka dotted shirt, with speech bubbles around them. Text on the right side of the image says: *I never use the word interview with participants. Interviews often remind people of high stakes, stressful situations where they have been judged. Instead, I always use the word chat, session or discussion, and that goes for all recruitment emails, consent forms, calendar invites and, ahem, the interview itself." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Qpupx9HuOC-5X4ozS2L1mQ.png" /></figure><p>It can be handy to ask yourself:</p><ul><li>Are you (unwittingly) exploiting a power dynamic of control by using language related to privacy and consent that’s hard to understand, question or say no to?</li><li>Are you giving participants enough time to read, reflect, and understand what you want to do with them?</li><li>Does your consent process feel empowering as well as informative?</li></ul><p>In my experience, if people are making active, specific choices (yes to this, no to that) about consent, this indicates far higher engagement and trust than if they just blindly sign forms.</p><p>Of course, it’s always fun to look outside of your immediate world for inspiration. We can learn a lot about active, enthusiastic consent from sex-positive resources and how they’ve inspired ideas around tech consent too. <a href="https://www.consentfultech.io/">See The Consentful Tech Project here.</a></p><h3><strong>Acknowledging power differentials</strong></h3><p>As a researcher, you hold a position of power. You’re the connector, the interpreter between an organisation / a greater movement, and the individuals that you’re hoping to support. Thinking about the power baked into your research role is essential for becoming more trauma-informed and responsive.</p><figure><img alt="An illustration of two people with their hands raised in the air. The text on the right side says: A great tip I learned from a prison psychologist a few years back, when I was conducting research with women in prison, was to recognise and actually talk about the power differential between you and the participant." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZLyVTsKEph8egXVuwIvvzQ.png" /></figure><blockquote><em>This prison psychologist said to me:</em></blockquote><blockquote>“Instead of pretending that you are on the same level, talk openly about the fact that you are the one holding more power. I’ll tell the (women in prison):</blockquote><blockquote>“Look, I know that I sound like I have a posh voice and I’ve asked you to come here to talk with me today, and you didn’t really get a choice in the matter. But, I am here to listen to you, and I’m going to give you some choices in how we use our time together”</blockquote><blockquote>So I’ll let them choose which chair to sit on and where that chair is positioned in the room (often they like to move it so they can see the door), and which order we talk about the topics, to give them some agency.”</blockquote><p>This advice has directly inspired me in my work in researching taboo topics. Taking part in research is obviously different from attending a psychologist appointment in prison, and participants do have a choice about whether they take part. But her direct, kind manner really stuck with me (and she became the first person to really teach me about trauma-informed practices).</p><p>Now, I always try to be mindful of the power dynamic that’s naturally created when one person is the organiser of a research session and one is joining in to share.</p><blockquote><em>I try to address this in sessions by saying something like:</em></blockquote><blockquote>“I’m really glad to have you here and I’m sorry that it’s in these circumstances — and about this topic/experience — that we’re meeting. Before we start, I just want to say that I understand that this is quite an unusual thing to be doing on a Thursday morning — talking with someone you’ve never met before about an experience as personal as this (e.g. sexual assault). Even if you want to be having this chat, it’s still not really normal. So, if you’re feeling a bit weird about that, I totally get it. Today we’re going to take it slow together, and see how it goes. We can stop or change topics at any time, and you won’t be letting me or anybody down if we do. We’re just here to learn from you.”</blockquote><p>I find this is quite a good leveller and just calls out the objective discomfort of being asked questions related to a traumatic incident.</p><h3><strong>Sharing power through offering to change your language</strong></h3><p>Finally, something else I like to do, to help distribute some power to survivors, is ask them in advance about the kind of language they’d like me to use.</p><blockquote><em>In this recent research, I said in prep emails:</em></blockquote><blockquote>“If there are any words or phrases that you particularly like, or prefer to be avoided when referring to you personally or your experience, then please feel free to let me know in advance. I’ll also ask you at the start of our session. There is no need to reply to this, if not.”</blockquote><p>This gives people the chance to give you a heads up, without requiring an answer. I heard back really helpful things like “I dislike hearing the word rape”, “I don’t actually identify with the word survivor”, “My pronouns are they/them”.</p><p>You can reference their answers when you begin your session, showing that you see them as an individual, and that you’re starting off on some common ground. It’s also a nice example of power sharing, through being willing to let them take the lead.</p><p><strong>That’s it for now. </strong>Watch out for my next piece in this series, where I’ll talk about our trauma-informed principle of <strong>equity</strong> — how we use research to build our services with people who have a spectrum of survivor experiences. There will be further pieces on<strong> trust/accountability</strong> and the role of <strong>hope</strong> in trauma-informed design research. You can read my first piece on <strong>safety </strong><a href="https://blog.chayn.co/keeping-survivors-safe-during-ux-research-eb20c1ee1f04">here.</a></p><p><strong>Our principles at Chayn mean we do everything we can to make taking part in research enriching, not extractive. You can find out more about that in </strong><a href="https://chayn.notion.site/Orbits-a-global-field-guide-to-advance-intersectional-survivor-centred-and-trauma-informed-interve-8d8dc6a1436543b8b25af63ddafaa409"><strong>Orbits</strong></a><strong>, our global field guide to advance intersectional, survivor-centred, and trauma-informed interventions to TGBV.</strong></p><p>If you’re doing UX research in a trauma-informed way, what are your tips and tricks for giving people choices and addressing power dynamics? I’m still learning, so feel free to connect and share with me on the topic.</p><p><em>Jenny is Chayn’s user researcher. She practices with a trauma-informed approach, ensuring that our services are survivor centric. She is a specialist in conducting research and design strategy to tackle taboos. Find out more about her </em><a href="https://blog.chayn.co/meet-our-user-research-lead-jenny-54938a891bd3"><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e984c250fcb7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://blog.chayn.co/sharing-power-with-survivors-in-ux-research-e984c250fcb7">Sharing power with survivors in UX research</a> was originally published in <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/">Chayn</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Keeping survivors safe during UX research]]></title>
            <link>https://blog.chayn.co/keeping-survivors-safe-during-ux-research-eb20c1ee1f04?source=rss-942dfddf96fc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eb20c1ee1f04</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-informed]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[service-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-informed-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny H Winfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Aug 2022 16:37:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-23T09:05:05.025Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="An illustration of a heart shaped lock inside a circle with the word Safety written on the right-side" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tT5te0Mv4668cIOH0PBbfg.png" /><figcaption>The trauma-informed principle of safety</figcaption></figure><h3>Helping survivors to feel safe during UX research</h3><h4>How I practiced the trauma-informed principle of Safety, while leading research with survivors of sexual assault</h4><p>Hi, I’m Chayn’s User Researcher, Jenny. I help the team to design and build products and services that truly meet user needs. You can read more about me <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/meet-our-user-research-lead-jenny-54938a891bd3">here.</a></p><p>Since I joined Chayn, I’ve been running some qualitative research with survivors of sexual abuse and/or assault, gathering insights to inform the service design of the <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/bloom-for-bumble-and-badoo-the-online-dating-industrys-first-ever-trauma-healing-service-is-now-a7f7cc4d4e69">Bumble and Bloom partnership</a>, which has recently launched.</p><p>Inspired by that process, I’ll be sharing a mini-series of blogs, with some learnings and practical tips for running research in a trauma-informed way, for anyone working in the same field. Find the full set <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/tagged/user-research">here</a>.</p><p><strong>This first piece explores the principle of Safety.</strong></p><blockquote>“I can sense that you’re feeling very upset. Shall we take a minute to pause, and do some breathing together?”</blockquote><blockquote>“Yes, please.”</blockquote><p>It’s the day before Christmas eve, and I’m in my parent’s study. It’s dark and drizzly outside, and I’m running the last user interview before the holidays. My participant is taking me through her experience of sexual assault, and although this story is not something I’ve directly asked her to talk about, I can feel in my bones that she needs to. Her tears are those of relief. She’s sharing this for the first time, with anybody, ever.</p><p>It was also a first for me, not that someone had cried in an interview, but that they had cried in such a way that I felt we should take a break. I drew upon one of the practices that’s embedded into many of our Chayn team meetings — a grounding exercise. We took some deep breaths together. After, I checked in whether she wanted to carry on. She did.</p><p>Here at Chayn, we design for safety as as one of our trauma-informed principles — meaning that our services and resources prioritise survivor safety, both physically and psychologically (from the prominent ‘Leave this site’ button on our website, to the practical support that our content offers survivors for escaping abusive relationships).</p><p>Safety is central to our research process too, because user research is a key touchpoint we have with survivors; helping participants to feel psychologically safe anytime they interact with us is my job. You want your participants to feel safe before, during, and after their time spent with you, not only because it’s the right thing to do, but because you develop deeper insights that way too. Here are some trauma-informed tips related to Safety, from my experience:</p><h3><strong>Before your research interview</strong></h3><h4><strong>Setting it up</strong></h4><p>One thing I did on this project was to let folks know in advance which topics I wanted to cover in the discussion, so that there wouldn’t be any surprises on the day. I also made sure to say what I <em>wouldn’t be asking them about</em> so that they could mentally prepare and hopefully avoid anxiety.</p><p>Although it might feel tempting to keep things light-hearted and even vague in your recruitment and prep comms, out of fear of scaring your participant away…</p><blockquote><em>For example, in the past, I might have said something like,</em> “It’s going to be a really relaxed chat, and you’ll get to choose what we talk about.”</blockquote><p>I’ve found that it actually makes participants feel much safer when they know my plan for how the discussion will run, and to have some roles and boundaries in place.</p><blockquote><em>It’s more trauma-informed to say</em>, “We’ll talk for an hour, and I will lead the discussion. It will feel friendly and supportive. First, I’ll ask you about X, then about Y. Then, we will look at some designs together on my screen, so that I can hear your feedback. I won’t be asking you about X, but you can share what you’d like to. You are the expert in your needs, so our main goal will be listening to and learning from you.” <em>I then reiterate this at the start of the session.</em></blockquote><p>In prep emails, I always give the participant the option to query, push back or request changes to the planned topics, to give them to best chance of feeling comfortable.</p><p>An unfortunate legacy of marketing-focused research is the tendency to withhold information from participants. I used to work in this world. In focus groups of old, the brand would always be kept a secret until right at the end of the session, and participants were rarely told what a research session would entail, for fear of priming them or skewing the answers. In trauma-informed design research, we flip this notion entirely.</p><p>You’re not asking for people’s reaction to a new ad. You’re asking for them to share their truth, their experiences and needs with you.</p><blockquote>A survivor is not going to be ‘more primed’ about their trauma and their needs than they already are naturally. A carefully informed and prepared participant is a safer one — and helps you to learn in a more collaborative way.</blockquote><p>As a researcher, you are unlikely to be able to eliminate anxiety totally from a participants’ research experience. But this approach — being really clear about exactly what you want to do and explore together — can go some way to making participants feel safe, if they do feel intrigued to participate.</p><h4>Physical comfort and safety</h4><p>You might also want to think about physical comfort and safety. Since we’re doing all qualitative research on Zoom now, I’d normally ask participants to chat with me from their home. But this is not necessarily safe or possible for people who have been sexually abused and/or assaulted.</p><p>They may have had to change their living situation and be in between places, or still be living with their abuser, where they wouldn’t have a safe space to talk about this stuff.</p><p>When making requests about their practical set up, be mindful that being at home, or having a quiet, distraction-free space is a privilege not available to everyone. On this project we had 2 participants who had moved in with their parents for extra support, and so needed to be offered interview times when their folks weren’t around to overhear them.</p><figure><img alt="An illustration of a person with curly hair holding a cat" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ajh0329bBjcQzvIUiiZuGw.png" /></figure><blockquote><em>I’d say, </em>“Choose a space and time where you feel safe, and you’re more likely to be able to talk freely”.</blockquote><p>In previous research projects, I’ve actively discouraged participants joining an interview from their workplace or in their car, while caring for their child or while taking a walk, because I’d feel that it wasn’t the way to do things. But in this context, it’s about letting the participant define what’s safe for them, and adapting to that. You may not get the perfect sound recording or their full attention, but you’re hearing from survivors in the place they feel safest.</p><h3><strong>During your research interview</strong></h3><h4>Guiding the conversation and staying on track</h4><p>Something that intersects commonly with trauma is having trouble with focused attention. This can manifest in interviews, with the participant struggling to stay on topic or oversharing very personal things, which could lead to them feeling quite unsafe afterwards. I often find that it helps to keep an active eye during the session on how the participant is feeling and responding, to try and contain the chat and prevent this from happening.</p><p>If you are clear in your set-up about how you’d like to focus your conversation, then even if it starts to veer away, you can bring it back carefully to the topics you’ve outlined. I led one session where the participant seemed to be losing the thread of the conversation, and I was feeling conscious of time slipping by. I waited for the next pause, and said:</p><blockquote>“You know, I feel that you and I could talk for hours about this! What you’ve shared about X and Y is so interesting/insightful. I’m learning a lot from you. Would it be OK if I asked you about a few other things in the time we have left?”</blockquote><p>My participant seemed relieved that she’d been gently guided back from oversharing. The key here is to make it clear that you’re not moving on out of lack of interest, but because there is so much more you’d like to explore and learn from them.</p><p>If your participant starts to seem overwhelmed or very emotional, you can recognise that too.</p><blockquote><em>I would say something like</em>: “I can sense how difficult this experience was for you, I’m so sorry you went through this. It sounds so hard.”</blockquote><p>You can make it clear that strong emotions are absolutely OK (it’s your job to hold space for those) but also that the participant is free to stop at any time. Doing a grounding or breathing exercise together can help as a mini reset, if the participant wants to.</p><p>You can also just ask them how they’re doing; during this research, I built 2–3 consent checkpoints into the discussion guide. This meant that a few times during the session, we stopped to see how the participant was feeling, and gave them the chance to take a break, grab a glass of water, switch topics, or stop completely. More often than not, this checkpoint gave me a chance to recap what I’d learned so far, and refocus the conversation with good energy.</p><h3><strong>After your research interview</strong></h3><h4>Personal well being</h4><p>It’s so important to plan for your own safety and that of your colleagues. On this project, we had a mini-debrief after each interview (good practice anyway to discuss fresh insights) but we checked in with each other emotionally too.</p><p>Many of us at Chayn are survivors and coping with our own traumas. Chayn ensures all staff have free access to an online therapy service (Spill). I organised a one-off session after leading a particularly difficult interview where I felt I’d taken on a lot of anger from the participant. It really helped to share the feelings that had come up for me. Aspects of these interviews were tough and I felt raw afterwards sometimes, as any human will when doing this kind of work.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-B7hPp2KuB0wmfvZ7PNbWQ.png" /><figcaption>Accessing therapy for our own wellbeing</figcaption></figure><p>At Chayn, we work in a trauma-informed way, which means that as a team we are aware and well-versed in issues like vicarious trauma and the impact of our work on our own wellbeing. We have a culture of openly discussing our feelings, prioritising self care, and we ask for each others’ help in sharing difficult experiences as they arise. We also plan research in a way that means we are taking care of ourselves. For example, I never conduct more than two-three qualitative interviews per day, because after that point I’m not 100% confident that I’m taking care of our participants, my colleagues, and myself adequately to do this work well.</p><p>If you want to learn more about supporting yourself in the best way while you’re exploring trauma, I really recommend <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/5653041-trauma-stewardship">‘Trauma Stewardship’ </a>by <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/2524307.Laura_Van_Dernoot_Lipsky">Laura Van Dernoot Lipsky</a>.</p><h3><strong>Following up</strong></h3><p>It’s also a good idea to follow up with participants who have shared any distress, and check in with how they’re doing. I’ll usually do this the day after, to give them chance to reflect, and I’ll always take the opportunity to mention how much I learned and how well I felt the interview went.</p><p>You can offer to share relevant supportive resources, and assure them that their generosity in sharing is going to support your work — and other people in a similar position to them too. More on that in the upcoming post about practicing the trauma-informed principle of Hope.</p><blockquote>Ultimately, a participants’ comfort and safety is more important than your research project. And, if this is your mindset, you’re likely to develop much richer insights anyway through creating positive research experiences.</blockquote><p>That’s all for now. You may be wondering where things like privacy and consent fit in — since they cross over with safety for sure, but I cover those in our next post, which will be about Agency, Choice and Power Redistribution. For more tips on how to do qualitative research in a trauma-informed way, follow this series. I’m still learning too, so if you have a similar approach and are working in this space, please do connect <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/jenny-winfield/">here.</a></p><p><em>You can read all of Jenny’s pieces about conducting trauma-informed research at Chayn </em><a href="http://Find the full set here."><em>here</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>You can read more about Chayn’s latest version of Trauma-informed Design Principles in </em><a href="https://chayn.notion.site/chayn/Orbits-a-global-field-guide-to-advance-intersectional-survivor-centred-and-trauma-informed-interv-8d8dc6a1436543b8b25af63ddafaa409"><em>Orbits</em></a><em>. Orbits is our global field guide to advance intersectional, survivor-centred, and trauma-informed interventions to Technology- facilitated Gender Based Violence (TGBV).</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eb20c1ee1f04" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://blog.chayn.co/keeping-survivors-safe-during-ux-research-eb20c1ee1f04">Keeping survivors safe during UX research</a> was originally published in <a href="https://blog.chayn.co/">Chayn</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bereavement brain and group consent]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@winnyltd/five-things-i-learned-from-doing-research-with-people-bereaved-by-suicide-259caaea9e72?source=rss-942dfddf96fc------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/259caaea9e72</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-informed]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux-research]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[service-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[suicide-bereavement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny H Winfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 28 Jul 2022 10:04:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-18T07:26:49.018Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Five learnings from UX research with folks bereaved by suicide</p><p>Last year, I did a pro bono piece of UX research for a brilliant charity called Suicide&amp;Co. They exist to support those bereaved by suicide with shared resources, stories, a conversation guide and now, free counselling. Check them out: <a href="https://www.suicideandco.org/">https://www.suicideandco.org/</a></p><p>As with many founders, they were building a digital product with insight drawn from their own personal experiences, in this case of of suicide bereavement, but they hadn’t done any user research before to inform their strategy and services. I help lots of start ups do their first round of user research, and move their understanding of the problem space from personal hunches to a defined set of problems to solve.</p><p>I spent time with five people who had lost loved ones to suicide and tested out Suicide&amp;Co’s proposition, as well as some of the tools on their website, such as their <a href="https://www.suicideandco.org/our-conversation-guide">conversation guide</a>. This work only took 5 working days, showing how much can be achieved with a small, focused piece of qualitative research.</p><p>The first three tips are about process, which should be helpful for any researchers embarking on work with people who are suicide bereaved. The final two are about content, which should help anyone designing solutions in this space.</p><h3><strong>1. Ask your participants about their preferred language.</strong></h3><p>There are some obvious words to avoid when discussing suicide — for example, the word ‘committed’, which is outdated and inappropriate now that suicide has long been decriminalised. But in doing this work, I realised that other words are a matter of preference.</p><blockquote>One of my participants disliked the word ‘loss’ because she felt it implies that if she just looked a bit harder, she’d find her loved one.</blockquote><p>There will be many instances like this, where a word, like ‘loss’ is widely used, but doesn’t feel right to individuals. You can’t anticipate all of the words and phrases that people may dislike, so it’s OK to ask. Once I realised this, I stopped being nervous about saying the wrong thing in interviews, and equipped myself with the info that I needed to have a good conversation by asking participants about their preferences.</p><p>It’s good practice to ask participants in advance about the words and phrases they prefer to use and dislike, and doing this is likely to contribute towards them feeling in safe hands. You can do this either in recruitment emails or at the beginning of interviews (I like to do both).</p><blockquote>I would say,<em> </em>‘it’s important to me that this conversation feels as comfortable as possible for you, and so, whilst there are certain words that I won’t use (e.g. committed) please do let me know if there are others that you feel strongly about me avoiding or including as we chat’</blockquote><p>As someone who doesn’t work full time in this world, I also realise that I can’t know everything — I’m not an expert on suicide bereavement. So asking the team at Suicide&amp;Co for any pointers and watch-outs was a great help too. If you’re freelance and working across multiple sectors, ask for the help you need to get up to speed quickly.</p><p>This tip goes for most taboo areas — for example in my work with survivors of sexual assault, there are often words (e.g. victim) that we don’t use, but others that people have personal preferences over (such as whether the word rape is used). Participants will largely be happy that you asked, so go ahead.</p><p>Remember, part of the reason that topics are ‘taboo’ is that they’re deliberately not talked about, and common language is lacking. Breaking the silence is going to take some feeling out.</p><h3><strong>2. Consider a group consent form.</strong></h3><p>I learned from one participant that for her, sharing her story about suicide bereavement was not just her decision. She wanted to ask her family for wider consent to share the story of her loved one’s death. So I created a bespoke consent form for this project that enabled her to get the consent of other people in sharing their story. You can check out the group consent form <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1_FQ05EROe2Bttzq8djnMQcwp-4HZG3IG/view?usp=sharing">here</a> and feel free to adapt/use as you wish.</p><p>This was a small tweak for me to make to our form, and took less than 10 minutes, but one that meant the difference between her participating and not.</p><h3><strong>3. Find people with different experiences</strong></h3><p>This pretty much goes for any research project, but it’s especially vital to hear different perspectives when you are only speaking with small numbers of people, and about a topic which is so important to grasp well.</p><p>Usually in recruiting, you’d be looking for a mix of demographics, cultural background, gender identities, etc, and all of this stands. But for this research, I deliberately tried to find people who would have different experiences of suicide bereavement, through asking in our screener about their relationship to the person who took their own life, and when that person died. I figured that these 2 questions would be the most useful in helping us to recruit participants who had a range of different needs from our services.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CpWqIbo_rodMufc-YhpS2w.png" /></figure><p>Asking this meant that I could find and hear from people who had respectively lost: their daughter, their partner, their aunt, and their dad, and with varying recency. We heard very different stories and challenges, but we also identified common needs — which was immensely helpful. You can be more confident that your insights will be more relevant if you’ve gleaned them from a wider range of people (even within a mini recruit like this).</p><p>It can be tempting when doing research around taboo topics to assume no one will want to talk to you, or you might feel too demanding if you ask to try and find a mix of people. This isn’t the case. There are lots of people who want to talk about taboo topics, if they are given a chance and a safe environment. This is especially true if you’re working on creating something hopeful that will help others in the future.</p><blockquote>Be clear about who will help you to learn the most, and ensure you wait to start research until you’re confident in your mix of diverse participants. For this research we created a simple screener in google forms and a posted on Suicide&amp;Co’s instagram page to spread the word about the research.</blockquote><h4>The next two learnings are insights about content, and should be useful for anyone working in this space.</h4><h3>4. Bereavement brain is a thing</h3><p>Two women — one who had lost her daughter and one who’d lost her partner to suicide — helped me to understand the idea of <em>‘</em><strong><em>bereavement brain’</em></strong>. They both spoke about how hard it was to concentrate on anything in the aftermath of the suicide, whilst at the same time being ravenous for information to explain, contextualise and support them in their loss. They wanted info, but they often couldn’t process it.</p><p>They liked using Instagram for suicide related information and advice, because it enabled them to either read posts or linked resources in full at the time, or simply save the post for later — when they felt more able to process ideas or advice.</p><p>Instagram became a single place for them to find saved information, vs it being scattered around the web.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4ZxyHUCkyjiQSp5BRikxQw.jpeg" /><figcaption>An example of the kind of info that participants liked to save to read later</figcaption></figure><p>This made it clear for us that Suicide&amp;Co’s focus on building content on Instagram was a practical and helpful move for the bereaved, not just a prettier place to promote their work. It also helped us to think more deeply about information processing — if people struggle to concentrate on reading — then having more visual, video and audio content is something to prioritise in future.</p><p>Knowing that people are hungry for information, but that appetite and capacity for concentration may be compromised, think about how your content is going to work for someone with ‘bereavement brain’.</p><p>The same goes for designing discussion guides and writing recruitment emails. Keep the main questions or requests light and simple, and include more information in a well designed, visually calming participant information sheet. Offer the chance to have a phone call to talk the details over. Give people longer to respond before you assume they’re not interested, as they may not be reading emails on the day you message.</p><h3>5. Helpful resources are the specific</h3><p>Another key insight that I learned was about how to improve the charity’s conversation guide. This is a part of their site that aims to support people with opening up about suicide. What I learned was that although participants found the guide broadly good, it felt a bit too much like a beginners’ guide to be helpful for them; they needed support that was much more specific and practical.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jCq_zos4SZQHJ1Lmow2rQA.png" /></figure><p>The guide tries to normalise talking about emotions and reassure the reader that they’re not alone. What participants told me was that they were dealing with much more pressing and difficult conversations than their own feelings. They might be trying to figure out how to tell a child about a suicide, how to tell someone’s workplace, their friends, and their bank or utilities provider. They needed conversation guides and advice for all of these things, because they’re all totally different challenges in their own right.</p><p>This led us to think about a second version of the guide which will include more real stories, FAQ’s and practical examples of how to navigate these really vital conversations. I was pleased to see Suicide&amp;Co post recently about the practical concerns surrounding inquests and how suicide bereaved people can prepare themselves here, too.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VMwmVVShvfUU34kc9pwTGQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>When creating resources, think about specific use cases and scenarios where people really need support (or speak with your user base to find out what these are). These will help to guide your content into places you may not have thought about but will genuinely help people, rather than paying lip service to their experience.</p><h4>When doing research and about taboo issues and with vulnerable groups, every interview is a real act of courage on the part of your participants. Making their generosity count, by feeding insights into the design and improvement of user-centric, innovative and well designed services is my job — and something that gives them hope too.</h4><h4>Find out more about my work on <a href="http://www.jennywinfield.co.uk/">www.jennywinfield.co.uk</a></h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=259caaea9e72" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>