<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Youssef El Gharably on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Youssef El Gharably on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@yelgharably?source=rss-f8d99c4b5712------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 14:20:28 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@yelgharably/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Hall With No Exit | Trained to Doubt, Unnumbered Letter.]]></title>
            <link>https://yelgharably.medium.com/the-hall-with-no-exit-trained-to-doubt-unnumbered-letter-29f59d11cff1?source=rss-f8d99c4b5712------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/29f59d11cff1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Youssef El Gharably]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 21 Aug 2026 23:15:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-21T23:15:25.580Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Foreword: This piece is not numbered into a Part, because it is not quite a letter — it is closer to the record of an afternoon spent reading obituaries of men I never met and recognizing too much of myself in the marginalia. It grew out of Letter 5, which asked what happens when doubt turns inward. This asks what happens when it turns inward and never turns back out.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*5l25U3QFsawlg3IM794Faw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure: <em>An infinite fractal spiral.</em></strong> Doubt without a governed exit does not stop — it recurses, the way this pattern does, finding another version of itself at every scale it’s pushed to. <a href="https://www.thewisemag.com/mystery/fractal-geometry/">Source.</a></figcaption></figure><p>08/21/2026–18:19</p><p>Some nights I catch myself believing I am carrying a piece of every troubled scientist who has ever lived. Between Cantor’s certainty of the trans-infinite, Gödel’s fear of his own dinner plate, and Newton’s three non-verbal years in Woolsthorpe, I can’t help but feel they are all folded somewhere into one soul. I am a believer that souls can have past lives, and our bodies are merely a vessel of said soul. If every vessel leaves a mark on the soul it carries, that means I could be carrying the lineage of troubled scientists as well as peasant workers, monks, and everyone in between. I don’t mean this as a diagnosis, but I mean it in the way you mean a recurring dream: a shape the mind keeps returning to, whether or not it is true. What accompanies this is a nightly and almost physical compulsion to have changed something by morning — as though the work is not a career but a debt coming due on a schedule only I and my past selves can see. I recognize that compulsion as kin to what <a href="https://yelgharably.medium.com/trained-to-doubt-letter-5-bdf6bd7d7605">Letter 5</a> described: doubt that no longer asks whether a model is complete and starts asking, <em>am I complete?</em> This is what happens when that question is allowed to keep going.</p><p>In <a href="https://yelgharably.medium.com/trained-to-doubt-letter-5-bdf6bd7d7605">Letter 5</a>, I drew a line between epistemic doubt and existential doubt. The first asks what evidence supports a claim, and the second asks what evidence supports me. I wrote that letter back in March 2026 inside a live problem, and I offered a discipline for it: separate the tool from the identity, apply the method inward carefully, and diversify the self so that one collapsing role does not take the whole structure down with it. I still believe all of that, but writing it left a question unanswered — one that only became visible once I started reading the lives around the discipline rather than the discipline itself: what does it look like when someone doesn’t have that exit? Not because they lacked insight, but because the century, the institution, or the tradition around them never built one?</p><p>Georg Cantor is the case one can reach for first, and for good reason. He gave mathematics the trans-infinite numbers, a rigorous account of infinities nested inside infinities. He spent much of his later life in and out of sanatoria, convinced that Kronecker’s public campaign against him was destroying his mind from the inside out. Eventually, he also became convinced that his mathematics had been dictated to him by God. That last part is usually treated as a footnote, but I think it is an argument. Cantor’s doubt about the infinite did not stay open — it closed, hard, into a certainty nobody around him could share or verify. That is not quite madness in the Romantic sense. It is what happens when doubt, denied any sanctioned resting place, manufactures its own opposing force — two forces struggling to keep each other in check inside a mind like Cantor’s, alone, unwitnessed, and therefore indistinguishable from delusion to everyone standing outside it.</p><p>A second case would be Ludwig Boltzmann. His doubt was never his own to begin with; it was inflicted on him by Mach and Ostwald, who spent years telling him, in print, that atoms were fiction and his life’s work with them. He died before Perrin’s experiments vindicated the atomic hypothesis he had defended alone for two decades. One of my graduate school professors once responded to a student’s curious question by saying that asking too many detailed questions in quantum statistical mechanics is what made Boltzmann kill himself. At the time I genuinely thought this was an unhinged joke thrown out because we were straying from the content of the class, and my colleagues and I have joked about it since then. But looking back at both — my professor’s throwaway line and Cantor’s own crisis — I realized they were trapped in the same kind of prison, each by a different architect. Different mechanisms of imprisonment, same result: doubt with nowhere sanctioned to go eventually goes somewhere unsanctioned.</p><p>And then consider Gödel, who I find harder to write about than the other two because the temptation to make him mean something is so strong that it should be treated as a warning sign rather than an invitation. He had rheumatic fever as a small child and emerged from it obsessively anxious about his health and endlessly asking why — earning the nickname <em>Der Herr Warum</em>. He grew up to prove that any sufficiently powerful formal system contains truths it cannot prove from within itself. He died refusing to eat because he was convinced his food was poisoned, trusting no one enough to be fed. It would be very easy to write a sentence here about the man who found the edges of provability starving at those same edges in his own kitchen, but writing that sentence flatters the story more than it tells the truth of it. His childhood illness and paranoia have a documented, unglamorous throughline that doesn’t need the incompleteness theorem’s help to be tragic. But I understand, writing this, exactly why that sentence is so tempting to reach for. That temptation itself is part of what this piece is about.</p><p>One of the many common — but not immediately obvious — things between these people is that they are all European men. I don’t believe this is a coincidence I am entitled to skip past. Cantor, Boltzmann, Gödel, and Newton are all cases with surviving letters, contemporaries who wrote down what they witnessed, universities that kept the paper trail, biographers who found the unraveling interesting rather than simply grounds for dismissal. Whose interior collapse gets remembered as genius undone by truth, and whose gets recorded — if at all — as instability or hysteria: that distinction is itself a function of who was let close enough to the institution to be watched in the first place. <a href="https://yelgharably.medium.com/the-outsiders-advantage-trained-to-doubt-letter-6-b1d4e602b7f1">Letter 6 </a>named this asymmetry directly — du Châtelet defending kinetic energy from outside universities, Fairfax teaching herself Laplace, Meitner watching her collaborator collect the Nobel Prize her physics had earned, Wu’s experiment overturning parity while the prize went to the men who had only theorized it. None of that record includes their 3 a.m. doubt on sleepless nights, because no one thought to ask. The “mad genius” is a category built for a specific kind of subject: the men who fit it get remembered as tormented geniuses, and the women who didn’t are remembered as “difficult,” or not remembered at all.</p><p>There is one more figure worth setting against all of this, and he comes from closer to home than the others. Ibn al-Haytham — the same al-Haytham whose work on optics <a href="https://yelgharably.medium.com/trained-to-doubt-letter-3-e9fccda9d9e5">Letter 3</a> named among the Islamic Golden Age’s contributions to a method the West would later claim as its own invention — reportedly feigned madness for years under house arrest in Cairo, after a Nile engineering scheme promised to the caliph al-Hakim failed to materialize. Depending on which account you trust, the performance may have saved his life. It was during that confinement, sane behind the mask of not being so, that he produced the bulk of his work on light and vision. I don’t offer him as a fourth case of doubt curdling inward. I offer him as the counter-current: madness worn deliberately, from the outside in, as armor against a despot rather than suffered from the inside out with no armor at all. Cantor’s God-given mathematics and al-Haytham’s performed unraveling look, from a distance, like the same shape. They are opposites. One is doubt with no exit finally breaking through the walls of the self. The other is a mind fully intact, choosing exile from its own sanity as the one door still open under a tyrant.</p><p>This is where I think the real argument of this piece lives, and it runs directly back through <a href="https://yelgharably.medium.com/trained-to-doubt-letter-3-e9fccda9d9e5">Letter 3.</a> I wrote there that al-Ghazali’s doubt in <em>al-Munqidh min al-Ḍalāl</em> was real, systematic, and centuries ahead of Descartes’ — but that it stayed personal, philosophical, never institutionalized into a reproducible method the way Cartesian doubt eventually was. What I didn’t say clearly enough in that letter is what al-Ghazali’s tradition had that Descartes’ successors quietly let go of on the way to building the laboratory: doubt as <em>shakk</em> was never meant to be a corridor with a guaranteed door at the far end. It was understood as a station one could dwell in — governed, named, survivable, with its own scholarly vocabulary for how long to stay and what counted as passing through versus getting lost. Descartes needed his doubt to terminate in the cogito, fast, because the method wouldn’t work otherwise — a doubt that never resolves is useless as a foundation for a philosophy of certainty. Scientific modernity inherited that descent and, I think, quietly discarded the other half: the idea that doubt might not resolve on schedule, and that a tradition owes its doubters a way to hold that without it destroying them. Cantor, Boltzmann, and Gödel were, in this reading, three men doing Cartesian descent with no <em>shakk</em> underneath them to catch them — no governed station, only a hallway that was supposed to have a door and, for each of them in a different way, didn’t.</p><p>I don’t know yet whether I’m one more entry in that list or something else. The nightly compulsion I described at the start of this — the sense of a debt coming due, the feeling of carrying other people’s unraveling as inheritance — might be exactly the kind of doubt with no exit I’ve just spent several pages describing. Or it might be closer to al-Haytham’s mask: a mind performing urgency because urgency is the only posture the field seems to reward, without that urgency having yet closed all the way into anything as final as Cantor’s God or Gödel’s poison. I genuinely don’t know which. I’m not sure that not knowing is a problem to be solved so much as the <em>ḥayra</em> — the bewilderment — that <a href="https://yelgharably.medium.com/trained-to-doubt-letter-3-e9fccda9d9e5">Letter 3’s</a> unfinished argument was always going to arrive at eventually, if I let it run long enough. I said in <a href="https://yelgharably.medium.com/the-permission-on-paper-trained-to-doubt-letter-7-a56548e309a1">Letter 7</a> that some gaps can’t be closed by a single person, or a single generation. I think this might be one of the gaps inside a single person that can’t be closed by a single letter, either.</p><p>I am going to leave it there, mid-question, the way <a href="https://yelgharably.medium.com/the-permission-on-paper-trained-to-doubt-letter-7-a56548e309a1">Letter 7 </a>left Helwan — not because the question resolves, but because I don’t yet trust any resolution I could write tonight more than I trust the honesty of not having one.</p><p><em>Bibliography</em></p><p>[1] Dauben, J. W. (1979). <em>Georg Cantor: His Mathematics and Philosophy of the Infinite</em>. Harvard University Press.</p><p>[2] Cercignani, C. (1998). <em>Ludwig Boltzmann: The Man Who Trusted Atoms</em>. Oxford University Press.</p><p>[3] Dawson, J. W. (1997). <em>Logical Dilemmas: The Life and Work of Kurt Gödel</em>. A K Peters.</p><p>[4] Sabra, A. I. (2003). “Ibn al-Haytham: Brief Life of an Arab Mathematician.” <em>Harvard Magazine</em>.</p><p>[5] al-Ghazali, A. H. <em>al-Munqidh min al-Ḍalāl</em> (Deliverance from Error).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=29f59d11cff1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Duel of Fates: FY2027 Budget vs. Science]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/science-policy-in-a-snap/the-duel-of-fates-fy2027-budget-vs-science-5ad5520bfcf8?source=rss-f8d99c4b5712------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5ad5520bfcf8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science-funding]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fy2027-budget]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Youssef El Gharably]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Apr 2026 15:36:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-27T03:12:01.970Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="A person holds a handwritten sign reading “Everyone needs Science / Science needs Everyone” in front of a large neoclassical government building with a white dome, photographed from below against a blue sky with clouds." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l7F5nIkibQr8j3-NizqSrQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>A demonstrator holds a sign outside the Rhode Island State House during a rally against federal cuts to research funding, Providence, March 2025.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Written by SNAP member </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/f8d99c4b5712"><em>Youssef El Gharably</em></a></p><p>Read this blog on our <a href="https://snapcoalition.org/blog/">website</a>.<br><em>Footnotes are denoted with superscript numbers. References are denoted with brackets.</em></p><blockquote><strong><em>TL; DR</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><strong><em>The FY2027 federal budget proposes cutting the NSF by 55%, NASA’s science budget by 50%, NIH by 13%, NOAA by 26% [1] [2] , and DOE’s science by 15% for the second year running. Congress rejected nearly identical cuts in FY2026 because scientists and advocates pushed back. The budget is not law yet, and the window to act is now. Contact your representatives, respond to Requests For Information, and write to your local community.</em></strong></blockquote><p>The President’s Budget Request for the Fiscal Year 2027, released on April 3rd, 2026, is the administration’s formal statement of funding priorities to Congress. Congress ultimately decides how money is allocated, but this budget request informs future negotiations, so its numbers carry real weight.</p><p>The headline is a proposed $73 billion cut to non-defense discretionary spending, offset by a $1.5 trillion defense increase, which is 44% of the current FY2026 budget. Within this framework, science fares poorly across the board:</p><ol><li>The <strong>National Science Foundation (NSF) </strong>has a proposed cut of $4.79 billion (55% of its current budget), which would bring the annual budget down to $4 billion. [1] Every research directorate would be reduced. Under the proposed budget, the Directorate for Social, Behavioral, and Economic Sciences (SBE), which currently funds research on human behavior, economic systems, and society, <strong>would be eliminated entirely. </strong>The administration is reportedly already moving to shutter SBE without waiting for congressional approval, [2] despite the Senate Appropriations Committee explicitly supporting its funding in FY2026.ᵃ Within the remaining budget, artificial intelligence (AI) and quantum technology would receive prioritized funding ($655 million and $231 million respectively). The rest of the research portfolio is reduced dramatically. [1]</li><li>The <strong>National Institutes of Health (NIH) </strong>has a proposed cut of $6 billion (13% of its current budget), bringing the total funding down to $41 billion. [1,3] The National Institute on Minority Health and Health Disparities, the Fogarty International Center (which supports global health research), and the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health are all targeted for elimination. The budget also proposed capping indirect cost reimbursements (the overhead funding that keeps university labs operational) at 15% of total grants, an idea Congress rejected repeatedly in appropriations law. Federal courts also declared this cap unlawful in January 2026.ᵇ [4]</li><li>The <strong>National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) </strong>has a proposed cut of $5.6 billion (23% of the current budget), bringing it down to $18.8 billion. [2] NASA’s Science Mission Directorate would be cut nearly in half, by $3.4 billion. This ends missions including the Mars Sample Return Mission and SERVIR.ᶜ [5]</li><li>The <strong>Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Science</strong> has a proposed cut of $1.1 billion (15% of its current budget), bringing it down to $7.14 billion [1,6]. The Biological and Environmental Research program (which funds atmospheric science, climate modeling, and ecosystem research) would be cut significantly. At the same time, the administration proposes a new Office of Artificial Intelligence and Quantum (AIQ) with a $1.2 billion budget, focused on AI supercomputers and quantum infrastructure at national labs. ARPA-E, an agency within DOE that funds early-stage clean energy R&amp;D, would be cut by 43%, bringing it down to only $200 million. [6]</li><li>The <strong>National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) </strong>has a proposed cut of $1.6 billion, bringing the agency down to $4 billion. [7] For the second consecutive year, the budget proposes eliminating NOAA’s office of Oceanic and Atmospheric Research, effectively shutting down the research infrastructure that supports the nation’s core weather forecasting and climate monitoring. Congress rejected this proposal for FY2026, yet it returns unchanged. [7,8] Independent analysis suggests that NOAA grant activity in early FY2026 has already collapsed to a fraction of historical norms: seven new grants were issued through March 2026 compared to 379 during the same period in 2025. [8] This suggests that cuts may already be underway through administrative actions before Congress has weighed in — witholding allocations to agencies, slowing or pausing grant approvals, and declining to spend funds appropriated by Congress.</li><li>The <strong>Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) </strong>has a proposed cut of approximately $4.6 billion (41% of its current budget), [9] with a significant portion being shifted to a new agency: the <em>Administration for a Healthy America</em>. Programs targeting minority health, occupational safety, and environmental health would see the deepest reductions with the cuts and shifts.</li><li>The <strong>Department of Education</strong> has a proposed cut of $2.3 billion (2.9% of its current budget). [1] The Institute of Education Science (which funds evidence-based education research) would be cut by 67%. The budget would also eliminate the Regional Education Laboratories and Statewide Longitudinal Data Systems programs.ᵈ</li><li><strong>The budget also proposes a ban on using federal funds to pay for “expensive” academic journal subscriptions or publishing fees, </strong>unless specifically required by statute or approved by an agency. [1] The proposal does not define which journals would be affected or what “<em>expensive</em>” means.ᵉ Most early-career scientists are required to publish to graduate or remain competitive in academia, and they cannot afford standard journal fees even for the lesser-known journals. These fees (often referred to as Article Processing Charges or APC) vary between $1500 to as high as $15000, depending on journal prestige, with open-access (subscription-free) articles costing extra. Furthermore, most early-career scientists’ labs rely on open-access mandates, and their institutions alone depend on government-funded subscriptions. The ambiguity in this item alone is disruptive.</li></ol><h3><strong>What these numbers mean in practice</strong></h3><p>Numbers at this scale are hard to internalize, so this is what they mean in practice. When the NSF loses half of its budget, grants don’t just get smaller–they disappear. Research programs end mid-project; graduate students lose funding; postdocs and PIs seek positions abroad; laboratory infrastructures get dismantled. [10] The researchers who could have made the next breakthrough in their field instead find that no funding exists for their work to continue.</p><p>When the NIH’s indirect cost recovery is capped at 15%, universities face a difficult choice: absorb the difference from other sources, or cut programs, facilities, and staff to make research possible. [11] For smaller institutions already operating on tight margins, the latter becomes the more likely outcome.</p><p>When NASA eliminates 40 space missions, they eliminate instruments already built, terminate data collection already underway, and slash international partnerships already established. The instruments will be faced with no choice but to collect dust in the lab while their builders seek other opportunities to stay in science.</p><p>When NOAA’s research office is eliminated, we lose the people who monitor the atmosphere, model extreme weather conditions, and analyze climate data that supports forecasts for families, farmers, emergency managers, and local governments. [7,8,12]</p><p>On the other hand, some programs received sustained or increased funding compared to last year’s budget proposal. AI and quantum computing research would be maintained and increased across DOE, NSF, and the Department of War. The Artemis moon program would receive $8.5 billion. Defense spending would reach $1.5 trillion. [1] Overall, the budget reflects a clear set of priorities: strategic technologies with near-term national security applications and military capabilities, with an unfortunate oversight of the fundamental science that makes these applications possible.</p><p>These investments are not necessarily misguided–AI and quantum computingᶠ are genuinely transformative. <strong>However, a healthy research ecosystem is made up of more than its frontier technologies. It consists of the soil and air that nourish these new developments: the basic science that produces unexpected discoveries, the training pipelines that produce researchers, the social and behavioral sciences that tell us how technologies interact with societies, and the environmental science that tells us whether the Earth will live to see those technologies. </strong>One cannot indefinitely harvest the fruits of science while trimming the roots.</p><h3><strong>What you can do, and what Congress can do</strong></h3><p>The budget proposal is not law — the President proposes, but Congress ultimately decides how federal money is spent. Congress holds the power of the purse, and the FY2026 process demonstrated that there is bipartisan support for core science funding. [13] This dynamic has not changed. If you’re a researcher or someone concerned about cuts to science funding, here’s what you can do:</p><ol><li><strong>Contact your congressional representatives</strong> directly and tell them specifically what your research does, its impacts, what funding agency supports it, and what would happen if that support dissolves.</li><li><strong>Write for your local community.</strong> SNAP’s <a href="https://snapcoalition.org/initiatives/mcclintock-letters/">McClintock Letters campaign</a> demonstrated that op-eds in hometown newspapers — not just in academic journals — move the needle. [14] Legislators read their local press. Explain to your neighbors what federally funded science means for their health, their weather, their water, and the generation their children will grow into.</li><li><strong>Engage with professional societies.</strong> The American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS), the American Astronomical Society (AAS), and other societies are actively mobilizing now. Many professional societies also publish newsletters and policy alerts that keep members informed about developments in their fields — subscribing is an easy first step to stay engaged. They need member voices to amplify their advocacy!</li><li><strong>Respond to Requests for Information (RFIs).</strong> When agencies like NIST, NSF, NIH, and BIS develop new science-related rules, they publish formal requests for public expert input. These RFIs appear several times a year and a well-argued submission from a PhD Candidate or PI carries genuine weight.</li></ol><p>If you’re a policymaker or a policy staffer, the FY2027 budget request is asking you to make a losing bet that the United States can cut foundational science funding while maintaining technological leadership, and it can also dismantle PhD training pipelines while expecting a strong research workforce. The appropriations window is open now, and the 2027 fiscal year begins October 1st, 2026. The window to act is now.</p><p><strong>The United States has never built its future by betting against knowledge, and this is not the year to start.</strong></p><h4><em>Recognition:</em></h4><p><a href="https://medium.com/u/f8d99c4b5712">Youssef El Gharably</a><em> is a Quantum Science and Engineering PhD Student at the University of Delaware studying quantum materials’ synthesis and thin-film growth optimization as applications for Quantum Computing hardware. He also serves as the Science Diplomacy Coordinator for the Science Policy Advocacy Coalition at the University of Delaware. Originally an Egyptian national, Youssef is trying to advocate for 3rd-world countries from within the U.S. as an international student.</em></p><p><strong><em>Special thanks to fellow SNAP members who provided feedback on this article:</em></strong></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/u/c3a2638ddff5">Amanda Finn</a>, <em>a Nutrition Sciences PhD candidate studying physiological and social determinants of insulin resistance in people with overweight/obesity; </em><strong>Chad Small<em>, </em></strong><em>a PhD candidate in Atmospheric and Climate Science at the University of Washington, where he researches how tropical phenomena can influence the severity of rainfall and flooding events in midlatitude regions; </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/fc215a75df6d">Cael Dant</a>, <em>a botanist at Northwestern University and the Chicago Botanic Garden studying the physiology, ecological interactions, and genomics of North American carnivorous plants; </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/10425de68e76">Emily Selland</a>, <em>an ecologist and public health scientist whose research focuses on sustainable and economically viable innovations for infectious disease control; and </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/8ddae6e53e7b">Jordan Williams</a>, <em>a pharmacology PhD candidate studying how to alter the lung’s innate immune responses to better treat chronic respiratory diseases.</em></p><h4>Footnotes:</h4><p><strong>a.</strong> The Senate Appropriations Committee’s FY2026 Commerce, Justice, Science report (July 17, 2025) explicitly directed NSF to fund SBE at no less than the FY2024 enacted level, calling its research “fundamentally important” to public health, national security, education, and the interface between humans and technology.</p><p><strong>b.</strong> NIH announced a 14% indirect cost gap on February 7, 2025. A federal district court in Massachusetts blocked it by March and permanently enjoined it in April 2025, and the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously upheld that ruling on January 5, 2026, declaring the policy <em>unlawful</em>. The White House administration subsequently declined to appeal further.</p><p><strong>c.</strong> NASA’s Science Mission Directorate funds five science portfolios: Earth Science, Planetary Science, Heliophysics, Astrophysics, and Biological and Physical Sciences. Mars Sample Return is a joint NASA/European Space Agency (ESA) mission to retrieve surface samples already collected by the Perseverance rover. SERVIR is a joint NASA/USAID program that uses satellite data to help developing nations monitor and adapt to environmental hazards.</p><p><strong>d.</strong> The Institute of Education Science (IES) is the federal government’s nonpartisan education research agency, best known for producing the “Nation’s Report Card.” The Regional Educational Laboratories translate that research into practical guidance for teachers and school districts across 10 federally designated regions. The Statewide Longitudinal Data Systems program funds infrastructures that all 50 states use to track student outcomes from early childhood through the workforce. It represents the data backbone behind evidence-based education policy. [16]</p><p><strong>e.</strong> The budget request states verbatim: <em>“The Budget prohibits the use of Federal funds for expensive subscriptions to academic journals and prohibitively high publishing costs unless required by Federal statute or approved in advance by a Federal agency.” </em>It does not define “<em>expensive</em>” or “<em>prohibitively high</em>,” nor does it specify which journals would be affected.</p><p>f. See SNAP’s Blog on <a href="https://medium.com/science-policy-in-a-snap/quantum-technology-a-double-edged-sword-for-science-diplomacy-bd546cea0e6d"><em>Quantum Technology as a Double Edged Sword for Science Diplomacy</em></a><em> </em>for further understanding of the potential of Quantum Computing in the future, by <a href="https://medium.com/@andrewhmattson">Andrew Mattson </a>and <a href="https://medium.com/@yelgharably">Youssef El Gharably</a>.</p><h4>References</h4><p>[1] White House Office of Management and Budget. (April 3, 2026). FY2027 President’s Budget Request. <a href="https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/information-resources/budget/">https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/information-resources/budget/</a></p><p>[2] Mosley, B. (April 8, 2026). President Trump Releases Another Potentially Disastrous Budget Framework for Fiscal Year 2027. Computing Research Association GovAffairs. <a href="https://cra.org/govaffairs/blog/2026/04/overview-fy2027-pbr/">https://cra.org/govaffairs/blog/2026/04/overview-fy2027-pbr/</a></p><p>[3] FABBS. (April 11, 2026). FY27 President’s Budget Request Slashes Funding for Federal Science Agencies. <a href="https://fabbs.org/news/2026/04/fy27-presidents-budget-request-slashes-funding-for-federal-science-agencies/">https://fabbs.org/news/2026/04/fy27-presidents-budget-request-slashes-funding-for-federal-science-agencies/</a></p><p>[4] Higher Ed Dive. (January 6, 2026). NIH cap on indirect research costs struck down on appeal. <a href="https://www.highereddive.com/news/nih-indirect-cost-cap-appeal-struck-down/808925/">https://www.highereddive.com/news/nih-indirect-cost-cap-appeal-struck-down/808925/</a> | See also: Chronicle of Higher Education. <a href="https://www.chronicle.com/blogs/the-trump-agenda/trump-cant-cap-overhead-rate-on-nih-grants-to-research-universities-appeals-court-rules">https://www.chronicle.com/blogs/the-trump-agenda/trump-cant-cap-overhead-rate-on-nih-grants-to-research-universities-appeals-court-rules</a></p><p>[5] Eos (AGU). (April 8, 2026). FY2027 Budget Request Slashes Billions in Science Funding. <a href="https://eos.org/research-and-developments/fy2027-budget-request-slashes-billions-in-science-funding">https://eos.org/research-and-developments/fy2027-budget-request-slashes-billions-in-science-funding</a></p><p>[6] Federation of American Scientists. (April 9, 2026). Hot Takes: What the FY27 Presidential Budget Request Means for Climate and Energy. <a href="https://fas.org/publication/fy27-budget-request-climate-energy/">https://fas.org/publication/fy27-budget-request-climate-energy/</a></p><p>[7] Balanced Weather (Substack). (April 3, 2026). White House releases FY27 budget proposal, continuing plan of massive cuts to Earth science, including elimination of NOAA Research. <a href="https://balancedweather.substack.com/p/white-house-releases-fy27-budget">https://balancedweather.substack.com/p/white-house-releases-fy27-budget</a></p><p>[8] Balanced Weather (Substack). (April 3, 2026). White House releases FY27 budget proposal, continuing plan of massive cuts to Earth science, including elimination of NOAA Research. <a href="https://balancedweather.substack.com/p/white-house-releases-fy27-budget">https://balancedweather.substack.com/p/white-house-releases-fy27-budget</a></p><p>[9] Voosen, P. (April 3, 2026). Slasher sequel: Trump again proposes major cuts to U.S. science spending. Science (AAAS). <a href="https://www.science.org/content/article/slasher-sequel-trump-again-proposes-major-cuts-u-s-science-spending">https://www.science.org/content/article/slasher-sequel-trump-again-proposes-major-cuts-u-s-science-spending</a></p><p>[10] Garisto, D. (April 3, 2026). Massive budget cuts for US science proposed again by Trump administration. Nature. <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-01105-7">https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-01105-7</a></p><p>[11] University of Washington Federal Relations Office. (April 3, 2026). Administration Releases FY2027 Budget Proposal.</p><p>[12] University of Georgia Extension. (March 2025). Budget cuts to NOAA and National Weather Service endanger us all. <a href="https://site.extension.uga.edu/climate/2025/03/budget-cuts-to-noaa-and-national-weather-service-endanger-us-all/">https://site.extension.uga.edu/climate/2025/03/budget-cuts-to-noaa-and-national-weather-service-endanger-us-all/</a></p><p>[13] C&amp;EN (January 6, 2026). Federal science agencies dodge big funding cuts for 2026. <a href="https://cen.acs.org/policy/research-funding/Federal-science-agencies-dodge-big/104/web/2026/01">https://cen.acs.org/policy/research-funding/Federal-science-agencies-dodge-big/104/web/2026/01</a></p><p>[14] SNAP Coalition. (2025). McClintock Letters Initiative. <a href="https://snapcoalition.org/">https://snapcoalition.org/</a></p><p>[15] Davis and Blyn, SNAP Coalition. (2026). <a href="https://snapcoalition.org/2026/03/17/the-appropriations-rollercoaster.html">The Appropriations Rollercoaster: Which Sciences Won and Lost?</a></p><p>[16] The Department of Education (2026) <a href="http://www.ed.gov/">www.ed.gov</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5ad5520bfcf8" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/science-policy-in-a-snap/the-duel-of-fates-fy2027-budget-vs-science-5ad5520bfcf8">The Duel of Fates: FY2027 Budget vs. Science</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/science-policy-in-a-snap">Science Policy in a SNAP</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Permission on Paper | Trained to Doubt: Letter #7]]></title>
            <link>https://yelgharably.medium.com/the-permission-on-paper-trained-to-doubt-letter-7-a56548e309a1?source=rss-f8d99c4b5712------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a56548e309a1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Youssef El Gharably]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Apr 2026 01:02:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-16T01:20:27.278Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>04/15/26, 19:27</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/723/1*brVFjfgQ2MUKf_6TmihgKg.png" /><figcaption><em>The original Arabic text of Article 23 of the Egyptian Constitution of 2014, as amended in 2019. Beside it: a relief of Sia (𓋴𓇋𓄿), the ancient Egyptian god of perception and divine knowledge, who walked beside the Pharaoh as his sacred advisor — the embodiment of the idea that power and knowledge must travel together.</em></figcaption></figure><p>In my second year of high school, I was deeply involved in my school network’s (STEM High School) National Astronomy Club. I had been learning about the mechanics of the night sky for months: the motion of planets, the geometry of stellar parallax, and the logic of celestial coordinates. This learning process was entirely from books and the software Stellarium, but I had no telescope, no observatory, and no one who had ever looked through one.</p><p>Egypt has an agency called <em>“The National Research Institute of Astronomy and Geophysics.”</em> They are usually the agency that reports on minor or major tectonic phenomena, and they are the ones that manage one of the few observatories in Egypt: The Helwan Observatory. Helwan sits in southern Cairo, and it serves as the point where the Delta Region ends, and the Upper Egypt region starts. Helwan’s observatory is one of the oldest observatories in Africa; it was founded in 1903. I knew this; I was sixteen, and I knew this, but I was never able to get in touch with them.</p><p>So, as a natural next step for a sixteen-year-old with a fresh fiery passion for astronomy, me and my close friend Khalifa took the Cairo Metro till its last stop in Southern Cairo: <em>Helwan</em>.</p><p>We didn’t sneak in; I called ahead. My school principal even wrote me a formal letter addressed to the institute’s administration, explaining who I was, what I had studied, and why I was asking to participate in their astronomy activities. Since no one responded, Khalifa and I decided to go anyway — the way you go somewhere when you believe the answer should be yes even if no one has said it yet. The Metro took us about 45 minutes to an hour; I remember being anxious in a way I did not yet have words to describe — the anxiety of doing something courageous for the first time and not knowing whether courage is the right word for it or whether a smarter version of yourself would have stayed home. I knew I had nothing to lose, so I didn’t stay home!</p><p>It was a cloudy day in March 2020, and the administrative building of the institute was quiet when we arrived. Two security guards sitting near the entrance sharing a cigarette stopped us. We were two teenagers out of breath from walking uphill to the observatory, and the expression on the guards’ faces was one I can only describe as bewilderment. Not necessarily hostile, just pure confusion from something they never expected to happen in their shift. I told them why I was there, that I was a student studying astronomy and that I wanted to contribute to their work in Astronomy. I wanted to learn, help if I could, and be part of something scientific on a national level outside of the classroom.</p><p>The guards disappeared down a hallway; I sat down attempting to catch my breath from talking so fast to the guards, and Khalifa sat down next to me and gave me the silent nod that signaled: “you did great.” The guards were gone for five to ten minutes, which felt like an eternity. I counted down the seconds; I was in a government building I never thought I would be in, and I was with Khalifa who believed in me enough to take the Metro to Helwan with me on a random Tuesday.</p><p>When the guards came back, they took me to see the acting chair of the institute. She heard me out, perhaps for two or three minutes. She nodded, gave me her business card, told me to call her, and sent me away.</p><p>I called. I never heard back.</p><p>I thought about that day recently for the first time in a long while. I have been getting more and more involved in science policy and diplomacy, and I was curious as to what the Egyptian constitution said about scientific research and collaboration. I sat down to read the constitution of 2014 (amended in 2019) in Arabic, which is the only language it was ever really meant to be read in. I had been contemplating its provisions on science and research, tracing the lines of what the Egyptian state had formally promised its people. <strong>I found Article 23</strong>:</p><blockquote>تَكفُل الدولةُ حُرِّيةَ البحثِ العلميِّ وتُشجِّع مؤسساتِه بوصفِه وسيلةً لتحقيق السيادةِ الوطنيةِ وبناءِ اقتصادِ المعرفة. وتَرعى الدولةُ الباحثين والمخترعين، وتُخصِّص ما لا يقِلُّ عن ١٪ من الناتجِ القوميِّ الإجماليِّ للبحثِ العلميِّ، تستكمِلُه تدريجياً حتى يتوافقَ مع المعدَّلات العالمية. وتلتزِم الدولةُ بتوفير وسائلِ الإسهامِ الفعّال للقطاعَين الخاصِّ والعامِّ وإسهامِ المصريين في الخارج في تنميةِ البحثِ العلميِّ.</blockquote><p><em>The state guarantees the freedom of scientific research and encourages its institutions as a means of achieving national sovereignty (السيادة الوطنية) and building a knowledge economy.</em> <em>The state sponsors researchers and inventors, and allocates no less than one percent of gross national product to scientific research.</em> Then, at the end, a clause that I had to read twice: <strong>the state commits to providing effective means for the contributions of Egyptians abroad to the development of scientific research.</strong></p><p>I found myself in my country’s founding document; not my name specifically, but the kind of person I became.</p><p>I am proud to be Egyptian. I want to say that plainly, and I want to mean it plainly, because it is easy to read what follows and mistake grief for contempt.</p><p>Egypt is the civilization that treated knowledge as sacred before the word civilization even existed. The ancient Egyptians didn’t merely practice science — they sanctified it. They placed <em>Sia</em>, the god of perception, beside the Pharaoh himself, because they understood that power without knowledge was not power at all. They built an entire theology around the idea that the universe was ordered, and therefore knowable, and therefore worth spending a life to understand. Thoth (the god of writing, the moon, and of reckoning) was not a minor deity. He was among the most important figures in the Egyptian cosmological imagination, because the Egyptians grasped something that many civilizations have since forgotten: the pursuit of knowledge is not separate from the pursuit of meaning, because it is the same pursuit.</p><p>I love that inheritance. I carry it. It is part of why I became a physicist — not despite being Egyptian, but in some deep sense because of it.</p><p>And yet.</p><p>Article 23 was the law of the land when Khalifa and I took the Metro to Helwan. Egypt had always had some version of this promise, even before the Egyptian constitution was first written in 1956. Science has always been a national value, research a state obligation, and knowledge a sovereign interest. The National Research Institute of Astronomy and Geophysics existed precisely because the state had decided (at some point in history) that astronomy mattered enough to fund, to house, to staff, and to give an address in Helwan and a founding date of 1903.</p><p>Yet, the guards were more invested in their cigarette than they were in me and Khalifa’s story. The acting chair handed me a card she probably thought was a waste to give away. And no one called back.</p><p>In <a href="https://medium.com/@yelgharably/trained-to-doubt-letter-3-e9fccda9d9e5">Letter 3</a>, I argued that the history of scientific progress is not a history of who doubted first, but of what societies chose to do with doubt once it appeared. Al-Ghazali doubted. His doubt was profound, systematic, and centuries ahead of its European counterpart. But it remained personal — philosophical rather than procedural and preserved in texts rather than embedded in institutions. The machinery of skepticism never fully engaged, because doubt was never detached from the individual who experienced it and transformed into a method that others can reproduce, critique, and improve upon independently.</p><p>A constitution is a document that attempts that precise transformation — not for doubt, but for rights. It takes what might otherwise remain a personal or moral claim (the freedom to inquire, the right to knowledge, and the sovereignty of the mind) and makes it procedural. It tells us that this is not merely what we believe, but it is also what we decide formally in writing, in law, and in society. This is the promise a state makes to itself about what kind of country it intends to be.</p><p>Article 23 is a remarkable promise. The framing of “national sovereignty, السيادة الوطنية” is not incidental. The drafters of the Egyptian constitution chose to justify scientific freedom not as a Western liberal value, not as an individual right modeled on foreign constitutions, but as an Egyptian national interest. Science, in this framing, is what makes Egypt sovereign: a country that cannot generate its own knowledge is a country that depends on others for the terms of its own reality. This is a deeply serious argument, and it is written into the foundational law of the state.</p><p>It was written into the foundational law of the state when I was in Helwan.</p><p>The gap between a constitutional promise and a lived reality is not unique to Egypt. Every country that has ever written a constitution also has a history of how far short it has fallen. The United States Constitution declared that all men were created equal in 1776 while still enslaving people; the French republic proclaimed liberty, equality, and fraternity while building one of history’s most extractive colonial empires. Constitutional promises are not descriptions of what exists. They are, at best, arguments about what should exist — binding the state to an aspiration that has not yet been earned.</p><p>But there is a specific kind of gap that I want to name, because it is the one I grew up inside. It is not the gap between what a government says and what it does — it’s the gap between what a document says and what a culture has been trained to feel is possible.</p><p>In Letters 1 and 2, I wrote about the permission problem in modern Egypt: the way curiosity, over generations, was transformed from a virtue to a risk. The way asking why began to sound dangerously close to saying no. The way doubt (which Letter 3 argues is the engine of all sustained scientific progress) came to require authorization before it could be exercised. None of that is in the constitution. The constitution says the opposite. The constitution states:</p><blockquote>تَكفُل الدولةُ حُرِّيةَ البحثِ العلميِّ<br>The state guarantees the freedom of scientific research</blockquote><p>The constitution says schools must plant the roots of scientific thinking in every child. The constitution says researchers and inventors are people the state is obligated to sponsor and protect.</p><p>However, the culture gave its business card to the constitution, and the constitution never heard back.</p><p>When I was sixteen, I didn’t know what I was experiencing had a name or that it would eventually drive me to leave. I knew only that I had gone somewhere with Khalifa, done everything right, and came home with a business card that never served its purpose.</p><p>Letter 3 ends with a sentence I still believe: doubt becomes transformative only when it no longer asks to be tolerated. I meant it as a statement about scientific methodology, about the difference between a civilization that produces brilliant individual skeptics and one that builds institutions in which skepticism is expected, rewarded, and continuously applied regardless of who is doing the applying.</p><p>I didn’t mean it as a statement about myself when I initially wrote it, but it has become one.</p><p>I left Egypt because I understood that I would never be the scientist I wanted to be there. Not because Egyptians are incapable — Egyptians are extremely capable, and the history of Arab science alone should embarrass anyone who suggests otherwise. Egyptians even have a saying:</p><blockquote>الطفلُ المصريُّ أذكى طفلٍ في العالم<br>The Egyptian child is the smartest child in the world.</blockquote><p>Egypt never lacked intelligence; it didn’t lack creativity or the hunger for knowledge. It has all of those qualities in abundance. I left because the machinery that transforms an individual’s curiosity into institutional knowledge requires more than a constitutional article to build. Egypt is missing the universities that reward questioning, the labs that normalize failure, and a culture that separates doubt from disloyalty. These require generations of unconditional permission to doubt, and Egypt had spent too many generations doing the opposite.</p><p>I am proud of my country, and I am proud of the ancient Egyptians who built an entire civilization on the premise that the universe was ordered and therefore worth understanding. I am deeply proud of the Arabic language, which carries centuries of mathematical and philosophical precision. I carry all of that with me to every lab I work in, every conference, and I proudly wear an Egyptian flag lapel pin on my blazer in the Capitol in D.C.</p><p>But I also carry the business card from Helwan. I carry Article 23, which tells Egyptians abroad that the state is committed to providing effective means for their contributions to Egyptian scientific research.</p><p>The card was never answered, but the clause exists.</p><p>I don’t know yet what to do with the distance between those two facts. I am not sure the distance can be closed by a single person, or a single generation, or a single constitutional amendment. What I know is that the promise was written in Arabic, the language I grew up in, and by people who understood that a country cannot be sovereign without the freedom to question. And I know that I went to Helwan at sixteen with Khalifa and a letter from my principal, left with nothing, but kept going anyway.</p><p><strong><em>That is not a resolution; it is the shape of a question I am still learning to hold.</em></strong></p><p>Bibliography:</p><p><em>[1] Constitution of the Arab Republic of Egypt (2014, amended 2019). Article 23: Scientific Research. Official Arabic text.</em></p><p><em>[2] Constitution of the Arab Republic of Egypt (2014, amended 2019). Article 19: Education; Article 66: Freedom of Research.</em></p><p><em>[3] Frankfort, H. (1948). Kingship and the Gods: A Study of Ancient Near Eastern Religion. University of Chicago Press. [On Sia and the theology of divine knowledge in ancient Egypt.]</em></p><p><em>[4] Pinch, G. (2002). Egyptian Mythology: A Guide to the Gods, Goddesses, and Traditions of Ancient Egypt. Oxford University Press.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a56548e309a1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Quantum Technology: A Double Edged Sword for Science Diplomacy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/science-policy-in-a-snap/quantum-technology-a-double-edged-sword-for-science-diplomacy-bd546cea0e6d?source=rss-f8d99c4b5712------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bd546cea0e6d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science-diplomacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[physics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quantum-computing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Youssef El Gharably]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Apr 2026 18:39:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-07-27T03:17:57.774Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="Close-up photograph of the interior of a dilution refrigerator, showing layered gold and copper hardware connected by cascading white coaxial cables against a dark background." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8b6IlqNMChCFamDzS_q29A.jpeg" /><figcaption>A dilution refrigerator — the workhorse of superconducting quantum computing. These devices cool quantum processors to temperatures near absolute zero, colder than outer space, to preserve the fragile quantum states that make computation possible. The dilution fridge has become one of the most recognizable symbols of the second quantum revolution. Credits to the <a href="https://physics.berkeley.edu/research-faculty/quantum-physics">University of California in Berkeley’s </a>website.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Written by SNAP Members </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/a7ad9d6ba82b"><em>Andrew Mattson</em></a><em> and </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/f8d99c4b5712"><em>Youssef El Gharably</em></a><em>. Andrew and Youssef contributed equally to this blog post.</em></p><p>Read this blog on our <a href="https://snapcoalition.org/blog/">website</a>.<br><em>Footnotes are denoted with superscript numbers. References are denoted with brackets.</em></p><p><em>Disclaimer 1: One of the authors (Youssef) is a non-US citizen studying Quantum Engineering in the United States with active exclusion from national quantum research funding.</em></p><p><em>Disclaimer 2: This blog was posted on the World Quantum Day: 04/14, which resembles the rounded value of Planck’s Constant.</em></p><p>In 1954, Europe’s nuclear research center (CERN) was founded with the explicit commitment to scientific openness across political divides. At the height of the cold war, this new research center included Americans, Europeans, and Soviets working together to push the frontiers of physics. However, perhaps CERN’s most underappreciated achievement was not scientific discovery, but diplomacy. Today, CERN has grown to over 16,000 scientists from 110 countries. [1] It has demonstrated that shared scientific infrastructure creates a new kind of international trust; <strong>nations develop a mutual stake in keeping the science running. </strong>The International Space Station successfully followed this same playbook of science diplomacy, using large collaborations to create and strengthen international partnerships.</p><p>On March 25th 2026, the U.S. Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee heard arguments for the National Quantum Initiative (NQI) Reauthorization Act of 2026. [2] This is the latest of many steps taken by governments around the world to position themselves as leaders in quantum technology. Quantum science and engineering have become some of the most important issues in science diplomacy, bringing physics back into the global spotlight in a way not seen since the nuclear arms race. As before, that attention brings both pressure and competition, creating the potential for opportunity or danger. Quantum physics could lead to groundbreaking technologies that improve quality of life across the globe and deepen our understanding of the universe. At the same time, these technologies could also be highly destructive. It is essential to act now to ensure this new era of innovation strengthens global science diplomacy and includes voices from many nations in the conversation.</p><h3><strong>What is quantum technology?</strong></h3><p>Pioneering work by physicists of the early 20th century (including Fermi and Einstein) led to the first quantum revolution in the 1920s. This burst of discovery led to technologies we now take for granted, including magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), nuclear energy, lasers, and maybe most importantly, semiconductor computer chips that we use every day in phones and computers. Much of this foundational research was done by scientists who were not U.S. citizens, many of whom contributed to science after immigrating to the U.S.</p><p>As our understanding of quantum physics has progressed, a second quantum revolution has begun.<strong> </strong>This revolution is centered around three main classes of new technology:</p><ol><li><strong>Quantum Sensing</strong> is the extremely precise measurement of particles as they respond to external electromagnetic fields or other particles. This field is well developed and has moved from laboratory curiosity to commercialization.</li><li><strong>Quantum Computing</strong> uses quantum bits (qubits) that, unlike ordinary computer bits which are either 0 or 1, can be both at once. This is a property known as superposition. It makes quantum computers exponentially faster than classical computers in problems like drug discovery, materials simulation, and breaking encryption.</li><li><strong>Quantum Communication</strong> exploits quantum properties like entanglement and superposition to transmit information in fundamentally new ways, which enables new and improved encryption but also introduces new vulnerabilities.</li></ol><h3><strong>Why should we be concerned about it?</strong></h3><p>In 2024, NATO’s first “quantum strategy” identified quantum sensing, computing, and communication as priority military capabilities. [5] Other defense-oriented analyses list numerous applications of these technologies: submarine detection, GPS-free precision navigation, weapons design optimization, and strategic simulations on an unprecedented scale.</p><p>This has created an arms race, in which every country wants to be the first to wield these new weapons. Much like the nuclear arms race of WWII, the competition itself has become a threat; a direct consequence is the “harvest now, decrypt later” problem [6], in which countries store each other’s encrypted communications today and plan to decrypt them later.</p><p>Quantum computers could play a major role in this. It has been shown that these devices can theoretically break encryption protecting bank transactions, diplomatic communications, and medical records in seconds. [7] Quantum sensing could create additional military threats by detecting underground structures, submarine movements, and electronic devices. Prototype versions of these technologies exist right now. [8]</p><h3><strong>Quantum diplomacy right now</strong></h3><h4><strong>Standards: where diplomacy and geopolitics intersect</strong></h4><p>Technical standards are often dismissed as mere bureaucracy, but they are crucial agreements on how technologies are used and who can use them. For example, international trade and scientific collaboration require that meters, kilograms, and other quantities be universally defined; hence, the International System of Units (SI units) exists.</p><p>The current landscape of quantum communication provides a pertinent example of the importance of standards in diplomacy. The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) held an international competition with submissions from researchers around the world to develop quantum versions of cryptographic algorithms for information processing and transmission. The winning algorithms came from international teams, through participation skewed toward certain geopolitical blocs. In parallel, the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) is developing its own algorithmic standards drawing from a different set of nations. [4] If ITU standards diverge from NIST standards, interoperability breaks down, and the fracture will run precisely along the geopolitical fault lines that science diplomacy was meant to bridge. Countries using one standard would not be able to securely communicate with those using the other standard.</p><p>This is an example of a negotiation happening right now, in working groups that most physicists are absent from. The focus, as always, lies on navigating the existing geopolitical tensions rather than the science itself. However, especially in the world of quantum communication, openness must be a deliberate diplomatic choice. It strengthens the chances of standardized international adoption of quantum cryptography, creating a common cryptographic foundation that improves security for every nation that uses it. A shared standard would lay the groundwork for secure communication and collaboration between nations, which is a diplomatic benefit beyond security.</p><h4><strong><em>Exclusion: another part of diplomacy</em></strong></h4><p>As international collaborations and diplomatic relationships develop, an implicit decision being made is <strong>who gets to do the science. </strong>Yet, in the world of quantum science and engineering, this is rarely mentioned.</p><p>The G7 endorsed a vision of the quantum future in June 2025 that explicitly commits to “STEM education and inclusion of underrepresented groups” as a pillar of the international framework [10], and the NATO quantum strategy talks about a transatlantic quantum community. The first quantum revolution succeeded because of international openness. Most of the major contributors to the principles of quantum theory were not American, but the U.S. provided refuge for many of them, despite significant barriers, even as immigration restrictions and religious discrimination created real obstacles.</p><p>The second quantum revolution has failed to continue this tradition, and instead treats quantum science as an export. The US Bureau of Industry and Security’s 2023 [11] interim rule imposed controls on quantum computers based on qubit thresholds. The Wassenaar Arrangement coordinates technology restrictions among 42 states. Across the U.S., international graduate students and postdocs are increasingly facing visa restrictions and being blocked from quantum research funding and programs. [12] Often, access is shaped more by nationality restrictions rather than by scientific merit. Other countries are following suit, each playing a role in accelerating a fragmentation that will ultimately cost every nation’s science. One of the authors of this essay is living this exclusion in real time as a non-US citizen studying quantum engineering at the University of Delaware. International students are excluded from the public funding that supports the very research they are advancing. The unfortunate truth is that the inclusive frameworks mentioned by G7 and NATO are being ignored in practice.</p><h3><strong>As a scientist or diplomat, what can you do?</strong></h3><p>The quantum policy and diplomacy infrastructure is being built today by scientific innovations, standards decisions, and international agreements that will shape research, collaboration, and security for decades. Scientists around the world will be greatly impacted, but are often not part of this process. Across many disciplines (physics, biology, chemistry, geology, archaeology, and more), people will either benefit from quantum technologies or suffer from their unsuccessful implementation. Beyond the lab, the world could be forever changed by the power of quantum science and engineering. To make sure these changes are for the better, there are a few things you can do:</p><ol><li><strong>Respond to requests for information.</strong> NIST, NSF, DOE, NIH, and BIS all issue RFIs when developing quantum-related rules. Most receive fewer than fifty substantive responses from experts. A single well-argued submission by a PhD student carries genuine weight.</li><li><strong>Engage with standards bodies. </strong>IEEE Quantum, ITU Study Groups 13 and 17 [4], ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 27 are actively writing the rules for quantum technology now. They need input from academics and researchers, not just industry representatives.</li><li><strong>Advocate for open science.</strong> Scientists should be publicly advocating for protections of international academic collaboration, both domestically and abroad.</li></ol><p>In the era of quantum technology, scientific knowledge is power. The expertise of scientists who understand these technologies is an invaluable resource for policymakers and diplomatic leaders. We must use that to ensure quantum science and engineering include all voices and create a better tomorrow for both those communities and the public that helped them get there.</p><p><strong><em>Recognition</em></strong><em>:</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/u/a7ad9d6ba82b">Andrew Mattson</a><em> is a physics PhD student developing quantum technologies for dark matter detection, gravitational wave observation, and life science/medical applications. He also serves as Science Diplomacy Coordinator for the Science Policy and Diplomacy Group at Johns Hopkins.</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/u/f8d99c4b5712">Youssef El Gharably</a><em> is a Quantum Science and Engineering PhD Student at the University of Delaware studying quantum materials’ synthesis and thin-film growth optimization as applications for Quantum Computing hardware. He also serves as the Science Diplomacy Coordinator for the Science Policy Advocacy Coalition at the University of Delaware</em></p><p><strong><em>Special thanks to the following SNAP members for providing feedback on this article</em></strong><em>:</em></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/u/64646984abf9">Bryce Wedig</a>, <em>a PhD candidate in physics studying dark matter in distant galaxies; </em><strong>Meredith Pritchard, </strong><em>a PhD student at the University of Texas at Austin studying particle physics; and </em><a href="https://medium.com/u/28db48dbd5a7">Shaurita D. Hutchins</a>, <em>a PhD candidate in Genetics, Genomics, and Bioinformatics advancing rare disease diagnostics and ethical genomics data stewardship.</em></p><h4><strong>Bibliography:</strong></h4><p>[1] CERN. (2016). <em>CERN Brochure: Facts and Figures</em>.<a href="https://home.cern/sites/default/files/2018-07/CERN-Brochure-2016-005-Eng.pdf"> https://home.cern/sites/default/files/2018-07/CERN-Brochure-2016-005-Eng.pdf</a></p><p>[2] U.S. Senate. (2026). <em>National Quantum Initiative Reauthorization Act of 2026</em>, S.3597, 119th Congress.<a href="https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/senate-bill/3597/cosponsors"> https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/senate-bill/3597/cosponsors</a></p><p>[3] National Institute of Standards and Technology. (2024). <em>NIST Releases First 3 Finalized Post-Quantum Encryption Standards</em>.<a href="https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2024/08/nist-releases-first-3-finalized-post-quantum-encryption-standards"> https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2024/08/nist-releases-first-3-finalized-post-quantum-encryption-standards</a></p><p>[4] International Telecommunication Union. (2024). <em>ITU-T Study Groups 13 and 17: Quantum Communication Standards</em>.<a href="https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-T/studygroups"> https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-T/studygroups</a></p><p>[5] NATO. (2024, January 17). <em>NATO Releases First-Ever Quantum Strategy</em>.<a href="https://www.nato.int/en/news-and-events/articles/news/2024/01/17/nato-releases-first-ever-quantum-strategy"> https://www.nato.int/en/news-and-events/articles/news/2024/01/17/nato-releases-first-ever-quantum-strategy</a></p><p>[6] Mosca, M. (2018). Cybersecurity in an era with quantum computers: Will we be ready? <em>IEEE Security &amp; Privacy, 16</em>(5), 38–41. <a href="https://eprint.iacr.org/2015/1075.pdf">https://eprint.iacr.org/2015/1075.pdf</a></p><p>[7] Shor, P. W. (1994). Algorithms for quantum computation: Discrete logarithms and factoring. <em>Proceedings of the 35th Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science (FOCS)</em>, 124–134. <a href="https://www.computer.org/csdl/proceedings-article/focs/1994/0365700/12OmNqNXErh">https://www.computer.org/csdl/proceedings-article/focs/1994/0365700/12OmNqNXErh</a></p><p>[8] Degen, C. L., Reinhard, F., &amp; Cappellaro, P. (2017). Quantum sensing. <em>Reviews of Modern Physics, 89</em>(3), 035002. <a href="https://journals.aps.org/rmp/abstract/10.1103/RevModPhys.89.035002">https://journals.aps.org/rmp/abstract/10.1103/RevModPhys.89.035002</a></p><p>[9] Ferrazzini, A. (2025). <em>Quantum, Diplomacy, and Geopolitics: Strategic Imperatives for Defence and Security in the Emerging Quantum Era</em> (v1.6). arXiv:2512.06052. <a href="https://inspirehep.net/literature/3090462">https://inspirehep.net/literature/3090462</a></p><p>[10] G7. (2025, June). <em>Kananaskis Common Vision for the Future of Quantum Technologies</em>.<a href="https://g7.canada.ca/en/news-and-media/news/kananaskis-common-vision-for-the-future-of-quantum-technologies/"> https://g7.canada.ca/en/news-and-media/news/kananaskis-common-vision-for-the-future-of-quantum-technologies/</a></p><p>[11] Bureau of Industry and Security, U.S. Department of Commerce. (2023). <em>Export Controls on Quantum Computing Items</em>, FR Doc. 2023–22151. Federal Register. <a href="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/09/06/2024-19633/commerce-control-list-additions-and-revisions-implementation-of-controls-on-advanced-technologies">https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/09/06/2024-19633/commerce-control-list-additions-and-revisions-implementation-of-controls-on-advanced-technologies</a></p><p>[12] Wassenaar Arrangement. (2023). <em>List of Dual-Use Goods and Technologies and Munitions List</em>.<a href="https://www.wassenaar.org/control-lists/"> https://www.wassenaar.org/control-lists/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bd546cea0e6d" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/science-policy-in-a-snap/quantum-technology-a-double-edged-sword-for-science-diplomacy-bd546cea0e6d">Quantum Technology: A Double Edged Sword for Science Diplomacy</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/science-policy-in-a-snap">Science Policy in a SNAP</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Outsider’s Advantage | Trained to Doubt: Letter #6]]></title>
            <link>https://yelgharably.medium.com/the-outsiders-advantage-trained-to-doubt-letter-6-b1d4e602b7f1?source=rss-f8d99c4b5712------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b1d4e602b7f1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[minorities]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[international-womens-day]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Youssef El Gharably]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 09 Mar 2026 16:27:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-09T17:04:44.272Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Foreword: This letter was written on International Women’s Day. It is dedicated to every scientist who has ever been made to feel that the room was not built for them — whether because of their gender, their origin, their background, or the way the world has chosen to see them. It is an argument, grounded in history, that the margins of science have never been empty. They have always been full of people doing extraordinary work.</blockquote><blockquote>It is also, in a small way, personal. The field I work in — Quantum Engineering — exists because scientists refused to honor the artificial boundaries between disciplines. Mary Fairfax saw that refusal as inevitable more than two centuries ago, long before the fields she was connecting even had their modern names. I am not sure my PhD program would exist without the intellectual tradition she helped build. This letter is written in her spirit, and in the spirit of every scientist whose name history has been slow to learn.</blockquote><p>Scientists are trained to doubt. From the beginning of our education, we are taught that no theory is sacred. We question experiments, challenge assumptions, and search for the flaw hidden somewhere in our reasoning. Scientific progress depends on this habit of skepticism. Most of the time, this doubt is directed toward nature. We doubt measurements; we doubt models; we doubt whether the equations we write truly capture the behavior of the universe. But there is another form of doubt that scientists rarely discuss.</p><p>It is doubt directed not at nature — but at the structure of science itself. History quietly suggests that some of the most transformative scientific insights came from people who stood slightly outside the scientific institutions that societies deemed “<em>traditional</em>.” They were often excluded from the universities and intellectual circles that defined what science was supposed to look like. Standing outside those structures sometimes gave them a clearer vantage point — what I call the Outsider’s Advantage. In history, outsiders who are brave enough to exploit that advantage are the ones who make the word “tradition” lose all meaning, and who break barriers for more groups of scientists to follow.</p><p>One of the earliest examples of this perspective comes from the eighteenth century, with the French physicist and mathematician <strong><em>Émilie du Châtelet</em></strong>. Du Châtelet lived during a time when the foundations of physics were still being fiercely debated. Newton’s laws had revolutionized mechanics, but fundamental questions about the nature of energy and motion remained unresolved. Many physicists believed that the quantity conserved in motion was proportional to velocity ( ), while others argued it was proportional to the square of velocity ( ).</p><p>Du Châtelet carefully studied the mathematical arguments behind these competing views and defended the idea that what we now call kinetic energy depends on the square of the velocity — directly contributing to solidifying a concept that would become central to modern physics. She also produced the most influential French translation and commentary on Newton’s Principia, a work so mathematically demanding that most of Europe had engaged with it only at a distance. What is remarkable is not only the work itself but the conditions under which it was produced. Du Châtelet operated entirely outside the formal academic institutions of her time, at a moment when women were actively excluded from universities and scientific societies. She relied not on institutional authority, but on mathematics and reasoning alone. Her example reveals an important feature of scientific skepticism: when authority is unavailable, arguments must stand entirely on their intellectual strengths.</p><p>Nearly a century later, another remarkable scientist would challenge a different kind of boundary. <strong><em>Mary Fairfax Somerville</em></strong> was born in Scotland in 1780 — I will refer to her throughout as Fairfax, her own name rather than her husband’s. She came of age in an intellectual world where the sciences were rapidly expanding and fragmenting into specialized disciplines. Like du Châtelet, Fairfax pursued mathematics largely outside formal institutions, teaching herself through intensive study of Newton and Laplace.</p><p>Fairfax’s most famous book, <em>On the Connexion of the Physical Sciences</em>, attempted something ambitious: to show that the increasingly specialized branches of science were not diverging, but revealing deeper relationships between the laws governing nature. Astronomy, chemistry, physics, and geology were not separate intellectual territories — they were different expressions of the same underlying structure of the universe. Today, this idea feels familiar. Interdisciplinary science is now a defining feature of modern research; fields like astrophysics, materials science, and quantum engineering exist precisely because the laws of nature refuse to respect the boundaries we draw between disciplines. In the early nineteenth century, however, Fairfax’s vision was unusual. She saw that the deeper scientists looked into nature, the more the divisions between fields began to dissolve.</p><p>What makes her work particularly striking is how she chose to present these ideas. <em>On the Connexion of the Physical Sciences</em> contains no mathematical equations. Rather than presenting formulae, Fairfax guided readers through scientific discoveries using explanation and narrative, forming what many consider the foundations of modern science communication. Her goal was to make the structure of scientific discovery visible to readers who lacked the mathematical training required to follow Newton’s <em>Principia</em> or Laplace’s <em>Celestial Mechanics</em> — a bold experiment that her outsider’s perspective made possible. Someone shaped entirely within institutional science might never have thought to try.</p><p>James Clerk Maxwell, of electromagnetic equations fame, admired her work but suggested that the unity she revealed reflected the method of science rather than the true unity of natural processes — that Fairfax had illuminated how scientists think, even if the mathematical machinery of nature remained partially concealed. It is a fair critique, and Fairfax herself seemed to understand it. Discussing phenomena such as the mysterious medium that nineteenth-century physicists believed carried light through space, she eventually reached a boundary where explanation could go no further. At that point, she wrote simply: <em>“Here, our knowledge ends.”</em> It is a profoundly scientific statement. Progress rarely begins with certainty. It begins at the edges of understanding, where explanations start to feel incomplete and new questions emerge. Systematic doubt lives precisely at those edges.</p><p>The stories of du Châtelet and Fairfax also reveal a dimension of doubt that extends beyond theories and equations. By pursuing science in worlds that actively discouraged their participation, they quietly questioned the structure of science itself. Without declaring revolutions, they demonstrated that intellectual authority does not belong exclusively to those whom institutions have traditionally permitted to enter.</p><p>Their stories are not isolated. <strong><em>Emmy Noether</em></strong> revolutionized theoretical physics through abstract algebra after years of working without formal academic recognition in early twentieth-century Germany — her contributions so fundamental that Einstein described her as the most significant creative mathematical genius yet produced. Lise Meitner co-discovered nuclear fission and was denied the Nobel Prize that her collaborator Otto Hahn received, her exclusion now considered one of the most glaring oversights in the history of science. <strong><em>Chien-Shiung Wu</em></strong> designed the experiment that overturned parity conservation, one of the most deeply rooted assumptions in twentieth-century physics, only to be left off the Nobel Prize awarded to the theorists whose hypothesis her work confirmed.</p><p>These examples share something subtle but important: people who stand slightly outside systems often see those systems more clearly. They notice assumptions that others have stopped questioning; they challenge conventions that insiders have come to accept as natural. Du Châtelet questioned foundational theories of motion; Fairfax questioned the boundaries dividing scientific disciplines; Noether, Meitner, and Wu each dismantled something their fields had treated as settled. In every case, the outsider’s vantage point was not a disadvantage to be overcome — it was the source of the clarity itself.</p><p>Systematic doubt, it turns out, is not only a method for interrogating nature. It is also what happens when someone who was never supposed to be in the room starts asking why the room was built this way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aBohxlnbSddahsv04Ddjvg.png" /><figcaption><em>Mary Fairfax, Chien-Shiung Wu, and Émilie du Châtelet. Three scientists who were never supposed to be in the room — and who changed what the room looked like forever.</em></figcaption></figure><p>Bibliography:<br> [1] Somerville, M. (1834). <em>On the Connexion of the Physical Sciences</em>. London: John Murray.<br> [2] Neeley, K. A. (2001). <em>Mary Somerville: Science, Illumination, and the Female Mind</em>. Cambridge University Press.<br> [3] Somerville, M. (1834). Discussion of ether and the limits of knowledge in <em>On the Connexion of the Physical Sciences</em>.<br> [4] Arianrhod, R. (2014). <em>Seduced by Logic: Emilie Du Châtelet, Mary Somerville, and the Newtonian Revolution</em>. Oxford University Press.<br> [5] Secord, J. A. (2016). “Mathematics for the Million? Mary Somerville’s <em>On the Connexion of the Physical Sciences</em>.” In <em>Visions of Science</em>. Oxford University Press.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b1d4e602b7f1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Doubt Turns Inwards | Trained to Doubt, Letter #5]]></title>
            <link>https://yelgharably.medium.com/trained-to-doubt-letter-5-bdf6bd7d7605?source=rss-f8d99c4b5712------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bdf6bd7d7605</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Youssef El Gharably]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Mar 2026 23:01:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-09T15:13:42.709Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Foreword: The person who wrote this letter is a scientist. He also lives with an anxiety disorder, bipolar depression, and chronic depression — not in spite of his work, but alongside it, every day. This letter is not written from a place of having figured it out. It is written from inside the problem. If you are a graduate student who finds it easier to exist inside a lab than outside of one — this was written for you.</blockquote><p>I didn’t find safety in science or faith alone; I found responsibility. What I didn’t anticipate was that responsibility would include managing my own mind. Science channels doubt and doesn’t eliminate it. I previously described doubt as posture <em>(Letter 2)</em>: restraint before belief and patience before certainty. I believed that once doubt was institutionalized, it became productive. I believed that the danger existed only in societies that feared questioning, but there is another danger greater than all of those previously described: when doubt turns inwards.</p><p>Self-awareness is often praised as maturity, and reflection is treated as intellectual virtue. Scientists, especially, are trained to interrogate everything from assumptions and data to motives and methodologies. Over time, this habit becomes a reflex. The mind scans for weaknesses automatically. But what happens when the object of interrogation is no longer the theory, but the self? There is a subtle transition that happens in scientific training. We begin by asking: is the model incomplete? Is this dataset biased? Is this interpretation premature? And without noticing, these questions mutate into: am I incomplete? Am I biased? Am I premature? The language remains analytical, but the target has changed from science to self.</p><p>The scientific method was designed to test claims about the universe. It was not designed to test one’s own worth. Yet, the brain does not naturally compartmentalize its tools. The same cognitive machinery that disassembles flawed arguments can disassemble confidence and existential awareness with equal efficiency. High self-awareness becomes recursive; reflection becomes rumination; rumination becomes erosion. Psychological research has shown that excessive self-focused rumination is strongly correlated with anxiety and depressive disorders. [1] Reflection, beyond a threshold, stops producing clarity and begins producing instability. The cost of knowing yourself too well is that you never stop auditing your existence.</p><p>A 2018 study published in Nature Biotechnology surveyed over 2,000 graduate students and found that 41% reported moderate to severe anxiety and 39% reported moderate to severe depression — rates far higher than those in the general population. [2] Another 2022 global survey in Nature reported that more than a third of PhD students had sought help for anxiety or depression related to their doctoral training. [3] Imposter phenomenon, the persistent feeling of being intellectually fraudulent despite objective evidence of competence, is disproportionately prevalent in high-achieving academic environments. [4] These findings are not anomalies; they reflect structural conditions. However, I believe the structural explanation is incomplete. Graduate school is stressful, yes; funding is uncertain; international students like myself are questioning their existence in the United States; evaluation is constant. Yet, many high-pressure environments don’t produce the same psychological profile. Scientists are not merely pressured; they are trained to doubt, and their strongest ally often transitions to be their greatest adversary.</p><p>There is a distinction that rarely gets articulated clearly: epistemic doubt refines knowledge, and existential doubt destabilizes identity. Epistemic doubt asks: “What evidence supports this claim?” Existential doubt asks: “What evidence supports me?” The first is scientific, but the second is unguarded inference. The transition between the two is subtle. It often hides behind humility. We are told not to be arrogant, not to be certain, not to trust intuition without verification. Don’t get me wrong, they are all good and essential principles because they protect knowledge and the means to reach it. However, when humility loses its boundaries, it becomes self-negotiation.</p><p>There is a romantic myth in academia that depth requires suffering. We often point to figures like John Nash — his battle with schizophrenia, his brilliance entangled with isolation and psychological collapse — and observe genius wrapped in torment. The mythology is seductive: intensity equals genius. However, there is no empirical evidence to suggest that chronic anxiety improves sustained cognitive performance. Burnout reduces flexibility; rumination narrows attention; exhaustion distorts judgment. Suffering may coexist with insight, but it does not generate it.</p><p>Scientists are uniquely exposed to three reinforcing conditions: delayed validation, constant comparison, and high cognitive intensity.</p><p>Delayed validation is perhaps the most insidious. Scientific work operates on long feedback loops. Experiments fail; papers get rejected; grants are denied. Recognition, when it comes, arrives after years of effort. The brain struggles with intermittent reinforcement. It begins to fill the silence with self-explanation and existential doubt.</p><p>Constant comparison compounds this. Academic environments are saturated by metrics: publications, citations, fellowship positions. Comparison becomes ambient. The mind learns to measure itself against external signals constantly, and over time, those signals begin to feel like verdicts.</p><p>High cognitive intensity closes the loop. People drawn to science are often naturally reflective. Studies suggest correlations between high cognitive ability and increased vulnerability to anxiety or mood disorders in certain populations. [5] Intelligence amplifies analysis; analysis without discipline amplifies doubt. The system rewards critique but rarely teaches containment.</p><p>Abandoning doubt is not the solution; that would contradict anything I have written so far and lead you, the reader, to believe that I have gone mad. The goal is not confidence without scrutiny; the goal is disciplined doubt.</p><p>First, we need to separate the tool from the identity. When an experiment fails, the hypothesis may be wrong. It does not logically follow that the experimenter is defective. The brain compresses these steps automatically. Discipline requires expanding them again and not allowing the brain to leap to a conclusion unchecked.</p><p>Second, we need to apply the scientific method inward — carefully. If the mind asserts “I am inadequate,” treat the statement as a hypothesis: What is the evidence of my inadequacy? What are the alternative interpretations? Am I generalizing from a single data point? Then spray yourself in the face with a garden hose for doubting your competence. (Not really, but you have free will.) Intellectual rigor should not be reserved for external claims.</p><p>Third, diversify your identity. When identity collapses into profession, professional instability becomes existential collapse. Humans are multi-dimensional; reducing oneself to a single role increases fragility.</p><p>Fourth, institutional responsibility matters. Cultural norms that equate overwork with dedication, silence with resilience, and exhaustion with seriousness create predictable and unequal outcomes. Structural reform is not weakness; it is maintenance, and it should be treated as such.</p><p>In my previous letters, I wrote that science does not save us from ourselves. It makes consequences legible. This applies internally as well. If doubt is a method, then it must be used as such. It cannot become an identity, or an ideology, and it certainly cannot become punishment. To live by systematic doubt is to accept uncertainty about claims — not to wage war against one’s own worth. Humility does not require self-erasure. Rigor does not require self-suspicion. Responsibility does not require self-destruction. The privilege of being trained to doubt comes with an additional responsibility: knowing where the doubt should stop. If civilizations decline when questioning requires permission, individuals decline when questioning never rests. The goal is not to believe in ourselves uncritically; it is to doubt precisely.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*D3pERBk3HiV2l1V_pzwteA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Hall of Two Truths, ancient Egyptian Book of the Dead — where the soul stands before Osiris as its heart is weighed against the feather of Ma’at, the goddess of truth and justice. To the Ancient Egyptians, self-examination was not punishment; it was passage. Letter 5 asks whether the scientist’s trained habit of doubt has quietly become its own judgment hall. See <a href="https://medium.com/the-archipelago/in-the-hall-of-two-truths-81bb52e96871">this </a>story by Jessica Pischko on the Hall of Two Truths.</figcaption></figure><p>Bibliography:</p><p>[1] Nolen-Hoeksema, S. (2000). The role of rumination in depression. <em>Psychological Bulletin</em>.</p><p>[2] Evans, T. M., et al. (2018). Evidence for a mental health crisis in graduate education. <em>Nature Biotechnology</em>.</p><p>[3] Woolston, C. (2022). PhD students and mental health. <em>Nature</em>.</p><p>[4] Bravata, D. M., et al. (2020). Impostor phenomenon: systematic review. <em>Journal of General Internal Medicine</em>.</p><p>[5] Karpinski, R. I., et al. (2018). High intelligence and mental health outcomes. <em>Intelligence</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bdf6bd7d7605" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science is Not Natural | Trained to Doubt, Letter #4]]></title>
            <link>https://yelgharably.medium.com/trained-to-doubt-letter-4-d901e6c17e2a?source=rss-f8d99c4b5712------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d901e6c17e2a</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Youssef El Gharably]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Jan 2026 16:06:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-09T15:13:06.913Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I started my journey learning science with a superstition disguised as respect: science was neutral. Not morally or politically neutral, but epistemically pure. I treated science as a machine that takes in nature and outputs truth. I thought science was what remained after all the human noise had been filtered out; it was an escape from the institutionalized permission I grew up with, where certainty was often enforced rather than earned. To me, science was absolute. I mistook this imagined purity for safety; science was not a human activity — it was an escape from humanity in an attempt to understand the divine nature of the universe.</p><p>However, what I began to slowly understand (then all at once) is that science does not abolish doubt. It disciplines it. It doesn’t make certainty cheap; it makes it expensive. The scientific method is not a ladder to truth so much as a set of rules for when you are allowed to say, “I think I have a case.” Evidence is not a decoration placed on conclusions; it is the price of speaking with confidence. In that sense, science was not a warehouse of facts. It is an ethic — a refusal to let belief outrun what can be shown.</p><p>In time, I learned that science was one of the anchors the world relied on sociologically, economically, and psychologically. Most people believe science is the procedural pathway the so-called “smart” people take to cure diseases, solve mysteries, build technologies, and advance knowledge. However, science does not demand intelligence; it demands posture and discipline. One need not be smart to be postured. That posture is not intellectual brilliance; it is restraint. It is the discipline of not answering questions before they are properly formed, and of not mistaking conviction for correctness. Science doesn’t reward those who think the fastest; it rewards those who wait the longest before believing themselves. This is why the mythology of the “smart scientist” misses the point. Intelligence accelerates reasoning, but willingness governs direction. Without willingness — to be wrong, to revise, to let evidence humiliate intuition — intelligence merely sharpens error.</p><p>Looking outward toward my future as a scientist, I began to see how this discipline quietly structures the world far beyond laboratories. Science reshapes societies even when no one is consciously “doing science.” It alters how risk is perceived, how authority is assigned, and how responsibility is distributed across time. Germ theory did not merely change medicine; it reorganized public trust, refined norms of cleanliness, and justified the existence of institutions that now feel inevitable. Climate science doesn’t simply describe atmospheric chemistry; it forces societies to confront obligations to people who do not yet exist. In these ways, science acts independently of economics and politics; its conclusions press against social structures whether or not they are welcomed.</p><p>Yet science is never alone. Economies decide which questions survive long enough to be asked, and societies decide which answers are tolerable. Policy emerges at the intersection, where evidence constrains imagination and values select among constrained possibilities. Governments don’t follow science because science is correct; they follow it when science makes denial too costly — legally, economically, or socially. When they don’t, science becomes something else: a language of justification, a shield for authority, or a warning left unread. This coupling is uncomfortable but unavoidable. Science sets the boundaries of reality; sociology negotiates acceptance; economics determines scale. When one is removed, policy becomes either fantasy, tyranny, or mere momentum forced onto people by institutional procedure.</p><p>What disturbed me most was realizing that science doesn’t save us from ourselves. It only makes the consequences legible. It doesn’t prevent misuse; it records it. It doesn’t enforce morality; it exposes trade-offs. It gives people both the choice and the means to make informed decisions. The hope that science would absolve humanity of its biases was itself a form of superstition — the gods people once trusted were merely replaced by graphs and footnotes. Science never promised neutrality of outcomes, only accountability of claims. My epiphany was that the intersection between faith and graphs was where I thrived. Lean too far toward either side, and balance is lost.</p><p>And so I stopped asking whether science was pure and started asking whether <em>I</em> was honest — about uncertainty, motivation, and how much belief I was smuggling under the banner of evidence. To live by science is not to live correctly, but to live corrigibly. It is the willingness to accept that reality keeps score even when no one is watching, and that the bill arrives regardless of how sincere or biased one’s intentions were. This is why science, as a philosophy, is accessible to anyone but practiced by few. It doesn’t require brilliance, credentials, or fluency in equations. It requires the willingness to let the world disagree with you and to adapt quietly when it does. That willingness has become rarer than intelligence, education, or confidence.</p><p>I did not find safety in science or faith alone — I found responsibility. And unlike certainty, responsibility cannot be delegated, nor is it dictated by permission.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*xkIBvSe8I4K4_-5d.jpg" /><figcaption>Thoth, the Egyptian God of Knowledge. (Credit: <em>The Rosicrucian Egyptian Museum</em><strong><em>)</em></strong></figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d901e6c17e2a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Doubt Becomes a Method | Trained to Doubt, Letter #3]]></title>
            <link>https://yelgharably.medium.com/trained-to-doubt-letter-3-e9fccda9d9e5?source=rss-f8d99c4b5712------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e9fccda9d9e5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history-of-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy-of-science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[egypt]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Youssef El Gharably]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 07 Jan 2026 07:42:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-09T15:12:26.444Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The foundation of modern science is not discovery, experimentation, or even mathematics; it is <em>doubt — specifically, disciplined and systematic doubt. </em>The scientific method does not begin by believing less; it begins by suspending belief long enough to test what survives. </strong>This idea is most commonly attributed to René Descartes, the French philosopher whose methodological skepticism reshaped European philosophy and, eventually, scientific inquiry itself. However, doubt did not originate in seventeenth-century Europe. It existed as a philosophical practice centuries earlier, articulated by Islamic philosophers as early as the eighth century.</p><p>Long before doubt was formalized into what we now recognize as the scientific method, it existed as a deliberate, disciplined, and deeply unsettling practice. In the Islamic intellectual tradition, Abu Hamid al-Ghazali embodied this approach most clearly. In his autobiographical work <em>Deliverance from Error</em>, al-Ghazali describes a profound epistemic crisis. He recounts losing confidence in inherited beliefs, religious authority, and even the reliability of sense perception itself. <em>What he undertook was not skepticism for its own sake, nor a rejection of faith or reason, but a temporary suspension of certainty. </em>He was willing to doubt what had been accepted without examination in order to discover what could withstand scrutiny and ultimately reach a clearer understanding of the universe and God.</p><p>Al-Ghazali questioned whether the senses could deceive, whether logical reasoning relied on assumptions that themselves went unexamined, and whether social consensus was a reliable source of truth. This was not an act of nihilism. On the contrary, doubt was treated as a painful but necessary tool — one used to clear away fragile beliefs in pursuit of firmer foundations. Only after this process did al-Ghazali reconstruct his worldview, reintegrating faith with a renewed sense of epistemic humility.</p><p>What is striking is not merely that al-Ghazali doubted, but how he doubted. His skepticism was systematic rather than impulsive, and intentional rather than rebellious. It followed a structure: suspend belief, interrogate sources of knowledge, and rebuild cautiously. <em>In this sense, doubt functioned as a passage, not as an endpoint.</em> Yet, unlike later European philosophy, this epistemic skepticism did not evolve into institutionalized methods of inquiry. Al-Ghazali’s doubt remained largely personal and philosophical rather than procedural. It was preserved in texts and taught as intellectual history, but rarely operationalized into a reproducible framework for generating new knowledge about the natural world. This distinction matters. Doubt existed. Skepticism was articulated. However, it was not trained into a method, nor embedded into institutions that rewarded its continuous application. <strong>What survived from al-Ghazali’s autobiography was the memory of doubt, not its machinery.</strong></p><p>The historical significance of early epistemic skepticism does not lie in who doubted first, but in what societies chose to do with doubt once it appeared. Philosophical skepticism alone does not produce science. It must be transformed, disciplined, externalized, and repeated before it becomes a method. This transformation is most closely associated with Descartes. He did not merely experience doubt; he operationalized it. He proposed that doubt should be applied deliberately, systematically, and impersonally — stripped of biography, belief, and circumstance. In doing so, doubt became portable. It could be taught, reproduced, critiqued, and improved upon by others who shared neither his theology nor his conclusions.</p><p><em>The shift from doubt as an internal crisis to doubt as a public procedure was decisive.</em> Once skepticism was no longer confined to the individual thinker, it could be embedded into institutions. Universities could teach it; journals could demand it; experiments could formalize it. Knowledge was no longer validated by lineage, authority, or spiritual resolution, but by survival under repeated, structured questioning. The contrast with earlier skepticism is subtle but critical. Where pre-modern doubt sought certainty, methodological doubt sought reliability. Philosophical skepticism asked, “What can I believe?” Scientific skepticism asked, “What holds up when tested by others?” The object of inquiry shifted from the self to the system.</p><p>Europe’s scientific acceleration did not occur because its thinkers were more skeptical, but because skepticism was detached from theology and personal salvation and repurposed as a collective tool. Doubt became an expectation rather than an event. It was no longer something one passed through, but something one applied. This distinction explains a great deal. A civilization can produce brilliant skeptics and still fail to produce sustained scientific progress. Without institutions that reward doubt continuously, skepticism exhausts itself until it becomes memory rather than momentum. What separated modern science from its philosophical predecessors was not courage, originality, or irreverence — it was repetition.<strong> Once doubt was mechanized, it no longer needed permission.</strong></p><p>Once doubt becomes a method, the next question is political rather than philosophical: who is allowed to use it? Knowledge does not stagnate because people stop thinking; it stagnates when the authority to question is centralized. <strong>When doubt requires permission, inquiry becomes fragile.</strong> In societies where skepticism is institutionalized, doubt ceases to be a personal risk. One no longer needs moral courage or social approval to question assumptions; questioning becomes an expectation built into the system itself. In societies where doubt remains conditional — as discussed in my earlier letters on modern Egypt — it never fully escapes suspicion. Skepticism survives, but only under supervision.</p><p>This distinction helps explain why epistemic skepticism could exist for centuries without producing sustained scientific momentum. Doubt that must justify itself before being exercised is already compromised. It learns to resolve quickly, to return safely to accepted conclusions, and to demonstrate loyalty before understanding. Over time, inquiry adapts to survive rather than explore.</p><p>This logic is not confined to philosophy or science. It mirrors patterns visible much earlier in life. <em>When children are taught what to think before they are taught how to think, curiosity becomes something to manage rather than cultivate.</em> Exposure is regulated, questions are prioritized based on acceptability, and uncertainty is treated as a threat to culture rather than a skill. What begins as parental protection often matures into intellectual self-censorship. Children grow up to fear skepticism rather than embrace it.</p><p>The same instinct scales upward. Educational systems reward correct answers over good questions. Religious discourse prioritizes certainty over exploration. Political authority favors predictability over critique. In each case, permission is centralized — not necessarily through explicit prohibition, but through social consequence. Doubt is not outlawed, but it is discouraged, delayed, or quietly shunned. This is where the boundary between faith and thought collapses. Belief, once a guide for meaning and ethics, begins to dictate what may be questioned at all. Inquiry is no longer judged by rigor, but by alignment. Questions slowly shift from “Is this true?” to “Is this allowed?”</p><p>When that shift occurs — whether slowly or abruptly — doubt loses its power. It becomes performative: invoked rhetorically, resolved prematurely, treated sarcastically, or avoided altogether. The machinery of skepticism never fully engages because it is always waiting for approval. What ultimately separates societies that sustained scientific progress from those that did not is not belief, intelligence, or tradition, but whether doubt was allowed to operate without permission. Doubt becomes transformative only when it no longer asks to be tolerated.</p><p>A millennium ago, the momentum of scientific progress pointed east. The Arab and Islamic world was not merely preserving knowledge; it was actively producing it. Al-Khwarizmi developed algebra; al-Zahrawi revolutionized surgery; Ibn al-Haytham transformed optics and geometry; Ibn Sina reshaped medicine and physics. Inquiry was continuous, cumulative, and expected to remain unfinished. Questions did not seek closure so much as refinement. Today, this momentum feels reversed. Scientific activity still exists, but motion is often episodic rather than sustained — dependent on exceptional individuals rather than institutions built to tolerate prolonged uncertainty. Knowledge is expected to justify itself quickly rather than grow through iteration.</p><p>Europe’s scientific momentum followed a different arc. Its defining feature was not certainty, but institutionalized self-reflection. Methods were turned inward; errors were documented; paradigms were replaced. Progress became reflexive rather than linear. <strong>Scientific momentum accelerates when revision is normalized. </strong>Where inquiry is expected to evolve, doubt becomes productive. <em>Where inquiry is expected to conclude, doubt becomes a liability.</em> The contrast is not one of past versus present, nor East versus West. It is the difference between cultures that trust motion and those that fear where it might lead.</p><p>In much of the modern Arab world, doubt has come to be interpreted as an ideology rather than a method. Questioning is frequently labeled liberalism, while certainty is framed as conservatism. Although this association is relatively recent, it has become deeply misleading for contemporary generations. <strong>Doubt is not liberal</strong>; it does not prescribe values, identities, or outcomes. It is a tool — one that tests assumptions, exposes fragility, and refines understanding. <strong>Certainty,</strong> likewise, <strong>is not inherently conservative.</strong> It can emerge from conviction, tradition, or faith, but it becomes ideological only when it refuses interrogation.</p><p>This confusion arises when methods are mistaken for moral positions. <em>Once doubt is treated as a political identity rather than an epistemic practice, it becomes an enemy to defend against rather than an ally to employ.</em> Certainty, in turn, becomes a signal of loyalty rather than a conclusion reached through inquiry. This framing echoes patterns described earlier — how children are taught what to think before how to think, how exposure is moralized, how uncertainty is feared rather than trained, and how the line between free thought and controlled thought collapses. What began as parental protection evolved into social expectation and eventually into ideological shorthand.</p><p>The tragedy is not that societies choose certainty or doubt, but that they confuse tools for truths and methods for identities. <strong>When that confusion takes hold, inquiry no longer asks what is true. It asks what is acceptable.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/928/1*nUzL7fFgGWsKj337i0xd8Q.png" /><figcaption>Image of Rene Descartes in Medival Islamic Attire generated by Google Gemini</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e9fccda9d9e5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Curiosity without Permission | Trained to Doubt, Letter #2]]></title>
            <link>https://yelgharably.medium.com/trained-to-doubt-letter-2-f63814c65ba2?source=rss-f8d99c4b5712------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f63814c65ba2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ancient-egypt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[arab]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[egypt]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Youssef El Gharably]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 05 Jan 2026 09:58:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-09T15:11:46.615Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The intersection of religion and science is one that has been thoroughly explored since the dawn of civilization. Ancient Egyptians, Olmecs, Ancient Indians, Ancient Chinese, and the Caral–Supe civilization all believed in a deity — or deities — that formulated the world they lived in and governed the rules by which it operated. They believed the stars in the sky carried information that guided human life, and they believed there were universal rules that always held. That belief in consistent order is what we later came to call science.</p><p>These civilizations thrived by chasing the unknown. Ancient Egyptians, in particular, developed unmatched medical skills for their time; they became experts in astronomy, engineering, medicine, and art. They did not merely excel in these disciplines — their civilization was sustained by the pursuit of knowledge itself. Nevertheless, they still held deep religious beliefs and worshipped a variety of gods governing different domains of existence — Thoth, the god of knowledge; Osiris, the god of the dead; Hathor, the god of love.</p><p><strong>Ancient Egyptians believed the universe was ordered by the gods; therefore, it was measurable.</strong> They believed knowledge was sacred; therefore, it was pursued. They believed gods governed domains; therefore, humans studied those domains and specialized within them. <em>They treated the unknown as a divine mystery — not as a moral danger.</em> They worshipped gods of knowledge, regardless of the validity of those gods’ existence. The unknown was not something to be silenced, but something to be approached carefully, methodically, and with reverence. The universe was not <em>fragile</em> to them; conflicting ideas did not shatter belief when touched by reason.</p><p>The successors of the Ancient Egyptians, unfortunately, fell short. <em>Curiosity turned into suspicion. Doubt became rebellion.</em> Asking “why?” began to sound dangerously close to saying “no.”</p><p>The way modern Egyptians came to approach their beautiful and sacred religions became an unintended downfall — not because of religion itself, but because of how it was wielded. Religion shifted from a framework for understanding the world into a boundary around acceptable thought. <strong>Modern Egyptians are not short on intelligence, talent, or creativity. They are short on permission</strong>: permission to question without being labeled, permission to doubt without being accused, and permission to explore without social or physical exile.</p><p>Liberalism and conservatism did not create this problem; they merely became the language through which it was justified. One side promises freedom without grounding, the other promises grounding without freedom. Both demand loyalty before understanding. Ancient Egypt demanded neither — it demanded curiosity. Modern Egyptians struggle to find a place between liberalism and conservatism not for lack of effort, but for lack of permission.</p><p>Modern Egyptians do not struggle with religion. Egypt remains a global exporter of renowned Muslim and Christian scholars. <strong>What modern Egyptians struggle with is distinguishing between faith and intellectual sovereignty.</strong> Religion answers questions of meaning, ethics, purpose, and ways of life. Freedom of thought governs how we interrogate reality, evidence, and causality. Islam, in particular, encourages the pursuit of the unknown as a pathway to understanding Allah and the universe He created.</p><p>Ancient Egyptians did not confuse the two. Gods provided symbolic order; humans pursued mechanistic understanding. In modern Egypt, that boundary collapses. Religion ceases to function solely as a moral compass and becomes an epistemic authority — a veto over inquiry, a test of loyalty rather than a source of values.</p><p>Faith becomes dangerous when doubt is treated as disobedience, when questions are interpreted as intentions, and when curiosity is moralized instead of examined. <strong>The problem begins when belief stops guiding behavior and starts governing thought.</strong></p><p>The erosion of freedom of thought in Egypt was not the result of religion itself, but of religion being repeatedly repurposed — first as a shield, then as a state tool, and finally as an identity fortress. Over centuries of empire, colonization, and authoritarian governance, belief stopped answering questions and started preventing them. <strong>The tragedy is not that modern Egyptians believe deeply, but that they were never taught where belief should end and where thought should begin.</strong></p><p>I left Egypt in pursuit of the unknown that modern Egypt feared. <em>I did not feel like I was abandoning my history or my religion. I felt like I was returning to them — closer than I ever had before.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/770/0*eS_nQ2LYlhJsFAJ5.jpg" /><figcaption>Original art by Artist Mohamed Abou ElWafa</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f63814c65ba2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The First Permission to Question | Trained to Doubt, Letter #1]]></title>
            <link>https://yelgharably.medium.com/trained-to-doubt-letter-1-4635425eedb3?source=rss-f8d99c4b5712------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4635425eedb3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[egypt]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[arab-world]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[middle-east]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[conservatism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[liberalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Youssef El Gharably]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 04 Jan 2026 02:13:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-09T15:10:43.313Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The First Permission to Question | Trained to Doubt: Letter #1</h3><p>My name is Youssef El Gharably, short for Youssef Hesham Mohamed El Desoky El Gharably. In the Arab world, one’s name often includes the names of their father and grandfathers in chronological order, honoring the existence of those who came before them. I was born in a small town in Egypt called Zefta — a suburban city surrounded by rural land and hardworking farmers. For the first eighteen years of my life, I never crossed the borders of Egypt.</p><p>That changed when I decided to dedicate most of my day-to-day effort to studying abroad. This decision was largely driven by the fact that what I was passionate about studying did not present a viable career path in Egypt. At least, that’s what I tell people.</p><p>As a child born into the heart of the Gen Z era, I grew up with the internet and computers as vital parts of my life. Gen Z was exposed to the outside world significantly earlier than the generations before them — millennials (Gen Y) and Boomers (Gen X). As a result, Gen Z encountered a variety of ideologies while growing up, unlike older generations who were often only exposed to the ideologies and values passed down through their families and immediate social circles.</p><p>A child born into an Islamic religious family in the past would almost inevitably grow up to become a religious adult holding values similar to those of their family. Similarly, children born to Christian or moderately religious parents typically adopted the values their families held.</p><p>The internet and social media widened the menu. The selection of ideologies was no longer under the control of the families children were born into. Children could be exposed to anything — whether they wanted to see it or not. A child could be introduced to pornography, ideologies and values different from the ones they grew up with, and knowledge that was almost inaccessible to their elders: science, religion, politics, sociology, philosophy, and much more. A child’s mind is not always the best judge of what should enter and what should not, especially when parents are busy navigating the world and their own responsibilities. Social media companies introduced features such as parental controls to give parents more authority over what their children see, but that control is bound to expire once a parent feels their child is ready for the overwhelming world of social media — and the world at large.</p><p>One school of thought suggests simply giving parents more control over what their children are exposed to well into their teenage and young adult years. While this approach may feel effective from a parental perspective, children often grow up to discover how vast the world truly is and may assign blame to their parents for withholding the freedom they feel they deserved. In some cases, this can trigger a rebellious phase. Children can rebel against their parents at any point in their lives once the hypothetical shackles placed on them are broken.</p><p>Other schools of thought argue that children should be exposed to the world in a controlled, gradual manner — an idea that forms one of the cornerstones of Western K–12 education systems. The restricted-exposure school of thought is far more predominant in the Middle East than in the West, while the controlled-exposure approach dominates Western societies. Interestingly, families who subscribe to one school often move to countries that practice the other, and vice versa. A notable consequence of this is that families moving from controlled-exposure regions to restricted-exposure regions tend to be very vocal about their intentions and highly critical of the former system. However, families moving in the opposite direction are far less vocal. Why is that?</p><p>The distinction between these two schools mirrors the ideological divide between liberals and conservatives. Liberals and conservatives hold different values, yet both sets of values often emerge from love and care for their children. Conservatives believe that exposing their children only to what they themselves were exposed to is the safest approach. Liberals, on the other hand, believe that gradually exposing their children to everything is healthier. Conservatives perceive uncertainty in how their children might react to exposure and therefore attempt to prevent it altogether. Liberals, however, embrace that uncertainty, believing it teaches children that they have free will in deciding what they believe and what they reject. This raises a critical question: to what extent should a parent restrict their child’s free will?</p><p>This is where religion enters the discussion. Muslim parents often rely on the values Islam provides, which guide everything from social interactions to beliefs about God, prophets, judgment day, angels, devils, good and evil, and more. Islam presents itself as a comprehensive guide to life; the Qur’an describes Islam as the religion that completes the two preceding Abrahamic religions — Christianity and Judaism. If conservatives rely on religion, then what do liberals rely on?</p><p>Liberals often rely on history, science, philosophy, sociology, psychology, and the principle of free will. However, Islam also instructs its followers to rely on science. The Prophet Muhammad stated that scholars are the successors of God’s prophets. Since liberals place trust in science and the humanities, and Muslims are instructed to value scientific knowledge alongside the Qur’an, there should theoretically be an intersection in their Venn diagram of ideologies.</p><p>Yet, this intersection seemed nonexistent during my upbringing in Egypt. We were taught to hate liberals and to reject Western ideologies outright.<br> Stay tuned to hear more about my life growing up within this framework.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jUqdtJpxDwD_ho8z.jpg" /><figcaption>The Library of Alexandria, 19th-century artistic rendering by German artist O. Von Corven</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4635425eedb3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>