<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Yatin Shah on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Yatin Shah on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@yatinrshah?source=rss-18aa8a6bd308------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 05:59:43 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@yatinrshah/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[NOTES ON TRANSMISSION OF TENANCY & BONAFIDE USER UNDER THE MAHARASHTRA RENT CONTROL ACT, 1999]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@yatinrshah/notes-on-transmission-of-tenancy-bonafide-user-under-the-maharashtra-rent-control-act-1999-322539d27dfb?source=rss-18aa8a6bd308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/322539d27dfb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[law-student]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[academic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[notes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lawyers]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yatin Shah]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 Mar 2026 12:45:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-23T12:45:27.252Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>NOTES ON TRANSMISSION OF TENANCY &amp; BONAFIDE USER UNDER THE MAHARASHTRA RENT CONTROL ACT, 1999</p><p>By: Mr. Yatin R. Shah</p><p>Solicitor</p><p>TRANSMISSION OF TENANCY:</p><p>Tenancy as we understand normally is a contract between two persons viz; the landlord and a tenant and a tenancy is a created by a contract between these two persons.</p><p>By a legal fiction on the determination of tenancy by the landlord under whatever circumstances, the tenancy then automatically becomes “statutory tenancy” meaning thereby that the tenancy though terminated, the existing rights of a tenant are protected by operation of law till the time legal recourse is taken against a tenant by the landlord by initiating proceedings under the relevant Rent Control Legislations, which in Maharashtra was earlier the Bombay Rent Hotels and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947 (better known as Bombay Rent Act, 1947) as it then stood and now the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 w. e. f 31st March, 2000.</p><p>There is one more offshoot of this being the concept of tenant holding over and the concept of Tenant at sufferance. The first one is when despite termination, the occupation of a tenant is continued by express or implied consent of the landlord. The second is when the Tenant continues in occupation against the wishes of the landlord.</p><p>The concept of transmission of tenancy comes from the concept of transfer by operation of law. The transfer of tenancy is otherwise by contract or by operation of law and transmission is something which takes effect by operation of law and is in that sense involuntary.</p><p>In the same manner like in other transfer by operation of law the concept of transmission of tenancy has evolved through years by legislative enactments. It was in the Bombay Rent Act initially and there was a new amendment in respect of tenanted premises by Amendment Act in the Bombay Rent Hotels and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947 (better known as Bombay Rent Act, 1947) by Maharashtra Act no. XXII of 1978, whereby the earlier provision was changed. The law has gradually evolved over a period of time starting from the judgment of the Supreme Court in Anand Nivas AIR 1965 SC 414 and Jagdish Chander Chatterjee AIR 1972 SC 2526. Thereafter there was one more judgment being of Damadilal AIR 1976 SC 2229. There was one more landmark being whether a deceased tenant whose tenancy has been determined and against whom eviction proceeding was pending were entitled to the benefit of protection afforded to the tenant after determination of tenancy in respect of business premises. The Supreme Court in the decision of Ganpat Ladha AIR 1978 SC 955 took the view that the benefit of the tenancy enured to the benefit of the members of the family. There was one more Judgement being of V. Dhanpal Chettiar AIR 1979 SC 1745 . To settle the divergent views, the Supreme Court in a 5 Judges Bench matter viz; Gian Devi vs. Jeevan Kumar AIR 1985 SC 796 settled the law and emphatically laid down that the provisions of statutory tenancy are applicable equally to commercial as well residential premises and that there is no difference between these two kinds of premises when it comes to question of protection as a statutory tenant.</p><p>It may be noted that the provision of S. 5 (11) (c) of the Bombay Rent Act is now incorporated in S. 7 (15) (d) of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act,1999 and the provision is more or less the same under both these legislations viz; that the person gets protection as a statutory tenant. The other facet of this provision is in respect of the manner in which transmission does occur as there are different aspects so far as this is concerned and though as laid down by the Courts definitely the tenancy gets transmitted to the next generation but to whom is a vexed question which has led to many views and too many conflicts in the Courts on a regular basis. The provision is that when the tenant dies, the persons viz; member of the tenant’s family who is residing with him in case the premises is residential or in case of a commercial premises, a member of the tenant’s family carrying on business with the tenant will become the “tenant”. If there is only one member of the tenant’s family then no issue arises, however, in case of more than one member of the family the dispute start and this where the provision comes into effect. It is laid down that in case there are more than one members of the family then the tenancy devolves upon any heir of the tenant by agreement between the members of the family and in case no agreement is reached by the members of the family then in that case the Court is to decide this particular issue and there are innumerable instances when suits are filed for declaration of tenancy as being heirs of the deceased tenant and there have been divergent views on this peculiar question and as human behavior is unpredictable so also various permutations and combinations arise on this particular issue and there have been various judgments on the different dimensions on the question of transmission in the favour of a particular heir of a tenant.</p><p>The Courts have evolved various principles of law pertaining to various dimensions on transmission of tenancy over a long period of time and the law is still evolving every day.</p><p>The Division Bench of Bombay High Court has stated that the provisions of S. 5 (11) (c) are not meant to supersede the rights of inheritance to tenancy vesting in the heirs under the personal law of the tenant and provisions of the legislation must yield to the superior rights of inheritance of the tenants. (1977) 80 Bom LR p 12 (DB).This view followed the view of Tulzapurkar J in an old Unreported Judgement.</p><p>An interesting question arose in a matter in Bombay High Court of whether a woman who is mistress of a tenant can claim to be a tenant if she is residing together with the tenant at the time of his death. (1978) 80 Bom LR p 365. This judgment did not decide this point and held otherwise relying on Anand Nivas AIR 1965 SC 414.</p><p>The rights of tenancy devolve on the heirs of the tenant as per the ordinary law of succession by which the tenant may be governed. AIR 1985 SC 796.</p><p>In case of dispute between various members of a tenant’s family claiming tenancy rights, the Court has to decide the rights and the Court can only make a choice and declare one amongst the legal heirs to be the tenant and normally the person in occupation with the tenant has a member of his family is given precedence. (2004) 1 Bom CR 839.</p><p>The tenancy rights though heritable do not confer any right on tenant to bequeath the tenancy rights by will and if any legacy is made a will by the tenant the same need not be considered and the heirs of tenant under the general law of succession will gain prevalence. AIR 1994 SCW 2601. This judgment upheld the judgment of the Bombay High Court in AIR 1980 Bom 69.</p><p>If the elder son is made a tenant after death of a tenant, he takes precedence over other legal heirs. 2001(II) UC 225 (SC) (Much more can be done by going further on this issue and in some future judgement there will be further clarity on this issue.</p><p>If a person is not related by blood to the tenant and is a stranger, he will not be included in the term “Tenant”. AIR 2002 Bom 462.</p><p>The right of a statutory tenant in a tenanted premises can be attached and sold in execution. AIR 2004 Bom 198 (FB)</p><p>A servant cannot claim rights as a “tenant” under the Rent control Act. (2006) 6 Bom CR 642</p><p>In case a partnership firm is a tenant and the firm is dissolved, the partnership loses the protection as a statutory Tenant and cannot claim protection under the Rent Control Act . 2019 (5) ADR 143</p><p>If there is a member of the Family of the tenant carrying on business with him, he excludes all other legal heirs of the tenant. 2016 1 Mah LJ 461.</p><p>BONAFIDE REQUIREMENT:</p><p>The law of bonafide requirement has been in the Bombay Rent Act in S.13 (1) (g) since the inception and provisions in respect of public charitable trust being a landlord were later incorporated in 1953. The provision in the Maharashtra Rent Control Act is in S.16 (1) (g) and the provision has remained the same without any change. The basic requirement is that the premises is “reasonably and bonafide” required by the landlord for “occupation by himself” or by “any person for whose benefit” the premises are held. Accordingly, there are two facets which are required to be analyzed viz; that the premises are required for bonafide user and that the premises are required for occupation by the landlord or any person claiming under him.</p><p>The provision of bonafide requirement as a ground of eviction arises out of the need to balance statutory protection to tenants as against genuine needs of the landlords under certain circumstances. The provision for bonafide requirement of a landlord is something which is a natural incident of ownership of a property and the statute recognizes this attribute of property law while putting certain conditions under which a landlord can claim such rights. The law has evolved into balancing the rights of the landlord and a tenant and just like human behavior different dimensions come out of different circumstances under which bonafide requirement is successful or unsuccessful as a ground of eviction.</p><p>There are certain basic criteria to be met for the Landlord to succeed in an action for Bonafide user and that is:</p><p>the need of the landlord should be genuine and not illusory;</p><p>the need of the Landlord should be reasonable;</p><p>the need may be of the landlord himself or his successor ;</p><p>the tenant will have to demonstrate a comparative hardship to him qua the claim of bonafide user.</p><p>The Courts have evolved different principles amongst which few maybe noted below:</p><p>The need of the landlord should be shown to be “genuine”. The landlord’s mere desire to occupy itself is not sufficient. The landlord has to show that there is a bonafide need/requirement for his own use and occupation or use and occupation by a family member. AIR 1988 SC 1060</p><p>The need should be reasonable as also bonafide and mere reasonableness or mere bonafide requirement are not sufficient. AIR 2001 SCW 5248. 2017 5 SCC 683.</p><p>The bonafide need has to be construed meaningfully without giving any straightjacket or stringent formula. AIR 1980 SC 315.</p><p>The landlord is said to be the best judge of his need and has a complete freedom to choose and proceed further and there can be no fetter on this proposition. AIR 2000 SC 534, AIR Online 2019 UTR 396. AIR 2017 SC 1047.</p><p>The bonafide need has to be taken as of the date of the application for eviction and nothing beyond that needs to be considered if the bonafide requirement as of the date of application for eviction is shown to be genuine. AIR 2019 SC 4525.</p><p>If an application for bonafide requirement is filed then subsequent events which may occur pursuant to the application and pending litigation are also required to be seen and considered. AIR 1985 SC 207. AIR 2017 SC 814.</p><p>The requirement may be either for residential or for non-residential premises and is not restricted only to residential premises. AIR 2010 SC 330.</p><p>In case the need is proved to be bonafide and genuine, then in that case there is no requirement for the landlord to even step in the witness box. AIR 1999 SC 3089. AIR 2017 SC 1047.</p><p>If there is a transfer of the title by the landlord then in that case, the transferee cannot continue the same proceeding and will have to show an independent bonafide requirement and then file new proceedings. AIR Online 1987 SC 75.</p><p>Sometimes it so happens that the landlord may suggest another premises to the tenant and claim the premises from the tenant by eviction under the ground of bonafide requirement, if such offer is made, the view is that such offer should be seriously considered by the Courts while considering the bonafide requirement. AIR 1991 SC 335.</p><p>The doctrine of comparative hardship has been evolved through various judicial precedents and it has been laid down definitely that comparative hardship of the tenant needs to be taken care of while considering bonafide requirement.</p><p>When there is a pleading of bonafide requirement then burden on the landlord is to show that there is in fact a bonafide requirement and that is sufficient. The degree of necessity need not be proved if the necessity is genuine. As against as that, so far as the tenant is concerned, the burden lies on the tenant to show comparative hardship and the question of degree of necessity becomes quite crucial and important. AIR 2003 SC 2713.</p><p>The burden is on the tenant to show that the alternate premises which the tenant has or the tenant has been offered is unsuitable for residential user. AIR Online 2019 MP 1039.</p><p>If the tenanted premises is owned by a partnership firm, then the asset becomes the asset of the firm and not of any individual partner and in case individual needs of a partner of the said firm is brought forward and pleaded the same does not come within the ambit of bonafide requirement. AIR Online 2019 Ker 498.</p><p>If a landlord has more than one plot, it is for the landlord to choose which plot he wants to construct on, the tenant cannot object or question the bonafide of the landlord . (2010) 4 Bom CR 618.</p><p>The law keeps evolving and precedents try to balance competitive claims between the two sides.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=322539d27dfb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Marital Rape : A Conundrum]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@yatinrshah/marital-rape-a-conundrum-b047ebd4df7f?source=rss-18aa8a6bd308------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b047ebd4df7f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[equality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Yatin Shah]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Mar 2026 17:54:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-13T17:54:40.747Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>With more than a hundred countries worldwide recognising marital rape as a crime, India remains one of the few who fail to do so. A serious offence such as rape cannot be ignored depending on who commits it. Why is India lagging behind by more than a hundred years when the Soviet Union criminalized marital rape in 1922? Because criminalizing marital rape is alleged to ‘weaken the institution of marriage’; over ending oppression of women. While this continues to be unfortunate, it only reflects India’s regressive social story. The deep-rooted rigidity is depriving an entire gender of intrinsic rights. The exception of continuing impunity of men deprives married women of their right to equality by denying them the same legal remedies as unmarried women. The question of rape cannot in any manner be linked with a woman’s status in society whilst overlooking that women are victims of sexual violence.<br>Such has been the posture of the Law Commission who rejected the 172nd Legislative Commission Report, 2000. The report batted for the need for marital rape to be recognised as a statutory offence like various other forms of violence, but its rejection indicated a complete disregard of the rights of married women. <br>The Indian Penal Code, particularly Section 375 failed to recognise sexual intercourse by a man with his own wife (of more than 15 years of age) as rape inspite of the likelihood of it being forcible, against her will and without her consent. While the Section 85 of the BNS recognises the effect of domestic violence and punishes both mental and physical cruelty, there is no provision punishing marital rape. Thus The BNS, failing to address this issue, serves to condone marital sexual violence. The law reform initiative which could have had an effect on the agenda of gender justice was missed. <br>A common stereotype pushed around is rape cannot happen within marriage. This is done with the intent of trivialising the psychological hardship and trauma faced by women. It is commonly believed that rape by a stranger is more traumatic than rape by a husband. However, the range of harm suffered by a woman if raped by her husband is not any different than by a stranger. <br> While the Supreme Court was hearing a myriad of petitions seeking criminalisation of non consensual sexual acts in a marriage, it was distinctly pointed out that when a wife resists her husband’s demand of sexual intercourse, she is wrongfully confined, threatened and criminally intimidated till she succumbs to pressure. These preliminary acts make offences in law, hence subsequently marital rape not being characterised as an offence remains mortifying. It is alarming that the Ministry of Home Affairs told the Supreme Court that while a husband cannot violate his wife’s consent, referring to it as “rape” is excessively harsh and disproportionate, considering the culture of silence associated with the plight of victims. The patriarchal social framework and rigid family dynamics in India pose an additional barrier, along with the lawmakers who overlook it. <br>This long-contested issue was brought back to the headlines when in early 2025 the Chhattisgarh High Court acquitted a man convicted of raping his wife and engaging in unnatural intercourse, resulting in her death. The Court observed that a husband cannot be charged with rape if his wife is over 15 years of age, even in absence of her consent. Such judgements do not help when in India’s social fabric most households nurture the superiority of a man’s will over a woman’s. A judiciary so progressive must not allow patriarchy to prevail. <br>Courts have also recognised the need for reform. In a split decision in RIT Foundation vs Union of India, Justice Rajiv Shakdher noted that the exemption was against Article 14 of the Indian Constitution. In Nimeshbhai Bharatbhai Desai vs State Of Gujarat, the Court acknowledged that marital rape is a significant issue that, regrettably, is not drawing much attention from the government, and the time is right for the legislature to step in and create suitable laws. The hope for reform in this regard has been seen through the introduction of a private member bill in the Lok Sabha by Shashi Tharoor to remove the marital rape exception in criminal law. The Legislature must come up with a safeguard which can ensure that married women are not victims of sexual violence in the guise of the “institution of marriage” they are so restless to protect. It is hoped that the state and the judiciary stop doing lipservice and help create an atmosphere to recognise marital rape as a social evil as also a serious crime.</h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b047ebd4df7f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>