<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by David Zhang on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by David Zhang on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@yihaozhang87507832?source=rss-37e9bff8319e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 20:17:52 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@yihaozhang87507832/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Crypto Market Pricing Power Returns to the Public Arena]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@yihaozhang87507832/how-crypto-market-pricing-power-returns-to-the-public-arena-78d0b99b26df?source=rss-37e9bff8319e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/78d0b99b26df</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Zhang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Jun 2025 22:08:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-14T22:08:25.590Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Why Liquid Funds Are Structurally Favored</strong></h4><h3><strong>TLDR:</strong></h3><ul><li><strong>The High-FDV Model Has Collapsed, Externalizing Risk to Secondary Markets</strong> The previously dominant “high valuation + low float + long vesting” fundraising structure is breaking down. Many tokens now peak at listing and enter prolonged downtrends, leading to severe valuation corrections, diluted VC ROI, and declining user engagement — forming a negative feedback loop.</li><li><strong>Fair Launches and Lean Market Entrants Offer High-Conviction Trades</strong> More projects are bypassing VC funding entirely, opting for low-FDV, high-float, and fair-launch mechanisms. These models are transparent, game-theoretic, and liquid — ideal for tactical positioning in secondary markets.</li><li><strong>Tooling and Data Infrastructure Are Empowering Institutional Trading</strong> Platforms like <strong>IntoTheBlock</strong>, <strong>TokenTerminal</strong>, <strong>Arkham</strong>, and <strong>Growthepie</strong> now offer robust analytics on on-chain behavior, protocol-level financials, and capital flows. This enables Liquid Funds to shift from narrative-driven speculation to data-informed, structure-based strategies.</li><li><strong>VCs Are Pivoting to Liquid Funds, and Pricing Power Is Moving On-Chain</strong> Leading firms like <strong>Symbolic</strong>, <strong>Delphi</strong>, and <strong>Pantera</strong> have launched liquid token funds, focusing on open-market execution over early-stage allocation. Even market makers like <strong>Wintermute</strong> are participating in public sales and executing rapid, closed-loop strategies.</li><li><strong>Takeaway for Retail: Research Is the New Alpha</strong> In a market where narratives are fading and data transparency is rising, retail investors can now leverage professional-grade tools to build conviction, manage execution, and participate systematically in on-chain supply-demand dynamics — transitioning from reactive followers to disciplined speculators.</li></ul><h3><strong>Why the Retreat of VCs Has Created a More Favorable Battleground for Liquid Funds</strong></h3><p>Historically, primary markets have served as the central arena for pricing and distributing crypto assets. However, this model of <em>closed, pre-allocated funding</em> is being increasingly displaced by mechanisms rooted in on-chain liquidity and open market dynamics. As projects bypass traditional VC rounds in favor of fairer, more transparent launch structures, the process of price discovery is shifting — from <em>protocol-driven pricing</em> to <em>market-driven bidding</em>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*gfPAfd4liJdMeOnk" /></figure><p>This transition forces investors to evolve — from passive TGE participants to active on-chain observers and behavioral strategists. In this new paradigm, <strong>institutions with access to data, capital, and execution capability — namely Liquid Funds — gain a distinct structural edge</strong>.</p><p>Key sources of strategic advantage for Liquid Funds in this shift include:</p><ul><li>Skipping the opaque, high-valuation, discount-laden TGE stage to engage directly in price discovery through live market trading;</li><li>Gaining early insight into supply-demand dislocations via on-chain data and capital flow signals;</li><li>Leveraging increasingly mature analytics and infrastructure to deepen research and accelerate execution.</li></ul><p>In the following sections, we break down this structural migration across three key dimensions.</p><h3><strong>The Breakdown of the High-FDV Model and Spillover of Structural Risk</strong></h3><p>During the previous bull cycle, many crypto projects adopted a fundraising model centered around <em>high valuations and low float</em>. Early-stage private rounds were conducted at extremely elevated fully diluted valuations (FDVs) — often reaching hundreds of millions or even billions of dollars — despite the project’s limited or nonexistent value capture capabilities. These rounds were typically coupled with strict long-term vesting schedules (e.g., 1–4 years of cliff plus linear vesting), further limiting initial circulating supply.</p><p>This approach — <em>front-loaded pricing with deferred delivery</em> — is increasingly dysfunctional in today’s market. On one hand, the moment a token is listed, the market treats it as a point of valuation realization. Given the limited circulating supply, the token often peaks immediately upon listing. On the other hand, with scheduled unlocks and the market repricing based on weak fundamentals, a surge of token supply flows into the secondary market without corresponding demand or sustainable revenue, triggering persistent selling pressure and a downward price spiral.</p><p>According to Animoca Research (2024), an analysis of 773 newly listed tokens across Binance, OKX, KuCoin, Bybit, and Bitget shows median returns ranging from –40% to –70%. In particular, Bitget and Bybit listings saw median drawdowns of over –66% and –70%, respectively. This indicates that the majority of newly launched tokens quickly fall below their initial valuations and become exit liquidity rather than centers of liquidity aggregation. (Source: <a href="https://cryptoslate.com/tokens-display-up-to-negative-70-median-returns-after-cex-listing-animoca-research/?utm_source=chatgpt.com">CryptoSlate / Animoca Research</a>)</p><p>This dynamic not only erodes secondary market confidence but also weakens project momentum. As token prices underperform, user engagement declines, incentive structures inside the ecosystem break down, and the project falls into a negative feedback loop: <em>price weakness → lower participation → weakening fundamentals → further sell pressure</em>. Meanwhile, VC-held tokens — often subject to long lockups — cannot be sold or repositioned during market downturns, resulting in severely diluted ROI.</p><p>As a result, the legacy fundraising model — high FDV, low float, long vesting — is no longer tolerated by the market. Founders increasingly recognize its long-term damage to token performance and community engagement. In response, many are shifting toward <em>more flexible, market-driven issuance models</em>, such as low-FDV launches and fair public offerings.</p><p>This structural transition is creating a more sustainable and gameable environment for the new generation of <em>secondary-market-focused liquid funds</em>, offering real-time entry points, clearer price discovery, and stronger alignment with long-term value creation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*wRdul9OjC5W2QMGH" /><figcaption>Token 7d Performance by Exchange(Animoca)</figcaption></figure><h3><strong>Return of ICOs and Small-Scale Launches: A Resurgence of Secondary Market Opportunities</strong></h3><p>Amid the structural breakdown of the high-FDV model, a growing number of crypto projects are deliberately bypassing traditional private rounds and venture capital. Instead, they are opting for low-FDV launches, fair public sales, or fully community-driven token distributions. These models restore transparency to early supply-demand dynamics, significantly reduce unlock-related sell pressure, and improve both accessibility and price stability in secondary markets.</p><p>A prime example is <strong>Hyperliquid (HYPE)</strong>, which entirely excluded VC and private investors. The project launched via a public airdrop of 31% of its token supply, coupled with token buyback and community incentive mechanisms to bootstrap early trading demand. With no discounts, no vesting, and no institutional market makers involved, HYPE achieved rapid price discovery through pure market activity. The token’s fully diluted valuation soared from $150 million at launch to over $15 billion, marking it as one of the most successful fair launches of the current cycle.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*toyW9V8L_X-qzmDZEkwwwA.png" /><figcaption>$HYPE token performance (DefiLlama)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Plasma (XPL)</strong> went even further in implementing a capital formation model rooted in egalitarian principles. During its fundraising campaign on Sonar, all participants — including retail users — received token allocations at the same $500 million FDV valuation as Founders Fund and other institutional investors. There were no reserved allocations, no discounts, and no vesting. Instead, its <em>time-weighted deposit</em> mechanism calculated allocation rights based on both the amount and duration of stablecoin deposits, ensuring that the final distribution was determined transparently on-chain. This model drew over $500 million in commitment during its initial round alone.</p><p>For investors with strong capabilities in on-chain monitoring and capital allocation, such structures offer superior clarity for strategic execution:</p><ul><li>Fundraising and price discovery occur simultaneously, enabling primary access to trading momentum;</li><li>Absence of hidden discounts or vesting schedules ensures a transparent and manageable supply curve;</li><li>High initial float combined with low valuations reduces sell-side overhang and supports long-term trading strategies.</li></ul><p>The fundamental advantage of these models lies in their ability to establish an early price anchor and foster market consensus through open participation. This approach offers a more sustainable path to token issuance — one that not only supports healthier project growth but also provides liquid funds and other secondary participants with a more stable and high-conviction investment landscape.</p><h3><strong>Maturation of Tooling and Data Infrastructure: Accelerating the Institutionalization of Crypto Secondary Markets</strong></h3><p>This structural shift is not only reflected in how projects raise capital, but also in how information is disseminated and processed. As the market evolves from a narrative-driven primary cycle to a liquidity- and behavior-driven secondary regime, the demand for transparency and analytical tooling has grown in parallel. Between 2024 and 2025, the crypto industry has witnessed rapid development of foundational research infrastructure — establishing a Bloomberg-grade standard for analyzing digital assets across on-chain data, protocol-level financials, and entity-level attribution.</p><p>Platforms like <strong>IntoTheBlock</strong> now offer comprehensive on-chain analytics across 1,000+ assets, enabling institutional investors to monitor large transactions, fund flows, holding concentration, unrealized PnL, DEX market depth, and trade dispersion metrics. These datasets are widely used to detect whale behavior and localized liquidity stress points.</p><p>Meanwhile, <strong>Token Terminal</strong> has institutionalized “financial statement-style” analytics for crypto protocols — standardizing key metrics such as protocol revenue, user activity, fees, and total value locked (TVL). Its integration into legacy systems like Bloomberg via API allows for valuation benchmarking and pricing models that mirror traditional equity research workflows.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GQLMThhkBOYn_qj5n1sQ2w.png" /><figcaption>AAVE Financial Statement(Token Terminal)</figcaption></figure><p>Complementary platforms like <strong>Arkham Intelligence</strong>, <strong>CryptoQuant</strong> enhance analytical precision by focusing on address-level identity, capital movement tracking, and market sentiment. For instance, Arkham’s entity mapping enables real-time monitoring of early buyers, project wallets, and market makers — providing actionable inputs for risk management and portfolio construction. CryptoQuant’s dashboards on stablecoin inflows and LST (Liquid Staking Token) dynamics are increasingly used to forecast short-term price elasticity and volatility.</p><p>Together, these tools significantly improve both the <strong>research depth</strong> and <strong>execution efficiency</strong> of secondary market strategies. Compared to the previous cycle — when narratives and private intel dictated most flows — investors can now construct bottom-up theses and structure trades using verifiable, live data. The ability to track on-chain supply/demand imbalances and react systematically to real-time signals enables Liquid Funds to operate with a level of precision previously unavailable in public crypto markets.</p><p>Enhanced transparency also fosters greater market efficiency and reduces susceptibility to manipulation. Research is no longer gated by insider access; instead, it is democratized through data platforms, analytical frameworks, and transparent blockchain behavior. This shift allows Liquid Funds to replicate the research-driven edge of traditional institutions, redefining the competitive landscape of secondary market investing and pushing crypto capital markets toward a more mature and professionalized era.</p><h3><strong>Conclusion</strong></h3><p><strong>Price Discovery Returns to the Open Market — Liquid Funds as the Strategic Winners of the New Cycle</strong></p><p>As traditional primary market structures falter and on-chain trading dynamics grow increasingly complex, the crypto markets of 2024–2025 are undergoing a profound reallocation of pricing power. Valuations are no longer determined by VC discounts and promotional narratives, but are instead anchored through transparent, real-time competition in open markets. In this context, <strong>Liquid Funds</strong> — institutions equipped with research, capital deployment, and execution capabilities — are emerging as the dominant force in this structurally reshaped landscape.</p><p>This shift is evident in the strategic moves of top-tier venture firms. In 2024, players such as <strong>Symbolic Capital</strong> (founded by the former Polygon co-founder), <strong>Delphi Ventures</strong>, <strong>Framework</strong>, and <strong>Pantera Capital</strong> all announced the launch or expansion of <strong>liquid token funds</strong>, signaling a transition away from closed, early-stage allocation games toward open-market, strategy-driven participation. These funds emphasize <strong>on-chain behavioral data</strong>, <strong>tokenomics structure analysis</strong>, and <strong>secondary market win-rate modeling</strong> — rather than competing for illiquid, pre-TGE positions.</p><p>Even more notably, leading market makers like <strong>Wintermute</strong> and trading-native funds like <strong>CMS Holdings</strong> have begun engaging directly in fair launches, rapidly closing liquidity loops through early-stage participation and active trading. This reflects a convergence between high-frequency trading (HFT) expertise and crypto-native research frameworks — a hybrid that is likely to define the future of alpha generation.</p><p>For retail investors, this paradigm shift also presents a critical insight: in a market where <strong>narratives weaken and data transparency strengthens</strong>, building an informed view through <strong>on-chain behavior and capital flow analysis</strong> will likely outperform reliance on social hype. Tools like <strong>IntoTheBlock</strong>, <strong>TokenTerminal</strong>, <strong>Arkham</strong>, and <strong>Growthepie</strong> now offer retail participants access to institutional-grade data, enabling them to evolve from passive trend followers to systematic, thesis-driven speculators — capable of identifying structural inefficiencies not yet priced in by the broader market.</p><p>Crypto markets are becoming more meritocratic — but also more demanding. As pricing power returns to the open market, success will increasingly be defined not by early access or insider connections, but by the ability to <strong>decode real-time demand/supply structures</strong> and act on <strong>clear, data-driven market signals</strong>. In this new cycle, the edge belongs to those who can combine research and execution at scale — and Liquid Funds are leading the charge.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=78d0b99b26df" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The End of Dollar Hegemony: Framework for Understanding the Collapse of the Global Order]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@yihaozhang87507832/the-end-of-dollar-hegemony-framework-for-understanding-the-collapse-of-the-global-order-bdb290ebfcbb?source=rss-37e9bff8319e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bdb290ebfcbb</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Zhang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Apr 2025 22:06:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-09T22:06:13.172Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Ray Dalio recently emphasized that the current global turmoil does not stem merely from surface-level tariff disputes, but rather from a deeper, structural collapse of the monetary, political, and geopolitical order. This collapse reflects a cyclical transformation in history, driven primarily by the interaction of five major forces:</p><h3>I. The Unsustainability of Dollar Hegemony</h3><h4>1. Debt Bubbles and Monetary Imbalance</h4><p>The current dollar-centric global monetary system is built upon a cycle of imbalance between debtor nations (e.g., the U.S.) and creditor nations (e.g., China, Japan):</p><ul><li><strong>U.S. debt expansion</strong>: As of 2023, U.S. federal debt has reached 132% of GDP. The country sustains its debt growth through ongoing quantitative easing, forming a vicious cycle of “borrowing new to pay old.”</li><li><strong>Creditor nations’ dependency is unsustainable</strong>: These countries accumulate U.S. dollars through exports and reinvest in U.S. Treasuries. However, under de-globalization trends, this trust-based relationship is breaking down due to supply chain fragility and rising concerns over U.S. debt default.</li></ul><h4>2. Inherent Contradictions in the Dollar System</h4><ul><li><strong>The Triffin Dilemma intensifies</strong>: The dollar must run persistent trade deficits to supply global liquidity. Yet, prolonged deficits undermine the dollar’s credibility, causing currency volatility and macroeconomic imbalances.</li><li><strong>Weakening real economy support</strong>: The U.S. has adopted a “debt-fueled + financialized” growth model (e.g., expansion of financial derivatives), eroding the material foundation of dollar hegemony. The recent reindustrialization push has yet to revive real competitiveness.</li></ul><h3>II. Disintegration of Political and Geopolitical Orders</h3><h4>1. Domestic Political Polarization and Social Fragmentation</h4><p>The U.S. faces extreme disparities in wealth distribution and access to education, leading to a “winner-takes-all” democracy. Compromise and the rule of law are increasingly marginalized. Dalio notes that such polarization will exacerbate economic volatility and capital market instability.</p><h4>2. Shifting Geopolitical Power</h4><ul><li><strong>Multilateralism gives way to unilateralism</strong>: U.S.-led “rules-based” systems (e.g., the WTO) are being replaced by a “power-first” logic, marked by trade protectionism, tech embargoes, and military deterrence.</li><li><strong>Emerging economies challenge the dollar monopoly</strong>: BRICS nations are advancing local currency settlements and currency swap agreements. The internationalization of the Renminbi and the development of digital currencies are directly undermining the dollar’s status as the sole reserve currency.</li></ul><h3>III. Catalytic Role of Technological Change and External Shocks</h3><ul><li><strong>AI and digital currencies</strong>: Technological advances are reshaping the economic order and weakening reliance on traditional financial systems centered on the dollar (e.g., blockchain reduces cross-border payment costs).</li><li><strong>Climate crisis and pandemics</strong>: Frequent natural disasters have exposed vulnerabilities in global supply chains, prompting nations to pursue de-dollarization and greater self-reliance.</li></ul><h3>The Dollar’s Fate in Historical Cycles</h3><p>Dalio compares today’s transformation to the historical decline of British pound dominance. The collapse of a hegemonic currency typically accompanies debt crises, geopolitical conflicts, and technological revolutions. While the dollar is unlikely to be entirely replaced in the short term, its relative decline is inevitable. Possible future scenarios include:</p><ul><li><strong>Balanced decline</strong>: The dollar coexists with other major currencies (e.g., the Renminbi, Euro) in a multipolar system.</li><li><strong>Systemic disruption</strong>: A debt crisis could trigger a collapse in dollar credibility, resulting in global financial turmoil.</li></ul><h3>Final Takeaway: Preparing for the Transition and Rethinking Reserve Assets</h3><p>In light of Dalio’s framework, the collapse of the existing global monetary and geopolitical order is not a temporary dislocation but a structural shift. For individuals, institutions, and sovereigns alike, preparation involves rebalancing portfolios, reassessing monetary dependencies, and embracing resilience-oriented strategies. Key actions include:</p><ul><li><strong>Diversifying away from dollar-denominated assets</strong>, especially long-duration U.S. Treasuries, which may face credit risk and purchasing power erosion.</li><li><strong>Increasing exposure to hard assets</strong> (e.g., commodities, gold, real estate in stable jurisdictions) as hedges against fiat devaluation.</li><li><strong>Reevaluating sovereign and corporate risk models</strong>, incorporating geopolitical fragmentation and supply chain regionalization.</li></ul><h3>Implications for Bitcoin: A New Kind of Reserve Asset?</h3><p>In this paradigm shift, Bitcoin (BTC) and similar decentralized digital assets are gaining renewed relevance — not as speculative plays, but as potential structural hedges. Several professional-grade arguments support this thesis:</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bdb290ebfcbb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The End of the Altcoin Supercycle? A Structural Shift in the Crypto Market]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@yihaozhang87507832/the-end-of-the-altcoin-supercycle-a-structural-shift-in-the-crypto-market-c22973754cc0?source=rss-37e9bff8319e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c22973754cc0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Zhang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 27 Mar 2025 21:55:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-27T21:55:09.597Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>From ICO Mania to Meme Coin Chaos: The Final Chapter of Altcoins</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1AKw6m05qdR1Un99" /></figure><p>Chris Solarz, CIO of Amitis Capital, recently argued that the era of “everything pumps” in altcoins is over. He believes that out of the 40 million tokens in today’s crypto ecosystem, 99.99% will ultimately go to zero, and fewer than 100 tokens are actually worth discussing.</p><p>I tend to agree with this view. From 2024 to 2025, we’ve witnessed the death of broad-based altcoin rallies. The core reason lies in deep structural changes in the market:</p><p><strong>1) Collapse of the Liquidity Allocation Mechanism</strong><br> <em>Venture capital dominance has broken price discovery.</em></p><p>In early 2024, VC-driven valuations were already pricing in aggressive future expectations. For example, private rounds for new Layer 1 projects often exceeded $3B, while FDV at mainnet launch skyrocketed past $10B. This created unsustainable valuation bubbles that led to immediate post-launch price dumps — triggering a “VC dump → retail exit liquidity” death spiral.</p><p>By contrast, in the 2020 bull run, top DeFi projects like UNI had a circulating market cap of only $300M at launch, with an FDV-to-circulating ratio around 4:1. In 2025, that ratio now averages 20:1.</p><p><strong>2) Meme Coin Liquidity Drain</strong><br> <em>Permissionless launch platforms are siphoning liquidity.</em></p><p>Platforms like Pump.fun mint over 24,000 tokens per day, with Solana alone seeing 186,000 meme coins launched in a single day. According to Dune data, meme coins accounted for 58% of total crypto trading volume in Q1 2025 — far exceeding DeFi’s share at the same point in 2021.</p><p>This has led to:</p><ul><li>Daily altcoin trading volume dropping from $48B in 2021 to just $9B in 2025</li><li>The top 200 altcoins falling 72% against BTC on average</li></ul><p><strong>3) A Shift in Market Participants</strong><br> <em>Institutional capital has structurally exited.</em></p><p>With Fed interest rates holding at 5.25–5.5%, traditional hedge funds have reduced crypto exposure from 2.3% in 2021 to just 0.8%. Institutions now favor low-risk assets like spot BTC ETFs. This is a stark contrast to 2020, when near-zero interest rates fueled a 340% annual increase in altcoin inflows from institutional investors.</p><p><strong>4) Evolution of Retail Behavior</strong><br> <em>Rug pulls have made retail investors hyper-speculative.</em></p><p>Retail has shifted to “hit-and-run” investing.</p><ul><li>Average holding period has collapsed from 17 days in 2021 to just 3.2 hours in 2025</li><li>Sniping bot usage at token launch has surged from 12% to 89%</li></ul><p>This speculative pattern prevents long-term capital from accumulating in the altcoin ecosystem — unlike the ICO era of 2017, where community capital remained sticky.</p><p><strong>5) The Collapse of Valuation Frameworks</strong><br> <em>FDV inflation has decoupled price from fundamentals.</em></p><p>In 2025, new projects only circulate an average of 4.7% of total supply at launch, compared to 18% in 2021. Take Berachain, for example: its private valuation reached $4.5B, yet 80% of tokens are locked until 2027.</p><p>This leads to:</p><ul><li>Median market cap/FDV ratio dropping from 0.32 in 2021 to 0.04 in 2025</li><li>First-day token turnover exceeding 600%, compared to 85% in 2021</li></ul><p><strong>Historical Contrast: Why Altcoin Seasons No Longer Repeat</strong></p><p>The 2017 “alt season” playbook is now obsolete:</p><ul><li><em>Tech narratives</em> have been replaced by <em>financial engineering</em>: Ethereum ecosystem upgrades are overshadowed by VC-driven quant strategies</li><li><em>Community consensus</em> is undermined by <em>algorithmic trading</em>: market makers control liquidity pools of 43 out of the top 50 altcoins</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rrzWuw1vrgnaHKOEY26zzw.png" /><figcaption>Drivers of Historical Altcoin Seasons (2017–2025)</figcaption></figure><p>Unless we see a technological paradigm shift — such as the fusion of AI agents and blockchain — the return of a traditional altcoin season is unlikely. What we’re witnessing now, particularly the “meme coin supercycle,” is not a healthy market rotation but a fragmented liquidity reaction to broken market structure.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c22973754cc0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Stablecoins Unpacked: The Current Landscape and Market Dynamics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@yihaozhang87507832/stablecoins-unpacked-the-current-landscape-and-market-dynamics-a4437f4bdce2?source=rss-37e9bff8319e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a4437f4bdce2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stable-coin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Zhang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Mar 2025 23:43:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-12T23:43:17.370Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>A Comprehensive Analysis of the Stablecoin Landscape, Emerging Innovations, and Market Prospects</h4><h3>I. Current status of the stablecoin track</h3><p>Stablecoins are one of the first<strong> killer apps</strong> to emerge from the RWA track and even the entire Web3 field, with their advantages of high efficiency, low transaction costs and a wide range of use cases. They have demonstrated strong market competitiveness and development potential.</p><p>In recent years, with the development of infrastructure such as Layer 2 and interactive solutions, the cost and timeliness of using stablecoins have been further improved. From the initial encrypted trading tools (more stable value storage and trading media), they have gradually evolved into more extensive and complex financial applications, which are used for cross-border remittances, lending and payment for goods and services, simplifying the process of global value transfer and promoting the landing and application of Web3 technology in the real world.</p><p>As for Market size and growth, stablecoins have already demonstrated excellent product-market fit. As of October 23, 2024, the total market value of the stablecoin market has grown from 4 billion U.S. dollars at the beginning of 2020 to 172.7 billion U.S. dollars today, accounting for 7.20% of the global cryptocurrency market value, with a CAGR of over 120%. According to statistics in June this year, stablecoins accounted for about 80% of all crypto transactions and 15% of global e-commerce payment transactions. (Circle). Its transaction volume in 2024Q2 reached 8.5 trillion, which is more than twice Visa’s 3.9 trillion. In addition, measured by daily active addresses, there are about 20 million addresses on the chain conducting stablecoin transactions every month. Stablecoins account for nearly one-third, or 32%, of daily cryptocurrency usage, second only to decentralized finance (DeFi) at 34%. (a16z State of Crypto Report), showing that the stablecoin market has strong demand and is growing rapidly.</p><p>With the increasing adoption rate of abstracted wallets, the improvement of cryptocurrency payment facilities, the development of local regulations, and the participation of more Web2 financial institutions and enterprises, the stablecoin industry and related infrastructure are expected to continue to flourish in the next few years.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/712/1*iLJ_BbER1HDdVttALDzYjQ.png" /><figcaption>(Source: DeFillama)</figcaption></figure><h3>Industry landscape</h3><p><strong>Centralized stablecoins</strong>: Tether (120B, 70%) and Circle (34.46B, 20%) still occupy a significant market share. Both have rapidly expanded and established high liquidity and strong network effects thanks to their early-mover advantage, which together form their competitive moat.</p><p>It is worth mentioning that PayPal’s PYUSD, as an emerging player in the centralized stablecoin space, has quickly gained market share through its global payment network and extensive user base. web2’s accumulated industry advantages and the easy on/off ramp through PayPal and Venmo wallets make PYUSD an ideal choice for retail users and businesses. It is also actively building an ecosystem around the Payfi concept.</p><p><strong>Decentralized stablecoin</strong>: In the past two years, MakerDAO has actively adjusted its strategy to enhance the diversity and stability of its economic model by increasing the proportion of RWA in the collateral, such as Ondo Treasury Bonds, which has improved the capital efficiency of Dai and also brought considerable benefits to MakerDAO. MakerDAO is also actively rebranding to adapt to market demand. For example, it has introduced a freeze function to enhance compliance, and has increased the yield by changing the token economics to increase the inflation reward and better support the development of its SubDAOs business.</p><p>Meanwhile, Ethena has rapidly captured the market through its unique Delta-neutral strategy, achieving stability and efficient capital utilization without overcollateralization. Combining the income from staking Ethereum (stETH) and the difference in funding rates in the derivatives market, it provides a very competitive yield (over 12%), attracting investors seeking higher returns. There are also upstarts like Usual Money that have risen quickly by distributing treasury bill yields to stablecoin holders and through innovative designs such as the $USUAL token to distribute ownership of the infrastructure.</p><p>Recent funding rounds have also revealed a number of interesting trends in the stablecoin industry. Project teams are actively exploring diversified ecosystems, and there is a clear interest in integrating with the Bitcoin ecosystem. For example, projects such as<strong> Lambda Finance</strong> and <strong>BIMA</strong> are committed to developing Bitcoin-based stablecoins. By using Bitcoin as a collateral asset, they have launched cross-chain compatible USD stablecoins, thereby leveraging the security and wide acceptance of Bitcoin to increase liquidity and stability.<br>Meanwhile, cross-chain interoperability is also a key development direction for the industry. Projects such as <strong>defi.money</strong>focus on supporting the interoperability of stablecoins on different chains through native cross-chain technology, especially between Ethereum layer-2 networks (such as Arbitrum and Optimism), enabling users to seamlessly transfer and operate assets in multiple blockchain ecosystems.<br>Innovations in Web2.5-oriented payment solutions are also gradually emerging. Projects like <strong>Bridge</strong> and <strong>WSPN</strong> are committed to providing fast payment and cross-border transaction services worldwide through stablecoins, using blockchain technology to achieve a low-cost, highly transparent payment model, and promoting financial inclusion and the facilitation of business scenarios.<br>From diversified ecosystems to cross-chain interoperability, from real asset collateral to global payment solutions, various innovations are attracting more and more capital into this market and driving the industry towards greater security, flexibility and diversification. Although the stablecoin industry has always been dominated by two players in terms of market share, newly designed stablecoin projects have still brought new vitality and possibilities to the entire industry through unique ecological focus, technological innovation and token economics innovation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/770/1*nrL7teyQnALoKL17z1KD4g.png" /><figcaption>(Source: Forbes)</figcaption></figure><h3>II. What are the main opportunities for the future of stablecoins?</h3><h3>From 1 to N: Expanding existing use cases</h3><ol><li><strong>Cross-border payments</strong>:</li></ol><p>Stablecoins have significant advantages in cross-border payments, providing a faster and cheaper alternative to traditional remittance services. Significant progress has already been made in a number of countries and companies. For example, fintech companies such as BVNK are using stablecoins to optimize cross-border payments, making fund transfers from Southeast Asia to Europe 3–4 times cheaper than using the Swift network, and transfers from Africa to Europe 5–10 times cheaper.</p><p>In addition, payment giants such as Visa and PayPal are exploring the use of stablecoins for cross-border transfers. As global trade grows, especially in emerging markets such as Africa, Latin America and Asia, where traditional financial infrastructure is not well-developed, there is a strong demand for low-cost, fast cross-border payments. Stablecoins can further expand their use in C2C, B2C and B2B transactions.</p><ol><li><strong>Merchant payments</strong>:</li></ol><p>● Stablecoins can gain wider adoption in consumer retail and online transactions through integration with payment processors and e-commerce platforms. For example, the Paxos and Stripe partnership, Pay with Crypto, makes it easier for merchants to accept stablecoin payments with instant conversion and settlement, reducing transaction costs and expanding the accessibility of international payments.</p><p>As crypto payment scenarios become more accepted, stablecoins could further penetrate the global merchant payment network in the future, especially in the e-commerce and retail sectors.</p><ol><li><strong>DeFi</strong>:</li></ol><p>● In the existing DeFi ecosystem, stablecoins are important tools for lending, liquidity provision and revenue generation. As DeFi grows, the use of stablecoins will continue to expand and become an important part of these new financial products. Existing stablecoins can be connected to more ecosystems.</p><h3>From 0 to 1: a new direction for innovation</h3><ol><li>PayFi:</li></ol><p>● PayFi is a new application model that combines payment functions with financial services. It promotes the efficient flow of value and optimizes the time value of money through blockchain and smart contract technology. Stablecoins can be used, for example, for payments and settlements in the supply chain, improving transparency and efficiency. Or for more time-sensitive trade financing. (Centrifuge, Huma finance)</p><p>Stablecoins will be the cornerstone of PayFi. If stablecoins are compared to a car, PayFi is like building a complete highway network, gas stations and various supporting service facilities for the car. New applications built around PayFi will undoubtedly increase the demand for stablecoins.</p><ol><li>Programmable currency:</li></ol><p>● Stablecoins can be used as programmable currencies to automate payments through smart contracts. This capability allows individuals to automate their financial management and businesses to automate payroll and bill payments, saving time and costs.</p><p>Currently, many projects are developing and improving the infrastructure for programmable currencies, such as Payment Data Layer, DID solutions, credit rating protocols, tokenization protocols, etc., which enrich the details of on-chain payment transactions.</p><ol><li>Asset tokenization integrated with the Internet of Things (IoT):</li></ol><p>Stablecoins can be integrated with IoT devices to enable machine-to-machine (M2M) transactions. Such applications will support seamless data exchange and automated payment processes, providing support for smart cities and Industry 4.0.</p><h3>Opportunities for large companies</h3><p>The further expansion of existing stablecoin applications presents a great opportunity for<strong> large companies that already have scale, vast resources and a global network</strong>. These companies can leverage their advantages to further expand their global business through stablecoins.<br><strong>Centralized stablecoin issuers</strong><br>Tether and Circle can further promote the use of their stablecoins (USDT and USDC) in cross-border payments. For example, partnering with international payment platforms, e-commerce companies, and fintech companies allows stablecoins to be seamlessly integrated into more payment scenarios. This will help them reach more users and merchants and increase the frequency of stablecoins being used in everyday payments.<br>The composition of asset collateral is also worth exploring. Tether and Circle can explore pegging stablecoins to real-world assets such as corporate bonds to launch more diverse financial products. For example, Circle has invested a portion of its USDC reserves in short-term Treasury bonds to improve the capital efficiency of USDC while providing users with more stable returns on their holdings. These kinds of combinations will make stablecoins more competitive in scenarios with high capital efficiency and low risk.</p><p><strong>Payment platforms</strong><br>such as those that can achieve a globally unified payment gateway/platform (such as Stripe and PayPal). Payment platforms can focus on building a more efficient and low-cost cross-border payment infrastructure that seamlessly integrates stablecoin payments and supports multi-currency transactions. This enables businesses to easily handle multi-country and multi-currency transactions, thereby reducing the complexity of existing cross-border payments. At present, major payment giants have already begun to make such attempts. Stripe, one of the leading US payment fintech giants, has recently invested <a href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/stripe-acquires-stablecoin-platform-bridge-techcrunch-founder">$1.1 billion to acquire Bridge, a stablecoin API service provider</a>, after testing encrypted payments for nearly two years. This marks the in-depth development of traditional payment platforms into the cryptocurrency ecosystem.</p><p>Bridge’s API can transfer funds globally within minutes, seamlessly send stablecoin payments, convert local fiat currencies into stablecoins, and provide US dollar and euro virtual accounts for consumers and businesses around the world, allowing users to save and spend in US dollars and euros. Further improving the convenience and user experience of stablecoins in the global market.</p><p>Large payment platforms can experiment with building new features around stablecoins, allowing users to easily access the global liquidity pool and conduct instant cross-border financial activities.<br><strong>On/off ramp</strong><br>On/off ramp platforms can provide users with real-time multi-currency exchange services based on the borderless nature of stablecoins, allowing them to easily purchase goods and services worldwide using their national currency. The increased demand for stablecoins means greater volume and frequency of use.<br><strong>DeFi platforms and other beneficiaries</strong><br>As the adoption of stablecoins increases, traditional on-chain lending and yield aggregation platforms (DeFi), RegTech companies, and payment solution integrators (such as Transak) are likely to become potential beneficiaries. DeFi platforms can use the stability of stablecoins to promote safer and more liquid lending and yield generation products, while RegTech companies can provide technical support for the legitimacy and compliance of stablecoin payments. Payment solution integrators can help traditional businesses and platforms access stablecoin payment networks faster and easier, promoting their use in the global market.</p><h3>Opportunities for startups</h3><p>The opportunities for innovation and new applications brought about by the development of stablecoins are better suited to small companies with flexibility and the ability to quickly adjust and iterate on products to validate the market.</p><h3>Innovative decentralized stablecoin protocols</h3><p>Stablecoin projects that go beyond the Ethereum ecosystem are showing unique growth potential. Stablecoins that use cryptocurrencies as collateral are not limited to Ethereum. Startups can explore new blockchain ecosystems. In addition to Bitcoin, ecosystems such as<strong> Injective</strong> and <strong>Solana</strong> are also becoming hotspots for stablecoin innovation.<br>Startups can also focus on creating new protocols that solve the stablecoin trilemma. The balance between “stability, decentralization, and capital efficiency” can be solved by designing new DeFi protocols. For example, Ethena attempts to solve the trilemma through a Delta Neutral strategy and Usual Money uses Treasury Bill yield distribution. These types of protocols not only provide decentralization and transparency, but also improve capital efficiency through innovative economic models.<br>By combining crypto assets, real-world assets (RWA) and algorithmic stabilization mechanisms, startups can develop new hybrid stablecoin models and novel tokennomics/Defi revenue models to cater to specific application scenarios and different user groups.</p><h3>Long-tail market innovation DeFi tools</h3><p><strong>Niche stablecoin lending and financing platforms</strong>: Startups can develop specialized stablecoin lending platforms in long-tail markets such as agricultural loans and personal microloans. These platforms can provide small businesses and individuals with faster and lower-cost financing solutions while leveraging the transparency and automation benefits of DeFi.<br>In emerging markets (Global South, Latam) and specific industries (e.g. agriculture, logistics), small businesses often face high financing thresholds and costs. Stablecoin lending platforms can fill this gap. Through DeFi technology, the platform can provide instant lending and settlement to help users solve short-term cash flow problems.<br>Small startups can gain early users from these market segments and expand the market through flexible business models and innovative financial products.</p><h3>IoT integration and M2M payment networks</h3><p>Startups can integrate stablecoins with Internet of Things (IoT) devices to create automated M2M payment networks (integrating Iotex and other ecosystems). Such networks can support automated payments and settlements between devices, such as automatic material procurement payments in industrial manufacturing or automatic payments for charging electric vehicles in smart cities.<br>Startups can develop middleware that supports M2M and even Agent to Agent payments, helping enterprises automatically process small payments through stablecoins and reduce manual intervention. Automated payments can improve efficiency, reduce costs, and simplify complex accounting. Through decentralization and borderless features, stablecoins can achieve lower transaction fees and faster settlement speeds.</p><h3>PayFi applications and infrastructure</h3><h3>Startups can develop more diverse applications around PayFi, such as real-time settlement in the supply chain, trade financing, and automated accounts receivable management. Or build related infrastructure, such as automated contract tools and liquidity pool management systems.</h3><p>In general, large companies in the stablecoin and related fields should make full use of their resources and global network advantages to lay out the stablecoin payment infrastructure in depth and seize market share. Startups, on the other hand, can leverage their flexibility to quickly iterate products by solving specific user needs around decentralized and innovative DeFi protocols, PayFi, and IoT application scenarios to gain a market advantage.</p><h3>III. What kind of team background is suitable for startups in this field?</h3><p>Starting a business in the stablecoin track requires a team with diverse and complementary backgrounds to meet the challenges of technology, marketing, and compliance. For those industries that are more web2.5 (PayFi, etc.), web2 fintech and product management experience are more important, which can help the team design products that are easy for traditional financial users to accept and connect traditional finance with blockchain. In some projects, founders with a traditional financial background also understand the needs of institutional investors better, giving the project a better Founder Market Fit.<br>For very web3 native projects, such as decentralized stablecoin protocols and DeFi platforms, the team needs to have strong blockchain technology development capabilities and smart contract design experience. These types of projects not only rely on complex decentralized algorithms and economic models, but also need to seamlessly interact across protocols in the DeFi ecosystem.<br>Moreover, as stablecoin regulation continues to tighten, legal experts familiar with global financial regulations and compliance requirements are needed on the team, especially for stablecoin protocols and stablecoin issuers. This helps the project operate legally within the legal framework and ensure the security and compliance of its services. For example, Bridge.xyz handles complex compliance issues and ensures that its API services can be used legally in multiple jurisdictions, which provides a good reference for how startups can handle compliance issues. Operating legally and in compliance is key to the long-term development of stablecoins and related projects.<br>Finally, being able to establish strategic partnerships and collaborate with other industry leaders is crucial. Support from a large company like Circle for Huma Finance can provide startups with resources, market access, and technical support. By establishing partnerships with large companies, startups can quickly enter the market and gain more users.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a4437f4bdce2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Decentralized data layer：new infrastructure of the AI era]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@yihaozhang87507832/decentralized-data-layer-new-infrastructure-of-the-ai-era-587c5193d0c0?source=rss-37e9bff8319e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/587c5193d0c0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Zhang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Mar 2025 22:29:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-12T22:30:20.124Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The engine behind AI x Crypto integration</h4><h3>TL / DR</h3><p>We have discussed how AI and Web3 can complement each other in various verticals, from computing networks to proxy platforms and consumer applications. When focusing on the vertical of data resources, Web3 represents projects that provide new possibilities for the acquisition, sharing and utilization of data.</p><ul><li>Traditional data providers are unable to meet the demand for high-quality, real-time verifiable data from AI and other data-driven industries, especially in terms of transparency, user control and privacy protection.</li><li>Web3 solutions are working to reshape the data ecosystem. Technologies such as MPC, zero-knowledge proofs and TLS Notary ensure the authenticity and privacy of data as it flows between multiple sources, while distributed storage and edge computing provide greater flexibility and efficiency for real-time data processing.</li><li>Among these, the emerging infrastructure of decentralized data networks has given rise to several representative projects: OpenLayer (a modular real-data layer), Grass (which utilizes users’ idle bandwidth and a decentralized network of crawler nodes), and Vana (a user data sovereignty Layer 1 network), which open up new prospects for fields such as AI training and applications using different technical approaches.</li><li>With the capacity of crowdsourcing, trustless abstraction layers and token-based incentives, decentralized data infrastructure can provide a more private, secure, efficient and economical solution than Web2’s hyperscale service providers, and give users control over their data and related resources to build a more open, secure and interoperable digital ecosystem.</li></ul><h3>1. Waves of data demand</h3><p>Data has become a key driver of innovation and decision-making in all industries. UBS predicts that the amount of global data is expected to grow more than tenfold between 2020 and 2030, reaching 660 ZB. By 2025, the world will generate 463 EB (Exabytes, 1 EB = 1 billion GB) of data per person per day. The data-as-a-service (DaaS) market is expanding rapidly. According to a report by Grand View Research, the global DaaS market is estimated to be worth US$14.36 billion in 2023 and is expected to grow at a compound annual growth rate of 28.1% to reach US$76.8 billion by 2030. Behind these high growth figures is the demand for high-quality, real-time and trustworthy data from multiple industry sectors.</p><p>AI model training relies on large amounts of data input to identify patterns and adjust parameters. After training, the dataset is also required to test the model’s performance and generalization ability. In addition, AI agents, as a new form of intelligent application that can be foreseen in the future, require a real-time and reliable data source to ensure accurate decision-making and task execution.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*w6b3OJb0QPTnLN4T.png" /></figure><p>The demand for business analytics is also becoming diverse and extensive, and has become a core tool for driving enterprise innovation. For example, social media platforms and market research companies need reliable user behavior data to develop strategies and gain insights into trends. Integrating diverse data from multiple social platforms can build a more comprehensive user profile.</p><p>For the Web3 ecosystem, reliable and real-world data is also needed on the chain to support some new financial products. As more and more new assets are tokenized, flexible and reliable data interfaces are needed to support the development of innovative products and risk management, so that smart contracts can be executed based on verifiable real-time data. In addition, there are fields such as scientific research and the Internet of Things (IoT).</p><p>New use cases show a surge in demand for diverse, real-world, real-time data across industries, and traditional systems may have difficulty coping with the rapidly growing volume of data and changing needs.</p><h3>2. Limitations and problems of the traditional data ecosystem</h3><p>A typical data ecosystem includes data collection, storage, processing, analysis and application. The centralized model is characterized by centralized collection and storage of data, managed and operated by the core enterprise IT team, and strict access control implemented.</p><p>For example, Google’s data ecosystem covers multiple data sources, from search engines and Gmail to the Android operating system. User data is collected through these platforms, stored in its globally distributed data centers, and then processed and analyzed using algorithms to support the development and optimization of various products and services.</p><p>In the financial markets, take LSEG (formerly Refinitiv) as an example. Its data and infrastructure generate analytical data and risk assessments using proprietary algorithms and models, which are offered as additional products. This is done by obtaining real-time and historical data from exchanges, banks and other major financial institutions around the world, as well as collecting market-related news using its own Reuters News network.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9DfZrseEa6Er9pFj.png" /></figure><p>Traditional data architectures have been effective in terms of professional services, but the limitations of the centralized model are becoming increasingly apparent. In particular, the traditional data ecosystem is facing challenges in terms of coverage, transparency and user privacy protection of emerging data sources. Here are a few examples:</p><ul><li>Insufficient data coverage: Traditional data providers have challenges in quickly capturing and analyzing emerging data sources such as social media sentiment and IoT device data. Centralized systems have difficulty efficiently accessing and integrating “long tail” data from many small or non-mainstream sources.<br>For example, the GameStop incident in 2021 also revealed the limitations of traditional financial data providers in analyzing social media sentiment. Investor sentiment on platforms such as Reddit quickly changed market trends, but data terminals like Bloomberg and Reuters failed to capture these dynamics in time, making market forecasting more difficult.</li><li>Limited data accessibility: Monopolies limit accessibility. Many traditional providers have opened up some of their data through API/cloud services, but high access fees and complex authorization processes still make data integration difficult.<br>On-chain developers have difficulty quickly accessing reliable off-chain data, and high-quality data is monopolized by a few giants, making access costly.</li><li>Data transparency and trust issues: Many centralized data providers lack transparency about their data collection and processing methods, and there is a lack of effective mechanisms to verify the authenticity and integrity of large-scale data. Verification of large-scale real-time data is still a complex issue, and the centralized nature also increases the risk of data being tampered with or manipulated.</li><li>Privacy protection and data ownership: Large technology companies and large-scale commercial platforms widely use user data. As private data creators, users can hardly get the value they deserve in return. Users are usually unable to understand how their data is collected, processed and used, and it is difficult for them to decide the scope and method of data use. Excessive collection and use of data leads to serious privacy risks.<br>For example, the Cambridge Analytica incident of Facebook revealed how traditional data providers have huge loopholes in transparency and privacy protection in the use of data.</li><li>Data silos: In addition, it is difficult to quickly integrate scattered data from different sources and formats, which affects the possibility of comprehensive analysis. A lot of data is often locked within organizations, limiting cross-industry and cross-organization data sharing and innovation. The data silo effect hinders cross-domain data integration and analysis.<br>For example, in the consumer industry, brands need to integrate data from e-commerce platforms, physical stores, social media, and market research, but this data may be difficult to integrate due to the inconsistent or isolated platform formats. Another example is ride-sharing companies like Uber and Lyft, which collect a lot of real-time data from users about transportation, passenger demand, and geographic location, but due to competition, this data cannot be proposed and shared for integration.</li></ul><p>In addition, there are issues of cost efficiency and flexibility. Traditional data providers are actively responding to these challenges, but the emerging Web3 technology provides new ideas and possibilities for solving these problems.</p><h3>3. Web3 data ecology</h3><p>Since the release of decentralized storage solutions such as IPFS (InterPlanetary File System) in 2014, a series of emerging projects have emerged in the industry, dedicated to solving the limitations of the traditional data ecosystem. We have seen decentralized data solutions form a multi-layered, interconnected ecosystem that covers all stages of the data lifecycle, including data generation, storage, exchange, processing and analysis, verification and security, as well as privacy and ownership.</p><ul><li><strong>Data storage</strong>: The rapid development of Filecoin and Arweave is proof that decentralized storage (DCS) is becoming a paradigm shift in the storage field. DCS solutions reduce the risk of single points of failure through a distributed architecture, while attracting participants with more competitive cost-effectiveness. With the emergence of a series of large-scale application cases, the storage capacity of DCS is showing explosive growth (for example, the total storage capacity of the Filecoin network has reached 22 exabytes by 2024).</li><li><strong>Data Processing</strong>: Decentralized data computing platforms such as Fluence use edge computing technology to improve the real-time nature and efficiency of data processing, making them particularly suitable for use cases with high real-time requirements such as the Internet of Things (IoT) and AI inference. Web3 projects use technologies such as federated learning, differential privacy, trusted execution environments, and fully homomorphic encryption to provide flexible privacy protection and trade-offs at the computing layer.</li><li><strong>Data marketplaces/exchange platforms</strong>: To promote the repurposing and circulation of data value, Ocean Protocol has created efficient and open data exchange channels through tokenization and DEX mechanisms. For example, it has helped traditional manufacturing companies (Daimler, the parent company of Mercedes-Benz) collaborate on the development of a data exchange marketplace to facilitate data sharing in supply chain management. Streamr, on the other hand, has created a permissionless, subscription-based data streaming network suitable for IoT and real-time analysis scenarios, and has shown outstanding potential in transportation and logistics projects (for example, in collaboration with the Finnish Smart City project).</li></ul><p>With the increasing frequency of data exchange and utilization, the authenticity, reliability and privacy protection of data have become key issues that cannot be ignored. This has prompted the Web3 ecosystem to continue innovating and iterating in the fields of data verification and privacy protection, giving rise to a series of groundbreaking solutions.</p><h4>3.1 Innovations in data verification and privacy protection</h4><p>Many web3 technologies and native projects are working to solve the problems of data authenticity and private data protection. In addition to ZK and MPC, other technologies such as TLS Notary are also widely used. TLS Notary is an emerging verification method that deserves particular attention. Introduction to TLS Notary Transport Layer Security (TLS) is an encryption protocol widely used in network communications to ensure the security, integrity, and confidentiality of data transmitted between clients and servers. It is a common encryption standard in modern network communications and is used in multiple scenarios such as HTTPS, email, and instant messaging.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/575/0*y8BxVhJnnf1ruBod.png" /></figure><p>When TLSNotary was born ten years ago, its initial goal was to verify the authenticity of TLS sessions by introducing a third-party “notary” in addition to the client (Prover) and server.</p><p>Using key splitting technology, the master key of the TLS session is divided into two parts, which are held by the client and the notary respectively. This design allows a notary to participate in the verification process as a trusted third party without having access to the actual communication content.</p><p>This notarization mechanism is designed to detect man-in-the-middle attacks, prevent fraudulent certificates, ensure that communication data has not been tampered with during transmission, and allow trusted third parties to confirm the legitimacy of the communication while protecting communication privacy.</p><p>As such, TLS Notary provides secure data verification and effectively balances the need for verification and privacy protection. In 2022, the TLS Notary project was rebuilt by the Privacy and Scaling Exploration (PSE) research laboratory of the Ethereum Foundation. The new version of the TLS Notary protocol was rewritten from scratch in Rust, incorporating more advanced encryption protocols (such as MPC).</p><p>The new protocol features allow users to prove to third parties the authenticity of the data they receive from the server without disclosing the specific content of the data. While maintaining the core verification function of TLS Notary, it has greatly improved privacy protection capabilities, making it more suitable for current and future data privacy needs.</p><h4>3.2 Variations and extensions of TLS Notary</h4><p>In recent years, TLS Notary technology has also continued to evolve, and several variations have been developed based on the foundation, further enhancing privacy and verification capabilities:</p><ul><li><strong>zkTLS</strong>: a privacy-enhanced version of TLS Notary that incorporates ZKP technology, allowing users to generate encrypted proofs of web page data without exposing any sensitive information. It is suitable for communication scenarios that require extremely high privacy protection.</li><li><strong>3P-TLS (Three-Party TLS)</strong>: introduces the three parties of client, server and auditor, and allows the auditor to verify the security of the communication without disclosing the content of the communication. This protocol is very useful in scenarios that require transparency but also require privacy protection, such as compliance reviews or audits of financial transactions.</li></ul><p>Web3 projects use these encryption technologies to enhance data verification and privacy protection, breaking down data silos and solving problems with trusted transmission, so that users can prove ownership of social media accounts, shopping records for financial lending, bank credit records, professional background and academic certification information without compromising privacy. For example:</p><ul><li><strong>Reclaim Protocol </strong>uses zkTLS technology to generate zero-knowledge proofs for HTTPS traffic, allowing users to securely import activity, reputation and identity data from external websites without exposing sensitive information.</li><li><strong>zkPass</strong> combines 3P-TLS technology to allow users to verify private data in the real world without disclosing it. It is widely used in scenarios such as KYC and credit services, and is compatible with HTTPS networks.</li><li><strong>Opacity Network</strong> is based on zkTLS and allows users to securely prove their activities on various platforms (such as Uber, Spotify, Netflix, etc.) without having direct access to the APIs of these platforms, enabling cross-platform activity proof.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kgrlLBj4FXgPMoMk.png" /></figure><p>Web3 data verification, as an important part of the data ecosystem, has broad application prospects. The rise of this ecosystem is leading to a more open, dynamic and user-centric digital economy. However, the development of authenticity verification technology is only the beginning of building a new generation of data infrastructure.</p><h3>4. Decentralized data networks</h3><p>Some projects combine the above data verification technologies to explore the upstream of the data ecology in greater depth, namely data traceability, distributed data collection and trusted transmission. The following focuses on several representative projects: OpenLayer, Grass and Vana, which show unique potential in building a new generation of data infrastructure.</p><h4>4.1 OpenLayer</h4><p>OpenLayer is one of the projects in the a16z Crypto 2024 Spring Crypto Startup Accelerator. As the first modular real-world data layer, it is dedicated to providing an innovative modular solution for coordinating the collection, verification and transformation of data to meet the needs of both Web2 and Web3 companies. OpenLayer has attracted the support of well-known funds and angel investors including Geometry Ventures and LongHash Ventures.</p><p>Traditional data layers face multiple challenges: a lack of trusted verification mechanisms, limited accessibility due to a reliance on centralized architectures, a lack of interoperability and mobility of data between systems, and a lack of fair data value distribution mechanisms.<br>A more specific problem is that AI training data is becoming increasingly scarce. On the public internet, many websites are beginning to prevent AI companies from accessing data on a large scale through crawler restrictions.</p><p>The situation is more complicated when it comes to private proprietary data. Many valuable data are stored in a privacy-preserving manner due to their sensitive nature, and there is a lack of effective incentives. In this situation, users are unwilling to share sensitive data because they cannot safely obtain direct benefits by providing private data.</p><p>To solve these problems, OpenLayer combines data verification technology to build a Modular Authentic Data Layer (MADL), and uses a decentralized economic incentive approach to coordinate the data collection, verification and conversion process, providing a safer, more efficient and more flexible data infrastructure for Web2 and Web3 companies.</p><h4>4.1.1 Core components of OpenLayer’s modular design</h4><p>OpenLayer provides a modular platform to simplify the process of data collection, trusted verification and conversion:</p><p>a) OpenNodes<br>OpenNodes is the core component of the OpenLayer ecosystem responsible for decentralized data collection. Data is collected through channels such as the user’s mobile app and browser extensions. Different operator nodes can be optimized to perform the most suitable tasks according to their hardware specifications and return the best results.<br>OpenNodes supports three main types of data to meet the needs of different types of tasks:</p><p>• Publicly available Internet data (such as financial data, weather data, sports data, and social media streams)<br>• Private user data (e.g. Netflix viewing history, Amazon order history, etc.)<br>• Self-reported data from trusted sources (e.g. data signed by the proprietary owner or verified by specific trusted hardware)</p><p>Developers can easily add new data types, specify new data sources, requirements and data retrieval methods, and users can choose to provide de-identified data in exchange for rewards. This design allows the system to be continuously expanded to meet new data needs. The diverse data sources make OpenLayer able to provide comprehensive data support for various application scenarios and also lower the threshold for data provision.</p><p>b) OpenValidators<br>OpenValidators is responsible for subsequent data validation, allowing data consumers to confirm that the data provided by the user matches the data source exactly. All provided validation methods can be cryptographically proven, and the validation results can be verified afterwards. Multiple different providers offer services for the same type of proof. Developers can choose the most suitable validation provider according to their needs.<br>In the initial use case, especially for public or private data from Internet APIs, OpenLayer uses TLS Notary as the authentication solution to export data from any web application and prove the authenticity of the data without compromising privacy.</p><p>Not limited to TLS Notary, thanks to its modular design, the authentication system can easily access other authentication methods to adapt to different types of data and authentication needs, including but not limited to</p><p>1. Attested TLS connections: Establishes authenticated TLS connections using a trusted execution environment (TEE) to ensure the integrity and authenticity of data during transmission.</p><p>2. Secure Enclaves: Uses a hardware-level secure isolation environment (such as Intel SGX) to process and verify sensitive data, providing a higher level of data protection.</p><p>3. ZK Proof Generators: Integrates ZKP to allow the verification of data attributes or calculation results without disclosing the original data.</p><p>c) OpenConnect<br>OpenConnect is the core module in the OpenLayer ecosystem responsible for data conversion and usability. It processes data from various sources and ensures data interoperability between different systems to meet the needs of different applications. For example:<br>• Convert data to the on-chain Oracle format for direct use by smart contracts.<br>• Convert unstructured raw data to structured data for preprocessing purposes such as AI training.</p><p>For data from users’ private accounts, OpenConnect provides data desensitization to protect privacy, as well as components to enhance security during data sharing and reduce data leaks and misuse. To meet the real-time data needs of applications such as AI and blockchain, OpenConnect supports efficient real-time data conversion.</p><p>Currently, through the integration of Eigenlayer, OpenLayer AVS operators monitor data request tasks, capture and verify data, and then report the results back to the system. EigenLayer pledges or re-pledges assets to provide financial guarantees for their actions. If malicious behavior is confirmed, there is a risk of forfeiting pledged assets. As one of the earliest AVS (Active Verification Services) on the EigenLayer mainnet, OpenLayer has attracted more than 50 operators and $4 billion in re-pledged assets.</p><p>Overall, the decentralized data layer built by OpenLayer expands the scope and diversity of available data without sacrificing utility and efficiency, while ensuring data authenticity and integrity through encryption technology and economic incentives. Its technology has a wide range of practical applications for Web3 Dapps seeking to obtain off-chain trust, companies that require real inputs to train and infer AI models, and companies that want to segment and price users based on their identity and reputation. Users are also able to value their private data.</p><h4>4.2 Grass</h4><p>Grass is the flagship project developed by Wynd Network, which aims to create a decentralized web crawler and AI training data platform. In late 2023, the Grass project completed a $3.5 million seed round led by Polychain Capital and Tribe Capital. Immediately afterwards, in September 2024, the project welcomed a Series A round led by HackVC, with the participation of well-known investment institutions such as Polychain, Delphi, Lattice and Brevan Howard.</p><p>We mentioned that AI training requires new data inputs, and one solution is to use multiple IPs to break through data access permissions and feed data to AI. Grass has created a distributed network of crawler nodes dedicated to decentralized physical infrastructure, using users’ idle bandwidth to collect and provide verifiable datasets for AI training. Nodes route web requests through users’ internet connections, accessing public websites and compiling structured datasets. It uses edge computing technology to perform preliminary data cleaning and formatting to improve data quality.</p><p>Grass uses the Solana Layer 2 Data Rollup architecture, built on Solana to improve processing efficiency. Grass uses validators to receive, verify, and batch web transactions from nodes, generating ZK proofs to ensure data authenticity. The validated data is stored in the data ledger (L2) and linked to the corresponding L1 on-chain proof.</p><h4>4.2.1 Grass main components</h4><p>a) Grass nodes<br>Similar to OpenNodes, C-side users install Grass applications or browser extensions and run them, using idle bandwidth to perform web crawler operations. The nodes route web requests through the user’s Internet connection, access public websites and compile structured data sets, using edge computing technology for preliminary data cleaning and formatting. Users are rewarded with GRASS tokens based on the bandwidth and amount of data they contribute.<br>b) Routers<br>Connect Grass nodes and validators, manage the network of nodes and relay bandwidth. Routers are incentivized to operate and receive rewards, the proportion of which is directly proportional to the total validating bandwidth relayed through them.<br>c) Validators<br>receive, verify and batch web transactions from routers, generate ZK proofs, use unique key sets to establish TLS connections, and select the appropriate cipher suites for communication with the target web server. Grass currently uses centralized validators, and in the future plans to move to a validator council.<br>d) ZK Processor<br>receives proofs from validators for each node session data generated, batches all web request validity proofs and submits to Layer 1 (Solana).<br>e) Grass data ledger (Grass L2)<br>stores the complete data set and links to the corresponding proofs on the L1 chain (Solana).<br>f) Edge embedding model<br>is responsible for converting unstructured web data into a structured model that can be used for AI training.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NJ1RpdtCnDnxTibX.png" /></figure><h4>4.2.2 Comparison of Grass and OpenLayer</h4><p>Both OpenLayer and Grass leverage distributed networks to provide companies with access to open internet data and closed information that requires authentication. Incentives are used to promote data sharing and the production of high-quality data. Both are committed to creating a decentralized data layer (Decentralized Data Layer) to solve the problem of data access and authentication, but they use slightly different technical paths and business models.</p><p><strong>Differences in technical architecture</strong></p><p>Grass uses the Solana Layer 2 Data Rollup architecture and currently uses a centralized verification mechanism with a single validator. OpenLayer, as one of the first AVS, is built on EigenLayer and uses economic incentives and forfeiture mechanisms to achieve a decentralized verification mechanism. It also adopts a modular design that emphasizes the scalability and flexibility of data verification services.</p><p><strong>Product differences</strong></p><p>Both provide similar To C products that allow users to monetize the value of their data through nodes. On the To B side, Grass provides an interesting data marketplace model and uses L2 to verify and store complete data from AI companies that provide structured, high-quality, verifiable training sets. OpenLayer does not have a dedicated data storage component for the time being, but provides a wider range of real-time data stream verification services (Vaas). In addition to providing data for AI, it is also suitable for scenarios that require fast responses, such as feeding prices as an Oracle for RWA/DeFi prediction market projects, providing real-time social data, etc.</p><p>Therefore, today Grass’s target customer base is mainly AI companies and data scientists, providing large-scale, structured training data sets, and also serving research institutions and enterprises that require a large amount of network data. OpenLayer, for the time being, is oriented towards on-chain developers who need off-chain data sources, AI companies that need real-time, verifiable data streams, and users who support innovative acquisition strategies, such as Web2 companies that verify product usage history.</p><p><strong>Potential future competition</strong></p><p>However, considering the development trend of the industry, it is indeed possible that the functions of the two projects will converge in the future. Grass may soon provide real-time structured data as well. And as OpenLayer is a modular platform, it is also possible to expand it to include its own data ledger for dataset management in the future, so the areas of competition between the two may gradually overlap.</p><p>Furthermore, both projects may consider adding the critical component of data labelling. Grass may be able to move faster in this regard, as they have a large network of nodes — reportedly over 2.2 million active nodes. This advantage gives Grass the potential to offer reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) services, which leverage large amounts of labelled data to optimise AI models.</p><p>However, OpenLayer, with its expertise in data verification and real-time processing, and its focus on private data, may maintain an advantage in terms of data quality and credibility. In addition, OpenLayer, as one of EigenLayer’s AVS, may have a deeper development in decentralized verification mechanisms.</p><p>Although the two projects may compete in some areas, their respective unique advantages and technical routes may also lead to them occupying different niches in the data ecosystem.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/644/0*3zmztLxFOUl_TCA1.png" /></figure><h4>4.3 VANA</h4><p>As a user-centric data pool network, Vana is also committed to providing high-quality data for AI and related applications. Compared to OpenLayer and Grass, Vana has adopted a more different technical path and business model. Vana completed a $5 million financing in September 2024, led by Coinbase Ventures, and previously received an $18 million Series A financing led by Paradigm. Other well-known investors include Polychain, Casey Caruso, etc.</p><p>Initially launched in 2018 as a research project at MIT, Vana aims to become a Layer 1 blockchain designed specifically for users’ private data. Its innovative use of data ownership and value distribution enables users to profit from AI models trained on their data. At the heart of Vana is the trustless, private and visible Data Liquidity Pool and the innovative Proof of Contribution mechanism, which enables the circulation and monetization of private data.</p><h4>4.3.1 Data Liquidity Pool</h4><p>Vana introduces a unique concept of Data Liquidity Pools (DLPs): as core components of the Vana network, each DLP is an independent peer-to-peer network that aggregates specific types of data assets. Users can upload their private data (e.g. shopping history, browsing habits, social media activities, etc.) to specific DLPs and flexibly choose whether to authorize these data to specific third parties for use. Data is aggregated and managed through these liquidity pools, and the data is de-identified to ensure user privacy while allowing the data to be used in commercial applications, such as for AI model training or market research.</p><p>Users submit their data to the DLP and are rewarded with corresponding DLP tokens (each DLP has a specific token), which not only represent the total contribution of the user’s data, but also give the user governance rights over the DLP and future profit distribution rights. Users can not only share data, but also receive continuous benefits from the subsequent call of the data (and provide visual tracking). Unlike traditional one-time data sales, Vana allows data to continue to participate in the economic cycle.</p><h4>4.3.2 Proof of Contribution mechanism</h4><p>Another one of Vana’s core innovations is the Proof of Contribution mechanism. This is a key mechanism for Vana to ensure data quality, allowing each DLP to control a unique Proof of Contribution function based on its characteristics to verify the authenticity and integrity of the data and evaluate the contribution of the data to the performance improvement of the AI model. This mechanism ensures that the user’s data contribution is quantified and recorded, thereby providing the user with rewards.</p><p>Similar to Proof of Work in cryptocurrencies, Proof of Contribution allocates rewards to users based on the quality, quantity and frequency of data they contribute. Automatically executed via smart contracts, this ensures that contributors receive rewards that match their contributions.</p><h4>4.3.3 Vana’s technical architecture</h4><ol><li><strong>Data Liquidity Layer</strong></li></ol><p>This is the core layer of Vana, responsible for contributing, verifying and recording data to DLPs, and introducing data as transferable digital assets on the chain. DLP creates and deploys DLP smart contracts, setting data contribution purposes, verification methods and contribution parameters. Data contributors and trustees submit data for verification, and the Proof of Contribution (PoC) module performs data verification and value assessment, granting governance rights and rewards according to the parameters.</p><ol><li><strong>Data Portability Layer</strong></li></ol><p>This is an open data platform for data contributors and developers, and also the application layer of Vana. The Data Portability Layer provides a collaborative space for data contributors and developers to build applications using the data liquidity accumulated in DLPs. It provides the infrastructure for distributed training in the User-Owned model and AI Dapp development.</p><p><strong>3. Connectome</strong></p><p>A decentralized ledger and a real-time data flow graph that spans the entire Vana ecosystem, using Proof of Stake to record real-time data transactions in the Vana ecosystem. Ensures the effective transfer of DLP tokens and provides cross-DLP data access for applications. Compatible with the EVM, allowing interoperability with other networks, protocols and DeFi applications.</p><p>Vana offers a different path, focusing on the liquidity and value empowerment of user data. This decentralized data exchange model is not only applicable to scenarios such as AI training and data markets, but also provides a new solution for cross-platform interoperability and authorization of user data in the Web3 ecosystem, ultimately creating an open Internet ecosystem where users own and manage their own data and the smart products created from that data.</p><h3>5. Value proposition of a decentralized data network</h3><p>Data scientist Clive Humby said in 2006 that data is the oil of the new era. In the past 20 years, we have witnessed rapid development in “refining” technology. Technologies such as big data analysis and machine learning have unlocked the value of data like never before. According to IDC’s forecast, by 2025, the global data circle will grow to 163 ZB, most of which will come from individual users. With the popularization of emerging technologies such as IoT, wearable devices, AI and personalized services, a large amount of data that needs to be used in the future will also come from individuals.</p><h4>The pain points of traditional solutions: Web3 unlocking innovation</h4><p>Web3 data solutions break through the limitations of traditional facilities through a distributed network of nodes, enabling broader and more efficient data collection, while improving the efficiency of real-time access to specific data and the credibility of verification. In the process, Web3 technology ensures the authenticity and integrity of data and effectively protects user privacy, thereby enabling a more equitable data utilization model. This decentralized data architecture promotes the democratization of data access.</p><p>Whether it is the user node model of OpenLayer and Grass, or Vana’s monetization of users’ private data, in addition to improving the efficiency of collecting specific data, it also allows ordinary users to share the economic benefits of data, creating a win-win model for users and developers, allowing users to truly control and benefit from their data and related resources.</p><p>Through token economy incentives, Web3 data solutions have redesigned the incentive model to create a more equitable data value distribution mechanism. It attracts a large number of users, hardware resources and capital investment, thereby synergistically regulating and optimizing the operation of the entire data network.</p><p>Compared with traditional data solutions, they also have modularity and scalability: for example, the modular design of OpenLayer provides flexibility for future technology iterations and ecological expansion. Thanks to its technical features, it optimizes the way data is obtained for AI model training, providing richer and more diverse data sets.</p><p>From data generation, storage, verification to exchange and analysis, Web3-powered solutions solve many of the drawbacks of traditional facilities through unique technological advantages, while also giving users the ability to monetize their personal data, triggering a fundamental shift in the data economy model. As the technology further evolves and application scenarios expand, the decentralized data layer is expected to become the next generation of critical infrastructure, along with other Web3 data solutions, to support a wide range of data-driven industries.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=587c5193d0c0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[MakerDAO’s Bold Leap: Should You Embrace $SKY or Stick with $MKR?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@yihaozhang87507832/makerdaos-bold-leap-should-you-embrace-sky-or-stick-with-mkr-5340a1966ad1?source=rss-37e9bff8319e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5340a1966ad1</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Zhang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 19 Oct 2024 22:28:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-19T22:35:33.701Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A Quick Analysis of the Rebranding</p><h3>Introduction</h3><p>Few weeks ago, DeFi landscape witnessed a significant transformation as MakerDAO, one of the pioneering protocols, undergoes a comprehensive rebranding to become Sky Protocol. This transition, encapsulated in MakerDAO’s ambitious “Endgame” plan, represents more than just a change in name — it’s a fundamental reimagining of the protocol’s structure, tokenomics, and long-term vision.MakerDAO, known for its $DAI stablecoin and $MKR governance token, has been a cornerstone of the DeFi ecosystem since its inception.</p><p>As the DeFi space evolves and faces new challenges, including regulatory scrutiny and scalability issues, MakerDAO’s leadership recognized the need for a substantial overhaul.The transition to Sky Protocol introduces new tokens ($USDS and $SKY), mechanisms, and governance structures designed to enhance flexibility, user engagement, and regulatory compliance. This rebranding represents a strategic pivot aimed at positioning the protocol for long-term sustainability and growth in an increasingly complex financial landscape. In this comprehensive analysis, we will:</p><ol><li>Examine the existing $MKR token model and its core functionalities.</li><li>Explore the details of the Endgame plan and the rebranding process.</li><li>Analyze the new $SKY token model, including its supply mechanisms and added features.</li><li>Discuss the potential implications of this transition for token holders, the DeFi ecosystem, and the broader cryptocurrency market.</li><li>Address criticisms and concerns raised by the community.</li><li>Evaluate the current adoption rate and future outlook for Sky Protocol.</li></ol><h3>$MKR Token Model: The Foundation</h3><h3>Token Supply Mechanism</h3><ul><li>Initial Supply: 1 million $MKR tokens minted in December 2017</li><li>Current Supply: Approximately 899,652.17 $MKR (as of October 18, 2024)</li><li>Maximum Supply: 1,005,577 $MKR (reached after the “Black Thursday” event in March 2020，more supply triggered by a sharp market downturn, led to mass liquidations and exposed a critical flaw in the system’s smart contracts, resulting in emergency $MKR minting.)</li></ul><h3>Key Features of $MKR</h3><ol><li>Governance Participation:</li></ol><ul><li>$MKR holders have the power to vote on critical system parameters, including selection of collateral types for Dai, setting debt ceilings, adjusting stability fees and setting other key system parameters, ensures that the protocol remains decentralized and adaptable to market conditions.</li></ul><p>2. Debt Offset Mechanism:</p><ul><li>In times of system deficit, $MKR serves as a backstop.</li><li>New $MKR is minted and sold to cover outstanding debt, effectively diluting existing holders to maintain system solvency.</li></ul><p>3. Value Accrual Through Burning:</p><ul><li>During periods of excess surplus, $MKR is bought back and burned.</li><li>This mechanism prevents oversupply and potentially increases the value of remaining $MKR tokens.</li></ul><h3>Minting Mechanism: Debt Auction</h3><ul><li>Triggered when the system faces a deficit, typically when collateral auctions fail to cover the debt of liquidated vaults.</li><li>New $MKR tokens are minted (effectively diluting the supply) and auctioned off to raise Dai to cover the shortfall.</li><li>This process ensures the protocol’s solvency but at the cost of existing $MKR holders.</li></ul><h3>Burning Mechanism: Surplus Auction</h3><ul><li>Activated when the system accumulates a surplus beyond a predetermined threshold.</li><li>Excess Dai (primarily from stability fees) is used to buy back and burn $MKR tokens.</li><li>Under the original mechanism, $MKR had no fixed issuance schedule or inflation rate.</li><li>As ecosystem usage increases, the $MKR supply tends to decrease, creating a potential deflationary effect that can accrue value to token holders.</li></ul><h3>The Rebranding: From MakerDAO to Sky Protocol</h3><p>The transition from MakerDAO to Sky Protocol represents a pivotal moment in the evolution of decentralized finance. This rebranding is not merely a cosmetic change but a comprehensive overhaul of the protocol’s structure, goals, and operational mechanisms. At the heart of this transformation lies the ambitious “Endgame” plan.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XL5IkGR_QAAEqJ92.jpg" /></figure><h3>Endgame Plan Overview</h3><p>Initiated in 2022, the Endgame plan is a strategic roadmap designed to propel MakerDAO (now Sky Protocol) into a new era of decentralized finance. The plan’s primary objectives are:</p><ol><li>Scale Stablecoin Usage: Dramatically increase the adoption and circulation of the protocol’s stablecoin.</li><li>Enhance Decentralization: Further distribute governance and operational control.</li><li>Build a New L1 Blockchain: Ultimately create a dedicated blockchain infrastructure to support the protocol’s expanded vision.</li></ol><p>The Endgame plan is structured into four distinct phases, each with its own set of goals and milestones:</p><ol><li>Pregame (Testing Phase):</li></ol><ul><li>Focus on rigorous testing and preparation.</li><li>Refinement of new concepts and mechanisms.</li><li>Community engagement and feedback gathering.</li></ul><p>2. Early Game (Rebranding and Initial Implementation):</p><ul><li>Official rebranding from MakerDAO to Sky Protocol.</li><li>Introduction of new tokens ($USDS and $SKY).</li><li>Implementation of core new features like Sky Savings Rate (SSR) and Sky Token Rewards (STR).</li><li>Transition to the new frontend interface, Sky.Money.</li></ul><p>3. Midgame (Expansion and Ecosystem Growth):</p><ul><li>Full rollout of Sky Stars (formerly SubDAOs).</li><li>Expansion of multi-chain support through Skylink.</li><li>Implementation of advanced governance mechanisms.</li><li>Further development of regulatory-compliant features.</li></ul><p>4. Endgame (New Chain and Full Realization):</p><ul><li>Launch of the new L1 blockchain (NewChain).</li><li>Complete migration of the protocol to the new infrastructure.</li><li>Achievement of full decentralization and scalability goals.</li></ul><h3>Key Changes in the Transition from MakerDAO to Sky Protocol</h3><p>The rebranding of MakerDAO to Sky Protocol involves several significant changes that go beyond a simple name change. These alterations are designed to enhance the protocol’s functionality, improve user experience, and position the ecosystem for future growth. Let’s examine the key changes in detail:</p><h4>1. Protocol Renaming: MakerDAO becomes Sky Protocol</h4><ul><li>This change signifies a broader vision and scope for the protocol.</li><li>Potential for increased brand recognition and appeal to a wider audience.</li><li>Opportunity to redefine the protocol’s identity in the evolving DeFi landscape.</li></ul><h4>2. Token Upgrades</h4><p><strong>a. $DAI to $USDS</strong></p><ul><li>Conversion: 1:1 ratio, allowing users to upgrade voluntarily.</li><li>Retains the same backing mechanisms as DAI.</li><li>Introduces new features like freezing capability (for regulatory compliance).</li><li>DAI Savings Rate (DSR) becomes Sky Savings Rate (SSR).</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ZNF6pD7cGzFmqCvY" /></figure><ul><li>Eligible for Sky Token Rewards (STR), incentivizing holding and usage.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2GBc5ti47hO30vn-" /></figure><p><strong>b. $MKR to $SKY</strong></p><ul><li>Conversion: 1 $MKR = 24,000 $SKY</li><li>Rationale: Lower nominal value per token to potentially increase governance participation.</li><li>Introduces new functionalities while preserving core governance rights.</li><li>Grant participation in Sky Stars ecosystems.</li><li>Access to new staking and reward mechanisms.</li></ul><p><strong>3. New Frontend: Sky.Money replaces the old interface</strong></p><ul><li>Enhance user experience and accessibility.</li><li>Streamlined interface for new functionalities like Sky Savings Rate (SSR) and Sky Token Rewards (STR).</li></ul><p><strong>4. SubDAOs to Sky Stars: Rebranding of ecosystem projects</strong></p><ul><li>Each Sky Star can have its own governance token and community management for Increased flexibility for project development and governance and rapid innovation while maintaining autonomy.</li><li>First Sky Star: Spark protocol, a DeFi lending platform.</li><li>Potential for more diverse and specialized DeFi offerings within the ecosystem.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*7EDh-q0OxtaJXMB-" /></figure><h3>$SKY Token Model: The Evolution</h3><h3>Supply Mechanism</h3><ol><li>Conversion from $MKR: 1 $MKR = 24,000 $SKY (reversible)</li><li>Fixed Inflation Rate: 2.5–3% annual inflation (approximately 600 million $SKY per year)</li><li>Smart Burn Engine: Automated mechanism to buy back and burn $SKY using protocol surplus</li></ol><h3>New Features</h3><h4>1. Sky Savings Rate (SSR)</h4><ul><li>Origin: Renamed from DAI Savings Rate (DSR).</li><li>Function: Allows users to earn interest by depositing $USDS.</li></ul><h4>2. Sky Token Rewards (STR)</h4><ul><li>Mechanism: Inflationary rewards distributed to $USDS stakers funded from the 2.5–3% annual $SKY inflation.</li><li>Purpose: Incentivize $USDS adoption and ecosystem participation.</li></ul><h4>3. Activation Options</h4><p><strong>a. Regular Activation</strong></p><ul><li>Flexibility: Users can activate or deactivate $SKY tokens at any time without lock-up periods.</li><li>Rewards: Offers lower yield compared to Sealed Activation but provides immediate liquidity.</li><li>Eligibility: Only applicable to $SKY tokens.</li><li>Target Users: Ideal for those prioritizing liquidity and short-term flexibility.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*LUvTmFdDsZBA8scZ" /></figure><p><strong>b. Sealed Activation</strong></p><ul><li>Lock-up Mechanism: Requires users to lock up $SKY or $MKR tokens for a period.</li><li>Enhanced Rewards: Provides higher yield potential compared to Regular Activation.</li><li>Exit Fee Structure includes Initial fee at 5% of the original sealed principal, and increases by 1% every 6 months, caps at 15% after 5 years.</li><li>Fees are deducted from the original sealed principal, not affecting earned rewards.</li><li>Reward Options: Initially distributed in $USDS. After Spark Star launch, users can opt to receive SPK tokens as rewards.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*LDqSIQRx6dVlTcVt" /></figure><h3>Rebranding Purpose and Utility</h3><p>The rebranding of MakerDAO to Sky Protocol serves multiple strategic purposes, aiming to address current limitations while positioning the protocol for future growth. A primary objective is to increase participation by simplifying the system and introducing new earning opportunities, such as the Sky Savings Rate (SSR) and Sky Token Rewards (STR). These features are designed to attract a broader user base and encourage more active engagement within the ecosystem.</p><p>The introduction of $USDS, with its potential freezing functionality, represents a proactive approach to regulatory adaptation, potentially enabling the protocol to navigate evolving compliance requirements more effectively. The rebranding also seeks to enhance governance by lowering the effective token price through the $MKR to $SKY conversion ratio, theoretically broadening participation in decision-making processes. Additionally, the transition to Sky Stars (formerly SubDAOs) offers more flexible support for ecosystem projects, facilitating easier token distribution and potentially fostering innovation within the broader Sky ecosystem.</p><h3>Will $SKY Experience Oversupply?</h3><p>While $SKY inherits $MKR’s auction mechanisms for supply control, most core features are yet to be migrated. The protocol plans to implement both inflationary and deflationary measures:</p><ol><li>Inflation: 2.5–3% annual rate to incentivize participation</li><li>Deflation: Burn mechanism to use protocol profit to strategically reduce supply</li></ol><h3>Current Adoption and Future Outlook</h3><p>As of now, only about 8% of $MKR has been converted to $SKY. This cautious approach is likely due to:</p><ol><li>Incomplete migration of core functionalities</li><li>Lack of governance voting for $SKY</li><li>Community concerns about new features and potential value dilution</li></ol><p>However, as more information is disclosed, core functions are migrated, and new features like token rewards and the burn engine are implemented, we may see increased adoption of $SKY.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>The transition from $MKR to $SKY represents a bold move in the DeFi space, balancing innovation with the need for stability and regulatory compliance. While the new model introduces inflationary elements, it also incorporates mechanisms to potentially offset this through strategic burning and ecosystem growth.The success of Sky Protocol will ultimately depend on its ability to deliver on promised functionalities, address community concerns, and navigate the complex DeFi landscape. As the protocol evolves, close attention from investors and users will be crucial in assessing its long-term viability and impact on the broader cryptocurrency ecosystem.</p><p><strong>Migration Status</strong></p><p>It’s crucial to note that currently, only about 8% of MKR tokens have been converted to SKY. This cautious approach from the community can be attributed to several factors:</p><ol><li>Incomplete Migration: Many of MKR’s core functionalities have yet to be fully transferred to SKY.</li><li>Governance Limitations: SKY has not yet implemented voting capabilities, a key feature for decentralized governance.</li><li>Community Hesitation: These factors have led to a wait-and-see attitude among token holders.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HLODT7NgESXSz2dpyg2ekQ.png" /></figure><p>However, there are several reassuring aspects to consider:</p><ol><li>Fixed Conversion Ratio: SKY and MKR maintain a fixed conversion rate (1 MKR = 24,000 SKY), and this conversion is reversible.</li><li>Market Efficiency: The principle of arbitrage in free markets should prevent significant disparities in value between SKY and MKR.</li><li>Gradual Transition: As more information about SKY is disclosed and additional features are implemented, we can expect a gradual shift in token circulation towards SKY.</li></ol><p>Given these factors, current token holders may not rush their decision. The market mechanisms in place should ensure that neither token experiences disproportionate inflation or value discrepancy relative to the other.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5340a1966ad1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[DA Status Quo]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@yihaozhang87507832/da-status-quo-806ba7f7b8ca?source=rss-37e9bff8319e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/806ba7f7b8ca</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Zhang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 16 Oct 2024 01:55:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-16T01:57:43.596Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>DA Industry Mapping</h3><p>The modular blockchain narrative has now become prevalent, driving infrastructure innovations, enhancing network interoperability, and fostering more collaboration and integration within ecosystems. Various Rollup-as-a-Service (RaaS) solutions (Conduit, Caldera, Gelato, Altlayer) have emerged. The figure below shows the interface of the Rollup development tool Conduit, highlighting how deploying a Rollup and selecting a DA solution has become extremely simple and convenient.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7cB53fu73YTLdjxl" /><figcaption>（Source: Conduit）</figcaption></figure><p>Over the past two years, alternative DA solutions (Alt-DA) such as Celestia, EigenDA, Avail, and NearDA have achieved significant development, each showcasing unique technical advantages and market shares. At the same time, with the implementation of Ethereum’s EIP-4844, which introduces blobs to replace calldata, the cost of using Ethereum’s native DA layer for Roll Ups has been greatly reduced. Developers and project teams now face more trade-offs when choosing a DA layer. This article will track and analyze current DA solutions, deeply explore their performance, costs, technical features, and market performance, and offer our thoughts on the future development of the DA track.</p><h3>Current Adoption of DA Solutions</h3><p>Rollups using Ethereum’s native DA solution primarily concentrate on mainstream Layer 2 solutions that have updated from calldata storage to blobs, including Arbitrum, Optimism, Base, Starknet, zkSync, and Scroll. By using Ethereum as the DA layer, data is validated and stored by Ethereum full nodes, benefiting from Ethereum’s security, decentralization, protocol upgrade continuity, and economic incentives. Comprehensive Layer 2 solutions occupy an important position in the Ethereum ecosystem, needing the legitimacy brought by native DA as a core differentiator. (Vitalik believes that the essence of Rollups is unconditional security: even if everyone is against you, you can still withdraw your assets. If data availability relies on external systems, equivalent security cannot be achieved.)</p><p>However, publishing data to Ethereum’s mainnet incurs high costs, especially before EIP-4844 (where calldata costs 16 gas per byte, and Layer 2s spent over 15,000 ETH on DA costs in just December 2023). Thus, multiple off-chain Alt-DA solutions, such as the already-launched Celestia, EigenDA, and the upcoming Avail, have emerged, utilizing different technical means (e.g., DAS, erasure coding, KZG commitments) to reduce data storage and transmission costs.</p><p>Among these, Celestia, a modular blockchain dedicated to DA, has become a leading project since its mainnet launch in October 2023, mainly targeting projects needing a modular architecture: cross-chain bridges, settlement layer solutions, DeFi projects, games, sequencers, and Layer 2 solutions beyond the Ethereum ecosystem. Its current clients include the Omnichain DEX protocol Orderly, the modular L2 Manta Pacific for EVM-native ZK applications, the L3 Hokum based on Base, and the DEXs Lyra and Aevo, focused on derivatives trading. As a modular DA layer not limited to a specific ecosystem, Celestia’s strengths make it the first choice for many emerging Layer 2 projects.</p><p>EigenDA, developed by EigenLabs, leverages the restaking mechanism of EigenLayer to provide efficient, secure, and scalable DA services. It inherits Ethereum’s security and its vast validator network to some extent. EigenDA focuses on providing high-performance DA solutions for the Ethereum ecosystem. As the first Active Validation Service (AVS) on EigenLayer, EigenDA went live in April alongside the EigenLayer mainnet. Its diverse client base includes Ethereum L2s like Swell, Celo, Mantle Network, and several other AVSs built on EigenLayer, such as the decentralized computing stack Versatus, Polymer, the DEX protocol DODO, and the social Layer 2 CyberConnect.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*eB0yyor544GS-zcG" /><figcaption>（Source: EigenDA）</figcaption></figure><h3>Native DA (EIP-4844) vs. Current Alt-DA Trade-offs</h3><h3>1. Ethereum Native DA</h3><p>A brief review of the development and evolution of Ethereum’s native DA solutions: before the Cancun upgrade, Rollups primarily used calldata as a means for data storage and transmission. Due to the permanence of storage and network congestion, high costs were the main obstacles to scaling and adoption. With the EIP-4844 mainnet upgrade, blobs — a new data structure — were introduced, which can store large amounts of data but increase the storage burden on nodes. Over time, storage demand will grow, potentially leading to higher hardware requirements for nodes, thus harming decentralization. As a result, blobs only need to be stored for about 18 days (4,096 epochs) before being deleted.</p><p>Since blobs require only temporary storage and use a separate fee market, after EIP-4844 implementation, the DA cost for major Layer 2 solutions dropped by around 99% on average over 60 days (30 days before and after blob adoption for Scroll &amp; Starknet). Among them, OP Rollups saw more significant cost reductions than ZK Rollups due to differences in the type of uploaded data (transaction data or state deltas).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*yHlVPBbMkDyY8nM3" /><figcaption>Source：Dune&amp; Growthepie</figcaption></figure><h3>EIP-4844 Blob Capacity, Storage Characteristics, and Pricing Mechanism</h3><p>Blob Capacity and Storage Characteristics:</p><ul><li>Each block can hold a maximum of 6 blobs.</li><li>Each blob can store up to 128KB of data (even if the 128KB space is not fully utilized, the sender must still pay for the full blob fee).</li></ul><p>The new blob gas market operates similarly to EIP-1559, adjusting the base blob fee according to changes in supply and demand:</p><ul><li>If the number of blobs in a block exceeds the target (currently set at 3), the base blob fee increases.</li><li>If the number of blobs in a block is below the target, the base blob fee decreases.</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*I3SYTSAKwfqEc6Pl" /></figure><p>Source： IOSG</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/716/0*tFlgZYxKCoSxg5i7" /><figcaption>Source：Dune</figcaption></figure><p>Layer 2s primarily use the newly introduced Type 3 transactions, which add two fields: max_fee_per_blob_gas and blob_versioned_hashes, representing the maximum fee users are willing to pay per blob gas and the hash output of kzg_to_versioned_hash, respectively.</p><p>This new pricing mechanism means that Type 3 transactions still require the fields max_fee_per_gas and max_priority_fee_per_gas, and they are subject to the existing EIP-1559 market dynamics. In addition to the blob space fees, Type 3 transactions also need to pay for the EVM space they use.</p><p>Therefore, blobs still face block space contention, leading to cost uncertainty, as each block has limited blob space, and the blob gas fee market dynamically adjusts based on demand.</p><p>Thus, Ethereum, as a general-purpose chain, has a weakness in the unpredictability of block space — unexpected on-chain activities such as NFT minting or airdrops could suddenly congest the network, driving up the price of blobs. This makes it difficult for Rollups to estimate their cost base. As a result, the unpredictability of Rollup expenses can lead to unstable profit margins, raising barriers for new projects that are still in their early stages. It also creates uncertainty for project teams in determining whether Ethereum DA can be a long-term solution. While blobs are typically around 98% cheaper than calldata, as shown in the graph below, there are times when blobs were only 59% cheaper than calldata.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*r54gEUpZAavBu3nB" /><figcaption>Source： Ethernow</figcaption></figure><p>We can calculate the cost of two blob transfers as examples:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/813/0*4eSc_37RmYbr6XYI" /><figcaption>source：Ethernow</figcaption></figure><p>The chart shows a Type 3 transaction for Zksync’s Validator Timelock in a block on March 28, 2024. We can break down its data cost based on blob fees, base execution fees, and priority fees:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cWNkaHT-lYJ58hUb" /></figure><p>Assuming the price of Ethereum is $3,600, the cost of using a 1MiB blob at that time would be:</p><p><strong>4×0.018ETH×3600USD/ETH = 259.2USD</strong></p><p><strong>Next, let’s take a Zksync Era Type 3 transaction from June 24, where mainnet activity had slightly decreased. We can break down the data cost:</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/823/0*HYn_5oM25DSJr7KF" /><figcaption>source：Ethernow</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1h5Pn_98YKf6DLmD" /></figure><p>At that time, the cost of using a 1MiB blob was approximately:</p><p><strong>4×0.0021ETH×3600USD/ETH = 30.24USD</strong></p><p>This illustrates the cost uncertainty of transmitting data via blobs, and the costs remain relatively high. For a Rollup, cost structure stability is one of the key considerations when selecting a DA solution.</p><h3>2. Celestia</h3><p>As the pioneer of modular blockchains, Celestia focuses on providing DA and consensus layers while separating the execution layer. This specialization optimizes DA functionality, improving efficiency and scalability. Celestia, as an off-chain Layer 1 solution, has several unique technical characteristics compared to Ethereum’s on-chain approach, reducing data availability costs while providing greater flexibility and scalability. Its modular design makes Celestia highly flexible, allowing developers to freely choose execution environments without being limited to a specific virtual machine (VM). This enables Celestia to support a variety of application scenarios, meeting diverse needs.</p><p>When integrating Celestia as a DA layer, Rollups need to submit transaction data (Data Blobs) generated by the execution layer to the Celestia network, rather than the Layer 1 (Ethereum), to ensure data availability for verification and transactions. Celestia’s Data Availability Sampling (DAS) technology uses a two-dimensional Reed-Solomon (RS) erasure coding scheme to re-encode block data. This allows light nodes to verify data availability by downloading only a small portion of the block data through multiple rounds of random sampling. Moreover, multiple nodes can process different parts of the data simultaneously, improving overall efficiency.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Yt5EzHGiQOPsShTi" /><figcaption>（Source：Celestia.org）</figcaption></figure><p>Another key technology in this process is Celestia’s introduction of Namespace Merkle Trees (NMTs), which enables different Rollups to download only the transaction data relevant to them, improving data processing efficiency. NMTs not only reduce data redundancy and enhance system performance but also provide developers with more efficient data processing methods.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7pzueE_09rd6qDB4" /><figcaption>（Source：Celestia.org）</figcaption></figure><p>In terms of security, Celestia is based on the Tendermint consensus mechanism, where validators agree on the availability of Data Blobs, ensuring data availability and consistency across the network. It can tolerate up to one-third of validator nodes experiencing failures or acting maliciously. By staking TIA tokens, Celestia’s validators are economically incentivized to behave honestly, and misbehaviors or improper actions are penalized, thus ensuring the network’s security. Currently, Celestia has a TVL (Total Value Locked) of about $6.44 billion and 100 full nodes.</p><p>Regarding scalability, Celestia’s block size can be dynamically adjusted based on the number of active light nodes in the network. As more nodes join, Celestia can safely increase block size, theoretically scaling throughput infinitely. Current data shows its data throughput is approximately 6.67 MB/s.</p><p><strong>Celestia Blob Capacity, Storage Characteristics, and Pricing Mechanism</strong></p><p>For a cost comparison, let’s briefly discuss Celestia’s performance and pricing mechanism. Users submit data on Celestia by sending Blob transactions (BlobTx), with fees composed of blob space fees and gas fees.</p><p>Specifically, the maximum size of each blob is slightly less than 2 MiB (1,973,786 bytes), and each block can contain multiple blobs, depending on the block’s total size limit. The current maximum block size is 64x64 shares (about 2 MiB), with a total of 4,096 shares. One share is reserved for PayForBlobs (PFB) transactions, and the remaining 4,095 shares are used for data storage. Celestia’s fee market is similar to Ethereum’s EIP-1559 mechanism, using a gas-price-based priority mempool. Transactions with higher fees are prioritized by validators, with fees consisting of a fixed transaction fee and a variable fee based on blob size. The current hard-coded block size limit is 100MB, combined with a block time of about 15 seconds, giving Celestia a throughput of about 6.67 Mbps.</p><p>According to rollup data aggregated on Celenium (June 17), for clients integrated with Celestia, the DA costs on Celestia range between 0.02–0.25 TIA/MiB. At the price of $TIA on June 17 ($7.26), the DA costs for major clients ranged from $0.15–$1.82 per MiB. Compared to Ethereum’s native DA, Celestia offers a competitive and stable cost structure.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Xh6ncgi3ATRUsjSi" /></figure><h3>Source：Celenium</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/609/0*8SbxAs4P-2PnsJYU" /><figcaption>(Source：Celenium)</figcaption></figure><p>However, Celestia itself is a Layer 1 blockchain network that requires a P2P network for broadcasting and consensus on Data Blobs. Although light nodes can use DAS to ensure data availability, the network still imposes high requirements on its full nodes (128 MB/s download and 12.5 MB/s upload), posing obstacles to decentralization and future throughput improvements. In contrast, EigenDA adopts a different architecture that doesn’t require consensus or a P2P network.</p><h3>3. EigenDA</h3><p>As an Active Validation Service (AVS) built on EigenLayer, EigenDA utilizes the restaking mechanism, leveraging Ethereum’s security (without introducing a new validator set, as Ethereum validators can freely opt-in; EigenDA’s restaking nodes are a subset of Ethereum nodes) to ensure data availability. This directly capitalizes on existing infrastructure. Its primary workflow involves the Rollup sequencer generating Blob Data and sending it to a Disperser (which can be operated by the Rollup itself or through a third party like EigenLabs). The Disperser splits the Blob Data, generating erasure codes and KZG commitments, and then publishes it to EigenDA nodes. The EigenDA nodes verify attestations and ensure data availability. After validation, nodes must store the data and send digital signatures back to the Disperser. The Disperser then collects the signatures and uploads them to Ethereum’s mainnet, where EigenDA’s smart contract verifies the aggregated signature’s correctness.</p><p>The core idea is to reduce the data storage and verification computational requirements for nodes through technology. Additionally, EigenDA aligns with Ethereum’s KZG commitment verification technology. EigenDA doesn’t rely on a consensus protocol or P2P broadcasting but instead uses unicast to further increase consensus speed.</p><p>To ensure that EigenDA nodes indeed store the data, EigenDA employs a Proof of Custody method. If lazy validators are detected, anyone can submit proof to the EigenDA smart contract, which will verify it. If the proof is valid, the lazy validator will be slashed.</p><p>Thus, EigenDA’s processes are conducted on Ethereum, with Ethereum providing consensus guarantees. This eliminates the bottleneck of consensus protocols and P2P network low throughput, as nodes do not need to wait for sequential ordering and can process data availability proofs in parallel, greatly improving network efficiency.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*RdyLUltsXcePyUsi" /><figcaption>(Source: Eigenlayer)</figcaption></figure><p><strong>EigenDA’s Capacity, Performance, and Fees:</strong></p><p>Currently, EigenDA has 266 node operators. Its target maximum throughput is 10 Mbps. Based on the 7-day average data, EigenDA’s data throughput is 0.685 MiB/s, and the data storage and transmission fees are approximately 0.001 Gas/Byte. Assuming a gas fee of 10 gwei and an Ethereum price of $3,600, the cost per 1MB of data would be around $0.038. The total value locked (TVL) for EigenDA is 3.33M ETH, approximately $12 billion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*pupycgZ6VWQpb1zK" /><figcaption>(Source： Eigenda.xyz)</figcaption></figure><h3>Comparative Analysis: Celestia vs. EigenDA</h3><p>From a technical perspective, Celestia and EigenDA differ in several ways. First, regarding node workload, Celestia’s full nodes need to handle broadcasting, consensus, and validation, with download bandwidth requirements of 128 MB/s and upload bandwidth requirements of 12.5 MB/s. In contrast, EigenDA nodes don’t handle broadcasting and consensus, requiring only 0.3 MB/s bandwidth, and they can use a subset of Ethereum’s nodes. Second, in terms of throughput, Celestia’s maximum throughput is around 6.67 MB/s, while EigenDA targets a maximum of 10 MB/s.</p><p>In terms of security, Celestia’s security comes from its network value, with a staked value of about $6.65 billion, and the cost of an attack is estimated to exceed $4 billion. EigenDA, on the other hand, leverages restaked assets and a subset of Ethereum’s mainnet validators, inheriting some of Ethereum’s security. Currently, EigenDA’s TVL is close to $12 billion, inheriting around 2% of Ethereum’s security.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/573/0*M75Jw7Gv4EpxBb_-" /></figure><p>Overall, Celestia’s competitive advantage lies in its flexible modular design and higher data throughput, making it more attractive to small-to-medium-sized L2 projects and application chains. EigenDA’s advantage comes from utilizing Ethereum’s infrastructure, decoupling data availability from consensus, and the legitimacy this brings. As both the modular and application chain trends continue to develop, Celestia could benefit from incremental markets, while EigenDA might capture a larger share of the Ethereum-centric market requiring higher security.</p><h3>Avail and NearDA</h3><p>While Celestia and EigenDA currently dominate the data availability market, future competition may intensify with the potential launch of projects like Avail and NearDA.</p><p>Avail is a blockchain network focused on data availability, designed to provide efficient transaction ordering and data storage services for EVM-compatible blockchains and Rollups. It uses the BABE and GRANDPA consensus mechanisms inherited from the Polkadot SDK, employs KZG polynomial commitments for proof of validity, and supports up to 1,000 validators through its Nominated Proof-of-Stake (NPoS) system. Additionally, it provides reliable backup through a unique light client P2P network sampling mechanism.</p><p>On the other hand, NearDA is a data availability solution introduced by the NEAR Foundation, mainly serving ETH Rollups and Ethereum developers. Its goal is to offer a cost-effective DA solution with decentralization levels comparable to Near Protocol. It has already established strategic partnerships with major players in the Ethereum ecosystem, such as Polygon CDK, Arbitrum, and Optimism.</p><h3>DA for Specific Scenarios</h3><p>In addition to the general-purpose DA solutions for Rollups mentioned above, the DA track is also seeing the emergence of early-stage projects and DA solutions tailored for specific scenarios, such as high-throughput DA solutions for AI like ZeroGravity (0G), and Bitcoin DA solutions like Nubit.</p><h4>Zerogravity（0G）</h4><p>The data availability needs of AI applications differ from those of traditional blockchain applications. AI model training and operations require handling large datasets, including model parameters, training datasets, and real-time data requests. These data need to be stored and transmitted quickly and reliably to ensure the efficiency and performance of AI models. However, existing general-purpose DA solutions, such as Celestia and EigenDA, are primarily designed to meet the data availability needs of regular blockchain applications, and they have certain limitations when handling ultra-high throughput, low-latency, large-scale data transmissions.</p><p>ZeroGravity (0G) aims to meet the specific needs of AI applications through modular design and high-performance data transmission. Its modular design separates the data availability workflow into two channels: one for data publishing and another for data storage. This allows the system to scale linearly with the number of nodes. The data storage channel focuses on large data transmission, ensuring that large datasets can be stored and accessed almost instantaneously. The data publishing channel guarantees data availability through a majority-honest arbitration system for verification. 0G Storage is an on-chain database composed of a network of storage nodes. These nodes participate in a “Proof of Random Access” (PoRA) mining process to ensure data availability and integrity. It supports the storage of various types of AI-related data, including models, training data, user requests, and Real-time Augmented Generation (RAG) data.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*AM7MJtZ6jpSshvXz" /><figcaption>(Source: 0G)</figcaption></figure><p>Through its innovative system design, 0G claims its goal is to achieve on-chain data transmission at GB levels per second, far exceeding the MB-level data transmission of other DA solutions like Celestia and EigenDA. Specifically, 0G claims its data throughput could reach 50 to 100 GB per second, supporting scenarios such as AI model training that require massive data transmission.</p><h3>Nubit</h3><p>As the Bitcoin ecosystem grows and gains attention, various technical routes for Bitcoin are emerging. With the development of these routes, applications such as Ordinals, Layer 2 solutions, and oracles are increasingly demanding efficient and secure data availability solutions. These applications need the ability to store and transmit large amounts of data quickly and reliably to ensure their proper functioning and improved user experience. For example, Ordinals requires efficient data storage and transmission to support the creation and trading of digital artworks, Layer 2 solutions need high throughput and low latency for better scalability, and oracles need reliable data transmission to ensure data accuracy and timeliness.</p><p>Nubit is the first native DA layer project in the Bitcoin ecosystem, designed to address the limited throughput of the Bitcoin mainnet and provide infrastructure support for the long-term development of the Bitcoin ecosystem. Nubit’s workflow includes multiple steps such as data submission, validation, broadcasting, storage, sampling, and consensus to ensure efficient data processing and high availability. Submitted data is processed with RS coding, and validator nodes use the NuBFT consensus algorithm for validation, generating KZG commitments. The validated data blocks are broadcast to the network, with storage nodes responsible for storing full data blocks, while light clients verify data availability through the Data Availability Sampling (DAS) protocol. Even in case of network failures, nodes can still recover data through full storage nodes and KZG commitments on the Bitcoin network.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*MZB7oPvOIKoShs9w" /><figcaption>(Source: Nubit)</figcaption></figure><p>Nubit aims to provide infrastructure for Bitcoin ecosystem projects and has established partnerships with multiple projects such as Babylon, Merlin Chain, and Polyhedra. Nubit will reduce data storage costs, making it more affordable to store and process data on Bitcoin, especially in scenarios like the booming demand for inscription markets.</p><h3>Closing Thoughts</h3><p>Analyzing the differences among DA track projects, we observe unique technologies and market positioning in terms of security (including data integrity, network consensus, etc.), customizability and interoperability, performance, and cost. As these DA solutions see broader adoption and as projects make different choices regarding DA layers, we are witnessing a range of unique technical and market approaches.</p><p>In the future, we believe more app-specific Rollups will enter the market. However, despite the potential market expansion, the DA track is showing clear leader effects, with Celestia, EigenDA, and others likely to dominate most of the market share, leaving fewer opportunities for mid- to lower-tier solutions. Competition is also intensifying. Current capacity for Rollups exceeds demand. For instance, after Celestia’s mainnet launch, its network bandwidth utilization has remained below 0.1%, far lower than its daily maximum capacity of 46,080 MB. However, compared to Ethereum’s current 15 Rollups and daily data volume of 700 MB, Celestia still has ample available space.</p><p>There may still be future demand for high DA bandwidth, such as for AI projects, or in more specific scenarios like Bitcoin DA. These specialized DA solutions could carve out a market niche. However, DA is essentially a B2B business, and the revenues of DA projects are closely tied to the number and quality of ecosystem projects. We believe that there isn’t a need for many off-chain DA solutions in the market unless their cost and efficiency see exponential improvements.</p><p>In conclusion, while the supply in the DA business model is currently sufficient, the track’s development is still evolving, with different solutions showcasing their competitiveness in technology and market positioning. Future growth will depend on continued technological innovation and the dynamic changes in market demand.</p><p>Reference：</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@MTCapital_US/mt-capital-research-da-sector-analysis-comparative-study-of-celestia-and-eigenda-acc07ea5694f">https://medium.com/@MTCapital_US/mt-capital-research-da-sector-analysis-comparative-study-of-celestia-and-eigenda-acc07ea5694f</a></p><p><a href="https://www.theblockbeats.info/news/51171">https://www.theblockbeats.info/news/51171</a></p><p><a href="https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s?__biz=Mzk0NjU2NTEwNQ==&amp;mid=2247491618&amp;idx=1&amp;sn=d28420cc1c35c1a83fe3b011437c1061&amp;source=41&amp;poc_token=HB6-gWaj323Mmjyn5A-CstonqsxUw2eNYu9-tGK2">https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s?__biz=Mzk0NjU2NTEwNQ==&amp;mid=2247491618&amp;idx=1&amp;sn=d28420cc1c35c1a83fe3b011437c1061&amp;source=41&amp;poc_token=HB6-gWaj323Mmjyn5A-CstonqsxUw2eNYu9-tGK2</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=806ba7f7b8ca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From Web2 to Web3: The Next Evolution Wave of Marketplaces]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@yihaozhang87507832/from-web2-to-web3-the-next-evolution-wave-of-marketplaces-41cd3faff572?source=rss-37e9bff8319e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/41cd3faff572</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[digital-collectibles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crypto]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[web3]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marketplaces]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[David Zhang]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Sep 2024 20:31:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-09-30T20:31:48.265Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>What’s Next for Digital Commerce</h4><h3>TL;DR</h3><p>Web3 marketplaces are poised to revolutionize digital commerce by addressing key limitations of traditional platforms and unlocking new value through decentralization, tokenization, and community-driven models:</p><ul><li>Web3 platforms give users more control over data and reduce reliance on centralized intermediaries, enhancing security and censorship resistance.</li><li>Liquidity aggregation and programmable assets allow for innovative business models and more efficient trading across platforms.</li><li>Token incentives help solve the cold start problem and drive user engagement.</li><li>Community-oriented governancecan increase platform stickiness and adaptability.</li><li>Emerging opportunities include IP/patent markets, complex data/compute resource markets, and personal time/skill marketplaces.</li><li>Successful Web3 marketplaces will need to balance desirability, feasibility, and viability to achieve long-term success and network effects.</li></ul><h3>Introduction</h3><p>Over the past decades, marketplace platforms have experienced remarkable development with the rise of e-commerce, explosive growth of social media, and widespread adoption of mobile internet. Craigslist emerged in 1995, connecting various needs from community events to housing rentals, jobs and services through a simple yet efficient listing method.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Gxf-r2KkQR29HPdT" /><figcaption>（Web2 platform vs. Craigslist, Souce： The Gong Show）</figcaption></figure><p>Subsequently, one online platform giant after another rapidly rose, simplifying transaction processes and more efficiently connecting supply and demand. They quickly expanded in their respective fields through network effects, replacing many of Craigslist’s categories while creating new business models and services through specialization and segmentation.</p><p>Airbnb disrupted the accommodation industry, Redfin reshaped the real estate market, while Indeed and LinkedIn fundamentally changed job searching and recruitment methods. With each shift in people’s lifestyles and technological upgrades, leading companies would emerge in the marketplace sector, radically changing consumer experiences by providing unprecedented supply-demand connection efficiency, achieving powerful flywheel effects and deep moats.</p><p>Yet as Web2 marketplace platforms gradually matured, they also began facing increasingly apparent bottlenecks. Many platforms impose fees as high as 20–40% (for example, Apple charges a 30% commission on all sales made on the App Store), directly affecting the profitability of small suppliers and weakening traditional consumer demand.</p><p>Data privacy issues have also become increasingly prominent, with 3,205 data breaches occurring in the US in 2023, affecting millions of users. A survey showed that 73% of consumers are more concerned about their data privacy than a few years ago, and 89% of consumers no longer trust brands to handle their data correctly, all of which have greatly diminished users’ trust in platforms.</p><p>Additionally, monopolistic behaviors have raised concerns about fair competition and user rights, with the centralized nature of Web2 markets allowing platforms to exert excessive control over products and services in the market. For instance, Amazon has been accused of abusing internal data and biasing search results towards its own brands.</p><p>Against this backdrop, the emergence of Web3 technology brings revolutionary changes.</p><h3>What Makes a Successful Marketplace</h3><p>For businesses, marketplace platforms provide comprehensive ecosystems from order fulfillment and payment processing to logistics services and data analytics. For consumers, marketplace platforms allow them to quickly browse, compare, and shop from a wide range of goods and services. At its core, a marketplace is an intermediary connecting the demand side (end consumers) with the supply side (sellers or suppliers), profiting by charging a certain percentage of transactions as commission or service fees, or by charging additional fees for value-added services (such as payment processing, product delivery, and customer support). The core function is access and visibility, providing a platform where sellers can reach a wide audience and buyers can easily find the goods they need. By aggregating supply and demand, it improves efficiency, reduces search and transaction costs, and achieves trust through certain security mechanisms such as rating systems, escrow services, and dispute resolution.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*FdSitv649JebYcsl" /></figure><p>A successful marketplace platform relies on:</p><p><strong>Demand Liquidity</strong>: This refers to the ability of the platform to quickly match and satisfy the demands of buyers and sellers. High demand liquidity means the platform can quickly respond to user needs, reduce transaction friction and waiting times, and improve satisfaction. For example, Uber can quickly find the nearest driver for passengers through its algorithm and vast driver network, providing efficient transportation services. DEX’s AMM mechanism provides continuous liquidity through algorithms and liquidity pools, making transactions faster and more convenient. More innovative mechanisms like Pump.fun’s Bonding Curve not only improve market liquidity but also ensure dynamic price adjustments and automated market operations, attracting more users to participate in transactions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8ySHsvwcVz1LZYfk" /></figure><p>For buyers, high demand liquidity means less searching, lower prices, and better user experiences; for sellers, it means higher sales volumes, lower inventory costs, and better pricing power. The two mutually promote incremental transaction activities and better returns for the platform.</p><p>In a successful marketplace platform, an increase in demand should be able to trigger further demand growth, forming a self-reinforcing flywheel. When demand grows on the platform, the ensuing transaction activities should be able to rapidly stimulate supply growth responses.</p><p>This response not only improves product diversity and quality but also enhances user experience and even trust in the platform to achieve brand effects, further driving network effects and continuously increasing the overall value of the platform. Only by efficiently realizing this flywheel effect can marketplace platforms maintain long-term competitive advantages through continuous improvement and innovation, constantly adapting to and meeting user needs.</p><p><strong>Blur vs. OpenSea</strong></p><p>Taking the competition between Blur and OpenSea as an example, apart from the advantages brought by airdrop incentives, Blur launched products with more precise Product-Market Fit targeting the needs of the main contributors to NFT market transaction volume (professional traders). By allowing traders to batch purchase NFTs with advanced sweeping tools, aggregating listings from multiple markets, faster transaction speeds, and lower gas fees, it improved demand liquidity.</p><p>Additionally, Blur’s pioneering bid wall allows users to place batch bids within specific price ranges, making it easier for sellers to find buyers, reducing price volatility, and improving transaction efficiency and liquidity.</p><p>With these advantages, Blur rapidly increased its average daily sales volume in a short time, now occupying 63.1% of the NFT marketplace market share. Higher demand liquidity drove further demand growth, forming a self-reinforcing flywheel effect and consolidating Blur’s position in the market.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/0*aBLfzHnyReCduwUr" /><figcaption>(Source: Delphi Digital)</figcaption></figure><p>Optimizing supply and demand is a key factor for the success of traditional marketplace platforms, which is crucial for exploring the potential of Web3 marketplace platforms. How Web3 technology optimizes supply-demand connections and economic benefits, making them more valuable and efficient for all participants, and further innovating platform operation models and economic effects, is the focus of the next part of this article.</p><h3>How Web3 Empowers Marketplaces</h3><p><strong>User Data Control and Censorship Resistance</strong></p><p>Traditional centralized marketplace platforms not only risk user data abuse but are also susceptible to manipulation and censorship. E-commerce giants like Amazon not only possess users’ shopping habits and search records but also use this data to prioritize recommendations for their own brands and even manipulate prices. Scandals like Facebook’s Cambridge Analytica directly exposed the enormous risk of user data misuse. Furthermore, in recent years, platforms like eBay have faced pressure to remove or block content when dealing with controversial items posted by users, sparking widespread discussions about platform censorship and content control.</p><p>Web3 marketplace platforms operate on distributed node networks. Reducing dependence on a single intermediary improves system security and censorship resistance, meaning users have greater control over their data. They can decide what content to share and ensure their transaction information is not affected by centralized leaks, aligning with users’ growing demand for data privacy and control. The advantages of decentralization are an important development direction for Web3 marketplaces.</p><p>The previous obstacle for decentralized marketplaces was the inability to achieve user experiences comparable to traditional markets. However, today’s technology and macro environment have undergone earth-shaking changes. Layer 2, cross-chain, DID, NFT, chain abstraction, combined with Visa and Mastercard beginning to support cryptocurrency payments, and more DeFi platforms seeking regulatory compliance, are all advancing the realization of mass adoption. Future decentralized markets will be able to narrow the gap with traditional markets, overcome past obstacles, and achieve broader applications and popularization.</p><p><strong>Transparency and Immutability: Revolution in the Collectibles Market</strong></p><p>The transparency and immutability of blockchain underlying technology have also shown enormous potential in the collectibles and luxury goods markets. The technology for tracing luxury goods can reduce traditional lengthy verification and transaction processes, making transactions more efficient and transparent. For example, Courtyard.io, which focuses on trading sports memorabilia and collectible cards, creates an immutable digital record for each item. Through blockchain technology, physical collectibles (such as jewelry, luxury goods, and artworks) are tokenized and stored in secure facilities. Each collectible is bound to an NFT (Non-Fungible Token), allowing users to verify the authenticity and ownership history of items, eliminating complex verification processes in traditional markets while ensuring secure storage and transparent transactions of items.</p><p><strong>Cross-border Payments and Global Accessibility</strong></p><p>In Web2, supporting cross-border payments requires integration with various local systems for internationalization. Over 80% of YouTube users reside outside the United States. To support local currency payments in each region, platforms must integrate with international payment gateways. Many platforms lack the resources to cover long-tail geographic areas. However, Web3 achieves unparalleled permissionlessness and global accessibility. With the development of various scaling technologies, transaction fees have also significantly decreased, lowering participation barriers.</p><p><strong>Asset Logic Embedding</strong></p><p>Traditional Web2 marketplace platforms face liquidity fragmentation issues, meaning sellers must list and price goods separately on different platforms, resulting in dispersed liquidity, poor user experience, and often high transaction fees. However, in Web3 marketplace platforms, smart contracts allow digital assets to be efficiently sold, traded, and displayed across multiple marketplace platforms. Through this liquidity aggregation, sellers can concentrate resources to sell goods at more competitive prices, while buyers can enjoy more favorable transactions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kpqYP30OH1RWNRxe" /><figcaption>（Source：Messari）</figcaption></figure><p>Moreover, the programmable nature of digital assets allows logic to be directly embedded into the assets rather than relying on applications that control the assets, providing possibilities for innovative business models and more flexible asset management. Compared to traditional markets, this achieves better empowerment for goods owners or creators. Most NFT markets today have embedded such logic, for example, Blur and Zora’s embedding of royalty logic in NFTs, realizing a continuous income stream for creators in each secondary sale, which is difficult to achieve in traditional art markets.</p><p><strong>Incentive Mechanisms</strong></p><p>The underlying essence of a marketplace platform where buyers and sellers can quickly complete transactions is having a sufficient base number of buyers and sellers in the market. For traditional platforms, attracting initial users and supply — the “cold start problem” — is usually a major challenge, as a marketplace platform has little value before reaching a certain scale.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/555/0*sqP9Ogf-yT9DUawS" /></figure><p>Traditional marketplaces usually require huge marketing expenditures to solve this startup problem, but Web3 technology can solve this problem through token incentives. Through token economics, it drives platform growth and value creation. This “better than free” business model can reward early participants, create a self-reinforcing ecosystem, and promote rapid growth of users and suppliers. The platform can also use token economics to maintain user retention later on.</p><p><strong>For the supply side:</strong> Goods or service providers can earn token rewards by joining and contributing to the platform. These tokens can appreciate in value, providing an additional source of income. Various DePIN networks and other tokenized marketplace platforms have successfully applied this model, overcoming the cold start problem. For example, the Helium network attracts users to provide IoT device connection services by rewarding HNT tokens, while Filecoin attracts storage space providers through token rewards.</p><p><strong>For the demand side</strong>: Consumers are incentivized to use the platform through token-funded rewards, discounts, or user loyalty programs. This not only attracts initial users but also encourages repeat purchases and long-term participation. For example, some DeFi platforms attract users to provide liquidity through liquidity mining and yield farming, and increase user engagement and loyalty through token rewards.</p><p><strong>Dynamic Inventives model</strong></p><p>Different types of marketplaces can apply different token incentive strategies. Based on different supply models, project teams can design targeted incentive mechanisms. Here we analyze two types of markets defined in Mason Nystrom’s article:</p><p><strong>Active Supply</strong>: In the active supply model, suppliers must continuously participate in the marketplace, and the opportunity cost for the supply side is usually higher as it often involves manual labor and service quality. For example, Uber drivers need to maintain vehicles and respond to passenger demands and feedback. For such platforms, token incentives can initially focus on the demand side, building a larger user base by rewarding users for using the platform, thereby attracting suppliers to join. Additionally, token reward vesting mechanisms can be designed to encourage suppliers to stay on the platform long-term.</p><p><strong>Passive Supply</strong>: In the passive supply model, suppliers need initial setup, but subsequent maintenance costs are low, usually with high sunk costs. For example, Filecoin’s storage space providers provide storage capacity after initial setup, with low maintenance costs. For such platforms, token incentives can first focus on the supply side, building a supply base by rewarding suppliers for providing resources. Ensure that suppliers’ returns exceed sunk costs to attract more suppliers to join.</p><p>Both types of markets can solve the cold start problem through token incentives. In specific implementation, incentive mechanisms not only increase user engagement but also bring higher liquidity and activity to the platform, helping marketplace platforms overcome the most difficult challenge of initial user and supply base. Through token incentive strategies designed for different supply models, Web3 platforms can achieve higher user engagement and supplier activity, thereby driving rapid growth and long-term success of the platform.</p><p><strong>From Decentralized Governance to Community-Oriented Markets</strong></p><p>Developers can use Web3 technology to build entirely new forms of markets, such as management through DAOs, integrating DeFi, NFT, and metaverse concepts to form innovative applications, enhancing market transparency and fairness, and strengthening users’ sense of participation and belonging. This allows users to directly participate in the decision-making process of the marketplace, transforming the platform into a community-driven ecosystem. This model can attract more loyal user groups with stronger platform stickiness, enabling the marketplace to more flexibly adapt to changes in user needs, expand functionality, and attractiveness.</p><p>Combined with the DAO model, future Web3 marketplaces can create more open, interactive community-oriented market platforms. The hugely successful live streaming e-commerce model we’re familiar with is a successful example of this community-oriented market. We’ve already seen social media platforms like Instagram and TikTok leverage their massive user bases to create vibrant social commerce hubs. The success of community-driven models like Whatnot, which has become the largest online auction and live shopping platform in the US by combining buying and selling collectibles, toys, and other hobby-related items with content creation, interaction, and sharing, provides real-world inspiration for the development of Web3 marketplace platforms.</p><p>In the Web3 domain, similar community-oriented models can be applied. For example, District0x provides decentralized market creation and management tools that allow users to easily create their own markets, facilitating community participation and interaction. Additionally, the on-chain sports card exchange Arena Club launched a Showroom feature that allows collectors and sports stars to create personalized virtual showrooms to publicly display their collections as NFTs to community members and list them for sale, enhancing community interaction and further increasing transaction activity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/871/0*4v3PdZFLVWUixDcN" /><figcaption>(Source: Arena Club)</figcaption></figure><p>With the development of SocialFi integration, it’s expected that future Web3 marketplaces will be able to better combine users’ social interactions with trading activities, allowing users not only to buy and sell on the platform but also to increase platform stickiness and user loyalty through community interactions, content creation, and sharing. For example, users can earn rewards through token reward mechanisms in social interactions, or establish connections with other community members through NFT displays and trading, further driving platform activity and transaction frequency.</p><p><strong>New Markets for Tokenized Real-World Assets (RWA)</strong></p><p>In addition to optimizing existing markets, new Web3 technologies have brought many innovative markets including data/decentralized AI markets, wireless network markets realized through DePIN, storage/computing resource markets. Here we discuss the innovative trading methods brought by RWA, which are closer to the consumer end.</p><p>As Colin Butler of Polygon Labs said, 2024 can be called the Year of Tokenization, with technological barriers being gradually broken through and traditional finance increasing its acceptance of crypto. For RWA, both volume and dimensions are increasing. According to a report by Boston Consulting Group, the size of the RWA tokenization market in 2023 was $0.6 trillion, and this figure is expected to reach $16 trillion by 2030. Traditional asset management and trading methods are undergoing fundamental changes, with RWA significantly expanding in both quantity and asset range. From the initial focus on fiat currencies, gold, and real estate, to artworks, luxury goods, intangible assets, and more, tokens not only realize basic DeFi lending functions, but tokenized physical assets also indispensably require corresponding marketplace trading platforms.</p><p>In the future, more real-world assets will be able to achieve on-chain trading, allowing more asset classes to enter the market, increasing the depth and breadth of Web3 markets, and giving rise to new markets, financial products, and business models.</p><p>RWA markets can provide better liquidity, with assets traditionally difficult to trade (such as real estate) becoming easier to buy and sell through platforms via tokenization, greatly enhancing market liquidity. Platforms like RealT allow investors to purchase tokens representing partial ownership of properties. This allows property owners on the</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>The rise of Web3 marketplaces signifies a potential fundamental shift in digital commerce, offering solutions to the limitations of Web2 platforms while introducing new opportunities and efficiencies. Decentralized networks, tokenization, and community governance models provide a fresh foundation for market platforms, enabling users to control their data, reducing reliance on centralized intermediaries, and fostering greater transparency. Token incentives and liquidity aggregation are poised to solve traditional challenges like the cold start problem and liquidity fragmentation, creating more efficient and innovative markets.</p><p>However, the success of these Web3 platforms hinges on achieving a balance between desirability, feasibility, and viability. As the tokenization of real-world assets accelerates and Web3 marketplaces expand into emerging sectors like intellectual property, data, and even personal time, the next generation of marketplaces will not only redefine commerce but also unlock new ways to generate value for users, creators, and investors alike.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=41cd3faff572" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>